The Official Auction of the Whitman Coin and Collectibles Baltimore

Transcription

America’s Oldest and Most Accomplished Rare Coin Auctioneer
The June 2014
Baltimore Auction
U.S. Coins
Baltimore, Maryland
Baltimore Convention Center
June 27 & July 1, 2014
The Official Auction of the
Whitman Coin and Collectibles
Baltimore Expo
Stack’s Bowers Galleries
Upcoming Auction Schedule
Coins and Currency
Date
Auction
Consignment Deadline
Continuous
Stack’s Bowers Galleries Weekly Internet Auctions
Closing Every Sunday
Continuous
August 6-10, 2014
Stack’s Bowers and Ponterio – World Coins & Paper Money
An Official Auction of the ANA World’s Fair of Money
Chicago, IL
June 7, 2014
August 6-10, 2014
Stack’s Bowers Galleries – U.S. Coins & Currency
Chicago, IL
June 23, 2014
August 18-20, 2014
Hong Kong Auction of Chinese and Asian Coins & Currency
Hong Kong
June 13, 2014
October 7-11, 2014
Stack’s Bowers Galleries – U.S. Coins
An Official Auction of the PNG New York Invitational
New York, NY
August 25, 2014
October 29-November 1, 2014
Stack’s Bowers and Ponterio –World Coins & Paper Money
Official Auction of the Whitman Coin & Collectibles Baltimore Expo
Baltimore, MD
August 25, 2014
October 29-November 1, 2014
Baltimore, MD
September 8, 2014
January 9-10, 2015
An Official Auction of the NYINC
New York, NY
November 1, 2014
January 28-30, 2015
Americana Sale
New York, NY
November 26, 2014
March 3-7, 2015
Baltimore, MD
January 26, 2015
April 2015
Hong Kong Auction of Chinese and Asian Coins & Currency
Hong Kong
January 2015
June 3-5, 2015
Baltimore, MD
April 3, 2015
August 11-15, 2015
Chicago, IL
June 15, 2015
August 11-15, 2015
Chicago, IL
June 30, 2015
Stack’s Bowers Galleries presents
The June 2014 Baltimore Auction
U.S. Coins
June 27 & July 1, 2014
One West Pratt Street
Baltimore, MD 21201
Tel: 410.649.7000
Featuring
The Bareford Family Collection
The Raymond W. Dillard Collection
of Elongated Coins, Part VII
The El Dorado Collection, Part II
California Office
1063 McGaw Ave.
Irvine, CA 92614
Telephone: 800.458.4646
Telephone: 949.253.0916
Fax: 949.253.4091
New York Office
123 W. 57th St.
New York, NY 10019
Telephone: 800.566.2580
Telephone: 212.582.2580
Fax: 212.245.5018
New England Office
P.O. Box 1804
Wolfeboro, NH 03894
Telephone: 866.811.1804
Telephone: 603.569.0823
Fax: 603.569.3875
Hong Kong Office
Unit 1702, 17/F
Dina House
Ruttonjee Centre
11 Duddell St., Central HK
Telephone: 852.2117.1191
www.stacksbowers.com
Copyright © 2014 Stack’s-Bowers Numismatics, LLC • All Rights Reserved
How to Bid
Before the Live Auction
There are several ways to bid prior to the start of the live auction.
Fax/Mail Bid Sheet
Use the enclosed bid sheet and mail or fax it to us. If sending by mail, please allow sufficient time for the postal service.
Mail:
Att. Auction Department
1063 McGaw Ave.
Irvine, CA 92614
United States
Fax: 949.253.4091
Phone
Telephone Stack’s Bowers Galleries at 949.253.0916
Internet
View additional images and add items to your personal tracking list. You may also place bids and check their status in
real time. Visit our website at www.stacksbowers.com.
During the Live Auction
Attend in Person
Auction Event: Baltimore Convention Center
One West Pratt St
Baltimore, MD 21201
Tel: 410.649.7000
Live Online Bidding
Stack’s Bowers Galleries will offer live online bidding for this auction. We strongly recommend that you register
to bid at www.stacksbowers.com at least 48 hours before the start of the auction.
Live Bidding by Phone
If you wish to bid by phone during the live auction, please register your interest at least 48 hours prior to the start
of the auction. Stack’s Bowers Galleries will ask for the lot numbers you are interested in with your complete contact
information. Stack’s Bowers Galleries will call you during the auction and you can place bids with our representative
in real time. We regret that we can only offer this service for lots estimated at $2500 or more. If you wish to arrange live
bidding by phone, contact Customer Service at 949-253-0916 or email info@stacksbowers.com.
ii
The June 2014 Baltimore Auction
June 27 & July 1, 2014
Lot Viewing
Lot Viewing will be conducted in the Irvine, CA offices (by appointment only): June 6-11, 2014
Lot Viewing will be conducted in the NY offices (by appointment only): June 17-21, 2014
Lot Viewing will be conducted at the Baltimore Convention Center, Room 307, as follows:
Tuesday, June 24
9:00 AM – 7:00 PM ET
Wednesday, June 25
9:00 AM – 7:00 PM ET
Friday, June 27
9:00 AM – 7:00 PM ET
Saturday, June 28
9:00 AM – 1:00 PM ET
Thursday, June 26
9:00 AM – 7:00 PM ET
Auction Location
One West Pratt St
Baltimore, MD 21201
Tel: 410.649.7000
Auction Details
The Auction will be conducted at the Baltimore Convention Center, Room 308 as follows:
Session 1 – U.S. Currency
(see separate catalog)
Thursday, June 26 – 6:00 PM ET
Lots 1-553
Session 2 – U.S. Coins
Friday, June 27 – 12:00 Noon ET
Lots 1001-1525
Session 4 – U.S. Coins Internet Only
Ends Tuesday, July 1 – 3:00 PM PT
Lots 3001-5084
Session 5 – U.S. Currency Internet Only
(see separate catalog)
Lots 6001-6671
Friday, June 27 – 6:00 PM ET
Lots 2001-2751
Lot Pickup
Lot Pick up will be conducted at the Baltimore Convention Center, Room 307, as follows:
Friday, June 27
10:00 AM – 1:00 PM ET
Saturday, June 28
10:00 AM – 1:00 PM ET
Bank Wire Information:
HSBC
950 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10022
For credit to (Payee):
Stack’s Bowers Numismatics,
Account #000186236
US Routing #021001088
International Routing (Swift Code) #MRMDUS33
iii
Greg Roberts
President and CEO,
Spectrum Group International
GRoberts@StacksBowers.com
Ext. 205
Brian Kendrella
President
BKendrella@StacksBowers.com
Ext. 291
Chris Napolitano
Executive Vice President
CNapolitano@StacksBowers.com
Ext. 224
Richard Ponterio
RPonterio@StacksBowers.com
Andrew Glassman
EVP, Credit Manager
AGlassman@StacksBowers.com
Ext. 254
Christine Karstedt
of Consignments
CKarstedt@StacksBowers.com
603.569.0823
Corey Maita
Chief Operating Officer
CMaita@StacksBowers.com
Ext. 259
Nirat Lertchitvikul
Director of Asian Operations
Nirat@StacksBowers.com
852.2.117.1191
Peter Treglia
Director of Currency
PTreglia@StacksBowers.com
Ext. 250
John P. Konop
Vice President,
Director of Distinguished Client Services
JKonop@StacksBowers.com
Ext. 293
Stack’s Bowers Galleries Founders
Q. David Bowers
Chairman Emeritus
qdbarchive@metrocast.net
iv
Harvey Stack
Senior Numismatic Consultant
Hgs1919@gmail.com
Lawrence R. Stack
Senior Numismatic Consultant
lawrencerstack@gmail.com
Cataloged by Jeff Ambio, Q. David Bowers, John Kraljevich, James Matthews, James McCartney,
Ben Orooji, John Pack, Andy Pollock, Eric Schena, Steve Tureen and Frank VanValen
Stack’s Bowers Galleries Team
Consignment and Numismatic Specialists
California Office: 949.253.0916
Thad Olson
Ext. 272 – TOlson@StacksBowers.com
Jeff Ambio
Ext. 204 – JeffA@StacksBowers.com
Wayne Berkley
Ext. 262 – WBerkley@StacksBowers.com
Chris Chatigny
Ext. 318 – CChatigny@StacksBowers.com
Ron Gillio
RGillio@StacksBowers.com
Benjamin Orooji
Ext. 295 – BOrooji@StacksBowers.com
John Pack
Ext. 258 – JPack@StacksBowers.com
Kerry Pieropan
Ext. 353 – KPieropan@StacksBowers.com
Kent Ponterio
Ext. 289 – KePonterio@StacksBowers.com
Amandeep Jassal
Ext. 249 – AJassal@StacksBowers.com
Kyle Ponterio
Ext. 212 – KyPonterio@StacksBowers.com
John Konop
Ext. 293 – JKonop@StacksBowers.com
Matt Quinn
Ext. 279 – MQuinn@StacksBowers.com
Dale Larsen
Ext. 248 – DLarsen@StacksBowers.com
Jeffrey Lubinski
Ext. 305 – JLubinski@StacksBowers.com
James McCartney
Ext. 232 – JMcCartney@StacksBowers.com
Todd McKenna
Ext. 221 – TMcKenna@StacksBowers.com
Richard Melamed
Ext. 217 – RMelamed@StacksBowers.com
Ryan Moretti
Ext. 284 – RMoretti@StacksBowers.com
Gene Nesheim
Ext. 219 – GNesheim@StacksBowers.com
Scott Reiter
Ext. 228 – SReiter@StacksBowers.com
New York Office: 212.582.2580
Andrew Bowers
Ext. 5222 – ABowers@StacksBowers.com
Greg Cohen
Ext. 5455 – GCohen@StacksBowers.com
New Hampshire Office: 603.569.0823
Melissa Karstedt
MKarstedt@StacksBowers.com
Frank Van Valen
FVanValen@StacksBowers.com
Hong Kong Office: +852.2117.1191
Nirat Lertchitvikul
Nirat@StacksBowers.com
Ping Lertchitvikul
Ping@StacksBowers.com
Other Offices
Bobby Avena
BAvena@StacksBowers.com
Danny Avena
DAvena@StacksBowers.com
James Matthews
JMatthews@StacksBowers.com
Consultants
Bruce Roland Hagen
Ext. 5462 – BHagen@StacksBowers.com
Mike Hodder
Steve Nugget
Ext. 5514 – SNugget@StacksBowers.com
Andy Pollock
Vicken Yegparian
Ext. 5459 – VYegparian@StacksBowers.com
John Kraljevich
Eric Schena
Steve Tureen
Customer Service
DJ Olivares
Photography
Shipping and Receiving
Ceilia Mullins
David Parks
Karen Bridges
Ron Castro
Danielle Hill
Jason Best
Stephanie Baur
Aubree Bova
Accounting
Jeremy Katz
Joe Delgado
Ai Tee Cheng
David Ruan
Vika Sabo
Jose Martinez
Adrianne Conrad
Fumi Norris Doan
Dan Malo
Anibal Ortiz
Samantha Douglas
Sofia Gallegos
Keven Tran
Linda Hood
Kathleen Huang
Amanda Iapello
Jennifer Koranda
Information Technology
Carol Holt
Sarah Jackels
Thinh Do Loung
Steven Balderrama
Carola Ponterio
Wendy Leonard
Phuong Nguyen
John Ballecer
Jenna Kendrella
Asha Ramcharan
Archie Bracey
Tyler Kreil
Brandon Tang
Brian Hunt
Cynthia LaCarbonara
Geoff LeDoyen
Brent Lemmon
Travis McDonald
Louis Melamed
Robin Olson
Marketing and Graphic Design
Administrative
Bernie Jimenez
Sam King
Andrea Espindola
Glenn Landenberger
Jennifer Meers
Michael Loeffler
Bryan Stoughton
James Puangco
Millie Wu
Anant Singh
v
The El Dorado Collection, Part II
On the morning of April 18, 1906, a major earthquake struck the
city of San Francisco. While it seemed that relatively little damage
occurred to the physical structures, water lines were severely
damaged, leaving the city vulnerable to the numerous fires that
followed the tremors. At its worst, the fires were described by a
witness as, “a solid wall of fire three miles in length.” The fires burned
for three days, destroying large areas of San Francisco.
Famously, the United States Mint survived the disaster, with merely
$53,500 in damage, as reported in The Annual Report of the Director
of the Mint. This structure’s survival was due to an internal fireprotection system as well as the efforts of a number of officers and
employees who were able to make it to the building to aid in its
protection. Among these men was Superintendent of Machinery
George McLoughlin. McLoughlin had earlier worked at the mints
in Philadelphia and Carson City, and his background as an engineer
likely made him a central figure in saving the Mint building in San
Francisco. He was recognized and thanked for his service in the
“terrible conflagration” by Mint Director Roberts.
McLoughlin had been around the Mint’s operations for years, and
he was aware of the special nature of the new 1907 double eagle by
Augustus Saint-Gaudens. He bought one for himself from a group of
freshly minted examples that had been shipped from Philadelphia
vi
to San Francisco, and eventually passed it on to his son. Skipping
a generation, the collecting bug struck again, and his grandson
endeavored to assemble a fine cabinet of Saint-Gaudens double
eagles. We had the pleasure of selling that lovely collection in
November 2006 (not including the 1907, which was retained until
the present time), and now are delighted to present the remainder
of this collection. The present offering is primarily Liberty double
eagles, a collection begun with a focus on those struck in San
Francisco from 1854 to 1907, which grew to include nearly every
date and mintmark from 1890 on. Also included are Territorial
issues struck in San Francisco by Kellogg & Company and the
United States Assay Office of Gold, precursor to the San Francisco
Mint. Among many highlights, the collection includes the Dallas
Bank Collection specimen of the famous 1861-S Paquet Reverse, a
coin that the collector considered his greatest acquisition. However,
undeniably his favorite coin was the magnificent 1906-S double eagle
from the Eliasberg Collection, struck in San Francisco the same year
his grandfather risked his life to help save the Mint building from
the great fire that consumed most of the city. It is the finest known
example of the issue, a spectacular coin, and certainly a highlight of
the present sale. We are delighted to once again work with this family
in the further presentation of the exceptional El Dorado Collection.
The Bareford Family Collection
We are honored to include a small grouping of state coppers
from the collection of Harold Bareford and family. The name
Bareford looms large among numismatic greats. State copper
collectors recall his spectacular collections of New Jersey
coppers, sold by Stack’s in May 1984. Collectors of U.S. federal
coins will associate the names with the amazing profusion of
Gems that populated his collections of silver and gold coins,
sold by Stack’s in 1978 (gold) and 1981 (silver). Among his
most prized specimens was the Dexter-Bareford 1804 dollar,
which for many years held the title of the most valuable coin
ever auctioned. Mr. Bareford’s careful connoisseurship and
attention to quality in an era when few others cared so much
about grade led to an extraordinary result when his collection
was sold. In fact, his gold coins brought $1.2 million in 1981
on a cost basis of just $14,000, an incredible return that first
interested Wall Street in the rare coin market and changed
the face of numismatics forever.
vii
Highlights from the June 2014 Baltimore Auction
Lot 1002 1862 Abraham Lincoln Indian Peace Medal.
Lot 1377 1898 Barber Quarter. Proof-68 Deep Cameo (PCGS).
Large Format. Silver. 76.0 mm. Julian IP-38. Choice Very Fine.
Lot 1006 (1800) Washington Funeral Medal. Gold.
Lot 1438 1859-S Liberty Seated Half Dollar.
MS-68 (PCGS). CAC. Secure Holder.
Baker-169. About Uncirculated.
Lot 1470 1919-D Walking Liberty Half Dollar.
Lot 1113 (1800) Washington Skull and Crossbones
Funeral Medal. Silver. Baker-165A. Rarity-8. VF-35 (PCGS).
Lot 1268 1880 Shield Nickel. MS-66 (PCGS).
Secure Holder.
viii
MS-64 (NGC). CAC.
Lot 2349 1878 Trade Dollar.
Proof-67 Cameo (PCGS). CAC. Secure Holder.
Highlights from the June 2014 Baltimore Auction
Lot 2437 1854 Kellogg & Co. $20. MS-60 (PCGS).
Lot 2570 1865 Liberty Eagle. Proof-62 (NGC).
Lot 2534 1875 Liberty Half Eagle. AU-53 (PCGS). CAC.
Lot 2629 1861-S Liberty Double Eagle. A.C. Paquet Reverse.
Lot 2547 1909-O Indian Half Eagle.
MS-62 (PCGS). Secure Holder.
Lot 2671 1882 Liberty Double Eagle.
Lot 2554 1795 Capped Bust Right Eagle.
BD-2, Taraszka-2. AU-58 (PCGS). OGH.
AU-58 (PCGS). Secure Holder.
Proof-65 Ultra Cameo (NGC).
Lot 2730 1906-S Liberty Double Eagle.
MS-66 (PCGS). CAC. OGH.
ix
Order of Sale
Friday, June 27 – 12:00 Noon ET
Lots 1001-1525
Friday, June 27 – 6:00 PM ET
Lots 2001-2751
Category
Lot Number
Indian Peace Medals.............................1001-1004
Washingtoniana ....................................1004-1011
Lincolniana ......................................................1012
Political Medals and Related .........................1013
Presidents and Inaugurals ...................1014-1015
Augustus Saint-Gaudens Medals .................1016
Art Medals .......................................................1017
So-Called Dollars ..................................1018-1021
Agricultural, Mechanical, Scientific,
and Professional Medals ................................1022
Award Medals ........................................1023-1025
School, College
and University Medals .........................1026-1027
Anti-Slavery .....................................................1028
Fairs and Expositions ...........................1029-1033
Miscellaneous Medals ....................................1034
Engraved Coins, Love Tokens,
and Coin Jewelry.............................................1035
Hard Times Tokens ..............................1036-1038
Patriotic Civil War Tokens ..................1039-1044
Civil War Store Cards ...........................1045-1054
Sutler Tokens ...................................................1055
Encased Postage Stamps ......................1056-1060
Indian Trader Tokens .....................................1061
Post-Civil War Military Tokens ....................1062
Late 19th and 20th Century Tokens ..1063-1064
Transportation Tokens .........................1065-1066
Counterstamps ......................................1067-1068
Massachusetts Silver Coinage .............1069-1078
Wood’s Hibernia Coinage..............................1079
Virginia Coinage .............................................1080
Elephant Tokens ..............................................1081
Nova Constellatio Copper .............................1082
Connecticut Copper.............................1083-1087
Machin’s Mills Halfpenny ....................1088-1091
Contemporary Counterfeit
English Halfpenny ................................1092-1097
New Jersey Copper ...............................1098-1108
Vermont Copper .............................................1109
Bar Copper.......................................................1110
Franklin Press Token ......................................1111
Washington Pieces ................................1112-1114
Fugio Copper.........................................1115-1121
Struck Copies of Colonial Coins
and Related ............................................1122-1125
Half Cents ..............................................1126-1140
Large Cents ............................................1141-1189
Small Cents ............................................1190-1231
Two-Cent Piece .....................................1232-1239
Silver Three-Cent Piece........................1240-1242
Nickel Three-Cent Piece ......................1243-1245
Nickel Five-Cent Pieces .......................1246-1307
Half Dimes .............................................1308-1316
Dimes ......................................................1317-1352
Twenty-Cent Piece................................1353-1354
Quarter Dollars .....................................1355-1407
Half Dollars............................................1408-1486
Bullion ..............................................................1487
Modern Commemorative .............................1488
Rolls.........................................................1489-1493
Mint Errors ............................................1494-1525
Category
Lot Number
Flowing Hair Silver Dollars .................2001-2008
Draped Bust Silver Dollars ..................2009-2037
Gobrecht Silver Dollars........................2038-2039
Liberty Seated Silver Dollars ...............2040-2065
Morgan Silver Dollars ..........................2066-2245
Peace Silver Dollars ..............................2246-2264
The Morris Minsberg Portfolio ..........2265-2338
GSA Dollars ...........................................2339-2341
Trade Dollar ...........................................2342-2353
Commemorative Silver Coins ............2354-2375
Commemorative Gold Coins .............2376-2383
Pattern and Experimental Coins ........2384-2425
Private and Territorial Gold Coins
and Related ............................................2426-2441
Hawaiian Coins, Medals, Tokens
and Related ............................................2442-2445
Gold Dollars ..........................................2446-2453
Quarter Eagles .......................................2454-2493
Three-Dollar Gold Pieces ....................2494-2507
Four-Dollar Gold Piece..................................2508
Half Eagles .............................................2509-2553
Eagles ......................................................2554-2593
Double Eagles ........................................2594-2751
x
Session 4 – U.S. Coins Internet Only
Lots 3001-5084
Category
Lot Number
Military Medals .....................................3001-3002
Washingtoniana ....................................3003-3005
Lincolniana ......................................................3006
Political Medals and Related ...............3007-3009
Presidents and Inaugurals ...................3010-3011
Art Medals .............................................3012-3013
Commemorative Medals .....................3014-3016
So-Called Dollars ..................................3017-3020
Award Medals ........................................3021-3022
Aviation ............................................................3023
School, College and
University Medals .................................3024-3025
Fairs and Expositions ...........................3026-3038
Numismatic Association Medals........3039-3054
Miscellaneous Medals ....................................3055
Hard Times Tokens ..............................3056-3061
Patriotic Civil War Tokens ..................3062-3064
Civil War Store Cards ...........................3065-3074
Civil War Tokens...................................3075-3078
Sutler Tokens .........................................3079-3081
Civil War and Confederacy ...........................3082
Indian Trader Tokens ...........................3083-3084
Post-Civil War Military Tokens ....................3085
Embossed Shell Cards ....................................3086
Counterstamps ......................................3087-3129
Elongated Coins ....................................3130-3209
and Coin Jewelry.............................................3210
Miscellaneous Tokens ..........................3211-3215
Rosa Americana Coinage ..............................3216
Wood’s Hibernia Coinage..............................3217
Machin’s Mills Halfpennies .................3218-3224
New Jersey Copper ...............................3225-3268
Vermont Copper .............................................3269
North American Token..................................3270
Kentucky Token ....................................3271-3272
Talbot, Allum & Lee Cent..............................3273
Castorland Medal, or Jeton .................3274-3276
Washington Pieces ................................3277-3283
Fugio Copper...................................................3284
and Related ......................................................3285
Half Cents ..............................................3286-3323
Large Cents ............................................3324-3466
Small Cents ............................................3467-3591
Two-Cent Piece .....................................3592-3611
Silver Three-Cent Piece........................3612-3619
Nickel Three-Cent Piece ......................3620-3647
Nickel Five-Cent Pieces .......................3648-3732
Half Dimes .............................................3733-3763
Dimes ......................................................3764-3856
Twenty-Cent Piece................................3857-3864
Quarter Dollars .....................................3865-3970
Half Dollars............................................3971-4116
Silver Dollars .........................................4117-4507
GSA Dollars ...........................................4508-4512
Redfield Dollar ................................................4513
Trade Dollars .........................................4514-4525
Modern Dollar ................................................4526
Gold Dollars ..........................................4527-4546
Quarter Eagles .......................................4547-4570
Three-Dollar Gold Pieces ....................4571-4574
Half Eagles .............................................4575-4601
Eagles ......................................................4602-4608
Double Eagles ........................................4609-4637
Commemorative Silver Coins ............4638-4799
Commemorative Gold Coins .............4800-4805
Modern Commemoratives..................4806-4821
Bullion ....................................................4822-4837
Pattern and Experimental Coins ........4838-4839
Mint Errors ............................................4840-5069
Miscellaneous U.S. Coins ....................5070-5076
Private and Territorial Gold Coins
and Related ............................................5077-5081
Philippines Under U.S. Sovereignty ...5082-5084
End of Sale
The June 2014
Baltimore Auction
Session 2
Friday, June 27, 2014
Start time: 12:00 noon ET
Lots 1001- 1525
Stack’s Bowers Galleries The June 2014 Baltimore Auction
Numismatic Americana
Indian Peace Medals
1001 “1849” Zachary Taylor Indian Peace Medal. Small Format. First Reverse. Bronzed Copper. 51 mm. By Henry K. Brown and John
Reich. Julian IP-29. MS-65 BN (NGC). This is the early reverse die with pointed As in the legend as opposed to the flat-topped As used
on the “new” reverse introduced in 1846. Gorgeous crimson-copper surfaces are boldly defined and free of detracting blemishes. Small
format Taylor IPMs are quite rare, and the present piece is sure to see spirited bidding, as such.
Lovely 1862 Lincoln Peace Medal
Large Format
1002 1862 Abraham Lincoln Indian Peace Medal. Large Format. Silver. 76.0 mm. 3163.8 grains. Julian IP-38. Choice Very Fine.
Lovely medium steel gray with deeper tones in the recesses and traces of light iridescence toward the rims. Somewhat lighter gray
on the higher points of the motifs. A few trivial scattered marks are noted in the open fields, but the medal is free of the large marks
typical of awarded pieces. Traces of proof like reflectivity remains on both sides, giving this piece a particularly pleasant aesthetic.
Neatly pierced at 12 o’clock, as issued, with an intact suspension ring. Struck on a very heavy planchet, with rounded rims, both
attributes consistent with medals struck from original dies at the Mint for collectors, subsequent to the production of those made
for distribution to Native Americans. Our John J. Ford, Jr. Collection offering included a remarkable presentation of seven large
size Lincoln medals, only one of which was this slightly later variant and it looked almost identical in quality to this one. The Ford
piece weighed in at 3,099.0 grains, but had no suspension loop. Large format Lincoln medals are always in strong demand, as they
were issued by one of America’s most favored administrations. In addition, the reverse motif that includes an early depiction of
baseball being played provides and added element of appeal. A fine example of this design and worthy of placement in an important
collection of American medals or Lincolniana.
Ex: Joseph Levine, privately, March 1992.
Page 2
Session Two Starts 12:00 Noon ET - Friday, June 27, 2014
1003 Undated (1911) Edward Knox Elder Medal for Osage
Chief Wa-She-Ha (Bacon Rind). Aluminum. 37.8 mm.
About Uncirculated, Lightly Corroded. Pierced for
suspension, as made. One of the more modern Indian Peace
medals, this type was struck privately by Edward Knox
Elder, Indian trader and brother of numismatist Thomas
Elder. Aluminum is the “common” metallic composition of
this type, with a reported mintage of 400 pieces, however
that figure is questionable as survivors appear in the market
with far less frequency that such a mintage would suggest.
This particular example exhibits only light, singularly
inconspicuous handling marks to surfaces that are
noticeably cameoed in finish. A small area of light corrosion
at the upper reverse border is noted.
Washingtoniana
Superb Washington Draped Bust/
Melbourne Kangaroo Muling
1004 1851 Washington Draped Bust Copper / Melbourne
Kangaroo Mule. Baker-3M, Vlack MEL-K. Copper.
Specimen-64 BN (PCGS). The PCGS insert incorrectly
lists the date of this piece as 1857. Obv: MELBOURNE arcs
above a kangaroo facing left, W.J. TAYLOR MEDALLIST /
TO THE GREAT / EXHIBITION / 1851 on four lines in
exergue. Rev: Seated Liberty left with liberty pole and cap
in left hand, olive branch in right, UNITED STATES arcing
above. Deep chocolate brown with a faint chestnut mottling
and overtones of pale blue iridescence. A lovely example,
slightly satiny and with only the most trivial marks. Nicely
struck with high rims and good central details. Far superior
to the specimen from our 2013 sale of the Ted Craige
Collection. Desirable to Washingtoniana collectors due to
the use of the Washington Draped Bust copper reverse die.
The event referred to is better known as the Crystal Palace
Exhibition from the configuration of the enclosure. The idea
was copied in New York City in 1853 with our own Crystal
Palace Exposition, this being done with private financing
and with P.T. Barnum in charge. The glass structure burned
in October 1858 and was the subject of a medalet distributed
by Augustus B. Sage from dies cut by George H. Lovett.
From the Charles A. Wharton Collection. Earlier from Anthony Terranova. Paper envelope with attribution notation included.
Extremely Rare Washington
Resumed Command Medal
The Baker-Garrett-Steinberg Specimen
1005 1799 Washington Resumed Command Medal. Bronzed
White Metal. 37.1 mm. 14.6 grams. Baker-67, var.
Extremely Fine. The flan was bronzed before striking and
is the only one we have seen in this format. Toned a deep
chocolate brown, but the tin beneath has pested resulting
in a generally rough appearance. There is some loss of the
bronze on the high points and a few small chips revealing
the white metal beneath. Nicely struck with excellent
definition remaining throughout. This type is a great rarity
among the early medals. When Michael Hodder cataloged
the Ford Collection example, he knew of just six including
all known die variants, Baker-67, 67A, and 67B. Today it
seems there are a couple more accounted for, but specimens
in the Smithsonian and Historical Society of Pennsylvania
Collections are not likely to become available to collectors.
In 2002 it was discovered by George Fuld that there were
three different die marriages for this type, while just two were
cataloged in the most recent revision of Medallic Portraits of
Washington (1999). Detailed examinations of the dies are
given in our catalogs of the Ford and Norweb examples. In
brief, the obverses are known with a space above the portrait
or with WASHI(NGTON) above, and with two different date
of death representations, 14 DECEMBER or DECEMBER
14, respectively. The two reverse dies differ in placement of
the letters of the legend, though the text is identical. One
has the G of GENERAL directly over the T of THE, while
the other has the G over the space between TH(E). There
are other differences as well. It is curious that two dies were
cut for each side, yet the medal is among the rarest of the era
today. The present one has the distinction of once being in
the collection of William Spohn Baker, and later that of the
Garrett family—a fine provenance for a Washington piece.
The Norweb Collection, credited with one example prior to
our presentation of it in 2006, included three of these medals
and two of the three different die combinations. It did not
include the one seen here. Today, the known specimens,
including all variants, are the present unique bronzed one,
(ex. Baker, Garrett, Steinberg); Lucien LaRiviere; John J.
Ford, Jr., Norweb (3); Smithsonian Institution; Historical
Society of Pennsylvania; American Numismatic Society.
From the Charles A. Wharton Collection. Earlier from the William
Spohn Baker Collection; our (Bowers and Ruddy’s) sale of the Garrett
Collection, Part IV, March 1981, lot 1758; our (Stack’s) sale of the Gilbert Steinberg Collection, May 1992, lot 27; our (Stack’s) sale of January
1996, lot 53; Presidential Coin and Antique’s Auction 60, June 1996, lot
158. Lot tags included.
Bid online at www.stacksbowers.com
Page 3
Rare and Interesting Washington Funeral Medal in Gold
Oval, “For the Ladies”
1006 (1800) Washington Funeral Medal. Gold. 24 x 29 mm oval. 13.92 grains.Baker-169. About Uncirculated. Uniface. A fine
example of this rare, paper thin, struck gold medal marking the passing of George Washington. The detail is excellent, though the
typically encountered waviness is present, with a short crease at HE IN and another from 11:30 to below 3 o’clock. Some natural
gaps in the metal are visible above RLD IN in the upper right quadrant. The surfaces are bright and reflective, showing light toning
against rich yellow gold. This piece shows no evidence of mounting.
On January 13, 1800, goldsmith and jeweler Eben Moulton of Cornhill Street in Boston listed the following classified
advertisement in the Columbian Centinel and Massachusetts Federalist: “FOR THE LADIES. Washington Medals, designed to put
up in Lockets executed by Mr. Perkins, for sale at No. 11 Cornhill by Eben Moulton.” This “ladies medal,” of more delicate size and
distinctive production, is the type seen here. Of the specimens that survive — which perhaps number a dozen or so, many of which
are in institutional collections — several are contained in fancy jewelry of the period, including the specimen offered in our May
1993 sale with a multi-pearled bezel, and the specimen that descended in the family of John Marshall, now in the collection of the
Colonial Williamsburg Foundation. It appears that this one-sided medal was sold on its own, such that the purchaser could have a
custom piece of jewelry produced to house it, though undoubtedly Moulton could have made any sort of housing to order. There
also exist at least a couple displayed in a grand Masonic housing (see The Numismatist, February 1954) and some, like this one, were
simply holed for suspension. This type is typically offered only when world-class offerings of Washingtoniana are sold. The Ford
specimen, one of the finest and earlier from the Zabriskie and Boyd Collections, brought $21,850 back in May 2004. A specimen in
our (Stack’s) May 2007 Henry Leon sale brought $34,500 in unholed condition. As thin and seemingly ephemeral as these medals
are, it is surprising that as many have survived as do.
From the Charles A. Wharton Collection. Earlier from Presidential Coin and Antique Company’s 48th sale, June 1990, lot 302; EAHA’s sale of December 1999,
lot 47; Heritage’s sale of August 2000, lot 5007. Lot tags included.
1007 “1789” (Circa 1890-1900) Private Indian Peace Medal.
Copper. 63 mm. 106.8 grams. Baker-173M. Choice Very
Fine. Actually sharper, but with some rim bumps and
handling. Deep chestnut brown with a pleasant gloss in the
obverse fields and deeper patina around the devices. Struck
from a later state of the dies with the reverse die crack at
3:30. The Rulau-Fuld plate piece.
1008 Undated (Circa 1862 or later) Washington / Jackson U.S.
Mint Medalet. Silver. 19 mm. Baker-223A, var., Julian
PR-29. Unc Details—Mount Removed (NGC). Plain
truncation, though close inspection reveals that the original
P marking has been carefully removed from the die. A
shadowy impression remains. Other reworking of the die is
evident, the most dramatic being the broad dentils. Likely
a later product, perhaps of the late 19th century. Having
been worn in jewelry for a time, as evidenced by the mount,
the surfaces have also been cleaned. There seems to be no
evidence of prooflike character, but there is none of the
heavy matte finish of the 20th century either.
From the Charles A. Wharton Collection. Earlier from our (Stack’s) sale
of the Jack Collins Collection, Part II, July 1996, lot 90. Lot tag included.
From the Charles A. Wharton Collection. Earlier from our (Stack’s) sale
of the Jack Collins Collection, Part I, April-May 1996, lot 155. Lot tag
included.
Page 4
Lincolniana
1009 1856 Buchanan—Eight Presidents Medal Muling.
White Metal. 46 mm. 33.4 grams. Baker-382A. About
Uncirculated. Nearly choice but for a small obverse scratch.
Nice luster, with traces of reflectivity in the obverse fields
while the reverse is quite prooflike in the circular recesses
around the eight presidents. Sharply struck and with strong
eye appeal. This medal is quite rare; George Fuld estimated a
surviving population of just five to nine pieces. We have had
the good fortune of handling two this year including this
one. The John J. Ford, Jr. Collection included a lovely Mint
State example. However, this could be misleading, as it has
been years since we have seen another. This is a muling of an
obverse for William Key’s Buchanan and Breckinridge 1856
campaign medal with the obverse of the Eight Presidents
medal by W.H. Bridgens, accomplished circa 1840.
From the Charles A. Wharton Collection. Earlier from the Paul Magriel
Collection; Presidential Coin and Antique’s sale of June 1988, lot 71; our
Coin Galleries sale of July 1996, lot 240.
1010 Undated (Circa 1890) Americanization Commemoration
July 4th Medal. Bronze. 50 mm. 48 grams. Baker-Unlisted.
About Uncirculated. Pierced for suspension. Issued at St.
Paul, Minnesota. The date is our suspicion based on style
and fabric, and little else. An interesting piece missed by
Rulau, and likely quite rare.
From the Charles A. Wharton Collection.
1011 Undated (Circa 1895-1908) Order of Washington Pin.
Gold, Enamel. 15 mm, without hanger. 1.4 grams. BakerUnlisted. Extremely Fine. An variant much different than
the Order of Washington badge cataloged by Rulau as Baker
F-678, but well accomplished, if small. A minor chip in the
enamel, but nice eye appeal.
From the Charles A. Wharton Collection. Earlier from Anthony Terranova. Paper envelope included.
1012 Undated (Circa 1907) Abraham Lincoln Plaque. Bronze.
280 x 360 mm (11 x 14.5 inches). By Victor David
Brenner. Choice About Uncirculated. Natural chocolate
brown with darker tones in the recesses and lighter shades
on the high points. The blank reverse has two integral
mounts with a heavy wire strung between for hanging. This
is an impressive and rare size for this plaque which could be
proudly displayed in the den of office of any coin collector.
Political Medals and Related
1013 1824 Andrew Jackson. Brass. 24 mm. DeWitt-AJACK
1824-5. Reeded Edge. MS-63 (NGC). Medium olive brass
with luster in the protected areas. Nice eye appeal.
From the Charles A. Wharton Collection. Earlier from Anthony Terranova. Paper envelope with attribution notation included.
Presidents and Inaugurals
1014 Undated (1866) Ulysses S. Grant U.S. Mint Medallet.
Silver. 19 mm. By Anthony C. Paquet. Julian PR-42.
Proof-64 Cameo (NGC). This lovely piece is richly and
originally toned in deep steel gray with multicolored
highlights that are particularly pronounced on the reverse.
Very attractive!
1015 1928 Herbert Hoover National Republican Club Medal.
Bronze. 69 mm. By Julio Kilenyi. Extremely Fine. Obv:
Bust of Hoover right with inscription HERBERT / HOOVER
around the periphery. Initials J.K (for Julio Kilenyi) in left
field. Rev: Inscribed NATIONAL REPUBLICAN CLUB /
NEW YORK / NOVEMBER 6TH 1928. Struck by Medallic
Art Company, and stamped as such on the edge. Handsome
deep tan-gold surfaces.
Augustus Saint-Gaudens Medal
1016 1937 Augustus Saint-Gaudens Portrait Plaque. Bronze.
46 mm x 36 mm. By John Flanagan. Choice About
Uncirculated. Obv: Bust of Saint-Gaudens left with the
inscription AUGUSTUS SAINT-GAUDENS / STATUAIRE
AETATISLVI above and the date MCMXXXIV divided by
Flanagan’s initials in the lower left field. Rev: Inscriptions IN
HONOR / OF AN AMERICAN / SCVLPTOR / AVGVSTVS
SAINT / GAVDENS above and SCVLPTORS DINNER
OF THE / MEDALLIC ART COMPANY NY / APRIL IX
MCMXXXVII. An appealing piece by the designer of the
Washington quarter honoring the designer of the Indian
eagle and Saint-Gaudens double eagle on the occasion of
the Sculptor’s Dinner of the Medallic Art Company in New
York on April 9, 1937.
Page 5
Art Medal
1017 Undated (1913) John Charles Fremont Circle of Friends of
the Medallion Medal. Bronze. 77 x 57.5 mm oval. By Rene
Theophile de Quelin. Alexander-COF 9.1. Mint State.
Obv: Pensive image of the explorer, general and presidential
candidate facing left with name and accolades to the right.
Rev: Winged Victory at California’s Golden Gate, seated
on plaque bearing the flag of the California Republic. Both
sides of this handsome piece exhibit swirling olive-brown
patina, the color a bit bolder on the obverse. Still mounted
in the original book-type case of issue, with is complete and
of solid technical quality. (Total: 1 medal; 1 book-type case)
So-Called Dollars
1018 1861 Bombardment of Fort Sumter. White Metal. 33.7
mm. HK-11. Rarity-7. Extremely Fine. Much original
luster remains on both sides, revealing the original prooflike
finish. Contact marks in the fields are typical for pieces struck
in this soft metal, and most are singularly inconspicuous to
the eye. This scarce and desirable So-Called dollar refers to
the bombardment of the Union’s Fort Sumter in Charleston
Harbor, South Carolina in April 1861, the “straw that broke
the camel’s back” and started the Civil War.
1019 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition. Official
Medal. Silver. 38 mm. HK-399. Rarity-5. MS-65 (PCGS).
This simply outstanding example exhibits brilliant, satiny
surfaces that are expertly preserved to preclude notice of
even a single trivial distraction. Struck to commemorate
the opening of the Panama Canal, as well as the 400th
Anniversary of the discovery of the Pacific Ocean and the
recovery of San Francisco from the 1906 earthquake that
destroyed much of the city. The design was by Robert Aitken,
a familiar name to collectors of commemorative coinage.
They were sold by the Department of Official Coins and
Medals headed by Farran Zerbe, another numismatically
familiar name.
Agricultural, Mechanical,
Scientific, and Professional Medals
1022 1906 City of Philadelphia John Scott Medal. Bronze.
102.3 mm. Julian AM-70. Extremely Fine, Cleaned.
Inscribed on the reverse: TO / DAVID CRAWFORD
CHENWORTH / FOR HIS / “CONTRETE PILE” / ON THE
RECOMMENDATION OF THE / FRANKLIN INSITUTE
/ 1906. Reddish color brought out by an ancient cleaning
that is now retoning. A significant edge bump is present at
5 o’clock on the reverse as well as a few other minor bumps
and nicks.
Award Medals
1023 1855 American Institute Award Medal. Silver. 51.05
mm. 61.5 grams. Extremely Fine. Awarded to MRS. M.A.
SCHERMERHORN / FOR THE BEST / HEAD DRESS /
1855. Deep navy patination with lighter champagne notions
surrounding the devices. Displaying mild traces of wear, but
still very appealing and attractive in-hand.
PCGS# 513227.
1020 1892 Phillipsburg Columbian Celebration. Bronze. 38
mm. HK-627, Eglit-309A. Rarity-5. MS-65 BN (NGC).
Handsome crimson-copper surfaces are sharply defined
and all but blemish free. Slightly mottled medium brown
highlights are also evident around the reverse periphery.
Issued October 12, 1892 in Phillipsburg, New Jersey to
celebrate the 400th Anniversary of the arrival of Columbus
in the New World; a statue of the explorer is the central
obverse motif of this scarce issue. Also struck in white
metal, and equally as scarce as the bronze piece offered here.
1021 1892 Phillipsburg Columbian Celebration. Bronze. 38
mm. HK-627, Eglit-309A. Rarity-5. MS-64 BN (NGC).
This is a lovely piece, fully Choice with dominant crimsonbrown patina. A few minor spots are all that seem to
preclude an even higher grade. So-Called Dollar aficionados
will celebrate the offering of two bronze examples of HK627 in this sale.
1024 1876 Centennial Award Medal. Bronzed White Metal.
101.4 mm. 441.75 grams. Julian AM-12, var. Extremely
Fine. Inscribed AWARDED BY / UNITED STATES /
CENTENNIAL / COMMISSION in the center of the reverse.
This medal is quite rare in this large format, and rarer still
with the reverse inscription delineated above. Julian reports
under both his AM-10 and AM-12 listings that, “very few
of these were made, all as patterns.” He states further that
they are only known in bronze. Indeed, the present example
at first appears to be bronze, but it is clear from a one inch
spot on the rim where the copper plating has come off that
this piece was originally struck in a heavy gray “white metal”
that is both harder and lighter than lead, and subsequently
bronze plated. The bronze finish has also cracked slightly
in the centers on both sides, although the mahogany finish
typical of this issue remains. Minor rim disturbances are
noted for accuracy.
From the Vincent W. Alones Collection. Earlier from NASCA’s KesslerSpangenberger sale, April 1981, lot 1776. Lot tag included.
Page 6
Anti-Slavery
1025 1905 250th Anniversary of Jewish Settlement in the
United States Medal. Bronze. 76.2 mm. By Isidore Konti.
Extremely Fine, minor edge bumps. Obv: Allegorical Justice
and Liberty above a cowering and defeated Intolerance. Rev:
Standing History is protected by an eagle as she inscribes the
dates 1655 and 1905 on a tablet. The Hebrew legend around
the border translates to “Freedom is Heaven-Born, Justice
and Righteousness are the Foundations of Her Throne.”
Only 284 examples of this type were struck in bronze (along
with 36 silver impressions and two pieces in gold) by the
Deitsch Brothers medal department, soon to be reborn as
The Medallic Art Company. Pleasing copper-tan surfaces.
School, College and
University Medals
1026 1843 Boston City Medal for Females. Silver. 12.7 grams.
31 x 38 hexagonal. Extremely Fine. Looped for suspension.
Obv: Inscription CITY MEDAL / FOR FEMALES /
INSTITUTED BY THE / SCHOOL COMMITTEE /
BOSTON / 1821. Rev: Inscription MERITED / BY / MARY
N. GARDNER (engraved in script) / FOR / SUPERIOR
SCHOLARSHIP / A.D. 1843.
1027 1845 Boston City Medal for Academic Achievement.
Silver. 16.7 grams. 13 x 13 mm hexagonal. Choice Very
Fine. Looped for suspension. Obv: Inscription CITY
MEDAL / INSTD BY THE / SCHOOL COMMITTEE /
BOSTON / 1821. Rev: Inscription MERITED / BY / F.W.
GARDNER / 1845.
1028 Great Britain. Undated (1790s) Am I Not A Man And
A Brother Conder Token. Middlesex. D&H-235. White
Metal. 32 mm. AU-50 (NGC). Even satin gray surfaces
reveal no singularly mentionable blemishes apart from a
faint reverse spot between the fourth and fifth lines of the
inscription. Otherwise we note only typical handling marks
for a token struck in this soft metallic composition. Boldly, if
not sharply defined throughout, with flickers of an original
semi-prooflike finish still readily evident in the fields.
Fairs and Expositions
1029 1877 Oregon State Agricultural Society First Premium
Award Medal. Gold. 44.35 mm. 50.1 grams. Awarded
to Decker Piano. Extremely Fine, Cleaned. Obv: Figures
representing Agriculture and Industry support a shield
showing agricultural tools and products. A ship and a steam
train are in the background, and a beaver sits atop the shield
between the two figures. The inscription OREGON STATE
AGRICULTURAL SOCIETY is at the upper border. Rev:
Six-line inscription within laurel wreath AWARDED TO /
DECKER PIANO / FIRST PREMIUM 1877 / FOR BEST
PIANO MADE / BY / M.A. DECKER / NEW YORK.
Cleaned long ago, as evidenced by light hairlining, both
sides have retoned nicely with mottled orange and lavenderbrown peripheral highlights around deep gold centers. Very
elusive in any metallic composition, this gold First Premium
medal is especially desirable. The exact gold contact is not
stated, and it is unknown to us.
1030 1901 Pan-American Exposition Award Medal. Gilt
Bronze. 63.5 mm. By Hermon A. MacNeil. Awarded to
Coldwell Lawn Mower Co. About Uncirculated. Obv:
North and South American Indians sharing a peace pipe.
Rev: Nude Liberty walking right with American bison.
A plaque below carries the name of the recipient, and
the designer’s “signature” is below the plaque. A rare gilt
variant of this impressive medal by MacNeil, designer of
the Standing Liberty quarter. Beautiful bright gold surfaces
reveal only a few trivial blemishes in isolated areas.
Page 7
and Coin Jewelry
1031 1901 Pan-American Exposition Award Medal. Bronze.
63.6 mm. By Hermon A. MacNeil. Awarded to the
Philadelphia Board of Health. About Uncirculated.
Obv: North and South American Indians sharing a peace
pipe. Rev: Nude Liberty walking right with American
bison. A plaque below carries the name of the recipient,
and the designer’s “signature” is below the plaque. This is
a fascinating design by MacNeil, designer of the Standing
Liberty quarter, and the present example exhibits lovely
copper brown patina to both sides.
1032 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition Award
Medal. Bronze. 70.7 mm. Choice Mint State. Obv: Nude
male and female figures reach for each other over the
Isthmus of Panama as the sub rises between them. Rev: The
Tower of Jewels at the Exposition. This handsomely original
piece exhibits warm olive-brown patina with abundant
golden highlights. Housed in the original round box of issue,
and also accompanied by the original mailing box from
the Panama-Pacific International Exposition International
Award System. (Total: 3 items)
1033 1964-1965 New York World’s Fair Medal. Gold. 24 mm.
7.0 grams. 917 fine. Choice Mint State. Obv: View of the
unisphere with satellite, orbits and stars around. Rev: Seal of
the City of New York and dates for the 300th anniversary of
the city. Struck in Spain. Accompanied by the plastic pouch
of issue and Certificate of Authenticity.
Miscellaneous Medal
1034 France. 1727 Reconstruction of the Forest of Haye Bridge
Medal. Copper. 63.39 mm. 93.29 grams. Molinari-120.
About Uncirculated. Obv: Cuirassed bust of Leopold I,
Duke of Lorraine, right wearing Order of the Golden Fleece.
Rev: Horseman crossing bridge towards abundant woods.
Some glue residue and staining on reverse, edge bump at 12
o’clock on obverse.
Page 8
1035 Gold Coin Watch Fashioned from a 1904-S Liberty
Double Eagle. The entire movement mechanism of this
watch is mounted inside what appears to be a normal, yet
hollowed out 1904-S double eagle. When you press a button
on the right edge of the watch face the obverse of the coin
pops open to reveal an Eska 18 karat movement mounted
on a hinged mechanism that allows the movement to stand
vertically. The band is woven gold mesh and is marked
14K. The opening/closing mechanism works perfectly,
however the watch is currently not operating and we cannot
guarantee that it can be repaired. Total weight: 62.3 grams.
Hard Times Tokens
1036 Undated (1833) I Take The Responsibility. HT-70, Low51. Rarity-1. Copper—Struck 25% Off-Center—VF-35
(PCGS). Prominently struck off center at 7 o’clock, this
visually appealing piece also exhibits overall smooth, glossy
brown patina to both sides. A few areas of pitting are noted
for the reverse, but there are no outwardly distracting
abrasions. Error coins in the Hard Times Tokens series
are but few and far between, at least in our cataloging
experience, and the present piece will certainly invoke heavy
bidding among HTT specialists.
1037 1838 Am I Not A Woman. HT-81, Low-54. Rarity-1.
Copper. 28.3 mm. AU-50 BN (NGC). Mottled steelbrown patina engages both sides, the surfaces also retaining
original color in faded orange-rose in isolated areas. A
boldly defined, carefully preserved AU with a pleasing
appearance. This ever-popular design type in the Hard
Times Tokens series is modeled after an English Conder
token of the 1790s, though those tokens dealt with the “Am
I Not A Man” theme — the “Am I Not A Man” Hard Times
token, Low-54a, is one of the great rarities among U.S. token
issues of any era.
1038 Pennsylvania—Philadelphia. Undated (1837) Isaac
Barton & Co. HT-385A, Low-Unlisted. Rarity-8. Gilt
Brass. Reeded Edge. 27 mm. EF-40 Scratched. Much of
the gilding remains on both sides of this predominantly
antique gold example. The color is brighter and more
vibrant in the protected areas around the devices, which
are boldly to sharply outlined in the absence of heavy wear.
Several faint pin scratches in the central obverse field are
noted. This is much the rarer variant of token issued by Isaac
Barton & Co., which occupied several different addresses in
Philadelphia from 1833 to 1844.
Paper envelope with attribution notation included.
Patriotic Civil War Tokens
1039 1864 Indian-Grant. Fuld-96/144 a. Copper. 19 mm—Rim
Clip—MS-64 RB (PCGS). This die combination is not
listed in the 2005 edition of the reference Patriotic Civil War
Tokens by George and Melvin Fuld, hence the lack of a rarity
rating. A beautiful near-Gem, both sides exhibit a smooth,
satiny texture beneath blended pinkish-lilac, autumn orange,
and powder blue patina. A shallow planchet clip, as made, is
evident just before 12 o’clock. Not long ago Civil War tokens
were the “red-headed step-child” of numismatics, collected
and appreciated by precious few collector. Boy, how times
have changed! IN today’s numismatic marketplace, highquality Civil War tokens are eagerly sought and just as
eagerly collected.
1040 Undated (1861-1865) George Washington. Fuld115/115A. Rarity-8. Copper. 20.5 mm. MS-65 BN
(PCGS). Lovely copper brown surfaces are vibrant in
appearance with hardly even a trivial blemish to report. The
present specimen of this popular Washington-related Civil
War token is no doubt one of the very finest examples of this
important Rarity-8 issue in existence.
1041 Undated (1861-1865) Washington-Lincoln. Fuld116/132B. Copper. 18 mm. MS-65 BN (PCGS). This die
combination is not listed in the 2005 reference Patriotic
Civil War Tokens by George and Melvin Fuld. Smartly
impressed with dominant glossy brown patina, flickers of
vivid pinkish-orange luster are also discernible around the
peripheries. Although no rarity rating is shown for this
Washington-Lincoln issue, we can assure you it is about as
far removed from “common” status as a token can get.
1042 1864 Lincoln-O.K. Fuld-127/248. Rarity-3. Copper. 18
mm. MS-66 RB (PCGS). Silky smooth surfaces are softly
frosted in texture with plenty of original reddish-orange
luster in evidence. No doubt one of the finest examples of
this variety extant, third-party holder or not.
1043 1864 Lincoln-Masonic. Fuld-127/252 a. Rarity-9. Copper.
19 mm. MS-66 BN (PCGS). Otherwise dominant copper
brown patina yields to vivid lilac-blue undertones as the
surfaces dip into a light. A lovely Gem, as struck, and simply
exquisite. Superb quality and extreme rarity combine in this
Civil War token die pairing.
1044 “1860” (1864) Abraham Lincoln. Fuld-507/514 a.
Rarity-9. Copper. 21 mm. MS-64 RB (PCGS). This
charming near-Gem exhibits minimal gray-brown toning to
mostly intact, autumn-orange luster. This rare Lincoln issue
is seldom found in grades of Mint State-64 as here; indeed,
it is seldom encountered at all.
Civil War Store Cards
1045 Illinois—Paris. 1863 A.C. Connely’s. Fuld-690B-7a.
Copper. 19 mm. AU-55 BN (NGC). This variety is unlisted
in the 1975 edition of the Fuld Civil War store card reference,
and the present example is an attractive Choice AU with
smooth copper brown surfaces.
1046 Indiana—Greensboro. Undated (Circa 1863) Baldwin &
Sweet. Fuld-365A-1a. Rarity-8. Copper. 19.5 mm. AU50 Cleaned. A sharply impressed example with curious
pinkish-tan obverse color, yet a more original golden-brown
reverse. This is the only token from this Indiana town.
1047 Indiana—Indianapolis. 1863 J.B. Grout. Fuld-460F-5a.
Copper. 19 mm. MS-63 BN (NGC). Unlisted in the 1975
edition of the Fuld Civil War store card reference, and
a rare type, this delightful Select example exhibits rosebrown patina to both sides. The obverse is partially lustrous
with subtle medium orange undertones, and the outward
appearance is smooth apart from a few trivial blemishes.
Sure to be of keen interest to the specialized CWT collector.
1048 Indiana—Indianapolis. Undated (Circa 1861-1865) J.B.
Wilson’s “Half Dime.” Fuld-460Y-4ei. Rarity-8. White
Metal. 15.5 mm. MS-66 (NGC). Likely the finest known
for this popular early half dime token, this brilliant Gem is
aglow with blazing satin silver luster. Modestly prooflike in
finish, and a delight to behold. Worthy of inclusion in the
finest CWT collection.
From our sale of the John J. Ford, Jr. Collection, Part XXIII, August
2013, lot 21563. Earlier ex: George Bauer Collection; Leonard Stark,
February 1962.
Page 9
1049 Kentucky—Newport. 1863 Newport & Covington Bridge
Company. Fuld-640B-3a, Atwood-KY 640B. Rarity-7.
Copper. 19.5 mm. AU-50 Cleaned. The obverse is toned
in deep brown, but the reverse exhibits curious bright pink
color that points to an old cleaning.
1050 Massachusetts—Boston. 1863 Joseph H. Merriam. Fuld115E-1b. Rarity-8. Brass. 19 mm. AU-50 Rim Nicks.
Evenly toned in warm golden-tan with no mentionable
blemishes apart from a few minor rim nicks and bumps. An
elusive token from this popular medalist and die sinker.
Sutler Token
1055 New York. E.E. Bedford 10 Cents. Schenkman-F10C,
Curto-25. Rarity-9. Brass. 21.4 mm. Fine-12 Damaged.
Tobacco-brown with electric blue iridescence shimmering
on the high points throughout. Mildly granular though still
considerably discernible, with a crack that radiates from the
8 o’clock border on the obverse. E.E. Bedford was a sutler
attached to the 127th New York State Volunteer Regiment.
From the Paul Koppenhaver Collection.
Encased Postage Stamps
1051 New York—New York. 1863 T. Brimelow. Fuld-630K3j. Rarity-9. German Silver. 23 mm. MS-61 (NGC).
Appearing far finer than the assigned grade, this outwardly
smooth, overall bright silver example exhibits only minimal
toning in mottled sandy-olive. Sharply defined from a well
executed strike, this piece is sure to sell for a strong bid.
Ex: Louis Kaufman Collection.
1052 Pennsylvania—Honesdale.
Undated
(1861-1865)
Petersen’s & Pittston Jewelers. Fuld-464A-4d. Rarity-8.
Copper-Nickel. 20 mm. MS-62 (NGC). Brilliant and satiny,
this delightful Mint State example exhibits bold striking
detail and bright pinkish-tan color throughout. At MS-62
the present specimen no doubt stands as one of the finest
pieces extant of this elusive rarity.
1056 1862 Ayer’s Sarsaparilla. One Cent. HB-28, EP-4A, S-13.
Medium AYER’S, Plain Frame. Extremely Fine. Frame:
Considerable silvering remains on the reverse, while the
obverse exhibits mottled olive-brown and brass patina.
Mica: Sound with tiny areas of subsurface lamination and
a few minor hairlines. Stamp: Bright original color, a bit off
center to the viewer’s right. The Ayer’s company was one of
the largest subscribers to Galt’s Encased postage format.
1057 1862 Ayer’s Sarsaparilla. Three Cents. HB-30, EP-34A,
S-15a. Medium AYER’S, Plain Frame. Very Fine. Frame:
Even olive-brown in tone, with no stains, discoloration or
other significant detractions. Mica: Sound. Stamp: Bold
original color with nearly perfect centering within the
frame. Readily among the most available of all EP issues,
and a variety that is often a stepping stone into the deeper
reaches of the series.
1053 Rhode Island—Providence. 1864 City Fruit Store. Fuld
700G-2j. Rarity-7. German Silver. Plain Edge. 19 mm.
MS-63 (NGC). Delicate golden iridescence decorates both
sides of this otherwise bright silver, satin textured piece.
An expertly centered example with bold to sharp definition
throughout the design. The City Fruit Store operated out
of No. 4 Weybosset Street in Providence, Rhode Island.
The reverse of this rare token features the legend RHODE
ISLAND FIRST IN THE FIELD surrounded by 13 stars and
the date 1864. The patriotic legend refers to the numerous
battles the Rhode Island troops fought in throughout the
Civil War.
1054 Wisconsin—Beloit. 1863 Peck & Pratt Liquors. Fuld-70A1a. Rarity-8. Copper. 20 mm. VF-20 Heavily Corroded.
Bold mahogany devices are backed against granular
tobacco fields. According to their token, Peck & Pratt were
purveyors of wines, liquors, and “segars.” This rarity is
seldom encountered in any grade.
1058 1862 Ayer’s Sarsaparilla. Three Cents. HB-32, EP-34B,
S-15b. Large AYER’S, Plain Frame. Extremely Fine.
Frame: Overall even olive-brown patina with no detractions
of note. Mica: Free of significant damage with only typical
light hairlines. Stamp: Well centered with nearly complete
color intensity. The Ayer’s three-cents issue is slightly scarcer
than most other low denomination Ayer’s issues.
1059 1862 Drake’s Plantation Bitters. Five Cents. HB-102,
EP-74, S-72. Plain Frame. Extremely Fine. Frame: Light
brassy color with a bit of original luster still in evidence.
Mica: Free of damage with a fresh “look” and only minimal
hairlining and subsurface laminations. Stamp: Slightly off
center toward the top, yet possessed of bright, original color.
This enigmatic firm also issued paper currency during the
Encased Postage era.
1060 1862 J. Gault. Five Cents. HB-131, EP-78, S-96. Plain
Frame. Extremely Fine. Frame: Problem free with brassy
vestiges of original luster on the reverse. Mica: No damage to
speak of, only light hairlines and perhaps a bit of dirt around
the edge. Stamp: Bold color, slightly off center toward the
viewer’s left. The eponymous issue of J. Galt, he not only
produced EP for other issuers, but for himself as well.
Page 10
Indian Trader Token
Transportation Tokens
1065 Montana Territory—Fort Benton. 1860 Baker Street
Ferry, M.L. Lynch 25 Token. Curto-320A. Brass. 24.4
mm. EF-40. This well defined example retains faint flickers
of original medium gold patina to otherwise deep brass
surfaces.
1066 Montana Territory—Fort Benton. 1860 Baker Street
Ferry, M.L. Lynch 50 Token. Curto-320B. Brass. 28.8 mm.
EF-40. This is a boldly defined, outwardly smooth, fully
original piece with handsome antique gold surfaces.
Counterstamps
1061 Dakota Territory—Cheyenne Agency. Undated (Circa
1880) G.W. Felt. Wright-310, Curto-66. Brass. 37.6 mm.
MS-60. Some of the golden brass finish remains, but the
surfaces have largely toned in lovely shades of orange, red,
blue and violet. A well produced and handsomely original
piece.
Post-Civil War Military Token
1062 Undated (Circa 1859-1878) Fort Larned Subsistence
Department. One Ration. Curto-M22, KS-170c. Copper.
28.8 mm. Fine-12. Holed, as made, with horse head,
retrograde dollar sign and other unusual counterstamps to
evenly toned medium brown surfaces. This piece is slightly
bent due to the multiple counterstamps.
Late th and th Century Tokens
1063 Alaska—Valdez. Undated (1907-1917) Copper Block
Buffet Dollar “Nugget” Token. Benice-Valdez 4-CII. Nickel. 39 mm, with 4 x 8 mm gold nugget. VF-20.
Dominant medium gray surfaces with scattered carbon
spotting. A classic token rarity from Alaska.
1064 Colorado—Manitou. Undated (Circa 1890) Hiawatha
Club. Good for 12 1/2 Cents. Pritchard-MA 370 Round.
Aluminum. 36.8 mm. VF-20 Environmental Damage.
Pierced. Some tin pest. The 12 1/2-cent denomination is
one of the most popular and collectable of all denominators
regardless of issuer or era; the value is based on the one real
coinage of Spain in the New World, or one “bit.”
1067 Maryland—Baltimore. HOUCK’S / PANACEA /
BALTIMORE on an 1807 Draped Bust half dollar. Brunk
H-779, Rulau HT-141. Rarity-4. Host coin Fine. The
counterstamp is neatly executed in the left obverse field,
with the host coin retaining good outline definition to
most elements of the design. Richly original in tone, and
problem-free apart from a small swirl of ancient verdigris
along the left reverse border. This is one of the most famous
of all counterstamps, and is virtually always seen on early
half dollars up to and including Capped Bust half dollars,
with that denomination the most prolific source for the
counterstamp.
1068 Maryland—Baltimore. J. WALTER on an 1823 Capped
Bust half dollar. Brunk W-136, Rulau-E Md 112, var.
Rarity-9. Host coin VG, counterstamp tooled. The
surfaces are originally toned in medium golden-gray with
no mentionable detractions apart from evidence of tooling
in and around the counterstamp. This counterstamp is
listed by both Brunk and Rulau, but the only half dollar
host coin that both sources report is an 1809. According to
information gleaned from the Rulau token reference (4th
Edition, 2004), Jacob Walter (1782-1869) was active as a
Maryland silversmith and watchmaker circa 1810-1840.
Page 11
Colonial Coins and Related
Massachusetts Silver Coinage
1071 1652 Oak Tree Shilling. Noe-7, Salmon 5-D. Rarity-6.
IN at Bottom. VF-20 Obverse Burnished. 62.1 grains.
The obverse of this curious piece has been mostly ground
down with only a partial TS remaining, while the reverse
is a mostly problem-free late die state example of the scarce
Noe-7 — other than a short planchet cut at 1 o’clock. Toned
an even light gray on both sides, the reverse also offers a bit
of colorful iridescence at the peripheries. A rare variety in
a completely affordable condition, this coin should be seen
before bidding judgment is passed.
PCGS# 45362.
1069 1652 Oak Tree Shilling. Noe-1, Salmon 1-A. Rarity-3.
IN at Left. VF-30 (PCGS). 59.72 grains. This is a lovely
mid-grade example of this challenging early Colonial era
type. Both sides are outwardly smooth with no detracting
abrasions and handsome, fully original, lavender-charcoal
patina. Boldly defined in all areas save for near the lower
right obverse border, the planchet has been lightly clipped
giving the coin a somewhat elliptical shape. The Oak Tree
issues followed the NE coinage (1652) and the Willow
Tree coinage (1653-1660). Oak Tree coinage is found in
four denominations, twopence; threepence; sixpence; and
shilling. The Oak Tree issues were struck circa 1660-1667.
Examples of the NE coinage and the Willow Tree coinage
are rare, with some varieties extraordinarily so, and the Oak
Tree coinage is where many collections of Massachusetts Bay
Colony silver coinage begins. There certainly is no shame
in that! Indeed, at Choice VF-30, the present piece would
mark an admirable beginning to a specialized collection of
Massachusetts silver coinage.
PCGS# 20.
1070 1652 Oak Tree Shilling. Noe-5, Salmon 3-D. Rarity-2.
IN at Bottom. VF-20 Planchet Crack, Environmental
Damage. 63.9 grains. Silver gray centers with deeper slate
at the peripheries, the obverse is off-center to the bottom
and shows a planchet crack from 7 to 8 o’clock, though
SATHUSET is bold and significant tree definition is
visible. The reverse is perfectly centered with bold details
throughout while the surfaces are just a bit granular under
low magnification. The present coin would represent the
design type nicely in a mid-grade set of early American
issues, especially with its association to the H.B.M.S.
Feversham treasure.
PCGS# 45362.
Earlier ex: H.B.M.S. Feversham; our (Stack’s) sale of January 1999, lot
7; and our (Coin Galleries’) sale of December 2008, lot 2003. Most recent lot tag and paper envelope with attribution and pedigree notation
included.
Page 12
Earlier from our (Stack’s) sale of the Hain Family Collection of Massachusetts Silver Coins, January 2002, lot 28. Paper envelope with attribution and pedigree notation included.
1072 1652 Oak Tree Shilling. Noe-10, Salmon 8-F. Rarity-6. IN
at Bottom. Fine-12 Clipped Planchet. 52.5 grains. Even
light gray surfaces with slate peripheries, about half of the
obverse letters are visible while the inner beaded circle is
nearly complete. The reverse displays stronger definition
with a bold date and denomination and NEW EN AN.DO
legible. Though the planchet has been clipped, the overall
shape is decidedly circular, if not a bit oblong with a slight
dimple at 12 o’clock on the reverse. A rare variety in a wholly
collectable condition.
PCGS# 45362.
1073 1652 Pine Tree Shilling. Large Planchet. Noe-8, Salmon
7-E. Rarity-4. Ligatured NE In Legend. Fine-12 Planchet
Heavily Clipped. 40.8 grains. The planchet has been heavily
clipped to remove much of the periphery, the resulting
coin being similar in size to a Massachusetts Bay Colony
sixpence. There is considerable wear through the centers, as
well, but part of the obverse tree and much of the reverse
date and denomination are discernible. Nicely toned in a
blend of various gray shades, a reverse pin scratch below the
denomination is noted for accuracy. Clipping of the rims of
coins is no doubt as old as coinage itself. The Massachusetts
Bay Colony issues suffered greatly from the practice of
stealing a tiny sliver of a coin’s rim before passing it on —
steal enough little slivers and you have a shilling’s worth of
silver. Unscrupulous merchants probably benefited best as
they handled much in the way of Massachusetts silver in
their day-to-day transactions and thus had the opportunity,
if so inclined, to help themselves to a sliver from the rim
of a coin or two. We can’t help but wonder whether these
same unscrupulous merchants would take a clipped coin at
its face value in a business transaction.
PCGS# 45373.
1074 1652 Pine Tree Shilling. Small Planchet. Noe-16, Salmon
2-B. Rarity-2. Genuine—Damage (PCGS). 62.8 grains.
The PCGS insert incorrectly attributes this coin as a Large
Planchet example. Nicely centered on both sides and fairly
original overall, nearly all major design elements are visible
with the reverse particularly bold. A planchet crack is noted
at 6 o’clock on the obverse, and a few light bends are noted
but the overall appearance is quite nice. Worth more than a
casual glance, this particular Pine Tree shilling could prove
a pleasant surprise to the right collector.VF Details.
PCGS# 24.
8-E. Rarity-5. Fine-12. 62.2 grains. Even pewter toning
with light golden centers, the surfaces are generally smooth
and wholesome. The obverse is well-centered and the
devices and legends are nearly completely visible, though
faintly so. A small clip at 3 o’clock corresponds with just a
touch of planchet roughness in the same area. The reverse
displays a planchet break from 8 to 10 o’clock though the
date, denomination and legends are mostly bold aside from
EW and DO which are only faintly legible. An ideal piece
for a collector who wishes to begin an early American type
set, this scarce variety will be welcomed by those with a
numismatic budget to consider.
PCGS# 24.
1078 1652 Pine Tree Threepence. Noe-36, Salmon 2-B.
Rarity-4. Without Pellets. VF-30 (NGC). 14.5 grains. Both
the obverse and reverse of this lovely piece are toned slate
gray, with moderate waviness to the planchet, as made. On
the obverse, the tree and inner border are full, the branches
are clear, and the root structure is readily evident. The
peripheral legends on both sides are nearly entirely legible
aside from an area of weakness at 9 o’clock on the reverse. A
small planchet chip is also present at 5 o’clock on the obverse.
Overall, an appealing example with excellent details at this
level. This “half a sixpence” is an ideal candidate for a midrange Massachusetts silver collection.
PCGS# 21.
12-G. Rarity-3. VF-25 (PCGS). 71.14 grains. Endearing
dove gray surfaces are evenly toned and free of detracting
blemishes. The strike is drawn toward the viewer’s left, but
it is uneven wear that has resulted in lack of detail along
the right obverse and left reverse borders. Otherwise
boldly defined, there is much to recommend this coin to
the circulated Colonial type collector. The present Pine
Tree shilling represents a perfectly acceptable example that
would make a sterling beginning to an early American or
Massachusetts Bay Colony silver collection.
Wood’s Hibernia Coinage
PCGS# 24.
1077 1652 Pine Tree Threepence. Noe-34, Salmon 1-A. Rarity-4.
Pellets at Trunk. VF Details—Damage (PCGS). A sharp
tree, bold date and denomination, and generally discernible
lettering enhance the appeal of this Massachusetts silver
piece for circulated type purposes. Both sides are mostly
light silver in tone, although subtle copper and charcoal
highlights are evident in the protected areas around some of
the devices. Largely free of outwardly distracting blemishes,
and significantly so given the stated impairment, a few tiny
obverse digs and traces of an old, light bend are the only
mentionable detractions. The threepence is the smallest
of the three Pine Tree silver denominations, which also
includes sixpence and shilling denominations.
1079 1724 Wood’s Hibernia Halfpenny. Martin 4.51-K.4.
Rarity-2. AU-55 (PCGS). Nicely centered and overall bold
on both sides, the smooth surfaces and warm, even, chestnut
patina further enhance already impressive eye appeal. There
are enough die varieties in the Wood’s coinage series of
1722 to 1724 to keep any specialists busy for a lifetime; even
a type set of the issues, small and large-sized, will keep a
collector busy for some time. Mostly found in well-worn
grades, AU and finer Wood’s pieces enjoy steady demand in
the numismatic marketplace.
PCGS# 190.
PCGS# 21.
Page 13
Virginia Coinage
Nova Constellatio Copper
1080 1773 Virginia Halfpenny. Newman 6-X. No Period
After GEORGIVS, 8 Harp Strings. MS-63 RB (NGC).
Light gray-brown patina, both sides also exhibit plenty of
original if slightly faded pinkish-red luster that shines forth
nicely as the surfaces rotate under a light. This is a well
struck, outwardly smooth example that would fit nicely in
a collection of Colonial-era type coinage. The 1773 Virginia
halfpennies are an official coinage for Virginia that came
to the colony for disbursal and commercial use as outlined
in the colony’s charter; Virginia was the only colony with a
coinage clause built into its charter and in 1773 they had the
Tower Mint in London strike up “some five tons” of the issue
according to Breen (Encyclopedia, 1988). The vast majority
of Mint State survivors of the type owe their existence to
a hoard found in a keg near Richmond, Virginia just prior
to the Civil War. This keg passed to Mendes I. Cohen
(1796-1879), a well-known numismatist of the mid-19th
century. Some 2,200 or so pieces were later sold by Cohen’s
descendants in 1929 — Wayte Raymond was the dealer who
dispersed most of the hoard to collectors of his era.
1082 1785 Nova Constellatio Copper. Crosby 4-C.
CONSTELLATIO, Pointed Rays. EF-40 (PCGS). Deep
golden brown with a hint of roughness, as made, around the
obverse periphery, but overall quite smooth. Both sides are
fairly well-centered and the legends are virtually complete
though a trifle weak from 12 to 3 o’clock on the obverse and
the corresponding area on the reverse. Wholesome overall
with substantial eye appeal. The numerous die varieties and
types in the series make for a fertile collecting area in early
American numismatics.
PCGS# 244.
Elephant Token
PCGS# 813.
Connecticut Copper
1083 1787 Connecticut Copper. Miller 1.2-C. Rarity-3. Mailed
Bust Right, Muttonhead—Planchet Lamination—VF
Details—Tooled (PCGS). This is a predominantly dark
brown example, although lighter orange-brown patina is
evident over most of the higher relief elements of the design.
Overall rough in texture with several prominent areas of
corrosion on the reverse, a few moderate scratches before
the seated figure are also noted for accuracy. The prominent
lamination at the upper right obverse border, however, is
as struck. Although not without problems, this piece does
offer bold outline definition to the central design elements,
allowing one to fully appreciate the popular Muttonhead
Guide Book variety.
PCGS# 343.
1081 Undated (Circa 1694) London Elephant Token. Hodder
2-B. GOD PRESERVE LONDON. Thick Planchet. MS62 BN (NGC). Handsomely toned, both sides exhibit a
blend of original charcoal-brown and orange-tan colors.
The surfaces are uncommonly smooth for the assigned
grade, and the strike is suitably bold for the type even
despite the fact that both sides are slightly off center toward
the 12 o’clock position. The Elephant tokens are a popular
British issue that has been adopted by collectors of early
American issues, and some no doubt circulated here. One
of the great numismatic legends is that these were made in
response to the plagues of the 1660s or the Great London
Fire of 1666, though today’s collectors are of the mind that
GOD PRESERVE LONDON is just a plaintive plea to the
Almighty to guide London on its way through thick and
thin.
1084 1787 Connecticut Copper. Miller 16.2-O. Rarity-5.
Draped Bust Left, INDL ET LIB. EF-40 Porous. 157.7
grains. There is a tremendous amount of detail on both sides
of this nicely centered, bold to sharp example. The surfaces
exhibit alternating crimson and olive-gray patina with light
scale and a few minor, well scattered pits that accuracy
compels us to mention. This scarce and popular variety is
listed on page 61 of the 2015 edition of A Guide Book of
United States Coins.
PCGS# 415.
PCGS# 55.
Page 14
1087 1788 Connecticut Copper. Miller 4.1-K. Rarity-5. Mailed
Bust Right. EF-40 Environmental Damage. 107.5 grains.
Sharply defined in and around the centers, the peripheries
are typically weaker for an example of this challenging die
marriage. Struck from clashed dies, with blended medium
copper and rose-brown retoning to both sides. The surfaces
are rough and granular in texture with evidence of an old
cleaning and several faint pin scratches over the left obverse.
A fairly scarce variety in any grade.
PCGS# 397.
1085 1787 Connecticut Copper. Miller 33.29-gg.1. Rarity-5.
Draped Bust Left, ETLIR. VF-25. 131.3 grains. An
important example of this scarce variety, tracing its
history to the famed and foundational Connecticut copper
collection of Dr. Thomas Hall. Choice glossy light brown
with exemplary eye appeal, with just a couple of light old
scratches in the upper left field of the reverse noted. Sharper
in some areas than the Ford coin, which was graded “Choice
Very Fine” and hammered at $575 in Ford IX. This piece is
accompanied by a B.G. Johnson envelope stamped “HALL
COLLECTION” with the inventory number 1936 and the
date stamp May 18, 1935, as well as the pierced, circular,
cardboard, ink-inscribed ticket from Dr. Hall identifying
this piece as Hall 33.26-G2.1. While these envelopes have
no doubt accompanied this coin since its acquisition by Mr.
Bareford decades ago, they appear not to match this coin.
The entry in the Hall inventory for 1936 is for a Hall 33.26G2.1, so the envelope and card match; alas, Hall 33.26-G2.1
is today known as Miller 33.38-gg.1, a different variety
with the same reverse. As pointed out to the cataloger by
the Connecticut specialists Christopher McDowell, Randy
Clark and Robert Martin, Hessberg:1480 was an ex: Hall
Miller 33.38-gg.1, but it was cataloged in the 1991 Hessberg
sale as Miller 33.29-gg.1, the correct variety of this example.
It appears that these two coins were placed in the wrong
envelopes at some point, probably when New Netherlands
Coin Company had the lion’s share of the Hall Connecticuts
in the 1950s, when both Mr. Bareford and Mr. Hessberg
were active customers. The two varieties are quite similar,
and the reverses are struck from very similar die states, this
example showing an unusually late progression of the die
before it was married to the 33.38 obverse. The purchaser
of this coin gets a very nice example of an elusive variety, a
B.G. Johnson-Hall envelope, an original Hall ticket, and the
answer to a question that has burned since 1991: why was
Hessberg:1840 misattributed?
PCGS# 391.
From the Bareford Family Collection. Earlier from the Dr. Thomas Hall
Collection to Virgil Brand in 1909; Armin Brand to B.G. Johnson, circa
1935; New Netherlands to Mr. Bareford sometime in the 1950s.
1086 1787 Connecticut Copper. Miller 42-kk.2. Rarity-5+.
Draped Bust Left, AUCTOPI, ET IIB—Double Struck—
Fine-12 Scratches. 142.1 grains. The second impression is
uniface on the obverse and off center at 10 o’clock. Although
the left peripheral devices on that side are absent, much of
the word CONNEC appears twice. The surfaces are a bit
rough overall with dark brown patina, light pin scratches to
the obverse portrait, and several deep scratches in the center
of the reverse. Still, a suitable example of a fairly scarce
variety with the added attraction of doubling on the obverse.
PCGS# 376.
Machin’s Mills Halfpennies
1088 1771 Machin’s Mills Halfpenny. Vlack 3-71B. Rarity-5.
GEORGIVS III. Fine-12 Obverse Damage. 122.1 grains.
Nice chestnut brown toning throughout with a well profiled
bust and some details visible in the wreath and armor. A
small blunt line extends from the neck to the ear and a
minor patch of roughness in the rim of the planchet is noted
at 3 o’clock. The reverse is boldly profiled with a strong date
and legends with 75% of the dentilation complete. A rare
variety that should experience spirited bidding activity.
PCGS# 448.
1089 1772 Machin’s Mills Halfpenny. Vlack 5-72A. Rarity-6.
GEORGIVS III. Fine Details—Bent (PCGS). This is a
pleasing example despite the stated impairment, with both
sides displaying uncommonly bold definition in a wellcirculated copper of this challenging type. The surfaces
are evenly toned in steely olive-brown with light porosity
throughout, a few moderate size digs in and around the
centers, and a trace of iridescence that suggest an ancient
cleaning. The bend referred to on the PCGS insert, however,
is slight and hardly discernible through the holder. Among
the rarest of the varieties made at Machin’s Mills, probably
sometime in 1787 or 1788. Despite the bend there will be
substantial bidding activity for this scarcity.
PCGS# 451.
GEORGIVS III. VG Details—Environmental Damage
(PCGS). This is a mostly dark copper example with a few
areas of crimson surface scale in isolated areas. Both sides
are overall rough with considerable pitting and granularity,
although there are no singularly distracting abrasions. The
definition is suitably bold for the assigned grade in all areas
save for around the reverse periphery, and in addition to
the diagnostic carrot-shaped break, a second reverse die
break is prominent at the border through the letters IT
in BRITANNIA. A highly collectable example of a rare
Machin’s Mills date and variety.
PCGS# 451.
Page 15
1091 1787 Machin’s Mills Halfpenny. Vlack 21-87D. Rarity-4.
GEORGIVS III. VF-35 Planchet Flaws. 116.3 grains. Dark
chocolate surfaces with sharp detail and a pleasing uniform
appearance throughout with several long planchet flaws,
as made, on both sides. A trivial rim bump at 2:45 on the
obverse is noted, though it is easily missed. The output from
the Machin’s Mills operation at Orange Pond in upstate New
York was never known for flawless planchets and superb
coinage quality — for just these reasons the series is popular
and highly collectable today.
PCGS# 469.
Contemporary Counterfeit
English Halfpennies
1094 1772 Contemporary Counterfeit English Halfpenny
Muling. George II Obverse, George III-Era Reverse.
Simian Style. VF-35. 97.8 grains. Struck on a tight flan
that is actually quite robust for the Simian Style, the tops of
the legends are off the flan due to its constricted size. Both
obverse and reverse dies are failing, the obverse especially.
Dark brown and attractive, with some old surface marks
and corrosion.
Paper envelope with collector notes included.
1092 1733 Contemporary Counterfeit English Halfpenny.
George II Type. Simian Style. VF-20. 81.6 grains. Light
brown surfaces show some old scrapes and large central
pits, while date and most of spidery legends are quite clear.
Date digits show evidence of overdating, 33/77 on this very
pleasant-for-the-issue specimen.
George III Type. BRTIANNIA. EF-40. 131.6 grains.
Medium brown and generally trouble-free for the issue,
this specimen exhibits a transposition of the “I” and “T”
in the reverse legend, rendering it into the comical form
“BRTIANNIA,” seemingly one of many legend foul-ups on
this style of 1773 halfpenny.
George III Type. Simian Style. AU-55. 79.9 grains. A
superb deep chestnut brown example that shows little actual
wear — the central weakness is due to the soft strike on this
paper thin planchet. Great style, eye appeal and a full date
on this iconic counterfeit halfpenny type.
George III Type. Simian Style. EF-40. 79.6 grains. A choice
light brown example of the Simian Style counterfeits struck
on the usual thin flan. Consignor identifies this as “Weston
4” from Byron Weston’s article in CNL #111, page 1972,
figure 23.
Page 16
1097 1775 Contemporary Counterfeit English Halfpenny
Muling. George II Obverse, George III-Era Reverse.
Simian Style. VF-20. 80.9 grains. Dark brown and a bit
rough, though exhibiting hard and glossy surfaces on
both sides. A scarce muling, the reverse die showing an
exaggerated “monkey arm” on Britannia.
1100 Lot of (5) New Jersey Coppers. Included are: 1786 Maris
23-R, Rarity-2, Blundered Six, Fine-15, evenly granular dark
olive with a substantial rim bruise at 8 o’clock on the reverse;
1787 Maris 29-L, Rarity-4, Fine-15, a reasonably nice coin
for this scarce Maris number, though the advanced obverse
die state limits the detail on the horsehead, even light
brown with a smattering of dark surface detritus, mostly at
obverse periphery and across the reverse; 1787 Maris 43-d,
Rarity-1, Fine-12, dark brown with slightly lighter devices,
three dull nicks behind horsehead; and (2) 1787 Maris 48-g,
Rarity-1, the first is Fine-15 with scattered light granularity,
especially on the reverse, the second is VG-8, light brown
with planchet striations.
From the Bareford Family Collection.
New Jersey Copper
1098 1786 New Jersey Copper. Maris 14-J. Rarity-1. Stegosaurus
Head. Unc Details—Altered Surfaces (PCGS). Medium
tan-rose with a boldly defined reverse. The obverse displays
some light detritus around the date, and minor planchet
roughness is noted on both sides. The stated impairment is
difficult to discern, although perhaps the surfaces are a bit
too glossy for PCGS’s liking. Maris.14-J is a product of the
Rahway Mint in New Jersey from dies reportedly by James
F. Atlee, who was active in the Connecticut, Vermont, and
New Jersey series and with other colonial-related issues.
PCGS# 498.
1101 1786 New Jersey Copper. Maris 24-P. Rarity-2. VF-25.
168.3 grains. Light brown and deeper olive with excellent
detail in the horsehead, though the central reverse shows its
typical weakness. The base of the obverse is quite striated,
minutely granular everywhere, date complete and present
though weak. Free of damage, no notable marks, a pleasing
example. Accompanied by a square ticket inscribed in ink
“N.J. / 1786 / 24-P,” seemingly of early to mid 20th century
vintage though not currently attributed.
PCGS# 45424.
1099 1786 New Jersey Copper. Maris 16-L. Rarity-2. Protruding
Tongue. EF-40. 149.9 grains. A handsome and wholesome
example of this popular major variety. Attractive and glossy
medium brown with a halo of deep olive toning around
design elements. Some light planchet flecks are noted,
particularly on the obverse and at the softly struck area at the
central reverse, but they are neither unusual or distracting.
The obverse is aligned to 3 o’clock, with the die edge visible
at the left side, while the reverse is ideally centered. A tiny
planchet flaw is present at S of PLURIBUS, but only a short
dull scrape below the snout is noted as a post-striking defect.
This is a very collectible example of this naked-eye variety.
PCGS# 45423.
From the Bareford Family Collection. Purchased from Empire Coin
Company (Q. David Bowers and Jim Ruddy), circa 1958-1965.
1102 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 32-T. Rarity-2. Fine15. 142.3 grains. Attractive light brown and olive with
significant striations and granularity on both sides. Probably
VF in terms of sharpness, with the eye of the horse still
fully outlined. Accompanied by an ancient square ticket
inscribed in pen “New Jersey / 1787 / 32-T / Good,” likely
accomplished by Henry Chapman.
PCGS# 503.
1103 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 38-a. Rarity-5. Fine-15.
149.7 grains. Lightly glossy in texture, with medium brown
patina, smooth surfaces and strong remaining details. A
minor patch of planchet roughness is visible on the obverse
periphery from 4 to 6 o’clock, and another small mark is
noted on the reverse periphery at 4 o’clock, but overall this is
a pleasing piece for the grade. A product of James F. Atlee at
the Rahway Mint facilities in New Jersey.
PCGS# 503.
Page 17
Mint State Maris 43-d New Jersey Copper
1104 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 43-d. Rarity-1. MS-63 BN (PCGS). CAC. One of the “Pronounced Outline to Shield” varieties,
although not designated as such on the PCGS insert. Left ear under space between C and A. Other ear under left upright of A. This
example was struck slightly off center on both sides, and the tops of the letters URIB on the reverse are off the flan. The reverse
has mild clash marks from the obverse design, occurring mainly across the lower right portion of the shield. A pleasing and nicely
preserved Select Mint State example. Lustrous and largely free of post-strike imperfections. Maris 43-d is one of the more readily
obtainable New Jersey copper die marriages in terms of total number of examples known, but the series as a whole is rare in Mint
State. The present example is one of perhaps just a half dozen or so Uncs known, per William T. Anton, Jr. (referenced in the
Whitman Encyclopedia of Colonial and Early American Coins by Q. David Bowers).
PCGS# 506.
1105 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 43-d. Rarity-1—Double
Struck, Close Overlap—VF Details—Environmental
Damage (PCGS). Deep brown and lighter sandy tan colors
compete for dominance over both sides of this generally
bold VF. The texture is a bit rough overall with areas of light
scaling, and the environmental damage also explains the
scattered pitting on the obverse. The double striking error
is difficult to discern given the coin’s condition, but closer
inspection does reveal this intriguing feature around both
the central and peripheral devices. Certainly an interesting
example of this popular Rahway Mint issue.
1107 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 62-q. Rarity-3. Hidden
Initials. Fine-15. 129.3 grains. Attractive and smooth steel
brown with nice eye appeal. Some light scrapes across the
central obverse are noted, though their appearance has
been diminished by some careful burnishing in that area.
No other notable issues are seen, and the details rise to VF
quality in areas. A handsome Large Planchet New Jersey
copper.
PCGS# 509.
PCGS# 506.
1106 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 48-g. Rarity-1. VF-20.
131.9 grains. Dark steel brown with lighter tan highlights
on the worn parts of the devices. Evenly granular but not
offensively so. Ideally centered and free of significant marks
or defects. Accompanied by a square ticket inscribed in ink
“New Jersey / 1787 / Maris 48-g,” of late 19th or early 20th
century vintage but unattributed.
PCGS# 503.
Page 18
1108 1788 New Jersey Copper. Maris 65-u. Rarity-4. VF20. 156.5 grains. Deep chocolate brown with good eye
appeal for this always crudely struck variety. The surfaces
are glossy and fairly even where unflawed, though the
peripheries show some minor granularity. The always soft
area at the central obverse retains a sizeable planchet flaw,
running on the same vector as the plow. Some more trivial
laminations are seen above the snout and through some
letters of CAESAREA. An extremely small rim clip is seen
at the end of the plow handles. The reverse is fairly choice,
showing just two very thin old hairlines that run along the
approximate x- and y-axes of the coin. The reverse is aligned
to 4:30, with denticles and die edge visible in the northwest
quadrant; the obverse is ideally centered. Very late die state,
equivalent to SHI DS4, with the obverse swollen and die
cracks abundant; a triangular area has broken free of the
die at the arc crack above the left side of O of NOVA. The
color of this piece is better than most of the variety, and its
die state and provenance increases its desirability by some
positive multiplier.
PCGS# 521.
Bar Copper Related
1110 Continental Army Ligate USA Uniform Button. Cast
Pewter. 19 mm, irregular margins. 59.6 grains. An
impressive dug example with deep gray surfaces, a full
shank and bold central detail. A small piece at 4 o’clock is
missing, where the metal is also slightly bent.
Franklin Press Token
1111 1794 Franklin Press Token. W-8850. Plain Edge. MS-62 BN
(NGC). Lovely steel-brown and pale lilac patina engages both
sides of this attractive piece, the surfaces also revealing glints
of underlying deep rose luster in isolated areas. Boldly defined
with a satiny texture and no singularly distracting blemishes.
Vermont Copper
PCGS# 630.
Washington Pieces
1109 1788 Vermont Copper. RR-16, Bressett 15-S. Rarity-2. Bust
Right. EF-45 (PCGS). Smooth chocolate brown surfaces
display nice gloss and exceptionally bold details; a softer
strike is noted in the centers, likely due to uneven planchet
thickness, indeed slight concavity is visible at the central
reverse, as made. Those who collect Vermont coppers know
just how rare an EF of any Bust variety is, save for maybe
Ryder-13, the Britannia variety. The present coin may serve
as an upgrade for some, or perhaps even as an introduction
to the fascinating coinage series of the Republic of Vermont.
PCGS# 563.
1112 1791 Small Eagle Cent. Baker-16. Rarity-3. UNITED
STATES Edge. AU-55 (PCGS). OGH. With smooth,
glossy, tan-brown surfaces, this boldly defined AU would
make an impressive addition to a type set of Washington
pieces. George Washington was adamantly against the use
of his portrait on any circulating coinage, so the plethora
of Washington types from the era basically never stood a
chance to become coin of the realm. Today, however, these
issues are avidly collected by devotees of Washington as well
as numismatists. The present piece is decidedly choice for
the grade and worthy of bold bidding activity.
PCGS# 705.
Page 19
Famous Washington Skull and Crossbones Funeral Medal
Silver, Circa 1800 Rarity
1113 (1800) Skull and Crossbones Funeral Medal. Silver. 29 mm. Baker-165A. Rarity-8. VF-35 (PCGS). Neatly holed for suspension
at 12 o’clock, as issued. This is an endearing mid-grade example with richly original, even toning in charcoal-blue. The design
is nicely centered on the planchet with bold definition to all major design elements. A few minor handling marks in the center
of the obverse and along the lower border on the same side are noted for accuracy, but the outward appearance of this piece is
uncommonly smooth in a Washington Funeral medal that was worn or otherwise carried for a significant period of time.
The Father of Our Country, George Washington, passed into history on December 14, 1799. Few Americans, if any, held a place
in the hearts of our forebears that was as sacred as that held by Washington, and the nation mourned for months. Sentiments
such as “He is in Glory, the World in Tears” and “First in War, First in Peace, First in the Hearts of His Countrymen” were familiar
to every living American who had passed through the birth of our nation with Washington at the helm. Countless celebrations
of Washington’s life and times followed almost immediately after his death and were held throughout the land from the largest
cities to the smallest of hamlets. One such event, a funeral procession held by Masons —Washington was a Mason – took place in
Boston, Massachusetts on February 11, 1800, the anniversary of Washington’s birth, and was attended by some 1,600 marchers and
doubtless many more onlookers. It is thought the Skull and Crossbones Funeral Medal was made for and worn by marchers and
onlookers of this first great event. On February 22, a civic procession wound its way through the streets of Boston, again with large
crowds and medallic tributes, this time with a funeral urn as the central motif on the medals. The famous Skull and Crossbones
medal was almost certainly made in early 1800, just weeks after Washington passed, but prior to the Masonic march held February
11. Virtually every example of the medal known is holed for suspension at the top, and were no doubt worn with pride at the
Mason’s march and probably long afterward, especially given the condition of many of the medals known today. We have sold
several of these popular and scarce Skull and Crossbones medals in the past, most recently an EF example in our January 2014
Americana Sale that realized $41,125 after the bidding subsided. In our January 2013 Americana Sale, we sold an example identical
in grade – PCGS VF-35 — to the specimen in our upcoming June Baltimore event, a coin that realized $27,348 after fierce bidding
competition.
PCGS# 412255.
1114 Undated (Possibly Circa 1793) Success Medal. Large Size. Baker-266B. Silvered Brass. Plain Edge. MS-62 (PCGS). CAC. This
charming piece is originally toned in a blend of warm dove gray and lighter silver gray shades. The strike is sharp, the surfaces are
smooth, and the overall appearance is suggestive of an appreciably higher grade. Lovely!The enigmatic Washington Success tokens or
medals are from an unknown source and era, though two schools of thought currently suggest the beginnings of the token issue. The
first scenario, favored by Baker, DeWitt, and others, has the medals issued for the second Inauguration of Washington on March 4, 1793.
Rulau and Fuld think the issue might be mid-19th century owing to their size relationship to certain popular spielmarke game tokens
from that era. In the March 1981 portion of the sale of the Garrett Collection, Dave Bowers wondered whether they might not be 19thcentury pieces as well (lots 1736-1742). Though the who, what, when, where, and why of the issue is uncertain, the fact that collectors
have actively pursued the issue for the past 150 or so years is a given. We expect a solid bidder turnout for this lot.
PCGS# 787.
Page 20
Fugio Copper
1115 1787 Fugio Copper. Club Rays. Newman 3-D. Rarity-3. Rounded Ends. EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS). 146.4 grains. Medium brown
with lighter devices and just a bit of iridescence on the reverse remaining from an old cleaning. Slightly granular throughout but glossy
and extremely sharp, little natural lamination left of the sunface, low spot at juncture of rings nearest 11 o’clock, flaw inside ring juncture
near 3 o’clock and some minor striations elsewhere. Late die state, clashing visible on reverse, cracked atop date and around cinquefoil
after FUGIO. Quite appealing, particularly so for this elusive advanced die state.
PCGS# 904.
From Early American Numismatics Sale # 1, January 1985, lot 304; our sale of the Robert Ayers Collection, August 2013, lot 1335. Early American Numismatics
and collector tag included.
Important Newman 10-T Fugio Copper Rarity
1116 1787 Fugio Copper. Pointed Rays. Newman 10-T. Rarity-5. STATES UNITED, 1/Horizontal 1, 4 Cinquefoils. EF Details—
Damage (PCGS). 142.6 grains. A major stumbling block on the way to a fine cabinet of Fugios, a rare major variety that almost
never appears on the market in high grade. Among the recent Fugio collections dispersed, the Retz coin stands as the best of the
Newman 10-Ts, graded EF-40 (PCGS) and selling for $16,450. The Craige coin was also a nice EF, though lightly cleaned; it still
brought $5,581. This piece is nearly as sharp as those, with glossy dark chocolate brown surfaces and pleasantly contrasting devices.
The surfaces are smooth and appealing, with no significant roughness. A couple of dull old marks at the central reverse have
flattened part of the central legends and left a very slight bulge above the central obverse at the outside edge of the sundial face, thus
the PCGS assignment. The issues are minor considering the positive aspects of the coin and its place among the pecking order of
survivors from these dies.
PCGS# 886.
From our sale of the Richard Moore Collection, November 2013, lot 4238.
1117 1787 Fugio Copper. Pointed Rays. Newman 11-X. Rarity-4. STATES UNITED, 4 Cinquefoils. AU-58 (PCGS). 128.6 grains. Very
attractive dark chocolate brown with glossy, somewhat lustrous surfaces. Well centered and free of significant marks, a soft area at
lower right side of sundial reveals some planchet texture; the opposite area at the upper right side of central reverse shows some related
texture and striations. A little patch around FU of FUGIO is a bit granular. Barely worn and very pleasing, with rich even color, this is a
handsome example of the variety.
PCGS# 883.
From our (Bowers and Merena’s) Montgomery Collection sale, May 1998, lot 195; and our sale of the Robert Ayers Collection, August 2013, lot 1357.
Page 21
1118 1787 Fugio Copper. Pointed Rays. Newman 12-X.
Rarity-3. STATES UNITED, 4 Cinquefoils. AU-58
(PCGS). This is a pleasingly glossy, mostly reddishcopper example that retains bold to sharp striking detail
throughout. There are no detracting abrasions, although
a couple of minor planchet flaws near the upper obverse
border and several planchet streaks on both sides are noted
for accuracy (all are as struck). This popular variety of our
nation’s first authorized coinage was well-represented in the
fabled Bank of New York Hoard — of 1,641 pieces in the
hoard, 264 were of the Newman 12-X persuasion.
PCGS# 883.
1120 1787 Fugio Copper. Pointed Rays. Newman 15-H.
Rarity-4. UNITED STATES, 4 Cinquefoils. EF Details—
Filed Rims (PCGS). 146.2 grains. A particularly sharp
example of this elusive variety, described in our (Bowers and
Merena’s) 1988 catalog of the Norweb Collection as:”Dark,
glossy brown. Edge nick at 9 o’clock on the obverse. Grip marks
at the base of the obverse and top of the reverse. Obverse edge
filed at top, obscuring sun face and outer portions of the 5th
through 7th links. Dual sets of obverse clash marks; usually
seen heavy break from rim at 5 o’clock into sundial’s face.
Reverse die perfect.”The unusual smoothing on the rim was
carefully and precisely accomplished, though your cataloger
(JK) could not even begin to explain why. In spite of this,
Rob Retz ranked this piece as fifth finest known for the
variety. It certainly ranks among the very sharpest extant.
PCGS# 889.
From our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of the Norweb Collection, Part III,
November 1988, lot 3452; and our sale of the Robert Ayers Collection,
August 2013, lot 1374. Norweb sale lot tag included.
1121 1787 Fugio Copper. Pointed Rays. Newman 15-Y.
Rarity-2. STATES UNITED, 8-Pointed Star on Label. VF35 (PCGS). 148.6 grains. Attractive dark chocolate brown
with slightly lighter devices. Finely granular under a glass,
some surface verdigris, most notable around 9 o’clock on
the reverse. A short striation is present over the date, no
significant contact marks. Slightly advanced die state with
a more typical appearing crack right of 6 o’clock on the
reverse. Very sharply struck, better detailed than indicated
by the assigned grade, both stars fully visible on the reverse.
This would be a very nice way to represent this important
variety in a set of the major Fugio varieties.
PCGS# 898.
1119 1787 Fugio Copper. Pointed Rays. Newman 12-KK.
Rarity-6. STATES UNITED, 4 Cinquefoils. EF Details—
Environmental Damage (PCGS). Both the rarity of this die
pairing and the exceptional sharpness of detail throughout
the design are sure to endear this important piece to a Fugio
copper variety specialist. The obverse, in particular, exhibits
virtually full definition to most features, and on the reverse
the only detail missing is the denticulation from 6 to 9
o’clock due to imperfect centering on that side. Dark goldenbrown patina throughout, with an overall rough texture, yet
with no singularly detracting abrasions. Newman 12-KK
is one of seven die combinations in the series that involves
Newman’s Obverse 12, and it is tied with N 12-LL as the
rarest of those seven varieties listed in the recent Newman
reference on the series. Surprisingly, the Ford Collection
did not feature a Newman 12-KK among its multitude of
offerings in the design type.
PCGS# 883.
From our sale of the Robert Ayers Collection, August 2013, lot 1380.
Ayers acquired the coin from Early American in July 1982. Paper envelope with attribution notation included.
and Related
1122 “1652” (1850s) Oak Tree Shilling. Wyatt Copy. W-14040.
MS-63. 59.2 grains. Exceptionally well struck with crisp
details throughout, even the background “shading” lines are
sharp. Nearly all of the original silvering remains to virtually
Choice surfaces. This popular concoction has long been
collected, along with other Wyatt pieces, since the time of
their inception.
Page 22
Half Cents
1123 “1652” (1850s) Good Samaritan / Massachusetts Bay
Colony Pine Tree Shilling Mule. Wyatt Copy. W-14082.
VF-20. 39.8 grains. Deeply toned with an irregular clipped
planchet, the reverse is struck up quite nicely with crisp
detail while the obverse Good Samaritan scene is a bit less
well-defined with some weakness at the periphery. Known
for more than 150 years, this popular concoction has always
found a place in the hearts of American collectors, and
bidding on this attractive specimen should serve to prove
our point.
1126 1793 Head Left. C-1. Rarity-3+. Manley Die State 2.0.
VF Details—Tooled (PCGS). Deep brown centers give
way to lighter brown patina towards the peripheries with
primarily smooth surfaces, likely due to tooling to remove
some roughness in the fields. The detail is strong to bold
throughout with just a touch of weakness at the reverse
center, and the eye appeal is pleasing overall. From the first
year of coinage operations at the newly opened Philadelphia
Mint, and a one-year-only type coin with Liberty’s portrait
facing left — all other half cents of the Flowing Hair style,
1794 to 1797, have Liberty’s portrait to the right.
PCGS# 1000.
1124 Electrotype Copy “1652” Pine Tree Sixpence. Noe-33,
Salmon 2-B. Pellets at Trunk. AU-50. 31.9 grains. This
quality electrotype retains most of the original silvering
and exhibits an attractive, wholesome appearance with
nice medium silver fields and slightly brighter devices
and legends. A great “filler” for a growing collection of
Massachusetts Bay Colony pieces, these have been avidly
collected for nearly as long as they have been made.
1127 1800 C-1. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 4.0. EF-45 BN
(NGC). Deep chocolate brown with red undertones and
lovely smooth surfaces, this piece also exhibits light gloss
and sharp details on both sides. A small, old dig on Liberty’s
bust is noted, though it blends in among the drapery lines
fairly well and doesn’t detract from the overall eye appeal of
this pleasing Choice EF. From the first year of the Draped
Bust half cent style, this design type lasted through 1808 and
was struck in every year during that time frame except in
1801.
PCGS# 35119.
1128 1803 C-3. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 3.0. Widely Spaced
3. EF-40 BN (NGC). This is an attractive example with
light copper brown toning and bold details throughout. A
few isolated areas show uneven toning, but the eye appeal
is good overall. The reverse is rotated approximately 30
degrees clockwise in relation to normal coin alignment.
Circulated examples of this date are seen frequently on
porous and discolored planchets — the present specimen is
a pleasing exception to that rule of thumb.
PCGS# 1060.
1125 Bar Copper Copy. Copper. 26 mm. 4.7 grams. AU-50. 70.0
grains. This nicely made 19th-century copy of unknown
origin displays pleasing medium brown surfaces with light
rub on the high points. Many are the copies and variations
of the Bar copper, some contemporary and some later than
the time of the original pieces, and many are the collectors
who own numerous types and variations of the issue.
1129 1804 C-13. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 2.0. Plain 4,
Stemless Wreath. AU-50 (PCGS). CAC. An impressive
high grade type candidate, this inviting piece offers glossy,
outwardly smooth surfaces and boldly defined central
devices. The toning is an attractive blend of orange-brown
and copper brown, the reverse a bit warmer in color than
the obverse. The 1804 half cent issue offers a playground of
varieties to an interested collector, of which five are listed
in the Guide Book. Just those five varieties — of which the
present coin is one — would make for an interesting subcollection for the date.
PCGS# 1063.
Page 23
1130 1806 C-4. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 2.0. Large 6, Stems.
MS-63 RB (PCGS). Handsome patina to both sides is
presented in a blended reddish-copper with brighter mint
orange in the protected areas. The surfaces are generally
smooth and the strike is bold aside from a few isolated weak
spots in the drapery and over the upper right reverse. The
reverse is rotated nearly 45 degrees clockwise in relation
to normal coin alignment, not an unusual occurrence for
the date. Draped Bust half cents in Mint State are always
in great demand and seemingly never go out of style with
numismatists. We suspect more than one serious bidder will
pursue this attractive specimen with vigor.
PCGS# 1100.
AU-55 (PCGS). This is a delightful piece with bold to sharp
definition in most areas from a generally well balanced
strike. Toned in slightly mottled light orange and pale gold,
this smooth looking Choice AU would do particularly
well in a high-grade type set. Three distinct styles of 1806
half cent are listed in theGuideBook, including the variety
offered here. Of the three, the Small 6 With Stems variety
is the rarest, with the variety offered here, C-4, one of the
most available varieties of the date. However, high-quality
examples such as offered here are an exception and not a
rule for the date.
1134 1809 C-6. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 1.0—Struck 10%
Off Center—AU-53 (PCGS). This attractive medium olivebrown piece exhibits smooth surfaces, bold to sharp details,
and light wear to the high points. Struck 10% off center at
1 o’clock, nearly all of Liberty’s hair is present and just the
tops of the letters ICA in AMERICA are missing from the
reverse. A neat error coin that will have wide appeal among
our bidders.
PCGS# 1123.
1135 1828 C-2. Rarity-2. Manley Die State 2.0. 12 Stars. AU58 (PCGS). This handsome piece is fully original with
warm golden-brown patina to both sides. The surfaces
are outwardly smooth, and the devices offer considerable
boldness of detail in most areas. This blundered star count
was most likely an oversight as the engraver placed just
five stars to the right instead of the usual six stars. Similar
engraving errors are known (1832 half eagle with 12 stars),
but this type of error is unusual and highly popular with
collectors.
PCGS# 1150.
PCGS# 1099.
1132 1808 C-3. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 3.0. AU-53 (PCGS).
An exceptionally attractive example, smooth, glossy
surfaces are boldly defined and free of detracting abrasions.
The obverse is warmly toned in medium copper, while the
reverse is mostly orange-brown in color. A few faint roller
marks on Liberty’s cheek are as struck and mentioned
here solely for accuracy. C-3 is a distinctive variety. On the
obverse, the two 8s in the date are radically different in size
and appearance. On the reverse, the right wreath stem is
connected by a die scratch to the 2nd A in AMERICA.
PCGS# 1107.
1136 1829 C-1, the only known dies. Rarity-1. Manley Die State
1.0. MS-65 BN (NGC). Lovely copper brown patina with
substantial mint red still present in the protected areas, this
appealing Gem displays a strong strike, choice surfaces, and
excellent eye appeal. The half cents of the era provide many
opportunities for today’s collectors to obtain a high degree
of quality for their numismatic dollar, perhaps more so in
the half cent series than with any other early 19th-century
type.
PCGS# 35267.
1133 1809/’6’ C-5. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 3.0. 9/Inverted
9. AU-55 BN (NGC). Deep even chocolate brown
patina throughout with attractive, virtually abrasion free
surfaces and crisp detail. This is a wholly satisfying piece
with substantial appeal. Long thought to be an overdate,
conventional wisdom lays this variety at the foot of an
inverted numeral punch instead.
PCGS# 35233.
Page 24
Large Cents
1.0—Struck 10% Off Center, 5% Reverse Brockage @ 12
O’Clock—EF-45 (PCGS). Medium olive-brown with deep
red patina at the reverse center, the surfaces are smooth
overall with a few tiny specks of verdigris visible on the
reverse. Struck off center at 3 o’clock, with a minor brockage
at 12 o’clock on the reverse that shows a dozen or so dentils
from the second coin. An exciting error that should appeal
to error specialists and half cent collectors alike.
PCGS# 1153.
1138 1834 C-1, the only known dies. Rarity-1. Manley Die Sate
1.0. MS-64 BN (NGC). CAC. OH. Medium chestnut brown
surfaces display a few traces or mint red in the protected
areas while the surfaces are completely smooth and choice.
A small speck of white detritus in the wreath speaks to the
strict originality of this attractive early copper. This popular
dater and grade combination is well represented in type sets
today owing to its ready availability in Mint State.
1141 1793 Chain Reverse. S-3. Rarity-3-. AMERICA,
Without Periods. Fair-2 (PCGS). An important find for
a budget minded type collector, this dark brown survivor
retains readily evident definition to the chain motif and
denomination in the center of the reverse. Other features
are expectably softer for a heavily worn Chain cent, and
some are absent, although much of Liberty’s portrait is
faintly outlined. Even at the assigned grade, there are always
buyers for this issue. Not everyone can afford a high-grade
1793 Chain cent, but many collectors enjoy owning one of
America’s first cents no matter the grade. Don’t be surprised
at the bidder participation when this coin crosses the
auction block.
PCGS# 1341.
From the McCoy-Baden Collection.
PCGS# 1165.
1139 1834 C-1, the only known dies. Rarity-1. Manley Die
State 3.0. MS-64 BN (NGC). Lovely copper brown patina
with appreciable areas of bright mint red in some protected
areas. The surfaces are smooth and display a strong strike
and good eye appeal. A great combination of date, grade,
and value for today’s collectors.
PCGS# 35285.
1.0. MS-65 RB (NGC). Sharply struck with substantial mint
orange luster remaining, the lustrous surfaces are problem
free and attractive in all regards. An exceptional half cent
that would do justice to an advanced type set or half cent
cabinet.
1142 1793 Wreath Reverse. S-8. Rarity-3-. Vine and Bars Edge.
VF Details—Devices Engraved (PCGS). This piece is
evenly toned in a rather pleasing medium copper patina.
There are no significant abrasions, although the surfaces
are extensively pitted due to environmental damage. More
significant are the devices, which have been extensively
tooled and now display curiously intricate and visually
interesting definition to both Liberty’s portrait and the
reverse wreath. One of the most popular of all early cent
types, the Wreath cent of 1793 is the second incarnation of
three styles of the denomination for the date — the Chain
cents were first, and the Liberty cap style followed the
Wreath type. The present piece offers both a suitable filler
example of the date and a neat conversation piece as well.
PCGS# 1347.
PCGS# 35331.
Page 25
1143 1793 Wreath Reverse. S-9. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State B.
Vine and Bars Edge. Fine Details—Improperly Cleaned,
Rim Damage (NGC). With all major design elements
boldly outlined and clear, this glossy dark brown example
is seemingly earmarked for inclusion in a budget-minded
type set. Scattered marks and rim bumps are noted, the
more prominent ones of which are confined to the obverse.
Still, an important and elusive type that is often represented
by filler examples such as this until a finer piece can be
procured.
PCGS# 1347.
1144 1793 Wreath Reverse. S-9. Rarity-2. Vine and Bars Edge.
VG Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS). Deep redbrown glossy surfaces display light to moderate corrosion
throughout, heaviest on the right side of the reverse. The
date is mostly clear and Liberty is well profiled with nearly all
hair ends plainly visible. The reverse displays similarly bold
detail except on the right side where details are obscured by
corrosion.
PCGS# 1347.
From the EAC Convention sale, April 2005, lot 85; the EAC 2007 Convention sale, April 2007, lot 117. Lot tags and paper cards with attribution notation included.
1147 1793 Liberty Cap. S-13. Rarity-4-. VG Details—
Environmental Damage (PCGS). Uniformly rough and
porous with even medium brown toning throughout. The
date, LIBERTY, and the bust are all well profiled, and the
reverse displays bold definition to the wreath and legends.
The 1793 Liberty Cap cent represents the third of three
distinct cent design types offered up by the Mint in its first
year of operations. It is thought the design was by Joseph
Wright, a young and promising engraver who succumbed
to Yellow Fever in the late summer of 1793.
PCGS# 1359.
Bob Grellman and Jeff Kierstead tags with attribution notes included.
1148 1794 S-28. Rarity-2+. Head of 1794. EF Details—
Environmental Damage, Reverse Scratched (NGC). This
piece offers a considerable amount of sharp definition
from a nicely centered, well executed strike. Orange-brown
surfaces are uniformly rough with light pitting, and a sizable
reverse scratch bisects the upper left wreath and the letter O
in ONE. All things considered, an amply suitable example
for a beginning large cent collection or early type set.
PCGS# 35528.
1145 1793 Wreath Reverse. S-11C. Rarity-3-. Lettered Edge.
EF Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS). The stated
impairment notwithstanding, this is an extremely inviting
coin for circulated type purposes. Bold copper brown
surfaces retain sharp striking detail throughout the design,
and although noticeably rough in texture, the surfaces are
free of outwardly distracting abrasions. Though the obverse
still retains the “frightened” head of Liberty with flowing
tresses that adorned the Chain cents of earlier in the year, the
reverse is now adorned with a central wreath that became,
in various forms, the standard for large cents until the end
of the denomination in 1857. There are several varieties of
1793-dated Wreath cents, the most famous of which is the
rare Strawberry Leaf variety. (During the days of ANR, the
present writer (FVV), along with several other staffers, had
the pleasure of holding all of the known examples of the
Strawberry Leaf large cent rarity in one hand.)
PCGS# 1350.
1146 1793 Wreath Reverse. S-11C. Rarity-3-. Lettered Edge.
VG Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS). Light
brown surfaces with uniform porosity throughout, strong
detail shows in Liberty’s hair and the date is plainly visible
at an angle. The central reverse is bold and the legends are
fully legible if not faint, and the rims are nearly complete on
both sides. The fact that we have more than one lower grade
1793 Wreath cent in this sale is a positive situation for those
trying to keep the numismatic budget in check.
1149 1794 S-64. Rarity-5-. Noyes Die State B. Head of 1794.
AU Details—Burnished (NGC). This is a remarkably
attractive coin despite the stated impairment. Both sides are
sharply to fully struck throughout and the color, although
not entirely original, is a pleasing and vivid reddish-copper.
There are also hardly any distractions to overall smooth
looking features, and a dull horizontal abrasion at the base
of Liberty’s neck is the only worthwhile pedigree marker.
This coin is listed in the Breen’s Large Cent Encyclopedia as
Condition Census tied for #4 and listed in the Noyes Census
as tied with one other for #6 of this tough variety. A rarity
that should strongly be considered by any variety specialist
seeking Condition Census level coins. The surfaces are
otherwise average and rather attractive when studied with a
loupe. All high grade 1794 Large cents are in high demand,
and have been for generations.
PCGS# 901374.
Ex: Stack’s, privately; Alfred Bonard; Numismatic Enterprises’ sale of
February 1968, lot 34; H. Jordan; Frederick Ouellette, August 22, 1973;
Denis W. Loring, August 22, 1973; John W. Adams, November 1974;
Denis W. Loring, July 28, 1979; John R. “Bob” Grellman, Jr.; George
Weintraub. Paper envelope with attribution and pedigree information
included.
PCGS# 1350.
Page 26
1150 1794 S-72. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A. Head of 1795.
Fine-12 (PCGS). Mottled crimson highlights are more
prevalent on the reverse of this otherwise golden-brown
example. A few small obverse spots and central marks on
both sides are noted, although boldly outlined definition
to all devices is sure to result in strong interest in this
piece among Guide Book variety collectors. The year 1794
is a veritable playground for variety collectors. While the
Red Book lists five distinct varieties for the date, serious
collectors know there are three score and more varieties
for the date, as the early dies were all created individually
by hand. There are three distinct head styles among the
60+ varieties, including the Head of ‘93; the Head of ‘94 as
offered here; and the Head of ‘95 that followed later in the
year.
PCGS# 1365.
1151 1797 S-125. Rarity-5. Noyes Die State A. Reverse of
1797, With Stems. VF-20 (PCGS). Medium brown with
pleasingly smooth surfaces and bold definition, the denticles
are complete on both sides and substantial detail is visible
within Liberty’s hair curls. A bit of weakness at the letters
LI in LIBERTY and toward the lower left reverse border
is noted, but the eye appeal is strong for an early copper
at the middle of the numismatic grading scale. There are
numerous varieties of 1797 large cents and the Red Book
lists four of the most popular, a list that includes the present
variety. A nice opportunity for a mid-range type or large
cent collection.
PCGS# 1422.
1152 1797 S-130. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State B. Reverse of
1797, With Stems. EF Details—Altered Surfaces (PCGS).
Sharply defined from an expertly centered and nicely
executed strike, this piece presents remarkably well despite
the stated impairment. There are no individually distracting
abrasions and the surfaces, although possessed of a curious
matte-like texture, are toned rather nicely in even reddishcopper. Tied for Condition Census #15 for the die marriage,
per notes that accompany this lot.
PCGS# 1422.
Paper envelopes with attribution and census information included.
1153 1799 S-189. Rarity-2+. Fine Details—Environmental
Damage (PCGS). A respectable example of this popular
key date issue, all devices are fully appreciable, even despite
characteristic (for the die marriage) softness of strike to
the digits in the date. Both sides exhibit an overall rough,
gray-brown appearance with light scaling in isolated areas,
as well as scattered pitting and contact marks that are more
widespread on the reverse. The 1799 large cent, along with
the 1799/8 overdate, represents an important key date
in a series that stretched from 1793 to 1857 with just one
interruption in 1816. Well worthy of in-person examination.
PCGS# 1443.
1154 1799 S-189. Rarity-2+. Fair-2 (PCGS). CAC. An obviously
enticing piece for a budget-minded early copper specialist,
this genuine 1799 cent is a problem free Fair with evenly
toned, deep brown and gray brown surfaces. The final
digit in the date is discernible, if faint, as is much of the
obverse portrait and portions of the word LIBERTY, the
denomination, wreath, and the legend UNITED STATES
OF AMERICA. Scattered contact marks are commensurate
with the assigned grade, and none are sizable or otherwise
singularly distracting. Even a Fair-2 example of this key date
will see modest bidding activity.
PCGS# 1443.
1155 1799 S-189. Rarity-2+. Fair-2 (PCGS). Otherwise golden
brown surfaces exhibit deeper crimson-tinged patina
throughout much of the field areas. Heavily worn with a
rough, pitted texture, this piece does remain highly desirable
in a 1799 cent given the fact that the tops of all four digits
in the date are boldly defined and clear. The key date among
large cents, and a well-loved rarity that is acceptable to
collectors in just about any grade — numerous fakes exist
of the date and a genuine piece such as this is always held in
great regard. Though certain varieties of large cents are more
difficult to obtain, as a date the 1799 is the cream of the crop.
PCGS# 1443.
1156 1802 S-242. Rarity-2. EF-45 (PCGS). Even medium brown
surfaces are exceptionally smooth and moderately glossy
on this choice early cent. Boldly defined throughout, with
strong eye appeal and a minor reverse rotation of 10 degrees
counterclockwise. Early Draped Bust large cents in Choice
EF never go out of style, and we predict bidding on this lot
will back us up on this statement.
PCGS# 1470.
1157 1802 S-237. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A. AU Details—
Damage (PCGS). Overall smooth, predominantly medium
brown surfaces reveal outlines of bright pink color to most
of the devices, especially those on the reverse. A dig in the
upper left obverse field and another on the reverse at the
first S in STATES are noted.
PCGS# 36320.
1158 1803 S-256. Rarity-3. Noyes Die State C. Small Date, Small
Fraction. AU-50 (PCGS). This boldly defined piece exhibits
light, even, olive-gray toning with underlying pinkishorange also very much in evidence. With no outwardly
distracting blemishes, there is much to recommend this
coin to a high-grade circulated type collector. 1803 is known
as a date with numerous varieties. The Guide Book lists six
distinct varieties, mostly having to do with date and fraction
size. A large cent collection based onGuide Book varieties
