Proper Planning and Execution of Surgical Excisions
Transcription
Proper Planning and Execution of Surgical Excisions
15 CHAPTER andExecution ProperPlanning Excisions of Surgical BARRYLESHIN he simple fusiform (elliptical) excisionis the cornerstoneof cutaneoussurgery.Properplanningof requiresknowledgeof superficialanatprocedure this ory, u*ur"ness oi many functional considerationsof the head and neck, and, in the treatmentof cutaneous of tumorbiology'Although understanding malignancies, the funda-mentalshave once complicated, seeniingly beenleiined, the fusiformexcisionis a relativelysimple procedure that can be performed expeditiouslywhile iimultaneoustyproviding an excellentcosmeticoutcome. Vital til any surgicalprocedureis adequatepreoperativeevaluation.r'zfnis evaluationmust include pitient assessment,considerationof risk factors for and patienteducation. Lomplications, B6fore excisionafsurgeryis performed' adequatlata tention to superficial'inaiomy is imperative'3' This as closure, of lines includesdeterminingthe favorable subunits' cosmetic affected the well as evaluating contractionof underlyingmuscles'Although numerous diagramsof theselines exist, there is considerableindividualvariation. There are a variety of ways of making an assessment of the underlying MSU-s around a particular lesion' The simplestippioach is to pinch the skin in all directionsto ileterminewherethe iension on the skin is least' Maximalwrinkling occurswith pinchingin the direction of the short axis of the plannedexcision' Alternatively, having the patient move the underlying musclesby grimaiing of smiling may also unmask.these lines. Fiially, it may be besi in somecasesto simply excisethe lesionas a-circlerather than as an ellipse,undermine the wound margins,and observethe direction in which the wound assumesan oval shape.The oval configuration can then be converted to a fusiform ellipse for woundclosure.s'13 COSMETICUNITS When performingexcisionson the face, it is critical that considerationbe given to cosmeticunits. Conceptually, the face can be subdividedinto multiple.topoFAVORABLELINESOF CLOSURE gtapiti" units. A scar confined to a single unit will' One of the most important initial stepsin planning ltti-at"ly be lessconspicuousthan one that crossesthe the ellipticalexcisionis determiningProPelorientation' boundarybetweentwb contiguousunits.6'1aIn many so ^that instanceithis principle takes priority over MSTLs or More specifically,the ellipseshouldbe d.esigned the scar is least noticeable and not likely to affect even the configurationof the lesion being removed.A function.s-7Orientationof an ellipsein the most favorlonser scar containedwithin a single cosmeticsubunit conspicuous less a only yields not of excision able lines -ui be less conspicuousthan a scar that crossesthe thin scar,but alsoone that healsfasterand has a higher boundarybetweentwo subunits. tensilestrength.This will result in an incisionline that runs paralleito imaginarylines kngwn-as maximalskin NATUREOF LESIONREMOVED tension lines (MSTLs).? Typically, but not always, If the lesionbeingremovedis benign, it is criticalthat consruent with' relaxed skin tension lines,E-l2MSTLs the ultimate scar be less conspicuousthan the lesion from to wrinkle lines and to folds resulting "onior* 171 Planningthe ElliPse 172 BASICSURGICALCONCEPTSAND PROCEDURES beins removed and that the amount of normal tissue be minimal. On the other hand, management sacri-ficed malignanciesaddsan additionalconsidercutaneous of ation to the proper planning of an ellipse.eFirst, it is imperative that an excision provide for the complete removal of the tumor. In addition, when excising a melanoma,attentionshouldalsobe paid to the direction of draining lymph nodes.This is particularlyimportant if a wider resectionor subsequentregional lymphadenectomy might becomenecessary.An improperly orientedinitial excisionmay ultimatelymeanthe difference between primary closure or a wound graft