PAR - The IEEE Standards Association

Approval of Extension Letter
Email This Letter
06 December 2006
Jeffrey G Gilbert
PPL Electric Utilities Corp
2 N 9th Street, GENN 4
Allentown, PA 18101-1179
jggilbert@pplweb.com
Re: PC37.110 - Guide for the Application of Current Transformers used for Protective Relaying Purpose
Dear Jeffrey:
I am pleased to report that on 06 December 2006 the IEEE-SA Standards Board approved the extension
request of the above-referenced project until 31 December 2007.
If you should have any further questions, please contact me at +1 732 562 6003 or by email at s.
hampton@ieee.org.
Sincerely,
Sherry Hampton
Administrator, Governance
Standards Activities
Phone +1 732 562 6003
FAX +1 732 875 0695
Email: s.hampton@ieee.org
CC: pbwinsto@southernco.com, stds-pes-scc@ieee.org
https://spadev.ieee.org/cgi-bin/sadb/print_par?print:84912/6/2006 12:02:12 PM
IEEE-SA Standards Board Extension Request
Revised 23 June 2004
1. Date of Request: 15-Sep-06
2. Assigned Project Number: PC37.110
3. Project Title: Guide for the Application of Current Transformers used for Protective Relaying
Purposes
a. Name of Working Group (WG): WG I15
b. Name of Working Group Chair: George P.Moskos
c. Name of Sponsoring Society and Committee: IEEE Power System Relaying Committee
d. Name of Sponsoring Committee Chair: Phil Winston - 2006 /Charlie Henville - 2007
4. Contact Information (Contact should be the person who will answer any questions concerning
this extension request):
a. Name: George P. Moskos
b. Telephone: 781-441-8619
c. FAX: 781-441-8657
d. EMAIL: george_moskos@nstaronline.com
5. Statement of why an extension is required. This should include a description of what the working
group has accomplished and what remains to be accomplished, along with the reasons why the
work was unable to be completed in the allotted timeframe :
Draft 8 was completed and submitted for balloting. The negative ballots are presently being
addressed but have not totally been resolved. They will not be resolved prior to October 16, 2006
deadline. WG I15 is very close to resolving the negative ballots and submitting the recirculation
ballot. The WG needs this one year extension in order to address all the Editorial and Technical
comments from the balloting process.
6. History
a. What date was the PAR first approved? 25-Oct-98
b. What date did you begin writing the first draft? 20-Jun-00
c. How many people are actively working on the project? 5
d. How many times a year does the working group meet:
1. In person? 3
2. Via teleconference? 0
e. How many times a year is a draft circulated to the working group via electronic means? 5
7. Document Progress
a. What percentage of the Draft is stable? 99%
b. How many significant work revisions has the Draft been through? 8
8. Project Plan
(Item #8a is only for projects that have been balloted. If your draft has not yet gone to ballot,
please go to Item #8b)
a. Balloting History - Provide history of all IEEE Sponsor ballots under this project::
1st Ballot Close date (or scheduled close): 2006-04-05
1st Ballot Draft Number: 8
1st Ballot results (% affirmative, %negative, %abstain): (89.6% affirmative, 6.4 % negative,
4% abstention)
2nd Ballot Close date (or scheduled close):
2nd Ballot Draft Number:
2nd Ballot results (% affirmative, %negative, %abstain):
(Add additional entries for ballots as needed):
When do you estimate that the final IEEE Sponsor ballot will be completed? 1-Jan-07
When do you expect to submit the proposed standard to RevCom? 1-May-07
b. For projects that have not yet begun Sponsor ballot, please answer the following:
When will IEEE sponsor balloting begin?
When do you estimate that the final IEEE Sponsor ballot will be completed?
When do you expect to submit the proposed standard to RevCom?
9. Future Adoptions
• If this is a new document, will it be adopted (in part or in whole) by another national,
regional or international organization? Choose One If yes, which organization?
• If this is a revision of an existing document, has this document been adopted by the IEC,
ISO, ETSI, SCC, etc? Do Not Know If yes, which organization?
10. Additional Extensions
a. Is this the first request for an extension? No (If yes, please do not go any further. You have
completed the form.)
b. If not, when was the previous extension approved? 8-Dec-04
After completion of this form, please e-mail this to the NesCom Administrator at
nescom-admin@ieee.org. Confirmation of submittal will be sent on receipt of this request.
