THE DELAWARE VALLEY RAIL PASSENGER DRPA Completes
Transcription
THE DELAWARE VALLEY RAIL PASSENGER DRPA Completes
Advancing the passengers’ agenda… THE DELAWARE VALLEY RAIL PASSENGER Vol. XXIV, No. 1 January-February 2006 Published by the Delaware Valley Association of Rail Passengers, Inc. in the interest of continued, improved, and expanded rail service for the present and potential railroad and rail transit passengers of southeastern Pennsylvania, southern New Jersey, and nearby areas $1.25 For more information about DVARP and good rail service, please contact us: 1601 Walnut St., Suite 1129, Philadelphia, PA 19102 phone 215-RAILWAY mail@dvarp.org www.dvarp.org DRPA Completes Gloucester Study by Robert Montgomery The Delaware River Port Authority has released their long-awaited ‘South Jersey to Philadelphia’ Transit study. The study details both a potential PATCO extension to Glassboro and Millville, as well as a light rail operation along Delaware Avenue/Columbus Blvd on the Philadelphia waterfront. This article will deal with the South Jersey portion of the study. The stated description of the study is “assess the need and a consensus for expanded rapid transit service for a growing congested corridor between Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and the outlying communities of Southern New Jersey. The study also analyzes the general feasibility of several potential transit investments.” The study is organized into five chapters, including mentions of existing conditions, and alternatives development. Three modes of transport were DVARP testifies on service cuts, fare increases the focus of the study: 1. PATCO 2. Modified PATCO (which could permit at-grade operation via both third rail and overhead catenary), and 3. diesel light rail (which could be similar to the existing River LINE cars). The long list of alternatives consisted of the following: continued on page 13 Schedule Change Alert New schedules now in effect for SEPTA R3, R5, and Glenside trains SEPTA City Transit schedules change in midFebruary. Legislators listen to DVARP testimony on Amtrak and regional rail issues at House Democratic Policy Committee hearing in Philadelphia. Full story: page 8 photo: Donald Nigro From the Editor’s Seat People of the Year Once again, it’s time to look ahead at the new year, and name some people I predict will have a significant effect on passenger rail and transit service in 2006— for good or for bad. David Laney has a tremendous challenge ahead of him—trying to restore his credibility with Congress and the credibility of the remnants of the Amtrak Reform Board. His clash with David Gunn might have been inevitable, but Laney managed to handle it in a very clumsy manner, and make Gunn into a Beltway hero. If Laney really means it when he says he is trying to improve Amtrak and not destroy it, he’d better come up with a constructive plan soon. Credibility is also at stake for SEPTA, which took a painful blow from two former supporters in the State Senate last month. Faye Moore may be down to her last chance to turn the image of the system around and regain the trust of the legislature. But to do so, she will have to insist that every SEPTA manager face up to SEPTA’s problems, and that candor and accountability replace spin and blame-shifting. The rest of top management might find that new attitude uncomfortable, but maintaining the status quo will be even more uncomfortable if Harrisburg concludes SEPTA is unable to reform itself. Zack Stalberg cared enough about SEPTA to keep it on the front burner when he was editor of the Daily News. He also cared enough about the city of Philadelphia to vehemently object to decisions being forced on it from outside. Now he’s become CEO of the Committee of Seventy, at a critical time for that government reform group. I hope he can take a little time from his fight against corruption in City Hall to speak up about SEPTA, and share his organization’s insights into how public transportation should be organized and managed. While SEPTA might get the most attention in reports about the future of public transit in Pennsylvania, I think what happens this year at PAT in Pittsburgh may be even more critical. PAT’s financial straits are even more dire than SEPTA’s, and the new labor settlement barring any privatization may be seen as a direct challenge to those legislators who are unhappy with the staus quo. Dennis Veraldi, a lawyer by trade and PAT’s general counsel before moving to the private sector, has been brought back into this cauldron as acting CEO. There is much more talk of a complete restructuring of transit in the Pittsburgh area than there is in Philadelphia, and Pittsburgh’s members of the Reform Commission are much less deferential to management than Philadelphia’s. A PAT collapse could have repercussions here. Someone else with a lot of issues to deal with is PennDOT chief Allen Biehler. Besides his usual responsibilities, he has to chair the Reform Commission and manage its investigations of transit and highway funding needs. If things fall apart for Amtrak, PAT, or SEPTA, Biehler is the one who will have to figure out how to pick up the pieces. Even if they all manage to get through the year, , he has to deal with the fallout from the Amtrak fare increases and service cuts (bad) and manage the Keystone Corridor improvements (good). Unfortunately for him (and everyone else on this year’s list) there’s no overtime pay.—MDM Correction Erase the marks on your calendar please. The dates for the July through December 2006 DVARP meetings were reported incorrectly in last month’s newsletter. The correct dates are July 15, September 16, October 21, November 18, and December 16. Thanks to DVARP member Burt Eisenberg for noticing the error.—MDM The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger (ISSN 1073-6859) is published monthly by DVARP; 1601 Walnut St., Suite 1129, Philadelphia PA 19102. Periodicals postage rates paid at Philadelphia, PA. Entire contents copyright © 2006 DVARP, except photos, figures © 2006 credited artists. Contact the Editor for permission before reprinting material. POSTMASTER: send address changes to Delaware Valley Rail Passenger, 1601 Walnut St. Suite 1129, Philadelphia PA 191012 DVARP President: Tony DeSantis Newsletter Editor: Matthew Mitchell for other officers and appointees, see back page Circulation Manager: Jeff Brown Opinions expressed in The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger are not necessarily those of DVARP or its members. We welcome your comments: call 215-RAILWAY page 2 The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger Roebuck, Washington Blast SEPTA Management Two state legislators vented their anger with SEPTA last month, upset with the authority over its failure to respond to their constituents’ concerns. Representative James Roebuck said he and his West Philadelphia colleagues were fed up with delays in completion of the Market Street El reconstruction project, which has caused street closures and other disruptions in their districts. State and city officials from West Philadelphia think SEPTA’s efforts to mitigate that disruption have been inadequate, and businesses are failing as a result. In a KYW Newsradio report, Roebuck voiced displeasure with the “inept, arrogant bureaucracy” of SEPTA. SEPTA was also called “arrogant” by State Senator LeAnna Washington of Mount Airy. She and her constituents