abu bedi monica salem

_
_
_
______
_
*
31(ST113
flarr
R1Tth4wwE.
F4ft/4
()i
____
1
r
WIIel
-#.,qa
rr4
WIG i
1m1tI11993*q'lra
**l1a
i,unuiawi
"
'S
*
fI5ft
IIT 11 Rt, 2005
4Mti
TNIRF
t
wft Sr
ftaqflu
fin 4nia
2005
NVffl
*
#WfVft1p1t43
izr1%
1UiZI*
1tri1
4i i4
t31WRF*TI
d'fl
4
~
qif
*1
qT
'ft iueii
Wt
u
dlkclikH
't
3U
ii 3* flE
fr
4'.34wfti
¶@lia
S3lfl9VEI993
4
ffij*?lTezrI
jrq1;
rh
WEF*
*
*W4
*ig
tn*wi;
¶Plia
4
* *
Mj9lZflfw4
Portuguese Sc Snubs
cm on Abu Salem Trial
NEWDELHI/MUMlAlßejectingthe CBI's pleathe
Portuguese
Supreme Court
has upheld a lower
courtdecision that extraditiontreatywith India
wasviolated in Aix, Salem'scase byslappingof
new charges
against the underworld don thatat-
tractdeath penalty. Reactingto the order, CBl clarified on Tuesday that the Portuguese Supreme
Court has notcancelledtheextradition ofSalem
and thatonlya technical point had been raised. It
also said the order is not expected to have any repercussions
goingtrial
on the status of Salem and on the on-
against him in India.
Salem, who is behind bars, moved alAoAcourt
in Mumbai, seeking closure of thetrial against him
in the 1993 Mumbai blastscase. Salem's plea
sex-.
pected tocome upfor hearingon Wednesday.
The European courtgave its orderon Saturday
while dismissinga CBI appeal againstthe lower
courtdecision.
-
Pll
Portugal top court
upholds quashing
of Salem extradition
NEWS NETWORK
New
Portugal's
D
Su
preme Court has upheld an order that
cancelled extradition
of underworld don Abn Salem
for violation of
deportation
rules by slapping new charges
:eddealthpenalty
that atifacU
Rejectin
ppeal Dy In-
dianauthorities,tfle ScinPor
tugal on Saturday upheld the
order of Court of Appeal in
Lisbon winch had held that
there was a breach of 'Rile of
Speciality' in extradition of
Salem (46) in 2005.
Reacting to the order, the
"The Portuguese Supreme
claimed on Tuesday that
the Portugal SC has not can-
Court has upheld the decisiou
(JBI
celled the
extradition of Sa-
of Court of Appeal, Lisbon,
throughwhich it hadheldthat
lemandonly atechnicalpoint
there was a breach of Rule of
had been raised. It also said
Speciality in the matter of
traditionof Abu Salem. There
the order would not have any
repercussion on the status of
Salem and the ongoing trial
tinsthiminlndia.
A UBI spokesperson
government
the
plore
the
proaching
would
possibility of
is expected to be no repercussion on status of Abu Salem
and
said
-
on-going
the
trial
ex-
Lucknow
ap-
rejectedhispetitions,"theCßl
the Constitutional
-
and Mumbai have
spokesperson said.
Bench of Portugal challengingSCorder.
on
against him. Trial Courts at
Salem had flied a petition
intheHCinLisbonallegingvi
Following the pronounce-
ment of the SC order, Salem,
who is behind bars, moved a
TADA court in Mumbai seek
-10 sure of the trial against
olation of Rule of Speciality
after which a judgement was
pronounced on September 19,
2011, saying there had been
breach of the Indian undergiventothe Portuguese
bim in the 1993 Mumbal blasts
taking
case, saying continuing it will
authorities.
be illegal. "We have moved an
application seeking closure of
Rule of Speciality'
trial as continuing
th the
trial will be illegal," said Salem's lawyer Rashid Ansari in
Mumbai. Salem'spleais likely
"The issue of 'violation of
has been
examined at length by the Sn
preme Court of India on simi-
lar petitions filed by Abu Salem in Indiawhichthrough its
come up on Wednesday He
is also facing trial in various
order
)ther
been no violation of Rile of
Speciality after examiningth
to
India
had
given
utive assurance to Portu
gal that it would not slap any
charges that invited death
dated
September
10,
2010, has held that there has
issues pertaining to
Speciality
Rule 01
with reference
and in comparison with extr;
penalty to Salem and would
dition law
not keep him behind bars for
a
ifit
more than 25 years.
so!nsaid.
