Rape Princess Spy Pak

Transcription

Rape Princess Spy Pak
Rape
Epidemic
indian
Name of the Game
The
Oct.-Dec. 2014, Vol. 8 No.2
www.theindianamerican.com
Grace Srinivasan as
Noor in “Enemy of the
Reich: The Noor Inayat
Khan Story” conveys
the complex emotions
with a nuanced
understanding of the
young Sufi woman who
became a British spy
American
Princess Spy
Pak
Military
Culture
CHAIRMAN AND PUBLISHER
SUDHIR M. PARIKH, M.D.
PRESIDENT AND CEO
KRISHNA KUMAR
EDITOR
SUNIL ADAM
CONTRIBUTING WRITERS
JOANNE FLYNN BLACK * ASEEM CHHABRA * ELA DUTT
DEENA GUZDER * BHARGAVI KULKARNI
KAMALA MAHABIR * PAROMITA MUKHOPADHYAY
SHILPI PAUL * SWATHI REDDY * DANIELA RIBLE
VIJI SUNDARAM * VISI TILAK
LAYOUT & DESIGN
SUNIL ADAM * SHASHIKANT WARIK
NEW MEDIA CONSULTANT
VEERABADRA KUMAR
CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER
SHOMIK CHAUDHURI
DIRECTOR OF ADVERTISING
ILAYAS QURAISHI
SONIA LALWANI
MANOJ VYAS
SYED SHEERAZ MAHMOOD
EDITORIAL OFFICE
37 West 20th Street, #1009, NEW YORK, NY 10011
TEL: 212.675.7515
WEST COAST OFFICE
650 VERMONT AVE., SUITE 46, ANAHEIM, CA 92805
TEL. 661.468.3851
CHICAGO OFFICE
2652 W Devon Ave., Suite # B, Chicago, IL 60659
Ph:773.856.3345/0545/3445, Fax:773.856.3537
WEBSITE
WWW.THEINDIANAMERICAN.COM
The Indian American is published by
The Indian American, LLC.
Copyright 2011.
All rights reserved. No material herein or portions thereof
may be reprinted without the consent of the publisher.
The publisher assumes no responsibility for unsolicited
manuscripts, photographs or illustrations. Views and opinions
expressed in this publication are not necessarily in accordance
with the opinions and views of the magazine, its personnel, its
agents and no liability is assumed by the publisher thereof.
Advertising copy and artwork are the sole responsibility of the
advertiser. No warranties, guarantees or endorsements are
made by the publisher.
2 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
indian
The
Oct.-Dec. 2014, Vol. 8 No. 2
www.theindianamerican.com
News in Jpegs
American
Boys Will
Be Boys
The Princes Spy
Pakistan’s Dueling
Military Cultures
3 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Name of
the Game
JULY 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
A Muslim man prays before having his Iftar (breaking of fast) meal, during the holy fasting month of
Ramadan at the Jama Masjid (Grand Mosque) in the old quarters of Delhi July 1.
Left, Hindu priests sit in cauldrons of water and make offerings to in front of a fire while performing the “Parjanya Varun
Yagam”, a special prayer for rain, in the western Indian city of Ahmedabad July 1. India’s monsoon rainfall was 43 percent below average in June, the weather office said on July 1, the weakest first month of the season in five years. Right,
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi shakes hands with French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius (L) during a meeting at
his residence in New Delhi July 1. France has proposed to give India a 1 billion euro ($1.4 billion) credit line to fund sustainable infrastructure and urban development projects, Fabius said on July 1.
4 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
JULY 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
A man arranges strands of vermicelli, which are kept for drying at a factory in the northern Indian city of Allahabad July 1.
Vermicelli is a specialty that is eaten during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan.
U.S. Senator John McCain
waves to members of the
media after his meeting
with India's Foreign
Minister Sushma Swaraj in
New Delhi July 2. A visit to
India by McCain on July 2
was overshadowed by a row
over reports that the
National Security Agency
was authorized to spy on
Prime Minister Narendra
Modi's Bharatiya Janata
Party in 2010.
Facebook's Chief Operating Officer (COO) Sheryl
Sandberg attends an interactive session organized
by the ladies' wing of industry lobby group
Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and
Industry (FICCI) in New Delhi July 2.
5 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
JULY 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
A Shi'ite Muslim girl takes part in a candlelight protest against the
ongoing conflict in Iraq, in New Delhi July 3. Nearly 50 Indian nurses
from the southern state of Kerala have been taken against their will
from a hospital in the militant-controlled city of Tikrit in Iraq,
India's Foreign Ministry said on July 3.
6 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
JULY 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
A laborer prepares to unload sacks of potatoes from a truck at a wholesale vegetable and fruit market in New Delhi July 2.
Left. India's Finance and Defense Minister Arun Jaitley attends a meeting with the finance ministers of Indian states on
the Goods and Services Tax (GST) issues in New Delhi July 3. Right, An Indian nurse (L), one of a group of nurses caught
up in fighting in Iraq, holds flowers upon her arrival at the airport in the southern Indian city of Kochi July 5. The group
of 46 nurses who had been holed up in a hospital in the Iraqi city of Tikrit arrived home in India on Saturday after briefly
being held captive by suspected militants, an outcome celebrated by the newly elected government in New Delhi as an
early diplomatic success.
7 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
JULY 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
India's state government officials and policemen stand next to the bodies of construction workers near the site of a
collapsed compound wall of a warehouse on the outskirts of the southern Indian city of Chennai July 6. Eleven builders
were crushed under a warehouse wall in Tamil Nadu on July 6, barely a week after the collapse of an eleven storey building killed some 60 people in the same state. Below, rescue workers clear debris from the site of a collapsed compound
wall of a warehouse on the outskirts of the southern Indian city of Chennai July 6.
8 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
July 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Passengers travel on an overcrowded train at Loni town in the northern Indian state of Uttar Pradesh July 8.
India's Railway Minister Sadananda Gowda
arrives to present the railway budget for the
2014/15 fiscal year, at the parliament in
New Delhi July 8. On July 8, Indian Prime
Minister Narendra Modi's new government
will unveil its maiden railways budget, with
expectations high that he will offer bold
plans to improve the service - a lifeline for
23 million Indians every day.
