to see it
Transcription
to see it
Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 15 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK BEER BELLY, INC., a California Corporation, COMPLAINT FOR TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT, UNFAIR COMPETITION AND CYBERPIRACY; DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL Plaintiff, v. BMT 1110, L.L.C., a New York Limited Liability Company d/b/a BM&T MANAGEMENT GROUP d/b/a THE BEER BELLY; BMT 1110 Realty, L.L.C. a New York Limited Liability Company d/b/a BM&T MANAGEMENT GROUP d/b/a THE BEER BELLY; and MICHAEL VIGLUCCI, JR., an individual; and DOES 1 through 10, inclusive, Civil Action No.: 1:16-CV-0506 (DNH/CFH) Defendants. Plaintiff, Beer Belly, Inc. (“Plaintiff”), by and through its attorneys, STRADLING, YOCCA, CARLSON & RAUTH, P.C. and HINMAN, HOWARD & KATTELL, LLP, as and for its Complaint against Defendants BMT 1110, L.L.C., a New York Corporation d/b/a BM&T MANAGEMENT GROUP d/b/a THE BEER BELLY (“BMT”), BMT 1110 Realty, L.L.C., a New York Corporation d/b/a BM&T MANAGEMENT GROUP d/b/a THE BEER BELLY (“BMT Realty”), MICHAEL VIGLUCCI, JR., an individual (“Viglucci”), and DOES 1 through 10, inclusive (collectively “Defendants”), hereby alleges as follows: THE PARTIES 1. Plaintiff Beer Belly, Inc. is, and at all times pertinent to this action has been, a corporation duly organized and existing under the laws of the State of California , and having its principal place of business in Los Angeles, California. Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 2 of 15 2. On information and belief, Defendant BMT 1110, L.L.C. d/b/a BM&T MANAGEMENT GROUP d/b/a THE BEER BELLY, is a limited liability company duly organized and existing under the laws of the State of New York, with its principal place of business in Albany, New York. 3. On information and belief, Defendant BMT 1110 Realty, L.L.C. d/b/a BM&T MANAGEMENT GROUP d/b/a THE BEER BELLY, is a limited liability company duly organized and existing under the laws of the State of New York, with its principal place of business in Albany, New York. 4. On information and belief, Defendant MICHAEL VIGLUCCI, JR., is an individual who is a New York resident with a principal residence in Albany, New York. On information and belief, Viglucci was and is a moving, active, conscious force behind BMT and BMT Realty’s infringement of Plaintiff’s trademark and associated rights. 5. Plaintiff is ignorant to the true names and capacities of the Defendants sued as Does 1–10, inclusive, and therefore Plaintiff has sued them by their fictitious names. Upon information and belief, Does 1–10 were and are moving, active, conscious forces behind the infringement of Plaintiff’s rights. As such, Does 1–10 are liable to Plaintiff. JURISDICTION AND VENUE 6. This is a civil action arising under the laws of the United States relating to trademarks (15 U.S.C. §§ 1114(1) and 1125(a)). This Court has federal question jurisdiction over Counts I, II and V pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338(a) and (b). This Court has supplemental jurisdiction over Count III pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1367. 7. This Court has personal jurisdiction over BMT and BMT Realty in that Defendants are citizens and residents of the State of New York, have engaged in business 2 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 3 of 15 activities in New York, and tortious acts by BMT and BMT Realty complained of in this Complaint have been committed within this judicial district. 8. Venue in this Judicial District is proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1391, given that a substantial portion of the acts and transactions complained of herein were conceived, carried out, made effective, and had effect within the State of New York and this Judicial District. 9. In addition, on information and belief, all Defendants are residents of the State of New York, and at least one of the Defendants resides or is deemed to reside in this Judicial District. NATURE OF THE ACTION 10. In this action, Plaintiff seeks injunctive relief, lost profits, damages and attorneys’ fees for Defendants’ acts of trademark infringement under 15 U.S.C. § 1114 et seq., unfair competition and false designation of origin under 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a), cyberpiracy and cybersquatting under 15 U.S.C. §1125(d), common law unfair competition, common law misappropriation and related causes of action. GENERAL ALLEGATIONS 11. Plaintiff owns and operates Beer Belly, a restaurant/bar focused on serving “craft beer, and crafty food.” 12. Plaintiff is the owner of the BEERBELLY mark, U.S. Trademark Registration No. 4,669,415, for use in connection with restaurant services. A copy of Plaintiff’s U.S. Trademark Registration No. 4,669,415 is attached hereto as Exhibit A. 13. Plaintiff began using its BEERBELLY trademark as early as May 1, 2011. 14. Plaintiff’s use of its BEERBELLY mark has been open, notorious, and continuous. 3 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 4 of 15 15. Beginning at least as early as December 2011, and continuing through the present, Plaintiff’s restaurant has garnered national attention and acclaim. For example, the BEERBELLY mark has been advertised or featured in national television shows and print or online publications such as: a. LA Weekly, Best 5 New Craft Beer Bars of 2011, http://blogs.laweekly.com/squidink/2011/12/beer_bars_la.php?page=2 (Attached hereto as Exhibit B-1); b. GQ Magazine, 12 Bars For Beer Lovers, http://www.gq.com/foodtravel/restaurants-and-bars/201210/best-beer-bars-october2012?slide=2#slide=9 (Attached hereto as Exhibit B-2); c. LA Weekly, Best Beer List 2012, http://www.laweekly.com/bestof/2012/award/best-beer-list-1892645/ (Attached hereto as Exhibit B-3); d. CNN.com, 8 Things to Know about Koreatown, http://www.cnn.com/2013/04/17/travel/koreatown-los-angeles/index.html (Attached hereto as Exhibit B-4); e. Los Angeles Magazine, 15 Best New Bars, http://www.lamag.com/features-hidden/2012/07/01/best-new-bars-no-10beer-belly (Attached hereto as Exhibit B-5); f. DRAFT Magazine, A Growing Beer Belly, http://draftmag.com/features/a-growing-beer-belly/ (Attached hereto as Ex. B-6); 4 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 5 of 15 g. Food Network - Diners, Drive-ins, and Dives, (Season 16, Episode 11: “Unlikely Partners”) (Copy of program information attached herein as Exhibit B-7); and h. Travel Channel - Food Paradise (Episode: Deep-Fried Paradise 3) (Copy of program information attached herein as Exhibit B-8). 16. The BEERBELLY mark is distinctive and identifies Plaintiff as the single source of origin of the services marketed and provided in connection therewith. 17. Since 2011, Plaintiff has spent significant time, energy and expense building up the good will and value of its BEERBELLY mark. 18. Without Plaintiff’s authorization or consent, and after Plaintiff began to use and had built up extensive and valuable business and good will in connection with the BEERBELLY mark, Defendants began using the confusingly similar “The Beer Belly” designation in connection with restaurant services. 19. On information and belief, Defendants have been using and continue to use the designation “The Beer Belly” to market and sell Defendants’ restaurant services. 20. On information and belief, Defendants seek to capitalize on the strength and reputation of Plaintiff’s BEERBELLY mark, by registering, trafficking in or using the domain http://www.beerbellyalbany.com which is substantively and confusingly similar to the distinctive BEERBELLY mark with a bad faith intent to profit. 21. On information and belief, Defendants’ use of a domain which is confusingly similar to Plaintiff’s registered trademark directs consumers to Defendants’ website where such consumers are misled as to the origin, sponsorship or approval of the goods and services 5 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 6 of 15 marketed and offered for sale through the http://www.beerbellyalbany.com website, and are deceived as to Defendants’ affiliation, connection or association with Plaintiff. 22. On information and belief, Defendants were or became aware of Plaintiff and its trademark rights before Defendants launched their services and adopted the “The Beer Belly” designation. 23. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and on that ground alleges, that Defendants adopted the confusingly similar ‘The Beer Belly’ designation with knowledge of Plaintiff’s trademark rights and with the intent to deceive consumers and to cause confusion among purchasers for the purpose of misappropriating and benefiting from the goodwill and public recognition associated with Plaintiff and to divert sales from Plaintiff to Defendants. 