is a challenge accepted by many collectors today, and the
present Choice AU coin would be a welcomed addition to
just such a set.
PCGS# 1482.
Page 27
1159 1803 S-260. Rarity-1. Small Date, Large Fraction. AU-55
(PCGS). This is a boldly defined, outwardly smooth, light
orange example that is sure to have no difficulty finding its
way into a high grade type, date, or variety set. In Choice
AU, as here, the supply of nice examples of the date — or
the type, for that matter — is thin and held closely by those
who own them. The present 1803 is choice for its surfaces
and color, and is certain to find a new cabinet without any
foreseeable difficulty, especially if past performances of AU55 Draped Bust large cents is any indicator.
PCGS# 1485.
1161 1804 S-266, the only known dies. Rarity-2. Noyes Die
State C. AU Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
Deep pink and steel blue toning dominate with highlights of
golden-tan on the reverse. The surfaces are uniformly rough
and detail is strong to bold throughout. Despite the obvious
issues this remains an attractive and desirable example,
particularly so with this level of detail. An important key
date large cent in any grade, the present specimen deserves
bidding attention when it enters the auction arena.
State C. Fine Details—Damaged (NGC). This evenly toned,
medium copper example retains bold definition to virtually
all major design elements. A bit rough overall, although the
only significant detractions are a pair of obverse digs before
and after the portrait. The 1804 ranks up there among large
cents as a date to be reckoned with for its elusive nature.
Pleasing examples of the date seem to be rarer than the
Rarity-2 listing, at least to our experience. Though some
distractions dot the surface of the present specimen, we still
imagine there will be premium bidding activity for this lot.
PCGS# 36422.
1160 1803 S-265. Rarity-4. Noyes Die State B. Large Date, Large
Fraction. AU-53 BN (NGC). This is the only die pairing of
the year with the Large Date, Large Fraction combination
which is a major variety designation in the Guide Book and
highly collected as such. Furthermore, this is one of the
finer examples seen of this die pairing and worthy of any
advanced collection. The surfaces are pleasing and offer a
deep mahogany brown hue that spans both sides. There
is a small area above the bust tip where a minor nick was
smoothed as well as a repaired rim bruise under the 3,
both features that are virtually undetectable. An important
offering and a coin with a solid provenance.
PCGS# 36413.
Ex: J.C. Morgenthau and Co auction of the Howard R. Newcomb Collection, Part I, February, 1945, lot 453; Leon Hendrickson; Jonathan
Kern; Tom Caldwell; Lillian Willins; Michael Kramer; our (Bowers and
Merena) auction of the Massachusetts Historical Society, November,
1994, lot 2059; Michael Kramer; Heritage, Orlando FUN Signature
Auction January, 1996, lot 5020; Superior’s Auction of the Dr. Wallace
Lee Collection, May, 2003, lot 532; Illinois Numismatic Association
Show, September, 2004; our (American Numismatic Rarities) auction
of the Drew St. John Collection, June, 2005; Heritage, Palm Beach Signature Auction, March, 2006, lot 88; Heritage, Summer FUN Auction,
July, 2013, lot 3038.
1163 1807 S-276. Rarity-1. Large Fraction. VF-25 (PCGS).
OGH. Medium brown with golden tan highlights on the
obverse and deeper red among the reverse. The surfaces
are primarily smooth with a few tiny specks of verdigris
noted on the reverse. Boldly defined at this grade level. An
exceptional example of the date and grade combination, and
a date that is represented by numerous varieties, of which
the five most popular are listed in the Guide Book.
PCGS# 1516.
1164 1812 S-290. Rarity-1. Small Date. AU Details—Smoothed
(PCGS). Uncommonly well-defined for an example of this
conditionally challenging type. Outwardly smooth, light
brown surfaces are also a strong suit for this more affordable
Classic Head cent. Take a good look at this one before
bidding judgment is passed.
PCGS# 1561.
1165 1817 N-6. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B/B. 13 Stars. AU-55
(PCGS). CAC. Lovely chestnut brown with variegated red
patina, the surfaces are fairly hard and glossy overall with no
serious blemishes. This is a wholesome and fully appealing
example of a popular type. All but one variety of 1817 large
cent has 13 stars — only N-16 has the oddball 15 star count.
Choice for the grade and an excellent selection for type coin
purposes.
PCGS# 1594.
1166 1817 N-14. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/C. 13 Stars. MS63 BN (NGC). Steely medium brown surfaces assume more
of a rose-brown appearance over much of the obverse.
Well struck for both the variety and die state, considerable
sharpness of detail is even noted for the central design
elements. Both sides are overall smooth with no significant
blemishes. The present coin would be an exciting addition
to a type set or large cent collection.
PCGS# 1594.
Page 28
1167 1818 N-10. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/B. MS-63 BN
(PCGS). Glossy surfaces are toned in a rich blend of deep
copper and pale lilac-rose. Sharply struck in and around the
centers, with surfaces that are uncommonly smooth given
the assigned grade. A pleasing collection of BN Mint State
large cents of the era is an admirable goal for a collecting
endeavor.
PCGS# 1600.
1168 1820 N-4. Rarity-4. Noyes Die State A/B. Small Date.
MS-63 BN (NGC). Slight mottling of golden-tan interrupts
otherwise even, glossy copper patina on both sides of
this piece. The surfaces are uncommonly smooth for the
assigned grade, and sharp striking detail to the central
design elements also provides superior eye appeal. This is a
tough die pairing to locate in upper grades and this example
is likely close to if not just in the Condition Census for
this variety. A prize for the advanced variety specialist that
should not be overlooked.
PCGS# 91615.
1171 1823 Unofficial Restrike. Copper. Noyes Die State I/E.
MS-64 BN (PCGS). CAC. Boldly defined with dominant
glossy copper patina, more direct angles also call forth
pretty pinkish-rose luster around the devices. Largely
free of post-production detractions, as befits the Choice
grade, with exceptional eye appeal for this popular restrike
type. A few faint carbon spots in the upper obverse field
should serve as useful pedigree markers. This interesting
“restrike” was mentioned in Breen’s 1988 Encyclopedia in
the following manner: “The 1823 was long believed scarce
enough in upper grades that when Joseph J. Mickley found
the broken original obverse die among scrap metal sold by
the Mint (1833), he and his friends eventually decided to
make restrikes, using an 1813 reverse from a similar source.”
This popular issue has long been associated with advanced
large cent holdings for decades.
PCGS# 81627.
1169 1821 N-2. Rarity-1. AU-58 (PCGS). Glossy copperrose surfaces reveal faint, yet discernible semi-reflective
tendencies in the fields as the coin rotates under a light. This
is a sharply struck example for the type, especially in and
around the centers, and there are no blemishes of note apart
from a dull, ancient contact mark on Liberty’s neck. Very
appealing for near-Mint survivor of this key date issue in the
early Matron Head cent series. As one of the tougher dates
in this series, high grade examples like this are always met
with strong demand when they appear on the market. There
simply are not enough nice examples to satisfy collector
demand. An outstanding example for the astute numismatic
buyer to acquire.
PCGS# 1621.
PCGS Population: 9; 8 are finer (Mint State-63 Brown finest) within the Brown Mint State
category.
From Heritage’s sale of the Jules Reiver Collection, Part I, January 2006,
lot 19826. Reiver acquired the coin from Garry Fitzgerald, November
1968.
1172 1824 N-3. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State B/A. MS-63 BN
(PCGS). CAC. Satiny in texture and free of detracting
abrasions, a few faint carbon spots are all that seem to
preclude an even higher Mint State rating. With suitably
bold detail and glints of original faded pink luster, this
otherwise lightly toned, tan-gray example is sure to please
the advanced collector of middle date large cents. This
is one of the tougher dates to locate from the 1820s and
especially so in high grades like this Choice Mint State coin.
The surfaces are a delight to examine and the satiny luster
is inviting to study. An impressive condition rarity this well
preserved and destined to represent this date or variety in an
advanced collection.
PCGS# 36772.
1170 1823 N-2. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State B/A. VF-30 (PCGS).
Original sandy-brown surfaces offer overall bold definition
and freedom from significant blemishes at the middle of the
numismatic grading scale. A problem free and thoroughly
satisfying example of this important key date large cent
issue. A wholesome and appealing coin that will please any
advanced variety specialist as well as any date collector who
is seeking this challenging condition rarity.
PCGS# 36757.
Page 29
1173 1826 N-4. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A/A. MS-64 RB
(PCGS). Plenty of vibrant, satiny, golden-orange luster
remains on both sides of this beautiful near-Gem. The
reverse is particularly praiseworthy in this regard, since
most of the glossy blue-brown toning that is present is on
the obverse. This is a crisp early die state example with bold
to sharp definition in most areas, and it is also exceptionally
well preserved with hardly even a trivial blemish in evidence.
In fact, were it not for two or three faint carbon spots on the
reverse this coin could easily have secured an MS-65 grade
from PCGS. Listed as tied for CC#2 in the Bland census and
a solid representative of this variety that will add depth to
any specialized variety set.
PCGS# 36821.
Ex: Elmer Sears; T. James Clarke; Ira & Larry Goldberg’s sale of the Ted
Naftzger Collection, Part II, February 2009, lot 172.
1175 1827 N-4. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A/A. MS-63 BN
(PCGS). This is a satiny, golden brown example with overall
smooth, tight surfaces. The strike is well centered and bold,
and a few tiny contact marks over and before the obverse
portrait seem to be the only impediment to an even higher
numeric grade. Tied with several as one of the top dozen of
this variety and appealing in all ways numismatic, especially
to a variety specialist seeking a high grade representative of
this die pairing.
PCGS# 1651.
1176 1835 N-6. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/B. Small 8 and
Stars. AU-58 (PCGS). Charming orange-brown surfaces
offer bold striking detail over and around the focal devices
in the centers. A swath of warmer medium brown bisects
the reverse, and a few other swirls of variegated toning are
also noted for the reverse periphery. A classic issue in a
classic collector grade.
PCGS# 37087.
1177 1835 N-16. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A/B. Head of 1836.
AU-58 BN (NGC). Pleasing medium brown with chestnut
undertones and hard, glossy surfaces. Light detritus in the
protected areas of the reverse attests to the coin’s originality,
and this is a wholesome and appealing example at the nearMint grade level. Choice for the grade and worthy of active
bidding pursuit.
PCGS# 1714.
1174 1826 N-6. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State C/B. MS-64 BN
(PCGS). Satiny steel-brown surfaces with a few faint,
generally well blended swirls or lavender-rose scattered
about. Sharply struck despite the advanced die state, this
fully Choice example is sure to have no difficulty finding its
way into another specialized large cent collection. Listed as
tied for #3 in Bland’s Census as MS-60+; tied for #5 in the
Noyes Census as MS-60. Impressive quality by all standards
and worthy of the most advanced middle date variety
collection.
PCGS# 36826.
From Ira & Larry Goldberg’s sale of the Ted Naftzger Collection, Part II,
February 2009, lot 179. Naftzger acquired the coin from Larry Whitlow,
via Jerry A. Bobbe, in April of 1976.
1178 1837 N-9. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B/A. Head of 1838.
MS-64 BN (NGC). Satiny golden-brown surfaces are
sharply struck over the focal features with none but a few
faint, easily forgiven blemishes. A handsome and appealing
example of this issue, which offers both a clean cheek on
Liberty as well as sharp curl definition. The reverse wreath
is crisply defined and the fields show the expected brown
luster. Close to the Gem level of preservation and a desirable
coin in all ways.
PCGS# 1729.
1179 1838 N-11. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State B/B. MS-64 BN
(PCGS). CAC. This is a handsome piece with subtle
golden-orange undertones to otherwise dominant glossy
brown patina. The die state is early enough that the central
devices are sharp and the denticles still show considerable
separation, although microscopic flowlining is discernible
with the aid of a loupe. Overall smooth and otherwise
full Gem in quality, an old, faint pin scratch in the upper
right reverse field (beginning at the final S in STATES) is
mentioned solely for accuracy. This example is one of the
finer ones seen and has an excellent pedigree to which the
lucky buyer can add their name.
PCGS# 37210.
Ex: Rod Burress, July 26, 987; March Wells; Superior’s sale of February
2000, lot 2049; Ira & Larry Goldberg’s sale of the Dan Holmes Collection, Part II, May 2010, lot 530.
Page 30
(PCGS). CAC. Considerable autumn orange luster remains
in the protected areas on both sides of this otherwise
originally toned, glossy brown and gray-brown example.
Sharply defined in the centers and outwardly smooth, this
beautiful near-Gem is sure to please the discerning copper
collector. While commonly seen as a die pairing, few are
found this well preserved and with such eye appeal.
PCGS# 1883.
1185 1852 N-22. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State D/B (N-9). MS-64
RD (PCGS). Brilliant mint red with satiny luster, choice
surfaces, and a razor-sharp strike. A wholly satisfying
example with exceptional eye appeal. Make no bones about
it, this one belongs in an advanced type set or large cent
cabinet.
PCGS# 147286.
From Ira & Larry Goldberg’s sale of the Ralls Collection, January 2014,
lot 874.
1181 1849 N-20. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B/B—Struck 40%
Off Center—VF-35 (PCGS). Choice smooth surfaces
display even medium brown toning with a substantial offcenter strike at 1 o’clock. Virtually all of Liberty’s portrait
is present, however, and the date and denomination are
also complete. A neat piece with strong visual appeal. This
exciting large cent error will be eagerly pursued by large cent
aficionados as well as error specialists.
PCGS# 1886.
1182 1850 N-7. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State C/C. MS-64 RB
(PCGS). CAC. Ample pale pink luster remains, especially
on the reverse, thereby confirming the appeal of this highgrade type candidate from the later Braided Hair cent series.
Boldly defined in and around the centers, with equally
original pale brown toning also very much in evidence.
Choice for the grade and certain to fit nicely into an
advanced type set or large cent collection.
PCGS# 1890.
1183 1851 N-2. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A/A. MS-64+ BN
(PCGS). Dominant glossy brown patina yields to areas of
original medium orange luster in the protected areas around
many of the devices. Definitely a premium quality piece
for the assigned grade, sharp central striking detail and
freedom from even trivial distractions are also praiseworthy
attributes. Choice for the grade with exceptional eye appeal.
1186 1852 N-22. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State D/C (N-9). MS-64
RB (PCGS). Plenty of original pale pink luster remains on
both sides of this minimally toned near-Gem. The outward
appearance of the strike is actually quite bold given the
advanced die state, and freedom from detracting blemishes
is another feature that is sure to endear this inviting piece to
the high grade type or date collector. Choice and appealing
in all respects.
PCGS# 1899.
(NGC). Mottled gray-brown iridescence allows much of
the original pale pink luster to shine forth from both sides.
Boldly, if not sharply defined in most areas, there is much
to recommend this coin to the Mint State type collector.
Choice and appealing and worthy of strong bidder pursuit.
PCGS# 1902.
(NGC). Iridescent rose-brown toning greets the viewer
from both sides, the surfaces also revealing faint remnants of
original pale pink luster as the coin dips into a light. Sharply
defined over virtually all design elements, this smooth and
attractive Gem is sure to excite the high-grade early copper
collector.
PCGS# 1905.
PCGS# 1892.
1184 1851 N-4. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B/B. Misplaced Date.
MS-64 BN (PCGS). CAC. A handsome and inviting piece,
both sides are evenly toned in warm copper-rose patina.
Boldly, if not sharply struck throughout, with surfaces that
are smooth enough to suggest an even higher numeric grade.
The base of an errant 1 can be seen in the space between the
5 and 1 of the date.
PCGS# 1892.
1189 1855 N-4. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A/A. Upright 5s. MS65+ BN (PCGS). CAC. Rich, even brown patina blankets
both sides of this appealing Gem, with red undertones
peeking through the patina. Sharply struck and lustrous, this
is an ideal candidate for a high-grade type set. Outstanding
quality to the forefront with this attractive Gem!
PCGS# 1907.
Page 31
Small Cents
1190 1857 Flying Eagle. MS-64 (PCGS). Vibrant satin surfaces
exhibit gorgeous pale pink highlights to otherwise light
tan patina. A sharp and inviting piece with the “look” of an
even higher grade. Mass production of the new small cent
design began in earnest in 1857 with a production run of
17,450,000 pieces. Many were put aside which made for
a ready source of attractive pieces such as this for today’s
collecting community.
PCGS# 2016.
1191 1859 MS-64 (PCGS). Boldly struck with scintillating tanorange luster, this delightful near-Gem is sure to have no
difficult finding its way into a high-grade type set. Struck
in the first year of J.B. Longacre’s Indian cent design type
and a one-year-only type coin. The reverse laurel wreath
was changed to an oak wreath and shield design in 1860 and
remained that way until the end of the type in 1909.
1196 1873 Close 3. MS-64+ RD (PCGS). CAC. With razorsharp striking detail in most areas and vivid rose-orange
luster throughout, this premium near-Gem is sure to please
even the most discerning Indian cent specialist. The present
beauty is the only “RD +” of the date certified by PCGS in
any grade.
PCGS# 2111.
PCGS# 2052.
1192 1859 MS-64 (NGC). With razor sharp devices and smooth,
satiny surfaces, this lovely tan-orange example is sure to
have no difficulty finding its way into a high grade type set.
From the first year of the Indian cent series, and a standalone type with a laurel wreath reverse — in 1860 the wreath
was redesigned to an oak wreath with a federal shield at its
top and remained that way through the demise of the type
in 1909.
PCGS# 2052.
1193 1865 Plain 5. Proof-65 RB (NGC). OH. Iridescent olivebrown toning allows ready appreciation of underlying
medium orange color, especially on the obverse. Both sides
are equally full in strike with a smooth, Gem-quality sheen.
The Guide Book suggest that “500+” Proofs of this early date
were struck, no doubt including those sold in sets as well
as single specimens made available to the public. Some of
the mintage may have been retained and melted at the Mint
owing to the lack of serious collectors and the coin hoarding
that was prevalent in the era.
PCGS# 2283.
1194 1869/69 Snow-3, FS-301. Repunched Date. MS-64
RB (PCGS). Endearing surfaces are fully original in a
combination of mottled olive-brown iridescence and deep,
rich, autumn orange luster. Fully struck, smooth, and of
even further desirability due to the popular RPD variety.
This popular variety was long considered to be an 1869/8
overdate.
PCGS# 37475.
1195 1872 Bold N. MS-63 BN (PCGS). Whereas the glossy
golden-brown obverse toning explains the BN designation
from PCGS, the reverse of this coin retains nearly complete
luster in dominant rose-orange color. Fully Select in quality,
with an uncommonly well-executed strike for the issue that
includes bold to sharp definition in all areas. More often
hasn’t not, this key date — just over four million struck — is
softly struck in areas, specially at the shield on the reverse.
The present piece is a welcomed escape from the usual for
the date.
1197 1877 Proof-64 BN (PCGS). Wonderfully original with rich
copper-rose patina, this razor sharp specimen also offers
freedom from detracting blemishes. Choice and Gem Proofs
of the date often take the place of the much rarer circulation
strike 1877 cents in advanced collections owing to the rarity
of the date in Choice and Gem Mint state.
PCGS# 2318.
From Superior’s sale of the Dr. Charles L. Ruby Collection, Part I, February 1974, lot 709. Lot tag included.
1198 1877 Proof. Unc Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
Fully struck with crisply denticulated borders, this no
questions Proof also offers extremely vivid, if curious,
toning in rose, powder blue, and reddish pink. The 1877
ranks as the undisputed key issue of the Indian cent series.
Certification service population data suggest to us that the
900-piece Mintage figure reported for Proofs in the Guide
Book is probably more accurate than other estimates that
place the Proof mintage as high as 1,500 pieces. Perspectives
may vary, but in the opinion of this cataloger (AWP),
certification data provide the best objective basis for
formulating an opinion.
PCGS# 2318.
1199 1877 AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS). With overall bold, if
not sharp definition, and rather pleasing retoning in deep
copper-rose, there is much to recommend this coin to a
budge-minded Indian cent collector. The hands-down key
date of the series, the 1877 never fails to elicit strong bids
whatever the grade. Worth a good look from prospective
bidders.
PCGS# 2127.
PCGS# 2103.
From Superior’s sale of the Charles L. Ruby Collection, Part I, February
1974. Lot tag included.
Page 32
1200 1877 EF-40 BN (NGC). Handsome, fully original toning
in deep copper greets the viewer from both sides of this
attractive and problem-free EF. Though desirable in any
grade — depending on the buyer’s pocketbook — at EF
the 1877 is heavily pursued by collectors. An EF example
of the date is something to take pride in, and a cut above
the typical well-worn specimen found in so many of today’s
collections.
1206 1909-S Indian. MS-64 BN (NGC). Lovely golden-copper
patina blankets both sides of this smooth, satiny near-Gem.
When more than one Mint State 1909-S Indian cent is
offered, as in the current sale, our bidders take notice.
PCGS# 2238.
PCGS# 2127.
1201 1877 Net VF-30 (ANACS). AU Details—Obverse Tooled,
Corroded, Cleaned. OH. Offering sharp definition for a
more modest sum, this minimally circulated key date coin is
sure to be of interest to a great many Indian cent collectors.
Both sides are retoned rather nicely in blended medium
copper and sandy-orange.
PCGS# 2127.
1202 1880 Proof-66 RB (PCGS). CAC. This is a simply gorgeous
specimen with silky smooth surfaces and extremely vivid
deep rose color greeting the viewer from both sides. Worthy
of a close look as well as a premium bid. An absolutely
superb example of this popular date.
PCGS# 2328.
1203 1902 Snow-4, FS-401. Die Gouge. MS-64 RB (PCGS).
Eagle Eye Photo Seal. Wonderfully original autumn
orange surfaces exhibit a smooth, softly frosted texture.
Predominantly blemish free, this lovely piece is suggestive of
a full Gem rating. A heavy gouge in the die resulted in a fairly
noticeable raised flaw near the corner of the Indian’s eye on
this elusive and popular variety. Snow-4 is only occasionally
cherrypicked by alert specialists, and Mint State pieces such
as this never fail to bring out the bidders.
PCGS# 412774.
1204 1905 Proof-66 RB (PCGS). A beautiful specimen with
undeniable originality. Both sides are sharply struck
throughout with uniform reflectivity to the finish. The
obverse is aglow in vivid gold and autumn orange colors,
while the reverse is more boldly toned in deep olive-rose. As
pretty as the proverbial picture.
PCGS# 2403.
1207 Virtually Complete Set of Matte Proof Lincoln Cents,
1909-1916. (PCGS). The coins are individually graded and
encapsulated by PCGS, as follows:
1909 Proof-64 RD (PCGS). This vivid specimen exhibit
smooth, bright orange surfaces that are free of detracting
blemishes.
1910 Proof-64 RD (PCGS). Charming rose-orange
color blankets both sides, the reverse a bit bold than the
obverse. A fully struck and smooth looking near-Gem.
1911 Proof-64 RB (PCGS). Plenty of original medium
rose color shines through gray-brown iridescence as the
surfaces rotate under a light.
1912 Proof-64 RD (PCGS). A few well scattered carbon
flecks are all that seem to preclude a full Gem rating for
this bright rose-orange specimen.
1913 Proof-65 RB (PCGS). Fully struck copper-rose
surfaces are expectably blemish free at the assigned grade
level.
1914 Proof-65 RB (PCGS). This bright, satiny specimen
exhibits lovely color in a predominantly golden-pink
shade.
1205 1909-S Indian. MS-65 RD (PCGS). Satiny and expectably
well preserved at the Gem grade level, this otherwise
orange-gold example reveals a blush of equally attractive
medium rose color in the center of the reverse. Sharply
struck throughout, and appealing in all regards. A scarce
and popular key date from the final year of the Indian cent
series. Only 309,000 examples were struck before the cent
presses were turned over to the new 1909-S V.D.B. design
type. The mintage for the date is the lowest of any circulation
strike mintage in the series, 1859 through 1909.
PCGS# 2240.
1915 Proof. Unc Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
Exceptionally appealing despite the stated impairment,
this is a smooth, distraction free piece with handsome
rose-brown color.
1916 Proof-64 RB (PCGS). This is a smartly impressed
specimen with dominant medium rose color and only
a single, tiny carbon spot in the right obverse field
precluding an even higher grade.
Also included in this lot is a 1909 V.D.B. MS-63 BN
(PCGS), which was cataloged as a Proof when offered
alongside the balance of the coins in this lot when sold by
Superior in 1974. Despite the earlier Proof designation of
this 1909 V.D.B., it is being offered in this lot strictly as
currently certified by PCGS, i.e., MS-63 BN.(Total: 9 coins)
From Superior’s sale of the Dr. Charles L. Ruby Collection, Part I, February 1974, lot 742.
Page 33
Outstanding 1909-S V.D.B. Cent
1208 1909-S Lincoln. V.D.B. MS-66 RD (PCGS). Secure Holder. Exquisite orange-gold surfaces are awash in full, billowy satin to softly
frosted luster. Fully struck, as befits the issue, with hardly even a trivial blemish in evidence. Arguably one of the most famous and
popular of all small cent issues, the 1909-S V.D.B. is one of “those” dates that collectors cherish in any and all grades. At the grand
Mint State level offered here, all the stops will be pulled and the bidding will be fast and steady.
PCGS# 2428.
1209 1909-S Lincoln. V.D.B. MS-64 RB (PCGS). Vibrant pale
gold luster mingles with original glossy brown iridescence
to create a picture of numismatic originality in an early
date Lincoln cent. Fully struck with silky smooth surfaces
as well, this key date example is sure to see spirited bidding
activity. Easily one of the best-known and most desirable of
all small cent issues — even non-collectors know the fame
and desirability of the issue.
PCGS# 2427.
From our (Stack’s) sale of the Winter Collection, January-February
1974, lot 1674. Lot tag included.
1210 1909-S Lincoln. V.D.B. MS-64 RB (NGC). Even pale
orange surfaces also reveal subtle light brown toning
highlights as the coin rotates under a light. With a full strike
and freedom from detracting blemishes, this is an enticing
Choice example of the ever popular ‘09-S V.D.B. cent.
1213 1909-S Lincoln. V.D.B. AU Details—Questionable Color
(PCGS). Boldly struck and free of detracting blemishes, the
surfaces are a bit glossy in texture, although they have been
retoned quite nicely in warm olive-tan. The 1909-S V.D.B. is
possibly the single most popular issue in the entire panoply
of American numismatics. Every child who has ever tried
to fill out a penny-board — or more recently a Whitman
Lincoln cent folder — has dreamed of finding an example in
change, something that may have been a realistic possibility
as recently as the 1930s.
PCGS# 2426.
PCGS# 2427.
1211 1909-S Lincoln. V.D.B. MS-63 RB (NGC). Warmly toned
in a blend of rose and orange, the obverse contrasts with
a near-fully lustrous golden-orange reverse. Both sides are
sharply impressed with smooth enough features to suggest
a Choice Mint State grade. It is difficult to imagine a more
collector-compatible date and grade combination for this
popular scarcity than that offered here.
PCGS# 2427.
1212 1909-S Lincoln. V.D.B. MS-63 BN (NGC). Soft satin luster
mingles with wonderfully original golden-brown and roseorange colors on both sides of this endearing ‘09-S V.D.B.
cent. The present piece at MS-63 represents the perfect
blend of desirability and grade to many bidders.
1214 1909-S/S Lincoln. FS-1502. S/Horizontal S. MS-66 RD
(PCGS). Frosty light orange surfaces are fully struck,
expertly preserved, and as attractive as only a Gem fully red
‘09-S Lincoln cent can be. A popular repunched mintmark
variety from the first year of the Lincoln cent series. Lovely,
and certain to impress our bidders.
PCGS# 37645.
PCGS# 2426.
Page 34
Condition Census
1943-D/D Cent
1215 1913-D MS-65 RD (PCGS). CAC. Splendid rose-orange
surfaces retain full, satiny luster in the absence of both
toning and detracting blemishes. An entirely engaging Gem
Lincoln cent from the early years of Denver Mint coinage in
the denomination.
PCGS# 2464.
1216 1914-D MS-64 RB (PCGS). Lovely rose-brown surfaces
exhibit an even blend of light toning and original luster.
Sharply struck and overall smooth, this coin makes a lovely
impression in all regards. Though perhaps only Lincoln cent
specialists know this, but the 1914-D becomes the key date
in the series once the Choice Mint State grade level comes
into play, eclipsing even the 1909-S V.D.B. as this Denver
Mint issue climbs up the grading charts.
1219 1943-D/D FS-501. Repunched Mintmark. MS-67
(PCGS). CAC. This virtually pristine Superb Gem
exhibits smooth, satiny surfaces that allow ready
appreciation of razor sharp devices. One of the most
prized Lincoln cent RPMs, the 1943-D/D has only
comparatively recently been recognized by specialists.
Readily available in lower grades, it becomes a serious
challenge in the Gem category, with this specimen at
the zenith of the PCGS Population Report. A prime
candidate for a Registry Set or a high grade Lincoln
specialist’s cabinet.
PCGS# 2715.
PCGS Population: 7; 0 finer.
PCGS# 2472.
From Paramount’s sale of May 1971, lot 1083. Lot tag included.
1217 1924 MS-66 RD (PCGS). Frosty in texture with incredible
vividness, the toning that blankets both sides includes
shades of red, rose, salmon pink and golden-orange. With a
sharp strike and expertly preserved surfaces, it is difficult for
us to imagine a more desirable 1924 cent in a premium Gem
holder. It is worth noting that fewer than 10 RD examples
of the date have been graded finer than the present Gem by
PCGS.
1220 1944-D/S FS-512. MS-65 RD (PCGS). CAC. This is a very
pretty Gem with fully original pink and rose-orange luster
blanketing sharply impressed features. Easily among the
most famous and sought-after overmintmark varieties in
U.S. coinage, especially so when seen in Gem RD grade as
here.
PCGS# 37837.
PCGS# 2551.
1218 1928-S FS-501. Large S. MS-64 RD (PCGS). Pretty roseorange luster blankets both sides in a satiny and inviting
texture. Well struck for a 1920s cent from the San Francisco
Mint, and just a few faint carbon flecks away from an even
higher grade. A pleasing specimen to the unaided eye. There
are also Large and Small S varieties of the date in the Liberty
Standing quarter series; the four issues, two cents and two
quarters, would make for an interesting type set.
PCGS# 37708.
1221 1955 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. MS-64+ RB (NGC).
CAC. Lustrous lilac-rose surfaces also retain ample original
luster in a medium orange color. A handsome piece that is
knocking on the door of a full Gem grade.
PCGS# 2826.
Page 35
1225 1955 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. MS-62 BN (PCGS).
Handsome antique copper surfaces are richly and evenly
toned over boldly impressed features. Uncommonly smooth
for the assigned grade, there are no detracting abrasions,
carbon flecks or other blemishes to report. This one had
nearly everyone looking through pocket change in the
mid-1950s, not just coin collectors. The fame of the issue
was spread on the backs of comic books of the era and by
word of mouth until seemingly everyone knew of the little
“double stamped” Lincoln cent error.
Deep, rich, golden-copper patina greets the viewer from
both sides of this undeniably original example. Were it not
for a few faint carbon flecks in the upper right obverse field,
this coin would almost certainly have secured a Choice Mint
State grade. It’s always a pleasure to offer more than one Mint
State example of this perennial favorite among collectors.
PCGS# 2825.
PCGS# 2825.
Attractively toned in blended medium tan, light brown and
pale gold, this sharp and inviting piece is smooth enough to
suggest a higher Mint State grade. The 1955 Doubled Die
became a favorite with collectors within a few years of the
time that it was first discovered. When Walter Breen wrote
his Complete Encyclopedia in 1988 he estimated that mintage
of the variety exceeded 20,000 pieces. Population statistic
published by the two major certification services suggest that
the extant population is probably only in the 6,000 to 8,000
pieces range. Most Double Dies grade AU or better indicating
that the vast majority were plucked from circulation within
months of having been issued. The median grade for the
variety is probably AU-58 or thereabouts.
PCGS# 2825.
Rich tobacco brown patina blankets both sides of this boldly
impressed, overall smooth piece. A few swirls of variegated
toning notwithstanding, this coin has the appearance of an
even higher numeric grade. Another of the issues in the
“most popular” small cents category, and another Lincoln
cent that is nearly as familiar to non-collectors as it is to
numismatists. A solid grade and value combination for your
consideration.
PCGS# 2825.
1227 1955 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. AU-50 (PCGS). OGH.
Boldly defined with no outwardly distracting blemishes, this
smooth-looking AU also exudes originality in the form of
blended copper-rose and golden-brown toning. Choice for
the grade and ideally suited to a collector who can’t stretch
the budget far enough to obtain a Mint State coin.
PCGS# 2825.
1228 1955 FS-101, Breen-2214. Doubled Die Obverse. Net AU50 (ANACS). AU Details—Cleaned. OH. Boldly defined
with relatively appealing rose-orange color. Uncommon
brightness and light hairlining to the surfaces point to
a cleaning. Still, a perfectly viable filler example of this
popular scarcity.
PCGS# 37190.
1229 1955 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. Net EF-40 (ANACS).
AU Details—Whizzed, Lacquered. OH. This bright,
medium orange example offers sharp to full striking
definition for a more modest sum.
PCGS# 37910.
1224 1955 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. MS-63 BN (NGC).
This handsomely toned, antique copper example exhibits
bold to sharp striking detail throughout the design. A few
streaks of faint olive tinting over the lower reverse and
several tiny carbon flecks in the right obverse field do little
more than define the Select Mint State grade from NGC.
The present Uncirculated example represents one of several
opportunities in this sale to acquire an example of this
popular issue.
PCGS# 2825.
1230 1958 MS-67 RD (PCGS). Vibrant, lustrous, satin textured
surfaces are exceptionally well preserved with nary a
distracting blemish in evidence. As nice as this date and
mint can readily be obtained, and a perfect coin for the
Registry Set specialist of this series.
PCGS# 2848.
PCGS Population: 32; just 1 finer in MS-67+ RD.
Page 36
1231 1972 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. MS-66 RD (PCGS).
CAC. Secure Holder. Delightful medium rose surfaces are
fully struck, highly lustrous, and free of even the most trivial
blemishes. As nice, if not nicer, than any Gem full Red
1972 DDO cent that we have offered in recent years. This
popular variety caused a stir in the numismatic community
when first discovered, and its popularity among small cent
specialists is secure today, more than 40 years later.
PCGS# 2950.
Two-Cent Pieces
1232 1865 Plain 5. Proof-65 RB (PCGS). OGH. A charming
piece, original pink, rose and orange undertones shine
through an overlay of mottled olive-brown and golden-olive
iridescence. This piece is fully struck, carefully preserved
and expectably attractive at the Gem grade level. The Guide
Book lists a Proof mintage for the date of “500+” pieces.
PCGS# 3628.
1235 1872 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. MS-65+ BN (NGC).
Intense glossy copper patina dominates the outward
appearance, although both sides also reveal intermingled
rose, red, orange, and antique gold colors as the coin rotates
under a light. A smartly impressed, silky smooth Gem that
is sure to appeal to the advanced two-cent piece collector.
From the final year of circulation strike coinage in the
denomination, and one of just 65,000 pieces struck for that
purpose. Undeniably choice for the grade.
PCGS# 38292.
1233 1866 MS-66 RB (PCGS). Vivid rose and light orange luster
shines forth powerfully through an overlay of light, mottled,
iridescent copper toning. A sharply struck and expertly
preserved piece that would accept nothing less than a
premium Gem grade. Just three years into the denomination
and already the mintage figures told of the impending demise
of this odd-denomination bronze coinage. The mintage for
the date of nearly 3.2 million pieces was down more than 10
million from the 1865 mintage, and the annual tallies would
continue to diminish in the series.
PCGS# 3589.
1234 1872 Proof-66 BN (NGC). Glossy copper toning mingles
with original, albeit subdued color in pinkish-rose to
provide a picture of numismatic originality. A smartly
impressed, expertly preserved survivor from this popular
year in two-cent piece production. From a Guide Book
estimate of “950+” Proofs of the date
1236 1872 MS-63 BN (PCGS). CAC. Richly toned in bold
antique copper, this smartly impressed and outwardly
smooth piece is certainly at the upper reaches of the Select
Mint State grade level. A pleasing survivor from a modest
mintage of just 65,000 pieces.
PCGS# 3612.
1237 1872 EF-40 (PCGS). Variegated shades of deep copper
and brown blend over both sides of this boldly defined and
smooth looking EF. One of just 65,000 examples of the date
struck for circulation, produced in the final year of such
coinage. In 1873 only Proofs were struck; the series ended
in that year.
PCGS# 3612.
PCGS# 3648.
1238 1873 Close 3. Proof-65 RB (NGC). Otherwise toned in
pretty glossy copper, this originally and carefully preserved
Gem reveals pale orange and lilac-rose undertones as the
surfaces dip into a light. One of an estimated 600 examples
struck of this Proof-only end-all to this short-lived series.
Choice for the grade and sure to please.
PCGS# 3652.
Page 37
Nickel Three-Cent Pieces
1239 1873 Open 3. Proof-64 BN (PCGS). OGH. Bold copper
brown patina blankets both sides, the surfaces of which
are uncommonly smooth even at the Choice grade level.
Sharply struck and thoroughly original, a bit more vibrancy
to the finish seems to be all that this coin would have needed
to secure an even higher numeric grade. From an unknown
quantity of this Proof-only date struck after the Close 3
Proofs of the date; the Open 3 style offered here is generally
referred to as the “restrike” of the date.
PCGS# 3654.
Silver Three-Cent Pieces
1240 1862/1 FS-301. MS-66 (PCGS). CAC. Splendid satin
surfaces are silky smooth in texture with no toning apart
from the lightest pale gold highlights in isolated peripheral
areas. Really a beautiful example. Scarcely more than 25%
of the 1862 circulation strikes certified by PCGS are the
Overdate variety. The 1862/1 is scarce at the MS-66 level and
rare finer.
1243 1865 Proof-66 (NGC). CAC. Exquisite golden tinged surfaces
are so smooth as to suggest an even higher numeric grade.
More direct angles also call forth modest cameo contrast
between the fields and devices, which serve to further enhance
already memorable eye appeal. Combined certification
service population data suggest that the Proof mintage figure
of 500 pieces listed in the Guide Book closely approximates the
actual number issued. By inference, it is reasonable to suppose
that the Proof mintage for nickel coins was the same as that
for silver coins during the year. Only a few dozen examples
grading Proof-66 or finer can be accounted for today.
PCGS# 3761.
PCGS# 3681.
1244 1877 Proof-64 (PCGS). OGH. This lightly and evenly
toned, golden-gray specimen exhibits a smooth, satiny
texture that is suggestive of a full Gem rating. The 1877
ranks as the undisputed key issue of the design type; only
900 Proofs were issued for the benefit of coin collectors —
no business strikes were produced during the year.
1241 1865 Proof-66 (NGC). OH. Richly original, expertly
preserved surfaces are awash in iridescent charcoal gray
patina. More direct angles allow ready appreciation of a well
mirrored finish, as well as more vivid gold and pale blue
undertones. The 1865 is a desirable date having a mintage
of just 500 Proofs together with a scant 8,000 circulation
strikes. Only a few dozen survivors grading Proof-66
or finer can be accounted for today. The median grade is
probably about Proof-64.
PCGS# 3773.
PCGS# 3715.
1242 1871 Proof-64 (PCGS). CAC. Exceptionally bright with
electric teal, rose and gold toning, the colors arranged in
nearly perfect concentric peripheral rings on the reverse.
Boldly struck, beautiful and definitely choice for the grade.
A very scarce date consisting of 960 Proofs together with
3,400 circulation strikes. Combined certification service
statistics suggest that perhaps only 500 to 700 Proofs still
exist.
PCGS# 3722.
From Ira and Larry Goldberg’s sale of the Benson Collection, Part II,
February 2002, lot 161.
1245 1881 Proof-68 H (NGC). Beautiful target toning in
multicolored pastel iridescence blankets the reverse but
is tightly confined to the periphery on the obverse. Both
sides are equally attractive, and the technical quality is also
superb in every way. Although a mintage of 3,575 Proofs
was claimed in government reports for the year, current
population data suggests that a smaller number was actually
distributed, perhaps in the range of 2,200 to 2,800 pieces.
Scarcely more than 2% of the Proof 1881 three-cent pieces
certified by NGC grade Proof-68; there are none at the MS69 and MS-70 levels.
PCGS# 3777.
NGC Census: 3; none finer (star designation only, including Cameos and Deep Cameos).
Page 38
Nickel Five-Cent Pieces
Amazing Cameo Proof 1867
No Rays Nickel Struck with Pattern Reverse
1246 1867 No Rays. Pattern Reverse. Proof-66 Cameo (PCGS). Delightful champagne-gold iridescence drifts over both sides of this
vibrant and highly reflective Gem. Razor sharp strike, with good contrast between the fields and devices that readily upholds the
validity of the CAM designation from PCGS. Only a handful of these are known currently, and doubtless not many more will be
discovered as the reverse is easy to identify. On this particular coin, the stars point between the letters EN and TS of CENTS while
on the regular issue No Rays Proofs the stars point down the upright posts of E and T of that word. It is the location of the reverse
stars that confirms this dies prior use to strike some of the pattern issues of the Shield nickel series. Apparently the Proof die was in
good condition after making the rare Pattern coins, and the coiner determined that is was suitable to make additional Proof coins,
these of the regular issue coins to be sold to collectors. No one noticed these rare mulings of a regular Proof die with a Pattern
reverse die until recently, and research through prior offerings found very few of these exist. As this important die variety becomes
more publicized the demand will certainly exceed the meager supply. Here is what is likely the finest example of this issue known,
and one that would make a major step forward for even the most advanced specialist of this series.
PCGS# 519407.
PCGS Population: just 1; none are finer in the Cameo category, and there are no DCAMs certified for the variety.
1247 1867 No Rays. Proof-66 Cameo (PCGS). Adorned
with delicate champagne-apricot iridescence, this fully
impressed and boldly cameoed specimen is solidly graded
as a premium quality Gem. The estimated mintage for
this issue by CoinFacts is 600 pieces, and the present coin
is one of the absolute finest seen for the No Rays design
type. A powerful example that will enhance any advanced
collection, especially one focused on the Shield nickel series.
PCGS# 83821.
PCGS Population: 11; none finer within the Cameo Proof designation.
From the Just Having Fun Collection.
1248 1869 MS-67 (NGC). Bright, satiny surfaces are free of both
appreciable toning and grade limiting abrasions. As the
Philadelphia Mint began to catch up to demand for these
still new copper-nickel Shield five-cent coins, production
finally slowed in 1869 to a little more than half the numbers
seen in the prior year. As expected, not quite so many of
the 1869 issue came down to us today in such superlative
grades, but here is one of the absolute finest which is certain
to add considerable attention to any collection that possess
this quality. An extraordinary opportunity to secure a classic
condition rarity.
PCGS# 3796.
NGC Census: only 3; none finer. The finest example of the issue known to PCGS is graded
MS-66+.
Page 39
1249 1870 Proof-66+ Cameo (PCGS). Brilliant, fully stuck
and possessed of superb eye appeal, it is difficult for us
to imagine a more desirable example of this Proof Shield
nickel issue with regards to both technical quality and
visual appeal. The PCGS Population Report notes that about
twenty percent of the Proofs certified for this date qualify
as having Cameo contrast, although to date there are no
Deep Cameo examples graded. With relatively bold contrast
and impeccably preserved features, it is little wonder that
this beautiful specimen is among the most highly regarded
Proof 1870 nickels ever to pass through the graders’ hands
at PCGS.
PCGS# 83824.
PCGS Population: just 3 with a CAM designation; none are finer in any category.
1251 1871 Proof-66+ Deep Cameo (PCGS). CAC. Bright
and brilliant surfaces are aglow with satiny devices and
deeply reflective fields. Fully struck and expertly preserved
throughout, this lovely premium Gem makes a strong visual
impression. The year 1871 saw a major reduction in the
regular issue mintage of circulation strike Shield nickels.
Proofs were struck in similar numbers to both the prior
and subsequent years, however, although exactly what
the original mintage amounted to remains somewhat of
a mystery since the Mint did not keep specific records on
Proof minor coin production during this period. Among
the surviving examples this delightful specimen stands tall,
ranking as it does as the only DCAM specimen known to
PCGS, as well as one of the highest graded for the date in all
categories.
PCGS# 93825.
PCGS Population: just 1 in all grades with a DCAM designation.
1250 1870 MS-66 (PCGS). The surfaces display light silver and
gray iridescence and are very attractive. Rarely are these
early Shield nickels seen with such bold visual appeal.
The mintage of this particular date fell considerably from
previous years, coming in at 4,806,000 pieces. Accordingly,
the number of Mint State survivors is much lower than noted
in previous years, and this trend will stabilize and continue
until 1882 when the reported numbers again increase to
levels seen in the initial years of this series. Pattern issues
for this copper-nickel design also settled down with none
produced beyond the off-metal strikings of this period,
but using regular coinage dies. Silver, and other metallic
trials of half dimes, were issued in considerable variation in
1870, so the focus of the Mint seemed to drift toward that
particular issue of this denomination, while these relatively
new copper-nickel Shield five-cent coins began to settle into
circulation.
1252 1871 Proof-66+ Cameo (PCGS). CAC. This is a bright,
brilliant and absolutely stunning example of both the issue
and the type. Condition rarities in the Shield nickel series
are gaining in both recognition and desirability among
advanced collectors, and this truly exceptional Proof 1871
would serve as a centerpiece in any cabinet.
PCGS# 83825.
PCGS Population: just 4; none finer within the Cameo designation.
PCGS# 3797.
PCGS Population: just 10; and none are finer.
Page 40
1253 1872 Proof-67 Cameo (PCGS). This radiant specimen with
golden iridescence reveals strong cameo contrast between
the fields and devices. Both the technical quality and eye
appeal readily uphold the Superb Gem rating from PCGS.
A relatively modest coinage of circulation strike Shield
nickels is noted for this particular year, as this denomination
continued to circulate alongside various fractional and
postage currency which formed a somewhat distasteful stew
of various monetary types in circulation throughout most
of the country. This fact would not be resolved easily, and
continued to varying degrees until the end of the decade. In
particular, few silver coins were seen or offered in normal
purchase transactions in the East throughout the late 1860s
and early 1870s. Collectors of the day set aside a few of these
Proof Shield nickels, this one certainly one of the absolute
finest known today. Indeed, most Proofs of this type fall well
short of the technical quality retained here.
1255 1874 Proof-67 Cameo (PCGS). Pristine satin surfaces are
free of even the most trivial blemishes. One of the finest
and most stunning high quality specimens known with
the Cameo contrast, and destined for the most advanced
collection of this series, the strike, color and surfaces are all
as perfect as one could hope to find in a Proof 1874 nickel.
The Cameo contrast simply adds to the already immense
appeal. Simply put, this condition rarity should not be
overlooked by anyone serious about assembling the finest
Proof Shield nickel collection.
PCGS# 83828.
PCGS Population: just 2; none finer within the Cameo designation.
PCGS# 83826.
PCGS Population: just three with the Cameo designation; and none are finer in any category.
There are no DCAM examples of this date certified.
1254 1873 Open 3. MS-66 (PCGS). CAC. Smooth, brilliant
surfaces are drenched in vibrant satin luster. There is a bit
of toning present, namely a blush of pale gold along the left
obverse border, and this piece is fully struck and attractive
in all regards. Here is another condition rarity even at the
Gem grade level, as these early Shield style nickels seldom
survived this well preserved. As more and more collectors
seek examples, there simply won’t be enough to go around,
keeping collecting pressure highest on examples like this
glorious premium Gem.In the normal course of events,
the dies for each denomination were prepared in late 1872
and coin production began as normal in early January
1873. However, examination of the date punches used on
most of the dies that year were determined to be faulty. The
ponderous knobs of the 3, and long accented arms, gave the
appearance of an 8 instead of the desired 3. The Open 3 date
logotype was thus adopted in late January 1873 and all new
obverse dies were prepared for the various denominations
as needed. Hence the Close 3 variety of this year is often
quite scarce as they were only issued for part of January,
1873. Collectors have long considered owning examples
of both the Close and Open 3 varieties as a prerequisite for
forming a complete collection.
1256 1874 Proof-66 Deep Cameo (PCGS). A blush or two of faint
golden iridescence can be seen on this essentially brilliant
specimen, with strong field to device contrast dominating
the outward appearance. This is a true condition rarity in
every since of the word, being the only Deep Cameo Proof
1874 nickel certified by PCGS, and a premium quality
Gem at that. These Deep Cameo coins are clearly the most
dramatic and eye appealing of the early Proof nickel five-cent
pieces, with the most in depth contrast between the highly
polished mirror fields and satin to frosty devices. During
the 1870s only a handful of specimens emerged from the
dies with such contract, likely early in the production run of
Proofs when the dies retained their greatest degree of polish
and were thus able to impart such spectacular contrast and
depth.Certified population data suggests that the 1874 is
the seventh rarest of the 20 popularly identified Proof issues
(counting the Rays and No Rays variants, as well as the
1878/9, as separate issues) in the Shield nickel series.
PCGS# 93828.
PCGS Population: just 1 in all grades with a DCAM designation.
PCGS# 3800.
PCGS Population: just 7; with a mere two finer graded MS-66+.
Page 41
1258 1875 Proof-65 Cameo (NGC). Brilliant and beautiful, this
snappy Gem combines watery fields with satiny, razor sharp
devices. An undeniable Cameo Proof striking of this, our
nation’s premier regular-issue nickel five-cent design. One
of somewhat more than 700 Proofs of the date produced.
PCGS# 22269.
1257 1874 MS-66+ (PCGS). CAC. Brilliant save for the lightest
golden toning that is largely confined to the obverse, this
lovely premium Gem is fully lustrous with a smooth, satiny
texture on both sides. Both the technical quality and eye
appeal are suggestive of an even higher grade. This issue is a
true condition rarity at any grade above the basal Gem level.
The original mintage exceeded 3.5 million pieces, but of
course most entered circulation with little fanfare and were
considered simply “small change” by most contemporary
Americans. However, a few escaped the economic demands
of circulation and have come down to us today in Gem or
finer condition. Here is an important condition rarity that
should not be overlooked by any serious specialist of the
Shield nickel series.The 1874 issue is the third rarest Shield
nickel at the grade of MS-66 or finer, nudged out only by
the key date 1880 and the 1873 Close 3 variety. The astute
numismatist, therefore, would do well to put this condition
rarity away as most other issues are more readily available.
This is truly an exceptional coin that will be a major highlight
of any advanced Shield nickel collection.
PCGS# 3803.
PCGS Population: only 1; none finer.
1259 1875 MS-66 (PCGS). Bursting with intense satin to softly
frosted luster, this brilliant Gem displays no significant
blemishes. As seen quite often on circulation strike nickels
of this type, the peripheries on both sides reveal numerous
spindly die cracks (as struck) that are more prevalent on
the obverse. This is a slightly scarcer date with the recorded
mintage for circulation strikes of just over two million
pieces. Even so, Mint State coins are obtainable with relative
ease through the MS-65 level, although in MS-66 the 1875
develops into an important condition. Indeed, the present
example is numbered among the handful of finest known
survivors, and its inclusion cannot help but to enhance the
importance of any specialized Shield nickel collection.
PCGS# 3804.
PCGS Population: 11; none finer.
PCGS Population: only 1; and none are finer in any category.
Superb Deep Cameo Proof 1876 Nickel
1260 1876 Proof-67 Deep Cameo (PCGS). This is a simply outstanding example of both the issue and the type. The fields are extremely
reflective and form a splendid backdrop to satiny, razor sharp devices. Free of all but the lightest silvery-gold toning, the surfaces
are virtually pristine. The year 1876 is an extremely popular one among numismatic collectors since it marks the centennial for
United States independence. It is likely that the Mint received more orders than usual among contemporary Americans given the
historical significance of this year, although fewer specimens were preserved when compared with other dates in the Proof Shield
nickel series. A number of 1876 Proofs exhibit Cameo contrast, in keeping with the high quality production techniques employed
by the Philadelphia Mint during the 1870s, but only a tiny percentage of survivors possess enough field to device contrast to support
a Deep Cameo designation. When it comes to technical quality and eye appeal, it simply doesn’t get any better than this in a Proof
1876 nickel.
PCGS# 93830.
Page 42
The Childs-JHF Specimen of the
Proof-Only 1877 Shield Nickel
1261 1877 Proof-67 Cameo (PCGS). Delectable bright silver surfaces are as fresh and inviting as the day the coin emerged from the dies.
The estimated mintage has been revised to 900 pieces for this Proof-only date, and from that issue only approximately 575 examples
are known today (according to the numismatic experts at CoinFacts). The present coin is tied with at most five others as the finest
seen by PCGS with the Cameo contrast, and as such has legitimate claim to the title of finest known 1877 Shield nickel.By 1877,
the Redemption Act of 1871 and Coinage Act of 1873 had the combined effect of causing small denomination copper and nickel
coinage to pile up in Treasury vaults, as well as in the holdings of the Post Office and transportation lines in various major cities.
Banks did not want these small coins, and the average citizen had more than enough pieces for their own personal needs. Thus the
Mint limited coinage of 1877 Shield nickels to Proofs struck solely for distribution to contemporary collectors; none were issued
for circulation. The 1877 nickel three-cent piece is also a Proof-only affair, and the 1877 Indian cent saw a limited circulation strike
mintage of just 852,500 pieces — the lowest yearly production for this denomination recorded since 1823! The 1870s was certainly
a trying decade for the United States Mint, and few coins could better represent these tumultuous times than a Proof 1877 Shield
nickel such as the expertly preserved and impressively pedigreed specimen offered here.
PCGS# 83831.
PCGS Population: just 6; none are finer in any category, and there are no DCAM specimens certified in any grade.
From the Just Having Fun Collection. Earlier from our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of the Walter H. Childs Collection, August 1999, lot 114. Acquired directly
from the Mint by Walter H. Childs.
A Second Exceptional Proof 1877 Shield Nickel
1262 1877 Proof-67 Cameo (PCGS). Outstanding surfaces display a bright, golden tinged appearance. A second opportunity for the
astute, quality conscious collector to acquire an example of this popular and elusive Proof-only issue in the Shield nickel series of
1866 to 1883.
PCGS# 83831.
PCGS Population: just 6; none are finer in the Cameo designation.
Page 43
Gem Proof 1878 Nickel
1263 1877 Proof-66 Cameo (PCGS). Gorgeous golden tinged
surfaces are expectably smooth at the premium Gem level
with nary a detracting blemish to report. Fully struck and
well contrasted in finish as well, this delightful specimen is
sure to please even the most exacting collector. A gorgeous
example of this desirable Proof-only date in the Shield nickel
series.
PCGS# 83831.
From our (Bowers and Ruddy’s) Stanislaw Herstal Collection sale, February 1974, lot 53. Lot tag included.
1264 1878 Proof-67 Cameo (PCGS). CAC. Brilliant apart from
subtle golden peripheral highlights, this exquisite Superb
Gem exhibits appreciable contrast between fully impressed
devices and satin to semi-reflective fields. The numbers
seen of this Proof-only issue are appreciably higher than
those of the prior year, the similarly Proof-only 1877 Shield
nickel. However, collector demand far exceeds supply for
both issues, particularly in the finer certified grades. Here
is the one of the nicest examples known to PCGS, one of
precious few to retain this degree of quality and contrast. An
important and highly desirable offering.
1265 1878 Proof-66+ Deep Cameo (PCGS). Ringed with
light golden peripheral toning, this otherwise brilliant
specimen readily reveals sharp contrast between satiny
devices and deeply mirrored fields. A silky smooth
premium Gem that is free of even the most trivial
detractions. Proof-only issues such as the 1877 and
1878 Shield nickels, the 1895 Morgan silver dollar
and the 1883 Liberty double eagle are often included
in date and mintmark collections of circulation
strike coinage to provide continuity. Hence, collector
pressure has always been strong for these issues, and is
likely to remain so in the coming years. This beautiful
condition rarity 1878 Shield nickel would make a wise
acquisition for the astute buyer.
PCGS# 83832.
PCGS Population: just 4; none are finer in this category, and there are no DCAM specimens
certified in any grade.
Page 44
PCGS# 93832.
PCGS Population: just 1; with a lone Proof-67 DCAM finer in this category.
1266 1879 Proof-67 Cameo (PCGS). Mostly brilliant surfaces
reveal delicate golden-orange, powder blue and silver-lilac
highlights as the coin is turned away from a light. This is
a simply gorgeous specimen, with cameo contrast between
frosty devices and semi-reflective fields. Tied with two
others at most as the finest seen of this Proof issue with the
desired Cameo contrast, and of considerable importance as
such, we note that no Deep Cameo specimens have been
certified by PCGS. This particular issue (normal date, not
the overdate) is the 12th rarest of the 20 issues and varieties
in the Proof Shield nickel series, and while obtainable with
patience up to the Gem level, finer examples such as this
delectable Superb Gem become considerably more difficult
to locate.
1267 1879 MS-66+ (PCGS). CAC. Bright and satiny, both the
obverse and reverse are devoid of even the most trivial
blemishes. This is a beautiful coin, one that is both expertly
produced and carefully preserved. This is the sole and finest
PCGS certified example of this date and mint. Furthermore,
there were no circulation strike Shield nickels struck in
1877 and 1878, and by 1879 demand remained limited so
that the Mint struck only 25,900 pieces — the second lowest
circulation strike mintage in the Shield series. Gems are
seldom available, and this stunning coin belongs in the most
PCGS# 3808.
PCGS Population: just 1; 0 finer.
PCGS# 83833.
PCGS Population: only 3; 0 finer.
Page 45
Important Gem Mint State 1880 Shield Nickel
Tied for Finest Known
1268 1880 MS-66 (PCGS). Secure Holder. Vibrant satin white surfaces and a full strike make it difficult for us to imagine a more technically
sound and visually appealing example of this key date Shield nickel. The mintage reported for circulation strikes came in at a paltry
16,000 pieces for the year, Others estimate as many as 21,000 were struck, however nearly the entire mintage slipped into circulation and
in time became lost. Today, numismatic experts at CoinFacts estimate that only 100 exist in all grades of these circulation strike coins, a
tiny fraction of Proofs known of this date. Thus, for the numismatist seeking an example of this incredibly rare issue, a number of minute
die markers must be confirmed to verify that the coin was originally struck for circulation purposes.
A strong loupe can aid in the confirmation as to which die pairing was used to create a specific coin, especially in high grades like this
outstanding Gem. Q. David Bowers in his Guide Book to Shield and Liberty Nickels notes that two 1880 dated obverse dies were “used
intermittently for the circulation and Proof strikes.” Therefore, the obverse die alone is not a determining factor as many Mint State coins
exhibit reflectivity, while some of the Proofs are satiny in appearance. The circulation strikes recognized by experts today exhibit a single
reverse die with three important diagnostic features:
1 - Upper left side of the first S in STATES is doubled or slightly repunched
2 - A small raised lump appears below the second T in STATES in the field, from a die pit or rust in the field.3 - A thin engraver’s
scratch or die line extends up from the center of a dentil located below and between the TS of CENTS.
Further Aspects of Rarity: While experts may differ on the actual number struck for circulation, whatever the number is, or perhaps
was, becomes a mere point of reference. It was the passage of certain legislation starting with the 1871 Redemption Act that had the
greatest impact on future mintage quantities of this denomination. Mint Director James Pollock had been restored to his post in 1869
after Henry Linderman was replaced, as these two traded the Mint directorship twice during this era. Pollock had been responsible for
gathering support for the redemption of the five cent piece in earlier years, and now that the country was overrun with minor coins,
something had to be done. Millions of coins had accumulated in the hands of postmasters, news dealers and transportation companies,
all of whom struggled to dispose of them. Treasury officials and members of Congress were bombarded with petitions for relief from
these minor coins. The Senate Committee on Finance approved a bill providing for the redemption of “copper and other token coins”
in January of 1871, and after brief discussion this was passed by the House and Senate on March 3, 1871. The bill provided for the
redemption in lawful currency (greenbacks) of all minor coins when presented in lots of $20 and authorized the Secretary to suspend
the issue of the coins when the volume of redemptions indicated redundancy. Within three months of the passage of the law, 11,000,000
minor coins were redeemed. The following fiscal year of 1872 saw nearly 26,000,000 fractional coins redeemed with a value of $475,000.
The Coinage Law of 1873 carried these same redemption provisions forward, and further eliminated the coinage of the silver three-cent
piece and the silver half dime. Between the fractional notes and abundance of copper and nickel coins, there was limited demand for new
coinage in the 1870s of the one, two, three and five cent denominations.
In December 1874 Senator Sherman introduced a bill that became the Specie Resumption Act of 1875. This Act contained three
provisions, the first was that as of January 1, 1879, greenbacks would be redeemed at par with gold coins (although in practice this
happened on December 17, 1878), another provision on greenbacks was that they were to be retired as the National Bank notes increased
in circulation and finally a provision directing the secretary of the Treasury to issue subsidiary silver coinage in exchange for fractional
paper notes. The effect of these provisions allowed silver coins to pile up in Treasury vaults, more silver coins returned to circulation from
long held private stashes as the greenbacks finally went back to par with gold for the first time since 1862.
Because of these factors, demand for the Shield five-cent coin was quite low in 1880. The Redemption Law of 1879 increased the
legal tender status from $5 to $20 for silver coins. So many coins poured into Treasury offices that few new issues were needed, and
the copper cents and copper-nickel Shield five-cent coins remained in low demand as there were more than sufficient numbers already
in circulation. Hence, the few 1880 Shield nickels produced were not needed, and when obtained in change in the normal course of
business, were soon back at the Treasury under these redemption limits. Research has shown the 1880 Shield nickel to be the rarest of
the entire series, and thus has the highest collector demand when an example appears on the market. Certainly this example, one of the
two finest certified by PCGS, is worthy of even the most advanced connoisseurs holdings.
PCGS# 3810.
PCGS Population: just 2; none finer.
Page 46
1269 1882 Proof-67+ Deep Cameo (PCGS). CAC. This is a
simply gorgeous Superb Gem, both sides sharply struck
with strong Deep Cameo contrast between the fields and
devices. The surfaces are untoned and free of grade limiting
blemishes, and the eye appeal is exceptional. Although this
is one of the more plentiful Proof issues in the Shield nickel
series, the technical and aesthetic quality of the present
example establish it as a Condition Census survivor that is
earmarked for inclusion in the finest cabinet.
PCGS# 93837.
PCGS# 38415.
1270 1882 MS-67 (PCGS). Brilliant and fully lustrous, this
satiny Superb Gem is sure to please even the most exacting
numismatist. The strike is razor sharp throughout, and the
surfaces are free of even trivial blemishes. Not only is this
example tied for the finest certified of the date at PCGS, it
is also one of the highest graded examples of the type, being
surpassed by only a single MS-67+ from the final year 1883
issue. This exciting coin, therefore, is sure to be the focus
of both type and date collectors when it crosses the auction
block in Baltimore.The Mint’s production of Shield nickels
for circulation in 1882 was extremely generous (by the
standards of the series) at nearly 11.5 million pieces struck.
However, the writing was clearly on the wall for Longacre’s
design, for the first pattern examples of what would prove
to be the Shield nickel’s successor had already appeared as
early as 1881. In 1883, the Shield nickel would pass into
coinage history as the first regular issue examples of Charles
E. Barber’s Liberty Head nickel made their appearance.
PCGS# 3812.
1271 1883/82 Shield. FS-304. MS-64 (NGC). Satiny and fully
impressed, this lovely near-Gem is untoned apart from
the lightest golden iridescence. An undeniably scarce and
seldom-seen overdate that is only infrequently offered to the
numismatic community — we might only offer one or two,
if even that many, during the course of an auction calendar
year. Bidding on this specimen should be bold and active,
especially if more than one specialist who knows the story
vies for the lot.
1272 1883/2 Shield. FS-302. AU-55 (PCGS). CAC. OGH.
Lovely golden-gray surfaces are lightly toned over nearly
complete satin luster. A problem free, premium quality
Choice AU that is sure to sell for a strong bid. As the FivazStanton numbering system has changed over the years, the
numismatist can find this variety listed in the 5th edition
(2009), on P. 261, where it is assigned the rarity rating URS4, signifying an estimated population of just five to eight
specimens in all grades; it seems likely that the presently
offered piece ranks in the Condition Census for the die
combination. Fivaz and Stanton list five different varieties of
1883/2 nickels, some of which are extremely rare — as here
— while others are common.
PCGS# 3814.
1273 1883 Liberty. No CENTS. Proof-66 Cameo (PCGS). CAC.
Secure Holder. A simply exquisite specimen, both sides
are boldly contrasted between satiny devices and deeply
mirrored fields. Virtually brilliant, and positively free of
detracting blemishes. An important one-year design type
that was soon discontinued when fraudsters gold plated
circulation strikes and passed them off as half eagles (these
are the so-called “racketeer nickels” which are sometimes
included in Liberty nickel sets). When the fraud came to
official notice, the Mint quickly responded by substituting a
modified design having the word CENTS on the reverse.
PCGS# 83878.
1274 1884 Proof-66 Cameo (NGC). CAC. Although 3,942
Proofs are said to have been minted, NGC has certified
fewer than 100 examples as Proof-66 or finer within the
Cameo designation.
PCGS# 22281.
1275 1885 Proof-65 (PCGS). The 1885 has long been recognized
as the key date in the Liberty Nickel series apart from the
celebrated 1913 issue. No explanation comes to hand to
explain the observed rarity of the date. The issue’s fairly
small 1,472,700-piece mintage doesn’t adequately explain
the elusive nature of the variety. The two certification
services — considered together — have graded circulation
strikes on barely more than 2,000 occasions since the mid
1980s, a figure that includes numerous Poor to VG pieces.
Due to the rarity of circulation strikes, much demand has
been focused on the available supply of Proofs, which —
judging from certification service statistics — may not be
much rarer than circulation strikes, all told.
PCGS# 3883.
Page 47
1276 1885—Reverse Planchet Flaw—MS-64 (PCGS). Crisply
impressed in virtually all areas, this key date Liberty nickel
also offers full satin luster and delicate champagne-gold
iridescence. The Mint error is a shallow lamination or strikethrough near the upper reverse border that only obscures a
small portion of the lettering in that area, and then again
only to a minimal degree. The undisputed key to the Liberty
nickel series, and one of the most important dates in the
entire denomination, 1866 through to the present. Mint
State coins are few and far between, and come to think of
it, so are circulated examples of the date. Take a good look
at this one, then take advantage of the opportunity and bid
accordingly.
1277 1886 MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. OGH. Satiny with a sharp to
full strike and nary a distracting blemish in evidence, the
eye appeal of this untoned example is far superior to that
which is implied by the assigned grade. A few extremely
shallow planchet voids over the lower obverse are as struck
and hardly worth mentioning. The low-mintage 1886
has proven to be an elusive date in any and all grades for
decades. Seldom seen in Mint State, we expect the bidding
reception for the present piece will prove to be exceptional.
PCGS# 3847.
PCGS# E3846.
Superb Gem Uncirculated 1893 Liberty Nickel
Tied for Finest Certified
1278 1893 MS-67 (NGC). A lively pearlescent-silver patina is haloed by a subtle champagne glow at the peripheries of this gorgeous
Superb Gem. The matte-like surfaces are intensely lustrous and virtually pristine throughout, exhibiting a razor sharp strike and
profoundly intricate devices on both sides. You have reached the “top of the pop” for quality if you’re the fortunate bidder on the
present beauty.
PCGS# 3854.
Combined PCGS and NGC Population: just 3; and none are finer at either service.
1279 1911 MS-66 (PCGS). Bright and satiny surfaces are further adorned in a blend of beautiful pale lilac and golden-apricot iridescence.
Lovely! An impressive Gem easily in the top 5% of all Mint State specimens certified by PCGS.
PCGS# 3872.
1280 1913 Type II. Proof-64 (PCGS). This razor sharp specimen exhibits a soft, satiny texture beneath slightly mottled, tan-gray patina. With
nary a detracting blemish to report, the surfaces have the appearance of an even higher grade. Just 1,514 examples of the date were struck
in the Proof format, a figure that is just six coins less than the Proof total for the 1913 Type I Buffalo nickel.
PCGS# 3990.
1281 1913-S Type II. MS-64 (NGC). Lightly and evenly toned in golden-gray patina, this satiny piece is expectably smooth at the Choice
grade level. The Type II 1913-S Buffalo nickel is the scarcest of the six different issues for the year.
PCGS# 3923.
Page 48
1282 1914 Proof-67 (PCGS). CAC. Radiant satin surfaces are
lightly and evenly toned in beautiful iridescent gold. A
fully struck and expertly preserved specimen that is sure
to delight the advanced Buffalo nickel collector. Only 1,275
Proofs were minted during the year, and the presently
offered specimen is in the top 20% of all examples certified
by PCGS.
PCGS# 3991.
1283 1914 Proof-65 (PCGS). Streaks of lovely golden-tan
iridescence leave areas of silvery brilliance on both sides of
this enchanting specimen. The satiny finish is uncommonly
vibrant for an early date Proof Buffalo nickel, and the devices
are extremely bold with needle-sharp definition. Just 1,275
Proofs of the date were produced, with far fewer than that
total known today.
1287 1916 Proof-67 (PCGS). CAC. This is a luxurious Superb
Gem Proof that sports razor-sharp striking detail, silky
smooth surfaces, and delightful silver-lilac and pale gold
toning. Only 600 Proofs of the date were produced, and
we estimate far fewer than that number can be accounted
for today. Its production tally of 600 pieces represents the
second-lowest Proof mintage of any date in the nickel fivecents series, 1866 to present; only the 1867 Rays Shield
nickel rarity had a smaller production figure.
PCGS# 3993.
PCGS# 3991.
1284 1914-D MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. Boldly struck with delicate
golden-gray patina, this satiny Gem is smooth, attractive
and sure to sell for a premium bid. This beauty ranks in the
top 25% of all Mint State examples certified by PCGS.
PCGS# 3925.
1285 1915 Proof-65 (PCGS). Crisply impressed with a vibrant
satin texture, this otherwise brilliant looking Gem reveals
streaks of pale golden tinting as the surfaces rotate under a
light. The Proof mintage for the date of 1,050 pieces is the
second lowest Proof production tally of the series. A lovely
Gem specimen!
PCGS# 3992.
1286 1915 Proof-64 (NGC). This fully impressed, satin-textured
specimen exhibits dominant golden-gray tinting with a
few streaks of warmer lilac-gray over the upper obverse.
Otherwise smooth, a well concealed contact mark within
the hair on the bison’s shoulder seems to be the only
impediment to an even higher grade. Just 1,050 Proofs of
the date were struck in the denomination, with that figure
representing the second-lowest Proof production tally of the
series.
PCGS# 3992.
1288 1918/7-D FS-101. EF Details—Improperly Cleaned
(NGC). There is a lot of bold to sharp detail remaining on
both sides of this desirable overdate nickel, and it includes
sharp definition to the all important 7 underdigit. Mostly
dusky gray in appearance, and a bit subdued due to the
stated impairment, speckles of light russet encrustation are
also noted for accuracy. An elusive overdate in all grades,
this well defined EF is sure to be of interest to more than a
few collectors.
PCGS# 3939.
1289 1918-S MS-63 (PCGS). This is an impressive example of
this conditionally challenging S-mint issue. Both sides are
uncommonly well produced with soft, satiny luster and
bold to sharp definition that even extends into the centers.
Carefully preserved, as well, the surfaces reveal no significant
blemishes beneath warm tan-gold patina. Worthy of a solid
bid. The value of this date escalates significantly in the Guide
Book once the MS-63 level is reached.
PCGS# 3940.
1290 1919-S MS-63 (NGC). This charming example exhibits a
soft, satiny texture and even pearl-gray toning. There are
remarkably few blemishes in the context of the assigned
grade, and a uniformly bold to sharp strike is also a superior
attribute in a Mint State survivor of this semi-key date
Buffalo nickel issue.
PCGS# 3943.
Page 49
1291 1926-S MS-62 (PCGS). Warmly toned in dominant tangray patina, more direct angles call forth subtle rose, powder
blue and pale gold undertones. A bit lightly struck overall, as
typically noted for this challenging issue, yet uncommonly
smooth and blemish free at the BU grade level. We estimate
the 1926-S Mint State population to be in the 600 to 800
pieces range, making this one of the most desirable issues
in the entire Buffalo nickel series. Circulated examples are
also very scarce, especially in grades above VG. Finally,
the relatively-low mintage of 970,000 pieces is the smallest
production figure for circulation strikes in the entire design
type, 1913-1938.
1293 1936 Brilliant Proof-67 (NGC). Flashy mirror finish
surfaces are lightly toned in pale gold, silver and powder
blue iridescence. A charming specimen, and a solidly graded
Superb Gem with nary a detracting blemish in evidence.
Scarce at this grade level and very rare finer; barely more
than 20% of the examples certified by NGC grade Proof-67
or higher.
PCGS# 3995.
PCGS# 3959.
1292 1936 Satin Proof-67 (PCGS). Ringed in warm sandy-gold
peripheral toning, this otherwise silver tinged specimen
radiates vibrant satin surfaces as the coin rotates under a
light. A razor sharp Superb Gem with eye appeal to spare.
In 1936, the Mint struck Proof nickels for the first time since
1916. The Proofs were struck in two different formats: the
first group of Proofs were made with fields having a satin
finish resembling those seen on Proof Buffalo nickels made
between 1913 and 1916, and later, a second group of Proofs
was made having mirror fields resembling 21st-century
Proof coins. Certification service statistics indicate that the
two different formats are approximately equal in scarcity. No
Buffalo nickel collection can be said to be complete unless
it includes examples of both types. The presently offered
example ranks way above average in terms of available
quality.
PCGS# 3994.
1294 1936 Brilliant Proof-66 (PCGS). CAC. OGH. Brilliant
silver gray features are fully impressed, expertly preserved,
and exceptionally attractive even at the premium Gem
grade level. The 1936 is notable for having the lowest Proof
mintage of any issue from that year up till the present
time(just 4,420 pieces; a figure that includes both Satin and
Brilliant formats).
PCGS# 3995.
1295 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. MS-64 (NGC). This attractive
near-Gem displays rich orange-gold patina to boldly
lustrous surfaces. The 1937-D Three-Legged variety is said
to have been created when an over-zealous Denver Mint
employee used an emery stick to remove clash marks from
an otherwise normal reverse die; the treatment succeeded in
removing the clash marks, but also erased the bison’s right
foreleg, leaving behind a detached hoof. The die was then
re-installed in the coinage press, producing thousands of
examples of a variety that has since become a favorite with
collectors. Perhaps 2,500 to 3,000 Mint State examples can
be accounted for today, mostly in the MS-61 to 63 range.
PCGS# 3982.
Page 50
1296 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. MS-63 (NGC). CAC. Veiled
in delicate olive-gold iridescence, this boldly impressed
and overall smooth example has the “look” of an even
higher grade. Of particular note is the lack of detracting
carbon flecks on both the obverse and the reverse. Always
in demand in any and all grades, today’s collectors place
particular significance on pleasing Mint State examples of
our hobbled bison friend.
PCGS# 3982.
1299 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. MS-62 (PCGS). Boldly struck
and remarkably smooth for the assigned grade, this satiny
golden-tinged piece has the appearance of a significantly
higher Mint State rating. Worthy of a close look! One of the
most popular and eagerly sought die varieties in the entire
panoply of 20th-century numismatics.
PCGS# 3982.
1300 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. MS-60 (PCGS). OGH. Satiny
medium gray surfaces also reveal a tinge of light golden
patina as the coin rotates under a light. Superior for the
assigned grade, this piece is lustrous, well struck for this
Mint error, and free of detracting blemishes. Every collector
knows of this error, and its popularity has grown with
Buffalo nickel aficionados in the past few decades. Years ago
it was viewed as an oddity that wasn’t necessarily needed to
complete a Buffalo nickel set, and now everyone wants one
— how the times and collecting tastes change!
PCGS# 3982.
1297 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. MS-63 (NGC). This outwardly
smooth, softly lustrous example is awash in light, even,
golden-silver patina. A well struck, nicely preserved survivor
of this ever-popular 20th-century Mint error. How fortunate
our bidders are to have more than one Mint State example of
this ever-popular “error” coin in this sale.
PCGS# 3982.
1301 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. AU-58 (NGC). Well struck for
this ever-popular mint error, this minimally worn example
also offers handsome toning in warm and even golden-gray.
Otherwise free of significant blemishes, a wispy abrasion
over the bison’s belly is noted for accuracy. Easily among the
most popular and most famous of all mint errors, the 1937D 3-legged Buffalo nickel is widely known even outside of
numismatic circles.
PCGS# 3982.
1302 1939-S Reverse of 1940. MS-66 FS (PCGS). This Gem
exhibits an exceptionally sharp strike and pleasing golden
patina throughout. The Reverse of ‘40 has better definition to
certain design details in and around the view of Monticello,
and many specialists are beginning to take note of such
varieties in the series.
PCGS# 894006.
PCGS Population: 21 within the FS designation; none finer.
1298 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. MS-62 (PCGS). Lovely golden
tinged surfaces are lustrous, boldly struck, and free of even
trivial distractions. Seemingly undergraded at the BU level,
and worthy of a close look, as such. Just a hair shy of the
quality offered in the MS-63 examples of the date appearing
immediately before this lot in the current catalog.
PCGS# 3982.
From our (Stack’s) George F. Scanlon Collection sale, October 1973, lot
Page 51
1306 1948 MS-67 5FS (NGC). Gorgeous pastel tones cover
both sides of this Superb Gem with an exceptional strike
and strong luster. If you’re looking for this date with a 6FS
designation, you won’t find one in a NGC holder graded
MS-67 — the present 5FS piece is the nicest you’ll encounter
with any step count.
PCGS# 524034.
NGC Census: only 1; 0 finer.
1303 1945-P FS-801. Doubled Die Reverse. MS-67 (NGC).
Heavily toned in emerald, pink and gold, the surfaces are
choice and the luster is bold. An important and elusive
variety that is helping stoke the fires of the renaissance in
collecting modern U.S. Mint coinage. Beautiful!
PCGS# 38505.
NGC Census: just 3; 0 finer.
1304 1945-P MS-67 (PCGS). A coin that really needs to be seen
to be fully appreciated, this beautiful Superb Gem exhibits
vivid multicolored toning to smooth, vibrant, satin to softly
frosted luster. This gorgeous War nickel signifies the end of
the 35% silver emergency five-cents coinage of 1942 through
1945. Worthy of a premium bid!
PCGS# 4025.
PCGS Population: 55; none finer within any designation. Six of the 55 are designated “+” by
PCGS, and eight of the 55 are designated “FS” by the firm.
1307 1948-S MS-67 FS (PCGS). Secure Holder. Silky smooth
in texture with a softly frosted finish, this gorgeous Superb
Gem also offers pretty toning in iridescent gold, pale pink
and powder blue. Simply put, it is difficult for us to imagine
a more attractive and appealing example of this issue. It
would have been difficult for old-time collectors to have
imagined the recent stratospheric popularity of some Full
StepsJefferson nickels in the top levels of available condition.
Coins that may have commanded only $20 or $30 dollars in
the years prior to the present era of grade certification can
now sometimes bring hundreds of times as much.
PCGS# 84036.
PCGS Population: 2; none finer within the FS designation.
Half Dimes
1305 1946-D/D FS-501. Repunched Mintmark. MS-66+ FS
(PCGS). Charming golden-apricot iridescence blankets
full, billowy, satin to softly frosted luster. Solidly graded as a
premium Gem, this exquisite piece also offers exceptionally
sharp striking detail for this popular RPM variety. This
variety is listed in the 5th edition of the Fivaz-Stanton
Cherrypicker’s Guide on p. 312, wherein the rarity rating is
given as URS-8 signifying an estimated population of just 65
to 125 pieces in all grades. The Cherrypicker’s Guide authors
consider interest in this variety to be high, appealing to both
mainstream Jefferson nickel specialists as-well-as die variety
enthusiasts. PCGS has certified fewer than three dozen
examples of the variety.
1308 1795 LM-6. Rarity-6. EF Details—Scratches (NGC).
Nicely retoned in iridescent steel gray, bold striking detail
and freedom from outwardly distracting abrasions are also
positive attributes of this early half dime. The scratches are
minor and easily overlooked, as is a touch of glossiness to
the surface texture from an old cleaning. From the second
and final year of the Flowing Hair design type, this date is
often selected to represent the type owing to the rarity of the
1794 half dime.
PCGS# 4251.
PCGS# 894029.
PCGS Population: 4; none finer
Page 52
Mint State 1800 Draped Bust,
Heraldic Eagle Half Dime
1310 1832 LM-5. Rarity-1. MS-66 (NGC). Radiant, fully
untoned surfaces are bursting with satin white luster. With
a sharp strike and silky smooth surfaces, the desirability of
this coin for high-grade type purposes is assured. The 1832
is one of just two dates in the design type, 1829 to 1837
inclusive, with a mintage that dipped below the one million
coin mark.
PCGS# 4279.
1309 1800 LM-1. Rarity-3. MS-61 (PCGS). A beautiful
example, vibrant and satiny surfaces exhibit vivid
peripheral toning in powder blue, olive-gray and
reddish-apricot iridescence. Otherwise silver gray
in tone, both sides are exceptionally smooth for the
assigned grade with nary a detracting abrasion or other
blemish to report. A satiny, sharply struck and visually
impressive piece that is sure to excite the Mint State
type collector. This is a difficult type, date and variety
to find in any Mint State grade as so few of these were
saved at the time they were released into circulation.
Furthermore many of the higher grade pieces have
problems which preclude them from grading today,
such as scratches or bends. These tiny coins were
prone to such problems during their early years, and
only those set aside and carefully preserved can offer
such attractive surfaces and high technical grade to
the specialist today. Don’t miss out if you have been
seeking an example of this date or type in Mint State!
PCGS# 4264.
PCGS Population: 4; 39 are finer (Mint State-68 finest).
1311 1838 No Drapery. Large Stars. MS-67 (NGC). CAC. OH.
Simply exquisite eye appeal in a No Drapery half dime,
both sides of this gorgeous Superb Gem exhibit vivid,
multicolored target toning that really must be seen to be
fully appreciated. Fully struck with smooth, satiny surfaces,
we anticipate that only the strongest bids will be able to
compete for this beautiful coin. From the first year of the
design type to feature obverse stars around Miss Liberty.
All 1838 half dimes are of the No Drapery style which was
supplanted late in 1840 by the new dies featuring drapery at
Liberty’s elbow.
PCGS# 4317.
1312 1845 MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. Billowy mint luster flows over
both sides of this smartly impressed and expertly preserved
Gem. Close to brilliant in the center of the obverse, with
the balance of the surfaces exhibiting lovely silver-orange
iridescence that is boldest at the borders. Nearly 1.6
million examples of the date were produced, a lofty figure
that thankfully allowed Gem-quality specimens such as
the present beauty to survive for the pleasure of today’s
PCGS# 4335.
Page 53
Intriguing Proof 1856/’4’ Half Dime Rarity
1313 1856/’4’ Proof-64 Cameo (PCGS). A thoroughly appealing
specimen, both sides are adorned in delicate silver gray and
pale pink iridescence through which a vibrant finish shines
forth powerfully at all angles. Fully struck with bold cameo
contrast and expertly preserved surfaces, this coin is sure to
have no difficulty finding its way into an advanced collection
of Proof Liberty Seated coinage.
All Proof coinage from 1856 is rare by the standards of just
a few years later. Perhaps 50 pieces were struck with 25 to 40
known today, if indeed that many. This was an early strike from
the dies, when the dies were able to induce the most contrast
between the mirror fields and frosted devices — enough to
win the well deserved award of the Cameo designation to this
rare coin. Liberty’s dress pendant is located over the tip of the
5, and the left edge of the serifs of the 1 align with the left
edge of a denticle below. This appears to be the normal Proof
obverse die used to create this small Proof issue. The reverse is
also the normal die, listed as Valentine-2. A tiny lump resides
just inside with wire edge above the D of UNITED, seen on all
other Proofs of this date examined.
However, the last time this particular coin appeared on
the market was way back in 1974 in our (Bowers and Ruddy’s
American Auction Association) sale of the Stanislaw Herstal
Collection. In that auction this coin is described as an 1856/4
Gem Proof and realized a high market price of $4,400 at that
time. Another recorded example (possibly the same coin) was
in B. Max Mehl’s sale of the W.W. Neil Collection in 1947, lot
1648. An apparently different example of this controversial
overdate was auctioned in our (Bowers and Merena) Stuart C.
Levine, MD Collection in April, 1986, lot 2191.Walter Breen,
in describing the 1856 Proof half dime in Superior’s Charles
L. Ruby Part I Collection, February 1974 notes “Heavy date,
heavy 6 closed by die defect. (Is this Neil’s unknown large
date?) Unlisted.” Years later, Breen, in his 1988 Encyclopedia
states the following “There is also a report of an “1856 over
54” proof, said to have date entirely repunched and larger
than usual (Neil:1648, ex S. Hudson Chapman Coll., 1929
possibly ex Eavenson:102). This has led to examination of
several earlier states of the regular V-2 proofs, but so far none
has exactly matched the description of the Neil coin, nor has
the latter shown up. Regular V-2 proofs do not show totally
repunched dates, nor are the dates larger than normal; the
var. remains a numismatic ghost which has refused to be
exorcised.”
Perhaps this “numismatic ghost” can finally be exorcised
with this reappearance of the Herstal coin. We invite any and
all half dime experts to examine closely the date and to draw
their own conclusions. There appears to be a small chip in the
6 right between the knob and the loop, which could easily be
confused as the crossbar of a 4. Furthermore the date punches
on the earliest die states sometimes have slight doubling
which wears away quickly if the repunching is extremely
shallow, and could give the appearance of a much larger than
usual date punch. For an 1854 die to have been hubbed and
set aside, without arrows(!), and later overdated in 1856, then
used for Proofs, would all seem to be unlikely. However,
here is one of the best representative coins for specialists to
examine, returning to market after 40 years in hiding.
PCGS# 84434.
PCGS Population: 2; just 1 finer (Proof-65 Cameo finest) within the Cameo Proof designation.
1314 1859-O MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC. Delightful surfaces exude
originality in the form of rich, blended, olive-copper and
silver gray patina. With an overall sharp strike and smooth,
billowy mint luster, there is much to recommend this coin
to the quality conscious collector. Mintage of 480,000 pieces
and this is clearly one of the finer examples known today.
Pictured on the CoinFacts website for this grade, and a truly
elegant representative of this New Orleans issue.
PCGS# 4370.
PCGS Population: 1; 10 are finer (Mint State-66+ finest).
1315 1865 Proof-65 (NGC). OH. Richly toned in charcoalcopper patina, this delightful Gem allows ready appreciation
of a well mirrored finish as the surfaces rotate under a
light. Sharply struck — and far better than the typical
business strike half dime from the 1860s in this regard —
this specimen would do equally well in a high grade Proof
type or date set. This is one of the lowest mintage dates for
circulation strikes with only 10,000 produced, thus many
collectors obtain a Proof to represent this date and mint.
This fact keeps pricing pressure high on the Proofs when
they are offered. Here is a splendid Gem that has been
tucked away for many years in an advanced collection.
1316 1867 Proof-67 (NGC). Draped in wonderfully original
olive-copper, cobalt blue, and reddish-rose iridescence,
this silky smooth specimen reveals decided cameo contrast
as the surfaces rotate under a light. One of a Red Bookestimated 625 Proofs of the date struck, most of those sold
in sets though individual sales also occurred. A pleasing
Gem Proof that is right at the “top of the pop” for Proof
specimens of the date.
PCGS# 4450.
PCGS Population: 6; none finer within any designation. One of the six pieces is designated
“Cameo” by PCGS.
PCGS# 4448.
NGC Census: 30; 14 finer (Proof-68 finest) within the Proof designation.
Page 54
Dimes
1317 1807 JR-1, the only known dies. Rarity-2. MS-63 (NGC).
Charming golden-toned centers are framed in equally
desirable copper-gray peripheral toning. Well struck for the
issue with a smooth, satiny texture throughout, this final
year Draped Bust dime is sure to excite the Mint State type
collector. Bold clash marks in the obverse field and light
adjustment marks near the lower obverse and upper reverse
borders are as struck. This is one of the few Draped Bust
silver issues that can be obtained in Mint State. The mintage
of 165,000 was large for the time, and remarkably a single
pair of dies were used. Even more incredible is the fact that
the reverse die for these was first used to coin most of the
1805 dimes as well as the quarter eagles of 1805 through
1807. Hence the strong die clashing is present as during all
this production the feeder mechanism occasionally became
blocked, allowing the dies to strike each other without a
planchet between them. While not the absolute finest seen,
this high grade dime is certainly quite respectable for the
grade assigned and a tough date to find this well preserved.
PCGS# 4480.
1319 1838 No Drapery. Large Stars. Fortin-109. Rarity-5.
Partial Drapery. MS-64 (PCGS). A satiny and outwardly
smooth near-Gem, the present example is also handsomely
toned in a blend of copper-rose, olive-gray and antique gold.
The “partial drapery” designation is actually the result of die
clash and not an intentional design motif from the mint.
This variety is the late die state of the 1838 Partial Drapery
dime, with the die clash below Liberty’s right (facing) elbow
weak due to die erosion.
PCGS# 4570.
1320 1838 No Drapery. Large Stars. Fortin-106. Rarity-3.
Obverse Die Crack #1. MS-64 (NGC). CAC. OH. A sharp,
bisecting obverse die crack is the most readily identifiable
diagnostic of this popular variety. This satiny near-Gem is
crisply impressed with silky smooth surfaces throughout.
Attractively toned, as well, we note warm charcoal-blue
peripheral iridescence that gives way to lighter silver and
pale gold tinting in the centers. The die crack extends from
the left side of star seven, down through Liberty to the edge
through the right side of the 1. A tough coin to find this well
preserved and worthy of any advanced collection.
PCGS# 4568.
1318 1837 Capped Bust. JR-4. Rarity-1. MS-63 (PCGS). CAC.
OGH. Satiny and uncommonly smooth for the assigned
grade, this snappy looking piece would not seem out of
place in a near-Gem holder. Iridescent golden-orange
peripheral toning adds further appeal. Struck in the final
year of Capped Bust coinage within the denomination, a
series that ended with a mintage of 359,500 pieces, just one
third that of the preceding year.
PCGS# 4529.
1321 1843-O Fortin-101, the only known dies. Rarity-6-. AU
Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Sharply struck and outwardly
smooth, handsome retoning in rich steel and golden-gray
further enhances the visual appeal of this piece. In fact, this
coin is remarkably attractive given the stated impairment,
and it is sure to have no difficulty finding its way into a
specialized Liberty Seated dime collection. The mintage
of 150,000 pieces for the year from the New Orleans Mint
mostly disappeared over the years. Today there are perhaps
200 known according to CoinFacts, and high grade examples
are particularly difficult to find.
PCGS# 4584.
Page 55
1326 1873 Arrows. MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. Original silver-rose
and pale blue toning is more prevalent on the obverse of this
delightful near-Gem. Both sides are boldly struck with full,
frosty luster to pleasingly smooth surfaces. The arrows at the
date signify a minor upward adjustment of the silver content
of the denomination from 2.49 to 2.50 grams, not enough to
upset the apple cart.
PCGS# 4665.
1322 1856 Small Date. Fortin-101. Rarity-6+. Doubled Die
Obverse. Proof-64 (NGC). Watery reflectivity and delicate
golden-orange iridescence greet the viewer from both sides
of this endearing specimen. This is a rare coin in any Proof
grade as so few were struck. Although the exact number
struck is not known, today we see that NGC records a total
of 27 grading events in various Proof designations with
some duplication likely within those numbers. A few years
after this rare coin was struck, the number of Proofs issued
climbed dramatically to meet growing collector demand,
and several hundred are known for most issues of silver
coins seen by the time the Civil War began. Hence this early
Proof issue is highly desirable, especially so close to the Gem
level.
PCGS# 4745.
NGC Census: just 6; 7 finer in this category.
PCGS# 84748.
1324 1865 Proof-65 (NGC). Smooth golden tinged surfaces
allow ready appreciation of bold field to device contrast
on both sides, making this coin a candidate for at least a
Cameo designation from NGC. There are no grade limiting
contact marks, and a tiny swirl of russet iridescence in the
left obverse field is noted solely for accuracy. Struck while
the final bugle calls of the Civil War were being sounded to
the tune of 500 or so pieces. Lovely!
PCGS# 4758.
1325 1873 No Arrows. Close 3. Proof-66 Cameo (NGC). Delicate
silver-rose iridescence engages both sides, the lower obverse
periphery further enhanced by even more vivid cobalt
blue patina. This is a silky smooth, highly attractive Gem
that is sure to sell for a strong bid. This issue was struck in
January 1873 prior to the Coinage Act of 1873 which slightly
altered the statutory planchets used in February of that year.
Furthermore, the Close 3 designation refers to the knobs of
the 3 being too close together and giving the appearance of
an 8 instead of the desired 3. From a mintage of 1,100 pieces
for this important issue, and this is one of the finer examples
seen today.
NGC Census: 11; 4 finer through Proof-68 Cameo.
PCGS# 4770.
1328 1878 Proof-65 Cameo (PCGS). Smartly impressed with
originally toned surfaces, the obverse is generally goldengray in appearance while the reverse is awash in deeper
charcoal-blue patina. Both sides also reveal more vivid
undertones when viewed with the aid of a direct light,
which angles also call forth appreciable field to device
contrast. Only 800 were struck in Proof, and this lovely Gem
Cameo is one of the finer ones known today. Destined for an
PCGS# 84775.
1323 1859 Proof-64 Cameo (PCGS). Secure Holder. This
charming specimen exhibits subtle cobalt blue peripheral
highlights to otherwise even olive-orange patina. Outwardly
smooth, there is not so much as a single detracting contact
mark or other blemish in evidence. Undeniably choice for
the grade and one of just 800 or so specimens of the date
struck in the Proof format.
PCGS# 84766.
1327 1874 Arrows. Proof-64 (NGC). Fully struck and
handsomely toned, both sides are drenched in a blend of
rose-gray, charcoal-blue and steel gray. More direct angles
call forth suitable vibrancy to the Proof finish, especially in
the fields. A sparkling Proof from the second and final year
of the denomination to show arrows at the date; the arrows
disappeared with the 1875 issue.
PCGS Population: 10; just 4 are finer (Proof-66 Cameo finest) within the Cameo Proof designation.
1329 1879 Proof-66 (NGC). Delicate silvery tinting is confined to
the obverse of this otherwise brilliant Gem. Overall smooth
surfaces readily uphold the validity of the Gem grade,
and there appears to be enough field-to-device contrast to
support a Cameo designation, especially on the reverse.
One of 1,100 Proofs struck, a comfortable figure that allows
for many pleasing Proofs of the date to be available to the
PCGS# 4776.
1330 1880 Fortin-102a. Rarity-4. MS-66 (PCGS). CAC. OGH.
This is an exquisite Gem with silky smooth and overall
brilliant surfaces. Satiny and vibrant in the luster category,
with delicate champagne pink iridescence clinging to the
denticles. Just 36,000 examples of the date were struck,
imparting semi-key status to this late-date issue. Choice for
the grade.
PCGS# 4688.
1331 1883 Proof-66 Cameo (PCGS). Rich teal and rose patina
glows from both sides of this exceptionally appealing
Gem Proof. A most handsome example for the type or
date specialist as this jewel offers not only splendid toning
but also bold contrast between satin-smooth devices and
mirrored fields. One of the finer examples seen today from a
modest Proof mintage of just 1,039 pieces.
PCGS# 84780.
Page 56
1336 1901 Proof-65 Cameo (PCGS). Ringed in delicate goldenapricot iridescence, the peripheries frame virtually brilliant
centers on both sides of this exquisite Gem. This is certainly
one of the finer Cameo Proofs known today from the
813 pieces struck in this format. Most of course lack the
desirable Cameo contrast, and even fewer can offer the Gem
level surfaces of the present coin. A handsome example that
will please any astute specialist.
PCGS# 84885.
PCGS Population: 12; 18 finer (Proof-67 Cameo finest) within the Cameo Proof designation.
1332 1887 MS-67 (NGC). Swirling satin luster greets the viewer
from both sides of this smooth and fully untoned piece.
Outstanding quality and a condition rarity at this grade
level as so few are known that even approach the Superb
grade level of preservation. Although the mintage was high
for this particular year, over 11 million were coined, but of
course only a minute fraction survive today at all. A bold
and worthy selection for the type or date and mint collector
to pursue.
PCGS# 4698.
NGC Census: just 4; with a mere 2 finer (both MS-68).
1333 1891 Proof-66 (NGC). Intensely vivid blue, gold, rose
and orange iridescence blankets both sides, the reverse in
particular with a delightful target-like distribution to the
toning. A premium Gem Proof with exceptional eye appeal
that is sure to command a strong bid. Struck in the final year
of this long-lived design type.
PCGS# 4788.
1334 1891 Proof-65 Cameo (PCGS). CAC. Untoned apart from
the lightest pale golden iridescence, and then again only
really around the peripheries, this gorgeous Gem allows
ready appreciation of bold cameo contrast. Silky smooth
surfaces and a razor sharp strike are also praiseworthy
attributes. Only 600 pieces were struck in this final year of
production for the Liberty Seated dime series. Certainly an
outstanding coin to pursue if you desire a high end Cameo
for your collection.
PCGS# 84788.
PCGS Population: 15; 17 finer (Proof-67+ Cameo finest) within the Cameo Proof designation.
1337 1904 Proof-67 (PCGS). Both the obverse and the left half
of the reverse are awash in a blend of dove gray, pale rose
and lilac-blue patina that yields to virtual brilliance over
the balance of the latter side. In addition to undeniable
originality, this handsome Superb Gem also possesses
needle sharp striking detail and silky smooth surfaces. An
outstanding example and clearly confirmed as one of the
best known today from a mintage of 670 pieces. Destined
for a high grade collection that demands quality, eye appeal
and condition rarity.
PCGS# 4888.
PCGS Population: 8; just 1 is finer (Proof-68 finest) within the Proof designation.
1338 1905 Proof-65 (PCGS). Mottled steel gray iridescence and
vivid rose-apricot undertones are much more extensive on
the reverse of this fully impressed, well mirrored Gem. From
a Proof mintage of just 727 specimens. The presently offered
specimen is decidedly above average in terms of available
quality.
PCGS# 4889.
1339 1907-D MS-64 (PCGS). Smooth with a hard, satiny texture,
this handsome near-Gem is awash in blended pearl gray and
orange-russet patina. An amply pleasing example from the
early days of Denver Mint coinage.
PCGS# 4843.
1335 1893 MS-66 (NGC). CAC—Gold Label. OH. A simply
outstanding example of both the issue and the type, this
luxurious Barber dime is bathed in a vivid blend of rich
multicolored toning. Fully frosted in texture with not even a
single troublesome blemish, it would not surprise us in the
least to see this coin in a Superb Gem holder. Given that the
finest seen are MS-67, this sparkling jewel will undoubtedly
find considerable interest when it crosses the auction block.
PCGS# 4800.
NGC Census: 17; only 5 finer (Mint State-67 finest).
1340 1908 Proof-65 (PCGS). Iridescent olive-copper toning
adorns both sides in a mottled fashion, more direct angles
calling forth gold, blue and rose undertones. A razor sharp
Gem with expectably strong eye appeal in a vividly toned
Proof Barber dime. From a scant Proof mintage of just 545
pieces. Scarcely more than 30% of the Proofs certified by
PCGS could match the quality offered here.
PCGS# 4892.
1341 1910-S MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. Splashes of sandy gold
iridescence adorn the smooth and satiny surfaces of this
razor-sharp Gem. A pleasing branch mint Gem Mint State
Barber dime for your bidding pleasure!
PCGS# 4856.
Page 57
Outstanding Gem 1924-S
Mercury Dime with Full Bands
1342 1916-D Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Sharply struck
throughout to include virtually full separation between the
central reverse crossbands, this satiny piece is worthy of a
close look prior to bidding. There are no sizable abrasions,
and evidence of a long-ago cleaning is minor and easily
forgiven. Wisps of delicate pinkish-silver iridescence further
enhance already significant eye appeal. The undisputed key
date in the Mercury dime series, and one of the most famous
of all issues in the entire denomination.
PCGS# 4906.
From an unnamed Paramount auction, lot 1044. Lot tag included.
1343 1916-D VF-30 (ANACS). OH. Warm golden-gray patina
blankets bold Choice VF features on both sides of this
appealing mid-grade survivor. A classic date for collectors
meets a perfect grade for collectors — this one will see
spirited bidding activity.
1346 1924-S MS-65 FB (PCGS). Captivating frosty white
surfaces are untoned apart from a few wisps of faint
silvery tinting in the right reverse field. The strike is
impressively full in the centers for a ‘24-S dime, and
with nary a detracting abrasion in evidence the validity
of the coveted Gem Full Bands rating from PCGS is
assured in our minds. While the Gem grade level is
certain to delight any specialist in this series for this
date and mint, this is only a part of the equation. What
is of paramount here is the sharp strike. During this
era, the branch mints often produced average quality
strikes. Full strikes were the exception in this era
on many dates and mints, such as this issue. Hence
collectors have to search high and low to find one this
well preserved, and offering the sharp central bands.
An important offering for the Mercury dime specialist.
PCGS# 4947.
PCGS Population: 16; 3 are finer (Mint State-66 Full Bands finest) within the Full
Bands designation.
PCGS# 4906.
1344 1916-D Good-6 (PCGS). This is a lovely piece for the grade
with honest wear and overall smooth, minimally marked
surfaces. Lightly toned in a blend of silver gray and pale
gold, both sides retain bold outline definition to all elements
of the design. This is the key date to the Mercury dime series
and with a mintage of only 264,000 pieces there are not
many to go around today. First year of issue as well, and this
date and mint has always been one of the most sought after
issues of the 20th century.
PCGS# 4906.
1345 1921 AU-58 (PCGS). Richly toned in original lavender-gray,
this softly frosted, outwardly smooth example is temptingly
close to full Mint State quality. An important key date in the
series, and one of just four dates in the design type with a
double-digit value in the Good-4 column of the Guide Book.
Worthy of a close look!
PCGS# 4934.
1347 1928-S MS-65 FB (PCGS). Exquisite satin to softly frosted
surfaces are expectably smooth at the Gem grade level.
Untoned save for a blush of pale gold over the upper right
obverse, a razor sharp strike further enhances this coin’s
appeal to advanced Mercury dime collectors. This is a scarce
date and mint at the Gem grade level, especially so with the
sharp strike on the center bands of the reverse. A specialist’s
coin that is certain to attract well deserved attention.
PCGS# 4971.
From our (Bowers and Ruddy’s) Matt Rothert Collection sale, November 1973, part of lot 424. Lot tag included.
1348 1931 MS-66+ FB (PCGS). Silky smooth in texture with
radiant mint frost, this otherwise brilliant Gem is further
enhanced by splashes of crimson-russet iridescence in
isolated peripheral areas. A truly beautiful piece struck in
the era of “say, buddy, can you spare a dime.” Fortunately
for us, someone “spared” this dime from the rigors of
circulation in the days of the Great Depression. Exquisite!
PCGS# 4983.
Page 58
1349 1931-D MS-66+ FB (PCGS). Satiny and smooth, this
solidly graded premium Gem also offers razor sharp
definition throughout the design. A generally brilliant piece,
a few wisps of light russet iridescence over the lower reverse
are easily overlooked. A splendid overall example of this
popular low-mintage semi-key date in the Mercury dime
series. Worthy of strong bidder support.
PCGS# 4985.
1350 1936 Proof-65 (PCGS). Radiant mint brilliance greets the
viewer from both sides of this expertly preserved and highly
attractive Gem. One of only 4,130 Proofs of the date struck
in the first year of Proof coinage in the denomination since
1915. Gem Proofs of the date are always well-received by
our bidders.
PCGS# 5071.
1354 1877 Proof-65 (NGC). Enchanting steel-olive and silver
gray iridescence greets the viewer from both sides, the
toning lightest over the right half of the obverse. Fully struck
and highly appealing, more direct viewing angles call forth
both colorful undertones and uniform reflectivity to the
finish. This Proof-only issue is from the third of just four
years of the denomination — no circulation strikes were
forthcoming from any mint in 1877 and the final year of
the type, 1878. Only 350 Proofs of the date were produced, a
tiny output by any standards.
PCGS# 5305.
Quarter Dollars
1351 1940-D MS-68 FB (PCGS). CAC. Ringed in vivid
multicolored peripheral toning, this charming Superb Gem
also sports billowy mint frost and silky smooth, virtually
pristine surfaces. The last reported auction appearance of
this grade in a PCGS holder was in 2006, so these clearly
don’t come up for auction often.
PCGS# 5025.
1352 1942/1 FS-101. AU-58 (PCGS). This brilliant, outwardly
smooth, and predominantly lustrous example has stronger
eye appeal than many lower-end Mint State ‘42/1 dimes
that we have handled over the years. Numerous examples of
this popular overdate were found by enterprising New York
City subway token employees once word of its discovery
and value — more than a dime — got out; they had privy to
searching countless dimes in a day, and many were found in
this manner. Worthy of a solid bid!
1355 1822 B-1. Rarity-2. EF-45 (PCGS). Rich charcoal-russet
outlines to the devices give way to lighter olive-gray patina
elsewhere. Boldly, if not sharply defined throughout, with
uncommonly smooth surfaces for a lightly circulated Large
Size Capped Bust quarter. The Choice EF grade would make
an excellent addition to a mid-range type set, and we suspect
numerous collectors will be in the chase for this specimen.
PCGS# 5332.
1356 1831 B-5. Rarity-2. Large Letters. MS-61 (NGC). Boldly
toned in a blend of iridescent steel gray and silver-rose, this
satiny BU type candidate offers outwardly smooth surfaces
and sharp central devices. By this time the quarter dollar had
become one of the mainstays in commerce, and the number
of pieces minted was well into the six-figure range for all of
the dates in the design type, 1831 through 1838. Pleasing
Mint State examples of the design type are always in demand.
PCGS# 5349.
PCGS# 5036.
Twenty-Cent Pieces
1353 1876 MS-63 (PCGS). This semi-prooflike piece exhibits
good contrast between modestly reflective fields and satiny,
fully impressed devices. Brilliant apart from delicate goldengray overtones, and positively free of singularly distracting
abrasions. Only 14,400 examples of the date were struck
in this, the final year of coinage intended for circulation in
this short-lived series. Mint State examples of the date make
excellent type coins.
PCGS# 5299.
1357 1845/845 Briggs 3-C, FS-301. Repunched Date. MS-64
(NGC). CAC. This is an endearing piece with soft, satiny
luster and light, mottled, olive-gray patina. Sharply struck,
as well, and an important find for the advanced Liberty
Seated quarter collector. An exciting specimen to study as
the repunched date feature is sharp and easily discerned
with a loupe. Furthermore, this handsome coin is tied with
two others at most as the finest seen of this elusive blundered
die. Both grading services will differentiate this blundered
date in their respective Census and Population Report, and
between both there are three grading events at this level, and
none noted finer. Only nine grading events are noted in total
by both grading services of this repunched date variety.
PCGS# 395928.
NGC Census: 2; none seen finer of the FS-301 Repunched Date variety.
Page 59
Gem 1853 Arrows and Rays Quarter
1358 1853 Arrows and Rays. MS-65 (NGC). Billowy satin luster mingles with wisps of iridescent golden-apricot on both sides of this
beautiful Gem. The technical quality is just as impressive as the eye appeal, with razor sharp devices and smooth, distraction free
surfaces. An always popular one-year type, the Arrows and Rays quarters came to be due to the rising price of silver. Minor coins
were hoarded and melted for more than their face value. To keep the statutory weight in line with the intrinsic value, the weight
was reduced in 1853. Distinctive arrows by the date and rays around the eagle on the reverse were added to flag these as the lighter
weight pieces, thus encouraging their circulation. While easily found even at the lower Mint State levels, Gems such as this are few
and far between in today’s market. If you are assembling a high grade type set, this is a coin for you!
PCGS# 5426.
NGC Population: 26; 11 finer
Excessively Rare AU 1860-S Quarter
1359 1860-S Briggs 1-A, the only known dies. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS). This is an impressive piece that is worthy of serious
consideration among advanced Liberty Seated quarter collectors. There is an exceptional amount of remaining detail for an issue
that is typically encountered heavily worn. With sharp to full definition to the focal features, in fact, the details grade is perhaps
better described as Choice AU. There is little wear, and only a few minuscule abrasions, and even the cleaning is minor and easily
forgiven. Satiny in texture and brilliant apart from speckles of light copper-russet iridescence, it really would not surprise us to
hear that this coin finds its way into a graded holder. With a mintage of only 56,000 pieces, the 1860-S Liberty Seated quarter is a
well-known rarity in all grades. Struck to meet the needs of a West that was starved for small change, these coins were not saved but
rather saw heavy commercial use. Most survivors are found well worn, impaired or both. PCGS has not graded a single Mint State
or even strict AU specimen, and NGC has certified just a lone MS-61. This coin would certainly be a centerpiece in an advanced
Liberty Seated quarter collection. Worthy of a close look!
PCGS# 5453.
Page 60
1360 1861 Proof-63 (PCGS). Splashes of vivid, iridescent blue
and reddish-orange toning are both bolder and more varied
on the obverse. The eye appeal is superior for the assigned
grade, and there are no singularly mentionable blemishes. A
glittering Proof from the first year of the Civil War — Civil
War issues make for an exciting sub-category in numismatics
owing to the diversity of the issues and denominations circa
1861 to 1865.
PCGS# 5557.
1361 1863 Proof-63 Cameo (PCGS). Lightly toned in warm
golden-honey, this smartly impressed piece readily reveals
reflective fields as the surfaces dip into a light. Satiny in
texture otherwise, with no outwardly noticeable contact
marks. The Guide Book lists an estimated 460 Proofs of the
date and denomination, struck while the Civil war raged not
far from Philadelphia. That figure is the lowest listed in the
reference through the end of the series in 1891.
PCGS# 85559.
1364 1873 Arrows. Proof-65 (PCGS). Secure Holder. Awash in
a blend of rich olive-charcoal and mauve-gray toning, the
obverse contrasts with a lighter reverse ringed in cobalt blue
and champagne-red iridescence. Crisply impressed with a
uniformly mirrored finish, the desirability of this coin for
Gem Proof type purposes is strong. The estimated Proof
output for quarter dollars of the date was just 500 pieces in
the first of two years that saw arrows at the date to note a tiny
increase in the silver content of the issue. A pleasing Gem at
every turn.
PCGS# 5574.
1365 1874 Arrows. Proof-64 (ANACS). This pretty piece
exhibits rich target toning in charcoal-blue, smoky gray,
olive-gold, midnight blue, and salmon pink. The most vivid
colors are reserved for the reverse, but both sides are equally
well endowed with razor sharp striking detail and outwardly
smooth surfaces. The Proof mintage for this popular issue
was 700 pieces according to the Guide Book.
1362 1865 Proof-66 (PCGS). CAC. OGH. A premium quality
coin in all regards, this specimen offers razor-sharp striking
detail, silky smooth surfaces, and delightful iridescent
toning. More direct angles also call forth bold field to device
contrast, suggesting that this coin could receive a Cameo
designation were it resubmitted to PCGS in today’s market.
Sure to sell for a strong bid! From an estimated Proof
mintage for this terminal year Civil War coinage of 500
pieces, one of the lowest suggested Proof mintages of the
entire design type from 1859 through 1891.
PCGS# 5575.
1366 1874 Arrows. MS-64 (PCGS). Razor sharp in strike
with smooth, satiny surfaces, mottled apricot, olive and
silver gray patina further enhances the desirability of this
handsome near-Gem. From the second of two years of the
design type with arrows at the date to signify a tiny statutory
increase in the silver content of the denomination.
PCGS# 5494.
PCGS# 5561.
1363 1868 Proof-65 (PCGS). OGH—First Generation. This
wonderfully original Gem is awash in rich lavender-copper
patina through which more vivid rose, blue and apricot
undertones shine as the surfaces rotate under a light. A razor
sharp specimen with nary a detracting blemish in evidence.
One of just 600 Proofs of the date produced against a
circulation strike mintage for the date of only 29,400 pieces,
making for a scarce issue in any production format.
PCGS# 5567.
1367 1876 Proof-66 Cameo (NGC). Vivid cobalt blue and
reddish-rose peripheral toning is particularly impressive
on the obverse of this beautiful premium Gem. A strong
candidate for inclusion in a high grade Proof type or date
set. A glorious Gem Proof from our nation’s Centennial
year, one of 1,150 examples struck.
PCGS# 85577.
1368 1880 MS-65 (PCGS). Brilliant with highly lustrous satin to
semi-prooflike surfaces, this razor sharp Gem would make
an impressive addition to a high-quality type or date set.
A faint planchet drift mark near the lower right obverse
border is as made and noted here solely for accuracy. From
a modest mintage for the date of 13,600 pieces.
PCGS# 5512.
Page 61
1369 1883 Proof-65 (PCGS). CAC—Gold Label. OGH—First
Generation. Exquisite silky smooth surfaces are knocking
on the door of a significantly higher grade. Brilliant apart
from the lightest golden iridescence, there is also enough
field-to-device contrast to suggest a Cameo designation by
today’s grading standards. PQ in all regards! One of 1,039
Proofs of the date struck against a circulation strike mintage
of just 14,400 pieces.
PCGS# 5584.
