vellezerit aliu
Transcription
vellezerit aliu
KPMG Albania Shpk Kosovo Branch 14, Sulejman Vokshi Street Pristina, Kosovo Telephone Telefax E-mail Internet +381(38)246771 +381(38)246772 al-kosovo@kpmg.com www.kpmg.al AUDIT REPORT ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF THE MUNICIPALITYOF SKENDERAJ FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2012 Pristina, July 2013 KPMG Albania Shpk Kosovo Branch, a branch of KPMG Albania Shpk, an Albanian limited liability company and a member firm of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Cooperative (“KPMG International”), a Swiss entity. Registered with the Kosovo Business Registration Agency with Business no. 70291840 TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................................................. 3 AUDIT SCOPE AND METHODOLOGY ........................................................................................................ 4 I. AUDIT OPINION ....................................................................................................................................... 5 II. FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - COMPLIANCE WITH THE REPORTING FRAMEWORK ......... 7 II.1 II.2 COMPLIANCE WITH THE REPORTING FRAMEWORK .............................................................................................................. 7 QUALITY AND ACCURACY OF INFORMATION PRESENTED IN THE ANNUAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ............................................... 7 III. PRIOR YEAR RECOMMENDATIONS .................................................................................................. 8 IV. FINACIAL MANAGEMENT AND CONTROL ..................................................................................... 9 IV.1 IV.2 IV.3 IV.4 IV.5 IV.6 IV.7 V. INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................................................................ 9 BUDGET PLANNING AND EXECUTION ............................................................................................................................... 9 CURRENT REPORTING AND TIMELINESS IN THE OVERALL BUDGET PROCESS ............................................................................. 10 REVENUES (INCLUDING OWN SOURCE REVENUES) ............................................................................................................. 10 EXPENDITURES .......................................................................................................................................................... 11 ASSETS .................................................................................................................................................................... 12 HANDLING OF DEBTS .................................................................................................................................................. 13 INTERNAL AUDIT SYSTEM ................................................................................................................ 14 V.1 V.2 INTERNAL CONTROL SYSTEMS....................................................................................................................................... 14 INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION ......................................................................................................................................... 14 VI. OVERALL CONCLUSION ON THE MANAGEMENT OF MUNICIPALITY OF SKENDERAJ 15 ANNEX 1 DIFFERENT TYPE OF AUDIT OPINIONS APPLIED BY KPMG IN THE ANNUAL AUDIT REPORT 2012 ................................................................................................................................................... 16 ANNEX 2: PRIOR YEAR RECOMMENDATIONS .................................................................................... 17 ANNEX 3 MUNICIPALITY OF SKENDERAJ MANAGEMENT COMMENTS AND KPMG RESPONSES ..................................................................................................................................................... 20 2 Executive Summary Introduction KPMG has carried out an audit of the Annual Financial Statements (‘AFS’) of the Municipality of Skenderaj (“Municipality”), on behalf of the Office of the Auditor General of Kosovo, for the year ended 31 December 2012. This report summarises the key matters arising from our audit. We would like to thank the Mayor and his team for their assistance during the audit process. Our audit was carried out in accordance with international auditing standards issued by the International Organisation of Supreme Audit Institutions (INTOSAI) and included such tests and procedures as we deemed necessary to arrive at an opinion on the financial statements. Our focus has been on whether the amounts and disclosures in the AFS are sufficient to give a reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free from material misstatement, whether caused by fraud or error. Our procedures included a review of the internal controls and accounting systems and procedures only to the extent considered necessary for the effective performance of the audit. Our findings should not be regarded as representing a comprehensive statement of all the weaknesses which exist, or all improvements which could be made to the systems and procedures operated. Our Overall conclusion on the Management of the Municipality is presented in Section VI of this report. Internal Control Our audit has identified weaknesses in several areas of financial management. These weaknesses are described in more detail within the report. Our conclusion is that the Municipality’s internal systems are not properly designed to eliminate evident weaknesses and are not implemented as they should be. In order to improve the functioning of the financial management system and internal controls, we recommend the Municipality to ensure: • • • A comprehensive list of its property, plant and equipment is maintained and reviewed; An automated billing system for all types of taxes is maintained; and Measures are taken to increase the collection of revenues from various taxes. Management of the Municipality was given the possibility to comment on the findings presented in this report. Management has agreed to make all efforts to address all our recommendations. Refer to Annex 3 for management’s comments to our recommendations and our responses to them. 3 Audit scope and methodology This audit relates to the annual financial statements of the Municipality of Skenderaj as at and for the year ended 31 December 2012. It is the responsibility of the Municipality to prepare financial statements in accordance with Financial Rule no. 07/2011 and International Public Sector Accounting Standards (IPSAS) for “Financial Reporting under the Cash Basis of Accounting”. KPMG, on behalf of The Office of the Auditor General, is responsible for carrying out an annual audit on the Municipality financial statements as at and for the year ended 31 December 2012. An audit is an attestation of financial accounting, involving examination and evaluation of Financial Statements and other financial records and provides assurance on: • Whether the financial statements give a true and fair view of the accounts and financial affairs for the audit period; • Whether the financial records, systems and transactions comply with applicable laws and regulations; • The appropriateness of internal controls and internal audit functions; and • Any other significant matters arising from or relating to the audit. In order to fulfil our responsibilities for the audit of the Municipality, we have undertaken the following activities: • Compared the Municipality’s Annual Financial Statements against the approved budget as at and for the year ended 31 December 2012; • Determined whether the Municipality’s Annual Financial Statements were prepared in accordance with IPSAS “Financial Reporting under the Cash Basis of Accounting” and Financial Rule no. 07/2011; • Established a materiality level, as a threshold for assisting in determining the type of opinion to render on the financial statements; • Used a combination of judgment and random sampling to select transactions for testing; • Undertook substantive testing of financial transactions; and • Relied on a combination of interviews, analytical reviews, document checking, and physical verification to assess the validity and propriety of financial transactions. In this report we summarise the audit findings and provide our opinion on the Annual Financial Statement as at and for the year ended 31 December 2012. INTOSAI set out specific criteria that govern the type of opinion that should be rendered regarding our audit opinion for the Municipality’s annual financial statements. These are set out more fully in Annex 1, which includes an extract from ISSAI 400. 4 I. Audit Opinion To Skenderaj Municipality Pristina, 2 July 2013 We have audited the accompanying financial statements of Municipality of Skenderaj (“the Municipality”), which comprise the statement of cash receipts and payments for the year ended 31 December 2012, a comparison of budget and actual amounts, and a summary of significant accounting policies and other explanatory notes. Management’s Responsibility for the Financial Statements Management is responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of these financial statements in accordance with Cash Basis International Public Sector Accounting Standards (‘IPSAS’) Financial Reporting Under the Cash Basis of Accounting and with the Financial Rule No. 07/2011 On Annual Reporting of Budget Organizations. This responsibility includes the design, implementation and maintenance of internal control relevant to the preparation and presentation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error. Auditors’ Responsibility Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these financial statements based on our audit. We conducted our audit in accordance with the International Organisation of Supreme Audit Institutions (INTOSAI) Fundamental Auditing Principles and Guidelines. Those standards require that we comply with ethical requirements and plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements are free from material misstatement. An audit involves performing procedures to obtain audit evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. The procedures selected depend on the auditor's judgement, including the assessment of the risks of material misstatement of the financial statements, whether due to fraud or error. In making those risk assessments, internal control relevant to the entity's preparation and presentation of financial statements is considered in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances, but not for the purposes of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of internal control. An audit also includes evaluating the appropriateness of accounting policies used, the reasonableness of accounting estimates made by management, as well as evaluating the presentation of the financial statements. We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our opinion. Opinion In our opinion, the financial statements present fairly in all material respects, the receipts and payments for the year ended 31 December 2012 in accordance with Cash Basis International Public Sector Accounting Standards (‘IPSAS’) Financial Reporting Under the Cash Basis of Accounting and with the Financial Rule No. 07/2011 On Annual Reporting of Budget Organizations. Emphasis of Matter Without qualifying our opinion, we draw attention to Section 16 ‘Disclosure of property, plant and equipment’. For certain properties, there could be uncertainty regarding ownership rights of the Municipality and various other Kosovo Government Agencies, and lack of supporting ownership documentation. In addition, due to lack of supporting documentation for the measurement of a significant part of these assets, the Municipality sought to measure them at fair value based on a valuation performed by an internally established committee. The valuation included only main municipal buildings and not all property, plant and equipment. 