rti release - Department of Infrastructure, Local Government and

Transcription

rti release - Department of Infrastructure, Local Government and
RR
Page 1 of2
Karen Paraskevas
Graham Webb
Sent:
Wednesday, 6 February 2013 2:14PM
To:
DMullins@qtc.com.au
Cc :
Richard Ferrett; Sharyn Watkins; Andrew Longmire; Jason Tibbits; Gary Kleidon
(Gary.Kieidon@dlgp.qld.gov.au)
Subject:
FW: QTC Document
LG
C
From :
Attachments: J2646 CE Deamalgamation review.pdf; _Certification_.htm; image001 .jpg
David,
As discussed. It is acknowledged that Gary Kleidon provided you with a copy of the Cummings
Economics Review Report prepared for the Mareeba proponents. For completeness I have provided the
covering message from Mick Borzi.
Graham Webb
-O
As QTC has done for other proponent groups that have questioned QTC Reports, could you please
provide a report for the Minister on the Mareeba Report.
Policy Advisor
Office of the Han. D avid Crisafulli MP I Minister for Local
Government, Community Recovery and Resilience
E
Phone: 07 3405 3210 I Fax: 07 3012 8901 I Mobile Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
Mineral House I 41 George Street I Brisbane I QLD 4000
PO Box 15031 I City East I Brisbane I QLD 4002
AS
Great State. Great Opportunity.
To Dept
LE
From: Sharyn Watkins
Sent: Wednesday, 6 February 2013 9:11AM
To: Graham Webb; Jason Tibbits
Cc: Richard Ferrett
Subject: FW: QTC Document
RE
From: Mick Borzi Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
Sent: Wednesday, 6 February 2013 7:35AM
To: Local Government
Subject: FW: QTC Document
Good morning Minister.
Attached is the report of a highly respected Economist we engaged to review the QTC figures.
TI
Unfortunately, but for good reason your visit has been postponed, so we seek your confirmation or
advice on :•
You told us that 50.1% of votes cast at the referendum is enough for de-amalgamation
•
What will be the wording on the ballot papers
•
What will be the composition of the Transition Committee
TRC claimed at a Mareeba Chamber of Commerce meeting last Friday that they were acting
•
20/08/2013
RTI Document No. 1 - RTIP1314-006
R
Page 2 of2
CR
under your inst ructions in vigorously opposing de-ama lgamation. This was in answer to a query on the
huge cost incurred by TRC.
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
-O
LG
Regard s..........Mick Borzi
20/08/20 13
RTI Document No. 2 - RTIP1314-006
RT
IR
EL
RR
EA
SE
-O
LG
C
Page 3 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
TI
RE
LE
RR
AS
E
-O
LG
C
Page 4 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
TI
RE
LE
RR
AS
E
-O
LG
C
Page 5 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
TI
RE
LE
RR
AS
E
-O
LG
C
Page 6 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
RT
IR
EL
RR
EA
SE
-O
LG
C
Page 7 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
RT
IR
-O
LG
CR
R
EL
EA
SE
Page 8 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
RT
IR
EL
RR
EA
SE
-O
LG
C
Page 9 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
RT
IR
CR
R
EL
EA
SE
-O
LG
Page 10 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
RT
IR
CR
R
EL
EA
SE
-O
LG
Page 11 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
TI
RE
LE
CR
R
AS
E
-O
LG
Page 12 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
RT
IR
EL
CR
R
EA
SE
-O
LG
Page 13 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
RT
IR
EL
RR
EA
SE
-O
LG
C
Page 14 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
RT
IR
EL
CR
R
EA
SE
-O
LG
Page 15 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
TI
RE
LE
R
AS
E
-O
LG
CR
Page 16 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.cummings.net.au/
CR
R
Page 1 ot J
Karen Paraskevas
From :
DMullins@qtc.com.au
Sent:
Monday, 11 February 2013 3:28 PM
To:
Graham Webb
Cc:
Andrew Longmire; Gary Kleidon (Gary.Kieidon@dlgp.qld.gov.au); Jason Tibbits; Richard
Ferrett; Sharyn Watkins; MMcMullan@qtc.com.au; JNelson@qtc.com.au
Subject:
Re: FW: QTC Document
LG
Attachments: Mareeba- response to _Cummings Economics Review_Final.docx; ATT00003.txt
Graham.
