ffi urat - 395 003. RF - Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Transcription

GUIARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
REGIONAL OFFICE,
SUMT
urat - 395
ffi
003. RF
It- is hereby informed that as per the Ministry
of Environmen! Forests & climate
change, Government of India, New Delhi vide
its notification no. s.0.1533 dated
L4/09/2006 and subsequent amendment s.0. soiz (El
dated oitti'iio09, pubtic
Hearing was fixed jorSrongsed Proiect of M/s.
KEIRIWAI INTEGMTED TEXTILE
PARK PvT' LTD; for Textile Park with
common Lffiuent Treatment plant (cETp)
having 2.5 MLD capacity with recycring facirity
su-uy No. 328, 333, 340 to 344,
358 village: Kareli, Ta: parsana, Dist. surar,
"i
GUTARAT
11?^?
30.10.Zors at
04:00 p.m. onwards at project site, sunrey No. g26,gzg;40 ong44,3sz&
to
3sg
village: Kareli, Ta: parsana, Dist surat (Guiarat),
which is covered under
Category-' B' of the Schedule.
A copy of the Draft Environment Impact Assessment
Report and the Executive
Summary of Draft Environment Impact Assessment
Report were sent to the
following
authorities or offices to make available for inspection
to the public during
normal office hours, till the public Hearing
is over:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
The District Collector Office, Surat.
District Development Office, SuraL
District Industries Centre, Surat.
J-"luF Development Office, Ta. palsana, Dist. Surat.
The chief conservator of Forests, Ministry
of Environment & Forests, Gow. of
India, Regional offic9 fwest Zone), Kendriya paryavaran
Bhavan, E - s, Area
Colony, Link Road - 3, Ravishankar Colony, ghopaf-a6
OtO.
Regional office, Gujarat pollution controiBo".d',338,
Belgium square, opp.
Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat _ 395 003.
i
Executive summary of Draft Environment Impact
Assessment Report was also
circulated in surrounding villages for effective p.iuri.itv.
other concerned persons having plausible stake in
the environmental aspects were
send their responses in writing to rhe concerned
regurarory
fi?ff:,T3r..
An advertisementin English was published
in "Times of
and in Gujarati in "Gujarat samaihar"
India,,dated 26.09/zo1s
dated z6.og.zots.
shri P' N' Makwall?, c-es., Resident Additional collector
and Additional District
Magistrate, surat supervised
and presided over the entire public hearing process.
A statement showing participants present during
the public Hearing is enclosed
herewith as Annexure A.
Page
I of2
GUIARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
SUMT
REGIONAL OFFICE,
338, Belgium square, opp.Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, surat - 39s
ffi
003. {F
A statement showing the salient points highlighting
issues raised by the
participants and responded to by the representative of
the applicant during the
Public Hearing in English Language is enclosed as Annexure
B and in Gujarati
Language is enclosed herewith as Annexure 81.
The representations received in written from the other
concerned persons having
plausible stake in the environment aspects
before and during the public hearing are
enclosed as Annexure c-1 to c-6 and replies from
the pr:o;ect'propon.nt to the
same are enclosed as Annexure D_1 to D-6.
\>=-
A,A
r,4{
a tttttt
Place: I(areli,
Ta. Palsana,
DisL: Surat
Date:30.10.2015
t./
^l*'tl
f. K patel
Regional Officer,
GPCB,Surat As
Representative of the
Member Secretary, GPCB
Encl.: 1. Annexure A, B, 81, C-1 to C-6 and D-1
to
2. Video CDIDVD of public Hearing.
P. N. Malrwana c.A.s.
Resident Additional
Collector and Additional
District Magistrate, Surat
D_6 as above.
Page 2
of2
GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD
ffi
!l{'llF
REGIONAL OFFICE, SURAT
338, Belgiunr Square, Typical 1't Floor, Opp.
Lincar Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat.
ANNEXURE _ A
A statement showing participants present during the public hearinq
As per the Ministry of Environment & Forests, Government of India, New Delhi vide its
notification number S.O. 1533 dated 14 September 2006 and subsequent amendment
S.O. 3067(E) dated 1't December 2009, Public Hearing was fixed for M/S Kejriwal
Integrated Textile Private Limited (KITPPL) for proposed establish integrated textile
park and Common Effluent treatment plant (CETP) with 2.5 MLD capacity at
Bfock No.328,333,340, 341,342,343,344,357,358, Village: Kareli, Ta: Palsana,
Dist-Surat.
The statement showing participants present during the public hearing held on
30.10.2015 at 16:00 hrs at projectsite Block No.328,333,340, 341,342,343,344,
357, 358, Village: Kareli, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat is as under'
q,t r{a uqlq?ql uataa, "tdt [0cdt'tt ttc]tottut 8:-l'i5: ilil.Ul'.1ttg E,
dr.ru/oe/?oo9 ?{a R,tr qd[+r UUr?t. sHis r],+t.utL. 3o9o (tl), ctl..ot/e.?/?ooe
?,r{rir{ra il }vfl.tct oRcJ}s }aaroet t{r8 ur. c'{l t}rrtttld[r{lr{lrlctt. +t{ "i.
att?cr +ttgt?ou
uta 3qC, ctLr|' SttG{1, ctLCJS-I UGt+tl'gl'[, E)
r.,ti s-Iu+ tJ5c1?{oe flal."a wtroa tdltldtr{ll e.\t
U?d q{ld tl@c)}s )AarOe utt
rl{Aet$t &:{cu. rtr} %c}r alsqat+gft"j rrttulv+ ctl..3ole.o/?ot\t 'tt t-I?t ts'oo 5([],
ul*ra tu.n q?, l. lvfl.ua oRcJls )aaulct urt ur. c'ft tlurttldtr{tr{trlel. il{ "i.
cl'l}t 5t}c'{:|., dtcjs-I qautq[t', u'
3 ?C,333,3YO,3U1,3U?,3U3,3UU,3qO r{a 3qc,
3
?C,333,3UO,3U1,,38?,3U3,3UU,3\tO
q?d Wa ?tl,tqtl{i
U{[aCa.
ttae al'sq'ttqgft e?]rrtoi
cstgf? ?&c.ti
c1]4"ft e{rdl
Sr. No.
Name and Designation
Organization / Village Name
s{s
'tt{ r*a AEf
{Nructt}t
:L
I
'*(f
t cL\ oua' ttlf'w'^'t
z
6
3
P,osuP62 <h /T/"
r
I o[
'j 'ttt+
S-rJ
t4a'-,al
i
gu,€f-A
-
6
"ftl
{9'ot D'
Signature
udl
^
rv
4ro(a
338, Belgiunr Square, Typicat
Sr. No.
sl{i5
h
5"
l"
Floor, Opp. Lincar llus Stand, Iling Road' Surat'
atx rrti. O-lel.
+iWryctp+
ut
c--\
Q -'r'R n' '\1 1, ^.., 1 -\^\^C\s - <nr.O4/
n
tr
Mil\*J
bf.J.r
€
1$-1""o F'C.41'
1
Mqn,"sh
B-Pate,t
(
n\LlKEsh.
m
I
t_!)
J ^r**
ildt
hn..n,^
€"1a"*
89*01'x--
v2
@
k1*'d4
... *'fr*e
n14p4/L,u.fuL
t/.rtL
M..7 I
pen a1 P ("e'l
L$Ll-i
(.,+-rt
q,1"
q)r.*f
t?.
|/^
$lptr--.-u< Ut-a't^wt
-wO
*..:fr',J
€*).4
/l
U
\}
g>.r r.rga\rli4 Vq
)+
4"'tl, y c,ldna
1{
16
q"
"j atu
Signature
KoS
,"'''/l
Ita]'r,
lcx:eJ*{
qnb-dLt
A-"ê
wr,ffit
Aq>r*,
Rr dilw
Rono.* . B' P'a{(\t '
LluvcLi
A, 0 Pqt(
C-,)2t- \rn, Q"tl
5
/
Ay q. s1l/t/ r\cvt
\t{c/7
z oL (
r
);dt
epy
a-r.v' Y.
{
GUJARAT POLLUTIOI{ CONTROL BOARD
338, Belgium square, Typical 1"t Floor, Opp.
l,ilcar llus Stand,
Ring Ro1cl, Surat.
{i{rur1{ "j arU
bnss {g\*Ja
w ,?fl"\r€ ?'td6t0a$r
t<
4.o
"?2
4.+
O
+{^B\
yn
4-3
.?,r
krlpr a./
a/t'l-
e-a>tr?fJ(r'.1n [t>ta
l\t-
6.rlZtze,tn
l{: e
----------2---
,\
td dt
9dc{
A.ot(16\
ufi1t\
(^
q^l'\
n_
aK97v7'< =<=
:-
4,t
)OlX s) ytr?,
[-tq
-tS
gw*a@-(*
&xt+t
n
\€q;n;xre-Ia\$S
ffi
$bfi
F9r.s\4
t
/L+y
\e
a4zif7T-t
Jo
31-
Ivw
dr\.(
1
{</#/1?/2t-
6(.e
n1,u6l
Rn-
ulftffitg9r'ra I/ \
uffiq6
P. zr l,\î)
s'{\
4l'
r<
,dw4
T{.)*tr1
5et'tt<a.-
r{&A
2;f4
La-^n \ 1
iL
)a
QQ
9r?t''l^\
r,".1
Hr Totft<lo
Signature
ud[
Sr. No. Name and Designation
s:{is
"ttl{ ?44 6]El
rT/^
p)qnrfd
,^hq
\<t-C
z o[
6
4f
:-:---,-:-
ffi
q"q;r
l't Floor, Opp. Lincar Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat.
338, Belgiunr Square, Typical
Sr. No.
slris
+tu r4i. elqf
ri+Euctru
3L
33
3r
Er+
3t
3e
3(
/iI
/5t de
/
|
,u\/
6t 2e1r,,^
S4ilYh Q^L)rr';,n)-t
(-nl
gtr a\h.
?pr
olfhor'4,.it
I\-Dq-
) t ft/?
*,Le;l
--eritn-
oftTnt
rL
3m
t{
h/
"fi.r*g',
qo
\-t
e^ s L-^1
s,Ln
-€\Jc-n
Trzrq
-
./
I
4a-eL
ASh*)o\
/
ot otl l"rsl
'rl it\
qn
J azr'gqo-1re!
of
\l.t-
t,iU
-, *F
-_-DA
\/'\
-
diw,I q.crl
n{h^s&
rt,Iu)a
kt&
,K-hl&^
4
,rr
e4
YmA
&1
t r 6"ir
Arry
8"raf
-
d\"'q
C,l^-q arrup
c\
,/1
+I+
yLC
?o
ds
t\
Cy{L{4
D,n,,e:zE
- (t.7
alr+?
l'.21fr
?rrele-J--{ Q"1,?-
JE s
futttt4
D.*+r^
D.tnA, .- , O=a,
,#e,-t
/
3(
Ug
yt^
'j aru
Signature
u6[
o[ A
.-:::*:;--i
ffi
a!.7F
338' Belgiunr square,'Fypical I*t liroor, opp. Linear llus stanr!, Ring Road, surat.
st{i5
'tu+ uti elql
{Nrucrrl+
a3
\hr*Lcfi,n i l<isl,ot bl-; l^kf
TD
$;VLnuqhafbhqi Qqrnqa
?r(
.++4r.^'"1'
KA
p= oL-*...-..l-k*
-4*"r.
\.f o (
\v
\r
"q3
13
w'o
rc*-u)
6i.n
V---
f/-/L
(
Ja^!.er[; .0*-t. tl t tJrl
W*Pr,*,t*!'J)s"
SlLvrnra
nf{tl
'
9r^-^S*l
14
Kaqrl-
Atrrr Sl LKru,tB
kr4yT",
#\hJ-,
Nrr'A1+,r
[*'
=?,f,\(tr
\
fu^ru
C
(,/-
{ai64^,8
\(
6@;;a
\k
@q" P"r,q2q
ft4t
/tf)^b.,
o-s$ \
&
Jt{cr
22-t<q1 dry'4.rry
|
ry
G
\ry--
G{ q1\a. \
ll,l,wnrol
l4l-'lJb
/, \
11:
2{g
\e
eM-
l^--,.t0^
Mlj
Signature
udt
w@
VuJ?-Â
rllf-
\v h-.i.t,"
\l
"j +tu
8'? .n
.-5t J^1
5 of
6
ordq t. ..
&
338, Belgiunr Square, Typical
l"
Floor, Opp. Lincar Bus Stand, Ring l{oad, Surat.
5]{ls
+rr+ rrti elqf
3o
na/,,4
riWructrq
(e
"j +ru
g/TDf?
