DOYON-Nortech-FAI_FNSB_Ben_Eielson_Jr

Transcription

ENERGY AUDIT – FINAL REPORT
Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School
675 Ravens Way
Eielson AFB, Alaska
Prepared for:
Mr. Larry Morris
Fairbanks North Star Borough School District
July 31, 2012
Acknowledgment: "This material is based upon work supported by the Department of
Energy under Award Number DE-EE0000095.”
Managing Office
2400 College Road
Fairbanks, Alaska 99709
p. 907.452.5688
f. 907.452.5694
3105 Lakeshore Dr. Suite 106A
Anchorage, Alaska 99517
p. 907.222.2445
f. 907.222.0915
www.nortechengr.com
4402 Thane Road
Juneau, Alaska 99801
p: 907.586.6813
f: 907.586.6819
ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING, HEALTH & SAFETY
Anchorage: 3105 Lakeshore Dr, Ste 106A, 99503 907.222.2445 Fax: 222.0915
Juneau: 4402 Thane Rd, 99801 907.586.6813 Fax: 586.6819
Fairbanks: 2400 College Rd, 99709 907.452.5688 Fax: 452.5694
info@nortechengr.com
www.nortechengr.com
As a Technical Service Provider (TSP) to the Alaska Housing Finance Corporation (AHFC) under Task
Order 4, NORTECH has completed an Investment Grade Audit (IGA) of Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School
in Eielson AFB, Alaska. This work was funded by AHFC through the American Recovery and
Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA).
Due to the scheduling requirements for completion of the IGAs and to provide a more thorough review
of certain mechanical systems, NORTECH sub-contracted RS Consulting for the primary energy audit
services for Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School. RS Consulting is owned and operated by Ray Sneeringer,
a licensed Mechanical Engineer in the State of Washington and most of the audit field work was
completed by Sandra Edwards, a Certified Energy Manager (CEM) and owner of Edwards Energy
Environmental and Waste Management.
RS Consulting’s IGA methodology generally followed that outlined in the REAL Manual for an IGA. RS
Consulting used Trane Trace 700 to model Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School due to the more complex
systems found in this facility. This report evaluates a few major EEMs and ECMs, which are generally
consistent with NORTECH’s overall findings that FNSB SD facilities are well-maintained and welloperated with few areas for significant potential energy savings.
While NORTECH agrees with the recommendations for the EEM/ECM packages, the cost estimates
appear to be somewhat lower than expected from local vendors. Since the recommended upgrade(s)
involve specific pieces of equipment and installation methods, NORTECH recommends the FNSB SD
obtain project-specific quotes or bids from local vendors before approving the specific project. Due to
rapid advancements of lighting technologies, project-specific lighting retrofits should be designed no
more than six months prior to retrofitting in order to achieve the best technology and maximum savings.
NORTECH believes some additional energy and cost savings may be achievable in particular areas of
the building. The data necessary to evaluate these upgrades is outside the scope of work of this IGA,
but could most likely be collected relatively easily using the mechanical system controls and/or some
dataloggers. Specific areas that have the potential for additional energy and cost savings include:
1)
2)
3)
4)
Plug load retrofits (ex: replacing old refrigerators, placing vending machines on timers)
Occupancy sensors in the gymnasium to go along with the proposed lighting retrofit
De-lamping areas of high foot-candles if lighting replacement isn’t performed
Domestic hot water generation and use (ex: low flow/automatic fixtures, solar water heating)
While this report differs from the format of other NORTECH reports produced for AHFC and the FNSB
SD, NORTECH has reviewed the work of RS Consulting and determined this report is complete and
accurately depicts the energy use of the building. Any future questions, comments, or correspondence
regarding this report should be addressed to the undersigned.
Sincerely,
NORTECH
Peter Beardsley, PE, CEA
Principal
F:\00-Jobs\2011\2602 F - AHFC Grade Audits\50-100 Doyon Fairbanks Region\50-127 FNSB SD Ben Eielson Jr
Sr\Reports\Final\Ben Eielson-Cover-Letter-V4.Docx
RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska ENERGY USE AUDIT REPORT FOR ALASKA HOUSING FINANCE CORPORATION Client: Prepared by: Principal Investigators: Prepared for: Alaska Housing Finance Corporation Research and Rural Development Division P.O. Box 101020 Anchorage, Alaska 99510 Attention: Ms. Rebekah Lührs RS Consulting 2400 NW 80th Street, Suite 178 Seattle, Washington 98117 Telephone: (206) 368‐1784 Edwards Energy Environmental & Waste Management PO Box 2110 Issaquah, Washington 98027 Telephone: (206) 303‐0121 Ray W. Sneeringer, PE Sandra F. Edwards, CEM, CDSM NORTECH Sustainable Environmental Engineering, Health, & Safety 2400 College Road Fairbanks, Alaska 99709 Telephone: (907) 452‐5688 July 30, 2012 Page 1 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND DISCLAIMER Acknowledgment: We would like to acknowledge and extend our heartfelt gratitude to the Department of Energy. This material is based upon work supported by the Department of Energy under Award Number DE‐
EE0000095. Disclaimer: This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States Government. Neither the United States Government nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States Government or any agency thereof. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States Government or any agency thereof. July 30, 2012 Page 2 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................................. 4 2.0 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................... 6 3.0 BUILDING DESCRIPTION ............................................................................................................... 8 4.0 ENVELOPE .................................................................................................................................... 9 5.0 LIGHTING ................................................................................................................................... 12 6.0 MECHANICAL ............................................................................................................................. 16 7.0 ENERGY USE .............................................................................................................................. 19 8.0 ENERGY MEASURES ................................................................................................................... 20 9.0 ENERGY MEASURE DESCRIPTIONS ............................................................................................. 22 10.0 SIMPLE PAYBACK AND SIR ......................................................................................................... 25 11.0 OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE ............................................................................................. 26 12.0 RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................................................................................ 27 APPENDICES
APPENDIX A ...................................................................................................... ENERGY UTILIZATION INDEX APPENDIX B ........................................................................................................................... COST ESTIMATE APPENDIX C ........................................................................................................... LIGHTING CALCULATIONS APPENDIX D .................................................................................................... MECHANICAL CALCULATIONS APPENDIX E ..................................................................................................................... SYSTEM DIAGRAMS APPENDIX F ............................................................................................................ EQUIPMENT SCHEDULES APPENDIX G ........................................................................................................................ TRACE 700 INPUT APPENDIX H ..................................................................................................................... TRACE 700 OUTPUT APPENDIX I ......................................................................................................... TREND LOG INFORMATION APPENDIX J ............................................................................................................................... FLOOR PLANS July 30, 2012 Page 3 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska 1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Background This energy audit report was prepared by RS Consulting and Edwards Energy Environmental & Waste Management in conjunction with NORTECH Sustainable Environmental Engineering, Health, & Safety for the Alaska Housing Finance Corporation. The Ben Eilson Jr/Sr High School is a 106,800 square foot facility located on Eielson Air Force Base, Alaska. The building serves 7th through 12th grade junior and senior high school students and consists of classrooms, shops, a theater, two gymnasiums, administrative offices, and other miscellaneous support functions. Scope This Level II Energy Audit focused on the building’s envelope, lighting, and heating/ventilation (HV) systems. The audit began with a review of existing utility bills and generation of the building’s Energy Utilization Index (EUI). Several on‐site reviews were conducted to examine the existing building systems and the most current construction drawings were reviewed to determine the configuration and sequencing of the mechanical systems. Once this information was gathered, the audit included identification of potential energy saving measures (ECMs/EEMS), creation of a computer simulation model to examine the energy saving measures, generation of a schematic level estimate of the installed costs of the measures and calculation of relative pay backs for each measure examined. The Trane Trace 700 computer program was used to model the existing building’s energy consumption. The energy consumption values predicted by the model were then compared to actual energy consumption as shown in utility bills from 2009 and 2010. The computer model was then “tuned” to match the actual energy consumption as closely as possible. Energy Use Index Two years of utility bills were examined to determine the current energy consumption of the facility. The Energy Use Index (EUI) for this facility is 90 kBTU/SF. The chart below compares the existing and proposed EUI for the building with the EPA Energy Star design target value for a similar building in this location. This target value was developed using the Energy Star Target Finder software and represents the design criteria for a 50% Energy Star Rated Building, rather than the median value for existing K‐12 Schools. July 30, 2012 Page 4 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska Energy Consumption The majority of the facility’s energy consumption can be attributed to the energy required to heat the outside ventilation air as it is introduced into the building. Any effort to conserve energy should start with an examination of the operation of the ventilation system. Utility Costs The annual utility cost predicted by the energy model for the existing building is $274,150. The estimated utility cost after implementation of the recommended Energy Efficiency Measures (EEM) is $233,040 for an annual savings of $41,110. A breakdown of the current and proposed energy costs is presented in the following charts: Recommendations An inspection and monitoring the outside air dampers of each air handling unit should be performed in order to reduce the amount of outside air being introduced into the facility to current code minimums during cold weather and to eliminate the introduction of outside air into the facility during unoccupied hours. We also recommend implementation of the Energy Efficiency Measures listed in the table below. Implementation of these measures should be accompanied by a more detailed Level III analysis, which should include operational data logging, detailed engineering drawings and cost estimates, and a plan for future monitoring and verification of the performance of the installed measure. BEN EIELSON JR/SR HIGH SCHOOL ‐ Recommended Measures Tag Measure Description ECM‐C Cold Run Set Point Mod EEM‐1 Lighting Upgrades EEM‐2 Add VSDs on Jr High Gym Cost Payback (Yrs) SIR $1,000 0.1 99.2
$265,800 8.9 1.6
$15,000 3.5 4.1
Please refer the body of this report for additional information on these Energy Efficiency Measures. July 30, 2012 Page 5 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska 2.0 INTRODUCTION This energy audit report has been prepared by RS Consulting (RSC) and Edwards Energy Environmental & Waste Management (EEEWM) in conjunction with NORTECH Sustainable Environmental Engineering, Health, & Safety for the Alaska Housing Finance Corporation (AHFC). RSC and EEEWM audited Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School in an effort to find cost effective opportunities to reduce building energy consumption. The Energy Conservation Measures (ECMs) and Energy Efficiency Measures (EEMs) analyzed in‐depth as part of the contract included several mechanical system improvements. Two classifications of energy saving measures were examined during this energy audit. The first is a low cost or no cost solution designed to save energy by making changes to occupant activities, schedules, control set points, or small upgrades to existing equipment. This type of measure is identified in this report as an Energy Conservation Measure (ECM). The second type of energy saving measure requires significant capital investment to achieve energy savings. This is referred to as an Energy Efficiency Measure (EEM). This Level II Energy Audit focused on the building’s envelope, lighting, and Heating and Ventilation (HV) systems. A level II energy audit includes a survey of the building and a breakdown of the energy end uses within the building. This audit identifies and examines practical ECMs and EEMs to determine the potential energy savings realized if the measure is enacted. It also serves to identify potential improvements that may require the more thorough data collection and detailed engineering drawings and estimates which typically occur in a Level III audit. The scope of work for this audit consisted of an on‐site review of the existing facility, a review of the most current construction drawings, identification of potential Energy Conservation Measures (ECMs) and Energy Efficiency Measures (EEMS), creation of a computer simulation model to examine these EEMs, and a schematic level estimate of the installed costs and relative pay backs for each measure examined. The audit team inspected the building during preliminary stages of the energy audit. The purpose of this field visit was to verify the configuration of the existing mechanical equipment and to assess its condition. Information was also gathered on the size and efficiency of the existing accessible mechanical system motors. A list of major mechanical equipment used in this facility can be found in Appendix F. We also performed a review of the building envelope to identify any potential areas for possible improvement in energy performance and documented the type and number of lighting fixtures used throughout the facility to in order to identify opportunities to improve the performance of the lighting system. Two years of utility bills were analyzed to determine the energy performance of the existing building in order to match the existing use with the use predicted by the computer model. Potential EEMs were identified and examined via the computer model or spreadsheet calculations. The predicted energy savings of these measures were then compared to the estimated installation cost to determine the relative pay back of each measure. A building energy model was used to validate a number of proposed EEMs. The Trane Trace 700 computer program was used to model the existing building’s energy consumption. The energy consumption values predicted by the model were then compared to actual energy consumption as shown in utility bills from 2009 and 2010. The computer model was then “tuned” to match the actual July 30, 2012 Page 6 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska energy consumption as closely as possible. This baseline was used to predict the energy savings realized by the proposed EEMs. The existing building energy use, as predicted by the computer model is shown in Figure 1. Figure 1: Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School: Energy Use by System Heating energy comprises72% of the energy used in the school. This is consistent with the extremely low temperatures experienced during the subarctic winters in Fairbanks. This heating energy consists of an oil component, which is the oil used by the boilers and the domestic hot water generators, and an electrical component, which is the electricity used by the boiler’s ancillary equipment, such as the oil pump, the burner fan and miscellaneous electrical controls. The cost of steam is significantly less than the cost of electricity per unit of energy ($.019/mbtu vs. $.052/mbtu) so although the heating system consumes 72% of the building energy, it represents only 47% of the total utility bills. Figure 2 shows the actual cost of the energy consumed by the facility. Figure 2: Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School: Energy Cost by System July 30, 2012 Page 7 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska The heating load consists of the heat lost across the building envelope and the heat used to warm outside air as it enters the building. This outside air is necessary to provide make up air for the building’s exhaust fans and ventilation air for the occupants. The breakdown of the total heat load of the school is shown in Figure 3. Figure 3: Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School: Building Heating Loads by Component It can be concluded from the preceding charts, that efforts to conserve energy in the facility should begin with an examination of the ventilation air system. Please refer to Section 9.0 of this report for a more detailed discussion of this ventilation system. Information in this study has focused on the areas of building envelope, lighting, and HVAC. Please reference subsequent sections of this audit report for detail information on the Energy Conservation Measures (ECMs), Energy Efficiency Measures (EEMs), calculation methodologies, and a summary of the findings and recommendations. 3.0 BUILDING DESCRIPTION Ben Eielson Junior‐Senior High School is a one‐story 103,200 square foot facility located on the Eielson Air Force Base (AFB) located in Alaska. The high school was originally constructed in 1962 and was 27,985 sq. ft. The school became occupied in 1963. In 1965, an addition of 5,966 sq. ft. was added to the facility. In 1975, the on‐base school joined the Fairbanks North Star Borough School District. In 1978, a new addition of 62,125 sq. ft. was built for the high school and the original structure built in 1962 became the junior high school. In 1978, the school became known as Ben Eielson Junior‐Senior High School. In 1996, a renovation study began and an additional 7,124 was added to the facility in 1998. Ben Eielson Junior‐Senior High School is unique in the district for a number of reasons. It is the only high school located on a military base, it is the smallest school in the district at their respective grade levels, and it is the only combined junior‐senior high school in the Fairbanks North Star Borough School District. The United States Air Force base is located approximately 26 miles southeast of Fairbanks, Alaska and just southeast of Moose Creek, Alaska. This building serves seventh (7th) through July 30, 2012 Page 8 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska twelve (12th) grade junior and high school students and consists of classrooms, library, theater, two gymnasiums, administrative offices, and other miscellaneous support functions. The assessment performed on this facility focused on the building’s envelope, lighting, and HVAC systems and consisted of an on‐site review of the existing facility, creation of a computer simulation model, review of the HVAC sequences of operation and schedules, and calculation of the relative paybacks for each measure examined. 3.1 Building Construction Year Built: 1962 Area: 106,800 sq. ft. Stories: One‐story Roof: Built‐Up Asphalt Roofing Floor: Slab on grade Walls: Combination of Concrete, Stucco (EIFS) /Metal Siding Windows: Double‐pane‐Vinyl Windows Doors: Metal/Glass 3.2 Building Operation Use: Education Operation: 6:00 am – 11:00 pm (cleaning /events until 11:00 pm) Monday – Friday Summer School (No) Occupancy / Enrollment: 55 Staff & 473 Students 3.3 Existing Energy Efficiency Items Several energy efficient measures are currently in use in this facility. These include:  Variable air volume terminal units in the classroom and administrative areas.  Variable speed supply and return fans on the majority of the air handling units.  Demand controlled ventilation (DCV) system with return air CO2 monitors.  Variable speed pumping with two way control valves. July 30, 2012 Page 9 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska 4.0 ENVELOPE 4.1 General The building envelope is more than a polished exterior of glass, concrete, and steel. The components utilized for controlling heat transfer, infiltration, stack effect, solar gain, and humidity are vital for a high‐
performance building. Insulated window or door panes whether it is single, double, or triple and “R” factors have an impact on the loads and efficiencies of mechanical and electrical systems. A cursory review of the existing building envelope and windows was performed to identify any areas, which may benefit from replacement, new weather stripping, caulking and/or seals to prevent infiltration of outside air. This review included verifying the proper operation and alignment of windows and doors, checking for proper levels of insulation where accessible, and noting if any insulation was found to be damaged. The Department of Energy has identified eight (8) climate zones for the United States. A list of counties and their respective climate zones can be found in American Society of Heating Refrigerating and Air‐
Conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) Advanced Energy Design Guide, and in the Department of Energy, Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Volume 7.1 Building America Best Practices Series. Hutchinson Institute of Technology is a part of Zone 8, which means it is a part of the subarctic climate. A subarctic climate is defined as a region with 12,600 heating degree‐days (65°F basis) or more. For this climate and to achieve over 30% above ASHRAE Standard 90.1‐1999, R‐values of between R13 to R60 is recommended depending on the type and the location of the envelope description. Window U‐values of .33 is recommended and this is again to exceed energy savings of 30% above ASHRAE Standard 90.1‐
1999. 4.2 Windows Figure 4.1 Typical Existing Classroom Windows Figure 4.2 Typical Existing Classroom Windows The windows installed at Ben Eielson Jr. /Sr. High School are dual glazed comfort T‐R, double pane, low e, with argon, and tempered inside and out vinyl windows. The air space between each pane is filled with argon gas. Each pane has heat reflective coatings (“low e” coatings). “Low e coatings” is another name for window film. The higher a window’s R‐value, the greater the resistance to heat flow and the greater the insulating value. The inverse of the R‐value provides the U‐value. Low U‐value ratings are good for windows. The window glass identification number is NWI ¼ U 16CFR1201CAT2ANSIZ97.1‐1984; July 30, 2012 Page 10 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska safety glass 1639 temper SG CC. The windows open from the top (see Figures 4.1 and 4.2) and have U‐
values of .33, which equates to R‐values of approximately R‐3.0. 4.3 Roof The roofing at Ben Eielson Jr. /Sr. High School is classified as single ply IRMA (Inverted Roof Membrane Assembly) built‐up asphalt roofing. Built‐up‐roofing (BUR) is a roofing system comprised of numerous layers of asphalt and felts, applied in the field (not factory coated) by the contractor to achieve various ply's as specified. Commonly referred to as 4‐ply or 5‐ply, pitch and gravel, hot tar, hot, and hot mop. The final ply must be protected from UV and may require a cap sheet, gravel or some other coating. The roof insulation (R‐value) thickness is approximately R‐40 and is made of extruded polystyrene. Polystyrene insulation is a type of rigid foam that provides continuous thermal insulation barriers for roofs. It has an exceptional ability to insulate against extreme temperatures, and is waterproof and long lasting. Polystyrene is held in place with a perimeter securement/ballast. These qualities combine to make polystyrene insulation an exceptionally useful product. Larger R‐values have greater thermal resistance or more insulating potential than smaller R‐values. 4.4 Walls Figure 4.3 Restroom J104‐Minor Cracks in Wall Figure 4.4 Restroom J104‐Minor Cracks in Wall The walls to this facility are a combination of brick, EIFS (stucco), sheetrock, GWB and plywood sheathing, fiberglass batt, and polystyrene vapor barrier. Typical wall insulation at Ben Eielson Jr. /Sr. High School has an R‐value of approximately R‐32. 4.5 Doors The weather‐stripping for the most part around most of the doors is in good condition. There was just one entrance door that was observed that was in need of reinforced weatherstripping. This entrance was vestibule 101 where there was ice built‐up. Typical doors are 3’x7’x1¾” and hollow metal with ¼” wire‐glass glazing. July 30, 2012 Page 11 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska 4.6 Miscellaneous During our walk through some envelope issues were noticed that were not directly related to building energy consumption. We are noting these items for use in planning future maintenance items. In the men’s restroom J104 there appears to be minor cracks in the wall. Samples are provided in (Figures 4.3 and 4.4). 4.7 Recommendations The following items should be implemented to improve the performance and operation of the building’s envelope:  Replace worn and/or broken weather‐stripping around doors Implementing these potential opportunities will have a holistic impact on mechanical and electrical systems through building envelope improvements. Investments in the building envelope will often add value to the buildings appearance. Please refer to Appendix D for calculation of building envelope heat transfer properties. 5.0 LIGHTING 5.1 General The majority of the lighting systems were upgraded circa 1996 and now predominantly uses T8 fluorescent lamps with electronic ballasts in most interior lighting areas. Exterior lighting consists of primarily high‐pressure sodiums (HPS) and metal halides. A lighting audit was performed to find and implement additional cost effective lighting related energy saving opportunities. A detailed description of the retrofit measures and lighting upgrades at each location can be found in Appendix C of this report. 5.2 Methodology Used A detail site survey was conducted to identify the type of light fixtures that exist in each area. A light meter was used to determine the existing light levels and compared to Illuminating Engineering Society of North America (IESNA) recommended lighting levels. A lighting ballast discriminator was used to determine the existing ballast type. A laser distance‐measuring tool was used to measure the height and width of the workspace. A camera was used to take pictures. Electrical drawings were also reviewed. The site survey results were used to determine the different types of retrofit measures to propose. A detail summary of the fixtures identified during the walk through is provided in Appendix C. July 30, 2012 Page 12 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska 5.3 Existing Lighting Figure 5.1 F32‐T8’s Lighting in the Corridors Figure 5.2 400‐W Metal Halides in Gym Figure 5.3 F32‐T8’s Typical Classroom Lighting Figure 5.4 Typical Lighting in the Theater Based upon a detailed lighting audit the majority of the existing interior lighting consists of a mixture of 32‐watt T8 lamps and normal ballast factor ballast (NBF). There are also some 40‐Watt, 65‐Watt, 100‐
Watt and 200‐Watt incandescent lamps. There are 250‐Watt mercury vapor lamps in classroom H136. In gymnasiums J101 and H113, there are mixtures of 400‐Watt metal halide lamps along with 32‐Watt T8 lamp fixtures. The outside perimeter of the building has a mixture of 100‐Watt, 250‐Watt, and 400‐
Watt high‐pressure sodium lighting (Figures 5.5‐Figures 5.8). 5.4 Ballast Factors T8 Fluorescent lighting has the advantage of offering a range of ballast factors ‐ from 0.60 to 1.30. Ballast factors are the ratio of lamp lumens produced when lamps operated by a given ballast to the lamp lumens produced when the lamps operated on reference ballast as used by lamp manufacturers and American National Standard Institute (ANCI) and rated at 1.0. Ballast factors range from low, normal and high. Ballast factors of .78 are considered “low”, Ballast factors of .88 are considered normal, and ballast factors of 1.10 are considered high. In a retrofit application, the ballast factor can be used to tune the light levels in a space, especially if the levels are determined to be too high relative to July 30, 2012 Page 13 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska the tasks performed. Most of the time T8 lamps in 25W, 28W and 30W models operate on low (0.71‐
0.78) and normal (0.87‐0.88) ballast factor with instant‐start or programmed‐start ballasts. The difference between instant‐ start versus program‐start ballast is the starting modes in which the cathodes are heated. Instant‐start ballast provides a high initial voltage to start the lamp without pre‐
heating the cathodes whereas program‐start provides an initial low voltage to heat the filaments first then after a short delay pre‐heats the cathodes. The instant start ballast starts lamps immediately, and is very energy efficient but can be cause short lamp life if used in an application where the lamps are frequently switched on/off. The program start provides maximum lamp life in frequent on/off starting conditions. In addition, if there are concerns regarding dimming you do not want to use instant start but should use program start. The ballast cost for instant start versus program start can vary between $15.00‐$19.00 for instant start and between $20.00 and $29.00 for program start. Consortium for Energy Efficiency (CEE) high performance 120/277 Volt T8 Ballast products have been provided in Appendix C which shows the difference, and benefits of using a program start versus an instant start, and the difference between using high, normal or low ballast factors. On many occasions, the ballast efficacy factor (BEF) performance is improved when using a low or normal ballast factor coupled with a high lumen lamp. 5.5 Existing Lighting Controls The majority of the lighting systems within the Ben Eielson Jr./Sr. High School are controlled via occupancy sensors. 5.6 Existing Lighting Level Measurements Recorded The lighting level measurements were taken using a light meter. These measurements were recorded in foot‐candles. A foot‐candle is a common unit of measurement used to calculate adequate lighting levels of workspaces in buildings or outdoor spaces. The existing foot‐candle level reading ranges at Ben Eielson Jr./Sr. High School were as follows: corridors‐(55), A102 administrative area‐(55), A102A administrative office‐(55), A104A administrative office‐(75), classroom H117 CR‐(75‐80), J101 gym‐(65), J101B girls locker‐(45),kitchen walk‐in‐(45), H109B multi‐purpose room‐(50‐65), and H113 gym‐(70). 5.7 Illuminating Engineering Society of North America (IESNA) Recommended Lighting Levels The Illuminating Engineering Society of North America (IESNA) recommends the following foot‐candle level reading ranges for the following: corridors‐(5‐10), A102 administrative area‐(20‐50), A102A administrative office‐(20‐50), A104A administrative office‐(20‐50),classroom H117 CR‐(20‐50), J101 gym‐
(30‐60), J101B girls locker‐(10), kitchen walk‐in‐(50), H109B multi‐purpose room‐(5‐30), and H113 gym‐
30‐60). Some of the existing lighting levels exceed what is recommended by IESNA target illuminances. Copies of IESNA recommendations are provided in detail in Appendix C of this audit report. 5.8 Incentives & Lighting Product Information Update The Energy Policy Act of 2005 included a new tax incentive. The "Commercial Building Tax Deduction" establishes a tax deduction for expenses incurred for energy efficient building expenditures made by a building owner. The deduction is limited to $1.80 per square foot of the property, with allowances for July 30, 2012 Page 14 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska partial deductions for improvements in interior lighting, HVAC and hot water systems, and building envelope systems. The Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008 (HR‐1424), approved and signed on October 3, 2008, extends the benefits of the Energy Policy Act of 2005 through December 31, 2013. In fact, by federal law, T12s won’t be manufactured after July 14, 2012; you eventually won’t be able to find replacements for burned‐out T12s. 5.9 Recommendations Based upon a detailed audit of all areas, we are recommending lighting efficiency upgrades of existing fluorescent, incandescent, mercury vapors, metal halides and high‐pressure sodium lighting fixtures located throughout this facility. In some of the corridors and classrooms we propose retrofitting the existing 32‐watt T8 lamps and normal ballast factor (NBF) to 28‐watt lamps with program‐start, low ballast factor(LBF). In some areas, the 28‐Watt lamp is paired with program‐start and normal ballast factor. In classrooms H102C, 102D, the theater, the walk‐in, and the nurse’s station, we recommend replacing the 40‐Watt incandescent lamps with 8‐Watt LED A‐19 lamps, the 65‐Watt incandescent lamps with 14‐Watt LED Par 30 lamps, the 100‐Watt Watt incandescent lamps with Phillips 16‐Watt A‐19 Style LED lamps, and the 200‐Watt incandescent lamps with 90‐Watt LED Par 38 lamps. The 250‐Watt mercury vapor lamps in classroom H136 should be replaced with F32T8 lamps and high ballast factor (HBF). In gymnasiums J101 and H113, there are mixtures of 400‐Watt metal halides along with 32‐Watt compact fluorescents. We recommend replacing the 400‐Watt metal halides with new F54 T‐5 lighting fixtures and high ballast factor ballast, and replacing the existing 32‐watt T8 lamps and normal ballast factor (NBF) with 28‐Watt lamps with program‐start, normal ballast factor (NBF). In the outside perimeter of the building where there are a mixture of 100‐Watt, 250‐Watt, and 400‐Watt high‐
pressure sodium lighting we recommend replacing the 100‐Watt with new 28‐Watt LED fixtures, the 250‐Watt metal halides with 104‐Watt LED’s, and the 400‐Watt high‐pressure sodium’s with 153‐Watt LED’s. The proposed cost and estimated savings are provided in the EEM Summary Table in Section 10.0 and a complete list of all the fixtures audited is located in Appendix C of this audit report. The lighting Calculations and Common Conversions, The Illuminating Engineering Society of North America (IESNA) Recommended Light Levels, IESNA Target Illuminances, Classroom Lighting Know How, and The Consortium for Energy Efficiency (CEE) List of High Performance for Commercial Lighting Systems are also included in Appendix C of this audit report. Printed below are some of the photos taken during this cursory walkthrough. July 30, 2012 Page 15 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Figure 5.5 Typical Exterior Lighting Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska Figure 5.6 Typical Exterior Lighting Figure 5.7 Typical Parking Lot Lighting Figure 5.8 Typical Parking Lot Lighting 6.0 MECHANICAL 6.1 Air‐Handling Systems Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School was orginally constructed in 1962 and substatially upgraded in 1998 and 2000. The 2000 remodel replaced several air handlers and the majority of the distribution ductwork and terminal units. The Direct Digital Control (DDC) system was also upgraded during this remodel. The Junior High classroom wing AHU (SF18) was replaced in 2000 and consists of a minimum outside air damper with a glycol preheat coil, an economizer damper, mixing box, heating coil, and a variable volume plug type supply fan equipped with a variable speed drive. Supply air from this unit is distributed through medium pressure ductwork located in a July 30, 2012 Figure 6.1 – SF10 Air Handling Unit Page 16 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska trench below the corridor, to variable volume terminal units located in the ceiling spaces. These terminal units are equipped with air volume dampers to control the volume of air being delivered to each temperature control zone. The terminal units vary the air between full design cfm and 40% flow depending on the load in the space being served. Heating of the perimeter zones is provided by finned tube heating elements at the exterior walls. Refer to Drawing M1.2 in Appendix E The Junior High Gym is served by the original built up air handling system. This system includes an outside air intake plenum equipped with a glycol preheat coil, a return air/outside air mixing room with a relief damper, and multiple centrifugal type supply fans with hot water heating coils. Refer to Drawing M1.3 in Appendix E for additional details. The main portion of the building (administration, offices, and cafeteria) is served by SF10 which is similar in arrangement to SF18. The Senior High Gymnasium and Multipurpose Room received new air handlers during the 2000 remodel. The gymnasium unit consists of an outside air intake with preheat coil, a mixing box, a heating coil and variable speed supply Figure 6.2 – Jr. High Gym Mechanical Room fan. The multipurpose AHU (SF17) is a heat recovery unit which captures heat from the locker room exhaust airstream and transfers this heat to the incoming outside air. A diagram of this system is shown in Drawing M1.5 of Appendix E. The Senior High classroom area is served by two original air handling units (SA12 and SA13). SA12 provides heating and minimum ventilation to the space, while SA13 provides additional ventilation and free cooling via outside air when needed. This system is shown in Drawing M1.6 of Appendix E. 6.2 Heating Systems Building heating is provided by a shell and tube steam to hot glycol converter. Steam is delivered to the building via an underground steam line originating at the main steam plant on the base This steam is passed through the heat exchanger where it transfers heat to the building’s combination water/glycol heating solution. The condensate from the heat exchanger is pumped back to the steam plant via a steam powered condensate return system. The junior high and senior high are served by two independent steam converters and the condensate from each of these systems is separately monitored. This system distributes hot glycol to heating coils Figure 6.3 – High School Steam Station located in the air handlers as well as heating coils located in the interior zone terminal units. Heating water is also distributed to perimeter finned tube July 30, 2012 Page 17 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska units, cabinet heaters (vestibules) and unit heaters (mechanical rooms). The heating water distribution pumps are controlled by variable speed drives that regulate the speed of the pumps in response to system loads. Two way heating water control valves are used throughout the facility. A small number of three way control valves are used at the end of each run in order to keep hot water flowing in each loop. Please refer to Diagram M1.1 in Appendix E for additional information on the heating water distribution system. 6.3 Control Systems The mechanical system is monitored and controlled by a Johnson Controls direct digital control (DDC) system. Valves and dampers are positioned by electric actuators. CO2 sensors are provided in the return duct of the majority of the air handlers to control the amount of outside air in response to building occupancy. 6.4 Domestic Hot Water Domestic hot water is generated by an instantaneous steam to hot water generator. 6.5 Mechanical System Trend Logs With the assistance of FNSB personnel, the operating parameters of a single air handling unit and the heating water system were monitored and recorded over a period of several days. This period included weekday and weekend operation. The intent of monitoring a select group of points was to determine if the operation of the mechanical systems was consistent with the assumed schedules and operating parameters used in the computer simulation model, and to identify any potential energy saving items that may be candidates for more in depth monitoring and analysis in the future. This data (typically referred to as a trend log) was taken for SF12 which serves Senior High classrooms. Observations for SF12 may or may not apply to the other units that were not monitored. Certain sections of the trend data were graphed to illuminate items of interest that were noted in our review of the data collected. The data points that were monitored during this study were a small selection of the total number of points available for monitoring in the future. The following observations are from our analysis of the trend logs: 

The heating water temperature control is stable and the heating water temperature appears to be resetting based on outside air temperature. The outside air damper does not appear to close during unoccupied hours when the supply fan is running. The control of the preheat temperature during this time is very unstable. Coil discharge temperatures vary by around 30 degrees over ten minute periods. Typical control variations would be expected to be in the 3‐5 degree range. The most July 30, 2012 Figure 6.4: Frosting of Lower Tubes on SF12 Preheat Coil Page 18 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management 
Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska likely cause of this variation is stratification of the outside air across the coil. We noted during our field investigation that the lower portion of the preheat coil was frosted while the upper portion was too hot to touch. Although this is not a significant problem, correcting this issue by employing a a device to distribute the air evenly over the coil in the duct would allow better control of this coil discharge temperature. Refer to Figure 6.4. The “Cold Run” Operation appears to be initiating at minus 10 degrees F, instead of the typical set point of minus 20 degrees F. Please refer to Appendix I for a graphical depiction of this data. 7.0 ENERGY USE The purpose of this energy audit is to identify measures or practices that will result in a reduction in the energy use of the facility. Fuel oil is used for building heating and domestic hot water generation, while electricity is used by fans, pumps, lights, and miscellaneous plug loads. A reduction in oil use can be achieved by one or more of the following actions: 



Reduce the amount of ventilation air being introduced into the building. Reduce the amount of heat lost through the envelope of the building. Recover heat before it is exhausted from the building. Improve the efficiency of the oil burning equipment. A reduction in electrical consumption can be achieved in one or more of the following manners: 



Improve the efficiency of the lighting systems. Vary the speed of fans and pumps in response to the building loads. Improve the efficiency of the motors. Turn off systems when they are not required. Two years of utility bills were analyzed to determine the energy consumption characteristics of the facility. These numbers were then normalized to account for any unusual weather conditions that may have occurred during the span of the two years. For example, if the winter of 2010 was abnormally warm, the yearly energy consumption would be less than that of a typical year. The number of actual heating degree days (HDD) for each month during the two year time period was compared to the historical average heating degree days for that month, and the oil consumption use was adjusted based on this ratio. These adjusted energy consumption values were then used to calculate an overall building energy use index. The calculated Energy Utilization Index (EUI) for this facility is 90 kBTU/SF. The EUI calculation is included in Appendix A. Figure 7.1 shows a comparison of the existing and proposed EUI with both the average EUI found in the building operated by the Fairbanks North Star Borough and the Environmental Protection Agency’s Energy Star target for a median building of a similar type. This target value was developed using the Energy Star Target Finder software and represents the design criteria for a 50% Energy Star Rated Building, rather than the median value for existing K‐12 Schools. July 30, 2012 Page 19 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska Figure 7.1 – Building Energy Use Index
8.0 ENERGY MEASURES 8.1 Types of Energy Savings Measures Potential energy saving measures (ECMs and EEMs) were identified for the facility based upon an on‐site inspection, a review of utility records, computer modeling and interviews with facility personnel. The purpose of identifying these energy measures is to reduce energy consumption, and lower operational costs. Each measure was analyzed either by utilizing a spreadsheet calculation or by employing the TRACE energy‐modeling program. A rolling baseline modeling system is employed during the modeling process. This system analyzes each alternative based on the results of the previous alternative. The first alternatives analyzed are the ones thought to be most likely to result in a short payback period. The rolling baseline system is used to prevent double accounting of energy savings. For example, if one alternative improves the building envelope and the following alternative increases the efficiency of the heating system, the second alternative must take into account the decreased heating load provided by improving the envelope in the first alternative. If this reduced heating load is not taken into account, the second alternative would show additional heating energy savings that would not be realized in a building with an improved envelope. July 30, 2012 Page 20 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska The following measures were analyzed for this facility: Energy Conservation Measures:  ECM A – Ventilation System Optimization  ECM B – Replacement of Existing Motors with More Efficient Motors  ECM C – Adjustment of Cold Run Set Point Energy Efficiency Measures:  EEM 1 – Lighting Upgrades  EEM 2 – Replace Inlet Vanes with Variable Speed Drives 8.2 Computer Modeling The TRACE building modeling system examined four alternatives. The lighting energy savings measure (EEM‐1) was calculated using a spreadsheet. This was accounted for by entering the proposed lighting values into the model prior to examining any other measures. The alternatives examined were: 8.2.1 Trace Model Alternative One: Baseline Building This alternative models the existing facility using information from the most current as built drawings, as well as information gathered during our field visits. The existing wall and roof u‐values were calculated and input into the model. The existing lighting densities, HVAC system types, airflows, and operational schedules were used. The energy use predicted by the baseline model was then compared to the actual utility bills (normalized to reflect an average year) to determine if the model was accurately describing the operation of the existing facility. The model was then “tuned” to follow the existing building energy consumption as closely as possible. 8.2.2 Trace Model Alternative Two: Lighting Upgrades This alternative accounts for the lighting upgrades that were calculated via a spread sheet. The reduction in lighting load will lead to a slight increase in building heating, and this is accounted for in this alternative. 8.2.3 Trace Model Alternative Three: Adjustment to Cold Run Set Point This alternative incorporates the lighting upgrades from EEM 1 and examines ECM‐C, changing the cold run set point from minus 10 Deg F to minus 20 Deg F. 8.2.4 Trace Model Alternative Four: Variable Speed Fans This alternative incorporates the changes Alternatives 2 and 3 and examines EEM 2, addition of variable speed drives to the Junior High School Gym fan system. July 30, 2012 Page 21 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska The TRACE 700 computer model input and output data is included in Appendix G and H respectively. A more thorough discussion of each ECM/EEM can be found in Section 9.0. 8.3 Energy Costs The following energy costs were used in this analysis: Steam = $1.90 per Therm Electricity Consumption = $.156 per Kwh Electrical Demand = $10.79 Kw Blended Electrical Rate = $.177 per Kwh 9.0 ENERGY MEASURE DESCRIPTIONS 9.1 ECM A – Ventilation Air Analysis Heating of the outside ventilation air is the primary source of energy use for the facility. Any actions taken to reduce the amount of ventilation air introduced into the building will save a significant amount of energy. A certain amount of fresh air is required in order to provide adequate indoor air quality; however, excessive amounts of outdoor air lead to increased energy consumption. This delicate balance between indoor air quality and energy consumption is perhaps the most important aspect of any energy conservation project. The 2009 International Mechanical Code stipulates the minimum outside air requirements for any facility. These requirements include a people component and an area component. For each particular use, the code specifies a cubic foot per minute of outside air per each occupant (cfm/person) and an amount of outside air required based on the square footage of the space (cfm/square foot). Codes that were in place during the design of this facility typically only included a people component. The 2009 IMC reduces many of the cfm/person requirements from the original codes in place during the time construction of this facility. However, some of the requirements for Classrooms have actually increased. Depending on the balance of Classroom to other uses, implementation of the new code may either increase or decrease the total required amount of outside air for a particular facility. An excerpt from the current code is listed below: July 30, 2012 Page 22 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska Minimum Ventilation Rates – Schools 2009 IMC Use Classroom (Age 5‐8) Classroom (Age 9+) Science Room Art Classroom Lecture Classroom Lecture Hall (Fixed Seats) Computer Lab Shops Music/Theater/Dance Multi‐Use/Assembly Office Cfm Cfm Person
