TAB 15 - Town of Jupiter
Transcription
TAB 15 - Town of Jupiter
TOWN OF JUPITER DATE: October 12, 2015 TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of Town Council THRU: Andrew D. Lukasik, Town Manager FROM: John Sickler, Director of Planning and Zoning SUBJECT: MALTZ JUPITER THEATRE – Special Exception and Site Plan applications for an expansion to the existing theater, on a 4.8± acre property, located at 1001 E. Indiantown Road. (PZ# 15-169) HEARING DATES: PZ 09/08/15 TC 10/20/15 (quasi-judicial) PZ #15-169 - Res #63-15 GW EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Consideration of a special exception and site plan amendment for an expansion of the existing theater. The Maltz Theatre is proposing to add a 31,524 square foot expansion, increasing the number of seats from 617 to 640. The expansion will house additional classrooms for students, office space, studio and rehearsal spaces, and a smaller flexible theater space with a seating capacity of 199 people, which is restricted from being operated concurrently with the main theater (see Attachment A). The conditions of approval regarding the underground utilities have been modified from the typical language based on Town Council’s previous commitment to pay for half of the cost of undergrounding the utilities. Based on an FPL estimate, the total cost of undergrounding the utilities would range from $50,000 to $75,000. In addition, the Town Council previously committed to pay for installing the decorative street lights along Indiantown Road. Based on the recent cost of the decorative street lights, staff estimates that the cost of installing the lights along the Maltz property would be approximately $65,000. Lastly, staff has recommended that the applicant pay for half of the costs associated with installing the fiber optic conduit. The total cost for installing the fiber optic conduit ranges from $8 per foot to dig a trench and install conduit to $20 per foot for an underground directional bore. The final contribution amount will be based on an engineer’s estimate of the undergrounding cost which is required to be submitted prior to building permits. Staff is recommending that the undergrounding work, street light installation, and fiber optic conduit installation be completed after the redesign of the section of Indiantown Road between US Highway 1 and A1A. Issues The applicant has no issues. PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION: At their September 8, 2015 meeting, the Planning and Zoning Commission voted unanimously (7 to 0 vote) to approve the above referenced project with no modifications. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of Resolution No. 63-15. Strategic Priority: Unique, Small Town Feel Attachments: Staff report and attachments Resolution No. 63-15 TOWN OF JUPITER TOWN MANAGER’S OFFICE DATE: October 12, 2015 TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of Town Council THRU: Andrew D. Lukasik, Town Manager FROM: John Sickler, Director of Planning and Zoning SUBJECT: MALTZ JUPITER THEATRE – Special Exception and Site Plan applications for an expansion to the existing theater, on a 4.8± acre property, located at 1001 E. Indiantown Road. (PZ# 15-169) Resolution # 63-15 PZ 15-169 GW Project name: Owner/Applicant: Agent: Location: Acreage: Square footage: Existing Use: Proposed Use: (breakdown by use): Present land use designation: Present zoning: Request: Meeting dates: PZ TC Maltz Jupiter Theater Maltz Jupiter Theatre, Inc. (Andrew Kato) Cotleur & Hearing, Inc. 1001 E. Indiantown Road 4.8 +/- acres 32,036 SF of theater with 617 seats 63,560 SF of theater with 640 seats Main Theater (+1,144 square feet, 4%) Flex Theater (+3,249 square feet, 10%) Classrooms (+4,610 square feet, 15%) Office Space (+2,923 square feet, 9%) Back of House (+19,598 square feet, 62%) Commercial IOZ, Parkway district with underlying C-2, Commercial General To add a 31,524 square foot expansion to the existing theater, increasing the number of seats from 617 to 640, to redesign the parking lot to add parking spaces, add new landscaping throughout the parking area and along the building, construct a new building facade. (see Attachment A) Applicant Issues. The applicant has no issues. 09/08/15 10/20/15 (quasi-judicial) Maltz Jupiter Theater - Staff Report Page 2 Staff Update. Staff received an inquiry from a nearby homeowner regarding the condition of the lake on the corner of Indiantown Road and A1A. The homeowner requests that the Maltz Theatre turn on the aerator fountain. In addition, she requested that the lighting along Indiantown Road and A1A be enhanced for safety (see Attachment E). The aeration fountain was not a required element and there is no associated condition of approval for the fountain to be operated. Additionally, staff has not included conditions for the lighting based on the recommendation that the Town be responsible to installing the new lighting along Indiantown Road when the roadway section is redesigned. Planning and Zoning Commission. At their September 8, 2015 meeting, the Planning and Zoning Commission voted unanimously (7 to 0 vote) to approve the above mentioned project with no modifications. Staff Recommendation. The Department of Planning and Zoning has reviewed the above referenced application and recommends approval, based on the conditions of approval outlined in Exhibit 1. Project data. Please find listed below pertinent site plan data and information in reference to the application. The information is as follows: Direction Existing Land Uses North Multi-Family Residential (Ocean Parks Condos) South Commercial (Office and Vacant land) East West Future Land Use/Zoning Districts High Density Residential / Residential, Limited Multi-Family (R3) Commercial / Indiantown Road Overlay Zoning (IOZ) Parkways district with underlying C-3 (Commercial, Office) Zoning Multi-Family Residential High Density Residential / Residential, Limited Multi-Family (Jupiter Dunes Condos) (R3) Commercial (Reynolds Plaza) Commercial / IOZ Parkways district with underlying C-2 (Commercial, General) Zoning Site plan information. Square footage of structure Minimum lot area Minimum lot width Minimum lot depth Maximum building height Maximum lot coverage Minimum green space (IOZ) Parkway with underlying C-2 zoning district requirements n/a 15,000 square feet 75.0 feet 150.0 feet 40.0 feet 35.0 percent 30.0 percent Applicant’s proposal 63,560 square feet 209,651 square feet 469.0 feet 437.0 feet 40 feet* 16.3 percent 32.6 percent Maltz Jupiter Theater - Staff Report Page 3 *With stage tower extending up to 64 feet, as allowed per Section 27-1117 Setbacks (IOZ) Parkway with underlying C-2 zoning district requirements Front 35.0 feet Rear 30.0 feet Side 10.0 feet Side corner 35.0 feet Applicant’s proposal 139.7 feet (South) 30.0 feet (North) 47.6 feet (West) 139.7 feet (East) Parking space requirements Minimum requirements Applicant’s proposal Theater seats (640 seats @ 1/3 seats) 213 242 Handicap parking spaces 7 7 Landscaping Number of perimeter trees Percentage of native plant material Foundation planting Minimum requirements 75 50% 2,689 square feet Applicant’s proposal 75 50% 4,676 square feet Signage. Signage allowed per IOZ Parkways District 1 Applicant’s proposal 136.8 square feet Not to exceed 48 inches 1 154 square feet** 132 inches (11 feet)** 1 69.75 square feet Not to exceed 48 inches 2 177 square feet*** 93 inches*** 2 (1 on Indiantown Road and 1 on A1A) 77 square feet 14.7 square feet 10 feet with a decorative feature at 12 feet**** Primary Façade sign (received variance) Sign copy square footage Sign height Secondary Façade sign (75% of allowable size per code) Sign copy square footage Sign height Monument Signs (conditioned in Resolution #65-03) Sign copy square footage Changeable copy square footage Sign height 1 140 square feet 25 square feet 15 feet **Received a Variance on April 13, 2004 for the larger sign than code allows. ***Condition of approval is included requiring the square footage and height of the sign to be reduced. ****Resolution #65-03 restricted signage to 8’ tall with a decorative feature extending to 10.5’ tall. Traffic. (See Attachment B) Satisfies PBC/Town of Jupiter TPS Average daily trips Stormwater management. Satisfies Town of Jupiter requirements Yes 39 ADT net increase from 1,055 to 1,094 trips (0 AM peak hour increase & 2 PM peak hour increase). Yes Pedestrian amenities for new buildings Benches Pedestrian amenity requirements 5 Applicant’s proposal 5 Maltz Jupiter Theater - Staff Report Page 4 Trash receptacles Bicycle racks provided 3 5 3 5 Background/history. The Maltz Theatre is proposing to add a 31,524 square foot expansion, increasing the number of seats from 617 to 640. The expansion will house additional classrooms for students, office space, studio and rehearsal spaces, and a smaller flexible theater space with a seating capacity of 199 people (see Attachment A). The smaller flexible theater space is proposed to be used for different types of programs which are not appropriate or conducive in the main theater. In addition, it will be used at different times than the main theater, ensuring that parking is available for guests. The following chart outlines the approvals and history of the theatre. Date 1979 1982 August 3, 1999 January 7, 2003 April 13, 2004 May 20, 2003 April 24, 2013 Approval information Building permits were issued to construct the Burt Reynolds Dinner Theater, consisting of a combination restaurant, theater, and lounge with seating for 380 people. Approval was granted to expand the number of seats to 450, consisting of a mixture of "dinner and a show" seating and conventional theater seating. The Town Council approved a conversion of the theater into a religious institution to be known as Christ’s Church of the Palm Beaches. The approved site plan consisted of expanding the existing structure to 37,202 square feet. The church was never constructed on the site and the site plan and special exception expired on August 3, 2001. The Town Council approved renovations to the existing theater to include the addition of a new porte-cochere, main entrance, backstage entrance, and an addition on the first level in the northwest corner of the building to be used as a founders lounge. The total addition included 7,036 additional square feet and increased the seating capacity to 598 seats. Resolution #138-02. The Zoning Board of Adjustments approved a variance for the