5 II. Financial Statements - Compliance with the Reporting Framework Our review of the Annual Financial Statements (‘AFS’) considers both compliance with the reporting framework and the quality and accuracy of the information recorded in the financial statements. We also consider the Declaration made by the Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer when the draft Annual Financial Statements are submitted to the Government. The declaration regarding presentation of financial statements incorporates a number of assertions relating to compliance with the reporting framework and the quality of information within the financial statements. A number of the declarations are intended to provide assurance to the Government that all relevant information has been provided to ensure that a comprehensive audit can be undertaken. II.1 Compliance with the Reporting Framework The requirements in LPFMA No. 03/L-048 and Financial Rule no. 07/2011. • The Municipality has prepared the financial statements according to Financial Rule 07/2011. • The Financial Statements have been signed by the Chief Administrative Officer and Chief Financial Officer of the audited body; • The Financial Statements were signed within the required time frame on 31 January 2013 and Submitted to Ministry of Finance (MF); • The Financial Statements were submitted to the Ministry of Finance only in the Albanian Language; and • The Municipality has prepared and submitted regular quarterly reports to the Ministry of Finance during 2012. Recommendation 1 The Municipality should prepare Financial Statements in Serbian language. II.2 Quality and Accuracy of Information Presented in the Annual Financial Statements Findings The primary reliable source of information for the preparation of financial statements is Free Balance. However, since Free Balance is not being used to record revenues from penalties, payments from third parties, or outstanding invoices, it cannot solely be used to produce comprehensive financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2012. Recommendation 2 We recommend the Mayor ensures that the preparation of the Municipality’s financial statements should include procedures and tools that are designed to ensure that information required is recorded, processed, summarized and appropriately reported in the financial statements. Information on payments from third parties, amounts receivable and outstanding invoices should be regularly updated and reviewed to ensure accuracy and completeness of such disclosures in the financial statements. 7 III. Prior Year Recommendations Our Report on the 2011 AFS included the following recommendations: 1. Prepare Financial Statements in Serbian language: to be addressed; 2. An automated billing system for all types of taxes should be put in place and measures should be taken to increase the collection of revenues from various taxes and to regularly perform reconciliations for such revenues: partly resolved: partly addressed; 3. Take further steps to improve controls over expenses and payments and strictly comply with Law on Public Procurement No 03-L-241 in order to avoid irregularities: partly addressed; 4. Additional resources should be involved in the registration and valuation of the assets of the Municipality: to be addressed; 5. Improvements need to be implemented in the areas of expenditure and wages and salaries: partly addressed; 6. Take further steps to improve controls over expenses and payments: to be addressed; 7. Reporting structure of the audit committee: to be addressed. The recommendations number 2, 3 and 5 above were partly addressed. In the current year the Municipality started to perform monthly reconciliations for revenues. All other main recommendations still need to be addressed. Failure to fully address our given recommendations in points 1,4,6,7 has led us to have similar findings in these four areas that remain to be addressed as in the future. 8 IV. Finacial Management and Control IV.1 Introduction We developed an understanding and evaluation of the actions taken by management to ensure effective financial management and control. For individual financial systems we seek to identify the level at which actual controls operate. This may, for example, be monitoring activity undertaken by senior management or lower level operational controls. We consider whether controls are well designed, have been implemented as planned and operate effectively. IV.2 Budget Planning and Execution We have considered the source of budgetary funds for the Municipality, spending of funds by economic categories and Revenues collected. The analysis of Actual Outcome in the Financial Statements compared to the Approved Budget indicates: Table 1: Overview of budget and actual spending Amounts in EUR ‘000 Initial Budget Final Budget 2012 Actual 2011 Actual 2010 Actual 8,741 9,391 9,358 8,994 8,279 - 153 150 195 154 1,100 1,100 418 1,058 829 Domestic Donations - 32 26 1 3 External Donations - 110 108 123 - I. Total receipts 9,841 10,786 10,060 10,371 9,265 Wages and Salaries 5,923 5,974 5,949 5,722 4,481 Goods and Services 767 896 884 818 794 Utilities 145 179 173 156 154 Subsidies and Transfers 110 110 105 130 116 2,896 3,627 2,949 3,545 3,720 - - - - - 9,841 10,786 10,060 10,371 9,265 - - - - - Description Government Grant Carried forward from prior year Own Source Revenues Capital Investments Reserves II. Total payments Difference I-II 9 Conclusion Actual total receipts were lower than final budget by EUR 726 thousand which is mainly due to lower realization of own source revenue by EUR 685 thousand, principally relating to concession income for a property which was budgeted but finally not given for concession, government grant of EUR 33 thousand and grants and donors of EUR 8 thousand. Total payments were lower than final budget by EUR 726 thousand due to wages and salaries being lower by EUR 25 thousand, goods and services being lower by EUR 12 thousand, utilities being lower by EUR 6 thousand, transfers and subsidies being lower by EUR 5 thousand and capital expenditure being lower by EUR 678 thousand. Initial budget was lower by EUR 945 thousand from the final budget due to following: additional allocation from governemental grant of EUR 650 thousand, own source revenues carried forward by EUR 153 thousand and grants and donors by EUR 142 thousand were not aniticipated in initial budget. All changes to the original budget were properly approved, approved upon revision of the budget, based on a Decision of the Government of Kosovo or approved by the Mayor and Municipality Assembly. These changes are also supported by the assembly decision and mandated by the legal framework Law 03/L-048. The unspent budget of the Municipality in 2012 is 6.7%. IV.3 Current reporting and timeliness in the overall budget process Fullfillment of current external reporting obligations as well as its budgetary process: • Budget requests were completed on a timely basis; • Quarterly reports including the nine month financial statements were submitted on a timely basis to MF. • Draft procurement plan was submitted on time to MF; • Action Plan on implementing recomandations was included in the annual financial statements of the Municipality. Findings No major exceptions identified. IV.4 Revenues (including own source revenues) Findings During our testing we noted the following: • Billing systems. An automated billing system exists only for tax on property. The Municipality does not maintain billing records for other types of revenue. Instead only cash collections from such revenue streams are recorded. • Collection of revenues. Except for taxes on property, bussines and construction licenses, the Municipality management does not maintain separate sub ledgers or lists of all its debtors from various taxes. Without sufficient, detailed, and accurate records of debtors, the Municipality is unable to prepare a reliable and accurate budget, to report an accurate collection ratio, nor follow up the collection of the own source revenues on a timely basis. 10 • Weaknesses in the automated billing system. The tax on property billing system is centralized and the Municipality has limited access to the system. Such limitations restrict the ability of the Municipality to generate regular and comprehensive reports on collection of revenue and related receivables, and as a result impair its ability to properly monitor and review such collections. Although such reports are automatically generated by the system on a centralized basis, the Municipality does not make regular use of them. Recommendation 3 We recommend the Mayor ensures that the Municipality takes steps to improve the billing and accounting systems in order to ensure safe, efficient and effective controls on billing and revenue. Improvement of the procedures related to such systems would enable management to monitor and manage significant risks, and to ensure that decisions related to budgeting, planning and collection of revenues are properly carried out. We recommend that the Municipality considers to: • Implement a billing system that includes updated details about the payers, their current address, history and collection rating. Such information should be accessible only to a limited number of persons and with the authorization of management. • Enter and centrally control the approved tariffs and tax rates in the system in order to calculate and generate bills automatically. The generation of bills should also be authorized and reviewed. • Automatically inter-connect the billing system with the accounting software so that information is automatically processed into the general ledger. • Automatically link the operational and billing units and perform regular reconciliations between them, in cases where the billing is directly related to services supplied by the operational units. This is especially important where a high volume of transactions is executed. IV.5 Expenditures 5.1 Procurement Findings During our inspection of the documents for our sample of procurement files we noted only few noncompliances with procedures as required by Public Procurement Law PL 04/L-042. These non compliances are described below: • Procurement no. 643-11-065-221: the guarantee for the execution of the contract was missing despite being required from Municipality. • Procurement no. 643-011-040-521: the technical acceptance report was not signed by a member of the committee. Recommendation 4 We recommend the Mayor ensures that the Municipality takes further steps to improve controls over expenses and payments and ensure that all required documentation is obtained and filed in order to strictly comply with laws and local regulatory requirements. 