City of Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan 5-Year Update
Transcription
City of Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan 5-Year Update
City of Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan 5-Year Update 2011 Final City Approval March 10, 2011 Final State Approval June 20, 2011 This update was finalized in early 2011. The preparation of this plan spanned the administration of Mayor James E. Doyle, and Mayor Donald Grebien. Pawtucket City Council 2009-2011 Henry S. Kinch, Jr., Council President 2008-2010 David P. Moran, Council President 2010 - Present Jean-Phillippe Barros James F. Chadwick, Jr. David P. Moran Lorenzo C. Tetreault Mark J. Wildenhain John J. Barry Thomas E. Hodge Christopher O’Neill Albert J. Vitali, Jr. Paul Wildenhain Pawtucket City Planning Commission Antero L. Martins, Chair John Q. Calista, Jr. David Chmielewski Carl I. Freedman Monique Renaud City of Pawtucket, Department of Planning and Redevelopment Barney Heath, Acting Director Susan Mara, Senior Planner Table of Contents Introduction Executive Summary Action Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ES-8 Chapter 1 – LAND USE I. Goals, Policies, and Actions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III. Future Land Use . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sources. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1-1 1-2 1-12 1-19 Chapter 2 – HOUSING I. Goals, Policies, and Actions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III. Summary of Major Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sources. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-1 2-2 2-16 2-18 Chapter 3 – ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT I. Goals, Policies, and Actions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III. Summary of Major Issues. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sources. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3-1 3-2 3-11 3-12 Chapter 4 – NATURAL AND CULTURAL RESOURCES I. Goals, Policies, and Actions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III. Summary of Major Issues. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sources. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-1 4-3 4-21 4-22 Chapter 5 – OPEN SPACE AND RECREATION I. Goals, Policies, and Actions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III. Summary of Major Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sources. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-1 5-3 5-14 5-15 Chapter 6 – COMMUNITY SERVICES AND FACILITIES I. Goals, Policies, and Actions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III. Summary of Major Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sources. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6-1 6-3 6-20 6-22 Chapter 7 –TRANSPORTATION I. Goals, Policies, and Actions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III. Summary of Major Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sources. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7-1 7-2 7-13 7-15 TABLES Table 1.1, Summary of Land Use Changes Pawtucket ,1960 – 2009. . . . . 1-3 Table 1.2 Zone Changes to Facilitate Mill Redevelopment . . . . . . . . . . . . 1-4 Table 1.3 Pawtucket Brownfield Redevelopment Projects. . . . . . . . . . . . . 1-8 Table 1.4 Mill Redevelopment – Residential Density . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1-10 Table 1.5 Zoning Map Amendments Since 2005. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1-12 Table 1.6 Individual Property Zoning Map Amendments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .1-12 Table 2.1 Housing Units 1970-2008. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-3 Table 2.2 Units in Structure, 2008 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-3 Table 2.3 Housing Units in the Metropolitan Core, 1980-2008 . . . . . . . . . 2-5 Table 2.4 New Units Added 1990-2008 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-5 Table 2.5 Household Types in Pawtucket, 1990-2008 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-6 Table 2.6 Housing Units by Planning District, 1990-2000. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-6 Table 2.7 Occupancy, 1980 – 2000 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-9 Table 2.8 Vacancy, 1980 – 2008 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2-10 Table 2.9 Age Distribution of Housing Stock . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-10 Table 2.10 2010 Federal Income Guidelines. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-11 Table 2.11 Subsidized Housing Units . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-12 Table 3.1 Educational Attainment, Population 25 Years and Older . . . . . . 3-3 Table 3.2 Occupations in Pawtucket 2002-2008. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3-3 Table 3.3 Twelve Largest Private Employers in Pawtucket . . . . . . . . . . . . 3-4 Table 3.4 Tax Base Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3-5 Table 3.5 Mill Redevelopment Projects in Pawtucket . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3-7 Table 3.6 Summary of City Economic Development/Retention Programs. 3-9 Table 4.1 Table 4.2 Table 4.3 Table 4.4 Major Soil Types, Pawtucket, Rhode Island . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-4 National Register of Historic Places, Pawtucket, Rhode Island. 4-13 Pawtucket Cemeteries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-16 City of Pawtucket Preservation Projects. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-17 Table 5.1 Location of Public Recreation Areas by Planning District . . . . . 5-7 Table 5.2 Population by Age Groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-9 Table 5.3 Recreation Requirements by Age Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-10 Table 5.4 Approved Local Recreation Bond Issues. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-11 Table 5.5 Parks and Recreation Division Budget. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-11 Table 6.1 Public Works Departments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6-5 Table 6.2 City of Pawtucket, Municipal Buildings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6-6 Table 6.3 Wastewater Pumping Stations, Pawtucket, Rhode Island. . . . . . 6-7 Table 6.4 Average Weekly Waste/Recycling Collected, 2010. . . . . . . . . . . 6-8 Table 6.5 Pawtucket Fire Stations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6-14 Table 6.6 Pawtucket Public School Facilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6-18 Table 6.7 Pawtucket School Enrollment History 2000-2010 . . . . . . . . . . . 6-18 Table 7.1 Ratio of Registered Automobiles per Person over time. . . . . . . Table 7.2 Roadways in Pawtucket. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Table 7.3 State-owned Roads in Pawtucket . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Table 7.4 Worst Intersections in Pawtucket, 2010. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Table 7.5 Transportation Improvement Program, 2009-2012, Pawtucket Projects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Table 7.6 Total Ridership on Routes Serving Pawtucket . . . . . . . . . . . . . Table 7.7, Downtown Pawtucket Parking Supply. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7-2 7-3 7-3 7-5 7-6 7-9 7-10 Table 7.8 Bridge Clearances along the Seekonk River Channel 7-12 MAPS Figure 1.1 Riverfront Development. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Figure 1.2 Land Use. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Figure 1.3 Zoning. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Figure 1.4 Potential Zone Changes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Figure 1.5 Future Land Use. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1-5 1-9 1-13 1-14 1-15 Figure 2.1 Planning Districts & Neighborhoods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2-8 Figure 3.1 Downtown Projects. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3-8 Figure 4.1 National Resources. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Figure 4.2 Cultural Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-5 4-15 Figure 5.1 Open Space and Recreation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5-5 Figure 6.1 Community Services and Facilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6-4 Figure 7.1 Major Routes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Figure 7.2 Public Transportation, Bikeways & Boat Ramps. . . . . . . . . . . 7-4 7-8 APPENDICES Public Meeting Documentation .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2005 Action Plan Status . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . Broad Regeneration Initiative Action Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pawtucket Downtown Design Plan Recommendations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hazardous Mitigation Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A B C D E City of Pawtucket, Rhode Island Comprehensive Community Plan 2011 Update INTRODUCTION Introduction This Comprehensive Plan is a broad statement for the future development of the City of Pawtucket. The principal components of the plan address the current and future condition of the City’s land, water, and human and natural resources, and how to protect and maintain assets like historic places, parks and schools, streets and highways, industry, and neighborhoods. Typically such plans are prepared to accommodate a twenty-year time frame because many goals and objectives cannot be achieved immediately. Comprehensive Plans are not meant to be static documents, and to ensure that they are viable, the following three conditions must be met: (1) the plan must reflect true community-wide interests; (2) it must look not just to the end of a twenty year time frame, it must also have milestones along the way to enable the assembly of a final product over a period of time; and (3) the plan must be reviewed and kept up to date every five years, as mandated by Rhode Island law. The current City of Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan was approved in 2005. The Rhode Island General Assembly enacted the Rhode Island Comprehensive Planning and Land Use Regulation Act (General Laws, Section 45-22.2) in 1988. The general requirements of the state enabling legislation allows each municipality to prepare a plan unique to its community’s needs, but it must be set within the overall State Goals and Policies as well as regional and municipal needs. Also, each plan must be prepared through a process that facilitates public participation during plan development and results in plan adoption by local planning commissions and city councils, and acceptance by the State of Rhode Island. Once adopted, the plan must be updated every five years and the local zoning ordinance must be brought into compliance with the future land use elements of the plan within 18 months. The community can adopt four plan amendments per year and each amendment may effect multiple changes to the plan. These procedures and requirements are intended to keep the plan responsive to changing community needs while maintaining a rational process for decision-making. Plan Development This update of the Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan began at the end of 2009. Planning staff began to update the Action Plan from the 2005 Comprehensive Plan, and to update the text for the various chapters. Since the 2005 Comprehensive Plan included a major rewrite, staff determined that the 2011 version would be a simple updating of that plan. The public outreach process began in late summer 2010 (Appendix A contains backup documentation from the public meetings). The Planning Department hosted a public meeting on September 23, 2010. The City utilized a number of venues to notice this meeting – including inviting stakeholders by mail and email, preparing a press release and notice on the City’s website. The Public Meeting began with a short presentation, followed by an opportunity for public comment. The goals, policies and action items from each chapter of the 2005 Comprehensive Plan were displayed on large sheets. Each sheet was attended by a City staff person who was familiar. Attendees were given three green stickers and three red stickers and asked to “vote” for the goals that they agreed with and disagreed with most strongly. Approximately 30 residents attended this I-1 meeting. A follow up meeting was held on October 21, 2010. The same methods of outreach were used, but there was significantly less attendance. This meeting included a presentation of the results of the first meeting, followed by discussion. Although there was less attendance, the participants represented many of the stakeholder groups (the downtown residents, Pawtucket Foundation, Pawtucket Public Library) and provided substantive comments and feedback. On December 22, 2010 the plan was posted on the City website and letters and emails were sent to all of the stakeholders, attendees of the public meetings, the City Council, Mayor, City Planning Commission, all abutting communities and well as Statewide Planning inviting them to review and comment. Based on public input, the plan was drafted and presented for Public Hearing by the City Planning Commission on January 18, 2011 and for City Council Public Hearing on February 23, 2011. Plan Organization The Rhode Island Comprehensive Planning and Land Use Regulation Act of 1988 requires the development and adoption of nine plan elements. Seven of these elements are for specific functional attributes of the community, while one element is oriented to the community goals and policies that will govern the future growth and development and the ninth element addresses the implementation program that has been designed to put the plan’s objectives into place. The seven functional elements are arranged in this plan as seven separate chapters covering the following specific aspects of the community. Within each element, goals and policies are set forth along with supporting text and graphics. This is consistent with the guidelines established by the State. The Action Plan, which is the proposed implementation program, is contained at the end of the end of the Executive Summary (A status update of the 2005 Implementation Plan is included as Appendix B). The Executive Summary summarizes the major issues and changes within each element, and also discusses this plan’s consistency with Land Use 2025. The Comprehensive Plan is laid out as follows: • • • • • • • • Executive Summary/Action Plan Chapter 1 Land Use Chapter 2 Housing Chapter 3 Economic Development Chapter 4 Natural and Cultural Resources Chapter 5 Open Space and Recreation Chapter 6 Community Services and Facilities Chapter 7 Transportation I-2 Executive Summary City of Pawtucket, Rhode Island Comprehensive Community Plan 2011 Update EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ES - 1 Executive Summary This update of the City of Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan includes seven Chapters: Land Use, Housing, Economic Development, Natural and Cultural Resources, Open Space and Recreation, Community Facilities and Services and Transportation. This Executive Summary is intended to review the major issues identified within each Chapter, discuss of the plan’s consistency with Land Use 2025, and summarize the planning studies and initiatives that occurred since 2005. The Action Plan is included at the end of this Chapter. I. Summary of Chapters Land Use Pawtucket’s goals for land use from the 2005 plan are generally the same in this plan: to preserve successful land uses - established residential neighborhoods; viable industrial areas; and public open space and recreation areas - and to revitalize of the downtown and riverfront. In the past ten years the Zoning Ordinance has been amended to accomplish the goal of protecting established residential neighborhoods, including an increase minimum lot size, and parking requirements for new residential development. In addition, the City has instituted a design review component for all new development, to ensure that infill development is appropriate for the surrounding area. Parkin Yarn Condominiums, 2009 During this same timeframe Pawtucket has also experienced the revitalization of vacant and underutilized mills. This Comprehensive Plan is supportive of this reuse, provided that it does not displace active manufacturing uses (although in most cases the layout of the older mill buildings is no longer viable for reuse in an industrial capacity). After a number of these mills had been rezoned to allow for commercial uses, the City developed a Mill Building Reuse District (MBRD) an overlay district which allows for the types of uses that are desirable in these redevelopments. In 2005 the entire stretch of land along the Blackstone River was rezoned to attract welldesigned, compatible economic development, open space, recreation and residential uses. All new development and redevelopment is subject to design review before the Riverfront Commission. There are three categories of riverfront development areas: Riverfront Public Open, Riverfront Industrial and Riverfront Mixed Use. Because of its industrial past, many properties within Pawtucket have some degree of contamination from hazardous substances. The City of Pawtucket has worked over the past five years to secure over $1 million in US EPA Cleanup Grants. The City has also worked with Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management on their Targeted Brownfields Assessment program to make funding available for assessment. Recent redevelopment projects have been locating within and around Pawtucket’s downtown: four hundred and fifty new residential units have been built, and over 350 are planned, for a total of 800 new residents living within walking distance of downtown ES - 1 Executive Summary Pawtucket. There are also a number of ongoing downtown redevelopments which will result in over 100,000 square feet of commercial and office space, with another 300,000 square feet planned. The historic W.T. Grant building on Main Street has been rehabilitated and is fully tenanted, bringing retail back to the downtown. Moving forward, Pawtucket must continue to protect its neighborhoods while encouraging redevelopment within the downtown, and the reuse of under-utilized mill buildings. The Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station presents an important opportunity for redevelopment, particularly within walking distance of the proposed station. The cities of Pawtucket and Central Falls began examining the potential to restore access to Boston to Providence commuter rail service in 2005. The Feasibility Study’s key findings affirmed that commuter rail service in Pawtucket/Central Falls was indeed viable. Pawtucket currently has a $1.9 million authorization in SAFETEA-LU for the Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station. Housing Pawtucket has met Rhode Island’s alternative standard for “low and moderate income housing”, but the provision of affordable housing for all socioeconomic groups will continue to be a goal for the City. Pawtucket’s efforts in affordable housing are focused on the groups most in need: there are a number of homeless in Pawtucket and Central Falls due to the prolonged downturn in the regional economy; providing housing for the population of mentally ill persons who find themselves in crisis Hicks Street, Affordable Housing Development also remains problematic; additional affordable rental units and additional subsidies are needed for families in the very low and lowincome brackets; continued assistance in purchasing a first home is needed for individuals and families in the moderate-income bracket; finally, continued subsidies and assistance is needed to keep elderly residents in their own homes. Economic Development Pawtucket’s economy is built on an intricate wed of inter-relationships that stretch far beyond the City’s borders. As such, the recent downtown has impacted the City’s ability to attract new development. The City is working to continue with the programs that have had success, and provide infrastructure and regulatory support where feasible. Manufacturing has historically been the mainstay of employment in Pawtucket and is likely to remain an important part of the City’s economic base. However, the City will have to take a more active role in maintaining its industry. To facilitate expansion of industries, which are likely to remain strong, the City should continue with its business retention programs and continue to emphasize communication between businesses and local government. The City should also recognize that manufacturing jobs will continue to be lost and should help displaced workers find the retraining they need to continue in the workforce. ES - 2 Executive Summary Pawtucket does not have a great deal of vacant industrial land suitable for new development. The City does have an estimated 1 million square feet of vacant industrial space found in existing mill structures as shown by a detailed mill inventory conducted by the City. Pawtucket should focus its efforts on maintaining viable industrial spaces for industrial uses, and allowing a more flexible redevelopment of other vacant and abandoned mill space. To this end, the City should continue its efforts to promote and market available space to small businesses, like artists. Natural and Cultural Resources The biggest challenge for Natural Resources in Pawtucket is water quality, which has consistently been a concern in Pawtucket over the past several decades. The major issue has been, and continues to be, combined sewer overflows. The Narragansett Bay Commission has begun an ambitious project to abate the pollution issues that arise from combined sewer overflows. This effort, coupled with the new RIDEM guidelines for storm water runoff, should begin to show an improvement in the quality of Pawtucket’s water resources. There are still other ground and surface water pollution problems remaining, particularly in the Pawtucket Water Supply watershed, that need to be resolved through a combination of regulations, site monitoring, individual small scale improvements, inter-municipal agreements, and resource management. Pawtucket Public Library Renovation, 2009 Pawtucket is rich in architectural and cultural resources. The preservation of these resources requires the cooperation of the City, State, and local non-profit preservation organizations. Moving forward, Pawtucket must work to preserve the structures that give Pawtucket its unique character. Open Space and Recreation Over the past few years, the City of Pawtucket has utilized state and federal grants as well as local funding sources to upgrade existing recreational facilities and acquire new areas for recreational development. Because of the developed character of the City, new parcels for recreational development are scarce. The City is focusing acquisition efforts along the city’s rivers Slater Park Playground, Renovated 2005 – the Moshassuck, Blackstone, Ten Mile and Pawtucket/Seekonk River corridors. These corridors offer the greatest opportunities for interconnection with adjacent community facilities. Pawtucket is also looking for creative redevelopment opportunities – like the ES - 3 Executive Summary McKinnon/Alves soccer complex, and the potential Mill Pond property – to expand its recreation and open space. As recreational facilities are continuously renovated and improved, management and maintenance of the facilities becomes more important. The Division of Recreation and Parks has and will continue to require maintenance plans for all park and recreation areas throughout the City to ensure that facilities are properly groomed, equipped and managed. Community Services and Facilities The City of Pawtucket must maintain its existing, aging, infrastructure in order to continue to provide services to its residents. The City’s sewage disposal system is still also functioning as a stormwater collector, and Pawtucket will continue to work with the Narragansett Bay Commission to phase out Combined Sewer Outfalls. Pawtucket is working to reduce the amount of solid waste generated. In 2009, the Director of Public Works presented a plan for pay as you throw in the City of Pawtucket. This proposal was, unfortunately, not successful. In an effort to still reduce the amount of waste generated, the Director proposed an alternative plan – mandatory recycling. The City of Pawtucket will not pick up trash unless there are also recycling containers present. These efforts have begun to reduce trash and increase recycling within the City. Transportation As with many older cities, transportation infrastructure in Pawtucket continually needs maintenance and upgrades. This situation is no more evidence than with the replacement of Interstate 95 Bridge 550, which spans the Pawtucket River. Pawtucket will work with the Rhode Island Department of Transportation and the Federal Highway Administration to ensure that the bridge is constructed in a manner that is sensitive to the residents of Pawtucket. Public transportation service improvements and improved marketing, Rendering of the proposed Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station and the development of alternative modes of transportation, such as better walkways and bikeways, especially during the design of new roadways and roadway improvements, are essential components of the overall strategy of keeping the City’s transportation system functioning smoothly and efficiently. The City of Pawtucket will continue to work on establishing a Commuter Rail station, to provide transportation alternatives for its residents traveling to Boston, Providence, and ultimately to South County. Pawtucket will also continue to work with RIPTA on their express Providence to Pawtucket bus project. The City will also work to provide Bikeways and pedestrian walkways throughout the City and especially within the downtown. ES - 4 Executive Summary II. Consistency with Land Use 2025 The City of Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan is consistent with the Goals listed in Land Use 2025. In particular, the following priority recommendations are consistent with Pawtucket’s Plan: • • • • • Sustain Rhode Island’s unique character through use of the Urban Services Boundary, rural centers, and holistic approaches to planning. Permanent Greenspace throughout the rural, urban, and waterfront areas. Development concentrated in well-designed centers, neighborhoods, and special places. A diverse and affordable housing stock. Public infrastructure maximized and coordinated with development. Pawtucket is located within the Urban Services Boundary, and is served by transportation and utility public infrastructure. As the City promotes redevelopment, it is meeting the goals of concentrating development in appropriate places. As the City works to improve the circulation of the downtown, it is meeting the goal of having a welldesigned center. Pawtucket’s goals of maintaining its greenspace, and providing affordable housing to all socio-economic groups mirror those same goals within Land Use 2025. Table ES-2, below, describes in more detail, each Chapter’s consistency with this plan, and other state planning documents. Table ES-2 Consistency with Land Use 2025 and other State Planning Documents Land Use Following are the Key Recommendations of Land Use 2025 relevant to this Chapter, and a description of how Pawtucket’s goals are consistent. • Sustain Rhode Island’s unique character through use of the Urban Services Boundary, rural centers, and holistic approaches to planning. • Development concentrated in well-designed centers, neighborhoods, and special places. Housing Economic Development Natural and Cultural Resources Open Space and Recreation The City of Pawtucket is located within the Urban Service Boundary. Pawtucket’s efforts towards the redevelopment of the downtown, riverfront and mill buildings are supportive of these goals. This type of redevelopment does not require additional infrastructure, and facilitates the reuse of historic buildings. Land Use 2025 includes language that is consistent with this plan’s overall goal of providing housing for all socio-economic groups: Objective 3D Provide a diverse, affordable housing stock. The City’s Economic Development goals are consistent with Land Use 2025 Land Use Goal 1 A sustainable Rhode Island that is beautiful, diverse, connected and compact with a distinct quality of place in our urban and rural centers, and abundance of natural resources, and a vibrant sustainable economy; Objective 1A recommends the support of traditional centers, like downtown Pawtucket, over new development. Land Use 2025’s main goal of preserving Rhode Island’s unique character is consistent with the Pawtucket’s goals of preserving both natural and cultural resources. Goal 2 A statewide network of greenspaces and greenways that protects and preserves the environment, wildlife habitats, natural resources, scenic landscapes, provides recreation and shapes urban growth. ES - 5 Executive Summary Objective 2B Upgrade and maintain urban and community Greenspace. Objective 2C Provide a diverse, well-balanced system of public outdoor recreation facilities. Community Services and Facilities Transportation The Greenways/Greenspace Element of the State Guide Plan includes the following policies which are consistent with Pawtucket’s Plan. • E-2 Restore or re-establish natural greenspace values where they have been disturbed by development, especially within urban and suburban areas. • P-2 Promote public access to and usage of the greenspace system, wherever feasible and consistent with protection of the system’s resource values. Pawtucket’s Comprehensive Plan is consistent with both Land Use 2025 and the Rhode Island Comprehensive Solid Waste Management Plan. Land Use 2025 includes language which supports maximizing public infrastructure. The City of Pawtucket is located within the Urban Services Boundary and is working to encourage redevelopment of vacant industrial and other sites. The Rhode Island Comprehensive Solid Waste Management Plan includes a goal for the management of solid waste in Rhode Island. Under Goal 2-3, is the following objective (#1): Reduce the amount of solid waste generated. Pawtucket’s recycling program has begun to reduce municipal solid waste. Because of the City’s work on the Commuter Rail Station, Bikeway and improvements to the downtown, the transportation goals of this Comprehensive Plan are consistent with the following sections of Land Use 2025: • Objective 4E Promote Intermodal Centers and Greater Reliance on Transit • Objective 4F Provide pedestrian connections through all centers and urban districts. This plan is also consistent with many of the goals listed in Transportation 2030: • Bicycle Goal B Maintain and expand an integrated statewide network of onroad and off-road bicycle routes to provide a safe means of travel for commuting, recreation, and tourism in order to improve public health and reduce congestion and auto dependency. • Intermodal Goal I Provide convenient intermodal facilities and services offering seamless connections for passenger and freight. • Goal PE Create and maintain safe and attractive walkable communities to encourage more walking trips, enhance transit usage, improve public health and reduce congestion and auto dependency. • Goal T Provide a safe, robust and convenient network of transit and ride services with seamless intermodal connections in support of increased employment opportunities, improved environmental quality and reduced congestion and auto dependency. III. Summary of Other Plans and Initiatives From 2005 to 2011 a number of planning studies were conducted that targeted specific geographic areas, or specific subject areas. These are listed and summarized below. The goals and recommendations of these plans have been integrated into this plan. Metro Bay Special Area Management Plan The City of Pawtucket worked with the communities of Pawtucket, Providence, East Providence and Cranston and the University of Rhode Island Coastal Resources Center on the Metro Bay Special Area Management Plan (SAMP). This plan helped to categorize the coastal land in Pawtucket, and also proposed Coastal Resources ES - 6 Executive Summary Management Council regulations that are more appropriate to the highly developed MetroBay region. Broad Street Regeneration Plan The Broad Street Regeneration Plan included the communities of Pawtucket, Central Falls and Cumberland. The Plan focused on how to revitalize the Broad Street commercial corridor, and has led to other funding opportunities for Environmental Assessments and loans for façade improvements. The Executive Summary of the Broad Street Regeneration Initiative Action Plan is appended to this document, as Appendix C. Downtown Circulation Study Pawtucket received a Challenge Grant in 2010 to take a comprehensive look at circulation and land use within the Downtown. The major findings of this study are included in the Comprehensive Plan as Appendix D. Pawtucket Hazard Mitigation Plan The City’s Hazard Mitigation Plan was updated in 2011. The recommendations within this plan have been incorporated by reference into the Community Services and Facilities Chapter and can be found in Appendix E. Blackstone Valley Corridor Commission – Study of Moshassuck Canal The John H. Chaffee Blackstone Valley National Heritage Corridor Commission conducted a resource study of the Moshassuck Canal. This study identified areas of the Canal within Rhode Island and Massachusetts which would be worthy of preservation. The report identified one area in Pawtucket, which is noted on the Future Land Use Map. IV. Action Plan On the following pages is the current Action Plan for the City of Pawtucket 2011 Comprehensive Plan. Following the Action Plan are all of the definitions for any acronyms used within the Plan. The status update for the 2005 Plan is included as Appendix B. ES - 7 2011 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan – Action Plan Reference No. Action Item Timeframe Responsible Party, Partners LU1. Review the City Zoning Ordinance and consider revisions to encourage appropriate mixed-use development, more flexibility in the reuse of existing mill buildings, and a more predictable review process. ST DPR, City Council, City Planning Commission LU2. Designate an area of Pawtucket potentially the downtown and area around the proposed Train Station, as a Growth Center. ST DPR, Pawtucket Foundation, GrowSmart RI LU 3. Review the Zoning within ½ mile of the proposed Commuter Rail Station to ensure that appropriate Transit-Oriented-Development would be allowed. MT DPR, Pawtucket Foundation, City Council, City Planning Commission LU 4. Amend the Zoning Ordinance to include specific criteria for all uses allowed by Special Use Permit. ST DPR, Department of Building and Code Enforcement, Zoning Board of Review LU 5. Review the City Zoning Ordinance and consider allowing increased density where appropriate: the downtown; mill redevelopment projects; around the proposed rail station. ST DPR, Pawtucket Foundation, City Council, City Planning Commission LU 6. Conduct a review of all buildable lots Citywide, and officially merge those which are already merged by the Zoning Ordinance. MT LU 7. Consider the rezoning of unusable vacant industrial land to open space, specifically along the Moshassuck. MT DPR, Department of Building and Code Enforcement, Tax Assessor, City Engineering, Data Processing, City Planning Commission DPR, City Council, City Planning Commission LU 8. Complete the review of tax title parcels and consider appropriate action to achieve the objectives of this plan. ST LU 9. Prepare an Executive Summary of the 2010 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan Update for public dissemination. ST LU 10. Implement the specific recommendations within: The Pawtucket Downtown Design Plan and the Broad Street Regeneration Initiative, including the investigation of an overlay district for Broad Street. ST DPR, Pawtucket Foundation, City Council, City Planning Commission LU 11. Amend the Zoning Map as identified in the Future Land Use Map. ST DPR, Department of Building and Code LAND USE DPR, Tax Assessors Office, Collections Department, Department of Building and Code Enforcement DPR, Pawtucket Foundation A-1 2011 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan – Action Plan Reference No. Action Item Timeframe Responsible Party, Partners ST Enforcement, City Planning Commission, City Council DPR, Department of Building and Code Enforcement, City Planning Commission, City Council H 1 Investigate housing resources available to assist moderate-income homebuyers. Ongoing DPR, BVCAP, PCDC, RI Housing H 2 Utilize HOME funds to provide affordable housing opportunities to low and moderate-income persons and families. Ongoing DPR, BVCAP, PCDC H 3 Create a complete brochure of all housing related opportunities for Pawtucket residents including homeownership, rental opportunities, elderly housing and housing rehabilitation. ST DPR, PRA, BVCAP, PCDC, Pawtucket Housing Authority, RI Housing H 4 Revise the Zoning Ordinance to offer better neighborhood protection. Neighborhood boundaries should be protected form intense commercial development through zoning regulation and enforcement. ST DPR, Department of Building and Code Enforcement, City Planning Commission, Pawtucket City Council H 5 Support the efforts of Pawtucket neighborhood advocacy groups including neighborhood associations and crime watch groups. Ongoing DPR, Pawtucket Police Department, Pawtucket Neighborhood Alliance, Barton Street Crime Watch H 6 Acquire vacant and abandoned properties to stabilize neighborhoods. Ongoing DPR, BVCAP, PCDC, Housing Court H 7 Analyze 2010 Census information to determine areas of the City where there are concentrations of poverty and develop programs targeting assistance to those areas. ST DPR, PCDC, WCDC H 8 Investigate the use of Pawtucket Housing Authority funding to rework Prospect and Galego housing developments into mixed-income developments ST DPR, Pawtucket Housing Authority H 9 Assist neighborhood clean-up efforts by supplying waste removal and regular street cleaning. Ongoing DPR, Pawtucket Foundation, DPW LU 12. In accordance with the State of Rhode Island Zoning Enabling Legislation (PL 91-307), amend the City of Pawtucket Zoning Ordinance, commencing January 1, 2004, or sooner, and completing the process within the prescribed 18 month period. HOUSING A-2 2011 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan – Action Plan Reference No. Action Item Timeframe Responsible Party, Partners H 10 Allow the subdivision of lots with two existing primary structures into undersized lots. ST DPR, Statewide Planning ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ED 1 Seek funding sources and implement the Pawtucket Downtown Design Plan. ST DPR, RIDOT, FHWA, FTA, RIPTA ED 2 Prepare promotional marketing materials, including a portfolio of successful adaptive reuse projects and a specialized economic development web presence. Ongoing ED 3 Update the Redevelopment Plan Ongoing DPR, Pawtucket Foundation, Rhode Island Historic Preservation and Heritage Commission, RIEDC DPR, PRA, PBDC ED 4 Improve the visibility and accessibility of downtown parking facilities. ST DPR, RIEDC, Pawtucket Foundation ED 5 Improve visitor access to major attractions by developing and implementing a cohesive signage program. ST DPR, RIEDC, Pawtucket Foundation ED 6 Develop a list for vacant downtown buildings which identified the cost and other issues that need to be addressed. ST DPR, Pawtucket Foundation, PBDC, Northern Rhode Island Chamber of Commerce ED 7 Establish a regular local business visitation program. Ongoing ED 8 Work with RIDOT and FTA to advance the Commuter Rail station. LT DPR, Mayor’s Office, RIEDC, Other City Departments DPR, FTA, RIDOT, RIPTA ED 9 Explore the creation of a downtown Business Improvement District ST DPR, Property Owners ED 10 Create a written economic development plan. ST DPR, Pawtucket Foundation ED 11 Identify sources of public financing/subsidy for the Roosevelt Avenue redevelopment site. ST DPR, RIEDC, Pawtucket Foundation ED 12 Investigate the expansion of higher education opportunities in Pawtucket. ST DPR, RIEDC, Department of Education, Library ED 13 Establish a regular monthly program for downtown events. ST DPR, Pawtucket Foundation, Mayor’s Office A-3 2011 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan – Action Plan Reference No. Action Item Timeframe Responsible Party, Partners ED 14 Work with the Pawtucket Foundation to implement their marketing program. ST ED 15 Analyze land within Industrial Zones to determine whether additional development is feasible, or if the land is more appropriately preserved as Open Space. ST DPR, Pawtucket Foundation, Mayor’s Office, RIEDC DPR, BRHNHCC ED 16 Designate a Growth Center within Pawtucket. ST DPR, Pawtucket Foundation NATURAL AND CULTURAL RESOURCES NR 1 Continue to work with the Pawtucket Water Supply Board in implementing their Water Supply Management Plan. Ongoing PWSB, DPR, RIDEM, NBC NR 2 Continue to work with DPW to minimize the use of salt on watershed roadways. Ongoing DPW, RIDEM, DPR NR 3 Continue to maintain and update information on unique, rare, and endangered natural resources within the City. Ongoing RIDEM, DPR NR 4 Continue to offer the street tree program to City residents and to enforce the landscape requirements of the Zoning Ordinance to expand the number and concentration of trees in the City. Ongoing DPR, City Council, CPC, Zoning Board of Review (ZBR) NR 5 Continue to apply for RIDEM’s Targeted Brownfields Assessment grants and USEPA Cleanup Grants Ongoing DPR, RIDEM, RIEDC NR 6 Advocate for the next segment of the Ten Mile River Bikeway to the Rhode Island Department of Transportation and establish a relationship with the Ten Mile River Watershed Alliance to help move the project forward. Ongoing DPR, RIDEM, RIDOT NR 7 Continue to provide support for the development of Fish Ladders at the Slater Mill and Main Street dams. ST DPR, NRCS, RIDEM NR 8 Coordinate with the Narragansett Bay Commission (NBC) on the status of the CSO abatement project. MT DPR, DPW, RIDEM, NBC CR 1 Establish a cemetery commission to promote the preservation and enhancement of the city’s cemeteries. ST DPR, DPW, PSP A-4 2011 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan – Action Plan Reference No. Action Item Timeframe Responsible Party, Partners CR 2 Map historic resources using (GIS) as part of a program to locate and identify historic sites and structures. ST DPR, Engineering Department CR 3 Enhance the aesthetics of the historic bridges on the river by lighting their architectural details. ST DPR, Rotary, CR 4 Offer design assistance through DPR to developers and owners of historic structures in the city. Ongoing DPR, PSP, HDC CR 5 Continue to provide financial incentives for landlord occupied multi-family historic housing. Ongoing Tax Assessor, DPR CR 6 Continue the partnership between the City, PRA and the RIHPHC to provide low interest loans for house repairs through the Historic Properties Rehabilitation Initiative. Ongoing DPR, PRA, RIHPHC CR 7 Support efforts to rehabilitate and reuse the Pawtucket Armory as a Performing Arts Center. Ongoing DPR, Gamm Theater CR 8 Work with the John H. Chaffee National Heritage Corridor Commission to preserve the land along the Moshassuck Canal, specifically the area behind Lorraine Mills. ST DPR, Property Owners, JHCBVNHCC, BVTC, RIHPHC CR 9 Work with the Public Library and the Preservation Society to identify a long-terms plan for the Elizabeth J. Johnson Pawtucket History Research Center. Ongoing DPR, RIHPHC, Preservation Society of Pawtucket CR 10 Maintain a list of properties eligible for the National Register Ongoing CR 11 Consider expansion of the Local District tax abatement to commercial properties. Ongoing DPR, RIHPHC, Pawtucket Historic District Commission DPR, Pawtucket Historic District Commission OPEN SPACE AND RECREATION R 1 Acquisition of open space land along the Moshassuck River and the Blackstone Canal for the development of a greenway/bikeway. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM, John H. Chaffee Blackstone Valley National Her R 2 Upgrade and improve recreational resources at Morley Field. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM A-5 2011 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan – Action Plan Reference No. Action Item Timeframe Responsible Party, Partners R 3 Evaluate and develop school sites for potential development of additional neighborhood recreation facilities. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 4 Continue progress on the Blackstone River Bikeway. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM,RIDOT R 5 Expand facilities at the Town Landing recreational area. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 6 Construct an outdoor track at Max Read Field that meets all necessary regulations to be used for scholastic track meets. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 7 Provide public access to the Seekonk River at Max Read Field. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 8 Automate irrigation and improve lighting at Wilkinson Park. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 9 Consider needs of the Family Y and the Pawtucket Boys’ and Girls’ Club in an overall parking plan for downtown. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM, YMCA, Boys and Girls Club R 10 Add lighting at the Goff Lots. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 11 Evaluate development of public access to the Blackstone River north of Exchange Street. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 12 Continue field improvements at McCarthy Park including additional lighting. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 13 Reconstruct/reuse tennis courts at McCarthy Park. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 14 Develop the former State Pier (Festival Pier), as recommended by the Riverfront Development Commission into a combination of open space, river walks, boat facilities, and seasonal commercial activity. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 15 Upgrade and improve facilities at Pariseau Field. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 16 Continue to advocate for the next segment of the Ten Mile River Bikeway. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 17 Request grant funding for the purchase of “Red Farms Studios” (1135 Roosevelt Avenue) to ensure its continued availability for passive recreation. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM A-6 2011 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan – Action Plan Reference No. Action Item Timeframe Responsible Party, Partners R 18 Upgrade facilities at Potter School. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 19 Explore other recreational/educational/revenue producing possibilities for Daggett Farm. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 20 Continue infrastructure improvements within Slater Park including the construction of a new sewer line, construction of new rest room facilities, installation and of new water and fire protection services at the Looff Carousel, automated irrigation, and lighting within the Park. ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM R 21 Engineer a solution to improve water quality in the pond and in Friendship Gardens at Slater Park. R 22 Develop parcel of land along the Ten Mile River known as Scout’s Island into a picnic area (passive park). ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM ST DPR/Parks and Recreation, RIDEM COMMUNITY SERVICES AND FACILITIES CS 1 Investigate opportunities for consolidating services with other Rhode Island communities, to reduce costs. Ongoing Mayor’s Office, Central Falls, Lincoln, Providence, East Providence, North Providence CS 2 Identify a location for a new public safety complex, including parking, municipal court, police administration and communications and the fire department. ST Police and Fire Departments, EMA CS 3 Evaluate the sewer system capacity in the Beverage Hill drainage basin to determine the causes of hydraulic overloading and develop a program for eliminating the problem. ST DPW- Sewer, Sanitation and Recycling Division, NBC, RIDEM CS 4 Reserve potential sites identified by the Narragansett Bay Commission for the location of combined sewer overflow mitigation facilities. MT NBC, DPW, DPR, RIDEM, EPA CS 5 Continue the composting program at the municipal transfer station and educate homeowners to compost landscape waste whenever possible. CS 6 Continue municipal curbside collection of residential solid waste and require commercial and industrial solid waster to be handled privately. Ongoing DPW- Sewer, Sanitation and Recycling Division, Rhode Island Resource Recovery DPW- Sewer, Sanitation and Recycling Division, Pawtucket residents Ongoing A-7 2011 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan – Action Plan Reference No. Action Item Timeframe Responsible Party, Partners CS 7 Where feasible, separate the sanitary sewer and the storm drainage systems and prohibit new connections of storm drains to the municipal sewer system. Ongoing DPW, NBC, DPR CS 8 Implement through the Executive Office and the PWSB, the Watershed Protection Plan, which establishes a program of land acquisition in the watershed region, requests regional communities to incorporate watershed protection policies and actions in their zoning and subdivision regulations; urges the establishment of inter-municipal agreements for watershed protection and creates a management program to protect water quality. Ongoing PWSB, Mayor’s office, DPR, Friends of the Moshassuck, Blackstone River Watershed Council, Town of Cumberland CS 9 Cooperate with the State of Rhode Island in the implementation of the Drought Management Plan as a means to reduce Rhode Island’s vulnerability to periods of low precipitation. Ongoing PWSB, DPR, City Council, Emergency Management Department, RIDEM CS 11 Continue to pursue funding opportunities from the FEMA to assist in helping Pawtucket to be a disaster resistant community. Ongoing CS 12 Implement the recommendations in “Strategy for Reducing Risks from Natural Hazard in Pawtucket, Rhode Island, A Multi- Hazard Mitigation Strategy”. Ongoing CS 13 Implement the recommendations in the City’s Long Term Energy Efficiency and Sustainability Plan Ongoing Emergency Management Department, DPR, Department of Building and Code Enforcement, Police Department, Fire Department, Mayor’s office RIEMA, FEMA Emergency Management Department, DPR, Department of Building and Code Enforcement, Police Department, Fire Department, Mayor’s office, RIEMA, FEMA DPR, DPW, City Departments RIEDC CS 14 Continue operation of the Leon Mathieu Senior Center. Ongoing CS 15 Create a task force of neighbors to solve parking problems near the library. ST CS 16 Investigate the feasibility of establishing satellite libraries in city neighborhoods, youth centers, or gathering places. ST CS 17 Improve access to library resources through improvements on the library website. ST Senior Services, DPR, RIPTA, Memorial Hospital, Blackstone Health, Inc., Meals on Wheels, BVCAP Public Library, DPR, Library Board of Trustees, Area Downtown businesses Public Library, DPR, Pawtucket Neighborhood Alliance, Library Board of Trustees Public Library, Champlin Foundation A-8 2011 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan – Action Plan Reference No. Action Item Timeframe Responsible Party, Partners CS 18 Identify and prioritize the social service needs of Pawtucket residents as part of the needs assessment portion of the City of Pawtucket Federal Housing and Community Development Consolidated Plan. Ongoing DPR, Social service providers statewide CS 19 Continue to evaluate alternatives for the alleviation of overcrowding and the provision of necessary classroom space at schools in need. Ongoing School Department, DPR, School Committee, Mayor’s office T 1 Maintain and regularly update the list of potential projects for inclusion in the State of Rhode Island Transportation Improvement Program (TIP). Ongoing DPR, DPW T 2 Work with RIDOT on the reconstruction of the closed bridges at Conant Street and at Cole Street to ensure pedestrian and vehicle safety and access. ST DPW, DPR, Police Department, RIDOT T 3 Work with RIDOT and FTA to advance the Pawtucket Commuter Rail Station. LT DPR, DPW, Amtrak, RIDOT T 4 Support the implementation of RIPTA’s Providence Metropolitan Transit Enhancement Study, especially plans to make Route 99 an express bus, and plans to provide a pedestrian connection to the South Attleboro Commuter Rail Station. ST DPR, RIPTA, RIDOT, Pawtucket Foundation T 5 Develop a linear greenway along the Pawtucket riverfront. ST T 6 Continue to coordinate with RIDOT on the development of the Blackstone River Bikeway, including the development of agreements for all required property and easements. ST DPR, DPW, Department of Parks and Recreation, RIDEM, RIDOT, Riverfront Commission DPR, Department of Parks and Recreation, Riverfront Commission, RIDOT, RIDEM T 7 Cooperate with RIDOT and East Providence on the continued construction of the Ten Mile River Bikeway. ST DPR, RIDOT, RIDEM T 8 Seek funding to implement the downtown circulation improvements identified in the 2010 Downtown Design Plan. ST DPR, RIDOT, FHWA, City, Pawtucket Foundation T 9 Improve/create boat landings along the entire riverfront. Ongoing T 10 Improve visitor access to major attractions by developing a comprehensive ST DPR, DPW, Department of Parks and Recreation, RIDEM DPR, Traffic Engineering Department, DPW, TRANSPORTATION A-9 2011 Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan – Action Plan Reference No. Action Item Timeframe signage program. Responsible Party, Partners Police Department BVCAP- Blackstone Valley Community Action Program DPR – Department of Planning and Redevelopment DPW – Department of Public Works FEMA - Federal Emergency Management Agency FHWA – Federal Highway Administration FTA – Federal Transit Administration JHCBVNHCC – John H. Chaffee Blackstone Valley National Heritage Corridor Commission NBC – Narragansett Bay Commission PCDC – Pawtucket Citizens Development Corporation PRA – Pawtucket Redevelopment Agency PSP – Preservation Society of Pawtucket RIDEM – Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management RIDOT – Rhode Island Department of Transportation RIEDC – Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation RIEMA – Rhode Island Emergency Management Agency RIHPHC – Rhode Island Historic Preservation and Heritage Commission WCDC – Woodlawn Community Development Corporation A-10 Land Use City of Pawtucket, Rhode Island Comprehensive Community Plan 2011 Update Chapter 1 – LAND USE Table of Contents I. Goals, Policies, and Actions 1-1 II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis 1-2 III. Future Land Use 1-12 Sources 1-19 Land Use I. Goals, Objectives, Policies and Actions Goal 1. Continued successful land uses: established residential neighborhoods; viable industrial areas; and public open space and recreation areas. 2. Revitalized downtown and riverfront. Objective 1. No loss of viable industrial land and buildings. 2. No conversions of residential to commercial within established residential neighborhoods. 3. No loss of publicly owned open space and recreation land. Policy 1.Protect existing residential neighborhoods form undue encroachment of conflicting non-residential uses. 2.Protect existing neighborhoods from increasing housing densities that lead to overcrowding, shortage of available offstreet parking and traffic congestion. 3.Control strip commercial development by promoting neighborhood and regional shopping districts. 4.Increase in the amount of available public recreation areas. 4.Maintain an updated file on all brownfields sites and encourage the remediation of these sites where necessary. 5.Reduction in the amount of vacant industrial space. 5.Encourage infill development that reflects the built character of the surrounding area. 6.Decrease of vacancy within downtown. 6.Protect and preserve environmentally sensitive areas through open space acquisition. 7.Increase residential density within the downtown. 7.Accommodate new industrial, commercial, residential and other developments through carefully considered rezoning. 8.Implement the Riverfront Development Plan. 9.Wherever possible, encourage pedestrian and bicycle links along the riverfront as well as throughout the City. Action LU1Revise the Zoning Ordinance to encourage mixed-use development, flexibility in the reuse of mill buildings, and a predictable review process. LU2Designate an area of Pawtucket, potentially the downtown and the area around the proposed Train Station, as a Growth Center. LU3Review the Zoning within ½ mile of the proposed Train Station to allow appropriate Transit-Oriented-Development. LU4Amend the Zoning Ordinance to include specific criteria for all uses allowed by Special Use Permit. LU5Review the City Zoning Ordinance and consider allowing increased density where appropriate: the downtown; mill redevelopment projects; around the proposed rail station. LU6Conduct a review of all buildable lots Citywide, and officially merge those which are already merged by the Zoning Ordinance. LU7Consider the rezoning of unusable vacant industrial land to open space, specifically along the Moshassuck. LU8Complete the review of tax title parcels and consider appropriate action to achieve the objectives of this plan. LU9Prepare the Executive Summary for public dissemination. LU10 Implement the specific recommendations within: The Pawtucket Downtown Design Plan and the Broad Street Regeneration Initiative, including the investigation of an overlay district for Broad Street. LU11 Amend the Zoning Map as identified in the Future Land Use Map. LU 12 In accordance with the RI Zoning Enabling Legislation (PL 91-307) amend the City of Pawtucket’s Zoning Ordinance, commencing January 1 2011 or sooner and completing the process within the prescribed 18 month period. 1-1 Land Use II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis A. Introduction This element of the Comprehensive Plan will examine the distribution of the City’s land among the various land use categories including residential, commercial, industrial, public and private recreation, institutional, mixed use, open spaces, and natural and sensitive areas. Land use considerations are closely related to virtually every other facet of community planning. The land use plan is a synthesis of land use considerations and many of the recommendations appear elsewhere in this Plan. Pawtucket’s population is relatively stable. The population in Pawtucket has been declining since 1950 and rose just slightly from 72,644 in 1990 to 72,958 in 2000 and population estimates from the US Census Bureau American Community Survey 20052007continue to project Pawtucket at approximately 72,000 residents. Pawtucket Tax Assessor’s data indicates that 440 acres of the City is vacant land. However, in reality very little of that land is actually buildable. Construction activity in the City of Pawtucket is therefore primarily redevelopment, and a smaller amount of infill development. Land use planning, therefore, has a different focus than in communities with large amounts of developable land. Pawtucket must instead focus on allowing flexibility in redevelopment while also protecting existing neighborhoods. The City must also focus on the design of infill development, to ensure that it is compatible with surrounding uses. B. Historic Land Use Trends Pawtucket’s geographic area is 8.94 square miles of which .1 square mile is water, located just northeast of Providence, Rhode Island’s capital. As an older former industrial powerhouse, Pawtucket’s population density of approximately 8,000 persons per square mile, making it one of the most densely populated municipalities in the state. The City is located in the northeasterly part of Rhode Island at the head of Narragansett Bay on a relatively flat plain that is penetrated by the valleys of the Blackstone and Moshassuck Rivers. The western half of the City has greater variations in elevation. The predominant surficial materials in the Pawtucket area are sand and gravel deposits laid down by receding glacial ice in pre-historic times. The only natural and physical barriers to the use of land in Pawtucket are excessive slope along the riverbanks and swampy deposits along the Moshassuck River Valley and the Ten Mile River. The original village was founded in 1671 by an ironworker, Joseph Jenks, Jr. The success of the Jenks family attracted settlement in Pawtucket as well as industrial development along both banks of the Blackstone. The City’s renown, however, is traced from 1791 when Samuel Slater opened the first mechanized cotton yarn spinning mill in America just above the Pawtucket Falls. This marked the beginning of the American Industrial Revolution. By 1817 there were 13 textile mills as well as assorted machine shops and other industrial buildings along the banks of the Blackstone. An 1829 collapse of the cotton goods market devastated Pawtucket’s economic base. Recovery 1- 2 Land Use began in 1847 when the Providence and Worcester Railroad line established a depot within the downtown and a year later the Boston and Providence line also established a station. New manufacturing operations began to locate in Pawtucket, both the north and west of the riverside mills while the downtown expanded. Pawtucket manufacturing experienced a boom period thanks to the Civil War. The City’s Pawtucket became an independent town in 1874, and then a City in 1885. Downtown Pawtucket was a thriving cosmopolitan downtown in the late nineteenth century, until the late 1950’s when it began an economic decline that was influenced by suburbanization, competition from southern textile mills and the construction of Interstate 95. The development pattern in older central cities like Pawtucket is relatively fixed. The challenge, moving forward, is to ensure that redevelopment will support the economic goals of the City and not conflict with established land uses and neighborhoods. C. Recent Land Use Trends Overall, the location and density of land use within the City of Pawtucket has remained relatively stable over the past twenty years. Table 1.1 summarizes the overall land uses for the City through the years. From 2002-2009 the amount of land within the commercial, industrial and vacant categories went down, while there was a corresponding increase in public/semi-public land. These shifts are a result of incremental changes over the past seven years where industrial land was rezoned into riverfront districts, and some brownfields were reclaimed as recreation sites. Table 1.1, Summary of Land Use Changes, Pawtucket, 1960 - 2009 Land Use Category Residential Commercial Industrial Public/Semi-Public Railroad/Utility Streets/Waterbodies Vacant Land Total 1960 (acres) 2,077 338 489 759 173 1,182 699 5,717 1977 (acres) 2,083 414 529 890 187 1,200 414 5,717 1988 (acres) 2,120 383 532 909 181 1,078 514 5,717 2002 (acres) 2,054 442 369 1,086 134 1,158 474 5,717 2009 (acres) 2072 435 353 1175 133 1109 440 5717 %Change 02-09 0.9% -1.6% -4.3% 8.2% -0.7% -4.2% -7.2% Source: Pawtucket Tax Assessor, 2009 This section will review some of the major land use trends, by topic area, and then proceed to talk about the current trends affecting all of the major land use categories, as listed in Table 1.1. Trends by Topic Area Mill Building Redevelopment - Some recent trends in Pawtucket land use and reuse include the redevelopment of vacant and underutilized mills. The loss of 4.3% of Industrial land uses from 2002 to 2009 is likely a result of the rezoning of these types of properties. This Comprehensive Plan is supportive of this reuse, provided that it does not displace active manufacturing uses. However, in many cases the layout of the older mill buildings is no longer viable for reuse in an industrial capacity. After a number of these mills had been rezoned to allow for commercial uses, the City developed a Mill 1- 3 Land Use Building Reuse District (MBRD) an overlay district which allows for the types of uses that are desirable in these redevelopments. Designation as an MBRD requires the submission of a Master Plan for redevelopment, including parking, landscaping, stormwater management, etc. which allows the City to take a more comprehensive look at the redevelopment, while allowing the applicant more flexibility in terms of future uses. Table 1.2, below, shows some of the zone changes necessary to facilitate recent mill Riverfront Lofts, Pawtucket, RI redevelopment projects. The two most recent, Kellaway Realty and the Thread Factory, were able to take advantage of the City’s new Mill Building Reuse District (MBRD). Table 1.2 Zone Changes to Facilitate Mill Redevelopment Mill Redevelopment Zoning District Hope Webbing Union Wadding Kellaway Realty The Thread Factory Rezoned: Residential Multi-Family to Commercial General Rezoned: Industrial Built Up to Commercial Downtown Industrial Built Up with MBRD overlay Manufacturing Open with MBRD overlay Source: Department of Planning and Redevelopment, 2010 Riverfront Redevelopment - In 1997 the City of Pawtucket prepared the Riverfront Development Plan. This planning process included an intense public outreach effort, including numerous public hearings, which were broadcast on the local cable access channels, and full-paged newspaper advertisements depicting the proposed plan. In the following years, Pawtucket has successfully implemented many of the plan’s recommendations. Figure 1.1 describes some of the ongoing riverfront redevelopment activities. Public Access along the River - North to South public access along both sides of the entire riverfront was identified as a goal during the 1997 process and the City is beginning to see the development of an interconnected pedestrian/bicycle network. The Blackstone Valley Bikeway will go a long way toward accomplishing this goal. The Bikeway was initially proposed by RIDOT to run along the City streets but the City worked with RIDOT to identify a riverfront route. A very prominent redevelopment site along the river includes an easement for public access along the river within the development requirements. The Pawtucket Foundation partnered with the City to clean a publicly owned site in front of Tolman High School that had become overgrown, and could in the future provide access. The construction of the new I-95 Bridge over the river will open up areas for public access along the river. The City has also had conversations with the major landowners and users on the river about the potential for public access along the river. Finally, the newly created Riverfront Commission includes the provision of public access along the river as part of their standards for review. Public Recreation Opportunities - The public process resulted in the identification of two sites for public access and recreation along the Riverfront – State Pier and Town Landing. In 2006, the City of Pawtucket began the Master Planning for these two sites. Currently, there is funding for projects at both sites: 1- 4 Land Use 1- 5 Land Use The City has $700,000 from the Rhode Island Department of Transportation to improve the docking facilities and for some limited site work at Town Landing, and Pawtucket has $350,000 in funding for site improvements and environmental cleanup at the State Pier. Redevelopment of Privately Owned Sites - In 2005 the entire stretch of land along the Blackstone River was rezoned to attract well-designed, compatible economic development, open space, recreation and residential uses. All new development and redevelopment is subject to design review before the Riverfront Commission. There are three categories of riverfront development areas: Riverfront Public Open, Riverfront Industrial and Riverfront Mixed Use. The City also created the Riverfront Commission, whose function is to review new development and redevelopment within the Riverfront Districts for consistency with the City’s vision for the riverfront. An important upcoming project for the Riverfront is a 7.5 acre redevelopment site at the corner of Division and Water Street. This project was initially intended to include a 200room hotel, 100,000 square feet of office space and a stand-alone restaurant. It began in 2005, but has stalled. The City is working to reformulate a request for proposals to identify the highest and best use for this site. One of the major challenges to the successful redevelopment of the riverfront is the Utility-owned property south of Division Street. Narragansett Electric owns over 20 acres of riverfront property along the west side. They are currently in the process of removing the storage tanks and support structures from this property. There is also known environmental contamination at this site. The City has been attempting to communicate with the owners about the future of their land, to perhaps reach a solution which would allow public access and some site redevelopment. Downtown – Recent redevelopment projects have been locating within and around Pawtucket’s urban core. All but one of the Mill Redevelopment projects listed in Table 1.2 are within ½ mile of the downtown. Although this topic will be covered in depth in the economic development Chapter, it is important to note that, through this redevelopment, four hundred and fifty new residential units have been built, and over 350 are planned, for a total of 800 new residents living within walking distance of downtown Pawtucket. There are also a number of ongoing downtown redevelopments which will result in over 100,000 square feet of commercial and office space, with another 300,000 square feet planned. The historic W.T. Grant building on Main Street has been rehabilitated and is fully tenanted, bringing retail back to the downtown. The Pawtucket Foundation is working on a project that could dramatically impact downtown Pawtucket: the redevelopment of a City-owned vacant site on Roosevelt Avenue. The Foundation developed a plan for this site that included 179,000 square feet of mixed use development, as well parking for the site and other buildings within the downtown with inadequate parking. The challenges moving forward are to try to encourage the redevelopment of the existing historic downtown buildings. The cost of the improvements required by the fire code and building code within these buildings can be a deterrent to their redevelopment. The City also must consider balancing the preservation the historic character of the downtown and increases in redevelopment costs. 1- 6 Land Use Train Station - The cities of Pawtucket and Central Falls began examining the potential to restore access to Boston to Providence commuter rail service in 2005. The cities believe that developing a Commuter Rail station would benefit both the residents, by increasing mobility and access to economic opportunity, as well as the cities, by improving the environment and encouraging economic growth. With funding from RIDOT, FTA and FHWA, the cities prepared a Feasibility Study to answer their initial questions about the viability of re-introducing commuter rail service in Pawtucket/Central Falls. The Feasibility Study’s key findings affirmed that commuter rail service in Pawtucket/Central Falls was indeed viable based on the following findings: • Of the 30 weekday commuter rail trains passing through Pawtucket/Central Falls, based on the schedule as of July 2006, 23 could stop at a commuter rail facility without adversely impacting Amtrak intercity, MBTA commuter rail, or PWRR freight rail service. • Approximately 1,500 weekday daily boardings were projected for the proposed commuter rail stop. • There are numerous opportunities in the surrounding areas for transit-oriented development. The Feasibility Study identified two potential sites – the Providence and Worcester Railyard (the Railyard) and the Historic Depot. During the study, the Railyard site was dismissed because of the costs of relocating the existing operation and because of traffic constraints. Since the completion of the Study the City has entered into conversations with Amtrak because the layout of the Historic Depot is such that both inbound and outbound trains must stop on the mainline. Amtrak has determined that this is unacceptable to them. The City has been working since then to identify an alternate site, and has found one, directly across from the Railyard site, that has none of the cost or traffic issues of the Railyard, and is able to satisfy Amtrak’s requirements. In 2009 the City of Pawtucket received a $1.9 million authorization in SAFETEA-LU for the Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station. The City of Pawtucket and RIDOT have secured the required match and in 2010 the City of Pawtucket received approval to enter Preliminary Engineering from the Federal Transit Agency. Brownfields Redevelopment - Because of its industrial past, many properties within Pawtucket have some degree of contamination from hazardous substances. The City of Pawtucket has worked over the past five years to secure over $1 million in US EPA Cleanup Grant funding. Table 1.3 shows the status of these projects. Recently, Pawtucket also turned a brownfield site into a soccer facility. The City has also worked with Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management on their Targeted Brownfields Assessment program to make funding available for assessment. 1- 7 Land Use Table 1.3 Pawtucket Brownfield Redevelopement Projects Project End Use Status Newman/Crosby Soccer Complex Front Street Pine Street State Pier Laurel Hill Playground Soccer Complex Complete Redevelopment / Bikepath Light Industrial Recreation Affordable Housing Cleanup 90% Complete Projected start 2011 Project start 2011 Projected start 2011 Source: Department of Planning and Redevelopment, 2010 Trends by Major Land Use Category Residential Land - Residential remains the dominant land use category within the City (See Figure 1.2)1. Residential developed and associated vacant land comprise almost 40% of City land. Residential development began during the 18th Century at the City’s center, at the Main Street Bridge. As commercial and industrial establishments grew out from the center of the City, the ring of residential development expanded further from the center with some bypassing of industrial tracts and wetlands. The minimum lot size for all residential zoning districts is 5,000 square feet. Higher density, approximately 14 dwelling units per acre (1 unit per 3,000 square feet), multifamily residential development is found primarily near the center of the City close to the mills and major transportation routes. Less dense, two-family and single-family residential development on 5,000 square foot lots is generally found to the east and west of the multi-family districts. A somewhat irregular pattern of rectangular blocks formed by city streets and residences covers most of Pawtucket’s area. (See Figure 1.3). In the past 10 years the City of Pawtucket has increased the minimum lot size and parking requirements for new residential development in Pawtucket, to protect existing neighborhoods from overcrowding. Current zoning allows 8 units per acre for single family homes, and 14 per acre for multi-family homes and required two parking spaces per unit. However, recent mill redevelopment projects have residential densities above what is allowed by zoning for new development (see Table 1.4). All of the redevelopment projects listed in Table 1.2, except for the Hope Artiste Village, are located within ¼ mile of the Commercial Downtown District. As residential density becomes less dense throughout the neighborhoods, the mill redevelopment projects are bringing higher residential densities to the downtown. The City must consider that this additional density helps to promote activity within the downtown and should also begin to plan for appropriate density to support redevelopment around the proposed Commuter Rail station. 1 High density residential is less than 1/8-acre lots, Commercial is the sale of products and services, Transportation includes roads, railroads and other transportation Vacant Land is all vacant land, Institutional is schools, hospitals, churches, etc. Water Bodies and Wetlands is all water and wetlands, power lines. Median density residential is ¼ - 1/8-acre lots, Industrial includes a mix of industrial and commercial, Recreation: Developed is all recreation Cemeteries is all cemeteries, Open Space is pasture, brushland and forest, Other is quarries, gravel pits, transitional areas, waste disposal and 1- 8 Land Use 1- 9 Land Use Table 1.4, Mill Redevelopment – Residential Density Mill Redevelopment # of Units Bailey Lofts (complete) Riverfront Lofts (complete) Hope Webbing (half complete) Slater Cotton (complete) Union Wadding (proposed) The Thread Factory (proposed) 25 Lot Size (Acres) .23 Residential Density 108/ac. 59 1.4 42/ac 7 135 + 220,000 sf commercial/ light industrial 125 1.63 19/ac. + commercial 76/ac. 242 6.6 36/ac. 376 + 350,000 sf commercial/ light industrial 22 17/ac + commercial Source: Department of Planning and Redevelopment, 2010 Commercial Land - There were 435 acres of land dedicated to commercial use in 2009. Commercial zones are divided into three types. Commercial General - The Commercial General land use category consists of commercial areas that are designated to satisfy the major shopping requirements of residents. The Commercial General zones tend to be more auto than pedestrian oriented. Approximately 266 acres are zoned for commercial general and are found throughout the City primarily along the major streets, including all of the numbered routes that run through Pawtucket – Routes 15, 122, 1, 1A, and 114. 266 acres are zoned for Commercial General within the City of Pawtucket. Commercial Local - This type of land use are areas devoted to limited commercial purposes which are suited to serve the day to day convenience shopping of people living nearby. Not many areas designated for Commercial Local and they are primarily found within established neighborhoods. There are approximately 43 acres zoned CL. Commercial Downtown - The Commercial Downtown district is located within downtown Pawtucket which was historically considered the major business district of the City. Land use in this area includes commercial buildings, residential structures, government buildings and other uses. There are approximately 50 acres zoned CD. The Broad Street Regeneration Action Plan includes a recommendation to extend the CD zone along Broad Street, north of the downtown to the Central Falls border. This change would allow the Broad Street commercial corridor to extend seamlessly into downtown Pawtucket. Industrial Land - Pawtucket’s industry started along the Blackstone River and spread to other parts of the City with the advancement of transportation - the Moshassuck River Canal, then railroads and then automobiles. There are industrial areas, therefore, surrounding the river, the canal and the railroad lines and some historic industrial areas 1- 10 Land Use just outside of downtown. More recently constructed industrial parks are located off of major roadways. In 2009 there were 353 acres of City land that has an industrial land use code. There are, however, a significant amount of vacant industrial buildings throughout the City. In general, the historic industrial areas, which are generally zoned Manufacturing Built-Up (MB), are less viable than the newer industrial infrastructure for reuse as industrial because of the current manufacturing needs for space. Parks and Recreation - There are currently 434 acres of public and semi-public parks in the City of Pawtucket. This number includes school fields and facilities. This number is expected to be relatively stable, perhaps increasing as the City workings on the acquisition and development of additional open space and recreation areas. Also, because federal funds were uses in improving many of Pawtucket’s recreation facilities, encroachment or reuse of an area would require replacing the acreage with elsewhere in the City. Railroad and Utility Land - Pawtucket’s three rail lines and two utility systems occupied a total of 181 acres in 1988. In 2009, 133 acres are classified as railroad and utility land. Most of this land is owned by Amtrak, the Providence and Worcester Railroad, or Narragansett Electric. The Amtrak line between New Haven and Boston runs through the City and there is also a small tract of land uses for engineering services and maintenance. The Providence & Worcester Company operates a short rail line from Pawtucket into Lincoln, Rhode Island. On the eastern side of the City, the Providence & Worcester Railroad tracks utilize the right-of-way of the George Bennett Industrial Highway. The Narragansett Electric Company and the Valley Gas Company have a substation and gas storage facility in Pawtucket on the west bank of the Pawtucket River. The Narragansett Electric Company also occupies various parcels of land in the City to carry transmission lines. As noted, the riverfront utility land presents a challenge to the successful redevelopment of Pawtucket’s riverfront. Vacant Land - The rate at which vacant land is developed was expected to decrease due to the unsuitability of the remaining land for development purposes. Between 1960 and 1977, 285 acres of vacant land were developed for some type of use. In 1988, 100 acres of vacant land was added. This increase is due to changes in the Narragansett Park area and the reclassification of the property. Between 1988 and 2002, 40 acres of vacant land were developed, and another 34 acres have been developed between 2002 and 2009. A portion of the remaining vacant land is thought to have environmental constraints, which might prohibit its use for development. Restrictions have been placed on activities such as filling, previously used to make marginal land suitable for development, therefore much of this land may remain vacant. Inadequate lot size is also a constraint to development, as not all vacant platted lots are buildable. Streets and Waterbodies - There are approximately 1,109 acres of streets and waterbodies. This figure was determined by subtracting the acreage of all other known 1- 11 Land Use land uses from the total acreage of the City. This remaining acreage was assumed to consist of streets and waterbodies. There are approximately 64 acres of waterbodies and 106 acres of freshwater wetlands. The wetlands are primarily along the Ten Mile River and the Moshassuck River. Local street right of ways consist of approximately 851 acres and Interstate 95 has approximately 137 acres of land. III. Future Land Use The following table is a summary of the zoning changes that occurred from 2005 – 2011. The majority were changes to support mill redevelopment projects. In 2009 the City created the Mill Building Redevelopment District to provide some flexibility and predictability to the permitting process. Figures 1.3, 1.4 and 1.5 show the City’s existing Zoning, Potential Zone Changes and Future Land Use, respectively. Because the City is built-out almost completely, the City’s existing Land Use and Zoning will remain consistent. However, there are a few areas proposed for change which are identified in both Figures 1.4 and 1.5. Table 1.5, Zoning Map Amendments Since 2005 Location Map Change 430 Central Avenue 57 properties - Citywide Union Wadding 448 Newport Avenue Pine Street Conant Street Manufacturing to Commercial General Added to Local Historic District Overlay Zone Change from Industrial Built Up to Commercial Downtown Change from Residential Single-Family to Residential Multi-family Designated as Mill Building Reuse Districts Designated as Mill Building Reuse Districts Source: Department of Planning and Redevelopment, 2011 As expected with a City as developed as Pawtucket, there are some discrepancies between current land use and current zoning. Some of these discrepancies do not necessarily warrant a zone change. For example, the Comprehensive Plan does not advocate changing the zoning of existing non-conforming commercial uses within established residential neighborhoods. However, Table 1.6 lists the individual parcels which are proposed for a zone change. Table 1.6 Individual Property Zoning Map Amendments Property Description 660 Cottage Street Dartmouth Street Parcels were in manufacturing use, and within a Manufacturing Open zone surrounded by an Residential Two-Family neighborhood. Have since been converted to condominiums. Change to residential zoning would preclude future change back to manufacturing. Parcels were in manufacturing use, and within a Manufacturing Built-Up zone surrounded by an Residential Multi-Family neighborhood. Portions have since been converted to residential. Change to residential zoning would preclude future change back to manufacturing. Source: Department of Planning and Redevelopment, 2011 In 2009 the Broad Street Revitalization Plan was completed. One of the Action Items listed in this plan is the extension of the Commercial Downtown zone northward to the Central Falls border. This specific recommendation is shown on the Future Land Use Map and the Action Plan is incorporated into this Comprehensive Plan as Appendix B. 1- 12 Land Use 1- 13 Land Use 1- 14 Land Use 1- 15 Land Use The City of Pawtucket has two voluntary overlay districts – the Historic District (HD) designation and also the Mill Building Reuse District (MBRD) which was created to facilitate the redevelopment of vacant and abandoned mill buildings. Properties are continually added to these overlay districts according to the procedures outlines in the Zoning Ordinance. There are also a few areas that are not yet proposed for a specific rezone, but have been identified as needing some review and assessment and may in the future be recommended for rezoning. A. Train Station The City of Pawtucket has approval from the Federal Transit Administration to enter Preliminary Engineering and to study the potential impacts of a new Commuter Rail Station on the City. Although the actual construction of a Commuter Rail Station is still 5-10 years out, it is time for the City to begin considering whether the land use regulations surrounding the station site will support the type of redevelopment activity that it would like to see. B. Industrial Areas It is the future plan of the City to retain the existing industrial areas that are appropriate and viable. The Zoning Ordinance classifies industrial areas into two types. The first is manufacturing built-up (MB) which consists of established multi-story structures. The second is manufacturing open (MO) which consists of the newer areas with more vacant land. Very little of MB zoned land is vacant – 3.2 acres – while there are 119 acres of vacant land zoned MO. However, much of the vacant MO land is located in areas which are constrained by topography and wetlands. Specifically, much of this land is located along the Moshassuck Valley Canal which has been identified by the John H. Chaffee Blackstone Valley National Heritage Corridor Commission (JHCBVNHCC) as a resource worthy of preservation. It is therefore unclear as to how much land is available for new