are upset with SEPTA’s summary dismissal of community concerns about paving over the trolley tracks on Germantown Avenue. She spared no adjectives in a December 2 letter to Faye Moore, copied to the SEPTA Board, Governor Rendell, state senate leaders, and other elected officials from the affected neighborhoods. The letter recounted the events of late November, after she learned of SEPTA’s plans to pave over the rails. SEPTA reportedly sent out a crew on Wednesday, November 23 to look at the street and prepare for the paving, which was to take place the following Monday—effectively the next working day, considering the long Thanksgiving weekend. Washington called an urgent meeting for Monday, so SEPTA engineers could understand the community’s opposition to the paving. At the meeting, the SEPTA personnel reiterated their decision to pave over the tracks, even after an outside engineer reported there were other alternatives to the paving that would in fact be safer than the SEPTA plan. Later, Washington learned that SEPTA’s engineers had not had direct consultations with PennDOT until just before the Monday meeting, even though Germantown Avenue is officially a state road. Nor could SEPTA document that they had given due consideration to any other alternatives such as traffic-calming. But SEPTA went ahead and sent the asphalt trucks anyway. Last-minute efforts to block the action in court failed, and the tracks were paved over on Friday. That was the last straw for Washington, and that day, her letter to Moore went out. The strong words in it tell just how infuriated people have become with SEPTA: “I am not an engineer, but I have difficulty with your contention that I should believe you and not my own eyes. This point, above all, has shaken any trust I had with your agency. The genuineness of your commitment to work with the community is dubious. SEPTA is not action as a good steward for the preservation of this historic street, and your single-minded approach engenders a continuing and growing distrust, supporting arguments that your motives are suspect—merely to direct responsibility for this road to PennDOT and to chip away at the viability of a transit option that you find objectionable. In all my time as an elected official, I cannot remember an agency presenting such intransigence to my request along with so many misrepresentations. The significance of Washington and Roebuck going public with their frustrations goes much further than just bad press for Faye Moore and her staff—it’s two fewer votes Moore can count on when she asks the legislature for the increased funding SEPTA dearly needs. Roebuck said flat out he “would not vote one cent for SEPTA” under the current circumstances. Washington reminded Moore: “Actions have consequences.” Worse yet, both Washington and Roebuck are Democrats from Philadelphia—among the legislators who would otherwise be the strongest supporters of public transportation. Their stated anger with how SEPTA is being managed will influence other legislators who might be sitting on the fence with regard to transit funding, and could be cited as justification by other members who have opposed sending more money to SEPTA. Finally, the legislators’ comments lend further credibility to earlier critics of SEPTA: both elected officials like Councilman Michael Nutter, and organizations like DVARP. The cases Washington and Roebuck cite add to a pattern of SEPTA decisions made for short-term expediency and not for the long-term growth and improvement of public transportation in the region, and they reinforce the message that SEPTA is aloof to outside concerns. If this is how SEPTA treats even its friends, “arrogant” is not too strong a word.—MDM January-February 2006 page 3 New Switches and Signals During the weekend of January 21-22, SEPTA activated its new signal system between Wayne Junction and Jenkintown. To their credit, SEPTA kept R2, R3, and R5 trains in service throughout the weekend, even though they had to single-track between Fern Rock and Jenkintown. By skipping stops at Elkins Park and Melrose Park, each train could get through the single-track segment fast enough to get a pair of trains through in 15 minutes and not set up delays that would mount the entire day. Also in service now are new crossovers just south of Jenkintown station. With a facing point crossover here (one where trains can switch from the normal track for their direction of operation to the opposite track without having to back up), SEPTA gains increased flexibility for dispatching trains, particularly if one track is out of service. Cab Signals Increase Speed, Capacity You may notice a flashing green aspect on some of the new signals. This is a “Cab Speed” signal, and it replaces the block signals formerly on this stretch of line between interlockings (switch and signal complexes). When the engineer sees this signal, the train is authorized to proceed at the speed indicated by the cab signal system. As the name suggests, cab signals display in the locomotive (or Silverliner) cab, in a special box on the engineer’s instrument panel. Several different signal aspects can be displayed, depending on the specific equipment in use. Typical systems show Clear (green), Approach Medium (green/ yellow), Approach (yellow), and Restricted (red) signals (or their position light equivalents). Cab signals have several advantages, among them the ability to update the signal after a train has entered a block of track. If there is a train in the block ahead, the signal will be yellow (Approach), and the train must not exceed medium speed (30 mph). Once the train ahead clears its block, the cab signal will change to green (Clear), and the engineer can accelerate to full speed. But if there were only conventional fixed signals, the engineer would not know the block ahead had cleared, and the train would have to continue at medium speed until the engineer gets close enough to the next block to see the green fixed signal. So trains can run faster (and closer together) in cab signal territory, while maintaining a safe separation between trains.—MDM page 4 On the Railroad Lines It’s Showtime! The trains home from Philadelphia will be a sensory treat (for most of us at least) from March 4 through 12, as the Philadelphia Flower Show has its annual run at the Convention Center. Expect RRD parking lots to fill up earlier, and expect extra crowds on the train. As they have in past years, SEPTA offers a “Bouquet Pass” good for unlimited travel on any bus, trolley, or train on the system any one day during the show. The Bouquet Pass is not valid on morning peak trains, and is not valid for travel to or from Trenton. You can buy passes in advance at rail stations, or get a discounted combination pack including Flower Show admission and the SEPTA pass at rail stations or selected garden centers. The pass itself costs $8.00, so even if you don’t go beyond the Convention Center, it will save you money if you’re traveling from a zone 4 station, or if you’re traveling from zone 3 and will be riding home on a peak-period train. Lots of people will also use SEPTA to get to the Auto Show, February 4 through 12. The “Turbo Transit Pass” is now on sale, also for $8.00. Rules and validity are the same as for the Flower Show promotional fare. Fortunately, we don’t expect the trains to smell of exhaust fumes. R3Weekday Brush Cutting New schedules effective