this PDF file
Transcription
this PDF file
GSTF International Journal of Engineering Technology (JET) Vol.1 No.1, 2012 Sustainable Community Based Mangrove Plantation Projects: Three Case Studies from Palawan Island, The Philippines Dimithri Devinda Jayagoda, Graduate School of Asia Pacific Studies (Doctoral Program) Ritsumeikan Asia Pacific University, Beppu City, Oita Prefecture, Japan. E-mail: mostlyibelieveinmyself@gmail.com Darshi Manohari Gamage, Chiikikagakukenkyusho (Area Development) Consultant, Oita Prefecture, Japan E-mail: dimithridarshi@gmail.com I. INTRODUCTION Abstract— Undoubtedly, mangroves and associated wildlife show signs of degradation in almost every region of the world. Historical data proves that in 10 regions, there have been continuous mangrove losses between the periods 1980 to 2005. The Philippines have lost its mangrove cover quite severely. In 1920, the country had 500,000 hectares of mangrove cover that has reduced to 117,000 by the year 1995. The heavy loss of mangrove forest in the world is due largely to human activities. There are community based mangrove plantation and livelihood projects conducted in the City of Puerto Princesa, on Palawan Island, Philippines, namely “Love Affair with Nature”, “Firefly watch in Iwahig mangrove forest” and “Mangrove Paddleboat tour in Sabang” were implemented and continued by the true efforts of the lord mayor, Edward Hagedorn. Valentines day mangrove plantation has been continuing annually since 2003. Mangrove forests have provided nursery grounds for fish, prawns and crabs and as supported matter, which are valuable sources of food for crustaceans and fishes. angroves are trees or large shrubs, including ferns and palms, which normally grow in or adjacent to the intertidal zone and which have developed a special adaptation in order to survive in this environment” (World Atlas of Mangroves 2010). Malena (1998) mentioned, “Mangroves are a community of intertidal plants including all species of trees, shrubs, vines and herbs found on coast, swamps, or border of rivers.” The term ‘mangrove’ can be used for both the ecosystem and the plant families that have developed specialized adaptations to live in this tidal environment (Tomlinson, 1986). Mangroves can be found in some Northern latitudes as high as 32 degrees, even though it is quite unique within 25 degrees North and South of the Equator (Maltby 1986). Mangroves cover an area of between 190,000 and 240,000 square kilometers (km2) globally and it counts for one quarter of the world’s tropical and sub-tropical coastlines (Kelleher 1995). The world Atlas of mangrove 2010 suggests that the total area of remaining mangrove in the third millennium is only 150,000 square kilometers. These calculations are done based on the available national statistics. Mangroves are considered as a rare global habitat. They currently make up less than 1 percent of tropical forests worldwide, and less than 0.4 percent of the global total forest estate (39,520,000 square kilometers) (FAO 2006). “M A unique methodology has been used in this study and photography has been used to document many of the qualitative findings. These Mangrove Plantation and livelihood Projects can be adopted in various other islands in the Philippines and the rest of the world. Recommendations are given to further improve the mangrove plantation project and to also stabilize and increase community participation. The qualitative data gathered from the local high-ranking officials and academia in Puerto Princesa proves that the mangrove is no longer being harvested and is continuously regaining through both the natural and planting processes of reforestation and afforestation. Findings from the interviews with local community prove that everybody in the city is aware about the importance of mangroves and that they are participating in the planting of and protecting the mangroves planted area in every possible manner. These qualitative findings are proved by available quantitative national statistics and which clearly shows the mangrove forest cover and the upland forest cover are increasing in Puerto Princesa during the last two decades. II. DECLINE OF MANGROVES IN THE WORLD There are two main types of sources causing heavy destruction of mangroves. Increasing population pressure in the coastal areas and over-harvesting of timber and other wood products is one type of destruction of mangrove forests. The second type is, in recent years, a more significant cause appears to be the demand for land by key primary sector economic development activities, such as mining, conversion to salt ponds, shrimp ponds, agricultural and aquaculture expansion (Barbier 2003). From 1989, shrimp farming has increased over 400 percent in tropical countries since1989 and its share of world shrimp production increased from 5 percent in 1982 to over 30 percent by 1996 (Anderson