façade sign on the south elevation. The variance allowed the sign to be 154 square feet and 11 feet tall. The Town Council approved an amendment to the previously approved expansion to allow the project to be constructed in two phases. Phase one of construction was completed, including the installation of conduit along Indiantown Road, but Phase two was never constructed. Resolution #65-03. Staff approved a small expansion to the existing theater, increasing to 617 seats. The expansion increased the theater by 3,108 square feet. The affected area was limited to the existing building on the north-east corner of the subject site. Staff is proposing to replace and amend the conditions of approval in Resolution #65-03 related to undergrounding utilities, cross access, and signage restrictions. The conditions within Exhibit Maltz Jupiter Theater - Staff Report Page 5 1/Resolution #63-15 include the previous conditions with modifications and will replace the two previous resolutions. Analysis. This section analyzes the land development regulations and notes the application’s inability or ability to satisfy all applicable development provisions of the Town Code and Comprehensive Land Use Plan (CLUP). The analysis is as follows: Comprehensive Plan consistency. The proposed development is in conformance with the Future Land Use Element of the Comprehensive plan. Theatre Expansion. The existing theater is considered a special exception within the Parkways district of the Indiantown Road Overlay Zoning District (IOZ) with underlying C-2, General Commercial zoning. Pursuant to Section 24-197, projects that propose to expand by more than 20 percent are not eligible for reduced development standards and are required to meet the code and eliminate non-conformities. The proposed expansion is for an additional 31,524 square feet (totaling 63,560 square feet or a 97 percent expansion), which requires the project to meet the code and eliminate non-conformities. Landscaping. The proposed development is in conformance with the Town Code, Chapter 23, entitled, “Landscaping”. Landscape median contributions – Pursuant to Section 23-67, properties with frontage on Indiantown Road are required to provide monies to help maintain landscape medians. During the theater expansion in 2003, staff recommended landscape median contributions, which totaled $17,915.10 at the time; however, the Town Council voted to remove the condition because there was no median in front of the property (see Attachment C). Staff has not included a condition for landscape median contributions, based upon the Town Council’s previous decision. Underground Utilities. The proposed development will be in conformance with Section 27868(6), entitled “Underground Utilities” with the proposed conditions of approval. The previous approval included conditions to underground the utilities. To date, the utility lines have not been placed underground. Below is a chart which outlines Town Council’s prior commitments, and recommended conditions within Exhibit 1. Item (status) Underground utility lines (conduit installed, lines not placed underground) Town Council’s previous commitments Decorative Street Lights (not installed) Fiber optic conduit Proposed conditions in Exhibit 1 Agreed to pay 100% of conduit installation cost (paid full amount in 2004) Agreed to pay 50% of undergrounding cost Agreed to pay 100% of installation after lines placed underground Did not exist at the time Applicant pay for 50% of the cost of undergrounding the utility lines in the existing conduit Town will pay for 50% of costs Town will pay for all costs of installing decorative street lights along Indiantown Road (no condition) Applicant pay for 50% of the cost of undergrounding the fiber Maltz Jupiter Theater - Staff Report Page 6 optic conduit Town will pay for 50% of costs The subject property is unique in that it is located on a section of Indiantown Road which may be redesigned in the near future. A workshop and conceptual plans are planned to be prepared soon for the redesign of Indiantown Road between US Highway One and State Road A1A. The final design of the roadway is to be determined in the future; however, the changes could potentially affect the location of underground utilities, street lights, and even fiber optic conduit. Because the final street design is unknown, staff suggests allowing the applicant to pay for half of the estimated costs of installing the utilities and fiber optic conduit underground. When Indiantown Road is ultimately redesigned, the Town can use the money to complete the undergrounding work, install the fiber optic conduit, and install the decorative street lights. Additional details regarding each staff recommendation are as follows: Undergrounding Utilities – On May 20, 2003, the Town Council approved a site plan amendment and a phasing plan for the previous building expansion. The approval included conditions on undergrounding the utilities along Indiantown Road which was an issue for the applicant. At the time, the cost associated with undergrounding was estimated at $131,000, which was too much for the theater to fund. Staff suggested that the Town pay for the conduit to be installed underground up front, which would allow the utilities to be placed underground without disturbing the landscaping or sidewalk during phase two. The Town Council voted to pay for half of the costs associated with the undergrounding of utilities, including paying the full cost of installing the conduit necessary for undergrounding (see Attachment D). The Town paid the theater $24,994.01 on October 28, 2004 to fund the installation the conduit. The conduits were installed underground and the sidewalk and landscaping were completed. Because phase two was never constructed, the utilities were never placed within the conduit. Since the subject application is a significant expansion, the property is required to meet all code requirements, including undergrounding the utilities along Indiantown Road. Because Indiantown Road may be redesigned in the future, staff is recommending a condition that requires the applicant to pay for 50 percent of the undergrounding costs prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. The applicant has obtained a verbal quote from Florida Power and Light for the cost associated with completing the undergrounding work ranging from $50,000 to $75,000. Decorative Street Lights – In addition to paying for the full cost of installing the conduit and committing to pay for 50 percent of the undergrounding costs, the Town Council in 2003 also agreed to install the decorative street lights along Indiantown Road after the undergrounding was complete. Staff has not included a condition regarding the decorative street lights because of Town Council’s previous commitment. Based on a recent cost estimate of the decorative street lights, staff has concluded that the Town’s cost of installing the lights would be approximately $65,000. Fiber Optic Conduit – The property is within Phase 3 of the Town’s proposed Broadband Fiber Optic Network which includes the property frontage along both State Road A1A and Indiantown Road. There is no code requirement yet adopted to require the installation of conduit. Projects that are being developed or redeveloped, which are located in the designated fiber optic loop, have been recommended to provide conduit for fiber optic cables. Similar to the recommendation for underground the utilities, staff has Maltz Jupiter Theater - Staff Report Page 7 recommended a condition that the applicant pay for 50 percent of the cost of installing the conduit for the Town’s fiber optic network. Staff has recommended 50 percent based on Town Council’s prior commitment to pay for 50 percent of the undergrounding costs. The cost of installing fiber optic conduit varies from property to property. If the conduit is installed by trenching within the grass strip of the right-of-way, the cost will be approximately $8 per linear foot. The cost to install conduit by directional bore is approximately $20 per foot. Because the costs can vary depending upon the property, the final contribution amount will be based on an engineer’s design of the undergrounding cost. Staff has included a condition that the applicant submit an estimate prior to building permits to determine the final contribution amount. The estimated total cost is $10,000 to 25,000 for fiber conduit. In addition, staff has included a condition requiring a 10 foot utility easement along the State Road A1A frontage to allow the Town to install the fiber optic conduit in the future. The condition also includes an option for the applicant to demonstrate that the conduit could be installed within the existing right-of-way in lieu of dedicating an easement. When the roadway is redesigned or the fiber is proposed to be installed, the money can be used to fund the installation of the fiber optic conduit. Traffic. The proposed development is in conformance with Palm Beach County’s and the Town’s traffic performance standards. New Driveway connection – The applicant is proposing a new driveway on the northwest corner of the property that connects the northern parking area to A1A in order to eliminate the dead end parking area and to provide better circulation for the student drop off and pick up. Because A1A is county owned, Staff has recommended that the applicant obtain approval from Palm Beach County to construct the driveway, prior to the issuance of permits. If approval cannot be obtained, the applicant is required to work with staff to redesign the area. Cross Access – The previous approval in 2003 required the applicant to obtain a formal cross access agreement from the entry driveway adjacent to Indiantown Road to Reynolds Plaza to the west. A formal cross access agreement was never finalized. Staff is recommending a condition of approval that the applicant provide the cross access agreement from the driveway adjacent to Indiantown Road to the property line where the shared driveway connects to Reynolds Plaza. It should be noted that Reynolds Plaza will be required to provide a similar cross access easement upon any redevelopment. Archaeological monitoring. The subject property is located in the Coastal Strand archaeological potential zone. Pursuant to Section 27-1675.11(4)(c), the applicant is required to address the potential impacts on any archeological resources. The Town’s archaeological consultant, Advanced