January 9 have revised mid-day train times on both the Media/ Elwyn and West Trenton sides of the R3. Crews will be trimming brush from around the tracks and overhead wires of the West Trenton line. The revised R3 schedules also affect passengers at the local stations from Jenkintown to Center City, so those passengers should make sure to have the January 9 edition of the Combined Glenside timetable R5Lansdale Weekend Delays Brush cutting crews will work weekends between Ambler and Lansdale, requiring singletrack operation and special schedules on affected weekends. To their credit, SEPTA has put this information right in the new R5 Doylestown timetable. Inbound trains will depart 8 to 14 minutes earlier from Doylestown, 10 minutes earlier from Lansdale, and 5 minutes earlier from Ambler, then on regular schedules from Fort Washington south. The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger Trains departing Doylestown after 4:00 pm are not affected. Outbound, departures from Center City will be at the usual times. Passengers going to points between Ambler and Doylestown should expect arrivals to be 11 to 20 minutes later. Trains leaving Center City after 4:00 pm are not affected. The special schedules will be in effect every weekend from January 28 through April 16, except for the Flower Show weekends of March 4-5 and March 11-12. Once the West Trenton work is done, in early spring, weekday brush cutting work will shift to the Doylestown branch. SEPTA plans to operate shuttle buses instead of trains mid-days between Lansdale and Doylestown. Schedules for that project have not been announced yet. R7Check Your Connections NJ Transit revised its Northeast Corridor Line schedules January 15. R8Wires Removed Catenary wire is being removed from the now freight-only second track between Newtown Junction (where the Fox Chase line joins the main line) and Cheltenham Junction (where the Fox Chase line and the CSX freight route to New Jersey diverge). Capital Budget: New Openness For the first time in its history, SEPTA is soliciting public comments on its capital projects before the official public hearings on the capital budget. The meetings will be January 30 at SEPTA headquarters. Public comments will also be accepted by mail or e-mail, if received by February 28. Visit the Public Notices section of www.septa.org for the address and for other details. The new meetings address some of DVARP’s chief criticisms of the SEPTA capital budget process: the public is not informed of important projects until it comes time to approve or reject the entire capital budget, and public input in the process comes too late for those comments to make any difference in how a project is designed or carried out. While the meetings are a welcome step forward in making SEPTA more responsive to the public, they still can not take the place of a longrange plan, developed in consultation with riders and other stakeholders. January-February 2006 Transit News Update Progress STD Station As part of the project to improve traffic flow on Garrett Road in Upper Darby, some Media-Sharon Hill trolley platforms will be moved to the far side of intersections. This will facilitate transit-priority signaling, as trolleys will proceed through the crossing before stopping to pick up or discharge passengers. Car and truck drivers who wish to cross the tracks won’t have to wait for the trolley to finish its station work before they get a green light. Further down the line, SEPTA is proceeding with installation of railroad crossing gates at various intersections from Aronimink to Media. Until now, most of those crossings had been protected only by traffic signals (gates were installed at three crossings in the 80s), but since auto drivers have shown less and less respect for signals, there has been an increasing number of close encounters of the dangerous kind. A few complaints have been reported—large overhead gantries have been installed for warning lights, and some people find them ugly and out of place in the leafy suburban territory. Transit Notes The subway-surface tunnel will be closed from Friday night to Monday morning the weekend of February 4-5, while SEPTA does track work. News compiled by Matthew Mitchell and correspondents: Howard Bender, Scott Maits, Don Nigro, Bill Ritzler Additional news from Baltimore Sun, New York Times, Philadelphia Daily News, Philadelphia Inquirer, Railpace. Your news tips are always welcome. Phone 215-RAILWAY or e-mail newsletter@dvarp.org Printed on recycled paper. NARP Region 3 Meeting April 1 in Bordentown see page 14 for details page 5 Third SEPTA Investigation Coming Concerned that the system performance review now underway for the Transportation Funding and Reform Commission will overlook crucial functions like the 2004 SEPTA management audit did, legislators directed the House Transportation Committee to undertake its own investigation of SEPTA, and the committee is moving swiftly to carry out that mandate. A consulting firm will be selected this month, and its final report is due by September 30, about the time the Reform Commission’s consultants are due to make their report. The House resolution (#538) cited SEPTA’s budget and operational problems as the reason for the investigation, but at the same time pointed out the need for a dedicated source of transit funding in Pennsylvania. It also recognized concerns about whether SEPTA would spend those funds wisely. Since SEPTA has not been forthright in addressing past management problems, elected officials’ confidence in SEPTA and its management has been eroding (see story above). That’s a major reason that increased transit funding wasn’t passed in 2004. Governor Rendell tried to alleviate those concerns by ordering an audit of SEPTA and other systems by the Transportation Funding and Reform Commission, but the resolution hints at legislators’ worry that the Reform Commission’s audit team is too close to SEPTA management: “Public confidence in an investigation of any ongoing problems incurred by SEPTA would be best served by an independent investigation.” [emphasis added] The resolution also spelled out the legislators’ wishes for “major organizational and personnel changes in management”: (1) The development of productivity standards based on fare box revenues. (2) Implementation of a more efficient management and personnel structure. (3) Provision for an annual and a biennial performance audit. (4) The use of private sector contracts for goods and services through competitive bidding. (5) The modernization of scheduling so that it better takes into account levels of ridership and efficiencies in operation; Finally, the resolution orders SEPTA to provide the legislature with a list of its management objectives for 2006-07, and subsequent quarterly reports on progress towards those goals. If SEPTA can make meaningful progress on the legislators’ priorities in the next six months, then not only will it be easier to secure dedicated funding, but the legislature will also be less inclined to impose change on SEPTA from outside. —MDM We Want Pictures, Not Names! DVARP’s board of directors gave a unanimous thumbs-down to the Pew Charitable Trusts’ proposal to rename 30th Street Station “Benjamin Franklin Station.” The foundation seeks the name change for tourism marketing purposes as well as to honor Philadelphia’s most famous citizen, and has dangled money in front of officials to help pay for the change. Official reaction was mixed, with Mayor Street lending his support to the change and others either seeing no need for the change or fearing it could confuse people. Some of the arguments for the name change were based on the faulty premise that “30th Street” was not the original name of the station, therefore there was precedent for another name change. But engineer and former SEPTA Citizen Advisory Committee member Lin Bongaardt found documentation that “30th Street” was indeed the station’s name at its opening in 1930, and the formal “Pennsylvania Station” moniker came three years later. DVARP director Scott Maits may have had the most apropos response to the proposal. He said that Amtrak didn’t need the name of Benjamin Franklin—it needed pictures of Franklin (as in hundred-dollar bills). DVARP did not take an official position beyond opposing the name change, but there was some sentiment among directors and members that renaming Philadelphia International Airport would be a much better choice than renaming the train station.