Here - aagbi
Transcription
Here - aagbi
The Newsletter of the Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland INSIDE THIS ISSUE: The WISE Anaesthetic Cup Arterial line safety – can we do better? Brugada syndrome: resources for the anaesthetist Teaching primary trauma care in Mozambique ISSN 0959-2962 No. 337 AUGUST 2015 Editorial Contents 03Editorial 05 President's Report Once again the honour of writing an editorial falls upon this still-new Council Member. Producing good material is always a challenge, and I hope you will enjoy the articles selected for this issue. 07 The WISE Anaesthetic Cup 07 09 First I would draw your attention to two events for which your generous donations are sought. At this year’s AAGBI Annual Congress in Edinburgh, there will be a football tournament contested between AAGBI members from Wales, Ireland, Scotland and England. This event demands an acronym, like every other medicine-related term, and so the victors will receive the WISE Anaesthetic Cup. Proceeds will go towards Lifeboxes for Rio and help to provide pulse oximeters to hospitals in need in Africa. In addition, from 17th to 21st September, volunteers will be cycling from the AAGBI headquarters, 21 Portland Place, London, to the Edinburgh International Conference Centre. Your donations can be offered via the Lifeboxes for Rio section of the AAGBI website. Alternatively, you can set up your own ‘My Donate’ facility, with reference to aagbi.org, then donate the proceeds to Lifeboxes for Rio. Further details can be found here – http://www.aagbi.org/about-us/fundraising/cycle/routes-and-information Meanwhile, the SAFE Programme goes from strength to strength, and teaching is now offered in many Francophone countries. Support for the delivery of this is given by the AAGBI – via the International Relations Committee (IRC) – which is important and valuable. Grants are available to those willing to give up their time, pending approval by the IRC. It behoves us to help improve the standard of worldwide anaesthesia if we are to be considered ‘worth our salt’. Visionary. Bringing advanced ultrasound to the bedside. Improve quality of care, efficiency, patient safety, patient satisfaction, and reduce complications and costs. To learn more about SonoSite Point-of-Care Ultrasound Solutions or request a product demonstration email us at ukresponse@sonosite.com or visit www.sonosite.co.uk The Value of Visualisation ©2015 FUJIFILM SonoSite, Inc. All rights reserved. The articles on safe arterial lines and Brugada syndrome are most interesting and may induce a few ‘There-but-for-the-grace-of-God-go-I’ feelings. Brugada syndrome seems to be uncommon yet each of us may encounter a few cases per career. I wonder how many have passed through my care unnoticed? Think of young patients without an ECG to hand. Finally, as Seminars Lead, I would like to make a call for new material. This request challenges all to produce new ideas and extends across the entire AAGBI membership. All ideas for seminars will be considered. Please do not be reticent. The format is not fixed but is theme-based. There are usually 5 or 6 talks in the morning and fewer in the afternoon, lasting 25 minutes each, with 5 minutes of questions. However, you could design something innovative, interactive, electronic, cinematic or whatever you think might be of educational value. Contact Rachael Arnold (rachaelarnold@aagbi.org) with submissions. Please come to Congress next month in Edinburgh. The Castle dungeons await those who don’t take part in ceilidh dancing… www.sonosite.co.uk www.sonosite.co.uk/education FUJIFILM SonoSite, Inc. the SonoSite logo and other trademarks not owned by third parties are registered and unregistered trademarks of FUJIFILM SonoSite, Inc. in various jurisdictions. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. The Northern Irish SAS Group appears to be developing well, and such gatherings can only enhance knowledge and the fellowship colleagues might gain through education and dialogue. The social benefits cannot be undervalued and it would be excellent to hear about more of these events throughout the UK and Ireland. SAS doctors are important to our Association, and we hope that in future years more will come forward to represent this group at the AAGBI. It is quite difficult to find willing representatives, so if you feel inclined to come forward when the need arises, please do so. Gerry Keenan 09 The Needle-Free Non-Injectable Arterial Connector (NIC) 11Safety Matters: Standards Committee work 13 Northern Ireland SAS Group Meeting 13 14 Brugada syndrome: resources for the anaesthetist 16 Art exhibition at Annual Congress 2015 17 ‘Anesthésie a moindre risque’ 20 Teaching primary trauma care in Mozambique 17 25 Arterial line safety – can we do better? 29 Anaesthesia Digested 30 Particles 32 Your letters 32 16 The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland 21 Portland Place, London W1B 1PY Telephone: 020 7631 1650 Fax: 020 7631 4352 Email: anaenews@aagbi.org Website: www.aagbi.org Anaesthesia News Managing Editor: Nancy Redfern Editors: Phil Bewley and Sarah Gibb (GAT), Nancy Redfern, Richard Griffiths, Sean Tighe, Tom Woodcock, Mike Nathanson, Rachel Collis, Upma Misra, Felicity Platt and Gerry Keenan Address for all correspondence, advertising or submissions: Email: anaenews@aagbi.org Website: www.aagbi.org/publications/anaesthesia-news Editorial Assistant: Rona Gloag Email: anaenews@aagbi.org Design: Chris Steer AAGBI Website & Publications Officer Telephone: 020 7631 8803 Email: chris@aagbi.org Printing: Portland Print Copyright 2015 The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland The Association cannot be responsible for the statements or views of the contributors. No part of this newsletter may be reproduced without prior permission. 2170 04/14 Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 Advertisements are accepted in good faith. Readers are reminded that Anaesthesia News cannot be held responsible in any way for the quality or correctness of products or services offered in advertisements. 3 The Preoperative 10 West of England Anaesthesia Update th 10th West of England Anaesthesia Update Based in Chalet Hotel St Christoph Talks cover a wide range of topics 15 CPD points RCOA Flights available from Bristol, Gatwick and other airports nationwide All grades of Anaesthetist from everywhere welcome. 18th – 22rd January 2016 St Christoph am Arlberg (nr St Anton), Austria EAST MIDLANDS CONFERENCE CENTRE Association NATIONAL CONFERENCE 5TH NOVEMBER 2015 NOTTINGHAM Pre-op ACCREDITED WITH 5 CEPD POINTS TOPICS TO INCLUDE: Role of Preoperative Assessment in Perioperative Medicine / Dynamic Cardiac Testing / Diabetic Guidelines Update / Obstructive Sleep Apnoea & ECG workshops / Brief Interventions in Preoperative Assessment / Debate: ‘Who is best placed to be the Perioperative Physician - Anaesthetist vs Physician’ ABSTRACT FOR PRESENTATIONS OR POSTERS TO BE SUBMITTED BY 25TH SEPTEMBER 2015 Open to all healthcare professionals involved in the preoperative assessment of the surgical patient. For full details and to book your place, please contact us: www.weauconf.com W: WWW.PRE-OP.ORG / T: 020 7631 8896 RESEARCH GRANTS THE ASSOCIATION OF ANAESTHETISTS OF GREAT BRITAIN & IRELAND AND ANAESTHESIA WILL BE AWARDING RESEARCH GRANTS IN SEPTEMBER 2015. The Associations’ research aims are: • Patient safety • Innovation • Clinical outcomes • Education and training • Related professional issues (e.g. standards and guidelines, working conditions, medico-legal issues) • The environment Applications must describe how the proposed project meets the Association’s research aims. Suitable projects may be large research studies, small clinical/benchtop projects, idea (innovation) development, observational studies/data collection, quality improvements or clinical audits (although the latter are unlikely to receive AAGBI funding if they are small, ‘routine’ local audits). Funding up to £20,000 may be sought, but applications will be judged on ‘value-for money’ as well as scientific credibility. Awards will be made via the NIAA and, if appropriate, will be eligible for NIHR portfolio status. For further information and to apply please visit the AAGBI website http://www.aagbi.org/research/aagbi-research-grants Completed application forms and supporting docs should be returned to the NIAA secretariat info@niaa.org.uk The deadline for applications is 5pm Friday 07 August 2015 PRESIDENT's REPORT All change! The last few months have seen changes at the top of many national anaesthetic organisations either take place or be announced. Dr Ben Fox took over as Chair of GAT from Dr Sarah Gibb at a hugely successful Annual Scientific Meeting in Manchester. It was an enormous privilege to be able to present Sarah with the AAGBI’s Anniversary medal, the first time a trainee has received one of the AAGBI’s high honours. Ben’s previous role as Honorary Secretary was taken by Dr Emma Plunkett, and Dr Rowena Clark succeeded Dr Caroline Wilson as Vice Chair. In Dublin, Dr Ellen O’Sullivan hands over the Presidency of the College of Anaesthetists of Ireland to Dr Kevin Carson. Ellen has been a permanent feature on the medico-political landscape for so many years, it will seem strange not to see her at AAGBI Council meetings. As Convenor of the Irish Standing Committee, an elected Council Member, Honorary Membership Secretary, AAGBI Vice President and finally as CAI President, I can think of no-one who has served longer or in as many roles at the AAGBI. Add to this her contributions as President of the Difficult Airway Society and to NAP5, Ellen was a very worthy recipient of the AAGBI’s John Snow Silver Medal presented on home turf at Annual Congress in Dublin in 2013. Closer to home, Tom Grinyer has recently taken over from Kevin Storey at the Royal College of Anaesthetists. Dr Liam Brennan will succeed Dr J-P Van Besouw as President in September and there will be new Vice Presidents in Drs Richard Marks and Jeremy Langton. On behalf of the AAGBI I congratulate all these new appointments and look forward to working closely with them, and thank all those demitting office for their massive contribution to our specialty. Here at 21 Portland Place we now know that Dr Paul Clyburn will succeed me as President and Dr Mike Nathanson will take over from Samantha Shinde as Honorary Secretary in 2016. I’ve worked with Paul for almost eight years on Council and know the AAGBI will be in safe hands. Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 Despite ‘all change’ I doubt many Members or Fellows will notice any major changes in what our respective Councils, Boards or Committees actually do. However the change (or non-change) in UK Government is likely to have a much greater impact on our working lives. I’ve yet to meet anyone who admits they saw a majority Conservative government as the likely outcome of the 7 May election. The slim, but working majority certainly gives the Government an opportunity to force legislation through the House of Commons, although with the House of Lords reforms it no longer benefits from the automatic majority in the Lords enjoyed by the last majority Conservative government led by John Major in the 1990s. Prime Minister David Cameron has made NHS reform one of his personal priorities with Jeremy Hunt remaining as Health Secretary. In England at least, we can expect rapid movement on Consultant Contracts to incorporate the commitment to seven day working, not only for emergency work, but for the whole range of NHS services. I suspect the impact on anaesthetists and intensive care doctors will be less than for many colleagues, and I personally fear for the impact on an already stretched and demoralised primary care sector. As colleagues get used to the change in pension arrangements, from final salary to the Career Average scheme only implemented recently, we should not assume there will be no further, probably unwelcome, changes such as the recent reduction in the pensions Lifetime Allowance, which is likely to affect most consultants, not just those in receipt of higher Clinical Excellence Awards. The AAGBI’s ability to influence contract, pay and pension negotiations is limited, although we will continue to support the BMA as far as we are able. In all such discussions we will maintain our priorities of Patient Safety and Membership Wellbeing, stressing that the two are closely linked. The other truth highlighted by the result of the General Election campaign is the starkly different political map of the four countries of the UK. Employment conditions and service priorities for the National Health Services 55 are likely to diverge even further during the current Parliament. Each NHS faces its own challenges and I’m not sure the grass is greener in any one of them. The challenge for the AAGBI and the Royal College will be to work together to maintain standards of practice, education and employment. The need for consultant anaesthetists is predicted to increase significantly over the next 20 years, but where these additional anaesthetists will come from is unclear. With the lag between medical student entry, specialist training recruitment and award of CCT currently almost three parliamentary sessions, governments can avoid getting bogged down in detail too. Free movement of workers (subject to recently imposed language requirements for medical specialists) is one of the key principles of the European Union, and the one perhaps most responsible for current government proposals for EU reform and a referendum before the end of 2017. During the recent Euroanaesthesia meeting in Berlin, I attended the UEMS EBA (European Union of Medical Specialists European Board of Anaesthesiology). The Board works mainly through three standing committees: Education and Professional Development, Patient Safety and Quality of Care, and Workforce, Welfare and Working Conditions. I was impressed by the energy of the EBA to drive forward standards in all three areas, and it was gratifying that the UK and Ireland are acknowledged to be leaders, with many countries aspiring to our levels of achievement. Regardless of the outcome of any referendum, the AAGBI and the UK can and should play a major part to improve standards across the EU, and can only hope to benefit from such change. The thorny issue of non-physician providers of anaesthesia is never far from discussions at the AAGBI or the Royal College. The UK is in the minority of countries where physician