Fall - The Silver Falcons
Transcription
Fall - The Silver Falcons
Honor, integrity, pride, fellowship — The rEAL Flight Crew! The Official Newsletter of The Silver Falcons Volume 13, Number 4 www.silverfalcons.com Fall 2009 Cowladies Anne Hughes, Jane Borrelli, Darlene Sanak, Mary Fullerton, Shirley Gordon, and Kathy Williams riding the ferocious bull at Gilley’s Honky Tonk in Fort Worth during our just ended and never forgotten convention i 2009 Fort Worth Roundup The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 1 Greetings to All, P.O. Box 71372 Newnan, GA 30271 Board of Directors Ron Shoop President Tel: (770) 929-1924 Bill Frank Director Tel: (770) 567-3763 jrshoop@gmail.com gwannie@earthlink.net Sandy McCulloh Vice President, E-Mail Editor Dick Borrelli Newsletter Editor Tel: (770) 491-0727 silverfalcons@bellsouth.net Stuart Hughes Director & Database Coordinator Tel: (770) 229-2784 southmetro@mindspring.com Hank Sanak Director Tel: (770) 254-1748 Fax: (770) 254-0179 conob@numail.org Joe Zito Financial Officer Tel: (770) 252-0761 Fax: (770) 252-0758 Cell: (678) 523-1235 jezdc9@numail.org Tel: (770) 487-4255 sanak@bellsouth.net The opinions expressed in The rEAL Word are the opinions of individual members and do not express the opinions of the BOD or the organization. Newsletter layout by KFD&P; 770 474-1953; kellie@kfdp.com The Silver Falcons is a group of former Eastern Airlines Pilots and Flight Attendants who honored the picket line in 1989. It is incorporated and registered as a nonprofit organization in the State of Georgia. The Silver Falcons is also registered as a tax exempt organization with the IRS. Dues are $25 per year for a Charter member and $10 per year for an Auxiliary member. A life membership may be purchased for $500 for a Charter member and $200 for an Auxiliary member. Dues and all correspondence should be mailed to: The Silver Falcons, P.O. Box 71372, Newnan, GA 30271. A quarter page ad for one year (Four issues) is $250. A half page ad, either horizontal or vertical, is $500 a year. Every attempt will be made to put these ads on the outside of the page rather than toward the middle. The back cover and the inside of the front cover will be offered for full page ads only and will cost $1000 a year. If you have a special event that needs attention for a short time, we will accept single issue ads at $62.50 for a quarter page, $125 for a half page, and $250 for a full page (If available). We will not decrease the content of the newsletter, but will increase it’s size to accommodate our advertisers. Every attempt will be made to insure that there is no more than one ad per page. The editor will have the right to reject any ad that he deems objectionable, although we do not anticipate this as a problem. All ads must be in black and white since we do not have color capability at this time. It will be the responsibility of the advertiser to supply a print ready ad to the editor at least thirty days prior to publication of the newsletter. Every effort will be made to accommodate any specific requests you may have. Publication dates are January 15, April 15, July 15, and October 15 each year. All materials can be mailed to The Silver Falcons, P.O. Box 71372, Newnan, GA 30271, or contact Dick Borrelli at this address, by fax at (770) 254-0179, or by E-Mail at conob@numail.org if you plan to participate. Deadline for ads is at least 30 days prior to the publication dates stated above. 2 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 I arrived at Ft. Worth not feeling too well and wondered if I should have stayed in bed. The antibiotics were beginning to kick in and the camaraderie of the good guys began to feel like old times. Judy and I drove there in formation with Bill and Janice Rogers with the opportunity to drive through the tornado that struck Shreveport and toppled the church steeple, crushed a car, and injured the occupant. We saw that on TV after arrival at the Hyatt. My apologies to everyone that I was not in a good mood and irritable like a bear and now you can see why. Everything was better from there starting with the dinner at Cattleman’s with a steak that was prime quality. Hours of story swapping in the hospitality room, cocktail party, and the banquet made the following days whisk by, making it a top notch layover memory. This convention crew can hold another Ft. Worth shindig like this anytime and we all agreed, no questions asked, we will be there! Mark Johnson, son of Lea Johnson, was only the third inductee voted to honorary status in the Silver Falcons. He read a letter at the banquet by his daughter concerning her acceptance of his ALS condition. There wasn’t a dry eye left. $1,000 was voted to ALS from the flower fund and an additional $150 was donated by one of the 50-50 winners at the banquet. The Dizzy 3 was won by yours truly at the door prize drawing. I couldn’t resist teasing them that although I’m an ancient birdman and flew her, it was in PNA (Pacific Northern Airlines) colors and not EAL. Never the less it sure looks great in my collection and thank you. The business meeting was very active and produced some surprising results. The financial health is stable but is projected to begin dipping into reserve funds with no change. Maxine Peterson made a stirring presentation on the flight attendant status and the membership voted to bring them into the fold with full membership and privileges. This action in effect now eliminates the slight loss in revenue to cover them as they will now be equal at $25 annual dues. Welcome aboard! Ed McGarvey presented a resolution creating a new category of non-voting family members at $25 annual dues. There were several new members signed up before we left Ft. Worth. As for new members, the board welcomes Bob Ramsey and Dave Ingle to replace Sandy McCullough and Stu Hughes. Thank you guys for your service. The plaque resolution of last year was withdrawn due to complications of by-laws and because some did not wish to support it with dues. However the board is unanimous in supporting it by voluntary contributions and many members also indicated their desire to do the same. You can easily make a contribution over and above your dues and indicate if the amount is for the flower fund or plaque. The feedback on the status of the plaque is that it still not settled but the committee will still be available to assist REPA and work with them on all ideas. The Silver Falcons are not against supporting this and wish all EAL pilots to so note. The board was given the task to organize the 2010 convention in ATL approximately the middle of September next year. Standby for further information as it becomes available. The 2011 convention is designated for SAT. It was a great time as always and thank you all who made it possible. Ron Shoop, President The Holidays will soon be here and plans are made for our Annual Christmas Dinner. We will gather Friday, December 4, 2009, at Petit Auberge in NE Atlanta. Out-of-towners are encouraged to join us and we welcome our REPA friends. Please mark your calendar and plan to attend. Bring your friends. Cash Bar Cocktail Hour begins at 6:30 PM with Dinner at 7:30 rpzpr Artichoke & Tomato Soup rpzpr Holiday Trio Salad Seasonal mixed greens, tomatoes vinaigrette, mushroom salad rpzpr Entrée choices include: 1. Chicken Piccata 2. Sautéed Snapper “Riviera” 3. Pan Seared Pork Tenderloin 4. Veal Viennese Breaded Veal in a Lemon Butter Sauce 5. Grilled Filet Mignon rpzpr Dessert – Layered Sherbet Meringue Layers of Sherbet, Ice Cream amd Meringue served on a Vanilla Sauce Coffee and Tea Petit Auberge 2935 N. Druid Hills Rd. · Atlanta, GA 30329 · 404-634-6268 The cost is $44.50 per person including tax and gratuity If you would like to attend please fill out the enclosed application and return it as soon as possible. The absolute cut off date for reservations is December 1, 2009. Our annual christmas dinner has become nearly as popular as our convention and the attendance is nearly as great. Plan to be there! The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 3 Air Force Training More Pilots for Drones than Manned Planes By Walter Pincus, Tuesday, August 11, 2009, Washington Post The Air Force will train more pilots to fly unmanned aerial systems from ground operations centers this year than pilots to fly fighter or bomber aircraft, Gen. Stephen R. Lorenz, the commander of Air Education and Training Command, told an audience Friday. What these aircraft bring “to the table is the ability to stay in position or maneuver over large areas for a long period of time, and that’s where a person in an aircraft becomes a limitation,” Deptula said. Without individuals in the aircraft “you can maintain your position for a long period of time with the opportunity to either watch or strike.” Today one ground-based pilot flies one Predator, Lorentz’s remark illustrates the major transformation occurring within that service. In a Pentagon session last month, Air Force Vice Chief of Staff Gen. Will Fraser told reporters that the unmanned systems are “delivering gamechanging capabilities today, and ones that I’m confident will continue to be invaluable in the future.” Technicians and mechanics from General Atomics move the Predator B, an unmanned surveillance aircraft, from an air hangar at Fort Drum, N.Y., on June 18. (By Heather Ainsworth – Associated Press) At that July 23 briefing, Air Force officers spelled out the growth of what they call the “ISR [intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance] transformation” of their service. Today, the Air Force is flying both Predators and the more capable Reapers over Iraq and Afghanistan in 35 simultaneous orbits, each of which is a combat mission that keeps an aircraft aloft 24 hours a day. The target is to have 50 orbits by 2011. A Predator was used over Pakistan last week in an attack that apparently killed Pakistani Taliban leader Baitullah Mehsud. Right now there is basically one sensor in each Predator whose surveillance system provides 10 full motion video images simultaneously to forces on the ground, according to Lt. Gen. David Deptula, Air Force deputy chief of staff for ISR. Deptula also attended the July briefing. The newest version of the Reaper flies faster than the Predator, up to 250 miles per hour, carries more arms and will beam back to ground forces up to 30 video images. Troops on the ground, using new equipment called Rover (remote operations video enhanced receivers), literally see what the aircraft’s sensor and the ground-based Reaper pilot—thousands of miles away—see. Rover also allows ground troops to send queries up to the aircraft. Where Reaper with its four sensors can cover over six square miles, a more advanced version with six sensors, scheduled to be available in 2013, will be able to cover over 20 square miles. It also will beam back 65 separate video images to the ground. assisted by two analysts. By 2013 the Air Force expects technology to permit one pilot to fly three Reapers, and to fly four in a crisis. Another advantage over manned aircraft is that there is always a fresh crew on the ground, “which enables any sort of persistence,” said Col. Eric Mathewson, director of the Air Force UAS Task Force, at the July briefing. There are 1,000 Air Force personnel flying these unmanned operations today and none is in harm’s way, according to charts at the briefing. He added that an unmanned aircraft could be designed to stay airborne for five years, “and I can man it that entire five years with little fatigue.” In fact, the Defense Advanced Projects Agency has a project called Vulture that is trying to do just that. While there are five launch and recovery units in the Iraq-Afghanistan-Pakistan theater, the global operations center is at Creech Air Force Base, Nev., with five other centers in North Dakota, upstate New York, Arizona, Texas and California. The hasty push of unmanned systems into the Iraq-Afghanistan battle area has shown some vulnerabilities, however, including the need for a better sorting, processing and distribution of the massive amounts of intelligence collected. That problem will only get worse with the new sensors. In addition, the House Armed Services Committee complained in its report on the fiscal 2010 defense authorization bill that money meant to fund the Predator portion of the planned fleet was redirected to the Reaper program, which doesn’t have enough aircraft in the pipeline to meet the 50-orbit goal. A long-term issue for the unmanned systems such as the Predator and Reaper aircraft is how to protect them when they operate in an area where the enemy has sophisticated air defenses and the United States does not control the airspace. Deptula conceded survivability is a concern. He said the service is looking at countermeasures and “low observability,” which means stealth aircraft that fly fast—even at hypersonic speeds—and cannot be picked up on radar. Will the unmanned aircraft ever completely replace either bombers or fighters? In delivering weapons on target, Deptula said, “Yes, you bet.” But when it comes to controlling airspace, flying against enemy fighters, the general said, the technology cannot yet achieve 360-degree awareness. A human brain is still superior in the assimilation of information and responding to it. “Someday we might be able to, but until then, we’ll still have manned aircraft,” the general said. 4 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 Pilot Speak AIRSPEED - Speed of an airplane. (Deduct 25% when listening to a retired fighter pilot.) BANK - The folks who hold the lien on most pilots’ cars. CARBURETOR ICING - A phenomenon reported to the FAA by pilots immediately after they run out of gas. CONE OF CONFUSION - An area about the size of New Jersey located near the final approach beacon at an airport. CRAB - A VFR Instructor’s attitude on an IFR day. DEAD RECKONING - You reckon correctly, or you are. DESTINATION - Geographical location 30 minutes beyond the pilot’s bladder saturation point. ENGINE FAILURE - A condition that occurs when all fuel tanks mysteriously become filled with low-octane air. FIREWALL - Section of the aircraft specifically designed to funnel heat and smoke into the cockpit. FLIGHT FOLLOWING - USAF Formation flying. GLIDE DISTANCE - Half the distance from an airplane to the nearest emergency