—MDM Update at press time: Pew has withdrawn its proposal. page 6 The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger Keystone Corridor Progress Amtrak crews replace ties and rail near Devon on the main line to Harrisburg, also used by SEPTA R5 Paoli trains. photo: Garry Patterson $5,000 State Grant to Help With Outreach DVARP is pleased to announce that it has received a Community Revitalization Assistance Grant through Pennsylvania's Department of Community and Economic Development. The grant, in the amount of $5,000, will be used for the purchase of a digital projector and a laptop computer for use by DVARP in its advocacy efforts. We plan to use it in presentations given to civic groups, business groups, transportation decision makers, and legislators. DVARP thanks State Representative Babette Josephs for bringing this grant opportunity to our attention. This is the first grant received by DVARP, and we hope it paves the way for future applications for grants to assist us in our endeavors.—PN January-February 2006 page 7 legislators on the Keystone Corridor Improvement Project, but when it came time for questions, a host of other topics came up, like platform configuration and delays to trains traveling to PittsState legislators on the House Democratic burgh. It was much the same with the Amtrak Policy Committee invited DVARP to testify at their presentation, given by a panel including planning hearing on rail service cuts January 18 in Philadirector Drew Galloway, Keystone Corridor prodelphia. Matthew Mitchell represented DVARP at ject manager Vinay Mudholkar, and government the hearing, joining speakers from PennDOT, affairs director Peter Cohen. Amtrak, and rail labor. The invitation is indicative Thus it was left to DVARP to explain why the of DVARP’s growing stature in Harrisburg, not Clockers were eliminated, and to speak about just on SEPTA reform, but on broader transportaskyrocketing fares for Northeast Corridor travel, tion issues. particularly to New York. Striking a balance The hearing was called at the recommendation between concern for passengers who can no longer of Rep. Babette Josephs (D-Philadelphia), many of afford to ride Amtrak trains and concern for whose constituents are regular Amtrak riders. Amtrak’s dire financial situation, Mitchell told the Those constituents are upset with steep Amtrak committee that Philadelphia passengers were fare increases and with the elimination of Clocker hardest hit by the fare increases. service to Philadelphia last year. So Josephs, Then he turned to solutions, first among them committee chairman Stephen Stetler (D-York) and implementation of the “One Seat Ride” service other legislators wanted to know more about those envisioned in the DVRPC Regional Rail Improvematters. About ten House members attended all ment Study of 2003. The study found that a direct or part of the hearing, which was held in Philaservice between Suburban Station and Midtown delphia City Hall, in the City Council chambers. Manhattan was technically feasible, giving PhilaIn her opening comments, Josephs criticized delphia passengers convenient service with no cuts in federal funding for Amtrak, and spoke of need to transfer at Trenton and lower fares than passenger rail as a security issue as well as an Amtrak charges. He urged the legislators to make economic and social issue. She was followed by a commitment to political and financial support of Toby Fauver of PennDOT. As Acting Deputy Secthat new service, and to take action quickly before retary for Local and Area Transportation, Fauver more passengers find alternate transportation is in charge of state passenger rail programs. instead of paying through the nose for Amtrak Fauver spent most of his time briefing the tickets. After mentioning the proposed NJ Transit Morrisville station at and the existing but underserved Amtrak stop at Cornwells Heights as other opportunities for PennDOT to mitigate service cuts, Mitchell shifted to the matter of threatened rail rights of way. Service on a number of routes in Southeastern Pennsylvania has been eliminated, and now some of those cuts could end up being made permanent if nobody steps in to prevent sale and/or development of the land the tracks stood on. He cited the PhiladelphiaBethlehem route as the most urgent example. A critical segment Matthew Mitchell offers legislators a CD-ROM of right of way between Hellerwith DVARP testimony and supporting material town and Bethlehem has been Photo: Donald Nigro abandoned and put up for sale by DVARP Testifies at Committee Hearing page 8 The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger Norfolk Southern. The legislators were urged to arrange for PennDOT or by a local authority to purchase the land and protect it from development. DVARP’s testimony also called the paving over of Route 23 trolley tracks to the legislators’ attention, as this represents another kind of rail service cut. Josephs and her colleagueswere visibly shocked when they heard how SEPTA had brushed off all community concerns and rushed to pave the street and foreclose any near-term restoration of trolley service to Northwest Philadelphia. There wasn’t time for DVARP to testify further about SEPTA at this hearing. Even though SEPTA funding and reform is our biggest issue in Harrisburg this year, it was more important to stay focused on the topic for which the hearing was called. The committee has indicated it plans to hold a hearing on SEPTA at a future date; DVARP will be prepared. Knowing that elected officials are busy people, DVARP tried to make their fact-finding process as easy as possible. CD-ROMs provided to Stetler, Josephs, and their staff included not just the DVARP testimony, but copies of the DVRPC study, the rail corridor study, and other supporting documents. Both the text and visual components of the presentation will be available for download from DVARP’s web site too. Monthly Fare Hike This Month The next step in Amtrak’s phased implementation of fare increases for monthly passholders takes effect February 16. Fares will go up another 16.7 percent as Amtrak scales back the discount on monthly fares from 60% to 50%. If you can plan and budget ahead, you can delay the impact of the increase by purchasing tickets for up to 11 months in advance. New Acela Express Fare Structure Amtrak is extending