providers are the overwhelming majority of anaesthetists, but PA(A)s exist in the UK and are unlikely to disappear. This is an area of where opinions remain sharply divided and there a few shades of grey. The debate continues, and is lively and (for the most part) good tempered. The AAGBI recognises the divergence of opinion exists not just at Board level but also within its membership and strives to strike the balance between quality of care, economic reality and professional reputation. This is one area where we will never be able to keep everyone happy, but we will keep trying. Whatever your view of this, it’s not going to go away. August is one of the quieter months at Portland Place, with few committees meeting and many Board members and staff taking holidays and the opportunity to spend time with family and friends. I’m certainly looking forward to one or two Fridays off before we meet again in September and prepare for Annual Congress in Edinburgh, welcoming new Board Members, saying farewell to those departing and starting all over on another annual cycle of the AAGBI (unintentional pun - but better than most I write!). Enjoy the summer. Andrew Hartle President, AAGBI The WISE Anaesthetic Cup It was on a drab Tuesday morning, as an operation dragged on like a Hibernian football game that minds in Glasgow’s Western Infirmary began to wander. As the surgeon asked, yet again, what the blood pressure was, it seemed extra time was inevitable. Then the surprise arrival of the country’s one trainee facilitated a prompt departure to the coffee room and perhaps a pie. Here, other minds escaping the monotony of the list united, and the idea of challenging the great Glasgow Royal Infirmary to a game of football started to take shape. It turned out it had all been done before. The secretaries had found a dusty cup called the Chadwick Trophy, which was now in two pieces at the bottom of a cupboard. The Chadwick Trophy was last engraved in 1992, and it was now time to glue it back together, dust it off, and sharpen the engraver’s pen. Soon all talk of the impending hospital merger was replaced by in depth discussion of the merits of a 4-4-2 formation. An inclusive approach allowed anaesthetists aged from their 20s to their 50s to take part and an open sub policy meant the varied fitness levels did not prevent the less fit taking part – they did, but only for as long as an average SPA rotation. Despite the all-encompassing approach, the competition was fierce, and unity across the city was only re-established when, during the post-match analysis (a pint in the West Brewery), a plan was hatched to team up and challenge Edinburgh. And so the annual fixture became two annual fixtures with great rivalry, but colleagues across all grades walked off the park knowing each other a little bit better. With the AAGBI coming to Edinburgh in 2015 we reached the inevitable conclusion that we should team up with Edinburgh and indeed all hospitals across Scotland and host a home nation’s cup. Who knows – perhaps at the end we can unite in British and Irish Lions tops and attend a world congress! The Wales, Ireland (as one team, like the rugby), Scotland and England (WISE) Anaesthetic cup will now be competed for on Wednesday the 23rd September 2015, after the first day of the AAGBI Annual Congress. It will be hosted at Hibernian Football Club’s training venue, which is a state-of-the-art facility just outside Edinburgh. All anaesthetists (male and female) are welcome and they should ensure they are members of the AAGBI to qualify to play. There are to be no ‘ringers’ (a ‘ringer’ is generally a theatre orderly with a past as a professional footballer…). An open sub policy will allow those who may have concerns regarding their fitness to dust off the boots and participate until their wisdom should return. You should feel free to play for the nation of your birth or nation where you now work. If you work in the UK but are not of a home nation’s heritage then please join in and approach the nation where you currently work. If you are outwith the UK, approach any of us (unless your surname is Messi in which case you should use the Scotland contact). The tournament will start at 1820 hrs and consist of a cup format with a winners and losers final. Each team would therefore play two matches – a qualifying match (2 x 25min halves) and either a 3rd or 4th place play-off (2 x 30 min halves). Penalties will be used in case of a draw at full-time. A large squad of players making use of an open sub policy will allow more of us to take part and stamina to become less of an issue. The target: The AAGBI wants to raise £96,000 which will buy 600 Lifebox Pulse Oximeters over the next 2 years - the same as the number of Team GB athletes attending the Olympic and Paralympic Games in Rio de Janeiro in 2016. Help us to reach the target! Join the campaign and become a Lifeboxes for Rio fundraiser So, if you are keen to contribute to this good cause and get involved please do not hesitate to use the relevant contact from the list on the right and declare your interest. Finally, if there are any referees who would like to contribute, could they make themselves known by using the Scotland contact? Bake, bike ride, run or walk – or devise your own fundraising concept. www.aagbi.org/lifeboxesforrio Fame may beckon if the match report meets the exacting publication standards of Anaesthesia News. AAGBI Foundation: Registered as a charity in England & Wales no. 293575 and in Scotland no. SC040697 Lifebox: Registered as a charity in England & Wales (1143018) Rio_Poster.indd 1 Contacts Wales: Pl refe ayers William Harrop-Griffiths dec rees and awhg@mac.com la p rele re int lease e van Ireland: r t co est to Colm Keane nta ct colmpkeane@hotmail.com Scotland: Graeme Hilditch graeme.hilditch@gmail.com England: Fraser Dunsire fraserdunsire@nhs.net General Enquiries: Michael Macmillan mhmacmillan@aol.com AAGBI contact Mathew Checketts mathew_checketts@mac.com It is hoped that this event will carry on the good work of the AAGBI in raising funds for the AAGBI fundraising campaign Lifeboxes for Rio. Each player would be expected to pay an entrance fee to cover expenses and obtain sponsorship. In addition we are looking at other fundraising initiatives including a sweepstake on the result, opportunity to be a spectator and strips available for sale. The aim: To save thousands of lives around the world where patients are at risk of death from hypoxia. 66 Team from the Western Infirmary, Glasgow 19/01/2015 10:31 Anaesthesia AnaesthesiaNews NewsAugust August2015 2015••Issue Issue337 337 Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 7 WSM_A5_Flyer.pdf 1 08/06/2015 15:35 The Needle-Free Non-Injectable Arterial Connector (NIC) European Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education (EACCME) has been applied for C 13 -15 JANUARY 2016 M Y CM MY CY CMY K Taking place over three days and offering: • Keynote lectures • core topics • poster competition • extensive industry exhibition • networking opportunities Paradoxically never events are fortunately rare, yet all too common. When they do occur the effects can be devastating for patients, distressing for healthcare workers and institutions may suffer considerable reputational damage. In a national survey, 28.5% of ICU directors reported having experienced mis-administration of medication into the arterial line at their trust.1 While education, labelling, training, audit and reporting structures are important, it is essential that, where possible, devices are developed to provide engineered solutions to eliminate otherwise inevitable human errors. Historically, as a specialty, anaesthesia can be congratulated above all others in this regard. AAGBI AAGBI INNOVATION INNOVATION Annual AAGBI Prize forInnovation Innovation TheThe Annual AAGBI Prize for in Anaesthesia, Critical Careand andPain Pain in Anaesthesia, Critical Care The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland invites applications for the 2016 AAGBI Prize for Innovation in Anaesthesia, Critical Care and Pain. This prize is open to all anaesthetists, intensivists and pain specialists based in Great Britain and Ireland. The emphasis is on new ideas contributing to patient safety, high quality clinical care and improvements in the working environment. The entries will be judged by a panel of experts in respective fields. Applicants should complete the application form that can be found on the AAGBI website www.aagbi.org/research/innovation. The closing date for applications is Wednesday 30 September 2015. Three prizes will be awarded and the winners will be invited to present their work and collect theirwww.aagbi.org/research/innovation prizes at the Winter Scientific Meeting in London on 15 January 2016. www.aagbi.org/research/innovation Kindly sponsored by: The Needle-Free Non-Injectable Arterial Connector (NIC; Amdel Medical, Liverpool, UK) eliminates the accidental administration of medication into the arterial line. Developed by a team of clinicians at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Kings Lynn, this simple device utilises the combination of a stop-valve and a unidirectional valve within the inner chamber. This combination physically prevents the injection of fluid, but permits sampling from the arterial line. The physical barrier also prevents bacterial ingress into the arterial line hub, reduces accidental blood spillage and supports the EU needle free directive. It is compatible with all arterial luer sampling sets. National policy detailed in the NHS document Innovation for Health and Wealth,2 seeks to harness grass roots NHS innovation and support UK businesses. Supporting this policy, the Eastern Academic Health Science Network has been instrumental in facilitating the implementation of the NIC into ICUs and theatres in 11 Trusts in the East of England. The study showed a 79% implementation rate over 6 months. Overall the NIC was extremely well received. A survey of healthcare staff showed that 96% said the NIC improved identification of the arterial hub and 81% wanted to continue using the connector after the trial period because of ease of use and in recognition of improved safety for their patients. An independently commissioned health economic evaluation demonstrated that while providing benefits, the NIC was also cost-effective, leading to a saving of £25,691 over 11 Trusts during this 6 month period. Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 Despite proven benefits and cost-effectiveness, new devices are notoriously difficult to introduce into the NHS due to complex and inconsistent local procurement decision making processes. Alongside our publication in Anaesthesia,3 winning 1st prize in the AAGBI Innovation Award (2015) has provided invaluable support and a seal of approval from peers for the NIC connector. The prize money has helped fund further research into arterial line safety, including the glucose problem,4 which has only been partially addressed and is also open to an engineered solution. Personally this award has supported my doctorate at the University of Cambridge examining Engineered Solutions to Never Events and has gained me a highly coveted place as a fellow on the NHS Innovator Accelerator Programme, allowing the opportunity to implement the patient safety benefits of the NIC both nationally and internationally. Maryanne Mariyaselvam Clinical Research Fellow Addenbrooke’s NHS Foundation Trust, Cambridge University Hospitals The Queen Elizabeth NHS Foundation Trust, Kings Lynn Conflict of interest The Queen Elizabeth Hospital, King’s Lynn NHS Trust holds the patent and has been supported by NHS Innovations East and by a grant from the Eastern Academic Health Science Network. References 1. Mariyaselvam M, Wijewardena G, Hutton A, Young P. Complications of accidental intra-arterial injections. Anaesthesia 2014; 69 (Suppl): 78. 2. Department of Health. Innovation Health and Wealth. http://www.institute. nhs.uk/images/documents/Innovation/Innovation%20Health%20and%20 Wealth%20-%20accelerating%20adoption%20and%20diffusion%20in%20 the%20NHS.pdf (accessed 10/6/15). 3. Mariyaselvam M, Heij R, Laba D, et al. Description of a new non-injectable connector to reduce the complications of arterial blood sampling. Anaesthesia 2015; 70: 51–5. 4. Problems with infusions and sampling from arterial lines. Supporting information for the Rapid Response Report. National Patient Safety Agency. July 2008. NPSA/2008/RRR006. http://www.nrls.npsa.nhs.uk/ resources/?entryid45=59891 (accessed 10/6/2015). 