24. On information and belief, Plaintiff and Defendants offer restaurant services which are nearly identical in scope. 25. On information and belief, Plaintiff and Defendants market and promote their restaurant services in nearly identical ways, including through their website, review sites (such as Yelp), print advertising, and social media. 26. Defendants’ “The Beer Belly” designation is sufficiently identical to the BEERBELLY trademark in sight, sound, connotation and commercial impression that its use in the sale and marketing of Defendants’ restaurant services to the same class of customers, through the same or similar channels of trade is likely to cause consumer confusion. 27. On information and belief, Viglucci is the founder, owner, president and creative force behind BMT and BMT Realty. On information and belief, Viglucci actively and knowingly participated in and directed BMT and BMT Realty’s willful adoption of the “The Beer Belly” designation. 6 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 7 of 15 28. On information and belief, Defendants knew or should have known of Plaintiff’s trademark rights prior to adopting the “The Beer Belly” designation and that use of this designation is confusingly similar. 29. The aforementioned acts by Defendants have caused, and will continue to cause, actual confusion and a likelihood of confusion in the minds of the public, and have damaged and will further damage Plaintiff’s reputation for exclusivity in connection with its BEERBELLY mark. 30. On or around April 28, 2015, upon learning of Defendants’ infringing use of the “The Beer Belly” designation, Plaintiff sent a Cease and Desist letter requesting that Defendants discontinue all use of the “The Beer Belly” designation and informed them of Plaintiff’s use since May 2011 and of its then pending federal trademark application. A copy of Plaintiff’s Cease and Desist Letter is attached hereto as Exhibit C. 31. Plaintiff never received any response from Defendants to the April 2015 Cease and Desist letter. 32. On or around July 28, 2015, Plaintiff sent a second Cease and Desist letter to Defendants. A copy of Plaintiff’s second Cease & Desist letter is attached hereto as Exhibit D. 33. On or around October 20, 2015, BMT indicated by email that it would change its restaurant signage to comply with Plaintiff’s demands. A copy of BMT’s email is attached hereto as Exhibit E. 34. Despite repeated attempts to follow-up on this transition, as of April 19, 2016, on information and belief, Defendants continues to use the “The Beer Belly” trademark on their website and on social media outlets such Facebook, Twitter and Yelp, to name a few. Copies of screenshots of Defendants’ website and social media profiles are attached hereto as Exhibit F. 7 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 8 of 15 35. On information and belief, Defendants BMT and BMT Realty are inadequately capitalized or insured to respond to claims against them; there is no separation between the business activities of BMT and BMT Realty and the personal activities of Viglucci; BMT and BMT Realty’s funds and Viglucci’s funds are co-mingled; BMT and BMT Realty’s funds are used to satisfy Viglucci’s debts; BMT and BMT Realty’s funds are used for Viglucci’s personal travel and entertainment expenses; and BMT and BMT Realty has disregarded corporate formalities. BMT and BMT Realty are mere instrumentalities of Viglucci’s will and are shells with no independent direction. As such, BMT and BMT Realty are the alter egos of Viglucci. 36. On information and belief, given the alter ego relationship between BMT and BMT Realty and Viglucci, Plaintiff alleges that fraud and/or injustice is likely to occur if the separation of entities is not disregarded. 37. On information and belief, Viglucci personally participated, directed, controlled, ratified, was the moving force behind, and acted consciously, willfully, deliberately, and knowingly when he and BMT and BMT Realty committed the wrongful acts alleged herein, injuring Plaintiff. COUNT I WILLFUL INFRINGEMENT OF FEDERALLY REGISTERED TRADEMARK (LANHAM ACT §32) 38. Plaintiff repeats and realleges each and every allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 37 hereof as if fully stated herein. 39. By virtue of Defendants’ conduct, Defendants have used and are using a spurious term in connection with the advertising, marketing, and offering of restaurant services, which are identified with the BEERBELLY mark used by Plaintiff. 8 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 9 of 15 40. Plaintiff’s services are offered and advertised to the same or similar classes of purchasers as Defendants. As a result of Defendants’ conduct, there is a strong likelihood of confusion, mistake, or deception, and many persons familiar with Plaintiff’s BEERBELLY mark, its reputation and favorable good will, are likely to purchase Defendants’ services in the mistaken belief that such services are related to, offered or authorized by Plaintiff. 41. Defendants’ actions have been and are willful, unfair, false and deceptive, in that they tend to mislead, deceive and confuse, and have had and will have the result of misleading, deceiving and confusing the public to believe that BMT and BMT Realty and/or its services are affiliated with, sponsored or controlled by Plaintiff. 42. As a consequence, Defendants have traded and are trading upon, and have gained and are gaining public acceptance and other benefits from, Plaintiff’s favorable reputation and valuable good will, which have accordingly been placed at risk and damaged by Defendants’ illegal actions and conduct. 43. The foregoing actions of Defendants constitute trademark infringement by inducing the erroneous belief that BMT and BMT Realty and/or its services are in some manner affiliated with, originate from, or are sponsored by Plaintiff in violation of Lanham Act § 32, 15 U.S.C. §1114. 44. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and on that ground alleges, that Defendants have made and/or will make unlawful gains and profits from their unlawful actions as alleged herein, and by reason thereof, Plaintiff has been deprived of gains and profits which otherwise would have inured to Plaintiff but for such unlawful actions. 45. Plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law for the injuries alleged in this Count. The injury is, in part, intangible in nature and not capable of being fully measured or valued in terms 9 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 10 of 15 of money damages. Further, the injury is of a continuing nature and will continue to be suffered so long as Defendants continue their wrongful conduct. 46. Notwithstanding the inadequacy of, and the difficulty of presently fully ascertaining the value of the damage to Plaintiff caused by Defendants’ wrongful conduct, said conduct has resulted in irreparable, direct and proximate damages to Plaintiff and Plaintiff is entitled to injunctive relief under 15 U.S.C. Section 1116(a). COUNT II FALSE DESIGNATION OF ORIGIN AND UNFAIR COMPETITION (LANHAM ACT §43(a)) 47. Plaintiff repeats and realleges each and every allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 46 hereof as if fully stated herein. 48. This claim arises under Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act. Defendants’ unauthorized use and continued use in interstate commerce of “The Beer Belly” constitutes use of a false designation of origin and a false description or representation that has caused and is likely to cause confusion, mistake or deception (a) as to the characteristics, qualities or origin of Defendants’ services, (b) as to an affiliation, connection or association between Plaintiff and Defendants, and (c) as to the sponsorship or approval of Defendants’ services by Plaintiff. 49. Such actions, as used in commercial advertising, have misrepresented and do misrepresent the nature, characteristics or qualities of Defendants’ services and/or commercial activities. 50. Upon information and belief, Defendants have intentionally and falsely designated the origin of their services by adopting and using a term that is substantially the same as the BEERBELLY trademark for its goods so as to profit from Plaintiff’s reputation by confusing the public as to the source, origin, sponsorship or approval of Defendants’ services, 10 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 11 of 15 with the intention of deceiving and misleading the public at large, and of wrongfully trading on the goodwill and reputation of Plaintiff. 