its ‘revenue managent’ pricing system to Acela Express effective January 28. Revenue management is a tool for increasing Amtrak’s total fare revenue by more precisely matching fares with projected demand. Instead of the current peak and off-peak fares with their fixed times of applicability, there will be five ‘fare buckets’ whose availability will come and go depending on the number of seats available on each particular train. As with the airlines, it will usually be cheaper to make reservations as far in advance as possible. January-February 2006 Bush Dodges Congress, Reappoints Board Members As Congress adjourned its 2005 session, President Bush took the opportunity to extend the terms of Amtrak Reform Board nominees Floyd Hall and Enrique Sosa for another year through recess appointments which do not need Senate confirmation. The move maintains a quorum of four board members, while three seats remain vacant. They have been vacant since 2003. The two other members are Chairman David Laney and Transportation Secretary Norman Mineta. Unlike the president’s blocked judicial nominations, there has been no formal hold placed on the Amtrak appointees—but no vote on confirmation has been scheduled. Part of the problem could be that the two Republicans are required to be accompanied by two Democrats, and the Democratic leadership of the Senate is not accepting Bush’s two Democrat choices: Robert Crandall and Louis Thompson. Democrats may not be considering Bush’s appointments complete because he has not replaced those two candidates, while Bush is using the failure to schedule a vote as justification for using recess appointments to seat his nominees. NARP and other rail advocates have joined Amtrak supporters in Congress in calling for the President and the Senate to resolve the standoff and get the Amtrak board back to full strength. Meanwhile, the Amtrak reauthorization bill introduced in the Senate last year as S. 1516 would expand the board to nine members, make Amtrak’s president a member of the board, and require seven of the other members to have relevant transportation experience. Gunn to Keynote Del. Meeting This year’s public policy conference at the University of Delaware’s Institute for Public Administration will be on the subject of “Building Inter-Metropolitan Rail Corridors.” Former Amtrak president David Gunn is scheduled to be the keynote speaker. The conference will be held Tuesday, February 21 in Newark, Delaware. The morning session will focus on rail corridors and their place in the nation’s transportation infrastructure. Project planners and officials from states with successful corridor programs like California and Washington will talk about their page 9 programs and what they’ve learned from developing them. In the afternoon, participants will discuss the current policy environment for intercity passenger rail, touching on legislation and advocacy among other topics. Operational issues will also be on the agenda. Co-sponsors include WILMAPCO, Delaware DOT, and the National Corridors Institute. NCI president James RePass will give a talk titled “Amtrak is Only the Symptom.” Academic guest speakers include Jean-Paul Rodrigue of Hofstra University and Allison De Cerrino of New York University. Registration is free, but by invitation only. For more information, contact the School of Urban Affairs and Public Policy at 302-831-1687, or email suapp@udel.edu. Amnotes The Silver Star will begin stopping at Cary NC on April 24. Cary is already a stop for the Piedmont, but up until now there was no passenger platform there for the track the Star uses. Also in April, ticket offices will be closed at several West Virginia stations, including Prince, Charleston, and Huntington. Up and Down the Corridor News from other Northeast rail and transit systems The existing freight and passenger tunnels are NYC Transit Pact Rejected both more than a century old, lack the safety In what was seen as a repudiation of TWU features of more modern construction, and Local 100 leader Roger Toussaint, union members constrain traffic capacity on the CSX and Amtrak rejected the contract settlement reached last main lines from Washington to Philadelphia. month with the New York City Transportation MARC Closing Little-Used Stations Authority. A second bus and subway strike looks Maryland’s MARC commuter rail system will unlikely any time soon though. MTA management stop service to four little-used stations on March has asked a state labor authority for arbitration. 6. The affected stations are St. Dennis and Jessup New Rail Map in Baltimore? on the Camden Line between Baltimore and In the aftermath of the 2001 Howard Street Washington, and Dickerson and Boyds on the Tunnel fire, the Federal Railroad Administration Brunswick Line between Martinsburg, West has suggested a new freight tunnel be built west of Virginia and Washington. A MARC statement said downtown Baltimore. Traffic and business in the the stations were served by one to four daily round city was disrupted for eight days after a CSX trips apiece and averaged 41 passengers boarding freight train derailed and caught fire. Water per station per day. leaking from old and deteriorated pipes may have VRE Demands Accountability, contributed to the accident. The FRA report also calls for a new passenger Gets CSX VP’s Attention train tunnel to replace the present B&P tunnels, Declining on-time performance has Virginia which run from Penn Station to south of the Inner Railway Express management upset with freight Harbor. The new tunnel would allow faster railroad host CSX Corporation. CSX owns the speeds, but would not require the station to be tracks to Fredricksburg as well as the Alexandriarelocated. The estimated cost for that tunnel is Washington trunk used by Manassas trains. High$500 million, but the report does not say who level discussions between VRE and CSX about the should pay for it. problem led to CSX appointing assistant vice presSeveral possible alignments are possible for ident Jay Westbrook to a position with specific the freight tunnels, which could cost $900 million responsibility for improving the performance of to $1.3 billion. Alignments under the harbor were VRE and Amtrak trains on Viriginia rails. Conconsidered, but they will be much more costly struction schedules are to be revised, communicathan an under-land alignment. The State of tions will be made more direct, and the two sides Maryland would like for other alternatives to be will work together to seek funding for a third track considered too, including a route within the I-95 between Washington and Richmond. right of way. page 10 The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger Rail Observations by Frank G. Tatnall, Jr., member of DVARP and NRHS Philadelphia Chapter SEPTA last month completed work on its latest Transit First project, at intersections on 52nd Street in West Philadelphia. When approaching a traffic light, Route 52 buses are equipped to send a signal which will hold the green light until the bus has passed through the intersection. This is similar to Transit First systems installed earlier on the Routes 10 and 15 trolley lines. As part of the project, Route 52 bus stops have been moved to far-side stops at 15 intersections along 52nd Street. The long-delayed pocket siding in Newtown Junction interlocking—intended as a holding track for northbound R8 trains entering the single track