1373 1890 Proof-65 Cameo (NGC). Warm, even, charcoal gray
patina envelops both sides, the toning with an iridescent
quality that allows ready appreciation of the underlying
Proof finish as the coin rotates under a light. Fully struck,
outwardly smooth, and solidly graded as a Gem. A real
beauty and a numismatic treat from a Proof mintage for the
date of just 590 pieces, with that figure among the lowest
Proof tallies within the design type.
PCGS# 85591.
1370 1886 Proof-66 Cameo (PCGS). Fully impressed with a soft,
satiny texture, the devices offer stark contrast to watery,
reflective fields. Ringed in delicate reddish-gold peripheral
toning, this outstanding Gem is sure to please even the
most discerning numismatist. One of 886 Proofs of the date
produced.
PCGS# 85587.
1371 1887 Proof-64 Cameo (PCGS). Ringed in pale golden
peripheral iridescence, this otherwise brilliant specimen
would fit nicely into a high grade type or date set of Proof
coinage. A pleasing survivor from a Proof mintage for the
date of just 710 pieces.
1374 1893-S MS-65 (NGC). This sharply impressed, highly lustrous
Gem is untoned apart from the lightest golden iridescence.
This is a low mintage date and mint and one of the classic
semi-key issues of the Barber quarter series. At the Gem
level only a handful are known, and finer pieces are virtually
unobtainable. A stunning, satiny prize for the date and mint
collector who appreciates the Gem level of preservation.
PCGS# 5606.
NGC Census: only 5; 2 finer through MS-67.
PCGS# 85588.
1372 1888-S Briggs 3-C. MS-64 (NGC). Layers of rich
multicolored toning blanket both sides of this supremely
attractive near-Gem. With solid technical quality, as
well, this better date S-mint example is sure to entice the
advanced Liberty Seated quarter collector. From the first
year of quarter dollar coinage at San Francisco since 1878,
and the final year from that edifice until the demise of the
type in 1891.
PCGS# 5521.
1375 1897 Proof-68 Cameo (NGC). Vividly toned in rich
multicolored iridescence, this delightful specimen also
offers freedom from even the most trivial blemishes. More
direct angles also call forth modest yet appreciable cameo
contrast. From a Proof mintage for the date of 731 pieces,
of which the present beauty is among the finest known
survivors.
PCGS# 5683.
NGC Census: 18; none finer within any designation. Six of the 18 are Proof; nine are Cameo as
here; three are Ultra Cameo.
1376 1897 Proof-64 (PCGS). Streaks of olive, mauve, silver, and
pale gold greet the viewer from both sides of this charming
near-Gem. Fully struck throughout the design, with strong
reflectivity shining forth from the fields as the surfaces
rotate under a light. From a Proof mintage for the date of
731 pieces, and a choice representative of the date and grade
combination.
PCGS# 5683.
Page 62
Glorious Superb Gem Deep Cameo Proof
1898 Barber Quarter
1377 1898 Proof-68 Deep Cameo (PCGS). Adorned with delicate silver-rose patina, the reverse contrasts with an obverse that is brilliant
apart from subtle golden-apricot iridescence here and there around the periphery. Field to device contrast is as sharp as one should
expect in an example of this uncommonly well produced Proof Barber quarter issue, and the surfaces are virtually flawless without
so much as a single trivial blemish in evidence. Beautiful!The total mintage was 735 pieces for this date in Proof. Perhaps ten to
fifteen percent of these display the Deep Cameo contrast. Considering this fact, and the towering grade awarded, there simply can’t
be more than a handful that can offer these combined and most desirable attributes. Why not add this beauty to your advanced
collection?
PCGS# 95684.
PCGS Population: 8; only 2 are finer (Proof-69 Deep Cameo finest) within the Deep Cameo category.
1378 1898 Proof-68 (NGC). Vividly toned in a patchwork of
olive-copper, blue, lilac-silver, and golden-apricot, this is a
truly outstanding example of both the issue and the type.
Readily among the finest survivors from a Proof mintage
for the date of 735 pieces. Vibrant in finish and virtually
pristine, this gorgeous Superb Gem is worthy of a premium
bid.
1379 1901 Proof-66 (PCGS). Whereas delicate silver gray
iridescence blankets the reverse, the obverse of this radiant
specimen is bedecked in a patchwork of charcoal-blue and
light apricot iridescence. Deeply mirrored in finish, and
expertly preserved to support the premium Gem rating
from PCGS. One of 813 Proofs of the date struck.
PCGS# 5687.
PCGS# 5684.
Page 63
Key 1901-S Barber Quarter
1380 1901-S VF-20 (PCGS). This richly and evenly toned example is draped in bold charcoal-olive patina. With all major design elements
sharp and the surfaces outwardly smooth in appearance, this key date quarter is sure to have little difficulty finding its way into
a specialized collection of Barber coinage. One of the classic 20th century U.S. Mint rarities, the 1901-S is far and away the most
challenging of the three key date Barber quarters to collect. With a mintage of just 72,664, it is second only to the 1913-S in terms
of quantities struck, but is much more difficult to find than its later San Francisco Mint counterpart. Interest in date and mintmark
combinations had not taken hold by the time the 1901-S was struck, and examples were not singled out for saving. Nice circulated
examples are rare in any grade, and this mid-grade coin is especially desirable.
PCGS# 5630.
1381 1901-S VF Details—Tooled (PCGS). Secure Holder. This
mostly silver-gray example does exhibit splashes of light
olive patina here and there around the peripheries. Well
defined in a mid-grade Barber quarter, this key date coin is
quite pleasing in hand. Indeed, concentrations of hairlines
are not outwardly distracting at all angles, and the “Tooled”
qualifier from PCGS seems a bit harsh in our opinion.
Worthy of a close look, as this ‘01-S has a lot going for it.
One of the three most important key dates in the Barber
quarter series, the 1901-S handily outdistances the other
two dates, 1896-S and 1913-S, in both the rarity and the
value categories. The value for the date in just VG is given
as $10,000 in the 2015 Guide Book, in which reference no
other date comes remotely close in value to the 1901-S in
any listed grade.
PCGS# 5630.
Page 64
1382 1908 Proof-67 (PCGS). This beautiful Superb Gem exhibits
smooth surfaces with blue and sea green highlights. A
paltry mintage of 545 pieces for the entire year in Proof was
forthcoming, and this is certainly one of the absolute finest
seen today, missing the absolute finest category by a single
grade point. Handsome in toning and glorious in quality, a
perfect collector combination.
PCGS# 5694.
1383 1910 Proof-64 (PCGS). Dusted with light, mottled,
pale silver iridescence, this endearing specimen offers
uncommon field to device contrast in a late date Proof
Barber quarter, even though a Cameo designation is not
included as part of the certified grade. The Proof mintage for
this date was a modest 551 pieces, one of the lowest Proof
production tallies in the design type. Worthy of a strong bid.
PCGS# 5696.
1387 1913-S Good-4 (PCGS). A wholesome example of this
key date issue, richly toned golden-charcoal surfaces retain
outline definition to most devices. The all important date
and S mintmark are clear. The 1913-S Barber quarter is a
key date in all grades, and this sale presents more than one
opportunity to obtain a low-grade but fulfilling example of
the date.
PCGS# 5666.
1384 1911 Proof-66 Cameo (PCGS). CAC. Delicate golden
iridescence engages both sides of this smooth, boldly
cameoed specimen. A simply gorgeous Gem with much
to offer a high-quality type or date collector. From a Proof
mintage for the date of 543 pieces, one of the lowest Proof
production runs in the design type.
PCGS# 85697.
1388 1916 Barber. MS-66 (PCGS). Frosty and vibrant on both
sides, this silky smooth Gem combines a peripherally toned
reverse with an obverse that is layered in vivid olive-gold
and reddish-apricot. A worthwhile Gem from the final year
of coinage in the Barber quarter dollar series.
PCGS# 5673.
1389 1916-D MS-66 (PCGS). Bursting with intensely radiant
mint frost, this otherwise brilliant Gem exhibits lovely
copper-blue toning highlights here and there around the
peripheries. One of the finer examples known from this
final year of issue, furthermore it is from the Denver Mint,
which issued quite a number of Barber quarters this year,
but was then silent for a few months until the launch of the
new Standing Liberty quarter type began in 1917.
PCGS# 5674.
1385 1912 Proof-67 (NGC). Vivid reddish-apricot and pale
gold undertones shine forth powerfully through a layer of
dominant olive-charcoal patina. This is an exquisite piece
— fully struck, expertly preserved, and with undeniable
originality. One of 700 Proofs of the date struck, with the
present beauty readily among the finest Proofs of the date to
be found in a NGC holder.
PCGS# 5698.
1386 1913-S Good-6 (PCGS). This well balanced and original
Good exhibits handsome pearl and dove gray toning to
overall smooth looking surfaces. One of the “big three’
rarities of the design type, all of which emanated from the
San Francisco Mint. The 1913-S enjoyed a mintage of just
40,000 pieces which represents the lowest production run
of any Barber quarter — you must go all the way back to the
1891-O quarter dollar to find a lower mintage figure in the
denomination. Always desirable in any grade, as bidding for
this lot will no doubt illustrate.
PCGS# 5666.
1390 1917 Type I. MS-66 FH (PCGS). CAC. Frosty and vibrant,
this charming Gem also sports razor sharp striking detail
and subtle olive-apricot peripheral toning. Hermon
MacNeil’s Standing Liberty quarter design — one of several
new design types among denominations in the early 20th
century that served to revamp and modernize America’s
coinage — is seen at its best advantage in the Type I issues
of 1916 and 1917. Later in 1917 MacNeil’s original barebreasted design type was changed somewhat with Liberty
now wearing chain mail armor and with three stars below
the reverse eagle. The design was revamped a second time
in 1925 to strengthen the date features.
PCGS# 5707.
1391 1917 Type I. MS-66 FH (PCGS). Frosty and smooth,
this splendid Gem is also possessed of attractive toning in
mottled blue-gray and crimson-gold. An ever-popular date
and type owing to the rarity of the 1916 Standing Liberty
type I quarter; the design type saw production in just two
years.
PCGS# 5707.
1392 1917 Type I. MS-65 FH (PCGS). CAC. Beautifully toned
in iridescent champagne-gold, this endearing Gem is as
sharp and smooth as only a Gem 1917 Type I quarter can
be. Perhaps the perfect grade and value blend for today’s
collectors.
PCGS# 5707.
Page 65
Rare and Desirable 1918/7-S
Standing Liberty Quarter in Mint State
1393 1918/7-S FS-101. MS-62 (NGC). This richly toned example exhibits dominant antique gold iridescence on the obverse with
speckled russet highlights in the protected areas around the devices and along the border. The reverse is even more boldly toned in
warm, even, rose-gray patina. Suitably lustrous for the assigned grade, with uncommonly smooth surfaces in a BU Standing Liberty
quarter, especially an example of the conditionally challenging 1918/7-S. This is one of the great silver rarities of the 20th Century.
After its discovery in the 1930s, the hunt was on to secure an example from circulation. Soon collectors figured out that there were
not many forthcoming and prices began to rise. Considering the facts that nearly 20 years had passed before these were noticed,
most entered circulation and stayed there. Therefore, Mint State examples survived at random, and there were not many produced
to begin with, so these Mint State coins are rare today. David Hall estimates that less than 100 Mint State survivors exist, and
furthermore probably not more than 1,000 of these are known today in all grades. Hence collectors who are serious about finding
one of these, especially in Mint State, should attempt to acquire any that are offered like this handsome example.
The obverse overdate was created when the dies were being hubbed, or stamped with the design for coinage. Two different hubs
were used for whatever reason to bring up the design on the new die, one however was dated 1917, the other 1918! This type of
overdate is highly unusual, but includes such notable overdate coins as the 1918/7-D Buffalo nickel, both 1942/1 dimes and the
1909/8 double eagle. As these were created with master hubs of two different dates, the undertype date is nearly as prominent as the
later date on each die and coin.
PCGS# 5726.
NGC Census: 19; 27 finer (Mint State-67 finest) within the designation.
1394 1918/7-S FS-101. VF Details—Smoothed (PCGS). There is plenty of bold definition on both sides to appreciate the design, and the
all important overdate feature is readily evident even without the aid of a loupe. The obverse is essentially untoned, but for the reverse
we note an even overlay of iridescent olive-charcoal patina. Lightly tooled overall, a benefit of which is the lack of outwardly distracting
abrasions. The 1918/7-S quarter represents the first overdate in the denomination since the 1823/2 issue, though some will call the 1853/4
quarter an “overdate” for lack of a better term.
PCGS# 5726.
Remarkable Perfectly Centered Broadstruck 1919 Quarter
1395 1919—Broadstruck—MS-67 FH (NGC). Sparkling white and lustrous throughout, with the central and peripheral devices mostly
bold, save for the extreme periphery which shows the expected drawn areas, in particular on the reverse. Given the apparent size of the
resultant error this coin was undoubtedly struck out of the collar and, indeed, there is no reeding around the edge. The date is obvious as
to when the coin was struck, but the tops of three of the digits are distended to a degree, but not enough to make the date 1919 illegible.
The strike is rather extraordinary with tremendous depth on Liberty’s head and shield. Full mint luster throughout mixes with a touch of
light gold toning and a few tiny russet specks. Standing Liberty quarter mint errors are extremely rare in any grade, at the Superb Gem
level there certainly can’t be more than a few if, indeed, the present offering is not unique in quality for such a blunder. The surfaces are
virtually pristine, with no distracting bagmarks, scuffs or other blemishes.
PCGS# E5729.
Ex: Just Having Fun Collection.
Page 66
1396 1919-S MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. Delightful brilliant white
surfaces are also free of significant abrasions. Fully Choice in
quality, with vibrant satin luster and bold to sharp definition
to most design elements. A scarce date in Mint State grades,
and a date that often causes a bidding stir when offered for
public sale.
PCGS# 5732.
1399 1924-S MS-64 FH (PCGS). CAC. Brilliant apart from a
few swirls of extremely faint sandy gold iridescence, this
vibrantly lustrous near-Gem would make an impressive
addition to an advanced SLQ set. The strike is crisp, as noted
by the FH designation, and the eye appeal befits and defines
the grade admirably.
PCGS# 5751.
1400 1929 MS-66 FH (PCGS). Smartly impressed with billowy
satin to softly frosted luster, this charming Gem belongs in
a high quality type or date set. A sharply struck beauty from
the waning years of the design type — in the next year, 1930,
the series would become history.
PCGS# 5773.
1397 1923-S AU-58 (PCGS). Sharply defined with appreciable
satin luster remaining, this otherwise untoned piece exhibits
mottled russet highlights at the borders. This popular semikey branch mint issue is one of just four dates in the design
type with a Guide Book value of three figures or higher in the
Good-4 column. Choice for the grade.
Lustrous Gem 1932-S
Washington Quarter
None Graded Finer by NGC
PCGS# 5744.
1398 1924-S MS-65 FH (NGC). Crisply impressed with brilliant
satin surfaces, this is an impressive survivor of an important
strike and condition rarity among S-mint Standing Liberty
quarters. This Gem condition semi-key date will be a grand
addition to a Liberty Standing quarter set or advanced U.S.
type set.
PCGS# 5751.
1401 1932-S MS-66 (NGC). Vibrant neon-green iridescence
is blended with subtle violet hues throughout this
splendid premium Gem. The satiny surfaces cartwheel
with unwavering luster, complimenting the evenly and
boldly pronounced design elements on both sides.
Along with its counterpart from the Denver Mint, the
1932-S Washington quarter ranks as one of the most
important key dates for this popular design type. The
present piece is an ideal candidate for inclusion in a
Registry Setor other world-class collecting endeavor.
They just don’t come any finer than this one!
PCGS# 5792.
NGC Census: only 5; none finer.
Page 67
1402 1936 Proof-67 (NGC). Peripheral russet and golden tones
accent the mostly brilliant surfaces of this Superb Gem. The
devices are well struck and pair nicely with the reflective,
watery fields on both sides. From the first year of Proof
production in the denomination since 1915. Just 3,837
Proofs of this issue were struck, a small mintage by later
20th century U.S. Mint standards. Choice and appealing.
PCGS# 5975.
NGC Census: 21; 0 finer.
1403 1936 Proof-65 (NGC). Brilliant silver white surfaces are
fully struck, outwardly smooth, and solidly graded at the
Gem Proof level. A flashy Gem Proof from the first year of
such coinage in the denomination since 1915. Only 3,837
Proofs of the date were struck.
PCGS# 5975.
1404 1936-D MS-66 (PCGS). Smooth, lustrous, otherwise silvertinged surfaces are ringed in light russet rim toning. A
popular semi-key Denver Mint issue that is well-received
whenever we offer a Gem specimen, and this time should
prove no different.
1406 Complete “Short Set” of Circulation Strike Washington
Quarters, 1941-1964. MS-66. All coins are individually
encapsulated, and all are certified by NGC except for the
1943-D, which is certified by PCGS. This set is complete
for all issues within the parameters and date range outlined
above; there are two identically graded and certified
examples of the 1955-D. This is a well matched set with
virtually all examples displaying either brilliant or minimally
toned surfaces. (Total: 62 coins)
PCGS# 5801.
1405 1938-S MS-67 (PCGS). Gorgeous olive-gold sand reddishrose iridescence is largely confined to the reverse of this
brightly lustrous, silky smooth Superb Gem. An amply
pleasing specimen that happens to be as fine as you will
currently find in a PCGS holder.
PCGS# 5807.
PCGS Population: 46; none finer within any designation. Three of the 46 are designated “+”
by PCGS.
1407 1943-S FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. MS-65+ (PCGS).
Secure Holder. Radiant frosty white surfaces are free of
both toning and grade limiting abrasions. A lovely piece that
is sure to excite the Washington quarter variety collector.
PCGS# 5823.
Page 68
Half Dollars
1408 1795 O-110. Rarity-3. Two Leaves. Fine Details—
Cleaning (PCGS). A popular variety with collectors due
to the repunching on the digit 9 in the date, the present
example is well defined for the grade with all devices
boldly outlined. Some sharper detail also remains in the
more protected areas of the design. Mostly bright silver in
appearance, the surfaces reveal charcoal gray outlines to the
devices, as well as swirls of variegated color over and before
the obverse portrait. A nice mid grade coin that offers both
definition and reasonable eye appeal for this first year type
coin of the Flowing Hair design.
PCGS# 6052.
1409 1795 O-128. Rarity-5+. Small Head, Two Leaves. VG
Details—Scratch (PCGS). Iridescent steel gray overtones
give way to silvery brilliance as the surfaces dip into a light.
This piece retains bold outline definition to all devices,
the recesses of Liberty’s hair and the eagle’s plumage even
presenting as relatively bold. Cleaned at one time, with a
moderate scratch in the right obverse field that is also worthy
of note. The Small Head refers to the size of Liberty’s head,
as two distinctive punches were used to make the obverse
dies. The Small Head style is only seen on three dies, each
of which is seldom seen and rather scarce compared to most
other 1795 obverse dies.
PCGS# 6054.
1410 1805 O-112. Rarity-2. EF-40 (PCGS). Wisps of iridescent
rose peripheral toning engage otherwise silver gray surfaces.
Free of significant abrasions and generally well defined for
the grade, softness of strike to the reverse high points is
attributable to the light adjustment marks (as made) present
in those areas. One of the nicer examples of this die pairing,
and while not within the Condition Census, certainly
represents a desirable coin that will suit any advanced variety
collector. The reverse die later forms a cud over portions of
STATES in a multiple die state failure.
PCGS# 6069.
1411 1806 O-119. Rarity-3. Pointed 9, Stem, Through Claw.
EF-45 (NGC). Sandy pearl and rose-gray overtones
yield to lighter pale silver patina toward the peripheries.
Boldly defined for a lightly circulated survivor of this die
marriage, a lack of outwardly distracting abrasions is also
a praiseworthy attribute. This coin would make a good
type choice or also would serve to represent this variety
well as the high technical grade allows ample definition to
study, and the high quality of the surfaces are inviting too.
A pleasing example of this early and popular Draped Bust,
Heraldic Eagle style.
1413 1806 O-120a. Rarity-4. Pointed 6, Stem Through Claw.
VF-35 (PCGS). Satiny, somewhat matte-like surfaces are
generally untoned with a light silver appearance. The devices
are well defined for the grade apart from characteristic
softness of strike in the center of the obverse, and there are
no singularly distracting abrasions to report. This reverse
die deteriorated in an unusual fashion, with chips falling
out of the die along the base of the horizontal shield lines.
Many of the known examples show various states of this
happening, and few are alike as the die kept losing more
pieces as striking coins continued. This high grade example
offers ample eye appeal and nice collector quality.
PCGS# 6071.
1414 1807 Draped Bust. O-102. Rarity-2. EF Details—Damage
(PCGS). Handsome olive-russet patina outlines the devices
on both sides of this otherwise lilac-gray example. Cleaned
at one time, several prominent digs and scrapes on the
obverse explain the qualifier from PCGS. This is the final
year of issue of the Draped Bust design on half dollars,
which were changed in late 1807 to the Capped Bust style.
Although a bit worse for wear, this scarce 1807 half dollar
still offers most of the original definition on Liberty’s hair
and the eagle’s wings retain many of the fine feather details.
PCGS# 6079.
1415 1807 Draped Bust. O-105. Rarity-1. VF-35 (PCGS).
Evenly toned in bold olive-gray, this well balanced Choice
VF is well defined throughout with outwardly smooth
surfaces. Speckles of lighter pale silver color provide
somewhat of a mottled appearance to the central obverse.
This is the final year of issue for the Draped Bust half dollar,
with Mint Engraver John Reich hired in 1807 to redesign
our coinage, one of the first new designs to appear is the
Capped Bust half dollar in 1807, struck soon after this coin
entered circulation.
PCGS# 6079.
1416 1810 O-102a. Rarity-2. AU-53 (PCGS). OGH. This is a
brilliant, satin white survivor with uncommonly strong eye
appeal in a lightly circulated, early date Capped Bust half.
If you have been looking for a splendid, high grade 1810
half dollar, look no further than this delightful jewel. The
eye appeal will dazzle you as well.
PCGS# 6095.
PCGS# 6071.
1412 1806 O-120. Rarity-3. Pointed 6, Stem Through Claw. EF45 (PCGS). Boldly defined throughout with considerable
satin luster remaining, this problem free Choice EF would
make a fitting addition to a high grade circulated type set.
Attractive in all ways for this early die state of this variety.
Seldom are 1806 half dollars found this well preserved
and collector demand is strong when these appear on the
market.
PCGS# 6071.
1417 1817 O-110a. Rarity-2. MS-62 (PCGS). This is an
undeniably original piece with blue-gray peripheral
highlights to otherwise dominant sandy-silver patina. Satiny
in texture and uncommonly smooth for the assigned grade,
there is much to recommend this coin to the Mint State type
collector. A scarce die variety this well preserved, but not
quite in the condition census. This series is highly popular
today as there are a number of dates and varieties that are
available in moderate to high grades and many come with
enticing and colorful toning. Why not try out a date run of
these half dollars and throw in a few overdates too, and soon
these will become a collecting favorite in your collection.
PCGS# 6109.
Page 69
1418 1820 O-103. Rarity-1. Curl Base 2, Small Date. AU-58
(NGC). CAC. Smooth, billowy, nearly full satin luster
is draped in gorgeous pinkish-silver patina that speaks
volumes about the originality of this impressive early
date Capped Bust half dollar. A scarce and desirable date,
especially at this lofty grade level. Although not quite in the
Condition Census for this variety, this example is right on
the cusp of that level and worthy of any advanced collection.
PCGS# 39563.
1419 1825 O-113. Rarity-1. MS-62 (NGC). Blended sandyorange and silver-lilac patina blankets both sides of this
boldly defined and uncommonly smooth BU example. Close
to or just within the lower range of the Condition Census
for the variety, and thus highly desirable for the specialist
of this series. Scarce as a type coin as well, with most of the
Mint State survivors of this series dated in the 1830s, rather
than this earlier 1825 issue. Mint State coins from this era
are comparative bargains today.
PCGS# 6142.
1420 1825 O-115. Rarity-3. AU-58 (PCGS). With brilliant, highly
lustrous surfaces and freedom from worrisome abrasions,
this lovely near-Mint example would do equally well in a
high grade type, date or variety set. A solid representative
in that sought after collector grade with just two points of
circulation on the uppermost devices.
PCGS# 6142.
1423 1829 O-115. Rarity-1. MS-63 (PCGS). Handsome steel gray
and antique gold toning greets the viewer from both sides of
this satiny and smooth-looking piece. A handsome example
that will add pizzazz to any type or variety collection as
there has always been strong demand for Choice examples
from the Capped Bust half dollar series. Add to the technical
grade the pleasing toning and sharp strike and you have
a coin that many collectors will certainly want to own. A
desirable example in all regards.
PCGS# 6154.
1424 1830 O-103. Rarity-1. Small 0. MS-63 (NGC). Outwardly
smooth with boldly toned surfaces, both sides exhibit a rich
blend of mauve-gray, steel gray and olive-gold. The texture is
a bit curious with somewhat of a glossy sheen, though bold
to sharp definition enhances the coin’s appeal, especially for
Mint State type purposes. A desirable example that offers
both the Choice Mint State grade and colorful toning to
delight the eye.
PCGS# 6156.
1421 1826 O-108a. Rarity-1. MS-64 (NGC). This is a handsome,
richly original piece layered in blended antique gold and
copper-russet patina. Satiny and smooth, with a razor sharp
strike to boot. Tied with a trio of others as fourth finest
of the “a” die state for this variety, and highly desirable as
Condition Census coins always receive the most collector
attention. Don’t miss out if you are seeking a strong example
of this later die state for your collection.
PCGS# 6143.
1422 1829/7 O-102. Rarity-2. MS-61 (NGC). This otherwise
satiny piece reveals decided semi-prooflike reflectivity on
the reverse as that side of the coin rotates under a light.
Peripherally toned in handsome olive-russet around silver
gray centers, a tiny dig on each side are the only readily
evident abrasions on this otherwise outwardly smooth
example. Scarce at this grade level and in strong demand for
the overdate feature. This is likely in the top dozen known
for this issue of the most desirable early die state, and a
pleasing coin that will add depth to any advanced collection.
PCGS# 6155.
1425 1830 O-118. Rarity-3. Small 0. MS-64 (PCGS). Lovely
satin white surfaces are boldly struck, lustrous and free of all
but light toning in isolated peripheral areas. This example
is within the Condition Census for the variety as noted in
Steve Herrman’s Auction & Mail Bid Prices Realized for
Bust Half Dollars 1794 - 1839 and would rank as tied with
two others or so at the fourth position. Although a plentiful
die pairing, at this splendid grade level this is indeed quite a
desirable specimen.
PCGS# 6156.
1426 1833 O-108. Rarity-1. MS-62 (NGC). Vibrant satin to semireflective luster shines forth powerfully through an overlay
of blended olive, lilac-gray and reddish-orange iridescence.
Boldly defined from a well centered strike, with surfaces
that appear smooth enough to suggest a higher Mint State
rating. A pleasing example for the type, date or variety
collector who is looking for a nice Uncirculated specimen
that borders on the Choice category.
PCGS# 6163.
Page 70
1427 1833 O-115. Rarity-5+. AU Details—Improperly Cleaned
(NGC). Sandy-silver patina blankets both sides and helps to
conceal a somewhat glossy texture from a cleaning. Plenty of
sharper detail remains in and around the centers, and there
are no outwardly distracting abrasions. This coin would be
of Condition Census quality for this rare die variety but
the surfaces have been cleaned. The Census currently reads
MS-63, AU-55, AU-50, AU-50 cleaned and this specimen
AU-50 cleaned, making this piece tied with one other as the
fourth best seen. This coin is certain to attract the attention
of the Capped Bust half dollar variety specialists as these are
seldom offered in high grade and most of those noted in
the Census have been locked away in collections and will
probably remain so for years to come.
PCGS# 6163.
1428 1834 O-106. Rarity-1. Large Date, Small Letters. MS-63
(NGC). Blended smoky gray and reddish-apricot patina
envelops both sides of this evenly and boldly struck piece.
The toning subdues the luster somewhat, thereby explaining
the assigned grade, but the surfaces are outwardly smooth
with no distracting abrasions. This is a solid representative
of this die pairing that is plentiful enough to not bring
a premium, yet offers high quality and elegant surfaces.
Destined for hours of admiration by the lucky collector who
wins this lot.
1431 1837 Reeded Edge. 50 CENTS. GR-11. Rarity-5. AU-58
(NGC). This bold to sharp near-Mint piece is lightly toned
in steel gray iridescence that appears to drift toward the
rims. Free of singularly mentionable abrasions, with flickers
of original luster peering from the protected areas around
the devices. Not only is this an outstanding, near Mint State
example of this popular short lived type coin, but this is a
rare die pairing as well. At present, this example is the second
finest seen from these dies and a tough variety to locate at all,
at the Rarity-5 level. Rare issues like this always command
a strong price and while still early in the collecting of this
series by variety, it won’t be long until these become more
and more popular with collectors. After the studies of the
Reeded Edge half dollars by Jules Reiver, and his published
work on the half dollars of 1836 to 1839 numismatist Dick
Graham decided to really study this group of coins and came
out with his own book entitledReeded Edge Half Dollars
1836 - 1839 a few years ago. This has opened the door to this
highly collectible series by die pairings and adds a whole new
dimension as well with outstanding photographs, updated
rarity ratings and detailed die analysis. Here is a great coin
that will be tough to beat in quality as more collections of
these Reeded Edge half dollars are formed.
PCGS# 6176.
PCGS# 6164.
1429 1834 O-109. Rarity-1. Small Date, Small Letters. MS-65
(NGC). Boldly defined with a smooth, vibrant, satiny sheen,
both sides of this handsome Gem also offer rich toning in
olive-gray and pinkish-silver. This example is tied for the
fourth finest seen according to Steve Herrman’s Auction
& Mail Bid Prices Realized for Bust Half Dollars 1794 1839. Furthermore it is an amazing Gem example that has
survived in simply incredible condition and will delight any
specialist today for its charming surfaces and eye appealing
quality. If you demand the finest available, then here is one
that you should add to your collection today.
PCGS# 6166.
NGC Census: 74; 26 finer (Mint State-67 finest) for the date.
1430 1836/1336 Lettered Edge. O-108a. Rarity-2. AU-55
(PCGS). CAC. This fully original, boldly defined Choice
AU exhibits mottled charcoal-russet overtones to a base of
deep golden-gray patina. Listed as a major overdate variety
in the Guide Book and always in high collector demand as
this is one of the major types that appeals to a broad swath
of collectors. This charming AU will certainly find many
suitors.
PCGS# 39955.
1432 1839-O Reeded Edge. HALF DOL. GR-1. Rarity-1. AU58 (PCGS). Brilliant apart from subtle pale gold peripheral
highlights, this piece exhibits a pleasing satin texture with
few outwardly distracting abrasions. The devices are sharply
struck and full — full enough, indeed, to suggest Mint State
quality — and it is only wispy hairlines to the surfaces that
confirm what appears to be a net grade of AU-58 from
PCGS. This is a tough issue to find this well preserved and
so close to full mint state. The obverse has the O mintmark,
which is of course unusual as seen in later years when the
branch mintmarks are nearly always found on the reverse of
the coin. Furthermore in 1839 there was a terrible outbreak
of yellow fever in New Orleans and many citizens died, as
well as Mint employees from New Orleans. This must have
been a difficult time for that region. Holding this handsome
1839-O half dollar will elicit many thoughts of where it
might have been and who saved it so long ago to keep it in
such stellar condition today.
PCGS# 6181.
1433 1839-O Reeded Edge. HALF DOL. GR-1. Rarity-1. AU
Details—Smoothed (PCGS). Offering sharp definition
for this popular early New Orleans Mint half dollar issue,
this piece combines even mauve-gray obverse toning and
mottled steel-gray reverse iridescence. A bit glossy in
texture due to mishandling, although free of individually
mentionable blemishes apart from a small area of residue
at the back of Liberty’s hair curls. Here’s a popular two-year
design type having the denomination expressed as HALF
DOL. The 1839-O ranks as the only readily collectible New
Orleans Mint issue having the Capped Bust design (the
1838-O was issued in Proof format only and is very rare).
PCGS# 6181.
Page 71
Important Proof 1846 Half Dollar
1434 1846 Medium Date. WB-101. Proof-63 (NGC). An undeniable Proof striking of this early Liberty Seated half dollar issue, this
piece exhibits razor sharp devices, reflective fields and broad, squared off rims. The devices are more satiny that reflective, and direct
light angles reveal extremely modest cameo contrast to the finish. Lightly toned in mottle tan-olive iridescence, grade limiting
contact marks in the right obverse field also serve as useful pedigree markers. The exact Proof mintage for this date is unknown
and subject to some speculation, but was no doubt minuscule. As noted in our January 2013 New York Americana Sale, we believe
the total number of coins struck to be around only 20-30 pieces at the most. All known Proofs of this issue are of the Medium Date
variety. To distinguish the Medium Date, examine the numeral 4 in the date — the bottom horizontal stand and the crossbar serif
are connected, whereas on the Large Date variety, they are clearly separated. A singularly rare opportunity for early Proof specialists
and connoisseurs of the Liberty Seated coinage alike.
PCGS# 6390.
NGC Census: 3; 4 finer
Gem 1851-O Half Dollar Rarity
1435 1851-O WB-4. Rarity-3. MS-65 (PCGS). A coin for the collector that values originality as well as high technical quality, this
enchanting Gem is richly toned in antique golden-copper and olive patina. Underlying satin luster is full and vibrant, and the devices
are intricately defined with even the more minor elements of the design sharp. While the 1851-O half dollar is not particularly rare
in circulated grades, it stands out as a true condition rarity at the finest Mint State levels. With nary a detracting abrasion or other
blemish in evidence, this impressive piece would serve as a highlight in the finest Liberty Seated half dollar collection.
PCGS# 6267.
PCGS Population: 6; 2 finer (both MS-66)
Page 72
Beautifully Toned Gem Proof 1856 Half Dollar Rarity
1436 1856 Proof-65 (NGC). Virtually brilliant in the center of the obverse, the balance of this charming Gem is adorned in target-like
toning of cobalt blue, olive gray and silver rose iridescence. Uniformly mirrored in finish and expertly preserved, the surfaces are
free of even the most trivial blemishes. The original mintage was certainly low and today there are estimated to be approximately 35
examples that exist as noted inCoin Facts.Gems like this are indeed rare and seldom offered and this is a prized rarity at this grade
level. A formidable issue that is easy to overlook as a few years later the number of Proofs stuck climbed dramatically and these later
dates are comparatively easy to locate.
PCGS# 6410.
NGC Census: just 4; with a mere two finer (both Proof-66) in this category.
Ex: “Colonel” E.H.R. Green; Green Estate; Partnership of Eric P. Newman and Burdette G. Johnson d.b.a. St. Louis Stamp & Coin Co.; Eric P. Newman at
$50.00; Eric P. Newman Numismatic Education Society; Heritage’s sale of the Eric P. Newman Collection, Part II, November 2013, lot 33488. Paper envelope
included.
1437 1857 Proof-62 (PCGS). CAC. Handsome mauve-gray patina blankets both sides with more direct angles calling forth vivid gold, apricot
and rose-blue undertones. Uniformly mirrored in finish, sharp striking detail also confirm this coin’s status as a rare Proof striking of the
1857 half dollar. A tiny swirl of seemingly inactive verdigris is well concealed within the eagle’s left (facing) wing, but there are no sizeable
or otherwise outwardly distracting contact marks. This is a rare early Proof issue, with no more than 30 to 50 pieces known today in all
grades and any offering is an important opportunity for the specialist of this series.
PCGS# 6411.
Page 73
Landmark 1859-S Half Dollar
1438 1859-S WB-6. Rarity-3. Late Die State. Medium S. MS-68 (PCGS). CAC. Secure Holder. This remarkable 1859-S half dollar
offers incredible eye appeal and quality with coruscating mint luster that spans the entire surface. It is nearly fully brilliant with
just a touch of light gold at the lower obverse and reverse borders. The strike is bold and complete, with all device definition fully
brought up by the dies. Virtually pristine, and a simply remarkable early S-mint half dollar. By 1859 the San Francisco Mint had
been coining silver for several years, beginning in 1855. The demand for these coins in change remained intense. There was little
numismatic interest in branch mint coinage, as this would not occur until several decades later. The present piece was marvelously
preserved. To put the rarity of this coin into perspective, it is the only example of the entire No Motto type that PCGS has graded
as MS-68. Such incredible quality and rarity commands well deserved attention any time it is offered.
PCGS# 6298.
1440 1861 WB-101. MS-64 (PCGS). Multicolored toning in
orange-gold, midnight blue and deep rose-gray adorns both
sides in a target-like fashion. This piece is sharply struck
with soft mint luster and freedom from detracting abrasions
— the perfect candidate to represent the No Motto Liberty
Seated half dollar in a high grade type set. Furthermore this
coin was struck in the fateful year the Civil War began, and
its a wonder it has survived in such outstanding condition.
PCGS# 6302.
1439 1861 Proof-65 (NGC). Handsome lavender-gray patina
blankets both sides and speaks volumes about the
originality of this fully struck, appreciably reflective Gem.
From a mintage of a mere 1,000 pieces in Proof, this coin
is clearly head and shoulders above the majority of those
known today. Furthermore the surfaces offer the Gem level
of preservation, a standard that is met by precious few of
these. Struck months before the outbreak of the Civil War in
1861, this historic rarity was clearly set aside and preserved
to this day through all the epic historical events of the past
153 years.
1441 1861 WB-101. MS-64 (NGC). Satiny and untoned
throughout much of the obverse, the reverse is boldly toned
in a blend of tan-gray, medium rose and charcoal-blue.
A halo of similar colors encircles the obverse periphery,
and both sides are equally smooth with no troublesome
abrasions to report. Close to the Gem grade level with all
the desirable eye appeal and surfaces that a specialist could
hope to acquire.
PCGS# 6302.
PCGS# 6415.
Ex: “Colonel” E.H.R. Green; Green Estate; Partnership of Eric P. Newman and Burdette G. Johnson d.b.a. St. Louis Stamp & Coin Co.; Eric
P. Newman at $12.50; Eric P. Newman Numismatic Education Society;
Heritage’s sale of the Eric P. Newman Collection, Part II, November
2013, lot 33763. Paper envelope included.
Page 74
1442 1861-O WB-103. Die Crack Bisected Date. AU-53 (PCGS).
Endearing silver white surfaces are satiny in texture and also
reveal blushes of faint golden iridescence in isolated areas.
The obverse die has a vertical crack which indicates this coin
was struck by the Confederacy. As such it is quite desirable
and highly collectible when found in such a high level of
preservation. The historic aspects of this issue can scarcely
be overstated, as the Confederacy struggled to get its feet
on the ground and demand for much needed war materials
were soon found in short supply. Hence any coins and
precious metals became highly sought after to pay for such
war materials, or simply to be saved to get through these
hard times. Here is a tough coin to find that came through
this trying period in our history.
PCGS# 572147.
1443 1861-O WB-102, FS-401. GSA Die Crack. AU Details—
Cleaning (PCGS). Sharply defined over the focal features,
this otherwise bright silver example exhibits iridescent
steel-olive and powder blue iridescence that is bolder on the
reverse. Scattered handling marks and a glossy texture from
cleaning are noted. The all important die crack is visible
from Liberty’s nose to just right of the star nearby and rim
above. This same obverse die was used to coin the famous
Confederate half dollars issued under the auspices of the
Confederacy in their early days at the New Orleans Mint.
Needless to say, all the half dollars that exhibit this die break
are highly sought after for their confirmed Confederacy
connection and represent a most turbulent time in our
nations history. High grade pieces, like this example, are few
and far between.
PCGS# 390906.
1444 1862 Proof-64 (PCGS). Fully struck with watery, reflective
fields, this enchanting piece is even further enhanced
by richly original toning. The most vibrant colors are
evident when the coin dips into a light, at which angles
one can appreciate vivid blue, lavender and even some red
iridescence. Only 550 were struck in the Proof format, this
certainly one of the finer examples seen today as many were
mishandled in the generations that have passed since it was
coined.
PCGS# 6416.
1445 1863-S WB-4. Rarity-3. Late Die State. Small Broken S.
MS-64+ (PCGS). Beautiful satin to softly frosted surfaces
are highly lustrous and brilliant apart from the lightest
golden tinting. Sharply struck and smooth, there is much
to recommend this conditionally rare ‘63-S to the advanced
Liberty Seated half dollar collector. This is undoubtedly one
of the finer examples known to specialists today, and would
make a wise selection for a high grade specialized collection
of Liberty Seated half dollars.
PCGS# 6310.
Exceptional Proof 1865
Liberty Seated Half Dollar
1446 1865 Proof-66 (PCGS). CAC. OGH. A simply
delightful specimen, the surfaces are silky smooth in
texture without so much as a single distracting blemish.
Fully struck with watery fields, the entire package is
handsomely toned in undeniably original olive-gray
and golden-apricot patina. The United States Mint
struck only 500 Proof half dollars in the final year of
the Civil War, which is also the last year of the No
Motto type within the Liberty Seated series (excluding
the 1866-S No Motto). If you are looking for a shining
example of either the issue or the type, then look no
further than this exquisite premium Gem.
PCGS# 6419.
PCGS Population: 7; just 1 finer in Proof-67.
Page 75
1447 1865 Proof-64 Cameo (PCGS). Adorned with delicate
pale gold iridescence, and then again only really around the
peripheries, this charming specimen also offers razor sharp
devices and bold cameo contrast. Only 500 Proofs were
coined during the year, and of these PCGS has certified just
a few dozen survivors within the Cameo designation.
PCGS# 86419.
1450 1874 Arrows. Proof-64 (PCGS). Dreamy apricot, rose
and cobalt blue undertones enliven otherwise mauve-gray
surfaces for this fully impressed Proof. Uniformly mirrored
in finish, and expectably smooth at the near-Gem grade
level. A scant 750 of these were struck in Proof, and they offer
the important Arrows at the date feature. This announces a
slight adjustment to the silver content in the planchet that
was authorized in early 1873. Hence the Arrows coins are
needed by type collectors as well as date collectors who are
assembling sets, keeping demand high for these short lived
coins. Scarce at this lofty grade level and downright rare any
finer.
PCGS# 6435.
1448 1866 Motto. Proof-65 (PCGS). Blended apricot-gray
and charcoal-blue obverse toning yields to lighter, more
uniform, champagne-silver iridescence on the reverse.
Both sides are equally full in strike with a smooth, reflective
finish that is sure to endear this coin to the high grade, first
year Proof type collector. Mintage of 725 pieces in Proof,
this splendid Gem is one of the finer ones known today and
merits a place of honor in any advanced collection. This is
also the first year the Motto was added to the reverse die,
which continued on the Liberty Seated design through the
end of its run in 1891.
1451 1874 Arrows. Proof-62 (PCGS). A strong candidate
for inclusion in a Proof type set, this smartly impressed
specimen is awash in blended mauve-gray and sandysilver patina. More vivid blue and pink undertones are
also evident at direct angles and, while the surfaces are a
bit subdued to explain the Proof-62 grade, there are no
outwardly detracting contact marks. Scarce in any grade
with a mintage of 750 pieces, and these are highly desirable
as they have the short lived Arrows at the date, so are needed
by type as well as date collectors of this series.
PCGS# 6435.
PCGS# 6424.
PCGS Population: 12; just 5 are finer (Proof-66 finest) within the Proof designation.
1449 1868 Proof-63 Cameo (PCGS). A delightful piece with
the eye appeal of a significantly higher grade, both sides
exhibit vivid orange-gold peripheral color around brilliant
centers. Grade defining handling marks are faint, singularly
inconspicuous and easily overlooked at most angles. Only
600 Proof half dollars were coined during the year, and
fewer than 20% of the examples certified by PCGS have
been awarded the Cameo designation.
PCGS# 6426.
1452 1878 Proof-65 (PCGS). The brilliant central obverse is
ringed in lovely toning in vivid, multicolored iridescence.
The reverse, on the other hand, is deeply and evenly toned in
steel charcoal. Uniformly smooth throughout, with enough
contrast on the obverse to describe that side of the coin
as cameo. All examples that were known to Walter Breen
when he wrote his Complete Encyclopedia in 1988 were
struck from the Type II reverse with pointed berry above H
in HALF. Since the publication of his book, a few examples
having the Type I reverse have been discovered; these latter
pieces are considered extremely rare. Only 30 1878 half
dollars grading Proof-65 or finer have been certified by
PCGS since the mid 1980s.
PCGS# 6439.
Page 76
Key Date 1878-S Liberty Seated Half Dollar
Extremely Rare in All Grades
1453 1878-S WB-1, the only known dies. Rarity-5. Fair-2 (PCGS). An enticing piece given the extreme rarity of this S-mint half dollar
issue, this coin is rather attractive at the Fair level of preservation. The peripheral devices are worn into the rims and mostly lost,
although the tops of the digits in the date can be seen. The central devices are at least partially outlined, and the S mintmark on the
reverse is clear. Toned in a blend of steel gray and antique gold, the surfaces reveal no abrasions that we deem significant for a heavily
circulated Frontier era silver coin of this size.
In 1878 the February 28 passage of the Bland-Allison Act pushed forward a law the domestically mined silver had to be purchased
and coined. And not just a little bit, but immense quantities at a very favorable price to the silver mine owners, who spearheaded
the law through their governmental contacts. The silver had to be made into silver dollars, and out came the Morgan dollar in
immense quantities starting in 1878. Furthermore, after 18 years of monetary disruption, the value of the paper dollar (greenbacks)
was finally coming back to par with gold, this occurred at this same time period, so a flood of long withheld silver and gold coins
came pouring back into circulation. Years of the mints production were suddenly available—everywhere! Coins piled up at the Post
Offices and other agencies, who had no plan on how to redistribute all these coins.
Mint demand sunk for smaller denominations. There had been a few Proof only issues in the 1877 and 1878 time frame that
likely caught the attention of Philadelphia Mint officials, as they wanted to thwart speculators from making too much of a profit
on recently released Proof coins, hence limited quantities of circulation strikes were also made of several dimes, quarters and half
dollars in the late 1870s and through the 1880s to have what was likely seen as a reasonable supply to keep speculators from driving
up prices on the Proof coins issued. Otherwise there was no need for these limited circulation strikes.
Perhaps these factors explain why only 12,000 1878-S half dollars were struck. These must have been sent overseas and melted
as there as so few known today. The survivors span all grade levels from this smooth Fair-2 up to Mint State-66, and everything in
between. Perhaps 50 to 60 are known today, and this is one of the most sought after issues of the entire Liberty Seated half dollar
series.
PCGS# 6360.
PCGS Population: 1; 28 finer (Mint State-66 finest).
1454 1880 Proof-64 Cameo (PCGS). Glassy, well mirrored fields support satiny, fully impressed devices on both sides of this charming
near-Gem. Attractively toned, as well, with iridescent tan-gold peripheral highlights around silver-lilac centers. Although a fairly high
number were struck in Proof — 1,355 pieces — a tad higher than most years in this era, this is one of the finer examples and also offers
the desirable Cameo contrast. The Cameo contrast is especially desirable when it is noted that PCGS has not certified any of this date and
mint with the Deep Cameo designation. A coin that would make a wise selection to represent this type or date in an advanced collection.
PCGS# 86441.
Page 77
1455 1885 Proof-65 Cameo (NGC). Frosty and fully impressed,
the devices appear to float atop illimitable reflectivity in the
fields. Silky smooth in texture with delightful peripheral
toning, it is difficult for us to imagine a more inviting
example of this late date Proof issue in the Liberty Seated
half dollar series. Mintage of 930 pieces in Proof, with this
example offering both technical high grade as well as rich
contrast. The date is seldom offered as well, as circulation
strikes were limited to 5,200 pieces for the year.
PCGS# 86446.
1457 1890 Proof-65 (NGC). CAC. OH. Ringed in vivid
peripheral toning of lavender, gold and rose, this otherwise
brilliant specimen would easily support at least a Cameo
designation were it recertified in today’s market. This is a
simply beautiful Gem — expertly produced, original and
carefully preserved. Only 590 were struck in Proof in this
penultimate year of the Liberty Seated series of half dollars,
and today few Gems survive. An opportunity for the
specialist in these early Proof half dollars.
PCGS# 6451.
NGC Census: 8; 26 are finer (Proof-68 Cameo finest) within the Cameo Proof designation.
Ex: “Colonel” E.H.R. Green; Green estate; Partnership of Eric P. Newman / B.G. Johnson (d.b.a. St. Louis Stamp & Coin Co.); Eric P. Newman, acquired for $6.50; Eric P. Newman Numismatic Education Society; Heritage’s sale of the Eric P. Newman Collection, Part II, November
2013, lot 33794.
1458 1890 Proof-63 (NGC). Ringed in warm cobalt blue and
copper-russet peripheral iridescence, this otherwise silver
tinged specimen exhibits a bright, uniformly brilliant finish.
Fully struck, as well, with only faint, minor signs of handling
to define the grade. One of 590 Proofs of the date struck
against a modest circulation strike mintage of just 12,000
pieces.
PCGS# 6451.
1456 1888 WB-101. MS-66 (PCGS). Bisecting swaths of faint
golden iridescence interrupt brilliance on both sides of this
highly lustrous, satin textured Gem. Overall fully struck,
as well, with nary a detracting abrasion in evidence. This
is a low mintage date of 12,000 pieces struck for the entire
year. Obviously not many survive this well preserved and
given the eye appeal and quality this coin certainly merits
considerable collector attention. The Liberty Seated half
dollars were nearing their end of production when this
piece was struck. An exceptional coin that will delight any
specialist for its abundant quality and ample charm.
PCGS# 6370.
1459 1893 Proof-65 (PCGS). Rich charcoal-blue patina blankets
the obverse and rings the reverse periphery, the center of the
latter side exhibiting lighter tan-rose and reddish-apricot
toning. These are the colors that the toning exhibits when
viewed at many angles, although the most direct light reveal
a veritable explosion of vivid blue, gold, pink and peach
undertones that are most attractive. A fully struck and
visually appealing specimen that is seemingly earmarked for
inclusion in a Gem Proof type or date set. As the mintage of
792 pieces implies, not many are known in Gem condition
or finer today. Highly recommended if you are seeking this
early Barber half dollar in Proof.
PCGS# 6540.
PCGS Population: 21; 29 are finer (Proof-68 finest) within the Proof category.
1460 1897-O VF-35 (PCGS). This is a wholesome, attractive
Choice VF with fully original, silver gray surfaces. This
New Orleans date and mint is a tough issue to find this
well preserved as most seen fall into much lower circulated
grades. One of the lower mintages too, at 632,000 pieces
for the year, and this is certainly a desirable example to
represent this issue.
PCGS# 6478.
Page 78
1461 1901 Proof-63 (PCGS). With handsome, multicolored
peripheral toning and suitable vibrancy to the finish, this
smartly impressed specimen has the eye appeal of a higher
grade. Wispy handling marks on the obverse portrait are
commensurate with the Select Proof designation. This
date is scarce in the Proof format as only 813 were coined,
and not many remain at the Choice grade or finer today.
Proof Barber half dollars are a highly collectible series that
numismatists are rediscovering.
PCGS# 6548.
1462 1903 Proof-63 (PCGS). OGH. Radiant mint brilliance
shined forth powerfully from both sides of this untoned,
fully impressed specimen. This date in Proof is scarce with
a modest mintage of 755 pieces. Choice examples offer both
eye appeal as well as attractive collector quality, as seen in
this offering.
PCGS# 6550.
1463 1905 Proof-64 (PCGS). Scarce this well preserved and just
a whisper from the Gem grade level. Only 727 were struck
in the Proof format, so collector demand remains high when
a nice example like this is offered.
1466 1912 Proof-67 (NGC). Cornucopia of vivid cobalt blue,
olive-gold, pale apricot and silver gray iridescence are
splashed over both sides of this remarkable piece. Smooth
and expertly preserved, as befits the Superb Gem rating,
with outstanding eye appeal that is sure to result in keen
bidder interest. From a Proof mintage of just 700 coins;
Proof-67 examples rank in the top 10% of all pieces certified
by NGC.
PCGS# 6559.
NGC Census: 13; 6 finer (Proof-68 finest)
PCGS# 6552.
1464 1906-D MS-65 (NGC). Ringed in faint golden-tan peripheral
toning, this otherwise brilliant Gem readily reveals full,
smooth, satin to softly frosted luster. Also possessed of a
razor sharp strike — an uncommon attribute for a Barber
half dollar — this charming piece is sure to please even the
most discerning type collector. First year of operation for the
Denver Mint, which began producing coins for circulation
in this year. This is one the finer examples known today and
should be high on your list of priorities if you need a Gem
example for your collection.
PCGS# 6505.
NGC Census: 8; just 5 are finer (Mint State-66 finest).
1467 1915 MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. OGH. This lustrous and
inviting piece is untoned save for delicate champagne pink
iridescence that is boldest around the reverse periphery.
Fully struck and carefully preserved, were it not for a few
trivial obverse handling marks we could easily see this coin
in an MS-65 holder. PQ! From the final year of Barber half
dollar coinage.
PCGS# 6532.
1468 1916-S AU-53 H (NGC). CAC. Warmly toned about
the peripheries, this premium AU Walker also offers
uncommonly smooth surfaces at the assigned grade level. A
delight to behold! Liberty Walking half dollars with obverse
mintmarks were coined only in the years 1916 and 1917.
PCGS# 6568.
1465 1910 Proof-66 (NGC). This delightful specimen is awash in
a blend of copper-rose, salmon pink, orange-gold and bluegray patina. The toning exhibits a desirable iridescent quality
that allows ready appreciation of razor sharp striking detail
and a vibrant, uniformly mirrored finish. Proof mintage
drifted lower for this year, with only 551 struck for sale
to collectors. This Premium Gem Proof will undoubtedly
satisfy any advanced collecting specialist for its reflectivity
and elegant toning.
1469 1917 MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. OGH—First Generation.
Fully struck with antique, matte-like mint frost, this expertly
preserved Gem is untoned apart from delicate rose-gold
highlights here and there around the peripheries. This is
the second year of issue of the Walking Liberty design, with
collectors eager to find Gems like this, demand is certain to
be high for this pleasing example.
PCGS# 6569.
PCGS# 6557.
NGC Census: 27; 24 are finer (Proof-68 finest) within the Proof designation.
Page 79
Condition Rarity 1919-D Half Dollar
1470 1919-D MS-64 (NGC). CAC. Smooth, satiny features are suggestive of full Gem quality in terms of surface preservation. Central
striking detail is quite soft, however, yet no more so than usually noted for survivors of this challenging Denver Mint issue. Solidly
graded as Choice, and brilliant apart from the lightest pale gold iridescence that is not readily evident at all angles. Walking Liberty
half dollars of 1919 have long been recognized as condition rarities, the Denver Mint issue especially so. Regularly found in
circulated grades, the 1919-D becomes scarce in AU and downright rare in Mint State. True Gems, in fact, are about as rare as they
come for this series. This example reaches for the top, with NGC having graded just four coins finer (all MS-65).
PCGS# 6578.
A Second Mint State 1919-D Walker
1471 1919-D MS-63 (PCGS). Satiny golden tinged surfaces are smooth enough to suggest a significantly higher Mint State rating. Most
features are boldly defined, as one would expect for the type, although characteristic (for the issue) softness of strike in the centers
undoubtedly explains the MS-63 designation from PCGS. A prominent scuff on the front of the PCGS holder obscures viewing of
the coin’s central obverse, making this piece a candidate for reholdering should the winning bidder elect to pursue that option with
the grading service. Placing this fantastic coin in a new holder will undoubtedly greatly increase the eye appeal and presentation.
David Hall said this about the 1919-D half dollar; “it is rare in all circulated grades and is very rare in high grades. It is rarer still in
Mint State and in Gem condition it is the rarest of all Walking Liberty half dollars.” For the date collector assembling an advanced
collection, this splendid Choice example will certainly turn many heads who will admire its amazing quality. There are so few
that qualify at this high grade level of this date and mint, it is simply a marvel to behold. If you are serious about completing this
challenging series in Mint State, then here is one of the show stoppers that must be obtained, so don’t miss out when it crosses the
block.
PCGS# 6578.
Page 80
1472 1921-D AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. Evenly toned in soft pinkishgray patina, this smooth looking piece is uncommonly well
preserved in a lightly circulated Walking Liberty half. Softly
struck in the centers, as often noted for the issue, yet free
of all but the lightest rub. The 1921-D is notable for having
the lowest mintage of any issue in the Walking Liberty
half dollar series, just 208,000 pieces. It is likely that only
a few thousand examples of the issue still exist in all grades
combined, perhaps representing 2 to 3% of the original
production figure; most examples seen are in the Good to
VF grade range signifying that many specimens circulated
for decades before being redeemed from the channels of
commerce.
1474 1936 Proof-66 (PCGS). CAC. OGH. Fully struck with
uniform mint brilliance, this delightful piece is untoned save
for a few wisps of extremely light golden-olive iridescence.
As the first Proof half dollar issue since 1915, the 1936 kickstarted a new era in Proof manufacturing at the Mint. Just
3,901 examples were struck, a figure that increased annually
in the years that Proof coinage was offered in the design
type. World War II put an end to Proof coinage in 1942, but
Proof coinage returned in 1950 and is with us still today in a
run unbroken save for the 1965 through 1967 Special Mint
Sets.
PCGS# 6636.
PCGS# 6584.
Rare and Impressive Gem
Mint State 1927-S
Walking Liberty Half
1475 1936 Proof-66 (PCGS). This razor sharp Gem is bright,
brilliant and uniformly reflective in finish. This is the first
year Proofs were struck from this series after most Proof
coinage was suspended during World War I. Initial sales
were for 3,901 pieces, and these have become far more
popular in recent years as collectors seek examples. At this
stellar grade level few coins are reported any finer, and
thus this offering is well suited to any specialist seeking a
premium example.
PCGS# 6636.
1473 1927-S MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. Simply exquisite
surfaces exhibit splashes of tannish-russet and royal
blue peripheral toning to full, softly frosted luster. Both
the striking quality and surface preservation are far
in excess of what we typically encounter in survivors
of this conditionally challenging San Francisco Mint
issue. An enticing Gem of this elusive issue. While not
quite as difficult to locate at the Gem grade level as the
1923-S and 1928-S issues, but certainly a challenging
issue to find. Furthermore, the 1927-S tends to
come with better strikes, as noted here, which adds
considerable to the strong appeal.
PCGS# 6587.
1476 1936 Proof-66 (PCGS). Radiant satin to semi-reflective
surfaces are free of both toning and grade limiting blemishes.
More than one Gem Proof example of this popular scarcity
can be found in the present listings, which is great news for
our bidders.
PCGS# 6636.
1477 1938 Proof-67 (PCGS). Secure Holder. Smartly impressed
with radiant mint brilliance, this silky smooth and highly
attractive specimen would accept nothing less than a Superb
Gem rating. From a modest Proof mintage for the date of
8,808 pieces.
PCGS# 6638.
Page 81
1482 1941-S MS-66 (PCGS). Uncommonly well struck for the
issue with frosty mint luster, this attractive Gem combines a
brilliant obverse with mottled pink and olive reverse toning.
Strike is the key with many S-Mint half dollars of the era,
most of which come somewhat flat at the center of the
obverse. Finding a coin with any amount of central obverse
hand details is a plus for any collector.
PCGS# 6613.
1478 1938-D MS-66 (PCGS). CAC. OGH. This fully original,
solidly graded Gem exhibits subtle golden peripheral
accents to soft, satiny luster. Only 491,600 1938-D half
dollars produced, the lowest mintage for any non-Proof
half dollar issue coined subsequent to 1921. The specimen
offered here is in the top 20% of all Mint State examples
certified by PCGS.
PCGS# 6605.
1483 1942 Proof-68 (NGC). Splashes of intense crimson red
peripheral iridescence frame silver tinged centers on both
sides of this delightful Proof Walker. One of 21,120 Proofs
of the date struck in what would prove to be the end of such
coinage until 1950. They don’t come much finer than this
Gem!
PCGS# 6642.
1479 1941 Proof-68 (NGC). Brilliant on the reverse, the obverse
of this expertly preserved specimen is adorned with mottled
sandy silver and pale russet iridescence. The designer’s
initials AW are extremely faint, yet discernible with patience.
From a Proof mintage of 15,412 pieces, a paltry amount
when compared to today’s Proof mintage figures. As near to
perfection as you may ever see in a Proof of this date.
PCGS# 6641.
1484 1942 Proof-67+ (PCGS). CAC. A coin for the toning
enthusiast, this otherwise silver gray specimen is ringed in
extremely vivid, exceptionally attractive, orange-gold and
crimson red peripheral colors. Beautiful, and fully deserving
of the “+” designation and the CAC certificate!
PCGS# 6642.
1485 1942-S MS-66 (PCGS). CAC. Fully untoned with radiant
mint frost, this silky smooth Gem would make a lovely
addition to a high grade Walker set. One of the finer
examples graded of this date and mint, and while not the
absolute top grade seen, is mighty close.
PCGS# 6617.
1480 1941 Breen-5182. No AW. Proof-68 (NGC). An undeniably
original specimen, both sides of this vivid Superb Gem
are draped in mottled golden-olive, powder blue and pale
pink iridescence. The present beauty is near the pinnacle of
perfection for the date — NGC has certified just a solitary
example of the issue at a finer grade.
PCGS# 6641.
1481 1941-S MS-66 (PCGS). This is a pretty piece, the surfaces
silky smooth in appearance with full, billowy, satin to softly
frosted luster. A bit more boldness to the central design
elements, in fact, and this coin may even have secured a
Superb Gem grade. Toning is minimal and largely confined
to golden-russet highlights at the rims. The 1941-S is
generally recognized as the scarcest Liberty Walking half
dollar issue of the 1940s in Uncirculated condition. This
piece is easily in the top 10% of all Mint State examples
certified by PCGS.
1486 1961 FS-801. Doubled Die Reverse. Proof-65 (PCGS).
CAC. Radiant brilliant white surfaces are fully untoned to
allow ready appreciation of a uniformly mirrored finish
from the dies. An elusive variety! PCGS has certified fewer
than 100 1961 Double Die half dollars over the years. The
reverse doubling is particularly pronounced at E PLURIBUS
UNUM, but is substantial in other areas of the design as
well. This variety is prominently listed with an illustration
in the 2015 edition of the Guide Book and thus is sure to
appeal to mainstream half dollar specialists as well as
Cherrypickerenthusiasts. It was not mentioned by Walter
Breen in his Complete Encyclopedia, and by inference the
existence of the variety was probably not known to him
prior to the publication of his book in 1988.
PCGS# 145292.
PCGS Population: 5; 8 finer (Proof-67 finest), all within the FS-801 designation.
PCGS# 6613.
Page 82
Bullion
1487 1987 Silver Eagle. MS-70 (PCGS). As struck, perfect and
rare as a 1987 silver eagle at the pinnacle of the PCGS
grading scale.
1491 Partial BU Roll of 1941 Walking Liberty Half Dollars.
With several coins grading solid MS-64 and even MS-65,
this impressive partial roll is sure to sell for a strong bid
(Total: 18 coins)
PCGS# 9808.
PCGS Population: just 15.
Modern Commemorative
1488 2001-W U.S. Capitol Visitor Center Gold $5. MS-69
(PCGS). A satiny beauty with virtually pristine, medium
gold surfaces.
PCGS# 9792.
1492 BU Roll of 1950-D Franklin Half Dollars. This is a high
quality roll with several coins grading as high as MS-64, if
not even finer. Worthy of a close look! (Total: 20 coins)
Ex: U.S. Vault Collection.
Rolls
1489 BU Roll of 1938-D Jefferson Nickels. A lovely roll with
most coins grading MS-64 or finer and many with pretty
iridescent toning. (Total: 40 coins)
1493 AU-BU Roll of 1946 Booker T. Washington
Commemorative Half Dollars. Most examples are Mint
State in the MS-60 to MS-63 grade range, although we do
note a few “sliders” in AU due to either light wear and/or
evidence of cleaning. (Total: 20 coins)
1490 Partial BU Roll of 1949-S Roosevelt Dimes. A delightful
selection of mostly brilliant, virtually complete Choice to
Gem quality pieces. (Total: 24 coins)
Page 83
Mint Errors
1494 1945 Lincoln Cent—Struck on a Netherlands East Indies
Cent Planchet—MS-64 BN (NGC). 2.3 grams. The size
differential between the planchet and dies has resulted in
incomplete peripheral definition on both sides, but the only
devices that are significantly affected by this feature are
the letter L in LIBERTY and much of the motto IN GOD
WE TRUST on the obverse. The central motifs are boldly
defined, and both sides retain flickers of original light
orange luster to otherwise gray-brown surfaces. Given the
history of the U.S. Mint striking coins for other nations, it
is small wonder that wrong-planchet errors such as offered
here have become popular with today’s collectors.
1495 1953-D Lincoln Cent—Struck on a Silver Dime Planchet—
VF-30 (PCGS). This is an uncommonly well defined piece
both for the assigned grade and in light of the error type.
The strike is well centered with only isolated portions of the
word LIBERTY and the Latin motto E PLURIBUS UNUM
beyond the bounds of the dime planchet. Light silver gray
throughout, with wispy handling marks and a tiny obverse
spot that we mention solely for accuracy. This type of error
is created when one of the tote bins used to transport blank
planchets too and from the coining machinery ends up with
minor cracks in the metal seams of its walls, or perhaps the
swinging door becomes worn. In either case the tote bin
traps a few planchets from the prior production, in this case
dime planchets, and when later the tote bin is filled with
cent planchets, the dime blanks become dislodged and are
fed into the coining equipment with the cent planchets. This
error is known to occur on many different dates, but usually
only a modest number are produced in any given year at
each mint.
PCGS# E2807.
1496 1960 Lincoln Cent. Large Date—Struck on a Silver Dime
Planchet—Unc Details—Damage (PCGS). Brilliant bright
silver surfaces are boldly defined save for where prominent
scrapes and scratches have obscured portions of both
the obverse and reverse designs. A scarce error, and on a
particularly popular date of issue as the Large Date and
Small Date cents of 1960 became quite popular soon after
their discovery. Finding a Lincoln Cent on a silver dime
planchet has always been challenging, and the number
of these struck in any given year is usually quite small.
As sometimes encountered these smaller sized “cents”
(struck on dime planchets) become fouled in coin counting
machinery and scratches and scuffs can occur when these
error coins go through this process.
PCGS# E2860.
1497 1982 Lincoln Cent. Bronze. Large Date—Three-Piece
Bonded Set—MS-64 RB (PCGS). This intriguing piece has
the appearance of a flower, the struck portion in the center
being surrounded by areas of blank planchet that radiate
out like the petals. Providing even further contrast is the
fact that the struck portions are predominantly lustrous
in a light orange, while the blank planchet areas around
the borders are toned in iridescent lilac-brown. A visually
dramatic piece that is sure to excite the error specialist.
Bonded sets are quite rare and are all the more desirable
when the various pieces are found together. Here is one
such example with multiple pieces that has been retained in
near Gem condition. Bonded coin errors are created when a
planchet fails to eject properly and additional planchets are
fed into the press and struck. Most of these types of errors
are caught by the mint or the distributing Federal Reserve
banks, although sometimes a shipment of a large steel
bin of coins is sent unopened directly to a large regional
bank where such errors are discovered when the coins are
wrapped for distribution by the regional bank. These types
of errors make a dramatic display when found.
PCGS# E146016.
Page 84
1498 1996 Lincoln Cent—Overstruck on a 1996-P Roosevelt
Dime—MS-66 (PCGS). The PCGS insert does not list
the date of the undertype, but all four digits as well as the
P mintmark from the Roosevelt dime are discernible at
the lower right reverse border of the cent. Silky smooth in
texture with brilliant surfaces, this coin is sure to please even
the most discerning error collector. This type of error is a
two step process, first off a 1996 Roosevelt dime is normally
produced, while travelling back to the counting and
weighing area, a struck coin becomes trapped in the seam
or gate of the tote bin and remains behind when the bin
is otherwise emptied. New cent planchets are then poured
into the bin and the struck dime becomes dislodged and is
struck along with the other Lincoln cents. The dime-cent
coin is then distributed normally. Especially desirable this
well preserved, with the prior striking evident when studied.
1500 1996 Lincoln Cent—Struck on a Copper-Nickel Clad
Dime Planchet—MS-63 (PCGS). The strike is drawn
toward the viewer’s left on both sides, the difference in size
between the dies and planchet resulting in (minor) loss
of detail along the left borders. Satiny and brilliant, this
minimally abraded piece has the appearance of an even
higher Mint State grade. A classic example of an off-planchet
error, where a leftover clad dime planchet was mixed into a
batch of cent planchets, and struck normally. Often these
escape into circulation unnoticed, but this Choice example
was plucked out of the original distribution of cents and well
preserved.
PCGS# E38112.
PCGS# E38112.
1499 1996 Lincoln Cent—Overstruck on a Roosevelt Dime—
MS-66 (PCGS). Brilliant silver white surfaces retain
considerable portions of the Roosevelt dime design,
although only faint portions of the date and mintmark
(P?) are discernible. Satiny and smooth, this piece is solidly
graded at the premium Gem level. A scarce off planchet
error, which is certainly one of the finer examples known
of this date and mint. An impressive coin for the advanced
error specialist.
PCGS# E38112.
1501 1999 Lincoln Cent—Five-Piece Bonded Cluster—MS64 RD (PCGS). Visually dramatic in all regards, multiple
strikings have not only fused the planchet together, but
caused them to distend, split and reveal considerable
portions of the underlying zinc. The final obverse strike is
sharp in the center, and faint portions of an earlier reverse
impression are evident around the blank central reverse
(which is actually so thin due to the error that a mirrored
impression of the obverse portrait is evident). Bonded
groups like this occur when the first planchet fails to eject
properly, then additional planchets are feed into the coining
press and struck, in this case bonding a total of five planchets
together. Most of these bonded planchet errors are caught by
the press operators or when the struck coins are returned to
the counting and weighing rooms or when first distributed
to the Federal Reserve banks. Some however, do escape into
numismatic hands and these are some of the most dramatic
mint errors known as they capture the force of the strike and
coining process when things go slightly wrong.
PCGS# E3154.
Page 85
1502 199X Lincoln Cent—Struck 10% Off Center on a CopperNickel Clad Dime Planchet—MS-64 (PCGS). The strike is
off center at 3 o’clock, with the result that the third digit in
the date is only partially evident, and the final digit is absent
in its entirety. Those features that are present are sharp, and
the struck portion of the planchet is smooth, lustrous and
satiny in texture. As the dime planchet is narrower and
thinner than the cent planchet intended, it is common to
see striking deficiencies and expected that portions of the
design near the edge will be missing. What is unexpected is
to find such an error nudging close to the Gem grade, and
this frosty coin will entice any specialist with this feature
alone.
PCGS# E11111.
1505 1943-S Jefferson Nickel—Struck on a Steel Cent
Planchet—Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS). This piece is
quite sharply defined from a well centered impression, only
the peripheral devices somewhat distended due to being
drawn toward the rims. Matte like in texture from a cleaning,
which seems to have been done in an effort to remove
coppery surface scale that is still evident over the lower
right obverse, as commonly seen on the regular issue 1943
Steel cent coins today. The smaller size of the cent planchet
when compared with that of the thicker and wider nickel
planchet intended, accounts for the usual edge distention
in the strike. Of course, 1943 mint errors are highly sought
after when they involve cent planchets, and this example has
the added feature of the desirable San Francisco mintmark.
PCGS# E4021.
1503 1941 Jefferson Nickel—Overstruck on a Lincoln Cent—
MS-66 BN (NGC). Virtually all of the nickel design is
present despite the fact that the cent planchet is smaller than
that of the larger denomination, and both sides have toned
nicely in warm orange-brown. Only a few elements of the
undertype are discernible, and then again only faintly. One
of the popular “six-cents” errors.
1504 1943-S Jefferson Nickel—Struck on a Silver Dime
Planchet—MS-61 (NGC). 2.5 grams. This satiny piece is
lightly and evenly toned in iridescent golden-tan. The strike
is incomplete due to the size differential between the nickel
dies and dime planchet, mostly along the upper obverse and
lower reverse borders. A popular error type that will see
spirited bidding support.
Page 86
1506 1977 Jefferson Nickel—Overstruck on a Lincoln Cent—
MS-64 RD (PCGS). Much of the undertype has been
obliterated by the overstrike, but faint outlines of Lincoln’s
portrait and the first two digits in the date are discernible, as
are sharp columns in the Lincoln Memorial over the center
of Monticello. Both sides exhibit vivid orange-red luster with
only the lower obverse and upper reverse peripheral areas
of the Jefferson nickel design off the planchet. This error
was created when a normally struck Lincoln cent became
lodged or stuck in the tote bin used to ferry new planchets
and struck planchets back and forth to the counting and
weighing rooms. In this case the newly struck Lincoln cent
lodged in the tote bin when the struck coins were removed,
and new blank planchets intended for nickels were poured
into the tote bin. When the new blank nickel planchets were
fed into the feeder mechanism this struck cent went along
for another trip to the presses. The pressure demanded for
striking up nickels is considerable, so much of the undertype
is obliterated as expected. An important type of mint error
and one that is well preserved.
PCGS# E11114.
1507 1998-P Jefferson Nickel—Multi-Struck Two-Piece
Bonded Pair—MS-66 (PCGS). The first two strikes are
uniface on the obverse, the initial one quite distended in the
center and the second one dramatically off center. The third
and final strike is sharp and clear on both sides, centered
over the junction of the two bonded planchets. This piece
is generally untoned with the struck portions bright and
satiny in appearance. Bonded pairs are rarely found and
are caused when a planchet fails to eject properly and an
additional planchet is fed into the press, bonding the two or
more planchets as the case may be. Outstanding condition
and bold visual appeal. Impressive!
PCGS# E4142.
1509 Undated Jefferson Nickel—Struck on a Copper-Nickel
Clad Dime Planchet—MS-63 (PCGS). The strike is flush
to the upper left obverse and lower left reverse borders, with
the result that the peripheral devices in the opposite areas
are completely missing from a planchet that was too small
to fill the dies. Satiny silver gray surfaces are perhaps just a
few trivial blemishes away from an even higher grade. This
error was created when a leftover dime planchet (1965 or
later being a clad design) was lodged in a tote bin used by
the mint to transport planchets. When nickel planchets
were added to the bin, this dime planchet became free and
was fed into the coining presses along with the much larger
nickel sized planchets. Impressive and desirable given the
variation in planchet sizes over that intended.
PCGS# E11111.
1508 2000-D Jefferson Nickel—Overstruck on a 2000-Dated
Lincoln Cent—MS-66 RD (PCGS). Satiny pinkish-red
surfaces retain more or less faint portions of the Lincoln
cent undertype, including all four digits in the date, but
not enough of the mintmark area to determine if the cent
was struck in the Philadelphia or Denver mints. This piece
is virtually pristine with hardly even a trivial blemish in
evidence. This was most likely a Denver 2000 Lincoln cent
that simply rode along for another trip to the coining press
when nickel planchets were poured into the tote bin, but it is
conceivable that it might have been a Philadelphia cent that
somehow became mixed into the nickel planchets awaiting
coinage. A solid representative of this type of error, and ever
popular for the year 2000 of issue.
PCGS# E11114.
1510 Undated Jefferson Nickel—Struck on a Silver Dime
Planchet—AU-58 (PCGS). Much of the peripheral detail
is off the planchet, but the motto IN GOD WE TRUST is
virtually complete along the left obverse border, as is the
word UNITED on the reverse. Brilliant and attractive, with
just the barest trace of handling to preclude a Mint State
rating. The silver dime planchets indicate a date of 1964 or
prior for this mint error. Scarce and pleasing to the eye as
the dies were struggling to strike up a much thicker nickel
sized planchet when this thin silver dime was all that was
available. A classic error type and well preserved for the
collector.
PCGS# E11111.
Page 87
1511 19XX-P Roosevelt Dime—Multi-Struck Two-Piece
Bonded Pair—MS-65 (PCGS). Bonded pairs are one
of the rarest types of mint errors because they are usual
discovered and destroyed either at the mint that created
them or by the next line of defense, the Federal Reserve
banks that sometimes count, wrap and distribute the coins
shipped directly from the mint in large boxes or containers.
Sometimes one of these containers is sent directly to one of
the larger regional banks and having been legally released
from the mint allows these errors to be legally owned. Such
errors are the result of a failed ejection of a planchet, while
another planchet (or more) is fed into the coining press. The
two or more planchets become bonded together and are
always distended during the dynamics of the strike. Bonded
pairs are always dramatic and highly desirable as a type of
mint error.
1513 1969-D Washington Quarter—Struck on a Cent
Planchet—MS-66 BN (NGC). 3.1 grams. The planchet has
become distended and misshapen due to the nature of the
Mint error, although only along the upper obverse and lower
reverse borders do we note appreciable absence of detail to
the quarter design. Silky smooth in texture with handsome
glossy brown patina throughout. From the early days of the
clad coinage era, but here on a cent planchet when they were
still bronze.
PCGS# E11111.
1512 1966 Washington Quarter—Struck on a Copper-Nickel
Clad Dime Planchet—MS-61 (PCGS). The planchet
was large enough to take only a portion of the design, in
this case the lower right obverse and upper right reverse.
We do note a clear date, however, as well as considerable
sharpness to Washington’s portrait and the reverse eagle.
Not only is the dime planchet much narrower than the
quarter sized intended, but the dime is also thinner which
makes the striking dynamic a challenge for the dies. Here is
an attractive Mint State example of this unusual off planchet
error.
1514 Undated Washington Quarter. Copper-Nickel Clad—
Struck 90% Off Center on a Type I Planchet—MS-63
(PCGS). Despite the attribution on the PCGS insert, we
believe that this piece might actually be a Kennedy half
dollar struck 90% off center on a Type I, copper-nickel
clad quarter planchet. The only design elements visible
are the letters LI in the word LIBERTY, and their size and
spacing are suggestive of the Kennedy half dollar design
rather than that of the Washington quarter. We leave the
final determination here up to the bidders, however, and
are selling this coin strictly as it is currently attributed and
certified by PCGS. Untoned.
PCGS# E11111.
PCGS# E5879.
1515 Undated Washington Quarter—Struck on a CopperNickel Clad Dime Planchet—MS-63 (PCGS). The
Washington design is basically flush with the left borders on
both sides of the planchet, with detail fading into obscurity
toward the opposite peripheral areas. Satiny, untoned and
overall smooth, this lovely piece would undoubtedly have
secured at least an MS-65 grade were it not for a vertical
cut in the left obverse field. A classic mint error where the
smaller dime sized planchet became mixed in with the
quarter planchets and was struck in that group. Scarce
when found at all, this pleasing Choice example will attract
collector attention when it crosses the block.
PCGS# E11111.
Page 88
1516 Undated Washington Quarter—Uniface Reverse Strike
on a Copper-Nickel Clad Dime Planchet—MS-63
(PCGS). The reverse impression is fairly close to centered
with most of the missing design elements confined to the
right periphery. This is a satiny, silver gray example that has
the eye appeal of an even higher grade. This dime planchet
must have been fed into the coining press with a regular
quarter sized planchet that received the obverse strike, while
the smaller dime sized planchet was tucked in beneath and
received the reverse strike. Pleasing surface quality and a
visually dramatic error.
PCGS# E11111.
1519 Undated Denver Mint Washington Quarter—Struck
on a Silver Dime Planchet—MS-62 (PCGS). The PCGS
insert does not identify the issuing Mint, although the D
mintmark for Denver is clearly visible as part of the reverse
design. The impression is fairly well centered with much of
the peripheral design absent due to the fact that the planchet
is too small for the dies. Essentially brilliant, the surfaces
are also free of sizeable or otherwise outwardly distracting
abrasions. Finding a struck Washington quarter on a silver
dime planchet is a challenge for most collectors, and while
the date is unknown is certainly between 1932 and 1964
when silver dime planchets were around and the mintmark
was located on the reverse of the Washington quarter.
PCGS# E11111.
1517 Undated Washington Quarter—Struck on a Bronze Cent
Planchet—MS-63 RB (PCGS). Lightly toned in graybrown, this otherwise lustrous piece presents considerable
medium orange color. Approximately two thirds of the
design is present on the planchet, with both sides fairly well
centered. The size differential between the cent planchet and
quarter planchet accounts for the lack of the date, as certain
design elements inevitably are off the edge of the much
smaller planchet used to create this quarter. A dramatic
and desirable mint error that offers high appeal and a solid
collector grade.
1520 1959 Franklin Half Dollar—Struck on a Quarter
Planchet—AU Details—Improperly Cleaned (NGC).
6.3 grams. Well centered in strike with the central design
elements bold and clear despite the presence of light wear.
Scattered hairlines are noted for accuracy, but there are no
singularly distracting abrasions. Ben Franklin making an
appearance on a planchet intended for George Washington
— those Founding Fathers just can’t be separated.
PCGS# E11113.
1518 Undated Washington Quarter—Struck on a CopperNickel Clad Dime Planchet—MS-62 (PCGS). This satiny,
smooth, silver gray example has the “look” of an appreciably
higher Mint State grade. Flush along the upper obverse and
lower reverse borders, the strike is bold over those features
that are present, but lacking the date digits as commonly
seen when the planchet is much smaller than that intended.
A scarce mint error that is always in demand.
PCGS# E11111.
1521 1964 Kennedy Half Dollar—Struck on a Silver Quarter
Planchet—MS-62 (PCGS). The strike is aligned to the
lower right obverse of the Kennedy half dollar design, with
bold to sharp definition for all features that are present. A
bright, satiny piece with smooth looking surfaces that seem
undergraded at the BU level. The 1964 Kennedy half dollar
is also a single year type coin as the following year Kennedy
half dollars were struck in a 40 percent silver planchet
instead of this 90 percent silver planchet. Here is one that
ended up struck on a quarter sized blank instead, and these
are scarce in any grade today. An impressive and desirable
mint error.
PCGS# E6706.
Page 89
1522 Undated Kennedy Half Dollar—Struck on a Nickel
Planchet—MS-62 (PCGS). The strike is flush along the
upper right obverse and lower right reverse borders of the
Kennedy half dollar design, with bold to sharp detail to
all devices that are present. Satiny, outwardly smooth in
most areas, and possessed of delicate pastel iridescence, the
appearance of this coin is suggestive of a significantly higher
grade. A considerable size difference is exposed between
the nickel sized planchet versus that of the intended half
dollar, hence peripheral details are missing such as the
date. Furthermore, the uniform composition of the nickel
planchet does not give a clue as to when this coin was struck.
A bold and enticing mint error for the specialist.
PCGS# E11111.
1524 Undated Kennedy Half Dollar—Struck on a Cent
Planchet—Unc Details—Damage (PCGS). Portions of the
central design elements are boldly defined on this visually
impressive Mint error, as are elements of the peripheral
lettering along the left obverse and reverse borders. Vivid
pink and light orange surfaces are suggestive of a cleaning,
although the damage referred to on the PCGS insert is minor
and confined to a few faint scratches at the lower reverse
border. Often these off planchet errors are found when the
odd sized planchets become caught in a counting machine.
As the counting machines are set up to a specific coin size,
the odd planchets become stuck, sometimes incurring
scratches in the process. Given the considerable difference
in thickness and width of a cent planchet when compared
to a half dollar planchet, such minor marks are easy to live
with. This is a dramatic mint error and a desirable example
of a half dollar struck on a cent planchet.
PCGS# E11112.
1523 Undated Philadelphia Mint Kennedy Half Dollar—
Struck on a Copper-Nickel Clad Quarter Planchet—MS62 (PCGS). Satiny and smooth, this charming example
also exhibits subtle pink and powder blue iridescence as
the surfaces rotate under a light. The left central design
elements are fully on the planchet and sharply defined. The
“P” mintmark is sharp and on the struck portion of the
planchet, but the date is not so lucky. Distended around
the edges as expected from the dynamic striking force, and
appealing as this obvious mint error offers mint fresh luster
and pleasing surfaces.
PCGS# E11111.
1525 1999-P Anthony Dollar—Foldover Double Struck,
Second Strike 50% Off Center—MS-64 (PCGS). The
second strike is also uniface on the obverse, and it is off
center at 7 o’clock. A satiny, lightly toned piece with a
profound visual appearance. An exceptional error on this
short-lived issue which was revived in 1999 for one year
after an 18-year absence from the coinage scene.
PCGS# E9581.
End of Session Two
Page 90
The June 2014
Baltimore Auction
Session 3
Friday, June 27, 2014
Start time: 6:00 PM ET
Lots 2001-2751
Silver Dollars
2001 1795 Flowing Hair. BB-25, B-6. Rarity-3. BB Die State III.
Three Leaves. VF-20 (PCGS). OGH. Evenly toned in light
silver gray, this pleasing mid grade survivor is well defined
in a VF early dollar. A few scattered digs are consistent
with the grade, and the adjustment marks that obscure the
denticulation along the lower obverse border are as struck
and very common to Flowing Hair silver dollars of all die
marriages. Although reasonably available with patience, this
die pairing is not at all common, especially when compared
to the BB-27, B-5 die pairing of this year and major type. As
such, the present offering would be a strong selection for
any type of collection and makes a fine representative of this
first style of silver dollar issued by the United States.
PCGS# 6852.
2003 1795 Flowing Hair. BB-26, B-12a. Rarity-5. BB Die State
II. Three Leaves. VF-30 Details—Damaged, Cleaned
(ANACS) Iridescent olive-gray retoning is most vivid
around the peripheries of this bold mid-grade early dollar.
Prominent adjustment marks are present over the left
central reverse, but they are as struck, and both sides exhibit
suitably bold definition in the presence of moderate wear.
A few well scattered nicks and digs on the revere aside,
there are no singularly mentionable abrasions. BB-26 is a
scarce variety with an estimated population of less than 100
pieces in all grades combined. According to Dave Bowers’
2013 Encyclopedia of United States Silver Dollars, 1794-1804,
published by us here at Stack’s Bowers Galleries, most of the
known examples of BB-26 are in the Good to Fine grade
range.
PCGS# 6852.
2002 1795 Flowing Hair. BB-25, B-6. Rarity-3. BB Die State
III. Three Leaves. VF-20 (NGC). Lightly toned in silver
gray, this boldly defined VF offers freedom from significant
abrasions in a mid grade early dollar. This is a somewhat
better variety which is much less often seen than the BB-27,
B-5 die pairing. An excellent selection for the collector who
appreciates quality and eye appeal.
PCGS# 6852.
Page 92
Session Three Starts 6:00 PM ET - Friday, June 27, 2014
Attractive 1795 Flowing Hair Dollar
2004 1795 Flowing Hair. BB-27, B-5. Rarity-1. BB Die State III. Three Leaves. AU-50 (NGC). This handsome, boldly defined AU is
seemingly earmarked for inclusion in a high grade type set. Both sides are well centered in strike with the design carefully executed
and wear light over only the highest elements of the design. The surfaces are also richly toned in dominant lavender-charcoal
patina with a few streaks of russet bisecting the upper central reverse. A few minor adjustment marks (as made) are also present in
and around the central reverse, but in terms of detracting abrasions we find nothing of note. Adjustment marks are thin lines that
were imparted into the planchets that were weighed and found to be too heavy—above the stated tolerance. Thus a file was used to
remove the excess silver weight, then the planchet was struck. Most of the evidence of the filing is obliterated by the strike, and these
fine lines are commonly seen on early dollars of this period. In terms of importance, the Flowing Hair design was only struck on
silver dollars in late 1794 (quite rare) and most of 1795, then the design was changed in October of 1795 to the Draped Bust, Small
Eagle style. Hence, collector demand has always been strong for this short lived and attractive type issue. Most of the 1795 Flowing
Hair dollars known today fall into the grade range of Very Good to Very Fine.
PCGS# 39977.
From the Jacobson Collection.
2005 1795 Flowing Hair. BB-27, B-5. Rarity-1. BB Die State II.
Three Leaves. VF-20 Details—Cleaned (ANACS). OH.
Handsome retoning in bold steel gray and antique copper
helps to conceal the effects of an old cleaning. Several
scratches at the back of Liberty’s head are also mentioned
for accuracy, although with boldly outlined devices the
desirability of this coin for budget minded type purposes
should be obvious to bidders. BB-27 ranks as one of the
most distinctive varieties in the Flowing Hair dollar series.
A small obverse die scratch is present on all specimens
between Liberty’s top curl and the fifth star. As soon as the
die scratch is noted, the attribution is certain.
PCGS# 39977.
II. Three Leaves. VF Details—Graffiti (PCGS). An
aesthetically pleasing piece despite the stated impairment,
both sides are nicely toned in even golden-gray. Well
defined at the middle reaches of the grading scale, with no
mentionable distractions apart from a few light scratches
over and behind the obverse portrait. Such minor faults
are fairly common on early dollars, and are simply a part
of the landscape on many of the early Federal coins. This
is an important and short lived type coin which offers the
first silver dollar design, the Flowing Hair obverse paired
with the large standing eagle on the reverse. The three leaf
reverse is determined by the number of leaves just beneath
the eagle’s wings.
PCGS# 6852.
Page 93
II. Three Leaves. VG-10 (PCGS). Evenly toned pewter
gray surfaces are overall smooth in outward appearance,
especially on the obverse, with all devices boldly outlined. A
few faint, wispy handling marks in the center of the reverse
are mentioned solely for accuracy. A rather wholesome
example of this scarce type issue. The surfaces are pleasing for
a coin that displays moderate circulation, but the important
devices are all present on both the obverse and reverse. All
early Flowing Hair dollars are scarce when found certified,
and demand has long exceeded supply of this first style of
silver dollar made for circulation.
2010 1795 Draped Bust. BB-51, B-14. Rarity-2. Off-Center
Bust. VF-30 (PCGS). This well balanced, overall bold
example is evenly toned in uniform dove gray patina. With
outwardly smooth, distraction free surfaces, there is much
to recommend this coin to the circulated type collector. This
ever-popular issue is nearly a type unto itself, as it is that
distinctive in appearance, what with Liberty’s bust far offcenter to the viewer’s left side of the obverse.
PCGS# 39996.
PCGS# 6852.
II. Three Leaves. VG Details—Cleaning (PCGS). This
light silver example retains outline definition to all devices,
thereby making it an attractive candidate for inclusion in
a budget minded type set. Lightly hairlined throughout,
several small digs in and around the centers are also noted
for accuracy. Smooth wear from circulation otherwise,
and all the important devices are well defined. This type of
the Flowing Hair obverse paired with the larger standing
eagle reverse was only issued in late 1794 through roughly
October 1795 before the entire design of the obverse and
reverse was changed to the Draped Bust design.
PCGS# 6852.
2011 1795 Draped Bust. BB-52, B-15. Rarity-2. BB Die State
IV. Centered Bust. EF-40 Details—Tooled, Cleaned
(ANACS). This piece offers overall sharp striking detail and
freedom from outwardly distracting abrasions for a more
modest sum. Richly retoned overall, the obverse exhibits
bold olive-charcoal patina while the reverse is more steelrose in color. Only two die varieties of Draped Bust dollars
were produced in 1795, and these are easily distinguished
from one another. On BB-52, Liberty’s profile is well
centered; on the other variety, BB-51, the Liberty portrait is
positioned a little too far to the left.
PCGS# 6858.
2009 1795 Draped Bust. BB-51, B-14. Rarity-2. Off-Center
Bust. VF-30 (PCGS). This lightly to moderately toned,
silver gray and lavender-tan example presents exceptionally
well in a mid grade early dollar. Overall boldly defined
from a well executed strike, with no abrasions that we deem
significant at the Choice VF level. The Draped Bust, Small
Eagle design was launched in late 1795, and first appears
on these silver dollars. Only two pairs of dies were used for
these new style coins, and they were intended to replace the
Flowing Hair design that proved unpopular with the public.
The Draped Bust style was well received and was soon
adopted onto both copper and silver coins as soon as master
hubs could be completed, these hubs were needed to make
the numerous dies required for coinage. Hence, these 1795
Draped Bust dollars have always been popular and are seen
as the first of their kind.
2012 1795 Draped Bust. BB-52, B-15. Rarity-2. Centered Bust.
VG Details—Damage (PCGS). This boldly toned, steel and
golden gray example offers well outlined devices for a more
modest sum. An overall rough, pitted texture to the surfaces
is the most significant sign of the stated impairment. Most
of these early silver dollars did not survive at all, and this
one certainly presents the desirable device definition for the
collector seeking an example. Not only was this early Draped
Bust design a scarce issue, but it was the first appearance
of this type on the silver dollar denomination in late 1795.
The Draped Bust design was soon adopted onto all silver
coinage, as well as the obverse for copper coinage as well in
1796 and later as soon as master hubs were prepared.
PCGS# 6858.
PCGS# 96858.
Page 94
2013 1796 BB-61, B-4. Rarity-3. BB Die State I. Small Date,
Large Letters. EF-45 (ICG). Otherwise golden-silver
surfaces reveal warmer iridescent steel outlines to many
of the devices. This piece is boldly, if not sharply defined
throughout, although a curious glossy to matte-like texture
is noted for accuracy. On this obverse die the engraver used
smaller sized digits for the date than seen on another obverse
die used in this year, hence the Small Date designation.
Similarly the reverse die shows larger sized letters than
commonly seen on silver dollars of this date, hence the
Large Letters refers to those in the legend UNITED STATES
OF AMERICA. The Draped Bust, Small Eagle type was
issued from late 1795 through early 1798, which created this
distinctive type coin. All are scarce and in high demand,
especially when found this well preserved.
PCGS# 40000.
2014 1796 BB-61, B-4. Rarity-3. BB Die State I. Small Date,
Large Letters. VG Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Retoning
nicely in mostly slate gray, warmer charcoal-russet
peripheral highlights are more pronounced for the obverse.
The borders are distinct, the devices are fully outlined, and
scattered marks are generally consistent with the assigned
details grade. A scarce early issue not only as a date but also
as a type with the Draped Bust, Small Eagle design.
PCGS# 6860.
2015 1796 BB-65, B-5. Rarity-4. BB Die State III. Large Date,
Small Letters. Genuine—Holed and Plugged (PCGS).
Rather nicely retoned in a blend of bold olive-charcoal and
mauve-gray, this more affordable type candidate also sports
ample sharpness of detail on both sides. The surfaces are quite
smooth overall, and only upon closer inspection are we able
to identify a carefully executed plug above Liberty’s head.
This is a scarce date and type, with the Draped Bust Obverse
and Small Eagle reverse. The devices are finely executed and
attractive, and this particular coin retains virtually all of
the original definition and shows light circulation evidence
on the uppermost devices only. Wholesome examples of
this issue are formidable purchases for most collectors.EF
Details.
2017 1797 BB-73, B-1a. Rarity-3. BB Die State III. Stars 9x7,
Large Letters. VF-20 (PCGS). OGH. Light to medium silver
gray iridescence adorns both sides of this overall smooth,
minimally marked survivor. Otherwise boldly defined at the
VF grade level, minor softness of strike is confined to the
upper left obverse and lower left reverse peripheral areas.
Scarce and desirable for the collector as this is one of the
more important major type and variety coins of this series.
The handsome portrait of Liberty offers strong definition of
her curls as well as some of the feathers on the eagle.
PCGS# 6863.
2018 1798 Heraldic Eagle. BB-105, B-23a. Rarity-3. BB Die
State III. Pointed 9, Wide Date. VF Details—Repaired
(PCGS). Iridescent steel gray drifts over both sides in a
somewhat mottled fashion. A reverse scratch at the letter R
in LIBERTY is noted, as are areas of obverse tooling both in
the field and over Liberty’s portrait. The balance of the coin
is attractive and offers both strong definition and minimal
wear from circulation.
PCGS# 6873.
State III. Pointed 9, Wide Date. Fine-15 (PCGS). This piece
is evenly toned in pleasing golden-gray with surfaces that
are uncommonly smooth for a well circulated silver dollar
of this type. Lightly struck in the centers, as befits the die
marriage, although the overall wear is commensurate with
the grade assigned by PCGS. The present piece represents
a great opportunity for a collector to take a step back into
the 18th Century with his or her coin election at a price that
makes good sense.
PCGS# 40022.
PCGS# 6861.
2016 1797 BB-71, B-3. Rarity-2. BB Die State III. Stars 10x6.
Fine Details—Graffiti (PCGS). Nicely toned in a blend of
light mauve and silver gray, this piece presents quite nicely
despite the presence of a few faint initials in the central
reverse field. Many early coins from this period have such
initials as this practice was apparently common. Today these
coins are truly scarce and highly desirable as some of the
first silver coins struck by the Philadelphia Mint. Collectible
and attractive at this grade level and worth a solid bid.
PCGS# 6865.
2020 1798 Heraldic Eagle. BB-111, B-11. Rarity-3. BB Die State
VIII. Pointed 9, Wide Date. EF-45 (NGC). This handsome
piece is evenly and originally toned in pewter gray. Sharply
defined from a well executed strike, even despite the
advanced die state, there is much to recommend this coin
to the early dollar variety specialist. The terminal die state
makes attribution a simple and almost instantaneous task.
The roster of “notable specimens” in Q. David Bowers
Encyclopedia of U.S. Silver Dollars, 1794-1804 includes pieces
ranging in grade from AU-55 down to VF-35. Both the
F.C.C. Boyd and A.J. Ostheimer specimens are comparable
with the presently offered piece in terms of quality.
PCGS# 6873.
Page 95
2021 1798 Heraldic Eagle. BB-113, B-27. Rarity-2. BB Die
State II. Pointed 9, Close Date. AU Details—Improperly
Cleaned (NGC). Nicely retoned in dominant olive-gray
patina, both sides also reveal iridescent, multicolored
undertones as the coin dips into a light. Ample sharpness
of strike is also a praiseworthy attribute, as is a lack of
outwardly distracting abrasions. Adding even further
interest to this enticing early dollar, Liberty’s profile is
boldly doubled. This feature is not indicative of a doubled
die, however, but rather strike (a.k.a. mechanical, bounce
or shelf) doubling. A few examples from this particular
obverse die have the boldly doubled profile feature, but this
is not commonly found. Remarkably, this same obverse die
was later paired with six more reverse dies, each creating a
new variety. Some are plentiful, others are common, but in
each case the reverse die cracked up and had to be replaced
with the tough obverse die lived on to strike more coins.
PCGS# 6873.
State II. Pointed 9, Close Date. VF Details—Improperly
Cleaned (NGC). Rather nicely retoned in even dove gray,
bold outline definition to all but a few isolated elements of
the design also enhance the appeal of this scarce 1798 BB121 dollar. The strike is fairly well centered between fully
denticulated borders, and there are no sizeable or otherwise
outwardly distracting abrasions. A scarce variety with an
estimated population thought to be no greater than 75
pieces in all grades combined.
PCGS# 40038.
PCGS# 6873.
2025 1799/8 BB-141, B-3. Rarity-3. BB Die State II. 15-Star
Reverse. Genuine—Damage (PCGS). Overall bold
definition to the major devices and handsome retoning in
antique gold and charcoal-copper enhance the appearance of
this mid grade early dollar. A few prominent scrapes on the
reverse shield are noted, as is a curiously glossy texture that
points to an old cleaning. This reverse die is most interesting
as the engraver blundered the star count and put 15 stars
over the eagle instead of the 13 stars required. What to do
now? A creative solution was employed by extending the left
and right most clouds down over the extra star! This unique
blunder is one of the more interesting corrective actions
laid forth in die steel. Thankfully for collectors today, these
dies lasted well and this is not a particularly rare variety, but
enormously popular for this blunder. VF Details.
PCGS# 6883.
State IV. Pointed 9, Close Date. VF-30 (ANACS). OH.
This well defined mid grade survivor is free of outwardly
distracting abrasions, a series of adjustment marks over
the eagle’s right (facing) wing being as struck features. A
muted, somewhat glossy texture points to an old cleaning,
although the surfaces have been rather pleasingly retoned in
even pewter gray. All 1798 silver dollars are scarce, as there
were the highest number of die pairings for the entire series
in 1798, but the number around today are fewer than one
might expect. Furthermore, interest in this particular date
continues to grow as there are many challenging varieties to
obtain as well as interesting die states.
PCGS# 40018.
State IV. Pointed 9, Wide Date. AU-53 (PCGS). Pleasing
pearl gray patina blankets both sides with intermingled
deep rose highlights also discernible at isolated angles. Well
struck for this die marriage, all areas are boldly to sharply
defined save for characteristic softness of detail over the
end of Liberty’s bust and the upper right reverse. There are
no mentionable abrasions, and the eye appeal is solid for
a minimally circulated early dollar. One of the top dozen
of this die pairing reported and a prime candidate for an
advanced variety collection. The later die state adds interest
as well to the high technical grade.
2026 1799 BB-157, B-5. Rarity-2. BB Die State IV. VF-35
(PCGS). This is a handsome, well balanced VF with plenty
of bold to sharp definition on both sides. Free of distracting
abrasions, the surfaces are attractively toned in rich lavendergray (obverse) and olive-gray (reverse) shades. The reverse
die offers a quick identifying feature in the form of the die
crack through STATES. This die crack wobbles on the first
T, by dipping down and then climbing back toward the tops
of the letters ATES. Bolender when writing his reference in
1950 refereed to his “a” die state as having “short die cracks
from lower left corner of E down to hair, and below first star.”
These are more likely clashing from the eagle’s tail at the E,
and from the wing below the star. Clashing was not well
understood in 1950 by most numismatists. Furthermore,
these clash lines may have been lapped away in the normal
course of Mint procedure.
PCGS# 6878.
Page 96
2027 1799 BB-159, B-23. Rarity-4. BB Die State I. Stars 8x5.
VF-20 (PCGS). The Stars 8x5 Guide Book variety is not
denoted on the PCGS insert. Slightly mottled rose-gray and
olive-gray patina is splashed over both sides of this bold VF
example. There are no outwardly noticeable abrasions, an
uncommon positive in a moderately circulated early dollar.
This variety is tough to find at all, and highly desirable for
the unique 8x5 star arrangement on the obverse and is listed
as a major type coin that is needed by collectors. This early
die state example is both appealing and scarce, with enough
definition to invite study by numismatists.
PCGS# 6881.
2029 1799 BB-169, B-21. Rarity-3. BB Die State IV. EF-45
(PCGS). This lightly toned, silver-lilac example retains
overall bold definition from a well executed, nicely centered
strike. A touch of glossiness to the surface texture is
noted for accuracy, but there are no sizeable or otherwise
singularly distracting abrasions to report. This is a tough die
pairing to find in high grade, perhaps two or three merit
the Mint State grade, then Condition Census fills with AU
coins. This pleasing EF-45 offers not only a high grade but
a later die state with an obverse crack up from the border
through the base of the 7, both 9s into Liberty’s drapery.
A good representative for the date or variety collector to
consider.
PCGS# 6878.
2028 1799 BB-163, B-10. Rarity-2. BB Die State IV. Unc
Details—Spot Removed (PCGS). An important piece,
and worthy of a close look prior to bidding, it would not
surprise us to see this early dollar end up in a graded Mint
State holder. Both sides are sharply defined from a well
executed strike, and the surfaces are overall smooth with
hardly a blemish to report. Satiny in texture, with iridescent
steel gray and olive-copper patina that lightens a bit around
Liberty’s portrait. The stated impairment is extremely minor
and is confined to a tiny area in the obverse field inside stars
10 and 11. As noted in Q. David Bowers Encyclopedia of
United States Silver Dollars 1794 - 1804 this specimen is one
of the top ten known for the variety as well as an important
offering for the type collector. Mint State Draped Bust silver
dollars are all rare and always in high demand. While this
example has a minor fault, it is certainly easy to overlook
given the demand for high grade examples from this
series. Furthermore, this later die state adds interest for the
multiple thin die cracks that extend through the stars and
legends. A handsome coin that will add considerable depth
to any advanced collection.
2030 1800 BB-184, B-12a. Rarity-3. BB Die State II. VG-8
(PCGS). Handsome deep olive-gray patina blankets both
sides of this exceptionally smooth VG. Softly defined in the
centers (probably due more to striking quality than wear),
yet with bold outline definition to the devices in other areas.
On balance an attractive example of this sought after type
coin, with their large size and heft, these early silver dollars
remain as impressive today as they were when first released
into circulation at the time of issue.
PCGS# 6887.
2031 1800 BB-187, B-16. Rarity-2. BB Die State IV. Fine-15
(PCGS). Bold olive-charcoal toning yields to lighter silver
gray in the center of the obverse. Well centered in strike
with crisp outline definition at the Fine grade level, a lack
of outwardly distracting abrasions further enhances this
coin’s desirability for circulated type purposes. BB-187 is
a distinctive die variety showing roughness between the
letters ES in STATES; this is probably the feature that most
numismatists notice first when attributing an example of the
variety.
PCGS# 6887.
PCGS# 6878.
Page 97
2032 1800 BB-190, B-10. Rarity-3. BB Die State III. Very Wide
Date, Low 8. VF-30 (NGC). The Very Wide Date, Low 8
Guide Book variety is not denoted on the NGC insert. This
boldly defined mid-grade example is warmly and evenly
toned in charcoal gray patina. Most of the die pairings of
1800 come well struck and preserved, as seen here. When
the engraver punched in the date, the numbers were set a
little too far apart, with the 8 decidedly low for this obverse
die. A solid collector coin that is more wholesome than
these are usually found.
PCGS# 6888.
2034 1802 BB-241, B-6. Rarity-1. BB Die State III. Narrow
Date. VF Details—Devices Outlined (PCGS). Mottled
silver-olive and steel gray patina greets the viewer from both
sides of this bold VF early dollar. The surfaces are outwardly
smooth in appearance, and even the stated impairment
is extremely minor and largely confined to the back of
Liberty’s head. Old encrustation is often removed with a
sharp instrument like a pin, and that may have been what
happened here. Still a decent coin which offers strong curl
definition on Liberty as well as most of the feathers on the
eagle to please the collector.
PCGS# 40087.
Date. VG-10 (PCGS). Handsome lilac-gray patina blankets
both sides and blends with warmer olive gray highlights
at the borders. A suitably bold VG with all devices boldly
outlined and readily appreciable. Scarce and desirable this
well preserved and a coin that will please most date or type
collectors for its impressive size and historical importance
as one of our first silver dollars.
PCGS# 40087.
2036 1802 BB-242, B-5. Rarity-5. VF Details—Obverse Graffiti
(NGC). This richly original piece is toned in handsome
olive-charcoal that accents overall bold definition to the
devices. In addition to graffiti in the right obverse field,
which appears to be a person’s name (the exact name, or
word, is illegible), a short, sharp dig in the reverse field
above the olive branch is worthy of note. This die marriage
is scarce too, and despite the minor graffiti this coin is still a
desirable and historic example of this series.
PCGS# 40087.
2033 1800 BB-192, B-19. Rarity-2. BB Die State I. AMERICAI.
VF-20 (NGC). CAC. OH. The AMERICAI Guide Book
variety is not denoted on the old style NGC holder. A
delightful piece, both sides exhibit dominant pale silver
surfaces with handsome russet outlines to the devices.
Smooth and well defined for the grade, we anticipate this
coin bringing a strong premium at auction. The additional
“I” is believed to be an engraver’s scratch although it could
be a part of a mispunched A that was too far to the right.
This reverse die was paired with two different obverses and
has been an important major variety for decades. Attractive
coins like this offering are always in strong demand.
2037 1803 BB-252, B-5. Rarity-2. Small 3. VF Details—
Smoothed (PCGS). In addition to ample boldness of detail,
this mid-grade early dollar offers rather attractive retoning
in mottled iridescent golden-copper that is sure to appeal
to the budget minded type collector. Worthy of in-person
examination.
PCGS# 6900.
PCGS# 6892.
Page 98
Handsome Proof 1836 Judd-60 Silver Dollar
2038 1836 Name on Base. Judd-60 (Second) Original, Pollock-65. Rarity-1. Dannreuther Reverse Die State h. Silver. Plain Edge. Die
Alignment IV. Proof-60 (PCGS). OGH. The old style PCGS insert attributes this coin as a Restrike, but the die alignment suggests
that this coin is one of the “second” originals from the March 1837 issue of 1836 Name on Base Gobrecht dollars. Brilliant apart
from iridescent golden overtones that are more pronounced on the reverse, this piece exhibits deeply mirrored fields supporting
satiny devices. The definition is sharp in all but a few isolated areas, and there are only small, wispy contact marks to define the
grade. This is the medal turn alignment with the eagle flying level when turned, and uneven pellets. The events that brought this
coin about started when Mint Director Samuel Moore tendered his resignation effective June 30, 1835, and Robert W. Patterson was
put into his position. Christian Gobrecht had been hired as an Assistant Engraver at the Mint to help prepare dies for the expected
branch mints and likely to help out at the Philadelphia Mint during this transitional time. Then the Chief Mint Engraver, William
Kneass suffered an incapacitating stroke in August of 1835 so Gobrecht became the primary engraver by default. Thus Gobrecht was
given the task of designing the new silver dollar with suggestions by Robert Patterson. Patterson suggested to Gobrecht that Liberty
should be depicted in the seated position and holding her cap upon a pole. The flying eagle design was also adopted, a significant
change from the eagle depicted as standing or fixed upon our Great Seal. Naturally these bold designs were immediately recognized
as outstanding and the popularity of these coins was apparent, at the time of issue and even greater today. This prime example will
certainly delight any collector who has been seeking one of these Gobrecht dollars and its capture will advance any specialized
collection.
PCGS# 11226.
2039 1836 Name on Base. Judd-60 Original, Pollock-65.
Rarity-1. Silver. Plain Edge. Die Alignment I. Proof. Fine
Details—Repaired (NGC). The brevity of this type, its
historical significance, and the paucity of survivors all point
to keen bidder interest in this more affordable Gobrecht
dollar. The major design elements are fully outlined and
clear, and we even note some bolder definition in a few of the
recesses. Minimally toned, with scattered hairlines, evidence
of tooling, and other repair work. Still, a Gobrecht dollar is
a Gobrecht dollar, and we have never seen an example “go
begging” in our sales no matter the grade. If a filler example
of the date is on your wish list, this opportunity is made just
for you.
2040 1845 AU-55 (NGC). Lightly and evenly toned silver-tan
surfaces are uncommonly free of sizeable abrasions for a
lightly circulated Seated dollar. The overall definition is
sharp, and more direct angles also call forth glints of original
satin luster. Scarce at this lofty grade level and a date that is
seldom offered in any Mint State grade, and certainly at a
far higher price when such a coin appears. Here is a solid
representative for the date collector who desires quality and
luster on a high grade Liberty Seated dollar.
PCGS# 6931.
PCGS# 11225.
Page 99
2041 1846-O AU-55 (PCGS). A challenging issue to find “nice,”
the present example retains considerable satin to semireflective luster beneath delicate golden-gray and reddishgold iridescence. Apart from characteristic softness of strike
to Liberty’s head, both sides are boldly defined throughout,
and there are no singularly distracting abrasions to report.
Most of the high grade pieces known from this date and
mint were from an original group released by the Treasury
years ago. Most were heavily bagmarked, but otherwise this
issue would be quite difficult to obtain in high grades. Only
59,000 were struck.
2045 1860-O MS-63 (NGC). Unlike most extant Mint State
‘60-O dollars, this coin is minimally abraded with toned,
as opposed to brilliant, surfaces. Boldly struck with a
vibrant satin finish, mottled pink, lavender and goldenrose iridescence engages both sides. The surface quality and
the toning of this piece suggest to us that it was known to
collectors prior to the Treasury releases of the early 1960s
when a bag or more of the date came to light — those pieces
are usually heavily ticked in the fields and brilliant.
PCGS# 6950.
PCGS# 6933.
2042 1848 AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS). This brilliant, silver
white piece retains both bold to sharp striking detail and
whispers of original satin luster. Heavily hairlined from a
cleaning, yet free of individually mentionable abrasions.
This type of cleaning is commonly seen on these early
silver dollars as they have been collected for generations
and somewhere along the line a misguided soul decided to
brighten the surfaces up. Given time the natural color and
more eye appeal should return.
PCGS# 6935.
2043 1859 Proof-64 Cameo (PCGS). Fully struck and satiny
in texture, the devices offer bold cameo contrast to the
mirrored fields in the absence of all but the lightest gold
and silver tinting. A few minor contact marks in the right
obverse field are all that seem to preclude full Gem status for
this captivating Proof silver dollar. The Guide Book suggests
a Proof mintage for this early date Liberty Seated dollar of
just 800 pieces, though certainly far fewer are known today.
The present specimen would make a grand addition to a
type set or an early dollar set.
PCGS# 87002.
2044 1859 Proof. Unc Details—Tooled (PCGS). Sharply
defined overall with swirling lavender-gray and tan-rose
patina, more direct angles also call forth vivid blue and
lilac undertones. The Proof finish is still discernible as the
surfaces dip into a light, although the toning does help to
conceal light tooling that is generally confined to the right
obverse field. 800 Proof silver dollars were coined during the
year, but seemingly fewer than half of these have survived.
During the 19th century and early decades of the 20th
century, Proofs often sold for just a small premium over face
value, and accordingly were sometimes spent by collectors
who were experiencing a “cash crunch”.
2046 1860-O MS-62 (PCGS). Secure Holder. A blush of
champagne pink iridescence along the upper obverse
border is all that denies full brilliance for this satiny,
intensely lustrous piece. Sharply struck, minimally abraded
for the grade, and perfect for Mint State type purposes.
Although this is a fairly plentiful issue with a mintage of
