PElllEIDIB

PElllEIDIB
HMeHeM Pocc:illicKoii <l>e)J;epa.rurn:
15 )J;eKa6p5I 2014 ro
r. XambI-Ma.Hc:illicK
('")
..
XaIITb1-Ma.Hc:illicK:illi paiioHHDlli cy,n: Xa.HThI-Ma.Hc:illicKoro a.BTOHOMHoro OKpyra IOrpoI B cocTa.Be rrpe)J;ce)J;aTe.JibCTB)'IOrn:ero cyJJ:DH BaKIIIeeBa H.B.,
npH ceKpeTape Kamrrcrn-roii O.A.,
c yqacTHeM Hc~a IOpKHHa A.B.,
rrpeJ.I:CTaBHTeneii oTBe'fllliKOB JlaTurnoBa C.B., KHH3HHa M.C.,
paccMOTI'P.B B OD<pbITOM cy)J;e6HoM 3ace)J;a.HHH Ip3.)l(,IJ:a.HCKoe )J;eno N2 2-4612/14
HCK)' ·: K BoeHHOM)' KOMHccapHazy Xa
Ma.Hc:illicKoro aBTOHOMHoro OKpyra - ·IO:t:ppI, JVlliHHcTepCTBY <l>HHa.HCOB Poccfil:icK:
<l>e)J;epau;ID1 0 IIpH3Ha.HHH )J;e:ijcTBitif He3aKOHHbRv!Ff; : · ~3bIGI<:aIDill ,n:eHe)l(HhIX cpeJ.I:CTB
cqeT B03Mern;eHH5I IIp}lq}!HeHHOrO yrn:ep6a,
\• -.:;,../
YCTAHOBHJI:
HcTeu: o6paTHnc5I : Bi cy,n: .c, HCKOM . •K · o'i'BeT1IBKaM , :o npH3Ha.Hlill )J;eii,oTB
1
He3aKOHHbIIvlli, B3bICKa.HHH ,n:eHe)l(HhIX .cpep:CTB. 'B' cm:eT ;B03Mem;eHH5I rrp}lq}!HeHHO
yrn:ep6a. Tpe6oBa:HWJ .·HCKa, MOTIIBUf>OBa.HbI TeM, ~o HCTeU: 01.09.2008. o6paTHnc5I
oT,n:en BoeHHoro KOMHccapHaTa ·no r. Ypaii o BI>I,n:aIIe y,n:ocToBepeHH5I BeTepa.Ha 6oeBb 1
,n:eiicTBHii. y ,l(OCTOBepeHHe 1He 6omo.Bbl,l(aHo' :s~ CB513W;O, ;OTCY,I.:CTBHeM ,l(OKYMeHTanbHO
no,n:rBep:>KJ.I:eHH5I. <]JaKTa :HenocpeJ.I:eTBeHHoro , yqacnrn .B;. -.6oeBI>IX , ,i:J:eiicT:B:IDtk ! iip
BbIIIonHeHHH 3a,n:aq B xo,n:e KOHTpTeppopncTIJHec.KHX onepau;IDI Ha·:reppHTopHH C~mep 1KaBKa3cKoro pemoHa. 27.10.2010. BHOBh ·o6p~rr$Ic5I 3a :Bol,l(aqeif·:coo'L'BeTcwyiom;e
YJ.I:OCTOBepeHH5I, . O)J;HaKO. HOTI(y ;QbDiOt nOBTOPH;9 j;Q11(a3a.HQ; .,.y.,l(OCT0B.epeHHe Berep
6oeBbIX )J;eiicTB:illi BhIJ.I:a.HO
-. A ,.B . JllilllJ:> 10.04.2014. ITonaraeT, ~o o65I3aHHOC1[f ·
no p03bICK)' apXHBHbIX J.I:OKYMeffi'vi.i, no,n:rBep:>K,II;aJOm;HX yqaCTHe Ip3.)l(,IJ:a.H B 6oeBb.ll
~:iic:13IDIX, B03.Jio:>KeHa Ha BoeHHDm ( KO:rvw:ccapFJaU>I H BoeHHDIM KOMHcq1pHaTo~ .·
AL\1AO-- IOrpoI J.I:.JIHTennHoe BpeM5I He BbIIIOnH5IJiocb, B pe3ynoTaTe qero, Hcreu: Jilllle~
. B03Mo:>KHocTH nonyqa,Tb e:>r<;eMec~. ,n:~He)J<Hy~<r BnJIIJI'!-TY B,.coqi::e~G~HH q,_n. 1
23.l cpeJ.I:epanoHoro 3.aKoHa "Q Berep~ma:x'.! : 1? nep:q:oJ.I:; C;:ceHl'5lPP5I ·2008-ro)J;a; ·no aTipe
2014 ro,lJ;a. YKa3bIBaeT, IITO )J;eiici:;~:lliil'vII'.l OTBe~~ :e:rvi;y : npJ:fCl}lliea ·.yru:ep6:· ~. B
· . ipy6.i:ieI:f... :I1p.ocHT . c
HenonyqeHHoii )J;eHe:>KHof1: . BbII1JiaTJ?,I. B ·o6rn:e:H; ,PyryiM_e ·. .
