FRENCH CUSTOMS 2013 Results
Transcription
FRENCH CUSTOMS 2013 Results
FRENCH CUSTOMS 2013 Results Serving the public, protecting businesses EDITORIAL The year 2013 was a significant one for French Customs, as it marked the end of the 2012–2013 Performance Contract. The Contract was proof positive that French Customs was capable of meeting the effectiveness targets it had been set, with better results across the board. This achievement was primarily due to the hard work, commitment and professionalism of every member of the French Customs staff, and showed an ability to adapt to a constantly-changing environment. 2013 was also the twentieth anniversary of the Single Market, a perfect symbol of our ability to change with the times. To meet the challenges of trade security and the development of legitimate commerce in a more competitive borderless zone, Customs has undergone sweeping transformations. French Customs today is an organisation of paperless, streamlined procedures, new control methods based on a better understanding of flows, risk analysis and targeting. It is an organisation of up-to-date taxation, and one that is ready to help businesses expand into world markets. More than ever, we will focus on protecting French territory and its citizens from an ever-growing set of risks. Furthermore, by providing support for businesses abroad and ensuring that tax revenue is collected, French Customs also plays an economic role. To address all these issues in the coming years, French Customs has, at the request of the ministers in charge of the economy, finance, foreign trade and the budget, rolled out a strategic plan. The plan will help French Customs gradually adapt to its environment and expand its mandate. It ensures that the women and men working for French Customs will be at the centre of any future changes, because it is their daily efforts and unwavering commitment that has made French Customs a proactive, reactive and inventive government department serving its country. The 2013 results confirm that the remit of French Customs and the work of its customs officers are resolutely at the heart of the key issues faced by our citizens – the protection of our national territory in a globalised economy that offers growth but also new risks; support for businesses to create added value and employment in France and develop productive investment; and fiscal consolidation through secure collection and a stepped-up fight against tax evasion. Hélène Crocquevieille, Director-General of Customs and Excise 1 CONTENTS Key Figures for 20134 2013 Highlights6 8 Combatting fraud Fighting major smuggling operations 16 2 8 Protecting French and EU territory 10 Combatting financial fraud and tax evasion 14 A winning global formula with French Customs Streamlining and cutting costs 16 Support for the competitiveness of businesses abroad 18 A customised approach to businesses 20 22 26 32 Reforming the duties collected by Customs Making collection more effective 22 Streamlining customs duties 22 The future of customs duties 24 Making people the heart of tomorrow’s Customs A strategic plan to provide French Customs with fresh momentum 26 Improving the workplace and fostering dialogue between labour and management 28 HR management – a qualitative approach 29 Basic facts about French Customs Organisation 32 French Customs around the world 34 Capacities 36 Human resources 38 Performance 39 3 013 2 R O F S E R U KEY FIG ACTIONS AGAINST FRAUD Narcotics 7.2 tons of cocaine intercepted (+57%) Consumer protection 7,113 citations for noncompliance with standards (+16.2%) 86 tons of cannabis seized (best result in 20 years) 49 tons of khat seized 3.6 million toys inspected (10 times more than in 2012) Smuggled tobacco 430 tons of tobacco Financial fraud and tax evasion €323m in taxes and duties reassessed (+9,8%) seized (+16%) Environment Counterfeit goods 7.6 million counterfeit items seized (+65%) 647 violations concerning endangered plant and animal species (+20%) 299 citations for waste (+56,5%) Weapons 823 weapons seized (twice as many as in 2012) 4 LT S 2013 RESU CUSTOMS CLEARANCE AND ECONOMIC ACTIVITIES Average clearance time 91% of customs declarations cleared in under 5 minutes Service quality and customer relations 90.5% of businesses satisfied with French Customs Paperless procedures Custom certification 85% 1,020 (AEO) 2,162 of overall customs declarations in 2013 paperless were Authorised Economic Operators (831 in 2012) businesses given free advice (84% in 2012) on how to expand their presence abroad TAXATION Effective taxation €68.23bn in revenue collected by Customs, including €740m in environmental tax 45 euro cents Streamlining 62% of wine harvest declarations submitted electronically 69.5% of customs revenue collected online the cost to French Customs for collecting €100 (47 euro cents in 2012) HUMAN RESOURCES Staffing and resources Vocational training 16,869 6.4 days employees (budgetary posts) as of 31 December 2013 514 departments (offices, units, indirect taxes excluding Customs postal facilities) of ongoing training per employee per year 5 S T H IG L H IG H 3 1 20 6 3 1 5 4 2 FEBRUARY JANUARY •F orty-seven years after Marielle Goitschel, Marion Rolland, skiing with the French Customs team, wins a gold medal in the women’s downhill at the World Ski Championships in Austria (3) •1 60 kg of cocaine seized at Le Havre from a container transporting rice (1) •T wo large-scale seizures of hashish (6.8 and 2.4 tons) at Le Perthus. The drugs were hidden in a load of oranges (4) •F rance’s Minister of Foreign Trade launches a project to streamline customs procedures •A site in Marseille producing counterfeit textiles is broken up MARCH •S eizure of an arsenal of 28 handguns, 17 rifles, grenades, mines and ammunition in Moselle (2) •M ore than 43 kg of heroin, weapons and €150,000 in cash seized in Nancy (Metz DNRED) (5) • Interception in Toulouse of 270,000 toxic button batteries •B reakup of a gang in the south of France with links to organised with excessively high levels of cadmium 8 7 crime. The group was holding illegal lotteries and laundering the proceeds (€1.5m in unpaid tax) (SNDJ) (6) 9 10 11 APRIL •S ignature of an agreement with the University of Alsace for a Master’s course in “International Purchasing” • 7.6 tons of cannabis seized in the Pyrénées-Atlantiques département, thanks to a portable scanner •A t Roissy airport, seizure of nearly 100 kg of scales taken from more than 300 pangolins, an endangered anteater (7) MAY •2 .1 tons of hashish worth more than €10 million seized in Tours in a load of carrots coming from Spain (8) •S eizure in Le Havre of 1.2 million packets of counterfeit aspirin hidden in a load of tea being shipped from China. This represents a record for both France and Europe (9) •M ore than 400 kg of cocaine seized off the coast of the Antilles from a vessel spotted by a French Customs aircraft •1 0,000 packets of counterfeit BN-brand biscuits seized at the port of Marseille following a targeting operation by the Maritime Unit 6 JUNE • First National Counterfeit Destruction Day – at 20 sites, more than 1 million items seized by French Customs are destroyed (10) • Presentation of the Beechcraft KA 350, French Customs’ new multipurpose aircraft, at the International Paris Air Show (11) • The “Customs 2018” conference is held, attended by French ministers and more than 300 French Customs partners. The goal: drafting a medium-term strategic plan for Customs LT S 2013 RESU 16 15 14 12 SEPTEMBER 13 JULY •D etection at Le Havre of an 18-km-long trail of maritime pollution coming from a chemical tanker (14) •S ignature of a Memorandum of Cooperation with FEFIS •F rance’s finance ministry hosts an International (the French Healthcare Industry Federation) with an eye to combating counterfeit healthcare products Experts Conference that brings together more than 300 business leaders around the theme of controlling free-trade agreements in order to encourage exports •F ifth Seminar of European Customs Chemists (250 attendees from 37 countries) (12) •D iscovery of 48 Greek tortoises, an endangered species, in the fairings of a vehicle inspected in the Ile de France region (15) AUGUST •2 0,000 mosquito traps – not in compliance with technical standards •4 7.6 kg of cocaine seized in Cayenne (French Guiana). and dangerous – intercepted at Le Havre in a container shipped from China (13) The drugs were hidden inside vegetables being carried by a passenger (16) •A t the Channel Tunnel, with the help of the Euroscan system, 435 kg of cannabis detected in a load of shrubs being shipped to the UK •A fter being spotted by a French Customs aircraft, a Tanzanian vessel carrying 20 tons of hashish was boarded in the Mediterranean 20 21 19 17 18 NOVEMBER •S eizure of 11 handguns and ammunition during the inspection of a coach near Tours OCTOBER •F ollowing a cooperative effort by French and British Customs, 280 kg of cocaine were found in a sloop that was boarded off the coast of the Antilles •A record seizure of 815 cartons of cigarettes at Roissy airport being carried by passengers (19) •€ 83,480 in counterfeit banknotes intercepted in Le Perthus •A ttended by the Minister for the Budget, celebration of the 10th anniversary of the National Customs Academy (17) •1 0,500 counterfeit luncheon vouchers seized at the Basel-Mulhouse Airport (18) •S eizure, in the Ile-de-France region, of more than 300,000 Chinese-made toys, soft toys and balloons. The items were not in compliance with European technical standards and were deemed to be dangerous and/or toxic DECEMBER • Seizure of 82 kg of smuggled ivory in Poitiers (20) • Th e EMEA Awards 2013: The DNSCE (National Directorate for Foreign Trade Statistics) receives the Innovation in IT Optimisation Award (21) • Th e Cyberdouane unit (Customs Intelligence Directorate) arrests an individual suspected of selling drugs on the “Dark Net” – a first in France 7 CHAPTER 1 RAUD F G IN T T A B M CO In 2013, French Customs’ score improved in every sector. Seizures of drugs reached a record high (a twofold increase in terms of value), and seizures of smuggled tobacco and counterfeits also rocketed (+16% and +65%, respectively). Results were also up in other sectors such as consumer protection and the fight against tax evasion. FIGHTING MAJOR SMUGGLING OPERATIONS PROTECTING CONSUMERS 86 tons of cannabis seized (a threefold increase over 2012 and the best result in 20 years) 7.2 tons of cocaine seized in 2013 (+57%) 430 tons of smuggled tobacco intercepted in 2013 (+16%) 8 Criminal organisations are taking advantage of the many new forms of trade to expand their illegal activities. At the same time, new forms of fraud are emerging. Individuals are increasingly using the Internet as a vehicle for selling counterfeits and fraudulent activities, and also take risks by purchasing all sorts of products online. Drug seizures – an excellent year The results for 2013 reveal a twofold increase in the value of seized drugs (€536m, against €255m in 2012). Seizures of cannabis nearly tripled, and those of cocaine jumped 57%. The most spectacular increase involved khat – there was a tenfold increase in volumes seized in 2013. This is due to tighter regulations in the Netherlands as of 5 January 2013, and in the UK since 23 July 2013. This shift has altered smuggling routes for khat in Europe, and shipments crossing France have increased sharply. Seizures of new psychoactive substances (NPS), including cathinones, synthetic cannabinoids, tryptamines and piperazines, soared in 2013, with 321 kg and 2,071 doses discovered in express and postal shipments. 