9 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
JULY 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
A demonstrator shouts slogans during a
protest in the southern Indian city of
Bangalore July 19. Hundreds of demonstrators on July 19 held a protest rally
demanding justice after a 6-year-old student was allegedly raped by two staff
members within a school's premises in
the city on July 2, the demonstrators
said.
A devotee performs as she
takes part in the annual Hindu
religious festival of "Bonalu" in
the southern Indian city of
Hyderabad July 20. The word
"Bonalu" is derived from the
Telugu word "Bhojanalu",
which refers to the food
offered to Goddess Kali, the
Hindu goddess of power
A father, center, and his two sons have
their heads shaven as part of a ritual
after what they say was fulfilment of
their wishes during the Aadi Krithigai
festival celebrations at a temple in the
southern Indian city of Chennai July 21.
During the festival, Hindu women also
fast for the whole day in hope of winning
the favor of Lord Muruga.
10 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
JULY 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Two boys push a motor
bike through a flooded
street after heavy rains in
the western Indian city of
Ahmedabad July 24.
India's monsoon rains
were 24 percent above
average in the week ended
July 23, the weather office
said on Thursday, the first
week of surplus rainfall
during this year's
monsoon season.
A man carrying his child
on his shoulders wades
through a flooded street
after heavy rains in the
western Indian city of
Ahmedabad July 24.
11 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
july 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Relatives wail as people crowd at the site of a collision between a train and a school bus in Medak district in the southern
Indian state of Telangana July 24. A train slammed into a school bus in southern India on July 24, killing at least
19 children and the driver, police said. The bus crossed a railway track at an unmanned crossing in Medak district
without stopping to check if the way was clear, said Indian Railways spokesman Anil Kumar Saxena
Devotees with their mouths pierced with tridents participate in a ritual to worship the Hindu goddess Durga during Aadi
festival celebrations in the southern Indian city of Chennai July 27. During the festival, Hindu women also fast for the
whole day in hopes of winning the favor of Durga.
12 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
JULY 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Onlookers stand at the crash site of an Advanced Light Helicopter of the Indian Air Force (IAF) at Sitapur
district in the northern Indian state of Uttar Pradesh July 25. A total of seven Air Warriors, including two pilots,
were on board and there are believed to be no survivors, IAF said on July 25.
Left, muslims offer prayers at the Jama Masjid (Grand Mosque) on the occasion of Eid al-Fitr in the old quarters of Delhi
July 29. The Eid al-Fitr festival marks the end of the holy month of Ramadan. Right, pigeons eat grains from stacked
sacks at the Agricultural Produce Market Committee (APMC) market yard, on the outskirts of the western Indian city of
Ahmedabad July 29. India threatened to block a worldwide reform of customs rules last week, saying it wants an agreement on food subsidies and stockholding to run parallel to the trade facilitation pact. With grain silos spilling over,
exports on the rise and an avowed market champion for prime minister, New Delhi's threat to trash the trade deal in the
name of food security and farm subsidies appears puzzling.
13 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
AUGUST
NEWS in JPEGS
A resident looks at the debris of her damaged house after a landslide at Malin village in the western Indian
state of Maharashtra July 30. Heavy rain triggered a landslide in India on July 30 burying up to 150 people
and rescuers were struggling through mud to try to reach them, a disaster official said.
Left, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry holds a meet and greet with staff of the U.S. Embassy in New Delhi Aug. 1. The
visit by Kerry to India is his first following the resounding election win by Modi in May. Right, Kerry (L) shakes hands
with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the Prime Minister's residence in New Delhi August 1.
14 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
AUGUST 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Kanwarias or devotees of Hindu god
Lord Shiva walk through the banks
after filling their pots with the water
from the river Ganga in the
northern Indian city of Allahabad
Aug. 4. Hundreds of the Kanwarias
carry holy water from the Ganga to
their hometowns to be offered to
Shivling (a symbol of Lord Shiva).
A student participates in a peace rally to commemorate the 69th anniversary of the atomic bombings
of the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, in Mumbai Aug. 6.
15 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
AUGUST 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Vendors sit at a flower market in the southern Indian city of Bangalore Aug. 7.
Above, an artisan works on an idol of Hindu Lord
Krishna ahead of the Janmashtami festival in the
southern Indian city of Chennai Aug.t 7. The festival,
which marks the birth anniversary of Lord Krishna,
will be celebrated across India on Aug. 18. An artisan
works on an idol of Hindu elephant god Ganesh, the
deity of prosperity, at a workshop in the southern
Indian city of Chennai Aug. 7. Idols of Ganesh are
made two to three months before Ganesh Chaturthi, a
popular religious festival in India.
16 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
AUGUST 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
U.S. Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel, center, inspects a guard of honor during his ceremonial reception in New Delhi
Aug. 8. India has offered to significantly increase an order for U.S. attack helicopters, Indian officials said, as
Hagel began a visit to New Delhi on Thursday aimed at boosting defense and strategic ties.
A view of a flooded road on the banks of river Ganga after heavy monsoon rains
in the northern Indian city of Allahabad Aug. 9.
17 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
AUGUST 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Left, schoolgirls tie "Rakhis" or traditional Indian sacred threads onto the wrists of Indian police personnel inside a police
station on the eve of Raksha Bandhan festival in the western Indian city of Ahmedabad Aug. 9. Rakhi is also the name of
a Hindu festival, also known as Raksha Bandhan, during which a sister ties one or more of the sacred threads onto her
brother's wrist to ask him for her protection.Right, a woman shops at a stall selling Rakhis, traditional Indian sacred
threads, at a market in the northern Indian city of Chandigarh Aug. 9.
Brahmins, or upper-caste Hindus,
hold "Janeu" (sacred thread), also
called "Yagnopavit", as they
perform prayers at a temple on
the occasion of the Raksha
Bandhan festival in the western
Indian city of Ahmedabad Aug.
10. Raksha Bandhan, an annual
Hindu festival celebrating the
bond between sisters and
brothers, is being celebrated
across the country on Aug. 10.
A Hindu devotee gets his cheeks
pierced as he takes part in an
annual religious procession called
"Shitla Mata" in the northern
Indian city of Chandigarh
Aug. 10. Hindu devotees subject
themselves to painful rituals
during the religious procession to
demonstrate their faith and as a
penance to the deity at a temple
dedicated to the goddess Shitla.
