MT-Winter-2016
Transcription
MT-Winter-2016
President Vice President Tpr. Nate Johnson Secretary/Treasurer D/Sgt. Duane Hickok 1st District..........................Tpr. Eric Byerly Post...........................................Representative(s) Lansing............................. Tpr. James Moots Brighton...................... Tpr. Joe Pendergraff Tpr. Olivia Sivy Jackson................Tpr. James “Tony” Weldy Tpr. James Wojton Monroe........................Tpr. Herman Brown Lansing Lab......................S/Sgt. Jeff Bedell Training Division............ Sgt. Rob Schwalm 2nd District............... Tpr. Jay Morningstar Post...........................................Representative(s) Metro........................................Tpr. Rich Fell Tpr. Joel Kuhn Tpr. Daniel Martin 2nd District HQ.........Tpr. Bradley Conner Gaming.............................Tpr. Marcus Wise SID...........................Tpr. Darrin Grandison Tpr. Raymond Rollet Northville Lab........ S/Sgt. Kathleen Lewis Sterling Hts. Lab.........S/Sgt. Tim Ketvirtis 3rd District........ Tpr. Christopher Tuckey Post...........................................Representative(s) Tri-City..........................Tpr. Justin Kemerer Tpr. Donald Pisha Tpr. Don Reich West Branch.......................Tpr. Jeff Devine Tpr. Gregg Kopkau Caro............................. Tpr. Andrew Warner Lapeer......................... Tpr. Stephen Cavner Tpr. Aaron Locke Flint............................. Tpr. Troy Bonadurer Tpr. Josh Coulter Tpr. Rick Lutz 3rd District HQ............. Sgt. Clinton Keene Bridgeport Lab...................................Vacant 5th District..........Tpr. Adam Starkweather Post...........................................Representative(s) Paw Paw..........................Tpr. O.J. Hamilton Wayland...................... Tpr. Taylor Bonovetz Tpr. Kellie Summerhays Niles....................................Tpr. Jeff Miazga Tpr. James Janes Coldwater............................Tpr. Jim McRae Tpr. Jereme Miller 6th District............... Tpr. Kelly Linebaugh Post...........................................Representative(s) Rockford.......................... Tpr. Eric Brogger Tpr. Jacob Cox Hart..................................Tpr. Dan Thomas Mt. Pleasant........................Tpr. Doug Hunt Lakeview...........................Tpr. Rob Metivier Tpr. Jim Yeager Grand Rapids Lab.......S/Sgt. Shawn Baker D/Sgt. Mitchell Stevens 7th District..........................Tpr. Paul Stone Post...........................................Representative(s) Cadillac............................. Tpr. Rick Pearson Tpr. Kat Wicker Houghton Lake..............Tpr. Bert Richards Tpr. Harold Terry Gaylord........................Tpr. Jason Nemecek Tpr. Bob Krupa Alpena..............................Tpr. Jay Kurowski Tpr. David Jackson Grayling Lab.......................................Vacant 8th District.................... Tpr. David Cowen Post...........................................Representative(s) Negaunee.................... Tpr. Jonah Bonovetz Sault Ste. Marie..........Sgt. Kristyn Kuenzer St. Ignace........................... Tpr. John Janicki Gladstone.......................... Tpr. Pat Madden Iron Mountain................. Tpr. Brad Lammi Wakefield............................ Tpr. Joe Renaud Calumet........................... Tpr. Steve Lanctot Marquette Lab.............. S/Sgt. Jay Peterson Region 1 Uniform Sergeant Sgt. Frank Williams Region 2 Uniform Sergeant Sgt. Mark Tamlyn Know your rights . . . protect your rights! Region 1 D/Sergeant D/Sgt. Bill Eberhardt Region 2 D/Sergeant D/Sgt. Bob Tomassi Constitution & Bylaws D/Sgt. Bill Eberhardt* Tpr. Jay Morningstar Sgt. Mark Tamlyn Discipline Advocates D/Sgt. Duane Hickok* Tpr. Eric Byerly Tpr. David Cowen D/Sgt. Bill Eberhardt Tpr. Nate Johnson Tpr. Kelly Linebaugh Tpr. Jay Morningstar Tpr. Adam Starkweather D/Sgt. Mitchell Stevens Tpr. Paul Stone Sgt. Mark Tamlyn Tpr. Christopher Tuckey Sgt. Frank Williams Drug & Alcohol Testing Tpr. Kelly Linebaugh* Tpr. Eric Byerly Mr. Larry Schneider, Esq. Elections Sgt. Frank Williams* Tpr. Eric Byerly Tpr. Bert Richards Tpr. Adam Starkweather Tpr. Christopher Tuckey Emergency Telephone Service Committee (State 911) Tpr. Adam Starkweather Finance D/Sgt. Mitchell Stevens* Tpr. David Cowen** Tpr. Kelly Linebaugh D/Sgt. Bob Tomassi Sgt. Frank Williams Grievance D/Sgt. Duane Hickok* D/Sgt. Bill Eberhardt** S/Sgt. Allan Avery Tpr. Herman Brown Tpr. Josh Coulter Tpr. Rich Fell Tpr. Amy Hofmeister Tpr. Nate Horan Tpr. Jay Kurowski Tpr. Jim McRae Tpr. Jay Morningstar Tpr. Trevor Radke D/Sgt. Mitchell Stevens Tpr. Paul Stone Tpr. Kellie Summerhays D/Sgt. Bob Tomassi D/Sgt. Sally Wolter Mr. Larry Schneider, Esq. MCOLES Tpr. Nate Johnson MSTAF Sgt. Rob Schwalm* Tpr. Rick Doehring Tpr. Jay Morningstar Tpr. Joe Rowley Tpr. Wes Smith D/Sgt. Mitchell Stevens Sgt. Mark Tamlyn Tpr. Kat Wicker Publications Sgt. John Faccio* Editor in Chief Tpr. Eric Byerly S/Sgt. Carissa Horan Tpr. Nate Horan Tpr. Lisa Lucio MSP Retirement Board D/Sgt. Mitchell Stevens Published by the Michigan State Police Troopers Association Out Of State Funerals Tpr. Craig MacDonald* D/Sgt. Mitchell Stevens Safety D/Sgt. Bill Eberhardt* Tpr. David Cowen Tpr. Adam Starkweather Sergeants-At-Arms Tpr. Herman Brown Tpr. Rick Doehring Training D/Sgt. Duane Hickok* Tpr. Eric Byerly Tpr. Josh Coulter Tpr. Joel Kuhn Tpr. Kelly Linebaugh Tpr. Jay Morningstar D/Sgt. Bob Tomassi Transfer Review Board Tpr. Jay Morningstar* Tpr. Adam Starkweather Sgt. Frank Williams Uniform Equipment Tpr. Eric Byerly* Tpr. Paul Stone Tpr. Christopher Tuckey Legal General Counsel (In-House) Lawrence P. Schneider, Esq. Labor Counsel Mr. Timothy Dlugos, Esq. White, Schneider, Young & Chiodini, P.C. Office Staff Marketing Director Pat Strzalkowski * Denotes Chair or Co-Chair ** Denotes Vice Chair 1 ▪ Michigan ▪ Road, Suite B • East Lansing, MI 48823 • (517) 336-7782 • Fax: (517) 336-8997 • Website: www.mspta.net Michigan Trooper •Trooper 1715 Abbey Winter 2016 On the Cover Attending the ceremonial bill signing were members of the MSPTA Executive Board and Retiree/Associate Membership Committee. Surrounding State Senator Mike Nofs, Governor Rick Snyder and State Senator Tom Casperson ( from left to right) are MSPTA Marketing Director Pat Strzalkowski, Region 2 Uniform Sergeant Representative Mark Tamlyn, MSPTA President Nate Johnson, MSP Director Col. Kriste Kibbey Etue, Retiree Committee Chair F/Lt. Diane Garrison (Ret.), Captain Roger Warner (Ret.), 5th District Representative Adam Starkweather, D/Sgt. John Boggs (Ret.), MSPTA Vice President Duane Hickok, Sgt. Gordon Gotts (Ret.), and MSP Lt./Col. Thomas Sands. (Photo Credit: Senator Tom Casperson’s office.) In this Issue From the President’s Desk................................................................2 Vice President’s View.........................................................................5 Counsel’s Corner.................................................................................6 Niles Post Troopers Participate in Toys for Tots Pub Run/5K By: Tpr. Joel Service.................................................................... 7 Troopers Step-Up to Lend a Helping Hand By: Tpr. Eric Byerly......................................................................... 8 The Wheels of Justice Turn Slowly By: D/Sgt. Donald “Hager” Anderson (Ret.)............................... 10 David Cornelius Memorial Snowmobile Enforcement Detail By: Tpr. Bert Richards.............................................................. 13 Eating a Big Slice of Humble Pie By: Tpr. Marv Carlson............................................................. 15 2016 Committee Appointments Associate Membership (Retiree Committee) Diane Garrison (Ret.)* John Boggs (Ret.) Gordon Gotts (Ret.) Alan Shaw (Ret.) Roger Warner (Ret.) Matthew Wesaw (Ret.) Tpr. Adam Starkweather D/Sgt. Mitchell Stevens Sgt. Mark Tamlyn Mr. Larry Schneider, Esq. MAGAZINE In Memoriam – D/Sgt. Michael D. McGuire By: Sgt. Timothy Fitz gerald...................................................... 18 MSPTA’s 11th President Passes Away By: Lynn Marie Ketzler............................................................20 Bill Would Rename U.S. 127 to Honor Fallen Trooper By: Ken Palmer (Reprinted with permission)............................. 21 MSPTA January Quarterly By: Sp./Sgt. Carissa Horan............................................................22 Work of Troopers Honors Memory of Mapes 2016 Cpl. Sam Mapes Awards.................................................26 Hart Post Detectives Receive Meritorious Service Award........28 Theis Honors Brighton Troopers (Reprinted with permission)........................................................29 Good Job Troops!.............................................................................30 Making the News............................................................................. 32 Trooper of the Year at Tri-City Post............................................. 33 In Memory of Our Retirees............................................................ 33 Register of Deeds............................................................................. 35 MSTAF News/13th Annual Golf Outing/Project ’57........ 36-39 In Memoriam – Senior Trooper Steven Vincent By: Tpr. Derek Hoffmann.........................................................40 In Memoriam – Trooper Sean E. Cullen By: Tpr. Christopher Tuckey..................................................... 42 Final Call........................................................................................... 44 End of Watch.......................................................Inside Back Cover Editorial Policy The Michigan Trooper is the official publication of the Michigan State Police Troopers Association. Opinions expressed in this publication do not necessarily represent those of the MSPTA. Articles represent the opinions of the author. Any similarity between the people and places in the fiction and semi-fiction of articles printed, and real people and places is purely coincidental. All rights in letters to the Michigan Trooper will be treated as unconditionally assigned for publication and copyright purposes; as subject to the Michigan Trooper’s unrestricted right to edit and to comment editorially. No responsibilities can be assumed for unsolicited materials. Letters or articles must be accompanied by the writer’s true name and address. Due to legal requirements and the potential financial liability for libel imposed upon the Michigan State Police Troopers Association, the Editor of the Michigan Trooper reserves the absolute right to select, edit, and reject all articles for publication. When an article is selected for publication, writers are assured of freedom of expression within necessary limits of good taste, available space, and legal requirements. Editor in Chief............................................Sgt. John Faccio The Michigan Trooper is published quarterly by the Michigan State Police Troopers Typesetting/Layout & Design................. Pat Strzalkowski Association. Cover Design....... Cherie Morehouse/Morehouse Media For information about securing permission to reprint Michigan Trooper articles, Submission E-mail................... troopereditor@gmail.com please address inquiries to the Editor. ■ ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 1 From the President’s Desk Trooper Nate Johnson Since being elected, it has been my priority to maintain a visible presence and voice at the Capitol on behalf of the MSPTA. The legislative process is a catalyst of change, impacting active members, retirees, and the agency as a whole. I want to take this opportunity to recognize legislative advocacy efforts, as well as to preview budget highlights for fiscal year 20162017, and anticipated changes in the coming year. Senate Bill 22 Senate Bill 22 was originally born in 2010 as SB-794, as a result of the relentless effort of retired D/Sgt. Hager Anderson to address below poverty level pensions. Over the next six years, three bills were introduced and failed, before SB-22 passed in 2015 with overwhelming support in the Senate (vote 16-0) and House (vote 103-2). Hager’s selfless advocacy included 903 handwritten letters, before SB-22 was signed into law by Governor Snyder in De cember of 2015, bumping 96 retiree pensions above the State poverty line to $16,000. It should be noted that Hager himself will not see a pension increase and has been solely motivated by doing the right thing. A note of appreciation to retiree 2 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ Supplemental Budget/ New Marshall Post I am pleased to share that we are looking to graduate 150 new troopers this year. Recruit schools were bud geted for 88 recruits. However, with Senator Nofs’s advocacy for a supplemental of 12 bodies, new ap propriations now total 100 recruits. An additional 50 recruits are slated to be brought on board as a result of attrition rates for a total of 150 new troopers in 2016. As described below in the budget recommendations, sup port for the maintenance of staff ing levels is critical. Senator Nofs was also instrumental in the development of the new Marshal Post (the Marshall Regional Law Enforcement Center). While still serving as the Post Commander in Battle Creek, Nofs wrote the first business plan for the facility in 1996 and continued efforts until the new facility opened its doors in 2015. Budget Proposal FY 2016-2017 In February, we entered into a new budget cycle after Governor Snyder announced his proposals for FY 2016-2017. The MSP budgeting pro cess will advance over the next couple months through a series of hearings that are conducted in the House and Senate. During these hearings, members of the Department will testify, justifying that every dollar works into the metrics and measures of moving Michigan forward. High lights of the budget are outlined below. Investment #1: Troopers – $9.5 Million Looking at the strength report on page 3, you will note that during the 2003 to 2011 tenure we saw trooper layoffs and historically low staffing levels. In 2012, Governor Snyder made public safety a priority, supporting the rebuilding of the MSP ranks. Although we have hired 492 troopers since 2011, we have only seen a net gain of 205 troopers which is still significantly less and well below the Resource Allocation Model (RAM). The RAM staffing model was published in 2008 before our commitment to the Secure Cities Partnership and before the State lost 2,200 law enforcement officers. To put MSP staffing levels into perspective, examine staffing at Marshall, Wayland, and Brighton; 3 of our 29 posts. According to the RAM model, the MSP Marshall Post should be staffed with 77 troopers compared to the 40 currently as signed. For the Wayland Post, RAM recommends 68 troopers, but is staffed with 31. And, instead of the targeted 58 troopers for the Brighton Post, currently there are only 37. In the next five years, we have over 600 troopers eligible to retire. Without support for appropriations dedicated to hiring troopers, attrition will be detrimental to the law enforcement services we provide in all areas of the State. For FY 2016-2017, a recommend ation of $9.5 million, including a onetime cost of $4.5 million to fund an 2,236 Investment #3: Statewide Drug Enforcement Strategy – $1.3 Million 2,200 2,141 2,048 2,000 Number of Enlisted Members committee chair, retired F/Lt. Diane Garrison, for countless trips to the Capitol and MSPTA office to garner bill support. And a special thank you for the tireless work of Senator Casperson and Senator Nofs who have been key in the bill’s reintroduction and testimony on behalf of our retirees over the last six years. Senate Bill 22 would not have come to fruition without the perseverance of them all. ( This edition’s cover features the signing of SB-22, as does Hager’s article beginning on page 10.) ster, Hamtramck, Harper Woods, Highland Park, and Benton Harbor. (Each city was chosen due to their high violent crime rate.) TOTAL ENLISTED STRENGTH (AT THE START OF EACH FISCAL YEAR) 1,878 1,907* 1,873 1,817 1,800 1,826 1,798 1,807 1,807 FY15 FY16 1,761 1,679 1,698 1,679 1,602 1,600 1,613 1,400 FY01 FY02 FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY17 The FY17 projected starting strength includes 100 new troopers * The FY17* projected starting strength includes 100 new troopers expected to graduate in FY16. expected to graduate in FY16. 