515,000 pieces, most of these probably went overseas in the
export trade according to Q. David Bowers. However, some
apparently stayed behind on these shores, tucked away and
nearly forgotten about. Legends and stories abound and
some of these are likely true, of great discoveries of an entire
mint bag of these 1860-O silver dollars coming to light a
hundred or so years after they were struck. Most of the
known coins show moderate to heavy bagmarks, and the
finest examples are generally from much earlier and random
sources. Today Mint State examples are highly collectible
and desirable in all grades, and represent an opportunity for
the astute numismatist.
PCGS# 6950.
2047 1860-O MS-61 (NGC). This is a highly lustrous, satin
textured piece that also offers sharp striking detail and
radiant mint brilliance throughout. A classic that is likely
from one of the original sources that were released about
fifty years ago or so, possibly from an original bag of these. It
would be hard to imagine opening up a bag of silver dollars
and finding Liberty Seated coins! There were clearly a few
groups or partial bags released given the numbers certified
today, the totals were probably lower than some rumors have
stated, and a clearer picture is available today. Thankfully for
collectors, not all of these became the trade coins expected
for overseas, as they would have been melted and few would
have survived.
PCGS# 6950.
PCGS# 7002.
Page 100
2048 1860-O MS-60 (PCGS). OGH. This frosty, sharply struck
and overall brilliant piece is sure to be of keen interest to the
Mint State type or date collector of U.S. silver dollars. Scarce
as a date and mint in any Mint State grade, this example
should please any Liberty Seated silver dollar collector who
seeks full definition and frosty surfaces. Best of all, this is a
New Orleans Mint coin, which struck silver dollars only on
a few occasions for this series, and all are scarce today.
2052 1865 AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Sharply defined with
light silver centers, warmer steel-gold highlights frame both
sides from the peripheries. A low mintage date of 46,500
pieces that were struck as the Civil War finally came to a
conclusion. Not many survived and fewer still in a high
technical grade like this. This is also the final year of the No
Motto style reverse.
PCGS# 6955.
PCGS# 6950.
2049 1864 MS-60 (PCGS). OGH. Crisply impressed with vibrant
satiny luster, this predominantly brilliant example has the
“look” of a higher grade. There are no sizeable abrasions, in
fact, although accuracy does compel us to mention wispy
hairlines that are not readily evident at all angles. Delicate
golden-olive peripheral toning further enhances already
strong eye appeal at the BU grade level. A tough issue with
a mintage of 30,700 pieces and not many are known in Mint
State. Here is a fine example to grace an advanced date or
type collection of this popular series.
PCGS# 6954.
2050 1864 AU-55 (ANACS). OH. Sharply defined with no
readily evident wear, this coin has the “look” of a Mint State
details grade. While there are few outwardly distracting
abrasions, glossy surfaces and curious sandy-gray retoning
suggest that this piece may have been net graded to AU55 due to cleaning. A scarce Civil-War-era issue having a
mintage of just 30,700 pieces. It appears that most of these
were probably melted into bullion long ago as the two major
services, considered together, have certified the issue on
fewer than 250 occasions over the years.
2053 1866 Motto. Proof-62 (PCGS). OGH. Charming golden
tinged surfaces exhibit more than enough field to device
contrast to support a Cameo designation. Also premium
quality at the Proof-62 numeric grade level, the surfaces are
outwardly quite smooth with only faint, wispy hairlines that
are easily overlooked at most angles. From the first year of
the denomination to bear the motto IN GOD WE TRUST,
and one of 725 examples of the issue struck in the Proof
format according to the Red Book. Worthy of a strong bid!
PCGS# 7014.
PCGS# 6954.
Gem Proof 1865 Silver Dollar
2051 1865 Proof-65 (NGC). CAC. OH. Fully original and
highly attractive, both sides are drenched in a blend of
rich charcoal-olive and lavender-gray patina. More direct
angles call forth not only iridescent gold undertones, but
also radiant mint brilliance in the fields. The devices are
satiny in texture with a full strike, and the surfaces are
expectably smooth at the Gem grade level. A mere 500
Proof silver dollars were struck in 1865. When you consider
the destruction and economic hardship during and after the
Civil War, and that one silver dollar represented over a day’s
pay for the average worker at that time, it would have been
a rare luxury for a contemporary collector to obtain such a
coin. While NGC has graded 176 proofs in all grades, the
bulk are at the Proof-64 level or below, and many entries are
certainly resubmissions. A beautiful specimen that is sure to
sell for a premium bid.
2054 1868 MS-61 (PCGS). Richly toned in mottled charcoal and
sandy-gray patina, this well struck piece also exhibits bold
to sharp definition in most areas. Minimally abraded for the
assigned grade, there are actually very few readily evident
distractions on either side. Despite a fairly generous mintage
of 162,100 pieces, probably no more than just a few hundred
survivors could be accounted for today, mostly in the VF to
AU grade range. The roster of Mint State examples is limited
to just a few dozen pieces. Certification service statistics for
the date are probably skewed by multiple submissions at the
highest grade levels.
PCGS# 6961.
2055 1870 Proof-62 (NGC). Draped in warm, even, tannish-gray
patina, more direct angles reveal faint traces of reflectivity
in the fields that help to confirm the Proof status of this late
date Liberty Seated dollar. The surfaces are uncommonly
smooth in outward appearance with no readily evident
handling marks.
PCGS# 7018.
PCGS# 7008.
NGC Population: 30; 13 finer in this category.
Page 101
Glorious Proof 1871 Silver Dollar
2056 1871 Proof-64 Deep Cameo (PCGS). Brilliant apart from
the lightest golden iridescence, this sharply struck, boldly
contrasted specimen makes a strong visual impression.
Equally solid in the technical category, there are none but
a few faint, easily overlooked handling marks precluding an
even higher grade. Gorgeous! Mintage of only 960 pieces of
which perhaps 10 to 15 are known with the Deep Cameo or
Ultra Cameo designation, the highest contrast awarded to
these handsome Proof coins. The visual appeal and impact
is tremendous when studied under a light source. As the
Liberty Seated silver dollar series was winding down in a
few years, these simply are not of potential Proof coins to
pursue as the earlier Proofs often did not create this depth
of contrast. An exceptional example for the numismatist
who appreciates strong visual appeal blended with technical
quality.
PCGS# 97019.
PCGS Population: 2; 4 are finer (Proof-66 Deep Cameo finest) within the Deep Cameo designation.
2059 1870-CC EF Details—Repaired (NGC). Richly and evenly
retoned in rather pleasing charcoal gray, this relatively
bold EF is sure to find many willing buyers among Liberty
Seated and/or CC-mint specialists. Outwardly smooth with
no troublesome abrasions, the repair is well concealed by
the toning and seems to be largely confined to tooling in
the fields. Liberty Seated dollars were struck at the Carson
City Mint over the course of just four years, and each issue
had a small mintage; only 11,758 examples were coined
in 1870. Perhaps as many as 1,000 examples survive in all
grades combined. If we accept 1,000 pieces as our high-end
estimate, this would suggest a survival rate of nearly 10%, a
rather large proportion of the original production figure.
PCGS# 6964.
2060 1870-CC VF-30 (PCGS). Pleasing medium gray surfaces
are boldly defined with no abrasions that we deem
noteworthy in a mid grade CC-mint Seated dollar. This is
the first year of issue of any coinage from the Carson City
branch mint, which was authorized back in 1863 and finally
ready for coinage in late 1869. Dies arrived but no coins were
apparently struck until 1870. These silver dollars were made
from the Comstock Lode silver which was first discovered
in 1859, and produced substantial quantities of silver and
gold, both of which were refined and minted at the Carson
City Mint. A total of 12,462 pieces were struck this year and
from that beginning perhaps 550 to 675 pieces exist today.
This is one of the finer circulated examples and would be a
welcome addition to an advanced collection.
PCGS# 6964.
2057 1871 Proof-62 (PCGS). This sharply impressed, richly
toned piece is awash in a blend of antique gold and deep
charcoal. A solid example of this scarce early Proof and a
good selection to represent this type or date.
PCGS# 7019.
2058 1871 Proof. Unc Details—Altered Surfaces (PCGS). Both
sides of this coin are fully struck and free of detracting
contact marks. The reverse has a somewhat original “look”
with light golden iridescence over cameo contrast. The
obverse, on the other hand, is quite muted in appearance
beneath curious olive-gray patina. The Red Book offers a
Proof mintage for the date of 960 pieces.
PCGS# 7019.
2061 1871 MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. Secure Holder. Beautiful satin
white surfaces are bursting with vibrant luster that accents
a sharply executed strike. A strong candidate to represent
the Motto Liberty Seated silver dollar in a high grade type
set. Walter Breen in his Complete Encyclopedia of U.S. and
Colonial Coins, claimed that there were a couple of bags
(with 1,000 pieces per bag) of Uncirculated examples from
the U.S. Treasury Hoard dispersed in the 1960s. Breen’s
claim doesn’t seem to be corroborated by population
statistics which suggest that scarcely more than 300 Mint
State examples have been certified over the years by the two
leading grading services combined.
PCGS# 6966.
Page 102
2062 1871 MS-62 (PCGS). OGH. This boldly struck piece
exhibits satiny, uncommonly smooth looking surfaces in
a BU Liberty Seated dollar. Otherwise brilliant, blushes of
pale golden iridescence are confined to the right obverse
and reverse borders. Although a few hundred Mint State
examples evidently exist, it is important to note that
Walter Breen’s claim that there were two Treasury bags
of Uncirculated pieces released in the 1960s has not been
corroborated by certification service statistics.
PCGS# 6966.
2065 1872-S EF-45 (PCGS). Warmly toned in deep, rich, olivecharcoal patina, this overall sharp example also offers
freedom from outwardly distracting abrasions. The 1872S is one of the tough to find date and mints of this series.
The original mintage of 9,000 pieces leaves few for modern
collectors of this day. Furthermore, the vast majority of that
modest number were melted in later years, leaving perhaps
ten percent of those issued available today. This is a major
rarity in all Mint State grades and most collectors, if they
can obtain one at all, find a moderately circulated example.
As such, this attractive EF-45 will certainly stand tall in
any advanced collection of the Liberty Seated silver dollars
series.
PCGS# 6970.
2063 1872 Breen-5491. Misplaced Date. MS-62 (PCGS). This
boldly toned example is awash in a blend of steel gray, goldencopper and pale rose patina. With few outwardly distracting
abrasions, the surfaces appear uncommonly smooth in a BU
silver dollar of this conditionally challenging type. Walter
Breen in his Complete Encyclopedia listed the Blundered
Date variety as “very rare.” Breen’s claim that there was at
least one released Treasury bag of Uncirculated 1872 dollars
(1,000 pieces) is seemingly contradicted by the combined
population statistics of the two major grading services
which together suggest a surviving Mint State population of
just 200 to 300 pieces.
PCGS# 6968.
2066 1878 7/8 Tailfeathers. Weak. VAM-44. Top 100 Variety.
7/5 Tailfeathers, Tripled Blossoms. AU Details—Cleaning
(PCGS). This piece is a bit glossy in texture from a cleaning,
although the devices are boldly defined overall and the
surfaces have started to retone in a blend of light silver and
gold. There are several different die varieties of 1878 8/7
Tailfeathers Morgan dollars (sometimes also referred to as
“Doubled Tailfeathers.”) These varieties are fully detailed
in the Van Allen-Mallis Encyclopedia of Morgan and Peace
Dollars, wherein all of the different variations are illustrated.
Some collectors over the years have enjoyed assembling a
set of the different VAM 8/7 Tailfeather varieties, several
which are known to exist in high grades. PCGS has certified
just a few dozen examples as VAM-44, but doubtlessly many
examples remain unattributed in collections.
PCGS# 133829.
2067 1878-CC Morgan. MS-65 (NGC). Fully struck and virtually
brilliant throughout, this otherwise satiny Gem reveals
modest semi-reflective tendencies in the reverse field. An
ever-popular date with collectors of Morgan dollars and
Carson City Mint specialists alike.
PCGS# 7080.
2064 1872-CC EF-40 (PCGS). This richly and evenly toned,
copper-russet example offers bold EF detail in an example
of a rare and conditionally challenging CC-mint issue.
Minimally abraded, and uncommonly so for a circulated
1872-CC Seated dollar, this coin is sure to excite the
advanced collector. A modest mintage of 3,150 pieces leaves
few for collectors today, especially if a high grade example
like this is desired. Many of those seen today are damaged
or have significant surface problems as these circulated
hard during their years of service in commerce. Here is a
well preserved, high grade example that is destined to be a
centerpiece of a major date and mint collection of this series.
PCGS# 6969.
2068 1879-CC VAM-3. Top 100 Variety. Capped Die. MS-61
(PCGS). This softly frosted, otherwise silver white example
exhibits pretty peripheral highlights in iridescent goldenorange. Well struck for the variety, with no singularly
distracting abrasions among the grade defining bag marks.
Known for decades as the “Capped Die” (whatever that
means) variety, most collectors now refer to it as a “CC over
CC” mintmark variety, which is how theGuideBook nowlists
this popular issue.
PCGS# 7088.
Page 103
2069 1879-CC Unc Details—Tooled (PCGS). This sharply struck,
overall smooth example offers rather strong eye appeal in a
brilliant, fully lustrous CC-mint Morgan. An unfortunate
concentration of scratches at the back of Liberty’s cheek
explains the PCGS qualifier. Still, this key date Carson City
issue is worth more than just a casual glance and could very
well be the example you’ve been searching for.
PCGS# 7086.
2070 1879-CC AU-55 (NGC). Brilliant, vibrant surfaces allow
ready appreciation of ample remaining luster. This is a
boldly defined and fully AU survivor of a popular semikey issue among Carson City Mint Morgans. The “normal”
mintmark style offered here is moderately scarcer than the
CC/CC reverse of this popular and elusive date — some
collections are known to house both reverse types.
PCGS# 7086.
2071 1879-S MS-67+ (PCGS). CAC. Splendid superb-quality
surfaces are brightly untoned with razor sharp devices and
radiant satin to softly frosted luster. Choice for the grade
with eye appeal that is completely up to the task. Beautiful!
2074 1880-CC MS-66 (NGC). Highly lustrous with silky smooth
surfaces, this satin white beauty makes a lovely impression
in all regards. Only 495,000 Morgan dollars were coined
at the Carson City Mint during the year, a low production
figure by Morgan dollar standards. The Guide Book lists five
popularly collected varieties for the issue, most of which
can be acquired in high grades without difficulty. The
piece offered here is easily in the top 10% of all Mint State
examples certified by NGC.
PCGS# 7100.
PCGS# 7092.
2072 1880/79-CC VAM-4. Top 100 Variety. Reverse of 1878.
MS-64 (PCGS). Frosty with razor sharp striking detail,
this delightful near-Gem also sports delicate orange-gold
peripheral iridescence that is more pronounced on the
reverse. The first of the Morgan dollar overdates, most of
which occur in 1880 save for the 1887/6 varieties. Always
popular and a date that can be cherrypicked with some
patience.
PCGS# 7108.
Gem Mint State 1880-O VAM
Morgan Dollar Rarity
VAM-7, Hit List 40
Ex: GSA.
2073 1880-CC MS-66 (PCGS). Bursting with brilliant satin to
softly frosted luster, this impressive Gem also sports an
uncommonly full strike in an 1880-CC Morgan dollar of
the Reverse of 1879 hub variety. The Guide Book lists five
different popularly collected varieties of 1880-CC dollars;
these were coined using two distinct reverses, together with
several different obverses mostly with prominent overdates.
Some Morgan dollar specialists endeavor to include all five
varieties in their sets. Many of the famous Treasury Hoard
1880-CC dollars were encapsulated in G.S.A. holders for
distribution to collectors during the 1970s. The presently
offered example is easily in the top 10% of Mint States
specimens certified by PCGS.
PCGS# 7100.
2075 1880-O VAM-7. Hit List 40. Rusted Die. MS-65
(NGC). This crisply impressed, fully lustrous piece
exhibits billowy satin luster on both sides. The reverse is
close to fully brilliant, although the obverse is splashed
with light, mottled, golden-apricot iridescence.
Carefully preserved, as befits the assigned grade, and
attractive in all regards. Information at the vamworld.
com website tells us: “ VAM-7 is an interesting Rarity-5
variety that is overshadowed by its peers selected for
the Top 100 list.” The obverse of this variety exhibits
fine rust pitting throughout the bust of Liberty as well
as at the date and on certain obverse stars and portions
of the legends. There is also minor repunching at the
880 of the date and at the reverse mintmark.
PCGS# 41166.
Page 104
2076 1880-O MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC Impressively well preserved
for an example of this conditionally challenging New
Orleans Mint issue, both sides retain full, vibrant mint frost
in the absence of detracting abrasions. Sharply struck and
brilliant, there is much to recommend this premium nearGem to an advanced Morgan dollar specialist. The mintage
for the date of just over 5.3 million pieces would seemingly
indicate a surfeit of pleasing Mint State examples for today’s
collectors, but such is not the case. Much of the mintage
went into commerce, if even for just a short time, making
EF and AU coins plentiful today. There were some small bag
quantities of the date released from time to time beginning
in the 1940s and in the 1962 Treasury release, but those have
long since been assimilated into collections. A Choice MS64+ example presents a modest acquisition challenge.
PCGS# 7114.
2078 1880-O VAM-4. Top 100 Variety. 80/79, Micro O,
Crossbar Overdate. MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. Frosty and
outwardly smooth, this engaging near-Gem is brilliant apart
from delicate reddish-gold highlights in isolated peripheral
areas. This elusive issue is much scarcer across the board
than its overdate counterpart of the year from the Carson
City Mint. Despite a large mintage, the 1880-O is scarce and
eagerly sought in high grades, something likely due to the
destruction of more than 200 million silver dollars pursuant
to the provisions of the Pittman Act of 1918. Although 2,000
to 3,000 1880-O dollars probably still exist in MS-64 and
higher grades, the 80/79 overdate variety is much rarer.
PCGS has certified fewer than 200 1880-O dollars as VAM-4,
mostly in grades below MS-64. Other examples have simply
been certified as ordinary 1880-O dollars, but the extent to
which this has happened is not known to us. Dave Bowers in
his Silver Dollars & Trade Dollars of the United States wrote:
“This variety has the clearest overdate features of any 1880O . . . and therefore is quite desirable.” He further added that
many examples of the variety “showed up in a bag from the
R.D. Donovan Hoard.”
PCGS# 7114.
2077 1880-O MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC. Fully frosted with lovely
mint brilliance, this premium ‘80-O dollar also offers bold to
sharp definition throughout. Despite a mintage of just over
5.3 million pieces, the 1880-O Morgan dollar is well-known
as an elusive date in Choice Mint State or better; no doubt
much of the mintage saw steady use in local commerce, and
probably any Mint State examples known today are here by
chance rather than intent.
PCGS# 7114.
2079 1880-S MS-68 (PCGS). OGH. Really an exquisite piece,
this delightful Morgan dollar is virtually pristine with
smooth, unblemished surfaces. Highly lustrous with a
radiant satin texture, the entire package is draped in mottled
toning in beautiful iridescent olive-apricot and pale silver.
An outstanding coin to represent either the type or the issue
in an advanced numismatic cabinet. An exceptional coin in
an uncommon condition.
PCGS# 7118.
Page 105
2080 1880-S MS-68 H (NGC). Exquisite surfaces are silky smooth
in texture with decided semi-reflective tendencies in the
obverse field. Otherwise satiny in finish, with an expectably
fully strike for this expertly produced San Francisco Mint
issue. The 1880-S is a “common” issue overall, but here
offered in an extremely uncommon grade; only a tiny
fraction of 1% of the 1880-S dollars certified by NGC could
match the quality offered here.
2084 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS). Beautifully toned on the reverse,
this radiant Gem exhibits vivid cobalt blue, salmon pink and
golden-orange iridescence.
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7118.
2085 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS). Whereas the obverse of this coin
is essentially brilliant, the reverse is layered in outstanding
multicolored toning in blue, pink, orange and gold.
PCGS# 7118.
2081 1880-S MS-68 H (NGC). Exquisite razor sharp devices and
radiant semi-reflective fields provide exceptional eye appeal
even at the Superb Gem grade level. Otherwise untoned,
splashes of olive-orange iridescence at the borders provide
additional character. Although NGC has certified more than
100,000 Mint State 1880-S dollars over the years, scarcely
more than two dozen of these have been awarded an MS68 designation within the star category. Further, only a tiny
fraction of 1% of the Mint State 1880-S dollars certified by
NGC have been graded as MS-68 or finer.
PCGS# 7118.
2086 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS). This bag-toned Gem exhibits a
crescent of simply delightful rainbow colored toning over
the lower left third of the obverse. Worthy of a premium bid!
PCGS# 7118.
2082 1880-S MS-68 (NGC). Delicate champagne pink peripheral
toning interrupts otherwise blazing white brilliance for this
gorgeous Superb Gem Morgan. Very close to the absolute
pinnacle of quality for the issue; the graders at NGC
generally have to examine several hundred 1880-S dollars
before they have the pleasure of seeing one as nice as this.
PCGS# 7118.
2083 1880-S MS-67 PL (NGC). CAC. OH. A simply outstanding
Superb Gem, delicate, glassy fields support satiny, razor
sharp devices on both sides. Brilliant in the centers, vivid
peripheral toning in pink, lavender and gold iridescence
enhances already memorable eye appeal. Although the
1880-S is a common issue overall, the example offered here
is in a decidedly uncommon grade. Prooflike examples are
very scarce at the MS-67 level and extremely rare finer.
2087 1880-S MS-64+ (PCGS). This remarkably attractive
Morgan dollar is bursting with vivid gold, rose, red and
powder blue toning that is both bolder and more expansive
on the obverse.
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7119.
Page 106
2088 1880-S MS-64+ (PCGS). A brilliant, frosty white obverse
contrasts markedly with a reverse that is adorned in swaths
of vivid rainbow colored bag toning.
PCGS# 7118.
2092 Roll of 1880-S Morgan Silver Dollars. MS-64+ (PCGS). All
examples are individually encapsulated by PCGS. A couple
of pieces exhibit mottled gold and/or pale rose iridescence,
but most are either fully brilliant or exhibit only the lightest
silvery tinting. (Total: 20 coins)
PCGS# 7118.
2089 1880-S MS-64+ (PCGS). The vividly toned reverse of
this otherwise virtually brilliant Morgan dollar is layered
in blended orange, olive, gold, powder blue and pale rose
iridescence.
PCGS# 7118.
2093 Roll of 1880-S Morgan Silver Dollars. MS-64+ (PCGS).
All examples are individually encapsulated by PCGS, and
most are either fully brilliant or exhibit only the lightest pale
silver tinting. (Total: 20 coins)
PCGS# 7118.
2090 1880-S MS-64+ (PCGS). A patchwork of deep blue, tanrose and golden-orange colors blankets the obverse, the
reverse brilliant apart from blushes of pale gold along the
upper border.
PCGS# 7118.
2094 Roll of 1880-S Morgan Silver Dollars. MS-64+ (PCGS).
all display areas of vivid, often multicolored toning on one
or both sides. A beautiful, well matched group. (Total: 20
coins)
PCGS# 7118.
2091 1880-S MS-64+ (PCGS). Handsome multicolored bag
toning over the right half of the obverse is sure to result in a
premium bid for this endearing near-Gem.
PCGS# 7118.
2095 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). This splendid rainbow toned
Morgan exhibits crescents of multicolored iridescence along
the right obverse and reverse borders.
PCGS# 7118.
Page 107
2096 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Otherwise brilliant, a bold swath
of deep, multicolored bag toning over the right half of the
reverse is sure to result in a premium bid for this wonderfully
original Morgan dollar.
2100 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Charming iridescent toning in
various antique colors enhances the reverse of this beautiful
rainbow Morgan.
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7118.
2097 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Exquisite surfaces are adorned in
iridescent copper-olive, antique gold, cobalt blue and roseorange colors that are largely confined to the obverse.
PCGS# 7118.
2101 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Frosty white brilliance on the
obverse gives way to swaths of blended copper, pale blue,
golden-orange and deep rose toning on the reverse. A truly
outstanding offering for the collector of rainbow toned
Morgans.
PCGS# 7118.
2098 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Brilliant on the obverse, the
reverse of this truly outstanding piece is awash in blended
reddish-rose, golden-orange and cobalt blue iridescence.
In a sale that includes numerous rainbow toned Morgans,
this beautiful near-Gem is easily among the most visually
impressive.
2102 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). A crescent of multicolored bag
toning over the left third of the reverse interrupts otherwise
dominant Mint brilliance for this delectable Morgan dollar.
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7118.
2099 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Swaths of vivid multicolored
reverse toning are sure to endear this lovely Morgan dollar
to the specialized collector.
2103 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Leaving the reverse brilliant,
slightly mottled golden-apricot, copper-rose and cobalt blue
iridescence adorns much of the obverse of this attractively
original near-Gem.
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7118.
Page 108
2104 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Mottled cobalt blue, salmon pink,
and reddish-gold toning over the left half of the reverse
interrupts otherwise dominant satin white brilliance for this
needle sharp Morgan.
PCGS# 7118.
2108 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). The most vivid shades are reserved
for the lower left of this obverse-toned Morgan dollar.
A beautiful piece in all regards that is sure to see spirited
bidding.
PCGS# 7118.
2105 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Soft blue-gray and golden-orange
reverse toning further enhances the appeal of this already
attractive Choice Morgan dollar.
PCGS# 7118.
2109 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Bag toned in multicolored
iridescence over the upper left obverse, the balance of this
snappy Morgan dollar is untoned and brilliant.
PCGS# 7118.
2106 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Crescents of toning in multiple
vivid colors grace the reverse of this otherwise brilliant
Morgan dollar.
PCGS# 7118.
2110 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). This fully struck, brightly lustrous
near-Gem combines a brilliant reverse with an obverse
swathed in light rose, golden-copper and powder blue
iridescence.
PCGS# 7118.
2107 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). A lovely piece, the obverse is awash
in dominant golden-orange iridescence with a blush of rose
and blue at the lower right border. The reverse is brilliant for
all intents and purposes, and the eye appeal is superior even
at the Choice Mint State grade level.
2111 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). This exquisite ‘80-S Morgan is
ringed in vivid obverse peripheral toning of cobalt blue,
pinkish rose and golden-orange. Outstanding!
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7118.
Page 109
2112 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Subtle orange, rose and blue
highlights enliven a base of antique copper patina, the
toning in its entirety confined to the obverse of this smartly
impressed and fully lustrous piece.
2116 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Gorgeous apricot, rose, powder
blue and olive-gold iridescence engages the upper right
obverse of this otherwise brilliant, brightly lustrous piece.
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7118.
2113 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Saturations of blue and antique
gold enliven a base of copper-rose patina on the obverse of
this captivating example. Brilliant on the reverse, with a full
strike and vibrant luster throughout.
2117 Roll of 1880-S Morgan Silver Dollars. MS-64 (PCGS). All
examples are individually encapsulated by PCGS, and most
are either fully brilliant or nearly so. (Total: 20 coins)
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7118.
2114 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Handsome, varied bag toning
lines the right obverse and — particularly — reverse of this
lustrous, razor sharp Morgan silver dollar.
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7118.
2115 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS). Beautiful copper-blue and roseorange toning over the lower left obverse interrupts
otherwise radiant Mint brilliance for this premium ‘80-S
dollar.
PCGS# 7118.
Page 110
examples are individually encapsulated by PCGS. This lot is
worthy of a close look, as all coins exhibit varying degrees of
vivid, multicolored toning on one or both sides. (Total: 20
coins)
coins are individually encapsulated by PCGS, and all exhibit
crescents of vivid peripheral toning on one or both sides.
Sure to sell for a premium bid! (Total: 20 coins)
PCGS# 7118.
2120 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Drenched in rich lavender-copper
patina, the obverse compliments a reverse that is brilliant
within a halo of peripheral golden-orange iridescence.
A visually stunning example that belongs in a specialized
collection of toned silver dollars.
2124 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Gorgeous golden-orange and roseblue toning lines the left obverse and reverse borders, the
color much more extensive on the former side. A lovely
piece!
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7118.
2121 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Lovely rainbow and pastel colors
overlay the reverse in several well blended, nearly horizontal
swaths. Brilliant on the obverse, with eye appeal to spare.
PCGS# 7118.
2125 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). With extremely vivid olive-gold,
salmon pink and cobalt blue iridescence engaging both
sides, it is difficult for us to imagine a more beautifully toned
Morgan dollar irrespective of date or issuing Mint.
PCGS# 7118.
2122 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Whereas the obverse is
predominantly brilliant, the reverse of this charming piece
is saturated in vivid, attractive, copper-rose and goldenolive toning.
PCGS# 7118.
2126 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Golden-olive, copper-rose and
pinkish-orange colors blend together nicely to engulf the
obverse of this attractively toned Morgan. The reverse is
largely brilliant, and both sides are equally impressive in the
areas of luster and striking quality.
PCGS# 7118.
2123 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). This visually impressive piece
exhibits a bold crescent of mostly copper-rose bag toning
over the right third of the reverse. A few other colors are
also intermingled, and this is a beautiful coin that is sure to
appeal to the collector of vividly toned Morgans.
PCGS# 7118.
2127 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Leaving the obverse brilliant,
toning in predominantly cobalt blue and pearl gray colors
blankets virtually the entire reverse of this gorgeous Morgan
dollar.
PCGS# 7118.
Page 111
2128 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Crescents of similarly varied and
vibrant colors overlay the upper reverse and right obverse
periphery of this breathtakingly beautiful Morgan dollar.
PCGS# 7118.
2132 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). With competing swaths of gold,
blue, orange and rose toning engulfing the obverse, this
is easily among the most visually impressive and enticing
Morgans in this sale — which is saying a lot given the rich
bounty of toned dollars offered herein.
PCGS# 7118.
2129 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Simply outstanding multicolored
peripheral toning rings much of the obverse, and also lines
the left reverse, of this enchanting Morgan dollar.
PCGS# 7118.
2133 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Golden-orange, deep rose and
charcoal-blue toning lines the right reverse border with a
blush of the first-listed color “bleeding through” to the right
periphery on the obverse.
PCGS# 7118.
2130 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). The reverse of this impressive piece
is bathed in competing copper-rose, pearl gray and orangegold toning. The obverse, on the other hand, remains as
brilliant as the day the coin emerged from the dies.
PCGS# 7118.
2134 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Sure to see spirited bidding at
auction, this delightful Morgan dollar combines a brilliant
obverse with a reverse that is layered in multiple shades of
vivid rainbow toning. Exquisite!
PCGS# 7118.
2131 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Lovely blue, rose and orange-gold
toning is largely confined to the obverse of this endearing
Morgan silver dollar.
PCGS# 7118.
2135 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Exceptionally vivid and varied
bag toning engulfs the obverse —while leaving the reverse
predominantly brilliant — of this thoroughly appealing
coin.
PCGS# 7118.
Page 112
2136 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Leaving the obverse brilliant, vivid
blue, lavender, rose and orange-gold iridescence blankets
much of the reverse of this exquisite rainbow toned Morgan.
PCGS# 7118.
2140 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). Delightful quality for the Morgan
dollar toning enthusiast, this piece combines a brilliant
obverse with a reverse that is saturated in copper-rose,
powder blue and pearl gray iridescence.
PCGS# 7118.
2137 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). This impressive and otherwise
brilliant piece exhibits a bold crescent of golden-copper
and cobalt blue bag toning over the lower right obverse.
Really an attractive piece, and one that is sure to command
a premium at auction.
PCGS# 7118.
2141 Roll of 1880-S Morgan Silver Dollars. MS-63 (PCGS).
all exhibit areas of vivid, often multicolored toning on one
or both sides. Worthy of a close look, as there are many
beautiful rainbow toned Morgans in this lot. (Total: 20
coins)
PCGS# 7118.
2138 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). This delectable piece sports an
even overlay of blended olive-gold and light copper-rose
iridescence on the obverse.
PCGS# 7118.
2142 1881 Morgan. Proof-64 Cameo (PCGS). Delicate sandysilver iridescence is more extensive on the reverse of this
fully impressed, boldly contrasted specimen. Minor scuffing
over and before Liberty’s neck is noted for accuracy, and it
seems to be the only impediment to an even higher numeric
grade. Mint records indicate a production figure of 984
Proofs, but combined population statistics suggest that the
actual number of survivors is probably no greater than 600
pieces. Significantly, PCGS has certified just a few dozen
cameo examples as Proof-64 or finer.
PCGS# 87316.
2139 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS). A lovely Morgan dollar for the
toning enthusiast, the obverse is awash in a blend of olivegold and pinkish rose colors that are boldest toward the
upper border.
PCGS# 7118.
Page 113
2148 1881-CC MS-64 DMPL (PCGS). OGH. Brilliant and fully
struck, this solidly graded near-Gem also offers sharp visual
contrast between frosty devices and mirror-finish fields.
The total number of DMPL 1881-CC dollars is probably no
greater than 2,000 pieces, and PCGS has certified DMPL
examples as MS-64 or finer on scarcely more than 700
occasions since the mid 1980s; many individual specimens
have likely been graded multiple times.
PCGS# 97127.
2143 1881-CC MS-67 (PCGS). With razor sharp devices, silky
smooth surfaces, and bright brilliant white luster, this coin
numbers among the most attractive 1881-CC Morgan
dollars that we have offered in recent sales. Sure to sell for a
strong bid. PCGS has just four grading events listed for this
date at a finer grade than that offered here.
PCGS# 7126.
2149 1881-O MS-65 (PCGS). Exceptionally attractive in an ‘81O Morgan dollar, this lovely Gem is not only sharply struck
with vibrant mint frost, but both sides also exhibit vivid
cobalt blue and reddish-copper peripheral toning around
brilliant centers. A visually engaging piece that is worthy of
a premium bid. Scarcer in Gem grades than its mintage of
5.7 million pieces suggests.
PCGS# 7128.
2150 1881-O MS-65 (NGC). This is an endearing Gem — the
strike sharp, the surfaces overall smooth, and the luster
bright with a brilliant satin texture. Despite a generous
mintage, and an ample supply of Mint State examples in
grades up to MS-64, comparatively few Gem-quality pieces
have survived; less than 5% of the Uncirculated specimens
certified by NGC grade MS-65 or finer.
PCGS# 7128.
2144 1881-CC MS-67 (PCGS). This silky smooth, richly frosted
example is aglow with radiant mint brilliance. The 1881-CC
is notable for having the 2nd-lowest mintage of any Morgan
dollar issue struck at the Carson City Mint, just 296,000
pieces, a remarkably-low figure by Morgan dollar standards.
The presently offered specimen is tied with several dozen
others as the fifth finest example graded by PCGS.
PCGS# 7126.
2145 1881-CC MS-66 (NGC). Radiant satin white surfaces are
free of both toning and grade limiting abrasions. A scant
296,000 examples were minted, the 2nd lowest production
figure of any Morgan dollar issue struck at the Carson City
Mint. Probably no more than 10% of the Mint State examples
certified by NGC are as nice as the specimen offered here.
PCGS# 7372.
2146 1881-CC MS-66 (NGC). Frosty and fully struck, this
otherwise brilliant Gem also offers a blush of pretty
multicolored toning at the upper obverse border. Easily in
the top 10% of all Mint State examples certified by NGC; the
median grade for the issue is probably MS-64 or thereabouts.
2151 1881-S MS-68 (NGC). Fully impressed with blazing
satin white luster, this enchanting Morgan dollar would
make a fitting addition to the even the finest type or date
set. Superb! The presently offered coin is literally one in a
thousand; the graders at NGC have certified almost exactly
1,000 Mint State 1881-S dollars for every example that has
been awarded the MS-68 designation. Moreover, no 1881-S
dollars have been certified by them as MS-69 or MS-70.
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7126.
2147 1881-CC MS-65 Cameo DMPL (ANACS). OH. Boldly
contrasted between frosty devices and mirror-like fields,
this fully struck and exceptionally attractive Gem is brilliant
apart from the lightest golden tinting along the denticles.
A popular low-mintage Carson City issue, particularly with
DMPL features.
PCGS# 97127.
2152 1881-S MS-67+ (PCGS). CAC. Delectable surfaces are silky
smooth in texture with smooth, brilliant, satiny mint luster
swirling around both sides. An otherwise common date in
a somewhat uncommon state of preservation, and desirable
for just that reason.
PCGS# 7130.
Page 114
2157 1882-CC MS-66+ (PCGS). CAC. Bursting with brilliant
satin to frosty luster, this delightful Morgan dollar also offers
sharp striking detail and overall pristine surfaces. Lovely
Gem quality with a PCGS “+” and a CAC seal of approval.
PCGS# 7134.
2153 1881-S MS-67+ (PCGS). CAC. With simply outstanding
rainbow peripheral toning, this expertly produced and
preserved Morgan dollar is sure to sell for a strong premium
at auction. Unquestionably, this example ranks in the upper
echelon of the finest survivors of the issue. The graders at
the certification services typically have to view hundreds
of 1881-S dollars before they have the pleasure to see one
as fine as this. A prize for the collector who appreciates
outstanding quality.
PCGS# 7130.
2154 1881-S MS-67 PL (NGC). OH. A simply exquisite Superb
Gem, both sides combine vibrant, mirror-finish fields
with razor sharp, satin-textured devices. Splashes of vivid
lavender-copper and blue-gray toning around the devices
further enhance the already exceptional eye appeal. Only
three PL examples of the date have been certified finer than
the present beauty by PCGS. A gorgeous Gem example of
an otherwise readily available date — you’ll wish all your
Morgans looked so fine.
PCGS# 7131.
2155 1882 Morgan. Proof-65 (PCGS). CAC—Gold Label.
OGH—First Generation. This exquisite piece exudes
originality in the form of vivid copper-gray, midnight blue,
and pearl gray iridescence that is markedly bolder on the
reverse. Brightly reflective in finish, with surfaces that are
so smooth as to readily suggest a Proof-67 grade! The Mint
produced 1,100 Proofs of the date, and the present piece is as
fine as you will find for the assigned grade. Certainly worthy
of more than just a casual look-see.
2158 1882-CC MS-66+ (PCGS). CAC. Crisply impressed with
billowy mint frost, this brilliant, premium quality Gem is
sure to please. This popular Carson City date was once one
of the primary rarities in the Morgan dollar series, but the
Treasury releases of the early 1960s and the G.S.A. offerings
of the early 1970s put an end to that.
PCGS# 7134.
2159 1882-CC MS-66+ (PCGS). CAC. This is a beautiful coin
with full striking detail, brilliant surfaces and exquisite
mint luster. An exemplary Gem example with a PCGS “+”
designation and the CAC seal of approval.
PCGS# 7134.
2160 1882-CC MS-65 DMPL (PCGS). Heavily frosted in texture
with razor sharp definition, the devices contrast markedly
with deeply mirrored fields. Both the cameo finish and
uncommon lack of distracting abrasions are fully appreciable
in the absence of even the lightest toning. A brilliant beauty
for your bidding consideration.
PCGS# 97135.
2161 1882-S MS-67+ (PCGS). Smartly impressed with brilliant
satin white luster, this enchanting Superb Gem would make
a beautiful addition to any high grade collection. No finer
“+” example of the date has been certified by PCGS.
PCGS# 7140.
2162 1882-S MS-67 (PCGS). CAC. Beautiful rainbow colored
obverse toning is sure to result in a strong bid for this
captivating Superb Gem Morgan.
PCGS# 7140.
PCGS# 7317.
2156 1882 MS-64 DMPL (PCGS). This handsome piece sports
frosty, razor sharp devices and vibrant, nicely mirrored fields
that readily uphold the validity of the DMPL designation.
Many DMPL Morgan dollar collections are currently being
formed, and the present piece affords a nice opportunity to
begin such a collection.
PCGS# 97133.
2163 1883-CC MS-67 (PCGS). CAC. Whereas both sides of this
pretty piece are fully struck with billowy mint frost, only the
obverse is toned in a rich, even blend of rose, blue-gray and
olive-gold colors. Fewer than a half dozen examples of this
plentiful Carson City issue have been certified finer than the
present beauty by PCGS.
PCGS# 7144.
Page 115
2168 1885-CC MS-65 (PCGS). Delicately toned in soft goldengray, this smooth, razor sharp Gem also exhibits a full
endowment of softly frosted luster. Only 228,000 examples
were minted, the lowest production figure of any Morgan
dollar issue struck at the Carson City Mint. The high grade,
the low mintage, and the immense popularity of Carson
City coins generally all combine here to create an bidding
opportunity that some collectors will find difficult to resist.
PCGS# 7160.
2164 1885-CC MS-66+ PL (PCGS). Brilliant and thoroughly
appealing in all regards, this silky smooth, premium quality
Gem is sure to see spirited bidding among dedicated CCmint Morgan dollar collectors. The present beauty is tied
with three other pieces for finest PL “+” of the date at PCGS.
PCGS# 7161.
2169 1885-O MS-67 (NGC). Highly lustrous with a smooth,
satiny texture, this otherwise brilliant Gem is further
enhanced by lovely reddish-gold peripheral toning. The
1885-O is ordinarily regarded as a “common” issue, but
here offered at an elusive grade level. Only a fraction of the
top 1% of examples certified by NGC grade MS-67; finer
specimens exist but are extremely rare.
PCGS# 7162.
2170 1885-S MS-65 (PCGS). Gorgeous satin to softly frosted
surfaces are brilliant and sharply struck throughout. A
scarce issue at the MS-65 level. Fewer than 10% of the Mint
State examples certified by PCGS are this nicely preserved.
PCGS# 7164.
2165 1885-CC MS-66+ (NGC). Exquisite satin white surfaces
are free of both toning and grade limiting abrasions. Only
228,000 examples were minted, by far the lowest production
figure of any Morgan dollar issue struck at the Carson City
Mint. The presently offered specimen is easily in the top 2%
of all Mint State examples of the variety certified by NGC.
2171 1885-S MS-65 (PCGS). Dappled cobalt blue and reddishrusset peripheral toning is more extensive on the obverse
of this otherwise frosty white Gem. A boldly impressed,
carefully preserved piece with a lovely appearance. Easily in
the top 10% of all Mint State examples certified by PCGS.
PCGS# 7164.
PCGS# 7160.
2166 1885-CC MS-66 (NGC). Exquisite brilliant white surfaces
are fully frosted in texture with nary a distracting abrasion
to report. Only 228,000 examples were minted, the lowest
production figure of any Morgan Dollar issue struck at the
Carson City Mint, but fortunately for collectors many nice
Uncirculated examples have survived down to the present
time. Fewer than 10% of the Mint State 1885-CC dollars
certified by NGC are comparable in quality to the presentlyoffered piece.
PCGS# 7160.
2167 1885-CC MS-65 (PCGS). This enchanting Gem combines
a brilliant reverse with an obverse that is toned in slightly
mottled golden-apricot iridescence. The 1885-CC is a
popular and eagerly-sought low-mintage issue. The cachet
conferred by the celebrated CC mintmark adds further to
the coin’s desirability.
2172 1886 MS-68 (NGC). Delightful silky smooth surfaces are
drenched in vibrant satin luster. Fully struck, as well, and
brilliant apart from the lightest champagne gold iridescence
along the lower obverse and upper reverse borders. A truly
gorgeous Morgan dollar at every turn. Interested bidders
will be hard-pressed to find a finer example of the date in
the current numismatic marketplace.
PCGS# 7166.
NGC Census: 25; none finer within any designation.
PCGS# 7160.
Page 116
Condition Census 1886-O Morgan
2173 1886-O MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC. Sharply struck and brilliant, this is a beautiful example of one of the best known condition rarities
in the early Morgan dollar series. Uncommonly well preserved in an 1886-O, both sides retain full, vibrant luster and are devoid
of distracting abrasions. The New Orleans Mint only struck silver dollars in 1886, and did so with little thought to high standards
of quality control. Additionally, and while large numbers were churned out, most saw circulation with few being retained in
government vaults. The comparatively few Mint State 1886-O dollars that avoided melting under the terms of the 1918 Pittman Act
generally have lackluster surfaces, making Gem examples among the most hotly pursued Morgan dollars. Temptingly close to full
Gem quality, and worthy of a strong bid, as such.
PCGS# 7168.
PCGS Population: 21; just 3 finer (with a sole MS-65+ as finest).
2174 1886-S MS-66 (PCGS). Exquisite satin surfaces are expertly
preserved without so much as a single detracting blemish.
Attractively toned, as well, this delightful Gem is adorned
in vivid reddish-gold iridescence. The 1886-S is a scarce
issue with a mintage of just 750,000 pieces, a low production
figure by Morgan dollar standards. MS-66 examples rank in
the top 1% of all Uncirculated pieces certified by PCGS.
PCGS# 7170.
PCGS Population: 40; 6 finer (MS-67 finest).
2175 1887/6 VAM-2. Top 100 Variety. MS-65 (PCGS). Satiny
and vibrant, this lovely Gem also offers sharp striking detail
from the rims to the centers. The 1887/6 is probably 100
times rarer than the 1887 Plain Date in high grades. PCGS
has certified 1887/6 dollars as MS-65 or finer on fewer than
200 occasions over the years.
PCGS# 7174.
2176 1887/6 VAM-2. Top 100 Variety. MS-65 (NGC). Softly
frosted in finish with razor sharp definition throughout,
the only toning to report for this lovely Gem is a blush of
pale golden-apricot along the lower right obverse border.
An elusive variety in MS-65 condition; there are probably
more than 100 Gem 1887 dollars for every Gem 1887/6
encountered. Notably, NGC has certified fewer than 120
1887/6 dollars as MS-65 or finer over the decades since the
mid 1980s. Further, because of price disparity, we doubt
that there are many examples of the overdate hiding in 1887
Plain Date holders.
PCGS# 133908.
2177 1887 MS-67 (NGC). This satiny, silky smooth Superb Gem
is untoned apart from crescents of pink and blue peripheral
toning that are more extensive on the reverse. Here’s yet
another beauty in the 1% category; only one piece per
several hundred examples certified by NGC is this superbly
preserved. Pieces such as this prove the numismatic axiom
that a relatively small increase in price can translate in a
relatively large decrease in certification service populations.
PCGS# 7172.
2178 1887/6-O VAM-3. Top 100 Variety. MS-63 (PCGS).
Lustrous and brilliant, this boldly struck Morgan makes
a lovely impression at the Select Mint State grade level. A
scarce variety at the Mint State level. Combined population
statistics suggest that no more than 2,000 Uncirculated
examples exist.
PCGS# 7178.
Page 117
2179 1887/6-O VAM-3. Top 100 Variety. MS-62 (PCGS). Frosty
and brilliant, this appealing BU Morgan is free of singularly
distracting abrasions. A popular Guide Book listed variety;
probably no more than 2,000 Mint State specimens are
available to accommodate the burgeoning cadre of Morgan
dollar specialists throughout the numismatic community.
PCGS# 7178.
2180 1887-O MS-65 (NGC). Outstanding satin white surfaces
are boldly to sharply struck with nary a detracting abrasion
to report. Despite a relatively enormous mintage and the
fact that thousands of Uncirculated examples have survived
to the present time, the issue is elusive in grades above the
MS-64 level. NGC has certified 1887-O dollars as MS-65
or finer on scarcely more than 100 occasions since the mid
1980s.
2183 1888-S MS-65 (PCGS). Attractively toned in iridescent
silver-apricot, this vibrant and satiny Gem is expectably
smooth at the assigned grade level. The 1888-S ranks as one of
the more desirable San Francisco Mint issues. Only 657,000
examples were minted, and survivors are comparatively
scarce in all grades. We estimate that there may have been 10
bags of Uncirculated pieces (1,000 pieces per bag) released
as part of the giant Treasury Hoard dispersed in the 1960s.
Notably, fewer than 10% of the Mint State examples certified
by PCGS grade MS-65 or finer.
PCGS# 7186.
PCGS# 7176.
2181 1887-S MS-65 (PCGS). Razor sharp in strike with radiant
satin white surfaces, this solidly graded Gem makes a strong
impression in all regards. Scarcely more than one in 20
Uncirculated examples certified by PCGS are comparable in
quality to the specimen offered here.
PCGS# 7180.
2184 1889-CC AU-53 (PCGS). Pleasing silver gray surfaces are
sharply defined with considerable satin luster remaining in
the presence of minimal wear. Outwardly smooth, as well,
this coin is sure to have no difficulty finding its way into
a specialized Morgan dollar set. Well-known for decades
as one of the primary key dates in the series, the 1889-CC
Morgan is certainly the key date among the Carson City
issues despite the fact that two other CC Morgan dollar
issues have lower mintages. Actively pursued in all grades,
the ‘89-CC is a prize in pleasing AU, and we suspect there
will be more than one active bidder on this lot.
2182 1888-S MS-65+ (PCGS). CAC This snappy Gem is fully
impressed and richly endowed with billowy satin to softly
frosted luster. Otherwise brilliant, charming olive and russet
toning highlights are scattered about in isolated peripheral
areas. From a modest mintage for the date of 657,000 pieces.
Nicely struck specimens of this date are in the minority
among surviving Mint State examples.
PCGS# 7190.
PCGS# 7186.
PCGS Population: 6; 1 finer within the “+” designation (MS-67+). Without the “+” designation
the date is fairly plentiful.
2185 1889-CC AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Retoning nicely
in light silver gray, splashes of tan-rose patina along the
left obverse border are also noted. Sharply struck with few
sizable abrasions, this key date CC-mint Morgan is sure to
win many adherents in today’s market. Why not take a look
at this specimen? It could very well fill the bill for an alert
collector.
PCGS# 7190.
Page 118
2186 1889-CC AU Details—Improperly Cleaned (NGC). Sharp
devices and freedom from outwardly distracting abrasions
enhance the appeal of this key date Morgan dollar. Both
sides have been retoned in dark charcoal gray, with areas
of corrosion discernible as the surfaces dip into a light.
The 1889-CC is one of the most elusive and eagerly-sought
issues in the Morgan dollar series; it handily eclipses both
the 1879-CC and 1893-CC in desirability, making it the
most highly-esteemed Morgan dollar issue struck at the
Carson City Mint. Because of a paucity of Mint State pieces,
collectors eagerly seek out circulated examples in any grade
available; to illustrate this point, NGC has certified close to
100 examples in the Poor to AG category.
PCGS# 7190.
2187 1889-CC EF-40 (ICG). Warmly toned in even olive-gray,
this well balanced EF is boldly defined overall with few
outwardly noticeable abrasions. The 1889-CC is one of the
rarest and most desirable issues in the Morgan dollar series
apart from the Proof-only 1895 and the elusive 1893-S.
Combined population statistics of the major certification
services suggest a total population of just 10,000 to 15,000
pieces, with an average grade in the VF to EF range.
Claims by some authors that there were as many as seven
Treasury bags of Uncirculated examples released in the early
1960s(7,000 pieces)isn’t corroborated by the best available
evidence, which instead indicates that a single bag of 1,000
specimens was probably released at that time. Because of a
paucity of Mint State pieces, there is continuing demand for
examples in any grade available; even AG to VG specimens
are prized highly enough to be certified on a regular basis.
PCGS# 7190.
PCGS# 7192.
2190 1889-S MS-65 (PCGS). Enchanting frosty textured surfaces
are silky smooth in appearance beneath an overlay of
delightful champagne pink, reddish-olive and powder blue
iridescence. Easily in the top 10% of Mint State examples
certified by PCGS.
PCGS# 7194.
2191 1890 MS-65 (PCGS). Layered in vivid olive, antique gold,
blue, rose and apricot toning, both sides of this endearing
Morgan make a profound visual impression. The luster is
full, the strike is bold and the surfaces are expectably smooth
at the Gem grade level. A comparatively scarce issue at the
MS-65 level. Fewer than 4% of the Mint State 1890 dollars
certified by PCGS could match the quality offered here.
PCGS# 7196.
2188 1889-CC VF-30 (PCGS). A wholesome mid-grade survivor,
both sides are overall boldly defined with handsome and
original dove-gray toning. The undisputed key to the
Morgan dollar Carson City issues, as well as one of the
primary keys in the entire series, 1878-1921.
PCGS# 7190.
2189 1889-O MS-65 (PCGS). Gorgeous frosty surfaces exhibit
peripheral red and blue iridescence around brilliant white
centers. Exceptionally well struck for this challenging issue,
with outstanding eye appeal, as well. Despite a large Mintage
of nearly 12 million pieces, it appears that comparatively few
bags of Mint State examples escaped from being tossed into
the refiner’s furnace during the early decades of the 20th
century. Although estimates on the number of Mint State
examples may be subject to debate and disagreement, we
believe that current population statistics of the two major
certification services are consistent with the view than there
were probably between 8 and 10 bags of Uncirculated pieces
(8,000 to 10,000 coins total) in the U.S. Treasury Hoard
distributed in the 1960s. Fewer than 5% of the Mint State
examples certified by PCGS are MS-65 or finer (a figure that
amounts to less than 200 pieces all told).
2192 1890 MS-65 (PCGS). Boldly, if not sharply struck
throughout, this softly frosted example is untoned apart
from the lightest golden toning, and then again mostly on
the reverse. The graders at PCGS typically have to examine
20 Uncirculated 1890 dollars before they find one as nice as
this.
PCGS# 7196.
2193 1890 MS-65 (NGC). Blushes of reddish-gold peripheral
toning along the upper obverse and lower reverse borders
interrupts otherwise satin white brilliance. A fully struck
and nicely preserved Gem that is sure to please. Decidedly,
in the top 5% of all Mint State 1890 dollars certified by NGC.
PCGS# 7196.
2194 1890 MS-65 (NGC). Gorgeous bright white surfaces are
highly lustrous with not even the lightest toning in evidence.
Although readily available in grades up to and including
MS-64, the 1890 becomes elusive in Gem condition. Scarcely
more than 2% of the Mint State examples certified by NGC
grade MS-65 or finer.
PCGS# 7196.
Page 119
2195 1890 MS-64 DMPL (ANACS). Ringed in iridescent copper
and cobalt blue peripheral toning, this otherwise brilliant
near-Gem allows ready appreciation of the full striking
detail and pronounced field to device contrast. A gorgeous
piece, choice for the grade and sure to please its next owner.
PCGS# 97197.
2196 1890-CC MS-64 (PCGS). Splendid frosty white surfaces are
sharply struck, vibrantly lustrous, and uncommonly smooth
for this conditionally challenging CC-mint issue. Choice for
the grade and certain to draw much bidding activity.
PCGS# 7198.
2197 1890-O MS-66 (PCGS). This handsome Gem is richly
toned in blended copper-rose and charcoal-gray patina. The
luster retains full vibrancy in a softly frosted texture, and the
strike is superior for the issue with impressive detail even
in the centers. An important and highly desirable condition
rarity at the MS-66 level. Despite an enormous mintage of
10,701,000 pieces, comparatively few Mint State examples
have survived at the Gem level. PCGS has certified examples
as MS-65 or 65+ on 552 occasions since the mid 1980s, but
as MS-66 or 66+ on a scant 21 occasions during the same
time period. No examples have been certified as finer than
MS-66+.
2200 1890-O MS-65 (PCGS). Brilliant, satin to frosty surfaces
are ringed in delightful golden-orange rim toning.
Carefully preserved and smooth, above average striking
detail also confirms this coin as a Gem quality survivor
of a conditionally challenging New Orleans Mint issue. A
high-mintage issue which is readily available in grades up
to and including MS-64, but scarce in MS-65 and higher
grades. Fewer than 5% of the Mint State specimens certified
by PCGS are comparable in grade to the presently offered
example.
PCGS# 7200.
2201 1890-S MS-66 (PCGS). CAC. Charming pastel apricot
and powder blue iridescence blankets both sides of this
sharply struck, exceptionally smooth ‘90-S dollar. Relatively
available in Mint State by Morgan dollar standards, at least
in lower grades, the 1890-S develops into an important
condition rarity above the MS-64 level. MS-65s are
obtainable with patience, however, although in MS-66 or
finer grades bidding opportunities are few and far between.
A lovely coin in all regards, and an important find for the
high grade, high quality Morgan dollar collector.
PCGS# 7202.
PCGS# 7200.
PCGS Population: 20; 1 finer (MS-66+)
2198 1890-O MS-65 PL (PCGS). CAC. Enchanting Gem surfaces
exhibit full, billowy luster beneath layers of beautiful apricot,
mauve and tan-gray patina. Although readily available in
grades up to MS-64, the 1890-O becomes elusive at the MS65 level. The piece offered here is very close to the absolute
apex of quality for prooflike examples.
2202 1891 MS-65 (NGC). A razor sharp Gem with brilliant
surfaces, satiny luster is also fully appreciable in the absence
of grade limiting abrasions. Although readily available in
grades up to MS-63, the 1891 is scarce at the MS-64 level,
and quite rare in MS-65 condition. Scarcely more than 2%
of the Mint State examples certified by NGC could match
the quality presented here.
PCGS# 7204.
PCGS# 7201.
PCGS Population: 36; 3 finer (MS-66 PL finest) within the designation.
2199 1890-O MS-65 (PCGS). Delicate champagne pink
iridescence drifts toward the borders of this otherwise
brilliant looking piece. Sharply struck — and uncommonly
so for the issue — this solidly graded Gem is sure to excite
discerning Morgan dollar collectors. Fewer than 10% of the
Mint State 1890-O dollars certified by PCGS over the years
have graded MS-65 or finer.
PCGS# 7200.
Page 120
2206 1891-CC VAM-3. Top 100 Variety. Spitting Eagle. MS-64+
(PCGS). CAC. Gorgeous frosty white surfaces are bursting
with full, billowy, overall smooth luster. A raised die lump at
the tip of the eagle’s beak gives rise to the variety’s nickname.
A delightful Choice representative of this extremely popular
CC-mint Morgan VAM variety.
PCGS# 133937.
2203 1891 MS-63 DMPL (PCGS). Brilliant apart from the
lightest pale silver iridescence, this smartly impressed and
highly attractive example reveals marked reflectivity in the
fields. Choice for the assigned grade.
PCGS# 97205.
2207 1891-CC MS-64 DMPL (ANACS). OH. Peripherally
toned in soft rose-apricot and blue-gray, this otherwise
silver tinged piece combines frosty devices with glassy, well
mirrored fields. Fully struck throughout, with a simply
delightful appearance in an example of this conditionally
challenging CC-mint Morgan dollar issue. An ever-popular
issue from the waning years of Carson City Mint production
PCGS# 97207.
2208 1891-CC MS-64 (PCGS). Sharply impressed with coruscant
satin luster, this brilliant near-Gem would fit nicely in a high
grade Morgan dollar set. The 1891-CC is eagerly sought and
very desirable; scarcer in high grades than most Carson City
Mint issues of the 1880s.
PCGS# 7206.
2204 1891-CC VAM-3. Top 100 Variety. Spitting Eagle. MS65+ (PCGS). Beautiful frosty white surfaces are free of
both toning and grade limiting abrasions. A razor sharp
Gem for the discerning CC-mint Morgan dollar collector.
The Spitting Eagle moniker is due the presence of a tiny die
lump beneath the tip of the eagle’s upper mandible. Each of
the two major certification services recognize the variety. It
appears that VAM-3 constitutes a fairly small proportion of
the total 1891-CC population, but certification statistics are
not helpful in this case, because many examples are housed
in holders without the applicable variety designation.
PCGS# 7206.
PCGS# 7208.
2205 1891-CC MS-65+ (PCGS). Fully struck with billowy satin
white luster, this engaging Gem is sure to have no difficulty
finding its way into a high grade Morgan dollar set. Easily in
the top fraction of 1% of all Uncirculated examples certified
by PCGS. The popularity of Morgan dollars generally and
of Carson City issues specifically is certain to result in
continuing high demand for examples near the top of the
grading roster as offered here.
PCGS# 7206.
PCGS Population: 17; 30 finer (MS-67 finest)
2209 1891-O MS-64+ (PCGS). Soft powder blue and tan-gold
iridescence is largely confined to the peripheries on both
sides of this smooth, softly frosted near-Gem. Somewhat
more elusive in high grades than its mintage of more than
7.9 million pieces suggests.
2210 1891-S MS-66 (PCGS). Delightful frosty textured surfaces
are essentially brilliant in the centers. The peripheries are
splashed with mottled multicolored iridescence, and all
areas are equally well preserved with solid premium Gem
quality. The 1891-S is elusive in high grades despite modest
valuations in popular collecting guides. Examples are rare at
the MS-66 level and all but unobtainable finer. Barely more
than 1% if the Mint State 1891-S dollars certified by PCGS
could match the quality offered here.
PCGS# 7210.
Page 121
Fantastic Gem Mint State 1892-CC
Morgan Silver Dollar
2211 1892-CC MS-65+ (PCGS). Exquisite Gem surfaces are free
of both toning and grade limiting abrasions. With a full
strike and radiant satin to softly frosted luster, this delightful
CC-mint example would make an important addition to an
advanced Morgan dollar set. This is certainly one of the very
finest of this date and mint seen today, with less than one
percent of those known qualifying at the Gem level. Carson
City Mint Superintendent Samuel C. Wright had been ill
much of this year, and spent time in San Francisco trying to
recover. Rumors swirled that bullion had been stolen from
the Carson City Mint, further dampening employee morale.
Bureau of the Mint Officers investigated these allegations,
but they were unfounded, and the Carson City Mint was
given an excellent report. However, by August 1, word
spread that Superintendent Wright had died, so the Mint
closed for a few weeks while T. R. Hofer was appointed to the
Superintendent post. By the end of year, bullion deposits of
gold and silver continued to flow into the Mint for refining
and coinage. As 1892 drew to a close, the tally of Morgan
dollars struck halted at 1,352,000 pieces. Over the next
generations, these were released into circulation with only
a few coins were discovered in the Treasury holdings in the
early 1960s, as virtually the entire mintage had been slowly
dispersed in prior years. Many of the Mint State 1892-CC
dollars may have survived in the Redfield Hoard or in early
Treasury releases, which has kept collector demand quite
strong for this elusive issue.
2213 1892-CC MS-64 (PCGS). This highly lustrous, satin to
softly frosted example is free of both toning and individually
distracting abrasions. Softly struck in the centers, this being
the only feature that seems to preclude an MS-64+ grade.
Popular and eagerly sought in all grades, with nice MS-64
examples always in high demand.
PCGS# 7214.
2214 1892-CC MS-63 (NGC). Crisply impressed and thoroughly
appealing, this brilliant piece is awash in richly frosted mint
luster. An ever-popular date from the next-to-final year of
Carson City Mint coinage production, and a date that has
proven to be more elusive in Choice Mint State than its
mintage of just over 1.3 million pieces suggests.
PCGS# 7214.
2215 1892-CC MS-62 (PCGS). Attractively toned in iridescent
pinkish-gold, both sides also offer sharp striking detail and
full satin to softly frosted luster. Not overly abraded for the
assigned grade, with above average eye appeal in a BU CCmint Morgan dollar. From the waning years of Carson City
Mint coinage productivity. Choice for the grade.
PCGS# 7214.
PCGS# 7214.
2216 1893-CC MS-62 (PCGS). Brilliant with extremely vibrant
mint luster, this radiant piece would fit nicely into a Mint
State collection of CC-mint Morgan silver dollars. Lightly
struck in the centers, as often noted for the issue, yet free
of singularly mentionable abrasions. One of only 677,000
pieces struck in the final year of Carson City Mint coinage,
a number that was down 675,000 pieces from the previous
year’s total. Choice for the grade and a good value overall.
PCGS Population: 23; 29 finer (Mint State-67+ finest).
PCGS# 7222.
2212 1892-CC MS-64+ (PCGS). Wisps of iridescent gold here and
there on the obverse hardly deny brilliance for this sharply
struck, satin textured near-Gem. A scarce and desirable issue
in all grades. This impressive example is in the top 10% of
all Mint State pieces certified by PCGS. Although more than
1 million examples were minted, it appears that few were
issued for use in day-to-day commerce. The giant Treasury
Hoard of Uncirculated examples probably included just 10
to 15 bags of 1,000 pieces each, mostly at the MS-62 to MS64 grade level.
2217 1893-CC EF-40 (PCGS). Lightly and evenly toned in
original silver gray, this attractive EF would make a pleasing
addition to a circulated Morgan dollar collection. A popular
date from the final year of Carson City coinage. One of
677,000 pieces struck, a figure that is down dramatically
from the million-plus mintages of the three previous dates
in the Carson City Morgan dollar series.
PCGS# 7222.
PCGS# 7214.
Page 122
Near-Gem 1893-O
Morgan Dollar
2220 1893-S EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Nicely retoned in
warm and even pearl gray patina, this boldly defined and
outwardly smooth example offers uncommonly strong eye
appeal in light of the stated impairment. The key-date 1893S Morgan is actively pursued in all grades, and though with
an added qualifier, the present coin is still worth a good
going over.
PCGS# 7226.
2218 1893-O MS-64 (PCGS). Delightful brilliant white
surfaces are aglow with billowy satin to softly frosted
luster. A bit lightly struck in the centers, as typical of
the issue, yet overall smooth to suggest a full Gem
rating in the area of surface preservation alone. Some
300,000 1893-O silver dollars were struck, making
this the lowest mintage New Orleans Mint Morgan
dollar issue. While many examples were paid out by
the Treasury in small groups between 1948 and 1955,
Q. David Bowers reports no record of any full bags
of 1893-O dollars coming to light. Popular even in
circulated grades, this issue is rare in Mint State and
virtually unheard of in Gem.
PCGS# 7224.
PCGS Population: 87; just 7 finer through MS-65.
2221 1893-S VF-35 (NGC). Splashes of blue-gray patina
further enliven otherwise golden-gray surfaces for this
boldly defined Choice VF. A wholly acceptable and highly
collectable example of the foremost regular-issue key date
in the Morgan dollar series. Even at Choice VF, as here, the
bidding activity on this lot should prove to be exciting.
PCGS# 7226.
2219 1893-S EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Rather pleasing
medium silver surfaces also exhibit wisps of more vivid oliverusset iridescence here and there around the peripheries.
Boldly defined throughout, and with no singularly
distracting abrasions, the key date status of this issue is sure
to ensure keen interest in this lot among budget minded
Morgan dollar collectors. This date is the key issue to the
series with a low mintage of 100,000 pieces and precious few
are in high grades like this example. While it shows minor
cleaning, this is quite commonly seen on many of these key
date issues, and is easy enough to ignore considering the
rarity of this prized date and mint.
PCGS# 7226.
2222 1893-S VF-25 (PCGS). OGH. Pleasing lilac-gray patina
blankets both sides of this outwardly smooth, boldly
defined VF. A very appealing Morgan dollar for the assigned
grade. The heads-up key to the circulation strike Morgan
dollar issues of 1878 through 1904 and again in 1921. Only
100,000 examples were produced, and much of the known
population is VF, as here, evidence of just how long and
hard these played out their role in commerce. We never have
difficulty assigning a new home to a pleasing VF example of
this rarity, so plan to bid accordingly.
PCGS# 7226.
2223 1893-S Fine-12 (PCGS). Warmly toned in a blend of dove
gray and light rose, this bold Fine is uncommonly smooth
in overall appearance for a well circulated S-mint Morgan
dollar. A perfect match of grade and budget awareness greet
the potential bidder on this important key date Morgan.
PCGS# 7226.
Page 123
2224 1893-S VG-10 (PCGS). Brilliant light silver surfaces retain
bold outline definition to all elements of the design. A
problem-free and more than respectable representative of
this important issue in the popular Morgan dollar series.
The key to the circulation strike issues in the series, the
1893-S is a date that sees spirited bidding activity no matter
the grade; point for point, there could be more interest in a
VG-10 example such as this than in a Gem Mint State piece.
PCGS# 7226.
2225 1893-S Good-6 (PCGS). Handsome golden-charcoal
toning blankets smooth, problem-free surfaces for this key
date Morgan dollar. With bold outline definition to the
devices and generally distinct rims, this pleasing Good+
coin would fit nicely into a circulated date and mint set
of America’s most popular silver dollar type. A wholly
collectable example of this popular rarity.
PCGS# 7226.
2228 1894-O MS-64 (PCGS). Ringed in vivid blue and reddishgold peripheral iridescence, this otherwise brilliant nearGem offers exceptional technical quality in an eye appeal
for the conditionally challenging 1894-O silver dollar
issue. Although the 1894-O is readily available in grades up
through AU, Mint State examples have proved to be elusive.
By all appearances, probably no more than three or four
bags of Mint State examples (having 1,000 pieces per bag)
emerged from the giant Treasury Hoard during the 1960s.
PCGS has certified fewer than 400 examples as MS-64 or
finer since the mid 1980s.
PCGS# 7230.
2226 1894 Proof-62 (NGC). Essentially untoned surfaces radiate
uniform mint brilliance to the finish. Fully struck with
only faint hairlines to define the grade, this piece would fit
equally well into either a Proof type or date set. One of 972
Proofs of the date struck, though no doubt somewhat fewer
than that tally could be accounted for today.
PCGS# 7329.
2227 1894 AU-50 (NGC). Warmly and evenly toned in pearl
gray, this bold, outwardly smooth example possesses
uncommonly strong eye appeal at the basal AU grade level.
The 1894 is notable for having the third lowest mintage
in the entire Morgan dollar series after the 1895 (12,000
circulation strikes were produced, but are now all presumed
extinct due to melting) and the 1893-S (with a mintage of
just 100,000 pieces); only 110,000 1894 dollars were minted.
PCGS# 7228.
2229 1894-S MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC. This smartly impressed
beauty is fully untoned with decided semi-reflective
tendencies in the fields. Those same fields reveal myriad die
polish lines as the surfaces rotate under a light — as struck,
and quite common for the 1894-S as an issue — although in
keeping with the premium near-Gem grade we are unable to
locate more than a few trivial, easily overlooked abrasions.
The mintage for this elusive date was more than 12 times
that of the preceding year’s tally, but at only 1.2 million, the
1894-S still ranks as a difficult date to corral in Choice Mint
State or better. Brilliant, attractive, and sure to see spirited
bidding at auction.
PCGS# 7232.
2230 1894-S MS-64 (PCGS). Smartly impressed with billowy
mint frost, this minimally abraded near-Gem combines a
brilliant obverse with streaks of golden-apricot and powder
blue toning on the reverse. A gorgeous example of a popular
semi-key date.
PCGS# 7232.
Page 124
2231 1894-S MS-63 DMPL (ANACS). OH. This target-toned
beauty exhibits bright, iridescent colors in crimson-copper,
autumn orange, lilac-rose, and bright gold. The boldest
toning is reserved for the peripheries, although the strike
is uniformly full throughout the design. After the shortfall
of Morgan dollars from the San Francisco Mint in the
preceding year, the 1892-S rolled off the presses to the tune
of more than 1.2 million pieces, certainly a welcome note for
today’s collectors.
PCGS# 97233.
Ex: Bill Lower Collection.
2232 1895-O AU-58 (PCGS). Just a whisper away from Mint
State, this key date Morgan offers bold to sharp striking
detail and virtually complete, bright satin luster. A brilliant
and highly appealing Choice AU. One of only 450,000
examples of the date struck, many of which went into
circulation. Even well-worn VF and EF examples of the
date are welcomed by today’s collectors, and in Choice AU
as here the date holds a certain numismatic magnetism. At
“just” Mint State-60 in the Guide Book,the value of this date
skyrockets into the five-figure category — the sky’s the limit
after that. Small wonder smart collectors set their sights on
Choice AU 1895-O Morgan dollars whenever a pleasing
example comes to light.
PCGS# 7236.
Sharp Gem 1895-S Morgan Dollar
2233 1895-S MS-65 (PCGS). This charming piece exhibits speckled crimson, russet, gold and blue peripheral toning around brilliant
centers. The colors are both more varied and more extensive on the obverse, although both sides are uniformly lustrous with a
vibrant satin to semi-reflective finish. Sharp striking detail and exceptionally well preserved surfaces for this often heavily abraded
issue round out an impressive list of attributes for this Gem 1895-S Morgan. While a few bags were released in 1942 in the San
Francisco Bay area and a few more at the Treasury window during the 1950s, most 1895-S Morgans dollars had entered circulation
years earlier and remained there. Desirable in all Mint State grades, Gems are seldom encountered since most Mint State examples
of this issue come heavily bagmarked (PCGS population figures bear this out). A prize for the advanced Morgan collector.
PCGS# 7238.
PCGS Population: 36;7 finer (a lone MS-67 DMPL is the finest).
Page 125
2234 1895-S MS-63 (PCGS). Boldly struck with vibrant satin
white luster, this brilliant Morgan exhibits only small,
singularly inconspicuous abrasions to define the grade.
The 1895-S is notable for having the 2nd lowest mintage of
any Morgan dollar issue struck at the San Francisco Mint
after the 1893-S; only 400,000 examples were produced.
Survivors are scarce in all grades. Evidently very few were
issued to accommodate the day-to-day needs of commerce,
and perhaps only a couple of bags of Uncirculated pieces
(1,000 pieces per bag) survived the great meltings of silver
dollars that occurred during the early decades of the 20th
century.
PCGS# 7238.
2237 1896-O MS-62 PL (NGC). Ringed in speckled orange-gold
peripheral toning, this otherwise brilliant example offers
uncommonly sharp devices and remarkably vibrant luster
in a BU ‘96-O dollar. A superior coin for both the issue
and the assigned grade, and one that would fit nicely in
an advanced collection of this popular silver dollar series.
Evidence from the combined population statistics of both
major certification services indicates that perhaps only two
or three bags of Uncirculated examples (1,000 pieces per
bag) emerged from the giant Treasury Hoard when it was
dispersed during the 1960s. Although readily available in
circulated grades, the comparatively small supply of Mint
State examples has resulted in enormous prices in recent
years.
PCGS# 7243.
Satiny Gem 1896-S
Morgan Dollar
2235 1895-S—Laminated Planchet Reverse—MS-62+ (PCGS).
Sharply defined in all areas save for those affected by
the Mint error, this overall brilliant example also sports
full, vibrant, satin textured luster. A prominent planchet
lamination over the left third of the reverse adds additional
charm and character to this key date Morgan dollar. A scarce
and desirable issue having a mintage of just 400,000 pieces,
the 2nd lowest production figure of any Morgan dollar issue
struck at the San Francisco Mint.
PCGS# 7238.
2236 1896 MS-67 (PCGS). Lustrous and smooth, this beautiful
Superb Gem combines a brilliant obverse with a rainbow
toned reverse. Here’s yet another “common” date in an
elusive grade of condition. Fewer than 1% of all the Mint
State 1896 dollars certified by PCGS are at the MS-67 level,
and finer specimens are all but unobtainable.
2238 1896-S MS-65 (PCGS). Smooth and satiny, this
brilliant piece would accept nothing less than a full
Gem rating. The strike is otherwise sharp, although
accuracy does compel us to mention minor softness of
detail to the central high points, where faint planchet
roller marks (as made) are discernible. While fairly
common in circulated grades, the 1896-S is very rare
in Mint State. Roughly half of the 5,000,000 pieces
struck ended up in the melting pot thanks to the 1918
Pittman Act, and only the occasional bag or two has
since turned up. Nowadays with emphasis on premium
quality coins, Gems are eagerly sought for top of the
line Morgan dollar collections.
PCGS# 7240.
Page 126
PCGS# 7244.
2239 1896-S Unc Details—Altered Surfaces (PCGS). Worthy of
careful bidder consideration, this outwardly smooth piece is
suggestive of a numeric Mint State grade. The surfaces are
rather nicely toned in soft pearl gray patina with more vivid
rose-apricot highlights at the rims. Rounded out by a bold
to sharp strike, this piece is sure to catch the eye of astute
Morgan dollar buyers. Available to a reasonable degree in
circulated grades, the 1896-S becomes downright rare in
Mint State. The present coin is certainly worthy of more
than just casual attention.
2244 1900-O/CC Top 100 Variety. MS-65 (PCGS). A coin for
the Morgan dollar toning enthusiast, this smartly impressed
Gem is bathed in rich, slightly mottled, orange-copper
and golden-blue patina. A great favorite with Morgan
dollar collectors, this variety was struck from old Carson
City reverse dies that had been revamped for use in New
Orleans years after Carson City closed its doors to coinage
operations.
PCGS# 7268.
PCGS# 7244.
2240 1897 Proof-62 (PCGS). Sharply defined with a suitably
vibrant finish at the assigned grade level, the surfaces are
nicely toned in warm sandy-apricot patina. Morgan silver
dollars in Proof are always in strong demand as their
mintages were tiny (731 this year) and survivors are far
fewer than that number. A handsome coin for the collector.
PCGS# 7332.
2241 1897 MS-66 (PCGS). This is a gorgeous, premium quality
Gem with overall brilliant surfaces and a sharply executed
strike. Worthy of a strong bid!
PCGS# 7246.
2245 1903-S VAM-2. Top 100 Variety. Small S. AU-50 (NGC).
Brilliant, satiny surfaces retain plenty of original luster,
the most vibrant of which is evident in the protected areas
around the devices. Those same devices are bold to sharp in
strike with little evident wear, and no significant abrasions. A
highly appealing AU example of this popular VAM variety.
The Small S variety offered here is many multiples rarer
than the “normal” S mintmark of the year, and today’s active
Morgan dollar aficionados are warming up to varieties such
as this in numbers large enough to fan the fires of supply and
demand.
PCGS# 133967.
2242 1900 MS-67 (PCGS). Engaging surfaces are fully lustrous,
smooth and sharply defined throughout. Generally brilliant,
blushes of pale gold at the lower obverse and upper reverse
borders are easily overlooked at most angles. The 1900 is
readily available in grades up to MS-65, but becomes an
important condition rarity at the MS-67 level and virtually
obtainable finer. About as nice an example as any collector
could hope to find.
PCGS# 7264.
PCGS Population: 31; 3 finer (MS-67+ finest).
2243 1900-O/CC Top 100 Variety. MS-66 (PCGS). Light amber
patination gives way to colorful iridescence at the peripheries
of this Superb Gem condition rarity. Rather than waste die
steel, the Philadelphia Mint sent discarded CC dies to New
Orleans after partially effacing the mintmark from the dies.
The end result is one of the most popular varieties in the
Morgan dollar series.
PCGS# 7268.
2246 1921 Peace. High Relief. MS-65 (PCGS). Lightly toned and
fully original, this handsome Gem also sports uncommonly
sharp central definition for a 1921 Peace dollar. Otherwise
outwardly smooth, a tiny nick on Liberty’s cheek is noted
for accuracy. Way above average for Mint State examples of
the issue. The 1921 Peace dollar is a perennial favorite with
silver dollar enthusiasts and type collectors alike.
PCGS# 7356.
2247 1921 Peace. High Relief. MS-65 (PCGS). Minimally toned
over virtually silver gray surfaces, this smooth, satiny piece
would accept nothing less than a Gem rating. The 1921
Peace dollar is part of a very popular two-year design type,
but since the 1922 High Relief dollars remained unissued
and eventually melted (save for the survival of a few Matte
Finish and Satin Finish Proofs together with one or two
stray circulation strikes), the 1921 is essentially the only
collectible date of the type. The issue is distinguished from
the Low Relief pieces of subsequent years by both its highrelief central motifs (almost medallic in their aspect) and
the presence of four rays beneath ONE in the denomination;
beginning with the Low Relief 1922 dollar there were only
three rays beneath ONE.
PCGS# 7356.
2248 1921 Peace. High Relief. MS-65 (PCGS). Halos of soft tanrusset toning frames the central devices of this undeniably
original Gem. Otherwise light silver in tone, this appealing
piece is expectably smooth for the assigned grade. Here’s
a beautifully-crafted two-year design type that ranks as a
favorite with thousands of collectors. Fewer than 15% of
all Mint State examples certified by PCGS grade MS-65 or
finer.
PCGS# 7356.
Page 127
2249 1922 MS-67 (NGC). This is an enchanting Superb Gem
with silky smooth surfaces, razor sharp devices and billowy
mint frost. Virtually brilliant, and attractive in all regards.
1922 dollars grading MS-67 are very elusive with just a few
dozen examples certified by the two major grading services
combined. Only a tiny fraction of 1% of the Mint State 1922
Peace dollars certified by NGC match the quality offered
here.
PCGS# 7357.
2252 1923 MS-66 (PCGS). CAC. With exceptionally vivid and
varied toning in a Peace dollar of any date or issuing Mint,
this simply beautiful 1923 is sure to sell for a premium
bid. Predominantly olive-gold in color, the toning assumes
even more colorful yellow gold and pinkish-rose shades in
and around the centers. Just about every date in the Peace
dollar series can be considered somewhat elusive in Gem,
especially above MS-65 as offered here.
PCGS# 7360.
NGC Census: 37; none finer.
2250 1922-S MS-65+ (NGC). A simply outstanding example
of this notorious strike and condition rarity among San
Francisco Mint Peace dollars, this satin white Gem belongs
in an advanced collection. The surfaces are free of both
toning and grade limiting abrasions, allowing one to
appreciate radiant mint luster. The strike is superior for the
issue with emerging detail in the centers and, in fact, were it
just a bit bolder on the reverse we could easily envision this
coin in an MS-66 holder. Worthy of a premium bid in all
regards.
2253 1923-S MS-65 (NGC). Uncommonly well struck for this
conditionally challenging issue, this satiny Gem is also
remarkably smooth for a 1923-S Peace dollar. Lightly toned
in pale, mottled, sandy-gold and silver-lilac iridescence, this
coin belongs in an advanced silver dollar set. The presentlyoffered example is well within the top 2% of all Mint State
1923-S dollars certified by NGC.
PCGS# 7362.
PCGS# 7359.
2251 1923 MS-67 (NGC). Lovely silver tinged surfaces are
expectably smooth for the assigned grade with a razor
sharp strike from the rims to the centers. Although NGC
has graded 1923 dollars on more than a quarter-million
occasions, fewer than 100 specimens have been certified
at the MS-67 level with none finer. If you desire the best
available quality, your search stops here.
PCGS# 7360.
2254 1924 MS-67 (NGC). Fully struck with silky smooth, frosty
textured surfaces, this conditionally rare Peace dollar also
offers vivid toning in the form of a crescent of olive-orange
around much of the obverse. Delightful! Tied with several
dozen other examples as the 2nd finest certified by NGC.
PCGS# 7363.
NGC Census: 87; 1 finer (MS-68).
2255 1924-S MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. Crisply impressed with
lively satin luster, this otherwise brilliant example exhibits
bisecting swaths of golden iridescence that are seen quite
often on San Francisco Mint silver dollars of the Peace
type. The 1924-S is a desirable issue at the MS-64 level, and
seldom offered finer.
PCGS# 7364.
Page 128
2260 1928-S MS-64+ (PCGS). Exceptionally smooth for this
conditionally challenging issue, especially on the reverse,
this premium 1928-S also offers billowy mint luster and
predominantly brilliant surfaces. The 1928-S is yet another
elusive issue in the higher echelons of preservation. Fewer
than 5% of Mint State examples certified by PCGS could
PCGS# 7374.
2256 1925 MS-67 (NGC). This satin to softly frosted Superb Gem
is virtually brilliant with exceptionally smooth surfaces for
a silver dollar of this conditionally challenging type. Only a
tiny fraction of 1% of the Mint State 1925 dollars certified by
NGC could match the quality offered here.
PCGS# 7365.
NGC Census: 71; 1 finer (MS-68)
Condition Rarity 1925-S
Peace Dollar
2257 1925-S MS-65 (NGC). This satiny, vibrant Gem is
exceptionally smooth in a 1925-S Peace dollar. The strike is
also above average for the issue with the central high points
bold and the balance of the features sharp. Overall brilliant
and highly attractive, a blush of faint golden iridescence in
the center of the reverse is easily overlooked at most angles.
A legendary condition rarity among Peace dollars, the 1925S is one of the few issues that have so far not been graded by
NGC or PCGS above the MS-65 level. Roger Burdette in his
Guide Book of Peace Dollars indicates that this is, “the most
poorly struck Peace dollar.” A chance to obtain a virtually
unimprovable example for the discerning Peace dollar
collector.
2261 1934-D MS-65 (NGC). Blazing satin white luster and
razor sharp devices greet the viewer from both sides of
this captivating Gem Peace dollar. The 1934-D is the final
Peace dollar issue struck at the Denver Mint apart from the
unissued and presumably extinct 1964-D.This beauty easily
ranks in the top 10% of all Mint State examples certified by
NGC.
PCGS# 7376.
Gem Key Date 1934-S Silver Dollar
2262 1934-S MS-65 (PCGS). A smooth Gem drenched in vibrant
satin luster, this beautiful piece also exhibits speckles of
original golden-olive iridescence in isolated areas. A boldly
struck, conditionally rare survivor of the key issue among
Mint State Peace dollars. Large numbers of Mint State 1934S Peace dollars were once thought to be stored in the San
Francisco Mint’s vaults. Not until the 1950s were those
rumors dispelled and numismatists realized that, with
relatively few Mint State coins extant, this is the undisputed
key date condition rarity of its type. Many examples were
released into circulation in earlier years and only a couple
of bags of Mint State coins have found their way into
numismatic circles. PCGS only records some 26 grading
events finer than the present specimen. A cornerstone coin
for any Peace dollar collection.
PCGS# 7377.
PCGS# 7366.
NGC Census: 62; only 1 finer (MS-65+).
2258 1926-S MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. OGH—First Generation.
Delicate olive-apricot highlights drift over both sides of
this fully lustrous, frosty textured Gem. Boldly struck
throughout, as befits the issue, with no abrasions or other
blemishes that would seem to preclude an even higher
grade. An impressive combination of date and grade for this
ever-popular branch mint Peace dollar issue.
PCGS# 7369.
2259 1927-S MS-64+ (PCGS). Billowy mint luster, overall
smooth surfaces and uncommonly sharp devices set this
coin apart from the typical near-Gem ‘27-S Peace dollar.
Worthy of a strong bid! A scarce and desirable issue at the
MS-64 level.
PCGS# 7372.
2263 1934-S MS-63 (NGC). Boldly struck with radiant satin
luster, this brilliant piece is uncommonly smooth in overall
appearance for a Select Mint State Peace dollar. Despite the
fact that the 1927, 1927-S, 1928, and 1934 all have lower
mintages, the 1934-S is the key date in the Peace dollar series
for any collector interested in putting together a Mint State
set. Combined population statistics suggest that it is likely
that around 3,000 Mint State examples exist, with MS-63
being in the middle if the range.
PCGS# 7377.
Page 129
2264 1935-S Three Rays. MS-66 (PCGS). A gorgeous piece with silky smooth surfaces, both sides offer brilliant satin luster to boldly impressed
features. This is the final year of the Peace dollar series apart from the unissued and noncollectible 1964-D. Two different varieties of
the 1935-S are popular with collectors, having either three rays or four rays under ONE in the denomination; different hubs were used
to produce each of the two types. Both varieties are thought to be about equally scarce. PCGS has certified fewer than 150 1935-S Peace
dollars as MS-66 or finer over the years.
PCGS# 7379.
The Morris Minsberg Portfolio
Stack’s Bowers Galleries is pleased to present the Morris Minsberg Portfolio, one of the most extensive holdings of Morgan and
Peace silver dollars in classic Paramount International Coin Corp. holders that we have offered in recent years. Many of these coins
are pedigreed to the famous LaVere Redfield Hoard, and several display attractive, often multicolored toning from years of storage
in these popular and eagerly sought Paramount holders. A “fresh” offering that is sure to excite specialized silver dollar collectors.
2265 1878 8 Tailfeathers. MS-63. Moderately prooflike on the
obverse, this appealing Morgan dollar exhibits substantial
Mint frost on the devices and light golden peripheral
toning. The first of numerous varieties struck in the first
year of Morgan dollar coinage. Housed in a red Paramount
International Coin Corp. holder with the grade listed as
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7072.
From the Morris Minsberg Portfolio.
2266 1878-CC Morgan. MS-62. Intensely lustrous, this sharply
struck Morgan dollar exhibits attractive gold to sea green
peripheral toning with a vivid streak of rainbow color at
the tip of the eagle’s right wing. Always popular as the first
of the Carson City Morgans. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7080.
2267 1878-S Morgan. MS-63. Intense cartwheel luster brings the
frosty devices to life on this extremely attractive first-year
Morgan dollar with light peripheral toning. Housed in a red
Paramount International Coin Corp. holder with the grade
listed as Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7082.
2268 1879 MS-64. Pretty pink peripheral toning accents this
lovely Morgan dollar with brightly lustrous, smooth
surfaces. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin
Corp. holder with the grade listed as Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7084.
2269 1879-S Redfield. MS-63. Modestly prooflike on the obverse,
this beautiful example exhibits vivid orange and blue
peripheral toning around brilliant centers. Housed in a red
Paramount International Coin Corp. Redfield Collection
holder with the grade listed as Mint State 65.
2270 1880 MS-64. Bright and lustrous, this pleasing dollar
exhibits bold device definition and attractive peripheral
toning of gold, pink, and blue. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7096.
2271 1880-S Redfield MS-64+. Exceptionally attractive vivid
rainbow toning graces the obverse periphery and covers
nearly 50% of the reverse of this sharply struck and
boldly lustrous near-Gem. Housed in a red Paramount
International Coin Corp. Redfield Collection holder with
the grade listed as Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7118.
From the Morris Minsberg Portfolio. Earlier ex: LaVere Redfield Hoard.
2272 1881 MS-64. Just a touch of light gold graces the obverse
periphery of this smooth and lustrous dollar, however the
reverse is set aglow by a vivid electric blue band that fades
into pink and gold. Housed in a red Paramount International
Coin Corp. holder with the grade listed as Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7124.
2273 1881-CC MS-64. Brilliant and lustrous, this sharply struck
Morgan dollar displays choice, smooth surfaces and vivid
gold to cobalt blue peripheries. Only 296,000 examples of the
date were struck. Housed in a red Paramount International
PCGS# 7126.
2274 1881-O MS-63. Sharply struck with billowy mint luster,
this charming piece also exhibits pretty peripheral toning in
iridescent gold, orange and blue. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7128.
PCGS# 7092.
Page 130
2275 1881-S Redfield MS-65. Expertly struck with wellpreserved, smooth surfaces, this boldly lustrous Gem is
highlighted by wispy, sweet lavender peripheral toning.
Housed in a red Paramount International Coin Corp.
Redfield Collection holder with the grade listed as Mint
State 65.
PCGS# 7130.
2276 1882 MS-63. This lovely Morgan silver dollar impresses the
viewer with frosty devices, smooth fields, excellent luster,
and vivid peripheral toning in shades of pink, gold, and
blue. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin Corp.
PCGS# 7132.
2277 1882-CC MS-64. Razor sharp in strike with otherwise
brilliant, frosty white surfaces, this delightful CC-mint
dollar exhibits iridescent peripheral toning in reddish-gold
that is much more pronounced on the reverse. Housed in
a red Paramount International Coin Corp. holder with the
grade listed as Mint State 65. An excellent date and grade
combination for today’s collecting community.
PCGS# 7134.
2278 1882-O MS-63. Beautifully toned from years of storage in
the present holder, both sides of this delightful Morgan are
adorned with vivid reddish-gold, orange-russet and cobalt
blue peripheral toning. Otherwise brilliant, with radiant
luster and a bold to sharp strike. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7136.
2279 1882-S Redfield. MS-63. Lightly toned around the rims in
reddish-gold iridescence, and then again predominantly on
the reverse, this otherwise brilliant piece radiate intense mint
luster at all angles. Housed in a red Paramount International
Coin Corp. Redfield Collection holder with the grade listed
as Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7140.
2280 1883 MS-64+. Bright and attractive, this dollar exhibits
flashy luster and a bold strike with vivid golden peripheries
and a sliver of electric blue. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7142.
2281 1883-CC MS-63. Boldly lustrous with a primarily brilliant
obverse, this attractive dollar has sharply defined devices
with substantial Mint frost; a trace of light rainbow toning
at the reverse periphery adds to the charm. Housed in a red
PCGS# 7144.
2282 1883-O MS-63+. Virtually fully brilliant surfaces exhibit a
bold strike and liberal luster, while a thin band of vibrant
colorful toning at the peripheries provides a bit of charm.
Housed in a red Paramount International Coin Corp. holder
with the grade listed as Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7146.
2283 1883-S Redfield. MS-63. Fully struck and highly lustrous,
this otherwise satin white example is ringed in delightful
tan-gold peripheral iridescence. Housed in a red Paramount
the grade listed as Mint State 65. A San Francisco Mint
issue that is far more difficult to locate in Choice Mint State
or finer despite a mintage of more than 6.2 million pieces;
much of the mintage saw commercial duty and relatively
few Uncirculated examples were set aside intentionally.
PCGS# 7148.
2284 1884 MS-63. This appealing Morgan dollar is bright and
intensely lustrous with smooth fields and vibrant peripheral
toning of golden-orange to pink. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7150.
2285 1884-CC MS-64. The boldly struck devices exhibit pleasing
Mint frost, while the bright, lustrous surfaces are accented by
thin bands of vivid gold at the peripheries. An ever-popular
date and grade combination. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7152.
2286 1884-O MS-63. This appealing dollar exhibits choice,
smooth surfaces and substantial luster, with exceptional
reverse peripheral toning of vivid blue and gold. Housed in
grade listed as Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7154.
2287 1885 MS-63. Bright and lustrous, this dollar exhibits light
Mint frost and pleasing golden-orange peripheral toning on
the reverse. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin
PCGS# 7158.
2288 1885-CC MS-63+. Sharply struck with creamy white surfaces
and attractive Mint frost on the devices; this pleasing dollar
also exhibits wispy light gold to blue peripheral toning.
One of 228,000 examples of the date struck, the lowest
production tally of any date among Carson City Morgans.
PCGS# 7160.
2289 1885-O MS-62. Boldly lustrous throughout, the essentially
fully brilliant obverse is paired with a sharply struck reverse
with gold, pink, and blue peripheral toning. Housed in a red
PCGS# 7162.
Page 131
2290 1885-S MS-63. Lovely smooth surfaces exhibit bold luster
and a sharply struck reverse, while pleasing peripheral
toning adds to the appeal. A popular and moderately scarce
date in the Morgan dollar series. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7164.
2291 1886 MS-63. Bright and lustrous with bold device
definition, this dollar exhibits lovely “orange-peel” surfaces
and a few wisps of colorful peripheral toning. Housed in a
red Paramount International Coin Corp. holder with the
PCGS# 7166.
2292 1886-S Redfield MS-63. This gorgeous dollar features lightly
frosted devices, bold luster, and a pleasing light golden cast
with peach and blue highlights. Only 750,000 examples of
this semi-key date were struck. Housed in a red Paramount
PCGS# 7170.
2293 1887 MS-63. Sharply struck with exceptional mint luster,
this highly appealing piece also exhibits thin bands of
vivid gold at the peripheries. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7172.
2299 1889-S Redfield MS-63. The sharply struck, choice surfaces
are brightly lustrous with nicely blended pink, lilac, and
cobalt peripheral toning. Housed in a red Paramount
PCGS# 7194.
2300 1890 MS-63. Crisp, smooth surfaces display bold Mint
luster and appealing peripheral toning of blue, gold, and
lilac. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin Corp.
PCGS# 7196.
2301 1890-CC MS-63. Splendid frosty textured surfaces are
sharply struck and free of singularly distracting abrasions.
Predominantly untoned, years of encapsulation in the
current holder have imparted delicate golden-rose toning to
the extreme peripheries along the denticles. Housed in a red
PCGS# 7198.
2302 1890-S Redfield MS-64. Deliciously smooth, brilliant
surfaces are overwhelmed by exceptionally strong cartwheel
luster, while a few light wisps of gold at the rims nicely frame
the devices. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin
Corp. Redfield Collection holder with the grade listed as
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7202.
2294 1887-O MS-63. Pretty, colorful peripheral toning highlights
the surfaces of this decidedly choice Morgan dollar, with
rich luster and a boldly struck reverse. Housed in a red
PCGS# 7176.
2303 1891 MS-64. Lovely rose-orange and powder blue
peripheral toning frames frosty, boldly struck, more or less
brilliant centers on both sides of this charming near-Gem.
PCGS# 7204.
2295 1887-S Redfield MS-63. Sharply struck with bold cartwheel
luster, this pleasing Morgan dollar exhibits bright, brilliant
surfaces with colorful highlights mostly confined to the
rims and the reverse legends. Housed in a red Paramount
PCGS# 7180.
2296 1888 MS-63. Bright white centers exhibit excellent luster
and vivid golden-orange to pink peripheral toning with a
thin band of electric blue on the reverse. Housed in a red
PCGS# 7182.
2297 1888-O MS-64. Pleasing luster and boldly struck devices
are found on this nicely toned Morgan dollar that displays
numerous pretty colors at the peripheries. Housed in a red
PCGS# 7184.
2298 1888-S Redfield. MS-64. This overall smooth, minimally
abraded beauty exhibits golden-tan and blue-gray peripheral
toning to otherwise frosty white surfaces. Housed in a red
Paramount International Coin Corp. Redfield Collection
holder with the grade listed as Mint State 65. Choice for the
grade.
2304 1891-CC MS-63. This endearing example is sharply struck
throughout with billowy mint frost and golden-tinged to
brilliant centers. The peripheries, on the other hand, are
adorned with vivid toning in iridescent reddish-apricot,
pale gold, and powder blue. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7206.
2305 1891-S Redfield MS-63+. Exceptionally bold luster is
exhibited on this brilliant, well-struck Morgan silver dollar
with bright, colorful toning peeking out from the rims.
State 65.
PCGS# 7210.
2306 1891-S Redfield MS-63. Bold cartwheel luster emanates
from this lovely silver dollar cloaked with warm gold and
vivid blue peripheral toning. Housed in a blue Paramount
no grade listed.
PCGS# 7210.
PCGS# 7186.
Page 132
2307 1892 MS-63+. Sharply struck and lustrous with fewer
abrasions than one might expect given our Select Mint State
rating, this otherwise golden tinged piece exhibits warmer
sandy-tan highlights in isolated peripheral areas. Housed in
PCGS# 7212.
2312 1897 Redfield MS-64. Choice, smooth fields are brought to
life by attractive warm toning that ranges from vivid gold
to azure at the peripheries, while the devices are bright
white with light mint frost. Housed in a red Paramount
PCGS# 7246.
2313 1897 Redfield MS-63. Sharply struck with crisp and brilliant
centers, this attractive Morgan exhibits lovely cartwheel
luster and peripheral toning that blends from gold to lilac
to cobalt blue. Housed in a blue Paramount International
as Mint State 60.
PCGS# 7246.
2308 1892-CC Redfield. MS-63+. Peripherally toned in soft silver
gray and tan-orange iridescence, this otherwise brilliant
piece is boldly struck and fully frosted in texture. A popular
date from the waning days of Carson City Mint coinage
operations. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7214.
2309 1893 MS-63+. This radiant, smartly impressed Morgan
dollar combines brilliant centers with peripheries that
are ringed in vivid blue and reddish-orange iridescence.
Certainly among the most attractive Mint State examples of
this popular low mintage issue that we have handled in recent
sales. Only 378,000 Morgan dollars were forthcoming from
the Pedophilia Mint in 1893. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7220.
From the Morris Minsberg Collection.
2314 1897-S Redfield MS-64. This bright and appealing Morgan
dollar exhibits creamy smooth surfaces, bold definition,
excellent luster, and a thin band of golden toning at the
rims. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin Corp.
State 65.
PCGS# 7250.
2315 1898 MS-63+. Strong luster and brilliant white surfaces are
accented by small patches of rainbow color at the rims and
along the legends. Housed in a red Paramount International
PCGS# 7252.
2316 1898-O MS-65. Boldly struck with strong definition
throughout, the surfaces are frosty and smooth, enhanced
by obverse rim toning that evokes the first glimpse of a
sunrise. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin
PCGS# 7254.
2317 1898-S Redfield MS-63. Sharply struck with strong luster,
this choice Morgan dollar exhibits virtually fully brilliant
surfaces with just a touch of golden peripheral toning.
State 65.
PCGS# 7256.
2310 1893-CC Redfield. MS-62. Uncommonly full in strike for a
‘93-CC Morgan dollar, this highly lustrous piece combines
a satin to semi-prooflike obverse with a uniformly frosted
reverse. Vivid peripheral toning also greets the viewer from
both sides and further enhances this coin’s appeal. One of
677,000 examples struck in the final year of Carson City
Mint coinage. Housed in a red Paramount International
as Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7222.
2311 1896 Redfield MS-64. The choice smooth surfaces of this
attractive dollar are bright and lustrous with just a touch
of golden peripheral toning. Housed in a red Paramount
2318 1899 MS-63. This fully struck, fully frosted piece exhibits
vivid peripheral toning in blue, orange and rose colors
that provides exceptional eye appeal at the Select Mint
State grade level. Housed in a red Paramount International
Coin Corp. holder with the grade listed as Mint State 65. A
popular low-mintage Morgan dollar date.
PCGS# 7258.
2319 1899-O MS-64+. Gorgeous mint frost blankets both
sides and accents a sharp to full strike. This is a beautiful,
premium, near-Gem with iridescent golden-tan framing
brilliant centers. Housed in a red Paramount International
Coin Corp. holder with the grade listed as Mint State 65. A
popular New Orleans Mint issue.
PCGS# 7260.
PCGS# 7240.
Page 133
2320 1899-S Redfield. MS-64. Captivating satin to softly frosted
luster greets the viewer from both sides of this sharply
struck and uncommonly abrasion free Redfield dollar.
Predominantly brilliant, blushes of light reddish-tan
iridescence are largely confined to the peripheries. Housed
in a red Paramount International Coin Corp. Redfield
Collection holder with the grade listed as Mint State 65. A
moderately elusive date at MS-64 or finer.
PCGS# 7262.
2321 1900 MS-64. Vibrant blue and gold grace the peripheries
of this sharply struck Morgan dollar with strong luster
and pleasing Mint frost. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7264.
2322 1900-O MS-64+. This peripherally toned example exhibits
soft, slightly mottled, sandy-tan peripheral toning around
brilliant, satin white centers. Sharply struck with eye appeal
to spare. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin
PCGS# 7266.
PCGS# 7286.
2329 1904-O MS-64. Brilliant and lustrous surfaces display bold
to sharp definition and wispy gold to blue peripheral toning.
PCGS# 7292.
2330 1921 Morgan. MS-60 Environmental Damage. This fully
struck piece exhibits dominant sandy-gold patina to both
sides. The surfaces are a bit subdued in the luster category,
although speckles of charcoal-russet verdigris over the lower
half of the obverse are the more significant impairment.
with the grade listed as Mint State 65. Struck in the final year
of Morgan dollar coinage after a hiatus in the design type of
17 calendar years.
PCGS# 7296.
2323 1900-S Redfield. MS-64. Featuring a crisp strike, this
lustrous Morgan silver dollar exhibits mostly brilliant
surfaces with light golden toning scattered in the fields and
peripheries. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin
Mint State 65.
PCGS# 7270.
2324 1901-O MS-64. This pretty Morgan dollar displays bold
cartwheel luster, smooth fields, and light golden rim toning
that adds significantly to the appeal. Housed in a red
PCGS# 7274.
2325 1902-O MS-64. This is a premium near-Gem with brilliant,
lustrous surfaces and a sharp, crisp strike throughout.
with the grade listed as Mint State 65. Nearly 30 years later
and nice coins from the famed Redfield Hoard still attract
attention.
PCGS# 7280.
2326 1902-S Redfield. MS-63. Frosty and well struck in a late date
S-mint Morgan, this piece combines a brilliant obverse with
a peripherally toned gold and apricot-tinged reverse. The
luster quality is also exceptional for the issue with a full and
vibrant softly frosted texture. Housed in a red Paramount
PCGS# 7282.
2327 1903 MS-63. This Morgan dollar exhibits a sharp strike with
excellent device definition and boldly lustrous surfaces; a bit
of color at the peripheries adds quite nicely to the eye appeal.
PCGS# 7284.
2328 1903-O MS-64. Fully lustrous with brilliant white surfaces,
a few accents of color at the peripheries add eye appeal, but it
is the boldly struck devices that steal the show on this lovely
Morgan dollar. Housed in a red Paramount International
2331 1921-D MS-64. Somewhat speckled copper-gold and cobalt
blue peripheral toning frames frosty white centers on both
sides of this beautiful final year Morgan dollar. Housed in
grade listed as Mint State 65. The only Denver Mint issue in
the Morgan dollar series.
PCGS# 7298.
2332 1921-S MS-63. A particularly endearing example of this
conditionally challenging issue, both sides are sharply
struck over all devices to include the high points in and
around the centers. Outwardly smooth with billowy mint
luster, soft tan-gold patina also adorns both sides, the color
deepening a bit at the borders. Housed in a red Paramount
Mint State 65. A popular branch mint issue from the final
year of the design type.
PCGS# 7300.
2333 1922 MS-64. This pretty Peace dollar exhibits bright, strong
luster with light golden toning that playfully enhances the
frosty surfaces. Housed in a red Paramount International
PCGS# 7357.
2334 1923 MS-63. Light, mottled, sandy-gold iridescence greets
the viewer from both sides of this sharply struck, richly
frosted piece. Housed in a red Paramount International
PCGS# 7360.
2335 1924 MS-64. This is an extremely attractive piece, the
surfaces fully frosted in finish, crisply impressed throughout,
and further enhanced with mottled gold, pale rose and russet
iridescence. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin
PCGS# 7363.
Page 134
2336 1926-S Redfield. MS-63. This peripherally toned beauty also sports full, vibrant mint luster and a superior quality of strike in a San
Francisco Mint Peace dollar. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin Corp. Redfield Collection holder with the grade listed as
Mint State 65. An ever-popular branch mint Peace dollar.
PCGS# 7369.
2337 1927 MS-64. Wonderfully original and expertly preserved to preclude notice of distracting abrasions, otherwise sandy-silver surfaces
are further enhanced by mottled russet highlights here and there around the peripheries. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin
Corp. holder with the grade listed as Mint State 65. The date’s mintage of 848,000 pieces is one of five dates in the series with a mintage
that dipped below the one million mark.
PCGS# 7370.
2338 1935 MS-64+. Virtually in the full gem category, this smooth, satiny and sharply struck example is further adorned with pale gold and
russet toning that is boldest at the borders. Housed in a red Paramount International Coin Corp. holder with the grade listed as Mint
State 65. A pleasing specimen that holds up admirably to today’s grading standards.
PCGS# 7378.
From the Morris Minsberg Collection.
End of The Morris Minsberg Portfolio
GSA Dollars
Elusive 1879-CC GSA
Morgan Silver Dollar
2339 1879-CC GSA Morgan Silver Dollar. MS-64+
(PCGS). A splendid example of this popular semi-key
date Carson City Mint issue, both sides are bursting
with full, brilliant, frosty textured luster. Fully struck
with hardly a distracting blemish, there is much
to recommend this coin to the quality conscious
collector. With a limited mintage of 756,000 pieces and
a below average rate of survival in Mint State, the 1879CC is one of the better known key date issues among
Carson City Mint Morgans. Examples are particularly
desirable — and elusive — in original GSA holders, for
only 4,123 pieces were distributed through the various
GSA sales during the 1970s. This total amounted
to just 0.50% of the issue’s original mintage, a paltry
percentage when we consider that a “common” GSA
dollar such as the 1882-CC saw 44.60% of its original
mintage distributed through these sales. With high
technical quality to boot, this important ‘79-CC is sure
to have no difficulty finding its way into an advanced
collection of GSA dollars. The original box and card
are not included.
2340 1879-CC GSA Morgan Silver Dollar. MS-64 (NGC).
Minimally toned with an outwardly brilliant “look,” this
frosty and boldly struck near-Gem is sure to excite the CCmint Morgan dollar collector. Minimally abraded, as befits
the near-Gem grade, and attractive in all regards. Reportedly,
there were some 4,100 1879-CC dollars distributed by the
GSA; thousands of others were likely distributed by the
Treasury during the early 1960s. The Mint State population
is hard to estimate because many examples in GSA holders
trade without grade certification. Perhaps a reasonable
estimate of the Mint State population would be 7,500 to
10,000 coins, which is very close to the estimate published
by Dave Bowers in his 1993 Silver Dollars & Trade Dollars
of the United States. NGC has certified fewer than 1,000
examples as MS-64 or finer. The original box and cards are
included.
PCGS# 518848.
PCGS# 518848.
Page 135
2341 1881-CC GSA Morgan Silver Dollar. MS-67 (NGC). This
is a beautiful Superb Gem with frosty, brilliant surfaces and
nary a detracting blemish in evidence. Many Carson City
Mint Morgan dollars were distributed by the GSA (General
Services Administration) during the early 1970s; these
dollars were part of the giant U.S. Treasury Hoard which had
already been mostly distributed into numismatic channels
during the early 1960s. In the experience of the present
cataloger (AWP), the majority of GSA dollars were within
the range of dates from 1880 through 1885; other dates
seemed to appear in the GSA holders with less frequency.
Presumably, many examples have been cracked out of their
GSA holders for certification in “slabs,” but the original GSA
holders are still quite common and remain popular with
collectors. Fewer than 1% of the 1881-CC dollars certified
by NGC grade MS-67 or finer. The original box and card are
not included.
PCGS# 518863.
Trade Dollars
2345 1876 Type I/I. MS-64+ (NGC). CAC. Crescents of bold
steel gray along the lower obverse and upper reverse borders
blends with otherwise dominant antique gold patina.
Lustrous and outwardly smooth in all areas, this premium
near-Gem would fit nicely in a high grade, high quality type
set. Probably no more than 1,000 Mint State examples exist
in all numismatics, and only a few dozen of them could
PCGS# 7041.
2346 1876 Type I/II. MS-62 (PCGS). Overall brilliant with
delightful satin luster, both sides are smooth enough to be
knocking on the door of a Select Mint State grade. The strike
is somewhat soft in the centers, yet considerably sharper
elsewhere. Combined population statistics of the two major
certification services suggest a surviving population of 600
to 800 Mint State examples. Some specialists consider the I/
II combination (as offered here) to be scarcer than the I/I.
Examples having the II/II configuration were unknown to
Breen when he wrote his Complete Encyclopedia, but have
since been reported, and are considered to be very rare.
PCGS# 7041.
2342 1875-CC Type I/I. Tall CC. MS-60 (NGC). Subtle russet
peripheral highlights interrupt otherwise silver gray
brilliance on both sides of this satiny, overall sharply
impressed piece. The surfaces are not overly abraded for
the assigned grade, although a few sizeable marks on the
obverse are noted. The 1875-CC is a scarce issue in Mint
State with perhaps 250 to 300 specimens accounted for. Two
different reverse types are known designated as I and II,
these are distinguished by the presence of a berry beneath
the eagle’s left talon (viewer’s right). If the berry is present, it
is Type I; if the berry is missing, it is Type II. 1875-CC trade
dollars are usually seen with the Type I reverse as offered
here.
PCGS# 7038.
2343 1875-S Type I/I. Large S. MS-62 (PCGS). CAC. Fully
lustrous with only faint handling marks to define the grade,
warm olive-russet peripheral toning on the obverse further
enhances already strong eye appeal for this BU trade dollar.
Walter Breen listed a half dozen different collectible varieties
of the issue when he wrote his Complete Encyclopedia back
in 1988; assembling a set of these 1875-S variants could be
an enjoyable pursuit for many collectors.
PCGS# 7039.
2344 1875-S Type I/I. Large S. MS-62 (PCGS). Lustrous for the
grade with a satiny texture, this minimally abraded example
is untoned apart from a few wisps of olive-russet patina
along the upper obverse border. Probably no more than
2,000 Mint State specimens still survive, not a large supply
as both date collectors and type set enthusiasts are vying for
examples.
2347 1876-S Type I/I. Large S. MS-62 (PCGS). Secure Holder.
This satiny, uncommonly smooth BU trade dollar exhibits
delicate golden toning that is boldest around the devices.
A sharply struck piece that is sure to appeal to the Mint
State type collector. Two different obverse die types and
two different reverse die types were used to coin trade
dollars during the year. with the resulting possibility of four
different combinations: I/I, I/II, II/I, and II/II. Walter Breen
in his Complete Encyclopedia of United States and Colonial
Coins was aware of I/I, I/II, and II/II, and these are the same
varieties currently recognized by the certification services.
No examples of II/I have been reported in the information
sources consulted by us, and so it is likely that none were
produced. Although the three major types of 1876-S trade
dollars vary somewhat in availability, none of them seem to
be particularly rare, and therefore any trade dollar collector
with a suitable budget should be able to acquire nice
examples of each.
PCGS# 7043.
2348 1877-S Large S. MS-62 (PCGS). Deep, rich, golden-copper
and russet patina greets the viewer from both sides of this
smartly impressed Mint State type candidate. The date’s
mintage of more than 9.5 million pieces is the largest
productivity tally in the design type by far. As such, nice
Mint State examples are generally available to this who seek
a specimen.
PCGS# 7046.
PCGS# 7039.
Page 136
Superb Gem Cameo Proof 1878 Trade Dollar
2349 1878 Trade. Proof-67 Cameo (PCGS). CAC. Secure Holder. This is an exquisite Superb Gem whose smooth, virtually pristine
surfaces readily reveal bold contrast between the fields and devices. Lightly and evenly toned in iridescent silver-rose, warmer
copper-blue highlights are also evident here and there around the peripheries. This is far and away one of the finest of this issue
of a mere 900 pieces. Furthermore this is the final year of the Trade dollars being struck for general circulation, although Proofs
continued in dwindling numbers until 1885 from this series. The Cameo contrast adds considerable appeal to a technically incredible
coin, and this stunning example needs to be viewed to fully enjoy its extraordinary presence. Destined for an advanced Registry
collection of this series or an ultimate type collection.
PCGS# 87058.
PCGS Population: just 2; none finer in either the Cameo or Deep Cameo categories.
2350 1879 Trade. Proof-64 (PCGS). Rich, mottled, crimsoncopper and steel-russet toning enlivens a base of olive-gray.
Nicely mirrored in finish, especially when observed with
the aid of a direct light source, this sharply struck specimen
makes a bold visual impression. A desirable Proof-only
issue that was produced expressly to accommodate the
numismatic community as no circulation strikes were
produced subsequent to 1878. Only 1,541 pieces were
struck, and the great majority of these evidently still exist.
Most specimens seen are in the Proof-63 to 64 range.
PCGS# 7059.
2351 1880 Trade. Proof-64 Cameo (PCGS). Brilliant with
pronounced cameo contrast to the finish, this smartly
impressed and carefully preserved Proof makes a strong
impression in all regards. A desirable Proof-only issue
having a mintage of just 1,987 pieces, which were struck
entirely for the benefit of the numismatic community; there
were no circulation strikes produced in the trade dollar
series subsequent to 1878. PCGS has awarded the Cameo
designation to fewer than 25% of the 1880 trade dollars
enumerated in their Population Report.
PCGS# 87060.
Page 137
2352 1880 Trade. Proof-64 (PCGS). This attractive, modestly
cameoed specimen exhibits speckled silver-olive toning that
yields to more vivid golden-apricot as the surfaces dip into a
