Exclusivefocus Fall 2012
Transcription
Exclusivefocus Fall 2012
Tablets Explained Branded Retail EnvironmentLetters to NAPAA Exclusivefocus Fall 2012 An Official Publication of the National Association of Professional Allstate Agents, Inc. Intriguing Agent Stories pages 14, 18, 20 Networking Ideas to Help your Agency page 34 Your Flood Book: Keep it, Sell it, or Roll it page 28 Great Expectations vs. Grim Realities: What Every New Allstate Agent Needs to Know page 22 Agency Business Objectives Program Exposed! page 40 A Bright New Day for Allstate Agents A Revolutionary Strategy to Minimize Price Objections while Enhancing your Community Status Page 42 Magazine for Allstate AgencyOwners Ownersand andAllstate AllstatePersonal PersonalFinancial FinancialRepresentatives Representatives AA AMagazine Magazinefor forAllstate AllstateAgency Agency Owners and Allstate Personal Financial Representatives Time For A Change PROS CURRENT CONTRACT CONS COMMISSIONS -- LOWER REDUCED EQUITY OF PRODUCT CHOICES -- LACK CONTRACTS CHANGING QUOTAS -- HIGHER FEELING FRUSTRATED -- UNAPPRECIATED MIXED MESSAGES PRICES -- UNCOMPETITIVE BROKEN PROMISES - LOSINGCUSTOMERS TWFG has: 200+CARRIERS HIGH COMMISSIONS IMMEDIATE EQUITY PERSONAL MARKETS COMMERCIAL MARKETS HEALTH MARKETS LIFE MARKETS INTERNAL SUPPORT TEAM COMMERCIAL TRAINING MARKETING CO-OP COMPARATIVE RATER AUTO HOME COMMERCIAL LIFE HEALTH AGENCY ADVISORY BOARD FREE WEBSITE WITH CONSUMER RATING GROUP E&O IN-HOUSE MARKETING CO. 1-800-596-8934 • twfgagentsolutions.com • agentinfo@twfg.com !!! GREAT It’s how Allstate agents feel when we lend them capital. We like that. With 80+ combined years of experience in agency lending, we know the outlook for Allstate agents is great. At Capital Resources, we’ve originated more than $250 million in Allstate loans. It’s our specialty. We offer key benefits you won’t find at every lender. A highly efficient loan approval process. Lower down payments than most traditional lenders. Competitive interest rates with a variety of repayment options. Solid, sizeable resources. Sound good to you? Give us a call at 866-523-6641. Your personalized lender www.CapitalResources.com ©2011 Capital Resources. Allstate is a trademark of Allstate Insurance Company. CA Residents: Loans made pursuant to a Department of Corporations California Finance Lenders License. Exclusivefocus fall 2012 An Official Publication of the National Association of Professional Allstate Agents, Inc. FEATURES 12 To BRE or not to BRE: That is the Question By Lezlee Liljenberg 14 Gone, But Not Fading Away 16 17 By Gerry Flores Give the Devil His Due By Dave Thorpe By Brian Spillman 18 I’m So Proud of You: A letter to a terminated agent 20 The Short-lived Career of a Promising New Agent 22 Great Expectations 28 Your Flood Book: Sell it, Keep it, or Transfer it… It’s Your Choice 40 Be Wary of the Wolf Disguised as the Agency Business Objectives Program New Agents; is Allstate Everything it was Cracked Up to Be? 46 50 26How to Turn Every Call Into a Sales Call…Guaranteed! By Bill Gough 30 The Five Critical Cs of Acquisitions By Rick Dennen 34 Networking To Grow Your Agency By Robyn Sharp Allstate’s Future Course Is Anyone’s Guess 42 BUSINESS Kindness is Contagious How to Increase Sales and Boost your Reputation Sad Times at Allstate By Bryan Ahlquist True Success without Allstate By Bryan Ahlquist A Magazine for Allstate Agency Owners and Allstate Personal Financial Representatives 4 — Exclusivefocus TECHNOLOGY 37 What’s all the Fuss about Tablets? By Scott Brodbeck 54 Has ALSTAR Support Ever Told You to Contact Your Own IT Support? (Part 2) By Dan Helton HUMOUR 51 Name Changes… Oops, I Mean “Moniker Alterations” By Brian Spillman DEPARTMENTS 6 8 53 60 62 President’s Letter Letters to NAPAA Membership Application NAPAA Market Place NAPAA Board of Directors Fall 2012 Grow your business. Retain your identity with Couri Associates. Hear what our associates are saying about our focus on agents and our great commissions! Visit www.couriagents.com/raves/ Or Scan this with your Smartphone QR Reader App. Search “QR Code” in your App store to download a mobile reader. Or Ask one of these strategic partners about Couri Associates’ value This is just a sampling of the quality carriers Couri represents. Interested in becoming part of the Couri family? Visit our website, couriagents.com or give Steve Albinger a call at 800-444-1215. president’s letter Trying to Make Cents out of Nonsense In Solidarity Bob Isacsen President NAPAA/OPEIU Guild 17 6 — Exclusivefocus My quarterly messages in Exclusivefocus are often dependent on what is happening to the agency force as a result of Allstate’s actions. Oftentimes, their actions make little sense because of the adverse affects they have on agents, customers and the Allstate brand itself. To make matters worse, the company rarely shares its true motivation for the moves it makes, frustrating us even further. Let’s begin with some unsettling issues that are impeding our progress and for which the company has not divulged its true motives. • Variable compensation with a 9% base. The company says that agents will make more money. What they aren’t saying is that only a fraction of the agents will achieve the top comp rate. In 2013, agents will have to jump through four “hoops” to get back to 10%. In the first year of two, it won’t be too hard to make, but watch for a tightening thereafter. The fact is the company doesn’t want agents to make more than 9% because it will affect profitability. What Allstate is not talking about is its plan for 2015, when the 9% compensation moratorium expires. Watch for your base compensation to drop to 8% or less. • Uncompetitive markets and fewer Allstate branded products. What the company will never tell you is that they are making a fortune on their Expanded Markets portfolio. Allstate has long been suspected of skimming commissions off the top and paying agents the paltry leftovers. Expanded Markets is a no-risk profit center for Allstate. It has no claim exposure, so its only expense is the ultra-low comp it pays you to sell and service the business. Watch for the company to further limit its branded property products in favor of more Expanded Market opportunities. It is no secret that Allstate has not been competitive in most markets for some time. It used to be that when agents complained about Allstate rates, management would retort by saying, “We’re Allstate and we’re worth it,” as if they were L’Oreal. But today, it has gotten so bad the managers don’t even believe the company line, as more and more of them take their business to Esurance. Will the competitive climate improve? Perhaps, but only if they plow the money they save from confiscating your commissions into rate relief. • What I fear is that instead of rate relief, Allstate will take those savings and use them to subsidize Esurance, which is experiencing significant underwriting losses. According to some reports, Esurance frittered away $1.22 for every dollar of revenue it collected in the first six months of 2012. Continuing to fund Esurance only hurts Allstate agents because it takes resources away from the Allstate brand. • Connexus, the new commercial software program for quoting commercial auto is a mess. According to feedback from our members, it is complicated and difficult to use, and what was once heralded as cutting-edge technology, has become another source of aggravation for users. Like most other company technology launches, agents have become the guinea pigs for trial and error. • The new Agency Business Objective program will be effective on January 1, 2013. Recently, agents were sent a new grid informing them of their new quotas. For most of us, this was no surprise, even though a small minority of agents thought that quotas might actually disappear as a trade-off for lower commissions. No such luck. The fact is Allstate will never willingly abandon quotas. Next year’s quotas are rather innocuous, but they will become more burdensome in years to come. If you don’t like them, you might want to get started on a Plan B. • Book values continue to plummet. Three years ago, agents might have sold their books for three to four times annual commissions. Today, they are lucky if they get two times and many don’t even bother to put their books up for sale anymore; they take TPP instead. Selling a book of business has become a nightmarish experience for some. There is too much management interference and lenders make too many demands. Gone are the days of counting on your book to finance a comfortable retirement. Now that we’ve covered some of the problem issues, let’s talk about some positives. The Allstate brand is still among the bestknown and most respected brands. The ad campaigns are better than they were a few years ago Continued on page 8. Fall 2012 “Is your agency planted in good soil, supported wIth deep roots and really growing?” Scan with smartphone to learn how ASNOA can help your business grow. http://asnoa.com/video/ mobile/index.html • More control over your future with Increased Independence “ASNOA provided direct access to the markets we needed, providing us the ability to compete with national and regional agencies. The automation support saved us time and money, which enabled us to divert more resources to marketing and growing our business. The results on our bottom line have been amazing!” • 80% total premium growth in 2011 • Increase your revenue faster than you ever thought possible • A Proven Network of Success • Secure Carrier Markets • A stellar support system for Independent Agents Fall 2012 John Garrett, CPCU, MBA, LUTCF, President-Chicago CPCU Chapter Principal, Coverall Insurance Services, Burr Ridge, IL We are Insurance Professionals helping other Insurance Professionals realize their full business potential. See how the ASNOA Advantage can help your agency grow. Watch the video at: www.asnoa.com/video ® www.asnoa.com Exclusivefocus — 7 © Copyright 2012 letters to NAPAA I’m really interested in seeing what happens with Allstate and I’m amazed the agents are putting up with all the changes. On the independent agent side, commissions are higher than I ever expected, i.e. Travelers is paying 22% on home and 17% on auto. Every company I represent pays at least 15% and the rates are better. By year-end, our largest competitor here in my state will move into the IA world and I’ll get an appointment with them. I can’t imagine what happened to Allstate and its rates. They pay minimum commissions and still can’t match the competition. Something’s amiss in Northbrook. ages from prior employers and are pouring the money into Dante’s Inferno. I talk with a lot of these folks and they all seem to agree that being an Allstate agent is not the “cakewalk” they were promised. I think my “Sabotage” article turned out well... Just out of curiosity, have you received any feedback on it? Also, do you have a digital version of the article? I have a few out-of-state friends I would like to send a copy to. president’s letter I believe very strongly that community involvement is key to long-term success in business. I am president this year of my local Rotary Club and do volunteer work for other community groups as well. I believe in my heart that what is lacking in our world is empathy, and with more of it, we could solve many of the world’s problems! I got an email from Dave from The Kindness Revolution and I will certainly watch the video. Editor’s response: Your community spirit is why you were among the first wave of agents we contacted about becoming involved with The Kindness Revolution. Their founder, Ed Horrell, spoke at our national conference in June and we were sold on the concept. Also, I have a couple of questions and I was wondering if you had any advice for me. I sent in my resignation with an effective date of 10/31/2012. Allstate is sending me a notice about the annual compliance requirement for AFS. Since I am resigning, is this still something I need to complete? I hate to spend the money if I don’t have to. I also got a notice from Allstate about the FINRA Regulatory Continuing Education Program due by 12/5/2012. I will no longer be with Allstate after 10/31, so Continued on page 10. Continued from page 6. and many of them mention the agent. However, I’m not too sure that Allstate really wants customers who live on Ramen Noodle budgets. We live in the Land of Opportunity. If Allstate isn’t right for you, other insurance opportunities abound. Be wary of captive carriers because more and more of them are following Allstate’s example. Your best chance of becoming a true independent contractor is by becoming an independent agent, but even then you must be cautious. NAPAA, your agent association, is in a strong position with a solid balance sheet and has an excellent affiliation with the Office and Professional Employees International Union (OPEIU). This synergy will produce results and opportunities for our members going forward. Who knows, management could change its ways and finally appreciate the value of the agency force, perhaps even stopping unjust terminations, eliminating quotas and restoring the 10% compensation rate. But if they do that, then pigs will surely learn to fly. Whichever direction your career path leads, remember that NAPAA is there to support you. Whether you plan to stay with Allstate or move on to the independent world, NAPAA will have your back. In Solidarity, Readers: For more information about The Kindness Revolution, please turn to page 42 to read one agency’s positive experience with this unique marketing approach. Bob Isacsen President NAPAA/OPEIU Guild 17 Always a cell phone call away: 201-744-8395 It appears to me that many of the middle-aged and older agents, who came to work for Allstate after losing their jobs during the recession are having second thoughts about their new career path. Many of them received severance pack8 — Exclusivefocus Fall 2012 Fall 2012 Exclusivefocus — 9 Continued from page 8. would I still need to do this CE? Plus, I’m not sure if I will have another job that will require that license after I leave Allstate. Editor’s response: I think the article turned out well, too. Thanks for taking time to share your story with our readers. While we haven’t received any written correspondence about your article, we have received several calls about it, all of which were positive. If we receive some letters or e-mails, I’ll forward them to you. We also requested an electronic copy of the article, which I’ll forward to you upon receipt. We’re uncertain about your questions regarding your AFS situation. I was never 6/63 licensed, so I am not familiar with the requirements. As I recall, however, if you terminate your affiliation, you have two years to re-affiliate elsewhere. But to be safe, you may want to call our trusted AFS representative, whose name and contact information I’ll send to you separately. Jim, thank you for the time and advice you’ve given me over the years. I appreciate your input. I plan to travel in the next year to visit/join/see your operation. I have always held NAPAA in high esteem for its high morals and standards. You are a true champion of the working class agents, whose honesty built this company and made it profitable. I’ve been appointed by Aflac as an independent agent and I love it. They go out of their way to look after their agents AND their customers. They are an excellent fit for my agency and I pick up lots of referrals from them. When you see the awards they’ve earned for customer service and most ethical company, I cannot help but wonder what the hell those jack-asses at Allstate are thinking and why they can’t treat their agents and customers the same way. I really enjoy working with different companies and even though some representatives arrive at my office while I’m meeting other reps, they are always very 10 — Exclusivefocus courteous and professional to each other. Since I’m fairly new at this, there is still a long road ahead for me. But if the support I’ve received from the companies I’m appointed with is any indication of things to come, I am more confident than ever that we will achieve what we have set out to do. There is life after Allstate! I look forward to hearing from the folks from The Kindness Revolution. It sounds interesting and very positive. I will renew my membership. At first I was undecided because of the upcoming commission reduction, which is forcing us to reduce overhead. But after reading an agent’s letter in the recent issue of Exclusivefocus, I decided to renew. The letter was about the decrease in revenue during certain months in 2011 and 2012. I was also trying to uncover the cause of the decrease, but I didn’t have enough time to do a full-scale comparison of 2012 paid renewals vs. the 2011 renewals. What I found is that it is very difficult to compare prior years with the current year because Allstate pays us when they receive the customer’s payment, which could be early one year and late the next. It was just too difficult, so I gave up trying to figure it out. Besides, I was spending too much time investigating and not enough time running my agency. We need a better method to track what we are getting paid for. I was alarmed that one agent’s inquiry led to the conclusion that agents do not get paid for Allstate policy increases unless the agent did the increase endorsement. That is shocking and must be investigated. I appreciate all you do to help the agents, who are the backbone of Allstate. I am renewing. After more than 30 years as an Allstate agent, the company effectively confiscated my book and limited me to two buyers. One didn’t have any money, so I sold to the other one. Then three days after I signed the Purchase/Sale Agreement, I received a 90-day termination notice. It was signed by the local sales leader who knew the sale would take place on or before June 1, 2012. The letter was to let me know that as of July 1, 2012, I was history for failing to achieve my Expected Results. This tactic –delivering a termination notice after a sale has been arranged – is spiteful and underhanded. Is the purpose to give sadistic managers one last chance to gloat over someone’s misfortune? Or perhaps the Region gets kudos for the number of agent termination letters it sends out. Whatever the purpose, it is offensive and in poor taste. NAPAA has been, and continues to be, a beacon of information for the agency force. Allstate should be more forthright, not only with new agents, but tenured ones as well. Goals should not be a moving target, determined at the whim of corporate management. I absolutely agree the Board of Directors needs to hold not only Tom Wilson accountable, but all senior leadership. To me, their accountability should encompass (no pun intended) not only profits, but PIF. Tom Wilson has decimated long-term clients, those loyal customers from whom an agent could get credible referrals. I love the USAA commercial: “I got mine when.” Allstate could learn a lesson here. If you don’t get the kids when they come off the parents’ policy, you don’t have much of a chance after they reach 25 or 30, unless you are willing to spend an arm and a leg on advertising. But, that’s what Allstate expects. It’s their business model. I didn’t agree with it, so I left. Continued on page 58. For information on how to to submit a letter to the editor, see page 59 for information. Fall 2012 Fall 2012 Exclusivefocus — 11 feature To BRE or not to BRE: That is the Question By Lezlee Liljenberg R ecently, I had a little dilemma over the ongoing saga of the Branded Retail Environment (BRE) and the accompanying inspection program. Every time I walk into my satellite office and see those two chairs, side table and silver letters, I am reminded of IKEA. As far as I could see, the biggest difference was the vast increase in price that I paid for the Swedish décor through Allstate. If only IKEA had been an option. I really love to decorate, so my offices have always been in great taste; very professional and what many would call “homey.” For eight years, the comments regarding my offices have always been positive and people feel at home and comfortable when they visit. Then along came BRE, and I was forced to spend ridiculous amounts of money to actually make my offices look worse. I am sure there are many agents out there – probably too many to mention – that have a mess of an office and perhaps in those cases, something needed to be done. After all, the Allstate brand is our brand and shoddy offices look bad for all of us. So Allstate made a decision to make its offices consistent, in spite of the fact that for some of us, the upgrade is actually a downgrade. And adding insult to injury, it cost us over $3,000 per office to lower our standards. I think not! I could have outfitted, advised and decorated hundreds of agencies for a fraction of the cost that agents have been forced to pay. What I keep wondering is if someone is getting a kickback, a bonus, a commission – call it whatever you want – from this “contract with the Devil?” Someone, somewhere must be benefitting from selling our “décor souls” to the highest bidder. 12 — Exclusivefocus My curiosity began to run wild, so for grins, I went to IKEA and found a similar version of the BRE and priced it out. Then I paid a visit to a favorite, local sign guy and I priced the lettering, the beacon and the vinyl. Here is what I found: EKTORP TULLSTA ARMCHAIR $149.00 EACH LACK SIDE TABLE $34.99 Each Silver Lettering & Hands My sign guy said he could probably only do it for a little less than the prices being offered through Allstate. Vinyl & Beacons The sign guy told me the signs were pretty much in line with what he would charge. So, what it boils down to is this: • The BRE package as a whole is overpriced at $3,000. • This is especially true for the furniture being sold by the company furniture vendor. • The sign company is reasonable and is reducing their price due to volume. • It seems that someone is making a “hefty” profit with the BRE package that is being forced upon the agency force. How is it that one person, without the benefit of volume “buying power” can find respectable BRE look-alike furniture for $1,000 and a major corporation, with all its bargaining power, can’t negotiate a better BRE package for less than triple the cost? How? Because they are passing the expense on to the agent, so why worry about the cost? Price doesn’t matter when you decide you will force it upon an unwilling audience and then mandate that the changes be made or ELSE! Again, let me reiterate – I am in agreement with protecting the brand, but if the company is going to spend all of this money on inspections and whatnot, then allow some leeway for individuality. Offices that do not need “fixing” – leave alone. Those that do need “fixing,” call me and I will set them up with an affordable alternative. No kickbacks required! Ef Lezlee Liljenberg is an active Allstate agent in Arlington, Texas and is a proud member of NAPAA Board of Directors. Fall 2012 Break the Shackles... Get EXCITED About Insurance Again! Remember Why You Became an Insurance Agent! To Build and Run Your Own Independent Business With Freedom, Autonomy and Without Limits Yet With Support and Experienced Guidance At PREMIER GROUP INSURANCE More Than 100 PGI Partners Have it All! Fall 2012 • • • • • • StrongNationalandRegionalProperty&CasualtyCarriers DirectCarrierAccessbyYouforYourBusinessPlanandClientNeeds BusinessOwnershipwithLucrativeBonusandPerpetuationOptions IncreasedCloseRatiosANDHigherCommissionswithNoLifeQuotas BusinessToolsYouNeed-E&O,ComparativeRater,AMS,Web-SEOOptions UnparalleledSupportwithInnovativeProgramsDedicatedtoYourSuccess! If you’re feeling captive explore your options at www.ThinkPremierFirst.com or Contact Premier’s President, Rex Hickling, CPCU, AIM directly at: (303)818-6218 or via email at RexH@ThinkPremierFirst.com Exclusivefocus — 13 featured profile Gone, But Not Fading Away By Gerry Flores I never thought after being raised in Mason City, Iowa that I would ever sell insurance. In college, I studied biology and minored in chemistry as I was planning to pursue a career in medicine. On a beautiful fall day during my junior year, I was hitchhiking from Loras College in Dubuque, Iowa to Mason City, when a Lifetime Cookware manager pulled over and gave me a ride. Before I knew it, I would be selling pots and pans to single working girls. It was a great part-time job for a young guy sporting a fifties-style ducktail. Most guys would kill for a job selling pots and pans to single girls, but I never mixed business with pleasure – not that I wasn’t tempted from time to time. While most everyone else my age was flipping burgers to make a few bucks, I had a job that put serious money in my pocket. For a kid from Mason City, I thought my academic record as an undergrad was acceptable and better than average. But when graduation day rolled around, I learned that my 3.0 GPA wouldn’t get me into medical school. With my dreams dashed, I opted to go to graduate school where I got a full ride, including a salary for teaching. But I hated it and left after one year. I had several offers to sell pharmaceuticals, but there was a catch. My draft 14 — Exclusivefocus status was 1A. Hence, I was ripe to become a combat corpsman in the Army. Hello Vietnam! I remember the draft board telling me that my notice would be sent out the following Monday. That Friday, I enlisted in the USAF. It was a four-year stint that I don’t regret, but I wouldn’t care to do it again. Shortly after my discharge, I ran low on funds and went to visit my best buddy from my Air Force days. Sitting at the bar in the local VFW club in Wilmar, Minnesota, I was watching the bartender interact with the vets. I soon found out he was a part-time insurance agent who was trying to convert their military life insurance policies, which at the time were issued under the Serviceman’s Group Life Insurance (SGLI) program. My friend said, “Gerry, that would be a good opportunity for you.” Well, it made sense. I was a vet and I could BS with the best of them, so I thought I would give the insurance business a try. My cousin sold appliances at Sears and told me that the Allstate agent there made more money than the store manager. This got my attention. Next, I went to an LSO – a company sales office housing several tenured agents – and all five employee agents told me that Allstate was the place