2013 also witnessed a change in drug traffickers’ modus operandi. In contrast to previous years, the quantities being transported were often smaller than a ton; loads of intercepted cocaine, for example, were often between 150 and 300 kg. In 2013, several seizures of cocaine were carried out by foreign customs authorities following leads provided by French Customs, including 486 kg seized from a vessel by Spanish customs (DAVA), based on intelligence from the National Directorate for Customs Investigations and Intelligence (DNRED). Moreover, 20 tons of cannabis were seized in the Mediterranean in September 2013, from a Tanzanian commercial vessel travelling between Morocco and the Middle East. Increased seizures of smuggled tobacco The good results achieved in previous years continued in 2013. Seizures were up 16% over 2012, for a total of 430 tons. In this respect, land-based seizures represented the lion’s share (40%), but there was also an increase in seizures connected with online purchases by individuals (+6.3%). French Customs is expanding its resources to take action against fraudulent websites with “.fr” domain names, as well as LT S 2013 RESU 35 tons of drugs worth ¤202m, were seized abroad based on intelligence from French Customs 7,113 citations in the area of consumer protection (+16.2%) Under the watchful eye of French Customs, nearly 380,000 noncompliant and dangerous toys were seized in 2013. its interception capacities, particularly in terms of cigarette traceability. Seizures abroad also expanded. Based on information from French Customs, 84 tons of tobacco were intercepted outside of France’s borders. A significant increase in seizures of weapons As part of its ongoing mandate to protect French territory, in 2013 French Customs seized 823 combat and defensive weapons (a twofold increase over 2012). PROTECTING CONSUMERS Increasingly globalised trade means a growing risk for consumers with the import of dangerous goods. French Customs’ remit to protect the health and safety of French consumers has become a priority. The number of cases involving consumer protection increased by 16.2%. Half of all inspections carried out in 2013 involved toys. PROTECTING BUSINESSES BY COMBATTING COUNTERFEITING Despite the effects of the recent Philips/Nokia ruling, there was a marked increase in seizures of counterfeits In 2013, French Customs seized 7.6 million counterfeit items, compared with 4.6 million in 2012. This activity shows no signs of abating. Thus, even though the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that customs may no longer seize counterfeit goods transiting through EU territory if they are not intended for the EU market, seizures of counterfeits within France continue to rise. 823 firearms seized in 2013 (twice as many as in 2012) 7.6 million counterfeit items seized (+65%) (including 1.3 million counterfeit medications) 9 CHAPTER 1 RAUD F COMBATTING PROTECTING FRENCH AND EU TERRITORY French Customs plays an active role in protecting both French and EU territory, alongside the 27 other European customs authorities, and is committed to converging European inspection methods. SAFER TRADE France takes third place in Europe within the Import Control System programme. In 2013, more than 7.3 million Entry Summary Declarations (ENS) were filed in France, compared with 6.6 million in 2010 (+10%). 24,189 seizures from postal and express shipments (+6.3%), including: - 11,381 counterfeit items - 2,746 seizures of tobacco - 2,176 seizures of drugs 10 The 9/11 attacks, recent health scares and the risks inherent to products manufactured on other markets – all have contributed to putting the safety and security of trade flows at the top of every country’s agenda. At the same time, organised crime has taken advantage of globalisation and the growth in world trade to expand and conceal fraudulent activities. French Customs has risen to the challenge of regulating trade. To do so – i.e. to provide a high level of protection for flows of goods without hampering legal trade by businesses exporting to world markets – French customs has developed a set of innovative tools to understand trade flows and to keep international trade transactions secure. A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF FLOWS OF GOODS The Import Control System: a new tool for understanding trade flows The Import Control System (ICS) is the pillar of European customs security. ICS requires that an Entry Summary Declaration (ENS) containing security and safety data be filed with the customs office of first entry within the territory of the EU. Based on the ENS, customs carries out a risk analysis to determine if the goods may enter the customs territory. If there is a confirmed risk, a “Do Not Load” message may be issued to the declarant. Keeping express shipments and postal traffic secure In 2013, French Customs continued its efforts to introduce the Air Cargo Advance Screening (ACAS) system in France. ACAS was developed by the US customs authorities to ensure the safety of express shipments and regular mail. Working with a major express shipment firm, French Customs experimented with electronic data transmission for certain sensitive shipments to the EU regardless of the point-of-entry airport. Following this test phase, which was unique in Europe, the project (known as PRECISE) was extended to standard air freight. At the urging of French Customs, the Universal Postal Union Convention was amended to encompass the concepts of prior electronic data transmission and management of safety risks. Based on the risk analysis, a “Do Not Load” order may be issued by French Customs. Similar to express shipments, the Commission wanted certain Member States to conduct experiments with their postal authorities. In France, tests were conducted on postal shipments from the US between 15 October and 15 November 2013. LT S 2013 RESU In 2013, targeting effectiveness improved 219 citations were issued out of 10,000 verified customs declarations (+63%) Illegal goods sold via e-commerce were a particular target in Customs postal facilities. Datamining: defining new tools to help guide inspections French Customs’ inspection strategy has, for several years now, been based on an information system that combines a dedicated software application for customs declarations (DELTA), an automated targeting and risk management tool (RMS) and a nationwide inspection database (BANACO). In 2011, the system was expanded upstream of the customs clearance process, thanks to the introduction of the Import Control System (ICS), which processes prior, electronic transmission of data about the safety and security of flows of goods. In 2013, French Customs continued to develop BANACO with an eye to achieving a better understanding of the full set of inspections carried out by its various departments. A datamining experiment was also launched in 2013; the idea is to automatically analyse the vast quantity of information received by French Customs and to optimise the effectiveness of inspections by eliminating irrelevant grounds for selection. Providing a high level of protection without disrupting trade flows means improving the inspection selection process. 11 CHAPTER 1 RAUD F COMBATTING INTELLIGENCE AND ANALYSIS To improve its ability to detect new threats, French Customs has expanded its intelligence activities in the legal, regulatory and technological fields. In particular, this intelligence relies on a comparative method under which Customs monitors other countries’ policies and best practices to broaden its understanding. French Customs relies on a network of specialists and analysts including experts in intelligence and regulations, control and legal departments, scientists, laboratories and its own international network (customs attachés in embassies, international technical experts seconded to foreign customs authorities and customs liaison officers within international organisations). data in order to better carry out controls, and to combat terrorism and organised crime. Customs will host the new inter-ministerial platform that will be operational by 2015. To encourage information exchange concerning both freight shipments and travellers, an agreement was signed with the SNCF on 8 January 2013. To improve cooperative efforts, points of contact were designated at both French Customs and at the SNCF. An SNCF employee was also seconded to Customs. Finally, cooperation arrangements between the two parties covering customs inspections in stations and aboard trains were spelled out. EXPANDED INTELLIGENCE EFFORTS AND STEPPED-UP INFORMATION EXCHANGE To combat counterfeit medications, three protocols were signed between December 2012 and July 2013 by French Customs and representative institutions for healthcare professionals. These included the French Federation of Healthcare Industries (FEFIS), the National Agency for Drug and Health Product Safety (ANSM) and the Pharmaceutical Security Institute (PSI), a not-for-profit organisation whose members include the 27 largest pharmaceutical manufacturers. A partnership-based approach to expanding intelligence efforts Increased international technical operational cooperation In 2013, French Customs continued to forge partnerships, particularly with transport firms, to sharpen its understanding of flows of goods. Several agreements were signed with Air France to improve baggage traceability and understanding of flight movements. French Customs’ international network adapts itself to address current issues in the fight against smuggling and in relation to the support provided to French businesses in foreign markets. It has also introduced an inter-departmental unit for strategic analysis, whose job is to detect and anticipate new threats and to modify Customs’ response accordingly. French Customs also was involved in laying the groundwork for the future Passenger Name Record (PNR) system, designed to facilitate access to passenger Customs created a new customs attaché position in