Archaeology, Inc., has reviewed the application and has recommended intermittent archaeological monitoring during ground disturbing construction activities. Staff has recommended a condition of approval requiring that the applicant to hire a qualified archaeologist to conduct the intermittent archaeological monitoring during ground disturbing construction. The applicant is then required to complete and submit to the Town a report of the findings of the archaeological fieldwork. Pursuant to town code, the cost of the Town’s archaeological consultant to review any archaeological reports submitted by the applicant, are to be borne by the property owner. Workforce Housing. Pursuant to Section 27-1675.38, all non-residential developments are required to provide a linkage fee of $1.00 per square foot of additional square footage over Maltz Jupiter Theater - Staff Report Page 8 10,000 square feet. The applicant is proposing a 31,524 square foot expansion. Therefore, staff is recommending a condition of approval that the applicant pay $21,524 into the Town’s Housing Trust Fund prior to the issuance of any development permits. Signage. The proposed application is not in conformance with the Indiantown Road Overlay Zoning (IOZ) Parkway District special sign regulations. Façade signs o Primary façade sign (south elevation) – The existing wall sign received a variance approval on April 13, 2004 to exceed the code requirements in both size and height. The code allows a 112 square foot sign at a maximum of 4 feet in sign height. The existing sign approved by the variance is 154 square feet and 11 feet in sign height. The applicant is proposing to maintain the existing sign and place it back on the façade after the architectural improvements are completed. Staff is supportive of maintaining the existing sign. o Secondary façade sign (east elevation) – The proposed secondary sign is 177 square feet and 7.75 feet tall, which exceeds the size allowed within the Parkways district of the Indiantown Road Overlay Zoning District. Pursuant to Section 27-871, Table 9, the façade sign is allowed to be a maximum of 69.75 square feet and a maximum of 4 foot in sign height. Staff has recommended a condition of approval that the secondary facade sign be reduced to meet the code requirements. Monument signs – Pursuant to Resolution #65-03, the applicant was allowed two monument signs, one on Indiantown Road and one on A1A. The signs were capped at 105 square feet with a 16 square foot changeable copy area. In addition, the height was capped at 8 feet, with the allowance for a decorative feature to extend to 10.5 feet. The applicant is requesting new monument signs with the proposed expansion. The applicant is proposing two, 77 square foot monument signs with 14.7 square feet of changeable copy area, which is less than the previously approved signage. However, the applicant is also proposing to increase the height of the sign to 10 feet with the decorative feature extending to 12 feet, which is taller than the previous approval allowed. Staff is proposing to carry over the signage conditions from Resolution #65-03 and allow the request to increase the height of the monument sign based on the following: o Pursuant to Section 27-871, Table 9, the monument signs are allowed to be up to 15 feet in height based on the property’s large street frontage. o The theater is on 4.8 acres and is setback 140 feet from Indiantown Road and A1A. The large setbacks and landscape buffers along the roadways hide the building from plain sight. o The theater is the only use on the property which reduces the potential visual clutter of multiple tenant names on the sign. o The architectural style of the sign is consistent with proposed building. Parking. The proposed development is in conformance with Section 27-1258 entitled, “Standards for required off-street parking and loading spaces”. The proposed theater expansion is increasing the number of seats from 617 to 640 parking spaces, requiring a total of 213 parking spaces. The applicant is redesigning the parking lot to increase the number of parking spaces to 242, and enhancing the circulation by connecting the rows of parking, which is a significant improvement to eliminate the dead end rows. Flexible Theater – The proposed expansion includes the addition of a flexible theater space with seats for 199 people. Because the number of parking spaces for a theater is calculated based on the number of seats, it is important to ensure the flexible theater Maltz Jupiter Theater - Staff Report Page 9 and main theater are not being used at the same time. The applicant justifies that the flexible theater space is used for a different type of performance and will not be used at the same time as the main theater. In order to ensure compliance and reduce the potential for parking issues, staff is recommending a condition that performances are not allowed during the same time within the main theater and flexible theater space, unless additional parking is provided. This would provide flexibility if events are proposed to occur at the same and the applicant can secure the required parking on nearby properties during such events. Such arrangements would need to be approved by the Town. Site plan criteria. Town Code, Section 27-96, contains minimum criteria for review of all development application processed. Upon review of the 12 criteria in Section 27-96, staff finds that the Owner has satisfied 11 of the 12 criteria. 2) Is the application consistent with all applicable land development regulations and all other portions of the Jupiter Town Code. Staff has recommended conditions of approval for the following code sections that will ensure that the proposed development is in compliance. Section 27-868(6), entitled “Underground Utilities” Section 27-1258, Table 1, entitled “Standards for required off-street parking and loading spaces” Section 27-1675.11(4)(c), entitled “Archaeological resources protection” Section 27-1675.38, entitled “Commercial and industrial development linkage fee” Section 27-871, Table 9, entitled “Parkway District Sign Standards Matrix” Special exception criteria. Section 27-98 contains minimum criteria for review of special exception applications. Upon review of the criteria in Section 27-98, staff finds that the applicant has satisfied all of the minimum criteria. (2) The proposed special exception use shall not have a detrimental impact on surrounding properties based on: a. The number of persons anticipated to be using, residing, or working on the property as a result of the special exception use; Staff comment: Staff has included a condition of approval regarding the proposed flexible theater space to ensure it is not used at the same time as the main theater, unless additional parking can be provided off-site. The condition has been recommended so that the number of people using the theater does not create a parking issue. (see Parking section above). Attachments. Attachment A – Statement of Use Attachment B – Traffic Statement Attachment C – TC minutes regarding median contributions Attachment D – TC minutes regarding underground utilities Attachment E – Email from Pat Stebbins \\Datant\cdev\Staff\WP51\Signature - TC\Oct 20\Maltz Theatre (Garret)\PZ 15-169_Staff Report_TC.docx Attachment A Landscape Architects I Land Planners I Environmental Consultants 1934 Commerce Lane Suite 1 Jupiter, Florida 33458 Ph 561.747.6336 Fax 561.747.1377 www.cotleurhearing.com Lic # LC26000535 Maltz Jupiter Theatre Site Plan Amendment and Special Exception Amendment Justification Statement Introduction The Maltz Jupiter Theatre, Inc. (the ‘Applicant’) is requesting a site plan amendment and an expansion of a previously approved special exception. Approval of this request would allow 31,524 expansion totaling 63,560 square feet. The expansion shall comprise majority of accessory uses such as the Conservatory for Performing Arts (COPA), a sewing room, dance studio and the flex theatre with 640 seats. The site has a Commercial future land use designation and is within the C-2 zoning district within the IOZ (Parkway) overlay. The property is located north of Indiantown Road and south-west of A1A, in the Town of Jupiter, Florida. Application Site Plan Review (14,999 to 49,999 SF) Special Exception Amendment PBC Traffic Review Contact Information Applicant Maltz Jupiter Theatre, Inc. Contact: Andrew Kato 1001 E Indiantown Road Jupiter, FL 33477 $4,500.00 $2,000.00 $150.00 Agent/ Planner Donaldson Hearing / Melissa Kostelia Cotleur & Hearing 1934 Commerce Lane, Suite 1 Jupiter, Florida 33458 Office 561.747.6336 ext. 102/114 History The subject site was originally approved via Resolution 138-02 and subsequently amended to allow phasing in 2013 via Resolution 65-03. The original approval was for 598 seats and expanded to 617 seats with an administrative approval in 2013. The theatre is the state’s largest award-winning regional theatre and a true regional asset to the Town of Jupiter community. The Maltz Jupiter Theatre is a not-for-profit, 501(c)(3) public charity and serves over 100,000 people annually in the tri-county area. Subject Request The applicant is requesting a site plan review and expansion to a previously approved special exception for a “Performance Theatre.” A theater is a special exception within the C-2 (General Commercial) zoning district. Approval of this request would allow a 31,524 SF expansion totaling 63,560 square feet or 640 seats, as shown below. Jupiter Maltz Theatre CH# 02-0206.02 DRC Amendment June 8, 2015 Revised August 4, 2015 Basement (new) First Floor Second Floor Third Floor Total Seats APPROVED PROPOSED DIFFERENCE 24,571 SF 6,977 SF 488 SF 32,036 SF 3,113 30,569 16,441 13,437 63,560 +3,113 +5,998 +9,464 +12,949 +31,524 617 640 +23 Seats Building Expansion The majority of the expansion areas shall comprise of accessory uses to enhance the existing structure and provide more amenities to the existing theatre. The basement area encompasses complementary uses for the orchestra, such as a changing room, restrooms and the orchestra pit. The first floor expansion includes a flex theatre (totaling 199 seats), expanded stage and the Conservatory for Performing Arts (COPA) lobby. The new costume shop (sewing room) is located on the second floor. The Jupiter Maltz Theatre sews 90% of the costumes for their productions; this proposed area shall add a lot of value to the existing theater. The third floor is the COPA (or educational