t tfle LJK,me US
Portugal," the spokesper
Vested interest behind 2G P11: Govt
Tells Sc That NGO Has Political Motives As It Targets Individual Ministers
Dhananjay Mahapatra F
ThN
New Delhi:
The Centre on
Thesday told the SupremE
offidavits
filed
in
¶ipport
thereof targeting individual
ninisters or the attorney gell-
NGO 'Centre
or the officers of CBI by
hlng their back in lic
granfl
it hrnneh of princiiplles nt
est Litigation' in the
IrntLwa
ftural justice,
Court
that
liadbeec'me
the PIL filed b
for Public Inter
2G
stain
apoliticalinterest
litigation with the petitioner
attempting to personally tar
t
ministers,
the
affonicy
neralmñoflicersof lhe
GET.
iedge
It is common lmo\t
it some of the office-becarers
f CPIL are consistently op
posed to the ruling party ant
cal
cc
pplication filed by UPIL
Salman Khurshid
headed law rnh stiy of stall
mgi
permissinn
tn
ttothie2Gcase.SpecialJudgeOPSainiallowcdtheprobe
agencyto place before it documents which cauld not bebrcught
on recordearlieralong withthechargesheet.
Saini said, "I maymentiorithat during arguments, it was
pointedoutbysoniedefencecounseltliattheentirefilein
whichdocun,ents mentioned intheapplicationarecoritained
was
iiistnhiiierital
court's notice
sam
in
ground that
could not b
spectrum.
However
the CBlhaddisre
gardeclrheconcurreritviewsot
Iwo
AGENCIES
Loop
an associate of Essar
for thorn to be iable for broach
)f u'-01
conthtionsattachedto gram
ternied
of
maybeallowedto be placedori record,towhichspecial public
in
quent fllThg of chargesheet
against former telecoinnñnts-
Loop Essor
ter
standing
;taiiding ol tne lacts aiicl
A ilaja, DMK
fl mid a host of
MPKariimoz
corporate
bi
0
September
ii' cuurt mothtormg of the probe and subse
2010 resulliiig
obiecled to Ihe UBI's proposition for prosecution of Loop
Essar on the linesof Relliancee
Swan
in 2G seam on th
uthilsEries mid
proceeded
to file the second suppleinen
ed as public interest litigation
is nowturriirigto lie apolitica
internst litigation,'
it said.
liiingiiig flic 2G
seeking
special court here on Tuesday allowedthe Central Bureau
related
ofinvestigationtopresentadditiorial documents
prosecutorhas noobjection."
testiga
;tigat ion.
UPIL
hly
a
fit
Sbwed to present more documents
A goeeeding
oeo'' winch st
lave been adopting the device
brhii4 certaul fads on record
but, hi the appilcations or the
ceb
-ecoin
CDusing
)t
tiling appilcations ostensi
the
die
to m
, salcllflr'wTflS¬t
flspj
CB
It
said the law mhuistry
view against
huias
and
pioseculion of
Khaitans
in the
scam was
offshoot
of
2G
his personal under
w
no way a hindrance for the CBI
lo proceed ahead in us iuvesd
itoiis.
Law
mhii
porate aID
tai chargesheet th the Uoj
Kssarcase. Hutpetitionerin2G
scanicPlLhadrnovedtheapex
)Un
alleging that Khurstiid'
givhg clean chit to
opirnon
I oop-FssarpossThly
liou
of
GET's
)ffl&fl
ledto dilucha]gesheel
executiv,
"
3flS fl3fl
-
3TMJSci
**uUUiSTjT
ftRl: fiT
WFIT*t
ThTF
thiz
IT
qr
*fIR
WMIN
W
'im
wy
ii
TTtt
WTITWI
lT
ciiiit
-
N WTF'T
~r
W1
ft
'W'NI
S 'ttRT fl
VBf2flli
RWMthSTffi
R
1
''iti
*-9 WT'
-i>
-teg 'vw'n
TTT
'iTT'V
lIPIt
ThZ
-Ttfl
tW
zifv
*WIfIPJrTTh-W
fw*lTlm9T
n,#L#tti*
#NRT
im
lVftl
kt3Wul
'rmt
zmfitii
T'TTflt
13Oth'iWP1'T'
fwitn'i'it
HC nod to CBI plea
to
AGE
submit 2G papers
CORRESPONDENT
NEW DELHI. JAN. 17
be placed by the agency on
the courts record.
"In
Bnishing
aside the
objec-
tions of several accused in
the 20 scam case, a Deihl
court on Tuesday accepted
the CEI's plea to submit as
evidence more documents,
including
the communica-
tions
between
Telecom
Regulatory Authority
of
Indla
(Trai)
and
ment of telecom
depart-
Fact
placed
on
accused.