Fox Chase Line, finally has been placed in service. The new bi-directional single track to Fox Chase was cut in last June 20 and most of the interlocking work was completed by then, but the pocket track seemingly was a low priority. Even though it is not mentioned in SEPTA’s 12year capital program, there is some talk of eventually extending R5 service beyond Thorndale to Atglen, on the Amtrak mainline to Harrisburg. Several years ago SEPTA acquired a parcel of land at Atglen from Conrail, which could be used for a future commuter rail terminal. Atglen is 11 miles west of Thorndale and three miles west of Parkesburg—which formerly was served by R5 trains. The now-famous but little-publicized “Liberty Limited” special carried more than 60 wounded veterans from military hospitals in Washington to the Army-Navy football game in Philadelphia on December 3. The brainchild of well-known Philadelphia private-car owners Bennett, Vivian, and Eric Levin, the impressive train was made up of 18 private cars. It was powered by ex-Pennsy E8 locomotives #5711 and 5809, also owned by the Levins. Departing from Washington Union Station shortly after 9:30 am, the special made a fast run up Amtrak’s Northeast Corridor, diverging onto Conrail’s freight-only extension to the CSX Greenwich intermodal yard in South Philadelphia, where the passengers were put aboard a SEPTA bus shuttle to nearby Lincoln Financial Field. The train returned to Washington after the game, which was won by Navy. It was the first time in 30 years that a special train to the Army-Navy Game January-February 2006 had operated directly into Greenwich yard. The massive undertaking had numerous sponsors in addition to the host railroads, with the Army War College Foundation as lead sponsor. A beautiful full-color brochure was produced for distribution aboard the train, and the trip was the subject of a five-column story by Ronnie Polaneczky in the December 22 edition of the Daily News. To complete the effort, a beautiful color poster entitled “America’s Railroads Salute America’s Heroes” was produced for the occasion. While arrangements for the train were rather hush-hush, we may expect to see many photos in upcoming railfan magazines—especially as the aptly-named “Liberty Limited” crossed the Susquehanna River bridge at Perryville, MD. This writer was there, and can attest to the magnificence of the train on that sunny, chilly morning. Teams of Federal air marshals were deployed to 30th Street Station during mid-December, in a pilot program initiated by the Tranportation Security Administration “to enhance security outside of aviation.” The VIPER test (Visible Intermodal Protection and Response) was conducted in cooperation with Amtrak and local police, but was abruptly ended after two days due to some confusion at the TSA, according to press reports. Amtrak’s 2006 wall calendar featuring a photo of the newly-upgraded Empire Builder is now available. For details, visit the www.amtrak.com website. Reportedly, the California Zephyr is the next long-distance train slated for a relaunch similar to last year’s upgrade of the Builder. On December 15 Amtrak completed the 2005 phase of its track replacement program on the Harrisburg mainline between Paoli and Overbrook. The mechanized Track Laying System began to remove the old #2 eastbound track in early October, replacing it with concrete ties and smooth-riding continuous welded rail. The new track extends as far as a point between Narberth and Merion stations where work will resume in March, and in the meantime service has resumed on the #2 track. After completing work on #2, the machine will shift to #3 track, presumably working west from Overbrook. Two unions affiliated with the Teamsters are threatening to strike Amtrak. The Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers & Trainmen and the Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employees page 11 claim that in contract negotiations Amtrak is attempting to reduce overtime pay and certain other benefits. In November, union members handed out leaflets to passengers at 30th Street Station, Washington Union Station, Newark’s Penn Station and South Station in Boston, warning of a possible strike this year. Amtrak is now halfway through its five-year Acela overhaul program, which is being carried out at SEPTA’s Frazer shop by employees of the builders, Alstom and Bombardier. The tenth trainset was released from the shop on December 10, with ten more to go. Amtrak plans to offer special discounted coach tickets on the Pennsylvanian and other trains for selected dates beginning next month. The latest skirmish in the war of words between CSX and the City of Philadelphia occurred on December 20, when a railroad vice president faced an irate City Council committee. Councilman Michael Nutter grilled CSX’s William Goetz about the railroad’s insistence on closing the two pedestrian grade crossings at Schuylkill River Park in center city, as well as about the trains that often are parked there for hours at a time. Goetz refused to make any substantive comments because the matter is in Federal court as part of a CSX lawsuit against the City. But he did promise to “soften the effect” of the standing trains— especially trains loaded with garbage enroute from New York to disposal sites in the South. CSX’s relations with the City could become important, if Philadelphia and other cities eventually win the right to restrict the movement of certain hazardous materials across their borders. [ed. note: the railroads argue that municipal governments do not have the authority to interfere with interstate commerce] The case involving CSX freight movements through Washington, DC still has not been finally resolved, and could be the subject of future legislation. NJ Transit has announced a $98-million plan to expand the Morrisville service facility, doubling its size to accommodate 120 cars at a time. Originally opened in March 2004, the Morrisville facility is built on part of the old Pennsylvania Railroad Morrisville yard, once a major freight terminal. It is used to store and service trains for NJT’s busy commuter operation between Trenton and New York. Conrail retains part of the yard for local page 12 freight and Norfolk Southern operates an intermodal terminal at the west end of the yard. NJT has signed up as the major tenant of the proposed Moynihan Station in New York City, which will be converted from the present Farley Post Office building in an $800 million project. Amtrak opted to remain at nearby Penn Station rather than pay to occupy the Moynihan facility, named for the late Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan who was instrumental in finalizing the project. Calling the deal a “once-in-a-lifetime opportunity,” NJT Executive Director George Warrington said that he is “desperate for space” in New York. NJT will pay about $4.8 million in annual lease charges, and will be given operational control at the new facility. Daily ridership on the River Line between Camden and Trenton exceeded 7,000 in November, a 20percent increase over the same month in 2004, reflecting greater awareness of the service and the rising cost of gasoline. NJT will purchase 157 state-of-the-art automated ticket-vending machines for its stations, as well as upgrading 543 older machines. The Delaware Desk Wicks Named to DelDOT Post The new Delaware Secretary of Transportation pending