Brazil. A presence in this emerging country is important to support French businesses there, but also to expand cooperative anti-trafficking efforts in this sensitive part of the world. A large number of technical cooperative efforts were carried out abroad by French customs experts, with an eye to bolstering the capacities of other customs authorities in the fight against major smuggling operations (drugs, tobacco, counterfeits, etc.). NEW MEANS FOR FIGHTING ORGANISED CRIME French Customs has invested in scientific and technological resources in many areas including IT tools, laboratories, airborne detection devices, vehicles, new airborne resources and maritime patrol vessels, mobile scanners, etc. In 2013, Customs continued to replace its fleet of aircraft, with the purchase of two new Beechcraft planes that will be used for aerial surveillance at sea, and the acquisition of a flight simulator to train crews in the use of this new equipment. A second helicopter was deployed to the Antilles to bolster drug-fighting capacities in this zone. Customs also issued a call for tender for the rollout of a system for developing the operational capacities of its air-maritime resources, the SIAM1. This system will centralise and process information gathered during aerial surveillance at sea. It will improve communication and information exchange between units, thereby ensuring better coordination of resources. An offshore patrol vessel will be added to French Customs’ maritime fleet. Financed in part by the European Commission, it will be deployed in the Mediterranean to carry out customs missions, as well as missions for the French State at sea and the European agency Frontex. France has also ordered four close surveillance vessels. 1. SIAM: Air-Maritime Integrator System. 12 LT S 2013 RESU 245 individuals rescued at sea by French Customs 99 cases of maritime pollution detected (93 in 2012) The new multi-purpose Beechcraft aircraft will be fitted with high-tech equipment. Their greater autonomy means a wider scope of action. With funding from the MILDT2, France has acquired new detection resources. These include, for example, a contract for screening devices that was awarded in 2013, an order for 50 endoscopes, the purchase of particle analysers, 16 night vision goggles for helicopter teams, as well as nearly 100 pairs of image stabilised binoculars. To bolster its automobile fleet, French Customs ordered 118 vehicles and 53 motorcycles in 2013. MAINTAINING FRANCE’S NATURAL HERITAGE The fight against maritime pollution French Customs plays a major role in the fight against maritime pollution. Its airborne resources, which include two aircraft fitted with “POLMAR” ocean pollution detection systems, provide surveillance for France’s coastlines. French Customs’ presence at sea, combined with heavy fines handed down by the courts, act as a strong deterrent for potential polluters. Promising results in the combat against traffic in endangered species French Customs saw a rise of nearly 20% in seizures of endangered species (647 seizures, compared with 541 in 2012). Safeguarding France’s cultural heritage French Customs’ presence at the country’s borders, as well as its legal and investigative powers, allowed it to play a role in safeguarding France’s cultural heritage. It strives to prevent attempts to illegally export historic items and cultural goods. 30,365 analyses carried out on behalf of French Customs by the Joint Laboratory Department (+12.5%) Interceptions of illegal waste transfers: +56.5% 2. MILDT: Joint Ministerial Task Force for Combating Drugs and Drug Addiction. 13 CHAPTER 1 RAUD F COMBATTING COMBATTING FINANCIAL FRAUD AND TAX EVASION €323m in taxes and duties reassessed in 2013 (+9,8%) On 4 February 2013, French Customs intercepted a non-French resident carrying a bearer certificate worth $86 million. The individual was travelling in a vehicle from Switzerland, and was in transit to a country in Latin America. This discovery led to an investigation carried out by the National Customs Judicial Department (SNDJ). In 2013, within the context of governmental guidelines, the fight against illicit financial flows and tax evasion became a priority for customs officials. French Customs has been tasked with enforcing legislation concerning transfers of capital that obliges any traveller entering or leaving France and carrying €10,000 or more to declare this sum to customs. To this end, customs officers are empowered to intercept cash, securities and assets that are being physically transported and that are connected with illegal activities, attempted tax evasion or money-laundering. This declaration requirement gives French Customs a vital tool for gathering information on physical transfers of funds into and out of France. Since February 2013, a new online service, DALIA3, allows users to file declarations via the Prodouane website. In the area of financial fraud, French Customs is introducing new structures. The National Directorate for Customs Investigations and Intelligence (DNRED) has created a group specialising in financial intelligence that provides technical and analytical support to financial investigations. A division of 17 investigators examines financial offences and follow-ups to citations issued by French customs’ inspection services. An operational “Illegal Financial Channels” unit, which was set up in 2013, works closely with 3. DALIA: Déclaration d’Argent Liquide Automatisée (Automated Cash Declaration). 14 the National Customs Judicial Department (SNDJ) and TRACFIN, the French FIU. Customs’ Antiterrorist Operational Group (GOLT), which is part of this unit, processes intelligence on funds that are potentially linked to terrorist networks. In 2013, French Customs played an active role in laying the groundwork for the adoption of the Act of 6 December 2013 concerning the fight against tax evasion and economic and financial crime. Several of the Act’s provisions concern French Customs. The SNDJ’s jurisdiction has been extended to include conspiracy and unlawful assembly, and the Department may use special investigative techniques for major economic and financial crimes. A right to requisition experts, which may be of use to customs officers during inspections and investigations with an eye to detecting sophisticated international tax avoidance schemes, has been created. Lastly, the new Act amends measures for searches of premises to include electronic documents and data (data searches) and expands the list of cash, securities and assets to be declared upon arrival or departure to include prepaid cards, gaming chips and gold. Several proposals for regulatory changes were referred to the European Commission. The National Anti-Fraud Commission, which met in February 2013 under LT S 2013 RESU €132m in undeclared sums (three-fourths of which were intercepted upon arrival in France or in transit, in cash and in number of citations) €31.1m in criminal assets seized or identified by the SNDJ Drug trafficking, arms smuggling, money laundering – French Customs is at the forefront of the fight against organised crime. the chairmanship of the Prime Minister, set national guidelines for coordinating the fight against tax evasion. Several measures had to do with cooperation between French Customs and the Public Finances Directorate General (DGFiP). In this context, Customs and the DGFIP signed a circular concerning information sharing with respect to physical cross-border transfers of cash, securities or assets, with an eye to stepping up the fight against financial fraud and money laundering, as well as terrorist financing. This goal was also behind the signing of the Customs-TRACFIN protocol. It sets out how information is to be shared between the two departments, and provides for the secondment of a Customs liaison officer to TRACFIN. There are other partnerships between French Customs and the OCRGDF4 as well as the OCRFM5. In 2013, French Customs expanded its activity in the area of seizure of criminal assets, with the goal of crippling criminal organisations by tracking down their illegal profits. Total criminal assets seized or identified by the SNDJ increased more than fourfold. Legal proceedings in 2013 following an investigation by the SNDJ: three and a half years in prison and payment of more than €65.5m in damages for one of the leaders of a VAT fraud involving CO2 emissions quotas, for fraud and money-laundering conspiracy (Paris Criminal Court – June 2013). 4. OCRGDF: Office central pour la répression de la grande délinquance financière (Central Office for Serious Financial Crime). 5. OCRFM: Office central pour la répression du faux monnayage (Central Office for Combating Counterfeit Currency). 15 CHAPTER 2 A L U M R O F L A B O A WINNING GL STOMS U C H C N E R F WITH Fighting fraud, protecting French territory and its citizens and collecting tax revenue are all vital missions for French Customs, because they support France’s economy and companies’ efforts to conquer overseas markets as part of legitimate world trade. At a time of heightened competition, French Customs encourages measures that defend businesses’ competitiveness and the appeal of domestic logistical platforms. STREAMLINING AND CUTTING COSTS 85% The overall rate of paperless procedures in 2013 (84% in 2012) For several years, French Customs has been committed to streamlining procedures. The goal is to help businesses free up resources in order to invest more in jobs and means of production. Customs clearance streamlining goals can be summed up in three phrases – facilitation, paperless procedures and reducing both waiting times and cost. LESSENING ADMINISTRATIVE BURDENS WITH THE ONE-STOP SHOP FOR ADMINISTRATIVE FORMALITIES (GUN) AND ONLINE PROCEDURES 12,200 subscribers to the economic newsletter Douane+ (a 350% increase in 2013) 16 Today, the 33 million customs declarations made each year are fully electronic. Nevertheless, specific approvals must be granted for the import and export of goods that may present health, safety or environmental risks. There are 34 such approvals, which are granted by 15 separate government departments. Via the one-stop shop for administrative formalities (GUN), an application compatible with the European Single Window project, French Customs is attempting to link databases in partner administrations with its IT clearance system. Following the complete introduction of paper-free import health certificates, on 2 April 2013, the Interministerial Government Modernisation Council (CIMAP) mandated the Directorate General of Customs and Excise (DGDDI) to do the same with import and export authorisations. In 2013, a pilot phase was conducted on farm export certificates, export licences for military equipment and CITES permits (endangered species). Many more Customs services are