-O
The attached document contains QTC's responses to those areas of the Cummings Economics Review
Report that we are able address.
It is noted that the Cummings Economics report is an unsophisticated attempt at analysis using a
simplistic "split of population" as the basis for a significant portion of the reports conclusions.
Let me know if we can assist further.
Regards
David
SE
David Mullins
Director 1 Local Government and Statutory Bodies Group
Queensland Treasury Corporation
EA
t 07 3842 4758 I m Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal
I f 07 3842
4958 1 dmullins@qtc.com.au I www.gtc.com.au
information
GPO Box 1096, Brisbane Queensland Australia 4001 1 Level 6, 123 Albert St, Brisbane Queensland 4000
From:
Graham Webb <Graham.Webb@ministerial.qld.gov.au>
To:
"DMullins@qtc.com.au" <DMullins@qtc.com.au>,
Richard Ferret! <Richard.Ferrett@ministerial.qld.gov.au>, Sharyn Watkins <Sharyn.Watkins@ministerial.qtd.gov.au>, Andrew
l ongmire <Andrew .longmire@ministerial.qld.gov.au> . Jason Tibbits <Jason.nbbits@ministerial.qld.gov.au>, "Gary Kleidon
(Gary.Kieidon@dlgp.qld.gov.au)" <Gary.Kieidon@dlgp.qld.gov.au>
06/ 02/2013 14:14
EL
Date.
IR
Subject FW: QTC Document
David
RT
As discussed. It is acknowledged that Gary Kleidon provided you with a copy of the Cummings
Economics Review Report prepared for the Mareeba proponents. For completeness I have
provided the covering message from Mick Borzi.
'>r\ ! Ml. /? 0
11
RTI Document No. 17 - RTIP1314-006
CR
R
Page L. or_,
Graham Webb
Policy Advisor
-O
LG
As QTC has done for other proponent groups that have questioned QTC Reports, could you please
provide a report for the Minister on the Mareeba Report.
SE
Office of the Hon. David Crisafulli MP I Minister for Local Government, Community Recovery and
Resilience
Phone: 07 3405 3210 I Fax: 07 3012 8901 1Mobile: Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
Mineral House I 41 George Street I Brisbane I QLD 4000
EA
PO Box 1503 1 I City East I Brisbane I QLD 4002
EL
Great State. Great Opportunity.
IR
From: Sharyn Watkins
Sent: Wednesday, 6 February 2013 9:11 AM
To: Graham Webb; Jason Tibbits
Cc: Richard Ferrett
Subject: FW: QTC Document
RT
To Dept
From: Mick Borzi
')() / ()Q /? ()
Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
11
RTI Document No. 18 - RTIP1314-006
R
Page 3 of3
LG
CR
Sent: Wednesday, 6 February 2013 7:35 AM
To: Local Government
Subject: FW: QTC Document
Good morning Minister.
Attached is the report of a highly respected Economist we engaged to review the QTC figures.
-O
Unfortunately, but for good reason your visit has been postponed, so we seek your confmnation or
advice on:You told us that 50.1% of votes cast at the referendum is enough for de-amalgamation
What will be the wording on the ballot papers
What will be the composition of the Transition Committee
AS
E
TRC claimed at a Mareeba Chamber of Commerce meeting last Friday that they were acting
under your instructions in vigorously opposing de-amalgamation. This was in answer to a query on
the huge cost incurred by TRC.