landing field. HOBBS - An instrument which creates an emergency situation should it fail during dual instruction. HYDROPLANE - An airplane designed to land long on a short and wet runway. IFR - A method of flying by needle and horoscope. LEAN MIXTURE - Nonalcoholic beer. MINI MAG LITE - Device designed to support the AA battery industry. NANOSECOND - Time delay between the Low Fuel Warning light and the onset of carburetor icing. PARACHUTES - The two chutes in a Stearman PARASITIC DRAG - A pilot who bums a ride and complains about the service. RANGE - Usually about 3 miles short of the destination. RICH MIXTURE - What you order at another pilot’s promotion party. ROGER - Used when you’re not sure what else to say. SECTIONAL CHART - Any chart that ends 25 nm short of your destination. SERVICE CEILING - Altitude at which cabin crew can serve drinks. SPOILERS - FAA Inspectors. STALL - Technique used to explain to the bank why your car payment is late. STEEP BANKS - Banks that charge pilots more than 10% interest. TURN & BANK INDICATOR - An instrument largely ignored by pilots. USEFUL LOAD - Volumetric capacity of the aircraft, disregarding weight. VOR - Radio navigation aid, named after the VORtex effect on pilots trying to home in on it. WAC CHART - Directions to the Army female barracks. YANKEE - Any pilot who has to ask New Orleans tower to “Say again.” DD-214s are online It’s official, DD-214s are NOW Online. Please pass it on to other vets. The National Personnel Records Center (NPRC) has provided the following website for veterans to gain access to their DD-214’s online: www.vetrecs.archives.gov This may be particularly helpful when a veteran needs a copy of his DD-214 for employment purposes. NPRC is working to make it easier for veterans with computers and Internet access to obtain copies of documents from their military files. Military veterans and the next of kin of deceased former military members may now use a new on-line military personnel records system to request documents. Other individuals with a need for documents must still complete the Standard Form 180, which can be downloaded from the website. Because the requester will be asked to supply all information essential for NPRC to process the request, delays that often occur when NPRC has to ask veterans for additional information will be minimized. The new web-based application was designed to provide better service to these requests by eliminating the records center mailroom and processing time. Additional documents and services such as awards and medals eligibility, replacement medals, benefits and claims, health and medical records, etc., can be provided by NPRC upon request. Please pass this information on to all retired military service members and their dependents and to all veterans you know. Be sure to log on and check out this useful website. The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 5 Obituaries Captain John Deyton We announce with deep regret the passing of Captain John Deyton, 77, who passed away Sunday, Oct. 11, 2009, at his home in the company of his family. Funeral services were held., Thursday, Oct. 15, at Greene Funeral Home Northwest Chapel, with the Rev. Gene Feagin officiating. Burial followed at Forest Hills Cemetery with full military honors conducted by The Honor Guard of Frank Roach Post #34 of the American Legion. John was born June 27, 1932, in Kannapolis, NC, to the late Robert T. and Sally Kate Deyton. While growing up in Kannapolis, he was a member of the Boy Scouts and played football for Cannon High School. He attended North Carolina State University on a swimming scholarship and played several positions on the Wolfpack football team. After college John became a pilot in the U.S. Air Force where he flew B-52s with the Strategic Air Command during which time he flew 26 bombing missions out of Guam during the Viet Nam War. Following his enlistment he joined Eastern Air Lines where he flew commercial airliners for 22 years and retired as a captain in 1988. He was a member of W.H. Booth Lodge #380 A.F.M. in Shreveport, La., and also a 32nd Degree Scottish Rite Mason. His professional associations included memberships in The Silver Falcons and Airline Pilots Association (ALPA). He was also a member of Trinity Methodist Church in York, S.C. John is survived by his wife, Sandra J. Deyton; his daughter, Diana E. Deyton of York; his son, John R. Deyton Jr. and wife, Robin of Clover, S.C.; his brother, Arleigh G. Deyton of Charlotte, N.C.; his sister, Ruth Covington of Richmond, Va.; two granddaughters, Alexandra E. Deyton and Raquel K. Deyton, both of Clover; and many nieces and nephews. In addition to his parents, John was preceded in death by his older brother, Roy Deyton, formerly of China Grove, N.C. If you had the pleasure of sharing John’s cockpit then you had the rare privilege of flying with a true aviation professional and a pilot who loved his work! Fly on, John. The layover is worth the trip!. Captain John Litzenberger Captain John John D. Litzenberger, 76, of Fayetteville, Georgia died August 17, 2009. He proudly served in The United States marine Corps, became a Pilot for Eastern Air Lines, and retired as a Captain after 26 years of service. He passionately supported our US troops. Captain Litzenberger was a loving husband, father, grandfather, cousin, and brother-in-law. He is survived by his wife, Sue Litzenberger; sons, David and Rita Litzenberger, of Dallas, GA, Michael and Sherry Litzenberger of Turin, and Kevin and Clarissa Litzenberger of McDonough; and grandchildren Cole, Jesse, Tristan, Mackenzie and 6 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 Riley. A Memorial Service was held Wednesday, August 19, 2009 at 4:00 PM at C.J. Mowell & Son Chapel, Fayetteville with Pastor John Hobbs officiating. In lieu of flowers, donations may be made to the Salvation Army. A committed and loyal member of The Silver Falcons, John will be sorely missed by all of his friends and especially by those who had the privilege of sharing his cockpit. John and Sue were a formidable team on an airplane. Alone, each was special—together they were truly a matched set! Blue skies, John! Captain Ralph and Mrs. Jolene Smith Captain Ralph and Jolene Smith entered into rest together while in flight to their home on Sunday, October 4th, 2009. Captain Ralph Smith, Sr. was born July 10, 1935 in Phoenixville, Pennsylvania to Raymond Oscar Smith and Johanna Maire Henkels. He graduated from Spring City High School and later attended Parks College receiving his pilots certificates following his schooling he served in the U.S. Air Force. During his service in the military he married Jolene Bailey September 10, 1955 in East St. Louis, Illinois. Following his military service they returned to Cahokia, Il where Ralph earned his flight instructors rating at Parks College after which he preceded to Maine where he flew crop dusters and hunting parties into Canada. Afterwards he began working for Westinghouse as a pilot. He later flew for Eastern Air Lines for over 32 years as well at United Express and Ryan International. He and Jolene came to Arizona 9 years ago settling in Aguila at Eagle’s Roost Air Park where they remained actively flying. Ralph and Jolene enjoyed, flying, RVing, motorcycles, camping and traveling. He was a member of the Redeemer Lutheran Church in Wickenburg, American Legion, Veteran’s of Foreign Wars, QB’s (Quiet Birdmen), Silver Falcons, Goldwing Roadriders Association, Short Wing Piper Club and the Comanche Society. Jolene Bailey Smith was born January 22, 1938 in Cahokia, Illinois to Loren Bailey and Margaret Draper Bailey. She was raised there and attended schools there. She married Ralph after high school and they moved to Gallup, New Mexico shortly thereafter to be together during Ralph’s military service. They later returned to Cahokia, Illinois where she was a homemaker and mother and also began a career in banking and worked in all capacities in banking eventually as a bank manager. Jolene was a member of the Order of the Eastern Star and a member of the Redeemer Lutheran Church in Wickenburg. Surviving family include sons: Ralph R. Smith, Jr.(Sherri) of Du Quoin, Illinois and Dwight L. Smith (Sonya) of Culpeper, Virginia. Grandchildren: Erin Muchowski of Roebling N.J., Ryan Smith of Richmond, VA., Kyle Smith & Nicholas Smith of Culpeper, VA. a great-grandhild Ava Grace Muchowski and sister Patricia Gallow of Phoenixville, PA. Memorial contributions in Ralph and Jolene’s memory may be made to the American Heart Association at americanheart.org It is difficult to write of the passing of any one of our members, but when a husband and wife, whom we have all known so well for so many years, pass together then the task simply becomes heart rending. May you both share eternity in peace! Bill Bennett’s Last Trip Captain Bill Bennett on his final flight as an airline pilot, July 21, 2009 News Release The Furlong’s didn’t make the Annual Reunion this year for the first time in history, but their oldest grandchild, Channing Lawson, made an appearance in the Junior League World Series recently. His team from Easley, SC won the South Carolina Championship and then faced the best of the Southeast teams and emerged as the Champions of the whole SE also. The five Regional US Champs and five International teams met outside of Detroit in August and played for the World Title. While Easley didn’t prevail there also, they played well and had a good time as one of the top ten teams in the world. 770 643-7648 / 800 965-3168 Fax 770 643-7650 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 7 The Editorial Our convention in Fort Worth is over and a good time was had by all! Our group of enthusiastic hosts could not have been nicer or more prepared, and gave us a party to be remembered for years to come. It seems each convention gives us a new benchmark to be exceeded. The plans for the 2010 convention are to hold it in Atlanta with 2011 to be held in San Antonio. You will be informed about these as the plans progress. Our convention committee in Fort Worth did an outstanding job and actually came in a bit under budget. They did so well we may let them do it again. One of the highlights of our gathering was the entertainment provided at both our cocktail party and our banquet by Conrad Olson And His Home Grown Band. Conrad is a former Eastern Pilot, retired from Southwest Airlines, and is a new member of The Silver Falcons. He is a well known presence on the Texas Country Music scene and provided us with the mood, the music, and the class to put our convention over the top. Conrad offered to entertain us free of charge at the banquet and then extended the offer to include the cocktail party too. Thanks, Conrad, you’re a true gentleman! President Ron Shoop held a well organized and record breaking business meeting and an amazing amount of business was transacted. REPA apparently has no current plan in place concerning the future location or disposition of the honorary plaque at the Atlanta Airport and last years resolution was rescinded as unworkable, and not allowed by our By-laws. All Silver Falcons that want to support the plaque are urged to make voluntary contributions to the plaque fund. Send the money to Joe Zito with an appropriate designation and he will forward it to REPA. The entire membership structure of The Silver Falcons has changed and the category of Auxiliary membership for the Flight Attendant members was abolished after a moving plea for equality from Maxine Peterson. A motion was presented and a unanimous vote was taken and the Flight Attendants are now Charter Members with a full vote, the ability to hold office, and annual dues of $25.00. Our Flight Attendants supported the strike in 1989 without the support of their union and with no strike benefits of any kind. Our Strike Center in Atlanta actually set up a food bank to assist them! Our Eastern Flight Attendants who walked beside us were the true heroines of our fight against Frank Lorenzo. Their sacrifice tends to be forgotten and recognition for what they have done is long overdue. We are proud to welcome you as full members of The Silver Falcons! Mark Johnson, son of Captain Lea Johnson, Silver Falcons supporter, and our long time convention bartender was unanimously elected an honorary Silver Falcon. Mark has been our inspiration and our hero as he has gallantly fought Lew Gehrig’s disease (ALS) for nine years. Welcome aboard, Mark! The position of Honorary member has been a closely guarded and infrequently awarded privilege that The Silver Falcons have only granted three times in the past fourteen years. To be an honorary Silver Falcon is to receive the greatest recognition for accomplishment, character, and service that we can bestow. No one deserves it more! After a short discussion, a motion from Captain Ed McGarvey to create a Family Membership category was passed and is now in effect. Membership is $25.00 per year and is open to immediate family members and blood relatives, has no voting privileges, and requires a sponsorship from a Charter Member. This move will allow us to expand our membership while still being able to control the quality and high standards of Silver Falcons membership. We are an Eastern Family and our families have always been a participative part of this. It was the crew members that did not have support at home who eventually caved in and crossed the line. We have our families to thank for giving us the support to hold fast and they deserve to be Silver falcons too! In a nutshell, all memberships in The Silver Falcons are now $25.00. The reason for this is very simple. It costs $17.50 per member, per year, to publish and mail the newsletter and a minimum annual contribution of $25.00 allows us to do this, cover all our administrative costs, and perhaps even save a little. In fourteen years of operation, with inflation running rampant, postage rising at an alarming rate, membership income dwindling (Currently we have forty widows with full membership privileges on our list), and fewer and fewer new members coming in because, let’s face it, they aren’t making any new Eastern crew members, we have remained solvent and have not had to raid the general fund! Maximum dues have never been raised above $25.00! Folks, no matter how you cut it, that’s a hell of an accomplishment! We are still solvent, membership is relatively stable, and the dues are still cheap! WOW! Dick Borrelli, Editor 8 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 New Grandbaby! Introducing Master Henry Thomas Chapman, born September 13, 2009 to David and Maddy Chapman. Henry weighed in at seven pounds, ten ounces. He is the great grandson of Captain J-Ron Wheeler. Captain J-Ron was our mystery pilot in last month’s newsletter and, although questioned by many people, no one was able to identify him. At least six people approached me at the convention to ask who he was. Bad for you, J-Ron, you’re just not pretty any more! Layabed The following Silver Falcons and family members are currently under the weather and would appreciate calls, cards, and visits from friends. A card or a friendly voice can do wonders when a person is really hurting! It’s easy to get on the Lay-A-Bed list. All it takes is a bad headache and a big mouthed friend. Getting off the list is another matter altogether! No one ever tells us when they get well! Therefore we have had to make rules to control this situation. In the future: 1. When the flower dies, take your name off the lay-a-bed list whether you are sick or not. 2. If you are still sick, put your name back on the list and we will send you a new flower! 