now available online. In 2013, no fewer than 23 online procedures were available on the web portal for professionals, pro.douane.gouv.fr. Another site, lekiosque.finances.gouv.fr provides detailed monthly statistical information on international trade by France, and quarterly foreign trade data for France’s regions and départements. Maps of France’s exports and monthly thematic studies can also be consulted. Lastly, the full range of customs regulations can be found on French Customs’ website, www.douane.gouv.fr. This site had more than 5 million visitors in 2013 (a 15% increase). LT S 2013 RESU In the space of 10 years, the average customs clearance time has been cut by two thirds – 23 4 minutes 30 seconds against 13 minutes in 2004 online procedures available for businesses at pro.douane.gouv.fr 33 million electronic customs declarations (+12%) Streamlining and paperless customs formalities contribute to the appeal of French logistical platforms. Customs publishes an e-newsletter specifically for businesses entitled Douane+. Subscribers can get information about changes in regulations, streamlining and new customs tools to help them be competitive on international markets. French Customs also has two smartphone apps, “Douane fr” for travellers on the move and “RIF” (French International Register), which provides tax information concerning commercial shipping and recreational boating. CUTTING WAITING TIMES AND COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH CUSTOMS CLEARANCE The average customs clearance time continues to fall, due to paperless procedures and streamlining. It is also the result of new inspection techniques based on upstream data gathering on flows of goods, an analysis of the risks of each transaction as well as targeting. Inspections are now focused on “sensitive” goods. Cutting waiting times and lowering costs helps businesses be more competitive when it comes to the current challenges of world trade (just-in-time production, falling costs, speed, fluidity, safety). At the same time, by focusing on “sensitive” trade flows, French Customs is more effective in its efforts to fight fraud and protect French territory and French citizens. 17 CHAPTER 2 CH CUSTOMS REN RMULA WITH F O F L A B O L G A WINNING SUPPORT FOR THE COMPETITIVENESS OF BUSINESSES ABROAD In 2013, 90.5% of businesses were satisfied with Customs’ services Source: People Vox survey, December 2013 France is in 12th place worldwide (out of 155 countries) in the area of logistics and customs Source: World Bank Logistics Performance Index, May 2012 Out of twenty-five countries, France is 2 number in implementing intellectual property protection Source: 2014 American Chamber of Commerce Index The new Union Customs Code entered into force on 30 October 2013. 18 On 23 September 2013, French Customs launched the “Tour de France des Experts” under the slogan “Overseas Success”. This is the first stage of a national campaign to inform businesses about the many ways Customs can help them win export market share, develop overseas markets and increase their competitiveness. French Customs assembled 300 business leaders at the Finance Ministry and explained how they could have better control over rules of origin, discussed free-trade agreement measures and presented the Approved Exporter status. One-to-one meetings were offered. HELPING BUSINESSES TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE NEW UNION CUSTOMS CODE French Customs put a great deal of effort into the new Union Customs Code (UCC), which was issued on 30 October 2013. By supplying European businesses with the tools they need to stay competitive, the new Code represents a major step forward in helping Europe adapt to globalisation. and May 2016, the date on which the UCC comes into effect. In 2013, the Customs Union reached a watershed in its history. A newly-formed group of 15 directors-general for customs proposed a new governance model with an eye to expanding harmonised practices and steering tools. To limit deflection of trade, France recommended increased pooling of certain procedures and resources for the purpose of risk and crisis management. HELPING BUSINESSES WITH THEIR INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS Businesses’ overseas strategies increasingly involve taking account of customs issues. To help businesses prepare their international transactions and keep them secure, French Customs provides a set of free professional tools. These help companies estimate how much tax and excise they owe and help them perfect their customs strategies. The UCC, and concepts such as centralised clearance and the status of Authorised Economic Operator (AEO), emphasise to an even greater extent the European nature of customs regulations. With the Binding Tariff Information (BTI) system, an AFNOR-certified instrument, a business may, prior to an import or export operation, submit an online request to French Customs to receive the tariff classification of its goods. This classification forms the basis of the taxes and excise to be paid and the formalities to be carried out. In 2013, a total of 7,926 BTIs were issued. For businesses wishing to expand into world markets, AEO status is becoming an invaluable passport. It is valid in all Member States but is recognised abroad (US, Japan, Switzerland, etc.). It provides access to cutting-edge streamlined customs procedures and reduced inspections. The UCC’s implementing provisions will be gradually introduced between now French Customs is also committed to clarifying product origins with the Binding Origin Information (BOI) system. This system provides information about the origin of goods (whether preferential, non-preferential or “made in”). Finally the Value for Customs Purposes (Avis sur la Valeur en Douane – AVD) notice allows businesses to determine the value that should be declared to customs. LT S 2013 RESU 166 BOIs 66 AVDs and issued in 2013 (+43% and +18%, respectively, over 2012) In 2013, businesses made 1,785 requests for Customs to help protect them against counterfeits (+13% over 2012) Launch of the “Tour de France des Experts” at the French Finance Ministry. IMPROVING FLOW TRACEABILITY TO BOLSTER THE APPEAL OF FRANCE’S LOGISTICAL PLATFORMS In 2013, a key element in discussions at the Customs/Business Forum concerned performance issues at both ports and airports. One of the points focused on improving the flow of information when freight transits through seaport and airport platforms. During the year, French Customs continued its efforts to introduce the Cargo Information Network, a tool for tracing goods at Roissy airport. INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY PROTECTION: A NATIONWIDE EVENT BASED ON KEY LEGISLATIVE REFORM On 11 June 2013, French Customs launched the first National Counterfeit Destruction Day in order to raise awareness of the dangers that counterfeiting poses to both the economy and to health and safety. More than one million counterfeit items were simultaneously destroyed in every region of France. As regards legislation, French Customs was very much involved in a number of draft bills, some of which were adopted in 2013. At European level, new Regulation (EU) No 608/2013 of 12 June 2013 concerning customs enforcement of intellectual property rights and repealing Council Regulation (EC) No 1383/2003 will enter into force on 1 January 2014. Customs authorities are now competent to enforce other intellectual property rights with regards to goods. The Regulation facilitates the processing of applications for action and simplifies the procedure for destroying counterfeit items. It also fosters information-sharing between customs authorities and rights holders. Talks are underway on the Directive and Regulation relating to trademarks. In these talks, French Customs is pushing hard for the resumption of inspections of non-EU goods suspected of being counterfeits that are in transit, undergoing transshipment or under duty suspension arrangements. These inspections have been on hold since the Nokia-Philips decision handed down by the Court of Justice of the European Union on 1 December 2011. As part of the 2009-2012 EU Customs Action Plan to Combat Intellectual Property Rights Infringement (which has been renewed for 2013-2017) and within the framework of Regulation No 608/2013, French Customs has laid the groundwork for the introduction of the SOPRANOCOPIS application. Ultimately, using this online tool, rights holders will be able to file, amend or renew applications for action. It will be connected to the European application COPIS6. An Act to help bolster anti-counterfeiting efforts was drafted in 2013 and is currently being adopted, following a unanimous vote on first reading in both the Senate and National Assembly. It will provide French Customs with a battery of legal tools to combat all types of counterfeiting through increased powers of intervention, including legal authority, thus bringing domestic measures into line with European law. 6. Anti-Counterfeit and anti-Piracy Information System: an automated European-wide system for registering and disseminating companies’ applications for action. 19 CHAPTER 2 CH CUSTOMS REN RMULA WITH F O F L A B O L G A WINNING A CUSTOMISED APPROACH TO BUSINESSES The Large Business Task Force – working with 104 major firms that represent more 50% than of France’s foreign trade 4,382 Authorised Exporters (3,678 at the end of 2012) “3S” stands for “Service, Streamlining and Security”. It also represents a trust pact of French Customs, committed to improving the service provided to businesses. 