rrpH3HaTI> J.I:eiicTBH5I .·. BoeHff<;ffo :. I<:Ol\i1.I:ICC~PH~T~ 1 .; X.~u.1-Ma.Hc:aiioI<:o,r:P. : . aJ?TQHQMIIO
oKpyra - IOrpoI B q~cTH ,Hec,B0,e~p~MeI;II:I9ii . Bhl;L.(C;i~<W;IJ;oqios.epe!fWJ B~:;.repcµI~ 16oeBb 1
)J;eMCTB:illi He3aKOHHbIIvlli, .)33Ji>IcKaT:o .. C,. · PPGCi.mG~Q~1 , <l?~.n:~p~:1 :'J3a; ' :C;r;IB,J:'( :~~ .I
Pocc:illicKoii <l>eJ.I:epa.rurn: GYMMY. ~eno}ifieHHoif. AeH.~?WfOM ·BhIIDiaTuI B pa3Mepe.· "
·
py6.rreii, B03MecTII.Tb pa~xoJJ:D~,no oru;rmy,rqcy.I(~P9TaeBEoif, noIJ.P:mHE.L 1 .. ; ,_. ,,· . ,, : ~ · ,
HcTeu:
A.B. i B; cy.ri:e6;HoM _3aq~~a.H,IDI· ;.rpeqOBCUW51 , HOK.a ·ino)J.t(ep:>Ka.ri . .
H3JIO)l{eHHbIMB HeM,l(OBO,l(aM. ".\;" ;:
' i ' '.'; ,
.: .. · ;,..: ( · ' : ·
.
! ; '. ; .: . c ! : , ; i:·!'
ITpe,n:cTaBHTenn .OTaeTillfl<a. .. BoeHHoro 1KOMHcpapJ;Ia.ra :X1V1A.O 1~ IOrpoI -<JiaThrn
C.B. HCKOBI>Ie T_Pe6QBa.HH5I . He., IIpH3HaJI; :,. I105,10HHJI,1; IITq_..... o65I3aFIH00TH ·rro :c6op ,1
,l(OK)'MeHTOB, no,n:TBep).K)J;aIOm;HX <Pa~ ~aC'l115l ' H~8.; '13 ~5o~BbIX \)J;eMCTBIImc' H~ oT,r(emu
1
I
p·
r
I,
0
1
•
l
..
•
t.
..
,· t
•·.• ·; .:.• 1! •
·,
•I•
•
. '· :,
'
·:"
._· '\~: ({; ~·~
I
..,
,'
··-. • • · ,
:
:
~· ~
·,
:
'
'
l '- '•
~
'
'
. ·... } ' ·. .
'
I
'
:
..
'I
~·-•
;
'. . :
'
·~
...
/
I
'
~
l
t
I '.
' ' , "'·
\ ·,
·:(
'
.. - · ~
,
..
2
BOeHH1IX KO:t\.rn:ccapHaTOB . h,6 i b:rCT516p51 2012 ro,n;a B03.Jio:>KeHbI. He 6billll. 0rBeT'IlfKOM
.r.Iln:rn, oK33:brnanocn. . :. · ·- ·A.B·. co,tJ;elicTBHe B rronyqeHllll Heo6xo,n;HMbIX apXHBHh&
crrpaBOK H 'BbIIIHCOK H3 :rrpHimoB; Bonee Toro; perneHHe 0 IIpH3HaHHH yqacTHHKOM
6oeBbIX ,n;eifcTBHH H Bhi,n;a4'e ·Y.n:<?·cToBepe:rillii ·rrpHHHMaeTc51 KoMMccHeli L(empa.r.IbHono
BOeHaoro «)i<pyra;' KOTOpOH 05.07.2011. BbIHece:Ho 38.K.JIKJqeHHe 06 OTKa3e B Bbi,n;aqe
y,tiocToBepeHH51. Pernelllie : KoMHccHH L(empan:BHoro BoeHHoro oKpyra o Bhi,n;aqe
'A.B. --' c'Oot~eTbr~YiOU:ier6 ·y,n;octoBepemrn · rrpHIDITo 10.04.2014., KoTopoe
Bp)'qeHO e:My·:OIBeTclliKOM ·'rtd 'rvi:eczy :>KfiTe.JibCTBa. ',[(o JK3'.3aHHoro MOMeHTa y HCTI{a
OTCyTCTBOBMO ·rrpaBo H:a .JThr6IBI H 'Mepbl coizyia.imHoii im,n;,n;ep:>KKH, rrpe,n;oCTaBAAeMbJX
co6i'Berc1Billf. c;. 33.KoH:o:M '! i'.10 ., BeTep8.Hax". TilloKe . . 3a.503IDI 0 rrporrycKe cpoKa Ha .
06p~eHiie :B c)';il/ · .·.:: ~- :. ·.·.::·:1·c:·
· Ilpe,n:crimllte.Jib MmillcTepcTBa 'cpHHaHcoB P<l> KHH3HH M.C. B cy,n:e6HoM: 3ace,n;a.Hlfil
T.pe6ol3a.Hlli! HCKa :He ripn3:fiarr; ·YKa3arr, qro Hcmo:rvi: He rrpe,n:cTaB.ITeHo ,n:oKa3aTe.JibC'DB
:Hapyill:eHIDt ·. e:to I;rp<iB ,.H )'CTaHORiieH'.HbIX 38.KOHOM ~CTpaTHBHbIX IIpOI(e,n:yp rr'o
rrpH3Ha:mtfo eto yqactmrko:tvi: 6oeBhIX ,n:eliCTBHH. TaIOKe 3a51BHJI o rrporrycKe cpo~a
HCKOBOH . ,n:hBiIOCTll no 3a5IBJieHHbIM HCTU:OM· 'Ipe60BaHH5IM 0 B3bICKaHHH ,n:eHe:>KHbJK
cpe,n:cTB B rrpe,n:errax TPex neT):(o·MOMeHTa rro,n:aqn HCKa. · ·
.
