What is a Centrifuge?
Transcription
What is a Centrifuge?
Northwest District MBAA Spring 2015 “Bringing your Brewery to the Next Level” GEA Westfalia Separator Centrifuges for Craft Brewing 1 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Table of Contents 1. Centrifuges in Breweries 2. Basics / Theory 3. What is a Centrifuge? 4. Why use a Centrifuge? 5. Clarification efficiency 6. Potential Yield Improvement 7. Capacity Increase 8. Operation 9. Maintenance 10. Advantages / Summary 2 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Centrifuges in Breweries 3 • Hot Wort / Trub wort • Tank bottoms • Process directly from the bottom of the Fermentor • Blended Tank Bottoms and Racked Beer • Process Cleaner beer from the racking arm and blend in Tank Bottoms • Dry Hopped Beers • Beers dry-hopped up to very high levels • Beer Prior to Filtration • Increase filter run times • Reduce Filter aid consumption • Polishing of Beers • Elimination of Filter depending on desired clarity in final product GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Ultimate Brewery 4 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Centrifuge Basics 5 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division 2. Basic Theory of Centrifugation > 8,000 + g 6 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Basic Theory of Centrifugation 7 • All separation methods that use gravity or centrifugal force occur because there is a density difference between the continuous media (Beer, Wort) and the media that is to be seperated (trub, yeast, hops). The density difference is the main factor that makes centrifugal separation work. • It is the density difference that allows settling and stratification • Stokes law is a fundamental law of physics that applies to settling GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Stokes law The speed that a particle will settle is calulated by: Vs = D2 * (d1-d2) 18 ή *g Centrifuges increase the particle settling velocity 8 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Stokes law • Increasing the particle size (D) increases the velocity squared (minimising shear, fining agents) D2 * (d1-d2) Vs = 18 ή *g • Increasing the density difference ((d1-d2)) increases the D2 * (d1-d2) settling velocity (sugar content, temperature) Vs = 18 ή *g 9 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Stokes law • Decreasing the viscosity (ή) increases the settling velocity (temperature, pH) • Increasing the g force increases the settling velocity D2 * (d1-d2) Vs = 18 ή D2 * (d1-d2) Vs = 18 ή 10 *g *g GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Basic Centrifuge 11 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division 12 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division What is a Centrifuge? • Centrifuge Overview Video 13 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division 14 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Important Design Considerations 15 • Bowl volume • Sediment Space • Important for processing tank bottoms • Larger sediment space keep the solids away from the Disc stack • Clarification Area • Beer Clarity • Better clarity at same flow rates • Bowl Geometry • Disc angle • Bowl angle • G-Force GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Why Use a Centrifuge? 16 • Recover Additional Wort • Up to 10% increased recovery • Recover Beer From the Tank Bottoms • Tank bottoms can be > 50% beer • Increase overall Brewery Yield • > 5% yields seen, more on dry hopped beers • Reduced Brewery Effluent • Ejections removed as solid waste • Less material sent to drains GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Why Use a Centrifuge? 17 • Increase Brewery Capacity • Less Tank retention time required • Less Fermentation Tanks for increased capacity • Easier scheduling of Fermentor drops • Cleaner beer to Filtration or BBT • Less Filter aid consumption ( DE, Pads, Cartridges ) • Less Product Losses at Filter ( Fewer Filter changes ) • Potentially eliminate of filter on some beer styles ( brewery decision ) GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Hot Wort 18 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Hot Wort 19 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Hot Wort 20 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Typical Craft Brewing Set up BB Tank Fermentor Buffer Tank Filter Feed Pump Manual Butterfly Valves to balance flow 21 Inline Sight Glass BEER RECOVERY Beer From Rack Valve Meter in Tank Bottoms GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Blending Tank Bottoms 22 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division 23 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Solids in the Feed / Discharge 12% Inlet Sample No solids in the outlet Sample Solids at 0.05% down to no visible solids seen in the samples on beers at production flow rates < 50,000 Yeast cell counts or none seen in Hemacytometer 24 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Process entire FV 25 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Clarification 26 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Product Clarity Good clarities can be attained even with high solids in the feed as seen in the photo and the next slides. Solids loading up to < 10 % ideal but up to 40% possible at reduced flow rates If the eliminate filtration is desired, lower flow rate will be required to attain the desired outlet clarity. When processing the tank bottoms higher solids in the outlet will be seen 27 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Basic Separation 28 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Centrifuge only, no filtration 29 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Yield / Beer Recovery 30 • The Centrifuge can process all of your fermentor • Minimal Cropping (except for quality reasons) • Tank bottoms can be >50% beer • Yield increases of 5 – 10% have been validated in testing and production depending on beer style • Additional product to package without any additional brews or raw ingredients GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Product Yield Spray water off Dry Yeast Solids ejected equals more bottles of beer per brew Spray water on 31 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division 32 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division 33 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division 34 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Heavy Dry Hopped Ejections Yeast and Hops Discharge from an Imperial IPA product and no Spray water Discharge from dry hopped product with Spray Water 35 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Yield • No additional Raw Ingredient Costs • No Additional Brews required • More Beer • Additional Packaging costs ( for extra beer recovered ) • Beer Revenue minus packaging costs = $$$$ Additional revenue to the brewery $$$$ 36 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division 37 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Case Example ( 40,000 bbl facility ) 38 • Bottling