20 For two decades, French customs has continuously customised its relations with users. Through dedicated offices providing advice to businesses, both in Paris and throughout France, French Customs shows its commitment to supporting the French economy. Today, the range of customs consulting services is wider than ever, and Customs is increasingly positioning itself as an “operator” and is providing certification for companies. ADVICE TAILORED TO BUSINESSES’ NEEDS Overtime, French Customs has built a relationship of trust with businesses. Some of the key steps include the introduction of Business Consulting Units within the Regional Customs Directorates (1992), the Infos Douane Service national call centre (2005), the regional economic development hubs (2005), the Large Business Task Force (2006) and the SME Unit (2008). A customised relationship is built on listening to businesses, answering their questions and providing information on regulations and how they are applied. But Customs’ involvement goes much further. It contacts SMEs directly, offering free personalised meetings in order to help them optimise their customs procedures. French Customs’ “3S” quality approach embodies a desire to offer businesses a coherent service. Working groups that brought together businesses and customs officials drew up a list of ten service commitments that French Customs introduced. After customs clearance, the “3S” quality approach was extended to the winegrowing and alcohol sector in late 2013. FRENCH CUSTOMS’ “LABELLING” – CERTIFICATION FOR ECONOMIC OPERATORS The process of certification is part of French Customs’ strategy of catering for businesses. To this end, in order to streamline export procedures and keep them secure, Customs has introduced the Authorised Exporter (AE) status. This status is stipulated in free-trade agreements between the EU and its partner countries, and is proof that exporting firms fully understand the rules of origin. For certain trade relationships (EU/South Korea) it is mandatory. A second customs label, the Authorised Economic Operator (AEO) status, is fast becoming an indispensable tool for export. It reconciles compliance with security and safety obligations with the need for speed in legitimate trade transactions. Trusted operators are granted certain advantages, including trading fluidity with countries that have signed Mutual Recognition Agreements (Japan, US, Switzerland, etc.), lighter administrative burdens, exemption from financial guarantees, more favourable conditions, customs clearance at domicile, etc. FOR BUSINESSES WITH A STRONG INTERNATIONAL PRESENCE, A SINGLE POINT OF CONTACT In addition to consulting services, businesses today are demanding fully customised treatment. In its five-year strategic plan, French Customs plans to expand the use of a single contact person for economic issues. This person will be able to provide advice as well as procedure attribution and management. LT S 2013 RESU In 2013, French Customs’ Economic Development Centres provided free advice to 2,162 businesses (in four years, they have offered customised support for nearly 10,000 businesses – or 10% of the country’s foreign trade) Free-trade agreements and rules of origin – French Customs provides advice to businesses during a theme day at the Finance Ministry. Taking more of an “operator” approach, French Customs wishes to further improve the quality of the service it offers and provide operators that are heavily involved in international trading with uniform treatment for all of their transactions. Additional initiatives are planned to personalise Customs’ treatment for each operator. More favourable conditions and even inspections are largely based on operators’ reliability, as well as their ability to supply accurate information and ensure the traceability of their trading. Increasingly, accountability and strict supply chain management are prerequisites for the granting of favourable customs conditions. In this way, Customs supports legitimate trade flows and can focus its attention on sensitive exchanges, thus providing effective protection at both domestic and European level. 1,020 Authorised Economic Operators (831 in 2012) 21 CHAPTER 3 TIES U D E H T G IN M REFOR S M O T S U C Y B D COLLECTE In 2013, French Customs collected more than €68bn in duties and taxes, an increase over 2012 (€67.9bn) This revenue is allocated to the central government budget, local authorities, social security organisations and the European Union. MAKING COLLECTION MORE EFFECTIVE REDUCING INTERVENTION RATES €68.23bn collected in 2013 (€67.9bn in 2012) To provide a better, lower-cost service, efforts to reform tax-collection procedures were carried forward in 2013. BOLSTERING TAXPAYER COMPLIANCE French Customs carries out audits to combat fraud, but also to encourage taxpayer compliance. Doing so involves coordination between the departments responsible for regulations, inspections and investigations. The increased use of datamining and targeting means that the efforts can be focussed on high-stake sectors such as energy and environmental taxation and on excise duties on alcoholic beverages. French Customs applies the “Excise Duties Audit” Charter. The code clarifies the role and the authority of French Customs and also encourages the acceptability of the audits that it carries out. The idea is to expand taxpayer compliance and inform users of their rights. STREAMLINING CUSTOMS DUTIES 69.5% of all customs revenue is collected online 22 By simplifying taxation schemes and reforming how tax transactions are processed, particularly through the use of online procedures, French Customs continued its efforts to improve the quality of service provided to users. Starting in 2013, receivables resulting from online customs clearance declarations (DELTA) and declarations of energy product consumption (ISOPE) must be settled using tele-payment. Formally this was optional. This also includes taxes on certain road vehicles (the so-called axle tax). Using this new online service, users can settle customs payments and monitor them in real time. This keeps operators’ banking fees down and offers an easy, quick and secure method of payment. By the end of 2013, 69.5% of customs revenue (€47.4bn) was collected online. There were 3,227 subscriber operators in 2013, a fourfold increase over the previous year. LT S 2013 RESU 62 % In 2013, of wine harvest declarations were made online Starting on 1 January 2013, paperless procedures were extended to registration of pleasure craft. The former “orange notebook” system, so familiar to pleasure craft operators, is being progressively replaced by a pre-filled form. To lighten the administrative burden on both users and professionals, French Customs tested a “Navigation One-Stop Shop”, in partnership with the Marennes and La Rochelle Maritime Affairs Departments. In 2013, the tele-payment system for the yearly registration duty was expanded to include new functionalities, such as computerised management of all types of pleasure craft, including jet skis, which are now subject to annual registration and navigation duty. French customs is also expanding its electronic VAT refund system, known as PABLO. The new measure, which was drawn up in 2013, will be introduced as of 1 January 2014. It will electronically stamp export sales forms. Electronic stamping makes the procedure faster, eliminates the return of the form by post and means that travellers can obtain an immediate VAT refund at a reimbursement window. French Customs has heightened its efforts to support winegrowers by lightening their administrative burden and improving the quality of the service provided to sector professionals. French Customs is in charge of the computerised vineyard register (CVI), which manages the entire winemaking sector. To lighten the declarative burden on French winegrowers, it has introduced modern online reporting procedures. Efforts are underway to introduce the new computerised vineyard register (nCVI), which will provide a one-stop shop for professionals and complete management for this very important sector of the French economy. In 2013, development entered its final phase, the rewriting of the land management modules (database of land parcels, along with their administrative and cultural characteristics, planting rights, etc.). This major, country-wide effort will be completed in 2016. When this phase is completed, the nCVI will give sector management departments (French Customs, DGCCRF, INAO, FranceAgriMer, etc.), professionals and operators access to sector data and online declarations made via the Prodouane website. The new computerised vineyard register (currently in its final stages of development) will make it easy to access information about this sector. The cost of collecting customs revenue continues to fall – €0.45 for each €100 collected (an intervention rate of 0.45, against 0.47 in 2012) 23 CHAPTER 3 S ED BY CUSTOM IES COLLECT MING THE DUT REFOR THE FUTURE OF CUSTOMS DUTIES ¤740m in General Tax on Polluting Activities (TGAP) revenue collected in 2013 Through taxation, French Customs regulates certain economic sectors, including winemaking, tobacco and energy products, and provides support for public policy. In the environmental sphere, customs tax revenue encourages good behaviour and dampens the environmental impact of certain activities. EXPANDING ENVIRONMENTAL TAXATION ¤11.46bn in consumption duties on tobacco products collected Since the introduction of the General Tax on Polluting Activities (TGAP) in 1999 for which French Customs is responsible for both collection and auditing, the scope of environmental taxation has expanded. In 2013, €740m in TGAP revenue was collected by Customs (a 1.4% increase over 2012), more than half of which was for waste. The revenue was primarily assigned to the French Environment and Energy Management Agency (ADEME). In 2013, the TGAP was extended to include new substances, and rate changes are pegged to the French consumer price index. SUPPORT FOR ECONOMIC OPERATORS In the energy field, in addition to sizable revenue collections, French Customs provided regulation for this sector at every level. It inspected imports, refineries, stocks, including strategic stockpiles, and transport. In 2013, several measures were taken to reduce the financial expenses borne 24 by international traders. These include extending the deposit exemption to taxes due on imports and to customs procedures with economic impact, as well as certain transactions carried out by small operators. In the tobacco sector, French customs collected €11.46bn in consumption duties on tobacco products in metropolitan France. The entire amount was allocated to the social security budget. French Customs’ efforts are not limited to collecting taxes. The third performance contract between the government and tobacconists (2012-2016) was carried forward. The contract provides support for tobacconists experiencing hardship, offers better visibility on the outlook for this profession and includes a commitment from tobacconists to help strengthen public policies to discourage smoking. SUPPORTING THE DEVELOPMENT OF MAYOTTE As part of Mayotte’s changeover to département status, in 2013 French Customs played an active role in introducing dock dues, which took effect on 1 January 2014. This represents a key element in the island’s taxation and in financing the local authority. Dock dues provide resources for the budgets of the département and its communities, and encourages the development of local businesses, thanks to the introduction of an exemption scheme. LT S 2013 RESU ¤36.8bn in energy taxes collected French Customs regulates the energy sector. BREAKDOWN OF REVENUE COLLECTED BY FRENCH CUSTOMS IN 2013 BY BENEFICIARY Social Security Organisations 22.5% Central government 54.2% Local authorities 18.1% Other 2.5% European Union 2.7% MAIN TAXES COLLECTED IN 2013 Other taxes 2.2% Taxes on energy products 35.6% General Tax on Polluting Activities 1.1% Fuel taxes