Industrial development. Preliminary analysis suggest that there is not very much, if any, but the City needs to review these zone districts and determine if and where any buildable industrial land exits, and consider rezoning the land that is not developable, because of environmental constraints, as open space. C. Consistency with Abutting Communities There are seven cities and towns that abut the boundaries of Pawtucket. These are Seekonk and Attleboro, Massachusetts, East Providence, Providence, North Providence, Lincoln, and Central Falls. In reviewing Pawtucket’s land use plan in comparison to the existing uses in the abutting communities, there was no obvious land use conflict discovered for Pawtucket’s proposed or existing land use activities. In most cases, there is a continuation of the same land use across the border. Each community was notified in writing of the Comprehensive Plan update. Eastern border Pawtucket’s eastern border is shared with Seekonk, Massachusetts. This border generally follows the Ten Mile River so for the most part Pawtucket is separated from Seekonk by the River and the surrounding sensitive land area. The exception is the 1- 16 Land Use Countryside neighborhood. This residential area is adjacent to a residentially zoned area in Seekonk. Northern Border Central Falls - Pawtucket’s downtown commercial area is bordered to the north by Central Falls. In the past few years, Pawtucket and Central Falls have collaborated on a number of planning efforts. First, the Broad Street Regeneration Initiative, which has been adopted as appendix to this plan. Also, Central Falls and Pawtucket have been working together to identify a location for the Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station. Finally, Pawtucket and Central Falls both worked to develop an appropriate solution which would facilitate the redevelopment of the Coats and Clark/Conant Thread Mill Complex, a 2 million square foot mill complex that sits half in Pawtucket and half in Central Falls. Both cities adopted a similar zoning overlay district which would allow more flexibility in terms of potential uses of this complex. Lincoln - The zoning and land use along the Pawtucket/Lincoln border are generally consistent with no plans for major changes. Attleboro, Massachusetts - The zoning and land use along the Pawtucket/Attleboro border are generally consistent with no plans for major changes. Western border Pawtucket shares its western border with the Town of North Providence. Most of this area is established residential neighborhoods, except for Mineral Spring Avenue (RI Route 15) which connects Pawtucket to North Providence. Southern Border The City of Pawtucket has been involved in the development of the Metro Bay Special Area Management Plan. Pawtucket worked with Providence, East Providence and Cranston on a plan for the coastal areas in these three communities. The process resulted in the development of the Urban Coastal Greenways Policy which provides the Coastal Resources Management Council with policies that are more appropriate to the urban coastal areas in the upper bay. Providence - Pawtucket and Providence share a portion of the Southern border and are connected by two major arterials – North Main Street, which becomes Pawtucket Avenue and Main Street in Pawtucket; and Hope Street, which becomes East Avenue in Pawtucket. The Neighborhood Plan Map for Mt. Hope and Blackstone summarizes the Comprehensive Plan for these areas of Providence. Generally, they are consistent with Pawtucket’s plans. Providence wants to limit the commercial expansion in the area around the Hope Street/East Avenue nexus. Pawtucket has a small area of Commercial Local zoning which corresponds to this commercial area and is surrounded by the Oak Hill neighborhood. At the nexus of North Main Street, Main Street and Pawtucket Avenue, Providence has plans to promote the redevelopment along North Main Street. Pawtucket’s zoning in this area, Commercial General, supports these plans. East Providence - East Providence is located along Pawtucket’s southern border, east of the Pawtucket River. East Providence is also connected to Pawtucket along the Ten Mile River. Below, the Special Area Management Plan discusses Pawtucket’s 1- 17 Land Use connections to East Providence and Providence along the River. Pawtucket and East Providence have been working together on the Ten Mile River Bikeway. The East Providence section has been completed, and Pawtucket is working over the next few years on its next segment. D. Summary of Other Plans/Projects From 2005 to 2011 there were a number of planning studies conducted that targeted specific geographic areas, or specific subject areas. These are listed and summarized below. The goals and recommendations of these plans have been integrated into this plan. • Metro Bay Special Area Management Plan The City of Pawtucket worked with the communities of Pawtucket, Providence, East Providence and Cranston and the University of Rhode Island Coastal Resources Center on the Metro Bay Special Area Management Plan (SAMP). This plan helped to categorize the coastal land in Pawtucket, and also proposed Coastal Resources Management Council regulations that are more appropriate to the highly developed MetroBay region. • Broad Street Regeneration Plan The Broad Street Regeneration Plan included the communities of Pawtucket, Central Falls and Cumberland. The Plan focused on how to revitalize the Broad Street commercial corridor, and has led to other funding opportunities for Environmental Assessments and loans for façade improvements. The Executive Summary of the Broad Street Regeneration Initiative Action Plan is appended to this document, as Appendix C. • Downtown Circulation Study Pawtucket received a Challenge Grant in 2010 to take a comprehensive look at circulation and land use within the Downtown. The major findings are summarized in Appendix D. • Pawtucket Hazard Mitigation Plan The City’s Hazard Mitigation Plan was updated at the same time as the Comprehensive Plan. The recommendations of this Plan are included in Appendix E. 1- 18 Land Use SOURCES City of Pawtucket, “Land Use Element”, 1995, 2005. City of Pawtucket, Tax Assessor’s Data Base, 2002, 2009. City of Pawtucket, “Zoning Ordinance”. City Planning Commission, “Capital Improvements Program, 2011-2015”. Pawtucket Riverfront Commission, “Riverfront Development Plan: A New Vision for Pawtucket,” 1997. Rhode Island Department of Administration, “State Guide Plan Overview,” Report 101, June 2001. Rhode Island Department of Administration, “Rhode Island Population Projections,” October 1999. U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, Census of Population and Housing: 1970, 1980, 1990, 2000. 1- 19 City of Pawtucket, Rhode Island Comprehensive Community Plan 2011 Update Chapter 2 – HOUSING Table of Contents I. Goals, Policies, and Actions 2-1 II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis 2-2 III. Summary of Major Issues 2-16 Sources 2-18 Housing I. Goals, Policies, and Actions Goals Objectives Policies Actions 1. Provide Pawtucket residents from all socio-economic groups with safe, decent and affordable housing. 1. Increase the amount of affordable units by 42 in 5 years. 1. Ensure that a consistent portion of the City’s rental housing stock remains affordable and is in compliance with the provisions of the State of Rhode Island Low and Moderate Income Housing Act. H 1 Investigate housing resources that are available to assist moderate-income homebuyers. 2. Reduce the number of illegal and substandard units. 2. Protect the City’s residential neighborhoods by preventing encroachment from other non-residential land uses and discouraging increased density. 2. Ensure that residential growth does not adversely affect environmental, recreational and cultural resources. 3. Protect the quality of life and character within established residential neighborhoods. 3. Promote the de-concentration of affordable housing. 3. Maintain or reduce densities in established residential neighborhoods. 4. Increase the number of units for special needs population by 5 units in 5 years. 5. Reduce the number of vacant/abandoned houses in residential neighborhoods. 6. Expand homeownership in all neighborhoods. 4. Support appropriately scaled housing that meets the needs of the displaced and homeless population as well as the development of transitional housing. 5. Investigate opportunities to convert underutilized and/or obsolete commercial/industrial structures to residential use. 6. Promote and enforce the federal Fair Housing Law throughout the City. 7. Continue to work with the existing network of nonprofits to develop support services and appropriately scaled permanent supportive housing for the homeless, disabled and other special needs populations. 8. Continue efforts to eliminate lead hazards in Pawtucket’s housing stock. 9. Ensure that the Minimum Housing Department has the necessary resources to enforce the minimum housing code. 10. Assist neighborhood clean-up efforts by supplying waste removal and regular street cleaning. H 2 Utilize HOME funds to provide affordable housing opportunities to low and moderate-income persons and families. H 3 Create a complete brochure and also website for all housing related opportunities for Pawtucket residents including homeownership, rental opportunities, elderly housing and housing rehabilitation. H 4 Revise the Zoning Ordinance to offer better neighborhood protection. Consider: Density controls using lot coverage; Enforcement of the merger clause; Discourage conversions of residential uses to non-residential uses in established residential neighborhoods. H 5 Support the efforts of Pawtucket neighborhood advocacy groups including neighborhood associations and crime watch groups. H 6 Acquire vacant and abandoned properties to stabilize neighborhoods. H 7 Analyze 2010 Census information to determine areas of the City where there are concentrations of poverty and develop programs targeting assistance to those areas. H 8 Investigate the use of Pawtucket Housing Authority funding to rework Prospect and Galego housing developments into mixed-income developments. H 9 Assist neighborhood clean-up efforts by supplying waste removal and regular street cleaning. H 10 Allow the subdivision of lots with two existing primary structures into undersized lots. 2 -1 Housing II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis A. Requirements The Comprehensive Planning and Land Use Regulation Act requires that the comprehensive plan reflect its goals, objectives and policies for housing, as well as other elements. At a minimum, the City’s housing policies must address the following: • • • • Upgrading deteriorating and substandard housing; Providing new housing opportunities geared to the needs of all elements of the population; Identifying steps to enhance the affordability of housing and identifying resources to be used in this regard; Identifying resources and steps designed to achieve housing goals and implement housing policies: o Specific steps to enhance housing affordability; o Municipal agency responsible for housing; o Code and ordinance changes and innovations to encourage achievement of housing goals; o Public and private resources to be utilized in achievement of housing goals; o Sites for housing development (location and types); o Potential conversion of existing structures to housing use; and o Financial strategies to be developed for housing. B. Historic Overview Residential development in Pawtucket began in the late 17th Century with the arrival of a few farming families and later by families who were more commercially oriented. Joseph Jenks, in 1671 purchased 60 acres of land on the west side of the Blackstone River and started an iron forge. A small industrial village had formed by 1720, but only two of the houses from this era survived. Two-thirds of the housing was built before World Was II and most were concentrated around the mills in the center of the City. Much of Pawtucket’s housing stock built during that era (1874-1920) consists of three-story wooden structures. Almost 50 percent of Pawtucket’s housing stock is made up of these multifamily structures. The emphasis of residential development in Pawtucket and in most of the country, shifted to lower density single-family units after World War II. A combination of federal housing policies affecting public housing authorities and private developers resulted in the construction of five high-rise apartments for senior citizens in and around the downtown area since 1960. Although the emphasis remains on single-family homes, in the past ten years mill buildings have been converted into residential apartments and condominiums. 2- 2 Housing C. Trends Much of Pawtucket’s land area is developed. Because so little vacant land remains, much of the residential building occurring today takes the form of infill development. Table 2.1 shows the number of housing units in Pawtucket in from 1970-2008. Since 1970, the number of housing units has increased by almost 4,000. However, most of that growth occurred prior to 1990. From 1990 to 2008 the number has remained relatively stable. In fact, the 2008 projections show a decrease of almost 200 units. Table 2.1 Housing Units 1970-2008 1970 1980 1990 2000 2008 27,819 31,615 31,819 31,673 Total 29,763 Source: 2008 American Community Survey and Census 1970, 1980, 1990, 2000 The ratio of single –family to multi-family in Pawtucket is consistent with that of other central cities in that there is a higher percentage of multifamily units. According to Table 2.2, among the four other cities in Rhode Island of comparable size, Pawtucket has the second lowest percentage of single-family housing at 37%. Table 2.2 Units in Structure, 2008 Units in Structure Total 1 Detached 1 Attached 2 Units 3-4 Units 5-9 Units 10-19 Units 20 -49 Units 50+ Units Mobile Homes Boat, RV, etc. Cranston 32,087 20,095 749 4,674 2,564 631 731 894 1,712 37 0 % 63 2 15 8 2 2 3 5 0 0 East Providence 20,756 10,722 447 3,036 2,166 943 891 873 1,579 99 0 % 52 2 15 10 5 4 4 8 0 0 Pawtucket 31,673 10,850 914 5,526 8,337 2,816 1,013 732 1,097 346 42 % 34 3 17 26 9 3 2 3 01 0 Providence 69,011 15,199 2,667 14,420 21,213 4,676 2,525 1,735 6,430 0 146 % 22 4 21 31 7 4 3 9 0 0 Warwick 37,346 26,939 845 1,609 1,162 930 2,622 1,567 1,503 169 0 Source: 2008 American Community Survey In 1980, 221 units were classified as mobile homes. This category grew to 737 in 1990. Manufactured homes are included as “other” and would account for a large portion of the increase in this unit group. The number of mobile homes in 1990 was actually approximately 375. In 2000, the number of mobile homes grew to 452. D. Residential Buildout Analysis Every community has a carrying capacity for development. The buildout analysis is a method of determining how much development is feasible in a given area based on the existing land use controls. Theoretically, that capacity is reached when every buildable parcel of land is subdivided so that it satisfies the minimum zoning requirements and is then built on. This analysis assumes that all developable land will be developed over time. The buildout analysis presents a scenario, based on pre-set assumptions, of the amount and type of development a community can support. The analysis considers existing land 2- 3 % 72 2 4 3 2 7 4 4 0 0 Housing use, undeveloped land, and the number of housing units permitted by the Zoning Ordinance. Although data from the City Assessor indicates that there were approximately 161 acres of land classified as residential vacant in 2009, other evidence suggests that the City of Pawtucket is actually very close to buildout in terms of new development. In theory a total of 1,402 legal lots could be divided from the residentially zoned vacant land in Pawtucket. However, some of the smaller lots are not contiguous and therefore do not have enough land area to support a new structure. Also, some of the lots have been merged with the undersized lots with a structure that are contiguous and in common ownership which also prevents some vacant lots from becoming buildable. Therefore, the actual number of units which might be built in the future on the remaining 161 acres of vacant land is likely to be considerably smaller. In 2007 the Planning Department conducted an analysis of vacant residential land in the City of Pawtucket. Using assessor’s data and GIS, they made a preliminary determination of which of these lots would be merged with adjacent lots because of an area or frontage nonconformity. The analysis determined that approximately 133 acres of this vacant residential land was not buildable. This analysis did not take into account topography or wetland issues, so it is a reasonable assumption that the 30 “buildable” acres would be further constrained. Assuming that half of the “buildable” land can indeed be built upon, that would leave 15 acres, upon which would result in approximately 130 5,000 square foot lots. Based on these assumptions, Pawtucket’s population at buildout capacity would be approximately 330 people (130 units x 2.541,). However, this analysis does not take into account redevelopment. The Pawtucket Mill Building Survey identifies just under 100 mills of varying sizes within City limits. The redevelopment of these structures normally requires relief from the City Zoning ordinance to allow more dense redevelopment, with less parking than would be allowed with new residential development. Without this flexibility, these structures, which are now inappropriate for large-scale industrial use, would remain vacant and under-utilized. As noted in a previous section, the density of recent redevelopments ranged from 17 to over 100 units per acre while zoning allows approximately 12 units per acre. E. Housing Market Area Pawtucket is part of the Metropolitan Core housing market area. The Metropolitan Core housing market area defined by the State Housing Plan consists of older, intensively urbanized central cities of Providence, Pawtucket, Central Falls, Cranston, East Providence, Johnston and North Providence. These cities all have older highly developed areas as well as less intensively developed suburban areas. Table 2.3 shows the total number of housing units in the seven Metropolitan Core communities. Pawtucket is ranked third in the market area for total housing units. Pawtucket’s share of the Core housing market area has decreased slightly since 1980. It accounted for 17.4 percent of the Core area’s housing in both 1980 and 1990 and 17 percent in 2008. Cranston and North Providence gained the most housing since 1980. The American Community Survey estimates show Pawtucket, East Providence and North Providence all losing some housing units between 2000 and 2008. However, data from the Building Department indicates that there actually has been an increase of 249 1 average household size in Pawtucket according to the 2005-2007 American Community Survey 3-Year Estimate 2- 4 Housing units from 2000 to 2008 (See Table 2.4). The reason for this discrepancy could be that the American Community Survey projections do not address the recent conversion of mills into residential units. Table 2.3 Housing Units in the Metropolitan Core, 1980-2008 1980 1990 2000 Cranston 27,239 30,516 32,068 East Providence 19,396 20,808 21,309 Pawtucket 29,763 31,615 31,819 Providence 67,513 66,794 67,915 Johnston 8,724 10,384 11,567 Central Falls 7,446 7,337 7,270 North 11,343 14,134 14,867 Providence Total 171,424 181,588 186,815 2008 32,087 20,756 31,673 69,011 11712 NA 14,740 187,249* Source: 2008 American Community Survey and Census 1970, 1980, 1990, 2000. *Total for 2008 assumes that Central Falls is the same as 2000. Table 2.4 New Units Added 1990-2008 Year Units New Units 1990 31,615 74 1991 31,639 64 1992 31,679 123 1993 31,776 21 1994 31,779 21 1995 31,787 15 1996 31,778 35 1997 31,790 35 1998 31,810 25 1999 31,815 22 2000 31,815 18 2001 31,819 18 2002 31,819 50 2003 31,856 82 2004 31,928 39 2005 31,951 61 2006 32,005 42 2007 32,036 22 2008 32,055 22 Demolished 50 24 26 18 13 24 23 15 20 22 14 18 13 10 16 7 11 3 9 Total 31,639 31,679 31,776 31,779 31,787 31,778 31,790 31,810 31,815 31,815 31,819 31,819 31,856 31,928 31,951 32,005 32,036 32,055 32,068 Change 24 40 97 3 8 -9 12 20 5 0 4 0 37 72 23 54 31 19 13 source: Pawtucket Department of Building and Code Enforcement, 2009 F. Household Formation Table 2.5 describes how the various household types in Pawtucket have changed over time. The number of households is projected to have fallen approximately 5% from 1990 to 2008. The number of female-headed households is projected to have grown almost 30% from 1990 to 2008. The number of householders older than 65 is projected to 2- 5 Housing increase substantially as well while the number of married couple families is projected to fall almost 25%. Table 2.5 Household Types in Pawtucket, 1990-2008 Total Households Family Households Married Couple Families Male Householder Female Householder Non-family Households Householders Living Alone Householder 65 Years + 1990 2000 2008 29,711 19,162 13,932 1,152 4,078 10,549 9,081 30,047 18,520 11,923 1,557 5,040 11,527 9,700 28,015 16,961 10,471 1,217 5,273 11,054 9006 % Change 1990-2008 -5.71% -11.49% -24.84% 5.64% 29.30% 4.79% -0.83% 4,001 3,756 5,419 35.44% Source: Census 1990, 2000 and American Community Survey 2008 G. Districts For the purposes of Comprehensive Planning in Pawtucket, eight planning districts were established. Figure 2.1 illustrates the eight different districts. District boundaries conform to census tract boundaries and where possible conform to perceived neighborhoods. Table 2.6 illustrates the estimated number of housing units by planning district for Pawtucket in 1990 and 2000. Data is not yet available at the census tract level from the American Community Survey. Table 2.6 Housing Units by Planning District, 1990-2000 District 1990 % of Total 2000 1 2,899 9.2% 2,950 2 5,924 18.8% 5,868 3 2,487 7.9% 2,590 4 1,851 5.9% 1,751 5 3,603 11.4% 3,698 6 3,347 10.6% 3,486 7 7,275 23.1% 7,409 8 4,136 13.1% 4,067 31,522 31,819 % of Total 9.3% 18.4% 8.1% 5.5% 11.6% 11% 23.3% 12.8% % Change 1.8% -1% 4% -5.5% 2.6% 4% 1.9% -1.7% 1% Source: Census 2000 District 1/Fairlawn District 1 includes census tracts150 and 163 located in the western part of the City. It includes the Fairlawn section of the City. Housing in this District is primarily single family with the exception of a number of blocks in the northern Fairlawn area, which is mostly two-family structures. Homeownership is more prevalent in Darlington than in the City at-large - 54% versus 44%. The Neighborhood Analysis prepared for the City of Pawtucket determined that Darlington is generally a white working and middle-class neighborhood. 2- 6 Housing District 2/Woodlawn District 2 encompasses the Woodlawn neighborhood, and includes census tracts 151, 161, and 164. Woodlawn is one of the denser, lower-income neighborhoods within the City and also holds over 20% of the City’s population. Housing in this district is dominated by multi-family structures with some exceptions along the southern and western portions of the neighborhood. Woodlawn also has one of the lowest homeownership and auto-ownership rates in the City. District 3/Oak Hill and West Riverview District 3 includes census tracts 165 and 166 and encompassed the area east of Pawtucket Avenue to the Pawtucket/Blackstone River. The two neighborhoods which make up this district are very different. West Riverview is characterized by younger, minority families. Oak Hill on the other hand, has a significantly higher average annual income than the City-wide figure. District 4/Barton Street and Downtown District 4 includes census tract 152 and generally conforms to the central business district (CBD). District 4 has the smallest supply of housing units in the City with 1,751 units, 5.5% of the units in the City. The Barton Street neighborhood was separated from the Downtown as part of the efforts of the City and the Pawtucket Citizens Development Corporation on neighborhood improvements and affordable housing. Downtown has very few residents – less than 800 according to the 2000 Census – and many of these units are located within subsidized housing structures, including two large senior citizens apartment towers. Barton Street, however, is the most dense neighborhood in the City. The neighborhood can also be characterized as low-income. District 5/Pleasant View District 5 includes census tracts 153, 154, and 160 and lies in the north central part of the City between the Blackstone River and the Industrial Highway. This district, known as the Pleasant View neighborhood, is dominated by multi-family residential development. District 5 had 3,603 units in 1990 and 3,698 units in 2000. District 5 comprises 11.6% of the City’s total housing units. District 6/East Riverview and Quality Hill and Beverage Hill/Plains District 6 includes census tracts 167 and 171 and lies south of Walcott Street and Armistice Boulevard between the Blackstone River and the Industrial Highway. This district is comprised predominately of multi-family residential development but does have an area of single-family units in its southern portion. District 6 had 3,347 units in 1990 and 3,486 units in 2000, a 4% increase. All neighborhoods have demographics which are similar to Pawtucket’s City-wide statistics. The Quality Hill neighborhood is differentiated because it is a district on the National Register of Historic Places. The East Riverview designation was created to describe a Redevelopment area. 2- 7 Housing 2- 8 Housing District 7/Darlington and Pinecrest District 7 includes census tracts 155, 156, 157, 158, and 159 and lies to the north of Armistice Boulevard between the Industrial Highway and the City’s eastern border with Seekonk, Massachusetts. This district, being the largest in area, also has the largest supply of residential units. Single-family development is found generally east of Newport Avenue and particularly within Pinecrest. District 7 grew by only 1.9% in the 1990’s. According to the 2000 Census Neighborhood Analysis, Darlington, like Pawtucket as a whole, is primarily white and working and middle-class. Pinecrest is one of the most rural sections of Pawtucket and the incomes of Pinecrest residents is approximately $10,000 higher than City averages. District 8/Slater Park and Countryside District 8 includes census tracts 168, 169 and 170 and lies to the south of Armistice Boulevard between the Industrial Highway and the City’s eastern border with Seekonk, Massachusetts. This district is the second largest in area but is ranked third in number of housing units primarily because most of the structures are single-family dwellings. Both Slater Park and Countryside have higher average annual household and family incomes than the rest of Pawtucket. H. Occupancy The majority of housing units in Pawtucket are multi-family, renter occupied units. The percentage of owner and renter occupied units has been relatively stable, with renter occupied just under 50% and owner occupied units just over 50%. Table 2.7 Occupancy, 1980 - 2000 Owner Occupied Renter Occupied Total Occupied 1980 13,103 15,044 28,147 46.6% 53.4% 1990 13,619 16,092 29,711 45.9% 54.1% 2000 13,331 16,716 30,047 2008 44.4% 55.6% 13,152 0.47 14,863 0.53 28,015 Source: Census 2000, American Community Survey 2008 I. Vacancy Pawtucket’s vacancy rate had been rising, 4.2 percent in 1970 to 5.4 percent in 1980 to 6.0 percent in 1990. 2000 showed a slight decrease in the vacancy rate to 5.6 percent. However, in 2008 the vacancy rate was estimated to more than double the figure from 2000. This dramatic increase is attributable to the high number of foreclosures. The vacancy rate for the State of Rhode Island in 2008 was estimated to be 11 percent. However, the rates for the bigger cities – like Providence and Pawtucket – are much higher than most other communities. In 2008 the vacancy rate in Providence was estimated to be 14 %. Even in the other core metropolitan communities – Cranston, Johnston, East Providence and North Providence – the vacancy rate ranged from 3 to 6 percent. 2- 9 Housing Table 2.8 Vacancy, 1980 – 2008 1980 # Vacant Units 1,616 Vacancy Rate 5.4 1990 1,904 6.0 2000 1,772 5.6 2008 3,658 12.1 Source: Census 2000, American Community Survey 2008 J. Age and Condition of Housing Units Fifty-four percent of Pawtucket’s housing units were built before 1940 and another 32 percent were built before 1960. Only 2.7 percent of the City’s housing stock has been added since 1990. The median year built for a structure in Pawtucket is 1939, compared to 1956 statewide, and 1974 nationally (2008 American Community Survey). Table 2.9 Age Distribution of Housing Stock Year Built # of Units Built 2005 or later Built 2000 to 2004 Built 1990 to 1999 Built 1980 to 1989 Built 1970 to 1979 Built 1960 to 1969 Built 1950 to 1959 Built 1940 to 1949 Built 1939 or earlier All Houses 81 133 557 1,614 2,008 2,324 4,058 3,677 17,221 31,673 % of Total 0.26% 0.42% 2% 5% 6% 7% 13% 12% 54% Source: American Community Survey, 2008 Since the majority of Pawtucket’s housing stock was built before 1970, lead paint is a serious issue facing the City. The Pawtucket Lead Safe Program is funded by HUD’s Office of Healthy Homes and Lead Hazard Control and is run in conjunction with Blackstone Valley Community Action Program, Inc. The Pawtucket Lead Safe Program provides financial assistance to qualified property owners to reduce lead hazards in their property. Deferred payment loans are offered and there is minimal cost to the homeowners until the property is sold or transferred. The goal of the program is to increase the number of lead-safe housing units in Pawtucket. K. Substandard, Overcrowded and Abandoned Housing Substandard housing as defined by the U.S. Census is any unit lacking complete plumbing facilities for exclusive use. In 2008, 0.5 percent (149 units) of all occupied units in Pawtucket lacked complete plumbing. Urban center such as Pawtucket typically have a greater percentage of substandard housing because of the age of the housing stock. Housing is considered overcrowded if there is more than one person per room. In 2008, approximately 733 units or 3 percent of all housing units in Pawtucket were considered overcrowded according to this criterion. 2 -10 Housing The City of Pawtucket, like many other urban communities, has been concerned with the increasing number of vacant, abandoned, or substandard properties and how to eliminate them. In 1995, the City successfully lobbied the Rhode Island General Assembly to expand the powers of its Housing Court. The housing court judge now has the ability to find an individual in contempt of court for failing to comply with a specific judicial order. Additionally, the judge now has the right to order properties into receivership, forcing owners to act quickly or lose their property. The judge has also been given the ability to order the removal of any cloud on the title to a building or property that has been ordered into receivership. This added authority has greatly strengthened the enforcement process because the City no longer has to petition the Superior Court to gain clear title of the property. Since its declaration, more than 250 abandoned or vacant properties have been removed from the City’s abandoned/vacant property list. This program was nationally recognized by Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government through its selection as an “Innovations in American Government” semifinalist. L. Affordability of Housing Affordability is most simply defined as housing cost to household income ratio. An affordable home is one that is within the means of a household at any income level paying 30 percent of household income for housing expenses. The federal HUD guidelines for assistance, those used by the City, are as follows: Table 2.10 2010 Federal Income Guidelines Moderate Income (80% of median) Low Income (60% of median) 1 Person $40,400 2 Person $46,200 3 Person $51,950 4 Person $57,700 5 Person $62,350 6 Person $66,950 7 Person $71,550 8 Person $76,200 $30,300 $34,620 $38,940 $43,260 $46,740 $50,220 $53,700 $57,120 Housing and Urban Development, 2010 According to Housing Works RI the median selling price of a single family house in Pawtucket was approximately $177,000 in 2008. The typical monthly mortgage payment for the median priced house would be $1,358 and the household income required to afford those payments would be $54,315. The average monthly rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Pawtucket in 2008 was $1.068, and the household income required for that rent to be affordable is $42,720. In 2009, the average private sector wage for jobs in Pawtucket was $36,504 and so the average monthly rent for a two-bedroom apartment or a median-priced home would not be affordable (Housing Works RI 2009 Fact Book). M. Federally Funded Housing Federally Subsidized Housing Units In Pawtucket, there are eighteen (18) developments that are insured and/or subsidized by the US Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). 2 -11 Housing Table 2.11 Subsidized Housing Units Facility Centennial Tower Geneva Plaza Apartments Lawn Terrace Lonsdale Senior Housing Northern Plaza Riverview Terrace Slater Hill Taylor Building Towers East Woodlawn Gardens (Elderly) Woodlawn Gardens (Family) Vincent J. Doyle Manor Burns Manor Galego Court St. Germain Manor John E. Fogarty Housing John F. Kennedy Housing Prospect Heights Total Elderly/Handicapped 101 149 130 101 81 104 86 148 31 83 92 112 248 171 1669 Family Units 100 48 44 161 292 626 Source: Pawtucket Housing Authority, 2010 To qualify for these units, applicants must fit into the HUD established “lower” income limit of $40,400 for 1 person, $46,200 for 2 people, $51,950 for 3 people and $57,700 for 4 people, or “very low” income limit of $25,250 for 1 person, $28,850 for 2 people, $32,450 for 3 people, $36,050 for 4 people. The Rhode Island General Assembly has enacted legislation, Chapter 45-25 that allows cities to establish local public housing authorities. A local public housing authority was created in Pawtucket in the early 1940’s. The five-person authority, whose members are appointed by the Mayor, has entered into an agreement with the Department of Housing and Urban Development to construct and manage public housing. At this time, the Pawtucket Housing Authority manages six housing complexes for a total of 453 units for families and 623 units for elderly and handicapped. Housing Investment Partnership Program (HOME) The City of Pawtucket Department of Planning and Redevelopment receives HOME funding from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). There are currently several initiatives in place to improve housing conditions for low and moderate-income residents in the City of Pawtucket. The Pawtucket Starter HOME Program provides down payment and closing costs grants to low and moderate-income first-time homebuyers to purchase a home in the City of Pawtucket. This grant can be used for down payment and closing costs on a newly purchased Pawtucket property. A maximum $7,000 in grant assistance is available for the purchase of a multi-family property in the target neighborhoods of Woodlawn and Pleasant View. Up to $5,000 in grant assistance is for the purchase of a multi-family property anywhere in the City of Pawtucket. A maximum of $3,000 is grant assistance is available for the purchase of a single-family property anywhere in the City. 2 -12 Housing Blackstone Valley Community Action Program (BVCAP) is the lead agency in the Pawtucket Starter HOME Program and provides continuous support through the home buying process. BVCAP offers technical assistance with all paperwork, assists with the mortgage process, and offers Homebuyer Education classes in several languages. The Pawtucket Starter HOME Program has assisted more than 495 families to acquire a home in the City of Pawtucket since its inception in 1994. HOME funds are also used to provide grant assistance to Pawtucket Citizens Development Corporation (PCDC) and BVCAP to acquire and rehabilitate abandoned or substantially distressed housing. These local non-profit agencies also receive administration funds because they are registered Community Housing Development Organizations (CHDO). Homes that are acquired by PCDC or BVCAP are sold to qualified first time homebuyers or are rented to low to moderate income families at an affordable rate and managed by the agency. Housing Rehabilitation Assistance – The Pawtucket Redevelopment Agency (PRA) offers low interest and deferred loans to eligible borrowers in order to provide decent, safe and affordable housing for the residents of Pawtucket. Loans up to $10,000 are available per dwelling unit. These loans encourage homeowners to make improvements and have pride in their homes. The Pawtucket Redevelopment Agency’s Residential Rehabilitation Loan Program, Elderly Paint Program, and the Lead Hazard Control Program, provides direct loans and grants to low and moderate-income property owners to rehabilitate and improve their property. This program has been on going for over twenty years. The Pawtucket Redevelopment Agency has also been making efforts to expand the availability of housing to low and moderate-income residents by making vacant parcels and buildable lots available to the Blackstone Valley Community Action Program and Pawtucket Citizens Development Corporation to construct to new homes for low and moderate-income buyers. N. Rhode Island Housing Pawucket residents are eligible for Rhode Island Housing’s low-interest loans and products for first-time homebuyers. If there are one or two people within a household, they may earn up to $87,800* (combined gross annual income) to qualify. Households of three or more people may earn up to $102,400*. O. At Risk Subsidized Housing The Low Income Housing Preservation and Resident Homeownership Act of 1990 was enacted to provide a solution of the termination of Section 8 projects whose mortgages are eligible for prepayment. The Act requires that owners of eligible property file a notice of intent with HUD, state and local government, stating they are going to terminate lowincome restrictions and seek fair market rents for their units. Tenants must also be informed of the owners’ filing. Owners seeking to prepay the mortgage, transfer the 2 -13 Housing project to a qualified purchaser, terminate the low-income restrictions, or extend the affordability restrictions must file a Plan of Action with HUD, tenants, and state and local government. There are 738 units in Pawtucket that are Section 8 and have Housing Assistance Payment (HAP) contracts. P. Homeless As one of the Rhode Island's core urban communities, the City of Pawtucket has a proportionate share of the state's number of individuals classifying themselves as "homeless". According to the Rhode Island Emergency Shelter Information Project Annual Report for 1998-99, the City of Pawtucket was listed third behind Providence and Cranston as the city of last residence by individuals who availed themselves of homeless assistance services. Again, according to the aforementioned report, the single biggest cause of homelessness in Rhode Island is the lack of affordable housing. Rhode Island is recognized as among the least affordable rental markets in the entire country. The City of Pawtucket is one of three municipalities (Providence, Woonsocket) that, along with the State of Rhode Island, receive an annual allocation of federal "Emergency Shelter Grant" funds to both assist in preventing persons from becoming homeless and assist those persons who are homeless with basic shelter needs. The 2009-2010 "Emergency Shelter Grant" (ESG) to the City of Pawtucket was $90,687. In addition to the city's ESG resources, Pawtucket's homeless providers access Community Development Block Grant (CDBG), HUD Supportive Services, and state homeless assistance monies as well as private sources of funds. Listed below are brief descriptions of the homeless assistance providers, which service the Pawtucket area. New Hope Shelter (former Emergency Shelter of Pawtucket and Central Falls) The Emergency Shelter of Pawtucket and Central Falls located in Pawtucket operates ten unit (10) transitional housing apartments. It provides a comprehensive set of services for homeless individuals designed to move them toward independent living situations. In 2009-2010, the City of Pawtucket provided $50,000 in Emergency Shelter Grant funding to help support the operating of the shelter. Blackstone Shelter The Blackstone Advocacy Center, located in Central Falls, provides domestic violence services to women and children in the Blackstone Valley. The Center provides a twentyone (21) bed shelter for women and children in crisis as well as a full complement of supportive services. In addition, the Center also offers three (3) transitional housing apartments in an adjacent property. In 2009-2010, the City of Pawtucket provided $31,153 in Emergency Shelter Grant funding for general operations. Q. Special Needs Housing Historically, housing options for the handicapped have been limited. Pawtucket has been working as a cooperative partner to provide independent group homes for the mentally and physically challenged. According to Rhode Island Housing, as of May 2009, there were approximately 2,419 group home beds in the state of Rhode Island. Pawtucket comprises about 5.6% of the total available beds (136 beds available in 2 -14 Housing residential facilities under 16). The only communities with a higher percentage of the total are Cranston (7%), Providence (13.2%), and Woonsocket (7.1%) The Pawtucket Zoning Ordinance was revised in 1994 to conform to the State Enabling Legislation allowing community residences in all residential and commercial districts, as well as one industrial district. The Zoning Ordinance also allows for rooming house units by special use permit. HOME funds provide a partial rental voucher for low-income clients through the Blackstone Valley Chapter of the Rhode Island Association of Retarded Citizens (RIARC). Clients pay 30% of their income towards their rent and HOME funded assistance pays the difference. This program assists special needs adults to live independently with the support of a local social service agency. Another program run by the City is the Removal of Architectural Barriers Program that provides funding and technical assistance to income eligible residents to install handicapped ramps at their residence. R. Low and Moderate Income Housing In 2009, a total of 8.57% of Pawtucket’s housing units were considered “low or moderate income” according to the Rhode Island General Laws2. There is an alternative calculation that also determines whether the municipality falls under the jurisdiction of the State Housing Appeals Board: “in the case of an urban city or town which has at least 5,000 occupied rental units and the units, as reported in the decennial census of the city or town, comprise twenty-five percent (25%) or more the housing units, is in excess of fifteen percent (15%) of the total occupied rental units. Pawtucket meets this alternative standard for determining the jurisdiction of the State Housing Appeals Board.” (The Rhode Island Low and Moderate Income Housing Act, March 2000). S. At Risk Populations Indicators of housing need are widely varied and are dependant upon the particular demand group. These groups may include homeless, young families, disabled persons, first time homebuyers, the elderly, single parents, etc. In Pawtucket, the following need groups (among others) can be identified: Low Income In Pawtucket, there are individuals and families who are unable to afford the high costs of housing and rely upon subsidy programs for assistance. Identifying the at-risk groups 2 (1) subsidized by the federal or state government under any program to assist the construction or rehabilitation of low and moderate income housing as defined in the applicable federal or state statute, and (2) built or operated by: (a) any public agency or nonprofit organization or limited equity housing cooperative, or (b) private developer of low and oderateincome rental housing that remains low and moderate-income housing for a period of not less than thirty (30) years from initial occupancy; (3) in which any non-residential component of the proposed development is secondary to the overall proposal, but in no even shall the non-residential component exceed the lower of: (a) the non-residential proportion or other measure allowed pursuant to the development’s proposed funding sources; or (b) twenty-five (25%) of the gross square footage of the proposed development. (4) accept tenant-based rental assistance, mortgages and mortgage insurance where there is no construction or rehabilitation under a state or federal program (Rhode Island Low and Moderate Income Housing Act, March 2000) 2 -15 Housing involves determining the number of individuals and/or families participating in the following programs: Family Independence Program (FIP), Food Stamps Program, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), and General Public Assistance (GPA). It is estimated that families in the very low and low-income brackets make up close to 38% percent of the City’s families. Approximately 14.9 percent of the City’s families are below the poverty level and 16.8 percent (12,131 individuals) of the City’s total population is below the poverty level. Individuals and families in these income groups require additional affordable units and more housing subsidies. Moderate Income The moderate-income population consists of those households earning between 80 to 100 percents of the median household income. The actual number of people in this income range is not known. Estimates indicate that moderate-income families constitute close to 15 percent of Pawtucket’s families. Assistance in purchasing a first home is needed for individuals and families in this income bracket. Elderly Pawtucket does offer a tax abatement for its elderly residents to assist in keeping in elderly residents in their own homes. Smaller rental units affordable to people on fixed incomes are needed for this segment of the population. Homeless It is not possible to obtain an accurate number of homeless persons living within Pawtucket at any one time. Housing costs have been on the rise and are prohibitively high for many individuals and families with marginal employment. This coupled with poor economic times will likely lead to an increase in the number of homeless in Pawtucket and surrounding communities. Additional shelter space and programs designed to get people back into an independent or semi-independent housing situation are needed. III. Summary of Major Issues Pawtucket has met the alternative standard for “low and moderate income housing” but the provision of affordable housing will continue to be a primary goal of the City. The present economic condition of the State and New England in general has led to a number of foreclosures. Many of the foreclosed properties are multi-family units so many of the City’s renters have been displaced. Although it may seem that the availability of vacant housing would be an opportunity to provide affordable housing, this has not been the case. Lending has become severely restricted and the City still struggles to provide affordable housing for all of its residents. Following is a summary of the type of housing that is most needed in Pawtucket: • Housing for the homeless. The two local emergency shelters have a combined capacity of less than 50 beds. • Housing for the population of mentally ill persons who find themselves in crisis. 