· ·· Ilpe,n:cTaBHTeJIH 'I'peThHX JIH1( YrrpaBrreHH51 I1eHcHoHHoro cpoH,n:a P<l> B ropo,n:e Ypae,
MHHHcTepcllia 06opom,1 P<P B cy,n:e6Hoe 3ace,n:aHHe He.51BHJIHCh, Cy,n: c yqeToM MHemJr
I
CTOpOH H IIpaBIDl CT. 167 ITIK ·P<t> cqerr B03MO:>KHbU'vf paCCMO'I'peTb ,n:erro B llX OTCJ'TCTBHel
npH Ha.JIIB.IHH E:a,n;rre:>Kmu:ero·H3Bem;eHH51 o Bpel\1eIDI R MecTe paccMO'I'peHH51 ,n:erra.
. .~ 3acrryrnaB CTOpOHbI; HCcrre.n:oBaB H ou;eHHB B COBOKJIIHOCTH ~CbMeHHbie MaTepmu111
·.z:i;ena, cy,n;·.· :rrpHIIIerr . K •BbIBO.IJY .. 06 OTCJ'TCTBHH :ocHOBaHllll ,1I,illI y,n:oBJieTBopeHH51 .
'I'pe6oBaHHH HCKa •BBH;IJy cne,[()!IOm:ero.
· · · ·. · ·
·
. · _CorrracHo . CT... .53 ; KoHCTifIYI(llli P<l> Ka:>K,n:blli HMeeT rrpaBo Ha B03Mem;eHHf
rocy,n:apCTBOM Bpe,n:a, rrpwrnHeHHoro He3a.KOHHbIMH .,n:eHCTBH5IMH (HITH 6e3,n:eHCTBIDIMM)
oprattoB rocy,n:apcTBeHHoli.BnacTH mm: HX ,Zl;OJI)KHOCTHhIX JIHI(.
.
.. B COOTBeTCTBHH . C q. 1 CT: 1064 rpa:>K,n:aHCKOI'O KO,Zl;eKca P<l> Bpe,n:, rrplfqHHeHHbIB
I
JIHqHOCTII. HJIH HMYm:eCTBY' rpa:>K,n:aHHHa, a Ta.K:>Ke Bpe,n:, rrpHqHHeHHbIB HMYm:eCTBY
lOpH,n:HY:eCKOI'O JIHI(a, rro,n:rre:>KHT.B03Mem:e:mno B IIOJIHOM o6'beMe JIHI(OM, IIpHY:HHHBllIHM
Bpe,n:. ,: ·. .' . · . · · ·
,· :· , .. . · :
··
'
·
CTaTMI 1069 f'pmK,i:l;aHCKoro Ko,n:eKca P<D, ycTaHaBJIBBaeT, 'YTO Bpe,D;, rrpHYJIBeHHblli
rpa)K.n;aHHHY . HJIH IOpl'.I,[(WieCKOMY JIH1(y B pe3yJibTaTe He3a.KOHHbIX ,n:eiiCTBHR .
(6e3,n:elicTBH5I) rocy,n:apcTBeHHbIX opraHoB, opraHoB Mecrnoro caMoyrrpaBrreHH51 JIH6co
. ..
'
.
)J;OJI)KHOCTHbIX JIH1( 3TllX opraHOB, B TOM qncrre B pe3yJibTaTe H3)J;aHH51 He
.
.
. .
I
cooTBeTCTB)'IOm:ero 3a.KOHY HJIH HHOMY rrpaBOBOMY a.KTY aKTa rocy,n:apCTBeHHoro opraHa
HJIH opraHa Mecrnoro caMoyrrpaBrreHID'r, rro,n:rre:>KHT B63Mem:emno. Bpe,n: B03Mem;aeTc5l 3~
cqeT cooTBeTCTB)'IOm:eH: Ka3HhI. ·
CTaTb5112 rpa:>K,n:aHCKOI'O KO,Zl;eKca P<l>, B KaqeCTBe O,n:HOI'O H3 crroco6oB 3am;HTbil:
lpa)K)J;aHCKHX rrpaB rrpe,n:ycMa'I'pHBaeT B03MO:>KHOCTb IIOTeprreBrneH: CTOpOHbl 'I'pe6oBa'Th
OT HeHCIIpaBHOH CTOpOHbI Bo3M:em:eHH51 y6bITKOB.
licXOM H3 rronmKeHHH"CT. 56 ITIK P<D, CT.CT.' 16 H 1069 rpa:>K,n:aHCKoro KO,Zl;eKca P<D
. .
.
I
3IDrnJI5151 'I'pe6oBaHHe 0 . .B03Mem;eHHH Bpe,n:a, HCTel( ,Zl;OJI)KeH ,Zl;OKa3aTb cpaKT
npoTHBOIIpaBHOCTH ll BmIOBHOCTH ,n:eHCTBHH (6e3,n:eHCTBH51) OTBeTY:HKa, rrp~
rrPHY:HHHO-CJie,n:cTBeHI!)'IO CB5l3b Me:>K,Dy 3TliMH ,n:eHCTBH51MH ll HaC1)'IIJieHHeM Bpe.n:al
c,
•·
.
·. __
c
I
I
I
I
.
.
v
I
I
:1
I
3
pa3Mep 'IIpiftrn:Hemmro Bpe,Ii;a,. a TaIOKe cal\1 cpaICT · ero B03HMKHOBemrn. OrcyrcTBMf
O,I(HOfO H3.3JieMeif!OB MCKJIIOqaeT B03MO:>KHOCTh Haczynrremrn OTBeTCTBeHHOCTM.