EL
E
Regards ...... .. ..Mick Borzi
TI
R
[attachment "J2646 CE Deamalgamation review. pdf' deleted by David
Mullins/Queensland Treasury Corporation/AU] (attachment "_Certification_.htm" deleted by David
Mullins/Queensland Treasury Corporation/AU]
')0 /0R/? 0 11
RTI Document No. 19 - RTIP1314-006
RT
IR
EL
EA
SE
RR
-O
LG
C
Page 20 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
R
-O
LG
CR
Page 21 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
RT
IR
EL
EA
S
E
CR
R
-O
LG
Page 22 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
RR
-O
LG
C
Page 23 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
TI
RE
LE
A
SE
R
-O
LG
CR
Page 24 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
R
-O
LG
CR
Page 25 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
RT
IR
EL
EA
SE
CR
R
-O
LG
Page 26 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
R
-O
LG
CR
Page 27 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
TI
RE
LE
A
SE
R
-O
LG
CR
Page 28 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
RT
IR
EL
EA
SE
CR
R
-O
LG
Page 29 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
R
-O
LG
CR
Page 30 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
RR
-O
LG
C
Page 31 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
RT
IR
EL
EA
S
E
CR
R
-O
LG
Page 32 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
RT
IR
EL
EA
SE
CR
R
-O
LG
Page 33 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
CR
R
-O
LG
Page 34 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------s. 53 - Other access available:
http://www.dlg.qld.gov.au/resources/report/local-government/bc/mareeba-qtc-report.pdf
R
Page 1 of3
From :
Andrew Longmire
Sent:
Tuesday , 12 February 2013 2:00PM
To:
David Crisafulli
Cc :
Graham Webb
Subject:
FW: QTC Document
CR
Karen Paraskevas
Attachments: Mareeba- response to _Cummings Economics Review_Final.docx; ATT00003.txt
LG
See re sponse to Cummings Economics report into QTC costing's for Mareeba de-amalgamation.
To discuss.
-O
From: DMullins@qtc.com.au [mailto:DMullins@qtc.com.au]
Sent: Monday, 11 February 2013 3:28 PM
To: Graham Webb
Cc: Andrew Longmire; Gary Kleidon (Gary.Kieidon@dlgp.qld.gov.au); Jason Tibbits; Richard Ferrett;
Sharyn Watkins; MMcMullan@qtc.com.au; JNelson@qtc.com.au
Subject: Re: FW: QTC Document
Graham.
AS
E
The attached document contains QTC's responses to those areas of the Cummings Economics Review
Report that we are able address.
It is noted that the Cummings Economics report is an unsophisticated attempt at analysis using a
simplistic "split of population" as the basis for a significant portion of the reports conclusions.
Let me know if we can assist further.
Regards
David
LE
David Mullins
Director 1 Local Government and Statutory Bodies Group
Queensland Treasury Corporation
1 f 07 3842
4958 1 dmullins@gtc.com.au 1 www.gtc.com au
Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal
information
GPO Box 1096, Brisbane Queensland Australia 4001 1 Leve16, 123 Albert St . Brisbane Q ueensland 4000
RE
t 07 3842 4758 1 m
From
To:
Cc.
Graham Webb <Graham.Webb@ministerial.gld.gov.au>
"DMullins@gtc.com.au" <DMullins@qtc.com.au>,
Richard Ferrett <Richard.Ferrett@ministerial.qld.qov.au>, Sharyn Watkins <Sharyn .Watkins@ministerial.qld .gov.au> , Andrew
Longmire <Andrew.Lonqmire@ministerial.qld.qov.au>, Jason Tibbits <Jason.Tibbits@ministerial.qld .gov.au> , "Gary Kleidon
(Garv.Kieidon@dlgp.gld.gov.au)" <Gary.Kieidon@dlgp.gld .gov.au>
Date.
06102/2013 14:14
TI
Subject. FW: QTC Document
20/08/2013
RTI Document No. 35 - RTIP1314-006
R
Page 2 of3
CR
David,
LG
As discussed. It is acknowledged that Gary Kleidon provided you with a copy of the Cummings
Economics Review Report prepared for the Mareeba proponents. For completeness I have provided
the covering message from Mick Borzi.
Graham Webb
Policy Advisor
E
-O
As QTC has done for other proponent groups that have questioned QTC Reports, could you please
provide a report for the Minister on the Mareeba Report.
RE
LE
AS
Office of the Hon. David Crisafulli MP I Minister for Local Government, Community Recovery and
Resilience
Phone: 07 3405 32 10 I Fax: 07 30 12 890 1 1Mobile: Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
Mineral House I 41 George Street I Brisbane I QLD 4000
PO Box 1503 1 I City East I Brisbane I QLD 4002
Great State. Great Opportunity.
TI
From: Sharyn Watkins
Sent: Wednesday, 6 February 2013 9: 11 AM
To: Graham Webb; Jason Tibbits
Cc: Richard Ferrett
Subject: FW: QTC Document
20/08/20 13
RTI Document No. 36 - RTIP1314-006
CR
R
Page 3 of3
To Dept
LG
From : Mick Borzi [ Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
Sent: Wednesday, 6 February 2013 7:35AM
To: Local Government
Subject: FW: QTC Document
-O
Good morning Minister.
