Precisely engineered CNC-cut metal kits simplify custom and
Transcription
Precisely engineered CNC-cut metal kits simplify custom and
Tab A Into Slot B Precisely engineered CNC-cut metal kits simplify custom and production projects at aluminum sailing-yacht builder K&M and steel-motoryacht builder Jetten, both in The Netherlands. Text and photographs by Hans Buitelaar Above—A 32.8' (10m) aluminum rescue vessel in build at K&M Yachtbuilders (Makkum, The Netherlands). Longi tudinal and transverse frames designed and engineered to close tolerances and cut by a computer numerically controlled (CNC) laser cutter slide together precisely and easily. This build method enables the structural framework to be erected and the hull shape verified before any components are welded. H istorically, metal-boatbuilding shops received raw plate or rough-cut components directly from their metal suppliers. A crew of skilled builders cut and shaped the metal to match patterns scaled off the naval architects’ plans, and eventually welded those components to create the finished hull shape. That was then. Today, at K&M Yachtbuilders, in Makkum, The Netherlands (see the sidebar on page 48), metal components delivered to the construction hall are far more refined: Precut stringers are the precise shape required to yield the finished hull, and they arrive from the computer numerically controlled (CNC) laser cutting facility with an intricate pattern of notches cut halfway through their depth to interlock with the transverse frames, which in turn have a corresponding pattern of narrow cuts around their outer curves. These precut structural members with cutouts, coupled with precut hull plating, assure a stronger hull than a conventional build, and require fewer highly skilled builders and much shorter production time on the shop floor. About the same time carefully engineered CNC-cut metal parts for hull construction were introduced at K&M in 2007, Jetten Yachting and Vripack Naval Architects (both of Sneek, The 46 Professional BoatBuilder MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 46 2/25/14 3:17 PM A yard worker at K&M confirms that the numbered parts for the next section of the Bestevaer 53ST (16.2m) are in the correct order after they arrive from the metal-cutting contractor Snijtech, in Joure. Ideally, crews can then start building the section by picking parts from the top of the pile. Netherlands) joined a governmentfunded innovation project to develop so-called lean manufacturing methods for the boating industry (production that minimizes inefficiencies in the workforce and maximizes the return on expensive equipment and shop space). Twenty-five companies, including boatyards, software developers, naval architects, and research institutes, took part, helping spur the development of precisely engineered CNC-cut aluminum and steel kits for boats. Building with kits saves much of the expert but time-consuming manual work, because engineered Jetten Yachting B rothers Marcel and Sander Jetten started their yard in the town of Sneek in 2000. In the middle of the Frisian lakes, the Royal Yacht Club Sneek hosts legendary open-boat regattas and is one of The Nether lands’ centers of powerboat cruising. The brothers had built yachts at several yards before deciding that by combining their skills they could do a better job than their respective employers. The Jettens began building cabin cruisers under the brand name Bully, producing more than a hundred in lengths from 31.2' to 45.9' (9.5m to 14m). Realizing that the word Bully did not have positive connotations in all languages, they changed their brand to the yard name Jetten to appeal to their growing parts come precut from CNC-laser, or CNC-plasma cutting machines and fit together only one way—on basically the same principle as simple wood or plastic construction kits for model airplanes, cars, and boats. If a precut part doesn’t fit, it’s in the wrong place, and the builder must find the right part. Sometimes it’s as easy as turning a seemingly symmetrical part around. Jetten Yachting (see the sidebar below) now builds all its boats with Vripack’s branded Smart Kit engineeringand-production system. CEO Marcel Jetten says, “In the traditional construction method, it would happen From metal cutting to launching, the Gamma 20 (73'/22.1m) steel motoryacht, built by Jetten Yachting (Sneek, The Netherlands) for the Italian yacht company Gamma, was completed in just eight months thanks in large part to Smart Kit technology from Dutch design-and-engineering firm Vripack. international clientele. Today, steel motoryachts from 30' to 70' (9.1m to 21.3m) are Jetten Yachting’s standard builds, with more than 100 boats produced. At the yard in December 2013, the next Gamma 20 (73' /22.1m) for the Italian yacht company was in advanced stages