A.
application
record
Raja and
has
by
bis
been
allowed, 1 do not. See any
reason for decllning the
CBI prayer as far as item
nuniber 2 (iii) (one particuof document in the
lar set
Saini
list) .is concerned. In view
of the facts and circum-
allowed the agency's plea to
submit to the court addi-
stances of the case and the
law appllcable on the sub-
Special judge
tional
ering
(DOT).
view of the
that all doctunents, barrhig
one, have been sought tobe
0?.
documents, considspecial public prose-
cutor U.U. Laut's argument
that former comunications
minister
A,
Raja
has
been allowed to
three out of the four
alreädy
take
sts of documents sought to
the prayer is allowed
amt documents are allowed
ject,
to be pläced on recörd," thö
court said.
Most of the accused had
opposed the CBI's plea for
placing
the additional doc-
uments
to Ute court.
Sadiq case: CBI seeks more time
lowing a key witness Ketai
TIMES NEWS NErWORK
dabad: The Centralßu
reau of Investigation (UBI) has
sought six months more from
Guj
it
high
)mplet
the pro be in the
Sadiq
Jamal
'rflfl
ins
issuedto him Tirod
kar, whose
statement
was recorded once, was the only link
prior to HG order to establish
Before the scientific eviden
is made available, it would be
difficult to come to aliy couclusiouthe petitioustated.
In the meanime. the stat
government has not sncceeded
initsappealagainstjusticeMß
Shah's decision to hand over
encounter case
that the Bhawiagar youth w
killed inpolice custody andthe
of 2003.
Gujarat police had secured his
iad on
16 trans1
ferred
the
custody
the Supreme Court refused to
stay CBlprobe and gaveagreen
HG
June
mc
prob'
-'leg
0e into the allegations
of
fake c
encounter
by the city
Cr]
branch sleuths to (JBI
withatime limit of six months.
the Central agency
has sought extension in the inHowever,
vestigationon several
grounds.
According to GBI connsel
Yogesh Ravaili, the petition
mentioned that the probe has
been
Ti
moving the Bombay
rodkar IL
high cour
Et challenging th
practically
stopped
fol
from Mumbai's
en-
counter specialist Daya Nayak.
During
the
GBI recorded
investigation,
statements
of
the case to CBI. The bench in
signal
to
the
central
probe
agency to come up with itsfinal
report.
On the
contrary
government found
the
itself
various witnesses that have establishedthat Sadiqwas incus-
state
tody
of Gujarat police for nearly
two weeks. However, GBI has
the apex court sought expi
thformed HG that various doc-
tion from it on how could it set
up a special task force (STF) to
uments and material evidence
have beensentto different labo-
fake encounter.
ratories for examination, and
the probe agency may get reports in the next few months.
introuble inthe proceeding, as
inquire hito the allegations of
tout on
Sadiq died in a shiOOtu
January 13, 2003
ne
tear Galaxy
Cinema in Naroda.
NEW DELHI: Dismissing the plea
of the Central Bureau of In
vestigation (CE!),
ortugal's
Portugal SC
Suprénie Coüi-t lipheld the
decision of its lower
that
the
court
traty
with India was violated in
Abu Salem's case by slapping
of new charges against the
underworld
don that:attract
death penalty.
However, the CB! clarified
on Tuesday that the Supreme
Court had not cancelled the
extradition of
Salem and that
only a technical point had
been raised. It also said the
not expected
order was
"have
tepercussions
any
to
On
the status ofAbu Salem and
the ongoing trial against him
in India. The Supreme Court
its order
gave
on Saturday
while dismissing a CEI appSl
against the lower court dcci-.
sion which had held that rules
had been breached during the!
extradition of AbuSalem in
2005.
A CBI spokesperson
said
here that the option of ffling
!
az appeal before the Constitutional Court in Portugal
was available to the agency
likely to be
and it was
exercised.
AbuSalem, the prime accused
in the
1993
Mumbfii sé-
rial blasts, and his girl friend
Monica Bedi were extradited
to India on November 11,
2005, after a prolonged legal
battle in Pqrtugal that went
on for three years. The underworld don was also wanted in
the murder of film producer
Guishan Kumar.
His extradition came after
an assurance by the Indian
tovernméñt totortugal that
he would
no!
be given death
penalty, a key requirement in
extradition
proceedings
in
Europe.
There iséxpected to be no
on the status of
repercussion
Abu Salem and on the on-gotrial' against
ing
him. Trial
courts at Lucknow and Mumhis petbai have rejected
itions," a CBI spokesperson
said.
Salem had Mcd a petition
in the High Court in Lisbon
allégihg violation of Rule of
Speciality after which a judgwas pronounced
on
ment
Septemberl9, last year, saying
there had been breach of
the Indian undertaking given
to the Portuguese authorities.