51. The activities of Defendants’ complained of herein have caused and, unless enjoined, will continue to cause substantial and irreparable harm to Plaintiff, its business reputation and its goodwill, for which Plaintiff is without adequate remedy at law. Such activities have also caused Plaintiff monetary loss and damage including, but not limited to, the loss of profits in an amount not yet determined. 52. Further, the injury is of a continuing nature and will continue to be suffered so long as Defendants continue their wrongful conduct. Notwithstanding the inadequacy of, and the difficulty of presently fully ascertaining, the value of the damage to Plaintiff caused by Defendants’ wrongful conduct, Plaintiff is informed and believes, and on that ground alleges, that said conduct has resulted in irreparable, direct and proximate damages to Plaintiff. COUNT III COMMON LAW MISAPPROPRIATION 53. Plaintiff repeats and realleges each and every allegation contained in Paragraphs 1 through 52 hereof as if fully stated herein. 54. Plaintiff has invested substantial time, man-hours, resources and money in adopting, developing and using the BEERBELLY mark, and the BEERBELLY mark is Plaintiff’s property. 55. In committing the acts of trademark infringement and unfair competition as alleged herein, Defendants have misappropriated and taken without permission Plaintiff’s property and converted it to their own use for their own benefit. 11 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 12 of 15 56. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and on that ground alleges, that by misappropriating and converting Plaintiff’s property, Defendants have benefited greatly and illegitimately by using “The Beer Belly” to offer its goods without having to make a substantial investment of their own. 57. Defendants’ acts constitute common-law misappropriation under the common law of the State of New York. 58. Defendants have been and will continue to be, unless enjoined, unjustly enriched by their acts of misappropriation. 59. The foregoing acts of Defendants’ have injured and will continue to injure Plaintiff by depriving it of sales of its genuine services and by injuring its business reputation and good will, all in violation of the common law of the State of New York. 60. Defendants’ acts have caused and will continue to cause irreparable harm and damage to Plaintiff, and have caused and will continue to cause Plaintiff monetary damage in an amount thus far not determined, for which Plaintiff is entitled to its actual damages, Defendants’ profits, punitive damages, attorneys’ fees and costs. 61. Plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law. COUNT IV CYBERPIRACY UNDER 15 U.S.C. 1125(d) OF THE ANTI-CYBERSQUATTING CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT 62. Plaintiff repeats and realleges each and every allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 61 as if fully stated herein. 63. Defendants’ acts as described in this Complaint including registering, trafficking in or using the domain www.beerbellydeli.com, which is substantially and confusingly similar to 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 13 of 15 Plaintiff’s distinctive BEERBELLY mark, with a bad faith intent to profit, constitute cyberpiracy and/or cybersquatting in violation of Section 43 of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. §1125(d). 64. By reason of its illegal conduct, Defendants have and continues to wrongfully derive income and profits from these acts, and Plaintiff has sustained and will continue to sustain, substantial injury, loss and damage. PRAYER FOR RELIEF WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendants as follows: A. That Defendants’ conduct infringes Plaintiff’s BEERBELLY mark, falsely designates the origin of Defendants’ services, falsely describes such services, and unfairly competes with Plaintiff, all in violation of Lanham Act §§43(a) and 32, 15 U.S.C. §1125, and 15 U.S.C. §1114 et seq. B. That Defendants’ conduct serves to infringe Plaintiff’s BEERBELLY mark and unfairly compete with Plaintiff under the common law of the State of New York. C. That Defendants and their agents, officers, directors, servants, employees, attorneys, its successors and assigns, and all others in active concert or participation with Defendants be preliminarily and permanently enjoined from directly or indirectly: i. Using Plaintiff’s BEERBELLY mark, or any other marks which are confusingly similar to or colorable imitations of Plaintiff’s BEERBELLY mark, including, without limitation, the term “The Beer Belly” alone or as part of or together with any other designs, word or words, trademark, service mark, trade name, trade dress or other business or commercial designation or any logo, symbol or design; 13 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 14 of 15 ii. Committing any act which, in and of itself, or from the manner or under the circumstances in which it is done amounts to false designation of origin, false description or false representation of Defendants’ services; and iii. Otherwise unfairly competing with Plaintiff or misappropriating Plaintiff’s intellectual property, including, but not limited to the BEERBELLY mark. D. That the Court issue an Order directing Defendants to file with the Court and serve on Plaintiff, within thirty (30) days after the service on Defendants of such injunction, a report in writing and under oath, setting forth in detail the manner and form in which Defendants have complied with the injunction. E. That the Court award judgment in favor of Plaintiff for the amount of either damages sustained by Plaintiff or the profits made by Defendants as a result of Defendants’ wrongful conduct, whichever amount is greater, and damages in an amount necessary for Plaintiff to conduct corrective advertising to eliminate the confusion caused by Defendants’ wrongful acts. F. That the Court award judgment in favor of Plaintiff in the amount of treble damages under 15 U.S.C. §1117, plus prejudgment interest. G. That the Court award statutory damages pursuant to 15 U.S.C. §1117(d), against Defendants in the amount of $100,000 or in an amount the Court otherwise considers just. H. That the Court award judgment against Defendants for the full costs of this action, including reasonable attorney fees. I. That the Court award to Plaintiff punitive damages sufficient to deter Defendants from committing such willful acts of infringement in the future. 14 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 15 of 15 J. For interest on all amounts found to be due to Plaintiff from Defendants, at the prevailing rate, from the date said amounts or any part thereof became or become due. K. That the Court requires Defendants to notify any parent, subsidiaries, investors, affiliated companies, commercial associates, advertising agencies, suppliers and customers of said Order. L. That the Court Order such other, further and different relief as the nature of this action may require and that the Court deem just and proper. M. That the Court retain jurisdiction of this action for the purpose of enabling Plaintiff to apply to the Court, at any time, for such further orders and directions as may be necessary or appropriate for the interpretation or execution of any order entered in this action, for the modification of any such order, for the enforcement or compliance therewith and for the punishment of any violations thereof. JURY DEMAND Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury pursuant to Rule 38 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure on each and every cause of action asserted in its Complaint that is triable by jury. DATED: May 2, 2016 HINMAN, HOWARD & KATTELL, LL Attorneys for Plaintiff Beer Belly, Inc. By: /s/ Paul T. Sheppard Paul T. Sheppard Bar Roll No. 102596 700 Security Mutual Building 80 Exchange Street P.O. Box 5250 Binghamton, New York 13902-5250 Telephone: (607) 723-5341 Fax: (607) 723-6605 Email: sheppard@hhk.com 15 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 2 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-1 Filed 05/02/16 Page 2 of 2 Top Hops: Best 5 New Craft Beer Bars of 2011 | L.A. Weekly Page 1 of 5 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-2 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 5 Top Hops: Best 5 New Craft Beer Bars of 2011 BY DANIEL DRENNON THURSDAY, DECEMBER 29, 2011 AT 9 A.M. The Many Colors of Craft Beer Keith Underwood Over the past few years, sales of mass-produced beer (Bud, Miller, Coors and the like) are down along with housing, investments and other barometers of economic growth. Guess what is not down? Craft breweries. Craft beer bars. Craft beer sales. http://www.laweekly.com/restaurants/top-hops-best-5-new-craft-beer-bars-of-2011-2374996 4/21/2016 Top Hops: Best 5 New Craft Beer Bars of 2011 | L.A. Weekly Page 2 of 5 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-2 Filed 05/02/16 Page 2 of 5 According to the Brewers Association, which represents the artists who brew innovative and exceptionally drinkable beer, craft beer sales went up 11 percent in 2010 and were up 14 percent in the first six months of 2011. Conversely, mass brewers are losing sales (silent applause OK here). Droves of (good) beer fans are supporting new beer bars in numbers that have bar owners expanding into second and even third locations within years of opening the first. Plus, seemingly every new restaurant that opens must offer 24 or more tap handles of craft beer. "It's an artistic movement," says Tony Yanow, who this summer opened Mohawk Bend in Echo Park. Yes, great craft brewers are a form of art. Here are the top five new beer bars of 2011, in alphabetical order. Burger and beer at Steingarten L.A. Daniel Drennon 5. Steingarten L.A., West Los Angeles: http://www.laweekly.com/restaurants/top-hops-best-5-new-craft-beer-bars-of-2011-2374996 4/21/2016 Top Hops: Best 5 New Craft Beer Bars of 2011 | L.A. Weekly Page 3 of 5 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-2 Filed 05/02/16 Page 3 of 5 David Watrous, aka the Gueuze Hound and a self-described "beer evangelist," has created 20 taps of rotating excellence and a bottle list that is even better. Watrous has forgotten more about sours, lambics and gueuzes than we know. Hence, if your beer preferences lean in that direction, Steingarten should be your new home away from home. If they lean more toward California craft, he has you covered there as well. Steingarten has frequent beer event nights with brewers. We especially recommend the happy hour, 4-7 p.m. weeknights. The food, which focuses on sausages and burgers, is excellent. The interior bar and restaurant are warm and welcoming. And the outdoor patio in the back is an escape from the hustle and bustle (read: traffic) of the Pico corridor. 10543 W. Pico Blvd., W.L.A. Mohawk Bend in Echo Park Kat Nguyen 4. Mohawk Bend, Echo Park: http://www.laweekly.com/restaurants/top-hops-best-5-new-craft-beer-bars-of-2011-2374996 4/21/2016 Top Hops: Best 5 New Craft Beer Bars of 2011 | L.A. Weekly Page 4 of 5 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-2 Filed 05/02/16 Page 4 of 5 Mohawk Bend is the latest project of Yanow, who also has the beer bar Tony's Darts Away, in Burbank, and the brewing company Golden Road Brewing. Mohawk Bend is a beer wonderland that features a whopping 72 tap handles with four nitro lines and two Firkin pump handles. Formerly a vaudeville theater, Mohawk has a relatively dark front room with high ceilings and, to the right, a long, cool bar with a wall of chrome tap handles, which seems to stretch on forever. The entire left side is an open kitchen. But your eyes are drawn to the skylight-lit backroom, with its original brick wall that is more than 100 years old. It is a beautiful space in which to drink beautiful beer. Half of the 72 tap handles will rotate with each blown keg, so customers can always expect something new and different. While the selection is overwhelmingly California-centric, five handles will be dedicated to an out-of-state brewer each month -- yes, they brew great beer in other states, too. 2141 W. Sunset Blvd., Echo Park. Vanessa Sikoff pours the "Hoppy Hour" glass jug of craft beer Daniel Drennon 3. City Tavern, Culver City: City Tavern is a sibling of Rush Street, which is several blocks west of it in downtown Culver City. City offers 22 rotating taps of craft beer, plus an additional nine taps split among three party-size booths where you can pour your own beer at the table. It has a big, inviting dining room and bar, along with a small but lovely outdoor patio. http://www.laweekly.com/restaurants/top-hops-best-5-new-craft-beer-bars-of-2011-2374996 4/21/2016 Top Hops: Best 5 New Craft Beer Bars of 2011 | L.A. Weekly Page 5 of 5 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-2 Filed 05/02/16 Page 5 of 5 Matt Meiers, the bar manager, keeps the California craft beers in a near-perfect rotation of styles and featured breweries. City Tavern also puts on beer-pairing dinners, with the brewers present for meet-and-greets that are extremely popular with beer geeks. Jessica Christensen's North Carolina-influenced menu pairs nicely with the brews. Simply put, one of our favorite places to hang. 9739 Culver Blvd., Culver City. NEXT PAGE ©2016 LA Weekly, LP. All rights reserved. http://www.laweekly.com/restaurants/top-hops-best-5-new-craft-beer-bars-of-2011-2374996 4/21/2016 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-3 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 1 Best Beer List | Beer Belly | food-and-drink | Best of L.A. | L.A. Weekly Page 1 of 8 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-4 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 8 SIGN UP LOG IN MENU BEST OF L.A. Best Of :: Food & Drink BEST OF L.A. /// FOOD & DRINK /// 2012 Beer Belly BEST BEER LIST 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 SEARCH NEIGHBORHOODS MAP IT ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT BARS & CLUBS FOOD & DRINK Best Beer List BEER BELLY Photo by Photo: Garret Synder With a strictly curated tap list of 12 hyper-local brews rotating on a near-daily basis, Koreatown's Beer Belly has become one of the craft beer bars of choice for drinkers looking to bump their beer knowledge into the next echelon. Can't order your usual hefeweizen? Try Eagle Rock's Manifesto witbier. No Guinness? Try Bootlegger's chipotlecoffee porter. By eliminating "the usual" order without overwhelming neophytes, Beer Belly probably has converted more Bud-swilling blockheads into certified beer nerds than any other place in town. Owner Jimmy Han's sharp eye for http://www.laweekly.com/best-of/2012/food-and-drink/best-beer-list-2580912 4/21/2016 Best Beer List | Beer Belly | food-and-drink | Best of L.A. | L.A. Weekly Page 2 of 8 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-4 Filed 05/02/16 Page 2 of 8 Best Steakhouse JAR Best Restaurant PROVIDENCE Best Free Water FOOD Best Overpriced Coffee COFFEE COMMISSARY hard-to-find IPAs and obscure sours doesn't hurt, either, especially when it comes to his collection of by-the-bottle offerings stocked in a back-room fridge. 532 S. Western Ave., Koreatown. (213) 387-2337, beerbellyla.com. —Garrett Snyder 532 S. Western Ave., Los Angeles, 90022 MAP 213-387-2337 beerbellyla.com Best San Fernando Valley Pastry Shop SWEET BUTTER Best Hollywood Glamour Restaurant POLO LOUNGE AT BEVERLY HILLS HOTEL Best Taiwanese Breakfast FOUR SEA RESTAURANT BEST OF L.A. /// FOOD & DRINK /// 2012 Jar BEST STEAKHOUSE Best Doughnut THE DONUT MAN Best Pie CAKE MONKEY Best Pho PHO FILET Best Tamales RIVERA Best Place to Fit in Dinner Before a Downtown Show 'TINA TACOS Best French Fries CHURCH & STATE Best Handmade Noodles SWEETHOME GRILL Best Taco GUISADOS Best Dim Sum Restaurant SEA HARBOUR SEAFOOD RESTAURANT In this era of gastropubs and fusion bistros, it comes as a welcome relief to enter a place that still calls itself a "chophouse," as does Suzanne Tracht's 11year-old West Hollywood restaurant, Jar. The moniker is a signal to other beautifully atavistic traits: a maitre d' in a suit and tie, white tablecloths, an iceberg wedge on the menu, a playlist of Sinatra and Armstrong and Nina Simone — and some of the best steaks in Los Angeles. Not only will your dry- http://www.laweekly.com/best-of/2012/food-and-drink/best-beer-list-2580912 4/21/2016 Best Beer List | Beer Belly | food-and-drink | Best of L.A. | L.A. Weekly Page 3 of 8 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-4 Filed 05/02/16 Page 3 of 8 Best Vegan-Friendly Restaurant ELF CAFE Best Sushi URASAWA Best Farmers Market SANTA MONICA CERTIFIED FARMERS MARKET Best Martini MUSSO & FRANK GRILL Best Brewery LADYFACE ALE COMPANIE Best Margarita aged Kansas City steak or your filet of beef or your prime rib-eye arrive perfectly cooked and presented, it will be served with a little white ceramic boat of sauce like the perfect accessory (a cufflink, a pocket square). The beef is so tender that it hardly needs the lobster béarnaise in the first place, but you are not here for restraint. (Think to yourself: What would Frank do?) Order a martini or two, then the stellar chocolate pudding for dessert. 