Onward Holdings Co Ltd (8016)

Transcription

SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Shared Research Inc. has produced this report by request from the company discussed in the report. The aim is
to provide an “owner’s manual” to investors. We at Shared Research Inc. make every effort to provide an
accurate, objective, and neutral analysis. In order to highlight any biases, we clearly attribute our data and
findings. We will always present opinions from company management as such. Our views are ours where stated.
We do not try to convince or influence, only inform. We appreciate your suggestions and feedback. Write to us at
sr_inquiries@sharedresearch.jp or find us on Bloomberg.
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Contents
Recent Updates .......................................................................................................4
Highlights ............................................................................................................4
Trends & Outlook .................................................................................................4
Business ............................................................................................................... 10
Business Description ........................................................................................... 10
Strategy ............................................................................................................ 24
Historical Financial Statements................................................................................ 28
Summary .......................................................................................................... 28
Income Statement.............................................................................................. 54
Balance Sheet .................................................................................................... 56
Cash Flow Statement .......................................................................................... 58
Other Information ................................................................................................. 59
History .............................................................................................................. 59
News & Topics ................................................................................................... 59
Top Management ............................................................................................... 61
Employees ......................................................................................................... 61
Major Shareholders ............................................................................................ 62
Dividends .......................................................................................................... 62
Investor Relations .............................................................................................. 62
By The Way ....................................................................................................... 62
Company Profile ................................................................................................. 63
About Shared Research Inc. ................................................................................... 64
Disclaimer............................................................................................................. 64
http://www.sharedresearch.jp/
Copyright (C) 2013 Shared Research Inc. All Rights Reserved
2/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Income Statement
(million yen)
Total Sales
YoY
Gross Profit
YoY
GPM
Operating Profit
FY02/10
Cons.
248,634
FY02/11
Cons.
244,550
FY02/12
Cons.
242,402
FY02/13
Cons.
258,369
FY02/14
Cons.
279,073
FY02/15
Est.
290,700
4.2%
-4.7%
-1.6%
-0.9%
6.6%
8.0%
114,176
115,825
115,113
124,490
129,959
-3.5%
45.9%
1.4%
47.4%
-0.6%
47.5%
8.1%
48.2%
4.4%
46.6%
4,383
8,928
10,953
11,192
9,422
12,300
-51.8%
1.8%
103.7%
3.7%
22.7%
4.5%
2.2%
4.3%
-15.8%
3.4%
30.5%
4.2%
Recurring Profit
6,120
10,497
13,329
13,405
12,211
13,700
YoY
RPM
-2.6%
2.5%
71.5%
4.3%
27.0%
5.5%
0.6%
5.2%
-8.9%
4.4%
12.2%
4.7%
Net Income
2,187
2,722
3,529
4,503
4,658
5,400
0.9%
24.5%
1.1%
29.6%
1.5%
27.6%
1.7%
3.5%
1.7%
15.9%
1.9%
172,922
29.7
24.0
1,103.0
34.4
24.0
YoY
OPM
YoY
Net Margin
Per Share Data
Number of Shares (Thousand)
172,922
172,922
172,922
172,922
EPS
14.0
17.4
22.5
28.7
Dividend Per Share
24.0
24.0
24.0
24.0
Book Value Per Share
999.0
1,002.3
995.1
1,043.6
Balance Sheet (Million Yen)
Cash and Equivalents
34,330
30,939
33,192
24,677
Total Current Assets
100,680
95,544
98,895 100,321
Tangible Fixed Assets, net
89,741
86,622
82,987
86,861
Other Fixed Assets
51,335
52,729
51,561
64,138
Intangible Assets
50,811
46,745
43,495
35,457
Total Fixed Assets
191,888 186,097 178,044 186,458
Total Assets
292,568 281,642 276,939 286,779
Accounts Payable
35,961
32,703
33,238
33,512
Short-Term Debt
35,697
30,886
29,865
47,581
Total Current Liabilities
90,929
82,677
84,091 100,740
Long-Term Debt
24,571
22,665
19,730
1,573
Total Fixed Liabilities
43,475
40,220
35,545
20,666
Total Liabilities
134,404 122,898 119,636 121,407
Net Assets
158,164 158,744 157,302 165,372
Interest-Bearing Debt
60,268
53,551
49,595
49,154
Cash Flow Statement (million yen)
Operating Cash Flow
14,057
11,206
13,180
10,137
Investment Cash Flow
-25
-5,151
-1,961
-10,682
Financing Cash Flow
-4,889
-9,271
-7,449
-7,848
Financial Ratios
ROA
0.7%
0.9%
1.3%
1.6%
ROE
1.4%
1.7%
2.2%
2.8%
Equity Ratio
54.1%
56.4%
56.8%
57.7%
Figures may differ from company materials due to differences in rounding methods.
Source: Company data, SR Inc. Research
27,375
110,349
102,878
65,926
34,276
203,081
313,430
38,305
44,956
101,009
14,051
37,391
138,401
175,028
59,007
13,361
-14,300
2,121
1.6%
2.8%
55.8%
3/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Recent Updates
Highlights
On April 4, 2014, Onward Holdings announced FY02/14 results and monthly sales data for February and
March; please see the results section for further details.
On February 4, 2013, the company released January monthly sales data: please see the monthly
trends section for further details.
For corporate releases and developments more than three months old, please refer to the
News & Topics section.
Trends & Outlook
Monthly Trends
Onward Kashiyama Monthly Sales
FY02/15 (YoY)
Mar
Apr
Men's
16%
Women's
9%
Children's
10%
Kimonos
-17%
Other
8%
Total
10%
FY02/14 (YoY)
Mar
Apr
Men's
2%
-8%
Women's
10%
1%
Children's
9%
-7%
Kimonos
-11% -11%
Other
-1%
-8%
Total
7% -2%
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
May
1%
6%
-3%
19%
-9%
4%
Jun
1%
10%
4%
-12%
2%
7%
Jul
-11%
0%
2%
-23%
0%
3%
Aug
7%
8%
9%
-6%
11%
8%
Sep
4%
2%
2%
-14%
-1%
2%
Oct
-3%
-5%
-2%
-23%
-11%
-5%
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
FY
16%
9%
10%
-17%
8%
10%
Nov Dec
Jan
0%
8%
3%
0%
5%
7%
0%
4% -1%
-14% -17% -15%
0%
5% -1%
0% 5% 5%
Feb
3%
0%
0%
-17%
-3%
1%
FY
0%
3%
1%
-12%
-2%
2%
4/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Quarterly Trends & Results
(million yen)
Sales
YoY
GP
YoY
Q1
67,581
10.1%
33,886
11.4%
FY02/13
Q2
Q3
53,305
70,479
1.9%
2.5%
23,863
36,649
3.2%
1.4%
Q4
67,004
11.8%
30,092
18.3%
Q1
72,174
6.8%
35,561
4.9%
FY02/14
Q2
Q3
60,145
73,122
12.8%
3.8%
26,884
36,413
12.7%
-0.6%
Q4
73,632
9.9%
31,101
3.4%
GPM
50.1%
44.8%
52.0%
44.9%
49.3%
44.7%
49.8%
42.2%
SG&A
YoY
27,669
7.5%
26,923
2.8%
29,102
10.3%
29,604
14.5%
29,170
5.4%
29,943
11.2%
29,621
1.8%
31,803
7.4%
SG&A / Sales
40.9%
50.5%
41.3%
44.2%
40.4%
49.8%
40.5%
43.2%
YoY
6,216
32.9%
-3,059
-
7,547
-22.8%
488
-
6,390
2.8%
-3,059
-
6,792
-10.0%
-701
-
OP
OPM
9.2%
-
10.7%
0.7%
8.9%
-
9.3%
-
YoY
6,029
12.2%
-2,307
-
8,038
-17.4%
1,645
45.3%
7,184
19.2%
-2,413
-
7,100
-11.7%
340
-79.3%
RP
RPM
8.9%
-
11.4%
2.5%
10.0%
-
9.7%
0.5%
YoY
2,815
30.4%
-2,293
-
4,114
-3.9%
-133
-
3,841
36.4%
-2,190
-
4,106
-0.2%
-1,099
-
NPM
4.2%
-
5.8%
-
5.3%
-
5.6%
-
NI
FY02/14
% of FY
FY Est.
100.7%
277,000
7.2%
73.0%
12,900
15.3%
82.5%
14,800
10.4%
93.2%
5,000
11.0%
4.7%
5.3%
1.8%
Comment on seasonality.
The company’s quarterly sales and profits fluctuate significantly due to the timing of seasonal bargain
sales. Q2 includes the summer sales period of July, and the proportion of merchandise sold at normal
prices is low in August as bargain sales continue while stores convert to new autumn lineups. As a result,
profitability is likely to be severely affected—Q2 operating profit was negative in both FY02/09 and
FY02/10. In a similar manner, Q4 profit is affected by the winter bargain sale in January and by the
revaluation loss recorded at fiscal year-end.
FY02/14 Results (announced on April 4, 2014; please refer to the preceding tables)
For the full year, sales were 279.1 billion yen (+8.0% YoY), operating profit was 9.4 billion yen (-15.8%
YoY), and recurring profit was 12.2 billion yen (-8.9% YoY). Net income was 4.7 billion yen (+3.5% YoY),
thanks to extraordinary profits such as 891 million yen on the sale of investment securities.
According to the company, full-year performance highlights were as follows.
Consolidated operating profit was down by 1.8 billion yen YoY. Breaking this down at the subsidiary level:
 Onward Holdings and Onward Kashiyama: Operating profit rose by 494 million yen;
 JOSEPH: Operating profit rose by 439 million yen;
 GIBO’ Co: Operating profit rose by 131 million yen;
 Jil Sander: Operating profit fell by 1.4 billion yen;
 Birz Group: Operating profit fell by 672 million yen.
Onward Holdings and Onward Kashiyama
Sales of 159.7 billion yen (up 2.2% YoY); operating profit of 11.5 billion yen (up 4.5% YoY)
Onward Trading
Chacott
Sales of 10.7 billion yen (up 1.7% YoY); operating profit of 573 million yen (down 23.1% YoY)
Creative Yoko
Sales of 7.0 billion yen (down 5.2% YoY); operating profit of 307 million yen (down 55.9% YoY)
Birz Group
5/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Sales of 6.1 billion yen (down 14.9% YoY); operating loss of 684 million yen (vs. an operating loss of 12
million yen in FY02/13)
Island
Sales of 8.4 billion yen (down 0.9% YoY); operating profit of 1.2 billion yen (down 17.5% YoY)
Across Transport
JOSEPH
Sales of 11.8 billion yen (up 34.1% YoY); operating profit of 97 million yen (vs. an operating loss of 342
GIBO’Co
Sales of 21.0 billion yen (up 42.3% YoY); operating profit of 932 million yen (up 16.4% YoY)
Jil Sander
Sales of 13.5 billion yen (up 29.6% YoY); operating loss of 1.3 billion yen (vs. an operating loss of 711
Domestic
Onward Kashiyama sales grew at a healthy pace in 1H, particularly in core brands. Menswear also moved
toward recovery. However, sales fell as inclement weather, such as typhoons hit during October, which is
the peak time for consumption in 2H. Sales were also negatively affected when consumer appetites
cooled following the decision to go ahead with the consumption tax hike. Other domestic subsidiaries
were similarly affected. E-commerce sales were robust, outperforming full-year targets at Onward
Kashiyama and other subisidiaries.
Sales at Onward Kashiyama core brands were as follows:
 Nijyusanku: +2.5% YoY;
 Kumikyoku: +9.4% YoY;
 ICB: +1.0% YoY;
 Jiyuku: +3.4% YoY.
Overseas
The JOSEPH Group reported strong results in Europe. The GIBO’ Co group also increased sales and built
a stable base for future profits. However, results weakened at the Jil Sander group due to upfront
investments with an eye toward future growth. Sales rose but profits fell in Asia and North America—the
result of political and economic uncertainty coupled with investment for future expansion.
For details on previous quarterly and annual results, please refer to the Historical Financial
Statements section.
6/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Full-Year (FY02/15) Outlook
FY02/15 Forecast
(million yen)
Sales
1H Act.
132,319
FY02/14
2H Act.
146,754
FY Act.
279,073
1H Est.
136,500
FY02/15
2H Est.
154,200
FY Est.
290,700
3.2%
5.1%
4.2%
YoY
9.5%
6.7%
8.0%
CoGS
69,874
79,240
149,113
10.7%
12.0%
11.4%
62,445
67,514
129,959
YoY
GPM %
8.1%
47.2%
1.2%
46.0%
4.4%
46.6%
SG&A
59,113
61,424
120,537
YoY
SG&A/Sales
8.3%
44.7%
4.6%
41.9%
6.4%
43.2%
Operating Profit
3,331
6,091
9,422
4,000
8,300
12,300
5.5%
2.5%
-24.2%
4.2%
-15.8%
3.4%
20.1%
2.9%
36.3%
5.4%
30.5%
4.2%
YoY
Gross Profit
YoY
OPM %
Recurring Profit
4,771
7,440
12,211
4,800
8,900
13,700
YoY
28.2%
-23.2%
-8.9%
0.6%
19.6%
12.2%
Net Income
1,651
3,007
4,658
1,700
3,700
5,400
216.3%
-24.5%
3.4%
3.0%
23.0%
15.9%
YoY
Future Outlook
Medium-Term Plan
FY02/12
FY02/15 Targets
(million yen)
(% of Total)
(% of Total) Vs. FY02/12
Sales
242,402
350,000
+44%
Existing Business Total
257,685
100% 346,000
100%
+34%
Domestic Total
213,730
83% 261,000
75%
+22%
Onward Kashiyama
149,985
58%
180,000
52%
+20%
Other Domestic
63,745
25%
81,000
23%
+27%
Overseas Total
43,955
17%
85,000
25%
+93%
Europe
34,170
13%
59,000
17%
+73%
Asia
6,895
3%
21,000
6%
+205%
US
2,890
1%
5,000
1%
+73%
New Business + M&A
35,000
Intercompany Eliminations
-15,283
-31,000
Recurring Profit
13,329
28,000
+110%
Existing Business Total
100%
29,200
100%
+81%
Domestic Total
92%
22,000
75%
+49%
Onward Kashiyama
16,000
55%
+42%
Other Domestic
6,000
21%
+74%
Overseas Total
8%
7,200
25%
+433%
Europe
5,000
17%
+350%
Asia
1,700
6%
+343%
US
500
2%
↑
New Business + M&A
2,800
Intercompany Eliminations
-4,000
ROE
2.3%
8.0%
7/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
On April 9, 2012, the company announced its New Medium-Term Three-Year Plan (from FY02/13 to
FY02/15). The targets in the final year of the plan, FY02/15, call for sales of 350.0 billion yen (up 43% on
FY02/12), operating profit of 26.5 billion yen (up 99%), recurring profit of 28.0 billion yen (up 110%), and
ROE of 8% (compared to 2.3% in FY02/12).
Based on the company’s forecasts for FY02/14, SR believes it is realistic to expect the company to achieve
its targets one year later than planned. It appears that the company will strengthen its financial base
through investment and other methods in FY02/13 and FY02/14, particularly in overseas markets, with
the aim of reaping the rewards in FY02/15 and beyond.
The company plans to increase the sales contribution from overseas operations from 17% in FY02/12 to
24% in FY02/15 for sales (from 8% to 25% [before eliminations] for recurring profit), by growing
earnings there. In addition, the plan calls for sales of 35.0 billion yen and recurring profit of 2.8 billion yen
by the end of FY02/15 from new businesses and acquisitions. The goodwill charges during the plan’s
period are assumed in the region of 4.0 billion yen per year.
The strategy to achieve these goals is as follows. (See also the Strategy section of this report).
Onward Kashiyama
 Shift personnel from existing businesses to new businesses, allowing for lower cost expansion and
more efficient existing cost structure. As the Japanese companies are generally reluctant to lay off
people, this would serve as a soft restructuring.
 Develop channels other than the traditional department store channel and build a customer-oriented
retail business. In the department store channel Onward depends on the department stores for
point-of-sale information, substantially reducing its ability to respond to quickly shifting customer
needs. “Stepping out” of this problem should allow incorporating consumer feedback and developing
new dynamic brands, growing a true retail business.
 Step up the brand-focused management—accelerate the shift to larger brands (as opposed to a
dispersed portfolio of many dozens of small “brandlets”), develop new brands, liquidate brands with
little growth potential.
Europe
 Seek to create an intermediate holding company, Onward Luxury Group, centered around GIBO’Co.
This would be a catch-all apparel maker, manufacturing and selling European-style high-quality goods.
Integrate the headquarters functions of GIBO’Co, JOSEPH, and Jil Sander and enhance GIBO’Co’s role
as the group’s manufacturing platform. At the same time, expand wholesale sales through new license
acquisitions and develop retail operations through new businesses.
 Focus investment in Jil Sander to boost the brand’s growth. Perfect the Collection line—which bears the
name of the brand’s founder, Jil Sander—and develop the Jil Sander Navy line into a standalone brand.
Open flagship stores to expand both retail and wholesale sales.
 Pursue more aggressive worldwide expansion at JOSEPH through new retail shop openings in Europe
and North America and channel growth (wholesale and franchise network) in Europe, Russia, the
Middle East, and Asia.
North America
 From 2013, the company plans to develop its new J.PRESS USA line for both wholesale and retail
operations.
 ICB has established an operations (planning) base for its Collection line in NY. In addition to opening
specialty stores in department stores all over the U.S., particularly in Barney’s, it is also planning to
open NY road-side stores.
8/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Asia
 In manufacturing, establish a profitable production system, continuously working to develop in-house
manufacturing and development capabilities, and lowering manufacturing costs, with an eye to
expanding production in the ASEAN region.
 In sales, increase the size of existing stores and thus grow sales per store. At the same time,
aggressively expand both geographically and by developing new brands.
 Make new businesses such as wholesale and e-commerce into material earnings contributors.
In summary, SR Inc. understands that the strategies consists of two main components—grow new
channels while maintaining the core domestic department store channel and grow overseas.
Domestically, Onward wants to redeploy its personnel where its growth focus is—in “new distribution” and
specialty store channels outside of department stores. The company is aware that it has not been terribly
successful growing new brands outside its core department store apparel competence. It is therefore both
serious about reassessing and reinforcing its existing business practices and keen to acquire companies
that own brands with the established track record in shopping center and similar non department store
channels.
Overseas, the focus is on Europe and Asia. In Europe, the company wants, in a way, to build an upscale
version of Onward Kashiyama—a successful integrated up-market apparel manufacturer/retailer. In Asia,
it aims to primarily market its European and Japanese brands. Expanding manufacturing capability is
another important component. In China, the company’s subsidiaries manufacture and sell apparel; the
retail network counted over 250 stores at the end of FY02/12. Also, a locally designed brand is sold
wholesale through distributors. In the near future the plan is to start selling European brands such as Jil
Sander Navy.
The company has commented that it is aware that achieving its new mid-term plan targets may not look
easy but explained that the numbers were put together after careful deliberations and are seen internally
as realistic.
9/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Business
Business Description
Sales by Type
(million yen)
Men's
YoY
Women's
YoY
Children's
YoY
Other
YoY
Apparel Total
YoY
Total
YoY
FY02/09
Cons.
58,259
-13.9%
143,976
-9.8%
7,150
-7.1%
36,035
4.8%
245,421
-8.9%
261,005
-9.1%
FY02/10
Cons.
53,460
-8.2%
137,707
-4.4%
6,505
-9.0%
36,508
1.3%
234,181
-4.6%
248,634
-4.7%
FY02/11
Cons.
49,478
-7.4%
137,664
0.0%
6,417
-1.4%
36,178
-0.9%
229,738
-1.9%
244,550
-1.6%
FY02/12
Cons.
48,124
-2.7%
137,126
-0.4%
6,369
-0.7%
35,912
-0.7%
227,532
-1.0%
242,402
-0.9%
FY02/13
Cons.