9 Anaesthesia & Cri-cal Care Update SAFETY MATTERS 9th & 10th October 2015 Hilton Warwick/Stra:ord-‐Upon-‐Avon Standards Committee work the leading centre in the delivery of awake upper limb regional anaesthesia in the uK presents: 12th royal Derby Hospital upper Limb regional anaesthesia Course thursday 26 November 2015 Workshops: Friday, 9th October, 2015 (6 CPD Credits) • Airway: Awake intuba9on Airway Ultrasound, ORSIM simulator • Focused Intensive Care Echo • Total Intravenous Anaesthesia • Ultrasound Guided Regional Anaesthesia royal Derby Hospital We work on the premise “the right block in the right place works every time!” the programme is dedicated to upper limb regional anaesthesia with an emphasis on practical, hands-on ultrasound training experience. Scien-fic Programme: Saturday 10th October, 2015 (6 CPD Credits) Course features: Live theatre link demonstrating techniques of upper limb blocks Small group workshops on scanning techniques on human models Practical hands-on training in probe handling and needling techniques on animal models and gel-phantoms Course Organisers: Dr Adrian Searle and Dr Zahid Sheikh CME approved 5 points Application forms and more information from: Course fee: £150 Course secretary Mrs. Shirley Goddard shirley.goddard@nhs.net tel. 01332 787195 Royal Derby Hospital, Anaesthetic Office, Uttoxeter Road, Derby DE22 3NE Sponsored by:G16418/0415 • • • • • • • Shape of Training Prepara9on for Consultant Post Advances in Cri9cal Care Updates in Bariatric Anaesthesia What’s new in Airway Management Anaesthesia Conundrums Free Paper presenta9ons For further details and registra9on please visit www.baoia.co.uk Organised by: Bri9sh Associa9on of Indian Anaesthe9sts (BAOIA) It has been my pleasure to work with many experts on the AAGBI Standards Committee during my time on Council. I write this in the hope that I can ignite a flame of interest among some of our younger members to help continue the vital, yet little-publicised work that is done by a dedicated band of heroes, some of whom are in part supported by AAGBI grants. Standards work hit the national headlines with neuraxial connector development several years ago, but they are just a small part of ‘small bore connector’ work, which in turn is just a fraction of the ever-evolving Standards that shape our work environment. A browse through the International Organization for Standardization’s (ISO) catalogue1 reveals the wide spectrum of items subject to standards, and you can find anaesthetic and respiratory equipment at 121. Therein lies ISO 26825:2008 ‘Anaesthetic and respiratory equipment - User-applied labels for syringes containing drugs used during anaesthesia - Colours, design and performance’, which may be vital for the reduction of wrong drug errors and has been discussed in several forums. ISO 4135:2001 ‘Anaesthetic and respiratory equipment - Vocabulary’ is settled and published, but ISO/CD 19223 ‘Lung ventilators and related equipment - Vocabulary and semantics’ remains in development. This standard introduces a number of new terms to the description of ventilation modes and ventilator/patient interaction, with commendable intention to reduce the scope for confusion, particularly as different manufacturers use many of the current terms with a different meaning. The AAGBI approves of standardisation and feedback from members would be invaluable. ISO/TC 210 is ‘Quality management and corresponding general aspects for medical devices’ within which we find ISO/DIS 803696 ‘Small bore connectors for liquids and gases in healthcare applications - Part 6: Connectors for neuraxial applications’. At the time of writing, I can see that voting has closed on this Standard, and the anticipated date of publication is December 2015. California is going to mandate that all neuraxial connectors meet the ISO standard within 6 months of publication, and so manufacturers will be racing to supply that market. In the UK, I would expect we will start to see ISO Standard connectors later in 2016. TC121/SC1 – ‘Breathing attachments and Anaesthetic machines’. Terry Longman chairs the UK delegation to ISO and keeps the AAGBI updated with developments. Terry is also a vital messenger of our views and concerns to various organisations who work on Standards. Reports to the Standards Committee can be found on our website.3 Why not make them part of your regular reading? Perhaps you’ll be both entertained and inspired. Dr David Scott chairs several BSI committees. Ever a practical man, David has recently drawn our attention to the importance of standards concerning the relative humidity in an operating theatre: ‘at every opportunity I point out that condensing atmospheres are common in my [Scottish] practice, especially in the home healthcare area. Equipment should, in my opinion, be capable of withstanding condensation without failing’. Dr Bill Boaden attended the June 2014 meeting of the ISO TC/121 in Incheon, South Korea. Bill is a member of British Standards Institute’s CH 121/SC1, the equivalent of ISO committee ISO/ Anaesthesia News News August August 2015 2015 •• Issue Issue 337 337 Anaesthesia Dr Harvey Livingstone was also in South Korea. He spent most of his time in the SC2 ‘Airways and related equipment’ meeting and was appointed to the drafting committee to prepare the resolutions to be submitted. Dr Philip Bickford-Smith, a co-designer of the Neurax connector system, is involved in practical testing of equipment. The British Anaesthetic and Respiratory Equipment Manufacturers Association (BAREMA) are represented on the AAGBI Standards Committee and Mr Paul Dixon currently provides reports from an industry perspective. For my part, I have enjoyed working with NHS England’s Small Bore Connector Clinical Advisory Group chaired by Dr Paul Sharp.2 As we approach a critical time of change, risks to patients are increased as incompatible connectors may find themselves in the same place at the same time. I’d strongly advise members to visit this website regularly over the next year or two. We are in no doubt that Standards work is vital to the safety of patients in Great Britain and Ireland, yet funding for NHS clinician participation is now the responsibility of commissioners. Unsurprisingly, obtaining that money is difficult or impossible. Earlier this year the President wrote to the Chief Medical Officer for the UK Government who replied that standards work is included in the national work for the benefit of UK healthcare systems that should be funded by local commissioners out of their allocations. Tom Woodcock Chair, Standards Committee References 1. 2. 3. International Organization for Standardization Standards catalogue. http:// www.iso.org/iso/home/store/catalogue_tc.htm NHS England. The safe introduction of medical devices with new small bore connectors into use in the NHS. http://www.england.nhs.uk/ourwork/ patientsafety/medical-device-incidents/small-bore-connectors/ (accessed 10/6/15). AAGBI Standards Committee. http://www.aagbi.org/safety/safety-andstandards-committee/committees/standards-committee 11 11 Lectures from GAT 2015 are now available to view The template is easy to use allowing you to reflect on the conference as a whole or on individual lectures. Step-by-step guide on how to reflect using the site: Step 1. Go to www.aagbi.org/education Step 2. Click on the ‘Learn@AAGBI’ box Step 3. Log in note: you will need your AAGBI membership number and password Step 4. From the search page select your required option Step 5. From the list select the video that you wish to reflect on Northern Ireland SAS Group Meeting Step 6. After watching the whole video, open the reflective learning form and complete it Step 7. If you are happy with what you have written, click on ‘Submit form’, or if you would like to add more later on, click ‘save draft’. This will upload into the ‘My CPD Area’ as either ‘draft’ or a completed ‘Submitted Reflective Note’. Go to www.aagbi.org/education and use Learn@AAGBI for your reflections at our meetings, and for your ongoing CPD and exam preparation. Learn_Anews_Aug.indd 1 Photograph ©spumador - Sunset over Peace Bridge of Derry, Northern Ireland Learn@AAGBI Northern Ireland may be small geographically but it has a lively and proactive SAS group. Formed in 2008 to try and add to the specific educational needs of SAS doctors who, for various reasons, were finding difficulty in meeting their CPD targets, it has gone from strength to strength over the years. 22/06/2015 14:43 It is a great way of getting together with others of the same grade to discuss work, opportunities, and changes in the delivery of healthcare as it pertains to us. We are lucky that our group comprises an AAGBI rep (yours truly), a Royal College rep and a BMA rep so that when we get together we can discuss any revisions that have occurred plus the opportunity to consider any matters which concern us as a group. These can then be brought up at the relevant committees which allow us a voice at local and national level. At present Northern Ireland has five large teaching hospitals and five DGHs with SAS doctors employed in all of them. Some jobs are pure ICU, some pure anaesthetics but most jobs are a mix of the two, many with an out-of-hours commitment. We can be the most senior doctors immediately available so we are keen to keep our skills up. Our meeting this year was held at Altnagelvin Hospital in Londonderry and 16 delegates attended. We try to have at least one person per hospital so that they can disseminate any information to as wide an audience as possible. The meeting was approved for 5 CPD points by the RCoA and was divided into two sessions. present case histories of difficult patients. There was a prize, this year won for the presentation on ‘Partial Subarachnoid Block at Caesarean Section’. Finally there was an appraisal workshop with the opportunity to see what is relevant and useful to include for Revalidation. At the close of the meeting there was a group dinner at a local restaurant and further informal discussion of life as an SAS doctor. It was also suggested that next year’s overall theme could be all things paediatric. In conclusion I would say that a local meeting has many benefits including tailored CPD, close proximity to home and an opportunity to meet with the people you have most in common with. It is also a way of finding out the good working practices available in other hospitals that could improve your own! Cathy Callaghan The morning session had a CPR simulation scenario to allow all the delegates to practice their ALS skills and a difficult airway station where candidates could practice low skill fibreoptic intubation and emergency tracheostomy skills with a manikin. The afternoon session consisted of a talk on management of the obese parturient and the opportunity for attendees to submit and Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 13 Brugada syndrome: resources for the anaesthetist It is tempting to dismiss rare eponymous syndromes as small print; interesting problems, but of little practical relevance given the small probability of seeing a patient with one on your theatre list. That is until the surgeons list a patient with a rare and potentially life-threatening cardiac abnormality during your weekend emergency theatres shift. an anaesthetic plan for the patient was formulated. Anaesthesia was induced with external defibrillator paddles present, using a combination of 1 mcg.kg-1 fentanyl and 5 mg.kg-1 thiopentone. Rocuronium 1 mg.kg-1 and 4mg.kg-1 sugammadex were used for muscle paralysis and reversal, respectively, thereby avoiding the theoretical arrhythmia risk with neostigmine. The peri-operative period was uneventful with no ECG changes detected. The patient was then extubated, recovered and received continuous ECG monitoring for the first 24 hours following surgery. that will be practical and valuable for anaesthetists caring for BrS patients on an international scale. I would like to commend the diligent and prompt response of Dr Postema, who has managed to make an already excellent resource even better. Clear, concise and careful recommendations are an important part of preparing for the anaesthetic management of patients with unfamiliar conditions in emergency situations. The care of BrS patients is clearly benefiting from the ongoing work and I would urge readers to take an overview of the information provided on the website. The website (http://www.brugadadrugs.org) and associated letter were vital resources in helping to plan the anaesthetic management of a patient with BrS, particularly in the context of providing simple recommendations in a time-dependent scenario. However it occurred to me that even greater value for anaesthetists, in similar positions to my own, could be gained with further clarification and additions to this resource. The Advisory Board at BrugadaDrugs.org would love to hear about your case experience with BrS. Feel free to contact them via: http://www.brugadadrugs.org/about The patient I saw had no ICD, but did show me the letter from his wallet, given to him by his cardiologist and produced by http://www. brugadadrugs.org, of medications that should be avoided in BrS. The list includes a number of anaesthetic and analgesic drugs, such as propofol, ketamine, tramadol and local anaesthetic agents. After a more detailed reading of the website, alongside case reports and several review articles (including Kloesel and Ackermann5), 14 Typical CG from a patient with Brugada syndrome Peter M. E Odor ST5, Department of Anaesthesia, East Surrey Hospital, UK Pieter1G. Type BPostema rugada ECG pattern with coved type ST segments (arrows) in the right precordial Department of Cardiology, University of Amsterdam, the Netherlands and V2 and in leads placed one intercostal space above V1 and V2 (V1ic3 and V2ic3). Oth specific) features of the Brugada ECG that are shown are the prolonged PR interval and w ECG from a patient with Brugada syndrome the Typical QRS w ith rECG ight ventricular delay. Type 1 Brugada pattern with coved type ST segments (arrows) in the right precordial leads V1 and V2 and in leads placed I saw a 35-year-old male with Brugada syndrome (BrS), who was listed for a laparoscopic emergency appendectomy. Although I had heard the term ‘Brugada’ back in medical school, I had little memory of exactly how the syndrome should influence anaesthetic management. Luckily I had some time to prepare and the patient came complete with a list, produced from his wallet, of drugs that should be avoided in his condition. Brugada syndrome is genetic cardiac conduction disease, which can lead to the development of ventricular arrhythmias and sudden death in otherwise fit, young individuals.1 Brugada syndrome is uncommon, with an estimated prevalence of approximately 1:2000,1,2 but not so rare that some awareness of the condition isn’t important for the general anaesthetist. The ECG of a BrS patient typically has a characteristic ST elevation in the right precordial leads (V1-V2 in the standard 4th intercostal space and in V1-V2 in higher intercostal spaces) with or without a right bundle branch block.1 However this pattern may not always be present or is only detected when pharmacologically provoked. Importantly, drugs with sodium channel blocking properties should be avoided in BrS as they can trigger ventricular arrhythmias.3 Fever, a notable risk in the septic patient on my theatre list, is another potential precipitant of arrhythmias.4 There are not many drugs available to prevent arrhythmic events in BrS except for quinidine, therefore implantable cardioverter defibrillators are recommended in those at high risk of arrhythmias. Written consent was gained from the patient for publication of details regarding this case. References 1. Priori SG, Wilde AA, Horie M, et al. HRS/EHRA/APHRS Expert Consensus Statement on the Diagnosis and Management of Patients with Inherited Primary Arrhythmia Syndromes. Heart Rhythm 2013; 10: e85-e108. 2. Postema PG. About Brugada syndrome and its prevalence. Europace 2012; 14: 925–8. 3. Postema PG, Wolpert C, Amin AS, et al. Drugs and Brugada syndrome patients: review of the literature, recommendations, and an up-to-date website. Heart Rhythm 2009; 6: 1335–41. 4. Amin AS, Meregalli PG, Bardai A, Wilde AA, Tan HL. Fever increases the risk for cardiac arrest in the Brugada syndrome. Annals of Internal Medicine 2008; 149: 216–8. 