to be, so I applied for a job. I was promptly turned down because I was single. The District Sales Manager (DSM) appealed on my behalf and I became an Allstate agent effective 8-011971. In those days, new hires received a monthly stipend – called a “guarantee” – for 3 years. My guarantee was $800 per month. If I earned more in commissions in any given month, the company would pay commissions only. It was a good system because all I had to worry about was finding ways to exceed the guarantee. I worked at a booth in Sears with a skillful old Irishman for 20 years. He was my mentor. Management promised that if I survived, they would assign his accounts to me when he retired. I later understood how the American Indians felt about broken treaties. I never saw any of those accounts; they all went to a newbie and they let him sell them to another newbie in June 2000. For the next six years, I was a Neighborhood Office Agent (NOA). Then in June 2000, the company dropped a bomb on the agency force. Employee agents like me would all be fired and rehired as EAs. This would cost us dearly as we lost all company benefits in exchange for promises of independence, which turned out to be just another example of broken treaties. I had mixed feelings about becoming an EA, but with two children entering college, I thought it was prudent for me to put my faith in God and stay onboard. Thankfully, my wife found a job with medical insurance. By 2007, I knew it was time to see if there was life outside Allstate. I had been a NAPAA member for around 17 years. Up to that point, I don’t think I called NAPAA more than a few times. I just paid my dues and kept both eyes open. I started calling Jim Fish, who seemed to be a good guy and he gave me some good Fall 2012 ideas. At the time, I was pretty stressed out because I was going through a second bout with cancer, making it hard to stay focused and think clearly. While I listened intently to Jim’s ideas, my mind was cluttered with other thoughts, which distracted me. In the end, I acted on some of his ideas, but not all of them. So anyway, April Fools’ Day came along and after nearly 37 years, I was finished with Allstate. Being somewhat introspective about those 37 years, I often wonder how in God’s name I ever did it. NAPAA helped me with ideas to find a buyer, but the buyer had no insurance experience and he bailed out in September of that same year. Had I known the buyer was going to bail within six months, I would have been much more prudent. I had an attorney, but he was unfamiliar with some of the clauses in the Asset Purchase Agreement. If I had it to do all over, I would have made sure the attorney had some experience with buying and selling Allstate books of business – it would have saved me a ton of grief. To agents that are selling, don’t be penny wise and dollar foolish. General Douglas McArthur once gave a speech to Congress in which he said, “I still remember the refrain of one of the most popular barrack ballads of that day which proclaimed most proudly that “old soldiers never die; they just fade away.” So when I retired, Jim Fish called to ask if I was willing to help NAPAA grow. I said “yes.” I thought, “Aha, this old Allstate agent isn’t going to fade away, he’s going to work for Jim and Nancy Fish at NAPAA. Well, here it is 4½ years after departing the Good Hands Company and I am still preaching the gospel of NAPAA. One of the funniest things that happened to me while I was an agent – which wasn’t so funny at the time – was when my manager came to the booth to give me and my booth buddy our annual reviews. My partner wanted to go golfing after his review, so he went first. In those days, the reviews were done in the Sears breakroom. While he was giving my partner his review, I noticed that he had left a file folder behind with my name on it. I figured it was something I was supposed to look at before he met with me. But Fall 2012 when I opened the folder, my eyes almost popped out of their sockets! He had meticulously documented every instance – including dates and times – where I had uttered a bad word or had said anything contrary to the company’s thinking. I couldn’t believe it; it was like he was the Allstate KGB. So, when he came back, I told him I thought he had left the file for me to review. His face turned cherry red. In case you are wondering, he never gave me my review; he was probably much too disconcerted. I think he faked my signature and sent it in. Anyway, I never saw much of him after that, which was fine with me. Needless to say, I never trusted Allstate management after that incident. While working for NAPAA, I get a chance to speak to many agents. We talk about the good old days and the challenges facing today’s Allstate agents. One of the agents I signed up told me a story that occurred around 2000. The agent had just bought his father’s book of business when an agent friend of his dad’s passed away. The son and his dad went to the wake to pay their last respects. What the agent told me next took my breath away. He said the deceased agent’s allegiance to the company was well-known, and hanging above his coffin was one of those lighted Allstate signs that could be found in every Allstate booth in the country. I said, “You’ve got to be kidding,” but he insisted it was a true story. In the back of my mind, I asked, “Pray tell my Lord and Savior, how many agents would do that today?” During this last four years, I have helped numerous new NAPAA members increase their AFS production. My last year with Allstate was my best; I had $128,000 in AFS production. I have always been willing to share my AFS sales secrets with anyone who is willing to join NAPAA. I can show you six different ways to make money and keep Allstate happy. These are out-of-the-box methods you can use on your own book. Once you join, I’ll email these techniques to you and your EFS will love you for it. To learn more, give me a call at 563-564-1800. Ef Attention New Agency Owners who either Bought an Agency or were Assigned a Book of Business Are you frustrated with your FSL for not providing you with “Proven” methods to write more Life and Annuity Business from your Book of Business? Let me show you a proven plan to increase your sales when you join NAPAA. With my plan, you’ll keep your FSL off your back and make your EFS Happy – or you can do it yourself and put the $$$ in your pocket. For more information, please contact: Gerry Flores Napaa Benefits Representative 563-564-1800 Exclusivefocus — 15 feature Give the Devil His Due By Dave Thorpe I n my last article, we reviewed what ultimately happened to certain Allstate agents who left the company and went on to bigger and better things. In recent years, we’ve seen large numbers of agents leave the company and, of course, we wish them the best. I’ve heard various numbers and my understanding is that the agency force has been reduced by something like 30 percent. For those remaining agents, is this a good or bad thing? Personally, I think it’s a great thing and gives the remaining agents new opportunities. Everyone’s complaining about auto rates. If you write an auto policy it’s usually because the client dislikes his present carrier for service or claims, thinks Flo has gotten too plump and complacent, is 16 — Exclusivefocus disgusted with the shameless flag-waving of USAA and/or likes the less pompous Allstate mayhem commercials – but these folks are too few and far between. Back to the greatly reduced agency force: less agents on every street corner means more clients visiting your office to service their accounts. So while changing vehicles for a dispossessed client, what’s a good line? How about “My goodness Mr. Smith I see you have three kids and no life insurance; shame on the previous agent. He’s left the company and I see the reason why. Look, we just lost a client and paid off a $500,000 claim…” and so on. Oh, and don’t forget; the client doesn’t get an insurance card until he listens to your spiel. Of course you’re selling tons of life insurance to your own clients, right? If not, you need to stop whining about auto rates and start selling policies that are competitively priced, like those aforementioned life insurance policies. The great thing about life insurance is that few people shop for it. So even if your rate isn’t the lowest, they’ll probably never know. Do you have a mature book of business that you recently purchased? Or a mature book you haven’t yet worked thoroughly? Let’s say a longtime client dies. The first step is to go to the funeral. This is absolutely de rigueur. Then call the widow to arrange for name changes, auto usage changes, things that clients need to do when a spouse passes. This is what big time agents do. If the deceased had life policies with other companies or with Allstate, you need to explain to the widow that although the death benefits are usually non-taxable, she must invest in tax qualified plans to keep the tax man away. Also, since many clients are unprepared to handle a financial windfall, they should be cautioned against loaning or giving money to relatives. An annuity is a great excuse for the widow to turn down greedy opportunists. “I’m sorry cousin Hilaria, all my money is tied up in an annuity to help me in retirement and put my kids through college.” I have a close working relationship with a very top producer. He recently went to the funeral of a longtime client. In the post mortem meeting, he converted the existing term policy of the widow to a variable UL. As the deceased’s policy was in excess of $700,000, he’s now working on an appropriate tax qualified annuity. When all’s said and done, the total commissions will exceed $25,000. This agent isn’t doing a lot of whining about auto rates. One other point; both the top producer and I have large Fall 2012 UL policies and tax sheltered annuities with Allstate. These are also tremendous selling tools. There’s nothing like demonstrating to the client that you practice what you preach. Years back, I sold a $500,000 life policy to a supposedly legal immigrant from Culiacan, Mexico. Personally, I’ve never been overly cautious about checking citizenship or legal status; I’m an insurance agent not an ICE agent. Several months after the sale, his wife showed up with a Mexican death certificate. He had drowned in a reservoir outside of Culiacan. Naturally, I wanted a speedy death claim along with a death proceeds check for the widow so I could sell her a life policy and possibly an annuity. Of course, I was also concerned about the welfare of her and the kids. But the claim dragged on and on and the wid- ow cried unceasing tears. The claims people wanted recovery of the body. I tried to explain to the claims person that a lot of bodies aren’t recovered in Mexico and even if the body was recovered, it might be lacking its head. In addition, Mexican authorities never bother dragging a lake for one more body. God knows how many they’d pull up, not to mention the expense. Anyway, the wife kept bugging me and I kept bugging the claims people. I decided to get one more heart-wrenching statement from her in Spanish and fax it to claims. I drove to her house, but her street was blocked off, so I tried the alley. As I parked adjacent to her back yard, I noted a man barbecuing in the yard. I recognized him. It was the either the deceased or his identical twin. He took one look at me, and after turning as white as the ghost he appeared to be had he drowned, he ran back into the house and locked the door. I reported this attempted fraud to claims. And since he thought we might pursue criminal action, he self-deported. But this little anecdote shouldn’t deter anyone from doing business with immigrants. It was an interesting experience in my career and something you don’t run into with P&C. The moral of the story is that sometimes the company knows what it’s doing. Ef Exclusivefocus readers have been very good at posting me with their anecdotes and I want to hear more. Readers can contact me through my website at www.davethorpe.net. Allstate’s Future Course Is Anyone’s Guess by Brian Spillman H ere we go again. The company has decided to make a complicated “grid” to use as a stick to encourage sales performance. It starts out in 2013 with friendly numbers – you’ll only need to write four autos a month to stay on track. But that’s not the point, is it? No. The point is to introduce this new platform to the agency force. This way, the agents will be used to it by the time the company decides to jack up the numbers to unrealistic levels. Having recently sold my agency, I am thrilled that I don’t have to abide by this crazy grid. It’s hard enough for agencies to figure out what they will be paid from month-to-month using the new 12-month moving life application count. And this isn’t even taking into account the numerous technical errors the company will surely encounter while trying to pay thousands of agents different commission levels each month. Can you say “Nightmare?” The key here is that the company is Fall 2012 not going to let up on its all-too-familiar “produce or get the hell out” message. It is in stark contrast with the message that Mr. Winters gave at the National Forum in Vegas, where he declared, “There’s a place for every agent at Allstate.” Apparently, he forgot to add, “as long as you are producing new business.” There still seems to be no place for agencies, who for good business reasons of their own, don’t want to grow. Not too long ago, there were agencies which were a bit like the local corner bakery. They were a place where customers loved to stop and visit, where agency employees enjoyed their jobs and the agency took good care of its customers. Allstate still won in this scenario because these agencies had good retention and loss ratios. I’m not sure which books the company has read about small businesses, but there are some very good and compelling reasons for a small business to limit growth! It’s not that I don’t understand change – it happens. But I don’t understand change for bad business reasons. If you want to grow as a company, the solution is simple – just hire new agencies! Leave the high-retention agencies alone. This will help to grow the company faster. If, on the other hand, new agencies can’t make it, as the company claims, then there’s a problem with the product, the pricing, the method of distribution, and/ or the advertising. Currently, the company’s answer to what’s wrong with new agencies is that they don’t have enough capital to stay in business. But they still won’t if they are paying off huge loans from buying large existing agencies. They will be cashstrapped. I’m not sure if the company thought of that, or cares. But it’s a fact. It’s anybody’s guess what the endgame will look like at Allstate, but it will certainly be very interesting to watch from the sidelines. Sometimes spectators have a better time at the game than the players and coaches. I have season tickets at the 50-yard line and I’m thrilled! Exclusivefocus — 17 feature I’m So Proud of You A letter to a terminated agent Dear 25-year ex-Allstater, I am so proud of how you survived the horrific experience of selling your business. It never should have been such a brutal and abusive experience, but you had a buyer, who with his attorney, were determined to squeeze everything possible from you. In all likelihood, com18 — Exclusivefocus pany managers conspired with them, filling their heads with ideas about how to extract more and more from you, as if you hadn’t conceded enough already. I say this because there is just no way your buyer and his shyster lawyer could have come up with so many ridiculous demands unless they were privy to inside information. How is it, for example, that the buyer insisted that you should work for him for free for months after the sale? I am also curious how they found out you were on a warning letter, making you even more susceptible to their despicable lowball tactics, such as demanding your last month’s commission. They claimed that without it, the buyer would have insufficient “operating capital” – as if the lack of which was somehow your fault. Then they informed you that the sale would include all agency property and that all you would be permitted to take were your personal effects. They claimed that the Company told them, “This is the way it is done.” You thought you were all done with the sale and began to remember it as a horrible nightmare. You didn’t get the price you deserved and you had to make concession after concession because you were under the gun. But you said, “What’s done is done; time to move on.” You thought you could begin to chill out because you closed the deal, but then part two of your never-ending nightmare began. Incessant texts, calls and emails from the buyer starting at 7:00 a.m. and ending at 11:00 p.m. daily – for months – making demands and whining about this or that. Obviously, the evil twins still wanted more than the pound of flesh they already took from you. Good for you that you decided early on to ignore their calls and attempts to contact you with their outrageous ultimatums and unremitting exploitation of your good nature. After all, the buyer’s sleazeball attorney ignored you and your attorney for days at a time, forcing your attorney to do most of the legal work, leaving you to pay the lion’s share of the legal bills. Of course, when he did speak to your attorney, he was as charming and affable as he could be, but in reality, he was as hateful Fall 2012 and disrespectful as they come. And all the while, the stress was killing you, and your health – which wasn’t the best to begin with – took a turn for the worse. And none of the players, including Allstate management, cared. Their only concern was completing the deal, regardless of the costs. Now you are free and the worst is over. You can wish him well with his business and move on. And please do move on. Your creativity has been stifled for a very long time and it’s time to get back to doing the things you love, things that will help you live. Once the bitterness subsides, you will remember the things that made you laugh. You will once again breathe the fresh spring air and embrace the healing power of nature. You’ll be able to spend quality time with your family. Then maybe, just maybe, you’ll feel joy in your life once more. Most of all, you must focus only on getting your health back. You are dealing with a serious health situation now. And, no matter what the other side knew during the course of your sale, the pummeling continued. Fall 2012 It was relentless and I am proud that you somehow managed to get through it all. It was so unprofessional, so unnecessary to ever do business this way. You turned the other cheek many times throughout this terrible ordeal, but that is who you are. You are a giver, not a taker, and you were treated unfairly, not just by one person, but by several. Despite this, I know you still wish the buyer well. He has partnered with a company that mirrors his values and disrespects people just as he does. Maybe one day, he will come to regret the horrible things he was advised to do, and did. I am proud of how you survived, 25year agent; I don’t know how you did. You were used, abused and bullied by unscrupulous persons who cared only for themselves. But you can hold your head high because you never stooped to their level – you have always acted with dignity and in good faith. Thankfully, you had many friends and loving people in your life to support you during those trying times. They include your agent friends who, like you, suffered through difficulties at the hands of All- state, yet they were always there to prop you up before you fell. I’m sorry that your elderly parents, no matter how you tried to shelter them, saw the horrors of how the company – to which they paid higher than average premiums and to which they were extremely loyal – treated their child. Before I go, I want to wish you all the happiness and sunshine that you deserve. There is a lot of cruelty in this world and you have certainly experienced your share. And finally, thank you for sending me the following note: “Goodbye Allstate. You gave me a good life and a lot of opportunities before everything changed. God help the rest of the agents, especially those with long careers, who are unappreciated and at risk of having their careers ended unceremoniously like mine. I hope they have the fortitude to endure the many problems that lie ahead. God forbid they have to deal with the evil forces that I did.” Most sincerely, A friend, whose life was near ruin and then most probably saved... Exclusivefocus — 19 feature The Short-lived Career of a Promising New Agent Submitted Anonymously I was approached by Allstate during October of 2011 after a friend, with my permission, exchanged my name for the $5,000 bounty that Allstate pays for successful referral candidates who are approved and become Allstate agents. After successfully completing Allstate’s tests and meeting their financial requirements, I was offered a position as an independent contractor agent, subject to me obtaining the necessary licensing from the state. I attended the required classes and obtained the necessary licenses in December. Then in January, I started training at Allstate, which I assumed would teach me the fundamentals of operating an Allstate Insurance agency. After nine weeks of intensive training, I opened my agency on March 20 — Exclusivefocus 1, 2012, only to discover that I still did not know much about insurance. I find it odd that a company seeking to hire people from outside the insurance industry doesn’t do a better job of preparing its new agents for their first real-world insurance experience. Since one of Allstate’s requirements was for me to hire two LSPs, one of my first priorities was to find and hire suitable support staff. After conducting many interviews, I was fortunate enough to hire and appoint an experienced LSP, satisfying half of Allstate’s requirement. Needless to say, the company was not happy that I had opened my agency with only one LSP and there was daily pressure for me to have another appointed. But having been a business owner for more than 20 years before coming to Allstate, I knew just how important the correct staff would be to my success. Consequently, I was not prepared to settle for simply anyone – especially someone who did not meet my standards – just to satisfy Allstate’s rigid demands. I decided to continue looking for a viable candidate we could train in case I was unable to find another experienced producer. I wasn’t terribly concerned about it because I knew that many agencies my size could operate successfully with only one LSP. Then after two months of searching, I finally found someone with the skill set I wanted. I hired her and we paid for licensing classes. I am happy to report that my instincts were correct; she was well worth the wait. And at least for the time being, the Allstate management monkey was off my back. Our first month was a disaster. It was like we were chasing our tails as we tried to write new business, learn Allstate’s systems and procedures, and get through training from the FSL and APS. Changes in management didn’t help either. In the five months between the time I started talking with Allstate and the date we first opened the doors to our agency, Allstate had changed FSLs three times and by June, we were on our 5th APS. This turnover in management began to make me wonder what I had gotten myself into. We were also promised the services of an EFS and it was strongly recommended that we refer all our life business to them. That promise went unfulfilled and we never got an EFS – but that did not let us off the hook to meet the life requirements. In fact, the pressure only increased. In April and May we stepped up our direct mailing campaign. Having 20 years Fall 2012 experience in that field, I knew how to get results with direct mail and it worked. We had two very good months, qualifying us for our tier 2 bonuses. In spite of our success with direct mail, Allstate insisted that I continue to buy internet leads even though I had found them to be a waste of time and money. It’s not as if I hadn’t made genuine efforts to get them to work, but after trying five different internet lead companies for three months with unsatisfactory results, I decided it was time to stop spinning my wheels and put my money into other marketing strategies. Of course, the company wasn’t keen on my decision to abandon internet leads. Their adamant belief in internet leads led me to wonder just how much marketing savvy they really had. Don’t get me wrong; I believe they were only trying to help me grow my book, but I wasn’t about to throw my marketing dollars away to make them happy. Maybe internet leads still work well for some agents, but to me they are a thing of the past, at least in my experience. During the period leading up to the launch of the new House and Home product this past June, I discovered we had prepared 500 quotes from which we wrote nearly 90 policies. I was frustrated because we were fairly competitive on auto, but not so much on homeowners. Every time we failed to close a sale and the customer walked away empty-handed, I was disappointed. Of course I knew we couldn’t win them all, but an 18% closing ratio was unsatisfactory to me. Then I went to one of the many seminars/product launches/ town hall meetings that I was expected to attend and I was shocked to learn that Allstate’s closing rate nationwide was 12% and nobody seemed surprised. I thought, “What’s wrong with this picture? They are proclaiming that an 88% failure rate is acceptable.” It was also at one of these meetings that we were informed about the new House and Home policy. I was told that it would be a “game-changer” and that Allstate would be much more competitive than before. Bearing this in mind, I soldiered on, anticipating great things to come and when the launch day arrived, I quickly re-quoted some of the homeowner policies I had priced-out under the old policy a few days earlier in order Fall 2012 to compare the savings. Imagine my surprise, shock and disappointment when I discovered that at the very best, the premium increased by $400 while another went up $800! Game-changer my a**. Once again, I listened and believed to what they said and, once again, I was disappointed… this would be a deal-killer. I enjoy the insurance industry. I