18 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
AUGUST 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Female personnel
of India's Border
Security Force (BSF)
patrol along the
fencing of the
India-Bangladesh
international
border ahead of
India's
Independence Day
celebrations, at
Dhanpur village in
India's northeastern
state of Tripura
Aug. 11. India
commemorates its
Independence Day
on August 15.
A girl practices with a rifle during
weapons training course at the firing range
of the police headquarters in the western
Indian city of Ahmedabad Aug. 12.
Thousands of girls across Gujarat state
are participating in the fifteen-day self
defense training programmes jointly
organized by the police and the state
government of Gujarat, a police media
release said.
Real estate
developer Donald
Trump speaks
during a news
conference to
announce his first
project in Mumbai
Aug. 12. Trump is
planning
"substantial
investments" in the
Indian property and
hotel sectors,
betting on Prime
Minister Narendra
Modi-led new
government's
efforts to revive the
economic growth
and boost
infrastructure.
Forest officials prepare a pyre for a dead male leopard at
Jorhat in the northeastern Indian state of Assam Aug.
11. A local forest official said a group of tea workers
killed the leopard on Sunday after it had attacked them,
injuring four people.
19 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
AUGUST 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Above, kites dot the sky during India's
Independence Day celebrations in the old
quarters of Delhi Aug. 15. Left, Indian Prime
Minister Narendra Modi addresses the nation
from the historic Red Fort during
Independence Day celebrations in Delhi
Aug.15. Below left, school students hold a
200-meter-long Indian national flag during
India's Independence Day celebrations in the
southern Indian city of Chennai Aug. 13.
Below right, college students with painted
faces pose for a picture as they take part in
India's Independence Day celebrations in the
southern Indian city of Chennai Aug. 13.
20 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
AUGUST 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Above, devotees try to form a human pyramid to break a clay
pot containing curd during the celebrations to mark the
Hindu festival of Janmashtami in Mumbai Aug. 18.
Janmashtami, which marks the birthday of Hindu god
Krishna, is being celebrated across the country today. Left,
an Indian artist dressed as Hindu Lord Krishna takes part in
a play during celebrations to mark Janmashtami festival in
New Delhi Aug. 18. Below, students hold an idol of Hindu
Lord Krishna during the celebrations to mark Janmashtami
festival inside a school in the western Indian city of
Ahmedabad Aug. 16.
21 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
AUGUST 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Boys run carrying chickens
after a truck transporting the
poultry was set on fire during
a protest at Golaghat district
in the northeastern Indian
state of Assam Aug. 20.
Thousands of protesters in
the far-flung Indian state of
Assam defied a curfew and
attacked police in a fifth day
of unrest over a territorial
dispute with a neighboring
state.
Villagers move with
their belongings to safer
places in a boat through
the flooded areas of
Morigaon district in the
northeastern Indian
state of Assam Aug. 24.
The latest heavy rains
have caused landslides
and floods in many parts
of India and Nepal.
Left, Britain's Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg holds a 'Kirpan', a Sikh religious sword presented to him by the
Gurudwara authorities during his visit to a Gurudwara (Sikh temple) in New Delhi Aug. 25. Clegg is on a three-day visit
to India. Right, rabbi looks at the ceiling of room during the reopening ceremony of Nariman House, which was damaged
during the November 2008 attacks in Mumbai Aug 26.
22 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
AUGUST 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Above, a devotee immerses
an idol of the Hindu elephant
god Ganesh, the deity of
prosperity, in an artificial
pond during the ten-day-long
Ganesh Chaturthi festival in
Mumbai Aug. 30. Ganesh
idols are taken through the
streets in a procession
accompanied by dancing and
singing, and later immersed
in a river or the sea symbolizing a ritual seeing-off of his
journey towards his abode,
taking away with him the
misfortunes of all mankind.
Left, Devotees carry an idol
of Hindu elephant god
Ganesh, the deity of prosperity, during a procession
through the streets before
immersing it in the waters of
the Arabian Sea on the last
day of the Ganesh Chaturthi
festival in Mumbai Sept 8.
A devotee, center,
cries as others prepare
to immerse an idol of
Hindu god Ganesh,
the deity of prosperity,
on the banks of the
river Yamuna in New
Delhi Sept. 8.
23 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
A man chips out the cross
from the entrance of his
house after taking part in a
religion conversion ceremony
from Christianity to
Hinduism at Hasayan town in
the northern Indian state of
Uttar Pradesh Aug. 29.
People take part in a religion
conversion ceremony from
Christianity to Hinduism at
Hasayan town in the
northern Indian state of
Uttar Pradesh Aug. 29.
Australia's Prime Minister Tony
Abbott waves to his Indian
counterpart Narendra Modi,
right, after his ceremonial
reception at the forecourt of
India's presidential palace
Rashtrapati Bhavan in New
Delhi Sept. 5.
24 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Performers painted to look like tigers dance during festivities marking the end of the annual harvest festival of Onam in
Trichur city in the southern Indian state of Kerala Sept. 10. The ten-day long festival is celebrated annually in India's
southern coastal state of Kerala to symbolize the return of King Mahabali to meet his subjects.
25 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
An aerial view taken from an Indian Air Force helicopter shows the flooded Srinagar city, Sept. 11. Authorities in Kashmir
collected the bodies of women and children floating in the streets on Thursday as anger mounted over what
many survivors said was a bungled operation to help those caught in the region's worst flooding in 50 years.
26 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
China's President Xi
Jinping's wife Peng
Liyuan watches folk
artists perform during
her visit to the
Sabarmati river front in
the western Indian city
of Ahmedabad Sept. 17.
China's President Xi Jinping,
center, holds an umbrella as
he watches folk artists
perform while visiting the
Sabarmati river front along
with India's Prime Minister
Narendra Modi (2nd L) in the
western Indian city of
Ahmedabad Sept. 17. Xi
arrived in India as the two
Asian giants take steps to
boost commercial ties. China
has pledged to invest billions
of dollars in Indian railways,
industrial parks and roads,
but ties between the
nuclear-armed nations have
long been held back by
distrust, mostly over their
contested border.
27 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
September 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Women dressed in traditional attire pose as they take part in
rehearsals for the "garba" dance ahead of Navratri festival in the
western Indian city of Ahmedabad Sept. 21. Right, Ram Singh
Chauhan, 62, shows his moustache, which he claims to be 5.4
meters (18 ft) long, during a ceremony in the western Indian
city of Ahmedabad Sept. 24. Chauhan, who holds the Guinness
World Record for the longest moustache, claims he has not
trimmed it since the age of 17.