Signature
udl
fiP/L*-
3r
gaRU'rAcr
qricl'l
i&q
St
"glIU(tq
f-foV c"\ /
5lZ'l
sft,fu
5t{€{\
sRv
3s
St
g\
g3
gs
t(
gk
9o
9L
tvl
\^
J(l k{
B. rlqlhurj
A".-j+
\J 9^.;
x}deJil
a"''Je
q,
"t\crcr*.J S
),.,.-t q. OJ Gt <-^.-S
q!
6ti.,{1
.n}.,f;
ctiol}"{-,
{J*L"4
{
a:-. .
11
--_
l,
ba*i s,rfu,
l
f""""'t
/tr^^
^''Ut*
WA kr^J-v
C^h^f.lt'a^4
6-,.*-r,t
krtk
6 oA (
N^,Y
-.-1
tu
n-{bL
G,
Annexure -B (ENGLISH)
A Statement showing issues raised by the participants and responses given by
the representative of the applicant duringthe public Hearing
As per the Ministry of Environment, Forests & Climate Change, Government of India,
New Delhi vide is notification no. 5.0.1533 dated L4/09/2006 and subsequent
amendment S.0. 3067 (EJ dated 0L/L2/2009, Public Hearing was fixed for proposed
Project of M/s. KEIRIWAL INTEGRATED TEXTILE PARK pVT. LTD; for proposed to
establish Integrated Textile Park along with Common Effluent Treatment plant
ICETP) having 2.5 MLD capacity with Recycling facility at Survey No. 328, 333, 340 to
344' 357 & 358 Village: Kareli, Ta: Palsana, Dist. Sura! GUIAMT covered under
Category-"B"i Environment Public hearing was fixed at project Site, Survey
No. 328,
333, 340 to 344, 357 & 358, Village: Kareli, Ta: palsana, Dist. Surat (GujaratJ
on
30.10.2015 at 04:00 p.m.
ResidentAdditional Collector and Additional District Magistrate and Chairman
of
Environment Public Hearing, Shri P. N. Malrwana c.A.s. supervised
and presided over
the entire Environment public Hearing proceedings.
Shri f'K.Patel, Regional officer (Ro)- Gujarat Pollution Control Board
(GpcB),
surat and Representative of the Member secretary-GPcB sought permission
from the
Chairman to staft the proceedings. Regional officer-GPCB welcomed
all present in the
Environment Public Hearing and outlined the various provisions
of the EIA
Notifications and briefed the process for conducting this public
hearing. He stated that
during this Public Hearing, Project Proponent will make brief project
presentation
about their project and then will give the replies to suggestions,
objections and
questions raised by the affected people, which will
be also recorded and forwarded to
the competent authority. He added that as per the provision
of the Notification only
local affected people can represent orally and other interested
people who have given
their written representations will be considered in the proceedings.
Thereafter, Shri Girdharilal Kejriwal, Director, Kejriwal Integrated
Textile park pvt.
Ltd', gave information for the proposed project and representative
of the consultant
made presentation in Gujarati covering introduction of
the technical information,
details of proposed project, Environmental Management
system, its impact on the
environment along with proposed mitigation measures
and industry,s proposed
activities regarding corporate social Responsibilities.
Thereafter, with the consent of the Additional District
Magistrate the forum was made
opened for the representations opinions suggestions
/
of the local affected people.
/
Page 1 of 10
-
During Public Hearing Questions raised by people present and answers given by the
representative of the applicant are as under.
Sr.
1.
proiect
Vill: Kareli,
proponent
He stated that, report of the Company's Representative
presentation shown over gave the copy of the
here should be given to us, presentation.
Ta. Palsana,
as we will forget
Dist: Surat
presentation shown
Shri.
Mukeshbhai
Patel
2.
Replies from
Points represented
Name
the
over
here afterward.
Shri. Manishbhai He asked that, whether the
Maganbhai Patel,
employee of the company
Vill: Gangapur
can remain present in the
Ta. Palsana,
Public Hearing? And if they
Dist: Surat
can then state us the
position of employee those
attend the
Hearing? Because 70 o/o of
the people sitting over here
employee
the
who can
are
Chairman stated that, this is
a Public Hearing, any local
person can attend this
Public Hearing and any
number of the affected
peoples can attend the
Public hearing. There is no
question about number of
people present.
of
company. Whether they
have come to show number
of people present in the
Public Hearing?
He further asked that,
Regional Officer stated that,
there any provision of notification is required to be
giving the notification of given in the Gujarati and
the Public Hearing to the English daily local
Panchayat?
newspaper before 30 days of
the Public Hearing and the
same was done. That
notification was also given
in D.D.O. office, T.D.O. office,
District
Industries
development Center, District
Collector Office, District
is
Panchayat 0ffice,
G.P.C.B.
Office and to all
Page 2
the
of 10
Panchayat
offices
surrounding villages.
of
Company's Representative
which consultant company state that this E.l.A. report is
has prepared this E.l.A. prepared by M/s. Detox
Report.
Corporation PW Ltd. surat.
He further asked that, Consultant Representative
whether the company who stated that, They have
has prepared the E.l.A. obtained accreditation
report, have a
proper earlier and submitted
certificate issued by the renewal application further
Central Government for the certificate is uploaded
preparing this report?
online by the Certificate
Agency which one can be
seen online.
Chairman added at this iuncture that whether the reply given by the authority
whatever question raised here is satisfactory or not, that will be decided by
competent authority
Shri. Manishbhai Patel further added that, there were protest in the Public Hearing
held in this area on previous occasion, however no one listen to us afterwards. If only
formalities are to be performed then there is no meaning.
Chairman added that Public Hearing is conducted as er the provision of the
Notification issued by Government of India. The replies given by the project
proponent of the questions raised verbally here and written replies to be written
representation received would be forwarded to the competent authority. This panel
has no jurisdiction to take any decision.
3.
Shri.
fagdishchandra
Patel,
Vill: Kareli,
Ta. Palsana,
Dist: Surat
He stated that, for the
knowledge of the Public
Hearing, notification of the
Public Hearing should be
kept in the besides villages
on the boards. Factories are
in the center of the lands of
the agricultural land of the
villagers.
Page 3 of 10
of Company's Representative
the nearby company's further stated that, our plant
entering into our is of water-jet looms plant.
agricultural land we are In this plant we are going to
suffering loss. So, survey of separate oil and grease from
the same should be done the water and processing it
and whether company will be reused.
Due to the polluted water
give
compensation in
would
any
any
damage takes place due to
there plant.
Chairman stated at this juncture tha! one should take into consideration the fact that
for which project the Public Hearing is conducted. The proposed project here is about
treatment plant of waste water where there is proposal for reusing the waste water
after treatment. The representation for other issues raised can be made separately to
G.P.C.B. and G.P.C.B. would take necessary action in this regard.
4.
Shri.
Mukeshbhai He stated thag if this plant
Balubhai Patel,
is not going to create any
Vill: Kareli,
pollution then what is the
Ta. Palsana,
requirement of the Public
Dist: Surat
Hearing?
Company's representative
whether any survey has stated that, company has
been conducted by your assisted the village for
company for the loss which making the road. When the
we suffer due to your plant bench was required for the
which is running
since village school company has
20L2? What steps did you assisted village school. We
company has taken for the are assisting the village
health of the people?
whenever village needs help.
He further said that, my
Chairman asked
to
company's representative to
for give details of what the
company has done for the
health of the villagers and
what is going to be done in
question is not for financial
assistance
health.
but it is
Page 4 of 10
future?
Company's check-up would
be held. He added that we
will carry out other health
activities as per the
suggestions of the villagers.
He suggested the company
that proper steps should be
taken for the health of the
villagers and medical
check-up should be done on
the 3 months of interval. He
added that there may be
indirect adverse
effect
which may not be visible
and if there are any effects
on agriculture that should
be studied. Is there any
survey conducted in last
three years?
5.
^
Shri.
Manishbhai He stated that, first of all
Maganbhai Patel,
certificate should be shown
Vill: Gangapur,
then after this Public
Ta. Palsana,
Hearing should proceed
Dist: Surat.
further.
Company's Representative
stated that, as per the
scheme of the Government
of India certificate issued to
us is for 3 years. Status is
updated online on every 10ttt
day of the month. It is to be
renewed at every 3 year. Re-
accreditation certificate is
also issued for 3 years.
However as the scheme has
been changed so still it is not
given to us and it is notified
that these agencies can
prepare E.l.A. report. And by
Dec. 2015 we will get the
Official Re-accreditation
Page 5 of 10
ceftificate by Q.C.l.
Regional Officer stated that
his representation has been
noted and whether to
consider the reply given by
consultant valid or not that
shall be decided by the
competent authority. There
is no provision to give any
written approval during the
Public Hearing.
He further stated that,
whether this Public Hearing
can be considered legal
without certificate?
further asked that
He
G.P.C.B.'s
officer is present here
whether he gives the
approval to the letter given
by the consultant?
He further stated that, after
getting the certificate by the
consultant
Public
Hearing
be
conducted again on any
other day. As the survey has
the
should
been carried without
certificate, it cannot be
considered valid. Therefore,
this Public Hearing is not
acceptable to us and shall
be treated as finished here.
He re-iterated that we are
not accepting this Public
Hearing.
Page 6 of 10
Chairman stated that, the p"rti.ip
Public Hearing as finished. He further stated that, the points raised by him
here are
Shri.
Mukeshbhai
Balubhai Patel,
Vill: Kareli,
Ta. Palsana,
Dist: Surat
He stated that, how we will Company's representative
I
come to know whether the
whatever
company got the approval decision will be taken in the
or not, after sending the Gandhinagar related to this
repoft of Public Hearing to project will be published in
stated that,
the
Gandhinagar for the Gujarati and
English
decision making?
daily news paper and will be
also uploaded on the
website of the G.P.C.B.
He further stated that, we
should also get the copy of
the E.C. which will be given
to the company, so that we
Company's representative
stated tha! we are giving
undertaking that one copy of
the E.C. will be given to you
can know the conditions and if required, company
subject to which E.C. is will discuss with the
given.
villagers about the
conditions of the E.C.
Shri. Manishbhai He stated tha! survey done
Maganbhai Patel,
without the certificate is
Vill: Gangapur,
illegal. So rhis public
Ta. Palsana,
Dist: Surat.
Hearing is illegal and so it is
be cancelled and he
added that he treats this as
cancelled.
to
While raising
other Company's representative
questions he asked where stated that, filtered
water
will be the filtered water be will be stored and then
after
disposed?
water will be given to
different companies.
He further stated that, you Company's representative
stated in your presentation stated tha! water
which will
that this water will be used be used in the garden
will be
in the garden. Then it
checked in the company,s
should be stated that which laboratory and
then after it
Page 7 of 10
f
quantity of water will be
used and whether any test
would be conducted before
using for gardening?
He then after giving the
specimen of the certificate
to the panel and stated that
this is the right specimen of
the certificate.
He further stated that, we
have certain demands. They
are as follows:
If the plant starts working
here then,
(1)One
committee
should be formed in
the village under the
chairmanship of the
District Collector in
which people
can
represent
their
problems and bring
out its solutions by
discussing it with the
company.
(2)That
comminee
should
empowered for
inspection.
(3)Bond of Rupees
crore should
taken from
company
as
guarantee which
be under
authority
Collector.
Page 8 of 10
(4) Committee should
be formed under the
chairmanship of
District
Collector
consisting of nearby
company
and
the
committee should be
vigilant to ensure
that government
subsidies should not
be misused.
He re-iterated that
E.l.A.
report should be cancelled
and if possible
Public
Hearing
be
conducted again after the
consultant receives the
certificate.
should
Shri.
He stated that, I support the
fagdishchandra
Patel,
Vill: Kareli,
demand raised
Ta. Palsana,
Dist: Surat
by
Shri
Manishbhai.
He added that the company
employees are present here
and they should be asked
whether they use
any
equipment for their health
and safety.
Shri.
Manishbhai He stated that, minutes and Regional Officer stated that,
Maganbhai Patel,
video recording of the proceedings prepared will
Vill: Gangapur,
Public Hearing prepared be uploaded on the web-site
Ta. Palsana,
should be given to us.
then additionally the copy
Dist: Surat.
will be given to us.
Page 9 of 10
Regional Officer stated while concluding that all oral and written representations,
suggestions have been recorded. Whatever oral and written representations have
been made and video graphy of the Public Hearing is also done, will be submitted to
the concerned authority. The replies given by the project proponent would also
incorporated in the proceedings and will be submitted for further action to the
Competent Authority. As no further representations received, Public Hearing was
concluded expressing thanks to all present.
\
Place: Kareli,
Ta. Palsana,
Dist.: Surat
Date: 3O/IO/2O15
40"^
K Patel
f.