have forged many lasting relationships over the years and my commitment to customer service – as well as my reputation as a straight shooter – would suffer irreparable damage if I put Allstate’s goals ahead of my customers’ needs. So I started doing some research into becoming an independent broker where I could select from an array of insurance carriers to meet my customers’ needs instead of having to look into every nook and cranny to find someone who might qualify for Allstate. Becoming an independent agent is not an easy task, but I would do it all over again if needed. I informed Allstate about my intention to go independent and then the fun began. My FSL had no idea what to do next and even though the situation became very awkward from there on out, Allstate insisted that I serve out my 90 days as per our contract. It was a given that I would not breach the non-compete and I accepted that as par for the course. To this day, I have not been contacted by management to inquire about my “surprising and sudden departure.” But after two weeks or so, I was informed by email that my 90-day notice period would be extended by 30 days for reasons that made little sense to me. It was then I contacted Jim Fish from NAPAA to seek advice. Jim responded to my plea for help very quickly and then I received a follow-up call from Nancy Fish. After speaking to them, the dark clouds gathering on the horizon were whisked away by a gust of refreshing wind. I followed Jim and Nancy’s advice about the options available to me and Allstate released me immediately. I have since heard nothing more from Allstate, except for the FedEx shipping label I received to send my customer files to them. At this point, I am waiting to receive the infamous “cease and desist” letter that seems to be standard operating procedure for them, regardless of whether one is in breach of the non-compete or not. But when that day arrives, I will be prepared to handle that as well. I have joined the local Independent Insurance Agent Association, which has helped me set up E&O insurance, bonds, and many other things that had never crossed my mind. I joined an independent agent cluster, enabling us to become appointed with top carriers that may not have otherwise given us a second look. We also have direct appointments with some carriers. I have been impressed with the independent agency system and how customers react. I was surprised to see how much more receptive potential customers were when I was able to present them with choices. I am under no illusion that it will be any easier being an independent agent. However, not having the constraints of being a captive agent has its rewards and we are already seeing the benefits. Certainly every carrier has its own set of rules and requirements, but I am able to live with that. I am looking forward to building my agency around my customers. Yes, my time at Allstate was brief, but I could see the handwriting on the wall. With Allstate, I was never going to be an “independent contractor” in the truest sense of the meaning. Sure, I could have kept plodding along, accepting lower commissions and hoping for the best, but I chose to move on before I became so entrenched that it would be impossible to leave. I also did not want to look back a few years from now and regret that I missed the opportunity to make the change. For me, the time to act was today, not five or ten years from now. I would like to stop to make a point here. It is common practice for independent agents to join one of the independent agent associations available to them. These associations wield a lot of power because of their strong membership base. I think it fair to say that if NAPAA enjoyed the same level of support as the independent agent associations, many of the setbacks Allstate agents have suffered over the past decade may have been averted. NAPAA helped me in my time of need and someday, you may require their help too. I urge you to join now. Thank you Jim and Nancy for all your help and words of encouragement. Ef Exclusivefocus — 21 feature Great Expectations New Agents; is Allstate Everything it was Cracked Up to Be? A career as a professional insurance agent can be extremely rewarding, both in the sense of personal accomplishment and monetary results. Like any start-up business, the early years can be grueling, but once established, the rewards can be great. As a licensed insurance agent, you will have a great responsibility. Thousands of consumers will place their security in your hands. Using your knowledge and expertise, you will recommend and tailor the insurance products in your “portfolio” to fit each individual’s or family’s needs, taking into account their budget constraints. And because of the trust 22 — Exclusivefocus placed in you, your conduct must meet the highest ethical and moral standards. As you have likely already learned, being an Allstate EA is much different than that of other insurance agents, especially on the independent agent side of the business. Here, we discuss more specifically what being an Allstate Exclusive Agent is all about. Now, let’s get specific about the realities of being an Allstate Exclusive Agent... First, you are a “captive agent,” meaning you can only sell policies through carriers that are approved by Allstate. You are described by Allstate as an “independent contractor,” a label that many, if not most, Allstate agents dispute. Since independent contractors are not employees, you do not receive any benefits, such as: health insurance, disability, Workers Comp, etc., and you do not have any federal or state protections applicable to employees, including any type of workplace discrimination. Your R3001 contract allows the Company to terminate its relationship with you for any reason – or no reason – with a 90-day notice (120 days in California). Since you are a “captive” agent, you can only sell Allstate products, state-mandated products ( JUA, Assigned Risk, Fair Plan, etc.) and those products the Company allows you to broker. Part of being a captive independent contractor Allstate EA means that certain privileges that are usually enjoyed by other independent contractor insurance agents do not apply to you. Here are some of them: • Your office location must be approved by the Company. If you wish to move, you must obtain permission from the Company. • Your office hours and days of operation are set by the Company. Your office must be open 44 hours per week. • Your licensed staff is subject to scrutiny and approval by the Company. The Company may require additionally that your staff be trained by the Company at your expense. • Your phone numbers are, in effect, owned by the Company. You are required to allow the Allstate Call Center to answer your telephone after normal business hours. In fact, the company controls your telephone nearly 75% of the time; you control it for 44 hours per week and the Company controls it 124 hours per week. • You have mandatory production Continued on page 24. Fall 2012 A Smart Choice ® for EVERYONE Join a network of over 3,000 successful independent agents. Fall 2012 www.smartchoiceagents.com | 888.264.3388 Exclusivefocus — 23 quotas that you must achieve or your contract will be terminated. These quotas will likely continue for the life of your relationship with the Company. • You will be required to obtain securities licenses within 24 months of your contract date. You will also have separate financial services quotas to achieve each year in order to maintain your affiliation with AFS and your agency contract. If you fail to obtain the required securities licenses within the first 24 months of your contract date, you will be terminated. • Your commission and/or bonus may be changed at any time with a short notice. As you know, base commissions are being reduced to 9% beginning in January, 2013. • Certain other objectives, such as, loss ratio, renewal ratio, growth and book penetration must be achieved. • You have a unilateral contract, meaning you have no input on contract changes. • Policy premiums and underwriting rules may be changed at any time. Even total moratoriums on new business may be imposed. Mass non-renewal of policies can be ordered by the Company. Mandatory Reading If you didn’t perform your due diligence before you agreed to become an Allstate EA, it would be prudent for you to do so now, before it is too late to change your mind. It is essential that you read the following material that controls your business relationship with Allstate: The R3001S (Sole Proprietor) or R3001C (Corporation) contract. And because the following documents – which can be amended at any time by Allstate – are expressly incorporated as part of those contracts and contain the “how, what and where” details that further control your “independent contractor” relationship, you must also read: The Supplement (the 57th revision was published June, 2012) (292 pages) The Exclusive Agency Independent Contractor Manual (25th revision published July, 2011) (59 pages) Allstate Agency Standards (15th revision, July, 2011) (58 pages) 24 — Exclusivefocus In addition, although not expressly incorporated into the contract, the Exclusive Agency Reference Guide is a must read as well (150 pages). This may seem like a lot of reading, but it is imperative that you understand that these manuals dictate your entire relationship with Allstate. As previously mentioned, your contract is unilateral; Allstate can and does revise these “3 ring binder” documents at will, with no input or approval from the agent. Any changes become part of your contract going forward. “ Your contract is unilateral; Allstate can and does revise these “3 ring binder” documents at will, with no input or approval from the agent. “ Continued from page 22. Most new hires are unaware of the existence of these documents before signing the contract. The documents are rarely handed out by Allstate recruiters, unless requested. Such requests, however, may only be granted reluctantly – or not at all – making it all but impossible for prospective agents to perform proper due diligence. These documents are available in electronic format, and there is no reason that potential EAs should not be able to examine them prior to executing the tenpage R3001 Agreement that incorporates them to the entirety of the agreement. Questions you probably should have asked before becoming an Allstate EA • Is the Company in a “growth mode” in your area? • Has the Company restricted writing of any particular lines of insurance or coverages, such as earthquake, wind, or property (homeowners) coverage? If so, what brokering opportunities are currently in place for you to assist clients with a complete insurance package? • How competitive are Allstate’s rates? Are they higher, lower or about the same as the main competition? Auto and property insurance products generate 95% or more the income in an established agency so it is imperative that the Company’s rates be competitive with other carriers. • What is the average number of auto and property policies written by the agents in your area? • Can you furnish me with a cash flow analysis that calculates the revenues generated by these averages? • What special requirements are there for obtaining and maintaining securities licenses? • What securities production quotas are specifically required to maintain my affiliation with AFS? • What is the consequence of failure to maintain the AFS affiliation? • How often and what have been the changes in the amount of the AFS production quotas? • What are the current quotas for the R3001 agent agreement? What happens if I fail to achieve them? • Can you provide me with a threeyear history of quotas? Note: they are usually increased annually and are subject to change at any time with little notice. How many Allstate agents are in my market and will the Company add more agents in the same area? • What are the requirements for buying/selling a book of business? • Will I be able to buy a book of business to grow my agency in the future, and if so, can you provide me an assurance in writing? • What are the demographics of my market and how does that information relate to my potential for success at this location? Major Points Termination of the Contract The contract may be terminated by either party (you or the company) at any time – for no reason or for any reason – Fall 2012 with a 90-day notice. In California, the company must provide a 120-day notice. The company regularly terminates agent contracts for failure to achieve quotas – also known as Expected Results or Business Objectives – for two or more consecutive years. In many cases, if not most, extenuating circumstances, including illnesses or other family crises, are not excused, resulting in the agent’s termination. Supplement, Manual and Agency Standards These may be revised at any time with little or no notice. They are expressly incorporated into the Agreement, and the changes made by the company become part of your contract. Commissions and Bonuses Compensation may be changed with a 90-day notice. Quotas (a.k.a. Expected Results or Business Objectives) Quotas and other requirements, such as, retention, loss ratio, growth, book penetration, etc. are imposed, and are regularly increased from year to year. Termination Payment Provision (TPP) TPP is a payment to an agent who leaves the company and does not sell his/ her book of business to another party. Presently, the payment is 1.5 times the previous twelve months’ commissions. It is currently paid out in 12 monthly payments, but for most agents, it will change to a 24-month payout beginning in January, 2013. Note that all policies written under one of the previous employee agent agreements are excluded from the calculation. Therefore, if you purchase an agency that was once owned by an employee, you may be purchasing policies that will not be eligible for TPP. R3001 contracts signed prior to November, 1999, guarantee TPP to the agent. The present contracts, the R3001S or R3001C, do not mention a termination payment. It is included in the Supplement. This means the company can reduce or eliminate TPP at any time. Fall 2012 Sale or Purchase of a Book of Business (BOB) One of the most attractive provisions of the contract is the ability to transfer interest in the agreement, which includes the ability to buy additional agencies, or to sell your agency. Eventually, every agent will want to realize the value of their business by selling it. This may be for retirement or to utilize the capital to establish another business. Agency valuations can fluctuate greatly. They can be affected by a number of variables, but oftentimes it is Company actions that lessen the value of agent’s books of business. These might include massive non-renewals of auto or property policies, or heightened restrictions for approving buyers. The Company has complete control over who purchases a BOB and reserves the right, in its exclusive judgment, to approve or disapprove any transfer. The requirements for buyer approvals have changed many times over the years, and although guidelines to qualify are published in the EA Manual, these are only guidelines; approval will occur at the sole discretion of regional management. As of this writing, few, if any, Allstate agents are being allowed to purchase a book of business and virtually no one can acquire a book and “merge” it into their existing BOB. At times agents Expand Your Agency • • • • or are allowed to have two agencies in the same location. But this means they have two separate contracts and two sets of Expected Results, requiring them to reach these quotas for both agencies every year. Many agents, wishing to sell their BOB, have not been able to find approved buyers and have had to take TPP. TPP is usually much less than the true market value of an agent’s BOB. Also, it is currently spread out over 12 months, making it difficult to capitalize a new business with the proceeds. Of course, when the payout period changes to 24 months in January 2013, it will become even more difficult. If an “outside” buyer is approved, he must then complete Company prescribed training before the sale transaction is complete. This process can take several months, a process which also hinders the BOB sale. Ef DISCLAIMER: This article is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice from NAPAA or its attorneys, and NAPAA expressly disclaims any such advice. Certain information contained in the article may not be pertinent to your circumstances, and is not intended to replace an independent evaluation with your attorney. Refinance at a Lower Rate Lending up to 80% of TPP at competitive rates Experience helping Allstate agents grow their businesses Community bank service with national reach and resources Strong and stable national institution Call us at 1-888-547-8877 or email TPPLoans@amgnational.com Member FDIC Equal Housing Lender AMG National Trust Bank www.amgnational.com Exclusivefocus — 25 sales and marketing How to Turn Every Call Into a Sales Call…Guaranteed! By Bill Gough Read the next sentence and be really honest. How many times a day do you notice yourself or your support staff speak to customers without mentioning anything about the missing lines of insurance in the household – especially life insurance? The answer to this question for many agencies is probably between 90-98%. For agencies with good processes in place, the ratio hovers between 50-70%. Even the very best agencies miss up to 50% of their customer contact opportunities. When you think about it, none of these percentages are as good as they should be. Successful agency owners are always looking for ways to improve their closing ratios and increase their household penetration, but finding and refining new processes is challenging. Therefore, sometimes it pays to use proven processes developed by others. Enter my good friend Bill Eggar, one of the premier Allstate agency owners in the country. Bill consistently writes $300,000+ in life and financial sales every year, and he does it by himself. He doesn’t have an Exclusive Financial Specialist (EFS) because he doesn’t need one. In addition, his agency writes 2,000 cars per year and has written about 1,000 Emerging Business (EB) policies over the past several years. Bill started his agency from scratch in 2002 in the midst of the Texas mold debacle. Fearful of mold claims, the insurance industry spurned new homeowner business, leaving him with an incomplete product portfolio. It wasn’t like today, where Allstate agents can broker through non-Allstate carriers approved by the company. Faced with the choice of his agency 26 — Exclusivefocus dying or surviving, Bill studied the very best agents and began to write life insurance to stay afloat. One trait he possessed that others in his position didn’t have, was a winning attitude and an iron-clad will to succeed. He not only survived, he thrived because of his attitude, work ethic and by networking with other top agents – all of which motivated him to be the best he could be. In 2005, Bill focused on how his support staff interacted with customers. In particular, he paid close attention to what his staff said to customers on phone calls and in-person office visits. He started keeping meticulous records of how long a typical service call would take and exactly what his staff was saying during those conversations. He would stand undetected in the hallway outside their offices so he could listen in without them knowing he was there. This gave him a true picture of what was being said, yet it spared his staff the increased anxiety that his presence in the room may have caused. What he discovered was that his staff was taking too much time processing routine endorsements and answering billing questions. Plus, they were just doing an average job of seeking and asking for new sales opportunities. As a result, Bill began tweaking his customer service process workflows and developed an easy-to-use fact-finder for his staff to uncover more sales opportunities without being seen as a pushy salesperson. In time, Bill refined his Green Sheet Process into a simple three-step system that delivers great customer service based on promises kept to his customers. At the same time, the process uncovers other insurance sales opportunities in the household, including all-important life insurance and retirement needs. Certainly, Bill Eggar is one of a kind. He was able to spot shortcomings in the way his staff conducted business with his clients and he developed a system to overcome them. Developing your own processes or borrowing great processes from others is how good agents become great agents. Obviously, it takes time, energy and stick-to-itiveness to accomplish this yourself, so if the must-have system you need is commercially available, you should consider buying it to spare yourself the hundreds of hours of research and development it will take to perfect a system of your own. I cannot stress to you the critical importance of creating processes that will continue to work in your agency, producing consistent results, month after month. We’re taught to work Right, then Smart, then Hard. Success comes from working smarter, not harder. Work smarter today by putting the right systems and processes in place. I don’t care how seasoned and how good you are at selling life insurance or cross-selling your book of business, EVERY agency owner can and should be using a similar process. It is critically important to implement a process in your agency that can get consistent, predictable results month after month, year after year. Ef Bill Gough is President of BGI Marketing Systems. BGI is a company dedicated to helping Allstate agents take their agencies to the next level of growth while maximizing profits. For more information about Bill Eggar’s Green Sheet Process, go to www. GreenSheetSuccess.com. Fall 2012 GO TO THE WEBSITE NOW FIND OUT HOW THIS SIMPLE PROCESS WILL CHANGE YOUR AFS WORRIES FOREVER!!! Fall 2012 Exclusivefocus — 27 feature Your Flood Book: Sell it, Keep it, or Transfer it… It’s Your Choice and buying agents and does not need to be disclosed to Allstate management. The book, in fact, can be split and sold to two different agents simply by providing a list of the policy numbers included in the partial transfer with the transfer request. The transfer request form can be found on the “Flood Connect Portal” website. Just click on the “Agents” tab and look for the form in the “Agency Information/Forms” section. Once the transfer is processed, the buying agent will have access to all of the policies the next day. The buying agent will receive commissions as the policies renew following the effective date of the transfer. W ith the distraction caused by the double whammy of reduced commissions and less than favorable Termination Payment terms, more and more agents are deciding to head for greener pastures. Many agents are not aware that they can retain an ownership interest in their flood book of business after leaving Allstate. Fortunately, there are several options available for them to retain or sell their flood book. When selling an agency, the most obvious choice is to sell the flood policies to the buyer of the Allstate agency. This process is simple, and only requires a “Book of Business Transfer Form” be 28 — Exclusivefocus sent to the Flood Service Center with the buying agent’s information. But for agents who have not been able to obtain approval for a buyer and are walking away with their TPP, there are some other options available. The flood book can be sold in part or in its entirety to another Allstate agent, even if he/she is not an approved buyer for the rest of the agency. Transfer of the flood book is processed by the Flood Service Center by submitting a Book of Business Transfer Form. The form must be signed by the selling agent, but does not require an approval from anyone else. The sale of the book, including the terms of the sale, is between the selling “A terminated R3001 Agent will be paid for Allstate Flood Insurance business in process at the time of termination of the agent’s R3001 Agreement. Unless sold, the agent maintains a commission interest in agency bound Flood policies produced until the first policy renewal after the agent’s termination date. Accordingly, all subsequent endorsement and cancellation transactions occurring after the termination date, but before the next policy renewal, will also be recorded in the terminated agent’s account.” - Source: R3001 Supplement Fall 2012 Rolling Flood Policies to a new Carrier Agents departing Allstate with plans to open an independent agency are able to retain the flood policy renewals by “rolling” their book to a new flood carrier. Agents should check with their new flood carrier to determine the process for the rollover of the book. Generally, you will need to provide the new carrier with your complete flood book of business – including copies of dec pages, Elevation Certificates and so forth – as soon as possible, and prior to your last day with Allstate. Most major flood carriers have an internal “Rollover” department that will assist agents with the rollover process. Important: The effective date of each new policy must be the expiration date of the Allstate flood policy. Allstate Flood will be sending a letter to each of your flood customers, asking them to select a new Allstate agent to service their policy. This letter may include inaccurate information, such as informing the customer that you are no longer available to service their policy. Your customers will receive two renewal notices; one from Allstate and one from the new carrier. Your new flood carrier will send a notification to the client as well as their mortgage company (if escrowed) 90 days prior to the renewal. This time frame is important as it allows the new flood carrier’s premium notice to get to the lender and the client before the Allstate renewal bill. It is imperative that you inform your customers that you are available and able to service their current policy, and that the renewal will be written by the new carrier. Make sure your letter includes a statement about flood coverage and rates being the same for all companies. Customers will be confused by the Allstate communication, so you may want to remind them more than once. After your termination date, you will be inactive in the Allstate system. All endorsements for a policy that has not reached its expiration date must be submitted via fax or mail. You will no longer have a login or be able to access policy information at AllstateFlood.com. In addition, Allstate will not provide declarations or any other policy documents directly to you; they will require the customer to make the request. Ef Remember, it is crucial that you retrieve all pertinent policy information prior to your termination date. Pre-termination Checklist to Prepare for the Rollover of your Flood Book: • Run the Policies in Force Report from Flood Connect • Log on to www.AllstateFlood.com • Click Agency Profile button • Click the blue Reports tab • Select Policies in Force • Sort by Expiration Date (on the right) • Leave the Filter by area alone • Click view for a PDF, or dowload for an Excel version • Declaration pages – Print or save to a file on your computer. • Request Elevation Certificates and any other pertinent policy documents that you do not have on file from the Flood Service Center prior to your last day with Allstate. • Contact Flood Service Center to notify them that you will be rolling the book to a new carrier and to request instructions and paper endorsement forms. • Select a new carrier for your flood book and request instructions for their rollover process. The Harford Flood Insurance PARTNER WITH THE HARTFORD, A Leader in Flood Insurance. The Hartford is one of the largest providers of flood insurance, offering a full-service solution, competitive commissions and a dedicated local Sales Director. Email us at flood@thehartford.com or call 866-553-5663. With The Hartford behind you, achieve what’s ahead of you.