after the definitivesurgicalprocedure.15 The configurationof the lesionmay be the key determinant of orientation of the ellipse.If the lesionbeing excisedis oval in shape,then by placingthe long axis of the ellipseparallel to the long axisof the lesion,the overalllengthof the scarwill be shortened(Fig. 15-1). In some settings, this compromisesthe principle of keepingthe scar within a singlecosmeticunit, and the final analysismay dependon the orientationthat yields the least noticeablescar. FUNCTIONALCONSIDERATIONS When planning an excision,attentionshouldalso be 10'la Two given to important functionalconsiderations.6' examplesof this include the need to avoid lower eyelid malposition when excising a lesion in the periorbital area and undesirablelip retractionwith excisionsin the perioral region. In a similar fashion,a fusiformexcision that is placed in a skin creaseon the forehead may elevatethe brow. Also, properorientation inadvertently of a fusiform excisionon the extremitiesavoidscontracture of an underlyingjoint. DIMENSIONS As a generalrule, the length of a fusiform excision should be three times the width, but the ratio of length to width may vary from 3:L to 4:1. The lengthof the short axis of the ellipseis predeterminedby the sizeof the lesion being removed.For instance,a 4-mm malignant tumor to be excisedwith 3-mm marginswill leave a short axis of 10 mm, and the long axis will be approximately 30 mm in length. It is important to recognizethat even a proportionate and properly designedellipsemay producea closurewith smallstanding cones,or "dogears,"at eachpole that mustbe removed. It is also important to recognize that the inherent elasticity of the skin and the geometry of an ellipse make a 30-degreeangle optimal for the tips of the ellipse. MARGINS No fail-safeguidelinesexist for determiningadequate margins.Obviously,the amount of normal tissueincluded in the excision of a benign lesion should be minimized. When excisinga nonmelanomamalignant skin tumor, a very rough guideline of 3 to 4 mm of skin is typically recommended.The normal-appearing margins of resection for melanomas require special 1s'16 consideration.e' FUSIFORMEXCISIONVARIATIONS There are two very useful variations on the classic fusiform excision,the S-plastyand the crescenticexcision. The S-plastyis a fusiform excisionin which the two sides of the ellipse are "lazy Ss." The ultimate effectof an S-plastyis to increasethe length of the scar between the two end points of the wound. This is particularly useful over convex surfacessuch as the cheek or extremity in which horizontal contractionon scar.By lengthening the scarmay resultin a depressed the scar, the horizontal forces of contractionwill pull and straightenthe "S," rather than depressthe scar (Fig. 15-2).1? The crescenticexcisioncan be accomplishedin two different ways. The simplesttechniqueis to designthe ellipseso that one side is substantiallylonger than the other. By then closing the defect using the "rule of halves,"a slightlycurvedscar is produced.lsAnother meansto achievea gently curved scar that matchesa curvedline of facial expressionis to createa "belly" in the midportion of the ellipse.This resultsin the wound havingsidesof equal length but in a configurationthat yieldsa gentlecurveto the ellipse.le'20 AND MARKINGTHE SKIN PREPARATION ELLIPSE Y L -zt Figure 15-1. By orientingthe ellipseso that the longaxisof the the longaxisof the ellipse,the lengthof the scaris lesionparallels shorter(Y is muchshorterthanX). significantly Before designingand marking the proposedskin incision lines, it is desirableto clean the operative site with a detergentantisepticsurgicalscrub. The incision lines may then be drawn using any of a variety of skin markerssuch as gentianviolet, brilliant green, Bonney blue or Berwick's solution.These may be applied with a toothpick or a broken wooden applicatorstick. Some surgeonsfavor a sterile surgical marking pen or a Sharpiepermanentmarker.21It is critical that the incision lines be drawn before injection of anesthetic,because vasoconstrictionmay substantiallyobscure the clinical clues that guide margin assessmentand the anestheticwill distort the tissue. OF SURGICALEXCISIONS PROPERPLANNINGAND EXECUTION ^ 173 B Figure1ts2.A, Whena lesionis scar excisedon a convexsurface, contractionwill result in a deoressedscar.B, Scarcontraction afterS-plastyresultsin straightening of the S. (Modifiedfrom ZitelliJA:TIPSfora betterellipse. 