2 -16 Housing • Additional affordable rental units and additional subsidies are needed for families in the very low and low-income brackets. • Continued assistance in purchasing a first home for individuals and families in the moderate-income bracket. • Continued subsidies and assistance to keep elderly residents in their own homes. Households headed by persons over 65 increased from 2000 to 2008 and is anticipated to continue to grow. Smaller rental units affordable to people on fixed incomes are also needed for this segment of the population. 2 -17 SOURCES Cassidy, Michael and Herbert Weiss, “Innovations in American Government, Award Application,” 2000. City of Pawtucket, Department of Building and Code Enforcement, 2009 City of Pawtucket, “Housing Element”, 1995, 2005 Housing and Urban Development, “Federal Housing and Community Development Programs, 2010 Income Guidelines,” May 2010. Housing and Urban Development, “Fair Market Rents,” 2010. Pawtucket Housing Authority, 2009 Rhode Island Department of Administration, “Economic Development Policies and Plan,” State Guide Plan Element 211, April 2000. Rhode Island Department of Administration, “State Housing Plan,” State Guide Plan Element 421, March 2000. Rhode Island Emergency Shelter Information Project, “Annual Report,” July 1. 1998June 30, 1999. Rhode Island Housing, “Community Residences for Mental Health, Retardation, Substance Abuse, and Children’s Services by RI City and Town,” May 2000. Rhode Island Housing, “Low and Moderate Income Housing by Community,” April 2009. Rhode Island Low and Moderate Income Housing Act, RIGL 45-53, March 2000. U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, Census of Population and Housing: 1970, 1980, 1990, 2000. American Community Survey 2008. 2-18 Economic Development City of Pawtucket, Rhode Island Comprehensive Community Plan 2011 Update Chapter 3 – ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT Table of Contents I. Goals, Policies, and Actions 3-1 II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis 3-2 III. Summary of Major Issues 3-11 Sources 3-12 3- 1 Economic Development I. Goals, Policies and Actions Goals Objectives Policies Actions 1. A strong, diverse and vital commercial downtown. 1. Decrease the amount of vacant square footage within downtown Pawtucket. 1. Support the maintenance and expansion of existing businesses in Pawtucket, especially within the downtown. ED 1 Seek funding sources and implement the Downtown Urban Design and Circulation Study. 2. Support and encourage policies that entice artists, art organizations and art institutions to relocate to Pawtucket ED 2 Prepare promotional marketing materials, including a portfolio of successful adaptive reuse projects and a specialized economic development web presence. 3. Provide the adequate infrastructure including utilities, roadways, and parking facilities, at appropriate locations for economic development activities. ED 3 Update the Redevelopment Plan. 4. Support the efforts of the Pawtucket Business Development Corporation (PBDC) in providing assistance to area businesses through low interest loans, information, and referrals, including the allocation of CDBG funding to PBDC for secondary low-interest loans to Pawtucket companies. ED 5 Improve visitor access to major attractions by developing and implementing a cohesive signage program. 2. A vibrant mixed-use riverfront. 3. Successful businesses within the manufacturing, health care, and artsrelated businesses. 4. A welleducated, prepared, workforce. 2. Increase the number of businesses in Pawtucket. 3. Increase the number of jobs in Pawtucket. ED 4 Improve the visibility and accessibility of downtown parking. ED 6 Develop a list of vacant downtown buildings, which identifies the code and other issues that need to be addressed. ED 7 Establish a regular local business visitation program. 4. Increase the number of high paying jobs in Pawtucket within the manufacturing, health care and artsrelated businesses. 5. Cleanup 10 acres of contaminated property in 10 years. 6. Increase graduation rate. 5. Coordinate with the Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation. 6. Utilize federal and state programs and financial incentives to remediate and reuse brownfield sites within the City. 7. Utilize the tax stabilization ordinance and other economic incentives as a means to encourage the expansion of economic development. ED 8 Work with RIDOT and FTA to advance the Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station. ED 9 Explore the creation of a downtown Business Improvement District. ED 10 Create a written economic development plan. ED 11 Identify source of public subsidy/financing for Roosevelt Avenue development. 8. Hold weekly developer meetings to assist in the navigation of the City’s regulatory review process and monthly meetings to identify ways to streamline the process. ED 12 Investigate potential to expand availability of higher education within Pawtucket. 9. Continue to establish relationships with similar sized communities worldwide to foster cultural exchanges. ED 14 Work with the Pawtucket Foundation to implement their marketing program. 10. Actively recruit and provide funding to restaurants, galleries, grocery stores, retail and other uses which support residential development, to locate in the downtown. ED 15 Analyze land within Industrial Zones to determine whether additional development is feasible, or if the land is more appropriately preserved as Open Space. ED 13 Establish a regular monthly program for downtown events. ED 16 Designate a Growth Center within Pawtucket. 3- 1 Economic Development II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis A. Introduction Once an industrial powerhouse, the City of Pawtucket has been combating economic decline since the late 1950’s when it began to lose first its manufacturing base and then much of its downtown retail as a result of suburbanization, competition from southern textile mills, the construction of Interstate 95 and, most recently an increasingly global economy. Since then, the City’s economic development efforts have been focused on both retaining manufacturing jobs and revitalizing the downtown. In 1985 the City of Pawtucket and the Pawtucket Redevelopment Agency developed an overall economic development strategy to revitalize the downtown which was multi-faceted and capitalized on Pawtucket’s strengths. Revitalization efforts focused on attracting a mix of commercial, office and residential using the riverfront, the City’s historic resources, and access to Interstate 95 as a draw. The City also began to focus on the arts as a vehicle for revitalization in the late 1990’s and has implemented an Arts District, developed a successful Arts Festival and provided funding for local artists. These efforts have begun to pay off. Many of the City’s vacant and under-utilized mill buildings have been converted into commercial and residential uses – four hundred and fifty new residential units have been permitted, and over three hundred and fifty are planned within downtown Pawtucket. The current economic climate, which is not only affecting Pawtucket but the region and nation as well, is not conducive to economic growth. The City’s short term economic goals are to maintain the gains realized in the past decade, and to take this opportunity to plan for the future. B. Regional Overview Located just to the north of Providence, Pawtucket is the fourth largest city in Rhode Island. Like all communities, Pawtucket’s economy is built on inter-relationships that stretch far beyond the City’s borders. – Pawtucket is linked with the labor markets of both Providence and Boston and is at the southern end of the Blackstone Valley. At present, Pawtucket is feeling the tremors of a larger economic readjustment affecting all of the United States. Unemployment statistics from the RI Department of Labor and Training in June 2009 showed an unemployment rate in Pawtucket as 11.9% (down from over 15% a year ago), and 10.6% statewide, compared with an average of 7.9% for the rest of the New England States. The per capita income of Pawtucket ($20,855) still well below the state average ($27,515) and the MSA ($29,613)1. This fact is likely based on the nature of Pawtucket’s employment which is largely comprised of traditionally lower paying jobs like manufacturing and retail. Median household income in 2008 was estimated to be $41,391, compared to a statewide household income of $55,701 (2008 American Community Survey). Since the 1960’s, Pawtucket has consistently been below the State’s median family income. The 2008 American Community Survey 1 Per capita income estimates come from the 2005-2007 American Community Survey 3-Year Estimates. 3- 2 Economic Development estimates that 18 percent of the population in Pawtucket had incomes below the poverty level, compared to 11 percent statewide. C. Labor Force The total labor force in Pawtucket decreased 4.4% from 1990 to 2000 - from 37,372 in 1990 to 35,745 in 2000 - but the 2008 American Community Survey estimates that this number is back up above 38,000. Table 3.1 below describes the educational attainment of Pawtucket residents as compared to Rhode Island and the nation. Compared to the state and nation, Pawtucket has proportionately more residents who did not finish high school, and less than have obtained at least a four-year college degree. The Pawtucket Foundation’s Blueprint Bridge to Prosperity identifies education and job training as one of its “strategic pillars” for economic success in the City of Pawtucket. Table 3.1 Educational Attainment, Population 25 Years and Older United States Rhode Island Did not finish high school High School Graduate/GED Associates Degree/ Some College Bachelor’s Degree or Higher Total Number 30,068,765 57,032,214 57,571,857 55,357,182 200,030,018 % 15 29 29 28 100 Number 115,478 197,197 183,191 212,880 708,746 % 16 28 26 30 100 Pawtucket Number 12,141 15,111 12,477 8,593 48,322 % 25 31 26 18 100 Source: 2008 American Community Survey D. Employment in Pawtucket This section of the community profile addresses the employment available in Pawtucket, and does not necessarily reflect employment for Pawtucket residents rather, indicated jobs within the City that are available to anyone in the State or Region. Table 3.2 shows the current and historic breakdown of occupations within the City. Although it continues to decline, manufacturing is still the second largest industry employer category in Pawtucket. Because of economic circumstances that affect the region and nation, many of the sectors have lost employees. However, Table 3.2 also shows where the City’s efforts to attract artists and other professionals has been successful. These industry groups all show a marked increase. Employees under arts, entertainment and recreation have increased almost 50% since 2002. Table 3.2 Occupations in Pawtucket 2002-2008 2002 Average Employment Total Private & Government Total Private Only Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing & Hunting Mining Utilities Construction Manufacturing Wholesale Trade Retail Trade Transportation & Warehousing 28,410 26,167 * 0 * 1,095 7,525 659 2,362 512 2008 26,122 23,617 0 0 9 902 4,830 542 1,787 421 % Change (8) (10) (18) (36) (18) (24) (18) 3- 3 Economic Development Information Finance & Insurance Real Estate & Rental & Leasing Professional & Technical Services Management of Companies & Enterprises Administrative Support/ Waste Mngmnt. Educational Services Health Care & Social Assistance Arts, Entertainment, & Recreation Accommodation & Food Services Other services (except Public Administration) Unclassified Establishments Public Administration 1,084 906 322 462 1,181 1,729 269 5,086 335 1,279 1,341 6 2,243 260 905 265 632 1,485 1,963 389 5,762 495 1,616 1,354 * 2,503 (76) (0) (18) 37 26 14 45 13 48 26 01 12 Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation, 2009. 2 The number of jobs available in Pawtucket decreased from 31,481 in 1989 to 27,085 in 2000. In the period from 2002-2008 there was a net loss of 2,288 jobs. Manufacturing lost 4,621 jobs in the 1990’s, and another approximately 2,600 so far in the 2000s. Besides Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, Information occupations had the smallest total employment in Pawtucket with 260 employees. Retail Trade saw a decrease in 575 jobs between 1990 and 2000. The second largest occupation group in the City of Pawtucket in 2008 was Health Care and Social Assistance. In 2009, there were 42 employers in Pawtucket who employed 100 or more people (see Table 3.3). Much of the growth that Pawtucket did experience in recent years, however, has been as a result of smaller enterprises. The City’s focus on the arts has resulted in a number of artists locating their studios in Pawtucket which are generally one or two person small businesses. Table 3.3 Twelve Largest Private Employers in Pawtucket Employer Memorial Hospital Hasbro, Inc. Gateway Healthcare, Inc. International Packaging Corp. Collette Vacations ARC of Blackstone Valley PFPC Inc. PNC Global Investment Servicing Teknor Apex Aid Maintenance Co., Inc. Lifetime Medical Nursing Services Pawtucket Red Sox Number of Employees 1,733 1,511 800 603 350 350 334 334 325 300 300 300 Product or Services Health Care Toys and Games Health Services Containers for Gifts Travel Agency Non-Profit/Human Services Financial Services Data Processing Rubber and Plastics Commercial Cleaning Nursing Services Baseball League Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation, 2009 New commercial and industrial construction is one indicator of the growth of the City’s economic base. The number of construction jobs remained relatively stable from 20022008. This number is anticipated to go up over the next year, as a result of the stimulus 2 * Information not available. 3- 4 Economic Development programming. Since the 2005 update, the new commercial and industrial square footage has increased slowly (City of Pawtucket Building Department, 2010). These figures, however, do not take into consideration the rehabilitation of space for commercial or industrial uses in historic mill and other buildings. E. Industrial Development and Redevelopment The Zoning Ordinance classifies industrial areas into two types. The first is manufacturing built-up (MB) which consists of established multi-story structures. The second is manufacturing open (MO) which consists of the newer areas with more vacant land. Very little of MB zoned land is vacant – 3.2 acres – while there are 119 acres of vacant land zoned MO. In addition, some of these buildings are no longer appropriate for reuse as industrial (with the exception of small-scale industrial/artisan type use). While there is a good amount of vacant land zoned MO, much of it is constrained by topography and wetlands. Specifically, much of this land is located along the Moshassuck Valley Canal. As noted in the Land Use Chapter, it is unclear how much, if any, land in Pawtucket is currently available for new industrial development. The City needs to review the Industrial Zones and determine which areas would be more appropriate as open space, because of environmental constraints. The John H. Chaffee Blackstone Valley National Heritage Corridor Commission has completed a study of the Blackstone Canal in Rhode Island and has determined that the segment in Pawtucket which is identified in Figure 1.4 is worthy of preservation. In addition, some of it has been rezoned to Riverfront Development Zoning Districts. New industrial enterprises will result from the redevelopment of mills where appropriate and also the build out of other areas, like the Narragansett Industrial Park. Pawtucket’s legacy of historic mills speaks to the historic importance of large-scale manufacturing. However, the current reality is that smaller-scale niche manufacturing continues to be successful within the City. Currently, there are just under 200 different manufacturers in Pawtucket with employees ranging from 1 to 5,000. F. Tax Base It is widely accepted that residential development does not “pay its own way”, that is, the cost of services demanded by the typical residential use is not met by the amount of taxes they pay to the City. Therefore, most residential development is a drain on the City’s resources. To offset the drain of residential development, a strong industrial and commercial base is necessary. A breakdown of the real estate assessments is shown in Table 3.4. Residential uses account for approximately 80 percent of the real estate tax base, while commercial and industrial real estate comprised approximately 20 percent. Table 3.4 Tax Base Information Use One Family Residence Two-Five Family Residence Commercial II Apartments Industrial Value $1,822,939,800 $1,071,529,600 $277,872,600 $264,054,900 $259,873,200 Percent of Total 44.13% 25.94% 6.73% 6.39% 6.29% 3- 5 Economic Development Commercial I Residential Condominium Combination Commercial-Industrial Vacant Land Residential Vacant Land Utilities & RR Other Commercial Condominium Mobil Homes Industrial Condominium Total $137,249,400 $102,470,800 $74,809,300 $41,132,700 $23,643,600 $14,603,600 $12,927,900 $11,767,900 $9,380,800 $6,235,800 $4,130,491,900 3.32% 2.48% 1.81% 1.00% 0.57% 0.35% 0.31% 0.28% 0.23% 0.15% 100.00% Pawtucket Tax Assessor, 2009 G. Economic Development Focus Areas Downtown Pawtucket’s downtown has been the subject of numerous studies and redevelopment efforts in the past and many of these past efforts have not flourished as anticipated. However, recent efforts have begun to have an impact. Currently two hundred and fifty new residential units have been built, and over five hundred are planned, for almost eight hundred new residents living within walking distance of downtown Pawtucket (See Figure 3.1). There are also a number of ongoing downtown redevelopments which will result in over 150,000 sf of commercial and office space, with another 350,000 sf planned. The historic W.T. Grant building on Main Street has been rehabilitated and is almost fully tenanted, bringing retail back to the downtown. There are now five galleries within the downtown, as well as Stone Soup Coffeehouse, a venue for musical performers, the Mixed Magic Theater, the Gamm Theater, a yoga studio, and a number of new restaurants. Following is a summary of some of the recent initiatives which focus on downtown Pawtucket: • • • Downtown Pawtucket National Register District - Downtown Pawtucket was recently listed as a National Register District. The City of Pawtucket recently completed a signage project, which identifies the newly designated District, and identifies contributing structures. The recent listing makes the federal tax credits available to owners of contributing structures within the District, and the City has marketed this opportunity to downtown property owners. Arts and Entertainment District - In 1998 the City of Pawtucket implemented the City’s Arts and Entertainment District. The Rhode Island General Assembly passed a law establishing the District in an area of the City that encompasses the downtown and mill district areas (approximately 307 acres). The State and City provide significant tax incentives to artists selling original art, who live and work within the district, and to art galleries that are established within the district boundaries. The City’s Department of Planning and Redevelopment maintains an extensive inventory of available commercial and industrial space within the arts and entertainment district to provide those interested relocating, information on properties that may be available for use as gallery or studio space. “Design Exchange” Armory Arts Planning Area - Plans are also ongoing to develop an educational/arts cluster in that area of downtown containing Tolman High School, the Pawtucket Armory and existing industrial properties on 3- 6 Economic Development Exchange Street. The Sandra Feinstein-Gamm Theatre is now in its 7th season at the Pawtucket Armory and now has 1,850 subscribers. The Pawtucket Armory Association is working on reusing the remainder of the Armory as theater/performance space. There are also a number of upcoming opportunities for downtown Pawtucket: • Roosevelt Avenue Redevelopment Site - The Pawtucket Foundation is working with the City on a project that could dramatically impact downtown Pawtucket: the redevelopment of a 2.4-acre City and Redevelopment Agency owned vacant site on Roosevelt Avenue. Recently a marking study was completed to identify potential uses. • Apex – The Rhode Island Department of Motor Vehicles recently left its location within downtown Pawtucket. • Fish Ladders at the Main Street and Slater Mill Dam – This attraction would bolster the City’s and the Blackstone Valley Tourism Council’s efforts to develop cultural tourism within Pawtucket and the Blackstone Valley. • National Park Service in Blackstone Valley – The Secretary of the Interior is conducting a Special Resource Study (SRS) to explore the potential for a permanent National Park Service (NPS) presence in the Blackstone Valley. A possible result of the study could be Congressional action creating a new unit of the National Park System in the Blackstone Valley. The following table summarizes the recent mill redevelopments. All of these, except for the Hope Artiste Village project, are located within and around downtown Pawtucket. There are an additional 450 residential units completed and currently permitted within ½ mile of downtown Pawtucket, and another 350 that are planned. Table 3.5, Mill Redevelopment Projects in Pawtucket Mill Redevelopment # of Units/ sf Commercial Bayley Lofts - Completed Riverfront Lofts – Completed Hope Webbing – Half Complete Union Wadding – Partly Complete Slater Cotton – Complete The Thread Factory - Proposed 25 59 135/ 220,000 sf commercial and light industrial 242 (45 of the 242 are complete) 125/6000 sf office 376 / 150,000 sf commercial and 200,000 sf light industrial 3- 7 Economic Development 3- 8 3-8 Economic Development The Arts Over the past 10 years, the City of Pawtucket has focused its revitalization efforts on the arts. This focus on the arts has resulted in a number of events which bring people into the City - The City of Pawtucket Arts Festival is in its 10th year and its Film Festival is in its tenth year. The Pawtucket Arts Festival was listed as one of the largest “Tourist and Cultural Attractions” in the 2009 Book of Lists prepared by the Providence Business News. This event was estimated to draw 25,000 visitors to the City of Pawtucket. The Sandra Feinstein-Gamm Theater, located in the Pawtucket Armory, was estimated to bring 27,000 people into downtown Pawtucket. As noted in the previous section, the City of Pawtucket has created an Arts and Entertainment that centers on the downtown. The City has also instituted grant programs to support the arts and spur local economic development. The Arts Panel reviews application for small grants ($500-$2000) which provide exposure to the arts to Pawtucket residents at a minimal or no cost. In previous years, the Arts Panel has received 8-10 applications. In 2009, the Panel received over 30 applications. In addition, the City provides organizational funding for established non-profit arts organizations which have performance or gallery space within Pawtucket. In addition to the downtown, there are a number of other clusters of artists in Pawtucket, the newly renovated Hope Artiste Village, 560 Mineral Spring Avenue, 250 Esten Avenue, 545 Pawtucket Avenue. While small artist studios have a minimal visual impact, the City appreciates that they are small businesses who have an economic impact. Transportation There are a number of transportation initiatives which will affect economic development in the City of Pawtucket: the Blackstone Valley Bikeway; the proposed Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station; circulation within the downtown and the new I-95 Bridge. Blackstone Valley Bikeway – The proposed Blackstone Valley Bikeway will ultimately link Worcester, Massachusetts to the City of Pawtucket. Segments of the bikeway, including Lincoln and Cumberland, have been completed. The Pawtucket portion is currently at 10 % design and the City has agreements for nearly all of the land required to develop the Bikeway. The Blackstone Valley Bikeway will be both a resource to commuters and tourists. The Bikeway in Pawtucket begins at Town Landing, a riverfront site, and travels through historic downtown Pawtucket, past the Slater Mill. The Bikeway provides a complement to the work of the Slater Mill and Blackstone Valley Tourism Council to promote the City and region as a cultural tourism destination. Commuter Rail Station – The proposed station in Pawtucket has two potential benefits - providing transit options to residents of the neighborhoods surrounding the station who are disproportionately low-income, minority and transit dependent; and providing a needed economic boost to both cities. The cities believe that the commuter rail station will help to encourage economic development in the surrounding areas, including downtown Pawtucket. The introduction of a station will provide a low-cost transportation alternative for Pawtucket residents commuting to Boston and Providence, and, 3- 9 Economic Development eventually, to the airport and south to the University of Rhode Island. The Great American Station Foundation commissioned a 43-city study in 2001 to analyze the beneficial economic impacts of stations on communities in which stations were revitalized. Data for the two communities of Pawtucket and Central Falls were estimated using the figures modeled for a community in our size category located in a “high density” rail corridor. This model suggests that up to 550 new jobs could be generated by the construction of the Pawtucket station. The cities are looking at the proposed Commuter Rail station to help reactivate old industrial and commercial buildings. Pawtucket River Bridge – This $100 million bridge will feature an iconic design that changes the image of Pawtucket from Interstate 95. Unlike the old bridge, the new one will be designed as a bridge, not merely an overpass, to let travelers know that they are passing over the Pawtucket River. Downtown Circulation - The current downtown traffic pattern was initiated in the 1960’s as a way to alleviate the effects of newly constructed I-95 on the downtown. The City of Pawtucket is currently conduction a study which focuses on improving auto, pedestrian and bicycle transportation in and around the downtown. H. Summary of Economic Development/Business Retention Programs The City of Pawtucket, working through the Pawtucket Business Development Corporation and the Pawtucket Redevelopment Agency, provides a number of opportunities and incentives for prospective and existing Pawtucket businesses. Table 3.6 Summary of City Economic Development/Retention Programs Program Description Arts and Entertainment District State sales tax exemptions can be obtained for artworks sold within the arts and entertainment district for “one-of-a-kind” or limited production works of art. The District also exempts artists living and working within the district from state income tax on the income generated from their creative work as an artist, writer, dance, composer/performer, sculptor, painter, photographer, actor, etc. Pawtucket has a designated Enterprise Zone. In FY 08 there were 47 businesses participating, and 29 new full time jobs were created during this time period. Federal Tax Credits are available for approved rehabilitation for historic commercial buildings within the downtown. The City offers two grant opportunities annually: Project based grant program (which awards $500-$2000 for art projects and programs that benefit the City) and an annual grant for operating costs for arts organizations. The PBDC offers low interest loans for relocation assistance for firms moving into Pawtucket as well as real estate and equipment purchases. The PRA offers low-interest loans for commercial or residential rehabilitation. Enterprise Zone Downtown National Register District Arts Grants Pawtucket Business Development Corporation - Low interest loans Pawtucket Redevelopment Agency – Low interest loans Tax Treaties The City Council may make tax treaties available for significant redevelopment projects. 3 - 10 Economic Development Source: Department of Planning and Redevelopment, 2010 III. Summary of Major Issues Manufacturing has historically been the mainstay of employment in Pawtucket and is likely to remain an important part of the City’s economic base. However, the City will have to take a more active role in maintaining its industry. To facilitate expansion of industries, which are likely to remain strong, the City should continue with its business retention programs and continue to emphasize communication between businesses and local government. The City should also recognize that manufacturing jobs will continue to be lost and should help displaced workers find the retraining they need to continue in the workforce. Pawtucket does not have a great deal of vacant industrial land suitable for new development. The City does have an estimated 1 million square feet of vacant industrial space found in existing mill structures as shown by a detailed mill inventory conducted by the City. Pawtucket should focus its efforts on maintaining viable industrial spaces for industrial uses, and allowing a more flexible redevelopment of other vacant and abandoned mill space. To this end, the City should continue its efforts to promote and market available space to small businesses, like artists. The City’s current economic development efforts have two focus areas – the downtown and the arts. The City’s recent projects and initiatives are geared toward making the downtown more marketable and also enticing artists to locate in Pawtucket. The current economic climate is not conducive to investment and revitalization. However, the City is taking this opportunity to plan for the future by identifying access and parking improvements to the downtown and preparing a marketing strategy which promote the City’s resources. 3 - 11 Economic Development SOURCES Cassidy, Michael and Herbert Weiss, “Customer Service Key to Growing an Arts Community,” Northeastern Economic Developers Association, Pg. 54- 60, 1999. City of Pawtucket, “An Ordinance Establishing Guidelines for the Exemption or Stabilization of Taxes on Qualifying Property Located in the City of Pawtucket,” Chapter 2539, October, 1999. City of Pawtucket, “Arts and Entertainment District,” 2000. City of Pawtucket, “Economic Development Element”, 1995, 2005 City of Pawtucket, “Pawtucket’s Business Development Corporation, Annual Report,” 2010. Preservation Society of Pawtucket, “Pawtucket Mill Building Survey,” 1990. Providence Business News, “Book of Lists”, 2009 Rhode Island Department of Administration, “Economic Development Policies and Plan,” State Guide Plan Element 211, April 2000, Rhode Island Department of Administration, “Mill Building Reuse: A Survey of Current Mill Conditions in Rhode Island and the Market for Mill Space,” Statewide Planning Technical Paper Number 150, February 2001. Rhode Island Department of Administration, “Industrial Land Use Plan,” State Guide Plan Element 212, August 2000. Rhode Island Department of Labor and Training, “Area Profile for Pawtucket,” 2009. Rhode Island Department of Labor and Training, “Private U.I. Covered Employment and Wages, City and Town Summary,” 2010. Rhode Island Economic Development Corporation, Research Division, “Pawtucket, Rhode Island,” 2009 U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, Census of Population and Housing: 1980, 1990, 2000. U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, American Community Survey, 2008 City of Pawtucket 3 - 12 Natural and Cultural Resources City of Pawtucket, Rhode Island Comprehensive Community Plan 2011 Update Chapter 4 – NATURAL AND CULTURAL RESOURCES Table of Contents I. Goals, Policies, and Actions 4-1 II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis 4-3 III. Summary of Major Issues 4-21 Sources 4-22 4-1 Natural and Cultural Resources I. Goals, Policies and Actions Goal Objective Policy Action 1. Use reduced salt level for winter snow and ice removal on city streets and sidewalks, and properly site and manage salt storage to prevent adverse water quality impacts. NR 1 Continue to work with the Pawtucket Water Supply Board in implementing their Water Supply Management Plan. Natural Resource Goals 1. Protect and improve ground and surface water quality by alleviating and where possible eliminating point and nonpoint sources of water pollution. 2. Preserve and restore any existing natural areas within Pawtucket. 1. Maintain current acreage of natural areas within Pawtucket. 2. Using the MetroBay Samp mapping as guidance, restore 1 acre of riverfront area. 3. In the next 10 years, cleanup 5 acres of contaminated land. 2. Utilize best management practices for design of new storm water management systems and regularly maintain the existing storm water management and drainage systems through cleaning catch basins and scheduled street cleaning. 3. Work cooperatively with State agencies and regional authorities to correct the problem of combined sewer overflows. 4. Assess, working with the RIDEM, the water quality impacts of material salvage yards found along the Blackstone and Moshassuck Rivers and implement mitigation measures as required. 5. To the maximum extent feasible, retain and restore the quality of the remaining natural wetlands within the City. 6. Investigate opportunities to restore riverfront areas, as identified through the Metro Bay Special Area Management Plan process. NR 2 Continue to work with the Department of Public Works to minimize the use of salt on watershed roadways. NR 3 Continue to maintain and update information on unique, rare, and endangered natural resources within the City. NR 4 Continue to offer the street tree program to City residents and to enforce the landscape requirements of the Zoning Ordinance to expand the number and concentration of trees in the City. Consider expanding the tree planning program to allow public trees to be allowed on private land. NR 5 Continue to apply for RIDEM Targeted Brownfields Assessment grants and US EPA Cleanup Grants. NR 6 Continue to advocate for the next segment of the Ten Mile River Bikeway to the Rhode Island Department of Transportation and establish a relationship with the Ten Mile River Watershed Alliance to help move the project forward. NR 7 Continue to provide support for the development of Fish Ladders at the Slater Mill and Main Street dams. NR 8 Coordinate with Narragansett Bay Commission on the status of the CSO abatement project. 7. Work with the Department of Public Works to implement RIDEM’s requirements for stormwater runoff. 8. Support the efforts of local watershed organizations in protecting water quality and species habitat. 4-1 4-3 Natural and Cultural Resources Cultural Resources Goals 1. Preserve or assess archaeological resources to expand the body of knowledge about the pattern of Rhode Island settlement. 2. Preserve through use, or reuse, structures or sites in the National Register of Historic Places, in the Local Historic District, or other structures and sites of historic significance to the city. 3. Preserve the integrity of historic neighborhoods where most of the residential structures are more than 70 years old. 1. Expand the Local Historic District by 10 properties by 2020. 1. Support efforts to re-establish the State Historic Tax Credit. CR 1 Establish a cemetery commission to promote the preservation and enhancement of the city’s cemeteries. 2. Continue to identify and document historic resources within the City. CR 2 Map historic resources using Geographical Information Systems (GIS) as part of a program to locate and identify historic sites and structures. 2. Increase understanding and appreciation for the City’s cultural resources. 3. Expand the local historic districts where appropriate. 3. Maintain all of the City’s National Register listed and eligible properties. 4. Encourage a reuse of vacant structures of historic or architectural interest. 5. Coordinate activities with the BRVNHC Visitor Center to promote visitors at the Slater Mill and other area attractions. 6. Continue to support the historic preservation efforts and programs of the Preservation Society of Pawtucket CR 3 Enhance the aesthetics of the historic bridges on the rivers by lighting their architectural details. CR 4 Offer design assistance through DPR to developers and owners of historic structures in the city. CR 5 Continue to provide financial incentives for landlord occupied multifamily historic housing. 7. Continue to research, map and predict archeological sites throughout the City. CR 6 Continue the partnership between the City, Pawtucket Redevelopment Agency and the Rhode Island Historical Preservation and Heritage Commission to provide low interest loans for house repairs through the Historic Properties Rehabilitation Initiative. 8. Encourage preservation of historic buildings over new construction where appropriate. CR 7 Support efforts to rehabilitate and reuse the Pawtucket Armory as a Performing Arts Center. 9. Support the educational efforts of PSP and the RIHPHC. CR 8 Work with the John H. Chaffee National Heritage Corridor Commission to preserve land along the Moshassuck Canal – specifically those areas behind Lorraine Mills. 10. Explore lead-safe guidelines that work with, as opposed to removing, historic fabric on historic properties. 11. Encourage the use of the plans and specifications from the RIHMFC affordable housing design context, "Design Rhode Island". 12. Using the Pawtucket Mill Building Survey (1990, reprinted 1995) published by the Preservation Society of Pawtucket (PSP), provide information to potential developers about available incentives for the rehabilitation of vacant or underused industrial buildings. CR 9 Work with the Public Library and the Preservation Society to identify a long-term plan for the Elizabeth J. Johnson Pawtucket History Research Center. CR 10 Maintain a list of properties eligible for the National Register. CR 11 Consider expansion of the Local District tax abatement to commercial properties. 4-4 4-2 Natural and Cultural Resources II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis A. Introduction This section of the Comprehensive Plan examines both the natural and man-made resources of Pawtucket. The City is nearly built-out, which makes it imperative that the existing natural resources be protected. Pawtucket also has played a significant part in the history of the nation, and of Rhode Island and so has many important cultural resources which are afforded varying degrees of protection. B. Land Resources Geology The presence of stable soils for building foundations and the absence of natural hazards have contributed to the developed character of the City. Topographically, Pawtucket can be described as a section of a broad coastal plain varied by two low hills and occasionally steep banks along the three southward flowing rivers, the Moshassuck, the Blackstone (the Blackstone River is referred to as the Pawtucket River south of the Main Street Bridge) and the Ten Mile. Local relief is about 100 feet. The highest elevation, 182 feet, is reached on Windmill Hill in the City’s southwestern corner. Underlying the glacial silt, sand, gravel and boulders that cover most of the City are sedimentary rocks (shale or conglomerate), approximately 350 million years old, of the Pennsylvania Period. There are outcrops of the formation visible from the Main Street Bridge in the channel of the Seekonk River and at the Blackstone River Falls. Eighteenth century drawings of the area show an extensive rock outcrop at the Falls (Main Street Bridge) that was used for fishing by the Indians. Later construction of foundation walls has reduced the extent of the visible rock outcrop. The bedrock formation in most of Rhode Island is overlain by layers or deposits of unstratified and stratified drift left some 10,000 to 12,000 years ago by melting glaciers. Stratified drift or outwash is the name given to layers of sorted sand, gravel, clay, and boulders, while unstratified drift, or till, is the same unsorted material. Approximately 80 percent of Pawtucket is covered by stratified drift, and it is deeper in the channel of the ancestral Pawtucket/Seekonk and Blackstone Rivers. Generally, the stratified drift or outwash is less that fifty feet thick, and it reaches a maximum of one hundred fifty feet in the river channels. Only the higher elevations of Pawtucket, in the Oak Hill Area and near Windmill Hill on the Providence border, have unsorted till. Soil The formation of soil cover is a process that takes thousands of years, and the resulting soil is a unique product of physical, chemical, and geological conditions. As the previous section has described, Pawtucket was covered with material deposited during a period of glaciation, and the soil cover in the area is the result of many forces acting to transform sand and gravel into soil. Rhode Island is fortunate that the entire state has been mapped by the Department of Agriculture’s Soil Conservation Service and the Rhode Island Agricultural Experiment Station. 