· <I>e.n:epaIThHDIM .3a.KOHOM M~ 5-<I>3 OT 12.01.1995. "O BeTepa.Hax" Ha JIBIJ;,
rrpMiillMasIIIBX yqacTMe B Bhm6JIHemm: 3a,n:aq B- xo.n:e KOHipTeppopMcTmecKMX onepa.IJ;Hii
Ha TeppMTopliH CeBepo-KaBKa3cKoro pernoHa: c asrycTa 1999 ro.n:a pacrrpOC'TpaIDieTC51
.n:eiiCTBMe CTaTeii 3 H 4 <I>e,ti:epaIThHOro 3aKOHa "O BeTepa.Hax", B TOM qMCJie H IIpaBO Ha
norryqe:Frn:e :Mep COJ.UiaIIbHOR riOMep)KKii B BH)J;e e:>KeMeC5JqHOH )J;eHe){<HOH BbIDJiaThI.
.: ..·-I lpir 3T~M pearrM3ali;IDI Mep cor(Milln.HOH noMep:>KKM BeTepaHOB 6oeBbIX .n:eiicTBMH
ocyrtieCTB.JNere51 rrpM rrpe.n:n5IBrremm: ID.rn: y;n:ocToBepemrn e)UIBoro · o6pa3u;a,
ycTaHOBJiemmro ,II;IDI KIDKAOH · KaTeropMM· BeTepa.HoB ·M qrreHoB ceMeii norn6IIIBX
(YM.eprrllix) · mffia.Jlli,r(oB :S6futbr, yqacTHMKbB BeJIMKoii OreqecmeHHoii BoiiHDr M
.Ben~pa.HoB 6oeBbIX ~eiicmmr TipaBMTeJibcTBOM CCCP .n:o 1 5IHBap51 1992 ro.n:a MJIM
npgs.kre.JThCIBOM PoccMiicKoiicDe.n:epau;MM (CT. 28 cpe.n:~paIThHOro 3aKOHa) .
.c: ·?tI~\ocHO;Ba.HMM ]IocrillioBnemrn IlpaBMTe.iTucTBa P<I> OT 19.12.2003. 763 "06
y.l:tocr613epemm: ·BeTepfilla; 6oeBI>ix .n:eiicTBMii" Bb:r,naqa y.n:ocToBepeHMii rrpoM3Bo,n;IITc51 B
noP-Wit<~, ycta.HoBiieHHOM B COOTBeTCTB)'IDI.I.UfX cpe.n:epaIThHbIX opra.Hax McnoJIHMTeJibHOH
B3:1~S~ ;a . opraHax · McnoJIHMTeJibHOH BrracTM cy6neKToB PoccMiicKoii <I>e.n:epau;MM, no
3·a5rJ3ft~HID.1M; rio.n:aaae:MbIM BeTepa.HaMM B 3TM opra.Hbr.
~f:;1:fff'.tie.JUIX paCCMO'TpeHE.5! .o6paru;eHMif Ii IIpMH5ITM51 perneHMH 0 Bb:r,naqe (OTKa3e B
B:&:I;I.J;~~ ~): . y.n:oCToBepeHMii BeTepaHa 6oeBbIX .n:eiicmMii B BoopJ:>KeHHDIX CMJiax
Poc~iilicKoii '<I>e.n:eparurM o6pa3.oBa.Hbr KoMMccMM BoeHI:Thix oKpyroB, cprroToB, BoiicKoBoii
no paccMo'TpeHHIO o6pam'.eHMii M5I ocpopMJiemrn M Bbl)J;aqM y.n:oCToBepeHMii
qactif:.·
BeTe~~im 6oeBbIX .n:eiiCTBMH ():(arree - KOMMCCMM).
-B '. ccioTBeTCTBMM c I1pMKa3oM ·J\1mrnc'Tpa o6opoHDr P<I> OT 11.08.2012. N~ 2288 "06
YTBep~eHMM nop51,I(Ka BI>i,n;aqM y.n:ocTcrnepeHMii BeTepa.Ha 6oeBbIX .n;eiicTBMH B
Bo9p)')J{eHHbIX CMJiax PoccillfcKoii <I>e.n:epau;MM" M5I norryqeHM51 y.n;ocToBepemrn
3amITepeCOBa.HHbie Jni.n;a o6pfilticiroTC51 B KOMMCCIDO BOeHHOI'O OKpyra, Ha TeppMTOpMM
KOTQporo OHM rrpo){{J.rnaIDT, 'qepe3 BoeHHblli KoMMccapMaT cy6neKTa PoccMiicKoii
<I>e.n:epau;MM no Meczy noCTaHOBKM- Ha BOMHCKMH yqeT (no Meczy :>KMTeJibCTBa).
BoeHHbre · KoMMccapMaTbI ; nocrre rrpoBepm .n;oKyMeHTOB, rrpMJio:>KeHHDIX K
o6pa.m;eHIDO, HarrpaBIDilOT HX ·)J;JI51 paCCMO'TpeHM51 B .KOMMCCIDO BOeHHoro OKpyra, B
COCFaB KOTOporo OHM BKJIIOqefilr.
', ,D;rur ocpopMJieHM51 3aKJilO':ieHM51 0 Bb:r,naqe (06 OTKa3e B BbI)J;aqe) Y.JJ:OCTOBepeHM51 H
Be,n;emur yqem BeTepaHOB 6oeBbIX .n:eiiCTBMH K o6pam:e:mno rrpHK1Ia,I(bIBaIOTC51 M5I JIBIJ;,
BbillOJIH5IBIIIBX 3a)J;aqM B xo.n;e KOH'TpTeppopMCTmeCKMX onepa.IJ;Hii Ha TeppMTOpMM
CeBepo-KaBKa3CKoro pernoHa, · -. - BbIIIMCKM H3 rrpHKa30B KOMaH)J;H.POB (HaqaJihHMKOB)
BOMHCKHX qacTeii, no.n;pa3,n;e,rre~ H opraHOB, IIpHBJieKaeMbIX K rrpoBe.n:e:mno
KmnpreppopHcTmecKMX onepa.IJ;Hii, B KOTOpbIX YKa3a.HbI ,n;aThr MJIM nepMO,I(bI yqacTM51
cooTBeTCTBYI,OI.I.UfX COTPY,IJ;HfiKOB H BOeHHOCJIY:>Kam;ax B KOHipTeppopMcTmeCKMX
onepau;M5IX M KOTOpbre. yrBep:>K,n;eHDr PYKOBO,n;IITerreM PernoHarrbHoro onepaTHBHoro
rnTa6a, a co 2 aBrycm 2006 r. - PYKOBO,n;IITerreM KOH'TpTeppopHCTmecKoii onepau;MM,
JIH6o )J;OK)'MeHTbI, no,IJ,TBep:>K,n;aIOID;He norryqeHHDre B CB513H c 3THM pa.HeHM51, KOHTY3MM
HITH YBe%51, JIH6o pearrM30Ba.HHbIB Harpa,n:Hoii MaTepHarr.