Regional Officer,
GPCB,Surat As
Representative of the
Member Secretary GPCB
Y
P. N. Makwana c.A.s.
Chairman of the
Environmental Public
Hearing and
Resident Additional
Collector and Additional
District Magistrate, Surat
A.
Page 10 of 10
f,i.ae-dlt
ctl.s
qtqtet.ft
u"ttqe0 eaurr+ €tqre e&ct elgf flet etr seqt{'t r,ttile qqtr,il
u[iR[Q flat qluqtlr't r,tta,e vqtc
qi
r{tqretc"tt
q't r-tqlqegt, ctot rrti. rcn ctg u{cd't }iatatq, otdl [tcd["tt
a{.?ct tt?gt?ott
gr+ts:il.il.rrl.. trrg3
qi
qn&e'tu+t
lar utft't
gt{t?t srris A.il.urL.3o9o (tt) cu..
ot-t?-?ooc ou. ?4ccttr lnd lqrflqta tt,{tc)}s }Aattlct qr3 utoa,a (dr{l}s, nd "i.
3?c,333,3xo et 3yu,3\to r,ti 3rtc, cu.r{:3tlc.{1, dt. r{ctutqtt, E). q?d,cJv?tct
rrtti. sf{"t rl,qgr,t"e flal'a rtttoa (dltldtr{l), a.q rl.q.ll.ct.$[. a{at r,ri. !4: qr{?te[
c?lct+Et. +t[da
i
cu..
Ly-oe-?oos
]aaroat ur3 r+r}'[ q.Qa qQqfv"tr
q"cril uulcegftu tiv{t
]]cr{ *dl" H[ r,ttqfl dcutre E r,ri
4{t E. r,u 4r} uql.reqftq ctls g+rcqft uftsa uu,a, ud
3?c,333,3yo eII 3uu,3\to ?rti 3rtc, c1.4:5ttc,{1, dt. qg1ilqtt, E). U?ct, cJv?tct,
rrtl, at. 3o/\o/?orq +t a'Iv uiqr't[ ov'oo sar] rtucrtr+i. ?4ra.at.
Rqtr{l r,t0,s Rc<tt sa.sae r,1i r,tfQs Rc<u [gQaa{l; gea i,ur qerlqeqfiq e1s
g+tctqftAt r,ttaAa{l r{l.rl't.:{sAtQu. u.f,.rln. otl tutirrt dert r4t,a{AUqU &gcn r,tt elg
q+tcgft r,ttqlga erd ed.
s{l'.8. }. u}e, utbGls r,tCI.st{t, cJet?tct uguqt Raiagr otl.S, gaa d€n u(Rr ttRqa{l
qu?tct Ugugt Raiagt qfS'u URAQ c{t} t{gl st{.{r6[ er? s?qr r,ttaaa{I"{l
tttl
6q(Aa +t1i rnqstql, ir,ilrl 6.?41.6.4. afdt[$]er"r
r,iclcta QOt{ frctqttlrril. r,ti al.sgarctgft'ft uBqr ouc,ti. {Rr.tHi l{ttd.{l rrut{I. luql
ea3ttql b; utt als g<tctgft eall.ut't Sqdl atat u].tsa qtott lu"]er+ oue rlu?clt<t
ueqt'tc[l
ct].s g+tcgft:-tt
Ul*sa Vul4"e 6t?t ?4tr{crrr+i ?arqel. aEt li
tsS s{t {c'tQa ilet{ ilrutlleili ritsctqt{i r{tqel.. t:+q1 GU } m&r'urri"0 frcrqtO
utalttl.? rtta i€rt4,8 rlil?r,tu afgf qr r{t etLg g+tcgftu'r flOs ?Vrltct sfl etgel., qrqt}
fda tretqat r{oet carBar,t] adt.{l ?3r.tua dCI'ar+i stcr E l"il qr stdqRui ill{ta.er
eLs-l+t gu+1, qttnrrtl., uqrctl.+t qrqtql,
stqtl+i. rtt.rel'
cfteu{atct }v{.uct, srqlgaa, lud }qrflqra 6Jtc)}s }aaule urt
utdQa Q{l}s; gtet qQ.a t{ltldtr{l ul*se'ft r3{uc tdel {(d.ft r,rr{l qi etr?orre
sottc€oeotl. URAQ 6t?t cJet?tc{l etturl+l lu"]er'r ?V s?cu:+i rrtqj. tti uftsadl
bs'ftse rtt[&.ft, UQa q{lqflr'u.[ {f6.ft uulcregt ca{crwuqor qur(a, qRa Rqres
dtL?o{.e a{l
Page
I of10
ile u4tqagt u? elo11? r4u? rli. 6U].ct gtet SeqtUl
Qi1 cjlretd ouutr+l Du"]et+ saqtul qtcai.
uctctl?rtl,
?'ttctatt?
ttt4tRg UqRr'tf
d{r?o{e r4Q.s [?c<u luQadl"fl r,r4+[iell teuG.s r4u?clid e]tt"tl ?vr4taz
rrr@Utuz+jq.tl, Hr) riu ulc<tl 5sqtr+i rrtcarL.
al.s garcrqft ea0.qt.'r €rqr? r8ct t€rrG,s al.s'l 6t?t Utecl}tl r,tta.ct
URAQ fl?l r,il\tcttl+i. t,ttde vqtqf. "0tr Svot E.
glt
rJqf
cV sr+te"j +trr
cU
setla
rJetutf
ui ne+i
udt
i{qt r{?qtet?ott
u{t?rfrdr+t URRQ
6t?t ?,ttuq,t4t qta.Gr
Uqrt?
t s{l g}eteutl otejcrutl lxgf qrguc{ }, rrtt I lo"}eta 3u'{l't[ u[iQ[0 gtet
qatqqr{ utd E i'tl ut&qre lrr'rlet+'{l arSe
ule
ctt. ltctttl.gtt,
rrt{a, rrtUqtul r4td., Sttgt ], rrtUqtUl
rlt S lu"tlet+ cctqqtr+l ?,ttd
[t. grc
E Q al
a{l r-tRltattd {rtaretrt
ltrqi b, al.s g+tqgftui r,rtaaa{lrl qrquql },
iu'ft+i r+tgutl. r,ttdl etlZ rrti. ?r{ ctlsg+tcgfl E,
fr qrdl etb af sui elgtetrnt r+fdqi s'lrrqqr N{tRs
rrrdl etle a r,t{a. vqttqf. r{rqtu r,ttdl et} E
i: srtc,{I,
?
qD,a
i
: ctlctge
ctl.. : t{C,ttttQtt
(t. : {?ct
r,tl
rrtta.Ct.
alctl "6dqi.
tr+91
r{dqi Qila citslui€Il r,ti ctl, iac{l
oo asr 3u'{l+i utgutl E. {rrqtr+l t+rrG.g
alsg+cgftrri etqrfl otcu.c{c{t. r4tt?clm ctfsf rrttdl
srrgr 3,
er} E. it{i
r,tt ctl.sl r,tQ.ct E 3 3:{a
sk,
{rrart"il Ua efaf 'tell.
ctls g+tcgft r,icf
uR@ r+t) y?ctt
Uq."tf stcttui rrtQ.a
E r,ti {r,i[0afi qilqt
stqtqi r,ttd,ct D.
t{qf cgxl Uoqi ],
q+tcgft"{I
t
uttGts r,tf0gtflr{lrl
qn&ara sfl E il ?flquqi 3, 30 [t,qu
uu. al,s
Page 2
of 10
ri{rqai qtuqpri r,ud.
s-lrt
trt)
lqdat
qrtbe ilrrr?{t?
ua c1mt.0 rrti
I oir1u*i tt&era
I r,tuqt"{l efq E qi
utqtt+ Er
I
I
L r,ttuqt4i *a.e
I
a
I
d[.St.utf, Uc€tt 6tr]ct
t_
m&eta
E.
$[.$LdL
I
i3"g,, Uc<tt
Sa.saa
gLfl, Uc<rt ri?{tqc
str{, u.{l.dl.o{t. '{l
str{ ?4i rrttgc'tt3l'+i
ctt{l'ft
riqtqal.rri
rrftucnq.t uttd B.
Ruql cgui ,Jreq 3, d.r4r6.A.
flqU sd
souete"a
iq'0
tr{r?r
or+rctcu{ urde Et d vquqL.
iq"{l4i
lrqrel !,
a {qll
otou.crcl.
n?sr? srar ua{tkr
3 }He
4r}
?,u
tt.?,ttt.Q. {tqll
gec'{l l. $tafa
slqTlet'r u. A. A
q{a.at
luql cgrrt Utsql !, I iq'{lQ
flqlt q'ude E. a 3q'0 qtil
uRRQrl
E.
3u'["ti
qtqttei
],
URAQA
rrtl. r,tctt6
}"q OCI-runaer"j
u{qrua E QIS[]et"t ilcndct E
rrti {"grrtCt r4?U
seqt{ rltQct E
i.Hqt a rricf
udt$tla r,il"tetd't
i al
rril.'tcttt't frtl etSf
rrtqels
ertar
E.
tsf.
I
I
Page 3
of 10
r,ttQ
8 uaf 6u(0a
s?tl
E l r,ic] s"ttc€"arl.
riafustes E b br+ aa a otql. iletu u.tttllgt{t Rqtq seel.
a{1. r+Rqcuorl 4uql } rrtcuG'ft crl.sq'uqqflHi \tgt lde-Itl slct €af,
sltl ttiottncj qeII. fr r{a rrtlu?rt{sat scqt"ft efa{ af i"tf rrtel "tell.
r,ttQct
qrqror
ui4
utunell
] auea u?st?ou. +l.dt8]er"t"{l qtlctqt6?,t1. ?,t{ttt? al.sq+t.tg[ etu
trecu{ rltd. E, *ui gutle :iQs uaf'tt 3u"0 *tt I qrqtql. rrttuqt{i rrud R qi
dQc e3oral* I dQa qrqtql. r4tuqt{i r,ud E. I ar+t:{'ft "tfhr s{ u.tt[0gt{a{li
r,ttaaa{If, qrqttql
uroqqtul uttd E rru Q'tea. sfd Rqtq dqt'ft u.tt 'teII.
qfllrql
?,tt eLs
r{l qrcrdtetriq \tD,ct
3
gatcgft r+D"j qlS r,ugottg+l
i: 5rtc.{1,
3,
iuql
3q"["ri
uRRQtl
cgui qrqrql !,
cul+l.u[ a1s gat.rgft"ft uR@' rrt{tt-l rlt * ra"a E
r+r} {sqi frtlrl. SeII rur+ a ql.aa *a g:a+1
ctl,. UctUtqtt,
R. gea
ctfsfi a1s q+tctqft"{l qflqt qtq. rêtoe
?Atvotl,V
qtll DSal"ft qrr{l.tl E
r,ti qzil !ga{t
r,ttd,e E.
E. utl
rr{.
r<tt"e{ utq[:{IPII
r,il.tla rrti cJlu'tt
cttcti. ?4ctct. g{,
qrqft uliln s{l s{t
6qql,ct{i
d.qt'tl
da.
r,uyoug'{l 3q"{l4i uqllell
?41u.?t
cu{t'ft Qdlqt$ti
{5euor ert?{
I
sitt
i'tf nd srqrl{l
rrttd.. ?4t tU+t"tt ,ttt'aell
{sertor Elar af ai q(^d?
r4rucrrr+i r,ttcrel.
} }ur
sqr ul.*sa"{l qarcgfl E i tati dqi frorl. rlr
uftsa{l ctetutgll4t q(Bsegt qt]'n rcu"a'{l e?qrrt E 8{i ejfGsegr oue urgft {tgcr
seqt"{l qtct E, q.el Gtlcla actdl t3rr,ttal U{l{lo{la r,tetcrell s{ etsrer E, *Hl
r,ttaaa{lrl r,u
aot*
qn3uqi
u{l{lo{l qac{l sralc{t0 seel..
U
s{l 1}ercutt qrgarro
qlcr
i: sttc.{l
ctt. Uctiltq[,
},
], fr ?4r
3q"{1.il rcu.oe sl6 ugqqr
i{gl
cgul rguqi
af
?,u. ctl.s
sec{t"tl. +ell
gar.tqft'{l q{tata qr er Ht}
Page 4
of10
R. gaa
ET
I
iu"ft"ti uRRQtI
ll+gf qgqi qtquql b, aut{
stlcft
?or? eII iu"{l rttc{l a&a E. erquql
i+eII r+{a. 8 '1sett+ Etq E. cttr+i, iu"{lrl ?trt[
i'tf ct{t?t 6t?t sqttet ud otcttctc{t l{t} it€tq
saqtqi, rrttd.ct Ez a{t{ iq"ft stcr E. cuq'ft qctui
der Hr) qr?? €dl
i{u.r€l?l Ht} sftt ilet4 gt Ez
3,
eul qqr 3u"ftrl
$€rar slct E. r,t {i
r4l. cu:{i cleu
q3
qa
ett r+ee s?ctt
edtfl dtQ.
itgl
cg vquq{ }, :{tel ua r,ttaaa{lrl
3q"0"ti
'uq[Clel il€te{ l+t} "tdt ui.J UAAQa etqrql 3,
3qdlf, cu{+i els-I"rl
+cl.t€t{ {t)'tf E.