49,631
3.1%
148,950
8.6%
6,691
5.1%
37,402
4.1%
242,675
6.7%
258,369
6.6%
Onward Kashiyama/Sales by Type, Channel
(million yen)
By Apparel Type
Men's
YoY
Women's
YoY
Children's
YoY
Kimonos
YoY
Other
YoY
Total
YoY
By Distribution Channel
Department Stores
YoY
New Distribution Channels
YoY
Specialty Stores
YoY
Chain Stores
YoY
Others
YoY
Total
YoY
FY02/09
FY02/10
FY02/11
FY02/12
FY02/13
44,386
-12.3%
120,749
-7.1%
7,150
-7.1%
2,980
-7.7%
5,566
-7.8%
180,831
-8.5%
38,048
-14.3%
105,041
-13.0%
6,505
-9.0%
2,436
-18.3%
4,800
-13.8%
156,830
-13.3%
36,828
-3.2%
104,590
-0.4%
6,417
-1.4%
2,006
-17.7%
4,475
-6.8%
154,316
-1.6%
36,316
-1.4%
101,490
-3.0%
6,369
-0.7%
1,595
-20.5%
4,215
-5.8%
149,985
-2.8%
36,986
1.8%
106,859
5.3%
6,691
5.1%
1,610
0.9%
4,134
-1.9%
156,280
4.2%
135,031
-9.1%
32,066
-3.6%
5,486
-8.8%
2,084
-19.8%
6,164
-12.6%
180,831
-8.5%
119,663
-11.4%
28,218
-12.0%
4,460
-18.7%
1,247
-40.2%
3,242
-47.4%
156,830
-13.3%
119,051
-0.5%
27,160
-3.7%
4,061
-8.9%
1,073
-14.0%
2,971
-8.4%
154,316
-1.6%
115,579
-2.9%
26,361
-2.9%
4,337
6.8%
772
-28.1%
2,936
-1.2%
149,985
-2.8%
119,376
3.3%
29,564
12.2%
4,247
-2.1%
641
-17.0%
2,452
-16.5%
156,280
4.2%
10/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
The company’s core business is manufacturing and sales of fashion apparel. It derives the bulk (about
83% FY02/13) of revenues from Japan but has a growing worldwide presence. Onward has started
focusing on overseas operations from FY02/10, particularly in Europe but also increasingly in Asia.
Domestically, the main channel is department stores, which comprised 76% of Onward Kashiyama’s
overall sales in FY02/13 (about 46% of the group’s overall sales). Onward Kashiyama sells most of its
fashion brands (menswear and womenswear with smaller lines for kids and fashion accessories) at such
stores. The company defines itself as an apparel manufacturer with strength in high-quality,
high-value-added apparel.
The company reports results across two segments: Apparel and Other. The Apparel segment is the most
important for Onward, generating 91.3% of consolidated sales and over 100% of OP in FY02/13.
The company is organized as a holding structure—Onward Holdings Co., Ltd. (Onward HD) is the
reporting entity that controls about 90 subsidiaries (FY02/13). By far the most important is Onward
Kashiyama Co., Ltd., responsible for apparel sales in Japan. See Group Companies for more.
Main Segments
Apparel (91.3% of sales, 14.5 billion yen operating profit in FY02/13)
Womenswear has historically been the larger contributor to apparel sales (approximately 60.3% of
FY02/12 sales); menswear has typically been less (21.2%).
Kumikyoku
Nijyusanku
11/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Womenswear
Womenswear focuses on upscale brand and fashion clothing. The target market in womenswear is
working women in their 20s and to 40s. The core domestic labels are Nijyusanku, Kumikyoku, ICB, and
Jiyuku (Kashiyama). JOSEPH and Jil Sander are the main international brands. Grace Continental—an
important brand for new distribution, department store, and directly managed store channels—has been
added through the acquisition of Island Co., Ltd. (See Brand Strategy for more.)
Main brands:
 Nijyusanku (est. 1993): Onward Kashiyama’s largest brand. Targeting mainly career women in their
30s, the company calls the brand “Tokyo real clothes,” simple basic lines nuanced by recent fashion
trends. FY02/13 sales were 26.6 billion yen.
 Kumikyoku (est. 1992): Casual lines with elements of today’s style, “standard clothing that does not
stand still” for young working women in their late 20s who prefer luxurious but natural looking apparel.
FY02/13 sales were 10.6 billion yen.
 ICB (est. 1995): Business formal line targeted for career women in their 30s. Offering good balance of
quality, fashion, and price for various scenes of a working woman’s life. FY02/13 sales were 9.0 billion
yen.
 Jiyuku (est. 2000): The brand for women in their late 30s and early 40s. Simple but luxurious clothing
based on concepts of “sophisticated,” “high quality,” and “daily wear.” FY02/13 sales of 9.1 billion yen.
 any FAM (est. 2005): Brand for new distribution channels such as shopping centers. Styling for women
in their 30s with kids. High-quality and easy-to-wear apparel at affordable prices. FY02/13 sales were
8.4 billion yen.
 any SiS (est. 2005): Brand for new distribution channels such as shopping centers. Basic clothing for
working women in their 20s. Basic items incorporating the essence of the recent fashion trends.
“Natural and feminine” casual brand with marine motives incorporating the essence of seasonal
fashion trends. FY02/13 sales were 7.7 billion yen.
 Grace Continental (from 2009): Brand managed by Island. Highly popular among sophisticated,
urbane women. The brand and its sub-brands offer a collection of wide-ranging items not only at new
distribution channels (e.g., inside train station buildings, fashion malls) but also at department stores
and directly managed stores. Island’s FY02/13 sales were 8.5 billion yen.
Menswear
Onward entered the apparel business by producing men’s suits and coats in 1950s. The company’s main
products are suits, coats, and jackets, targeted mainly toward businessmen above 30.
Main brands:
 Gotairiku (est. 1992): Clothing for urban businesspeople blending “cosmopolitan” and “relevant” under
the concept of “apparel from Tokyo for the world.” FY02/13 sales were 4.4 billion yen.
 J.PRESS (from 1974): Targeting traditionally minded conservative 30-40-year olds. “Evolving tradition”
of New York’s Madison Avenue. FY02/13 sales were 9.2 billion yen.
Overseas brands
The company owns the brand businesses of JOSEPH and Jil Sander after acquiring JOSEPH Group in 2005
and Jil Sander Group in 2008. These brands form the core of the global strategy push of the company.
 JOSEPH (from 2005): High quality and easy-to-wear casual clothing based on the concept of “sleek &
chic” targeting sophisticated urban men and women. Global brand with stores in major cities of the
world starting with London. FY02/13 sales were 8.8 billion yen.
 Jil Sander (from 2008): Luxury brand born in Germany in 1973, known worldwide for its simple and
minimalistic but at the same time sharp tailoring and high level of sewing technology. On February 28,
2012, it was announced that the brand founder, Jil Sander, had returned as a creative director from the
12/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
2013 Spring & Summer collection, responsible for the entire range of Jil Sander products, from the
Collection line and menswear to Navy. FY02/13 sales were 10.4 billion yen.
JIL SANDER NAVY Aoyama store
Other (6.1% of sales, 332 million yen operating profit in FY02/13)
Includes logistics business, sports facilities, and resort operations; negligible impact on the company’s
performance.
Business Model
The company’s business model (manufacture and sale of apparel) is executed differently in Japan vs.
internationally.
Domestically, Onward develops/designs apparel (for any of its multiple brands), manufactures at partner
factories or through trading companies, and sells it (primarily in department stores). In case of
department store sales, although the company bears risk from conception to final sale, the retail
transaction is recorded as a sale by the department store; Onward books only a wholesale price. Any
returns or unsold inventory are the company’s responsibility, and it makes final decisions about
merchandise price (full or discounted). The department store mark-up is a predetermined percentage of
the price as discussed in more detail below.
Internationally (predominantly in Europe), the company owns two core brands, JOSEPH and Jil Sander,
and sells to department stores and other merchants, as well as in directly managed stores. A part of
manufacturing is handled by GIBO’Co., an Italian manufacturing subsidiary.
Domestic Business
While Onward defines itself as an apparel manufacturer, it bears most characteristics of an SPA retailer
(Specialty Store Retailer of Private Label Apparel). The company has multiple brands and directs
manufacturing (done by partner factories or trading companies) of apparel and accessories under those
13/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
brands, rather than using its own factories. The key difference between Onward and other SPA
retailers—such as Fast Retailing (UNIQLO) (TSE1: 9983), Inditex (ZARA), and Hennes & Mauritz
(H&M)—is that in the majority of cases, Onward doesn’t own directly managed stores. Instead the stores
belong to department stores.
While in the past the company was a manufacturer (wholesaling to department stores), during the ’90s
and 2000s it transitioned into a retailer by all measures but technical details of who books sales and who
owns stores.
When selling through the department stores, the company owns most fixtures, displays, and the
inventory at stores. It also supplies sales staff. The store space itself is owned by a department store and
items sold are booked as department store sales (going through its POS and accounting systems; Onward
manages sales and inventory using its own store information system in parallel). Technically, Onward
recognizes these as wholesale sales. The reality is that Onward acts as a retailer, taking inventory and
other operational risks. Department stores provide store space, and as such are little different from
landlords. The wholesale price is determined using a ratio called “buritsu.” “Buritsu” is a department
store’s gross profit margin and is essentially a variable rent calculated as a percentage of sales. The ratios
are determined in negotiations and differ by the product category, brand, and company involved. A typical
“buritsu” rate for apparel is in the 30%-40% range.
A note on the terminology employed in the apparel manufacturer vs. Japanese department store
relationship. The Japanese term for the main transaction method is “shouka” (“purchase-as-sold”),
generally translated as “consignment sales.” Confusion can arise from the second method employed in the
relationship, “itaku hanbai,” also translated as “consignment sales.” Despite common translation, the
two methods have different accounting treatments. The former (“purchase-as-sold”) presumes that the
title is not transferred to a department store until actual sale, i.e. never booked as department store
inventory; the latter (“consignment sales”) implies the goods become department store inventory
(returnable to the manufacturer if unsold).
The outright purchase method popular in the U.S. (department stores purchase inventory and assume
inventory risk) also exists in Japan, and is called “kaitori” (“outright purchase”). This method is
uncommon in Japan and represents a negligible part of Onward’s department store business.
Currently over 90% of all sales made by Onward are “purchase-as-sold” type. That means that the
company is effectively acting as an SPA retailer in terms of inventory risk, even when selling at the
department stores.
In other channels the model is different. In shopping centers and similar facilities, a retailer (and Onward
would act as a retailer selling there) pays a fixed minimal rent and a percentage of sales on top of it for
sales exceeding a predetermined minimum. SR Inc. understands that, in practice, the fixed rent portion
dominates, with the overall rental payments typically being about 10% relative to the sales volume. In
case of standalone stores, the company would typically pay a fixed rent.
Product Development Process and Cycle at Onward Kashiyama
The process of product development is run by two main groups—sales (internal buyer) teams and
planning (brand) teams. Production is driven by decisions of people who put product in stores—internal
buyers (called “sales staff” by the company, they belong to one of eight domestic sales offices (branches)
and internally source apparel for stores; customers are the end buyers of apparel). Their decisions are
driven by performance and feedback from shops.
The company is seeking to reorganize its corporate restructure by introducing a branch office system.
Each branch, which previously served as an outpost of Onward Kashiyama, will be integrated into the
14/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
group for its branding strategy. The traditional sales office (branch office) structure is optimal when
servicing department stores where securing the sales floor space is more easily done on a company
(Onward Kashiyama) rather than a brand level. For sales in other channels however it is better to manage
by brand on a nationwide level.
In general, there are four main fashion seasons. For each of them, planning teams develop collection
samples which are presented at internal exhibitions. An example of such an exhibition (typically twice a
year) is an Autumn-Winter one, normally held in May. Among the samples shown at the exhibition, the
patterns are selected and altered based on the opinions of internal buyers and clients. Then, items
selected as a result of this process are ordered by the internal buyers and produced in initial quantities.
Additional orders are made based on smaller interim exhibitions mid-season (4-6 per year) and viewings.
Planning teams are responsible for making sure that items that are more likely to be reordered can be
manufactured. That means securing materials early and keeping them in stock.
In terms of the additional production response, 30 days turnaround is the shortest possible cycle. If fabric
and accessory parts are available, the order is dispatched to a domestic or overseas factory (in China and
in the future likely in ASEAN countries) and a ready garment is shipped (mostly by sea). If fabric needs to
be bought or patterns altered, this adds at least another 1-2 weeks to production.
The company sources fabric and accessory parts (including lining and interlining materials) in advance,
which are kept at factories or warehouses of firms that actually “assemble” the apparel. It doesn’t own or
operate production facilities but rather provides guidance to its subcontractors.
Each collection or merchandising mix for a particular period consists of both items that would not be
reordered when sold and items that are likely to be reordered. Normally around 20%-30% of the
collection is designed with reorders and continuous production in mind. Those items (examples may
include light casual tops, shirts, casual jackets, etc.) are generally responsible for about 70% of total sales.
At the same time, one-off items create the collection’s unique signature and add zest that increases the
fashion statement of the brand. In a nutshell, the customer will most likely buy a pair of gray pants but
she will remember that bold coat design in purple and associate her purchase at least partly with that
design.
How much to allocate to each individual store is a complex decision based on a number of factors. As a
manufacturer, the company has to guess which styles will sell. The management decides on how
aggressive it wants to be in terms of the amount of inventory and the number of new items, based on
current status of sales and achievement vs. forecasts as well as current economic conditions and future
market outlook.
When selling at the department stores, discounting is done at the end of each season, during seasonal
sales. The characteristic feature of Japanese department store’s seasonal sales is that discounting tends
to be lower and start earlier than in the U.S. or Europe.
However, since FY02/13, the company has delayed its summer sales season and adopted a stance of
providing appropriate products at reasonable prices at the right time. Despite a decline in sales during the
seasonal sales period, sales of full priced items have increased, gross profit margin have improved, and
the company has been successful in achieving its earnings targets.
While discounts of 50%-70% are common during European bargain sales, in Japan 30%-50% are more
prevalent. In a way, the Japanese model provides a relatively shorter window for early season full-price
customers, instead offering items at 30% lower prices in the middle of the season and selling items at
higher markdown levels early on without having to discount further at the end of each season. The net
result is a somewhat smoother distribution of seasonal performance. In the recent years, the seasonal
15/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
sales at the department stores have been affected by the changing patterns and growing influence of
other channels and business models. Examples include the timing of seasonal bargain sales at the
retailers selling apparel at railway station complexes and “fashion buildings” (an urban shopping center
inside a multi-story building), weekend sales campaigns, and limited time sales at the “fast fashion”
retailers.
Onward is a conservative company in SR Inc.’s view, and its business seems experience-driven rather than
systems-driven. This conservatism allowed the company to stay profitable despite struggling sales and its
relative performance vis-à-vis peers has been respectable (see Competition). One problem however, was
that relatively stable gross profit margins were set against declining sales in the department store channel.
At the same time, the company found it hard to cut SG&A costs sufficiently, leading to OPM deterioration.
The new strategy highlighted in the new FY02/13-FY02/15 mid-term plan is to make existing businesses
more efficient and allocate more sales personnel to new operations to improve overall profitability.
Store Staffing and Sales Practices
The company’s hiring trends have been changing—new hires have been mostly on more flexible
term-based contracts, as well as part-time employees. It generally means benefits similar to permanent
employees but makes termination easier. The issues, however, have been that as a result of this shift
fewer young staff fill senior positions, as promotions are generally reserved for permanent employees.
This may have created a situation where upper middle management is dominated by males in their 50s.
While this means a wealth of experience, it can also mean conservatism and slower decision making.
Senior management is aware of the problem and admits that changes are needed. One way to add “new
blood” is M&A. The “rejuvenation” at the head office may take time however.
Salespeople at company stores are full-time employees (contract sales employees). Staff report sales and
inventory data directly to the headquarters using proprietary store information system. This enables
timely additional orders and manufacturing of popular items.
Store sizes and efficiency vary substantially by store location, channel, and the specific brand strategy.
The merchandise mix is allocated by its sales organization. Individual stores have some freedom in terms
of item placement and display inside the store.
New Distribution Channels
The company sees new channels (“new distribution” in company’s parlance) as the key to domestic
growth. FY02/13 sales in new channels (shopping centers, train station complexes, urban fashion malls,
standalone stores, and E-commerce) were 29.6 billion yen, or about 19% of total domestic sales at
Onward Kashiyama (about 11% of the group’s overall sales). This figure somewhat overstates the real
sales through the channel as the bulk of department store sales are recorded at wholesale prices (i.e.
after deducting department store margin; so called “gedai” price) while in the new channels the sales are
booked at final retail prices (so called “jodai” prices). Nevertheless, new channel sales are large and rising.
Furthermore, while the company does not disclose the profitability of new channels, it seems likely
(particularly for internet sales) that ultimate profitability can be higher than for the core department store
channel.
The shopping center channel has shown mixed performance over the past few years (FY02/08 to
FY02/13). While Onward has brands specifically for this channel, their contribution has been limited, with
three main brands (anyFAM, anySiS, field/dream) contributing less than 20% of total sales (with the same
caveat as mentioned above).
16/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
VIA BUS STOP Daikanyama store
(directly managed)
OPENING CEREMONY LUMINE
SHINJUKU store
An interesting development has been Island Co., Ltd., operating Grace Continental stores in “fashion
buildings,” or urban-type commercial facilities such as Parco or Lumine, as well as in department stores.
In early 2012, the company acquired Birz Group, another small SPA retailer. Birz Group also has direct
manufacturing capabilities in Asia and experience in selling to young consumers, a know-how that
Onward is keen to leverage for the benefit of the entire group. Onward wants to make further acquisitions
and build a brand portfolio that could be expanded both domestically and in the rest of Asia.
Currently, earnings contribution from E-commerce is gradually increasing, and the company is targeting
e-commerce sales of 5 billion yen in its plan for FY02/14 (versus sales of 3.8 billion yen in FY02/13).
Birz Association Ltd. brand Language shop
Overseas Business
Although the company operates in Europe, Asia and the U.S., Europe accounts for the majority of
overseas business (approximately 13% FY02/13 sales). European operations use GIBO’Co (Italian apparel
company Onward acquired in 1990) as manufacturing platform. It has grown in strategic importance for
Onward following acquisitions of JOSEPH Group (2005) and Jil Sander (2008). Onward owns close to
100% of GIBO’Co (management has a small stake).
17/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
JIL SANDER Munich store (directly managed)
The European fashion business is characterized by widespread outsourcing. Design houses rarely have
planning and manufacturing capability—this is provided by GIBO’Co. The company develops samples,
produces and sells the product, in exchange for a license payment to the designer. To further GIBO’Co’s
manufacturing capabilities a number of specialty manufacturing firms were added over time.
 ERIKA s.r.l. in 2004 (luxury knitwear)
 IRIS S.p.A. in 2005 (luxury shoe manufacturer)
 FRASSINETI s.r.l. in 2007 (handmade leather bags)
One of the issues GIBO’Co had over the years is that it was essentially a production and distribution
purveyor for up-and-coming independent apparel labels. Arguably therefore, acquisitions of JOSEPH and
particularly Jil Sander were game changing events and a real start for Onward’s global expansion
ambitions.
GIBO’Co is aiming to increase sales by signing new licensing agreements with companies outside the
group while also working with group companies such as Jil Sander, on their production and wholesale
channels to improve production efficiency (as of FY02/13).
18/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Cost Structure
SG&A Breakdown
(million yen)
Advertising
Provision for Bad Debt
Labor
Accrued Bonuses
Provision for Director Bonuses
Retirement Benefit Expense
Provision for Director Retirement
Rent
Depreciation
Amortization of Goodwill
Other
Total
FY02/09
Cons.