The! CBI, through the Ministry
rejects CBI plea
extradition
of External Mfairs, filed
a plea in the Portuguese Sulireme CoUrt contending that
it was a matter of interpretation of the Rule of Speciality
by the highest court of India,
which was binding on all subordinate courts in the country, officill
sources said.
onAbu Salem
ektradition
Special Correspondent
Pörtugal court
rejects CBI plea
AGE CORRESPONDENT
JAN. 17
SALEM MOVES
a setback for the CEI, the
COURT, SEEKS
NEW DELHI,
Supreme Court of Justice
(Portugal) has upheld verdiet
öf the
high court
of
Lisbon which had tenninated the extradition of
gangster and 1993 Mumbai
serial blast's accused Abu
Salon,
ThQ high court
(Lisbon),
litt its order on
END TO TRIAL
AGE
CORRESPONDENT
17
MUMBAI, JAN.
Hoürs
after the. Portugal
Supreme
Court ruled
that
September 20, 2011, had terminated its government' $
India
had
terrns
ot his
authorisation of the extradition öf Salern to Indla in
treaty, 1993 bomb blasts
accused Abu Salern ffled an
November 2005 to face trial
In aroundelght cases.
nated
While
rejecting
Indias
plea,
Portuguese
the
Suprenje Court upheld the
violated
the
extradition
appllcation with Ute desigTada court seeking
an end to Ute trial agalnst
hirn.
Salem, who is currently
order of court of appeal
(high court-Lisbon) which
lodged in Ute Central Jail
In Ta.loja, was brought to
had
India frorn Portugal In 2005
and has been under trial
held that there was a
breach of rtile of speclality
In the matter of extradit lon
46-year-old
of
Salem.
Cancelling the extradition,
high court accused
the
probe
ageneies,
Indian
Including the CBJ, of violat
Ing
Ute
conditions
under
which he was permitted to
be
taken
India in
to
November 2005 to. face trial
in eight cases.
Reacting to the order, the
on Tuesday claimed
.
since heil.
Onj'uesday,
Ute Portugal
Suprerne Court ruled that
Salem's extradition treaty
had been
violated after
charges
penalty
against
attracting
had been
hirn. As
punishment
has
death
slapped
capital
been
banned
in Portugal, his
extradition treaty was terminated, Ute court aid.
CBI
that the Supreme Court of
Justice (Portugal) has not
cancelled the extradition of
Constitutional
Court
thera," sald the official.
nical point had been raised.
A senior official of.the CBI
The offlcial added, "The
issue of violation of rule of
speciality' has been exam-
said,
"The order is not
expected to have any reper-
med
cussions on the status of
Salem and on the on-going
similar petitions mcd by
Abu Salem in India which
trial against hirn in Indla."
"The Union governtuent
through its order dated
September 10, 2010 has held
is exploring the possibility
of
approaching
the
that thera has been no violation of Rule of Speciality
alter examining the issues
Salem and that only a tech-
Constitutional
Court
of
Portugal.
The Union government is likely to file an
appeal against the verdict
of Ute Portuguese Supreme
Court
before
the
length
by
at
the
Supreme Court of India on
pertaining
to
Rule
of
Speciality with reference to
and 1n
comparison with
extradition laws of the 13K,
the 118 and Portugal."
Setback to CBI in
Abu Salem case
NEW DELHI, 17 JAN: The Supreme Court of Portugal
today rejected the CBI's plea and upheld aPortuguese
lower court's decision that rules have been breached in
tile case of the extradition of underwofid don Abu Salem
by adding nS charges that carry the
death penalty.
The CBI, however, maintained that there is no setback
in the Salem case and it has another
option of filing an
appeal before the Constitutional Court in Portugal.
'As of
now we cannot comment anything more than this. We
will:: first have to study the Portujl Supreme Court
order," said a senior CBI officer.
The 43-year-old Aim Salem Abdul Qayoom Ansari
was an absconding accusedin thel993 Mumbai serial
blasts case kad extradited to India in 2005. He had filed a
petition in the High Court m Lisbon claiming the CRI
had violated the Rule àf Speciality b adding charges
which attract death penalqc
India had given an "execUtive assurance" to. Portugal
that Salem would not be given death pehàky or charged
with any section of law which entails iail term of more
than 25 years.
in iS order on 19 September
last yeaE, theHigh Court
;in Lisbon dberved that the CBI had
breached the
undertaking given by the. Ihdian authorities
to the
Portuguese authorities. siis
2G
press trust
CBI allowed to place more docs
of india
Special
...
public prosccmor U Ii lalits
argument that former telecom miniskr
17 JAN: Rejecting the
thiecrions of almost all the accused, a
NEW DELBI,
Delhi couxt ttsog the 2G spectrum dieution case today aflovtd the CBF a plea
more documents, including
the communications between Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
(ThAI) and Department of Telecom
(DoT), as eiidence.