Email This Letter
13 December 2004
Mohindar Sachdev
University of Saskatchewan
243 Willoughby Cres.
Saskatoon, SK, S7H 4W6
CANADA
m.s.sachdev@ieee.org
Re: PC37.110 - Guide for the Application of Current Transformers used for Protective Relaying Purpose
Dear Mohindar:
I am pleased to report that on 08 December 2004 the IEEE-SA Standards Board approved the extension request
of the above-referenced project until 31 December 2006.
If you should have any further questions, please contact me at 732-562-6367 or by email at j.haasz@ieee.org.
Sincerely,
Jodi Haasz
Program Manager
International Stds Programs and Governance
Standards Activities
Phone +1 732 562 6367
FAX +1 732 875 0695
Email: j.haasz@ieee.org
cc: george_moskos@nstaronline.com, rick.taylor@sgswitter.com, stds-pes-scc@ieee.org
1 of 1
IEEE-SA Standards Board Extension Request
Revised 23 June 2004
1. Date of Request: 7-Oct-04
2. Assigned Project Number: PC37.110
3. Project Title: Guide for the Application of Current Transformers Used for Protective Relaying
Purposes
a. Name of Working Group (WG): I15
b. Name of Working Group Chair: George P. Moskos
c. Name of Sponsoring Society and Committee: IEEE Power System Relaying Committee
d. Name of Sponsoring Committee Chair: Richard Taylor
4. Contact Information (Contact should be the person who will answer any questions concerning
this extension request):
a. Name: George P. Moskos
b. Telephone: 781-441-8619
c. FAX: 781-441-8624
d. EMAIL: george_moskos@nstaronline.com
5. Statement of why an extension is required. This should include a description of what the working
group has accomplished and what remains to be accomplished, along with the reasons why the
work was unable to be completed in the allotted timeframe Here is an update on the
accomplishments of the working group. The new section 6.5 was added on "Ct Performance Under
GIC Conditions". Annex D was also added to be informative on the subject: " Optical Current
Sensor Systems". The existing guide was also improved on in many secrtions. New references were
added the the Reference Section. New definitions were added to the Definition Section. Section 4.3
"Knee -Point Voltage" was rewritten. A new section 4.5.2 was added on "Saturation Voltage".
Figures 12-1, 12-2, 12-3 were redrawn in the section covering Remanant Flux . Section 4.7 was
rewritten to cover the fundamental transformer equation. All the units in the guide exa mples were
converted to metric. New section 7.2.2.7 covering "Applying an Auxiliary Ct in a Ground
Differential Circuit" was added. New section 7.2.2.8 covering "Split-Phase Protection" was added.
The section on High Impedance Differential Relaying was rewritten. The section on Selecting Cts
for Line Protection was rewritten and a new example was added. All the examples in the various
section were reviewed and improved on since this guide needs to be used to help train protection
engineers to select the correct Ct for their applications. This guide has been coordinated with
C57.13.1, C57.13.3. All three of the Ct working groups are working at the same time for
reaffirmation. We have met and agreed on moving and relocating various sections in the C57.13.1,
C57.13.3, and C37.110 between the working groups. The document is in its final stages of being
ready to send to IEEE for balloting. Do to the unpredictable weather our company has experienced
during this hurricane season, I have not had time to finalize the document for balloting. This will be
the last extension request since we are at the balloting stage for the project.
6. History
a. What date was the PAR first approved? 25-Oct-98
b. What date did you begin writing the first draft? 20-Jun-00
c. How many people are actively working on the project? 5
d. How many times a year does the working group meet:
1. In person? 3
2. Via teleconference? 0
e. How many times a year is a draft circulated to the working group via electronic means? 3
7. Document Progress
a. What percentage of the Draft is stable? 100%
b. How many significant work revisions has the Draft been through? 6
8. Project Plan
(Item #8a is only for projects that have been balloted. If your draft has not yet gone to ballot,
please go to Item #8b)
a. Balloting History - Provide history of all IEEE Sponsor ballots under this project::
1st Ballot Close date (or scheduled close):
1st Ballot Draft Number:
1st Ballot results (% affirmative, %negative, %abstain):
2nd Ballot Close date (or scheduled close):
2nd Ballot Draft Number:
2nd Ballot results (% affirmative, %negative, %abstain):
(Add additional entries for ballots as needed):
When do you estimate that the final IEEE Sponsor ballot will be completed?
When do you expect to submit the proposed standard to RevCom?
b. For projects that have not yet begun Sponsor ballot, please answer the following:
When will IEEE sponsor balloting begin? 5-Jan-05
When do you estimate that the final IEEE Sponsor ballot will be completed? 6-Jan-06
When do you expect to submit the proposed standard to RevCom? 6-May-06
9. Future Adoptions
• If this is a new document, will it be adopted (in part or in whole) by another national,
regional or international organization? Do Not Know If yes, which organization?