10
10
10
10
7.5
7.5
10
10
10
7.5
5
Sq Ft 0.12
0.12
0.18
0.18
0.06
0.06
0.12
0.18
0.06
0.06
0.06
People 1000 Sq Ft 25
35
25
20
65
150
25
20
35
100
5
Previous Net Cfm Code Person Cfm/Per 14.8 15 13.4 15 17.2 15 19.0 15 8.4 15 7.9 15 14.8 20 19.0 20 11.7 20 8.1 20 17.0 20 If the air‐handling system provides ventilation air to multiple zones, several additional calculations must be performed to determine the fraction of outdoor air required at the air‐handling unit. These calculations provide correction factors for over ventilated zones, air distribution effectiveness, and system efficiencies. A calculation of the overall percentage of outside air required at each air‐handling unit can be found in Appendix D. Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School utilizes CO2 sensors in the return air ducts to monitor the ambient CO2 level. The control system modulates the amount of outside air introduced in the building in proportion to the number of people in the space at any given time. This is known as demand controlled ventilation (DCV) and is the best method to balance the need for adequate indoor air quality with the desire to reduce energy consumption. Demand Controlled Ventilation (DCV) is a method of adjusting the amount of outside ventilation air introduced in to the building based on the number of occupants at any given time. The number of occupants can be determined indirectly by measuring the concentration of carbon dioxide (CO2) in the air. Each person produces CO2 at a fairly constant rate, therefore the concentration of CO2 in the return air system can be used as an indication of the number of people occupying the space. Measuring the return air CO2 is a relatively inexpensive method of DCV since it requires only one sensor and minimal control wiring. However, this method provides an average reading of all the spaces served by the system. If one space is fully occupied and the other is empty the average value read in the return air stream will not be indicative of what is actually happening on a room by room level and some zones may be over ventilated, while others are under ventilated. July 30, 2012 Page 23 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska The control system monitors the CO2 level in the return air stream and opens the outside air damper when this level exceeds a certain set point. This set point is based on a calculation of the minimum amount of outside air required by code. The calculation of the maximum allowable CO2 level is provided in Appendix D. This CO2 set point should be compared to the current set point and adjusted, if possible, to reduce the amount of outside air required. We also recommend a visual inspection of all the outside air dampers in the facility to verify that they are closing properly during unoccupied hours. Also, the seals on these dampers should be inspected to verify that the damper is not leaking when it is closed. 9.2 ECM B – Energy Efficient Motors The pay back derived from replacing existing electric motors with premium efficiency motors depends on the horsepower, the efficiency, hours of operation, type of system, and the location of the existing motor. Larger motors tend to provide lower pay back periods. The tables included in Appendix D provide information on the typical motors used in this facility and indicates the existing motor efficiency at which the payback period becomes feasible. For example, if an existing 10 horsepower motor used in a perimeter heating loop has an efficiency of 87.5% or less, then replacing the motor with a premium efficiency model will provide a payback of 5 years. Motors used in variable speed systems will have a longer payback than indicated in the charts because the motor is not operating at full design horsepower for the number of hours indicated. Additionally motors located in the airstream of fan systems will also have a slightly longer payback, because the heat produced by the inefficiency of the motor is used in a beneficial way during the heating season. Please refer to the tables to determine the feasibility of replacing other motors used throughout the facility. Since many of the motor nameplates are obstructed or could not be found, a simple payback calculation for each motor is not feasible. However, as maintenance personnel are working in this building, this chart can be used to determine if the motors should be replaced or re‐used. 9.3 ECM C – Adjust the Cold Run Set Point During the Cold Run operation, if the outside air temperature falls below a certain set point value and the building is in unoccupied mode, the fan starts and the outside air damper is opened slightly to pressurize the building. This is done to prevent accidental freeze up and subsequent damage to equipment. There is a cost associated with running the system in this mode, since the fan consumes electricity and heating the incoming outside air requires steam consumption. Examination of the trend logs for SF12 indicates that the Cold Run operation is being initiated at temperatures below minus 10 degrees F (see excerpt from the trend logs in Appendix I). Other typical buildings in the school district are set to initiate the Cold Run operation at minus 20 degrees F. Adjusting the on point of the Cold Run sequence to a lower temperature reduces the time the fans are running and therefore saves energy. A table showing the approximate fan energy and heating energy costs for several different initiation temperatures is included in Appendix D for reference. 9.4 EEM 1 ‐ Lighting Upgrades Based upon a detailed audit of all areas, we are recommending lighting efficiency upgrades of existing fluorescent, incandescent, mercury vapors, metal halides and high‐pressure sodium lighting fixtures July 30, 2012 Page 24 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska located throughout this facility. In some of the corridors and classrooms we propose retrofitting the existing 32‐watt T8 lamps and normal ballast factor (NBF) to 28‐watt lamps with program‐start, low ballast factor(LBF). In some areas, the 28‐Watt lamp is paired with program‐start and normal ballast factor. In classrooms H102C, 102D, the theater, the walk‐in, and the nurse’s station, we recommend replacing the 40‐Watt incandescent lamps with 8‐Watt LED A‐19 lamps, the 65‐Watt incandescent lamps with 14‐Watt LED Par 30 lamps, the 100‐Watt Watt incandescent lamps with Phillips 16‐Watt A‐19 Style LED lamps, and the 200‐Watt Watt incandescent lamps with 90‐Watt LED Par 38 lamps. The 250‐Watt mercury vapor lamps in classroom H136 should be replaced with F32T8 lamps and high ballast factor (HBF). In gymnasiums J101 and H113, there are mixtures of 400‐Watt metal halides along with 32‐Watt compact fluorescents. We recommend replacing the 400‐Watt metal halides with new F54 T‐5 lighting fixtures and high ballast factor ballast, and replacing the existing 32‐watt T8 lamps and normal ballast factor (NBF) with 28‐watt lamps with program‐start, normal ballast factor (NBF). In the outside perimeter of the building where there are a mixture of 100‐Watt, 250‐Watt, and 400‐Watt high‐
pressure sodium lighting we recommend replacing the 100‐Watt with new 28‐Watt LED fixtures, the 250‐Watt metal halides with 104‐Watt LED’s, and the 400‐Watt high‐pressure sodium’s with 153‐Watt LED’s. A complete detail of all of the fixtures audited and savings estimated is provided in Appendix C of this audit report. 9.5 EEM 2 – Convert the Jr. High Gym Fan System to Variable Speed The existing Junior High School gymnasium is served by two constant volume supply fans. This EEM replaces the existing fan motors and adds variable speed control to the fans, so that their speed can be reduced during periods of low occupancy.  Replace the existing motors with high efficiency motors designed for use with variable speed drives.  Provide new variable speed drives for each fan motor.  Extend the existing DDC control system to incorporate these new points. 10.0 SIMPLE PAYBACK AND SIR The total energy saved by employing Energy Conservations Measures ECM‐A, Ventilation Air Reduction and ECM‐B, Energy Efficient Motors, could not be calculated. Calculation of the total energy saved from implementing ECM‐A requires detailed data monitoring and analysis of each individual air handling system in order to determine the existing energy consumption of each unit. Calculation of the total energy saved by employing ECM B could not be performed since many of the motor nameplates were inaccessible or missing during our walkthrough. This level of detailed analysis is beyond the scope of a Level II audit and is typically performed during a Level III Audit. Therefore, simple payback and Savings to Investment Ratio (SIR) calculations are not presented for the recommended Energy Conservation Measures (ECM A and ECM B). However, we do have enough data to estimate the energy saved by employing ECM C so we are able to calculate the simple pay back and SIR of this ECM. The simple payback calculation is a quick method of comparing various ECMs/EEMs; however, does not take into account the time value of money or the costs or savings beyond the first cost. The savings‐to‐investment ratio (SIR) is the ratio of the present value savings to the present value costs of an energy conservation measure. The numerator of the ratio is the present value of net savings in July 30, 2012 Page 25 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska energy plus or minus any additional maintenance costs related to the measure. The denominator of the ratio is the present value of the installation cost of the measure. The following formulas were used in the calculation of each ratio: Simple Payback = Cost of Energy Saved/Cost of Installation of ECM/EEM SIR = Present Value of Energy Saved for the Life of the Measure/Present Value of the Installed Cost BEN EIELSON JR/SR HIGH SCHOOL ‐ EEM SUMMARY Annual Energy and Cost Savings Measure Number Measure Description Peak Electricity Demand Usage Savings Savings Kw ECM‐C Cold Run Set Point Mod EEM‐1 Lighting Upgrades EEM‐2 Add VSDs on Jr High Gym 45 659 25 Kwh 25,000 Oil Usage Savings Annual Cost Savings Measure Cost Therms $ $ 1,397 168,560 *(1,936) 18,450 Payback Calculations 629 $7,040 Simple Savings to Payback Invest Ratio Yrs $2,500 0.4 39.7 $29,728 $265,800 8.9 1.6 3.5 4.1 $4,343 $15,000 * Reducing the lighting load leads to an increase in overall building heating demand. 11.0 OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE A successful operations and maintenance plan is the key to continued energy savings in any facility. According to the American Society of Heating and Refrigeration Engineers (ASHRAE) 2007 Handbook, the original design and installation of a mechanical system constitutes only around 10% of the total life cycle cost, while operation and maintenance costs represent approximately 80% of the total cost over the life of the system. The remaining 10% of the life cycle cost is attributed to acquisition, renewal and disposal. When a mechanical system is installed, it should be commissioned to ensure that the operation of the system meets the design intent. Over the life of this system, its operation should be verified via control system trending and/or field measurements. If the system is found to be operating outside of the original design intent, corrective action or retro commissioning should be initiated. A quality preventative maintenance plan can extend the life of the mechanical system beyond the estimated service life of the equipment and free up capital funds for other projects. Frequent filter changes can result in significant energy savings over the life of the building. The pressure drop across the filter increases as it captures dirt and dust. This increased pressure drop results in additional energy consumption, a decrease in airflow, or both. For a typical 20,000 cfm fan system a 1‐inch static pressure increase will result in an increased annual energy cost of $2,000. The level of maintenance at the Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School appears to be excellent. The level of quality of the installed Pace and Trane custom air handlers is very high, and there were no visible signs of wear or of any maintenance problems. The mechanical spaces are clean and well kept and the filters appear to have been changed frequently. July 30, 2012 Page 26 RS Consulting Edwards Energy Engineering & Waste Management Energy Audit – Final Report Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Eielson AFB, Alaska 12.0 RECOMMENDATIONS We recommend further analysis of the following Energy Conservation Measures:  ECM A Ventilation Air Reductions  Verify that the maximum CO2 set points used in the Demand Controlled Ventilation (DCV) control scheme are in agreement with current codes. It is possible that some of the set points may be increased, which will reduce the amount of outside air needed.  Revisit the practice of pressurizing the building in cold weather during unoccupied hours. This practice may be required to prevent freeze up or damage, but any reduction in the amount of pressurization required will result in substantial energy savings.  Inspect and repair all outside air dampers that may be leaking or not closing properly to prevent introduction of un‐wanted outside air during unoccupied hours. The majority of the facility energy use can be attributed to the heating of the outside air as it is introduced into the building. Therefore, anything that can be done to reduce this outside airflow will have the greatest impact on the overall energy consumption of the facility.  ECM B Replace Low Efficiency Motors Where Applicable Replace motors that do not meet the minimum efficiency criteria as listed in the Table provided in Appendix D. We recommend implementation of the following Energy Conservation and Energy Efficiency Measures:  ECM C Change the set point temperature of “Cold Run” to Minus 20 Cold Run operation is initiated during unoccupied hours when the outside air temperature drops below a set point value. It appears from analysis of Trend Logs for SF12, that this set point is currently minus 10 degrees F. Both fan energy and heating energy can be saved if this set point is adjusted down.  EEM 1 Lighting Upgrades Electrical energy consumption will be reduced significantly by upgrading the lighting system with energy efficient fixtures.  EEM 2 Variable Speed Drives on Junior High Gym System Remove the existing fan motors and provide new premium efficiency motors with variable speed drives. July 30, 2012 Page 27 APPENDIX A – CALCULATION OF ENERGY USE INDEX
Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Energy Use Index
Building Square Footage
106,760
Steam Use
Assumes Delivery of 50 psig Saturated Steam & Return of 200 Deg Cond
Cond
Net
Date
Lbs
kbtu-Stm
Cost
Cost/kbtu
Cost/Lb
Jan-09 1,059,600
1,055,362 $ 15,143 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Feb-09
995,020
991,040 $ 14,220 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Mar-09
774,000
770,904 $ 11,061 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Apr-09
606,800
604,373 $
8,672 $
0.014 $ 0.014
May-09
376,000
374,496 $
5,373 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Jun-09
71,400
71,114 $
1,020 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Jul-09
71,400
71,114 $
1,020 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Aug-09
100,000
99,600 $
1,429 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Sep-09
610,220
607,779 $
8,721 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Oct-09 600,000
597,600 $
8,400 $
0.014 $
0.014
Nov-09
995,020
991,040 $ 14,220 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Dec-09
696,510
693,724 $
9,954 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Jan-10 1,200,000
1,195,200 $ 16,800 $
0.014 $
0.014
Feb-10 1,000,000
996,000 $ 14,000 $
0.014 $
0.014
Mar-10
774,010
770,914 $ 11,061 $
0.014 $ 0.014
Apr-10
606,800
604,373 $ 10,637 $
0.018 $ 0.018
May-10
376,000
374,496 $
6,591 $
0.018 $ 0.018
Jun-10
71,400
71,114 $
1,252 $
0.018 $ 0.018
Jul-10
71,400
71,114 $
1,252 $
0.018 $ 0.018
Aug-10
100,000
99,600 $
1,753 $
0.018 $ 0.018
Sep-10
339,120
337,764 $
5,945 $
0.018 $ 0.018
Oct-10
619,700
617,221 $ 11,447 $
0.019 $ 0.018
Nov-10
600,000
597,600 $ 11,085 $
0.019 $ 0.018
Dec-10 700,000
697,200 $ 12,600 $
0.018 $
0.018
* Data is not available, assumed values based on other months
Avg Cost
2009 6,955,970
6,928,146 $ 99,234 $
0.014 $
0.014
2010 6,458,430
6,432,596 $ 104,422 $
0.016 $
0.016
Averages
6,707,200
6,680,371 $ 101,828 $
0.015 $
0.015
Energy Use( MBH)
2009
2010
Steam
6,928,146
6,432,596
Elect
2,897,812
2,570,942
Total
9,825,958
9,003,538
Energy
BTU/SF
92,038
84,334
Average
Notes
*
*
*
*
Heating Deg Days
Actual
Average
Base 60
Base 60
HDD
HDD
2095
2150
1833
1763
1654
1634
850
780
357
328
123
119
61
88
260
205
456
459
987
1145
1820
1712
1928
2035
2263
2150
1555
1763
1459
1634
665
780
291
328
126
119
78
88
161
205
505
459
1018
1145
1434
1712
2447
2035
12,424
12,002
12,213
12,418
12,418
12,418
Electrical Use
KWH
kbtu-Elec
115,500
394,086
71,400
243,617
66,000
225,192
74,400
253,853
51,900
177,083
37,200
126,926
26,700
91,100
60,600
206,767
108,900
371,567
105,000
358,260
69,900
238,499
61,800
210,862
115,000
392,380
70,000
238,840
59,400
202,673
83,100
283,537
47,400
161,729
22,500
76,770
33,600
114,643
52,500
179,130
29,100
99,289
107,400
366,449
70,500
240,546
63,000
214,956
849,300
753,500
801,400
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
2,897,812 $
2,570,942 $
2,734,377 $
Cost per
kbtu
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.060
$ 0.066
$ 0.066
$ 0.066
$ 0.066
$ 0.066
$ 0.066
$ 0.066
$ 0.066
$ 0.066
Total
Energy Use
kbtu
1,449,448
1,234,657
996,096
858,226
551,579
198,041
162,215
306,367
979,346
955,860
1,229,539
904,586
1,587,580
1,234,840
973,587
887,910
536,225
147,884
185,758
278,730
437,053
983,670
838,146
912,156
173,034 Avg Cost
Avg Cost
163,816 Per KWH
Per Kbtu
168,425 $ 0.221 $ 0.065
9,825,958
9,003,538
18,829,496
Cost
23,527
14,544
13,444
15,155
10,572
7,578
5,439
12,344
22,183
21,420
14,239
12,589
23,460
14,280
12,100
18,623
10,622
5,042
7,530
11,765
6,521
24,004
15,757
14,112
Cost Per
KWH
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.204
$ 0.224
$ 0.224
$ 0.224
$ 0.224
$ 0.224
$ 0.224
$ 0.224
$ 0.224
$ 0.224
Adjusted
For HDD
91,993
87,257
89,600
Avg Utility Costs
Utility Costs/ SF
Steam
Electric
$ 101,828 $ 168,425 $
$
0.95 $
1.58 $
Total
270,253
2.53 per Square foot
Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School Energy Use Index
Steam Consumption (Lbs)
Monthly Electrical Consumption (KWh)
Sep-10
Nov-10
Jul-10
May-10
0
Jan-10
20,000
0
Mar-10
40,000
200,000
Nov-09
60,000
400,000
Jul-09
80,000
600,000
Sep-09
100,000
800,000
May-09
1,000,000
Jan-09
120,000
Mar-09
1,200,000
Total Monthly Energy Consumption (kBtu)
2,000,000
1,500,000
1,000,000
500,000
Dec-10
Nov-10
Sep-10
Oct-10
Jul-10
Aug-10
Jun-10
Apr-10
May-10
Mar-10
Jan-10
Feb-10
Dec-09
Oct-09
Nov-09
Aug-09
09
Sep-09
09
Jul-09
09
Jan
Jan-09
Feb
Feb-09
Mar--09
Apr-09
-09
May-09
09
Jun-09
09
0
Building Energy Consumption Steam and Electricty (kBtu)
1,200,000
1,000,000
800,000
600,000
kbtu-Elec
400,000
kbtu-Stm
200,000
0
APPENDIX B – COST ESTIMATES
RS Consulting
Opinion of Probable Cost
Job: Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School
Job #:
Status of Design: Energy Audit
QTY
UNIT
DESCRIPTION
EEM
Date:
Est:
MATERIAL
UNIT TOTAL
LABOR
UNIT TOTAL
29-May-12
RWS
ENGINEERING EST
UNIT
TOTAL
Provide Variable Speed Drives for Jr High Gym Supply Fans
Remove Existing Motors
Provide New Premimum Eff Motors
Provide VSD for Supply Fans (3 Hp)
Electrical Wiring
Modify DDC Control Signal
Control Wiring and Conduit
Controls Programming and Test
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
EA
560
1050
300
250
100
1120
2100
300
250
100
250
180
450
2500
1200
800
1250
500
360
900
2500
1200
800
1250
250
740
1500
2800
1450
900
1250
Subtotal
General Conditions
Construction Contingency
Design
$500
$1,480
$3,000
$2,800
$1,450
$900
$1,250
$11,380
25%
15%
12%
$2,845
$2,134
$1,963
Total for EEM
Round to
$14,225
$16,359
$18,322
$18,322
$18,000
APPENDIX C – LIGHTING CALCULATIONS
Project
Name
Ben Eielson Jr & Sr High School
Sandra Edwards
Contact
-
(206) 303-0121
19804 141st Place NE Woodinville, WA 98072 Office: 425-806-9200 Fax: 425-806-7455
Project Analysis for Ben Eielson Jr & Sr High School
Energy Analysis
Existing System Baseline
498,418 kWh / Yr.
Energy Efficient System
329,861 kWh / Yr.
Energy Reduction
Annual Energy Savings
Estimated Annual Savings
33.82%
168,557 kWh / Yr.
at
15.600¢
per kWh
Estimated Demand Savings
$26,294.95
$7,111.82
Total Savings
$33,406.76
Rebates
Estimated Potential Golden Valley Elec Utility Rebate / Grant
$0.00
Project Investments
Lighting System
Sensors / Controls
$248,255.00
$0.00
Lamp Recycle
$5,833.99
Permits
$5,560.91
Waste Removal
$6,131.90
Haz-Mat (PCB) Fees
$0.00
Lifts and Equipment
$0.00
State Tax (if applicable)
0.00%
$0.00
Total Project Investment
$265,781.80
Proposal Outline
Total Initial Investment
$265,781.80
Total Estimated Rebate
$0.00
Actual Investment
$265,781.80
Total Annual Energy Savings
$33,406.76
Simple Payback
7.96 Years
I, the undersigned, do hereby give consent to proceed with the project as outlined in this and all other relevant project documents. I understand that the
material costs are considered current for sixty days from the date stated below. All other data provided by sources other than Northwest Edison is subject
to change without notice.
Authorized Signature ______________________________________________________________________
Date ___________________
The information provided herein is based on information collected from the building location during our energy surveys and also provided by authorized personnel. All data
contained within this document is to be considered as an estimate. This information is proprietary, not to be disclosed to third parties without prior written permission from
Northwest Edison.
Energy Audit
19804 141st Place NE
Woodinville, WA 98072
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
Fairbanks North Star
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Existing / Proposed Fixture Description
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
E
Exterior
25
EFHPS400
Existing Fixture High Pressure Sodium 400
watt Lamp
400
464
12
7
P
Exterior
25
NLED153
New Exterior LED Fixture 153 watts
153
153
12
7
E
Exterior
25
EWHPS100
Existing Wall Pack High Pressure Sodium
100 watt Lamp
100
130
12
7
P
Exterior
25
NLED28
28
28
12
7
E
Exterior
2
EFMH250
Existing Fixture Metal Halide 250 watt Lamp
250
295
12
7
P
Exterior
2
NLED104
104
104
12
7
E
Exterior
13
EFHPS100
watt Lamp
100
130
12
7
P
Exterior
13
NLED28
28
28
12
7
E
Entry / Hall
145
ET4332N
Existing Troffer T8 4' w 3 F32 32 watt Lamp,
NBF Ballast
32
85
12
7
28
48
12
7
1
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
Shoebox @ 28', square pole, 2 bolts, silver
*
2
with semi cut-off
*
3
*
4
Canopy
*
5
55
AC
P
Entry / Hall
145
TK4228NP
Troffer Kit with Reflector 4' w 2 F32 28 watt
T8 Lamp, PRS NBF Ballast
E
Entry / Hall
6
ES4232N
Existing Strip T8 4' w 2 F32 32 watt Lamp,
NBF Ballast
32
58
12
7
P
Entry / Hall
6
LB228N
Lamp And Ballast Retrofit w 2 F32 28 watt
Lamp, NBF Ballast
28
48
12
7
E
Entry / Hall
66
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
12
7
28
26
12
7
*
6
In display
*
7
In cove
P
Entry / Hall
66
LB128N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
Entry / Hall
5
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
12
7
28
26
12
7
*
8
Uplight
P
Entry / Hall
5
LB128N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
Entry / Hall
15
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
12
7
28
26
12
7
*
9
In display
P
Entry / Hall
15
LB128N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
A102 Admin
7
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
LB328NP
Lamp and Ballast Retrofit w 3 F32 28 watt
28
73
9
5
*
10
P
A102 Admin
7
This information is proprietary, not to be disclosed to third parties without prior written permission from Northwest Edison.
AC, 0.84x120 motorola ballast
Energy Audit Calculation 1 of 22 1/24/2012
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
A102 Admin
2
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
24
7
28
72
24
7
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
10A
2 on e-circuit
P
A102 Admin
2
LB328N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
A102 Admin
8
ECFL226
Existing Dual 26 watt Compact Fluorescent
Lamp
26
52
9
5
P
A102 Admin
8
14WLEDP30
14 watt LED Par 30 Lamp
14
14
9
5
E
A102A Office
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
11
55
7-1/2" hole
*
12
55
AC
P
A102A Office
4
LB328NP
E
A102B Office
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
13
AC
P
A102B Office
4
LB328NP
E
A102C Workroom & Lounge
18
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
P
A102C Workroom & Lounge
18
LB328NP
28
73
9
5
E
Counseling Office
8
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
14
AC
*
15
AC
P
Counseling Office
8
LB328NP
E
A104A Office
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
16
75
AC
P
A104A Office
4
LB328NP
E
A104B Office
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
17
AC
P
A104B Office
4
LB328NP
E
A106 Hall to Nurse
3
ET4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12
7
28
42
12
7
*
18
AC
P
A106 Hall to Nurse
3
LB228LP
T8 Lamp, PRS LBF Ballast
E
A110
2
EW4232N
Existing Wrap T8 4' w 2 F32 32 watt Lamp,
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
LB228LP
28
42
9
5
*
19
P
A110
2
AC
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
A114 Nurse
4
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
42
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
20
65
AC
P
A114 Nurse
4
LB228LP
E
A114 Nurse
2
EINC200
Existing Incandescent 200 watt Lamp
200
200
9
5
P
A114 Nurse
2
90WLEDP38
90
90
9
5
E
A114 Restroom
2
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12.5
5
28
42
12.5
5
*
21
10", Can with new tile
*
22
AC
P
A114 Restroom
2
LB228LP
E
A116 Conference
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
23
P
A116 Conference
4
LB328NP
E
A118 Office
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
P
A118 Office
4
LB328NP
28
73
9
5
E
A120 Office
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
24
*
25
P
A120 Office
4
LB328NP
E
A120A
6
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
26
AC
P
A120A
6
LB428NP
E
H117 CR - Applied Tech
33
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
27
75-80
AC
P
H117 CR - Applied Tech
33
WK4228NP
Wrap Kit with Reflector 4' w 2 F32 28 watt
E
H117A
2
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
28
P
H117A
2
LB228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
H117B
8
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
WK4228NP
28
48
9
5
*
29
P
H117B
8
AC
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H117B
3
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
30
AC, On wall
P
H117B
3
LB228NP
E
J102 Womens Restroom
8
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12.5
5
28
42
12.5
5
*
31
AC, In cove
P
8
LB228LP
E
4
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12.5
5
28
42
12.5
5
*
32
AC
P
4
LB228LP
E
J104 Restroom
8
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12.5
5
28
42
12.5
5
*
33
P
J104 Restroom
8
LB228LP
E
J104 Restroom
4
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12.5
5
P
J104 Restroom
4
LB228LP
28
42
12.5
5
E
J104 B Janitorial Closet
1
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
2
5
28
48
2
5
*
34
*
35
P
J104 B Janitorial Closet
1
WK4228N
T8 Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
J106 CR
15
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
36
AC
P
J106 CR
15
WK4228NP
E
J106 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
37
Task lighting
P
J106 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J108 Mechanical
4
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
2
5
28
42
2
5
*
38
One on top
P
J108 Mechanical
4
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J110 CR
8
ES8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
LB328NP
28
73
9
5
*
39
P
J110 CR
16
Direct / Indirect, AC
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
J110 CR
3
ES4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
40
P
J110 CR
3
LB328NP
E
J110 CR
3
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
41
Task lighting
P
J110 CR
3
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J112 CR
8
ES8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
42
P
J112 CR
16
LB328NP
E
J112 CR
4
ES4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
43
P
J112 CR
4
LB328NP
E
J112 CR
3
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
P
J112 CR
3
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
28
22
9
5
E
J114 CR
8
ES8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
44
*
45
P
J114 CR
16
LB328NP
E
J114 CR
4
ES4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
46
P
J114 CR
4
LB328NP
E
J114 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
47
P
J114 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J116 CR
8
ES8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
48
P
J116 CR
16
LB328NP
E
J116 CR
4
ES4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
LB328NP
28
73
9
5
*
49
P
J116 CR
4
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
J116 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
50
P
J116 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J118 CR
8
ES8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
51
P
J118 CR
16
LB328NP
E
J118 CR
4
ES4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
52
P
J118 CR
4
LB328NP
E
J118 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
53
P
J118 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J120 CR
8
ES8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
P
J120 CR
16
LB328NP
28
73
9
5
E
J120 CR
4
ES4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
54
*
55
P
J120 CR
4
LB328NP
E
J120 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
56
P
J120 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J122 Workroom
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
57
AC
P
J122 Workroom
4
LB328NP
E
J122 Workroom
1
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
42
9
5
*
58
P
J122 Workroom
1
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J122B Office
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
LB328NP
28
73
9
5
*
59
P
J122B Office
4
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
J115 CR
12
ES8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
28
73
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
60
P
J115 CR
24
LB328NP
E
J115 CR
4
ES4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
61
P
J115 CR
4
LB328NP
E
J115 CR
1
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
62
P
J115 CR
1
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J113 Office
3
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
63
P
J113 Office
3
LB428NP
E
J111 CR
15
ES8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
P
J111 CR
30
LB328NP
28
73
9
5
E
J111 CR
5
ES4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
64
*
65
P
J111 CR
5
LB328NP
E
J111 CR
3
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
66
P
J111 CR
3
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J111C
4
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
67
P
J111C
4
LB228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
J111B
2
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
68
P
J111B
2
LB228NP
E
J111A
4
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
LB228NP
28
48
9
5
*
69
P
J111A
4
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
J109 CR
12
ES8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
28
73
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
70
P
J109 CR
24
LB328NP
E
J109 CR
4
ES4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
71
P
J109 CR
4
LB328NP
E
J109 CR
8
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
72
P
J109 CR
8
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J109A
3
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
73
P
J109A
3
LB228NP
E
J107 CR
15
ES8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
P
J107 CR
30
LB328NP
28
73
9
5
E
J107 CR
5
ES4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
74
*
75
P
J107 CR
5
LB328NP
E
J107 CR
6
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
76
P
J107 CR
6
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
J107A
2
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
77
P
J107A
2
TK4228NP
E
J105 CR
11
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
78
P
J105 CR
11
LB328NP
E
J105 CR
3
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
28
22
9
5
*
79
P
J105 CR
3
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
J103 Janitorial Closet
1
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
2
5
28
48
2
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
80
P
J103 Janitorial Closet
1
WK4228NP
E
J101 Gym
24
EFMH400
Existing Fixture Metal Halide 400 watt Lamp
400
458
10
5
54
364
10
5
*
81
65
AC, 22', with cage & lens
P
J101 Gym
24
N1748E654H
New Paragon 1748E Fixture 4' w 6 F54 54
watt T5 Lamp, HBF Ballast
E
J101A
2
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
82
P
J101A
2
LB428NP
E
J101A
2
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
42
9
5
*
83
P
J101A
2
LB228LP
E
J101B Girls Locker
9
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
P
J101B Girls Locker
9
LB228NP
28
48
10
5
E
J101B Girls Locker
5
EV4232N
Existing Vapor Tight T8 4' w 2 F32 32 watt
Lamp, NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
28
48
10
5
*
84
45
*
85
P
J101B Girls Locker
5
LB228NP
E
J101C Storage
5
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
2
5
28
48
2
5
*
86
P
J101C Storage
5
LB228NP
E
J101D
2
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
87
P
J101D
2
LB428NP
E
J101D
1
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
88
P
J101D
1
WK4228NP
E
J101E Boys Locker
12
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
LB228NP
28
48
10
5
*
89
P
J101E Boys Locker
12
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
J101E Boys Locker
4
EV4232N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
28
48
10
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
90
P
J101E Boys Locker
4
LB228NP
E
J101F
4
ET4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
42
9
5
*
91
P
J101F
4
LB228LP
E
Back Entry x 2
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
12
7
28
48
12
7
*
92
P
Back Entry x 2
4
TK4228NP
E
H119
6
ET4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
93
P
H119
6
LB228NP
E
H119A
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
P
H119A
4
TK4228NP
28
48
9
5
E
H119B
3
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
94
*
95
P
H119B
3
LB228NP
E
H124 Weight Room
14
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
10
5
28
73
10
5
*
96
P
H124 Weight Room
14
LB328NP
E
H124B
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
97
P
H124B
4
LB328NP
E
H122 CR
18
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
98
AC
P
H122 CR
18
LB328NP
E
Short Hall by H113
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
12
7
TK4228NP
28
48
12
7
*
99
P
Short Hall by H113
4
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H116 Electrical
3
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
2
5
28
42
2
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
100
P
H116 Electrical
3
LB228LP
E
H113 Womens Locker Room
15
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
28
48
10
5
*
101
AC
P
15
LB228NP
E
4
EV4232N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
28
48
10
5
*
102
AC
P
4
LB228NP
E
2
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
28
48
10
5
*
103
AC
P
2
LB228NP
E
H113A Office
2
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
P
H113A Office
2
WK4228N
T8 Lamp, NBF Ballast
28
48
9
5
E
H113A Office
1
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
104
*
105
P
H113A Office
1
LB228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
Stairs to Mezzanine
2
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12
7
28
42
12
7
*
106
P
Stairs to Mezzanine
2
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H203 Mat Room
20
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
10
5
28
48
10
5
*
107
P
H203 Mat Room
20
WK4228NP
E
H203 Mat Room
3
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
28
48
10
5
*
108
P
H203 Mat Room
3
LB228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
H202 Mechanical
9
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
2
5
LB228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
28
48
2
5
*
109
P
H202 Mechanical
9
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H118 Book Storage
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
2
5
28
48
2
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
110
P
H118 Book Storage
4
TK4228NP
E
H120 Book Storage
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
2
5
28
48
2
5
*
111
P
H120 Book Storage
4
TK4228NP
E
K101 Kitchen
16
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
12
5
28
48
12
5
*
112
P
K101 Kitchen
16
TK4228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
K101 Kitchen
2
EINC100
100
100
12
5
P
K101 Kitchen
2
16WLED
16 watt A19 Style LED Phillips Lamp
16
16
12
5
E
K101 Restroom in Kitchen
1
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
12.5
5
P
K101 Restroom in Kitchen
1
TK4228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
28
48
12.5
5
E
K101B
2
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
113
*
114
*
115
P
K101B
2
TK4228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
Walk-In
1
EINC100
100
100
2
5
P
Walk-In
1
16WLED
16 watt A19 Style LED Phillips Lamp
16
16
2
5
E
L101 Library
52
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
116
45
Locked, fixture may also be VT 2L HO T12
*
117
P
L101 Library
52
LB428NP
E
L101 Library
23
ECFL226
Existing Dual 26 watt Compact Fluorescent
Lamp
26
52
9
5
P
L101 Library
23
14WLEDP30
14
14
9
5
E
L101 Library
9
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
LB328NP
28
73
9
5
*
118
*
119
P
L101 Library
9
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
L107 Video
3
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
48
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
120
P
L107 Video
3
TK4228NP
E
L108 CPU
6
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
121
P
L108 CPU
6
LB328NP
E
L109
6
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
122
P
L109
6
TK4228NP
E
L104
2
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
123
P
L104
2
LB428NP
E
L103 Conference
2
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
P
L103 Conference
2
LB428NP
28
94
9
5
E
L102
3
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
124
*
125
AC
P
L102
3
LB328NP
E
H101 CR
8
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
126
AC
P
H101 CR
8
LB428NP
E
H103 Restroom
10
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12.5
5
28
42
12.5
5
*
127
P
H103 Restroom
10
LB228LP
E
H103 Restroom
3
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12.5
5
28
42
12.5
5
*
128
P
H103 Restroom
3
LB228LP
E
H103 Restroom
1
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
12.5
5
WK4228NP
28
48
12.5
5
*
129
P
H103 Restroom
1
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H105 Janitorial Closet
2
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
2
5
28
48
2
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
130
P
H105 Janitorial Closet
2
WK4228NP
E
H107 Mens Restroom
11
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12.5
5
28
42
12.5
5
*
131
P
H107 Mens Restroom
11
LB228LP
E
H107 Mens Restroom
3
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
12.5
5
28
42
12.5
5
*
132
P
H107 Mens Restroom
3
LB228LP
E
H107 Mens Restroom
1
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
12.5
5
28
48
12.5
5
*
133
P
H107 Mens Restroom
1
WK4228NP
E
H107A Electrical
1
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
2
5
P
H107A Electrical
1
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
28
42
2
5
E
H109B Multi-Purpose Room
48
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
134
*
135
P
48
LB328NP
E
8
EW8632N
NBF Ballast
32
170
9
5
LB428L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
28
82
9
5
9
5
28
42
9
5
50-65
*
136
P
E
8
Warm white
*
136A
Warm white
P
8
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
28
42
9
5
9
5
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
9
5
*
137
P
E
4
Warm white
*
137A
P
4
Warm white
28
22
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
2
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
42
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
138
P
2
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H109A Electrical
3
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
2
5
28
48
2
5
*
139
P
H109A Electrical
3
LB228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
H111 Mens Locker
3
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
10
5
28
48
10
5
*
140
P
H111 Mens Locker
3
TK4228NP
E
H111B Locker Room
15
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
28
48
10
5
*
141
P
H111B Locker Room
15
LB228NP
E
H111B Locker Room
2
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
P
H111B Locker Room
2
LB228NP
28
48
10
5
E
H111B Locker Room
5
EV4232N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
32
58
10
5
28
48
10
5
*
142
*
143
P
H111B Locker Room
5
LB228NP
E
H111A Office
2
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
144
P
H111A Office
2
WK4228NP
E
H111A Office
1
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
42
9
5
*
145
P
H111A Office
1
LB228LP
E
H113 Gym
30
EFHPS400
watt Lamp
400
464
10
5
54
364
10
5
*
146
70
26', with cage & lens
P
H113 Gym
30
N1748E654H
New Paragon 1748E Fixture 4' w 6 F54 54
watt T5 Lamp, HBF Ballast
E
H113 Gym
12
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
10
5
WK4228NP
28
48
10
5
*
147
P
H113 Gym
12
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H113H
2
ET4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
148
P
H113H
2
LB228NP
E
H1113H
6
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
149
P
H1113H
6
LB228NP
E
Entry x 2
2
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
12
7
28
48
12
7
*
150
P
Entry x 2
2
TK4228NP
E
H113D
4
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
42
9
5
*
151
P
H113D
4
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H113E
4
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
P
H113E
4
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
28
42
9
5
E
H126
4
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
152
*
153
AC
P
H126
4
LB328NP
E
H121 CR
12
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
154
AC
P
H121 CR
12
LB428NP
E
H121 CR
3
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
155
AC, task lighting
P
H121 CR
3
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H123 CR
12
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
156
P
H123 CR
12
LB428NP
E
H123 CR
3
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
28
22
9
5
*
157
P
H123 CR
3
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H128 CR
12
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
158
P
H128 CR
12
LB428NP
E
H128 CR
11
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
159
Task lighting
P
H128 CR
11
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H130
1
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
160
P
H130
1
WK4228NP
E
H137 Prep
13
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
161
P
H137 Prep
13
WK4228NP
E
H201 Mechanical (Up-Pull-Down)
7
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
2
5
P
H201 Mechanical (Up-Pull-Down)
7
LB228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
28
48
2
5
E
H125 CR
12
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
162
*
163
P
H125 CR
12
LB428NP
E
H125 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
164
Task lighting
P
H125 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H127 CR
12
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
165
P
H127 CR
12
LB428NP
E
H127 CR
1
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
166
P
H127 CR
1
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H132 Womens Restroom
7
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
12.5
5
WK4228NP
28
48
12.5
5
*
167
P
H132 Womens Restroom
7
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H132B Janitorial Closet
2
ES4234N
Existing Strip 4' 2 Lamp F34 T12 Standard
Ballast
34
82
2
5
28
42
2
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
168
P
H132B Janitorial Closet
2
LB228LP
E
H134 Mens Restroom
7
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
12.5
5
28
48
12.5
5
*
169
P
H134 Mens Restroom
7
WK4228NP
E
H134A Electrical
1
ES4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
2
5
28
42
2
5
*
170
P
H134A Electrical
1
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H129 CR
12
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
171
P
H129 CR
12
LB428NP
E
H129 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
P
H129 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
28
22
9
5
E
H131 CR
12
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
172
*
173
P
H131 CR
12
LB428NP
E
H131 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
174
P
H131 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H133 CR
12
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
175
P
H133 CR
12
LB428NP
E
H133 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
176
P
H133 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H138 CR
12
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
LB428NP
28
94
9
5
*
177
P
H138 CR
12
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H138 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
178
P
H138 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H136 CR
27
ES8432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
179
P
H136 CR
27
LB428NP
E
H136 CR
7
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
180
P
H136 CR
7
LB328NP
E
H136 CR
3
EFMV250
Existing Fixture Mercury Vapor 250 watt
Lamp
250
285
9
5
32
146
9
5
*
181
Surface mount
P
H136 CR
3
NT4432H
New Troffer Fixture 4' w 4 F32 32 watt
Lamp, HBF Ballast
E
H136A
2
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
P
H136A
2
WK4228NP
28
48
9
5
E
H136B
2
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
182
*
183
P
H136B
2
WK4228NP
E
Mechanical (Up-Pull-Down)
3
EV4232N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
32
58
2
5
28
48
2
5
*
184
P
Mechanical (Up-Pull-Down)
3
LB228N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
H136C
1
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
185
P
H136C
1
LB428NP
E
H139 CR
18
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
186
P
H139 CR
18
LB428NP
E
H141 CR
11
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
LB428NP
28
94
9
5
*
187
P
H141 CR
11
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H141 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
188
Task lighting
P
H141 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H146 CR
12
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
189
P
H146 CR
12
LB428NP
E
H146 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
190
Task lighting
P
H146 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H144 CR
15
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
191
P
H144 CR
15
LB428NP
E
H144 CR
7
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
P
H144 CR
7
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
28
22
9
5
E
H142 CR
18
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
192
Task lighting
*
193
P
H142 CR
18
LB328NP
E
H142 CR
4
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
22
9
5
*
194
Task lighting
P
H142 CR
4
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H140
1
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
42
9
5
*
195
P
H140
1
LB228L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
E
H135 CR
16
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
196
P
H135 CR
16
LB428NP
E
H135 CR
6
ES4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
LB128L
Lamp, LBF Ballast
28
22
9
5
*
197
P
H135 CR
6
Task lighting
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H140 Stage
13
EW4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
72
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
198
P
H140 Stage
13
LB328N
Lamp, NBF Ballast
E
Prop Storage
6
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
2
5
28
48
2
5
*
199
P
Prop Storage
6
TK4228NP
E
Theater
31
EINC65
65
65
9
5
P
Theater
31
14WLEDP30
14
14
9
5
E
Theater
32
ET4132N
NBF Ballast
32
32
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
200
Warm white
*
201
P
Theater
16
LB228NP
E
Theater
2
EW4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
P
Theater
2
WK4228NP
28
48
9
5
E
Control Room
3
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
202
*
203
AC
P
Control Room
3
LB328NP
E
H102 Music
1
EW4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
204
P
H102 Music
1
WK4228NP
E
H102 Music
26
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
205
P
H102 Music
26
LB328NP
E
H102A Office
2
ET4432N
NBF Ballast
32
112
9
5
28
94
9
5
*
206
AC
P
H102A Office
2
LB428NP
E
H102B
2
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
TK4228NP
28
48
9
5
*
207
P
H102B
2
AC
Energy Audit
Project
Name
Facility
Contact
675 Ravens Way
Building
Contact
Phone
Address
City
State
County
ECM
#
Eielson Afb
Phone
Alaska
Facility
Type
0.00%
Tax Rate
99702
Zip Code
Sandra Edwards
(206) 303-0121
Auditor(s)
Mike Campbell
NWE Contact Phone
(509) 680-3963
Audit Date
11/21/11
Office Phone #
(425) 806-9200
Last Revised
1/23/12
Office Fax #
(425) 806-7455
Ext.