of construction. —Hans Buitelaar April/May MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 47 2014 47 2/25/14 2:30 PM The first plate of the hull skin is fitted to the rescue boat at the K&M yard. The precision-cut panels need no adjustment or resizing to fit the underlying structural members and consequently yield a hull that requires little or no fairing. that the shop-floor workers would weld a part just a fraction aside the marking line. Or sometimes the marking lines themselves were a bit away from their drawn position. With Smart Kit, the only possible way to build a yacht is to follow the way the engineers planned it; otherwise it just won’t fit. We have installed a DXF viewer on the shop floor; the computer program shows the 3D model. Any part number typed in will light up on the screen, so we know where the part goes in the boat. Sometimes workers may be uncertain about where parts of similar shape might belong in the different sections of the boat.” Kits at K&M In K&M’s kit system, CNC-cut notched metal cutouts slide over and mate with crossing components. With each new precut piece fitted but not bonded, the framework becomes stronger and more stable. If the demanding design work has been done well, when all components are in place every frame should be perfectly vertical, with virtually no movement in the structure. Welding can then begin with confidence that no adjustments or further cutting will be needed. “We started assembling precut metal parts into boats with this construction method some seven years ago,” says Klaas Kuperus, foreman at K&M. “At first, we had to learn to trust the engineers who had anticipated in their 3D design how everything would fit together perfectly. As aluminum boatbuilders, we were used to receiving a load of roughly cut metal parts that we would adjust, fit, and weld together on the spot. Following a design plan, we were the skilled craftsmen who could shape a three-dimensional boat from a piece of paper and a load of metal plates. We still do that, but with the new cutmetal kits, we actually only need to put them together, and the threedimensional form will take shape as intended by the yacht designers and naval architects who engineered the metal-cutting pattern. “It happened with the first kits that at some point in the assembly the wrong part was placed,” Kuperus recalls. “From there on, every new crossbeam would be a little more out of vertical level than the one before. So the builders started adjusting parts to correct this—just like they used to do. They were perplexed and at that K&M Yachtbuilders E euwe Kooi, manager at K&M, started building aluminum sailing yachts in the Dutch town of Makkum in 1999. At the Frisian shore, near the locks through the Afsluitdijk (Enclosure Dike), which separates the salty, tidal Waddenzee from the freshwater IJsselmeer, the yard has built a reputation for rugged long-distance cruising sailing yachts of quality finish. Vessels like the Stadtship 70 (68.9'/21m) by Van de Stadt Design, the Axonite 69 (68.6' /20.9m) by Guido de Groot Design, and the series of Bestevaer sailing yachts from Dykstra Naval Architects define the yard’s offerings. In early December 2013, construction started on the first MKII Bestevaer 53ST (16.2m), inspired by Gerard Dykstra’s own yacht. The build was well under way during my yard visit December 17. Workers were nearly finished welding the structural members and were preparing hull plating for installation. —H.B. Naval architect Gerard Dykstra’s yacht, pictured here, inspired the Bestevaer 53ST, in build at K&M. A relatively fair hull right out of the construction hall is particularly important for an unpainted aluminum boat that will not be touched up with fairing compound and finish paint. 48 Professional BoatBuilder MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 48 2/25/14 2:30 PM Marcel Jetten shows how wooden panels for the interior of the Gamma 20 are also CNC-cut and fit together by sliding slots over intersecting parts. point not quite convinced that this new construction method was an improvement.” The engineers saw immediately that parts had been incorrectly placed and then unsuccessfully adjusted to make them match the plans. When the misaligned structure was taken apart and rebuilt with all parts in their proper places, it fit perfectly and everything was straight. It was a eureka moment for the yard crew. Kuperus, the son of a well-known builder of Dutch sailing barges, has been building boats since he was a child. He acknowledges that with adoption of the CNC-cut kits, boatbuilding is evolving from craftsmanship into a more industrial assembly process. “I like this new way of building boats,” he says. Nevertheless, “I must admit with the old method the welders on the shop floor had a very big part in making the hull what it