and Fong 1997). Naylor et al. 2000 said that farmed fish and shellfish in the coastal zone Keywords-Community Participation, Environmental projects, Leadership, Mangroves, Sustainability 38 © 2012 GSTF GSTF International Journal of Engineering Technology (JET) Vol.1 No.1, 2012 have more than doubled in the past 15 years and there is a huge increase in global demand. the trend, the positive note is that mangrove area changes in 2000–2005, shows a reduction of the annual rate of loss in all regions. “The world mangrove experts are of the opinion that the long-term survival of mangroves is at great risk due to fragmentation of the habitats and that the services offered by the mangroves may likely be totally lost within 100 years” (Duke et al., 2007). Some other estimates show that global loss rates annually at 1 million hectare, and in some regions facing a danger of complete loss (Kathiresan and Bingham, 2001). Global mangrove cover has been declining at an alarming rate, and it has lost about 35 percent of the total area in the past decades. Therefore the coastal mangrove systems are now considered as one of the “most threatened” ecosystem and much threatened than coral reefs and tropical forests (Valiela et al. 2001). During past 30 to 40 years, in Asia, Latin America and Africa have lost between 30 and 70 percent of their mangrove area (Spalding et al. 1997; WRI 1996). Whenconsidering the country level, Indonesia, Mexico, Pakistan, Papua New Guinea and Panama has recorded largest losses of mangroves during the 1980’s which counts for 1 million hectares and this is the land area of Jamaica (FAO 2006). Figure 1 clearly shows that during the period 1980 to 2005, there was a dramatic loss in mangrove forest in every region except for Australia. South East Asia, North and Central America, Pacific Ocean and East Asia show the highest decrease and it is more than 20 percent in 25 years. But when analyzing the global trend in terms of declining comparatively there is a slight reduction. In 1980`s the annual global loss is 1.04 percent and in 1990`s it is 0.72 percent and further dropped to 0.66 percent during five year period in 2000`s. However Duke et al (2007) estimates that the decline is 1 to 2 percent and Valiela et al (2001) estimates it as 2.07 percent per year. These estimates are significantly higher than the FAO estimates. Figure1: Decline in mangrove by regions between 1980- 2005 1980 1990 70,000 2000 60,000 2005 Area (Km2) 50,000 III. MANGROVES IN PHILIPPINES The Philippine mangrove forest area was estimated to be around 450,000 hectares in 1920 and due to conversion to fishponds and salt beds, cutting of trees for firewood and other domestic uses and reclamation for industrial or other development purposes. This area has reduced to less than 150,000 hectares that is distributed among 22 percent in Palawan, 32percent in Mindanao, and 23 percent in Eastern Visayas and Bohol (DENR 2011 interview). Also Cheryl et al 2005 mentioned that the mangroves in Philippines was 500,000 hectares in at the early 1900’s and reduced to 117,700 hectares by 1993 spread in 18,000 kilometer long shoreline. There is a record of mangrove depletion at a rate of about 3,700 hectares per year, during 1980 to 1991 specially due to conversion to fishponds and due that old growth mangrove areas are reduced to less than 20,000 hectares, about 65 percent of which are found in Palawan and the remaining in Zamboanga del Sur (Cheryl et al 2005). 40,000 30,000 20,000 10,000 0 Region Figure 2: Decline of Mangrove Resources in the Philippines Source: Estimations based on FAO 2007 data Mangrove raea (Hectares) Over different time periods, factors influencing the structure and function of mangrove forests change in relation to global, regional and local scales (Duke et al. 2007). Rate of mangrove loss is three to four times higher than overall global forest loss, which was estimated at 0.22 percent per year in the 1990’s, dropping to 0.18 percent per year in the five years to 2005 (FAO 2006). The countries in the three regions of East Asia, South East Asia and Pacific Ocean, have the highest annual rate of declining more than 1 percent. Even though the mangrove forests are still facing major threats, the rate of loss has been decreasing recently. From a record of 187 000 hectares lost annually in the 1980`s (–1.04 percent per year) has reduced to 102 000 hectares annually (–0.66 percent per year) during the 2000–2005 period (FAO 2006). By analyzing 600,000 500,000 400,000 300,000 200,000 100,000 0 1918 1970 1980 1988 1993 1995 Year of record Mangroves Source: Modifications based on DENR Statistics 1998 39 © 2012 GSTF GSTF International Journal of Engineering Technology (JET) Vol.1 No.1, 2012 Princesans participated in this massive mangrove tree-planting project. The project aims to protect and conserve remaining mangroves/beach forest tree species and to