SpecU judge 0 j' Saini allowed the
agencys plea to submit to the court
additional documents, acceding tocßlls
to submit to it
has alreadybeen allowed to take
three our of the ftsor sets of documents
sougiat to be placed by the agency on
A Raja
the courts rerord.
inviewolthe
ftctthatalldocu.
ments batting one, have been sought to
be placed on record by accused A Ra
and his application has been allowed, I
do not see any reason for declining the
CBI prayer as list as item number 2 (110
(one particular set of document in the
list) is concerned.. In 'lew of the facts
and drrumst2tircs of the cast and the
law applicable on the subject, the prayer
is
allowed
and
to be placed
documents axe allowed
on record,"
the court said.
Most of the accused bad opposed
airs plea lbr placing the additional
documents to else court arguing why
CIII did not place them despite having
a-telecom
Clii had no objection to it,
cngthe prayer is allowed and
die entire tile in with documents, mendoned in the appbis are contilneti
are allowed to be placed onrecord, copies
of th have alreac
been supplied tee
the accused persons," it said: A day
scheddedbennlog of the
before
deposition by
chairman Neipendau Misra,
them in their possession. The court said
former IlWs
that during arguments, defence counsel
had pointed out that the entire ThAI file,
from which the documents have been
placed on the court record, should be
allowed to be submitted to the court as
a 2G case wimess, on 11 January, the Clii
had sought to place some adthtkS documents on court records,
The dixurnerns include 11W tiles, the
corrDndence between Mr Misra and
secresary and accused
Shldlmeth Debuts on issues of spectrum
alloarion. CDI. el its plea, had said the
dcoal4lçnLl could not hat been placed
on record earlierdue coinadwnence",
The agencfs -plea was opposed by
some of the accused on the ground that
the prosecution should not be allowed to
fit such applications as and when it
chooses todo sa During the arguments,
Mr U-U Lalit submitted Iherewas no
legal bar in placing documents which
could -not be placed on record earlier
with the change-sheet.
Bbanwari Dcvi, utterly unequal
She may have used sex and threats to get her way, but her murder
raises troubling questions about crime and political power
the
BRINDA KARAT
delay ha takhig
ton5
hiss
against
action
lain
from the cabinet and thi
ova
ciii
party was only because of the court heat
rnga Thia
blatant
oo
the
ser,
TTTF C2Tdirectorwna reiaiiactecl oft Hot
Macoil
flea and
film. Sca
on
it is
a
J-ideoutpe.
-
responsible for a.rresti.ng
Blaunwari De
i
se
cii
a key
Manr
fa.r more
syst em
r
when
are
'a
nis-
con-
to
a fall-
caste-based considerations, surety
"-oman
dangerous
clevelopo,enr for
than the ftt ie.d
to get
a
return.
efforts of
ifit is
even
a
through
hi ackm sit, for what she h sri p roviclerl.
ha action to fel leisure otticers
spoke at
se
the other. If criminals
woman
the
in office because ofthe tear of
out
at,
of caste to demean the
haod aod to val o rise
one
on
tinoe
loilced to the faarth issue, th
is
usc
Whdo there is hardly ant rissc-u asian on
ho] cis I,
sat! es. there are no
arred on
a.ccusecl in the
these
in t lao naedia,
she ehr, rr,cser assassinat ion of Ehanws' ri
widely
reader and viewers would agree. Indeed.
Dcvi. For example, it was
there seems to he cleat evidence 0f tlatck-
that CDT officials had founcJ evirtence that
mail,
politicians, sex,
(l)s",
the CIII
as
edoa put it. BhmawariDevise
lady
CD'
on some
replayingof
.s
a.o
iS
aH
the
ol th
that di is
a
playing and
xchange for
therrgranthnother,and
ro ooen'
in
that really what the
case
a CD?
worn
ala
re.lv
awflv
ight
defence, that whatever she did
t tc
'cii
nier. Tn all
Dcvie cacte,
a 'eat the
we na
rin
cannot j
us
it ii iThanwari
character carl behaviour, which
centre nfpublic atteiit ion.
cases ate
en who
cia i's vi ct mi
Sation in consensual sexual relations. The
consent of
in
a sexua
against
a.ct is
it. L nder Section 375 oft he Indian Pc-
nat Curie, there
include being
aix
ass
cIa useS, which
given intoxieants.
unsound us i or] and
to
on.
being of
wh cia. if relevant
it sating
in the ea'se, wouldbe considered aa
the
as-
The
consent.