Attached is the report of a highly respected Economist we engaged to review the QTC figures.
Unfortunately, but for good reason your visit has been postponed, so we seek your confirmation or
advice on :-
E
You told us that 50.1% of votes cast at the referendum is enough for de-amalgamation
LE
AS
What will be the wording on the ballot papers
What will be the composition of the Transition Committee
TRC claimed at a Mareeba C hamber of Commerce meeting last Friday that they were acting
under your instructions in vigorously opposing de-amalgamation. This was in answer to a query on
the huge cost incurred by TRC.
RE
Regards .... .. ... .Mick Borzi
TI
[attachment "J2646 CE Deamalgamation review.pdf' deleted by David
Mullins/Queensland Treasury Corporation/AU) [attachment "_Certification_.htm" deleted by David
Mullins/Queensland Treasury Corporation/AU)
20/08/20 13
RTI Document No. 37 - RTIP1314-006
TI
RE
LE
R
AS
E
-O
LG
CR
Page 38 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 20
TI
RE
L
R
EA
SE
-O
LG
CR
Page 39 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 21
TI
RE
LE
RR
AS
E
-O
LG
C
Page 40 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 22
TI
RE
LE
R
AS
E
-O
LG
CR
Page 41 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 23
TI
RE
LE
R
AS
E
-O
LG
CR
Page 42 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 24
TI
RE
LE
CR
R
AS
E
-O
LG
Page 43 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 25
TI
RE
LE
R
AS
E
-O
LG
CR
Page 44 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 26
TI
RE
R
LE
AS
E
-O
LG
CR
Page 45 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 27
TI
RE
LE
RR
AS
E
-O
LG
C
Page 46 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 28
TI
RE
R
LE
AS
E
-O
LG
CR
Page 47 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 29
TI
RE
LE
R
AS
E
-O
LG
CR
Page 48 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 30
TI
RE
LE
R
AS
E
-O
LG
CR
Page 49 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 31
TI
RE
LE
RR
AS
E
-O
LG
C
Page 50 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 32
TI
RE
LE
RR
AS
E
-O
LG
C
Page 51 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 33
TI
RE
LE
CR
R
AS
E
-O
LG
Page 52 redacted for the following reason:
--------------------Duplicate: RTI Document No. 34
RR
Page 1 of 1
Karen Paraskevas
From:
Rocnard Ferre n
Sent:
Monday, 25 February 2013 2 35 PM
To:
Andrew Longm"e
Subject: FW DE-AMALGAMATION
Andy,
Cheers,
RIChard
From: Paul Leven
Sent: Monday, 25 February 2013 11:39 AM
To: Richard Ferrett
Subject: Fwd: DE· AMALGAMAnON
FYI
The Premier has provided numerou s re sponses to Mr Boni.
can you give me a few lines for • response?
PL
Sent from my IPad
Begm forwarded me ssage:
From: Glenvs Jenk1n <GienysJenkin@premlers.gld.gov.au>
Date: 25 February 201311:15:13 AM GMT+10:00
To: 'Paul Leve n' <Paul.leven@mmlstenal.gld.gov.au>
Cc: Bee McCoan <bec.mccoan@ministerial.old. gov.au>
Subject: FW: DE-AMALGAMATION
HoPaul
Below 1s an email from M 1d; Borzl (former Mayor} seek1ng an urgent response pnor to a
meetong held In M•reeba tomorrow n<ght (TUESDAY, 26 FEBRUARY 2013).
Xtnd regard~.
-O
LG
C
Can you send me a couple of hn~ for this one.
Glenys
SE
Glenys Jenkon
Senoor Depa11memal ua.son Offocer
Department of the Premoer and Cabinet
Phone· 07 322 45692
Fa< 07 322 11809
rA l,lea::,r
ron~ider
the en,·irunmen1 tx-forC. Ilrin tin!e, ihis email
Hello Glenys
EA
From: The Premier
Sent: Monday, 25 February 2013 10:55 AM
To: Glenys Jenkin
Subject: FW: DE·AMALGAMAnON
Email from M ~ck Borzi seekmg a response pnor to a meettng tomorrow night. wm TRI M
and send up In the usual manner but thought an early copy might be needed.