+cu.rs?r
HtD
ste D qa
qi
srd
qi seeitt
I qrquqf.
luqf 3q"{li Uq'r ?,u\i }, iq"{l4i URRQ?I
cttq'ti ctlsf'tt +cl.t€t{ {t} qfcq vqrql 3, rrtl. sa{1"0s
uctal dcrr frtlQ rrti. ee agt q'ttq.qt+i dA r,ri
qrn'ri rrial c[{ afs-l'rl il$lsa it{i tcgct il.s?au
{s-r,tq seqf fr64. i4g1 6U s{tqi ui cur+'tt el,sl,
3 tt{l.j +6[ ui.1 qe'Ia {tl s]t, Uq'r rnQ a Urugl.
olsettot U.j e1u r+i Q.0 ut o{lqn rrue-Iceri. ecrar
r,tnr erdl cfq .it i."rl. ?a(R{tn stuT s{qj.
seql f,oA, 2rqr qdul gfo nd
sarJ
r.{
Er
3q'[l4i
ulct
lr+Q e4u.?j !, udet udtftla
qatcrctt4l rrttd utjl ?,tt ct].s
qrqrql
i
g'tt.rg[ r4tct4 crtrtaqtul qtd'
tresra"{l rflr+ Uvor
a{l {RqQu.tt {ctorartd
: ctlctga,
uRhQa
3,
a{?cr
Page 5
of 10
?4{a
ctt. : r{C,tttl.Qtt
[t. : +J?ct
(la' e3rr41a1
"}
ud[6t]a
?r{.qc{.qi r{tQ
0.
I
g
c{ ut}"j e'lq E. a
e? r+6t+t'{l ro
dt{Q
rril.'tattl't
otec{ct
ut0 {sclt:{
rnd E. I ea 3 c{{
{"9 srrccr"j e1u E.
{tQ}$t+t"t
udt$t}a
qgr 3 qd {r}
r,ttqqtqi rrttQ. E.
ui.J +fll+ oteeto
Itctt a rrt{4, €g
r,ttqqtqi
uti
qabr
rrttQ.A +ell
qile E b
?rl.
rlqrClrril
tJ.?,t1.6.4. flult
q.ttdl et} E rli
flilrote ?ottt qtll:+i
sq.{l.r,ttl. 6t?t r,tqa.
uil${lqa {tfl}$tu"t
udt{l}a
r{rqqrql
r*tqel..
utbGls r,tf0nfls{lA
lrqrel 3,
lugl
cgr+i etqrql
?!l-ttta'{l "t]q Qqt,{t
!, +tdt$tla
I
c{ct? ?,u al.s
aut{l
rrudl E qi
q+rcetti srut,ue SottG€oeott
I
I
**l
qfc{L
utflz qdl Ur{l+tldl'u {t"q atr4ql. } }u, i
r,tQst{ €t%? E a sat.a,a<t "t#[ secr"j st,r
qaa {t"?tct ut0. E } }:{Z uetl+ r,tQa{t"j E
rtqu?r
i
|
I
I
I
I
I
I
utl ?4t arori
I
I
dOar+i r,uuct"{l slo
Page 6
of10
I
d.crqul +ell.
lugl
ctgui vrErql 3, al. qdl
r,t ctlsq'uctqft iqdli +tdt{t}a
lrs{l mq flr?oile s{tell etrrtdl
f,tlil
strgt
!
udtt$ba qcta
I
nd sqT 0. a l{t"q atu{l etstat
+0. a lrt} r,tt al,s g+rcg[l
rrtrti. rige 'tell rrti utdt Ugt
sflA.
+gui' qrqrql ], rlt als
gatctgfti r,tl. r{lsteat 'teII.
iuql
r,ttaa+{lrl qrqrqi
}, r4r a1s gatcgfti
u&e saqt.tl. r,t[0.ste au]. +ell. iuql
eg{ erq[qj ], artret rjgtr,il'ft rrtdl "t]tl seqr{ r,ttd.at E.
I s{l 1}eteutl ottgQtttt ir{gl qrq[ql ], ?,1. als iq"{l4i uRRQrl
g'ttctg[+1 {tq]t qrqtt erqrql b, cttll"rcrr{i
ule
ctitll'tcte flseqrxl rruqe]. rti. I g-Itl Relq ?4r
i' srlc{l
qrqrt r,u uL*sa+]. Rglq d.qrr+t uftga [Qel dcuul
ctl.. qctttl.gtl.,
rrttqel.. af rrrqi srJ {l qnqt r,uqel. R c.lvetc{l ua
R. qra
Eel. 3 ?,u ul*sai Qgcct r,ic)u tRs ill+t?r.?
qar+i qnde seqt:{i
r,ttqqtqi ottd.a E ! "tdtZ
Uel
tti
qrqeL
.{l dq
ur6e 6ua uqr
u.{1.{l.o{1.
lsctul
it+q] cgui erquql 3, cr+i
r,uqe]..
I 3u"{l"ti uRROrl
!, r,tl qGt{fl
rrur{lrl dA }
O."cttqel."e SG{lqe"U rrttUqp{ erqrql
r,uqel.,
i"{l fls
sl.{l ?lr+a. uqt
r,ttqqtql tttd. SgII rrtui. ugt rl.rrtqt l."e sc{lara"u
tu"{lqi uftsai su "{l ils sfr{I aui
etaal.i. uttt{l't ,iV{t r4tqqt{ rlrqqt{i rltcrel, uri
rrttda E.
v?? erqtrq af a'{l
mgr Er?r 3
etral.
tiel
iu'ft
Page 7
of 10
ou.rrcil.
ctfsf
at{Ia qql
o
r{l
11Qua116
ulct
i
: ctlctge,
ctl.. : tlC'tl{l.Ql.l.
[i.
: !?ct
rtct,rartd
ntE
geeL.
3rr"{l
uRaQa
l,l{ql rgr.ql !, ud[{t}a qcr?
iu"{l 6t?r I nd saqrql ?4ract qrquqi B, {[cea era.e
E. a cl,rgr?rtue E. a l{t} uu uq[+] rtcte seqt{i
efs U'ttc{q[ ?e s?dl frtltl r,ttqel. rrti ,{d[ a
rla € aa ?e era.ct ctqi g rltgfti ?rtctct ?rtctc1
lrrql q"?r ueil. eg sat gt4i ! 3u"{lr,tli r{tqqtr+i
flcee stat qtqft+], G.sta setl rrttqel..
seq.tul r,tctel.Z
i
qy13ttqf.
il+ql cgr+i 6U }, al iq"0+i uRaQfl
l)+bet'u+t q'quei 3 r4r.
utq[+], 6u?rfct otcftlrtr+t
qrqrqj 3, qcft?urti
I
qtgft"il 6uql.ct
seqtql rltcre].. af f, tqttctf ] geqt{ r,tctel a
laet utq['t] 6uql.ct saqt{t iq"tl"{l dqflafl:ri
rrucrel. r,ri usrug[l s{ti qstilgfl seqr{i
rrttqel. uti cqt?otte
"tlutqt{i r,tqef } }t{Z
li Gq?ncrlrl a.qtl+l
rruqel.
lugl crgui Qacti +tdt{}a+l
't{"tf qrqdr vq[gj ], un
tudUl]a.tl urul +5it E. ntli
udt$tla ut rgror"j elq E.
i'l{gl cgr+i qtqttqi
r,trjs uictgftr,il E.
I
!,
r,t:{tfl
"{Iil
ryrr,t
E.
d. r,t rtttoe eti saqtql qra.
cf;
(t)
r+t't'ftq
sdsaas{l4i
rrttaflUgtF+i ctu-tltl AS
tuRR q'tl'q,t{ r,ud. *l{i
crrq'rl ct].sf ufat'tl Uaf
Page 8
of l0
?V 5{
rje}eftr,il qa
?Ttlta 3u"ft iltO qr{
s{
[i..uegr audl etstq.
(?) ile? +tQRi R{agt"{l
ild[ rltUcttUi rtd..
(3
) ?,t 3u"{l qtilell' 3Qar rls
se-Is"tf oit.s dcttl+l r,uQ.
8'{l ilil
sO,saes{l r-ril.
e&ef.
(U) tttYottg<i cu{'ti afgf
r,ti su"{l }tu{li sdsaa
ut&q'tr urti{erqgu. &our
uQR q'ttcrcrrqt rlrQ.
"?t{i uasrfl uo{+{lSt"{l
A\
esl.t.tl geualct
't enq i
utlR 6r?r
etuqtrtl
alerfl
?rttd.
i:+gl yor 6U } o.?,no.A.
flqlti ?€, s{, s"ttc€"ea.
udtQla qATPII ersq o]q al gfl
ctl.sgatcgft se.{I.
c
i' srtc{l
}, r+'{lltatt6rl t
1gtur1 s8ct E aa uta-I crEr
ctl.. qC.till.qtt,
?4{1.?t cttr{qf"tl..tl
a{l qrctdterquo
u}ct,
l{gl
erquc?j
}Sl E.
R. qea
ctgr+i 6il{ } 3u"{l s{{{?af
r,t). Ctqre E i. i{'rt rrtta-lcar
utlott, ilgdl rtt}'tt tutr.tf qtul
E3!:{,igtreit.
e
r{l lrRqeu.tt
rtcr..tQr.tt
i:{ql eflilei }, rru ctfs
qle
q'ucgft"{l
t
td$teil lg-l$[cr Rqra grqrr+l
'
ctlctYe,
ctt. :
t-tC.tttl.Qtl,
r^ttQ.
I
r{l"tlaq
a'{l rls
rli
s-lr{l rrt{a.
utbGts r,tfQstfl8{lq
eryrej
!, r{
cits
q+tcg["{l stalqrdt
.rft{
U.{1.{l.o{l.dl
Page 9
of l0
l4tUcttl{l
R. : +J?ct
44.
d.quttla
6ut
rrtuefs
s?c{rl{i ?Atqel' i{
tsal ar+i. l.'ft +sct
rrttUqt{ rrttqef.
dclri. utbGls r,r[0st{ts{1il verql }, rleue gtllui tdQtr e3rr'tct1, UqA dQarti ?,ti
r+l0sui {s{I E l, autrt"{l "tftr saqtr+l r,{Q.a E. r,tl I d0'a r,ti :l0s ?Srltcil Etl
E i rli ctls g+tcgtt"tl Q$tu1c114 qqr saqtql r,td.ct E I arttrt [a,cta] {c,i[0ct
rrilEf{tdt ilHet e3' SecttUl rrttqel.. Uftsa Uqf't"e Atet I q'c{tot r,ttUqt{ ?Atca[ E, R.t]
ugr ur+tdet s{t srdqtdl +]tr ilal+ il.u[0st{s{li. rructrn'0 stdqtdl r,t{ {fsac{t{t
rttqel.. dll.?o{.e cg sttl ua 6q(Ad ot Ectt u1+1, rruatte .arsc g{t; als g+tcrgft Ugl
Eilet qrt&e saqt{ qtdl.
,f(M
n l"-
ctt. qctilq|'|',
ctl.. 3O/tO/?Otq.
cJer?tcr
\\
Y
8.3.ula
r{.f,."t.r{S cttBtt u.rt.f,n.
utbGls rl[0gt{,
uarlqtqt a1s g+tcg[+t rrttaa
?9l,st: cttrL 5tlC.0,
[3. gca
'|
uguqr Raiagr oil.s, gea
u(lqa[, c.1.U.G,.ot1S,
crtdl+cu'u utiRQ
ctEt +t(rat
aEt F.qrt{[ ot[0.s gO.saa
r4Q.s
?4a.
ftrcu luQa, Uea
Page 10
of10
From: gpcbpublichearing@gmail.com [gpcbpublichearing@gmail.com]
Sent: Monday, October 26,zOtS 2:15 PM
To: MINAXI UMESHCHANDM SHAH(GoG-GPCB Dept.)