5. Kloesel B, Ackerman MJ, Sprung J, Narr BJ, Weingarten TN. Anesthetic management of patients with Brugada syndrome: a case series and literature review. Canadian Journal of Anaesthesia 2011; 58: 824–36. one intercostal space above V1 and V2 (V1ic3 and V2ic3). Other (but less specific) features of the Brugada ECG that are shown are the prolonged PR interval and widening of the QRS with right ventricular delay. I II Sternal angle V1 V2 I contacted Dr Pieter Postema, University of Amsterdam and lead author of the website, with my thoughts. Following the course of several email correspondences, sharing references and ideas, there is now a new page on the website, presented alongside an updated patient letter (available in a range of language translations). This new page provides a set of easy-to-follow recommendations for emergency anaesthetic management of BrS and is universally accessible at http://www.brugadadrugs.org/emergencies Only a limited number of case reports and experimental studies have been conducted with anaesthetic drugs in BrS. Furthermore there may be large variability in terms of the response to certain drugs and conditions, such as fever. These recommendations are pragmatic, but not a substitute for clinical judgment in individual patient care. V1ic3 V1 ic3 V2 V1 V2 ic3 V3 V4 V5 V6 V4 Alternative lead placement to enhance Brugada pattern recognition V2ic3 V6 10 mm/mV 25 mm/s 10 mm It is satisfying to reflect that my management of a single patient with BrS has prompted the further development of a clinical resource Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 15 ABSTRACTS FOR PRESENTATION AT AAGBI WSM LONDON 2016 You are invited to submit an abstract for poster presentation at WSM London in January 2016. The deadline for submission is 23:59 on Monday 31 August 2015 and further instructions and information can be found on our WSM microsite: www.wsmlondon.org C M Y CM AT ANNUAL CONGRESS, EDINBURGH 23-25 SEPT 2015 After the deadline, a preliminary review of the abstracts received will determine which ones are accepted for poster presentation. MY CY CMY All accepted abstracts will be published in Anaesthesia in the form of a fully referenceable online supplement (NB Editor-in-Chief reserves the right to refuse publication, e.g. where there are major concerns over ethics and/or content). K Authors of the best poster(s) will be awarded ‘Editors’ Prizes’. If you have any queries, please contact the AAGBI Secretariat on 020 7631 1650 (option 3) or secretariat@aagbi.org DIFFICULT AIRWAY SOCIETY AIRWAY REVALIDATION COURSE 13 Oct 2015 Venue: Medical Education Training Centre, Kirklands Hospital, Fallside Rd, Bothwell, Glasgow, G71 8BB Local coordinator - Dr Raj Padmanabhan, Consultant Anaesthetist, NHS Lanarkshire CPD approved meeting 5 CPD points What you need to know about safe Airway Management Following on from the very successful National Audit Project 4 (NAP4), Airway Leads Day, and several new ‘Airway’ guidelines, Difficult Airway Society is pleased to announce the second of a series of Airway Revalidation Courses to be held on 13 Oct 2015. The Course launched in collaboration with The RCoA is specifically designed to meet the airway CEPD requirements of UK Anaesthetists. It benefits from DAS standardisation, peer review and quality control. It is based on latest evidence and draws upon the experience and consensus of experts in airway management. DAS experts and high profile airway trainers have developed the full day course consisting of up-to-date lectures on various aspects of airway management which include • • • • • • • Airway Assessment Decision making in Airway management Choosing The Right Equipment Managing The Correct Technique Extubation Human Factors and Non Technical Skills Airway management outside theatre environment The Course is specifically designed to meet the Airway CPD requirements of UK anaesthetists. For more information and booking details visit www.das.uk.com Artistic anaesthetists are encouraged to submit their work to this year’s Art Exhibition. The aim of the exhibition is to showcase the talents of all anaesthetists and their families and help raise funds for the Lifeboxes for Rio campaign. Your work will need to be brought along yourself at the beginning of Congress. It would greatly assist us if you register your work in advance regardless as it will enable us to plan the exhibition and provide a catalogue of contributors for visitors’ use during the exhibition. In recent years the exhibition has been opened out to include all manner of art and craft other than the mainstay painting and photography. We have had jewellery, needlework, beading, sculpture, pots - there seems to be no end to the creativity of anaesthetists and their families! Please come along and support the Art Exhibition in Edinburgh in September. You can do this in so many ways. You can: • • • • • Contribute by exhibiting some of your art or craft Donate for sale any you can bear to part with Buy a stunning work of art created by a colleague for a fraction of the market cost Buy beautiful greetings cards Just simply visit and enjoy the talents of your colleagues For further information and a submission form, please visit www.annualcongress.org or contact members@aagbi.org. a e i s é h t s e ‘An ’ e u q s i r e r moind cing the SAFE es introdu Our experienc eaking Africa p -s h c n e r F in rse obstetric cou The Safer Anaesthesia From Education (SAFE) obstetric course, an initiative of the AAGBI, was designed in 2010. It is a 3-day intensive training course of lectures, small group discussions and simulation sessions aimed specifically to teach the safe conduct of obstetric anaesthesia for practitioners in developing countries. It has been taught throughout the world, particularly in English-speaking African countries including Uganda, Rwanda, Liberia and Ghana. In 2014, in association with Mercy Ships, we introduced the first SAFE obstetric courses in parts of French-speaking Africa; CongoBrazzaville in March and Madagascar in December. Worldwide, more than 800 women die every day due to complications in pregnancy and childbirth; that’s equivalent to 33 women per hour. Of these deaths, 99% are in developing countries and more than half are preventable.1 Although huge improvements in maternal mortality have been made in the last 20–30 years, it is a sobering fact that we remain woefully short of achieving the Millennium Development Goal 5’s aim ‘to reduce maternal mortality by threequarters by 2015’. The causes of these deaths are multifactorial and often deeply entrenched but include poverty, lack of adequate antenatal care, education, insufficient numbers and training of staff, as well as distance or other barriers to reaching care. Training healthcare workers to conduct safe obstetric anaesthesia is one key component to improving outcomes. Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 The SAFE obstetric course covers a range of topics including airway management, safe conduct of general and regional anaesthesia, resuscitation of the newborn and mother, and management of common obstetric emergencies including eclampsia, sepsis and haemorrhage. The course is evaluated by pre- and post-course MCQs and hands-on skills-testing. The aims are to improve knowledge and competence and empower anaesthetists to be a force for change in their hospitals, region and country. Both week-long trips involved a team of around ten teaching faculty members; a mix of both consultant and trainee anaesthetists and an obstetrician. In addition to the SAFE team, a group of at least four interpreters attended per day, from the UK, France, Australia and Canada, working alongside local interpreters. The trips began with a visit to local hospitals, with opportunities to speak to anaesthetic providers about their equipment, drugs and common experiences, before finalisation of last-minute course details. Pointe Noire, Congo-Brazzaville, 25th–27th March 2014 Congo-Brazzaville in Central Africa has just ten anaesthetic doctors for a population of 4.4 million, seven of whom work in the capital, Brazzaville. The majority of anaesthetics are therefore given by trained anaesthetic nurses or practitioners with little support. Maternal mortality currently stands at 410 per 100,000 live births,2 slightly below the average for Africa as a whole. In the UK this figure is 8 per 100,000.2 Running the first French-speaking SAFE obstetrics course involved significant prior translation of course material and lecture notes. 17 The course was also adapted, removing aspects which had been taught in-country in recent programmes to make allowances for the extra time required for translation, and because knowledge and experience of 'local timekeeping' meant it would not be realistic to cover all the information without prioritising key aspects! This was highlighted on day one when, after a heavy rainstorm overnight, early buses could not run due to flooding on the roads leading to a delayed start. Many of our teaching techniques – for example, using simulation with manikins – were very unfamiliar to the participants, but after only a short time we had all relaxed enough to learn, teach and have a good time. Particular highlights were discussing safe conduct of a rapid-sequence induction using intubating manikins, watching the participants manage faculty members having an eclamptic seizure and the infamous ’guess the blood loss quiz‘ when discussing massive obstetric haemorrhage. In all, 35 participants (25 anaesthetic nurses, three doctors and seven midwives and obstetricians) were trained on the course in Pointe Noire, the second largest city in Congo-Brazzaville. The MCQs showed a small improvement (66% pre-course vs 68% post-course) and a significant improvement in the skills assessments (4 to 6 out of 10). Feedback from the course was overwhelmingly positive; ‘In summary I can say that in 3 days I grew a year’ and ‘Our wish would be that simulation training seminars be performed every year’ were just two of the comments received. All candidates were given copies of the lectures, as well as a French textbook aimed specifically for anaesthetists working in resource poor locations. Antananarivo, Madagascar, 16th–18th December 2014 Madagascar is the fourth largest island in the world and situated 250 miles off the east coast of Africa. The population is estimated to be just over 22 million, with a physician to population ratio of just 2 per 10,000.3 The maternal mortality ratio is currently 440 per 100,000 live births3 and, although this is a significant improvement since 1990, it is almost double the 2009 figures before political instability.4 The course took place in the capital Antananarivo, located in the very centre of the island, in order to reach as many anaesthetic practitioners as possible. Fifty-five healthcare professionals attended the course, comprising 24 anaesthetic doctors, 15 anaesthetic nurses, as well as 16 obstetricians and midwives. There was a much higher ratio of doctors to nurses than had been the case in Congo-Brazzaville but often the variation in management was more notable between hospitals than between these groups. We found the addition of the midwives and obstetricians on the second and third days to be of particular benefit to the group when discussing issues surrounding communication and teamwork in the management of obstetric emergencies. There was a significant increase in both the MCQ results (average of 68.9% improved to 77.4%), and the skills test (4.8 out of 10, to 8), most notably demonstrated in the neonatal resuscitation scenario which improved from average 2.9 to 7.8 by the end of the course. Feedback for the course was again very positive; when asked if the course had helped to improve practice, and how likely they were to share the information learned they rated 9.4 and 9.7 out of 10, respectively. A further SAFE obstetrics course will run in Madagascar in 2015, and the hope is that a ‘Training of Trainers’ course will also run alongside this to teach some of the more impressive candidates to become faculty and lead to a sustainable teaching programme for the country. SEMINARS Summary Teaching on these courses has been a real privilege; the healthcare practitioners were engaged and keen to learn and improve standards, and we were humbled by their experiences and learnt many lessons from them. Small group work helped us to understand what it might be like to work in a hospital where perhaps 4–5 patients on a ward were suffering the complications of severe pre-eclampsia and eclampsia at any one time, or the regular devastation of seeing women presenting critically unwell due to unnecessary delay or being left to die because of being unable to afford simple, lifesaving treatments. It also allowed us to see novel methods of dealing with common healthcare problems; in Madagascar, for example, they had reduced delay and improved access to potentially lifesaving blood transfusions because patients are no longer required to pay, but instead must arrange for two people to donate blood for every unit used thus replenishing the supply. Working in a different language was probably the most significant challenge we faced, including the use of lay-interpreters. We stayed alert to ensure the correct message was passed on – one subtle example was explaining to a local interpreter that a ‘seizure in a pregnant patient’ could not be translated as ‘epilepsy’. But with the incredibly hard work of the interpreters and the nature of the course to use repetition of important points in different stations as a teaching tool, we were able to demonstrate improvements in knowledge and skills, showing this course can be run successfully in French. To see the courses in the Congo and Madagascar in action, please view the videos at http://vimeo.com/91066502 and https://vimeo. com/119803729 Acknowledgements Our special thanks to Mercy Ships who helped organise the course and supported us financially and logistically, particularly Dr Michelle White and Ms Krissy Close, and to the AAGBI and Mrs Thomson for additional sponsorship. Finally thanks to Dr Keith Thomson, Dr James Leedham, Dr Emma Halliwell and all the faculty and interpreters who helped make these first French-speaking SAFE obstetric courses such a success. Nikki Cox ST3, University Hospital Southampton Helen Howes ST5, Great Western Hospital, Swindon Savini Wijesingha ST4, Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh Further information about the SAFE Obstetric Anaesthesia Course can be found on the AAGBI website: www.aagbi.org/ international/safe-safer-anaesthesia-education References 1. WHO. Maternal mortality statistics. Updated May 2014. http://www.who.int/ mediacentre/factsheets/fs348/en/ (accessed 8/2/2015). 