- The Borneo Orangutan Survival Foundation
Transcription
- The Borneo Orangutan Survival Foundation
Progress Report Orangutan Post Release Monitoring in Kehje Sewen Forest, East Kalimantan by the BOS Foundation and Restorasi Habitat Orangutan Indonesia (RHOI) Report Authors: BOS Foundation and RHOI Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 1 2013 Content ExECUTIVe SUMMARY 7 Release GROUP I 10 Release GROUP II 13 Release GROUP III 15 Cross-Province Release 18 2 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 3 INDONESIAN ORANGUTAN HABITAT RESTORATION PROGRAM (RHOI) RHOI (Restorasi Habitat Orangutan Indonesia, which translates as Indonesian Orangutan Habitat Restoration) is an independent organization established by the Borneo Orangutan Survival (BOS) Foundation in 2009. The sole purpose of the organization is to provide a permanent safe, sufficient forest site for wild or semiwild, and rehabilitated Bornean orangutans where they can live in freedom, and establish a new, viable wild population to bolster conservation of this endangered species. BORNEO ORANGUTAN SURVIVAL FOUNDATION The Borneo Orangutan Survival Foundation (BOSF) is an Indonesian charity whose efforts focus on the conservation, rescue, rehabilitation and reintroduction of Bornean orangutans (Pongo pygmaeus). To achieve our goals, the Foundation is responsible for the ongoing management of two Orangutan Reintroduction Programs, one in East Kalimantan, Samboja Lestari and one in Central Kalimantan, Nyaru Menteng. As at the beginning of 2012, these programs cared for approximately 850 orangutans focusing on the welfare, rehabilitation and reintroduction of wildborn rehabilitated orangutans to secure natural forest. 4 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 5 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY I n 2013, the Borneo Orangutan Survival (BOS) Foundation team in Samboja Lestari and PT. Restorasi Habitat Orangutan Indonesia (Indonesian Orangutan Habitat Restoration – RHOI) reintroduced 15 orangutans into the Kehje Sewen Forest located in East Kalimantan. Release events took place in April, October and December (Tables 1 and 2) and bring the total number of rehabilitated and semi-wild orangutans reintroduced into Kehje Sewen since early 2012 to 21. Included in the 15 new orangutans reintroduced this year were three orangutans from our Rehabilitation Program in Nyaru Menteng, Central Kalimantan. Following DNA results these three female orangutans, including a dependent young, were revealed to belong to the subspecies Pongo pygmaeus morio which naturally inhabits the eastern part of Kalimantan. Subsequently those orangutans were transported from Central to East Kalimantan becoming our first crossprovince orangutan reintroduction event. During 2013, our field teams also continued to follow the progress of the orangutans we released in 2012 (Hamzah, Berlian, Lesan, Casey, Mail and Abbie) (Table 2 and Figures 1a, b, and c). These six orangutans were released in 2012, however Abbie was last seen across the Soh River in January 2013. 6 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 7 Table 2. Total observation days (hours) 2013 Table 1.Category of orangutans released in Kehje Sewen Forest 2012-2013 Release Group Release I April 2012 Release II April 2013 Release III October 2013 Name Category Sex Age Age at arrival* Origin Hamzah Semi wild M 10 4 Berlian Rehab F 11 Lesan Rehab F Casey Rehab Mail Release Group Name Age Days of follow (n-n) Total hours* Bontang Hamzah 10 16 (7) 138 hours 19 minutes 4 Samarinda Berlian 11 24 (8) 157 hours 38 minutes 10 3 Hutan Sungai Lesan, Berau Lesan 10 19 (11) 176 hours 7 minutes F 9 4 Tenggarong Casey 9 25 (12) 210 hours 36 minutes Rehab M 9 3 Petung Mail 9 13 (4) 87 hours 58 minutes Abbie Rehab F 13 7 Samarinda Abbie 13 0 0 Leo Rehab M 20 4-5 Sebulu Leo 20 21 (11) 165 hours 48 minutes Juminten Semi wild F 21 6-7 PT.SHJ, Sebulu Juminten 21 17 (6) 97 hours 58 minutes Titin Rehab F 23 4-5 Samarinda Titin 23 18 (13) 146 hours 52 minutes Emerson Semi wild M 26 15 Sangatta Emerson 26 8 (6) 68 hours 