• If this is a revision of an existing document, has this document been adopted by the IEC,
ISO, ETSI, SCC, etc? Choose One If yes, which organization?
10. Additional Extensions
a. Is this the first request for an extension? No (If yes, please do not go any further. You have
completed the form.)
b. If not, when was the previous extension approved? 26-Feb-02
After completion of this form, please e- mail this to the NesCom Administrator at
nescom-admin@ieee.org. Confirmation of submittal will be sent on receipt of this request.
Jodi Haasz
06/14/2002 08:16 AM
To: sachdev@engr.usask.ca
cc: Bill Higinbotham <bhiginbotham@nac.net>, george_moskos@nstaronline.com
Subject: Extension Requests
14 June 2002
Mohindar S. Sachdev
243 Willoughby Cres.
Saskatoon SK
Canada S7H 4W6
Re:
PC37.93
Guide for Power System Protective Relay Applications
of Audio Tones over Voice Grade Channels
PC37.97
Guide for Protective Relay Applications to Power System Buses
PC37.110
Guide for the Application of Current Transformers Used
for Protective Relaying Purposes
Dear Mr. Sachdev:
I am pleased to report that on 13 June 2002 the IEEE-SA Standards Board approved the extension of the
above referenced projects until December 2004.
If you should have any further questions, please contact me at 732-562-6367 or by email at j.haasz@ieee.org.
Sincerely,
Jodi Haasz
Senior Administrator
IEEE-SA Governance and Electronic Processes
Standards Activities
Phone +1 732 562 6367
FAX +1 208 460 5300
Email: j.haasz@ieee.org
IEEE-SA Standards Board Extension Request
Revised 6 December 2000
1.
Date of Request: [02/26/02]
2.
Assigned Project Number: [PC37.110]
3. Project Title: [IEEE Guide for the Application of Current Transformers Used
for Protective Relaying Purposes ]
a. Name of Working Group(WG): [I15]
b. Name of Working Group Chair: [George P. Moskos]
c. Name of Sponsoring Society and Committee: [IEEE Power System Relaying
Committee]
d. Name of Sponsoring Committee Chair: [George Nail]
4. Contact Information (Contact should be the person who will answer any
questions concerning this extension request):
a. Name: [George P. Moskos]
b. Telephone: [781-441-8619]
c. FAX: [781-441-8624]
d. EMAIL: [george_moskos@nstaronline.com]
5. Statement of why an extension is required. If this is a request for an
additional extension, please state why you believe that this extension request
will be your final request, and the reason for this additional extension.
[The approved PAR showed a completion date of September 2003. This was always
the target date for completion. We were recently told that the PAR expires in
December 2002. The document will not be done by the end of this year. The
document is in its final stages and will be done during the next six to eight
months. It will be then submitted for balloting.]
6. History
a. When was the PAR first approved? [Submitted on 10/25/98 to the next NESCOM
meeting for approval]
b. When did you begin writing the first draft? [Mid 2000 ]
c. How many people are actively working on the project? [8]
d. How many times a year does the working group meet in person? [ 3 ]
e. How frequently is a draft version circulated to the working group via
electronic means? [ After every meeting ]
7. Document Progress
a. How much of the Draft is stable? [Writing assignment are all complete
(100%).]
b. How many significant work revisions has the Draft been through? [New
application examples and sections have been added to the Guide]
c. Briefly describe what the development group has already accomplished, and
what remains to be done. [The Guide is all written and is being proof-read,
edited and put in the "Style Manual Format."]
8. Project Plan
a. When did/will IEEE sponsor balloting begin? [April 2003]
b. When do you estimate that the final IEEE Sponsor ballot will be completed?
[January 2004]
c. When do you expect to submit the proposed standard to RevCom? [June 2004]
d. Do you see value in help or mentoring from the Standards Board staff to meet
your projected schedule? If so, what kind of help would be useful? [No]
9. Additional Extensions
a. Is this the first request for an extension? [Yes ] (If yes, please do not go
any further. You have completed the form.)
b. If not, when was the previous extension approved? [ ]
c. How much additional time is needed to complete the project? [ ]
After completion of this form, please e-mail this to the NesCom Administrator at
j.haasz@ieee.org. Confirmation of submittal will be sent on receipt of this
request.
Networking
14 December
IEEE
the
World..