11 5.2 Other expenditures Findings No major exceptions identified. 5.3 Remunerations (Wages and Salaries) Findings We received only the monthly payroll list from the Ministry of Public Administration for the year 2012 but we were not provided from the Municipality with the signed Comittment Payment Orders for such expenses. Recommendation 5 We recommend that the Mayor ensures that the Municipality keeps proper evidence of approval, authorization and payment of wages and salaries. 5.4 Subsidies and Transfers Findings No major exceptions identified. IV.6 Assets 6.1 Handling of cash and cash equivalents Findings No major exceptions identified to report. 6.2 Handling of receivables Findings The Municipality does not have in place a robust process for identifying, evidencing and following up on issued invoices for its taxes. Many of the receivables disclosed in the financial statements, related to previous years. The Municipality has not taken necessary actions to collect these amounts and no aging analysis is maintained. For instance the receivables as per central billing system for tax on property do not reconcile with receivables for such taxes disclosed in Note 34 to the financial statements. Recommendation 6 We recommend the Mayor ensures a process is designed and established, which ensures that receivables are recorded upon issuing of each invoice and that overdue amounts are followed up regularly. 12 6.3Capital and non capital assets Findings The following issues are noted in regard to disclosure of non-financial capital assets at values above EUR 1,000 in possession of the budget organization in Note 30 to the financial statements: • EUR 467 thousand represent non-financial capital assets provided to the Muncipality through third party payments which were not initially recorded as Municipality assets despite being activated and their ownership been transferred to the Municipality. However, subsequent to our questioning, these assets were included as a disclosure to the financial statements, during our audit. • Although the Municipality has prepared and disclosed a list of real estate property in Note 30, for certain assets, there are uncertainties regarding ownership rights of the Municipality or various other Kosovo Government Agencies and lack of supporting ownership documentation. • The Municipality has not maintained a comprehensive register of its property, plant and equipment, including information like the date of purchase and disposal of the assets and the depreciation charge for the year. • Due to a lack of supporting documentation for the measurement of a significant part of its property, plant and equipment, disclosed in Note 30, the Municipality sought to measure such items at fair value based on a valuation performed by an internally established committee. The valuation included only main municipal buildings and not all property plant and equipment was included. Recommendation 7 We recommend the Mayor to involve additional resources in the registration, control and valuation of the assets of the Municipality. IV.7 Handling of debts Findings Obligations reported in note 28 “Reporting obligations under the LPFMA” are not always supported with invoices which would prove the work done and actual cost. In certain cases such oligations were estimated from the Municipality based on the remaining contracted amounts. Although the Municipality has prepared an annex setting out detailed list of unpaid invoices the following information were missing: • In accordance with Law No. LPFMA 03/L-048, Article 39.1, the budget organization is responsible for ensuring that each valid invoice and request for payment for goods and services supplied and/or works completed for the budget organizations are to be paid within thirty (30) calendar days after receipt of invoice or request for payment by the concerned budget organization. We noted 155 invoices were due for more than 30 days in total amount of EUR 54 thousand. • Description of invoices and reasonability for invoice being outstanding were not completed. • In one case the the invoice date was missing. Recommendation 8 We recommend the Mayor ensures that the Municipality takes further steps and compile action plans to make payments within the required period and provide with all required disclosures on invoices. 13 V. Internal Audit System V.1 Internal Control Systems V.2 Internal Audit Function Findings During our audit we noted the Audit Committee has reported directly to the Mayor instead of the Municipal Assembly. In addition, the work of Internal Audit was focused on the previous year, rather than in the current period. Recommendation 9 We recommend that the Audit Committee should report directly to the Municipal Assembly to ensure that the responsibilities are carried out with the appropriate level of independence. In addition, the Mayor should produce an Action Plan that should be implemented to ensure that internal audit work is done and reported on a timely basis and to address resulting recommendations, detailing responsible officers and timescales for implementation. 14 VI. Overall conclusion on the Management of Municipality of Skenderaj General conclusions As discussed within this report, improvements need to be made in the areas of revenues, handling of receivables, payment of obligations within the required timeframe, measurement of capital and non-capital assets, and internal audit function. Overall Recommendation • The financial statements should be prepared in compliance with the actual administrative instructions and IPSAS; • An automated billing system for all types of taxes should be put in place, reconciliations of revenues between the own source revenue officer and operational departments should be performed, and measures should be taken to increase the collection of revenues from various taxes; • Additional resources should be involved in the registration, control and valuation of all assets of the Municipality; and • Audit committee should report directly to the Municipal Assembly to ensure that the responsibilities are carried out with the appropriate level of independence. In addition, The Mayor should produce an Action Plan that should be implemented to ensure that internal audit work is done and reported on a timely basis and to address resulting recommendations, detailing responsible officers and timescales for implementation. 15 Annex 1 Different type of Audit Opinions applied by KPMG in the Annual Audit Report 2012 (extract from ISSAI 400) 9. An audit opinion is normally in a standard format, relating to the financial statements as a whole, thus avoiding the need to state at length what lies behind it but conveying by its nature a general understanding among readers as to its meaning. The nature of these words will be influenced by the legal framework for the audit, but the content of the opinion will need to indicate unambiguously whether it is unqualified or qualified and, if the latter, whether it is qualified in certain respects or is adverse (paragraph 14) or a disclaimer (paragraph 15) of opinion. 10. An unqualified opinion is given when the auditor is satisfied in all material respects that: a) the financial statements have been prepared using acceptable accounting bases and policies which have been consistently applied; b) the statements comply with statutory requirements and relevant regulations; c) the view presented by the financial statements is consistent with the auditor's knowledge of the audited entity; and d) there is adequate disclosure of all material matters relevant to the financial statements. 11. Emphasis of Matter. In certain circumstances the auditor may consider that the reader will not obtain a proper understanding of the financial statements unless attention is drawn to unusual or important matters. As a general principle the auditor issuing an unqualified opinion does not make reference to specific aspects of the financial statements in the opinion in case this should be misconstrued as being a qualification. In order to avoid giving that impression, references which are meant as "emphasis of matter" are contained in a separate paragraph from the opinion. However, the auditor should not make use of an emphasis of matter to rectify a lack of appropriate disclosure in the financial statements, nor as an alternative to, or a substitute for, qualifying the opinion. 12. An auditor may not be able to express an unqualified opinion when any of the following circumstances exist and, in the auditor's judgement, their effect is or may be material to the financial statements: a) there has been limitation on the scope of the audit; b) the auditor considers that the statements are incomplete or misleading or there is an unjustified departure from acceptable accounting standards; or c) there is uncertainty affecting the financial statements. 13. Qualified Opinion. Where the auditor disagrees with or is uncertain about one or more particular items in the financial statements which are material but not fundamental to an understanding of the statements, a qualified opinion should be given. The wording of the opinion normally indicates a satisfactory outcome to the audit subject to a clear and concise statement of the matters of disagreement or uncertainty giving rise to the qualified opinion. It helps the users of the statements if the financial effect of the uncertainty or disagreement is quantified by the auditor although this is not always practicable or relevant. 14. Adverse Opinion. Where the auditor is unable to form an opinion on the financial statements taken as a whole due to disagreement which is so fundamental that it undermines the position presented to the extent that an opinion which is qualified in certain respects would not be adequate, an adverse opinion is given. The wording of such an opinion makes clear that the financial statements are not fairly stated, specifying clearly and concisely all the matters of disagreement. Again, it is helpful if the financial effect on the financial statements is quantified where relevant and practicable. 15. Disclaimer of Opinion. Where the auditor is unable to arrive at an opinion regarding the financial statements taken as a whole due to an uncertainty or scope restriction which is so fundamental that an opinion which is qualified in certain respects would not be adequate, a disclaimer is given. The wording of such a disclaimer makes clear that an opinion cannot be given, specifying clearly and concisely all matters of uncertainty. 16. It is customary for SAIs to provide a detailed report amplifying the opinion in circumstances in which it has been unable to give an unqualified opinion. 