3. When the new flower dies, go back to rule one! Captain Bob Ramsey 3173 Inman Park Ct. Marietta, GA 30062 robjet@bellsouth.net (770) 977-5424 Captain Tim Chase 109 Carols Lane Locust Grove, GA 30248 Ardyc1@aol.com (770) 320-8526 Mrs. Dee McKinney Wife of Capt. Clancy McKinney 2860 Roxburgh Drive Roswell, GA 30076 cl_demckinney@bellsouth.net (770) 475-1129 Mrs. Pauline Mallary Wife of Capt. Pete Mallary 221 Magnolia Church Rd. Statesboro, GA 30461 7666r@bellsouth.net (912) 587-2376 Captain Doyne Langrell 4373 Chateau Ridge Lane Castle Rock, CO 80108 dlangrell@comcast.net (303)688-9751 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 9 CARIBAIR – CARIBBEAN-ATLANTIC AIRLINES Only Caribair Goes All the Way by Bruce Drum Welcome aboard! Captain Philip Hutchinson posed for the camera on the San Juan ramp in 1968. Captain Hutchinson was ready to fire up the piston-powered, JATO-assisted Convair 340-02 N3409 (msn 26) for the short flight shuttling tourists and business people to the islands. N3409 appears in the 1949 yellow and red colors. The 340s never wore the later 1965 “Caribbean blue” livery except after they were converted to the turbine-powered 640Ds. Captain Hutchinson was hired by Caribair’s Executive Vice President and General Manager Jose M. Sierra, with a little help from his mother. (William W. Sierra) T his year the former employees, family and friends of Caribbean-Atlantic Airlines, Inc. will assemble once again. They will take a bit of time to fondly look back and celebrate the 70th anniversary of the founding of the regional carrier. This airline was certainly different. It proudly displayed the American flag on its airliners; however, it was firmly planted in the Caribbean as “Puerto Rico’s airline”. It also carried a Latin accent. As with most small airlines, the operation often resembles a close family. The successes are always more personal and the lows often bring the group even closer together. Having their story told has been long overdue. 22 10 • AIRLINERS • NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2007 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 The Powelson Line “fleet” is pictured resting between flights at San Juan. Powelson had its own airfield near the San Jose Lagoon that is adjacent to the current day Luiz Munoz Marin International Airport (SJU). After the name change in 1939, the fleet grew to four Stinson SR Reliants in 1941. A fifth was added a year later to meet the increased demand for the Virgin Islands flights. The company would later move to Isla Grande Airport next to downtown San Juan and finally to the current day international airport in May 1955. (Files of CBA) It All Started with a Rum Distillery In 1937, a young pilot named Dennis Powelson saw the early potential for aviation in Puerto Rico and the surrounding islands. The Mercedita Distilling Co. in Ponce had a need for air transportation, and Powelson offered to transport the executives. Feeling confident of his early charter success, Powelson established the Powelson Line a year later with 10-passenger Stinson SR Reliant trimotors. A daily service was offered between Ponce and San Juan, the two principle cities on the island. A total of 444 passengers were air lifted on the 30-minute flights in the first year by the fledging Ponce-based airline. neighboring U.S. Virgin Islands – the daily flight from San Juan to St. Thomas charged $10 for a one-way fare. The company also operated between St. Thomas and St. Croix twice a week. The growing airline was becoming attractive to others. George T. “Ted” Baker of National Airlines, agreed with Powelson to trade some of each other’s company stock. As part of the deal, Baker sent some of his personnel and two 14-passenger Lockheed 18 Lodestars to the islands. Baker was actually trying to take over Caribbean-Atlantic without a formal merger agreement that would need the approval of the CAB. However, the CAB caught on and squashed the deal Caribbean-Atlantic Airlines is Born On February 27, 1939, the Powelson Line became Caribbean-Atlantic Airlines, Inc. under the laws of Puerto Rico, a commonwealth under United States law. The name change was necessary because it needed a more regional name to reflect its ambitions to expand outside of Puerto Rico. Like any U.S. airline, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and the Civil Aeronautics Board (CAB) rules and decisions governed the young airline. Later in the year on December 16, the company stretched its wings and inaugurated services to the National Airlines created this design, shown here in the May 15, 1945 timetable. It had a tagline that read, “Proposed subsidiary of National Airlines, Inc.” This logo probably was never painted on the leased National Airlines Lodestars. – It issued a Cease and Desist Order to both companies. The Lodestars and the National personnel were returned to Florida. After World War II, in 1946, Powelson sold the airline to the Trigo brothers, namely Dionisio, Benigno and Juan. The brothers had their family roots in Spain, and had a vision of an expanding Puerto Rican airline that would grow into the Caribbean. The First Douglas DC-3s Arrive In May 1946, the first two 30-passenger Douglas DC-3s entered service. DC-3-313 N21787 (msn 2186) and C-47A-DL N79044 (msn 9654) came from Pennsylvania Central Airlines (PCA), and flew for several years in basic PCA colors. The “P” was conveniently painted over leaving only the “CA” letters for CaribbeanAtlantic. A triangle-shaped logo was also developed for the DC-3s. The new This “winged triangle” design was applied to the DC-3s from 1946 to 1949. The early ex-PCA DC-3s wore the basic PCA livery (minus the “P”) with this logo. 23 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 11 Caribair, continued On July 20, 1948, the CAB authorized Caribbean-Atlantic Airlines to adopt the shorter “Caribair” name. Caribair would operate 11 individual DC-3s, a mixture of DC-3 built airliners and ex-military C-47s. The Trigo brothers were inspired by the colors of the Spanish flag and developed this yellow and red livery. The DC-3s were the first type to wear the pictured yellow and red livery. All of the DC-3s carried this distinctive livery. The pictured DC-3D N34970 (msn 42966) is seen at a stop at St. Maarten in 1961 (St. Maarten was added in 1958). Jose Sierra insisted that all of the airplanes be spotless and this picture underscores this point. A C-47A-DK (N1549V, msn 13480) crashed on takeoff at San Juan on September 22, 1964. It stalled and crashed, but the two crew members flying the ferry flight survived. The DC-3s would be phased out in 1967. (Captain Philip Hutchinson) The ground crew meets Douglas DC-3-313 N21787 (msn 2186) in the early 1950s at San Juan. Ship 200 as N21787 was known in the company, was delivered on April 29, 1946, and introduced the yellow and red livery in 1959. It would remain faithful, operating for 22 years with Caribair, until November 4, 1968. (Dean Hochstetler, from the Lehman Collection, http://flickr.com/photos/tlehman/) airliners allowed the airline to expand and carry more passengers under the new ownership. Under the brother’s leadership, 66,950 passengers were carried in the first year. The family, however, needed an experienced airline veteran to handle the expansion. Jose M. Sierra, with his previous experience at TWA and Pan Am, was hired in 1946 as the Chief Pilot and Operations Manager. Sierra ran a tight ship. He was strict, but fair-minded. 24 12 • AIRLINERS • NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2007 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 Sierra was responsible for all aircraft purchases starting with the DC-3s. Jose would quickly become Vice President of Operations and Chairman of the Executive Committee. The famous guard house (“garita”) symbol inspired by the Castillo de San Felipe del Morro “El Morro” fortress in old San Juan became the logo in 1959, when the yellow and red livery was introduced on the DC-3s. This logo would be modified when the newly delivered Convair 340s arrived in 1962, but the colors were retained. Caribair, Continued An Era with the Convairs Commences After careful consideration for a DC-3 replacement, the Convair 340 was found to be suitable to replace the sevenstrong DC-3 fleet. Initially, five ex-Braniff Airways types were acquired from Texas. However, the airline operated from some very short runways, in particular, from the Harry S. Truman Airport in St. Thomas. The FAA insisted on an extra safety margin. The Convairs would need a bit of extra lift. They would be fitted with Aerojet’s JATO (Jet Assisted Take-Off) rockets. A total of 36 of Caribair’s 64 pilots were trained for the upgrade. On July 10, 1962, the first two (of five) 54-passenger Convair 340-32s went into service. Caribair would eventually operate nine individual ex-Braniff Convair 340-32s. In addition, two Convair 440s (N4405 and N45003) would be leased from General Dynamics in the 1966 to 1967 period to cover the aircraft shortage while the 340s were being converted to 640Ds. N4405 wore a basic Hawaiian Airlines scheme without titles. Seven of the 340s would be converted to the Rolls-Royce Dart powered 640D turboprop model; Caribair was the first airline to place orders for the type. It was also the first airline to put the type into revenue service on December 1, 1965. The first converted Convair was the pictured N3407 (msn 20), sitting forlornly on the San Juan ramp near the end of its career. N3407, in the beginning, wore an experimental scheme that did not carry the traditional stylized watchtower, “garita”, logo on the tail. It was actually the second converted Convair (N3420, msn 64) that introduced the 1965 “Caribbean blue” color scheme with featured a redesigned garita logo which gave the impression of a “C”. When this picture was taken in May 1973, N3407 was already out of service. After the acquisition by Eastern, it was overhauled and it went to Zantop International. (Bruce Drum) The triangular watch tower logo was launched in 1962, with the arrival of the first Convair 340. The serviceable DC-3s were progressively repainted with this new logo until the last one was retired. There were a couple of 640Ds, specifically N3408 (msn 21) and the pictured N3411 (msn 31) at St. Croix, that sported a unique variation of the Caribbean blue color scheme. This version featured a broad yellow cheatline, and was introduced in 1966. This alternate design was applied after the first four 640Ds were delivered in the Caribbean blue scheme. However N3408 was declared an insurance write off on January 23, 1967 at San Juan. The serviceable left wing of N3408 was mated with N3420 that was also damaged at San Juan four months later. By the time Eastern was ready to merge with Caribair in 1973, only two 640s (N3412 and N3417) were in flying condition. These two would fly without titles for Eastern from May 15, 1973 to December 1, 1973. (Robert Drum) 25 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 13 Caribair, continued The blue modernized logo was applied on the second Convair 640D which arrived in January 1966. The first 640D wore the experimental blue scheme without the watch tower logo. The guard tower outline design cleverly gives the impression of a “C”. The “Caribbean blue” livery was introduced in 1965, without this logo that was added later. Eventually all of the 640s and DC-9-31s would adopt this logo and color; the two non-converted Convair 340s never adopted this logo or blue scheme. We Need Jets to Compete with Pan Am and Others Caribair recorded its highest yearly operating profit in 1965. It was a profit of $422,074 – not exactly a large sum of money, even for 1965. However, it was the golden era for Caribair. In fact, 1962 to 1966 would be the most profitable period, as it posted a profit of $929,081. Caribair always operated in the shadow of the U.S. flag carrier, Pan Am. In February 1966, Pan Am upped the ante by introducing Boeing 727 jet service on the New York (JFK) to St. Thomas route, threatening Caribair’s loads on the lucrative San Juan–St. Thomas connecting flights. Eastern and Trans Caribbean were also authorized to fly nonstop to the Virgin Islands, with jets from the mainland. In addition, Puerto Rico International Airlines (PRINAIR) was formed in 1966 that contributed greatly to Caribair’s ultimate demise. The unregulated air taxi operated 19-passenger DH.114 PRINAIR Herons on many of Caribair’s routes. By the late 1960s, no less than 20 air taxi operators were skimming off traffic on the lucrative San Juan–Virgin Islands routes. Caribair needed to expand on the longer haul routes in the Caribbean. St. Kitts and St. Lucia joined the network in 1966. On December 19 in the same year the CAB authorized the carrier to fly to the islands as far south as Trinidad and Tobago. Martinique and Barbados were added in 1967. The system map now stretched from Santo Domingo in the west to Barbados in the southeast. The Douglas DC-9-31 was selected for these new longer range routes. It had to remain