rehabilitate denuded coastal areas. The project has been successfully continuing to date and as of April 2009, the city government of Puerto Princesa was able to enrich/rehabilitate 58.5 hectares of denuded mangrove areas in adjoining barangays of San Jose and San Manuel. So far, 56,500 mangrove seedlings and 29,000 propagules were planted, with a survival rate of 71.7% (City ENRO 2011). Mangroves in Philippines are substantially changing over last 100 years. Huge quantities of mangroves are lost and remaining areas are degraded to some extent. According to Primavera 2000, 99.8 percent of mangroves in Manila Bay by 1951 are vanished by the year 1994. Further in Visayan Islands the losses are dramatic and it counts for 95 percent of mangroves lost during 1951 to 1994. Between 1968 and 1983 almost half of the total national mangrove area had decreased and it counts for 237,000 hectares of mangrove (Fernandez, 1978). According to the Research and Development Extension Framework 2007–2010 mangroves have degraded continuously and about 25 percent of the original mangrove areas have been converted into fishponds with an average rate of 5,000 ha/year in 1970’s and early 1980’s. The long-term objective of this program is to enrich the coastal water natural resources of Puerto Princesa in ways that are environmentally sustainable, socially equitable and economically practicable. The short-term objective is to protect and conserve the remaining mangrove/beach forest tree species and to rehabilitate denuded coastal areas. IV. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY Both qualitative and quantitative approaches are used in this study. The data was gathered from both secondary and primary sources. The data gathering techniques used in this study is desk research, interviews, case studies, observations, photography, focus groups, and surveys. The interviews were conducted at three different stages. The policy makers including the city mayor, high ranked cityhall staff and city environment office staff being interviewed on one to one basis. Focus group discussions and one to one interviews were conducted among the faculty members of the Palawan State University, Palawan Council for Development (PCSD) and other government organizations in the city. Three different questionnaires were used to interview people at different stages. Informal discussions and interviews were conducted among community leaders, university students, fishermen’s and participants at the Love Affair with Nature 2011. Several tourists, boatmen are interviewed in during fire fly watch and paddleboat tour. The author has participated in Love affair with Nature project in 2011 and visited the planting site and planning offices in both 2010 and 2011. Strict observations were been done during these visits and photography was used to record qualitative findings. Also observations and case studies were conducted in two other mangrove based ecotourism sites, to gather more information and opinions of local citizens. V. Figure 3: Mass wedding followed by mangroves planting Source: Author 2011 Mass wedding was introduced and mangrove seedlings serve as a vow material of the newly wedded couple as an added attraction to the project. In September 26, 2005 City Ordinance No 287, an Ordinance declared February 14 of every year as “Love Affair with Nature Day” in the City of Puerto Princesa. It aims to institutionalize “Love Affair with Nature Day” and to expand Valentine’s Day expression of love from the traditional person-to-person to Mother Nature and as a continuing call to ensure the protection and sustainable use of natural resources. Thus, every thereafter, massive mangrove tree planting and mass wedding has been conducting. THREE SAMPLE CASE STUDIES CASE 1: “LOVE AFFAIR WITH NATURE” The original idea was implemented by a group of boy scouts and girl scouts in Puerto Pricesa City. They have organized a mangrove plantation project in a valentines day and invited mayor to deliver a speech. After the first event, City Government of Puerto Princesa thru City Mayor Edward S. Hagedorn is spearheading the “Love Affair with Nature.” The program is one of the answers of Puerto Princesa to the call of Mother earth to address the alarming Global Warming. It was launched on February 14, 2003 by planting 2500 mangrove seedlings to two-hectare denuded mangroves of Barabgay (Community/village) San Jose. More or less 2500 Puerto CASE 2: “FIREFLY WATCH IN IWAHIG MANGROVE FOREST” This project was initiated by ABS-CBN investing money and implemented together with the city government. They didn't require any payment back but the community was requested to protect the nature. This project was started in 2008 and averagely 20 people from the local community worked per night. There are 137 members of ICETA (Iwahig Community Ecotourism Association) incorporated involved in this project. 