in overseas départements 0.7% Dock dues and similar taxes 1.6% VAT on petrol 17.2% Customs duties 2.7% Alcohol, wine, beverages 6.3% VAT on imports 15.4% Tobacco 17.3% 25 CHAPTER 4 RT A E H E H T F F A MAKING ST OMS T S U C ’S W O R OF TOMOR Throughout 2013, a strategic five-year plan for French Customs was drawn up. The plan is a response to a request, by the ministers responsible for the economy, foreign trade and the budget, that “the Directorate General of Customs and Excise carry out its mandates in a more efficient manner, in line with the best practices of EU customs administrations, to support the competitiveness of the French economy, effective and responsive taxation, and the protection of France’s territories and citizens, while striving to provide the best working conditions for its employees”. A STRATEGIC PLAN TO PROVIDE FRENCH CUSTOMS WITH FRESH MOMENTUM BUILDING THE CUSTOMS OF 2018 The goal of the strategic plan is simple – bolstering French Customs’ role as the department responsible for trade regulation and the monitoring of flows of goods, in order to cope with the major issues and challenges of 2018. Budgetary positions: 16,869 full-time equivalent positions The strategic plan sets out broad guidelines for French Customs, with the goal of providing greater visibility for both its partners and its staff. The plan is the result of a year’s worth of extensive talks in which a number of departments took part. A discussion forum was set up for the occasion. A number of French Customs’ partners, both in France and abroad, were also brought in. The crowning point of the consultation process was a meeting on 28 June 2013, which brought together, around the ministers concerned, nearly 350 individuals – customs officers, business leaders, professional organisations, logistics professionals, economists, academics, consumer groups, journalists and members of civil society. They shared their vision of how the customs environment will change over the next five years. The Douane 2018 strategic plan incorporates changes in international trade with continuing growth in trading, as well as new forms of trade and the emergence of underlying risks. The plan 26 calls for greater professionalism in risk analysis, inspections and fraud-fighting efforts, in order to better protect France’s territory, citizens and businesses. Douane 2018 will be an innovative plan when it comes to support for businesses. It calls for greater professionalism in relations with businesses, whether multinationals or SMEs, in order to support their development and their competitiveness in global markets. It is based on changes in European regulations to support the development of French logistical platforms. Douane 2018 will also introduce reforms and streamlining in the area of taxation. To meet these goals, French Customs will increase its professionalism and leadership based on stronger structures at both national and inter-regional level, which will guide the action of the various departments, whether dealing with inspection, fraud-fighting, economic policy or tax collection. The regional level will be refocused on operational support for departments. Through this strategic plan, French Customs is playing its part in government streamlining and modernisation efforts. LT S 2013 RESU 53.8% 46.2% of staff involved in commercial transactions and general administration of staff involved in surveillance Main entrance to the Directorate General of Customs and Excise in Montreuil. Over the next five years, the strategic plan will introduce incremental changes in the way French Customs operates, its primary activities and its organisation. French Customs is aware of the efforts demanded of its staff, and will pay particular attention to providing support for these reforms. The strategic plan not only assigns priorities in terms of service provided to users, but also focuses on reforming working conditions, and on taking account of the career goals and professional plans of its employees. Training courses and teaching methods will be overhauled to lay the groundwork for these occupational changes. Special attention will be given to the working conditions for implementing these changes. Forward planning for HR will be revitalised with a view to improving hiring policies and personnel management practices. NEW WORKING METHODS Updating internal procedures and becoming a benchmark government administration Efforts to reengineer working processes, which were launched in late 2011, were carried forward in 2013. The goal is to improve effectiveness, provide greater service quality for users and manage risks better, as well as to introduce one of the most highly developed internal control systems. Senior field staff, who are at the heart of these efforts, identify business processes that need to be improved or streamlined to lessen the burden on the various departments, while enhancing the quality of service provided to users. In addition, a best practices code governing thoughtful consumption and sustainable development was adopted. It includes reducing paper consumption, substituting videoconferences for business travel, better waste management by recycling, and developing an energy-saving mindset. Innovative service provision to adapt to a changing world To structure this tactical approach and provide guidelines for all those involved in combating road transport-based fraud, a networked working group was set up at local level. This led to the creation of Topographic Reference Documents (Documents Topographiques de Référence – DTR). These reference materials provide a local, practical guide to the tactical approach – they set out the various interception methods along with the required human and material resources. Local management can thus choose the most appropriate methodology, share resources and good practices and improve mission planning. Unit heads are thus provided with support for leading their teams, and customs officers better understand their role and how it connects with that of their co-workers. Given the expansion of free-flow toll collection and the emergence of more extreme forms of fraud, French Customs’ land-based surveillance teams are improving their tactical approach to inspections. The goal is to maintain effectiveness while ensuring safe and secure interventions for all road users, whether customs officers or the general public. 27 CHAPTER 4 S OW’S CUSTOM R R O M O T F O F THE HEART MAKING STAF IMPROVING THE WORKPLACE AND FOSTERING DIALOGUE BETWEEN LABOUR AND MANAGEMENT IMPROVING HEALTH, SAFETY AND THE QUALITY OF WORKING CONDITIONS The Human Resources Service Centre (CSRH) is not just a different tool – it represents a thorough overhaul of HR attributions with a view to providing a higher quality service for everyone. 3,092 one-to-one interviews with members of staff in 2013 The DGDDI is thoroughly committed to preventing psychosocial risks within its departments. To do so, it has set up a “Workplace Well-being” steering committee, whose members include staff representatives. Guidelines for preventing psychosocial risks were drafted in 2013. The goal of these guidelines is to seek joint solutions to the issues involved. A pilot phase was launched in the second half of 2013 within an inter-regional directorate, and the guidelines will be rolled out nationwide in early 2014. In 2014, management will be given training in the importance of quality working conditions, and every member of staff will received a guide to preventing workplace risks. Lastly, as part of the Ministry for the Civil Service’s efforts to draft a code of conduct, an action plan was launched. Women represent 37.1% of all staff MODERNISING RESOURCES While controlling spending, French Customs is working to maintain its operational capacity in order to combine efficient service provision with staff security. In an effort to combine safety and comfort, the uniforms of motorcycle 28 teams now include innovative safety equipment, such as airbags. Clothing items that were originally restricted to high-altitude teams have been more widely deployed. Following the accidental rupture of a pistol breach in early 2013, a steppedup weapons inspection plan was put in place. To better protect customs officers against increasingly determined criminal gangs, 900 bulletproof vests were ordered in 2013, and ergonomic tests were carried out jointly with the police, the gendarmerie and the prison administration. French Customs is continuing to upgrade its computers, office equipment and applications. The Customs IT Centre (CID) in Cergy-Pontoise is being overhauled to enable the IT system to expand and to make customs applications more available to users. In-house, a new e-mail system, Mercure, has been rolled out. Its advanced functionalities allow staff to work in groups and in project mode. Several real estate transactions in 2013 improved working conditions and stepped up French Customs’ operational capacities. The most important of these involved new premises for the Le Havre laboratory and for the Customs Judicial Department Unit in Metz. A plan to combine the Customs laboratories in Paris and Massy-Palaiseau is currently being examined. LT S 2013 RESU e-training 33 training topics 167 vocational training courses, 261 training sessions organised in 2013 Lecture theatre of the National Customs Academy in Tourcoing, which trains customs managers. IMPROVING HR MANAGEMENT – A QUALITATIVE APPROACH MODERNISING HR MANAGEMENT Since September 2013, French Customs has been testing an ambitious programme for modernising and improving HR management. This is centred around a national Human Resources Service Centre (CSRH) located in Bordeaux, which is slated to automate the administrative and payroll management for 17,000 customs officers. To do so, a complex programme for upgrading existing applications and creating new ones was launched. Automation will boost HR management quality through new functionalities that staff can access online (registration for promotion lists and aptitude lists, part-time work and holiday requests, access to individual staff files, etc.). The new system will be guided by the spirit of open access. The new HR Service Centre will reshape HR attributions within French Customs: central departments will focus on setting HR policies, while local HR departments will develop quality-based HR management, and will, in particular, provide support for staff in terms of career paths, training, dialogue between management and labour and career advice. CUSTOMISED SUPPORT FOR STAFF In a constantly changing environment, members of staff need visibility about their individual situation and their career. Customised support is based on a panoply of interviews in order to assess each staff member’s family and personal circumstances. In 2013, all of the parties involved, including the network of social liaison officers in each regional customs directorate, continued their efforts to provide employees with a high level of service. Moreover, in line with its commitment to update its HR policy, French Customs tested, in the second half of the year, a national Consulting, Mobility and Career Development Unit. Officially inaugurated in January 2014, the Unit offers career development meetings for every member of French Customs’ staff. The goal of this confidential interview is to provide advice for staff throughout their professional career, with a view to analysing and enhancing their career paths, and to point them towards sensible career changes within French Customs or, if need be, towards external options (jobseeking help, assistance with CVs and cover letters, identifying training needs, etc.). These interviews also are used to examine employees’ skill sets in order to seek the best match between profiles and positions. 