22:101-1Q3' J AmAcadDermatol 1990.) After marking the skin and infiltrating local anesthetic,the skiniJ then ideallyrepaintedwith an aqueous any uniis"pti" surgicalprep solution' Beforeincision' gauze a with removed be should wetnesi residualsurfade sponge. Removingthe SPecimen Although seeminglysimple, severalaspectsof specirequiri tlose attentionto providethe best rn"n r"-&l outcome. cosmetic AVOIDINGCROSS.HATCHING To avoid unnecessaryinjury' it is desirablethat the tios of the ellipsemeet at a fine point, without unnecof the incisionbevond that point (Fig' ;il; it t' ";;;.id; isjj^i when usins the standardNo' 15 blade, the is in.iiion initiated wiih the scalpelhandleheld perpe.nto the skin' After the incision is made' the ei;il; ;;;l;;i handleis then gentlv tilted to a 45-degreeangle i"i itt.iti"g the remainier of the margin until the other iio i. r"u.[.d. At that point the blade is then returned very to the perpendicularposition' When pertormtng Cross-hatching to usea smaller smallexcisions,it is often advantageous a No' 11 alt-ernatively, or, 15c No' LfuO" tu.tt as a blade. AVOIDINGBEVELEDEDGES When incisingthe skin, it is preferable to make an ln"ision perpeniicularly thro-ugh.the dermis into the By so unAertyirigiubcutaneousfatT " (Fig' I?iel' evert to likely doing ihe"wound marginswill-be more If closure' acceptable for a co"smetically aoor"opriately specimen the of base the inward, beveled are if,J "og"t UJ .o.promised, bringing the -resectionmargins "un close to the lages of the lesion being .rnnecessarlty .*.it"A. In hair-bearingregions'it is preferableto angle the incision lines so itrat ttrey are parallel to follicles (ng. $+ils' 7'18to avoid foilicle transectionand permanenthair lossaround the scar. PASSESTHROUGHTHE DERMIS MINIMIZING The amount of pressureor force used when incising the skin is learned'only by experience'The force nec.rtuiy io l""ise throug"hthe db.rmisobviously a."q"{: on the thicknessof dermis' It is desirableto mlnlmlze the scalpel makes through.lhe G number of passes ^"staircasing" t6e wound margins(Fig' dermisto avoid 1j-j1 anOcompromisingthJapproximationof the edges' / Nicked edges the Figure 15-3. Careful incisiontechnique avoids cross-hatching tipi and nickingthe wound edges. to the skin ';, A, An incisionis caniedout perpendicular Fioure1S4. parallel is angled the'incision skin, n"it:bearing i.lrin"i r" ;?; NA: trom Swanson (Modified transeltion. iJin" n"-i,torli.lesto avoid Surgery.Little,Brown,Boston'1987'p 19') ntas ot-dutaneous 174 BASICSURGICALCONCEPTSAND PROCEDURES A 4.sa4t_-: passes through thedermis during incision Figure1tsS.Minimizing (right). woundmargin avoidsa staircased UNIFORMTHICKNESS There is a common tendencywhen removing an excisionalspecimento reduce the amount of tissue removedat the two ends.This resultsin a boat-shaped specimen(Fig. 15-6). More importantly,the residual tissueleft in the defectmay causeprotrusionsat the two The assistant can put tips, creating"pseudo-dogears."17 traction on the skin perpendicularto the direction of the incisionto help provide a smoothcontour to the incision,therebydecreasingthe effort requiredto make the incisionto the desiredlevel. After careful incision, the base of the tissuecan be transectedat the desired depth with either a scalpelor scissors. the Defect Undermining BREADTHOF UNDERMINING Underminingthe defectafter removalof the specimen minimizes teniion on the wound margins, facilitates vascularcompromise, everts