acting space for children) and consists of a dance studio, flex room, offices, acting rooms, miscellaneous studios and rehearsal spaces. It is important to note, performances will not run in both the main theatre and the flex theatre at the same time. Please see the attached letter from the Maltz Jupiter Theatre detailing the existing and future operations of the theatre, including the flex theatre, cross access, visitors and employees. Architecture The previous dinner theatre was designed as a “modified fly” stage and was not designed to meet theatre standards. The added massing and height of the expansion will allow full floor-to-ceiling scenery and backdrop equal to Broadway show standards. The south-west corner of the building has been redesigned to incorporate acrylic glazing to simulate frosted glass. The acrylic glazing shall appear milky white during the day and transparent at night. The glazing is angled and recessed to reduce glare similar to 1950’s store fronts. The purpose of this architectural feature is to showcase the first floor green room, the costume shop and rehearsal space of the COPA. Architectural aluminum details suggest Hollywood sky-beam lights to add modern touch. The port-cohere has been designed to replace the existing awning and a new entrance was added for the COPA on the east side of the building. Both of these entrances incorporate score lines to match the acrylic glazing detail. Setbacks The front setback along State Road AIA is required to have a minimum of 50’ setback. The proposed expansion is 92’ measured from the front property line. The front setback is appropriately screened and landscaped by the way of an existing landscape buffer. The side setback, adjacent to a residential community, is an existing condition of 30’ from the property line. The LDRs require a minimum a 10’ setback. The side setback is appropriately screened by the way of an existing landscape and a 6’ concrete wall. 2 Jupiter Maltz Theatre CH# 02-0206.02 DRC Amendment June 8, 2015 Revised August 4, 2015 Parking, Loading and Access The applicant is proposing a new right in- right out ingress/egress from A1A. The entrance shall maintain the 15’ landscape buffer along the north property line, primarily serve the COPA students and aid the overall circulation of the site. The loading area has been redesigned and relocated due to the expansion area. The theatre is planning on a few “Pre-Broadway” shows a year. In order to bring in the props and staging materials, the site has been designed to have an easily accessible loading area to accommodate a large truck and/or semi. The theatre parks at one per three seats. The applicant is proposing a total of 640 seats, resulting in 213 required parking spaces. The existing site plan has 224 parking spaces, which is more than enough to accommodate the additional 23 seats; however there are several dead-end rows of parking and more than ten (10) parking spaces in a row without a parking island. Since the proposed expansion request is greater than 20 percent, the site does not qualify for Section 24-197, Incentives for Redevelopment. The applicant is required to bring the entire site up to current code. The site plan has been redesigned to eliminate all dead-end parking and add an additional 18 parking spaces, totaling 242 spaces. The existing parking lot, located out of the affected area, shall remain and utilize the disbursement of shade code provision. Greenspace and Lot Coverage According to Chapter 27, Article VI, Division 7, Section 27-554, Area and dimension regulations: the minimum greenspace is 30 percent. The proposed greenspace is 32 percent. The maximum amount of lot coverage is 35 percent; the actual lot coverage is 16 percent. Landscape The subject site currently consists of existing landscape buffers on all sides. The majority of the existing landscape buffers shall remain as it is today. However, the since the parking lot has been redesigned the majority of the existing landscape in the parking lot will have to be removed or relocated. There are a total of seven coconut palms within the east buffer within area of the new entrance drive, all seven coconuts will be relocated and tucked within the eastern buffer along A-1-A. The north 15’ wide landscape buffer is adjacent to an existing multifamily residential community. The buffer comprises of an existing 6’ wall along with a dense buffer of seagrape that line the wall on both sides. Areca palms and shade trees are sprinkled within the north buffer. This buffer has been enhanced to include japanese blueberry trees which will provide additional coverage for the residential community and meet the north buffer code requirements. The west and south buffers will remain and are not within the affected area. 3 Jupiter Maltz Theatre CH# 02-0206.02 DRC Amendment June 8, 2015 Revised August 4, 2015 Foundation Planting The foundation planting for the expanded Maltz Theatre plays off of the specialized architecture and materials, to enhance the aesthetics to its fullest potential. The south elevation planting allows for a grand entry with three medjool date palms and skirts of bougainvillea. The landscape has been deliberately design to mimic patterns within the planting beds which respond directly from the architectural elements, as shown on the South Elevation Detail, sheet 2 of 2 of the Landscape Plans. The remaining elevations include a rhythmic dance of palms at a variety of heights to allow for movement and the softening of the outer walls and to provide scale to the building. It is important to note, the north elevation (adjacent to the residential district) was carefully designed, heavily planted and was not treated as the “back of house” area in any way. Mechanical Equipment The majority of the mechanical requirement onsite has been relocated to be on the roof, hidden by a proposed parapet. Signage The applicant is proposing to “relocate” the existing wall signage unto the proposed architecture. The theatre is in the process of possibly rebranding, therefore the final sign copy and square footages shall be provided under separate cover. However, the architect has schematically shown the signage on the illustrative graphics. The proposed monument signs require an amendment to the existing condition of approval. Per Resolution-65-03, Condition F, Indiantown Road and State Road A-1-A monument signs are limited to 105 SF with 16 SF changeable copy, a maximum of 8’ height with a decorative feature extending 10.5’ height. The applicant is proposing monument signs less than the maximum square footage; however the height is proposed at 12’. Undergrounding of Overhead Lines Around 2003-2004 conduit was installed along Indiantown Road for the purposes of undergrounding overhead lines. Town of Jupiter staff has indicated that applicant should underground these lines with this application. The project’s budget has increased due to the redesign of the parking lot and now requires demolition of the existing parking lot, new lighting, drainage and landscaping. The applicant is requesting some relief from this requirement. Conclusion The applicant, Maltz Jupiter Theater, is excited to move forward with their much sought out theater expansion. The success of the theater has been in direct relation from the support of the Town of Jupiter. If you should have any questions please do not hesitate to contact the agent Melissa Kostelia, directly at 561.747.6336 x 114. 4 Jupiter Maltz Theatre CH# 02-0206.02 DRC Amendment June 8, 2015 Revised August 4, 2015 Section 27-98 Criteria for Special Exceptions (a) A special exception use shall not be approved unless all of the following criteria are met: 1) The proposed special exception use shall be compatible with the character and use (existing and future) of the surrounding property in its function; hours of operation; type and amount of traffic to be generated; building location, mass, height and setback; and other relevant factors peculiar to the proposed special exception use and the surrounding property. RESPONSE: The proposed Special Exception Use – Theatre, architectural design, and landscape design are compatible with the surrounding high density residential (north), surrounding commercial uses and complimentary to the surrounding entertainment district. The proposed increase in seats is nominal and the proposed expansion areas are complementary use that shall create minimal impact on surrounding uses. All Town Codes for land development regulation are being strictly adhered to as part of this petition. 2) The proposed special exception use shall not have a detrimental impact on surrounding properties based on: a. The number of persons anticipated to be using, residing, or working on the property as a result of the special exception use; RESPONSE: The expansion areas increase the seats by only 23 seats and complementary uses to the day activity. b. The degree of noise, odor or other potential nuisance factors generated by the special exception use; and RESPONSE: The proposed Special Exception Use – Theatre is expected to generate little nuisance. In addition, careful attention has been considered when designing along the north property line (the residentially zoned district). c. The effect on the amount and flow of traffic within the vicinity of the proposed special exception use. RESPONSE: A traffic analysis shall verify that the proposed Special Exception Use- Theatre does not adversely affect the existing traffic conditions on Indiantown Road and A-1-A. The project meets PBC Traffic concurrency (Traffic Performance Standards). Section 27-96. - Criteria for site plan review (a) The criteria listed below shall apply to all site plan applications, including small-scale developments, large-scale developments, planned unit developments, developments of regional impact, and modifications of existing approved development orders. (1) The proposed development is consistent with the goals, objectives and policies of the Town of Jupiter Comprehensive Plan. RESPONSE: The project is consistent with the Town’s Comprehensive plan. The proposed development is consistent with the infill and redevelopment goals and policies of the plan. Additionally the project meets all of the LOS requirements of the plan and is being developed where services are readily available to the site. 5 Jupiter Maltz Theatre CH# 02-0206.02 DRC Amendment June 8, 2015 Revised August 4, 2015 (2) The proposed development is consistent