29 CHAPTER 4 S OW’S CUSTOM R R O M O T F O F THE HEART MAKING STAF The new “training path” concept represents a profound shift in training methods, which up to now have been structured by activity sector. IMPROVED SKILLS MANAGEMENT New training concepts French Customs has committed to taking a clearer, more proactive approach to career development in order to better cope with changes to specialised positions and encourage flexibility in its employees. To expand its range of training courses, French Customs is developing e-learning and is also using mobile training units. E-learning allows staff to follow a course at their own pace, based on each individual’s workload. In 2013, the e-learning catalogue contained 301 training resources grouped under more than 30 headings. The most recent additions include training in inspecting express freight, the axle tax and the fight against smuggling of cultural goods. Measures concerning specialised positions (35.2% of the total) are designed to match staff with posts (initial training, gaining professional experience, vocational training, etc.). Improved methods for defining these positions provide staff with greater visibility for all available positions. ENHANCING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF VOCATIONAL TRAINING 6.4 days of training per year and per employee in 2013 (a national average of 5.7) 2013 – creation of the Consulting, Mobility and Career Development Unit 30 With the introduction of the Douane 2018 strategic plan, vocational training is seen as a critical element in helping both employees and departments cope with changing professions. Ongoing efforts to set up the new Customs Academy in La Rochelle Efforts continued to prepare for the opening of the new National Customs Academy in La Rochelle in September 2015. It will house the training organisations currently located in Rouen, which train B- and C-class employees in charge of inspecting commercial flows, as well as those in La Rochelle, which provide training for surveillance employees. The new Academy will also be the occasion to introduce a new pedagogic approach based on a common training core, which will introduce a single “Customs culture” and foster the sharing of skills and synergies. Customs-specific training Roaming customs controls in which vehicles are taken out of traffic flows and inspected are becoming a common method of intervention. To teach drivers the necessary techniques for carrying out these controls as safely as possible, a special training course was set up. It consists of a day in the classroom, in which trainees go over the rules of the procedure, safety issues and the French Highway Code, with a second day devoted to hands-on training. In 2013, 1,142 customs staff attended a total of 124 training sessions. In the maritime sector, French Customs has teams specialised in inspecting confined areas aboard commercial vessels moored at dock. A specific training course was established. The initial phase of the training took place over a ten-day period in November 2013 at the La Rochelle Academy, using a specially-commissioned simulator that mimics the atmosphere and the working conditions in tight spaces. The training was completed with exercises aboard commercial vessels in the port of La Pallice. LT S 2013 RESU Specialised surveillance staff: 659 maritime officers 275 motorcyclists 251 dog handlers 187 airborne officers 414 investigators 206 judicial officers Training sessions are designed to minimise risks during inspections. Partnerships with universities French Customs has carried forward its policy of reaching out to the academic world, with a view to knowledge-sharing and better adapting higher education training to the needs of businesses. There are currently 15 partnerships in place with technical universities, and others with higher education institutions such as the ISTELI (Higher Institute for Transport and International Logistics), to provide training for individuals and businesses making customs declarations, and with ISEL (Higher Institute for Logistical Studies in Le Havre), which offers a degree in logistical engineering with a focus on customs, and a university degree in customs. 21 skiers from the French Customs Team were selected for the Sochi Winter Olympics OUR VALUES: HARD WORK, SOLIDARITY AND SETTING AN EXAMPLE FOR OTHERS More details about the team’s performances are available from the official website, equipefrancedouane.fr. The France Douane team – sporting values that are an inspiration Support for customs associations Since 1967, French Customs has sponsored high-level sports. This is a way of showing its commitment to sporting values such as courage, perseverance, striving for performance and team spirit – all values that are shared by its employees. The French Customs Team (Équipe de France Douane) team currently hosts 40 experienced and younger athletes belonging to six Olympic federations – athletics, fencing, judo, skiing, shooting and sailing. Their devotion to their fields of endeavour helps make France a worldwide contender and enhances French Customs’ reputation. In 2013, the team won eight world champion and seven vice-world champion medals in skiing. They also took home a vice-champion title in judo and two European titles in athletics. Customs staff belong to a network of non-profit associations. French Customs provides support for them in order to promote cohesion among the customs community, via the solidarity that such actions convey. These associations include the Œuvre des Orphelins des Douanes (ODOD), the Mutuelle des Douanes, the Association for the History of the French Customs Administration (AHAD), and the National Customs Sporting Association (ASND), which boasts more than 3,000 members. La Masse, a public establishment, manages 3,400 social housing units throughout France that accommodate customs employees. 31 B A S I C FAC T S A B O U T F R E N C H C U S T O M S OPERATIONAL ORGANISATION OF THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF CUSTOMS AND EXCISE (DGDDI) Directorate General 12 Inter-regional Directorates 40 Regional Tax Collection Offices 78 Territorial Divisions 42 Regional Directorates 179 Customs Offices including 14 Customs Postal Centres* 76 Excise Departments 214 Land-based Units * Customs postal centre: an inspection department within a postal sorting centre. 4 Regional Coast Guard Directorates - Antilles - Marseille - Nantes - Rouen 7 National Departments National Customs Judicial Department (SNDJ) National Directorate for Customs Investigations and Intelligence (DNRED) DGDDI / DGCCRF Joint Laboratory Department (SCL) 8 Local SNDJ Units - Paris - Lille - Metz - Lyon - Marseille - Toulouse - Bordeaux - Nantes Customs Intelligence Directorate (DRD) 11 Joint Laboratories - Ile-de-France - Lille - Strasbourg - Lyon - Marseille - Montpellier - Bordeaux - Rennes - Le Havre - Antilles (Guadeloupe) - La Réunion Customs Investigations Directorate (DED) Customs Operations Directorate (DOD) 11 DOD Offices - Paris - Lille - Metz - Lyon - Marseille - Montpellier - Toulouse - Bordeaux - Nantes - Rouen - Fort-de-France 45 Airborne-naval Units Tourcoing National Customs Academy Grade A National Directorate for Recruitment and Vocational Training (DNRFP) 2 Departments - St-Pierre-et-Miquelon - Wallis and Futuna National Directorate for Foreign Trade Statistics (DNSCE) Customs IT Centre (CID) National Customs Museum (MND) - Bordeaux 32 Rouen National Customs Academy Grades B and C OP-CO/AG Branch La Rochelle National Customs Units Academy Grades B and C SURV Branch LT S 2013 RESU THE DGDDI IN METROPOLITAN FRANCE AND OVERSEAS Paris (DI) Paris (DR) MAP OF FRENCH CUSTOMS’ REGIONAL (DR) AND INTERREGIONAL (DI) DIRECTORATES Roissy (DI) Roissy Fret (DR) Roissy Voyageurs (DR) Paris-Est (DR) Paris-Ouest (DR) Dunkerque (DR) Lille (DI) Lille (DR) Orly (DR) Picardie (DR) Le Havre (DR) Champagne-Ardenne (DR) Basse-Normandie (DR) Rouen (DI) Rouen (DR) Coast Guard (DR) Metz (DI) Lorraine (DR) Brittany (DR) Strasbourg (DR) Mulhouse (DR) Nantes (DI) Pays-de-la-Loire (DR) Coast Guard (DR) Centre (DR) Dijon (DI) Burgundy (DR) Franche-Comté (DR) Poitiers (DR) Léman (DR) Auvergne (DR) Antilles-Guiana (DI) Martinique (DR) Coast Guard (DR) Lyon (DI) Lyon (DR) Bordeaux (DI) Bordeaux (DR) Bayonne (DR) Guadeloupe (DR) Chambéry (DR) Provence (DR) Midi-Pyrénées (DR) Montpellier (DI) Montpellier (DR) Guiana (DR) Mayotte (DR) Marseille (DI) Marseille (DR) Coast Guard (DR) Perpignan (DR) Overseas Communities Réunion (DR) Nice (DR) New Caledonia (DR) Corse (DR) French Polynesia (DR) Customs departments in: Saint-Pierre and Miquelon Wallis and Futuna 33 B A S I C FAC T S A B O U T F R E N C H C U S T O M S FRENCH CUSTOMS AROUND THE WORLD IN 2013 Primary cooperation agreements signed in 2013 Agreement with Spain’s Department of Customs and Special Taxes regarding operational cooperation with respect to aerial surveillance at sea. Memorandum of Understanding with DP World Callao SRL, the managing authority of the Callao private cargo port in Peru, to prevent drug trafficking. National Targeting Centre Cooperation agreement between the National Directorate for Customs Investigations and Intelligence (DNRED) and the Naval Intelligence Directorate of the Colombian Navy (JINA). French Embassy Memorandum of Understanding concerning a mutual assistance agreement for customs issues with Cape Verde. Memorandum of Understanding with the Albanian Directorate General of Customs. Memorandum of Understanding with Customs Authorities of the Union of the Comoros and Madagascar, and the customs division of the Seychelles Revenue Commission. Administrative cooperation agreement with the New Zealand Customs Service. 