85-graduate recruit school. Total cost includes training, wages, supervision, patrol vehicles, uniforms, weapons, as well as computers, radios, phones and other technology. Investment #2: Secure Cities Partnership – $1.5 Million Since 2012, we have partnered with local agencies to reduce crime in four of the State’s most violent cities (Detroit, Flint, Saginaw, and Pontiac) through increased patrols and in vest igative resources of our Secure City Partnership (SCP). Deploy ment of SCP has proven effect ive, reducing violent crime by up to 45% and property crimes by up to 40%. (See chart on page 5.) What does this mean? It means there are 13,000 fewer victims of violent crime in Michigan. Recommendations for FY 2016-2017 include $1.5 million to expand patrols, investigative resources, and crime analysts into Muskegon Heights, Ink SECURE CITIES PARTNERSHIP CRIME RATE CHANGE Crime Rate Change 2012 - 2015 Cities Violent Property Flint – 45.5% – 40.4% Saginaw – 40.0% – 34.4% Detroit –14.7% – 22.8% Pontiac – 8.0% – 29.5% *2015 data is preliminary and subject to change. Data reported by 1/11/2016. Heroin, prescription drug abuse, and methamphetamine are the most significant drug threats facing this State. Opioid abuse has increased dramatically in Michigan, with drug overdose deaths tripling since 1999. Last year, Michigan had 876 people killed in traffic crashes while 1,745 died of drug overdoses. Prescription drug abuse is affecting every region of the State. Michigan ranks highest among the States in painkiller pre scriptions, with a staggering 107 prescript ions for every 100 residents. Recent data indicates that Michigan is #2 in the nation for methampheta mine incidents, proving clandestine methamphetamine labs continue to remain a significant problem. The $1.3 million would include analysts, awareness education, and additional resources for detecting, investigating, and arresting violators. Investment #4: Cyber Security and Digital Evidence – $2.2 Million The proliferation of web-enabled “smart” devices and continued ad vances in technology have inundated the computer crime unit, increasing case loads 280% since 2011. Digital evidence can effectively be used to solve crimes against persons and property, including serious violent crimes. With more than 80% of the CCU’s caseload coming from outside agencies, the $2.2 million for addi tional computer analysts, as well as technology and equipment, will be a resource multiplier for law enforce ment, prosecutors, and judges. see PRESIDENT, page 4 ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 3 from PRESIDENT, page 3 Investment #5: School Saftey One-time funding of $4 million will support additional technology and equipment grants to school districts and local law enforcement agencies to further enhance security across the State. One-time funding of $500,000 will be used to support sexual assault prevention and education initiatives on higher education campuses. Investment #6: Emergency Management Appropriations of $6.0 million to the State’s Disaster and Emergency Contingency Fund for use in assisting State and local governments with State disaster-related costs. One-time funding of $750,000 to support the development of a Vice President’s View statewide strategy and implementa tion plan for preparedness in the event of long-term power outages. Over the next couple months, I will continue to attend hearings on our budget and relevant legislation, and as always, I will keep the membership appraised on any changes. Stay safe and I look forward to seeing everyone at the April quarterly. ■ In our world at the MSPTA there are three kinds of arbitration. Number one is arbitration of a successor col lective bargaining agreement of which we have conducted twice in my career. This type of arbitration is fairly rare for the MSPTA. There is also arbitration concerning interpretation of current contract language and arbitration of discipline cases which is a common means to settle disputes about contract language or discipline. In February, President Nate John son, 7th District Representative Paul Stone and I attended a Labor Law & Labor Arbitration training conference which dealt with con tractual interpretation and disci pline arbitrations. There probably is not a better group of teachers than the arbitrators who decide and hear the cases. We learned about how arbitrators tick from teachers who are among the top tier of labor arbitrators in the nation. The topics covered the latest devel opments in labor law and labor arbitra tion. Included were sections of train ing on the seven tests of just cause, advocacy as art and science, rules of evidence, computer misuse, contract interpretation principles, contract law, FMLA, insubordination, past pract ice doctrine, job performance, drugs and alcohol and the list goes on. With the knowledge gained we are now better able to advocate for our members and engage in strategic thinking applications for our work here at the association. The classes were all taught by five nationally recognized arbitrators, with one well-known local arbitrator, George Roumell, who is somewhat of a legend. Throughout the train ing actual arbitration case facts were reviewed. Then the panel of arbitra tors would render a decision. The surprising part of the case reviews was there was rarely consensus in the arbitrator’s decisions. A large majority of the cases reviewed ended up in split decisions among the arbitrators on the panel. They almost always had disagreement with whether or not to uphold a termination or a five day suspension, for example, or allow certain evidence into the record. This is why when making a decision whether or not to go to arbitration on a proposed discipline case or settle the case, it is not easy. We are unable to predict what an arbitrator may decide. Even when the case may have seemed a slam dunk for one decision over the other, the results were very often mixed between the five arbitrators. The exceptions to the split decision seemed to involve any type of workplace violence or threatening behavior. In any of the cases involving violence or threatened violence the results were unanimous in upholding the discipline. The percentage of grievances where the employer prevailed is at D/Sgt. Duane Hickok 66 percent nationally. With proposed discipline of termination cases at the MSPTA the employer prevails forty nine percent of the time. At the conclusion of the training it was evident that the arbitration process is continually evolving and each arbitrator often times has a different approach and interpretation of the issue at hand. We found the training to be very valuable and useful especially for our discipline advocates. The MSPTA will be sending three more board members to the training in the very near future to better defend our members’ due process rights as well as their contractual rights. I’m anxious to hear their evaluations of the training when they return. Please keep Detective Sergeant Mike McGuire’s family in your thoughts and prayers and stay safe. ■ Contribute to the Michigan Trooper! The Michigan Trooper publications committee is always looking for stories from the road (past or present), feature articles of activities you are involved with in your community, baby pictures, wedding pictures, favorite quotes and anecdotes, etc. Please send all files to: troopereditor@gmail.com Deadline is May 1st for the Spring 2016 issue. 4 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 5 Counsel’s Corner The Law Student and the Trooper Lawrence P. Schneider MSPTA General Counsel A few years ago, I participated in a conversation between a third-year Cooley law student and a veteran Michigan State Police Trooper. I can only describe this conversation’s effect on me as “profound.” I had introduced this law student to my friend, the trooper, because I was participating in a mentorship program with the law student, whom I will call “my mentee.” Because my mentee, an African American young man who had been raised in an innercity neighborhood, wanted to become a criminal lawyer, I wanted him to meet a white police officer – outside of the courtroom. I wanted the two of them to talk about the law in a conversational, non-adversarial way. Their conversation quickly turned to the topic of seat belt laws. My mentee said he was concerned that we are seeing many of our “constitut ional freedoms” being eroded by legislative action. When the trooper asked for an example, my mentee cited the law requiring drivers to wear a seat belt or face a stiff financial penalty. My mentee admitted that he usually chose to wear his seat belt while driving, but he felt that the law was a “classic example” of the government restricting a choice that ought to be available to every driver. “After all, the failure of a driver to wear a seat belt is not the cause of traffic crashes,” he observed. My mentee asked the trooper, “Besides me, who suffers as a result of my constitutional right not wear a seat belt?” My Trooper friend gave a calm and moving response that floored me and the mentee. “Me.” My mentee responded, “You? I don’t understand.” My Trooper friend paused a mo ment, and said, “Have you ever been the first person to arrive at a traffic crash and seen a beautiful high school senior who has just had her faced crushed against a windshield? I have. Her boyfriend was able to walk away from the accident. He had his seatbelt on.” My trooper friend continued. “There is only one thing worse than this experience.” “What could be worse than that?” my mentee respectfully asked. “Knocking on her parent’s door at 2:00am and telling them that their 17-year-old daughter had just died in a violent car crash. Seeing their faces, and experiencing their agony, as I was required to respond to their questions about how their precious daughter had died less than an hour earlier. It is the most difficult thing about being a trooper. If she had only worn a seatbelt, I thought to myself, without saying it out loud, I would not be here.” The conversation continued for a while after that. But in that brief moment, my law student mentee had learned more than I could have ever taught him from my many years of practicing law. Both men had a tear in their eyes as they shook hands, did a “man hug,” and promised to stay in touch. My mentee has gone on to become an esteemed lawyer. My trooper friend played an instrumental role in his wonderful career. My life has never been the same. I learned how to be a mentor without lecturing. ■ Niles Post Troopers Participate in Toys for Tots Pub Run/5K By: Tpr. Joel Service 106th Recruit School Niles Post On December 6, 2015 members of the Niles Post, along with family and friends, participated in the ninth annual Toys for Tots Pub Run/5K in Benton Harbor. This year’s run The Sunset Coast Striders runn ing club took on the task of organizing the Pub Run this year and was able to deliver five hundred new toys and almost $1000 to the Toys for Tots program. This was our seventh year parti cipating in the Pub Run and our largest turn out yet. We usually have between fifteen and twenty-five people – this year we had a whopping thirty-seven! This was about one fifth of the total runners. Niles Post troopers have become a bit of a fixture at this run, mainly because of our team motto. Printed on our shirts every year, we are known as Team FIDO, which was a suggestion by Sgt. Steve Barker many years ago. It stuck. The rated “G” version of FIDO stands for Forget It, Drive On. You can guess what Tpr. Ben Mahaffie hitching a ride between stops with Tpr. Adam Kowalk. Team FIDO, 2015 Pub Run. “A PROUD tradition of SERVICE through EXCELLENCE, INTEGRITY, and COURTESY.” 6 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ featured over two hundred runners and stops at seven local bars and restaurants through out St. Joseph and Benton Harbor area. Most of the establishments provided drink specials and free appetizers for all of the runners. There was also a raffle and costume contest at the end with the proceeds going to Toys for Tots. the “R” version is. Quite simply, it means that when you run up against something that you have no control over, put it behind you and keep going. Over the years our turnout has included our post commander, ser geants, troopers, motor carrier offi cers, dispatchers, prosecutors, de tectives, retirees, and many family members and friends. There is no limit to how many we can have on the team and the only price of admission is an unwrapped toy to donate to Toys for Tots. In past years we have run in subfreezing temperatures, lake effect snow, freezing rain and high winds. This year we were blessed with clear skies and 50 degree temperatures. We were also fortunate to have traffic control at the start provided by Tprs. Duwayne Robinson and Matt Totten. This was well received and much appreciated; thanks guys! If you have the first weekend in December open next year, think about coming out to join us. It is a fun time and supports a great cause. Until next year, “FIDO!”. ■ ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 7 Troopers Step-Up to Lend a Helping Hand By: Tpr. Eric Byerly 1st District Representative 117 th Recruit School Brighton Post Brighton Post K-9 Trooper Rich Chaffee and his family have been through a lot in the last couple years. In September 2014, the family home was struck by lightning and burned down. Thankfully, the family was not home at the time and the house was rebuilt over several months. On Thanksgiving Day 2015, their youngest daughter fell on a glass vase and sustained a severe injury to her brain, requiring glass fragments to be removed by a neurosurgeon. Around New Years 2016, Tracy Chaffee was hospitalized with severe complications that required the emer gency delivery of their fourth child, Jacob Daniel. At birth after only 28 weeks development, he weighed 2 lbs., 7 oz. The PICU at Sparrow has been taking care of him day and night. The Brighton Post personnel decided to show their support by turning the January Post MSPTA meeting into a euchre tournament fundraiser at the Chaffees’ residence. Which, by the way, is a full-fledged dairy farm. Yes, in addition to work ing full time as K9-12, Rich runs a large farm. I also contacted MSTAF and Sgt. Rob Schwalm was able to get a check to Rich and Tracy right away to help out with some bills. The euchre tournament was a huge success, with about 20 entrants. Tpr. Joe Pendergraff and Sgt. Mike Sura, among others, administered and kept us going to the right tables. I managed to come in dead last, but we raised around $1000 for the Chaffee family. I was amazed by their positive attitude throughout these hardships. They are buoyed by their faith. They are thankful that no one was home at the time of the fire, and that although the medical emergencies have been extremely trying, they have all had positive outcomes. They’re looking forward to everyone being home and healthy and to settling in to their home. This was a great example of the MSP taking care of their own. Please consider contributing to MSTAF if you do not already. You never know when it might be needed by someone in your MSP family. ■ NOTE FROM THE MSTAF BOARD: This is exactly what the Michigan State Troopers Assistance Fund (MSTAF) is all about – the ability to extend financial assistance in times of extreme and unforeseen immediate need. MSTAF is an IRS recognized 501(c)(3) charitable organization. Rules and guidelines pertaining to such charitable entities are strictly enforced and followed. Requests for assistance from MSTAF must meet legal criteria, and each request is voted on for approval on a case by case basis. Nobody ever expects to “live” a tragedy or emergency situation, but having the means to step up and help when circumstances arise is MSTAF’s mission. On behalf of the MSTAF Board, thank you for your continued support; it is greatly appreciated. 