OTBeTcTBeHHOCTb 3a no.n:roToBey .n:oKyMeHTOB (HarrpaBrreHMe 3arrpocoB M5I po3bICKa
)J;OKyMeHTOB), rrpMJiaraeMbIX K 66paru;e:mno, B03JiaraeTc51: )J;JI51 BOeHHOCJIY:>Kall.UfX H JIBIJ;
rpa:>K.n;aHcKoro nepcoHarra , Boop~<eHHDIX CHrr PoccHiicKoii .<I>e.n;epau;MM - Ha
.
I
'~
4
Henocpe,n:crBeHHbIX KOMaH,n:HpOB (Haqa.JibHMKOB); ,n:IDI HllblX JilII( - Ha BOeHHbIX
KOMllCCapoB no Mecry noCTaHOBKM Ha BOIDICI<IDi yqer (no Mecry )KlfTeJibCTBa
o6paTIIBIIIeroc5! JIB6o no Mecry Haxm1<,n:eHIDI HcrrpamneJibHoro yqpe)l(,ll;eHIDI, B KOTopoM
oT6ornaer HaK33aHHe o6paTHB:rrrn:Hc5!).
Ilo HTOraM paccMo:rpeHIDI KOMHCCH.H rrpIDIHMaeT peIIIeHHe 0 BO:I,n;aqe ( OTK33e B
Bb~aqe) y,n:oCTOBepeHIDI. 3aKJJJOqeHHe no,n:IIHChIBaeTC5! 3aMeCTHTeJieM rrpe,n:ce,n:aTeJUI
i(eHTpaJIOHOM KOMHCCHH (KOMHCCHH), qneHaMH ce:r<peTapHaTa u:eHTpa.JibHOM KOMHCCHH
(KOMHCClill) H YTBep)l(,ll;aeTC5l rrpe,n:ce,n:aTeJieM u;eH:rpa.ITbHOM KOMHCCHH (KOMHCCHH).
CornacHo ,n:elicTBOBaBIIIeMY ,n:o 15.10.2012. Ilop.H,n:Ky, YTBep)l(,ll;eHEIOMY IlpHK330M
Mmmc:rpa o6opoHOI P<I> OT 02.11.2009. N2 1177 "O nop5!,Il;Ke B:E.I,n:aqlf y,n:ocToBepeHHH:
BeTepatta ·6oeBoIX ,n:elicTBHM B BooppKeHHbrx CHJiax PoccHlicKoli <I>e,n:epau;HH" ,n:IDI
no.rryqemur y,n:ocToBepeHIDI BoeHEIOCJI)')Karr.i;He H JilII(a Ipa)l(,ll;aHcKoro nepcoHana
Boop)rn<eHHhrx CHJI PoccHlicKoli <I>e,n:epau;HH, ,n:oIDKHhI 6oIJIB o6paTHThC5! B KOMHccmo
BOe:Hiiof9 ·oKpyra; Ha TeppHTopHH KOTOporo OHM IIpO)!GIBaIOT.
· .. ·K · o6parr(eHIDO ,n:oIDKHhI 6:bIJIB 6oITh IIpHJIO)KeHOI ,n:Be cpoTorpacpHH H ,n:oK)'MeHThI,
no,z::i:IBep)l(,ll;aIOIII;lie Henocpe,n:CTBeHHoe yqacTHe B 6oeB:E.IX ,n:elicTBIDIX: ,n:IDI JilII(,
B~i;r:i().nIDrnnrnx 3a,IJ;aqlf B ycnoBIDIX BooppKeHEioro KOHcpJIBKTa B LJeqeHcKoH: Pecrry6JIHKe
H H!i_gpiffieraIO:rn;m<. K Hell TeppHTOpIDIX, OTHeCeHHOIX K 30He BOOppKeHHOro KOHcpJIBKTa,
Jlli.qt6:';#·;* o,n:e KOH:rpTeppopm::rmecKHX onepau;HM Ha TeppHTOpHH CeBepo-KaBK33CKoro
pefbb.H:ajf/Jll16o .no o6ecneqeHIDO 6e3onacHOCTH H 3arr.J;HTe Ipa)l(,ll;aH PoccHlicKoli
.· <Pf~€7~, '> rrpo)!GIBaIO:rrt;m<. Ha TeppHTOpIDIX Pecrry6JIBKH IO)l(Ha.H OceTH.H H
~.91.fil<1:t·· A6x33H.H, - BhIIIHCKM H3 IlpHK330B cooTBeTCTB)'IO:rrt;m<. KOMaH,n:HpOB
(:
:: QB), no,n:TBep)l(,ll;aIOiu;He Henocpe,n:CTBeHEioe HX yqaCTHe B 6oeBbIX ,n:eMCTBIDIX
1g~fu'rn:bm Harpa,n;HOM MaTep:aan;
· ·~~yroiu;ae : y,n:ocToBepeHIDI ocpopM.IDIJIHCh B Ka,IIpOBOM opratte BOeHEioro
·';.y~Y~PPW9PHH KOToporo o6paTHBIIIHeC5! JIBIJ;a IIpO)!GIBaIOT. OcpopMJieHHb1e
;~IBaJIBCh B KHHre yqeTa y,n:oCTOBepeHHH: H HarrpaBJUIJlliCb ,n:IDI
;,~~!Aa~· 'B opra.H BoeHEioro yrrpaBm.'lHIDI, BOIDICK)'IO qacTh, opraHH3au;H10
.' ~·~fuitEoccliiicKOM <I>e,n:epaIJ;IIB, B KOTOpoIX IIpOXO,n:HT BOeHEI)'IO CJI)0K6y
··. · ep
. l'.·., ·- '~jf·ioeHHblli KoMHccap:aaT cy6oeKTa PoccHlicKoli <I>e,n:epaIJ;IIB, no Mecry
···" ._ ~-. ··"· ~.#;ip~amrna, 06paTHBIIIeroc51 3a BoI,n;aqeli y,n:oCToBepeHIDI.