Mtchele
From: Mick Borzi
Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
Sent: Monday, 25 February 2013 8:05AM
To: The Premier
RE
L
Cc: Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal
: Michaelinformation
Trout
Subject: DE-AMALGAMAnON
Dear Premter. 1 have just learned that t he Boundanes Commission is advertising on local
Radto stations about the de~amalgamatlon referendum.
While t o advise the public of the requirement to vote is not a problem, the: actual wording
that ls scare-mongering is 1m proper and not expected of what Is said to be an impartial
Government appointed organisation.
I have directed thts email to you because I suspect It must have had the approval of the
M i nister.
I have a publ1c meetins tomorrow (Tuesday) night here i n Mareeba and wou ld appreciate
your response by email before that so I can explain it to the audience.
Kind regards.................Mick Borzl mobile
Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
Thl.s email is i ntended only for che addressee. I t s use i a liau.ted to that
to be d.l.stributed w1.chout the author's consent.
TI
Unless otherwise s t ated, the State of Que ensland a ccepts no liability f or
subsequently confi rmed in writing. The opin1on s expressed in this email a
repr esent the v.1.ews of the State of Queensland . This ema1.l is conf1.dent.1a
If you have received this ema1.l in error, please notify the author and de
20/08/2013
RTI Document No. 53 - RTIP1314-006
R
Page 1 of2
Karen Paraskevas
Arldrew LOOQmlfe
Sent :
Monday, 25 February 2013 2 57 PM
To:
Rochard Ferren
Subj ect : RE: DE-AMALGAMATION
See below·
The Governme nt's only Interest 1s to tnform res•dents of the costs or de·amalgamatlon so they can make
an onformed chooce when they go to vote on March 9.
The mformat1on contained m the Queensland Boundaries CommtssJOner
repon tnto the proposed de-
amal&amatlon of Mareeba os publocally available and a true reflection or the pottntoal costs.
From: Richard Ferrett
-O
LG
Sent: Monday, 25 February 2013 2:35 PM
To: And~Longmi~
Subject: FW: DE-AMALGAMATION
Andy,
Can you send me a coupte of l1nes for this one.
Cheers,
Rochard
From: Paul Leven
Sent: Monday, 25 February 2013 11: 39 AM
To: RiChard Ferrett
Subject: Fwd: DE-AMALGAMATION
FYI
The Premier has provided numerous responses to Mr 8orzi.
Can you give me a few lines for a response?
PL
Sent from my iPad
AS
Ho Paul
E
Begin forwarded message:
From: Glenys Jenkin <Gienys.Jenkln@prem•ers.gld.gov.au>
Date: 2S February 2013 11:15:13 AM GMT+10:00
To : 'Paulleven' <Paul.leven@mmisteri al.gld.gov.au>
Cc Bee McCoan <bec.mccoan@mimsterial.gld.gov.au>
Subject: FW: DE -AMALGAMATION
Below is an emaol from Mick Bono (former Mayor) seekong an urgent response proor to a
meetong held in Mareeba tomorrow noght (TUESDAY, 26 FEBRUARY 1013).
Kind regards,
Glenys
Glenys Jenk•n
Senoor Departmental LoaiSOO Off.cer
Department of the Prem1er and Cab1net
o;
LE
Phone 07 322 45692
Fax
322 11809
,A Pl ca'c consi(i(-r I he environment befo re printing I his ,·mail
From: Tl1e Premier
Sent: Monday, 25 february 2013 10: 55 AM
To: Glenys Jenkin
Subject: FW: DE -AMALGAMATION
Hello Glenys
RE
Email rrom Mick Borzl seeking a response pnor to a meeting tomorrow noght. Will TRIM
and send up on the usual manner but thought an early copy moght be needed.
Michele
From: Mick Borzi [
CR
From:
Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal! information
Sent: Monday, 25 February 2013 8:05AM
To: Tl1e Premier
Cc:
Michael Trout
Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal
information
Subject: DE-AMALGAMATION
Dear Premier, I have j ust learned that the Boundaries Commission is advertJslng on local
Radoo stations about the de-amalgamation referen dum.
TI
Whil e to advise the public of the requirement to vote is not a problem . the actual wording
that is scare·mongering is improper and not expected of what is said to be an impartial
Government appointed organisation.
I have directed th is email to you because I suspect i t must have had the approval of the
20/08/201 3
RTI Document No. 54 - RTIP1314-006
Minister.