closure,avoidsunnecessary the wound margins, enhancesthe cosmeticoutcome after scar contraction, and provides a horizontal scar plate to help minimize the spreadof scarsat sites of high wound tension.TDead spacecan result from underminingthat producesa seromaor hematoma.Some although surgeonsfavor obliterationof this deadspace,22 this is not imperative.' The amount of tissuethat needsto be underminedis that which is sufficientto allow minimal tensionon the wound marginsso they may be evertedwithout compromising vascularity.It is important to underminecompletely around the defect, including the two ends. By missingthe two ends,theseareasbecomeunnecessarily tetheredand may ultimatelyprotrude upwardwith scar contraction(Fig. 15-7).1? DEPTHOF UNDERMINING The recommendeddepth of underminingvarieswith the anatomic site. In general, underminingshould be Figure 1$-6. A, A boat-shapedspecimenthat leavesadditionaltissue at the wound tips may result in pseudo-dogears.8, A specimenof uniformthicknessavoidsthis Droblem.(Modifiedfrom ZitelliJA: TIPS for a betterellipse.J Am Acad Dermatol22:101-103,1990.) as carriedout usingblunt-tippedscissors as superficially possibleto avoid unnecessary damageto blood vessels and nerves.Underminingon the scalp is best carried out belowthe galeato avoidtransectionof hair follicles. The looseareolartissuebeneaththe galeais an easily identified,bloodlessplane, and the galeaaponeurotica easilysupportsthe suturetensionrequiredfor closure of scalpwounds.The foreheadis best underminedin the deepsubcutaneous tissue,sincedeeperundermining threatenssensoryinnervationto the scalp. To avoid injury to the superficialmotor nerves,underminingon the temple,cheeks,and chin should be carriedout in the superficialsubcutaneous tissue.On the trunk and extremities, underminingcan be carriedout at any level above the musclefascia, the middle to deep subcutaneousadiposelayersusuallybeing optimal. At sitesof minimalsubcutaneous tissue.suchasthe handsandfeet. A <z_k_jj+-t_* , 1 't_L>) Figure15-7.A, Failureto undermine the woundtips may resultin tissueprotrusion afterclosure.B, Undermining the tips avoidsthis problem.(Modified from ZitelliJA: TIPS for a betterellipse.J Am 1990.) AcadDermatol 22:101-103. OF SURGICALEXCISIONS PROPERPLANNINGAND EXECUTION 175 underminingshould be carried out just below the dermis.7 ^--Ouring undermining, it is also-,importantthat the crushing *ounO niutginsbe hanlled gently' Unnecessary formultitoothed or sErrated ;i;h; *ouia edges.with outcome' cosmetic ultimate the ceDSmav compromlse ifi. *obtt"nc^e of handling the wound margins-gently ;iih };;"pt or a skin hoolicannot be overstated'23 woundin a youngerindividual might bestb-eclosedwith a 6-0 polypropylenesubcuticularsuture' Whateverthe puii" nl t"t'tin g,' tft" closure technique-includin g wo-und mater-ials,suture techniques,and timing of su"loru." ture removal-should be modified to achieve a wellaooroximated, everted wound with minimal suture tr'*ting. A varietyof suturetechniques(Fig' 15-8)may be usefll in cutaneoussurgery' with each having clear 2L2e and disadvantages.18' advantages HEMOSTASIS Care Postoperative During incising and underminingof.the skin, blood vesselsa"reineviiably transectedor nicked' To preve-nt hematomaformation, hemostasisshouldbe achievedby .furnpingand ligatinglargevesselsor by pinpointeleciro"dug,itutiono*releitrodesiccation'It is alsoimportant to uufiO excesselectrosurgery,which results in the of nonvital, charr6d tissue that may impede "i"ution *ounO healingor serveas a nidus for wound infection' Mil;; uteediilg from transecteddermal capillariesis ette.tiuetystop-pedby suturesusedfor wound closure' Closure SUTURETECHNIQUES Closuretechniquevariessubstantiallyfrom site to site in and from patientto patient.For example,a wound face person's h;;"iiy ;*;-damaged^skin on an elderly outcomewith a runningcontin.igtti Vi"fOan exc"ellent uoit S-O monofilament suture' However, the same Figure 15-8. A to C, A buried sutureproduces verticalmattress eversionol the wound prolonged harqin-.