should be. With the cleverly engineered metal parts that fit together to become a firm structure without the workers manipulating any part, construction follows the procedure planned by the engineers. Still, it is a fascinating process to see a yacht take shape following the arrival of a pile of metal parts. And we can build much faster now.” Key to the straightforward assembly of the metal parts is having them arranged in the sequence they will be needed in construction, so the builders are able to pick up the next part from the top of the pile. In reality, the kits are not always that tightly planned, but at least the parts are grouped by section, so the crew knows where to look for the components in the section they’re working on. In addition, this work routine can accelerate the build even more, as the first sections of the boat can be assembled while other sections are still being cut. Another advantage of kitted construction is the ease of creating a smooth hull skin. Kuperus: “As most of our builds are aluminum sailboats, a lot of owners like to leave the hull unpainted. It gives a rugged look and saves painting and repainting many times during the boat’s life span. This preference poses a challenge to us boatbuilders. We cannot use fairing compound to even out the inevitable bumps or dents in the hull skin, so we carefully smooth out the aluminum plating using a hammer after the yacht is finished. When we build with metal kits, the hull comes out smooth with a lot less finishing work.” Eeuwe Kooi, manager at K&M, strongly believes in the benefits of kitting these components. “It eliminates errors,” he says. “Every part will only fit in one place. Yard workers know that if it doesn’t fit, the part at hand should fit somewhere else, and they have to look on the shelf to find the part that does fit. Although we have the kind of skilled workers who can build a yacht from a flat drawing on their own knowledge, it saves time and material if they can just work steadily without having to think of solutions to make non-fitting parts fit. On top of that, the quality of the hulls and the smoothness of the finish are much better, thanks to refined CNC cutting. And as we offer series of boats, semicustom built, we really have a big cost advantage when a boat of the same design is ordered for a second and third time. On such occasions we already have the complete cutting pattern and can start construction immediately. A 50' [15.2m] boat can be finished within months.” In The Netherlands, as in most of Europe, yards suffer from a shortage of skilled construction workers, and every year it’s harder to find metalworkers who can build a smooth hull. That, Kooi admits, is also a compelling reason to invest in foolproof engineering. It allows welders and yard professionals with less experience to Intricate curved T-section hull-to-deck reinforcements were assembled before fitting them to the Bestevaer hull. April/May MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 49 2014 49 2/25/14 2:30 PM build a strong, lightweight hull exactly to specification in a predictably short time. But it’s not all about savings in build time and costs. “Especially in the case of one-offs, the whole process of design, engineering, and construction does not in all aspects become cheaper,” Kooi says. “We gain time on the shop floor, but we have to invest more in engineering and laser cutting. For the typical boat we build here, we would spend some 80 to 100 hours of engineering to make a traditional cutting plan. Working out a refined kit cutting plan, we invest 250 hours of engineering.” The upside is that no material is lost when the process is being refined on the computer; the downside is that trained engineers and designers are paid higher hourly rates than most construction workers. “Fellow yard managers often ask me, ‘Eeuwe, why do you invest so much in these cutting plans? You have the yard workers that can build a hull from drawings. Why don’t you let them go with their experience? You put a lot of money in the engineering and take the work out of experienced people’s hands.’ Well, my answer is that I see progress in the quality of our boats. We can build more of them to more competitive prices. Even though third parties can present us a load of traditionally cut plates and we will be able to build a yacht from it, all our own boats are now built from refined CNC-cutting plans. I want to make this step toward a more industrial approach because in the end, if we can build boats at better prices, we are able to sell more of them.” Boat designs come to K&M from offices such as Dykstra Naval Architects (see “Sailing Master,” Professional BoatBuilder No. 89, and “Dykstra Revisited,” PBB No. 141) or Van de Stadt Design. “They provide the lines and look of a yacht,” Kooi says, “and, of course, the required structural strength at critical points as well as estimated weight of the hull, keel, and rig. After the engineering office has translated the design into an aluminum-cutting plan, we send this back to the initial designers for them to confirm the resulting strengths that should be achieved in our construction: height of frames, distance between longitudinal stringers and crossbeams. Even with our experience we think it is good to have the naval architects cross-check it.” Jetten and Vripack “We had a lot of demand for the kind of quality-built steel motoryachts we build here,” Marcel Jetten recalls of the booming market in 2007. “To maintain the competitive edge with our national industry, ways were sought to improve on building speed, while maintaining the high quality standards. That is why the innovation program was started [the governmentfunded project mentioned earlier; Vripack’s Smart Kit was one outcome—Ed.]. We saw increasing international interest in our yachts at that time, with wealthy owners willing to order ever-bigger yachts but not willing to wait for delivery maybe two years. This was our reason to join.” At Jetten Yachting one of the first LED NAVIGATION LIGHTS LOW PROFILE - SMALL FOOTPRINT - BRIGHT LIGHT - USCG APPROVED LED TOP MOUNT NAV LIGHTS A: 2-9/16” B: 2-1/4” C: 1” LED SIDE MOUNT SIDE LIGHTS A: 3-9/16” B: 2-5/8” C: 3/4” SEA-DOG.COM 866-732-3641 50 Professional BoatBuilder MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 50 2/25/14 2:31 PM boats built by the Smart Kit method was a 40' (12.2m) steel-hulled cruising yacht. The yard had built hulls to this design previously but always by tradi tional methods. The same boat built from a Smart Kit was finished in just eight months, cutting build time in half. Soon after that Smart Kit build, the Italian motoryacht company Gamma Yachts approached Vripack to design a 73' (22.1m) steel luxury yacht. The Italians chose a Dutch yard, as steel motoryachts from The Netherlands enjoy a reputation for being well built, and Gamma also required fast delivery. “That is why Vripack directed Gamma and their client to us, in January 2010,” Jetten says. “We had just successfully finished the pilot. We were now ready to prove the concept for a third party, with a client that was anxious to get delivery as soon as possible.” This second Smart Kit build evolved into a model project. The yacht was also finished in just eight months, launching in Sneek in August 2010. Since then, Vripack has provided Smart Kit services to many boatbuilders and shipbuilders, creating designs and In Vripack’s Smart Kit, parts for the Gamma 20 hull under construction at Jetten Yachting are indelibly numbered. In addition to the assembly order of structural metal parts, installation of systems and equipment is engineered and specified beforehand. improving the engineer ing for its ready-to-build packages. Vripack’s commercial manager, Marnix Hoekstra, points out other advantages of Smart Kit engineering. “Yachts become lighter, as no extra parts are made on the yard floor to even out fluctuations in the hull construc tion,” he said. In traditional metal boatbuilding, welders often have extra pieces fitted to ensure strength. Smart Kits eliminate this extra metal. Hoekstra continues, “It thereby saves lots of metal parts that need to be protected against corrosion and that need to be welded in place; it saves working hours and thus saves the yard a lot of money. An extra benefit—one I must admit we did GO FURTHER WITH STEYR MOTORS! HIGH PERFORMANCE - LOWER COST FOR FUEL. 4 3 2 1 mpg 300 HP 5,7 L GAS 225 HP 2-STROKE 225 HP 4-STROKE 280 HP DI DIESEL Typical Test Boat 27 ft. Cruiser-Cabin | AVG. Cruiser RPM 3500@25 mph. …SAVE YOUR MONEY! FUEL EFFICIENT MAXIMUM DRIVING RANGE Take advantage of the STEYR MOTORS high pressure unit injector DI diesel it will take you further! MO286/H43 For more information please contact: STEYR MOTORS North America, Inc 3014 Lisenby Ave. #12 Panama City, FL. 32405 USA Rich Alley, General Manager Phone (850) 784 - 7933 Fax (850) 784 - 7932 office@steyr-motorsna.com www.steyr-motorsna.com Dealer inquiries welcome! April/May MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 51 2014 51 2/25/14 2:31 PM not at first foresee—is that hulls constructed with Smart Kits have extra sound-dampening qualities. A vessel will be quieter if assembled this way. This saves on extensive sound isolation.” In Build K&M crews working as if it made no difference which construction method they used. They just worked fast. From a shop-floor perspective, the two methods are very similar. One difference mentioned by Kuperus is that while in both methods engineers design slotted metal plates that slide together and lock at their intersections, Vripack’s Smart Kit employs an additional pin-in-hole assembly method to