8225 Beverly Blvd. (323) 655-6566, thejar.com. —Amy Scattergood 8225 Beverly Blvd., Los Angeles, 90048 MAP 323-655-6566 thejar.com BORDER GRILL Best Macaroni and Cheese BAY CITIES ITALIAN DELI BEST OF L.A. /// FOOD & DRINK /// 2012 Best Bloody Mary FIG Providence Best Breakfast Spot BEST RESTAURANT CANELE Best Burrito LA AZTECA TORTILLERIA Best Pizza SOTTO Best Pizza Slice VITO'S PIZZA Best Salad DOMINICK'S RESTAURANT Best Culinary Cocktails INK. Best Soul Food R&R SOUL FOOD Best Burrata OSTERIA MOZZA Photo by Anne Fishbein Spot prawn jewels Michael Cimarusti's seafood palace on Melrose Avenue in Hollywood earlier this summer http://www.laweekly.com/best-of/2012/food-and-drink/best-beer-list-2580912 4/21/2016 Best Beer List | Beer Belly | food-and-drink | Best of L.A. | L.A. Weekly Page 4 of 8 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-4 Filed 05/02/16 Page 4 of 8 Best Oyster Bar L&E OYSTER BAR Best Upscale Burger RUSTIC CANYON WINE BAR AND SEASONAL KITCHEN Best Baguette BREAD LOUNGE Best Lowbrow Burger THE SPICE TABLE Best Drinking Chocolate DEMITASSE Best Farm Stand in the SFV TAPIA BROS. FARM STAND Best Pisco Sour PICCA Best Cheese Shop THE CHEESE STORE OF BEVERLY HILLS celebrated its seventh birthday, a suitably biblical number for a fish restaurant with an excellent pastry kitchen. In those seven years, Providence has neither plateaued nor reversed direction: It has gotten better, kind of a stunning achievement for a restaurant that was worth 2 Michelin stars back when they gave them out in this town. Cimarusti and his crew manage something rare: a combination of technical mastery and playfulness, and a willingness to change things up instead of resting on their considerable laurels. The menu transforms as frequently as the fish swim in and out of their seasonal waters, the staff forages for local greenery, and the plates emerge from the kitchen like small epiphanies. Maybe you can credit it all to the fact that the chef and the general manager like to go fishing out of San Pedro on their few days off. 5955 Melrose Ave., Hlywd. (323) 460-4170, providencela.com. —Amy Scattergood 5955 Melrose Ave., Hollywood, 90038 323-460-4170 providencela.com MAP Best Fish Taco RICKY'S FISH TACOS Best Place to Eat Alone advertisement PIZZERIA MOZZA Best Korean BBQ KANG HO DONG BAEKJEONG Best Torta COOK'S TORTAS Best Old-School Food Truck MARISCOS JALISCO Best Carrots WEISER FAMILY FARMS Best Stone Fruit TENERELLI ORCHARDS BEST OF L.A. /// FOOD & DRINK /// 2012 Best Bibimbap FOOD OO-KOOK KOREAN BBQ http://www.laweekly.com/best-of/2012/food-and-drink/best-beer-list-2580912 4/21/2016 Best Beer List | Beer Belly | food-and-drink | Best of L.A. | L.A. Weekly Page 5 of 8 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-4 Filed 05/02/16 Page 5 of 8 Best Tapas RACIÓN BEST FREE WATER Best New-School Food Truck JOGASAKI SUSHI BURRITO Best Boat Noodles PA-ORD NOODLE Best Pasta ANGELINI OSTERIA Best Omakase Deal KIRIKO SUSHI Best Ramen TSUJITA L.A. Best Falafel JOE'S FALAFEL Best Shawarma TA-EEM GRILL Best Okonomiyaki GOTTSUI Best Butcher MCCALL'S MEAT AND FISH Best Japanese Curry FAT SPOON Best Fried Chicken JIM DANDY Best Place to Feel the Heat NIGHT + MARKET Best Crispy Dumpling BEIJING PIE HOUSE Best Filipino Pastry Shop GOLDILOCKS BAKESHOP Back in 2007, when Judy Ornstein first opened her neighborhood café FOOD, she had a recycling brainstorm: Why not install a plastic, serve-yourself, all-you-can-drink dispenser and fill it with filtered H20, ice cubes and whatever fruity odds and ends she found in the kitchen? Sometimes there are hunks of pineapple sweetly infusing the cold water; other times it's a mind-bendingly thirst-quenching day spa mainstay of cucumber slices and handfuls of fresh mint. Often they go refreshingly tropical with floating orange, lime and lemon slices. Ornstein's light, rejuvenating, bright idea also doubles as an art installation that changes daily: Some have compared the dispenser, sitting in a far corner next to a stack of glasses, to wallpaper in a ladies' restroom circa 1968 or a freeze-frame from a Trix cereal commercial. But we think it recalls a dreamy, zero-gravity fruit salad experiment at NASA — and what's not to like about that? 10571 W. Pico Blvd., W.L.A. (310) 441-7770, food-la.com. —Margy Rochlin 10571 Pico Blvd., Los Angeles, 90064 310-441-7770 food-la.com MAP Best Natural Wine List SALT'S CURE Best Sake List KATANA BEST OF L.A. /// FOOD & DRINK /// 2012 http://www.laweekly.com/best-of/2012/food-and-drink/best-beer-list-2580912 4/21/2016 Best Beer List | Beer Belly | food-and-drink | Best of L.A. | L.A. Weekly Page 6 of 8 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-4 Filed 05/02/16 Page 6 of 8 Best Deli BRENT'S DELICATESSEN & RESTAURANT Best Potpie Coffee Commissary BEST OVERPRICED COFFEE GOOD GIRL DINETTE Best Peruvian Food MO-CHICA Best Arepas BOLÍVAR CAFE & GALLERY Best Yakitori KOKEKOKKO Best Hot Dogs FAB HOT DOGS Best Macarons EUROPANE Best Coffee Roaster HANDSOME COFFEE ROASTERS Best Funnel Coffee BALCONI COFFEE Best Bánh Mì BÁNH MÌ MY THO Best Hot Dog Time Warp CUPID'S HOT DOGS Best Place for 4 a.m. Thai Crispy Pork CRISPY PORK GANG & GRILL Best Place to Dine Like a Beijinger BEIJING RESTAURANT Best Shaved Snow CLASS 302 Four dollars for a cup of coffee? Before you spit out your Starbucks, hear us out: There's a revolution going on in the java world that has little to do with the over-barbecued cafe loco you're used to and everything to do with small organic farms in South America that are churning out product with the kind of terroir previously associated only with wine. Now, we're not so sure about hints of chocolate and pomegranate in our perfect, 195-degree cup of Commissary joe, but it is super smooth and low on acid. Props to Intelligentsia Coffee for kickstarting this thing in L.A. But what we like about the 2-year-old Coffee Commissary in West Hollywood is that it's simple, casual and gimmick-free. Nobody's slurping and "cupping" this stuff, and you won't be huffed on if you don't know your Coava from your Victrola. Hot water is swirled over a cone of precious grinds, with the resulting brew transferred to a thick mug. That's it. 801 N. Fairfax Ave., #106, W. Hlywd. (323) 782- 1465, coffeecommissary.com. —Dennis Romero 801 Fairfax Ave., Los Angeles, 90046 323-782-1465 coffeecommissary.com MAP Best Thai Grocery BANGKOK MARKET Best Juicy Dumplings BEST OF L.A. /// FOOD & DRINK /// 2012 Best Hot Pot Sweet Butter LUSCIOUS DUMPLINGS http://www.laweekly.com/best-of/2012/food-and-drink/best-beer-list-2580912 4/21/2016 Best Beer List | Beer Belly | food-and-drink | Best of L.A. | L.A. Weekly Page 7 of 8 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-4 Filed 05/02/16 Page 7 of 8 BOILING POINT Best Bargain Oaxacan Cuisine EXPRESION OAXAQUEÑA BEST SAN FERNANDO VALLEY PASTRY SHOP Best Soufflé MAISON GIRAUD Prettiest Restaurant EVA RESTAURANT Best Sommelier CHRISTOPHER MILLER, SPAGO Best Wine Program TERRONI Best Wines by the Glass LUKSHON Best Non-Fast Food Drive-Thru SUNNY GRILL Best Prepared Mole RIVAS FOOD COMPANY'S MOLE ROJO TELOLOAPAN Best Hung-lay Curry SPICY BBQ Best Foodie Toy LA TIENDITA'S CHEF KEY RINGS Best New Restaurant BÄCO MERCAT Best Empanada THE EMPANADA FACTORY Best Trader Joe's Parking Lot FAIRFAX TRADER JOE'S Best Raw-Food Restaurant CAFÉ GRATITUDE Best Poutine ANIMAL Best Bakery MILO & OLIVE On a chic strip of shops near a leafy Sherman Oaks neighborhood filled with film-industry types, Sweet Butter is designed to feel as if you've stumbled into a sidewalk pastry shop in Paris. Fleur de sel caramel brownies, butter-rich croissants, bread pudding with brioche (in coconut-lemon and chocolate versions), cinnamon muffins filled with homemade peach or strawberry jam, plum-lemon bars and savory bacon-cheddar scones are churned out by three in-house pastry chefs. Founder Leslie Danelian, a former food stylist and longtime caterer, keeps the charm factor high but the prices low: Mouth-watering chocolate chip cookies are $2, muffins and scones $2.75. The pastry items rotate, so each day Sweet Butter's glass case is filled with surprises. The French county–style restaurant offers full breakfast and lunch menus, with items such as grilled turkey, fig jam and bleu cheese sandwiches. 