48 minutes Sarmi Semi wild F 19 4-5 PT.KPC, Sangatta Sarmi 19 8 (5) 72 hours 16 minutes Mona Semi wild F 20 4-5 Tenggarong Mona 20 8 (5) 63 hours 54 minutes Agus Rehab M 14 3-4 Tenggarong Agus 14 1 1 hour 0 minutes Mayang Rehab F 16 9-10 BKSDA KalSel Mayang 16 2 4 hours 46 minutes Acong Rehab F 15 8-9 month PT. KPC, Bengalon Acong 15 5 (2) 36 hours 42 minutes Noel Rehab M 13 1-2 Sangatta Noel 13 9 (1) 30 hours 29 minutes Inge Rehab F 15 3-4 Bontang Inge 15 4 16 hours 0 minutes Siwi Rehab F 13 6 Samarinda Siwi 13 0 0 BKSDA KalSel Yayang 15 2 (2) 19 hours 40 minutes Sayang 4 2 (2) 19 hours 40 minutes Diah 17 14 (12) 125 hours 43 minutes Release I April 2012 Release II April 2013 Release III October 2013 Cross Province Release (from Central to East Kalimantan) Release IV December 2013 Yayang Rehab F 15 Sayang Semi wild F 4 Diah Rehab F 17 *) Arrival in Samboja Lestari Rehabilitation Center 8 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 6-7 Kaja Island 4-5 Sebulu Release IV December 2013 *) In order to minimize the issue of bias, only observation data of a minimum 20 hours per month are analysed to check the adaptation pattern of released orangutans Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 9 2013 Activity Budgets of Orangutans Released in 2012 (Fig.1a) 2013 Activity Budgets of Orangutans Released in 2012 (Fig.1a) 120 100 80 Other Rest 60 Move 40 Release Group I Feed 20 Casey Lesan 0 Hamzah Mail Berlian Lesan Casey 2013 Diet composition of Orangutans Released in 2012 (Fig.1b) 2013 Diet composition of Orangutans Released in 2012 (Fig.1b) 100% 90% 80% U p until July 2013, all of the orangutans released in April 2012, were still followed nest-to-nest, with the exception of Abbie. Behavioral data were recorded and analysis during 2013 showed significant development (Figures 1a, b, c), particularly on the utilization of increased elevation (above ground activities) by Casey and Lesan. Hamzah Berlian 10 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 Others 60% Insect 50% Pith 40% Bark 30% Leaves Fruit 20% 10% 0% The three females, Berlian, Lesan, and Casey did not range as far as the older female Abbie or males Hamzah and Mail. Abbie appeared to remain across the Soh River. Male orangutan Mail followed her temporarily in January 2013, then continued to explore as far as Sepan and Atip Rivers. In May 2013, Mail returned to the forest surrounding the camp for a short period and continued to explore areas along the Soh River. He was last found in the north of Lembu River (Figure 2). Hamzah’s range was larger than those of the females; he ventured into the conservation forest (Hutan Lindung) which borders the Kewje Sewen Forest and along the Lembu River. Together with some of the females released in 2012 (Lesan, Casey, Berlian) and females from the newer group reintroduced in 2013 (Siwi and Inge), he was observed initiating contact and foraging for food including Macaranga sp., Lauraceae, Baccaurea tetrandra, Aglaia sp. During these contacts, Hamzah was also recorded attempting to copulate with several females and his efforts were finally successful after forced copulation with both Lesan and Casey. 70% Hamzah Berlian Casey 2013 UseMailof strata ofLesan Orangutans Released in 2012 (Fig.1c) 2013 Use of strata of Orangutans Released in 2012 (Fig.1c) 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% > 10 m 50% 5-10 m 40% <5m 30% 0 20% 10% Mail 0% Hamzah Mail Berlian Lesan Casey Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 11 Release Group II Figure 2.Orangutan Distribution Monitoring Map 2013 Unlike the orangutans within the first release group the second group of orangutans released, were all older individuals aged between 20-23 years. This second group was released in April 2013 in the northern area of Lembu River which is approximately 4 km from the first release point. Large cheek-padded male Leo and adult females Juminten and Titin had all undergone a very long rehabilitation process, including Forest School (Table 1) which spanned 15 years. This is clearly not an ideal situation nor the intention, however