2. The World Bank. Maternal mortality ratio, 2014. http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/ SH.STA.MMRT (accessed 8/2/2015). 3. WHO. Madagascar: Factsheets of Health Statistics, 2010. http://www.aho.afro. who.int/profiles_information/images/c/cb/Madagascar-Statistical_Factsheet.pdf (accessed 8/2/2015). 4. WHO. Madagascar: Maternal and Perinatal Health Profile. http://www.who.int/ maternal_child_adolescent/epidemiology/profiles/maternal/mdg.pdf (accessed 8/2/2015). DATES FOR YOUR DIARY SEPTEMBER 2015 An introduction to obstetric regional analgesia and anaesthesia for trainees Quality improvement in emergency laparotomy Monday 07 September 2015 Wednesday 11 November 2015 Organisers: Dr Sunil Halder, Oxford & Prof Steve Yentis, London Trainees Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 Discounted fees apply OCTOBER 2015 Organiser: Dr Dave Saunders, Newcastle World Anaesthesia Society (WAS) seminar Thursday 12 November 2015 Organiser: Dr Bruce McCormick, Exeter One lung anaesthesia: Challenges and practical solutions Thursday 01 October 2015 Perioperative complications in anaesthesia – Prevention & cure Organiser: Dr Kate O’Connor, Bristol Thursday 19 November 2015 Organisers: Drs Jane Sturgess & Kamen Valchanov, Cambridge Difficult airways AAGBI Management & leadership course Monday 12 October 2015 Monday 23 & Tuesday 24 November 2015 Organiser: Dr Mark Sandby-Thomas, Cardiff Organiser: Dr Jonathan Price, London GAT: Consultant interview Tuesday 13 October 2015 Organiser: Dr Lyndsey Forbes, Dundee Trainees Wednesday 14 & Thursday 15 October 2015 Organisers: Dr Atul Gaur, Leicester & Dr Vijay Kumar, Scunthorpe Delegates can register for one or both days NOVEMBER 2015 Anaesthesia for trauma and orthopaedic surgery Monday 02 November 2015 Organisers: Dr Santhosh Babu, Manchester History - Anaesthesia & resuscitation in unusual environments: Past, present and future Tuesday 03 November 2015 Organiser: Dr Alistair McKenzie, Edinburgh Infectious outbreaks Wednesday 04 November 2015 Organisers: Dr Jonathan Handy & Prof Steve Yentis, London Perioperative management of the surgical patient with diabetes mellitus Organisers: Dr Nicholas Levy, Bury St Edmunds & Dr Bev Watson, Kings Lynn Special fees apply Ultrasound in anaesthesia 2 day spinal sonography Monday 09 November 2015 18 NOVEMBER 2015 Thursday 26 November 2015 Organiser: Dr Andrew McEwen, Torquay DECEMBER 2015 SAFE - Safer Anaesthesia From Education: Training of the trainers Monday 07 December 2015 Organiser: Dr Kate Grady, Manchester Anaesthesia for non-cardiac surgery in congenital heart disease - Paediatric anaesthesia Tuesday 08 December 2015 Organiser: Dr Raju Reddy, Birmingham Bleeding, clotting & haemorrhage Thursday 10 December 2015 Organiser: Dr Ravi Rao Baikady, London Venue: 9-10 Portland Place, W1B 1PR All AAGBI seminars are priced as listed below unless otherwise stated £133 - AAGBI members £88 - AAGBI trainee members £66.50 - Retired members £260 - Non-members All meetings & seminars are held at 21 Portland Place, London unless otherwise stated. Check availability and book online today www.aagbi.org/education Teaching primary trauma care in Mozambique Despite its many problems, the NHS is still highly regarded by many patients and healthcare professionals in Europe and further afield. The UK Department for International Development (DFID), and the Tropical Health Education Trust (THET) have established the Health Partnership Scheme (HPS) as a four-year programme to support developing health services in some of the world’s poorest countries. NHS staff who volunteer overseas are contributing to the advancement of global health. By gaining teaching experience, they return with skills and experiences that benefit the UK. The Primary Trauma Care Foundation (PTCF) is a non-profit nongovernment organisation set up in 1997 and currently supported by the HPS to go to ten countries in Africa. It trains doctors and other frontline healthcare professionals in the management of severely injured patients in resource poor settings. The PTCF aims to work alongside each country’s healthcare system, assessing healthcare needs and providing trauma procedure and teaching methodologies to facilitate the creation of locally sustainable training schemes for the care of trauma patients. So far the PTCF has run courses in over 60 countries worldwide. The PTC Manual, which is used to support the course, has been translated into 14 languages and can be downloaded from the web. 20 Each PTCF visit comprises a two day PTC course for those experienced in trauma management, a one day instructor course and then supervision and guidance for these newly trained local instructors to run their own two day locally delivered course with a new batch of trainees. The latest African operation of the PTCF is a collaboration between the PTCF and the College of Surgeons of East, Central and Southern Africa (COSECSA), facilitated by the COSECSA-Oxford Orthopaedic Link. The initial courses in each of the ten COSECSA countries have been delivered by NHS clinicians. Over the last two years nearly 45 courses have been conducted in these countries and that number is increasing. Mozambique is a Portuguese speaking country, rich in natural resources. It lies on the southeast coast of Africa bordering Tanzania, Malawi, Zambia, Zimbabwe, Swaziland and South Africa, with extensive tropical coastline along the Indian Ocean. As a result, its cuisine is famed, with sumptuous seafood, chicken and nuts, often spiced with piri-piri and garlic. After a turbulent period of civil war, multi-party elections were first held in 1994. Despite starting to capitalise on foreign investment, Mozambique’s gross domestic product per capita still ranks among the lowest in the world. The population is over 25 million with 1.2 million living in the capital Maputo.1 Only a proportion of the population has access to safe water and improved sanitation, 43% and 19% respectively, with these resources being more accessible to those who live in urban rather than rural areas.2 There are only three physicians per 100,000 people, one of the lowest doctor to patient ratios worldwide,3 and the country’s spending on healthcare per capita is a fraction of that spent in the developed world.4,5 It is therefore unsurprising that the average life expectancy remains one of the lowest in the world at just 53 years.6 The region also has the highest fatality rate from road trauma in the world. The World Health Organization Global Status Report on Road Safety in 2013 estimated that the annual number of road deaths in Mozambique to be 18.5 per 100,000 people, which is five times that seen in the UK.7 In addition there are also a significant number of patients that will sustain non-fatal injuries from road trauma. Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 In February 2013, we travelled to Maputo to conduct the first PTC course and have all subsequently returned as part of smaller groups to aid and facilitate the running of some of the local courses in Mozambique’s provinces, between us going to Beira, Pemba and Tete. In total UK instructors have attended five courses in Mozambique over the past two years. The Mozambiquan government is currently trying to reduce the impact of trauma nationally, implementing primary prevention strategies, such as traffic regulations, and improving the care received by trauma victims. Our presence coincided with these initiatives and was publicised heavily, helping to advertise and reinforce the importance of the above. on the responsibility themselves and our role became more supportive. There have been three courses so far that have been held using exclusively Mozambiquan faculty, which is encouraging progress. We hope that the Mozambiquan government will support the introduction of this course into the teaching curriculums for both doctors and clinical officers/technicians. Positive engagement from enthusiastic and dynamic local faculty provides hope that local health professionals can continue to sustain this project, disseminating it across Mozambique to improve the care of trauma patients throughout the country. The first trauma and instructor courses in Maputo were run in English but by using the newly qualified local instructors meant subsequent courses were taught predominantly in Portuguese (with translation when required for the UK instructors). Initially, while local faculty would teach the course content, all the administration, timing and co-ordination of the courses was left almost entirely to the UK faculty. Throughout the programme these tasks were increasingly delegated to the local faculty who ultimately took Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 21 Teaching primary trauma care in Mozambique Emma King Juan Graterol Being involved in PTC has been an incredibly rewarding experience. Participating in the scheme provided the perfect opportunity to combine my interests of teaching and medicine in a resource poor environment. It was with feelings of excitement and trepidation that I boarded the plane to Mozambique for the first time. When teaching in the UK I have been familiar with the local set up, the resources available and taken for granted that both faculty and candidates speak English. None of this could be guaranteed for the course in Mozambique. I would also be teaching experienced clinicians and technicians with a wealth of trauma experience that would greatly exceed my own. As an overseas-trained doctor I feel very passionate about this project. I would have been a willing recipient of this course had I stayed in Venezuela when I graduated from medical school. I need not have worried. Candidates had an attitude of mutual respect and a willingness to learn from each other's experiences. There was great interaction and the concept of ABCDE was readily acknowledged, appreciated and easily taught. The original candidates were then able to teach these concepts effectively in their own courses later in our stay. Seeing them take ownership of the course and the enthusiasm they had for running it was a real highlight for me. Experienced clinicians may be sceptical at first, which is why mutual respect is important. By recognising their expertise and encouraging them to contribute positively to the learning experience, they may incorporate it into their own teaching with a multiplying effect. Respect also includes adapting the course material to local circumstances; there is very little benefit in pretending to get a CT scan or FAST scan during the simulations or scenarios if those facilities are not currently available. The learning tools are usually those available at the host country. This makes it more realistic and relevant for participants but demands a degree of flexibility from the UK-based instructors. My Portuguese is somewhat limited but we were assured the whole course would be run in English. On our arrival it became clear that this was not the case. Throughout medical training we are frequently taught the importance of non-verbal communication. This experience has helped me truly appreciate its importance. It is amazing what can be conveyed by an individual’s body language and tone of voice. There were many additional challenges that arose in attempting to run a course abroad. There was a great deal of local excitement about the course, but the helpful attitude and desire to please did sometimes mean questions would be answered with what we wanted to hear, rather than the truth. Adapting and working to the relaxed 'African Time' ethos, although not always conducive to efficiency, was quite a refreshing change from the occasionally restrictive British expectations on time keeping. Working collaboratively with each other, adapting to local needs and finding solutions to problems as they arose, we were able to run excellent trauma courses that were enjoyed by all. It was rewarding to be involved in a project that gives local people the resources and skills to continue their own development. In doing so we hope it may have a lasting impact on trauma care throughout Mozambique. I learnt an incredible amount from this experience. I further developed my skills as a teacher and clinician but also renewed my appreciation for the NHS, the service it provides, the resources we all have available to us, and the quality of training we receive. I would thoroughly recommend getting involved. For further information regarding PTC visit www.primarytraumacare.org 22 22 There are two aspects of this model that I find particularly attractive: sustainability and respect. The main emphasis on the first course was to train local trainers who will continue cascading the ABCDE approach to trauma care. It is essential to involve local leaders for this type of project to get a firm hold on the ground and be able to stand on its own two feet once our brief visit ended. Local idiosyncrasies and cultural differences must be acknowledged and embraced; time keeping in tropical countries is not always as rigid as Brits would expect! A good deal of diplomacy, interpersonal skills and socialising in a less formal environment usually helps to ensure that positive links are formed – links that will be key to keep momentum and drive the project forwards. I am very pleased I had the opportunity to be part of the first PTC visit to Mozambique and would encourage everyone to get involved. It is an enriching experience on many levels. MSc in Anaesthesia (Perioperative) 1 year full-time or 2 years part-time Starting October 2015 in Medway (London in 42 mins by rail) A high quality programme which focuses on perioperative care and quality improvement. Our MSc in Anaesthesia (Perioperative) has been designed in collaboration with leading anaesthetists to ensure it meets the personal and professional development of anaesthetists working in the NHS and private sector. Practical sessions, lectures and research methodologies are used to cover: Quality improvement in anaesthesia Pre-assessment and risk stratification Intraoperative and postoperative care Find out more e: allison.allen@canterbury.ac.uk www.canterbury.ac.uk/pg/anaesthesia A AGBI TOPICS INCLUDE: Anaesthetists in training Clinical anaesthesia Clinical measurement/equipment GUIDELINES APP Contractual/job planning Elderly anaesthesia Ethics and law Haematology Human factors Independent practice 6 new guidelines recently added Irish anaesthetists Emma King ST7 in Anaesthesia, University Hospitals Bristol NHS Foundation Trust Thomas Hampton CT2 in Plastic Surgery, Queen Victoria Hospital, East Grinstead Juan Graterol Consultant in Anaesthesia and Pain Medicine, Royal Cornwall Hospital NHS Trust References 1. http://www.citypopulation.de/Mocambique.html (accessed 7/11/14). 