key parts to one another. Another advantage made possible by the integration of 3D design software with precise laser cutting and sharing design drawings over My visit to K&M in December 2013 was a great opportunity to compare the two types of kits in the two new builds rapidly progressing there. One, a Dykstra-designed Bestevaer 53ST (16.2m) sailing yacht, was being built with the K&M-developed CNC-cutting and assembly process. The other, a 32.8' (10m) aluminum rescue boat for a merchant vessel, was designed by Vripack as a Smart-Kit build. In the production hall the two aluminum boats stood side by side with the Cutouts in the stringers and transverse frames allow for spray and moisture to flow into the bilge, reducing potential for water to pool and corrode those members after the boat is finished. Superior performance. Epoxies for laminating, infusion, tooling and assembly. prosetepoxy.com | 888-377-6738 © ORACLE TEAM USA / Photo: Guilain GRENIER 52 PROFESSIONAL BOATBUILDER MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 52 2/25/14 2:31 PM computer networks is the ease of outsourcing or subcontracting components, systems, or whole sections of the boat. Thanks to digital design, suppliers such as interior builders, equipment suppliers, and electronics installers can preassemble their components to close tolerances with confidence in the fit (see the sidebar “The Cutter”). Later, when equipment is installed, the benefits of a kit engineered to tight tolerances are obvious: cutouts in crossbeams and structures allow flawless placement of cables, pipes, and hoses. CNC laser cutting of steel and aluminum, with margins of 0.1mm over large pieces of metal, allows for tight assembly, so Jetten can build different sections of the yacht at different sites and assemble them later. Such is the case of the Gamma 20 hull, under construction in its assembly hall during my visit. “The hull and other parts of the yacht were built at three different locations,” Marcel Jetten says. “We have seven different modules: the hull itself, sections of the motor mount Building with kitted CNC-cut components is so efficient that just two weeks after construction began, the hull of this Bestevaer at K&M is ready for plating, which has started at the garboard. OEMs First Choice For the boat of your dreams Sea Recovery is the brand boatbuilders trust most. The Aqua Matic watermaker gives more advantages such as space saving, lighter weight loads, and unlimited fresh water. Best of all, Sea Recovery water helps conserve a boat’s surface shine and finish with routine wash downs. A complete boat is a boat with a Sea Recovery watermaker. Call us to find out more about our line of watermakers. (310) 637-3400 | (800) 354-2000 www.searecovery.com AQUA MATIC Produces up to 75 gal/hr Compliments of Viking Yachts April/May MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 53 2014 53 2/25/14 2:39 PM The Cutter V ripack, Jetten Yachting, and K&M Yachtbuilders all go to the Frisian company Snijtech, in Joure, for laser cutting. Founded in 1995 this full-service metal-cutting facility was early to invest in computerized laser cutters. Today it provides engineering, and CNC-laser, CNCplasma, and CNC-waterjet cutting of kits for components in aluminum, steel, and stainless steel. “We get involved with our clients in the yacht-building industry,” says sales director Peter Aukema. “With our experience in metal cutting and marking the different parts, we try to advise yacht builders on efficient ways to get their processes organized. We are one in a chain of companies that are all involved in the making of a yacht. If all of these companies work closely together on a project basis, a lot of overhead cost may be eliminated. Even if it is just by arranging the numbered parts or organizing transport directly to the different locations where parts of the yacht are being built.” Eeuwe Kooi, manager at K&M, agrees. “We try to do all the steps of the process at the work floor that is best laid out for that specific task,” he says. “So the deburring of the parts after cutting can be done most efficiently at Snijtech. We also ask them to do the arranging of the different parts by number, so we get them at our shop floor in the correct order. It just saves us all time to do it like that.” —H.B. Clearly labeled and sequentially stacked aluminum parts precut at Snijtec are ready for assembly on the shop floor at K&M. THE NON-SKID PATTERN SOURCE BOAT YARDS can make near-perfect repairs to molded-in, non-skid patterns. No more sanding out smooth areas or trying to cover it up with carpet or some other item. BOAT BUILDERS “ONE OFF BUILDERS” can now add non-skid patterns to their plugs or molds, repair production molds or boats that are accidentally damaged during construction. can now have a choice of patterns