During
us an
coni d then be tried
fos
i apc
on
rape law reform, the issue of
cape. when
the discussions in the 'SOs
a sat an u t ii isea
po'ec
hitsuperior
1'osi-
tion to
have sexual relations with
pioyee.
wasalso discussed. I tnfottunateiy,
thiswas not
accepted.
Lnder Section 376.
the law tecognises the issue
rect
im
an ena-
only
in
an
mdi-
r, that ia. by enhancing the pun
'ii an
acon
ted hat
'ii isused
liic
position to rapo asubordmato insomo spocitic institutions ] ike remand hornet, hotpoticic st at ions. Iho mrnisrn,
pilsils,
for the
iccu
sed
puni
at
in such
ci seq
years. In Bhanwari's
neitherof these
case,
'tivu LLtili
g!2flj
extract
d the
empi
LVOU 15.
sexti
of Bhaiva ri"
S
oii
the
now ont
old-see
isbn
as a result,
onlvbc conccture, hut
supplicant
clearly
officials havo donatod part of thoir
introducedlie r to the
that enable ministers and Ml As
the relations were consensaol.
the free riorn
this however
unequal
an
th nec involved
aide,
serving
a
(Hehiot
negate
in the
In
mist ci
an elected
Mt.A ot the ml
36
worn an
enipi
cams-midwife
Singh,
an lvi
transfer
women
to
r-otd
oyed
He pal ri
ached tiled
as an
one
associate, also
auxit ia rv
On the
coat
flu ree-
Bhonwam ri first met Mciltdaon
IA frnni the a.rea,
away
(mis
home. ft is
employees to
elected
woman
yeci
the
in the Ashok
hja
other,
itV of
reta a ions of
(In
Ca SC
gosemment and
ci
th C lea
power
rn stop
common
(1 ft
en
a case
,ia
,r
of
they
cIuIt
to
ccxii
choose
a ilv
UCC
to
RS
hay!
I1
and getaway in
conse 'it?
TT3R there
-
the
jeeli
a
hadeground check of how many Ehanwari
Devis there
may
have been?
Tt is not he ins
Dev
W3S fl
VjctiEll
argued
who had
aersou a
and iarer
agency in th
case
questions
does rais
rebarcIiva
t
behaviourand actions of elected representarives and she disturbing trends that
rdflcctod intha dogencrasionand criminal
the
of exploitation
and anise ae of power if the detect reps
are
ity in the political system.
Firstly there is the blat tint
sa
nat
rate
8 per
community
today is
she was,
a
amoon
cent,
it
as
high
-
reach hun, school She
tion tests to
iss
as
5(5
-
in
when for her
was eves,
En
lower.
die telaooi
88 per cent, here
child hIde, who managed to
passed
hecon,e
idwife {ANM). iii Es
a.n
Et
the
rtualisica-
auxiliaty
not
a
nurse
small inst.
pur district helong to the S Ifs and hUt. of
whom
hardly
munity.
any
helens to
of power
com-
chilrlren to school. Todrn those chilnlresa
cannot, perhaps, be shieldcd from the bra
tality
of their mothers death, hut they
arid ahott Id ho p rot edo ci fran
their mother really
th0
iudoenieots
can
highly
ofwho
w,
con-
cabinet minister hurl with ci iminat,
murderous gangs. Thc third issue
the not
She used her earnings to send her
coloured and one-sided
use
tot sexual natification. Secondly, the
tact
own
literacy
was j List
Only 47women of Lhe 617 ANMs in jodh-
Ui at Blianwa ii
no
choices she made. but the
RSIJSL sthsin
even
ally
for
may have tomoke repeated visits. It
would, however, he
women as
ft is alsoworthrememboring that Bhao
ri De imd cxossecl several harriers. Ai
when the dropout rate inrEv
her
make such req LIests
teprentatives.
mister.
ni
goven,.ment also has made known
time when the
Wlav was this clone? Are there special rule
sectinnewnutdaflaly. AccoicEng torhe law,
the utterly
she w
and ho the power centre, it
an un-
compassionate gest 050. investiga-
its decision to pro isle assist once to them.
TheeIrcuulst~Lnces
the
s he sii o
oyees need to
of
have dis
cwsrd money to hctp thc childs cit Jiac Rsi-
1ncounters with the MLA
can
woutdbu onhancod from sesonycars to ton
con-
sexual
i
sau
a woman
crucial m laws
siclered
and
jast I, an
i ch rile 'it if the
chine nt
cautiouswhen it conies
to represeciting wois
FtUHNIr VHUKL
pet
say, in he'.