a direct result of the difficulties in finding a suitable, safe orangutan release area in this region of Kalimantan. Early observation results after release and during the two months thereafter showed behavioral improvements, especially in terms of the gradually increasing the period of time they spent feeding rather than resting (Fig. 3a). Improvements were also shown in food variety consumed, despite the tendency for some of the orangutans to eat a diet largely based on leaves or bark (Fig. 3b). In terms of arboreal behavior and above ground activities, the three orangutans showed positive developments by ceasing their ground activities (Fig. 3c). These early observation results are of significant importance considering there are still many more orangutan release candidates of an older aged and maturity waiting in Samboja Lestari for possible reintroduction. Left to right: Juminten, Leo,Titin 12 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 13 Activity Budgets for Release Group II: Apr-Jul 2013 (Fig.3a) Activity Budgets for Release Group II: Apr-Jul 2013 (Fig.3a) 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Release Group III Other Rest Travel Feed Diet composition of Release Group II: Diet composition of Release Apr-Jul 2013 (Fig.3b)Group II: 100% Apr-Jul 2013 Diet composition of Release Group II:(Fig.3b) Apr-Jul 2013 (Fig.3b) 90% 80% 100% 70% 90% 60% 80% 50% 70% 40% 60% 30% 50% 20% 40% 10% 30% 0% 20% 10% 0% Leo April Leo May-July Juminten April Juminten May-July Titin May-July Left to Right: Agus, Mona, Sarmi Other Leo April Leo May-July Juminten April Juminten May-July Titin May-July Insect Other Pith Insect Bark Pith Leaves Bark Flower Leaves Fruit Flower Fruit Use of strata of Release Group II: AprJul 2013 (Fig.3c) Use of strata of Release Group II: Apr-Jul 2013 (Fig.3c) 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 14 > 10 m 5-10 m <5m 0 Leo April Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 Leo May-July Juminten April Juminten May-July Titin May-July Our third orangutan release was conducted in October 2013 and divided into two stages and from two different release points. Orangutans within the first group were all semi-wild and comprised of cheekpadded male Emerson, accompanied by two adult females Sarmi and Mona who were released south of the Lembu River. The second group consisted of rehabilitant orangutans; juvenile male orangutans Agus and Noel accompanied by four females Mayang, Acong, Inge, and Siwi who were released in the Gunung Belah River area (Figure 4). We can only analyze data for five out of nine orangutans from post monitoring observational data for orangutans released in October due to inadequate observation periods. Difficulties in recording data was also exacerbated due to logistical issues given that release points are quite in a distance from the camp and unfavourable weather conditions by the end of the year which caused rivers to flood and hence become no longer crossable. Five individuals were observed in October 2013, Emerson, Noel, Sarmi, Acong and Mona (Fig. 5a, b, c). However, despite the inadequate observational period for analysis, the other individuals were well-observed during the first quarter of the year; Agus, Inge, Sarmi and Mona (Bani pers.comm). The immediate post-release observation results show clearly that in terms of activity budgets, all were dominated by resting. Acong, Noel and Mona travelled more than either Emerson or Sarmi, but feeding time was generally similar across the orangutans. Diet and food consumption were positive with fruit forming a large portion of the overall diet, with the exception of Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 15 Release point Activity Budgets for Release Group III: Octfor Release 2013Group (Fig.5a) Activity Budgets III: Oct 2013 (Fig.5a) 100% 90% 80% 70% female Acong who consumed only leaves. This might be related to access or competition at the release point where three other females were also released. Moreover, the previously released females Berlian, Lesan and Casey had also established their