® Policies are written subject to the National Flood Insurance Program. Insurance is provided by the property and casualty insurance companies of The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc., Hartford, CT. Fall 2012 CLIENT AD# / / The Hartford P00333-X1 © 2012 The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc., Hartford, CT 06155. All Rights Reserved. Exclusivefocus — 29 (HFG CO) PROD MGR TRAFFIC / / Cheryl Sparks Stephanie Browne PUB / Prepared by buying and selling The Five Critical Cs of Acquisitions By Rick Dennen and expose new issues that must be addressed. These problems can often drain resources – both human and financial – that were perfectly fine before. Sometimes an acquisition can even put your existing business at great risk. Here are the five Cs to remember when considering an insurance agency acquisition. An acquisition, no matter how we might view it, is a merger. Keep these factors in mind to avoid hidden issues that can lead to buyer’s remorse. Culture Q uick romances don’t usually make happy, lasting marriages. It’s easy to be in love when a relationship functions on the surface. But the romance quickly fades as the daily grind exposes each person’s true character. That’s why divorce rates are extremely high for hasty unions. The statistics regarding mergers and acquisitions are similar, as many fail to meet buyer expectations. How could that be? I believe both sides forget about the “merge” and focus on the “acquire” part. They romanticize the entire deal, setting their sights on the financial results because that’s usually the motivation for buyers and sellers. A key lesson I’ve learned after funding and servicing hundreds of agency acquisitions is how critical it is for agency 30 — Exclusivefocus Culture clashes can hurt both employee and customer relations. If one agency has a quiet doctor’s office-type culture and the other is akin to a bustling café, there’s going to be friction. Disparities in management styles, office environments, compensation philosophies, personalities and other differences can be enough to cause employee conflicts and deteriorate morale. Both can negatively affect how customers perceive the agency and how they are treated. owners to acquire the right company with the right people. Even when agency owners start the acquisition process with an open mind, patience and the willingness to involve experienced brokers, accountants, attorneys and other professionals, they can drift towards transactions that aren’t ideal because they overlook or rationalize away crucial details. On paper, the financials and commission projections show great promise. On the surface, the selling agency’s principals are decent, solid business professionals with prudent management philosophies. The real story may be slightly or extremely far from appearances. While the hidden details, once they surface, may not be enough to render the deal worthless, they may result in lower profit Contracts Depending upon agreements made during negotiations, you may have to take on carrier, employee, lease agreement and other contracts that were secured by the selling agency. Hidden loopholes or overlooked details can result in extra demands or expenses that your agency is unprepared and ill-equipped to handle. They can change the dynamics of your agency and render healthy aspects unhealthy and vulnerable. Carriers Selling agents are often motivated by rumored or confirmed carrier changes that are anticipated in the near or distant future. Let’s face it, through tightly-knit networks and contacts, people learn big Fall 2012 news about carriers or discern changes long before official company announcements are made. Agency sellers may be fairly certain of new requirements that will be enforced, system or policy changes planned, significant product modifications or other major shifts that may negatively impact the agency’s ability to grow and maintain its existing customer base. Customers The value of an acquisition rests squarely on the ability to continue the selling agency’s commission stream; the ability to retain its customers. Some customers have little, if any, contact with their agents and, therefore, they have little loyalty to them. Others are so connected with their agents they would never consider switching. In either scenario, there’s a real risk of losing customers after an acquisition. There must be a strong knowledge of the selling agency’s customers and what their disposition is likely to be once the agency is dissolved or merged into another. Join “ALL Agents Page” on Facebook All New Group for Allstate Agents and Former Allstate Agents Only See page 35 for how to join! Competition Just as agents can be motivated to sell based on real or predicted carrier changes, they also can be prompted to enter the market because of impending competition. It’s critical to know what competing carriers are planning for your market. Is there a national or regional strategy to expand through new start-up agencies? Are they infusing more capital into existing agencies or into advertising to increase business? And what about competing agencies? What information do you have about their future moves? Agencies can be shocked and derailed by competitive forces if they are unaware of plans that may have been in the works long before an acquisition. Ef Rick Dennen is president and CEO of Oak Street Funding, which provides commissionbased lending for insurance agents that need capital to buy, build or sell their agency. Dennen is a licensed agent for Life, Accident & Health products and a licensed Certified Public Accountant in the State of Indiana. He can be reached at rick. dennen@oakstreetfunding.com. Fall 2012 WRIGHT BEAMER, Attorneys SERVING NAPAA AND THE AGENTS OF ALLSTATE SINCE 2000 DIRK A. BEAMER, ATTORNEY EXPERT CONSULTING FOR AGENTS AND THEIR ATTORNEYS ON: ALLSTATE CORPORATE SECURITY INVESTIGATIONS BUYING & SELLING BOOKS ALLSTATE EA AGREEMENTS PH: 248.477.6300 WRIGHTBEAMER.COM DBEAMER@WRIGHTBEAMER.COM Exclusivefocus — 31 Ready to acquire or sell? Know why acquisitions fail to meet the expectations of most buyers and sellers. The majority of acquisitions fail to achieve the desired increase in value, economies of scale, spike in profitability, Resources to Sell, Grow or Acquire 1 Sell your agency: oakstreeetfunding.com/Sell 2 Position your agency to grow and sell: oakstreeetfunding.com/Grow 3 Take your agency to the next level with acquisitions: oakstreeetfunding.com/Acquire and other expectations. Agency owners are predicted to acquire and sell agencies at record levels in 2012. What do you need to know to select the right agency or accept the right offer and how should you prepare for the acquisition process? To help you reach a successful acquisition outcome, whether you are purchasing or selling, read Oak Street Funding’s complimentary white paper on insurance agency acquisitions. And when you need funds to invest in growth or help aligning your agency sale with the right buyer, we can help. Now more than ever, agencies must find a lender that understands their needs and market conditions. Oak Street Funding knows the insurance agency business and its unique Contact us today at 1-877-879-6771 intangible assets. * The materials in these papers are for informational purposes only. They are not offered as and do not constitute an offer for a loan, professional or legal advice or legal opinion and should not be used as a substitute for obtaining professional or legal advice. The use of these materials, including sending an email, voice mail or any other communication to Oak Street, does not create a relationship of any kind between you and Oak Street. TAKING YOU WHERE BANKS WON’T. Rates as low as 7.5% Fixed * for a limited time Competition is tough. Your agency needs an advantage. With a lowrate loan from Oak Street Funding, we’ll help you pull ahead of the competition. What could you do with the money you’re saving on your loan? You decide. It’s your money. • ACQUIRE AN AGENCY • HIRE A PRODUCER • INVEST IN YOUR BUSINESS W O N T AC ans le lo Eligib close by must 1, 2012 3 Dec. Oak Street Funding can help you grow your business or acquire an agency with minimal out-ofpocket cost by leveraging the power of its commission stream. Whether you need $10,000 or $10,000,000, we’ll customize a loan for your needs. When banks won’t help, Oak Street Funding will. Call us now to take advantage of our loan sale or visit us online for a free quote at oakstreetfunding.com/quote. 1-877-879-6771 | oakstreetfunding.com/Quote * Must qualify for Oak Street Funding underwriting criteria. Certain restrictions apply. Loan amounts available from $10,000-$10,000,000. Available terms up to 10 years. A minimum new money advance of $125,000 is required for refinance of existing Oak Street loans. Loan must close and fund by December 31, 2012. Potential borrowers are responsible for completing their own due diligence on acquisitions. California residents: Loans made pursuant to a Department of Corporations California Finance Lenders License. sales and marketing Networking To Grow Your Agency By Robyn Sharp huge boost in new customers after attending a group like BNI on a regular basis. It does require a time commitment, but you should be able to directly calculate how much return you see after a few months of membership. The key is consistency! See if there is a group available in your area or consider starting your own chapter. Other Networking Groups N etworking is an important part of building your agency and getting more clients. When people know who you are, they will likely choose you over other agents in your area when they need a quote. Many agents aren’t sure where to go or even what kind of networking will benefit them the most and if you try to do too much all at once, it can be a timeconsuming and expensive process. If you want to get your name out there, here is a list of six great places to get started. It is important to remember that as an agency owner, you shouldn’t spread yourself too thin, because your time is limited. If you’d like to pursue multiple networking opportunities, you might want to assign key staff personnel to represent your agency in groups where you want a presence, but don’t have enough time to do it yourself. 34 — Exclusivefocus Weekly Breakfast Networking Group These groups are a great place to begin if you’re looking for referrals. They meet early in the morning to make it more convenient for business owners to attend. The most well-known networking association is Business Network International (BNI) (www.bni.com). There is an annual fee to belong to a group but you can visit at least once for free. Members are required to attend these weekly meetings, get to know one another’s businesses, and share referrals. One benefit is that no two people can be in the same industry, so there won’t be another insurance agent. You benefit by meeting, not just from the people directly in the group, but from the Rolodex of all the other members! Many referral-based businesses see a There are other non-breakfast networking groups, some of which are dedicated to a specific cause. One that comes to mind, and is the subject of a feature article in this issue of Exclusivefocus, is an organization called The Kindness Revolution™. This non-for-profit organization is relatively new, but appears to be on verge of becoming a substantial player in the networking arena. Like BNI, each local group is made up of businesses that want to promote kindness in their communities through a variety of events that show a true commitment to kindness. For insurance agents, one suggestion is a “Don’t text and drive” campaign, which is designed for local high school students. Thanks to the efforts of NAPAA, Allstate agencies are able to get in on the ground floor of this exciting networking concept. Also like BNI, there is an annual fee, but when one considers the costs of other marketing efforts and the ROE realized, this seems like an easy decision. For more information, go to page 42 of this magazine to read the feature article about The Kindness Revolution™. Chambers Of Commerce You are most likely already a member of the local Chamber of Commerce, but are you attending their events? Typically, each Chamber offers at least one big networking event each month, Fall 2012 like a Business After Hours get-together. These events are usually pretty large and very casual. Attendees range from business owners to staff, and even include some retirees. Depending on the size of your city, there might be many more options than just this one event. Check out the monthly calendar and see what is available. Chamber events are helpful because you see a lot of the same people each month. You really get to know one another quickly. Many times, the people who attend Chamber of Commerce events are also well-involved in the community and have a large network. Since events are monthly instead of weekly, it’s important to commit to attending at least one event every single month no matter what. Skipping will leave too much time and it will be harder to get to know anyone. Special Interest or Alumni Groups One of the beauties of marketing an insurance agency is that basically everyone needs what you sell. Everyone in attendance needs auto insurance and home or renters insurance. You don’t have to run around looking for a small narrow niche of people at a networking event. Your target customer is everywhere you go. This is nice because it means that your networking doesn’t have to be limited to business events. You can get your name out anywhere and get more quotes. Look at special interest groups that you are involved in and commit to attending those events on a regular basis. The options are endless! You could be involved in your church, your kid’s soccer team, be on the board of a local shelter, join a Rotary club, or join a running club. You could get involved in your alumni association or volunteer at the kid’s school. Anywhere you put in time and meet new people is going to benefit you as you grow your agency. Your main goal is to become better-known in the community. Then when people have a rate increase or a bad claims experience and go out looking for new insurance, they’ll already have you in mind. If you’re concerned about not having Fall 2012 time to “network” then this is a good solution too. You are basically multi-tasking! You get to do the stuff you already enjoy and have the opportunity to grow your agency at the same time. Networking With Other Allstate Agents Odds are that in the past you’ve joined organizations locally that involve only insurance agents. While occasionally helpful, you’re unlikely to see a lot of new clients coming from these groups because they all sell insurance, right? Plus, many are agents for other companies and you can’t share ideas or strategies because you market to the same local client base. Your time is limited and valuable so these probably aren’t the best places to spend hours each month when they don’t give a lot of return. But there is another option... NAPAA has created an easy online option for networking with Allstate agents all around the country and you don’t even have to leave your desk! NAPAA now has a private Facebook group available for current and former Allstate agents only, and you don’t have to be a NAPAA member to participate. The goal of this group is to bring agents together in a private setting to discuss issues they may be experiencing, share marketing ideas, and provide support from people in similar situations. Facebook is an excellent place for networking in this way because it’s very user- friendly and easy to access. Once becoming a member of the group, you can easily post a question, comment on others, make a poll, or share information right from your computer or mobile phone. While NAPAA has offered an online forum in the past, they decided that this would be a more user-friendly option and allow you to easily keep up and interact and network with other agents. I am helping to facilitate and coordinate NAPAA’s Facebook effort. By working together, we can help as many agents as possible! Please go to Facebook and search at the top for the ALL Agents Page. Since this is a private group and membership must be approved, you will need to request to join. Once approved, we will add you as a member the next day. Networking is an important part of being an agency owner. You need to have strong name recognition in the community and be well-connected amongst other local business owners. Take advantage of these opportunities and make time for them on your calendar each week. You’ll see more phone calls coming in, more referrals, and faster growth. Then join us on the ALL Agents Page and let us know what is working for you! Ef Robyn Sharp is a former agency owner and insurance marketing expert. Visit www. agencyupdates.com to receive a copy of her free report “59 Ways to Attract All the Insurance Clients You Need.” Join the discussion today! https://www.facebook.com/groups/304988616263352/ Click JOIN once you’re a member, the link will be under Groups on your Facebook page Exclusivefocus — 35 36 — Exclusivefocus Fall 2012 technology What’s all the Fuss about Tablets? By Scott Brodbeck O ne of the questions I’m asked on a regular basis is, “Do I need a tablet?” My answer is usually, “You may not need one, but once you understand the convenience, you’ll probably want one.” Tablets used to be nothing more than oversized cell phones – without the ability to make phone calls – but as the technology has become more popular and the user base continues to grow, many people are replacing their laptops with tablets. The first thing to understand is that for the most part, whatever you can do on the Internet with your laptop you can probably do with a tablet. As more webbased, or cloud-based, services pop up, we move get ourselves further and further away from standalone software that is installed on individual PCs. It has even been rumored that the next iteration of Microsoft Office will be cloud-based. The convenience of carrying an iPad Fall 2012 or an Android-based tablet rather than a bulky laptop to an in-home life appointment not only makes you look cool, but it also is just easier. Many companies are developing “apps” – programs that take their cloud-based service and optimize the interface for your tablet – so that you’re not trying to fill out a web-based form using a web browser. Not all tablets are created the same, so there are some decisions that you have to make before you buy. In this article, I will try to cover the biggest and most important differences along with some pros and cons to help in your decisionmaking process. iPad or Android? When Apple first introduced the iPad, many users had their first experience in the “Apple Ecosystem.” Many PC users who said that they would never use a Mac quickly found themselves using some- thing that sure looked “Mac-like.” Apple spends a lot of time and money to make sure the user experience is simple, elegant and without bugs. In order to do this, they exert a lot of control over the third party apps that are available. If you want to buy something through an app, you end up buying through Apple rather than the company that created the app. There is an upside to this; Apple is the only company who has your personal information, including your credit card number. Apple takes 30% of whatever fees are paid for the apps it sells, as well as for anything that’s sold by the app. Interestingly, Apple won’t permit the app creator to offer a better price outside of the app. What this means for you is that companies can’t charge higher prices for something you buy using an app. Without going into too many technical details, Apple also controls how the app can behave when it’s running on an iPad. This makes the user experience more fluid and reduces the chances of apps running in the background, which could otherwise tie up system resources, causing the foreground application to come to an abrupt end. Android is the Apple alternative. It was originally developed by Google as an operating system for cell phones, but has since moved over to the tablet world. Many manufacturers including Asus, Samsung and Toshiba manufacture Android tablets. Unlike Apple, Google takes a much less controlling role in app development and has remained committed to its “open source” philosophy by willingly sharing the code for its operating system with developers. Android refers to the operating system developed by Google which was originally designed to work on cell phones. As tablets were developed, they were viewed by the Android operating system as just Exclusivefocus — 37 cell phones with bigger screens. Over the course of time, there have been newer versions of the Android operating system released, but many tablet manufacturers don’t upgrade their existing base of tablets to the most recent operating system. Each version of the operating system has a name, with “Jellybean” being the most recent. Other names that you’ll come across are “Gingerbread,” “Ice Cream Sandwich,” “Froyo” and “Honeycomb.” One of the downsides of Android-based tablets is that an app that runs on one tablet may not run on another. One of the reasons for this is that it was written to run under a specific version of the operating system and there’s never a guarantee that it will run on a different version. Don’t misunderstand; many apps will run trouble-free, but if there is a problem, operating system incompatibility is usually at the root of the problem. The number of available apps continually changes, but at this time there are many more “apps” available for the iPad – which are downloaded from the Apple App Store – than there are for Androidbased tablets, which are downloaded from the Google Play Store. Since there are hundreds of thousands of apps available for both platforms, it is really not a big deal; you can generally find whatever you’re looking for. However, if you have a specific app that you must run and it’s only available on one platform, then you will want to purchase a tablet with that runs it, because you can’t run an iPad app on an Android device, and vice versa. Size Matters Tablets are available in either a 10inch or a 7-inch form-factor. As of this writing, the iPad is only available in the larger size, but it is rumored that Apple will soon release a ‘mini’ version. The 10-inch version makes using the virtual onscreen keyboard much simpler and viewing a webpage requires less “pinching.” Pinching is the technique used to increase and decrease the size of the text within a browser window and is accomplished by using you thumb and forefinger and literally pinching the image on the screen. So why then do people buy a 7-inch tablet if they have to constantly pinch the image? Portability and the 38 — Exclusivefocus fact that a 7-inch is lighter are the usual reasons. Seven inch tablets have become very popular as e-readers to read electronic versions of your favorite books, but both form-factors can easily be used as e-readers by loading the appropriate app. The most popular e-readers are Amazon Kindle and Barnes and Noble’s Nook – apps for them are available for both iPads and Androids. My recommendation to people is to always go to the electronics store and look at both versions; touch both versions and look at the apps that you plan to use the most, because you will likely prefer one size tablet over the other. Wi-Fi Only or 3G/4G? If you plan to use your tablet where WiFi is readily available you can save money by purchasing a Wi-Fi only version. These tablets require a wireless router and internet service independent of the tablet. If you want to use the tablet on the road, you will probably want to get a version that works on your cellular carrier’s service. 