Womenactiviete working on sexual harassnient
tion
and hlackiaa ailed
'a
clepe.iid e'it
continuedgoing to school. In fact, in
usual
While same wruld say she
w;th hiacknin it, othe vs
know
now
thor in jail. thc thrcc childrcn are
is all
should have known that she could not
We
trcn the t iiith. With the ii ta-
t
rnwhac1ashc
sclaenung
through
is
audio recorclio
about'? An elderly political leadertrapped
by
had amassed huge amounts of
nurse
wealth throuehhla.ckn,sil."
channelsand lb
hen rd oak ing for
the ci). BLLt
ottlie
dia
1rticu
i
explici because
i
reported
concerns
17w
T+rilirLs!ainam
herofih
0"
PMpolithun
Extradition rules flouted: Portugal SC
EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE
Supreme Court, contending that it was a
NEW DELHI, JANUARY17
matter of interpretation of Rule of Spe-
setback for the CBI, Portugal's
was binding on all subordinate courts
ciality by the highest court of India, which
IN
A
Supreme Court rejected its appealagainst
in
the countr)c
the decision of the Lisbon High Court
Meanwhile, Salem has moved aTADA
which had held that mles were violated
court in Mumbai seeking closure of the
during the ext mdition of undeiworld don
trial against him
Abu Salem since hewas slappedwithnew
charges that attract death penalty.
dition of Abu
Salem,"
Salem, a key accused in the 1993 blast
ABU SALEM
CASE
confirmed a CBI
spokesperson.
onWc
day.
cision ofthe Court of Appeal, Lisbon, vide
of Rule of Speciality inthe matter of extm-
itwill beillegal.Thc
IAL)Acourtwillhearliispl
"The PortugueseSChasupheld the de-
which it had held that there was a breach
the 1993 Mumbaiblasts
continuh
case, was extradited to Indiawith Monica
11, 2005,
Bedi on November
after
marathon legal process in Portugal. h
Court inLisbon
allegingviolationof Rule
2c05, the NDAgoveinment gave the exec-
of Speciality after which ajudgement was
utive
have no effect on
pronounced on September 19 last year
would be tried
Salem's ongoingtrial in Mumbaiand Luc-
stating that there had been breach of the
would not be awarded imprisonment cx-
know. Officials pointed out that Portu-
given to the Por
hxlian undertaking
agg
tuguese authoriti
rities.
ceeding25yenThegiwemment
alsoun-
dertook that he would not be tn
d und1er
The CBI. however, maintained that
the verdict would
gal's
Supreme Court has not cancelled
Salem's extradition, and had
only raised
India had given
an"exe cutive assur
gv
any
assurance to Portugal that Salem
only
in eight cases and
special law. The CBI then justified
a technical point. The agency isplanningto
ance" to Portugal that Salem would not
file an appeal before the constitutional
be given death penalty or charged with
had no option but to agree to Portugal's
court of Portu
any section of lawwhich
entailsjail tenn of
conditions as Salem was holding a Pak-
Salem, 43,whowasextmditedtolndia
in 2005, had filed a petition in the High
more than 25years.
The CBIhad
pproached Portugal's
dropping of MCOCA charges, saying it
istani passport and could have been de
portedtoartcountiy.
sdoii&ib
1I5R
ttcIH
31
3f11
iR's
at 4nn
-
iftwti Stt
39UTf*t9T
ftw
aiñt
*l1
ti
21Mtii
2111
3T
7
iwir
W 2005
q5ffgMd:sflNafl
16
3'k
13
YR
5tlt
ZN
IIR
ZI5 Q
2013
ZEF
31(
tlR1t
3tff ?qmT
UI
1tdF3I
31gTZt
*I31V9
3
yIr
IZVI1
*1
I5
Sadiq encounter probe: CBI seeks 6 months more
LAK(
HIliECI:enrrol Bureau olIn-
vesluntiorl
(CIII
los
sixinioutit extensou
(lujaral
sou1hu
frotnt]ne
Hielt Court for i0
the 2003 police
ve.stijting
encounter
of Sacliq Jamal
N4cFatartnT.4ving
o[ireer.s ofal ne
hitch
rank
pohee.
An application
on
thin re-
Iiti:.il be 11oCt11 in
tire 11 igincoit rt on hi onclay.
ea'-ct nrnia
hud ni-dered 681
robe into the encrettlte r of
6
I?
'
bribe1
by
Na rode
Jo
(lEinja rat po1 ire
area
an aty .13,
of the
to
tfl(
ectoplete iroct
t'ortprefera ttv witti.i
otittix,
'perO]i
t
mile
tvhtc Ii
cix
got
\ltoicI..:iv.