13824 Ventura Blvd., Sherman Oaks. (818) 788-2832, sweetbutterkitchen.com. http://www.laweekly.com/best-of/2012/food-and-drink/best-beer-list-2580912 4/21/2016 Best Beer List | Beer Belly | food-and-drink | Best of L.A. | L.A. Weekly Page 8 of 8 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-4 Filed 05/02/16 Page 8 of 8 Best Kimchi GRANNY CHOE'S KIMCHEE CO. Best Pastry Shop JOAN'S ON THIRD Best Way to Drink Wine While Traveling 60 mph —Jill Stewart 13824 Ventura Blvd., Sherman Oaks, 91423 MAP 818-788-2832 sweetbutterkitchen.com AMTRAK'S COAST STARLIGHT Best Late-Night Eats DU-PAR'S MORE AWARDS Best Garlic WINDROSE FARM Best Korean Restaurant for Partying GAAM RESTAURANT AND LOUNGE Best Organic Greengrocer COOKBOOK Best Cooking Class THE GOURMANDISE SCHOOL OF SWEETS AND SAVORIES SHOPPING & SERVICES SPORTS & RECREATION ©2016 LA Weekly, LP. All rights reserved. http://www.laweekly.com/best-of/2012/food-and-drink/best-beer-list-2580912 4/21/2016 8 things to know about L.A.'s Koreatown - CNN.com Page 1 of 4 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-5 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 4 Travel + Search and Save Live TV Hotels Flights Cars Packages Powered by Search over 1,000,000 properties at once City Apr 22 Apr 24 2 people 8 things to know about L.A.'s Koreatown Besha Rodell, Special to CNN Updated 6:19 PM ET, Wed March 25, 2015 13 photos: The flavor of L.A.'s Koreatown The flavor of L.A.'s Koreatown – Mae Uhn Tang (spicy fish stew) at Dong Il Jang restaurant in L Koreatown. Anthony Bourdain visits the neighborhood in the new show "Parts Unknown." 1 of 13 http://www.cnn.com/2013/04/17/travel/koreatown-los-angeles/index.html 4/21/2016 8 things to know about L.A.'s Koreatown - CNN.com Page 2 of 4 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-5 Filed 05/02/16 Page 2 of 4 Travel + Story highlights L.A.'s Koreatown is home to one of the city's densest populations Looking around, it feels like Asia, but the area is also 100% L.A. The neighborhood is home to Asians, Central Americans, South Americans and more Koreans are the largest group, but the neighborhood is majority Latino Live TVwinning World-renowned chef, author and Emmy television personality Anthony Bourdain visits Los Angeles' Koreatown in the next episode of "Anthony Bourdain: Parts Unknown," airing Sunday, April 21, at 9 p.m. ET. Follow the show on Twitter and Facebook. Los Angeles, California (CNN) — "Have you been to Koreatown yet?" my friend asked eagerly over the phone. It was my third week as a resident of Los Angeles, and I could no longer claim the pure shock of moving to a city so sprawling, so overwhelming, as the reason I had yet to explore its most interesting neighborhoods. But I had to answer "no." In a city as vast as Los Angeles, Koreatown seemed especially impenetrable, a huge warren of restaurants, markets, strip malls and residences. As much as I knew that it held a treasure trove of food, culture and nightlife, I was intimidated to even get started. Now, almost a year later, Koreatown is one of my favorite things about living in Los Angeles. It's like having an entire other city within a city, a gloriously foreign one at that. There are places in Koreatown where you look around and swear you are in Asia. And yet, it's also 100% Los Angeles: a strange, sprawling melting pot full of hidden delights. Here are eight things to know about Koreatown, things that I hope will help make discovering this neighborhood a little less daunting. 15 things to do around Los Angeles It's big Related Video: Artist earns millions with Facebook stock 00:10 Koreatown is west of downtown and south of Hollywood and is considered part of the MidWilshire district. Its borders are somewhat amorphous and have shifted over time, but the neighborhood's generally accepted area is around 3 square miles and has one of the densest populations in Los Angeles. In the 1920s and '30s it was very much a swinging spot for Hollywood celebrities, and was the location of the Ambassador Hotel, which hosted the Academy Awards in the '30s and '40s (and was also the site of the Robert F. Kennedy assassination). Though the Ambassador was torn down in 2005, you can still see some remnants of that old glamor in other buildings scattered among the newer strip malls and construction. The ever-changing flavor of L.A.'s Koreatown http://www.cnn.com/2013/04/17/travel/koreatown-los-angeles/index.html 4/21/2016 8 things to know about L.A.'s Koreatown - CNN.com Page 3 of 4 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-5 Filed 05/02/16 Page 3 of 4 Travel + Related Video: Bourdain gets 'low-down' in a lowrider 00:10 Related Video: Korean-American food true to its roots 00:10 The neighborhood has seen turmoil Live TV Heavy Korean settlement in the area cemented the neighborhood as Koreatown in the 1970s, when many South Koreans immigrated to California. In 1992 Koreatown bore the brunt of much of the violence and looting that happened during the L.A. riots, and many Koreans fled to the suburbs after the riots. But renewed development in the early 2000s, plus a new subway line with stations in the neighborhood, led to a revitalization of the area. Most of the residents are Latino This is a tri-lingual neighborhood: Wherever you go, you will hear Korean, Spanish and English, and often times a mashup of all three. This blend of cultures has led to some of L.A.'s most recognized food, such as Roy Choi's Kogi tacos, the original Korean taco truck. Choi, who is Korean but grew up surrounded by L.A.'s Latino influences, channels a completely authentic experience of America's melting pot. While L.A. has the nation's largest Korean population and Koreans make up the largest nationality in the neighborhood (22%, according to demographic analysis) most of the residents of Koreatown are Latino: 58%. But you can also find Bangladeshi, Brazilian, Vietnamese, Pakistani and all manner of South American residents, businesses and eateries in the area. Koreatown never sleeps Twenty-four-hour restaurants are just the beginning. Koreatown is home to more nightlife than many other entire cities can claim, from dive bars to high-end cocktail speakeasies, from karaoke clubs to establishments that must be a business of some sort, on the second level of a strip mall with a sign in Korean and people coming and going at 4 a.m. There's a lot of mystery here, but also a lot on full display. A few spots to get you started: In the dive bar category there's Hangover bar (3377 Wilshire Blvd.) with all you can drink beer and soju for $21.99. Lock & Key (239 S. Vermont Ave.) is a new speakeasy where you have to try different doorknobs from the foyer to get in. Inside, it's all Korea meets 1920s Hollywood glam. The tucked-away spot is fronted by Stall 239, a walk-up restaurant serving international snacks late. Koreatown is said to have the highest concentration of restaurants and nightclubs in Southern California. My Koreatown nightlife of choice? Karaoke. Most karaoke clubs here have private rooms, so you and your friends can sing your hearts out without having to deal with a bunch of drunk strangers' off-key wailings. Try Palm Tree L.A. (3240 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 401), a swank club with private rooms and songs in Korean, Japanese and English. http://www.cnn.com/2013/04/17/travel/koreatown-los-angeles/index.html 4/21/2016 8 things to know about L.A.'s Koreatown - CNN.com Page 4 of 4 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-5 Filed 05/02/16 Page 4 of 4 If strangers' off-key wailings is what you're in the mood for, you can hit up Brass Monkey (3440 Wilshire + Travel Live TV Blvd.), a more American karaoke dive bar that's good for sloppy fun. There is a LOT of good food here Koreatown is home to some of the country's best Korean barbecue (check out Park's and Genwa for high quality meat as well as fantastic banchan, or small side dishes served with rice), but there's so, so much more to explore. Soup, porridge, raw fish salads, stews -- every Korean specialty you can imagine exists in this neighborhood. It's hard to even begin to list favorites -- every Angeleno has a Koreatown hole in the wall they want to rave to you about. The fun is in getting out there and finding your own personal must-try dish. Korean food isn't all that's on the menu Koreatown is home to more than just Korean -- for instance, Guelaguetza, one of the city's best Mexican restaurants, lives in the heart of Koreatown. Expect amazing moles, live music on weekends, a ton of families sharing huge platters of grilled meats, and fun fruity tropical mezcal cocktails. Beer Belly, a newer craft beer bar, finds its home in an odd building behind one of Koreatown's strip malls and serves killer bar food along with one of the best beer selections in the city. And the rest of the neighborhood's diverse population means tremendous eateries are tucked throughout. For more on the neighborhood's