2. http://www.unicef.org/mozambique/child_survival_2948.html (accessed 7/11/14). 3. http://www.usaid.gov/mozambique/global-health (accessed 6/11/14). 4. http://www.who.int/countries/moz/en/ (accessed 6/11/14). 5. http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.PCAP (accessed 6/11/14). 6. http://www.who.int/gho/countries/moz.pdf?ua=1 (accessed 6/11/14). 7. World Health Organization. Global Status Report on Road Safety 2013. http://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/road_safety_status/2013/en/ (accessed 7/11/14). Anaesthesia Anaesthesia News News August August 2015 2015 •• Issue Issue 337 337 Obstetric anaesthesia Resuscitation and trauma ntent Updates to existing co SAS anaesthesia Wellbeing FREEGBI FOR A A RS MEMBE Checklist for t anaesthetic equipmen ol Reflective learning to DOWNLOAD THE APP TODAY FOR APPLE AND ANDROID DEVICES www.aagbi.org/guidelines-app 25th National Acute Pain Symposium Thurs 10th & Fri 11th September 2015 Crowne Plaza Hotel, Chester The Nation's premier Acute Pain forum Plenty of interesting content for anyone involved in Acute Pain management See and hear what the innovators are doing around the country PCA’s : Old and New Pain in the ICU Management of Patients Addicted to Opiates - A Patient Story Role of the Clinical Psychologist in the Acute Pain Team Managing Acute Pain in the Trauma Patient from Roadside to Recovery & Beyond Shock of the Fall : Rib Fracture Management Functional Abdominal Pain - Inpatient Management Role of the Physical Therapist in Management of Surgical Patients with Acute Pain Essential Pain Management - Experience in Uganda Role of Ketamine in Modern Acute Pain Management Pain Service Involvement in MSK Service Redesign Poster Exhibition with short presentations by Competition winners Acute Pain Special Interest Group Meeting Please visit us at www.acutepainsymposium.co.uk for more information PLEASE JOIN US AT THIS LANDMARK EVENT Details & Bookings : Georgina Hall Tel : (0151) 522 0259 Mob : 07901 717 380 E-mail : medsymp@btinternet.com Registration Fees : Consultants NCCG SpR & SHO Nurses £345 £345 £275 £195 Arterial line safety – can we do better? Arterial lines play a significant role in monitoring accurate blood pressure, titrating drug treatments and obtaining blood samples for bedside and laboratory tests. Hence it is crucial for staff involved to be aware of factors influencing the management of these arterial lines. What happened? In August 2013, during the evening handover time in the emergency maternity theatre, an arterial line was inserted as part of the management of a severe post-partum haemorrhage prior to transfer of the patient to the intensive care unit. The arterial line was accidentally connected to an infusion pump with propofol attached and a few millilitres of propofol were administered before the error was detected. Fortunately, there was no harm to the patient. Comprehensive Trade exhibition Informal Delegate Dinner - Brazilian Restaurant A wonderful relaxed and friendly evening. A favorite amongst those who have attended before 8 CPD points from the Royal College of Anaesthetists applied for 24 Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 1. 2. 3. Why we think it happened 4. The cause was multifactorial. It was an emergency situation with high stress levels, several anaesthetists with varied experience were present, and it was changeover time. Although an experienced trainee, the person taking over was new to the hospital and unfamiliar with the local arterial line set-up, there was an unlabelled three-way tap on the arterial line set-up and the connections and tubing employed were similar to those used for other intravenous fluids. 5. Why did we ask the question? Following the above incident, we reviewed the literature about incidents involving arterial line management and currently available guidance on arterial line safety. There are a number of case reports of accidental intra-arterial injections1,2 as well as reports of other incidents3,4 relating to arterial lines. Hear about & see the new & existing Acute Pain related products Box 1: Summary of NPSA Rapid Response Report on Arterial lines in July 2008. These included two incidents in which death occurred following severe hypoglycaemia and neuroglycopenic brain injury. This was caused by glucose contamination of arterial line blood samples as a result of glucose containing solutions being attached to the arterial line flush bag.3,4 In 2008, the National Patient Safety Association (NPSA) published guidelines5 on arterial line management to improve safety (see Box 1). Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 6. Arterial blood sampling should be performed only by competent and trained staff. Arterial lines must be clearly identified by use of a labelling system such as continuous coloured lines. Any infusion attached to the arterial line must be prescribed and checked before administration. Further checks should be made at regular intervals such as shift handover. Only sodium chloride 0.9% should be used as the infusion fluid for arterial lines. Labels should clearly identify contents of infusion bags, even when pressure bags are used. More recently, the AAGBI published further guidance6 on blood sampling from arterial lines, reiterating NPSA guidance. Further, the AAGBI recommended use of closed arterial line sampling systems, pressurising devices designed to permit unimpaired inspection of the contained flush infusion bag and an unexpectedly high blood glucose should raise suspicion of sample contamination and prompt medical review prior to starting insulin. In addition, removing three times the dead space prior to blood sampling to prevent contamination of samples with flush fluid has been recommended.3,7 We took this opportunity to explore experiences of adverse events with arterial lines and to establish the level of awareness of the NPSA guidance among anaesthetists across Scotland. We also wanted to identify measures which different centres and individual anaesthetists take to minimise the risk of such events occurring, in the hope of adapting this knowledge and experience to reduce further risk within our own hospital. At the time of the survey, the NPSA guidance was the only national guidance available on arterial line management. 25 Scotland-wide survey on arterial line management Question 7: Have you ever had a near miss with use of arterial lines in theatre? Some examples are mentioned in Box 3. A set of questions were formed on the SurveyMonkey website and a link to the survey was distributed to all anaesthetic departments in Scotland to forward on to their individual anaesthetists. We received a total of 273 responses in 4 weeks which included 192 consultants, 32 SRs (ST5–7), 17 ST3–4s, 20 core trainees and 12 anaesthetists of other grades. After analysing the survey results, we reviewed practice within our anaesthetic department and implemented the following changes: Change 1: Arterial line labelling Prior to the incident described, our arterial line set up at the patient end in theatre included a short extension with three-way tap (Figure 1). Results Question 1: Are you aware of the 2008 NPSA guidance on use of arterial lines? What did we do? Question 5: What volume of dead space do you remove prior to sampling? Less than one-third of the respondents were aware of NPSA guidance. Figure 1: Three-way tap Box 3: Examples of near misses related to arterial line management • • • Question 2: How do you label arterial lines? • ‘Other’ answers were mostly along the lines of specific volumes such as 10 ml, 5 ml, ml, ‘a couple of ml’ and ‘dead space and a bit’ Question 6: Have you experienced any critical incident with arterial lines in theatre? Some examples are mentioned in Box 2. • • • • • Nearly attached the remifentanil infusion instead of the transducer Near accidental drug injection (flucloxacillin, atracurium, metariminol) 5% dextrose used as flush bag - not picked up until patient in ICU. No harm occurred. Injected metaraminol. Realised when the continuous BP trace was transiently lost and hastily aspirated several ml before it reached the patient Taking over case, unlabelled line taped to pillow. Noticed it pulsing before injection so took the three-way tap out Inadvertent dextrose flush got picked up before insulin given for hyperglycaemia Almost did intra-arterial injection. Spotted error just before pushing plunger. Distracted. Midwife hung metronidazole on arterial flush line and contacted me as drip not dripping Absentmindedness - almost connecting a drug filled syringe to the 3 way port instead of the IV line - realised before injection occurred Propofol infusion was attached to this three-way tap during the incident. These connectors were removed from use with arterial lines. However, we felt errors could still occur with the subsequent set-up (Figure 2) and it did not comply with the national guidance that recommended clear labelling of lines, for example with colour. Figure 2: Arterial line set-up ‘Other’ methods included: ‘Arterial’ stickers applied to dressings/Red line on tubing/Red three-way taps/Red bung Question 3: Do you ever check what type of fluid is connected to the transducer before connecting? Finally, we asked for any other comments, and some interesting responses are shown in Box 4. Box 2: Examples of critical incidents related to arterial line management Box 4: Other comments • • • • • Question 4: Where do you take blood samples from usually? • • • • • • • • ‘Other’ methods in this case included ‘bung on end of arterial line itself’, ‘sampling port at patient end’ and ‘three-way tap halfway’ 26 Patient taken back to theatre for surgical removal of an arterial line fragment that sheared off in recovery. Required a venous patch Incorrect flush bag used: 0.18% NaCl + 4% glucose Disconnection, limb ischaemia, antibiotic mistakenly given, air in line, diluted samples etc. Accidental injection of medications (heparin, magnesium, atracurium, cefuroxime) Cerebral air embolism. Amputation of arm following intra-arterial injection of thiopentone ITU patient – hypoxic brain damage from too much insulin guided by falsely elevated blood glucose readings (glucose used for flush bag) Loose connection hidden by drapes leading to some blood loss Brachial haematoma from heparin flush overdose Moderate ischaemia of the hand at the end of surgery which resolved in the recovery room after removal of the arterial line Vented cap put on open three-way tap at transducer causing minor blood loss Treated high blood pressure because transducer had fallen to floor Surgeons using intra-operative clamp, trapped the arterial line tubing between the clamp and the operating table, transecting the tubing completely. A flat arterial line trace prevented significant blood loss Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 • • • • • • • • Danger arises when more than one anaesthetist in theatre and they do things differently Recommend closed sampling technique to avoid risk of contaminating sample with dead space fluid which leads to inaccurate results and may have contributed to hypoglycaemia death in ICU case Easy, clearly attached labels (standardised for ease of recognition) would seem very sensible Maybe we need incompatible connectors as for central neuraxial kit We should check the fluid. We should have only one sample tap at the transducer. Drugs should never be given at the transducer even if into CVP line We also prescribe the fluid on the fluid chart and there is a red label on the flush bag, which says arterial line flush on it Huge variability in practice is a risk factor for incidents or nearmisses, and that an accepted way of standardising labelling and check listing would improve safety, which would be a welcome development Why can't manufacturers pre-label the lines/taps? Standardisation of kit across sites would be helpful Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 The department reached a consensus view that alternative arterial line tubing featuring a clear red line down the tubing along with red three-way taps (Figure 3) should be introduced, initially in theatres with the plan to expand their use in other areas where arterial lines are routinely used. Figure 3: New arterial line set up 27 Change 2: Flush bag prescribing and recording Our second challenge was to explore ways of improving our process of checking and prescribing the flush bag. There was much discussion about how best to ensure that the flush bag is prescribed on fluid charts without causing confusion to total daily fluid balance. It was agreed it would be best to develop a sticker (Figure 4) for the theatre fluid chart which states that fluid is for purely arterial administration and is 0.9% sodium chloride solution. Prior to administration this bag should be checked and the chart signed by two members of staff (nursing and/or medical). A compliance audit will be carried out regularly and a monthly chart displayed. Figure 4: Colour coded arterial line prescription sticker on a fluid balance chart Discussion The literature shows that critical incidents with arterial lines continue to occur and can lead to death or serious harm. A third of anaesthetists who responded to our survey had experienced either a critical incident or near miss with an arterial line. In addition, there is still a lack of awareness of the potential problems with arterial lines and a wide variety in current practice in reducing risk. We have used this as an opportunity to increase awareness of the risks this piece of monitoring equipment can pose within our own department and have brought in two simple changes to our current practice that we hope will reduce future risk and improve patient safety. Disclaimer: This survey was presented as a poster an NHS Scotland Event last year. Alison Kearsley ST7 Anaesthetics Pavan Raju Consultant Anaesthetist Ninewells Hospital & Medical School, Dundee References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Holley HS, Cuthrell L. Intraarterial injection of propofol. Anesthesiology 1990; 73: 183–4. Samanta