with any applicable, countywide land development regulations. RESPONSE: The project is consistent with all the applicable countywide land development regulations and will abide by any other permitting or licensing regulations by the county. The proposed entitlement has been analyzed through the Palm Beach County traffic performance calculations and meets the criteria as discussed in the traffic report included herein. (3) The proposed development is consistent with all applicable land development regulations and all other portions of this Code. RESPONSE: The project is consistent with all sections of the zoning code with the exception to the dumpster setback. All lot dimensions have been met, as well as open space, lot coverage, building height, density, sidewalks, landscape and parking requirements. (4) The proposed development is compatible and/or consistent with the established or proposed character of a neighborhood or area. RESPONSE: The proposed theatre, architectural design, and landscape design are compatible with the surrounding high density residential (north), surrounding commercial uses and complimentary to the surrounding entertainment district. The proposed increase in seats is nominal and the proposed expansion areas are complementary use that shall create minimal impact on surrounding uses. All Town Codes for land development regulation are being strictly adhered to as part of this petition. (5) The proposed development does not create or excessively increase traffic congestion or otherwise affect public safety. RESPONSE: The proposed PUD will not excessively increase traffic or adversely affect public safety. The site is located on a main arterial roadway that has been planned for mass vehicular trips. Multiple sidewalks and crosswalks have been provided for pedestrians. (6) There are adequate levels of service for public facilities, including, but not limited to, transportation, water supply, drainage and sanitation, available concurrent with the impacts of the development proposed by the application. RESPONSE: There are adequate levels of service for transportation, water, drainage and sanitation in the immediate vicinity from the County, the Town, and Loxahatchee River District. (7) The proposed development does not significantly reduce light and air to adjacent properties. RESPONSE: The commercial property shall comply with all photometric regulations at the time of the final plans submittal, prior to the issuance of the permit for lighting. All the buffers adjacent to the residentially zoned property have been significantly landscaped to ensure spillage does not occur. (8) The proposed development does not adversely affect property values in adjacent areas. RESPONSE: The development of this site will provide value to the surrounding residential community by providing a first class theatre within in walking distance. (9) The proposed development would not be a deterrent to the improvement or development of adjacent property in accord with existing regulations. 6 Jupiter Maltz Theatre CH# 02-0206.02 DRC Amendment June 8, 2015 Revised August 4, 2015 RESPONSE: The proposed development will not deter, rather incentivize redevelopment of the adjacent properties. (10) The proposed development does not create noise or visual pollution. RESPONSE: The applicant is not proposing a use that will create noise or visual pollution. The uses are residential and commercial in nature and will abide by all the Town’s code regulations. (11) The proposed development does not negatively impact adjacent natural systems or public facilities, such as parks. RESPONSE: No environmentally sensitive land, preservers, lakes or public parks are located on the subject site or within close proximity of the subject site. (12) The proposed development provides pedestrian amenities, including, but not limited to, benches, trash receptacles, and/or bicycle parking. RESPONSE: The plan has been proposed with all of the required pedestrian amenities including benches, trash receptacles and bicycle racks. 7 Attachment B June 5, 2015 Revised August 4, 2015 Mr. Dave Harris General Manager Maltz Jupiter Theatre, Inc. 1001 East Indiantown Road Jupiter, Road 33477 Re: Maltz Jupiter Theater Jupiter, Florida Dear Mr. Harris: Kimley-Horn was retained to provide a traffic concurrency evaluation for the above-mentioned site. The site is located on the northwest corner of Indiantown Road & Ocean Boulevard (SR A1A) in Jupiter, Florida. The PCN for the site is 30-43-41-05-00-002-0022. Figure 1 shows the site location. The existing site contains a 617-seat theater. It is proposed to add a 23 seats to the theater, for a total of 640. This analysis evaluates the net traffic-related impacts of the proposed expansion. The analysis was prepared to address the requirements of the Palm Beach County Traffic Performance Standards (TPS) Ordinance. Trip Generation Analysis A trip generation analysis was undertaken to evaluate the trips associated with the existing and proposed uses. Since Palm Beach County does not publish trip generation rates for live theaters, and since ITE only provides limited data for live theaters, the Palm Beach County rates for Movie Theater were used. As shown in Table 1, the proposed development results in a net increase of 39 net new daily trips and 2 PM peak hour trips (2 in, 0 out). Per the Palm Beach County Traffic Performance Standards (TPS) Ordinance, the radius of development includes only the directly accessed links. Traffic Assignment The AM and PM peak hour trips associated with the project were assigned to the surrounding roadways. Figure 2 illustrates the project traffic assignment. Test 1 Significance Analysis Per Article 12 – Traffic Performance Standards of the Unified Land Development Code, the links on which the project traffic is greater than 1% of the level of service (LOS) D generalized service volume are considered to be significantly impacted. As shown in Table 2, none of the roadway links are projected to be significantly impacted. Therefore, no further roadway or intersection capacity analyses are required. Event Trip Generation Analysis A trip generation analysis was undertaken to evaluate the trips associated with a sold out production. In order to best calculate the traffic associated with this scenario the ITE trip generation rate for Movie Theater with Matinee was used to determine the Saturday peak hour of generator. As shown in Table 3, the event traffic results in 294 peak hour trips (165 in, 129 out). For informational purposes, the peak driveway volumes are shown in Figure 3. However, it should be noted that these volumes will occur infrequently and often at times of day that do not correspond with peak hours of adjacent street traffic; therefore no additional turn lanes are recommended. kimley-horn.com 1920 Wekiva Way, Suite 200, West Palm Beach, FL 33411 561 845 0665 Page 2 Driveway Evaluation The site is currently accessed by one full access driveway on Indiantown Road and one full access driveway on SR A1A. It is proposed to construct a right-in/right-out driveway on SR A1A, north of the existing driveway. The proposed trips associated with the site were assigned to the driveways as shown in Figure 3. The project driveway volumes were compared against the Palm Beach County thresholds to determine the turn lane requirements of the driveways. The Palm Beach County Design Standards Manual contains a threshold for providing a right-turn lane when inbound peak hour rightturning traffic is 75 vehicles or more and the street average daily traffic volume exceeds 10,000 vehicles per day. This manual also contains a threshold for providing a left-turn lane when inbound peak hour left-turning traffic is greater than 30 vehicles. Based on the analysis undertaken, the left turning volume entering the site from Indiantown Road is expected to exceed 30 vehicles in the peak hour. However, the inside lanes of Indiantown Road serve as de-facto left-turn lanes on this segment of Indiantown Road; no turn lanes are provided for other driveways. Furthermore, the proposed addition will only add one peak hour left turn at this location. Therefore, it is not recommended to add a left-turn lane at this location. Flexible Seating Area It is proposed to include a flexible seating area of 199 seats. The Maltz Theater has issued a letter stating the following: “The proposed project would add a small number (23) seats to the main theatre auditorium, making the current parking density still in compliance with regulations. The second performance space proposed by the project would provide for a maximum capacity of 199 attendees. It is not intended to run performances in both the main and second spaces at the same time. The purpose of the second space is to provide different types of programming not permitted in the main theatre auditorium, with such programming largely taking place when the main theatre is “dark” or not being otherwise used. This allows the Maltz Jupiter Theatre to be fully utilized during the busiest times of the year, offering a full range of programming to our community. Accordingly, the project does not propose to increase the amount of parking for second performance space attendees, minimizing the impact to the site.” Therefore, because the flexible seating area will not be in use at the same time as the main theater, no additional peak hour traffic will be generated by the flexible seating area. kimley-horn.com 1920 Wekiva Way, Suite 200, West Palm Beach, FL 33411 561 845 0665 Page 3 Conclusion The foregoing analysis demonstrates that the proposed development on the site will meet the requirements of the Palm Beach County TPS Ordinance. No additional turn lanes are recommended to accommodate site traffic. We appreciate this opportunity to work with you on this project. Should you have any questions regarding this analysis please contact me via telephone at (561) 840-0874 or via email at adam.kerr@kimley-horn.com. Sincerely, KIMLEY-HORN AND ASSOCIATES, INC. Adam B. Kerr, P.E. Transportation Engineer Florida Registration Number 64773 Certificate of Authorization Number CA00000696 Attachments k:\wpb_tpto\1444\144467003 - maltz theater\2015-05-28_trafficstatement.docx kimley-horn.com 1920 Wekiva Way, Suite 200, West Palm Beach, FL 33411 561 845 0665 Kimley»>Horn Page 3 Conclusion The foregoing analysis demonstrates that the proposed development on the site will meet the requirements of the Palm Beach County TPS Ordinance. No