Folk dancers perform Dandiya, a traditional dance, during a rehearsal ahead of
Navratri festival in the western Indian city of Ahmedabad Sept. 24
28 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
Mohammed Jaffer-SnapsIndia
NEWS in JPEGS
Jay mandal/On Assignment
Mohammed Jaffer-SnapsIndia
Above, Prime Minister Narendra Modi arrives in New York for the 69th session of the United Nations General Assembly. Modi was received by
India's Ambassador to the U.S. Subrahmanyam Jaishankar and his wife
Kyoko, India's Ambassador to the United Nations Asoke Mukerji, and
Consul General of India in New York Dnanyeshwar Mulay and their
wives at the John F. Kennedy International Airport Sept. 26. Below,
Prime Minister Modi greets a large number of Indians who had gathered
outside his hotel to welcome him.
29 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Mohammed Jaffer/SnapsIndia
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi
addresses the 69th United Nations General
Assembly at the U.N. headquarters in New
York Sept. 27.
India's Prime Minster Narendra Modi lays
a yellow rose on the name of an Indian at
the site of the 9/11 Memorial in the lower
Manhattan borough of New York Sept. 27.
30 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
India's Prime Minster
Narendra Modi appears on
screen as he speaks on
stage during the Global
Citizen Festival concert in
Central Park in New York
Sept. 27.
Reuters
Modi, left, holds hands
with actor Hugh Jackman
on stage during the Global
Citizen Festival concert in
Central Park in New York
Sept. 27.
31 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
Mohammed Jaffer/SnapsIndia
NEWS in JPEGS
Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses Indian-Americans at New York’s Madison Square Garden on Sept. 28.
32 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Right, a supporter holds up U.S. and
Indian national flags as he assembles
with a large crowd of people in Times
Square to watch the speech by
India's Prime Minister Narendra
Modi simulcast on a giant screen in
New York Sept. 28.
33 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
Mohammed Jaffer/SnapsIndia
NEWS in JPEGS
Jay Mandal/On Assignment
Above, Hillary Clinton hugs Foreign Minister Sushma
Swaraj, as Bill Clinton greets Modi during their meeting in
New York on Sept. 28. Left, Dr. Sudhir M. Parikh, publisher
of Desi Talk, greeting Prime Minister Narendra Modi
at a dinner reception hosted by India’s Ambassador to the
U.S. Subrahmanyam Jaishankar at the Taj Pierre in New
York on Sept. 28. While the two also met at the
dinner, this photo was taken when Dr. Parikh called on the
Prime Minister at the New York Palace Hotel on Sept. 27.
Below, Modi speaks at the Council on Foreign Relations in
New York on Sept. 29.
34 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Modi meets New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie in New York on Sept. 27.
Left, Modi meets New York Mayor Bill de Blasio on Sept. 26. Right, Modi with former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg.
35 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Governor’s Office/Tim Larsen
SEPTEMBER 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
SEPTEMBER 2014
PIB
NEWS in JPEGS
Left, Modi meets Secretary of State John Kerry at a private dinner hosted by President Obama in his
honor at the White House on Sept. 30. Right, Modi at the Sept. 30 private dinner.
Below, Modi with South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley in New York on Sept. 28.
36 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
SEPTEMBER 2014
NEWS in JPEGS
Obama and Modi walk at
the National Martin Luther
King Memorial on the
National Mall in
Washington on Sept. 30.
Reuters
Obama and Modi talk at
the National Martin
Luther King Memorial on
the National Mall in
Washington Sept. 30.
37 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
T
Princess
Spy
Cover Story
By Ela Dutt
Grace Srinivasan as Noor in
“Enemy of the Reich: The
Noor Inayat Khan Story”
conveys the complex emotions
with a nuanced understanding
of the young Sufi woman who
became a British spy
he hour-long docudrama “Enemy of the
Reich: The Noor Inayat
Khan Story” premiered
on television on PBS
this Sept. 9. The young
“matahari” was Noor
Inayat Khan, (1914-1943) an
Indian-American British spy during
the Nazi invasion of Europe, is
already famous in the United
Kingdom. Now she’s been introduced to American audiences. Unity
Productions Foundation, a nonprofit documentary company,
recruited a novice to do the part of
the brave British secret agent of
Indian-American descent. It was
pure coincidence and perhaps the
stars aligned to make it happen,
Grace Srinivasan, 23, a music student at Baltimore’s Peabody
Conservatory tells Desi Talk.
The docudrama has aired in
numerous theaters since February.
Srinivasan attended two of the
showings, one in Washington, D.C.
and the other in New Jersey.
“Both shows were sold out. And
the audience was so enthusiastic. It
was very surreal – people coming to
ask for my autograph!” Srinivasan
recalls. Her interview is marked by
a similar forthrightness.
Different Centuries,
Different Backgrounds
Alex Kronemer, the executive
producer of the show says
Srinivasan embodied the spirit of
Noor – that subtle mix of toughness
and gentleness, apart from the
same ethnicity – an Indian father
and a Caucasian mother. That’s
38 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
where the likeness ends. One hundred years ago Noor was born in
Moscow to a Sufi Muslim father
from India, and a white American
mother. She was brought up in
France in a Sufi school run by her
father. She also attended Sorbonne
University, and was a children’s
writer. Then they moved to
England, lived through World War
II, and she became a spy and secret
agent for the British secret service,
went behind enemy lines, was
betrayed by Nazi collaborators, was
caught but escaped
twice from her captors while imprisoned in Paris and
refused to reveal
the names of her
collaborators
despite being tortured.
She was
finally executed at the infamous Dachau
concentration camp in Germany.
Noor was the first woman
radio/wireless operator to be sent
into Nazi-occupied Paris; she was
the longest survivor in that role – a
record 3 months according to a
biographer, and 4 months according to the PBS website, more than
any man had ever survived in that
role.
Shrabani Basu, author of
Princess Spy, the definitive biography on Noor published in
2006, says witnesses corroborated that Noor’s last word before
dying was “Liberte.”
39 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Compare that to the life of Srinivasan who
has not seen any conflict at close quarters.