4-3 Natural and Cultural Resources The major soil types are listed in Table 4.1. The table shows that two major soil types combine to make up 70 percent of the Pawtucket area. These two types are the Merrimack Sandy Loam Series and Windsor Loam Sand Series. On the average, the soil is six feet in depth. Table 4.1 Major Soil Types, Pawtucket, Rhode Island Soil Type Acres Merrimac Sandy Loam Series Windsor Loam Sand Series Paxton Sandy Loam Series Hinckley Gravelly Sandy Loam Cut and Fill Miscellaneous Soil Groups Landfills Total Area in Acres 2875 1115 515 410 305 170 20 5410 Percentage 53.1 20.6 9.5 7.5 5.6 3.1 0.6 100% U.S. Department of Agriculture, Soil Survey of Rhode Island, 1981. For the purposes of planning, the two largest soil types comprising nearly 75 percent of the City present only slight obstacles to building site development. The only problem is that shallow excavations have a tendency to cave inward. Generally, the areas that are underlain by stratified drift have easy grading and protection from frost-heaving of foundations. Most other soils found in Pawtucket pose few serious constraints, meaning that more than 90 percent of the City is suitable for development. Agricultural Land While at one time there were farms located in Eastern Pawtucket, there is no longer agricultural land in Pawtucket. The major soil groups in the City identified in Table 4.1 are not noted as being highly productive for agricultural uses. Filled Wetlands Development of the City over the past 300 years has resulted in ponds and marshes being filled and extensions of man-made fill into river and tidal areas. Many of the modifications have occurred so long ago that the public today is unaware of the changes that have been made. Figure 4.1 shows the location of all natural resources in Pawtucket. There were several ponds located in the area now occupied by a small industrial park and McCoy Stadium. These ponds were drained by Bucklin Brook, which flowed southwesterly and into the Pawtucket River near Beverage Hill Avenue. This area has been transformed so that building with the proper foundation is possible. Another area with extensive fill is the land in the Moshassuck Valley. Freshwater Wetlands There is a series of freshwater wetlands totaling approximately 106 acres adjacent to the City’s river systems. The largest extent of wetlands is on the Ten Mile River System and the Moshassuck River. Those wetland areas are used extensively by migrating waterfowl. For the purposes of general planning, the location of wetlands can be determined by using U.S. Geological Survey topographic maps and information from Rhode Island Geographic Information Systems. It is the responsibility of public and private entities and developers to submit applications to the Freshwater Wetlands Section of the Department of Environmental Management for development projects 4-4 Natural and Cultural Resources 4-5 Natural and Cultural Resources within 200 feet of a stream greater than 10 feet wide, 100 feet of stream less than 10 feet wide, or within 50 feet of a pond or wetland. Forest and Wooded Areas Pawtucket has minimal vacant land throughout the City. As the City developed, forestland was converted into farmland and then into house lots. The amount of land that can be classified as forestland or wooded is very small, less than 300 acres. Common tree types are oak, maple, and miscellaneous deciduous varieties. A way for the City to incorporate trees appropriately into the landscape is through the installation of street trees. Street trees are of great value in an urban environment. This fact has been recognized by the City and the Department of Public Works, which, over the past decade, has been using City and other funds, to install street trees in more areas of the City. Also, the Zoning Ordinance mandates new landscaped areas and trees be installed in parking lots over 4 spaces and in overall developments occurring on 20,000 or more square feet. The Department of Planning and Development have also used their Development Plan Review process to preserve old growth trees, to the extent feasible. The City of Pawtucket has two trees of statewide significance: the State Champion Cedar of Lebanon is located at 689 East Avenue and the third largest Atlas Cedar is located in Riverside Cemetery. Coastal Features The Blackstone River ends at the falls under the Main Street Bridge and from that point, the Pawtucket/Seekonk River widens out as the northern most extension of Narragansett Bay. The river shoreline is tidally affected as far north as the Pawtucket Falls at Main Street. The shoreline is largely confined to man-made retaining walls from the Falls to the southern terminus of the former state pier on the eastern shore and to the vicinity of the Max Read Field on the western shore. The immediate upland areas that are not developed are characterized by steep embankments along most of the shore. The Rhode Island Coastal Resources Management Council reviews construction and physical alterations that affect the coastal areas of Rhode Island. Although Pawtucket does not have an extensive shoreline, the same basic regulatory process is in effect for the City’s coastal feature, the Pawtucket/Seekonk River. Certain major industrial activities as well as all proposed actions within 200 feet of the tidal area shoreline require review by the Coastal Resources Management Council. Pawtucket worked with the communities of Providence, East Providence and Cranston on the Metro Bay Special Area Management Plan (SAMP). That process resulted in the development of the Urban Coastal Greenways Policy, a guidance document which allows for these developed urban areas to be regulated differently from undeveloped rural areas. C. Water Resources Water resources serve many purposes in the community such as providing sources of drinking water, powering industrial uses, furnishing recreational opportunities, allowing transportation, and giving aesthetic pleasure. It was the presence of the Blackstone River that attracted the founding settlers to the City. They saw the river as an instrument 4-6 Natural and Cultural Resources to turn the power wheels and shafts of the first industries in Pawtucket. For 170 years, the riverfront area of the Blackstone River was extensively used for industrial purposes, and there are the remains of a number of structures from the era when industries were located on the riverfront. In the mid-1990’s, the City commissioned the Riverfront Development Plan to guide the redevelopment of the waterfront. The implementation of the recommendations from that plan continues today. Pawtucket lies within the drainage basin of two major systems, the Blackstone River and the Narragansett Bay/Seekonk River System. Additionally, there are two other minor rivers, the Moshassuck and the Ten Mile River that flow through Pawtucket. An extensive amount of research has been completed to determine the conditions of the Blackstone River and the Narragansett Bay, such as the amount and types of discharges entering the waterways, their suitability for drinking water and other purposes, determining an overall rating for their condition and recommending improvements. It is expected that as the land uses adjacent to the rivers becomes less industrial in nature, the quality of the water will improve. Groundwater Resources Most of the City is covered with glacial materials that are favorable for the storing and the movement of subsurface water or groundwater. This feature is also present in Cumberland, Rhode Island along the course of the Abbott Run Brook, which is of critical importance to Pawtucket’s public drinking water supply. Pawtucket and the Abbott Run Brook have an extensive amount of stratified drift aquifer and also hold groundwater reservoirs. The groundwater reservoirs are the part of the aquifer, where there is the greatest potential for water supply development. The Pawtucket Water Supply Board draws over 2.0 million gallons daily from wells in the Valley Falls area of Cumberland. However, there is presently very little water being withdrawn from the groundwater resources within the City of Pawtucket. This is because of the presence of a citywide water system that uses mainly surface water reservoirs in the Town of Cumberland. This surface water system has been able to meet the water demands of three communities; Central Falls, Cumberland and Pawtucket, all served by the Pawtucket Water Supply Board. Having a groundwater supply within the borders of Pawtucket is fortunate, but it has been found that the groundwater is not suitable for drinking without further treatment because of the history and concentration of industrial and commercial uses in the City. Surface Water Quality All the waters in the state have been classified by the Department of Environmental Management based on the suitable use of that water body. The classifications are based upon a number of physical and water quality parameters. If it is determined that a certain body of water does not meet the water quality criteria for its classification, that body of water is then considered to be out of compliance with its classification, or impaired. There are two ways to define pollution sources, point and non-point source pollution. Point source pollution is liquid that is discharged from a pipe or conduit directly into a waterway. Non-point source pollution refers to many sources of contaminants, nutrients, and pathogens that are not from an identifiable “pipe source”. Non-point pollution is closely associated with land development. 4-7 Natural and Cultural Resources The Blackstone River bisects the City into two roughly equal parts and meets the uppermost extension of Narragansett Bay known as the Pawtucket River. The Ten Mile River flows on the eastern boundary of the City with Massachusetts, and eventually flows into the Seekonk River in East Providence. On the west side of the City is the Moshassuck River, which begins in Lincoln, and was once used as part of a canal to Worcester in the 1840’s. While not in Pawtucket, the Abbott Run Brook in Cumberland and Massachusetts brings water from reservoirs in Cumberland to the water treatment plant in the Valley Falls section of Cumberland, and for this reason, it is important for Pawtucket. Blackstone River Basin - The Blackstone River, bordered by six Rhode Island cities and towns, is the area’s major river. One RIDEM classified segment of the Blackstone River flows through Pawtucket. This portion of the Blackstone begins at the combined sewer overflow outfall located at River and Somoset Streets in Central Falls and ends at the Slater Mill Dam. This water is classified as B1(a) which is defined by Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management (RIDEM) as follows: “these waters are designated for primary and secondary contact recreational activities and fish and wildlife habitat. They shall be suitable for compatible industrial processes and cooling, hydropower, aquacultural uses, navigation, and irrigation and other agricultural sues. These waters shall have good aesthetic value. Primary contact recreational activities may be impacted due to pathogens from approved wastewater discharges. However all Class B criteria must be met.” The entire length of Blackstone is considered impaired by according to RIDEM’s Year 2008, List of Impaired Waters. A Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) or a control action functionally equivalent to a TMDL has been developed for these waters and implementation is underway which will result in the attainment of the water quality standards. In addition, the Consent Agreement for Combined Sewer Outfall (CSO) abatement is anticipated to reduce the pollutant levels by 2022. The Abbott Run Brook originates in Wrentham, Massachusetts, and flows through the Diamond and Abbott Run reservoir, Robin Hollow Pond and Happy Hollow Pond, which are all public water supply impoundments for the City of Pawtucket, thus receiving a water classification of A. The Robin Hollow Pond was de-listed from the list of impaired waters. The Abbott Run Brook has a TMDL. Narragansett Bay Basin - The Pawtucket River from the Slater Mill Dam at Main Street in Pawtucket until the Providence border is a part of the Narragansett Bay Basin and is classified as SB1(a) which is defined by RIDEM as follows: “These waters are designated for primary and secondary contact recreational activities and fish and wildlife habitat. They shall be suitable for aquacultural uses, navigation, and industrial cooling. These waters shall have good aesthetic value. Primary contact recreational activities may be impacted due to pathogens from approved wastewater discharges. However, all Class SB criteria must be met.” This portion of the Seekonk River is listed on RIDEM’s List of Impaired Waters. A TMDL is underway. 4-8 Natural and Cultural Resources Moshassuck River Basin - The Moshassuck River from the combined sewer overflow outfall located at Higginson Avenue in Central Falls to its confluence with the Providence River is the portion that flows through Pawtucket and is classified as B(a) which is defined by RIDEM as follows: “These waters are designated for fish and wildlife habitat and primary and secondary contact recreational activities. They shall be suitable for compatible industrial processes and cooling, hydropower, aquacultural uses, navigation, and irrigation and other agricultural uses. These waters shall have good aesthetic value.” This portion of the Moshassuck River is listed on RIDEM’s List of Impaired Waters. A Consent Agreement for Combined Sewer Outfall (CSO) abatement is anticipated to reduce the pollutant levels by 2022 and negate the need for TMDL. Ten-Mile River Basin - The Ten-Mile River and its tributaries, from the MA-RI border to the Turner Reservoir is classified as B1 (see definition under Blackstone River Basin). This portion of the Ten Mile River are listed on the RIDEM’s List of Impaired Waters. NO TMDL is planned because the impairments are not pollutants. Lakes and Ponds - The only ponds in Pawtucket are manmade, the Slater Park Pond at Slater Park, and a portion of Central Pond known as Turner Reservoir which is mainly in East Providence, extending into the southeast corner of Pawtucket. The Slater Park Pond is classified at B1 – Hypereutrophic, which means it has extreme eutrophic conditions. The Slater Park Pond is listed on RIDEM’s List of Impaired Waters, with a TMDL is planned for 2010. The Turner Reservoir is classified as B – Eutrophic, which means there is excess algae and nutrients. It is listed on RIDEM’s List of Impaired Waters, and TMDL is planned for 2010. D. Threats to Resources The area’s natural resources are under constant pressure from contaminants and increased development. The means of reducing or eliminating these conditions rest on preventative regulations and technology. This section of the plan will discuss some of the conditions that are adversely affecting the City of Pawtucket and its watershed area in neighboring towns. Combined Sewer Overflow Discharges from municipal wastewater treatment plants and industries are considered point source discharges. All point source discharges in Rhode Island are regulated by discharge permits. Rhode Island is a delegated state, therefore effluent limitations are set and permits are given by RIDEM and reviewed by EPA. An effluent limitation is the maximum amount of pollutant that may be discharged into any water body. These limitations formally establish performance criteria for wastewater treatment facilities. Pawtucket’s wastewater is pumped to the Narragansett Bay Commission’s wastewater treatment facility at Bucklin Point in East Providence. One of the major water pollution problems in the Narragansett Bay region is combined sewer overflows (CSO) that periodically discharge into the Narragansett Bay. There are 20 CSO in Pawtucket. During wet weather, the combined sanitary/storm water flows can 4-9 Natural and Cultural Resources exceed the sewerage capacity. The excess is discharged at overflow points into the region’s rivers. The Narragansett Bay Commission has begun the Combined Sewer Overflow Abatement Project, a 20-year, $500 million, 3-phase project to provide for the storage and treatment of combined sewer overflows. Construction has begun for Phase I of this project, which only affects Providence. A tunnel, approximately 26 feet in diameter and 3 miles long, 250 feet down in bedrock, will be constructed to store the combined sewer overflows that are the result of wet weather. Once the system is caught up, the overflow will be pumped to the water treatment plant. This will significantly cut down on the CSO that discharge into the area’s waters. Phase III of the project calls for a similar tunnel to be constructed in Pawtucket. Landfills When solid wastes are deposited in a land disposal facility (landfill), the wastes degrade as a result of various chemical and biological reactions, producing solid, liquid and gaseous by-products. Ferrous and other materials are oxidized. Organic and inorganic wastes are consumed by microorganisms through aerobic and anaerobic digestion. Liquid waste products of microbial degradation, such as organic acids, increase chemical activity within the fill. Surface water and, in many cases, groundwater, infiltrating through the landfill will collect contaminants contained within the solid waste. This contaminated liquid is called “leachate” and may be produced by both active and inactive landfills. As the leachate migrates from the landfill, it can directly contaminate ground and surface water. Surface water also may be contaminated indirectly by polluted groundwater. There are four known inactive landfills in Pawtucket: (1) in the area of the former municipal incinerator, (2) off San Antonio Way (former ash landfill), (3) off Grotto Avenue (convergence of Moshassuck Valley Railroad and Amtrak Railroad lines), and (4) off Palm Street (former private dumping area). Other Sites of Concern There are also a number of locations in Pawtucket that are not landfills but are of concern because of potential contamination. There are two sites listed on the Environmental Protection Agency’s Comprehensive Environmental Recovery, Compensation, and Liability Information System (CERCLIS). The first is a utility company property along the Seekonk River. The property owners are in process of preparing a remediation plan for the cleanup of the site. The other property is the former municipal incinerator. Storm Water Runoff Polluted storm water runoff can enter municipal separate storm sewer systems and ultimately be discharged into local rivers and streams without treatment. Pollutants carried by storm sewers can impair waterbodies, interfere with habitat for fish or other aquatic organisms and wildlife, contaminate drinking water supplies and discourage recreational uses. The National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Phase I storm water program, initiated in 1990, required discharges from large construction sites, certain industrial activities and operators of medium or large municipal separate storm sewer systems (more than 100,000 served), to obtain permits and implement a storm water management program as a means to control polluted discharges from these activities. 4-10 Natural and Cultural Resources Since 1984, RIDEM has been delegated the authority to implement the NPDES program in Rhode Island. (RIPDES Storm Water Program, 2002) The EPA finalized the Storm Water Phase II Rule on December 8, 1999. It requires municipal separate storm sewer systems to obtain permits and establish a storm water management program that is intended to improve waterbodies by reducing the quantity of pollutants that can enter storm sewer systems during storm events. The Storm Water Phase II Rule extends the coverage of the NPDES storm water program to include small municipal separate storm sewer systems. The Phase II Rule automatically covers on a nationwide basis, all small municipal separate storm sewer systems located in urbanized areas as defined by the Bureau of the Census, which includes Pawtucket. (RIPDES Storm Water Program, 2002). Pawtucket received a $25,000 grant from the RIDEM Nonpoint Source Pollution Program to develop a Storm Water Management Program Plan to guide Pawtucket into compliance with the Phase II Rule. This plan was completed in 2003, and the City continues its implementation. Erosion and Sedimentation Erosion and sedimentation can be a major problem at any site where the surface vegetation is removed and soil instability results. All construction projects should employ best management practices to prevent soil erosion into water bodies and must comply with all applicable RIDEM regulations. Road Salt The use of road salt (both sodium chloride and calcium chloride) to accelerate the melting of ice has been common since the 1960’s. Road salt contamination of surface and groundwater can result from two sources: road salt storage and application to roads. The City of Pawtucket keeps road salt in a covered storage shed at the Department of Public Works on Armistice Boulevard. The controlled use of chlorides within the City limits will reduce the impacts on surface water and groundwater, but on the road network within the Pawtucket Reservoir watershed basin, the use of road salts should be minimized. Individual Subsurface Disposal Systems In the City of Pawtucket, all of the residential areas are served by public sewers, but a few homes and industrial areas have not connected to the system. The use of Individual Subsurface Disposal Systems (ISDS) is more of an issue within the watershed area of the Pawtucket Water Supply Board. E. Natural Hazards In 1997, the City of Pawtucket, in conjunction with the University of Rhode Island Coastal Resources Center and the Rhode Island Emergency Management Agency, completed “A Strategy for Reducing Risks from Natural Hazards in Pawtucket, Rhode Island”. This document was part of a regional effort to evaluate natural hazards and identified areas at risk from natural hazards and further defined mitigation actions to protect infrastructure, population, and other resources. Flood Hazards 4-11 Natural and Cultural Resources The natural occurrences that are of concern to Pawtucket residents are floods and hurricanes. Generally, flooding is still a danger to be considered, especially on the Blackstone River, and during the hurricane season on the Pawtucket/Seekonk River. The most severe flooding has been associated with hurricanes and the two most destructive storms occurred in 1938 and 1955. The historical development of Pawtucket resulted in industrial activities located next to the river. Periodic floods have damaged or removed structures. Detailed maps of flood prone areas are currently available. The City controls development in the flood plain through zoning regulation and wetlands protection. Zoning regulations restrict the intensity of development in the flood plain thereby reducing damages and permitting an unrestricted flow of water in the floodway. Wetlands are also being preserved to act as a retaining area for floodwaters. The completion of “A Strategy for Reducing Risks from Natural Hazards in Pawtucket, Rhode Island” was integral in the City receiving $300,000 from the Federal Emergency Management Agency in 1999 to implement projects that would reduce flood risks in the City. This funding enabled the City to be proactive in creating a disaster resistant community. As a result of the funding, a number of important projects were completed including; rebates to approximately 35 residents for installing backflow prevention valves, installation of an emergency generator connection at the Senior Center, installation of backflow prevention valves at City Hall, the Fire Station and the Police Department, design and printing of “Safety Guidelines for Storms and Hurricanes”, design and printing of Disaster Preparedness Coloring Book to educate young children about disaster preparedness, training sessions for a variety of special interest groups including Post Disaster Recovery for municipal and private industry and general training for boards and commissions, and a complete catch basin cleaning of Darlington area of Pawtucket where major street flooding has recently occurred. The City also obtained a Class 8 rating from FEMA’s Community Rating System, entitling affected properties to lower flood insurance rates. The City is in the process of updating the Strategy, which is scheduled for completion in March 2010. The actions recommended in the Strategy will be included in the Comprehensive Plan as Appendix C. F. Special Resources Unique Natural Resources The City of Pawtucket has developed the vast majority of its land area. The areas that are considered vacant are scatted parcels throughout the City. There is about 450 acres of open space and recreation land in the City, but the RIDEM Inventory of Significant Open Lands has identified no large significant natural areas. The City does have significant man-made sites; there are over 100 acres listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Rare and Endangered Species There are no endangered species of wildlife in Pawtucket as defined by the Federal Endangered Species Act. The RIDEM, Natural Heritage Program has provided the City with information pertaining to wildlife species that are of State concern. There are several species in Pawtucket that are classified as “state threatened”. The first is the plant species, the Zigzag Bladderwort, which has been identified at Slater Park’s 4-12 Natural and Cultural Resources Friendship Garden. Marsh Wren have been identified at Central Pond. A number of wildflower types can be found in Slater Park. The wildlife in the City is mostly limited to ducks in the wetland areas of the City. Archeological Resources The Blackstone Valley has been populated for thousands of years, and a number of archeological sites have been listed in the state inventory. The Pawtucket area was once utilized by the Wampanoag and Narragansett Indians, who used to fish at the falls of the Blackstone River. Archeological surveys have been done in two general areas, Beverage Hill Avenue and Taft Street, in conjunction with proposed improvement projects. The specific locations of archaeological sites are not available because of the danger of vandalism. Future construction projects in areas where significant archaeological resources are predicted should be surveyed. G. Cultural Resources Background The most recent and extensive survey of Pawtucket architecture was done in 1976–77 by the Rhode Island Historical Preservation Commission under contract with the Pawtucket Department of Planning and Redevelopment. Funding for the survey was provided in part by the city, through a Community Development Block Grant, and in part by the Rhode Island Historic Preservation and Heritage Commission (RIHPHC), through a survey-and-planning grant from the National Park Service. The survey inventoried 1,300 structures, districts, objects, and sites of architectural, historical, or visual interest. These resources date from the late seventeenth century through to the mid-1970s. Copies of the survey forms and maps are kept at the RIHPHC’s office at 150 Benefit Street in Providence, the Pawtucket Department of Planning and Redevelopment, and at the Pawtucket Public Library. Following the survey, the RIHPHC published “Pawtucket, Rhode Island”, Statewide Historical Preservation Report, P-PA-2 in 1978, which serves as an excellent reference on the subject of local history and architecture. The report was reprinted in 1991 and is available for sale to the general public at the City Clerk’s office and the Slater Mill gift shop. Currently, there are over 300 properties listed as part of a district or individually, on the National Register of Historic Places in Pawtucket. Table 4.2 National Register of Historic Places, Pawtucket, Rhode Island National Register District Contributing Structures Quality Hill Historic District Church Hill Industrial District South Street Historic District Old Slater Mill Historic District Blackstone Canal Historic District Slater Park Historic District Exchange Street Historic District Individual Structures Downtown Pawtucket Historic District 180 20 20 3 N/A 4 7 37 35 4-13 Natural and Cultural Resources Total 306 Source: Department of Planning and Redevelopment, 2010. A study commissioned by the City of Pawtucket identified a number of properties which are eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places. Properties are added to this list, as the City becomes aware of them. Community Character Figure 4-2, Cultural and Historic Resources, identifies National Register-listed properties and historic districts, cemeteries, and cultural sites within the city. There are six general features that are most characteristic and unique to the city: the presence of a major river, the Blackstone River/Pawtucket River; residential neighborhoods; multi-family residential structures; mill structures; cemeteries; and the downtown. Blackstone River - The Blackstone River is the largest and most historically significant of the three rivers that run through Pawtucket. Entering the city from the north, the Blackstone courses generally southward, dividing Pawtucket into almost equal parts. At the Pawtucket Falls, the Blackstone falls into the tidal Seekonk River, a navigable extension of Narragansett Bay. The waterpower available at the falls was the primary reason for Pawtucket’s early development. It attracted past settlements with early manufacturing activity and settlement continued to center around the river and the falls. Residential Neighborhoods - In 2002, a team of Brown University students analyzed Pawtucket geography, architecture, economic and demographic characteristics and concluded that Pawtucket has 14 distinct residential areas that can be defined as neighborhoods. The 14 different neighborhoods illustrate the diversity of the city, ethnically, architecturally, and socioeconomically. The 14 neighborhoods include Barton Street, Beverage Hill/Plains, Countryside, Darlington, Downtown, East Riverview, Fairlawn, Oak Hill, Pinecrest, Pleasant View, Quality Hill, Slater Park, West Riverview, and Woodlawn. Each of these areas has a unique history, which has been influenced by natural and physical features. Figure 4-3 shows Pawtucket’s neighborhoods drawn with generalized boundary lines. Multi-Family Structures - As the City developed, most residents lived in multi-family structures, and many of these structures are still in use. The private textile mills of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries did not provide housing for their workers in the manner of mills in other locations. Privately built and owned tenements were the main form of housing, beginning first with two-family structures, then evolving to the threestory tenements of the early 1900s. According to the 2008 American Community Survey approximately 65% of the housing stock in Pawtucket is comprised of multi-family structures. Mill Structures - Pawtucket has historically been, and is still today, an industrial community. It has been the scene of some of the proudest accomplishments in American industrial history. Although most of the great textile companies for which Pawtucket was once famous have moved south or ceased operation, a number of the mill buildings remain inhabited. A survey of existing mill buildings in Pawtucket was prepared in 1990 by Extrados Architects for the Preservation Society of Pawtucket. The Pawtucket Mill Building 4-14 Natural and Cultural Resources 4-15 Natural and Cultural Resources Survey documents approximately 100 textile-related structures in Pawtucket detailing their historical and physical characteristics. This document contains location data, architectural descriptions, historical narrative, and a conditions assessment for each property. Some industrial resources along the Blackstone River still remain today. These buildings represent industrial accomplishments from the age of steam power, rather than those earlier industries run by waterpower. The largest mill building remaining on the Blackstone River is the former Greene and Daniels mill, which dates back to 1860. It is currently used as residential condominiums and office space for Collette Travel. Not all of these structures will continue in manufacturing uses given the decline of such activity in Rhode Island and New England. The Pawtucket Mill Building Survey provides a valuable resource to evaluate individual buildings for potential reuse. Currently, there is only one industrial building (Parkin Yarn) in Pawtucket’s local historic district, but many of the mill structures are included on the National Register of Historic Places. Cemeteries - Historically, Rhode Island communities had small farm cemeteries, and Massachusetts communities had large town and church cemeteries. Because Pawtucket originated as a Massachusetts town it has few cemeteries. Pawtucket’s eight cemeteries, each with their own unique history, total 192 acres and contain an estimated 19,000 marked graves. An unused portion of Swan Point Cemetery is also located in Pawtucket. See Table 4.3 for a listing of the affiliation and noteworthy information for each cemetery. Generally, older private cemeteries are finding it difficult to finance the continuous task of maintenance because of an inadequate fund established for perpetual care. Each private cemetery is working on its own program to meet its obligations and secure additional operating funds. Cemeteries are also plagued by vandalism. Tipped over headstones are expensive to reset and damages to sculpture and statues are expensive to repair. Table 4.3 Pawtucket Cemeteries Historic Name Cemetery # 1 Affiliation Comments City-owned Burial site of the Jenks family 2 Mineral Spring Avenue Mount St. Mary's Catholic Prospect Street 3 St. Francis Catholic Largest cemetery in Pawtucket, 4 Walnut Hill Private Armistice Boulevard 5 Oak Grove City-owned 28 acres, in active use 6 Notre Dame Catholic Daggett Avenue 7 Riverside Private 8 St. Mary's Catholic Listed on National Register of Historic Places Part of St. Mary's Church complex; Historic Source: Cultural Resources Plan, PAL, 2001. 4-16 Natural and Cultural Resources Downtown - Pawtucket’s downtown is a densely built-up area of both older and post World War II buildings. A number of structures are listed on the National Register, including the Public Library and Annex, City Hall and Slater Mill Historic Site. Pawtucket’s downtown has been the subject of numerous studies and has been the focus of redevelopment efforts in the past. Over the past decades, many of the past efforts of the City had not flourished as anticipated, until the creation of the City’s Arts and Entertainment District. In 1998, the Rhode Island General Assembly passed a law establishing an Arts and Entertainment District in an area of the City that encompasses the downtown and mill district areas (approximately 307 acres). Designated as a model development project, the State and City provide significant tax incentives to artists selling original art, who live and work within the district, and to art galleries that are established within the district boundaries. The effect on historic resources must be considered when attempting to attract new development into the downtown and in 2007 Downtown Pawtucket became a designated National Register District. With the exception of the Leroy Theater and adjacent Fanning Building, there has been very little demolition of downtown buildings in recent years. Wherever feasible, the City encourages reuse and redevelopment over demolition, particularly in the downtown core. Preservation Activities in Pawtucket City of Pawtucket - The City of Pawtucket has rehabilitated a number of important City resources using City funds and state and federal grant funds. Table 4.4 City of Pawtucket Preservation Projects Project Funding Source City Hall Tower Rehabilitation Pawtucket Public Library Slater Park Bandstand Hiker Park Rehabilitation JC Potter Casino, Slater Park City Bond Save America’s Treasures/State Preservation Grant Save America’s Treasures/RIDEM Open Space Grant – Passive and Historic Parks RIDEM Open Space Grant – Passive and Historic Parks State Preservation Grant Source: Department of Planning and Redevelopment, 2010 In addition, in 2009 the City of Pawtucket partnered with Cumberland, Central Falls and the Blackstone Valley Tourism Council to receive a Preserve America grant for the Broad Street Regeneration Initiative. This plan was prepared for Broad Street, the commercial corridor which links the three communities. The focus of the plan was on revitalization through preservation. A number of programs have resulted from the plan, including a CDBG-funded façade improvement grant program and assessment funding from the Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management. Pawtucket Historic District Commission - The most common method for municipalities to control or influence the condition of their historic areas and structures is through the use of a local Historic District Commission (HDC). The State of Rhode Island has enabling legislation, Title 45-24-1, permitting municipalities to appoint a Historic District Commission to review alterations, new construction and demolition work 4-17 Natural and Cultural Resources within a historic district, or to designated individual structures. On January 25, 1989, the Pawtucket City Council approved the appointment of the City’s first Historic District Commission. The Pawtucket Zoning Ordinance, Chapter 410, Article V, describes in more detail the powers of the Commission and their procedures for the designation and review of structures. Although the Pawtucket HDC was originally charged with protecting the Quality Hill neighborhood, the District has been expanded Citywide. The largest additions occurred in October 1997 when a total of 92 structures were added. A total of 280 public and private properties are currently under the jurisdiction of Pawtucket’s HDC Other activities of the HDC include collaborating with the Preservation Society of Pawtucket on specific projects such as the publication of neighborhood guides. The HDC applies for and receives a small amount of grant funds from the Certified Local Government (CLG) Program of RIHPHC. CLG funds have been used for the preparation of National Register nominations and the publication of tour brochures for the City’s neighborhoods. Most recently, these CLG funds were used to install historic markers designating the downtown as a National Register District. The Pawtucket Historic District Commission celebrated 20 years of service in 2009. The long-standing Chair, Fred Love, was also the recipient of the Antoinette Downing Award for Volunteer Service in Preservation. The HDC has a set of design review standards to assist local historic property owners through the Certificate of Appropriateness process. The HDC also reviews improvements to city buildings, designates new properties to the local historic district, and provide opinions and technical advice on matters affecting historic properties. Pawtucket recently became the first Rhode Island community to offer financial incentives for becoming a part of the local historic district. As of 2000, owner-occupied properties in the local historic district became eligible for a tax exemption of $30,000 on local property taxes. Also, properties in the local historic district are eligible for a state income tax credit for exterior repairs to their home. The Pawtucket Library houses a Preservation Collection to assist in public education. Public education will prove even more important over the years to come as the economic development downtown intensifies, improvements to the Pawtucket Riverfront progresses and the Zoning Ordinance is revised. The Elizabeth J. Johnson History Research Center, which is housed within the private residence of Elizabeth J. Johnson, contains her life’s work – a collection of documents and images related to the history of Pawtucket. This collection is substantial and has been utilized by researchers across the country. Currently, it is being operated by the Pawtucket Public Library, but a longterm plan for the safety of the collection and the continued access to the public is needed. Finally, the Pawtucket HDC worked with the Department of Planning and Redevelopment on the drafting of a demolition delay ordinance which would allow the City time to work with owners who propose to demolish significant historic structures within the City, even those that are not listed within the local Historic District. 