that can be more attractive than sprayed or rolled-on sand grit surface. Over 60 unique patterns Used by most major U.S. and international composite manufacturers (817) 236-5021 info@gibcoflexmold.com 6657 E. Peden Rd. Fort Worth, TX 76179 www.gibcoflexmold.com 54 Professional BoatBuilder MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 54 2/25/14 2:31 PM The refined engineering necessary for effective kitting of metal hulls also allows larger intricate components to be prefabricated with certainty that they will fit the hull as planned. That includes elements as large as the keel framework for the Bestevaer (right). and the engineroom, the tank section in the yacht, the cabin, stern sections, the staircases from the flybridge to the aft deck, and the flybridge itself. When starting construction at different locations we try to choose locations close to each other. We also carefully think, before starting production of the different sections, about how we are going to transport them to the assembly hall. The bigger sections like the main part of the hull and the flybridge we therefore build at our main facility.” Refined Engineering As with any new technology there have been instances when perceived advantages eluded builders, and others where unintended advantages emerged. “We have gone through some learning with this type of pre-engineered Contemporary WOODEN BOATBUILDING (wood/epoxy, cold-molded, glued lapstrake, foam core) 9-month Diploma 12-month AOS Degree Full-Time Programs Financial aid, Veteran’s Benefits, and Scholarships may be available to those who qualify www.nwboatschool.org 360-385-4948 or info@nwboatschool.org Port Hadlock, WA Located on Port Townsend Bay Stephens Waring Yacht Design Sentinel-24 AZULITA Our school is accredited by the Accrediting Commission of Career Schools and Colleges (ACCSC) ProBoat-third-HZ-904-001.indd 1 MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 55 April/May 2/13/1455 9:44 AM 2014 2/25/14 2:31 PM assembly,” Jetten says. “With the first kits we were engineering too much. For example, we had the laser cutter carve a piece of steel to be formed into a joint between deck and hull plating. This piece was then placed in a folding brake. Following all these actions we had the same thing we could have bought from stock in the metal shop: a steel angle profile. In following versions of the Smart Kit we eliminated this bit of over-engineering. Accurate design files also facilitate outsourcing large structures such as this staircase from the aft deck up to the flying bridge on the Gamma 20. Built to spec by another shop, it fit perfectly into the time-sensitive build at Jetten Yachting. “After the first five boats built we have come to the point where Vripack engineers, in co-operation with our Quality Color Our business is not only about paint or boats. It’s about people. ALEXSEAL® technicians are passionate about color. With every factory produced batch of topcoat, our technicians measure and adjust the color to ensure an accurate match with the ALEXSEAL color cards available to you globally. As a result, you can count on the paint that you buy anywhere in the world – last year, today or in the future – to match precisely. ALEXSEAL.COM EU: +49 (40) 75 10 30 > USA: +1 (843) 654 7755 ISO 9001 TS 16949 EN 9100 ISO 14001 shop-floor professionals, work out about 10% fewer parts, as we can easily use standard parts at these places in the boats. Other aspects of thorough engineering save time. The metal-cutting machine can make holes for fittings like the cabin window frames a lot faster and more precisely than any yard worker with a drill could do it.” Another cost savings of Smart Kits for Jetten is that not all plates must be cut by laser. Laser metal cutting allows no more than 0.1mm deviation from computer drawings, but less expensive plasma cutting is now as precise as 0.5mm to 0.8mm maximum deviation. “So we have the main construction of transverse frames and stringers laser-cut, but the hull plating plasmacut,” Jetten says. “The process of optimizing cost and build time for our yachts continues. The Smart Kit gets smarter all the time, while we also try to improve on yard logistics and cost efficiency. In the end, motoryachts are luxury items that not everyone can afford. The lower the cost of our yachts, the bigger our market. Short delivery times can make the difference if another yard might be able to offer a yacht with dimensions, performance, and finish comparable to ours. If we have the same yacht built within eight months, while a year and a half is the common building time, we hope to get the order.” About the Author: Hans Buitelaar is a freelance marine journalist specializing in the Dutch and North European boatbuilding industry. 56 Professional BoatBuilder MetalCutting148_ADFinal.indd 56 2/25/14 2:32 PM