. . ._-.:;w~'.;~6p~.oryr;,;,n:y;ij:C'fl?.OB~III11¥ ,n:o OKT5!6p5! 2012 ro,n:a IIOp5!,Il;KOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTh
3fi)~l¥.R~~f,§~ey:;;54~~eHioB ' : (imnpaBrreIDie 3aiip0co:B ,n:rrn po3I>1cKa · ,n:oK)rMemoB),
:rrtfMJia~~Mb'&: JKI:'.o6palu;eHIDO, Ha BOeHHbIX KOMHCCapo:B no Mecry nOCTaHOBKM Ha
Bo~c1<irn yqer.(i:ro Mecry )KlfTeJibcTBa o6paTHBIIIeroc5!) He B03Jiaranaco.
:;<:He ·iJfoiraranoco Ha BoeHHb1e KOMHccap:aaThl o65!3aHEiocTH no c6opy 3a o6paTHBIIIeec5!
JIMcloi nopTBep)l(,ll;aIOIIJ;HX ,LI;OK)'MeHTOB H ,n:eMCTBOBaBIIIHM ,n:o 26.04.2010. IlpHK330M
~c'tj)ao6opoH01 P<I> oT 15.03.2004. N2 77 (pe,n:. oT 07.03.2008.) "O nopMKe Boi,n:aqlf
y,n;9c±d13"epeHHH: Berepatta 6oeBoIX ,n:elicTBHM B Boop)0KeHHbrx CHJiax PoccHlicKoH:
<I>e;n;epap;mr".
· A.B. 01.09.2008. H 27.10.2010.
KaK·:ycTaHOBJieHo B cy,n:e6HoM 3ace,n:aHHH, 1·
06parn;anc51 B BOeHHOrn KOMHccap:aaT no r. YpaIO XattThI-MattcHlicKoro aBTOHOMHoro
OKpyra:~:3aIDmeHHeM 0 Bhi,n:aqe y,n:oCTOBepeHIDI BeTepatta 6oeBbIX ,n:eMCTBHM.
y ,tiO~'fOBepe:HHe HCTIJ;y He 6omo Bhl,Il;aHO B CB5!3H c Herrpe,n:cTaBJieHHeM K 3a5IBJieHIDO
now:Bep:>K,LI;aIOIIJ;HX ,LI;OK)'MeHTOB, 0 qeM 05.07.2011. KOMHCCHeM U:eHTpa.JibHOro BOeHEioro
·. f
'
' ··" J.
'•'
i
5
mcpyra rro paccMo'Ipemno o6pa.rri;e:mlli rorn ocpopMJieIDrn H BI>:r;::i:atrn y.n;ocToBepe:mrii
BeTepaH:a 6oeBhIX .n;e:H:cmllli IIpHIDITo perneIDie (rrpoTOKOJI M! 29 n. 32).
YKcnaHHoe PEfilleIDie HCTIJ;OM He o6)KaJIOBaHo, rrpe.Lt;MeTOM paccMOTpeHIDI
HaCTmIIn;ero cnopa He 5IBIDieTC51 H IIpH 3TOM CBH.L(eTeJibCTByeT 06 OTCYTCTBHH Ha TOT
MOMeHT OCHOBa.HIDI )])I5I BbI,LI:atrn '
A.B. COOTBeTCTB)'IOIII,ero y.n;ocTOBepeHIDI H
3aKOHHOCTH ocnapHBaeMhIX .n;e:H:CTBHH opraHOB rocy.n;apCTBeHHOH BJiaCTH.
EoJiee Toro, BOeHHhIM KOMHccapHaTOM, HeCMOTp51 Ha OTCYTCTBHe 3aKOHO.L(aTeJibHOH
o651~_ffi,IHOCTII no c6opy .Lt;OK)'MeHTan;HH, no.n;TBep:>I<,n;aEOIII,eH: rrpaBo A.B. Ha
no~~illie y.n;oCTOBepeIDrn BeTepaHa 6oeBbIX .n;eHCTBIDf, OKa3aHa HCTD;y HeOOXO.L(HM35I
no~olM? HO.p03hICKY apXHBHhIX .L(OK)'MeHTOB, no.n;TBep>I<,n;aEOIII,HX ero yqacTHe B 6oeBbIX
.. ~~!1.?~~51,~fr-::· ';
(,~>. ~-: ~~:-~iM:t KQl\lli9CapHaTOM XMAO IOrpI>I. B CB513H c o6paIII,eIDieM HCTIJ;a
'· .