(ModifiedbY Permission of tFe oublisherfrom ZitelliJA' Mov RL: Buriedverticalmattress suture.J DermatolSurg Oncol 1989 1989.CoPYright 15:17-19, by ElsevierSciencePublishing Co.,Inc.) WOUND DRESSING"THE After cleansingthe skin surfaceimmediatelypostoperativelyto removeany dried bloo1loJ residualantiseptic, the wounddressingisapplied.Typically,this consists of four layers: an occlusiveantibacterialointment, a nonadherehtgauze material, an absorbentcushionto wick blood awayfrom the wound, and tape' Patientsshouid be instructedto remove the postoperative pressuredressingafter 24 to 48.hours, cleanse the wound surfacewith fiydrogenperoxide,and reapply the occlusiveointment' this wbund careis repeatedtwo io ttrree times daily until the suturesare removed' A iigttt guut. dressingis optional dependingon the site of the wound and need for a protectlvedresslng' SUTUREREMOVAL The timing of epicutaneoussuture removal is of bbviously, suturesshouldbe left in criticalimpor"tance. : I 176 BASICSURGICALCONCEPTSAND PROCEDURES long enoughfor epithelializationacrossthe wound margins to be complete.However, they shouldbe removed suturetracking.Typearly enoughto avoid unnecessary ically, sutures are removed from the face at 7 days, althoughsomesurgeonsfavor earlier removalat 5 days. Suture removal on the trunk and extremitiesis usually performedat L0 to 14 days.Certainlythere is significant individual variability in wound healing. For example, young, healthy, nonsmoking patients can have their suturesremovedearlier than older, lesshealthy,sm.oking patientsbecauseof problemswith delayedhealing. To bolster the wound marginsafter suture removal, it is advisableto use wound closuretapesfor 5 to 7 days. Complications Although complicationsare relatively infrequent in It is imperativethat cutaneoussurgery,they do occur.30 patients be informed of the potential complications before surgeryand educatedas to how such complications might be manifestedimmediately after surgery. the surgeonmust be When problemsare encountered, able to recognizeand managethem adeptly. NECROSIS Wound necrosisafter fusiform excisionalbiopsy is rare. It most typicallyoccurswhen a wound is closed under significanttension, which compromisesthe vascularity of the wound margins. In this setting, it is important to remove suture material, debride the necrotic tissue,and allow the wound to heal by second intention. SUMMARY The proper planning and execution of a surgical excisionare of fundamentalimportanceto the cutaneous surgeryinsurgeon.Essentialingredientsof successful cludea masteryof a wide array of principlesthat involve anatomy,anesthesia,tumor biology, wound healing, and surgicaltechnique.With attentionto thesedetails, this procedurecan provide an exceptionallygood cosmetic and functional result both safely and efficiently and can also yield an appropriatespecimenfor subsequent histologicanalysis. REFERENCES HEMATOMA Hematomastypically occur during the first 48 to 72 hours after surgery and are manifestedas swelling, at the woundsite.Hematomas ervthema.and tenderness shbuld be evacuatedearly by partially or completely opening the wound, controlling any active bleeding, and, if treatedwithin 48 to 72 hoursof surgery,resuturing the wound. Alternatively, after evacuationof the hematoma, the open wound may be left to heal by secondintention with scarrevisionperformedat a later date, if necessary.In someinstances,small hematomas may be managedconservativelywith warm compresses until resolutionoccurs. INFECTION Infection is a rare event in cutaneoussurgery,having a rate of occurrenceof less than lVo.31When a wound is frankly infected, it is imperative that all sutures, including buried sutures,be removed and the patient begunon antibiotics.Considerationshould be given to culturing an infectedwound before initiating antibiotic therapy. DEHISCENCE Dehiscenceis the easiest of the complicationsto recognize,since the wound pulls apart. If there is no underlying infection, the dehiscentwound can simply be resuturedif dehiscencehas occurredwithin 48 to 72 hours after surgery. Dehiscenceis more typically a complicationof an underlyingwound infectionor hematoma, and theseunderlyingproblemsmust obviously be managedfirst. A dehiscentwound can be allowedto heal by second intention with delayed scar revision performedlater, if necessary. 