Utility
Golden Valley Elec
Demand Rate
$10.79
Heat
Lamp
Replace
Ballast
Replace
Second Tier
Start Level
0.0000
Group
PCB /
Percent
Maint. Rate
Ext.
Sq. Feet
AC
Spot
Location
Fixture
Qty
Fixture ID
Lamp
Watts
Fixture
Watts
Fixture
Height
Hours/ Days/W
Day
eek
H102C
2
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
FC
Sensor
Qty
Sensor /
Power Pack
kWh Rate
Energy
Saved
15.600¢
Sensor
Height
Survey Notes
*
E
208
AC
P
H102C
2
LB328NP
E
H102C
12
EINC40
40
40
9
5
P
H102C
12
8WLEDA19
8 watt LED A-19 Lamp
8
8
9
5
E
Back Door to Stage
4
EW4232N
NBF Ballast
32
58
9
5
28
48
9
5
*
209
Globe vanity
*
210
P
Back Door to Stage
4
LB228NP
E
H102D
2
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
28
73
9
5
*
211
P
H102D
2
LB328NP
E
H102D
24
EINC40
40
40
9
5
P
H102D
24
8WLEDA19
8 watt LED A-19 Lamp
8
8
9
5
E
H102E
2
ET4332N
NBF Ballast
32
85
9
5
LB328NP
28
73
9
5
*
212
Globe vanity
*
213
P
H102E
2
E
Existing Fixture Total
1,741
P
Proposed Fixture Total
1,839
*
Sensor Total
0
Lighting - Calculations and Common Conversions
Sample Calculation:
Fixture Quantity = 52
Existing Fixture (Troffer T8 4’ w 3 F32 32 watt lamp NBF)
Proposed Fixture (Light & Ballast retrofitted with 3 lamp F32 T8 28 watt lamp PRS NBF Ballast)
Existing Wattage Lamp Wattage = 32 Watts
Proposed Wattage Lamp Wattage = 28 Watts
Existing Watts/Fixture = 85 Watts
Proposed Watts/Fixture = 73 Watts
Existing Lighting Power: [ kWEX ]
((# Fixtures) EX x (Watts / Fixture) EX) / (1,000 W/kW) = kWEX
52 x 85/1000 = 4.42 kW (existing)
Proposed Lighting Power: [kWPR]
((# Fixtures) PR x (Watts / Fixture) PR) / (1,000 W/kW) = kWPR
52 x73/1000 = 3.796 kW (proposed)
Existing Lighting Power Consumption: [kWhEX]
(kWEX) x (Annual Burn Hours) = kWhEX
4.42 kW (existing) x (12 hrs/day)x (7days/wk) x 48 wks./year = 17, 821.44 kWh (Existing)
Proposed Lighting Power Consumption: [kWhPR]
(kWPR) x (Annual Burn Hours) = kWhPR
3.796 kW (proposed) x (12 hrs/day)x (7days/wk) x 48 wks./year = 15, 305.47 kWh (Proposed)
The following calculations were performed on a building-by-building basis:
Annual Lighting Power Savings: [KwLGHT]
(kWEX) – (kWPR) = KwLGHT
4.42 kW – 3.796 kW = .0624 kW
Annual Lighting Power Consumption Savings: [kWhLGHT]
(kWhEX) – (kWhPR) = kWhLGHT
17,821.44 kWh – 15,305.47 kWh= 2,515.96 kWh
Illuminating Engineering Society of North America
(IESNA)
RECOMMENDED LIGHT LEVELS
Table 1.00a – IESNA Lighting Levels
Type of Space
Assembly Areas
Office Areas
Dining Areas
Retail Areas
Classroom Areas
Corridors
Restrooms
Misc.
Exit/Emergency
Mechanical Rooms
Stairwells
Gymnasium
Shop Areas
Category
2
C
C&E
3
B
E
C&E
A
B
C
B
C
A
Various
E
Foot-candles
10 to 15
20 to 50
5
50
20 to 50
5
5
10 to 15
5
10 to15
3
30 to 50
50
Target illuminances are based on the recommendations of the IESNA.
Space Type
Auditorium
Banking Activity Area
Break Room (Dining)
Classroom / Lecture Hall / Training room
Closet
Conference / Meeting Room
Convention Hall Multipurpose Area
Corridor
Dining
Electrical / Mechanical Area
Examination Room (Medical)
Exercise Area
Exhibition Hall
Financial Institution
Food Preparation (Kitchen area)
Grocery Store General Merchandise Area
Gymnasium Playing Area
Hotel Function Area
Hotel Lobby
Industrial Area < 20ft. ceiling height
Industrial Area > 20ft. ceiling height
Kitchen / Food Preparation
Laboratory Medical
Laboratory - Industrial
Library
Lobby - Hotel
Lobby - Waiting Area (Other Buildings)
Mall General Sales Area (see Retail Sales)
Mall Arcade / Atrium / Concourse
Manufacturing (Industrial) Area < 20ft. ceiling height
Manufacturing (Industrial) Area > 20ft. ceiling height
Medical and Clinical Care
Multipurpose Room (Meeting Room)
Museum
Nurses Stations (Medical)
Office, Private (< 300 sq. ft.)
Office, Open Plan (> 300 sq. ft.)
Reception Area (Lobby)
Religious Worship
Restaurant
Restroom
Retail Sales Fine Merchandise Area
Retail Sales General Merchandise Area and Wholesale Showroom
Shipping (Industrial) Area < 20ft. ceiling height
Shipping (Industrial) Area > 20ft. ceiling height
Stairs (Support Area)
Storage - Industrial, Commercial
Theater - Motion Picture
Theater - Motion Picture, Lobby
Theater - Performance
Warehouse Area < 20ft. ceiling height
Warehouse Area > 20ft. ceiling height
"Other Lighting" Codes:
A: plus 0.9 W/Sq. Ft. for Accent Lighting
C: plus 1.4 W/Sq. Ft. for Accent Lighting
C1: plus 3.5 W/Sq. Ft. for Accent Lighting
D: plus 0.9 W/Sq. Ft. for Medical Lighting
Lighting Power Allowance
Light
(LPA)
Level
W/Sq. Ft.
Target
CLP Allowance Other Lighting (Footcandles)
1.4
1.8
1.3
1.4
0.9
1.4
1.4
0.7
1.3
0.9
1.4
1.0
3.0
1.8
2.0
1.9
1.7
2.2>
1.7
1.9
2.7
2.0
1.4
1.9
1.6
1.7
0.9
1.3
1.9
2.7
1.4
1.4
1.4
1.4
1.4
1.4
0.9
2.9
1.5
0.7
1.9
1.9
1.9
2.7
0.7
0.9
0.9
0.9
1.4
1.9
2.7
A
A
A
A
D
A
A
C
A
A
D
A
A
A
D
A
D
A
A
A
C1
C
A
10
50
30
30
N/A
30
30
5
10
N/A
50
50
10
30
50
50
60
30
10
30
30
50
50
50
30
10
10
30
50
50
50
30
10
30
50
30
30
10
30
10
30
30
30
30
5
10
10
30
10
10
10
“ENERGY EFFECTIVE” LIGHTING FOR CLASSROOMS: COMBINING QUALITY DESIGN AND ENERGY EFFICIENCY
C L A S S R O O M
L I G H T I N G
General Classroom Layouts
Computer Classroom Layouts
Corridor Layouts
Lighting Fixture Specifications
TOPICS:
The Value of Lighting Quality
Lighting Controls
Daylighting
knowhow
CLASSROOM LIGHTING
Good lighting promotes better
learning. Today’s schools must
provide a stimulating environment
where children will learn best.
High quality lighting improves
students’ moods, behavior,
concentration, and therefore their
learning.1
1 - Adapted from “Designing the Future,” AIA Center for
Building Performance.
1
2
3
George Leisey/Photographer, Bellows Falls, VT
4
better yet
Lighting quality means visual
comfort, good color, uniformity
and balanced brightness. This
can be achieved with lightcolored materials, glare control,
distribution
of light to
ceiling and walls,
and flexible
lighting controls.
These factors
contribute to
long-term system
performance and
aid in student
concentration.
Shadows, glare,
lamp flicker
or chaotic patterns
can be distracting
and should be
avoided. (See the chart below for
the importance of quality factors.)
This guide
gives you the
knowhow to
provide “energy
effective”
lighting for
classrooms –
Classrooms
lighting
with windows
help keep
systems that
children alert.
optimize
See back page
energy use
for more
while creating
information
on daylighting.
a productive,
comfortable,
and adaptable
learning environment. Energy
effective lighting is the best use of
financial and natural resources.
Lighting on the walls and ceiling improves lighting quality.
Numbers refer to quality issues in chart below.
ACHIEVING BETTER &
BETTER YET RESULTS
Classrooms often are lighted by
recessed parabolic fluorescent
2’ x 4’ or 2’ x 2’ fixtures, systems
that may not provide the best
quality of light for learning. This
knowhow guide shows you energy
effective solutions that will deliver
Better quality with improved energy
efficiency. The Better Yet solutions
identify further improvements,
providing even greater long-term
value for schools.
QUALITY ISSUES FOR SCHOOL LIGHTING
Light on walls and ceilings 1 on photo above
Control of direct and reflected glare 2
Uniformity 3
Daylight 4
Color rendering and color temperature
Lighting controls
Quantity of light (horizontal footcandles)
Very Important
Important
General
Classroom
Computer
Classroom
School
Corridor
40-50 fc
20-40 fc
10 vert. fc
Somewhat Important
* Adapted from the Lighting Design Guide.
IESNA Lighting Handbook, 9th Edition
Copyright 2002, Northeast Energy Efficiency Partnerships, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Any use, reproduction or distribution of knowhow
or its contents without the express written consent of NEEP is prohibited. Contact www.neep.org or (781) 860-9177 ext. 10.
knowhow classroom lighting
how to achieve
lighting quality
COLORS & FINISH TIPS
USE HIGHER REFLECTANCES
A small increase in room
70%
reflectances (lighter-colored
surfaces) greatly improves efficiency.
The lighter-colored room (below)
40%
provides 55% more light on the work
40%
surface for the same energy or uses
70% less energy for equivalent
20%
brightness. The lighter-colored
room also provides better daylight
distribution, improves brightness ratios, and is more visually comfortable.
These significant improvements are possible at little or no additional cost.
Light is both reflected and absorbed
90%
by surfaces. Lighter colors reflect
more than darker colors. When
more light is reflected, room surfaces
70%
become more uniform and visually
comfortable. Reflectances are
40%
deceiving – surfaces absorb more
light than you think! Don’t guess:
verify finish reflectances with manufacturers.
70%
CONTROL GLARE
Glare occurs when bright light sources and reflections interfere with the
viewing of less bright objects. This high contrast may be uncomfortable
or even disabling. Direct Glare is caused by fixtures located in front of
students. Overhead Glare is caused by fixtures directly overhead. Reflected
Glare is caused by bright reflections in surfaces such as glossy papers,
shiny surfaces or computer screens. Glare control is especially important
in flexible classrooms where desks and tables may face any direction, or
in rooms with full time computer use.
• Acoustic ceiling tiles are often only 70% reflective. Specify 80% or
higher. Ceiling tile and paint companies list these values in their
product specifications.
• Choose wall colors that are light in color (pastels) and at least
65% reflective.
• Choose furniture that is light in color (60% or higher).
• Always use matte (not shiny or high gloss) surface finishes for
walls, ceilings, and furniture.
• Limit the use of primary or saturated colors to accents or wainscots,
since they absorb a lot of light.
CREATE BALANCED BRIGHTNESS
Light levels throughout the classroom should not differ greatly from the
light level on the desks. Large variations in brightness will cause
distraction and fatigue.
• Use pendant light fixtures that direct at least 50% of the light upward.
• Avoid high contrast. The brightest and darkest room surfaces should be
no greater than 3 times or 1/3 as bright as the task (preferred) or 10
times or 1/10 as bright as the task (maximum).
• For best student concentration, the brightest surfaces should be desk
tops and focal walls.
• Use only semi-specular or white louvers to prevent harsh wall patterns.
10:1
2:1
1:3
GLARE PREVENTION TIPS
• Distribute light to walls and ceilings. Bi-directional fixtures such
as A, D, and E (see p. 7) work well.
• Use daylight to light walls and ceilings.
• Use adjustable blinds or shades that control window glare while
retaining view.
• Choose higher reflectance room surfaces.
• Select only semi-specular or white painted louvers and reflectors.
Avoid mirrored or specular (shiny) reflectors or louvers that can
be seen from any angle.
• Shield the lamp from view with baffles, louvers, lenses or
diffusing overlays.
• Use lamps of lower brightness. Use more fixtures if necessary.
• Only use T5, T5HO and T5 biaxial lamps in coves or indirect
applications where the lamp is not visible by classroom users.
• Use no more than three (3) T8 lamps in 2’ x 4’ fixtures.
2
ACCENT FOCAL WALLS
The brightest surfaces should be the most important surfaces. Lighting
the focal walls helps teachers catch and hold students’ attention as well
as to improve the visibility of information.
• For rooms where desks face one direction, provide focal lighting on
the front wall or board.
• For multi-purpose spaces, provide focal lighting on two or three walls.
• Dedicate light fixtures (such as Type H, J, K) to accent these surfaces.
• Light levels on boards or focal walls should be at least equal to light
levels on the desktop, or up to twice that level if the board is green or
black. For uniformity, the edges of the board should not be less than
1/3 the brightness of the center.
• Locate fixtures 1 to 3 feet from the board or vertical surface so that
light reflections do not obscure information on the board.
lighting controls
Lighting controls give teachers the flexibility to set the lighting level to match the tasks being performed.
Controls also turn off lights automatically in an empty room or dim the electric lights when there is enough
daylight. For lighting controls to operate properly, they must be checked and set at the beginning of each school
year. Calibration and maintenance of lighting controls are essential for energy conservation.
MATCH CONTROLS TO ROOM TYPES
General
Classroom
Computer School
Potential
Classroom Corridor Energy Savings*
30%
35%
45%
15%
10%
Ceiling Occupancy Sensor, Manual-On, Auto-Off
Multi-Level Switching with Ceiling Occupancy Sensor
Daylight Controls with Occupancy Sensor
Multi-Level Switching
Building Time Controls
Appropriate
Sometimes Appropriate
* As compared to standard manual switching for a 5,000
Not Appropriate
Conserve Energy by:
• Reducing power. Use energy
efficient sources, ballasts and
luminaires. The power limit*
for schools is 1.5 w/sf total
connected load.
• Reducing energy use. Provide
lighting controls to reduce the
time of use (by switching) or
level of power (by dimming).
• Wise design. Integrate daylight,
room surfaces and layouts.
• Proper maintenance. Clean
surfaces, group relamp,
calibrate controls.
* ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Std. 90.1 - 2001
sq. ft. building with a 1.2 watts per sq. ft. connected load.
OCCUPANCY SENSORS
• Require that lights turn off automatically when spaces are not occupied.
• Use manual-on automatic switches (AS) with ceiling or wall
mounted sensors (OS) for all spaces with daylight or receiving
spill light from other rooms. Manual-on prevents unnecessary
activation when daylight is adequate or when doors are opened.
The switches also allow the lights to be turned off for AV purposes. AS
• Manual-off is recommended only as a temporary override. Sensor must
stay in automatic-off mode at all times.
• Use ultrasonic sensors – they are more sensitive than infrared to
subtle motion and less likely to turn lights off in an
occupied room. Dual technology is not required when
OS
sensor is to be used with manual-on capability.
• Set sensors for medium to high sensitivity and 10-minute delay.
• Locate sensors inside classrooms so they do not “see” corridor motion.
MULTI-LEVEL SWITCHING
• Avoid less-efficient one-lamp ballasts. Use master-slave wiring between
adjacent fixtures and use multi-lamp ballasts. (See layouts 1, 6 & 7.)
• Use switchable two-level ballasts for three-lamp fixtures. Occupants
can choose between two levels of light while maintaining uniform
distribution.
SEPARATE ROW SWITCHING
• Provide multiple levels in a uniform pattern by factory-wiring each
row of lamps separately (shown below) or dimming. Avoid distracting
switching patterns.
OCCUPANCY SENSOR (OS) & PHOTOSENSOR (PS) TIPS
The row of lights closest to the window dims in response to daylight.
DAYLIGHTING CONTROLS AND PHOTOSENSORS
• Orient fixtures parallel to window wall. (See layouts 1 to 5.)
• Control each row of lamps separately.
• Continuous dimming is much better than switching
– there are no distractions and greater energy
savings. Electronic dimming ballasts typically dim
PS
to 10% of full output.
• Start dimming when combined light levels exceed
125% of designed light level.
• Specify photosensors of the “continuous response” type.
• Use “open loop” controls, i.e. photosensor is located to respond to
daylight only, rather than located to sense daylight and the electric light
source being controlled. (See windows.lbl.gov/daylighting/designguide/
designguide.htm for reference.)
• Specify a 60 second time delay to allow for temporary cloud cover.
Optimum product locations, coverage areas and wiring requirements
vary between products – work closely with manufacturers to verify
appropriate coverage, installation and location. Redesign may be
required if products are substituted during construction.
3
classroom lighting
16’
general and multi-purpose classrooms
H
What Makes Layout 1 ‘Acceptable’?
• Fixtures are oriented parallel to window; best for front focus,
multipurpose uses, and daylighting.
• Fixtures use minimum 3” deep louver for greater comfort.
• Separate light on front board increases visibility and student attentiveness.
• Master-slave wiring saves energy by using multi-lamp ballasts.
• Occupancy sensors with manual-on switches save more energy in daylit spaces.
What Makes Layout 2 ‘Better’?
• More visually comfortable than recessed or totally direct fixtures.
• Wider distribution puts more light on walls.
• White louvers and spill light on ceiling reduce fixture glare.
• Two-level switching of continuous rows more uniform.
• Best choice for ceiling lower than 8’-9’.
AS
master-slave wiring
OS
LAYOUT 1 –
What Makes Layout 3 ‘Better Yet’?
• Combination direct/indirect more comfortable than totally direct or
surface systems. Works well for part-day computer use.
• Direct/indirect more energy efficient than totally indirect systems.
• Pendants faster to install than recessed fixtures, and easier to maintain.
• Most cost effective. Greatest long-term value for investment.
• Overhead glare not a problem, due to T8 lamp and lighted ceiling.
• Wide distribution and white louvers reduce contrast and increase uniformity.
• Separate light fixtures accentuate front board.
ACCEPTABLE
10’
J
B
BETTER
Controls Upgrade: Switch fixture adjacent to window separately, and connect to
photosensor for automatic response to daylight. This is more reliable than leaving
daylight control to the teachers.
Alternative 2A: Add 3” stems and diffuser on top, to increase light on ceiling.
Controls Upgrade:3 Provide dimming ballasts and photosensor
for better control of light levels.
Alternative 3A: Use Type D T-8 fixtures with parabolic louvers,
to provide more shielding for intensive computer use.
34’
C
AS
OS
12’
D
LAYOUT 2 -
BETTER
16’
LAYOUT TIPS FOR WIDER ROOMS
• For rooms 28 to 34 feet wide with continuous windows along the long wall,
consider shifting both rows of fixtures 2 to 4 feet farther away from the windows.
• For rooms 34 to 38 feet wide, use three rows of fixtures.
• Perform lighting level calculations to verify expected light levels.
BETTER YET
12’
K
COMPARISON CHART FOR GENERAL CLASSROOMS
For classrooms from 750 to 850 sf.
Interest
Uniformity
Comfort & Quality
Power Density (w/sf)
Energy Savings (Potential %)2
First Cost (% Increase)
Maintained Footcandles (fc)
OVERALL VALUE
Base Case1
Layout 1
Layout 2
Layout 3
1.32
1.01
1.16
1.16
Base
46%
40%
40%
Base
40%
170%
115%
50-60
45-50
45-50
45-50
ACCEPTABLE
BETTER
BETTER YET
Layouts shown will meet light level requirements and current energy codes if they are within the given size ranges, between 8’0”
and 9’6” ceiling heights. 1 - Base case assumptions used for comparison are 12 fixtures, recessed 3-lamp 2’x4’ parabolic 12cell with T8 electronic ballasts and two-level switching. 2 - Includes savings due to controls shown. Control upgrades will yield
greater energy savings. 3 - Go to www.designlights.org/classroomwiring/ for schematic daylighting control diagrams.
4
ACCEPTABLE
24’
A
AS
OS
LAYOUT 3 –
BETTER YET
See page 7 for complete fixture specifications.
For computer classrooms from 750 to 850 sf.
Base Case1
Interest
Uniformity
Comfort & Quality
Maintained Footcandles (fc)
OVERALL VALUE
Alt. 4A
Layout 5
1.32
1.01
1.01
1.01
Base
46%
46%
Base
46%
12%
30%
30%
40-50
35-40
30-35
35-40
BETTER
BETTER
BETTER YET
Layout 4
Layouts shown will meet light level requirements and current energy codes if they are within the given size ranges, between
8’6" and 9’6" ceiling heights. 1 - Base case used for comparison is 12 fixtures, recessed 3-lamp 2’ x 4’ deep-cell VDT
parabolic, 27-cells, with T8 electronic ballasts and two-level switching. 2 - Includes savings due to controls shown.
Control upgrades will yield greater energy savings.
16’
12’
AS
F
“Pendant fixtures can save installation
time and cost, since they only
require one power feed at the end
of each row.”
Electrical Contractor, Braza Electric
What Makes Layout 4 ‘Better’?
• Indirect lighting more comfortable than totally direct systems.
• No overhead glare.
• Greater uniformity of light on ceilings and walls.
• Two levels of control provide flexibility and energy savings.
• Glowing sides reduce contrast, increase comfort.
• Pendant fixtures faster to install and easier to maintain.
Controls Upgrade: Provide a third switch to control lamps
nearest the front of the room for better contrast on video screen.
34’
Alternative 4A: Same layout. Use fixture Type F1 with T5HO
lamps. (See T5 box on page 6.)
• High lumen output of the T5HO lamp
F1
requires half the amount of lamps.
• Illuminance decreased. Appropriate for
computer use only.
OS
LAYOUT 4 –
BETTER
10’
J
12’
AS
OS
D
LAYOUT 5 –
BETTER YET
What Makes Layout 5 ‘Better Yet’?
• Combination direct/indirect more comfortable than
totally direct.
• Direct/indirect more energy efficient than totally indirect.
• More cost effective. Greatest value for investment.
• T8 lamp and lighted ceiling prevent overhead glare.
• Higher light levels and 2-level switching more flexible
for computer rooms with paper tasks.
• Separate fixtures used for front board when video
screen not in use.
Controls Upgrade: Provide dimming ballasts and wall box
dimmer for better light level control.
Alternative 5A: Same layout. Use Type E
three-lamp T-8 fixtures.
• Direct and indirect components
can be controlled separately.
• Greatest flexibility for rooms used
for both computers and paper tasks.
E
Use A Different
Approach for
Computer Rooms
• Avoid totally direct
lighting systems.
• Recessed fixtures leave
ceilings dark. Contrast
between bright lamps
or lens and dark
ceiling is too great
for computer rooms.
• Specular (shiny)
louvers or reflectors
create overhead glare
(see diagram) and
harsh patterns.
OVERHEAD
GLARE ZONE
LUMINAIRE
SHIELDING
ANGLE
"NORMAL ANGLES"
OF VIEW (45°)
COMPARISON CHART FOR COMPUTER CLASSROOMS
Photo by Whitney Cox. Courtesy of Norman Rosenfeld Architect.
computer classrooms
• Small-cell louvers are
very inefficient and
create cave-like rooms.
• Always provide some
light on ceiling and
walls. Distribute light as
uniformly as possible.
5
lamp and ballast
specifications
school corridors
T5 LAMPS
LAYOUT 6 –
LAYOUT 7 –
BETTER
BETTER YET
8’
M
M1
34’
8’
L
L1
master-slave
ballast wiring
What Makes Layout 6
‘Better’?
• One-lamp fixtures, oriented
parallel to corridor, provide
uniform distribution on lockers
and walls.
• Master-slave ballast wiring saves
energy by using multi-lamp
ballasts.
What Makes Layout 7
‘Better Yet’?
• Surface mounted fixture allows
for greater ceiling height.
• Works well with any tile system
and access panels.
• Wide distribution and white
louvers provide most uniformity.
T5 lamps are not a replacement
for T8 lamps. They are different
lengths, use different sockets
and ballasts, and have different
pros and cons.
Advantages:
• Smaller size allows for
greater reflector control.
• Smaller lamps and ballasts
allow for smaller fixtures.
• Higher lumen output (T5HO)
reduces the number of lamps
and ballasts to maintain.
• Costs for T5 fixtures are
competitive with T8 fixtures.
• Efficiency of T5 and T8
systems are comparable.
Disadvantages:
• Excessive brightness of T5
and T5HO limits their use to
primarily indirect fixtures.
• Current replacement cost of
components (lamps and
ballasts) higher than T8,
but will reduce over time.
• Using one T5HO lamp instead
of two T8 lamps eliminates
two-level switching options.
• Adds an additional lamp type
to a project, complicating
ordering, maintenance
and repair.
The following specifications apply to
all of the fixture types shown on page 7
for both T8 and T5 linear fluorescent
systems.
Lamp Criteria:
• Minimum Color Rendering Index
(CRI) of 80.
• Color temperature of 3500 Kelvin or
4100 Kelvin. Provide mockup for other
colors. Note: Generic color code "835"
means CRI of 80 and color temperature
of 3500.
• Mean lamp lumens (at 40% of rated
life) at least 94% of initial lumens.
Ballasts and Lamp-Ballast
System Criteria:
• High-frequency electronic using instant
start or program rapid start circuitry.
• Harmonic distortion shall not
exceed 20%.
• Ballast factor minimum 0.88 for T8
and 1.0 for T5.
• Consider "low" or "high" ballast factor
ballasts to optimize lamp count, input
watts, and power density. Limit any
ballast type to only one type of fixture.
• Mean system efficacy (mean lamp
lumens times # of lamps divided by
ballast input power): Minimum 83
lumens/watt for 4’ long T8 at 25°C
and minimum 80 lumens/watt for
4’ long T5HO at 35°C.
COMPARISON CHART FOR SCHOOL CORRIDORS
Base Case1
Interest
Uniformity
Comfort & Quality
Maintained Footcandles (fc)3
Layout 6
Layout 7
0.61
0.49
0.49
Base
20%
20%
Base
60%
23%
on walls
5-15
8-12
8-12
OVERALL VALUE
ACCEPTABLE
BETTER
BETTER YET
1-Base case assumptions used for comparison are 2’x4’ lensed fixtures, with two T8 lamps and electronic
ballasts, spaced 12’ on center, oriented perpendicular to the corridor, and on time clock control.
2-Includes savings due to controls shown. Layout tips for wider corridors: Layout 7 works for 10’ corridor.
Layout 6 limited to 9’ corridor.
SCHOOL CODE TIP
If your state code requires minimum light levels, consider:
• Computer calculations for greater accuracy.
• Precise definition of task area.
• High output ballasts.
• Higher room reflectances.
A+
6
Lamp / Ballast Efficacies
USE ENERGY
EFFICIENT
SOURCES
100
Fluorescent lighting today
is not only more energy
80
T8
efficient, but rivals
T5
&
HO
T5
incandescent in quality,
T5
Twin
60
comfort and aesthetics.
Lamps are available in
CFL
40
a variety of superior
colors providing a
natural appearance for
20
people and room colors.
Tungsten
Halogen
Electronic high frequency
0
ballasts eliminate the flicker
Lamp Types
and noise of older model
ballasts. The graph compares
efficacies (mean lumens per watt)
of common fluorescent lamp/ ballast
combinations with the efficacy of a tungsten
halogen (incandescent) lamp.
Mean Lumens Per Watt
For corridors up to 9 feet wide.
lighting fixture schedule
These specifications are for cost-effective fixtures that ensure a balance of performance, energy savings, comfort, lighting quality and ease of
maintenance. Many standard products meet these generic specifications. Even small variations from these specifications may result in undesirable
effects. For example, specular louvers or reflectors may increase light levels and reduce reflected glare, but will also increase overhead glare and
decrease desirable room surface brightness.
AMBIENT LIGHTING
A. Pendant Direct/Indirect Baffled
LAMPS: (2) 32W T8 fluorescent, 835 color
DESCRIPTION: Pendant mounted. White crossbaffles. Minimum 35° lengthwise shielding. Wire
for separate row switching. Multi-lamp ballasts.
80% min. fixture efficiency. Nominal 59 watts per
(2) lamps.
A
Valances (Type H) are an inexpensive way to light focal walls,
but don’t provide the best uniformity.