16 Annex 2: Prior year recommendations Audit Component Recommendation given VI. Financial Statements Compliance with reporting framework and the quality of information VII.1 Revenues The Municipality should also prepare the Financial Statements in the Serbian language. The Municipality takes steps to improve the billing and accounting systems in order to ensure safe, efficient and effective controls on billing and revenue. Improvement of the procedures related to such systems would enable the management to monitor and manage significant risks, and to ensure that decisions related to budgeting, planning and collection of revenues are properly carried out. Recommendation fully implemented Partly addressed Not addressed Not Adressed Partially adressed We recommend that the Municipality: • Implement a billing system that includes updated details about the payers, their current address, history and collection rating. Such information should be accessible only to a limited number of persons and with the authorization of the management. • Enter and centrally control the approved tariffs and tax rates in the system in order to calculate and generate the bills automatically. The generation of bills should also be authorized and reviewed. 17 Audit Component Recommendation given VII.1 Revenues (continued) • Automatically inter-connect the billing system with the accounting software so that the information is automatically processed into the general ledger. • Perform regular reconciliations between the two systems on a regular basis for all types of revenues. Any reconciling differences should be promptly followed up and cleared in a timely manner. • Automatically link the operational and billing units and perform regular reconciliations between them, in cases where the billing is directly related to services supplied by the operational units. This is especially important where a high volume of transactions is executed. • Ensure that proper procedures are applied in tax on property department regarding the new applicants register and claims handling procedures. • Ensure that uniref code invoices are issued appropriately conform the revenue items in order to present a true allocation of revenue data. VII.2.1 Purchases through Procurement VII.2.3 Remunerations (Wages and salaries) The Municipality takes further steps to improve controls over expenses and payments and strictly comply with Law on Public Procurement No 03-L-241 in order to avoid irregularities. The Municipality takes further steps to improve controls and to comply with laws and local regulatory requirements regarding personnel. Recommendation fully implemented Partly addressed Not addressed Partially adressed Partially adressed 18 Audit Component Recommendation given VII.4.3 Capital and non capital assets The Municipality makes additional efforts in relation to confirming the ownership, registration and valuation of all real estate. VIII.1 Internal Control Systems VIII.2 Audit Committee The Municipality takes further steps to improve controls over expenses and payments. The Audit Committee should report directly to the Municipal Assembly to ensure that the responsibilities are carried out with the appropriate level of independence. Recommendation fully implemented Partly addressed Not addressed Not addressed Not addressed Not addressed 19 Annex 3 Municipality of Skenderaj management comments and KPMG responses Recommendations Agree Partially agree Recommendations 1: The Municipality should prepare the Financial Statements in Serbian language. Recommendation 2: We recommend the Mayor ensures that the preparation of the Municipality’s financial statements should include procedures and tools that are designed to ensure that information required is recorded, processed, summarized and appropriately reported in the financial statements. Information on payments from third parties amounts receivable and outstanding invoices should be regularly updated and reviewed to ensure accuracy and completeness of such disclosures in the financial statements. Recommendations 3: We recommend the Mayor ensures that the Municipality takes steps to improve the billing and accounting systems in order to ensure safe, efficient and effective controls on billing and revenue. Improvement of the procedures related to such systems would enable management to monitor and manage significant risks, and to ensure that decisions related to budgeting, planning and collection of revenues are properly carried out. We recommend that the Municipality: X The Municipality recently (after the audit) prepared the financial statements in the Serbian language. X We will follow the recommendations of the auditor. X Do not agree Comments from the Municipality KPMG response Municipality of Skenderaj has an automated billing system for Taxes in Business, Public Space (Rent) and Tax on Property, which provide with details for such taxes based on the records kept, explaining the obligations, payment and the remaining amounts. While for taxes on services (administration and staff) the MLGA is preparing a unified program for all municipalities of the Republic of Kosovo. 20 Recommendations Recommendations 3 (continued): • Implement a billing system that includes updated details about the payers, their current address, history and collection rating. Such information should be accessible only to a limited number of persons and with the authorization of management.Enter and centrally control the approved tariffs and tax rates in the system in order to calculate and generate the bills automatically. The generation of bills should also be authorized and reviewed. • • • Agree Partially agree Do not Comments from the Municipality agree KPMG response X Enter and centrally control the approved tariffs and tax rates in the system in order to calculate and generate bills automatically. The generation of bills should also be authorized and reviewed. Automatically inter-connect the billing system with the accounting software so that the information is automatically processed into the general ledger. Automatically link the operational and billing units and perform regular reconciliations between them, in cases where the billing is directly related to services supplied by the operational units. This is especially important where a high volume of transactions is executed. 21 Recommendations Agree X Recommendation 4: We recommend the Mayor ensures that the Municipality takes further steps to improve controls over expenses and payments and strictly comply with laws and local regulatory requirements. Recommendation 5: We recommend that the Mayor ensures that the Municipality ensures to keep proper evidence of approval, authorization and payment of wages and salaries. X Recommendation 6: We recommend the Mayor ensures a process is designed and established, which ensures that receivables are recorded upon issuing of each invoice and that overdue amounts are followed up regularly. X X Do not agree Comments from the Municipality KPMG response Only the fifth member has not signed the acceptance report while the other four members have. This is allowed under the applicable law. The document for the execution of the contract in a procurement procedure such as “Vehicles Insurance” is not a legal obstacle, because such tariffs are determined by the CBK. Currently the Municipality has obtained all signed payment orders for payroll expenses for 2012. We will follow the recommendations of the auditor. X Recommendation 7: We recommend the Mayor to involve additional resources in the registration, control and valuation of the assets of the Municipality. Recommendation 8: We recommend the Mayor ensures that the Municipality takes further steps and compile action plans to make payments within the required period and provide with all required disclosures on invoices. Partially agree All records were made as per municipal committee reports at the beginning of the registration of property. For other assets from third parties we follow the recommendations of the auditor. We will immediately follow the recommendations of the auditor. 22 Recommendations Agree Recommendation 9: We recommend that the Audit Committee should report directly to the Municipal Assembly to ensure that the responsibilities are carried out with the appropriate level of independence. In addition, The Mayor should produce an Action Plan that should be implemented to ensure that internal audit work is done and reported on a timely basis and to address resulting recommendations, detailing responsible officers and timescales for implementation. X Partially agree Do not agree Comments from the Municipality KPMG response We will immediately follow the recommendations of the auditor. 23 Republika e Kosovës Republika Kosova-Republic of Kosovo KOMUNA SKENDERAJ OPSTINA SKENDERAJ MUNICIPALITY SKENDERAJ Financial Statements As at and for the year ended 31 December 2012 SKENDERAJ, 2013 1 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 12. Statement of Cash Receipts and Payments for the year ended 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) 2012 Payments from third parties € '000 9,358 568 134 10,060 1,254 1,254 8,994 1,253 124 10,371 7 8 9 5,949 884 173 7,006 - 10 105 2,949 10,060 1,254 1,254 2 3 4 5 6 Total Payments Operations Wages and Salaries Goods and Services Utilities Transfers Transfers and subsidies Capital expenditures Property, Plant and Equipment Other payments Return of Loans Total 11 12 13 Single treasury account KCB € '000 Payments from third parties 2010 Single treasury account KCB € '000 Notes Receipts Government Grant Own Source Revenues Fund designated for specific purpose Designated Donor Grants Borrowed Funds Other receipts 2011 3 Single treasury account KCB € '000 Payments from third parties 9,466 9,466 8,279 983 3 - 9,764 9,265 9,764 5,722 819 156 6,697 - 4,481 794 154 5,429 - 130 3,544 10,371 9,466 9,466 116 3,720 9,265 9,764 9,764 € '000 € '000 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 13. Budget Execution Report for the year ended 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) 2012 Original Budget (Appropriation) A Note Cash inflows from Treasury account Taxation Owns Source Revenues Grants and Assitance Capital Receipts Privatization Fund Borrowings Other Total Receipts collected for KCB Cash outflows from Treasury accounts Wages and Salary Goods and Services Utilities Transfers and Subsidies Capital expenditures Privatization Fund Return of Borrowings Other Total Payments made from KCB through STA Final Budget (Appropriation) B € '000 € '000 2011 2010 Payments C € '000 Variance D=C-B € '000 Payments E € '000 Payments F € '000 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 1,100 1,100 1,253 142 1,395 571 134 705 (682) (8) (690) 1,212 124 1,336 1,024 3 1,027 21 22 23 24 25 26 5,923 767 145 110 2,896 9,841 5,974 896 179 110 3,627 10,786 5,949 884 173 105 2,949 10,060 (25) (11) (6) (5) (678) (725) 5,722 818 156 130 3,545 10,371 4,481 794 154 116 3,720 9,265 27 The General Fund amounts totaling EUR 8,741 thousand for original budget, EUR 9,391 thousand for final budget and EUR 9,358 thousand for 2012 realisation (2011: 8,994 thousand, 2010: EUR 8,279 thousand;) have not been included in the Cash inflows from treasury account section in the above table, although they were used to help pay the various expenses of the Municipality presented under the Cash outflows from treasury accounts section. In the year ended 31 December 2010 such amounts were recorded as a separate category within the Cash inflows from treasury account in Section 13 Budget Execution Report. 