6,183
417
50,640
1,666
133
1,664
318
11,188
5,451
2,400
29,179
109,245
FY02/10
Cons.
5,484
446
49,212
1,271
262
2,822
15
13,606
73,118
3,405
28,178
109,793
FY02/11
Cons.
5,376
0
48,154
1,282
299
2,678
22
13,323
71,134
3,637
27,177
106,896
FY02/12
Cons.
5,127
0
46,391
1,005
267
2,619
23
12,974
4,803
3,664
27,281
104,154
FY02/13
Cons.
6,312
0
49,392
1,070
252
2,316
27
15,925
4,953
3,937
29,112
113,296
The two main cost components for Onward have been costs of goods sold and labor. Onward’s gross profit
margins have typically been stable at approximately 45.8% (FY02/02-FY02/12). One of the key risks for
apparel manufacturers is inventory risk; if products don’t sell as expected, excess inventory must be
either sold or written off. Onward utilizes the approach whereas the inventory unsold by the end of a
season is marked down by 70%. The company commented that their policy is to aggressively liquidate
unsold inventory at special sales and similar events to avoid having to incur inventory disposal losses.
Inventory losses reported in cost of goods sold for FY02/10 and FY02/11 were negligible.
Historically, the SG&A-to-sales ratio has been about 38.2% (FY02/02-FY02/12). In terms of cost
budgeting, the company allocates as much cost as they feel is necessary to achieve sales targets under
certain profitability constraints. Labor is a constant that the company chose to work with; no
restructuring-like labor cuts were ever performed. Advertising is treated as semi-fixed expense, typically
about 2.0 billion yen is spent each year with cuts performed in difficult environments like the financial
crisis of 2008-2009.
19/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Profitability Snapshot, Financial Ratios
Profit Margins
FY02/09 FY02/10 FY02/11 FY02/12
(Million Yen)
Cons.
Cons.
Cons.
Cons.
Gross Profit
118,329
114,176
115,825
115,113
Gross Profit Margin
45.3%
45.9%
47.4%
47.5%
Operating Profit
9,084
4,383
8,928
10,953
OP Margin
3.5%
1.8%
3.7%
4.5%
EBITDA
17,470
13,532
18,207
20,095
EBITDA Margin
6.7%
5.4%
7.4%
8.3%
Financial Ratios
ROA
-10.2%
0.7%
0.9%
1.3%
ROE
-17.4%
1.4%
1.7%
2.2%
Total Asset Turnover
86.2%
84.4%
85.2%
86.8%
Inventory Turnover
426.0%
416.0%
420.3%
411.9%
Days of Inventory
85.7
87.8
87
89
Working Capital Requirement
20,396
19,800
23,052
23,461
Current Ratio
107.1%
110.7%
115.6%
117.6%
Quick Ratio
54.0%
66.1%
72.2%
73.6%
OCF / Current Liabilities
11.7%
15.3%
12.9%
15.8%
Net Debt / Equity
22.1%
16.4%
14.2%
10.4%
OCF / Total Liabilities
8.7%
10.3%
9.1%
11.0%
Cash Cycle (days)
19.2
22.7
28
32
Changes in Working Capital
1,081
-596
3,252
409
Source: Company data processed by SR Inc.
FY02/13
Cons.
124,490
48.2%
11,192
4.3%
20,850
8.1%
1.6%
2.8%
91.7%
406.2%
90
26,827
99.6%
57.6%
11.0%
14.8%
8.3%
35
3,366
The company’s stable gross profit margins mean that operating profit is thus a function of SG&A spending
(the largest component being labor, see Business Model for more). In comparison to peers, Onward’s
gross profit has been lower than the median (typically several percentage points); however the
company’s OPM has been substantially higher than other firms (see Competition). One possible reason is
that although Onward’s direct costs are higher (the company suggests that it uses high-quality
components which can reduce GPM), management controls over expenses compensate for lower GPM.
The company’s asset base has been relatively productive in terms of turnover (averaging about 86.5%
from FY02/02 through FY02/13). The company’s M&A activity has added notable goodwill to the balance
sheet.
20/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Strengths, Weaknesses
Strengths:
 Strong presence in the department store channel: While the department store market is
shrinking, the channel will continue to be a major source of cash flow and brand exposure. The
expertise acquired in this channel is also likely to contribute to long-term growth in the Asian market.
 Strong financial position: Onward is cash and asset rich.
 Overseas, strong potential in Europe and opportunity to leverage JOSEPH and Jil Sander
throughout Asia: Onward owns internationally recognized brands with substantial growth potential.
It also has a manufacturing base in Europe allowing it to make high-quality merchandise, ranging from
clothing to bags to shoes. Despite past mixed record (with financial crises aggravating the challenges),
this represents a substantial growth opportunity.
Weaknesses:
 Dependence on department store channel: The shrinking main channel and lack of retailing
experience in other channels. Rigid organizational structure optimized for the department stores.
 Dependence on economically sensitive high-end apparel: Deflation hurts.
 Dependence on shrinking Japanese market: The company has been slow in developing a
successful strategy and executing overseas. The new mid-term plan calls for that to change but given
the poor track record investors are likely to be skeptical until the company starts delivering.
Group Companies
About 90 group companies (as of the end of February 2013)
The main subsidiaries are:
 Onward Kashiyama Co. Ltd. (Japan): Core company of the group.
 Onward Trading (Japan): Uniforms and sales promotion goods.
 Chacott (Japan): Dancing wear, costumes and cosmetics.
 Creative Yoko (Japan): Pet fashion, character accessories etc.
 Bus Stop (Japan): Multi-brand store operation.
 Birz Group (Japan): Youth apparel and cost efficient manufacturing in Asia.
 Charles & Keith Japan Co. Ltd.: Manufacturer and sale of shoes and bags
 Project Sloan (UK): Holding company of Joseph group companies.
 Joseph Ltd. (UK): Manufacture and sale of apparel, shoes, and bags.
 GIBO’Co S.P.A. (Italy): Production platform in Europe with following subsidiaries:
IRIS (shoes)
CORPORATE (apparel; Antonio Berardi label)
ERIKA (knitwear)
FRASSINETI (leather bags)
 Violine S.a.r.l. (Luxemburg): Holding company of Jil Sander group companies. Includes 15 subsidiaries.
 Jil Sander Italia S.P.A.: Manufactures and sales of apparel (knit and woven), shoes and bags.
 Island Co., Ltd.: Grace Continental manufacturing and sales operations.
 Candela International Co., Ltd. (Japan): Operation of CROON A SONG select shops.
 Onward Fashion Trading (China) CO., LTD.: Sales of apparel.
 J. PRESS Inc.: Apparel sales in the US.
 Across Transport: logistics and processing of apparel.
 Onward Beach Resort Guam, Inc. (Guam): Hotels and resort facilities.
21/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
 Onward Resort & Golf: Golf club
 Market and Value Chain
Market Overview
Domestic apparel market has been heavily impacted by the declining and aging population. Furthermore,
the economic situation of the past several years has changed apparel shopping patterns—more people
feel it is fine to buy cheap apparel and fewer people can afford expensive one. While the womenswear
market is facing challenges but is still robust, the high-end menswear market shrank dramatically both in
term of volume and spending (down 20.2% from 2008-2012, data according to the Japan Department
Stores Association). For all practical purposes, the market worth analyzing when assessing future growth
domestically is womenswear.
The casual apparel revolution led by Fast Retailing’s UNIQLO brand and furthered by domestic and
overseas “fast fashion” brands has had profound implications for the entire apparel market, including the
high-end market. The consumers came to believe that buying very cheap clothing is not embarrassing. As
for first fashion brands, these brands have super short production and reordering cycle (sometimes only a
week), and low prices at acceptable quality allowed the consumer to follow trends and buy multiple items
without spending much money. In many ways, this contributed to hollowing out of the upscale apparel
and created a substantial challenge for such apparel’s main channel, department stores.
Customers
Although the company’s main customer is department stores, the end customers (who buy apparel) have
most bargaining power in the value chain. Customers can shop easily in different channels (stores, online,
etc.). In this sense, the consumer is clearly the most important. In a way, the biggest problem for Onward
over the past 10-15 years has been its inability to change with the consumer. Indeed, for the company
“consumer” and “customer” were not the same—its customers are to a great extent the department
stores. The company obviously sells to the end consumer. However, it has been constrained by the
demands of its dominant channel and that slowed down the reform.
Suppliers
Onward doesn’t own factories and its key suppliers are overseas factories (90% of manufacturing is done
outside Japan, of which 70%-80% is done in China). The Japanese trading houses play an important role
in the supply chain. They handle parts of the production process, connecting the company with
manufacturing plants and suppliers, and taking on some risks. They generally guarantee prices for
materials and produced items in Japanese yen, i.e. take on the currency fluctuation risks. The main
partners for the company are Mitsubishi Corporation (TSE1: 8058), Mitsui Corporation (TSE1: 8031), and
Sumikin Bussan Corporation (TSE1: 9938). Onward has been also looking to develop its own
manufacturing capabilities and the acquisition of Birz Group (a retailer with direct links to production
factories in Asia) in early 2012 was a small step in that direction.
22/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Competition
Performance vs. Peers
FY2008
FY2009
FY2010
FY2011
FY2012
261,005
133,089
111,817
62,683
342,758
79,665
248,634
114,231
100,333
52,196
314,117
83,504
244,550
112,057
N/A
55,890
305,541
90,571
242,402
104,614
N/A
N/A
329,894
102,052
258,369
107,630
N/A
N/A
336,480
115,041
45.3%
47.2%
50.0%
49.1%
60.9%
51.0%
45.9%
42.7%
51.5%
49.3%
60.4%
51.3%
47.4%
46.8%
N/A
47.7%
59.8%
53.0%
47.5%
47.4%
N/A
N/A
57.8%
54.5%
48.2%
48.1%
N/A
N/A
56.3%
54.4%
50.0%
49.6%
51.3%
50.3%
50.3%
47.7%
54.5%
51.0%
54.4%
51.3%
3.5%
3.6%
0.0%
4.2%
5.2%
5.4%
1.8%
-4.6%
0.9%
0.8%
3.6%
5.9%
3.7%
2.2%
N/A
0.8%
2.9%
8.2%
4.5%
2.0%
N/A
N/A
3.6%
10.0%
4.3%
5.4%
N/A
N/A
2.1%
10.9%
Median ex Onward
Median OP
4.2%
3.9%
0.9%
1.3%
2.6%
2.9%
3.6%
4.0%
5.4%
4.9%
Net Profit Margin
Onward Kashiyama
Sanyo Shokai
Sanei International
Tokyo Style
World
United Arrows
-11.8%
1.7%
-3.3%
-15.0%
1.5%
1.6%
0.9%
-3.6%
-1.4%
1.4%
0.7%
1.7%
1.1%
0.7%
N/A
-18.6%
0.1%
4.0%
1.5%
-1.1%
N/A
N/A
0.8%
4.9%
1.7%
2.0%
N/A
N/A
-0.2%
6.4%
Median ex Onward
Median NP
1.5%
-0.9%
0.7%
0.8%
0.4%
0.7%
0.8%
1.1%
2.0%
1.9%
Sales
Onward Kashiyama
Sanyo Shokai
Sanei International
Tokyo Style
World
United Arrows
Gross Profit Margin
Onward Kashiyama
Sanyo Shokai
Sanei International
Tokyo Style
World
United Arrows
Median ex Onward
Median GP
Operating Profit Margin
Onward Kashiyama
Sanyo Shokai
Sanei International
Tokyo Style
World
United Arrows
Note: Data was not adjusted for differences in the month of fiscal year end.
Note: Sanei was acquired by Tokyo Style and delisted in 2010.
Note: Tokyo Style was delisted after MBO in 2011.
In a larger sense the company competes with any apparel company, but World Co., Ltd. (unlisted) and
Sanyo Shokai Ltd. (TSE1: 8011) are direct competitors that merit mentioning in SR Inc.’s view.
World operates wholesale and retail apparel business both in Japan and overseas. Sanyo Shokai is a large
apparel company selling largely in the department stores, a significant (undisclosed) component of
revenues being Burberry license sales in Japan.
23/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Strategy
The high level strategy stated by the company is to offer highly fashionable, high quality products selling
at prices appropriate to their value. In addition, the company aims to enhance profits by improving the
brand value of its core brands through its basic strategy of "brand-based management." It also aims to
establish a worldwide presence, focusing on its experience with high-end apparel.
In order to achieve its strategic goals, the company also states that it has been shifting the focus towards
a “product-oriented” approach as opposed to a “market-oriented” approach. The difference between the
two is that the “market-oriented” approach is mostly about trying to understand current trends and
respond with an adequate product. The “product-oriented” approach is more about thinking up and
creating a product by taking advantage of an apparel makers strength, offering consumers some unique
value; proactive vs. reactive.
It appears to SR Inc. that despite the common theme, Onward’s domestic and overseas strategies are
markedly different. Therefore, they are discussed separately in this report after a brief discussion about
fashion brand building in general (more pertinent to the domestic business).
Brand Strategy
While some U.S. and European companies have won with multiple brands, this typically was via
acquisitions. Japanese firms tend to have many smaller domestically-oriented brands, developed
in-house.
One explanation for this has been the historic focus on specific channels. To some extent all major
Japanese apparel firms defined their businesses first by sales channel and then by the target consumer.
Onward and some peers mentioned in Competition have historically focused on department stores. The
company calls itself a “general apparel company,” making all sorts of apparel including uniforms and pet
wear. However both investors and consumers probably recognized it as a high-end apparel producer
which sells in department stores.
While seemingly irrelevant to casual observers, SR Inc. believes that the channels dictated business and
brand strategies for many Japanese manufacturers. Furthermore, it is likely that preferences and needs of
core channel clients, especially powerful department stores, promoted independence of individual
operators and proliferation of multiple smaller brands.
Independence here means the remarkable absence of major domestic M&A in the apparel sector. Each
manufacturer, especially those selling in department stores, had brands which were replaceable and of
limited uniqueness. Buying a competitor would not necessarily guarantee an increase in the sales space
allocated by a department store. Developing brands in-house and mastering the relationship with the
channel has been the smartest choice. Onward is one of the smartest if not the smartest when it comes to
department stores. Hence Onward’s more than 70 brands, and deep but historically profitable
dependence on department store sales.
Conveniently, the multi-brand approach also reduces risk. Japanese consumers in particular have
relatively short-lived preferences and the Japanese fashion cycle is notoriously short and volatile; brands
that become too popular too fast often face violent downturns as customers grow weary and flock
elsewhere. This is why large overseas apparel companies (excluding sportswear) are multi-brand
conglomerates (who buy brands, not create them). Therefore, in SR Inc.’s view, it is reasonable to
24/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
conclude that developing multiple brands has been and probably remains the optimal strategy in Japan.
While it doesn’t create household names that carry on through generations, it allows apparel companies
to manage their business in a manner not dissimilar from diversified asset management companies—a
little bit of everything for a stable portfolio.
Some brands have distinct items which not only sell well but also distinguish the brand. Theory and
Onward’s own JOSEPH achieved that in women’s pants. Similarly, mentioning Ralph Lauren invokes
images of polo shirts, and Burberry, checkered pattern scarves and coats. Onward commented that selling
such items is extremely easy and profitable, but finding the right balance between core and new items is
one of the hardest parts of brand management.
Developing such brands requires bold vision and initial risk-taking. It’s possible that Onward’s (and other
large and successful companies) relatively bureaucratic and consensus-based organization doesn’t easily
lend itself to individual risk-taking. It’s therefore hard for Onward to repeat the success of acquired brands
(JOSEPH, Jil Sander) domestically. This is probably why the company seems to prefer developing
overseas brands as a separate group, using its Italian subsidiary GIBO’Co as a manufacturing platform.
This seems the optimal choice for the worldwide expansion (see discussion below).
SR Inc. believes that Onward is a product-oriented company. It’s less about fashion per se, but more
about building a product portfolio uniquely suited to its main department store channel. Rather, the focus
is on generating constant flow of apparel corresponding to individual styles of relatively narrowly defined
brands.
Sales for higher-priced brands, even quite successful ones, typically range between 20-30 billion yen (the
biggest rarely reaching 50 billion yen). They are different from mass-market brands bought by tens of
millions of people. As prices increase so does fashion, i.e. the ability of the brand to respond to the unique
needs of a particular group of customers.
Domestic Strategy
Domestically, the company aims to grow by increasing the profitability of the existing business through
the structural reform (but not a full-blown “restructuring”) while expanding new businesses and acquiring
existing ones. The idea is to continue to see the department store channel as a core one but at the same
time pursue growth through other channels.
(SR Inc. notes that this commitment to department stores could be one reason why the declining sales do
not automatically lead to restructurings across-the-board. Furthermore, the company argues that given
low flexibility of the Japanese labor market and high costs associated with the restructurings (one time
pay-offs), it is not clear whether a drastic cost reduction would produce any long-lived benefits.)
SR Inc. estimates that the department store sales will likely move in-line with the general demographic
trends, the economic cycle and be a function of total sales floor space of major department stores. It
seems reasonable to assume that given strong core brands, Onward’s share in the channel remains stable
or slowly increases. Given continued renovations and floor expansion of the department stores in large
cities, it is conceivable that around FY02/15, Onward’s sales in the channel could again reach the 140-150
billion yen, the level last seen a number of years ago. The retail space of Onward in the department stores
is set to decline in FY02/14 (-1.1% YoY). In the same year, however, the company is looking to grow
domestic sales for two years in a row. Sales may rise 2.1% YoY, signifying that it may have finally returned
to domestic growth.
25/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Further domestic expansion would without doubt involve other distribution channels such as shopping
centers, fashion buildings, multi-brand standalone stores, and the internet. The company sees growth in
these “new distribution” channels as strategically important and expects its sales space there to increase
1.2% YoY in FY02/14 bringing about sales of 33.7 billion yen (13.7% YoY). The plan is to achieve this
growth while controlling costs, in a large part by shifting existing personnel to these growth areas.
The domestic brand strategy is twofold. The main part is to concentrate resources in core brands. At the
same time Onward will seek to add new unconventional looks and styles (either create brands or, more
likely, acquire existing brands). A good example of what the company is trying to do is the acquisition of
Island Co. Ltd in December 2009, with its Grace Continental store brand. Such initiatives outside of the
traditional “comfort zone” are the key to domestic growth. The company is planning to continue growing
Island, make further acquisitions (such as the acquisition of Birz Group in early 2012), and use those
assets as a leverage of expansion both domestically and in new emerging markets.
Overseas Strategy
The overseas strategy in recent years is something that the market has not been giving Onward much
credit for (as of early 2013). The company made two large acquisitions in 2005 and 2008. Unfortunately,
from the moment of acquisition and through FY02/13, both overseas subsidiaries, JOSEPH and Jil Sander,
failed to generate economic returns and were detractors of earnings.
The company may have a right to an excuse or two. First, the timing of the acquisitions was unfortunate
as the financial crisis of 2007-2009 suddenly pushed the luxury apparel business from the fast growth
lane off the road. That should be remembered when assessing earnings of the company’s two high-end
European brands, both of which relied on purely clothing sales over that period. Furthermore, the
currency trends were not necessarily favorable at the consolidated level. Finally, brand businesses are
notoriously hard to turn around.
The European business may finally be turning the corner. While it is way early to draw conclusions, the
crown jewel in the overall strategy is Jil Sander with its new Navy line. Launched in 2011, it was initially
marketed as an extension of the main Jil Sander Collection line. However, the approach backfired, as the
new line was not what the existing Collection customers were expecting and at the same time failed to
attract a sufficient number of new ones (however, the line has received a favorable following in Japan
marketed as an individual brand). The company quickly changed the course and will try to build new line
Jil Sander Navy into a strategically important separate brand. This means a separate marketing, more
retailing opportunities, and a larger market. The brand’s founder, Jil Sander, will step down from her role
as creative director, with the Spring/Summer 2014 collection being her last in the post. The company
states that this will have little effect on its products, as it has been enhancing its company structure for
everyone from chief designers down (including menswear, womenswear, and accessories).