light. The winds of change had swept over the regular issue
Trade dollars at the close of 1878, but for the next few years
Proofs were struck for collectors. For 1880 a total of 1,987
pieces were issued in the Proof format, and collectors of this
series usually include these handsome Proofs in their date
and mint collections of Trade dollars. Close to the Gem level
and pleasing in all regards.
PCGS# 7060.
2353 1880 Trade. Proof-63 (PCGS). This razor sharp specimen
is lightly toned in silver gray iridescence through which
ample reflectivity shines forth from the fields. Mintage of
1,987 pieces, and this Choice Proof will certainly dazzle
most collectors who are seeking such a coin. Furthermore,
no 1880 Trade dollars were struck for circulation, but only
in the Proof format so precious few survive.
PCGS# 7060.
Commemorative Silver
Coins
2354 1893 Isabella Quarter. MS-65 (PCGS). This originally
toned, sandy-olive Gem is sharply struck throughout with
nary a detracting abrasion in evidence. Struck in 1893
upon petition of the Board of Lady Managers of the World’s
Columbian Exhibition, the authority for the coinage was
issued March 3, 1893, and production commenced soon
thereafter. The design was by Charles E. Barber and it was
the first U.S. coin to bear the likeness of a woman other than
that of Liberty.
2355 1900 Lafayette Silver Dollar. MS-64+ (PCGS). Brilliant
satin to softly frosted surfaces are exceptionally well
preserved for the type with hardly even a trivial distraction
in evidence. The entire mintage of the Lafayette dollar is
said to have been coined on December 14, 1899, the 100th
anniversary of George Washington’s death. The funds that
accrued from the sale of the dollars were earmarked to help
finance the erection of a memorial statue honoring Lafayette
in Paris. The hubs used to make the obverse and reverse dies
were incomplete, and consequently some of the lettering
and other details were individually punched into the dies
resulting in distinguishable varieties. These varieties were
studied by George H. Clapp and Howland Wood who were
able to distinguish between four different die combinations
in 1925; years later Anthony Swiatek described a fifth variety.
For some unknown reason, the collecting of Lafayette
dollars by die variety never became popular with collectors,
and accordingly catalogers rarely bother to mention them in
auction presentations. Terse descriptions of the obverse and
reverse dies can be found listed in Swiatek and Breen’s Silver
& Gold Commemorative Coins, 1892-1989.
PCGS# 9222.
2356 1900 Lafayette Silver Dollar. MS-63 (PCGS). Vivid
reddish-apricot iridescence engages the borders of this
otherwise brilliant piece. Lustrous and visually appealing,
a few wispy handling marks on the obverse are the only
impediments to an even higher grade. The 1900 Lafayette
was the only silver dollar issue produced during the socalled “classic” commemorative era which commenced
in 1892 (with the Columbian Exposition half dollar)
and closed in 1954 (with the last members of the CarverWashington half dollar series). Decades later, beginning in
1983, the issuance of silver dollars as components in various
U.S. commemorative coinage programs became routine.
PCGS# 9222.
2357 1921 Alabama Centennial. 2x2. MS-65 (NGC). Satiny and
smooth, this otherwise brilliant Gem reveals a few swirls
of faint champagne pink iridescence around the obverse
periphery. A lovely piece with eye appeal to spare. The
Alabama Centennial half dollar was issued in 1921 despite
the fact the state centennial had been celebrated two years
earlier in 1919. The famous sculptor Laura Gardin Fraser
created the designs for the issue.
PCGS# 9225.
PCGS# 9220.
Page 138
2358 1937 Antietam Anniversary. MS-67 (PCGS). Gorgeous
silky smooth surfaces are bathed in sandy-gray patina that
gives way to bold orange-russet rim highlights. Issued to
commemorate the 75th anniversary of the famous Civil
War battle. The obverse features jugate portraits of Generals
McClellan and Lee. The reverse depicts a famous Antietam
landmark — the Burnside Bridge — which has long been
recognized as emblematic of the battleground. Fewer than
10% of the 1937 Antietam half dollars certified by PCGS
PCGS# 9229.
Glorious Superb Gem
Mint State 1954-S
Carver/Washington
2359 1937 Antietam Anniversary. MS-67 (NGC). This virtually
pristine, highly lustrous Superb Gem is brilliant apart from
subtle sandy-silver highlights around the reverse periphery.
A radiant and extremely attractive piece. Only a small
proportion of examples certified by NGC could match the
quality of this beauty.
PCGS# 9229.
2360 1939-D Arkansas Centennial. MS-67 (PCGS). CAC. This
is a wonderfully original Superb Gem that exhibits smooth,
satiny surfaces on both sides. Also lightly toned in pale
silver iridescence, halos of bold russet also cling to the rims
and form a nice frame for the centers. One of only 2,104
examples of the date distributed in a series that was struck at
all three mints from 1935 through 1939 — 15 different coins
are needed to complete an Arkansas commemorative half
dollar collection.
2362 1954-S Carver/Washington Commemorative. MS67 (PCGS). Intense mint luster shines on both sides
accenting exquisite iridescent gold, blue and pinkishapricot toning. This virtually pristine piece is sure
to please even the most discerning commemorative
collector. This majestic beauty is outstanding, not
only for its technical grade, but also for the elegant
toning. A most stunning example that will appeal to
connoisseurs.
PCGS# 9444.
PCGS# 9250.
Frosty and Virtually Pristine
1892 Columbian Expo Half
2361 1952 Carver/Washington Commemorative. MS-67
(PCGS). CAC. Secure Holder. Intensely vivid speckles of
multicolored toning decorate both sides of this expertly
preserved and visually stunning Superb Gem. This specimen
is the very definition of a condition rarity as so few have
been awarded the Superb grade by PCGS. View the majestic
toning and high quality surfaces before formulating a bid on
this memorable coin.
PCGS# 9434.
PCGS Population: just 13; and 3 are finer through MS-68.
Ex: Heller Collection.
2363 1892 Columbian Exposition. MS-67 (PCGS). Exquisite
brilliant white surfaces are virtually pristine with radiant
satin to softly frosted luster. An exceptional coin that
demands a home in an exceptional collection. The surfaces
are simply breathtaking as they are so close to perfection.
Furthermore the luster is a feast for the eyes, and the
entire appearance is outstanding. A condition rarity at this
monumental grade level, and clearly one of the very finest of
this popular issue.
PCGS# 9296.
PCGS Population: 19; just 4 finer, all MS-67+.
Page 139
2364 1892 Columbian Exposition. MS-66+ (PCGS). Delightful
frosty textured surfaces exhibit irregular halos of rich
charcoal-blue and rose-apricot peripheral toning around
ice white centers. Struck in the first year of the silver
commemorative half dollar series, this popular first-ever
issue was struck again the following year with the date
1893. The obverse portrait was by Charles E. Barber and the
reverse design was by George T. Morgan.
PCGS# 9296.
2366 1928 Hawaiian Sesquicentennial. MS-64 (PCGS). This
satiny, fully original near-Gem is adorned with mottled
steel-olive and sandy gold patina. The key to the early
commemorative series, 1892 through 1954, the Hawaiian
Sesquicentennial half dollar commemorated the 150th
Anniversary of the discovery of the islands by Captain James
Cook in 1778; Cook died in the islands during a skirmish
with the war-like natives. The design was by Juliette May
Fraser of Honolulu, and the dies were executed by Chester
beach.
PCGS# 9309.
2365 1928 Hawaiian Sesquicentennial. MS-65 (PCGS).
Endearing satin to softly frosted surfaces are both
uncommonly vibrant in finish and remarkably smooth in
appearance for an example of this key classic Commemorative
type. The 1928 Hawaiian is widely regarded as the single
most desirable design type in the entire commemorative
half dollar series. Scarcely more than 10,000 examples were
issued. The obverse features a bust of Captain James Cook to
left. The reverse is a standing figure of King Kamehameha of
Hawaii based on the famous statue sculpted by Thomas R.
Gould in Florence, Italy circa 1880. The coin designs were
modeled by Chester Beech, following sketches by Hawaiian
artist Juliette May Fraser.
PCGS# 9309.
2367 1928 Hawaiian Sesquicentennial. Unc Details—
Questionable Color (PCGS). Satiny in texture and
outwardly smooth, even somewhat hazy tannish-silver
iridescence does not detract much from this key date
commemorative half. The 1928 Hawaiian is widely
considered to be the most desirable design type in the entire
commemorative half dollar series. The scarcity of the issue
has often been explained by the high initial distribution
price of $2, which was seemingly regarded as exorbitant at
the time. In the end, barely more than 10,000 examples were
issued.
PCGS# 9309.
2368 1928 Hawaiian Sesquicentennial. Unc Details—
Improperly Cleaned (NGC). Brilliant and fully struck, a
touch of glossiness to the surface texture hardly inhibits the
eye appeal of this radiant piece. A desirable key issue in the
commemorative half dollar series featuring a bust of Captain
James Cook facing left on the obverse and a standing figure
of Hawaiian King Kamehameha on the reverse.
PCGS# 9309.
From our (Bowers and Ruddy’s) Scott Collection sale, June 1975, lot
2369 1923-S Monroe Doctrine Centennial. MS-65 (PCGS).
CAC. Slightly mottled pinkish-silver patina blends with
smooth, softly frosted luster on both sides of this undeniably
original Gem. MS-65 pieces rank in the top 15% of Mint
State examples certified by PCGS.
PCGS# 9333.
Page 140
2370 1936 Norfolk, Virginia Bicentennial. MS-68 (NGC).
Delightful reddish-apricot and golden-tan peripheral
toning frames brilliant, satin white centers on both sides
of this virtually pristine beauty. Very close to absolute
perfection! Commemorative specialists are well aware that a
large proportion of Norfolk half dollars have been preserved
in Gem condition, and specimens are readily available in all
grades desired up to and including MS-67. MS-68 examples
are scarce, however, and comprise fewer than 5% of the Mint
State pieces certified by NGC. Further, NGC has certified
just one finer example, a solitary MS-69.
PCGS# 9337.
2371 1935 Old Spanish Trail. MS-65 (PCGS). Dusted with
lightly mottled sandy gold patina, this endearing Gem is
exceptionally smooth for this conditionally challenging
commemorative type. An ever-popular key issue. The Old
Spanish Trail commemorative half dollar cites an ill-fated
cross-country trip that ended years after it began and left
but two survivors. The design was by L.W. Hoffecker and the
models were prepared by Edmund J. Senn.
PCGS# 9376.
2372 1935 Old Spanish Trail. MS-64 (PCGS). Swirls of
sandy-gold obverse toning interrupt satiny brilliance for
this lustrous and uncommonly smooth near-Gem. This
commemorative marked the 400th anniversary of the
expedition of the Spanish explorer Cabeza de Vaca through
territory now embodied in the states of Florida, Alabama,
Mississippi, Louisiana, and Texas. The famous Texas coin
dealer and one-time A.N.A. president L.W. Hoffecker —
backed by some prominent Texas historical organizations
— was a moving force behind the idea. He is credited
with having created the coin designs which were modeled
by El Paso sculptor Edmund J. Senn. The obverse design
is a punning allusion to the name of the explorer, which
translates into English as “head of cow.”
PCGS# 9376.
2373 1935 Old Spanish Trail. MS-64 (PCGS). Delightful satin
surfaces are overall smooth and untoned apart from delicate
peripheral highlights. A scarce and desirable issue that
was issued at the behest of various historical and cultural
organizations in El Paso, Texas. The idea was evidently
spearheaded by the El Paso coin dealer and one-time A.N.A.
president L. (or Lyman) W. Hoffecker. Hoffecker is credited
with having created the designs for the issue, which were
modeled in plaster by the El Paso sculptor Edmund J. Senn.
Scarcely more than 10,000 examples were issued, and as a
result, the 1935 Old Spanish Trail is much scarcer and more
expensive than most other commemorative half dollar
design types.
2374 1925 Stone Mountain Memorial. MS-67 (PCGS). CAC.
Frames of golden-russet peripheral toning encircle virtually
brilliant centers, the color markedly bolder on the reverse.
Fully frosted and silky smooth throughout, this is a simply
outstanding example of a popular classic commemorative
type. This “memorial to the valor of the soldier of the south”
was designed by Gutzon Borglum who is best-known for
his magnificent creation at Mount Rushmore. The Stone
Mountain half dollar was struck first on January 21, 1925,
the anniversary of the birth of Confederate General Thomas
“Stonewall” Jackson’s birthday. The proceeds helped defray
the cost of the carving of Confederate soldiers on Stone
Mountain in Georgia, a project that was completed and
dedicated in 1970.
PCGS# 9378.
2375 1936-D Texas Independence Centennial. MS-67+ (PCGS).
CAC. Bursting with smooth, billowy mint frost, this
enchanting Superb Gem is at the threshold of numismatic
perfection. Delicate pastel iridescence on the obverse gives
way to much bolder, more irregular swirls of russet patina
on the reverse. Only 9,039 examples of this popular issue
were distributed. The models for this crowded yet attractive
design were prepared by Pompeo Coppini.
PCGS# 9387.
Commemorative Gold Coins
2376 1915-S Panama-Pacific Exposition Gold Dollar. MS-66
(NGC). Beautiful satin textured surfaces are also possessed
of smartly impressed devices and vivid medium gold color.
These pieces were struck at the San Francisco Mint for
distribution at the 1915 Panama-Pacific Exposition staged
in San Francisco. The number of different denominations
included in the Panama-Pacific series remains unmatched
by any other commemorative program since that time.
The denominations issued included the half dollar, gold
dollar, quarter eagle, and $50 gold (both round and
octagonal formats). The famous coin dealer, numismatic
author, and one-time ANA president Farran Zerbe had the
numismatic concession at the Exposition and was in charge
of distributing the Panama-Pacific coins. Only 15,000 of the
gold dollars were distributed.
PCGS# 7449.
PCGS# 9376.
Page 141
Popular 1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific Exposition
Round Format
2377 1915-S Panama-Pacific Exposition $50. Round. Unc Details—Improperly Cleaned (NGC). Warmly toned in dominant orangekhaki, the central obverse also reveals whispers of light rose iridescence as the coin rotates under a light. A touch of glossiness to the
texture notwithstanding, the stated impairment is hardly discernible for this boldly defined and overall attractive piece. The Round
$50 and Octagonal $50 were both designed by sculptor Robert Aitken. His initials RA are located below the branch. On both sides
of the octagonal coin, but not the round, are eight small dolphins tucked into the corners, otherwise the designs are identical other
than their exact size modified to fit on the existing planchets. The Round $50s and Octagonal $50s were authorized on January 16,
1915. The Round $50 had an authorized issue of 1,500 pieces, but only 483 were sold and the balance melted. As such this is one
of the rarest commemorative coins today based on the net mintage. The obverse depicts the head of Athena, wearing her Athenian
helmet tipped back on her head, with Roman date MCMXV on her shield. The reverse design has a large owl standing on a pine
tree branch, and given the style of cones used on the branch appears to be a Jeffery pine, which has this type of large size, shape and
tight seeds when growing. Sold at the Panama-Pacific Exposition in 1915, these coins were too expensive for all but the most well
to do for purchase given their issue price. Each $50 coin cost $100 to help offset the costs of production. Hence sales were slow and
less than half of the numbers struck were sold then, the balance unsold were all melted. Today these are one of the most sought after
issues, not only for their immense size and impressive devices, but their relentless solid market indicators as well. Although lightly
cleaned, this rarity will make a bold acquisition for the astute collector.
PCGS# 7451.
2378 1916 McKinley Memorial Gold Dollar. MS-66 (PCGS).
CAC. This delightful Gem is awash in billowy satin luster
and vivid golden-rose patina. A delightful example of the
first of two years of the design type, the sales proceeds of
which were earmarked for a memorial to the martyred
president in his home town of Niles, Ohio.
PCGS# 7454.
Satiny and smooth, this honey-rose example is solidly
graded at the Gem Mint State level. Struck in the fist of two
years of the design type, the proceeds for the issue were for a
memorial building dedicated in Niles, Ohio, the birthplace
of the assassinated president. The obverse design was by
Charles E. Barber and the reverse honors went to George T.
Morgan.
PCGS# 7454.
2380 1917 McKinley Memorial Gold Dollar. MS-66 (NGC).
CAC. Vivid rose-orange patina blends with vibrant satin
luster on both sides of this simply outstanding Gem. From
the second of two years of the type, and somewhat scarcer
than the 1916 issue. This beauty would make a splendid
companion for the impressive 1916 MS-66 example just
offered.
PCGS# 7455.
Page 142
Pattern and
Experimental Coins
2381 1922 Grant Memorial Gold Dollar. No Star. MS-67
(PCGS). CAC. OGH. Dressed in original and satiny
medium gold luster, this silky smooth Superb Gem would fit
comfortably into even the finest classic commemorative set.
Designed by Laura Gardin Fraser whose design also graced
the Grant half dollar issues of the date. If you seek the finest
coins available for your collection, you will do well to look
into this specimen — you won’t find a finer example in a
PCGS holder.
PCGS# 7458.
2384 1855 Pattern Flying Eagle Cent. Judd-168, Pollock-193.
Rarity-4. Bronze. Plain Edge. Proof-53 BN (NGC). Obv:
An eagle flies left with 13 stars around the border and the date
1855 below. Rev: The denomination ONE CENT is enclosed
by a laurel wreath with the legend UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA around the border. Handsome copper brown
patina blankets both sides of this boldly defined, minimally
worn specimen. The means by which Dr. Judd distinguished
between copper and bronze impressions from these dies
is not clear. By including separate listings for copper and
bronze, he may simply have been following the style used in
the Adams-Woodin pattern book published decades earlier
in 1913. It is the suspicion of the present cataloger (AWP),
that when Adams and Woodin listed “bronze,” they really
intended to signify “bronzed.” Copper (or copper alloy)
patterns produced during the era, were sometimes struck
on planchets that had been treated with bronzing powder
prior to striking (something that was also commonly done
with mint medals). Today, the use of the term “bronze,” as
it applies to patterns of the mid 19th century, is seemingly
divorced from any connection with bronzing powder;
attributions are likely made either as a result of spectral
analysis, or by making a “judgment call” i.e. guesswork on
the part of the numismatist performing the attribution.
PCGS# 11720.
2382 1922 Grant Memorial Gold Dollar. No Star. MS-66
(PCGS). Gorgeous medium gold surfaces are drenched in
smooth, billowy, satin textured luster. A delightful Gem
that is sure to please even the most discerning collector.
This variety was issued in connection with the centennial of
Ulysses S. Grant’s birth. The designs were created by Laura
Gardin Fraser, and closely match the those of the related half
dollars. Only 5,016 examples of the “No Star” variety were
issued. These pieces were evidently carefully handled by the
issuing committee, as most survivors are in the MS-63 to
MS-66 range, with the median grade being about MS-64+
or thereabouts.
PCGS# 7458.
2383 1926 Sesquicentennial of American Independence
Quarter Eagle. MS-65 (NGC). Gorgeous satin to softly
frosted, medium orange surfaces are uncommonly
smooth in an example of this conditionally challenging
commemorative type.
PCGS# 7466.
2385 1859 Pattern Half Dollar. Judd-235, Pollock-282.
Rarity-5. Silver. Reeded Edge. Proof-63 (PCGS). Obv:
Liberty is seated left supporting a faces with her right hand
and a shield with her left hand. Thirteen stars encircle the
periphery, the date 1859 is below, and an olive sprig and
three arrows are at the base of the shield. Rev: An eagle with
outstretched wings and a shield on its breast clutches a scroll
inscribed with the Latin motto E PLURIBUS UNUM in its
beak. The scroll is “perfect” (i.e., it is not “broken”). A group
of three arrows is in the eagle’s left talon and its right talon
clutches an olive branch. The legend UNITED STATES
OF AMERICA is inscribed along the upper border and
the denomination HALF DOLLAR is at the lower border.
Charming silver-gold surfaces are modestly reflective in
the fields with few readily evident handling marks. The
eye appeal alone is suggestive of a Choice Proof grade. The
designs are attributed to Mint engraver Anthony Paquet.
PCGS# 11960.
From our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of the Harry W. Bass, Jr. Collection, Part I, May 1999, lot 1160. Bass acquired the coin from Abe Kosoff
on August 3, 1971.
Page 143
2386 1865 Pattern Shield Nickel. Judd-417, Pollock-489.
Rarity-7-. Copper. Plain Edge. Proof-64 RD (PCGS).
CAC. The obverse and reverse designs are those of the
Shield nickel With Rays type, as adopted for regular-issue
production in 1866. Vibrant satin to semi-reflective surfaces
are further adorned with fully original, vivid rose color.
Fully struck, and highly appealing. Fewer than a dozen
examples of this rare Shield nickel pattern are thought to
exist. It is thought by some that this is a back-dated pattern
struck circa 1868, though the jury is still out on that one.
No matter the circumstances, this rarity will play well to an
audience of pattern specialists and Shield nickel enthusiasts
alike.
PCGS# 80599.
PCGS Population: just 1; with none finer.
2388 1868 Pattern Five Cents. Judd-628, Pollock-697.
Rarity-7+. Copper. Reeded Edge. Proof-65 RB (PCGS).
Obv: A bust of Liberty faces left with the legend UNITED
STATES OF AMERICA around the border and the date 1868
below. Liberty is wearing a coronet inscribed LIBERTY, and
the portrait is very similar to that used to strike regular-issue
nickel three-cent pieces. Rev: The denomination 5 CENTS
in the center with a laurel wreath around and the motto IN
GOD WE TRUST inscribed along the upper border. Struck
on a broad planchet. Satin to semi-reflective surfaces are
drenched in lovely orange-brown color. This rare pattern
was issued in three-piece sets along with a one-cent and
three-cent denomination. Only a half dozen or so examples
of Judd-628 are known.
PCGS# 70845.
2387 1868 Pattern Five Cents. Judd-623, Pollock-692. Rarity-6-.
Nickel. Plain Edge. Proof-65 Cameo (PCGS). CAC.
Secure Holder. Obv: Liberty head facing left with coronet
on which LIBERTY is inscribed in raised letters with no
star. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA surrounds with date
below. Rev:A large open laurel wreath with fruit, within
which is the denomination 5 / CENTS and above the motto
IN GOD WE TRUST in tiny letters. Struck on a broad nickel
planchet with wide rims to frame and protect the designs.
Classic nickel blue and gold wisps of toning shimmer across
reflective and frosty surfaces. Perhaps 25 to 30 examples of
this type exist today in all grades, and this beautiful Gem is
likely the finest known. A prize for the astute specialist.
PCGS# 411768.
PCGS Population: just 1; none finer in any designation.
2389 1868 Pattern Five Cents. Judd-633, Pollock-704. Rarity-4.
Nickel. Plain Edge. Proof-66 (PCGS). CAC. Obv: Similar
to that used for the regular issue three-cent nickel series
of 1866 to 1889, a bust of Liberty faces left with the legend
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA around the border and
the date 1868 below. Liberty is wearing a coronet inscribed
LIBERTY and ornamented with a single star, and the date is
set low in the field. Rev: A Roman numeral V is surrounded
by a laurel wreath with the motto IN GOD WE TRUST on a
scroll above. A small Maltese cross surmounts the scroll. This
uniformly semi-reflective specimen is further enhanced by
wisps of lovely gold and pale apricot iridescence. This design
type was issued in three-piece sets that also included a cent
and a three-cents of the same style.
PCGS# 60851.
Page 144
2390 1868 Pattern Liberty Seated Dime. Judd-641, Pollock-713.
Rarity-7-. Nickel. Reeded Edge. Proof-66 (NGC). Obv:
The same design that the Mint used to strike regular issue
Liberty Seated dimes, although with no date in exergue
below Liberty’s portrait. Rev: A six-pointed star, the
denomination ONE DIME and the date 1868 are enclosed
by a wreath of cereals. Lovely silver gray surfaces are bright,
fully struck and free of even the most trivial detractions.
One example of this rare pattern was tested and found to
have a metallic content of 24 percent nickel and 76 percent
copper. This coin has not been so tested that we are aware
of. The Mint was experimenting quite a bit during this era.
What is known is that this is a truly rare issue that is seldom
offered or seen. This is the finest example graded between
PCGS and NGC in the Proof category, but there is one
Cameo Proof certified by NGC at the PR-67 level finer. That
places this rarity as second finest seen for this rare Pattern
issue.
PCGS# 60859.
2392 1869 Pattern Dime. Judd-704, Pollock-783. Rarity-7-.
Copper. Reeded Edge. Proof-65 BN (NGC). CAC. Obv:
Standard Silver design with a right facing bust of Liberty
in the center, the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
above, and the motto IN GOD WE TRUST on a scroll
below. Liberty is wearing a diadem, and her hair is tied
in a bun. Rev: A wreath of oak and laurel surrounds the
denomination 10 CENTS with the inscription STANDARD
SILVER above and the date 1869 below. Beautiful copperrose surfaces are silky smooth in texture with vivid gold,
blue, and pink undertones. One of only three examples of
the variety certified by NGC, all of those Proof-65. Rare and
desirable, and important as well. The uspatterns.com website
notes: “The Standard Silver design. These were sold in sets
with the other designs and denominations for $15.” Perhaps
just a dozen or so examples of J-704 can be traced with any
certainty today.
PCGS# 60929.
NGC Census: 3; none finer. Two of the three are BN, the other is RD.
NGC Census: 1; none finer within the Proof designation.
Sparkling Cameo Proof 1869
Judd-770 Pattern Quarter Eagle
2391 1868 Pattern Liberty Seated Dime. Judd-641, Pollock-713.
Rarity-7-. Nickel. Reeded Edge. Proof-65 Cameo (PCGS).
CAC. Obv:The same design that the Mint used to strike
regular issue Liberty Seated dimes, although with no date in
exergue below Liberty’s portrait.Rev:A six-pointed star, the
denomination ONE DIME and the date 1868 are enclosed
by a wreath of cereals. Brilliant with excellent field to device
contrast, this smartly impressed and expertly preserved
Gem makes a strong visual impression in all regards. This
is the finest and only Cameo example seen by PCGS of this
Pattern issue, and there are no Deep (or Ultra) Cameo coins
reported by either grading service. One is noted finer in
the NGC Census, at the PR-67 Cameo level, another they
have seen is tied with this coin at PR-65 Cameo. While it
is impossible to claim which coin at the same grade level
is finer than another — without actually seeing both coins,
this offering is undoubtedly high in the Condition Census
for this rare and unusual Pattern issue.
PCGS# 507107.
PCGS Population: 1; none are finer in the Cameo designation.
2393 1869 Pattern Liberty Quarter Eagle. Judd-770,
Pollock-855. Rarity-7-. Aluminum. Reeded Edge.
Proof-64+ Cameo (PCGS). Regular dies trial striking of the
1869 Liberty quarter eagle. A beautiful specimen, both sides
exhibit bright silver gray color with strong field to device
contrast. The strike is uniformly bold throughout, and the
surfaces are expectably smooth and inviting at the nearGem grade level. A faint planchet drift mark (as struck) is
well concealed within the front of Liberty’s coronet, and we
mention it here solely for the sake of accuracy. This is the
only Cameo example certified by PCGS, and furthermore no
Deep Cameo coins of this Pattern issue have been certified
by that service. These rare aluminum Patterns were stuck for
collectors but in tiny quantities. Today there are between six
and ten known of this issue.
PCGS# 507363.
PCGS Population: only 1, with none finer in the Cameo designation.
Page 145
2394 1870 Pattern Dime. Judd-849, Pollock-956. Rarity-5.
Silver. Reeded Edge. Proof-65 (PCGS). Obv: Standard
Silver design with a right facing bust of Liberty as the
focal device. Liberty is wearing a headband ornamented
with a single star, and her hair is tied in a bun. The legend
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA encircles the periphery
and the motto IN GOD WE TRUST is inscribed on a
scroll below. Rev: A wreath of cotton and corn encircles
the denomination 10 CENTS and the date 1870, with the
word STANDARD inscribed along the upper border. Pretty
olive-copper, antique gold, rose-copper and powder blue
iridescence blankets both sides of this vibrant, uniformly
mirrored, solidly graded Gem. Standard Silver patterns make
up one of the most extensive series of varieties in American
numismatics. Because of a lack of public confidence in
the U.S. economy following the outbreak of the Civil War,
silver coins stopped circulating in the eastern and midwestern portions of the United States. By 1869, when the
first Standard Silver patterns were produced, the situation
remained unresolved, and the public continued to rely on
fractional currency together with assorted bronze and nickel
coins to make change. One possible solution to the problem
was to retain the silver coinage alloy at the standard 0.900
fineness that had been in use for decades, but to reduce the
weight of the coins. By implementing this plan the intrinsic
value of the silver in each coin would become too low to
prompt hoarding by the public. In the end, the discovery of
new sources of silver such as the Comstock Lode in Nevada,
resulted in lower silver prices, and as a result, silver coins
started flooding back into circulation without any further
government action.
PCGS# 61093.
2395 1870 Pattern Half Dollar. Judd-939, Pollock-1052.
Rarity-5. Silver. Reeded Edge. Proof-61 (ANACS). OH.
Obv: Standard Silver design with a bust of Liberty facing
right, the legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA around
the border and the motto IN GOD WE TRUST on a scroll
below. Liberty is wearing a soft cap ornamented with two
stars, and a ribbon inscribed with the word LIBERTY in
incuse letters crosses her shoulder. The tip of Liberty’s cap
is under the middle of the second letter S in STATES, and
the tip of the bust is distant from the scroll. Rev: A wreath
of cotton and corn encircles the denomination 50 CENTS
and the date 1870 with the word STANDARD inscribed
along the upper border. Uniformly mirrored in finish,
if a bit muted from a light cleaning, this piece is brilliant
apart from delicate orange-gold peripheral highlights.The
Standard Silver issues cover several denominations and
make for a fascinating collection. Most of the varieties are
available with patience and only a few are rare enough that
they present a serious acquisition problem, but then, that’s
the fun and challenge of numismatics. The present pattern,
moderately scarce, can serve as a grand introduction to the
fascinating discipline of pattern coins.
Rarity-7-. Aluminum. Plain Edge. Proof-65 (PCGS).
CAC. Obv: A bust of Liberty faces left with the legend
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA around the border and
the date 1871 below. Liberty is wearing a coronet inscribed
LIBERTY. Rev: The denomination V CENTS is centered
within a laurel wreath, with the Roman numeral V reversed.
Fully struck and satiny in texture, the devices of this gorgeous
Gem contrast nicely with semi-reflective fields. Fewer than a
dozen examples are known of this popular five-cents pattern
in aluminum.
PCGS# 61311.
PCGS Population: just 1; 1 finer in Proof-66.
Rarity-7-. Aluminum. Plain Edge. Proof-65+ Cameo
(PCGS). CAC. Obv: A bust of Liberty faces left with the
legend UNITED STATES OF AMERICA above and the date
1871 below, the date is high with the first 1 nearly touching
the base of Liberty’s bust, and the portrait is similar to
that used on regular issue nickel three-cent pieces. Rev: A
laurel wreath surrounds the denomination 5 CENTS. This
brilliant, pristine-looking specimen exhibits strong field to
device contrast on both sides. This is a truly rare issue with
about 10 known, this is the finest seen by PCGS, and the
only one to exhibit the Cameo contrast, there are no Deep
Cameo examples certified by that service of this Pattern.
This design explored the possibility to mimic the smaller
Three-cent Nickel coin with a close match to that obverse
design, the reverse offered a much larger than usually seen
(as no legends were included surrounding the wreath) open
wreath design with the denomination within the center so
it would be easy to differentiate between the 5 cent coin
and the 3 cent coin if this design had been adopted. An
important issue that relates to the Shield nickel through its
era of production, although the design remained unchanged
until 1883.
PCGS# 522774.
PCGS Population: just 1 in all grades with a CAM designation.
PCGS# 61185.
Page 146
Rare Copper Pattern
1875 Shield Nickel
The Finest Certified by PCGS
2398 1871 Pattern Quarter Dollar. Judd-1100, Pollock-1236.
Rarity-7-. Copper. Reeded Edge. Proof-64 RB (PCGS).
Obv: Liberty is seated left with 13 stars around the periphery
and the date 1871 below. Liberty is wearing a feathered
headdress, her left hand rests atop a globe inscribed
LIBERTY, and with her right hand she supports a liberty
pole. A pair of flags are behind the portrait. Rev: The same
design that the Mint used to strike regular issue Liberty
Seated quarters of the Motto type. Uniformly reflective in
finish with razor sharp devices, this fully original piece is
awash in a blend of vivid salmon pink, pale apricot, glossy
copper and steel gray colors. Probably 10 to 12 specimens
exist in all with at least two or three examples impounded in
major museum collections. The obverse is a version of James
B. Longacre’s Indian Princess design, which made its first
appearance in a Mint sketch book no later than 1852, but
which did not make a debut on a pattern coin — so far as we
are aware — until 1870, a year following Longacre’s death.
The Indian Princess motif appeared on several different
pattern varieties up through 1873, but was never adopted
for use on U.S. regular-issue coinage.
Rarity-7+. Copper. Plain Edge. Proof-65 RD (PCGS).
Struck from regular issue dies of the 1875 Shield nickel.
Beautiful reddish-orange surfaces are semi reflective in the
fields with satiny, razor sharp devices. A greatly prized rarity
among pattern specialists, this variety is seldom offered for
public sale. The uspatterns.com website notes: “Although
called regular dies trial; pieces, these were more likely
deliberately struck for sale to collectors as part of complete
off-metal sets. The presently offered example of this rarity is
the finest certified by PCGS within any color designation,
something worth considering when planning your bidding
activity.
PCGS# 81694.
PCGS Population: just 1; none finer.
PCGS# 71359.
2399 1871 Pattern Liberty Half Eagle. Judd-1170,
Pollock-1312. Rarity-7+. Copper. Reeded Edge. Proof-65
RB (PCGS). Regular dies trial striking of the 1871 Liberty
half eagle. Gorgeous copper-rose surfaces reveal more vivid
undertones as the coin dips into a light. A no questions Gem,
this endearing specimen is fully struck, carefully preserved
and appreciably reflective in the fields. Presumably this was
once part of a complete Proof set struck in copper, possibly
produced at the behest a Treasury secretary, Mint director,
or some other high ranking public official. The manufacture
of complete off-metal Proof sets commenced no later than
1867, and these were generally produced in extremely small
numbers.
Rarity-7-. Copper. Plain Edge. Proof-66 RB (PCGS). Obv:
Very similar to that of the regular-issue Shield nickel design
of 1882, although without the ornamental ball at the base of
the shield. Rev: The same design that the Mint used to strike
regular-issue 1882 Shield nickels. Struck on a thick planchet.
Blended reddish-orange color and glossy brown iridescence
provide strong eye appeal for this exquisite Gem. Fewer
than a dozen examples of this rare pattern issue are known.
PCGS# 72099.
PCGS Population: just 1; and none are finer in any category.
PCGS# 71433.
PCGS Population: 1; none finer within any designation.
Page 147
Undated (1857) Uniface Pattern Liberty Quarter Eagle
Rare White Metal Splasher
2402 Undated (1857) Pattern Liberty Quarter Eagle Uniface Obverse Die Trial Splasher. Judd-A1857-3, Pollock-3140. Rarity-8.
White Metal. MS-65 (PCGS). Secure Holder. A bust of Liberty faces left with 13 stars arranged around the border. Liberty is
wearing a coronet inscribed LIBERTY, and the design is virtually identical to that which the Mint used to strike regular issue nickel
three-cent pieces. Uniform silver-gray surfaces with a little bit of paper adhering to the central reverse, as made. This rarity from
Judd’s Appendix A listings is a classic example of Mint technology and the use of lead “splashers” for new designs — they are known
in many denominations and dates, especially from the mid-to-late 1800s. The present Gem examples comes to us through a series
of collectors who evidently treated this piece with the proverbial kid gloves as soon as it was received at the Mint, and then handled
likewise down through the ages to collectors today. The present Gem is the only example of the issue certified by PCGS within any
designation or grade; it is also the Plate Coin for the 10th Edition of the Judd reference. Have at it, specialists, and may the most
sincere bidder win.
PCGS# 20032.
PCGS Population: just 1 in all grades.
The plate coin for the type in the 10th edition of the Judd pattern reference.
Possibly Unique Undated (1863) Pattern Two-Cents
Rare White Metal Splasher
2403 Undated (1863) Pattern Two-Cent Piece Uniface Obverse Die Trial Splasher. Judd-A1863-1, Pollock-3257. Unique (?). White
Metal. MS-64 (PCGS). Secure Holder. The design is similar to that of the regular issue two-cent piece, although the motto reads
GOD OUR TRUST and there is no date below the shield. Handsome silver gray surfaces are just a few stray carbon flecks away from
an even higher grade. This “splasher” — a uniface impression from a die that is usually struck in soft metal — is considered unique
by many specialists today. Indeed, it is the only example of the variety listed by PCGS within any grade, and is the Plate Coin in the
110th edition of the Judd reference. This prized rarity should be the focal point of lively bidding activity when it enters the auction
arena.
PCGS# 20036.
PCGS Population: 1; no others in any grade.
The plate coin for the type in the 10th edition of the Judd pattern reference.
Page 148
2404 1803 “Half Eagle” Kettle Token. Judd C1803-3, Pollock-8020. Brass. Plain Edge. VF-35 (PCGS). Obv: Similar to that of the regular
issue 1803 Capped Bust Right half eagle, with the name KETTLE faintly visible among the border after the date. Rev: Also similar to that
of the regular issue 1803 Capped Bust Right half eagle. This is one of the best produced, most attractive examples of the type that this
cataloger (JLA) has handled in a number of years. Both sides are overall boldly defined with richly original, brassy-gold color to smooth,
distraction free surfaces. Worthy of a premium bid. These are scarce and highly collectible today.
PCGS# 515881.
 International Nickel Company (Inco.) Patterns
D
By Andrew W. Pollock III
ue to rising silver bullion prices in the early 1960s, it was anticipated that the intrinsic value of the silver in dimes, quarters, and half dollars would soon exceed the face value of the coins. In response to this concern, the U.S. Mint and some major corporations undertook to
find a suitable substitute for silver, and with that objective produced experimental pieces to test the characteristics of numerous different
metals and alloys. When I wrote United States Patterns and Related Issues back in 1994, I listed literally dozens of different varieties made in connection with the 1964 coinage-metal research program. All of these private patterns -- so far as we were aware -- were issued by the International
Nickel Company, DuPont, and Corning Glass Works.
Corning Glass Works. One of the most interesting varieties that I had the privilege to study and catalog was a half dollar pattern produced
by Corning Glass Works using a material described as “clear photochromic glass”. The company produced transparent glass disks that included a
chemical matrix capable of becoming translucent white when photographically developed using the company’s technology. The design was made
in similitude to the obverse of a 1964 Kennedy half dollar. A survivor of the variety was offered in our Brooks Collection sale of June 1989.
DuPont. DuPont produced a half dozen or more varieties of test pieces. Some of DuPont’s varieties were struck from dies that had originally
been used for the manufacture of quarter-dollar-sized medals and tokens. The dies were presumably supplied by a novelty company, but no specific
details come to hand. All the DuPont varieties known in 1994 were made using sandwich metal planchets. The planchet stock was produced using
a special process which employed explosives to forcible bond the different layers of metal. It’s possible that the experimental nature of some of these
varieties would never have been recorded apart from the research efforts of the late Jules Reiver and Kenn Henderson, both of whom are worthy of
deep gratitude from the numismatic community.
International Nickel Company (Inco.): By far, the greatest number of pattern varieties was produced by the International Nickel Company.
Literally dozens of varieties have been described based on differences in design, composition, and size of module. Most of the listings in U.S. Patterns and Related Issues were based on material in the National Numismatic Collection at the Smithsonian Institution, but in the years subsequent
to 1994, at least one additional major collection of Inco test pieces came to light. Most of our historical background knowledge about Inco’s involvement in the 1964 coinage-alloy research program originated with Kenn Henderson, who worked for the company at that time. Henderson penned
articles on the topic that were published in Coin World in 1985 and 1993.
The private pattern issues of 1964 are as fascinating now as they were when they were first produced. Unlike federal patterns which often sell for
four-figure amounts or more, it’s likely that many Inco pattern varieties will cross the auction block for just a few hundred dollars each despite the
fact that they helped us to chronicle one of the most important events in U.S. economic history -- the abandonment of silver as a circulating coinage
metal. The present offering is the largest we have had the pleasure to handle. While it includes numerous examples of the “quarter” size pieces, the
two “dimes” are very rare and the “half dollar” is the only one we have ever seen.
Dr. Paul D. Merica, who is portrayed on many Inco patterns in the following lots, was born in Warsaw, Indiana in 1889, received a bachelor’s
degree in 1908 from the University of Wisconsin, and a Ph.D in 1914 from the University of Berlin. In 1919 he was employed by the International
Nickel Company, where he remained for 38 years. He rose up through the company ranks to become the president of the firm in 1952. During his
career he was presented with several different gold and platinum medals of professional societies for his achievements. In 1942 he was elected to
membership in the National Academy of Sciences. He died in 1957.
Page 149
2405 1964 International Nickel Company Pattern “Dime.”
Judd-Unlisted, Pollock-5335. 95% Nickel, 5% Silicon on
a Permalloy Core. Plain Edge. MS-65 (NGC). Obv: Large
bust of Dr. Paul D. Merica faces right with the inscription
PAUL D. MERICA above and the word LABORATORY
below. The truncation of the bust is close to the word
LABORATORY, and the top of the portrait nearly touches
the letter M in MERICA. Rev: An aerial view of the Paul D.
Merica Laboratory at Sterling Forest, New York dominates
the design with the inscription INTERNATIONAL NICKEL
COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. With satiny
medium gray surfaces.
2406 1964 International Nickel Company Pattern “Dime.”
Judd-Unlisted, Pollock-5335. 95% Nickel, 5% Silicon
on a Permalloy Core. Plain Edge. MS-60 PVC Residue
(Uncertified). Obv:Large bust of Dr. Paul D. Merica
faces right with the inscription PAUL D. MERICA above
and the word LABORATORY below. The truncation of
the bust is close to the word LABORATORY, and the top
of the portrait nearly touches the letter M in MERICA.
Rev:An aerial view of the Paul D. Merica Laboratory at
Sterling Forest, New York dominates the design with the
inscription INTERNATIONAL NICKEL COMPANY
INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. With number 098-22 in
the right obverse field. This is a brilliant, satiny piece that
is of virtual Choice quality apart from a small spot of PVC
residue on the top of the obverse portrait.
2407 1964 International Nickel Company Pattern “Quarter.”
a Permalloy Core. Plain Edge. MS-66 (NGC). Obv:Large
the letter M in MERICA.Rev:An aerial view of the Paul D.
COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. This satiny,
almost matte-like Gem offers exceptional eye appeal for the
type.
Page 150
COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. Satin to
matte-like surfaces are untoned, although a faint planchet
streak (as made) is present at the left reverse border.
the design with the inscription INTERNATIONAL
NICKEL COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around.
Lovely matte-gray surfaces are free of both toning and grade
limiting blemishes.
This handsome matte-gray Gem is just one or two trivial
blemishes away from an even higher grade.
Matte-like satin luster greets the viewer from both sides of
this handsome steel gray example.
COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. Satin to
matte in texture, both sides of this medium gray example
are expectably smooth at the Gem grade level.
COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. This silver
gray Gem is boldly struck for the type with pleasing,
outwardly smooth surfaces.
COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. Appealing
medium gray features are well struck for the type and free of
troublesome blemishes.
COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. A few stray
abrasions are all that seem to preclude an even higher grade
for this matte textured, silver gray piece.
COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. A few faint
flyspecks on the reverse are all that seem to preclude a full
Gem rating for this matte-gray example.
COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. Pleasing
medium gray surfaces are free of significant blemishes.
COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. This matte
textured near-Gem exhibits subtle rose-russet highlights
around the peripheries.
Judd-Unlisted, Pollock-5350. Nickel (magnetic). Plain
Edge. MS-67 (NGC). Obv:Large bust of Dr. Paul D. Merica
inscription INTERNATIONAL NICKEL COMPANY INC.
DEDICATED 1964 around. With number 11-14 in the right
obverse field. Exquisite bright silver surfaces are satin to
matte like in texture with not so much as a single detracting
blemish to report.
DEDICATED 1964 around. With number 11-14 in the right
obverse field. Bright satiny surfaces are free of both toning
and grade limiting blemishes.
DEDICATED 1964 around. With number 11-14 in the
right obverse field. Lively satin to matte-like surfaces are
expectably distraction free at the premium Gem grade level.
Page 151
2422 1964 International Nickel Company Pattern “Quarter.” Judd-Unlisted, Pollock-5350. Nickel (magnetic). Plain Edge. MS-65 (NGC).
Obv:Large bust of Dr. Paul D. Merica faces right with the inscription PAUL D. MERICA above and the word LABORATORY below. The
truncation of the bust is close to the word LABORATORY, and the top of the portrait nearly touches the letter M in MERICA.Rev:An
aerial view of the Paul D. Merica Laboratory at Sterling Forest, New York dominates the design with the inscription INTERNATIONAL
NICKEL COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. With number 11-14 in the right obverse. A satiny, silver gray example with a
lovely appearance in all regards.
NICKEL COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. With number 11-14 in the right obverse field. lively satin to matte-like surfaces
are boldly struck with solid Gem quality.
NICKEL COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. With number 11-14 in the right obverse field. Appealing silver gray surfaces.
2425 1964 International Nickel Company Pattern “Half Dollar.” Judd-Unlisted, Pollock-5375. 95% Nickel, 5% Silicon on a Permalloy Core.
Plain Edge. MS-64 (NGC). Obv:Large bust of Dr. Paul D. Merica faces right with the inscription PAUL D. MERICA above and the word
LABORATORY below. The truncation of the bust is close to the word LABORATORY, and the top of the portrait nearly touches the letter
M in MERICA.Rev:An aerial view of the Paul D. Merica Laboratory at Sterling Forest, New York dominates the design with the inscription
INTERNATIONAL NICKEL COMPANY INC. DEDICATED 1964 around. With number 101-12 in the right obverse field. The texture of
this silver gray example alternates between semi-matte and brighter satin qualities, with all areas equally free of significant blemishes.
Private and Territorial Gold Coins and Related
2426 Undated (1837-1842) Christopher Bechtler $1. K-4. Rarity-4. 28.G., N Reversed. AU Details—Damage (PCGS). This piece presents
remarkably well given the stated impairment, the surfaces overall smooth in outward appearance. Rich khaki-gold, pale copper and
powder blue toning greets the viewer from both side and accents sharply impressed devices. The damage referred to on the PCGS insert
is actually quite minor and takes the form of a few tiny digs and shallow indents in the fields around the central devices. These early gold
coins tended to circulate hard and their soft gold surfaces often show varying degrees of impairments. This example is certainly nicer
than many seen, and deserves a respected place in a territorial gold collection.
PCGS# 10055.
2427 Undated (1837-1842) Christopher Bechtler $1. K-4. Rarity-4. 28.G., N Reversed. EF Details—Damaged (NGC). Otherwise khaki
gold surfaces are further accented with outlines of copper-russet in the protected areas around the devices. All design elements are at
least discernible, although this piece has been bent and straightened, and it also reveals several scratches and surface digs. Gold is a
soft metal compared to most others and is usually alloyed with copper or silver to help strengthen the planchet. Many of these smaller,
thinner gold coins have been bent by the vicissitudes of circulation, and this is a fairly common occurrence for this issue. Scarce and
historic.
PCGS# 10055.
Page 152
Mint State Christopher Bechtler $2.50 Gold
Among the Finest Certified
2428 Undated (1837-1842) Christopher Bechtler $2.50. K-13. Rarity-6. 70.G., 20 CARATS. MS-62 (NGC). Satiny in texture with
modest semi-reflective tendencies evident at more direct light angles, this handsome piece is evenly toned in vivid khaki-gold. The
lettering and numerals are crisply executed, and the surfaces are uncommonly smooth in outward appearance at the BU grade level.
Christopher Bechtler and his son Augustus and nephew Christopher, Jr. operated their own private mint in Rutherfordton, North
Carolina from 1830 to 1852. The coins were struck at two sites, one at their home in Rutherfordton and another near their mine
just north of town. They also produced the United States’ first gold dollar in 1831. Originally housed at the American Numismatic
Society Museum, the coin press and several of the dies are currently on display at the Bechtler House Museum in Rutherfordton. An
interesting aspect to this particular $2.50 variety is the use of an inverted V for A in the legend. Bechtler’s gold coinage circulated
widely in the South for decades. As a consequence, most specimens seen are worn to one degree or another, making this example
especially desirable. An excellent opportunity to add one of the finest known for the type to an advanced Territorial gold collection.
PCGS# 10070.
NGC Census: just 6; none finer at this service.
2429 Undated (1837-1842) Christopher Bechtler $5. K-20.
Rarity-4. 134.G., 21 CARATS, With Star. AU Details—
Planchet Flaw (PCGS). Handsome surfaces exhibit full
originality in the form of warm olive-gold patina. Well defined
with satiny texture and no singularly mentionable abrasions, a
prominent planchet flaw is evident in the upper obverse field.
These early pieces were made with local native gold, and on
this particular one there was a minor flaw in the gold which
caused the lamination. These are commonly seen on all types
of coins, especially so when various metals are mixed together.
They are mint caused and should not diminish the value of the
coin significantly. This is a scarce and desirable issue for the
Territorial gold specialist, made even more so by what appears
to be partial reeding around the edge of the coin. Whether this
feature is as struck or represents some form of post-striking
damage we leave to bidders to decide.
2430 Undated (1842-1852) August Bechtler $1. K-24. Rarity-3.
27.G., 21.C., Plain Edge. Unc Details—Bent (PCGS).
This vibrant, lustrous piece exhibits a lovely satin to semireflective finish on both sides. Blended olive-khaki and
pinkish-copper patina is also a strong suit, while a bisecting
bend has been rather expertly straightened, it is still readily
evident on both sides. These thin planchets were susceptible
to bends or similar problems and many surviving examples
exhibit such evidence. Nevertheless, the general charm and
appeal is intact and this is a scarce early territorial gold issue.
PCGS# 10040.
PCGS# 10097.
Page 153
2431 1849 Moffat & Co. $5. K-4a. Rarity-4. VF Details—Damage (PCGS). This piece is softly defined over the top of the obverse portrait,
although the detail is much bolder elsewhere, especially throughout the reverse eagle. Matte like medium gold surfaces are suggestive of
a cleaning, and several prominent scratches are also noted for both sides. This is an early territorial gold issue that was struck from the
initial findings of gold from the California Gold Rush. In 1849 people flocked to the gold fields and streams in search of riches, some were
lucky and found more than their share, others did not. Those that came in 1849 had the best chance of finding riches, but soon the word
got out and the Gold Rush was in full force. Here is a coin that captures that magic year, struck soon after the initial discovery of gold in
1848 at Sutter’s Mill that started this epic event in our history.
PCGS# 10240.
Early Gold Rush Era 1849
Moffat & Co., TEN DOL. Gold Piece
2432 1849 Moffat & Co. $10. K-6a. Rarity-5+. TEN DOL. AU-53 (NGC). Uncommonly well defined for the type, the remaining detail
is particularly sharp over the obverse stars and throughout much of the eagle’s plumage on the reverse. Attractively toned in vivid
copper-gold, as well, with ample evidence of a satin finish. A minimally abraded, minimally worn survivor that would make an
impressive addition to a collection of California Pioneer gold. While Moffat & Co., was not the first mining establishment in the
early Gold Rush days in California, they were certainly the most important in California private gold minting. Their reputation
was outstanding, well deserved, and carefully retained through this tumultuous era. The Moffat partners arrived in San Francisco
by June of 1849 and opened for business, smelting gold dust and ore and making it first into small ingots, then into coins like this
handsome $10 eagle. Today survivors are rarely seen at all, especially this wholesome and attractive. The acquisition of a Moffat &
Co., gold coin represents one of the most important cornerstones of any advanced Territorial gold collection so these 1849 dated
$10 gold pieces have always been sought after by numismatists. There simply are not many around these days in collectible grades,
as most were melted as the San Francisco Mint became a reality starting in 1854.
PCGS# 10246.
NGC Census: 2; 7 are finer (About Uncirculated-58 finest).
2433 1852/1 Augustus Humbert $20. Gold. K-9. Rarity-6. VF Details—Smoothed (PCGS). Handsome khaki-orange patina shines forth
from both sides and enhances the eye appeal of this boldly defined mid grade survivor. A bit glossy in texture, yet free of individually
mentionable abrasions apart from a few small ticks in and around the centers. There are not many of these that survive at all, let alone
in a relatively high grade like Very Fine. Despite a long ago enhancement the devices have a lot to offer, and this is a historic rarity that
is seldom at any level of preservation. One of the most sought after issues from the Territorial era, and a coin that is certain to find an
honored place within an advanced collection.
PCGS# 10193.
Page 154
Rare High Grade and Wholesome 1853
United States Assay Office of Gold $20
884 THOUS Variety
2434 1853 United States Assay Office of Gold $20. K-17. Rarity-7-. 884 THOUS. AU-58 (PCGS). Vivid copper-rose highlights are
splashed about on both sides of this otherwise deeply toned, olive-orange example. The most vivid color is evident at the borders,
but the strike is equally sharp — and impressively so — throughout. Minimally abraded for the type with considerable satiny luster
remaining, this lovely near-Mint survivor is sure to be of keen interest to advanced Territorial gold collectors. PCGS in all its years
of certifying coins records a mere 15 grading events for this issue, in all grades. That provides some guidance as to the likely rarity
of this prized issue. These were struck by the official United States Assay Office of Gold in San Francisco, although not enough were
coined to meet the demand in the burgeoning community of San Francisco, which was all wrapped up in the Gold Rush at this
time. Hence, after some delays the San Francisco Mint opened the following year, and after a few more bumps in the road the West’s
demand for coinage began to be met. This is an important, and quite rare, example of one of the interim solutions for coinage that
represents this historic territorial gold era.
PCGS# 10010.
PCGS Population: 1; 5 are finer (Mint State-63 finest) within the .884 designation.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Previously purchased from us (Stack’s) on March 15, 2007.
Lovely Very Choice AU 1853
United States Assay Office 900 THOUS $20 Gold Coin
2435 1853 United States Assay Office of Gold $20. K-18. Rarity-2. 900 THOUS. AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. OGH. Sharply defined in virtually
all areas, and uncommonly so for the type, this delightful piece also sports original honey-rose patina and overall lustrous surfaces. A
strong candidate to represent the coinage of the U.S. Assay Office of Gold under Curtis, Perry and Ward in a type set of Territorial gold.
Coinage of these twenty dollar coins continued with the flow of gold coming into San Francisco from the surrounding hills and streams.
These double eagles were accepted as custom payments at full value, and they circulated widely. However, the San Francisco Mint began
operations the following year, and this event began the rapid wind down of the Territorial gold issues in that area over the next few
years. Most of the territorial gold coins were gathered up and melted, greatly reducing the stock available for collectors today. Here is an
outstanding example that will add depth to any advanced collection.
PCGS# 10013.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Superior’s sale of February 2001, lot 4752.
Page 155
High Grade 1851 Baldwin & Co. $10 Gold Piece
2436 1851 Baldwin & Co. $10. K-4. Rarity-6+. AU Details—Tooled (PCGS). This is an extremely interesting piece, representing as it does
the latest die state for an 1851 Baldwin & Co. $10 that this cataloger (JLA) has ever handled. On the obverse, a prominent, sizeable cud
die break (as made) joins star 4 to the adjacent border area. Apart from characteristic softness of strike in the centers, this piece is boldly
defined in all areas with little to report in the way of actual wear. While there are no distracting abrasions, a glossy texture and smoothing
to the surfaces are noted for accuracy. This is one of the rarest of the early Territorial gold coins. Most come with soft strikes and are
frequently encountered with surface problems. In this particular case, the surface problems were lightly smoothed down, a common
event on these prized rarities today. Most of course were melted soon after they were struck. It is interesting to notice this very late die
state, which also accounts for their limited issue at the time these were struck. Destined to be a major highlight of an advanced Territorial
gold collection and a prize that is rarely offered in any grade.
PCGS# 10031.
Important Mint State 1854
Kellogg & Co. Twenty-Dollar Gold
2437 1854 Kellogg & Co. $20. K-1b. Rarity-5. Short Arrows. MS-60 (PCGS). This intricately defined piece exhibits exceptionally full
striking detail in a Territorial gold coin irrespective of type or issuer. Liberty’s hair curls and the star centrils are equally sharp on
the obverse, as are the eagle’s neck, tail and wing feathers on the reverse. Vibrant satin to semi-reflective luster greets the viewer
from both sides, and it is fully appreciable in the absence of singularly distracting abrasions. The surfaces are uncommonly smooth
for the assigned grade, in fact, and vivid honey-yellow color is also worthy of praise. When the U.S. Assay Office of Gold shut down
in December 1853, the new San Francisco Mint had not yet started coin production. John G. Kellogg helped fill the gap by striking
twenty-dollar gold pieces in 1854. The coins were an immediate success with the contemporary public and today the vast majority
of pieces extant are well worn, if not impaired. K-1b is somewhat scarcer among the 1854 varieties, and a Mint State coin of any
die marriage with this kind of quality and strike represents an important bidding opportunity for the advanced Territorial gold
collector.
PCGS# 10222.
PCGS Population: 2; 9 finer
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of January 2003, lot 2640.
Page 156
Lustrous 1855
Kellogg & Co. Twenty
Elusive 1849 Mormon
$2.50 Gold Piece
2438 1855 Kellogg & Co. $20. K-3. Rarity-4. Long Arrows.
AU-55 (PCGS). OGH. With razor sharp definition
and no readily evident wear, this coin has the “look” of
a Mint State grade. Liberty’s hair curls and the eagle’s
feathers are exceptionally crisp and fully delineated.
There is perhaps a trace of friction in the fields and
over the some of the obverse stars, but the luster
remains virtually full in a satiny, almost matte-like
texture. Otherwise free of sizeable abrasions, a pair of
minor reeding marks on the obverse around star 13
are noted solely for accuracy. Kellogg & Co. produced
some 300,000 $20 gold pieces in total, according to
Don Kagin. Once the San Francisco Mint was in
full operation, the public’s preference was given to
the Treasury’s product and most privately minted
Territorial gold coins were melted and recoined by the
Mint. What few that remain are worn; in fact PCGS
has only graded two Mint State 1855 Kellogg $20
gold pieces of any variety. A lovely piece, and a strong
candidate for inclusion in a high grade, high quality
type set of Territorial gold coinage.
2439 1849 Mormon $2.50. K-1. Rarity-5+. VF Details—
Tooled (PCGS). This is a well balanced piece with
even medium gold patina and bold to sharp definition
throughout the design. As there are no significant
abrasions, the light to moderate tooling in and around
the centers was probably done to efface detracting
marks. These early Mormon issues were struck
under the authority of the Mormon Church in Utah
beginning in 1849. The obverse states TO THE LORD
HOLINESS around, the central device is a Phrygian
cap or miter (the emblem of the Mormon priesthood)
with the all seeing eye of Jehovah below. For the
reverse the abbreviated capital letters G.S.L.C.P.G.
(Great Salt Lake City Pure Gold) surround two clasped
hands over the date 1849, with TWO. AND. HALF.
DO. below. The dies bulged early in the striking of
this limited issue, which is believed to have numbered
around 3,560 pieces. Today only 40 to 70 remain in all,
and these are in the first year of coinage production by
the Mormon Church. The Mormon gold coinage was
found to be debased below 90% pure gold, and once
specimens reached outsiders most were melted. Thus
surviving examples of this important issue are highly
prized by collectors today.
PCGS# 10225.
PCGS Population: 10; only 5 finer.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. From our (Stack’s) sale
of July 2008, lot 2253.
PCGS# 10259.
Page 157
Impressive Choice AU
1861 Clark, Gruber & Co.
$10 Gold
Hawaiian Coins, Medals,
Tokens and Related
2442 1847 Hawaii Cent. Medcalf-Russell 2CC-2. Crosslet 4,
15 Berries. MS-63 BN (PCGS). OGH. Handsome copperrose patina greets the viewer from both sides of this fully
original, nicely preserved piece. The copper cent coinage of
the Hawaiian Islands occurred in just 1847, and there are
several die varieties for the mintage. Coinage would not be
forthcoming for Hawaii again until 1883, at which time only
silver dimes, quarters, half dollars, and dollars were struck
to the combined total of $1 million.
PCGS# 10965.
2440 1861 Clark, Gruber & Co. $10. K-7. Rarity-4. AU55 (PCGS). Bright and appealing yellow gold surfaces
are boldly defined for the type with no outwardly
distracting abrasions. Gently circulated for a brief time
and carefully preserved since the time of issue with a
whisper of wear on the highest points of the design
only. The surfaces are a delight to study and offer much
enjoyment for these unique designs that so closely
match a typical Liberty eagle of this era. These are
rarely encountered so well preserved as most entered
circulation and stayed there, or were later melted
down. Hence their relative scarcity today — they
simply didn’t survive into the next generation in large
numbers. High grade, high appeal specimens like this
are in great demand, as the Colorado gold story had
a life of its own and deserves greater attention from
numismatists. Here is a classic relic from that period,
one that will be a welcome addition to any advanced
collection.
PCGS# 10141.
2443 1883 Hawaii Quarter Dollar. Medcalf-Russell 2CS-3. MS66 (PCGS). This undeniably original, expertly preserved
Gem exhibits mottled olive-russet patina to richly frosted
luster. Fully struck, smooth, and worthy of a strong bid in
all regards. Only 14,400 circulation strikes of the date were
produced in a year where the Philadelphia Mint had bigger
fish to fry, namely the Morgan dollar, of which more than 12
million coins were produced.
PCGS# 10987.
From our (Bowers and Merena’s) Estate of Abe Kosoff sale, November
2444 1883 Hawaii Dollar. Medcalf-Russell 2CS-5. AU-55
(NGC). Lustrous and boldly defined for the grade, splashes
of vivid blue, orange and pink peripheral toning further
enhance the visual appeal of this conditionally scarce Hawaii
dollar. The 1883 Hawaiian dollar or AKAHI DALA (one
dollar) was struck to the tune of 499,794 pieces, of which
more than 460,000 examples have been “redeemed” (mainly
melted in the early 1900s) leaving only a modest population
for today’s collectors with an interest in the coinage of
Hawaii.
PCGS# 10995.
2445 Complete Type Set of Regular Issue Kingdom of Hawaii
Coinage. (PCGS). OGH. Included are: 1847 cent, MedcalfRussell 2CC-6, Plain 4, 15 Berries, AU-53; 1883 ten cents,
Medcalf-Russell 2CS-1, AU-50; 1883 quarter, MedcalfRussell 2CS-3, AU-50; 1883 half dollar, Medcalf-Russell
2CS-4, AU-53; and 1883 dollar, Medcalf-Russell 2CS-5, AU53. The cent exhibits even medium copper patina while the
silver pieces are brilliant to lightly toned apart from a few
swirls of russet color on the reverse of the dollar. (Total: 5
coins)
Gold Nugget
2441 Natural Gold Nugget. 10.7 grams. 22 x 11.5 x 6.4 mm. A
lovely water-worn nugget with pleasing surfaces and a deep
honey patina. Small natural deposits seen in the recesses.
Accompanied by an old wrapper with the handwritten
inscription, “Gold Nugget / Alaska.”
Page 158
Gold Dollars
Rare Choice Mint State
1853-D Gold Dollar
2446 1849 Open Wreath, No L. MS-65 (PCGS). OGH.
Delectable satin surfaces are fully struck with vivid orangegold patina. An interesting die crack (as struck) bisects the
upper reverse through the digit 1 in the denomination.
Walter Breen enumerated several collectible varieties of
1849 gold dollars in his Complete Encyclopedia. Most of
these are quite distinctive and are noted in auction catalogs.
The “No L” ranks as one of the more popular varieties. It has
a separate listing in the Guide Book, and is recognized by
each of the two major certification services. Several hundred
Mint State examples of “No L” dollars likely exist, mostly in
the MS-62 to 64 range; fewer than 15% of those certified by
NGC grade MS-65 or finer.
PCGS# 7501.
2447 1849-O MS-62 (PCGS). OGH. Boldly defined with satiny
yellow gold luster, both sides of this appealing O-mint gold
dollar seem conservatively graded at the BU level. Current
population data suggest a Mint State supply of between
500 and 750 pieces, quite small in comparison with most
Philadelphia Mint issues of the same design type.
PCGS# 7508.
2449 1853-D MS-63 (NGC). This is a well produced
Dahlonega Mint gold coin, both sides displaying bold
to sharp definition over virtually all elements of the
design. Impressively preserved, as well, bright yellow
gold surfaces retain vibrant satin to semi-reflective
luster in the absence of significant abrasions. As
noted by noted expert Doug Winter, the 1853-D is
one of the rarest Type One Dahlonega gold dollars in
Mint State grades. Most the surviving examples are
worn from circulation, and few are seen that earn the
Choice designation as found here. With the growing
popularity of key date gold pieces, especially when
found in the top dozen known, there will be many
bidders ready to secure such a condition rarity as this
when it crosses the auction block.
PCGS# 7523.
2448 1853 MS-65 (PCGS). Satiny and smooth, this exceptionally
vivid Gem offers mottled reddish-rose reverse color to
otherwise pinkish-gold patina. Scarcely more than 5% of the
Mint State examples listed in the PCGS Population Report
PCGS# 7521.
2450 1855 Type II. MS-61 (PCGS). CAC. Satiny and minimally
abraded at the BU grade level, an uncommonly full strike
for the type is also an important attribute. An overlay of
exceptionally vivid reddish-rose and deep orange patina
completes the picture for this beautiful Type II gold dollar.
The 1855 is an eagerly-sought and desirable issue that
commands high premiums because of its three-year design
type status. Perhaps only 3,000 to 4,000 Mint State examples
can be accounted for in collections.
PCGS# 7532.
2451 1877 MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. This yellow gold beauty
displays bright reflective surfaces and excellent field to
device contrast. The original mintage of 3,900 pieces was
likely reduced to no more than 300-400 pieces. This Choice
example is quite pleasing and will charm any specialist into
bidding. Don’t miss out if you are seeking an example of this
issue.
PCGS# 7578.
Page 159
2452 1889 MS-66 (PCGS). Light yellow gold patina mingles with
satin to softly frosted luster on both sides of this exquisite
premium Gem. Coined during the final year of the design
type. No subsequent issues of gold dollars were ever
minted for circulation in the United States, although some
non-circulating commemoratives were issued in the 20th
century. Today, a few thousand Mint State 1889 gold dollars
still exist, including some nice Gem-quality pieces such as
offered here.
PCGS# 7590.
2453 1889 MS-65+ (NGC). CAC. Fully struck with delightful
pale rose color, this silky smooth example would accept
nothing less than a premium Gem grade. Lovely! The 1889
is the final issue of the design type and the denomination
(apart from some 20th-century commemoratives). An
excellent candidate from inclusion in either a superlative
type set or extraordinary specialized collection.
PCGS# 7590.
Quarter Eagles
Seldom Offered 1806/4 Stars
8x5 Quarter Eagle
2455 1832 BD-1, the only known dies. Rarity-4. AU Details—
Edge Damage (PCGS). Well defined for a lightly circulated
survivor of this challenging issue, both sides retain bold to
sharp definition in all but a few isolated areas. Otherwise
honey gold in color, whispers of more vivid reddish-russet
iridescence cling to the denticles and provide a visually
pleasing appearance. The stated impairment is minor and
easily overlooked, and there are no singularly mentionable
distractions to the surfaces save for two small swirls of PVC
residue on the obverse at and near star 2. Of the 4,400 pieces
originally struck for this year, only 80 to 100 coins exist today
from this meager beginning. The balance were melted long
ago, especially soon after these were struck when their gold
value exceeded their face value literally from the day they
were struck. Naturally, most were gathered up and melted
for the profit, forcing numismatists in this much later time
to compete heavily when one of these survivors appears on
the market. This example is desirable despite its minor flaw,
and should be considered if there is a desire to own one of
these prized rarities.
PCGS# 7672.
2454 1806/4 BD-1. Rarity-4+. Stars 8x5. AU Details—Repaired
(PCGS). Secure Holder. Boldly defined throughout
the obverse, the central reverse is softly struck due to a
concentration of vertical adjustment marks (as made)
in that area. Wear is minimal, however, as are singularly
distracting abrasions. The surfaces exhibit a curious glossy
to matte-like texture, although they have retoned rather
nicely in olive-gold (obverse) and honey-orange (reverse)
that enhances the overall eye appeal. This is a tough coin to
find in any grade at all, only 75 to 90 examples exist today
in all grades from the original mintage of 1,136 pieces. The
rarity of this particular should be put into perspective, its
actually one of the more available — relative to Capped Bust
Right quarter eagles, all of which can be considered rare by
most numismatic standards. Few collectors will have the
opportunity to own one of these today as they have been
priced accordingly for their rarity for many years.
PCGS# 7654.
2456 1842-D EF-45 (PCGS). This bright honey-gold example
exhibits a vibrant, satiny texture that is free of singularly
distracting abrasions. Boldly defined, especially for a lightly
circulated Dahlonega Mint quarter eagle, this piece is sure to
have no difficulty finding its way into a specialized collection
of Southern gold. This is a tough date and mint to find at
this grade level, as so few survived from the original mintage
of 4,643 pieces. Mint State coins are unknown according
to PCGS although NGC has graded a few that merit that
grade level. Perhaps the total known are limited to 80 pieces
(CoinFacts) or 125 to 135 pieces (Doug Winter). What is
clear is that this glowing 1842-D Liberty quarter eagle offers
an outstanding opportunity to represent this date and mint
in a major collection.
PCGS# 7725.
PCGS Population: 15; 23 finer (About Uncirculated-58 finest).
Page 160
2457 1842-O Winter-1, the only known dies—Reverse Die
Break on Rim @ 5 O’Clock—AU-55 (NGC). A series of
spindly die cracks through and around the letters MERIC
in AMERICA correspond to the late die state of the 1842O quarter eagle as known to Doug Winter (Gold Coins of
the New Orleans Mint: 1839-1909). The present example,
however, is an even later die state with a prominent reverse
rim cud outside the letters CA in AMERICA that extends
nearly to the letter D in the denomination. Light, even,
honey-olive patina flows over sharply defined, generally
satin-textured features. A reasonably scarce early issue from
the New Orleans Mint, but the really extraordinary feature
is the well developed rim cud on the reverse. The New
Orleans Mint really pressed their limited dies until they fell
apart, but undoubtedly precious few of these were produced
that show this advanced die state. A specialist’s delight, and
a difficult issue to locate as well preserved as Choice AU.
2460 1850-C EF-45 (PCGS). This pleasingly original, khaki-gold
survivor also offers uncommonly bold definition in a lightly
circulated C-mint quarter eagle. There are no singularly
distracting abrasions, and both the technical quality and
eye appeal are sure to endear this coin to Southern gold
specialists. The mintage at the Charlotte Mint was 9,148
pieces for the year. Only 150 to 175 survive today, a tiny
sum considering the number of date and mint collectors
combined with Charlotte Mint specialists who each seek
an example to represent this scarce issue. This specimen
will please any specialist for its high technical grade and
attractive surfaces.
PCGS# 7756.
PCGS# 7726.
2458 1845 MS-61 (NGC). Blushes of pale pink iridescence in
the fields enhance otherwise medium yellow gold surfaces.
This is a boldly to sharply struck example and, with no
singularly mentionable abrasions, both the eye appeal and
the technical quality are well above average for the assigned
grade. A pleasing Mint State survivor from a fairly modest
mintage for the era of 91,051 pieces. Typically served up
in VF and EF grades, at AU or finer the date is moderately
scarce.
PCGS# 7737.
2461 1850-D AU-50 (NGC). Warmly toned in honey-rose, both
sides of this important piece also offer uncommonly bold
definition in an 1850-D quarter eagle. Outwardly smooth
with no detracting abrasions, as well, there is much to
recommend this coin to the advanced Southern gold
collector. A modest mintage of 12,148 pieces for the year,
not many survived at all, especially so at this lofty grade
level. Scarce and desirable for the date and mint collector as
well as the Dahlonega specialist.
PCGS# 7757.
2459 1847-C AU-55 (PCGS). Bright yellow gold surfaces also
reveal warmer pale olive undertones as the surfaces turn
away from a direct light source. Uncommonly sharp for a
C-mint gold coin, with no particularly significant abrasions
to distract the eye. From a modest mintage of 23,226 pieces,
most of which saw heavy circulation in the commercial
areas around Charlotte. VF and EF coins abound for the
date, with AU and finer pieces marginally more difficult to
locate. Choice for the grade.
PCGS# 7745.
Page 161
2462 1857-S AU-58 (NGC). This sharply struck, crisply
delineated survivor exhibits vivid honey-orange patina to
both sides. Outwardly smooth with appreciable luster, there
is much to recommend this coin to the advanced collector
of Liberty gold. Despite a fairly generous mintage for the era
of 69,200 pieces, David Akers regarded the issue as scarce
in all grades and as rare in AU and finer condition when he
wrote his quarter eagle monograph back in 1975. Since that
time, the availability of the issue has seemingly increased;
perhaps additional specimens were found in overseas gold
reserves. Presently, it appears unlikely that more than 200 or
300 pieces can be accounted for in grades above EF.
2466 1896 Proof-62 (ANACS). OH. The satiny devices of this
yellow gold Proof elegantly juxtapose the deeply mirrored
fields throughout, imparting mild cameo contrast on the
reverse. Gorgeous to behold, and from a mintage of only
132 Proof quarter eagles for the date. While not the finest
survivor, this piece is certainly a visually appealing coin for
the assigned grade.
PCGS# 7922.
PCGS# 7785.
2463 1866-S AU-53 (NGC). Well-defined for a lightly circulated
survivor of this challenging issue, this vibrant honey-gold
example reveals only a few sizable abrasions from a short
stint in circulation. At 38,960 pieces, the San Francisco Mint
was the largest producer of quarter eagles of the year —
Philadelphia minted just 3,080 quarter eagles of the date.
PCGS# 7804.
2464 1870-S EF-40 (PCGS). CAC—Gold Label. Charming
honey-rose surfaces are boldly to sharply defined without
so much as a single detracting blemish. Suitably lustrous,
as well, and nicer even than many AU examples of this
conditionally challenging issue that we have handled over
the years. One of only 16,000 examples of the date struck,
with much of that number finding long and hard use in
commerce. The present piece is about typical for the issue,
though the presence of the CAC “gold bean” sticker should
alert our bidders to the overall quality of this top-notch EF40 1870-S quarter eagle.
PCGS# 7812.
2467 1897 Proof-62 Cameo (PCGS). CAC. This nicely contrasted
specimen combines fully impressed, satin textured devices
with deep pools of reflectivity in the fields. The color is an
original and attractive medium gold, and none of the grade
defining contact marks are sizeable enough to warrant
individual mention. From a paltry Proof mintage of just 136
pieces, the smallest production figure of any Proof quarter
eagle issue from 1897 through to 1913.
PCGS# 87923.
2468 1902 MS-65 (NGC). Handsome honey-gold patina mingles
with billowy mint luster on both sides of this razor sharp
Gem. The piece offered here ranks in the top 20% of all Mint
State examples certified by NGC.
PCGS# 7854.
2465 1877 MS-62 (NGC). This satiny and highly lustrous piece
also offers delightful color in bright pinkish-gold. Sharply
struck, minimally worn and with only small, wispy abrasions
that are well within the context of the assigned grade. The
1877 ranks as a scarce and desirable issue having a mintage
of just 1,632 pieces, one of the lowest production figure of
the design type. Perhaps only three or four dozen Mint State
examples still exist, with MS-62 being about average for the
group.
2469 1903 MS-67 (NGC). So smooth as to be virtually pristine,
this beautiful satin-finish Superb Gem also offers razor
sharp devices and vivid rose-orange patina. A gorgeous
Gem quarter eagle at every turn.
PCGS# 7855.
PCGS# 7826.
PCGS Population: 6; just 6 finer (MS-64 finest).
Page 162
2470 1903 MS-67 (NGC). Competing swirls of medium gold and
light orange patina adorn both sides of this silky smooth,
brightly lustrous Superb Gem. Right near the zenith of thirdparty grading results, this sparkling Gem quarter eagle has
Registry Set written all over it! (Figuratively, of course.)
PCGS# 7855.
2474 1908 MS-65+ (PCGS). CAC. Drenched in warm, satiny,
medium orange luster, this expertly preserved Gem is sure
to have no difficulty findings its way into a high quality type
or date set of 20th century U.S. gold. Barely more than 3% of
the 1908 quarter eagles certified by PCGS grade MS-65+ or
finer.
PCGS# 7939.
2471 1904 Proof-62 Cameo (PCGS). Vivid reddish-orange
patina greets the viewer from both sides of this charming
Proof two-and-a-half. Fully struck with bold cameo
contrast, the only grade defining contact mark of note is a
shallow graze on Liberty’s cheek. Notably, fewer than a third
of the Proof 1904 quarter eagles certified by PCGS have
been awarded the Cameo or Deep Cameo designation.
2475 1908 MS-65 (PCGS). Billowy satin to softly frosted luster
blends with gorgeous light khaki patina on both sides of this
delectable Gem. This example ranks way above average in
terms of available quality.
PCGS# 7939.
PCGS# 87930.
2472 1904 MS-65+ (NGC). CAC. With a razor sharp strike and
smooth, satiny, medium gold luster, this beautiful Gem is
seemingly earmarked for inclusion in a high grade gold type
set. MS-65 examples are in the top 20% of all Mint State
pieces certified by NGC, while those grading MS-65+ or
finer are in the top 10%.
PCGS# 7856.
2476 1909 MS-64 (NGC). Razor sharp in strike with original
khaki-olive patina, this outwardly smooth piece has the
“look” of an even higher grade.MS-64 examples are in
the top 20% of all Mint State pieces certified by NGC; the
median grade for Uncirculated specimens appears to be
MS-62 or thereabouts.
PCGS# 7940.
2473 1907 MS-67 (NGC). Delightful satin smooth surfaces are
drenched in a blend of vivid rose and orange-gold colors.
A fully struck, expertly preserved quarter eagle that would
accept nothing less than a Superb Gem rating. Very scarce
at the MS-67 level and extremely rare finer; barely more
than 2% of the examples certified by NGC could match the
quality offered here.
PCGS# 7859.
Page 163
Key Date 1911-D in
Choice Mint State
2477 1910 MS-65 (NGC). Lustrous, softly frosted surfaces also
possess attractive color in an original deep rose shade.
Sparkling Gem Mint State Indian quarter eagles never go
out of style and are frequent appointees to advanced type
sets. Just 14 grading eventsfor the date have been accorded
finer grades than the present beauty by NGC.
PCGS# 7941.
2478 1911 MS-65 (NGC). Gorgeous yellow gold surfaces are
drenched in billowy satin luster that accents a razor sharp
strike. A scarce and desirable issue at the MS-65 grade level
and extremely rare finer. Fewer than 2% of the Mint State
examples certified by NGC could match the quality offered
here.
PCGS# 7942.
2480 1911-D Strong D. MS-63 (PCGS). Crisply impressed
with razor sharp definition throughout, even the D
mintmark is executed in high relief. Free of singularly
distracting abrasions, even medium gold patina and
a satiny texture further enhance already strong eye
appeal at the Select grade level. This is the key date of
the Indian quarter eagle series, far and away with the
lowest mintage — 55,680 pieces. Of course most of
those are not around today having been melted down
in the 1930s when gold coins were removed from
circulation and many were returned to government
agencies for eventual melting down. Collectors who
want to collect a series of gold coins by date and mint
often choose the Indian quarter eagle, as there is only
one really expensive issue, this one, the 1911-D. Yet,
it can be obtained for a price, and today one lucky
collector can put away this key issue and achieve the
crowning glory of this popular gold series. There are
two different dies used to strike the reverses of this key
date, one with a Strong D as seen here, the other with
a weakly impressed D, which sells for a discount as
most collectors really want to see the all important D
mintmark on their 1911 quarter eagles.
PCGS# 7943.
2479 1911 MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC. Exquisite satin to softly
frosted surfaces also possess sharply impressed devices and
wonderfully original light orange patina. Although readily
available in the lower reaches of the Mint State category,
pieces grading MS-64+ or finer are scarce and desirable.
PCGS# 7942.
Page 164
Highly Collectible 1911-D
Indian Quarter Eagle
2481 1911-D MS-63 (NGC). Although not designated as
such on the NGC insert, this is a Strong D example
with a crisp, fully defined D mintmark. The balance
of the devices are also sharply impressed, and satiny
honey-orange luster provides superior eye appeal at
the assigned grade level. This has always been the key
date to the Indian quarter eagle series, not only borne
out by its tiny mintage, but its rarity has survived
despite several seemingly common dates giving the
1911-D a run for the top rarity position. Simply put,
this is a challenging series to collect in high grades,
and several other dates and mints have proven to be
far more difficult to obtain than generally realized.
However, the king of the series remains the 1911-D
and it has always been sought after in all grades and
highly desirable when found at the Choice grade level.
2483 1911-D Strong D. AU-58 (PCGS). Appealing honeygold surfaces are near fully lustrous with a satiny texture
throughout. Sharply struck, as well, and free of outwardly
distracting abrasions. The 1911-D is the undisputed key
issue of the Indian Head quarter eagle series; it has the
lowest mintage by far of any issue in the design type (just
55,680 pieces), of which perhaps 15 to 20% still exist. Most
seen appear to grade EF or better indicating that these
typically circulated little. Possibly many were held in reserve
for the redemption of gold certificates; others may have
turned up in overseas gold hoards subsequent to World War
II. This coin is accompanied by Manfra, Tordella & Brookes,
Inc. Integrity Seal # 02145 that lists the grade as MS-62.
The Integrity Seal is available to the winning bidder upon
request to Stack’s Bowers Galleries after the close of the
auction.
PCGS# 7943.
PCGS# 7943.
2484 1911-D Strong D. AU-53 (PCGS). Pretty honey-gold
surfaces are minimally abraded for the grade with bold to
sharp definition throughout. The absolute hands-down key
date in the Indian quarter eagle series, and a date that saw a
mintage of just 55,680 pieces, the lowest by far in the design
type. The Strong D variety offered here is far more actively
sought than the so-called “Weak D” variety where, in some
instances, the viewer must often have faith that there is
actually a “D” to be seen. Pleasing for the grade and sure to
attract lively bidding activity.
PCGS# 7943.
2485 1913 MS-64+ (PCGS). Richly frosted with lovely deep gold
color, this beautiful piece is knocking on the door of a full
Gem grade. Undeniably choice for the assigned grade and
worthy of bold bidder support.
PCGS# 7945.
2482 1911-D Unc Details—Improperly Cleaned (NGC). In
addition to a full, strong D mintmark, this more affordable
example also offers sharp focal devices and rather pleasing
toning in a warm honey-gold. The cleaning is minor with
only faint, wispy hairlines that are easily overlooked at most
angles. Worthy of a close look, as there is a lot of “coin” here
relative to the assigned qualifier from NGC. Unquestionably,
the most eagerly sought and desirable 20th-century quarter
eagle issue; the 1911-D $2.50 ranks high on the “wishlist” of
thousands of collectors.
PCGS# 7943.
Page 165
2486 1914 MS-64 (PCGS). This honey-rose beauty is sharply
struck with full, billowy satin luster. A popular and
somewhat important semi-key date, especially at MS-64
or finer. Choice for the grade and sure to please its next
steward.
PCGS# 7946.
2493 1929 MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. Uncommonly sharp in strike
for this final year Indian quarter eagle issue, this exquisite
Gem also offers vibrant satin luster and vivid rose-gold
patina to expertly preserved surfaces. A scarce and desirable
issue at the MS-65 level and extremely rare finer. Barely
more than 1% of the Mint State examples certified by PCGS
could match the quality offered here. The 1929 is notable as
the final issue of the $2.50 denomination produced by the
U.S. Mint.
PCGS# 7953.
Three-Dollar Gold Pieces
2487 1915 MS-65 (NGC). Pretty pinkish-khaki surfaces and
smartly impressed features provide strong eye appeal for
this solidly graded Gem quarter eagle. As nice as you’re ever
apt to see for a MS-65 NGC-certified example of the date.
PCGS# 7948.
2488 1915 MS-64 (NGC). Warmly medium gold patina blankets
softly frosted surfaces, both sides also revealing isolated
blushes of pale rose iridescence as the coin rotates under a
light. A popular date and grade combination.
PCGS# 7948.
2489 1915 MS-64 (NGC). Pretty khaki-rose patina blankets both
sides and provides strong eye appeal for this sharply struck,
carefully preserved near-Gem. Examples grading MS-64
are easily within the top 20% of all Mint State 1915 quarter
eagles certified by NGC.
PCGS# 7948.
2490 1915 MS-64 (NGC). Light pinkish-honey patina blends
nicely with satiny luster, the surfaces expectably well
preserved at the Choice grade level. As nice as they come in
a MS-64 holder!
PCGS# 7948.
2491 1927 MS-65 (PCGS). Thick satin luster and handsome
medium gold color greet the viewer from both sides of this
delectable Gem Indian two-and-a-half. A sparkling Gem
from the waning years of the design type and denomination.
2494 1854-O AU-53 (NGC). This bright, satiny, yellow gold
example is uncommonly free of sizeable abrasions in a
lightly circulated ‘54-O three. Wispy hairlines are noted for
accuracy, however, although with plenty of bold definition
in the absence of all but trivial wear the eye appeal is above
average for this conditionally challenging issue. Only 24,000
were struck from the New Orleans Mint, the only issue of
this denomination by this Mint. Furthermore, this is the
first year of the denomination so considerable effort was
made to get this new coin out into the public domain. While
this date and mint is available in circulated grades, the 1854O is all but unobtainable in Choice Mint State grades, and
difficult to procure in About Uncirculated grades. Here is a
solid example that should please most collectors for its high
technical grade as well as its pleasing surfaces.
PCGS# 7971.
PCGS# 7951.
2492 1927 MS-65 (NGC). Sharp and inviting, this softly frosted
light orange Gem would make a fitting addition to a high
grade type or date set. As pretty as the proverbial picture.
PCGS# 7951.
Page 166
2498 1856-S Medium S. EF-45 (NGC). Satiny in texture with
plenty of original luster, this evenly toned, medium gold
survivor is exceptionally attractive in a lightly circulated
S-mint three. A trio of punches were used to impart the “S”
to the reverse die, one is rather large, two dies are seen with
a Medium sized “S”, and yet another die sports a Small sized
“S”. This Medium “S” is the most plentiful of these variations.
PCGS# 7975.
2495 1854-O EF-45 (NGC). Light olive-khaki patina blankets
boldly defined features. Remnants of a satin to semireflective finish are evident in the protected areas around the
devices, and there are few individually distracting abrasions.
A touch of glossiness to the texture and a few wispy hairlines
are noted solely for accuracy. This is a scarcer issue in all
grades, with a modest mintage and perhaps 1,000 or so that
survive today. Most are in circulated grades like the present
coin, but highly collectible to represent this denomination
as well as this tough branch mint issue.
2499 1856-S Medium S. EF-45 (NGC). Warmly toned in khakiorange, this boldly defined, minimally abraded Choice EF
also offers flickers of original luster in the protected areas
around the devices. An early San Francisco issue of a much
needed denomination in the West during the heady days of
the Gold Rush in California. Most of these circulated down
to lower grades or were later melted. Mintage of 34,500
pieces for the year. Of course, only a small fraction of that
original number is known today with the balance melted
down.
PCGS# 7975.
PCGS# 7971.
2496 1855 AU-55 (NGC). Light honey-gold patina greets the
viewer from both sides of this boldly defined, visually
appealing Choice AU. A popular Philadelphia Mint issue with
lots of 5s in the mix — 50,555 pieces were struck in 1855.
PCGS# 7972.
Condition Rarity
1856-S Three in Mint State
2500 1859 AU-58 (PCGS). Bright, satiny, medium gold surfaces
are exceptionally appealing for the grade with not so much
as a single notable abrasion. This is an issue that is obtainable
from this popular series, however, all things being relative
the entire mintage for this year is still a paltry 15,558 pieces.
Perhaps a tenth of those survive today, and this handsome
AU-58 will serve well to represent the type or date for this
series.
PCGS# 7979.
2497 1856-S Medium S. MS-61 (NGC). This bold, satiny piece
reveals only wispy, well scattered abrasions to define the
grade. Otherwise evenly toned in light olive-orange, a
tiny swirl of crimson-copper at the letter S in DOLLARS
on the reverse is noted for accuracy. The 1856-S has the
fifth highest mintage of the series, and these are available
in moderate circulated grades. However, not many were
saved and high grade pieces above AU are not commonly
found. Many in fact, are in grades of VF and lower,
confirming that this issue entered circulation and stayed
there when these were released. Here is one of the few
seen that retains full mint surface and far more eye appeal
than commonly seen on a circulated example. Destined
for an advanced Three-Dollar gold piece collection or
specialized San Francisco group.
2501 1859 AU-55 (NGC). Well balanced medium gold surfaces
also reveal a tinge of pale olive at isolated angles. With bold
to sharp definition and freedom from outwardly distracting
abrasions, there is much to recommend this coin to the
specialized three-dollar gold collectors. Always in demand
in high grades by type and date collectors alike, and struck
during those eventful years that let up to the Civil War in
this country.
PCGS# 7979.
PCGS# 7975.
NGC Census: 12; 11 are finer (Mint State-64 finest).
Page 167
2502 1868 MS-61 (PCGS). Satiny with modest semi-reflective
tendencies in the fields, this honey-gold example offers
sharp striking detail and freedom from singularly distracting
abrasions. While the 1868 Philadelphia issue of Three-dollar
gold pieces is considered the most plentiful issue of this
decade, these are still scarce today. The original mintage
of 4,850 pieces was modest at best, and considering at least
two-thirds of those struck are no longer available as they
were likely melted in the ensuing years, makes for a more
balanced picture of the true rarity today. An impressive
example of this historic style and denomination.
PCGS# 7989.
2506 1885 Proof-62 (PCGS). Handsomely toned in warm deep
rose and honey-gold, this crisply impressed specimen also
reveals well mirrored fields when viewed with the aid of a
good light source. There are none but wispy, well concealed
contact marks to help define the grade, and the eye appeal
alone points to a Select Proof rating. Mintage for the year
halted after 109 Proofs were coined, this one managed to
survive, which is not always the case on these early gold
issues. This example offers the expected boldness in the
strike, as well as the expected contrast between the frosted
devices and mirror fields.
PCGS# 8049.
2503 1870 EF-45 (NGC). Warmly toned in even pale khaki, this
boldly defined EF reveals no outwardly distracting abrasions
— a rare attribute in a lightly circulated three-dollar gold
piece. Scarce in all grades today as the original mintage was
3,500 pieces, not unusual for this series that produced many
low mintage rarities today.
PCGS# 7991.
2504 1878 MS-64 (PCGS). Billowy mint luster and freedom from
all but a few wispy abrasions are sure to endear this pretty
rose-orange coin to the Mint State gold type collector. A tough
grade to find on this particular series and highly popular
with collectors as Gems are much scarcer and bring a large
premium over this nearly-so grade level. An enticing coin that
should please any specialist seeking quality and eye appeal.
PCGS# 8000.
Gem 1888 Three-Dollar Gold
2507 1888 MS-65 (PCGS). This handsome Gem exhibits
smooth, satiny surfaces with a touch of honey-orange
haziness to the reverse. Otherwise rose-orange in
color, with a sharp strike that further enhances already
strong appeal. Originally conceived to coincide with
the three-cent postal rate introduced in 1851, threedollar gold pieces never proved to be popular with the
contemporary public. By the last years of the series,
mintages were minuscule and examples circulated
very little. To illustrate this point, the circulation strike
mintage for the 1888 amounted to only 5,000 pieces.
Survivors are relatively few in number, and in Gem
Mint State, as here, they are quite scarce from a market
availability standpoint. Simply put, this is a beautiful
and important example from the penultimate year of
the type.
PCGS# 8010.
2505 1882 AU-58 (NGC). CAC. Crisply impressed with satiny
medium gold features, this carefully preserved near-Mint
survivor would make an impressive addition to an advanced
three-dollar gold set. A modest issue for this particular year as
a mere 1,500 were struck for circulation. Not known to have
survived in any hoards, but thankfully for collectors, this date
is available in most grades with patience. Here is a nearly new
survivor that offers strong eye appeal and ample luster.
PCGS# 8004.
Page 168
Four-Dollar Gold Piece
Classic Proof 1879
Flowing Hair Four-Dollar Stella
2508 1879 Flowing Hair. Judd-1635, Pollock-1833. Rarity-3. Gold. Reeded Edge. Proof-60 (PCGS). Secure Holder. Swirling
tannish-silver and pale rose overtones contrast with a base of more vibrant medium orange color. This piece is sharply struck in
all areas, and the often seen planchet rollermarks (as made) over the central high points are so faint as to be all but invisible even
under close inspection with a loupe. Although a bit hazy in appearance, this feature does help to conceal wispy, grade defining
hairlines. An aesthetically pleasing specimen all things considered, and a more than respectable example of a highly important and
extremely popular gold type. Four-dollar gold pieces, or Stellas, so-called from the five pointed star on the reverse, are patterns,
not regular coins. Stellas were produced in 1879 and 1880 at the suggestion of Hon. John A. Kasson, a Minister to Austria. Kasson
believed that a coin of this size and weight would be beneficial to United States travelers who could use these Stellas in exchange
for gold coins of similar sizes in Germany and France, as well as other European countries. As noted on the coin itself, its value
and various weights were spelled out literally, so any transaction would be a matter of simplicity. The obverse states (with stars
separating each device) 6G., .3S, .7C, 7G,R,A,M,S, or properly spelled out 6 Grams of gold, .3 grams of silver, .7 grams of copper
for a total of 7 grams. This brief summary noted on the coin itself allowed for rapid determination of value.Charles E. Barber,
the Chief Engraver of the Mint at the time, designed the Flowing Hair style on the Stellas as well as the reverse dies used to coin
both varieties. Another engraver, George T. Morgan, designed the Coiled Hair style that was also used in 1879 and 1880 on these
popular Stellas. On the reverse, the Motto appears as DEO EST GLORIA or God is Glorious instead of In God We Trust as seen
on coins large enough to support the motto since 1866. Mintages for this particular issue has long been reported as 425 pieces but
was likely a bit higher. These have been exceptionally popular since they were coined for their unusual denomination as well as
being one of the few gold patterns that could be obtained by collectors.
PCGS# 8057.
Page 169
Half Eagles
Flashy Mint State 1804 Small 8 Capped Bust Right Half Eagle
2509 1804 BD-2. Rarity-4+. Small 8. MS-62 (NGC). Pleasingly toned in a blend of honey-gold, khaki-olive and reddish-orange, both
sides exhibit a predominantly satin texture to the finish. More direct angles also call forth modest semi-reflective tendencies in the
fields which provide uncommon vibrancy at the BU grade level. Boldly to sharply struck throughout, with only wispy, singularly
inconspicuous abrasions to define the grade. The reverse die crack through the E of AMERICA continues through the shield and
out the left wing (facing) of the eagle. Scarce this nice and likely one of the top ten or so of this die pairing to exist. A pleasing coin
to study and one that would be a wise selection for a type or advanced variety collection.
PCGS# 8085.
NGC Census: 25; 25 finer (Mint State-64 finest) for the date.
Lustrous Choice Mint State
1807 Capped Bust Left Half Eagle
2510 1807 Capped Bust Left. BD-8. Rarity-2. MS-63 (NGC). Intricately defined from a sharply executed strike, this bright, satiny,
medium gold example is smooth enough to suggest an even higher Mint State grade. This is the first year of the new style of half
eagle designed by the talented Mint Engraver John Reich. The obverse depicts a bust of Liberty facing left, wearing a soft cloth dress
with a clasp on her shoulder and also wearing a cloth cap inscribed LIBERTY. The reverse shows a standing eagle clutching an olive
branch in his right claw and three arrows in his left. His breast is covered with a shield, and above is the Motto E PLURIBUS UNUM
on a raised ribbon. The denomination appears below for the first time on our gold coinage, giving a stated value of 5 D. Although
this die pairing is plentiful, not many exist at the Choice grade level or finer, hence this is a highly desirable example for the collector
looking for an attractive, high grade piece to represent this issue.
PCGS# 8101.
NGC Census: 19; 22 finer (Mint State-66 finest).
Page 170
Attractive Mint State 1808
Capped Bust Left Half Eagle
2511 1807 Capped Bust Left. BD-8. Rarity-2. Unc Details—
Obverse Damage (NGC). Exceptionally attractive despite
the stated qualifier, both sides are predominantly lustrous
with rich orange-gold patina. Virtually full in striking detail,
as well, a tiny cut on Liberty’s cheek is the only significant
detraction to otherwise minimally marked, outwardly
smooth surfaces. From the first year of the design type, and
a date that is often selected to represent the type in advanced
gold type sets. This one deserves more than just a casual
glance.
PCGS# 8101.
Lustrous Mint State 1808/7
Capped Bust Half Eagle
2513 1808 BD-3. Rarity-4. Normal 5D. MS-61 (NGC). Vivid
reddish-orange patina blankets both sides of this sharply
struck, suitably lustrous example. Minimally abraded for
the grade, and thoroughly appealing for BU type purposes.
These early half eagles are hard to find in Mint State grades
today, as most entered circulation at their time of issue, and
only a few were randomly saved. Furthermore as the price of
gold rose in value, many of these half eagles were melted for
a profit over their face value, so this fact further reduced the
numbers known today. Mercifully for numismatists, some
did survive and here is a pleasing coin that will enhance
any specialized collection that is seeking a Mint State
representative of this type issue.
PCGS# 8102.
2514 1809/8 BD-1, the only known dies. Rarity-3+. EF Details—
Damaged (NGC). Evenly toned in a rather appealing blend
of light olive and yellow gold, this piece also offers ample
definition to appreciate this classic early U.S. gold design
type. Faint flickers of original luster are discernible in
isolated areas, although the surfaces are overall glossy in
texture from a cleaning, and several pin scratches are also
noted for accuracy. Still and all, this is a scarce issue and type
coin that is always in high collector demand. Most of the
original mintage was melted in the following decades after
production as the price of gold rose above the face value of
the coins stated value. Any high grade example like this is
highly collectible today.
PCGS# 8104.
2512 1808/7 BD-2. Rarity-4+. Die State b/c. MS-61
(NGC). Bright yellow gold surfaces are awash in
smooth, satiny luster. This is an uncommonly well
struck example for an early half eagle, the definition
bold to sharp throughout the design. A prominent
bisecting die crack over the upper obverse is as struck
(it is diagnostic of obverse die state b as defined by John
W. Dannreuther, 2006), and for a BU Capped Bust
Right five it is remarkable that there are no sizeable
or otherwise outwardly distracting abrasions. This is
highly desirable example of this elusive overdate issue.
Given the tiny number seen at this grade level or finer,
any serious numismatist would do well to secure this
condition rarity as soon as possible—in this case when
the hammer falls with your winning bid!
PCGS# 8103.
NGC Census: 6; 3 are finer (Mint State-63 finest) within the 1808/7 designation.
2515 1834 Classic Head. McCloskey-4. Plain 4. AU-55 (PCGS).
Lustrous with satiny orange-gold surfaces, this appealing
Choice AU type candidate also offers sharp to full definition
to all devices. Otherwise free of individually mentionable
abrasions, a pair of thin, faint scuffs in the upper reverse
field are noted for accuracy. This is the first year of the
Classic gold half eagle design, and although this particular
die marriage is plentiful, high grade examples like this are
always in strong demand. A solid representative of this type
or date for any numismatist to enjoy.
PCGS# 8171.
2516 1834 Classic Head. McCloskey-8. Plain 4. AU-50 (PCGS).
This sharply defined, suitably lustrous example also offers
attractive toning in predominantly light olive-gold. A
pleasing coin that would make a great addition to a midgrade gold type set.
PCGS# 8171.
Page 171
2522 1846-D AU-53 Details—Cleaned (ANACS). Suitably
bold in detail for a lightly circulated survivor of this issue,
this piece is uncommonly smooth with not even a single
mentionable abrasion. The surfaces exhibit a glossy texture
from a cleaning with curious honey-rose color. A series
of scratches on the back of the ANACS holder are noted,
especially since they obscure viewing of the coin’s reverse.
Aside from the cleaning, this is a handsome Dahlonega
Mint half eagle that is reasonably scarce with an original
mintage of 80,294 pieces.
2517 1839 AU-58 (NGC). CAC. Delightful light khaki-orange
surfaces are satiny in texture and exceptionally smooth for
the assigned grade. Boldly, if not sharply defined in all areas
as well, it is difficult for us to imagine a more appealing AU
example of the date. Struck in the first year of Christian
Gobrecht’s Liberty or Coronet half eagle design, the 1839
is an ever-popular date with type collectors. It is somewhat
elusive in Choice AU and even more so in Mint State. Choice
AU-58 is a smart choice in today’s numismatic climate.
PCGS# 8228.
2523 1847 MS-61 (NGC). Radiant satin surfaces are uncommonly
lustrous for an early Liberty five at the BU grade level.
Minimally abraded, as well, with beautiful light orange
patina that further enhances already exceptional eye appeal.
Worthy of a strong bid! Scarce in any Mint State grade and
a popular issue for those seeking an early half eagle of the
1840s.
PCGS# 8231.
PCGS# 8191.
2518 1841-C Fine-15 (PCGS). Pleasing khaki-gold surfaces
exude originality in a circulated C-mint gold coin. All major
devices are boldly outlined, and there are no abrasions that
we deem worthy of individual attention. Given the scarcity
of Southern gold coin as a group, this more affordable, yet
problem free 1841-C five is sure to be of interest to budget
minded type collectors of mintmarked coinage.
PCGS# 8203.
2519 1842-C Large Date. AU Details—Improperly Cleaned
(NGC). Sharply struck, and uncommonly so for a C-mint
gold coin, this piece also exhibits pleasing olive-orange
patina to enhance the appeal. Free of singularly distracting
abrasions, yet overall glossy in texture due to the stated
impairment. A tough early Charlotte Mint issue that comes
in both Small Date and Large Date styles. The Large Date
style is more plentiful, but highly collectible when found
with such strong hair definition on Liberty as well as the
feather details on the eagle’s wings.
PCGS# 8209.
2520 1843-D Fine-12 (NGC). Original, otherwise khakigold surfaces are ringed in vivid pinkish-rose peripheral
iridescence. Problem free for the grade, and highly desirable
as a more affordable Dahlonega Mint half eagle.
2524 1851 MS-62 (PCGS). OGH. Luxurious satin luster flows
over both sides of this handsomely toned, fully original,
medium orange example. Bold to sharp in strike, with
overall smooth surfaces that would probably have secured
an even higher grade were it not for a touch of haziness
easily overlooked at most angles. Worthy of a close look,
and also a premium bid. This is not a particularly rare date
and mint, but is a true challenge to find this well preserved.
An enticing example that offers considerable appeal for the
modest grade.
PCGS# 8246.
PCGS# 8215.
2521 1844-O AU-58 (NGC). Charming khaki-olive patina
provides a refreshingly original “look” to this early O-mint
half eagle. Sharply struck, and exceptionally appealing for a
pre-Civil War Southern gold coin. This is one of the more
plentiful issues from the still early days at the New Orleans
Mint, but high grade pieces like this always find many
buyers when they are offered.
PCGS# 8222.
Page 172
2525 1851-D AU-50 (NGC). Evenly toned in light khaki
patina, this piece offers some bolder definition in isolated
areas — a positive attribute for a notorious strike rarity
among Dahlonega Mint half eagles. Heavily abraded, also
as often seen for the issue, yet important as a ‘51-D five
in a conditionally scarce AU holder. Mintage from the
Dahlonega Mint in 1851 for half eagles is a mere 62,710
pieces, of which no more than a few hundred or so exist
today. This one retains considerable definition on Liberty’s
hair curls as well as the eagle’s feathers.
PCGS# 8248.
2526 1853-C AU-55 Details—Cleaned (ANACS). Sharply
defined in the absence of all but minimal wear, this coin
should be of obvious importance to the budget minded
Southern gold collector. A few pin scratches in the left
obverse field are noted, as is a curiously glossy texture from a
cleaning, although both sides do exhibit rather pleasing color
in rich olive-orange. Mintage of 65,571 pieces, and only a tiny
percentage of that original issue is around today. Here is one
with a few minor issues, but retains ample reasons to collect
it for the high grade and general scarcity of this issue.
for four long years. This No Motto style lasted until 1866,
and many collectors will be seeking an example for their type
collections as well as for the date and mint issue.
PCGS# 8288.
PCGS# 8254.
2527 1853-C AU-53 (NGC). Radiant satin surfaces are aglow with
bright gold color. Minimally worn and not overly abraded
for the assigned grade, this boldly defined C-mint half eagle
has much to offer the Southern gold specialist. The original
mintage of 65,571 was higher than most Charlotte issues but
is not at all common today when compared to many other
issues from this series. The surfaces offer good eye appeal as
well as the devices. This coin would make a good selection
to represent this mint, which is seldom available at regional
shops.
2531 1867-S EF-45 (PCGS). Generally rose-orange in color, this
boldly defined survivor has enough detail to suggest an AU
designation. A touch of glossiness and light haziness to
the surfaces suggest that PCGS has net-graded this piece
to Choice EF due to an old, light cleaning. Only 29,000
examples of the date were struck against a Philadelphia
Mint total of only 6,870 pieces — half eagles were not a big
production item for either of the active mints in 1867.
PCGS# 8314.
PCGS# 8254.
2528 1854-D Large D. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS). With crisp
definition to the devices and rather pleasing color in a vivid
medium gold, this more affordable Dahlonega Mint five is
sure to win many adherents among both mintmarked type
collectors and Southern gold specialists. A scarce date and
mint when compared to many Philadelphia Mint issues, and
always in high collector demand for its Dahlonega mintmark.
PCGS# 8258.
2529 1860-D Medium D. VF-30 (PCGS). Handsome khaki-rose
color blanket both sides of this moderately, yet evenly worn
survivor. A bit scuffy overall, yet free of singularly distracting
abrasions, this piece also retains some bolder definition
in the more protected areas of the design. Dahlonega gold
coinage is quite rare when issued just prior to the Civil War as
most of the available coins were hoarded, many later melted
down. Survivors as scarce today, especially when found in
wholesome condition.
PCGS# 8286.
2532 1867-S EF-45 (NGC). Handsome khaki-rose surfaces
retain overall bold definition for a lightly circulated survivor
of this challenging early S-mint issue. Wispy abrasions
are commensurate with the assigned grade, and none are
worthy of singular mention. An elusive date that enjoyed a
tiny mintage of only 6,870 pieces with the typical survivor
from that tally apt to be VF or so. It is certainly worth noting
here that no Mint State examples of the date have been
certified by NGC. Indeed, the NGC-certified AU specimens
are but few and far between as well, which should make this
Choice EF specimen all the more attractive to our bidders.
PCGS# 8314.
2533 1873-S AU-50 (NGC). A sharp and inviting AU, this
conditionally scarce half eagle also offers satiny rose-orange
luster and freedom from singularly distracting abrasions.
From a modest mintage for the date of 31,000 pieces, all
of those of the Close 3 date style. Typically found in VF or
so, and somewhat elusive at AU. Specialists take note: NGC
has certified just one Mint State example of the date which
places a lot of acquisition pressure on the supply of AU
pieces in the marketplace.
PCGS# 8332.
2530 1861 MS-62 (NGC). Sharp, satiny and possessed of pretty
medium orange color, this minimally abraded BU is seemingly
earmarked for inclusion in a Mint State type set. A scarce date
this well preserved and rare any finer, as most of these entered
circulation and few were saved. These were stuck at the outset
of the Civil War, which erupted in early 1861 and continued
Page 173
Extremely Rare 1875
From a Mintage of Just 200
2534 1875 AU-53 (PCGS). CAC. Remarkably appealing in an
example of this extremely rare and challenging issue, this
charming piece is evenly toned in deep honey-khaki patina.
More direct angles call forth faint remnants of original
satin to modestly semi-reflective luster, but not even close
inspection reveals a singularly mentionable abrasion. Ample
sharpness of detail from a well executed strike rounds out
an impressive list of attributes for this key date Liberty half
eagle.
The 1875 Liberty half eagle has the lowest mintage of
an issue in the series of Liberty half eagles with a scant 200
pieces struck for circulation. This extremely limited issue
surpasses even the 1854-S half eagle mintage of 268 pieces
struck. However, the 1854-S has only three examples known
and thus it nudges out the 1875 Philadelphia issue as the
rarest date and mint coin to obtain for this popular series.
As any experienced collector knows, the original mintage
is only a starting point when it comes to gold coinage, as
the vagaries of time and attrition also contend with the vast
numbers melted in the case of so many of these gold issues.
Gold coinage production from American mints was
generally much lower after the Civil War began, but
continued in fits and starts until 1879, when the paper
greenbacks that had been used to help finance that War
finally traded at par (paper dollars had the same monetary
value as physical gold dollars once again in 1879—after
paper money traded at a discount to gold since 1861). Thus,
most of the gold coins produced during the late 1860s, and
until the end of the 1870s, saw little circulation during this
Page 174
period. Today, it is clear that the majority were melted in
the coming generations, judging by the tiny fraction which
remains from the original mintages of this era.
From this meager issue of 200 pieces there are perhaps
seven to nine individual 1875 half eagles known today.
This particular example is tied for the finest seen by PCGS,
with one other photographed on the CoinFacts website at
this grade level, and possibly two others noted in the PCGS
Population Report. Its historic importance as an exceptional
rarity among American gold coins cannot be overstated.
The year 1875 produced several famous gold rarities as
demand and production fell to dismal lows during this
year on all denominations other than the double eagle—
lows unseen before or after that date. Many great rarities
were struck at the Philadelphia Mint during that year. The
Gold dollar series show only 400 pieces coined, the Liberty
quarter eagle also recorded 400 pieces struck, Three-dollar
gold coins were only struck in Proof with no business strikes
made at all, Liberty eagles note a token 100 pieces struck for
commerce, while Liberty double eagles, perhaps reflecting
large banking needs, were plentiful with 295,700 coined in
1875.
Of the known examples of 1875 Liberty half eagles
the grades range from EF to AU. This example i likely
tied with the finest known, with perhaps as many as five
others that all roughly merit the same grade level with a
few others showing slightly more circulation. This issue is
actually more available—for a price—in Proof condition
which offers a grand total of 20 pieces struck in that format.
More of the Proof coins survived than the total circulation
Liberty Half Eagle
Pieces Among the Finest Known
strikes of this date and mint. Clearly, any 1875 half eagle
is a truly rare coin and these are seldom offered for sale
even when major collections are sold. Eliasberg obtained a
Proof example of this date and mint, but the Norweb’s never
obtained one. The Harry Bass, Jr. example offers the same
grade as this offering, but a different specimen. Needless to
say, few collectors will ever have a chance to see an example
of this date and mint, let alone obtain one at any price. This
1875 Liberty half eagle is a rare coin by any measure and
will feature as a major highlight in even the most advanced
collection.
The roster of the known examples we were able to trace
includes (not necessarily in order of finest as the first several
are virtually tied in quality:
1). The Present Specimen: AU-53 (PCGS) CAC. CoinFacts
plate coin. Small field nick above star two, reverse two
cuts on post of I(TED). Prior provenance unknown but
possibly Paramount’s ANA Sale, August, 1974, lot 884;
the Wolfson Coin (Stack’s), October, 1962, lot 514; or
even the World’s Greatest Collection example, lot 429,
graded “Very Fine” but not plated.
2). AU-55 (NGC), also pictured on CoinFacts as AU-53
(PCGS). Our Auction, (Bowers and Merena), November,
2010, lot 5043, at $149,500; Goldbergs, February, 2007,
lot 2335; Heritage, January, 2006, lot 3491, as AU-50
(PCGS).
3). AU-53 (PCGS) Bass Collection Specimen. Nick between
star three and Liberty’s mouth in field, reverse with nick
below E(TED). Our (Bowers and Merena) Auction of
the Harry Bass, Jr., Collection, November, 2000, lot 526,
at $36,650; Paramount, October, 1968, privately after its
discovery in Europe by Paul Wittlin in the 1960s.
4). AU-55 (NGC) The Richmond Collection Specimen:
Heritage, April, 2014, lot 5752; The Richmond Collection,
DLRC, July, 2004, lot 1444, realized $86,250; Heritage,
October, 2001, lot 8278; Heritage Bullet Sale, February,
1993, lot 557.
5). AU-50 (PCGS) Nick in field between stars two and three
to chin, Our auction (Stack’s), September, 1999, lot 1213,
at $51,750; Diocese of Buffalo specimen #1, Heritage
ANA sale, August, 1997, lot 5384, at $43,125.
6). “EF-45” raw, Scratch along upper jaw, field cut right of
star four. The Diocese of Buffalo Specimen #2, Heritage,
June, 1997, lot 5439.
7). EF-40 (PCGS) Sharp nick on denticle above A(TES),
neck nick above 8. Bagmark located above right upper
olive leaf on the reverse. Goldbergs, September, 2003, lot
1150, at $34,500; Kardatzke Collection, Goldbergs, June,
2000, lot 1350.
Additional offerings likely included above: Paramount
ANA, August, 1974, lot 884; earlier our Wolfson Auction
(Stack’s), October, 1962, lot 514, at $950.
Another World’s Greatest Collection of United States
Gold Coins, Numismatic Gallery, January, 1946, lot 429, at
$200, graded “Very Fine”.
PCGS# 8336.
PCGS Population: 4; none are finer.
Page 175
2535 1878-S MS-62 (NGC). Radiant pinkish-gold surfaces
are exceptionally lustrous and minimally abraded at the
assigned grade level. A glittering Mint State specimen
of a date that is most often seen at VF and EF in today’s
numismatic marketplace. Pleasing AU and Mint State coins
are far more elusive than the date’s mintage of 144,700 pieces
suggests.
2538 1886-S MS-64 (PCGS). Original khaki-rose surfaces exhibit
a soft, satiny texture to boldly impressed features. Frosty and
bright, with good visual appeal for the grade assigned and
pleasing in all ways.
PCGS# 8370.
PCGS# 8347.
NGC Census: 23; 9 finer (MS-64 finest).
2536 1880-S MS-64+ (NGC). Crisply impressed with lovely roseorange patina, this premium near-Gem is sure to please