RR
Page 2 of2
I have a public meeting tomorrow (Tuesday) night here In Mareeba and would appreciate your response by email before that so I can explain it to the audience.
Kind regards.................M ick Bom mobile
Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
This email is inte nde d only f or the addresse e. I ts use is l i mit ed to t ha t intende d by the author at the time and it is not
to be distributed without the author's conse nt .
Unless otherwise stated. the State of Queensland accepts no liability f or the contents of thi s e ma i l except where
subsequently confirmed i n writ i ng. The opinions expressed io this email are those o f the a uthor and do not necessar ily
-O
LG
C
represent the views of the State of Queensla nd . Th is e mail is con fidential a nd may be subj e ct to a cla im o f legal privilege.
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
I f you ha ve received this email in e rror, ple ase notify the author and delete this message ifl'lt'lediately.
20/08/2013
RTI Document No. 55 - RTIP1314-006
From:
Sharyn Watkins
Tuesday, 26 February 2013 2:04 PM
Michelle Haddrick
FW: FROM YOUR VISIT
Sent:
To:
Subject:
-O
LG
Could you do this up as final for Min's signature please.
CR
R
Sharyn Watkins
Thanks
--------------------------From: Richard Ferrett
Sent: Tuesday, 26 February 2013 1:59PM
To: Sharyn Watkins
Subject: RE: FROM YOUR VISIT
This is fine
From: Sharyn Watkins
Sent: Monday, 25 February 2013 2:58 PM
To: Richard Ferrett
Subject: FW: FROM YOUR VISIT
E
Richard
Andy has drafted the following for your approval plea se:
AS
Dear XXXX,
I refer to your questions received via email on 25 February 2013 regarding the proposed
de-amalgamation of Mareeba from the Tablelands Regional Council (TRC).
LE
At the time of Queensland Treasury Corporation's (QTC) analysis, it was found a new
Mareeba Shire Council (MSC) would be al located $25,307,000 if it were to de-amalgamate
from the TRC.
(Table 12 - Summary Balance Sheet Allocation, page 18 De-ama lgamation Analysis of Tablelands Regional
Council)
RE
This number doesn't take into account the time elapsed between QTC's analysis and the
possible estab lishment of a new MSC and is subject to change.
TI
If residents vote in favour of Mareeba's de-amalgamation, I will appoint an interim CEO
who will be totally independent and have no affiliation w ith either the TRC or Mareeba. It
wi ll be the CEO's responsibility to oversee the transition process and put in place
everything needed for a new MSC to begin operations on January 1, 2014.
As to your second question, the structure of a new MSC has not been decided and will be
determined during the transition process if residents vote in favour of de-amalgamation.
1
RTI Document No. 56 - RTIP1314-006
CR
R
I want people to focus on the costs versus the benefits rather tha n the personalities or the
mechanics of de-amalgamation when they go to vote on Ma rc h 9.
------ --·-·--·---
-O
LG
From: Mick Borzi Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
Sent: Sunday, 24 February 2013 10:40 AM
To: Local Government
Subject: FROM YOUR VISIT
Dea r Minister Crisafu lli.
During your visit I asked what reserves would be transferred to MSC and while you sa id t hey were in the QTC report,
you undertook to respond.
Another question: Will there be divisional representation in the new MSC ?
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
Regards ......... M ick Borzi
2
RTI Document No. 57 - RTIP1314-006
From:
Sent:
Sharyn Watkins
Tuesday, 26 February 2013 2:21 PM
Michelle Haddrick
RE: FROM YOUR VISIT
To:
Subject:
-O
LG
Maybe ask Andy or Gary Kleidon??
From: Michelle Haddrick
Sent: Tuesday, 26 February 2013 2:21 PM
To: Sharyn Watkins
Subject: RE: FROM YOUR VISIT
Do you have address details for Mick Bo rzi?
From: Sharyn Watkins
Sent: Tuesday, 26 February 2013 2:04 PM
To: Michelle Haddrick
Subject: FW: FROM YOUR VISIT
Cou ld you do this up as fina l for Min's signature please.