8 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 9 The Wheels of Justice Turn Slowly By: D/Sgt. Donald “Hager” Anderson (Ret.) I assume many of you have heard this saying, but have you ever actually had the experience of living within the bowels of this adage? The ‘wheels of justice’ saying can be applied to a variety of judicial situat ions, however, when you are involved in trying to turn those wheels, it takes on a whole new meaning. With a youthful imagination, please join me as we walk through my experience with the slow-moving justice system. Some of you may interpret this letter as my “swan song” and in a way you may be right, but deep down I feel compelled to tell this story. My story began in January, 2010, while meeting for breakfast with some older MSP retirees from the Iron Mountain area. We ran out of stories to tell so our attention was directed to our pensions. I was horrified when I discovered we had three older troops in our area drawing pensions below the poverty level. The thought hit me like a ton of bricks – to think Michigan’s finest retirees could qualify for welfare. When I came home and told my wife what I had learned about our pension situation, we agreed that something should be done about this shameful pension injustice. I vowed to start 10 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ thinking of ways to oil the wheels of justice. With very helpful assistance from F/Lt. Diane Garrison (Ret.), chair of our MSPTA Retiree Committee, a list of all 2600 state police retirees was obtained from the Office of Retirement Services (ORS). Without names, this list included all MSP re tirees – troopers, sergeants, and command officers – retirement dates and current annual pension as of 2010. Our main focus was on those who retired before October 1, 1986 and their pensions. Much to my amazement I discovered we had 626 who had retired before that date, and we had 190 troops drawing pensions under the poverty level. Troops who retired after 1986 were covered by a more adequate pension. Armed with this unbelievable information, especially the actual number of older troops drawing poverty pensions, my next move was to contact my local legislator. To start with, I knew Senator Mike Prusi from working on a previous MSP Bill, so I got reacquainted with him. Face-to-face meetings and phone calls resulted in the introduction of Senate Bill 1433 on July 28, 2010. This bill covered just those 626 who retired before October 1, 1986, requesting a $300 per month “jump” in their pension. We felt this bill was a fair, reasonable, and less complicated way to bump up their pensions. My letter writing began. After I secured a copy of the State of Michigan Citizens’ Guide booklet which covers all the legislators (38 Senators and 110 Representatives), their committee assignments and other information, my “mass mailing” began. My letters went out to all 148 legislators, as well as a copy to the Governor and our State Police Director, just for their information. This letter told the sad story about the pensions of our older retired troops and I suggested ways to correct this situation. Bill 1433 rested in the Senate Appropriations Committee without turning a wheel and died with the December 31, 2010 end of session. A new year, 2011, brought a new two-year session along with many new legislators. Senator Tom Casperson replaced Mike Prusi who was term-limited. Representative Ed McBroom came on the scene as my U.P. Representative. Once again several face-to-face meetings with these legislators were conducted reference our cause. On November 2, 2011, Senators Casperson, Nofs and Emmons introduced Senate Bill 794, with basically the same wording as SB 1433. As SB 1433 had done, Senate Bill 794 also settled in the Senate Appropriations Committee. With this bill having over a year to gain momentum, I thought we might see some action – WRONG. Many more mass mailings and phone calls were made with Diane working the Lansing area to no avail. Once again the wheels failed to turn and Senate Bill 794 died on December 31, 2012. January 2013 rang in with again many new legislators. More letters were sent to all the newcomers, again trying to acquaint them and promote our mission. A new bill, SB-813 was introduced by Senators Casperson and Nofs with pretty much the same language as our two previous bills. This being the third time around, I really felt we would see some positive action. I thought the many older legislators would recognize the need for passage and begin to sympathize with the needs of our oldest retirees and talk it up with their colleagues – WRONG. Once again the chairman, exer cising his authority for another two years, never put SB-813 on his agenda for discussion with the other 15 members of the Senate Appropriations Committee – even though they meet every Wednesday afternoon. Sounding like a broken record and with frustration creeping in, we once again saw SB-813 suc cumb on December 31, 2014. With no action I began to wonder if the wheels of justice would ever turn. With money being the cry, Diane and I felt we might nudge the wheel if we only focused on the original 190 retirees actually drawing pensions below the poverty level. 2015 began like the previous several years with many more new legislators and mass mailings. On January 14, 2015, as soon as the new session opened, Senators Casperson and Nofs, carrying the same wording, introduced Senate Bills 21 and 22, but with a tie-bar clause – meaning one bill would not pass without the other. As usual, these bills went to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this time chaired by Senator Dave Hildenbrand. My thoughts were ignited with a spark of excitement, thinking they would have two years to work on these bills. The fourth time around for this pension issue also brought a fierce determination by Senator Nofs to grease the wheels and slowly put this project in motion. Along with Diane, retiree Gordon Gotts stepped in to lend his voice to the cause. He and Diane together, wanting to see a favorable climax to this five-year drama, attended many meetings with Senator Nofs and a representative from Budget and Management and were able to hammer out a substitute bill, SB 22S1. Drawing on information from ORS, it was determined we still had 96 retirees receiving pensions below the poverty level of $16,000. What a sad situation!!! This new Substitute Bill attached to SB-22 would bring Hager Anderson (right), and his wife, Roxanne, prepare to video chat, or Skype, into Gov. Rick Snyder’s bill signing session in Lansing. One of the bills Snyder signed regarding Michigan State Police retirees’ pensions was the result of a six-year letter writing campaign by Ander son. (Photo Credit: The Iron Mountain Daily News.) all 96 retirees up to at least $16,000. Money again was a big stumbling block, but this was finally resolved. I could almost hear the wheels turning! Incidentally, even though I retired in 1981, I am not part of the group of 96, so there will be no change in my pension. The new Chairman of the Senate Appropriations Committee, Sen. Hil denbrand, spent time discussing the addition to Bill 22 with Sen. Nofs, who was leading the charge. More letter writing. Within weeks the Senate Appropriations Committee voted 16-0 for passage of Senate Bills 21, 22-S1. A short time later the full Senate voted 38-0 to move our bills to the House Appropriations Committee. Wow, what a statement for the House members to chew on. With the justice wheel making a “half turn” my adrenalin began to reflect signs of positive excitement. Then the House Appropriations Chair proclaimed in a news release to flex his muscles. Apparently he chose to start from scratch, starting by closely examine these bills (and not by giving them a “top priority”) claiming he was concerned about setting a precedent with apparently no influence from all the previous work done by the Senate. The justice wheel suddenly ground to a halt. In a letter I sent to the chairman, I asked him point blank, “What’s wrong with setting a positive precedent?” For any state employee who has worked the minimum years to draw a pension, that pension should be at least at the poverty level. In the same letter I reminded him of the $500 million surplus the state boasted about three years earlier, and the $200 million the state gave to help bail out the city of Detroit, but no money for our own state police retirees? (I was never given the courtesy of a reply to my letter.). Needless to say I’ve been very disappointed in our justice system and the mindset of our honorable legislators – it seemed that if you put off a bill long enough, it will eventually die in the process. During this now six-year ordeal, my mind was held together by what see JUSTICE, page 12 ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 11 from JUSTICE, page 11 I refer to as my three working P’s. I tried to be Persistent, with a Positive attitude, attached to a lot of Patience. I also try to live by, “It’s more blessed to give than to receive.” The winters are long in the U.P. and so was this mission. You have to start with a projected realistic youthful imagination and a strong focus for helping to right a wrong. One last “Kudo” for Diane Gar rison and her undying work in the Lansing area: without her help we would have been lost in the wild scramble of politics as usual. On October 7, 2015, the House Appropriations voted 24 to 1 for passage of SB 22-S1. On October 20, 2015, the full House passed our Bill 103 to 2 and sent it on to the Governor’s office. Our wheels of justice made the complete revolution! I am happy for MSP’s 96 oldest retirees affected by this new law. Thank you again to all those who not only supported this project, but promoted it too – there IS a difference. My letter writing to Lansing ended at 903, and that’s snail-mail letters! Finally, the BIG day arrived with the signing of THE BILL on December 15, 2015. I was physically unable to make the trip to Lansing for the bill signing. Senator Casperson and other people in Lansing made arrangements to Skype the signing of the bill with my son, Kevin, doing the honors from my home in the U.P. This was a history-making ceremony as neither myself or the Governor had ever done any Skyping. What a wonderful climactic ending to see Governor Snyder actually signing our bill and for me to verbally thank all the people who helped work on this bill. Lastly, thank you for taking the time to read my story. Perhaps someday you too will encounter a dreadful situation that requires changing. Remember though, the wheels of justice turn slowly. ■ Sincerely Submitted, Don “Hager” Anderson MSP Retired Det./Sgt. David Cornelius Memorial Snowmobile Enforcement Detail By: Tpr. Bert Richards 116th Recruit School Houghton Lake Post On Saturday, January 23, 2016, I had the opportunity to participate in the “David Cornelius Memorial Snowmobile Enforcement” detail. The Houghton Lake Post has been part icipating in this detail for over 10 years as part of “Operation Life saver.” David Cornelius was a Norfolk Southern Railroad Police Officer for 35 years. He started the Michigan Operation Lifesaver Snowmobile Gov. Rick Snyder (seated), displays state Senate Bill 22 after signing it. Also pictured are state Sen. Tom Casperson, R-Escanaba (left), Hager Anderson (on screen at bottom right), some Michigan State Police retirees and MSPTA Executive Board members. Casperson made arrangements for Anderson to attend the bill signing via the video chat program Skype. (Photo Credit: Senator Tom Casperson’s office.) 12 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ Enforcement program about 15 years ago and was very active with the Officer on the Train (OOTT) program. He also instructed over 80 classes on Grade Crossing Crash Investigation for law enforcement across Michigan from 2001 to 2014. David was diagnosed with fibrosis of the lung in 2013 and was placed on the transplant list. He received a double lung transplant in February 2015. Sadly, the transplant failed and he passed away at U of M Hospital at the age of 65. David’s last Operation Lifesaver event was just one month earlier, even though he had to carry an oxygen tank with him on the train. He was very devoted to the detail and will be greatly missed. Our 2016 detail began at the Crawford County Sheriff’s Office in Grayling. After briefing with Mr. Sam Crowl, State Coordinator of Michigan Operation Lifesaver, and Lake State Railroad Engineer, David Murringer, Tpr. Mike Harger boarded the locomotive outfitted with mag netic MSP shields and traveled north to Gaylord, about 29 miles. Tpr. Bob Krupa of the Gaylord Post and I were on the road along with a Crawford County Sheriff Deputy. Four DNR Conservation Officers also patrolled the trails along the railroad. The plan worked well as we had police presence at each crossing and at areas where there was heavy snowmobile traffic. To our surprise, there were no snowmobile violations even though there were over 200 sleds that went by us both ways. The riders seemed friendly and mostly waved as we passed. In previous years, the number of violations were too numerous to enforce. After returning to Grayling, Tpr. Harger observed five highway grade violations involving passenger cars where Tpr. Krupa and I were able to take enforcement. On behalf of Michigan Operation Lifesaver, Mr. Crowl thanked the Michigan State Police, the Department of Natural Resources, the Crawford County Sheriff ’s Office and especially the Lake State Railroad for their participation and cooperation. It led to an excellent enforcement effort with everyone looking forward to working together again in the future. ■ (Photos courtesy of Mr. Sam Crowl) ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 13 l The note at left was received at Eating a Big Slice of Humble Pie the MSPTA off ice. As the Dallas family wanted to express their gratitude for law enforcement, we felt it important to share their message with the f ield. Voluntary Benefit Plan (VBP) Commonly referred to as the $5 Plan VBP Questions: Ms. Nonda Beebe 517-241-1007 BeebeN@michigan.gov This is a new phone number for Ms. Nonda Beebe. Please make this change in your MSPTA pocket calendar. Making the News ... Everyone loves a parade! Tpr. Lisa Smith reports that working America’s Thanksgiving Parade in Detroit to be a favorite detail every year. Submitted By: Sgt. David Malhalab (Ret.) Detroit Police Department 14 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ By: Tpr. Marv Carlson 105th Recruit School Gaylord Post Admitting you were wrong can be a bitter pill to swallow. Admitting I was wrong by publishing that infor mation in a magazine article makes that pill seem like it’s the size of a golf ball. With that in mind, here goes; I was wrong. Last fall we had a district asso ciation meeting in Gaylord. Our new 7th District Commander, Captain Mike Caldwell, and new Assistant District Commander, Inspector Mike Hahn, were invited to attend the meeting for a meet and greet. After introductions Captain Caldwell in vited us to voice any concerns we had. Ignoring the little voice in my head telling me to, “sit down and shut up Marv” I stood up and asked him why we were no longer putting snow tires on our patrol cars. I’m pretty sure I could faintly hear the little voices in the heads of Nate Johnson and Duane Hickok also saying, “sit down and shut up Marv.” Unfortunately, I chose to ignore their little voices too. I advised Captain Caldwell that myself and others I’ve talked to seem to get stuck more often in the rear wheel drive Chargers than we did in the Crown Vics. I attributed this to the fact that we are no longer swapping out summer tires for snow tires in the winter. Captain Caldwell assured me that the current Nokian tires were thoroughly tested and determined to be the best tires available for our patrol cars. He also explained that although there are many winter tires on the market, the tires for our patrol cars have to have a W pursuit rating because the Chargers are capable of speeds of 150 mph. In fact, in the Fall 2015 issue of the Michigan Trooper magazine, MSPTA President Nate Johnson described the results of the tire testing conducted by the drive track team in January, 2015. Fast forward about three months. On December 29, 2015 most of the state was hit with a severe winter storm. On December 28th, the day before the storm, the powers that be in Lansing wisely decided to close all government buildings-statewide. While the rest of state government enjoyed their snow day on the 29th, many of us weren’t as lucky and had to show up for work nonetheless. I was one of those unlucky troopers. I started my shift at 6:00am in my driveway, completely stuck in 12 inches of fresh snow. After shoveling for 20 minutes I was able to get my patrol car out my driveway and onto the road in front of my house . . . where I immediately became stuck again going downhill. Fortunately, my incar camera wasn’t recording. I could fill three pages of this magazine with the kaleidoscope of colorful language I was mumbling – each word being about four letters long. I should also mention that I possess the unique skill of being able to curse fluently in five different languages – English (of course), as well as German, French, Spanish, and Greek. I’m also hoping to pick up some Mandarin from my daughter who’s a Chinese linguist in the Air Force. Half an hour later I was able to rock my patrol car back and forth enough to get from my road onto another secondary road that had already been driven on by a four wheel drive pickup. I was able to stay in the truck’s tracks until I reached a primary road that had been plowed. I slowly made my way to the post where I parked my patrol car for the next 48 hours. Fortunately there was 4-wheel drive Tahoe available for me to use because the two midnight troopers to which it was assigned were on pass. Had that not been the case, I would have been confined to the three primary roads in Otsego County that had been plowed. Some of you may recall receiving a sarcastic (another one of my hidden talents) message from me on that date over the MDT – something to the effect of, “Don’t you wish we had snow tires?” I also composed an email to Captain Caldwell voicing my frustrations with what I perceived were inadequate tires on my patrol car. I was even so bold as say that I believed a rear wheel drive Charger outfitted with snow tires would outperform an all-wheel drive Charger outfitted with summer tires