even the most discerning collector of classic U.S. Mint gold.
A large mintage for this particular year allowed for many
survivors, but most of them fall well short of the quality
offered here. In fact, most are circulated. This example is
a gnat’s whisker from the Gem grade level, which places it
ever so close to the finest seen by NGC. An impressive coin
for any date, especially for this early 1880s half eagle.
PCGS# 8353.
2539 1891-CC MS-62 (NGC). This fully struck khaki-gold
example is uncommonly smooth in a BU Carson City Mint
gold coin. Pleasingly original as well, we can easily see this
piece serving with distinction in a specialized CC-mint gold
collection. An ever-popular issue from the waning years of
Carson City Mint gold production, and a date that would
add distinction to a burgeoning gold type set..
PCGS# 8378.
2537 1885-S MS-65 (PCGS). OGH. Vivid reddish-orange patina
mingles with vibrant satin luster on both sides of this simply
exquisite Gem. A tough issue to find this well preserved as
Gems are few and far between, and finer pieces are virtually
unobtainable as so few exist. A handsome example for the
date and mint specialist or type collector seeking an earlier
issue to represent this series rather than the more commonly
seen 20th century Gem half eagles.
PCGS# 8368.
Page 176
2540 1895 MS-65 (NGC). Dreamy orange-rose surfaces are silky
smooth in appearance with a full endowment of billowy
satin luster. Choice and appealing, and near the “top of the
pop” at NGC — fewer than 10 examples of the date have
been certified finer than the present beauty by that firm.
PCGS# 8390.
2541 1899 MS-65 (NGC). Sharp and lustrous, this exquisite Gem
also offers vivid deep orange patina to silky smooth surfaces.
A satiny bright coin that will dazzle any specialist seeking a
high grade type coin or one to represent this date and mint.
The surfaces are outstanding and the eye appeal is worthy of
any advanced collection.
PCGS# 8398.
2544 1909-D MS-64 (PCGS). Delightful honey-rose surfaces
offer full luster and bold striking detail at the Choice grade
level. While available for a price this well preserved, finer
examples are indeed scarce to rare. A lovely example to
represent this plentiful issue for type or as a date and mint
coin.
PCGS# 8514.
2542 1901-S MS-66 (NGC). This pristine looking Gem reveals
nary a distracting blemish to satiny, vivid, medium rose
features. A beautiful coin that is sure to be of keen interest
to the high grade gold type or date collector. Like the eagle
of the same date and mint, the 1901-S half eagle is often
selected for inclusion in high-grade gold type sets.
2545 1909-D MS-64 (NGC). This conditionally scarce Indian five
is minimally abraded with satiny honey-orange surfaces.
This is one of the most plentiful issues of the type, but as
such is available at this near Gem grade to appease high
collector demand. A prize to represent the ever popular
Indian half eagle design.
PCGS# 8514.
PCGS# 8404.
2543 1908 Liberty. MS-65 (NGC). Gorgeous surfaces are
drenched in vibrant satin luster and vivid reddish-orange
patina. A razor sharp Gem for the high grade gold type
or date collector. This is the final year of issue of the long
running Liberty half eagle style, which began coinage way
back in 1839 and saw only a couple of minor changes to
the original design. Later in 1908 the first Indian half eagles
were launched. Here is a classic Gem that will entice any
knowledgeable collector to bid high.
2546 1909-D MS-63 (PCGS). Endearing satin textured surfaces
are sharply struck throughout with a full endowment
of original rose-orange color. Perhaps the most readily
available of all the mintmarked Indian eagles, Choice and
Gem Mint State examples of this date frequently wind up in
high-grade gold type sets.
PCGS# 8514.
PCGS# 8418.
Page 177
Key 1909-O
Indian Half Eagle
2547 1909-O MS-62 (PCGS). Secure Holder. Impressive technical quality for this key date Indian half eagle, both sides of this
‘09-O are sharply struck to include a well defined mintmark. The color is no less impressive with full, satiny luster having
assumed a handsome honey-orange tone over the years. There are few abrasions relative to the assigned grade, and even
fewer that are large enough to be readily evident to the unaided eye. The 1909-O stands out from the pack with the lowest
mintage of any Indian half eagle with a scant 34,200 pieces struck. Compare this to the almost three and a half million struck
at the Denver Mint the same year. As a rule 1909-O half eagles went immediately into circulation and stayed there, with few
Mint State examples extant. All in all, a premium quality BU survivor of an issue that is eagerly sought even in circulated
grades.
PCGS# 8515.
Page 178
Impressive 1909-O
Indian Half Eagle
2548 1909-O AU-58 (NGC). This handsome, evenly toned
piece is awash in medium khaki-orange patina. The
strike is uniformly sharp throughout, even over the all
important O mintmark, and the surfaces have survived
a short stint in active circulation without acquiring
any singularly distracting abrasions. An uncommonly
attractive near-Mint example of this popular key date
Indian half eagle. This is the only New Orleans Indian
half eagle produced, and in limited quantities of 34,200
pieces. There are precious few around today, and most
of the known population is circulated into lower grades
than seen here. As such this is a perfect opportunity to
purchase a coin with virtually all of the mint surface
intact and will serve an honored place in a high grade
Indian half eagle date and mint collection.
2550 1911-D MS-60 (NGC). Dominant khaki-olive patina adorns
both sides of this suitably bold BU example. Moderately
abraded, as befits the grade, although perhaps more
distracting are scattered swirls of russet coloration. While
this issue is not the lowest mintage of the series (the 1909-O
is lower) this is still one of the most challenging issues to find
in high grade, especially in Mint State-64 or finer. Collector
demand has always been high for these, and any Mint State
coin is eagerly snapped up as date and mint collectors seek
this grade level for their sets of Indian half eagles. Many of
the original mintage were melted in the 1930s, much to the
frustration of numismatists of our generation.
PCGS# 8521.
Lustrous Choice
1913-S Indian Half Eagle
PCGS# 8515.
Glorious Gem Mint State 1910
Indian Half Eagle Condition Rarity
2549 1910 MS-65 (NGC). Thick satin to softly frosted luster
mingles with delightful medium rose patina on both sides of
this beautiful Gem. With a sharp strike and smooth features,
this coin would fit nicely into the finest Indian half eagle set.
This is a truly challenging issue to find at the Gem grade level
as such a limited number have been certified at this level or
finer. By far the majority of those seen, even in Mint State
grades, fall well short of the satiny smooth surfaces present
here. A delightful and sparkling jewel that will enhance any
2551 1913-S MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. This is a beautiful key
date Indian five with satiny, light orange surfaces
greeting the viewer from both sides. Outwardly
smooth, and uncommonly so for the assigned grade,
an overall sharp strike further enhances already
memorable eye appeal. This is one of the tougher dates
and mints to find at the Choice grade level or finer, with
the Population noted below. While available in grades
of MS-62, this issue is much harder to find at this level
than several other dates and mints in this series. While
the original mintage came in at 408,000 pieces, the one
percent or so known today are nearly all circulated to
some degree, the balance of the mintage was melted
long ago, mostly in the 1930s. This coin is destined to
be a highlight of an advanced collection of Indian half
eagles.
PCGS# 8526.
PCGS# 8517.
Page 179
Impressive Choice Mint State
1914-S Indian Half Eagle
2552 1914-S MS-63 (NGC). Vibrant, satiny, khaki-gold
surfaces provide exceptional eye appeal for this
conditionally challenging S-mint issue. Boldly, if not
sharply struck throughout, with no abrasions that
we deem worthy of individual attention. Mintage
of 263,000 of which perhaps one percent are around
today. However, of those seen today most are circulated
— and if found in Mint State virtually all seen are at
the Mint State-62 grade or lower in technical quality.
Hence demand from collectors for Choice examples is
quite high, but there are few coins to go around. Gems
are virtually unobtainable as there as so few that are
reported by the grading services. Here is a bold choice
for the date and mint specialist who is able to top most
collectors groupings of this series.
Lovely Mint State
1915-S Half Eagle
2553 1915-S MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. With razor sharp
devices and vivid medium orange patina, this frosty
condition rarity is sure to be of keen interest to
advanced collectors of Indian gold coinage. The
original mintage of 164,000 pieces mostly found their
way to the melting pots of the 1930s, leaving 2,500 or so
of these in all grades. The vast majority of survivors are
circulated, with relatively few examples certified even
in the lowest Mint State grades. This prized example
will certainly be a major centerpiece in any advanced
collection of this series.
PCGS# 8529.
Page 180
PCGS# 8531.
PCGS Population: 39; 10 finer (all MS-64).
Eagles
Exceptional High Quality
1795 Capped Bust Right Eagle
First Year of Issue for the Denomination
2554 1795 BD-2, Taraszka-2. Rarity-4+. AU-58 (PCGS). OGH. Thoroughly PQ in all regards, and worthy of a strong bid as
such, uncommon originality in an early eagle is the first feature that presents itself to the advanced bidder. Both sides are
attractively toned in warm olive-gold patina that lightens to rose-gold (obverse) and medium gold (reverse) as the surfaces
dip into a light. Virtually complete luster remains in a satin to modestly semi-prooflike finish, and the definition is bold
to sharp from a well executed strike. There are few singularly mentionable abrasions, especially for such a large size pre1834 U.S. gold coin, and a few adjustment marks (as made) in the center of the obverse are so faint as to be hardly worth
mentioning. Attractive and highly appealing, this coin is sure to see spirited bidding at auction. Only 5,583 were reportedly
struck, perhaps a few more during 1796 but dated 1795, but not many. Today these are highly sought after by specialists as
the first year of issue and denomination, as well as for their elegant devices. Notice Liberty with her tall cap, there is a large
curl of her hair that wraps forward, up from behind that encircles the front of her cap. LIBERTY is boldly stated above, with
the date below her bust. For the reverse a standing eagle is central, holding a small closed laurel wreath in his beak, and he
is perched on a palm branch. In this case the branch has 13 leaves, likely a reference to the 13 original states in the colonies.
No denomination is stated, and the edge was lightly reeded. Each of these planchets was carefully weighed and adjusted if
found to be slightly heavy, keeping these important coins within a narrow weight tolerance was a necessity. There was great
want in our country for our own coinage, and it needed to be of full value and weight. Most of these early eagles circulated
in the major cities of America, but were seldom seen in the smaller towns and villages, especially west of the major cities.
In later years, most were melted and made into current gold coinage. For this die pairing, there are believed to be 90 to 110
known, a tiny sum considering the number of collectors that would desire to own one of these. Needless to say, this is an
incredible opportunity for one collector to finally obtain this elusive and challenging issue, in a sparkling near mint grade
that will dazzle any specialist.
PCGS# 8551.
Page 181
High Grade 1796 Eagle
2555 1796 BD-1, Taraszka-6, the only known dies. Rarity-4. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS). With plenty of bold to sharp striking
detail and ample evidence of a satin to semi-prooflike finish, this somewhat more affordable early eagle is sure to see spirited
bidding among high grade type collectors. Scattered hairlines are noted, but it is an uncommonly bright “look” to the surfaces that
more readily betrays a cleaning. This date is about twice as difficult to obtain than a 1795 eagle of this type. The actual mintage is
recorded as 4,146 pieces, but this may have involved different dates being produced. What is known is that there are about 125 to
175 pieces that exist of the 1796 eagle, and demand is quite high. Many of those known were cleaned to varying degrees, as seen
here, but the all important historical aspects and high technical grade are intact. The obverse design is well balanced with the stars
arranged eight by eight, which pressed part of LIBERTY to the tight space above the cap. The reverse die has the same style as the
prior year, but in 1796 shows only 11 leaves in the branch clutched by the eagle’s claws. Prior branches had either 13 leaves with one
showing only nine leaves. The eagle holds a small laurel wreath in his beak. These designs are classic Federal style and represent our
highest denomination coin issued at the time.
PCGS# 8554.
2556 1803 BD-5, Taraszka-30. Rarity-4+. Large Reverse Stars,
Extra Star. AU Details—Repaired (PCGS). The Extra Star
attribution is not denoted on the PCGS insert, and due
to both isolated softness of strike and light wear the 14th
star is only partially visible within the last cloud. Overall
definition is suitably bold for the type, however, and the
surfaces exhibit bright olive-orange color throughout. The
obverse has been extensively tooled in an effort to remove
pin scratches and graffiti, some of which features are still
partially discernible. Light adjustment marks near the lower
left obverse border are as struck. The modest mintage for
the date of 15,017 pieces was split about evenly between the
Large Reverse Stars variety offered here and the variety with
small stars on the reverse. The two varieties display similar
values in the marketplace.
2557 1842 Small Date. AU-58 (NGC). Sharply, if not fully defined
in all areas, this minimally circulated, bright olive-yellow
survivor offers exceptional appeal in an early No Motto
Liberty eagle. Not overly abraded for the assigned grade, as
well, and free of singularly mentionable distractions. This
popular variety had a mintage of 18,623 pieces, a modest
amount for the era. The Small Date variety offered here has
a Plain 4 in the date, while the Large Date variety of the 1842
eagle has a Crosslet 4. The Small Date variety is the scarcer
of the two varieties, especially in Choice AU or finer. One
for an alert specialist.
PCGS# 8585.
PCGS# 98565.
Page 182
2560 1843 Breen-6861. Tripled Date. AU-53 (NGC). This is a
suitably lustrous AU with ample evidence of a bright, satiny
finish discernible in the protected areas around the devices.
Evenly toned in light khaki-gold, with bold devices and no
singularly distracting abrasions. While not a rare date in
the scheme of eagles of the era, this variety is surely much
scarcer than a “normal” date specimen of the date. Coins
such as this can add a little flair to a mid-range to high-end
gold type set.
PCGS# 8588.
2558 1842-O AU-53 (NGC). Pleasingly toned in a blend of
bold olive and orange-gold, this minimally worn, sharply
defined piece also offers uncommonly smooth surfaces in a
circulated New Orleans Mint eagle from the pre-Civil War
era. Scarce this well preserved and downright rare even a
few grade points finer. A handsome example of this early
New Orleans Mint issue.
PCGS# 8587.
Condition Rarity 1843
Ten Dollar Gold Piece
2559 1843 MS-60 (NGC). Brilliant satin surfaces are aglow
with inviting yellow gold patina. Sharply, if not fully
struck throughout, this impressive condition rarity is
uncommonly free of singularly distracting abrasions
for an early date Liberty eagle at the BU grade level.
Although a seemingly available issue in most grades,
the limited mintage of 75,462 pieces apparently entered
circulation and stayed there. Only a couple can claim
the lower grades of Mint State today, and this is one
of the few — fewer than six have been certified at any
Mint State grade between both major grading services.
An enticing delight for the specialist.
2561 1844-O Winter-1. Repunched Mintmark. AU-55 (NGC).
Pretty honey-orange patina blankets both sides, the reverse
in particular retaining considerable satiny mint luster.
Sharply defined throughout, especially for an early date New
Orleans Mint gold coin, with no mentionable abrasions
apart from a thin graze behind Liberty’s chin. A popular
date with the added attraction of a moderately scarce die
variety.
PCGS# 8591.
2562 1844-O AU-53 (NGC). Richly toned in dominant khakiolive, this enticing piece also exhibits vivid reddish-rose
outlines to the reverse devices. Flickers of original luster are
evident on both sides as the coin dips into a light, and the
overall definition is suitably bold in a lightly circulated gold
coin from the earlier years of New Orleans Mint production.
The number coined was still decent for this early issue, but
subdued from 1843 at the New Orleans Mint for eagles.
Think how many of these wended up their way along the
Mississippi River, perhaps to St. Louis or points north to be
used in trade with early settlers in that still rather wild region.
Holding this high grade coin elicits many possibilities as to
where it has been, and yet remained in high grade today.
PCGS# 8591.
PCGS# 8588.
NGC Census: 3; just 1 finer (Mint State-61 finest).
2563 1846 AU-55 (NGC). Sharply defined with handsome olive
and khaki-gold patina, this appealing Choice AU also reveals
ample evidence of a semi-prooflike finish as the surfaces
rotate under a light. The 1846 issue is scarce with a mintage
of only 20,095 pieces. Survivors are elusive, especially this
well preserved. A delightful collector coin.
PCGS# 8594.
Page 183
2564 1851-O AU-50 (NGC). Pleasing golden-olive patina greets
the viewer from both sides of this boldly defined, generally
distraction free AU. Scarce and attractive for this New
Orleans date, and a solid representative for the issue.
PCGS# 8607.
2565 1853-O Winter-4. Repunched Date. AU-53 (NGC). Satiny
in texture with warm honey-gold patina, this piece reveals
flickers of original luster in isolated areas as the surfaces
rotate under a light. None of the wispy abrasions are worthy
of individual attention — an uncommon attribute for a
lightly circulated, early date New Orleans Mint eagle. The
Winter reference on the gold coins of the New Orleans Mint
gives this date an overall rarity rating of R-4, though in AU,
as here, a High Rarity-6 figure is suggested.
Key Date and High Grade
1859-S Liberty Eagle
PCGS# 8612.
2566 1856 Misplaced Date. AU-55 (NGC). The base of what
appears to be an errant 1 is present at the obverse border
below the ball of the digit 5 in the date. Interestingly, the
Walter Breen U.S. and colonial coin Encyclopedia(1988)
does not list an MPD variety for this issue. This is a bright,
satiny piece with even honey-orange patina and minimally
abraded surfaces for the grade. The modest mintage for the
date of 60,490 pieces makes for a moderately scarce date in
today’s marketplace, especially if AU or finer is in the cards
for you.
PCGS# 8619.
2567 1856-O AU-58 (NGC). This vibrant yellow gold example
is overall sharply struck with ample evidence of a satiny
finish on both sides. Only 14, 500 examples of this elusive
date were struck, and much of that modest amount was
heavily circulated during the era. As a reference, the two
major third-party grading services have certified just five
examples of the date in Mint State, and all five are just MS60. At AU-58, as here, you are confronted with a rarity that
is somewhat unheralded today — this is what opportunity is
all about!
2568 1859-S AU-53 (NGC). Evenly toned in a pleasing light
honey-gold, this important coin offers uncommonly
sharp definition in a surviving 1859-S eagle. The centers
are crisply impressed from the dies, and minor softness
of detail toward the borders is commonplace for many
Liberty eagle issues from the 1850s. Satiny in texture
with plenty of luster remaining, and uncommonly
distraction free for the grade. Only 7,000 were struck
in this year as the San Francisco Mint continued to
strike far more double eagles of the current year. Most
of these eagles entered circulation unnoticed, leaving
collectors to find out years later how truly rare any
example is today. Furthermore, high grade pieces are
extremely rare, including any certified at the AU grade
level or finer. In all about 45 surviving examples exist
according to CoinFacts, a tiny sum considering the
number of avid collectors seeking this key date and
mint.
PCGS# 8630.
PCGS# 8620.
NGC Census: 20; 4 finer (all MS-60).
2569 1861 AU-58 (NGC). Handsome khaki-orange surfaces are
warmly and evenly toned over sharply impressed features.
Lustrous for the grade, with no particularly noteworthy
abrasions. A pleasing Choice AU example of this popular Civil
War date; after this date the mintage figures at Philadelphia
and the branch mints fall significantly in the denomination
as time, effort, and bullion went mostly to churning out
double eagles during the era. The denomination gained
momentum again after 1879, but unlike at Philadelphia, the
branch mints turned out far fewer eagles than double eagles.
PCGS# 8633.
Page 184
Rare and Desirable 1865 Proof Liberty Eagle
One of Only 25 Struck
2570 1865 Proof-62 (NGC). Needle sharp in striking detail with a somewhat more satiny texture, the devices contrast appreciably
with glassy reflectivity in the fields, although not quite enough to support a Cameo designation. A subtle orange peel texture is
discernible in the fields as the coin is examined with the aid of a loupe, but not even such close inspection reveals more than a few
singularly mentionable blemishes. A trio of faint alloy spots over and around Liberty’s portrait, a thin contact mark in the field
before the chin, and a more expansive mark in the left reverse field are certainly useful identifying markers, but the extreme rarity
of this issue and the infrequency with which examples trade have combined to thwart our best attempts at establishing this coin’s
pedigree. A superior quality specimen given the assigned grade, especially in a Proof 1865 Liberty eagle — an issue that represents
a major challenge for the advanced gold collector at all levels of preservation.
Here is an exceptionally rare early Proof Liberty eagle, one of the few known today from a mintage of just 25 pieces struck in
the Proof format. There are believed to be approximately a dozen known today from this prized issue according to CoinFacts.
The exact number known is difficult to ascertain, Walter Breen believed there are only 8-10 that survive. There have only been
two other auction appearances of this issue in Proof in the last fifteen years. First of all in April of 1865, the Civil War was finally
winding down, but not until April of that year, a month after Proofs of this year were struck (March 8 is the recorded issue date)
and distributed. Of the perhaps dozen known at least two are permanently impounded, one the Smithsonian, another in the ANS
collection. These early Proofs are seldom offered or seen at all, and are always a major highlight of any advanced collection. The
paucity of auction records for this issue would seem to indicate fewer survivors than even the experts believe.
Numismatic legend David Akers notes that the issue of 1865 is a tougher date to find than the earlier 1862, 1863, or 1864 Proof
Liberty eagles. 1865 also represents the final year of the No Motto style for the eagle design, as the Motto IN GOD WE TRUST was
adopted and included on 1866 and later. Two pattern 1865 eagles are known with the addition of Motto on the reverse, one of these
resides in the Smithsonian, the other in private hands. The Harry W. Bass, Jr., Foundation has a pattern example with the Motto
struck in gilt copper that was offered in the first of the four Bass Collection auctions.
Stack’s Bowers sold an example of this rare issue in August, 2013 in our ANA Auction that is probably the finest known for a
record price of $528,750 for this issue. That particular coin is graded PR-66+ Deep Cameo by PCGS. This same came was offered
previously in our James A. Stack Auction on March 1, 1995. Proof gold rarities like this 1865 Liberty eagle, have found considerable
numismatic interest in the last decade, given their rarity and beauty, we suspect this trend will continue. After all, Proof United
States gold coins from this era are truly the finest caviar of coins minted, and have always been sought after by knowledgeable
collectors for these attributes.
PCGS# 8801.
NGC Census: just 1 with a single coin finer (Proof-64 finest) within the Proof category.
Page 185
2573 1878-S AU-53 (NGC). Satiny in texture with considerable
luster remaining, this vivid rose-orange example also
retains bold to sharp definition from a well executed strike.
Uncommonly free of outwardly distracting abrasions, and
worthy of a solid bid. A pleasing survivor from a modest
mintage of only 26,100 pieces — in 1878 the presses in San
Francisco were alive with the ringing of freshly minted
double eagles of which more than 1.7 million were produced.
We note fewer than a half dozen examples of this elusive
branch mint eagle have been called Mint State by NGC.
2571 1874-CC VF-35 (PCGS). With honest wear and freedom
from singularly distracting abrasions, this khaki-rose
survivor is sure to be of keen interest to more than a few
dedicated CC-mint gold collectors. The recorded mintage
for this date and mint is 17,767 pieces. Q. David Bowers
believes that between 150 and 225 exist and Rusty Goe
believes a few more are out there with his range of survivors
pegged at the range of 340 to 415 pieces. Only two examples
are Mint State, confirming that these entered circulation
with little fanfare when they were released. This offering is
a solid representative of this scarce issue, with enough wear
to smooth down the normal circulation marks, yet a high
enough grade to keep all the devices well defined and sharp.
PCGS# 8670.
PCGS# 8682.
2574 1889-S MS-64+ (NGC). CAC. This gorgeous near-Gem is
bursting with full and satiny deep orange luster. Sharply
struck throughout, as well, and attractive in all regards. The
1889-S is an otherwise common date, even in Mint State, but
at MS-64, as here, the “common” status changes immediately
to rare. Few and far between are the MS-64 examples of the
date, and the “+” designation adds yet another depth to the
importance of the present coin. This specimen deserves the
attention of all collectors who appreciate the Liberty eagle
series.
PCGS# 8716.
NGC Census: 9; none finer within any category. Only one of the nine pieces, the present coin,
has been designated “+” by NGC.
2572 1875-CC EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Well outlined
devices include a faint, yet discernible CC mintmark. There
are no individually mentionable abrasions on either side
and, although glossy in texture with light hairlining, the
surfaces are toned quite nicely in deep khaki-rose. A tough
date and mint to find at all, as the mintage halted at 7,715
pieces for the year. Most of those known have striking
softness, as noted above. Q. David Bowers estimates that 60
to 80 exist today, Rusty Goe a little higher, but regardless
any offering of an 1875-CC Liberty eagle is an important
opportunity for the numismatist.
PCGS# 8673.
2575 1891-CC MS-61 (PCGS). Crisply impressed with original
khaki-orange patina, this solidly graded BU is seemingly
earmarked for inclusion in a mintmarked type set of
classic U.S. gold. The mintage for the date or 103,732 pieces
represents the only date in the Carson City eagle series, 1870
to 1893, that the mintage figure went north of the six-figure
mark. Fortunately for today’s collectors Mint State examples
of the date are available to those with a bit of patience.
PCGS# 8720.
Page 186
2576 1891-CC Unc Details—Improperly Cleaned (NGC). With
a sharp strike, overall smooth looking surfaces, and plenty
of original luster remaining, there is much to recommend
this piece to a budget-minded collector of CC-mint gold
coinage. Interestingly, the 1891-CC is the only eagle struck
in Carson City, 1870-1893, with a mintage that crossed the
100,000 piece mark, though just barely at 103,732 pieces.
PCGS# 8720.
2577 1891-CC AU-58 (NGC). Drenched in vivid reddish-rose
patina, this sharp and lustrous near-Mint survivor offers
solid eye appeal and quality for the assigned grade. A nice
opportunity for a type collector looking to add a touch of
variety to a set of gold coin denominations.
PCGS# 8720.
2580 1893-CC AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Nicely toned
in dominant khaki-gray, both sides also reveal more vivid
copper-rose highlights around the peripheries. The overall
appearance of this coin belies the stated impairment, and
only at a few isolated angles can we discern light hairlining
from a cleaning. A sharply struck and surprisingly attractive
piece that is worthy of careful bidder consideration. Scarce
too, with a modest mintage of 14,000 pieces for the year. This
is also the final year of coin production from the Carson
City Mint, and perhaps a few were saved as this date and
mint is known in Mint State by a dozen or so coins. Most
of the known examples fall into the Very Fine to Extremely
Fine grade range, so this higher grade coin represents a
strong option for the date and mint specialist.
PCGS# 8726.
2581 1895-O MS-61 (NGC). Vibrant satin luster mingles
with handsome orange gold patina on both sides of this
uncommonly smooth BU eagle. Accuracy alone compels us
to mention a couple of tiny alloy spots near the lower reverse
rim. Lovely for the grade and worth more than just a casual
glance.
PCGS# 8733.
2578 1893-CC AU-58 (PCGS). Pleasingly original khaki-gold
surfaces are sharply defined in the absence of all but trivial
rub. Minimally abraded for the grade, as well, with only a few
well scattered marks that are easily overlooked. One of only
14,000 eagles struck in this swan-song year for the Carson
City Mint. A nice opportunity to obtain a near-condition
census example of a popular and fairly scarce Carson City
eagle.
2582 1899-S MS-63 (NGC). Smartly impressed with luxurious
rose-orange color, this handsome piece also exhibits a
vibrant mint finish that includes considerable reflectivity
in the fields. A nice selection for the type or date and mint
collector in terms of quality and eye appeal.
PCGS# 8744.
PCGS# 8726.
2583 1901-S MS-66 (NGC). Exquisite satin surfaces are silky
smooth in texture with vivid, highly attractive, reddish-rose
patina. A glorious Gem example of a popular branch mint
issue that is often selected for inclusion in high-grade gold
type sets.
PCGS# 8749.
2579 1893-CC AU-55 (NGC). Vibrant, satiny surfaces retain
both sharp striking detail and virtually complete luster in the
absence of all but trivial wear. Free of singularly distracting
abrasions, with bright khaki-orange color throughout. A
pleasing example of this terminal date in the Carson City
Mint’s history.
PCGS# 8726.
Page 187
Glorious Virtually Superb 1907 No Periods Indian Eagle
2584 1907 Indian. No Periods. MS-66+ (PCGS). This charming Gem is awash in smooth, frosty, yellow gold luster. Sharply struck and
exceptionally smooth, this thoroughly appealing Indian ten would serve with distinction in the finest collection of 20th century U.S.
Mint gold. Although many were saved as the first year of issue — this is still the third major type attempted to adjust the designs
to improve striking quality. At last this one was determined to work, although many scholars like David Akers have noted that the
strikes seen on this issue were little improved over the Rolled Edge style in general. Here is one of the finer and sharper examples
seen today, which has come through the grading gauntlet near the very top of those seen by PCGS. It would be hard to imagine a
more handsome and technically outstanding coin to represent this popular first year of issue.
PCGS# 8852.
PCGS Population: 25; 7 finer (Mint State-68 finest within the designation).
2585 1907 Indian. No Periods. MS-65 (NGC). Gorgeous
medium gold luster shines forth powerfully from both sides
of this smooth and satiny Gem. Among the most popular
of all 20th-century eagles, the first year of the new SaintGaudens series is well respected and a shoo-in for type sets,
especially in Gem condition.
PCGS# 8852.
2586 1907 Indian. No Periods. MS-64 (PCGS). Inviting medium
rose-orange surfaces are sharply struck, minimally abraded,
and fully lustrous with a billowy satin texture. A lovely high
grade representative of this popular first year Indian eagle
issue. Attractive examples such as this are frequently chosen
to represent the No Motto type in advanced U.S. gold type
sets.
PCGS# 8852.
Page 188
2587 1908-D Motto. MS-63 (PCGS). Lustrous with a satin to
softly frosted texture, this pretty rose-gold example also
offers razor sharp definition throughout the design. A coin
of “firsts,” the 1908-D eagle represents the first branch mint
coinage in the new Saint-Gaudens design type, as well as the
first date to bear the motto IN GOD WE TRUST.
PCGS# 8860.
2590 1910-S/S Breen-7114, VP-001. Late Die State. Repunched
Mintmark. MS-61 (NGC). A tinge of pale rose iridescence
to otherwise honey-gold surfaces provides pleasing eye
appeal in a BU Indian eagle. Moderately abraded, as perhaps
one should expect at the assigned grade level, yet free of
singularly distracting marks. The 1910-S is the most readily
available of the S-mint eagles in the design type, and is often
selected for inclusion in Mint State type sets.
PCGS# 8867.
2588 1909 MS-64 (NGC). Deep gold surfaces exhibit subtle
olive undertones as the coin rotates under a light, as well as
even fainter pale silver highlights. The strike is razor sharp
throughout, and there are few evident abrasions to overall
smooth looking surfaces. This is a condition rarity at this
grade level and much tougher to find any finer. Most seen are
in the lower Mint State grades with the expected bagmarks
from handling. Hence, this satin smooth and attractive high
grade coin will certainly grace any advanced date collection
of Indian eagles.
PCGS# 8862.
Choice Mint State
1910-S Indian Eagle
2589 1910-S MS-63 (NGC). With exceptional pinkish-gold luster
and none but a few wispy abrasions, this premium quality
example has the eye appeal of a higher grade. Worthy of
a close look, and also a strong bid. This is a low survivor
issue from this challenging series. The original mintage of
811,000 pieces does not at all reflect the modest number
seen today. Perhaps 4,000-5,000 exist, mostly in circulated
grades. Mint State coins are available but diminish markedly
in number at the Choice or finer grade. Here is one of the
nicer Choice examples that is destined for a high grade date
and mint collection of Indian eagles.
2591 1911-D AU-53 (PCGS). Overall sharply defined with
vibrant honey-gold color, this minimally circulated piece
retains ample evidence of a satin finish from the dies. From
a small mintage of just 30,100 pieces, the smallest regularissue mintage of any date in the series. Additionally, the
1911-D eagle is one of just a small number of dates in the
design type with a value of four figures or more in the VF
value column in the current edition of the Guide Book. A
pleasing AU such as the present piece makes excellent sense
in today’s numismatic marketplace.
PCGS# 8869.
2592 1911-D AU-53 (NGC). Pleasing honey-rose surfaces
are suitably bold in detail with few singularly distracting
abrasions in a lightly circulated Indian ten. This is the lowest
mintage of the regular issues struck after 1908 for this series
at 30,100 pieces. Today any example is sought after and this
attractive coin will fit well into an advanced collection of
Indian eagles.
PCGS# 8869.
2593 1914 MS-63 (NGC). Vivid orange-gold surfaces are sharply
struck, lustrous, and minimally abraded. Choice for the
assigned grade with plenty of overall eye appeal.
PCGS# 8875.
PCGS# 8867.
Page 189
Double Eagles
Scarce Choice About Uncirculated
1851-O Liberty Double Eagle
2594 1850-O AU-50 (NGC). Pleasingly original khaki-olive
surfaces are warmly and evenly toned over boldly defined
features. Moderately abraded, yet no more so than one
should expect in a lightly circulated early date double
eagle from the New Orleans Mint. Our southernmost mint
produced 141,000 double eagles in 1850, the first year of
general production in the denomination. Many of today’s
survivors from that production run tend to be VF to EF, but
at AU, as here, the population begins to thin and the elusive
nature of this scarcity shines forth. Worth a premium bid.
PCGS# 8903.
2596 1851-O AU-55 (NGC). This lovely Choice AU exhibits satiny
olive-khaki surfaces and bold to sharp devices. Minimally
abraded for a lightly circulated, early date New Orleans Mint
twenty, neither side reveals a singularly distracting blemish.
Although this date and mint is rather plentiful by New
Orleans standards, the true number of survivors is rather
low. Furthermore, this is a major condition rarity is all but
unobtainable in Uncirculated grades. Thus most collectors
who are able, pursue a lustrous Choice About Uncirculated
example for their collections, such as this pleasing example.
PCGS# 8905.
2595 1851 AU-53 (NGC). CAC. Handsome light khaki surfaces
retain flickers of original luster in the protected areas around
the devices. Minimally abraded for a circulated early date
double eagle, and impressive as such, with ample evidence
of a bold to sharp strike. Historically, these have been
regarded as much scarcer in AU than in the VF to EF grade
range. This perception is still “alive and well” as indicated by
the generous premiums commanded by AU examples in the
retail sector.
PCGS# 8904.
2597 1851-O AU-55 Details—Cleaned (ICG). Nicely toned in
warm khaki-orange, this piece is also boldly defined with
no singularly mentionable abrasions apart from a few
light scuffs to Liberty’s cheek. Quite pleasing in hand, with
stronger eye appeal than the stated impairment might imply.
A scarce and desirable issue. The 1851-O is eagerly sought
in all grades from VF to AU. Mint State examples exist,
but are very rare. Dave Bowers in his 2004 Guide Book of
Double Eagles published by Whitman, estimated a surviving
population of just 400 to 700 circulated pieces. Since that
time, some additional supplies have come out of hiding,
perhaps from overseas gold hoards, and it now appears that
there may be between 1000 and 1500 specimens accounted
for, mostly in the grade range from EF-45 to AU-55.
PCGS# 8905.
Page 190
2598 1852-O AU-53 (NGC). Vibrant with a satiny yellow gold
appearance, this captivating piece also reveals faint traces of
semi-reflectivity in the fields as the surfaces dip into a light.
Sharply defined throughout, and largely free of individually
distracting abrasions. New Orleans produced 190,000
double eagles in 1852, a number that was down considerably
from the preceding year, and a figure that foretold the future
of the denomination at the southern mint. A pleasing
example of the date and grade combination.
PCGS# 8907.
2599 1853/’2’ FS-301. AU-50 (NGC). This suitably lustrous, light
orange example retains plenty of sharp definition from a
well executed strike. Otherwise free of singularly distracting
abrasions, a shallow mark on Liberty’s cheek is noted for
accuracy. The 1853/’2’ is much scarcer that the regular-date
type. NGC population statistics suggest that only about
15% of 1853s show the overdate feature. Premiums paid for
the variety are fairly small in the VF to EF range, but spike
prominently at higher grade levels.
PCGS# 145730.
2600 1853 AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Uncommonly
attractive in light of the stated impairment, this outwardly
smooth, boldly defined example has retoned nicely in
blended khaki-gold and pinkish-rose. Some of the original
luster also remains, especially in the protected areas around
the devices. High-grade pieces are extremely scarce. Grades
most likely to be encountered in collections range from
about EF-45 to AU-58. Population estimates are conjectural
as few pieces in grades below EF-45 have been certified. In
the future it’s likely that some low-grade pieces will be culled
from available supplies when bullion prices spike, and hence
we expect the total population to gradually decline over
time.
2601 1854 Small Date. AU-58 (NGC). Predominantly lustrous
with a vibrant frosty texture, this delightful near-Mint
example is also sharply defined with vivid rose-gold color.
Scarce at this grade level and a classic condition rarity for
the collector to consider. The Small Date is more plentiful
than the Large Date issue of 1854, but neither is widely
found at this grade level.
PCGS# 8911.
Appealing Near-Mint
1854-S Double Eagle
2602 1854-S AU-58 (PCGS). Boldly impressed with nearly
complete satin luster, this coin is at the threshold of full Mint
State quality. Orange-rose surfaces are also uncommonly
smooth for the grade, and there is not so much as a single
sizable or otherwise individually distracting abrasion to
report. From the first year of production for the newly
opened San Francisco Mint, the 1854-S twenty has a modest
mintage of 141,468 pieces. Virtually all of those coins went
into immediate commercial use and stayed there until
worn out or lost, accounting for the overall scarcity of this
issue. Most survivors are well worn with Mint State coins
virtually unobtainable. Only after the recovery of some 200
to 250 coins from the wreck of the S.S. Yankee Blade did a
few higher grade pieces appear in the market. An appealing
near-Mint survivor of this early San Francisco Mint double
eagle issue.
PCGS# 8913.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: our (Bowers and
Merena’s) sale of November 2000, lot 808.
PCGS# 8908.
Page 191
Attractive and Lustrous
1855-S Liberty Double Eagle
2603 1854-S AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS). Crisp striking
detail, handsome orange gold patina and virtually complete
satin luster provide uncommonly strong eye appeal in light
of the stated impairment. One of 141,468 double eagles
struck in the first year of San Francisco Mint coinage
operations. The first 1854-S double eagle was struck on April
3, 1854, and now resides in the National Coin Collection
at the Smithsonian Institution. According to the Bowers/
Whitman reference (2004): “This is the only Proof striking
of any San Francisco Mint $20 of the design type.”
PCGS# 8913.
2604 1854-S AU Details—Tooled (PCGS). This appealing roseorange piece is sharply struck and free of sizable or otherwise
individually distracting abrasions. The stated impairment is
extremely minor and easily overlooked given the overall
strong eye appeal of this Type I double eagle. From the first
year of double eagle coinage at our westernmost mint.
2605 1855-S Variety-14E. Bold S. AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. Housed
in a special gold label S.S. Central America PCGS holder,
this beautiful piece has the eye appeal of a full Mint State
rating. Sharply defined throughout with virtually complete
luster, just the lightest bit of friction on the obverse is all
that justifies the Choice AU designation. Sure to sell for a
premium bid. Although not considered a scarce issue, at this
lofty grade level these are indeed quite scarce. A scattering
of Mint State coins are recorded, and most of these were
recovered from the S.S. Central America shipwreck. Recall
that in 1855 the California Gold Rush was in full swing,
with these double eagles pouring forth from the San
Francisco Mint and quickly entering circulation. Most of
those known are in much lower grades today, with PCGS
noting approximately 200 grading events at this grade level
or finer for this date and mint. Furthermore, most of the
coins recovered in this famed shipwreck were the 1857-S
issue a few years later, the year of the sinking. An impressive
example that will dazzle any numismatist when viewed.
PCGS# 70044.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: S.S. Central America; Heritage’s sale of September 2007, lot 3788.
PCGS# 8913.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: our (Stack’s)/Sotheby’s sale of the Dallas Bank Collection, October 2001, lot 11; and from
Goldberg’s sale of February 2009, lot 1600.
2606 1855-S AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. Truly a premium near-Mint
example, this boldly defined, lustrous piece is far smoother
than many lower Mint State Type I double eagles that we
handle in a typical year of auction activity. Worthy of a
strong bid. Although several examples were found of this
date and mint in the cargo of the S.S. Central America, this
is still a tough issue to find this well preserved—especially
so attractive. One of the primary challenges of these early
gold coins, is finding one with clean and attractive surfaces,
as noted here. Make sure not to miss this prize when the
hammer falls.
PCGS# 8916.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: our (American Numismatic Rarities’) sale of August 2006, lot 1610.
Page 192
2607 1855-S AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. Minimally abraded with
satiny original light olive-gold surfaces, this PQ example
offers exceptional technical quality and eye appeal in a nearMint State Type I twenty. By 1855, just a year after its initial
coinage runs, the San Francisco Mint was up and running
— sprinting is more like it, as the number of gold coins
produced there was up considerably from the 1854 totals.
A pleasing branch mint issue that is sure to sell for a strong
bid!
PCGS# 8916.
Merena’s) sale of June 2002, lot 2352.
2608 1855-S AU-58 (PCGS). Otherwise satiny rose-orange
surfaces exhibit a decided semi-prooflike finish in the
obverse field. Sharply struck throughout, and free of
singularly distracting abrasions. A choice and appealing
coin at every turn, and a piece that would add additional
variety to a high-grade gold type set.
PCGS# 8916.
Merena’s) sale of August 1999, lot 444.
2609 1855-S AU Details—Salt Water Damage (PCGS). Sharply
impressed with rich deep khaki patina, this minimally worn
example has the “look” of a Mint State grade. The surfaces
are lightly etched overall due to years of immersion in sea
water, but the overall appearance is uncommonly strong in
light of this impairment.
According to our consignor, this coin was salvaged as
part of the Fort Capron Treasure, a Third Seminole War
payroll lost on the reefs off Fort Pierce, Florida on May
1, 1857. In 1857, in the middle of continuous hostilities
between Federal troops and the native Seminole tribes,
Major Jeremiah Yellot Dashiell left Charleston, South
Carolina with $23,000 in his possession, entrusted to him
as payment to Federal troops stationed at Fort Capron, an
outpost near modern Fort Pierce, Florida. Dashiell found
transport on the William and Mary, and from that large
vessel took a small boat to shore — but he ran into a tiny
problem: the large sum of cash which he was charged with
protecting as an Army paymaster was spilled from the boat
when it tipped over in the surf, and it was not recovered in
the soft sand below. Congress released Dashiell from fault
the next year, despite the fact that within a month the major
portion of another payroll was stolen from him when he left
it unattended in a hotel room! The latter negligence did cost
Dashiell his job by executive order of President Buchanan.
The Fort Capron payroll was finally found over a century
later, in 1963, when the coins were discovered scattered
across the limestone deposits under the sand of what was
once an environmental feature called the Indian River
Inlet. According to a state inventory of coins located, 582
gold coins were found, fairly equally divided between $20,
$5, $2.50, and $1 gold pieces, with a smaller number of $10
eagles. Over 200 silver coins were also recovered in badly
corroded condition. In a later court action, the amateur
divers who found the treasure admitted to recovering more
than 3,000 gold coins and never reporting them to the state,
meaning that the vast majority of coins found were sold
into numismatic channels without a word of where they
were recovered — thus losing this fascinating historical
provenance. Many of the coins were scarce issues from the
Charlotte, Dahlonega, New Orleans, and San Francisco
mints — the dates on the double eagles ranged from 1850
to 1856 and included coins struck in Philadelphia, New
Orleans, and San Francisco. Further reading: Clausen,
Carl J. “The Fort Pierce American Gold Find.” The Florida
Historical Quarterly, July 1968.
PCGS# 8916.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Fort Capron Treasure, per our consignor; our (American Numismatic Rarities’) sale of
August 2006, lot 1609.
2610 1856-S AU-58 (PCGS). Handsome medium orange surfaces
are sharply defined in the absence of all but the lightest high
point rub. Also free of sizeable or otherwise troublesome
abrasions, this is easily among the nicest Choice AU 1856S double eagles that we have offered in recent sales. Scarce
and historic, as this is one of the ever popular San Francisco
issues, struck at the height of the California Gold Rush, and
apparently was carefully saved—or survived in one of the
hoards known to contain this date and mint. The most likely
source, if from a hoard, is the recovery from the S.S. Central
America shipwreck, as the coins retained their luster, while
coins from the sands of Florida in the Fort Capron Treasury
hoard are generally dull and in lower circulated grades. An
exciting example to study!
PCGS# 8919.
Page 193
2611 1856-S AU-58 (NGC). Satiny light orange surfaces are
lustrous, sharply defined and minimally abraded at the
threshold of full Mint State quality. This date and mint is
usually found with satiny luster as noted here, even David
Akers commented that he had never seen a prooflike
example of this date and mint.
2614 1856-S AU Details—Salt Water Damage (PCGS).
Appearing Mint State in terms of detail, this piece is sharply
struck throughout with no evident wear. The surfaces are
lightly etched and granular due to the stated impairment,
but with rich khaki-orange patina and freedom from
sizeable abrasions the overall eye appeal is relatively strong.
According to our consignor, this coin was recovered as part
of the Fort Capron Treasure, more information on which
is given above in our lot description of the El Dorado
Collection 1855-S double eagle that is also pedigreed to that
find.
PCGS# 8919.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Fort Capron Treasure, per our consignor; Heritage’s sale of May 2001, lot 6060.
Beautiful Choice
1857-S Double Eagle
PCGS# 8919.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Goldberg’s sale of
May 2005, lot 1690.
2612 1856-S Variety-17Q. No Serif, High S. AU-55 (PCGS).
CAC. Bright satin to softly frosted surfaces exhibit subtle
copper-rose highlights to otherwise dominant medium gold
color. A sharp and especially inviting piece, there is much
to recommend this coin to the high grade double eagle type
or date collector. Housed in a special gold label PCGS S.S.
Central Americaholder. This gently circulated coin offers a
compelling option to obtain one of these historic coins from
this most famous shipwreck as it offers so much eye appeal
and a bonanza of California Gold Rush history.
PCGS# 70026.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: S.S. Central America; our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of October 2000.
2615 1857-S Variety-20A. Spiked Shield. MS-64 (PCGS).
CAC. Housed in a special gold-label PCGSS.S. Central
Americaholder, this gorgeous near-Gem radiates a smooth,
frosty, bright gold sheen. A blush of slightly warmer reddishorange iridescence along the lower reverse border further
enhances the appearance of this enticing example. Among
the thousands of Mint State 1857-S double eagles retrieved
from the wreck of theS.S. Central America,numerous die
varieties were discovered and studied, with the present
variety among the “neater” of the varieties found. This
lot includes the originalS.S. Central Americapresentation
box and Certificate of Authenticity as distributed by the
California Gold Marketing Group, LLC.
The box and certificate are available to the winning
bidder upon request to Stack’s Bowers Galleries after the
close of the auction.
PCGS# 70000.
Ex: S.S. Central America.
2613 1856-S AU-50 (PCGS). OGH. Vivid khaki-orange patina
greets the viewer from both sides of this boldly impressed,
minimally circulated example. Largely free of singularly
distracting abrasions, although accuracy compels us to
mention wispy hairlines and a touch of glossiness to the
surface texture. Only a few thousand 1856-S double eagles
are thought to exist; Q. David Bowers provided a high-end
estimate of 3,000 pieces in his Guide Book of Double Eagles
published in 2004 — a figure that amounts to just a small
fraction of 1% of the original mintage. There is an element
of uncertainty respecting any population estimate due to the
fact that examples in grades below AU are seldom certified.
PCGS# 8919.
Page 194
2616 1857-S Variety-20F. No Serif, Right S. AU-58 (PCGS).
CAC. This sharply defined, brightly lustrous piece is
exceptionally smooth for a lightly circulated, early date San
Francisco Mint double eagle. Also possessed of endearing
pale orange and light rose patina, this delightful example
is sure to have no difficulty finding its way into another
specialized collection. Housed in a special gold label PCGS
S.S. Central America holder. The coins recovered from this
famous shipwreck are widely dispersed today, and collectors
who desire and example have to wait for one to come back
on the market. This lustrous example must have been
plucked from circulation in the summer months of 1857,
and met its fate on its long journey East. Now recovered and
carefully preserved for collectors going well into the future.
2618 1857-S AU-55 (PCGS). OGH. Satiny light gold surfaces are
further enhanced by splashes of rose-orange iridescence in
isolated areas. A sharply defined, minimally circulated piece
with no particularly worrisome abrasions. This San Francisco
double eagle was struck right at the height of the California
Gold Rush. This era is both historic and fascinating. Early
California history is rich in big ideas and big events, but
none come close to the immense impact of the Gold Rush
that really began in 1849. Holding this double eagle in your
hand elicits many thoughts and no doubt dreams of those
previous owners who carried and spent this coin as it was
intended in the channels of commerce.
PCGS# 8922.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier Ex: Sierra, August 1995.
PCGS# 70005.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: S.S. Central America; our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of April 2005, lot 3601.
2617 1857-S AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. This is a lovely near-Mint
survivor with original rose-orange patina that is a bit warmer
on the reverse. Lustrous with a satin to softly frosted texture,
a lack of singularly detracting abrasions further enhances
already strong eye appeal. A handsome, high grade example
of this date and mint that will offer hours of enjoyment to
any specialist.
2619 1858-S Unc Details—Scratch (PCGS). Vibrant semi-reflective
fields support satiny devices on both sides of this sharply
struck twenty. Vivid and highly appealing despite the stated
impairment, a couple of extremely minor scratches over and
before Liberty’s portrait are easily forgiven. This is a scarce date
to find at this grade level, and much of the eye appeal is intact.
PCGS# 8925.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Sierra, January 9,
1997.
PCGS# 8922.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier Ex: Superior’s sale of
October 2001, lot 2929.
2620 1858-S AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. Delightful reddish-khaki
patina blankets both sides of this boldly defined, nearfully lustrous survivor. Minimally abraded for the grade,
as well, most areas are outwardly smooth. All in all, this is
a lovely upper-end Type I double eagle for the Choice AU
grade level. Gold was still coming in to the San Francisco
Mint from the California gold fields in 1858, and the mint
responded with large quantities of double eagles. Choice AU
examples of the date are moderately elusive and tend to be a
solid value owing to the rarity of the issue in Mint State.
PCGS# 8925.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Heritage’s sale of July
2004, lot 8459.
Page 195
2621 1859-S AU-58 (PCGS). Richly toned in blended olive
and rose-orange, this handsome piece retains sharp to full
definition throughout. The luster is also virtually complete,
an otherwise softly frosted texture yielding to modest, yet
appreciable semi-reflective tendencies in the obverse field.
A superior double eagle in all regards, both for the issue as
a whole and the assigned grade. No Mint State examples of
this date and mint were found in the various treasure hoards
or from importations, thus high grade examples like this are
still scarce and find strong demand when they are offered.
PCGS# 8928.
2623 1859-S FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. AU-58 (PCGS).
Original khaki-gold surfaces reveal considerable bright satin
luster as the coin rotates under a light. A boldly struck and
minimally circulated example with no abrasions that are out
of context for the assigned grade. Light doubling is noted
at LIBERTY on the obverse. The mintage for the 1859-S
double eagle was down more than 200,000 pieces from the
tally of the previous year. The date is moderately elusive in
Choice AU, as here, and downright rare in Mint State, which
is why many savvy collectors appreciate the AU-58 grade.
PCGS# 145732.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Heritage’s sale of
January 2007, lot 6266.
2622 1859-S AU-58 (PCGS). Soft satin to frosty luster blends with
vivid pinkish rose toning on both sides of this lovely nearMint twenty. Remarkably smooth for the assigned grade,
especially on the obverse, a blush of faint orange-copper
tinting in the upper reverse field is not readily evident at all
angles. A scarce issue this well preserved with high grade
pieces always finding strong collector demand when offered.
Here is one of the nicer examples we’ve handled and is
destined for specialized collection of double eagles or San
Francisco issues.
August 2001, lot 7990.
2624 1859-S EF-40 (PCGS). OGH. Undeniably original, medium
khaki surfaces are boldly defined with faint remnants of
original luster discernible in isolated areas. A few light scuffs
in the left obverse field are the only individually mentionable
abrasions. An affordable alternative to a high-grade AU or
Uncirculated example of the date.
PCGS# 8928.
PCGS# 8928.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Sierra, August 1,
1995.
Page 196
Conditionally Challenging Mint
State 1860 Liberty Double Eagle
2625 1860 MS-62+ (NGC). This delightful Mint State example
exhibits dominant reddish-orange patina that lightens a bit
to a medium gold shade toward the centers. The luster is full
and frosty throughout, and an impressively sharp strike is
also seen in all areas. Wispy abrasions are uncommonly few
in number for both the issue and the assigned grade, with the
result that this piece is certain to see spirited bidding among
advanced Liberty double eagle collectors. While the mintage
of 577,760 pieces may seem generous today, recall that only
a handful exist in true Mint State condition today. Here is
one that nudges quite close to the Choice grade level, and
as such is one of only 2 seen at this grade level with a mere
dozen grading events of finer examples noted in the NGC
Census. A classic condition rarity and a solid representative
of this date and mint for the advanced specialist.
2627 1860-S AU-53 (NGC). OH. Pale khaki undertones give
way to dominant rose-orange patina as the surfaces dip
into a light. Sharply defined throughout, with no abrasions
that are out of context for a lightly circulated Type I double
eagle. Only 544,950 examples were minted, one of the
lowest production figure of any $20 issue struck at the San
Francisco Mint. Dave Bowers’ high-end population estimate
for the issue was scarcely more than 2,500 pieces which
seems to dove-tail nicely with up-to-date population data
from the two major certification services.
PCGS# 8931.
PCGS# 8929.
NGC Census: 2; only 12 are finer (Mint State-65 finest).
2628 1861 AU-58 (NGC). Lustrous medium gold surfaces exhibit
a satiny texture that is uncommonly free of sizable abrasions
in a lightly circulated Type I twenty. Boldly struck, and
perfect for near-Mint type purposes. This ever-popular date
is often selected for inclusion in Civil War-era type sets, a
popular pursuit among American numismatists..
PCGS# 8932.
2626 1860-S AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. A gorgeous piece in all
regards, both sides are highly lustrous with satiny and vivid
orange-gold features. There are remarkably few abrasions of
even a small size for a lightly circulated Type I twenty, and
the outward appearance of this coin is not all that far from
what we would expect to see at the Select Mint State grade
level. Premium quality, for sure, and worthy of a strong bid.
This popular San Francisco Mint issue grows in scarcity the
farther up the grading ladder we go. VF and EF examples are
relatively plentiful and available for a price, and in Choice
AU the true nature of this elusive issue comes to light. Many
consider the date downright rare in Mint State, making a
Choice AU coin a great acquisition.
PCGS# 8931.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from our (Stack’s) sale
of the R.L. Miles, Jr. Collection, October 1968, lot 852; our (Bowers and
Merena’s) sale of the Harry W. Bass, Jr. Collection, Part II, October
1999, lot 1739.
Page 197
Legendary 1861-S
Tied for
2629 1861-S A.C. Paquet Reverse. AU-58 (PCGS). Secure
Holder. Truly remarkable quality in an example of this
rare and challenging double eagle issue, the amount of
remaining detail is the first feature that impresses us
in this regard. The obverse is bold apart from minor
softness to a few of the stars, while the reverse is even
sharper with particularly intricate detail to the eagle’s
plumage. Clearly this is a well produced piece, although
the exceptional level of surface preservation also helps
to explain the crispness of detail on the reverse. The
principle downfall of the Paquet reverse design was
its inability to wear well due to the narrowness of the
rim, so the present example obviously saw very little
commercial use.
Further confirming the accuracy of the near-Mint
designation from PCGS is the vibrancy and virtual
fullness of the luster that remains on both sides. The
texture is a blend of equally desirable satin and softly
frosted qualities that mingle nicely with fresh, original,
rose-orange patina. Scattered abrasions are typical
Page 198
in a circulated 1861-S Paquet Reverse double eagle,
although we stress that most are small enough to be
singularly inconspicuous to the eye. In fact, the only
readily evident pedigree markers are a concentration
of shallow scuffs over and around Liberty’s nose and
another faint obverse scuff in the field between stars 12
and 13. Thoroughly appealing in all regards, and rare
as such for this key date issue, this beautiful Condition
Census piece would serve as a highlight in the finest
double eagle cabinet.
Anthony C. Paquet was born in Hamburg,
Germany in 1814 and emigrated to the United States
in 1848. The son of a bronze worker, he opened an
engraving business in New York before being hired as
assistant engraver at the Philadelphia Mint in 1857. He
prepared several unsigned patterns while at the Mint,
as well as numerous signed medals. Most notably, he
also engraved the military’s highest decoration, the
first pattern Medal of Honor (which bears his script
signature on the obverse). The double eagle reverse
Paquet Double Eagle
Finest Known
remains the only coin design positively attributed to
Paquet. He died in Philadelphia in 1882.
Paquet preferred a tall and thin logotype style easily
discernible from Chief Engraver James Longacre’s
more squat font. The differences between the two dies
can be readily seen with the letter O: the space between
the uprights is extremely thin on Paquet’s reverse
while Longacre’s O is much wider. In addition, the
central halo of stars above the eagle are separate from
the background rays on Paquet’s dies, but are nestled
in the rays in Longacre’s work. Four pairs of dies with
Paquet’s reverse were prepared at the Philadelphia
Mint in November 1860 and shipped to San Francisco
in December. On January 5, 1861 production with the
new reverse dies began at the Philadelphia Mint. It was
almost immediately halted after concerns were raised
that the narrow rim of the reverse design would lead
to poor wearing characteristics. Mint Director James
Ross Snowden sent a directive to the San Francisco
Mint to halt coinage with the new dies and revert
to Longacre’s older reverse. The message — sent via
telegraph and overland express — did not reach the
San Francisco Mint in time to prevent production. A
total of 19,250 double eagles with Paquet’s reverse were
struck in the San Francisco Mint and subsequently
issued before the cease order could be implemented.
While only two Philadelphia Mint Paquet reverse
double eagles are presently known, approximately 100
S-mint examples are in numismatic circles. No Mint
State examples have been graded by either PCGS or
NGC, however, and the vast majority of surviving
examples are heavily worn. The appearance of a Choice
AU example, as here, is certainly a newsworthy auction
event. A legendary coin from an often overlooked
engraver.
PCGS# 8936.
PCGS Population: only 3; none finer.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: H. Jeff Browning;
our (Stack’s, in conjunction with Sotheby’s) sale of the “Dallas Bank”
Collection, October 2001, lot 31.
Page 199
2630 1861-S AU-58 (PCGS). Variegated tan-orange and deep
rose colors compete for dominance over both sides of this
sharp near-Mint survivor. A touch of light haziness to the
obverse is noted for accuracy, but we are unable to locate
any sizeable or otherwise singularly mentionable abrasions.
Mint State examples of this date and mint are downright
rare and seldom offered, and finding an attractive AU-58
like coin would make an excellent selection for the advanced
date and mint collector to represent this issue.
PCGS# 8935.
2631 1861-S AU-55 (PCGS). Suitably lustrous for the assigned
grade, both sides also possess bold to sharp definition and
freedom from sizeable handling marks. Warm, even, honey
gold patina rounds out an impressive list of attributes for
this Brother Jonathan treasure coin. This is a tough date to
find appreciably finer as there are no more than a few dozen
that qualify in the lower ranges of Mint State of this date
and mint. As such this attractive AU-55 specimen is one of
the finer pieces that can be readily obtained, and with an
excellent provenance too.
PCGS# 8935.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: S.S. Brother Jonathan, No. 112; our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of May 1999, lot 112.
Frosty and Bright Mint State 1862-S Double Eagle
2632 1862-S MS-61 (PCGS). Softly frosted in finish with a vibrant rose-gold appearance, this boldly impressed condition rarity belongs
in another notable double eagle collection. There are few singularly distracting abrasions — a rare and highly desirable attribute in
a BU gold coin of this size. While the mintage of 854,173 pieces may seem more than adequate, not many survived in Mint State
condition, in fact not even a few dozen have been seen by PCGS that qualify at the level for this date and mint. In conclusion, this
is one of the finer examples seen today and a coin that would make a wise addition to any advanced collection of this series.
PCGS# 8938.
PCGS Population: 8; just 9 are finer (Mint State-63 finest).
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Superior’s sale of November 1996, lot 2513.
Page 200
Mint State 1862-S
Liberty Double Eagle
2633 1862-S MS-61 (NGC). Well struck for an early S-mint
double eagle, especially on the reverse, this vibrant
yellow gold example exhibits billowy mint luster
throughout. There are uncommonly few abrasions for
the assigned grade, and certainly none that are sizeable
or otherwise singularly distracting when closely
examined. This is a true condition rarity when found
in any Mint State grade, as only a handful seen today
qualify at this most desired grade range. Although the
mintage was reasonably large for the era, this date and
mint is represented by extremely sparing numbers
in Uncirculated grades as noted below in the NGC
Census numbers. As such, this handsome piece is
no doubt headed for an advanced date and mint or
specialized San Francisco collection of double eagles.
2635 1863 Net EF-40 (ANACS). AU Details—Cleaned. OH.
Bold striking detail and freedom from all but light wear
enhance the appeal of this piece. Bold khaki-orange color
also presents quite well given the stated impairment,
although we are compelled to mention considerable
glossiness to the texture that points to polishing. A very
scarce date with an estimated population in the range of 300
to 400 pieces in all grades combined, a figure that’s less than
1% of the original mintage (142,790 coins). Most examples
seen range in grade from EF-45 to AU-58.
PCGS# 8939.
Important Mint State
1863-S Double Eagle
PCGS# 8938.
2634 1862-S EF-45 (NGC). Warmly toned in even honey-orange,
glimmers of original luster are still discernible in isolated
areas as the surfaces rotate under a light. Boldly defined
for the grade, with no sizeable or otherwise individually
distracting abrasions. David Akers regarded the 1862-S as
“one of the rarest dates from the San Francisco Mint.” The
issue is scarce enough at the EF-45 level to be routinely
certified for inclusion in collections.
2636 1863-S MS-61 (PCGS). Pretty rose-orange patina
mingles with vibrant, satiny luster on both sides of
this minimally abraded survivor. Boldly defined
throughout, with no mentionable blemishes apart
from a faint alloy spot that is well concealed at the top
of Liberty’s head. The vast majority of 1863-S double
eagles extant are in VF and EF grades. Not until the
coins from the S.S. Brother Jonathanshipwreck were
discovered did appreciable numbers of examples at
higher levels of preservation appear in today’s market.
An always popular Civil War date, with the distinct
S mintmark also associating this piece with the early
days of the Wild West.
PCGS# 8940.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: our (Bowers
and Merena’s) sale of January 2003, lot 756.
PCGS# 8938.
Page 201
Condition Rarity Mint State
1863-S Liberty Double Eagle
2637 1863-S MS-61 (PCGS). Pretty honey-rose patina
mingles with soft, satiny luster on both sides of this
endearing Type I twenty. Sharply struck with an
uncommonly smooth “look” at the BU grade level,
even wispy abrasions hardly detract from the strong
visual appeal of this piece. A tough issue to find in
any Mint State grade and this is borne out by the
Population data noted. There simply are not more than
a few dozen at this grade level, and finer pieces thin out
quickly. Hence, if you are a serious collector of Liberty
double eagles, you would do well to secure this high
grade example for your advanced collection, as not
many may be offered for a long time to come.
2638 1863-S AU-58 (NGC). Speckles of russet color aside, this is
an evenly toned, medium orange piece with traces of luster
discernible as the surfaces rotate under a light. The obverse
is a bit lightly struck overall, as often noted for the issue, but
wear is expectably minimal for the grade, and the reverse is
bold throughout. The 1863-S was once regarded as a very
scarce date in AU and higher grades, but a supply of coins
grading AU and finer was recovered from the wreck of the
S.S. Brother Jonathan in the 1990s, enabling collectors to
upgrade their holdings. Population estimates for the 1863S are conjectural because few pieces in grades lower than
EF-45 have ever been certified. The two leading services
— considered together — have certified fewer than 2,000
specimens in all grades.
PCGS# 8940.
PCGS# 8940.
2639 1863-S AU-55 (PCGS). CAC. Soft, billowy, frosty textured
luster is very much in evidence on both sides of this
handsome Choice AU double eagle. Free of mentionable
abrasions, with vivid light orange and medium rose
patina that is a bit bolder on the reverse. This grade level
is a challenge to find for this date and mint. Not many are
known in full Mint State, and any Choice AU example like
this is a scarce item today. Struck during the depths of the
Civil War, when much of the nation was focused on that
horrific event unfolding in the East.
PCGS# 8940.
2640 1863-S AU-50 (NGC). Original khaki-orange patina
blankets both sides of this moderately abraded, yet overall
boldly defined survivor. Only a small portion of the
estimated total population has survived at the AU level.
PCGS# 8940.
Page 202
Pleasing Mint State 1864-S Liberty Double Eagle
2641 1864-S MS-62 (PCGS). Full satin to softly frosted luster is bathed in a blend of gorgeous reddish-orange and pale rose patina. The
strike is well balanced and uniformly bold throughout, and both the technical quality and eye appeal are superior in an example of
this conditionally challenging S-mint issue. Although a total of 793,660 pieces were struck, most of these entered circulation or were
melted in the following decades. Today the number believed to exist is a paltry 2,500 or so according to CoinFacts website. Mint State
examples represent less than five percent of those seen, and Choice examples are virtually unobtainable of this date and mint. This
solid MS-62 coin is destined for an advanced collection of double eagles.
A generation ago the landscape of collecting Type 1 double eagles was forever changed. First off, most of the known coins from this
era (1850 to 1866-S) were circulated. A typical date and mint thirty years ago was represented by less than one percent of those struck, the
balance melted or lost long ago. So date and mint collectors had a tremendous challenge finding the scarcer dates, some of which were
represented by fewer than 100 known coins. In the 20th century after World War II advances in scuba diving and skills allowed many
shallow shipwrecks to be recovered, including a fair number of coins, including a scattering of Type I double eagles. Then new advances
were developed in shipwreck recovery which allowed deep water wrecks to be found and their contents recovered by remotely operated
vehicles. The most famous of these is the S.S. Central America, which sank in 1857 with a massive cargo of gold ingots and coins—right
from the height of the California Gold Rush. Another famous shipwreck that had a quantity of Type I double eagles was the S.S. Republic
that sank in 1865. Some of the coins recovered on that ship were dated 1865 or 1865-S in the form of Double eagles. One 1864-S recovered
from that shipwreck is apparently the finest known today, but only a few mint state 1864-S double eagles were found from that source. The
result of these shipwrecks being recovered has allowed additional collectors to own a true Mint State double eagle from this important era,
some of the dates and mints that were virtually unobtainable before these unique shipwreck recoveries were brought to the surface.
PCGS# 8942.
2642 1864-S AU-58 (PCGS). This outstanding near-Mint twenty
offers handsome reddish-orange patina, sharp devices and
nearly complete satin luster. Worthy of a strong bid, as this
minimally abraded example is also smoother than many
lower Mint State Type I double eagles that we have handled
over the years. True Mint State pieces are very rare, and
this specimen is ever so close to that grade level, with only
a whisper of wear on the uppermost points. Truly a tough
date and mint at this grade level that should not be missed.
this is an important condition rarity from the Civil War era.
PCGS# 8942.
2643 1864-S AU-58 (PCGS). Lovely light honey surfaces retain
nearly complete luster in a billowy satin texture. Minimally
abraded for the grade, with sharp striking detail that further
enhances already strong technical quality. Typically available
in VF and EF, forays into Choice AU are not common
occurrences, and Mint State examples of the date were
downright rare until a couple of dozen or so Uncirculated
coins came into the marketplace upon the dispersal of the
S.S. Brother Jonathan treasure.
PCGS# 8942.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: S.S. Brother Jonathan, inventory number 388; our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of the S.S.
Brother Jonathan Treasure Coins, May 1999, lot 392.
Page 203
2644 1865 EF-45 (PCGS). OGH. Handsome khaki-orange
surfaces are originally and uncommonly well preserved in a
Choice EF Type I twenty. Outwardly smooth in virtually all
areas, with plenty of bold to sharp definition remaining. A
popular date and grade combination from the final year of
Type I double eagle coinage.
PCGS# 8943.
2647 1865-S AU-58 (PCGS). This is a colorful, deep rose and
medium orange example that also sports sharp to full
definition throughout the design. With a vibrant, softly
frosted texture and no mentionable abrasions, there is much
to recommend this coin to the high grade double eagle
collector. This coin must have slipped into circulation for
a very brief time before boarding the ill fated S.S. Brother
Jonathan. The surfaces are quite pleasing to study for their
quality, luster and strike.
PCGS# 8944.
2645 1865-S MS-60 (NGC). CAC—Gold Label. OH. Delightful
rose-orange surfaces are boldly struck throughout with
billowy, frosty mint luster. Uncommonly abrasion free for
the assigned grade, both the technical quality and eye appeal
are suggestive of a significantly higher Mint State rating.
Worthy of a premium bid! The 1865-S was once regarded
as a major rarity in Mint State, but the recovery of more
than 600 Uncirculated examples from the wreck of the S.S.
Brother Jonathan in 1999 greatly changed the situation;
many collectors who would have been compelled to settle
for a VF or EF example a generation ago can now acquire a
nice Mint State specimen instead. Virtually all Uncirculated
pieces available today can trace their origins to that source.
Seldom Offered 1866-S
No Motto Double Eagle
PCGS# 8944.
2646 1865-S Unc Details—Altered Surfaces (PCGS). Blushes
of pale rose interrupt otherwise dominant medium gold
patina on both sides of this sharply impressed piece. Free
of both wear and sizable abrasions, wispy hairlines and a
curious satin-like texture confirm the stated impairment.
An ever-popular date with fame and popularity that was
notably increased when the S.S. Brother Jonathantreasure
was recovered.
2648 1866-S No Motto. AU Details—Smoothed (PCGS).
With bold to sharp devices and freedom from
singularly distracting abrasions, this coin presents
exceptionally well in light of the stated impairment.
Smoothing is minimal, in fact, and largely confined to
the obverse, leaving the reverse with a fresh, original
“look.” Attractively toned in vivid khaki-rose, this coin
is worthy of careful bidder consideration, especially
given the rarity and key date status of the 1866-S No
Motto double eagle. Famed as one of the rarest San
Francisco Mint double eagles of this type, the 1866S No Motto has long been in demand. Almost all
survivors are circulated with a mere seven Mint State
grading events recorded at both PCGS and NGC
combined.
PCGS# 8944.
Merena’s) sale of May 1999, lot 798.
Page 204
PCGS# 8945.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from our (Bowers
and Merena’s) sale of March 2001, lot 257.
A Second High Grade 1866-S No Motto Twenty
2649 1866-S No Motto. AU Details—Improperly Cleaned (NGC). There is much to recommend this key date Type I double eagle to the
sharp-eyed collector. Both sides offer uncommonly sharp definition in a lightly circulated ‘66-S No Motto and bold, even, khakirose patina also makes a positive impression. An overall subdued, matte-like texture points to a cleaning, but with no sizeable or
otherwise singularly distracting marks, this piece is sure to sell for a strong bid. Worthy of careful bidder consideration. These were
struck early in 1866 at the San Francisco Mint. However, in 1865 the new Motto had been adopted for inclusion on all coins large
enough to support, thus IN GOD WE TRUST was to be added to all but the smallest coins. New dies were prepared with the new
Motto and sent to San Francisco, but they apparently did not arrive in time and coinage began using the old style dies without the
Motto above the eagle. Records state that 120,000 were struck, but this number seems to high based on the far fewer coins seen
today—in a relative fashion. What is known today is that the 1866-S No Motto is one of the toughest issues to find at all, especially so
above the grade of Very Fine or so. Apparently those that did survive, circulated long and hard before being saved. This high grade
example will be a coin that’s hard to top in terms of wear and surface quality.
PCGS# 8945.
2650 1866 MS-60 (PCGS). Sharply impressed with handsome,
original patina, both sides are awash in honey gold with
lighter pinkish rose highlights in isolated areas. Luster is full
and vibrant, and none of the grade defining abrasions are
worthy of individual attention. A scarce date and mint in
full Mint State as most of those known show at least some
degree of circulation on the high points. Further, this is the
first year of the new style, which includes the adopted Motto
on the reverse of IN GOD WE TRUST. A highly desirable
coin for the date and mint specialist.
PCGS# 8949.
2651 1866 MS-60 (ANACS). OH. Crisply impressed devices,
vivid reddish-rose color and modestly semi-prooflike
surfaces provide superior eye appeal at the basal Mint State
grade level. A very scarce and desirable issue in Uncirculated
condition. Dave Bowers in his 2004 Guide Book of Double
Eagles published by Whitman, estimated a Mint State
population of just 15 to 25 different pieces. It is possible that
a few additional examples have come out of hiding since
that time, perhaps from overseas bank reserves.
PCGS# 8949.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Superior’s sale of
March 2000, lot 1016.
Page 205
Lustrous and Scarce 1866-S Motto Double Eagle
2652 1866-S Motto. AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. A thoroughly appealing piece, both sides are near fully lustrous with vivid toning in a blend
of deep rose and medium orange. A sharply executed strike and freedom from troubling abrasions round out an impressive list of
attributes for this premium near-Mint double eagle. This is one of the toughest San Francisco issues, as noted by David Akers the
1866-S Motto is on par with the 1860-S, 1861-S, 1862-S, 1864-S, 1867-S, and 1868-S issues. At this high grade level, it is that much
tougher to find and certainly quite difficult to surpass in quality. The finest seen was recently discovered in the Saddle Ridge Hoard
of gold coins, and that piece tops the PCGS Population Report at MS-62+.
PCGS# 8950.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Heritage’s sale of January 2002, lot 8390.
Enticing 1866-S Motto Liberty Twenty
2653 1866-S Motto. AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. Enchanting rose-gold luster flows over both sides in a softly frosted texture. Minimally worn
and positively free of singularly mentionable abrasions, this bold Type II double eagle is sure to please even the most discerning
gold specialist. This is a tough condition rarity at this grade level, and an issue which is difficult to find in true Mint State condition.
The finest seen is MS-62+. Demand must have been high for double eagles in 1866 as most of these clearly circulated, and few were
saved that today can claim the AU grade level with most falling into the Very Fine to Extremely Fine grade range. Here is a high end
coin that is destined for an advanced collection.
PCGS# 8950.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Superior’s sale of February 2003, lot 7316.
Page 206
Brilliant 1869-S Double Eagle
2654 1866-S Motto. AU-55 (PCGS). CAC. Plenty of softly frosted
luster remains on both sides of this suitably bold, pale orange
example. This issue is tough and is comparable in rarity to most
of the dates from the 1860s of the San Francisco Mint double
eagles. Mint State examples are formidable rarities of this date
and mint, and hence most collectors try to locate a pleasing
About Uncirculated example like this for their specialized
collections. An impressive and desirable example of this first
appearance of the new Motto on the double eagle in 1866.
PCGS# 8950.
2655 1867-S AU-58 (PCGS). Boldly toned in deep khaki-rose,
this minimally abraded, outwardly smooth piece has much
to entice the collector specializing in high grade Liberty
double eagles. An original mintage of 920,750 pieces would
seem to allow for a number of finer examples today, but this
not at all the case. These were not saved nor did large numbers
survive overseas apparently, at least not in Choice condition!
The finest seen by PCGS is Mint State-62. Therefore this is
a high condition rarity but is rather available in moderately
circulated grades. An enticing example for the date and
mint specialist that should not be overlooked.
2657 1869-S MS-62 (NGC). Gorgeous satin luster greets the
viewer from both sides of this exceptionally vibrant,
yellow gold example. Sharply struck for the type and
minimally abraded for the grade, it is not a stretch for
us to write that the surfaces are silent on the subject
of distracting abrasions. Most examples are found in
circulated grades with Mint State coins scarce to rare
in all grades. Premium quality for a BU double eagle,
this piece is sure to sell for a strong bid.1869 was the
year of the infamous Black Friday when Jay Gould and
James Fisk attempted to corner the gold market. Gould
and Fisk bought large quantities of gold to the point
where the market premium on a double eagle was
almost one third higher than at the start of the year. On
that fateful Friday the 24th of September, $4,000,000
in government gold hit the market causing the price to
plummet, ruining many investors.
PCGS# 8956.
NGC Population: 13; only 3 finer.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier Ex: Goldberg’s
sale of May 2007, lot 1712.
PCGS# 8952.
2656 1868-S AU-58 (PCGS). Exquisite deep orange surfaces are
lustrous, boldly struck and uncommonly distraction free in
a lightly circulated gold coin of this size. Impressive nearMint quality for the discerning double eagle collector. A
scarce date in AU, and one that is downright rare in Mint
State. Choice AU examples such as the present piece never
fail attract a wide bidding audience.
PCGS# 8954.
2658 1869-S AU-58 (PCGS). Satiny and vibrant, this beautiful
near-Mint twenty also offers bold definition and freedom
from singularly distracting abrasions. Much more rare in AU
and Mint State than its mintage of 686,750 pieces indicates.
Though plentiful in VF and EF, no hoard quantifies of
the date were ever unearthed, and pleasing Choice AU
specimens such as that presently offered are about the best a
serious collector is apt to encounter today.
PCGS# 8956.
Merena’s) sale of December 2001, lot 6408.
Page 207
2659 1870-S AU-58 (PCGS). Decidedly prooflike in finish, this
vivid khaki-rose example reveals semi-reflective tendencies
in the fields as the surfaces dip into a light. Boldly struck with
few readily evident abrasions, there is much to recommend
this coin to the advanced Liberty double eagle collector. San
Francisco was the mint of choice for double eagles during
the era, and coins from that mint tend to be readily available
in most grades up to AU, though there the population dips
somewhat. Choice AU-58 examples of the date are always in
demand, and pleasing examples such as the present coin will
be eagerly pursued no matter the venue.
2662 1873 Open 3. MS-60 (NGC). Original orange-gold surfaces
are boldly struck with a fully lustrous, frosty texture. First
popularized by the late Harry X Boosell, the Open 3 and
Close 3 varieties of 1873 were spread across just about every
denomination, including the double eagles of the date. Many
collectors today include both styles of the date in their cabinets.
PCGS# 8967.
PCGS# 8959.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Smythe’s sale of July
2009, lot 745.
2660 1871-S MS-60 (NGC). Satiny and vibrant, this boldly
impressed, medium orange example is uncommonly free
of singularly distracting abrasions in a BU double eagle.
Not a prominent rarity in the series, but elusive enough in
Mint State grades to draw attention whenever an example
is offered publicly. Most of the known Mint State 1871-S
double eagles are in MS-60 to MS-62 or thereabouts.
PCGS# 8962.
2663 1873-S Close 3. MS-62 (PCGS). CAC. This highly lustrous,
rose gold beauty exhibits a lovely frosty texture to both sides.
Well struck for the type with uncommonly smooth surfaces
at the BU grade level, this captivating example is sure to
please the advanced double eagle collector. Although lower
grade Mint State coins are available with patience, this is one
of the finer examples seen today as noted by the Population
Report information below. The Close 3 designation refers
to how the knobs on the 3 are quite close together, giving
the appearance of an 8 instead of the intended 3, this fault
was noticed early on in the year, and new dies were ordered
which created considerable extra work for the mints, as well
as an interesting variation for collectors to study.
PCGS# 8969.
PCGS Population: 17; only 3 are finer (Mint State-63 finest) within the Close 3 designation.
September 2003, lot 2000.
2661 1872-S AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. Endearing orange-gold luster
flows over both sides with a vibrant satin texture. Well struck
for this challenging issue; a general lack of sizable abrasions
further establishes this coin as a PQ near-Mint 1872-S
double eagle. As noted in the Bowers/Whitman volume on
the denomination: “The 1872-S is another one of those San
Francisco Mint double eagles that can be found in quantity
in worn grades, but for which even a low-level Mint State
coin is rare.” At AU-58, as here, there should be an exciting
round of bidding activity.
2664 1873-S Open 3. AU-58 (PCGS). CAC. Sharply struck and
uncommonly so in a Type II double eagle, this captivating
piece also sports billowy satin luster and wonderfully original
rose-gold patina. Typically located in VF and EF, with AU
examples only moderately elusive. The mintage for the date
of just under 1.1 million coins includes the Close 3 and Open
3 varieties of the date, with the Open 3 variety offered here
nominally more elusive than its Close 3 counterpart.
PCGS# 8965.
PCGS# 8979.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Smythe’s sale of July
2004, lot 746.
Page 208
2665 1874-CC EF-45 (NGC). A few swirls of copper-russet
notwithstanding, this is a predominantly honey-gold example.
Partially lustrous with suitably bold definition in a lightly
circulated ‘74-CC double eagle, wispy handling marks and a
touch of surface glossiness is mentioned solely for accuracy. This
is the first year that double eagles from the Carson City Mint
are somewhat obtainable in circulated grades, but certainly not
common. In Mint State condition, the few seen that qualify at
that level tend to be close to the MS-60 grade in quality.
PCGS# 8971.
2668 1876-S MS-62 (PCGS). Satin to softly frosted luster
swirls around both sides of this uncommonly vibrant,
minimally abraded BU double eagle. Really a lovely piece,
sharp devices and vivid reddish-orange patina are also
praiseworthy attributes. This is the final year of issue of the
Type II design, when 1877 began the reverse master hub for
double eagles was changed to read TWENTY DOLLARS
instead of TWENTY D. Not many survive much finer than
this attractive coin, and this is also the Centennial year since
America declared her independence.
PCGS# 8978.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II.
2666 1874-S MS-62 (PCGS). Blended medium orange and rose-gold
colors greet the viewer from both sides of this lightly abraded
BU example. Lustrous and frosty, a suitably bold strike in a Type
II double eagle also provides superior eye appeal at the assigned
grade level. This date and mint is plentiful in circulated grades,
as one would expect from the generous mintage of 1,214,000
coins. However, Mint State pieces are scarce, but available
as high as MS-61. Beyond that and the 1874-S becomes a
classic condition rarity. Neither grading service has awarded
any examples with a grade above MS-63. If you are seeking
to assemble a high grade collection, then this splendid MS-62
would be a focal coin in this auction to obtain.
2669 1878 MS-62 (PCGS). This vibrantly lustrous satin-textured
piece is awash in vivid rose-gold iridescence. A fully struck
and minimally abraded BU with plenty of eye appeal. Choice
for the grade and a wise selection for a type collection.
PCGS# 8985.
PCGS# 8972.
2667 1875-CC VF-35 (NGC). This richly toned, crimson-khaki
example retains ample boldness of detail for a mid-grade
Type II double eagle from the Carson City Mint. Free of
singularly mentionable abrasions, as well, and sure to appeal
to specialized gold collectors. A very popular issue with
collectors as are all Carson City Mint double eagles. Unlike
most Philadelphia Mint and San Francisco Mint issues
from the same era, Carson City Mint double eagles always
receive a warm reception from the numismatic community
regardless of grade, and many specialists are eager to acquire
VF specimens for their cabinets.
2670 1879-CC VF-25 (NGC). Warm russet outlines to the devices
interrupt otherwise dominant, even color in a handsome
khaki-gold. Wispy handling marks are mentioned for
accuracy, although a lack of singularly distracting abrasions
is an uncommon attribute in a CC-mint double eagle,
particularly one that saw this extensive circulation. Mintage
of only 42,565 pieces and today and Rusty Goe estimates
that between 1,250 and 1,450 of these exist today. Many of
course were shipped overseas and melted, greatly reducing
the original mintage to the numbers seen today. Always in
high collector demand for the Carson City Mintmark and
rich history of its production.
PCGS# 8989.
PCGS# 8974.
Page 209
One of the Finest Known Gem Ultra
Exceptional Quality
2671 1882 Proof-65 Ultra Cameo (NGC). This
extraordinary coin offers hours of enjoyment and
study, as the bold visual effect of the Ultra Cameo
contrast is so dramatic. Glassy, deeply reflective
fields form a splendid backdrop to fully defined,
frosty textured devices on both sides of this simply
outstanding Proof Liberty double eagle. There is
nary a detracting blemish to report, which feature is
particularly desirable in the fields since it allows one
to fully appreciate the handsome “orange peel” texture
for which many later date Proof Liberty gold coins
are known. Bathed in luxurious deep orange patina,
this coin is sure to find its way into one of the finest
collections of classic U.S. Mint Proof coinage ever
assembled. The original mintage came in at 59 pieces
in the Proof format. From that small issue, perhaps 13
to 15 survive today in all grades, this Gem example
is clearly one of the finest known. Furthermore it
offers the exquisite Ultra Cameo contrast between the
perfectly mirrored fields and highly frosted devices.
As so few of these Proof double eagles were struck in
1882, the dies retained their utmost polish and most
Page 210
of the Proofs were imparted with either the Cameo
or Ultra Cameo contrast. Worthy of note is the fact
that this is also a low mintage date for the regular issue
with a mere 590 pieces struck for circulation for the
entire year, creating one of the key dates of the Liberty
double eagle series, in Proof or Mint State grades. There
is a single 1882 double eagle certified a point finer by
NGC with the Ultra Cameo contrast, and their Census
notes two coins at this grade level. The website notes
two examples they consider to be PR-65 Deep Cameo
and possibly three others as PR-64 Deep Cameo, so
this example is certainly one of the finest of this select
group. In absolute terms of preservation, the surfaces
are a marvel as they show so few signs of handling or
blemishes from the past 132 years since it was struck.
Precisely how the dramatic “orange peel” effect was
created on these early Proof coins has been subject
to considerable speculation. Noted researcher John
Dannreuther has discovered the Proof coin planchets
were first heated prior to striking, and this process
helps to create the “orange peel” effect in the fields
when the coins were struck. When examining the
Cameo Proof 1882 Liberty Double Eagles
and Eye Appeal
fields notice how they appear as perfectly smooth as
glass—yet also appear to have a texture that looks
much like the surface of an orange peel. Some liken
this to the appearance of sun baked dry mud that has
cracked up into thousands of interlocking pieces. Most
of the Proof gold, as well as other Proof coins, show
the “orange peel” texture when closely examined, and
this is part of the unique process created for the most
visual impact on Proof coinage of this era.
better system to use as was applied in Manhattan in
1882. However, as time and economy have dictated,
the alternating current electrical system proved to be
cheaper to deliver and more efficient, and thus became
the adopted standard in later years. One must give a
nod to this rapidly changing era when this double
eagle was struck, as the future was being developed,
and invented, with each day filled with change and
opportunity for those with ideas and capital.
When you hold this majestic jewel in your hands
recall that history was unfolding in that very year. The
famed outlaw Jesse James was gunned down for the
sizable reward money offered—by his fellow outlaw
Robert Ford in his own residence in St. Joseph, Missouri.
Meanwhile, the inexorable march of progress lit up
Manhattan, literally—as Thomas A. Edison started
the world’s first commercial electric power plant and
provided power to light up an entire square mile of
lower Manhattan. This early development required
further refinements, as only 59 customers were served
by this initial power distribution company. Edison
was at the time, a believer that direct current was the
The year 1882 brought about change, famous deaths
and births included the passing of Henry Wadsworth
Longfellow and Ralph Waldo Emerson, and at the
other end of the life spectrum Franklin Delano
Roosevelt was born in this year. John D. Rockefeller
created how own special birth with the formation of
the Standard Oil of New Jersey, as well as the Standard
Oil Trust to oversee what would become one of the
most powerful corporations yet seen in America in the
following years.
PCGS# 99098.
NGC Census: just 2; with a single coin finer (Proof-66 Ultra Cameo finest) within the Ultra
Cameo designation.
Page 211
2672 1883-CC AU-55 (NGC). Lustrous, satiny surfaces are also awash in light golden-orange patina. Sharply defined, minimally abraded
throughout, and highly attractive in a lightly circulated CC-mint twenty. An eagerly-sought issue having a mintage of just 59,962 pieces.
Probably no more than 3% of the original production figure still survives. The celebrated CC mintmark also confers desirability.
PCGS# 8999.
Premium Mint State 1884-CC Double Eagle
2673 1884-CC MS-62 (PCGS). Lovely rose-orange surfaces are sharply struck, fully lustrous, and remarkably smooth for a BU gold coin
of this size. The obverse is choice for the grade, and the reverse speaks of an even higher Mint State rating. Though 81,139 examples
of this issue were struck, the typical survivor is apt to be only VF to EF — Carson City Mint gold coins typically experienced a
high incidence of circulation in their day, and precious few were intentionally saved in the 1880s. As for this piece, fewer than 10
examples of the date have been graded finer than the present 1884-CC double eagle by PCGS, and all of those are certified MS-63.
This MS-62 specimen is a worthwhile combination of quality — about as fine as can be found in a PCGS holder — and value in our
estimation, and we expect heavy bidding activity on this lot before the bidding curtain falls.
PCGS# 9001.
2674 1887-S MS-62 (PCGS). Crisply impressed with wonderfully original deep orange patina, this minimally abraded example is uncommonly
free of sizeable abrasions in a BU gold coin of this size. Lustrous and softly frosted in texture, as well, this piece is sure to excite the
advanced double eagle collector. While obtainable with patience at this grade level, finer examples start to really get tough to locate. As
such, this lustrous and attractive coin should strongly be considered as it offers ample appeal without forcing a monumental price for a
slightly finer example.
PCGS# 9007.
Page 212
2675 1889 MS-62 (PCGS). Smartly impressed with softly frosted
rose-gold surfaces, this solidly graded piece is free of both
wear and singularly distracting abrasions. From a modest
mintage for the date of just 44,070 pieces, an amount that
figures out to well under a million dollars in face value.
Throughout the 1880s Philadelphia Mint double eagle
production was scant at best for most dates. In fact, the
1883, 1884, and 1887 were all Proof-only dates! From 1880
through 1889 inclusive, just 326,132 double eagles were
produced for intended circulation at Philadelphia; 226,161
of that total was struck in 1888, with that year’s total an
anomaly for the era at the Mother Mint.
2677 1890 MS-62 (PCGS). Lovely reddish-orange patina blends
with swirling satin to softly frosted luster on both sides of this
beautiful double eagle. Minimally abraded for the assigned
grade, as well, and sure to sell for a strong bid. Choice and
appealing, and a wise selection for a type collection.
PCGS# 9013.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from our (Stack’s) sale
of March 2002, lot 1199.
PCGS# 9010.
Impressive BU 1890-CC Twenty
Elegant and Flashy
1889-CC Liberty Double Eagle
2676 1889-CC MS-61 (PCGS). A handsome piece with
originally toned surfaces, we note a blend of orange
and rose-gold colors on both sides. The luster is
uniformly frosty and vibrant throughout, and a sharp
to full strike also touches all elements of the design.
With a mintage of only 30,945 pieces it is clear that
these are scarce to rare today. Here is one of the finer
examples seen, retaining the original mint surfaces
and appealing quality as well. The Carson City Mint
had closed in 1885 but reopened in 1889 and these
gold coins and silver dollars began to flow once again
from this famous Mint. Most entered circulation and
stayed there. Hence precious few Mint State coins are
available today, and when a pleasing example like this
turns up, collectors have to bid accordingly if they
expect to capture this prized condition rarity.
2678 1890-CC MS-62 (PCGS). CAC. Boldly toned in
original honey-rose, this fully struck and satiny double
eagle would not seem out of place in an MS-63 holder.
The surfaces are minimally abraded at the BU level,
in fact, and neither side reveals so much as a single
mentionable abrasion. PQ! The PCGS Population
Report shows less than a dozen coins in higher grades,
with the finest known a lonely MS-64. An example
worthy of any Carson City Mint aficionado’s cabinet.
PCGS# 9014.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: our (Bowers
and Merena’s) sale of July 2002, lot 660.
PCGS# 9011.
Page 213
Sharp Near-Gem
1890-S Double Eagle
2679 1890-S MS-64 (NGC). Attractively original surfaces are
drenched in deep, rich, reddish-rose patina. Also fully
endowed with hard satiny luster, this coin is boldly struck
throughout with expectably few abrasions at the Choice
Mint State grade level. The 1890-S is usually found heavily
bagmarked, making premium quality coins true condition
rarities. This example is at the pinnacle for the date and
Mint and would be an important addition to even the finest
cabinet.
2680 1890-S MS-62 (PCGS). Handsome medium orange surfaces
are fully lustrous with a sharply executed strike. There are no
singularly distracting abrasions — an uncommon attribute
in a BU double eagle — and a tiny alloy spot within the
reverse rays is mentioned solely for accuracy. Choice for the
grade and worthy of selection for a growing type collection.
PCGS# 9015.
PCGS# 9015.
NGC Population: 7; just 1 finer (MS-65).
Key Date 1891-CC Liberty Double Eagle
2681 1891-CC AU-58 (PCGS). Virtually complete luster in a bright, satin to softly frosted texture mingles with equally attractive oliveorange patina. This is a sharply defined near-Mint survivor from this popular key date issue among Carson City Mint double eagles.
This is the third toughest Carson City double eagle to find in all grades, behind the famed 1870-CC and the 1871-CC. The mintage
was low at 5,000 pieces and from that comparatively low issue it is believed that 175 to 250 survive in all grades according to Q.
David Bowers. Bowers further notes that it seems likely that 1,000 to 2,000 of this date and mint circulated locally while the rest were
exported. Only a single die pair was used to coin this date and mint, and this is one of the finer examples recorded today.
PCGS# 9017.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of the Harry W. Bass, Jr. Collection, Part III, May 2000, lot 894. Bass
acquired the coin from Mr. Louis (Chicago) on March 16, 1972.
Page 214
2682 1891-S MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. A razor sharp near-Gem
drenched in deep and satiny khaki-rose patina, this is an
impressive high-grade example of both the issue and the
type. “Mint State examples are available from MS-60 to MS63, after which the 1891-S is very rare” noted the Bowers/
Whitman reference (2004). Indeed, PCGS lists just one finer
certification event for this date, a solitary MS-65 coin. MS64, as offered here, is nearly as fine as you will see for the
date, something to consider when placing your bids.
PCGS# 9018.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Sierra, January 9, 1997.
2683 1891-S MS-64 (PCGS). This is a highly lustrous, satin to softly
frosted piece whose surfaces are also drenched in vivid reddishorange patina. Fully struck and smooth, this piece is highly
recommended for inclusion in an advanced Mint State double
eagle set. Tied with a select group of less than one hundred
of this date and mint as the second finest seen of this issue by
PCGS, and certainly hard to find this well preserved. A delight
to behold and quite impressive when examined closely.
PCGS# 9018.
PCGS Population: 94; just 1 finer (Mint State-65 finest).
March 2000, lot 1024.
Choice Mint State
1892 Liberty Double Eagle Rarity
2684 1892 MS-64 (PCGS). Splendid yellow gold surfaces also reveal tinges of pale pinkish rose iridescence as the coin rotates under a
light. With a needle sharp strike, equally full luster and exceptionally smooth surfaces, this Philadelphia Mint example is destined
for inclusion in another important double eagle cabinet. The 1892 is basically scarce in all grades and is considered to be a key
date in the series. Most of the circulated or lower grade Mint State pieces have returned to these shores after many years overseas
where they were sent soon after issue. Most of course, were melted soon after they arrived. Walter Breen, writing in 1988 in his
Encyclopedia, believed this date was represented by no more than 16 to 20 circulation strikes. David Akers, in his reference U.S.
Double Eagles 1849 to 1933 notes that he felt the 1892 Philadelphia double eagle was roughly on par in with the 1855, 1856, 1857,
1858, 1863, 1864, 1869, 1879, 1880, and 1890 double eagles. Today, with the relative clarity of the certified coin data, we see that
the 1892 offers the lowest available number of certified examples of any of these dates listed by David Akers. Reviewing other
Philadelphia Mint issues and those noted by David Akers reveals that based on the certified date, the 1859 and 1863 are the closest
in the number of surviving examples today, but the 1892 is still the rarest date and mint of Akers’ prestigious list. While the 1892
is not as rare as believed by Walter Breen (many having shown up long after his assessment from overseas), it is still a tough issue
to find at all. Of course, this is no average 1892 double eagle but one of the very finest known. It is tied with the finest certified by
PCGS with two others at most. NGC records a few finer examples in their Census, and with these additional high grade examples
the current offering is tied as one of the top five examples reported between both grading services. The provenance is outstanding
as well, and we look forward to handling this coin anytime it comes up for auction.
PCGS# 9019.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from our (Stack’s) sale of the Gaston DiBello Collection, May 1970, lot 1283; our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale
of the Harry W. Bass, Jr. Collection, Part III, May 2000, lot 895.
Page 215
Scarce and Attractive 1892-CC Double Eagle
2685 1892-CC MS-62 (PCGS). This highly appealing example possesses noticeable prooflike reflectivity to vivid, original, rose-gold
surfaces. Minimally abraded, both for the issue and the assigned grade, with a suitably bold strike that is actually razor sharp in
and around the centers. Q. David Bowers estimates that perhaps 800 to 1,200 or so survive of this date, and from that number 150
to 225 are Mint State — most of those were brought in from European bank hoards in the second half of the last century. Prior to
these double eagles returning, this date and mint was virtually unobtainable in Mint State. When these double eagles circulated,
they tended to circulate hard, many also ended up going overseas as export trade coins, and those that survived in high grades are
generally from these oversea sources today. The double eagles that circulated out West tend to show more extensive wear as they
were used as intended, as money.
PCGS# 9020.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from Heritage’s sale of the “Eagle Collection” of Liberty Double Eagles, January 2002, lot 4112.
2686 1892-CC Net EF-45 (ANACS). AU Details—Cleaned.
OH. Sharply defined with a vibrant semi-reflective finish,
yet curiously glossy in texture with light hairlining from a
cleaning. One of 27,265 examples of the date struck.
PCGS# 9020.
2687 1892-S MS-64 (NGC). Crisply impressed with billowy
medium orange luster, overall smooth surfaces readily
uphold the validity of the coveted Choice Mint State grade.
A far more elusive date at MS-64 than its sizable mintage of
930,150 pieces suggests, though we imagine the bidding for
this beauty will reflect the elusive nature of examples this
fine. Few and far between are the examples of the date that
exceed MS-64 in quality.
PCGS# 9021.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from Heritage’s sale of
the “Eagle Collection” of Liberty Double Eagles, January 2002, lot 4113.
2688 1893 MS-64 (PCGS). Intricately defined with full, frosty,
medium orange luster, this delightful near-Gem makes a
lovely impression in all regards. As Q. David Bowers notes
in his A Guide Book of Double Eagle Gold Coins for this date
“High grade 1893 double eagles abound in the market, with
the typical grades being AU to MS-63. Higher grades are
very rare.” Bowers further notes that in David Akers study
of auction records, not a single Mint State example of this
date was auctioned prior to 1965. Hence, most if not all of
the known Mint State 1893 double eagles must have come
back to these shores from European or South American
bank holdings or similar hoards. The vast majority of these
fall into the grade ranges of Mint State-63 and lower. That
makes this Very Choice example one of the finer examples
known today.
PCGS# 9022.
PCGS Population: 66; just 3 are finer (Mint State-64+ finest).
June 2002, lot 4052.
Page 216
One of the Finest Mint State 1893-CC Double Eagles
2689 1893-CC MS-63 (PCGS). Gorgeous medium orange surfaces also exhibit subtle coppery-rose highlights that appear to streak
through the central obverse. Fully lustrous with a sharply executed strike, the satiny features are also uncommonly well preserved
with remarkably few abrasions in a survivor of this historic final-year Carson City Mint gold issue. The mintage of 18,042 was not
all that large for this Mint, but a good number of these were sent overseas in the export trade. Those double eagles that stayed in
the West tended to circulate. The Carson City Mint was shut down in 1893 after months of wrangling so coinage was halted by the
end of the year. As the exported coins slowly came back to these shores, many were found to be in the lower Mint State grades.
Finding a Choice example requires patience, and no finer examples than MS-63 have yet to turn up at PCGS or NGC. Therefore,
this outstanding coin is highly recommended for the advanced specialist of the Carson City Mint or the Liberty double eagle series.
PCGS# 9023.
PCGS Population: 21; none are finer.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Sierra, July 15, 1999.
2690 1893-S MS-63 (PCGS). Frosty rose-orange surfaces offer
bold striking detail and minimally abraded surfaces at the
Select Mint State grade level. At the Choice grade level this
date and mint is available for a price, but any finer and an
1893-S double eagle becomes a true condition rarity. Hence,
this example is a perfect blend of nice quality and eye appeal
for a moderate price.
PCGS# 9024.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Sierra, July 2, 1999.
2691 1894 MS-64 (PCGS). OGH. Handsome medium orange
patina blends with softly frosted luster on both sides of
this minimally abraded, outwardly smooth piece. A sharp,
lustrous and thoroughly appealing example of both the type
and the issue. Tied with a select group at this near Gem level
and technically exceeded by only a small handful for this
date and mint. As such, this coin would be a worthy target
to acquire when the auction unfolds, so make sure to bid
accordingly to capture this prize.
PCGS# 9025.
Page 217
2692 1894-S MS-63 (PCGS). Fully original, and attractively so,
this delightful piece exhibits light, mottled, iridescent pink
overtones to dominant deep orange patina. With swirling
mint luster and smartly impressed devices, we anticipate
keen bidder interest in this attractive Mint State twenty.
Scarce at the Choice grade level and difficult to locate
appreciably finer.
PCGS# 9026.
Merena’s) sale of March 2001, lot 282.
2693 1895 MS-64 (NGC). Full satin to softly frosted luster swirls
around both sides of this sharply impressed, vividly original,
medium rose example. A surprisingly smart value in today’s
numismatic marketplace.
PCGS# 9027.
2695 1895-S MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. Exceptionally vibrant light
orange surfaces reveal decided semi-prooflike tendencies
to otherwise satiny mint luster. With a razor sharp strike
and no singularly distracting abrasions, we anticipate keen
bidder competition for this PQ Type III twenty. With a
mintage similar to that of the 1895 Philadelphia Mint issue,
this branch mint example will add a touch of diversity to a
gold type set for the same cost.
PCGS# 9028.
2696 1896 MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. Wonderfully original in deep
orange gold patina, this fully lustrous, smartly impressed
piece is not all that far from full Choice quality. This year’s
mintage was down more than 300,000 pieces from the
previous year’s total at Philadelphia.
PCGS# 9029.
2694 1895 MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. Bright and satiny, this highly
lustrous piece is further endowed with vivid rose-orange
color. Fully struck throughout, and smooth enough to
suggest a Choice Mint State rating. MS-63 affords the best
meeting of grade and value for the date, especially if you are
interested in a Liberty double eagle for your type collection.
2697 1896-S MS-62 (PCGS). CAC. Lustrous and boldly
impressed, both sides of this satiny piece also offer
undeniable originality in the form of vivid orange-rose
color. The somewhat sizable mintage for the date insures
that collectors desiring a pleasing example such as that
offered here will have occasional opportunities to make the
acquisition. Don’t miss this one.
PCGS# 9030.
PCGS# 9027.
2698 1897 MS-64+ (PCGS). Frosty rose-orange surfaces are
overall smooth with outstanding luster quality. Silky smooth
in most other areas, a tiny reeding mark at the back of
Liberty’s cheek seems to be the only impediment to a full
Gem rating. Choice and appealing with every turn, and
ideally suited to a high-grade gold type set.
PCGS# 9031.
Page 218
Attractive Cameo Proof 1898
Liberty Double Eagle
2699 1897 MS-63 (PCGS). This smartly impressed, razor-sharp
example is drenched in a blend of deep orange patina and
satin to softly frosted luster. Absolutely choice for the grade
and ideally suited for inclusion in a Mint State gold type set.
PCGS# 9031.
2700 1897-S MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. This beautiful near-Gem is
sharply struck with minimally abraded medium orange
features. Full luster in a bold satin texture further enhances
already strong eye appeal. Choice for the grade and worthy
of a premium bid.
PCGS# 9032.
2702 1898 Proof-60 Cameo (NGC). This richly toned, deep
orange specimen is fully struck with mostly small,
wispy, singularly inconspicuous contact marks to
define the grade. Nicely cameoed in finish, as well, the
eye appeal of this piece could easily support a higher
numeric grade. A mere 75 of these were struck in the
Proof format, and most if not all seen today would
qualify as Cameo or Ultra (Deep) Cameo Proofs. So
few were struck that the dies never lost their dramatic
finish that when applied to coins induces the Cameo
contrast. The dies were prepared to create this fantastic
level of contrast between the fields and the devices,
which came out beautifully on these Proof coins from
the waning years of the 19th century. While there are a
few minor nicks and lines, these are not uncommon on
these large coins, with extremely delicate surfaces it is
easy to forgive a few trivialities when one considers the
immense rarity and intense quality that these Proofs
possess. Today, there are no more than 30 to 40 of these
known in Proof according to Ron Guth, a tiny number
considering how many collectors would desire to own
an example of a Proof double eagle from this period.
PCGS# 89114.
NGC Census: 1; 19 finer (Proof-66 Cameo finest) within the Cameo Proof designation.
2701 1897-S MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. OGH—Second Generation.
Luxurious satin to semi-reflective luster shines forth
powerfully from both sides of this expertly produced piece.
Sharp, original and possessed of vivid medium orange
color, this PQ example is sure to see spirited bidding. A
frosty delight that will add pizzazz to any specialized date
collection of this series.
PCGS# 9032.
2703 1898 MS-62 (PCGS). CAC. Gorgeous orange-rose patina
blankets both sides of this sharply impressed, lustrous,
minimally abraded example. Just 170,395 examples of the
date were struck, a modest amount when compared to the
previous year’s tally of nearly 1.4 million pieces. A timely
opportunity for an alert collector.
PCGS# 9033.
Page 219
2704 1898-S MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. Fully struck with blazing
mint luster, this vivid rose-orange example makes a strong
impression in all regards. Much finer than the vast majority
of available Mint State specimens.
PCGS# 9034.
2708 1899-S MS-63 (PCGS). Beautiful satin to softly frosted
luster mingles with original orange-rose color on both sides
of this well struck piece. Undoubtedly, in the top 25% of all
Mint State specimens in terms of quality.
PCGS# 9036.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from our (Bowers and
Merena’s) Stetson University Collection sale, May 1993, lot 2303. Lot
tag included.
2709 1899-S MS-62+ (PCGS). CAC. Satiny and vibrant, this
delightful double eagle is toned in a patchwork of pale rose
and light orange-gold. Uniformly sharp throughout, and
outwardly smooth enough to suggest a significantly higher
grade. Probably no more than 1% of the original mintage
still survives in Mint State.
PCGS# 9036.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: our (Stack’s) sale of
2705 1898-S MS-64 (PCGS). This rose-orange beauty is sharply
struck with swirling satin luster to overall distraction free
surfaces. Choice for the grade, this particular branch mint
specimen would make a great addition to an advanced type
collection.
PCGS# 9034.
2710 1900-S MS-63 (PCGS). Fully impressed with radiant
medium gold luster, this satiny beauty would fit nicely into a
Mint State type or date set of Liberty gold coinage.
PCGS# 9038.
2706 1899 MS-64 (PCGS). Delightful rose-gold surfaces are
sharply struck with smooth, frosty luster swirling around
both sides. Only a small proportion of the total Mint State
population is this nicely preserved.
PCGS# 9035.
Merena’s) sale of January 2000, lot 430.
2711 1901 MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC. Satiny and vibrant, this
gorgeous near-Gem is fully struck, smooth and suggestive
of an even higher Mint State grade. Only 111,430 examples
were minted, one of the smaller 20th-century production
figures for the denomination.
PCGS# 9039.
May 1991, lot 1757.
2707 1899 MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. Satiny in texture and highly
lustrous, this handsome rose-gold example is not all that
far from a fully Choice rating. An excellent candidate for
inclusion in a quality 19th-century gold type set.
PCGS# 9035.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from our (Bowers and
Merena’s) Stetson University Collection sale, May 1993, lot 2302. Lot
tag included.
Page 220
Satiny Near-Gem 1902-S Liberty
Double Eagle
One of the Finest Certified
1902 Double Eagles
2712 1902 MS-64 (NGC). Gorgeous golden-orange surfaces
are awash in full, vibrant, satin-textured luster. A solidly
graded near-Gem, this piece is minimally abraded
with no singularly mentionable marks. A lone reverse
alloy spot is noted for accuracy, however, although it
is out of the way at the border outside the letter E in
UNITED. Only 31,140 double eagles were struck in
the Philadelphia Mint during 1902, the lowest 20th
century mintage for the Liberty type. Most known
Mint State coins are impaired or are otherwise at the
lowest end of the scale, making this coin an important
stand-out condition rarity.
PCGS# 9041.
NGC Census: only 3; none are finer at this service.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from Heritage’s
sale of the “Eagle Collection” of Liberty Double Eagles, January
2002, lot 4133.
2713 1902 MS-62 (PCGS). Pretty rose-gold surfaces are
fully lustrous with a razor sharp strike that also extends
throughout the design. The 1902 is notable for having the
smallest mintage of any 20th-century Liberty Head double
eagle, just 31,140 examples were produced.
2714 1902-S MS-64 (PCGS). OGH. This fully lustrous, softly
frosted beauty is also awash in richly original rose-gold
patina. Expectably smooth for the near-Gem grade assigned
by PCGS, both sides are sharply struck with eye appeal to
spare. A condition rarity at this grade level, which is about
as nice as most collectors could hope to acquire. A handful
exist in finer grades, but even the Gem level becomes sparse
as only four coins are reported at that grade or finer by
PCGS. An important offering for the date collector who
demands high quality and bold stunning visual impact.
PCGS# 9042.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Sierra, May 13,
1994.
2715 1903 MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. Splendid medium orange
surfaces are highly lustrous and free of significant abrasions.
The total surviving Mint State population is thought to be
no greater than 2% of the original production figure.
PCGS# 9043.
2716 1903-S MS-63 (PCGS). This lovely orange-rose example