She was born in Washington, D.C., to
Suresh Srinivasan, a graduate of the Indian
Institute of Technology, Delhi, of Tamil
descent; and mother Nancy Hanna of suburban Pittsburgh. Both parents are into
numbers, dealing with math and statistics
who met while working at NASA in
Greenbelt, Maryland.
Grace Srinivasan grew up in Silver Spring,
Maryland, was home-schooled because of
her rigorous ballet schedule, and went to
George Washington University where she
did music but also math, science and biolo-
gy. She hopes to make classical singing her
career. She does not have the same exposure to Indian culture that Noor had,
though she did go to India once when she
was 17 and relatives from India visit occasionally.
India in Her Life
Her grandfather is still in India and family from India does visit occasionally,
Srinivasan says, but, “My Dad didn’t teach
40 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
me Tamil,” though relatives
all speak in Tamil when they
call from India or visit her
home, and she admits, “I do
have a language barrier.”
She is a lifelong vegetarian
as both her parents are. “My
mom was a vegetarian even
before she met Dad,”
Srinivasan says. She loves
Indian food.
Unlike Noor’s family,
Srinivasan has a secular
background. But she sings
in a Catholic church, St.
Stephen Martyr in
Washington, D.C., on weekends to make some money.
“It’s my job. I’m very lucky,”
she says.
“I’m not religious, my Dad
was not religious, and our
family isn’t. But I do want to
“Noor was
really connected
to all aspects of
her family. She
embraced all of
it. I realized I
hadn’t and
would like to be
more that way. I
don’t know how,
but I would love
to go back again
and explore the
country (India)”
explore religions –
Catholicism, Hinduism,
Buddhism – in my non-existent spare time,” she says.
However, some influence
in music must have seeped
in as evident from
Srinivasan’s career choices.
“My Dad plays Carnatic
music on the violin – so that
was around me growing up,”
she notes.
“But I’m really close to my
Mom’s family,” she admits.
Her mother has always
worked from home while
Srinivasan was growing up
and still does, on issues
relating to health statistics.
Her father came to study
statistics and computer science from IIT, Delhi, and
worked with the National
41 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Institutes of Health and is
now with the Centers for
Disease Control in their statistics department.
Srinivasan has hardly seen
any Bollywood or Tollywood
movies and laughs at the
idea that she might in the
future be approached by
Indian film makers.
“I never really got into
Bollywood. I wish I had as a
kid, but no.” She loves
movies however, “Almost
everything – fantasy, period
drama, I’m all over the
map.”
She sees another plus to
being in this docudrama. “I
am getting more interested
in Indian culture now, and
this whole project renewed
my interest,” she told Desi
Talk. “Noor was really connected to all aspects of her
family. She embraced all of
it. I realized I hadn’t and
would like to be more that
way. I don’t know how, but I
would love to go back again
and explore the country
(India).”
Regarding a future in film,
Srinivasan is realistic. “If
there are any opportunities,
yes,” she says, “But it’s so
much about luck,” she adds.
As for Bollywood or
Tollywood, “I don’t know
42 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
enough to say what I would
do (if approached),” she says
frankly.
How She Got the Part
Regardless of the differences, Grace was the one
finally chosen from among
those selected by a
Baltimore casting agency
deputed for the task of finding a Noor and another 12
cast members for “Enemy of
the Reich” says Alex
Kronemer, executive producer of the docudrama.
While in her freshman year
at George Washington
University, Srinivasan had
signed up with a local casting agent in case there was
any opportunity for landing
a summer job.
That didn’t pan out. So
last year when she got a call
from the agent about some
company in Baltimore needing a half-Indian-half
Caucasian woman, she was
astonished at the chance. “I
didn’t know the story but I
went there and read the
script.”
A few days later they
called her to come back for a
second audition. That’s
when she got her act together as it were, read up on
Noor and got more into the
character, before she auditioned again.
“I was surprised when I
got the call next day for the
part. It was really, really
crazy.”
That Je Ne Sais Quoi
Not only did Noor happen
to have the same ethnicities
as Grace and the looks needed, but Grace also had the je
ne sais quoi, that indefinable
quality. “Grace kind of
inhabited the Noor from history – a combination of
somebody with incredible
courage but also extremely
vulnerable. Noor was petite
and her personality was
demure, yet when she took
on the challenge, she was
steely. Grace gives off similar vibes – a person who is
determined but also gives off
a sense of obvious vulnerability.”
So even though Srinivasan
had no acting experience,
Kronemer and Rob Gardner,
the producer and director,
took the risk because of that
something they saw in the
23-year old musician, the
grace in movement, the
nuanced approach.
“Another person had quite
a bit of experience, but at
the end of the day, actors
have to respond to direction,
and she seemed to have the
ability to respond to what
you were asking her to do
and do it,” Kronemer said.
It took ten days in June last
year to shoot the parts needed on two blocks of
Baltimore’s Mount Vernon
Square that mirrors the
streets of Paris. “All through
those 10 Days, Grace was
able to convey the nuanced
and complicated emotions.
So she has acting gifts. It
was the best choice,”
Kronemer says.
43 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
‘Boys Will Be Boys’
India
O
In India's largest state, a
misogynistic family-run
political dynasty wants to
pretend a rape epidemic
doesn't exist
By Ankita Rao and Vivekananda Nemana
n the morning of May 27, villagers in the Badaun district in India's Uttar Pradesh state found two teenage
girls, raped and murdered, hanging from a mango tree.
The girls had disappeared the night before, never
returning after wandering into the fields near their
home to go to the bathroom. The attack came days
before a series of brutal assaults across the state: Four
men gang-raped a 17-year-old girl, and another group
of men beat the mother of a different rape victim after
she refused to withdraw an official complaint. On May
30, reporters confronted chief minister Akhilesh Yadav
in the state capital of Lucknow about the recent wave
of sexual violence.
But the 41-year-old leader of India's most populous
and arguably most lawless state was unrepentant.
"Aren't you safe?" Yadav shot back, standing amid a
gaggle of microphones, his aides smirking behind him.
"You're not facing any danger, are you?"