legislative confirmation, is Carolann Wicks. Wicks, a highway engineer, has been with DelDOT for more than twenty years, and was the first woman to serve as their Chief Engineer. She also has a degree in public policy. Wicks’s predecessor, Nathan Hayward, announced his resignation in December after being diagnosed with prostate cancer. DART on the Move DART First State has moved its executive offices in downtown Wilmington. The new address is 119 Lower Beech St, Suite 100, Wilmington DE 19805. The offices are on the corner of Maryland Avenue and Beech Street. South Jersey Report Students Ride Free! A one-week promotion this month encourages college students in New Jersey to try transit. Eligible students can ride any NJ Transit bus or The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger train for free the week of January 30 through February 5. Just visit www.njtransit.com/nn_college. html, fill out the online registration form, and print out the coupon you will receive by e-mail. Then show the coupon and your student ID when you board the bus or train. Casino Express Trains Discussed Sources close to the negotiations report great interest from Atlantic City casinos in a proposed new weekend express train service from New York to Atlantic City. NJ Transit would operate the trains, while the casino sponsors would manage tickets, marketing, and on-board services. A premium service is envisioned, catering to gaming hall patrons, unlike the regular commuter rail service to Atlantic City, which mainly serves employees in the casino and hospitality industry. Whether or not the trains serve Philadelphia or other Pennsylvania points will be up to the sponsors. Current Amtrak Promotion Codes H545 (small group fare, expires March 31): 90% off regular fares for up to four additional travelers when two pay regular fares (including NARP discount fares). Valid only on Northeast Regional trains, Empire Service between New York and Albany, and Downeaster. Not valid on Keystone service to New York. Tickets must be purchased by March 31 for travel through August 31. See V832 and V806 for blackout dates. V832 (expires March 31): 50% off your companion’s fare when you travel to New York. Blacked out Feb. 17-20. V707 (expires March 31): 50% off your companion’s fare for travel in New York state on Empire Service trains, plus Ethan Allen Express, Maple Leaf, and Adirondack. Blacked out same dates as V832. V806 (expires Sept. 30): 50% off your companion’s fare when you travel to Princeton Junction or Trenton. Blacked out same dates as V832, plus April 13-17, May 26-29, Sept 1-4. Unless otherwise specified, Northeast Corridor promotion codes are not valid for Acela Express or Metroliner service, and promotion code discounts also apply to senior citizen and disabled persons’ fares, but not with the 10% NARP members’ discount. Reservations must be made at least three days in advance. Other restrictions may apply. Promotion codes were valid when researched, but may be changed or withdrawn by Amtrak at any time. January-February 2006 Gloucester Study continued from page 1 Alternative 1 would run from Millville along Route 55 to Route 42, and would join the existing line in downtown Camden, and from then into Philadelphia. This would be built in two phases— phase one would operate to Glassboro, and phase two from Millville to Glassboro. This is the short lists’ “NJ-2” alternative. Alternative 1A would be the same as Alt. 1, except would be operated as diesel light rail, and would terminate at the Camden waterfront. Passengers would then have to transfer for Philadelphia. Alternative 1B would be the same as Alt 1 except it would diverge from Rt. 42 at the NJ Turnpike, and would then follow the Grenloch Branch until I-676, until joining PATCO. Alternative 2 would run along the Vineland Secondary (from Glassboro to Camden) rail line until joining PATCO. Phase two of Alt. 2 would be a connection to Millville from Glassboro. This is the “NJ-3” alternative which DVARP has endorsed. Alternative 3 would begin at Glassboro along the Conrail right-of-way, then join Route 55 at approximately exit 53, to Route 42 and 676. Phase two would connect to Millvlle via the railroad ROW. Alternative 4 is the inverse of Alt. 3, which would operate from near exit 50 near Glassboro on Route 55, then would join the railroad at exit 53, then would travel via the railroad until Camden and join PATCO. Alternative 5 would be an extension of the current PATCO line to Berlin, then would operate along Route 536 to Williamstown. A version of this is the “NJ-1” short list option. Alternative 6 would start at Grenloch in Gloucester Township along the Grenloch Branch, then travel north on 676 until reaching Morgan Boulevard. It would then join the CR ROW, then merge with PATCO. The three routes which were ultimately chosen were alternative 1 (NJ-2) “for its use of existing right-of-way and directness from end-to-end”, alternative 2 (NJ-3) “for its use of existing rightof-way and directness from end-to-end” and support smart growth development. And alternative 5 (NJ-1) which was modified from the original to run on route 42 to the Cross Keys Road exit of the Atlantic City Expressway. It was kept as an page 13 option because it “would increase the service area of the existing speedline”, and to “help increase ridership on an already well-liked system”. A major criterion in any new start project is not only ridership estimates, but also a reduction in vehicle miles traveled (VMT). In other words, the proposed new transit service must get as many people out of their cars—the more, the better rating the project will receive. The highway alignments (NJ-1, NJ-2) can only work for peakdirection travel, and will have little to no use for reverse-commute trips. The NJ-3 alignment along the railroad from Glassboro to Camden can eliminate many car trips entirely for travel to Philadelphia. NJ-3 will also allow people to travel directly to Rowan University, and downtown Woodbury, from Camden County and Philadelphia. Another advantage of the NJ-3 option is the prospect of induced trips—people riding the new service just for fun, and in so doing, will get off the train, and walk around towns such as Westville, Woodbury, and Wenonah. This would be a boon to local businesses, especially within walking distance to a station. I have spent several Sunday afternoons since the River LINE opened, walking through Burlington, Palmyra, and Riverside. More people walking also helps make a community more livable. Also, these new visitors will patronize local businesses, as I have done myself in my travels along the River LINE. The next step is for the DRPA to initiate a full alternatives analysis. This is where all the alternatives’ capital and operating costs, and ridership estimates are studied in much greater detail. Federal funding is sought for preliminary engineering as well. Ultimately, the DRPA will have to choose a “locally preferred alternative”, or LPA, which will have to meet a long list of FTA criteria in order to achieve a good rating. The FTA’s rating will ultimately determine whether this project will be built. We hope the DRPA will act on this study, and not let this be one more study for rail transit in Gloucester County which will sit on the regions’ bookshelf. Want to see the full report? You can view it online at www.drpa.org page 14 Looking at the Route When the railroad comes out of