also offers solid technical quality in the form of sharply
struck devices and billowy mint luster. Most Uncirculated
examples in modern-day collections were repatriated to
the United States from European bank hoards. Prior to the
1960s, Mint State examples were regarded as elusive; the
specimens in the Flanagan, Lee, Farouk, and Baldenhofer
collections were all listed as VF when auctioned in the 1940s
and 1950s.
PCGS# 9044.
PCGS# 9041.
Page 221
2717 1904 MS-66+ (NGC). A simply outstanding Gem, the
surfaces are silky smooth in texture with subtle pale pink
highlights to otherwise dominant medium rose patina.
Exquisite! A “common denominator” date in most grades,
the 1904 is perhaps the most readily available of all Liberty
double gales in Mint State. The Gem offered here is an
exception to the typical MS-64 or so example of the date.
2721 1904 MS-65 (NGC). CAC. OH. Beautiful medium gold
surfaces offer sharp striking detail and full, satin luster at
the Gem grade level. Far and away above average in terms of
available quality. Pride of ownership comes to the fore with
this beauty.
PCGS# 9045.
PCGS# 9045.
2718 1904 MS-66 (PCGS). OGH. A delightful Gem, both sides are
silky smooth in texture with full, satiny, medium orange luster.
A scarce issue at the MS-66 level and extremely rare finer; this
specimen is easily in the top 1% of all Mint State survivors.
2722 1904 MS-65 (NGC). OH. This is a lovely Gem that sports
vibrant, satin textured luster, vivid deep orange patina and
overall smooth surfaces. What more could the numismatist
ask for?
PCGS# 9045.
PCGS# 9045.
2719 1904 MS-65+ (PCGS). CAC. This fully struck and expertly
preserved Gem is just one or two stray abrasions away from
an even higher grade. An attractive PQ double eagle for the
high-quality gold type collector. Choice at every turn.
2723 1904 MS-64+ (PCGS). Handsome khaki-gold surfaces
exhibit a bright, satiny sheen that accents a razor sharp
strike. Pleasing for the grade.
PCGS# 9045.
PCGS# 9045.
2720 1904 MS-65 (PCGS). Delightful satin surfaces are fully
struck with vivid deep gold color. Perhaps the most available
date of all Liberty double eagles in Gem Mint State, and a
date that finds its way into many great type sets as a result.
PCGS# 9045.
2724 1904-S MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC. Smooth satin to softly
frosted luster mingles with delightful medium orange
patina. A sharply impressed and expertly preserved piece
with eye appeal to spare. Choice for the grade and a cut
apart from the typical MS-64 example of the date.
PCGS# 9046.
July 1988, lot 455.
Page 222
Pleasing Proof 1905 Double Eagle
2725 1905 Proof-61 (PCGS). CAC. Intricately defined devices and glassy, reflective fields leave little doubt as to the Proof status of this
Liberty double eagle. The dominant color on both sides is one of light copper-rose, and a few swirls of deeper crimson-russet are
confined to the lower left reverse. With no sizeable or otherwise singularly mentionable contact marks, it is only wispy hairlines that
explain the Proof-61 designation from PCGS. For the grade, this is a thoroughly pleasing Proof twenty, and both the striking quality
and originality further enhance its already significant appeal. Roughly one third of the 92 Proof double eagles struck in 1905 are
known today. Proof double eagles were costly to acquire and retain even at the time of production, and many examples went unsold
at year’s end or were later placed into circulation. Many survivors, indeed, are impaired from mishandling, and a pleasing specimen
such as this Proof-61 represents a desirable find for this challenging issue. Of further importance in this regard is the fact that the
circulation strike 1905 double eagle is a key date issue that is scarce to rare in all Mint State grades.
PCGS# 9121.
PCGS Population: just 4; 15 finer (Proof-65 finest in this category).
Important Near-Gem 1905 Double Eagle
PCGS Pop: 1/0
2726 1905 MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC. Simply put, this is a beautiful Liberty double eagle irrespective of date or issuing Mint. The surfaces
are smooth and drenched in a blend of satin luster and vivid medium orange patina. Sharply struck, as well, and sure to have no
difficulty finding its way into another noteworthy double eagle collection. With a mintage of 58,919 coins, the 1905 is a well known
rarity among 20th century double eagle issues. At one time the date was practically unavailable in Mint State, but since then many
have been repatriated from overseas holdings, bolstering the collectible numbers. Still, the vast majority of survivors fall into the
AU-58 and MS-62 grade range. Above the BU level this issue is a formidable condition rarity, and in MS-64+ the example we offer
here is of tremendous importance as the finest survivor known to PCGS.
PCGS# 9047.
PCGS Population: just 1; none are finer at this service.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier from our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of May 1993, lot 2451.
Page 223
2727 1905-S MS-64 (PCGS). OGH. Satiny and vibrant, this beautiful rose-orange example also possesses sharp striking detail and overall
smooth surfaces. Worthy of a close look, this coin is seemingly not all that far from an even higher Mint State grade. While available with
patience at this grade level, finer examples are sparse, with only a few dozen noted at higher grade levels within the PCGS Population
Report.
PCGS# 9048.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Sierra, May 1991.
Remarkable 1906 Double Eagle
2728 1906 MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. Fully struck and expertly preserved, this vivid rose-gold twenty is sure to please even the most
discerning numismatist. With nary a distracting abrasion in evidence, both the technical quality and eye appeal are suggestive of
a full Gem grade. Most Mint State 1906 double eagles on the market are in the MS-60 or MS-61 range, unlike this unquestionably
Choice example. Exquisite in all regards, and a highly important condition rarity for the advanced Liberty double eagle collector.
PCGS# 9049.
PCGS Population: 21; just 7 finer through MS-66.
2729 1906-D MS-63 (PCGS). Crisply impressed with vivid medium orange satin textured luster. Were it not for a few extremely faint obverse
handling marks this lovely piece would easily have secured at least a Choice Mint State grade. Still, an amply pleasing example of the first
double eagle coinage from the newly opened Denver Mint.
PCGS# 9050.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of January 1991, lot 1636.
Page 224
Landmark 1906-S Double Eagle
The Eliasberg-Clapp Specimen — Finest Known
2730 1906-S MS-66 (PCGS). CAC. OGH. This is a breathtakingly beautiful piece, a true “monster” coin that stands head and shoulders
above all other 1906-S double eagles extant. Graded MS-68 (!) by David Hall and Gordon Wrubel when they bought this coin out of
our (Bowers and Ruddy’s) October 1982 sale of the United States Gold Coin Collection, the surfaces provide a glimpse of numismatic
perfection in a Liberty double eagle. Both sides are so smooth as to be virtually pristine, and we are hard pressed to even find a single
trivial tick or other blemish that could serve as a useful pedigree marker beyond a fine line on Liberty’s neck which serves to verify the
provenance as the Eliasberg coin. The luster is intensely vibrant in a blend of satin and softly frosted qualities, and it gains even greater
visual impact through the vivid, original, rose-gold patina that blankets both sides. Sharply struck and nothing short of exquisite, this is
a “must have” coin for the collector assembling the finest known collection of Liberty double eagles. Remarkable!
This coin traces its pedigree back to the day it was purchased at the San Francisco Mint in March of 1906 at face value by John H.
Clapp. It resided in the Clapp collection for the next 36 years. In 1942, the coin was part of the purchase of the entire Clapp Estate
Collection by Louis E. Eliasberg, Sr. Hailed as the only complete collection of United States coins by date and mintmark ever assembled,
Eliasberg’s cabinet was also focused on quality. This 1906-S double eagle spent the next four decades in the Eliasberg cabinet until
October of 1982 when the Eliasberg gold coins were sold in October of that year. Dealers David Hall and Gordon Wrubel purchased it
and then promptly resold it. It has resided in the present collection since 1992. Interestingly, as relayed in the description of the lovely
Mint State Saint-Gaudens high relief double eagle from this collection, the grandfather of the collector who assembled this fine cabinet
was an engineer employed as superintendent of machinery at the San Francisco Mint. It was the machinery in his charge that struck this
fabulous coin, and incredibly, his grandson who would eventually own and care for it in nearly the exact condition it was in the day it was
struck. From the PCGS CoinFacts website, we quote David Hall in his entirety regarding this marvelous numismatic survivor:
“There is one monster 1906-S double eagle and it may not be listed in the PCGS CoinFacts census. It’s the Eliasberg-Clapp coin, sold at the
Eliasberg sale in October, 1982. Gordon Wrubel and I bought the coin at that sale for what was a big price at the time, $16,500. We graded
the coin MS68! The PCGS Pop Report shows one MS66, with none higher. Is this the Eliasberg coin? Maybe...maybe not.
“Here’s what happened to the coin in 1982. My long term partner Van Simmons sold the coin almost immediately after Gordy and I
bought it. It was a very strange transaction. A guy calls us and says he wants to buy some great coins. He shows up at our office with about
$100,000 in cash, He bought the 1906-S $20 and some other super coins. We didn’t know the guy, had never seen him before, and we have
never seen him or the coin since!”
An exceptional coin with an equally exceptional story. Not many coins have spent the past 108 years in the hands of only a few
collectors. Now is your chance to add your name to the pedigree list of an extremely important and highly desirable Liberty double eagle.
PCGS# 9051.
PCGS Population: 1; 0 finer
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: John H. Clapp, acquired directly from the San Francisco Mint in March 1906 for face value; Louis E. Eliasberg,
Sr., 1942; our (Bowers and Ruddy’s) sale of the United States Gold Coin Collection (Eliasberg), October 1982, lot 1017; David Hall-Gordon Wrubel, 1982; unknown
intermediaries; United States GSA Auction of Confiscated Property, May 1992; Ray Bolduc, to the Eldorado Collection.
Page 225
2731 1906-S MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. Beautiful light rose patina mingles with billowy mint luster on both sides of this richly original near-Gem.
A pretty branch mint piece from the waning years of this long-lived design type.
PCGS# 9051.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Heritage’s sale of April 2001, lot 8133.
Handsome Cameo Proof
1907 Liberty Double Eagle
2732 1907 Liberty. Proof-64 Cameo (PCGS). CAC. A truly extraordinary specimen, this final-year Proof Liberty double eagle possesses
exceptionally bold contrast between the fields and devices. The former features are not only satiny in texture, but exhibit needle
sharp striking detail that further sets them apart from watery, deeply reflective fields. The entire package is silky smooth in texture
and drenched in luxurious yellow gold patina. Beautiful! This is one of the finer examples known in two important ways. First off,
the surfaces approach the Gem level, with scarcely any signs of handling when closely examined. Second, there is considerable
contrast between the mirror reflectivity of the fields in comparison to the frosted devices, which earns this piece the coveted Cameo
designation. The total mintage in Proof is recorded as 78 coins. From that modest group at least two thirds have the regular, non
Cameo contrast, while the balance fall into the Cameo designation at PCGS (no Deep Cameo coins have been certified by that
service of the 1907 Liberty double eagle).Big changes were in the wind in 1907, as the famous sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens was
contracted to provide new designs to replace the Liberty double eagle. These came about in late 1907, making this Liberty double
eagle the final year of issue of this long running and popular series. Why not add this glorious Cameo example to your advanced
collection today?
PCGS# 89123.
PCGS Population: 7; only 5 are finer (Proof-67 Cameo finest) within the Cameo designation.
Page 226
2733 1907-D MS-64+ (PCGS). Razor sharp in strike with flowing medium orange luster, this uncommonly smooth double eagle would make
an impressive addition to a high grade type or date set. Mint records state that the first coins were struck on September 30 of 1907, yet
Virgil Brand acquired one on July 8, of 1907! This may never be sorted out. However, one thing is likely, these were struck with Cripple
Creek gold as noted by Q. David Bowers, as that was the nearest gold mine to the Denver Mint. Gems are scarce, and this example is ever
so close to that grade level, with excellent eye appeal and strong luster to entice any collector specialist to bid accordingly.
PCGS# 9053.
2734 1907-S MS-64 (PCGS). CAC. Intensely vivid rose and reddish-gold patina greets the viewer from both sides of this simply beautiful
double eagle. Sharply struck and highly lustrous as well, we anticipate keen bidder interest in this premium near-Gem. Absolutely choice
for the grade and a sterling representative example of the final San Francisco Mint issue of the type.
PCGS# 9054.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: our (Bowers and Merena’s) sale of January 2000, lot 438.
2735 1907-S MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. Radiant satin surfaces are drenched in lovely khaki-rose patina. Minimally abraded for the assigned grade,
and worthy of a strong bid. Decidedly choice for the assigned grade.
PCGS# 9054.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: our (Stack’s) sale of May 1991, lot 1785.
Page 227
Rare Very Choice Proof MCMVII (1907)
Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle
2736 MCMVII (1907) Saint-Gaudens. High Relief. Wire Rim. Proof-64 (NGC). A vibrant satin finish mingles with handsome orangegold patina on both sides of this exquisite specimen. Uncommonly sharp (!) in strike for this normally carefully produced issue,
this outwardly smooth near-Gem would serve as a highlight in an advanced collection of popular 20th century U.S. gold coin types.
These handsome coins are seldom offered and always in high collector demand. The surfaces are a delight to examine, with their
seductive satin finish and each every device boldly impressed.
This glorious coin was designed by famed sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens in 1907, at the insistence of President Theodore
Roosevelt. Saint-Gaudens was one of the most talented artists in the country and had designed a few medals in the past for the Mint.
Seen as an outsider, and not familiar with minting equipment, Mint Engraver Charles E. Barber did not welcome an invasion to his
turf at the Mint. Furthermore, the designs Saint-Gaudens came up with required a great depth to the coins, struck in “high relief ”.
This refers to the depth of the designs on the coin, which had to be raised by striking the blank planchet not just once, or even twice,
but at three to fives times! The designs by Saint-Gaudens were as beautiful as they were impractical. Striking the 11,250 pieces for
circulation required far more time than Barber could stand. Production simply could not be accomplished by having to strike each
coin several times. In the end, Barber won the day and he revised the elegant designs to remove high relief depth, which allowed
for each planchet to be struck only once, while retaining the designs of Saint-Gaudens, but in a much lower relief. This Proof High
Relief has stood as our most beautiful coin since the time it was struck, and it will certainly take a huge effort to produce a coin even
more beautiful in the future.
NGC Census: 92; 77 finer (Proof-69 finest) within the Proof designation.
2737 MCMVII (1907) Saint-Gaudens. High Relief. Wire Rim. Unc Details—Repaired (PCGS). Sharply defined with satiny yellow gold
surfaces, this coin presents much better than the stated impairment would imply. There are also no sizeable or otherwise singularly
distracting abrasions, and the repair is minor and seems to be largely confined to smoothing in the right obverse field. Here’s a one-year
design type that is considered by many to be the most beautiful issue in the entire panoply of U.S. federal coinage. The designer —
Augustus Saint Gaudens — has been recognized for well over a century as one of America’s premier sculptors, and it is likely that many
art scholars would place him at the very top of the roster.
PCGS# 9135.
Page 228
Select MCMVII (1907) High Relief Double Eagle
Obtained Directly from the Mint as a Family Memento
2738 MCMVII (1907) Saint-Gaudens. High Relief. Flat Rim. MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. Seldom have we offered a Select Mint State High Relief
double eagle with surfaces that are smooth, lustrous and inviting as those of the present piece. There is nary a distracting abrasion in
evidence, and with vivid, satiny, yellow gold luster further accentuating a needle sharp strike, this beautiful coin is sure to sell for a
premium bid.
This lot includes a tattered, yet intact piece of paper that measures approximately 32 mm x 24 mm. The back of the paper has a printed
list of officers and directors of an unknown organization, but it is the front of the paper that is much more important. On that side of the
paper one will find the following handwritten note:
”This coin is valuable being one of an issue which was cancelled and only a few were coined. Do not spent it without investigation.
Purchased by George McLoughlin. U.S. Mint, S.F. Calif.”
This note, which refers to the present coin, indicates that it was acquired from George McLoughlin directly from the San Francisco
Mint in 1907, where he worked as the superintendent of machinery. (A small group of High Relief double eagles had been shipped to
San Francisco from the Philadelphia Mint.) For more on McLoughlin, the part he played in saving the San Francisco Mint during the
San Francisco earthquake of 1906, and the significance of this coin to the El Dorado Collection, please refer to the introduction to this
collection located in the front matter of our printed catalog for this sale. An historic offering and one which will certainly find a cherished
place in an advanced collection.
George McLoughlin was an engineer and had extensive experience at the Mints in both Philadelphia and Carson City, and worked
at the San Francisco Mint in 1906. On the fateful morning of April 18, at 5:12 am a massive earthquake struck San Francisco and the
surrounding area. McLoughlin made his way to the San Francisco Mint and found it standing and relatively unscathed. However, the
danger was yet to come. Massive fires broke out in the next three days from ruptured gas lines. Furthermore, the water lines were also
ruptured so water pressure was non existent to aid in fighting the many fires that broke out. While the earthquake and numerous
aftershocks caused much damage, the real problem and most damaging factor unleashed by the earthquake were the subsequent fires.
Over 25,000 buildings were destroyed on 490 city blocks. Estimates are that over 3,000 people died, and the population of 410,000 that
survived suffered greatly. More than half the population was homeless after the fires died out. McLoughlin stayed at his post with other
loyal employees of the Mint and prepared to protect the building from fires. In the end the Mint withstood the conflagration and shaking,
with relatively little damage. Given the challenging circumstances of that week, McLaughlin’s steadfast behavior and dedication to his
post no doubt helped to save the Mint.
PCGS# 9136.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Acquired directly from the San Francisco Mint in 1907.
Page 229
2739 1908 No Motto. MS-66 (PCGS). OGH. Exquisite orangegold surfaces possess full mint luster and bold to sharp
definition. A gorgeous Gem example of one of the most
plentiful dates in the Saint-Gaudens double eagle series,
this from the Wells Fargo Hoard. No Motto type SaintGaudens double eagles were struck in 1907 and 1908 only.
The Wells Fargo Hoard is famous for its overall high quality;
an unusual circumstance since bank hoards of double eagles
are generally characterized by heavily bagmarked pieces.
Many of the Wells Fargo coins have been certified as MS-65
or finer over the years.
2742 1908-S EF-45 (PCGS). With only light high point wear
and just a few singularly distracting abrasions, this vibrant
medium gold example presents very well for a lightly
circulated gold coin of this size. More direct angles also call
forth considerable remnants of bright satin luster. All 1908S double eagles are of the Motto type.
PCGS# 9149.
PCGS# 9142.
Ex: Wells Fargo Nevada Gold.
2743 1908-S Genuine—Cleaning (PCGS). Generally boldly
defined with dominant deep orange patina, more vivid
copper-rose iridescence outlines many of the obverse
devices. Faint hairlines and a few moderate size abrasions
are noted. Scarce and desirable in all grades.EF Details.
2740 1908-D Motto. MS-65 (PCGS). Lustrous and satiny, this
solidly graded Gem is drenched in bright khaki-orange
patina. Struck later in the year after the motto IN GOD WE
TRUST was added to the reverse design. The mintage for
this type was only about half that of the earlier 1908 No
Motto type.
PCGS# 9149.
PCGS# 9148.
2741 1908-D Motto. MS-64 (PCGS). Satiny and vibrant, this
orange-rose piece also offers sharp striking detail and
freedom from significant abrasions. Certainly above average
in terms of the available quality of Mint State pieces.
PCGS# 9148.
2744 1909-D MS-61 (NGC). Blended khaki-gold and pale pink
patina greets the viewer from both sides of this minimally
abraded BU example. A trace of light rub to the high points
is noted for accuracy. From a small mintage for the date
of 52,500 pieces, one of the lowest production tallies of
any date in the design type. Of that figure, few were ever
exported with much of the mintage retained stateside. In
his reference on the denomination, Dave Bowers noted:
“Although the dispersal of several hoards has augmented
the supply of Mint State 1909-D double eagles from what it
was 20 or 30 years ago, this low-mintage issue is still a highly
important key date.” Opportunity is knocking!
PCGS# 9152.
Page 230
Fantastic Gem Mint State 1912
Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle
2745 1912 MS-65 (NGC). Crisply impressed with billowy mint luster, this delightful Gem is remarkably smooth and well preserved in a
survivor of this low mintage double eagle issue. Predominantly deep gold in color, a few wisps of slightly warmer copper-rose patina
in and around the centers further establish the originality of this impressive coin. There are a number of these in Choice Mint State
or finer, but Gems are decidedly tough to find of this date and mint. Another feature of the 1912 double eagle bears mention, the
addition of two obverse stars representing the new states of New Mexico and Arizona, and these two additional stars are found on
the lower right side below the date. An exciting example of this issue and worthy of the most advanced Saint-Gaudens collection.
PCGS# 9160.
2746 1922 MS-65 (PCGS). A beautiful Gem, both sides are
silky smooth in texture with a rich blend of frosty luster
and original deep rose patina. The 1922 is comparatively
scarce at the MS-65 level and all but unobtainable finer. The
presently-offered specimen is easily in to top 5% of the total
Mint State population. For some coins in today’s market, it
is possible to get a big increase in quality for a comparatively
small increase in price; the MS-65 1922 $20 falls into that
category.
PCGS# 9173.
2747 1922-S MS-63 (PCGS). This is a pleasingly bright Select
example of this San Francisco Mint issue, with yellowgold surfaces that show a few red-orange spots — from
an imperfect alloy mixture — that are located mainly on
the reverse. Both sides are boldly defined with full mint
frost. Formerly a great rarity in the series, this issue is now
considered “only” scarce, but its elusive nature has thwarted
more than one collector who has sought an attractive
example at auction. The bidding is always surprising for
this issue, and we suspect there may be a surprise in store
when the action begins for this lot. A few generations ago
the 1922-S was one of the toughest date and mints to find,
as virtually all of those saved from the time of issue were
melted, except for those that were exported and preserved
in foreign banks. Many 1922-S double eagles have now
returned from these extended European vacations, much to
the delight of numismatists here that can now readily obtain
a handsome example like coin this for their collections.
PCGS# 9174.
Page 231
Seldom Offered 1926-D
Double Eagle
in Choice Mint State
2748 1924 MS-66 (NGC). OH. Satiny and smooth, this medium
gold Gem is seemingly earmarked for a high grade type
set of classic U.S. Mint gold. While available at this lofty
grade level, finer examples are all but unobtainable as their
numbers dramatically dwindle in a most dramatic fashion
even with the “+” designation. Hence this is an ideal coin
that combines high quality, outstanding surfaces and
mesmerizing luster that any collector can long enjoy.
PCGS# 9177.
2749 1925 MS-66 (PCGS). Intensely lustrous with billowy mint
frost, both sides also exhibit razor sharp devices and lovely
medium gold color. Though a plentiful issue in most grades,
we note that fewer than a half dozen examples of the date
have been certified finer than the present piece by PCGS.
PCGS# 9180.
2750 1926-D MS-63 (PCGS). Handsome honey-rose
patina greets the viewer from both sides of this smartly
impressed, softly frosted piece. With no sizeable
or otherwise singularly distracting abrasions, the
technical quality of this coin is superior in a Select
Mint State double eagle of the popular Saint-Gaudens
design type. The 1926-D issue is on par with the rarity
of the 1925-D double eagle, and these rank 11th
and 12th rarest in terms of availability for this series
respectively. The rarest coins in this series include
three issues that are virtually unobtainable, the 1907
Ultra High Relief, the 1927-D and the 1933 issues.
Given the rarity of the 1926-D, a collector can begin
to grasp how challenging the Saint-Gaudens series
is to collect. PCGS in their years of certifying coins,
reports a total of 183 grading events for wholesome
1926-D double eagles. That’s certainly not many to
go around considering the number of collectors out
there seeking an example of each date and mint. This
Choice example would make a worthy acquisition for
the advanced Saint-Gaudens specialist.
PCGS# 9184.
2751 1928 MS-66 (NGC). OH. Beautiful softly frosted luster
blends with equally attractive orange-gold toning on both
sides of this endearing Gem. Glorious quality and more than
exceptional eye appeal, the surfaces of course, are assuredly
satin smooth as expected for this lofty Gem grade level.
PCGS# 9189.
End of Session Three
Page 232
The June 2014
Baltimore Auction
Session 4
Internet Only
Ends 3:00 PM PT
Tuesday, July 1, 2014
Lots 3001-5084
Military Medals
3001 “1847” Major General Zachary Taylor Military Medal.
Bronzed Copper. 64.8 mm. By John T. Battin (obverse).
Julian MI-23. Extremely Fine, Lacquered, Scratched, Rim
Nicks.
3002 Lot of (4) Military-Related Medals. Included are: 1859
U.S. Navy Arctic Explorer Elioha Kent medal, white
metal, 50 mm, Very Fine; 1905 Denver Grand Army of
the Republic medal featuring trains at the summit of Pike’s
Peak, bronze, 70 mm, About Uncirculated; 1910 General
Meade’s Monument at Gettysburg medal, bronze, 64 mm,
Choice About Uncirculated; and a 1923 25th Anniversary
of the Spanish-American War medal honoring New York’s
volunteer soldiers and sailors, bronze, 69 mm, Extremely
Fine. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
Washingtoniana
3003 Lot of (3) Washington Medals. Included are: 1876
Centennial International Exhibition, Danish medal, white
metal, 53 mm, Baker-426B, Rarity-4, About Uncirculated;
1885 Washington Monument Dedication, silvered white
metal, 45 mm, Baker N-322, About Uncirculated; and
(1889) Brooklyn Bridge, gilt copper, 25.5 mm, Douglas-9,
Rarity-4, Mint State, double struck at 6 o’clock, pierced for
suspension, as issued.
3004 Undated (Circa 1786-1790) General Washington
Medal. Uniface. White Metal. 54.7 mm. Baker-Unlisted.
Extremely Fine. The design features a left facing military
portrait of Washington with the inscription GENERAL
WASHINGTON above. An enigmatic piece of unknown
origin, the specimen we sold in our John J. Ford, Jr. Collection
sale, Part II, lot 245, was in brass. Ford speculated it may
have been the back to a military field mirror. Whatever
the case, this is a scarce piece. Extremely Fine condition,
unholed, with a segment of the planchet missing between 8
and 10 o’clock, probably a manufacturing defect.
Political Medals
and Related
3007 Undated (1860) Abraham Lincoln. DeWitt-AL 1860-60,
King-57. Brass. 24 mm. Mint State.
3008 1868 Ulysses S. Grant. Ferrotype. DeWitt-Unlisted. Brass
Shell. 25 mm. Very Fine. Brass shell enclosing portrait.
Remnants of a stick pin attached to center of reverse. As
Dewitt-USG 1868-84, but with wreath instead of rope-like
border. Grant Portrait 2 image bold, but missing an area of
image from 7 o’clock to 9 o’clock at the edge of the ferrotype
disc. Does not affect the portrait.
3009 1907 Pennsylvania Republican Party Ticket on Silk
Ribbon. 3.25 x 9.5 inches. Extremely Fine. This
multicolored ribbon exhibits a flag-adorned picture of John
O. Sheatz, the successful candidate for state treasurer in this
election, as well as the names of other Republican Party
candidates for other positions. The additional names are on
the image of a scroll below Sheatz’s picture. From the scroll
hangs the image of an irregular oval medallion inscribed
PLEDGED / TO AN HONEST / ADMINISTRATION / OF
PUBLIC AFFAIRS. A brass pin is attached to the back of the
ribbon for wearing. Rare.
Presidents and Inaugurals
3010 1957 Dwight David Eisenhower and Richard Nixon
Second Inaugural Medal. Silver. 69.3 mm. 171.0 grams.
By Medallic Art Co. Dusterberg-OIM 14S70. Edge: 726
(of 1,031). Extremely Fine, Obverse Scuffing.
3011 1974 Nelson Rockefeller Vice Presidential Inaugural
Medal. Silver. 63.5 mm. 156.7 grams. 999 fine. By Medallic
Art Co. Dusterberg-OVPIM 2S63. Edge: 1577 (of 2,410).
Mint State.
Art Medals
3005 Lot of (8) Woven Silk Ribbons Featuring George
Washington. These ribbons were issued for the 1876
U.S. Centennial Exposition and the World’s Columbian
Exposition of 1892-1893. Makers include Stevens, Tilt
and Phoenix. One example is a duplicate, and one is a
reproduction. Grades range from VF to Mint State, with a
stain noted for one example, and mildew spots for another.
This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
Lincolniana
3006 Lot of (4) 1909 Lincoln Birth Centennial Medals.
Extremely Fine. Included are: bronze, 76 mm, by AugustusSaint-Gaudens and Philip Martiny; bronze, 63 mm, by J.E.
Roine; and (2) 51 mm, by Bela Lyon Pratt, one bronze and
the other silvered-bronze. This is a must see, sold as is, no
return lot.
Page 234
3012 Lot of (13) Heraldic Art Medals, 1959-1964. Silver. 31
mm. Mint State. Highlights include (2) Alaska and (4)
Hawaiian pieces, as well as a set of the first three issues from
1959 housed in a heavy plastic holder. This is a must see,
sold as is, no return lot.
Art Medals – Medallic Art
Company
3013 Undated (1973) Inspiration Medal. Silver. 56.4 mm. 240.6
grams. By Frank Eliscu. Mint State. Two-piece nested set.
Obv: Pegasus being released from the hand of God. Interior:
intaglio and relief image of man harnessing the elusive
Pegasus which nest together perfectly. Rev: Heads of man
and Pegasus in harmony and repose. The first multi-part
medal produced in America, housed in the original case
with descriptive brochure.
Session Four Ends 3:00 PM PT - Tuesday, July 1, 2014
Commemorative Medals
3014 1876 United States Centennial Medal. Gilt Copper. 57.6
mm. Julian CM-11, Swoger-3Icv1. Extremely Fine.
3015 1876 United States Centennial Medal. Gilt Copper.
57.6 mm. Julian CM-11, Swoger-3Icv1. Extremely Fine,
Corrosion Spot.
3016 1876 United States Centennial Medal. Bronze. 57.5 mm.
Julian CM-11, Swoger-3Idv1. Extremely Fine.
So-Called Dollars
3017 1893 World’s Columbian Exposition. Official Medal.
Type II. Brass. 37 mm. HK-155, Eglit-23A. Rarity-2.
Small Letters Obverse. MS-65 (NGC).
3018 1920 Manila Mint Opening (Wilson Dollar). Copper. 38
mm. HK-450. Rarity-4. About Uncirculated.
3019 1933 Pedley-Ryan Dollar. Type IV. Silver. 38 mm. HK825. Rarity-5. Extremely Fine, Rim Nicks.
3020 1897 Bickford Dollar. Aluminum, Brass Center. 28 mm.
HK-835. Rarity-5. About Uncirculated.
Award Medals
3021 1899 The American Pet Dog Club Award Medal. Bronze.
63.3 mm. Choice About Uncirculated. Obv: Heads of five
different dog breeds, in the center a shield inscribed THE
/ AMERICAN / PET DOG / CLUB / INCORPORATED
/ 1888. Rev: A floral-bordered scroll engraved at the top
AWARDED TO and engraved within CHAMPION /
ANNOYANCE / A.P.D.C. / NEW YORK / 1899. Housed in
a custom American Pet Dog Club hinged velour case.
3022 Undated (Circa 1950s) Felix M. Warburg Memorial
Award Medal. Bronze. 76 mm. About Uncirculated.
Obv: Name of award around central medallion showing a
menorah and the inscription FEDERATION OF JEWISH
PHILANTHROPIES OF NEW YORK. Rev: Inscription
PRESENTED TO / MRS. SIMON GUGGENHEIM /
FOR FIFTY YEARS / OF DEVOTED SERVICE / TO
FEDERATION / THE COMMUNITY / AND HUMANITY.
Looped for suspension, with lovely medium gold surfaces.
Includes the fitted presentation case.In 1898 Simon
Guggenheim, the noted philanthropist and one time senator
from Colorado (1907-1913), married Olga Hirsch (18771970), the Mrs. Simon Guggenheim of this medal. The
Warburg medal is awarded only after a lifetime of service to
humanity.
Aviation
3023 1927 Charles Lindbergh New York to Paris Flight
Commemorative Medal. “The Lone Eagle.” Bronze. 70
mm. By Charles Hinton. About Uncirculated. Obv: Bust
of the aviator half right. Rev: The Spirit of St. Louis above a
rising sun.
School, College
and University Medals
3024 1870 Brooklyn, New York School Award Medal for the
Mansfield Academy. Silver. 31.4 mm. 17.3 grams. About
Uncirculated. Obv: Maltese Cross with a numeral 5
engraved at the center. Legends MANSFIELD ACADEMY
above and BROOKLYN below. Rev: Inscribed RECTITUDE
DILIGENCE PUNCTUALITY around a wreath of palm,
engraved JUNE / R.H. HAWKINS / 1870 in script within
the wreath with F.R. SMITH in tiny letters below the wreath.
Deeply toned in gray patina with hints of multiple iridescent
colors, especially on the reverse.Housed in a hinged case
inscribed WISE / 233 FULTON ST. / BROOKLYN inside
the top interior. The case is in Fine condition. (Total: 2
items)
3025 1910 The Gift of Franklin Medal, Issued for Academic
Achievement by the Boston City Schools. Silver. 34 mm.
19.5 grams. Julian SC-11, Greenslet-361, Sallay F-11.
About Uncirculated. Obv: Bust of Franklin left with the
inscription THE GIFT OF / FRANKLIN around the border
and the date MDCCXC in Roman numerals below. Rev:
Inscribed AWARDED TO on a ribbon at the top with the
engraving JAMES / D. RYAN / ‘10 in the center and a simple
wreath-like device below. A U.S. Mint product.
Fairs and Expositions
3026 1876 U.S. Centennial Exposition Soap Medallion. Brown
Soap. 46 x 64 mm oval. Very Fine. Top: Inscription
MEMORIAL HALL . 1876 above domed building. Bottom:
Inscription CENTENNIAL / EXPOSITION. Portions of the
border are broken away.
3027 1904 Louisiana Purchase Exposition Commemorative
Medal. Bronze. 71.5 mm. 71 mm x 71 mm shield (greatest
dimensions). By Adolph A. Weinman. Extremely
Fine. Obv: Liberty enveloping nude girl in the folds
of an American Flag. Rev: Eagle with outspread wings
perched on a cartouche inscribed COMMEMORATIVE
MEDAL / LOUISIANA PVRCHASE / EXPOSITION,
shell and dolphins below. Weinman would later adopt this
representation of Liberty for the design of the Walking
Liberty half dollar.
3028 Lot of (3) 1904 Louisiana Purchase Exposition Prize
Medals. Bronze. About Uncirculated. Included are: goldlevel prize, 71.5 mm x 71.5 mm shield (greatest dimensions);
silver-level prize, 64.3 mm square; and bronze-level prize,
67.3 mm round.
3029 Lot of (2) Early 20th Century Exposition Medals. Bronze.
About Uncirculated. Included are: 1904 Louisiana Purchase
Exposition America Welcomes the World medal, 50.5 mm;
and 1905 Lewis and Clark Exposition award medal, 63.8
mm, unawarded.
3030 1907 Jamestown Tercentennial Exposition Award Medal.
Gilt Bronze. 62.5 mm. By Tiffany & Co. Awarded to
Coldwell Lawn M’R Co. Choice About Uncirculated. Obv:
Native American couple sitting on a shoreline watching an
approaching ship, the border inscribed with the name and
date of the exposition. Rev: A seven-line inscription within
a wreath of corn and tobacco with an eagle below. The final
line of the inscription is the name of the medal’s recipient,
and it is expressed on a small cartouche.
Page 235
3031 1907 Jamestown Tercentennial Exposition Award
Medal. Bronze. 62.5 mm. By Tiffany & Co. Awarded to
North Carolina State Museum. Extremely Fine. Obv:
Native American couple sitting on a shoreline watching an
approaching ship, the border inscribed with the name and
date of the exposition. Rev: A seven-line inscription within
a wreath of corn and tobacco with an eagle below. The final
line of the inscription is the name of the medal’s recipient,
and it is expressed on a small cartouche.
3032 1907 Jamestown Tercentennial Exposition Award Medal.
Gilt Bronze. 62.5 mm. By Tiffany & Co. Awarded to G.
William Schlichten. Extremely Fine, Scratched, Pitted.
Obv: Native American couple sitting on a shoreline watching
an approaching ship, the border inscribed with the name
and date of the exposition. Rev: A seven-line inscription
within a wreath of corn and tobacco with an eagle below.
The final line of the inscription is the name of the medal’s
recipient, and it is expressed on a small cartouche.
3033 Complete Set of 1909 Alaska-Yukon-Pacific Exposition
Award Medals. Bronze. 76.3 mm. Unawarded. Extremely
Fine. Obv: Liberty seated, holding medallion of George
Washington as a Native American, miner and logger
look on. Rev: Cartouche with award level, but otherwise
uninscribed. Included are: gold-level award; silver-level
award; and bronze-level award. Quite scarce, especially as a
set. (Total: 3 medals)
3034 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition Award
Medal. Silver-Plated Bronze. 71 mm. By John Flanagan.
Extremely Fine. Obv: Nude male and female figures over
the Isthmus of Panama. Rev: Exposition buildings within
wreath, plaque inscribed MEDAL OF AWARD below,
border inscribed with name, location and date of exposition.
Flanagan is well known to collectors of United States coins
as the designer of the Washington quarter.
3035 Lot of (4) 1915 Panama-California and Panama-Pacific
International Exposition Medals. Very Fine. Included
are: Panama-California Exposition: Westgate View
medal, aluminum, 63 mm; Panama-Pacific International
Exposition: Swedish Pavilion medal, bronze, 50.6 mm;
award medal, gilt-lead copy, 70 mm, awarded to The Cheney
Talking Machine Co.; and a uniface brass disc, 69 mm, used
as The Cheney Talking Machine Co.’s nameplate from one of
their products. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
International Exposition Medal of Award. Bronze.
76.5 mm. By Albert Laessle. Edge: BBB Co PHILA.
About Uncirculated. Obv: Defiant eagle protecting nest
with Independence Hall and a rising sun in the distance,
designer’s “signature” near lower right border. Rev:
Inscription SESQUICENTENNIAL INTERNATIONAL
EXPOSITION PHILADELPHIA 1776-1926 around wreath
enclosing another inscription MEDAL / OF AWARD in
center.
3037 1933 Century of Progress International Exposition Official
Medal. Bronze. 70 mm. Choice About Uncirculated.
Obv: Nude male standing on a base inscribed 1833 - 1933
with the words RESEARCH left and INDUSTRY right.
Rev: Name and year of the exposition around an aerial
view of the grounds with compass points. Edge: Inscribed
PRESENTED BY A CENTURY OF PROGRESS TO JAMES
O’DONNELL BENNETT, NOVEMBER 11, 1933. Bennett
was a well known Chicago journalist working for the
Chicago Tribune at the time of the exposition.
Page 236
3038 1935 California-Pacific International Exposition
Award Medal. Gold-Plated. 70.5 mm. By Medallic
Art Co. Unawarded. Choice About Uncirculated.
Obv: View of the California Tower and Archway with
inscription .CALIFORNIA.PACIFIC.INTERNATIONAL.
EXPOSITION. around the border, SAN DIEGO on a scroll
below, and the date 1935 at the bottom. Rev: Nude male and
female figures flying left toward a rising sun. The area for an
inscription below has been left blank.
Numismatic Association
Medals
3039 Undated (1907) Button for the American Numismatic
Association Convention in Columbus, Ohio. Celluloid.
32 mm. Extremely Fine. A simple button used for
membership recognition at this early ANA show. Gold print
on red background reads AMERICAN NUMISMATIC
ASSOCIATION / ORGANIZED 1891 around the ANA
logo. The paper insert on the back is still present, and the
pin is fully functional.
3040 1909 American Numismatic Association Convention
Badge for the Annual Meeting in Montreal. Very Fine.
This badge consists of a 37.5 mm celluloid badge with 50
mm lengths of white and gold silk ribbons. Minor foxing to
the button and light tattering to the ribbons are noted.
Badge for the Show in New York City. Celluloid. 32 mm.
Very Fine. Cream-colored pinback badge with olive printing
that reads A.N.A. / N.Y. / 1910 divided by the logos of the
ANA, ANS and New York Numismatic Club. Attached are
60 mm red, white and blue silk ribbons.
3042 1911 American Numismatic Association Badge for the
Convention in Chicago. Very Fine. Consists of a 24 x 63 mm
pinback name tag with printed MEMBER under celluloid.
Suspended is a yellow and beige watered silk ribbon lettered
in gold CONVENTION / AMERICAN / NUMISMATIC /
ASSOCIATION / AUG. 28-29-30-31 / 1911 / CHICAGO,
ILL. At the bottom of the ribbon is a 34 mm black on white
celluloid ANA logo. The ribbon is slightly smudged.
Convention in Rochester, New York. Very Fine. The
badge is composed of a 23 x 50 mm bronze oval pinback
with the inscription AMERICAN NUMISMATIC ASSN
/ ROCHESTER, N.Y. 1912 surrounding the ANA and
Rochester Numismatic Association logos. A suspended
41 x 112 mm red, white and blue silk ribbon is inscribed
ROCHESTER / N.Y. / AUGUST 26-27-28 / 1912 in silver
print. The metal hangar is nearly Mint State, although the
ribbon is somewhat spotted.
Badge for the Annual Show in Springfield, Massachusetts.
About Uncirculated. This is a two-piece, gold-plated brass
hanging badge, the upper pinback with the ANA logo on
a shield and a banner inscribed SPRINGFIELD MASS
AUG 22-26 1914. Suspended is a 41 mm round medallion
showing the clock tower and city hall. Mounted to the
original Whitehead & Hoag card.
Badge for the Annual Show in San Francisco. A 16 x
46 mm blank pinback name plate supports a 42 x 85 mm
gold silk ribbon inscribed AMERICAN / NUMISMATIC
/ ASSOCIATION / SAN FRANCISCO / 1915 and a gilt
bronze Panama-Pacific Exposition so-called dollar, HK-401.
The so-called dollar is AU, but the ribbon is badly frayed and
beginning to separate between the words NUMISMATIC
and ASSOCIATION.
Badge for the Annual Meeting in Baltimore. About
Uncirculated. This is a four-part badge with a BALTIMORE
inscribed pinback bar supporting a copper replica of a Lord
Baltimore penny and a white watered silk ribbon. At the base
of the ribbon is a ring and a 38 mm silver-plated medal with
the ANA logo on one side and on the other the inscription
25TH / ANNIVERSARY / CONVENTION / BALTIMORE,
MD . SEPT 23-27 / 1916 within a laurel wreath.
Annual Meeting in Rochester, New York. By Bastian
Brothers. About Uncirculated. This is a two-part metal
badge with red, white and blue silk ribbon. The pin back
hangar bears the ANA logo, two shields and the inscription
26TH ANNUAL CONVENTION. The larger hanging
medal features the High Falls of Genesee in Rochester and
surrounding buildings, most of which still remain standing
today.
3048 Lot of (2) 1919 American Numismatic Association
Convention Badges for the Annual Meeting in
Philadelphia. Extremely Fine. Included are: pinback Liberty
Bell supporting a red, white and blue silk ribbon imprinted
with the convention dates and location; and a pinback
inscribed PHILADELPHIA portraying Independence Hall,
from which hangs a gray and yellow watered silk ribbon
marked A.N.A. / OCTOBER / 4TH TO 8TH / 1919, a brass
image of the Liberty Bell is suspended from the ribbon.
3049 Lot of (4) American Numismatic Association Convention
Pins and Badges, 1920-1924. Extremely Fine. Includes
pinback medals from the 1920 Chicago and 1921 Boston
conventions and ribbon badges for the 1923 Montreal and
1924 Cleveland conventions.
3050 Undated (1922) Joseph Choate Medal. Bronze. 63.5 mm.
By Herbert Adams. Edge: 75 (of 238). Very Fine. Obv:
Bust left, with name CHOATE inscribed along left border
and initials of designer HA near lower right border. Rev:
Oil lamp above inscription JOSEPH HODGES CHOATE
/ 1832-1917 / PATRIOT / AMBASSADOR / JURIST /
ORATOR. A wreath encircles the inscription and the ANS
logo is below.
Badges, 1925-1929. Included are pinback badges for the
following conventions: 1925 Detroit; 1926 Washington,
D.C.; 1927 Hartford, Connecticut; 1928 Rochester, New
York; and 1929 Chicago. Grades range from Extremely Fine
to Mint State. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
Badges, 1930-1934. About Uncirculated. Included are:
1930 Buffalo; 1931 Cincinnati; 1932 Los Angeles; 1933
Chicago; and (2) 1934 Cleveland, one bronze and the other
silver-plated. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
Badges, 1935-1939. Included are: (2) 1935 Pittsburgh, one
bronze and the other silver-plated; 1936 Minneapolis; 1937
Washington, D.C.; 1938 Columbus; and (2) 1939 New York
City, one standard badge and the other a Committee badge,
the ribbon that supports the heavy Committee badge medal
has separated and is hanging by a thread (literally). Most
examples are Extremely Fine. This is a must see, sold as is,
no return lot.
3054 Lot of (15) American Numismatic Association Badges,
Pins, Medals and Ribbons, 1940-1950. Includes the rare
1941 Ladies’ pin. A diverse selection that should be viewed
to be appreciated. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
Miscellaneous Medals
3055 Lot of (4) Miscellaneous Medals. Highlights include a
uniface zinc piece of New York sculptor Louis Zoellner and
a cast bronze 1889 25th Anniversary of the Founding of the
New York School for Young Women (now Reed College)
medal. Sizes range from 52 to 67 mm, grades average Very
Fine to Extremely Fine, and three of the pieces appear to be
trial strikes. Worthy of a close look. This is a must see, sold
as is, no return lot.
Hard Times Tokens
3056 1838 Am I Not A Woman. HT-81, Low-54. Rarity-1.
Copper. 28.3 mm. VF Details—Improperly Cleaned
(NGC).
3057 Great Britain—Middlesex. Undated (1790s) Am I Not A
Man And A Brother Political Token. D&H-1039A. Edge:
PAYABLE IN DUBLIN. VF-30 BN (NGC). These popular
British provincial pieces are related to the Hard Times
tokens HT-81 and HT-82 by both subject and design.
3058 New York—New York. 1837 Feuchtwanger Cent. HT-268,
Low-120, Die Combination 5-H. Rarity-1. German Silver.
18.5 mm. VF-20.
3059 New York—New York. 1837 Feuchtwanger Cent. HT-268,
Low-120, Die Combination 5-H. Rarity-1. German Silver.
18.5 mm. VF-20.
3060 New York—New York. 1837 R.E. Russell. HT-309, Low128. Rarity-5. German Silver. 19.5 mm. Fine-12 Damaged.
3061 Lot of (9) Hard Times Tokens. Various satirical types
are represented, including Daniel Webster, Illustrious
Predecessor, Liberty-Not One Cent and Mint Drop. Also
included in this lot is a Root & Co. merchant token. Grades
range from VG to EF, with most examples VF and several
impaired. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot. (Total:
10 tokens)
Page 237
Patriotic Civil War Tokens
3062 Lot of (9) Patriotic Civil War Tokens. Copper. (NGC).
Included are: 1863 God Protect The Union, Fuld-5/288,
Rarity-2, MS-65 RB; 1864 Army & Navy, Fuld-11/298,
Rarity-1, MS-64 BN; 1863 Army & Navy, Fuld-13/297,
Rarity-2, MS-63 BN; 1863 Indian / Crossed Cannons, Fuld79/351, Rarity-1, MS-63 BN; 1863 Indian / Crossed Cannons,
Fuld-82/352A, Rarity-2, MS-65 BN; 1863 Washington /
New York, Fuld-110/442, Rarity-1, MS-64 BN; undated
(1861-1865) Benjamin Franklin, Fuld-151/430, Rarity-1,
MS-63 BN; 1863 First in War, First in Peace, Fuld-174/272,
Rarity-1, MS-65 RB; and undated (1861-1865) The Federal
Union, Fuld-225/327, Rarity-1, MS-65 BN.
3063 Lot of (10) Patriotic Civil War Tokens. Copper. (NGC).
Included are: 1863 Not One Cent, Fuld-61/335, Rarity-3,
MS-65 BN; 1863 Not One Cent, Fuld-69/369, Rarity-3,
MS-65 RB; 1863 Indian / Crossed Cannons, Fuld-80/351,
Rarity-3, MS-65 BN; 1863 Indian / Crossed Cannons,
Fuld-81/351, Rarity-2, MS-65 RB; 1863 Indian / Crossed
Cannons, Fuld-82/352A, Rarity-2, MS-64 BN; 1863 First
in War, First in Peace, Fuld-174/272, Rarity-1, MS-64 BN;
1863 Union Must Be Preserved, Fuld-178/267, Rarity-1,
MS-65 BN; undated (1861-1865) Flag Of Our Union, Fuld214/416, Rarity-1, MS-64 BN; undated (1861-1865) Our
Country, Fuld-231/352A, Rarity-1, MS-65 RB; and undated
(1861-1865) Army & Navy, Fuld-299/350, Rarity-2, MS-64
RB.
3064 Undated (1861-1865) Tradesmens Currency. Fuld202/434 a. Rarity-1. Copper. 19 mm—Rim Clip—MS-64
BN (PCGS).
PCGS# E605039.
Civil War Store Cards
3071 New York—New York. Undated (1863) Broas Pie Baker.
Fuld-630M-1b. Rarity-2. Brass. 19.5 mm—Uniface
Obverse Strike—AU-55. The reverse design is completely
missing when an intervening blank planchet came between
it and the die at the time of striking. Somewhere out there is
the mate to this piece with a uniface reverse strike.
3072 Ohio—Cincinnati.
Undated
(1861-1865)
Frank
Beresford. Fuld-165P-1a1. Rarity-2. Copper. 19 mm. MS62 BN (NGC).
3073 Ohio—Morrow. 1863 E. Levy. Fuld-570B-2a. Rarity-5.
Copper. 19.5 mm. EF-40 Cleaned.
3074 Philadelphia—Pennsylvania. Undated (1861-1865) M.B.
Allebach Watch Maker. Fuld-750B-1d. Rarity-6. CopperNickel. 19 mm. MS-61 (NGC).
Civil War Tokens
3075 Lot of (4) Civil War Tokens. Included are: (2) Patriotic; and
(2) store cards. Four different types, with grades ranging
from VF to AU. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
(2) store cards. Grades range from EF to AU for this quintet
of mixed types. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
(6) store cards. A selection of different types, with grades
ranging from EF to Mint State. This is a must see, sold as is,
no return lot.
(6) store cards. This is a high grade group of mixed types, EF
and better, with all but two examples retaining a significant
amount of red luster. This is a must see, sold as is, no return
lot.
Sutler Tokens
3065 Connecticut—Bridgeport. Undated (Circa 1863) A.W.
Wallace. Fuld-35B-1b. Rarity-8. Brass. 19 mm. AU-55.
3066 Lot of (7) Civil War Store Cards, 1863-1864. Copper.
Included are: Illinois: Chicago, Ira Brown Book Dealer,
Fuld-150G-3a, Rarity-7; Indiana: Columbia City, Kepner
& Son Groceries, Fuld-175C-1a, Rarity-6; Corunna, Ira
W. Bowen Drugs, Fuld-190B-3a, Rarity-6; Fortville, J.H.
Thomas Dry Goods, Fuld-285A-3a, Rarity-6; Ohio: Berea,
D.E. Stearns, Fuld-74A-7a, Rarity-8; Cincinnati, W.W.
Hanley Wholesale Grocer, Fuld-165BL-3a, Rarity-8; and
Wisconsin: Fond du Lac, Clark and Carpenter Dry Goods
and Groceries, Fuld-220D-1a, Rarity-6. Grades range from
EF to AU, and most examples are impaired due to cleaning.
3067 Indiana—Cadiz. 1863 Hiatt & Showalter. Fuld-160B-1a1.
Rarity-8. Copper. 19 mm. AU-58 BN (NGC).
3068 Michigan—Detroit. 1863 Geo. H. Parker, Dealer in Hides,
Leather and Wool. Fuld-225BB-2a. Rarity-7. Copper.
19.5 mm. MS-64 BN.
3069 Michigan—Mussey. 1863 E.C. Morse. Fuld-680A-1a.
Rarity-5. Copper. 19 mm. AU-50 Cleaned.
3070 Michigan—Paw Paw.1863 J.D. Sherman. Fuld-745D-2a.
Rarity-6. Copper. 19.5 mm. EF-40 Cleaned.
Page 238
3079 Nebraska. S. W. Beall 25 Cents. Schenkman-C25B.
Rarity-9. Brass. 21 mm. EF-40 (NGC).
From our sale of the John J. Ford, Jr. Collection, Part XXIII, August
2013, lot 21433. Paper envelope with attribution notation included.
3080 New York. J.J. Benson 25 Cents. Schenkman-A25C.
Rarity-6. Copper. EF-40 BN (NGC).
3081 Ohio. P. Merwin 5 Cents. Schenkman-I5B. Rarity-7.
Brass. 17 mm. MS-61 (NGC).
Civil War and Confederacy
3082 1865 General George Henry Thomas Lauditory Medal.
Bronze. 77.3 mm. Struck by the Paris Mint and Published
by Tiffany & Co. Edge: (bee) CUIVRE. Extremely Fine,
Cleaned, Scratches. Obv: Bust of the general left with
inscription TO MAJOR GENERAL GEORGE H. THOMAS
FROM THE STATE OF TENNESSEE around the border.
Rev: Courthouse in center with inscriptions “I WILL
HOLD THE TOWN TILL WE STARVE.” above and “BY
JOINT RESOLUTION / ADOPTED NOV. 2. / 1865 below.
Rare.
Indian Trader Tokens
3083 Arizona—Ganado. Undated (1892-1930) J.L. Hubbell
Trading Post. Good for $1.00 in Merchandise. Aluminum.
38 mm octagonal. VF-20. Also included in this lot is a 29
mm round brass token of Lohnes & Ault, Plattsmouth,
Nebraska, good for 25 cents in trade. This Nebraska piece
is not an Indian Trader, but it is interesting, nonetheless.
(Total: 2 tokens)
3084 Indian
Territory—Cheyenne
Agency.
Undated
(Circa 1880) Lee & Reynolds Trade Token. Curto-69,
Wright-590. “Trade Mark” Variety. White Metal. 31 mm.
VF-20 Attempted Puncture. Reverse with TRADE MARK
largely obliterated, as is the case with many examples of this
type.
Post-Civil War
Military Token
3085 Undated (Circa 1859-1878) Fort Larned Subsistence
Department. One Ration. Curto-M21; Cunningham-KS
170a. Copper. 24.3 mm. VF-20 Cleaned. Holed, as made.
Embossed Shell Card
3086 New York—New York. Shafer & Hamilton. 34.4 mm.
Very Fine, Obverse Dents. Double sided with a Liberty
Head obverse and the reverse carrying the inscription of the
merchant.
Counterstamps
3087 Maine—Bangor. C.A. STRANGE on an 1864 L on Ribbon
Indian cent. Brunk S-1061, Rulau Me-BA24. Host coin
Fine.
3088 E. COONS on an 1876-S Type I/I trade dollar. BrunkUnlisted, Rulau-Unlisted. Host coin VF.
3089 PA / Floret Engraved on 1794 Liberty Cap cent. Host coin
Fair. Looks like a counterstamp at first glance. Chocolate
brown toning.
3090 R on an 1830 Large 0 Capped Bust half dollar. BrunkUnlisted, Rulau-Unlisted. Host Coin VF.
3091 VOTE THE LAND / FREE (Free Soil Ticket(?)—Political
Party) on an 1842 Braided Hair cent. Brunk V-110. Host
coin VG. Blended tan and olive brown with navy highlights.
Minor reverse verdigris. Vote the Land Free tokens were
issued in 1844 as part of the current presidential campaign.
A section on this particular counterstamp appears in Dave
Bowers’ 2002 book, More Adventures with Rare Coins. In that
book Bowers suggests that this counterstamp may have been
applied by members of the National Reform Association.
3092 Floret Punch Counterstamped 12 Times on a worn
(1794?) Liberty Cap cent. Host coin Poor. Due to wear no
attribution can be attested, but certain surviving features
suggest the possibly of Sheldon 18 or 19.
3093 Lot of (10) Counterstamps on U.S. Half Cents. Many have
manufacturer’s or vendor’s names or initials in rectangular
incuse punches. Most are Brunk-Unlisted except as noted.
Included are: W.B. in serrated rectangle on 1804; P. BOWL
in rectangle on worn Draped Bust; C.& G.A.H on 1828;
Massachusetts silversmith, three pseudo hallmarks—date
letter B, eagle, and standing Indian with bow, each in
separate elliptical cartouche on 1806; S heart JS on 1828;
N.S. in serrated rectangle on 1851; C.T. on worn Draped
Bust, Brunk T-16; and (3) A.V in serrated rectangle on
1834, Brunk V-5. Grades of host coins range from Fair to
EF. Counterstamps on half cents are far rarer as a class than
are those on large copper cents.
3094 Lot of (10) Counterstamps on U.S. Half Cents. Most are
Brunk-Unlisted except as noted. Included are: Eagle A on
1828, Brunk A-1; Cursive LWC monogram on 1829; OxD
on 1835, Brunk O-3; O&G on 1832, Brunk O-4; (2) O&G on
1835, Brunk O-4; R/I with letters superimposed, I alignment
rotated 90 degrees with respect to R, all in serrated circle,
also flower on 1828; C.T. and unicorn’s head, similar to
Brunk T-17, but no cigar; Crowned X stamped twice on
1835, Brunk X-1 (ascribed to pewterer Thomas Wildes);
and # (hash mark) in incuse square punch on 1804. Grades
of host coins range from Poor to VF.
3095 Lot of (10) Counterstamps on U.S. Half Cents. Most have
either single letters or two/three-letter sequences. All are
Brunk-Unlisted except as noted. Included are: B on 1833;
G.B on 1853; G.W.C. on 1835, Brunk C-53; VVVL on 1851,
Brunk L-26; PM on 1828; JP on 1807; IT on 1804; JW on
1831; 95 on 1855; and a small sunburst within round incuse
punch on 1857. Grades of host coins range from Poor to EF.
either single letters or two/three-letter sequences. Most are
Brunk-Unlisted except as noted. Included are: A&T on 1850,
Brunk A-20; ABBE/10 on 1804; G.F on 1855, Brunk F-20;
PK on 1851; VVVL on 1828, Brunk L-26; G.D.S. (crossed by
awl, needle or spike) on 1828; IAS on 1828; J.V. on 1825; J:W
on 1834; and a small sunburst in incuse round cartouche on
1857. Grades of host coins range from Fair to EF.
3097 Lot of (10) Counterstamps on U.S. Half Cents. All have
Brunk-Unlisted except as noted. Included are: A&T on
1850, Brunk A-20; G on 1855; O.H. on 1825; M.K. on 1828;
M on 1834; SPL (PL ligatured) on 1851; D.S. on 1806; MS
on 1854; and W.T. on 1828; D.W./6 on 1836. Grades of host
coins range from Poor to EF.
Brunk-Unlisted except as noted. Included are: AB on 1855;
J.A. DE[///] (incomplete stamp) on 1828, probably Brunk
D-277; AJ on 1803; VVVL on 1851, Brunk L-26; CM on
1826; EWP on 1851; G.D.S. (crossed by awl, needle or spike)
on 1828; J.V. on 1828; 1/2 on 1835; and a small sunburst in
incuse round cartouche on 1857. Grades of host coins range
from Poor to EF.
3099 Lot of (2) Counterstamped Large Cents. Included are:
New Hampshire—Pittsfield, DR. G. G. WILKINS on an
1853 Braided Hair cent, Brunk W-610, Rulau NH-112, host
coin Fine; and RK (?) on an 1823 Matron Head cent, Brunkunlisted, Rulau-unlisted, host coin VG.
Page 239
3100 Lot of (10) Counterstamps on U.S. Large Cents. The
counterstamps all consist of one, two, or three letters in
incuse rectangular punches, often with serrated borders.
These stamps are the type often used by early 19th-century
craftsmen to identify their wares. None of the marks were
found listed in Brunk or Rulau, and it’s possible that some
may be unique. The listings are arranged alphabetically
by the last letter in the mark. Included are: J.H.C on 1820
cent; G.H.+ and floral motif on 18—Matron Head cent; M
on 1802 cent; B.B.S on 1797 cent; J:C:S on worn Matron
Head cent; R.S on 1798 cent; W.S on 1798 cent; S:T on 1803
cent; H.W on 1802 cent; and W:W on worn (Classic Head?)
cent. Host coins grade average Poor to VG. (As specialists
know, for counterstamps the more worn the host coin is, the
clearer the counterstamp is apt to be. Many counterstampers
deliberately selected well-worn coins for counterstamping, a
situation quite opposite that of regular numismatics.
3104 Lot of (14) Counterstamps of Ornamental Elements
on U.S. Large Cents. Ornaments include: anchor, cross,
diamonds, florets, foliage sprigs, geometrical patterns, and
sunburst. Host coins grade from Poor to VF, and dates from
1803 to 1852. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
3101 Lot of (30) Counterstamps on U.S. Large Cents. These
pieces consist mostly of random stamped letters or numerals,
while others have multiple letters or numerals. Some may
have been stamped with logotypes. A few were probably
intended as service checks used in restaurants where meals
would be received by the customer at the counter after
payment had been tendered. In two or three cases letters
were crudely engraved rather than stamped. Host coins
range from Poor to VF or better. Dates range from 1798
up into the 1850s. Several different host types are present
including both Draped Bust and Classic Head designs.
In-person examination is recommended to prospective
bidders. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
3106 Lot of (10) Counterstamps and Related Items. Included
are: PATENTED on 1824 cent, Brunk P-220; PATENT / 10 /
NEW-YORK on 1847 cent, Brunk P-220 (type); PAT’D MAY
2 / 1871 on 1852 cent, Brunk-Unlisted; (floral ornaments)
on (4) cents—1796 (Liberty Cap), 1797, 1819, and 1825;
(unidentified company logotype) on 1842 cent; pseudo
full obverse and reverse brockage of dateless Matron Head
cent with initials H.F.W. raised on reverse (F. backwards),
electrotype, resembles a counterstamp at first glance; and
1798 cent, holed at center and plugged with disk made from
center of D.L. Wing Civil War token, NY-10H-7a, with
WING visible on obverse and [U]NIO[N] [FL]OU[R] on
reverse. This last piece was probably made as a novelty to
befuddle a novice collector. Grades of host coins range from
Poor to VF.
counterstamps are nearly all two-letter logotypes of the type
used by craftsmen to identify their wares between the early
and mid 19th century. Included are: CA on worn Matron
Head; C.B. on 1805; DB on 1836; IB on 1814; IB on worn
Matron Head; JB on 1837(?); S/B on 1837; DC on 1810; FC
on 1840; HC on 1818; S.C on worn Matron Head; M.D. on
worn Classic Head; S.D. on 1803; A.E on 1807; IG on 1798;
CH on 1853; S.H on 1798; L.I. on 1802 (possibly engraved
rather than punched); C.K. on 1851; T.L on 1852; DM on
worn Matron Head; I.M on 1824; TN on 1849; JO on 1850;
H.P. on 1803; W.P. on 1802; DS on 1802; G.S. on worn
Matron Head; W.S./O on worn Classic Head; S.T on 1812;
S.T on 1822; and ST on 1820. Host coins range from Poor to
VF. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
3103 Lot of (15) Counterstamps on Different Types of Large
Cents. Made using incuse rectangular punches, logotypes,
and individual letter punches. Most are Brunk-Unlisted
except as noted. Included are: AB in incuse rectangular
punch on worn, rough Matron Head; J.F.G. on 184x Petite
Head; T.J.H. on 1822; IML monogram in rectangular punch
on 1848; T.W.L. on worn Matron Head; VVVL on 1851,
Brunk L-26; M.McM on 1802; Inverted N in square punch
on 1826; EN on 1805 (Sheldon-269), VF, with rim damage;
JAJR (individual letter punches) on 1838; C.T.S. on 1850;
W.S.M.T. (individual letter punches) on 1816; T.A.W. on
1845; unattributed world counterstamp on worn Draped
Bust; and an unattributed world counterstamp on 1856.
Host coins range from Poor to VF. Incused rectangular
punches were commonly used by manufacturers of hand
tools, agricultural implements and the like, to mark their
products made of metal or of hard wood. Over a period of
time many once-unattributed marks have been identified, a
field that has many interesting challenges. This is a must see,
Page 240
3105 Lot of (10) Counterstamps on U.S. Large Cents. Likely
used as identification marks by silversmiths, jewelers, watch
makers, pen manufacturers, and related trades. Most are
Brunk-Unlisted except as noted. Included are: J.B. & Co.
and E.L.P. on 1812; J.P.B. on worn Matron Head; RF on
1816, cleaned; RF on 1818; W.G. & S (William Gale & Son)
and G. & S. (same) on 1848, Brunk G-32; SH on 1807/6
(Sheldon-273); DK on worn Draped Bust; I.K on 1803
(possibly silversmith Joseph Keeler); J.R on 1803 (possibly
silversmith Joseph Richardson Jr.); and undetermined
maker’s mark and pseudo hallmarks on 1808. Grades of host
coins range from Poor to VF.
stamps are likely those of manufacturers and merchants.
Most appear to be logotypes, but some may have been
made using individual letter punches. Most are unlisted in
Brunk, except as noted, and some varieties may be unique.
Included are: A.C. COBB on 1849; C GARDNER on worn
copper (possibly plane-maker Charles Gardner of Cornwall,
Connecticut); GARDNER (incomplete stamp, missing first
initial) on 1848, Brunk-Undetermined; P. HOFF on 1796
Liberty Cap; D. HUTCHINS / 1841 on 1839; MOUSLEY
& KENNEDY on 1822; H. REES on 1823, Brunk R-163; R.
TELLER on 1852; A.& S. THAYER on 1830; and A.H. VOSS
on 1854. Grades of host coins range from Poor to VF. A very
interesting lot with endless research possibilities for seeking
historical information on the Internet.
3108 Lot of (10) Counterstamps on U.S. Large Cents. Most are
unlisted in Brunk except as noted; some may be unique.
Included are: BACKUS on 1802; BARTLETT (incomplete
stamp, missing first initial) on 1850, Brunk-Undetermined;
BERKS CO (probably a location, Berks County rather than
business name) on 1839; DOTZER on 1837; FISH on 1818;
S. FRITZ on 1817; MC NEILL or [O’NEILL?] (incomplete
stamp, missing first letter), Brunk M-535(?); PIKE on 1803,
Brunk P-491; H. TRIPP on 1822, Brunk T-422; and WM
WALKER on 1814, possibly the auger maker from Rochester
3109 Lot of (2) E.A.C. (Early American Coppers) Convention
Souvenir Counterstamps. Included are: E A C / 69;
and EAC / FLORIDA / 1979 / HERB / 13. These are each
stamped on worn Matron Head cents that grade Poor.
3110 Lot of (10) Counterstamps. All examples are on United
States large cents, except where noted. Many are unlisted
in Brunk, except as noted; some may be unique. Included
are: G.W. AKIN on 1851, Brunk A-156; H.S. BURGES on
1851, Brunk B-1333 (old Stack’s auction envelope included);
COLBY (possibly incomplete stamp), Brunk-Uncertain;
I. (or J.?) CONOVER on large worn, unidentified copper,
Brunk-Unlisted; CURRAN on 1847; J.G. HALL on worn
Matron Head; T. IDE on 1803, Brunk I-22; E.W. LOOMIS
on 1848, Brunk L-485; M. SER (possibly incomplete stamp),
on 1838; and a SON on worn Draped Bust. Grades of host
3111 Lot of (7) Counterstamps. All examples are on United
States large cents, except as noted. Most are Brunk-Unlisted
except as noted. Included are: CAST STEEL and eagle/
crown logo on 1832, Brunk C-270; DR2 and L.A. CO. on
1848, L.A. CO, holed, possibly a keytag; DRAM on 1807,
Dram weight die stamped twice on obverse; Masonic, 265
/ R.A.M. (Royal Arch Masons), Brunk M-43; SQUARE and
1234567890 on worn copper (or blank planchet), Brunk
S-793; floret on 1832; and florets and jewel on 1802. Grades
of host coins range from Poor to VF.
3112 Lot of (10) Counterstamps on U.S. Large Cents. A few are
not listed in Brunk. Included are: BLAKELY on 1851, Brunk
B-756; L.P. BOSWORTH on 1805, Brunk B-912; CLARK on
corroded 1840, Brunk C-483; S. DARBY and S.M. HINE on
worn 180- Draped Bust, Brunk D-Unlisted and H-622; J.B.
DELANY on 1819, Brunk-Unlisted; D.E. DOWNS on 1831,
Brunk D-506; R.W. LANDER on 1845; S.A. MURRAY on
1838, Brunk-Unlisted; J.H. ROOT on 1836, Brunk R-501;
and E.L. WEMPLE on 1821, Brunk W-387. Grades of host
3113 Lot of (6) Counterstamps on U.S. Large Cents. Included
are: J. CLEWELL on 1853, Brunk C-589; S.I. EATON on
1837, Brunk-Unlisted; N. KEYS on 1802, Brunk-Unlisted;
RICE on 1818, Brunk R-224; N.J. TRACY on 1839, Brunk
T-387; and N.J. TRACY on 1843, Brunk T-387. Tracy was
a prolific counterstamper, but so far his identity has eluded
many researchers. Grades of host coins range from Poor to
Fine.
3114 Lot of (4) Counterstamps on U.S. Large Cents. Included
are: SEE DEUTERO- / NOMY 23: 1,2! on worn Classic
Head, Brunk D-315; [///]GOLD / N-Y (incomplete stamp,
missing first part of name) on 1846, Brunk-Undetermined;
GRISWOLD & CO. / CAST STEEL on worn Draped Bust,
Brunk G-580; and TERRAPIN on 1846, Brunk T-137.
Grades of host coins range from Poor to Fine.
3115 Lot of (29) Counterstamps on Flying Eagle, Indian and
Lincoln Cents. These mostly have either single letters
or numerals or sequences of two, three, or four letters or
numerals. It’s presumed that letter sequences represent name
initials. Highlights include: PAT AUG. / 17 - 75 on 1863,
Brunk-Unlisted; and pseudo date letter “Y” (?) in shieldshaped cartouche on 1857 Flying Eagle, Brunk-unlisted.
Grades of host coins range from Poor to AU. Counterstamps
on Flying Eagle and Indian cents are largely an unexplored
area, one which offers many opportunities for research,
without much competition elsewhere in the marketplace.
3116 Lot of (22) Counterstamps on Flying Eagle and Indian
Cents. Included are: C.W. B[///] (incomplete stamp) on
1857 Flying Eagle, probably Brunk B-429; FOTZ (individual
letter punches) on 1862, Brunk-Unlisted; LAYETTE
(misspelling of LAFAYETTE?; individual letter punches)
on 1859, Brunk-Unlisted; C.H. LEE on 1874, Brunk L-224;
C.W. LEWIS on 1880, Brunk-Unlisted; LILLIE on 1862,
Brunk-Unlisted; C.W. LUND / F.R. WOOD on worn
bronze Indian cent, Brunk-Unlisted; L. MILLER on 1863,
Brunk M-688; MOULTSU on 1858, probably M-939 which
would mean a misspelling in Brunk; [///]ORBE (incomplete
stamp) on 1882, Brunk-Undetermined; THE OTTAWA
on 1890, Brunk O-146, ship name (?); SEAVER on 1860,
Brunk-Unlisted; L. SPAULDING on 1858, Brunk S-740;
STERLING on 1863, Brunk S-918; WATERBURY / KNIFE
C2 on 1858, Brunk-Unlisted; [///]WEST[///] (incomplete
stamp) on 1893, Brunk-Undetermined; J.C. WESTOVER
on 1874, Brunk-Unlisted; (2) DR. G.G. WILKINS on 1857
and 1858, Brunk W-610; C. WYMAN on 1859 , Brunk
W-929; (eagle) on 1860, Brunk-Unlisted; and (flower) on
1863, Brunk-Unlisted. Grades of host coins range from
Poor to EF. This is a great lot for research, largely unexplored
territory. There are scattered exceptions, such as the famous
Wilkins counterstamps. This is a must see, sold as is, no
return lot.
3117 Lot of (32) Counterstamps on Two-Cent Pieces, Silver
Three-Cent Pieces, Nickel Three-Cent Pieces, and Nickel
Five-Cent Pieces. These mostly have either single letters
or numerals or sequences of two, three, or four letters or
numerals. It’s presumed that letter sequences represent
name initials. Highlights include: DEAL / W.C. CO., INC.
/ WARRANTED / 14K on 1908 Liberty Nickel, BrunkUnlisted; G. COOK on 1869 Shield Nickel, Brunk C-860;
H.& S. on blank five-cents size nickel planchet, BrunkUnlisted; W.H. REYNOLDS on 1883 No CENTS nickel,
Brunk-Unlisted; A. SCHUTT on 1865 nickel three cents,
Brunk S-205; and IDA WILLSON on 1868 Shield Nickel,
Brunk W-675. Host coins of counterstamps range from
Poor to AU. This is a must see, sold as is, no return lot.
3118 Lot of (11) Counterstamps on U.S. Two-Cent Pieces.
Included are: [///]AGGAN (incomplete stamp) on 1864
Large Motto, Brunk undetermined; S.M. CARTER, Brunk
C-236; U. G. DAVIS on 1864 Large Motto, Brunk-Unlisted;
EAGLE on 1865, Brunk-Unlisted; HENRY (Brunk H-496)
and H.W. (Brunk-Unlisted) on silvered 1866; HUNT &
MOORE on 1865, Brunk H-923; M. MATTHEWS on 1865,
Brunk-Unlisted; MONROE on 1864 Large Motto, BrunkUnlisted; J.S. OAK[///](incomplete stamp) on 1868, BrunkUnlisted; JR / SMITH on 1865, Brunk-Unlisted; and J.
ULRICH on 1865, Brunk U-18. Grades of host coins range
from Poor to VF.
3119 Lot of (2) Counterstamps on U.S. Two-Cent Pieces.
Included are: CHELSEA FILE WORKS on 1866, BrunkUnlisted; and [///] PAT. JULY 3 / MILWAUKEE WS
(incomplete stamp) on 1865, Brunk-Undetermined. The
Directory of American Toolmakers places the Chelsea File
Works in Norwich, Connecticut during the closing decade
of the 19th century. Host coins grade average AG to Good.
Page 241
3120 Lot of (13) Counterstamps on U.S. Half Dimes and Dimes.
Included are: E.C.D. on 1873 Arrows dime, Brunk-Unlisted;
ELKL[///] (incomplete stamp) in 188x dime, BrunkUnlisted, resembles certain railroad counterstamps; C.W.F.
on 1841-O half dime, Brunk-Unlisted; J. & H. on 1861
dime (possible O mintmark), Brunk J-6 (type); PATENT
/ JUNE 8, 1856 on 1850 dime, Brunk-Unlisted; W.A.R. on
1859 dime, Brunk-Unlisted; K.E.S. on 1877 dime, BrunkUnlisted; [///]STITT (incomplete stamp) on 1853 Arrows
dime, Brunk uncertain — possibly S-992; (2) Liberty Seated
half dimes counterstamped variously with numerals 0 and
2; (2) Liberty Seated dimes counterstamped variously with P
and flower; 1897-O dime counterstamped with R. Grades of
host coins range from AG to VF. With regard to patent dates
on various counterstamps, Google Patents on the Internet is
an ideal source for tracking down the issuers of such pieces,
definitive in some instances, speculatively in others, but an
interesting challenge in any respect.
3121 Lot of (9) Counterstamps. All examples are on Capped
Bust dimes, except where noted. All are Brunk-Unlisted.
Included are: ADB on 1833; J.B on 1827; P. COLKINS
(lettering stippled in by engraver, not counterstamped), host
coin is dateless; HUNTER / WATRIN and stray individual
letters on worn cob real (?): K on 1820; CM on 1835; FZ on
1827; 1854, host coin dateless; and a floret punch stamped
six times on 1832 half dime.
3122 Lot of (2) Counterstamps on 1875-S Twenty-Cent Pieces.
Included are: H.M.S., Brunk-Unlisted; and 20 (separate
numeral punches), Brunk-Unlisted. Host coins grade
average AG to Good.
3123 Lot of (2) Counterstamps on Capped Bust Quarter
Dollars. Included are: T on 1822, Brunk-Unlisted; and
W.H.W. on 1818, Brunk-Unlisted, scratched. Host coins
grade AG to Good.
3124 Lot of (15) Counterstamps on U.S. Quarters. All are
Brunk-Unlisted except as noted. Included are: C.R.B. on
1876-S; USE /GGG on 1853 Arrows and Rays, Brunk G-9; J
on 1853 No Arrows; F.S.L./X on 1893; H.U.E. RUFFER[///]
(incomplete stamp) on 1857, Brunk-Undetermined;
Inverted S on 1895; J.F.S. on 1858; J.II.V on 1876; WW on
1854 Arrows; YALE on 1909-D, Brunk Y-6; 313 on 1876;
(eagle) punch stamped twice on 1853 Arrows and Rays,
Brunk ETC-13; (flower) on 1854 Arrows; (five-pointed star)
on 1877; and a winged-A (Austin Motor Company logo) on
1934. Grades of host coins range from Fair to VF. This is a
must see, sold as is, no return lot.
Page 242
3125 Lot of (8) Counterstamps on Capped Bust Half Dollars.
All are Brunk-Unlisted except as noted. Included are: J.E.
on 1838; A.L.L. on 1831 (individual letter punches), Brunk
A-192; W.D.P in incuse rectangular punch on 1810; J.F.W.
on 1831; X on 1830; large Latin cross on 1831, scratched;
(small flower in incuse diamond-shaped punch) on 1834;
and a (large five-pointed star) on 1836 Lettered Edge.
Grades of host coins range from VG to EF.
3126 Lot of (9) Counterstamps and Related Items on U.S.
Half Dollars. Included are: G.A. BROMLEY on 1871,
Brunk B-1136, holed for suspension; W.E. COOK on 1857,
Brunk-Unlisted; WM. A. RHEINER on 1876-S, BrunkUnlisted; (unidentified company logo resembling IIIF) on
1859-S, Brunk-Unlisted; also (3) Liberty Seated half dollars,
counterstamped variously with numeral 2, date 1887, and
eight five-pointed stars; 1855 half dollar with carved letters
WW, resembles counterstamp at first glace; and a clockwise
swastika on (sun motif) of 1941 half dollar. Grades of host
coins range from AG to VF.
3127 Lot of (2) Counterstamps on Morgan Silver Dollars.
Included are: PAT. APPL’D. FOR on 1880, Brunk P-196
(type), host coin grades VG; and C.M. SMITH on 1882-O,
Brunk S-561, host coin grades EF.
3128 Lot of (6) Counterstamps on Spanish Colonial Coins.
Included are: W.A. BRABINER on 1757-Mo M 2 reales,
Brunk B-999; MOFFAT[T] (incomplete stamp) on worn
Carlos III 2 reales, Brunk M-789; J.A.P. in serrated rectangle
on 1782 LIMAE MI real, Brunk-Unlisted; S on 1807 Mo
TH real, Brunk-Unlisted; P. STORRS on 1787 LIMAE MI
2 reales; and N-YORK on 1760 Mo M real. Brunk Y-31.
Grades of host coins range from Poor to Fine.
3129 Lot of (5) Counterstamps on Spanish Colonial Coins.
Included are [///]. JONES (incomplete stamp) on worn
Carlos IIII two reales. Brunk-Undetermined; E. LYMAN
on 1774 POTOSI JR 2 reales, Brunk L-613; LYONS on 1799
LIMAE IJ 2 reales, Brunk-Undetermined; J.L. REED on
1783 Mo FF two reales, Brunk R-141; and [///] I W WEP
[///] (incomplete stamp) on 1820 LIMAE JP 2 reales, BrunkUndetermined. Grades of host coins range from Poor to
Fine. One is holed.
The Raymond W. Dillard Collection of Elongated Coins
Stack’s Bowers Galleries is proud to offer selections from the Raymond W. Dillard Collection, a remarkable selection
of elongated coins. A collector of U.S., Canadian and Mexican coins since the 1960s, Ray’s focus eventually turned
to elongated coins, and over the years he carefully built his collection by buying individual rarities as well as entire
collections when it suited him. Thirty years later, he has amassed what is one of the most, if not the most, significant
collections of its kind. The selections offered below represents an excellent opportunity to acquire a large and diverse
assortment of these specialty items — an opportunity that is seldom encountered.
3130 “1853” Port Isabel, Texas Lighthouse Elongated 1928
Lincoln Cent. Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks TEX-XXX-3.
Rarity-10. Extremely Fine, holed at top. MAY 5 1936 is
lightly scratched into both the obverse and reverse fields.
From the Raymond W. Dillard Collection.
3131 1893-1894 Manhattan, New York Exposition Elongated
Large Cent. Dow NY-ME-1. Rarity-6. Very Fine.
3132 Lot of (3) 1893-1894 Manhattan, New York Exposition
Elongated Coins. Dow NY-ME-2. Rarity-7. Included are:
Indian cent, Extremely Fine; Two-Cent Piece, Extremely
Fine; 1845 Liberty Seated dime, Very Fine, holed at top.
3133 Undated (Circa 1901) Buffalo, New York Charles F. Damm
Elongated Aluminum Blanks. About Uncirculated.
Included are: Dow NY-BUF-1, Rarity-5; Dow NY-BUF-2,
Rarity-5; Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks NY-BUF-2a, Rarity-7;
Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks NY-BUF-2b, Rarity-7, holed at
top. This is a must see, sold as is, no returns lot.
3134 Undated (Circa 1901) Buffalo, New York Charles F.
Damm Personal Card Elongated Aluminum Blank. DowUnlisted, Fairbanks-Unlisted. Extremely Fine, minor
vertical crease. Obv: COIN MACHINES / * / FOR SALE BY
/ CHAS. F. DAMM / BUFFALO, N.Y. Rev: THE MACHINE
/ THAT MAKES / SOUVENIRS / OF PENNIES.
3135 1905 Buffalo, New York Elks and Buffalo Elongated Cent.
Muling of Dow NY-BUF-6 and NY-BUF-4. Dow-Unlisted,
Fairbanks-Unlisted. About Uncirculated.
3136 1905 (Portland, Oregon) Lewis and Clark Centennial
Exposition F.L.T / I.O.O.F. Elongated 1902 Barber Dime.
Dow-ORE-LCCE-2. Rarity-5. Extremely Fine, rolled
slightly off-center to the right.
Exposition F.L.T. / I.O.O.F. Elongated 1902 Indian Cent.
Dow ORE-LCCE-2. Rarity-5. Extremely Fine.
Exposition F.L.T. / I.O.O.F. Elongated 1905 Barber Dime.
Dow ORE-LCCE-2. Rarity-5. Very Fine, holed at top and
bottom, copper pin and stud base on reverse.
3139 1905 Portland, Oregon Lewis and Clark Centennial F.L.T.
/ I.O.O.F Elongated Japanese Silver 10 Sen Coin. DowORE-LCCE-2. Rarity-5. Extremely Fine.
3140 Lot of (4) Scarce Circa 1907 Coney Island, New York
Elongated Cents. Extremely Fine. Included are: 1911
Electric Tower, Dow NY-CI-3, Rarity-6; Coney Island Fire,
Dow NY-CI-6, Rarity-5; 1907 Dreamland Tower, DowCI-7, Rarity-6; 1911 Dreamland Destroyed, Dow-Unlisted,
Fairbanks NY-CI-8b, Rarity-5. This is a must see, sold as is,
no returns lot.
3141 1907 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Elk’s Convention. Dow
PEN-PHI-1. Rarity-5. Extremely Fine.
3142 1908 Allentowqn, Pennsylvania Lucky Cent Elongated
1907 Indian Cent. Dow PEN-ALL-1. Rarity-5. Very Fine.
3143 1908 New York Syracuse State Fair Lucky Cent Elongated
1908 Indian Cent. Dow NY-SYR-1. Rarity-7. About
Uncirculated.
3144 1908 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania William Penn
Anniversary Lucky Cent Elongated 1908 Indian Cent.
Dow PEN-PHI-2. Rarity-5. About Uncirculated.
3145 1910 Aero Club of Pennsylvania Elongated Lincoln Cent.
Dow PEN-XXX-2. Rarity-6. About Uncirculated.
3146 1910 Gettysburg, Pennsylvania Dedication State
Monument Elongated 1910 Lincoln Cent. Dow PENGET-2. Rarity-6. Extremely Fine.
3147 1910 New York City Madison Square Garden Elongated
1909 Lincoln Cent. Dow NY-NY-9. Rarity-7. Extremely
Fine.
3148 1910 New York Pine Plains Lucky Cent Elongated 1884
Indian Cent. Dow NY-PPL-1. Rarity-7. Extremely Fine.
3149 1911 Coney Island, New York Luna Park 1911 Season
Elongated 1910 Lincoln Cent. Dow NY-CI-5. Rarity-7.
Extremely Fine.
3150 Lot of (3) 1911 and 1913 Rochester, New York Elongated
Coins. Extremely Fine. Included are: (2) Dow NY-ROC-1,
Rarity-5, one holed at top; Dow NY-ROC-2, Rarity-6. This
is a must see, sold as is, no returns lot.
3151 1911 Cincinnati, Ohio N.A.S.E. Convention Lucky Cent.
Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks R-7. Rolled on a Lincoln Cent.
About Uncirculated.
Page 243
3152 Lot of (3) Cincinnati, Ohio Elongated Cents. Included
are: 1911 Opening of the New Dam, Dow O-Cin-1,
Rarity-5, About Uncirculated; Undated Zoological Gardens,
Dow O-CIN-4, Rarity-5, About Uncirculated; 1901 Peebles’
Opening/Armour and Company, Dow O-CIN-5, Rarity-5,
Extremely Fine.
3153 1911 (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania) East Liberty
Exposition Lucky Cent Elongated 1897 Indian Cent.
Dow PEN-PIT-4. Rarity-7. Extremely Fine, minor dark
spotting.
3166 1912 Uniontown, Pennsylvania Old Home Week
Elongated 1903 Indian Cent. Dow PEN-UNI-1. Rarity-5.
About Uncirculated.
3167 1912 Dallas, Texas State Fair Lucky Cent Elongated 1912
Liberty Nickel. Dow TEX-DAL-1. Rarity-6. Extremely
Fine.
3168 1912 Dallas, Texas State Fair Lucky Cent Elongated
Lincoln Cent. Dow TEX-DAL-1. Rarity-6. About
Uncirculated.
3154 1911 Reading, Pennsylvania Industrial Exposition
Elongated Lincoln Cent. Dow PEN-REA-1 Rarity-5.
Extremely Fine.
3169 1912 Houston, Texas No-Tsu-Oh Lucky Cent Elongated
1910 Liberty Nickel. Dow TEX-HOU-1. Extremely Fine,
holed at top.
3155 1911 Coraopolis Bridge Opening Elongated Lincoln
Cent. Dow PEN-XXX-1. Rarity-5. About Uncirculated.
3170 1912 Wisconsin State Fair Lucky Cent Lincoln Cent.
Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks WIS-S.F.1. Rarity-7. Extremely
Fine, holed at top.
3156 1911 Pottsville County Centennial Elongated Lincoln
Cent. Dow PEN-POT-1. Rarity-5. Extremely Fine.
3157 1912 8th Annual Motor Boat Show Elongated Lincoln
Cent. Dow NY-NY-14. Rarity-7. About Uncirculated.
3158 1912 Beaumont, Texas Southeast Texas Fair Lucky Cent
Elongated Lincoln Cent. Dow-Unlisted, FairbanksUnlisted. Choice Very Fine.
3159 1912 Cleveland, Ohio Fraternal Order of Eagles National
Convention Elongated Lincoln Cent. Dow O-CLE-3.
Rarity-7. Extremely Fine, holed at top.
3160 Lot of (3) Cleveland, Ohio Elongated Cents. Included are:
(2) 1912 Fraternal Order of Eagles Lucky Cent, Rarity-5, one
on an 1837 Matron Head cent, Very Fine, and one on a 1909
Indian cent, About Uncirculated; 1939 7th World Poultry
Congress, Dow O-CLE-1, Rarity-6, About Uncirculated.
3161 1912 Columbus, Ohio Centennial Elongated 1911 Liberty
Nickel. Dow O-COL-1. Rarity-4. About Uncirculated.
3162 1912 Columbus, Ohio Centennial Elongated 4.7 gram
Nickel Planchet. A Muling of Dow O-CLE-1 and Dow
O-CLE-3. Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks-Unlisted. Rarity-4
and Rarity-6 Individually. Extremely Fine.
3163 Lot of (2) 1912 Columbus, Ohio Centennial Elongated
Cents. Dow O-COL-3. Rarity-6. Extremely Fine. Host
coins include: 1825 Matron Head cent; 190X Indian Cent.
3164 1912 Frankford, Pennsylvania Historical Celebration
Lucky Cent Elongated 1893 Indian Cent. Dow PENFRA-1. Rarity-5. About Uncirculated.
3165 1912 Norristown, Pennsylvania Centennial Lucky Cent.
Dow-PEN-nor-1. Rarity-6. Rolled on a Lincoln Cent.
Choice About Uncirculated, holed at right.
Page 244
3171 1913 New Rochelle, New York 225th Anniversary Lucky
Cent Elongated Lincoln Cent. Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks
NY-NR-1. Rarity-10. Extremely Fine.
3172 Lot of (5) 1913 New York Grand Central Station
Elongated Coins. Dow NY-NY-13. Extremely Fine. Host
coins include: Large cent; Indian cent; Barber quarter;
Liberty Seated half dollar; aluminum blank. This is a must
see, sold as is, no returns lot.
3173 Lot of (4) 1913 New York City Municipal Building
Elongated Coins. Dow-NY-NY-15. Rarity-7. Extremely
Fine. Host coins include: 1838 Matron Head cent; Indian
cent; Liberty nickel; aluminum blank. This is a must see,
sold as is, no returns lot.
3174 Lot of (5) Scarce New York City Elongated Cents.
Extremely Fine. Included are: 1913 National Print and
Pub Exposition Lucky Cent, Dow NY-NY-2, Rarity-6; 1909
Madison Square Garden Bowling Tournament Lucky cent,
Dow NY-NY-6, Rarity-6; 1912 Madison Square Garden
Trap Shooting Show, Dow NY-NY-8, Rarity-5; Empire State
Building, Dow-Unlisted; Fairbanks NY-NY-16a, rarity-5;
1901 Madison Square Garden Bicycle Race Mule, Dow NYNY-17, Rarity-5. This is a must see, sold as is, no returns lot.
3175 Lot of (4) 1913 New York City Woolworth Building
Elongated Coins. Dow NY-NY-12. Rarity-7. Extremely
Fine. Host coins include: Large cent; Indian cent; 1877-S
Liberty Seated quarter; New Orleans-Minted Barber half
dollar.
3176 1913 Utica, New York State Firemen Lucky Cent Elongated
Lincoln Cent. Dow NY-UT-1. Rarity-7. Extremely Fine,
holed at top.
3177 1913 50th Anniversary of The Battle of Chickamauga
(Tennessee) Elongated Lincoln Cent. Dow TEN-XXX-1.
Rarity-6. Extremely Fine.
3178 1913 West Virginia Golden Jubilee Elongated Lincoln
Cent. Dow EV-XXX-1. Rarity-5. Extremely Fine, holed at
top.
3180 1914 Coney Island, New York Luna Tower Elongated
1902 Indian Cent. Dow NY-CI-13. Rarity-7. Very Fine.
3191 1939-1940 Collection of (50) New York World’s Fair
Elongated Coins. Assorted Issues and Host Coins.
Featuring an assortment of issues including: NY-WF-15;
17; 17a; 17b; 18; 19; 20; 22; 30; 31. Also included are: RelTC-5; 18; and Soc-AL-1 which were rolled at the fair but
bear no notice of a place of issue on the coin. Host coin types
include: half cent; Flying Eagle cent; Indian cent (bronze
and Copper-Nickel); Seated Liberty dime; Mercury dime;
Capped Bust quarter; Liberty Seated quarter; Standing
Liberty quarter; Washington quarter; an assortment of civil
war tokens; Canadian large and small cents; and a number of
foreign silver coins. A nicely varied lot worthy of your close
inspection. This is a must see, sold as is, no returns lot.
3181 1915 San Antonio, Texas Cattlemen’s Convention
Elongated 1911 Liberty Nickel. Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks
TEX-XXX-4. Rarity-8. Extremely Fine.
3192 1939 Cleveland, Ohio Seventh World’s Poultry Congress
Elongated Cent. Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks-Unlisted.
Same Event as Dow O-CLE-1. About Uncirculated.
3182 Undated (1930s) South Dakota Mount Rushmore
Memorial Elongated 1930-D Lincoln Cent. Dow SDXXX-2. Rarity-5. About Uncirculated. Mount Rushmore
with only three portraits, Theodore Roosevelt not yet added.
3193 1940 New York World’s Fair Music Building Elongated
1925 Quarter Eagle. Dow NY-WF-23A. Rarity-4. Choice
About Uncirculated.
3179 1913 Wilson and Marshall Inauguration Elongated 1887
Indian Cent. Dow P-PC-9. Rarity-5. Rolled on top of an
off-center 1912 Cleveland, Ohio Fraternal Order of Eagles
Lucky Cent, Dow O-CLE-2, Rarity-5. Choice Very Fine.
Most likely a trial piece by the roller on an earlier rejected
rolling.
3183 1935 Cleveland, Ohio Greater Cleveland Home Show
Elongated 1910 Lincoln Cent. Dow-Unlisted, FairbanksUnlisted. About Uncirculated.
3184 1935 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Philadelphia On Parade
Elongated Cent. Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks-8. Rarity-7.
About Uncirculated.
3194 Lot of (3) Ohio Elongated Cents. Included are: 1941
Miami Valley Celebration, Dow O-DAY-1, Rarity-5, About
Uncirculated; 1913 Perry’s Victory Centennial, Dow
O-PIB-1, Rarity-5, Extremely Fine, holed at top; Undated
Miami, Ohio Sesquicentennial, Dow O-XXX-2, Rarity-6,
About Uncirculated.
3185 1935 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Philadelphia On
Parade/Lord’s Prayer Reverse Elongated Cent. Obverse
Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks-8. Rarity-7. Very Fine.
3195 1941 West Virginia University Engineer’s Show Elongated
Small
Cent.
Dow-Unlisted,
Fairbanks-Unlisted.
Extremely Fine. Outline map of West Virginia with WEST
VA. UNIVERSITY above and ENGINEER”S SHOW below.
Reverse with 1941 on crosshatch background.
3186 1936 (Texas) San Jacinto Monument Elongated 1931
Lincoln Cent. Dow TEX-XXX-2. Rarity-5. Extremely
Fine.
3196 1941 Milwaukee, Wisconsin American Legion National
Convention Elongated 1918 Lincoln Cent. Dow WISMIL-4. Rarity-6. About Uncirculated.
3187 1936 Texas Centennial Exposition Ford Building
Elongated 1928-D Lincoln Cent. Dow-Unlisted,
Fairbanks TEX-TCE-12. Rarity-10. Extremely Fine.
3197 1946 Milwaukee, Wisconsin Centurama Elongated
Small Cent. Dow WIS-MIL-3. Rarity-5. Choice About
Uncirculated.
3188 1936 Texas Centennial, Alamo Elongated Lincoln Cent.
Dow TEX-TCE-7. Rarity-7. Extremely Fine.
3198 Undated Coney Island, New York Dreamland Tower
Elongated 1906 Indian Cent. Dow NY-CI-10. Rarity-7.
Very Fine.
3189 1938 West Virginia University Engineer’s Show Elongated
Small Cent. Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks WV-XXX-2.
3190 1939 New York World’s Fair Y.M.C.A. Building
Elongated 1902 Liberty Quarter Eagle. Dow NY-WF-26.
Rarity-4. Choice About Uncirculated. The frontal view
of the building is rolled slightly off-center to the right, with
Liberty’s image on the reverse remaining especially clear
and bold.
3199 Undated Coney Island, New York Feltmans’ Deutscher
Garden Elongated 1911 Lincoln Cent. Dow-Unlisted;
Fairbanks NY-CI-15. Rarity-10. Very Fine.
3200 Undated Cleveland, Ohio Euclid Beach Elongated
Lincoln Cent. Dow O-CLE-4. Rarity-7. Extremely Fine.
3201 Undated South Carolina Palmetto State/Armour’s
Fertilizer Elongated Indian Cent. Dow SC-XXX-1.
From the Raymond W. Dillard Collection. The Dow plate coin.
Page 245
3202 Undated Centralia, Washington Pioneer Days Elongated
1920-S Lincoln Cent. Dow-Unlisted, Fairbanks-Unlisted.
Extremely Fine.
3203 Undated Washington, Grand Coulee Dam Elongated
Small Cent. Dow WAS-XXX-2. Rarity-7. Very Fine, holed
at top.
3204 Lot of (5) New York Elongated Coins. Extremely Fine.
Included are: Hudson-Fulton Celebration, Dow NY-HFC-3,
Rarity-6; 1905 Buffalo, NY Benevolent and Protective Order
of Elks Reunion, Rarity-5; 1909 Lake Champlain Lucky
Cent, Dow NY-LC-1, Rarity-5; 1909 Poughkeepsie Fireman
Lucky Cent, Dow NY-POU-1, rarity-6; an Unlisted muling
of Buffalo FLT North Buffalo Lodge, Dow NY-BUF-7 and
Dow NY-XXX-12. This is a must see, sold as is, no returns
lot.
3205 Lot of (71) Assorted New York Elongated Coins Mostly
Rarity-1 to Rarity-4 examples with some higher Rarity and
even Unlisted pieces included, with a wide variety of host
coin types present. This is a must see, sold as is, no returns
lot.
3206 Lot of (54) Elongated Coins From Various Southern and
Western States. Included are issues from: South Carolina;
South Dakota; Tennessee; Texas; Virginia; Washington; West
Virginia; Wisconsin and Wyoming. Most issues Rarity-4 and
under, with some unlisted varieties also present. Noteworthy
highlights include: SD-XXX-1; TEN-MEM-1; TEX-BEU-1;
TEX-TCE-1; 2; 3; 4; 5; 6; 8; VIR-WIN-1; WAS-XXX-6; WVELK-1; WIS-MIE-1; WIS-MIL-2. Many of these pieces are
quite elusive and might take even an ambitious collector
years to track down! This is a must see, sold as is, no returns
lot.
End of The Raymond W. Dillard Collection
Additional Elongated
Coins
3207 Undated (Circa 1905) For President Theodore Roosevelt
Rolled on a 1904 Indian Cent. Dow-12a. Rarity-3. About
Uncirculated.
3208 1933 Chicago, Illinois. Century of Progress Exposition
Elongated 1914-D Lincoln Cent. Belgian Village. Dow17. Rarity-2. Extremely Fine. Both the date and mintmark
of this key date Lincoln cent are clear.
3209 1893 Chicago, Illinois. World’s Columbian Exposition
Elongated 1886 Liberty Nickel. Dow-3. Rarity-3. Three
Stars, Level S Variety. Extremely Fine, Holed at Right. The
1886 is a key date issue in the Liberty nickel series.
Engraved Coins, Love Tokens, and Coin Jewelry
3210 W C F engraved on an 1829 Capped Bust dime. Host coin
EF.
Miscellaneous Tokens
3211 Lot of (4) 19th Century Tokens. Included are: Patriotic
Civil War Tokens: (2) 1864 Our Army, Fuld-47/332 a,
Rarity-1, copper, 18.5 mm; Civil War Store Card: New
York—New York, 1863 Broas Pie Baker, Fuld-630M-6ao,
Rarity-3, copper, 20 mm; and Trade Token: New York—
New York, 1866 Metropolitan Insurance Company, Rulau
NY-NY 210, copper, 31 mm. Grades are Extremely Fine to
About Uncirculated.
3212 1913 New York City Subway System Inauguration Medal.
Bronze. 50.6 mm. By Whitehead-Hoag. Extremely Fine.
Obv: Mercury and Commerce viewing a train entering
a subway line. Rev: New York City shield above plaque
inscribed COMMEMORATING / THE SIGNING OF THE
/ CONTRACTS FOR THE / DUAL SUBWAY SYSTEM OF
/ GREATER NEW YORK / APRIL 2, 1913.
Page 246
3213 Lot of (10) Predominantly 19th Century Medallions.
Includes Sage and Robinson pieces, a California $20 flag
counter, an 1876 Battle of Bennington piece issued by
the Vermont Numismatic Society, a Theodore Roosevelt
Memorial Association Founders Medal by Fraser, and other
diverse pieces. Grades range from Very Fine to Mint State,
with a few examples holed or pierced. This is a must see,
3214 Mixed Exonumia Lot. Including counterstamps, tokens,
antique scale weights, and service checks. Many are very
esoteric, but some might be identifiable by specialty
collectors. Highlights include: 1920s-1930s St. Christopher
medal in sterling silver; 1904 Barber quarter counterstamped
with Florida State Seal button die; brass harness racing token
(Saratoga Springs?); OLEARYS / 52 counterstamp, possibly
a service check used at restaurant; scale weight made by JAC
in brass; and MD and crown scale weight in tin. Grades
range from VG to EF; host coins of counterstamps range
from Poor to VF. (Total: 24 items) This is a must see, sold as
is, no return lot.
3215 Mixed Exonumia Lot. Items in this lot range in date from
1832 to 1940, and in size from 14 to 51 mm. One piece is
silver, while the balance are in minor metals. Highlights
include: 1833 silver U.S. Mint Andrew Jackson second
inaugural medallet, holed; 1849 California counter; and
1858 California fractional quarter-sized charm. Grades
range from Good to Mint State. (Total: 16 pieces) This is a
must see, sold as is, no return lot.
Rosa Americana Coinage
3216 1723 Rosa Americana Penny. Martin 2.41-Eb.15. Rarity-4.
EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 125.
Wood’s Hibernia Coinage
3217 1723 Wood’s Hibernia Halfpenny. Martin 4.57-Fa.2.
Rarity-3. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 180.
Machin’s Mills Halfpennies
3231 1786 New Jersey Copper. Maris 18-M. Rarity-3. Bridle.
VF-20. 146.8 grains.
GEORGIVS III. Fine-12. 121.3 grains.
3232 1786 New Jersey Copper. Maris 18-M. Rarity-3. Bridle.
VF-20 Environmental Damage, Cleaned. 139.7 grains.
PCGS# 448.
From the Eighth Annual C-4 Convention Sale, November 2002, lot 475.
Lot tag and paper envelope with attribution notation included.
GEORGIVS III. Fine-12, Obverse Damage. 115.8 grains.
PCGS# 451.
GEORGIVS III. Fine-15 (PCGS).
PCGS# 932.
GEORGIVS III. Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# 457.
GEORGIVS III. EF-40 Bent, Straightened. 87.4 grains.
PCGS# 466.
From the Ninth Annual C-4 Convention Sale, November 2003, lot 482.
Lot tag and paper envelope with attribution notation included.
3223 1787 Machin’s Mills Halfpenny. Vlack 17-87B. Rarity-2.
GEORGIVS III. VF-25 (PCGS).
PCGS# 469.
3224 1787 Machin’s Mills Halfpenny. Vlack 21-87D. Rarity-4.
GEORGIVS III, Group III. EF-40 Scratches, Porous. 111.2
grains.
PCGS# 469.
New Jersey Copper
3225 Lot of (4) New Jersey Coppers. Included are: 1787 Maris 6-D,
Rarity-2, Double Coulter, VG-10, cleaned; 1786 Maris 17-b,
Rarity-3, PLUKIBUS, VG-8 environmental damage, scratches;
1786 Maris 18-M, Rarity-3, Bridle, VG-8 environmental
damage, cleaned; and 1786 Maris 23-P, Rarity-4, Blundered
Six, VG-8 environmental damage, cleaned.
Paper envelopes with attribution notation included.
Head. Fine-12 Environmental Damage. 138.1 grains.
PCGS# 45423.
Paper card with attribution notation included.
Head. Fine-12 Environmental Damage, Planchet Flaw.
122.2 grains.
PCGS# 45423.
3228 1786 New Jersey Copper. Maris 15-J. Rarity-4. Leaning
Head. VG-8. 145.6 grains.
PCGS# 496.
3229 1786 New Jersey Copper. Maris 16-L. Rarity-2. Protruding
Tongue. VF-30 Corroded. 153.7 grains.
PCGS# 496.
3230 Lot of (3) New Jersey Coppers. Included are: 1786 Maris
17-K, Rarity-3, Fine-12 environmental damage, planchet
crack, scratches; 1786 Maris 17-b, Rarity-3, PLUKIBUS,
VG-8 environmental damage, cleaned; and 1787 Maris 64t, Rarity-1, Trident Shield, Fine-12 environmental damage,
planchet flaw.
PCGS# 501.
PCGS# 501.
3233 1786 New Jersey Copper. Maris 24-P. Rarity-2. EF
Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 45424.
3234 1786 New Jersey Copper. Maris 24-P. Rarity-2. VF-20
Environmental Damage. 153.2 grains.
PCGS# 496.
3235 1786 New Jersey Copper. Maris 24-P. Rarity-2. Fine-12
Planchet Flaw, Environmental Damage. 141.3 grains.
PCGS# 496.
3236 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 32-T. Rarity-3. VF-25
(PCGS).
PCGS# 503.
Environmental Damage, Planchet Flaw. 146.5 grains.
PCGS# 503.
Porous, Cleaned, Planchet Flaws. 141.6 grains.
PCGS# 503.
3239 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 38-Y. Rarity-3—Clipped
Planchet—VF-20 Porous. 138.3 grains.
PCGS# 506.
Cardboard flip with attribution notation included.
3240 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 38-Y. Rarity-3. Fine-12
Cleaned, Porous. 140.6 grains.
PCGS# 506.
3241 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 38-a. Rarity-5. VG-8
Environmental Damage, Tooled. 140.8 grains.
PCGS# 506.
3242 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 38-c. Rarity-3—Clipped
Planchet—Fine-12 Cleaned. 147.0 grains.
PCGS# 506.
3243 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 39-a. Rarity-2. VF-30.
152.7 grains.
PCGS# 503.
3244 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 39-a. Rarity-2. VF-20
Corroded. 147.0 grains.
PCGS# 503.
3245 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 39-a. Rarity-2. Fine-12
Environmental Damage, Planchet Crack. 134.0 grains.
PCGS# 503.
3246 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 39-a. Rarity-2. Fine-12
Environmental Damage, Cleaned. 145.0 grains.
PCGS# 503.
3247 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 43-d. Rarity-1. VF
PCGS# 506.
Paper envelopes with attribution notation included.
Page 247
3248 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 43-d. Rarity-1. Fine-12
Planchet Flaw. 139.8 grains.
PCGS# 503.
3265 1788 New Jersey Copper. Maris 67-v. Rarity-1. Head
Right. Brushed Mane. VF-20 Cleaned, Rim Nicks. 139.2
grains.
PCGS# 521.
3249 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 43-d. Rarity-1. Fine-12
Porous. 154.0 grains.
PCGS# 503.
3266 1788 New Jersey Copper. Maris 67-v. Rarity-1. Head
Right. Brushed Mane. VF-20 Light Porosity. 141.2 grains.
PCGS# 521.
3250 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 43-d. Rarity-1—Obverse
Planchet Flaw—VG-8 (PCGS).
PCGS# 506.
3251 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 48-g. Rarity-1. VF-20
Environmental Damage, Cleaned. 139.3 grains.
PCGS# 503.
3252 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 48-g. Rarity-1. Fine-12
Porous, Corroded. 154.3 grains.
PCGS# 503.
3267 1788 New Jersey Copper. Maris 67-v. Rarity-1. Head Right.
Brushed Mane. VF-20 Planchet Flaw, Environmental
Damage. 149.1 grains.
PCGS# 521.
3268 Lot of (3) Early American Coppers. Included are: 1788
New Jersey copper, Horse’s Head Right, AG-3 old cleaning,
minor roughness; 1788 Vermont copper, Bust Right, Fair-2
damaged, bent, corroded; and 1787 Fugio copper, Pointed
Rays, STATES UNITED, 4 Cinquefoils, Good-4 porous.
3253 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 48-g. Rarity-1. VG-8
Vermont Copper
PCGS# 503.
3254 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 53-j. Rarity-4. Fine-12
PCGS# 503.
3255 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 56-n. Rarity-1. Camel
Head. VF-20 Environmental Damage, Surface Damage.
85.3 grains.
PCGS# 515.
3256 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 56-n. Rarity-1. Camel
Head—Overstruck on a Connecticut Copper—Fine-12
Damaged. 114.8 grains.
PCGS# 515.
3257 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 60-p. Rarity-4. PLURIBS.
Fine Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 512.
Initials. VF Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 509.
Initials. Fine-12 Environmental Damage. 137.1 grains.
PCGS# 509.
3260 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 63-q. Rarity-3. Broken
Shield. VF-20 Scratched. 143.1 grains.
PCGS# 509.
3261 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 63-q. Rarity-3. Broken
Shield. Fine-12. 147.0 grains.
PCGS# 509.
3262 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 63-s. Rarity-2. VF
Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 509.
3263 1787 New Jersey Copper. Maris 64-t. Rarity-1. Trident
Shield. VF-20 Altered Surfaces. 147.7 grains.
PCGS# 506.
Page 248
North American Token
3270 “1781” (Circa 1820) North American Token. W-13980.
VF-25 BN (NGC).
Kentucky Tokens
3271 Undated (Circa 1793-1795) Kentucky Token. W-8800.
Copper. Plain Edge. AU Details—Tooled (PCGS).
PCGS# 614.
3272 Undated (Circa 1793-1795) Kentucky Token. W-8810.
Copper. LANCASTER Edge. EF-40 BN (NGC).
PCGS# 623.
Talbot, Allum & Lee Cent
3273 1794 Talbot, Allum & Lee Cent. With NEW YORK.
W-8570. Large & on Reverse, Lettered Edge. EF Details—
Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 634.
Scott Stamp & Coin Co. paper envelope with attribution notation included.
Castorland Medals,
or Jetons
3274 “1796” Castorland Medal, or Jeton. Paris Mint Restrike.
W-9155. Copper. Reeded Edge. MS-64 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 518540.
W-9165. Silver. Plain Edge. Unc Details—Cleaning
(PCGS).
PCGS# 518539.
3264 1788 New Jersey Copper. Maris 65-u. Rarity-4. Head
Right. VF-20 Rim Damage, Planchet Flaws. 91.6 grains.
PCGS# 563.
PCGS# 589.
PCGS# 521.
3269 1788 Vermont Copper. RR-25, Bressett 16-U. Rarity-2.
Bust Right. Good Details—Damage (PCGS).
W-9170. Copper. Plain Edge. Matte Finish. MS-65 BN
(PCGS).
PCGS# 523563.
Washington Pieces
3290 1804 C-8. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 3.0. Spiked Chin—
Double Struck—VF-20 BN (NGC).
3277 “1783” (Circa 1820) Unity States Cent. Baker-1. Rarity-1.
AU Details—Planchet Flaw (PCGS).
3291 1804 C-9. Rarity-2. Manley Die State 5.0. Crosslet 4,
Stems. VG-8 (PCGS).
PCGS# 689.
3278 “1783” (Circa 1820) Military Bust Copper. Baker-4, Vlack
5-D. Rarity-1. Large Military Bust. EF Details—Cleaning
(PCGS).
PCGS# 667.
Wayte Raymond paper envelope with identification notation included.
3279 Undated (1815-1820) Double-Head Cent. Baker-6.
Rarity-1. Plain Edge. EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 692.
Wayte Raymond paper envelope with attribution notation included.
3280 1791 Large Eagle Cent. Baker-15. Rarity-2. Lettered Edge.
EF Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 702.
3281 1791 Large Eagle Cent. Baker-15. Rarity-2. Lettered Edge.
VF-20 Corroded. 186.1 grains.
PCGS# 702.
3282 1793/2 Ship Halfpenny. Baker-18. Rarity-3. Copper.
Lettered Edge. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 734.
3283 1795 Grate Halfpenny. Baker-29AA. Rarity-1. Large
Buttons. Copper. Reeded Edge. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 746.
PCGS# 35167.
PCGS# 1069.
Stemless Wreath. EF Details—Smoothed (PCGS).
PCGS# 1063.
Stemless Wreath. VF-30 BN (NGC).
PCGS# 35176.
3294 Lot of (7) Half Cents. Included are: Draped Bust: 1804
Crosslet 4, Stems; 1807; Classic Head: 1809/’6’, 9/Inverted 9;
1825; (2) 1835; and Braided Hair: 1855. Grades range from
Good to Extremely Fine, and a few examples — including
both Draped Bust pieces — are impaired. This is a must see,
3295 1805 C-1. Rarity-1. Medium 5, Stemless. VG-10 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1081.
AU Details—Smoothed (PCGS).
PCGS# 1090.
3297 1806 C-1. Rarity-1. Small 6, Stemless. AU Details—
PCGS# 1093.
3298 1806 C-1. Rarity-1. Small 6, Stemless. EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1093.
Fugio Copper
3.0. VF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
3284 1787 Fugio Copper. Pointed Rays. Newman 7-T. Rarity-4.
STATES UNITED, 4 Cinquefoils. EF Details—Corroded
(NCS).
3300 1808/7 C-2. Rarity-3. Manley Die State 2.0. VG-8 BN
(NGC).
PCGS# 883.
Struck Copies of Colonial
Coins and Related
PCGS# 1104.
PCGS# 35212.
3301 1809 C-6. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 2.0. AU Details—
Improperly Cleaned (NGC).
PCGS# 1123.
3302 1825 C-1. Rarity-3. Manley Die State 3.0—Rotated Dies—
EF-45 BN (NGC).
PCGS# 35246.
3285 “1789” (1860s) Large Eagle Cent. Robinson Copy.
Kenney-7, Baker-14. Copper. Plain Edge. MS-62 BN.
245.0 grains.
3303 1826 C-1. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 3.0. MS-61 BN
(NGC).
Half Cents
3304 1828 C-3. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 4.0. 13 Stars. Unc
Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
3286 Lot of (6) Half Cents. (NGC). Included are: Draped Bust:
1800 C-1, VG Details—Obverse Damage; Classic Head:
1809 C-3, VG Details—Environmental Damage; 1812 C-2,
12 Stars, Good-6 BN; Braided Hair: 1850 C-1, AU Details—
Improperly Cleaned; 1853 C-1, AU Details—Improperly
Cleaned; and 1853 C-1, VF Details—Environmental
Damage.
3287 Lot of (4) Half Cents. Included are: 1803 Draped Bust—
Clipped Planchet—VG-8 scratched; 1809 Classic Head,
Fine-12 porous; 1835 Classic Head, EF-40; and 1857 Braided
Hair, EF-40.
3288 1804 C-8. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 3.0. Spiked Chin. EF
Details—Scratch (PCGS).
PCGS# 1075.
3289 1804 C-8. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 1.0. Spiked Chin.
VF-30 (PCGS).
PCGS# 35252.
PCGS# 1147.
3305 1832 C-1. Rarity-2. AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1159.
3306 1832 C-2. Rarity-1. Manley Die State 3.0. AU-55 BN
(NGC).
PCGS# 1159.
1.0. MS-63 BN (NGC).
PCGS# 35282.
2.0. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1162.
2.0. MS-62 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 1165.
PCGS# 1075.
Page 249
2.0. MS-62 BN (NGC).
PCGS# 35285.
3327 1794 S-31. Rarity-1. Head of 1794. VG-8 Environmental
Damage.
PCGS# 901374.
3.0. VF-30 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 1165.
Collector tag with attribution notation included.
3328 1794 S-43. Rarity-2+. Noyes Die State B. Head of 1794.
VG-8 Environmental Damage.
PCGS# 901374.
(NGC).
PCGS# 35288.
(PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 1168.
3314 1849 C-1. Rarity-2. Manley Die State 2.0. Large Date. MS62 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 1218.
From our (Coin Galleries’) sale of April 2010, lot 2172. Collector tag
with attribution and pedigree notes included.
3329 1794 S-49. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State B. Head of 1794.
VG-8 Environmental Damage.
PCGS# 901374.
3330 1794 S-51. Rarity-5-. Noyes Die State B. Head of 1794.
Fine-12 Corroded.
PCGS# 901374.
2.0. MS-63 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 1227.
3331 1794 S-54. Rarity-3. Head of 1794. VG-8 Porous, Cleaned.
PCGS# 901374.
2.0. MS-62 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 1227.
1.0. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 1227.
1.0. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 35327.
2.0. EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1227.
1.0. Unc Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
PCGS# 1230.
2.0. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1230.
3322 1857 C-1, the only known dies. Rarity-2. MS-62 BN
(NGC).
PCGS# 35339.
3323 1857 C-1, the only known dies. Rarity-2. Unc Details—
Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 1239.
3332 1794 S-56. Rarity-3. Head of 1794. VG-8 Environmental
Damage.
PCGS# 901374.
3333 1794 S-60. Rarity-3. Head of 1794. Good Details—
Planchet Flaw (PCGS).
PCGS# 901374.
Fine-12 Corroded.
PCGS# 901374.
Fine-12 Environmental Damage.
PCGS# 1365.
3336 1795 S-74. Rarity-4. Lettered Edge. Fine-12 Corrosion,
Rim Dents, Verdigris.
PCGS# 1377.
Collector tag with attribution notes included.
3337 1795 S-74. Rarity-4. Lettered Edge. VG Details—Rim
Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 35714.
Large Cents
3338 1795 S-76B. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A. Plain Edge. VF
Details—Graffiti (PCGS).
3324 1793 Wreath Reverse. S-10. Rarity-4. Vine and Bars Edge.
AG Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 1347.
J.R. “Bob” Grellman tag with attribution notation included.
3325 1794 S-Unattributable. Head of 1793. Poor/Fair Details—
Damage (PCGS). The obverse die is that of S-18b and
S-19b, but since the reverse of this piece is worn smooth we
cannot determine which of the attribution is correct for this
coin.
PCGS# 1362.
J.R. “Bob” Grellman tag with attribution notes included.
PCGS# 1380.
3339 1795 S-76b. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A. Plain Edge. Fine12 Dark, Granular.
PCGS# 1380.
3340 1795 S-76B. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A. Plain Edge. VG
Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 1380.
3341 1795 S-76B. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A. Plain Edge. VG
Details—Edge Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 1380.
Fine-12 Environmental Damage.
PCGS# 901374.
3342 1795 S-78. Rarity-1. Plain Edge. VG Details—
PCGS# 1380.
3343 1795 S-78. Rarity-1. Plain Edge. Good-4 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1380.
Page 250
3344 1796 Liberty Cap. S-83. Rarity-4. Good-4 (PCGS).
PCGS# 35756.
3345 1796 Liberty Cap. S-91. Rarity-3. Good-4 Porous,
Cleaned.
PCGS# 1392.
3346 Lot of (4) 1796 Draped Bust Cents. Included are: 1796 S-97,
reverse of 1795, Good-6 porous; 1796 S-103, LIHERTY,
AG-3; 1796 S-110, reverse of 1794, AG-3 cleaned and 1796
S-115, reverse of 1797, Fine-12 pitted, recolored.
Collector tags with attribution notes included.
3347 Lot of (5) Draped Bust Large Cents. Included are: 1796
LIHERTY Error, Fair-2 cleaned; 1798 Style I Hair, Poor-1
minor roughness; 1801 VG-10; 1806 VG-8; and 1807/6
Large Date, Pointed 1, Good-6.
3348 Lot of (4) 1797 Draped Bust Cents. Included are: S-120a,
VG-8 environmental damage, scratches; S-128, VG-8
porous, scratches; S-131, Good-4 granular, cleaned and
S-136 VG-8 porous.
Lot tags and collector tags with attribution notes included.
3349 1797 S-120b. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State B. Reverse of 1795,
Gripped Edge. VG-8 Scratches, Corrosion, Verdigris.
PCGS# 1416.
3350 1797 S-136. Rarity-3-. Noyes Die State B. Reverse of 1797,
With Stems. Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1422.
3351 1797 S-136. Rarity-3-. Noyes Die State B. Reverse of 1797,
With Stems. Good Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 1422.
3352 1797 S-137. Rarity-2. Reverse of 1797, With Stems. Good
Details—Environmental Damage (NGC).
PCGS# 1422.
3353 1798 S-145. Rarity-3. Style I Hair. VG Details—
PCGS# 1431.
3354 1798/7 S-151. Rarity-3+. Good-6 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1440.
3355 Lot of (4) 1798 Draped Bust Cents. Included are: 1798/7
S-152, AG-3; 1798 S-155, style I hair, Good-4; 1798 S-161,
style I hair, Good-6 and 1798 S-172, style II hair, VG-8
porous, verdigris.
3356 1798 S-160. Rarity-3+. Style I Hair. VF Details—
PCGS# 1431.
3357 Lot of (4) Draped Bust Cents. Included are: 1798 S-166,
style II hair, Fine-12 corrosion, cleaning; 1802 S-233, Fine12 damaged, porous, cleaned; 1803 S-258, small date, large
fraction, Good-6 scratches and 1803 S-259, small date, large
fraction, VG-8 bent.
3361 1798 S-184. Rarity-2-. Style II Hair. VF Details—Altered
Surfaces (PCGS).
PCGS# 1434.
3362 1798 S-187. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A. Style II Hair.
Good-4 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1434.
3363 1799/8
S-188.
Rarity-4.
Poor/Fair
Details—
PCGS# 36131.
3364 Lot of (3) 1800 Draped Bust Cents. Included are: 1800/1798
S-191, Style I Hair, Fine-12 porous, scratches, environmental
damage; 1800 S-192, 80/79, Style II Hair, Good-4 porous,
cleaned; and 1800/79 S-196, Style II Hair, Good-4 cleaned.
3365 1800 S-196. Rarity-1. 80/79, Style II Hair. VG-8 BN
(NGC).
PCGS# 36167.
3366 Lot of (3) 1800 Draped Bust Cents. Included are: 1800
S-196, 80/79, Style II Hair, Good-4 scratches; 1800 S-199,
VF-20 scratches, porous, recolored; and 1800 S-211, Fine-12
pitted, corrosion, verdigris.
3367 1800 S-211. Rarity-3-. VG Details—Environmental
Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 1449.
S-215, VG-8 porous; 1801 S-219, 3 errors, AG-3 rim
bumps; 1801 S-220, fraction 1/000, Good-6 corrosion,
environmental damage and 1801 S-224 Good-4 porous,
cleaned.
3369 1801 S-221. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A. 1/100 Over
1/000. Fine Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 1458.
3370 1801 S-222. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B. VF Details—
PCGS# 1458.
3371 Lot of (6) Draped Bust Cents. Included are: 1802 S-227;
1802 S-228; 1802 S-241; 1803 S-243; 1803 S-249 and 1803
S-255. Grades Range from About Good to Very Good with
many pieces displaying surface problems.
3372 1802 S-231. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A. Stemless Wreath.
EF Details—Bent (PCGS).
PCGS# 1476.
3373 1802 S-236. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A. VG-8 (PCGS).
OH.
PCGS# 36317.
3358 1798 S-173. Rarity-3-. Style II Hair. EF Details—
Corrosion (NGC).
PCGS# 1428.
3359 1798 S-174. Rarity-2-. Style II Hair. EF Details—
Smoothed (PCGS).
PCGS# 1434.
3360 Lot of (4) Draped Bust Cents. Included are: 1798 S-176,
style 2 hair, Fine-12 porous, cleaned; 1801 S-216, Good6 verdigris, scratches; 1805 S-267, AG-3 and 1806 S-270,
Good-4.
From the McCoy-Baden Collection. Earlier Ex: Col. Steven Ellsworth,
November 30, 2012; Shawn A. Yancey. Yancey company tag with attribution and pedigree notes included.
3374 1802 S-238. Rarity-4. Noyes Die State B. VF Details—
PCGS# 1470.
Page 251
3375 Lot of (3) Draped Bust Cents. (PCGS). Included are:
1802 VG Details—Smoothed; 1802 Fraction 1/000, Good
Details—Smoothed, the Fraction 1/000 Guide Book variety
is not denoted on the PCGS insert; and 1803 Small Date,
Large Fraction, Good Details—Cleaning.
3376 1803 S-246. Rarity-3. Noyes Die State C. Small Date, Small
Fraction. EF Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 1482.
3377 Lot of (5) Draped Bust Cents. Included are: 1803 S-248
VG-8 environmental damage, scratches; 1803 S-253 VG-8
scratches; 1803 S-255, Fine-12 porous, verdigris; 1803 S-260,
Good-4 porous, scratches and 1803 S-262, VG-8 scratches.
All but the 1803 S-260 are from the 2004 EAC Convention sale, lots
227, 231, 237 and 265. Lot tags and collector tags with attribution notes
included.
3378 1803 S-251. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State B. Small Date,
Small Fraction. Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1482.
3379 1803 S-254. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A. Small Date,
Small Fraction. VG-8 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1482.
3389 Lot of (3) Classic Head Cents. (PCGS). Included are:
1808 Fine Details—Environmental Damage; 1810 VG
Details—Environmental Damage; and 1811 Good Details—
Environmental Damage.
State B. VG-10 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1546.
3391 1810 S-281. Rarity-1. VF Details—Obverse Scratched
(NGC).
PCGS# 1549.
3392 Lot of (2) Classic Head Cents. Included are: 1810 S-285,
Good-4 corrosion and 1814 S-295, plain 4, Good-4.
3393 Lot of (9) Classic and Matron Head Cents. Included are:
Classic: 1810/09 VG-8; Matron Head: 1816 Good-6; 1817
13 Stars, Fine-15; 1817 13 Stars, VG-8; 1817 15 Stars, VG-8
old cleaning; 1818 Fine-12 cleaned, porous; 1818 VG-8
reverse scratched; 1819 Large Date, Fine-12 tooled; and
1819 Small Date, VG-8 minor roughness.
3394 1811 S-287. Rarity-2. VG-8 (PCGS). CAC.
3380 1803 S-260. Rarity-1. Small Date, Large Fraction. Fine
PCGS# 1485.
3381 1803 S-261. Rarity-2+. Noyes Die State B. Small Date,
Large Fraction. EF Details—Environmental Damage
(PCGS).
PCGS# 1485.
3382 1803 S-265. Rarity-4. Noyes Die State C. Large Date,
Large Fraction. Genuine—Altered Surfaces (PCGS). VF
Details.
PCGS# 1501.
From our (Bowers and Merena’s) Robert W. Schwan Collection sale,
October 2000, lot 152. Lot tag and paper envelopes with attribution and
census notes included.
State B. Poor-1 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1504.
3384 Lot of (3) Draped Bust Cents. (PCGS). Included are: 1805
VF Details—Environmental Damage; 1806 VG Details—
Cleaning; and 1807 Large Fraction, Good Details—Damage.
PCGS# 1555.
3395 1812 S-289. Rarity-1. Large Date. VF Details—Damage
(PCGS).
PCGS# 1564.
3396 Lot of (6) Large Cents. Included are: Classic Head: 1812
S-289; Matron Head: 1816 N-7; 1817 N-11; 1819 N-5; 1827
N-2; and 1827 N-3. Grades range from Very Good to Very
Fine with many pieces displaying surface problems.
3397 1812 S-290. Rarity-1. Small Date. Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1561.
3398 1812 S-291. Rarity-2+. Small Date. AU Details—
PCGS# 1561.
3399 Lot of (5) Classic Head Cents. (PCGS). Included are: (2)
1812 Large Date, VG Details—Environmental Damage; 1813
Fine Details—Cleaning; 1813 VG Details—Environmental
Damage; and 1814 Crosslet 4, VG Details—Cleaning..
S-271, AG-3 scratches; 1807 S-271, comet variety, Good4, scratches, recolored; 1807/6 S-273 pointed 1, Good-4
recolored and 1807 S-275, large fraction, Good-4 porous.
3400 1813 S-293. Rarity-2. Fine-15 (PCGS). CAC.
3386 1807/6 S-273. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B. Large Date,
Pointed 1. EF Details—Environmental Details (PCGS).
3402 1814 S-295. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B. Plain 4. VG-10
(PCGS).
PCGS# 1528.
PCGS# 1570.
PCGS# 1576.
3387 Lot of (8) Classic Head Cents. Included are: 1808 S-277;
1809 S-280; 1810/09 S-281; 1810 S-282; 1811/10 S-286;
1811 S-287; 1812 S-288 and 1813 S-293. Grades range from
Good to Very Good with many pieces displaying surface
problems.
3388 1808 S-278. Rarity-3. VF Details—Scratch (PCGS).
PCGS# 1543.
PCGS# 1570.
3401 1813 S-293. Rarity-2. VG-8 (PCGS).
3403 1814 S-295. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B. Plain 4. Good-4
(PCGS).
PCGS# 1576.
3404 Lot of (9) Matron Head Cents. Included are: 1816 N-2;
1817 N-10; 1817 N-16; 1817 N-12; 1817 N-15; 1818 N-6;
1819/8 N-1; 1819 N-2; and 1819 N-6. Grades range from
Very Good to Extremely Fine with many pieces displaying
surface problems.
The 1817 N-12 is from the 2002 EAC Convention sale, lot 689. Lot tag
and collector tags with attribution notes included.
Page 252
3405 1816 N-5. Rarity-3. Noyes Die State B/B. AU-50 BN
(NGC).
PCGS# 1591.
3421 1827 N-1. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A/A. AU Details—
Smoothed (PCGS).
PCGS# 1651.
3406 1816 N-8. Rarity-3. Noyes Die State C/B. VF-35 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1591.
3407 Lot of (3) Matron Head Cents. (PCGS). Included are: 1817
13 Stars, Fine-12; 1820 Large Date, VF-20; and 1821 VF
Details—Environmental Damage.
3408 1818 N-10. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/B. Unc Details—
Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 1600.
3409 1819/8 N-1. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A/A. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1612.
3410 Lot of (11) Matron Head Cents. Included are: 1820/19 N-1;
1820 N-4; 1820 N-10; 1821 N-2; 1822 N-3; 1823/2 N-1; 1823
N-2; 1824/2 N-1; 1824 N-3; 1825 N-2; and 1826 N-1. Grades
range from Very Good to Fine with many pieces displaying
surface problems.
3411 Lot of (7) Matron Head Cents. Included are: 1820/19 VG8; 1820 Large Date, Fine-12 cleaned, scratched; 1821 VG-8
tooled; 1822 VF-20; 1823 Good-6 minor porosity; 1824
Good-4 tooled; and 1825 Good-4.
3412 1822 N-11. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A/A. AU-53 BN
(NGC).
PCGS# 1624.
3413 1823/2 N-1. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A/A. VG-8 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1630.
From our (Stack’s) sale of the Samuel W. Wolfson Collection, Part II,
May 1963, lot 68. Lot tag included.
3422 Lot of (9) Matron Head and Modified Matron Head
Cents. Included are: Matron Head: 1831 Large Letters,
Fine-12 porous, cleaned; 1831 Small Letters, VG-8; 1832
Large Letters, VF-30; 1833 Fine-12 cleaned, rough; 1834
Large 8, Small Stars, Medium Letters, VF-30 cleaned, tooled;
1835 Small 8 and Stars, VF-30 obverse scratches; Modified
Matron Head: 1836 VF-20 cleaned; 1837 Plain Cords, Small
Letters, VF-35 cleaned; and 1838 Fine-12 tooled.
3423 Lot of (12) Large Cents. Included are: Matron Head: 1832
N-1; 1834 N-1; Modified Matron Head: (2) 1837 N-7; 1838
N-2; 1838 N-7; (2) 1838 N-12) (2) 1839 N-5; 1839 N-13; and
Braided Hair: 1855 N-8. Grades range from Fine to About
Uncirculated with many pieces displaying minor surface
problems.
3424 1832 N-2. Rarity-3. Noyes Die State C/B. Medium Letters.
PCGS# 1690.
3425 Lot of (19) Matron Head and Modified Matron Head
Cents. Included are: 1832 N-2; 1832 N-3; 1833 N-5; 1834
N-2; 1834 N-3; 1834 N-5; 1834 N-6; 1835 N-1; 1835 N-7;
1835 N-8; 1836 N-2; 1837 N-1; 1837 N-4; (3) 1837 N-10;
1838 N-6; 1838 N-8; and 1839/6 N-1. Grades range from
Very Good to Very Fine with many pieces displaying surface
problems.
3414 1824/2 N-1. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/B. VF-20 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1639.
3415 Lot of (11) Large Cents. Included are: Matron Head: 1824
N-2; 1826 N-6; 1827 N-1; 1827 N-5; 1828 N-11; 1832 N-2;
1833 N-2; Modified Matron Head: 1836 N-1; 1837 N-5;
1837 N-10 and 1838 N-6. Grades range from Good to Very
3416 Lot of (4) Matron Head Cents. (PCGS). Included are: 1824
VG-10; 1824 VG-8; 1826 Fine-12, CAC; and 1833 VG-10.
3417 Lot of (8) Matron Head Cents. Included are: 1825 Fine-12
cleaned, porous; 1826 Fine-12 cleaned, porous; 1826 VG8; 1827 Fine-12; 1828 Large Narrow Date, Fine 15 minor
roughness; 1828 Small Wide Date, VG-8 tooled; 1829 Large
Letters, Fine-12; and 1830 Large Letters, VF-20 cleaned,
verdigris.
3418 1826 N-4. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State C/C. AU-50 BN
(NGC).
PCGS# 1645.
3419 1826 N-5. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State B/A. AU Details—
Environmental Damage (PCGS)
PCGS# 1645.
3420 Lot of (9) Matron Head Cents. Included are: 1826 N-7; 1827
N-7; 1827 N-8; 1828 N-10; 1829 N-4; 1829 N-9; 1830 N-8;
1831 N-3 and 1831 N-12. Grades range from Very Good to
Very Fine with many pieces displaying surface problems.
3426 1835 N-14. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A/A. Head of 1836.
AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1714.
3427 1837 N-4. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State C/C. Plain Cord,
Medium Letters. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1735.
(NGC).
PCGS# 37195.
3429 1838 N-10. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B/F. EF-45 (PCGS).
CAC.
PCGS# 1741.
3430 Lot of (11) Modified Matron Head and Braided Hair
Cents. Included are: 1839/6 N-1; 1839 N-2; 1839 N-4; 1839
N-8; 1839 N-10; (2) 1840 N-1; 1840 N-4; 1840 N-5; 1841
N-3; and 1842 N-2. Grades range from Very Good to Fine
with many pieces displaying surface problems.
3431 1839 N-3. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/B. Head of 1838,
Beaded Cords. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 1744.
3432 1839 N-4. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B/B. Silly Head. AU
PCGS# 1748.
3433 1839 N-13. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State A/B. Booby Head.
PCGS# 1751.
The 1829 N-9 is from the 1997 EAC sale, lot 248. Lot tag and collector
tags with attribution notes included.
Page 253
3434 Lot of (20) Modified Matron Head and Braided Hair
Cents. Included are: Modified Matron Head: 1839
Silly Head, VG-8 minor roughness; 1839 Booby Head,
Fine-12 tooled; Braided Hair: 1840 Small Date, Fine-12
environmental damage; 1841 Small Date, VF-20; 1842 Large
Date, Fine-12 cleaned; 1843 Petite Head, Small Letters,
Fine-12; 1844 VF-20 cleaned; 1845 VF-20; 1846 Tall Date,
Fine-15 tooled; 1847 VF-20 cleaned; 1848 VF-20 tooled;
1849 Fine-12 tooled; 1850 Fine-15 obverse damage; 1851
VF-30; 1852 VF-20 cleaned; 1853 VF-20 cleaned, reverse
scratched; 1854 VF-20 cleaned; 1855 Upright 5s, EF-40
smoothed; 1855 Slanting 5s, Knob on Ear, EF-40 cleaned;
and 1856 Slanting 5, EF-40 cleaned.
3435 Lot of (12) Braided Hair Cents. Included are: 1840 N-1;
1840 N-6; 1842 N-4; 1845 N-5; 1847 N-7; 1847 N-38; 1849
N-7; 1849 N-19; 1849 N-27; 1850 N-1; 1850 N-21 and