SubJCCT Fwd: PUBLIC HEARING OF KE]RIWAL INTEGMTED TEffILE
PARK
PW
LTD
Sent from my iPhone
Begin forwarded message:
From: ms-gpcb <ms-opcb@quiarat.qov.in>
Date: 25 october 2015 at l1:28:07 AM IST
To:"@"<@>
SubJECI FW: PUBLIC HEARIT{G OF KE,RIWAL INTEGRATED TEXTILE PARK PVT LTD
From : JITENDRA PATEL liitendraoatel 16293@qmail.coml
Sent: Monday, October 26,2075 10:05 AM
To: ms-gpcb; oocbrosrt@vahoo.in
SubJect: PUBLIC HEARING OF KEIRIWAL INTEGMTED TEXTILE
PARK PW LTD
Please, find out attached sheet of Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park Private
letter in minute of meeting.
Limited
public hearing related letter. Submit our
Thanks With Regards,
Jitendra Patel
Ankleshwar
9998980s19
Drsrl:air:lgr:
Thi5n1eSS.?geancal1yfileska,lsn1ii|eiwitlrilaieccniidsnt;al,pfooriete'ytoGcv3rn)ento
'rth€ertityli.isadd|€sSedialf.y,oua|enotthe|ni€ncec|ec!pientcfinirn']essa!e.you3renoiaJtnsrizedicreed.io^'aId,pIinreiain.
rn€s*iag€ ai ary cart of rt. lf ycu rave received lhis eriaii in errcr. please notii/ ihe s€rd€r irnnedlateli/ by return email and delete it from lcrir^ ccrnpuief. The
cilrncany arcepts nc iiabiiify icr a,ly canlage cause<i by an./ virus trarsnrilteii by in:s eHir,l
This message contains confidential information and 1s intended only for the individual
named. If you are not the named addressee you should not disseminate, distribute or copy
this e-mail. Please notify the sender immediately by e-mail if you have received this email by mistake and delete this e-mai.1 from your system. E-mail transmission cannot be
guaranteed to be secure or error-free as information could be intercepted, corrupted,
l-ost, destroyed, arrive l-ate or incomplete, or contain viruses. The sender therefore does
not accept liability
for any error or omissions in the contents of this message, whj,ch
ari-se as a result of e-mai-1 transmission,
Drs{ia!nigr:
Thrs n:essaEe an! any fiies trarsmiitei witn ri aie canfidential. procietary tc Gcvernmsni cf Gujafat {GOG). pl'riiegec or cther$JisE *rciectec by iaw. Views or
spiaions ;)resentet :n this elnarl are ihose of iire authcr and dc rct necessar:y reprRsen! tiose cf rn€ ccrncary. Tha ,nfor$atinn !s sciely inteDded fcf the indiv:iuai
qe€R<€qRTffirt
st-Y, rrqrfiqrd M,
em.fr.q€ Ed+ fr$,
*.ennS.S., siq;#q{
Rqrqs-q-*eooR
fqt6:q7qo/Rot\
tl;n t&rft,
Usrcrd
lrswr tr+r"r
qtefr;rIn
dg
qSEq*,
r6ffi q,RS rrf+ ffiqre Eai}}s tgarTq qrdc|'{+e
dffi il ffi eqfr f{qffi{ pq drt gvre tr
qrq ffi €tq +ffid ffir Est R +S tus qqrqr }1
11 qq{ Errfr+ EFFT E{ ffi
r) qtat +e ET+ qeit errerd+t vgFunt w+qftfr+l qqrq w<* ffi qm wr ${ffi tr
fdniq' eo ef,qfi+ Sqe
ffi
RFwEn
qrtf++' ETdr$
ffi
q) Es fdqTr+ t-sreT frat
'rot tr
yqi.d{ur
fq+d€qn T{ffn€ qteT
+
tt'**q{
9998980519
Subject:
Attachments:
FW: UrgentAttention - VIOLATION OF MANDATORY TOR COMPLIANCE lN RESPECT OF
QCI-NABET ACCREDITATION CERTIFICATE AS PER SET PROCEDURE - Urgent
Clarification regarding documents to be allowed as proof of accreditation for Environmental
Public Hearing (EPH) o
Detox - Kejriwal.pdf; Detox - Shanti Integrated.pdf
From : GPCB RO Surat [mailto : gpcbrosrt@yahoo.in]
Sent: Wednesday, October 28,2015 3:02
PM
To: Parth Desai
Subject Fw: Urgent Attention - VIOLATION OF MANDATORY TOR COMPLIANCE IN RESPECT OF QCI-NABET
ACCREDITATION CERTIFICATE AS PER SET PROCEDURE - Urgent Clarification regarding documents to be allowed as
proof of accreditation for Environmental Public Hearing (EPH) o
Regional Officer
GPCB,Surat
OnTuesday'27october2o154:51PM,Krishnakant.@>wrote:
MOST URGENT BY EMAIL
VIOLATION OF MANDATORY TOR COMPLIANCE IN RESPECT OF QCFNABET
ACCREDITATION CERTIFICATE AS PER SET PROCEDURE.
Date:27 October, 2015
To,
The Secretary
Ministry of Environment and Forest & Climate Change
Prithvi Block,First Floor, lndira Paryavaran Bhawan
Jor Bagh Road, Aliganj, New Delhi - 110 003.
The Director (Environment)
Gujarat State,
Gandhinagar
The Chairman,
Gujarat Pollution Control Board,
Paryavaran Bhavan,
Sec 10-A, Gandhinagar
The Member Secretary,
Paryavaran Bhavan,
Subject : Urgent Clarification regarding documents to be allowed as proof of accreditation for
Environmental Public Hearing (EPH) of M/s Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park and M/s Shanti
Integrated Textile Park Pvt. Ltd. To be held on 30-10-2015 lN Surat district, Gujarat.
Madam/Sir
This is with regard to our previous letters written to you at various point of time and also same issue
raised during various EPHs held in state of Gujarat since last two years.
The EPH are held as per the guidelines of EIA Notification 2006 and amendments there under. As
per the guidelines ElAs for a public hearing are to be prepared by Consultants Accreditated by aCl NABET. The QCI-NABET issues accreditation certificates to various consultants after a series of
scrutiny. The TORs issued by MOEF or SPCB specifically asks for Accreditation Certificate issued by
QCI-NABET.
However we have been raising the issue of overlooking of such an important process of accreditation,
wherein various consultants have submitted various other documents other than a valid Accreditation
Certificate from QCI-NABET as part of mandatory disclosure in the EIA document. We have brought
this to notice relevant authorities during many EPH, however no proper reply has been received.
Through this representation we seek clarification on what documents are legally allowed in lieu of a
valid Accreditation Certificate.
The above two public hearings mentioned are to be held on 30th October and according to the
provisions of the EIA Notification 2006 no valid Accreditation Certificate is produced with the EIA
documents. We are annexing the documents produced by the EIA Consultant M/s Detox Corporation
Pvt. Ltd. as part of mandatory disclosure with regard to the EIA Consultant.
WE SEEK AN URGENT CLARIFICATION WHETHER THE SAID DOCUMENTS ARE VALID IN
LIEU OF AN VALID ACCREDITATION CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY QCI-NABET. Kindly also
provide documents and gazettes notifying list of documents to be allowed in lleu of proper
Accreditation Certif icate.
In absence of any response we would assume that the above mentioned EPH are happening in
violation of the Environmental Procedures prescribed.
Anticipating an urgent response in this regards in interest of Environment and Sustainable National
Development.
Sincerely,
Krishnakant
Paryavaran Suraksha Samiti/ NAPM
Ph: +91 -9427849310
Subject:
FW: Clarification regarding documents to be allowed as proof of accreditation for
Environmental Public Hearing (EPH) of M/s Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park and M/s Shanti
lntegrated Textile Park Pvt. Ltd. To be held on 30-10-2015 lN Surat district, G...
From : Jayesh Patel loateliavesh 196 1 @oma il.coml
Sent: Tuesday, October 27,2OlS 4:15
PM
To: Hardik Shah (Director-Env-FED); secv-moef@nic.in; Dr. K U Mistry(Chairman-GPCB.); ms-gpcb
Cc: gpcb-sur
Subject: Clarification regarding documents to be allowed as proof of accreditation for Environmental Public Hearing
(EPH) of M/s Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park and M/s Shanti Integrated Textile Park hrt. Ltd. To be held on 30-10-2015
IN Surat district, Gujarat.
URGENT BY EMAIL
Date: 27 October, 2015
To,
The Secretary
Ministry of Environment and Forest & Climate Change
Prithvi Block,First Floor, Indira Paryavaran Bhawan
Jor Bagh Road, Aliganj, New Delhi - 110 003.
The Director (Environment)
Gujarat State,
Gandhinagar
The Chairman,
Paryavaran Bhavan,
The Member Secretary,
Paryavaran Bhavan,
to be allowed as proof of accreditation for Environmental Public
Hearing (EPH) of ltl/s Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park and M/s Shanti Integrated Textile Park hrt. Ltd. To
be held on 3O-10-2015 IN Surat district, Gujarat.
Subject : Clarification regarding documents
Madam/Sir
This is with regard to our previous letters written to you at various point of time and also same issue raised during
various EPHs held in state of Gujarat since last two years.
The EPH are held as per the guidelines of EIA Notification 2006 and amendments there under. As per the guidelines EIAs
for a public hearing are to be prepared by Consultants Accreditated by QCI - NABET. The QCI-NABET issues accreditation
certificates to various consultants after a series of scrutinys. The TORs issued by MOEF or SPCB specifically asks for
Accreditation Certificate issued by QCI-NABET.
However we have been raising the issue of overlooking of such an important process of accreditation, wherein various
consultants have submitted various other documents other than a valid Accreditation Certificate from QCI-NABET as part
of mandatory disclosure in the EIA document. We have brought this to notice relevant authorities during many EPH,
however no proper reply has been received.
Through this representation we seek clarification on what documents are legally allowed in lieu of a valid Accreditation
Certificate.
The above two public hearings mentioned are to be held on 30h October and according to the provisions of the EIA
Notification 2006 no valid Accreditation Certificate is produced with the EIA documents. We are annexing the documents
produced by the EIA Consultant M/s Detox Corporation h^. Ltd. As part of mandatory disclosure with regard to the EIA
Consultant.
WE SEEK AN URGENT CLARIFICATION WHETHER THE SAID DOCUMENTS ARE VALID IT LIEU OF AN VALID
ACCREDITATIOI{ CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY QCI-NABET. Kindly also provide documents and gazettes notifying list
of documents to be allowed in lieu of proper Accreditation Certificate.
In absence of any response we would assume that the above mentioned
EPH are happening in violation of the
Environmental Procedures prescribed.
Anticipating an urgent response in this regards in interest of Environment and Sustainable National Development.
Sincerely,
Jayesh Patel
Secretary, Khedut Samaj Gujarat
Oisclairner:
This ,.nessag€ en,i any files transniltted i.,.tti it ars ccniiCen::al. prspri€tary
Ir Government cf Guja.ai 1GOG). nr:vilegec, cr otheffi:se Dfc:ectec by
rnessaQeoraryparlrir: ltycuravereceiyec fhrsamaii ;nerror.pleasenctif/thesenderinrnrediately!'t'returne;nari
icmDery accepts nc irabiiity icr ary ca:nage aansec by an;: virus transnirtted by ihi! enra:l.
!ae,,.
V:€ws cr
anddsiets:ifron-:ysurccmpuier The
Mittal
Subject:
FW: response to EPH of m/s KEJRIWAL integrated textile park , palsana, dist Surat,
Gujarat, on 30 October 15 at 16 hrs.
From : GPCB RO Surat fmai lto :o ocbrosrt@vahoo.
in
I
Sent: Wednesday, October 28,zOtS 3:05 PM
To: Parth Desai
Subject: Fw: response to EPH of m/s KEIRIWAL integrated textile park , palsana, dist Surat, Gujarat, on 30 October
15 at 16 hrs.
Regional Officer
GPCB,Surat
onTuesday,27october201511:51PM,quickcommunication<@>wrote:
ms-gpcb has asked me to send e mail to
Shri RVPatel saheb,
pl. forward this mailto ms-gpcb & secy-SLEAC.,
hope, this attachment is open properly, if not, pl. inform me on my
mob 09377958840.
,
RESPECTED
MS-GPCB,
REP OF MS.GPCB
DlST. MAGISTRATE,
As per qci-nabet directive, we understand PROVISIONAL ACCREDITED
CoNSULTANT ( NOT HAVING l2',FAE',APPROVED) ARE NOT ELIGIBLE
TO PREPARE EIA REPORT,
IN CASE ]F RULE IS CHANGED BY QCI-NABET, & IF THIS EIA REPORT
IS ACCEPTED FOR ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING,
THEN PL. LET US KNOW, SO THAT WE WILL NOT RAISE ANY SUCH
QUERY IN FUTURE, AND IF RULE IS NOT CHANGED, THEN HOW
THIS MERE-MISS-ALERT, MISS THE ATTN. OF GPCB's DEPUTY
RESPONSIBLE STAFF,
lN ANY CASE, AS PER OUR UNDERSTANDING, ToR COMPLIANCE lS NOT
IN ORDER & REAL VALID QCI-NABET ACCREDITED CERTIFICATE
IS NOT AT DESIRED ANNEXURE / EIA PAGE NO. AND OTHER DOCUMENTS
AS SUBM]TTED, IN ANY WAY, IT DOES NOT JUSTIFY AS A VAL]D ACCREDITED
CERTIFICATE AS THERE IS NO WORD LIKE A CERTIFICATE.