The opportunity for Jil Sander Navy seems significant. First, the original brand, a truly luxury one, had a
somewhat limited market. Navy should have a wider appeal. The company opened the world-first flagship
Jil Sander Navy store in Aoyama, Tokyo, in September 2012. With a full apparel and accessories lineup, it
could go from the established retail markets to new dynamic markets of Russia, Middle East, and Asia.
JOSEPH is more of a wildcard. FY02/13 failed to bring clarity about what needs to be done to restore
profitability and growth. However, conceptually JOSEPH is a highly marketable brand with its clean lines,
broad luxury appeal and item flexibility. The company is looking to focus on expanding the retail presence
in outside of the main UK and Japanese markets into North America, Russia, Germany, and Asia both
through direct stores and franchising relationships.
26/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
GIBO’Co will provide key support on the manufacturing side, particularly for Jil Sander. It will also likely
play a quasi-headquarters role for the Onward group in Europe, helping coordinate the management of
the European operations and set the group-level agenda. SR Inc. is also intrigued by direct forays into
retail by GIBO’Co—selling apparel and accessories on a consignment basis in select European department
stores.
Expansion in Asia offers long-term growth potential for the company. The company’s mid-term plan
through FY02/15 is calling for 21.0 billion yen in Asian sales in FY02/15, a threefold increase compared to
FY02/12 results. This is still only 6% of the total consolidated sales target (with a similar percentage
contribution to earnings). It seems logical however, that Asia should become the second largest revenue
generator for Onward in the long run thanks to its sheer market size and the opportunity for the company
to leverage both its Japanese and European brand assets. Onward will open more new stores, increase
the size of its existing stores, experiment with e-commerce, and expand wholesale sales through
distributors.
While the existing brands are likely to play the key role in Asian expansion, locally developed brands also
hold great potential. The company would leverage its branding and manufacturing capabilities, and the
retail know-how to start purely local brands. Doing this through locally established companies with fewer
visible links to Onward, or acting only as a wholesaler, allows better pricing flexibility (going down market
without hurting the perception of the existing brands). It also lowers the risk of being seen as “Japanese,”
something that may be of value in such sometimes sensitive markets as China, especially dealing with the
mass consumer.
The potential of Asia doesn’t end there. Onward has stated that it would pursue developing independent
production capabilities in China and ASEAN. This means developing direct links with factories in the region,
bypassing such helpers as trading companies. While using the trading houses does bring about large
benefits as discussed elsewhere in the report, they are also increasingly becoming competitors. The
independent manufacturing capability will give Onward better cost controls and more flexibility.
The U.S. contribution will remain minor although things like the re-launch of ICB as a truly international
brand and efforts to grow J.PRESS warrant some attention. Onward plans to further boost its North
American presence by opening new offices and showrooms in the U.S.
27/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Historical Financial Statements
Summary
Earnings Results Discussion for the Year Preceding Current Fiscal Year (For
Reference Purposes)
Q3 FY02/14 Results (announced on January 10, 2014; please refer to the preceding
tables)
In cumulative Q3, sales were 205.4 billion yen (+7.4% YoY), operating profit was 10.1 billion yen (-5.4%),
and recurring profit was 11.9 billion yen (+0.9%). Net income was 5.8 billion yen (+24.2%), pushed up
by extraordinary gains, including a gain on the sale of investment securities (887 million yen).
SR Inc. estimates that cumulative Q3 operating profit was more than 1.0 billion yen short of the
company’s forecast (consolidated basis). Sales of Onward Kashiyama’s products for the fall season
struggled due to unfavorable weather, and some of the domestic subsidiaries came in under expectations.
December monthly sales of Onward Kashiyama were up 5% YoY and there is likely to be a surge in
demand in Q4 to beat the consumption tax hike. However, this is unlikely to make up for the shortfall in
Q3, and there is some downside risk to the full-year FY02/14 forecasts.
28/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Results and forecasts for main subsidiaries
(million yen)
HD+Onward Kashiyama
YoY
% of FY
Onward Trading
YoY
% of FY
Chacott
YoY
% of FY
Creative Yoko
YoY
% of FY
Island
YoY
% of FY
Across Transport
YoY
% of FY
JOSEPH
YoY
% of FY
GIBO'Co
YoY
% of FY
Jil Sander
YoY
% of FY
Cumulative Q3 FY02/14
FY02/14 Forecast
Sales
OP
Sales
OP
119,479
1.5%
73.8%
11,887
2.7%
77.1%
8,356
2.6%
77.3%
4,773
-6.9%
65.5%
6,307
-1.8%
72.5%
8,971
2.4%
77.2%
7,849
30.2%
74.1%
14,830
41.3%
76.8%
9,653
31.7%
73.0%
10,979
12.7%
88.5%
774
-22.4%
69.0%
609
-10.8%
81.3%
75
-72.9%
11.7%
923
-17.4%
61.2%
230
19.8%
111.1%
-354
772
3.9%
73.2%
-1,258
-
162,000
3.7%
15,417
4.7%
10,803
2.5%
7,291
-1.4%
8,696
2.5%
11,613
1.1%
10,593
20.1%
19,303
30.6%
13,217
26.7%
-
12,400
12.2%
1,121
9.3%
749
0.5%
641
-7.9%
1,508
3.0%
207
6.7%
-180
1,055
31.7%
-1,101
-
Domestic: Onward Kashiyama
For Onward Kashiyama (96.1% of forecast FY02/14 operating profit), Q3 (September-November only)
was tough. Unfavorable weather such as typhoons in October and a temporary downturn in consumer
sentiment due to the decision to go ahead with the consumption tax hike dampened sales. In Q3
(September-November) sales change for the core brands (36% of Onward Kashiyama’s total sales) was
-0.5% YoY: Nijyusanku, -1.1%; ICB, -4.6%; and Jiyuku, -2.8%. Kumikyoku grew sales by 5.4% YoY,
thanks to ongoing promotional activities featuring Satomi Ishihara, a popular actress. For Onward
Kashiyama’s core brands, cumulative Q3 sales growth was: Nijyusanku, +2.3% YoY; Kumikyoku, +8.8%;
ICB, +1.3%; and Jiyuku, +4.2%.
In the core menswear brand, Gotairiku, which struggled through 1H, from 2H the company boosted its
high-quality suits, which are differentiated by materials and styling, and target men in their 40s
(second-generation baby boomers). In Q3 (September-November only), Gotairiku’s sales rose 6.0% YoY.
While poor weather hit sales in October, they grew by a robust 15% in the month of December, in line
with forecasts. The company said that the menswear market overall was recovering, with suit sales
especially brisk.
29/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Among core brands sold through new distribution channels (13% of Onward Kashiyama’s total sales), Q3
(September-November only) sales were +0.9% for anyFam (-5.2% YoY), impacted by the poor weather
in October. (anySis grew by 7.7% and field/dream rose by 0.6%.) For cumulative Q3, sales for anyFam
grew by 2.0%, anySis by 9.9%, and field/dream by 0.2%. anyFam recovered to post 6.5% growth in
December. In e-commerce, Onward is likely to exceed its full-year 5.0 billion yen sales target (+30% YoY)
with sales of over 5.3 billion yen, thanks to a growing membership and higher sales per customer. It
appears that the increase in sales per customers is partly due to the active shopping of some frequent
customers.
As a result of the growth of e-commerce and good sales of highly profitable products, Onward
Kashiyama’s gross profit margin in Q3 (September-November), rose from 54.7% the previous year to
55.1%; in cumulative Q3, it rose from 51.6% in the previous corresponding period to 52.0%. Due to poor
sales, the company made efforts to constrain costs by more than called for in the company’s forecasts.
The selling, general and administration expense ratio in Q3 (September-November) was 39.5% (steady
YoY), and for cumulative Q3 it was 42.8% versus 43.3% the previous year. However, it appears that the
decrease in expenses is not enough to cover the slide in sales, and operating profit has fallen somewhat
below the company’s target.
Domestic: other subsidiaries
Onward trading (uniform and sales promotion goods) is still being affected by rising raw material costs
due to yen weakness; profits fell both in Q3 and cumulative Q3. In Q4 it should be able to get back on
track to meet its full-year forecast of 1.1 billion yen, due to a recovery in orders, a review of materials
procurement, and progress on price pass-through.
Profits fell at Chacott (dancewear) as existing-store sales slumped due to poor weather, and the brand
also incurred personnel and marketing costs associated with the launch of the innerwear business.
However, the company expected these increases in costs, and had already incorporated them into its plan.
Thus, at the end of Q3, this brand looked, for the most part, to be progressing according to plan.
Creative Yoko (pet clothing and character goods) suffered from poor weather and sales opportunity loss
caused by the late delivery of some products manufactured in China. It seems that the business will have
difficulty meeting FY02/14 forecasts. The shipping from China took longer than usual to clear customs
due to stricter inspections of exports to Japan. To attract customers, the company planned to open large
stores covering 100 tsubo (330m2) in urban areas in FY02/15.
At Island (production and sales of the Grace Continental brand, which targets women in their 20s and
30s), sales and profits fell YoY, due to poor weather and because the popularity of the brand is starting to
wane a little. From FY02/15, the company plans to boost customer appeal by introducing new concept
stores, such as a store focusing on fashion accessories (jewelries).
Birz, the new subsidiary, requires some time to improve delivery and quality controls at its own factories in
Asia. Sales therefore struggled as the result of late deliveries and uncompetitive products. Due to costs
associated with laying the foundations for improvement, it appears the business will post operating losses
of around 5.0 billion yen in FY02/14. The company is reviewing the product value and price setting, and
plans to improve the spring and summer 2014 collection. In addition, the company plans to scrap
unprofitable stores to reduce operating losses to a few hundred million yen in FY02/15, and lay the
groundwork for a move into the black.
30/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Overseas
GIBO’Co posted a rise in profit as it booked sales of new bags and shoes brands and completed the
necessary investments to improve its production capability—such as expanding factories and hiring more
workers. In FY02/15, as the cost of the new brand’s samples falls, a further improvement in profits is in
prospect.
At Jil Sander, Q3 cumulative operating losses expanded to around 1.3 billion yen (from around 1.1 billion
yen in cumulative Q2). Despite upfront investment in restructuring the business, sales at Jil Sander
Navy—a key sales driver—were not growing as much as expected. In addition, the impact of forex
fluctuation widened the profit loss. Ms. Jil Sander will step down as creative director after showing the
2014 Spring/Summer collection. According to Onward, the design team of Jil Sander has been improved
(in menswear, womenswear, and accessories) and the departure of the creative director should not cause
a problem with regard to product creation. Also, the company will see a reduction in costs related to the
designer herself of several hundred million yen in FY02/15, followed by further reduction of a similar scale
in FY02/16.
In JOSEPH, following on from the first half, sales grew, driven by improvements in its “essential products”
line-up. The company indicated that recurring profit would likely return to the black as expected in
FY02/14. The company planned to focus on growing sales per store in FY02/15 rather than expanding the
number of the store, and as a result boost profits by around 150 million to 200 million yen.
In North America, the company was incurring upfront costs—increased personnel numbers of ICB
business and the renovation of J.Press flag ship store. It seems that operating losses will be around
400-500 million yen from this year to FY02/16.
1H FY02/14 Results (announced on October 4, 2013; please refer to the preceding
tables)
In 1H FY02/14, sales were 132.3 billion yen (+9.5% YoY) and operating profit was 3.3 billion yen (+5.5%
YoY). Recurring profit was 4.8 billion yen (+28.2% YoY), reflecting an improvement in non-operating
income and expenses (the company booked a foreign exchange loss of 505 million yen in 1H FY02/13).
Net income for 1H FY02/14 was 1.7 billion yen (+216.0% YoY), which included extraordinary gains, such
as an 887 million yen gain on the sale of investments in securities.
Results exceeded the company’s plan (consolidated basis) by the following percentages: sales 4.2%,
operating profit 4.1%, recurring profit 25.6%, and net income 175.2%. Although results at some
domestic subsidiaries fell short of plan, core domestic brands were the main performance driver. In
overseas operations, despite a slow recovery in sales in Asia, results were largely in line with plan in
Europe.
Based on performance in 1H and foreign exchange trends, the company reviewed its pricing policy for 2H.
As a result, it raised the full-year sales forecast from 273.0 billion yen to 277.0 billion yen. Profit forecasts
were unchanged.
31/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Results and forecasts for main subsidiaries
（ million yen）
HD+Onward Kashiyama
YoY
Onward Trading
YoY
Chacott
YoY
Creative Yoko
YoY
Island
YoY
Across Transport
YoY
JOSEPH
YoY
GIBO'Co
YoY
Jil Sander
YoY
１H FY02/14
2HFY02/14 Forecast
Sales
OP
Sales
OP
75,492
4,128
86,508
8,272
3.1%
38.3%
4.1%
2.6%
8,248
659
7,169
462
5.8%
-2.8%
3.5%
32.8%
5,546
479
5,257
270
2.6%
8.4%
2.4%
-10.9%
3,046
30
4,245
611
-9.3%
-79.9%
5.3%
11.7%
4,026
608
4,670
900
-0.9%
-7.3%
5.7%
11.4%
5,781
101
5,832
106
2.4%
13.5%
0.0%
1.0%
5,188
-315
5,405
135
36.2%
7.9%
9,189
206
10,114
849
40.7%
-33.8%
22.7%
73.3%
6,195
-1,098
7,022
-3
40.5%
16.5%
-
Domestic: Onward Kashiyama
At Onward Kashiyama, which accounts for 74% of the company’s domestic business (based on operating
profit, including Onward Holdings), sales of the four core brands (Nijyusanku, ICB, Jiyuku and Kumikyoku),
together with other main brands sold through department stores, surpassed the forecast.
Specifically, consumer sentiment improved on the back of economic recovery, and the company
implemented measures to enhance differentiation, such as strengthened product planning and
merchandising. Sales increased YoY by the following percentages: Nijyusanku 4.5%, ICB 4.1%, Jiyuku
8.7%, and Kumikyoku 10.9%. The strong performance by Kumikyoku was underpinned by an aggressive
TV advertising campaign. Based on 1H performance, the company raised its full-year sales forecasts.
Kumikyoku sales are expected to grow 7% YoY (5% under the initial plan), while Jiyuku sales are forecast
to increase 6% YoY (4% under the initial plan).
Although core men’s brand Gotairiku recorded a 5.1% decline in sales YoY in 1H, the company plans to
target customers in their 40s (second-generation baby boomers) in 2H, centering on the sale of
high-quality suits (materials and styling). To minimize opportunity-loss, the plan calls for a full lineup of
products in terms of both price points and volumes. The company will work to revitalize the men’s apparel
business by through an aggressive advertising strategy and by appointing the director of CK Calvin Klein
operations to concurrently oversee Gotairiku. The company forecasts 2H sales to increase 16% YoY.
Regarding strategy for department store brands in FY02/15 and beyond, the company plans to focus
resources on core brands while reviewing unprofitable stores and brands. The company says it will aim to
maintain YoY sales growth at around 5% for core women’s brands, and is targeting 30% YoY sales growth
in FY02/15 for Gotairiku.
Regarding performance in new channels (non-department store) in 1H, sales at core brand anyFAM were
32/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
up 5.9% YoY, anySiS was up 11.1% YoY and field/dream was unchanged YoY. From FY02/15, the
company plans to use advertising to drive further sales growth. By building a solid sales track record and
enhancing its relationship with retail developers, the company aims to cultivate advantages for future
store openings. In e-commerce channels, the company achieved an increase in site membership and
expanded the number of brands on offer. As a result, 1H sales were up approximately 50% YoY, to 2.4
billion yen. Progress toward the company’s full-year sales target of 5.0 billion yen (+30% YoY) was ahead
of forecast. The company says it is aiming for e-commerce sales of around 7.0 billion yen in FY02/15, and
10.0 billion yen in FY02/16.
Gross profit margin in 1H at Onward Kashiyama was 50.2% (1H FY02/13: 49.7%), driven by robust
performances by high-margin core brands and e-commerce. From FY02/13, the company has focused on
improving sales of full-price items by delaying the start of seasonal bargain sales. In Q2, the company
sold summer items at full prices up to early-July, which resulted in higher sales of full-price items,
centering on core brands. Hence, the strategy appears to have succeeded largely as planned. The
SG&A-to-sales ratio improved to 44.7% (1H FY02/13: 45.7%) through a continuing tight rein on expenses.
This contributed to double-digit growth in operating profit, surpassing the company’s forecast.
Domestic: Other Subsidiaries
Operating profit at other domestic subsidiaries was down approximately 500 million yen YoY, falling
several hundred million yen short of forecast. At main subsidiaries, centered on Onward Trading, the rapid
depreciation of the yen had a negative impact on gross profit, as measures to overhaul the production
structure as well as responses in price negotiations were unable to make up for forex impact. In addition,
a lag in recovery at new subsidiaries contributed to the decrease in operating profit. The company
anticipates an improvement in earnings in 2H at Onward Trading and other subsidiaries based on an
overhaul of materials procurement and measures to pass on cost increases in product pricing.
Although orders—including those from new clients—are on a recovery trend at Onward Trading, as
previously mentioned, results were affected by the weakening of the yen.
Chacott grew sales at standalone stores, achieving higher sales and operating profit. However, the
company expects profit to decrease in 2H due to labor and marketing expenses related to a new business.
At Creative Yoko, which sells pet fashion and character goods, comparable store sales declined, reflecting
the impact of severe midsummer heat and intensified competition.
Island increased its store count and aggressively rolled out high-end products to build the brand. However,
in 1H these measures only made a limited contribution to earnings.
Overseas
According to the company, in 1H although sales recovery lagged in Asia, in the overseas business’ core
European operations, GIBO’Co and Jil Sander achieved progress in line with plan and JOSEPH was on a
recovery path. Yen depreciation led to a fall of approximately 300 million yen in operating income.
GIBO’Co grew OEM and wholesale sales, however, due to such factors as sample-production costs for a
new brand of OEM shoes, there was an overall increase in sales but decrease in operating income.
According to the company, in 2H sample costs are expected to decline and shipments of autumn/winter
items and 2014 spring shoes are forecast to increase. Based on such factors, the company forecasts
operating profit to rise 73.3% YoY.
33/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
At Jil Sander, operating loss increased by approximately 1.1 billion yen due to upfront expenses relating to
rebuilding of the business and the impact of foreign exchange. However, results were largely in line with
the company’s initial plan, which anticipated a deterioration of approximately 400 million yen YoY in 1H
earnings. To increase sales especially for Jil Sander Navy, the company plans to open more standalone
stores and stores within retail complexes, and will also work to expand wholesale sales. There have been
several media reports (as of November 2013) suggesting that Ms. Jil Sander will resign from her position
as creative director following the showing of the Spring/Summer 2014 collection. According to the
company, an organizational structure is being put in place that will facilitate a smooth shift in the role of
Ms. Jil Sander, and there is no other official comment on the matter. SR Inc. does not expect these
developments to have a large impact.
At JOSEPH, in recent years unsuccessful product design and merchandising have seen an ongoing decline
in sales of the Essential Line. The company is working to remedy this situation through merchandising
aimed at returning the brand to its roots. This resulted in an increase in sales YoY in 1H as Essential Line
sales improved. Operating loss was reduced YoY, from 498 million yen in 1H FY02/13 to 315 million yen in
1H FY02/14. This reflected a decrease in depreciation expenses relating to new store openings and store
refurbishments as well as progress in sales of items from previous years (inventory write-downs were
booked in FY02/13).
In North American operations, although performance of the apparel business fell short of plan, the resort
business performed strongly. While operating loss came in at 169 million yen (versus operating profit of 0
million yen in 1H FY02/13), North American operations as a whole were slightly ahead of forecast.