1855 N-8. Grades range from Good to Extremely Fine with
several pieces displaying surface problems.
1847 N-37; 1849 N-11; 1849 N-14; 1849 N-22; 1850; 1850
N-4; 1850 N-15; 1850 N-23; 1851/81 N-3; 1852 N-4; (2)
1855 N-9; 1855 N-10; (2) 1855 N-13; 1856 N-11 and 1856
N-14. Grades range from Poor to Extremely Fine with many
pieces displaying surface problems, though most coins in
this lot grade Fine or better.
3447 1850 N-2. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A/B. MS-63 BN
(NGC).
PCGS# 405863.
3448 1850 N-3. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B/B. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1889.
3449 Lot of (11) Braided Hair Cents. Included are: 1850 N-14,
VF-20; 1851 N-26, VF-20; 1852 N-22, VF-30; 1854 N-6, VF30; 1854 N-25, VF-30; 1854 N-29, VF-30; 1855 N-2, VF-20;
1855 N-3, VF-30; 1856 N-6, VF-20; 1856 N-7, EF-40 and
1856 N-18, Fine-15.
From the 2005 EAC Convention sale, lot 512 and part of lot 493. Lot
tags and collector tags with attribution notes included.
3436 Lot of (4) Braided Hair Cents. (PCGS). Included are: 1840
Large Date, Fine-15; 1842 Small Date, Fine-15; 1843 Petite
Head, Small Letters, VF-25; and 1845 EF-45.
3450 1850 N-21. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State C/D (N-10). MS-64
BN (PCGS).
3437 1841 N-7. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State D/B. Unc Details—
Smoothed (PCGS).
EF-40; 1851 EF-40, CAC; 1852 VF-30; 1853 EF-45; 1854 EF40; and 1856 Upright 5, VF-25.
PCGS# 1832.
1842 N-5; (2) 1843 N-2; 1843 N-6; 1844/81 N-2; 1844 N-3;
1845 N-12; 1846 N-6; 1846 N-8; 1846 N-9; 1846 N-12;
1846 N-14; 1846 N-18; 1847 N-2 and 1847 N-5. Grades
range from Very Good to Extremely Fine with many pieces
displaying surface problems.
The 1846 N-12 is from the September 1991 Early Copper Auction, lot
114; 2002 EAC Convention sale, lot 754. Lot tags and collector tags with
attribution notes included.
3439 1842 N-8. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A/A. Large Date. MS63 BN (NGC).
PCGS# 1835.
3440 Lot of (22) Braided Hair Cents. Included are: (2) 1843 N-2;
1843 N-8; (2) 1843 N-10; 1844 N-3; (2) 1844 N-6; 1845 N-4;
1845 N-5; 1846 N-2; 1846 N-14; 1846 N-15; 1847 N-6; 1847
N-38; 1848 N-8; 1849 N-22; 1849 N-26; 1850 N-6; 1850
N-17 and (2) 1851 N-5. Grades range from Very Good to
3441 Lot of (6) Braided Hair Cents. Included are: 1845 N-13,
EF-40 dark, porous; 1846 N-5, EF-40; 1847 N-3, VF-30;
1851 N-20, AU-50 scratched, verdigris; 1853 N-8, EF-40;
and 1854 N-9, EF-40.
From the 2005 EAC Convention sale, part of lots 472 and 475. Lot tags
and collector tags with attribution notes included.
3442 1846 N-11. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State A/E. Medium Date.
MS-62 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 1868.
3443 1846 N-16. Rarity-4. Noyes Die State B/A. Tall Date. VF20.
PCGS# 1871.
Small Date, VF-35; 1847 EF-45; 1848 VF-30; and 1849 EF40.
3445 1847 N-1. Rarity-2. Noyes Die State B/B. Repunched
Date. MS-62 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 1889.
1851 N-8; 1851 N-25; 1851 N-37; 1852 N-3; 1852 N-14; 1852
N-17; 1853 N-1; 1853 N-10; (2) 1853 N-12; 1853 N-32; 1854
N-1; and 1854 N-20. Grades range from Fine to Extremely
1851 N-31; 1852 N-4; 1852 N-11; 1852 N-18; 1853 N-20;
1853 N-29; 1854 N-24; 1854 N-25; 1855 N-2; 1855 N-8;
1856 N-1; and 1856 N-19. Grades range from Very Good to
3454 1851 N-13. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/C. MS-63 BN
(PCGS).
PCGS# 1892.
3455 1852 N-3. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B/C. Unc Details—
Smoothed (PCGS).
PCGS# 1898.
(NGC).
PCGS# 1904.
3457 1854 N-17. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/D. MS-64 BN
(NGC).
PCGS# 1904.
3458 1855 N-10. Rarity-1. Slanting 5s. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1910.
3459 1856 Braided Hair. N-3. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State D/D.
Slanting 5. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1922.
3460 1856 Braided Hair. N-6. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B/B.
Upright 5. AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1919.
3461 1856 Braided Hair. N-14. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/B.
Slanting 5. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1922.
PCGS# 1877.
Page 254
3462 1856 Braided Hair. N-20. Rarity-3. Noyes Die State D/C.
Upright 5. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 1919.
3463 1857 Braided Hair. N-1. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/C.
Large Date. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1928.
PCGS# 2289.
3485 1867 Unc Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
PCGS# 2088.
3486 1867 AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2088.
3464 1857 Braided Hair. N-1. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State C/C.
Large Date. AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1928.
3465 Lot of (2) 1857 Braided Hair Cents. Included are: 1857
N-1, large date, VF-25 rim bumps, recolored and 1857 N-4,
small date, Fine-15 verdigris.
3466 1857 Braided Hair. N-2. Rarity-1. Noyes Die State B/B.
Small Date. AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 1931.
3487 1868 Unc Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
PCGS# 2092.
3488 1868 AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2091.
3489 1869 AU Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 2095.
3490 1869 EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2094.
3491 1870 Bold N. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2097.
Small Cents
3492 1870 FS-901. Shallow N. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2097.
3467 1857 Flying Eagle. Snow-4, FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse.
EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 37378.
3493 1871 Proof-65 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 2300.
3494 1871 FS-901. Shallow N. Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
3468 1858 Small Letters. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2100.
PCGS# 2020.
3495 1871 Bold N. Fine-12 (ANACS).
3469 1858 Small Letters. MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 2100.
PCGS# 2020.
3496 1872 Proof-63 BN (PCGS).
3470 1858 Small Letters. MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 2303.
PCGS# 2020.
3471 1858 Small Letters. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2020.
3497 1872 FS-901. Shallow N. EF-45 (PCGS).
3472 1859 AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2103.
PCGS# 2052.
3498 1872 Bold N. EF-45 BN (NGC).
3473 1861 MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2103.
PCGS# 2061.
3499 1872 Bold N. VF-20 (PCGS).
3474 1861 AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2103.
PCGS# 2061.
3475 Lot of (4) Indian Cents. (NGC). Included are: 1863 AU
Details—Improperly Cleaned; 1880 MS-62 BN; 1882 MS-62
BN; and 1909 MS-62 BN.
3476 1864 Copper-Nickel. MS-63 (PCGS).
3500 1872 Bold N. Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2103.
3501 1873 Close 3. Proof. Unc Details—Questionable Color
(PCGS).
PCGS# 2306.
PCGS# 2070.
3477 Lot of (3) Certified Indian Cent Varieties. Included
are: 1864 Bronze, L on Ribbon, Repunched Date, VG-10
(PCGS), CAC; 1875 Snow-1, FS-301, Repunched Date, EF40 (PCGS), CAC; and 1894 Doubled Date, Snow-1, FS-301,
EF-45 BN (NGC), CAC.
3478 1865 Plain 5. Proof-64 BN (PCGS).
3502 1873 Open 3. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2106.
3503 1873 Close 3. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 2109.
3504 1874 Proof-65 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 2309.
3505 1876 MS-63 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 2282.
3479 1865 Proof. Unc Details—Environmental Damage
(PCGS).
PCGS# 2282.
PCGS# 2125.
3506 1877 Fine-15 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 2127.
3507 1877 VG-8 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2127.
3480 1865 Fancy 5. MS-63 RB (NGC).
3508 1877 VG Details—Scratch (PCGS).
PCGS# 2083.
PCGS# 2127.
3481 1865 Plain 5. MS-62 BN (PCGS).
3509 1877 Good-6 (PCGS).
PCGS# 92082.
PCGS# 2127.
3482 1866 MS-63 BN (PCGS).
3510 1877 Good-6 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2085.
PCGS# 2127.
3483 1866 AU Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
PCGS# 2085.
3484 1867 Proof-65 RB (PCGS).
3511 1877 Good-4 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2127.
Page 255
3512 1877 Good-4 (PCGS).
3541 1909-S Lincoln. MS-64 RB (PCGS). OGH—First
Generation.
PCGS# 2127.
PCGS# 2433.
3513 1877 Good-4 (PCGS).
3542 1909-S Lincoln. MS-64 RB (NGC).
PCGS# 2127.
PCGS# 2433.
3514 1877 Good-4 (ANACS).
3543 1909-S Lincoln. Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 2127.
PCGS# 2432.
3515 1877 Good Details—Damage (PCGS).
3544 1909-S Lincoln. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2127.
PCGS# 2432.
3516 1877 AG-3 (PCGS).
3545 1909-S Lincoln. AU Details—Planchet Flaw (PCGS).
PCGS# 2127.
PCGS# 2434.
3517 1877 AG-3 (PCGS).
3546 1909-S/S Lincoln. FS-1502. S/Horizontal S. EF-45
(PCGS).
PCGS# 2127.
3518 1877 AG-3 (PCGS).
PCGS# 92432.
PCGS# 2127.
3547 1909-S Lincoln. VF-35 (PCGS).
3519 1877 AG Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 2432.
PCGS# 2128.
3548 1909-S/S Lincoln. FS-1502. S/Horizontal S. VF Details—
Bent (PCGS).
3520 1878 MS-64 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 2130.
PCGS# 92432.
3521 1880 Proof-65 RB (NGC).
3549 1910 Proof-63 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 2328.
PCGS# 3307.
3522 1883 Proof-65 RB (NGC).
3550 1910 Proof. Genuine—Questionable Color (PCGS).
Proof-60 Details.
PCGS# 2337.
3523 1886 Type II Obverse. MS-64 RB (NGC).
PCGS# 3308.
PCGS# 92155.
3551 1910-S MS-65 RD (PCGS).
3524 1890 Proof-64 RB (NGC).
PCGS# 2440.
PCGS# 2358.
3552 1910-S MS-64 BN (NGC). OH.
3525 1900 Proof-65 RB (NGC).
PCGS# 2438.
PCGS# 2388.
3553 1912-S MS-64 RD (PCGS).
3526 1902 MS-65 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 2458.
PCGS# 2212.
3554 1914-D VF-30 (PCGS).
3527 1904 MS-66 RD (NGC).
PCGS# 2471.
PCGS# 2219.
3555 1914-D VF-30 (PCGS).
3528 1905 MS-65 RB (NGC). OH.
PCGS# 2471.
PCGS# 2221.
3556 1914-D VF-25 (PCGS).
3529 1908-S AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 2471.
PCGS# 2232.
3530 Lot of (3) Indian and Lincoln Cents. (PCGS). Included are:
Indian: 1909 Unc Details—Questionable Color; Lincoln:
1923-S Unc Details—Questionable Color; and 1931-D AU
Details—Questionable Color.
3531 1909-S Indian. AU-50 (PCGS).
3561 1914-D Good-6 (PCGS).
3533 1909-S Indian. VF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 2471.
PCGS# 2238.
3562 1915-D MS-64 BN (PCGS).
3534 1909-S Indian. Fine-12 (ANACS).
PCGS# 2480.
PCGS# 2238.
3563 1917 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. VF-25 (PCGS).
3535 1909 Lincoln. V.D.B. MS-66 RD (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 37673.
PCGS# 2425.
3564 1919-S MS-64 RD (PCGS). CAC.
3536 1909 Lincoln. V.D.B. MS-66 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# 2521.
PCGS# 2425.
3565 1922 No D. FS-401, Die Pair II. Strong Reverse. VF-30
(ANACS). OH.
3537 1909-S Lincoln. V.D.B. VF-25 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2426.
3538 1909-S Lincoln. V.D.B. VF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
3540 1909-S Lincoln. MS-65 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 2471.
3559 1914-D Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2471.
PCGS# 2238.
PCGS# 2433.
3558 1914-D VF-20 (PCGS).
3560 1914-D Good-6 (PCGS).
3532 1909-S Indian. VF-35 (PCGS).
3539 1909-S Lincoln. MS-65 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 2471.
PCGS# 2471.
PCGS# 2238.
PCGS# 2426.
3557 1914-D VF-20 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3285.
3566 1922 No D. FS-401, Die Pair II. Strong Reverse. Fine-15
(ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 3285.
3567 1924-D Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 2554.
PCGS# 2433.
Page 256
3568 1926-S MS-63 BN (NGC).
3593 1864 Large Motto. MS-65 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 2573.
PCGS# 3577.
3569 1929-D MS-64 RB (PCGS).
3594 1864 Large Motto. MS-65 RB (NGC). CAC.
PCGS# 2598.
PCGS# 3577.
3570 1931-S MS-65 RB (PCGS).
3595 1864 Large Motto. MS-65 BN (NGC).
PCGS# 2619.
From an unnamed Paramount auction, lot 285. Lot tag included.
3571 1931-S MS-64 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# 3578.
PCGS# 2620.
3572 1931-S MS-64 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# 3577.
PCGS# 2620.
3573 1931-S Unc Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
PCGS# 2620.
PCGS# 3577.
3599 1864 Large Motto. KF-L8. Repunched Date. MS-64 RB
(PCGS).
3574 1936 Brilliant Proof-64 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 3334.
PCGS# 3577.
3575 1943-D/D FS-501. Repunched Mintmark. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2715.
PCGS# 3577.
3576 1943-D/D FS-501. Repunched Mintmark. MS-61 (PCGS).
PCGS# 2715.
3601 1865 Plain 5. MS-64 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 3583.
3577 1944-D/S FS-511. AU-55 BN (NGC).
3602 1865 Plain 5. MS-63 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 37832.
PCGS# 3582.
3578 1946-S/D FS-511. EF-45 BN (NGC).
PCGS# 37841.
3579 1953 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. Proof-65 Cameo
(ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 83368.
3580 1955-S/S/S FS-501. Repunched Mintmark. MS-66+ RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# 37933.
3581 1956-D/D FS-508. Repunched Mintmark. MS-64 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# 37939.
3582 1960 FS-103. Tripled Die Obverse. Proof-66 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# 3416.
3583 1971-S Doubled Die Obverse. Proof-65 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# 3548.
3584 1972 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. MS-65 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 2949.
3585 1972 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. MS-65 RB (ANACS).
OH.
PCGS# 2949.
PCGS# 2950.
PCGS# 2950.
3588 1972 FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. MS-64 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 2949.
3589 1983 FS-801. Doubled Die Reverse. MS-65 RD (PCGS).
OGH.
PCGS# 3056.
3590 1983 FS-801. Doubled Die Reverse. MS-64 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# 3055.
3591 1999 FS-901. Wide AM. MS-65 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# 391432.
Two-Cent Pieces
3592 1864 Large Motto. KF-L9. Repunched Date. MS-65 RB
(PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 3577.
PCGS# 3576.
3596 1864 Large Motto. MS-64 RD (PCGS). CAC.
3603 Lot of (3) Two-Cent Pieces. (PCGS). Included are: 1865
Fancy 5, AU-58; 1866 AU-53; and 1869 AU-58.
3604 1866 MS-62 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 3588.
3605 1867 MS-64 RB (NGC). CAC.
PCGS# 3592.
3606 1867 MS-63 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 3591.
3607 Lot of (5) Two-Cent Pieces. (PCGS). Included are: 1867
AU Details—Environmental Damage; 1868 VF-25; 1869
VF-35; 1869 VF-30; and 1870 VF Details—Environmental
Damage.
3608 1868 Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 3597.
3609 1869 Proof-63 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# 3639.
3610 1871 MS-65 BN (NGC). CAC.
PCGS# 3609.
3611 1871 AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3609.
Silver Three-Cent Pieces
3612 1851-O AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 3665.
3613 1859 Proof-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3708.
3614 1859 MS-61 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 3677.
3615 1861 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3679.
3616 1861 MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3679.
3617 1861 AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3679.
PCGS# 3680.
3619 1868 Unc Details—Bent (NGC).
PCGS# 3688.
Page 257
Nickel Three-Cent Pieces
3620 1865 Proof Details—Obverse Improperly Cleaned
(NGC).
PCGS# 3761.
3622 1865 AU-55 (PCGS).
3647 1888 Proof-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3731.
PCGS# 3785.
3623 1865—Broadstruck—VF-20 (NGC).
PCGS# E3731.
3624 1865—35% Detached Lamination on Reverse—Fine-12
(PCGS).
3625 1866—Uncentered Broadstrike, Cracked Planchet at 3
O’Clock—Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# E3732.
PCGS# 83764.
3628 1868 Proof-63 (PCGS). CAC.
3630 1869 MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3881.
PCGS# 3735.
3632 1874 Proof-65 Cameo (PCGS).
PCGS# 3845.
PCGS# 83770.
3658 1884 AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3845.
PCGS# 83774.
From Superior’s sale of the Dr. Charles L. Ruby, Part I, February 1974,
lot 747. Lot tag included.
PCGS# 3777.
3636 1881—Clamshell Split Planchet—VF-20 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3782.
3643 1887/6 FS-302. Proof-65 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 3784.
Page 258
PCGS# 3846.
3660 1886 VF-20 (PCGS).
3661 1886 VG-10 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3847.
3662 1890—60% Reverse Detached
Details—Damage (PCGS).
3635 1881 Proof-66 (NGC).
3642 1886 Proof-65 (NGC). CAC. OH.
3659 1885 VG-8 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3847.
PCGS# 83775.
PCGS# 3781.
PCGS# 3838.
3655 1883 Shield. MS-64 (PCGS).
3656 1883 Liberty. With CENTS. Proof-65 (NGC).
3631 1869 MS-62 (PCGS).
3641 1885 Proof-64 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 22273.
PCGS# 3813.
PCGS# 3735.
PCGS# 3780.
3652 1879 Proof-66 Cameo (NGC).
3654 1883 Shield. Proof-66 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 83765.
3640 1884 Proof-65 (ANACS). OH.
3651 Lot of (2) Nickels. (NGC). Included are: 1876 Shield, MS62; and 1964 Jefferson, Proof-67.
PCGS# 3812.
PCGS# 3780.
PCGS# 3826.
3653 1882 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3764.
3639 1884 Proof-65 (PCGS).
3649 1872 Proof-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E3799.
PCGS# 3733.
PCGS# 83779.
3648 1867 Rays. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
3650 1872—Partial Clamshell Split Planchet—VF Details—
Damage (PCGS).
3626 1867 MS-64 (PCGS).
3638 1883 Proof-65 Cameo (NGC).
Nickel Five-Cent Pieces
PCGS# 3791.
PCGS# E3731.
PCGS# 3778.
PCGS# 3755.
3646 1888 Proof-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3731.
3637 1882 Proof-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3784.
3645 1887 AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3785.
3621 1865 MS-63 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# E3749.
3644 1887/6 FS-302. Proof-64 (NGC). OH.
Lamination—Fine
PCGS# E3851.
3663 1891—Obverse Portion of Split Planchet—VG-10
(PCGS).
PCGS# E3852.
3664 1893 MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3854.
3665 1896 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3857.
3666 1899 MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3860.
3667 1900 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3861.
3668 1900—Clamshell
Split
Planchet—VG
Details—
PCGS# E3861.
3669 1901—Obverse of Split Planchet—Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# E3862.
3670 1904 Proof-65 (PCGS).
3699 1919-S Net AU-55 (ANACS). Unc Details—Cleaned. OH.
PCGS# 3902.
PCGS# 3943.
3671 1905 Proof-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3903.
PCGS# 3943.
3672 1905 AU-58 (PCGS).
3701 1920-D AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3866.
PCGS# 3945.
3673 1908 Proof-66 (PCGS).
3702 1920-S AU-53 (NGC).
PCGS# 3906.
PCGS# 3946.
3674 1908 MS-64 (PCGS).
3703 1921-S EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 3869.
PCGS# 3948.
3675 1909 Proof-64 (PCGS).
3704 1923-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3907.
PCGS# 3950.
3676 1910 MS-64+ (NGC).
3705 1923-S MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 3871.
PCGS# 3950.
3677 1912 Proof-65 Cameo (NGC). CAC.
3706 Lot of (3) Buffalo Nickels. (PCGS). Included are: 1924-D
AU Details—Cleaning; 1925-S AU Details—Cleaning; and
1927-D Unc Details—Filed Rims.
PCGS# 3910.
3678 1912-S Fine-15 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3875.
3679 Undated Liberty Nickel—Reverse of Split Planchet—
Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
PCGS# 3957.
3681 1913 Type I. MS-65 (PCGS).
3710 1926-D MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3915.
PCGS# 3958.
3682 1913-D Type I. MS-65 (PCGS). CAC.
3711 1926-S EF-40 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 3916.
PCGS# 3959.
3683 1913-D Type II. MS-64 (PCGS).
3712 1926-S EF-40 (NGC).
PCGS# 3922.
PCGS# 3959.
3684 1913-S Type II. Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 3923.
PCGS# 3923.
3715 1928-D MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 93924.
PCGS# 3964.
3687 1914-D AU Details—Machine Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 3925.
3717 1936 Satin Proof. Unc Details—Polished (PCGS).
PCGS# 3926.
PCGS# 3994.
3689 1914-S—Minor Planchet Flaw Reverse—MS-63 (PCGS).
3692 1916-S MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3933.
3693 1917-D MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 3935.
3694 1917-D AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3935.
3695 1918 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3937.
3696 1918-D AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3938.
3697 1919-D EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3942.
3698 1919-S AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3943.
3716 1928-S MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 3965.
3688 1914-S MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 3929.
3714 1927-S AU Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 3962.
3686 1914/3 FS-101. VF-35 (NGC).
3691 1915-S AU-55 (PCGS).
3713 1927 MS-65 (NGC). CAC.
PCGS# 3960.
3685 1913-S Type II. AU Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 3927.
3708 1925-D AU-53 (PCGS).
3709 1926 MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3915.
3690 1915 MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 3953.
PCGS# 3955.
3680 1913 Type I. MS-66 (NGC).
PCGS# E3926.
3718 1936-D MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3978.
3719 1936-S/S FS-501. Repunched Mintmark. MS-64 (PCGS).
CAC.
PCGS# 38474.
3720 1936-S/S FS-501. Repunched Mintmark. MS-64 (NGC).
CAC.
PCGS# 38474.
3721 1937 Proof-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3996.
3722 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. AU-53 (NGC).
PCGS# 3982.
3723 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3982.
3724 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. AU-50 (NGC).
PCGS# 38475.
3725 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. EF-40 (NGC).
PCGS# 38475.
3726 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. VF-25 (NGC).
PCGS# 3982.
Page 259
3727 1937-D FS-901. 3-Legged. VF-20 (NGC).
3753 1853 Arrows. AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 38475.
PCGS# 4356.
3728 1938-D/S Buffalo. OMM-4. MS-66 (PCGS).
3754 1857 AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 3985.
From an unnamed Paramount sale, lot 373. Lot tag included.
3729 1938-D/S Buffalo. OMM-1. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4365.
3755 1858 AU-50 (NGC). OH.
PCGS# 4367.
PCGS# 3985.
3756 1860 MS-64 (PCGS). CAC.
3730 1938-D Buffalo. MS-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 4377.
PCGS# 3984.
3757 1860 MS-63 (PCGS).
3731 Lot of (2) 1938-D Buffalo. MS-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 4377.
PCGS# 3984.
3758 1865 Proof-64 (PCGS).
3732 1942-P Type II. MS-67 5FS (NGC).
PCGS# 4448.
PCGS# 524016.
Half Dimes
3759 1869 Proof-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 4452.
3733 1829 LM-3. Rarity-2. Unc Details—Questionable Color
(PCGS).
PCGS# 4276.
3734 1830 LM-3. Rarity-2. Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 4277.
3760 1872 MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4400.
3761 1872-S Mintmark Above Bow. MS-65 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 4402.
3735 1832 LM-3. Rarity-1. MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 84456.
PCGS# 4279.
3736 1832 LM-5. Rarity-1. MS-62 (PCGS). CAC.
3763 1873 MS-63 (ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 4279.
PCGS# 4404.
3737 1832 LM-5. Rarity-1. MS-61 (NGC).
Dimes
PCGS# 38667.
3738 1832 LM-5. Rarity-1. VF-30 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4279.
3764 1821 JR-5. Rarity-3. Large Date. AU Details—
Questionable Color (PCGS).
3739 1832 LM-7. Rarity-2. MS-62+ (NGC).
PCGS# 4279.
3740 1833 LM-9. Rarity-2. Unc Details—Questionable Color
(PCGS).
PCGS# 4280.
PCGS# 38829.
PCGS# 4281.
From Heritage’s sale of the Jules Reiver Collection, Part III, January
2006, lot 22212. Reiver acquired the coin from David J. Davis, February 1979.
3742 1834 LM-4. Rarity-1. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4281.
3743 1835 LM-10. Rarity-1. Small Date, Small 5C. AU-50
(ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 4285.
3744 1837 Capped Bust. LM-1. Rarity-1. Large 5C. AU-58
(PCGS).
PCGS# 4289.
PCGS# 4317.
3747 1839 No Drapery. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4319.
3748 1840 No Drapery. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4321.
3749 1844 MS-63 (PCGS). CAC. OGH.
PCGS# 4333.
3750 1851-O AU-58 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 4348.
3751 1853 Arrows. MS-64 (NGC). CAC.
PCGS# 4356.
3752 1853 Arrows. MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4356.
Page 260
3767 1832 JR-7. Rarity-3. EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4521.
3768 1833 JR-5. Rarity-1. Last 3 High. EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4523.
3769 1835 JR-9. Rarity-2. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4527.
3745 1837 Liberty Seated. No Stars. Small Date. AU-58 (PCGS).
3746 1838 No Drapery. Large Stars. AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 94496.
3766 1829 JR-4. Rarity-2. Small 10C. VF-35 (NGC).
3741 1834 LM-2. Rarity-1. AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4312.
PCGS# 4496.
3765 1821 JR-8. Rarity-2. Small Date. VF-30 (ANACS). OH.
3770 1837 Capped Bust. JR-4. Rarity-1. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4529.
3771 1838-O No Stars. Fortin-101. Rarity-3. Repunched
Mintmark. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4564.
3772 1838-O No Stars. Fortin-102. Rarity-3. EF-40 Details—
Cleaned (ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 4564.
3773 1839 No Drapery. Fortin-107. Rarity-3. EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4571.
3774 1842 Fortin-105. Rarity-2. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4581.
3775 1842-O Medium O. EF-40 (NGC).
PCGS# 4582.
3776 1850 EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4593.
3777 1858 MS-64 (PCGS). OGH.
3803 1908 Proof-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4616.
PCGS# 4892.
3778 1861 Proof-62 (PCGS). CAC. OGH.
3804 1908 Proof-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4754.
PCGS# 4892.
3779 1872 Proof-62 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 4765.
3780 1875-CC Mintmark Above Bow. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4673.
3781 1876-CC Type I Reverse. Fortin-131. Rarity-4. AU
PCGS# 4680.
PCGS# 4893.
3807 1909 MS-64 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 84894.
3783 1891 MS-64 (PCGS).
3809 1911 Proof-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4706.
PCGS# 4895.
3784 1891 MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 4706.
3810 1911 MS-65+ (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 84875.
PCGS# 4857.
3786 1892 MS-64 (PCGS).
3811 1912 MS-65 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 4796.
PCGS# 4860.
3787 1892 MS-63 (PCGS).
3812 1912 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4796.
PCGS# 4860.
3788 1894 Proof-63 (PCGS).
3813 1913 Proof-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4878.
3789 1895-O Good-6 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4897.
3814 1914 Proof-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4807.
PCGS# 4898.
3790 1895-O Good-6 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4807.
3815 1914 MS-65 (NGC). CAC.
3791 1897 MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4865.
PCGS# 4812.
3816 1914 AU-55 (PCGS).
3792 1897 MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4865.
PCGS# 4812.
3817 1916 Barber. AU-58 (PCGS).
3793 1898 MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4870.
PCGS# 4815.
3818 1916-S Mercury. MS-64 FB (PCGS).
PCGS# 4909.
3794 1900 Proof-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4884.
3795 1900—Struck 5% Off Center—VF-30 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4821.
3819 Lot of (2) 1918-Dated Mercury Dimes. (PCGS). Included
are: 1918 Unc Details—Cleaning; and 1918-S MS-64.
3820 1918-D MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 4918.
From David W. Akers’ sale of the John Jay Pittman Collection, Part I,
October 1997, lot 735. Pittman acquired the coin from B. Max Mehl on
February 18, 1944 for $3.50.
3796 1902—Broadstruck—AU-55 (NGC).
3797 1904 Proof-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4888.
3821 1919 MS-64 FB (PCGS).
3798 1904 Proof-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4923.
PCGS# 4888.
3799 1905 MS-64 (PCGS).
3822 1919-S AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4926.
3823 Lot of (2) 1920 Mercury Dimes. (PCGS). Included are:
MS-63 FB; and Unc Details—Altered Surfaces.
PCGS# 4835.
3800 1906 Proof-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4890.
3801 1906 MS-64 (PCGS). OGH—Second Generation.
PCGS# 4840.
3806 1909 Proof-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 4776.
PCGS# 4838.
PCGS# 4846.
PCGS# 4850.
3782 1879 Proof-64 (PCGS).
3802 1906-O MS-65 (NGC).
3805 1908 MS-64 (PCGS).
3824 1921 VF-30 (ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 4934.
3825 1921-D AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4936.
3826 1921-D EF Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 4936.
Page 261
3827 1921-D VF-30 (ANACS). OH.
3849 Lot of (7) Certified Mercury Dime Varieties. Included are:
1938-D/D VP-001, MS-65 (NGC); 1940-S/S FS-501, MS-65
(PCGS); 1941-D FS-101, Doubled Die Obverse, Doubled
Die Reverse, MS-65 FB (NGC); 1941-S/S, FS-501, Small S,
MS-65 (NGC); (2) 1944-D/D FS-501, MS-66 (PCGS); and
1944-D/D FS-501, MS-65 FB (PCGS).
PCGS# 4936.
3828 1921-D VF-25 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4936.
3829 1923 MS-65 FB (PCGS).
PCGS# 4939.
3850 1939 Proof-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 5074.
3830 1924-D MS-64 FB (PCGS).
3851 1940 Proof-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4945.
PCGS# 5075.
3831 1924-S MS-62 FB (PCGS).
3852 1941 Proof-67 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4947.
PCGS# 5076.
3832 1926 MS-65 FB (PCGS).
3853 Lot of (3) Certified Mercury Dimes. Included are: 1941-D
MS-65 FB (PCGS); 1943-D Repunched Mintmark, MS-65
FB (NGC), the RPM variety is not designated on the NGC
insert; and 1944 MS-66 FB (NGC), CAC.
PCGS# 4955.
3833 1926-D MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4956.
3834 1926-S MS-63 (PCGS).
3854 1942/1 FS-101. VF-35 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4958.
PCGS# 5036.
3835 1926-S AU-55 (PCGS).
3855 1942/1-D FS-101. VF-20 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 4958.
PCGS# 5040.
3836 1927-D Unc Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
PCGS# 4962.
3856 1947-S/S FS-503, RPM-2. Repunched Mintmark. MS-66
(ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 5208.
3837 1927-S MS-64 (PCGS).
Twenty-Cent Pieces
PCGS# 4964.
3838 1928-D AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4968.
3839 Lot of (2) Mercury Dimes. (PCGS). Included are: 1929
MS-63 FB; and 1930-S AU-58.
From our (Bowers and Ruddy’s) Matt Rothert Collection sale, November 1973, part of lot 424. Lot tags included.
3840 1929-D MS-65 FBL (PCGS).
3857 1875 AU-53 (NGC).
PCGS# 5296.
3858 1875 AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 5296.
3859 1875 AU Details—Smoothed (PCGS).
PCGS# 4975.
PCGS# 5296.
3860 1875 VF-35 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5296.
3841 Lot of (3) Mercury Dimes. (PCGS). Included are: 1929-S
MS-63; 1930 MS-64 FB; and 1931 AU-58.
3861 1875-S Unc Details—Filed Rims (PCGS).
3842 1931-D MS-65 FBL (PCGS).
3862 1875-S FS-302. Misplaced Date, Repunched Mintmark.
AU-53 (PCGS).
From our (Bowers and Ruddy’s) Matt Rothert Collection sale, November 1973, part of lot 424. Lot tags included.
PCGS# 5298.
PCGS# 5298.
PCGS# 4985.
3843 1931-S MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5298.
3864 1876 EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 4986.
PCGS# 5299.
Quarter Dollars
3844 1934-D MS-65 FB (PCGS).
PCGS# 4991.
3845 Lot of (4) Certified Mercury Dime Varieties. Included are:
1934-D RPM-001, MS-64 (ICG); 1935 DDO-001, AU-58
(ICG); 1941-D/D WRPM-002, Plate, MS-63 FSB (ANACS),
OH; and 1943-S/S WRPM-001, Plate, MS-63 FSB (ANACS),
OH.
3846 1936 Proof-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 5071.
3847 1937 Proof-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5072.
3848 1938 Proof-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 5073.
3865 1805 B-4. Rarity-4-. VF Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 5313.
3866 1806 B-9. Rarity-1. Good Details—Tooled (PCGS).
PCGS# 5314.
3867 1806 B-9. Rarity-1. AG-3 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5314.
3868 1818 B-5. Rarity-4+. EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 5322.
3869 1821 B-3. Rarity-3. VF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 5331.
3870 1825/4/(2) B-2. Rarity-2. VF-20 (PCGS).
PCGS# 38975.
3871 1833 B-1. Rarity-2. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 5352.
Page 262
3872 1833 B-1. Rarity-2. VF-25 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5352.
PCGS# 5619.
3873 1835 B-4. Rarity-4. AU Details—Scratch (PCGS).
PCGS# 5354.
PCGS# 5685.
3874 1835 B-5. Rarity-3. VF-30 (PCGS).
3901 1899-O AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5354.
PCGS# 5623.
3875 1835 B-6. Rarity-3. EF-45 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 5354.
3902 1899-S AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5624.
3876 1835 B-7. Rarity-2. VF Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 5354.
3903 1902 Proof-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5688.
3877 1838 Capped Bust. B-1, the only known dies. Rarity-1. EF
Details—Smoothed (PCGS).
PCGS# 5357.
3904 1902 Proof-60 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 5688.
3878 1853 Arrows and Rays. MS-62 (ICG).
3905 1904 Proof-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 11028.
3879 1853 Arrows and Rays. Unc Details—Questionable Color
(PCGS).
PCGS# 5426.
3880 1853 Arrows and Rays. Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 5426.
PCGS# 5690.
3906 1908 MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 5649.
3907 1909 MS-65 (PCGS).
3881 1854 Arrows. AU-53 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 5653.
PCGS# 5432.
3882 1860-O Briggs 1-A. Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 5452.
3908 1909-O VF-20 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5655.
3909 1909-O VG-10 (PCGS).
3883 1873 Arrows. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5655.
PCGS# 5491.
3910 1910 Unc Details—Scratch (PCGS).
3884 1873 Arrows. AU-50 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 5657.
PCGS# 5491.
3911 1912 MS-64 (PCGS).
3885 1875 MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5662.
PCGS# 5498.
PCGS# 5579.
3912 1913 EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5664.
3913 1914 AU-55 (PCGS).
3887 1879 Proof-63 (NGC). CAC.
PCGS# 5667.
PCGS# 5580.
3914 1914-D MS-64 (PCGS).
3888 1885 MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5668.
PCGS# 5517.
3889 1890 Briggs-2-B. Unc Details—Altered Surfaces (PCGS).
PCGS# 5523.
3890 Undated Carson City Mint Liberty Seated Quarter—
Reverse Portion of Split Planchet—Good-6 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
3915 1915 MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5670.
3916 1916-D Unc Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
PCGS# 5674.
3917 1917 Type I. MS-64 FH (PCGS).
PCGS# 5707.
3891 1892 Type II Reverse. MS-64 (PCGS).
3918 1917 Type I. MS-64 FH (PCGS).
PCGS# 5601.
PCGS# 5707.
3892 1892-O AU-53 (PCGS).
3919 1917 Type I. MS-63 FH (PCGS).
PCGS# 5602.
PCGS# 5707.
3893 1892-S AU-53 (PCGS).
3920 1917 Type I. MS-63 FH (PCGS).
PCGS# 5603.
PCGS# 5679.
PCGS# 5707.
3921 1917 Type I. MS-63 FH (PCGS).
PCGS# 5707.
3895 1895 Proof-63 (PCGS).
3922 1917 Type I. MS-63 FH (NGC).
PCGS# 5681.
PCGS# 5707.
3923 1917-D Type I. MS-64 FH (PCGS).
PCGS# 5709.
3896 1896-S Good-4 (PCGS).
3924 1917-D Type I. MS-63 FH (PCGS).
PCGS# 5615.
PCGS# 5709.
3897 1896-S AG-3 (PCGS).
3925 1917-D Type I. MS-63 (PCGS). OGH—First Generation.
PCGS# 5615.
PCGS# 5708.
3898 1897 Proof-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5683.
3900 1899 Proof-62 (PCGS). OGH.
3926 1917-D Type I. Unc Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
PCGS# 5708.
Page 263
3927 1917-S Type I. MS-63 FH (PCGS).
3956 1935-S MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5711.
PCGS# 5799.
3928 1917-S Type I. EF-40 (PCGS).
3957 1936 Proof-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5710.
PCGS# 5975.
3929 1917 Type II. MS-64 (NGC).
3958 1936-D MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5714.
PCGS# 5801.
From Paramount’s sale of May 1971, lot 1324. Lot envelope included.
3930 1917 Type II. AU-55 (PCGS).
3959 1936-D MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5714.
PCGS# 5801.
3931 1917-S Type II. AU-55 FH (PCGS).
3960 1936-S MS-66+ (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 5719.
PCGS# 5802.
3932 1918 MS-64 FH (NGC). OH.
3961 1937-S MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5721.
PCGS# 5805.
3933 1918 MS-62 (NGC).
3962 1939-S MS-67 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5720.
PCGS# 5810.
3934 1918-D MS-63 (PCGS).
3963 1942 MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5722.
PCGS# 5817.
3935 1918-D MS-63 (NGC).
3964 1942-D FS-101. Doubled Die Obverse. EF-45 (PCGS).
CAC.
PCGS# 5722.
3936 1918-S MS-63 (ANACS).
PCGS# 5818.
PCGS# 5724.
3965 1947-D MS-67 (NGC).
3937 1919-D VF-35 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5834.
PCGS# 5730.
3938 1919-S AU Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 5732.
PCGS# 5740.
PCGS# 5750.
3966 1949 MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5839.
3967 1952-D FS-501. Huge D. MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 147814.
3968 1953-S MS-66+ (NGC). CAC.
PCGS# 5854.
3969 1958 MS-67 (PCGS). CAC.
3941 1926-D MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5864.
PCGS# 5756.
3970 1964 MS-66 (PCGS). CAC.
3942 1927-S VF-20 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5876.
PCGS# 5764.
Half Dollars
3943 1928-D MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5768.
3944 1928-S MS-66 (PCGS). CAC.
3971 1795 O-113. Rarity-3. Two Leaves. A/E in STATES. Good
Details—Graffiti (PCGS).
PCGS# 5770.
3945 1929 MS-65 FH (PCGS).
PCGS# 6052.
PCGS# 5773.
3972 1803 O-104. Rarity-3. Small 3. VF-25 (NGC).
3946 1929-D MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 39274.
PCGS# 5774.
3973 1805 O-110. Rarity-5. VG-10 (PCGS).
3947 1930 MS-64 FH (PCGS).
PCGS# 6069.
PCGS# 5779.
3974 1806 O-119. Rarity-3. Pointed 6, Stem Through Claw. VF
3948 1932-D AU Details—Smoothed (PCGS).
PCGS# 5791.
PCGS# 6071.
3949 1932-D EF-40 Details—Scratched (ANACS).
3975 1806 O-125. Rarity-5. Pointed 6, Stem Through Claw. VG
PCGS# 5791.
3950 1932-S MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6071.
3976 1809 O-102a. Rarity-1. XXX Edge. EF-40 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 5792.
3951 1932-S Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 5792.
PCGS# 6093.
From an unknown Paramount auction, lot 1146. Lot envelope included.
3952 1932-S VF-25 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5792.
3953 1934-D Heavy Motto. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 85796.
3954 1934-D MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5796.
3955 1935-D MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 5798.
3977 1809 O-103. Rarity-1. AU Details—Improperly Cleaned
(NGC).
PCGS# 6092.
3978 1811 O-105a. Rarity-2. Small 8. AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6097.
3979 1814 O-103. Rarity-1. EF-45 (NGC).
PCGS# 39477.
3980 1818 O-107. Rarity-1. EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6113.
3981 1818 O-107a. Rarity-1. EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6113.
Page 264
3982 1820 O-104. Rarity-4+. Square Base Knob 2, Large Date.
EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6122.
PCGS# 6154.
4009 1830 O-102. Rarity-3. Small 0. EF-40 (ANACS). OH.
3983 1821 O-104. Rarity-1. VF-35 (PCGS).
PCGS# 39811.
PCGS# 6128.
4010 1831 O-102. Rarity-1. AU-58 (PCGS).
3984 1822/1 O-101. Rarity-1. VF-25 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6159.
PCGS# 6130.
4011 1832 O-103. Rarity-1. Small Letters. EF-45 (PCGS).
3985 1822 O-115. Rarity-3. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6160.
PCGS# 6129.
3986 1823 O-111a. Rarity-2. Unc Details—Reverse Damage
(NGC).
PCGS# 6131.
3987 1824 O-111. Rarity-2. AU-50 (PCGS).
4012 1832 O-106. Rarity-1. Small Letters. AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6160.
4013 1832 O-106. Rarity-1. Small Letters. AU Details—
Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6160.
PCGS# 6137.
4014 1833 O-105. Rarity-2. VF-30 (PCGS).
3988 1825 O-111. Rarity-3. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6163.
PCGS# 6142.
3989 1825 O-112. Rarity-3. EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6142.
4015 1833 O-109. Rarity-3. AU-55 (NGC).
PCGS# 6163.
4016 1834 O-104. Rarity-2. Large Date, Small Letters. AU-50
(PCGS).
3990 1825 O-115. Rarity-3. AU-53 (NGC).
PCGS# 6165.
PCGS# 39662.
3991 1825 O-116. Rarity-3. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6142.
4017 1834 O-106. Rarity-1. Large Date, Small Letters. AU-55
(PCGS).
PCGS# 6165.
3992 1826 O-101. Rarity-1. EF-45 (NGC).
4018 1835 O-103. Rarity-2. AU-50 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 39666.
PCGS# 6168.
3993 1826 O-101a. Rarity-2. EF-45 (PCGS).
4019 1835 O-104. Rarity-3. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 39667.
3994 1826 O-109. Rarity-1. EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6143.
PCGS# 6168.
4020 1835 O-110. Rarity-2. AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6168.
3995 1826 O-112. Rarity-4+. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6143.
3996 1827/6 O-103. Rarity-4. EF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6147.
3997 1827 O-106. Rarity-2. Square Base 2. AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 39698.
3998 Lot of (2) 1827 (PCGS). Included are: O-113a, Rarity-4-,
Square Base 2, EF Details—Cleaning; and O-146, Rarity-2,
Curl Base 2, VF Details—Cleaning.
3999 1827 O-125. Rarity-3. Square Base 2. EF Details—
Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6144.
4000 1827 O-142. Rarity-3. Square Base 2. AU Details—
Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6144.
4001 1827 O-146. Rarity-2. Curl Base 2. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6145.
4002 1828 O-101. Rarity-1. Curl Base No Knob 2. AU Details—
Graffiti (PCGS).
PCGS# 6148.
4003 1828 O-103. Rarity-2. Curl Base No Knob 2. EF-45 (NGC).
PCGS# 6148.
4004 1828 O-107. Rarity-2. Curl Base Knob 2. VF-35 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6149.
4005 1828 O-116. Rarity-2. Square Base 2, Small 8s, Large
Letters. VF-30 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6151.
4006 1828 O-117a. Rarity-1. Square Base 2, Small 8s, Large
Letters. EF Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 6151.
4007 1829 O-108. Rarity-2. AU Details—Scratch (PCGS).
PCGS# 6154.
4008 1829 O-115. Rarity-1. VF-35 (PCGS).
4021 1836 Lettered Edge. O-101. Rarity-1. AU-58 (PCGS).
OGH—First Generation.
PCGS# 6169.
4022 1836 Lettered Edge. O-106. Rarity-1. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6169.
4023 1837 Reeded Edge. 50 CENTS. GR-6. Rarity-3. AU-58
(PCGS).
PCGS# 6176.
4024 1837 Reeded Edge. 50 CENTS. GR-5. Rarity-1. EF-45
(PCGS).
PCGS# 6176.
4025 1838 Reeded Edge. HALF DOL. GR-14. Rarity-3. AU-58
(NGC).
PCGS# 6177.
4026 1838 Reeded Edge. HALF DOL. GR-14. Rarity-3. AU-50
(PCGS).
PCGS# 6177.
4027 1838 Reeded Edge. HALF DOL. GR-2. Rarity-3. AU
PCGS# 6177.
4028 1838 Reeded Edge. HALF DOL. GR-10. Rarity-3. EF-45
(PCGS).
PCGS# 6177.
4029 1839 Capped Bust. Reeded Edge. HALF DOL. GR-4.
Rarity-1. AU-53 (NGC).
PCGS# 6179.
4030 1839 Liberty Seated. No Drapery. WB-101. VF-30
(PCGS).
PCGS# 6230.
4031 1842 WB-104. Medium Date, Medium Letters (a.k.a.
Reverse of 1842). AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 6240.
Page 265
4032 1842 WB-104. Medium Date, Medium Letters (a.k.a.
Reverse of 1842). AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 6239.
4033 1842 Medium Date. WB-106. Repunched 8, Misplaced 8.
AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6239.
PCGS# 6244.
PCGS# 6492.
PCGS# 6245.
PCGS# 6524.
4036 1845 WB-101. AU-55 (NGC).
4064 1913-D AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6248.
4037 1846 WB-105. Medium Date. Doubled Die Obverse. MS61 (NGC).
PCGS# 6251.
4038 1849-O WB-13. Rarity-3. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6263.
4039 1850-O WB-101, Breen-4822. Open 5, Partial Drapery.
AU-53 (ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 6265.
4040 1853 Arrows and Rays. WB-101. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6275.
4041 1853 Arrows and Rays. WB-101. EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6275.
PCGS# 6529.
4066 1916-D AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6567.
4067 1916-S (PCGS).
PCGS# 6568.
4068 1917-D Obverse Mintmark. VF-35 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6570.
4069 1917-D Reverse Mintmark. AU Details—Cleaning
(PCGS).
PCGS# 6571.
PCGS# 6572.
PCGS# 6280.
4043 1854-O Arrows. WB-101. Shipwreck Effect (NGC). VF
Details.
PCGS# 6280.
4071 1918-D VF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 6575.
4072 1919 EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6577.
Ex: S.S. Republic.
4073 1919-D EF-40 (PCGS).
4044 1855-O Arrows. WB-101. AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6578.
PCGS# 6283.
4074 1919-S VF-35 (PCGS).
4045 1856-S WB-2. Rarity-4. VF-35 (NGC).
PCGS# 6579.
PCGS# 6289.
4046 1857-O WB-102. Misplaced Date. MS-61 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6291.
4075 1920-D VF-30 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6581.
4047 1858-O WB-101. AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 6582.
PCGS# 6294.
4048 1858-O WB-101. AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 6585.
PCGS# 6294.
4078 1923-S VF-30 (PCGS).
4049 1858-O WB-101. AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 6586.
PCGS# 6294.
4079 1927-S EF-45 (PCGS).
4050 1858-S WB-7. Rarity-3. Large S. AU-53 (NGC).
PCGS# 6587.
PCGS# 6295.
4051 1873 Arrows. WB-106. Large Arrows. EF-45 (NGC).
PCGS# 6343.
4052 1875 WB-101. Unc Details—Artificial Toning (NGC).
PCGS# 6349.
4080 1929-S AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6590.
4081 1933-S AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6591.
4082 1933-S AU-50 (PCGS).
4053 1875 WB-101. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6591.
PCGS# 6349.
4083 1934 MS-64 (PCGS).
4054 1876 Proof-63 (ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 6592.
PCGS# 6437.
4055 1877-S Type I Reverse. WB-2. Rarity-3. Micro S. AU-55
(NGC).
PCGS# 6357.
PCGS# 6462.
PCGS# 6528.
4070 1917-S Obverse Mintmark. EF-45 (NGC).
4042 1854-O Arrows. WB-101. AU-50 (PCGS).
4058 1893-S VG-8 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6471.
4061 1899 MS-62 (NGC).
4035 1844 WB-101. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6445.
PCGS# 6467.
4060 1895 EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6483.
4034 1843-O WB-12. Rarity-3-. EF-45 (PCGS).
4057 1892-O AU-53 (PCGS). OGH.
4059 1893-S Good-6 (PCGS).
4084 1934-D MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6593.
4085 1934-S Unc Details—Machine Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 6594.
PCGS# 6596.
4087 1935-S MS-64+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 6597.
PCGS# 6467.
Page 266
Silver Dollars
4088 1938 Proof-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6638.
4089 1938 Proof-64 (PCGS).
State III. VF Details—Smoothed (PCGS).
PCGS# 6638.
4090 1938 MS-63 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 6873.
PCGS# 6604.
4118 1800 BB-190, B-10. Rarity-3. BB Die State II-III
(transitional die state). Very Wide Date, Low 8. VF
Details—Cleaning (PCGS). The Very Wide Date, Low 8
Guide Book variety is not denoted on the PCGS insert.
4091 1939-D MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6607.
4092 1939-D MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6607.
PCGS# 6887.
4119 1801 BB-214, B-4. Rarity-4. BB Die State III. VF Details—
Cleaning (PCGS).
4093 1939-S MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6608.
4094 1941 Breen-5182. No AW. Proof-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6641.
4095 1941 MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6893.
Normal Date. Fine Details—Scratches (NGC).
PCGS# 6895.
PCGS# 6611.
4121 1842 AU-53 (NGC).
4096 1941-D MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6928.
PCGS# 6612.
4122 1843 AU Details—Scratch (PCGS).
4097 1941-S MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6929.
PCGS# 6613.
4123 1844 VF-25 (PCGS).
4098 1942 MS-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 6930.
PCGS# 6614.
4124 1845 EF Details—Devices Outlined (PCGS).
4099 1942-D MS-67 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6931.
PCGS# 6615.
4125 1846-O VF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
4100 1942-D MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6933.
PCGS# 6615.
4126 1850-O VG Details—Smoothed (PCGS).
4101 1942-D MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6938.
PCGS# 6615.
4102 1943 MS-67 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 6941.
PCGS# 6618.
4103 Lot of (2) Walking Liberty Half Dollars. MS-65 (PCGS).
OGH—First Generation. Included are: 1946-D; and 1946-S.
4104 1946-S MS-66+ (PCGS). CAC.
4128 1859 AU Details—Scratch (PCGS).
PCGS# 6946.
4129 1859-S EF Details—Repaired (PCGS).
PCGS# 6948.
PCGS# 6629.
4130 1860-O VF-30 (PCGS).
4105 1946-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6950.
PCGS# 6629.
4131 1867 Breen-5478. Large/Small Date. AU Details—
Cleaning (PCGS).
4106 1946-S MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 6629.
PCGS# 6960.
4107 1947-D MS-66+ (NGC). CAC.
4132 1869 EF Details—Smoothed (PCGS).
PCGS# 6631.
PCGS# 6962.
4108 1947-D MS-65 (NGC).
4133 1871 AU-50 (NGC).
PCGS# 6631.
PCGS# 6966.
4109 1948 MS-65 FBL (PCGS).
4134 1872 Breen-5491. Misplaced
PCGS# 86651.
4110 1948 MS-65 FBL (PCGS).
Date.
EF
Details—
PCGS# 6968.
PCGS# 86651.
4135 1872-S VG Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
4111 1951 Proof-66 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 6970.
PCGS# 6692.
4112 1961 FS-802. Doubled Die Reverse. Proof-67 Cameo
(PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 147803.
4136 1878 8 Tailfeathers. MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 7072.
PCGS# 7072.
4113 1963 Proof-68 Deep Cameo (PCGS).
PCGS# 96704.
4114 1976-D Kennedy Half Dollar—11% Clipped Planchet—
MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6727.
4115 1998-S Silver. Matte Finish. MS-70 (PCGS).
PCGS# 6775.
4116 1998-S Silver. Matte Finish. MS-69 (ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 7072.
4139 1878 8 Tailfeathers. VAM-12. Notched Star. MS-62
(NGC).
PCGS# 133794.
4140 1878 7/8 Tailfeathers. Strong. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7078.
PCGS# 6775.
Page 267
4141 1878 7 Tailfeathers. Reverse of 1878. MS-64 (ANACS).
PCGS# 7074.
4142 1878 7 Tailfeathers, Reverse of 1878. VAM-82. Doubled
Stars. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 134042.
4143 Lot of (2) Certified Mint State Morgan Silver Dollars.
Included are: 1878 7 Tailfeathers, Reverse of 1878, MS-63
(NGC); and 1903 MS-65 (ANACS), OH.
4144 1878 7 Tailfeathers. Reverse of 1879. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7076.
4145 1878-CC Morgan. MS-64+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7093.
4173 1880 MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7080.
4148 1878-CC Morgan. MS-62 (NGC).
PCGS# 7096.
4174 1880 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7080.
4149 1878-CC Morgan. MS-60 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7096.
4175 Lot of (3) Early Date Philadelphia Mint Morgan Silver
Dollars. MS-64 (NGC). Included are: 1880; 1881; and 1882.
PCGS# 7080.
4150 1878-S Morgan. MS-65 (PCGS).
4176 1880-CC MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7082.
4151 1878-S Morgan. MS-64+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7100.
PCGS# 7082.
4152 Lot of (3) San Francisco Mint Morgan Silver Dollars. MS64 (NGC). Included are: 1878-S; 1880-S; and 1881-S.
4153 1878-S Morgan. MS-63 (PCGS).
4180 Lot of (3) Certified Morgan Silver Dollars. Included are:
1880-O AU-58 (PCGS); 1880-S MS-64 DMPL (ANACS),
OH; and 1901-O MS-64 (NGC).
4155 1879 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7084.
4181 1880-S MS-67 (PCGS). CAC.
4156 1879 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7084.
4182 1880-S MS-66+ (PCGS).
4157 1879-CC EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7086.
4158 1879-CC VAM-3. Top 100 Variety. Capped Die. VF-35
(PCGS).
PCGS# 7088.
4185 1880-S MS-66 (PCGS).
4160 1879-O MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7090.
4161 Lot of (5) New Orleans Mint Morgan Silver Dollars.
(NGC). Included are: 1879-O MS-61; 1883-O MS-64; 1884O MS-64; 1885-O MS-64; and 1888-O MS-64.
PCGS# 7092.
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7118.
PCGS# 7090.
4166 1879-S MS-65 (PCGS).
4183 1880-S MS-66 (PCGS). CAC.
4184 1880-S MS-66 (PCGS).
4159 1879-O MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 7093.
4178 1880-CC MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7114.
PCGS# 7084.
4165 1879-S MS-65 PL (PCGS).
PCGS# 7100.
4179 1880-O MS-63 (PCGS).
4154 1879 MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7092.
4177 1880-CC MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7100.
PCGS# 7082.
4164 1879-S MS-66 (PCGS).
4170 Lot of (3) 1879-S MS-64 (PCGS).
4172 Lot of (5) 1879-S MS-63 PL (PCGS).
PCGS# 7092.
PCGS# 7093.
PCGS# 7092.
PCGS# 7080.
4163 1879-S MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7093.
4169 Lot of (3) 1879-S MS-64 PL (PCGS).
4171 1879-S MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 7092.
4168 Lot of (3) 1879-S Morgan Silver Dollars. (PCGS). Included
are: MS-64+ PL; and (2) MS-64 PL.
PCGS# 7092.
PCGS# 7080.
4162 1879-S MS-67 (PCGS). CAC.
Included are: 1879-S MS-65 (ANACS), OH; 1880-O MS62 (ANACS); 1882-S MS-64 (ANACS), OH; 1887 MS-64
(ANACS); 1889 Brilliant Uncirculated (NGC); and 1890-O
MS-63 (ANACS), OH.
4186 1880-S MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4187 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4188 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4189 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4190 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4191 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4192 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4193 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
Page 268
4194 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4195 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4196 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4197 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4198 1880-S MS-65+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4199 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4200 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4201 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4202 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4203 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4204 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4205 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4206 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4207 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4208 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4209 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4210 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4211 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4212 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4213 1880-S MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4214 1880-S MS-64+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4215 1880-S MS-64+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4216 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4217 1880-S MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4218 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4219 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4220 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4221 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4222 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4223 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4224 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4225 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4226 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4227 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4228 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4229 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4230 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4231 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4232 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4233 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4234 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4235 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
4236 1880-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7118.
Included are: 1880-S MS-63 (NGC); 1884 MS-63 PL
(ANACS), OH; and 1904-O MS-64 PL (ANACS), OH.
MS-63 (PCGS). OGH—First Generation. The old style
PCGS insert does not list the overdate feature.
PCGS# 7108.
MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 7108.
4240 1881 MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7124.
4241 1881-CC MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7126.
4242 1881-CC MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7126.
4243 1881-CC MS-65 (ANACS).
PCGS# 7126.
4244 1881-CC MS-64 DPL (NGC).
PCGS# 97127.
4245 1881-CC MS-63 (PCGS). OGH—First Generation.
PCGS# 7126.
4246 1881-O MS-64 DMPL (PCGS). Secure Holder.
PCGS# 97129.
4247 1881-O MS-64 DMPL (PCGS).
PCGS# 97129.
4248 1881-O MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7128.
4249 1881-O MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7128.
4250 Lot of (4) Morgan Silver Dollars. MS-63 (PCGS). Included
are: 1881-O; 1883-O; 1890; and 1902.
4251 1881-S MS-67 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 7130.
Page 269
4252 1881-S MS-67 (NGC).
4280 1882-S MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7140.
4253 1881-S MS-67 (NGC).
4281 1882-S MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7140.
4254 1881-S MS-67 (NGC).
4282 1882-S MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7140.
4283 Lot of (5) Philadelphia Mint Morgan Silver Dollars. MS64 (NGC). Included are: 1883; 1884; 1885; 1887; and 1888.
4255 1881-S MS-66 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 7130.
4256 1881-S MS-66 (PCGS).
4284 1883-CC MS-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7144.
4257 1881-S MS-66 (PCGS).
4285 1883-CC MS-66 (ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7144.
4258 1881-S MS-66 (ANACS). OH.
4286 1883-CC MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7144.
4259 1881-S MS-65 (PCGS).
4287 1883-CC MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7144.
4260 1881-S MS-65 (NGC).
4288 1883-CC MS-65 (ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7144.
4261 1881-S MS-64 DMPL (PCGS).
4289 1883-CC MS-64+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 97131.
PCGS# 7144.
4262 1881-S MS-64 DPL (NGC). OH.
4290 1883-CC VAM-5A. MS-64 DMPL (ANACS).
PCGS# 97131.
PCGS# 97145.
4263 1881-S MS-64 PL (PCGS).
4291 1883-CC MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7131.
PCGS# 7144.
4264 1881-S MS-64 (PCGS). OGH.
4292 1883-CC MS-62 (NGC).
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7144.
4265 1881-S MS-64 * (NGC).
4293 1883-O MS-65 UDM (ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 97147.
4266 1881-S MS-64 * (NGC).
4294 1883-O MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7146.
4267 1881-S MS-64 (NGC).
4295 1883-O MS-65 (NGC). OH.
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 7146.
4268 1881-S MS-64 (NGC).
4296 1883-O MS-64 DMPL (PCGS).
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 97147.
4269 1881-S MS-63 (PCGS). CAC—Gold Label. OGH—First
Generation.
PCGS# 7130.
PCGS# 97147.
PCGS# 7130.
4299 1883-O MS-63 (NGC).
4271 1881-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7146.
PCGS# 7130.
4300 1883-O MS-62 (PCGS).
4272 1882-CC MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7146.
PCGS# 7134.
4301 1884 MS-65 (PCGS).
4273 1882-CC MS-65+ PL (PCGS).
PCGS# 7150.
PCGS# 7135.
4302 1884 MS-65 (PCGS).
4274 1882-CC MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7150.
PCGS# 7134.
4303 1884 MS-64 Cameo DMPL (ANACS). OH.
4275 1882-CC MS-63 DMPL (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 97151.
PCGS# 97135.
4304 1884-CC MS-66 (PCGS).
4276 1882-CC MS-63 DMPL (PCGS).
PCGS# 7152.
PCGS# 97135.
4277 Lot of (7) Morgan and Peace Silver Dollars. MS-64
(PCGS). Included are: Morgan: 1882-O; 1882-S, OGH; (2)
1886; 1898, OGH; 1921; and Peace: 1925.
4278 1882-O/S VAM-5. Top 100 Variety. O/S Broken. AU-58
(PCGS).
4279 1882-S MS-67 (NGC). CAC.
PCGS# 7140.
Page 270
PCGS# 7146.
4298 1883-O MS-63 DMPL (PCGS). OGH.
4270 1881-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 133893.
4297 1883-O MS-64 (PCGS).
4305 1884-CC MS-65 PL (PCGS).
PCGS# 7153.
4306 1884-CC MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7152.
4307 1884-CC MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7152.
Ex: GSA.
4308 1884-CC MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7152.
4309 1884-CC MS-65 (PCGS).
4337 1885-CC MS-64 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 7152.
PCGS# 7160.
4310 1884-CC MS-65 (NGC).
4338 1885-CC MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7152.
PCGS# 7160.
4311 1884-CC MS-64 DMPL (PCGS).
4339 1885-CC MS-63 DMPL (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 97153.
PCGS# 97161.
4312 1884-CC MS-64 (PCGS). CAC.
4340 1885-O MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7152.
PCGS# 7162.
4313 1884-CC MS-64 (PCGS). OGH—Second Generation.
PCGS# 7152.
PCGS# 7162.
4314 1884-CC MS-64 (PCGS).
4342 1885-O MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 7152.
PCGS# 7162.
Ex: GSA.
4343 1885-O MS-64 (PCGS).
4315 1884-CC MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 7162.
PCGS# 7152.
4344 1885-O MS-63 (NGC).
4316 1884-CC MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7162.
PCGS# 7152.
4345 1885-O MS-61 (PCGS).
Ex: GSA.
PCGS# 7162.
4317 1884-CC MS-63 (PCGS).
4346 1885-O Unc Details—Altered Surfaces (PCGS).
PCGS# 7152.
PCGS# 7162.
4318 1884-O MS-65 (PCGS).
4347 1885-S MS-61 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7154.
PCGS# 7164.
4319 1884-O MS-64 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 7154.
PCGS# 7164.
4320 1884-O MS-63 DMPL (PCGS).
4349 1886 MS-67 (NGC).
PCGS# 97155.
PCGS# 7166.
4321 1884-O MS-63 (PCGS).
4350 1886 MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7154.
PCGS# 7166.
4322 1884-O MS-63 (PCGS).
4351 1886 MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 7154.
PCGS# 7166.
4323 1884-O MS-62 H (NGC).
4352 1886 MS-64 DPL (NGC). OH.
PCGS# 7154.
PCGS# 97167.
4324 1884-S EF-45 (PCGS).
4353 1886 MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 7156.
PCGS# 7166.
4325 1885 MS-66+ (NGC). CAC.
4354 1886-O AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7158.
4326 1885 MS-65 (PCGS). CAC—Gold Label. OGH—Second
Generation.
PCGS# 7158.
4327 1885 MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. OGH—First Generation.
PCGS# 7158.
4328 1885 MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. OGH—Second Generation.
PCGS# 7158.
PCGS# 7158.
4330 1885 MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. OGH.
4357 1887 MS-66 (NGC). OH.
PCGS# 7172.
PCGS# 7172.
PCGS# 7158.
4332 1885 MS-64 DMPL (PCGS). OGH—First Generation.
PCGS# 97159.
4360 1887 MS-65 (NGC). OH.
PCGS# 7172.
4361 1887 MS-64 (PCGS).
4333 1885 MS-64 DPL (NGC). OH.
PCGS# 7172.
PCGS# 97159.
4334 Lot of (3) Morgan and Peace Silver Dollars. (PCGS).
Included are: Morgan: 1885 MS-64; 1896 MS-63; and
Peace: 1923 MS-64.
PCGS# 7158.
PCGS# 7170.
4359 1887 MS-65 (PCGS).
4331 1885 MS-65 (NGC). OH.
4336 1885 MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 7168.
PCGS# 7172.
PCGS# 7158.
PCGS# 7158.
PCGS# 7168.
4355 1886-O AU-58 (NGC).
4358 1887 VAM-12. Top 100 Variety. Doubled Die Obverse,
Alligator Eye. MS-66 (NGC). The VAM-12 Alligator Eye
attribution is not denoted on the NGC insert.
4329 1885 MS-65 (PCGS). CAC. OGH.
4335 1885 MS-64 (NGC). OH.
4341 1885-O MS-65 (PCGS).
4362 1887-O MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7176.
4363 1887-O MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7176.
4364 1887-S MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 7180.
4365 1887-S MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7180.
Page 271
4366 1887-S MS-61 (PCGS).
4394 1891-CC VAM-3. Top 100 Variety. Spitting Eagle. MS-63
(NGC).
PCGS# 7180.
PCGS# 133937.
4367 1888 MS-66 (NGC).
4395 1891-O MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7182.
PCGS# 7208.
4368 1888 MS-65 (NGC). OH.
4396 1892 MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7182.
PCGS# 7212.
4369 1888 MS-64 (PCGS). CAC.
4397 1892-CC VF Details—Bent (PCGS).
PCGS# 7182.
PCGS# 7214.
4370 1888 Unc Details—Altered Surfaces (PCGS).
4398 1892-O MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7182.
PCGS# 7216.
4371 1888-O MS-65 DMPL (ANACS). OH.
4399 1892-O MS-62 (ANACS).
PCGS# 97185.
PCGS# 7216.
4372 1888-O MS-64+ (PCGS).
4400 1892-S EF-45 (NGC).
PCGS# 7184.
PCGS# 7218.
4373 1888-O MS-64 UDM (ANACS). OH.
4401 1893 AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 97185.
4374 Lot of (3) Certified Morgan Silver Dollar VAM Varieties.
Top 100 Variety. Included are: 1888-O VAM-9, Doubled
Die Reverse, Doubled Arrows, MS-61 (NGC); 1889-O
VAM-6, Doubled Date, AU-53 (ANACS); and 1899-O
VAM-31, Micro O, AU-50 (ANACS).
4375 1888-S MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7220.
4402 1893-CC EF Details—Filed Rims (PCGS).
PCGS# 7222.
4403 1893-O AU-50 (NGC).
PCGS# 7224.
PCGS# 7186.
PCGS# 7224.
4376 1889 MS-65 (PCGS). OGH.
4405 1893-S Good Details—Scratch (PCGS).
PCGS# 7188.
PCGS# 7226.
4377 1889 VAM-22. Top 100 Variety. Barwing. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 133929.
PCGS# 7228.
4378 1889-CC VF Details—Rim Damage (PCGS).
4407 1894 AU Details—Tooled (PCGS).
PCGS# 7190.
PCGS# 7228.
4379 1889-O MS-64 (NGC).
4408 1894 Fine Details—Cleaning (PCGS)
PCGS# 7192.
PCGS# 7228.
4380 1889-S MS-64 (NGC). CAC.
4409 1894-O AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 7194.
PCGS# 7230.
4381 1889-S MS-63 (PCGS). OGH—First Generation.
PCGS# 7194.
4410 1894-O AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7230.
4382 1889-S MS-63 (PCGS).
4411 1894-O EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7194.
PCGS# 7230.
4383 1889-S MS-62 (PCGS).
4412 1895-O EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7194.
PCGS# 7236.
4384 1890 MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC.
4413 1895-O EF-45 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7196.
PCGS# 7236.
4385 1890 MS-64 (PCGS).
4414 1895-S Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7196.
PCGS# 7238.
4386 1890 MS-64 (PCGS).
4415 1896 MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7196.
PCGS# 7240.
4387 1890-O MS-64 (NGC).
4416 1896 MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7200.
PCGS# 7240.
4388 1890-S MS-63 DMPL (ANACS). OH.
4417 1896 MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 97203.
PCGS# 7240.
PCGS# 7202.
4418 1896-O AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7242.
4390 1891 MS-64 (PCGS).
4419 1896-O AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 7204.
PCGS# 7242.
4391 1891 MS-63 (PCGS). OGH.
4420 1896-O AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 7204.
PCGS# 7242.
4392 1891-CC MS-63 (PCGS).
4421 1897 MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7206.
PCGS# 7246.
4393 1891-CC VAM-3. Top 100 Variety. Spitting Eagle. MS-63
(NGC).
4422 1897 MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 7246.
PCGS# 133937.
Page 272
4423 1897 MS-65 (PCGS).
4452 1900-O/CC Top 100 Variety. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7246.
PCGS# 7268.
4424 Lot of (6) Morgan Silver Dollars. MS-64 (NGC). Included
are: 1897; 1899-O; 1900; 1901-O; 1903; and 1904-O.
4453 1900-S MS-64 (PCGS). CAC.
4425 1897-O AU-58 (PCGS). CAC.
4454 1900-S MS-64 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 7270.
PCGS# 7248.
4455 1901 AU-55 (PCGS).
4426 1897-O AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7272.
PCGS# 7248.
4456 1901 AU-55 (NGC).
4427 1897-S MS-65+ (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 7272.
PCGS# 7250.
4457 1901-O MS-63 PL (NGC). OH.
4428 1897-S MS-65 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 7273.
PCGS# 7250.
4458 1902 MS-65 (PCGS). CAC.
4429 1897-S MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7278.
PCGS# 7250.
4459 1902 MS-65 (PCGS).
4430 1898 MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7278.
PCGS# 7252.
4460 1902 MS-65 (NGC).
4431 1898-O MS-66 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 7278.
PCGS# 7254.
4461 1902-O MS-65+ (NGC).
4432 1898-O MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7280.
PCGS# 7254.
4462 1902-O MS-65 (PCGS).
4433 1898-O MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 7280.
PCGS# 7254.
4463 1902-S MS-62 (PCGS).
4434 1898-O MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7282.
PCGS# 7254.
4464 1903 MS-66 (PCGS). CAC.
4435 1899 MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7284.
PCGS# 7258.
4465 1903 MS-65 (PCGS).
4436 1899 MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 7284.
PCGS# 7258.
4437 1899 MS-64 (PCGS). OGH—Second Generation.
PCGS# 7258.
4466 1903-O MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7286.
4467 1903-O MS-64 (PCGS).
4438 1899 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7286.
PCGS# 7258.
4468 1903-O MS-63 PL (PCGS). OGH—Second Generation.
4439 1899 MS-64 (NGC). OH.
PCGS# 7287.
PCGS# 7258.
4469 1904 MS-64 (PCGS).
4440 1899 MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 7290.
PCGS# 7258.
4470 1904 MS-64 (ANACS).
4441 1899 MS-63+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 7290.
PCGS# 7258.
4442 1899 MS-63 (PCGS). OGH—First Generation.
PCGS# 7258.
4471 1904-O MS-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 7292.
4472 1904-O MS-65 (PCGS).
4443 1899 MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7292.
PCGS# 7258.
4473 1904-O MS-65 (PCGS).
4444 1899-O MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7292.
PCGS# 7260.
4474 1904-O MS-65 (PCGS).
4445 1899-O MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7292.
PCGS# 7260.
4475 1904-O MS-65 (NGC). OH.
4446 1899-O MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 7292.
PCGS# 7260.
4476 1904-O MS-65 (ANACS). OH.
PCGS# 7292.
PCGS# 7262.
4477 1904-O MS-64 (PCGS).
4448 1900-O MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 7292.
PCGS# 7266.
4449 Lot of (5) Mint State Morgan Silver Dollars. (NGC).
Included are: 1900-O MS-64; 1902-O MS-64; 1904-O MS64; 1921 MS-63; and 1921-D MS-64.
PCGS# 7268.
PCGS# 7268.
PCGS# 7270.
4478 1921 Morgan. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7296.
4479 1921 Morgan. MS-63 (ANACS).
PCGS# 7296.
4480 1921-D MS-65 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 7298.
4481 1921-D MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7298.
Page 273
GSA Dollars
4482 1921-S MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 7300.
4483 1921-S MS-64 (PCGS).
4508 1879-S GSA Morgan Silver Dollar. MS-65 (NGC). The
original box and card are not included.
PCGS# 7300.
4484 1921 Peace. High Relief. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7092.
PCGS# 7356.
4509 1882-CC GSA Morgan Silver Dollar. MS-63 (Uncertified).
A minor obverse strikethrough from the lower border
bisects the second digit 8 in the date.The original box and
card are not included.
PCGS# 7356.
4486 1921 Peace. High Relief. MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 7356.
PCGS# 518866.
4510 1883-CC GSA Morgan Silver Dollar. MS-63 (Uncertified).
The original box and papers are included, but not the original
certification card. Also, the lid of the box is detached from
the base.
PCGS# 7356.
4488 1922 MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 7357.
4489 Lot of (5) Mint State Philadelphia Mint Peace Silver
Dollars. Included are: 1922 MS-64 (NGC); 1923 MS-64
(PCGS), OGH; 1924 MS-63 (PCGS); 1925 MS-64 (PCGS),
OGH; and 1926 MS-64 (NGC).
4490 1922 VAM-12A. Top 50 Variety. Moustache. MS-62
(PCGS).
PCGS# 133747.
PCGS# 518869.
4511 1884-CC GSA Morgan Silver Dollar. MS-63+ (PCGS).
The original box and card are not included.
PCGS# 518872.
4512 1884-CC GSA Morgan Silver Dollar. MS-63 (PCGS). The
original box and card are not included.
PCGS# 518872.
Redfield Dollar
4491 1922-D MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7358.
4492 1923 MS-66 (PCGS).
4513 1880-S Redfield Morgan Silver Dollar. MS-64
(Uncertified). Housed in a red Paramount International
PCGS# 7360.
4493 1923-D MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7361.
PCGS# 7118.
4494 1923-S MS-64 (PCGS).
Trade Dollars
PCGS# 7362.
4495 1923-S MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 7362.
4514 1873-CC Trade. Wide C C. AU Details—Repaired
(PCGS).
4496 1925 MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7365.
PCGS# 7032.
4497 1925 MS-66 (PCGS).
4515 1874-CC Minute CC. AU Details—Improperly Cleaned
(NGC).
PCGS# 7365.
PCGS# 7035.
4498 1926 MS-65 (NGC).
4516 1874-S Large S. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 7367.
PCGS# 7036.
4499 1926-S MS-65 (PCGS).
4517 1874-S Medium S. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 7369.
PCGS# 7036.
4500 1926-S MS-65 (PCGS).
4518 1875-S Type I/I. Large S. AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 7369.
PCGS# 7039.
4501 1926-S MS-64 (PCGS).
4519 1876 Type I/II. EF-45 (NGC).
PCGS# 7369.
PCGS# 7369.
4521 1877 Fine-15 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7371.
PCGS# 7044.
4504 1927-S Unc Details—Damage (PCGS).
4522 1877-CC Tall CC. EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7372.
PCGS# 7045.
4505 1935 MS-65 (NGC).
4523 1877-S Large S. Unc Details—Surface Tooled (PCGS).
PCGS# 7378.
4506 1935-S Four Rays. VAM-4. Top 50 Variety. Doubled
Reverse. MS-64+ (PCGS).
4507 1935-S Three Rays. MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7379.
Page 274
4520 1876-S Type II/II. Micro S. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7043.
4503 1927-D MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 133783.
PCGS# 7041.
PCGS# 7046.
4524 1877-S Large S. AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 7046.
4525 1878-S Trade. Large S. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7048.
Modern Dollars
4526 Lot of (5) Certified Modern Dollars. Included are:
Sacagawea: 2001-S Proof-69 Deep Cameo (PCGS); (2)
2001-S Proof-69 Ultra Cameo (NGC); Presidential: 2007-S
Thomas Jefferson, Proof-69 Ultra Cameo; and 2007-S James
Madison, Proof-69 Ultra Cameo (NGC).
Gold Dollars
PCGS# 7762.
4551 1852-O AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7766.
4552 1853 AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7767.
PCGS# 7777.
4554 1861 Type II Reverse. MS-62 (NGC).
PCGS# 7794.
4555 1861 Type II Reverse. MS-61 (NGC).
4527 1851 MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7794.
PCGS# 7513.
4556 1870-S AU-55 (NGC).
4528 1851 MS-61 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7812.
PCGS# 7513.
4529 1851-C AU Details—Improperly Cleaned (NGC).
PCGS# 7514.
4557 1872-S AU-55 (NGC).
PCGS# 7816.
4558 1878-S MS-61 (PCGS).
4530 1852 MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7829.
PCGS# 7517.
4531 1852 AU-55 (NGC). CAC—Gold Label. OH.
PCGS# 7517.
4559 1900 Unc Details—Tooled (PCGS).
PCGS# 7852.
4560 1901 MS-62 (PCGS).
4532 1852 AU-53 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7853.
PCGS# 7517.
4561 1903 MS-62 (NGC).
4533 1853 AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7855.
PCGS# 7521.
4562 1904 MS-62 (NGC).
4534 1853 AU Details—Bent (PCGS).
PCGS# 7856.
PCGS# 7521.
4563 1907 MS-63 (NGC).
4535 1853-O MS-62 (NGC).
PCGS# 7859.
PCGS# 7524.
4536 1854 Type II. AU-55 (PCGS). OGH—Second Generation.
PCGS# 7531.
4537 1854 Type II. AU Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 7531.
4538 1854 Type II. Genuine—Damage (PCGS). EF Details.
PCGS# 7531.
4564 1910 AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7941.
4565 1913 MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 7945.
4566 1913 MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 7945.
4567 1915 MS-63 (NGC). CAC.
4539 1855 Type II. AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 7948.
PCGS# 7532.
4540 1855 Type II. EF Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 7532.
4541 1856 Slant 5. AU-50 Details—Holed, Bent (ICG).
PCGS# 7540.
4568 1915 MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7948.
4569 1925-D MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7949.
4570 1928 MS-64 (NGC).
4542 1857 MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7952.
PCGS# 7544.
4543 1857 AU-55 (ANACS).
PCGS# 7544.
4544 1873 Open 3. AU Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 7573.
Three-Dollar Gold Pieces
4571 1854 AU-53 (NGC).
PCGS# 7969.
4545 1885 MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 7586.
PCGS# 7980.
4546 1885 MS-63 (NGC).
4573 1874 AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 7586.
Quarter Eagles
PCGS# 7998.
PCGS# 8000.
Half Eagles
4547 1836 McCloskey-5. Block 8. EF-40 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 97694.
4548 1843-O Small Date. AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7731.
4549 1851 MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 7759.
4575 1843 AU-58 (NGC).
PCGS# 8213.
4576 1844-O VF-20 (PCGS).
PCGS# 8222.
Page 275
4577 1861 AU-50 (PCGS).
4605 1908 Motto. MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 8288.
PCGS# 8859.
4578 1872-S EF-45 (NGC).
4606 1908-D Motto. Unc Details—Altered Surfaces (PCGS).
PCGS# 8327.
PCGS# 8860.
4579 1873-S EF-40 (NGC).
4607 1910 AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 8332.
PCGS# 8865.
4608 1932 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 8344.
PCGS# 8884.
Double Eagles
4581 1877-S EF-40 (NGC).
PCGS# 8344.
4582 1878 MS-62 (PCGS).
4609 1864-S VF Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 8345.
PCGS# 8942.
4583 1878-S MS-61 (PCGS). CAC. Secure Holder.
4610 1872 AU Details—Rim Filing (NGC).
PCGS# 8347.
PCGS# 8963.
4584 1879-S MS-62 (NGC).
4611 1891-S MS-60 (ICG).
PCGS# 8350.
PCGS# 9018.
4585 1880 MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 8351.
PCGS# 9018.
4586 1881 MS-63 (PCGS). CAC.
4613 1896-S AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 8354.
PCGS# 9030.
4587 1881 MS-61 (NGC).
PCGS# 8354.
PCGS# 9037.
4588 1881 Unc Details—Edge Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# 8354.
4589 1882-S MS-62 (PCGS).
4615 1901-S Unc Details—Tooled (PCGS).
PCGS# 8360.
PCGS# 9040.
May 1997, lot 1106.
4590 1887-S MS-62 (NGC).
PCGS# 8371.
4616 1903 MS-64 (NGC). OH.
4591 1892 MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 9043.
PCGS# 8379.
4617 1903 MS-64 (NGC). OH.
4592 1892-CC EF-40 (NGC).
PCGS# 9043.
PCGS# 8380.
4618 1903 MS-64 (NGC). OH.
4593 1895 MS-63+ (NGC).
PCGS# 9043.
PCGS# 8390.
4619 1903 MS-64 (NGC). OH.
4594 1895 MS-62 (NGC).
PCGS# 9043.
PCGS# 8390.
4620 1903 MS-64 (NGC). OH.
4595 1901/0-S FS-301. AU-55 (NGC).
PCGS# 9043.
PCGS# 8403.
4621 1904 MS-63 (PCGS).
4596 1907-D MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9045.
PCGS# 8417.
4622 1904 MS-62 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 9045.
PCGS# 8517.
4623 1907 Liberty. MS-62 (PCGS).
4598 1910-S AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9052.
PCGS# 8519.
4624 1907 Liberty. Unc Details—Cleaning (PCGS).
4599 1911 MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9052.
PCGS# 8520.
4600 1911-S AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 8522.
4601 1912-S AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9053.
From the El Dorado Collection, Part II. Earlier ex: Sierra, May 1991.
PCGS# 8524.
Eagles
4626 1908 No Motto. MS-62 (NGC).
PCGS# 9142.
4627 1908 Motto. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9147.
PCGS# 8691.
4603 1892-CC AU Details—Improperly Cleaned (NGC).
PCGS# 8722.
4604 1901 MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 8747.
Page 276
4628 1911-D/D FS-501, VP-001. Repunched Mintmark. MS-62
(NGC).
PCGS# 145010.
4629 1915-S MS-64 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 9168.
4630 1916-S MS-64+ (PCGS). CAC.
4655 1936-S Bay Bridge Opening, MS-65 (Uncertified), housed
in special distribution plastic holder #537/1000 with
picture and signature of designer Jacques Schnier.
PCGS# 9169.
4631 1922 MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9254.
PCGS# 9173.
4656 1935/34 Boone Bicentennial. MS-65 (PCGS).
4632 1922 AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9262.
PCGS# 9173.
4657 1936-D Boone Bicentennial. MS-66 (NGC).
4633 1924 MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 9267.
PCGS# 9177.
4658 1937 Boone Bicentennial. MS-66 (PCGS).
4634 1927 MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 9270.
PCGS# 9186.
4659 1936 Bridgeport, Connecticut Centennial. MS-66
(PCGS).
4635 1927 MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 9186.
PCGS# 9279.
4660 1936 Bridgeport, Connecticut Centennial. MS-64
(PCGS). OGH—Second Generation.
PCGS# 9186.
4637 1928 MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 9279.
PCGS# 9189.
Commemorative
Silver Coins
4638 1893 Isabella Quarter. MS-64 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 9220.
PCGS# 9281.
4662 1925-S California Diamond Jubilee. MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 9281.
4663 1925-S California Diamond Jubilee. MS-62 (NGC).
PCGS# 9281.
4664 1925-S California Diamond Jubilee. AU-58 (PCGS).
4639 1893 Isabella Quarter. MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 9281.
PCGS# 9220.
4640 1900 Lafayette Silver Dollar. MS-61 (NGC).
PCGS# 9222.
4641 1921 Alabama Centennial. 2x2. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9225.
4642 1921 Alabama Centennial. 2x2. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9225.
4643 1921 Alabama Centennial. Plain. MS-64 (PCGS). OGH—
First Generation.
PCGS# 9224.
4644 1921 Alabama Centennial. Plain. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9224.
4645 1936 Albany, New York Charter. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9227.
4646 1936 Albany, New York Charter. MS-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 9227.
4647 1936 Albany, New York Charter. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9227.
4648 1936 Albany, New York Charter. MS-64 (NGC). OH.
PCGS# 9227.
4649 1937 Antietam Anniversary. MS-65 (PCGS). OGH—First
Generation.
PCGS# 9229.
4650 1937 Antietam Anniversary. MS-64 (PCGS). OGH—
Second Generation.
PCGS# 9229.
4651 1937 Antietam Anniversary. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9229.
4652 1937 Antietam Anniversary. Unc Details—Cleaning
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9229.
4653 1935 Arkansas Centennial. MS-65 (NGC). The NGC
insert incorrectly lists the date as 1936.
PCGS# 9233.
4654 1936-S Bay Bridge Opening. MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 9254.
4661 1925-S California Diamond Jubilee. MS-66 (PCGS).
CAC.
4665 Lot of (3) Certified Commemorative Silver Half Dollars.
Included are: 1952 Carver/Washington Commemorative,
MS-65 (PCGS); 1936 Delaware Tercentenary, MS-66
(NGC), OH; and 1946-S Booker T. Washington Memorial,
MS-65 (PCGS).
The Delaware Tercentenary is ex: Starr.
4666 1936-D Cincinnati Music Center. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9284.
4667 1936 Cleveland Centennial/Great Lakes Exposition. MS66 (NGC).
PCGS# 9288.
4668 1936 Columbia, South Carolina Sesquicentennial. MS-66
(NGC). OH.
PCGS# 9291.
4669 1936-S Columbia, South Carolina Sesquicentennial. MS66+ (NGC).
PCGS# 9293.
4670 1892 Columbian Exposition. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9296.
4671 1893 Columbian Exposition. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9297.
4672 1935 Connecticut Tercentenary. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9299.
4673 1935 Connecticut Tercentenary, MS-65 (PCGS), with
original box of issue as distributed by the Hartford
National Bank and Trust Co. (Total: 2 items)
PCGS# 9299.
4674 1935 Connecticut Tercentenary. MS-63 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 9299.
4675 1935 Connecticut Tercentenary. MS-63 (NGC).
PCGS# 9299.
4676 1936 Delaware Tercentenary. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9301.
4677 1936 Delaware Tercentenary. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9301.
4678 1936 Elgin, Illinois Centennial. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9303.
Page 277
4679 1936 Elgin, Illinois Centennial. MS-65 (PCGS).
4704 1918 Lincoln-Illinois Centennial. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9303.
PCGS# 9320.
4680 1936 Gettysburg Anniversary. MS-65 (PCGS).
4705 1936 Long Island Tercentenary. MS-66 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 9305.
PCGS# 9322.
4681 1936 Gettysburg Anniversary. MS-65 (NGC).
4706 1936 Long Island Tercentenary. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9305.
PCGS# 9322.
4682 1936 Gettysburg Anniversary. MS-62 (PCGS).
4707 1936 Long Island Tercentenary. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9305.
PCGS# 9322.
4683 1936 Gettysburg Anniversary. Unc Details—Cleaning
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9305.
4684 1936 Gettysburg Anniversary. Unc Details—Cleaning
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9305.
4685 1922 Grant Memorial. No Star. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9306.
PCGS# 9322.
4710 1936 Long Island Tercentenary.
PCGS# 9306.
4688 1935 Hudson, New York Sesquicentennial. MS-64+
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9312.
4689 1935 Hudson, New York Sesquicentennial. MS-64
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9312.
4690 1935 Hudson, New York Sesquicentennial. MS-64 (NGC).
OH.
PCGS# 9312.
4691 1935 Hudson, New York Sesquicentennial. MS-62 (NGC).
PCGS# 9312.
From our (Bowers and Ruddy’s) Scott Collection sale, June 1975, lot
4692 1924 Huguenot-Walloon Tercentenary. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9314.
PCGS# 9314.
4694 1924 Huguenot-Walloon Tercentenary. MS-65 (NGC).
PCGS# 9314.
PCGS# 9314.
4696 1924 Huguenot-Walloon Tercentenary. MS-64 (NGC).
PCGS# 9314.
Details—
Ex: Heller Collection.
4712 1936 Lynchburg, Virginia Sesquicentennial. MS-65
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9324.
(NGC).
PCGS# 9324.
4714 1920 Maine Centennial. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9326.
4715 1920 Maine Centennial. MS-63 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 9326.
4716 1934 Maryland Tercentenary. MS-65 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 9328.
4717 1934 Maryland Tercentenary. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9328.
4718 1921 Missouri Centennial. 2x4. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9331.
4719 1921 Missouri Centennial. 2x4. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9331.
4720 1921 Missouri Centennial. 2x4. AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9331.
4721 1921 Missouri Centennial. Plain. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9330.
4722 1921 Missouri Centennial. Plain. MS-62 * (NGC).
PCGS# 9330.
4723 1923-S Monroe Doctrine Centennial. MS-64 (PCGS).
4697 1946 Iowa Centennial. MS-67+ (NGC). CAC.
PCGS# 9333.
PCGS# 9316.
4724 1938 New Rochelle, New York 250th Anniversary. MS-67
(PCGS).
4698 1946 Iowa Centennial. MS-67 (NGC).
PCGS# 9316.
PCGS# 9335.
4699 1946 Iowa Centennial. MS-67 (NGC).
(PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 9316.
4700 1946 Iowa Centennial. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9335.
PCGS# 9316.
Sesquicentennial.
MS-66
(PCGS).
MS-65
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9335.
PCGS# 9318.
Sesquicentennial.
PCGS# 9335.
PCGS# 9318.
Sesquicentennial.
MS-63
(NGC).
PCGS# 9335.
PCGS# 9318.
Page 278
Unc
PCGS# 9324.
4687 1922 Grant Memorial. No Star. Unc Details—Cleaning
(PCGS).
4703 1925 Lexington-Concord
(PCGS). OGH.
4709 1936 Long Island Tercentenary. MS-65 (NGC).
(PCGS).
4686 1922 Grant Memorial. No Star. MS-64 (NGC).
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9322.
PCGS# 9322.
PCGS# 9306.
(PCGS).
4708 1936 Long Island Tercentenary. MS-65 (NGC).
4729 1938 New Rochelle, New York 250th Anniversary, MS-64
(Uncertified), with original five-coin tab holder issued
by the New Rochelle Commemorative Coin Committee.
The tan holder is fully intact and in above average condition
with no significant detractions or foxing. (Total: 1 coin; 1 tab
holder)
PCGS# 9335.
4730 1936 Norfolk, Virginia Bicentennial. MS-66 (PCGS).
OGH.
PCGS# 9337.
4731 1936 Norfolk, Virginia Bicentennial. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9337.
PCGS# 9367.
4754 1937 Roanoke, North Carolina 350th Anniversary. MS-65
(PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 9367.
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9367.
(PCGS). CAC—Gold Label. OGH.
PCGS# 9367.
4732 1926 Oregon Trail Memorial. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9340.
4733 1936 Oregon Trail Memorial. MS-67 (NGC).
PCGS# 9345.
4734 1937-D Oregon Trail Memorial. MS-67 (NGC). CAC.
PCGS# 9347.
4735 1937-D Oregon Trail Memorial. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9347.
4736 1938 Oregon Trail Memorial. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9348.
4737 1938-D Oregon Trail Memorial. MS-67 (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 9349.
4738 1938-D Oregon Trail Memorial. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9349.
4739 1938-S Oregon Trail Memorial. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9350.
4740 1915-S Panama-Pacific Exposition. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9357.
4741 1920 Pilgrim Tercentenary. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9359.
4742 Lot of (2) 1920 Pilgrim Tercentenary. Unc Details—
Cleaning (PCGS).
PCGS# 9359.
4743 1921 Pilgrim Tercentenary. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9360.
4744 1921 Pilgrim Tercentenary. MS-63 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 9360.
4745 1936 Rhode Island Tercentenary. MS-66 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 9363.
4746 1936 Rhode Island Tercentenary. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9363.
4747 1936 Rhode Island Tercentenary. Unc Details—Cleaning
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9363.
4748 1936-D Rhode Island Tercentenary. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9364.
4749 1936-S Rhode Island Tercentenary. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9365.
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9367.
4751 1937 Roanoke, North Carolina 350th Anniversary. MS66+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 9367.
4752 1937 Roanoke, North Carolina 350th Anniversary. MS66+ (PCGS).
PCGS# 9367.
(PCGS).
(PCGS). OGH—First Generation.
PCGS# 9367.
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9367.
4759 1936 Robinson—Arkansas Centennial. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9369.
4760 1935-S San Diego, California Pacific International
Exposition. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9371.
4761 1935-S San Diego, California Pacific International
Exposition. Unc Details—Questionable Color (PCGS).
PCGS# 9371.
4762 1936-D San Diego, California Pacific International
Exposition. MS-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 9372.
4763 1936-D San Diego, California Pacific International
Exposition. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9372.
4764 1926 Sesquicentennial of American Independence. MS64+ (PCGS). CAC.
PCGS# 9374.
Ex: Guttag Family Collection.
4765 1926 Sesquicentennial of American Independence. MS64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9374.
4766 1926 Sesquicentennial of American Independence. MS64 (NGC).
PCGS# 9374.
4767 1926 Sesquicentennial of American Independence. MS63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9374.
4768 1925 Stone Mountain Memorial. MS-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 9378.
4769 1925 Stone Mountain Memorial. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9378.
4770 1925 Stone Mountain Memorial. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9378.
4771 1925 Stone Mountain Memorial.
Unc
Details—
PCGS# 9378.
4772 1925 Stone Mountain Memorial—Counterstamped
TENN. 169—EF-40 (Uncertified).
PCGS# 9378.
4773 1935 Texas Independence Centennial. MS-67 (PCGS).
CAC.
PCGS# 9382.
PCGS# 9382.
Page 279
4775 1935 Texas Independence Centennial. MS-66 (NGC).
PCGS# 9382.
PCGS# 9386.
PCGS# 9390.
PCGS# 9390.
PCGS# 9390.
4780 1937-D Texas Independence Centennial. MS-67 (PCGS).
CAC.
PCGS# 9391.
4781 1937-D Texas Independence Centennial. MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9391.
4782 1937-D Texas Independence Centennial. MS-64 (NGC).
CAC. OH.
PCGS# 9391.
4783 1937-S Texas Independence Centennial. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9392.
4784 1925 Fort Vancouver Centennial. MS-65 (PCGS). CAC.
OGH.
PCGS# 9399.
4785 1925 Fort Vancouver Centennial. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9399.
4786 1925 Fort Vancouver Centennial. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9399.
4787 1925 Fort Vancouver Centennial. MS-63 (PCGS). OGH.
PCGS# 9399.
4788 1927 Vermont Sesquicentennial. MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9401.
4789 1927 Vermont Sesquicentennial. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9401.
4790 1927 Vermont Sesquicentennial. MS-63 (PCGS). OGH—
First Generation.
PCGS# 9401.
4791 1927 Vermont Sesquicentennial. Unc Details—Cleaning
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9401.
4792 1950 Booker T. Washington Memorial. PDS Set. MS-66
(NGC). (Total: 3 coins)
4793 1936 Wisconsin Territorial Centennial. MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9447.
4794 1936 York County, Maine Tercentenary. MS-67 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9449.
PCGS# 9449.
4796 1936 York County, Maine Tercentenary. MS-66 (NGC).
OH.
PCGS# 9449.
PCGS# 9449.
4800 1903 Louisiana Purchase Exposition Gold Dollar.
McKinley Portrait. MS-64 (PCGS). This lot includes
a Manfra, Tordella & Brookes, Inc. “Integrity Seal” and
accompanying holder for this coin, identification number
USO-123178, additional number 02408, and signed by
Gerald Bauman. The seal and holder are available to the
winning bidder upon request to Stack’s Bowers Galleries
after the close of the auction.
PCGS# 7444.
4801 1915-S Panama-Pacific Exposition Gold Dollar. MS-63
(PCGS).
PCGS# 7449.
PCGS# 7454.
PCGS# 7454.
PCGS# 7455.
Quarter Eagle. MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# 7466.
Modern Commemoratives
4806 Lot of (4) Modern Commemorative Silver Dollars.
Proof-69 Deep Cameo (PCGS). Included are: 1990P Eisenhower Centennial; 1991-S United Service
Organizations; 1994-P Women in Military Service
Memorial; and 2002-W West Point Bicentennial.
4807 “1991-1995” (1993-W) 50th Anniversary of World War II
Gold $5. Proof-70 Ultra Cameo (NGC).
PCGS# 9679.
4808 1994-W World Cup Tournament Gold $5. Proof-70 Ultra
Cameo (NGC).
PCGS# 9685.
4809 1996-W XXVI Olympiad/Flag Bearer Gold $5. MS-69
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9736.
Ex: US Vault Collection.
4810 1996-W XXVI Olympiad/Cauldron Gold $5. MS-69
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9738.
4811 1996-W Smithsonian Institution 150th Anniversary Gold
$5. MS-69 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9744.
4812 1997-W Franklin D. Roosevelt Gold $5. MS-69 (PCGS).
PCGS# 9748.
4813 2002-W Salt Lake City Olympic Games Gold $5. MS-69
(PCGS).
PCGS# 9799.
PCGS# 9449.
OGH—Second Generation.
PCGS# 9449.
Commemorative Gold Coins
4814 2003-W First Flight Centennial Gold $10. MS-69 (PCGS).
PCGS# 21003.
4815 Lot of (6) 2005-P Marine Corps 230th Anniversary Silver
Dollars. Proof-69 Ultra Cameo (NGC).
PCGS# 921007.
Page 280
4816 Lot of (7) Modern Commemorative Silver Dollars.
MS-69 (NGC). Included are: 2006-P Benjamin Franklin
Tercentenary/Scientist; 2006-P Benjamin Franklin
Tercentenary/Founding Father; and (5) 2009-P Louis Braille
Bicentennial.
4817 2006-S San Francisco Old Mint Centennial Gold $5. MS69 (PCGS).
PCGS# 21012.
4833 2007 One-Ounce Gold Buffalo. Early Releases. MS-70
(NGC).
PCGS# 149122.
4834 2010-W One-Ounce Gold Buffalo. Proof-70 Deep Cameo
(PCGS).
PCGS# 418865.
4835 2010-W First Spouse Gold Bullion Coin. Abigail Fillmore.
MS-70 (PCGS).
PCGS# 418377.
4818 2007-W Jamestown 400th Anniversary Gold $5. MS-69
(PCGS).
PCGS# 147441.
4836 2010-W First Spouse Gold Bullion Coin. Abigail Fillmore.
MS-70 (PCGS).
PCGS# 418377.
4819 2008-W Bald Eagle Gold $5. MS-69 (PCGS).
PCGS# 394419.
4837 MMIX (2009) Ultra High Relief $20 Gold Coin. MS-69
(NGC).
PCGS# 407404.
4820 Lot of (7) 2009-P Louis Braille Bicentennial Silver
Dollars. Proof-69 Ultra Cameo (NGC).
PCGS# 408826.
4821 Lot of (9) 2010-P Boy Scouts of America Centennial
Silver Dollars. Proof-69 Ultra Cameo (NGC).
PCGS# 418539.
Bullion
4822 Lot of (17) Silver Eagles. MS-69 (NGC). Included are:
1987; 1988; 1990; 1991; 1992; 1993; 1998; 2000; 2001; 2002;
2003; 2004; 2005; 2007; 2008; 2009; and 2010.
4823 Lot of (8) Silver Eagles. MS-69. Included are: 1988 (ICG);
1993 (NGC); 2001 (NGC); (2) 2008 Early Releases (NGC);
2009 Early Releases (NGC); 2010 (PCGS); and 2010 Early
Releases (NGC).
4824 Lot of (6) 2011-Dated Silver Eagles. Included are: 2011 25th
Anniversary Set, MS-70 (NGC), NGC 25th Anniversary
Black Holder; 2011-(S) Early Releases, MS-70 (NGC); 2011W Early Releases, Proof-70 Ultra Cameo (NGC); 2011-W
Early Releases, Proof-69 Ultra Cameo (NGC); 2011-W 25th
Anniversary Set, First Strike, MS-70 (PCGS); and 2011-(W)
MS-70 (NGC).
4825 2011-P Silver Eagle. 25th Anniversary Set. First Strike.
John M. Mercanti Signature. Reverse Proof-70 (PCGS).
PCGS# 509194.
4826 2011-S Silver Eagle. 25th Anniversary Set. Early Releases.
MS-70 (NGC).
PCGS# 509189.
4827 2006-W Quarter-Ounce Gold Eagle. MS-69 (PCGS).
PCGS# 79982.
4828 2006-W Half-Ounce Gold Eagle. MS-69 (PCGS).
PCGS# 79983.
4829 2007-W Quarter-Ounce Gold Eagle. MS-69 (PCGS).
PCGS# 150429.
Pattern and
Experimental Coins
4838 “1876” (2011) George T. Morgan Proposed Design $100
Union. Private Issue. Silver. 69.70 mm. 5 ounces. 999
fine. Ultra Cameo Gem Proof. (NGC). The original velvet
pouch and information card are included. The supporting
items are available to the winning bidder upon request to
Stack’s Bowers Galleries after the close of the auction.
4839 “1876” (2011) George T. Morgan Proposed Design $100
Union. Private Issue. Silver. 69.70 mm. 5 ounces. 999
fine. Ultra Cameo Gem Proof. (NGC). The original velvet
pouch and information card are included. The supporting
items are available to the winning bidder upon request to
Stack’s Bowers Galleries after the close of the auction.
Mint Errors
4840 Undated (1856-1864) Copper-Nickel Cent Blank
Planchet. (NGC). 4.6 grams.
4841 1863 Indian Cent—Broadstruck Out of Collar—VG-10
(PCGS).
PCGS# E2067.
4842 1864 Indian Cent. Bronze. L on Ribbon—Struck 20% Off
Center—EF-40 BN (NGC).
4843 1882 Indian Cent—Double Struck, Second Strike 15%
Off Center—Fine-15 (PCGS).
PCGS# E2142.
4844 1896 Indian Cent—Struck 10% Off-Center—AU-58 BN
(NGC).
PCGS# 2193.
4845 1897 Indian Cent—Struck 10% Off-Center—EF Details—
Damaged (NGC).
PCGS# E2196.
4830 2007-W Half-Ounce Gold Eagle. MS-69 (PCGS).
PCGS# 150430.
4831 2013-W Tenth-Ounce Gold Eagle. Proof-70 Deep Cameo
(ANACS). The front of the ANACS holder is badly scuffed,
affecting viewing of the coin and making this piece a
candidate for reholdering should the winning bidder decide
to pursue that course of action with ANACS.
PCGS# 518207.
4832 2006-W One-Ounce Gold Buffalo. First Strikes. Proof-70
Ultra Cameo (NGC).
4846 18XX Indian Cent. Bronze—Struck 30% Off-Center—
EF-45 BN (NGC).
4847 1901 Indian Cent—Uncentered Broadstrike—AU-50
(PCGS).
PCGS# E2208.
4848 1908 Indian Cent—Double Struck—VG-8 BN (NGC).
4849 Undated Indian Cent—Struck 25% Off Center—EF-40
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11112.
PCGS# 799198.
Page 281
4850 1920 Lincoln Cent—Struck on a Thick Planchet—AU-50
BN (NGC). 3.5 grams.
4851 Undated Lincoln Cent. Zinc-Coated Steel—Full Brockage
Obverse—Unc Details—Environmental Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4852 1945 Lincoln Cent—Struck on a Netherland East Indies
Half Cent Planchet—MS-63 BN (NGC). 2.3 grams.
Cent Planchet—Unc Details—Scratches (NGC). 2.3
grams.
Cent Planchet—AU Details—Environmental Damage
(NGC). 2.3 grams.
4855 1945 Lincoln Cent—Double Clamshell Split Planchet—
EF Details—Damage (PCGS).
PCGS# E2734.
4856 1972-D Lincoln Cent—Struck Thru Split After Die Cap—
MS-63 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# E2955.
4857 1975-D Lincoln Cent—Double Struck, Second Strike 70%
Off Center—MS-62 BN (PCGS).
PCGS# E82979.
4858 1979-D Lincoln Cent—Double Struck Die Cap—MS-63
RB (PCGS).
PCGS# E38041.
4859 1980 Lincoln Cent—Struck Thru Late Die Cap—MS-63
RB (PCGS).
PCGS# E3000.
4860 1982 Lincoln Cent. Bronze. Large Date—Double Struck,
Second Strike 40% Off Center and Cupped—MS-65 RB
(PCGS).
PCGS# E146016.
4861 Undated Lincoln Cent. Memorial Reverse. Bronze—
Double Struck, Both Strikes Off Center, 70% and 98%—
MS-65 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
4862 1985 Lincoln Cent—Broadstruck Out of Collar—MS-64
RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E3071.
4863 1985 Lincoln Cent—Triple Struck, Second and Third
Strikes 25% and 85% Off Center—MS-64 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E3071.
4864 1987 Lincoln Cent—Foldover Strike—MS-64 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E3065.
4865 1987 Lincoln Cent—Obverse Die Cap—MS-63 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# E3065.
4866 1989 Lincoln Cent—Edge Strike at 3 O’Clock and Struck
50% Off-Center—MS-64 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E3077.
4867 198X Lincoln Cent—Partial Foldover Reverse Strike—
MS-64 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
4868 1996 Lincoln Cent—Double Struck, Large Broadstrike—
MS-65 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E3136.
4869 1996 Lincoln Cent—Flipover Double Struck, Second
Strike 50% Off Center—MS-64 RD (PCGS).
Page 282
PCGS# E3148.
4872 1998
Lincoln
Cent—Double
Broadstruck—MS-64 RD (PCGS).
Struck,
Hugely
PCGS# E3148.
4873 1998 Lincoln Cent—Struck on a Foreign Planchet—MS64 RD (PCGS). 27.4 grains.
PCGS# 3148.
4874 1998 Lincoln Cent—Triple Struck and Cupped—MS-64
RB (PCGS).
PCGS# E3147.
4875 1999 Lincoln Cent—Obverse Die Cap—MS-65 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# E3154.
4876 1999 Lincoln Cent—Double Struck Reverse Die Cap—
MS-65 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E3154.
4877 1999 Lincoln Cent—Two-Piece Bonded Die Cap—MS-65
RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E3154.
MS-64 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E3154.
4879 199X Lincoln Cent—Triple Struck, Second and Third
Saddle Strikes—MS-63 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
4880 19XX Lincoln Cent. Copper-Plated Zinc—Mated Pair—
MS-65 RD (PCGS). The coins are housed together in an
oversize PCGS holder. (Total: 2 coins)
PCGS# E11114.
4881 19XX Lincoln Cent. Memorial Reverse. Bronze—
Foldover Strike—MS-63 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# E11113.
MS-65 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E3160.
4883 2000 Lincoln Cent—Reverse Die Cap—MS-64 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# E3160.
4884 Undated Lincoln Cent. Memorial Reverse. Copper-Plated
Zinc—Double Struck, Second Strike 60% Off Center,
First Strike Cupped—MS-66 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
4885 Undated Lincoln Cent. Memorial Reverse. CopperPlated Zinc—Full Brockage and Broadstrike—MS-65 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
Zinc—100% Struck Thru and Broadstruck—MS-65 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
Zinc—100% Struck Thru and Broadstruck—MS-65 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
Zinc—Struck Thru Late Die Cap, Obverse Cupped—MS65 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
PCGS# E3136.
4870 1996 Lincoln Cent—Broadstruck Out of Collar—MS-63
RB (PCGS).
PCGS# E38113.
4871 1998 Lincoln Cent—Struck 20% Off Center, Full Brockage
Reverse—MS-65 RD (PCGS).
Zinc—Double Saddle Strike—MS-65 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
Zinc—Saddle Double Strike—MS-65 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
PCGS# E11111.
Zinc—Double Struck, Both 95% Off Center—MS-65 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
4892 Lot of (2) Undated Lincoln Cents. Memorial Reverse.
Copper-Plated Zinc—Double Saddle Strike—MS-65 RD
(PCGS). Both examples are individually encapsulated by
PCGS.
PCGS# E11114.
Zinc—Full Brockage and Broadstruck—MS-64 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
Zinc—Uniface Obverse Broadstrike—MS-64 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
Zinc—Obverse Brockage and Broadstruck—MS-64 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
Zinc—Detached Piece—MS-64 RD (PCGS). 1.4 grams.
PCGS# E11114.
Zinc—90% Obverse Brockage and Broadstruck—MS-64
RB (PCGS).
PCGS# E11113.
4898 Undated Lincoln Cent. Memorial Reverse. Bronze—
Foldover Strike—MS-64 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# E11113.
Zinc—Late Brockage and Huge Broadstrike—MS-63 RD
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
Zinc—Triple Saddle Strike—MS-63 RD (PCGS).
PCGS# E11114.
4901 Undated (1913-D) Buffalo Nickel. Type I—Reverse
Portion of Split Planchet—Good Details—Damage
(PCGS).
PCGS# E3916.
4902 1913-Dated Buffalo Nickel—Obverse Portion of Split
Planchet—Good Details—Scratch (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4903 1929-S Buffalo Nickel—Struck 5% Off Center—Fine-15
(PCGS).
PCGS# E3968.
4904 1942-P Jefferson Nickel. Type II—Clamshell Split
Planchet—VG-8 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4016.
4905 1943-Dated Jefferson Nickel—Obverse of Split Planchet—
Fine-12 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4906 Undated Philadelphia Mint Jefferson Nickel. Wartime
Silver Alloy—30% Ragged Clipped Planchet—MS-64
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
Silver Alloy—20% Clipped Planchet—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
Silver Alloy—Reverse of Split Planchet—Fine-12 (PCGS).
4909 1952-Dated Jefferson Nickel—Obverse of Split Planchet—
EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4046.
4910 Lot of (2) 1964 Jefferson Nickel Mint Errors—Mated
Pair—(PCGS). The coins are individually graded and
encapsulated by PCGS, as follows: MS-64; and MS-63.
PCGS# E4075.
4911 1964 Jefferson Nickel—Multi-Struck and Broadstruck,
Second Strike Uniface Reverse—MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4075.
4912 Lot of (2) 1964 Jefferson Nickel Mint Errors—Mated
Pair—(PCGS). The coins are individually graded and
encapsulated by PSGS, as follows: MS-62; and MS-64.
PCGS# E4075.
4913 1964 Jefferson Nickel—Retained Reverse Laminations—
VF-30 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4075.
4914 1980-P Jefferson Nickel—Struck on a Cent Planchet—
MS-63 RB (PCGS).
PCGS# E11113.
4915 1980-P Jefferson Nickel—Triple Struck, Second and Third
Strikes 75% and 90% Off Center—MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4104.
4916 1983-P Jefferson Nickel—Flipover Double Struck, 70%
Off Center—MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4110.
4917 1984-Dated Jefferson Nickel—40%
Broadstruck—MS-64 (PCGS).
Brockage
and
PCGS# E11111.
4918 1986-P Jefferson Nickel—Struck 40% Off Center and
Jammed Strike—MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4116.
4919 1995-P Jefferson Nickel—Double Strike, Second Strike
65% Off Center—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4136.
4920 1996-P Jefferson Nickel—80% Brockage and Huge
Broadstrike—MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4137.
4921 Lot of (2) 1996-P Jefferson Nickel Mint Errors. (PCGS).
Included are: 20% Obverse Brockage and Broadstruck—
MS-65; and 15% Obverse Brockage and Partial Collar—MS63.
PCGS# E4137.
4922 1999-P Jefferson Nickel—Obverse
Brockage
and
PCGS# E4144.
4923 1999-P Jefferson Nickel—Double Struck, Both Off Center
20% and 50%—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E4144.
4924 Lot of (2) 199X Jefferson Nickel Mint Errors—Mated
Pair—MS-64 (PCGS). The coins are individually
encapsulated by PCGS.
PCGS# E11111.
4925 2000-P Jefferson Nickel—Obverse Die Cap—MS-65
(PCGS).
PCGS# E4146.
4926 Undated Jefferson Nickel—80% Brockage and Partial
Collar—MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
Page 283
4927 Undated Jefferson Nickel—80% Brockage and Huge
4928 Undated Jefferson Nickel—Full Brockage and Large
PCGS# E11111.
4929 Undated Jefferson Nickel—Obverse Brockage and
4930 Undated Jefferson Nickel—Struck 35% Off Center on a
16% Straight End Clipped Planchet—MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4931 Undated Jefferson Nickel—60%
Brockage
and
PCGS# E11111.
4932 Undated Jefferson Nickel—90%
Brockage
and
PCGS# E11111.
4933 Undated Jefferson Nickel—Triple Struck, Strikes 40%,
80% and 90% Off Center—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4934 Undated Jefferson Nickel—Obverse Brockage and
PCGS# E11111.
4935 Undated Jefferson Nickel—Multi-Struck and Broadstruck,
Second Strike Uniface Reverse—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4936 Undated Jefferson Nickel—60% Off Center Obverse
Brockage—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4937 Undated Jefferson Nickel—Struck 40% Off Center on a
22% Straight End Clipped Planchet—MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4938 Undated Jefferson Nickel—100% Late Stage Brockage—
AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4939 Undated Jefferson Nickel—Reverse of Split Planchet—
EF-40 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4940 Lot of (3) Mercury Dime Mint Errors. (NGC). Included
are: 1918-D—Cracked Planchet @ 9 O’Clock—AU-58;
1931-D—Planchet Crack @ 6 O’Clock—MS-62 FB; and
1943—15% Curved Clip—EF-45.
4941 1940 Mercury Dime—Uncentered Broadstrike—MS-62
(PCGS).
PCGS# E5022.
4942 1941-S Mercury Dime—Partial Collar—MS-63 (NGC).
4943 1942 Mercury Dime—Struck 10% Off Center—MS-62 FB
(NGC).
4944 1942 Mercury Dime—Broadstruck on a 24% Clipped
Planchet—MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5034.
4945 1944 Mercury Dime—Struck 10% Off Center, Obverse
Struck Thru—MS-64 (NGC).
4946 1944 Mercury Dime—Broadstruck—Unc Details—
Reverse Wheel Mark (NGC).
4947 1945 Mercury Dime—Partial Collar—MS-65 (NGC).
4948 1945 Mercury Dime—Broadstruck—Unc Details—
4949 1945 Mercury Dime—Broadstruck on a Type I Planchet—
Unc Details—Scratch (PCGS).
PCGS# E5056.
Page 284
4950 1953-S Roosevelt Dime—20% Clipped Planchet and
PCGS# E5105.
4951 1956 Roosevelt Dime—15%
Straight
Clip
and
PCGS# E5112.
4952 1964 Roosevelt Dime—4% Ragged End Clip and
PCGS# E5128.
4953 Undated Roosevelt Dime.
Brockage—MS-64 (PCGS).
Silver—Full
Obverse
PCGS# E11111.
4954 1965 Roosevelt Dime—Struck on a Thick Planchet—Unc
Details—Edge Damage (NGC). 2.9 grams.
4955 1973-D Roosevelt Dime—Struck on 47% Scrap Planchet—
MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5144.
4956 1974 Roosevelt Dime—40% Early Brockage—MS-65
(PCGS).
PCGS# E5145.
4957 1977-D Roosevelt Dime—Obverse Die Cap—MS-66
(PCGS).
PCGS# E5152.
4958 Lot of (3) Roosevelt Dime Mint Errors. (PCGS). Included
are: 1979-D—Struck 10% Off-Center on a 7% Straight
Clipped Planchet—MS-63; 1981-D—Struck on a 38%
Clipped Planchet—MS-63; and 1983-P—Struck 12% Off
Center on a 7% Clipped Planchet—MS-64.
4959 1983-P Roosevelt Dime—Struck on Scrap Planchet—MS64 (PCGS). 12.5 grains.
PCGS# E5164.
4960 1984-D Roosevelt Dime—Struck 65% Off Center and
Brockage Reverse—MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5167.
4961 1992-D Roosevelt Dime—Struck Thru Late State Capped
Die—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5183.
4962 1994-P
Roosevelt
Dime—40%
Brockage
and
PCGS# E5186.
4963 1994-P Roosevelt Dime—40% Indent and Broadstruck—
MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5186.
4964 Lot of (4) Roosevelt Dime Mint Errors. (PCGS). Included
are: 1994-D—12% Clipped Planchet and Broadstruck—
Unc Details—Machine Damage; 1996-P—Struck 15%
Off-Center on a 12% Clipped Planchet—MS-64; 1998-P—
Struck 10% Off-Center on a 12% Clipped Planchet—MS-64;
and 1998-P—50% Clipped Planchet and Broadstruck—MS63.
4965 1996-P Roosevelt Dime—20% Indent and Broadstruck—
MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5191.
4966 1996-P Roosevelt Dime—45% Reverse Brockage and
PCGS# E5191.
4967 1996-P Roosevelt Dime—25% Obverse Brockage and
PCGS# E5191.
4968 1996-P
Roosevelt
Dime—10%
PCGS# E5191.
Brockage
and
4969 1998-P
Roosevelt
Dime—Multi-Struck
and
PCGS# E5195.
4970 19XX Roosevelt Dime—Struck on
Planchet—MS-65 (PCGS). 26 grains.
an
Elliptical
PCGS# E11111.
4971 19XX-P Roosevelt Dime—Cupped Broadstrike Out of
Collar—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4972 2000-P Roosevelt Dime—60% Indent and Large
PCGS# E5199.
4973 Undated Roosevelt Dime. Copper-Nickel Clad—Late
Stage Brockage and Broadstruck—MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4974 Undated Roosevelt Dime. Copper-Nickel Clad—Full
Brockage and Broadstruck—MS-66 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4975 Undated Roosevelt Dime. Copper-Nickel Clad—Full
Obverse Brockage—MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4976 Undated Roosevelt Dime. Copper-Nickel Clad—85%
Obverse Brockage and Broadstruck—MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4977 Undated Roosevelt Dime. Copper-Nickel Clad—25%
Brockage Obverse and Broadstruck—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4978 Undated Roosevelt Dime. Copper-Nickel Clad—Late
Stage Obverse Brockage—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4979 Lot of (5) Undated Roosevelt Dime Mint Errors. CopperNickel Clad. (PCGS). Included are: Struck 35% Off Center
on a 28% Straight Clipped Planchet—MS-64; Struck 80%
Off Center on a 3% Clipped Planchet—MS-64; Struck 70%
Off Center on a 2% Clipped Planchet—MS-63; Struck 80%
Off Center—MS-63; and Struck 60% Off Center—MS-63.
4980 Undated Roosevelt Dime. Copper-Nickel Clad—Obverse
85% Struck Thru Layer—MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
4981 Undated Roosevelt Dime—Struck on Scrap Planchet—
MS-62 (PCGS). 3.1 grains.
PCGS# E11111.
4982 1960 Washington Quarter—4% Ragged End Clip—AU53 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5868.
4983 1964 Washington Quarter—Reverse Struck Thru Silver
Piece—MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5876.
4984 1964-D Washington Quarter—10% Ragged End Clip—
AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5877.
4985 1965 Washington Quarter—Incomplete Punched
Planchet and 3% Double Clip Planchet—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5878.
4986 1965 Washington Quarter—Obverse Portion of a
Detached Planchet Layer—MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5878.
4987 1966 Washington Quarter—21% Triple Clip Planchet and
PCGS# E5879.
4988 Lot of (3) 1967 Washington Quarter Mint Errors. (PCGS).
Included are: 45% Clipped Planchet and Broadstruck—MS65; 30% Clipped Planchet and Broadstruck—MS-63; and
Reverse 99% Struck-Thru Detached Clad Layer—AU-55.
PCGS# E5880.
4989 1967 Washington Quarter—Partial Obverse Clamshell
Split Planchet—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5880.
4990 1968-D Washington Quarter—Struck on 52% Scrap
PCGS# E5882.
4991 1976 Washington Quarter—Double Struck, Second
Strike 90% Off Center—MS-61 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5896.
4992 (1976) Washington Quarter. Copper-Nickel Clad—Struck
PCGS# E11111.
4993 1977 Washington Quarter—25% Double
Planchet and Broadstruck—MS-67 (PCGS).
Clipped
PCGS# E5902.
4994 1978 Washington Quarter—Partial Reverse Clamshell
Split Planchet—AU-50 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5904.
4995 1979 Washington Quarter—Struck on a Nickel Planchet—
MS-61 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5906.
4996 1983-P Washington Quarter—Double Struck, Second
PCGS# E5914.
4997 1984-P Washington Quarter—Double Struck Large
Broadstrike, Uniface Second Strike Obverse—MS-65
(PCGS).
PCGS# E5916.
4998 Lot of (2) Washington Quarter Mint Errors. CopperNickel Clad. AU-58 (PCGS). Included are: 1985-P—5%
Indent and Partial Collar; and 19X5-P—Double Struck,
Second Strike 80% Off Center.
4999 1988-P Washington Quarter—100% Struck Thru
Obverse—AU-55 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5924.
5000 Lot of (3) Washington Quarter Mint Errors. (PCGS).
Included are: 1993-D—15% Straight End Clip—MS-64;
1997-P—31% Clipped Planchet and Partial Collar—MS-66;
and Undated, Copper-Nickel Clad—38% Clipped Planchet
and Partial Collar—MS-63.
5001 1995-P Washington Quarter—Double Struck Large
Broadstrike, Uniface Second Strike Obverse—. MS-67
(PCGS).
PCGS# E5938.
5002 Lot of (3) 1995-Dated Washington Quarter Mint Errors.
(PCGS). Included are: 1995-P—Double Struck, First Strike
20% off Center, Second Strike 90% Off Center—MS-65;
1995-P—20% Obverse Indent and Partial Collar—MS-62;
and 1995-Dated—Double Struck, Both Strikes 85% Off
Center—MS-63.
5003 1995-P Washington Quarter—20% Brockage Obverse
and Partial Collar—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5938.
5004 1995-P Washington Quarter—15% Brockage Obverse
and Partial Collar—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5938.
Page 285
5005 1996-P Washington Quarter—37% Straight End Clip and
Struck 10% Off Center—MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5960.
5006 Lot of (3) Washington Quarter Mint Errors. (PCGS).
Included are: 1997-P—Broadstruck on a 21% Straight End
Clipped Planchet—MS-63; 1998-Dated—Double Struck,
Second Strike 70% Off Center and Uniface Reverse—MS64; and 1998-Dated—Struck on a 10% Defective Planchet—
MS-64.
5007 Lot of (2) 1998-P Washington Quarter Mint Errors. MS66 (PCGS). Included are: 10% Brockage and Broadstruck;
and Struck 25% Off Center, 15% Indent Reverse.
PCGS# E5942.
5008 1998-P Washington Quarter—Struck on a 38% Straight
End Clipped Planchet—MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5942.
5009 1998-P Washington Quarter—8% End of Strip Clipped
PCGS# E5942.
Double Struck, Second Strike Obverse Brockage—MS-66
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
5011 Undated Philadelphia Mint Washington Quarter.
Copper-Nickel Clad—Struck on a 65% Scrap Planchet—
MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
5012 Undated Denver Mint Washington Quarter. CopperNickel Clad—Struck on a 38% Straight End Clipped
PCGS# E11111.
5013 Undated Denver Mint Washington Quarter. CopperNickel Clad—Struck on Planchet Scrap—MS-65 (PCGS).
14 grains.
PCGS# E11111.
Struck on a 26% Straight End Clipped Planchet—MS-65
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
Quadruple Struck on Scrap—MS-64 (PCGS). 9.25 grains.
PCGS# E11111.
Struck on Planchet Scrap—MS-64 (PCGS). 23 grains.
PCGS# E11111.
Uniface Reverse Strike on a 56% Scrap Planchet—MS-64
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
5018 Undated Denver Mint Washington Quarter. CopperNickel Clad—Struck on a 45% Quadruple Clipped
PCGS# E11111.
Struck 70% Off Center on a 47% Straight End Clipped
Planchet, Brockage Reverse—MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
Struck 70% Off Center on a Detached Clad Layer—MS-63
(PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
5021 Lot of (2) Undated Washington Quarter Mint Errors.
Copper-Nickel Clad. (PCGS). Included are: Struck 60%
Off Center and Obverse Indent—MS-63; and 15% Straight
Clip and Partial Collar—MS-61.
5022 Undated Denver Mint Washington Quarter. CopperNickel Clad—Double Struck, Second Strike 70% Off
Center—MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
5023 1999-D Statehood Quarter. Delaware—22% Triple Clip
Planchet, Broadstruck—MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5945.
5024 (1999)-D Statehood Quarter. New Jersey—Struck 50%
PCGS# E5945.
5025 1999-P Statehood Quarter. New Jersey—60% Brockage
Obverse—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5948.
5026 1999-P Statehood Quarter. New Jersey—Double Struck,
Second Strike 50% Off Center—MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E5948.
5027 1999-P Statehood Quarter. Connecticut—Multiple
Struck—MS-64 (NGC).
5028 1999-P Statehood Quarter. Connecticut—Triple Struck—
MS-64 (NGC).
5029 2000-P Statehood Quarter. South Carolina—Struck 25%
PCGS# E5958.
5030 (2000)-P Statehood Quarter. New Hampshire—Struck
PCGS# E5962.
5031 2000-Dated Statehood Quarter. Virginia—Struck 10%
Off Center on a 30% Clipped Planchet—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
5032 Undated Philadelphia Mint Statehood Quarter—Uniface
Obverse, Double Struck, Both Off Center, 25% and 50%—
MS-64 (PCGS). The PCGS insert incorrectly labels this
piece as a uniface reverse strike, but it is the reverse of the
coin that is blank.
PCGS# E11111.
5033 1964 Kennedy Half Dollar—12% Ragged End Clipped
PCGS# E6706.
5034 1964 Kennedy Half Dollar—6% Defect and Cracked
PCGS# E6706.
5035 1967 Kennedy Half Dollar—Clamshell Split Planchet—
MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6710.
5036 1967 Kennedy Half Dollar—Retained Split Layer
Obverse—MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6710.
5037 1967 Kennedy Half Dollar—30% Defective Obverse
Layer—AU-58 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6710.
5038 1968-D Kennedy Half Dollar—Clamshell Split Planchet—
MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6711.
5039 1971-D Kennedy Half Dollar—6% Straight End Clip and
Partial Collar—MS-62 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6717.
5040 1974 Kennedy Half Dollar—34% Clipped Planchet—AU58 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6722.
Page 286
5041 1976-D Kennedy Half Dollar. Copper-Nickel Clad—
Struck 5% Off Center—MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6727.
5062 1979-S Anthony Dollar—5% Double Clipped Planchet—
MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E9573.
5042 1976-D Kennedy Half Dollar. Copper-Nickel Clad—15%
Indent and Partial Collar—MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6727.
5063 1979-Dated Anthony Dollar—15% Clipped Planchet—
MS-64 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
5043 1977 Kennedy Half Dollar—Clamshell Split Layers—AU58 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6731.
5064 1979-Dated Anthony Dollar—27% Straight End Clipped
PCGS# E11111.
5044 1979 Kennedy Half Dollar—Uncentered Broadstrike—
MS-63 (PCGS).
PCGS# E6735.
5065 1999-P Anthony Dollar—Flipover Double Struck, Second
PCGS# E9581.
5045 197X-D Kennedy Half Dollar—22% Clipped Planchet—
MS-65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
5066 Undated Anthony Dollar—28% Clipped Planchet—MS65 (PCGS).
PCGS# E11111.
5046 1985-Dated Kennedy Half Dollar—Double Struck,
Second Strike 70% Of

The Official Auction of the Whitman Coin and Collectibles Baltimore

Transcription

Similar documents

Barry County regional stockyards opens under new owners

rare gold. rare prices.

Full Step Jefferson Nickels: A Re-Evaluation - Biblical

May 27, 2014 - Amazon Web Services

August 11, 2015 - Amazon Web Services

our mojito recipe

NGC Certifies A 1928 Standing Liberty Quarter Struck On A Cent

precious metals at a glance

Rarities Night catalog - Stack`s Bowers Galleries

Executive Currency