3G/4G enabled devices also work on Wi-Fi so you only need to use the cellular capabilities when you are outside the range of a wireless router. It is important to note that when you buy a cellular-enabled tablet, you are locked into the carrier that it was designed to work with. In other words, can’t buy an AT&T-enabled tablet and make it work on Verizon’s service. Most tablet manufacturers offer several versions of their devices so that you can purchase the version that works with the service of your choice. As more and more tablets are developed to work with cellular carriers’ 4G capabilities – which is significantly faster than traditional 3G service – people will gravitate to 4G networks because of the speed in which data can be served from the Internet. But increased speed is a double-edged sword – the faster you can receive data (or stream movies) the more data you are likely to use. The days of unlimited data are long gone with the traditional cellular services. Verizon and AT&T just revamped their entire menu of services and the recurring theme seems to be the “share everything” model. In this model, you purchase a block of data once per month – usually sold by the gigabyte – and you share it amongst all of the devices on your account, including your cell phones. Adding a tablet will most likely increase the amount of data that you’re going to use, so it is important that you purchase the right cellular package, otherwise you might end up with overage charges at the end of the month. It is generally cheaper to buy more than you’ll use than it is to buy less and go over. Not all 3G/4G tablets require that you enable the cellular service at the time of purchase. That means that you can turn the service on when you need it; some even offer a pay-as-you-go plan on a month-tomonth basis with no fixed contract. This is very convenient if you only need cellular service once in a while (say when you go on vacation). However, cellular-enabled tablets can run $100 to $200 more than their Wi-Fi-only equivalents, so knowing what you’ll need and how often you’ll need it will help you make the right choice between the two technologies. Replacing your Laptop Tablets are the mainstay for many people who used to take their laptop with them when they left the office. For data consumption – browsing the Internet, reading and replying to email and watching the occasional movie – tablets can easily replace your laptop. For data creation –typing long or complex documents, spreadsheets or designing Power Point presentations – a tablet can do the job, but it will take you more time than it would using your laptop. Many external keyboards are now available for both iPads and Android tablets, so even the lines between consumption and creation are starting to blur. And in a few years, who knows where technology will have led us. Do you need a tablet? Maybe. Should you try a tablet? Absolutely! Ef Scott Brodbeck is a Microsoft Certified Systems Engineer and a Master Certified Novell Engineer who is also a former EA and IA. Currently he develops technical marketing tools and provides marketing consulting services specializing in the profitable growth of insurance agencies. He can be reached via email at scott@scottbrodbeck.com or by phone at 724-622-2904. Fall 2012 “Is your agency planted in good soil, supported wIth deep roots and really growing?” Scan with smartphone to learn how ASNOA can help your business grow. http://asnoa.com/video/ mobile/index.html • More control over your future with Increased Independence • 70% total premium growth in 2010 • Increase your revenue faster than you ever thought possible • A Proven Network of Success • Secure Carrier Markets • A stellar support system for Agents Fall Independent 2012 “I was looking for a variety of insurance products from National & Regional carriers plus more control over my future. I have seen phenomenal growth with ASNOA when most agencies are going backwards in revenue.” Christine Newton, Chesterton, IN South Shore Insurance We are Insurance Professionals helping other Insurance Professionals realize their full business potential. See how the ASNOA Advantage can help your agency grow. Watch the video at: www.asnoa.com/video ® www.asnoa.com Exclusivefocus — 39 © Copyright 2011 feature Be Wary of the Wolf Disguised as the Agency Business Objectives Program A s part of the company’s transition to variable compensation, Allstate will roll out a new quota schematic in January that will identify underperforming agency owners who will then be “considered for termination.” The Agency Business Objectives program replaces the Resources for Growth (RFG) “grids” that were introduced in 2006. The measure of performance under RFG was the Agency Performance Profile. Touted as “a new measurement system designed for use across a wide range of agency programs,” RFG was initially thought to be a replacement for the previous bonus structure. Agents soon learned that RFG not only determined the amount of their bonus; it was also the yardstick by which thousands of agents would be terminated for their so-called “failure to meet business objectives.” Each year – from 2006 through 2011 – the RFG was adjusted, altered, and otherwise tweaked by the company. Thousands of agents failed to achieve the goals handed down by Allstate and company managers were then charged with handpicking select agents for termination. Early on, it became apparent that the oldest, most tenured agents were the first to be considered for termination. Financial production and overall growth were the only two factors of the five that really mattered. Later, overall growth goals were replaced with auto growth goals and a new category called the Agency Loyalty Index (ALI) was introduced. ALI scores were calculated using customer survey responses and unfavorable scores would soon become a stand-alone reason for terminating agent contracts at will. Over the course of the five RFG years, thousands of agents operated their agencies under the constant threat of termina- 40 — Exclusivefocus tion. Letter after letter was sent to agents warning them that “failure to achieve the objectives could jeopardize your agency’s continued relationship with Allstate.” The company proceeded to rid itself of an estimated 5,000 of its long-term, most experienced agents. Agencies that were built by a lifetime of sweat equity and financial sacrifice were confiscated by an unappreciative company with a mere 90-day termination notice. In most cases, these steadfast warriors were cut loose without as much as a word of thanks for their many years of dedicated service. Instead, their books of business were redistributed to new buyers, company call centers and other agents. Looking back, some have theorized that the events of the last twelve years – beginning with the termination of employee agent contracts in 2000 through the culling of the company’s most tenured agents over the past five years – were all part of a grand scheme, which is becoming more apparent every day. In May, 2011, the company floated a plan that would rock the already fractious agency force by introducing the concept of variable compensation, which would reduce base commissions from 10% to 8%. Details were sketchy and inconsistent, as evidenced by the parade of often conflicting communications that were sent out to the field. Indeed, the company appeared to be thrown off balance by the backlash from NAPAA and the agency force. Disenchanted with the prospect of establishing agency business plans based Questioning the Wisdom of Allstate Leadership A continuous decline in the number of Allstate agents, accompanied by higher percentages of inexperienced agents and staff seems to be a recipe for disaster. This intentional process is eliminating high retention profit centers. Rewarding exceptional profitability, retention and growth has been supplanted with Woople, office appearance and one licensed staff. Agent morale is at an all time low, as evidenced by Allstate’s own Agency Relationship Survey. Yet instead of working to improve the situation, the CEO and other top management continue to deny that there are problems. The company continues to implement disruptive changes, distracting the agency force with uncertainty over reduced revenues and ever-changing guidelines that could lead to the confiscation of their agencies. Standard auto PIF has declined by nearly 1.25 million policies from the all-time high of 18,271,000 in Q2 2007. Homeowner policy count declined by 1.58 million during the same period. Allstate is losing market share, not only to internet rivals GEICO and Progressive, but to the nation’s largest personal lines insurer, State Farm, which continues to successfully operate and thrive with an agent-based distribution model. Fall 2012 on 20% less revenue, NAPAA and the agents pushed back hard. Finally, many agents threw their hands up and vowed they were giving up, declaring they could no longer afford to run an agency with 20% less revenues and still contend with ever-shifting quotas. That fall, an estimated 1,000 agents voluntarily resigned from Allstate. Pushed into a corner by the unplanned surge of agent defections, poor morale and NAPAA’s affiliation with OPEIU, the company backed down and offered a temporary reprieve for 2013 and 2014, agreeing to move the planned base compensation rate from 8% to 9%. Without admitting it had pushed too far, the company said the change was made to “ease the transition to the variable component and better allow you to plan for your business over the next several years and determine your long term strategy.” While the letter did not specifically provide the level of commissions for 2015 and beyond, the implication was that this two-year reprieve was designed to “ease the transition” to an 8% base compensation rate in 2015. With the introduction of the variable compensation model, the company declared the sunset of RFG in 2012. Since December of 2011, additional changes have been quietly announced. Agency Success Factors (ASF) quickly became known as the new standard to “earn back” the 10% reduction in revenue. The Allstate Customer Experience Survey (ACES) replaced the Agency Loyalty Index (ALI). Payment of TPP would soon be extended from 12 months to 24 months. And more recently, the company acquired the eAgent agency management system from eBridge. Until now, the four components of the new Agency Success Factors were touted as simple components to recapture the 10% loss in revenue. Upon further examination, however, agents are learning that the structure of the new ASF requirements mean that compensation can fluctuate from month to month, moving back and forth between 10% and 9%, possibly several times a year. Indeed, the new ASF is so complicated, the company decided to implement grace periods for two of the four components. Fall 2012 With the announcement of the Agency Business Objectives program, agents have suddenly learned that failure to achieve all four of the Agency Success Factors will be one of the objectives of the new “Expected Performance” measurement – which will ultimately be used as a basis to terminate agent contracts. Sound familiar? RFG was introduced as the replacement for the Agency Achievement Bonus, but by the end of its five-year existence, it is being remembered by most as the company’s principal agent termination tool. What does the future hold for the Agency Success Factors? Will they continue to be the relatively simple requirements needed to earn back commissions that they are today? Will the four components be altered, tweaked and manipulated, enabling the company to drop commissions whenever it wants to decrease its expense ratio? What is the plan for agency terminations? Will the termination process become as subjective as it was with RFG, wherein thousands of agents were terminated? Just exactly what is in store for the future of the Allstate agent? Based on past history, the outlook is bleak at best. Ef Resources for Growth (RFG) Agency Performance Profile Agency Business Objectives (ABO) Agency Success Factors Profitability Good Hands Certification – Woople Retention (later combined with Auto growth into one measurement) Office Assessment – (reinspection of agent offices that were company approved before they opened) Growth (later combined with Retention into one measurement) Minimum 1 Staff (LSP) per office (three month grace period, twice each calendar year) AF Production goal (Minimum $20,000 production) AF Proprietary Life Policies Sold (12 or 18 policies on 12 mm scale) (one month grace period, twice each calendar year) Emerging Business Production (category added in 2008) Agency Loyalty Index (ALI) Allstate Customer Experience Survey (ACES) Exclusivefocus — 41 cover story Kindness is Contagious How to Increase Sales and Boost your Reputation D uring my career as a professional Allstate agent, I’ve tried just about every conceivable method of marketing imaginable. I admit that some of those ideas were stinkers, but I let somebody talk me into trying them anyway. I have tried internet leads, magazine ads, TV and radio, school and athletic sponsorships, trade shows, Chamber of Commerce functions, direct mail, etc. I even hired a firm that specialized in “restroom” advertising; they strategically placed my poster-style ads in the stalls and at eye level above the urinals in restrooms all across town. And they were noticed. I’m not certain how much business they generated, but we got a lot of humorous calls from customers and competing agents! What I have learned is that most legitimate forms of marketing will produce 42 — Exclusivefocus results, but some produce better results than others. I have also learned that repetition matters. The more people see your name, the more likely they are to do business with you. But getting your name out there comes at a hefty price. And with lower commission rates on the way, agents will have to find ways to stretch their advertising dollars farther than ever before. I plan to shun those costly – and typically disappointing – marketing schemes that are often enthusiastically proposed by management. I also plan to pare back on internet leads and other forms of marketing in favor of the hands-on, community-based marketing approach I am currently using with great success. Like most agents, I have fallen for some sure-to-fail marketing programs in my career. As a result, I am much wiser and far less gullible than I was in my early years. These days I am more skeptical, which makes it harder for someone to put one over on me. Interestingly enough, when I was first introduced to The Kindness Revolution™, I didn’t experience any feelings of doubt or skepticism. Instead, I found myself wanting to learn more about it. And when I learned more about it, I wanted to share it with other Allstate agents, which why I am writing this article. In recent times, Allstate agents have few advantages over the competition. We are not competitive in most markets, yet we are still required to achieve our “business objectives” or we stand to lose our livelihoods. I became angry because there weren’t enough tools in my toolbox to overcome the price differential between my rate and the competition’s. But partnering with The Kindness Revolution™ (TKR) is changing all of that for our agency. Before I tell you more about our experiences with The Kindness Revolution™, let me provide you with some background about this remarkable nonprofit organization. Named after a popular book of the same name, The Kindness Revolution™ is a movement that seeks to raise the awareness of wholesome values – such as kindness – among business leaders, in schools and local communities and amongst consumers. As we began to look more closely at The Kindness Revolution™, it became clear that nobody is opposed or offended by the values it espouses. Examples of the values it stands for include its anti-bullying and anti-texting while driving campaigns. Needless to say, these are values that any responsible person would support. Fall 2012 This shared commonality among business and community leaders is a key attraction of The Kindness Revolution™. These leaders want people in their communities to know that they cherish positive values. It’s no secret that consumers want to do business with like-minded businesses, especially those that are located within their own communities. This is where The Kindness Revolution™ excels. The idea is to bring groups of local leaders together to promote the principles of kindness to their clients and the public. These tightly-knit groups share referrals with each other as well as host joint events in conjunction with The Kindness Revolution™. As you read this article, I can envision a puzzled look coming over your face as you wonder, “Why share this idea with other Allstate agents?” My answer is: “Why not?” Participation in The Kindness Revolution™ is done on a local basis. If I am participating in my community, why should I mind if other agents do the same thing in theirs? Besides, I don’t want State Farm agents or Farmers agents to be the first to know about it – I want Allstate agents to be “first on the block” for a change. After seeing the potential of TKR and what it could do for Allstate agents across the country, we approached NAPAA about spreading the word to the agency force. They agreed with the understanding that it would be offered to NAPAA members first. The roll-out to the members began in August and will continue until early October, around the time this magazine is distributed to the full agency force. NAPAA acted quickly because it wanted Allstate agents to be the first to be able to seize upon The Kindness Revolution™ opportunity. There is no doubt that other agent groups and/or insurance companies will follow suit. But if Allstate agents respond enthusiastically, as we think they will, they will be the first to establish a presence in their communities, driving more business to their agencies. Of course, there are multiple Allstate agencies in most markets, so it will be important for interested agents to act quickly. I’m confident that many of you have Fall 2012 been involved in other networking groups which have brought you some degree of success. I’ve experienced the following negatives in such groups: • No exclusivity. Oftentimes, there are other competitive insurance agents in the group. This is especially difficult for a new agent trying to overcome the ‘good old boys’ in the group. If you form your own group with TKR, you decide which business owners should be invited into the group. • Whether you are the only insurance agent in the group or one of several, you are always viewed as peddling insurance. And as we know, many folks shy away from us because of the business we’re in. With TKR this doesn’t happen; you are involved because of the principles you believe in, making your occupation secondary. We were ecstatic to meet Ed Horrell, the founder of The Kindness Revolution™. His input was invaluable and Break the Shackles... Get EXCITED About Insurance Again! Remember Why You Became an Insurance Agent! To Build and Run Your Own Independent Business With Freedom, Autonomy and Without Limits Yet With Support and Experienced Guidance At PREMIER GROUP INSURANCE More Than 100 PGI Partners Have it All! • Strong National and Regional Property & Casualty Carriers • Direct Carrier Access by You for Your Business Plan and Client Needs • Business Ownership with Lucrative Bonus and Perpetuation Options • Increased Close Ratios AND Higher Commissions with No Life Quotas • Business Tools You Need - E&O, Comparative Rater, AMS, Web-SEO Options • Unparalleled Support with Innovative Programs Dedicated to Your Success! If you’re feeling captive explore your options www.ThinkPremierFirst.com or Contact Premier’s President, Rex Hickling, CPCU, AIM directly at: (303)818-6218 RexH@ThinkPremierFirst.com Exclusivefocus — 43 44 — Exclusivefocus the story is that kindness begets its own rewards. Not only are we seeing more and more sales as a result, but the positive messaging of the campaign has invigorated everyone in the agency, creating more camaraderie and giving us inspiration and peace of mind knowing that we are giving something back to our community. “ The other thing we’ve noticed is that price has become less of an issue. It seems people will pay more if they like you and the cause you represent. “ helped us in our decision to participate. Early in the process, we were introduced to the Community Champion program. This gave us the opportunity to: • Meet and join together with likeminded business owners from other industries, who support the initiatives of The Kindness Revolution™. • Benefit from referrals from likeminded business owners in our group. • Work with schools in our community to promote anti-bullying, sportsmanship, anti-texting while driving, and the “It’s Cool to be Kind” campaigns. • Become the local voice of kindness in our community. • Network with consumers and consumer groups who have similar goals, resulting in more leads for our agency. • Determine for ourselves how much time we want to devote to the program. TKR is very flexible, leaving the level of participation up to us. In our case, we opted to be an active participant. Our motto and battle cry is: “The more you put into it, the more you’ll get out of it!” • Last, it gives us a warm fuzzy feeling to know the causes we’re supporting will help to create a more civil society for everyone. We have had great success with The Kindness Revolution™. Thank goodness we had the vision to sign up under the Community Champions program. It has been an awesome experience, not only because it brought more sales opportunities to our agency, but because it has motivated everyone in the agency to become more involved. The interesting part of all of this is that new sales are simply a by-product of the process. The overriding reason we initially decided to get involved was to generate more sales, but as we watched the process unfold, it became clear that the increase in sales was due to the good things we were doing and people wanted to reward us by buying from us. The other thing we’ve noticed is that price has become less of an issue. It seems people will pay more if they like you and the cause you represent. As we know, loyalty to the agent runs deep in the insurance business, so it is gratifying when people tell us that they are buying their insurance from us because they like what we’re doing. The moral of Additionally, we are able to accurately measure our results. We know how many leads and referrals we receive and can calculate the commissions we’ve earned. And since we’ve joined together with other business owners, not all the leads we receive are for home, auto and EB. We also get commercial leads, workplace leads and life insurance leads. In fact, we recently closed a million dollar life sale as a result of one of our “mini-events.” We were pleased when NAPAA became an ardent supporter of The Kindness Revolution™. At our suggestion, they booked Ed Horrell as a guest speaker at their national conference this past June. Now NAPAA is onboard and is leading the way to introduce The Kindness Revolution™ to Allstate agents. NAPAA understands that the key to success is for Allstate agents to be the first in their communities to become Community Champions. They also know that success in any business is largely dependent on business owners being able to recognize winning strategies and be the first to capitalize on them. This is why they are leading the charge to acquaint Allstate agents with The Kindness Revolution™ ahead of the competition. Let’s face it; Allstate agents need an edge dur- ing these times of sagging agent morale and uncompetitive rates. After reading Ed Horrell’s book, I had a paradigm shift in the way I looked at society. Our everyday world is fraught with man’s inhumanity to man and too little kindness. We see this in all parts of society from politics to religion. What I have decided to do in our agency is to seek out clients from our book of business who exemplify the kindness lifestyle and reward them with recognition. The Kindness Revolution™ provides a way to recognize everyday folks who do good things for the benefit of all. As an example, I have a client who is a teacher and an investor with rental properties. Last year, she started working with highly regarded charities that help place homeless people in her vacant rentals. Now she’s started a program encouraging other investors to help. The school administrators where she teaches are thrilled with the idea that one of their teachers is being recognized for her generosity and devotion to a worthy cause. She and her school will always remember our agency, The Kindness Revolution™ and, of course Allstate. There is so much more to tell you about The Kindness Revolution™ and I wish I had the space to say more. I’ll conclude by saying that TKR gives us great ideas, support, examples of printed materials and giveaways, social media assistance, press releases, posters, and much more as we market and network in our community. The process is simple, straight forward, and effective. I can safely say that it is like nothing else I have ever seen. Find out how you can become part of The Kindness Revolution™ by calling TKR founder Ed Horrell at 901-7573768 or by sending an email to Allstate@ TheKindnessRevolution.net. For priority service, be sure to mention you are a current or former Allstate agent. Thank you for allowing me to share my experiences with you. If you decide to join The Kindness Revolution™, I hope you’ll consider writing a letter or article for publication in a future issue of Exclusivefocus magazine so other Allstate agents can benefit from your successes. Ef Editor’s note: For additional information, visit www.TheKindnessRevolution.net. Fall 2012 n o i t u l o v e R s s e n d n i K e h T ™ Welcomes its new partnership with NAPAA Our goal is to start a Revolution of Kindness in every community. To do that, we need a local face to be our Community Champion. n o i t u l o v e R s s e n d n i K e h T Watch your sales skyrocket when you become the first and only agent in your community to represent the movement that will make people smile every time they think of you! ™ Simple, Powerful, Affordable and Effective For one Allstate agency’s experience, read the accompanying article titled “Kindness is Contagious” t e n . n o i t u l o v e r s s e n d n i k e h t @ e t a t s l l a : t a s u l i a m e n o i t a m r o f n i e r o m r o F 0 6 0 6 . 4 8 3 . 