B. Surface Mounted Baffled, Wide Distribution
DESCRIPTION: Same as Type ‘A’ except surface
mounted. Luminous sides for wide distribution.
60% min. fixture efficiency.
WALL ACCENT OPTIONS
H. Fluorescent Channel with Valance
LAMP: (1) 32W T8 fluorescent, 835 color
DESCRIPTION: Surface mounted standard
channel concealed by architectural valance.
Multi-lamp ballasts. Nominal 30 watts per fixture.
B
C. Two-Lamp Recessed Parabolic 2’ x 4’
DESCRIPTION: Recessed. White baked enamel
reflector (minimum 90% reflectance) and
minimum 3" deep parabolic louvers. 12 cells. Wire C
for separate row switching. Multi-lamp ballasts.
76% min. fixture efficiency. Nominal 59 watts per (2) lamps.
H
J. Recessed 1’ x 4’ Linear Wall Wash
DESCRIPTION: Recessed wallwasher with semispecular aluminum reflector. Locate 2’ to 3’ away
from wall. Nominal 59 input watts per (2) lamps,
67% minimum fixture efficiency.
D. Pendant Direct/Indirect Parabolic
J
K. Bracket Mounted Asymmetric Board Light
D
DESCRIPTION: Wall mounted. Asymmetric
reflector. Cantilever 6" to 12" from board. Multilamp ballasts. 71% min. fixture efficiency.
Nominal 59 watts per (2) lamps.
K
E. Pendant Direct/Indirect Three-Lamp
CORRIDOR OPTIONS
DESCRIPTION: Pendant mounted. 2 lamps up
and 1 lamp down. Semi-specular low-iridescent
parabolic cross-baffles, minimum 1-3/4" deep and
3" on center. Optional lamp shield for center lamp.
Wire for separate row switching. Multi-lamp
ballasts. 71% min. fixture efficiency. Nominal 89
watts per (3) lamps.
L and L1. Surface Mounted Corridor Wall Lighter
E
DESCRIPTION: Surface mounted. White baked
L
enamel housing and prismatic lens. Multi-lamp
ballasts. 78% min. fixture efficiency. Nominal 59
watts per (2) lamps. (Available as pendant version
if ceiling height is greater than 9’0".) Alternative:
White cross baffles. 68% min. fixture efficiency. L1
DESCRIPTION: Pendant mounted. Semi-specular
low-iridescent parabolic cross-baffles minimum
1-3/4" deep, 3" on center. Wire for separate row
switching. Multi-lamp ballasts. 80% min. fixture
efficiency. Nominal 59 watts per (2) lamps.
F and F1. Pendant Indirect – Perforated Sides
DESCRIPTION: Pendant mounted. 85% indirect
component with perforated sides. Wire for separate
row switching. Multi-lamp ballasts. 78% min.
fixture efficiency. Nominal 59 watts per (2)
lamps. Alternative F1: (1) 54W T5HO lamp, 95%
indirect component. 88% min. fixture efficiency.
Nominal 117 watts per (2) T5HO lamps.
F1
M and M1. Recessed Fluorescent 1’ x 4’
F
DESCRIPTION: Recessed. White upper
reflector and white parabolic louvers 6" on
center. Multi-lamp ballasts. Nominal 59
input watts per (2) lamps. 73% min. fixture
efficiency. Alternative: Prismatic lens. 65% min.
fixture efficiency.
M
M1
7
Daylighting is a key to lighting quality. Students with daylight in their
classrooms (from windows and skylights) perform 20 to 25% better on
reading and math tests than students without access to daylight.2 The
same study shows that students in classrooms with larger window areas
progress up to 20% faster than their counterparts in rooms with smaller
window areas. Go to http://www.h-m-g.com to read the study that presents
these data.
Research has shown that information presented visually is absorbed
faster and retained more reliably than information presented orally.1
To promote learning, provide an environment where teachers and students
can perform their visual tasks comfortably, quickly and accurately.
Lighting impacts the psychological and emotional needs of students: it
makes a room attractive and pleasant, stimulates learning and improves
behavior. High quality, energy effective lighting is a wise investment
for our schools!
DAYLIGHTING HINTS
Daylight only saves energy if the electric lights are dimmed or switched off.
Dimming lights in response to daylight is less distracting than switching,
but requires dimming ballasts and a commitment to maintenance. Avoid
direct solar penetration – it creates glare and overheating. Use neutralcolored window glass and exterior overhangs to control window glare and
solar heat gain.Balance the light by providing daylight from more than
one direction. See page 3 and classroom layouts for daylight controls.
1 - Adapted from Good Lighting for Schools by Fodergemeinshaft GutesLicht.
“Visual richness in classrooms stimulates
creative thinking. Quality lighting and flexible
lighting controls are major contributors to a
positive learning environment.”
Professor, Texas Christian University
2 - The Heschong-Mahone Group (published 1999)
high quality checklist
✓ Use fixtures that provide comfort by distributing some
better lighting =
better learning
daylighting
Students and teachers benefit from a connection to the outdoors –
windows not only provide daylight but also a sense of time, weather,
and distant focal points – all of which prevent fatigue and contribute
to greater alertness in class.
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
light on ceilings and walls, such as direct/indirect or
semi-indirect fixtures.
Use light-colored finishes on room surfaces to maximize
reflected light.
Include windows or skylights in every classroom.
Design electric lighting to maximize benefits from
natural lighting.
Use interior blinds to control window glare.
Use lighting controls to increase flexibility and decrease
energy use for each room.
Provide additional light for front wall or board, and
other important room features.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The LIGHTING KNOWHOW series was developed, funded and sponsored by the following members of the DesignLights Consortium:
www.designlights.org
Efficiency Vermont
Conectiv Power Delivery
Jersey Central Power & Light,
A FirstEnergy Company
Long Island
Power Authority
National Grid:
· Massachusetts Electric
· Narragansett Electric
· Granite State Electric
· Nantucket Electric
United Illuminating
Northeast Utilities:
· The Connecticut Light &
Power Company
· Western Massachusetts
Electric Company
Northeast Energy Efficiency
Partnerships, Inc.
Unitil:
· Fitchburg Gas & Electric
Light Company
Content/graphics by Hayden McKay
Lighting Design Inc. Support from
Lindsley Consultants Inc. Additional
consultation by Donna Leban, Mark
Loeffler, Charles Michal and Naomi
Miller. Market Research Review by
Light/Space/Design. Graphic design
by Outsource.
For commercial lighting services in your area contact:
NSTAR Electric
NYSERDA
New York State Energy Research
and Development Authority
8 Disclaimer: These guides are provided for information purposes only. Neither the Sponsoring Agents nor any of their employees or sub-contractors makes any warranty, expressed or implied,
or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any data, information, method, product or process disclosed in this document, or represents that
its use will not infringe any privately owned rights, including, but not limited to, patents, trademarks or copyrights.
DESCRIPTION OF COLUMN HEADINGS FOR CEE
HIGH-PERFORMANCE 4’ T8 LAMP
Column Heading
Manufacturer
Product Name,
Order Code, Model
Number
AND BALLAST QUALIFYING LISTS
Description
By clicking on this field, the user will be directed to the
manufacturer Web site and on-line catalogue.
Information provided from manufacturers on product including
ordering codes.
Color Temperature The perceived “whiteness” of the light source in Kelvin.
LAMP
Rated Life
IS
RS/PRS
Initial Lumens
Mean Lumens
CRI
Operating hours that a lamp lasts at 3 hours duty cycle
depending upon the type of Ballast.
Instant Start Ballast
Rapid Start or Programmed-Rapid Start
Amount of luminous flux emitted by a lamp after 100 hours of
operation at 25C.
Amount of luminous flux emitted by a lamp at 40% of the rated
lamp life.
Color Rendering Index. The effect that the spectral characteristic
of the light emitted by the lamp has on the color appearance of
the objects illuminated by the lamp.
Lumen Maintenance Ratio of mean lumens to initial lumens.
Voltage
BALLAST
Input Watts
BEF
Operating voltage for ballasts. Multiple voltage ballasts (also
referred to as Universal Voltage) designated with two voltage
values.
Reported ANSI rated watts for ballast.
Ballast Efficacy Factor. This is a calculated value with the
exception of Howard Industries, who provides this value in their
catalogue.
Ballast Start Type
Ballast starting circuitry identified as Instant (I), Rapid (R) or
Programmed-Rapid (P).
Ballast Factor
Ratio of lamp lumens produced when lamp(s) operated by a
given ballast to the lamp lumens produced when the lamp(s)
operated on a reference ballast.
Ballast Factor
Range
Ballast factor range of low, normal or high based upon CEE
specification.
HP T8 Lamps
QUALIFYING PRODUCTS
High-Performance 4’ T8 Lamps
(Last Updated 12/30/11)
CEE High-Performance Commercial Lighting Systems Initiative
Legend: Red Font is a product no longer manufactured, but existing stock still meets the criteria as qualifying products
Mfr
Product
Name
Atlas Lighting
Products, Inc.
Aura Light
Bulbrite
Contractor Lighting
CRI Lighting
DLU Lighting USA
Accendo | AURA
ULTIMATE US
Long Life
Energy Wiser
BEST LAMP
N/A
Tri-Lux
Tri-Lux/Medistar
Eiko
Espen Technology,
Inc.
Full Spectrum
Solutions, Inc
Fusion Lamps
General Electric
Company
Halco Lighting
Technologies
H&H Industries, Inc.
Howard Industries
Eiko High Lumen
Elite HE
Maxum 5000
F32T8
Shatterproof
Fusion HLO
Series
Ecolux High
Lumen
ProLume
CoverShield
POWR-TEK
PLUS
VITEK93+
High Lumen
Hygrade (also
NARVA,
Hygrade/Narva, and
TriPhase)
High Lumen
IWI Lighting
IntegraLight
Rated Life (hrs)1
Order Code
Model Number or
Description
Shape
Color
Temp
(K)
F32T8/841
F32T8/841
Linear
4100
20,000
24,000
3100
2950
82
0.95
F32T8/850
F32T8/851
Linear
5000
20,000
24,000
3100
2950
82
0.95
455338
ULTIMATE US 32W/835
Linear
3500
53,000
60,000
3100
2900
80
0.94
455334
ULTIMATE US 32W/841
Linear
4100
53,000
60,000
3100
2900
80
0.94
529632
F32T8/835/HL
Linear
3500
24,000
30,000
3300
3135
85
0.95
529732
F32T8/841/HL
Linear
4100
24,000
30,000
3300
3135
85
0.95
529832
F32T8/850/HL
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3200
3040
85
0.95
12-32T8-850
n/a
IS
Lumen
Initial
Mean
Maintena
RS/PRS Lumens Lumens CRI
nce
12-32T8-850
Linear
5000
20,000
24,000
3100
3000
85
0.97
F32T8/830 XP
Linear
3000
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
83
0.94
F32T8/835 XP
Linear
3500
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
83
0.94
F32T8/841 XP
Linear
4100
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
83
0.94
F32T8/850 XP
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
83
0.94
F32T8/865 XP
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
83
0.94
F32T8/841TL
Linear
Linear
6500
FLTHNVX5V
4100
24,000
24,000
3150
2950
85
0.94
FLTHNVX6V
F32T8/850TL
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3150
2950
85
0.94
FLTHNVXDV
F32T8/859TL
Linear
5900
24,000
24,000
3150
2975
85
0.94
n/a
F32T8/830K/HL
Linear
3000
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
83
0.94
n/a
F32T8/835K/HL
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
83
0.94
n/a
F32T8/841K/HL
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
83
0.94
n/a
F32T8/850K/HL
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3000
2820
83
0.94
n/a
F32T8/865K/HL
Linear
6500
24,000
24,000
3000
2820
83
0.94
13986
F32T8/827/HE
Linear
2700
24,000
30,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
13987
F32T8/830/HE
Linear
3000
24,000
30,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
13988
F32T8/835/HE
Linear
3500
24,000
30,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
13989
F32T8/841/HE
Linear
4100
24,000
30,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
13990
F32T8/850/HE
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
32865
F32T8/865/HE
Linear
6500
24,000
30,000
2976
2798
85
0.94
B32841
FB32T8/841/HE
U-Bend
4100
20,000
24,000
3100
2900
85
0.94
B32850
FB32T8/850/HE
U-Bend
5000
20,000
24,000
2980
2830
85
0.95
204453SC
F32-T8 48" Shatter Proof 5000K
Linear
5000
34,000
28,000
3300
2950
91
0.95
FN6C32A2F/HLO
FN6C32A2F/HLO
Linear
4100
20,000
24,000
3200
3000
85
0.94
FF32/T8/830/HLO
FF32/T8/830/HLO
Linear
3000
20,000
24,000
3200
3000
85
0.94
FF32/T8/835/HLO
FF32/T8/835/HLO
Linear
3500
20,000
24,000
3200
3000
85
0.94
FF32/T8/841/HLO
FF32/T8/841/HLO
Linear
4100
20,000
24,000
3200
3000
85
0.94
FF32/T8/850/HLO
FF32/T8/850/HLO
Linear
5000
20,000
24,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
10327
F32T8/XL/SPX30/HL/ECO
Linear
3000
25,000
36,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
10326
Linear
3500
25,000
36,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
10322
Linear
4100
25,000
36,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
42556
Linear
5000
25,000
36,000
3000
2820
80
0.94
109404
F32T8/850/ECO
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3050
2900
86
0.95
109428
F32T8/865/ECO
Linear
6500
24,000
24,000
3050
2900
86
0.95
35153
F32T8/850/ECO/IC
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3050
2900
85
0.95
35154
F32T8/865/ECO/IC
Linear
6500
24,000
24,000
3050
2900
85
0.95
35155
F32T8/830/ECO/HL
Linear
3000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
35156
F32T8/835/ECO/HL
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
35157
F32T8/841/ECO/HL
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
35158
F32T8/850/ECO/HL
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
35161
F32T8/850/ECO/XL
40,000
40,000
2950
2800
85
0.95
F32T8/850/ECO/IC/CS
Linear
Linear
5000
90093
5000
24,000
24,000
3050
2900
86
0.95
HH301
F32T8POWR-TEK PLUS
Linear
5000
36,000
36,000
3150
2992
89
0.95
HH9312
F32T8VITEK93+
Linear
6700
36,000
36,000
3010
2860
93
0.95
01947
F32T8/830/HL/ECO
Linear
3000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
01948
F32T8/835/HL/ECO
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
01949
F32T8/841/HL/ECO
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
02858
F32T8/850/HL/ECO
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
03753
F32T8/830/HL/ECO/IC
Linear
3000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
83
0.95
03754
F32T8/835/HL/ECO/IC
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
83
0.95
03755
F32T8/841/HL/ECO/IC
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
83
0.95
03756
F32T8/850/HL/ECO/IC
5000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
83
0.95
04933
F32T8/865/HL/ECO/IC
Linear
Linear
6500
24,000
24,000
2950
2800
83
0.95
681
F32T8/HL/830
Linear
3000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
682
F32T8/HL/835
Linear
6500
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
683
F32T8/HL/841
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
684
F32T8/HL/850
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
91613PIL
F32T8IntegraLight
Linear
5000
36,000
36,000
3100
2950
86
0.95
HP T8 Lamps
Mfr
Product
Name
Earthcare
Kumho Electric USA
Elemental
Sequoia
Color Brite T8
LITETRONICS, INT.
Maintenance
Engineering
ENERGY-LITE
Premira
Flourescent
Premium T8
Maxlite
T8 XL
Midwest Industrial
Lighting
Optilumens
Orion Energy
Systems
F32T8-850HL
-
ArmorLite
ECO-LUMEN
Octron XPS
OSRAM SYLVANIA
Octron
Philips Lighting
P.Q.L., Inc.
Satco Products, Inc
Shat-r-shield, Inc
Alto Advantage
SuperiorLife HiLum
Satco Hygrade
Clear SafetyCoated Extended
Performance
Rated Life (hrs)1
Order Code
Model Number or
Description
Shape
Color
Temp
(K)
413830
F29T8/830/EC-HL
Linear
3000
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
413835
F29T8/835/EC-HL
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
413841
F29T8/841/EC-HL
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
413850
F29T8/850/EC-HL
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3070
2885
82
0.94
403830
F32T8/830
Linear
3000
24,000
36,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
403835
F32T8/835
Linear
3500
24,000
36,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
403841
F32T8/841
Linear
4100
24,000
36,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
403850
F32T8/850
Linear
5000
24,000
36,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
IS
Lumen
Initial
Mean
Maintena
nce
403865
F32T8/865
Linear
6500
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
82
0.94
453830
F32T8/830/SQ (HL)
Linear
3000
60,000
70,000
3100
2976
80.5
0.96
453835
F32T8/835/SQ (HL)
Linear
3500
60,000
70,000
3100
2976
80.5
0.96
453841
F32T8/841/SQ (HL)
Linear
4100
60,000
70,000
3100
2976
80.5
0.96
453850
F32T8/850/SQ (HL)
Linear
5000
60,000
70,000
3025
2904
80.5
0.96
L-359
F32T8 CB50
Linear
5000
30,000
30,000
3200
3025
90
0.94
L-334
F32 T8 830
Linear
3000
30,000
30,000
3100
2925
85
0.94
L-335
F32 T8 835
Linear
3500
30,000
30,000
3100
2925
85
0.94
L-336
F32 T8 841
Linear
4100
30,000
30,000
3100
2925
85
0.94
L-337
L-385
F32 T8 850
F32 T8 835 U
Linear
U-Bend
5000
3500
30,000
30,000
30,000
30,000
3100
3100
2925
2925
85
85
0.94
0.94
L-386
F32 T8 841 U
U-Bend
4100
30,000
30,000
3100
2925
85
0.94
L-387
F32 T8 850 U
U-Bend
5000
30,000
30,000
3100
2925
85
0.94
PMX135
F32T8/AWX8550/TC
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3050
2898
85
0.95
PMX139
F32T8/VLX9155/TC
Linear
5500
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
91
0.95
51048
F32T8/830
Linear
3000
24,000
24,000
3100
2900
85
0.94
51045
F32T8/835
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3100
2900
85
0.94
51046
F32T8/841
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2900
85
0.94
51047
F32T8/850
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3100
2900
85
0.94
51053
F32T8/865
Linear
6500
24,000
24,000
3100
2900
85
0.94
51058
F32T8/835XL
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3200
3020
85
0.94
51050
F32T8/841XL
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3200
3020
85
0.94
51049
F32T8/850XL
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3200
3020
85
0.94
51060
F32T8/865XL
Linear
6500
24,000
24,000
3200
3020
85
0.94
45728
FE32-850HL
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3150
2995
86
0.95
4187
FL32T8/835/HO/ECO
Linear
3500
20,000
24,000
3200
3050
82
0.95
4188
FL32T8/835/HO/ECO
Linear
3500
20,000
24,000
3200
3050
82
0.95
0.95
4189
FL32T8/850/HO/ECO
Linear
5000
20,000
24,000
3200
3050
82
4182
FL32T8/850/ECO
Linear
5000
20,000
24,000
3000
2850
82
0.95
10322AL
T8 ARMORLITE 841 HL LAMP
Linear
4100
25,000
36,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
42556AL
T8 ARMORLITE 850 HL LAMP
Linear
5000
25,000
36,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
18041
ORION F32 T8 / 841
Linear
4100
36,000
36,000
3100
2915
82
0.94
18050
ORION F32 T8 / 850
Linear
5000
36,000
36,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
21660
FO32/850XPS/ECO3
Linear
5000
24,000
40,000
3100
2914
81
0.94
21680
FO32/830/XPS/ECO3
Linear
3000
24,000
40,000
3100
2914
85
0.94
21659
FO32/865XPS/ECO3
Linear
6500
24,000
40,000
3000
2820
81
0.94
21697
FO32/835/XPS/ECO3
Linear
3500
24,000
40,000
3100
2914
85
0.94
21681
FO32/841/XPS/ECO3
Linear
4100
24,000
40,000
3100
2914
85
0.94
22168
FBO32/850XPS/6/ECO
U-Bend
5000
18,000
24,000
2980
2830
85
0.94
22143
FO32/850/ECO
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
2950
2773
80
0.94
22026
FO32/850XP/ECO
Linear
5000
24,000
40,000
3000
2820
85
0.94
22002
FO32/850/XP/XL/ECO
Linear
5000
36,000
52,000
2950
2832
80
0.96
13987-3
F32T8/ADV830/ALTO
Linear
3000
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
85
0.97
13988-1
F32T8/ADV835/ALTO
Linear
3500
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
85
0.97
13989-9
F32T8/ADV841/ALTO
Linear
4100
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
85
0.97
13990-7
F32T8/ADV850/ALTO
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3100
2935
82
0.97
91610
F32T8/835 - Hi Lumen
Linear
3500
30,000
36,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
91611
F32T8/841/Hi Lumen - Superior Life
Linear
4100
30,000
36,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
91612
F32T8/Sky-Brite Plus Hi Lumen
Linear
5000
30,000
36,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
91613
F32T8/Sky-Brite Plus® Hi Lumen
Linear
5000
30,000
36,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
91613-HL
F32T8/850 Hi Lumen
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
91607-HL
F32T8/841 Hi Lumen
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
91601-HL
F32T8/835 Hi Lumen
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
91603-HL
F32T8/830 Hi Lumen
Linear
3000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
72614
F32T8/865
Linear
6500
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
91615
F32T8/VITA-BRITE
Linear
5400
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
88
0.95
82614
F32T8/865 - Superior Life
Linear
6500
24,000
36,000
3100
2950
85
0.95
S8426
F32T8/830/HL/ENV
Linear
3000
24,000
24,000
3200
3050
85
0.95
S8427
F32T8/835/HL/ENV
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3200
3050
85
0.95
S8428
F32T8/841/HL/ENV
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3200
3050
85
0.95
S8429
F32T8/850/HL/ENV
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3200
3050
85
0.95
46547S
F32T8 830/XPS/ECO
Linear
3000
24,000
36,000
3100
2945
85
0.95
46549S
F32T8 835/XPS/ECO
Linear
3500
24,000
36,000
3100
2945
85
0.95
46548S
F32T8 841/XPS/ECO
Linear
4100
24,000
36,000
3100
2945
85
0.95
46550S
F32T8 850/XPS/ECO
Linear
5000
24,000
36,000
3100
2945
81
0.95
46551S
F32T8 865/XPS/ECO
Linear
6500
24,000
36,000
3100
2945
81
0.95
46648
F32T8 ADV830/ALTO
Linear
3000
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
85
0.97
46646
F32T8 ADV835/ALTO
Linear
3500
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
85
0.97
46548
F32T8 ADV841/ALTO
Linear
4100
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
85
0.97
46558
F32T8 ADV850/ALTO
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
82
0.97
46823S
FO32/850/ECO
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
2950
2773
80
0.94
46828S
FO32/850/XP/ECO
Linear
5000
24,000
36,000
3000
2820
80
0.94
46822S
FO32/850/XP/XL/ECO
Linear
5000
36,000
40,000
2950
2832
80
0.96
HP T8 Lamps
Mfr
Product
Name
SLI Lighting/Havells
USA
Terra-Lux High
Lumen
SOLTERRA
F32 T8
XL31 Safety Max
Standard Products,
Inc.
XL31
Earthsaver
Super Eco Products,
LLC
Super Eco T-8
Plus
Superior Lamp, Inc.
Heavy Duty
Flourescent
Technical Consumer TCP High Lumen
Products, Inc.
Topaz Lighting
TOPAZ/CXL
Universal Lighting
Technologies
Universal 800HL
USHIO America, Inc.
ULTRA 8 High
Lumen
Westinghouse
Lighting Corporation
XL
Triten 50 Ultra
1
Rated Life (hrs)1
Order Code
Model Number or
Description
Shape
Color
Temp
(K)
1920
F32T8/HL/835
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
1921
F32T8/HL/841
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
IS
Lumen
Initial
Mean
Maintena
nce
1923
F32T8/HL/850
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
30080
T8, 800 Series, 32 Watt
Linear
3500
20,000
24,000
3100
2914
82
0.94
30090
Linear
4100
20,000
24,000
3100
2914
82
0.94
30100
F32T8/830/XL31SM
Linear
5000
20,000
24,000
3100
2914
82
0.94
58769
Linear
24,000
36,000
3100
2950
89
0.95
58771
F32T8/835/XL31SM
Linear
3000
3500
24,000
36,000
3100
2950
89
0.95
57022
F32T8/841/XL31SM
Linear
4100
24,000
36,000
3100
2950
89
0.95
58772
F32T8/850/XL31SM
Linear
5000
24,000
36,000
3100
2950
89
0.95
10914
F32T8/830/XL31
Linear
36,000
3100
2950
85
0.97
F32T8/835/XL31
Linear
3000
3500
24,000
10915
24,000
36,000
3100
2950
85
0.97
10916
F32T8/841/XL31
Linear
4100
24,000
36,000
3100
2950
85
0.97
10917
F32T8/850/XL31
24,000
36,000
3100
2950
85
0.97
10004
F32T8/50K/8/RS/G13/STD ESV
Linear
Linear
5000
5000
24,000
30,000
2950
2800
85
0.95
51169
F32T8/65K/8/RS/G13/STD ESV
Linear
6500
24,000
30,000
2950
2800
85
0.95
32830
F32T8/830/SuperEco
Linear
3000
24,000
30,000
3200
3040
86
0.95
32840
F32T8/840/SuperEco
Linear
4200
24,000
30,000
3200
3040
86
0.95
32850
F32T8/850/SuperEco
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3200
3040
86
0.95
HDX145
F32T8/FWX8550/TC
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3050
2898
85
0.95
HDX149
F32T8/VLX9155/TC
Linear
5500
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
91
0.95
31032850HL
F32T8/850/HL
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
86
0.94
31032830HL
F32T8/830/HL
Linear
3000
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
31032835HL
F32T8/835/HL
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
31032841HL
F32T8/841/HL
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
31032865HL
F32T8/865/HL
Linear
6500
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
85
0.94
31032850
F32T8/850
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
2950
2800
85
0.95
FO32/830/XL-40
32W 48" T8 3,000K Flourescent
Linear
3000
24,000
30,000
3100
2900
85
0.94
FO32/835/XL-40
Linear
3500
24,000
30,000
3100
2900
85
0.94
FO32/841/XL-40
Linear
4100
24,000
30,000
3100
2900
85
0.94
FO32/850/XL-40
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3100
2900
85
0.94
25898
F32T8/835HL
Linear
3500
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
84
0.94
25899
F32T8/841HL
Linear
4100
24,000
24,000
3100
2915
84
0.94
25900
F32T8/850HL
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3000
2820
82
0.94
3000480
F32T8/841/HL
Linear
4100
24,000
30,000
3150
2990
86
0.95
3000524
F32T8/850/HL
Linear
5000
24,000
30,000
3150
2990
86
0.95
07027
F32T8/830/XL/ECOMAX
Linear
3000
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
86
0.95
07028
F32T8/835/XL/ECOMAX
Linear
3500
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
86
0.95
07029
F32T8/841/XL/ECOMAX
Linear
4100
24,000
30,000
3100
2950
86
0.95
60766
F32T8/Triten50/ULTRA/ENV
Linear
5000
24,000
24,000
3100
2950
86
0.95
Life based on 3-hr. duty cycle
© 2007 Consortium for Energy Efficiency, Inc. All rights reserved.
CONSORTIUM FOR ENERGY EFFICIENCY
www.cee1.org
617-589-3949
HP 120 and 277 V T8 Ballasts
QUALIFYING PRODUCTS 1
High-Performance 120 and 277V T8 Ballasts
Updated 12/30/11
For a list of qualifying 347 V T8 ballasts, see:
www.cee1.org/com/com-lt/347-ballasts.xls
Click "Open." When "Connect to www.cee1.org" box opens, click on "Cancel" twice
Legend: Red Font is a product no longer manufactured, but still meets the criteria as a qualifying product
Manufacturer
Product
Name
Model Number
Ballast
NEMA4 Voltage Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
Ballast
Factor
Input
Watts
(W)
BEF³
HP T8 Qualified Ballasts with 1 Lamp
ACCUPRO
American Ballast
High
Efficiency
High
Efficiency
DuroPower
(BallastWise)
Ballastwise
Dynamic Ballast
High
Efficiency
Fulham
Workhorse
GE Ultramax
General Electric
Company
UltraStart
Proline
Halco Lighting
Technologies
ProLume
Hatch Lighting
Hatch
HEP Group USA,
Inc.
HEP HE
Ballast
HEX
Electronic
Howard Industries
HE High
Efficiency
HE Micro
Case
A*-132-IP-UNV
yes
277
I
Normal
0.87
28
3.11
AB1-32-IP-UNV-HE
AB1-32-IP-UNV-1
DXE1H81
DXE1H81U
yes
yes
no
no
120/277
120/277
120
120/277
I
I
I
I
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
0.91
0.91
0.88
0.88
29
29
28
28.2
3.14
3.14
3.14
3.12
DY 132 IS WV - HE
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.88
28
3.14
WHHE2-UNV-T8-IS
WHSG2-UNV-T8-HB
WHPS1-UNV-T8-PS
GE-132-MAX-N/Ultra
GE-132-MAX-L/Ultra
GE132-MVPS-L
GE132-MVPS-N
GE132-MVPS-H
GE-132-MV-N
EP232IS/L/MV/HE
EP232IS/MV/HE
EP232IS/120/SL
EP232IS/MV/SL
HL232AIS/UV/HE/W
HL232BIS/UV/HE/W
SIS117-32 UNI 21
SIS117-32S UNI
E1/32IS-120HEX
E1/32IS-277HEX
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
277
I
I
P
I
I
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
I
I
High
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
High
High
High
Normal
High
High
High
Normal
Normal
1.08
1.38
0.88
0.88
0.77
0.72
0.89
1.18
0.87
0.95
1.05
1.15
1.15
0.95
1.05
1.05
1.05
0.87
0.87
34
45
30
28
25
25
30
39
28
30
33
38
38
30
33
34.5
34.5
28
28
3.18
3.07
2.93
3.11
3.08
2.88
2.97
3.03
3.11
3.17
3.18
3.03
3.03
3.17
3.18
3.04
3.04
3.11
3.11
EP2/32IS/MV/SC/HE
no
120/277
I
Normal
1.00
35
2.86
EPH2/32IS/MV/MC/HE
no
120/277
I
High
1.08
35/34
3.09/3.18
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
P
P
P
I
Low
Normal
Normal
Low
High
High
0.77
0.87
0.88
0.77
1.18
1.18
25
28
31
27
40
39
3.08
3.10
2.84
2.85
2.95
3.03
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
Premium
Series
SKEU322HEL
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.95
30
3.17
Maxlite
High
Efficiency
Ballast
Electronic
Ballasts
SKEU322H/SC
no
120/277
I
High
1.38
45
3.07
EB-132PRS-U-ES
EB-132PRS-U-ES-HBF
FL2T17-32M NO
FX2T17-32M NO
FX2T17-32M HO
FL2T17-32M HO
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
P
P
P
P
P
P
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
High
High
0.88
1.18
0.87
0.87
1.21
1.21
30
38
28
28
39
39
2.93
3.11
3.11
3.11
3.10
3.10
HIGH
OB2-T8-32-120/277-E-IN-0.9
EFFICIENCY
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.89
28
3.18
QHE1x32T8/UNV ISH-SC
QHE 1X32T8/UNV ISL-SC
QHE 1X32T8/UNV ISL-SC-1
QHE 1X32T8/UNV ISN-SC
QHE1x32T8/UNV ISN-SC-1
QHE1x32T8/UNV PSN-MC
QTP 1X32T8/UNV PSN-TC
QTP 1X32T8/UNV PSX-TC
QTP 1X32T8/UNV ISN-SC
IOP-1S32-SC
IOP-1P32-SC
IOP-1P32-HL-SC
IOP-1P32-LW-SC
IOP-1S32-LW-SC
IOPA-1P32 LW-SC
IOPA-1P32-SC
ICN-1P32-N
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
I
P
I
P
I
P
I
I
I
High
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
1.20
0.78
0.77
0.88
0.87
0.88
0.88
0.71
0.89
0.88
0.87
0.88
0.77
0.72
0.77
0.87
0.91
38
25
25
28
28
30/29
31/30
25
28.6
28
28
28
25
24
25
28
29
3.16
3.12
3.08
3.14
3.11
2.93/3.03
2.84/ 2.93
2.84
3.11
3.14
3.11
3.14
3.08
3.00
3.08
3.11
3.14
MW McWong
International
Electronic
Ballast
Omnitronix
Engineering LLC
Smart
Ballast
Orion Energy
Systems
OSRAM SYLVANIA Quicktronic
Philips - Advance
Optanium
Centium
1 Lamp Products
Keystone
Technologies
KTEB-132-UV-IS-L-P
KTEB-132-UV-IS-N-P
KTEB-132-UV-PS-N-P
KTEB-132-UV-PS-L-P
KTEB-132-UV-PS-H-P
KTEB-132-UV-IS-H-P
Manufacturer
P.Q.L., Inc.
Robertson
Worldwide
Product
Name
Superior Life
Sterling
Series
-
Model Number
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
Ballast
Factor
Input
Watts
(W)
BEF³
70201
70210
70213
SL-1/32IS-120 (70209)
SL-1/32IS-277 (70200)
ISL132T8HEMVL
ISU232T8HEMV
PSA132T8HEMV
PSA132T8HEMH
NLO232T8PIS
SAU139Q2
SLU232T8HPIS-ROHS
NU240T8RS-ROHS
SAU139Q2
SLU232T8HPIS-ROHS
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120
120
277
120/277
120
120/277
120/277
120
120
120/277
120
120
120/277
I
P
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
I
Normal
High
High
Normal
Normal
Low
High
Normal
High
High
Normal
High
High
High
High
0.87
1.06
1.37
0.88
0.88
0.77
1.12
0.91
1.18
1.03
1.00
1.40
1.40
1.02
1.40
27/26.5
34
45
28
28
25
36
30
39/38
36
33
45
41
33
45
3.22/3.28
3.12
3.04
3.11
3.11
3.08
3.11
3.03
3.03/3.11
2.86
3.03
3.11
3.41
3.09
3.11
Sage Lighting Ltd
Sage
SOLA Canada
Lighting & Power
Inc
Sola
E-758-F-132SC
no
120
I
Normal
0.97
31
3.13
Optistart
E232T8PRS120-277/L
E232T8PS120-277/N/XTRM
E232T8PRS120-277/N
E232T8PS120277/N/AS/BULK
E132T8IS120/N
E132T8IS120/L/BULK
E132T8IS120/L
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120/277
P
P
P
Normal
High
Normal
0.88
1.40
0.90
29
41
29
3.03
3.41
3.10
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.90
29
3.10
no
no
no
120
120
120
I
I
I
Normal
Low
Low
0.90
0.78
0.78
28
25
25
3.21
3.12
3.12
Ultralumen
U-1/32PSE
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.88
30
2.93
Technical
Consumer
Products, Inc.
-
TCP2P32ISUNVH
E2P32ISUNVHE
TCP2P32ISUNV
E2P32ISUNVLE
E2P32ISUNVHE
E2P32ISUNVE
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
High
High
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
1.37
1.37
0.99
0.88
1.37
0.99
45
45
31
28
45
31
3.04
3.04
3.19
3.14
3.04
3.19
Topstar
International Inc.
T8 Electronic
Ballast
BB-T8/UVH-2x32/HPF
no
120
I
Normal
0.96
30
3.20
SR132120
SR132277
PR232120M-HE
UT132120M-HE
UT132120ML-HE
UT232120L-HE
PR132120M-P-HE
PR232120M-P-HE
PR232120ML-P-HE
B232PUNVEL-A
B232PUNVHP-A
B232IUNVEL-A
B232IUNVHE-A
B132PUNVHP-A
B132IUNVHE-A
B132IUNVEL-A
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
P
P
P
I
I
I
P
P
P
P
P
I
I
P
I
I
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Low
0.86
0.86
0.97
0.87
0.74
0.97
0.88
0.88
0.72
0.71
1.00
0.95
1.05
0.88
0.87
0.77
30
30
33
28
24
30
30
29
24
25/23
32
30
33
31/30
28
25
2.87
2.87
2.94
3.11
3.08
3.23
2.93
3.03
3.00
2.84/3.09
3.13
3.17
3.18
2.84/ 2.93
3.11
3.08
Standard
Products, Inc.
Sunpark Electronics
Corp.
Gold Label
Ultrasave Lighting
Ltd.
-
Universal Lighting
Technologies
F32 T8 HP T8 Qualified Ballasts with 2 Lamps
ACCUPRO
High
Efficiency
American Ballast
High
Efficiency
A*-232-IP-UNV
A*-232IP-H-UNV
A*-232IP-L-UNV
AB2-32-IP-UNV-HE
AB2-32-IP-UNV-1
AB2-32-IP-UNV-HBF
AB2-32-IP-UNV-LX
EB232UIH
EB232UI
yes
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Normal
High
Low
Normal
Normal
High
Low
High
Normal
0.88
1.18
0.77
0.89
0.89
1.18
0.77
1.18
0.87
55
76/75
48
56
56
76/75
48
70
55
1.60
1.55/1.57
1.60
1.59
1.59
1.55/1.57
1.60
1.69
1.58
Atlas Lighting
Products, Inc.