The remarks were consistent with what has become a
disturbing party line. Yadav is one of the leading politicians in the Samajwadi Party ("Socialist Party"), a left44 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Two girls are seen
hanging from a tree in
a village in the northern
Indian state of Uttar
Pradesh on May 28,
2014, in this still image
taken from video.
leaning group that has built a reputation as one of the
most anti-women parties in the country. In April,
Yadav's father, party head and former Uttar Pradesh
chief minister Mulayam Singh Yadav, opposed capital
punishment for rape, citing that "boys will be boys ...
they make mistakes." Just days later, Abu Azmi, the
head of the party's Maharashtra state branch, argued
that if men were hanged for rape, then women should
be hanged for having premarital sex. In July, Mulayam
sparked controversy again by claiming that out of all
Indian states, Uttar Pradesh had the most people but
the fewest rapes – a blatant lie. (Reached through a
party spokesperson, Yadav and his father declined to
Demonstrators from All
India Democratic
Women's Association
(AIDWA) hold placards
and shout slogans during a protest against
the recent killings of
two teenage girls, in
New Delhi May 31.
45 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Onlookers stand at the
site where two teenage
girls, who were raped,
were hanged from a
tree at Budaun district
in the northern Indian
state of Uttar Pradesh
May 31.
comment.)
A combination of uneven development, a flawed judiciary, and systemic police corruption have made Uttar
Pradesh among the most difficult places to be a woman
in India. The state – with a population of roughly 200
million, enough to make it the fifth-largest country in
the world – reported over 32,500 incidents of genderbased crime in 2013, ranking second only to the admittedly less populated Andhra Pradesh. Of those, 3,000
were rapes – more than a 50 percent rise from the year
before, according to the Ministry of State for Home
Affairs, which oversees the national police service. Yet
these numbers don't tell the whole story; rape carries
India's Congress party
vice president Rahul
Gandhi, right,
accompanied by local
officials, visits the
house of one of the two
teenage girls, who
were raped and
hanged from a tree, at
Budaun district in the
northern Indian state of
Uttar Pradesh May 31.
46 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Supporters of Bharatiya
Janata Party (BJP) shout
slogans as police use a
water cannon to stop them
from moving towards the
office of Akhilesh Yadav,
the chief minister of the
northern Indian state of
Uttar Pradesh, during a
protest against recent rape
and hanging of two girls,
in Lucknow June 2.
significant stigma in India, and can often lead to abuse
directed towards the victim, causing sexual assault to
go widely underreported.
The scale of gender-based violence in Uttar Pradesh
is likely much worse than the already disturbing figures
suggest. That is not the way the party sees it, however.
"This whole thing about violence against women –this
is propaganda," Rajendra Chaudhary, a Samajwadi
Party cabinet minister and spokesman, told Foreign
Policy. "These incidents are unfortunate and we're trying to fix them, but this is a social problem. We can't
say that this is happening because of government."
Meanwhile, the Samajwadi Party has resisted efforts
to reform rape laws, refused to reserve a portion of
seats in its parliament for women, and opposed
The veiled mother of
one of the two teenage
girls, who were raped
and hanged from a
tree, weeps outside her
house at Budaun district in the northern
Indian state of Uttar
Pradesh May 31.
47 THE INDIAN AMERICAN JULY-SEPTEMBER 2014
increased penalties for sexual crimes after the nowinfamous 2012 Delhi gang rape, where a young woman
was brutally -- and fatally -- assaulted on a bus in the
capital. In Uttar Pradesh "violence against women,"
said activist Kavita Krishnan, who runs the All India
Progressive Women's Association, a women's rights
organization, "seems to be a feature of governance."
While the state's leaders have long presided over an
inept administration that enables widespread sexual
violence, the younger Yadav was supposed to be different. Australia-educated, well-spoken, and charismatic,
Yadav ran as a reformer who could fix Uttar Pradesh's
corrupt and sclerotic bureaucracy -- and, in turn, upend
the state institutions that had abetted impunity for
criminal perpetrators. But two years later, he has done
little to distinguish himself from the party's old guard;
sexual assault remains pervasive in his state. It's a
product of a systemic rape culture, according to
Krishnan, that very much still "flows from the top."
– Foreign Policy
Indian policemen show
two men (L and 2nd R),
who are accused of
gang raping and
hanging two girls, to
the media at Budaun
district in the northern
Indian state of Uttar
Pradesh May 30.
Onlookers look at the
body of a woman, hung
from a tree, in
Moradabad district in
the northern Indian
state of Uttar Pradesh
June 12.
48 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
NEWS INDIA
www.newsindiatimes.com
Published Weekly By Parikh Worldwide Media LLC, New York. Vol. XLV. No. 40 60 Cents Friday, Oct. 3, 2014
Great
Expectations
TIMES
Narendra Modi’s American Odyssey
PAGE 1
www.newsindiatimes.com
By Raza Rumi
Pakistan’s
Dueling Military
Cultures
P
akistan’s military
has been in the
global spotlight for
several decades.
Within the country,
it has shaped both
state and society,
including arbitrating key decisions -- from foreign policy to
economic management. A large
number of Pakistanis view it as
a “guardian” of the state. Yet,
scant scholarship exists on the
institution itself and the roles it
has played. Instead, hagiographical accounts from
Pakistani authors (mostly
retired military officers) and
media commentary that often
overlook the important questions dominate the discussion.
South Asia
Two new books published in
quick succession have expanded the debate and provide new
insights into the workings of
the Pakistani military. The first
is a provocative assessment by
Dr. C. Christine Fair entitled
Fighting to the End: The
Pakistan Army’s Way of War
and second is Aqil Shah’s indepth study, The Army and
Democracy: Military Politics in
Pakistan. Both books extend
the scope of research by relying
on the military’s own literature,
and by bringing to light lesserknown dimensions of the internal norms and processes that
determine its organizational
culture and outlook.
It is well-known that the
50 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Pakistani army soldiers direct Muslim Sunnis arriving to attend the funeral of fellow
Sunni who were killed in Friday’s sectarian clashes during a Muharram procession,
near Laiquat Bagh, Rawalpindi Nov. 17, 2013. Below, Paramilitary soldiers checks a
motorist along a street in a neighbourhood, after a gunfire attack on a security
academy run by the Airports Security Force (ASF) in Karachi June 10.
Pakistan Army has long viewed
itself as the arbiter of “national
interest.” The military gave
itself a preponderant role in
the running of the state and
exercises a veto power over the
nation’s security, foreign, and
economic policies. Fair’s book
examines the “strategic culture” of the institution and
how its culture evolved from
the conflict with Pakistan’s
powerful neighbor India,
transforming into a larger,
more defined viewpoint. The
eleven chapters of Fair’s book
probe into all the facets – genesis and evolution, ideology,
regional and global implications – of this strategic culture.