Q1 FY02/14 Results (announced on July 5, 2013; please refer to the preceding
tables)
In Q1 FY02/14, sales were 72.2 billion yen (+6.8% YoY) and operating profit was 6.4 billion yen (+2.8%
YoY). Recurring profit was 7.2 billion yen (+19.2% YoY), reflecting an improvement in non-operating
income and expenses (the company booked a foreign exchange gain of 302 million yen compared with a
foreign exchange loss of 443 million yen in Q1 FY02/13). During Q1, Onward booked extraordinary gains,
including an 887 million yen gain on the sale of investments in securities, which contributed to net income
of 3.8 billion yen (+36.5% YoY).
According to the company, Q1 performance highlights were as follows.
Consolidated operating profit was up 174 million yen YoY. Operating profit YoY on an individual subsidiary
basis was down 204 million yen at GIBO’Co, Jil Sander was down 206 million yen and down 90 million yen
in Asia. In contrast, YoY operating profit at Onward Holdings and Onward Kashiyama rose by 787 million
yen and at JOSEPH improved 152 million yen, thereby underpinning the consolidated operating profit
increase.
At the subsidiary level:
 Onward Holdings and Onward Kashiyama
 Onward Trading
 Chacott
34/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
 Creative Yoko
Sales of 1.6 billion yen (down 9.1% YoY); operating profit of 54 million yen (down50.5% YoY)
 Island
 Across Transport
 JOSEPH
Sales of 2.7 billion yen (up 16.8% YoY); operating loss of 148 million yen (vs. an operating loss of 300
million yen in Q1 FY02/13)
 GIBO’Co
 Jil Sander
Sales of 3.4 billion yen (up 15.0% YoY); operating loss of 155 million yen (vs. an operating profit of 51
million yen in Q1 FY02/13)
 Asia
Sales of 1.9 billion yen (up 14.6% YoY); operating loss of 164 million yen (down 35.4%)
Domestic
Centering on Onward Kashiyama, the Company implemented measures to boost product appeal and
enhance store management capabilities. As a result, core brands and other main brands achieved sales
surpassing the company’s forecasts. In addition, the company pursued structural reforms and improved
cost efficiency through efforts to enhance productivity. With regard to YoY sales performance at Onward
Kashiyama’s core brands, Nijyusanku was +4.2%, Kumikyoku was +11.6%, ICB was +5.3% and Jiyuku
was +8.5%.
Results at other subsidiaries were largely in line with company forecasts.
Overseas
Although sales recovery is lagging in the Asia region, sales grew at the European operations—the core of
the overseas business—and the company’s efforts to improve business management were progressing
according to plan.
FY02/13 Results (announced on April 5, 2013)
For the full year, sales were 258.4 billion yen (+6.6% YoY), operating profit was 11.2 billion yen (+2.2%
YoY), and recurring profit was 13.4 billion yen (+0.6% YoY). For the period, Onward booked 7.6 billion
yen extraordinary losses (3.4 billion yen in FY02/12) due to 6.9 billion yen impairment losses including 6.7
billion yen goodwill impairment at subsidiary Project Sloane Limited and fixed asset impairment losses.
However, higher deferred income tax YoY reduced income tax charges, resulting in net income of 4.5
billion yen (+27.6% YoY).
Sales, operating profit, and recurring profit fell short of company forecasts by 3.1%, 18.9%, and 13.0%.
Domestic businesses posted an earnings increase YoY even though they failed to meet target. The
35/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
company’s overseas operations, on the other hand, had a significant earnings decline YoY and missed
target by a wide margin, presenting an issue that will linger through FY02/14 and beyond.
According to the company, full-year performance highlights were as follows.
Consolidated operating profit was down by 239 million yen YoY and breaking this down at the subsidiary
level:
 Operating profit at JOSEPH dropped by 787 million yen YoY; by 498 million yen at GIBO’Co; by 264
million yen at Jil Sander; and by 480 million yen in Asia.
 Operating profit at Onward Holdings and Onward Kashiyama rose by 1.5 billion yen; and by 316
million yen at Onward Trading.
 Onward Trading
 Chacott
 Creative Yoko
 Island
Sales of 8.5 billion yen (up 3.6% YoY); operating profit of 1.5 billion yen (down 5.1% YoY)
 JOSEPH
 GIBO’Co
 Jil Sander
 Asia
Domestic
Onward Kashiyama undershot its full-year sales estimate. The company struggled in Q3 because of
lingering summer heat. Although sales began to pick up toward the end of FY02/13, the recovery was not
strong enough to enable the company to achieve its sales target. However, sales of high-margin core
brands and those through new distribution channels (e.g., e-commerce) were robust. The gross profit
margin consequently increased to 50.6%, up 1.4 percentage points from FY02/12, and the company’s
domestic profitability improved largely as planned due to sales-linked cost controls. Operating profit was
in line with forecast after the company reduced its operating expenses by 1.6 billion yen from an initial
plan.
Sales in FY02/13 at core brands were as follows: +7.8% YoY for Nijyusanku; +5.0% for Kumikyoku;
+0.8% for ICB; and +6.7% for Jiyuku. Among the new distribution channels, sales at anyFAM rose 9.7%
YoY, anySiS rose 9.3% YoY, and field/deram rose 12.8% YoY. The company’s e-business generated sales
of 3.8 billion yen (+69.4% YoY), exceeding its target. The six main brands (JOSEPH, Paul Smith, TOCCA,
36/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
BEIGE, field/dream, and OPENING CEREMONY), which operated a “retail brand business system,” may
have had a double-digit sales increase. (The retail brand business system, unlike the previous
branch-based system, integrates the management of planning, production, marketing, and sales on a per
brand basis.)
Operating profit rose 1.2 billion yen and 100 million yen during Q1 and Q2 of FY02/13, respectively.
Operating profit fell 1.2 billion yen in Q3 and rose 1.5 billion yen in Q4.
In Q1, sales of core-brand products, including spring costs and Cool Biz items, were brisk. The company
benefitted from an increase in sales of full-price items. During Q2, sales of full-price summer items
expanded significantly, raising the company’s gross profit margin more than expected. However, inventory
valuation losses increased after discount sales fell. Sales of autumn items were also sluggish because of
lingering summer heat in August.
In Q3, sales of autumn products were slow to take off. The start of a “family sale” event was delayed until
December (For FY02/12, the event took place in November). The company also made investments in
sales floors and increased advertising expenses. However, gross profit margin improved significantly in Q4
thanks to strong sales of full-price cold-weather items, mostly womens’ brands. This, along with a
reduction in operating expenses, contributed to a significant profit increase YoY.
Other subsidiaries’ performance was largely in line with company estimates. While Creative Yoko Co. and
Island Co. had some difficulty meeting their targets, Onward Trading Co. and Across Transport Co. had
strong showing. Creative Yoko was affected by its decision to scrap directly run shops inside shopping
centers. Island failed to meet its sales target and its gross profit margin declined as a result of an
inventory increase. Onward Trading benefitted from a large-scale order and a cost reduction achieved
through an expansion of production in Asia. Profitability at its uniform and sales-promotion operations
improved. Across Transport, meanwhile, increased sales after adding customers.
Overseas
The company accelerated investments and production in Europe and Asia in accordance with its
aggressive expansion strategy. However, worsening economies, political instability, etc. in these regions
led to substantially lower-than-expected overseas sales for the year. Overseas profitability accordingly fell
YoY with certain operational issues lingering.
Sales and profits fell at GIBO'Co. Sales fell because it had fewer orders for 2012 autumn and winter
collection. Shipments of 2013 spring collection were also delayed.* Profit fell because of upfront costs
involving the production of sample products, advertising, and the expansion of showrooms.
The company’s European units end its fiscal year in November. For GIBCO’Co at the parent level, this means
shipments of some products scheduled for FY11/12 have been delayed until FY11/13. The European units’
sales and profits for the December-February period (Q1) are included in the March-May period (Q1) of the
consolidated earnings.
Retail sales expanded at Jil Sander thanks to a rollout of full-scale operations of Jil Sander Navy.
However, there was a delay in the planning of the Collection Line. As a result, shipments of some products
scheduled for FY02/13 were delayed until FY02/14. Thus, the unit posted a recurring loss, instead of a
profit as planned.
At JOSEPH, sales of Essential Line items fell as a result of economic stagnation in Europe and
37/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
merchandising failures. Despite aggressive efforts, sales declined and valuation losses increased. The
unit’s profits plunged.
In Asia, the company sought to expand China operations by increasing production. However, a
deterioration of Japan-China relations and economic conditions led to substantially lower sales.
Q3 FY02/13 Results (Announced on January 11, 2013)
In cumulative Q3, sales were 191.4 billion yen (+4.9% YoY), operating profit was 10.7 billion yen (-5.9%
YoY), and recurring profit was 11.8 billion yen (-3.6% YoY). Net income was 4.6 billion yen (+6.4% YoY)
on the back of smaller extraordinary losses YoY (in cumulative Q3 FY02/12, the company booked 2.9
billion yen extraordinary losses, including 1.1 billion yen in connection with the implementation of
accounting standards related to asset retirement obligations and 1.3 billion yen related to headquarters
rebuilding).
The company maintained its full-year forecasts. However, SR Inc. thinks that the company’s overseas
performance in Europe, Asia, etc. was somewhat disappointing in the cumulative Q3 period. Accordingly,
SR Inc. estimates that although its domestic performance will be largely in line with estimates, Onward
will likely undershoot its full-year FY02/13 operating profit target due to weaker-than-expected overseas
performance.
According to the company, cumulative Q3 performance highlights were as follows.
Consolidated operating profit was down by 666 million yen YoY and breaking this down at the subsidiary
level:
 Operating profit at Onward Trading rose YoY by 443 million yen; by 236 million yen at Onward Resort
Group; by 6 million yen at Onward Holdings and Onward Kashiyama; and by 1 million yen at Jil Sander.
 Operating profit at JOSEPH dropped YoY by 436 million yen; by 419 million yen at GIBO’Co; and by 276
million yen in Asia.
 Onward Trading
 Chacott
 Island
Sales of 6.4 billion yen (up 4.7% YoY); operating profit of 1.1 billion yen (down 2.8% YoY)
 Creative Yoko
 Onward Resort Group
million yen YoY)
 JOSEPH
million yen YoY)
 GIBO’Co
38/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
 Jil Sander
million yen YoY)
 Asia
Domestic
Onward Kashiyama saw higher sales and profitability YoY although the sales fell short of its estimate.
Sales in cumulative Q3 at core brands were as follows: +8.3% YoY for Nijyusanku; +4.3% for Kumikyoku;
-0.6% for ICB; and +7.3% for Jiyuku. In the Q3 alone, sales rose 5.3% YoY for Nijyusanku; +11.3% for
Kumikyoku; -3.5% for ICB; and +0.7% for Jiyuku. As these figures show, ICB faced difficulties, while
Kumikyoku performed well. The company has been rebuilding its product strategy and refurbishing its
retail spaces for Kumikyoku. In the Q3, the company began airing TV commercials—the first in the past
ten years—featuring Japanese actress Satomi Ishihara. These initiatives bore fruit, according to the
company, with the brand’s recognition increasing among younger customer groups on top of core
customers in their 30s, and the company believes that this led to robust results at Kumikyoku.
In cumulative Q3, sales in new distribution channels were steady as well (e.g., anyFAM sales: +9.8% YoY;
anySiS: +9.7% YoY; field/dream: +12.1% YoY). In the Q3 alone, sales at anyFAM rose 5.8% YoY; 4.9%
YoY at anySiS; and 1.9% YoY at field/dream.
The company’s performance in the Q3 alone was under the negative impact of lingering summer heat in
September and mid-October 2012 as well as of a “family sale” event that was pushed back from
November to December (i.e., Q4 FY02/13). Still, the company maintained that its December performance
was robust even when leaving out the positive impact of the “family sale” event and it saw steady sales at
the beginning of January 2013.
At subsidiaries, Creative Yoko suffered intensified competition. However, better-than-expected
performance at Onward Trading, Chacott, etc. drove overall results, according to the company.
Overseas
Weak consumer spending in Europe and Asia due to economic slowdown and political instability meant
lower-than-expected overseas sales and profitability YoY.
Lower sales and profitability YoY at GIBO’Co were due to economic slowdown in Europe and higher costs
in connection with new-brand sample production and showrooms, things that can be viewed as upfront
investments. GIBO’Co has been working to expand wholesale sales through stronger partnerships with
licensors (i.e., designers) and pursue group-wide synergy. On top of these ongoing efforts, GIBO’Co was
accelerating the development of a new retail business (e.g., strengthening consignment sales at
European department stores) through these investments.
Sales at Jil Sander were lower YoY. Although Jil Sander Navy saw higher retail and wholesale sales YoY,
Collection Line sales were weak due to stagnant consumer spending in Europe. The brand founder, Jil
Sander, had returned as a creative director from the 2013 Spring & Summer collection. The change of
designers, however, caused a delay in planning work on the Collection Line, highly likely pushing back
some products’ launches originally scheduled within FY02/13 to FY02/14 (see Note below). SR Inc.
estimates that the company’s future outlook depends on the pace of Jil Sander Navy’s growth going
forward and the Collection Line’s profitability improvements.
39/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Note: Onward’s subsidiaries in Europe close a book in November each year. So, for Jil Sander alone, some of
its products initially scheduled for release within FY11/12 will now be launched in FY11/13. Sales and profits
at European subsidiaries during their Q4 (September-November) are included in Onward’s consolidated
results in Q4 (December-February).
JOSEPH saw a higher operating loss YoY due to weak sales of JOSEPH-branded items and period-end
inventory write-downs. In Q4, JOSEPH appears to be experiencing similar trends. Still, the company
seems confident about improving profitability from FY02/14 through better product planning capabilities
and more accurate product output adjustments.
Onward’s substantially lower profitability YoY in Asia was due to weak sales in China. In addition, although
the company slowed down the pace of new store openings, Onward was not able to effectively adjust its
production output, resulting in inventory write-downs. As the Chinese economy was slowing down,
department stores in general (a distribution channel for Onward) appeared to be facing difficult conditions.
The company stated it would need to tackle the Chinese market through strategies similar to those in
Japan, i.e., maintaining strong presence in the department store channels and at the same time
expanding operations through new distribution channels. The company added that it would strengthen
the “rosebullet” brand for young customers and accelerate low-cost production in Asia.
Q2 (1H) FY02/13 Results (Announced on October 5, 2012; please refer to the
preceding tables)
The company maintained its full-year forecast.
Sales were up 6.3% YoY at 120.9 billion yen, and operating profit up 97.5% at 3.2 billion yen. Despite the
overseas business suffering a lower gross profit margin attributable to inventory write-downs, the
group-level gross profit margin was up 0.7 percentage point YoY at 47.8% thanks to strong sales at
Onward Kashiyama’s core brands, higher sales of full-price items during summer bargain sales, and
higher sales via new distribution channels. Also, sales growth absorbed a 5.1% YoY rise in SG&A
expenses with the SG&A-to-sales ratio dropping 0.5 percentage point YoY to 45.2%. As a result, the
operating profit margin was up 1.2 percentage points YoY at 2.6%. Despite non-operating expenses
larger than non-operating income (mainly due to a 505 million yen FX loss), recurring profit was up 50.6%
at 3.7 billion yen. Net income shot up 578.9% to 522 million yen on the back of smaller extraordinary
losses YoY (in 1H FY02/12, the company booked a 1.1 billion yen extraordinary loss from the
implementation of accounting standards related to asset retirement obligations).
Sales fell slightly short of company forecast due to weak sales of autumn apparel, caused by lingering
summer heat in August, and to the negative impact of roughly 2.5 billion yen, caused by foreign exchange
rate fluctuations in Europe. Meanwhile, operating profit was 21.4% higher than forecast thanks to
Onward Kashiyama and other domestic subsidiaries performing better than expected, which compensated
for the overseas business falling short of estimates.
According to the company, 1H performance highlights were as follows.
Consolidated operating profit was up by 1.6 billion yen for the period YoY and breaking this down at the
subsidiary level:
 Operating profit at JOSEPH fell by 218 million yen YoY and by 72 million yen at GIBO’Co.
 Operating profit rose by 1.2 billion yen YoY at Onward Holdings and Onward Kashiyama, 298 million
yen at Onward Trading, 134 million yen at Onward Resort Group, and 69 million yen at Jil Sander.
40/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
 Onward Trading
 Chacott
 Island
 Creative Yoko
Sales of 3.4 billion yen (down 0.5% YoY); operating profit of 149 million yen (up 50.5% YoY)
million yen YoY)
 JOSEPH
million yen YoY)
 GIBO’Co
 Jil Sander
million yen YoY)
 Asia
Domestic
Onward Kashiyama registered a significant YoY improvement in performance. This resulted in operating
profit 35.7% higher than estimate in Japan, despite domestic sales falling short of estimate by 1.9%.
Sales in this 1H at core brands were as follows: Nijyusanku rose 10.2% YoY; +0.4% for Kumikyoku;
+0.8% for ICB; and +11.9% YoY for Jiyuku. Also, sales at brands through new distribution channels were
robust overall with anyFAM climbing 12.1%; +12.4% at anySiS; and +17.8% at field/dream.
Regarding 2012 summer bargain sales, Isetan Mitsukoshi Holdings Ltd. (TSE1: 3099) announced that it
would start summer bargain sales from mid-July (beginning-July in past years). Lumine Co., Ltd. (a
subsidiary of East Japan Railway Company; TSE1: 9020) followed Isetan Mitsukoshi Holdings, delaying its
summer bargain sales also to mid-July. Other department store operators decided to begin summer
bargain sales from July 1 as with previous years. These moves by department store operators caused a
rather confusing situation at apparel companies that were selling the same brands wholesale to or were
tenants simultaneously at both Isetan Mitsukoshi/Lumine and other department stores. More specifically,
apparel companies would have to sell the same products at different prices depending on the location of
their shops. This resulted in each apparel company starting its summer bargain sales on a different date.
In such an environment, Onward adopted the policy of presenting right products at the right price and
time, i.e., selling its products at full price at the beginning of July (when demand is high). Accordingly, the
company started summer bargain sales from after the mid-July. Despite lower bargain sales, full-price
item sales rose, leading into a higher gross profit margin as the company intended. In August, however,
lingering summer heat meant weak sales of autumn apparel.
Focusing on six brands (JOSEPH, Paul Smith, TOCCA, BEIGE, field/dream, and OPENING CEREMONY),
Onward is shifting from its traditional “branch-office system” to a “retail brand business system” in which
41/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
it integrates the management of planning, production, marketing, and sales on a per brand basis. The
company maintained that benefits from this systematic shift would materialize from 2H, adding that it was
steadily implementing related business initiatives in 1H.
Performance at Onward Trading and other domestic subsidiaries was in line with company estimates,
except at Island, which experienced a lower gross profit margin YoY due to higher write-downs at the
period end in connection with inventory optimization efforts.
Overseas
In Europe, GIBO’Co performed largely as planned. In contrast, Jil Sander performance was somewhat
stagnant, and JOSEPH results were significantly lower than estimates.
More specifically, GIBO’Co sales and profits were lower YoY mainly due to higher costs in connection with
new-brand sample production and showrooms, things that can be viewed as upfront investments. Still,
Onward explained that GIBO’Co performance was largely in line with estimates.
For Jil Sander, both retail and wholesale performance at Jil Sander Navy was better than expected.
However, retail sales of the Collection Line were stagnant due to weak consumer spending in Europe. As
a result, Jil Sander subsidiary did not return to profitability in 1H.
At JOSEPH, the merchandising failure led to weak sales and higher end-of-period inventory write-downs
of JOSEPH-branded items, resulting in a substantially lower gross profit margin and, consequently, lower
sales and profits. Onward views such merchandising failure as one of the issues for JOSEPH subsidiary to
address going forward.