4 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 1 General information on the budget organization and the accounting policies 1.1 Basis of preparation The financial statements have been prepared in accordance with Cash Basis IPSAS “Financial Reporting Under The Cash Basis of Accounting” and with the Financial Rule No. 07/2011 On Annual Financial Statements Of Budget Organizations. The notes to the financial statements are an integral part of these financial statements and are to be read in conjunction with them. The accounting policies have been applied consistently throughout the period. 1.2 Reporting entity The financial statements are for the public sector entity: Municipality of Skenderaj (‘the Municipality’). These financial statements comprise the Municipality pursuant to the Law for the management of Public Finance and Responsibility (03/L-048 and 03/L-211). The Municipality of Skenderaj is controlled by the Kosovo Government and all financial activities are financed from the Consolidated Budget of Kosovo (“KCB”). 1.3 Payments by Third Parties The Municipality of Skenderaj benefits from goods and services purchased on its behalf as a result of cash payments made by third parties, other than the Government, during the reporting period. The payments made by the third parties do not constitute cash receipts or payments of the Municipality. The payments are reported in the column Payment by Third Parties in the Statement of Cash Receipt and Payments. 1.4 Treasury Single Account The Municipality of Skenderaj does not operate in its own bank accounts. The Government has a centralized Treasury function, which administers the receipt of cash received by all budgetary entities during the financial year. Payments made in this account regarding the Municipality of Skenderaj are presented in the column Single Treasury Account in the Statement of Cash Receipt and Payments. 1.5 Return of expenses from the previous year The funds returned to KCB from the previous year are reported as receipts in the current year and not as reductions to expenses in the year when the expense occured. 1.6 Reporting currency The reporting currency is Euro (€) 1.7 Authorization Date The financial statements were authorized for issue on 31 January 2013 and approved by Sami Lushtaku Mayor of the Municipality, and Ismet Aliu, Finance Director. 5 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Sources of funds Note 2 General Fund Appropriation Economic classification 2012 € '000 2011 € '000 2010 € '000 Wages and Salaries Goods and Services Utilities Subsidies and transfers Capital Outlays Total 5,902 769 171 2,516 9,358 5,722 663 156 2,453 8,994 4,437 695 154 2,993 8,279 2012 € '000 2011 € '000 2010 € '000 48 17 105 398 568 81 130 1,042 1,253 44 99 116 724 983 2012 € '000 2011 € '000 2010 € '000 97 2 35 134 75 49 124 3 3 Note 3 Own Source Revenue Economic classification Wages and Salaries Goods and Services Utilities Subsidies and transfers Capital Outlays Total Note 4 Designated Donor Grants Economic classification Wages and Salaries Goods and Services Utilities Subsidies and transfers Capital Outlays Total Note 5 Borrowed Fund Lender There were no borrowed funds during 2012 6 2012 € '000 - 2011 € '000 - 2010 € '000 - - - - Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 6 Other Receipts Economic Classification USAID -/ DEMI GTZ Norwegian Embassy Ministry of Youth, Culture & Sport Ministry of Agriculture Ministry of Labour and Social Welfare Ministry of Local Government Administration Ministry of Transport and Communication Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning Ministry of Education Total 2012 € '000 2011 € '000 2010 € '000 10 138 65 340 701 24 40 200 151 211 7,790 1,050 45 23 4,200 5,496 - 1,254 9,466 9,764 Note 7 Wages and Salaries Description Payments Net Salaries Payments to unions -0.10% te 0.50% Overtime payments Part time payments Night-shift salaries Net salary for maternity leave Daily payments for Assembly and committee members Contracted payments Personal Income Tax Employer pension contribution Employee pension contribution Court decisions Total KCB € '000 2012 OSR DDG € '000 € '000 Total € '000 2011 2010 € '000 € '000 5,089 22 - 48 - - 5,137 22 - 4,948 21 - 3,910 16 - 224 283 283 5,901 48 - 224 283 283 5,949 209 272 272 5,722 128 213 214 4,481 7 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 8 Goods and Services Description Payments Expenses for travel within the country Expenses for travel abroad Per Diem of official travel abroad Accomodation of official travel abroad Other expenses for official travel abroad Internet expenses Telephone expenses Postal expenses Training expenses Other contractual services Technical services Membership expenses (AKK) Copying machine under EUR 1000 Trafic equipment under EUR 1000 Trafic equipment over EUR 1000 Other equipment under EUR 1000 Furniture under EUR 1000 Computers under EUR 1000 Furniture from EUR 1000-5000 Computer from EUR 1000-5000 Hardware for IT Photocopy machine Specialized medical equipment Traffic equipment up to EUR 5000 Other equipment up to EUR 5000 Office supplies Supply with food and drinks Medical supplies Cleaning supplies Waredrobe supplies Accommodation Funeral expenses Oil Central heating oil Heating oil Coal Wood Fuel for generators Balance carried forward KCB € '000 2012 OSR DDG € '000 € '000 1 4 7 5 1 1 13 2 138 2 1 4 5 10 22 93 12 8 20 4 3 43 24 84 9 516 10 1 5 16 8 - 2011 2010 Total € '000 € '000 € '000 1 4 7 5 1 1 13 2 138 2 1 4 5 10 22 93 22 8 21 4 3 48 24 84 9 532 2 3 2 1 15 3 146 3 4 10 8 9 109 17 9 15 5 4 51 16 67 5 504 1 8 2 12 2 2 179 4 2 2 1 16 7 120 13 13 16 2 8 45 20 47 7 529 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 8 Goods and Services (continued) Description Balance brought forward Vehicle fuel Advances for official travels Registration and maintenance of vehicles Registration and insurance of vehicles Old building insurance Vehicle maintenance School maintenance Maintenance & reparation of buildings Maintenance of local roads Highway maintenance Rent for land IT maintenance Maintenance of furniture and equipment Advertisement and notifications Publication Official lunch Court decision expenses Computer under EUR 1000 Other telephone expenses Contractual services Technical services Furniture under EUR 1000 Other equipment under EUR 1000 Office supplies Other ezpenses Food and drink expenses Cleaning supplies Advertisement and notification Advance for PC Registration and insurance of vehicles Insurance of other buildings Vehicle maintenance Official lunch Maintenance and reparation Total KCB € '000 516 90 2 4 7 26 11 21 14 9 2 30 4 5 28 769 2012 OSR DDG € '000 € '000 16 2 1 23 2 11 1 4 3 9 42 1 18 97 9 2011 Total € '000 532 90 2 4 7 2 26 11 21 14 9 2 30 4 5 28 1 23 2 11 1 4 3 9 42 1 884 € '000 504 81 5 8 22 3 28 4 2 1 23 3 15 42 3 31 18 4 9 10 1 1 1 819 2010 € '000 529 65 1 8 31 47 5 14 1 1 30 5 11 39 7 794 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 9 Utilities Description Electricity Water Telephone Waste Total KCB € '000 2012 OSR DDG € '000 € '000 2011 2010 Total € '000 € '000 € '000 2 2 108 29 13 23 173 87 32 11 26 156 80 31 15 28 154 2012 OSR DDG € '000 € '000 2011 2010 Total € '000 € '000 € '000 45 85 130 5 52 59 116 106 29 13 23 171 - Note 10 Transfers and Subsidies Description Payments Subsidies Subsidies for public entities Subsidies for cultural entities Subsidies for non-public entities Transfers for other governments Payments for individual beneficiaries Base pensions Disabled pensions Pensions or social assistance Pensions of TMK Pensions of I category (family members) Pensions of II category (family members) Payments for war invalids Payments for civil invalids Payments for war victims families Trepca provisional pensions Court Decisions Total KCB € '000 - 37 68 105 10 - 37 68 105 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 11 Property, Plant, and Equipment Description KCB € '000 Payments Residencial buildings Non-residencial building Other structures Road constructions Sidewalks Sewage Water Energy, generators, transfers and supplies Equipment over EUR 1000 – furniture Transportation vehicles Machinery Other capital IT equipment Other equipment Land Intangable assets Capital transfers for public entities Capital transfers for non public entities Court decisions Total 20 365 1,941 18 2 101 17 52 2,516 2012 OSR DDG THPP € '000 € '000 € '000 112 27 207 20 10 15 7 398 12 3 14 1 5 35 701 50 503 1,254 2011 2010 Total € '000 € '000 € '000 144 395 2,849 18 72 627 33 65 4,203 785 1,645 9,533 104 184 16 141 464 9 73 10 46 13,010 5,110 765 69 6,859 35 89 203 31 116 45 23 133 6 13,484 Note 12 Other payments There were no other payments during the year 2012 or previous years. Note 13 Return of loans 2012 € '000 - Description Lender 1 Lender 2 Lender 3 Total 2011 € '000 - 2010 € '000 - Note 14 Taxation Description Tax Revenues 1 Tax Revenues 2 Tax Revenues 3 Total Note 2012 2011 2010 € '000 - € '000 - € '000 - % of total 2012 % % % 0% Note: The table relates only to taxes related to Customs and Tax Administration of Kosovo (“TAK”) 11 % change from 2011 % % % % Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 15 Own source revenues Description Tax on Property Participation in health Municipality taxes for construction license Municipality tax for businesses Taxes for the registration of vehicles Other civil fees for certificates Tax for change of owner Tax for registration of heritage Tax for birth certificate Tax for death certificate Use of public property Participation on education Inspections and field measurements Tax for marriage certificates License for technical premises Administrative tax for request form Tax for participation in tender Fines by inspection Rent from public facilities Revenues from traffic fines Consession revenues Revenues from court fines Revenues from forestry agency Total Own source revenue carried forward from previous years 2012 2011 2010 € '000 € '000 € '000 % of total 2012 % change from 2011 117 16 62 64 56 25 22 28 23 21 10 10 1 21 1 10 17 67 571 138 19 53 89 63 26 11 25 22 13 20 10 9 5 5 3 3 1 24 631 42 1,212 92 11 118 68 45 36 12 23 22 1 5 18 7 11 8 6 3 2 1 42 441 51 1 1,024 20.49 2.80 10.86 11.21 9.81 4.38 3.85 4.90 4.03 3.68 1.75 1.75 0.18 3.68 0.18 1.75 2.98 11.91 100 (15.22) (15.79) 16.98 (28.09) (11.11) (3.85) (100.00) (12.00) 27.27 76.92 5.00 11.11 (80.00) 320.00 (100.00) (66.67) 900.00 (29.17) (100.00) 60.00 (52.89) 154 195 154 Own source revenues presented in Section 13, for the year 2010 have been restated from EUR 829 thousand to EUR 1,024 thousand. Concession revenues for the year 2011 and 2010 represents revenue from concession of Municipal properties to private businesses for a period of 99 years. As per agreements, the Municipality benefited 21% of the value of such investments as own source revenue. No such revenues were recognized for 2012. Note: The above table does not include grants received from other donors through the Municipality account. Such revenue was disclosed in Note 16 in the following page. 12 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 16 Grants and Assistance Source of Funds World Bank UNOPS European Council Code 94118 96701 99307 PTK Civil participation Kosovo Insurance Bureau Unused funds nil 86122 86122 Description School supplies Registration of population Municipal center BF Presenation in Culture, Youth and Sports Participation project BM House construction Total 2012 € '000 