40 © 2012 GSTF GSTF International Journal of Engineering Technology (JET) Vol.1 No.1, 2012 much visitors and sometimes only 5 visitors per week. But there was an increase of visitors after 2008. In 2009 10,000 tourists enjoyed paddleboat tours and in 2010 the number was increased up to 15,000. During the boat tour the tour guides provides various information about mangrove and they show various types. The members consist of 11 boatmen, 3 information staff and the rest are community members who invite for potential tourists. Figure 4: Iwahig Fiver and mangrove forest Figure 5: Mangrove Paddle Boat tour in Sabang Source: Author 2011 Source: Advertising of this activity is conducted via local hotels, travel agencies, tricycle drivers and word of mouth. Most of mangroves are here for so many years and cannot be cut down or harvested for any business. During the daytime and during off-season boatmen and local community gathers together and plant mangroves near the river. They strongly believe that more mangroves will be a habitat for more fireflies and that will results in more visitors and increased income. In the year 2010 there is a record of 7032 visitors. The safety is guaranteed and the boatmen are well trained as lifeguards in any case of an emergency situation. Safety jackets are used and visitors can conduct small workshops or information sharing meetings using the poster presentation at the sight. One boat tour cost Peso 600 (approximately $7) and a boat accommodates 3 visitors. The boatmen’s are very much educated and they also tour guide while paddling the boat. The boatman’s are well knowledgeable about the scientific, social and environmental aspects of the mangrove and fireflies. Out of the total daily income 50 percent goes to the staff worked in that particular day and balance 50 percent goes to the community organization. The local community can access that money as a loan in an emergency at very low interest rate. Author, Kumara 2010, 2011 Also visitors can enjoy the wild life sounds of birds and can see snakes in the branches of mangroves. The tour guide sings a song in the local language and also the translated version in English, which expresses about the beauty and the importance about mangroves. After the boat tour ends the visitors are welcome to plant mangrove trees as a memory to leave in Sabang. There will be 100 Peso ($ 2-3) charge for a boat ride per each visitor. Also the visitors are welcome to provide donations. From this earning 20 percent will be allocated on protection of mangrove and barangay (village) development project. The balance 80 percent will be divided among tour guides. Also there is financial support provided for local community when they are in an emergency, illness or accident. In Sabang the total mangrove area is only about 4 hectares and which is the natural forest. There will be no direct usage of the mangrove trees for livelihood activities. Only the indigenous people are allowed to extract firewood and the local community is now convincing them to use alternative options. In the fallen branches of mangrove a worm can be found called ‘Tamilo’. This is a local delicacy where people eat the worm raw by dipping in lime juice. The tourist can give donations and be allowed to try this very healthy local delicacy. CASE 3: “M ANGROVE PADDLE BOAT TOUR IN SABANG” VI. OUTCOME OF THE CONTINUOUS PROJECTS The Sabang mangrove tour is one of the fascinating attractions of Palawan. There are about 3to 4 boats in operation in every day. This project was initiated with the efforts of various partner organizations both locally and internationally. This project was initiated in 2002. The tour guide who works as the boatmen at the same time, have received 15 day training and every one of them are capable in communicating in English. The promotions about the project are done through pamphlets of the tour companies’ hoardings at hotels and information centers at the airport. During 2002 to 2008 there were not There was a study conducted by the PCSD in 2005 with the support of JAFTA, which is the most reliable updated data available to evaluate the mangrove forest cover in Puerto Princesa. This study shows the current mangrove cover in Puerto Princesa, which is 5,896.40 hectares, as shown in Figure 5. The mangrove forest was 4,052 hectares in 1992. Using SPOT satellite images PCSD has conducted the study in 1992. 