competitive. The Convair 640D aircraft never met the sales pitches and promises of the manufacturers. They were continuously underperforming, especially on fuel consumption, and they were often in for maintenance. They also needed frequent overhauls as the FAA still mandated JATO rockets with the turboprop Dart engines. Caribair ended up taking both General Dynamics and the Rolls-Royce Division to court. It pleaded its case to the court that the converted turboprop aircraft was not living up to the specifications. After several years of litigation the court finally ruled in Caribair’s favor. The problems associated with the Convair 640D were a significant contributing factor to Caribair’s ultimate demise. On January 23, 1967, the company began daily service between San Juan and Trinidad. However, the good news was only short term. On the same day, a Convair 640D (N3408) operating as Flight CB 101 touched down 250 feet short of the runway while landing at San Juan. The nose and right main gear collapsed causing the right wing to separate. The number two engine also The first DC-9-31 was N938PR (msn 47098) that was delivered on June 1, 1967 – the initial registration of N1938R was not used. N938PR, unfortunately, arrived late and was immediately shipped off to Air Canada for six months during the slow summer months. It finally entered revenue service for Caribair on December 2, 1967. The DC-9s wore the tropical Caribbean blue look and each was dubbed a “Fiestajet”; in the beginning they wore just Caribair titles. Later around 1968 additional “Puerto Rico” subtitles were added. This was part of an effort by Caribair to convince local officials that they needed to financially support the “Puerto Rican flag carrier” when the times got tough. It also had another intention of staving off any political moves to force a merger with PRINAIR. However, the local political support never materialized. The second DC-9-31 was the pictured N939PR (msn 47120) that arrived on December 12, 1967, 10 days after N938PR entered service. It is seen leaving the gate at San Juan during 1968 Christmas holidays. N938PR became N8988E with Eastern and N939PR was re-registered N8990E when Eastern absorbed the DC-9s. A third DC-931, N967PR, would arrive on March 23, 1968, later becoming N8989E with Eastern. (William W. Sierra) 26 14 • AIRLINERS • NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2007 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 Caribair, Continued separated. Fortunately there were no injuries but the newspaper headlines did not help the reputation of the company. As a result, the company slid further into the red in 1967. It reported a massive net loss of $1,236,328. The Trigo family needed financial help to survive. It reached out to the General Host Corporation, which specialized in food service and tourism. General Host agreed to exchange 500,000 General Host shares for 529,479 Caribair shares. In addition, General Host injected $3.2 million in cash to keep the airline flying. However, one strong condition was the airline could not lose over three quarters of a million dollars in any given financial year. This stipulation caused the agreement to fail quickly in the next year. It was cancelled on February 1, 1968, when CB’s losses exceeded the agreedupon limit. Good news finally came later in 1968, when President Lyndon B. Johnson approved the CAB’s decision to award the airline permanent authority to operate to every point (except Cuba) in the Caribbean, including Miami and the Bahamas, subject to foreign government approvals. However, the Miami route award was a restrictive award and the aircraft were forced to route through Santo Domingo and Port-au-Prince. A new “Only Caribair goes all the way” slogan was developed to emphasize its expanding route map. Unfortunately the situation further deteriorated in 1969. Traffic declined in the Caribbean, and the unreliability of the Convair 640Ds forced the company to substitute the longer-range DC-9s on the short and uneconomical Convair routes when the turboprops broke down. By mid-year, the company was in a severe financial crisis. It had lost over $3.2 million in 1968, and was bleeding $2.8 million already in the first quarter of 1969. It could not continue operations without a subsidy. The CAB steadfastly declined to help. Eastern Airlines and Caribair Begin Discussions Eastern approached the failing airline about a possible takeover. However, the initial discussions failed as Eastern considered the initial asking price to be excessively high. Other airlines were approached, but respectfully declined. On August 12, 1969, another bigger tragedy struck the company. DC-9-31 N938PR ran off the short, wet runway at St. Thomas. The aircraft hydroplaned through the security fence into the street hitting a car and injuring one person on the ground. The bad publicity with the crash and unreliability of the Convairs forced the company to take drastic actions. It immediately grounded the Convairs, and suspended service to the previous Convair cities of Ponce, bankers and Eastern. Eastern at this point was only interested in parts of Caribair. “Papi” Carrion asked Eastern to take a look at buying the entire airline. The losses continued – Caribair lost $7.4 million in 1969. The situation was becoming even more critical. By July 1970, Eastern indicated it was interested in pursuing a complete purchase, pending a CAB approval, if it could assume immediate management. Meanwhile, the CAB declined Caribair’s request for a temporary subsidy. The formal Eastern bid did not materialize until October 27, when Eastern made the offer Mayaguez, St. Kitts, Dominica, St. Vincent and Grenada. The biggest creditor, Banco Popular de Puerto Rico, was authorized by Caribair’s board to take control of the failing airline under the direction of President Rafael “Papi” Carrion, Jr. The bank put the Convairs back into service and the routes were restored. By October 1969, the second round of discussions commenced between the public. It would acquire the company, including the three DC-9-31s for $10.4 million. As part of the deal, it would supply management to assist in an orderly transition. This became known as the Interim Management Agreement (IMA), which limited Eastern’s total financial assistance to Caribair to only $1 million. Eastern also clearly stated that a CAB final decision was necessary by June 30, 1971, or the deal would 27 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 15 Caribair, continued be cancelled. The bank pressured Trigo to sell the airline to Eastern for this price. The bank wanted an immediate sale so it could recover the debt of $14 million; however, Trigo wanted to declare bankruptcy. Both the bank and later Eastern opposed any bankruptcy filing. Pan Am actually matched Eastern’s offer. Under the Pan Am plan, Caribair would remain a local service carrier in the Caribbean. The CAB hearings in November dismissed the Pan Am offer. On November 5, 1970, the CAB found Caribair to be in dire financial condition and approved the IMA, pending a final CAB determination concerning the merger. This order was made final on November 22. The agreement was effective on December 1, and was valid only to July 1, 1971. Pan Am and PRINAIR objected to the order that would contribute to the delays in a final CAB decision. Caribair’s identity had to be maintained during the IMA period until the agency ruled on the Eastern takeover. Eastern assigned George Lyall, who later established Miami Air, to lead the management team to run Caribair during this interim period as the Vice President and General Manager. However, the losses continued – Caribair lost $14.8 million in 1970. Eastern adjusted Caribair’s schedules to better connect with Eastern’s flights at San Juan. An hourly San Juan– St. Thomas shuttle was established. Feeling it was turning a corner with Eastern’s assistance, Caribair adopted a new “We’re a lot more airline” slogan with a new muscle-bound cartoon figure of a DC-9 jet with beefed-up engines. In the spring of 1971, a CAB case examiner recommended approval of the Eastern acquisition of Caribair despite continued objections by Pan Am and PRINAIR. The cash crunch continued and Eastern was reluctant to spend any more money. Caribair was down to only two operational Convair 640Ds and could not afford to pay for spare parts. Because of the delays by the CAB in making a final decision, Eastern was forced to extend the IMA on a month-tomonth basis beyond its own imposed 28 16 • AIRLINERS • NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2007 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 June 30 deadline. Eventually the agreement was extended 18 times, until April 15, 1973. Eastern’s patience was wearing thin with the delays. It notified Caribair it would terminate all financial assistance after October 31, 1972. Losses extended to $1.7 million by June 30. In September 1972, Eastern pressured Caribair to accept a 50% reduction in the sale price due to the continued losses, and delays with the final CAB approval. Trigo balked at this new proposal. They were not prepared to take $3 million less. Eastern countered that its financial assistance was now larger than what it had agreed to with the initial acquisition offer. On August 3, 1972, the CAB voted to reject the Eastern purchase plan. Puerto Rican Governor Luis A. Ferre interceded and asked then President Richard Nixon to pressure the CAB to overturn the ruling. The employees were told on October 31 not to report for work the following day because the airline was in limbo, and would have to shut down unless a last minute decision could resurrect the Eastern purchase. The governor bailed out the airline with a $100,000 monthly subsidy to keep it running until a new CAB (hopefully favorable) ruling arrived. Eastern reluctantly agreed to extend the Interim Management Agreement, once again, to January 15, 1973. Eastern also agreed to advance further financial support until March 16. By February 28, Eastern had pumped almost $6 million into the basically bankrupt regional carrier. The CAB again rejected the Eastern acquisition, stating it would hurt Pan Am in the Caribbean. Caribair wanted to file for bankruptcy again, but Eastern warned against this move. Both airlines were still hoping that President Nixon would finally overrule the CAB. Ultimately, on April 11, 1973, Nixon overruled the CAB and ordered the approval of Eastern’s 30-month long quest to acquire the debt-ridden Caribair. The approval, of course, had strings attached and Eastern did not get everything it wanted. The extended cost of keeping Caribair afloat only added to the purchase cost for Eastern. Eastern and Caribair finally agreed to the terms of the acquisition on May 15; the date of integration was set for December 2, 1973. After that, the former Caribair would operate as Eastern Airlines – Caribair Division. The DC-9-31s were quickly repainted in Eastern colors, and all signs of Caribair quickly disappeared. On December 2, 1973, Caribair’s integration into Eastern was complete. Caribair had previously filed for Chapter 7 liquidation on June 7, 1973, after the Acquisition Agreement with Eastern was completed, and Caribair quietly slipped into aviation history. The main question that comes to mind after the Eastern takeover always concerns whether Caribair could have survived on its own? “Probably not” is the answer given by Jose M. Sierra, still living at age 93. He now regrets the decision to order the Convair 640Ds that were one of the major contributing factors that lead to the demise of the carrier. It was a tough choice between the Darts and the Allison-powered Convair 580s. The company considered the 580, but it was deemed to be too heavy for the Caribair routes. There would be a two- to four-seat penalty on each flight to operate the 580s. The Allison engines had a lower thrust than the Rolls-Royce Dart engines on the 640D. The Darts were designed to run hotter in order to Caribair, Continued produce a higher thrust. However, the Darts apparently had a higher failure rate in the hot section. Caribair was small enough that everyone knew each other – it was a family that cared. The employees put their heart and soul into the company each day to keep it going; it was truly their pride and joy. The former employees and family members refuse to let the memory of Caribair die. In their hearts and memories, the airline still lives on, especially on November 11. Just the Facts SPECIAL THANKS goes to Billy Sierra and Jose Alfonso who each provided most of the information used in this article along with many historic photos and many anecdotes about the airline. Billy is the son of Caribair’s Executive Vice President and General Manager, Jose M. Sierra. Jose Alfonso has acquired an extensive collection of Caribair material. Both are involved in the 70th Anniversary of Caribair’s Founding Reunion in San Juan on November 11, 2007. For further information please contact them at caribair70@yahoo.com. � Name: Caribbean-Atlantic Airlines, Inc. - 1938-1973 (Caribair after July 20, 1948) IATA Code: CB Head Office/Base: San Juan, PR Established: 1938 (as the Powelson Line). On February 27, 1939 it became Caribbean-Atlantic Airlines, Inc. Started: 1938 FLEET LIST Regn. Model MSN Acquired Disposed FLN Notes The Great Airline Novel9/22/64 of Our203Time! 13480 WO SJU 9/22/64 Douglas DC-3/C-47 N1597V C-47A-DK N16068 DC-3A-191 N18940 DC-3A-197B N21787 DC-3-313 N25879 DC-3A-197C N28323 DC-3-277C N34970 DC-3D N65389 C-47A-DL N74620 C-47-DL N79044 C-47A-DL N8011E C-47-DL 1908 2006 2186 2176 2253 42966 19382 4294 9654 4521 9/25/62 4/29/46 9/17/62 5/31/57 /63 12/53 1/12/63 8/17/62 11/4/68 3/31/63 11/4/68 /71 /67 6/63 /71 11/4/68 207 208 200 210 204 206 201 209 202 205 THE TARGET Owned Leased Owned Leased Owned Owned Owned Love, Death and Airline Deregulation Convair 340/440/640 N3406 340-32 N3407 340-32 N3408 340-32 6 4/30/64 20 7/30/65 21“one of the best 7/25/62 airline books since Ernie Gann’s “ 26 4/12/62 Mighty” 27The High & The 6/1/62 N3409 N3410 N3411 N3412 N3417 N3420 340-32 340-32 340-32 340-32 340-32 340-32 31 32 48 64 N4405 N45003 440-75 440-89 463 440 Douglas DC-9-31 N938PR DC-9-31 10/1/65 5/15/73 5/15/73 5/15/73 5/15/73 5/15/73 5/15/73 2/8/67 2/66 11/11/67 10/66 3/28/62 — Captain 9/4/62 Kelly Wilson, EAL, ABX, 