10 100 2011 € '000 25 4 195 2010 € '000 195 5 15 12 (8) 134 1 (101) 124 3 3 (198) 3 Note: An amount of EUR 100 thousand relates to a project of the previous year (European Council RCFB). The Grant related to Presentation in Culture, Youth and Sport Department was not allocated because it was granted by the end of the year. In total EUR 8 thousand remain unspent, which consists of EUR 3 thousand from European Council and EUR 5 thousand from Post and Telecommunication of Kosovo (“PTK”). Note 17 Capital receipts 2012 € '000 - Asset Type Land Buildings Infrastructure Machinery Equipment Transport vehicles Other Total - Profit from Sale 2011 € '000 - 2010 € '000 - Note 18 Privatization fund Profit from Privatization 2012 2011 2010 € '000 € '000 € '000 POE POE #1 POE #2 POE #3 POE #4 POE #5 Total - 13 - - Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 19 Borrowings Description Lender 1 Lender 2 Lender 3 Lender 4 Lender 5 Total 2012 € '000 - 2011 € '000 - 2010 € '000 - 2012 € '000 2011 € '000 2010 € '000 - - - Note 20 Other Receipt type Lottery games deposit Regulatory committee deposit Ministry of Justice deposit Other deposit Expropriation Total An amount of EUR 118 thousand was transferred using Municipality account, from Treasury to an economic operator in Skenderaj, namely “Vellezerit Geci” for the expropriation of the construction material factory. Consequently this transaction is only a transfer through Municipal account but it does not represent cash inflow or outflow of Municipal funds. Note 21 to Section 27 Unlike notes 11 -16, these notes are used to explain material difference in column D on the Budget Execution Report, ie material differences in budget realizations. Depending on the size of the difference, there is no need to offer explanations for all categories. 21. Difference between payments and final budget for wages and salaries Salaries and wages are lower than anticipated by EUR 25 thousand. This is due to decrease in number of pupils in schools and consequently decrease in number of teachers. Two classes were closed, in village of Syrigane and Llaushe. Furthermore the number of maternity paid leaves was lower than anticipated. 22. Difference between payments and final budget for goods and services Goods and services were lower by EUR 11 thousand mainly due to spending in the Culture, Youth and Sports and Education department being lower by EUR 8 and EUR 3 thousand unused funds from the donor funds due to late receipt of these funds. 23. Difference between payments and final budget for utilities Municipal expenses were lower by EUR 6 thousand. This is mainly due to unused funds by the education department. 14 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 14. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) 24. Difference between payments and final budget for transfers and subsidies There is a difference of EUR 5 thousand between the budgeted and expenses for subsidies. This is mainly due to unused funds for schoolarships in the department of education. 25. Difference between payments and final budget for capital expenditure Capital expenditures were lower by EUR 678 thousand. This is maninly due to source of funding of such expenditure being lower than planned. Actual own source revenues were EUR 529 lower than initially planned. In addition 149 thousand of own source revenues realized in December 2012 were not able to be allocated for finance of capital expenditures and were carried forward to be spent in the year 2013. 26. Difference between payments and final budget for privatization fund There are no differences in this economic category. 27. Difference between payments and final budget for other funds There are no differences in this economic category. 15 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Section 15 Disclosure of liabilities Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA Summary Economic category 13210 13220 13230 13250 13310 13320 13460 13470 13503 13506 13509 13610 13620 13630 13640 13720 13720 13770 13780 14010 14020 14023 14040 14050 14120 14210 14230 14310 13141 21200 30000 Description Electricity Water Waste PTK Internet Mobile phone“Ipko” Other contractual services Technical services Computers Medical equipment Other equipment Office supplies Food supplies Medical Supply Cleaning supplies Central heating Wood Generator fuel Vehicle fuel Maintenance and reparation of vehicles Facility maintenance School maintenance IT maintenance Furniture and equipment maintenance Land Advertising Public information Official lunch Per diem Total : goods and services Subsidies Capital Total 1) Attached to these financial statements is the annex 1 with details of upaid invoices. 16 2012 € '000 9.79 0.63 0.87 0.73 0.01 1.23 20.1 0.44 0.4 0.08 1.52 6.5 5.63 0.06 0.69 1.98 0.76 0.6 18.99 8.17 0.12 2.77 0.08 1.17 1.44 1.19 0.13 6.62 0.25 93 4 1,406 1,503 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date 21.05.2012 22/12 13460 14.07.2012 Supplier Association of Municipalities 06.09.2012 0030817 14310 17.10.2012 NTSH Valentina 0.07 12.11.2012 12-210-001-1007 13780 23.12.2012 Alfa Trade 0.12 10.08.2012 12-210-001-707 13503 30.11.2012 Info Com 0.40 22.11.2012 12-210-001-1025 13780 23.12.2012 Alfa Trade 0.67 16.11.2012 319/12 13610 29.12.2012 NTL Rilindja 0.33 20.11.2012 330/12 13610 30.12.2012 NTL Rilindja 0.37 29.12.2012 348/12 13610 03.01.2013 NTL Rilindja 0.21 27.11.2012 62/12 13610 03.01.2013 DPT Blini 0.28 26.11.2012 12-Oct 13610 03.01.2013 Foto Kabashi 0.22 07.12.2012 24/12 14010 10.01.2013 Auto Washing Labi 0.24 01.11.2012 10/2012-k.k.s 13310 27.12.2012 0.01 29.11.2012 666-2012 14230 10.01.2013 PTK Office of the Prime Minister 01.11.2012 300/2012 13640 10.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.08 30.11.2012 0165920 13320 10.01.2013 IPKO 0.67 06.09.2012 0068008 14310 27.10.2012 NTSH Valentina 0.19 22.10.2012 0030931 14310 13.12.2012 NTSH Valentina 0.23 28.10.2012 0030937 14310 11.01.2013 NTSH Valentina 0.27 07.11.2012 0030839 14310 11.01.2013 NTSH Valentina 0.19 28.11.2012 0030838 14310 11.01.2013 NTSH Valentina 0.37 21.11.2012 12-Jan 14010 26.12.2012 Fullda 0.05 15.11.2012 034/12 14010 26.12.2012 Fullda 0.05 21.11.2012 38/12 14010 26.12.2012 Fullda 0.36 21.11.2012 12.12.2012 37/12 0061577 14010 14310 26.12.2012 20.01.2013 Fullda Freskia SHPK 0.07 0.02 17 Amount 3.96 0.04 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date 11.12.2012 17/12 13610 20.01.2013 11.12.2012 62/12 14050 18.10.2012 06.12.2012 132/2012 12-210-0011128 12-110-0011129 28.12.2012 Supplier Amount 0.30 20.01.2013 Foto Kabashi NTSH Urban Teknology 20.01.2013 NTSH Doni Comerc 0.11 13780 24.01.2013 Alfa Trade SHPK 0.34 13780 24.01.2013 Alfa Trade SHPK 1.30 0019833 13460 28.01.2013 Radio Drenica 0.60 28.12.2012 00198839 14210 28.01.2013 Radio Drenica 0.15 28.12.2012 00198834 14210 28.01.2013 Radio Drenica 0.10 28.12.2012 00198837 14210 28.01.2013 Radio Drenica 0.10 28.12.2012 0019836 14210 28.01.2013 Radio Drenica 0.10 28.12.2012 0019835 14210 28.01.2013 Radio Drenica 0.10 19.11.2012 326/12 14210 28.01.2013 NTL Rilindja 0.11 28.12.2012 2/2012 14120 28.01.2013 Naser Deliu 1.44 30.11.2012 321/2012 13620 28.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.14 31.10.2012 13620 28.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.01 13780 08.02.2013 Alfa Trade SHPK 2.44 13780 08.02.2013 Alfa Trade SHPK 0.94 13780 08.02.2013 Alfa Trade SHPK 0.31 13780 08.02.2013 Alfa Trade SHPK 0.18 31.12.2012 290/2012 12-210-001-1183 12-210-0011182 12-210-0011188 12-210-0011185 12-210-0011187 13780 08.02.2013 Alfa Trade SHPK 0.12 31.12.2012 0019473 14230 08.02.2013 Rilindja SHPK 0.06 27.12.2012 1-2/12321 13620 09.02.2013 NTP Arieta 2.43 29.12.2012 358/2012 13620 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.21 31.12.2012 18.12.2012 0170110 02/nr.120-1134 13320 13141 09.02.2013 30.12.2012 IPKO Bahri Hasani 0.56 0.04 06.12.2012 31.12.2012 31.12.2012 31.12.2012 31.12.2012 18 0.07 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date Supplier Amount 18.12.2012 02/nr.120-1135 13141 30.12.2012 Bahri Hasani 0.04 19.12.2012 02/nr.120-42 13141 31.12.2012 Halit Xhema 0.16 20.12.2012 4492364 13210 12.01.2013 KEK 0.12 20.12.2012 4492365 13210 12.01.2013 KEK 0.13 20.12.2012 4492366 13210 12.01.2013 KEK 0.13 20.12.2012 4492367 13210 12.01.2013 KEK 0.12 20.12.2012 4492361 13210 12.01.2013 KEK 0.12 20.12.2012 4492362 13210 12.01.2013 KEK 0.31 20.12.2012 4492363 13210 12.01.2013 KEK 0.12 20.12.2012 4471321 13210 24.01.2013 KEK 0.07 31.12.2012 4520539 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.98 31.12.2012 4520521 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.00 31.12.2012 4520525 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.00 31.12.2012 4533534 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.02 31.12.2012 4535582 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.02 31.12.2012 4539360 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.34 31.12.2012 4520520 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 2.46 31.12.2012 4534496 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.01 31.12.2012 4539051 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.08 31.12.2012 4539044 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.55 31.12.2012 4536879 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.03 31.12.2012 4533619 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.04 31.12.2012 4539381 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.39 31.12.2012 31.12.2012 4538794 4538789 13210 13210 08.02.2012 08.02.2012 KEK KEK 1.47 0.40 19 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date Supplier Amount 31.12.2012 4539045 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.31 31.12.2012 4538748 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.26 31.12.2012 4540342 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.02 31.12.2012 4540345 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.01 31.12.2012 4540346 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.01 31.12.2012 4540347 13210 08.02.2012 KEK 0.11 31.12.2012 467/sk 13230 26.01.2013 Uniteti KRMH 0.17 31.12.2012 468/sk 13230 26.01.2013 Uniteti KRMH 0.13 31.12.2012 469/sk 13230 26.01.2013 Uniteti KRMH 0.19 31.12.2012 470/sk 13230 26.01.2013 Uniteti KRMH 0.14 31.12.2012 473/sk 13230 26.01.2013 Uniteti KRMH 0.03 31.12.2012 474/sk 13230 26.01.2013 Uniteti KRMH 0.01 31.12.2012 471/sk 13230 26.01.2013 Uniteti KRMH 0.03 31.12.2012 472/sk 13230 26.01.2013 Uniteti KRMH 0.17 05.12.2012 287594352012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.08 05.12.2012 287742612012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.01 05.12.2012 287550852012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.01 05.12.2012 287369812012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.01 05.12.2012 287385782012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.02 05.12.2012 287369802012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.08 05.12.2012 05.12.2012 287763322012 2873860722012 13250 13250 27.01.2013 27.01.2013 PTK PTK 0.04 0.02 20 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date Supplier Amount 05.12.2012 287550842012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.02 05.12.2012 287720642012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.03 05.12.2012 287789842012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.02 05.12.2012 287369792012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.01 05.12.2012 287593992012 13250 27.01.2013 PTK 0.30 31.12.2012 287524532012 13250 04.02.2013 PTK 0.04 31.12.2012 287604772012 13250 04.02.2013 PTK 0.00 15.12.2012 11/2012-K.K.S 13250 19.01.2013 PTK 0.01 22.06.2012 169/2012 21200 05.