ELIGIBILITY OF CONSULTANT IN PREPARING EIA REPORT IS STILL
A BIG QUESTION MARK,
ANY WAY, YOU ARE A BEST JUDGE TO DECIDE FURTHER LINE FOR
AN APPROPRIATE ACTION.
DESIRED EIA PAGES EXTRACTED FROM EIA REPORT, IS REPRODUCED
HEREWITH AS SR PAGE NO. 3,4,5,6,7,8,910,11,12,13, Ot 14,
HOW EVER I-AST SR. PAGE NO. 14 OF 14 IS A SPECIMEN COPY OF REAL
VALID ACCREDITED CERTIFICATE EXTRACTED FROM OTHER EIA REPORT
PREPARED BY ANOTHER CONSULTANT, IS ALSO SUBMITTED HEREWITH
FOR THE INFORMATION OF GPCB SENIORS AND PROPONENT TO KNOW
HOW IT LOOKS LIKE.. SO THAT NEXT TIME GPCB SENIORS CAN CHECK
PROPER ACCREDITATION CERTIFICATE WHILE ACCEPTING EIA REPORT.
st.l'ft :+t5[ +r?sr?r+l uRq.t't at.tqr'0 r,tqtfl r+ rls G.+cr.tel iIQIqt D steet]
ur{t?t ucr.cr u{ldlo{I.{l Qor ntda q? {5tqt qdl qqu iq'ft r+t@.s-I ?aa.
q:ri.
rllt"ft eist'j tt{tt{tot sa{ .s.j, rr{r+t?t
rlaUr'it t\alrl uqt r,rteflr,utf erdl ]rr qtorcrr+i nlfl qcu+t1 sfl eftuL E
r{lBert Ral
rtt,ett €cu, rrti
tsal uet Ur{dloft'tt dl'{lr,ile r,tQ.st{ldl.a Aqi atc'I
,
} eQ Ufdlo'tct rl}fl}s
trt'ft qril
flqL€ U{teL r? QcI-NABET APPRovED rne qqt 4eII
rL qet tlrruttrl. Rritea ct'ttdl et} D al qtfl rl]t"0 .rta utr{l ,.iltl et} D
steqt} statet4t ctg tlqtste Ur{l{lo{l+t dl'0r,ite r,t[Sstflciqtt E
5a+Jc€.'e,
,
dQa{i s} a]. .rtrt} +ttqdlsteqt
prrer *e{l qtql ucu.a]. erQ.\er Hi s-Itt qqt sl
't[i r,ti rrttqt flu].€'tt rttrtr ur
ui.1
rr1 rrtt r,tra.i[
gctrul utt'ft ttqt
u?rtqee0e{ al.s q"uce0 erta{ }
cttl
erB
rllal
uu,cr?
}}r i"tl
Rqla{ ur{ltfto{lat ?cu,otet? rrtf0.stflctqtn
0.
QaeuQ {tqf2ui burrlct
adr,iliqr pr{ldlo{l+r tirr"rl? cttdl etflrl tilf,.
r,r tlLcti rtet {l"0auqi a.qt A"i.{t,
VERSION 02 WITH AS APPLICABLE FURTHER TECHNICAL QUERIES
FOLLOWS SOON.
thanks,
pravinbhai p sheth,
senior citizen, technocrat & environmentalist
Ankleshwar 393001
mob 09377958840,
other detail contact are in my attached letter.
VERSION 02 follows with additional technical query as applicable.
sauno sath-sauno vikas
WE ALL NEED A HELPING HAND.
WE WELCOME ALL INDUSTRIES AND ENVIRONMENTAL
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS, SUPPORTED BY A GOOD
QUALITY EIA REPORT.
tol
tr
GPCB TO NOTE:
PL. READ YELLOW ICON REMARK ON PAGES 3+
JUST SEE AT LAST PAGE HOW A REAL CERTIFICATE LQQI(SJJIfF
-sR. pliGFol oF 14
save Envtronment: care for next ceneratr-on'Envlronment publlc hearlng of
m/s , Kelriwal Integrated textlle park, palsana, dlst. surat, Gularat
Date 26 l1O 12A15
FOR MOSTURGENT ATTN
VERSION OI
From:
Pravlnbhal P. Sheth, A-8, KallndlAppartment, Chlkurmdl,Anklestnrar-393001. G,rJarat.
Senlor citlzen : Technocrat & envlronmentallst
cell no. :09377958840.
conlact mall ld - ocfastservice2@omail.com
lo, fmember secretary, GFCB, Gandhinagar,GuJarat
cc rDlst. Hagistrate
m+ooeb@oulard.oov.in
& chalr person,
environment publlc hearing, Dlst. Surat. GuJarat
rregional
AtJarat
SLEAC, Giandhinagar, GuFrat
'secrelffy,
*ceo.nabat
l{ev tblhl
r dlrector, impact assessment{oEF ilewDethl
officer,$rrat'
chairman-GPCB i
unithead-cFcq
*ToR
Gandhinagar
srrat
collector-surrtsou larat. oov. ln
opcbrosrt@ahooln
rnsoocbdoularat. oov.ln
n$at@qdn,ora
ritakfimna@nic.ln
chalrmm-aoeb@ruhrat.oov.in
@
58 compliance, ls not accegable, as, none sf the documcnts aJrererreE
in
Annexure 14 ls avalld QCFNABETACCREDTED CERTTFTCATE
{ a speclmen Cory of CERTIFICATE, ls JUST for ref. of GFCBlProponent ls at last page }
Sub: envlronment publlc hearlng of mls , KeJrlnlal lntegrated tefiile park, vlll, karell,
plot 341+, Palsana, dist. Surat GuJarat, on 30 October 15
file no. EIA-I0-2014-2151-E ToR dt 29.05.2015, ToR lssued bysecretary€LEAC-kcm
ProJect actlvlty- 5 (0
7(c), 7(h), study area 10 km radtus,
period,l March- 31 lday ( Irear not cleared on page 51t!l But presuming as 2015 )
?
Respected Hardik shah saheb,
Werefertothe'public notlce', Invitlng awritten response from publlc, we have revlewed
draft REIA report, and ntithout arry blas approach & with all due respect to proponent &
consultant, we forward here wtth an ALERT I MERE MISS for an correcflve idton.
s
01
u2
Comments
On EIA front page, though there is a menflon on@
all mlsleadlng one, as NABET letter as referred on page 232 and list of
consultants dt June 2015 ( on page A 239,, lt ls not for June 20is, but August
2014, ten months old) , are Nor rHE vALtD AccREDtrATtoN cERTtFrcCrs.
REMARK ON FRONT PAGE IT SELF IS MISLEADING ONE
There is a clear dlrectlve on ToR condtfion
other optlons are provlded,
We understand, as per QCI-NABET scheme, Accreditdlon certlfieate ls issued
?qyg_n g-o:q3.S_e-gfj2 FAE, so the ToR 58 compilance as referred on EtA Fege A
239, lS NOT !f,l ORDER; & ts a tftlSLEADtNG ONE, and as per eCt.NAeeT,
PRovlsloNAL accrediled consultant are not eligibh to prepare EIA report,
lf not agreeable to proporcnt he can produce such ellglbllfty btter of eCl-lrtABET
and submlt to us on our e mall ld. at least 24 hrs before the Oate, start hrs of EpH.
Draft REIA Report reviewed by Pravi nbhai Sheth, An kleshwar. cet | 093779F8840
SR. PAGE 02 OF 14
Save Environment: Care for next Generatlon
Envlronment Publlc hearlng of
mls
q!
E |s referred where one has NOT SIGNED
all 12 FAE for a deslred sec'tor, is
directive,
to
QCFNABET
AT ALL,-accorOing
requlred to qualify to obtaln Accredltation CERTIFICATE, and then only one can
EIA report.
be ellolble to
nths o]9, ls aletter wlth T & C aPPIY'
CERTIFICATE''
IT IS NOT AT ALL 'ACCREDITATION
What ls the value of thls docu
from SLEAC, to start base llne studies
in lUnnbU - MAY ( yeai not cleai on age 51 ) PRIOR to lssuing an sfficial ToR
on October 15?. lf so, pl. provlde such d
l
se llne studles samPle
anatysts carrled out, pl. provlde the detalls lllte'
a-+ontac't details of aPPrwed labb-how far ls thls from ProJect slte?
c-pt. provlde valld appiovbl certlflcde of NABL I MoEF as appllcable.
04
05
06
Pl. provlde desired reply and Incorporate the same in MoM'
We request Secretary-SLEAC, to proceed'EC' process In llne.of our'ALERTS' and
frfene MISS' , & if any documentli wlll be submltted after slgnlng Mo*|, toJustlfyAccreditalon certtflcate, pl. forward the same to us also for our veriflcation and further
comments lf anY.
Slnce mandatory ToR 58 compllance ls not ln order, and provlslonal accredlted
consultant ls not etlgllle to piepare EIA report, in consideratlon tothls, we request ltlSDlst.
crcB, HtS AUTHOnSEO RLpRESEUTATiVE to declde In consultation &wlth
a wrong
set
conducted
be
stlll
can
publlc
hearlng
envlronment
whether
Maglstrate,
CERTIFICATE
pre-cedence oR to postpone tlll proponent provides valld 'ACCREDITED
Deslred copy of EIA page no€. dffitn loaded from EIA repo{s, 1J Pl?Yllegle1:Ylih'
wltn necesiiry yeldwicon, as appllcable FoR NEcESSARY READY REFERENcE
CI.ARIFICATION'
PL DO CONTACT U6 FOR ANY II/IORE IFORMATION OR FOR ANY
Verslon 02, follows soon, with more technlcal querles'
thanks,
{.r.r"rl>rnr.d qt't"rJ,{^-f
(
'
pravlnbhal P sheth )
benlor cltlzen, technocril & env{ronmentdlst
EIA report'
mJ - Xejrfwat-OetJxiurat3OlOlS - enc- deslred extracted pages from.
pl. excuse, for arry type .tyPe setting I spelling / vocabulary mistakes if any.
reduce green house gases emission
plant more trees
save environment
care for next generation
WEALL NEED A HELPING HAND
-
Sauno saath
LET US PROTECT THE ENVIRONMENT
- sauno vikas
DraftRE|AReportreviewedbyPravinbhaisheth,Ank|eshwar.ce||09377958840
@
FRONT PAGE, REFER REMARK AT
LAST
SR. PAGE 03 OF 14
E
Assessment
Proposed Project
Integrated Textile Park &
Common Eflluent Treatment Plant (2.5
IILD)
At
Village: Kareli" Ta Palsana, District Surat, Gujarat
Project Proponent
IGntuMt Inugratef, te&ib Aar{rtue
Ert
Prepared By:
G
DHTOX GROUP
DfiP",ffitr
3'd Floor, IC G. Chambers,
Opp. Gujarat Samachar Press,
Udhns Darwaja, Ring Road,
Surat - 395 002.
ffi?ffi]
I
I
44s
...Sf.l
'd&rcp
u
I
N"IBET Accreditation vide letter no. N,IBET/EWRA002/004 and list of QCI approved consultant
uplouded on 11h Juue 2015
@
E
QCI LETTER IS NOT THE CERTIFICATsE- THAT
TOO
22 MONTHSD OLD!!!
PROVISIONAL LIST IS NOT THE CERTIFICATE- TAH TOO 4 MONTHS OLD
@ ToR coPY
SR. PAGE 04 OF 14
STATE LEVEL EXPERT APPRAISAL
xErRlrvA.L*,=*oift.=
COililITTEE, GUJARATDRAFT ElA REPoRT
Affice : Gujarat Poflutlon Control Board,
PARKPWLTD,
&
"Paryavarafi Bhavanu, Sector 10-A,
Gandhinagar-38?01 0, GUJARAT
**ilJ*t
$ccnEttnr
stetc l.Gnd
Phone : Ql9-23232152,
Far
Bqstr0ofiuxl
c
: 079 +3[13278r*'
[_
I fr{Ay lilt$
Tor.'"'