4-18 Natural and Cultural Resources Community Development Block Grants - Another major event affecting historic preservation in Pawtucket was the start of the Community Development Block Grant Program in 1975. The City is eligible for a sizeable federal grant contingent on the completion of an annual application for eligible activities. As a part of the environmental review for each project, the impact on historic properties must be assessed. The City of Pawtucket continues to utilize the historical survey conducted by the Rhode Island Historical Preservation Commission in the mid-1970’s for grants and ongoing questions regarding the historical significance of houses and commercial structures in the City. During the late 1970s and 1980s, through funding from the Community Development Block Grant program, City bond issues were able to assist in the adaptive reuse of several former fire stations: 636 Central Avenue, 420 Main Street, a city ward room, several residential structures, an early gas station conversion to offices, and the early post office into a library annex. The projects, which also used private funding, are considered excellent examples of reuse. The 1980s was a decade that witnessed intense interest in orienting development and rehabilitation along the Blackstone and Pawtucket/Seekonk rivers. Some results of this effort have been the creation of Hodgson-Rotary Park (1989) and the creation of a Veterans’ Memorial Amphitheater adjacent to City Hall (1990). Several mill buildings close to the waterfront were also rehabilitated and reused, including the Green and Daniels Mill, which was converted to condominiums. Over the past five years, the city has seen many successful reuse projects. The former Peerless building on Main Street has been reused as a Visitor Center and several city agencies. The Pawtucket Armory building on Exchange Street is being reused for a number of arts-related uses. The PSP bought and rehabilitated 67 Park Place to house their organization’s office. The former Pawtucket Children’s Museum building at 58 Walcott Street in Quality Hill is now used for private functions and receptions under the business name "Grand Manor." A number of mill rehabilitation projects have successfully returned outdated industrial complexes into residences or mixed use buildings. Preservation Society of Pawtucket - The Preservation Society of Pawtucket (PSP) was incorporated in 1978 as a non-profit 501(c)(3) membership-driven community organization devoted to identifying, promoting, and encouraging the preservation of the rich historical and architectural resources of the City of Pawtucket through education, advocacy, and technical assistance. The PSP strives to protect the integrity of neighborhoods, encourage policies that foster environmental and historic preservation concerns, and promote a shared sense of community through education and advocacy. The PSP has worked with the Pawtucket Historic District Commission to research, write, and produce brochures highlighting seven of the city’s historic neighborhoods: Quality Hill Historic District, Main Street - the Jenks Settlement, the Church Hill Industrial District, Woodlawn, Pleasant View, Fairlawn, and Oak Hill. Each brochure is designed to allow a self-guided walking tour of the area, and includes notes on architectural features, anecdotal facts, and the significance of the buildings to the history of Pawtucket. The PSP has also produced a well-received children’s education program, "This is Our City", to teach 1st through 4th grade children about the history and importance of local buildings. Survey work during the past five years has included a Barton Street Study (1998), Pleasant View (1998), and the Sayles Heights Area (1998). 4-19 Natural and Cultural Resources Currently, the PSP has no paid staff. The PSP volunteer Board of Directors carries out all functions, including a quarterly newsletter. In 1999, the PSP purchased the building in which their offices are housed. Located in the historic 1823 Jonathan Baker House at 67 Park Place, the building is the earliest remaining house between the Pawtucket River and its location on Park Place, and is the only Federal Period brick house left in Pawtucket. Old Slater Mill Association - One of the early historic preservation efforts in Rhode Island occurred in 1924 when the Slater Mill building was purchased by a group of businessmen and incorporated under the name of the Old Slater Mill Association. The mill was restored to its presumed appearance of around 1835, and opened to the public in 1955. At that time, the adjacent Wilkinson Mill was still used for commercial purposes. As part of the Slater Urban Renewal Project, federal funds were used in the late 1960s to buy and restore the Wilkinson Mill and move the Sylvanus Brown House (circa 1758) to the site as part of a three-building complex. The adjacent commercial land to the south was converted into open space and named Hodgson-Rotary Park, and additional land was acquired across the Blackstone River to provide a clear view of the entire site. In the 1980s, through the use of a combination of federal, state, and foundation grants, Slater Mill was able to reconstruct the water wheel in the Wilkinson Mill and provide educational material for visitors to the mill complex. The Slater Mill Historic Site is designated as the southern anchor for Blackstone River Valley National Heritage Corridor. The opening of the Blackstone Valley Visitors Center across the street in September 1999 has served to draw even more visitors to the area. The Slater Mill Historic Site, together with assistance from local agencies, has been engaged in a comprehensive planning process to reassess its current programs and develop new attractions as a way to better serve its visitors. The City, together with the Old Slater Mill Association, has planned some major construction projects around the Slater Mill Historic Site to improve infrastructure and aesthetics at the site and as well as access to the site. John H. Chafee Blackstone Valley National Heritage Corridor Commission - The John H. Chafee Blackstone Valley National Heritage Corridor Commission commissioned a study of the Blackstone Valley Canal in Rhode Island. The Lorraine Mill area of Pawtucket was identified by this study as a key project. The City of Pawtucket is working with the property owner to prepare a conservation easement which would allow this resource to be preserved and made available to the public. Blackstone Valley Tourism Council - The Blackstone Valley Tourism Council is located in downtown Pawtucket. Part of their mission is to encourage cultural tourism within the Blackstone Valley, including Pawtucket. 4-20 Natural and Cultural Resources III. Summary of Major Issues This element has addressed the natural resources in Pawtucket. The major issue has been, and continues to be, combined sewer overflows. The Narragansett Bay Commission has begun an ambitious project to abate the pollution issues that arise from combined sewer overflows. This effort, coupled with the new RIDEM guidelines for storm water runoff, should begin to show an improvement in the quality of Pawtucket’s water resources. There are still other ground and surface water pollution problems remaining, particularly in the Pawtucket Water Supply watershed, that need to be resolved through a combination of regulations, site monitoring, individual small scale improvements, inter-municipal agreements, and resource management. Pawtucket is rich in architectural and cultural resources. The preservation of these resources requires the cooperation of the City, State, and local non-profit preservation organizations. The past five years have witnessed increased participation in preservation-related activities. The continued involvement of the City, Historic District Commission (HDC), non-profits, and non-professional advocates in preservation-related activities is important to the future success of preservation initiatives in Pawtucket. Each has broadened its membership and clarified organizational goals. Pawtucket has had a number of preservation successes, including having downtown Pawtucket listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The HDC also spearheaded an effort to introduce a demolition delay section of the City’s zoning ordinance to protect significant historic properties. 4-21 Natural and Cultural Resources SOURCES Coastal Resources Center, University of Rhode Island, “Strategy for Reducing Risks from Natural Hazards in Pawtucket, Rhode Island: A Multi-Hazard Mitigation Strategy”, 1997, 2010 City of Pawtucket, “Cultural and Natural Resources”, 1995, 2005 City of Pawtucket, “Zoning Ordinance”, Article V, Historic Districts, 1998. City of Pawtucket, Department of Planning and Redevelopment, “Local Historic District Directory”, 2002. City of Pawtucket, Department of Planning and Redevelopment, “National Register Properties Directory”, 2010. City of Pawtucket, Department of Planning and Redevelopment, “Project Impact Application”, 1999. Extrados Architects, “Pawtucket Mill Building Survey”, 1990. Hadden, Tracy and Ethan Horowitz, Brown University, “A City of Neighborhoods; Pawtucket, Rhode Island: Neighborhood Analysis and Census 2000 Update”, 2002. Pawtucket Water Supply Board, “Water Supply Management Plan”, 1998, 2007 Public Archeology Lab, “Cultural Resources”, 2001. Rhode Island Department of Administration, “Greenspace and Greenways Plan,” State Guide Plan Element 155, 1994. Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management, “Regulations for the Rhode Island Pollutant Discharge Elimination System, Storm Water Program”, 2002. Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management, “State of the State’s Waters”, 2002. Rhode Island Historic Preservation Commission, “Pawtucket, Rhode Island”, Statewide Historical Preservation Report, P-PA-2, 1978. Rhode Island Historic Preservation and Heritage Commission, “State Tax Credit Program”, 2002. Rhode Island Historical Area Zoning Act, RIGL 45-24.1, 1993. United States Department of Agriculture, “Soil Survey of Rhode Island”, July 1981. City of Pawtucket 4 - 22 Open Space and Recreation City of Pawtucket, Rhode Island Comprehensive Community Plan 2011 Update Chapter 5 – OPEN SPACE AND RECREATION Table of Contents I. Goals, Policies, and Actions 5-1 II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis 5-3 III. Summary of Major Issues 5-14 Sources 5-15 5-1 Open Space and Recreation I. Goals, Policies and Actions Goal 1. Continue to maintain and improve existing recreational and open space resources and programs. Objective 1. Maintain all of the existing recreation facilities within the City of Pawtucket. 2. Seek sites for future active and passive recreational activities which help Pawtucket to provide a balanced geographic distribution of resources. 2. Increase the number of recreation opportunities in the Barton Street neighborhood. 3. Develop recreation resources which link together City recreation sites, cultural sites, natural resource sites, etc., including the Blackstone Valley Bikeway, the Ten Mile River Bikeway, walkways along both sides of the Pawtucket River. 3. Begin work on the next segment of the Ten Mile River Bikepath within five years. 4. Begin work on the Blackstone Valley Bikeway within five years. Policy 1. Continue to improve citywide facilities. 2. Continue to implement an overall maintenance plan as well as maintenance documentation for each City facility. 3. Continue to promote and coordinate City funded activities with the private sector to expand opportunities for recreational activities and avoid duplication of services. 4. Coordinate recreational facility improvements with public school site improvements and other City and privately sponsored revitalization efforts. 5. Lease or purchase additional recreation and open space as funding becomes available. 6. Continue to make existing recreation facilities universally accessible through rehabilitation projects and include accessibility requirements in new construction. 5-1 Open Space and Recreation Actions Planning District #1 (Fairlawn) R 1 Acquire open space along the Moshassuck River and the Blackstone Canal for the creation of a greenway/bikeway. R 2 Upgrade and improve recreational resources at Morley Field. Planning District 2 (Woodlawn) R 3 Evaluate and develop school sites for potential development of additional neighborhood recreation facilities R 4 Continue progress on the Blackstone River Valley Bike Trail R 5 Expand facilities at the Town Landing recreational area. Planning District 3 (Oak Hill/West Riverview) R 6 Construct an outdoor track at Max Read Field that meets all necessary regulations to be used for scholastic track meets. R 7 Provide public access to the Seekonk River at Max Read Field. R 8 Automate irrigation and improve lighting at Wilkinson Park. Planning District 4 (Barton Street/ Downtown Area) Planning District 5 (Pleasant View) Planning District 6 (Quality Hill/East Riverview) R 9 Consider needs of the Family Y and the Pawtucket Boys’ and Girls’ Club in an overall parking plan for downtown. R 10 Add lighting at Goff lots. R 11 Evaluate development of public access to the Blackstone River north of Exchange Street. R 12 Continue field improvements at McCarthy Park including additional lighting. R 13 Reconstruct/reuse tennis courts at McCarthy Park. R 14 Develop the former State Pier, as recommended by the Riverfront Development Commission into a combination of open space, river walks, boat facilities, and commercial activity. R 15 Upgrade and improve facilities at Pariseau Field. R 16 Continue to advocate for the next segment of the Ten Mile River Bikeway. R 17 Request grant funding for the City purchase of the former “Red Farm Studios” (1135 Roosevelt Avenue) to ensure its continued availability for passive recreation. R 18 Upgrade facilities at Potter School. Planning District 7 (Darlington/Pinecrest) Planning District 8 (Slater Park and Countryside) R 19 Explore other recreational/educational/revenue producing possibilities for Daggett Farm. R 20 Continue infrastructure improvements within Slater Park including the construction of new rest room facilities, installation and of new water and fire protection services at the Looff Carousel, automated irrigation, and lighting within the Park. R 21 Engineer a solution to improve water quality in the pond and in Friendship Gardens at Slater Park. R 22 Develop parcel of land along the Ten Mile River known as Scout’s Island into a picnic area (passive park). 5-2 II. Community Profile and Needs Assessment A. Historical Perspective It is instructive to look back to the 1890’s to gain perspective on the development of open space and recreational resources in Pawtucket. In 1890, the City’s population was about 30,000 and these residents were concentrated in the area of multi-family homes surrounding the downtown business district. There were, on the western and eastern fringe of the City, large vacant tracts of land that would one day be developed into Fairlawn Veterans’ Memorial Park and Slater Park. Developed active areas for recreation were limited to several sporting fields owned by local industries and the small areas at local public schools. Several ponds on the eastern side of the City, tracts of undeveloped land, and the Pawtucket River also served as recreational resources. During the course of the following one hundred years, a combination of circumstances, some more planned than others, has led to the expansion of recreation and open space property. Slater Park was acquired in 1894 and developed in the early 20th century. A network of smaller neighborhood playgrounds such as Payne Park, John Street, Smithfield Avenue, Ayotte Park and the Goff Lots were created. The State of Rhode Island acquired title to several open space areas in Pawtucket such as the Ten Mile River Reservation and the Seekonk River Reservation, also known as Metropolitan Field. The 1960’s and 1970’s were an era when state and federal funds for acquisition and development were obtained, resulting in a considerable expansion of the recreation and open space system. All of the following facilities were either acquired or developed during this period: Morley Field, Newell Avenue Playground, Max Read Field, Lynch Ice Arena, Pariseau Field, and Dunnell Park. During the 1970’s and early 1980’s, the Slater Park Zoo was rebuilt together with other facility improvements at Slater Park. In the late 1980’s, the City secured funds to construct and upgrade many facilities including Metropolitan Field, Pariseau Field, Morley and Max Read Fields, John Street and Payne Park, and Galego Court. The 1990’s were focused on redevelopment and renovation of existing facilities, particularly Slater Park. Most recently, the City has begun expanding and upgrading playground facilities to bring them into compliance with current codes. Since 2000, some new recreational facilities have been developed in conjunction with school and parent organizations. The City has looked to the reuse of brownfield sites for potential recreation and in 2005 completed the 5-acre McKinnon/Alves soccer complex from a formerly contaminated industrial site. A skate park, along with upgrades to the basketball and tennis courts, was constructed at the Jenks Junior High School in 2009. The City’s inventory of open space and recreation land is approximately 434 acres. With widespread interest in organized recreation activity and a year round need for recreational facilities, the factors are present to make the open space and recreation element a key part of the Comprehensive Plan. City of Pawtucket 5-3 B. Description of the Area The primary zoning district for recreation areas is the Public Open district. The Public Open district is used to reserve open space, recreation, public education and municipal uses. The following map illustrates all recreation/open space areas in the City. C. Organization The recreation facilities in Pawtucket are owned by the City, the State of Rhode Island and several non-profit organizations. Approximately 426 acres of the total recreation land is owned by the City. The major recreation areas that are not City owned are Hodgson-Rotary Park, the facilities at the public housing complexes, 560 Prospect Street and Galego Court and the Lynch Arena. The City-owned arena was sold in August 2009 to a private corporation, under the agreement that the rink will continue to be accessible to the public and utilized as a recreational resource for both City and nonCity residents. Within the City, recreation facilities at schools and public housing are under the control of the School Department and the Housing Authority. The remaining City recreation facilities are the responsibility of the Department of Public Works, Division of Recreation and Parks. D. Relationship to State Recreational System The residents of Pawtucket make extensive use of the state recreational facilities. Residents utilize the beach at Lincoln Woods State Reservation. Outdoor swimming resources in Pawtucket are limited to the pool at Fairlawn Veterans’ Memorial Park. Indoor pool facilities are at the private Pawtucket Boys’ and Girls’ Club and the YMCA. The Pawtucket facilities that are most used by non-local residents are Slater Park, Lynch Arena, and the Hank Soar Softball Complex. During the summer, youth and adult softball teams use the facilities at Fairlawn Veterans’ Memorial Park, the Hank Soar Complex, Slater Park and Max Read Field. The public schools also use the recreational facilities: Max Read Field (football, baseball, soccer, track), Pariseau Field (football, soccer, walking track). The tennis courts at the Duffy Complex, Slater Park, and Veterans’ Memorial Park are also used by the public and private schools. During the winter, the Lynch Ice Arena is used by Tolman High School and St. Raphael Academy. In summary, many of Pawtucket’s recreational facilities are used by non-city residents and are an integral part of the State’s public and private schools’ athletic programs. City of Pawtucket 5-4 Open Space and Recreation 5-5 Open Space and Recreation E. Facilities Inventory Public Recreation and Open Space Facilities This section contains a summary of private and public recreation open space facilities in Pawtucket by planning district. As shown in Table 5.1, the distribution of facilities is not even. It is an established goal of this plan to have open space and recreation areas distributed equally throughout residential areas. Also, it is important that as new recreational facilities are created and existing recreational facilities rehabilitated, all resources are universally accessible and recreational opportunities for those with special needs are expanded. The 5-acre McKinnon Alves Soccer Complex, which was constructed on a remediated Brownfields site in 2005, is a major addition to the City’s recreation resources. Table 5.2 lists all of the recreational facilities, size, ownership, and facility type. Over the last 15 years, major reconstruction and renovation work has been funded through state and federal grants, community development block grants, and City bond issues. This has enabled major improvements to existing recreational resources (Slater Park, Veterans’ Memorial Park, John Street, Ayotte Park). It is also important to remember that although they are not all listed in the table, the City does provided an array of indoor recreational activities for different age groups through the Department of Parks and Recreation and the Senior Center. These activities include aerobics, dance, muscle toning, yoga and other classes which are available to Pawtucket residents at a low-cost. Private Recreation Facilities Pawtucket is fortunate to have a number of private, nonprofit institutions offering recreational opportunities to City residents. The Family Y and the Pawtucket Boys’ and Girls’ Club offer a variety of indoor activities, such as basketball leagues, swimming, aerobics and weightlifting. Outdoor activities for people of all ages are offered as well, including summer youth camps. The Boys’ and Girls’ Club share the operation and maintenance of a leased facility, McCarthy Park. Both the Boys’ and Girls’ Club and the Family Y charge membership fees. The Pawtucket Country Club operates a golf course that is located in both Seekonk, Massachusetts and Pawtucket. It is a 40-acre facility that charges membership fees. Hodgson-Rotary Park, a privately owned park at the Slater Mill, is 2.1 acres. The total area of private facilities is approximately 47 acres. River Waterfront Access There are three rivers flowing through Pawtucket, the Blackstone/Pawtucket, Ten Mile and Moshassuck, and all of them are important from the aspect of public access to the water. Clearly, the Blackstone/Pawtucket and the Ten Mile Rivers are important because of the public land along the water that could potentially be developed for water access. The City has acquired land from the Pawtucket Redevelopment Agency that will allow public access to the Blackstone River and is moving forward with plans for bike paths along both the Blackstone and Ten Mile Rivers. There is public land abutting the Moshassuck River and it is the City’s long-term goal for this land is to develop a greenway/bikeway along it. 5-6 Open Space and Recreation Table 5.1 Location of Public Recreation Areas by Planning District Planning District 1/Fairlawn 2/Woodlawn 3/Oak Hill and West Riverview 4/Barton Street and Downtown 5/Pleasant View 6/ East Riverview and Quality Hill 7/Darlington and Pine Crest 8/Slater Park and Countryside Total Facilities Smithfield Avenue Playground Fairlawn Veterans’ Memorial Park Galego Court Slater Jr. High Baldwin School* Morley Field Payne Park John Santos Park Cunningham Elementary* Randall Street Park Collyer Park Town Landing Max Read Field Perez Passive Park Thomas Duffy Complex Varieur Elementary Wilkinson Park Hodgson-Rotary Park Veterans’ Park Amphitheater Goff Lots Winters Elementary School* Jenks Junior High Ayotte Park Pariseau Field McCarthy Park Hank Soar Softball Field Berkeley Park McCoy Stadium* Agnes Little Elementary School* Dennis O’Brien Memorial Field 560 Prospect Street* State Pier John Street Playground Ten Mile River Reservation Potter Burns Elementary School* Curvin/McCabe Elementary School* Doreen Tomlinson Complex Slater Park Fallon Elementary School* McKinnon/Alves Soccer Complex Acreage 39.7 14.2 21.8 4.8 2.8 59.1 78.9 213.5 434 Source: Department of Parks and Recreation 2010 * Certain Pawtucket School recreation areas are not maintained by the Department of Parks and Recreation. 5-7 FACILITY 560 Prospect Street Ayotte Park Baldwin School Berkeley Park Collyer Park Cunningham Elementary Curvin/McCabe Elementary Duffy Complex Fallon Elementary Fairlawn Veterans’ Memorial Park Galego Court Goff Lots Hodgson-Rotary Park Jenks Junior High John Street Playground Little Elementary Lynch Ice Arena McCarthy Park McCoy Stadium McKinnon/Alves Soccer Complex Morley Field O’Brien Memorial Field Pariseau Field Payne Park Perez Passive Park Potter/Burns Elementary Randall Street Park Read Field Santos Park Slater Junior High Slater Memorial Park Smithfield Avenue Playground Soar Softball Complex State Pier Ten Mile River Reservation Tomlinson Complex Town Landing Varieur Elementary Veterans’ Park Amphitheater Wilkinson Park Winters Elementary OWNER H C C C C C C C C C H C P C C C Private C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C ACREAGE 1 1.4 0.2 0.9 0.5 0.2 0.2 1.7 0.2 39 2.5 2.4 2.1 0.9 1.4 0.2 1.7 15.8 17.9 5.0 5.3 1 5.3 1.2 1 6.8 0.1 13.5 0.1 0.4 208.3 0.7 9.6 5.1 65.5 5 5.4 0.2 0.3 0.7 0.4 1 2 3 4 5 6 • 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 • 21 22 23 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 24 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •* • • • • • • • • • • • • • • MAP KEY • • • • • • OWNERSHIP KEY 1 2 Baseball (only) Football (only) 7 8 Multi-Use Field Tennis Courts 13 14 3 4 5 6 Soccer (only) Softball (only) Volleyball (only) Basketball (only) 9 10 11 12 Public Pool Boat Ramp River Access Fishing 15 16 17 18 Picnic Area Playground w/Equipment Track Natural Areas Restrooms Hockey 19 20 Ice Skating Lights 21 22 23 24 Benches Passive Park Play Area Universal Accessibility P C H Public City Housing Authority 5- 8 Open Space and Recreation F. Open Space and Recreation Needs Assessment Assessment Perspectives Other recreation and open space assessment is restricted to comparing the amount of recreation land in a community with the standards proposed by the National Recreation Association. While an accurate measurement of the land used for open space and recreation purposes was done, the City Planning Commission is also concerned with the conditions of facilities, trends in recreational usage, funding sources and management and upkeep of facilities. This section discusses recreation and open space areas from the following perspectives: • • • • What are the population age groups of the City and what are their main requirements? How does Pawtucket fare in comparison to national standards for recreation areas? What vacant areas could be used for recreation and open space purposes? What is the recent level of expenditures in current revenue and capital improvements for the recreation system? Population Of prime importance in considering needs are the overall population of the City and the breakdown of the various age components. For the second decade in a row, the population of Pawtucket increased slightly from 72,644 in 1990 to 72,958 in 2000 and has remained relatively stable since then. An analysis of Table 5.2 shows the 25-44 year old age group is the largest in the City with approximately 23,000 people. This large group has two distinct needs: the first, for themselves as adults, and secondly, as parents interested in recreational needs for their children. Table 5.3 has been created to correlate the various age groups with the type of recreational facilities most needed. The next largest age groups are 45-64 and 5-19. The 45-64 age group is more interested in passive activities, like walking, than active ones. Like the 25-44 year olds, the 5-19 group is more interested in active recreational opportunities like skate parks, ball fields, and passive parks. Table 5.2 Population by Age Groups Age Number under 5 5 - 19 20-24 25-44 45-64 65+ Total Percentage 5,470 12,649 3,645 23,618 16,207 8,497 70,086 8 18 5 34 23 12 100 Percentage in 2000 7 21 6 31 20 15 100 Source: 2008 American Community Survey 1 Year Estimates 5-9 Open Space and Recreation Table 5.3 Recreation Requirements by Age Group Age Group Facility Under 5 Tot lots, Passive Parks, Pools 5-19 Playgrounds, Playing Fields, Open Space Areas, Passive Parks, Skate Parks, Tennis Courts, Basketball Courts, Bike Trails, Pools 20-24 Playing Fields, Skate Parks, Passive Parks, Tennis Courts, Basketball Courts, Walking Trails, Bike Trails, Pools 25-44 Playing Fields, Passive Parks, Skate Parks, Walking Trails, Bike Trails, Basketball Courts, Tennis Courts, Pools 45-64 Passive Parks, Walking Trails, Indoor Activities, Pools 65 + Passive Parks, Walking Trails, Indoor Activities, Pools Source: Department of Parks and Recreation, 2002 Recreational Standards The adequacy of recreational facilities to meet the requirements and needs of these population groups can be measured in many ways. The Parks and Recreation staff is aware of National Recreational Standards put forth by the National Recreation and Parks Association. Members of Pawtucket’s Parks and Recreation staff are members of the Rhode Island Recreation and Parks Association and attend monthly meetings and seminars to be better able to keep Pawtucket’s recreational facilities up to state and national standards. All new and reconstructed recreational facilities incorporate ADA requirements. Voter support for recreational facility development and management had been weak up until 1993. As shown in Table 5.4, “Local Recreation Bond Issues”, Pawtucket residents approved referenda totaling $3.6 million for the reconstruction and renovation of existing facilities. In 2000 a $1,500,000 bond was approved for the development of the McKinnon Alves Soccer Complex. Without capital funds, the improvement and expansion of the parks and recreation system would not progress as it has been. The improvements would be limited to those that are attainable through the annual operations and maintenance budget, which is shown in Table 5.5. 5-10 Open Space and Recreation Table 5.4 Approved Local Recreation Bond Issues Year Rehabilitation and Reconstruction 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 $250,000 $500,000 $350,000 $350,000 $250,000 $250,000 $250,000 $250,000 $300,000 $300,000 $300,000 $300,000 Source: City of Pawtucket, Finance Department 2009 Table 5.5 Parks and Recreation Division Budget Budget Category 1999-2000 2009-2010 Personnel Maintenance/Operating Programming Equipment Total $1,786,693 $ 406,699 $ 87,320 $ 17,354 $2,298,066 $1,375,171 $ 452,896 $ 104,892 $ 25,056 $1,958,015 Source: City of Pawtucket, Finance Department 2009 In Pawtucket, the responsibility for the two main functions of activity programming and facility management has been placed in one division, the Division of Recreation and Parks. There are about 28 permanent employees and additional employees are hired during the spring, summer and fall. As is evident from the bond funds utilized, the City has invested considerable time and money rehabilitating its existing recreational facilities. A good example of an improved facility is Slater Memorial Park. Slater Park is a 200acre park in Pawtucket. Over the past few years, the historic core of the park has been completely renovated including Daggett Farm (former zoo site), the Daggett House, Looff Carousel, and various ball fields. The antiquated zoo was closed in 1993. The site was reopened several years later as Daggett Farm. The farm houses many domestic plants and animals and serves as an educational resource for the public school system. There is also a cooperative agreement with RIARC in place where clients and personnel operate and maintain an active greenhouse at the farm. The Daggett House (1685), the oldest standing house in the City, was completely renovated using City funds and Champlain Foundation funds. The Looff Carousel, the oldest of its type in the world, was completely renovated in spring 2001, and the ceiling repainted in 2008. All 50 figures were historically restored, and the floor and ceiling were replaced. A 2/3 mile bike trail along the Ten Mile River through the park was completed. The ball fields at Slater Park were reconstructed and lighted and concession stands and bathrooms were constructed. The tennis courts and the picnic area were also reconstructed. A comprehensive arts program has also begun at Slater Park. This program includes 5-11 Open Space and Recreation festivals in the spring, at Halloween and during the winter, sixteen summer performances, and the annual Pawtucket Arts Festival. Open Space Protection and Recreation Area Development The City of Pawtucket is one of the most densely populated Cities in the entire state therefore the amount of viable, vacant land is limited. Over the past few years, open space protection efforts have focused on the vacant land along the riverfront. It is the City’s goal to improve public access to the river areas and create additional recreation activities linked to the river, for example, passive parks, boat landings, dock areas, fishing opportunities, and bike trails. In 2000 the City of Pawtucket has purchased two major sites along the east and west bank of the Pawtucket River and is trying to create a walkable area along both sides of the entire riverfront. The City is working to reconstruct docking facilities at one of these sites. Efforts to create the Blackstone Valley Bikeway will also provide access along the riverfront. As noted, there is limited vacant land for the development of new recreational facilities so the City of Pawtucket needs to explore alternative solutions. In 2005 the City remediated a 5-acre brownfield site and developed a first-class soccer complex which serves Pawtucket’s youth. The City is currently remediating another brownfield site, along the river, which will comprise part of the future Blackstone River Bikeway. The City is also in negotiations with a private mill owner, to purchase a parcel of land that contains an historic firepond, and could provide passive recreation opportunities. G. Coordination with Regional Needs While the emphasis of this plan is on Pawtucket, there has been a continuous examination of what is occurring in the Greater Providence Metropolitan area and the Blackstone River Valley National Heritage Corridor. With the ease of transportation in this region, many of Pawtucket’s recreational and open space resources can be considered part of the regional context. The following sections list a number of recreation areas that can be considered regional in their area of influence and the patrons they attract. Ten Mile River Bikeway In 1993, the City of Pawtucket and the City of East Provident jointly applied for funding for this bikeway as a Transportation Enhancement Project. A 3/4 mile segment in Slater Park, Pawtucket, and a just under 2 mile segment from Slater Park south to the Kimberly Ann Rock Athletic Fields in East Providence, have been completed. A segment of the Pawtucket portion of this bikeway is included in the TIP. Blackstone River System The Blackstone River Valley Heritage Corridor is very active in all areas of the Blackstone watershed. There is also the Blackstone River Watershed Council, which has been working closely with RI Department of Environmental Management to compile and adopt an Action Plan. The Action Plan, which is in draft form, addresses such topics as water quality, public and environmental health, natural, cultural and recreational resources, and sustainable economic development. 5-12 Open Space and Recreation The Blackstone River Watershed Council and the Friends of the Blackstone are working with RIDEM and NRCS to construct fish ladders at historic dams along the Blackstone. There are two fish ladders plan in Pawtucket – one at the Slater Mill Dam and one at the Main Street Dam. The City of Pawtucket is an active partner in this project, along with the Slater Mill and National Grid. This project is slated to begin in 2010. Blackstone River Bikeway Work on the Blackstone River Bikeway, which will ultimately link Providence to Worcester is ongoing. RIDEM has prepared 10% designs and the City of Pawtucket has agreements with over 80% of the landowners for potential easements and acquisitions. The next steps for this project are the development of 30% plans by RIDEM for permitting. Additional funding will be needed for the completion of the Bikeway. Pawtucket/Seekonk River The Pawtucket River flows into the Seekonk River, which opens into the Providence River and Narragansett Bay. There is a federal navigation channel up to the vicinity of the former state pier on the eastern shore, just south of Division Street. The authorized channel depth is sixteen feet. The site of the former state pier was once the location of a privately operated marina. The City has purchased the site and is exploring its potential for recreational uses. It has fishing access and a public boat launch. For the past nine years, it has also been the site of the Chinese-American Festival whose events have drawn over 1,000 people from all over New England to the site. The City of Pawtucket has utilized Brownfields Assessment money and determined the steps that need to be taken to redevelop state pier into a first-class waterfront recreational amenity, including parking facilities, landscaping and support structures. The City has requested Brownfield Cleanup funding to begin to implement these steps. New waterfront recreational activities have been created on the west bank of the river south of Division Street Bridge, just north of the former state pier. Portions of “Town Landing” have been built, including handicapped accessible fishing areas and a boat launch. There are plans to further develop the site to include a rest area and other visitor amenities. The City is working on providing landscaping and pathways at Town Landing. This work has been approved by the Coastal Resources Management Council, and is slated to begin in 2010. Moshassuck River Greenway The John H. Chafee Blackstone Valley National Heritage Corridor Commission commissioned a study of the Blackstone Valley Canal in Rhode Island. The Lorraine Mill area of Pawtucket was identified by this study as a key project. The City of Pawtucket is working with the property owner to prepare a conservation easement which would allow this resource to be preserved and made available to the public. 5-13 Open Space and Recreation III. Summary of Major Issues Over the past few years, the City of Pawtucket has utilized state and federal grants as well as local funding sources to upgrade existing recreational facilities and acquire new areas for recreational development. Because of the developed character of the City, new parcels for recreational development are scarce. The City is focusing acquisition efforts along the city’s rivers – the Moshassuck, Blackstone, Ten Mile and Pawtucket/Seekonk River corridors. These corridors offer the greatest opportunities for interconnection with adjacent community facilities. Pawtucket is also looking for creative redevelopment opportunities – like the McKinnon/Alves soccer complex – to expand its recreation and open space. As recreational facilities are continuously renovated and improved, management and maintenance of the facilities becomes more important. The Division of Recreation and Parks has and will continue to require maintenance plans for all park and recreation areas throughout the City to ensure that facilities are properly groomed, equipped and managed. 5-14 Open Space and Recreation SOURCES City of Pawtucket, “Capital and Operating Budget, FY 2002.” City of Pawtucket, “Capital Improvements Program,” Various Years. City of Pawtucket, Parks and Recreation Division, Interviews, 2002. City of Pawtucket, “Open Space and Recreation Plan,” 1995. City of Pawtucket, “Open Space and Recreation Plan Amendment,” 1998. Rhode Island Department of Administration, “Ocean State Outdoors: Rhode Island’s Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation Plan,” State Guide Plan Element 152, June 1992. Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management, “Outdoor Recreation Facility Inventory,” March 2002 5-15 Community Services and Facilities City of Pawtucket, Rhode Island Comprehensive Community Plan 2011 Update Chapter 6 – COMMUNITY SERVICES AND FACILITIES Table of Contents I. Goals, Policies, and Actions 6-1 II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis 6-3 III. Summary of Major Issues 6-20 Sources 6-22 Community Services and Facilities I. Goals, Policies and Action Items Goals: Provide the City of Pawtucket with a full range of city services and community facilities commensurate with the needs of an urban industrial city. Increase energy efficiency, Citywide. Objectives Policies Action Items 1. Get a clear benchmark of City Energy Usage 1. Regularly review and prioritize public works operations and capital need for inclusion in the five-year capital improvement program and the annual municipal budget. CS 1 Investigate opportunities for consolidating services with other Rhode Island communities to reduce costs. 2. Complete Long Term Energy and Sustainability Plan 3. Decrease GHG emissions from City assets by 10% 4. Increase energy efficiency by 10% on a BTU/ft2 basis across the City’s building portfolio 5. Improve the water quality of Pawtucket’s waterways through the elimination of combined sewer overflows by cooperation with the Narragansett Bay Commission to site combines sewer overflow treatment or mitigation facilities, as necessary. 6. Reduce the number of existing homes that are not connected to the municipal sewer system. 7. Achieve, through the recycling program, a 30 percent reduction in volume of the disposable solid waste stream to reduce the overall cost of solid waste disposal. 8. Reduce the amount of total stormwater runoff. 2. Develop renewable energy generating assets in the City and encourage the City’s use of renewable energy 3. Maintain and improve groundwater and surface water quality by requiring the use of Best Management Practices for stormwater management. 4. Utilize RIDEM’s “Standard Requirement for Subsurface Stormwater Disposal Systems within Residential Developments and Roadways”, “Land Management Project”, “Land Use and Water Quality Issues Series” and the RIDEM-USDA Soil Conservation Service “Rhode Island Soil Erosion and Sediment Control Handbook” for design guidance for all new and improved drainage systems. 5. Require developers of unserviced parcels of land to connect to municipal sewer system. 6. Preserve the Pawtucket Water Supply Board (PWSB) reservoir impoundment system to guarantee a continued source of water for future generations. 7. Explore numerous grant opportunities through EMPG, UASI and FIRE grants. CS 2 Identify a location for a new public safety complex, including parking, municipal court, police administration and communications and the fire department. CS 3 Evaluate the sewer system capacity in the Beverage Hill drainage basin to determine the causes of hydraulic overloading and develop a program for eliminating the problem. CS 4 Reserve potential sites identified by the Narragansett Bay Commission for the location of combined sewer overflow mitigation facilities. CS 5 Continue the composting program at the municipal transfer station and educate homeowners to compost landscape waste whenever possible. CS 6 Continue municipal curbside collection of residential solid waste and require commercial and industrial solid waste to be handled privately. CS 7 Where feasible, separate the sanitary sewer and the storm drainage systems and prohibit new connections of storm drains to the municipal sewer system. CS 8 Implement through the Executive Office and the PWSB, the Watershed Protection Plan, which establishes a program of land acquisition in the watershed region; requests regional communities to incorporate watershed protection policies and actions in their zoning and subdivision regulations; urges the establishment of intermunicipal agreements for watershed protection and creates a management program to protect water quality. 6 -1 Community Services and Facilities 8. Annually review through the budgetary process senior services delivery systems and levels of service to ensure efficient and effective service delivery to qualified residents. 9. Utilize to the maximum extent senior volunteer services in the operation of the senior center and to provide assistance and care to other older adults in the community. 10. Continue to be a proactive resource in the community by increasing awareness and access to library services. 