Onward’s performance in Asia came in below estimates mainly due to weak performance in China. As the
Chinese economy was slowing down, department stores in general (a distribution channel for Onward)
appeared to be facing difficult conditions. More specifically, a large decrease in sales of full-price items led
to higher inventory write-downs and, consequently, a lower gross profit margin in China. Nevertheless,
with sales growing higher than expected in Asia ex-China, sales and profits in the region as a whole
increased YoY.
Commentary by Onward Kashiyama President Akinori Baba
The following sums up Onward Kashiyama President Baba’s comments at the 1H results meeting.
1. Onward’s Strategy Going Forward
 As discussed in the New Medium-Term Three-Year Plan, Onward needs to have a multifaceted business
model that goes beyond existing business fields. To this end, the company must move to a new era
where it is not about “creating new brands” but rather “creating new businesses.” Otherwise, it will not
be able to adjust to changes in operating environments.
 New business creation will be underpinned by: (1) expanding product categories, initiatives, and
services; (2) developing new brands and new distribution channels; and (3) accelerating overseas
business.
 Expanding product categories, initiatives, and services involves going beyond just apparel offerings
and providing lifestyle-oriented products and services. Onward will expand business fields by taking up
new business models and offering accessories and other goods with a focus on “new lifestyles.”
 In developing new distribution channels, Onward will continue to use department stores as it main
channel. However, with different department store operators going into different directions, various
traditional distribution channels are increasingly being integrated. Therefore, the company intends to
develop new brands to spur a drastic structural change in the distribution industry. Onward will also
42/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
consider expanding business by better utilizing its existing nationwide sales network and staff.
 Onward aims to accelerate overseas business by maximizing the use of the Onward Group’s brand
assets.
2. Concrete Plans
“Expand Product Categories, Initiatives, and Services”
 This plan involves the three brands of Charles & Keith, united bamboo, and kimono studio mon.
 Charles & Keith offers fashionable yet reasonably priced shoes, handbags, and accessories. The brand
rolls out products throughout Asia centered on Singapore. Onward Holdings will establish a joint
venture with Singapore-based Charles & Keith to develop the brand’s business in Japan. The company
plans to open stores in so-called “fashion buildings,” urban shopping centers, etc. nationwide from the
spring-summer 2013 season.
 In addition to apparel, New York-based united bamboo offers bags (Le Bac by united bamboo).
Onward Kashiyama acquired the “united bamboo” trademark rights in Japan and Asia and plans to
begin wholesale sales of bags (Le Bac) from the spring-summer 2013 season.
 For kimono studio mon, Onward has already opened a flagship store in Futako-Tamagawa
(Setagaya-ku, Tokyo). The flagship store not only sells kimonos but also provides comprehensive
services, from photo studio, dressing, and hair and makeup styling to kimono storage. Other stores (of
a smaller scale) will open in key areas starting from FY02/14.
“Develop New Brands and New Distribution Channels”
 This plan is underpinned by HEART of DKNY and Sebiro & Co. brands and by establishing a new
specialty-store business, among other initiatives.
 Derived from the DKNY brand that the Onward Group already carries, the HEART of DKNY brand
features large-scale stores primarily located in shopping centers. Under the concept of “Manhattan
Weekend Life,” the brand presents new lifestyle ideas through men’s, women’s, and kids’ offerings.
 Sebiro & Co. has custom-made suit stores at locations close to customers (i.e., in residential districts)
for better convenience for customers. The flagship stores in Jiyugaoka (Meguro-ku, Tokyo) and
Kichijoji (Musashino City, Tokyo) offer additional services for suit repair and pressing. The company
plans to accelerate store openings in key regions nationwide by utilizing Onward Kashiyama’s
manufacturing technology, know-how, and sales network.
 In establishing a new specialty-store business, Onward intends to transfer existing sales personnel
over to the new business. For example, Onward Kashiyama’s sales organizations will target prominent
specialty stores to expand sales of products from the Birz Group, now part of the Onward Group.
“Accelerate Overseas Business”
 J.Press plans to launch “J.Press York Street” in the US from the spring-summer 2013 season, targeting
young, affluent fashion enthusiasts. Going forward, J.Press aims to expand a network of large-scale
lifestyle shops that include menswear, womenswear, children’s clothing, and even home furnishings.
 ICB has started the exclusive rollout of ICB NY Exclusive Collection to US Barneys New York locations
and plans to expand retailing to department stores throughout the US as well as to Asia and Europe
from the autumn-winter 2013 season. From around 2014, Onward intends to integrate ICB’s planning
teams now in both New York and Japan and move to a structure in which, for example, New York
handles design processes, Japan manages business, and Asia performs production.
 Jil Sander Navy will be developed as a brand separate from the Collection Line in Japan and the US.
Onward opened the brand’s first flagship store in September 2012 in Tokyo’s Aoyama district.
3. Others
 From autumn 2012, existing businesses were facing increasingly difficult conditions. Onward intends to
overcome adversities and achieve double-digit sales growth in FY02/14 by expanding into growth
fields.
 It will be from 1H FY02/14 that the company will begin to see the benefits of organizational
43/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
restructuring in actual figures. Onward has already started centralizing administrative divisions.
 Onward will promote a cycle of “scrap and build” (withdraw or expand) for each brand, thereby
improving the efficiency in existing businesses.
 In 1H, delaying summer bargain sales was a success. But Onward plans to begin winter bargain sales
from January 2 as with previous years. Key to success in bargain sales is to present right products at
the right price and time.
 JOSEPH in Europe expanded the offering of trendy products in a bid to broaden its wholesale sales
channels worldwide but suffered a slowdown in existing businesses. Onward plans to make things turn
around at JOSEPH.
Q1 FY02/13 Results (Announced on July 6, 2012)
The company maintained its forecast.
Sales were up 10.1% YoY at 67.6 billion yen, and operating profit up 32.9% at 6.2 billion yen. The
operating profit margin was up 1.6 points YoY at 9.2%. The higher OPM was thanks to a higher gross
profit margin YoY (+0.5 point, at 50.1%) resulting from strong sales of Onward Kashiyama’s core brands
and higher sales through new distribution channels and also thanks to a lower SG&A-to-sales ratio (-1.0
point, at 40.9%). Higher SG&A YoY (+7.5%) was offset by sales growth. Despite non-operating expenses
larger than non-operating income (mainly due to a 443 million yen FX loss), recurring profit was up 12.2%
at 6.0 billion yen. Net income shot up 30.4% to 2.8 billion yen on the back of smaller extraordinary losses
YoY (in Q1 FY02/12, the company booked a 1.1 billion yen extraordinary loss from the implementation of
accounting standards related to asset retirement obligations).
Operating profit showed a substantial rebound YoY, although this was largely attributable to a decline
caused by the Great East Japan Earthquake in Q1 FY02/12. In fact, Q1 FY02/13 OP was essentially on par
with those in Q1 FY02/08 and Q1 FY02/09 (periods prior to Lehman Brother’s collapse). Also, Q1 FY02/13
OP came in above company estimate, possibly thanks to robust performance of domestic businesses (e.g.,
Onward Kashiyama), despite weak performance of certain overseas businesses (e.g., JOSEPH, China).
The company maintained 1H forecasts, commenting it had yet to see the trends and results of 2012
summer bargain sales. As of beginning-July, other apparel companies have already started summer
bargain sales. In contrast, aiming to expand sales of full-price items, the company has begun summer
bargain sales slightly later, after mid-July. The company could face the risk of excess inventory should the
summer bargain sales disappoint the company. If the company sells as planned through the summer
bargain sales, however, the GPM is likely to improve significantly even with July monthly sales being flat
YoY. In addition, the company will likely be able to continue bargain sales in August without running out of
stock. In this sense, the company’s monthly sales in July and August deserve close monitoring.
According to the company, Q1 performance highlights were as follows.
Consolidated operating profit was up by 1.5 billion yen for the period YoY and breaking this down at the
subsidiary level:
 Operating profit at JOSEPH fell by 111 million yen YoY and by 34 million yen at Jil Sander.
 Operating profit rose by 1.2 billion yen YoY at Onward Holdings and Onward Kashiyama, 178 million
yen at Onward Trading, 69 million yen at Onward Resort Group, and 63 million yen at GIBO’Co.
 Onward Trading
44/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
 Chacott
 Island
 Creative Yoko
 JOSEPH
million yen YoY)
 GIBO’Co
 Jil Sander
 Asia
Domestic
Onward Kashiyama registered a significant YoY improvement in performance, led by its core brands (see
above for actual figures).
Q1 sales at core brands were as follows: Nijyusanku rose 15.1% YoY; +3.2% for Kumikyoku; +18.8% for
Jiyuku; and +6.5% YoY for ICB. Sales for Nijyusanku and Jiyuku grew significantly as some products from
these brands became major success, although there were some rebound effects after a decline a year
earlier due to the disaster. Kumikyoku sales growth was relatively smaller. The company commented, with
Kumikyoku already seeing some hot sellers, it confirmed signs of the brand’s performance bottoming out.
Sales in new distribution channels were steady as well (e.g., anyFAM sales: +11.8% YoY; anySiS: +10.8%
YoY).
Onward Trading performed well, helped by demand recovery for both uniforms and sales promotion
goods as well as by lower CoGS. Island maintained robust performance. Other domestic subsidiaries’
performance was largely in line with company estimates.
Overseas
In Europe, performance at JOSEPH fell short of company estimates due to weak year-end and New Year
bargain sales. On the other hand, performance at GIBO’Co came in above company estimates. European
retail businesses seemed to be increasingly affected by economic slowdown. Still, the company intends to
expand its European operations further through various measures aimed at overcoming weak economy
and other adversities. In fact, strong Jil Sander performance was thanks to measures to increase Jil
Sander Navy sales.
Sales in China fell short of plan, possibly due to weak performance of department stores there. In the
late-1990s, after the Japanese economy matured, the department store industry experienced stagnant
performance. The company said the Chinese market, still growing rapidly, may have already begun seeing
similar trends at department stores.
Overall, the company’s overseas business performed largely in line with company estimates, with weak
results at JOSEPH and in China being offset by better-than-expected results at GIBO’Co, etc.
45/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
FY02/12 Results (Announced on April 6, 2012)
Despite a 0.9% decline in sales YoY to 242.4 billion yen, the company’s operating profit was up 22.7%, to
11.0 billion yen. This partly due to better cost controls, with the SG&A-to-sales ratio improving by 0.6%
YoY. The recurring profit came in at 13.3 billion yen (27.0% up YoY). The company booked 1.0 billion yen
in extraordinary profit for the period (due to sales of fixed assets); however, it also posted a 3.4 billion yen
extraordinary loss stemming primarily from asset retirement obligation accounting provisions (1.1 billion
yen) and the rebuilding and renovation of company headquarters (1.3 billion yen). As a result of all of
these factors, net income was up 29.6% YoY, to 3.5 billion yen.
The loss related to headquarters rebuilding and renovation was booked in FY02/12 although the actual
construction work takes place over three years. The company will rebuild its head office in Nihombashi in
central Tokyo. After the new building is complete, a part of it will be rented out to third-party tenants.
Looking at the 1H and 2H numbers, in the 1H when the results were affected by the earthquake, sales fell
2.3% but profits rose 1.9%. In 2H, aggressive merchandising and marketing allowed to grow both sales
(+0.4% YoY) and operating profit (+27.1% YoY).
The full year sales were approximately 1% below the company forecast, but operating profit was 7.4%
higher than anticipated, principally thanks to improved cost controls.
The group’s main subsidiaries performed as follows (the sales and operating profit totals shown below are
simple aggregate totals calculated prior to eliminations).
Sales of 150.0 billion yen (down 2.8% YoY); operating profit of 9.5 billion yen (up 28.7% YoY)
 Onward Trading
 Chacott
 Island
 Creative Yoko
million yen)
 JOSEPH
million yen)
 GIBO’Co
Sales of 14.9 billion yen (up 19.8% YoY); operating profit of 1.2 billion yen (vs. an operating profit of 585
million yen)
 Jil Sander
million yen)
Consolidated operating profit was up 2.0 billion yen YoY. Breaking this down at the subsidiary level,
operating profit at Onward Trading fell by 222 million yen and by 119 million yen at Onward Resort Group;
conversely, it rose 2.1 billion yen at Onward HD (the legal entity at the top of the Onward group of
46/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
companies) and Onward Kashiyama, and 605 million yen at GIBO’Co.
Domestic: sales of 213.7 billion yen (down 1.9% YoY); operating profit of 13.0 billion yen
(up 16.9% YoY)
Onward HD and Onward Kashiyama
Onward Kashiyama registered a significant rise in profitability, led by its core brands. It absorbed the
impact from the earthquake in 1H (which caused an estimated decrease in sales of about 3.0 billion yen
due to store closures and reduced opening hours in the Tohoku and the Kanto regions) by bolstering its
product offerings and store sales and improving its costs controls, including for labor and advertising costs.
This resulted in improved profits.
Sales of core brands were as follows: Nijyusanku +0.3% YoY, Kumikyoku +11.6%, Jiyuku +0.7%, and
ICB +0.6%.
By quarters, the operating profit grew by about 100 million yen, 200 million yen, and 1.8 billion yen, in Q1,
Q2, and Q3 respectively, and roughly flat YoY in Q4.
In Q1-Q2, the earthquake, early start of seasonal sales by competitors, and weak performance of the fall
apparel amid unseasonably hot weather hurt profitability. At the same time, gross profit margins
benefited from lower minimum royalty guarantees on licensed brands and higher weight of apparel sold
at full prices (benefiting from Cool Biz casual business wear trend). The company also controlled SG&A
costs.
In Q3, sales were strong, driven by the original merchandise under the Cross-Brand Strategy umbrella
(unified theme items represented across the brand portfolio) such as MIRA SHAWL items (“mirror shawl”)
and Warm Biz merchandise. The profitability improved as gross profit margins further benefited from less
discounting and successful cold-weather outerwear offering and SG&A costs were controlled tightly. In Q4
however, profits were practically unchanged YoY despite cost reductions as sales fell by 1.0bn yen YoY,
hurt by weakness of spring apparel affected by the unusually long and cold winter.
Onward Trading
The recovery of the sales promotion unit was not sufficient to compensate for the decline in orders for
both school and work uniforms due to the earthquake. In addition, the company was not immediately
able to transfer the increased production costs it incurred in China onto product prices. As a result of
these factors, operating profit in 1H fell and there was a decline in both sales and profits for the full fiscal
year.
Chacott
The dancewear subsidiary steadily increased customer numbers, led by its flagship store and its
e-business, and achieved an increase in both sales and profits.
Island
Aggressive merchandising strategy and corresponding efforts to carry broader inventory meant lower
gross profit margins (offering an aggressively wider variety of items means that more items won’t sell at
full prices). However, the strategy paid off as it also meant more customers and more items sold, resulting
in stronger top line and better operating profitability (both beating forecast).
Creative Yoko
Sales fell in the aftermath of the earthquake, but the pet wear subsidiary managed to grow profits as
spend per customer and gross profit margins increased driven by strong new product offering.
47/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Overseas: sales of 44.0 billion yen (up 5.9% YoY); operating profit of 323 million yen
(previous year, an operating loss of 99 million yen)
Operations in Europe recorded a significant improvement in financial results, with an increase in both
sales and profits.
 Europe: sales of 34.2 billion yen (up 6.6% YoY); operating profit of 197 million yen (previous year, an
operating loss of 363 million yen)
JOSEPH
Despite efforts to refresh the brand image, sales came in below plan as the European retail business failed
to recover.
GIBO’Co
Orders from Jil Sander and other brands (both from the inside and outside of the Onward group
companies) increased, leading to a strong apparel and shoes wholesale business. Operating profit
increased approximately 600 million yen YoY and was also about 3 million yen above the company’s
forecast.
Jil Sander
The gross profit margins improved by using GIBO’Co’s production platform. Sales of its new line, Jil
Sander Navy, did not reach the company’s ambitious forecast. On the other hand, wholesale sales trended
according to forecasts.
 Asia: sales of 6.9 billion yen (up 6.7% YoY); operating profit of 333 million yen (down 19.0% YoY)
Sales in Asia, centered on China, trended strongly until Q3, but consumer confidence deteriorated in Q4
due to anxiety about the economic environment, and full-year sales were below the company’s forecast.
 United States: sales of 2.9 billion yen (down 3.5% YoY); operating loss of 207 million yen (previous
year, an operating loss of 147 million yen)
Retail (J.PRESS) sales were slightly down, but the gross profit margin improved because of an increase in
sales of full-price items, and, as a result, the size of the deficit decreased. Profitability for the resort unit
recovered in 2H. However, the unit was unable to offset the decrease in sales in 1H caused by the
substantial decline in customer numbers as a result of cancellations following the earthquake.
Consequently, the company recorded a deficit in this region for the full fiscal year.
Q3 FY02/12 Results (Announced on January 6, 2012)
The company maintained its full-year forecast.
Despite a recovery in consumption following March 2011’s earthquake in Tohoku, bad weather over the
period resulted in a 0.3% YoY decline for cumulative Q3 FY02/12 sales, which came in at 182.5 billion yen.
Gross profit margin though improved to 49.1% from 48.5% YoY on the back of a review of royalties of
overseas licensed apparel brands and a strengthening of the product offering and store sales. The
SG&A-to-sales ratio declined 2.3% YoY due to expense controls, which further raised profitability.
Consequently, there was a 30.7% YoY increase in operating profit to 11.4 billion yen.
The company booked 1.0 billion yen in extraordinary profit for the period due to sales of fixed assets,
however it also posted a 2.9 billion yen extraordinary loss stemming primarily from asset retirement
48/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
obligation accounting provisions (1.1 billion yen) and the rebuilding/renovation of company headquarters
(1.3 billion yen). Net income thus declined 7.0% YoY to 4.4 billion yen.
Q3 sales at Onward Kashiyama were positively affected by the company bringing forward a “family sale”
event into the Q3 period and strong January New Year sales campaign.
Consolidated operating profit was up by 2.7 billion yen YoY. At the major subsidiaries, operating profits
deteriorated at Onward Trading, Jil Sander, JOSEPH, and Island, while improving at Onward Kashiyama,
GIBO’Co, Chacott, Creative Yoko, Across Transport and Onward Resort Group.
Domestic
Onward Kashiyama registered a significant rise in profitability, led by its core brands, absorbing the
earthquake impact. Cumulative Q3 sales at core brands were: +0.3% YoY for Nijyusanku, -11.3% for
Kumikyoku; +0.8% YoY for Jiyuku, and +0.3% YoY for ICB. (On a quarterly basis Q3 core brand sales
were: +5.1% YoY for Nijyusanku; -6.7% for Kumikyoku; +9.0% for Jiyuku, and +6.1% YoY for ICB.
Island continued to perform well and exceed forecasts, while Chacott also generated solid results. In
contrast, while Onward Trading has shown signs of a recovery in 2H, this has not been sufficient to make
up for the slump it experienced in 1H and it failed to hit its forecasts. Other domestic subsidiaries
performed approximately in-line with expectations.
Overseas
Operations in Europe improved, generally outperforming the budget; Performance at JOSEPH came in
below forecasts as the business was unable to recover from its 1H weak performance. Jil Sander was in
line with expectations. Both sales and profits came in better than anticipated at GIBO’Co, where
performance was driven by wholesale revenues from new licensees.
Sales in Asia up to Q3 were strong. As of Q4, sales in China fell YoY and while this situation needs
monitoring, sales in South Korea and Hong Kong were steady and region-wide Onward was experiencing
no real problems.
Q2 (1H) FY02/12 Results (Announced on October 7, 2011)
1H (cumulative Q1-Q2) FY02/12 sales declined 2.3% YoY to 113.7 billion yen as consumers pulled back
on consumption in the wake of March 2011’s earthquake in Tohoku. Gross profit margin though improved
0.3% (to 47.1% from 46.8% in the same period of FY02/11) thanks to downwardly reviewed royalties on
selected licensed apparel brands and other factors.