Pf.Cfdrnrtat Kejriwal
Iftjriwel Intryntd Texfile Pmk
70&1, Wcrld Trade Center,
, Ring Road Surat"
* '"
Sub;Environmcnt Cle*nncs und€r the EIA Nstific*tion tr(S6 for your proposcd project
st Vill:Ksrs{i, Plot No: 3{fS*IJ42J2&f$JS?;358n Felerna' Suret.
'
Dear
"r
.'
.
Sir,
{
This refers to your applicatiorr on the subject mentioned above and the meeting held with the
$tse Lcvel Sffihperaisat Cffirmiseq Cdffi dr ?4tt Xdsreh tO'fS:'tftri rcl€*diit inftrnrcion
F
f, itefeasibitity r€prt ond presentation madE hefore the SEAC was considered
, and the sdditional TOR prescribed was communicated to you ry thr SEAC inrmediately after the
said preserrtation. Howyver, a copy of the same is anaihed h€rewith for furtlwr necessary action
at your snd. You may please frrni$ tlre desircd information / documents to enable us tD process
furnished in
* ,
'l
.
the application furttter.
'*'ithrcgards,
*
Yot*
sincerely,
d?-"Mirtry)
{K C
3mrttrry, Si"t* f*vut Erpert Apprebnl Comrnitte€
Encl : As above.
@ ron coPY
* '.
OETOX CORPORANOil FVTLTD
ruLY at15
REFER ToR
6
66
58
CERTTFTCATE
IS REQUIREED
SR
FAGE
ptanied,
corrmihnerl
@
d
the
nnnageru{ to parry out the S€g plantatbn
aativities outside
arpas atld gltaithere,
LTO; -.
ne
prernises
a
05 0F
I
14
DRAFT €IA REFORT
", Progoeal far soeio-e€onomic
4€r
dgaF$rymf,S g$,fuitiee fndudirq conununiry uelfse progffi npsi usefut
in the pmiiect area fw ttp ovsEil inrpravament of the environmnt Subm4t a details flan for social
eorporfite responsibilities, wilh sppr0tri*fte h{rdgetsrf pouisiona for lk fidld hre years and activiti*
Bropssed bl he nani*d o1tq, 9ffi
:b. ltlcifi1r.-rr,#nt deffqgraphk a{alua of the araa.
trqRftPW
;
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,ifiC
A tahisr chart for the
isEiuas rai€Ed and ddr€$B6d dw*rq publh hearirq/cansUfidion and
commitsnent of the pr$c't ptrWtlt pn fie $€rne shoulri be provkled. F$ ection plan to address tha
iseuEe raised during publh h€s:i{g srrd tha il€cess€ry atluaiion of tunds fCIr the saffe shog{d be
prouirled.
Phn for cornplimce af CETP gulddl$c t$sued ry rhs CFcg.
5t. Whsther any litigatiofl pending and / or any direction / order passed by any Court of Law ageinst the
sompany, if so. detailelhare€f.
53. Oetaile
of cch€rre,fur sqrfaee as well ru
@
top rain $fiaFr h€rwsting arrd grburd urater rcchsrg€
wilh proper 3ci€nttfic cehulalione coflsidering rainfall in the region. cetchryEnt area, land
/
soil
charectertsics. grcund uater qecharye rate. duration of rein $rater harvesting etc. Deheils of provioons
{'f p|e'lreaftEnt of tha railrw$er Le the eate of su'frc run o'lT is ts be hsrsBstsd. Locsfion d rech*ge
pcrcdation wello on tha b1nuf dag.
(a) Does th€ eompsny hsve a rrell hlj dqurn Environmmt Policy approved by its Board of Diregtors?
lf so, it may be d€taihd, in fte EIA tsFert tb). @s the Environment Fdirry pressribe hr Etandard
prma / pfoe6d$e8 iow|s j*so @€,any rnfrngenrnt J dqrhr*xr I vbbttorn of tha,
"p"$ttE
environmental or fsest norms / condMons? ff eo. it msy be dsbfl€d in 0re €lA.
55_
Disciplinery pofuy oil CEIP fpr
56.
ljslal
iB
units.
lhs hitwchical Fyabtn,ar flSrninidmtiva order ot the sornpgfly to daal,wilh tha €nyirofirnenhl
i&e EC mnditions? Debib of {lrh $ystarn may br gfuen-
iseues snd for €nsunng
5f,
rirmr*r
Does lhe ssnpany
Sm@
hwe a ontarn of reportirlg of non comgbrnee / vbbtions of er,rvilryunemla{ nsrns
tn ihe Boad ot Direc*ols of the iryFany snd 1 or. shsrehold€fs or stak€hotderx
d hrge?
This
reparting m€qhanism sfrould be d€tafud ln the E[4 Report.
58. Certincate of ffir€difafion bsu€d
tncorporaied in lhe EIA
RWo{"
59. A tabular chart u,itt irdex
fs
t)'fie
FABET, QCI to the environmental coRsullant slpuE be
"
poipt-.$ae conrpliance of aborya TORa
€{}. Any furthpr darifmarion on cmtiog q.il h€ abow sturfcs ineluding sn{icipded i&pacts due io the
poiect and milignrtive nreeerree, proleet proponGnt can rebr to th€ model ToR available on Minbtry
rwbeite
& CETPs'.
Thess addi$oi€l TORI sttouH be oanl4dar€d fdr
the rehvant hrformglion
fts
prsparalion of the dfa* EIA report in addition to all
m per ns ganerh sir$ciure of €lA
lll A Appsndix ltl A of th€
pdtutisn
Guj*ts
Gontrol Boarct for
giuerr in Appendix
EIA Notificationl ?q06" The draft EIA repct shail be submMed to
*r*
conducling the publh consultation p{oceB$ aa per the provisions of the EIA l',totilicetion, 2006. T}xs proidct
shall b€ appraised on rec€id af
tE ftal
EIA r?port.
CERTIFICATE IS REQUIRED
AND NOT THE LETTR. LIST. SCOP OF ACCREDITATION,
ISSUED BY QCI-NABET .
OEfOX CORFORATIOi{ FV? LTD
I
SR PAGE 06 OF 14
KEIRIWAL
I NTEG
PARK
DRAFT EIA REPORT FOR
TEXTILE PARK
RATED TEXTILE
LTD.
F/T.
PAGE A 236 IS
A
LETTER & 3 MORE DOCUMENTS
Board of Directors of the company and
or
stakeholders
at
/ or shareholders
large? This reporting mechanism
should be detailed in the EIA Report.
E
58
Certificate of accreditation issued by the NABET, QCI to
the environmental consultant should be incorporated in
Refer annexure 10, Page
no,
4-236.
p
the EIA Report
59
A tabular chart with index for point-wise com
Refer Chapter 1, Table 1-5,
above TORs,
page no, 19.
1.10.3 Structrre of EIA Report
This report is organized into eight sections:
Table 1-6: Structure of EIA Report
Sr.
'I
ro"
lffiffiiittiifs
-,:....-
cqffif
Introduction
Purpose of the report
:]-':.]'
'l:
:
.'
Identification of project & project proponent
Brief description of nature, size, location of the project and
its importance to the country, region
Scope of the study
-
details of regulatory scoping carried
out (As per Terms of Reference)
2
Depicts the details of the proposed project, auxiliary and
Project Description
supporting facilities,
It
includes technology and process
description
Description
3
Environment
of naseline environmental conditions in the vicinity of the
project site. Data pertaining to the ambient air quality'
surface and ground water quality, soil quality, land-use
pattern, flora
- fauna study and
socioeconomic
environment has been Presented
4
Anticipated
environmental
impacts
and mitigation measures
DETOX CORPOMTION PVT. LTD.
JULY.zO
I5
Predicted environmental impacts due to construction and
operational phases of the proposed project. Air quality
modeling results and minimum required stack heights,
29
SR PAGE 07 OF 14
@
FAE DETAILS"
KURIWAL INTEGRATED TEXTILE PARK PW. LTD.
ACCREDITATIOI{S
e
.
o
ISO gOOt-2OOg certification
NABL (National Accreditation Board for Testing & Calibration Laboratories)
ilABET (National Accreditation Board for Education & Training) registration from
Quality Council of India as EIA Consultant
REGISTRATIOT{S
r
r
o
Class AA Contractor registration from Surat Municipal Corporation (SMC)
Recognized Environmental Auditors from GPCB
MoEF Registration for recognized Environmental Lab.
LIST OF EC & FAE ITTIVOLVED IN REPORT PREPARATION
The list of experts involved in report preparation are as mentioned below
EI,A COORDIilATON,
Name
:
Mr. CHETAN CONTMCIOR
FUilCTIONALAREAEXPERT
@
Sr. no.
Name of the
Functional ar€a
I.
AP
PUSHPAK SHAH
2.
WP
PUSHPAK SHAH
3.
,i'*"-t<*A
&-.sl',ez
PUSHPAK SHAH
/'
4'"e/ba-
ta'*''gaa
NV
PUSHPAK SHAH
5.
SE
DR. DIUP SHAH
5.
EB
DT.
HG
N
DETOX CORPOMTION PVT, LTD.
JULY-2015
Signature
r''
4.
-7
expert/r
I
BHAVM
MEHRA
LK,ANTH ](AVA I-AN EK.AR
w.w
107
oNLy 10 FAE, AND ONE HAS NOT STGNED?
sR PAGE 08 oF
KE]RIWAL INTEGMTED TEXTILE PARK PW. LTD,
E
8.
AQ
ANKTTA BHAIRAVIYA
9.
LU
JESSICA KARTA
10.
RH
ANIL CHAUMAL
AD
DITTOilAL
PERSOTTIT{
l{ame of the
exFcrt/s
1.
AP, AQ, Noise and RH
Ankita Bhairaviya
z.
RH
Mitesh Desai
J.
SE
Ms. Hetal
4.
AFAE-AQ, WP, SHW
Maitri Contractor
5.
AFAE
5.
AFAE .
-
???
1-f'
ir\u
.g
ft,b$ry."-
EL
Functional arer
Sr.
no-
@
AP, AQ
DETOX CORPOMTION PVT. LTD,
JULY.zO15
Signature
:**,*'l
,Y&e ,'Fs
Parth Desai
Mittal Kyada
108
14
SR PAGE 09 OF 14
ORAFT EIA REPOFT FOR
TEXTILE PABK
KEJRIWA INTEGRATEO TEXTILE
PARK FIT, LTD,
@
@
E
nmeryre
10:
tffi$Et.flcrefrtatim ccnficau of
consltt{rt
ANNEXURE 10,
HAS MANY DOCUMENTS,
WHICH IS THE CERTIFICATE???
PAGE A 236 IS NOT THE ACCREDITED CERTIFICATE.
IT IS A PAYMENT REMIDER THAT TOO 22 MONTHS OLD.
OETOX CORPORATION P\/T, LTD.
l-l
lrl
fl-._-
TH|S LETTER tS NOT THE CERT|F|CATE. sR PAGE
IdL INTEGRA]ED TEXTILE
LTD.
ru
ati o n a Pffif,tFffiFlffi
Bcard
for Education and Training
Decenter 12,201!l
ilABFr/EtA/FAmvOlf
The Chairman and MD
Detox Corporadon ftivate Limited
3rd Floor K.G Chanbers, Udhna Dantaia,
Riq Boad, SuEt- 395002
(Xird Attention: tflt. Chct.n Contractor)
DesrSir,
Sub:
leAcctcdltation
reference to your application to QCFNABET for re-accreditation (RAl as EIA Consuhant
Organization and th€ asscssment carried for rame in your organization from S€ptembEr 11 - 13' 2013,
Ihis has
based on tic document and sffrce assesimentr du!'ing RA, the
Accreditation Committee har approred renewal ol accreditation given to your orgenization subiect to
coverage d hlance Functional areas and spedfic respons€ to NC5/Obs./Alerts is:ued {Refer Annexure lll}
we a.e pleased to inform you that
with the fqllowing det-alls:
1. Annexure I
2. Anncrurell
3. rAnnexure lll
4. rAnnerure lV
5" Annexure V
5. Anncxure vl
7, Annerufe Vll
Result
-
Scope of accreditation
-
Observations on Qrnlity lllanagement SYstcm (QMSI
Listofexp€rtswithappG€dsectors/functionalareas
ilon-Conformanced ObservatlonV Alerts {ltlG/ Obc/ Alerts)
Ternrs
ald conditions of accreditaton
Resultofassessment
Guidellnes for addresslng Major
Non{onfrmancas/ Observationsl Alcrts
of RA includin€ l.lqn-Confonnances/ Observations/ Aletts INCV Obtl Alerts) apPllcable to your
oqani?atbn as per RA are also post€d on QCI website vide minutes of the Accrefitaticn Committee
meeting dated S€pternb€r 2C, 2013. You arc requested to take necessarY actions to close the NG/ Obs. as
_j:
per guidellnes and timeframe mentioned ln Annexure Vll of this letter.
you atg requir€d{o make all paynentsto iIABET as applicable, within one month from the date sf invoice
sent to you. Contingation of this accreditation of your organlzation is subject to the clearance of all dues
by your organizatlon, satishctotY corrpliarKe to Annexure lU and V.