10/30/64 Silver Falcon 6/1/67 Never converted Conv. 11/18/65 (#1) Conv. 5/17/66 (#5) WO SJU 1/23/67 Left wing to N3420 Never converted Conv. 8/19/66 (#7) Conv. 6/10/66 (#6) Conv. 3/22/66 (#3) Conv. 4/21/66 (#4) Conv. 1/15/66 (#2) DMGD SJU 4/25/67 LF Gen. Dynamics LF Gen. Dynamics LT AC until 12/1/67 Also ONA/Sudflug N939PR DC-9-31 47120/209 12/12/67 5/15/73 LT Dominicana 8/1/68 – 11/30/68 www.caddispublishing.com N967PR DC-9-31 47121/277 3/23/68 5/15/73 Became N8989E Codes: Conv. = Converted; DMGD = Damaged; LF = Leased from; LT = Leased to; SJU = San Juan; WO = Written off by J.R. Hauptman 47098/108 5/15/73 5/15/73 1/23/73 Owned Owned 5/15/73 A u t o g r a p h e d C o p i e s, A i r l i n e D i s c o u n t s 29 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 17 2009 Silver Falcons Convention Photo Journal Adeline & Joe Wolbert Ann & Stuart Hughes Beryl & Lee Korb Buddy & Vicki Davison Cocktail Party 18 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 Buddy Davison & Ron Russell Cocktail Party Carole & Don Thompson Dana & Jake Jacobus Dave & Marianne Ingle Donna & Jerry Thompson, Linda Lauderdale Dana Jacobus Cecil & Ethel Sales Dick Borrellli & J-Ron Wheeler Kathy & Jerry Williams Darlene & Hank Sanak Cocktail Party The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 19 Don & Marlene Teel Dick & Jane Borrelli Donna Russell & Len Seifert Eilen & Joe Zito Hospitality Suite 20 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 Duane & Paul Fischer Gil & Gaye Gilbert Hank Sanak & Max Peterson Donna & Ron Russell Ethel Sales & Dave Ingle Hopalong Shoop Joe & Adeline Wolbert Jim & Mary Fullerton Jack & Sandy Coleman Jay Madala & Linda Lauderdale Ironman Zito Jim & Linda Lauderdale Gretta & John Green Jack & Shirley Gordon Jack Gordon, Jim & Linda Lauderdale Jerry & Kathy Williams, Donna Mergele The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 21 Kathy Williams Linda & Jim Lauderdale Kathy & Ed McGarvey Lea Johnson, Karen Thompson, Mark Johnson Judy & Ron Shoop Karla Fratt & Jay Madala Karen Thompson & Mark Johnson Lee Korb, Merv Hartwick, Byron Ellis Longhorn Cowboy Line Dancers 22 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 Lea Johnson & Karen Thompson Len Seifert & Jim Fullerton Max Peterson & Jay Madala Mark Johnson & Dick Borrelli Mary Fullerton & Len Seifert Mark Johnson Mark’s 9th Anniversary Cake Len Seifert & Jerry Williams Mark Johnson & Jerry Williams Mark Johnson & Cake The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 23 The Teel Family Ron & Karla Fratt Mark Angstadt & Jane Oament Mike & Donna Gibson Tom & Terry Rast Suzette & Byron Elllis Shirley Gordon & Donna Russell The Ingles Ron Shoop, Donna Russell & Lil Ayars Travis Dugger 24 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 Shirley & Jack Gordon Nina & Len Seifert Special Eastern Dessert Mona Locey & J-Ron Wheeler Scott & Lil Ayars Rick Chisholm & Ron Russell Local Color Sandy McCulloh & Stu Hughes Conrad Olson’s Home Grown Band The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 25 Silver Falcons Annual Business Meeting Hyatt Place Stockyards Hotel, Ft. Worth, TX October 31, 2009 President Ron Shoop called the meeting to order at 0905 CDT. Present were Vice President Sandy McCulloh, Secretary Stuart Hughes, Financial Officer Joe Zito and Director Hank Sanak (proxy for Bill Frank). President Shoop then asked for a financial report. Joe Zito acknowledged the cost cutting efforts of Dick Borrelli and Paul Fisher. He thanked all involved for the flower fund contributions and Maxine Peterson, in particular. The LaFerla Group was also recognized for their $500 convention contribution and noted that we had about $30,000 in the checking account, prior to paying this year’s convention expenses. in 2008, equally share with REPA the future expense of maintaining the Bronze Memorial of Deceased Eastern Pilots.” The motion was seconded by Drawdy and passed 35 For, 7 Against, 0 Abstentions. (Sec. note: it was erroneously read that the motion passed unanimously). A little more discussion followed, with the consensus that we should maintain the dialog with their committee and our voluntary contributions. A straw poll was taken with the result that about 4 members would contribute. It was not determined how many of the members present had already done so. New Business Old Business Eastern Plaque. President Shoop offered the following motion: “This Board of Directors has reviewed the “Plaque Motion” passed at the 2008 Business Meeting and found it to be invalid under the Silver Falcons Bylaws. Therefore, we move to rescind said motion.” This was seconded by Paul Fisher. The President then gave a little background on our discussions with REPA liaison Bob Drawdy and how we had previously been asked to share “equally” in the costs to maintain the project. Distilled to its essence, Drawdy said that REPA didn’t know what to do about the plaque and that he would recommend the project be terminated. The Secretary was then asked to read the 2008 motion proposed by Jim Holder: “Whereas REPA has for over 30 years maintained at great expense the Bronze Memorial of Deceased Eastern Pilots, presently located in the main terminal at the Atlanta Airport and Whereas since all deceased Silver Falcons are listed by name on the Memorial and eventually all Silver Falcons will be so listed, the Silver Falcons believe it is proper that our group now contribute to the continuance of this worthy project. Therefore be it resolved that the members present at the 2008 Annual Silver Falcons Business Meeting hereby direct the 2009 Silver Falcons President to promptly appoint, in accordance with Article X of the Bylaws, a standing Memorial Committee, consisting of, at the minimum, a Memorial Committee Chairman and Be it further resolved that the Silver Falcons Memorial Committee Chairman then work closely with the REPA Memorial Committee Chairman in the care, updating and preservation of the Bronze Memorial of Deceased Eastern Pilots and Be it further resolved that the Silver Falcons, commencing 26 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 Dick Borrelli made the following motion: “I hereby move that our annual contribution of $1,000 to ALS be renewed.” Second by Ron Wheeler. Paul Fisher commented that this actually comes from the flower fund and asked for continued support. The motion passed unanimously. Dick Borrelli made the following motion: “Whereas the Silver Falcons have always guarded and held dear the privilege of Honorary membership in our organization and have only allowed two honorary members to date and Whereas the Silver Falcons have supported ALS (Lou Gehrig’s disease) for a number of years as our primary charitable contribution and Whereas Mark Johnson has inspired us with his bravery and attitude while fighting ALS and has supported the Silver Falcons and has been our skilled and loyal bartender at many conventions, I hereby move that Mark Johnson be elected an honorary member of the Silver Falcons.” Second by Ron Wheeler, passed unanimously. Ed McGarvey offered the following: “Whereas this organization’s membership is limited by the average age of its members and we continue to age and it is desirable to include a new generation to carry on the tradition of the Silver Falcons, I move that the Bylaws be amended, to wit: Article III—add a class of non-voting members known as family members (those related to charter members) and Article V—add dues for family members to be at the then current rate of Charter Members.” Second by Lea Johnson. A short discussion followed concerning voting rights and age restrictions. The motion then passed unanimously as stated. The 2010 Convention. A discussion started about the 2010 Atlanta Convention. Borrelli introduced a motion, seconded by Madala. It was later withdrawn with the consent of the second Annual Business Meeting, Continued after Director Sanak volunteered the Board to be the 2010 host. We then talked about the 2011 Convention site and the possibility of having a permanent site such as the Chicago Group uses. This went over like soap in the gumbo and Lea Johnson moved to have the Board set the 2011 site, second by Byron Ellis. After a brief discussion, the members, by acclamation, decided to use the lunch break to canvas their mates to better determine what they desired in any given site. Bill Rogers moved to adjourn for lunch, second by Paul Fisher, passed unanimously at 1055 CDT. The session resumed at 1132 CDT. There were two offers to host the 2011 Convention: one from Carole Thompson in SAT and the other from Jim Fullerton for Branson, MO. Lea Johnson withdrew his motion with Ellis’ okay and a short discussion ensued about the possibility of paying some expense money to a host who did not actually live in the convention city, such as Branson. The Board will consider these offers in the coming year. 2008 Business Meeting Minutes. The Secretary was asked to read the 2008 minutes. Don Teel moved to approve the minutes without reading. It was seconded by Gil Gilbert and passed unanimously. Gil Gilbert offered the following: “Move the Board research and report at the next convention on the legal way the monies left in the treasury will be disbursed when the Silver Falcons cease to exist.” Second by Paul Fisher, passed unanimously without discussion. President Shoop noted that Secretary/Director Hughes and Director McCulloh would be leaving the Board in January and replaced by volunteers Dave Ingle and Bob Ramsay. The body approved them by acclamation and applause. The President introduced Mark Johnson who gave an update on ALS. Member Maxine Peterson had requested to address the body and she came forward with a plea to upgrade the flight attendant’s status in the organization. Jim Fullerton moved to Amend the Bylaws to elevate all flight attendants to Charter Membership status. Second by Bill Rogers, passed unanimously. Lea Johnson moved to adjourn, seconded by Mark Angstadt and passed unanimously at 1219 CDT, sine die. Respectfully submitted, Stuart Hughes Secretary A Guest Post By Captain Steve Dubner After reading some of the excepts of Captain Sullenberger’s various speeches, especially those of a few weeks ago with the National Transportation Safety Board, I would like to add my editorial from a seasoned international captain. Captain Sullenberger has been a class act all the way. He’s not been petty, pious, or egotistical. He is, however, much like most of the captains I know and, more broadly, most of the pilots I know. Why? He doesn’t need to be otherwise. When someone has accomplished what he and the scores of men and women like him have accomplished, why do we need to boast? He implies that what he did while serving as the “skipper” of US Airways flight 1549 was simply his job. He is being as honest and accurate as he can be: “Please, no fanfare, no applause, just doing my job.” But what he has also alluded to in some of his speeches is that it has taken years, even decades, to prepare himself for that one single “lifetime event” of guiding his jet into the safe, smooth landing on the Hudson River. What he is not saying is this: We, the airline pilots, are facing a losing battle in the PR department. You believe that we make huge salaries and are treated like royalty. Pure fiction. The public persona or image as propagated by airline management and the ATA is grossly wrong. Why have we been losing this battle for such a long time? Simple. Because most of us are like “Sully”; we don’t want applause or fanfare for doing what we are trained to do. However, we do realize that we should be fairly compensated for what we have achieved to get this job and what we continue to do on a daily basis to keep it. This backlash of pilot bashing is building to a boiling point. Regional carriers, like the Colgan Airlines flight in Buffalo, are simply this: they employ the lowest-bidder pilots. No offense to them, this is not personal. Don’t make that a distraction to the problem. It is the system that is at fault. Money and profits at all cost. Airline history lesson 101: It used to be, up until the mid 1980’s, that a young pilot would be hired on at a major carrier, become a flight engineer (FE), and then spend a few years managing the systems of the older-generation airplanes. But he or she was learning all the while. These new “pilots” sat in the FE seat and did their job, all the while observing the “pilots” doing the flying, day in and day out. The FE’s learned from the seasoned pilots about the real-world of flying into the Chicago O’Hares and New York LaGuardias. They learned decision making, delegation, and the reality of “captain’s final authority” as confirmed in the law. When they got the chance to upgrade, they became a copilot. The copilot’s duty was to assist the captain in flying; but even during their time as the new copilot, they had the luxury of the FE looking over their shoulders - i.e., more learning. This three-man-crew concept, now a fond memory in the domestic markets but used predominately in international flying, was considered one more layer of protection. But it’s gone. Now domestic flying is being shifted to the regional carriers, like the American Eagles, Comairs, Mesas, and Colgan Airs, to name a few. These consist of the lowest bidders and the newest pilots flying into the harshest of environments. The airline management teams would respond that it works and that this is routine flying. I beg to differ. The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 27 A Guest Post, continued Analogy: You are told you need open-heart surgery for a quadruple bypass. I ask that from this date forward you go out and search the Internet for the cheapest price that you can get, and you rush to schedule this operation because there are only two dates that you can get that cheap rate. Done! Do any of us do that? No. What do we do? We get second opinions, we ask who is the best in town, etc. We ask: “Is there anyone who has been doing this surgery for the last 20 to 25 years”? We don’t say, “Let me use someone who just graduated from medical school and was rushed through residency because it will be cheaper.” I challenge you on this. Is your life worth less because you are over the heartland of America in the dark of night rather than climbing into the skies of Rio over the Amazon or headed out across the Pacific? It