on winter roads. I would later be forced to eat my words and choke them down with an ice cold glass of humility. In the past, the drive track staff has invited command members to attend and observe the testing of winter tires in the U.P. Captain Caldwell and Inspector Hahn decided this year it would be a good idea to send a trooper to observe the testing since it is troopers who will actually be using the equipment tested. They say, “the squeaky wheel gets the grease” and I was squeaking pretty loudly. Some who know me might describe me as opinionated and outspoken . . . and those would be two of my better qualities. Inspector Hahn requested I attend the testing in Calumet and see HUMBLE PIE, page 16 ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 15 from HUMBLE PIE, page 15 then write an article in the Trooper magazine informing members of the test results. Do you see where this is going? Sgt. Mike McCarthy was the team leader and my contact from the MSP Drive Track Team. Other members of the team included Sergeants Rob Schwalm and Andy Douville and Troopers Pat Agema and Tony VanLuchene. F/Lt. Jim Flegel from the training division/traffic services oversaw the project. The members of the team are all car guys and experts when it comes to understanding vehicle mechanics, so I have to admit I felt a little out of my element. I am not a car guy. I know which pedals to push to make the car go faster or slower and I know which way to turn the round thingie to make the car go in the direction I want. That being said, I consider myself to be a pretty decent driver. I actually learned how to drive on winter roads growing up in the Upper Peninsula forty years ago. I’ve been involved in dozens (yes dozens) of high speed pursuits – most of which occurred in the 2nd District back and forth across the Michigan/Ohio state line. I’ve successfully used the PIT maneuver on multiple occasions to terminate chases and I’m still fortunate enough to wear a gold Oscar G. Olander award on my uniform. Why is it then, I asked Sgt. Mc Carthy, am I now getting stuck so often in my patrol car? And why do I now have to drive at a snail’s pace on winter roads even when responding to emergencies? I never seemed to have that problem when I drove a Caprice or Crown Vic outfitted with Good Year Ultra Grips. The problem, Mike assured me, isn’t my tires. It’s the car itself. He said driving the rear wheel drive Charger is like driving a race car and he compared it to driving a Corvette. How many Corvettes do you see on the highways of northern Michigan between December and March? Granted, in the 90’s, I patrolled in 16 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ both the Mustang 5.0 and Camaro Z-28 but that was also in the 2nd District. To my knowledge those vehicles were never used to patrol the highways of northern Michigan – at least not during the winter months. The department is already taking steps to correct the problem. We are no longer purchasing rear-wheel drive Chargers. In fact, after the few remaining RWD Chargers at the drive track are sent to the field our entire fleet will be replaced with allwheel drive or 4-wheel drive patrol vehicles. Mike said our department will likely never issue rear-wheel drive patrol cars again. Back to the issue of tire testing. The testing took place over four days February 8 through the 11th. The area was under a winter weather advisory throughout the duration of the testing. Each day we received several inches of fresh blowing snow. Temperatures were in the single digits with 25-35 mph winds which frequently created white out conditions. It appeared to be the perfect time to test winter tires. The four patrol cars tested or “platforms” as they were referred to by drive track team included the RWD Charger, the AWD Charger, the 4-wheel drive Chevrolet Tahoe, and the Ford Explorer (utility). The five tires tested included the current Nokian WRG3, the Good Year Ultra Grip, the Good Year Eagle RSA, the Firestone Firehawk Pursuit GT, and the Firestone Firehawk PVS. The Good Year RSA and Firestone Firehawk Pursuit GT are ‘all season’ radial tires. The Good Year Ultra Grip, Firestone Firehawk PVS, and the Nokian WRG3 are all speed rated winter tires. You heard me correctly. The Nokians are in fact a speed rated winter tire. The department chooses to use them year round on our patrol cars because they wear so well. Typically a winter tire is made of softer rubber and does not wear as long as a summer tire. The testing was conducted at the Keweenaw Research Center in Houghton County. The facility is located at the Houghton County Airport. It was designed and con structed by Michigan Technological University and is maintained by the university as well. The portion of the facility where we tested the tires is known as the Vehicle Dynamic Area or VDA. The VDA is a closed and gated course consisting of several testing areas. Chrysler leases the facility for several thousand dollars per day and allows MSP to use the facility free of charge as their guest. Sgt. McCarthy told me the MSP maintains a close relationship with Chrysler and it was clearly evident. Not only did our gracious hosts from Chrysler feed us quite well, but they loaned us their vehicle hoists, tools, and personnel to change all of the tires on each vehicle during the testing. One the privileges of attending the testing was also getting a sneak peak at some of the future Dodge and Chrysler models. The department contracted with Race Logic to compile and analyze the data. Go to racelogic.com to learn more about this company. Engineer Jim Lau from Race Logic was assigned to compile and analyze the data for the drive track team. The simplest way to describe how the data was collected is this. Each “platform” (patrol car) is outfitted with two GPS units on top of the vehicle – one toward the front and one near the back on top of the car. By placing two separate GPS units toward the front and rear of the vehicle, Race Logic can measure the straight line as well as lateral speed (cornering) of each vehicle as it performs the various tests. The placement of the GPS units also allowed Race Logic to determine the elevation of the vehicles as they performed the tests. This was useful when the vehicles performed the hill climbing portion of the testing. There is a circular track at Ke weenaw Research Center consisting of individual loops of 300, 600 and 900 feet in diameter. Sgt. Rob Schwalm with Tpr. Tony VanLuchene used the 300 foot circle to test lateral acceleration. Lateral acceleration re fers to the cornering capabilities of the tires. The test consisted of driving around the circle at a constant speed and increasing speed by one mph each lap until the vehicle experienced understeer or oversteer. Sgt. Schwalm performed this test clockwise and counterclockwise. During the test, the Racelogic equipment was plug ged into the car’s computer while also gathering its own data. This allowed Jim Lau to cross reference his equipment with the vehicle’s wheel speed sensors at the moment the tires lost traction and determine lateral force. To keep the testing consistent, Sgt. Schwalm performed all the driving for this portion of the testing. On each of the four vehicle platforms, the Nokian tire performed the best. Sgt. Andy Douville and Tpr. Pat Agema conducted the acceleration and deceleration portion of the test. Again for consistency, Sgt. Douville performed all of the driving for these tests. On a straight level packed snow surface at the VDA, each vehicle equipped with each tire was timed accelerating from 0 to 30mph and again from a rolling 7mph to 30mph. Each tire was tested 10 separate times with the traction control activated and 10 additional times with traction control off. Race Logic recorded the results of all of the tests and computed the average time for each tire. For both Charger platforms, the overall winner was the Nokian. While the Nokian performed the best on both Chargers, it should be noted that it took the RWD Charger twice the amount of time to reach a speed of 30mph from a stop (average of 11.10 seconds for RWD compared to 5.37 seconds for AWD). On the Chevy Tahoe the Nokian and Goodyear Ultra Grip performed the best and their results were nearly identical. On the Ford Explorer, the Firestone Firehawk PVS actually performed better than the Nokian and Good Year Ultra Grip and the Ultra Grip performed slightly better than the Nokian. Sgt. Douville and Tpr. Agema also conducted deceleration testing on the same portion of the course. Again for consistency, Sgt. Douville performed all of the driving. Each vehicle platform outfitted with each of the tires was tested 30 times. This test consisted of bringing the vehicle to a speed of 30mph before full brake pressure was applied with ABS. Race Logic logged the results of each test and then came up with an average distance and time it took to stop each vehicle with each tire. Here, the clear winner was the Nokian on all four vehicle platforms. The final test was the hill climb. Again, each vehicle equipped with each of the five tires was tested in its ability to climb hills of various grades from a complete stop at the bottom of the hill. The hill grades were 7%, 10%, 15%, and 25%. I didn’t receive the results from Race Logic for this portion of the testing but according to Sgt. Schwalm the Chevy Tahoe with the Nokians performed the best and was the only vehicle platform that was able to climb the steepest hill (25% grade). With the exception of the Firestone Firehawk PVS on the Ford Explorer during the straight line acceleration portion of the test, the Nokian tires out-performed each of the other tires on all of the vehicle platforms. Based on the data, it appears the Nokians are in fact, still the best tires for our patrol cars. If you recall earlier in this article, I said I believed the RWD Charger outfitted with winter tires would perform better than the AWD Charger with summer tires. Well, the answer is yes . . . and no. In comparing the RWD Charger outfitted with the best performing tires (the Nokians) and the AWD Charger outfitted with the worst performing tires (Firestone Firehawk Pursuit GT), the AWD Charger beat the RWD Charger in straight line acceleration. However, the RWD Charger with Nokians beat the AWD Charger with summer tires in stopping and lateral acceleration (cornering) so I guess it’s a draw. Finally, if you drive a rear wheel drive Charger, I encourage you to check the tread depth on your tires frequently. As I stated earlier, the Nokian WRG3 is considered a winter tire. There is a snowflake emblem on the inside of the tire tread that disappears at 5/32 inch indicating it is worn out as a winter tire. The tire is still acceptable for use during the other three seasons but needs to be replaced when it reaches 3/32 inch. Here is the take away. We are fortunate to have such a dedicated group of professionals working for our department at the drive track. Rather than rely on other agencies to determine what equipment is best for our patrol cars, our MSP drive track team is constantly testing and implementing new innovations that will make our jobs easier and safer. I honestly had no idea how busy these guys are and how hard they work. Sgt. Schwalm told me the drive track team approaches the testing of each product from the standpoint that they themselves may be returning to road patrol and will be using the same equipment. Their single most priority is making the patrol car safer and more functional for the trooper. I’ve been fortunate to experience a lot of technological advances in my 26 plus years in law enforcement. In the not too distant future it may be considered nostalgic to you tell your cubs that ‘back in the day’ you drove a rear wheel drive patrol car. In the mean time, if that doesn’t give you solace while patrolling winter roads in a RWD Charger, I can teach you a few colorful foreign words to mutter out loud while your camera is recording. Stay safe and keep it between the snow banks. ■ ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 17 ~ In Memoriam ~ D/Sgt. Michael D. McGuire January 10, 1964 – January 13, 2016 By: Sgt. Timothy Fitzgerald 111th Recruit School Legislative Liaison/Legislative and Legal Resources Section D/Sgt. Mike McGuire, or “Gramps” as many people knew him, was one of my best friends. When I was contacted to write an article about him for the Trooper magazine, my first thought was he’d hate this ... but I am writing anyway so he can be remembered for who he really was, a loyal, honorable partner and friend. Mike was a tremendously proud father. Anyone that worked with him always knew about he and Linda’s kids’ many successes. In recent years his grandson, really seemed to give Mike a lot of enjoyment, and softened up the old crusty Marine. Mike was a proud veteran of the U.S. Marine Corps, having served as a Sergeant in 1st Force Reconnaissance Company in the Gulf War. Mike joined the Michigan State Police in 1999, a member of the 118th Trooper Recruit School. Mike earned the Top Gun award for marksmanship in recruit school, and eventually became a firearms instructor for the department. 18 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ Mike was assigned to the Cold water Post out of recruit school, and I was his first FTO. Mike and I got along right from the start. Ironic as this seems now, one of the first calls we were dispatched to was an attempted suicide. As we entered the house there was a male on the couch with a self inflicted gun shot wound, moaning. Mike, with two weeks on the job, looked down at him, and his first comment was “you ‘messed’ that up, didn’t you?” I knew right away he would make it in the State Police. Mike always carried himself with this stern command bearing, but once you got to know him he had a sense of humor and a true ability to make people laugh. On one occasion, at the annual Coldwater Post fishing trip, he hooked his partner, retired D/Sgt. Jim Karbon, in his eye lid while casting. Mike had to remove the lure with pliers, all the while making it seem like Jim was somehow responsible for the whole thing. Mike later had the lure set in a shadow box and presented it to Jim at his retirement party – along with his version of the tale. Mike was a great story teller and could talk to anyone. I remember when Mike talked a New York City cab driver into lowering a fare. I also recall many times when he was able to get others to see things from his point of view, usually to his advantage. Mike eventually went to the Southwest Enforcement Team, where he used his “ Irish Diplomacy” excelling in narcotics investigation. Mike was selected to be on the Governors Security Detail, and served for three years until his pro motion to D/Sgt. and returned to narcotics investigations which he had such a passion for. Mike was a great friend, loyal and reliable. There were many times when I reached out to him and leaned on him, and he was always there for me. Mike was a friend to many and always kept in touch with people after transfers, reassignments, etc. It was Mike who always took the time to call people. When I spoke at his funeral, I mentioned this and challenged those present to take that time. Cherish your close friends and make those check-in calls. I know I certainly wish I would have made one to Mike after receiving an email that struck me as odd the day before he died. Unfortunately I didn’t. Mike took his own life on January 13th. Lt. Mario Gonzales, speaking at Tpr. Chad Wolf’s funeral, captured it perfectly. It’s not how he died, it’s how he lived. Mike McGuire represented every thing good about being a husband, father, friend, partner, and team member. Mike was larger than life in many ways. However, he was human, with real struggles too that he didn’t burden anyone with out of a sense of honor. To all who were fortunate enough to know him and work with him, please share your stories with those that didn’t, and raise a glass in his memory. ■ Sláinte, McGuire ~ May God grant you a generous share of eternity. ~ ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 19 Bill Would Rename U.S. 127 to Honor Fallen Trooper MSPTA’s 11th President Passes Away ~ In Memory ~ Obituary for Herbert Bradley Ketzler January 10, 1964 – January 13, 2016 Submitted By: Lynn Marie Ketzler Herbert Bradley Ketzler passed away peacefully at the home he shared with his current wife, Linda King Ketzler, on Tuesday, November 24, 2015. His passing was the result of Cerebrovascular Disease which presented itself in late May of 2015. He is survived by his children, Mike, father of Ashley and Andy Ketzler, and Lynn Marie, mother of Emma and Tyler Kremers. He was married to Georgia England Ketzler for 50 years until her passing in 2009. His oldest brother, David, passed in July of 2015. He is also survived by siblings, Peter, Mike, and Martha Ketzler, and many loving nieces and nephews. Linda King was not only his wife, she was his friend, training