11. Work independently and with local and non-profit service providers to obtain sufficient funding to meet the social service needs of Pawtucket residents. CS 9 Cooperate with the State of Rhode Island in the implementation of the Drought Management Plan as a means to reduce Rhode Island’s vulnerability to periods of low precipitation. CS 10 Establish a communications center for the Fire Department as a separate building or as a self-contained portion of a building. CS 11 Continue to pursue funding opportunities from the Federal Emergency Management Agency to assist in helping Pawtucket to be a disaster resistant community. CS 12 Implement the recommendations in “Strategy for Reducing Risks from Natural Hazard in Pawtucket, Rhode Island, A Multi- Hazard Mitigation Strategy- 2010 Update”. CS 13 Implement the recommendations in the City’s Long Tern Energy Efficiency and Sustainability Plan. CS 14 Continue operation of the Leon Mathieu Senior Center, 12. Allow the use of alternative pavement types on parking lots, sidewalks, and other vehicular storage and travel ways to reduce stormwater runoff and to preserve architectural and landscape character. 13. Consistently seek out available social service funding at all levels to apply to specific issues or geographic areas (i.e. U.S Department of Justice – Pleasant View Weed and Seed, Rhode Island Housing – Barton Street Neighborhood Revitalization). 14. Encourage through the Executive Office, the PWSB and the NBC, industrial water use conservation through exploring the use of groundwater resources, developing process water recycling and other technologies that reduce the use of potable water and volume of wastewater. CS 15 Create a task force of library neighbors to solve parking problems in the vicinity of the library. CS 16 Investigate the feasibility of establishing satellite libraries in city neighborhoods, youth centers, or gathering places. CS 17 Improve access to library resources through improvements on the library website. CS 18 Identify and prioritize the social service needs of Pawtucket residents as part of the needs assessment portion of the City of Pawtucket Federal Housing and Community Development Consolidated Plan. CS 19 Continue to evaluate alternatives for the alleviation of overcrowding and the provision of necessary classroom space at schools in need. 6 -2 Community Services and Facilities II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis A. Introduction This chapter addresses the various public services and infrastructure that the City provides for its residents. In a City the size of Pawtucket that will include ensuring that the roads are paved, storm water is collected and drained away, snow is plowed and public places well maintained, our seniors are able to reach their daily activities, critical services reach those in need, our schools in good physical condition and operating with up-to-date facilities, there is sufficient water supply to meet our residential and industrial demand and to provide adequate fire flow, the garbage is collected, the recyclables are property recycled, and the City’s sanitary waste is treated. It is the provision of these services and facilities that improve the quality of live of Pawtucket residents and the goal of this plan to promote the health, safety and welfare or the City’s citizens, its neighborhoods, and its business and industry through the provision of the necessary community services and facilities. All of these services are provided through delivery systems that are unique to the particular service. Often the service or facility is greatly affected by federal or state standards or law, or is the responsibility for the service is shared with other communities in the Blackstone Valley. These complexities can impact the cost and the effectiveness of services. For instance, the sharing of responsibilities for sanitary sewage disposal affects the cost to Pawtucket, not only for daily use, but also eventually for the elimination of combined sewer overflows. Standards for education programs and facilities and state building code requirements can influence the cost of providing building space for our schools. The National Fire Protection Standards can require substantial changes in equipment used by our fire fighters to protect their health and safety as well as to protect lives and property. Social services are provided to the City by a number of regional and state entities that must ensure that they are offering services that meet the critical needs of City residents. Changing community needs must be continually addressed as the City’s population ages pr becomes more culturally and ethnically diverse. Figure 6.1 is a map of Pawtucket’s existing community facilities. Since 2005 there have been a number of major improvements and changes that will impact the provision of community services to Pawtucket residents. The City recently constructed a state of the art animal shelter within Slater Park. This shelter can accommodate the current capacity of the City. Historic City Hall has been renovated. The Pawtucket Public Library underwent almost $1million in renovations. At the same time, due to fiscal constraints, the City has reduced its staffing. B. Public Works Pawtucket’s Department of Public Works (DPW) is comprised of eight divisions including: Parks and Recreation, Highway, City Hall Maintenance, Sewer, Sanitation and Recycling, Traffic, Engineering, Building Maintenance, and Equipment Maintenance. The Department’s facilities are located on Armistice Boulevard. A staff of 153 employees is responsible for providing the Department’s varied responsibilities. Table 6.1 describes the staffing and duties of the various Departments. 6-3 Community Services and Facilities 6-4 Community Services and Facilities Table 6.1 Public Works Departments Department Staff Description This Department maintains all passive and active parks, playgrounds Parks and 45 and traffic islands throughout the City. Among others, this includes Recreation Highway 31 City Hall Maintenance 12 Sewer, Sanitation and Recycling 34 Traffic 8 Engineering 2 Building Maintenance 9 Equipment Maintenance 14 Slater Park, Veterans Memorial Park, and the Hank Soar Complex. The Division is also responsible for recreation programming, facility operations and permits. It coordinates a wide variety of programs, performances, trips, field permits, and is also responsible for maintaining and operating Daggett Farm, and the Looff Carousel. Responsible for the maintenance and reconstruction of approximately 200 miles of City streets and curbing including the coordination and supervision of outside contractors. Street sweeping services are provided from April through November and snow removal and icy road condition control during the winter months. The Division coordinates the Youth Litter Corps during the summer, operates the Blackstone Valley Regional Transfer Station on Grotto Avenue, and controls the compost site where the fall leaves are composed into usable mulch. The City owns two cemeteries, the Mineral Spring Cemetery and the Oak Grove Cemetery, both of which are maintained by the Highway Division. Responsible for all custodial services for City Hall, Police Station, Police Annex, Public Works Center, Senior Center, Slater Park Office, VIN Station, Fire Station Main Office, and Library. Responsible for one weekly trash and recycling pick-up services to Pawtucket residents by City trucks, and bulky waste metals by appointment. The Division also maintains approximately 200 miles of sanitary storm water lines within the City’s sewer system, including maintenance and cleaning of the system’s 6,000 catch basins and the operation and maintenance of the City’s five sewage pumping stations. Responsible for the design, layout, installation, repair and replacement of the City’s traffic control devices, and establishing and implementing detours and road closures for many public and private events. The Division also conducts studies and analysis on improving and reducing congestion and accidents, improving conditions for motorist and pedestrians, and safety through the usage, upkeep and recalibration of traffic control devices. Responsible for the 50-50 sidewalk program, inspection of new sewer tie-ins, survey crews for all new municipal construction and rehabilitation, maintenance of Tax Assessor’s maps, utility maps, sewer pipe location maps, and blue prints and records for all municipal facilities. The division is also beginning to become more involved in the management and upkeep of the City’s GIS database. Maintains all City-owned buildings and providing related services including building, remodeling, installation of air conditioners, painting, wallpapering, laminate work, basic plumbing, maintenance of underground sprinkler systems, restrooms and concession stands, including all winterization of facilities. Electricians maintain electrical systems in all City-owned buildings and maintain lights for ball fields as well as the lighting at Slater Park. The division builds, paints, assembles and maintains stages for City run special events. Responsible for the maintenance of the entire vehicular fleet under the Public Works, Police, Fire, Library and Senior Center. The division also maintains and repairs all small engine equipment, orders and apportions all fuel, and performs all welding and fabricating. 6-5 Community Services and Facilities Source: Department of Public Works, 2010 C. Public Buildings The City owns and maintains approximately 318,600 square feet of floor space in 35 buildings. These facilities include administrative offices and operations as well as Fire and Police, Library, Public Works and City Hall. Table 6.2 provides a more detailed summary of the municipal buildings. Table 6.2 City of Pawtucket, Municipal Buildings Building Name Location Original Const. Date/Renovations Type Total Area City Hall – includes Police Station & Fire Station #2 Public Works Center Deborah Cook Sayles Library Roosevelt Avenue 1934/2006 Masonry 59,900 Armistice Boulevard 13 Summer Street 1967 1899-02 / 1962-67 Steel Masonry 34,800 20,564 Gerald S. Burns Library Annex Fire Station #1 Fire Station #3 Fire Station #4 Fire Station #5 Fire Station #6 Slater Park Office Daggett House Boat House Daggett Farm Building and Gift Shop Lynch Ice Arena Municipal Transfer Station Water Supply Board Water Treat. Facility Animal Shelter Senior Center Remodeled New Horizons Day Care Carpenter Shop Cemetery Office Cemetery Office (Oak Grove) Parking Garage Quonset Hut #1 Welding Shop Police Annex Walter Gatchell Wardroom Darlington Girls Softball League Concession Stand Darlington American Little League Concession Stand Looff Carousel Hank Soar Restrooms Veterans Memorial Park Pool Locker Rooms Fairlawn Little League Concession Stand Morley Field Concession Stand and Restrooms Max Read Concession Stand and Restrooms Pariseau Concession Stand and Restrooms Tomlinson Concession Stand and Restrooms 13 Summer Street 1896-99 / 1980-81 Masonry 22,111 394 West Avenue 2 Columbus Ave 397 Cottage Street 301 Smithfield Ave 385 Newport Ave Slater Park Slater Park Slater Park Slater Park 1901 1957 1974 1963 1948 1874 1685 1917 / 1981 Masonry Masonry Masonry Masonry Masonry Wood Wood Masonry Masonry 5,070 5,266 7,870 5,106 4,775 1,320 2,178 4,552 4,962 Beattie Street Grotto Avenue Branch Street Mill St, Cumberland Slater Park Original Fire Station 420 Main Street Adjacent to 420 Main Armistice Boulevard Armistice Boulevard Central Avenue 1973 / 1979 1963 1880 / 1980 1941 Rebuilt 2008 1896 1980 1920 / 1989 1981 1850 1880 Masonry Masonry 30,926 17,194 Masonry Masonry 10,000 8,842 Masonry Masonry & Wood Masonry Wood 2,400 288 1,530 Main Street Armistice Boulevard Armistice Boulevard Armistice Boulevard 171 Fountain Street Slater Park 1978 1986 1887 2000 Masonry Metal Metal Masonry Masonry Masonry 60,168 4,000 2,000 2,400 Slater Park 1998 Masonry 1,152 Slater Park Prospect Street Smithfield Avenue/ Vets Memorial Park Smithfield Avenue/ Vets Memorial Park Moshassuck Street 1910 1990 Wood Masonry Masonry 3,600 1,170 4,280 2002 Masonry 672 Masonry 602 Masonry 900 Masonry 336 Masonry & Wood 1,296 Pleasant Street Division Street Daggett Avenue 2001 456 6-6 Community Services and Facilities Source: Pawtucket Department of Public Works, 2010 Several City owned buildings are leased to private organizations including: Daggett Farm Greenhouse and Gift Shop to the Rhode Island Association of Retarded Citizens (RIARC), Daggett House at Slater Park is leased to the Daughters of the American Revolution, the Boat House at Slater Park is leased to the Rhode Island Watercolor Society, and the Walter Gatchell Wardroom is leased to the Gatchell Post VFW. As noted on Table 6.2, many of the public buildings date back to the early 1900’s and require constant upkeep, maintenance and repair work. Since 2005, a significant number of building repairs have been completed on municipal buildings including the rehabilitation of the City Hall Tower, as well as interior upgrades. The Pawtucket Public Library was further waterproofed. The Pawtucket Animal Shelter was rebuilt. Public Buildings are valuable community assets that should be properly maintained. As building codes change and building uses evolve, the space often requires renovations that go beyond simple maintenance. The City has a base of information that has been used to formulate cost estimates to support bond referendum to pay for building repairs. This database should be expanded to include all City-owned buildings and the data should be standardized and computerized to allow for prioritization of needs. D. Sewage Collection, Treatment and Disposal The City of Pawtucket is virtually 100% sewered. The existing sewer system is primarily a combined system collecting both sewage and storm water. Historically, the construction of sewers was begun in the Blackstone and Moshassuck Valley areas in the late 1800’s. The Blackstone Valley System was allowed to discharge untreated wastewater directly into the river up until 1954 when the Blackstone Valley District Commission, now the Narragansett Bay Commission (NBC), was formed. Currently, all sewers within the Pawtucket sewer system discharge to NBC interceptor sewers that convey flows to the Bucklin Point wastewater treatment plant in East Providence. The City owns and maintains approximately 200 miles of collector sewers that directly service the City’s residents. The City also owns and maintains as a part of the collection system, five (5) wastewater pumping facilities. These facilities provide for sewer service to lower lying areas, primarily along the Ten Mile River. Table 6.3 provides a summary of the wastewater pumping stations, including capacities. Operation and maintenance of the local sewer system is provided through the City’s Department of Public Works – Sewer, Sanitation and Recycling Division. Table 6.3 Wastewater Pumping Stations, Pawtucket, Rhode Island Station 1 2 3 4 5 Capacity 367 gpm at 65’ TDH 160 gpm at 55’ TDH 50 gpm at 30’ TDH 100 gpm at 44’ TDH 100 gpm at 40’ TDH Size Force Main 6” 4” 4” 4” 4” Construction Date 1980 1984 1979 1978 1984 Location Narragansett Park Slater Park Parkside Pinecrest Branch Street Source: Pawtucket Department of Public Works, 2003 6-7 Community Services and Facilities Combined Sewer Overflows Flows from Pawtucket’s collector sewer system go into NBC’s interceptor sewers. Considering the system’s dual function as sewer and storm water collectors, wet weather flows increase dramatically beyond the existing pipe capacities. A series of combined sewer overflow (CSO) structures along the Blackstone and Seekonk Rivers provide relief by allowing direct overflow of the system into the River. A total of 19 combined sewer overflows fall within Pawtucket’s city limits. E. Solid Waste Management The collection of the City’s residential waste is performed through the Department of Public Works, Sewer, Sanitation and Recycling Division. Once per week curbside trash pickup service is provided to City residents through the Division’s five daily collection routes. Trash collected by the Division is delivered to the City’s Transfer Station on Grotto Avenue for ultimate disposal at the State’s Central Landfill facility in Johnston, RI. The Transfer Station is operated at the former City incinerator building and used the existing facilities, with minor modifications, to accommodate roll-off containers and a hydraulic compactor. In 2009, the Director of Public Works presented a plan for pay as you throw in the City of Pawtucket. This proposal was, unfortunately, not successful. In an effort to still reduce the amount of waste generated, the Director proposed an alternative plan – mandatory recycling. The City of Pawtucket will not pick up trash unless there are also recycling containers present. These efforts have begun to reduce trash and increase recycling within the City. Table 6.4 describes the amount of recycling in Pawtucket before and after the program has been implemented. These figures only represent ten weeks of “After Program”. However, they do show a trend toward increased recycling, especially since there were a number of issues with non-compliance within the first few weeks of the program. Table 6.4 Average Weekly Waste/Recycling Collected, 2010 Before Program After Program Difference Total Tonnage 459 427 -32 Trash Tonnage 394 340 -53 Recycling Tonnage 64 86 +21 Recycling as percent of Total 14 20 +6 Department of Public Works, 2010 Considering the limited remaining life at the state’s Central Landfill in Johnston, recycling and source reduction options will play a key role in helping the City maintain an affordable trash collection and disposal system. The Division plans to pursue source reduction and recycling options to reduce the City’s solid waste stream through various public awareness campaigns, including a twice per year newsletter for recycling and sanitation. An oil “igloo” container is also available for recycling crankcase oils from City residents. Tires are separated from the waste stream as a matter of typical operation, but recycling opportunities are limited and constantly changing. The Division also operated a 6-8 Community Services and Facilities composting program for leaves, grass clippings and Christmas trees. facilities are located at the City’s Transfer Station. Composting F. Stormwater Management Only very limited sections of the sewer system has been separated. Accordingly, the existing infrastructure must accommodate widely fluctuating flows during wet and dry weather. The City’s storm water system includes approximately 6,000 catch basins over 200 miles of streets and sewers. Operation and maintenance of the system including catch basin cleaning and disposal, street cleaning, the flushing of dead end streets, replacement of frames and grates, and other minor pipe cleaning repairs are performed by the Sewer, Sanitation and Recycling Division of the Department of Public Works. The National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Phase I storm water program, initiated in 1990, required discharges from large construction sites, certain industrial activities and operators of medium or large municipal separate storm sewer systems (more than 100,000 served), to obtain permits and implement a storm water management program as a means to control polluted discharges from these activities. Since 1984, RIDEM has been delegated the authority to implement the NPDES program in Rhode Island (RIPDES Storm Water Program, 2002). The EPA finalized the Storm Water Phase II Rule on December 8, 1999. It requires municipal separate storm sewer systems to obtain permits and establish a storm water management program that is intended to improve water bodies by reducing the quantity of pollutants that can enter storm sewer systems during storm events. The Storm Water Phase II Rule extends the coverage of the NPDES storm water program to include small municipal separate storm sewer systems. The Phase II Rule automatically covers all small municipal separate storm sewer systems located in urbanized areas as defined by the Bureau of the Census, which includes Pawtucket. (RIPDES Storm Water Program, 2002). Pawtucket has amended its Zoning Ordinance to ensure that new development complies with requirements for stormwater control. The Division will continue to pursue funding sources for the separation of storm and sanitary sewers to comply with EPA and RIDEM standards. G. Water Supply, Treatment, and Distribution The Pawtucket Water Supply Board (PWSB) through a system utilizing both surface and groundwater sources, supplies water to the City of Pawtucket, the City of Central Falls and the Valley Falls portion of Cumberland. The original system was established in 1875. Up until 1970, the water system was operated and maintained by the City’s Department of Public Works, at which time the PWSB was established to take over all aspects of the water system. Service Area The PWSB system is one of the larger water suppliers in the state, serving approximately 99,000 customers in Pawtucket, Central Falls, and the Valley Falls portion of Cumberland. The PWSB has wholesale contracts with Seekonk, who has not used PWSB water since 2001, and Cumberland. The PWSB currently has emergency interconnections with Seekonk, Lincoln, Attleboro, East Providence, and the Providence Water Supply Board. The service area is almost fully developed and includes similar 6-9 Community Services and Facilities proportions of medium/high density residential, commercial and industrial zoning. (PWSB, Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update, 2007). Water Sources The source of the PWSB water supply is the Abbott Run watershed, a sub basin of the Blackstone Valley Drainage Basin. The watershed covers an area of about 27.8 square miles in the Town of Cumberland, RI and the Towns of Wrentham, Franklin, Plainville, North Attleboro and Attleboro, Massachusetts. The Diamond Hill Reservoir is the first and largest of the ponds and impoundments that make up the surface water supply. It was originally constructed in 1887, has been enlarged twice, and has a storage capacity of 3,666 million gallons of water. Downstream is the Arnold Mills Reservoir. It was constructed in 1927 and can store up to 1,165 million gallons of water. There are four other smaller ponds along the seven-mile length of Abbott Run. The Robin Hollow Pond and the Happy Hollow Reservoir are owned by the PWSB. The total available storage in these ponds is about 135 million gallons. Rawson Pond and Howard Pond are privately owned. The total storage in these ponds is about 43 million gallons. (PWSB, Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update, 2007). The PWSB owns and operates a series of eight wells along Abbott Run that can supplement the surface water supply. The groundwater recharge area for these well generally falls within the surface water watershed area. The PWSB has withdrawn groundwater at various times, most often during the summer months. The PWSB has plans to replace well #2. The safe yield of surface sources is 15-17 million gallons daily from surface supplies and 3.6 million gallons daily from groundwater supplies, making the combined water supply safe yield approximately 18.6 – 20.6 million gallons daily. (PWSB, Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update, 2007). Water Quality Protection The PWSB completed an inventory of known potential pollution sources in the Abbott Run watershed in 1999 (1999 Pollution Source Inventory). This inventory identifies the type of potential contamination and the proximity to key PWSB water sources. The RI Department of Health conducted a source water assessment of the Abbott Run watershed in 2003. Both these studies were updated in the 2007 Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update. Overall, the Pawtucket supply has been assessed as highly susceptible to contamination. The PWSB completed a Watershed Management and Protection Plan in 1999. This was also updated in the 2007 Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update. This Plan specifies a comprehensive set of plans and programs that will work to protect the raw water supply of the PWSB. Highlights of the plan include: • Wellhead & Surface Water Protection Plans • Raw & Treated Water Quality Monitoring Programs • Watershed Management GIS System. This will allow the PWSB to both consider the impacts of land use and zoning throughout the watershed and more effectively monitor water quality and other conditions. Current protection measures are limited to fences, signs and field inspections. The portion of the watershed owned by the PWSB has some signs to prevent trespassing and illegal dumping. Signs that warn that the watershed area is protected are posted in 6-10 Community Services and Facilities many locations. Frequent field inspections are valuable for catching day-to-day incidents like vandalism, and anticipating trouble spots. Inspections also provide information for communicating and coordination with police, fire, and public works departments in the six communities spanned by the Abbott Run Watershed. A contracted security company patrols the reservoir areas regularly. The PWSB has been involved in land purchases in the watershed area. A land purchase priority list has been compiled and the PWSB has used this list to negotiating land purchases utilizing funds from the water quality surcharge administered by the RI Water Resources Board. Water Treatment The new treatment plant went online March 17, 2008. The existing eight (8) wells will be reconfigured to pass through a Cascading Aeration Unit (for radon), then blended with raw water from Happy Hollow, discharged directly to the Johnson Intake Screen at the new raw water pump station, and then treated with permanganate (for iron and manganese). This will also help initial treatment of the well supplies in the Happy Hollow Reservoir itself prior to treatment in the water treatment plant. Distribution System Pumping Stations -There are two standby pump stations in the PWSB system that have the ability to pump treated water into the transmission and distribution system. Branch Street (Station 4) is located at 85 Branch Street in Pawtucket. In 1983, five new pumps were installed at this facility: three 9 MGD pumps, one 6 MGD pump and one 3 MGD pump. Original design capacity was 36 MGD but due to impeller trimming and operating inefficiency, the current estimated output capacity equals 27 MGD. In 1993, the PWSB replaced the impellers and installed new surge control valves. (PWSB, Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update, 2007). The second pump station is also on Branch Street (Station 1). It is also located at 85 Branch Street and is an emergency station consisting of one 9 MGD pump coupled to a diesel engine. This pump has been run periodically during power outages. (PWSB, Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update, 2007). Transmission System - The PWSB owns and operates a total of 263 miles of transmission and distribution water main. Approximately 18 percent of these mains are unlined cast iron pipe. All water mains 16 inches and larger are considered transmission mains and do not have water services. The total length of transmission mains is approximately 22 miles. (PWSB, Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update, 2007). Water is conveyed from the treatment plant by a combination of four 13 million gallon per day MGD pumps located in the treatment plant. The pumping station delivers water into a network of transmission mains, which convey the water to the storage facilities at Stump Hill, and into the distribution mains to the customers. (PWSB, Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update, 2007). Water Services - The PWSB meters 100 percent of its customers and maintains two types of billing periods. Residential and small industrial customers (approximately 22,800 accounts) are billed on a quarterly basis; this group represents approximately 99.6% of the PWSB customer base. There are approximately 100 large industrial and 6-11 Community Services and Facilities commercial customers that are billed on a monthly basis. Management Plan 5-year Update, 2007). (PWSB, Water Supply In 1988, the average water use was 13.0 MGD then decreased to 12.3 MGD in 1989. In 1992, the average water use was 14.3 MGD. In 2000, the average daily demand was 12.8 MGD, in 2008 the average daily demand dropped dramatically to 9.8 MGD. (PWSB, Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update, 2007). System Management Leak Detection and Repair - From July 1985 to May 1986, the PWSB employed the services of Heath Consultants, Inc. of Stoughton, Massachusetts to conduct a Leak Detection Program. During this time, every section of the water main owned by the PWSB was (233.53 miles) was inspected using a sensitive sonic detection instrument. The survey was successful in locating a total of 88 leaks, with an estimated loss of 2.6 million gallons per year. 79% of the leakage was service related, 16% of leakage was hydrant related and 5% of the leakage was water main related. Each of these leaks was repaired. The PWSB does not currently employ an active Leak Detection and Repair (LDR) Plan. The PWSB has requested funding for a LDR Plan including equipment and funding for a position through the PUC. The PUC has previously only approved funding for equipment and no funding for a position/manpower or training. The PWSB will look to implement a formal LDR Plan pending approval of funding by the PUC for both leak detection equipment and funding of personnel and training. The PWSB has been replacing, cleaning, and lining mains as part of its Capital Improvements Plan since 1988. The PWSB has approximately 27% of its system in need of repair (cleaning and lining) or replacement as of 2007. Through this program the PWSB has had the ability to review and evaluate water mains within its system. This Capital Improvements Plan has rendered more than 70% of the PWSB water mains in good or new condition. The implementation of this aggressive improvement plan has ultimately achieved the objective of a leak detection and repair plan; the identification and correction of water main defects. (PWSB, Water Supply Management Plan 5-year Update, 2007). Capital Improvement Plan - The PWSB maintains a comprehensive capital improvement plan (CIP) that is updated on a yearly basis. The capital improvement plan outlines capital improvements for raw water, treatment and distribution facilities for the next 20 years. Capital improvements can be funded in two main ways: (1) pay-as-yougo Infrastructure Replacement Fund dollars which are collected through water sales revenue; (2) Clean Water Finance (CWF) low interest loans paid through debt service. The PWSB recently took advantage of the Federal Stimulus money and received ~23% principle forgiveness on a main replacement project. H. Public Safety Emergency services are provided to the community through the Department of Public Safety, which includes the Police, Fire and Emergency Management Departments. The Mayor is the supervisor of the entire Department of Public Safety. 6-12 Community Services and Facilities Police Department The Police Department is headquartered in the City Hall complex on Roosevelt Avenue. All administrative functions and temporary lock-up facilities are located at this office. The Department’s vehicular fleet operates from facilities on Armistice Boulevard, adjacent to the Public Works Department Complex. For the year 2001, the Department received 67,805 calls resulting in a total of 14,505 written reports. The Department currently has 153 authorized police officers. The personnel breakdown includes: 1 – Chief; 3 – Police Commanders; 5 – Captains; 8 – Lieutenants; 22 – Sergeants; 20 – Detectives and 94 – Patrolmen. The Department also employs 63 civilian personnel, which includes, among others, school crossing guards, animal control officers, VIN station inspectors, and police signal operators. Fire Department The Fire Department maintains 6 active stations serving the City. Table 6.6 lists the existing fire stations. The Department is headquartered at the City Hall complex on Roosevelt Avenue and provides operational service through 2 shifts per day, 24 hours per day, 7 days per week, and 365 days per year. The Department currently has a Class 2 ISO Rating, which reflects favorably on the Department’s fire prevention and fire fighting capabilities. The rating also affects insurance rates for residential, commercial and industrial buildings. The Department maintains full fire fighting capabilities for multistory building fires. This is an important for the several multi-story residential complexes for seniors in the City. The Fire Department employs total staff of 146 and provides operational service through 2 shifts per day. Each shift is staffed by a Battalion Chief and provides a minimum staff manpower of 31 per shift. The Department staff personnel include the following: 1 – Chief; 1 – Assistant Chief; 4 – Battalion Chiefs; 8 – Captains; 28 – Lieutenants; 6 – Rescue Lieutenants; 2 – Rescue Captains; 98 – Fire Fighters. The standard for Fire Department staffing requirements is generally five full time fire fighters per 1,000 dwelling units. Based on the current number of full time personnel in proportion to the 2000 count of dwelling units, 31,360, a net deficiency of 11 fire fighters exists. Considering the slow population increase that is projected for the next 10 years and the slow rate of new dwelling unit construction, this deficiency is not expected to increase significantly. As shown on Table 6.5, all of the existing fire stations are old structures ranging in age from 102 to 28 years old. Station 4 at 397 Cottage Street is the most recent structure, built in 1974. All of the stations require varying degrees of improvements to correct Building and Life Safety Code deficiencies. The Fire Department has identified potential improvements approaching $1 million to correct existing deficiencies. An extensive rehabilitation of the exterior of West Avenue was completed in 2002 to ensure that the structure remain a focal point of the neighborhood and retain its historic character. Exterior rehabilitation of the other facilities in the City is also necessary. Interior rehabilitation of the West Avenue structure as well as the other structures is necessary to update heating systems, electrical wiring, and plumbing fixtures. 6-13 Community Services and Facilities Table 6.5, Pawtucket Fire Stations Station Number Location Construction Date 1 394 West Avenue 1901 2 Roosevelt Ave./ City Hall 1937 3 2 Columbus Avenue 4 Building Type Area (Sq. Ft.) 2 Story Masonry 2 Story Masonry 5,070 1957 1 Story Masonry 5,266 397 Cottage Street 1974 1 Story Masonry 7,870 5 301 Smithfield Avenue 1963 1 Story Masonry 5,106 6 385 Newport Avenue 1948 2 Story Masonry 4,775 Equipment Staff per Shift 1 – Engine 5 1 – Rescue 1 – Engine 7 1 – Ladder 1 - Marine 1 – Battalion 1 – Chief 1 – Engine 4 1 – Marine 1 – Res.Lad. 1 – Res.Res. 1 – Engine 8 1 – Ladder 1 – Rescue 1 – Engine 3 1 – Res.Eng. 1 – Res.Res. 1 – Engine 7 1 –Res.Eng. Pawtucket Fire Department, 2009 The Fire Department’s primary equipment includes six engines (pumper trucks), two aerial ladder trucks and two rescue units, each providing advanced life support (ALS) system capability. The Department also maintains reserve equipment including two pumper trucks, one aerial ladder truck and two rescue units. Many of the vehicles are over 10 years old. Replacement, up grading and life cycling of the Department’s fleet should be continued. Emergency Management and Response Man made disasters (fire, chemical spills, terrorist attacks, and acts of war against the United States) and natural disasters (floods, hurricanes, blizzards) are destructive and disruptive events that can affect any community. Past disasters have taught valuable lessons on mitigation and recovery out of which has emerged the field of emergency preparedness. The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) is the federal branch of emergency preparedness assisting communities to recover from disaster as well as assisting them in becoming disaster resistant. In the northeast, FEMA has been most active in establishing development codes for regulating building in flood prone areas. All states now have emergency management agencies, as do many large cities. Pawtucket has a Director of Emergency Management housed at the new Office of Emergency Management and Emergency Operations Center located at 260 Armistice Boulevard. In the case of an emergency, the office of the Director of Emergency Management will coordinate all essential operations at the Emergency Operations Center. Based on the incident type the Director will utilize his/her ESF partners to prepare, respond, mitigate and recover from the manmade or natural disaster. The Emergency Management Agency has signed MOU contracts with Rhode Island Emergency Management, American Red Cross, First Student Bus Company, and has designated shelters in the city which include Jenks Junior High School, Baldwin Elementary School, Varieur 6-14 Community Services and Facilities Elementary School, Curvin McCabe Elementary School and Nathaniel Greene Elementary School. These locations are designated as emergency shelters in case of a natural disaster, but can be utilized as a Point of Distribution (POD) as well. The completion of “A Strategy for Reducing Risks from Natural Hazards in Pawtucket Rhode Island” was integral in the city receiving $300,000 from the Federal Emergency Management Agency in 1999 to implement projects that would reduce flood risks in the City. This funding enabled the City to be proactive in creating a disaster resistant community. As a result of the funding, a number of important projects were completed including; rebates to approximately 35 residents for installing backflow prevention valves, installation of an emergency generator connection at the Senior Center, installation of backflow prevention valves at City Hall, the Roosevelt Avenue Fire Station and Police Headquarters. Designing and printing of Disaster Preparedness Coloring Book to educate young children about disaster preparedness, training sessions for a variety of special interest groups including Post Disaster Recovery for municipal and private industry and general training for boards and commissions, and a complete catch basin cleaning of the Darlington area of Pawtucket where major street flooding has recently occurred. The City also obtained a Class 8 rating from FEMA’s Community Rating System, entitled affected properties to lower flood insurance rates. Most recently the Pawtucket Emergency Management Agency opened a regional Emergency Operations Center (EOC) located at 260 Armistice Blvd utilizing $ 286,900 of UASI grant funding. Pawtucket is in the processing of completing an update to the Strategy. The implementation items from this plan are incorporated into this plan as Appendix C. The Director of Emergency Management also acts as the liaison for Emergency-911 (E911). Those responsibilities include the review and update of the E-911 Master Street Guide (MSG) annually or as often as requested, verification and confirmation of street ranges, check and correction of incorrect addresses, verification and confirmation of new locations and addresses, and attendance at state and regional meetings and workshops as scheduled. The Director of Emergency Management also sits on the Urban Area Security Initiative (UASI) Stakeholders group representing the City on grant funding which is made available to the City. I. Senior Services The Leon Mathieu Senior Center was designated as Pawtucket’s community focal point on aging in November 1, 1980. The facility opened after the major renovation of a vacant Fire Station and was funded by Community Development Black Grant and Title V of the Older Americans Act monies. The Rhode Island Department of Elderly Affairs was an integral participant. The Leon Mathieu Senior Center has demonstrated its capability to provide comprehensive services to its elderly population. The Senior Center enjoys its positive community image of providing full access to information and services available through all federal, state, and local sources with an emphasis upon targeting services to low and low-moderation income individuals. The Senior Center offers a variety of programs which include: support services, a monthly newsletter, daily exercise classes, monthly health screenings, educational programs, tax preparation, arts and crafts, information and referrals on resources, programs and services available locally, statewide and 6-15 Community Services and Facilities federally, RIPTA bus passes, Senior Health Insurance Programs, Alzheimer’s Alert Program and RI Pharmaceutical Assistance to the Elderly. One of the most successful programs of the Senior Center is the Check ‘Em Program run in conjunction with the Police Department. The Check ‘Em Program is a telephone reassurance system that will call senior 60 years of age or older living in their own home, or who live in private apartment, to ensure that they are okay. This is a potential life saving program that is free to Pawtucket residents. It is especially comforting to children living out of state with an older parent living along. An automated call is placed in the morning. If there is no answer, the call is placed again every 15 minutes for 45 minutes. If there is still no answer, a policeman is dispatched to check on them. Although the number of people enrolled in the program is constantly changing, the program averages about 100 participants. After a 16-month evaluation and application period, the Leon Mathieu Senior Center became nationally accredited by the National Council on the Aging’s National Institute of Senior Centers, as of January 2002. The Center is one of 14 accredited senior centers in Rhode Island and one of fewer than 100 accredited senior centers nationally. J. Library Services The Pawtucket Public Library is a facility made up of two connected buildings, both of which are on the National Register of Historic Places. The buildings provide 42,675 square feet for library use including seating for 225 users and a 100-seat auditorium. The library is open 64 hours per week, a reduction from previous years. The library also has a bookmobile that delivers library services to Pawtucket neighborhoods and schools. The library owns over 180,000 items, including books, videos and audio materials. Not included in this number are periodicals and the many on-line resources that the library subscribes to and makes available to its users in the building and through the library’s website www.pawtucketlibrary.org. The library is a member of a network of public libraries in the state that share a common database and circulation system. They purchase many items as a group at a discounted rate. Interlibrary loan is provided to library users through a multi-type statewide library network called Library of Rhode Island. Library services include traditional information/reference service, circulation of materials, and programs for children, young adults, and adults. Two of the library’s most popular programs are computer workshops and literacy classes. The library provides meeting room space for community meetings, access to the Internet and personal computers for public use. The library’s website includes information about the library’s services, library’s catalog, links and on-line resources our users find invaluable. The library has seen increased usage as a result of the difficult economic times. People are borrowing more books and media, using the libraries computers for job searching and to further their education. They are attending the library’s free programs for entertainment. The waiting lists for English language literacy and computer classes continue to grow 6-16 Community Services and Facilities K. Social Services The City of Pawtucket is an active partner in the network of social service providers that assist Pawtucket residents. Whether hosting monthly strategy sessions around the issues of juvenile justice (Comprehensive Strategy) and substance abuse (Pawtucket Prevention Strategy Coalition) or directly obtaining specific social service targeted funding (i.e., Woodlawn Weed and Seed), the City of Pawtucket is constantly working to enhance the resources available to address the social service needs of Pawtucket residents. The City of Pawtucket has, and will continue to, partner with area interest groups and providers to define the nature and extent of social service issues, lend technical expertise, develop appropriate programmatic responses, identify available resources, apply and lobby for grant and legislative monies, and participate in implementation efforts. L. Public Schools The Pawtucket School System consists of 10 elementary schools, 3 junior high schools, and 3 senior high schools and the school administration building. Since the 2005 update one elementary school, the Webster Street School, which was leased to address elementary school overcrowding, is no longer utilized. The City of Pawtucket also added the Jacqueline M. Walsh School for Performing and Visual Arts, a high school, in 2006. The oldest facility in the system is Slater Junior High School (1915) while the newest schools are Jenks Junior High and Curvin McCabe Elementary School (both 1977). Table 6.6 provides an overview of the different facilities, including current enrollment and estimated student capacity for each school. Enrollments have been decreasing since a historic high of 12,474 students in 1970. Between 1990 and 2000, enrollments have risen in elementary schools by 15%, in junior high school by 35% and high school by 17%. Since 2000, elementary school and junior high school enrollment has begun to drop, and from 2002 to 2010 total enrollment fell by 15%. However, in the last year, this trend is reversing. Due to both the closing of many Catholic schools, and the impact of the economic recession, there are fewer children attending private and parochial schools. The number of children in private or religious schools went from 2,044 in 2000 to 1,357 in 2010. Right now this increase is only at the Elementary School level, however, in the future it will affect all grade levels. Refer to Table 6.6 for a summary of Pawtucket’s school facilities, and Table 6.7 for City enrollment history. Projections provided by the New England School Development Council predict an increase of 3.5% from 2010 to 2020, but these projections do not take these two factors into account. The Pawtucket School Department predicts a greater increase in enrollment over the next ten years. 