-
Axis Technologies
DDH
AX232B
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.99
64/66
1.55/1.50
Ballastwise
DXE2H8
DXE2H81
DXE2H8U
DXE2H8U-HBF
no
no
no
no
120
120
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
Normal
Normal
Normal
High
0.92
0.88
0.88
1.18
56
55
55/54
74/72
1.64
1.60
1.60/1.63
1.59/1.64
DY 232 IS WV - HE
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.88
55
1.60
EEL-PSB-F32-2-MVOLT
no
120/277
P
Normal
.88/.91
59
1.49/1.54
VE232MVHIPE
VE232MVHIPHE
VE232MVHRPHE
VE232MVHRPE
VE232MVHIPLE
VE232120HIPE
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
I
I
P
P
I
I
Normal
High
High
Normal
Low
Normal
0.89
1.19
1.18
0.88
0.77
0.85
55/54
76/75
72/71
57/56
48/47
53
1.62/1.65
1.57/1.59
1.64/1.66
1.54/1.57
1.60/1.64
1.60
DuroPower
(BallastWise)
Dynamic Ballast
Energy Efficient
Lighting Supply
Espen
Technology, Inc.
High
Efficiency
High
Efficiency
Elite
Apollo
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
Ballast
Factor
Input
Watts
(W)
BEF³
High
High
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
1.02
1.27
0.88
0.89
1.18
0.92
66
81/80
57/56
55/54
74/73
58/57
1.55
1.57/1.59
1.54/1.57
1.61/1.64
1.59/1.62
1.59/1.61
I
Normal
0.87
55
1.58
120/277
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
277
I
I
I
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
High
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
Low
Normal
Low
High
High
Low
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
1.18
0.88
0.89
1.15
0.89
0.71
1.00
0.77
1.15
1.19
0.77
0.87
1.15
0.89
0.89
76
55
56
75 / 74
58
47
62
48
73
74/73
48
54 / 53
74 / 73
57
57
1.55
1.60
1.59
1.53/ 1.55
1.53
1.51
1.61
1.60
1.58
1.61/1.63
1.60
1.61/ 1.64
1.55/ 1.58
1.56
1.56
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.99
64/66
1.55/1.50
EP232IS/MV/HE
EP232IS/L/MV/HE
EP232IS/H/MV/SL
EP332IS/H/MV/SL
EP232PS/MV/HE
EP232PS/L/MV/HE
HL232AIS/UV/HE/W
HL232BIS/UV/HE/W
HL332AIS/UV/HE/W
HL332BIS/UV/HE/W
HL332CIS/UV/HE/W
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
Normal
Low
High
High
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
High
High
0.87
0.77
1.18
1.33
0.88
0.77
0.77
0.87
0.92
1.58
1.60
1.59
1.60
1.47
1.48
1.60
1.58
1.61
1.27
55
48
74
83
60/60
52/52
48
55
57
64/63
82/81
SI2117-32 UNI
no
120/277
P
Normal
1.00
59
1.69
E2/32IS-120HEX
E2/32IS-277HEX
EL2/32IS-277HEX
EPL2/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EP2/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EPH2/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EPH3/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EP2/32IS/MV/MC/HE
EPL2/32IS/MV/MC/HE
EP2/32PRS/MV/MC/HE
EPH3/32IS/MV/MC/HE
EPL3/32IS/MV/MC/HE
EPH2/32IS/MV/MC/HE
EPH2/32IS/MV/MC
KTEB-232-UV-IS-L-P
KTEB-232-UV-IS-N-P
KTEB-232-UV-PS-N-P
KTEB-232-UV-PS-L-P
KTEB-232-UV-PS-H-P
KTEB-232-UV-IS-H-P
DB-232H-MV-TP-HE
DB-232N-MV-TP-HE
DB-232L-MV-TP-HE
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
120
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
277
120/277
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
High
High
Normal
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
High
High
Low
Normal
Normal
Low
High
High
High
Normal
Low
0.87
0.87
0.77
0.77
0.87
1.14
1.25
0.89
0.78
0.88
1.27
0.92
1.18
1.18
0.77
0.87
0.88
0.77
1.18
1.18
1.18
0.87
0.77
55
55
48
48
54/53
73/72
80
55/54
48
57 / 56
80
57
74/73
74/73
48
55
60
52
78
74/73
74/73
55
48
1.58
1.58
1.60
1.60
1.61/1.64
1.56/1.58
1.56
1.62/1.65
1.63
1.54/1.57
1.59
1.61
1.59/1.61
1.59/1.62
1.60
1.58
1.47
1.48
1.51
1.60/1.61
1.59/1.62
1.58
1.60
Product
Name
Model Number
Fulham
Workhorse
WHSG3-UNV-T8-IS
WHSG3-UNV-T8-HB
WHPS2-UNV-T8-PS
WHHE2-UNV-T8-IS
WHSG2-UNV-T8-HB
WHSG3-UNV-T8-LB
no
no
no
no
no
no
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
P
I
I
I
Fusion Ballasts
Electronic
ballasts
FB232MVE-HE
no
120/277
GE-232-MV-H
GE-232-MV-N
GE-232-277-N
GE-232-MV-PS-H
GE-232-MVPS-N
GE-232-MVPS-L
GE-232-MAX-N+
GE-232-MAX-L-42T
GE-232-MAX-H-42T
GE-232-MAX-H
GE-232-MAX-L/Ultra
GE-232-MAX-N/Ultra
GE-232-MAX-H/Ultra
GE-232-120-PS-N
GE-232-277-PS-N
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
AX232B120
Manufacturer
Proline
Ultrastart
General Electric
Company
Ultramax
Ultrastart
Green Ballast Inc.
Halco Lighting
Technologies
Hatch Lighting
HEP Group USA,
Inc.
DDH
ProLume
-
HEP HE
Ballast
HEX
Electronic
HE High
Efficiency
Howard Industries
HE Micro
Case
Micro Case
no
no
1.02/1.01
1.59/1.60
1.55/1.57
Keystone
Technologies
Premium
Series
Lighting and
Power
Technologies
Deltek
Maintenance
Engineering
Premira
Electronic
Ballast
BPM932
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.88
55
1.60
AntiStriation
SKEU322AS
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.88
44
2.00
SKEU322HE/SC
SKEU322HEH/SC
SKEU322HEL/SC
SKEU322HEL
SKEU322L/SC
SKE1323
SKE1324
SKE1324L
SKEU322H/SC
SKEU323HER/SC
SKEU323HEHR/SC
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
120
120
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
Normal
High
Low
Low
Low
Normal
High
Normal
High
Normal
High
0.89
55/54
1.62/1.65
1.19
76/75
1.57/1.59
0.77
48/47
1.60/1.64
0.77
0.78
0.96
1.05
0.94
1.18
0.88
1.18
48
48
55
67
58
74/73
57/56
72/71
1.60
1.63
1.75
1.57
1.62
1.59/1.61
1.54/1.57
1.64/1.66
High
Efficiency
Ballast
Maxlite
Electronic
Ballasts
Manufacturer
Product
Name
0.88
0.78
1.18
0.89
0.78
1.18
0.95
1.25
0.86
0.86
1.19
1.19
57/56
52/51
72/71
55/54
48
74/73
60
78
56
56
76
76
1.54/1.57
1.50/1.53
1.64/1.66
1.62/1.65
1.62
1.59/1.61
1.58
1.60
1.54
1.54
1.57
1.57
HIGH
OB2-T8-32-120/277-E-IN-0.9
EFFICIENCY
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.89
56
1.59
QHE 2X32T8/UNV ISH-SC
QHE 2X32T8/UNV ISN-SC-1
QHE 2x32T8/UNV-PSH-HT
QHE 2x32T8/UNV-PSN-MC
QTP 2X32T8/UNV PSN-TC
QTP 2X32T8/UNV PSX-TC
QTP 2X32T8/UNV ISH-SC
QHE 2x32T8/UNV ISM-SC
IOP-2P32-HL-SC
IOP-2S32-SC
IOP-2P32-SC @ 120V
IOP-2P32-SC @ 277V
IOP-2P32-LW-SC
IOP-2S32-LW-SC
IOPA-2P32-LW-SC
IOPA-2P32-SC
IOPA-2P32-HL-SC
IOP-2PSP32-SC
IOPANA-2P32SC
IOPA-2P32-N
IOP-2PSP32-LW-SC
IOPA-2P32-LW-N
REL-2P32-HL-SC
VEL-2P32-HL-SC
ICN-2P32-LW-SC
ICN-2P32N
70201
70210
70213
SL-2/32IS-120 (70209)
SL-2/32IS-277 (70200)
ISL232T8HEMVL
ISA232T8HEMV
ISA232T8HEMVH
ISA232T8HEMVL
ISL232T8HEMV
ISS232T8HEMVH
ISU232T8HEMV
ISU232T8HEMVL
ISS332T8HEMVH
ISS332T8HEMV
PSS232T8HEMV
PSA232T8HEMV
PSA232T8HEMH
PSL232T8HEMV
NLO232T8PIS
NLU232T8PIS
SLU232T8HPIS-ROHS
NU232T8RS-ROHS
NU240T8RS-ROHS
SLU232T8HPIS-ROHS
SU232T8LMCIS-ROHS
E2-32-I-UV-H
E2-32-I-UV-N
E2-32-I-UV-L
E-758-F-232-HL
E-758-F-232SC
E-758-U-232SC
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
yes
yes
no
no
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
277
120
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
120
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
P
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
High
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
High
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
High
Medium
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Low
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
High
High
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
High
Low
Normal
High
Normal
Low
High
High
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
High
High
Low
High
Normal
Low
High
Normal
Normal
1.20
0.78
0.77
0.88
0.87
0.99
1.06
1.15
0.88
0.88
0.71
0.88
1.20
1.00
1.18
0.88
0.87
0.87
0.77
0.71
0.77
0.87
1.18
0.85
1.00
.87/.89
0.71
.77/.80
1.20
1.20
0.78
0.89
0.87
0.88
1.18
0.88
0.88
0.77
0.89
1.18
0.78
0.88
74 / 73
48
48
55
55
62
68
72/70
57/55
59 / 56
47 / 46
55.6
77
63/62
74/72
56
55
54
48
47
48
54
74/72
58
59
55/56
46/45
48/50
77
77
48
56
54/53
1.62 /1.64
1.63
1.60
1.60
1.58
1.60
1.56
1.60/1.64
1.54/1.60
1.49/ 1.57
1.51/ 1.54
1.58
1.56
1.61
1.59/ 1.64
1.57
1.58
1.61
1.60
1.51
1.60
1.61
1.59/1.64
1.47
1.69
1.58/1.59
1.54/1.58
1.60
1.56
1.56
1.63
1.59
54.6/54.7
1.61
1.62/1.59
1.60
1.60
Omnitronix
Engineering LLC
Smart
Ballast
Optanium
Philips - Advance
Standard
Centium
Superior
Life
Sterling
Series
-
Sage Lighting Ltd
SLI
Lighting/Havells
USA
SOLA Canada
Lighting & Power
Inc
Sage
SLI
Sola
1.18/1.19
.92/.93
0.82
1.33/1.34
1.01/1.03
0.93
0.88
1.18
0.88
0.90
0.90
1.18/1.20
0.90
1.20
1.18/1.20
0.78
1.18/1.20
0.88
0.77
1.16
0.91
0.94
73/74
56
56
48/47
55
74/73
48
55
75/76
58
51
85
64/65
61
58/56
76/74
60/59
58
58/59
73
61
75
73
48.9
73/74
55
48
74
57
58.5
1.61/1.64
1.60/1.64
1.62
1.59/1.62
1.63
1.60
1.57
1.58/1.60
1.61
1.56/1.58
1.58
1.52
1.52/1.57
1.55/1.60
1.47/1.49
1.55
1.55/1.53
1.62/1.64
1.48
1.60
1.62/1.64
1.60
1.62
1.60
1.60
1.57
1.60
1.61
2 Lamp Products
Normal
Low
High
Normal
Low
High
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
High
High
High
Efficiency
Ballast
Robertson
Worldwide
BEF³
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
P
Mylar Electronics
Co, Ltd.
P.Q.L., Inc.
Input
Watts
(W)
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
Electronic
Ballast
EB-232PRS-U-ES
EB-232PRS-U-ES-LBF
EB-232PRS-U-ES-HBF
EB-232IS-U-ES
EB-232IS-U-ES-LBF
EB-232IS-U-ES-HBF
U-2/32IS
U-2/32IS HO
FX2T17-32M NO
FL2T17-32M NO
FL2T17-32M HO
FX2T17-32M HO
Ballast
Factor
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
MW McWong
International
Orion Energy
Systems
Model Number
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
Manufacturer
Standard
Products, Inc.
Product
Name
Gold Label
OptiStart
HiLumen
Sunpark
Electronics Corp.
Superior Lamps,
Inc.
Ultra Lumen
Heavy Duty
Electronic
Ballast
SwitchGenie, LLC. SwitchGenie
E32
E432
Technical
Consumer
Products, Inc.
-
TransPower
Company
Ultrasave Lighting
Ltd.
Universal Lighting
Technologies
Energy
Saving
Ballast
-
F32 T8
Ultim8
Triad
Model Number
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
Ballast
Factor
Input
Watts
(W)
BEF³
E232T8IS120/N
E232T8IS120/N/BULK
E232T8IS120/L
E232T8PS120-277/N/XTRM
no
no
no
no
120
120
120
120/277
I
I
I
P
Normal
Normal
Low
High
0.88
0.88
0.78
1.20
55
55
48
75
1.60
1.60
1.63
1.60
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.88
57/56
1.54/1.57
E232T8S120-277/L/AS/BULK
no
120/277
P
Low
0.78
52/51
1.50/1.53
E232T8PRS120-277/L
E232T8PRS120-277/N
E232SPR120-277L
U-2/32IS
U-2/32IS HBF
U-2/32ISE
U-2/32ISE-HBF
U-2/32ISE-LBF
U-2/32PSE
U-2/32PSE-HBF
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
Low
Normal
Low
Normal
High
Normal
High
Low
Normal
High
0.71
0.88
.67/.70
0.89
1.17
0.89
1.18
0.78
0.88
1.15
47
56/55
42/44
55.7
74.9
54
73
48
56
71.6
1.51
1.57/1.60
1.60/1.59
1.60
1.56
1.65
1.62
1.63
1.57
1.61
BPS932
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.88
55
1.60
SG232
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.88
54
1.63
E32IS32120H
E32IS32277H
E432IS32120N
E432IS32277N
E432IS32120L
E432IS32120U
TCP2P32ISUNVLE
TCP2P32ISUNVE
TCP2P32ISUNVHE
TCP2P321SUNVH
E2P32ISUNVHE
TCP2P32ISUNV
E2P32ISUNVE
TCP2P32ISUNVL
E2P32ISUNVLE
E3P32ISUNVE
E3P32ISUNVHE
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120
277
120
277
120
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
High
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Low
Normal
High
High
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
High
1.22
1.22
0.89
0.99
0.79
0.72
0.78
0.89
1.18
1.18
1.18
0.88
0.88
0.78
0.78
0.99
1.27
77
78
55.9
63
49
44
48
55/54
74/73
73/72
73/72
54/53
54/53
48
48
62
82/81
1.58
1.57
1.59
1.58
1.60
1.62
1.63
1.62/1.65
1.60/1.62
1.61/1.64
1.61/1.64
1.63/1.66
1.63/1.66
1.63
1.63
1.60
1.55/1.57
APC 402 U
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.95
61
1.56
APC 402 U
no
120/277
P
High
1.10
68
1.62
SR232120
SR232277
UT232120MH
UT232120M-HE
UT332120M-HE
PR232120M-HE
UT232120ML-HE
UT332120MH-HE
PR232120M-P-HE
PR232120ML-P-HE
PR232120M-PP-HE
B332I277HE
B232IUNV104-A
B232PUNVHE-A
B232PUNVEL-A
B332PUNVHP-A
B232IUNVHP-B
B332I120HE
B332I120L-A
B332IUNVEL-A
B232PUNVHP-A
B232I120HE
B232I277HE
B232IUNVHE-A
B332I277EL
B332I120EL
B232I120EL
B232I2770EL
B232IUNVEL-A
B232IUNVHEH-A
B232PUNVEL-A
B232PUNVEL-B
B232PUNVHE-A
B232PUNVHE-B
B232IUNV104-A
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
no
yes
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120
120
277
277
120
277
120/277
277
120
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
P
P
I
I
I
P
I
I
P
P
P
I
I
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
P
I
Normal
Low
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
High
Normal
Low
Normal
High
High
Normal
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Low
High
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
High
0.88
0.85
1.18
0.87
1.00
0.93
0.77
1.26
0.87
0.70
0.91
1.01
1.04
0.88
0.71
0.99
0.88
0.96
0.92
0.89
0.88
0.87
0.87
0.87
0.87
0.86
0.77
0.77
0.77
1.18
0.71
0.71
0.88
0.88
1.04
55
53
75
55
63
62
48
81
56
46
61
61
65/64
56/55
47/46
64 / 63
55
60
58
56
60
54
53
55 / 54
55
53
47
47
48
74/73
47/46
46/44
56/55
55/54
65/64
1.60
1.60
1.57
1.58
1.59
1.50
1.60
1.56
1.55
1.52
1.49
1.66
1.60/1.63
1.57/1.60
1.51/1.54
1.55/1.57
1.60
1.60
1.59
1.59
1.47
1.61
1.64
1.58/1.61
1.58
1.62
1.64
1.64
1.60
1.59/1.61
1.51/1.54
1.54/1.61
1.57/1.60
1.60/1.63
1.60/1.63
Normal
High
Low
0.88
1.18
0.77
83
112/109
73
1.06
1.05/1.08
1.05
HP T8 Qualified Ballasts with 3 Lamps
ACCUPRO
High
Efficiency
A*-332-IP-UNV
A*-332IP-H-UNV
A*-332IP-L-UNV
yes
no
no
277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
Manufacturer
Product
Name
American Ballast
High
Efficiency
Atlas Lighting
Products, Inc.
-
DuroPower
(BallastWise)
Ballastwise
Dynamic Ballast
Energy Efficient
Lighting Supply
High
Efficiency
High
Efficiency
Apollo
Espen
Technology, Inc.
Elite
Fulham
Workhorse
Fusion Ballasts
Electronic
ballasts
Proline
-
General Electric
Company
Ultramax
Ultrastart
Halco Lighting
Technologies
ProLume
Hatch Lighting
Hatch
HEX
Electronic
Howard Industries
HE High
Efficiency
Micro Case
HE Micro
Case
Model Number
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
Ballast
Factor
Input
Watts
(W)
BEF³
AB3-32-IP-UNV-HE
AB3-32-IP-UNV-1
AB3-32-IP-UNV-HBF
AB3-32-IP-UNV-LX
EB332UIH
EB332UI
DXE3H8
DXE3H81
DXE3H8U
DXE3H8U-HBF
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
120
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Normal
Normal
High
Low
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
High
0.88
0.88
1.18
0.77
1.18
0.87
0.92
0.88
0.88
1.18
83
83
112/109
73
108/106
83
83
82
83/82
109/107
1.05
1.09/1.11
1.05
1.11
1.07
1.06/1.07
1.08/1.10
DY 332 IS WV - HE
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.88
83
1.06
EEL-ISB-F32-3-MVOLT
no
120/277
I
Normal
.94/.96
89/91
1.06/1.05
VE332120HIP
VE332120HIPH
VE432120HIPE
VE332MVHIPLE
VE332MVHIPE
VE332MVHIPHE
VE332MVHIPH
VE332MVHRPE
VE332MVHRPHE
WHSG3-UNV-T8-IS
WHCG4-120-T8-IS
WHSG3-UNV-T8-HB
WHSG3-UNV-T8-LB
WHSG4-UNV-T8-HB
WHSG4-UNV-T8-IS
FB432MVE
FB432MVE-HE
GE-332-277-N
GE-332-MV-L
GE-332-MV-N
GE-332-MV-H
GE-332-MAX-N+
GE-332-MAX-N-42T
GE-332-MAX-L-42T
GE-332-MAX-H-42T
GE-332-MAX-H/Ultra
GE-332-MAX-L/Ultra
GE-332-MAX-N/Ultra
GE-332-MVPS-L
GE-332-MVPS-N
GE-332-MV-PS-H
GE-332-120-PS-N
GE-332-277-PS-N
EP332IS/L/MV/HE
EP332IS/MV/HE
EP332IS/H/MV/SL
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120
120
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120
120/277
277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
P
P
I
I
I
Normal
High
Normal
Low
Normal
High
High
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
High
Low
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Low
High
High
Low
Normal
Low
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
High
0.88
1.18
1.00
0.78
0.88
1.17
1.18
0.88
1.18
0.88
0.99
1.18
0.78
1.19
0.96
0.99
0.96
0.88
0.78
0.87
1.15
1.00
0.87
0.77
1.18
1.18
0.77
0.87
0.71
0.89
1.15
0.89
0.89
.78/.77
.87/.88
1.18
84
109
94
74
84/83
110/108
109/107
87/85
113/110
83
91
109/107
74
115/112
89
92
88
84
74/73
81/80
113/110
91/90
82/80
72/71
106/104
1.05
1.08
1.06
1.05
1.05/1.06
1.06/1.08
1.08/1.10
1.01/1.03
1.04/1.07
1.06
1.09
1.08/1.10
1.05
1.04/1.06
1.08
1.08
1.09
1.05
1.07
1.09
1.05
1.10/1.11
1.06/1.09 1.07/1.08
1.06/1.04
1.11/1.13
72/71
82 / 80
68
84
110/108
84
85
75/74
83/81
108
1.07/1.08
1.06/1.09 1.04
1.06
1.04/1.06
1.06
1.05
1.04
1.05/1.09
1.09
EP432IS/L/MV/HE
EP432IS/MV/HE
EP432IS/L/MV/SL
EP432PS/L/MV/HE
HL432AIS/UV/HE/W
HL432BIS/UV/HE/W
HL332AIS/UV/HE/W
HL332BIS/UV/HE/W
HL332CIS/UV/HE/W
E3/32IS-277 HEX
E3/32IS-120 HEX
EL3/32IS-120 HEX
EL3/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EL3/32IS-277 HEX
EP3/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EPH3/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EPL4/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EPL3/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EP4/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EP3/32IS/MV/MC
EPL3/32IS/MV/MC
EPH3/32IS/MV/MC
EP3/32IS/MV/MC/HE
EP4/32IS/MV/MC/HE
EPH3/32IS/MV/MC/HE
EPL3/32IS/MV/MC/HE
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120
120
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
High
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Low
Normal
High
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
Low
High
Normal
Normal
High
Low
.87/.86
.94/.95
0.84
.78/.79
.87/.86
.94/.95
.78/.77
.87/.88
1.18
0.87
0.87
0.77
0.75
0.77
0.87
1.15
0.84
0.75
0.92
0.88
0.78
1.18
0.88
0.96
1.18
0.78
81/78
89/88
79
78
81/78
89/88
75/74
83/81
1.07/1.10
1.06/1.08
1.06
1/1.01
1.07/1.10
1.06/1.08
1.04
111/108
1.06/1.09
83
83
73
71
73
82/80
110/107
80 / 79
72/71
88
84/83
75/74
109/107
84/83
89
1.05
1.05
1.05
1.06
1.05
1.06/1.09
1.05/1.07
1.05/1.06
1.04/1.06
1.05
1.05/1.06
1.04/1.05
1.08/1.10
1.05/1.06
1.08
1.08/1.10
1.04/1.05
109/107
75/74
1.06
1.06
1.05/1.08
1.11/1.13
1.05/1.09
Manufacturer
Product
Name
Jefferson Electric
Jefferson
High
Efficiency
Keystone
Technologies
Premium
Series
Lighting and
Power
Technologies
Deltek
Maintenance
Engineering
Premira
Electronic
Ballast
High
Efficiency
Ballast
Maxlite
Electronic
Ballast
MW McWong
International
Electronic
Ballast
Mylar Electronics
Co, Ltd.
High
Efficiency
Ballast
Philips - Advance
Optanium
P.Q.L., Inc.
Superior
Life
Ballast
Factor
Input
Watts
(W)
BEF³
401-4320-UNV
KTEB-332EBF-UV-TP-PIC
KTEB-332HBF-UV-TP-PIC
KTEB-332-UV-IS-L-P
KTEB-332-UV-IS-N-P
KTEB-332-UV-PS-N-P
KTEB-332-UV-PS-L-P
KTEB-332-UV-PS-H-P
KTEB-332-UV-IS-H-P
DB-332H-MV-TP-HE
DB-332N-MV-TP-HE
DB-332L-MV-TP-HE
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
Normal
Low
High
Low
Normal
Normal
Low
High
High
High
Normal
Low
0.94
0.77
1.18
.78/.77
.87/.88
0.88
0.77
1.18
1.18
1.18
.87/.88
.78/.77
89
74
108
75/74
83/81
88
79
114
111/108
111/108
83/81
75/74
1.06
1.04
1.09
1.04
1.05/1.09
1.00
0.97
1.04
1.06/1.09
1.06/1.09
1.05/1.09
1.04
BPM933
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.88
81
1.09
SKEU324HE
SKEU324HEL
SKEU323HEL/SC
SKEU323HE/SC
SKEU323HEH/SC
SKE1323/SC
SKE1323H/SC
SKEU323H/SC
SKEU323L/SC
SKEU323/SC
SKE1323
SKE1324
SKE1324L
SKEU1324L
SKEU323HER/SC
SKEU323HEHR/SC
EB-332PRS-U-ES
EB-332IS-U-ES
EB-332IS-U-ES-LBF
EB-332IS-U-ES-HBF
U-3/32IS
U-3/32IS HO
QHE 3X32T8/UNV ISH-SC
QHE 3X32T8/UNV ISL-SC1
QHE 3X32T8/UNVISN-SC1
QHE 3X32T8/UNV PSN-SC
QTP 3X32T8/UNV PSN-SC
QTP 3X32T8/UNV PSX-SC
QTP 3X32T8/UNV ISH-SC
QTP 3X32T8/UNV ISL-SC
ICN-3P32-SC
ICN-3P32-LW-SC
IOP-3P32-HL-90C-SC
IOP-3S32-SC
IOP-3P32-SC @ 120V
IOP-3P32-SC @ 277V
IOP-3P32-LW-SC @ 120V
IOP-3P32-LW-SC @ 277V
IOP-3S32-LW-SC
IOPA-3P32 LW-SC
IOPA-3P32-SC
IOPA-3P32-HL-SC
IOP-3PSP32-SC
IOPA-4P32-HL
70204
70205
70208
70211
70214
70220
SL-3/32IS-120 (70212)
SL-3/32IS-277 (70203)
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120
120/277
120/277
120
120
120/277
277
120/277
120
120
120
120
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
277
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
Normal
0.96
89
Normal
0.86
80
Low
0.78
74
Normal
0.88
84/83
110/108
High
1.17
Normal
0.88
84
High
1.18
109
109/107
High
1.18
Low
0.78
74
Normal
0.88
85
Normal
0.88
75
Normal
0.96
91
Low
0.85
77
Low
0.84
77
Normal
0.88
87/85
High
1.18
113/110
Normal
0.88
87/85
Normal
0.88
84/83
Low
0.78
74
108/106
High
1.18
Normal
0.95
88
High
1.15
104
High
1.18
111/109
High
1.15
110/108
Low
0.78
73/72
Low
0.77
73
Normal
0.88
83 / 82
Normal
0.87
82/81
Low
0.85
80
Normal
0.96
90/89
Normal
0.88
83/82
Normal
0.88
88 / 85
Low
0.71
73/71
High
1.18
114/111
Normal
0.88
84
Low
0.78
75
Medium
0.98
90/89
Normal
0.88
84
Low
0.77
73
High
1.18
110/107
Normal
0.88
83
Normal
0.87
82
Normal
0.87
80
Low
0.77
73
Low
0.77
71
Low
0.71
72
Low
0.77
73/71
Normal
0.87
82/80
High
1.18
110/107
Normal
0.88
84/85
High
1.29
122/120
Normal
0.88
84/83
Normal
0.88
84/83
Normal 0.88/0.90 83 / 86
Normal 0.94/0.96 89 / 91
High
1.28/1.31 109/111
Normal
0.85
76 / 77
Normal
0.88
84
Normal
0.88
84
1.08
1.08
1.05
1.05/1.06
1.06/1.08
1.05
1.08
1.08/1.10
1.05
1.04
1.17
1.06
1.10
1.09
1.01/1.04
1.04/1.07
1.01/1.03
1.05/1.06
1.05
1.09/1.11
1.08
1.11
1.06/1.08
1.05/1.07
1.08
1.05
1.06/1.07 1.06/1.07
1.06
1.07/1.08
1.06/1.07
1/1.04
.97/1.00
1.04/1.06
1.05
1.04
1.10
1.05
1.05
1.07/1.10
1.06
1.06
1.09
1.05
1.08
0.99
1.05/1.08
1.06/1.09
1.07/1.10
1.05/1.04
1.06/1.08
1.05/1.06
1.05/1.06
1.06/1.05
1.06/1.05
1.17/1.18
1.12/1.10
1.05
1.05
3 Lamp Products
Centium
Model Number
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
Manufacturer
Robertson
Worldwide
Product
Name
Sterling
Series
-
Sage Lighting Ltd
SLI
Lighting/Havells
USA
SOLA Canada
Lighting & Power
Inc
Standard
Products, Inc.
Sage
SLI
Sola
Gold Label
Optistart
HiLumen
Sunpark
Electronics Corp.
Superior Lamps,
Inc.
Ultra Lumen
Heavy Duty
Electronic
Ballast
E32
E432
Technical
Consumer
Products, Inc.
-
Topstar
International Inc.
Ultrasave Lighting
Ltd.
T8 Electronic
Ballast
-
Model Number
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
Ballast
Factor
Input
Watts
(W)
0.88
1.18
0.78
0.77
0.88
.80/.81
84/83
108/106
74
73/72
83/81
76/77
1.16/1.17
110/111
0.92
85/86
80
90/91
95
89
117
73
83
104
1.08/1.07
.84/.85
0.97
.98/.99
0.91
1.43
0.78
0.88
1.18
BEF³
ISA332T8HEMV
ISA332T8HEMVH
ISA332T8HEMVL
ISL332T8HEMVL
ISL332T8HEMV
ISS332T8HEMVL
ISS332T8HEMVH
ISS332T8HEMV
ISS432T8HEMVL
ISS432T8HEMV
PSL432T8HEMV
SAU440IS-ROHS
SAU440HPIS-ROHS
E3-32-I-UV-L
E3-32-I-UV-N
E3-32-I-UV-H
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
I
I
I
I
Normal
High
Low
Low
Normal
Low
High
Normal
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
High
Low
Normal
High
E-758-F-332
no
120
I
Normal
0.86
82
1.05
E332T8IS120/N
E332T8IS120/L
E332T8IS120/L/BULK
E332T8IS120/L/90C/BULK
E432T8IS120/L
E432T8IS120/N
E432T8IS120/N/BULK
E432T8IS120-277/N
E432T8IS120/L/BULK
E432T8IS120/H
E432T8IS120/H/90C
E432T8PS120277/L/AS/BULK
E432T8PRS120-277/N
E432T8PRS120-277/L
U-3/32IS HPF
U-3/32IS HBF
U-3/32ISE
U-3/32ISE-HBF
U-3/32ISE-LBF
U-3/32PSE
U-3/32PSE-HBF
U-332PS3
U-332PS3-HBF
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120/277
120
120
120
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Normal
Low
Low
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
High
High
0.90
0.78
0.78
0.77
0.85
0.97
1.00
0.94
0.85
1.15
1.15
83
73
73
73
80
88
93
89
80
109
109
1.08
1.07
1.07
1.05
1.06
1.10
1.08
1.06
1.06
1.06
1.06
no
120/277
P
Low
0.76
78
0.97
no
120/277
P
Normal 0.94/0.96
89/91
1.06/1.05
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
P
Normal
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
High
Low
Normal
High
Normal
High
0.94
0.87
0.89
1.17
0.88
1.18
0.78
0.88
1.18
1.00
1.15
89
78
82.9
109.8
83
106
74
85
110
100
115/111
1.06
1.12
1.07
1.07
1.06
1.11
1.05
1.04
1.07
1.00
1.00/1.04
BPS933
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.88
81
1.09
SG332
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.88
81
1.09
E32IS32120H
E32IS32277H
E432IS32120N
E432IS32277N
E432IS32120L
E432IS32120U
E432IS32277L
E432IS32277U
TCP3P32ISUNVLE
TCP3P2ISUNVE
TCP3P32ISUNVHE
TCP3P32ISUNVH
E3P32ISUNVHE
TCP3P32ISUNV
E3P32ISUNVE
TCP3P32ISUNVL
E3P32ISUNVLE
E4P32ISUNVLE
E4P32ISUNVE
E4P32ISUNVHE
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120
277
120
277
120
120
277
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
High
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Low
Low
Low
Normal
High
High
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
High
1.20
1.18
0.87
0.95
0.84
0.77
0.82
0.77
0.78
0.88
1.18
1.18
1.18
0.88
0.88
0.78
0.78
0.86
0.94
1.27
114
112
80
89
78
72
77
71
74
84/83
108/106
109/107
109/107
84/83
84/83
75/74
75/74
78/77
89
122/120
1.05
1.06
1.08
1.07
1.07
1.07
1.07
1.08
1.05
1.05/1.06
1.09/1.11
1.08/1.10
1.08/1.10
1.05/1.06
1.05/1.06
1.04/1.05
1.04/1.05
1.10/1.12
1.06
1.04/1.06
BB-T8/UVH-4x32/HPF
no
120
I
Normal
0.90
84
1.07
BB-T8/UVH-3x32/HPF
no
120
I
Normal
0.86
81
1.06
UT332120
UT332120M
UT332120MH
UT432120
UT432120M
eT432120M
GTL432120
UT432120L
UT432120M-HE
UT332120M-HE
UT332120MH-HE
UT332120ML-HE
PR432120M-PP-HE
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
120
120/277
120/277
120
120/277
120/277
120
120
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
Normal
0.89
0.89
1.18
1.00
1.00
0.99
0.91
0.82
0.96
0.87
1.13
0.76
0.95
83
83
110
93
93
92
86
78
88
82
108
73
89
1.07
1.07
1.07
1.08
1.08
1.08
1.06
1.05
1.09
1.06
1.05
1.04
1.07
High
Low
Normal
1.05/1.06
1.09/1.11
1.05
1.05/1.07
1.06/1.09
1.05
1.05
1.05/1.06
1.08/1.07
1.03/1.04
1.02
1.22
1.07
1.06
1.13
Manufacturer
Universal Lighting
Technologies
Product
Name
Model Number
F32 T8
Ultim8
B332I120RHH
B332I277RHH
B332I277RHU-A
B432I277HEH
B332IUNVHP-A
B332I120HE
B332I277HE
B432I120HE
B432I277HE
B332IUNVHE-A
B432I120EL
B332IUNVHEH-A
B332PUNVEL-A
B332PUNVHE-A
B432PUNVHP-A
B432IUNVHP-A
B432IUNVHE-A
B432I277EL
B432I120EL
B332I120EL
B332IUNVEL-A
ES1720B
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120
277
277
277
277
120
277
120
277
120/277
120
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
277
120
120
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Ballast
Factor
Input
Watts
(W)
BEF³
High
High
High
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
High
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
1.18
1.18
1.08
1.28
0.88
0.87
0.87
0.96
0.96
0.87
0.84
1.18
0.71
0.88
0.93
0.94
0.96
0.87
0.85
0.77
0.77
0.87
113
113
102
119
83
80
79
88
89
83 / 81
79
111/108
70/69
84/82
92/90
89
84/82
76
73
70
74 / 73
80/82
1.04
1.04
1.06
1.08
1.06
1.09
1.10
1.09
1.08
1.05/1.07
1.06
1.06/1.09
1.01/1.03
1.05/1.07
1.01/1.03
1.06
1.14/1.17
1.14
1.16
1.10
1.04/1.05
1.09/1.06
ACCUPRO
High
Efficiency
American Ballast
High
Efficiency
Atlas Lighting
Products, Inc.
-
DuroPower
(BallastWise)
Ballastwise
Dynamic Ballast
Energy Efficient
Lighting Supply
Espen
Technology, Inc.