4 0 4 t a y l i a D e v a D l l a c r O Fall 2012 Exclusivefocus — 45 feature Sad Times at Allstate By Bryan Ahlquist A “Great Sadness” has settled over the Allstate agency force. It has no specific identity, nor is there a discernible moment in time in which it first appeared. Its presence may not even be apparent to those infected by it and for now, there seems to be no cure. To those on the outside looking in, Allstate appears to be like many other companies struggling with the economic downturn. The loss of market share, an unprecedented decline in PIF and the loss of thousands of tenured Allstate agents can readily be blamed on the economic maelstrom that has engulfed our economy over the past four years. For many, the plausibility of this excuse has led them to believe that perception is reality, despite the fact that most carriers in Allstate’s peer group are not faring nearly as poorly. But those positioned at the epicen- 46 — Exclusivefocus ter of the company’s business processes know a different reality. They are keenly aware that it is management’s misguided decisions that are responsible for the company’s problems. And for the agents, the fact that management is not only aware of the problem, but is actually the cause of it, makes their plight even more troubling. Much has changed since the salad days when Allstate agents sold policies from booths inside Sears stores. Then, agents not only worked for a company built by agents, but for a company whose management respected them. Customers were eager to affiliate with sales professionals who represented an industry leader and their only real competition was limited to a few select companies. Today, insurance agents struggle to compete in a new environment where they not only face fierce competition from traditional players, but from unconventional sources. Taking their cue from Progressive, companies like Allstate and Farmers have bought into the premise that it is okay to “eat their young” by buying established direct marketers Esurance and 21st Century, both of which compete with their agents. Not only do agents lose new prospects to them, they are losing renewal business as well. Surely customers who see commercials stating that Esurance is an Allstate company are curious to see if the rates are lower. After all, most are happy with Allstate and their agent, so why not see if they can save any money? In all likelihood, however, they don’t realize that saving a few dollars means losing their family insurance agent. Of course, this cannibalistic betrayal is but one of many issues causing the melancholy mood of the agency force. The stature of the agent is rapidly diminishing, thanks to the unilateral nature of the agent contract. More and more, agents perceive their role has shifted to one of “disposable tool,” rather than the indispensible cornerstone they once were. Promised one thing delivered another In 2000, when Allstate “transitioned” (fired then re-hired) its agent sales force from employee to ‘independent contractor,’ most agents made the move from Neighborhood Office Agent (NOA) to Exclusive Agent (EA) with only minor adjustments. The NOA program, which was launched in the mid 80’s, was the precursor of the EA contract. NOA agents were still employees, but they were allowed certain entrepreneurial and financial freedoms, but only a portion of their expenditures were reimbursed by the company. While NOAs liked the entrepreneurial side of the contract, Fall 2012 most considered the expense reimbursement to be woefully inadequate. This would soon become a bone of contention between NOAs and management; a rift so serious that it led to the founding of the National Neighborhood Office Agents Club (NNOAC) in 1989. The group subsequently changed its name to the National Association of Professional Allstate Agents (NAPAA). In 1990, the company introduced the EA contract, an ‘independent contractor’ agreement that eliminated expense reimbursements and offered commissions of 10/10 on auto and 20/10 on property. Virtually all new agents were hired under the EA agreement while existing employee agents were allowed to convert to the new contract only if they qualified. The pace of voluntarily employee agent conversions was slow, however. Perhaps the company thought the employee agents would be so eager to become EAs that they would strive to meet the conversion qualifiers. But that didn’t happen, and after ten years, approximately 6,200 agents were still employees. It was clear that they had reservations about the EA contract, which stripped them of all employee benefits and protections. In the mid 90’s the company fired all of its California agents and rehired them as ‘independent contractors’ in response to a lawsuit that had been filed there. Although the company denied it would ever happen again, the stage had been set. Possibly a result of the tepid pace of voluntary employee-to-EA conversions and the substantial cost savings it realized from the forced conversions in California, the company grew restless and eager to move agents into the ‘independent contractor’ model. Finally in 2000, the company fired the bulk of its remaining employee agent workforce, offering to rehire them as ‘independent contractors.” Since the mindset of the NOA agent was already semi-entrepreneurial, they adapted sooner than those who had been under other employee agent contracts. And the promised freedoms associated with ‘independent contractor’ status, as well as the assurance of owning their book of business, only heightened their excitement. Agents eagerly sought to grow their books of business because Fall 2012 they were told only the business they wrote as ‘independent contractors’ would count toward their “ownership interest.” This ownership interest was frequently touted by Allstate as a commodity that could be easily sold or passed down to a qualified relative. But now, 12 years removed from the glitz and glamour of those early promises, a troubling reality has emerged wherein management routinely micro-manages buyer approvals and interferes with the sales process. Presumably pressured by Wall Street expectations, but more likely because of its stubborn reluctance to relinquish its longstanding employee-employer mentality, Allstate continues to cling to a management philosophy that is decades old. Rather than savor the emancipation it promised to grant its ‘independent contractor’ agents in its now infamous Private Letter Ruling, Allstate has instead made a conscious decision to keep its agency force in check by dredging up and instituting employee-like controls that fly in the face of IRS precepts. This backward thinking has stymied the entrepreneurial spirit of the agency force and prolonged the life of the company’s obsolete management corps – the structure of which has remained virtually unchanged since the employee agent days of the NOA. Within a year of implementing the Exclusive Agent program, Allstate had already begun its subtle transition back to the very controls it utilized for its employee agents. Initially, the company began by testing the waters, one change at a time. Maybe they reasoned that since a majority of the agency force had been employee agents, they could gradually reintroduce employee-like controls without much agent pushback. Aside from NAPAA, few agents could fathom how the reconstitution of quotas, mandatory office hours, mandatory call forwarding and other controls would ultimately affect their independent contractor status and their careers. For the most part, the vast majority of Allstate agents ignored the transition back to their former status as employee agents. Perhaps this nonchalance was due to the fact that their whole world had been turned upside down by the mass conversion. The fact that its ‘independent contractor’ agents offered little resistance at first, gave Allstate management the confidence it needed to accelerate its return to the days of full-blown employee controls. Further, they surmised that in spite of the aggressive reimplementation of previous employee controls, many agents would rather focus on the promise of independence than on the reality that they were once again operating under the complete control of Allstate’s old employee agent system. Even worse than the letdown associated with the unfulfilled goal of gaining true independent contractor freedoms, more and more agents have concluded that Allstate’s promise of “independence” was a cruel sham which was never intended to be delivered. The Sword of Damocles With the exception of new agents, there isn’t an agent in the country who doesn’t personally know another agent who has been fired. It is no accident that Allstate designed the “90-day termination notice” the way it did. Ostensibly designed as a mechanism to allow poorly performing agents to rectify production deficiencies in order to meet company quotas, or “business objectives,” it instead serves as a gauntlet of shame that typically ends in an agent’s termination while simultaneously serving as a harbinger for those who remain. Clearly, no agent wants their business to fail. This understatement hasn’t lost its meaning at Allstate’s home office. When Allstate first implemented its Neighborhood Office Agent (NOA) program, management knew the single most important aspect of the program’s design had to include a perception of ownership even though there was none. They knew that unless agents believed they had an ownership stake in their NOA agencies, they would not make the necessary emotional or financial commitments to ensure the success of the program. Once the agents bought into the program, Allstate knew it could institute ever-increasing controls without the risk of an agent easily walking away. It is no mistake that the current EA program is an enhanced clone of the Exclusivefocus — 47 NOA program, including the perception of ownership. To be sure, Allstate management’s life was made easier by the fact that they did not have to alter much of the prior employee program when they introduced the EA program. But the EA program goes beyond the NOA program in some respects. Because it no longer classifies agents as employees, the company is no longer bound to honor employee protections. Presumably, the company has sought legal counsel for the purpose of skirting IRS guidelines that govern whether someone is an independent contractor or not. Visiting the section of the IRS website that describes its independent contractor guidelines is more that enough to convince most people that Allstate is pushing boundaries to the extreme. Apart from not fulfilling their life “validation” quotas during the first three years of their contracts, employee agents in the 80’s were rarely terminated. And compared to today’s standards, the validation quotas were miniscule, probably averaging between $3,000 and $4,000 per year in issued life premium. Once agents made it three years, it was unlikely they would be fired for anything except misrepresentation, falsification of applications, stealing or dereliction of duty, such as regularly failing to show up for work. When an NOA did manage to get terminated, they departed with little more than a memory of their tenure at Allstate. The financial impact, while serious, was mostly attributable to the loss of money invested in growing and operating their business. When an EA is fired, it begins with a review process that includes a measurement of the agent’s performance as compared to company imposed business objectives, also known as quotas or Expected Results. But unlike the NOA employee agent, the EA has an ownership interest in his book of business. So the stakes are much higher when an EA is terminated. From the outset, the EA is encouraged to write as much business as possible to supercharge the “economic interest” of the book of business. Under normal circumstances this would be sound advice; invest in your agency to build your business and reap the re48 — Exclusivefocus wards when it is time to sell. It makes a lot of sense, right? Not necessarily. In the past five years, thousands of Allstate agents have been terminated or been intimidated into leaving; forcing many to accept “fire sale” prices for their books of business. Many more were unable to find buyers and had to settle for TPP. In most of these cases, the tens of thousands of dollars they invested to build their agencies were lost, causing some to go bankrupt or even attempt suicide. And those with large outstanding loans on their books and/or long-term leases were similarly affected. Of course, what is rarely talked about is the loss of future income attributable to return of investment from an owned asset – hundreds of thousands of dollars in many cases. Allstate understands all of this and uses it like a Sword of Damocles over the heads of its EAs. Because of this, leveraging proscribed behaviors from its EA agency sales force has now become a simple matter of instituting a threat process, followed closely by a reminder of just exactly what the agent has to lose: EVERYTHING. To the agent, it sounds something like this: “Now that it is March, here are your ‘Business Objectives’ for the year. How you reach these corporately mandated business objectives is up to you, but failure to do so could jeopardize your business relationship with Allstate.” Which translates to: either chase after our quotas or lose everything. Testing and then implementing this management philosophy was elementary for Allstate. It was this “sense of ownership” that Allstate would use as leverage when it decided to proceed with the mass conversion of employee agents to EAs in 2000. As an inducement to convert the employee agents to EA status, they simply offered to let them keep the very agencies they had already built. Allstate knew that virtually no agent could afford to walk away from a lifetime’s worth of work and investment. And to this day, Allstate leverages an agent’s commitment to success against his fear of losing everything. Many agents have likened their business relationship with Allstate as: “All stick and no carrot.” Others recognize the true nature of the abusive re- lationship, but cannot afford to extricate themselves without dire financial consequences. Stockholm Syndrome? After spending a certain amount of time in captivity, kidnap victims have been known to begin to empathize with their abductors. This “rationalization,” known as Stockholm Syndrome, can occur even if there is severe trauma or abuse associated with the process. Among the ranks of Allstate agents, there exists a contingent of unabashed supporters of the current management regime as well as an acceptance of the current EA contract. Mostly made up of “Mega Agencies,” with large staffs, they seem out of touch with the average Allstate agent. Without doubt, it is much easier to meet your quotas with a cadre of LSPs; a luxury most agents can ill-afford. There are also a number of smaller midsize agents who “play the game” and who don’t seem too bothered with the mandatory quotas. For these agents, it has become a matter of ignoring Allstate’s use of employee controls and willingly sacrificing their status as ‘independent contractors.’ Mindful to shield its newly hired agents from reality, Allstate managers have been largely successful in steering them away from resources like NAPAA and ALLBlueBlog. Management wants to be the sole source for advice – from which sales processes to use to the necessary expenditures they should make as they run their agencies. These spoon-fed neophytes often buy into Allstate’s master plan, only to recant their allegiance at a later date when they realize that running an agency in the real world is nothing like the imaginary world presented to them by their never-owned-an-agency FSLs. It is confounding how any agent can ignore the fact that their true status is one of an employee, not an independent contractor. Even successful agents know their tenure as an Allstate agent is dependent on two things; meeting their monthly and yearly quotas and Allstate’s current R3001 Agency Supplement, which changes frequently. What many agents still don’t get is that they Fall 2012 signed a unilateral agreement, not a bilateral agreement. It is time for Allstate agents to demand and secure a bilateral agreement that ensures true independent contractor status. For new hires, it is imperative that they perform some degree of due diligence by contacting NAPAA, getting on ALLBlueBlog and by comparing the Allstate 3001 EA Agreement (and R3001 Supplement) to a true independent contractor agent agreement. Whether they realize it or not, the two agent segments referenced above operate in a stress-filled environment resulting from trying to reconcile perception with reality. As Allstate agents approach 2013, it will be increasingly difficult to avoid the necessity to perform at a higher level just to get back to 10% compensation. It is expected in some circles, that the base will fall even further in 2015. The highest level of fiduciary responsibility There is no doubt that a morale problem exists within the ranks of the Allstate agency sales force. It has been well-documented on the Allstate Agency Community as well as in the company’s annual Agency Relationship Survey. The fact that Allstate CEO Tom Wilson repeatedly demeans his own integrity and credibility by issuing frequent public denials covering up the truth should give agents reason for concern. But then, he seems prone to spinning yarns. At the Allstate shareholder meeting last May, he denied the company ever had any plans to reduce the number of agents. He made this preposterous statement in spite of the fact that Allstate has turned over more than 5,000 agents since he began leading the company in late 2007. In addition, programs such as “Agency Performance Segmentation,” the Agency Loyalty Index (ALI) and others were specifically contrived to depopulate the agency force. Apparently, Mr. Wilson never learned that mendacity is an unflattering trait. But let’s give Mr. Wilson the benefit of the doubt and say that he is simply ignorant of the morale problem among the agents. If true, it is a breathtaking example of how out of touch he is with his responsibilities as CEO. If we consider the former of the two Fall 2012 hypotheses, it follows that Wilson expects a rather swift implementation of his agenda and that any negative impact from poor agent morale will not be permanent. Further, while it is possible the morale issue was not one of his primary concerns, it is possible that it has now been factored into his plan and will serve to advance his agenda. When considering the latter of the two hypotheses, (that Wilson is simply out of touch with the rank and file agent), it would seem inconceivable that a CEO could be that oblivious to an issue that has resulted in thousands of agents terminating their relationships with Allstate. Regardless of Wilson’s motivation, his actions, or the lack thereof, impact thousands of agents. It is unconscionable to think that he would allow the current level of discord to continue, leaving agents and outsiders alike wondering when or if the problem will be addressed. The added stress resulting from uncertainty has manifested itself into an increasing number of despondent agents posting increasingly desperate comments on ALLBlueBlog and the Allstate Agency Community. Tom Wilson is the cause, and there might not be a cure Someone once said: “Recognizing that a problem exists, is half the battle.” Even if management acknowledged the agent morale problem, it is doubtful Tom Wilson would look for a cure. His statement at this year’s Allstate Shareholder Meeting, whence he exclaimed, “We can do whatever we want,” seems to have put to rest any possibility of addressing the issue any time soon. In spite of the uncertainty, some agents are vowing to weather the storm, hoping for better days. With so much going against them, including an upcoming reduction in compensation, these agents are choosing to focus on the things that they can control, such as trying to increase their sales production and retention. Still others have likened it to battening down the hatches, as they count the days until retirement. An increasing number of agents are opting out by choosing a “Plan B.” Un- willing to wait for the ultimate outcome of Wilson’s grand plan, a serious number of agents are planning to quit before year-end in order to take advantage of the current 12-month TPP, or Termination Payment Provision. For these agents, self-medication takes the form of resigning, moving a mile, and opening up a true independent insurance agency. In the past few years, it has become evident that Tom Wilson’s idea of a successful company is based solely on the destination, not the road traveled. His detachment from the humanistic side of the business has enabled him to turn his back on the very people who helped build the company; a fact that does not sit well with tenured agents. He is fully aware of the cries for help on ALLBlueBlog and the Allstate Agency Community. He is likely briefed daily on the status of the number of agents leaving the company, yet his response is a chilling denial of these problems, followed by silence. So what are agents left with? For now, it is clear the company will offer nothing to assuage their concerns. Equally clear is Tom Wilson’s focus on other corporate enterprises he hopes will help turn around Allstate’s dwindling PIF. Like a desperate poker player, Wilson made an “all-in” bet with the purchase of Esurance. Since all of chips are now on the table, agents can expect this “all-in” bet will get his “allout” support to ensure its success, even if it means sacrificing profits. If Esurance should fail, it would spell the end of Tom Wilson’s Allstate career. This all-out effort to prove he’s right will come at the expense of the agency force, whose morale is already near rock bottom. Mr. Wilson’s disdain for the agency force has never been clearer. If he cared as much for the agents as he seems to care for Esurance, the agent morale issues would have been solved long ago. For some agents, the cure to this “Great Sadness” may be in savoring a bittersweet goodbye from the company they once loved and a cheery hello to their newfound home in the world of independent agents. Shame on you Tom Wilson for enriching yourself at the expense of those great people who built Allstate. Ef Exclusivefocus — 49 feature True Success without Allstate By Bryan Ahlquist T he solitary figure exited the red bricked building and walked with purposeful strides across the narrow street. Upon reaching the other side, the man looked back and marveled at the crispness of the parallel lines that separated each of the oven-fired, Chicago made bricks. Turning to begin the short walk that lay ahead, he noticed the evening air had been scented with the delicious aroma of grilled steaks and with what he thought was a touch of smoke coming from a slow cooking rack of barbeque ribs. His neighbor’s lawn had been recently mowed and the smell of the freshly cut grass seemed particularly fragrant and clean. When his eye caught a swatch of deep azure peeking from behind the towering oaks that lined the street, he felt as if he were noticing the sky for the first time. Without realizing it, a broad grin had erupted across his face, replacing what was usually a stoic if not melancholy countenance. Then, as the awareness of all of these things slowly made their way to his conscious thoughts, he knew for the first time in a long time, he was going to be happy. He knew the thing that he had dreaded the most was finally behind him. There would no longer be sleepless nights, followed by anxiety-filled days. His heart and mind both told him that the days ahead were going to be the best days of his life. Then just for a moment, he allowed himself to drift back to the point in time that had become the catalyst for the event that would forever change his life. The phone had been busily ringing all morning. Most of the calls were clients wanting his attention, or that of his capable staff. Thinking the latest incoming call was a prospective client, he quickly answered the call. Minutes after hanging up, he knew his future was about to be changed. At first, 50 — Exclusivefocus there was disbelief and then came the anger. In the end, there was sadness. The call had been from his Allstate manager, who called to give him a “heads up” that he would be receiving a 90-day “improvement” notice in the mail the following day. Nearly 30 years of service, a 40% loss ratio, 90% retention, an ALI score of 85, and multiple awards could not stave off the letter that was coming. None of that mattered because he was told he was failing to achieve the only true measurement of success as defined by Allstate’s mandated “Expected Results.” He had failed to sell enough Allstate Financial Services products to be “on pace” for his annual quota. In the few months that followed, he sold the requisite premium in life insurance and met the mandate handed down to him. No second letter followed the first one, only his manager’s brief call telling him that for now, he was safe. It was then that he realized the true nature of the relationship he had with Allstate. It was also then that he vowed never to let Allstate be the arbiter of his success. By any customary measure of accomplishment for a businessman, he was a success. He employed three terrific support staff and his generosity allowed each of them to have financial security along with an excellent work environment. But more than the financial aspect of his agency, he felt he and his staff provided a valuable service to the community. Thinking back to that fateful day, he allowed that same feeling of anger to well up inside him again. In a way, he was mad at himself too. Had he taken a stand early in his career, he might have made the decision to leave much sooner, sparing him what he now considered to be wasted years. Instead, he allowed his actions and business goals to be defined by Allstate. He had trusted a company that had never given him as much as he had given it. That would never happen again. Now, as he turned the corner to walk back to where he lived, he knew he would be making an even bigger, more dramatic turn in his life. Earlier that day he had sent his resignation to his manager via email. He informed him that he would be opening a true independent agency “more than a mile” from his old Allstate office. He even told his manager he would be happier in his new endeavor, in spite of the dire warnings he had received in past conversations with him. Crossing the street, he slowed his pace a bit as he approached the sidewalk leading to his house. The grin that had occupied his face during his walk grew even larger. Pausing to stare at his house, he knew for the first time that just like his house, he could pass his agency on to his children if that is what he wanted to do. On his approval only, he could enrich the lives of his kids with the simple act of love that knew no constraints. His agency would finally be his and only his. For the first time in years, he had smelled the fresh scented air and took notice of his surroundings. The fresh air on his walk that day stimulated his senses and filled him with possible solutions. Was this an unexpected awakening for him, or had the air always held the “possibilities” that