Tb
IiiI'
tie
ncou!.t(rr
n1<
key
invoLved
fficilot(..iL'jal-!t
LdiIg "UspcI"Idc(I
As pail ofiawestiution CIII
Soh'ssLmddi'sSheikhtkkeen
counterc
hut he Icl c halle'teed itin the
Imn(Jcd
h1 ,mthat Elligh court saving
that lie ahotikl not Lv inlerro
fleece
I
Ite
rsrodkar has also
issued simnnnoi CsI5ALuln
BibasacI ic)um!JlstL
C[3T
accesed in
has cited rettacate Lila
scrrs-recerptrsf reports
Jb1Ei.
askcI
H
iii
city ott
IRS ofhe,r ]) c:,\SIL1n:L,on
of the
srfsci-
striPs tests from Irrb:s.
nt.cci to exanhitte more
in I tie
rate
I
Ire
wa
anti pen-
un 'nr'u of petittoin n M urnhtti
tititnit Crut-t e Intatenpintn ton,
issued by ftc agency
15cc we ne.sscs Ki:snI1.irc.4
0 seek
exlenyusn.
nt his
Tiroikar had alkgcd than
atliclavit tiled
COCA toe
rt
at
special MCc
ot Mathraltstca
tkat \1LlflH!i polic&s
Naval
lm(J
Li
I)ava
in I
w hen
hipNt idanoflSu
has air
dv cxa'ninccl 107
witneises
neonnectionwith
wn
ase.
The
over to Cnjai-at
nuaiy
A not her
of
cks
retttone
soic.nrific
ited
by
nd
otud
to ats
vii
were
riottsoge.n
Eoenichh
ot
remim to
iii its
it tike]y
n1:[nv
to
kiter
for "seok Ltr extettston
that rv:poda of aittimbor
awaited front
me.t tee
II. 2003.
lie
K7B1[
'vat
led i ver SaiL1
toGujarzt pol'cctooblu
cE:
Ise affidavit t has
I
On June16Iastveun. HiIu
PRESSTRUSTOFINDIA
khMtVAt\D.JAN
witn.
be etotni.neci. C7B111
ttpptics[tiontnatm
While nrdeiingChiT probe
in
he
cane inn
junali cc.
.Tu me lana year,
that his brotlict
led
jat-at
encounter
by
high raoleittg
tst)lsee
stilseets
ita
was
(Ills-
a fake
reason-
ensitlet-ir g l]attt in
thres other police ettootuitter
etuses.
probe
'vat out
aeattat
theaatneoifieeru.
With aview ta'ttvott!
tea.' itt ::aad caty ttjrther::i.ttetytfuture. itt
itt the
the
bias ut
tioa 0' bias
ut future.
Ni '1:1 Shah round upp
rehcaueioin tannin hr Sari ic1'e
brot Ito Sha its ir in It is peti-
tion
DIice
able'.
circuitances
theease, tha court
ion titat
i-ied
oLd
doe000
tat
o1
taptit-
maettirtttiot he
car
hoot iILdS]DeILLkILL
like. CBI."
tktetvrcl.
court
had
_
_
_
_
_
__
_
jcilll
(j,sfiH
'E
t ffr: *nT
ft
lIrl*I
ft iikcti dlß'i
4 14)3T
c
*i a*'iui
ft?11 ?sm
11T
If
IMI4uI
31fl 314t9 f
i
INT
9va
lAti
193 W
f
%
aii
3ttll
ti W
iiG
SR4«(
UT
4ukAw
31U1*11
*
*rt
*lTIa*&T1i(43)
2OOStMcF&i
‚ ‚
IIHI
MCI4UI
„‚
ft
UdlpM
31cIdd '31N1'II
ic*IL
Vl3
111919
R*T
il4lan
qii4tift
ITIIIT
iiiismm
iicfl adwft4t
r
tPti a*nizinaallfl'g
dtaiiti
MiidwipMtiwhlra
aiiqi«i fii
R%ts*ft
u'u
ffmi
11ft141tt
25 1119
11?IT
t 11tI
t
it
i
1z
*li.n ft
Sii
ffl
altft9pT
*
R
2U
3T1991
fi
*
ftiil
rgramfilfWM
tIM
qlgMg
-t
irnjfia%
ftuflrz tf~9,
eiul
20103T4311T*
iii'iOtS
tftfiiv
flaflu
rr
"
3flS fl3fl
-
3TMJ5ci
**uUUi5TjT
ftR1: fiT
thiz
IT
WF1T*t
HII1N
qr
'im
wy
ii
TTtt
lT
WT1TW1
ciiiit
ft
'W'NI
''iti
S 'ttRT fl
V8f2flli
RWMthSTffi
N WTF'T
im
lVftl
-i>
-teq 'vw'n
TTT
*-9 WT'
'iTT'V
IIP1t
~r
-Ttfl
W1
R
1
tW
jfv
TLWIflPJrTL1TW
*impt
n,#t"mit
#NWT
k'3Wu1
zmki
T'TTflt
13Oth'iWP1'T'
fwit"'i'n