J'•-·. :' ': :~ ·.E&~J"!ye,; 12 ~ pa3) .n;eJiaJIHCb 3arrp0Chl B apXHBhl BOeHHhIX mcpyroB,
'@~y~:-µ92:_. iY:1~CTy : •'IIpOXO)K.L(eHH51 CJIY)K6bI. 3aKOHO.L(aTeJibHhIX cpoKOB
...:_-:.· 9~'
pa6dll,:( .n;llir Boe:Hm,IX KoMHccapnaToB He ycTaHOBJieHo. OTcYTcTBne
.-;:-··_
1
·::,;.
-
:;,," .
.
' . - XEjBHhIX .L(OK)'MeHTOB He rrpeII5ITCTBOBaJIO
~:'f;~~~~tt;:K::;~::rn
HCTD;y CaMOCT051TeJibHO
K 3MBJieHHID 0 Bbmaqe Yl10CTOBepemrn
.n;9~~ff:Th'F6omir11onyqeHhI B 5IHBape 2014 ro.n;a.
. ::.·Jtb~'.~Ql4>
'··~ ' ' ' ' A.B. BHOBb o6paTHJIC51 c 3a5IBJieIDieM 0 Bh:r;::i:aqe y.n;ocTOBepeHIDI
Ber~p~a ;~9qeBbrX :;:.n;ei1:cTBHH. Ha OCHOBaHHH 3aKJII011eHIDI KOMHCCHH L(empaIIbHOro
Boe~§f.o -·o.::I<pyr;:t·oT)0.04.2014. ~ ~
··:·''
_ A.B BhVJ:aHO y.n;ocToBepeIDie BeTepatta 6oeBI>IX
.
.n;eH:cwMH:. ·
' rii{ii)3e,n;eI!J-Il,Je BJ?Iille o6CT051TeJibCTBa .L(OCTOBepHo CBH.L(eTeJibCTB)'IOT 0 TOM, 11TO
OTB~q.M "'.'~a,µfte)fs. o6pa30M HCnOJIH5IJIHCb 'lpe60B8.HIDI IIpHKa30B Mmrn:cTpa
o6opoiffir ~):><t),~·--~;'f~ffiaM:eHTIJP)'IOIII,HX .n;e51TeJibHOCTh B ccpepe nopMKa BI>:r;::i:atrn
y.n;oCToBep~~§~er~pillla 6oeBbIX .n;e:H:cTBIDi.
Bone~'!('.!~tc&itd~~ '·::acren: rrpocHT rrpH3HaTh He3aKoHHhIMH .n;e:H:cTBH51 BoeHHoro
KOMHccap~a-r~ :~oHOMHOro OKpyra B 11aCTH HeCBOeBpeMeHHOH BbI,LI:atrn y.n;oCTOBepeHIDI.
fIC>P!J~fili~- 11. 3 CT. 196 ITIK P<D cy;:i; rrpHHHMaeT perneHHe B rrpe;:i;errax 335IBJieHHhIX
HC~'fA0¥, i._R~Q()BaHHH.
·Co:f:iraehg: n. .. 1?.
nop51,D;Ka Bh:r;::i:atrn y.n;ocToBepe:mrii Bcrepatta 6oeBhD\ ;:i;eH:cTBIDi,
Yr:13ep5AA~~9ro IIpHKcnoM Mmrn:cTpa 06op0Hh1 P<D oT 11.08.2012. N2 2288,
3ahdhii~Hffi,1e y,ziocTOBepeIDrn IlO.L(ITHChIBaEOTC51 COOTBeTCTB)'IOll.I,HMH Ha11aJihHHKaMH
Ka,l:(p«:)i3%ix·opraHoB BoeHHI>IX oKpyroB, cprroToB, Boi1:cKoBoi1: 11acT11
OcpopMJieHHh1e
y;:i;ocTOBep~HH51 ytrn:ThIBaEOTC51 B KIDire yqeTa y;:i;ocTOBepe:mrii, BbI,LI:aEOTC51 BeTepaey ITO)];
pacITHcey JIH6o HaIIpaBJI5IEOTC51 ,1JJI5I nocrre.rzyioIII,e:H: Bh:r;::i:atrn B opra.H BOeHHoro
ynpaB.rreHH51, BOHHCK)'IO 11aCTh, opraHH3aI(IDO, B KOTOpbIX IIpOXO,JJ;HT BOeHH)'IO CJIY)K6y
(pa6omeT) o6paTHBrnIDfC51, HJIH B BOeHHhlli KOMHCcapHaT no Meczy noCTaHOBKH Ha
BOHHCKMH yqeT (no Meczy :>ICHTefilCTBa) rpa)K.L(aHHHa, 06paTHBrneroc51 3a BI>:r;::i:a11ei1:
y;:i;ocTOBepeHH51, JIH6o no Meczy HaxO)K.L(eHIDI HcrrpaBHTeJibHOro yqpe)K.L(eHIDI, B KOTOpOM
o6paTHBWHHC51 oT6ornaeT HaKa3aHHe B BH.L(e JIHilleHH51 cBo6o)J;DI.
OcpopMJieHHoe KOMHccne:H: L(eHTpaJihHoro BOeHHoro OKpyra y,n:ocToBepeHHe
A.B. noczynHJio B oT.n;err BoeHHoro KOMHccapnaTa nor. YpaH: 16.06.2014. H
6bDIO He3aMe)J;JIHTeJibHO BpyqeHO HCTizy, qTo crre;:i;yeT H3 )J;OBO,JJ;OB HCKa H o6paIII,eHIDI
A.B. B BOeHHhlli KOMHCCapHaT OT 15.07.2014.