A state that views India as
“its eternal foe that not only
seeks to dominate Pakistan but
51 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
to destroy it” is the central argument
of the various materials that Fair relies
upon. However, Fair argues that this
fear is primarily an ideological tool
that enables the Army to position itself
as a defender of Pakistan’s “ideological
frontiers,” as defined by the twonation theory, and an “Islamic identity” vis-à-vis a “Hindu” India. The
Army takes its capability to mount a
challenge to India as its raison d’etre,
asserts Fair.
Fair also argues that seeking strategic parity with India has been an overriding policy goal within the
Pakistani
defense literature. She
makes a detailed
review of
Pakistan’s
relations with
the United States
and shows how the United
States, despite its historical assistance
to modernize the Pakistani Army, is
viewed as an unreliable ally. China, on
the other hand, gets a favorable position and is viewed a counterweight to
U.S. hegemony in the region.
Since the nuclearization of the subcontinent, Fair argues, Pakistan has
kept its nuclear doctrine flexible, managing to deter India from escalating
any conflict while drawing international actors like the United States into
various crises. The strategic assessment of the Army, as Fair elaborates,
is that Pakistan’s position as a nuclear
state restrains the United States from
completely abandoning the country.
Can this ingrained strategic worldview change? Fair is not hopeful. She
paints a dire picture and argues the
institution is “fundamentally unsatis52 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
A Pakistani soldier guards a road in Sadda, Kurram Agency, along the Afghan border July 6, 2010.
fied with the status quo,
desiring additional territory
even when it is not desired
for security.” In a striking
insight, she also challenges
the conventional wisdom
that democratization will
improve things. Fair says
the Army’s strategic culture
permeates Pakistan’s “civil
society, political culture and
bureaucracies.”
However, she does note a
change in recruitment patterns. In 1972, Army officers
came from only a few districts in Punjab and KhyberPakhtunkhwa provinces, but
by 2005, nearly all of the
districts in Pakistan were
sending officers. Fair’s
research shows that many of
these officers may not be
sharing the Punjabi-dominated Army’s core values
with the same intensity, and
shows the potential for
transformation.
Aqil Shah’s The Army and
Democracy is another
detailed review of the genesis and evolution of the
Pakistani Army’s institutional culture and world view.
The book shows that the
Army’s attitudes echo the
fears and dogma of
Pakistan’s early history.
Shah argues that the Army’s
dominant political role was
not inevitable, despite the
underdeveloped nature of
political institutions.
This is a major departure from earlier studies that cited
the overdeveloped nature of
colonial state.
Shah painstakingly traces
the anatomy of coups in
Pakistan and the underlying
belief systems that resulted
in the Army taking charge of
the country’s affairs. He
argues that national security
is perceived by the institution to be a “national interest” and this has thwarted
the evolution of political
institutions in Pakistan.
Yet Shah goes
beyond the view
that the military is driven
by its cor-
53 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
A Pakistani soldier oversees the incineration of hashish and betel nuts on International Day
against Drug Abuse and Illicit Trafficking in Karachi June 26.
porate interests. He elaborates, through a rich array of
literature and interviews,
that an adherence to institutional norms and “traditions
of tutelage” explains the military’s appropriation of the
chief defender role. The
“military mentality” (i.e. its
norms) informs its overarching role as the savior of last
resort. The use of archive
material and military documents makes Shah’s study a
rich source of global references on the Pakistani military’s dominance and how
its own pronouncements
reinforce its tutelary traditions. He also explores the
military’s socialization program and curricula, and discovers that apprehensions
about Indian designs to
harm Pakistan continue to
be a major theme in defense
instruction.
Shah also argues that the
existence of terrorist groups
and nuclear weapons on
Pakistani soil raise questions
about the viability of the
military’s conventional
world view. A close reading
of both Shah and Fair suggest that the Pakistani Army
may be taking huge risks
with long-term implications
for regional and international security to achieve short-
term parity with India.
Both books, however,
understate the public pronouncements of Pakistan’s
former military chief, Gen.
Ashfaq Parvez Kayani. Since
2011, and until his retirement in 2013, Kayani had
advanced the notion that
Pakistan’s real threats were
internal. There have been
some changes to the 2013
Green Book (a leading internal publication that collates
essays by serving officers),
that also express this idea,
along with the usual Indiacentric postulates. The troubled and asymmetrical relationship with the United
54 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
States, ironically, has played some role
in this shift; and the discovery of
Osama bin Laden in Abbottabad, and
the subsequent criticism of the Army,
made it, once again, look inwards.
A decade ago, more than 90 percent
of Pakistan’s military personnel and
assets were deployed to counter the
Indian threat. But a substantial number of these resources have been
diverted to Western borders; and the
rise of the Pakistani Taliban has provided a new challenge to the military
and its intelligence apparatus. Internal
security challenges have also compounded the emerging world view,
and the ongoing security operation in
North Waziristan – the third major
offensive in the last five years – indicates that there is a greater emphasis
on sorting out Pakistan’s internal
messes than on fighting a battle for
regional domination.
Whether the recent changes are lasting and will result in a revision of the
Army’s security doctrines or impact its
curricula and institutional culture are
open questions. There is increasing
pressure within Pakistan itself to
adopt a zero-tolerance policy for militancy. An important variable here
would the trajectory of democratization and how far the political elites are
willing to challenge the strategic culture that Fair has elaborately theorized in her book. Pakistan’s incumbent Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif has
already challenged the India-centric
security paradigm and this is one of
the reasons why he faces a rocky
future. The ongoing trials of former
president Pervez Musharraf -- which
would have been unthinkable a decade
ago – also indicate a subtle shift is
underway.
Both Fair’s and Shah’s books explain
why the civilian space in Pakistan is
limited and why Pakistan’s military
will likely enjoy many more years as
the nation’s ascendant political force.
The country’s activist judges and
media have expanded the discussion,
but it will take a decade or more for
this to result in a more rational balance of civil-military power in
Pakistan.
– Foreign Policy
55 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Name of the Game
India
Can TV, Bollywood and Big
Money Rescue Fading
Village Game of kabaddi?