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 22.06.2012 168/2012 21200 05.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 22.06.2012 167/2012 21200 05.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.08 27.06.2012 175/2012 21200 05.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 06.06.2012 153/2012 21200 05.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 08.06.2012 154/2012 21200 07.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 11.05.2012 131/2012 21200 07.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.11 07.05.2012 125/2012 21200 07.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 8.05.20112 127/2012 21200 07.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.02 10.09.2012 218/2012 21200 12.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 31.08.2012 209/2012 21200 18.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.09 29.08.2012 204/2012 21200 18.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 19.09.2012 244/2012 21200 6/3/1907 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.06 26.09.2012 250/2012 21200 29.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.03 11.10.2012 263/2012 21200 30.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 17.10.2012 17.10.2012 272/2012 271/2012 21200 21200 30.11.2012 30.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.02 0.03 21 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date Supplier Amount 05.10.2012 260/2012 21200 30.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.07 16.10.2012 270/2012 21200 30.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 16.10.2012 269/2012 21200 30.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.06 05.10.2012 261/2012 21200 30.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.08 21.09.2012 247/2012 21200 29.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.03 31.10.2012 285/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 31.10.2012 284/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 15.11.2012 304/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.06 31.10.2012 286/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 31.10.2012 283/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 31.10.2012 288/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 15.11.2012 305/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.03 31.10.2012 291/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.06 0.511.2012 302/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 31.10.2012 289/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.06 31.10.2012 287/2012 21200 29.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.06 23.11.2012 314/2012 21200 10.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.06 23.11.2012 315/2012 21200 10.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 05.10.2012 259/2012 21200 10.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 23.11.2012 312/2012 21200 03.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.18 23.11.2012 313/2012 21200 03.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.18 30.11.2012 323/2012 21200 28.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 03.12.2012 325/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.07 03.12.2012 03.12.2012 326/2012 327/2012 21200 21200 08.02.2013 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 0.05 22 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date Supplier Amount 05.12.2012 329/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 05.12.2012 330/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 12.12.2012 333/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 17.12.2012 336/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 17.12.2012 337/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 18.12.2012 338/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 20.12.2012 342/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 05.12.2012 328/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 19.12.2012 339/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 19.12.2012 340/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 19.12.2012 341/2012 21200 08.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 24.12.2012 345/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 24.12.2012 346/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 27.12.2012 347/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 27.12.2012 348/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.20 27.12.2012 349/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.20 28.12.2012 356/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.20 28.12.2012 352/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 28.12.2012 350/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 28.12.2012 351/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 28.12.2012 353/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.01 28.12.2012 357/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.06 29.12.2012 358/2012 21200 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.21 01.11.2012 07.12.2012 011/12 23/12 13460 14010 06.01.2013 07.01.2013 NT "Memi Reisen " Auto Washing " Albi " 0.85 0.01 23 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date 30.11.2012 19470 12-210-0011130 14230 10.01.2013 "Rilindja" Shpk-shpernd 0.03 13780 24.01.2013 "alfa trade " Shpk 0.17 13620 26.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.03 31.12.2012 316/2012 12-210-0011184 13780 08.02.2013 "alfa trade " Shpk 0.17 27.12.2012 1-2/12322 13610 09.02.2013 NTP "Arjeta " 1.57 20.07.2012 92/2012 13509 20.08.2012 NSHT " Doni Comerce " 0.80 19.10.2012 276/2012 13640 19.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.03 24.10.2012 277/2012 13620 24.11.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.18 24.10.2012 13640 24.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.03 08.11.2012 278/2012 12-210-0011005 14050 08.12.2012 alfa trade Shpk 0.10 09.11.2012 299/2012 13640 09.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.02 09.11.2012 298/2012 13620 09.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.20 16.11.2012 308/2012 13620 16.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.26 16.11.2012 309/2012 13640 16.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 23.11.2012 310/2012 13620 23.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.19 23.11.2012 311/2012 13640 23.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 30.11.2012 320/2012 13640 30.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 30.11.2012 319/2012 13620 30.12.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.56 27.11.2012 68019 14310 27.12.2012 NTSH " Valentina " 0.12 07.12.2012 332/2012 13640 07.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.02 07.12.2012 13620 07.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.28 12.12.2012 331/2012 12-210-0011107 13720 12.01.2013 alfa trade Shpk 1.98 17.12.2012 334/2012 13620 17.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.18 17.12.2012 21.12.2012 335/2012 344/2012 13640 13640 17.01.2013 21.01.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare NTSH "Tradition Tarde 0.03 0.03 06.12.2012 23.11.2012 24 Supplier Amount Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date Supplier Amount 21.12.2012 343/2012 13620 21.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.18 28.12.2012 355/2012 13640 28.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.01 28.12.2012 354/2012 13620 28.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.37 05.12.2012 28716674 13250 05.02.2013 SHA PTK 0.02 31.12.2012 246309 13220 05.02.2013 KUR "Mitrovica " 0.22 01.10.2012 31/12 13610 10.02.2013 De Rada 0.15 05.12.2012 246308 13210 10.01.2013 KEK-u 0.87 13220 28.01.2013 KUR "Mitrovica" 0.16 31.12.2012 11.10.2012 280/12 13610 11.11.2012 NTL "Rilindja" 0.40 28.10.2012 12-210-001-897 13770 28.11.2012 " alfa trade " Shpk 0.41 02.11.2012 004/12 14210 02.12.2012 FVR "Kabashi" 0.53 07.11.2012 1067 14023 07.12.2012 NTP " Agrocoop" 2.77 17.09.2012 68006 14310 15.12.2012 NTSH " Valentina " 1.00 10.12.2012 035/12 13760 10.01.2013 " Dervishaj " Sh.P 0.76 0 197/12 14020 12.01.2013 NSHT "Doni Comerce" 0.12 12.12.2012 1106 14050 12.01.2013 " alfa trade " Shpk 1.00 04.06.2012 003/12 13460 15.01.2013 NT " Memi Reisen " 0.17 12.09.2012 37/12 13610 02.01.2013 NTSH "Europa 91" 0.14 04.06.2012 001/12 13460 17.01.2013 NT " Memi Reisen " 0.09 03.07.2012 68292 14310 03.01.2013 NTSH " Valentina " 0.02 05.10.2012 262/2012 13620 17.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.16 11.09.2012 223/2012 13620 17.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.03 30.09.2012 192033 13220 17.01.2013 KUR "Mitrovica" 0.04 31.10.2012 221002 13220 17.01.2012 KUR "Mitrovica" 0.10 25 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date Supplier Amount 30.11.2012 223737 13220 17.01.2013 KUR "Mitrovica" 0.06 31.12.2012 246325 13220 09.02.2013 KUR "Mitrovica" 0.06 04.06.2012 002/12 13460 17.01.2013 NT " Memi Reisen " 0.17 16.11.2012 36/012 13460 16.12.2012 NPT " Meti Benz " 0.17 08.12.2012 68474 14310 08.01.2013 DPHGJ " Freskimi " 0.10 16.11.2012 61569 14310 16.01.2013 SHPK "Freskia " 0.25 05.12.2012 DMI- 9006163 13210 14.01.2013 KEK-u 0.10 05.12.2012 DMI- 9039132 13210 14.01.2013 KEK-u 0.04 07.11.2012 005/12 13610 19.12.2012 NTP "Agrotoli" 0.04 02.11.2012 004/12 13610 19.12.2012 NTP "Agrotoli" 0.04 31.10.2012 12-210-001-910 13780 13.12.2012 alfa trade Shpk 0.66 05.12.2012 DMI- 9006135 13210 11.01.2013 KEK-u 0.11 05.12.2012 DMI- 9006167 13210 11.01.2013 KEK-u 0.04 31.12.2012 360/2012 13620 09.02.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.09 30.11.2012 012/12 13460 03.01.2013 Foto Kabashi 0.91 03.12.2012 13/12 13460 03.01.2013 Foto Kabashi 0.28 05.08.2012 189/12 13640 11.10.