food, check out some of Anthony Bourdain's recent culinary stops in the gallery above and tune in for "Parts Unknown" on Sunday at 9 p.m. ET. $15 spa day? Yes, please Korean spas are a lovely and affordable way to pamper yourself, and Koreatown has a whole slew of options. Natura Spa offers an all day pass for $15, which gains you access to the saunas, steam rooms, hot tubs and cold pool, with extra options like body scrubs available. Wi Spa is open 24 hours and has a kid's area as well as a mud spa. Korean spas generally have Korean cafes within, and many of those serve really great food, making them perfect all-day immersions. Stinky, spicy souvenirs abound There are some amazing kimchi purveyors in Koreatown, stores that sell jars of fermented cabbage and other delicious banchan. Seek out artisan producers like the folks at Kaesung Market (1010 S. St. Andrews Place) where owners have been making kimchi for 35 years. Besha Rodell moved to L.A. in May 2012 to become the lead restaurant critic for L.A. Weekly. She has previously lived in (and written about) Atlanta, North Carolina, New York and Melbourne, Australia. You can read her weekly reviews of L.A. restaurants and daily musings on the food world at laweekly.com/restaurants. Powered by Livefyre http://www.cnn.com/2013/04/17/travel/koreatown-los-angeles/index.html 4/21/2016 Best New Bars No. 10: Beer Belly - Los Angeles Magazine Page 1 of 2 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-6 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 2 FOOD CULTURE CITYTHINK LONG-FORM BEST OF LA 52 GREAT SATURDAYS LIQUID L.A. L.A. DRIVER LIFE + STYLE TRAVEL LA SOCIAL 3 74°F Search Today's Weather Forecast: Slim Shady SIGN IN 0 0 0 0 Best New Bars No. 10: Beer Belly [Koreatown] July 1, 2012 Los Angeles Magazine 0 Comments hotograph courtesy blogs.laweekly.com http://www.lamag.com/features-hidden/best-new-bars-no-10-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 Best New Bars No. 10: Beer Belly - Los Angeles Magazine Page 2 of 2 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-6 Filed 05/02/16 Page 2 of 2 • The bites from chef Wes Lieberher are such a draw that Beer Belly skirts the line between drinking establishment and restaurant. Beer lovers-turned-entrepreneurs Jimmy and Yume Han focus on quality, not quantity, with their frequently rotating selection of rare and specialty kegs. The “bar” has just a few stools, but the tables are open to drinkers as well—if you can land a seat. Good tip: Log into the bar’s wireless system and control the music from your smart phone. » 532 S. Western Ave. TAGS: 2012, JULY 2012 0 Comments http://www.lamag.com/features-hidden/best-new-bars-no-10-beer-belly/ 1 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 1 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 12 ô (https://www.facebook.com/draftmagazine?_rdr=p) ò (http://twitter.com/draftmag) Ċ (http://instagram.com/draftmag) (http://draftmag.com) (http://draftmag.net/adsdraft2/www/delivery/ck.php? oaparams=2__bannerid=94__zoneid=1__cb=7b597e60dc__oadest=http%3A%2F% 2Fwww.magichat.net%2Felixirs%2Flowkey%2F%3Futm_source%3Ddraftmag.com%2F% 26utm_medium%3D728x90banner%26utm_campaign%3Dlowkeyapril2016) Home (http://draftmag.com/) z Feature (http://draftmag.com/category/feature/) z A growing Beer Belly A growing Beer Belly FEATURE (HTTP://DRAFTMAG.COM/CATEGORY/FEATURE/) SHARE ò ô FOOD (HTTP://DRAFTMAG.COM/CATEGORY/FOOD/) (http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/&t=A growing Beer Belly) (https://twitter.com/home?status=A growing Beer Belly+http://dra ftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/) (https://plus.google.com/share?url=http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/) ÷ ù (http://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beerbelly/&media=http://draftmag.com/wp-content/uploads/beerbelly_1.jpg&description=A growing Beer Belly) http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 2 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 2 of 12 (http://draftmag.com/new/feature/a-growing-beer-belly/beerbelly_1/) Koreatown’s suddenly famous beer joint is shaking up L.A.’s culinary scene. Oh, and the fries are awesome. It’s 9:30 on Sunday morning, and Jimmy Han quickly sweeps the black concrete floors, stopping only to wipe away beads of sweat: Last night was Beer Belly’s biggest night ever, and he has a pretty good guess at what drew the crowd. “Yesterday was National French Fry Day,” he smiles. Not exactly a bank holiday, but still, famed Los Angeles food critic Jonathan Gold included Beer Belly’s Death by Duck Fries on a list of five L.A. dishes for the occasion. Even in the quiet, sunny morning, it’s easy to imagine this casually cool wood- and metal-clad space—a converted tire shop—buzzing with fry-crazed foodies, mmm-ing over metal pails of crisp strings, topped with crispy duck-skin cracklins and smothered in duck confit, before sliding them through a thick berry condiment, a sweet counterpart to savory perfection. http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 3 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 3 of 12 The man behind the fries, Chef Wes Lieberher, saunters in, double-fisting Powerade and water; he greets Han and heads to the kitchen. He’s tired, too. For both, the banner night was the sum of a two-year whirlwind that’s landed Beer Belly atop restaurant lists, earned critics’ favor and even captured national airtime on the Food Network’s “Diners, Drive-ins and Dives.” Beer Belly’s skyrocket was entirely unexpected; Han says its popularity was the biggest surprise he encountered opening his first restaurant. It’s the sort of statement that might bristle veteran restaurateurs; after all, Beer Belly was his first brush with the food world. A Koreatown native and a real estate guy with a thing for craft beer, Han wanted to turn his hobby (cracking open bottles and drinking along with online reviews, eventually collecting hard-to-find vintages and joining The Bruery’s rare-beer Reserve Society) into a new path. His vision was just a small mom-and-pop beer bar in his otherwise brew-vacant neighborhood—a family business with his wife that would support them and his infant daughter. Above all, it had to be affordable, not only to suit the area, but to be as recession-proof as possible. “The Korean culture is very ‘work hard, play hard,’ so there are a lot of places open late at night, a lot of karaoke bars, a lot of clubs. People in Koreatown love to eat and drink, so there’s a nice mini-economy of nightlife.” He’d find a new after-hours niche with the beer angle, and, determined to be “hyper-local,” turn his taps over to Los Angeles breweries. “Two years ago, I wasn’t sure I could fill up 12 taps with local brews,” he says. But while Beer Belly took flight, so did beer in Los Angeles. “Now there are so many breweries, I basically have everyone on a two-week rotation.” SoCal taps from Eagle Rock, Haven and Smog City are regulars, and the cellar list holds gems like a 2006 Pike Old Bawdy Barleywine. A foodie in his own right, Han met Lieberher at an L.A. sausage company (“Jimmy was my best customer,” Lieberher remembers). Han invited him to see Beer Belly, and when the young chef dropped by a week before the opening, he found Han in the kitchen rolling meatballs. “He said, ‘My chef didn’t show up.’ I told him I would help make him a menu, and he could see if he liked it.” Lieberher’s classically trained in a hard-knocks sort of way: He learned the ropes in the humming kitchen of a family Italian restaurant in Philadelphia, later landing a sous chef (then executive chef) position plating upscale French cuisine for the white tablecloth set. There, he honed his skill with duck, now a Beer Belly motif from those duck-topped fries to the melty Duck French Dip. He also learned to cook with wine, a precursor to deftly splashing beer in his dishes. The sausage shop brought him to L.A., but it’s Beer Belly that’s keeping him here: “I’ve accepted that here I’ve found my niche in food,” Lieberher says. http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 4 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 4 of 12 That niche is a divine brand of beer-friendly comfort cuisine, and in a city known for “skinny,” Lieberher embraces the literal beer belly with fly-in-the-face-of-fitness indulgences. After all, who could resist a four-layered grilled cheese sandwich, warm Cheddar, Asiago, Gruyere and goat cheese oozing over crisp, smoky bacon; the lightly toasted, buttery bread still crisp against a thick drizzle of maple syrup? The oft-overrated gourmand mac and cheese is also a revelation