S, Samanta S. Accidental intra arterial injection of diclofenac sodium and their consequences: report of two cases. Anaesthesia, Pain & Intensive Care 2013; 17: 102–3. Gupta KJ, Cook TM. Accidental hypoglycaemia caused by an arterial flush drug error: a case report and contributory causes analysis. Anaesthesia 2013; 68: 1178–87. Sinha S, Jayaram R, Hargreaves CG. Fatal neuroglycopaenia after accidental use of a glucose 5% solution in a peripheral arterial cannula flush system. Anaesthesia 2007; 62: 615–20. National Patient Safety Agency. Infusions and sampling from arterial lines. Rapid Response Report. NPSA/2008/RRR006 Woodcock TE, Cook TM, Gupta KJ, Hartle A. Arterial line blood sampling: preventing hypoglycaemic brain injury. Anaesthesia 2014, 69: 380–5. Burnett RW, Covington AK, Fogh-Anderson N, et al. Recommendations on whole blood sampling, transport, and storage for simultaneous determination of pH, blood gases, and electrolytes. International Federation of Clinical Chemistry Scientific Division. Journal of the International Federation of Clinical Chemistry1994; 6: 115–20. EVELYN BAKER MEDAL Digested August 2015 AN AWARD FOR OUTSTANDING CLINICAL COMPETENCE Performance of manual ventilation: how to define its efficiency in bench studies? A review of the literature The Evelyn Baker award was instigated by Dr Margaret Branthwaite in 1998, dedicated to the memory of one of her former patients at the Royal Brompton Hospital. The award is made for outstanding clinical competence, recognising the ‘unsung heroes’ of clinical anaesthesia and related practice. The defining characteristics of clinical competence are deemed to be technical proficiency, consistently reliable clinical judgement and wisdom and skill in communicating with patients, their relatives and colleagues. The ability to train and enthuse trainee colleagues is seen as an integral part of communication skill, extending beyond formal teaching of academic presentation. Nominees should normally still be in clinical practice. Khoury A, De Luca A, Sall FS, Pazart L, Capellier G. Last year the award was won by Dr Sally Millett (Worcester). Details of previous award winners can be found on the website http://www.aagbi. org/about-us/awards/evelyn-baker-medal Nominations are now invited for the award, which will be presented at WSM London in January 2016. Members of the AAGBI can nominate any practising anaesthetist who is also a member of the Association. Examples of successful previous nominations are available on request. Nominations should include an indication that the nominee has broad support within their department. The nomination, accompanied by a citation of up to 1000 words, should be sent to the Honorary Secretary at HonSecretary@aagbi.org by 17:00 on Friday 18 September 2015 Reliability of manikin-based studies: an evaluation of manikin characteristics and their impact on measurements of ventilatory variables De Luca A, Sall FS, Sailley R, Capellier G, Khoury A. Two articles critique the reliability of artificial physiological measurements and, to some extent, the applicability of those measurements to people. Manikins cannot die or suffer hurt. They are therefore valuable when one tests the safety and provisional performance of machines that might subsequently be attached to people, who of course can die and be hurt. The results of manikin experiments should not be extended beyond their remit: too often manikin studies are presented as definitive evidence for the clinical superiority of one device. When Ex Machina cyborgs pass the clinical equivalent of the Turing’s test we might dispose of clinical studies. Until then, mind the gap between the evidence and its clinical application. Laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy in five awake obese patients using paravertebral and superficial cervical plexus blockade Kanawati S, Fawal H, Maaliki H, Naja ZM. Might you be worried about anaesthetising a patient with a BMI of 54 for a sleeve gastrectomy? If so, don’t. That is, don’t anaesthetise them, but you have to be good at numbing. Now, where did I put that yellow pillow? Evaluation of a new double-lumen endobronchial tube with an integrated camera (VivaSight-DLTM): a prospective multicentre observational study Koopman EM, Barak M, Weber E, et al. I indulge my vanity by believing that, for most patients, I can see the glottis as well with direct laryngoscopy as I can with indirect laryngoscopy. I studiously ignore the interpretation of this sentence that I’m just as bad at both. I don’t think that I can see the carina from the mouth, even with a very bright torch. Koopman et al. describe bronchial intubation with a double-lumen tube tipped by a camera. One day we might have a self-driving subglottic airway that follows the aroma of carbon dioxide to the lungs. Until then, maintain your driving licence. J. B. Carlisle, Editor, Anaesthesia N.B. the articles referred to can be found in either the latest issue of Anaesthesia or on Early View (ePub ahead of print) Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 29 Particles Nørskov AK, Rosenstock CV, Wetterslev J, Astrup G, Afshari A, Lundstrom LH. De Jong A, Molinari N, Pouzeratte Y, et al. Mishriky BM, Waldron NH, Habib AS Diagnostic accuracy of anaesthesiologists' prediction of difficult airway management in daily clinical practice: a cohort study of 188 064 patients Difficult intubation in obese patients: incidence, risk factors, and complications in the operating theatre and in intensive care units Impact of pregabalin on acute and persistent postoperative pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis Anaesthesia 2015; 70: 272–81 British Journal of Anaesthesia 2015; 114: 297–306 Background Although NAP41 and the American Society of Anesthesiologists recommend preoperative airway assessment there is no consensus on what assessment should be undertaken. No single test reliably predicts difficult intubation.2 The Danish Anaesthesia Database records compulsory data from 75% of anaesthetic departments in Denmark. The authors utilised this quality assurance resource to investigate if airway assessment accurately predicted difficult intubation or mask ventilation. Background This study looks at the association between obesity and intubation, and life threatening complications in both the intensive care unit (ICU) and in the operating theatre (OT), and the incidence of difficult airways in both these settings. Raised body mass index (BMI) has been associated with difficult intubation, in both ICU1,2 and the OT.3,4 Major airway complications occurring in ICU5 and the OT6 involved obese patients in 47% and 40% cases, respectively. Methods This observational study included every patient undergoing attempted tracheal intubation or mask ventilation in a three year period between 2008 and 2011. ‘Yes/No’ answers to two compulsory questions, ‘Is difficult tracheal intubation by direct laryngoscopy anticipated?’ and ‘Is difficult mask ventilation anticipated?’ were recorded before induction of anaesthesia. An initial airway management plan was documented before performing airway management and ease of mask ventilation was recorded. Difficult intubation was defined as more than two attempts at direct laryngoscopy, use of intubation adjuncts or specialised equipment (e.g. video laryngoscopy) or failed intubation. Mask ventilation was subjectively graded as easy or difficult. Analysis was performed in three cohorts: • • • Patients who had intubation attempted using only direct laryngoscopy (primary analysis) Patients in the primary analysis plus those with anticipated difficult intubation where use of specialised airway equipment was pre-planned (sensitivity analysis 1) All patients undergoing attempted intubation (irrespective of technique) but using a stricter definition of difficult intubation of three or more attempts (sensitivity analysis 2) Results A total of 188,064 patients were included. In the primary analysis 3,383 (1.9%) intubations were difficult; 93% of these were unanticipated. Anticipated difficult intubations were actually difficult in 25% of patients, 75% of difficult intubations were not predicted in sensitivity analysis 1 and 91% were not predicted in sensitivity analysis 2. Difficult mask ventilation cases were identified in 857 patients, of which 94% were unanticipated. A total of 49% of patients with difficult mask ventilation were also difficult to intubate. Failed intubation occurred more frequently in cases of difficult mask ventilation (3.7% vs 0.1%). Discussion This large study of Danish anaesthetic practice has clear applicability to UK practice. Although the incidence of difficult intubation was lower than in previous studies there was a surprisingly high incidence of unanticipated difficult intubation. Most airways that were anticipated to be difficult were not. This study has significant strengths including the number of patients studied and compulsory database entry but also has limitations including potential recording bias due to default settings in the database that may have resulted in under-recording of anticipated difficulty. Nonetheless, this study confirms that prediction of airway difficulty remains challenging and as such we must remain aware of the potential for unexpected difficulties when managing even the most straightforward airway. Methods This was a multi-centre prospective observational cohort study in ICU and the OT in obese (BMI>30) patients. The primary endpoint was the incidence of difficult intubation, defined by the ASA Task Force on Management of the Difficult Airway.7 Secondary endpoints were the risk factors for difficult intubation, the use of difficult airway management techniques, and severe life-threatening complications related to intubation. Results In cohorts of 1,400 and 11,035 consecutive patients intubated in ICU and in the OT, 20% and 19% were obese, respectively. In obese patients, the incidence of difficult intubation was twice as frequent in the ICU as in the OT (16.3% vs 8.2%, p = 0.01). In both cohorts, risk factors for difficult intubation were Mallampati score III/IV, obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome, and reduced mobility of cervical spine. Limited mouth opening, severe hypoxaemia, and coma were specific to ICU. Specific difficult airway management techniques were used in 36% cases of difficult intubation in obese patients in the OT and in 22% cases in ICU. Severe life-threatening complications were significantly more frequent in ICU than in the OT (41.1% vs 1.9%, RR 21.6, 95% CI 15.4–30.3, p<0.01). Discussion Limitations of the study included the use of two databases which were multicentre, possibly leading to information bias. However, multivariate models were used. Pre-oxygenation and intubation position were not standardised. On occasion the physicians recording the data variables were the same as those performing the intubation, so the degree of difficulty may have been biased. In obese patients, the incidence of difficult intubation was twice as frequent in ICU as in the OT and severe life-threatening complications related to intubation occurred 20x times more often in ICU in this group. The ICU setting was found to be an independent risk factor of severe complications, in comparison with the OT. The use of specific difficult airway management techniques was less in the ICU compared with OT. In the OT, rapid sequence induction was used in 2% of the patients vs 74% of patients in ICU. The higher rate of severe complications in ICU may be explained by the increased risk of significant desaturation in critically ill patients during rapid sequence induction.8 Shelley Barnes CT2b, Severn Deanery References 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Andrew Ray CT2B ACCS, Severn Deanery 6. References 1. 2. 30 Cook TM, Woodall N, Frerk C. Fourth National Audit Project. Major complications of airway management in the UK: results of the Fourth National Audit Project of the Royal College of Anaesthetists and the Difficult Airway Society. Part 1: Anaesthesia. British Journal of Anaesthesia 2011; 106: 617–31. Shiga T, Wajima Z, Inoue T, Sakamoto S, Sakamoto A. Predicting difficult intubation in apparently normal patients. Anaesthesiology 2005; 103: 429–37. Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 7. 8. De Jong A, Molinari N, Terzi N, et al. Early identification of patients at risk for difficult intubation in ICU: development and validation of the MACOCHA Score in a Multicenter Cohort Study. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine 2013; 187: 832–9. Frat J-P, Gissot V, Ragot S, et al. Impact of obesity in mechanically ventilated patients: a prospective study. Intensive Care Medicine 2008; 34: 1991–8. Langeron O, Cuvillon P, Ibanez-Esteve C, et al. Prediction of difficult tracheal intubation: time for a paradigm change. Anesthesiology 2012; 117: 1223–33. Lundstrøm LH, Møller AM, Rosenstock C, et al. High body mass index is a weak predictor for difficult and failed tracheal intubation: a cohort study of 91,332 consecutive patients scheduled for direct laryngoscopy registered in the Danish Anesthesia Database. Anesthesiology 2009; 110: 266–74. Cook TM, Woodall N, Harper J, et al. Major complications of airway management in the UK: results of the Fourth National Audit Project of the Royal College of Anaesthetists and the Difficult Airway Society. Part 2: intensive care and emergency departments. British Journal of Anaesthesia 2011; 106: 632–42. Cook TM, Woodall N, Frerk C, et al. Major complications of airway management in the UK: results of the Fourth National Audit Project of the Royal College of Anaesthetists and the Difficult Airway Society. Part 1: anaesthesia. British Journal of Anaesthesia 2011; 106: 617–31. Practice guidelines for management of the difficult airway: an updated report by the American Society of Anesthesiologists Task Force on Management of the Difficult Airway. Anesthesiology 2003; 98: 1269–77. El-Orbany M, Connolly LA. Rapid sequence induction and intubation: current controversy. Anesthesia & Analgesia 2010; 110: 1318–25. Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 British Journal of Anaesthesia 2015; 114: 10–31. Background Pregabalin is currently licensed for neuropathic pain and control of epilepsy; however its use in the peri-operative period is increasing, but at present is off licence. Pregabalin binds to the α-2-δ subunit of voltage gated calcium channels, leading to a reduction in the release of excitatory neurotransmitters.1 Many trials and meta-analyses have been conducted investigating the peri-operative analgesic effects of pregabalin, with varying doses from 50 mg to 300 mg. Mishriky et al aimed to provide an up-to-date review on the use of peri-operative pregabalin and its effect on pain score and opioid consumption. Methods A search of MEDLINE, Cochrane Central Register, EMBASE and CINAHL was made for randomised controlled trials comparing pregabalin with control patients undergoing surgery, following the recommendations of the PRISMA statement. Primary outcomes were pain scores and opioid consumption at 2 and 24 hours. Secondary outcomes were duration of PACU and hospital stay, incidence of persistent pain, pre-operative anxiety scores and side effects. The visual analogue scale for pain and anxiety (0 no pain, 10 worst pain) was used, and opioid consumption was calculated using standard morphine equivalents. The incidence of persistent pain was compared at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months after surgery. Results Of the 695 eligible studies, 55 were included in the final analysis of the review, comparing 2,270 patients who received pre-operative pregabalin with 1,885 controls. Pain scores at 2 hours were reduced at rest [mean difference (MD) -0.81] and on movement (MD -0.58) in the pregabalin group. At 24 hours, pain scores were reduced at rest (MD -0.38) and on movement (MD -0.47). All pregabalin doses >75mg showed a reduction in pain scores. Opioid consumption at 2 hours was reduced (MD -2.09mg) with pre-operative pregabalin doses >100 mg. At 24 hours opioid consumption was reduced (MD -8.27mg) for all doses. Single dosing was as effective as multiple dose regimes at reducing pain scores and opioid consumption. There was no difference in length of stay in the post anaesthesia recovery unit [MD -2 mins (95% CI -9.76, 5.66)], but pregabalin medicated patients achieved hospital discharge 13.75 hours earlier (95% CI -23.26, -4.24). Reported side effects included: Sedation (46% increase), dizziness (33% increase) and visual disturbance (3.5x more likely) were significantly more common at 24 hours with a 300 mg dose, but not at a lower dose. However pruritus and postoperative nausea and vomiting were significantly reduced by 51% and 38%, respectively. The meta-analysis showed no difference in persistent pain at 1 and 3 months, however reduced rates of persistent pain at 6 (4 vs 15%) and 12 months (9 vs 20%). Discussion Mishriky et al. have shown that pre-operative pregabalin administration can be a useful adjunct in patients undergoing surgery – the meta-analysis indicates that opioid use is reduced, postoperative nausea and vomiting and pruritis rates reduced and time to hospital discharge significantly reduced. There is also some evidence to suggest that this strategy can reduce the development of chronic postoperative pain. Further work is needed to compare the efficacy of difference doses and of single vs multiple dosing regimens of pregabalin to assess the ideal dosing strategy. Andrew Grant CT2b, Severn Deanery Reference 1. Taylor CP, Angelotti T, Fauman E. Pharmacology and mechanism of action of pregabalin: the calcium channel α2–δ (alpha2–delta) subunit as a target for antiepileptic drug discovery. Epilepsy Research 2007; 73: 137–50. 31 Dear Editor Figure 1 The ‘sartorius roll’: a reliable tactile landmark for fascia iliaca blocks The traditional landmarks for the fascia iliaca block as described by Dalens et al.1 include the pubic tubercle. Anecdotal evidence from our own practice suggests sometimes the pubic tubercle is generally estimated, not palpated. In the absence of ultrasound guidance, this may result in incorrect needle placement and an unreliable block. The medial border of the sartorius forms the lateral border of the femoral triangle. The injection point is medial to the medial border of the sartorius. Hence, we suggest a routine fingertip roll of the sartorius muscle as an additional landmark to reassure a correct and safe injection point (Figure 1). SEND YOUR LETTERS TO: The Editor, Anaesthesia News at anaenews.editor@aagbi.org Please see instructions for authors on the AAGBI website Mark Gotecha ST3 Anaesthetics Santosh Mehrotra Consultant Anaesthetist Dear Editor Russel Emamdee Consultant Anaesthetist Anaesthetics: a health warning! Broomfield Hospital, Chelmsford Lumbar back pain is a common complaint in the UK with a one month period prevalence of 28.5%.1 In 2014, I had the misfortune of experiencing an acute episode of lumbar back pain; the sudden onset of which coincided with leaning forwards to insert a cannula in theatre. Simple analgesia provided little relief and associated muscle spasms rendered me frozen to the spot over a four week period. Reference 1. Dalens B, Vanneuville G, Tanguy A. Comparison of the fascia iliaca compartment block with the 3-in-1 block in children. Anesthesia & Analgesia 1989; 69: 705–13. Dear Editor Dear Editor A return to the dark ages? During a recent laparoscopic nephrectomy, I was using a maintenance technique of TCI propofol and remifentanil. To best guide the target concentrations I was using a Bispectral Index (BIS) monitor. At knife to skin I was alarmed to see the BIS reading leap from 32 to 70. I immediately increased the concentrations of both propofol and remifentanil but this brought no reduction in BIS. I gave a bolus of propofol but again without effect. At no point did any other index suggest inadequate anaesthesia: blood pressure and heart rate remained unaltered, a check of the patient’s eyes found the pupils to be small and revealed no lacrimation. As a recent new mother I had the unfortunate experience of developing rigors one week post-delivery and needed to return to hospital. My temperature was 41.2°C and my heart rate was 135 bpm. I was treated promptly with IV co-amoxiclav and IV Tazocin and was taken to theatre for an ERPOC. I continued with IV antibiotics until I was afebrile for 24 hours and then switched to oral antibiotics. I returned home four days after being re-admitted none the worse for my experience. Having taken my treatment for granted my (non-medical) father pointed out to me that if this had been 80 years ago, before the discovery of antibiotics, I would most likely have died. After reading recent articles about the growth of antibiotic resistance and the lack of funding for research into new antibiotics it is possible that if this occurred in 80 years time I would also have died. Worryingly, Science Daily reported1 that only 1% of research funding goes towards antibiotics. It could easily be that within our lifetime we see a time where routine minor operations become potentially life-threatening or a simple cut could mean loss of a limb. Natalie Gray CT2 Anaesthetist Cheltenham General Hospital Reference 1. Less than 1% of UK public research funding spent on antibiotic research in past 5 years. Science Daily 25 July 2014. http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/07/140725080339.htm (accessed 13/6/15). your Letters A check of the BIS probe found it to be well applied, but in close proximity to the hose of the warm air blanket which was draped on the patient and had been turned on after the drapes had been applied. Wondering about interference, I turned the blanket off and within seconds the BIS fell from 70 back to the high 20s – a number suggestive of deep anaesthesia. The lay perception is that anaesthetists sit and read the newspaper or, in this modern age, scroll through the internet on a tablet. Only after the onset of my back pain did I realise that the physically active nature of our job was a likely contributing factor. Whether leaning forward to intubate, doing cardiac compressions, carrying large ITU transfer bags or lifting heavy oxygen cylinders – the constant flexion and extension of the lumbar spine continued to exacerbate my back pain and made relatively simple tasks very challenging. The manoeuvre that caused most difficulty involved burying myself under the surgical drapes to insert a nasogastric tube after an operation had started. I was fortunate that lumbar facet joint injections did relieve the pain; however, I am conscious that it could recur and my experience has encouraged me to reflect on how my anaesthetic practise should be changed. As I started my CT2 year, I took particular note of the manual handling section of our online trust mandatory training. For someone who is 190cm tall, simple changes such as adjusting the bed height can minimise the mechanical stress placed on the lumbar spine during cannulation and intubation. It is important to position equipment carefully and consciously think about posture prior to doing procedures in order to reduce excessive spinal movements. My GP did also recommend Pilates – though this might require some further persuasion… There is little in the literature about the prevalence of back pain among anaesthetists; although the Labour Force Survey indicates that health professionals, when compared to all occupations, had a statistically significant increased prevalence of back disorders during 2009–2012.2 It is important to raise awareness of this potential health hazard and, with simple measures, the negative professional, social and economic consequences of work-related back pain can be reduced. I re-arranged the warm air blanket and was able to return to lower target concentrations of propofol and remifentanil without any further high BIS readings. Throughout the case I regularly turned the warm air blanket off to confirm the accuracy of the readings. It seemed the warm air blanket was directly interfering with the BIS reading, with the potential to cause alarm or unnecessarily injudicious anaesthetic agent use to treat spurious readings. A PubMed search revealed no previous descriptions of this phenomenon, although the manufacturers of BIS do mention in their product literature of the potential for medical devices (including electrocautery and warm air blankets over the patient’s head) to cause interference with BIS readings.1 Ian Davies ST5 Anaesthesia Royal United Hospitals, Bath Michael Robson CT2 Anaesthetics Western Sussex Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust Reference 1. Macfarlane GJ, Beasley M, Jones EA, et al. The prevalence and management of low back pain across adulthood: results from a population-based crosssectional study (the MUSICIAN study). Pain 2012; 153: 27–32. His first induction had been turbulent due to failed cannulation followed by a combative gas induction. His mother had been quite distressed by this and requested a gas induction for this procedure. The boy suffered from exercise induced wheeze for which he was prescribed a salbutamol inhaler via a ‘spacer’ with a paediatric facemask (Aerochamber Plus, Trudell Medical International, Canada). The mother explained she had been practising with him at home using this to prepare him for anaesthesia. In the anaesthetic room we noted the soft material for insertion of a metered dose inhaler port could easily accommodate the HME filter connection (Flexicare, UK) attached to the common gas outlet via an Ayre’s T-piece (Figure 1). The boy happily breathed the anaesthetic mixture via his own spacer and anaesthesia was achieved with no further distress to the boy or his mother. Figure 1 Use of a spacer for gas induction has been described before1 but the fact that the boy’s mother had already been preparing her child with his own device and that it already had a close fitting facemask that worked safely and effectively make this a useful option in anxious children who are already familiar with asthma devices. This technique can be useful to discuss in the pre-operative stage at the time of listing, with parents helping to ease familiarity of anaesthesia induction by practice with their own device. Having multiple techniques to achieve a successful gas induction is part of the art of paediatric anaesthesia and we have found this to be a useful trick to add to the repertoire. Consent obtained. Dr Therese Walsh ST4 Anaesthesia Dr Neil Oakes Consultant Anaesthetist Wirral University Hospital NHS Foundation Trust Reference 1. Monitoring Consciousness Using the Bispectral Index™ (BIS™) During Anesthesia (2nd edition) 2012. p19. http://www.covidien.com/rms/products/brain-monitoring/bis-4electrode-sensor#resources (accessed 22/02/2015). Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 We report the use of a spacer device to facilitate a universally stress free induction for all. Induction of anaesthesia in children can sometimes be challenging because of previous unpleasant experiences resulting in fear and apprehension of the next anaesthetic. We recently anaesthetised a 3-year-old boy for a circumcision; a few months previously he had had a grommet inserted. 2. Health and Safety Executive. Musculoskeletal Disorders in Great Britain 2014. http://www.hse.gov.uk/statistics/causdis/musculoskeletal/msd.pdf (accessed 22/8/2014). Reference 32 Dear Editor 1. Beringer R, and Robinson S. A familiar asthma spacer for inhalational induction. Anaesthesia 2002; 57: 818–38. Anaesthesia News August 2015 • Issue 337 33 28 September 1 October 2015 doctorsupdates 18th Anaesthesia, Critical Care and Pain Forum TM www.doctorsupdates.com Da Balaia, The Algarve Portugal education in a perfect location© H G R U B EDIN D N A L T O C S RENCE CENTRE ATIONAL CONFE EDINBURGH INTERN EARLY BOOKING RATE Ends: 28 July 2015 W O N K O O B PS, O H S K R O IONS, W NSIVE INDUSTRY S S E S L E L L PARA , EXTE S T C A R T S B POSTER A N AND MUCH MORE EXHIBITIO UDE: L C N I S E R ECTU ternal a m y h W KEYNOTE L iety d soc n a x e s , h issue e lt c a e h l Scien a b still a glo , Australia s i y t li a t r o m Melbourne , is n n e D Dr Alicia eland: r I & n i a t i r Great B n i a i s e h t s rfect? Anae e p e r u t u F se; Present ten op-Griffiths, London Harr Dr William The EICC is Scotland’s greenest convention centre and the AAGBI are committed to working with them to make Annual Congress as environmentally friendly as possible.
Similar documents
View now
From my own perspective, I have watched GAT, the trainee committee of the AAGBI go from strength to strength. GAT has consolidated links with Irish colleagues, taken up the cudgel on behalf of trai...
More informationA YEAR IN REVIEW
Although based at different hospitals, and deaneries, we used Skype to viva in pairs or small groups from our own homes. Skype video calls gave us face-to-face practice that replicated the ‘across ...
More information