additional turn lanes are recommended to accommodate site traffic. Attachments k:\wpb_ tpto\ 1444\ 144467003 - maltz theater\2015-05-28_trafficstatement. docx ' kim ley-horn.com 1920 Wekiva Way, Suite 200, West Palm Beach, FL 33411 561 845 0665 PROJECT SITE INDIANTOWN ROAD LEGEND SITE FIGURE 1 SITE LOCATION MALTZ JUPITER THEATRE TABLE 1 TRIP GENERATION COMPARISON MALTZ THEATER AM PEAK HOUR DAILY INTENSITY TRIPS TOTAL IN OUT LAND USE Existing Development Theater 617 seats PM PEAK HOUR IN OUT 1,111 0 0 0 89 53 36 56 0 0 0 4 3 1 Driveway Volumes 1,111 0 0 0 89 53 36 Net New External Trips 1,055 0 0 0 85 50 35 1,152 0 0 0 92 55 37 58 0 0 0 5 3 2 1,152 0 0 0 92 55 37 1,094 39 0 0 0 0 0 0 87 2 52 2 35 0 Pass-By Theater 5% Proposed Development Theater 640 seats Pass-By Theater 5% Driveway Volumes Net New External Trips Trip Differential (Proposed - Existing) Daily Trips Theater AM Peak Hour Theater PM Peak Hour Theater Pass-By Theater TOTAL [PBC] = 1.8 trips / seat [PBC] = 0 trips [PBC] = 0.144 trips / seat (60% in, 40% out) [PBC] = 5% INDIANTOWN ROAD 5% 85% LEGEND SITE XX% PERCENT ASSIGNMENT FIGURE 2 TRAFFIC ASSIGNMENT MALTZ JUPITER THEATRE SR A1A Indiantown Road Project Driveway SR A1A Project Driveway Indiantown Road US 1 Project Driveway US 1 Project Driveway ROADWAY SEGMENT 2L 2L 4L 4L COMMITED NUMBER OF LANES Class I Class I Class I Class I FACILITY TYPE 880 880 1,860 1,860 5% 5% 85% 5% o i i o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 TABLE 2 TEST 1 SIGNIFICANCE ANALYSIS MALTZ THEATER LOS D GEN. SVC. % ASSIGN- NB/EB TRIPS MENT IN/OUT? VOLUME NB/EB SB/WB 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% No No No No 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% No No No No PROJECT TRIPS AM PEAK HOUR % IMPACT NB/EB Sig? SB/WB Sig? 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 TRIPS NB/EB SB/WB 0.00% 0.00% 0.11% 0.00% No No No No 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% PM PEAK HOUR % IMPACT Sig? SB/WB NB/EB No No No No Sig? 20 95 6 0 (2) 111 0 (31) 1,037 9 0 (3) INDIANTOWN ROAD 140 0 (47) LEGEND SITE XX PEAK DRIVEWAY VOLUMES XX INBOUND AM VOLUME (XX) INBOUND PM VOLUME XX OUTBOUND AM VOLUME (XX) OUTBOUND PM VOLUME DAILY VOLUMES XXX FIGURE 3 DRIVEWAY VOLUMES MALTZ JUPITER THEATRE TABLE 3 TRIP GENERATION COMPARISON MALTZ THEATER LAND USE Proposed Development Movie Theater with Matinee Net New External Trips Saturday Peak Hour of Generator Theater SATURDAY PEAK OF GENERATOR TOTAL IN OUT INTENSITY 640 seats [ITE 444] = 294 165 129 294 165 129 0.46 trips / seat (56% in, 44% out) Attachment C TIC MINUTES - Page 9 January 7. 2003 REGULAR AGENDA PUBLIC HEARINGS 8. Resolution 138-02, Jupiter Theater (Council comments) Mr. Baird suggested Council could approve the site plan with a condition that the landmark feature and the undergrounding issues come back to Council with a Staff recommendation, after Staff and the Theater representatives had time to reach a solution on the issue. He suggested the language in Paragraph 6 be amended. Mayor Golonka indicated Paragraph 6 would need to be modified to reflect Mr. Baird's comments. Consensus of Council agreed. She indicated she could not support the Town contributing any more money to enhance the landmark feature around the pond. ViceMayor Henderson and Councilor Daniels agreed. Mr. Bartolotta suggested inserting a 120 day time limit in paragraph 6. Consensus of Council agreed. Mayor Golonka summarized Council's comments: 1) the condition regarding handicap parking spaces be modified to indicate that valet parking will meet the special needs guests as a means to accommodate the handicap parking; 2) Council would not require the interconnection of the eastern parking lots due to the applicant providing a turn around; 3) Delete the requirement regarding the median, due to there not being a median at that location; 4) Delete the requirement for the additional coconut palms; 5) modifying condition 8b reducing the size of the triangle easement to 115 feet; and 6) revise plan dates in the resolution to match Council approved plans. Councilor Kozinski moved to approve Resolution 138-02, with changes and modifications as discussed by Council; seconded by Vice-Mayor Henderson; motion passed. Golonka Yes Henderson Yes Daniels Yes Kozinski Yes Kuretski Yes Mayor Golonka recessed the meeting at 9:50 P.M. and reconvened the meeting at 9:55 P.M. 9. Resolution 158-02, Pebworth Properties - Site plan and special exception applications for the construction of a commercial shopping center greater than 20,000 sq. ft. and for a restaurant on a 3.3 acre property known as Pebworth Properties. Located on the south side of Indiantown Road between Hepburn and Orange Avenues at 250 West Indiantown Road. Quasi-judicial Ex-parte Communications: • Councilor Daniels mentioned he had met with Mr. Steinhauer about a month ago to review proposed plans. • Vice-Mayor Henderson mentioned she had met with Mr. Steinhauer previously regarding the site plans. • Councilor Kozinski stated she had met previously with Mr. Steinhauer on the project. • Councilor Kuretski had no disclosures on this matter. • Mayor Golonka had no disclosures on this matter Attachment D TIC MINUTES- Page 6 MAY 20, 2003 ITEMS REMOVED FROM CONSENT AGENDA TO REGULAR AGENDA PUBLIC HEARINGS 3. Ordinance 21-03, Second Reading, Ritz-Carlton, PUD Mr. Stephanie Thoburn, Staff Principal Planner noted a inconsistency on condition 31 (b) on Page AA. She explained 4 foot was incorrect and should be consistent with the waiver at 4.8". Councilor Daniels moved to amend his motion to approve Ordinance 21-03, adding 4.8" to the condition; seconded by Councilor Kozinski; motion passed. Title read by Vice-Mayor Kuretski. Kuretski Yes Henderson Abstain Daniels Yes Kozinski Yes END OF ITEMS REMOVED FROM CONSENT AGENDA TO REGULAR AGENDA REGULAR AGENDA PUBLIC HEARINGS 9.1 Resolution 65-03, Jupiter Theater - Site plan amendment application to allow for phasing of the renovations approved for the Jupiter Theater, and to determine the applicant's contribution for undergrounding the utilities. Located on 5.0± acres, at the northwest corner of Indiantown Road and State Road A 1A. Quasi-judicial Ex-parte Communications • Councilor Kozinski advised she had spoken within the last month with Mr. Price and Mr. Katz regarding the application. • Vice-Mayor Kuretski, Councilor Henderson, Councilor Daniels had no disclosures at this time. The Deputy Town Clerk swore in ten people. Ms. Stephanie Thoburn, Staff Principal Planner, stated Staff recommended approval of applicants' request to modify Resolution 65-03 to allow phasing of the approved renovations to the Theater and to determine the applicant's contribution to the undergrounding of the utilities. [14 minutes remaining] Mr. Donaldson Hearing, of Cotleur and Hearing, and representing the applicant explained the Theater needed to defer the fac;ade improvements to enable the Theater to open, as fundraising was not as strong as hoped. He made a presentation which showed the powerlines and the 140' triangle easement for the landmark feature, as well as the pedestrian access easement and additional right of way along Alternate A 1A, and the 30' pedestrian access and landscape easement along Indiantown Road. He noted these components of the site plan would be completed, and construction would be started when Staff advised as to the design cross-section of A 1A. TIC MINUTES - Page 7 MAY 20, 2003 REGULAR AGENDA PUBLIC HEARINGS 9.1 Resolution 65-03, Jupiter Theater Mr. Hearing listed the components which the applicant wanted to defer were fa9ade changes, foundation landscaping, and utilitarian improvements to the rear of the building. He listed the following would occur in phase one: parking lot renovation including landscaping, the northern buffer wall and parking lot lighting. He stated the current status was that demolition had commenced, exotic vegetation was removed and parking lot and audience chambers renovations were commencing. He noted the Theater was probably not going to receive a $500,000 grant from the Florida legislature this year; the Theater was doing $2.5 million in renovations in phase one and the project was $5 million short in total. He agreed with Staff's recommendation for the Town to fund the power conduit, deferring the power lines to a later date, but disagreed with the recommendation requiring phase two completion within 24 months. He also noted the Theater could not post a surety bond, and that the Theater would do extensive landscaping but not foundation landscaping which would be removed during phase two. [5 ~minutes remaining] (Council questions) Councilor Henderson requested clarification on the opening date. Mr. Todd Price, Theater Director, stated it was January 2004. She requested the timetable for phase two, and Mr. Hearing advised the goal was three years after completing phase one, but it was dependent upon fund-raising. Mr. Bartolotta emphasized the resolution included a two year time frame for completion; the applicant was requesting an open-ended time frame. Councilor Henderson felt the two-year limit helped fund raising efforts by creating a sense of urgency, and supported it, with the understanding the Theater could request an extension. She did not support the bond requirement. Councilor Daniels questioned who would pay for the streetlights when the power lines were undergrounded, and what type of lighting would be needed. Mr. Schattner, Director of Engineering, advised one light would be required; cost was $1,000 - $3,000. Mr. Bartolotta noted the Staff recommendation was the Town bearthe $25,000 cost forthe conduit, with the Theater burying it in phase two; their commitment being guaranteed with a bond. Councilor Daniels felt the Town should budget for ornamental streetlights and control the style. Vice-Mayor Kuretski questioned and received Applicant/Staff clarifications that phase two construction would take nine months, that undergrounding by Adelphia would cost $36,000, and that FPL would not bury without the other utilities removing their lines first. Councilor Kozinski clarified the water service agreement requirement was due to increased water consumption. TIC MINUTES - Page 8 MAY 20, 2003 REGULAR AGENDA PUBLIC HEARINGS 9.1 Resolution 65-03, Jupiter Theater (Public comments) Mr. Richard Katz of Spyglass Lane in Jupiter and Jupiter Theater Board of Directors member stated the Theater needed to go forward and requested the permitting as soon as possible. (Council