41 © 2012 GSTF GSTF International Journal of Engineering Technology (JET) Vol.1 No.1, 2012 upcoming projects. Mostly two types of mangroves are planted in the projects due to the availability and accessibility for seedlings. A variety of mangroves should be planted to create the diversity. Plants like ‘Rhizophora’ can be planted without pre-planting and they actually grow fast. Proper system needs to be taking place in terms of removing plastic bags from the seedlings. There was no garbage removal system found on site at the moment of planting. The water level got increased and most of the bags were floated in to Sea due to high tied and for heavy raining which would create other environmental issues. Huge amounts of sea grass were uprooted in the mangrove-planting site because thousands of people walked on top of them. Sea grass also needs to be planted together with mangroves to increase the bio-diversity of the planting project. There were no hording or leaflets providing instructions on how to plant the mangroves. There were observations that people planted the trees without removing the plastic bag. To increase the survival rate, every participant should be informed about the steps of proper planting. Figure 6: Mangrove cover in Puerto Princesa Hectares Mangrove 6000 4000 2000 0 1992 1998 2005 Year Source: PCSD 2010 There is a slight increase in mangrove in 1998 compared to the data of 2005. An official at PCSD mentioned that the study in 1998 was conducted by a private organization using a different mechanism. Therefore, it is difficult to use a comparison because the mechanism is different in both 1998 and 2005. However, when comparing with the 1992 data, it is clearly visible that the cover of mangrove forest in Puerto Princesa has been increasing during last two decades. Much advanced invitation system is needed to attract more organizations to participate in the project. Proper advertising system needs to implement to promote paddleboat tour and fire fly watch. Regular Information Education Campaigns (EIC) needs to be implemented and proper advice also needs to be given to local community about the importance of mangroves in terms of environmental protection and increased economic gains. Increased tours and including the two tourism projects in tourist packages will increase the number of visitors. Almost everyone in Palawan is aware about the “Love Affair with Nature” project, but not all of them participate. Wider area is needed to be used for the community to plant more trees. When they have more space and seedlings are provided closer to planting area, there would be a higher tendency that each person may plant more trees. More funds are also needed for proper and strict implementation of mangrove conservation projects. In addition, manpower such as forest rangers is needs to be increased. The difficulty of following international regulations is a huge issue and a proper mechanism to measure carbon sequestration is required together with more tools to monitor such as GPS systems. Proper accesses to the two tourist sites are a major requirement needed to increase the efficiency of livelihood activities. There is a positive growth of mangroves in the province of Palawan as well as in the city of Puerto Princesa. It was just 29,910.14 hectares in 1992 and gained up to 57,386.52 hectares by the year 2005 in Palawan province as shown in Figure 6. All these planted areas were placed under protected status to form part of the Integrated Protected Area System (IPAS). The increase of mangrove forest in Puerto Princesa backs up by these local policies. Figure 7: Mangroves on Palawan Island Hectares Mangrove 60000 40000 20000 0 1992 1998 2005 Year VIII. CONCLUSION Source: PCSD 2010 There is clear evidence as shown in the paper that mangrove forests cover in the world is declining. In the Philippines, this decline rate is huge in the past few decades. But in Palawan however, there is one example that shows different trends against the usual global trend. “Love Affair with Nature” has following elements: Government involvement, necessary law enforcement, political will, proper leadership, community involvement, alternative livelihoods, education campaign, involvement of all local and national organization and willingness of local communities. These are needed to change this trend of degradation of mangroves in to VII. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FURTHER IMPROVEMENT OF PROJECTS Site selection should be conducted in a scientific manner so as to make sure that the most needed areas are been selected as the planting sites. “Love affair with Nature”project focuses more on planting mangroves closer to the sea. There is a need to plant mangroves closer to land also. Planting on riverbanks will also be another option to consider in the 42 © 2012 GSTF GSTF International Journal of Engineering Technology (JET) Vol.1 No.1, 2012 [5] rehabilitation. This project is implemented and continued by the true efforts and the leadership of the Mayor Edward Hagedorn. Every citizen of the Puerto Princesa is proud to be environmentally sound citizens. After conducting this study, the authors have developed a framework of success for the project “Love Affair with Nature” as shown in Figure 7. This framework consists of the three pillars of Sustainability: Economy, Environment and Society. The inputs and outputs are