1. LeshinB, McCalmontTH: Preoperativeevaluationof the surgical patient.Dermatol Clin 8:787-794, 1990. 2, Leshin B, Whitaker DC, SwansonNA: An approachto patient and preparationin cutaneousoncology.J Am Acad assessment Dermatol19:1081-1088, 1988. 3. Bernstein G: Surface landmarks for the identificationof key anatomicstructuresof the face and neck. J Dermatol SurgOncol L2:722-726 , 1986. 4. Salasche SJ, BernsteinG, SenkarikM: SurgicalAnatomy of the Skin. Appleton & Lange, East Norwalk, CT, 1988. 5. SpicerTE: Techniquesof facial lesion excisionand closure.J DermatolSurgOncol8:551-556,1982. 6. WebsterRC, Smith RC: Cosmeticprinciplesin surgeryon the face.J DermatolSurg Oncol 4:397-402,1978. 7. Bennett RG: Fundamentalsof CutaneousSurgery.CV Mosby, St. Louis, 1988,pp 353-444. 8. BorgesAF, AlexanderJE: Relaxedskin tensionlines. Z-plasties on scars,and fusiformexcisionof lesions.Br J PlastSurgL5:242254,1,962. 9. Bart RS, Kopf AW: Techniquesof biopsyof cutaneousneoplasms. J DermatolSurgOncol 6:979-987,7979. 10. BernsteinL: Incisionsand excisionsin elective facial surgery. 3. Arch Otolaryngol 97:238-243,1,97 11. Courtiss EH: The placementof elective skin incisions.Plast ReconstrSurg31:31-44,1963. 12. KneisselCJ: The selectionof appropriatelinesfor electivesurgical incisions.PlastReconstrSurg8:1-28, 1951. 13. DavisTS, GrahamWP III, Miller SH: The circularexcision.Ann PlastSurg4:21-24,1980. 14. StegmanSJ: Planningclosureof a surgicalwound. J Dermatol SurgOncol 4:390-393,1978. 15. Balch CM, Milton GW, Shaw HM, Seng-JawS: Cutaneous Melanoma.JB Lippincott, Philadelphia,1985,pp 71-90. 16. VeronesiU, CascinelliN, Adamus J, et al: Thin stageI primary cutaneousmalignant melanoma: comparisonof excision with 1988. marginsof 1or 3 cm. N Engl J Med 318:1159-1162, 17. Zitelli JA: TIPS for a betterellipse.J Am Acad Dermatol22:101' 103,1990. 18. SwansonNA: Atlas of CutaneousSurgery.Little, Brown, Boston, 1987. 19. Lapins NA: The crescenticellipse revisited. J Dermatol Surg 1988. Oncol14:935-936, 20. MansteinCH, MansteinME, MansteinG: Creatinga curvilinear scar.PlastReconstrSurs 83:914-915.1989. PROPERPLANNINGAND EXECUTIONOF SURGICALEXCISIONS 21. SebbenJE: Steriletechniqueand the preventionof woundinfection in office surgery-Pait II. J Dermatol SurgOncol 15:38-48' 1989. 22. OcampoJ, Camps A: The application of the tie-down suture to the excisionof cuianeoustumois' J DermatolSurgOncol14:13571360,1988. 23. Popkin GL, Gibb RC: Another look at the skin hook' J Dermatol SurgOncol 4:366-367,1978. Z+. Stefrnan SJ: Suturing techniques-for dermatologicsurgery' J Deimatol Surg Oncol 4:63-68' 1978. 25. ieny AW, M"cShaneRH: Fine tuning of the skin edgesin the closureof surgicalwounds:controllinginversionand eversionwith the path of ihe needle-the right stitch at the right time' J' Dermatol Surg Oncol 7:471-476'1981 i 177 26. Robinson JK: Even coaptation of wound edges of unequal thicknessesor unequal heights. J Dermatol Surg Oncol 5:844, 1979. 27. Coldiron BM: Closureof wounds under tension:the horizontal 1989' mattresssuture.Arch Dermatol 125:1189-1190' 28. Zitelli JA, Moy RL: Buried vertical mattresssuture' J Dermatol SurgOncol15:17-19,1989. 29. BerinettRG: Selectionof wound closurematerials'J Am Acad Dermatol 18:619-637,1988. SJ: Acute surgicalcomplications:cause,prevention,and 30. Salasche 1986' treatment.J Am Acad Dermatol 15:1163-1185' 31. Whitaker DC, Grande DJ, JohnsonSS: Wound infectionrate in dermatologicsurgery. J Dermatol Surg Oncol 14:525-528' 1988.