he was now just discovering? Suddenly, he realized that he had just not been able to “see” them until he freed himself from the restraints of his inner and outer demons. Opening his front door, he held his head higher than he had in a long time. He now understood that the truest measure of success could only come from within. He also knew that whatever lay ahead, only he would be able to affect the outcome. He would use these two simple truths to guide him the rest of his life. Ef Fall 2012 humour Name Changes… Oops, I Mean “Moniker Alterations” By Brian Spillman IONAL! S U L E D Expected Results A llstate is big on name changes these days. Instead of “Pro Shops,” we now have “Good Hands Repair Networks.” Instead of Motor Club, we now have “Good Hands Roadside.” Instead of homeowners Insurance, we have “House and Home.” C’mon, House and Home? Isn’t that like calling it Home and Home or House and House? All of this not-so-clever name-changing is either a sign of desperation or a way to keep managers employed. Well, Allstate doesn’t really care about anyone keeping their jobs, so I’ve got to go with desperation here. Since I sold my agency effective June Fall 2012 1st, I’ve decided I would like to be hired by the name-changing division at Allstate. Then I could change names based on agency perspectives, using input from agents. Here’s a sample of what I would bring to the table, so please consider this my application for this position. “Expected Results” should be changed to “Delusional Results.” Other names I would consider: “Random Results,” “Unexpected Results,” and “You’ve Gotta Be Kidding Me!” The new homeowner product, which includes whopping tropical cyclone deductibles and no replacement cost on roofs over 10 years old, should be changed from “House and Home” to “Moderate Assistance Insurance.” The runner-up was “I Have to Pay what?!” As a side note, I suggest we hand out smelling salts with every new policy in the event the customer comprehends the Tropical Cyclone Deductible (TCD). “Exclusive Agent,” which is sort of like a franchise, but not really, will be changed to “Disenfranchised Agent.” I feel this name better reflects the position. “Non-Qualifying Agents,” who don’t meet their year-end goals, should be referred to as “Infidels.” Licensed Sales Producers should be renamed “Risk Magicians,” since it better defines the role of encouraging customers to take on more risk by switching to Allstate. “Tropical Cyclone Deductible” should be changed to “Gotcha!” I would also consider using “Read the Fine Print,” but that lacks the soul-crushing snap that “Gotcha!” brings to the table when the deductible applies. My suggestion for Woople? How about “Poople?” It seems to be the most appropriate word to describe some of the inane material presented in those crazy videos. Other suggestions I considered were “Stinkle,” and “Suckle.” The Commercial Department needs to change its name to the “Risk Aversion Department.” As I write this article, I think the only risk we accept is hair salons, and that’s only if they don’t use scissors! Everything else goes to Northeast, Northwest, or Butwin. But why stop here? I’ve been leading up to the biggest name change of all. I suggest changing the entire company name to better reflect its awesome potential and future direction. “Allstate Insurance” should be changed to “Titanic Insurance Company.” Needless to say, I probably won’t be hired for the name-changer gig. That’s clear to me now. Ef Exclusivefocus — 51 NAPAA Membership Puts Money in Your Pocket T here are many benefits to NAPAA’s affiliation with the Office and Professional Employees International Union (OPEIU). In addition to the strength that comes with being part of an organization with more than 108,000 members and the legislative and legal support it offers, there are a number of membership perks that can put money directly into your pocket. Among these benefits is the Errors and Omissions Deductible Subsidy, which reimburses members 20 percent of their deductible for any E&O claim paid, up to $500 per member per year. Members taking advantage of this benefit have been pleased with how quick and easy it is to collect their reimbursement checks. “NAPAA membership has very real and tangible benefits when you have something like the E&O subsidy,” said a satisfied agent from New Jersey. “The $200 payment I received is more than half of the NAPAA membership fees. It almost pays for my membership right there!” Clearly delighted, he added, “The bottom line is that NAPAA membership really pays dividends.” NAPAA membership also includes other unique benefits, one of which is a unique subsidy program that provides a $50 payment for continuing education every two years. Filing for these benefits is simple and easy. Applications for both the E&O and the Continuing Education subsidy are available at www.napaaUSA.org. But the list of benefits doesn’t end there. As a NAPAA member, you are entitled to a free comprehensive defense against identity theft – the fastest growing crime in the United States. Identity theft affects one in twenty households, costs businesses billions of dollars every year and, on average, takes 165 hours for a victim to regain pre-theft status. In the event of identity theft, NAPAA members will be restored to “pre-victim” status, with a fully managed recovery provider that could save you hundreds of hours of your own time, productivity and money. If you are a member and haven’t already registered for the free ID theft program, you are encouraged to do so as soon as possible by visiting http://promos.privacymaxx.com/opeiu/. You can also register via phone by calling 888-247-9441. NAPAA membership also provides access to the Perks national discount savings program, a towing program that includes two towing/service calls per year (valued at up to $100 each and applicable to all family members living in the same household), educational scholarships, and much more. Take advantage of these great member benefits today. If you’re not a NAPAA member, sign up by completing the application found elsewhere in this magazine or by visiting www.napaaUSA.org. Ef RHINOTEK Providing Premium Imaging Supplies for Over 28 Years! RHINOTEK is a preferred NAPAA supplier for ink and toner products. Great Savings - Group Buying Discounts Guaranteed Quality - Higher Page Yields Free Shipping - 30 Day Net Terms Help the Environment - Save the Rhino We provide our customers with value every step of the way! • A vast selection of 6500 compatible and OEM imaging supplies • Over 28 years as an industry leader of premium inkjet and toner supplies • High-quality output, vivid colors and exceptional yields • Compelling price to performance value • A knowledgeable sales team focused on your growth through savings TRYING TO SAVE MONEY BY MAKING WISE PURCHASING DECISIONS? A RHINOTEK NEW LIFE PRINTER and PREMIUM TONER CARTRIDGE IS YOUR BEST SOLUTION. Part Number Product Description NA13MS-Q5927A RHINOTEK CERTIFIED PRE-OWNED HP LaserJet 1320 with 13 Month Warranty NAPAA Price $255 QH-1320 RHINOTEK Compatible HP Laserjet Black Toner Cartridge - 7000 yield $72 Call your representative today at (800) 695-RHINO for special NAPAA pricing on all Rhinotek branded ink, toner and maintenance kits. Don’t forget to ask about our complete line of Certified Pre-Owned New Life Printers. Rhintotek Computer Products, Inc. 2301 E. Del Amo Blvd., Carson, CA 90220 (800) 695-RHINO www.rhinotek.com/napaa.htm 52 — Exclusivefocus Fall 2012 Confidential NAPAA Membership Application Name:______________________________________ Off Ph:_______________________ Cell__________________________ Street:________________________________________________ E-Mail:__________________________________________ City:________________________________________ State:_____ ZIP:__________ Agent since__________(year) Comment? MEMBERSHIP SECTION Regular (Gold) Membership q Annual: $350 Elite Membership (includes Producer Online Subscription) q Annual: $475 To Activate Producer Online Subscription only: q EFT: $29 /mo q EFT: $39 /mo User Name _____________ Password _____________ PAYMENT SECTION q CHECK – Annual: Please make payable to NAPAA. q CREDIT CARD – Annual: I authorize this amount to be charged to my credit card. (Please complete the information below) Card type: q VISA q MasterCard q Discover q American Express Name on account _________________________________________ Amount to be Charged: $__________ (Annual only) Account Number __________________________________________ Expiration date __________ Security code________ Address on Card _______________________________________________________________________ ZIP____________ Signature of Cardholder _______________________________________________ Todays Date _____________ (1/12 EF) q EFT (PAM) - Monthly (attach or fax voided check) I understand that the amount stated above will be deducted from my checking account every month until instructed otherwise. I have enclosed a voided check and understand that the withdrawals will occur on or about the 20th of every month. Authorization Signature: _____________________________________________________________ Date ____________ PLEASE FAX or MAIL APPLICATION TO: National Association of Professional Allstate Agents, Inc. P. O. Box 7666, Gulfport, MS 39506-7666 Call Toll-free: 877.627.2248 • E-Mail: HQ@napaausa.org • Fax Toll-free: 866.627.2232 Please include your generous donation to the NAPAA Action Fund Fall 2012 Exclusivefocus — 53 technology Part 2: Has ALSTAR Support Ever Told You to Contact Your Own IT Support? By Dan Helton I n our previous article, we discussed how to correctly connect everything hardware-wise. Now I will talk more about how your network needs to be configured properly in Windows so that you have access to your Public Drive, or “P” drive, and shared printers. How your Network should be Configured First, all of the PCs in your network have to be in the same workgroup or 54 — Exclusivefocus domain. Domains are more for big companies that have their own logon servers and many more computers than most Allstate offices have. Domains require a separate server to hold the login IDs for the company and the servers are very expensive. So for most Allstate offices, the correct network configuration is the workgroup model. In the workgroup model, each computer maintains its own list of login IDs for users and all computers must be added to the workgroup. When I was converting agent offices, I used the location code, or “booth code,” as the workgroup name for each agency. For instance, if an agent’s Booth Code was IL698, I would set the workgroup for each computer to IL698. Then I would set the PC Names to be IL698-PC01, IL698-PC02 and so on. On the primary PC, designated as PC #1, I would add all of the user names in the office. All of the other PCs usually only had one user, so, besides the Administrator account, only one user was listed. Each user name must also have a password. If a user sets their password to be blank, the networking will not work. Plus, it is always advisable to have a password associated with each user name. If someone breaks into your office and steals your PCs, a PC with no password allows the thief to access to all files on that PC. On each of the other PCs, the user names and passwords must be the same as were entered on PC #1. Then on PC #1, the file folder that is being used as the Public Drive must be shared with the network. Each of the other network PCs which will share that folder must then be mapped to the Public Drive. After this is done, all network PCs can share files by simply putting the file to be shared into the Public Drive. Another thing that I do is enable the Administrator Account on all of the computers and assign a password to this account. I generally do not give out this password to anyone unless it is absolutely necessary. This way, if a computer is compromised with viruses or malicious software, another account is available to log into the affected computer, which Fall 2012 can usually be fixed by using the additional account. It is complicated to get into more specifics without going into much greater detail, which we don’t have space for in this article. This is especially true since some agent offices are using PCs with Windows XP, and some use Windows Vista, and still others are using Windows 7. The set-up configuration is a little different for each of these operating systems. Note: The login User IDs and Passwords I referred to above have nothing to do with the User ID and Password that an agent uses to login to the Allstate Gateway; they only have to sign in after the PC is first turned on. Different Operating Systems When Allstate forced its agents to convert to their own computers, it came out with a list of minimum requirements. At the time, the only operating systems that were on the market were Windows XP and Windows Vista. There were previous versions of Windows, but none of those met the minimum specifications that Allstate required. In 2010, Microsoft rolled out Windows 7. Windows XP had a Home edition, a Professional edition and a Media Center edition. Only the Professional and the Media Center editions had the required networking capability. Windows Vista had 4 versions: Vista Home Basic, Vista Home Premium, Vista Business and Vista Ultimate. Only Vista Business and Vista Ultimate had networking capability. That is why Allstate required you to have Windows XP Professional or Windows Vista Business as a minimum. Without networking capability, you would not be able to use the Public Drive, or share printers. Windows 7 has 4 versions: Windows 7 Home Basic, Windows 7 Home Premium, Windows 7 Professional and Windows 7 Ultimate. Only Windows 7 Professional and Windows 7 Ultimate have the networking capability. If you go out and buy a PC or laptop, chances are you will get a PC with Windows 7 Home Premium. This means for you to be able to use it in your office, you will have to upgrade it to one of the Windows 7 versions that have the networking capability. Fall 2012 This article was written at the end of August, 2012. If you must buy a new PC immediately, it is likely that the only operating system they can sell right now is Windows 7, so be sure to ask if the PC you are buying can support being upgraded to either Windows 7 Professional or Windows 7 Ultimate. You may have to pay a little more to have them load it with one of these networking capable operating systems, but it will save you a whole lot of headaches in the long run to do so. On the other hand, if your need is not urgent, you may want to wait for Windows 8, which should be released sometime this fall – maybe by the time you receive this issue of Exclusivefocus. To make matters even more confusing, each of the Windows Operating Systems has a 32-bit version and a 64bit version. Most PCs on the market at the time Allstate was doing the conversions had standard Pentium 4 Processors in them. Around the same time, PC makers were coming out with systems that contained the next line of processors from Intel called the Core 2 Duo. In simple language, the Core 2 Duo processors consist of twin Pentium 4 processors that are incorporated into a single chip. In accomplishing this, the Core 2 Duo processor was able to handle instructions that are 64 bits long, whereas the standard Pentium 4 processor could only handle instructions that were 32 bits long. Thus, to keep up with this new technology, Microsoft created both 32bit and 64-bit versions of their operating systems. At the time of the technology conversions, not many software vendors had written programs to work correctly on the 64-bit versions of the Windows Operating Systems, which included the Allstate Gateway programs. Hence, Allstate only required that agents buy the 32-bit versions of Windows XP or Windows Vista. Presently, Allstate and most other software companies have now made their software compatible to work on these 64-bit versions of the operating systems. Another Allstate requirement is that PCs have Microsoft Office Small Business 2007 or greater. I have found that many people confuse Microsoft Office with the Microsoft Windows operating system. The operating system is what controls how you log into the computer, PC networking, and all of the other software programs you load onto a PC. Microsoft Office is a suite of software programs that you load as a package onto the PC after the operating system is installed. Microsoft Office contains many Microsoft programs such as Word, for writing letters and other documents, Excel, used for creating spread sheets, Publisher for creating publications, Access for creating databases, Outlook for sending and receiving e-mail, Power Point for creating slide show presentations, Picture Viewer for viewing pictures, and some other tools for scanning and printing documents that you create using the programs in the MS Office Suite. As with the Microsoft Windows operating systems, Office also has different versions that determine which of the above listed programs are included in the MS Office Suite that you buy. In 2010, Microsoft came out with Microsoft Office 2010. For legal reasons, vendors that sell PCs can no longer load a PC with the Microsoft Office programs unless purchased in advance. So, what you will get when you buy a PC from a retail store is a 90-day trial version of the 2010 Office Suite. After the trial period, you will be required to either purchase it online or install another program that will allow you to access any files you created during the trial period. Since 2000, every time Microsoft has come out with a new Windows operating system, it has also released a new version of the MS Office Suite. This was so the Office Programs would work best with the new operating system. Below is a list of which release of MS Office was released with which operating system: • W indows 2000 – Microsoft Office 2000 • Windows XP – Microsoft Office 2003 • Windows Vista – Microsoft Office 2007 • Windows 7 – Microsoft Office 2010 • Windows 8 – Microsoft Office 2012 (fall 2012 release expected) Although there were earlier releases Exclusivefocus — 55 than those listed above, I don’t know of anyone still using a Windows operating system lower than Windows XP. As of January 2010, Microsoft says they no longer support Windows XP, but they still provide Windows Updates for it. And Allstate’s minimum requirements list Windows XP as the oldest operating system that will work with its Gateway programs. Within each release of Microsoft Office there were also different versions. Each version offered variations of which MS Office programs were included in the package. To get a full listing of all of the different versions of each release and which programs are included, go to the following URL: http://en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/History_of_Microsoft_Office. Other Required Allstate PC Software Allstate also requires that some other software be installed on your PCs so that the Gateway programs function properly. All of this software is free on the Internet and are listed below. Allstate also has a website where you can easily download all of these programs. The URL is gatewaysupport.allstate.com. When entering the address in your browser, do not preface with the standard “www.;” just clear the browser address bar and type the address exactly as shown. The Allstate Gateway Support site also lists the minimum requirements for PCs and software that Allstate requires. Here are the other programs that Allstate requires: • Allstate GO Gateway: Installs the Allstate Gateway access program and sets browser settings. Also installs the Gateway icon and the Gateway Support icon on your desktop. • Adobe Acrobat Reader: Allows you to view PDF files. • Adobe Shockwave: Allows you to view animation and other multimedia web content. • Adobe Flash Player: Also allows you to view certain multimedia web content. • Citrix Web Client: Client software allowing you to access to the AS/400based Alstar Program. • Java: Allows you to view certain 56 — Exclusivefocus web content in your web browser. • MS Directx: A collection of application programming interfaces (APIs) that handle tasks related to viewing multimedia and video content. Anti-Virus and firewall software is also a requirement. A firewall is software that determines which IP addresses and ports are allowed access to your PC. This software essentially filters out IP addresses, ports and websites that should not be allowed into your PC. Microsoft Windows has a built-in firewall. Many antivirus software packages replace the Windows firewall when you install them. I recommend using antivirus software that does not do this or gives you the option of not installing the firewall. There are many different antivirus software companies. The top three rated are AVG, Bit Defender and Kaspersky. I personally recommend using AVG or Microsoft Security Essentials, which came out in early 2012. I know most people prefer Norton, McAfee or Trend Micro, but they automatically install firewalls that block remote connections, causing me to waste a lot of time talking the user through the steps of shutting off their firewall so that I can begin to remotely fix their computer problems. And some versions of Norton and McAfee are problematic. They can be very hard to get rid of because the software installs itself in many different places in your computer. Hence, when the user wants to change antivirus providers, it becomes a major project to remove the software. AVG offers a free version and a paid version. The paid version has many more features, but some of these features block you from going to a few of the websites that are used with Allstate programs. Consequently, I now recommend using the free version. It does not block me when I need to remote into a customer’s computer, and it is easy to uninstall. The paid version is only around $40.00 per year, and you can get even better deals if you go through a vendor. Microsoft Security Essentials is free antivirus software that automatically updates itself when you do Windows updates. I will be testing it and let you know my evaluation of it in coming articles. Printers Setup and Usage As stated in the previous section, Allstate’s minimum specifications require you to use a Windows Operating system that is networking capable. This also makes it possible for you to share printers. Let’s say you have more PCs in your office than printers, or you have a printer that has a mechanical failure. By sharing any of the printers attached to one of the other PCs in your office, you allow a PC without a printer attached to print to one of the other printers in the office. The first thing you need to do when setting up a PC with a local printer is to make sure the printer is fully functional all by itself. Most printers are capable of running a self-test. With most HP printers, which Allstate has used for many years, you simply have to hold down a button while you are powering up the printer. The button to hold down varies with printer make and model and should print out a self-test page. The test also verifies that the toner or ink cartridge is installed properly, that there is paper in the printer and that all mechanical functions of the printer are working correctly. Next you need to install the correct printer driver for the PC. To do this, you need to know which Windows operating system you are using, and whether it is the 32-bit version or the 64-bit version. To find this information, go to the Start button on your computer desktop; two columns will appear. The left column will have programs, and the right column will have short-cuts to other things in the operating system. If you are using Windows XP, look for “My Computer” in the list on the right. If you are using Windows Vista or Windows 7, look for the item listed as “Computer” in the right-hand column. Click once on “My Computer” or on “Computer” in order to highlight your selection; then rightclick and a menu will pop-up. Click on the “Properties” option and a window, called “System Properties,” will open up and you will be in the “General” tab of the Window. The first section listed is “System,” and describes which operating system you have and the version you are using. For example, if the top line reads, Windows XP, the next line might read Home Edition, followed by the next line, Fall 2012 which might read Version 2002. Also, if it does not indicate that you have the 64bit version, you have the 32-bit version. If you have a HP LaserJet Printer, I recommend you go to the HP website download the correct driver for your printer. If you have another manufacturer’s printer, I suggest you go to their website to get the correct driver. Printer driver installation varies from printer to printer and from manufacturer to manufacturer, so it is impossible for me to go into the specifics in this article for installing all printers. If you do not know how to download and install a printer driver, there are many ways you can get help doing this. Google is one source, or you can contact the manufacturer of the printer and they may help you for a fee. Alstar Support is another option, but if they can’t help, you can always contact an independent computer support service for assistance. Once you have the driver downloaded and installed, the printer must be “shared” in order for other computers in the workgroup to be able to print to it. To share the printer, you need to go into your computer’s “Control Panel” and locate the “Printers” icon. It is important to note here that the Windows Control Panel has two different views. One is called “Category View” and the other is called “Classic View.” Classic View displays individual icons for each item and Category View lists categories in text. On either screen, you are given the option to switch from one view to the other. This option can be found on the far left-hand side of the screen. Windows Vista is a bit different, as the area to the left will say Control Panel Home, and Classic View. In Windows 7, the way you switch views is to open the Control Panel. In the top right-hand side of the main part of the window will be a drop-down box labeled “View by,” which will allow you to switch between Category View, Large Icons or Small Icons. The whole purpose of my going into this is to get you to the Classic View in XP or Vista or the Large Icons View in Windows 7, making it easier for you to select the Printers icon. Now you