is worth less if you are on the low-cost regional carrier because you chose to pay less. If you are on the regional carrier headed to Denver and the engine is on fire, I am sure that it is comforting to know that you saved 15 percent by shopping the Internet for the cheapest fare. Isn’t it great to know that you have the newest, least-experienced, exhausted, starving young cockpit crew that this regional airline could find? Good for you! Why not apply the same logic that the public uses to buy an airplane ticket to this surgery scenario? Bypass surgery is routine, right? Some surgeons do two, three, or four a day. It must be easy. To take that a step further, how many surgeons have to retake their medical boards every nine months in order to be qualified? Airline pilots do. We are subject to simulator check-rides every nine months to demonstrate knowledge, proficiency, and ability. How many surgeons have to take a physical exam every six months by the A.M.A. in order to work? None! Airline pilots do. Fail your medical exam and you’re done! How many surgeons (or any other critical professional like surgeon or politician) are subject to random drug and alcohol testing? None. Did I say starving? Yeah, I did. Did you know that these regional crews can work for 12 to 13 hours every day, flying five to eight legs a day, but their airline does not feel it’s important enough to provide food for them? They are already on welfare wages, and now they have to find time and money while on the ground for 25 minutes to simply nourish themselves. It’s a sad state of affairs. Remember, you bought the cheapest ticket. Why do we do this? We do this in spite of having lost our pensions, lost 50 percent of our wages, and our horrible work conditions. Our job is intense. It is very fatiguing. Our work causes us to break circadian rhythms and we can’t sleep. I told you, we are dedicated and professional. Flying across the North Atlantic is routine, right? It wasn’t just a short few decades ago. We, the pilots, make it routine for you because we have skills, experience, and training like very few others. Gifted? No, not many of us are. But dedicated and focused upon excellence, you bet! I have told my kids one thing many times since they were little children: “I don’t expect perfection, I expect excellence.” I expect 100 percent effort in all you do. This is the creed of every pilot I know. The public thinks it is entitled to fly anywhere in the country for $99. Get Real. You get what you pay for. Less airfare means less pay, less maintenance, and less customer service. Lower fares mean peanuts are now too expensive and pretzels will cost you. By the way, the next shoe to drop is for airlines to allow foreign investment. Prepare to have our airlines taken over by foreign governments, robbed of cash, and then disbanded. You will now be flying on China Eastern, Lufthansa, or British Airways from O’Hare to Denver. Our jobs and the entire airline industry is about to implode, just so you can have your $99 fare. Flying from Chicago’s O’Hare to Denver is routine, right? But it wasn’t a few decades ago. We, the pilots, make it routine too. But Transplant Donation Request To The Silver Falcons, I was a Flight Attendant for Eastern Air Lines, Kiwi International and US Airways, with service totaling over 33 years. In 1999 I found out that I have a rare lung disease called Alpha 1 Antitrypsin Deficiency. In 2004 it was with great sadness that I was forced into retirement. This disease has progressed to the point that I need a double lung transplant. On Friday, September 25th I was put on the transplant list. They tell me the transplant will probably be within the next six months. Humbled and desperately in need of everyone’s help. I will need help to pay for the high cost of drugs required after surgery. The cost will be up to $10,000 more than what my insurance will cover. GA Transplant Foundation was founded to help people like myself with the high costs of transplantation. They will match every donation given in my name up to $10,000, but only until September 14, 2010. This is a non-profit foundation which was started by a transplant recipient who saw the need. 28 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 I can’t personally thank all of you, but please know how grateful I am. No words can express my appreciation for your generosity and kindness. Please help by passing this on to a friend. I can use all of the help that I may receive. You may donate online at www.gatransplant.org/Client/dhurdstrom or if you do not have access to a computer, you may make a check out to GA Transplant Foundation. In the For/memo line put D. Hurdstrom and mail it to me at 2263 Kilkenny Way NE, Marietta, GA 30066-4625. Thank you from the bottom of my heart, and bless all of you. Sincerely, Diane Hurdstrom Doolittle Raid on Tokyo This is a really excellent firsthand account by the pilot of aircraft #13 on the Doolittle Raid off the Hornet in 1942. Take the time and enjoy a bit of history. My name is Edgar McElroy. My friends call me “Mac”. I was born and raised in Ennis, the youngest of five children, son of Harry and Jennie McElroy. Folks say that I was the quiet one. We lived at 609 North Dallas Street and attended the Presbyterian Church. My dad had an auto mechanic’s shop downtown close to the main fire station. My family was a hard working bunch, and I was expected to work at dad’s garage after school and on Saturdays, so I grew up in an atmosphere of machinery, oil and grease. Occasionally I would hear a lone plane fly over, and would run out in the street and strain my eyes against the sun to watch it. Someday, that would be me up there! I really like cars, and I was always busy on some project, and it wasn’t long before I decided to build my very own Model-T out of spare parts. I got an engine from over here, a frame from over there, and wheels from someplace else, using only the good parts from old cars that were otherwise shot. It wasn’t very pretty, but it was all mine. I enjoyed driving on the dirt roads around town and the feeling of freedom and speed. That car of mine could really go fast. 40 miles per hour! In high school I played football and tennis, and was good enough at football to receive an athletic scholarship from Trinity University in Waxahachie. I have to admit that sometimes I daydreamed in class, and often times I thought about flying my very own airplane and being up there in the clouds. That is when I even decided to take a correspondence course in aircraft engines. Whenever I got the chance, I would take my girl on a date up to Love Field in Dallas. We would watch the airplanes and listen to those mighty piston engines roar. I just loved it and if she didn’t, well that was just too bad. After my schooling, I operated a filling station with my brother, then drove a bus, and later had a job as a machinist in Longview. but I never lost my love of airplanes and my dream of flying. With what was going on in Europe and in Asia, I figured that our country would be drawn into war someday, so I decided to join the Army Air Corps in November of 1940. This way I could finally follow my dream. I reported for primary training in California. The training was rigorous and frustrating at times. We trained at airfields all over California. It was tough going, and many of the guys washed out. When I finally saw that I was going to make it, I wrote to my girl back in Longview, Texas. Her name is Agnes Gill. I asked her to come out to California for my graduation. and oh yeah, also to marry me. I graduated on July 11, 1941. I was now a real, honest-to-goodness Army Air Corps pilot. Two days later, I married “Aggie” in Reno, Nevada. We were starting a new life together and were very happy. I received my orders to report to Pendleton, Oregon and join the 17th Bomb Group. Neither of us had traveled much before, and the drive north through the Cascade Range of the Sierra Nevada’s was interesting and beautiful. It was an exciting time for us. My unit was the first to receive the new B-25 medium bomber. When I saw it for the first time I was in awe. It looked so huge. It was so sleek and powerful. The guys started calling it the “rocket plane”, and I could hardly wait to get my hands on it I told Aggie that it was really something! Reminded me of a big old scorpion, just ready to sting! Man, I could barely wait! We were transferred to another airfield in Washington State, where we spent a lot a time flying practice missions and attacking imaginary targets. Then, there were other assignments in Mississippi and Georgia, for more maneuvers and more practice. We were on our way back to California on December 7th when we got word of a Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. We listened with mixed emotions to the announcements on the radio, and the next day to the declaration of war. What the President said, it just rang over and over in my head, “With confidence in our armed forces, with the un-bounding determination of our people, we will gain the inevitable triumph. So help us God.” By gosh, I felt as though he was talking straight to me! I didn’t know what would happen to us, but we all knew that we would be going somewhere now. The first weeks of the war, we were back in Oregon flying patrols at sea looking for possible Japanese submarines. We had to be up at 0330 hours to warm up the engines of our planes. There was 18 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 29 Doolittle’s Raid, continued inches of snow on the ground, and it was so cold that our engine oil congealed overnight. We placed big tarps over the engines that reached down to the ground. Inside this tent we used plumbers blow torches to thaw out the engines. I figured that my dad would be proud of me, if he could see me inside this tent with all this machinery, oil and grease. After about an hour of this, the engines were warm enough to start. We flew patrols over the coasts of Oregon and Washington from dawn until dusk. Once I thought I spotted a sub, and started my bomb run, even had my bomb doors open, but I pulled out of it when I realized that it was just a big whale. Lucky for me, I would have never heard the end of that! Actually it was lucky for us that the Japanese didn’t attack the west coast, because we just didn’t have a strong enough force to beat them off. Our country was in a real fix now, and overall things looked pretty bleak to most folks. In early February, we were ordered to report to Columbus, South Carolina. Man, this Air Corps sure moves a fellow around a lot! Little did I know what was coming next! After we got settled in Columbus, my squadron commander called us all together. He told us that an awfully hazardous mission was being planned, and then he asked for volunteers. There were some of the guys that did not step forward, but I was one of the ones that did. My co-pilot was shocked. He said “You can’t volunteer, Mac! You’re married, and you and Aggie are expecting a baby soon. Don’t do it!” I told him that “I got into the Air Force to do what I can, and Aggie understands how I feel. The war won’t be easy for any of us” We that volunteered were transferred to Eglin Field near Valparaiso, Florida in late February. When we all got together, there were about 140 of us volunteers, and we were told that we were now part of the “Special B-25 Project.” We set about our training, but none of us knew what it was all about. We were ordered not to talk about it, not even to our wives. In early March, we were all called in for a briefing, and gathered together in a big building there on the base. Somebody said that the fellow who’s head of this thing is coming to talk to us, and in walks Lieutenant Colonel Jimmy Doolittle. He was already an aviation legend, and there he stood right in front of us. I was truly amazed 30 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 just to meet him. Colonel Doolittle explained that this mission would be extremely dangerous, and that only volunteers could take part. He said that he could not tell us where we were going, but he could say that some of us would not be coming back. There was a silent pause; you could have heard a pin drop. Then Doolittle said that anyone of us could withdraw now, and that no one would criticize us for this decision. No one backed out! From the outset, all volunteers worked from the early morning hours until well after sunset. All excess weight was stripped from the planes and extra gas tanks were added. The lower gun turret was removed, the heavy liaison radio was removed, and then the tail guns were taken out and more gas tanks were put aboard. We extended the range of that plane from 1000 miles out to 2500 miles. Then I was assigned my crew. There was Richard Knobloch the co-pilot, Clayton Campbell the navigator, Robert Bourgeous the bombardier, Adam Williams the flight engineer and gunner, and me, Mac McElroy the pilot. Over the coming days, I came to respect them a lot. They were a swell bunch of guys, just regular All-American boys. We got a few ideas from the training as to what type of mission that we had signed on for. A Navy pilot had joined our group to coach us at short takeoffs and also in shipboard etiquette. We began our short takeoff practice. Taking off with first a light load, then a normal load, and finally overloaded up to 31,000 lbs. The shortest possible take-off was obtained with flaps full down, stabilizer set three-fourths, tail heavy, full power against the brakes and releasing the brakes simultaneously as the engine revved up to max power. We pulled back gradually on the stick and the airplane left the ground with the tail skid about one foot from the runway. It was a very unnatural and scary way to get airborne! I could hardly believe it myself, the first time as I took off with a full gas load and dummy bombs within just 700 feet of runway in a near stall condition. We were, for all practical purposes, a slow flying gasoline bomb! In addition to take-off practice, we refined our skills in day and night navigation, gunnery, bombing, and low level flying. We made Doolittle’s Raid, Continued cross country flights at tree-top level, night flights and navigational flights over the Gulf of Mexico without the use of a radio. After we started that short-field takeoff routine, we had some pretty fancy competition