High
Efficiency
High
Efficiency
Elite
Apollo
Fulham
Workhorse
Fusion Ballasts
Electronic
ballasts
Proline
Ultramax
General Electric
Company
Ultrastart
Halco Lighting
Technologies
ProLume
Hatch Lighting
Hatch
A*-432-IP-UNV
A*-432IP-H-UNV
A*-432IP-L-UNV
AB4-32-IP-UNV-HE
AB4-32-IP-UNV-1
AB4-32-IP-UNV-HBF
AB4-32-IP-UNV-LX
EB432UIH
EB432UI
DXE4H8
DXE4H81
DXE4H8U
yes
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
120
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Normal
High
Low
Normal
Normal
High
Low
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
0.88
1.18
0.77
0.88
0.88
1.18
0.77
1.18
0.87
0.92
0.88
0.88
108
147/144
96
109
109
147/144
96
140/134
109
111
108
109/107
0.81
.80/.82
0.80
0.81
0.81
.80/.82
0.80
.86/.90
0.80
0.83
0.81
.81/.82
DY 432 IS WV - HE
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.88
106
0.83
EEL-ISB-F32-4-MVOLT
no
120/277
I
Normal
.87/.88
106/108
.82/.81
VE432MVHIPL
yes
120/277
I
Low
0.77
98/96
0.79/0.80
VE432MVHIPE
yes
120/277
I
Normal
0.88
110/108
0.80/0.81
VE432MVHIPHE
VE432MVHIPH
VE432MVHIPLE
VE432120HIPE
WHSG4-UNV-T8-IS
WHSG4-UNV-T8-IS
WHCG4-277-T8-IS
WHSG4-UNV-T8-LB
WHSG4-UNV-T8-HB
FB432MVE
FB432MVE-HE
GE-432-MV-L
GE-432-MV-N
GE-432-MV-H
GE-432-MAX-H/Ultra
GE-432-MAX-N/Ultra
GE-432-MAX-L/Ultra
GE-432-MAX-N+
GE-432-MAX-N-42T
GE-432-MAX-L-42T
GE-432-MAX-H-42T
GE-432-277-PS-N
GE-432-120-PS-N
GE-432-MVPS-N
GE-432-MVPS-L
GE-432-MVPS-H
GE-432-277-N
EP432IS/L/MV/HE
EP432IS/MV/HE
EP432IS/L/MV/SL
EP432PS/MV/HE
EP432PS/L/MV/HE
HL432AIS/UV/HE/W
HL432BIS/UV/HE/W
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
120
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
P
P
I
I
High
High
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
High
High
Normal
Low
Normal
Normal
Low
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
High
Normal
Low
Normal
Low
Normal
Low
Normal
Normal
1.16
1.16
0.77
0.88
0.88
0.92
0.89
.79/.80
1.16
0.87
0.86
0.80
0.88
1.18
1.18
0.87
0.77
1.00
0.87
0.77
1.15
0.88
0.89
0.89
0.71
1.16
0.88
.78/.77
.88/.87
0.77
0.86
0.74
.78/.77
.88/.87
145/144
145
98/96
110
108
112
110
98/96
145/144
108
106
100/98
110
146/143
148/145
108/106
97/95
121
108/106
97/95
148/145
110
112
114/112
88
144
110
98/96
110/106
96
114
97
98/96
0.80/0.81
0.80
0.79/0.80
0.80
0.81
0.82
0.81
.81/.83
.80/.81
0.81
0.81
.80/.82
0.80
.81/.83
.80/.81
.81/.82
.79/.81
0.83
.81/.82
.79/.81
.80/.81
0.80
0.79
.78/.79
0.81
0.81
0.80
0.80
.80/.82
0.80
0.75
0.76
.80/.80
.80/.82
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
110/106
Manufacturer
Product
Name
Keystone
Technologies
Input
Watts
(W)
BEF³
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
120
277
120
277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
Low
High
Normal
0.87
0.87
0.77
0.77
0.75
0.75
0.87
0.88
0.77
0.88
0.77
1.16
0.88
109
109
98
96
95 / 94
94
109/107
110/108
98/96
98/96
145/144
108
0.80
0.80
0.79
0.80
0.80
0.80
.80/.81
.80/.81
.79/.80
.80/.82
.79/.80
.80/.81
0.81
High
Efficiency
KTEB-432EBF-UV-TP-PIC
no
120/277
I
Low
0.77
96
0.80
Premium
Series
KTEB-432-UV-IS-L-P
KTEB-432-UV-IS-N-P
KTEB-432-UV-PS-N-P
KTEB-432-UV-PS-L-P
KTEB-432-1-IS-N-P
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
I
I
P
P
I
Low
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
.78/.77
.88/.87
0.87
0.74
0.88
98/96
110/106
114
97
108
0.80
.80/.82
0.76
0.76
0.81
DB-432L-MV-TP-HE
no
120/277
I
Low
.78/.77
98/96
0.80
DB-432N-MV-TP-HE
no
120/277
I
Normal
.88/.87
110/106
.80/.82
HE High
Efficiency
Micro Case
Jefferson Electric
Ballast
Factor
E4/32IS-120HEX
E4/32IS/-277HEX
EL4/32IS-120HEX
EL4/32IS-277HEX
EPL4/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EL4/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EP4/32IS/MV/SC/HE
EP4/32IS/MV/MC
EPL4/32IS/MV/MC
EP4/32IS/MV/MC/HE
EPL4/32IS/MV/MC/HE
EPH4/32IS/MV/SC
401-4320-UNV
HEX
Electronic
Howard Industries
Model Number
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
Small Case
Jefferson
110/108
Deltek
Maintenance
Engineering
Premira
Electronic
Ballast
BPM934
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.87
110
0.79
AntiStriation
SKEU324AS
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.88
88
1.00
SKEU324L/SC
SKEU324/SC
SKEU324H/SC
SKEU324HE
SKEU324HEH/SC
SKEU324HEL/SC
SKEU324HE/SC
SKEU324HEL
EB-432IS-U-ES
EB-432IS-U-ES-LBF
EB-432IS-U-ES-HBF
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Low
Normal
High
Normal
High
Low
Normal
Low
Normal
Low
High
0.77
0.88
1.16
0.88
1.16
0.77
0.88
0.77
0.88
0.77
1.16
98/96
108
145
109
145/144
98/96
110/108
95
110/108
98/96
145/144
.79/.80
0.82
0.80
0.81
0.80
.79/.80
.80/.82
0.81
.80/.81
.79/.80
.80/.81
U-4/32IS
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.90
110
0.82
QHE4x32T8/UNV ISH
QHE4x32T8/277 ISH
QHE 4X32T8/UNV ISN-SC-1
QHE 4x32T8/UNV-PSN-SC
QTP 4X32T8/UNV PSN-SC
QTP 4X32T8/UNV PSX-SC
QTP 4X32T8/UNV ISL-SC
ICN-4P32-LW-SC
ICN-4P32-SC
ICN-4P32-N
IOP-4P32-HL-90C-G
IOP-4S32-SC
IOP-4P32-SC @ 120V
IOP-4P32-SC @ 277V
IOP-4P32-LW-SC @120V
IOP-4P32-LW-SC @277V
IOP-4S32-LW-SC
IOPA-4P32-LW-SC
IOPA-4P32-SC
IOP-4PSP32-SC
IOPA-4P32-HL
70204
70205
yes
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
no
no
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
277
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
P
I
I
I
High
High
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
Medium
Low
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Low
Low
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
1.15
1.15
0.78
0.77
0.88
0.87
1.15
0.88
0.88
0.71
0.78
0.88
0.98
0.77
0.89
0.89
1.18
0.88
0.87
0.87
0.77
0.77
0.71
0.77
0.87
0.88
1.18
0.87
0.87
144/141
148
95
96
108/107
109/107
143/141
111/108
118/113
93/91
98
110
122/120
95
111
111
148/144
109
108
106
97
95
92
94
106
109/110
152/148
109/107
109/107
0.80/0.82
0.78
0.82
0.80
0.81/0.82 .80/.81
.80/.82
.79/.81
.75/.78
.76/.78
0.80
0.80
0.80/0.82
0.81
0.80
0.80
0.80/0.82
0.81
0.81
0.82
0.79
0.81
0.77
0.82
0.82
.81/.80
.78/.80
.80/.81
.80/.81
70211
no
120/277
P
Normal
70214
no
120/277
I
High
1.20
140/134
.86/.90
70220
SL-4/32IS-120 (70212)
SL-4/32IS-277 (70203)
no
no
no
120/277
120
277
I
I
I
Low
Normal
Normal
0.78
0.88
0.88
95 / 96
110
110
.82/.81
0.80
0.80
Electronic
Ballasts
Maxlite
High
Efficiency
Ballast
MW McWong
International
Electronic
Ballast
Mylar Electronics
Co, Ltd.
High
Efficiency
Ballast
Centium
Philips - Advance
Optanium
P.Q.L., Inc.
Superior Life
0.87/0.88 106/104
.82/.85
4 Lamp Products
Lighting and
Power
Technologies
Manufacturer
Robertson
Worldwide
Product
Name
Sterling
Series
-
Sage Lighting Ltd
SLI
Lighting/Havells
USA
SOLA Canada
Lighting & Power
Standard
Products, Inc.
Sage
SLI
Sola
Gold Label
Optistart
HiLumen
Sunpark
Electronics Corp.
Ultra Lumen
Superior Lamps,
Inc.
Heavy Duty
Electronic
Ballast
E432
Technical
Consumer
Products, Inc.
-
Topstar
International Inc.
Ultrasave Lighting
Ltd.
Universal Lighting
Technologies
T8 Electronic
Ballast
-
F32 T8
Ultim 8
Model Number
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
ISA432T8HEMV
ISA432T8HEMVL
ISL432T8HEMVL
ISL432T8HEMV
ISS432T8HEMVL
ISS432T8HEMV
PSL432T8HEMV
SAU440IS-ROHS
SAU440HPIS-ROHS
E4-32-I-UV-L
E4-32-I-UV-N
E4-32-I-UV-H
E-758-F-432SC
E-758-U-432SC
E432T8IS120/L
E432T8IS120/N
E432T8IS120-277/N
E432T8IS120/N/BULK
E432T8IS120/L/BULK
E432T8IS120/H
E432T8IS120/H/90C
E432T8PS120277/L/AS/BULK
E432T8PRS120-277/L
U-4/32IS HPF
U-4/32IS HBF
U-4/32IS LBF
U-4/32ISE
U-4/32ISE-HBF
U-4/32ISE-LBF
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120
120/277
120
120
120/277
120
120
120
120
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
High
Low
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
no
120/277
no
Ballast
Factor
Input
Watts
(W)
BEF³
110/108
98/96
95/94
110/108
98
High
High
0.88
0.77
0.77
0.88
0.79
0.90
.90/.91
0.88
1.33
0.78
0.87
1.20
0.91
0.91
0.78
0.85
0.88
0.88
0.78
1.15
1.10
114
107
143
95/96
106
140/134
112
13
95
105
106
108
95
109
140
.80/.82
.79/.80
0.81/0.82
0.80/0.81
0.81
.82/.81
.79/.80
0.82
0.93
0.82
0.82
.86/.90
0.81
0.81
0.82
0.81
0.83
0.81
0.82
1.06
0.79
P
Normal
0.87
110/109
0.79/0.80
120/277
P
Low
0.71
93/92
0.76/0.77
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
Low
Normal
High
Low
Normal
High
Low
0.77
0.88
1.17
0.78
0.88
1.16
0.77
101
109
149.8
97.2
108
144
96
0.77
0.81
0.79
0.80
0.81
0.81
0.80
BPS934
no
120/277
P
Normal
0.87
110
0.79
SG432
no
120/277
I
Normal
0.88
108
0.81
E432IS32120N
E432IS32277N
E432IS32120L
E432IS32120U
E432IS32277L
E432IS32277U
TCP4P32ISUNVLE
TCP4P32ISUNVE
TCP4P32ISUNVHE
TCP4P321SUNVH
E4P32ISUNVHE
TCP4P32ISUNV
E4P32ISUNVE
TCP4P32ISUNVL
E4P32ISUNVLE
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
120
277
120
120
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Low
Low
Low
Normal
High
High
High
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
0.87
0.88
0.78
0.72
0.75
0.70
0.77
0.88
1.16
1.18
1.18
0.88
0.88
0.77
0.78
107
108
95
84
92
85
98/96
110/108
145/144
147/145
147/145
110/108
110/108
96/95
96/95
0.81
0.82
0.82
0.85
0.82
0.82
.79/.80
.80/.82
.80/.81
.80/.81
.80/.81
.80/.81
.80/.81
.80/.81
.81/.82
BB-T8/UVH-4x32/HPF
no
120
I
Normal
0.86
108
0.80
UT432120L
eT432120M
GTL432120
UT432120MH
UT432120M-HE
UT432120L-HE
UT432120ML-HE
PR432120M-PP-HE
B432I277HEH
B432I120HE
B432PUNVHP-A
B432IUNV-D
B432I277RH-A
B432IUNVHP-A
B432I277HE
B432IUNVHE-A
B423I120HE
B432I277L-A
B432I120EL
B432I277EL
B432IUNVEL-A
ES1720B
B432PUNVEL-A
B432PUNVHE-A
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
no
no
120
120/277
120
120/277
120/277
120
120/277
120/277
277
120
277
277
277
277
277
120/277
120
277
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
I
I
P
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
P
P
Low
Normal
Low
High
Normal
Low
Low
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Low
Low
Low
Normal
Low
Normal
0.71
0.87
0.82
1.18
0.86
0.79
0.76
0.88
1.18
0.87
0.88
0.88
0.88
0.88
0.87
0.87
0.87
0.78
0.77
0.77
0.77
0.87
0.71
0.87
93
108
101
146
106
100
96
110
145
100
115
109
110
108
105
109/106
106
98
95
93
97/96
107/108
91/90
109/107
0.76
0.81
0.81
0.81
0.81
0.79
0.79
0.80
0.81
0.87
0.77
0.81
0.80
0.81
0.83
0.80/0.82
0.82
0.76
0.81
0.82
0.79/0.80
0.81
0.78/0.79
0.80/0.81
110/111
Manufacturer
Product
Name
Model Number
Ballast
Factor
(V)
Type ²
Premium®
Range
Ballast
Factor
Input
Watts
(W)
BEF³
1.18
221/215
.53/.55
1
UltraMax
GE632MAX-H90
yes
120/277
I
High
CEE's specification uses the BALLAST EFFICACY FACTOR (BEF) as the true measure of efficiency. The input watt figure
calculations are based on a premium 4', 32W T8 reference lamp.
2
3
“P” signifies programmed start, “I” signifies instant start, "D" signifies dimming capabilities
BEF is calculated by multiplying the Ballast Factor by 100 and dividing by the input watts, except for Howard Industries and Standard Products,
which provide the information in their catalog.
4
NEMA Premium® is a trademark of the National Electrical Manufacturers Association. It is an identifiable certification mark for manufacturers to use
on products that meet the ballast portion of CEE's current specification for High Performance Lighting Systems. The label is available to all
manufacturers that enroll in the NEMA Premium® program and sign a Memorandum of Understanding and Licensing agreement with NEMA.
www.cee1.org
617-589-3949
6 Lamp
General Electric
Company
QUALIFYING PRODUCTS
1
High-Performance 120 and 277V T8 Dimming Ballasts
Updated 12/30/11
For a list of qualifying 347 V T8 ballasts, see:
www.cee1.org/com/com-lt/347-ballasts.xls
Click "Open." When "Connect to www.cee1.org" box opens, click on "Cancel" twice
Legend: Red Font is a product no longer manufactured, but still meets the criteria as a qualifying product
Manufacturer Product Name
Model Number
NEMA4
Premium®
Lamp
Wattage
Voltage
(V)
Ballast
Type ²
Ballast
Ballast
Input
Factor
Factor Watts (W)
Range
BEF³
HP T8 Qualified Ballasts with 1 Lamp
DALI
FLT-120-1x32WT8HBF-DALI
FLT-277-1x32WT8HBF-DALI
no
no
32
32
120
277
PD
PD
Normal
Normal
1.00
1.00
35
35
2.86
2.86
UltraStart T8
100-3%
Dimming
GE132MVPS-N-VO3
no
32
120/277
PD
Normal
0.88
30/29
2.93/3.03
Leviton
Sector
LUMEnergi
LUMEnergi
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120
277
120/277
120/277
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
High
High
High
Normal
High
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
1.15
1.15
1.20
1.00
1.17
1.00
1.17
0.88
0.87
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
39
39
40
2.95
2.95
3.00
35.1 / 34.8
2.85/2.87
Mark 7
ROVR
SD1F8-32M
SD1J8-32M
LUM-LD-IB100
H3D T832 C UNV 1 10
H3D T832 C UNV 1 17
EHD T832 C U 1 10
EHD T832 C U 1 17
QTP1X32T8/UNVDIM-TC
QHES2X32T8/UNVPSN-SC
REZ-132-SC
VEZ-132-SC
IZT-132-SC
IDA-132-SC
Sterling Series
PSL132T8MV3D
yes
32
120/277
PD
Normal
B232PUNVDRL-A
B232PUNVDR-A
B232PUS50-A
B132PUNVSV3-A
yes
yes
yes
yes
32
32
32
32
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
PD
PD
PD
PD
Hi-Lume3D
Lutron
EcoSystem
OSRAM
SYLVANIA
Philips Advance
Robertson
Worldwide
Universal
Lighting
Technologies
Quicktronic
Mark 10
Powerline
DemandFlex
Ballastar
SuperDim
39.7
2.95
35.1 / 34.8
2.85/2.87
39.7
30
28/29
35
35
35
27/35
2.95
2.93
3.00/3.11
2.86
2.86
2.86
3.70/2.86
1.00
34
2.94
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
.83/.84
0.88
0.88
0.88
23.7/23.8
29/30
29
30
2.88/2.87
3.03/2.93
3.03
2.93
ELB
Electronics,
Inc.
ELB Plus
Dimming Ballast
0-10VDC
Espen
Technology,
Inc.
Dynamus
UltraMax BiLevel Switching
General
Electric
Company
UltraMax
LoadShed
Dimming
UltraStart T8
100-3%
Dimming
Leviton
Sector
LUMEnergi
LUMEnergi
Hi-Lume3D
Lutron
EcoSystem
Eco-10
ELB-2L32 EA10ES120-277
no
32
277
PD
Normal
0.88
58.3
1.51
ELB-2L32 EA10E120-277
no
32
277
PD
Normal
1.00
67.5
1.48
ELB-2L32 EA10EH120-277
no
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
74.2/72.3
1.59/1.63
VE232MVHRPT3-AB
yes
32
120/277
PD
Normal
1.00
68
1.47
VE232MVHRPHT3-AB
yes
32
120/277
PD
High
1.20
79
1.52
GE232MAX90-S60
yes
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
75/74
1.57/1.59
GE232MAX90-V60
yes
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
75/74
1.57/1.59
GE232MVPS-N-VO3
no
32
120/277
PD
Normal
0.88
58/56
1.52/1.57
GE232MVPS-H-VO3
no
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
76/74
1.55/1.59
SD2F8-32M
SD2J8-32M
LUM-LD-IB100
H3D T832 C UNV 2 10
H3D T832 C UNV 2 17
EC5 T832 G UNV 2L
EC5 T832 J UNV 2
EHD T832 C U 2 10
EHD T832 C U 2 17
EC3 T832 C U 2 10
EC3 T832 G U 2 10
EC3 T832 C U 2 17
EC3 T832 G U 2 17
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
High
High
High
Normal
High
Low
Low
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
High
High
1.15
1.15
1.20
1.00
1.17
0.85
0.85
1.00
1.17
1.00
1.00
1.17
1.17
76
76
76/75
66.5/65.7
76.9/75.4
56.9
59.1/57.4
1.51
1.51
1.58/1.60
1.50/1.52
1.52/1.55
1.49
1.44/1.48
66.5 / 65.7
1.50 / 1.52
76.9 / 75.4
1.52 / 1.55
66.5 / 65.7
1.50/1.52
66.5 / 65.7
1.50/1.52
76.9 / 75.4
1.52/1.55
76.9 / 75.4
1.52/1.55
1 Lamp
Fifth Light
Technology
General
Electric
Company
Philips Advance
Pure
Spectrum
Lighting
Robertson
Worldwide
Sage Lighting
Ltd
Sunpark
Electronics
Corp.
Ultrasave
Lighting Ltd.
Universal
Lighting
Technologies
Quicktronic
yes
32
120/277
PD
Normal
0.87
55/54
1.58/1.61
QTP2X32T8/UNV DIM TC
yes
32
120/277
PD
Normal
0.88
60/58
1.47/1.52
QHELS2X32T8/UNV-ISN-SC
yes
32
277
ID
Normal
0.88
56/55
1.60
QHES2X32T8/UNVPSL-SC
yes
32
120/277
PD
Low
0.77
48
1.60
QHE2x32T8/UNV DALI
yes
32
120/277
PD
Normal
1.00
66/65
1.51/1.54
Mark 7
EssentiaLine
ROVR
REZ-2S32-SC
VEZ-2S32-SC
IZT-2S32-SC
ILV-2S32-SC
IDA-2S32-SC
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
32
32
32
32
32
120
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
1.00
1.00
1.00
0.88
1.00
68
68
67
59
68.0
1.47
1.47
1.49
1.49
1.47
PureSpectrum
PST232PNS3
no
32
277
PD
Normal
1.00
68
1.47
Sterling Series
PSL232T8MV3D
no
32
120/277
PD
Normal
1.00
68
1.47
Sage
NU232T8D-ROHS
no
32
120/277
PD
Normal
0.88
60
1.47
U-232PS3
no
32
277
PD
Normal
1.00
68
1.47
U-232PS3-HBF
no
32
277
PD
High
1.20
79
1.52
PR232120M-D
no
32
120/277
PD
Normal
1.00
67
1.49
B232PUNVDR-A
B232PUNVDRL-A
B232PUNVDRH-A
B232PUNVDFH-A
B232PUNVDYL-A
B232PUNVDY-A
B232PUNVDYH-A
B232PU104S50-A
B232PUS50-A
B232PUNVSV3-A
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
Normal
Low
High
High
Low
Normal
High
High
Normal
Normal
0.88
0.71
1.18
1.15
0.69
0.87
1.15
1.04
0.88
0.88
56/55
47
74/72
76/75
46
58/57
76/74
65
57/56
57/56
1.57/1.6
1.51
1.59/1.64
1.51/1.53
1.50
1.60
1.54/1.57
1.54/1.57
Mark 10
Powerline
2 Lamp
OSRAM
SYLVANIA
QHES2X32T8/UNVPSN-SC
Ultra Lumen
-
Demand Flex
Ballastar
SuperDim
1.50/1.53
1.51/1.55
ELB-3L32 EA10ES120-277
no
32
120/277
PD
Normal
0.88
84/82.5
1.51
ELB-3L32 EA10E120-277
no
32
277
PD
Normal
1.00
98.8
1.48
ELB-3L32 EA10EH120-277
no
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
118.4/115.9
1.59/1.63
VE332MVHRPT3-AB
yes
32
120/277
PD
Normal
1.00
99
1.01
VE332MVHRPHT3-AB
yes
32
120/277
PD
High
1.20
119
1.01
GE332MAX90-S60
yes
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
113/110
1.04/1.07
GE332MAX90-V60
yes
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
113/110
1.04/1.07
GE332MVPS-N-VO3
no
32
120/277
PD
Normal
0.88
87/85
1.01/1.04
GE332MVPS-H-VO3
no
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
116/113
1.02/1.04
LUM-LD-IB100
H3D T832 C UNV 3 17
H3D T832 G UNV 3 10
EC5 T832 G UNV 3 17
EC5 T832 G UNV 3L
EHD T832 G U 3 10
EC3 T832 G U 3 10
EC3 T832 G U 3 17
QHELS3X32T8/UNV ISN-SC
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
yes
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
120/277
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
ID
High
High
Normal
High
Low
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
1.20
1.17
1.00
1.17
0.85
1.00
1.00
1.17
0.88
QTP3X32T8/UNVDIM-TC
yes
32
120/277
PD
Normal
0.88
ROVR
IZT-3S32-SC
REZ-3S32-SC
VEZ-3S32-SC
IDA-3S32-G
yes
yes
yes
yes
32
32
32
32
120/277
120
277
120/277
PD
PD
PD
PD
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Sterling Series
PSL332T8MV3D
yes
32
120/277
PD
U-332PS3
no
32
277
U-332PS3-HBF
no
32
120/277
ELB
Electronics,
Inc.
ELB Plus
Dimming Ballast
0-10VDC
Espen
Technology,
Inc.
Dynamus
General
Electric
Company
LUMEnergi
UltraMax
LoadShed
Dimming
UltraStart T8
100-3%
Dimming
LUMEnergi
Lutron
EcoSystem
Eco-10
OSRAM
SYLVANIA
Philips Advance
Robertson
Worldwide
Sunpark
Electronics
Corp.
Quicktronic
Mark 7
Mark 10
Powerline
1.06/1.07
1.10/1.11
95.4/93.5 1.05/1.07
106.8/105.7 1.10/1.11
85.9/86.5
.99/.98
95.4 / 93.5
1.05 / 1.07
95.4 / 93.5
1.05 / 1.07
106.8/105.7
1.10/1.11
83/82
1.06/1.07
87/84
1.01/1.05
1.00
0.97
0.97
1.00
93
96.0
96.0
99.0
1.08
1.01
1.01
1.01
Normal
1.00
100
1.00
PD
Normal
1.00
100
1.00
PD
High
1.15
115/111
1.00/1.04
Ultra Lumen
3 Lamp
Hi-Lume3D
113/112
106.8/105.7
Universal
Lighting
Technologies
Demand Flex
B332PUNVDR-A
B332PUNVDRL-A
B332PUNVDRH-E
yes
yes
yes
32
32
32
120/277
120/277
120/277
PD
PD
PD
Normal
Low
High
0.87
0.71
1.15
85/83
72
115/111
1.02/1.05
0.99
1.00/1.04
General
Electric
Company
Philips Advance
Quicktronic
Mark 7
ROVR
Universal
Lighting
Technologies
Demand Flex
Ballastar
yes
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
149/146
0.79/.81
GE432MAX90-V60
yes
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
149/146
.79/.81
GE432MVPS-N-VO3
no
32
120/277
PD
Normal
0.88
114/111
.77/.79
GE432MVPS-H-VO3
no
32
120/277
PD
High
1.18
150/148
.79/.80
QTP4X32T8/UNV DIM-TC
yes
32
120/277
PD
Normal
0.88
114/110
.77/.80
IZT-4S32
VZT-4S32-G
VZT-4S32-HL
VZT-4PSP32-G
IDA-4S32
B432PUNVDR-E
B432PUNVDRL-E
B432P277V5-E
B432P277V5H-E
yes
yes
yes
no
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
120/277
277
277
277
120/277
120/277
120/277
277
277
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
PD
Normal
Normal
High
Normal
Normal
Normal
Low
Normal
High
0.88
0.88
1.18
0.88
0.88
0.88
0.71
0.88
1.18
116
116
149
112
116
116/112
93
115
150
0.76
0.76
0.79
0.79
0.76
0.76/0.79
0.76
0.77
0.79
4 Lamp
OSRAM
SYLVANIA
UltraMax
LoadShed
Dimming
UltraStart T8
100-3%
Dimming
GE432MAX90-S60
GE632MAX-H90-S60
yes
32
120/277
ID
High
1.18
221/215
.53/.55
GE632MAX-H90-V60
yes
32
120/277
ID
High
1.18
221/215
.53/.55
UltraMax
3
BEF is calculated by multiplying the Ballast Factor by 100 and dividing by the input watts, except for Howard Industries and Standard Products,
which provide the information in their catalog.
4
NEMA Premium® is a trademark of the National Electrical Manufacturers Association. It is an identifiable certification mark for manufacturers to use
on products that meet the ballast portion of CEE's current specification for High Performance Lighting Systems. The label is available to all
manufacturers that enroll in the NEMA Premium® program and sign a Memorandum of Understanding and Licensing agreement with NEMA.
www.cee1.org
617-589-3949
6 Lamp
General
Electric
Company
APPENDIX D – MECHANICAL CALCULATIONS
U-VALUE CALCULATIONS
RS Consulting
Job Name:
Job Number:
Seattle, Washington
Date:
3-Dec-11
Eng:
R. Sneeringer
Wall -1
Remodel Areas
Construction
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
Resistance (R)
At Frame Btwn Frame
20%
80%
0.17
0.17
12.00
12.00
0.80
0.80
4.35
--18.00
0.56
0.56
0.68
0.68
Outside Air Film (15 mph)
3" EIFS @ R-4/in
3/4" Plywood
2x6 Wood @ 16" OC
R-19 Batt Insulation (comp)
5/8" Sheetrock
Inside Air Film (still air)
R-Total
Wall U-Value
Wall - 2
Gym Areas
Resistance (R)
At Frame Btwn Frame
20%
80%
0.17
0.17
8.00
8.00
0.80
0.80
5.80
--21.00
0.80
0.80
1.56
1.56
0.68
0.68
3" EIFS @ R-4/in
3/4" Plywood
2x8 Wood @ 16" OC
R-21 Batt Insulation (comp)
5/8" Ply
5/8" Sheetrock
R-Total
Wall U-Value
32.21
0.036
Construction
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)
18.56
0.035
17.81
33.01
U-VALUE CALCULATIONS
RS Consulting
Job Name:
Job Number:
Roof-1:
Seattle, Washington
Date:
3-Dec-11
Eng:
R. Sneeringer
Resistance (R)
At Frame Btwn Frame
100%
-0.17
-0.50
-40.00
-0.80
-2.00
-0.17
Construction
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
Built Up Roofing
20" Rigid Insulation
3/4" Plywood
Air Space
R-Total
Roof U-Value
Floor:
Existing Slab /Grade
N/A
43.64
0.023
Construction
Resistance (R)
At Frame Btwn Frame
Insulated Slab Edge
R-Total
Floor U-Value
Windows:
N/A
0.550 Btu/deg f/lin ft
Double Pane
Construction
1) Vinyl Frame, Triple Pane 1/2" Air Space, TBrk, 1" Thk
2) Use Value from ASHRAE Table 13 1989
Window U-Value
0.330
Shading Coefficient
Clear Glazing
Doors:
Man Doors
0.83
Construction
1) Sandwiched Panel Insulated
Door U-Value
0.600
Building Envelope - Calculations and Common Conversions
•
U-Value = 1/R-Value
•
R-Values per Inch of Common Insulation Materials
Fiberglass Blanket 3.2
Loose Fiberglass 2.5
Fiberglass Blown-in-Bat 4.0
Loose Rock Wool 2.8
Loose Cellulose 3.5
Wet-Spray Cellulose 3.9
Vermiculite 2.7
Polyisocyanurate 5.8
Expanded Polystyrene (bead board) 3.8
Extruded Polystyrene (blue board) 4.8
Foil Faced Polyisocyanurate 7.0
Spray applied Foam 6.0
U value = btu’s/ Hour x sq ft x deg F = 1/R
R value = Hours x sq ft x deg F / BTU’s= 1/U
q (Building heat loss in btu’s/hr)= U x A x Delta T = U x A x DD x 24 (annual heat loss)
Sample Calculations:
Building Envelope-Heat Transfer Calculations
R- “Resistance value” of building materials to heat flow
RT = R inside film + R1 + R2 +… R outside film
U-value: “overall heat transfer co-efficient”
(Includes allowance for BOTH convection and conduction heat transfer)
U = 1/ RT
Sample Calculation 1:
Windows: window area is 1000 square feet
Window is triple pane; U = .27
Q = A * U * (Ti – To)
Where
Q = Total hourly rate of heat loss through walls, roof, glass, etc in Btu/hr
U = Overall heat-transfer coefficient of walls, roof, ceiling, floor, or glass in Btu/hr ft2°F
A = Net area of walls, roof, ceiling, floor, or glass in ft2
Ti = Inside design temperature in °F = 70
To = Outside design temperature in °F = 30
Q = U * A * delta T
= .27 x 1000 x (70 – 30) = .27 x 1000 x 40
= 10,800 Btu/hour
Sample Calculation 2:
For sample calculations- outside design = 30 F, inside design = 70 F
Walls: wall area is 1000 square feet
Wall is wood stud with R-30 insulation;
U = 0.033
Q = U x A x delta T
= 0.033 x 1000 x (70 – 30) = 0.033 x 1000 x 40
= 1333.3 Btu/hour
Radiation heat gain thru windows
Q = (A) x (SHGF) x (CLF) x (SC)
Where:
Q = heat transfer in BTU/HR
A = window area in ft2
SHGF= solar heat gain factor (dependent on orientation and location)
CLF = cooling load factor (dependent on shading and color of interior surface)
SC = shading coefficient (property of glazing; dependent on clear/tinted/mirror glass surface)
Other ratings- SHGC = solar heat gain coefficient = SC x 0.86
Glazing selection – Single pane vs. dual/triple pane
Single pane- “U” = 1.10
Dual pane- “U” = 0.35
Triple pane- “U” = 0.22
(NOTE effect of interior “films” at glass surfaces; insulation value increases due to air space and number
of surface films)
– “low E” glass coating that allows light to get thru but not heat
Glazing Selection
SHGC- Solar Heat Gain Coefficient
(% of ALL radiation (UV, visible and IR) that gets thru glass)
VT- Visible Transmittance
(% of visible light that gets thru glass)
SOUTH FACING GLAZING:
– Cold climate: SHGC > 0.6; high VT; low “U”
– Moderate climate: SHGC < 0.6; high VT; low “U”
– Hot climate: SHGC < 0.4; medium VT; low “U”
– East/west facing: SHGC < 0.4; high VT; low “U”
OUTSIDE AIR CALCULATIONS
Job:
Job Number:
Date:
22-May-12
Zone
No.
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
123
131
128
124
125
126
127
129
130
122
101
102
103
Zone
Description
Area
Sf
Az
Boys/Girls restrooms
Boys/Girls locker rooms, storage
Junior High Gymnasium
Applied tech, metals, woods
ISS reception, ISS
Faculty lounge, workroom
Principal, VP, secretary
VP, conf, recp, councel, career
Corridors
Library, offices, Computer lab
Mens/Womens restrooms
Cafeteria
Corridors
Scullery, storage, elect
CADD classroom, weight rm, train
Gym storage
Custodian, general, service
Storage
Mens/Womens locker room
Music
Math, social studies
Language arts, math
Corridors
Foreign language, physics, biotech
Art Class
Computers, health, social studies
Theater, stage, office, storage
Senior High Gymnasium
Art, Science Classrooms
Classrooms
Corridors
Ceil Ht
Ft
880
2,610
6,560
2,820
1,150
1,100
530
2,050
4,430
5,760
1,120
5,170
2,920
1,830
2,180
870
740
140
3,450
2,710
3,300
5,810
4,150
5,590
1,710
2,090
1,470
9,780
6,700
6,310
3,180
9.0
9.0
29.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
12.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
10.0
9.0
10.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
15.0
29.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
Room
Vol cf
V
7,920
23,490
190,240
25,380
10,350
9,900
4,770
18,450
39,870
51,840
10,080
62,040
26,280
16,470
19,620
7,830
6,660
1,400
31,050
27,100
29,700
52,290
37,350
50,310
15,390
18,810
22,050
283,620
60,300
56,790
28,620
99,110
TAG
SF03
SF10
SF11
SF12
SERVES
JUNIOR HIGH GYM
OFFICE ADMIN
CLASSROOMS
CLASSROOMS
Area
Served
SF
10,050
38,970
3,300
20,820
Zone SA
Cfm
Vpz
400
400
6,500
2,700
1,170
2,325
785
2,095
1,200
4,780
600
6,760
850
2,640
3,040
840
730
240
1,645
4,020
4,620
11,600
1,200
5,130
3,700
2,440
5,120
13,500
10,850
10,850
1,185
From 2009 IMC Table 403.3
Number of Occ
People Rate
Area Rate
Density
Total cfm/per
cfm cfm/sf
cfm
#/1000 sf
Pz
Rp
Ra
0
0
34
13
17
14
15
5
0
25
0
48
0
3
28
0
0
0
0
9
32
35
0
25
23
25
58
41
25
35
0
Tot
People
Sys Ps
220
450
105
500
5
5
5
10
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
10
5
5
5
5
10
10
10
5
10
10
10
10
5
10
10
5
0
0
1100
360
100
75
40
50
0
725
0
1250
0
25
600
0
0
0
0
250
1050
2050
0
1400
400
520
850
2000
1650
2200
0
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.18
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.12
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.06
0.12
0.12
0.06
0.12
0.18
0.12
0.06
0.06
0.18
0.12
0.06
50
160
390
510
70
70
30
120
270
350
70
310
180
110
260
50
40
10
210
160
400
700
250
670
310
250
90
590
1210
760
190
50
160
1,490
870
170
145
70
170
270
1,075
70
1,560
180
135
860
50
40
10
210
410
1,450
2,750
250
2,070
710
770
940
2,590
2,860
2,960
190
2,206
113,915
Primary
Tot
Air
People
Cfm Zone Pz
7,300
220
36,420
574
4,620
105
29,190
522
0
0
220
36
20
15
8
10
0
145
0
250
0
5
60
0
0
0
0
25
105
205
0
140
40
52
85
400
165
220
0
OA
Vbz
Vbz
Diversity
of People
D
100%
78%
100%
96%
Total
OA
Voz
1,700
6,310
1,450
7,490
Zone
Zone OA Primary
Zone
Eff (Ez)
Voz
OA Fract Served
Ez
Voz
Zp
By
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
50
160
1,490
870
170
150
70
170
270
1,080
70
1,560
180
140
860
50
40
10
210
410
1,450
2,750
250
2,070
710
770
940
2,590
2,860
2,960
190
13%
40%
23%
32%
15%
6%
9%
8%
23%
23%
12%
23%
21%
5%
28%
6%
5%
4%
13%
10%
31%
24%
21%
40%
19%
32%
18%
19%
26%
27%
16%
SF03
SF03
SF03
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF11
SF12
SF12
SF12
SF12
SF12
SF12
SF16
SF18
SF18
SF18
OA
Cfm/Sf
Avg
Met
Rate
2.5
1.2
1.2
1.2
25,550
Uncrtd
OSA
Vou
1,700
4,947
1,450
7,174
Max
Zp
%
40.0%
32.2%
31.4%
40.4%
Vent
Eff
Ev
0.70
0.80
0.80
0.70
Total
OSA
Vot
2,429
6,184
1,813
10,249
OA
Percent
33%
17%
39%
35%
OA
Cfm/Per
Ros
11
11
17
20
0.24
0.16
0.55
0.49
CO2
Setting
1,500
1,100
700
700
SF16
SF18
SENIOR HIGH GYM
CLASSROOMS
9,780
16,190
13,500
22,885
400
385
99,110
113,915
2,206
400
300
100%
78%
2,590
6,010
2,590
4,683
25,550
22,544
19.2%
27.3%
0.90
0.80
2,878
5,854
Area of the zone (sq ft)
Pz
Zone population
Rp
Outdoor air required per person (Table 6.1)
Ra
Outdoor air required per unit area (Table 6.1)
Vbz
The design outdoor airflow in the breathing zone ( people factor plus area factor in accordance with Table 6.1)
Voz
The design outdoor airflow supplied to the zone ( Vbc/Ez)
Vou
Uncorrected outdoor intake (sum of all zones served by the ahu times the occupanct diversity D)
Vot
Design outdoor intake flow ( Vou/Ev)
Ez
Ev
Zone air distribution effectiveness in accordance with Table 403.3.1.2
System ventilation efficency ( Per table 403.2.2.3.2)
Short Term Conditions
If the peak occupancy will be of short duration, the design may be based on the average condtions over a time period T.