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.31 31.12.2012 246316 13220 09.02.2013 KUR "Mitrovica" 0.01 04.06.2012 004/12 13460 17.01.2013 NT " Memi Reisen " 0.26 31.10.2012 12-210-001-755 13770 13.12.2012 alfa trade Shpk 0.10 20.11.2012 002/2012 13770 20.12.2012 alfa trade Shpk 0.05 31.07.2012 016/12 13460 31.08.2012 Security Code Shpk 2.56 31.08.2012 017/12 13460 31.09.2012 Security Code Shpk 2.56 30.09.2012 018/12 13460 30.10.2012 Security Code Shpk 2.48 26 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date Supplier Amount 31.10.2012 019/12 13460 31.11.2012 Security Code Shpk 2.56 30.11.2012 020/12 13460 30.12.2012 Security Code Shpk 2.48 27.11.2012 317/12 13620 27.01.2013 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.04 27.11.2012 318/12 13620 27.01.2012 NTSH Tradita Tregtare 0.05 15.11.2012 12-220-001-127 13509 19.12.2012 INFOCOM 0.72 11.02.2012 020/12 14010 11.03.2012 "Fulda" 0.54 09.02.2012 015/12 14010 09.03.2012 "Fulda" 0.20 10.02.2012 018/12 14010 10.03.2012 "Fulda" 0.30 13.02.2012 021/12 14010 13.03.2012 "Fulda" 0.51 16.03.2012 029/12 14010 16.04.2012 "Fulda" 0.24 20.03.2012 038/12 14010 20.04.2012 "Fulda" 0.49 21.03.2012 042/12 14010 21.04.2012 "Fulda" 0.17 19.03.2012 037/12 14010 19.04.2012 "Fulda" 0.26 07.08.2012 0.1/2012 14010 07.09.2012 "Fulda" 0.18 16.10.2012 032/12 14010 16.10.2012 "Fulda" 0.22 05.09.2012 010/12 14010 05.10.2012 "Fulda" 0.36 07.08.2012 0'9/2012 14010 07.09.2012 "Fulda" 0.74 28.06.2012 4/8/2012 14010 28.07.2012 "Fulda" 0.11 11.07.2012 05/2012 14010 11.08.2012 "Fulda" 0.49 20.06.2012 3/8/2012 14010 20.07.2012 "Fulda" 0.31 16.10.2012 031/12 14010 16.11.2012 "Fulda" 0.16 14.09.2012 022/12 14010 14.10.2012 "Fulda" 0.52 16.10.2012 030/12 14010 16.11.2012 "Fulda" 0.23 15.09.2012 023/12 14010 15.10.2012 "Fulda" 0.14 27 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date Supplier Amount 24.09.2012 024/12 14010 24.10.2012 "Fulda" 0.42 21.11.2012 12-Apr 14010 21.12.2012 "Fulda" 0.28 21.11.2012 12-Feb 14010 21.12.2012 "Fulda" 0.07 22.11.2012 12-May 14010 22.12.2012 "Fulda" 0.22 22.11.2012 12-Jul 14010 22.12.2012 "Fulda" 0.03 22.11.2012 12-Jun 14010 22.12.2012 "Fulda" 0.07 31.10.2012 12-210-001-967 13780 31.11.2012 "Alfa-Trade" 3.66 30.10.2012 12-210-001-966 13780 31.11.2012 "Alfa-Trade" 0.24 03.11.2012 21/12 14010 03.12.2012 "Albi" 0.14 03.11.2012 14010 03.12.2012 "Albi" 0.03 13780 03.01.2013 "Alfa-Trade" 3.30 13780 31.01.2013 "Alfa-Trade" 3.82 13780 26.01.2012 "Alfa-Trade" 0.35 31.12.2012 22/12 12-210-0011131 12-210-0011181 12-210-0011135 12-210-0011180 13780 31.01.2012 "Alfa-Trade" 0.21 21.12.2012 23394 13620 31.01.2013 0.03 26.07.2012 101/12-e 13470 26.08.32012 "Freskia" Institute of Medicine for Worker 10.12.2012 458/012 13140 10.01.2013 Zenun Shala 0.04 10.12.2012 457/012 13140 10.01.2012 Qazim Behrami 0.04 10.12.2012 456/2012 13140 10.01.2012 Xhavit Durmishi 0.04 18.09.2012 6266 13506 18.10.2012 "Koslabor" 0.05 28.12.2012 7449 13506 28.01.2012 "Koslabor" 0.03 01.11.2012 302/12 13610 01.12.2012 "Rilindja" 1.11 30.11.2012 12-210-MIT-66 14040 30.12.2012 "Info-com" 0.08 30.11.2012 384/2012 13610 30.12.2012 "Litografija" 1.35 20.12.2012 31.12.2012 26.12.2012 28 0.17 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 28 Reporting obligations under the LPFMA (continued) Details of unpaid invoice Invoice Date Invoice No. Economic code Due date Supplier Amount 23.11.2012 12-Jan 13630 23.12.2012 "Lindi" 0.06 23.11.2012 68016 14310 23.12.2012 "Valentina" 0.07 06.09.2012 F-365QK/2012 14310 06.10.2012 "Bio-lab" 2.16 31.12.2012 418 14310 31.01.2013 "Koslabor" 0.53 31.12.2012 451 14310 31.01.2013 "Koslabor" 0.53 31.12.2012 2376 14310 31.01.2013 "Koslabor" 0.53 31.12.201 112/11-E 13470 31.01.2012 Institute of staff healthcare 0.07 12.12.2012 153/12-E 13470 12.01.2013 Institute of staff healthcare 0.04 17.05.2012 71/12-E 13470 17.06.2012 Institute of staff healthcare 0.07 11.05.2012 46/5-E 13470 11.06.2012 Institute of staff healthcare 0.09 Outstanding liabilities from capital investments Capital Project Asphalting of road in Prekaz –Mikushnice –Lubaves 227 Capital Project Asphalting of road in Vojnik segment I 48 Capital Project Contraction of the municipality building 340 Capital Project Constriction of Primary School “Shote Galica “ in Runik 214 Capital Project Constriction of Primary School “Shaban Jashari “ in Skenderaj 577 Total 1,503 Note 29: Contingent Liabilities Contingent Liability Type Property disputes Dispute of payment of wages Hotel service litigations Elementary school child Company “Çlirimi” Debt compensation claims Execution requests Total Reason for Liabilities Life insurance Miscellaneous claims 2012 € '000 45 10 33 190 35 313 Contingent liabilities represent the total value subject to litigations which are currently in court. 29 2011 € '000 144 8 4 33 189 2010 € '000 33 29 62 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Section 16 Disclosure of Property, Plant and Equipment Note 30: Summary of non-financial capital assets (at values above EUR 1,000) in possession of the budget organization 2012 € '000 20,513 70,612 25,721 943 5 1,838 38 21 4 15 9 281 5,168 125,168 Assets Classification Building Land Road infrastructure Sidewalks Sewage Machinery Water Other equipment Medical equipment Photocopy machine Generator Computer Vehicle Other structures Other capital Total Note: 1) 2) 2011 € '000 35,104 70,612 23,053 185 6 1,964 140 3,034 66 16 720 185 4,575 139,660 2010 € '000 38,168 70,299 22,502 261 254 7 1,955 253 3 11 1,251 136 3,601 29 138,730 The source of information is the property registry for values greater than 1000 Euro in KFMIS Attached to these financial statements is the annex 2 with details of property, plant and equipment at values above EUR 1,000 Euro Note 31: Summary of non-financial assets valued under EUR 1,000 and useful life of more than one year Non capital assets (valued less than EUR 1,000) 2012 € '000 3,948 3,948 Assets Classification Equipment and furniture Total Note: 1) 2011 € '000 1,117 1,117 2010 € '000 863 863 The source of information is the property registry for values less than 1000 Euro of the Budget Organisation. 30 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Details of property, plant and equipment at values under EUR 1,000 Euro No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 Assets in Education Department, Schools Primary School Enver Haliti Lubovec Primary School Faik Braga Leqinë Primary School Faik Braga Leqinë Primary School Ilir Lushtaku Prekaz Posh. Primary School Azem Bejta Prekaz Eperm Primary School Malush Ahmeti Rezallë Primary School Deshm.Qyqav. Krasmirovc Dashevc Qirez Primary School Kuvendi D. Murgë Abri e Poshtme Primary School "2 Korriku" Ticë Primary School Skender S. " Vojnikë Izbicë Primary School "Shota Galica " Kastriot" Runik Surigan Radishev Primary School "Drenica " Polac" Polac te Lisat Morinë Primary School "Shaban Jashari" Skenderaj Primary School Elena Gjika" Makerrmal" Primary School "Fehmi Rama " Likoc Primary School "Bashkim Sad" Tushilë D>E.F.ZH. Department of Culture Youth and Sport Department of Education Department of urbanization Department of Public services Department of Administration Department of Geodesy Mayor Office Department of Health Kindergarten Q.P.M.Social Amount in EUR '000 8 136 5 78 1,072 34 5 2 11 3 35 47 20 4 1 1,573 4 6 35 12 7 85 21 29 9 31 17 12 9 55 89 22 8 450 9 4 3,948 Total 31 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Note 32: Summary of inventory at end of the period Inventory 2012 € '000 - Asset Classification Inventory Total 2011 € '000 - 2010 € '000 - Note 33: Unjustified Loans and advances Issue Date No of CPO 2012 € '000 Purpose Total - Note 34: Receivables (applies to organizations that collect revenue) 2012 Economic Code 40110 50201 50405 Description Property tax Municipal tax for businesses Use of public property - Rent Debtors Multiple Multiple Multiple €'000 399 190 103 Total 692 Note: 1) source of information is the register of accounts receivable to Budget Organisation. Section 17 Note 35 Summary of Carried Forward Own Source Revenues Plus Minus Own source revenues carried over from last year Own Source Revenues received this year by section 15 Total available for sharing in the current year The amount spent in the current year The amount left for transfer 32 2012 € '000 154 571 725 2011 € '000 195 1,212 1,407 2010 € '000 154 1,024 1,178 (568) 157 (1,253) 154 (983) 195 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Section 18 Note 36 Reconciliation between Original and Final Budget Appropriations Appropriation Category Revenues Own source revenues Designated donor grants Capital receipts Privatization funds Other Expenses Wages and Salaries Goods and services Public services Transfers and subsidies Capital expenditures Privatization funds Other Total Changes authorized by LPFMA Initial Changed Changed Changes budget according to according according Changes Changes for disposal of article 29 to article 30 to article 31 of owns donor Law no. Law no. source grants (Law on Law no. Budget) 03/L-048 03/L-048 03/L-048 revenue defined € '000 € '000 € '000 € '000 € '000 Changes for other sources of finance Final Budget Appropria tion KFMIS EUR ’000 Adjustment from Original Budget EUR ’000 1,100 1,100 - - - 153 153 142 142 - 1,253 142 1,395 13.9% 100.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 26.8% 5,923 767 145 110 2,896 9,841 11 16 623 650 14 16 (30) - - 51 102 153 104 2 36 142 - 5,974 896 179 110 3,627 10,786 0.9% 16.8% 23.4% 0.0% 25.2% 0.0% 0.0% 9.6% An increase of EUR 200 thousand in revenues from Government Grant was approved upon revision of the budget, whilst an increase of EUR 450 thousand was based on a Decision of the Government of Kosovo and was allocated to capital projects. 33 Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Section 19. Number of employees Department Total budgeted full time & part time no. of employees Administration Mayor office Administration and personnel Budgeting and Finance Public services Community Office Agriculture Cadastre and Geodesy Urban and environmental planning Culture, youth and sport Health and Social Care Administration Primary health care Social services Education and science Administration Preschool education and kindergarden Elementary education Middle school education Total Nr. 04/L-001 208 11 52 34 38 8 16 17 10 22 203 10 176 17 985 10 15 729 231 1,396 34 Actual no. of the employees in the beginning of 2012 Full time 182 12 48 24 38 8 13 13 7 19 199 9 173 17 948 9 15 697 227 1,329 Actual no. of employees at the end of 2012 Part Time - Full time 189 12 49 25 40 8 14 14 8 19 200 9 174 17 928 9 16 682 221 1,317 Part Time - Municipality of Skenderaj Section 15-20. Notes to the financial statements 31 December 2012 (Amounts in thousands of EUR, unless otherwise stated) Section 20. Report on taken and proposed actions on findings and recommendations of the Auditor for the prior year Taken or proposed action Deadline for implementation Effect No financial statements in Serbian language were prepared Immediately Not addressed.. The software has been implemented only for tax on property and we are working toward this point Immediately Partially adressed. Recommendations were considered Immediately Partially adressed Recommendations were considered Immediately Partially adressed Recommendations were considered but additional actions are considered Immediately Not addressed. 6 Ensure that the Municipality takes further steps to improve controls over expenses and payments. Recommendations were considered Immediately Not addressed 7 The Audit Committee should report directly to the Municipal Assembly to ensure that the responsibilities are carried out with the appropriate level of independence. Recommendations were considered but the actual practice is in accordance with legislation in place Immediately Not addressed. No Recommendation or finding The Mayor of Municipality ensures that the Municipality prepares financial statements in the Serbian language. 1 The invoice system of own source revenues should be comprehensive, and regular monthly reconciliations and also the division of work performed should be done 2 3 4 Improve controls over expenses and payments and strictly comply with Law on Public Procurement No 03-L-241 in order to avoid irregularities. Ensure that the Municipality take further steps to improve controls and to comply with laws and local regulatory requirements regarding personnel. Ensure that the Municipality makes additional efforts in relation to confirming the ownership, registration and valuation of all real estate. 5 35