6-17 Community Services and Facilities Table 6.6 Pawtucket Public School Facilities Facility Enrollment 2009 Capacity (estimated) Remaining Capacity Construction Date Baldwin Cunningham 725 501 755 597 30 96 1963/1974 1965 Curtis 327 364 37 1956/1965 Curvin/McCabe 448 510 62 1977 Fallon Greene Little Potter/Burns Varieur Total Elementary 556 549 425 558 382 4,913 699 571 449 556 360 5,343 143 22 24 -2 -22 430 1949/1968 1918 1967 1919 1971 Goff Jenks Slater Total Junior High 488 515 549 1,552 665.4 620 693.4 1,979 177.4 105 144.4 426.8 1931 1977 1915 Shea Tolman Jacqueline M. Walsh Total Sen. High 958 1,154 125 2,267 1,016 1298.8 58 144.8 1940 2,455 202.8 Source: Pawtucket School Department 2010 Table 6.7 Pawtucket School Enrollment History 2000-2010 2000 2010 Net Change Percent Change Elementary 5,692 4,913 -779 -13.69% Junior High 2,096 1,552 -544 -25.95% Senior High 2,281 2,112 -169 -7.41% Total Public School 10,069 8,577 -1,492 -14.82% Private schools 2,044 1,357 -643 -34% Source: Pawtucket School Department 2010 As of the 2005 Comprehensive Plan Update, elementary schools were operating beyond capacity. Overcrowding was such a problem that the Pawtucket School Department has leased space for the Webster Street School for 6 years. As of 2010, that lease is no longer necessary. Overall, the 10 elementary schools have room for an additional 430 students before they are at capacity. However, as noted, enrollment is beginning to increase at the elementary school level due to closing parochial schools and the economic recession. All three junior high schools and two high schools are currently operating below capacity. The new high school, the JMW Arts School opened in 2005 and graduated its first class 6-18 Community Services and Facilities in 2009. This is a conservatory style school and students are accepted based on auditions. There are currently 98 students enrolled with an additional freshman class being enrolled for the 2010-11 school year. An additional class of 25-28 students will be added over the next three years. The school was initially housed at the Pawtucket Armory but has moved to the Jenks Junior High School. Each year, the Pawtucket School Department is required to submit an Asset Protection Plan to the Rhode Island Department of Education, which illustrates the most important school facility projects for the fiscal year. The Pawtucket School Department links the Asset Protection Plan directly to its Capital Improvement Plan request. These projects include upgrades to existing facilities like painting, parking, masonry, and window replacement. The Pawtucket Capital Improvement Program (2011-2015) includes an annual request of $1,500,000 from the School Department to maintain school facilities. M. Sustainability The City of Pawtucket considered preparing a separate chapter on Sustainability for this 2011 Comprehensive Plan. However, most of the sustainability measures were already discussed within other Chapters. Specifically, Brownfield remediation, historic preservation, encouraging the reuse of vacant mill buildings, revitalizing the downtown, working toward a the Blackstone Valley and Ten Mile River bikeways are all sustainable practices. In 2010 the City of Pawtucket received $660,000 in Energy Efficient Block Grant (EECBG) funds. The first project that the City undertook was to change out all of the traffic signals into energy efficient LED lights. The City retained the services of a consultant to undertake a number of projects including a lighting audit, developing existing utility consumption on each City building; organizing baseline info on each City-owned building (architectural, HVAC, infrastructure). The consultant will utilize this information to prepare a longterm energy plan for the City, and also recommend whether Pawtucket should enter into a contract with an energy services company (ESCO). The City also received EECBG funds to prepare a bike stripe, to connect finished portions of the Blackstone Valley Bikeway with the City of Providence. This “Bike Stripe Program” will be a placeholder while the City works with the State on obtaining funding for the design and construction of the Blackstone Valley Bikeway. As noted, the City also began its “No Bin No Barrel” program, which has increased recycling and reduced the amount of waste generated. 6-19 Community Services and Facilities III. Summary of Major Issues Public Buildings The average age of Pawtucket’s public buildings is more than 70 years old, therefore many of the structures are in need of significant repairs. The City has a base of information that has been used to formulate cost estimates to support bond referendum to pay for building repairs. This database should be expanded to include all City owned buildings and the data should be standardized and computerized to allow for prioritization of needs. Sewage Collection, Treatment and Disposal The principle issue relating to sewage disposal is the system’s dual function as sewer and storm water collectors. Although the primary responsibility for resolving this problem rests with the Narragansett Bay Commission, the City should be of assistance where possible. Solid Waste Management The Division will continue to pursue source reduction and recycling options to reduce the City’s solid waste stream through various public awareness campaigns, including a twice per year newsletter for recycling and sanitation. Storm Water Management The City will continue to implement the Storm Water Management Plan. Water Supply, Treatment, and Distribution The most important issue is the protection of the water supply reservoirs and their watershed, which lie outside the corporate boundaries of Pawtucket. The PWSB has worked with officials in Cumberland, co-purchasing several properties that will be useful as open space for Cumberland and that also protect water quality within the PWSB watershed. Public Safety The major problem facing both the Police Department and Fire Department at its current headquarters is space. Both facilities are dated and too small to adequately accommodate all the personnel and equipment needed at those locations. A public safety complex would be ideal so that the Police Department, Fire Department and Emergency Management Agency can share resources where feasible and design and construct a space that would fully meet their layout and space needs. The neighborhood fire stations are in need extensive renovation and modernization to be brought up to code for health and safety requirements. The Emergency Management Agency should continue to work to implement the action step given in “A Strategy for Reducing Risks from Natural Hazards in Pawtucket, Rhode Island” to continue to strive to make Pawtucket a disaster resistant community. Senior Services Provision of transportation, meals, day care, support services and other senior services, especially services that enable seniors to remain at home, rather than in nursing or health care facilities is dependant upon Community Development Block Grant funding. Library Services The two major issues facing the Pawtucket Public Library are lack of convenient parking and level of support. 6-20 Community Services and Facilities Social Services The City will continue to work independently and cooperatively with the network of area interest groups and social service providers to define the social service needs of Pawtucket residents, develop appropriate programmatic responses, identify an apply for available resources, and if successful, participate in implementation efforts. Public Schools Continued repairs to Pawtucket’s school facilities are a priority for the Pawtucket School System. An Asset Management Plan is in place and specifies school facility projects that are needed over the next five years. The Department will also continue to provide technology related opportunities for the largest amount of students possible and pursue funding for increased special education and English as a second language resources. Sustainability The City will work on implementing the recommendations of the Long Term Energy and Sustainability Plan. 6-21 Community Services and Facilities SOURCES Coastal Resources Center, University of Rhode Island, “Strategy for Reducing Risks from Natural Hazards in Pawtucket, Rhode Island: A Multi-Hazard Mitigation Strategy”, 1997. City of Pawtucket, “Annual Budget”, FY 1999 – 2003. City of Pawtucket, “Community Services and Facilities Element”, 1995. City of Pawtucket, Department of Planning and Redevelopment, “Federal Housing and Community Development Consolidated Plan”, FY 2003. City of Pawtucket, Department of Planning and Redevelopment, “Project Impact Application”, 1999. City of Pawtucket, Division of Senior Services, “National Council on the Aging, National Institute of Senior Centers, National Accreditation Program Application”, 2001. City of Pawtucket, Division of Senior Services, “Senior Programs”. City of Pawtucket, Fire Department, “Annual Report”, 1997-2001. City of Pawtucket, Police Department, “Annual Report”, 2000, 2001. City of Pawtucket, “Sewer, Sanitation, and Collection, Annual Report,” 2002. City Planning Commission, “Capital Improvements Program, 2003-2007”. Pawtucket Public Library, “Five Year Strategic Plan”, 2001. Pawtucket Public Library, www.pawtucketlibrary.org, 2003. Pawtucket Public School System, “Asset Management Plan”, 2002-2006. Pawtucket Water Supply Board, “Water Supply Management Plan”, 1998. Pawtucket Water Supply Board, “Water Supply Management Plan Review”, 2000. Rhode Island Department of Administration, “State Guide Plan Overview,” Report 101, June 2001. Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management, “Regulations for the Rhode Island Pollutant Discharge Elimination System, Storm Water Program”, 2002. City of Pawtucket 6 - 22 Transportation City of Pawtucket, Rhode Island Comprehensive Community Plan 2011 Update Chapter 7 –TRANSPORTATION Table of Contents I. Goals, Policies, and Actions 7-1 II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis 7-2 III. Summary of Major Issues 7-13 Sources 7-15 7-1 Transportation I. Goals, Policies and Actions Goal 1. Complete the Pawtucket segment of the Blackstone Valley Bikeway 2. Reestablish rail passenger service in the City of Pawtucket. 3. Improve the efficiency and safety of pedestrian, auto and bicycle traffic in the downtown. 4. Ensure that the proposed Interstate 95 Bridge 550 is constructed in a manner sensitive to Pawtucket’s industrial heritage, and also improves circulation along local streets. Objective 1. Increase the number of street trees by 10%. Policy 1. Work with federal, state and local agencies of government and non-profit entities to maintain and implement the State’s Transportation Improvement Program (TIP). 2. Complete construction on the Pawtucket/ Central Falls Commuter Rail Station within ten years. 2. Evaluate the need to install sidewalks, curbs and drainage improvements in neighborhoods and on streets where these amenities do not exist. 3. Complete construction of the Blackstone Valley Bikeway within ten years. 4. Reduce the number of annual auto and pedestrian accidents. 3. Continue to improve universal accessibility at street intersections and other crosswalks. 4. Improve the visibility and accessibility of downtown parking facilities. Action T 1 Maintain and regularly update through the Department of Public Works and the Department of Planning and Redevelopment the list of potential projects for inclusion in the State of Rhode Island Transportation Improvement Program. T 2 Work with RIDOT on the reconstruction of the closed bridges at Conant Street and at Cole Street to ensure pedestrian and vehicle safety and access. T 3 Work with RIDOT and FTA to advance the Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station. 5. Maintain and expand as necessary, the database for the citywide pavement management program to facilitate the prioritization and implementation of local street improvements. Consider the inclusion of data concerning sidewalk and drainage conditions. T 4 Support the implementation of RIPTA’s Providence Metropolitan Transit Enhancement Study, including plans to make Route 99 an express bus, and efforts to provide a connection to the South Attleboro Commuter Rail station. 6. Continue to implement the 50/50 sidewalk/curb improvement program. T 5 Develop a linear greenway along the Pawtucket riverfronts. 7. Continue with the street tree planting plan and implementation program which allows for the planting of new trees and the replacement of diseased and dying trees along the city’s street. 8. Survey and evaluate intersections with narrow turning radii for inclusion in the Capital Improvement Program to improve turning movements. 9. Establish “No Right Turn on Red” signs at dangerous intersections. 10. Evaluate the population in need of para-transit services and expand the service eligibility requirements if necessary. 11. Provide bicycle storage facilities at municipal buildings and other facilities and work with community businesses to establish bicycle storage facilities at places of commerce and employment. T 6 Continue to cooperate with RIDOT in the development of the Blackstone River Bikeway including the development of agreements for all required private property and easements. T 7 Continue to cooperate with RIDOT and the City of East Providence in the development of the Ten Mile River Bikeway. T 8 Seek funding to implement the downtown circulation improvements identified in the 2010 Downtown Design Plan. T 9 Improve/create boat landings along the entire riverfront. T 10 Improve visitor access to major attractions by developing a comprehensive signage program. 12. Enforce no parking and other regulations and ordinances to prevent the obstruction of sidewalks and to allow for the safe passage of all pedestrians. 7-1 Transportation II. Community Profile and Needs Analysis A. Introduction Transportation infrastructure provides links between land uses. The Transportation Element of the Pawtucket Comprehensive Plan considers a wide range of travel modes, the most significant of which is the automobile. Table 7.1 below shows how the ratio of cars per person has risen over the past fifty years so that it now approaches a ratio of 1:1. Table 7.1 Ratio of Registered Automobiles per Person over time. 1960 1990 2010 Population 81,000 72,000 72,958 Registered Automobiles 25,000 51,000 65,000 Cars per person 0.3 0.7 0.9 Source: 2000 US Census; Pawtucket Tax Assessor’s 2010. The City of Pawtucket, therefore, must continually work to make street and highway improvements that will enhance traffic flow and improve traffic safety. The 2009-2012 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) identified $1.4 billion available for bridge repairs, intersection improvements, traffic signals, universal accessibility, public transit and other roadway improvements. During the next five years, the City will spend approximately $800,000 per year to repair and maintain city streets, sidewalks and bridges and control traffic. The adequacy of parking in neighborhoods throughout the city has also been consistently identified as an issue due to the lack of off street parking for many of the city’s older multifamily houses, which were constructed before the prevalence of the automobile. Although the automobile is clearly the predominant method of transportation in Pawtucket, the City is working with state agencies to provide and encourage transportation alternatives. The Rhode Island Public Transit Agency (RIPTA) provides bus service in the City of Pawtucket. Senior Transportation is furnished by two City funded para-transit vehicles administered by Blackstone Health/COASI, who are also responsible for providing services for the RIde Program of the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority (RIPTA). Three freight rail lines within the City are operated by the Providence & Worcester Railroad. Pawtucket residents in need of rail passenger services must travel to Providence or the South Attleboro commuter stop. The bicycle can be an important means of transportation, especially for local trips and for recreational purposes. There are two planned bikepaths within the City – the Ten Mile River and the Blackstone Valley Bikepath and the recently completed Downtown Design Plan emphasizes pedestrian routes and connections. Pedestrian movement is one of the most important ways for getting people to their destinations. Once the car is parked, the traveler must still walk. Sidewalk improvements, universal accessibility, signalization and crosswalks assist in providing safe pedestrian access, while the continued development of a riverwalk along the Pawtucket River will not only enhance the aesthetics of the City, but also the recreational opportunities. 7-2 Transportation B. Roads, Highways and Bridges Approximately 1,000 acres of land area in the City is used for streets and highways. This represents 18% of the total city land area and is the second largest land use in the City. Table 7.2 shows how the approximately 56.27 miles of roadway in Pawtucket are broken down. Table 7.2 Roadways in Pawtucket Road Classification Interstate Principal Arterial Minor Arterial Collector Total Mileage 3.54 20.95 13.99 17.79 56.27 The majority of these roadways are City owned and maintained. There are also some numbered routes which are State owned, but City maintained, and still others that are State owned and maintained (see Table 7.3). Interstate 95 is a federal highway which bisects the City. Figure 7.1 illustrates the major transportation routes within the City. Table 7.3 State-owned Roads in Pawtucket Route # Name Location 1A Newport Avenue Entire roadway 15 Armistice Boulevard From York Avenue to the Seekonk line Central Avenue From Industrial Highway to Seekonk line Dexter Avenue From Goff St. to Central Falls line 126 Smithfield Avenue Entire roadway 1 Broadway Entire roadway Source: City of Pawtucket, Traffic Engineering, 2010 Table 7.4 shows the ten worst intersections in the City of Pawtucket, as well as any improvements that are planned. 7-3 Transportation 7-4 Transportation Table 7.4 Worst Intersections in Pawtucket, 2010 Location Control 2009 Rank 2009 Accidents Comments Lonsdale Ave. at Mineral Spring Ave City 1 40 RIDOT is repairing sidewalks and repaving along Mineral Spring Ave. Armistice Blvd. at Newport Ave. Beverage Hill Av. at Newport Av. Mineral Spring Ave. at Smithfield Ave. Central Ave. at Newport Ave. Barton St. at Dexter St. RIDOT 2 37 RIDOT is repairing sidewalks and repaving all along Mineral Spring Ave. RIDOT 3 35 RIDOT 3 35 RIDOT 4 33 City 5 25 City installed LED displays and implemented timing/phasing changes. Cedar St. at Garden St. City 6 23 Division St. at School St. City 7 22 Experiencing increased traffic volumes due to I-95 detour, State implementing improvements under I-95 project. Experiencing increased traffic volumes due to I-95 detour, State implemented phasing/timing changes, City installed LED displays. Benefit St. at Newport Av. Division St./Grace St. ay Pleasant St. RIDOT 8 20 City 9 19 Lorraine St. at Mineral Spring Ave. City 9 19 Main St. at School St. City 9 19 Experiencing increased traffic volumes due to I-95 detour, State proposing to redesign intersection, City installing LED displays. City installed LED displays and timing changes. RIDOT is repairing sidewalks and repaving all along Mineral Spring Ave. Experiencing increased traffic volumes due to I-95 detour, City installing LED displays and timing changes. Source: City of Pawtucket, Traffic Engineering, 2010 Scheduled State Improvements The Rhode Island Department of Administration, Division of Statewide Planning, in conjunction with the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority, the Rhode Island Department of Transportation, along with cities and towns, prepares the Transportation Improvement Program (TIP). This is a four-year scheduling document, which currently covers the period of 2009-2012. All projects listed in the TIP are eligible for federal funding. The majority of the funding in the FY2009-2012 TIP is allocated to the Highway programs (69%). Bus Transit (13%) and Rail Transit (8%) also receive funding in the TIP. The TIP funding categories and their percentage of the funds are as follows: Administrative Program (0%), Bike/Pedestrian Program (1%), Bridge Program (22%), 7-5 Transportation Change Orders (4%), Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality (4%), Enhancement Program (1%), GARVEE Debt Service (17%), Highway Program (5%), Interstate Program (8%), Major Projects with Multi-Year Funding (7%), Pavement Management Program (9%), Planning Program (2%), Study and Development Program (0%), and the Traffic Safety Program (7%), SAFETEA-LU Earmarks (13%) Table 7.5 shows the Pawtucket projects that have been scheduled in the 2009-2012 TIP. Only the projects listed in a specific year are eligible to receive individual funding authorization. There were also three Enhancement Projects: Exchange Street Enhancements, Roosevelt Avenue Enhancements and Blackstone Navigation. Table 7.5 Transportation Improvement Program, 2009-2012, Pawtucket Projects Funding in $ Millions Project 2009 2010 2011 2012 Future Ten Mile River Greenway Conant Street Bridge #915 Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station Moshassuck Valley Industrial Access Road Waterfront Drive/ Newport Ave. Connector Mineral Spring Avenue Pawtucket Bridge 550 I-95 Service Roads Stormwater Retrofit Demo. Project Blackstone River Bike Facility (3A) Blackstone River Bike Facility (3B) Total .38 3 .62 4 1.83 Study/Development Study/Development 2.09 17 38 37 6.25 1.03 3.75 6.25 20.62 43.83 38.03 6.25 12.47 Transportation Improvement Program, 2009-2012 Bridges There are a total of 43 bridge structures in the City of Pawtucket. Of this total, 15 bridges are owned and/or maintained by the City; 23 of the 43 are associated with Interstate 95. Two bridges are currently closed and have been for some time now: #915 Conant Street and #937 Cole Street. Bridge #915 Conant Street, has been approved for inclusion in the TIP for $7,000,000 for reconstruction. This project is ready for construction, but is currently on hold. Improvements to Bridge 550, which is the I-95 Bridge over the Pawtucket River, have been designed. There was a ground-breaking for this project in November 2010 and the project is currently under construction. The design of the new Pawtucket River Bridge was accomplished through a partnership between Rhode Island Department of Transportation and the City of Pawtucket. Emphasizing that this bridge is the southbound entrance to the State, the City of Pawtucket petitioned RIDOT to provide a bridge that was reflective of the City and its history. The resulting design, which was refined through a public process, is sensitive to Pawtucket’s past. 7-6 Transportation Photo 7.1 . Rendering of the proposed Interstate 95 Bridge 550. Local Streets There are approximately 186 miles of local streets and road which are the responsibility of the City of Pawtucket. The Department of Public Works maintains these streets by repairing the pavement, striping where necessary, maintaining the integrity of the road shoulder and clearing vegetation along the roadside, plowing and sanding/salting in the winter and maintaining the drainage systems. If the road is on the functional classification, as indicated in Table 7.2, the City’s responsibility for repair and/or reconstructions of the roadway may be assisted through funding from the state aid system. The City has budgeted $500,000 for each of the next five fiscal years through the Capital Improvement Program for street and sidewalk improvements. There are very few private streets or private right-of-ways within the City. These ROW usually access only one or two homes or businesses and are in very close proximity to an accepted City street. These private streets and right of ways do receive City services like trash pickup. The Department of Public Works has a pavement management system that provides a rating of the City’s streets based on the Pavement Condition Index. The evaluation results are computerized in conjunction with construction/inspection history and are use to formulate the schedule of repairs. C. Public Transportation Fixed Route Scheduled Bus Service The City of Pawtucket is serviced by the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority (RIPTA) through a total of 14 routes. A RIPTA bus facility was constructed in Pawtucket at Roosevelt and Main Street, sharing space with the Visitor Center in downtown Pawtucket. Most of the Pawtucket service goes through downtown Pawtucket. Currently, there is no looped bus service within Pawtucket. Figure 7.2 shows the various public transportation modes in Pawtucket, including marine facilities. 7-7 Transportation 7-8 Transportation Though ridership has continued to decrease as a result of service reductions fueled by both budgetary constraints and the elimination of underutilized routes, RIPTA is upgrading its aging fleet and introducing improved facilities such as the Intermodal Transportation Center in Kennedy Plaza. (RIPTA website, 2003). The average weekday systemwide ridership for all RIPTA routes within Pawtucket is almost 11,000 passengers on routes serving Pawtucket (See Table 7.6) RIPTA has no current plans for additional routing for the Pawtucket System. RIPTA focuses rather on changing the current system by reassessing systemwide service, consolidating low service routes where feasible, and replacing large capacity buses with smaller busses. RIPTA is working on a pilot project, potentially designating one of the most heavily traveled Pawtucket routes (the #99 which travels between Kennedy Plaza and downtown Pawtucket) into an express bus. Table 7.6 Total Ridership on Routes Serving Pawtucket Average Weekday Average Saturday Route Ridership Ridership 35 500 233 42 1,850 850 51 450 230 53 198 No Service 71 500 325 72 870 415 73 195 99 75 240 149 76 270 150 77 470 214 78 940 640 79 205 90 80 120 50 99 4,240 2,360 Total 11,048 5,805 Average Sunday Ridership 198 400 No Service No Service 170 207 65 110 85 74 263 No Service 23 1,345 2,940 Total 931 3,100 680 198 995 1,492 359 499 505 758 1,843 295 193 7,945 19,793 Source: RIPTA 2009 Para-Transit Service Two Para-Transit operations provide service to City residents. There are two shuttles owned and operated by the Pawtucket Senior Center: one shuttle provides fixed route service to the elderly public housing complexes, the other provides service by appointment. The RIde program also operates in Pawtucket. The RIde program is coordinated and managed by RIPTA. If a disability prevents someone from using RIPTA's regular bus service, (s)he may be eligible for ADA Para-transit Services. ADA Para-transit service is available for any trip purpose. RIde also operates service for people age 60 and over that can only be used for specific types of trips, such as medical appointments or adult daycare. 7-9 Transportation D. Downtown Parking and Circulation In 2000, a Downtown Parking Study and a Market Based Strategy for Downtown were completed for Pawtucket. Both documents address the issue of parking. The Market Based Strategy stressed the need for a supply of accessible, well maintained and well designed parking in an amount adequate to support a range of land uses and activities in the area. Both studies found an overall parking deficiency currently at 162 spaces and a future projected deficiency of 232 spaces. The current deficiency is in the Summer Street area, related to the Pawtucket Public Library and the YMCA. The Downtown Parking Study recommends the redistribution of surplus parking, an upgrade of the existing City-owned parking structure on Main Street and the possible new construction of parking lots or structures. Table 7.7 describes the parking situation in 2000. There have been minimal changes to the downtown since then, so the current situation is very similar. Parking is also available for rental to downtown businesses at a rate of $10.00 per month in the City-owned parking structure on Main Street. Table 7.7 describes the utilization of the City-owned lots and structures within the downtown. Table 7.7 Downtown Pawtucket Parking Supply Type Number of Spaces Utilization On-Street Off-Street (Public) Off-Street (Private) 193 (10.6%) 359 (19.8%) 1263 (69.6%) 86% 65.2% 69.9% Total 1815 70.7% Downtown Parking Study, 2000 Appendix D contains the summary of findings from the Downtown Pawtucket Design Plan. E. Rail Facilities Passenger Rail Amtrak operates both high speed and regional intercity passenger rail service along the North East Corridor (NEC) through Pawtucket and Central Falls. Amtrak’s operation is focused on providing intercity service between Boston, New York City, and Washington DC. On a typical weekday Amtrak operates 17 trains in each direction, for 34 total trains. Of these 34 trains, 16 are high speed and 18 regional service trains. Massachusetts Bay Transit Authority (MBTA) operated commuter rail trains traverse Pawtucket and Central Falls along the Northeast Corridor. The MBTA operation is focused on providing local service between Providence and Boston, and the nearest stops are in Providence and in South Attleboro, Massachusetts. On a typical weekday, the MBTA operates 15 trains in each direction, for a total of 30 trains. During the weekday morning commute period, the MBTA operates seven trains from Providence to Boston (5:00-9:00AM departure times). In the evening, six trains operate from Boston to Providence (3:30-7:00pm departure times). The MBTA has recently expanded weekend service to Providence, which consists of nine trains in each direction on Saturday, and seven in each direction on Sunday. Currently, no rail passenger service exists in Pawtucket. Commuter (MBTA) and Amtrak passenger rail service is available only from Providence or South Attleboro. The 7-10 Transportation mainline corridor passes through Pawtucket but there are no stations or terminals. The cities of Pawtucket and Central Falls began examining the potential to restore access to Boston to Providence commuter rail service in 2005. The cities believe that developing a Commuter Rail station would benefit both the residents, by increasing mobility and access to economic opportunity, as well as the cities, by improving the environment and encouraging economic growth. With funding from Rhode Island Department of Transportation (RIDOT), Federal Transit Administration (FTA) and Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), the cities prepared a Feasibility Study to answer their initial questions about the viability of re-introducing commuter rail service in Pawtucket/Central Falls. The Feasibility Study’s key findings affirmed that commuter rail service in Pawtucket/Central Falls was indeed viable based on the following findings: • Of the 30 weekday commuter rail trains passing through Pawtucket/Central Falls, based on the schedule as of July 2006, 23 could stop at a commuter rail facility without adversely impacting Amtrak intercity, MBTA commuter rail, or Providence and Worcester Railroad’s (P&W) freight rail service. • Approximately 1,500 weekday daily boardings were projected for the proposed commuter rail stop. • There are numerous opportunities in the surrounding areas for transit-oriented development. With these positive findings, the City of Pawtucket is anxious to move forward onto the next steps necessary for the development of a Commuter Rail stop on the MBTA Providence to Boston Commuter Rail line. The Feasibility Study identified two potential sites – the Providence and Worcester Railyard and the Historic Depot. During the study, the Railyard site was dismissed because of the costs of relocating the existing operation and because of traffic constraints. Since the completion of the Study the City has entered into conversations with Amtrak because the layout of the Historic Depot is such that both inbound and outbound trains must stop on the mainline. Amtrak has determined that this is unacceptable to them. The City has been working since then to identify an alternate site, and has found one, directly across from the Railyard site, that has none of the cost or traffic issues of the Railyard, and is able to satisfy Amtrak’s requirements. Pawtucket currently has a $1.9 million authorization in SAFETEA-LU for the Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station, and the City and RIDOT have secured the required match. Freight Rail Rail and freight service is available through and within Pawtucket provided by the Providence and Worcester Railroad (P&W) along several secondary rail corridors. East Providence Running Track - The East Providence Secondary Line and the East Junction Secondary Track were merged into the East Providence Running Track. This track has an overall length of 8.9 miles from Valley Falls to the Massachusetts State Line. Moshassuck Industrial Track - The track is owned by the P&W and the FRA rating is Class 1. The track extends approximately 2 miles along the Moshassuck River Valley 7-11 Transportation providing service to a heavily industrialized area at the Pawtucket/Lincoln line and it also links to the P&W’s yard on the Shoreline route. F. Marine Facilities The Pawtucket River provides direct access to Narragansett Bay via the Providence River. The Pawtucket River Channel extends approximately 2.9 nautical miles north from Cold Spring Point at the Providence River to the Town Landing and provides an approximately 150’ wide navigable channel varying in depth from 16 ‘ Mean Low Water (MLW) to 6.7’ MLW. The entire Seekonk River Channel is tidal up to a point just below the Main Street Bridge. Although several bridge structures cross the channel within this reach of the river, the horizontal and vertical clearances appear to be capable of accommodating larger vessels (See Table 7.8). Table 7.8 Bridge Clearances along the Seekonk River Channel Bridge Horizontal Clearance Vertical Clearance Division Street Cold Spring Point Washington Bridge (I-195) India Point Swing Bridge 50 feet 100 feet 100 feet 84 feet 30 feet 42 feet 40 feet Unlimited Siegmund & Associates, 1991 There are two areas where direct public access to the water is available for boaters. Town Landing on Taft Street has a 100-foot dock, a small boat launch ramp, parking facilities and a handicapped accessible fishing area. Because of the current at this location, the dock has been damaged. The City of Pawtucket is currently working on a construction project to relocate the dock and rebuild it. This project also includes the redevelopment of the land area, into walking paths. The project has funding and is ongoing. A future phase of the project includes the construction of an intermodal facility (Town Landing is also the planned southern terminus of the Blackstone Valley Bikeway), with restrooms and concessions. There is also a public boat launch at the Former State Pier facility on the east bank of the Pawtucket River (now referred to by the City as Festival Pier). Residents utilize the pier for fishing. Also, for the past nine years, the site has also been host to the Pawtucket Chinese American Festival, which has drawn thousands from all over New England to participate in the Dragon Boat Races and to enjoy the food and entertainment. G. Bikeways, Trails and Pedestrian Walkways There are two bikeways proposed in Pawtucket. The Blackstone River Bikeway which is about an 18 mile bikeway extending from Cumberland to Pawtucket and the Ten Mile River Bikeway which connects Pawtucket to East Providence. Blackstone River Bikeway This Bikeway will be designed by Rhode Island Department of Transportation (RIDOT) and constructed by the Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management (RIDEM). The Bikeway is divided into 8 project segments which cover approximately 18 7-12 Transportation miles of both shared-use bike path and on-road signed bike routes. Currently the Blackstone Valley Bike Path ends in Cumberland at the Town Hall. Segment 3 of the Bikeway runs along the Blackstone River through Pawtucket. There are ten percent design plans prepared for this section. Based on that information, the City of Pawtucket has agreements in place for over 80 percent of the land required to construct the Bikeway. Funding for the Bikeway’s construction is included in the TIP as a future project. The City is currently working with RIDOT to identify funding for the next phase of design. Ten Mile River Bikeway In 1993, the City of Pawtucket and the City of East Provident jointly applied for funding for this bikeway as a Transportation Enhancement Project. A 3/4 mile segment in Slater Park, Pawtucket, and a just under 2 mile segment from Slater Park south to the Kimberly Ann Rock Athletic Fields in East Providence, have been completed. A segment of the Pawtucket portion of this bikeway is included in the TIP. Pedestrian Walkways The City of Pawtucket is an urban environment; therefore, sidewalks exist in many areas of the City to ensure pedestrian safety. Pawtucket has two intersections that have had multiple pedestrian crashes, Dexter Street and Barton Street (3) and Main Street and Roosevelt Avenue (4). The City, in cooperation with RIDOT and RIPTA, is about to begin construction of intersection improvements including a pedestrian crossing signal, better signage and an improved crosswalk, which should increase pedestrian safety in the Main Street and Roosevelt Avenue area. The Dexter/Barton Street intersection will be addressed during the planning for the proposed Commuter Rail facility. The Pawtucket Downtown Design Improvements Study will include specific recommendations for improving pedestrian safety and access within the downtown. As part of the overall riverfront redevelopment, Pawtucket is working on improving pedestrian access along the river. Their ultimate goal is to provide pedestrian access along the entirety of both sides of the river. South of the Division Street Bridge, this is feasible because a majority of the land is owned by the City or the Pawtucket Redevelopment Agency. Other major landowners, including the Boys and Girls Club and National Grid, have indicated their future cooperation. The reconstruction of Bridge 550, over the Pawtucket River, provides an opportunity to connect this area south of Division Street with downtown Pawtucket. III. Summary of Major Issues Maintenance of Existing Infrastructure The operation, maintenance, improvement and provision of streets, bridges, public transportation, and transportation alternatives have significant costs that are shared by the City of Pawtucket, the State of Rhode Island, combined with federal funding. As with many older cities, transportation infrastructure continually needs maintenance and upgrades. Timely, routine maintenance can extend the useful life of capital facilities which the City accomplished through the annual budget and the five-year Capital Improvement Program. The Capital Improvement Program should continue to cover all 7-13 Transportation transportation facilities, modes of transportation, and levels of responsibility from local street maintenance to projects to be included in the state Transportation Improvement Program. The replacement of Interstate 95 Bridge 550 is the most significant upcoming improvement to the roadway system. Planning for Transportation Alternatives Public transportation service improvements, improved marketing, and the development of infrastructure, such as walkways and bikeways, during the design of new roadways and roadway improvements, are essential components of the overall strategy of keeping the City’s transportation system functioning smoothly and efficiently. The following projects are the most important transportation alternative projects: Pawtucket/Central Falls Commuter Rail Station; the Blackstone Valley and Ten Mile River Bikeways and the Pedestrian and Bicycle Improvements identified in the Pawtucket Downtown Design Improvement Study. These three projects were identified as priorities during the public process. 7-14 Transportation SOURCES City of Pawtucket, “Transportation Element”, 1995, 2005 City of Pawtucket, Division of Senior Services, “Senior Programs”. City of Pawtucket Police Department, “Accident Statistics”, 2009. City Planning Commission, “Capital Improvements Program”. Harrall-Michalowski Associates, Lambert Advisory, “Market Based Strategy for Downtown Pawtucket,” 2000. Pawtucket Riverfront Commission, “Riverfront Development Plan: A New Vision for Pawtucket,” 1997. Rhode Island Department of Administration, “State Guide Plan Overview,” Report 101, June 2001. Rhode Island Department of Administration. “Transportation Improvement Program, 2009-2012. Rhode Island Department of Administration, “Transportation 2030”, State Guide Plan Element 611, August 2008. Rhode Island Department of Transportation, “Bike Rhode Island Construction Update”, www.dot.ri.gov, 2003. Rhode Island Department of Transportation, “Listing of Posted Bridges”, 2009. Rhode Island Department of Transportation, “Making Pedestrians a Priority: Pedestrian Safety Plan”, 2001. Rhode Island Public Transit Authority, www.ripta.com, 2009. Wilber Smith Associates, “Downtown Parking Study, Pawtucket, Rhode Island,” 2000. City of Pawtucket 7 - 15