34 Herndorn Regulation concerning implementation of a bilateral cooperation mechanism between Columbia and France. Miami Caracas French Embassy Bogotá French Embassy São Paulo French Embassy LT S 2013 RESU Brussels Geneva France’s Permanent Representation to the European Union World Customs Organization (WCO) – European Commission (EC) United Nations (UN) Cologne Lyon Luxembourg World Customs Organization (WCO) Europol - Interpol European Court of Auditors General Court of the European Union European Institute of Public Administration Frankfurt Madrid European Central Bank French Embassy Berlin The Hague Prague Belgrade Vienna French Embassy French Embassy - Europol European Global Navigation Satellite System Agency French Embassy ADETEF Serbia International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Washington French Embassy International Monetary Fund (IMF) World Bank – French Consulate London Sofia Moscow French Embassy French Embassy French Embassy Almaty ADETEF Kazakhstan Beijing French Embassy Tripoli Cooperation Dubai French Embassy Rabat Ouagadougou French Embassy Cooperation Brazzaville ADETEF - Republic of Congo Moroni Nouakchott Dakar Cooperation Cooperation French Embassy - Cooperation Conakry Niamey Bamako Cotonou Cooperation Cooperation Cooperation Cooperation * Seconded or assigned 35 B A S I C FAC T S A B O U T F R E N C H C U S T O M S CAPACITIES BUDGETARY RESOURCES (In millions of euros, excluding the Joint Laboratory Department and excluding contributions to the special pensions allocation account) 2010 2011 2012 2013 Staff 797.8 797.7 798.4 798.4 Operations and miscellaneous expenditure 166.9 167.5 162.7 170.6 Interventions 298.7 299.7 271.8 253.8 31 25.5 32.9 38.6 1,294.4 1,290.4 1,265.8 1,261.4 361.9 393.4 320.1 336.1 Investment Total Contributions to the special pensions allocation account MATERIAL RESOURCES Land-based fleet Number of 2012 2013 Motor vehicles 2,815 2,710 433 449 2 2 19-to-32-metre coast guard patrol boats 19 19 10-to-14-metre inshore patrol vessels 17 17 3 3 17 (including two Polmar and 4 Beechcraft KA 350) 17 (including two Polmar and 4 Beechcraft KA 350) Motorcycles 43-metre coast guard patrol vessels Air and naval fleets Teaching vessels Twin-engine aircraft Single-engine aircraft 2 2 Helicopters 9 9 (including 5 EC 135) Fixed scanners 2 1 Mobile scanners Detection equipment 36 5 5 X-ray devices 67 67 Densimeters 150 150 Particle analysers 23 26 (12 fixed and 14 mobile) Radiation survey meters 45 47 LT S 2013 RESU FRENCH CUSTOMS’ SEA AND AIR SURVEILLANCE SYSTEM IN 2013 Dunkerque Coast guard patrol vessels (PGC) Surveillance aircraft Boulogne Twin-engine Coast Guard patrol boats (VGC) of 21 m or longer (VGC) Cherbourg Single-engine Le Havre Polmar aircraft Granville Brest Inshore patrol vessel (VSR) ROUEN Helicopters 14 m AS 355 Saint-Malo 10 m Lann-Bihoué EC 135 Lorient La Trinité Dugny Teaching vessels Saint-Nazaire Shared between Le Havre and Hyères Maritime prefecture headquarters NANTES HEADQUARTERS OF A REGIONAL COAST GUARD DIRECTORATE (DRGC) AND A CUSTOMS OPERATIONS CENTER (COD) La Rochelle Rouen DRGC (Channel / North Sea) Nantes DRGC (Atlantic) Royan Marseille DRGC (Mediterranean) Antilles DRGC Paris inter-regional Directorate Bordeaux Dugny Air and naval departments MARSEILLE La Grande-Motte Sète Grau-d’Agde Port-la-Nouvelle Bayonne Menton Nice Cannes Port-de-Bouc Ste-Maxime Bandol Hyères Toulon Port-Vendres OVERSEAS FRANCE FORT-DE -FRANCE GUADELOUPE Kourou Pointe-à-Pitre Le Lamentin Le Marin CORSE Basse Terre Bastia Marigot FRENCH GUIANA MARTINIQUE Ajaccio SAINT-MARTIN Porto-Vecchio Papeete Dzaoudzi FRENCH POLYNESIA MAYOTTE 37 B A S I C FAC T S A B O U T F R E N C H C U S T O M S HUMAN RESOURCES DEMOGRAPHICS 2012 2013 Male employees 63.1% 62.9% Female employees 36.9% 37.1% Male employees 52.4% 52% Female employees 47.6% 48% Male employees 75.6% 75.2% Female employees 24.4% 24.8% 41% 46.8% 46 years 46 years 14% 13.9% 35 to 49 years old 42.4% 42.2% Over 50 years old 43.6% 44% Total male and female employees Male and female employees in the commercial operations branch and in the general administration Male and female employees in the surveillance branch Percentage of women in entry-level executive positions (IP2) Age of employees Average age 19 to 34 years old EMPLOYEE GRADES (IN NUMBER OF EMPLOYEES) 7,475 7,524 5,587 4,097 5,391 4,142 Grade A Grade B 2012 Grade C 2013 PERCENTAGE OF INTERNAL PROMOTIONS IN 2013 575 Grade C promotions (29.5% of promotions) 557 Grade A promotions (28.6% of promotions) 816 Grade B promotions (41.9% of promotions) 38 LT S 2013 RESU TAX COLLECTION FRENCH CUSTOMS TAX REVENUE IN MILLIONS OF EUROS (BREAKDOWN) Customs clearance Customs duties 2012 2013 12,828 12,411 1,952 1,865 10,853 10,525 23 21 Energy and environment 37,337 37,540 TICPE 24,095 24,284 Import VAT Other TSC DOM 467 460 11,146 11,707 TICGN + TICFE + TICHLC 335 331 One-off contribution on the value of petroleum product inventories 548 0.5 13 18 733 740 15,784 16,212 VAT on petrol Taxes and remuneration on behalf of petrol industry professionals TGAP Excise duties Alcohol and beverages 3,831 4,265 11,826 11,817 128 130 Dock dues and maritime activities 1,567 1,609 Dock dues 1,055 1,079 Port dues 467 483 46 47 171 168 Tobacco Other excise duties DAFN TSVR – Tax on certain road vehicles (axle tax) Miscellaneous Total 259 290 67,946 68,230 TICPE: Domestic consumption tax on energy products TSC DOM: Special consumption tax in Overseas départements TICGN: Domestic consumption tax on natural gas TICFE: Domestic consumption tax on electricity for end-users TICHLC: Domestic consumption tax on coal, brown coal and coke, known as the “Carbon Tax” TGAP: General tax on polluting activities DAFN: Registration (as a French ship) and navigation duty DUTIES AND TAXES REASSESSED SINCE 2009 (IN MILLIONS OF EUROS) Duties and taxes reassessed 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 272 296 265 294 323 39 B A S I C FAC T S A B O U T F R E N C H C U S T O M S NARCOTICS AND TOBACCO QUANTITIES OF DRUGS SEIZED (ESTIMATED STREET VALUE IN MILLIONS OF EUROS) €600 million 536 €500 million €400 million 288 €300 million €200 million 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 VALUE OF DRUGS SEIZED ABROAD THANKS TO FRENCH CUSTOMS SINCE 2009 (IN MILLIONS OF EUROS) €250 million 202 €200 million €150 million 114 93 €100 million €50 million €0 million 88.6 45 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 SEIZURES OF TOBACCO OVER 10 YEARS (IN TONS) 500 t 430 450 t 400 t 350 t 300 t 250 t 200 t 185 150 t 100 t 2004 40 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 LT S 2013 RESU COUNTERFEIT GOODS SEIZURES OF COUNTERFEITS OVER 10 YEARS (IN MILLIONS OF ITEMS) 10 7.6 8 6 3.4 4 2 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 MAIN SEIZURES OF COUNTERFEITS BY TYPE OF PRODUCT IN 2013 (IN NUMBER OF ITEMS) Pharmaceuticals 1,354,705 Clothing 1,075,913 445,089 Personal accessories Shoes 369,157 Toys, games and sporting goods 350,083 Cell phones 293,190 Food 261,570 Beauty care products Electrical, electronic and computer equipment CDs, DVDs and software applications 171,712 98,515 73,542 REQUESTS BY BUSINESSES FOR INTERVENTION BY FRENCH CUSTOMS TO INTERCEPT COUNTERFEITS 2,000 1,785 1,586 1,450 1,500 1,000 500 1,290 910 1,035 1,117 1,171 687 0 2007 2008 2009 Number of requests for intervention 2010 2011 2012 2013 Number of registered rights holders 41 B A S I C FAC T S A B O U T F R E N C H C U S T O M S RESULTS OF THE 2012-2013 PERFORMANCE CONTRACT COMMITMENT 1 – FRENCH CUSTOMS, A PARTNER FOR BUSINESSES ABROAD Indicator Unit 2012 Target 2012 Results 2013 Target 2013 Results % 83% 93% 85% 90.5% Number 2,000 2,154 2,000 2,162 Overall rate of paperless customs clearance % 81% 84% 84% 85% Average time that goods are immobilised Minutes and seconds 6 mn 35 s 4 mn 46 s 5 mn 4 mn 30 s Effectiveness of targeting customs declarations Per 10,000 82 134 150 219 Number of consumer protection citations Number 4,000 6,122 4,200 7,113 % 25% 27.3% 30% 31.1% User satisfaction Businesses that were the focus of a customised approach Share of imports-exports by Authorized Economic Operators COMMITMENTS 2 – FRENCH CUSTOMS PROTECTS FRENCH TERRITORY AND ITS CITIZENS Indicator 42 Unit 2012 Target 2012 Results 2013 Target 2013 Results Seizures of drugs Millions of euros 340 255.8 340 536 Seizures of smuggled tobacco and cigarettes Millions of euros 82.5 80.3 85 90 Number of counterfeit items seized Millions of items 6 4.6 5 7.6 Number of citations concerning anti-fraud efforts Number 6,200 8,559 6,500 9,522 Rate of operational availability by surveillance units % 79.4% 80.8% 79.5% 82% Operational cooperation index Number 6,100 5,486 6,300 9,406 Seizures of criminal assets by the SNDJ Millions of euros 5 7.2 8 31.1 Contribution to the fight against maritime pollution % 80% 81.6% 81% 83.9% LT S 2013 RESU COMMITMENT 3 – FRENCH CUSTOMS, A MODERN TAX ADMINISTRATION Indicator Unit 2012 Target 2012 Results 2013 Target 2013 Results Number 530 426 540 501 Intervention rate with respect to customs revenue % 0.50% 0.47% 0.50% 0.45% Duties and taxes reassessed Millions of euros 290 294 310 323 Collection of duties and taxes reassessed % 64% 58% 65% 61.3% Computerised vineyard register management quality % 30% 52.2% 60% 83.7% Taxpayer responsibility index % 99.1% 99.1% 99.2% 99.1% Number of energy- and environmentrelated citations COMMITMENT 4 – FRENCH CUSTOMS, A FORWARD-LOOKING GOVERNMENT DEPARTMENT IN TUNE WITH ITS STAFF Indicator Unit 2012 Target 2012 Results 2013 Target 2013 Results Availability of online procedures % 98.8% 98.1% 99% 99.3% Real estate occupancy rate by employee in square metres m2 12.5 12.8 12 12.7 Hierarchical audience share among the employee information vectors % 47% 43% 50% 43% Percentage of positions requiring special skills % 33% 34.2% 34% 35.2% Private vehicles complying with the emissions standard of 120 g CO2/km % 60% 60% 70% 81% Overall satisfaction rate of employees taking part in initial or ongoing training % 72.5% 75.7% 73% 80% 43 Publication Manager: Hélène Crocquevieille Editor-in-Chief: Serge Puccetti Produced by: Directorate General of Customs and Excise (DGDDI) Information and Communication Department Graphic design: René Bertramo, 75011 Paris Photo credits © Directorate General of Customs and Excise © Agence Zoom - Grenoble (no. 3, page 2) © Donlore - Fotolia.com (no. 9, page 2) © Olivier Bonnet (no. 11, page 2 and page 13) Printed in France in 2014 Printer: L'Artésienne - BP 99 - 62802 Liévin Cedex Publisher: Directorate General of Customs and Excise (DGDDI) 11, rue des deux Communes - 93558 Montreuil Cedex dg-bic@douane.finances.gouv.fr French Customs 2013 Results is available online at www.douane.gouv.fr Legal deposit: February 2014 ISSN: 1960-9345 44 Directorate General of Customs and Excise Information and Communication Department 11, rue des Deux Communes - 93558 Montreuil Cedex www.douane.gouv.fr Twitter: @douane_france February 2014