1998
Miriam Sanders
Pulsar Technologies
4050 NW 121 Avenue
Coral Springs, FL 33065
Re:
PC37.110
Guide for the Application of Current Transfonners used for Protecti ye
Relaying Purposes
Dear Ms. Sanders:
I am pleasedto inform you that on 8 December 1998 the IEEE StandardsBoard approved the
above referenced project with the addition of PFJSUB under coordination. A copy is enclosed
for your files.
We are also enclosing the IEEE StandardsKit Phase2 (After PAR Approval). This kit includes
items which you may find useful in the development of your proposed standard and submitting
your final draft for approval. Written responsesfrom all committees/organizations listed on the
PAR as proposed coordination must be included with the final draft when it is submitted.
If coordination is effected by common membership, i.e., a person on the standard's developing
committee who is also a member of the committee/organization specified on the PAR for
coordination, there must be a document included with the final draft from that coordinating body
which statesthat person is authorized to represent it. We strongly recommend that a copy of
your draft be sent to this office for review prior to the final voting by the working group to allow
for a quick review by the editorial staff before sponsor balloting.
If you should have any further questions, please contact me at 732-562-3808 or by email at
r .kershner@ieee.org.
If you should have any further questions, please contact me at 732-562-3808 or by email at
r .kershner@ieee.org.
Sincerely,
"RcN"'-
Rona Kershner
Manager, Standards Board Support
N esCom Secretary
cc:
G. Moskos
The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc'45 HoesLane. P.O.Box 1331 .Piscataway NJ 08855-1331,USA .Phone 732.981.0060.Fax 732.562.1571.www.ieee.org
-I
-=-.
-, !
IEEE STANDARDS BOARD
PROJECT
AUTHORIZATION
REQUEST
{PAR)
FORM
EEE
I.
2.
Sponsor
Date of
Request:
4.
}~
PROJECl'
Project
Number:
li~~B
TITLE, COPYRIGHT
I will write/revise
AGREEMENT,
a Standards Publication
3.
Assigned
with the following
PAR
~ al
Date:
APprO
PC
3(
Confer
.\10'
with
staff
AND WORKING
TITlE
I:eav
bl
GROUP FOR THIS PROJECl'
(Check only one, Spell out all acronyms)
I:J STANDARD [FOR] (Document stressing the verb "SHALL.")
I:J RECOMMENDED PRAC11CE FOR (Document stressing the verb "SHOULD.")
.GUIDE
FOR (Document stressing the verb "MA Y.")
U5~~rY1b+ecJ+(l>..e
I hereb
owledg
~~t~
y apooi
~
IIC
!) ~('"
t as Official Reporter (usually the W .G. Chair) to
~
at my option, as an Official Reporter, I agree
"work made for hire" as defined by the Copyright Act, and, that as to any work not so
101,4-1£1
Typeorprintn~king<:roUPChair:
Title:
l.e.?~
~
"];:lRe~~~~\,
~D('~~
1J.
(Y)O~~~
£"",,~1-('1P...Q..r""-
B
.
IEEEMebNo:
D12~0551
:
Address:
8
~ o "::B o ~ ' ~"("\
i City: ~~b-T)
5.
-State:
Describe
(a)
(b)
I
0
A.
"f'(\-f\
This Project:
Fax:
ZIP:
C2.\99
E-mail:~{)Of'~Q..
-fY)o~~~@
b~d~o1'\
.
(O1Y)
(Choose ONEfrom each group below.)
Is this in ballot
OYES
now?
~NO
NEWSTANDARD
REVISION of an existing standard. (Indicate standard number and year.) C ; (
SUPPlEMENT to an existing standard. (Indicate standard number and year.)
., 1 o -\
Ot q ~
~=
(c)
..FULL
USE (5-year life cycle)
0 TRIAL USE (2-year life cycle)
(d)
Fll.L IN TARGET COMPLETION DATE for submittal to IEEE Standards Review Committee (RevCom): ge.r;+
.12 o~
Scope ofProposed Project: (Whatis being done,including the technicalboundariesofthe project.)
Jo
(evt~.
C'o~(>f'e,~,~
i ~pf\\tR*1G/)
~-\.e<l\1)~
! ~
-+h
,
~
Update an existing PAR.
O YES )tNO
(Indicate PAR number/approval date.)
~
0
6.
5:t::c~
c.~
~~
---~
+r~
-e.J\"'1'\.Q.Q.,
~~r.;Y'\~
<?J'\AlcLR -ro
, f\')w
-,
Q.Y'\of t-t(Jcf~+-e.
-t~~1~5
-+i,.