T
V
Averaging time period , min ( 3v/Vbz)
Volume of the zone , cu ft
CO2 Calculations
Cru - C0 = 1,000,000 x Nb x M / Ros
Calculates rise in CO2 concentration if all supplied outdoor air is consumed.
Cs-C0 = Zs x 0 + (1-Zs) x (Cru - C0)
Calculates target SA CO2 concentration (above ambient) based on previous calculation.
Cru = CO2 concentration in recirculated air if all outdoor air supplied to the building is used.
C0 = CO2 concentration outdoors.
Nb = CO2 generation rate per person at base metabolic rate. Default = 0.0091 CFM/Person (0.0043 L/s per person).
M = Relative metabolic rate in met units. Default is sedentary person = 1.2 mets, ASHRAE standard 62.1-2007, Appendix C.
400 Assumed Ambient OA CO2 Concentration [PPM]
20% Factor of Safety (accounts for lag in controls)
0.0091 Base CO2 Generation Rate (PPM/Person)
Ros = OA Dilution Per Person (Vot / Population Served)
7
15
0.29
0.36
2.5
1.2
2,400
800
29,405
Based on 2009 IMC
Az
21%
26%
ASHRAE 62.1, 2007 Appendix A-2:
Table A-A Typical Met Levels For Activities
MET ACTIVITY
1.0 Seated, quiet
1.0 Reading and Writing, seated
1.1 Typing
1.2 Filing, Seated
1.4 Filing, Standing
2.0 Walking, at 0.89m/s
2-3 House Cleaning
3-4 Exercise
Motor Upgrades Feasiblity Analysis
Blended Electrical Cost
Maximum Acceptable Payback
Ratio of BHP to Motor HP
Exist
Motor
Hp
1
1.5
2
3
5
7.5
10
15
20
25
30
40
50
60
75
100
$0.177
5 Years
75%
Main Building Fan Systems
Replace if Proposed Required
Est
New
Existing
Brake Motor Eff
Is Less
Motor
Energy
Hp
Than
Eff
Cons KWh
0.75
67.6%
85.5%
2,976
1.13
72.0%
86.5%
4,192
1.50
74.6%
86.5%
5,395
2.25
79.6%
89.5%
7,585
3.75
83.2%
89.5%
12,101
5.63
85.1%
91.0%
17,746
7.50
86.2%
91.7%
23,369
11.25
88.0%
93.0%
34,338
15.00
88.2%
93.0%
45,672
18.75
88.4%
93.6%
56,963
22.50
89.6%
94.1%
67,409
30.00
90.1%
94.1%
89,427
37.50
90.7%
94.5%
111,048
45.00
91.3%
95.0%
132,314
56.25
91.2%
95.0%
165,573
75
91.8%
95.4%
219,386
Proposed
Energy
Consump
KWH
2,355
3,491
4,655
6,749
11,248
16,594
21,956
32,474
43,299
53,776
64,189
85,585
106,529
127,161
158,952
211,047
Estimated Annual Hours of Operation
3600
Required Required Proposed Required
Energy
An Energy
Motor
Simple
Savings
Savings Instalation Payback
KWH
$
Costs
Yrs
621
$
110 $
550
5.0
701
$
124 $
620
5.0
740
$
131 $
655
5.0
836
$
148 $
740
5.0
853
$
151 $
755
5.0
1,153
$
204 $ 1,020
5.0
1,412
$
250 $ 1,250
5.0
1,864
$
330 $ 1,650
5.0
2,373
$
420 $ 2,100
5.0
3,186
$
564 $ 2,820
5.0
3,220
$
570 $ 2,850
5.0
3,842
$
680 $ 3,400
5.0
4,520
$
800 $ 4,000
5.0
5,153
$
912 $ 4,560
5.0
6,621
$ 1,172 $ 5,860
5.0
8,339
$ 1,476 $ 7,380
5.0
$0.177
5 Years
75%
Gymnasium Fan Systems
2400
Replace if Proposed Required Proposed Required Required Proposed Required
Exist
Est
New
Existing
Energy
Energy
Energy
Motor
Simple
Motor
Brake Motor Eff
Is Less
Motor
Energy
Consump
Savings
Hp
Hp
Than
Eff
Cons KWh
KWH
KWH
$
Costs
Yrs
1
0.75
61.3%
85.5%
2,191
1,570
621
$
110 $
550
5.0
1.5
1.13
66.5%
86.5%
3,028
2,328
701
$
124 $
620
5.0
2
1.50
69.8%
86.5%
3,844
3,103
740
$
131 $
655
5.0
3
2.25
75.5%
89.5%
5,335
4,499
836
$
148 $
740
5.0
5
3.75
80.4%
89.5%
8,352
7,499
853
$
151 $
755
5.0
7.5
5.63
82.4%
91.0%
12,215
11,063
1,153
$
204 $ 1,020
5.0
10
7.50
83.6%
91.7%
16,050
14,638
1,412
$
250 $ 1,250
5.0
15
11.25
85.6%
93.0%
23,514
21,649
1,864
$
330 $ 1,650
5.0
20
15.00
85.9%
93.0%
31,239
28,866
2,373
$
420 $ 2,100
5.0
25
18.75
86.0%
93.6%
39,037
35,851
3,186
$
564 $ 2,820
5.0
30
22.50
87.5%
94.1%
46,013
42,793
3,220
$
570 $ 2,850
5.0
40
30.00
88.2%
94.1%
60,899
57,057
3,842
$
680 $ 3,400
5.0
50
37.50
88.8%
94.5%
75,539
71,019
4,520
$
800 $ 4,000
5.0
60
45.00
89.6%
95.0%
89,927
84,774
5,153
$
912 $ 4,560
5.0
75
56.25
89.4%
95.0%
112,589
105,968
6,621
$ 1,172 $ 5,860
5.0
100
75
90.1%
95.4%
149,037
140,698
8,339
$ 1,476 $ 7,380
5.0
$0.177
5 Years
75%
Perimeter Pump Systems
4800
Exist
Est
New
Existing
Energy
Energy
Energy
Motor
Simple
Motor
Brake Motor Eff
Is Less
Motor
Energy
Consump
Savings
Hp
Hp
Than
Eff
Cons KWh
KWH
KWH
$
Costs
Yrs
1
0.75
71.4%
85.5%
3,761
3,140
621
$
110 $
550
5.0
1.5
1.13
75.2%
86.5%
5,356
4,655
701
$
124 $
620
5.0
2
1.50
77.3%
86.5%
6,947
6,207
740
$
131 $
655
5.0
3
2.25
81.9%
89.5%
9,835
8,998
836
$
148 $
740
5.0
5
3.75
84.7%
89.5%
15,850
14,997
853
$
151 $
755
5.0
7.5
5.63
86.5%
91.0%
23,278
22,125
1,153
$
204 $ 1,020
5.0
10
7.50
87.5%
91.7%
30,687
29,275
1,412
$
250 $ 1,250
5.0
15
11.25
89.2%
93.0%
45,163
43,299
1,864
$
330 $ 1,650
5.0
20
15.00
89.3%
93.0%
60,104
57,732
2,373
$
420 $ 2,100
5.0
25
18.75
89.6%
93.6%
74,888
71,702
3,186
$
564 $ 2,820
5.0
30
22.50
90.7%
94.1%
88,805
85,585
3,220
$
570 $ 2,850
5.0
40
30.00
91.0%
94.1%
117,955
114,113
3,842
$
680 $ 3,400
5.0
50
37.50
91.6%
94.5%
146,558
142,038
4,520
$
800 $ 4,000
5.0
60
45.00
92.2%
95.0%
174,701
169,549
5,153
$
912 $ 4,560
5.0
75
56.25
92.1%
95.0%
218,557
211,936
6,621
$ 1,172 $ 5,860
5.0
100
75
92.7%
95.4%
289,735
281,396
8,339
$ 1,476 $ 7,380
5.0
$0.177
5 Years
75%
Heating Coil Pump Systems
2550
Exist
Est
New
Existing
Energy
Energy
Energy
Motor
Simple
Motor
Brake Motor Eff
Is Less
Motor
Energy
Consump
Savings
Hp
Hp
Than
Eff
Cons KWh
KWH
KWH
$
Costs
Yrs
1
0.75
62.3%
85.5%
2,289
1,668
621
$
110 $
550
5.0
1.5
1.13
67.4%
86.5%
3,174
2,473
701
$
124 $
620
5.0
2
1.50
70.6%
86.5%
4,038
3,297
740
$
131 $
655
5.0
3
2.25
76.2%
89.5%
5,617
4,780
836
$
148 $
740
5.0
5
3.75
80.8%
89.5%
8,820
7,967
853
$
151 $
755
5.0
7.5
5.63
82.9%
91.0%
12,907
11,754
1,153
$
204 $ 1,020
5.0
10
7.50
84.1%
91.7%
16,965
15,552
1,412
$
250 $ 1,250
5.0
15
11.25
86.0%
93.0%
24,867
23,002
1,864
$
330 $ 1,650
5.0
20
15.00
86.3%
93.0%
33,043
30,670
2,373
$
420 $ 2,100
5.0
25
18.75
86.4%
93.6%
41,278
38,092
3,186
$
564 $ 2,820
5.0
30
22.50
87.9%
94.1%
48,687
45,467
3,220
$
570 $ 2,850
5.0
40
30.00
88.5%
94.1%
64,465
60,623
3,842
$
680 $ 3,400
5.0
50
37.50
89.2%
94.5%
79,978
75,458
4,520
$
800 $ 4,000
5.0
60
45.00
89.9%
95.0%
95,225
90,073
5,153
$
912 $ 4,560
5.0
75
56.25
89.7%
95.0%
119,212
112,591
6,621
$ 1,172 $ 5,860
5.0
100
75
90.4%
95.4%
157,831
149,492
8,339
$ 1,476 $ 7,380
5.0
$0.250
FAIRBANKS - ANNUAL COST PER CFM BASED ON TOTAL SYSTEM FLOW OF COLD RUN SEQUENCE
AT VARIOUS INITIATION TEMPERATURES
$0.230
Assumptions:
Fans run at min setpoint of 40% of total flow
Outside air dampers are set at 10% of fan flow
$0.195
$0.210
$0.190
$0.170
$0.138
$0.150
$0.130
Example: If a building's total design airflow is
100,000 CFM and the Cold Run Sequence is set
to initiate when the outdoor air temperature is
below minus 20 Deg F, the annual cost of
running this sequence would be $9,500
$0.114
$0.138
Heat
Fan
$0.110
$0.095
$0.099
$0.090
$0.070
$0.082
$0.070
$0.069
$0.050
$0.030
$0.034
$0.051
$0.057
$0.032
$0.039
$0.032
$0.010
$(0.010)
$0.044
-5
-10
-15
$0.026
-20
$0.019
-25
$0.025
$0.012
$0.009
-30
-35
APPENDIX E – SYSTEM DIAGRAMS
HEATING WATER SYSTEM
HEATING WATER SYSTEM DIAGAMS
M1.1
MAIN BUILDING VAV AIR HANDLING UNIT
TYPICAL AHU
M1.2
JR HIGH GYM AIR HANDLING UNIT
GYM AHU
M1.3
SR HIGH GYM AIR HANDLING UNIT
GYM AHU
M1.4
LOCKER ROOM/MULTIPURPOSE HEAT RECOVERY UNIT
LOCKER ROOM HRU
M1.5
SR HIGH CLASSROOM WING AHU SYSTEM
SR HIGH AHU
M1.6
APPENDIX F – EQUIPMENT LIST
AHFC ENERGY AUDITS - EXISTING EQUIPMENT SCHEDULES
STEAM CONVERTER SCHEDULE - BEN EIELSON JR/SR HIGH SCHOOL
SERVES
MARK
HX-1
HX-2
JR HIGH HEATING
SR HIGH HEATING
MANUF
TYPE
BELL & GOSSET
TACO
MODEL
#
SHELL/TUBE SU165-4
SHELL/TUBE QSU207-4
CAP
STEAM
PPH
3,040
8,968
STEAM
PRESSURE
PSIG
5
5
FLUUID
GPM
FLUID
TYPE
215
634
50% PG
50% PG
OUTLET
TEMP
F
190
190
REMARKS
AHU SCHEDULE - BEN EIELSON JR/SR HIGH SCHOOL
MARK
SA02
SA03
SA10
SA11
SA12
SA13
SF16
SF17
SF18
SERVES
FAN
MANUF
JR HIGH GYM
JR HIGH GYM
SR HIGH AREAS B,C,D,F
EAST PORTION OF E
SR HIGH SCIENCE
SR HIGH SCIENCE
SR HIGH GYM
SR HIGH MULTIPURPOSE
JR HIGH CLASSROOMS
RECOLD
RECOLD
PACE
TRANE
PACE
PACE
TRANE
TRANE
TRANE
AIR
FLOW
CFM
3,250
3,250
36,420
4,620
23,030
2,840
13,500
3,000
22,900
MIN
OSA
CFM
650
650
7,284
924
4,606
568
2,700
600
4,580
TSP
IN
H20
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
3.12
2.86
3.30
CAPACITY
CONTROL
CV
CV
VSD
CV
VSD
VSD
VSD
CV
VSD
MOTOR
SIZE
HP
3
3
40
5
25
10
20
5
15
MOTOR MANUFACTURER
WAGNER
WAGNER
N/A
N/A
WESTINGHOUSE
WESTINGHOUSE
N/A
BALDOR SUPER E
REMARKS
MOTOR
EFF
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
90.0%
INTERIOR ZONE - COOLING
PERIMETER ZONES
HEAT RECOVERY UNIT
PUMP SCHEDULE - BEN EIELSON JR/SR HIGH SCHOOL
MARK
P1 - GO5
P2 - G06
P3 - G07
P4 - G08
SERVES
JR HIGH HEATING
JR HIGH HEATING
SR HIGH HEATING
SR HIGH HEATING
PUMP
MANUF
PUMP
TYP
B&G
B&G
B&G
B&G
END SUCT
END SUCT
END SUCT
END SUCT
PUMP
MODEL
#
1510
1510
1510
1510
PUMP
FLOW
GPM
215
215
634
634
PUMP
HEAD
FT H20
55
55
65
65
CAPACITY
CONTROL
VSD
VSD
VSD
VSD
MOTOR
SIZE
HP
5
5
15
15
MOTOR
MANUF
MOTOR
EFF
MARATHON
MARATHON
MARATHON
MARATHON
84.0%
84.0%
88.5%
88.5%
RS Consulting - Mechanical Engineering - 2400 NW 80th St #178 Seattle, WA 98117
REMARKS
REDUNDANT
REDUNDANT
APPENDIX G – TRACE 700 INPUT DATA
Building Input Form - Trace 700
Bldg:
Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High
Zone
Number
Zone
Name
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
201
202
203
Classrooms
Corridors
ISS reception, ISS
Corridors
Cafeteria
Corridors
Gym storage
Storage
Language arts, math
Corridors
Art Class
Music
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Fan room, multipurpose
Fan room
Fan room
Floor
Area
Sf
6,700
6,310
3,180
880
2,610
6,560
2,820
1,150
1,100
530
2,050
4,430
5,760
1,120
5,170
2,920
1,830
2,180
870
740
140
9,780
3,450
5,810
4,150
5,590
1,710
3,300
2,090
1,470
2,710
290
60
60
60
120
80
80
130
50
70
120
110
3,450
990
210
Roof
Area
Sf
6,700
6,310
3,180
880
2,610
6,560
2,820
1,150
1,100
530
2,050
4,430
4,920
1,120
5,170
2,920
1,830
2,180
870
740
140
9,780
0
5,810
4,150
4,600
1,500
3,300
2,090
1,470
2,710
290
60
60
60
120
80
80
130
50
70
120
110
3,450
990
210
Total
Perimeter
Lgth, Ft
226
291
0
35
0
109
86
71
55
30
0
0
0
0
225
0
0
0
63
62
84
182
0
191
0
0
120
182
67
0
104
27
8
9
17
0
20
21
13
25
17
23
11
122
154
120
Floor
to Floor
Ht Ft
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
29.0
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
15.0
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
10.0
29.0
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
22.0
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
12.5
18.0
19.0
Ceiling
Height
Ft
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
29.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
12.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
10.0
29.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
9.0
15.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
10.0
18.0
19.0
Plenum
Ht
Ft
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
0.0
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.0
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
0.0
0.0
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
7.0
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
2.5
0.0
0.0
Grs Wall
Area
Sf
2,825
3,638
0
438
0
3,158
1,075
888
688
375
0
0
0
0
3,375
0
0
0
785
771
840
5,275
0
2,388
0
0
1,500
2,275
838
0
1,295
333
100
113
213
250
250
263
163
306
209
288
133
1,525
2,772
2,160
Window
Area
Sf
310
300
0
0
0
0
0
194
66
161
0
0
0
0
324
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
430
0
0
200
192
48
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
#
of
People
165
220
0
0
0
220
36
20
15
8
10
0
145
0
250
0
5
60
0
0
0
400
0
205
0
140
40
105
52
85
25
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
35
0
1
Occ
per
1000 sf
25
35
0
0
0
34
13
17
14
15
5
0
25
0
48
0
3
28
0
0
0
41
0
35
0
25
23
32
25
58
9
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
10
0
5
Lights (Existing)
Total
Watts
Watts
Per SF
13,577
2.0
13,597
2.2
3,232
1.0
1,504
1.7
3,050
1.2
10,992
1.7
4,482
1.6
1,760
1.5
765
0.7
2,210
4.2
3,511
1.7
4,553
1.0
10,659
1.9
2,246
2.0
5,896
1.1
3,045
1.0
2,769
1.5
1,530
0.7
1,530
1.8
862
1.2
464
3.3
15,264
1.6
3,777
1.1
10,144
1.7
4,755
1.1
9,394
1.7
5,034
2.9
2,832
0.9
5,034
2.4
3,656
2.5
6,147
2.3
232
0.8
85
1.4
85
1.4
85
1.4
85
0.7
85
1.1
85
1.1
85
0.7
170
3.4
170
2.4
85
0.7
85
0.8
3,052
0.9
290
0.3
291
1.4
Lights (Proposed)
Total
Watts
Watts
Per SF
11,465
1.7
10,773
1.7
1,950
0.6
1,056
1.2
2,404
0.9
8,736
1.3
2,208
0.8
1,288
1.1
657
0.6
1,898
3.6
2,729
1.3
2,566
0.6
8,084
1.4
1,512
1.4
4,836
0.9
1,860
0.6
1,470
0.8
1,314
0.6
1,314
1.5
624
0.8
336
2.4
11,496
1.2
2,874
0.8
8,402
1.4
2,566
0.6
6,460
1.2
3,779
2.2
2,338
0.7
4,182
2.0
2,587
1.8
3,152
1.2
192
0.7
48
0.8
48
0.8
48
0.8
48
0.4
48
0.6
48
0.6
48
0.4
96
1.9
96
1.4
48
0.4
48
0.4
1,620
0.5
240
0.2
241
1.1
Misc Plug Loads
Total
Loads
Watts Watt/Sf
8,040
1.20
7,572
1.20
795
0.25
220
0.25
653
0.25
1,312
0.20
7,050
2.50
1,725
1.50
1,925
1.75
795
1.50
3,075
1.50
1,108
0.25
11,520
2.00
280
0.25
2,585
0.50
730
0.25
5,490
3.00
5,450
2.50
218
0.25
185
0.25
35
0.25
1,956
0.20
863
0.25
6,972
1.20
1,038
0.25
6,708
1.20
2,993
1.75
3,960
1.20
6,793
3.25
3,675
2.50
3,252
1.20
0
0.00
0
0.00
0
0.00
0
0.00
0
0.00
0
0.00
0
0.00
0
0.00
0
0.00
0
0.00
0
0.00
0
0.00
863
0.25
248
0.25
263
1.25
System
SF18
SF18
SF18
SF03
SF03
SF03
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF10
SF16
SF10
SF12
SF12
SF12
SF12
SF11
SF12
SF12
SF10
CH
CH
CH
CH
CH
CH
CH
CH
CH
CH
CH
CH
SF17
CH
CH
Design
Airflow
Cfm
10,850
10,850
1,185
400
400
6,500
2,700
1,170
2,325
785
2,095
1,200
4,780
600
6,760
850
2,640
3,040
840
730
240
13,500
1,645
11,600
1,200
5,130
3,700
4,620
2,440
5,120
4,020
750
150
150
150
300
200
200
300
150
150
250
250
3,200
850
250
Design
Cfm
SF
1.62
1.72
0.37
0.45
0.15
0.99
0.96
1.02
2.11
1.48
1.02
0.27
0.83
0.54
1.31
0.29
1.44
1.39
0.97
0.99
1.71
1.38
0.48
2.00
0.29
0.92
2.16
1.40
1.17
3.48
1.48
2.59
2.50
2.50
2.50
2.50
2.50
2.50
2.31
3.00
2.14
2.08
2.27
0.93
0.86
1.19
Building Input Form - Trace 700
Bldg:
Zone
Number
Zone
Name
204
205
Fan room
Fan room
Vestibules
Floor
Area
Sf
840
530
Roof
Area
Sf
840
530
Total
Perimeter
Lgth, Ft
120
104
106,360
100,870
2,991
Floor
to Floor
Ht Ft
18.0
18.0
Ceiling
Height
Ft
18.0
18.0
Plenum
Ht
Ft
0.0
0.0
Grs Wall
Area
Sf
2,160
1,872
45,531
Percent Windows
Window
Area
Sf
0
0
2,225
5%
#
of
People
0
0
Occ
per
1000 sf
0
0
2,242
27% Diversity
163,357
1.5
Lights (Proposed)
Total
Watts
Watts
Per SF
48
0.1
48
0.1
119,929
1,230
Exterior Lts
Total Student Enrollment
AIR HANDLING UNITS
TAG
SERVES
SF03
JR HIGH GYM
SF10
MAIN BUILDING
SF11
2000 CLASS ADDITION
SF12
HIGH SCHOOL SCIENCE
SF16
HIGH SCHOOL GYM
SF17
MAT ROOM
SF18
JR HIGH CLASSROOMS
CH
VESTIBULES
CH
MECHANICAL
Lights (Existing)
Total
Watts
Watts
Per SF
58
0.1
58
0.1
AREA
10,050
38,970
3,300
20,820
9,780
3,450
16,190
1,230
2,570
106,360
CFM
7,300
36,420
4,620
29,190
13,500
3,200
22,885
3,000
2,800
122,915
CFM/SF
0.73
0.93
1.40
1.40
1.38
0.93
1.41
2.44
1.09
1.16
602
17130
5097
1.1
Misc Plug Loads
Total
Loads
Watts Watt/Sf
210
0.25
133
0.25
100,685
0.95
System
CH
CH
Design
Airflow
Cfm
850
850
122,915
Design
Cfm
SF
1.01
1.60
Building Input Form - Trace 700 - Wall Data
Bldg:
Zone
Number
Zone
Name
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
201
202
203
204
205
Classrooms
Corridors
ISS reception, ISS
Corridors
Cafeteria
Corridors
Gym storage
Storage
Language arts, math
Corridors
Art Class
Music
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Vestibule
Fan room, multipurpose
Fan room
Fan room
Fan room
Fan room
Wall Direction: North = 0, East = 90, South = 180, West =270
Wall
Length Ft
Gross Wall
Sq Ft
38
265
475
3313
0
438
0
1073
538
438
600
88
0
0
0
0
1350
0
0
0
313
401
840
287
0
163
0
0
625
313
838
0
320
113
100
113
113
213
138
125
163
109
100
75
133
388
1062
190
576
324
35
37
43
35
48
7
90
25
32
84
10
13
50
25
67
26
9
8
9
9
17
11
10
13
9
8
6
11
31
59
10
32
18
Wall 1
Wall
Glass
Type
Area
1
1
300
Glass
Type
Wall
Direction
Wall
Length Ft
Gross Wall
Sq Ft
2
270
180
188
26
72
43
36
7
23
2350
325
0
0
0
2085
538
450
88
288
0
0
0
0
675
0
0
0
473
320
0
3045
0
2225
0
0
250
1650
0
0
975
220
0
0
0
0
113
138
0
89
109
138
0
750
648
399
1008
1224
1
1
1
2
2
2
132
66
62
2
2
2
180
0
270
180
180
180
90
1
324
1
270
45
2
2
1
1
270
270
0
270
38
26
105
1
270
178
90
0
180
20
132
90
90
180
90
90
0
0
270
0
180
270
180
180
270
270
270
270
270
78
18
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
1
1
200
48
1
2
9
11
7
9
11
60
36
21
56
68
Wall 2
Wall
Glass
Type
Area
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
310
Glass
Type
Wall
Direction
2
0
270
62
2
99
2
Wall
Length Ft
0
270
270
270
180
1
180
90
1
2
0
0
4
1
0
67
1
430
1
0
1
2
192
2
90
50
25
1
1
180
180
1
1
90
0
1
1
1
270
0
270
9
1
1
2
1
1
180
0
180
180
180
31
59
21
32
18
6
Gross Wall
Sq Ft
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1350
0
0
0
0
50
0
1943
0
0
0
0
625
313
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
109
0
75
0
388
1062
399
576
324
Wall 3
Wall
Glass
Type
Area
Glass
Type
Wall
Direction
1
90
2
90
1
1
270
180
1
0
1
0
1
1
2
2
1
90
90
90
90
90
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Leaving cooling coil:
Heating supply:
Supply duct temperature diff: 0.0 °F
Reheat Temperature diff: 0.0 °F
Type: Dry Bulb
"On" Point:
Type: None
Cooling coil sizing method:
Cooling coil location:
Block cooling airflow:
Ventilation deck location:
Supply duct location:
Return air path:
Max Percent OA: 100%
°F
Direct efficiency:
0%
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
0%
Available (100%)
Night purge schedule: Off (0%)
Optimum start schedule: Off (0%)
Optimum stop schedule: Off (0%)
CO2-based DCV: None
System ventilation flag: Sum Room OA Reqs
Supply air path / duct location: Return Air
Space convective gains to occupied layer: 100 %
Underfloor plenum height: 0.0 ft
Conductive resistance of raised floor: 0.8 hr·ft²·°F/Btu
Upstream nominal leakage fraction: 0 %
Downstream constant leakage fraction: 0 %
Aux cooling coil losses to plenum: 0 %
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
150.0 % of Design Capacity by adjusting Available
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
150.0 % of Design Capacity
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
150.0% of Design Capacity
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Optional ventilation
Auxiliary
Indirect efficiency:
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Reset per worst case room schedule: Off (0%)
Max reset:
Use system default outside air reset: Yes
Control Method
Auxiliary cooling coil Activate After Primary System
Auxiliary heating coil Activate After Primary System
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Schedule: Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Supply fan motor location:
Return fan motor location:
Supply fan cofiguration:
Supply fan sizing:
Fan mechanical efficiency :
Apply Std62 People Avg:
Std62 Max Vent (Z) Ratio:
Peak
Zone
Design humidity ratio diff:
Min room relative humidity:
Type
Static Press.
Full Load Energy Rate
Schedule
FC Centrifugal const vol
None
None
None
None
None
LEED Fan Power Adjustment
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.3 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00032 kW/Cfm-in wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Efficiency Demand Limiting Priority
80
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Project Name: Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School
Dataset Name: C:\Users\Ray\Documents\TRACE 700 Projects\ben_eielson.trc
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8 calculated at 08:18 PM on 05/29/2012
Alternative - 1 Entered Values Systems page 1 of 36
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
150.0 % of Design minus Aux Capacity Available (100%)
150 % of Design Capacity
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
FC Centrifugal var freq drv
None
None
None
None
None
None
5.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
4.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
3.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
Zone
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
Schedule
150.0 % of Design Cooling Capacity
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
None
Capacity
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Type: Fixed-membrane HX (OA precondition) Sup-side deck: Ventilation upstream
Exh-side deck: Room exhaust
Sensible
Latent
Clg effectiveness at 100% airflow: 55%
Htg effectiveness at 100% airflow: 55%
HTg effectiveness at 75% airflow: 58%
Supply Side Options
Exhaust Side Options
Design air leaving dry bulb:
Economizer lockout: Yes
Percent airflow:
Evap precooler type: None
Design air leaving humidity ratio:
Part load control: Modulated
Heat source: 0 °F
Evap precooler Eff:
Coolant type: N/A
Static pressure drop: 0.7 in. wg
Fan static pressure : 0.0 in. wg
Frost prevention type: Outdoor air preheat
Coolant approach: N/A
Bypass dampers: No
Fan static pressure drop: 0.7 in. wg Frost prevention set point: -5 °F
Integral heat recovery: No
OA frost threshhold: -5 °F
Parasitic energy: 0.0 kW
Bypass dampers: No
Return air path:
Peak
Zone
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Supply fan sizing:
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
CO2-based DCV: None
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.8 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
3.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
No Coil
Room
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
ROOMDK
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Space convective gains to occupied layer:
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
0.0 % of Design Capacity by adjusting airflow
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
No Fan
75%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
0.0 in. wg
0.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
90
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Type: Dry Bulb
"On" Point:
Type: None
Return air path:
°F
Direct efficiency:
0%
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
0%
Available (100%)
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Available (100%)
Supply fan sizing:
Peak
Zone
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.3 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
80
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
5.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
4.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
3.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
Zone
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
Schedule
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
None
Capacity
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Sensible
Latent
Supply Side Options
Percent airflow:
Heat source: 0 °F
Evap precooler Eff:
Coolant type: N/A
Bypass dampers: No
Bypass dampers: No
Return air path:
Peak
Zone
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Supply fan sizing:
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
CO2-based DCV: None
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.8 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
3.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
FB Fan Eielson
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
No Coil
Room
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
ROOMDK
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
No Fan
75%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
0.0 in. wg
0.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
90
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Type: Dry Bulb
"On" Point:
Type: None
Return air path:
°F
Direct efficiency:
0%
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
0%
Available (100%)
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Available (100%)
Supply fan sizing:
Peak
Zone
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.3 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
80
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
5.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
4.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
3.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
Zone
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
Schedule
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
None
Capacity
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Sensible
Latent
Supply Side Options
Percent airflow:
Heat source: 0 °F
Evap precooler Eff:
Coolant type: N/A
Bypass dampers: No
Bypass dampers: No
Return air path:
Peak
Zone
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Supply fan sizing:
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
CO2-based DCV: None
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.8 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
3.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
No Coil
Room
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
ROOMDK
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
No Fan
75%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
0.0 in. wg
0.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
90
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Type: Dry Bulb
"On" Point:
Type: None
Return air path:
°F
Direct efficiency:
0%
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
Schedule
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
0%
Available (100%)
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
None
Capacity
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Block
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Available (100%)
Supply fan sizing:
Block
Zone
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
AF Centrifugal var freq drv
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.3 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
80
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
5.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
4.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
3.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
Zone
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
Schedule
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
None
Capacity
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Sensible
Latent
Supply Side Options
Percent airflow:
Heat source: 0 °F
Evap precooler Eff:
Coolant type: N/A
Bypass dampers: No
Bypass dampers: No
Return air path:
Peak
Zone
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Supply fan sizing:
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
CO2-based DCV: None
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
2.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.8 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
Block
System
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
PLENUM
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
Wall Convector
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
airflow (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
Peak
70%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
3.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
1.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Fan Eielson 20
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
88
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Max
Min
Cooling supply:
Heating supply:
Return air path:
Supply fan sizing:
No Coil
Room
Return/Outdoor Deck
Return Air
ROOMDK
Capacity
Main cooling:
Aux cooling:
Main heating:
Aux heating:
Preheat:
Reheat:
Humidification:
CO2-based DCV: None
Control Type
None
None
Schedule
Diversity
People 100%
Lights 100%
Misc loads 100%
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Primary
Secondary
Return
System Exhaust
Room Exhaust
Auxiliary
Supply
Return
Draw Thru
No Fan
75%
No
Max reset:
Control Method
Auxiliary fan
No Fan
Type
Static Press.
Schedule
None
None
None
None
None
None
0.0 in. wg
0.5 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.0 in. wg
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
0.00000 kW
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
Available (100%)
90
85
90
90
85
90
85
0.0 in. wg
Simulation type: Reduced year
January - December
Cooling design
Heating Design
January - May
June - August
Weekday
Weekday
September - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Weekday
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
50.0
8 a.m.
11 a.m.
100.0
11 a.m.
noon
80.0
noon
1 p.m.
20.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
30.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
50.0
8 a.m.
11 a.m.
100.0
11 a.m.
noon
80.0
noon
1 p.m.
20.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
30.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
5.0
8 a.m.
3 p.m.
5.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
5.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
0.0
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 5 of 28
January - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Saturday to Sunday
ben_eielson.trc
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
50.0
8 a.m.
11 a.m.
100.0
11 a.m.
noon
80.0
noon
1 p.m.
20.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
30.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Percentage
Utilization
0.0
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 6 of 28
January - May
January - May
January - May
June - August
June - August
June - August
Cooling design to Weekday
Saturday
Sunday
Saturday
Sunday
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
5.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
50.0
8 a.m.
11 a.m.
100.0
11 a.m.
noon
80.0
noon
1 p.m.
20.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
30.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
5.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
5.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
10.0
8 a.m.
3 p.m.
30.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
10.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
5.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
5.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
50.0
8 a.m.
11 a.m.
100.0
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
5.0
Percentage
Utilization
5.0
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
5.0
Percentage
Utilization
5.0
Percentage
Utilization
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 7 of 28
Saturday
Sunday
Heating Design
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
11 a.m.
noon
80.0
noon
1 p.m.
20.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
30.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
5.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Percentage
Utilization
5.0
Percentage
Utilization
5.0
Percentage
Utilization
0.0
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 8 of 28
January - May
June - August
January - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Saturday to Sunday
ben_eielson.trc
Setpoint °F
Start time
End time
Midnight
9 a.m.
95.0
9 a.m.
4 p.m.
80.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
95.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
9 a.m.
95.0
9 a.m.
4 p.m.
80.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
95.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
95.0
7 a.m.
6 p.m.
95.0
6 p.m.
Midnight
95.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
9 a.m.
95.0
8 a.m.
5 p.m.
75.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
95.0
Setpoint °F
Setpoint °F
Setpoint °F
Thermostat
Thermostat
Thermostat
Thermostat
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 9 of 28
January - December
Cooling design
Heating Design
January - May
June - August
Weekday
Weekday
January - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Weekday
Saturday to Sunday
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
50.0
8 a.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
50.0
5 p.m.
7 p.m.
20.0
7 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
3 p.m.
10.0
3 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
50.0
8 a.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
50.0
5 p.m.
7 p.m.
20.0
7 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Utilization
0.0
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
0.0
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 10 of 28
January - May
Heating Design
January - December
June - August
Saturday to Sunday
Reset / Lockout
30 % if Outdr DB
30 % if Htg Setpt
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
<
<
-20.00 ░F
68.00 ░F
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
6 a.m.
0.0
6 a.m.
4 p.m.
100.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
11 a.m.
0.0
11 a.m.
2 p.m.
100.0
2 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
10 a.m.
0.0
10 a.m.
2 p.m.
100.0
2 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
6 a.m.
0.0
6 a.m.
4 p.m.
100.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
And
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 11 of 28
January - May
June - August
January - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Saturday to Sunday
ben_eielson.trc
Setpoint °F
Start time
End time
Midnight
5 a.m.
65.0
5 a.m.
6 a.m.
66.0
6 a.m.
7 a.m.
67.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
68.0
8 a.m.
9 a.m.
69.0
9 a.m.
5 p.m.
70.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
65.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
5 a.m.
65.0
5 a.m.
6 a.m.
66.0
6 a.m.
7 a.m.
67.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
68.0
8 a.m.
9 a.m.
69.0
9 a.m.
5 p.m.
70.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
65.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
65.0
7 a.m.
6 p.m.
65.0
6 p.m.
Midnight
65.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
65.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
65.0
8 a.m.
5 p.m.
65.0
5 p.m.
6 p.m.
65.0
6 p.m.
Midnight
65.0
Setpoint °F
Setpoint °F
Setpoint °F
Thermostat
Thermostat
Thermostat
Thermostat
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 12 of 28
January - March
Cooling design to Sunday
Heating Design
April - September
October - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
9 a.m.
100.0
9 a.m.
4 p.m.
0.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
100.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
100.0
7 a.m.
6 p.m.
0.0
6 p.m.
Midnight
100.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
5 a.m.
100.0
5 a.m.
8 p.m.
0.0
8 p.m.
Midnight
100.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
8 a.m.
100.0
8 a.m.
6 p.m.
0.0
6 p.m.