between the crews. I think that one crew got it down to about 300 feet on a hot day. We were told that only the best crews would actually go on the mission, and the rest would be held in reserve. One crew did stall on takeoff, slipped back to the ground, busting up their landing gear. They were eliminated from the mission. Doolittle emphasized again and again the extreme danger of this operation, and made it clear that anyone of us who so desired could drop out with no questions asked. No one did. On one of our cross country flights, we landed at Barksdale Field in Shreveport, and I was able to catch a bus over to Longview to see Aggie. We had a few hours together, and then we had to say our goodbyes. I told her I hoped to be back in time for the baby’s birth, but I couldn’t tell her where I was going. As I walked away, I turned and walked backwards for a ways, taking one last look at my beautiful pregnant Aggie Part 2 Within a few days of returning to our base in Florida, we were abruptly told to pack our things. After just three weeks of practice, we were on our way. This was it. It was time to go. It was the middle of March 1942, and I was 30 years old. Our orders were to fly to McClelland Air Base in Sacramento, California on our own, at the lowest possible level. So here we went on our way west, scraping the tree tops at 160 miles per hour, and skimming along just 50 feet above plowed fields. We crossed North Texas and then the panhandle, scaring the dickens out of livestock, buzzing farm houses and a many a barn along the way. Over the Rocky Mountains and across the Mojave Desert dodging thunderstorms, we enjoyed the flight immensely and although tempted, I didn’t do too much dare-devil stuff. We didn’t know it at the time, but it was good practice for what lay ahead of us. It proved to be our last fling. Once we arrived in Sacramento, the mechanics went over our plane with a fine-toothed comb. Of the 22 planes that made it, only those whose pilots reported no mechanical problems were allowed to go on. The others were shunted aside. After having our plane serviced, we flew on to Alameda Naval Air Station in Oakland. As I came in for final approach, we saw it! I excitedly called the rest of the crew to take a look. There below us was a huge aircraft carrier. It was the USS Hornet, and it looked so gigantic! Man, I had never even seen a carrier until this moment. There were already two B-25s parked on the flight deck. Now we knew! My heart was racing, and I thought about how puny my plane would look on board this mighty ship. As soon as we landed and taxied off the runway, a jeep pulled in front of me with a big “Follow Me” sign on the back. We followed it straight up to the wharf, alongside the towering Hornet. All five of us were looking up and just in awe, scarcely believing the size of this thing. As we left the plane, there was already a Navy work crew swarming around attaching cables to the lifting rings on top of the wings and the fuselage. As we walked towards our quarters, I looked back and saw them lifting my plane up into the air and swing it over the ship’s deck. It looked so small and lonely. Later that afternoon, all crews met with Colonel Doolittle and he gave last minute assignments. He told me to go to the Presidio and pick up two hundred extra “C” rations. I saluted, turned, and left, not having any idea where the Presidio was, and not exactly sure what a “C” ration was. I commandeered a Navy staff car and told the driver to take me to the Presidio, and he did. On the way over, I realized that I had no written signed orders and that this might get a little sticky. So in I walked into the Army supply depot and made my request, trying to look poised and confident. The supply officer asked “What is your authorization for this request, sir?” I told him that I could not give him one. “And what is the destination?” he asked. I answered, “The aircraft carrier, Hornet, docked at Alameda.” He said, “Can you tell me who ordered the rations, sir?” And I replied with a smile, “No, I cannot.” The supply officers huddled together, talking and glanced back over towards me. Then he walked back over and assured me that the rations would be delivered that afternoon. Guess they figured that something big was up. They were right. The next morning we all boarded the ship. Trying to remember my naval etiquette, I saluted the Officer of the Deck and said “Lt. McElroy, requesting permission to come aboard.” The officer returned the salute and said “Permission granted.” Then I turned aft and saluted the flag. I made it, without messing up. It was The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 31 Doolittle’s Raid, continued April 2, and in full sunlight, we left San Francisco Bay. The whole task force of ships, two cruisers, four destroyers, and a fleet oiler, moved slowly with us under the Golden Gate Bridge. Thousands of people looked on. Many stopped their cars on the bridge, and waved to us as we passed underneath. I thought to myself, I hope there aren’t any spies up there waving. Once at sea, Doolittle called us together. “Only a few of you know our destination, and you others have guessed about various targets. Gentlemen, your target is Japan !” A sudden cheer exploded among the men. “Specifically, Yokohama, Tokyo, Nagoya, Kobe, Nagasaki and Osaka. The Navy task force will get us as close as possible and we’ll launch our planes. We will hit our targets and proceed to airfields in China.” After the cheering stopped, he asked again, if any of us desired to back out, no questions asked. Not one did, not one. Then the ship’s Captain then went over the intercom to the whole ship’s company. The loudspeaker blared, “The destination is Tokyo!” A tremendous cheer broke out from everyone on board. I could hear metal banging together and wild screams from down below decks. It was quite a rush! I felt relieved actually. We finally knew where we were going. I set up quarters with two Navy pilots, putting my cot between their two bunks. They couldn’t get out of bed without stepping on me. It was just fairly cozy in there, yes it was. Those guys were part of the Torpedo Squadron Eight and were just swell fellows. The rest of the guys bedded down in similar fashion to me, some had to sleep on bedrolls in the Admiral’s chartroom. As big as this ship was, there wasn’t any extra room anywhere. Every square foot had a purpose... A few days later we discovered where they had an ice cream machine! There were sixteen B-25s tied down on the flight deck, and I was flying number 13. All the carrier’s fighter planes were stored away helplessly in the hangar deck. They couldn’t move until we were gone. Our Army mechanics were all on board, as well as our munitions loaders and several back up crews, in case any of us got sick or backed out. We settled into a daily routine of checking our 32 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 planes. The aircraft were grouped so closely together on deck that it wouldn’t take much for them to get damaged. Knowing that my life depended on this plane, I kept a close eye on her. Day after day, we met with the intelligence officer and studied our mission plan. Our targets were assigned, and maps and objective folders were furnished for study. We went over approach routes and our escape route towards China. I never studied this hard back at Trinity. Every day at dawn and at dusk the ship was called to general quarters and we practiced finding the quickest way to our planes. If at any point along the way, we were discovered by the enemy fleet, we were to launch our bombers immediately so the Hornet could bring up its fighter planes. We would then be on our own, and try to make it to the nearest land, either Hawaii or Midway Island. Dr. Thomas White, a volunteer member of plane number 15, went over our medical records and gave us inoculations for a whole bunch of diseases that hopefully I wouldn’t catch. He gave us training sessions in emergency first aid, and lectured us at length about water purification and such. Tom, a medical doctor, had learned how to be a gunner just so he could go on this mission. We put some new tail guns in place of the ones that had been taken out to save weight. Not exactly functional, they were two broom handles, painted black. The thinking was they might help scare any Jap fighter planes. Maybe, maybe not. On Sunday, April 14, we met up with Admiral Bull Halsey’s task force just out of Hawaii and joined into one big force. The carrier Enterprise was now with us, another two heavy cruisers, four more destroyers and another oiler. We were designated as Task Force 16. It was quite an impressive sight to see, and represented the bulk of what was left of the U.S. Navy after the devastation of Pearl Harbor. There were over 10,000 Navy personnel sailing into harm’s way, just to deliver us sixteen Army planes to the Japs, orders of the President. As we steamed further west, tension was rising as we drew nearer and nearer to Japan. Someone thought of arming us with some old.45 pistols that they had on board. I went through that box of 1911 pistols, they were in such bad condition that I took several of them apart, using the good parts from several useless guns until I built a serviceable weapon. Several of the other pilots did the same. Admiring my “new” pistol, I held it up, and thought about my old Model-T. Colonel Doolittle called us together on the flight deck. We all gathered round, as well as many Doolittle’s Raid, Continued Navy personnel. He pulled out some medals and told us how these friendship medals from the Japanese government had been given to some of our Navy officers several years back. And now the Secretary of the Navy had requested for us to return them. Doolittle wired them to a bomb while we all posed for pictures. Something to cheer up the folks back home! I began to pack my things for the flight, scheduled for the 19th. I packed some extra clothes and a little brown bag that Aggie had given me, inside were some toilet items and a few candy bars. No letters or identity cards were allowed, only our dog-tags. I went down to the wardroom to have some ice cream and settle up my mess bill. It only amounted to $5 a day and with my per diem of $6 per day, I came out a little ahead. By now, my Navy pilot roommates were about ready to get rid of me, but I enjoyed my time with them. They were alright. Later on, I learned that both of them were killed at the Battle of Midway. They were good men. Yes, very good men. Colonel Doolittle let each crew pick our own target. We chose the Yokosuka Naval Base about twenty miles from Tokyo. We loaded 1450 rounds of ammo and four 500-pound bombs... A little payback, direct from Ellis County, Texas ! We checked and re-checked our plane several times. Everything was now ready. I felt relaxed, yet tensed up at the same time. Day after tomorrow, we will launch when we are 400 miles out. I lay in my cot that night, and rehearsed the mission over and over in my head. It was hard to sleep as I listened to sounds of the ship. there was a message in it which said, “From the Hornet to the Army—Good luck, good hunting, and God bless you.” I still had a large lump in my throat from reading this, when all of a sudden, the intercom blared, “General Quarters, General Quarters, All hands man your battle stations! Army pilots, man your planes!!!” There was instant reaction from everyone in the room and food trays went crashing to the floor. I ran down to my room jumping through the hatches along the way, grabbed my bag, and ran as fast as I could go to the flight deck. I met with my crew at the plane, my heart was pounding. Someone said, “What’s going on?” The word was that the Enterprise had spotted an enemy trawler. It had been sunk, but it had transmitted radio messages. We had been found out! The weather was crummy, the seas were running heavy, and the ship was pitching up and down like I had never seen before. Great waves were crashing against the bow and washing over the front of the deck. This wasn’t going to be easy! Last minute instructions were given. We were reminded to avoid non-military targets, especially the Emperor’s Palace. Do not fly to Russia, but fly as far west as possible, land on the water and launch our rubber raft. This was going to be a one-way trip! We were still much too far out Part 3 Early the next morning, I was enjoying a leisurely breakfast, expecting another full day on board, and I noticed that the ship was pitching and rolling quite a bit this morning, more than normal. I was reading through the April 18th day plan of the Hornet, and The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 33 Doolittle’s Raid, continued and we all knew that our chances of making land were somewhere between slim and none. Then at the last minute, each plane loaded an extra ten 5-gallon gas cans to give us a fighting chance of reaching China. We all climbed aboard, started our engines and warmed them up, just feet away from the plane in front of us and the plane behind us. Knobby, Campbell, Bourgeois and me in the front, Williams, the gunner was in the back, separated from us by a big rubber gas tank. I called back to Williams on the intercom and told him to look sharp and don’t take a nap! He answered dryly, “Don’t worry about me, Lieutenant. If they jump us, I’ll just use my little black broomsticks to keep the Japs off our tail.” The ship headed into the wind and picked up speed. There was now a near gale force wind and water spray coming straight over the deck. I looked down at my instruments as my engines revved up. My mind was racing. I went over my mental checklist, and said a prayer? God please, help us! Past the twelve planes in front of us, I strained to see the flight deck officer as he leaned into the wind and signaled with his arms for Colonel Doolittle to come to full power. I looked over at Knobby and we looked each other in the eye. He just nodded to me and we both understood. With the deck heaving up and down, the deck officer had to time this just right. Then I saw him wave Doolittle to go, and we watched breathlessly to see what happened. When his plane pulled up above the deck, Knobby just let out with, “Yes! Yes!” The second plane, piloted by Lt. Hoover, appeared to stall with its nose up and began falling toward the waves. We groaned and called