Gloucester, the route could be “at grade” since there are a few bridges over Little Timber & Big Timber Creek, leaving two major grade crossings in Westville, at Crown Point Road, and Olive Street. At Olive, some work along the adjacent roads could mitigate any negative effect a passenger line may have, from altering signaling, providing an alternative route for large trucks, and other, smaller details which would make the railroad work in this area. The proposed station at Route 295 is in a very good location, though some more engineering work would have to be done to make sure ramps would be feasible to a proposed station. In north Woodbury, some right-of-way would have to be reclaimed, as there are several parking lots near the Colonial Diner. The proposed line, I believe, would have to be put in a cut near Cooper Street in Woodbury, as this is a major intersection where a station is proposed. Below Woodbury, grade crossings are sporadic, and the line is relatively straight. There are, however, two clusters of grade crossings, in Pitman, and Glassboro. These are two places that a cut, or perhaps an elevated line would be appropriate. In conclusion, more engineering and surveying is definitely required, as much of the line could remain at-grade, without much additional grade separation than what already exists.—RDM Region 3 Meeting April 1 The NARP Region 3 Annual Meeting will take place on Saturday, April 1 in Bordentown, New Jersey. The place is the Farnsworth House Restaurant on 135 Farnsworth Avenue, a threeminute walk up the hill from the picturesque RiverLINE Station in Bordentown. George Chilson, President of NARP, will be the guest speaker. Registration is $25.00, including lunch. For more information call DVARP or e-mail Al Papp at alpappjr@earthlink.net The restaurant overlooks the former Camden and Amboy Railroad (it’s in a cut) and there is a plaque inset in a rock across from the restaurant placed there by the former Pennsylvania Railroad to honor this first railroad to operate in New Jersey. The first trial run was made with the locomotive “John Bull” on November 12, 1831. Bordentown was also called home for awhile by Thomas Paine. The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger DVARP Details Help Recruit New DVARP Members DVARP has a new membership brochure. We have updated the graphic and the text. The brochure is a tri-fold brochure printed on a quality buff paper. We are interested in getting the brochures into locations where there is a possibility of reaching individuals who might wish to join DVARP. If you have a library, community center, coffee shop or other place that you think would make a good display location for the brochures, please let us know. DVARP can send you some for stocking. Contact Patricia Nigro at 215-724-5929 or by e-mail at mail@dvarp.org. Mark Your Calendar Interested in the great railroad stations of America? Christopher Brown, author of “Standing Still: A Century of Urban Train Station Design” will give a talk and sign copies of his book Wednesday, February 1, 7:00 pm at Barnes and Noble, 1805 Walnut St., Philadelphia. Dates of Interest Meetings and other events are subject to cancellation or change. Call sponsors to confirm dates. SEPTA CAC Railroad Subcommittee: Tue., Feb. 7, 5:45 pm at 1234 Market St., Philadelphia. th DVRPC Regional Transportation Committee: Tue., Feb. 7, 10:00 am at 190 N. 6 Street, Philadelphia. DVRPC Regional Citizens Committee: Tues., Feb. 14, 11:00 am at 190 N 6th Street, Philadelphia. NJ Transit Board Meeting: Wed., Feb. 15, 9:00 am at One Penn Plaza, Newark. Note change in date. DRPA and PATCO Board meetings: Wed., Feb. 15, 10:00 am at One Port Center, Camden. SEPTA Board meeting: Thurs., Feb. 16, 3:00 pm at 1234 Market St., Philadelphia. DVARP general meeting: Sat., Feb. 18, 1:00 pm at 1601 Walnut St., Suite 1129, Philadelphia. University of Delaware public policy forum on intercity rail corridors: Tues., Feb. 21, in Newark, DE. See page 9 for information. SEPTA CAC Transit Subcommittee: Tues., Feb. 21, 5:45 pm at 1234 Market St., Philadelphia. Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission: Thurs., Feb. 23, 10:30 am at 190 N 6th Street, Phila. SEPTA Board meeting: Thurs., Feb. 23, 3:00 pm at 1234 Market St., Philadelphia. SEPTA Citizen Advisory Committee: Tues., Feb. 28, 5:45 pm at 1234 Market St., Philadelphia. APTA Legislative Conference : March 5-7 in Washington. Visit www.apta.com for more information SEPTA CAC Railroad Subcommittee: Tues., March 7, 5:45 pm at 1234 Market St., Philadelphia. DVRPC Regional Transportation Committee: Tues., March 7, 10:00 am at 190 N 6th Street, Philadelphia. NJ Transit Board Meeting: Wed., March 8, 9:00 am at One Penn Plaza, Newark. WILMAPCO Council meeting: Thurs., March 9, 6:30 pm at 850 Library Ave., Newark DE. DVRPC Regional Citizens Committee: Tues., March 14, 11:00 am at 190 N 6th Street, Philadelphia. DRPA and PATCO Board meetings: Wed., March 15, 10:00 am at One Port Center, Camden. SEPTA Board meeting: Thurs., March 16, 3:00 pm at 1234 Market St., Philadelphia. DVARP general meeting: Sat., March 18, 1:00 pm at 1601 Walnut St., Suite 1129, Philadelphia. APTA Fare Collection Conference: March 19-22 in Atlanta. Visit www.apta.com for more information SEPTA CAC Transit Subcommittee: Tues., March 21, 5:45 pm at 1234 Market St., Philadelphia. Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission: Thurs., March 23, 10:30 am at 190 N 6th Street, Phila. SEPTA Board meeting: Thurs., March 23, 3:00 pm at 1234 Market St., Philadelphia. Pennsylvania Transportation Funding and Reform Commission: Thurs., March 23, at Keystone Office Building, Harrisburg. See December DVRP for full schedule. SEPTA Citizen Advisory Committee: Tues., March 28, 5:45 pm at 1234 Market St., Philadelphia. NARP Region 3 meeting: Sat, April 1, 12:00 in Bordentown Registration and lunch $25.00. See page 14 for more information. To add your event to this calendar, phone DVARP at 215-RAILWAY or e-mail calendar@dvarp.org January-February 2006 page 15 DVARP Meeting Schedule • • • • Saturday, February 18, 2006 at DVARP offices, 1601 Walnut St., Suite 1129 (Medical Arts Building), Philadelphia. Building entrance on 16th St. If entrance is closed, use annunciator or phone 215-RAILWAY. Saturday, March 18, 1:00 to 4:00 at 1601 Walnut St. NARP Region 3 meeting: Saturday, April 1 in Bordentown, NJ Saturday, April 15, 1:00 to 4:00 at 1601 Walnut St. SEPTA On-Site SEPTA On-Site schedule unavailable at this time DVARP Directory Center City Office Telephone 1601 Walnut St., Suite 1129 Philadelphia, PA 19102 office hours by appointment Philadelphia office: 215-RAILWAY Fax: 215-564-9415 Electronic Mail President Vice-President Treasurer Recording Secretary Directors Delaware Coordinator Lehigh Valley Coordinator Legislative Affairs Coordinator Newsletter Editor Communications Director page 16 Tony DeSantis Donald Nigro Robert Montgomery Michael Greene Tony DeSantis Michael Greene Bob Machler Scott Maits Matthew Mitchell Robert Montgomery Donald Nigro Patricia Nigro Paul Murray Brad Pease vacant Matthew Mitchell Patricia Nigro desantis@dvarp.org nigro@dvarp.org montgomery@dvarp.org greene@dvarp.org desantis@dvarp.org greene@dvarp.org machler@dvarp.org maits@dvarp.org mitchell@dvarp.org montgomery@dvarp.org nigro@dvarp.org nigro@dvarp.org murray@dvarp.org pease@dvarp.org newsletter@dvarp.org nigro@dvarp.org The Delaware Valley Rail Passenger