SG&A expense controls further helped profitability leading to a 1.9% YoY increase in operating profit to
1.6 billion yen. Net income though declined 93.4% YoY to 76 million yen due to 1.3 billion yen in
extraordinary losses (versus 202 million yen of extraordinary losses in 1H FY02/11). The bulk of
extraordinary losses came from 1.1 billion yen of asset retirement obligation accounting provisions.
Sales, operating and recurring profits were all better than the company’s original forecast of 112.4 billion
yen (actual results 1.2% above forecast); 1.4 billion yen (actual results 14.2% above forecast), and 2.2
billion yen (actual results 12.4% above forecast), respectively. Net income also came in stronger than the
originally forecast 500 million yen net loss, as the company sold some land and realized an extraordinary
gain of just under 1.1 billion yen.
49/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
The main subsidiaries’ 1H performance was as follows:
Domestic
Sales of 68.5 billion yen (down 6.1% YoY); operating profit of 1.8 billion yen (up 22.3% YoY)
(Note: while Onward Holdings does not generate any sales its costs are grouped with Onward
Kashiyama’s). Operating profit beat the original forecast owing to better gross profit margins (lower
royalty payments and higher percentage of items sold at full prices) and lower SG&A expenses. Sales of
core brands though were in negative territory, declining 3.0% YoY for Nijyusanku; 14.0% for Kumikyoku;
3.0% for Jiyuku, and 4% YoY for ICB.
 Onward Trading
Profitability declined as orders for both school and work uniforms fell due to March 2011’s Tohoku
earthquake and increased production costs in China.
 Island
Due to YoY base effects from 1H FY02/11 sales (of men’s brands that are no longer carried) profits were
down YoY, but sales exceeded the company forecast due to growth in sales at existing stores and new
store openings.
 Chacott
Led by the flagship store, since April a recovery in sales has accelerated and operating profit exceeded the
company plan.
 Creative Yoko
Sales fell short of the company forecast due to the effects of March 2011’s earthquake, but the gross
profit margin met company expectations due to solid sales of full price items.
Overseas
 GIBO’Co
million yen in 1H FY02/11)
Both sales and profits came in better than expected, driven by revenues from new licensees and improved
factory utilization helped by the order flow from Onward group companies, such as Jil Sander.
 Jil Sander
At Jil Sander, gross profit margins improved further thanks to it concentrating its manufacturing at
GIBO’Co (as opposed to third party manufacturers). At the same time, expanding retail sales of Jil Sander
Navy remained an issue.
 JOSEPH
Gross profitability improved as the ratio of full-price (non-discounted) items in the sales mix increased.
However, poor performance during the key winter-holidays sale period hurt performance, bringing sales in
below expectations.
50/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
The company left its full year FY02/12 forecast unchanged, citing the uncertain environment.
Sales of the company’s core domestic unit, Onward Kashiyama, suggest sluggish Q2 performance due to
the company’s decision to run its seasonal sale as ususal in July. At the same time a number of
competitors started cutting prices earlier, driving consumers towards bargains and away from fully-priced
items offerd by Kashiyama. SR Inc. understands the underwhelming performance trend started reversing
itself in September and into October.
The following is a selection of comments made by Akinori Baba, the new president of Onward Kashiyama,
at the 1H FY02/12 results meeting held on October 11, 2011.
 Under the current harsh business conditions, growth is not possible without higher sales. The company
will look to make reforms in its organizational, manufacturing and creative capabilities and leverage
these to propel growth in the new three year mid-term that begins from FY02/13.
 As far as growth goes there is room to expand domestically, as well as overseas. Department stores
have been the company’s main distribution channel and the company will continue to strengthen its
operations there, as well as moving to bolster its other sales channels.
 The company’s main products occupy the mass-market segment and have respectable and safe name
recognition there. However, there is a sense that the company over the past several years has also
failed to create a brand that inspires a sense of fashion. The company owns the Japanese trademark
rights for “Opening Ceremony,” an overseas boutique store operator well known in the fashion industry.
By using the Opening Ceremony brand we can send a message about how committed our company is
to fashion.
 Jil Sander Navy has been rolled out overseas as an extension apparel line. On visiting Europe in
September and discussing with the regional manager, we agreed Jil Sander Navy needs to be pushed
harder as a diffusion line.
 Regarding JOSEPH, the company is aware that European consumers cut back on spending starting in
September. However, in addition to Europe, Onward also has overseas operations in North America and
Asia and increasing sales in North America and Asia is an urgent task for JOSEPH.
 J.PRESS is currently the company’s main brand in North America but there are plans to begin sales of
ICB in autumn 2012. A design and planning team based in New York has been set up. The company
would like to use ICB as a test-bed for exporting a brand to North America and then “importing” it back
into Japan. The idea of exporting a brand to North America, and then depending on the circumstances,
importing aspects back to Japan is something that could also apply to Asia. Japan and Europe are not
the only geographies with the ability to create apparel. The company wants to create a system in
which information and products from across its four geographies of operation can flow freely.
Q1 FY02/12 Results (Announced on July 8, 2011)
Sales were down 4.8% YoY at 61.4 billion yen affected by poor consumer confidence and self-restraint
due to March 2011’s Tohoku earthquake. Nonetheless, the company’s gross profit margin improved to
49.6% from 48.9% YoY, lifted by cost controls and its overseas business plan proceeding on track
(primarily driven by reviewing overseas brand licensing royalties and inventory controls).
Operating profit was up 4.0% YoY at 4.7 billion yen. Net income, however, fell 16.7% YoY to 2.2 billion
yen due to the booking of a 1.1 billion yen extraordinary loss from the implementation of accounting
standards related to asset retirement obligations (the total extraordinary loss for the period was 1.2 billion
yen vs. 156 million yen a year earlier).
51/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
According to the company, these results came in better than planned due to two factors: April-May sales
at Onward Kashiyama beat forecasts, and on a consolidated-basis cost-cutting was more effective than
expected. The company had assumed April-May sales at Onward Kashiyama would be down 6.0%
YoY, instead they came in 0.4% higher. Finally, SG&A expenses decreased 4.7% YoY primarily focused
on labor and advertising costs at the consolidated level.
The company left its 1H and FY02/12 forecast unchanged. June sales at Onward Kashiyama were weak;
down 4.0% YoY, and it appears the company was being cautious over Q2 FY02/12 results. Some
competitors conducted summer sales ahead of schedule, while the company held sales at the beginning
of July as usual, but it appears these were affected by weak consumer confidence.
Performance at the company’s main subsidiaries was as follows:
 Onward Holdings and Onward Kashiyama: 37.0 billion yen in sales (down 7.6% YoY), operating profit
3.8 billion yen (up 3.3% YoY)
 Onward Trading: 4.3 billion yen in sales (up 1.3% YoY), operating profit 312 million yen (down 20.6%
YoY).
 Island: 1.9 billion yen in sales (up 7.9% YoY), operating profit of 318 million yen (down 16.1% YoY)
 Across Transport: sales 2.9 billion yen (up 5.4% YoY), operating profit 205 million yen (up 26.5% YoY).
 JOSEPH: sales of 2.4 billion yen (down 7.6% YoY), operating loss of 322 million yen (vs. previous year
 GIBO’Co: sales of 3.9 billion yen (up 7.6% YoY), operating income of 308 million yen (up 15.4%)
 Jil Sander: sales of 2.8 billion yen (up 5.5% YoY), operating income of 42 million yen (vs. previous year
Domestic
 Onward Kashiyama: As mentioned above, results came in above company expectations. Total sales
of core brands in Q1 FY02/12 did, however, fall 7.6%. By brand, Nijyusanku sales were down 4.6%
YoY; Kumikyoku sales declined 15.6% YoY; ICB sales fell 4.4% YoY and Jiyuku sales were down 7.1%
YoY. However, if one stripped out March’s performance due to the Tohoku earthquake, sales for April
and May actually rose 1.1% for the core brands with Nijyusanku sales increasing 4.0% YoY for these
two months; Kumikyoku sales gained 5.8% YoY; ICB sales rose 2.9% YoY and Jiyuku sales were up
1.3% YoY.
 Onward Trading: profitability declined as orders for both school and work uniforms fell due to March
2011’s Tohoku earthquake and production costs in China increased.
 Island: profit declined YoY due to base effects with sales conducted in Q1 FY02/11 year, although the
company commented figures came in line with forecasts
 Across Transport: profitability increased with the acquisition of new contracts
Overseas
 JOSEPH: year-end and new-year bargain sales were weak and results came in below expectations.
However, the company said it did not believe the situation was serious given strong sales for full-price
items.
 GIBO’Co: results came in above forecast driven by new license agreements and increasing production
rates for group enterprises, such as Jil Sander.
 Jil Sander: results came in above forecast.
FY02/11 Results (Announced on April 8, 2011)
Sales, operating and recurring profit all came in above company forecasts driven by its robust
52/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
performance of its main brands. Nonetheless, net income came in below the company’s forecast. The
company said a 1.3 billion yen write-down on marketable securities was the main cause behind this.
Operating income for FY02/11 was up 103.7% YoY at 8.9 billion yen of which Onward Kashiyama
(including HD) generated 7.4 billion yen in operating profit (a 24.2% YoY increase) and Island—which
became a consolidated subsidiary in December 2009—generated 1.5 billion yen in operating profit.
Among its overseas subsidiaries Joseph posted an operating loss of 352 million yen (vs. a 746 million
operating loss in the previous year); Jil Sander a 664 million yen operating loss (vs. a 1.9 billion yen
operating loss in the previous year), and GIBO’Co recorded an operating profit of 585 million yen (up
13.4%YoY).
On the other hand, operating profit at Onward Trading fell 24.7% YoY to 932 million yen, and was down
a sharp 71.7% YoY at 80 million yen at Across Transport.
Domestic
Both sales and operating profit at Onward Kashiyama came in above the company’s projections. The
company cited three main drivers for the better-than-forecast results were:
 Solid performance at core brands (sales at Nijyusanku up 7% YoY, ICB up 5% YoY, Jiyuku also up 5%
YoY)
 Strong sales for its Air Jacket menswear product
 Expansion of its e-commerce business.
Negatives were an 8% YoY decrease in sales at Kumikyoku (one of its core brands) and an unseasonably
hot weather that delayed sales of seasonal autumn items.
As for other domestic subsidiaries, the company made the following comments:
Island: sales and operating profit hit record highs.
Onward Trading: profitability declined as the business was hit by lower orders for sales promotion goods
and higher production costs in China.
Chacott: operating profit was up despite sales not growing as planned.
Across Transport: profitability hit by higher costs and oil prices.
Overseas
Sales were down 8.9% YoY mainly due to currency headwinds but still managed to beat the company’s
forecast. The company recorded an operating loss of 100 million yen for its overseas subsidiaries; a
significant improvement on the previous year’s 2.1 billion yen operating loss, and better than forecast.
Exchange rates negatively impacted the sales performance of foreign subsidiaries to the tune of 5.9 billion
yen, adjusting for currency effects sales would have risen 4.1% YoY.
In Europe results beat forecasts as the company strengthened its operating base there and consequently
improved business performance resulting in a far smaller operating loss. Asia on the other hand was
affected by higher Chinese production costs pulling operating income lower and below plans.
Regarding its European subsidiaries the company made the following comments:
Jil Sander: by shifting production to GIBO’Co there was a significant improvement in gross margin at the
label.
JOSEPH: a renovation of its flagship store helped boost sales.
GIBO’Co: Profitability improved driven by its expanded wholesale business and taking on business from Jil
Sander.
53/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Income Statement
Income Statement
(million yen)
Total Sales
YoY
CoGS
Gross Profit
GPM
FY02/10
Cons.
248,634
FY02/11
Cons.
244,550
FY02/12
Cons.
242,402
FY02/13
Cons.
258,369
FY02/14
Cons.
279,073
FY02/15
Est.
290,700
4.2%
-4.7%
-1.6%
-0.9%
6.6%
8.0%
134,458
114,176
128,725
115,825
127,288
115,113
133,878
124,490
149,113
129,959
45.9%
47.4%
47.5%
48.2%
46.6%
109,793
106,896
104,159
113,298
120,537
SG&A / Sales
44.2%
43.7%
43.0%
43.9%
43.2%
Operating Profit
4,383
8,928
10,953
11,192
9,422
12,300
-51.8%
1.8%
103.7%
3.7%
22.7%
4.5%
2.2%
4.3%
-15.8%
3.4%
30.5%
4.2%
4,667
2,929
6,120
4,165
2,597
10,497
3,860
1,484
13,329
3,726
1,514
13,405
4,209
12,211
13,700
-2.6%
2.5%
71.5%
4.3%
27.0%
5.5%
0.6%
5.2%
-8.9%
4.4%
12.2%
4.7%
2,419
2,150
4,174
65.3%
27
2,187
486
2,431
5,708
66.7%
120
2,722
1,094
3,353
7,450
67.3%
90
3,529
1,967
7,623
3,188
41.1%
56
4,503
1,129
3,866
4,781
50.5%
34
4,658
5,400
-107.1%
0.9%
24.5%
1.1%
29.6%
1.5%
27.6%
1.7%
3.5%
1.7%
15.9%
1.9%
SG&A
YoY
OPM
Non-Operating Income
Non-Operating Expenses
Recurring Profit
YoY
RPM
Extraordinary Gains
Extraordinary Losses
Tax Charges
Implied Tax Rate
Minority
Net Income
YoY
Net Margin
The company’s sales rose at approximately 4.5% per year from FY02/02 through FY02/07 (peaking at
approximately 319 billion yen in FY02/07) before declining about 22.0% into FY02/10.
Gross profit margins have been largely stable (a median of 45.8% GPM within a tight range between
43.4% and 47.5%, FY02/02-FY02/12). Operating profit margins peaked at 8.9% in FY02/05 before
declining to 1.8% in FY02/10. The largest factor impacting them has been sales given that the SG&A costs
stayed largely unchanged over the period (with labor costs the biggest fixed component).
Onward has typically recognized net non-operating profit such as rent and royalties. The large
non-operating expense in FY02/09 was due to a FX loss (subsidiary loans arranged in yen to lower the
interest costs, backfiring when the yen exchange rate trend suddenly reversed from mid 2007; the
practice was officially terminated following the losses).
Recurring profit margins have generally tracked changes in operating profit margins.
The company has recognized extraordinary losses in the past. The 22.2 billion yen loss in FY02/02 was
related to a change in accounting convention (related to retirement benefit obligations). The 17.8 billion
yen loss in FY02/07 was partially related to asset impairment charges of the resort business in Guam
(approximately 6.1 billion yen). The company recognized a 37.8 billion yen extraordinary loss in FY02/09
largely due to a valuation charge on investment securities (approximately 22.6 billion yen) and
impairment losses on goodwill of a UK subsidiary (approximately 11.6 billion yen).
54/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Net profit margin peaked in FY02/04 when an accounting change related to pension liabilities provided a
10.5 billion yen extraordinary gain boosting the net income. The net loss in FY02/09 (30.9 billion yen) was
due to extraordinary items discussed above.
DuPont ROE Analysis
Net Profit Margin
Asset Turnover
Leverage Factor
ROE
FY02/09
Cons.
-11.8%
86.2%
1.70
-17.4%
FY02/10
Cons.
0.9%
84.4%
1.86
1.4%
FY02/11
Cons.
1.1%
85.2%
1.81
1.7%
FY02/12
Cons.
1.5%
86.8%
1.77
2.2%
FY02/13
Cons.
1.7%
91.7%
1.75
2.8%
FY02/12
Cons.
244,800
242,402
-1.0%
10,200
10,953
7.4%
11,600
13,329
14.9%
3,500
3,529
0.8%
FY02/13
Cons.
266,600
258,369
-3.1%
13,800
11,192
-18.9%
15,400
13,405
-13.0%
5,000
4,503
-9.9%
Historical Performance vs. Estimates
Initial CE vs. Results
(million yen)
Sales (Initial CE)
Sales (Results)
Operating Profit (Initial CE)
Operating Profit (Results)
Recurring Profit (Initial CE)
Recurring Profit (Results)
Net Profit (Initial CE)
Net Profit (Results)
FY02/09
Cons.
291,000
261,005
-10.3%
20,600
9,084
-55.9%
24,200
6,285
-74.0%
12,400
-30,895
-
FY02/10
Cons.
252,600
248,634
-1.6%
8,000
4,383
-45.2%
10,000
6,120
-38.8%
3,600
2,187
-39.3%
FY02/11
Cons.
250,000
244,550
-2.2%
6,600
8,928
35.3%
9,000
10,497
16.6%
3,500
2,722
-22.2%
55/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Balance Sheet
Balance Sheet
(million yen)
ASSETS
Cash and Equivalents
Accounts Receivable
Allowance for Doubtful
Inventories
Prepaid Expenses
Other Current Assets
Total Current Assets
Buildings, Land
Acc. Depreciation
Other Fixed
Acc. Depreciation
Total Tangible Assets
Investments
LT Loans
LT Prepaid Expenses
Deferred Tax Assets
Other
Allowance for Doubtful
Total Other Fixed Assets
Goodwill
Other
Total Intangible Assets
Total Fixed Assets
Total Assets
LIABILITIES
Accounts Payable
Short-Term Debt
Corporate Taxes Payable
Allowance for Loss on Unsold Inventory
Reserve for Bonuses
Other Current Liabilities
Total Current Liabilities
Long-Term Debt
Allowance
Valuation-Based Deferred Tax Liabilities
Other Fixed Liabilities
Total Long-Term Liabilities
Total Interest-Bearing Debt
Total Liabilities
Issued Capital
Reserves
Retained Earnings
Treasury Stock
Valuation and Translation Adjustments
Share-Purchase Warrants
Minority Interests
Total Shareholder Equity (Net Assets)
Working Capital
Interest-Bearing Debt
Net Debt
FY02/10
Cons.
FY02/11
Cons.
FY02/12
Cons.
FY02/13
Cons.
FY02/14
Cons.
34,330
25,730
-862
30,893
4,238
6,348
100,680
131,920
50,294
26,340
18,225
89,741
31,193
4,969
881
5,529
12,001
-3,240
51,335
47,417
3,393
50,811
191,888
292,568
30,939
25,399
-723
30,356
4,074
5,499
95,544
129,380
50,748
25,827
17,836
86,622
34,592
4,839
750
5,627
9,273
-2,354
52,729
43,731
3,014
46,745
186,097
281,642
33,192
25,256
-387
31,443
3,820
5,571
98,895
125,904
52,092
27,562
18,386
82,987
35,179
5,028
743
4,495
8,916
-2,801
51,561
40,793
2,701
43,495
178,044
276,939
24,677
25,863
-452
34,476
7,931
7,826
100,321
128,633
52,891
30,797
19,678
86,861
42,730
5,275
1,212
3,600
13,862
-2,541
64,138
32,769
2,688
35,457
186,458
286,779
27,375
28,250
-635
40,678
5,108
9,573
110,349
137,044
52,879
41,161
22,448
102,878
49,161
5,446
1,182
3,079
10,028
-2,971
65,926
29,740
4,535
34,276
203,081
313,430
35,961
35,697
4,085
545
1,830
12,806
90,929
24,571
3,395
5,949
9,558
43,475
60,268
134,404
30,079
50,043
118,816
-23,489
-18,949
412
1,251
158,164
19,800
60,268
25,938
32,703
30,886
4,533
869
1,867
11,819
82,677
22,665
3,587
5,941
8,027
40,220
53,551
122,898
30,079
50,043
117,776
-23,445
-17,405
532
1,163
158,744
23,052
53,551
22,612
33,238
29,865
5,699
513
1,266
13,510
84,091
19,730
4,261
3,966
7,588
35,545
49,595
119,636
30,079
50,043
119,524
-23,326
-20,327
653
656
157,302
23,461
49,595
16,403
33,512
47,581
4,829
528
1,289
13,001
100,740
1,573
3,210
3,966
11,917
20,666
49,154
121,407
30,079
50,043
120,164
-23,146
-13,420
724
926
165,372
26,827
49,154
24,477
38,305
44,956
955
496
1,286
15,011
101,009
14,051
3,556
3,966
15,818
37,391
59,007
138,401
30,079
50,043
121,007
-23,052
-4,981
823
1,109
175,028
30,623
59,007
31,632
56/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
The company’s capital structure has been mostly equity from FY02/02-FY02/12.The company has used
debt financing in the past, typically short term (repaid all long term debt from in FY02/02; used more in
FY02/09). The balance sheet has been highly liquid (current ratio above 100% from FY02/02 through
FY02/12). The company has typically held a high cash balance (exceeding working capital requirements).