here: Skillet-served and shareworthy, each heavy forkful of Fontina, Provolone and gooey basil beer whiz gets a crisp lift from bacon breadcrumb sprinkles and a sweet honey swirl. Lieberher is masterful with beer as an ingredient, from simple statements like a witbier-battered fish to expressive octopus in a brew-infused twist on a Bordelaise sauce. His falls-off-the-bone short rib soaks in Eagle Rock Solidarity for hours; the black English mild stands as the neutral background to deep-hued, tender slow-cooked meat; spicy chipotle snaps it into the moment. “It’s fascinating how much you can do with beer,” he says. “It’s probably the coolest ingredient I’ve ever come across.” In spring, the restaurant’s beer got a few cool ingredients of its own. Patrick Rue, founder of Orange County’s The Bruery collaborated with Han on an anniversary beer, FUBRue (For Us, by Rue). The two scouted neighborhood Korean markets for inspiration, eventually landing on black sesame seeds, jujubes and azuki red beans; Rue brewed the beer and blended it with his own Oude Tart, a sour Flanders red ale. Han calls it a Korean-American brew, noting the fruity notes from the red beans and touch of toast from the sesame seeds easily married the sour. It’s just another success that’ll keep the world buzzing about Beer Belly. • (http://draftmag.com/recipes/detail/290) Beer & Chipotle Braised Short Rib with Cheddar Puff Pastry (http://draftmag.com/recipes/detail/290) L.A.'s Beer Belly tops cheesy pastry with ultratender spicy short rib. ô (http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php? http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 5 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 5 of 12 u=http://draftmag.com/a-growingbeer-belly/&t=A growing Beer Belly) ò (https://twitter.com/home? status=A growing Beer Belly+http://draftmag.com/a-growingbeer-belly/) ÷ (https://plus.google.com/share? url=http://draftmag.com/a-growingbeer-belly/) ù (http://pinterest.com/pin/create/butto url=http://draftmag.com/a-growingbeerbelly/&media=http://draftmag.com/wpcontent/uploads/beerbelly_1.jpg&descri growing Beer Belly) Next Article Figueroa Mountain Davy Brown Ale (http://draftmag.com/figueroa-mountain-davy-brown-ale/) http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 6 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 6 of 12 Previous Article Dogfish Head Palo Santo Marron (http://draftmag.com/dogfish-head-palo-santo-marron/) RELATED ARTICLES FEBRUARY 15, 2012 (http://draftmag.com/morning-after-l-a-%e2%80%99s- silver-lake/) Morning After: L.A.’s Silver Lake (http://draftmag.com/morning-after-l-a-%e2%80%99s-silverlake/) JUNE 28, 2013 (http://draftmag.com/win-two-tickets-to-the-savannah- craft-beer-fest/) Win: Two Tickets to the Savannah Craft Beer Fest! (http://draftmag.com/win-two-tickets-to-thesavannah-craft-beer-fest/) OCTOBER 9, 2012 http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 7 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 7 of 12 (http://draftmag.com/10-harvest-beers/) 10 harvest beers (http://draftmag.com/10-harvest-beers/) LEAVE A REPLY Your email address will not be published. Name (required) Email (required) Website Comment SUBMIT COMMENT ADVERTISEMENT http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 8 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 8 of 12 (http://draftmag.net/adsdraft2/www/delivery/ck.php? oaparams=2__bannerid=95__zoneid=5__cb=2358c67057__oadest=http%3A%2F% 2Fwww.magichat.net%2Felixirs%2Flowkey%2F%3Futm_source%3Ddraftmag.com%2F% 26utm_medium%3D300x600banner%26utm_campaign%3Dlowkeyapril2016) @DRAFTMAG ON INSTAGRAM http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 9 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 9 of 12 (https://www.instagram.com/p/BDoh8(https://www.instagram.com/p/BDmbp2nDDuo/) (https://www.instagram.com/p/BDjVLN_jDqI/) (https://www.instagram.c nDDr_/) (https://www.instagram.com/p/BDekSYyDDiM/) (https://www.instagram.com/p/BDdh9MSjDrN/) (https://www.instagram.c (https://www.instagram.com/p/BDZF86DjDkG/) RECENT POSTS (http://draftmag.com/sump-to-conclusions/) Sump to conclusions (http://draftmag.com/sump-toconclusions/) APRIL 21, 2016 (http://draftmag.com/pub-games-and-the-importance-of-play/) m/pub-games-and-the-importance-of-play/) Pub games and the importance of play (http://draftmag.co APRIL 21, 2016 http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 10 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 10 of 12 Oskar Blues expands Beer (http://draftmag.com/oskar-blues-expands-beer-relay/) Relay (http://draftmag.com/oska r-blues-expands-beer-relay/) APRIL 20, 2016 (http://draftmag.com/old-town-brewery-go-for-the-ghost-stay-for-the-goldmedals/) Old Town Brewery: Go for the ghost, stay for the gold medals (http://draftmag.com/old-town-brewery-go-for-the-ghost-stay-for-the-gold-medals/) APRIL 19, 2016 GET CONNECTED (http://www.twitter.com/draftmag) (https://facebook.com/draftmagazine) (https://instagram.com/draftmag) © DRAFT MAGAZINE Contributors Guidelines (http://draftmag.com/submissions/) Beer Submissions (http://draftmag.com/beer-submissions/) Contact Us (http://draftmag.com/contact/) Advertise with Us (http://draftmag.com/advertising/) Privacy Policy (http://draftmag.com/privacy/) Online Newsletter Signup (http://draftmag.com/newsletters/) http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 11 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 11 of 12 TRAVEL (http://draftmag.com/old-town-brewery-go-for-the-ghost-stay-for-the-goldmedals/) Old Town Brewery: Go for the ghost, stay for the gold medals (http://draftmag.com/old-town-brewery-go-for-the-ghost-stay-for-the-gold-medals/) APRIL 19, 2016 (http://draftmag.com/brew-cruise/) Cruise for brews on these 6 bike and bus beer tours (http://draftmag.com/brew-cruise/) APRIL 19, 2016 (http://draftmag.com/sydney-beer-bars-breweries-guide/) dney-beer-bars-breweries-guide/) A guide to suburban Sydney’s beer revival (http://draftmag.com/sy APRIL 18, 2016 (http://draftmag.com/brussels-belgium-bars-beer-post-attacks/) (http://draftmag.com/brussels-belgium-bars-beer-post-attacks/) Brussels: Where surrealism makes the most sense APRIL 14, 2016 FOOD (http://draftmag.com/best-breakfasts-chicago/) Best breakfasts: Chicago (http://draftmag.com/bestbreakfasts-chicago/) APRIL 14, 2016 (http://draftmag.com/pairing-beer-with-thai-food/) Pairing beer with Thai food (http://draftmag.com/pairingbeer-with-thai-food/) APRIL 13, 2016 http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 A growing Beer Belly | DRAFT Magazine Page 12 of 12 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-7 Filed 05/02/16 Page 12 of 12 Bartenders’ night out: New (http://draftmag.com/new-orleans-nightlife-guide/) Orleans (http://draftmag.com/neworleans-nightlife-guide/) MARCH 31, 2016 (http://draftmag.com/san-diego-nightlife-beer-dining-bars/) san-diego-nightlife-beer-dining-bars/) Bartenders’ night out: San Diego (http://draftmag.com/ MARCH 24, 2016 © DRAFT Magazine http://draftmag.com/a-growing-beer-belly/ 4/21/2016 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-8 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 1 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-9 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 1 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-10 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 2 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-10 Filed 05/02/16 Page 2 of 2 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-11 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 2 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-11 Filed 05/02/16 Page 2 of 2 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-12 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 1 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-13 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 4 http://www.beerbellyalbany.com/ 04/21/2016 DOCSOC/1757333v1/102959-0004 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-13 Filed 05/02/16 Page 2 of 4 https://www.facebook.com/BeerBellyAlbany/ 04/21/2016 DOCSOC/1757333v1/102959-0004 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-13 Filed 05/02/16 Page 3 of 4 http://www.yelp.com/biz/the-beer-belly-albany 04/21/2016 DOCSOC/1757333v1/102959-0004 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-13 Filed 05/02/16 Page 4 of 4 https://twitter.com/BeerBellyAlbany?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcamp%5Eserp%7Ctwgr%5Eauthor 04/21/2016 DOCSOC/1757333v1/102959-0004 Case 1:16-cv-00506-DNH-CFH Document 1-14 Filed 05/02/16 Page 1 of 1 0206-3657538 $400.00 DNH Case No.: 1:16-CV-0506 CFH