mentioned under each category and these elements guarantee the success and continuation of the project “Love Affair with Nature”. The framework can also be used in other parts of Palawan and other islands of the Philippines. [6] [7] [8] The left picture of the Figure 8 shows the Metropolitan Manila city and the two pictures on right side show the Puerto Princecsa city. These pictures were taken about one kilometer away from ground level while traveling by an airplane. This proves the efforts of the Puerto Princesa citizen’s love towards the nature. [9] [10] [11] Figure 8: From Manila to Puerto Princesa [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] Duke, N.C., Meynecke, O.J., Dittmann, S., Ellison, A.M., Anger, K., Berger, U. Cannic, S., Eiele,K., Ewel, K.C., Field, C.D., Kodedam, N., Lee, S.Y., Marchand, C, Nordhanus, L., and Dahdough‐Guebas, (2007) A world without mangroves? Letters. www. Sciencemag.org. p41. FAO (Food and Aggriculture Organization) (1994) Mangrove forest management guidelines. FAO Forestry Paper 117. Rome. FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization) (2006) Global Forest Resources Assessment 2005: Progress Towards Sustainable Forest Management, Rome, Forestry Department, FAO Fernandez, P.M. (1978). Regulations and their impact on mangrove areas for aquaculture – the Philippine experience. Workshop Proceeding on the conversion of mangrove areas to aquaculture, Iloilo, pp. 78‐84. Kathiresan, K. and Bingham B. L. (2001) Biology of mangrove and mangrove ecosystems. Advances in Marine Biology, 40: 81-251. Kelleher, G., Bleakley, C. and Wells, S. (1995) A Global Representative System of Marine Protected Areas. Volume 1. Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority, The World Bank and World Conservation Union. Maltby, E. 1986. Waterlogged Wealth: Why Waste the World's Wet Places? London: Earthscan Publications. Mark Spalding, Mami Kainuma, Lorna Collins (2010) World Atlas of Mangroves, Eaerthscan publications. Melana, D. M. (2000) Mangrove Management Handbook. Manila: Coastal Resource Management Project of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources. Spalding, M., Blasco, F. and Field, C. (1997) World Mangrove Atlas. International Society for Mangrove Ecology, World Conservation Monitoring Centre 1997. Tomlinson, P.B. 1986. The botany of mangroves. Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press. Valiela, I. J.L. Bowen and J.K. York (2001). „Mangrove Forests: One of the World‟s Threatened Major Tropical Environments.‟ BioScience 51(10), 807-815. World Resources Institute (WRI) (1996) World Resources 1996-7. World Resources Institute. New York: Oxford University Press. Source: Author 2011 Authors: ACKNOWLEDGMENT Dimithri Devinda Jayagoda (Sri Lankan) is pursuing a Ph.D. in the Graduate School of Asia Pacific Studies at Ritsumikan Asia Pacific University (APU) – Japan. Dimithri earned a master’s degree from APU in development economics and a bachelor’s degree in business administration. He has also completed Postgraduate Diploma in Marketting from the Chartered Institute of Markerting – United Kingdom. He is the founder of “Dimi on Education,” an open Facebook group that shares educational information. The authors would like to thank the Mayor Edward Hagedorn, faculty of Palawan State University, staff of City Hall and City Environmental Office, staff of PCSD and the citizens of Puerto Princesa City. A special thank goes to Professors Susumu, Sanga and Fellizar for their tireless support during this research. Also a special thank goes to APU faculty member Mr. Simon Bahu for enormous support. [1] [2] [3] [4] REFERENCES Anderson, J.L. and Fong, S.W. (1997) "Aquaculture and International Trade." Aquaculture Economics and Management 1(1):29-44 Barbier, E.B. (2003) “Habitat-Fishery Linkages and Mangrove Loss in Thailand,” Contemporary Economic Policy, forthcoming. Cheryl Joy J. Fernandez, Rodelio F. Subade and Paul Erwen T. Parreño (2005) 8th National Symposium in Marine Science held in Palawan State University, Puerto Princesa City on October 20-22, 2005. City Environment Office. (2011) “Love Affair with Nature”, internal communaication document, Puerto Princesa City. Darshi Manohari Gamage (Sri Lankan) has graduated from the college of Asia Pacific studies of Ritsumeikan Asia Pacific University-Japan in 2009. She has specialized in the field of tourism and currently working as a development-consultant at Chikikagaku- kenkyusho in Oita, Japan. Currently Darshi is the person in charge of two websites. One website is called “C-Voice” and which is targeting Japanese people and foreigners to come and experience the beauty, uniqueness, culture and special events in rural areas of Japan. The other website is known as “Nippon” and this website focus on promoting unique things of Japan to foreigners and it has an open Facebook group for interaction. 43 © 2012 GSTF