Assets
The asset base for the company has historically been dominated by fixed assets (tangible assets related
to sales activities and other fixed assets such as investments and long term loans). The company’s M&A
activity in FY02/06 and FY02/09 has resulted in substantial amounts of goodwill on the balance sheet.
Adjusting (removing) goodwill from the balance sheet reveals a different liquidity profile: current assets
(cash and working capital) are the largest group of assets. Onward does not own manufacturing facilities
(see Business Model), therefore working capital is an important component of the business model.
Liabilities
Liquidity of liabilities mirrors assets; current liabilities have historically been over 80% of total liabilities
(from FY02/02 through FY02/12). Current liabilities have been mostly working capital, however the
company’s use of short term debt has been an increasingly large component in current liabilities. Short
term debt as of FY02/10 was bank loans.
The company seems to have shifted to using all short term debt in FY02/02 (total debt / assets was
similar pre-2002, but the composition of short term debt increased), matching the short-term cycle of the
business model. The company added long term debt in FY02/09, lowering the equity ratio from levels
seen during FY02/02-FY02/07.
Net Assets
Shareholders’ equity has generally increased with net income (net dividend payments) from FY02/02
through FY02/08. A net 11.0 billion in valuation charge in FY02/07 (mostly related to land) offset net
income for the year, and a net 28.5 billion yen charge in FY02/08 (9.7 billion yen related to securities and
18.6 billion yen of minority interest decreases) caused a 27.5 billion yen decline in net assets.
The company has also been a buyer of its own stock: purchasing approximately 5.3 billion yen in FY02/04,
approximately 9.4 billion yen in FY02/06, and approximately 7 billion yen in FY02/08.
Per Share Data
Per Share Data (yen)
No. of Shares (thousand)
Earnings Per Share
EPS (Fully Diluted)
Dividend Per Share
Book Value Per Share
FY02/09
Cons.
172,922
-197.2
-197.2
30.0
1,001.4
FY02/10
Cons.
172,922
14.0
13.9
24.0
999.0
FY02/11
Cons.
172,922
17.4
17.3
24.0
1,002.3
FY02/12
Cons.
172,922
22.5
22.4
24.0
995.1
FY02/13
Cons.
172,922
28.7
28.5
24.0
1,043.6
57/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Cash Flow Statement
Cash Flow Statement
(million yen)
Operating Cash Flow (1)
Investment Cash Flow (2)
Free Cash Flow (1+2)
Financial Cash Flow
Depreciation & Amortization (A)
Capital Expenditures (B)
Working Capital Changes (C)
Simple FCF (NI + A + B - C)
FY02/09
Cons.
10,839
-40,950
-30,111
17,971
8,386
-2,793
1,081
-26,383
FY02/10
Cons.
14,057
-25
14,032
-4,889
9,149
-2,967
-596
8,965
FY02/11
Cons.
11,206
-5,151
6,055
-9,271
9,279
-2,977
3,252
5,772
FY02/12
Cons.
13,180
-1,961
11,219
-7,449
9,142
590
409
12,852
FY02/13
Cons.
10,137
-10,682
-545
-7,848
9,658
-6,387
3,366
4,408
Operating Cash Flow
The largest component of OCF has historically been net income (a median of 41.4% of from FY02/02
through FY02/12), illustrating the cash generating nature of the company’s business model. OCF in
FY02/04 was the result of strong net income growth along with a reduction in working capital (payables
increased 4.9 billion, reversing a decrease of 2.4 billion yen the previous year). OCF in FY02/06 grew YoY
due to timing related to FY02/04 taxes (paid in FY02/05), creating the appearance of volatility which was
not due to core earnings.
OCF was positive in FY02/09 despite a net loss of 30.9 billion yen. This was in part due to sizeable
non-cash charges (22.6 billion yen securities write-down, 13.0 billion yen impairment losses).
Investment Cash Flow
FY02/06 investment cash flow of 37 billion yen was related to the purchase of the JOSEPH Group (16.9
billion yen) and the purchase of investment securities (13.3 billion yen). Investment cash flow in FY02/08
was due in part to the sale of Impact 21 (6.3 billion yen outflow). Investment cash flow in FY02/09 was
largely due to the purchase of Jil Sander (26.6 billion yen) and Creative Yoko (6.7 billion yen).
Financial Cash Flow
The relatively large outflow in FY02/03 was mostly due to paying down debt (approximately 9.4 billion
yen short-term, 2.1 long-term). The outflow in FY02/04 was due to a share buyback (5.3 billion yen) and
repayment of short term debt (3.1 billion yen). Outflows in FY02/06 and FY02/08 were also the result of
buybacks (9.4 and 7.0 billion yen, respectively). The inflow in FY02/09 was the result of a long term credit
facility (approximately 33 billion yen) to finance M&A.
Simple Cash Flow
In terms of simple free cash flow the company has typically generated relatively large amounts, yielding a
median of 5.5% per year (on average net assets, FY02/02-FY02/12).
58/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Cash Converison Cycle
Accounts Receivable Turnover
Days in Accounts Receivable
Inventory Turnover
Days in Inventory
Payables Turnover
Days in Payables
Cash Conversion Cycle (days)
FY02/09
Cons.
9.6
38.0
4.3
85.7
3.5
104.5
19.2
FY02/10
Cons.
9.7
37.5
4.2
87.8
3.6
102.6
22.7
FY02/11
Cons.
9.6
38.2
4.2
86.8
3.7
97.3
27.6
FY02/12
Cons.
9.6
38.1
4.1
88.6
3.9
94.5
32.2
FY02/13
Cons.
10.1
36.1
4.1
89.9
4.0
91.0
35.0
The company has typically been efficient with cash conversion. Total days in cash increased from FY02/08
through FY02/12 due to lower inventory turnover.
Other Information
History
October 1927.
March 1947.
October 1960.
July 1964.
September 1988.
January 1990.
May 2005.
September 2007.
October 2008.
October 2008.
December 2009.
April 2012.
Established as Kashiyama Shoten (Kashiyama Trading) in Osaka.
Company name changed to Kashiyama Kogyo (Kashiyama Co., Ltd.)
Listed on the 2nd Section of the Tokyo, Osaka and Nagoya Stock Exchange
Listed on the 1st Section of the Tokyo, Osaka and Nagoya Stock Exchange
Company Name changed to Onward Kashiyama Co., Ltd.
Acquired GIBO SA
Acquired UK fashion label JOSEPH
Established Onward Holdings Co., Ltd.
Acquired CREATIVE YOKO Co., Ltd.
Acquired Jil Sander S.p.A.
Acquired Island Co., Ltd.
Acquired Birz Association Co., Ltd.
“Kashiyama” comes from its founder Junzo Kashiyama, who initially worked as an unpaid apprentice for
Mitsukoshi kimono mercer (currently department store Mitsukoshi). In 1927, he set up his own apparel
company called Kashiyama Shoten. Shortly after the Second World War, the company started making and
selling ready-to-wear men’s suits. Women’s suits were added in 1960. The company grew together with
the Japanese economy and with fashion tastes (from tailored clothing to readymade). Onward has always
had a main focus on one business: fashion apparel, which has been key in establishing durable
relationships with department stores. In recent years Onward has heavily invested in overseas businesses
by acquiring international labels such as Joseph in 2005, and Jil Sander in 2008.
News & Topics
May 2012
On May 29, 2012, Onward Holdings issued a press release titled “Onward Holdings’ Approach to
Reduction of Minimum Trading Unit for Its Stock.”
59/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
According to the release, the company recognizes the importance of measures to maintain high liquidity
in stock trading, encourage long-term stock holdings, and expand shareholder base. In line with such
recognition, the company sees the reduction of stock trading unit as an effective measure. Accordingly,
the company maintained that it would continue to examine the feasibility of the measure with due
consideration given to the price of its stock, shareholder numbers and stock market trends.
March 2012
On March 16, 2012, the company announced that it would acquire all the shares in Birz Association Ltd.,
Birz Village Ltd. and NAIMA Ltd. (collectively referred to as Birz Group hereafter) on April 1, 2012.
Birz Group owns the brands Language, Smork by Language, Libre, AGOSTO and Ylang Ylang, which have
been focused on retailing at commercial buildings in train stations and fashion malls across Japan. The
group is particularly strong in using overseas production (such as through its factories in Vietnam etc.)
and has positioned itself as a vertically integrated, low cost producer of quality apparel.
Onward hoped it would be able to grow Birz Group’s profitability by leveraging its own operational
infrastructure, knowhow and global network. In addition it noted the acquisition should help drive its
business expansion and reap operational synergies, such as through store locations, product procurement,
overseas factory utilization etc.
February 2012
On February 24, 2012, Onward’s subsidiary Jil Sander Italia SPA announced that its brand founder, Jil
Sander, had returned to the company as creative director.
August 2011
On August 26, 2011, the company announced that its board had passed a resolution to change its
president and directors.
The changes were as follows (effective as of September 1, 2011):
Onward Holdings Co.:
 Takeshi Hirouchi—New Position: Chairman and President; current position: Chairman
 Kentaro Mizuno—New Position: Vice Chairman; current position: President
 Kazuya Baba—New Position: Executive Vice President; current position: Vice President
Onward Kashiyama Co.:
 Akinori Baba—New Position: Representative Director and President; current position: Managing
Executive Director
 Kentaro Mizuno—to step down from current position as Representative Director and President
 Kazuya Baba—to step down from current position as Senior Executive Vice President
The company said it was implementing the new management structure as part of its strategy to promote
its global growth. For further details on Onward Kashiyama’s new president please refer to the Top
Management section.
March 2011
On March 16, 2011, the company made an announcement regarding the March 11 Tohoku earthquake.
Damage situation report:
60/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
 A portion of the company’s plants and sales floors sustained damage to their buildings, and some
merchandise fell to the floor and was soiled or otherwise damaged.
 Some areas in Japan were lacking essential utilities, especially in Tohoku (northeastern Japan). The
company didn’t announce plans for refurbishing and reopening affected sales floors, and had
temporarily closed or shortened operating hours of others.
April 2010
On April 12, 2010, the Jil Sander Group announced the launch of a new line called Jil Sander Navy, an
important strategic step in development of the Jil Sander brand.
Jil Sander Navy is an extension of the core Jil Sander brand seeking to approach new types of customers
and expand the appeal for the existing customers by emphasizing sports casual elements and lower price
points.
Characterized by pure and simple line and ease of wear, the product range includes core outerwear, light
jersey, and easy-to-wear knitwear as well as a line of accessories such as handbags, footwear and belts.
The collection was shown on June 2010 and the sales are planned to start simultaneously worldwide in
2011 season. The emphasis of the launch is on the US and Japanese markets.
Top Management
Onward Holdings
Takeshi Hirouchi, representative director and chairman and president, was born in 1942 and joined the
company in 1965. He became director in 1985, managing director in 1991, senior managing director in
1994 and representative director and president in March 1997. He became representative director and
chairman in March 2005. Due to transition to a holding-company structure in September 2007, he became
chairman and CEO of Onward Holdings Co., Ltd. while continuing to serve as representative director,
chairman of newly established Onward Kashiyama Co., Ltd. Since September 2009 he has served as both
president and chairman of the company.
Onward Kashiyama
Akinori Baba, representative director and president, was born in 1968 and joined the company in 1990. In
2004 he became an executive officer at Onward Kashiyama and the division director of Nijyusanku and in
2005 a corporate executive officer at Onward Kashiyama and the division director of Nijyusanku and ICB.
In 2010 he became managing executive director of the ladies business, division director of Nijyusanku,
ICB, Jiyuku, and Kumikyoku. In September 2011 he gained the current posts while retaining his role as
division director.
Employees
Onward employed 3,993 full-time (11,824 part-time) employees as of FY02/12 on a consolidated basis.
There were 36 employees at the parent level: average age 45.3, with the company for 19.5 years, and
earning a salary of 9.6 million yen.
61/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Major Shareholders
Top Shareholders
Kashiyama Scholarship Foundation
Japan Trustee Services Bank, Ltd. (Trust account)
Nippon Life Insurance Company
The Master Trust Bank of Japan, Ltd. (Trust account)
Isetan Mitsukoshi Ltd.
The Dai-ichi Mutual Life Insurance Company, Ltd.
Japan Trustee Services Bank, Ltd. (Trust account 9G)
Onward Holdings Customers' Shareholding Association
MARUI GROUP CO., LTD.
Northern Trust Co. AVFC Re U.S. Tax Exempted Pension Funds
Amount
Held
5.03%
3.90%
3.60%
3.41%
2.89%
2.42%
2.26%
2.03%
1.97%
1.70%
(As of February 28, 2013)
Dividends
The company has a stated minimum 35% payout ratio, however the company also paid a dividend in
FY02/09 when EPS was negative.
Investor Relations
Result meetings are held in Tokyo after the announcement of interim and fiscal year end results. The
company maintains an IR website in both English and Japanese.
By The Way
The name Onward, added in 1962 was derived from a Christian hymn (“Onward Christian Soldiers”) that
Junzo Kashiyama, the founder, liked.
62/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
Company Profile
Company Name
Onward Holdings Co., Ltd.
Head Office
Toda Building 4th Floor
1-7-1 Kyobashi Chuo-ku
Tokyo, Japan 104-8329
Listed On
Phone
+81-3-4512-1020
Tokyo Stock Exchange 1st Section
Nagoya Stock Exchange 1st Section
Exchange Listing
October 2, 1961
Fiscal Year-End
February
IR Web
http://www.onward-hd.co.jp/site/english/ir/message.html
IR Phone
+81-3-4512-1051
Established
September 4, 1947
Website
http://www.onward-hd.co.jp/site/english/
IR Contact
IR Mail
Main Consolidated Segments (% of total sales)
Apparel-related
93.93 %
Others
6.07 %
(as of February 2013)
Directors
Takeshi Hirouchi,
Representative Director, Chairman, and President
Masaaki Yoshizawa, Managing Director
Kenichi Iizuka, Senior Corporate Director
Akinori Baba, Director
Hiroaki Yamada, Director
Hachiro Honjo, Director (Outside)
Yoshihide Nakamura, Director (Outside)
Hitoshi Aoyama, Full-time Corporate Auditor
Kenichiro Tamai, Full-time Corporate Auditor
Others
2 directors
(as of May 2013)
Employees (consol.)
Employees (parent)
Average age (parent)
Average salary (parent)
5,208
33
45.2 years
9.4 million yen
Shares Outstanding (including treasury shares)
172,922,000 shares
Shareholders Capital
30.1 billion yen
Main Subsidiaries
Onward Kashiyama Co., Ltd.
Onward Trading Co., Ltd.
Chacott Co., Ltd.
Creative Yoko Co., Ltd.
ISLAND, Co., Ltd.
Main Banks
Sumitomo Mitsui Banking Corp.
The Banking of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd.
Mizuho Bank, Ltd.
Auditors
Ernst & Young ShinNihon LLC
63/64
SR Research Report
2014/4/4
About Shared Research Inc.
We offer corporate clients comprehensive report coverage, a service that allows them to better inform investors and other stakeholders
by presenting a continuously updated third-party view of business fundamentals, independent of investment biases. Shared Research
can be found on the web at http://www.sharedresearch.jp.
Current Client Coverage of Shared Research Inc.:
Accretive Co., Ltd.
Fields Corp.
Onward Holdings Co., Inc.
AEON DELIGHT Co.
FreeBit Co., Ltd.
Panasonic Information Systems Co.
Ai Holdings Corp.
Gamecard-Joyco Holdings, Inc.
Paris Miki Holdings Inc.
Anritsu Corporation
GCA Savvian Corporation
Pigeon Corp.
Apamanshop Holdings Co., Ltd.
Grandy House Corp.
Resorttrust, Inc.
ArtSpark Holdings Inc.
Gulliver International Co., Ltd.
Round One Corp.
Axell Corporation
Happinet Corporation
Sanix Incorporated
BALS Corporation
Harmonic Drive Systems Inc.
Sanrio Co., Ltd.
Bell-Park Co., Ltd.
Infomart Corp.
SATO Holdings Corp.
Benefit One Inc.
Intelligent Wave Inc.
Ship Healthcare Holdings Inc.
Canon Marketing Japan Inc.
ITO EN, Ltd.
SMS Co., Ltd.
Chiome Bioscience Inc.
J Trust Co., Ltd
Star Mica Co., Ltd.
Chiyoda Co., Ltd.
Japan Best Rescue Co., Ltd.
Takashimaya Co., Ltd.
Comsys Holdings Corporation
JIN Co., Ltd.
Takihyo Co., Ltd.
Creek & River Co., Ltd.
Kenedix, Inc.
Tamagawa Holdings Co., Ltd
Daiseki Corp.
Lasertec Corp.
3-D Matrix, Ltd.
DIC Corporation
MAC-HOUSE Co.
TOKAI Holdings Corp.
Digital Garage Inc.
Medinet Co., Ltd.
Verite Co., Ltd.
Don Quijote Co., Ltd.
MIRAIT Holdings Corp.
WirelessGate, Inc.
Dream Incubator Inc.
mobcast inc.
Yellow Hat Ltd.
Elecom Co.
NAIGAI TRANS LINE LTD.
Yumeshin Holdings
EMERGENCY ASSISTANCE JAPAN Co.
NanoCarrier Ltd.
ZAPPALLAS, INC.
en-Japan Inc.
Nippon Parking Development Co., Ltd.
FerroTec Corp.
NS Tool Co.
A ttention: If y ou w ould like to see firms y ou inv est in on this list, ask them to become our client, or sponsor a report y ourself.
Disclaimer
This document is provided for informational purposes only. No investment opinion or advice is provided, intended, or solicited. Shared
Research Inc. offers no warranty, either expressed or implied, regarding the veracity of data or interpretations of data included in this
report. Shared Research Inc. shall not be held responsible for any damage caused by the use of this report.
The copyright of this report and the rights regarding the creation and exploitation of the derivative work of this and other Shared
Research Reports belong to Shared Research Inc. This report may be reproduced or modified for personal use; distribution, transfer, or
other uses of this report are strictly prohibited and a violation of the copyright of this report. SR Inc. officers and employees may currently,
or in the future, have a position in securities of the companies mentioned in this report, which may affect this report’s objectivity.
Japanese Financial Instruments and Exchange Law (FIEL) Disclaimer
The report has been prepared by Shared Research Inc. (“SR”) under a contract with the company described in this report (“the
Company”). Opinions and views presented are SR’s where so stated. Such opinions and views attributed to the Company are
interpretations made by SR. SR represents that if this report is deemed to include an opinion by SR that could influence investment
decisions in the Company, such opinion may be in exchange for consideration or promise of consideration from the Company to SR.
Contact Details
http://www.sharedresearch.jp
Email: info@sharedresearch.jp
3-31-12 Sendagi
Bunkyo-ku Tokyo, Japan
Phone: +81 (0)3 5834-8787
64/64

Onward Holdings Co Ltd (8016)

Transcription

Similar documents

スライド 1

Kato Sangyo Co.,Ltd Company Profile 2012.11

English - BEENOS株式会社

Tax-Free Shopping

6-7

Kakaku.com

12 Vol. 28 Net One Systems Co., Ltd.

Enjoy Eco Card