example • Average sales price per case $20.00 • Packaging costs ~$6.00 per case (bottles , six-packs, crowns, labels, etc…) • Labor $2.38 per case, only a 2.5 % increase, so $0.06 per case. All set up, break down and cleaning are already accounted for in the main packaging labor • $20.00 - $6.00 - $0.06 = $13.94 gross profit per case x 13.77 cases/bbl x 600 bbls = $114,980.00 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Revenue Increase VOLUME YIELD PER YEAR / INCREASE BBL's % BBL/YR Bottles/YR Cases/YR 5% 39 Value per Case Packaging Potenital Packaging Labor per Revenue per cost per case case year $20 $6.00 $0.12 5,000 5% 250 82,667 3,444 $20 $6.00 $0.12 $47,812 10,000 5% 500 165,333 6,889 $20 $6.00 $0.12 $95,625 25,000 5% 1250 413,333 17,222 $20 $6.00 $0.12 $239,062 50,000 5% 2500 826,667 34,444 $20 $6.00 $0.12 $478,123 100,000 5% 5000 1,653,333 68,889 $20 $6.00 $0.12 $956,247 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Solids Ejection High Concentrated Solids gives minimal Beer Losses = and more beer to sell to your customers to enjoy! 40 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division 41 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Capacity Increase ( Case Example 40,000 bbl facility ) • Centrifuges can process high solids levels of yeast and hops • 40% by volume if processing directly from the tank bottoms 42 • No more waiting for additional tank retention time to get the yeast loading down to process in the filter or rack. • Eliminate additional tank retention time ( settling days ) • On a typical 12 day process with two days shorter tank retention time equals a 16+% increase in capacity • More turns of the fermentors per year give increase capacity without additional fermentor purchases GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Capacity Increase ( Case Example 40,000 bbl facility ) 43 • Even bigger difference with big dry-hopped beers • Old method: ferment, cool, and flocculate, then drain as much as yeast as possible before dry-hopping • This was generally an 18 day process for “big” beers • Dry-hopping: 10 days • Total tank retention time: 28 days. • • New SOP: Dry-hop at the end of fermentation, regardless of cell count Approx. day 8, followed by 10 days on dry-hops for a total of 18 days • This is a 10 day decrease in tank retention time = 35+% increase in capacity GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Capacity Increase ( Case Example 40,000 bbl facility ) • When the brewery looked at the facilities overall production • 470 bbl of increased capacity available with centrifuge in process • Increased capacity due to shortened tank retention time equated to the value of two 240 bbl fermentors • Estimate: $65,000 per tank, our total value is $130,000 of increased capacity per year This gave the brewery the additional capacity with the use of the Centrifuge without adding additional Fermentors to the brewery. 44 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Small Breweries ( < 5,000 to 10,000 BBL/Year ) 45 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Yield Increase small brewery 46 • What does it mean if you are a 5000 bbl brewery and pub? • Estimate a 3% increase in yield on 5000 bbls, which yields 150 bbls. • For this example assume all of the extra beer was sold at the Pub or Tap room • $4.00 pints - $1.00 /pint for Microstar charges- $0.50/pint for labor = $2.50/pint profit • 150 bbls x 248 pints/bbl x $2.50/pint = $93,000.00 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Operation 47 • From a dead stop: Start Centrifuge 10 minutes to ramp up to speed Ready for CIP or sanitize or goes into Idle Mode • Sanitize Centrifuge: Same time as lines are sanitized ( no additional time required ) Centrifuge program has a sanitize mode • Transition to Process Select Recipe for product to be processes Go from Sanitize directly to product • End of Product Run: Transition directly to next product Push lines with CO2 of water Rinse lines and CIP GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Operation 48 • CIP Systems have a CIP program included Start CIP and clean along with process lines. Full CIP cycle with Rinse, Caustic, Final rinse approx. 45 • Shut down: Stop Centrifuge Let unit spin to a stop Turn off utilities GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Maintenance 49 • Annual maintenance Based on operating hours or 12 months time • Minor Overhaul Inspect bowl Replace gaskets, o-rings, etc. on bowl, oil change • Major Overhaul Minor work as well as the bearings, belt, etc. on the drive • Maintenance Plans: Use Factory Service Technicians 3 year fixed price programs with Parts and Labor Schedule service as required ( based on hours ) Purchase parts only and have in-house maintenance do the work GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Advantages 50 • DO pick up • DO pick up across the centrifuge < 20 PPB • Process complete fermentor volume, either blended ( preferred method ) or 100% tank bottom from cone • Ease of Operation • Control scheme very user friendly • Operator not required 100% on machine, can operate and do other functions in the brewery simultaneously • High Yield due to Bowl Ejection system and Controls • Thick solids ejected, > 22% DS in sludge, no free liquid • Can be pumped directly into spent yeast tank GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Advantages 51 • Shorten Fermentation retention times • Process Beer without waiting additional days for settling • Increase brewery capacity • Filtration Improvement • Less Filter Aid consumption due to cleaner beer to filter • Longer filtration runs between re-coating which gives increase yield as well • Stabilizer additions to products and removal by Centrifuge possible • Standardization of cloudy beer products • Potential Elimination of Filtration • Would need to be validated by each Brewery location and style GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division Advantages 52 • Reduced Effluent • Yeast / Hops / Trub removed as solid waste • Less material sent to drain • Better Hop Character • Hops put under high G-force • Better extraction of oils from hops • Much anecdotal information from centrifuge customers • Less Hops usage possible • Some breweries have reduced the dry hopping rates • Brewery decision GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division SUMMARY 53 • Centrifuge can recover the beer currently being sent to drain • Increase yield can have a large impact on revenue • Filtration improved with lower solids loading to filter or elimination of filter • Less Filter aid consumption or disposal • Reduced effluent to drains • Brewery capacity increase possible with shortened retention times prior to processing • Can schedule fermentation drops better • Sizes to fit every breweries requirements GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division THANK YOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION! GEA Westfalia Separator Chris Boos chris.boos@gea.com 54 GEA Mechanical Equipment US, Inc. / GEA Westfalia Separator Division