partner and caregiver. Linda has three daughters, Tiffany, Amanda and Tammy. Herbert was born in Flint, Michigan, on April 21, 1936, to Dorothy and Curtis Ketzler. Being raised in a rural area on a dairy farm and nursery, he grew up loving the outdoors and initially wanted to become part of the forest service after high school. During high school he was very active in football and other extracurricular activities. After graduating from Swartz Creek High School in 1954, Herbert enlisted in the United States Marine Corps and proudly served for five 20 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ years. Following the Marine Corps, his natural instinct was to continue to serve by applying to the Michigan State Police. He graduated from recruit school in 1962 and was assigned to the Jackson Post. He transferred to the Munising Post where he served the remainder of his 23 years with the MSP. Herbert received several awards and recognition for his work with the community, including the Governor’s ‘Citizen of the Year’ award in 1972. He served as the 11th President of the Michigan State Police Troopers Association. He was also very active in The Marine Corp League and Moose Lodge. Upon retirement, he and Georgia moved to Reno, Nevada. He did not fully retire, working in several areas including casino security, transportation, and tour guiding. He fell in love with the area and enjoyed being a guide so he could share his knowledge of The Great Basin with others. He also became a competitive race walker and runner, and won countless awards. The most important thing about my father was that he was a chameleon. He could be compassionate, stern, selfless, resourceful, and deeply com mitted – all dependent on the given situation. I believe that his best characteristic was his sense of humor. One of his favorite things to do was to make his brother David laugh until he would fall off his kitchen counter. He brought something different to each life he touched depending on their needs. He went too quickly and too soon and we were lucky to have him in our lives. I hope many of you are able to attend the service and share your stories and experiences so that we may keep him alive in spirit as well as our hearts. His ashes will be spread in Virginia City, Nevada – a place where he spent a lot of time researching and hosting tours. A service will be held in his honor on Thursday, June 30, 2016, in Muni sing, Michigan, at the American Le gion Post 131, 610 Munising Avenue, at 11:00 a.m. All are welcome. ■ Ken Palmer Lansing State Journal February 9, 2016 Reprinted with permission. LANSING – A section of US-127 near Leslie would be named for a long-fallen Michigan State Police trooper under a bill introduced today in the state Legislature. Trooper Craig Scott, 28, was shot and killed during Michigan State Police a traffic stop in southern Ingham County on February Fallen Trooper Memorial 9, 1982. Tuesday is the 34th anniversary of his death. Ceremony, 2011. “It’s long past time that we honored Trooper Scott (Photo Credit: Michigan State Police.) and his family for his sacrifice,” said state Sen. Curtis Hertel Jr., D-Meridian Twp., the bill’s sponsor. Senate Bill 775 would designate U.S. 127 between Bellevue Road and the Jackson County line as the “Trooper Craig Scott Memorial Highway,” Hertel said. It was along that stretch where Scott had arrested a driver and was placing him in the patrol car when a passenger came up behind him and shot him three times with a .38-caliber revolver, according to the Michigan State Police Troopers Association. Despite his injuries, Scott returned fire as the suspects fled in the stolen Chevrolet Camaro. The suspects drove into Leslie, robbed someone of an Oldsmobile Cutlass and were later arrested by the Ingham County Sheriff’s Department, MSPTA said. Both had extensive criminal records and were sentenced to life in prison in Scott’s death. Hertel said he was a young child at the time of the incident and doesn’t know Scott’s family. He said he became aware of the upcoming anniversary last year and wrote the bill for introduction on that day. “I’ve always had a tremendous amount of respect for those who serve on the front lines and give their lives in the line of duty,” he said. The bill will go to the Senate Transportation Committee. ■ Happy Birthday, Clarence! On December 6, 2015, F/Lt. Dale Hinz and Tpr. Tom Coles paid a visit to MSP retiree Clarence Bonter who was celebrating his 105th birthday! Clarence Bonter retired on December 5, 1960 from the Paw Paw Post as a specialty sergeant. ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 21 MSPTA January Quarterly Submitted By: Sp./Sgt. Carissa Horan 120th RS | Lansing Lab/ Firearms & Toomarks On January 29-31, 2016, approx imately 200 Michigan State Police troopers, sergeants and their guests converged at the Great Wolf Lodge in Traverse City, Michigan, in what has become one of the most popular quarterly venues. Those who arrived on Friday enjoyed the arcade and waterpark before catching up with old friends and getting to know some of the newer troopers at the hospitality suite. Saturday morning’s training ses sion provided an overview of the different pension systems and the importance of supplemental retire ment savings and how much extra income may be generated by con tributing to accounts such as 401ks, 457s and IRAs. After lunch the general session began with a moment of silence being offered for Tpr. Chad Wolf and D/Sgt. Mike McGuire, as well as thoughts and prayers for the family of Tpr. Rich Chaffee who have recently endured an inordinate amount of difficulties and hardships. Next MSPTA members heard from Col. Kriste Kibbey Etue and Lt./Col. Thomas Sands in reference to the hiring of new troopers (ap proximately 150 recruits over the course of three schools), the potential budget impact of the Flint water crisis on state departments, as well as the anticipated delivery of new winter hats and an upcoming vote on wearing campaign hats for the 100th year anniversary of the Michigan State Police. Both Col. Etue and Lt./ Col. Sands made themselves avail able for additional questions and discussions in the evening. Sgt. Rob Schwalm provided reas surance to members that the drive track had thoroughly tested patrol car tires and those selected were the best available. He advised all available winter and all-season tires were tested both last winter and this winter with the Nokian tire being the overall best performing tire. Sgt. Schwalm also requested to the membership to consider donating to the Michigan State Troopers Assistance Fund (MSTAF). MSTAF provides immediate cash assistance to members and families who experience unforeseen duty related hardships. Everyone who signed up for MSTAF was entered into a drawing for a 4k Smart TV (won by Tpr. Tim Roberts). Also, raffle tickets were sold for a commemorative 60th MSPTA anniversary Colt model 1911 pistol for further MSTAF funding. Additional raffle tickets – a maximum of 500 – will be sold with the drawing being held at the July Quarterly. Mr. Larry Schneider, MSPTA’s legal counsel, advised members of a potential Supreme Court ruling effecting union membership and the rights of members to opt out of paying dues, yet still receive the same benefits negotiated in the contract. Likely, we will hear more about this ruling in the future. Vice-President D/Sgt. Duane Hickok commented on a grievance currently in process with regards to lab positions being dually posted for both enlisted and civilians that deviates from past practice of offering the positions to enlisted first. Members and their families en joyed the amenities of the hotel for the remainder of the afternoon before reconvening for dinner, drinks, socializing and, of course, the MSTAF raff le drawing. The MSPTA was fortunate to have the family of Tpr. Chad Wolf present as guests for the weekend. Members of the Wolf family drew the winning raffle tickets. Historically, the Great Wolf Lodge quarterly has been well-attended and for good reason. Everyone had a great time! ■ There was a full house at the January Quarterly, held at the Great Wolf Lodge in Traverse City. I want to thank State Representative Larry Inman for taking time out of his weekend to spend with our members answering questions and swearing in the 2016 MSPTA executive board. Representative Inman is from the 104th District representing Grand Traverse County. Inman sits on the House Appropriations Committee where he has been an advocate for the Michigan State Police. Thank you to Senator Wayne Schmidt of the 37 th District covering Luce, Chippewa, Mackinac, Emmet, Cheboygan, Charlevoix, Antrim and Grand Traverse counties. Senator Schmidt donated Traverse City souvenirs to the quarterly raffle helping raise money for MSTAF our 501(c)3 charity. Senator Schmidt introduced Senate Bill 218 which would guarantee healthcare for surviving spouses and dependents of law enforcement officers killed in the line of duty. MSPTA President Nate Johnson See more Quarterly photos on pages 24-25. 22 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 23 Waterpark? What waterpark? Already been there! Tpr. Tim Roberts (Flint Post), was the lucky winner of the 65" smart tv! 24 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ Everyone had a “howling” good time at the Great Wolf Lodge! ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 25 Work of Troopers Honors Memory of Mapes 2016 Cpl. Sam Mapes Awards Editor’s Note: Introduction to this article is provided by Sgt. Mike Sura, 119th Recruit School, Brighton Post, and has been adapted from his “Ask A Trooper” column that appeared in the Livingston Daily Press & Argus on February 28, 2016. The article further includes information provided from the Michigan Department of State Police. In 1927, Al Capone ruled Chicago, and paid corrupt police, judges and lawyers to build an illegal empire. He had liquor brought in from Canada, with routes that ran through Michigan, Ohio, Indiana and Illinois. One of these routes passed through the patrol area of Cpl. Sam Mapes of the Michigan State Police. On the afternoon of May 1, 1927, Mapes made a traffic stop on two vehicles traveling through the area. These vehicles were filled with crates of an unknown liquid. Mapes questioned the drivers of these vehicles and through his investigation discovered they were indeed rum runners. The bottles in question were filled with liquor. Mapes could have easily ignored the problem, issued a citation, and let them go on their way. He could have just let them go. However, this is not the Michigan State Police way. He advised the men they were going to be under arrest. One of the men facing arrest decided to offer Mapes a bribe of $300. In 1927, a bribe of that nature would be equivalent to offering someone $4,000 by today’s standard. A lot of money – Why not? It was only liquor, no big deal, and in those days it happened all the time. However, that was not the Mich igan State Police way either. Mapes would not dishonor his department, or himself. Mapes re fused the bribe, stopped a motorist and asked him to call for assistance (in those days there was no such things as radios for law enforcement to call for back-up). While Mapes was talking to the motorist, the suspect came up from behind him, grabbed his weapon and fired point-blank range into Mapes’ body. The suspect then took Mapes’ weapon and fled the scene. Days later, after an intense investi gation and manhunt, the suspect was eventually tracked down and brought to justice. He was convicted by a jury and sentenced to life imprisonment in the Jackson prison. Now why do I tell you this story? Because, this year is the first year of the Michigan State Police Cpl. Mapes Award. The award was named in his honor and memory. The sacrifice Mapes made that day is a cornerstone in the building of integrity that was started back in 1917, when this department first formed. He refused to sway to corruption, refused to ignore the problem, carried out his duty and looked deeper into the situ ation rather than just ignoring it. The honesty Mapes displayed was important for his fellow troopers and the department. During prohibition, public corruption was rampant and there was low public regard for police officers. Corporal Mapes’ refusal to accept a bribe, at the cost of his own life, significantly improved our de partment’s image. The state police looked at data of each trooper’s activity while at work to determine the awards. These awards ref lect the best of the best, those who lead at the post. The award is presented to the top five percent of troopers in each district for the overall amount of felony arrests they make. About the possibility of being killed on the job, a police officer is one of the only professions where its ranks come to work not knowing if they will save a life, take a life or give their life. Mapes was the seventh Michigan trooper to die in the line of duty, and was awarded a Citation of Valor for his actions and integrity. ■ The award was named in his honor and memory. The sacrifice Mapes made that day is a cornerstone in the building of integrity that was started back in 1917, when this department first formed. He refused to sway to corruption, refused to ignore the problem, carried out his duty and looked deeper into the situation rather than just ignoring it. . . . The honesty Mapes displayed was important for his fellow troopers and the department. 26 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ The 2016 Cpl. Sam Mapes Awards were presented at a ceremony held at the Michigan State Police Training Academy on Thursday, January 28, 2016. There are over 1,000 Michigan State Police troopers in the department. This year, 64 troopers statewide received the award. (Photo Credit: Kimberly Dowling, MSP Photo Lab) The 2016 Cpl. Sam Mapes award recipients and their MSP posts are: First District Trooper Don Pasternak........Brighton Trooper Ray Matthews.........Brighton Trooper Tony Weldy................Jackson Trooper Thomas Kill............Brighton Trooper Dan Clise.................Brighton Trooper Ty Purdy...................Brighton Trooper Dan Verlin...............Brighton Trooper Jeffrey Duttlinger.....Jackson Trooper Lance Tedora........... Monroe Trooper David Williams........ Lansing Trooper Jeffery Schrieber.......District Hometown Security Team Second District Trooper Matt Kiser....................Metro Trooper Chris Kurish................Metro Trooper Travis Hop....................Metro Trooper Benjamin Sonstrom....Metro Trooper Mandy Coy...................Metro Trooper Armin Harba...............Metro Trooper David Skeans...............Metro Trooper Tim Madison................Metro Third District Trooper Dan Richter....................Flint Trooper John Faucette II.............Flint Trooper Thomas Pinkerton........Flint Trooper Nicholas Medina...........Flint Trooper Jason P. Coon.................Flint Trooper Bryant Greenert...... Tri-City Trooper Justin Kemerer......... Tri-City Trooper Jason E. Raymond................. West Branch Trooper Paige Kinneberg............Caro Trooper Daniel Stickel............District Hometown Security Team Trooper Aaron Locke.............. Lapeer Sixth District Trooper Chris Boven...........Rockford Trooper Jordan Lohman.....Rockford Trooper Andrew Wilson...................... Mt. Pleasant Trooper Brock Benavides..................... Mt. Pleasant Trooper Blake Bitner.......Mt. Pleasant Trooper Ben Stadler.............Lakeview Trooper Ryan Akers.............Rockford Trooper Ryan Maki..............Lakeview Trooper Jeff Hammond............... Hart Seventh District Trooper Marc R. Moore........ Cadillac Trooper Rick E. Pearson....... Cadillac Trooper Jeffrey Mercer.......... Gaylord Trooper Anthony Utt...............Alpena Trooper Michael A. Wilt...................... Houghton Lake Fifth District Eighth District Trooper Todd Workman...... Wayland Trooper Keegan Riley...........Marshall Trooper Cameron K. Sweet....... Niles Trooper Ernest Felkers......... Wayland Trooper Matthew Berry........Marshall Trooper James A. Janes............... Niles Trooper Benjamin A. Mahaffie........... Niles Trooper John C. Moore..........District Hometown Security Team Trooper Lena Wileczek.........Paw Paw Trooper Blaine Bachman..... Wayland Trooper Jeremy Cleary...........Calumet Trooper John Janicki...........St. Ignace Trooper William Crisp........Negaunee Trooper Kevin Ryan............Negaunee Trooper Thomas Nolan......Negaunee Trooper Paul Ferraro..........St. Ignace Trooper Scott A. Ritsema..................... Iron Mountain Trooper Joshua Filz.............Wakefield Trooper James Maki........... Gladstone Trooper Joseph LeBlanc....................... Sault Ste. Marie ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 27 Hart Post Detectives Receive Meritorious Service Award At a special ceremony held in Lansing, Michigan State Police (MSP) Director Col. Kriste Kibbey Etue presented D/Sgt. John Forner, D/Sgt. Scott Rios and D/Sgt. Michael Stephens of the Hart Post with the MSP Meritorious Service Award for their diligence during a very complex, 26-year-old cold case investigation involving the homicide of Ms. Shannon Siders. After failing to return home one evening in July 1989, Siders was reported missing to the MSP Newaygo Post by her father. In early September 1989, identi fication and other items belonging to Siders were found in the national forest and brought to the Newaygo Post. The area was searched where the items were found, but no evi dence was located. In October 1989, Siders’ remains were recovered in the national forest and her cause of death was ruled a homicide. Investigators established a time line and learned that Siders was last seen alive in the company of two brothers. As the investigation cont inued, additional leads were submitted and multiple suspects and theories were explored, but tips became sparse over time and the investigation grew cold. In 2011, a cold case task force comprised of Forner, Rios and Stephens, along with officers from the Newaygo Police Department and the Newaygo County Sheriff’s Department was formed to reexamine the case. Detectives examined all available evidence, collected missing 28 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ D/Sgt. John Forner D/Sgt. Scott Rios D/Sgt. Michael Stephens Theis Honors Brighton Troopers documents and compiled a list of suspect theories. After the task force indexed the report of over 2,000 pages and conducted over 500 interviews, the original suspects were again identified as prime suspects in the case. In June 2014, homicide warrants were obtained and the suspects were arrested. The case went to trial in April 2015 and in May 2015 one suspect was convicted of first degree murder and the other suspect was convicted of second degree murder. In awarding Forner, Rios and Stephens with the department’s Meritorious Service Award, the MSP Board of Awards recognizes that without their dedication and expert investigative skills, justice may have never been obtained for Siders. Forner joined the department in 1998, graduating as a member of the 117th Trooper Recruit School. Prior to being assigned to the Hart Post, he served at the Grand Haven and Rockford posts, as well as the Sixth District Headquarters. Rios joined the department in 1988, graduating as a member of the 103rd Trooper Recruit School. Prior to being assigned to the Hart Post, he served at the Ypsilanti, Detroit, Lakeview, Grand Haven and Newaygo posts. Stephens joined the department in 1999, graduating as a member of the 118th Trooper Recruit School. Prior to being assigned to the Hart Post, he served at the Newaygo, Lakeview and Mt. Pleasant posts. ■ Michigan Rep. Lana Theis presents an award to Michigan State Police Trooper James Gilmer. Lisa Roose-Church Livingston Daily Press & Argus February 17, 2016 Reprinted with permission. Photos courtesy of Lisa Roose-Church/ Livingston Daily. State Representative Lana Theis presented Troopers James Gilmer, Donald Pasternak and Raymond Matthews with a plaque at a brief ceremony Monday at the post on Buno Road in Brighton Township. “It’s a unique time in policing,” Theis, R-Brighton Township, said. “The defense of our first responders is huge. … I find it amazing the frustration against our police officers by some of those in the community. “I think the vast majority of us really appreciate what you do and understand to the extent that some civilians can’t understand how much time and effort you put into this and it is your life,” she told the troopers. “There is never actually a time you put it down. It’s important to recognize when you go above and beyond.” Gilmer, who has been with the state police for 15 years, was recognized for saving a woman who suffered a life-threatening self-inflicted leg wound. Gilmer said although he is aware not everyone in the community trusts police offices, it is officers’ goal “everyday to build that trust” and to work with the community. Pasternak, whose childhood dream Michigan Rep. Lana Theis presents an award to Michigan State Police Trooper Donald Pasternak. was to be an officer, echoed Gilmer’s sentiment. Theis recognized Paster nak, who has been at the Brighton Post for more than three years, for providing emergency medical care to a semi driver who was trapped in his vehicle and suffering serious injuries from a multi-vehicle crash in January, 2015, in Washtenaw County. “I think it’s great the community recognizes us for positive things,” he said. Matthews agreed, but he deflected recognition from himself to the Brighton Post troopers as a whole. Matthews, who has been a trooper Michigan Rep. Lana Theis presents an award to Michigan State Police Trooper Raymond Matthews. for five years, helped a motorcyclist who was “in a state of delirium” and suffering from life-threatening injuries in September, 2014. Matthews helped stop the man’s blood flow and helped keep him conscious until paramedics arrived on scene. “It’s nice to shine the light; not on me personally, but on the post and police in general,” Matthews said. “It’s our job. I was only doing my job. I’m supposed to help.” ■ Michigan Representative Lana Theis, R-Brighton Township, recognized three state police troopers from the Brighton Post on Monday for saving citizens’ lives. Pictured, from left, Lt. Kevin Caldwell, Trooper James Gilmer, Theis, T roopers Donald Pasternak and Raymond Matthews, and Post Commander F/Lt. Joel A llen. ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 29 Good Job Troops! LARCENY OF ELECTRICITY/ UDAA RECOVERY: On 01/03, Tprs. Jeff Lowder and Tiler Bacon were in vest igating a larceny of electricity from Consumers Power. Tprs. Bacon, Lowder, and Tpr. Jeffrey Duttlinger made contact at the residence. A LEIN check was conducted on all occupants. A male and female, visiting from Arkansas, were wanted out of the Oklahoma for felony UDAA. Tpr. Lowder interviewed the caretaker of the home and he gave a full confession to the theft of the electricity. Troopers also noticed a white van in the yard with no registration plate. Upon further investigation, Troopers noticed the ignition had been punched and a leatherman tool was on the driver’s seat. A VIN check was done showing the vehicle to be confirmed stolen out of Arkansas. Tpr. Lowder also located suspected methamphetamine from the male out of town visitor. Both the male and female were lodged at the Hillsdale County Jail for possession of stolen property, outstanding warrants, and possession of methamphetamine. The subjects will also be awaiting extradition back to Oklahoma. Great investigative teamwork by all! Further investigation to continue by the Jackson Post. AUTH: Sgt. Frank Williams – MSP Jackson Post PWID/ATTEMPTED DRUG SMUGGLING INTO A STATE PRI SON/FUGITIVE: D/Sgt. Mi chael Schroeder, Sault Ste. Marie Post, received a call from Kinross Correction al Facility regarding a suspicious SUV, silver in color, driving near the prison. D/Sgt. Schroeder called Chippewa County Central Dispatch and requested a BOLO aired on the vehicle. Tpr. Ryan Godfrey, St. Ignace Post stopped the vehicle just prior to it crossing the Mackinac Bridge. D/Sgt. Gary Demers, St. Ignace Post interv iewed the driver and passenger after receiving additional information from D/Sgt. Schroeder. MDOC recovered several canisters in the woods near the prison containing 7 cell phones and approximately 2 pounds of marijuana. Eventually, both suspects admitted to their involvement. There is a female believed to be involved from the 30 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ Kincheloe area. A first name was given and D/Sgt. Schroeder was able to obtain a last name from checks with local law enforcement. MIOC analysts were re quested to assist with a work up on the relationship and origin of the drug dealer (aka: JRock) out of the Detroit area. As of now, 8th District HST is transporting the male driver (age 20) and male passenger (age 22) to the Chippewa County Jail on charges of PWID and Attempted Drug Smuggling into a State Prison. The passenger also had a felony warrant out of Detroit for Assault with a Dangerous Weapon. Excellent team work by all involved personnel! AUTH: D/F/Lt. Robert Pernaski, 8th District HQ – SIS 3rd DISTRICT FUGITIVE TEAM: The 3rd District Fugitive Team was requested to attempt to locate and arrest a man wanted in Indiana for Homicide. Detectives reported the man shot the victim to death at a motel in Indian apolis and was rumored to have fled to the Flint area. Multiple days were spent on surveillance with the assistance of HST and the Flint FBI Safe Streets Team. Contact was made with multiple family members and friends of the sus pect, resulting in numerous arrests for unrelated drug and gun crimes. Infor mation received from an arrest led the Team to an address in the City of Flint. The Homicide suspect was finally arrested on 1/5 with the assistance of FBI Safe Streets and Tpr. Joseph Labelle (K9-31) with his recently healed partner, “Zeke”. The suspect now awaits extradition back to Indiana. AUTH: D/Sgt. Joe Jones, 3rd District Fugitive Team SAULT STE. MARIE POST AC TIV I T Y: Tpr. Dan Browne began an embezzlement investigation on 10/19/15. The complainant, a business owner in Newberry, found possible evidence that one of his employees was embezzling money from at least one of the companies’ gas stations. Tpr. Browne was able to ascertain through his investigation that an employee and her husband had embezzled in excess of $100,000.00 over several years, maybe as much as $500,000. On January 5th, Tpr. Browne arrested the employee on a 2 count felony warrant for Conspiracy to commit Embezzlement $100,000.00 or more & Embezzlement $100,000.00 or more and her husband on a 1 count felony warrant for Conspiracy to commit embezzlement $100,000.00 or more. To add a little salt to the wounds, the suspect is receiving unemployment compensa tion for being fired for theft. AUTH: F/Lt. David Hopper, Sault Ste. Marie Post TRAVERSE NARCOTICS TEAM ACTIVIT Y: Tpr. Andrew Wilson of the Mt. Pleasant post conducted a traffic stop of an individual which turned into a successful confidential informant for TNT. An undercover officer was able to go direct with the suspect and completed successful purchases of marijuana from the suspect within the past three months. On 01/06, TNT executed a search warrant at a residence in Reed City, MI. Subsequent to the search warrant TNT seized a marijuana grow operation (21 plants) along with processed marijuana packaged for resale, scales, TNT buy money, a long gun, cross bow, and drug proceeds. In addition, interviews were conducted at the suspect’s residence which revealed that the suspect was selling Marijuana to high school students from the Reed City area. The suspect was lodged at the Osceola County Jail on numerous Drug Felony charges. AUTH: D/Lt. Dan King, TNT PUTTING OUT FIRES: At the con clusion of Sgt. Dale Lynema’s after noon shift on 01/14, he overheard a fire department call concerning a truck fire that was burning next to an attached garage of a residence. This location was close to Sgt. Lynema’s home, and he responded to the scene to assist. Tpr. Blaine Bachman also responded. Upon their arrival they found that the truck was almost fully engulfed in flames. The homeowner and a local volunteer fire fighter had just utilized two fire extinguishers with nil results. After Sgt. Lynema’s extinguisher had been emptied, everyone at the scene began to shovel snow onto the burning truck, which slowed the fire considerably. A fire truck eventually arrived and completely extinguished the remaining flames. The actions of all involved undoubtedly minimized the potential property dam age. This successful conclusion was an unanticipated benefit of the Assigned Vehicle Program. AUTH: Sgt. Michael Jafri, Wayland Post 2nd DISTRICT HST: On 01/16, 2nd District HST stopped a rental vehicle on s/b I-75 in Monroe County for im proper lane use. While speaking with the occupants of the vehicle, troopers became suspicious and asked for con sent to search. Consent was granted and a searched was conducted. While searching the vehicle, troopers located 444 oxycodone pills hidden behind the carpeting in the trunk. The passenger of the vehicle admitted to the pills and stated that he was paid $500 to deliver the pills to Loraine, OH. Also on 01/16, 2nd District HST stopped a vehicle for following too closely on s/b I-75 in Monroe County. After speaking with the occupants of the vehicle, troopers became suspicious and asked for consent to search. Consent was denied. K9-20 and “Otto” performed a sniff around the vehicle, giving a positive indication for narcotics. The vehicle was then searched. 778 oxycontin pills were located hidden in the dash, behind the radio. The driver of the vehicle was arrested for PWID analogues. Auth: Sgt. John Duffy, 2nd District HST METRO POST, UNLAWFUL IM PRISONM ENT/DOMESTIC: On 01/10, Tprs. William Dobberstein, David Busacca and Samuel Lentine (Bruce Twp. detachment) responded to a 911 call of a domestic in progress. Upon arrival Troopers observed through a window a male walking around in the residence. The male refused to answer the door as troopers repeatedly requested. When Tprs. overheard a female screaming and crying inside the residence, they forced their way inside and located the 40 year old female locked against her will inside the bathroom. The 32 year old male had retreated to the basement. Tprs. cautiously made entry into the basement locating the belligerent male suspect and after a brief confrontation took him into custody. The suspect had several warrants for probation violation and a PPO against him from the victim. It was also learned that Tpr. Dobberstein had previously arrested the same suspect for domestic violence against the victim on 12-20-15 and was awaiting trial. After interviews (and multiple threats of future retribution from the suspect) the suspect was lodged on charges of Unlawful Imprisonment, MDOP and probation violations. Fantastic Job by all troopers involved. AUTH: Sgt. Jay Rider, Metro Post, Bruce Twp. Detachment SAGINAW SCP ACTIVITY: On 01/19, Tprs. Adam Whited and Justin Kemerer initiated a traffic stop on a vehicle for an equipment violation. The passenger identified himself with a false I.D. card and fled on foot when he was about to be confronted by the troopers. A foot pursuit ensued and the passenger was eventually caught and identified utilizing the Mobile I.D. Fingerprint Scanner. He had three felony warrants in LEIN for AWIM, Possession of Cocaine, and Felonious Assault. A search of the vehicle located 2 stolen semi-automatic handguns, .40 cal. Ruger and .45 cal. Springfield, both loaded. Both driver and passenger lodged for several charges including, CCW, Felon in Possession of Firearm, Possession of Analogues, and Possession of Stolen Firearm. AUTH: Lt. John Julin, Tri-City Post WAYLAND POST ACTIVITY: On 01/19, Tpr. Anthony Adams was dis patched to a residential fire in south ern Barry County. While on scene, fire department personnel advised Tpr. Adams they observed signs of illegal drugs while extinguishing the fire in the residence. Tpr. Adams entered the residence to ensure no persons remained inside. While clearing the residence, Tpr. Adams observed marijuana plants growing in multiple locations. SWET was contacted to assist with the inves tigat ion. The homeowner arrived at the scene but refused consent to search his house. SWET detectives obtained a search warrant for the residence. During the search SWET detectives located and seized one hundred forty seven (147) marijuana plants, BHO, and a firearm. The homeowner told SWET detectives he was a member of the Cannabis Church in Hawaii and believed he could possess marijuana due to his religious beliefs. Charges will be sought against the homeowner. AUTH: D/Sgt. Raymond Durham, SWET FLINT ACTIVITY: Tprs. Thomas Pinkerton and Derek Hoffmann ob served a subject walking in the road way on Brownell where sidewalks are prov ided and attempted to contact the subject and in doing so the subject fled on foot. As he was running away Tpr. Hoffman observed the subject with a black metallic object in his hand. The subject was apprehended after troopers searched the area. Once in custody the subject did not have anything on his person. The suspect tracks were traced in the snow and it lead troopers to a brush pile where a loaded .357 magnum was recovered. The subject was interviewed and admitted to having the weapon and trying to hide it after he ran. AUTH: Lt. Amy Dehner, Flint Post MSP JACKSON POST LIFE SAV ING: On 1-26, Tprs. Stephen Kings ley and Kyle Michael were dispatched to the city of Litchfield for a report of a 21 year old male who was trying to hang himself. Troopers arrived and found the victim hanging from a rope around his neck that was tied to a tree. The victim’s friend who saw the attempt from inside a residence, was trying