6
TaKHM o6pa3oM, HerrpaBoMepHE>IX, He cooTBeTCTBYJOII(IDC ycnmoBrreHF!hIM rrpaBMJiaM
,n;eiicTBilli no HecBoeBpeMeHHoii BE.:r,n:a-qe
A.B. y,n;ocToBepemrn Berepa:Ha 6oeBhIX
,n;e:i1:cTBilli BoeHHbIM KO:MHccap1mTOM Xl\1AO - IOrpi,r He ,n;orryr:0;eHo.
Xo,n;aTaHCTBa OTBeT1IHKOB no npHMeHeHHH K .D;a:HHbIM T_Pe6oBaHIDIM
A.B.
T_PeXMec5Pffioro cpoKa Ha o6pam:eHHe B cy,n;, ycTa:HOBJieHHoro CT. 256 ITIK P<I>, cy,n; He
Hax:O,n;HT 3aC.JI)0KHBaIOm;HMH BHHMamrn, IIOCKOJibK)' B03HHKIIIIlli Me)l()Jy CTOpOHaMH crrop
IIO,n;Jie)l(lfl' pacCMOT_Pe:mno B HCKOBOM rrop.sI,II;I<e, HCXOM H3 xapaKTepa IIpaBOOTHOIIIe:mill:,
H3 KOTOpbIX BbITeKaeT T_Pe6oBaHHe .r.rm.i;a, o6paTHBIIIeroc5I 3a cy,n;e6Hoii 3am:HTOM.
KpoMe Toro, HCTeu; YKa3hIBaeT Ha npH1IHHeHHe eMY opraHaMH rocy,n;apCTBeHHoii
BJiaCTH y6hITKOB B BH,n;e HeIIOJIY1IeHHOll 3a rrepHO,D; c ceHT5I6p5I 2008 ro,n;a no anpe1Ib 2014
ro,n;a e)J(eMeC5PIBOM ,n;eHe)J(HOM BbIIIJiaTbI B COOTBeTCTBHH c II. 1 CT. 23.l <i_le,n;epalibHOro
3aKOHa "O BeTepaHax".
BMecre c TeM, rro.rryqeHHe YKa3a:HHoit BhIIIJiaThr HOCHT 3a5IBHTeJibHhIB xapaKTep,
ycTaHaBJIHBaeTc.H H .. BhIIIJia1IHBaeTC5I ._. ·T.eppwropMam;iH;hIM opraHOM IleHCHOHHOro
.<i_loH,n;a . ·PoccHMCKOM <I>e,n;epar.iliH HCKJII01IHTeJibHO . Ha OCHOBa:HHH 3a5IBJiemrn
rpIDK,n;a:HHHa co ,n;H5I o6pam:emrn 3a Heit.
•1
A.B. o6paTHJic5I B YnpaBJieHHe rreHclioHHoro <i_loH,n;a P<I> B r. Ypae c
3a5IBJieHHeM o Ha3HatieHHH .• e)J(eMec5Pffioit ,n;eHe)J(Hoif . BhIIIJiaTbr 26.04.2014. Pa:Hee
YKa3a:HHOM ,n;aThr c ceHi5I6pH · 2008 · ro,n;a c TaKHM · 3a5IBJieHHeM He o6pam:aJic5I, B
Ha3HatieHHH BbIIIJiaTbI B CB5I3H . c OTCYTCTBHeM y Hero y,n;ocTOBepemrn HCTQY He
OTKa3bIBaJIOCb.
· TffirnM o6pa30M, _HCTD;().~(g~ ; rrBe~cTaBJieHO cy,n;y ,D;OKa3aTeJibCTB B03HHKHOBe~ y
Hero HMYIQeCTBeHHo~o yW:ep§ft~pf3yJibTaTe ,n;eifcTBilli rocy,n;apcTBeHHhrx opra:HoB.
y-qeTOM IDJimK~_H}Iofg~;:fi,~~<i*~Wm CT. 56 ITIK P<I>, cy,n; IIpHXO,n;HT K BhIBO.D;y 0 TOM,
l!TO .
.~ :~~~~~~·' :iij¢~~~~~if9:;c;n;oKa3aTeJibCTB BHHhl opraHOB rocy,n;apcTBeHHOM
BJiacTH H.MX ,n;o~9·~~L . ··_" ·
· -,_ ~;._ -. >- . eHHH HCTQY Bpe,n;a, <i_laKTa npH1IHHemrn Bpe,n;a, a
TaK)J(e npHtIHHH9:~~~.; ,;
.~it Me)l()Jy HHMH, 1ITO HCKJIIOqaeT B03MO)J(HOCTh
··
."
...
0-; ..
y,n;oBJieTBopemrn :A; - · ,
Ha ocHoBaJiiili..;
:. '.p!30,IJ;CTBY5ICh CT.CT.56, 194-199 ITIK P<I>, cy,n;
_
4
c
·::~··
~~·~;-~;·~~~~Mv
· .c-.;<~. .:t:[it
1 ;;_
~:
"'' \ · -.. ·
. . .. -.. . .. ..., \O_-UpH3Ha:HHH ,n;eH:cTBHM He3aKOHHhIMH, B3hICKa:HHH
ocraBHTh 6e3
~ 4;C.,~e·=t;.-.~_63~ern:eiIIDI . rrpH1IHHeHHoro yrn:ep6a -
B arreJIJI5IQHoHHoM rrop5I,D;Ke B cy,n; Xa:HThIIOrpi,r B TetieHHe Mec5IQa qepe3 Xa:HThI-
- _. llicy.n:.
·
. q~,'-pellie:ID:i~ . GJ;>.£TaBJieHo H rro,r:o:rnca:Ho cocTaBoM cy,n;a 22 ,n;eKa6p5I
H.B. BaKIIIeeB