tlqEt i\x/q/t

erq-r
fw"arfrrorfr Hierr{ qi+ qrqrf,qrd.
R
qr$rq qT(q,
r . q-atq nqtiq rsit+t,
x. qruqrt {qziq ui}frT, L\. q€ pwp tig.161,
vd n. gxqnl rardrfl stqTaqrsl, f,r.qrdifl{s
r . y-qlur
1
Q-
.
t
3rR-8\'€ erqtd*'. 3o/oY
qffi
{Tq.iq
lqiifr{,
eiiio qrium"qrqq
fu'a=t(
q.
'- nr 3Tfr-dTrfi
q{id rilfu.q e.i}*a,{r.$Tqnl, stqlacil-s}, 61.q6frlgg
(q{f,{rqqdt{Ff,
qTqTfiTd-s-#+eri{
rriqrd qiq
nrq-si
I-E;FR
qraRr{g
tlqEt
^{rf,
?\x/t/q
oTfrTFrqq qqqe
*s-"Tq rx\e erq-+)
frqrf,[d
qidt.elTi
o.(a
i\x/q/t
o.Yo
q.Bqfurilrflq arftronl qd{K qi-S Gil{8\r{T BrqhiT tnq'if, ttu/otr
R€T
elrtqTrfrdq
3Tfuan
fr
q-dnT 'rilTqTq. qrEq
qti t-** lqiqiloox rtql
qiqt l1q_ili BrqtiT
qT
qr.ileFlrfl qrqi{
Ad
stTa
?.
q&-mT?fi
qtqT
o
qi*
EqTquA{Ta}
x/q?/?
o
?. q-qil
tx
nGft
qrs"f, At+dT srqlo qr
ftq'lf,r€Idt
Eiq
q oy/q?/Roq,x lts1 Eilq"ft
t qi gqT-d"frqT iTR{qtqT ,kdq{ {t-dd. ffi
qfUeTrfi BqRrd qq@d
e iqiql errrrf,r gEf,-qrE fr ql qffiaqrq {re{
zrsri enqq{+.
l-ilnrd
sTfo-dTrfi{
!cn-{o-i
He;
ArqT(
3n--d1
Errs q{-iqri kqq
Ad"mT qT6}. qT sKUrR.rc{
xtq-d-i eqtf, e'rd{
Tffmq:fr,
"ArR
qrq futT{
erws emremrsncrd ,{qu} qI{{
3ne.
x. qT. gqtqqrqreq,
e
wuqrf, srd.
Roiqt/Roqx,?rg/1q/Roty
srtfl-q}ytrfr {-fr if're
ti
BTnr,aurd erri;. eriqorfi
ftne{ +ikT qT-fl Hii rqii Eqni qisuqrwfr Hqt n{q
!-fl"ft k{io-
dr{qt 3lfudirfi
flqiiaqtrf,
1963 SUPREME COURT 146(1) (V 50 C 14)
(From Madhya Bl.rarat :Madh BLJ l955 H.C.R. 568 ) 2'd May, 1962
J.L.Kapur, K.C.DAs GUPTA AND RAGHUBAR DAYAL,.IJ.
CivilappealNo. 469 of 1960, Dl2-5-1962.
Thakur Sukhpal Singh, Appellant v.Thal<Lrr Kalyan Singh ancl arrorlrer, Itesponclepts.
qr fusrf,[drf, qtq Art qTt
clppelhte eauxr i4 ftit aurut t{L furid> an appea!. on
o& 4erad, ufrpn tfro appel.hnt appeq,,Lt qt tfiL frpnxirry Ail
Jt cqn aiomiab tfrz oppeal. l; cbt urlr" ( {trcvtn s 16,20 )
"1fr.e,
"-t,
tme mr@iol.
mzxit'| on tfre eooio
"f,
dnos nnt adlxp,tb tfrn ulut.
Jt i'r tfie d"t* ,l- tfrz appeManr tu r(wut tfist tfie ,jurksnwi. u.ttt{cr. appec(. i,t eua*eowo
cettan
fu
'tPlt4ota and it Lt *r{r* a{tsL ru cvppeU.ant frrw o{ur*rt t{tb t{tcrt t{w cvppel.kie
esad ' uould cnl!. wpan tfie, raryatul.ent to *pW ta tfie canterttitrrt. Jt a an{rp tfien tfre tfrat
tfra 'iunrln&.flta{ tfre appellnte eruatt ccut
{uilt* contah. aW tlle uuxktta tt* mz.nlianed, in
^
5l'31.0- 41. q. tfu appe%mt oufimil,s ruarfury
{t't itr catukloution, tfiz appellnrn Q.ou,tt catt
dzridg tfu
uitfrnut qtul uek/ffirz ta aruy pznrnedfuuy o4 tfrn eautt i.lo*. emd, in claing
"pp*l,
oo, it crut sunph* my tfrat tlle appelLuia frsaa rut wrgcc{, cgu,fftin{t. wfiicft wautd
terul ta
ofrua tfrat tfrn.iulgmmr Mul deruz wulen uppeal, (aene u,{tttt." ( i'u,rrr', !;,s
),,
rqil 3r+dTd qrfr qiqt sTrml gqdqrq qr qFilFFn€ HrEr +eT qT(,1. .Bqi+rrTmq
eTRmT"fr
qdq{ qiq} Brrrd\"s
srqhf,
sqi-f, t?s/o1 qtn oraaa
M
g*sH
s*
entd
t frtq
HuqrflTdl iqiqi slrraEt ddi roquvgBil-qrE qr qr{iloqrg qrq{ a,imT r-16}. erg} qr
€-ql'q qFllaril-4| fr.*req-*r.fro 'It can clismiss the appeal lor cle iault' q1 ffq{Ts Brtg{q
qq-d-+ Brqtf,flEqaffiu) anqrqm ent
\.
vqqqlc'mM
errirTi-d
eTi6.
3{rtYr
q. erfr-f, ftTq1 a.Fn-qTf,
R.
+d
eTrt.
qqfqrE-a eirtql.qrdn.
42,
i. fr-*ian-* qqq qzi {hift{diqi fuqrd qrq}.
B-srrT:- qtorTi
/qR/?"qx
ms:96'-
eTfr-flrefi E Efl{ipfi qiqT
q?r :-
ildisc,rfl{
qc{w
qrft-ffi
e
qrc{-{qcn
dr
*t)
ffiHTaT
qirT
HIE-dqT frsrdq-rTqT o* *alqto niq e;p-rp n-f,rts}qiA qr,ia rrfo-.ri?fi q
orfr-drfi
qiiT E-qq'ft m-oq iqii |Eqiis-d {EIeRti vfta6 gd-dT BTEqTm aTld
iq.{sin {ds]-d s]qiEqTs
ir
qr{{ m-{l-qt.
y6;- sq'1qqpflq 3TRrqrfr qd{W qiqT e-iffifl 3rR-E\rq 3rqfd .s-.
Rrs/oQ iilf,+ fiTrqq}
HR il6td. 1i:r+"raq**rqt gs' trf, qlfrnlrila E errqflq cF Hr qtdqrffi