to hold up the victim. Trooper Michael helped to hold the victim up, while Trooper Kingsley climbed the tree and cut the rope freeing the victim. The victim who later became combative with EMS is expected to survive. AUTH: Sgt. Toby Baker, MSP Jackson Post WEST BRANCH POST LIFE SAV ING: On 1/26, Tpr. Robert Lee, a Gladwin PD officer, and a Gladwin County sergeant responded to a house fire on Hockaday Road in Gladwin County. Upon arrival, the house was engulfed in flames. Tpr. Lee and the Gladwin officer gained entry into the residence and located an elderly woman who was unconscious and not breathing. They removed her from the residence and initiated rescue breathing and revived the victim. Tpr. Lee was treated and released for smoke inhalation. AUTH: F/Lt. Chris Luty, West Branch Post ■ ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 31 Making the News ... Trooper of the Year at Tri-City Post Trooper Among Monroe County’s Officers of the Year At a time when many police officers around the country are being vilified or targeted, four in Monroe County are being commended and congratulated. On Thursday, February 11, 2016, during the Monroe Exchange Club’s 47th annual Officer of the Year event, 38th Circuit Judge Mark S. Braunlich spoke of how it seems some people are waiting for the next police video to go viral. “Accordingly, the importance of recognizing and acknowledging the efforts of law enforcement is more important than ever,” the judge told the audience. “The quality of life we enjoy in our community is dependent on dedicated law enforcement pro fessionals.” He called the four recipients “in strumental leaders in making our community a safer place for us and our families.” The four are Michigan State Police Trooper Robert Bow of the Monroe Post; South Rockwood police Officer Greg Henke, Monroe County Sheriff’s Detective Jeff Hooper, and Cpl. Daniel Clanton of the Monroe Police Department. Trooper Bow, 34, has been a state police officer for seven years. He has served on the Emergency Support Team and as a detective in the drug unit MANTIS. Since 2013 he has been a volunteer trainer for the Monroe High School football team and assists in mentoring young men with advice on leadership and personal responsibility. He also serves as a field training officer and represents the department in ceremonial details. “I have found him to consistently maintain a positive attitude regardless of the circumstances faced,” said F/ Lt. Tony Cuevas, post commander. “He accepts assignments without hesitation and strives to do his personal best.” Trooper Bow, a member of the 121st Trooper Recruit School, is a seven-year veteran of the Air Force where he earned the rank of staff sergeant and served two tours of duty in Iraq. “This is a great event, the only event of its kind,” he said. “It means a lot to us to be recognized for the work we put in. I feel humbled.” Trooper Bow and his wife, Amy, have an 18-month-old son, Michael. ■ LAPEER, Michigan (WEYI: Reprinted with permission.) — The family of a little boy rescued from a burning house is thanking Michigan State Police troopers. “We thought he was dead. It’s pretty hard,” said father Curt Lewis. Holding back tears, Curt Lewis from Lapeer relived the moments his home caught fire with his son Ashton still trapped inside. He says Troopers Jared Grigg and John Sholtz rushed to the house and quickly sprang into action. Firefighters say they ran into the burning home. Sholtz found Ashton and Grigg safely removed him and began first aid. They were heroic efforts, but these troopers say they were just doing their job. “It’s kind of a blur of what happened. I couldn’t tell you any of the radio traffic or what we were talking about. We knew there was someone in there and we had to get them out,” said Trooper Grigg. “It’s what we were trained to do, it’s what we volunteered to do when we became police officers,” said Trooper Sholtz. Everyone else made it out of the home safely. Lewis says words cannot express how grateful he is to Troopers Grigg and Sholtz for risking their own lives to save his son’s. ■ A 6-year-old was rescued from a house fire Monday (January 4, 2016) by Michigan State Police troopers. (Photo Credit: Michigan State Police) 32 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ A state police trooper at the Mich igan State Police Tri-City Post in Williams Township has been named Trooper of the Year. MSP Director Col. Kriste Kibbey Etue and Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette presented the Dr. Carl A. Gerstacker Trooper of the Year Award to Trooper Michael Darrow at a special ceremony in Lansing on Thursday, January 21, 2016. The Gerstacker Award recogn izes a trooper or sergeant who symbolizes outstanding professional ethics, dedi cation to duty and a concern for giv ing back to their community. The late Carl A. Gerstacker, former chairman of Dow Chemical Company, created the award in 1961. Schuette is Gerstacker’s stepson. “Trooper Darrow’s exceptional work performance, leadership skills and dedication to community out reach make him an excellent choice for the Trooper of the Year Award,” Etue said in a press release. Darrow has been with the agency for 15 years. He serves as a commu nity service trooper at the Tri-City Post, 2402 Salzburg Road, where he has taken on multiple leadership roles in work and community-related Trooper Michael Darrow programs, and is known for his dedi cation to service. Darrow is instrumental in several MSP community outreach initiatives, such as Light Up the City and the Community Action United Team In Our Neighborhood program, known as CAUTION. Darrow also serves as a team leader for the Michigan Special Olympics Torch Run and oversees the new cadet program being established for the MSP Third District covering the Flint, Saginaw, and Bay City areas. Darrow serves as an instructor for the Student Tools for Emergency Plann ing (STEP) program, the MSP Teaching, Educating and Mentoring (TEAM) curriculum and for the youth leadership academies for atrisk youth held at the MSP Training Academy in Lansing. He has also assisted a local law enforcement agency with organizing its leadership academy and served as an instructor and mentor for the program. Darrow is a horse leader for the Bay County 4-H Horsemanship for Handicappers, a nonprofit organi zat ion that provides therapeutic and recreational horseback riding to children and adults with physical, emot ional, mental and social chal lenges. He and his family own all of the horses used in the program. In addition, Darrow helped a local recording artist Kyrsta Strickland organ ize a 5-on-5 basketball tourna ment between youth and law enforce ment officers to help strengthen the relationship between the community and law enforcement. As a result of the event’s success, the sponsor agreed to hold the tournament annually. Darrow served in the U.S. Army from 1986 to 1991 and he attended Central Texas University. He hails from Mackinaw City and currently resides in Bay City with his wife. ■ In Memory of Our Retirees Lt. Duane Thayer (Ret.)..........................................28th Recruit School............ 5/8/1926 – 12/28/2015 D/Sgt. Duane F. Baley (Ret.)............................... 42nd Recruit School.............. 5/20/1930 – 1/5/2016 Tpr. Ralph A. Graham, Jr. (Ret.)......................... 73rd Recruit School............ 7/26/1943 – 1/10/2016 D/Sgt. Larry W. Beals (Ret.)................................ 72nd Recruit School..........10/31/1943 – 1/14/2016 Lt. Francis “Frank” C. Heckaman (Ret.)..........40th Recruit School..........11/30/1930 – 1/18/2016 Sgt. Edward A. Heribacka (Ret.)......................... 42nd Recruit School............ 1/30/1931 – 1/28/2016 D/Sgt. Ralph E. Kartheu (Ret.)...........................41st Recruit School............. 3/19/1931 – 1/29/2016 D/Sgt. Arthur W. Neigebauer (Ret.)...................29th Recruit School............ 5/14/1924 – 2/17/2016 Former Tpr. Norman G. Rushing (Ret.)........... 62nd Recruit School............ 4/13/1937 – 2/26/2016 Sgt. William C. Burk (Ret.)....................................60th Recruit School.............. 9/4/1940 – 2/29/2016 ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 33 Contribute to the Michigan Trooper Magazine! Register of Deeds Submitting material for publication in the Michigan Trooper magazine? Send all files to: troopereditor@ gmail.com Please provide captions for images when possible, including name(s) of those pictured, and name/details of the event. Inspector Emmitt McGowan (right) is welcomed to his new position as the Department’s advocate in arbitration cases by two veterans of the process. MSPTA lawyer, Larry Schneider (left), has represented the MSPTA since the very first arbitration hearing was held in 1981. Samuel McCargo (center) is the longest serving arbitrator on the MSPTA-MSP panel, having rendered decisions in every decade since joining the panel in 1985. Raff le Tickets On Sale Now! MSTAF’s first gun raffle is underway! This 60th Anniversary 1911 Colt .45 caliber pistol was generously donated to the MSPTA by Steve Progler (Capt. Steve) out of Standish, Michigan. Steve is one of the top five Colt dealers in the country and recently came across the pistol. The pistol has been in the MSP family since 1977 and we plan to keep it that way. Tickets are only available for purchase to active and retired enlisted members of the MSP. Additionally, only 500 tickets are available for sale. Ownership history was published in the Fall 2015 issue of the Michigan Trooper magazine (page 3) and will be provided to the winner. Ticket sales for the Colt 1911 pistol began at the January Quarterly and will be available at district meetings, the April, and July quarterlies, and at the MSPTA office. Addit ionally, you can view the pistol and purchase tickets at Scorin-rite Firearms Sales and Instruction (scorin-rite.com), 1163 N. Bradley Road, Charlotte, Michigan. Stop by the MSPTA office during business hours, or mail your check (MSPTA, 1715 Abbey Road, Suite B, East Lansing, MI 48823) and we will complete your ticket(s) and mail your stub to you. Good Luck! ■ 60th Anniversary 1911 Colt .45 Caliber Pistol Tickets available to MSP active and retired enlisted only. Tickets $20 • Limited drawing – only 500 tickets available. Drawing: July 12, 2016 (Need not be present to win.) 34 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ Deadline is May 1st for the Spring 2016 issue. Trooper William Smith (Tri-City Post), and his wife, Joni, announce the birth of their son, Liam Peter Smith. Liam was born on November 21, 2015, was 20" long and weighed 7 lbs., 11 oz. Liam joins his big sister, Kaitlyn, at home. ~~~~~~~~~ THIS IS YOUR MAGAZINE! Do you like to write? Do you have a f lair for journalism? If you are interested in being on the Publications Committee, contact the editor, Sgt. John Faccio, FaccioJ@michigan.gov or Pat Strzalkowski at the MSPTA office, pat@mspta.net Trooper Korey Rowe (Second District Fugitive Team), and his wife, Samantha, announce the birth of their second daughter, Sadie Leigh Rowe. Sadie was born on December 20, 2015, was 20-1/2" long and weighed 8 lbs. Sadie joins her big sister, Sophia, at home. ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 35 $500 $250 $100 $75 OTHER $ ______________ OR BI-WEEKLY CONTRIBUTION $20 $15 $10 $5 OTHER $ _____________ (989) 773-6830 I would like to donate to the Michigan State Troopers Assistance Fund in the following manner: ANNUAL LUMP SUM 1559 South Chippewa Road | Mt. Pleasant, MI 48858 May 23, 2016 The Michigan State Troopers Assistance Fund (MSTAF) was formed by the Michigan State Police Troopers Association in 1993 as a non-profit charitable organization under 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. MSTAF provides assistance to families affected by law enforcement tragedies and supports other 501(c)(3) charities and charitable causes throughout Michigan. Donations to MSTAF are tax deductible charitable contributions. 18 Holes 4-Person Scramble 9:00 a.m. Registration 10:00 a.m. Shotgun Start (Monday before Memorial Day) East Lansing, MI 48823 at ... 1715 Abbey Road, Suite B East Lansing, MI 48823 (517) 336-7782 http://mspta.net/mstaf/about-mstaf OR ONE-TIME GIFT $500 $250 $100 $75 OTHER $ ______________ Annual lump sum and bi-weekly contributions are recurring donations. AUTHORIZATION AGREEMENT FOR DIRECT PAYMENTS (ACH DEBITS) Date ________________________ schwalmr@michigan.gov Sgt. Rob Schwalm (517) 861-6412 rowleyj@michigan.gov Tpr. Joe Rowley (989) 370-6555 doehrinr@charter.net Tpr. Rick Doehring (231) 649-7925 Questions, contact: (Mention the MSTAF Outing) Super 8 989-773-8888 $75 + taxes $99 + taxes SSN Last Four Digits XXX-XX- ____________ Signature __________________________________________________ ~PLEASE ATTACH A VOIDED CHECK OR DEPOSIT SLIP FOR ACCURATE PROCESSING~ NOTE: DEBIT AUTHORIZATIONS MUST PROVIDE THAT THE RECEIVER MAY REVOKE THE AUTHORIZATION ONLY BY NOTIFYING THE ORIGINATOR IN THE MANNER SPECIFIED IN THE AUTHORIZATION. Please provide the following information to receive a tax year-end receipt of charitable MSTAF donations. One-time donors will receive a receipt shortly after funds are transferred. Email __________________________________________________ Mailing Address: The Michigan State Troopers Assistance Fund is a non-profit 501(c)(3) charitable organization governed and operated by volunteers from the Michigan State Police Troopers Association, Inc. 36 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ The Michigan State Troopers Assistance Fund tax identification number is 38-3113607. (Please Print) Members of the MSTAF Board serve without compensation, and 100% of proceeds are devoted to programs administered by the Assistance Fund. Name ________________________________________ Cut-off date: 5/1/2016 This authorization is to remain in full force and effect until COMPANY has received a signed, written notification by mail or electronic facsimile from me (or my estate) of its termination in such time and in such manner as to afford COMPANY and DEPOSITORY a reasonable opportunity to act on it. (Mention MISTATETROOP) Savings Account (Select One) The Michigan State Troopers Assistance Fund (MSTAF was founded in 1993 as an IRS approved 501(c)(3) nonprofit charitable organization. MSTAF provides assistance for families affected by law enforcement tragedies and supports other 501(c)(3) charities and charitable causes throughout Michigan. Checking Account 989-817-4801 or 877-2EAGLE2 Account Number ____________________________ (includes waterpark entrance) Routing Number ___________________________ Soaring Eagle Waterpark & Hotel State ___________________ Zip ______________ available for Sunday, 5/22 and Monday, 5/23: City _____________________________________ Lodging Options Branch____________________________________ (based on double occupancy) Depository Name __________________________ Special day before/ day after golf rates: Sunday $65 (regularly $98) between 1:00 and 2:50. $55 after 3:00 (regularly $65). Tuesday $68 (regularly $88). Contact Buck’s Run (989) 773-6830 to schedule your tee time. I hereby authorize the Michigan State Police Troopers Association, Inc., hereinafter called COMPANY to initiate debit entries to my account indicated below at the depository financial institution named below, hereafter called DEPOSITORY, and to debit the same to such account. I acknowledge that the origination of ACH transactions to my account must comply with the provisions of U.S. law. ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 37 • • • • Schedule of Events 9:00 a.m. Registration 10:00 a.m. Shotgun Start Dinner, Prizes and Raff le following Golf Prizes awarded to 1st, 2nd and 3rd place teams! Longest Drive (men & women) Closest to the Pin (men & women) Skins (optional) Don’t miss out ... register today! Note: In the event of inclement weather, Buck’s Run acting Golf Pro will refund greens fees in the form of rain checks only. No cash or other refunds will be issued. Includes: Golf • Cart • Gift Bags Prizes • Dinner Deadlines: Team and individual registrations will be accepted until the outing is full! Tee Sponsorships & Prize Donations must be received by May 10, 2016 MSP PROJECT ’57 SPONSORSHIP FORM (Donations can be made on-line at: www.mspta.net) The Michigan Department of State Police will be celebrating its 100th anniversary in 2017 (1917- 2017). Retired and active members are in the process of refurbishing a 1957 Ford Custom 300 as a MSP patrol vehicle replica. A trailer will also be purchased to transport the vehicle to special events. Sponsorship donations offer many opportunities for businesses and private individuals to be a part of the MSP 100th Anniversary celebration. o Golf Registration @ q $20 Please register entire team on the same form, listing Player #1 as captain. If you do not have a full team, we are happy to place you on a team. q Include Banquet $90 q Golf Only $65 # Adults @ q $35 # Children @ q $20 $90/Golfer • $360/Foursome q Include Banquet $90 q Golf Only $65 # Adults @ q $35 # Children @ q $20 Payment may be made in advance or at the door. q Include Banquet $90 q Golf Only $65 # Adults @ q $35 # Children @ q $20 Non-golfing guests are invited to attend the banquet at a cost of $35.00/Adult | $20/Child q Include Banquet $90 q Golf Only $65 # Adults @ q $35 # Children If you are unable to attend the banquet, please join the outing at the “golf only” price of $65.00 Name Guest(s) City / Zip Address Email Name Guest(s) City / Zip Address Email Name Guest(s) Address City / Zip Email Name Guest(s) Address City / Zip Email Platinum Sponsor Level Donation / $1000 • Includes business/person name displayed on trailer and show board, vehicle parked in front of business (5 days), framed picture of vehicle, letter of thanks from 100th Anniversary Committee. Gold Sponsor Level Donation / $500 • Includes business/person name displayed on trailer and show board, vehicle parked in front of business (3 days), framed picture of vehicle, letter of thanks from 100th Anniversary Committee. Silver Sponsor Level Donation / $250 • Includes business/person name displayed on trailer and show board, vehicle parked in front of business (1 day), framed picture of vehicle, letter of thanks from 100th Anniversary Committee. o Tee Sponsorship – $100 Name: Company Name: Email: Address: City / State / Zip: Phone / Fax: Name as you would like it to appear on your tee sign: MSPTA Rep.: o Prize/Donation Description q Prize q Gift Bag Item q Cash Donation q Other Value: MSPTA Rep.: is enclosed. o Sorry, I/we are unable to attend, however, a contribution of $ Make checks payable to: MSTAF and mail to: MSTAF c/o MSPTA 1715 Abbey Road, Suite B East Lansing, MI 48823 Thank you for supporting MSTAF! 38 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ 100 YEAR ANNIVERSARY Bronze Sponsor Level Donation / $125 • Includes business/person name displayed on trailer and show board, letter of thanks from 100th Anniversary Committee. Private Collection Level Donation / $25 • Includes name listed on show board, letter of thanks from 100th Anniversary Committee. In-Kind Donation • Depends on the amount/value of contribution, includes name listed on show board, letter of thanks from 100th Anniversary Committee. All donations to Project ’57 will be used specifically for this project and donations are tax deductible. Please print your business information below. Business/Individual Name: Contact Name: Address: City / State / Zip: Phone: Email: Make checks payable to: MSTAF/ PROJECT ’57 Mail form with payment to: MSTAF/ PROJECT ’57, 1715 Abbey Road, Suite B, East Lansing, MI 48823 ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 39 In Memoriam ... By: Tpr. Derek Hoffmann | 116th Recruit School | Flint Post Senior Trooper Steven Vincent Louisiana State Patrol • EOW August 24, 2015 On August 29, 2015, Tpr. Thomas Pinkerton and I had the privilege of representing the Michigan State Police at the funeral of Senior Trooper Steven Vincent. Trooper Vincent was assisting a motorist who was in the ditch. Unknown to Trooper Vincent was that the suspect he was helping had already killed another person earlier. Thinking of the suspect’s safety, Tpr. Vincent told him to stay in the truck due to the steep angle of the ditch. Tpr. Vincent began walking back to his patrol unit when the door of the suspect’s vehicle opened. As Tpr. Vincent heard the door open he began to turn back around to caution the suspect again. In a true coward’s fashion the suspect surprised Tpr. Vincent with a shotgun blast that struck Tpr. Vincent in the head. As Tpr. Vincent lay on the ground the suspect exited and stood over him. He asked if Tpr. Vincent if he was still alive. As Tpr. Vincent laid on the ground, still breathing, the suspect told him, “You’re lucky, You’re lucky – you’re going to die soon.” Three good citizens stopped to help Tpr. Vincent, apprehended the suspect and handcuffed him with Tpr. Vin cent’s handcuffs. Being a Trooper at another State Trooper’s funeral is a humbling ex perience. All of the State Troopers from other states surrounded Tpr. Vincent’s family and his fellow LSP family as Colonel Michael Edmonson spoke at the church. Colonel Edmonson stated, “Steven always wanted to visit all fifty states, we’ve brought them to you.” Among those attending was Governor Bobby Jindal and other dignitaries. The 40 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ Photographer, April Reeves, was contacted by Mrs. Katherine Vincent a few months after her husband, Senior Trooper Steven Vincent was killed in the line of duty as she had followed her work for some time. Mrs. Vincent wanted some images done with her nine year old son, Ethan, and his father’s things. Ms. Reeves was not a friend of the family, but knew about the tragedy because as she described, “It hit the entire state so hard.” Ms. Reeves went on to express, “It was such an unbelievable incident and my heart broke for this family that I did not know. I knew that I had to do something special for them.” Several photographs were taken of Ethan but neither he nor his mother knew how the final photographs were going to turn out. This extremely talented photographer was able to tell Ethan’s story of loss. She wanted people to understand that there is a life behind the badge and feel some of his broken heart when they saw the images. In the time she spent photographing Ethan it was clear to her he had a strong bond with his father and stated “Ethan’s face lit up every time he put that hat on.” Ms. Reeves described the experience of taking these photographs that the Vincent family can now treasure for years to come as “amazing, although it was an emotional one too.” ■ Colonel’s comments were sincere and succinct. The community support in Lake Charles and the entire community was overwhelming. Some families held signs that read “Police lives matter.” Tpr. Vincent is survived by his wife, Katherine Tilley Vincent, son Ethan James Vincent, as well as his extended family. His brother Terrel is a Trooper with the LSP and his other brother is Chief of Police in Iowa, Louisiana, where Tpr. Vincent graduated high school. He was a 13-year veteran of the LSP and had received 13 awards and commendations during this time. Before joining the LSP Tpr. Vincent was an officer with Lake Charles Police. He also served in the U.S. Army during operation Desert Shield and Desert Storm. ■ ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 41 By: Tpr. Christopher Tuckey | 3rd District Representative 115th Recruit School | Lapeer Post In Memoriam ... Trooper Sean E. Cullen New Jersey State Police • EOW March 8, 2016 On March 8, 2016 New Jersey Trooper Sean Cullen was killed in the line of duty. Tpr. Cullen responded to a vehicle fire with injuries that occurred near milepost 23 on the southbound lanes of I-295 in Deptford Township. He was out side of his cruiser and walking near the scene of the fire when he was struck by a passing vehicle. Trooper Cullen was transported to Cooper University Hospital, in Camden, where he died from his injuries. The driver of the vehicle who struck Trooper Cullen remained at the scene. According to several members of the NJSP, the cause of the crash appeared to be the driver’s distraction by roadside activities at the scene of the fire. Neither alcohol nor cell phone use appeared to have played a factor in contributing to the crash. Trooper Cullen served with the New Jersey State Police for 18 months and was assigned to the Bell mawr Station. He had previously served with the Westampton Police Department. He is survived by his 9-month-old son, Seamus Cullen and fiancée, Aryn McCormick. Aryn is twenty weeks pregnant with the couple’s second child. Tpr. James “Mike” Bunk and I were honored to represent the State of Michigan, Department of Michigan State Police and the Mich igan State Police Troopers Associa tion in Cinnaminson, New Jersey, at 42 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ the funeral. It was one of the most well-attended funerals for any law enforcement officer I have attended in my 18 year career. In attendance were troopers from numerous states throughout the nation including Ohio, Minnesota, Vermont, Maine, Kentucky, Connecticut, New York, Missouri, Arkansas and Iowa. There were hundreds of other officers in attendance from local department, as well as various departments through out the United States. It was clear from the sheer number of attendees of the funeral that Sean was a very well liked and highly respected Trooper with the NJSP. The weather dampened the uniforms that day but not the collective spirit of the hundreds of officers in attendance. We spoke with several members of his department who spoke highly of Sean and his tragically short career. The evening before the funeral, the State Troopers NCO Association of New Jersey, Inc. put on an extra ordinary reception for fellow troop ers, friends and family of Sean. A private room was reserved for the hundreds of attendees at Miller’s Ale House, just blocks from the hotel where almost every out of state trooper was staying. A private shuttle was chartered to transport officers from the hotel to the reception. No one who at tended the reception left hungry, thirsty or without a smile on their faces that night. I was in awe of the hospitality and respect shown to us by every member of the NJSP in attendance that night. Command officers to dispatchers were appreciative of our attendance. Throughout the night Mike and I were pulled to different corners of the room to be proudly introduced as the “Michigan guys” to other NJSP Troopers. At times, Mike and I felt like we were the guests of honor. As Mike pointed out regarding the new friendships formed that night, “something good can come of something sad.” ■ I encourage all enlisted members of the MSP who haven’t attended an out of state Trooper’s funeral as a representative from Michigan to do so. It is a humbling way to meet officers from different parts of the country and to forge new friendships. Contact Tpr. Craig MacDonald via email (MacdonaldC@michigan.gov) to be added to the list for attending out of state Trooper funerals. ▪ Winter 2016 ▪ 43 Final Call Trooper Eli M. McCarson New Jersey State Police End of Watch: Thursday, December 17, 2015 Age: 30 Tour of Duty: 10 months Badge Number: 7775 Cause of Death: Automobile Accident Date of Incident: December 17, 2015 Trooper Eli McCarson was killed in an automobile accident while responding to a domestic violence call. Trooper McCarson was responding to a domestic violence call and was traveling on Quinton-Alloway Road near Route 49. He was driving in heavy rain when he lost control of the patrol car and struck a utility pole. Trooper McCarson was taken to The Memorial Hospital of Salem County, where he died from his injuries. Trooper McCarson served with the New Jersey State Police for 10 months. He graduated the 155th class of the New Jersey State Police Academy in February 2015. ■ Trooper Sean E. Cullen New Jersey State Police End of Watch: Tuesday, March 8, 2016 Age: 31 Tour of Duty: 2 years Badge Number: 7594 Cause of Death: Struck by Vehicle Date of Incident: March 7, 2016 Trooper Sean Cullen was struck and killed by a vehicle while assisting at the scene of a vehicle fire. Trooper Cullen had responded to a vehicle fire with injuries that occurred near milepost 23 on the southbound lanes of I-295 in Deptford Township. He was outside of his cruiser and walking near the scene of the fire when he was struck by a passing vehicle. Trooper Cullen was transported to Cooper University Hospital, in Camden, where he died from his injuries. The driver of the vehicle who struck Trooper Cullen remained at the scene. Trooper Cullen served with the New Jersey State Police for 18 months and was assigned to the Bellmawr Station. He had previously served with the Westampton Police Department. He is survived by his 9-month-old son and fiancée. ■ Officer Nathan Taylor California Highway Patrol End of Watch: Sunday, March 13, 2016 Age: 35 Tour of Duty: 6 years Badge Number: 20154 Cause of Death: Struck by Vehicle Date of Incident: March 12, 2016 Officer Nathan Taylor succumbed to injuries sustained the previous day when he was struck by a vehicle on I-80, near Donnor Summit. He was directing traffic at the scene of a previous accident when a vehicle suddenly changed lanes and accelerated past slowing traffic. The vehicle struck Officer Taylor, causing him to be thrown into the median. He suffered two broken legs and internal injuries. He was transported to a local hospital where he succumbed to his injuries the following day. Officer Taylor served with the California Highway Patrol for six years. He is survived by his wife, three sons, parents, and two brothers. One of his brothers also serves with the California Highway Patrol. ■ First Sergeant Joseph G. Portaro West Virginia State Police End of Watch: Monday, March 14, 2016 Age: 50 Tour of Duty: 17 years Badge Number: Not Available Cause of Death: Heart Attack Date of Incident: March 12, 2016 First Sergeant Joseph Portaro suffered a medical emergency while participating in a physical fitness run near the West Virginia State Police Academy, where he served as the Deputy Director of Training. He was transported to Thomas Memorial Hospital where he passed away. Sergeant Portaro served with the West Virginia State Police for 17 years. He is survived by his wife and three children. ■ 44 ▪ Michigan Trooper ▪ Tpr. Harold E. Anderson Sgt. Milan Pratt Tpr. John P. Clinton Sgt. Harvey Bolen Tpr. William F. Martz Tpr. Howard H. Funk Cpl. Sam Mapes Tpr. Delos A. Williams Tpr. John S. Burke Tpr. Richard F. Hammond Tpr. Irvine F. Wurm Tpr. John W. Cain Tpr. Charles T. Wood Tpr. Ralph L. Broullire Tpr. John D. Ryan Tpr. George R. Branny Sgt. Perry L. Critchell Tpr. Calvin R. Jones Tpr. George E. Lappi Tpr. Bert A. Pozza Tpr. Dugald A. Pellot Tpr. Albert W. Souden Det. Robert R. Gonser Tpr. Carl P. Lindberg Tpr. Roger M. Adams Tpr. Gary T. Rampy Tpr. Charles B. Stark Tpr. Steven B. DeVries Tpr. Darryl M. Rantanen Tpr. Larry L. Forreider Tpr. Norman R. Killough D/Sgt. Harry Sorenson D/Sgt. David Hubbard Tpr. Allan Peterson Tpr. Craig A. Scott Tpr. Vicki Moreau-DeVries Tpr. Tony Thames Tpr. Robert Mihalik Tpr. Paul L. Hutchins Tpr. James E. Boland Tpr. Kermit Fitzpatrick Tpr. James R. DeLoach Tpr. Steven J. Niewiek Tpr. Byron J. Erickson Tpr. Bryon S. Egelski Tpr. Manuel H. Fields Tpr. Frederick A. Hardy Tpr. Rick L. Johnson Tpr. Kevin M. Marshall Tpr. Jeffrey J. Werda Tpr. Paul K. Butterfield II Tpr. Chad H. Wolf March 12, 1921 April 15, 1922 January 8, 1923 May 4, 1923 March 12, 1925 July 8, 1926 May 1, 1927 July 30, 1929 October 13, 1930 January 20, 1937 January 26, 1941 November 26, 1941 April 14, 1942 March 16, 1943 March 3, 1950 April 12, 1950 March 20, 1954 February 10, 1956 November 19, 1956 November 19, 1956 September 30, 1957 September 3, 1959 August 8, 1968 May 26, 1969 May 14, 1971 December 31, 1971 December 31, 1971 October 12, 1972 May 27, 1974 December 5, 1974 October 7, 1978 December 5, 1978 September 16, 1980 August 29, 1981 February 9, 1982 July 22, 1982 June 12, 1983 September 9, 1984 August 29, 1985 July 26, 1987 July 7, 1991 February 1, 1992 February 2, 1992 July 31, 1993 July 11, 1994 August 27, 1994 November 6, 1999 May 6, 2000 July 7, 2003 April 6, 2011 September 9, 2013 August 28, 2015 Non Profit Org. US Postage PAID Lansing, MI Permit #515 MICHIGAN TROOPER Michigan State Police Troopers Association 1715 Abbey Road Suite B East Lansing MI 48823 Sine The badge number on the cover of the Michigan Trooper honors Tpr. Chad H. Wolf. On August 28, 2015, Tpr. Chad Wolf was killed when his motorcycle was struck by a vehicle. Trooper Wolf was on motorcycle patrol and traveling northbound in the right lane of Dixie Highway and crossing over southbound I-75 when a vehicle towing an empty trailer traveling in the left lane quickly changed lanes in an attempt to access the I-75 entrance ramp. As the vehicle changed lanes, it struck Trooper Wolf ’s motorcycle. Trooper Wolf was dragged for several miles on I-75 before the driver pulled over at a rest area. Trooper Wolf served with the Michigan State Police for seven years. His Post assignments included Jackson, Flint, and Metro, most currently a member of the MSP Second District, Special Enforcement Section, Motor Unit. He is survived by his wife and four children. Trooper Wolf is the 52nd Michigan State Police officer killed in the line of duty. Pari Next Quarterly Meeting Saturday, April 16, 2016 (Lodging Friday & Saturday, April 15 & 16) Greektown Casino-Hotel – Detroit, Michigan Registration Deadline is Friday, March 25, 2016* Call: Toll Free (877) 424-5554 and make your reservation today! Website: www.greektowncasino.com • Group Block Code: MSPTA16 *(RSVPs will be accepted after the deadline if space is available, however, rate is not guaranteed.)