comments) Councilor Daniels commented that he did not see a need for a 140' landmark easement, as he thought the consensus of Council was the fa9ade was the landmark, and Mr. Bartolotta agreed, but noted the easement was in return for the Town maintaining the landscaping. Councilor Daniels supported no bond, and leaving the time requirement, particularly since he was receiving citizen comments on the site being currently unattractive. Vice-Mayor Kuretski noted that six months ago, the Town made a $200,000.00 commitment to the Theater with the sidewalk, water and maintenance from current and future tax collections. He expressed a concern with supporting further commitment of public funds without knowing the impact on ad valorem tax rate. He supported the time limit and had reservations on leaving the undergrounding issue open-ended. Mr. Hearing clarified the Theater did not have the money to do the undergrounding. Councilor Kozinski complimented the Theater on the job they have been doing, and stated the Theater needed assistance from the town. She felt a charitable organization should not have to pay for undergrounding; the Town should pay as the corner and undergrounding was so important to the Town. She agreed with the two-year concept, but wanted language added regarding best efforts so the Theater would not be caught in the future. She supported no foundation plantings. Councilor Kozinski made a motion to approve Resolution 65-03 with the Town paying for the conduit and undergrounding, that the fa9ade be completed within two years using best efforts, no bond requirement, and no foundation plantings during phase one. The motion died for lack of a second. Councilor Daniels moved to approve Resolution 65-03 with the two year requirement with Council option to extend, no foundation planting until phase two, no bond requirement, the Town pay for Council selected street lighting after undergrounding of the utilities, which would be paid for with the Town funding the conduit up front, and up to 50% of the total undergrounding cost at phase two; seconded by Councilor Henderson. Councilor Kozinski stated she would support the motion to move the Theater project forward, although she still had the concerns stated. Vice-Mayor Kuretski reiterated he could not support undergrounding between a budget cycle without knowing the impact on ad valorem taxes. We have made all these decisions on the Theatre between budget cycles. TIC MINUTES - Page 9 MAY 20, 2003 REGULAR AGENDA PUBLIC HEARINGS 9.1 Resolution 65-03, Jupiter Theater Councilor Daniels noted the Council contingency funds could be used, but he expected to be able to find funding over three years. Motion passed. Kuretski No Henderson Yes Daniels Yes Kozinski Yes 10. Ordinance 3-03, First Reading, Public School Facilities Element and Capital Improvements Element - Comprehensive Plan Amendments - Text Amendment to the Public School Facilities (PSF) Element of the Comprehensive Plan pertaining to annual updates to the concurrency map series. Replacement School Attendance Zone maps in PSF Element Data and Analysis with updated maps. Amendment to the Capital Improvements Element pertaining to annual update of Table 11 entitled "School District of Palm Beach County Six-Year Capital Improvement Schedule." (Second Reading - TBA) Mr. David Kemp, Staff Principal Planner, explained this was an annual update to the school the six-year CIP for the County, text facilities element of the comp plan changing: amendments including map changes, and attendance area boundary maps needing updating. He stated the amendments came from the lnterlocal agreement establishing school concurrency. Vice-Mayor Kuretski noted he discovered the capacity standard for a single school in the area had been increased from 120% to 130%, and he questioned how this happened. Mr. Kemp advised this had been adopted in the second round of amendments December 2002 and sent to the Department of Community Affairs at that time. He thought the School Board had changed this due to increased population in the area. Vice-Mayor Kuretski inquired about adding language to require the School District to consider traffic concurrency. Town Attorney Baird noted the School District must approve facilities consistent with the comp plan, so if the comp plan was revised they would be required to meet that provision. Vice-Mayor Kuretski expressed disappointment with the School Board merely changing the school capacity Level of Service standard to appear in compliance. Councilor Henderson asked how the capacity standard could be reversed and noted Palm Beach County had stated the standard would be going down. She felt supporting this amendment would not be meeting concurrency. Mr. Shannon, Director of Community Development, advised Staff would research, but felt the interlocal agreement would have to be revised. Attachment E From: To: Subject: Date: Pat Stebbins Garret Watson; Pat Stebbins Maltz Theater Site Exception 15-169, hearing October 20, 2015 Monday, October 05, 2015 8:25:05 AM I am a home owner in Ocean Parks located on the north side of the Maltz Theater. Four or five years ago Ocean Parks homeowners took advantage of your great Neighborhood Matching Grant Program to rebuild and refurbish our ponds including two beautiful fountains as well as a signage project. Also at our home owner's expense we contributed $50,000. to the extensive landscaping project along A1A when it was improved 6-7 years ago, and we have continued to maintain it over the years costing us thousands of dollars. We are all about beautification and improvement in our community and along A1A. The Maltz Theater is a wonderful asset for our community. People from all over come to see the plays, bands or take classes and join outreach programs to enjoy and learn. In the past 4-5 years the owners of that property have made sizable investments in the buildings and hard scape but have left the landscape and outside community exposure unimproved and deteriorating. With that said, I want to shed light on some issues that I believe are improvements that should be considered in their current request, Site Exception 15-169. 1. Over the last 10 years, I have tried to have the pond (lake) located on the corner of the Maltz Theater property at Indiantown Road and A1A, cleaned of debris and garbage. I have also asked that the present aeration fountain be repaired or replaced. 2. Also lighting at that corner as well as all around Maltz property needs upgrading for safety and landscape beautification. All of the avenues available to me through Code Enforcement, Natural Resource Program, Building and Zoning, Planning and some Palm Beach County departments have not brought any response from my many attempts for improvement. I am requesting that the approval of site exception 15-169 from the Town be contingent on the Theater's agreement for these improvements in the pond and lighting as described above. I have a real and personal interest in this area, not only because I live next door but because I walk by there with my dog most every day. I see it up close and spend time in the morning as well as the evening hours. It is a shame to see the debris and offensive condition around the lake when it could be so beautiful. I hope you agree and can make this happen. Thank you, Pat Stebbins (561-748-1290) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 RESOLUTION NO. 63-15 A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF JUPITER, FLORIDA, APPROVING A SPECIAL EXCEPTION AND SITE PLAN AMENDMENT FOR THE MALTZ JUPITER THEATRE, AUTHORIZING AN EXPANSION; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, Maltz Jupiter Theatre, Inc. is the owner (“the Owner”) of 22 approximately 4.8 acres of property known as the Maltz Jupiter Theatre, the address of 23 which is 1001 E. Indiantown Road, the legal description of which is attached hereto and 24 incorporated herein as Exhibit A (the “Subject Property”); and, WHEREAS, Cotleur & Hearing as the Owner’s authorized agent (the Applicant) 25 26 has submitted an application to expand the Maltz Jupiter Theatre (the Application); and, 27 28 WHEREAS, at a public hearing, the Planning and Zoning Commission reviewed the Application, and made its recommendations to the Town Council; and, 29 30 WHEREAS, at a public hearing, the Town Council considered the Application; and, 31 WHEREAS, at its public hearing, the Town Council considered the evidence 32 presented to it by the Town staff, the Owner and Applicant, and others, regarding the 33 Application’s consistency with the Town’s Comprehensive Plan; and, R#63-15 Page B 1 WHEREAS, at its public hearing, the Town Council considered the evidence 2 presented to it by the Town staff, the Owner and Applicant, and others regarding 3 whether the Application meets the regulations of the Town’s Zoning Code; and, 4 WHEREAS, the Town Council has determined that the conditions which are 5 incorporated into Section 3 are necessary for the Application to be consistent with the 6 Town’s Comprehensive Plan, and to meet the regulations contained within the Zoning 7 Code. 8 9 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF JUPITER: 10 11 Section 1. The whereas clauses are incorporated herein, are true and correct and represent the findings of fact and conclusions of law of the Town Council. 12 Section 2. The Town Council hereby determines that the Application is 13 consistent with the Town’s Comprehensive Plan and meets the regulations contained 14 within the Zoning Code. 15 Section 3. The Owner, Applicant, and their successors or assigns shall comply 16 with and maintain the following conditions: 17 1) The Owner shall install and maintain all improvements in compliance with the 18 following: 19 a. Site Plan and Details, referenced as “Sheet 1 of 2 and Sheet 2 of 2”, revised 20 on 08/04/15, prepared by Cotleur & Hearing, received and dated by the 21 Department of Planning and Zoning on 08/05/15. 22 b. Landscape Plan, Relocation Plan, and Landscape Details, referenced as 23 “Sheet 1 of 3, Sheet 2 of 3, and Sheet 3 of 3”, revised on 08/04/15, prepared 24 by Cotleur & Hearing, received and dated by the Department of Planning and 25 Zoning on 08/05/15. R#63-15 Page C 1 c. Overall Site plan, Floor plans, and Roof Plan, referenced as “A1.01, A2.01, 2 A2.02, A2.03 and A2.04”, revised on 08/04/15, prepared by Currie Sowards 3 Aguila Architects, received and dated by the Department of Planning and 4 Zoning on 08/05/15. 