Mold Standards of Practice
Transcription
Mold Standards of Practice
Mold Standards of Practice National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Copyright© 2013 Gary Rosen, Ph.D. & Certified Mold Free Corp. Questions: Tel: 954 614 6860 Email: Info@Free-Mold-Training.org www.Free-Mold-Training.org About Course Author This entirely FREE online course was developed as a public service by Gary Rosen, Ph.D. President of Certified Mold Free Corp along with the National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors (www.Free-Mold-Training.org). Dr. Rosen (Ph.D. Biochemistry UCLA) holds Florida licenses in Mold Assessment, Mold Remediation and Building Construction and has performed over 1000 mold assessments and over 1000 mold remediations. Dr Rosen has been formally IICRC S520 trained and IICRC AMRT certified as well as IAQA trained and certified in mold assessment and remediation. He is the author of 5 books on mold assessment and mold remediation all available on Amazon.com. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 2 Free Training While the training is free, this is no indication of the quality of the training courses. Most students upon completion of our Free Mold Training courses find that the courses offer the finest and most comprehensive training for mold and mold assessment in the industry. More extensive supplemental professional training can be found (not free but at a low cost) in the author’s mold books available on Amazon.com (link below.) http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=searchalias%3Dstripbooks&field-keywords=mold%20gary%20rosen Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 3 For Florida Mold Contractors The Department of Business and Professional Regulations approved the subject matter covered in this course. Course provider Certified Mold Free Corp is Florida approved Mold Continuing Education Provider #2757. Mold Standards of Practice (SOP) is Florida Mold Continuing Education Course #154 (Correspondence) is approved for Two hours of Mold Continuing Education Credit. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 4 Outside of Florida Courses are widely applicable to mold contracting outside of Florida. Courses are FREE however there is a fee of $25 each if you would like to receive Certificates of Completion for the training courses. Completion of all 14 hours of training makes you eligible for the credentials: Certified Green Indoor Air Quality Specialist and/or Certified Green Mold Remediation Contractor. Certification cost is $50/year. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 5 About Course This course has been designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. This material and course is provided with the understanding that the provider is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, or other professional services. If legal advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional person should be sought. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 6 Course & Exam Pricing Report Writing is part of our 14-HR MOLD Continuing Education Training for Florida Mold Services. Training is no charge. Download the material. Complete the course. EXAM is no charge. A link to the EXAM can be found on the last page of this course. Any questions call 954-614-6860 or email: info@free-mold-training.org Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 7 The Exam There are 20 questions on the EXAM. A passing score is 70%. There is no limit to the number of times the EXAM can be taken. Florida students: – When you pass the Exam you will receive CE credit with Mold Services. – We provide the Dept your information electronically. Allow 24-48 hours for processing. Students outside of Florida: – When you pass the Exam you are eligible for a Certificate of Course completion for $25.00 Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 8 Optional Certification Mold contractors that pass our 14 hour Mold CE training are eligible for NAERMC (National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors) certifications. Cost is $50/ year. Our certification logos look great on your web site or business cards! GO GREEN! Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 9 Optional Certification Certified Green Mold Remediation Contractor logo. Certified Green Indoor Air Quality Specialist logo. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 10 Optional Certification Please support National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors and Free Mold Training and we will be back in 2 years with another set of free Mold CE courses. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 11 Course Introduction Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 12 Standards Developed for Different Audiences The two most widely cited mold standards are EPA/OSHA and IICRC S520. – EPA/OSHA was developed for consumers and facility managers based on input from a broad set of leading scientists; government agencies; and industrial hygienists. – S520 (2008) was developed by IICRC members for IICRC Certified Mold Remediators based on the needs of the IICRC member organization. Note: S520 has many problems, as we shall see, and has now been withdrawn by IICRC as an official IICRC standard, yet it is still widely cited! Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 13 EPA/OSHA Vs. IICRC Mold Standards Which standard a mold contractor bases his assessment, protocol or work guidelines on will significantly affect: – How the mold is assessed. – How the mold work is done. – How many contractors are involved. – Biocides used or not used. – Who is, in the end, responsible for the overall quality. – How much it costs. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 14 Limitations of Standards Actual practice of Mold Remediation in Florida has developed, to a significant degree, somewhat independent of such standards as EPA/OSHA and S520, based on the needs of: – Florida consumers – Realities of the marketplace including what Florida home owner insurance will pay for – Concerns about liability/ requirements of Environmental Insurance – Florida Mold Law – Background and training of Florida Mold Assessors and Remediators Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 15 Common Objectives This course is for professional Florida Mold Assessors and Mold Remediators. Mold remediation and assessment recommendations developed for facility managers & home owners (EPA/OSHA), or IICRC members (S520) will never be completely applicable to Florida Mold Contracting. Nevertheless, finding mold, removing mold and making sure the work is properly done will have many essential similarities no matter who is doing the work. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 16 Focus on EPA/OSHA This course and our entire 14 Hour Mold Continuing Education program is heavily focused on presenting the benefits of EPA/OSHA mold remediation procedures for professional mold contractors. For the mold professional the EPA/OSHA mold remediation procedures (with minor tweaks) can be quite effective in terms of cost, elimination of mold, worker safety, keeping mold from returning … and overall customer satisfaction. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 17 IICRC S520 S520 has been and continues to be a popular procedure for professional mold contractors but has serious flaws and has been withdrawn as a standard by IICRC. We compare and contrast EPA/OSHA to S520 in Mold Standards of Practice. It should become clear by the time this course is finished why we support EPA/OSHA for mold professionals and why S520 has been recalled. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 18 Course Outline Introduction EPA/OSHA vs. IICRC S520 Mold & Moisture Assessment/ Inspection approaches compared EPA/OSHA vs. IICRC S520 Mold remediation procedures compared Green (Chemical-Free) Remediation Practices Review Questions Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 19 EPA/OSHA Investigating, Evaluating, Moisture and Mold Problems Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 20 EPA/OSHA Standards EPA/OSHA Mold Remediation Standard was written for home owners and facility managers: – Developed by the Federal Government as a guide to identify and remediate mold problems in homes, schools and commercial buildings. www.epa.gov/mold – Philosophically similar to New York City mold remediation guidelines established in the early 90’s. www.nwhealth.org/pubs/NYC%20DOH%20Guidelines.pdf Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 21 EPA/OSHA Standards EPA guidance on mold remediation can be found on their web site: www.EPA.gov/mold. And in their publication: Mold Remediation in Schools and Commercial Buildings. Students should download this booklet and read it! OSHA guidance is essentially the same as EPA. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 22 EPA/OSHA Assessment Considerations: – Focus is on Investigating & Evaluating both Moisture and Mold Problems. – EPA/OSHA does not separate Mold and Moisture when it comes to identifying or fixing the problem. – Find the moisture problem and you will find the mold. – Fix the moisture problem, remove the mold, and mold does not return. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 23 EPA Check List: Mold & Moisture Investigation Assess size of moldy area (square feet). Consider the possibility of hidden mold. Clean up small mold problems and fix moisture problems before they become large problems. Select remediation manager for medium or large size mold problem. Investigate areas associated with occupant complaints. Identify source(s) or cause of water or moisture problem(s). Note type of water-damaged materials (wallboard, carpet, etc.) . Check inside air ducts and air handling unit. Throughout process, consult qualified professional if necessary or desired. From p 27 EPA: Mold Remediation in Schools and Commercial Buildings. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 24 Mold & Moisture Linked Remediation of mold is tied to moisture and length of exposure to water. Find the moisture … and you find the mold. If items are wet for a short period of time, before mold has a chance to grow, simply dry them out. If not, they must be remediated for mold. In EPA guidelines water damage mitigation and mold remediation are linked together. Contrast this approach with IICRC guidelines for which mold remediation (S520) and water damage mitigation (S500) are performed under different standards and by different contractors. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 25 Always Check HVAC & Ducting for Mold & Moisture Problems EPA guidance states to always “check inside air ducts and air handling unit” for mold and moisture problems. EPA recommends referring to the EPA Manual “Should You Have the Air Ducts in Your Home Cleaned”? EPA photo of moldy AC lining Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 26 EPA/OSHA: Mold Assessment Considerations If the problem is determined to be not AC or ducting related … assess the size of the mold problem (large, medium or small). Apply EPA containment and remediation methods based on size of problem assessed. EPA explains that the extent of hidden mold may not be obvious until remediation starts. (Mold Remediation in Schools and Commercial Buildings Chart p 5). Hidden mold discovered during remediation may cause remediators to re-evaluate the size of the problem and the type of containment and remediation methods used (Chart p 5) Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 27 EPA/OSHA: Moisture is the Source of Mold Problems With EPA/OSHA, there is a very strong focus on assessing/identifying the moisture problem that caused the mold. Characterizing the type and duration of moisture problem will determine or help determine the location and often the extent of the mold problem. Characterizing the moisture problem will help determine whether the mold is hidden or (often cleanable) surface mold which of course impacts the cost of the remediation and rebuild. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 28 EPA/OSHA No Turf Wars With EPA/OSHA guidelines, there is no separate mold standard and water mitigation standard as there is with IICRC (S500 & S520). With EPA/OSHA there are no conflicts or turf wars between mold remediators and water mitigation contractors. With EPA/OSHA, one contractor (or facility manager) should be able to perform most aspects of mold remediation jobs including identifying the location and extent of the problem, remediating or discarding wet and moldy building materials, remediating or discarding wet and moldy content. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 29 HVAC Mold Assessment Concerns One area of focus in the EPA/OSHA guidelines is mold and moisture problems in the AC and/or ducting. However, a mold assessor or mold remediation may not be able to properly evaluate such contamination without the aid of a licensed AC contractor. Florida Contracting Law complicates such work as a Mold Contractor may not quote or subcontract the activities of other State Licensed Contractors. Only Mold Remediation contractors that are also Certified General, or Certified Building contractors may quote or hire Licensed AC Contractors. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 30 BLACK WATER CAUTION If the cause of the water damage is black water, always bring in a trained water mitigation contractor with expertise in black water mitigation. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 31 EPA/OSHA on Mold Sampling EPA/OSHA recommends the use of mold assessment professionals for complex jobs only. In our opinion, post remediation air sampling should be performed on ALL mold jobs. There is no other way to assure that the indoor air at the work site has been left clean and mold free. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 32 IICRC S520 Initial Inspection Procedures Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 33 EPA/OSHA Vs. IICRC Mold Standards In 2008, the Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification (IICRC) published the S520* mold remediation standard based on the needs of their members. (www.IICRC.org) S520 takes a markedly different approach from EPA/OSHA and actually states that it rejects the fundamentals of the EPA/OSHA mold recommendations. *S520 (2008) has been withdrawn and will be replaced with an updated version that is under development. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 34 IICRC S520 (2008) Mold Assessment According to IICRC, S520 rejects the EPA and NYC approaches to assessing mold based on establishing the size of the problem and then employing remediation procedures appropriate to the size of the problem. – Instead IICRC bases the assessment on determining conditions (Elevated Mold, Active Mold or Normal Fungal Ecology). – Once the condition is determined (by an Indoor Environmental Professional IEP) a custom protocol is developed to perform remediation to return the problem area to Normal Fungal Ecology. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 35 IICRC S520 (2008) Rejects EPA Approach Page 6 of IICRC S520 “S520 represents a philosophical shift away from using “size” of visible mold growth to determine the remediation response. Instead, it established mold contamination definitions and guidance, which, when properly applied, can assist remediators and others in determining remediation response or confirm remediation success.” Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 36 Indoor Fungal Ecology In S520 an Independent Indoor Environmental Professional (IEP) must be brought in to classify the indoor environment as being Condition 1, 2,3. – Condition 1: Normal fungal ecology – Condition 2: Settled spores – Conditions 3: Active Mold There is no such thing as a simple job under S520. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 37 No Emphasis on Moisture In S520 there is little emphasis on “find the moisture problem you find the mold” contrast this with EPA/OSHA where the focus is find the mold when you find the water. Moisture/ water damage is covered by water mitigation contractors and not mold contractors. The focus of S520 assessment is initial and post remediation testing. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 38 IEP Must Establish Initial Condition Once the Condition (1, 2 or 3) is established by the IEP, the Mold Remediator and team member Indoor Environmental Professional develops a remediation procedure to restore the premises to Normal Fungal Ecology. With S520, one must bring in the IEP team member to test before remediation to establish the “Initial Condition” of the property before a suitable remediation protocol can be developed. (Under EPA one contractor can do the assessment as well as remediation.) Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 39 IEP Establishes Remediation Success And with S520 … one must again bring in the IEP team member to test after remediation to determine if the goal of restoring the property to Condition 1 (Normal Fungal Ecology) has been achieved. This is may appear to be excellent for Mold Assessor employment but will result in mold remediation bids not being competitive for many smaller or mid size jobs and therefore no work for anyone! Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 40 S520 Conditions S520 Conditions – Is there active growth as determined by air/dust sampling ? – Or are there “elevated” settled spores? – Or is the indoor environment a “normal fungal ecology”? – Evaluating “Conditions” and then developing remediation protocols to return the contaminated area to “normal fungal ecology” is not as simple as it sounds. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 41 Elevated Settled Spores “Elevated Settled Spores is an indoor environment that is contaminated with settled spores that are a result of a mold growth contamination.” (IICRC definition.) A practical problem with this definition is that any property that is not truly clean will have elevated settled spores and this may have nothing to do with active mold growth. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 42 Normal Conditions Normal indoor environment may have: – (Some) settled spores, – Fungal fragments, & – Even traces of some actual mold growth All reflective of a “normal” ecology for a similar indoor environment. (IICRC definition.) Per IICRC, the goal in a microbial remediation project is to return a problem area to normal conditions. But if there is dirty carpet and/or lots of clutter and/or open windows or dirty A/C and/or ducting, returning a problem location to “normal” will NOT be as simple as it sounds. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 43 Normal Conditions According to IICRC, if you were to air sample a normal condition, you would expect to find … compared to outdoors… similar types of molds, with lower concentrations indoors. This overly simplistic IICRC definition often makes little sense when applied in the real world. Many factors impact the ratio of inside to outside mold and the type of mold inside compared to outside. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 44 Comparing Inside to Out Affecting Inside to Outside spore types and ratios: How clean the house is. How often cleaned. Carpets: Clean or not clean. New or old. Quality of AC air filter used. Windows open or not. Near ocean or inland. AC & ducting old/new. Recently cleaned? Season or even daily variation — outdoor mold levels and mold types can vary by a factor of 10 or more from day to day. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 45 EMLab Chart of FLA Outdoor Spore Count Range Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 46 EMLab Chart for FLA Outdoor Spore Count Range Outdoor spore counts in Florida can vary by a factor of 25 or more. On the previous page we see the common indoor and outdoor mold Cladosporium has outdoor levels that vary from a low of 27 to over 7000. Concluding using S520 that indoor mold in settled dust is Elevated or Not Elevated by comparing to outdoor mold levels is not as simple as it sounds. Returning a problem area to normal conditions based on comparing indoor mold to outdoor mold is NOT as simple as it sounds. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 47 IICRC : Many Standards • • • • • • • IICRC IICRC IICRC IICRC IICRC IICRC IICRC S100 S210 S300 S500 S520 S600 S800 Carpet Cleaning Dimension Stone Restoration Upholstery Cleaning Water Damage Restoration Mold Remediation Carpet Installation Carpet Inspect There are many IICRC standards but there is no IICRC standard for Mold Assessment! IICRC has no training/ certification program as to how one can determine what exactly is Normal Fungal Ecology! Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 48 IICRC : No Mold Assessment Std. • IICRC has standards for mold remediation, carpet cleaning, carpet inspection, etc. • But IICRC has no standard or training/ certification program for Mold Assessors (IEP training) to determine before remediation what should be remediated and to determine after remediation if the job was successful. As far as we know, there is no lab where you can send surface and air samples and get back results that indicate Condition 1, 2, 3. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 49 IICRC : No Mold Assessment Std. Why no training/standard for IEP’s? Because (in our opinion) it is not practical to write a protocol to properly perform or evalutate mold remediation work on the basis of evaluating Fungal Ecology of the air or settled dust. Is it any wonder that S520 has been withdrawn by IICRC as an IICRC standard? Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 50 Important Caveats About S520 Unless there is visible mold … on a wall or ceiling which often is not the case as the home owner typically cleans surface mold to make the home more livable while getting quotes for mold remediation work. Unless there is visible mold … the Indoor Fungal Ecology may not be affected by even large amounts of mold inside of walls or ceilings (unless there are openings in wall for the spores to pass through.) What this means is that in actual real world situations, the extent and size of most mold problems is typically much more closely tied to the size and duration of water damage than Indoor Fungal Ecology of household dust. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 51 Important Caveats About S520 If the AC coils need cleaning there is very often Elevated Settled Spores throughout the entire building but no need for mold remediation work. Simply have the coils cleaned and install a new air filter. In such a case, this imbalance in the Indoor Fungal Ecology would be a red herring. In actual real world situations, the extent and size of “real” mold problems is typically much more closely tied to the size and duration of water damage than Indoor Fungal Ecology of household dust. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 52 Important Caveats About S520 If the home owner has put a high quality air filter in the air handler (such as Merv 11 or better) and the AC and ducting are clean… There may be absolutely no indication of mold problems in the home as determined by measuring the Fungal Ecology of the indoor dust. Yet the home may have significant even massive hidden mold problems. In actual real world situations, the extent and size of “real” mold problems is typically much more closely tied to the size and duration of water damage than Indoor Fungal Ecology of household dust. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 53 Important Caveats About S520 A home may have significant even massive hidden mold problems. But in the dry season, mold may go inactive due to lack of moisture. Inactive mold does not produce mold spores. There may be absolutely no indication of such mold problems in a home during the dry season as determined by measuring the Fungal Ecology of the indoor dust. One must assess such problems either by checking for mold behind discolored areas and/or understanding a building’s history and/or looking for defects such as old, cracked window caulking. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 54 IICRC : No Mold Assessment Std. More often than not, the Fungal Ecology of Spores in Settled Dust will not tell us anything about the size, location and source of actual mold problems. Again, is it any wonder that S520 has been withdrawn by IICRC as an IICRC standard? Nevertheless, Florida Mold Contractors reference IICRC S520 more than any other standard for recommended mold remediation procedures. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 55 EPA/OSHA Mold Remediation Procedures Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 56 EPA Check List: Mold & Moisture Remediation Fix the moisture problem, implement repair plan and/or maintenance plan Dry wet, non-moldy materials within 48 hours to prevent mold growth . Clean and dry moldy materials (see Table 2 and text). Discard moldy porous items that can’t be cleaned From p 27 EPA: Mold Remediation in Schools and Commercial Buildings. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 57 EPA/OSHA Remediation Basics First address moisture problems. Then implement remediation plan. – Smaller problems are treated simply (using a Limited Containment). – Larger problems are treated with more complex procedures including containments with walk-in decontamination chamber. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 58 EPA/OSHA Limited Containment One layer of fire-retardant polyethylene sheeting. Maintain area under negative pressure. Block supply and return air vents within containment area. EPA guidelines also define Full Containment with air A Limited Containment lock and decontamination chamber. Full containments are rarely used in mold remediation as most jobs can be “broken down” to numerous smaller jobs, using multiple limited containments. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 59 EPA/OSHA Containment Tips Always maintain the containment area under negative pressure. Exhaust fan to outdoors and ensure that adequate makeup air is provided (containment is not too tight.) If the containment is working, the polyethylene sheeting should billow inwards on all surfaces. If it flutters or billows outward, containment has been lost, and you should find and correct the problem before continuing remediation activities. Additional post remediation cleaning may be required if containment effectiveness is breached. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 60 EPA/OSHA Containment Tips EPA recommends 6 mil plastic sheeting for the containment. (The enclosure around the moldy area should consist of a single layer of 6-mil, fire-retardant polyethylene sheeting.) This is a throw back from Asbestos where containments were built to stay up for weeks or months and had to be heavy film that as fire retardant. The best material for containment walls is 0.3 mil plastic which is very light weight and inexpensive and can also be used for covering furniture. Build small containments around the work areas and take them down when finished with the drywall removal. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 61 EPA/OSHA Clean Up Methods Method 1: Wet vacuum (in the case of porous materials, some mold spores/fragments will remain in the material but will not grow if the material is completely dried). Steam cleaning may be an alternative for carpets and some upholstered furniture. Method 2: Damp-wipe surfaces with plain water or with water and detergent solution (except wood—use wood floor cleaner); scrub as needed. Avoid dust producing methods. No sanding or sweeping. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 62 EPA/OSHA Clean Up Methods Method 3: High-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) vacuum after the material has been thoroughly dried. Dispose of the contents of the HEPA vacuum in well-sealed plastic bags. Method 4: Discard – remove water-damaged materials and seal in plastic bags while inside of containment, if present. Dispose of as normal waste. HEPA vacuum area after it is dried. Avoid dust producing methods. No sanding or sweeping. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 63 EPA Discard Recommendations Don’t Make Sense for Mold Work EPA recommends double bagging and 6 mil bags. “Building materials and furnishings that are contaminated with mold growth and are not salvageable should be double-bagged using 6-mil polyethylene sheeting.” This is a throw back from asbestos remediation. Not necessary for mold work. Note that the thickness of the bag is often times not as important as the toughness of the bag. A 4 mil plastic bag can often be a more secure bag than a 6 mil bag. We use and are happy with 4 mil bags from PlasticPlace.com. No charge for shipping. www.plasticplace.net/index.php?file=productdetail&iprod_id=273 Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 64 EPA/OSHA: Controlling Moisture is the Key to Mold Control With EPA/OSHA, when the moisture problem is controlled, mold will not return. Control the moisture and then biocides with residual killing power NOT needed to keep mold from returning. Since dead mold is still allergenic and contains toxins and irritants, killing mold is not enough. Mold must be removed. IICRC S520, as we shall see, approaches many or most of these issues quite differently. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 65 Always Erect Containments Even for the Smallest Jobs • The EPA/OSHA mold remediation guidelines are based on setting up levels of containment based on the size of the problem. • While the EPA does not require a containment for the smallest problems …. even the smallest problems need to be contained when the work is done by a mold professional. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 66 Always Erect Containments Even for the Smallest Jobs • Why do mold professionals not follow EPA/OSHA guidelines that allow remediation work to be done without environmental controls when there is limited mold? Less than 10 sq ft? • Note that according to Florida Mold Law if there is less than 10 sq ft of mold the size of the problem is below the threshold where you need a mold professional. • But still Florida mold contractors will use containments for jobs less than 10 sq ft. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 67 Always Erect Containments Even for the Smallest Jobs • Why do mold professionals always use containments even when there is less than 10 sq ft of mold? 1. The EPA/ OSHA procedures were written for school maintenance personnel that do not have access to today’s spring loaded poles that make setting up containments a snap. 2. School maintenance personnel also have limited concerns about liability. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 68 Always Erect Containments Even for the Smallest Jobs • Why do mold professionals always use containments even when there is less than 10 sq ft of mold? 3. One never knows if there are immune compromised or mold sensitive people involved that can be affected by even very small levels of cross contamination as the result of mold work. 4. There can be up to 100 million mold spores per square inch of heavy mold growth on drywall. Therefore, the size in square feet of mold is not always a good indicator as to the potential for cross contamination. How heavy is the growth will often be the key factor. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 69 Always Erect Containments Even for the Smallest Jobs 5. The EPA recommended remediation procedure is to investigate the extent of hidden mold and then if necessary, go back and revise your safety and containment strategy as appropriate (See Key Steps, page 5 MRSCB). Since most mold jobs require fixed bid quotes, a mold professional does not want to make it a practice of revising their safety and containment strategy (and price) on the spot based on new evidence of hidden mold found during the remediation. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 70 You Never Know the Extent of Hidden Mold Inside the Wall • For a mold professional… best to assume significant hidden mold that will require one or more limited containments; negative air; suitable safety gear and trained crew; along with post remediation air scrubbing and post remediation testing even for the smallest jobs. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 71 Containment Use The EPA recommends containments be set up only when visible mold is over 10 sq ft. However simple/limited containments using plastic sheeting and spring loaded poles can be set up in under 10 minutes…. so why not always use them and protect the most sensitive individuals? Always use containments even when visible mold is under the EPA threshold of 10 sq ft. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 72 Containments Reduce Cleaning When you use simple/limited (often times multiple small) containments around mold problems rather than larger more complex containments you can often dramatically reduce the size of the area that you later need to clean and test. Setting up containments actually reduces the overall job cost because the cost of setting up the containment is more than offset by the reduction in the cost of cleaning and testing outside of the work areas. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 73 Containments: Safer Work Environment Setting up containments makes workers more efficient because the air inside a containment (under neg air pressure) is continually changed and workers work better when in a clean dust-free environment. Setting up containments actually reduces overall job cost because the cost of setting up the containment is more than offset by the improved efficiency of workers working in a relatively dust-free environment. Copyright© 2010 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 74 Summary of EPA/OSHA Mold Remediation Procedures • While the EPA/OSHA guidelines are written for facility managers and not mold professionals, “mold is mold” as we say, and how a facility manager finds and removes mold will be quite similar to how a mold professional would do same. • For the mold professional with minor tweaks (as discussed) the EPA/OSHA mold remediation procedures can be quite effective in terms of cost, elimination of mold, worker safety, keeping mold from returning … and overall customer satisfaction. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 75 EPA Content Remediation Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 76 Contaminated Building Contents EPA has rules for water damaged and/or visibly moldy items … EPA has rules for porous and semi-porous material items … EPA has rules for items that are hard non-porous … Note that when EPA says HEPA Vac you can replace with Shop Vac equipped with Drywall Filter bag you do not need a true HEPA filtered vacuum for mold work. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 77 Cleaning Contents In the case of a black water problem, contents that have not either: • Actually come in contact with contaminated water; OR • Are exposed to/covered with spores or bacteria due to improper use of air movers Such contents do not need remediation Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 78 Move and Clean Contents Start off by isolating contaminated contents from unaffected contents. Dispose of water-damaged items that are not cleanable. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 79 Move and Clean Contents Move easy to carry items to clean, dry, and secure area. • HEPA vacuum and damp wipe with disinfectant as appropriate If moving off-site, be sure to use clean, dry storage containers. If storage is during humid season, we recommend air conditioned storage. Non-moveable items • HEPA vacuum and damp wipe with disinfectant as appropriate • Wrap with polyethylene Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 80 Porous Contents Porous contents with Elevated Settled Spores are typically restorable. HEPA vacuuming will remove settled spores Air washing using an electric leaf blower also works Laundry or dry cleaning or steam cleaning works. The EPA provides detailed tables & guidelines for saving/discarding many types of porous contents, but the simple advice listed above pretty much sums it up. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 81 Porous Contents Porous contents with Actual Mold Growth are usually unrestorable, based on material composition. Examples: • Stuffed animals • Fabric couches • Mattresses & pillows & Covers • Oriental rugs • Chairs Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 82 Porous Contents Porous contents with Actual Mold Growth are usually unrestorable, but that does not mean never restorable. • • • • Certainly HEPA Vac will not restore. (Why not? Because only removes surface mold.) Dry cleaning, spot cleaning or steam cleaning may work. Keep in mind that inexpensive carpet usually costs more to restore than to replace. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 83 EPA Porous Contents Table 1: Water Damage - Cleanup and Mold Prevention from EPA Publication: "Mold Remediation in Schools and Commercial Buildings" Guidelines for Response to Clean Water Damage within 24-48 Hours to Prevent Mold Growth* Actions Water-Damaged Material† Books and papers Carpet and backing – dry within 24-48 hours§ Upholstered furniture Window drapes For non-valuable items, discard books and papers. Photocopy valuable/important items, discard originals. Freeze (in frost-free freezer or meat locker) or freeze-dry. Remove water with water extraction vacuum. Reduce ambient humidity levels with dehumidifier. Accelerate drying process with fans. Remove water with water extraction vacuum. Accelerate drying process with dehumidifiers, fans, and/or heaters. May be difficult to completely dry within 48 hours. If the piece is valuable, you may wish to consult a restoration/water damage professional who specializes in furniture. Follow laundering or cleaning instructions recommended by the manufacturer. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 84 Porous Contents Gray or Black Water : Recommend to Discard • What about 5 square feet of $50/yard carpet? Try to clean? • Clean water: • Since clean water will turn to gray water after a few days, discard carpet and other porous items if not properly dried immediately after water event Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 85 Porous Contents Pressed Wood (Wood composites) & Fabric furniture If Elevated Spores: Clean (HEPA Vac, Steam Clean, Dry Clean) If Active Growth: Recommend to Discard Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 86 Porous Contents Can you or should you always throw away furniture with a little mold on it? What if the person is not sensitive to mold? What if it there is some mold on fabric furniture on a patio? What if the furniture is in a water front vacation cottage that has the windows open when occupied? Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 87 Porous Contents If Elevated Spores: Clean (Laundry, Dry Clean). If Active Mold Growth: Typically cannot be restored due to staining or physical damage Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 88 Porous Contents Books: Depends on value. Microwave can kill mold. Elevated Spores can be cleaned by air washing/HEPA vacuuming/Freeze Dry. Commercial services available. http://www.theconservationcenter.com/ Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 89 Semi-Porous Contents Semi-porous items (such as soft wood) that are primarily organic can absorb moisture and are susceptible to microbial growth. Semi-Porous with Elevated Settled Spores are usually restorable. Semi-Porous with Active Mold Growth is usually unrestorable unless mold growth is in a readily removable bio-film on the surface of the item; or … If there is a practical means for mold removal. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 90 EPA Non-Porous Materials Table 1: Water Damage - Cleanup and Mold Prevention from EPA Publication "Mold Remediation in Schools and Commercial Buildings" Guidelines for Response to Clean Water Damage within 24-48 Hours to Prevent Mold Growth* Water-Damaged Material† Hard surface, porous flooring§ (Linoleum, ceramic tile, vinyl) Non-porous, hard surfaces (Plastics, metals) Wood surfaces Actions Vacuum or damp wipe with water and mild detergent and allow to dry; scrub if necessary. Check to make sure underflooring is dry; dry underflooring if necessary. Vacuum or damp wipe with water and mild detergent and allow to dry; scrub if necessary. Remove moisture immediately and use dehumidifiers, gentle heat, and fans for drying. (Use caution when applying heat to hardwood floors.) Treated or finished wood surfaces may be cleaned with mild detergent and clean water and allowed to dry. Wet paneling should be pried away from wall for drying. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 91 Non-Porous Materials Non-Porous (Hard Wood) with Elevated Settled Spores are restorable. Non-Porous (Hard) with Active Mold Growth are usually restorable, and can be cleaned using appropriate methods, or HEPA Vac’d if dry, based on material composition. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 92 Non-Porous Contents Hard woods can be cleaned with soap and water. The moldy fabric should be discarded. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 93 IICRC S520 Mold Remediation Procedures Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 94 IICRC S520 IICRC S520 is a 237 page book of detailed specifications and recommendations. It includes the Standard (pages 1-59). And Reference which is the rest of the book. Note that S520 (2008) has been withdrawn as a mold remediation standard by IICRC. Nevertheless it is still widely referenced by mold contractors. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 95 IICRC S520 (2008) As we have mentioned, the S520 standard has been withdrawn. A new version is in the works at IICRC. In the following section we review a few of what we consider problems with S520 (2008). We point out where S520 is at odds with EPA/OSHA and/or is internally inconsistent or perhaps problematic to implement. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 96 IICRC Dust Producing Techniques IICRC S520 (2008) recommends dust producing techniques such as sanding structural wood and dry ice blasting. Such techniques not only produce mold fragments which are invisible to mold spore sampling but can release dangerous chemicals used in the production of pressure sensitive wood. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 97 IICRC Dust Producing Techniques EPA offers better advice in this regard … no dust producing techniques. EPA/OSHA recommend premoistening materials to keep down the release of hazardous dusts and to use no dust producing techniques. We disagree with S520 dust producing recommendations for mold remediation. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 98 IICRC Containments IICRC S520 recommends that containments be monitored to make sure they have a negative pressure of at least ≥ 5 Pa. (This is the same specification for a mold containment as for Asbestos work.) The IICRC containment pressure must be monitored by an IEP just as in Asbestos work This is overkill for most mold work. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 99 IICRC Biocide Use IICRC S520 has an over emphasis on using biocides in mold work. No doubt they are important in S500 when dealing with black water clean up. But biocides that keep on killing should not be used for mold work. Remove the mold. Make sure the moisture source is fixed. Biocides not needed. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 100 IICRC AC Ducting Remediation Unlike the EPA, IICRC does not make it clear that biocides should not be used to remediate AC and nonmetallic ducting surfaces. There are NO biocides that keep on killing approved by the EPA for such use. We disagree with the use of biocides on fiberglass lined AC lining, ducting and plenums. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 101 S-520: Many Conflicts with EPA/OSHA S520 (2008) appears (at least to us) to have many conflicts with established government standards including both EPA/OSHA and New York City. In the next section we look at actual excerpts from the S520 manual. The reader can judge for themselves as to problems or not with S520. Again note that S520 (2008) has been withdrawn by IICRC as a standard. So no doubt others beside this course author have found issues with S520. Nevertheless S520 even though withdrawn is the most widely referenced standard in Mold Remediation proposals so we study it. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 102 Example Excerpts from IICRC S520 Mold Remediation Procedures Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 103 IICRC Conditions Comment Says: “when conditions 1,2,3 cannot be determined by the remediator.” But this is silly advice as remediators may never make such determinations as evaluating Conditions requires testing. Catch 22, you cannot tell if Condition 1, 2, or 3 exists without first engaging an IEP to do sampling. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 104 IICRC Reject Size Indicators Comment Per S520, contrary to EPA/OSHA and NYC guidelines, the size of the mold problem should not determine the type of remediation response. Per IICRC S520 the action plan for mold remediation is based on responding to Conditions 1, 2, 3. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 105 IICRC Contradiction Comment Yet, here S520 uses the term “moderate” levels of fungal growth that is not defined anywhere in S520 to determine the type of containment to be set up. Complete contradiction to the previous page. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 106 IICRC Containment Set Up Comment Hidden mold inside of a wall does not affect the Condition of the room as home owners clean / vacuum. The size, type and duration of water damage are better indicators as to the extent and location of containment. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 107 HEPA VAC Overkill for Mold Comment A Shop-Vac with a drywall filter bag works well and costs a fraction of what a true HEPA-VAC costs to buy and maintain. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 108 IICRC Demolition Comment IICRC S520 recommends dust producing cleaning methods “wire brushing” and “sanding”. Mold microfragments produced by sanding and brushing are too small to be detected by air and surface sampling. Not appropriate for “Green” procedures. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 109 IICRC AC Cleaning Comment Silly advice to replace coils and blower if dirty. Coils and blowers can be removed from the AC unit and always cleaned no matter how dirty. Once cleaned they are hosed off so that no chemical residue remains. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 110 IICRC Condition 2 Comment Bad advice. Condition 2 means settled spores on it. These are always restorable as explained by EPA/OSHA guidelines. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 111 IICRC Condition 2 Comment Abrasive blast cleaning to remove settled spores? Absurd. No wonder S520 has been withdrawn by IICRC as a standard. So many mistakes. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 112 IICRC Condition 2 Comment Condition 2 (settled spores) on clothing is always restorable as per EPA/OSHA guidelines. More bad advice. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 113 IICRC Abrasive Remediation Comment Dust producing remediation techniques such as using orbital sanders to sand wood can produce toxic dusts from chemicals in wood and will always spread mold microparticles invisible to mold sampling. HEPA Vac’s connected to orbital sanders do not capture all dusts and rapidly clog expensive HEPA filters resulting in the HEPA Vac’s being disconnected due to cost issues. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 114 IICRC Chemical Use Comment Chemicals that leave a residue that keep on killing are not “useful and complementary tools” in mold work. They are not necessary. Control the moisture and you keep mold from returning. Chemicals not required. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 115 IICRC Chemical Use Comment Again, always avoid using biocides and anti-microbials in post remediation application. Controlling moisture is the key to keeping mold from returning. Not chemicals. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 116 IICRC Conditions 3 S520 Page 162 Comment on Semi-Porous The focus is on abrasive methods for cleaning concrete and concrete block. Whoever heard of sanding or blasting concrete block to clean mold from the surface? Mold is not growing on the concrete which is not a food source for mold but on dirt or dust adhering to the concrete surface. So many mistakes and errors in S520. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 117 IICRC Containment Maintenance Comment On the contrary, except for the very rare complex mold jobs that require full containments, a limited containment can be set up and taken down in one day. Bringing in an IEP to test for fungal ecology; wait for lab results; and then get the okay for the containment to be removed makes no sense in the real world of typical mold jobs. Sure, can make sense for larger jobs. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 118 IICRC Containment Neg Pressure Comment Here S520 states than an even higher negative pressure for a mold containment than asbestos may be “necessary in some cases”. This makes no sense. A mold containment is completely different from an asbestos containment. Continued … Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 119 IICRC Containment Neg Pressure Comment Continued A mold containment is completely different from an asbestos containment. Asbestos dusts are not exhausted outside but must be filtered inside the containment. Zero asbestos is allowed to be released from the containment. Strict containment pressures and monitoring are critical for asbestos work. Mold dusts are exhausted outside and are controlled by the speed of the air flow into and out of the containment and not the air pressure. And mold spores are part of the environment. You don’t care if a mold spore or two escapes from a mold containment to be later cleaned up during post remediation cleaning. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 120 IICRC Containment Neg Pressure Comment Continued Applying rules to mold work that make sense only for asbestos remediation is not being prudent. It is ripping off the customer who must pay for such unnecessary and useless procedures. Or it is causing the mold remediator to lose jobs because they are being non-competitive. Again, S520 has been withdrawn by IICRC but is still the basis of many or most mold remediation protocols in Florida. This makes no sense at all. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 121 IICRC HEPA Vacs Comment S520 does not allow remediators to use Shop-Vacs equipped with drywall dust bags filters. Only very expensive Hepa Vacs may be used in mold work. So long as the work area and surroundings are tested clear (normal fungal ecology) in post remediation verification why restrict the use of Shop-Vacs? Makes no sense. Continued … Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 122 IICRC HEPA Vacs Comment Continued Not allowing the use of Shop Vac’s with drywall filters for mold remediation and only permitting HEPA Vacs which cost 10x to buy and 50x to use versus Shop Vacs with drywall filters is again a hold over from asbestos. Overkill is not being prudent. Mold remediation is not the same as asbestos remediation. Why burden the consumer with unnecessary costs that have no benefits in terms of overall job quality? Makes no sense. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 123 IICRC Misting Comment Contrary to NYC and EPA guidelines that recommend misting (and recommend avoiding dust producing techniques), S520 states misting is controversial. S520 should note all cases when they contradict existing EPA/OSHA standards . Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 124 IICRC Responsibility Comment In S520, the remediator is not responsible for making sure there is no water intrusion before performing remediation work. This is clearly a mistake. For example, often mold work is the result of old or inadequate window caulking. No “building envelope expert” is going to be called in. The mold remediator should have the knowledge to address such issues. That’s why FL Mold Law requires mold contractors to have knowledge of water & moisture intrusion. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 125 S-520: Many Conflicts with EPA/OSHA We see that S520 is commonly referenced in many if not most mold assessor recommended mold protocols as well as in mold remediator’s quotes for mold work. Yet S520 (2008) has been withdrawn as a standard. As shown in this section, S520 (2008) has many mistakes and inconsistencies and clearly should be replaced. So why recommend that S520 be the basis of mold work? Makes no sense to do so as far as we can see! Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 126 Green (Chemical-Free) Remediation Practices Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 127 Chemical-Free Mold Remediation Professional mold training is often sponsored by chemical companies and there is little to no focus on green/ chemical-free approaches to mold removal. Aspergillus Niger Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 128 Mold Remediation Additionally, most problem buildings have mold in the AC and ducting. Identifying and correcting mold problems in the AC and ducting are either not covered in professional mold training courses or the focus of training is to spray chemicals that keep on killing into duct work. Checking AC closet wall cavity under air handler for mold problems after a drain line overflow. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 129 You Need to Know! Regardless of whether you have professional mold training or this is your first course you need to understand the important messages in this course including: How to limit construction dusts; How to clean without chemical residues; and The importance of a clean AC, plenums and ducting. Inspecting for mold under air handler. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 130 Toxic Dust Creation There is always the potential for harmful dusts as a result of mold work because there is often extensive mold inside of walls and behind wall paper when only a small amount of mold is growing on the surface. The physical effort of opening the walls or removing the wall paper can shake loose millions of mold spores and (toxin and/or allergen containing) mold fragments. Millions of mold spores being release when removing wall paper on moldy wall. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 131 Toxic Dust Creation When opening walls avoid dust and fragment producing techniques such as: – Using hammers to break open walls – Sanding wood – Dry ice or baking soda blasting Using dust producing techniques automatically makes a small job into a large job that requires complex containments and moon suits and extensive post remediation testing. Dust containment with plastic barriers. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 132 Circular Saws vs. Hammers Rockwell VersaCut circular saw or similar. Adjustable cutting depth with easy-to-read gauge on blade housing. A small circular saw that connects to your Shop Vac is a must for anyone serious about safely removing drywall. The cutting depth can be set so that you never cut any wires or plumbing or insulation. Adjusts easily for 1/2” or 5/8” drywall. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 133 Circular Saws Reduce Mold Dusts By using a circular saw and cutting out small pieces of drywall one piece at a time close to the negative air intake: – Hammers do not need to be used to break the drywall and you reduce the spread of construction dusts. – For very small jobs you may not need an actual containment if you take out only small pieces of problem drywall one at a time in front of the neg air intake ducting outside. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 134 Toxic Dust Creation We strongly recommend that remediation practices that release contaminated dusts and mold micro-particles be avoided. (EPA/OSHA and Not S520) Such dust producing activities will cause workers to be exposed to high levels of contaminants. Such dust producing activities also will leave the remediation work site contaminated with toxins and allergens that will then be difficult to clean. Double bagging is often an over kill for mold related contamination Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 135 Containments Remediation work must always be performed with the health and safety of workers & occupants in mind. In order to protect workers and occupants during drywall demolition or cabinet removal which always generates large amounts of (contaminated) construction dusts, one must build “containments”… which means putting up plastic barriers under neg air to isolate the work area. Simple Containment: Plastic sheeting attached to spring loaded polls to isolate the work area. And one should remove drywall using techniques that minimize dust production. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 136 Other Contaminants Mold growth as a result of water damage is one potential hazard involved in mold remediation. Other contaminants/ hazards that may result from water damage which workers and occupants need to be protected from include: Antimicrobials & biocides used in the water damage cleanup, along with contaminated construction dusts, bacteria, viruses, insects and dust mites. These non-spore contaminants in toxic dusts are invisible to post remediation spore sampling. When you protect against the spread of these hazards you also protect against cross contamination from mold… and vice versa. Wall destroyed by mold because window caulking was not refreshed every year. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 137 Before Remediation Starts Make sure that the moisture or water problem is fixed. Make sure that the actual indoor air quality (occupant complaints or odor) problem is not due to dirty AC and/or ducting before focusing on hidden mold in walls or ceilings. Make sure that good remediation practices will be used to avoid the creation of toxic and/or allergenic construction dusts. That procedures will not cross contaminate the AC and ducting. (Follow EPA/OSHA recommendations and not S520). Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 138 Before Remediation Starts Do not use harmful chemicals that leave residues that keep on killing. If the moisture/ water source is eliminated, mold will not come back and the post remediation application of chemicals is not required. Make sure that procedures are in place to clean the site of ALL contaminants including non-mold contaminants. When remediation is done right … the post remediation verification is fairly straight forward. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 139 Avoid Harmful Chemicals Again … make sure before remediation starts that harmful chemicals will not be used. Mold contractors always state they use only EPA approved chemicals. But these chemicals are generally not approved for use in home kitchens or food prep areas. Only use EPA approved cleaners for household use that you can find in a grocery store. Commercial biocides leave a residue which is NOT DETECTED by post-remediation testing. Once a biocide has been used it is very difficult to 100% remove. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 140 Avoid Harmful Chemicals Use only cleaners EPA approved for household use – At the concentrations recommended on the label. – For use recommended on the label (Kitchens and Food Surfaces?) – For surfaces recommended on the label (Hard surfaces? Fabrics?) – Applied by methods recommended on the label (Spray? Fog?) Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org EPA approved for household used. Page 141 Post-Remediation Cleaning When remediation is done right … the post remediation cleaning is straight forward. – Clean the floors of dust. No sweeping … use mops or Swiffer or Shop Vac with High Efficiency Filter Bag. See pix on right. – Clean dust from overhead fan blades. – Clean dust from fabric furniture by vacuuming with Shop Vac equipped with High Efficiency (Drywall) Filter Bag and floor brush accessory. See pix on right. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 142 Post-Remediation Cleaning When remediation is done right … the post remediation cleaning is straight forward. – Clean dust from hard surface furniture by wiping clean with rags sprayed with dust magnet or damp wiping. – Check floors and content for dust with white glove/ black glove. – Air scrub 48 hours while running AC with new air filter. (Put correct size Merv 11 rated air filter in AC and turn FAN=ON.) – Follow by post remediation air sampling. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 143 Air Scrubbing Work Area If the settled dust has been removed because you have carefully cleaned, then air scrubbing can be very quick and efficient. If there is settled dust you will never be able to quickly clean the rooms with air scrubbers because the contaminated dust in the air is constantly being replenished from settled dust. Supply register before cleaning. After cleaning and sealing. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 144 EPA Common Sense Approach • Much of the professional mold industry has rejected the common sense approach to mold removal recommended by the US EPA and OSHA in favor of IICRC S520. • S520 based procedures are overly complex and costly procedures and more often than not, result in lower quality work than the simpler EPA/ OSHA procedures. • Nor has the professional mold Mold behind kitchen cabinets associations placed adequate from leak in exterior wall. focus on chemical-free, green techniques. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 145 IICRC Many Standards At IICRC there are standards and certifications for carpet and wood cleaning; for water mitigation; and for mold remediation among others. Each group has their own turf and even though you cannot properly separate mold from water damage IICRC has attempted to do so. The result is a mold remediation standard that is far inferior to the EPA/OSHA and NYC guidelines that S520 was meant to replace. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 146 No IEP Standard IICRC membership includes a significant contingent of Indoor Environmental Professionals (IEP) for which there is no IICRC training or certification program. There is no IEP training and certification program: – Because S520 has defined Mold Assessment in such a way as to be impossible to properly perform and; – Because with no IEP Certification and Training program the developers of S520 which were mostly IEPs limit competition. Sad but true! Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 147 Not For Florida Mold Professionals The IICRC has developed S520 Mold Remediation Standard that rejects EPA/OSHA recommendations because it was what made sense for their members NOT because it makes sense for the consumer or for Florida Mold Professionals. S520 has been withdrawn by IICRC as a standard so even if you do not agree with this course’s criticism of S520 it should not be referenced for mold work as it is not an Active Standard. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 148 Review Questions 1. Mold remediation professionals are not generally well trained in which two areas. a. Chemical free techniques b. Dealing with mold in AC’s c. Removing moldy drywall. 2. When opening walls or ceilings avoid the following dust producing techniques. (Pick all). a. Using hammers. b. Sanding c. Dry ice blasting. d. Baking soda blasting e. All of the above. 3. Setting up containments… a. Is hard to do and rarely worth the effort. b. Is easy to do with spring loaded polls and reduces overall cost by reducing the spread of mold and hence reducing the time and cost of cleaning. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 149 Review Questions 4. EPA containments are based on what criteria? a. The results of air sampling. b. The results of lift tape sampling. c. The actual physical size of mold in square feet of surface area. d. Dust (surface) sampling 5. What can be said about cleaning? a. Best to clean and then spray what cannot be fully cleaned with biocide. b. Cleaning all settled dusts removes not only mold spores but other contaminants. 6. Rules for disinfectant/ cleaner use. (Choose all.) a. EPA approved for household use. b. At the concentrations listed on the label. c. For areas specified on the label (kitchen and food surfaces?) d. For surfaces recommended (hard surfaces, fabrics.) e. Applied by methods approved on label (fog, spray?) Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 150 Review Questions 7. Avoid dust producing techniques. Use the following approach. a. Hammers b. Sanding c. Carefully cutting drywall with circular saws or drywall knives. 8. IICRC Normal Fungal Ecology looks at type of mold and ratio to outside. What could affect the Fungal Ecology. Pick one or more. a) b) c) d) e) How clean the house is of dust on Content. Carpets: Clean or not clean. New or old. Quality of AC air filter used. Windows open or not. Near ocean or inland 9. EPA/OSHA mold assessment is to determine a) b) c) Source of moisture. Location and size of mold problem for the purpose of selecting the type of containment to use. Fungal ecology. Normal, elevated spores, mold growth. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 151 Review Questions 10. IICRC recommends abrasive remediation for removing mold from wood and concrete. How does this compare to EPA/OSHA? a) b) EPA/OSHA does not recommend dust producing techniques. EPA/OSHA recommends rotary sanders if hooked to HEPA VACs. 11. IICRC states “chemical products can be useful and complementary tools”. a) b) Yes this is what they say, but better to eliminate moisture so mold does not return. Better to not rely on chemicals. Using chemicals to keep mold from returning is only for professionals. 12. IICRC Condition 2 concerning Textiles a) b) c) May or not be restorable according to IICRC S-520 According to EPA/OSHA is always restorable. a&b Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 152 Review Questions 13. According to EPA Mold Remediation in Schools and Commercial Buildings (MRSCB) a) b) c) d) Once the location of the problem is determined one must determine the extent of the problem. Assess size of mold problem and note type of mold-damaged materials. Plan remediation, adapt guidelines to fit situation. Determine the fungal ecology and then build the containment to isolate area with elevated mold spore levels. 14. Unless there is visible mold … on a wall or ceiling which often is not the case as the home owner typically cleans surface mold to make the home more livable while getting quotes for mold remediation work... The extent and size of most mold problems are much more closely tied to the size and duration of water damage than Indoor Fungal Ecology. T or F Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 153 Review Questions 15. Unless there is visible mold … the Indoor Fungal Ecology may not be affected by even large amounts of mold inside of walls or ceilings (unless there are openings in the drywall for the spores to pass through.) The extent and size of most mold problems are much more closely tied to the size and duration of water damage than Indoor Fungal Ecology. T or F Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 154 Answers Check your answers against the correct ones below. 1. a, b 9. a, b 2. e 10. a 3. b 11. a 4. c 12. c 5. b 13. a - c 6. a – e (all) 14. a 7. c 15. C 8. a – e (all) 16. T 17. T Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. www.Free-Mold-Training.org Page 155 Additional Reading For a comprehensive treatment of chemical free mold remediation see: Environmentally Friendly Mold Remediation available on Amazon.com ISBN-10: 0979495660 at Amazon.com. Written by course author Gary Rosen, Ph.D. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 156 Additional Reading For those that would like to read more on how mold can affect childhood (and adult) health, learning & behavior see When Traditional Medicine Fails: Your Guide to Mold Toxins. ISBN-10: 0977397165 at Amazon.com Written by course author Gary Rosen Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 157 Optional Certification Contractors that pass our 14 hour Mold CE training are eligible for NAERMC (National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors) certifications. Cost is $50/year. Our certification logos look great on your web site or business cards! Sign up for the NAERMC certifications to keep these free CE training courses coming! Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 158 Optional Certification Certified Green Mold Remediation Contractor logo. Certified Green Indoor Air Quality Specialist logo. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 159 The Exam There are 20 questions on the EXAM. A passing score is 70%. There is no limit to the number of times the EXAM can be taken. Florida students: – When you pass the Exam you will receive CE credit with Mold Services. – We provide the Dept your information electronically. Allow 24-48 hours for processing. Students outside of Florida: – When you pass the Exam you are eligible for a Certificate of Course completion for $25.00 Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 160 The Exam Registration Important Note: The Exam is given online. To take the Exam you will need to Register with the online Exam software site. Follow directions exactly in order to receive credit for the course. Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 161 Exam Registration (Florida) License # here. NOT name. Email here. NOT name. Your Name Here! Pick a password. The link to the Standards of Practice Exam is: http://quizegg.com/q/79981 Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 162 Exam Registration (Outside of Florida) First Name here. Email here. NOT name. Last Name here. Pick a password. The link to the Standards of Practice Exam is: http://quizegg.com/q/79981 Copyright© 2013 Certified Mold Free Corp. National Association of Environmentally Responsible Mold Contractors Page 163