Midnight
100.0
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 13 of 28
January - May
Weekday
Heating Design
January - December
June - August
Saturday to Sunday
Weekday
January - December
Cooling design
Reset / Lockout
100 % if Outdr DB
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
<
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
6 a.m.
0.0
6 a.m.
4 p.m.
100.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
11 a.m.
0.0
11 a.m.
2 p.m.
100.0
2 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
10 a.m.
0.0
10 a.m.
2 p.m.
100.0
2 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
6 a.m.
0.0
6 a.m.
4 p.m.
100.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
100.0
-10.00 ░F
ben_eielson.trc
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 14 of 28
Heating Design
January - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
8 a.m.
75.0
8 a.m.
5 p.m.
100.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
75.0
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Utilization
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 15 of 28
January - May
Weekday
Heating Design
January - December
June - August
Saturday to Sunday
Weekday
January - December
Cooling design
Reset / Lockout
100 % if Outdr DB
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
<
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
6 a.m.
0.0
6 a.m.
4 p.m.
100.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
11 a.m.
0.0
11 a.m.
2 p.m.
100.0
2 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
10 a.m.
0.0
10 a.m.
2 p.m.
100.0
2 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
6 a.m.
0.0
6 a.m.
4 p.m.
100.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
100.0
-20.00 ░F
ben_eielson.trc
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 16 of 28
January - December
Cooling design
Heating Design
January - May
June - August
Weekday
Weekday
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Weekday
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
10.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
20.0
8 a.m.
9 a.m.
50.0
9 a.m.
11 a.m.
20.0
11 a.m.
1 p.m.
100.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
20.0
3 p.m.
Midnight
10.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
10.0
7 a.m.
11 a.m.
20.0
11 a.m.
1 p.m.
80.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
20.0
3 p.m.
Midnight
10.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
1 p.m.
10.0
1 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
10.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
20.0
8 a.m.
9 a.m.
50.0
9 a.m.
11 a.m.
20.0
11 a.m.
1 p.m.
100.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
20.0
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
0.0
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 17 of 28
January - December
Saturday to Sunday
3 p.m.
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
10.0
Percentage
Utilization
10.0
January - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Start time
End time
Status
Midnight
Midnight
Off
Equipment operation
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 18 of 28
January - May
Heating Design
January - December
June - August
Saturday to Sunday
Reset / Lockout
30 % if Outdr DB
30 % if Htg Setpt
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
<
<
-10.00 ░F
68.00 ░F
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
6 a.m.
0.0
6 a.m.
4 p.m.
100.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
11 a.m.
0.0
11 a.m.
2 p.m.
100.0
2 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
10 a.m.
0.0
10 a.m.
2 p.m.
100.0
2 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
6 a.m.
0.0
6 a.m.
4 p.m.
100.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
And
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 19 of 28
January - December
Heating Design
January - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Saturday to Sunday
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
10.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
30.0
8 a.m.
5 p.m.
100.0
5 p.m.
6 p.m.
30.0
6 p.m.
7 p.m.
10.0
7 p.m.
Midnight
10.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
0.0
Percentage
Utilization
10.0
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 20 of 28
January - December
Cooling design
Heating Design
January - May
June - August
Weekday
Weekday
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Weekday
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
10.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
50.0
8 a.m.
11 a.m.
100.0
11 a.m.
noon
80.0
noon
1 p.m.
20.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
30.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
10.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
10.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
50.0
8 a.m.
11 a.m.
100.0
11 a.m.
noon
80.0
noon
1 p.m.
20.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
30.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
10.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
10.0
8 a.m.
3 p.m.
30.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
10.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
0.0
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 21 of 28
January - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Saturday to Sunday
ben_eielson.trc
Midnight
7 a.m.
10.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
50.0
8 a.m.
11 a.m.
100.0
11 a.m.
noon
80.0
noon
1 p.m.
20.0
1 p.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
30.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
10.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Percentage
Utilization
10.0
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 22 of 28
January - December
Cooling design
Heating Design
January - May
June - August
Weekday
Weekday
January - December
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Weekday
Saturday to Sunday
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
9 a.m.
50.0
9 a.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
50.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
9 a.m.
50.0
9 a.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
50.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
8 a.m.
20.0
8 a.m.
3 p.m.
50.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
20.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
7 a.m.
0.0
7 a.m.
9 a.m.
50.0
9 a.m.
3 p.m.
100.0
3 p.m.
5 p.m.
50.0
5 p.m.
Midnight
0.0
Start time
End time
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
0.0
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
Utilization
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 23 of 28
Midnight
Midnight
0.0
January - December
Heating Design
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Percentage
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Utilization
100.0
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 24 of 28
January - May
January - May
January - May
June - August
June - August
June - August
Saturday
Sunday
Saturday
Sunday
Saturday
Sunday
Heating Design
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Percentage
Start time
End time
Midnight
8 a.m.
100.0
8 a.m.
4 p.m.
25.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
100.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
8 a.m.
100.0
8 a.m.
4 p.m.
25.0
4 p.m.
Midnight
100.0
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Start time
End time
Midnight
Midnight
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Percentage
Utilization
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Utilization
100.0
Percentage
Utilization
100.0
TRACE® 700 v6.2.8
Page 25 of 28
APPENDIX H – TRACE 700 OUPUT DATA
Date: May 29, 2012
City: Eielson Air Force Base, Alaska
Note: The percentage displayed for the "Proposed/ Base %"
column of the base case is actually the percentage of the
total energy consumption.
* Denotes the base alternative for the ECB study.
Weather Data: Fairbanks, Alaska
* Alt-1 Existing Building
Proposed
/ Base
Peak
Energy
kBtuh
10^6 Btu/yr %
Alt-2 Lighting Modifications
Proposed
Energy
/ Base
Peak
10^6 Btu/yr %
kBtuh
Alt-3 Adjust Cold Run On Point
Proposed
Energy
/ Base
Peak
10^6 Btu/yr %
kBtuh
Alt-4 VAr Speed on Jr Gym
Proposed
Energy
/ Base
Peak
10^6 Btu/yr %
kBtuh
Lighting - Conditioned
Electricity
1,006.4
11
568
733.1
73
414
733.1
73
414
733.1
73
414
Space Heating
Purchased Steam
6,957.8
73
6,072
7,151.4
103
6,117
7,011.7
101
6,117
6,948.8
100
6,202
Pumps
Electricity
13.3
0
15
13.7
103
15
13.3
100
16
13.3
100
16
Fans - Conditioned
Electricity
756.5
8
328
751.7
99
300
666.3
88
300
603.3
80
281
Receptacles - Conditioned
Electricity
557.7
6
408
557.7
100
408
557.7
100
408
557.7
100
408
Stand-alone Base Utilities
Electricity
261.0
3
58
77.7
30
17
77.7
30
17
77.7
30
17
Total Building Consumption
Total
9,552.8
9,285.3
9,059.9
8,933.9
68
10
88
5
92
5
92
0
Number of hours heating load not met
Number of hours cooling load not met
Energy
10^6 Btu/yr
Cost/yr
$/yr
Energy
10^6 Btu/yr
Cost/yr
$/yr
Energy
10^6 Btu/yr
Cost/yr
$/yr
Energy
10^6 Btu/yr
Cost/yr
$/yr
Electricity
2,595.0
167,451
2,133.9
139,762
2,048.2
135,744
1,985.2
132,009
Purchased Steam
6,957.8
118,283
7,151.4
121,573
7,011.7
119,199
6,948.8
118,130
9,553
285,734
9,285
261,336
9,060
254,943
8,934
250,138
Total
Dataset Name: ben_eielson.trc
Energy Cost Budget Report Page 1 of 1
On-Pk Cons. (kWh)
On-Pk Demand (kW)
93,354
350
63,658
352
84,591
352
63,226
356
69,253
360
28,756
350
27,397
350
29,620
350
63,568
359
71,348
356
68,248
351
97,313
359
760,331
360
On-Pk Cons. (therms)
On-Pk Demand (therms/hr)
12,376
54
7,495
48
9,382
47
4,778
34
3,814
27
776
3
751
4
984
7
2,845
23
4,565
31
7,795
45
14,017
61
69,578
61
89,479 Btu/(ft2-year)
26,987,798 lbm/year
27,836 gm/year
87,954 gm/year
106,760 ft2
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Alternative - 1 Monthly Energy Consumption report Page 1 of 4
On-Pk Cons. (kWh)
On-Pk Demand (kW)
79,404
309
51,000
305
69,879
305
52,584
308
57,711
309
21,390
305
20,282
305
21,982
305
52,776
308
57,960
308
55,526
304
84,728
311
625,224
311
12,593
54
7,622
48
9,713
48
4,904
34
3,933
27
846
7
809
7
1,000
7
2,926
23
4,827
31
8,062
45
14,278
61
71,514
61
22,192,186 lbm/year
22,890 gm/year
72,325 gm/year
106,760 ft2
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
On-Pk Cons. (kWh)
On-Pk Demand (kW)
69,533
309
51,000
305
60,973
305
52,584
308
57,711
309
21,390
305
20,282
305
21,982
305
52,776
308
57,960
308
55,526
304
78,390
311
600,106
311
11,922
54
7,622
48
9,055
51
4,904
34
3,933
27
846
7
809
7
1,000
7
2,926
23
4,827
31
8,062
45
14,210
61
70,117
61
21,300,654 lbm/year
21,970 gm/year
69,420 gm/year
106,760 ft2
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
On-Pk Cons. (kWh)
On-Pk Demand (kW)
66,809
303
49,721
299
59,461
299
51,218
302
56,246
303
20,714
299
19,600
299
21,285
299
51,404
302
56,497
302
54,107
298
74,584
305
581,646
305
11,731
54
7,565
47
8,982
50
4,881
33
3,952
27
846
7
809
7
1,008
7
2,949
24
4,829
30
7,962
45
13,974
62
69,488
62
20,645,394 lbm/year
21,295 gm/year
67,284 gm/year
106,760 ft2
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
27,980.2
166.6
25,315.5
166.6
30,645.0
166.6
26,647.8
166.6
29,312.6
166.6
15,022.7
166.6
13,657.0
166.6
15,705.6
166.6
26,647.8
166.6
29,312.6
166.6
27,980.2
166.6
26,647.8
166.6
294,875.0
166.6
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
17,819.0
119.5
16,122.0
119.5
19,516.1
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
18,667.5
119.5
1,314.6
119.5
1,195.1
119.5
1,374.4
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
18,667.5
119.5
17,819.0
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
163,406.7
119.5
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.2
0.0
1.7
0.0
0.7
0.0
0.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
2.6
0.0
9,027.5
17.1
8,153.9
17.1
9,027.5
17.1
4,625.1
17.1
4,779.3
17.1
4,625.1
17.1
4,779.3
17.1
4,779.3
17.1
4,625.1
17.1
7,434.4
17.1
7,194.6
17.1
7,434.4
17.1
76,485.4
17.1
Proc. Hot Water (therms)
Peak (therms/Hr)
966.9
5.5
874.5
5.5
1,039.5
5.5
924.0
5.5
1,003.2
5.5
427.9
1.7
413.6
1.7
445.0
1.7
924.0
5.5
1,003.2
5.5
960.3
5.5
930.6
5.5
9,912.7
5.5
Peak (therms/Hr)
659.3
3.8
596.3
3.8
708.8
3.8
630.0
3.8
684.0
3.8
291.8
1.1
282.0
1.1
303.4
1.1
630.0
3.8
684.0
3.8
654.8
3.8
634.5
3.8
6,758.6
3.8
9,077.4
40.4
5,474.3
35.1
6,819.1
35.8
3,445.0
24.4
2,693.7
19.0
466.7
1.9
452.5
4.1
649.5
5.9
1,941.5
17.3
3,250.3
22.2
5,641.5
32.7
10,311.8
45.8
50,223.3
45.8
592.0
2.8
317.8
2.8
403.5
2.8
155.2
1.8
125.8
1.4
49.0
0.2
47.7
0.4
53.0
0.4
102.7
1.3
133.9
1.7
320.8
2.6
688.0
3.5
2,989.4
3.5
3,298.3
13.1
2,021.2
12.8
2,562.8
12.2
1,333.1
9.7
1,120.5
8.3
308.9
1.2
298.5
1.2
334.6
1.2
903.4
6.4
1,315.2
8.8
2,153.1
12.1
3,705.3
14.9
19,354.7
14.9
Recoverable Water (1000gal)
Peak (1000gal/Hr)
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
Purchased Steam (therms)
Peak (therms/Hr)
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
Peak (therms/Hr)
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Alternative - 1 Equipment Energy Consumption report page 1 of 12
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
160.2
0.7
74.3
1.0
103.4
0.8
50.7
0.7
61.4
0.6
29.8
0.1
29.0
0.1
30.2
0.1
56.3
0.4
55.0
0.6
76.1
0.9
193.9
0.8
920.3
1.0
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
4,298.3
6.9
1,502.0
6.9
2,782.5
6.9
1,592.0
6.9
1,709.6
6.9
775.2
6.9
782.1
6.9
802.9
6.9
1,592.0
6.9
1,709.6
6.9
1,640.4
6.9
5,149.6
6.9
24,336.2
6.9
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
125.4
0.7
133.4
0.7
147.6
0.7
169.8
0.7
296.9
0.7
243.3
0.7
192.6
0.7
206.6
0.8
211.6
0.8
142.3
0.7
130.7
0.7
126.5
0.7
2,126.7
0.8
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
11,744.3
20.0
4,197.5
21.7
7,752.3
22.0
4,672.7
24.9
5,113.7
28.8
2,311.3
33.6
2,394.4
35.6
2,247.0
23.9
4,956.7
30.7
5,041.9
27.0
4,556.8
22.1
14,087.5
21.5
69,076.0
35.6
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,202.2
1.9
420.1
1.9
778.3
1.9
445.3
1.9
478.2
1.9
216.8
1.9
218.8
1.9
224.6
1.9
445.3
1.9
478.2
1.9
458.8
1.9
1,440.4
1.9
6,806.8
1.9
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
5,907.9
9.5
2,064.5
9.6
3,824.5
9.7
2,189.4
10.1
2,352.4
10.1
1,074.7
10.7
1,083.2
10.3
1,103.6
9.5
2,196.2
10.2
2,350.3
9.7
2,254.7
9.5
7,078.1
9.5
33,479.5
10.7
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
2,479.6
4.3
910.9
4.3
1,642.2
4.3
996.0
4.3
1,188.7
4.3
657.3
4.7
611.0
4.5
629.8
4.3
1,039.1
4.5
1,027.7
4.3
979.9
4.3
2,970.3
4.3
15,132.3
4.7
ben_eielson.trc
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
2,304.4
3.7
805.3
3.7
1,491.8
3.7
853.5
3.7
916.6
3.7
415.6
3.7
419.3
3.7
430.5
3.7
853.5
3.7
916.6
3.7
879.5
3.7
2,953.2
13.7
13,239.6
13.7
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
2,624.5
4.2
917.1
4.2
1,698.9
4.2
972.0
4.2
1,043.9
4.2
473.3
4.2
477.6
4.2
490.2
4.2
972.0
4.2
1,043.9
4.2
1,001.6
4.2
3,144.3
4.2
14,859.3
4.2
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
371.9
2.0
265.6
2.0
352.5
2.0
291.3
2.0
354.0
2.0
175.6
2.1
161.2
2.0
171.4
2.3
323.4
2.3
306.8
2.0
291.1
2.0
387.4
2.0
3,452.1
2.3
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
4,631.8
7.5
1,618.5
7.5
2,998.4
7.5
1,715.5
7.9
1,842.3
7.8
845.9
9.9
858.0
9.9
865.2
7.5
1,715.5
8.7
1,842.3
7.5
1,767.7
7.5
5,549.2
7.5
26,250.4
9.9
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,944.8
3.4
716.2
3.4
1,289.4
3.4
783.8
3.4
939.4
3.4
525.0
4.4
489.0
4.3
500.4
3.4
816.9
3.7
807.5
3.4
769.8
3.4
2,329.6
3.4
11,911.8
4.4
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
139.5
0.9
124.0
0.7
137.4
0.7
95.3
0.5
70.9
0.3
0.9
0.0
1.4
0.0
5.2
0.1
43.5
0.3
77.9
0.4
126.0
0.7
161.7
1.0
983.6
1.0
ben_eielson.trc
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
20,381.9
121.3
18,440.8
121.3
22,323.1
121.3
19,411.4
121.3
21,352.5
121.3
10,943.2
121.3
9,948.3
121.3
11,440.6
121.3
19,411.4
121.3
21,352.5
121.3
20,381.9
121.3
19,411.4
121.3
214,798.8
121.3
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
17,819.0
119.5
16,122.0
119.5
19,516.1
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
18,667.5
119.5
1,314.6
119.5
1,195.1
119.5
1,374.4
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
18,667.5
119.5
17,819.0
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
163,406.7
119.5
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.2
0.0
1.8
0.0
0.7
0.0
0.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
2.8
0.0
2,687.7
5.1
2,427.6
5.1
2,687.7
5.1
1,377.0
5.1
1,422.9
5.1
1,377.0
5.1
1,422.9
5.1
1,422.9
5.1
1,377.0
5.1
2,213.4
5.1
2,142.0
5.1
2,213.4
5.1
22,771.5
5.1
Peak (therms/Hr)
966.9
5.5
874.5
5.5
1,039.5
5.5
924.0
5.5
1,003.2
5.5
427.9
1.7
413.6
1.7
445.0
1.7
924.0
5.5
1,003.2
5.5
960.3
5.5
930.6
5.5
9,912.7
5.5
Peak (therms/Hr)
659.3
3.8
596.3
3.8
708.8
3.8
630.0
3.8
684.0
3.8
291.8
1.1
282.0
1.1
303.4
1.1
630.0
3.8
684.0
3.8
654.8
3.8
634.5
3.8
6,758.6
3.8
9,252.9
40.8
5,573.2
35.1
7,116.5
36.2
3,543.3
24.4
2,795.5
18.9
537.1
5.6
510.6
5.5
661.3
6.0
2,010.6
17.4
3,482.5
22.3
5,878.6
32.9
10,530.4
46.1
51,892.4
46.1
603.6
2.9
326.0
2.8
425.8
2.9
159.7
1.8
125.6
1.4
49.6
0.2
48.0
0.4
52.1
0.4
102.1
1.3
146.1
1.7
338.3
2.6
703.7
3.5
3,080.4
3.5
3,339.8
13.2
2,049.0
12.8
2,596.4
12.3
1,360.8
9.7
1,138.0
8.3
308.9
1.2
298.8
1.2
338.7
1.3
915.9
6.5
1,344.1
8.8
2,183.4
12.1
3,747.7
15.0
19,621.4
15.0
Peak (1000gal/Hr)
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
Peak (therms/Hr)
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
Peak (therms/Hr)
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
163.3
0.7
75.5
1.0
105.0
0.8
51.0
0.7
61.5
0.6
29.8
0.1
28.9
0.1
30.1
0.1
56.2
0.4
54.0
0.6
77.5
0.9
195.1
0.8
927.7
1.0
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
4,298.3
6.9
1,502.0
6.9
2,782.5
6.9
1,592.0
6.9
1,709.6
6.9
775.2
6.9
782.1
6.9
802.9
6.9
1,592.0
6.9
1,709.6
6.9
1,640.4
6.9
5,149.6
6.9
24,336.2
6.9
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
125.4
0.7
133.4
0.7
147.6
0.7
169.8
0.7
296.9
0.7
242.5
0.7
192.6
0.7
206.6
0.8
207.1
0.7
142.3
0.7
130.7
0.7
126.5
0.7
2,121.3
0.8
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
11,694.4
18.8
4,128.0
20.4
7,674.6
20.4
4,508.8
22.8
4,888.5
23.8
2,280.6
30.5
2,352.6
30.7
2,230.5
22.7
4,672.2
26.9
4,820.9
24.3
4,463.1
19.1
14,010.7
18.8
67,724.9
30.7
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,202.2
1.9
420.1
1.9
778.3
1.9
445.3
1.9
478.2
1.9
216.8
1.9
218.8
1.9
224.6
1.9
445.3
1.9
478.2
1.9
458.8
1.9
1,440.4
1.9
6,806.8
1.9
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
5,907.9
9.5
2,064.5
9.5
3,824.5
9.5
2,188.1
9.7
2,349.9
9.8
1,073.6
10.6
1,081.8
10.3
1,103.6
9.5
2,190.7
10.0
2,349.9
9.5
2,254.7
9.5
7,078.1
9.5
33,467.0
10.6
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
2,479.6
4.3
910.9
4.3
1,642.2
4.3
995.5
4.3
1,187.7
4.3
656.8
4.7
610.4
4.5
629.8
4.3
1,036.8
4.4
1,027.5
4.3
979.9
4.3
2,970.3
4.3
15,127.2
4.7
ben_eielson.trc
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
2,325.2
8.9
805.3
3.7
1,491.8
3.7
853.5
3.7
916.6
3.7
415.6
3.7
419.3
3.7
430.5
3.7
853.5
3.7
916.6
3.7
879.5
3.7
2,883.2
11.4
13,190.3
11.4
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
2,624.5
4.2
917.1
4.2
1,698.9
4.2
972.0
4.2
1,043.9
4.2
473.3
4.2
477.6
4.2
490.2
4.2
972.0
4.2
1,043.9
4.2
1,001.6
4.2
3,144.3
4.2
14,859.3
4.2
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
371.9
2.0
265.6
2.0
352.5
2.0
291.3
2.0
354.0
2.0
173.3
2.0
161.2
2.0
171.4
2.3
309.6
2.0
306.8
2.0
291.1
2.0
387.4
2.0
3,436.0
2.3
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
4,631.8
7.5
1,618.5
7.5
2,998.4
7.5
1,715.5
7.5
1,842.3
7.5
843.1
9.4
853.7
9.3
865.2
7.5
1,715.5
7.7
1,842.3
7.5
1,767.7
7.5
5,549.2
7.5
26,243.3
9.4
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,944.8
3.4
716.2
3.4
1,289.4
3.4
783.8
3.4
939.4
3.4
523.8
4.1
487.2
4.0
500.4
3.4
816.9
3.4
807.5
3.4
769.8
3.4
2,329.6
3.4
11,908.8
4.1
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
143.0
0.9
127.2
0.7
141.2
0.7
98.6
0.5
74.6
0.3
1.0
0.0
1.6
0.0
6.9
0.1
47.2
0.3
81.5
0.5
129.5
0.7
165.1
1.0
1,017.5
1.0
ben_eielson.trc
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
20,381.9
121.3
18,440.8
121.3
22,323.1
121.3
19,411.4
121.3
21,352.5
121.3
10,943.2
121.3
9,948.3
121.3
11,440.6
121.3
19,411.4
121.3
21,352.5
121.3
20,381.9
121.3
19,411.4
121.3
214,798.8
121.3
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
17,819.0
119.5
16,122.0
119.5
19,516.1
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
18,667.5
119.5
1,314.6
119.5
1,195.1
119.5
1,374.4
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
18,667.5
119.5
17,819.0
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
163,406.7
119.5
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.2
0.0
1.8
0.0
0.7
0.0
0.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
2.7
0.0
2,687.7
5.1
2,427.6
5.1
2,687.7
5.1
1,377.0
5.1
1,422.9
5.1
1,377.0
5.1
1,422.9
5.1
1,422.9
5.1
1,377.0
5.1
2,213.4
5.1
2,142.0
5.1
2,213.4
5.1
22,771.5
5.1
Peak (therms/Hr)
966.9
5.5
874.5
5.5
1,039.5
5.5
924.0
5.5
1,003.2
5.5
427.9
1.7
413.6
1.7
445.0
1.7
924.0
5.5
1,003.2
5.5
960.3
5.5
930.6
5.5
9,912.7
5.5
Peak (therms/Hr)
659.3
3.8
596.3
3.8
708.8
3.8
630.0
3.8
684.0
3.8
291.8
1.1
282.0
1.1
303.4
1.1
630.0
3.8
684.0
3.8
654.8
3.8
634.5
3.8
6,758.6
3.8
8,740.3
41.0
5,573.2
35.1
6,607.5
37.6
3,543.3
24.4
2,795.5
18.9
537.1
5.6
510.6
5.5
661.3
6.0
2,010.6
17.4
3,482.5
22.3
5,878.6
32.9
10,487.8
46.1
50,828.3
46.1
562.0
3.6
326.0
2.8
385.7
3.1
159.7
1.8
125.6
1.4
49.6
0.2
48.0
0.4
52.1
0.4
102.1
1.3
146.1
1.7
338.3
2.6
699.0
3.5
2,994.0
3.6
3,181.7
13.2
2,049.0
12.8
2,447.5
13.5
1,360.8
9.7
1,138.0
8.3
308.9
1.2
298.8
1.2
338.7
1.3
915.9
6.5
1,344.1
8.8
2,183.4
12.1
3,722.1
15.0
19,288.8
15.0
Peak (1000gal/Hr)
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
Peak (therms/Hr)
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
Peak (therms/Hr)
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
150.8
0.9
75.5
1.0
92.3
1.0
51.0
0.7
61.5
0.6
29.8
0.1
28.9
0.1
30.1
0.1
56.2
0.4
54.0
0.6
77.5
0.9
193.4
0.8
900.9
1.0
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
3,163.2
6.9
1,502.0
6.9
1,758.1
6.9
1,592.0
6.9
1,709.6
6.9
775.2
6.9
782.1
6.9
802.9
6.9
1,592.0
6.9
1,709.6
6.9
1,640.4
6.9
4,416.0
6.9
21,443.0
6.9
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
117.7
0.7
133.4
0.7
141.3
0.7
169.8
0.7
296.9
0.7
242.5
0.7
192.6
0.7
206.6
0.8
207.1
0.7
142.3
0.7
130.7
0.7
124.6
0.7
2,105.5
0.8
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
8,606.0
18.8
4,128.0
20.4
4,887.8
20.4
4,508.8
22.8
4,888.5
23.8
2,280.6
30.5
2,352.6
30.7
2,230.5
22.7
4,672.2
26.9
4,820.9
24.3
4,463.1
19.1
12,014.6
18.8
59,853.5
30.7
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
884.7
1.9
420.1
1.9
491.7
1.9
445.3
1.9
478.2
1.9
216.8
1.9
218.8
1.9
224.6
1.9
445.3
1.9
478.2
1.9
458.8
1.9
1,235.1
1.9
5,997.6
1.9
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
4,347.7
9.5
2,064.5
9.5
2,416.5
9.5
2,188.1
9.7
2,349.9
9.8
1,073.6
10.6
1,081.8
10.3
1,103.6
9.5
2,190.7
10.0
2,349.9
9.5
2,254.7
9.5
6,069.7
9.5
29,490.4
10.6
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,829.5
4.3
910.9
4.3
1,057.3
4.3
995.5
4.3
1,187.7
4.3
656.8
4.7
610.4
4.5
629.8
4.3
1,036.8
4.4
1,027.5
4.3
979.9
4.3
2,550.1
4.3
13,472.1
4.7
ben_eielson.trc
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,716.6
8.9
805.3
3.7
942.6
3.7
853.5
3.7
916.6
3.7
415.6
3.7
419.3
3.7
430.5
3.7
853.5
3.7
916.6
3.7
879.5
3.7
2,489.8
11.4
11,639.2
11.4
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,931.4
4.2
917.1
4.2
1,073.5
4.2
972.0
4.2
1,043.9
4.2
473.3
4.2
477.6
4.2
490.2
4.2
972.0
4.2
1,043.9
4.2
1,001.6
4.2
2,696.3
4.2
13,092.8
4.2
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
347.6
2.0
265.6
2.0
332.6
2.0
291.3
2.0
354.0
2.0
173.3
2.0
161.2
2.0
171.4
2.3
309.6
2.0
306.8
2.0
291.1
2.0
381.9
2.0
3,386.2
2.3
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
3,408.6
7.5
1,618.5
7.5
1,894.5
7.5
1,715.5
7.5
1,842.3
7.5
843.1
9.4
853.7
9.3
865.2
7.5
1,715.5
7.7
1,842.3
7.5
1,767.7
7.5
4,758.6
7.5
23,125.6
9.4
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,435.1
3.4
716.2
3.4
830.9
3.4
783.8
3.4
939.4
3.4
523.8
4.1
487.2
4.0
500.4
3.4
816.9
3.4
807.5
3.4
769.8
3.4
2,000.2
3.4
10,611.3
4.1
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
143.0
0.9
127.2
0.7
141.2
0.7
98.6
0.5
74.6
0.3
1.0
0.0
1.6
0.0
6.9
0.1
47.2
0.3
81.5
0.5
129.5
0.7
165.1
1.0
1,017.5
1.0
ben_eielson.trc
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
20,381.9
121.3
18,440.8
121.3
22,323.1
121.3
19,411.4
121.3
21,352.5
121.3
10,943.2
121.3
9,948.3
121.3
11,440.6
121.3
19,411.4
121.3
21,352.5
121.3
20,381.9
121.3
19,411.4
121.3
214,798.8
121.3
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
17,819.0
119.5
16,122.0
119.5
19,516.1
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
18,667.5
119.5
1,314.6
119.5
1,195.1
119.5
1,374.4
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
18,667.5
119.5
17,819.0
119.5
16,970.5
119.5
163,406.7
119.5
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.3
0.0
1.8
0.0
0.7
0.0
0.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
3.0
0.0
2,687.7
5.1
2,427.6
5.1
2,687.7
5.1
1,377.0
5.1
1,422.9
5.1
1,377.0
5.1
1,422.9
5.1
1,422.9
5.1
1,377.0
5.1
2,213.4
5.1
2,142.0
5.1
2,213.4
5.1
22,771.5
5.1
Peak (therms/Hr)
966.9
5.5
874.5
5.5
1,039.5
5.5
924.0
5.5
1,003.2
5.5
427.9
1.7
413.6
1.7
445.0
1.7
924.0
5.5
1,003.2
5.5
960.3
5.5
930.6
5.5
9,912.7
5.5
Peak (therms/Hr)
659.3
3.8
596.3
3.8
708.8
3.8
630.0
3.8
684.0
3.8
291.8
1.1
282.0
1.1
303.4
1.1
630.0
3.8
684.0
3.8
654.8
3.8
634.5
3.8
6,758.6
3.8
8,732.5
40.9
5,566.5
35.1
6,601.1
37.6
3,540.5
24.4
2,793.8
18.9
537.1
5.6
510.6
5.5
661.3
6.0
2,011.0
17.4
3,480.8
22.2
5,874.3
32.8
10,479.4
46.1
50,789.0
46.1
561.4
3.6
325.4
2.8
385.1
3.1
159.5
1.8
125.4
1.4
49.6
0.2
48.0
0.4
52.1
0.4
102.1
1.3
146.0
1.7
338.0
2.6
698.4
3.5
2,991.0
3.6
2,998.2
13.8
1,998.9
13.3
2,380.8
14.1
1,340.4
10.2
1,157.8
8.7
308.9
1.2
298.8
1.2
346.9
2.3
938.0
7.1
1,348.6
9.2
2,087.3
12.7
3,494.4
16.0
18,699.0
16.0
Peak (1000gal/Hr)
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
Peak (therms/Hr)
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
Peak (therms/Hr)
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
ben_eielson.trc
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
143.0
1.1
77.5
0.8
93.7
0.9
54.6
0.6
64.2
0.5
30.8
0.1
30.0
0.1
31.7
0.2
59.5
0.4
56.7
0.5
78.0
0.8
184.1
1.0
903.6
1.1
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
436.0
1.0
218.4
1.5
246.0
1.1
219.4
1.0
235.7
1.6
106.9
1.0
107.8
1.0
110.7
1.0
219.5
1.0
236.9
1.2
226.1
1.0
608.7
1.0
2,972.1
1.6
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
129.0
0.7
137.0
0.7
144.1
0.7
175.5
0.7
302.1
0.7
240.3
0.6
190.3
0.6
205.5
0.6
209.2
0.7
150.2
0.7
131.6
0.7
138.1
0.6
2,152.7
0.7
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
8,606.0
18.8
4,128.0
20.4
4,887.8
20.4
4,508.8
22.8
4,888.5
23.8
2,280.6
30.5
2,352.6
30.7
2,230.5
22.7
4,672.2
26.9
4,820.9
24.3
4,463.1
19.1
12,014.6
18.8
59,853.5
30.7
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
884.7
1.9
420.1
1.9
491.7
1.9
445.3
1.9
478.2
1.9
216.8
1.9
218.8
1.9
224.6
1.9
445.3
1.9
478.2
1.9
458.8
1.9
1,235.1
1.9
5,997.6
1.9
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
4,347.7
9.5
2,064.5
9.5
2,416.5
9.5
2,188.1
9.7
2,349.9
9.8
1,073.6
10.6
1,081.8
10.3
1,103.6
9.5
2,190.7
10.0
2,349.9
9.5
2,254.7
9.5
6,069.7
9.5
29,490.4
10.6
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,829.5
4.3
910.9
4.3
1,057.3
4.3
995.5
4.3
1,187.7
4.3
656.8
4.7
610.4
4.5
629.8
4.3
1,036.8
4.4
1,027.5
4.3
979.9
4.3
2,550.1
4.3
13,472.1
4.7
ben_eielson.trc
Project Name:
Dataset Name:
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,716.6
8.9
805.3
3.7
942.6
3.7
853.5
3.7
916.6
3.7
415.6
3.7
419.3
3.7
430.5
3.7
853.5
3.7
916.6
3.7
879.5
3.7
2,489.8
11.4
11,639.2
11.4
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,931.4
4.2
917.1
4.2
1,073.5
4.2
972.0
4.2
1,043.9
4.2
473.3
4.2
477.6
4.2
490.2
4.2
972.0
4.2
1,043.9
4.2
1,001.6
4.2
2,696.3
4.2
13,092.8
4.2
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
348.6
2.0
265.1
2.0
329.6
2.0
288.6
2.0
354.7
2.0
166.6
1.9
154.3
1.9
165.3
1.9
305.0
2.0
305.9
2.0
285.5
2.0
380.2
1.9
3,349.5
2.0
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
3,408.6
7.5
1,618.5
7.5
1,894.5
7.5
1,715.5
7.5
1,842.3
7.5
843.1
9.4
853.7
9.3
865.2
7.5
1,715.5
7.7
1,842.3
7.5
1,767.7
7.5
4,758.6
7.5
23,125.6
9.4
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
1,435.1
3.4
716.2
3.4
830.9
3.4
783.8
3.4
939.4
3.4
523.8
4.1
487.2
4.0
500.4
3.4
816.9
3.4
807.5
3.4
769.8
3.4
2,000.2
3.4
10,611.3
4.1
Electric (kWh)
Peak (kW)
143.0
0.9
127.2
0.7
141.2
0.7
98.6
0.5
74.6
0.3
1.0
0.0
1.6
0.0
6.9
0.1
47.2
0.3
81.5
0.5
129.5
0.7
165.1
1.0
1,017.5
1.0
ben_eielson.trc
APPENDIX I – TREND LOG INFORMATION
100
85.0%
Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High - SF12 - Jan 12 - Jan 15, 2012
90
80
Outside Air Percentage
65.0%
Return Air Temperature
70
45.0%
60
Mixed Air Temperature
50
25.0%
40
OAT
MAT
30
Preheat Coil Temperature
5.0%
RAT
PHT
20
OA %
-15.0%
10
0
-35.0%
-10
Outside Air Temeprature
-20
-55.0%
-30
-75.0%
21:40
23:00
00:20
01:40
03:00
04:20
05:40
07:00
08:20
09:40
11:00
12:20
13:40
15:00
16:20
17:40
19:00
20:20
21:40
23:00
00:20
01:40
03:00
04:20
05:40
07:00
08:20
09:40
11:00
12:20
13:40
15:00
16:20
17:40
19:00
20:20
21:40
23:00
00:20
01:40
-40
Linear (PHT)
100
90
Ben Eielson Jr/Sr High School - SF12 With Averaged Preheat Coil Temps
80
70
Unoccupied Hours with OSA
at 25%
85.0%
65.0%
45.0%
60
50
25.0%
40
OAT
30
20
5.0%
Preheat Coil Discharge Temp
Averaged over 2 Hour Periods
0
-35.0%
-10
-20
-55.0%
-30
-75.0%
21:40
23:00
00:20
01:40
03:00
04:20
05:40
07:00
08:20
09:40
11:00
12:20
13:40
15:00
16:20
17:40
19:00
20:20
21:40
23:00
00:20
01:40
03:00
04:20
05:40
07:00
08:20
09:40
11:00
12:20
13:40
15:00
16:20
17:40
19:00
20:20
21:40
23:00
00:20
01:40
-40
RAT
Avg PHT
-15.0%
10
MAT
Avg Osa
240
220
30%
Ben Eielson Sr High Steam/Heating Water System -Jan 13- Jan 15, 2012
200
180
160
25%
Heating Water Supply
Temperature Showing Correct
Reset Based on OSA Temp
20%
140
120
100
15%
OAT
HWS
Stm Valve
80
60
10%
40
20
5%
0
-20
0%
21:20
22:40
00:00
01:20
02:40
04:00
05:20
06:40
08:00
09:20
10:40
12:00
13:20
14:40
16:00
17:20
18:40
20:00
21:20
22:40
00:00
01:20
02:40
04:00
05:20
06:40
08:00
09:20
10:40
12:00
13:20
14:40
16:00
17:20
18:40
20:00
21:20
22:40
00:00
01:20
-40
APPENDIX J – FLOOR PLANS

DOYON-Nortech-FAI_FNSB_Ben_Eielson_Jr

Transcription

Similar documents