out, “Up! Up! Pull it up!” Finally, he pulled out of it, staggering back up into the air, much to our relief! One by one, the planes in front of us took off. The deck pitched wildly, 60 feet or more, it looked like. One plane seemed to drop down into the drink and disappeared for a moment, then pulled 34 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 back up into sight. There was sense of relief with each one that made it. We gunned our engines and started to roll forward. Off to the right, I saw the men on deck cheering and waving their covers! We continued inching forward, careful to keep my left main wheel and my nose wheel on the white guidelines that had been painted on the deck for us. Get off a little bit too far left and we go off the edge of the deck. A little too far to the right and our wing-tip will smack the island of the ship. With the best seat on the ship, we watched Lt. Bower take off in plane number 12, and I taxied up to the starting line, put on my the brakes and looked down to my left. My main wheel was right on the line. Applied more power to the engines, and I turned my complete attention to the deck officer on my left, who was circling his paddles. Now my adrenaline was really pumping! We went to full power, and the noise and vibration inside the plane went way up. He circled the paddles furiously while watching forward for the pitch of the deck. Then he dropped them, and I said, “Here We Go!” I released the brakes and we started rolling forward, and as I looked down the flight-deck you could see straight down into the angry churning water. As we slowly gained speed, the deck gradually began to pitch back up. I pulled up and our plane slowly strained up and away from the ship. There was a big cheer and whoops from the crew, but I just felt relieved and muttered to myself, “Boy, that was short!” We made a wide circle above our fleet to check our compass headings and get our bearings. I looked down as we passed low over one of our cruisers and could see the men on deck waving to us. I dropped down to low level, so low we could see the whitecap waves breaking. It was just after 0900, there were broken clouds at 5,000 feet and visibility of about thirty miles due to haze or something. Up ahead and barely in sight, I could see Captain Greening, our flight leader, and Bower on his right wing. Flying at 170 mph, I was able to catch up to them in about 30 minutes. We were to stay in this formation until reaching landfall, and then break on our separate ways. Now we settled in for the five hour flight. Tokyo, here we come! Williams was in the back emptying the extra gas cans into the gas tank as fast as we had burned off enough fuel. He then punched holes in the tins and pushed then out the hatch against the wind. Some of the fellows ate sandwiches and other goodies that the Navy had put aboard for us... I wasn’t hungry. I held onto the controls with a firm grip as we raced along westward just fifty feet Doolittle’s Raid, Continued above the cold rolling ocean, as low as I dared to fly. Being so close to the choppy waves gave you a true sense of speed. Occasionally our windshield was even sprayed with a little saltwater. It was an exhilarating feeling, and I felt as though the will and spirit of our whole country was pushing us along. I didn’t feel too scared, just anxious. There was a lot riding on this thing, and on me. As we began to near land, we saw an occasional ship here and there None of them close enough to be threatening, but just the same, we were feeling more edgy. Then at 1330 we sighted land, the Eastern shore of Honshu With Williams now on his guns in the top turret and Campbell on the nose gun, we came ashore still flying low as possible, and were surprised to see people on the ground waving to us as we flew in over the farmland. It was beautiful countryside. Campbell, our navigator, said, “Mac, I think we’re going to be about sixty miles too far north. I’m not positive, but pretty sure.” I decided that he was absolutely right and turned left ninety degrees, went back just offshore and followed the coast line south. When I thought we had gone far enough, I climbed up to two thousand feet to find out where we were. We started getting fire from antiaircraft guns. Then we spotted Tokyo Bay, turned west and put our nose down diving toward the water. Once over the bay, I could see our target, Yokosuka Naval Base. Off to the right there was already smoke visible over Tokyo. Coming in low over the water, I increased speed to 200 mph and told everyone, “Get Ready!” Part 4 When we were close enough, I pulled up to 1300 feet and opened the bomb doors. There were furious black bursts of anti-aircraft fire all around us, but I flew straight on through them, spotting our target, the torpedo works and the dry-docks. I saw a big ship in the dry-dock just as we flew over it. Those flak bursts were really getting close and bouncing us around, when I heard Bourgeois shouting, “Bombs Away!” I couldn’t see it, but Williams had a bird’s eye view from the back and he shouted jubilantly, “We got an aircraft carrier! The whole dock is burning!” I started turning to the south and strained my neck to look back and at that moment saw a large crane blow up and start falling over!... Take that! There was loud yelling and clapping each other on the back. We were all just ecstatic, and still alive! But there wasn’t much time to celebrate. We had to get out of here and fast! When we were some thirty miles out to sea, we took one last look back at our target, and could still see huge billows of black smoke. Up until now, we had been flying for Uncle Sam, but now we were flying for ourselves. We flew south over open ocean, parallel to the Japanese coast all afternoon. We saw a large submarine apparently at rest, and then in another fifteen miles, we spotted three large enemy cruisers headed for Japan. There were no more bombs, so we just let them be and kept on going. By late afternoon, Campbell calculated that it was time to turn and make for China. Across the East China Sea, the weather out ahead of us looked bad and overcast. Up until now we had not had time to think much about our gasoline supply, but the math did not look good. We just didn’t have enough fuel to make it! Each man took turns cranking the little hand radio to see if we could pick up the promised radio beacon. There was no signal. This is not good. The weather turned bad and it was getting dark, so we climbed up. I was now flying on instruments, through a dark misty rain. Just when it really looked hopeless of reaching land, we suddenly picked up a strong tailwind. It was an answer to a prayer. Maybe just maybe, we can make it! In total darkness at 2100 hours, we figured that we must be crossing the coastline, so I began a slow, slow climb to be sure of not hitting any high ground or anything. I conserved as much fuel as I could, getting real low on gas now. The guys were still cranking on the radio, but after five hours of hand cranking with aching hands and backs, there was utter silence. No radio beacon! Then the red light started blinking, indicating twenty minutes of fuel left. We started getting ready to bail out. I turned the controls over to Knobby and crawled to the back of the plane, past the now collapsed rubber gas tank. I dumped everything out of my bag and repacked just what The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 35 Doolittle’s Raid, continued I really needed, my .45 pistol, ammunition, flashlight, compass, medical kit, fishing tackle, chocolate bars, peanut butter and crackers. I told Williams to come forward with me so we could all be together for this. There was no other choice. I had to get us as far west as possible, and then we had to jump. At 2230 we were up to sixty-five hundred feet. We were over land but still above the Japanese Army in China. We couldn’t see the stars, so Campbell couldn’t get a good fix on our position. We were flying on fumes now and I didn’t want to run out of gas before we were ready to go. Each man filled his canteen, put on his Mae West life jacket and parachute, and filled his bag with rations, those “C” rations from the Presidio. I put her on auto-pilot and we all gathered in the navigator’s compartment around the hatch in the floor. We checked each other’s parachute harness. Everyone was scared, without a doubt. None of us had ever done this before! I said, “Williams first, Bourgeois second, Campbell third, Knobloch fourth, and I’ll follow you guys! Go fast, two seconds apart! Then count three seconds off and pull your rip-cord!” We kicked open the hatch and gathered around the hole looking down into the blackness. It did not look very inviting! Then I looked up at Williams and gave the order, “JUMP!!!” Within seconds they were all gone. I turned and reached back for the auto-pilot, but could not reach it, so I pulled the throttles back, then turned and jumped. Counting quickly, thousand one, thousand two, thousand three, I pulled my rip-cord and jerked back up with a terrific shock. At first I thought that I was hung on the plane, but after a few agonizing seconds that seemed like hours, realized that I was free and drifting down. Being in the total dark, I was disoriented at first but figured my feet must be pointed toward the ground. I looked down through the black mist to see what was coming up. I was in a thick mist or fog, and the silence was so eerie after nearly thirteen hours inside that noisy plane. I could only hear the whoosh, whoosh sound of the wind blowing through my shroud lines, and then I heard a loud crash and explosion. My plane! Looking for my flashlight, I groped through my bag with my right hand, finally pulled it out and shined it down toward the ground, which I still could not see. Finally I picked up a glimmer of water and thought I was landing in a lake. We’re too far inland for this to be ocean. I hope! I relaxed my legs a little, thinking I was about to splash into water and would have to swim out, and then bang. I jolted suddenly and crashed over onto my side. Lying there in just a few inches of water, I raised my head and put my hands down into thick mud. It was rice paddy! There was a burning pain, as if someone had stuck a knife in my stomach. I must have torn a muscle or broke something. I laid there dazed for a few minutes, and after a while struggled up to my feet. I dug a hole and buried my parachute in the mud. Then started trying to walk, holding my stomach, but every direction I moved the water got deeper. Then, I saw some lights off in the distance. I fished around for my flashlight and signaled one time. Sensing something wrong, I got out my compass and to my horror saw that those lights were off to my west. That must be a Jap patrol! How dumb could I be! Knobby had to be back to my east, so I sat still and quiet and did not move. It was a cold dark lonely night. At 0100 hours I saw a single light off to the east I flashed my light in that direction, one time. It had to be 36 The rEAL Word | Fall 2009 Knobby! I waited a while, and then called out softly, “Knobby?” And a voice replied “Mac, is that you?” Thank goodness, what a relief! Separated by a wide stream, we sat on opposite banks of the water communicating in low voices. After daybreak Knobby found a small rowboat and came across to get me We started walking east toward the rest of the crew and away from that Japanese patrol. Knobby had cut his hip when he went through the hatch, but it wasn’t too awful bad. We walked together toward a small village and several Chinese came out to meet us, they seemed friendly enough. I said, “Luchu hoo megwa fugi! Luchu hoo megwa fugi!” meaning, “I am an American! I am an American!” Later that morning we found the others. Williams had wrenched his knee when he landed in a tree, but he was limping along just fine. There were hugs all around. I have never been so happy to see four guys in all my life! Well, the five of us eventually made it out of China with the help of the local Chinese people and the Catholic missions along the way. They were all very good to us, and later they were made to pay terribly for it, so we found out afterwards. For a couple of weeks we traveled across country. Strafed a couple of times by enemy planes, we kept on moving, by foot, by pony, by car, by train, and by airplane. But we finally made it to India. I did not make it home for the baby’s birth. I stayed on there flying a DC-3 “Gooney Bird” in the China-Burma-India Theatre for the next several months. I flew supplies over the Himalaya Mountains, or as we called it, over “The Hump” into China. When B-25s finally arrived in India, I flew combat missions over Burma, and then later in the war, flew a B-29 out of the Marianna Islands to bomb Japan again and again. After the war, I remained in the Air Force until 1962, when I retired from the service as a Lt. Colonel, and then came back to Texas, my beautiful Texas. First moving to Abilene and then we settled in Lubbock, where Aggie taught school at MacKenzie Junior High. I worked at the S&R Auto Supply, once again in an atmosphere of machinery, oil and grease. I lived a good life and raised two wonderful sons that I am very proud of. I feel blessed in many ways. We have a great country, better than most folks know. It is worth fighting for. Some people call me a hero, but I have never thought of myself that way, no. But I did serve in the company of heroes. What we did, will never leave me. It will always be there in my fondest memories. I will always think of the fine and brave men that I was privileged to serve with. Remember us, for we were soldiers once and young. With the loss of all 16 aircraft, Doolittle believed that the raid had been a failure, and that he would be court-martialed upon returning to the states. Quite to the contrary, the raid proved to be a tremendous boost to American morale, which had plunged following the Pearl Harbor attack. It also caused serious doubts in the minds of Japanese war planners. They in turn recalled many seasoned fighter plane units back to defend the home islands, which resulted in Japan’s weakened air capabilities at the upcoming Battle of Midway and other South Pacific campaigns. Edgar “Mac” Mc Elroy, Lt. Col., U.S.A.F. (Ret.) passed away at his residence in Lubbock, Texas early on the morning of Friday, April 4, 2003.