By Rama Lakshmi
56 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
F
ourteen players stood in formation on both
sides of the starting line for their daily
evening practice of the muddy ancient Indian
game of kabaddi. They said a quick prayer at
the temple in the corner of the field, touched
their coach's feet and kissed the soil as they
waited for the opening whistle.
Bare-chested and barefoot, Kaptan Singh muttered
the words "kabaddi, kabaddi" menacingly under his
breath as he crossed the line into the opponents'
muddy turf in his village on the outskirts of New Delhi.
Singh, 25, is the "raider."
Dabang Delhi players
grab a Bengal Warriors
player during their
match in New Delhi.
57 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Tanwar Sports Club
members prepare the
kabaddi playing field.
Seven opponents, called "defenders," knit their hands and circle
Singh, ready to pounce. Singh's
mission is to touch one of them and
make it safely back to his side of the
field. As he inches close, one
defender roughly yanks Singh's leg,
and another pulls his arm. As Singh
flees, they chase and tackle him,
falling on top of each other in a big
pile. Singh is crushed in the sloshy,
rain-drenched mud.
Turbaned village spectators
cheered.
The renewed buzz over kabaddi
in small villages such as Dera is
part of a national revival of a rural
sport that until recently was slowly
fading into antiquity, overshadowed
by the country's craze for cricket,
rapid urbanization and affluence,
villagers say. The comeback kicked
off with the just-concluded sixweek professional kabaddi league, a
made-for-TV tournament replete
with thumping music, fancy lights,
58 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Sunil Tanwar holds on
tightly to an opponent,
No. 21, during a training
session.
A player tries to score a
point by tapping his opponent during the team’s
training session.
Bollywood stars, fashionistas and big money aimed at
recasting the rustic game for India's urban middle
classes.
"The boys have seen so many kabaddi champions on
TV last month that they now feel they too can be stars,"
said Bijender Tanwar, 38, a coach in Dera. "This was a
poor man's village game, wilting away in modern India.
It has got a new breath of life."
But reimagining kabaddi and fueling a cultural
revival of sorts was not easy. The game lacked media
attention, stadiums and even a formal vocabulary for
TV commentary.
"Kabaddi has deep roots and resonance, but the challenge was to present it for the urban middle-class
A kabaddi player’s mission is to touch a
defender and make it
safely back to his side
of the field.
59 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Bijender Tanwar, one of
the trainers of the
Tanwar Sports Club,
wrestles a younger
player to the ground
during a kabaddi training session in Dera,
India.
Indians as a style and attitude statement. To get them
to say 'Oh my god, kabaddi is actually quite cool,' " said
Uday Shankar, chief executive of Star India, the entertainment and sports network that is a division of 21st
Century Fox.
At the opening and the finals of the professional
kabaddi tournament, an Indian who's who — including
movie stars and the family of Mukesh Ambani, India's
richest businessman — turned out to cheer for their
favorite teams. They waved team flags, wore colorful
team T-shirts, took selfies with each other and tweeted.
The games generated more than 2 billion digital mentions. The razzamatazz in the matches was akin to the
NBA Finals.
Opening night drew 10 times the number of TV viewers as soccer's World Cup this year, making pro kabaddi
the second-biggest sport after cricket here, the channel
said. About 426 million people watched the games over
36 days.
Opponents wrestle on
the ground during a
training session.
60 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
A member of the
Tanwar Sports Club
checks the dimensions
of the playing field
before a training session in Dera
"This was possible only because there is now a new
self-confidence among Indians to explore what is in
their own back yard even as they chase what is cool
abroad," Shankar said.
The template for the kabaddi makeover was the fiveday gentleman's game of cricket that was turned into a
three-hour TV event a few years ago replete with dance
music, cheerleaders and celebrity team owners.
In Dera, the number of young children at kabaddi
practice has tripled since the TV league. And now, villagers have set themselves the goal of producing at least
four players for next year's pro kabaddi season.
"The pro kabaddi game drew such glamorous and
powerful people. The league players even got police
security as if they were VIPs," gushed Rohit Sharma,
23, a truck driver by night and kabaddi player by day.
"This makes us feel so important. Nobody bothered
about us until now. We were just dismissed as those
A few spectators watch
the members of the
Tanwar Sports Club’s
kabaddi team prepare
the playing field before
their training session in
Dera. In rural areas, the
game is played on
muddy turf.
61 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Sunil Tanwar, the team’s
captain, warms up.
Tanwar, 25, has been
playing kabaddi since he
was 9.
who play in the mud."
On television, the game looked a bit different.
TV kabaddi was played on the mat, and the men wore
shoes. The maximum weight is 190 pounds, slimmer
than the Dera players.
"After seeing that the TV event used mats, our local
politician has promised to buy us a mat too," said
Pappu Pehelwan, a muscular 38-year-old coach. "My
boys are saying, 'Give us a mat if you want our vote.' "
Players are enjoying the glamour but are also aware
that it is a mixed blessing.
"The TV commentary was a bit too dramatic," Singh
Tanwar Sports Club
Coach Krishna Kumar
Dagar instructs his
players.
62 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014
Bengal Warriors
players try to catch a
Dabang Delhi player,
No. 10, during a match
in New Delhi.
said.
"Hopefully, the glamour does not take away from the
purity of the game later," another player said.
Until now, Pehelwan said, the biggest wish of players
in Dera was to be picked by the government for a police
or railway job because of their talent. But now they are
also dreaming of TV fame and fortune.
"Kabaddi, the game of the soil, is making unexpected
heroes of the sons of soils," said an article in India
Today magazine about the impact of the new league.
Kabaddi was introduced in the Asian Games in 1990,
and India has won gold each time. Indian immigrants
in Britain and Canada also have organized kabaddi
tournaments in the past decade.
But the game remained largely ignored by urbanized
Indians.
In Dera, coaches reminisced about the game back in
their day. In the 1970s, the prize at a kabaddi match
was usually a vest and a wooden shield, they said. Then
it changed to kitchen utensils and steel buckets. Then
bags, radios and color TVs.
"Then suddenly, out of nowhere, comes pro kabaddi
and the champions win $85,000," said Tanwar, the
coach. "That tells you the story of kabaddi. Who knows,
India may even forget cricket in some years. It is all
destiny."
– The Washington Post
63 THE INDIAN AMERICAN OCTOBER-DECEMBER 2014