AS
E
Thanks
From: Richard Ferrett
Sent: Tuesday, 26 February 2013 1:59PM
To: Sharyn Watkins
Subject: RE: FROM YOUR VISIT
CR
R
I
Sharyn Watkins
This is fine
Richard
LE
From: Sharyn Watkins
Sent: Monday, 25 February 2013 2:58 PM
To: Richard Ferrett
Subject: FW : FROM YOUR VISIT
Andy has drafted the following for your approva l please:
RE
Dear XXXX,
I refer to your questions received via email on 25 February 2013 regarding the proposed
de-ama lgamation of Ma reeba from the Tab lelands Regional Council (TRC).
TI
At the time of Queensla nd Treasury Corporation's (QTC) analysis, it was found a new
Mareeba Shire Council (MSC} would be al located $25,307,000 if it were to de-amal gamate
from th e TRC.
(Table 12- Summa ry Ba lance Sheet Allocation, page 18 De-amalgamation Analysis of Tablelands Regional
Counci l)
1
RTI Document No. 58 - RTIP1314-006
CR
R
\
This number doesn't take into account the time elapsed between QTC's ana lysi s and th e
possible est ablishment of a new MSC and is subject to change.
If residents vote in favo ur of Mareeba's de-amalgamation, I will appoint an interim CEO
who will be totally independent and have no affiliation with either the TRC or Mareeba . It
will be the CEO's responsibility to oversee the transition process and put in place
everything needed for a new MSC to begin operations on January 1, 2014.
-O
LG
As to your second question, the structure of a new MSC has not been decided and will be
determined during the transition process if residents vote in favour of de-amalgamation.
I want people to focus on the costs versus the benefits rather than the personalities or the
mechanics of de-amalgamation when they go to vote on March 9.
From: Mick Borzi Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
Sent: Sunday, 24 February 2013 10:40 AM
To: Local Government
]
Subject: FROM YOUR VISIT
E
Dear Minister Crisafulli.
AS
During your visit I asked what reserves would be transferred to MSC and while you sa id they were in the QTC report,
you und ertook to respond.
Another question: Will there be divisional representation in the new MSC?
TI
RE
LE
Regards ......... Mick Borzi
2
RTI Document No. 59 - RTIP1314-006
From:
Sharyn Watkins
Monday, 25 February 2013 2:58 PM
Ri chard Ferrett (Richard.Ferrett@ministerial.qld.gov.au)
FW: FROM YOUR VISIT
Sent:
To:
Subject:
-O
LG
Richa rd
CR
R
Sharyn Watki ns
Andy has drafte d the following for your approval please:
Dear XXXX,
I refer to your questions received via email on 25 February 2013 rega rding the proposed
de-ama lgamation of Mareeba from the Tablelands Regional Council (TRC) .
At the time of Queens land Treasury Corpora t ion' s (QTC) analysis, it w as found a new
Mareeba Shire Council (MSC) would be allocated $25,307,000 if it were to de-amalgamate
from the TRC.
(Table 12- Summary Balance Sheet Allocation , page 18 De-amalgamat ion Analysis of Tableland s Regiona l
E
Counci l)
AS
This number doesn't take into account t he tim e ela psed betw een QTC's analysis and the
possible establishment of a new MSC and is subject to change.
If residents vote in favour of Mareeba's de-ama lgamat io n, I wi ll appoint an inte ri m CEO
who will be totally ind ependent and have no affiliation with either t he TRC or Mareeba. It
will be the CEO's responsibility to oversee th e transition process and put in place
everything needed for a new MSC to begin operations on Janua ry 1, 2014.
LE
As to your second question, the structu re of a new MSC has not been decided and w ill be
determined during the t ransition process if residents vote in favour of de-amalgamation.
RE
I want people to f ocus on the costs versus the benefits rather than the personalities or the
mechanics of de-amalgamati on when they go to vote on March 9.
TI
From: Mick Borzi Sch. 4(4)(6) - Personal information
Sent: Sunday, 24 February 2013 10:40 AM
To: Local Government
Subject: FROM YOUR VISIT
Dear Minister Crisafulli.
1
RTI Document No. 60 - RTIP1314-006
CR
R
During your visit I asked what reserves would be tra nsferred to MSC and w hile you said they were in the QTC report,
you undertook t o respond .
Another quest ion : Will there be divisiona l representation in the new MSC?
TI
RE
LE
AS
E
-O
LG
Regards .........Mick Borzi
2
RTI Document No. 61 - RTIP1314-006