should be able to open the Control Panel and switch to the view where the main part of the control panel Fall 2012 window has icons. Scroll down if necessary and double click on the Printers icon. Another window will open and the printer you just installed the driver for should be displayed there. Only one of the printers listed will have a check mark next to it, indicating that it is the “default” printer, which means that Windows and other programs will automatically print to it when you are in a program and hit the print button. If the printer just installed does not have this check mark, click once on the printer to select it and then right-click your mouse and another pop-up Menu will appear. Usually, the second Item in this menu will say, “Set as Default.” You will want to select this option and the check mark should move to this new printer. Next, right-click on this printer again and the menu will pop-up once more; go to the very bottom of the menu and select “Properties.” The Printer Properties window will come up and you will be in the General tab. On this page there should be a button that says “Print a Test Page.” Click this button and a Windows test page should print out. This verifies that the printer is correctly connected to the PC, the printer driver is correctly installed and Windows can print to this printer. In the Printer Properties window, you’ll see several other tabs. Now you’ll want to click on the tab labeled “Sharing.” Then click the radial button labeled “Share this Printer.” Leave the name the same and click OK at the bottom. Your printer will now appear with both the check mark and have a picture of a hand under it. The picture of the hand under the printer indicates it is shared. Now go to another PC in the office that does not have a printer attached to it. If using Windows XP, click on “Start” and then on “My Network Places.” A window will open and over on the left-hand side of the main window under “Other Places,” you’ll want to select “Entire Network.” Then double-click on “Microsoft Windows Network” and the workgroup name set for your office should appear in the main window. Double-Click on this workgroup and the main window should show all computers that are powered on in the office. Double-click on the computer that has the shared printer. The window will change again and the printer will appear along with any other folders that are shared on this computer. You should then right-click on the printer and select “Connect.” Now if you go back to the Control Panel and select the Printers icon, the networked printer should appear in this folder. You will note that it appears a bit differently than it did on the PC where it was initially installed. What you will see is an icon that represents a network printer. You should be able to right-click on it, go to the Properties page for the printer and click on the “print a test page” button as you did before. Also, you should be able to right-click on the printer and choose the “Set as Default” option as well. I’m sure this article may have been difficult to follow at times, but if you plan to set up your own printers, it will make much more sense once you get started. Just remember to take it step by step and you’ll be fine. Ef Dan Helton has worked in the computer industry 32 years. Since 1995, he has worked almost exclusively with Allstate agencies handling their technology needs. In 2001, Dan started WECUSS International, a computer support company offering remote technical support to Allstate agents nationwide. For more information, call (877) 993-2877 or (877) 9WE-CUSS. Exclusivefocus — 57 letters to NAPAA Continued from page 10. Thanks for the “heads up” about The Kindness Revolution. I am looking forward to talking with them. By the way, tell Nancy she has my vote to go toe-to-toe with Tommy anytime. Editor’s response: I’ll tell Nancy to sharpen her claws for the next shareholders meeting. As always, I read the last Exclusivefocus from cover to cover. Over the past year, NAPAA has promoted its alliance with the union. I always thought the purpose of affiliating was the power that the union body brings to the table. NAPAA, in order to further its cause, not only needs to operate from a position of strength by adding more members, but rank and file union members must also have a clear understanding of our movement so they are willing to champion our cause and show solidarity. Now I am a bit confused because it sounds like you are telling us that Tom Wilson is untouchable and Allstate can do “whatever we want.” With the lower commissions, SRM6, new inspections, etc., the company does not care about their customers, only stockholders. This is a perfect time for a media blitz from the union and NAPAA wherein union members let it be known that they are willing to support the agents that support NAPAA. There are millions of union members out there and if they all said, “I will only buy Allstate from a NAPAA member,” it would send a powerful message to the company. Our region is going to introduce the new House & Home product and we have been told that the modeling is already underpriced and a rate change is in the works. We also had a meeting on SRM6 and we were told that the compa58 — Exclusivefocus ny is rerunning credit. I can’t rerun credit without permission, how can Allstate? These are issues that affect us daily and if you KEEP addressing the small issues that drive us crazy, you will pick up support. My agency is growing nicely. I sure don’t miss the cesspool at Allstate. Seems everybody there is miserable. One of our more active referral sources called last week and said they haven’t written a single Allstate policy in six days. Everything they’ve written was in the Expanded Market program. He’s a good producer, so that’s just unheard of for him. That’s pretty scary. Our loss ratios are excellent. With our primary property carrier we actually have a negative L/R. How cool is that? I am so happy when I get those kinds of visits from company reps. They also thank us for any and all business we submit, which is so different from Allstate where we had to constantly jump through hoops and when we did, we rarely ever got any thanks or recognition. I don’t miss that nonsense at all. I still shake my head daily at some of the stories and posts on ABB. I guess some folks just have thicker heads or more patience than I do. My only regret is that I didn’t take TPP the day they announced the homeowner non-renewals back in 2005. I should have taken my kaching and ran like hell. I just hope the agents who are struggling find peace either with staying or leaving. Making the decision is the hardest part. After that, it’s a cakewalk. My agency is in pretty good shape now. I’ve been at this for three years and I am earning as much now as I was at Allstate after 13 years. I can’t whine about that. All in all, I am so happy I made the change… things are really good for me on this side of the fence. The only downside is that I miss you guys! Thank you for including me [in The Kindness Revolution notification]. I apologize, but whenever I get a message from anyone whom I don’t know personally, saying that I have been selected or are among a select group, I get a bit skeptical. How is it that my agency was chosen to be in the first 60 to be offered this opportunity? Editor’s response: Quite honestly, I remembered that you appeared to have a keen social conscience as evidenced by your disapproval of the prisoner train we depicted on the cover of Exclusivefocus magazine a couple of years ago. Our goal for The Kindness Revolution was to choose agents that we believed would be sincere advocates of the principles of kindness. I felt you demonstrated that virtue when you spoke out against the cover of the magazine. I sat down and read the letters section in the last edition of Exclusivefocus a hundred times, if not more. It is clear Allstate is not at all concerned about its agents – or shall we say, soon-to-be exagents – and even less concerned about its customers. I have decided to leave Allstate and continue my insurance career as an independent agent for many of the same reasons as other agents have cited in your magazine. I feel that Allstate has not provided the level of support they committed to and it has become increasingly frustrating to deal with them on a daily basis. At the meeting with my FSL on July 5th, I was told that I would most likely be released from my contract without having to serve out the 90-day period as required. More than a week later, I received a phone call, as well as an email, informing me that I would need to serve out the 90-day period and terminate at the end of September. Then yesterday, I Fall 2012 was informed by email that I would be released at the end of October. As you can imagine, this development will have a severe impact on my financial situation, as it will be impossible to continue writing business for Allstate during this period. It will most likely also have a negative impact on my health, having recently undergone a heart procedure. Worst of all, what about the customers? I opened my Allstate agency earlier this year and took over a book of business from an agent who was only with the company for less than six month. Now instead of Allstate putting the customer first, they have decided to play kindergarten games to teach me a lesson. I am no fool, but I am inclined to write a letter to my FSVP with a copy to Tom Wilson about the ethical problems we seem to have in our state. I plan to point out the conviction dates of several agents and managers who have been fined by the state for lying, cheating and for defrauding the state department of insurance in a continuing education scam. Of particular concern is the fact that the company gave two of these criminal agents 609000 accounts. Two other agents have been reported to local management for falsifying applications. But instead of terminating them, some of them were rewarded with 609000 accounts! This is very distressing to see what is happening to our company, especially after seeing honest long-term agents terminated for missing their Expected Results quotas. This is common knowledge in the field. Should I sell before I report this or do it now? Editor’s response: Before you report anything, first be sure you have all the facts straight. Then instead of writing to your FSVP and copying Tom Wilson, you might want to file a report using the Allstate i-Report process, which is the proper procedure to use in cases like this. It would not be surprising if your FSVP tried to sweep this under the rug, as he is held accountable for things that happen in his region. If Tom Wilson did see your letter, he would likely refer it back to the region for resolution. There is also a chance that your letter would never make Fall 2012 it past his secretary. To file a confidential i-Report with the Alert Line, go to www. AlertLine.com or call 800-427-9389. In my state, the termination carnage affected 75% or more of all the agents over 55 years old. Profitability, retention and honesty were disregarded. All that mattered were new sales and a speck of growth. Honest agents who walked bad business were given their pink slips, leaving the unscrupulous behind to mind the store. Imagine what will happen to the quality of the state’s book of business with these morally challenged hooligans in charge. As for me, I refuse to cheat, just to write a few lousy apps. I have been a successful agent over the years, but I cannot be a part of this anymore. The lies and deceit are too much for any moral person to endure. As for my still-ethical peers who remain, I wish you the very best. In my last two years with Allstate I became ill. My nerves got to me and I couldn’t sleep. It was like I was all used up and had no more to give – I was completely drained and became a physical and mental mess. With all the threats and demands from management I was overwhelmed. Today, after undergoing weeks of tests, I found out that I’ve had several mini-strokes, that I have an irregular heartbeat and other stress-related health issues. The bottom line is that if I had stayed with Allstate, I would not be here today. Allstate is a chapter in my life that I have closed and do not want to think about. The company cares nothing about its agents; they still want to run peoples’ lives via Scientology. It is a shame that every agent has allowed this to happen. I know, I know, I was one of the agents that allowed it all to happen. I guess we were all afraid we would lose our jobs, but in the end, most of us lost them anyway. It sickens me to see what the company has done to so many of good people. I truly wish the best for the remaining agents. Fair warning though, the management are all liars. I am so glad I don’t have to put up with their bullshit any longer. Letters and articles submitted to NAPAA may be edited for clarity, space, grammar, syntax and suitability. Names of agent contributors will only be published with writer’s permission. Letters and other submissions can be e-mailed to Exclusivefocus@napaaUSA.org or mailed to: NAPAA, P.O. Box 7666, Gulfport, MS 39506 Exclusivefocus — 59 the NAPAA market place Agencies for Sale Arizona Green Valley Brad Balmer bradbalmer@allstate.com 520-400-3097 Asking Price: $240,000 PIF: 1,557 Premium: $1,205,000 Number of Staff: 2 Low overhead. L/R 27%, Retention 89%, Only EA within 25 miles. Scottsdale Rob robertocammarata@msn.com 480-734-7574 Asking Price: $524,950 PIF: 2,891 Premium: $2,455,000 Number of Staff: 3 81 ALI, 85% retention Tucson Agencies for Sale Port Orange Bert Daniel rsdanielinc@cfl.rr.com 386-547-0220 Asking Price: Negotiable PIF & Premium: Call for details Number of Staff: 3 87% retention, 47% LR. Same location 20 years. A070725@ALLSTATE.COM 520-744-3994 Asking Price: $375,000 PIF: 1,518 Premium: $1,515,114 Number of Staff: 1 Prime area, easy to find, same location over 10 years. 35 yr agent. Colorado Colorado Springs Steven R Nelson ph7196608711@gmail.com 719-634-2106 Asking Price: 2X PIF: 745 Premium: $742,000 Number of Staff: 1 Connecticut East Haven Douglas M Hughes douglashughes@allstate.com 203-469-2289 Asking Price: Call PIF: 2,202 Premium: $2,783,289 Number of Staff: 1 ALI over 90 Florida Naples, Florida Cynthia Hill McIntosh cmcintosh@allstate.com 239-434-7877 Asking Price: $450,000 PIF & Premium: Call for details Number of Staff: 1 60 — Exclusivefocus Tifton Georgia Private insforsale@hotmail.com 229-382-0550 Asking Price: $450,000 PIF: 1,677 Premium: $1,800,000 Established 1998. 90% retention. Saint Cloud Macon Marilyn Cochran Private MaJaPa10@AOL.com 407-922-9471 Asking Price: $450,000 PIF: 1,500 Premium: $1,500,000 Number of Staff: 3 Figures listed are rounded mel@sammconsulting.com 678-223-7397 Asking Price: Negotiable PIF: 4,300 Premium: $4,700,000 Number of Staff: 5 Incredible team of agents. Retention 90%. Deland Denny Cowart Harold Broc Broccoletti Agencies for Sale denniscowart@allstate.com 386-734-6551 Asking Price: $575,000 PIF & Premium: Call for details Number of Staff: 1 27 yr agency, 48% LR, 94% Prop Retention, 89% Auto Retention Haines City Carol Eddy CarolEddy@allstate.com 863-860-9555 Asking Price: $600,000 PIF: 1,740 Premium: $2,400,000 Number of Staff: 2 Retiring after 27 years. Same location since 1995. Miami Arnoldo Arguello ArguelloArnoldo@gmail.com 786-499-3415 Asking Price: Please call PIF: 3,000 Premium: $4,000,000 Number of Staff: 3 22 year agent. Retention: 85%, LR: 50%, ALI 81 Kissimmee Dale Revels Gwinnett County Private mel@sammconsulting.com 678-223-7397 Asking Price: Negotiable PIF: 4,000 Premium: $4,200,000 Number of Staff: 2 Market leading agency, branded Allstate office, lease $1250 per month. Retention 90%. Albany Private mel@sammconsulting.com 678-223-7397 Asking Price: Negotiable PIF: 866 Premium: $1,000,000 Number of Staff: 1 Established 2006. I am changing industries to pursue other interests. Tyrone Brad Gohsman gohs31392@msn.com 770-487-1112 Asking Price: $475,000 PIF: 1,850 Premium: $1,450,704 Number of Staff: 2 25 yr agency, reasonable rent, low LR, high retention. Agencies for Sale Illinois Hickory Hills Bryant Harris BRYKATH@comcast.net 708-254-4629 Asking Price: $499,000 PIF: 2,412 Premium: $2,043,000 Number of Staff: 2 Same location 17 yrs. Retention 87, ALI 74 Indiana New Castle Janet Begley jbegley1127@att.net 765-623-6432 Asking Price: $325,000 PIF: 1,305 Premium: $1,320,918 Number of Staff: 1 LR 51, Retention 82.2, 25 yr agent Maryland Several locations Ed Hogg (Rep) ehogg9@gmail.com 703-862-8168 Asking Price: Negotiable PIF: Premium: Call for info Seller Rep, several locations, call for details Glen Burnie Catherine Sorrell cbsagent@aol.com 410-768-4446 Asking Price: $1,115,000 PIF: 3,027 Premium: $3,714,000 Number of Staff: 2 Retention 90.1, LR: 44.5, ALI 85 Nevada Las Vegas Howard M Shaw howardmshaw@allstate.com 702-365-1392 Asking Price: $472,500 PIF: 1,574 Premium: $2,100,000 Number of Staff: 3 Retiring after 34 years. ALI 90. Retention 92.3, LR 49.4. dalerevels@gmail.com 407-924-5336 Asking Price: Please call PIF: & Premium: Call for info Number of Staff: 1 Fall 2012 the NAPAA market place Agencies for Sale Agencies for Sale New York Oklahoma Brooklyn Barbara Shamah Leeds barbararose583@aol.com 917-301-2477 Asking Price: Please call PIF: 1,758 Premium: $4,600,000 Number of Staff: 3 Best location in Brooklyn, 30 yr agent retiring Brooklyn Yuri Kibardin yuri.kibardin@yahoo.com 646-270-8021 Asking Price: $625,000 PIF: 1,581 Premium: $3,127,742 Number of Staff: 3 North Carolina Durham Sherwood Smith ncrosewood@hotmail.com 919-801-1221 Asking Price: $180,000 PIF: 1,570 Premium: $999,999 Number of Staff: 1 Asheville Mike Gentilini gentilini@bellsouth.net 828-712-0707 Asking Price: Negotiable PIF: 3,900 Premium: $3,234,000 Number of Staff: 4 31 year agency in beautiful Blue Ridge Mountains. Option to purchase or lease office, F&E (7 workstations) included. LR 39, retention 90+. Pisgah Forest Leca Harris D! lecaharris@allstate.com SOL 828-606-9515 Asking Price: Call PIF: 2,112 Premium: $1,725,000 North Dakota Grand Forks Leland Jelinek ljelinek2@gra.midco.net ALE ! S G 701-746-9330 DIN ENNegotiable Asking P Price: PIF: 1,227 Premium: $1,000,000 Fall 2012 Norman Louis Hemphill louishemphill@allstate.com E SAL G! 405 -360-7656 I D N call ENPlease AskingP Price: PIF: 2,000 Premium: $2,000,000 Pennsylvania Pittsburgh Lawrence Ross Agency LarryRoss67@gmail.com Asking Price: Negotiable PIF: 2,636 Premium: $2,522,201 Number of Staff: 1 Retention 91%, LR 45.27, Policies /HH: 2.08. 23 years, in professional area of Pleasant Hills. Premium does not included brokered business. No Phone Calls please email. Philadelphia Michael Phillips michael.phillips@allstate.com 484-571-7646 Asking Price: Negotiable PIF: 2,441 Premium: $2,673,000 Number of Staff: 3 12 yr agent, HH Ret 90%+ Denton Texas Steve Sullivan steve@thesullivanagency.com 940-566-2234 Asking Price: $400,000 PIF: 1,156 Premium: $1,600,000 Number of Staff: 1 Good location, inexpensive rent, good signage, largest growing county in Texas. Austin Blake Simpson blakesimpson@allstate.com 512-923-3004 Asking Price: $465,000 PIF & Premium: call for details Number of Staff: 1 Retention 92.2, LR 53.64, HH 680. Rent is $650 including utilities. Please contact via email, or after 5:30 by phone. Agencies for Sale Agencies for Sale Virginia Austin Springfield Lee zaubyaj@yahoo.com 512-630-6699 Asking Price: $770,000 PIF: 3,047 Premium: $3,200,000 Number of Staff: 1.5 Established 1989, two books combine for 3.2 million, 2.5 miles apart. Approved for merger. Utah Spanish Fork Mark Peterson petersoninsuranceutah@ gmail.com 801-367-7428 Asking Price: $325,000 PIF: 1,800 Premium: $1,600,000 Number of Staff: 2 Great Main Street Location, Low overhead and Rent. West Jordan Ryan Davis whosgameisit23@gmail.com 801-562-8866 Asking Price: Please call PIF: 1,180 Premium: $1,065,000 Number of Staff: 2 Vermont Brattleboro Michael Dorner dorninc@yahoo.com D! 802 -380-0014 SOL Asking Price: $520,000 PIF: 2,464 Premium: $2,271,000 Number of Staff: 1 Larry A Bronstone lbronstone@gmail.com 703-967-8287 Asking Price: $725,000 PIF: 2,286 Premium: $2,939,736 Number of Staff: 4 Several locations Ed Hogg (Rep) ehogg9@gmail.com 703-862-8168 Asking Price: Negotiable PIF: Premium: Call for info Seller Rep, several locations, call for details Washington Spokane Richard Cerenzia RCerenzia@allstate.com 509-326-3069 Asking Price: $175,000 PIF: 938 Premium: $720,000 Number of Staff: 1 4 Yr agent. ALI 91%, Retention 91, LR 42%. Buyer qualifies for accelerated commission Spokane, Washington Dick Triesch dickjtriesch@yahoo.com E 509-768-0957 SAL G! IN call Asking Price: Please END P PIF: 1,987 Premium: $1,675,349 The NAPAA market place… where buyers meet sellers. Place your classified ad here for just $99 per issue of Exclusivefocus (Price reduced to $50 if ad is in conjunction with online ad.) For more information, go to www.napaausa.org, or contact NAPAA at 877-627-2248, or HQ@napaausa.org. Exclusivefocus — 61 NAPAA Board of Directors 2011-2012 Administrative Offices Jim Fish, Executive Director P. O. Box 7666 Gulfport, MS 39506 Ph # 877-269-3474 Nonmembers: Call 563-564-1800 ExecutiveDirector@napaausa.org Nancy Fish, Association Manager P.O. Box 7666 Gulfport, MS 39506 Ph #877-627-2248 Nonmembers: Call 563-564-1800 Fax #866-627-2232 hq@napaausa.org Please email HQ@napaausa.org to contact our officers and directors. Include the name of the person in the subject line. OFFICERS Bob Isacsen President Hoboken, NJ Dale Revels Immediate Past President Kissimmee, FL Debe Campos-Fleenor Executive Vice President Tucson, AZ Exclusivefocus This issue of Exclusivefocus magazine may contain articles of interest submitted to NAPAA by outside authors. NAPAA is not responsible for the opinions, advice or accuracy of any information provided therein. P.O. Box 7666 Gulfport, MS 39506-7666 Phone Toll Free (877) 627-2248 Toll Free Fax (866) 627-2232 Web Site www.napaausa.org Email HQ@napaausa.org Nonmembers: call 563-564-1800 NAPAA’s Mission Statement NAPAA is dedicated to the success of Allstate Exclusive Agency Owners and to advance the independence and entrepreneurial spirit of our members. National Association of Professional Allstate Agents, Inc. Jim Fish Executive Editor P.O. Box 7666 Gulfport, MS 39506 Phone (877) 269-3474 • Fax (866) 627-2232 Exclusivefocus@napaausa.org Nonmembers: call 563-564-1800 Exclusivefocus and DirectExpress are official publications of NAPAA - The National Association of Professional Allstate Agents, Inc. No part of this publication may be reproduced without prior written permission of the publisher. It is the policy of this publication to reflect the professional thoughts and attitudes of our members and to advance the professionalism of the insurance industry to the ultimate benefit of the insuring public. The views expressed by NAPAA, or any of its positions relative to its activities and those of its members’ actions on behalf of this organization, are expressly those of NAPAA, and do not reflect the views or the opinions of Allstate Insurance Company, or any of its affiliates. Letters to the Editor: All letters must include an address and a daytime and evening phone number. We reserve the right to edit letters for clarity and space. TABlETS ExPlAINEd BRANdEd RETAIl ENvIRONMENT NAPAA’s Goals Our goals are subject to alteration, influenced by a constantly changing environment and the needs and wishes of our members. NAPAA encourages its members to actively participate in the process of defining and refining our Mission, Goals and Positions. Our General Goals: • To provide an organization specifically tailored to benefit Allstate Exclusive Agents • Monitor legislative and legal issues pertinent to Agents and their clients • Maintain an Action Fund to support issues beneficial to agents and clients • Provide reliable communications on all issues that affect Agents and the ability to call upon our members to act • Provide Agents with a distinct voice on issues that affect them, continually exploring options and solutions • Make tools and resources available for members in an effort to increase agency value and success. For more information, please visit www.napaausa.org lETTERS TO NAPAA Exclusivefocus Fall 2012 An Official Publication of the National Association of Professional Allstate Agents, Inc. Ismael Melendez, Jr. Treasurer Federal Way, WA Judy Ost Secretary Battleground, WA DIRECTORS Al Bullard, Floral Park, NY Ed Hogg, Fairfax, VA Greg Thompson, Burleson, TX Lezlee Liljenberg, Arlington, TX 62 — Exclusivefocus Intriguing Agent Stories page 34 Fall 2012 Your Flood Book: Keep it, Sell it, or Roll it page 28 issue of Exclusivefocus Great Expectations vs. Grim Realities: What Every New Allstate Agent Needs to Know brought to you by the pages 14, 18, 20 Networking Ideas to Help your Agency page 22 Agency Business Objectives Program Exposed! page 40 A Bright New Day for Allstate Agents A Revolutionary Strategy to Minimize Price Objections while Enhancing your Community Status Page 42 National Association of Professional Allstate Agents. Magazine for Allstate AgencyOwners Ownersand andAllstate AllstatePersonal PersonalFinancial FinancialRepresentatives Representatives AA AMagazine Magazinefor forAllstate AllstateAgency Agency Owners and Allstate Personal Financial Representatives Fall 2012 Insurance Professionals: IS IT TIME TO BECOME THE OWNER OF YOUR OWN INDEPENDENT INSURANCE AGENCY? • Are you locked with a captive and all of the mounting restrictions? • Are you tired of trying to write the business “they” want you to write? • Are you just tired of working for someone else? IF YOU ANSWERED “YES” TO ANY OF THESE QUESTIONS, THEN IT’S TIME TO CONTACT EQUITY ONE! Our GlobalGreen Insurance Agencies have access to: • Multiple Carriers for EVERY Insurance Need • Software Support • State of the Art Agency Management System • Bonus Program Call or E-mail us today for the Opportunity of a Lifetime! 636-536-5005 or Toll Free 877-452-5476 ask for Jeff Wilson or jwilson@globalgreeninsuranceonline.com Visit us online to see our growing list of carriers: GlobalGreenInsuranceOnline.com Travelers Insurance Company’s 2009 Agency of the Year
Similar documents
May. 17 - St. Catharine`s Website
“Peter stood up in the midst of the brothers…He said ‘My brothers, the Scriptures had to be fulfilled which the Holy Spirit spoke beforehand…it is necessary that one of the men who accompanied us t...
More information