range here. The use of height in daily activities was positive for Emerson, Sarmi and Acong, but not for Noel and especially Mona. Both Noel and Mona still chose to spend a large portion of their time on the ground (Fig. 5a, b, c). The technicians are tasked with encouraging the orangutans to climb and focus their activities in the trees which can be challenging for orangutans who have spent significant periods away from Forest School. Top Left to Right: Emerson, Mayang, Siwi ; Bottom Left to Right: Noel, Inge, Acong 16 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 Based on the initial observation results from this release group, it is clear that when releasing rehabilitated orangutans in large numbers and at different release points requires large numbers of technicians required to ensure each orangutan can be closely monitored. The design and layout of the release points especially must ensure that competition amongst orangutans is completely avoided as this will significantly influence adaptation and reintroduction success. 60% Other 50% Rest 40% Travel 30% Feed 20% 10% Activity Budgets for 0% Diet composition of Release Group Group III: III: Emerson_Oct Sarmi_Oct Acong_Oct Noel_Oct Mona_Oct Oct2013 2013 (Fig.5a) Oct 5b) Group III: Diet composition of(Fig. Release 100% 100% Oct 2013 (Fig. 5b) 90% Diet composition of Release Group III: Oct 2013 (Fig. 5b) 90% 80% 80% 100% 70% 90% 70% 60% 80% 60% 50% 70% 40% 50% 60% 30% 40% 50% 20% 40% 30% 10% 30% 20% 0% 20% 10% 10% 0% 0% Other Insect Other Pith Other Rest Bark Insect Travel Leaves Pith Feed Flower Bark Fruit Leaves Flower Activity Budgets for Release Group III: Fruit Emerson_Oct Sarmi_Oct Acong_Oct Noel_Oct Mona_Oct Oct 2013 (Fig.5a)Group III: Use of strata of Release 100% Oct 2013 Use of strata of Release Group(Fig.5c) III: Oct 2013 (Fig.5c) 90% 100% 80% 90% 70% 80% 60% 70% 50% 60% 50% 40% 40% 30% 30% 20% 20% 10% 10% 0% 0% Other Rest Travel > 10 m Feed 5-10 m <5m 0 Emerson_Oct Sarmi_Oct Acong_Oct Noel_Oct Mona_Oct Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 17 Yayang and Sayang The natural behaviours displayed by these three orangutans are not altogether surprising given that all spent significant periods on natural pre-release islands. Diah adapted well on Palas Island and Yayang delivered her daughter on Kaja Island. Both Palas and Kaja Islands are two of the final pre-release islands we manage in Central Kalimantan and these serve as the final stage of learning for orangutans who have graduated from the Forest School. Diah Cross-Province RELEASE 18 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 December 2013 was another milestone for the BOS Foundation and PT. RHOI. DNA test results showed that several orangutans cared for within our Rehabilitation Center in Nyaru Menteng, Central Kalimantan were not of the subspecies Pongo pygmaeus wurmbii, but Pongo pygmaeus morio which naturally occurs in East Kalimantan. Their life histories also showed that they were not confiscated from Central Kalimantan (Table 1). We are committed to ensuring we follow national and international (IUCN) guidelines for orangutan reintroduction one of which is to ensure orangutans are reintroduced into their subspecies range. Clearly in cases like this, substantial costs are incurred to transport orangutans between provinces and sometimes even islands within Indonesia. Female Yayang and her daughter Sayang and companion female Diah were all released by the Lesik River, 1.5 km from Gunung Belah River. Observation results immediately post-release show that they adapted well in terms of balanced feeding, mobility and activity budgets. This was also reflected in their food choice where fruit formed the main bulk of their diet, but was supplemented with leaves, bark and flowers. The majority of activities were recorded above ground especially for Yayang and Sayang who preferred to stay in the trees. Diah spent more time on the ground especially when being observed (Fig 6a, b, c). Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 19 Activitiy Budgets of Cross-Province Release Group: Dec 2013 (Fig.6a) Activity Budgets of Diah vs Berlian (Fig.7a) Activitiy Budgets of Cross-Province Release Group: Dec 2013 (Fig.6a) Activity Budgets of Diah vs Berlian (Fig.7a) 100% 100% 90% 90% 80% 80% 70% 70% 60% Other 60% Other 50% Rest 50% Rest 40% Travel 40% Move 30% Feed 30% Feed 20% 20% 10% 10% DietYayang_Dec composition of Cross-Province Sayang_Dec Diah_Dec Release Group: Dec 2013 (Fig.6b) 0% Diet composition of Cross-Province Release Group: Dec 2013 (Fig.6b) 100% 0% Diah_rehab_Kaja Island (n=13) Berlian_rehab Samboja (n=14) Diet composition of Diah vs Berlian (Fig.7b) Diet composition of Diah vs Berlian (Fig.7b) 90% 100% 80% Other 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 90% Insect 80% Pith 70% Bark 60% Leaves 50% Flower 40% Fruit 10% Other Insect Pith Bark Leaves 30% Flower Use 0% of strata of Cross-Province Release Yayang Sayang Diah Group: Dec 2013 (Fig.6c) 20% 100% Use of strata of Diah vs Berlian (Fig.7c) 0% Diah_rehab_Kaja Island (n=12) Use of strata of Cross-Province Release Group: Dec 2013 (Fig.6c) 90% Fruit 10% 80% Berlian_rehab Samboja (n=14) Use of strata of Diah vs Berlian (Fig.7c) 70% 100% 60% > 10 m 50% 5-10 m 40% <5m 30% 0 20% 10% 0% Yayang_Dec Sayang_Dec Diah_Dec 90% 80% 70% 60% > 10 m 50% 5-10 m 40% <5m 30% 0m 20% 10% Data from our first cross-province orangutan release provides us with a comparison of our Rehabilitation Center facilities in Central Kalimantan and East Kalimantan. Natural pre-release islands have only so far been available to us in Central Kalimantan (Nyaru Menteng) whilst at Samboja Lestari the final process finishes in Forest School. Although a larger dataset is required we compared the post monitoring results from the first month after the release of female Diah (from Nyaru Menteng, Central Kalimantan) and female Berlian (from Samboja Lestari, East Kalimantan) (Fig. 7a, b, c). 20 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 0% Diah_rehab_Kaja Island (n=13) Berlian_rehab Samboja (n=14) Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 21 Less variation in Diah’s activities compared to those of Berlian’s, especially in feeding, were probably related to Diah’s adaptation period to the food variety in East Kalimantan. There were also other likely factors such as fatigue after travel, however based on the same comparison, Diah and Yayang (and Sayang) had the same patterns. In terms of food choice, Diah showed similar patterns to Berlian, even though Diah chose to eat more flowers and Berlian the other way around. For activities above ground, Berlian adapted faster and undertook more activities in the trees, while Diah spent more time on the ground especially during observations. The comparison results show that both have undergone adequate field education during the release preparation period, however we acknowledge that this is likely to be extremely variable within each of our orangutans depending on the final part of their rehabilitation phase. Top: Diah ; bottom: Diah’s nest Cross Province Transport for Further Rehabilitation During 2013, DNA results also confirmed that 5 of our orangutans cared for within Samboja Lestari were of the subspecies Pongo pygmaeus wurmbii which naturally occurs in Central Kalimantan. Hence in November 2013, we transported these individuals to our facility in Central Kalimantan (Nyaru Menteng) for further rehabilitation on our natural pre-release islands prior to their eventual release into the Bukit Batikap Conservation Forest. 22 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013 23 Borneo Orangutan Survival Foundation Jalan Papandayan No. 10, Bogor 16151, Indonesia P: +62 (0)251 831 4468 / 831 4469 F: +62 (0)251 832 3142 Email : yayasanbos@orangutan.or.id Website : www.orangutan.or.id Yayasan Penyelamatan Orangutan Borneo t @bornean_OU PT Restorasi Habitat Orangutan Indonesia Jalan Kumbang 31, Bogor, 16128 West Java, Indonesia P: +62 (0)251 832 5723 F: +62 (0)251 832 1847 Email : yayasanbos@orangutan.or.id Website : www.theforestforever.com Restorasi Habitat Orangutan Indonesia t @orangutanku 24 Kehje Sewen PRM Report 2013