5 d. Building elevations, referenced as “A3.01 and A3.02”, revised on 08/04/15, 6 prepared by Currie Sowards Aguila Architects, received and dated by the 7 Department of Planning and Zoning on 08/05/15. 8 e. Signage Program, referenced as “Page 1 and Page 2”, prepared by Baron 9 Signs Manufacturing, revised on 08/04/15, received and dated by the 10 Department of Planning and Zoning on 08/05/15. 11 f. Preliminary Engineering, referenced as “C-01 and C-02”, prepared by Kimley- 12 Horn and Associates, received and dated by the Department of Planning and 13 Zoning on 08/05/15. 14 g. Statement of Use, revised 08/04/15, prepared by Cotleur & Hearing, received 15 and dated by the Department of Planning and Zoning on 08/05/15. 16 h. Traffic Impact Statement, revised 08/04/15, prepared by Kimley-Horn and 17 Associates, received and dated by the Department of Planning and Zoning on 18 08/05/15. 19 i. Drainage Statement, dated 08/04/15, prepared by Kimley-Horn and 20 Associates, received and dated by the Department of Planning and Zoning on 21 08/05/15. 22 2) The uses conducted on the Subject Property shall conform to the representations 23 in the Statement of Use prepared by Cotleur & Hearing, received and dated by 24 the Department of Planning and Zoning on 08/05/15. 25 26 3) Any revisions to the site plan, landscape plan, elevations, signs, Statement of Use or other details submitted as part of the Application, including but not limited R#63-15 Page D 1 to the location of the proposed improvements or additional, revised or deleted 2 colors, materials, or structures, or changes to the business’ operation, shall be 3 submitted to the Department of Planning and Zoning (the Department) and shall 4 be subject to its review and approval. 5 4) the Department’s review and approval. 6 7 5) 8 9 Any condition associated with the submission of the final plans shall be subject to The conditions of approval herein shall apply to the Owner, Applicant and their successors and assigns. 6) Site Plan - Upon the submission of the final plans, and prior to the issuance of 10 any development permits, the Owner shall modify the Site Plan to: 11 a. Label the 25 foot radii at the southern driveway onto Indiantown Road. 12 b. Indicate the sidewalk width for the existing sidewalk along Indiantown Road. 13 c. Add a stop bar and stop sign at the northbound approach of second access 14 aisle west of the porte cochere. 15 d. Remove the stop bar and stop sign at southeast corner of the most eastern 16 row of parking. 17 e. Shift the parking spaces along the western property line adjacent to Reynolds 18 19 Plaza two feet eastward, in order to provide a five foot landscape buffer. 7) Landscaping - Upon the submission of the final plans, and prior to the issuance 20 of any development permits, the Applicant shall revise the landscape plans to: 21 a. Shift the proposed landscaping shown on top of the existing sidewalk 22 adjacent to the new driveway at the northeast corner of site. b. Add the 10’ x 30’ safe sight triangles at all driveways. 23 24 8) Undergrounding Utilities/Fiber Conduit. R#63-15 Page E 1 a) Prior to the issuance of any development permits, the Owner shall submit an 2 estimate of the cost to place all utility lines along Indiantown Road 3 underground and the cost of installing the fiber optic conduit along Indiantown 4 Road and A1A. The Owner shall be responsible to obtain any permits for 5 undergrounding the utilities from all necessary parties, including but not 6 limited to FPL, Palm Beach County, the Town and any other applicable 7 agencies. 8 b) Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Owner shall provide 9 monies to the Town equal to 50% of the cost of placing the utilities along 10 Indiantown Road underground and 50% of the cost of installing the conduit 11 for the Town’s fiber optic network underground. 12 c) Prior to the issuance of any development permits, the Applicant shall revise 13 the Site Plan to include a 10 foot utility easement along the frontage of State 14 Road A1A to accommodate the future underground placement of conduit for 15 the Town’s Fiber Optic Network. Prior to a Certificate of Occupancy, the 16 Applicant shall submit a copy of the recorded easement for the Town’s Fiber 17 Optic Network to the Department. If the Applicant can demonstrate that the 18 conduit for the fiber optic network can be installed within the existing right-of- 19 way to the satisfaction of the Town, the easement shall not be required. 20 9) Traffic. 21 a) Upon the submission of the final plans, and prior to the issuance of any 22 development permits, the Applicant shall obtain a permit from Palm Beach 23 County authorizing a new driveway at the northern end of the Subject 24 Property. 25 b) Upon the submission of the final plans, and prior to the issuance of any 26 development permits, the Applicant shall submit a draft of the proposed cross R#63-15 Page F 1 access easement for the driveway adjacent to Indiantown Road, and 2 extending west to the Subject Property’s property line at the shared driveway 3 with Reynolds Plaza in the southwest corner of the property. Prior to the 4 issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall submit a copy of 5 the recorded easement to the Department. 6 10) Archeological monitoring. Prior to beginning any ground disturbing site work 7 on the Subject Property, the Applicant shall be financially responsible for 8 retaining a qualified archaeologist to perform intermittent archaeological 9 monitoring throughout the construction period. Prior to the issuance of a 10 Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall submit to the Town a report from the 11 archaeological consultant which contains the findings of the archaeological 12 fieldwork, field specimen analysis (if any specimens are recovered), consultant 13 summary of the findings, the methodology employed by the consultant, results, 14 and any recommendations regarding the protection and/or relocation of any 15 archeological resources. 16 11) Workforce Housing. Upon the submission of the final plans, and prior to the 17 issuance of any development permits, the Owner shall contribute $21,524 in the 18 Town’s Housing Trust Fund for Workforce Housing. 19 12) Signage. 20 a) Upon the submission of the final plans, and prior to the issuance of any 21 development permits, the Applicant shall reduce the size of the wall sign on 22 the east elevation to 69.75 square feet and its height to 48 inches. 23 b) The theatre building shall be permitted one freestanding sign adjacent to 24 Indiantown Road and one freestanding sign adjacent to State Road A1A. 25 Each sign shall be limited to 105 square feet of sign face, 16 square feet of R#63-15 Page G 1 changeable copy area, and shall not exceed 10 feet in height, with the 2 exception that decorative features may be no greater than 12 feet in height. 3 13) Performances within the main theater and flexible theater space shall not occur 4 simultaneously, unless the Owner has demonstrated to the satisfaction of the 5 Department that it has made arrangements for sufficient parking off site to 6 accommodate both performances. 7 14) Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the Applicant shall submit a 8 signed and sealed letter from a Florida registered engineer containing the total 9 site area, total impervious area, and total pervious area. 10 15) Upon the submission of the final plans, and prior to the issuance of any 11 development permits, the Owner shall execute an amendment to its Water 12 Service Agreement with the Town which provides for any additional capacity 13 reservation required as a result of the expansion of the theatre. 14 16) The placement of any type of vending machines or units which dispense food, 15 beverages, candy, merchandise, products, goods, handbills, or advertising 16 magazines outside the confines of the principal structure on the exterior portions 17 of the Subject Property within public view, is prohibited. 18 17) Outdoor loudspeaker systems including, but not limited to, bells, amplified 19 telephone ringers, music paging systems, etc., which are audible outside the 20 confines of the principal structure are prohibited. 21 22 Attachments: Exhibit A – Legal Description (Maltz Jupiter Theatre) 23 24 \\Datant\cdev\Staff\WP51\PROJECTS\Maltz Jupiter Theater\15-169 Theater Expansion\TC\Resolution 63-15.doc 25 October 14, 2015 EXHIBIT A LEGAL DESCRIPTION: BEING A PARCEL OF LAND LYING OVER A PORTION OF THE NORTHWEST QUARTER OF SECTION 5, TOWNSHIP 41 SOUTH, RANGE 43 EAST, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA; SAID PARCEL BEING MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS: COMMENCING AT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THE NORTHWEST QUARTER OF SAID SECTION 5; PROCEED NORTH 89°53'10” EAST, ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID NORTHWEST QUARTER AND THE NORTH RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF INDIANTOWN ROAD (STATE ROAD NO. 706), A DISTANCE OF 539.69 FEET TO A POINT ON THE WEST LINE OF THAT CERTAIN PARCEL OF LAND AS DESCRIBED IN OFFICIAL RECORDS BOOK 12970, PAGE 132, PUBLIC RECORD OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, AND THE POINT OF BEGINNING; THENCE CONTINUE NORTH 89°53'10” EAST, DEPARTING SAID WEST LINE, AND ALONG THE SOUTH LINE OF SAID NORTHWEST QUARTER AND SAID NORTH RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE, A DISTANCE OF 644.71 FEET TO A POINT ON THE WESTERLY LINE OF THE ADDITIONAL RIGHT-OFWAY DEDICATION AS RECORDED IN OFFICIAL RECORDS BOOK 16736, PAGE 1283, PUBLIC RECORDS OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA; THENCE NORTH 21°47'17” EAST, DEPARTING SAID SOUTH LINE OF THE NORTHWEST QUARTER AND SAID NORTH RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE, AND ALONG SAID WESTERLY LINE OF THE ADDITIONAL RIGHT-OF-WAY DEDICATION, A DISTANCE OF 74.23 FEET; THENCE NORTH 46°18'36” WEST, ALONG THE SOUTHWESTERLY LINE OF SAID RIGHT-OF-WAY DEDICATION, A DISTANCE OF 616.99 FEET TO A POINT ON THE NORTHWESTERLY LINE OF SAID PARCEL DESCRIBED IN OFFICIAL RECORDS BOOK 12970, PAGE 132; THENCE SOUTH 43°39'05” WEST, DEPARTING SAID SOUTHWESTERLY LINE, AND ALONG SAID NORTHWESTERLY LINE, A DISTANCE OF 318.74 FEET; THENCE SOUTH 01°18'59” WEST, ALONG THE WEST LINE OF SAID PARCEL DESCRIBED IN OFFICIAL RECORDS BOOK 12970, PAGE 132, A DISTANCE OF 265.84 FEET TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING. SAID PARCEL CONTAINING 4.81 ACRES, MORE OR LESS.