~k
.--~~
ln
ca/.IIO-\<;94
ot -t~
~~d
~~f\i~O()
~
-+~
co-('('d
~LQ &) c--() dY)~
~Y'po~
m~~
it
~
~u
..l1\.slf}~r'fJo~
-~~
~$~
~t.!> C.(.IlG5\C)/):J-n-tit
~
0
'"'
.~
.REV.1196
~pfllei<Jr,..o-t!)
.S;b-{'-+~
,~
"-oe-Ol~~0:1~
.../
o.(:+h.Il
~u;~
Ct5 4b ~~iot
d:P6>\\~ic-"{)
't1-2."iY')':f~
-(...(\5)~
\5+0
~
fr~t'd..
-t~ rQ;~
C~5 ~-r
\..\.);1) ~
~~
fQ
~tfJ~
? ~7 n
/
~t6
() ~
I
7.
-;;:"" 5:;~
~-
;'
~~~)n, -tk fiJ'IAffo~
-t~rY'oI2J{)"1 t..1:;
-tk -r~
-Q>I'fj11)esL("
JY)-tk
m~~
~'JYY){)~
8.
n
isit ..iP;;:(
C~
:~'"Z)
..;1:::;;~~~~
.()~I
f'..vI.)l~ ~v.l'~ 16 t'o ~,,~~-::r d C~f~~~1~
~o). 9'f7pl1~1~
~-r c~ -tD Q6S~5T-1-h (~
~tfC..(")
~+k~")'~-1"1~
-bf: Ci:B
ab(A...(~t
..~
"\~
~6~125
o-t~
~J.
~\6)Di)
M»~~fl~
ib
~~~
b{,d~l~
';);\~Sponsor:
~~n-~klf
(Givefull name;speU
~~~~g
out all acronyms.)
Society/Committee:
.9.
S
~
-9b
G
-G
s proJe .
(a.l) Are you awareo anypa n s re e
a YES (Attach an explanation.)
~
NO
(a.2) Are you aware of any copyrights relevant to this project1
a YES (Attach an explanation.)
~ NO
(a.3) Are you aware of any trademarks relevant to this project1
Q YES (Attach an explanation.)
~ NO
(b) Are you aware of any other standards or projects with a similar scope?
Q YES (Attach an explanation.)
~ NO
(c) Is this standard intended to form the basis of an international standard?
Q YES
Q NO (Attach an explanati.
j
(d) Is this project intended to focus on health, safety. or environmental issues?
" ,
a YES (Attach an explanation.)
~! NO
10.
Proposed
Coordination/Recommended
( Coordination
is accomplished
Method
of Coordination
by the foUowing : Circulation
Membership
Mandatory
or Cd'mmor(1r/~!s1fif:)
(b)
;
l
Coordination:
scc
10 (IEEE
-,
Dictionary)
and mEE
Staff
Editorial
Review
Circulation
of Drafts
'
KNOW
DO N~~ow
, ,",
;, ,
of Drafts or Liaison
..,
(a)
'" r':,~,
~c""t;",
Jj
,
",
f
,
..~
.,
,
~,l,,*,
1
f
,,'I'
:...
,.j
.
f
,,
SCC 14 (Quantities, Units, and Letter Symbols)
Circulation of Drafts
,
IEEE Coordination Requested by Sponsor: (Use additional page i/necessary.)
;... , , ~ .H you believe your project will require a Registration Authority, please list mEE RAC (refer to Worliing-ti~}~~
"
(lfno coordination is required, please attach an explanation.)
COORDINATION
METHODOFCOORDTNATION
~
circJdrafts
Q liaison memb
CJ common memb.
circJdrafts
Q liaison memb
CJ common memb.
circJdrafts
Q liaison memb
CJ common memb.
Q circJdrafts
Q liaison memb
CJ common memb.
Q circJdrafts
Q liaison memb
CJ common memb.
A
~
(c)
II.
Additional
Submitted
Coordination
Requested
by Others:
(Leave blank -To
By: (This ".,ust,be the
signatureofSUbmitte~~i1?"
by the Standards StajJ:)
to the IEEE Standards Board.)
Date:
~
~/.9?B.EE
Name:
Miriam
C
ompany.!4050
Address:
City:
Pulsar Technolo gies, Inc
Title: Product Mana g er
NW 121 Avenue
Telephone: 954-344-9822 x 215
Coral Springs, FL 33065
Fax: 954-340-6676
email: miriam.sanders@pulsartech.com
DO
NOT
WRrrE
BELOW
nnSLINE
P. Sanders
be completed
IEEE No.07653439
MemberNo.
-