Whh best rigards,
Yours sincerely,
PAYMENT REMINDER LETTER!!!
,lfi{1
L&Y*.
Mt*tf$$tll
eeo
InstituSon of Engincers
Tef. : +91-11-2337 9321,2337 W57
10
2nd Floor, Bal'radur Shah Zafar Marg, New D€lhi - 110 002,
Fax : +91-11-2337 867s €-meil : nabet@qcin.org lVebsite : www.qcin.org
oF
14
SR PAGE 11 OF
THIS IS A SCOPE- AND -NOT THE CERTIFICATE
@
W
M
-'
S-""--
-i
F
i
Scooe
&-crtJeEE
!oOncatg!
1
t"
i.
,t
1 {a)
rAi
EEl
'=ffi
l$iilffi
C:tcsorr
llint!6fs.dirr
Alt
Sel!!!10!
1
ti}
rrKrwiilE vFH
rvllmnE
&
1{b}
ffishore rnd Onshore ,all and rEaF "exdotetion,
A
A
dd{db &produqtlbn
T?prmal PowerFlants
4.
I
MetatufsXcel
5.
5tdf,
t1l
6,
1{F }
7.
/"tdt
,&
?.f*l
InStrles
"Ig
lii.s,
{ferrous & no'n fenous}
Tq{iffi
6sn61
-
both
aiiiffirade fibers
3?
c9Tr9w
disno*al faffil
##.
;r#ffi
ictthg
Comrnon Muddpii$
erwt
ecenomk rones (SEzr!.
q!
$#*',
Htff
storage atld
ffifu"
&"
ffiwtrffiHffi
OETOX CORPORATION
rnla4 furat
F/T. LID.
A
A
rttlLt
B
B
?ffidii#ec +.k.lttig+ a"otSrnert protects
B
_i,
Detoxcorporadon Prlvrtc I
A
mh-
ffi
E IEl
A
A
6compkres/ alws,
&sl
*fft
rr:i;Ii:ii:..-
jr:
:
prtmar*and secq4fuv
l1
,:'.it',ft
A
minine
4
s
I
Privata timited
rfdl
*f,ii
3"
---=-=B
Annrrurc
!3i',
llii
DRAFT EIA REPOflT FOR
ofAcredftation
lsAMt of rH f consutrAf{T oR6A{_ffi
5lo
*-
*-* ..
TEXTIE
KE'RIWAL INIEGRAIEO
Fage 2 of 18
14
SR PAGE 12 OF 14
THIS IS A PROVISIONAL LIST- 14 MONTHS OLDNO
E CERTIFICATE
r.rir-t, rwunt- lt&at
6f*fi.t&tdm!ilt
il.:81-ll'lllLls
qr@rt.lr
*ffi
ql|Er I o|llEr c ttd rr
!.r$Frrrt I
*fl!q!
2
r5@
trl
Eiltgfl|ffiEud|t|OFl
d/Uid.mudlfrr
1
o.|-qtordrH,lra'
lf*
f Eq. f, G. ffir, OF. a{F
hid|f firq Lrfi.l| ttrrh il|| lEd,g!rt-
rd.&r
a
||.lrl'|H lldurr.
t
ordr!fo!!5!q4
d.|-Sfrra*
l' C
nb-
t3
lat 46:l- Ultslllt
n
t!.drffi
ConhA!ffiu(frbUrl*l/R.v,tv&|'
.t*trfftlE#Gldc
'
\ xb-"'t./#iW,t l. r i i ::,--r
;;
;
i:f
ffiffi
lffi
q rlEErE{trlbn ficrE
d
tJh,,,yt
l.nt
p*tdatid FdGt pdrl
||dorl
d|lq|,t
i6/
c.fd '.'|rl
t-Jtl
-En
.!a|{lJf
t.E$h tI|J
lELirlEFlEl
cFa.tEt5
tuqt1
- CGr ftl
F.rttr,|
A
rol
A
eht
A
5ldt
A
6(r,
0$2Ot{
ramFbd r.|.* q/tl
Fl|r*tl l'eFZI Sr..L
GdEilL ro|t SEI|L ldl
F4
B
F5
D
3
3:r
r(d0t
tu
3t
D-FrrC!|rlEihlru'
t-3t
h.ttrr.|t'ffi-7ut5
L*Effirso
A
0
I-:t-
:'.:il
Cg|r|gr dll.:rt trErana
A
7
A
rldl
l
D
rGl
E
!ht
qG
E
r lbl
tt$l q ||ftil
tEuct! gFl
cdUrtmurdi$r
-'.il
lr i-]il
I-.1-l'1F
A
p*c. Htt dropp|| tdl,
rnrluc
oarmcrd
rfirFlE hadlt rrtrE
fcdbrd&r.hqrna
HaEi4rc n'ElFilrJt
fiU-ldr illrrlm{irv
D
t_!
?.t!r*t-ttffi
ttttd*dll
E*oftErr&d cEdEasalEElw a,buua')/
ffi
.-iiEi-i-
''r.Tll
{c)
tt+ 0s.?f71
;:l
':--:
rtdo
3F)
SR PAGE 13 OF 14
pc*ntft.difrf nud|l|
cortueri
A
fIE|r
nr|rtldr|I sf r
riq.p.r r||d ru|fEllr d
pw frgrr radv ph rilrtr
A
5O
a
lEdour OrcE (& g
phdrl $:tEy
tffi
ffilncdrrmtdlddt
lttotFrfhSlt
c
5lDl
t-t
I (rl
E
n
Fq.Gahdd[dqCt|d+
rrffCE
rnn td
.!rrlh+ haq .rf,
rilstrEnlrw
prq.d
ilH|| d drr* lop'| d
il
n*ffitrEffGd-
^
r:l
g{i:1,
Rrv.
2VA*
05,
tO14
"W
.Irha" tu tu, hr f5. 14 F?d
|tlqr, ror
/rqns
4nl squrq Xbdh.
lo.4 llgr -
Hr*&llrlllfri€o
tuomlztl/ril
glzt'In'/|
eB*
I
lhmffi
I
mH
SE (Iio Eo., ldr& ?eillq|{. O- hcdr
HdrCf&ltrorfl E4Srt-tEG'
Etrdrdt6aYdF.fl
E!t- z4ltcll utEuB
q&DIIffi
ffigptt
L*aflEtU GddEe!@c|
ffi
hdtft (Fm!
urrr*c
ffi
A
9
OrnE|trlri!
A
tl
r-.|a n|f|| ld tse
bdrcn*!
A
I
t1,r
th)trt
tkbd--EacrrlElot-dr
-
15
A
dLl
UrdAEqtr d Conln,OndAorr GstrDrA*I/
fi
aJl
I
t
t
:6
t
ucrt|lH rutttatrt+r(lla
ncr llnud - lGar FlrD.rI rd
cLr
Grimt
drib
ffitri&in
@i
e
l.l
+td
9
A
tF)
A
3Gt
B
HdtuHrGtrd F#d.
rDd liEm.rb (c.drrft
A
5Ft
T* - r!6!r rd r!rr*
Cb
t
5
H-dg
A
so
bnffldii!
i3
2t
ObbldE|'r/ n r. r1l r[!
$noil|c o.|JL drrH
0!, 2O1,r
t*r
I
dn
ldl
hlrA
A-240
SPECIMEN COPY OF CERTIFICATE DOWN LOADED FROM
OTHER EIA REPORT JUST AS AN EXAMPLE ,HOW IT LOOKS
CERTIFICATE BELONGS TO OTHER CONSULTANT. SR pAGE 14 OF j4
G{'ANAT STATE ETNO$U{
Ur{rED
CORrcRATFil
Antnnro 6: Ccrfficft of
T#ffiHfl:Tiffffiru*
ADOMOSAT WEUS TO TANAR'R EPS FI
Brco<CB€t$2
Kzdanr Envimmnentd
funtultrl b lmm
$tilE(nEs
QCI
/
Natlonal Accredlution Board for
Education 8c Training
Qnlity
M&
m
Council of India
thdffi Envlrunmrnal fonrultenu
877/A/3, GIOf
Is hereby
nABEf
Molorym, Wdfro, Guiorot -
39@.10
dffotdd ac$adlw{on
Conwlt
rr+
inq Jr*wqr
edirar
**ritdtri.t6€#
under the QcF$aBtT !tchefe lor AEfdlwtlon ol EA
Oryaniratloni fneu 0y. nugust 2017t taF tlte loltot tlng scope:
I Rag
taE
@G d trr t ffi
l# :.fr
ffi e t( as 5 & D
4,
cl
i.rrFdttrl&tftrnlari{tâSdtlotrfisr4tsdffirntf,t *?r*Irhrl''tTt*tttWwfr*rrstFlt&frnbd'.Fn'dff.''(tfrl
Aellprrtlrfirfr*rdadrD i* &e rrlt tut ed Mtp8w 16 rtr tcffi 6dCtrdrnotadrE udni'lta
G.flffic.tc r{o;
NAg€n aAl 13r6t RAo04
ft
t'll[BET
Varld upbd
18, tu 6
$9.
tw eld rR&;fte*.fi.dsb#+t4,
&.sSl{Mqfffib,
. l*trl&dr..,dttr6ffik
r.drrirrdd:taM
lcsi{ryffitfrltd|tqd
ci
lGDl,{ Ellvrnoil{ErrrAr. @ilsurArrsl tur.Y 2015
t0
c5
From: gpcbpublichearing@gmail.com [gpcbpublichearing@gmail.com]
Sent: Tuesday, October 27,2015 5:58 AM
To: MINAXI UMESHCHANDRA SHAH(GoG-GPCB Dept.)
Subject: Fwd: Environmental Public Hearing of M/s. Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park Private Limited (KnPPL), at Village:
Kareli, Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat to be scheduled on 30th October 2015.
Sent from my iPhone
Begin forwarded message:
From : paryavaran m itra < oarvavaranm itra@vahoo.com >
Date: 26 October 2015 at 3:52:26 PM IST
To: "qDcboublichearinq@qmail.com"
Cc: Collector Surat <collector-sur@quiarat.oov.in>, GPCB Surat <oDcb-sur@quiarat.qov.in>
<@>
Subjech Environmental Public Hearing of M/s. Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park Private Limited (KITPPL),
at Village: Kareli, Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat to be scheduled on 3oth October 2O15.
Reply-To: paryavaran mitra < oarvavaranmitra@vahoo.com >
Ref:
PM/MPl263ll20l5
Datez26ll0l20l5
To,
Member Secretary
Gujarat Pollution Control Board
Gandhinagar
Sub. : Environmental Public Hearing of M/s. Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park Private Limited
(KITPPL), at Village: Kareli, Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat to be scheduled on 30ft October 2015.
Sir,
We have studied the draft EIA report of the
above-mentioned project. Following are our
observation/comments/questions regarding project and draft EIA report.
l. What was the previous land use of the land for proposed project? Has Industry obtained NA permission
for the land? Please provide the document.
2. How the required land for the project is acquired? Was it a government or private land?
3. When was environmental clearance for this project in Form I applied?
4. What is the status of NOC application to GPCB for this project?
5. What provision will be taken into consideration to tackle the fluctuations in the pollution load and
quantities, at individual member industries?
6. Please justifr domestic waster requirement for the proposed project.
7. Why baseline study was started even before issuance of TOR?
8. Please give exact dates of ambient air quality, surface water, ground water, noise monitoring and soil
quality monitoring.
9. In Figure 4-l to Figure 4-3 (Isopleths for PM, SOx and NOx), date is mentioned as 1710712016. Please
explain.
I
10. Why only 7 .46Yo of total land area
will
be developed for greenbelt rather than guideline of at least 33
%?
ll. What will be the impact of temporary housing availed by labors during construction phase on
surrounding environment?
12. What will be action plan for socioeconomic development of an area by project proponent?
13. What activities industry will take up as a part of CSR and what will be the budget for it?
14. How many local people will get employment through this proposed project? Please give classification of
skilled and unskilled manpower.
Yours truly,
Mahesh Pandya
CC: l. Collector, Surat
2. Regional officer, GPCB, Surat
Paryavaran Mitra
5O2, Raj Avenue, Bhaikakanagar road
Thaltej, Ahmedabad - 380059
Telefax - 079-2685 L32L
email - paryavaranmitra@vahoo.com
website - www.parfravaranmitra.org.in
g!sc!aimer:
'fhis message and any files transnritted wrtn ii are confidential.
Vr?netary to Gcvernn'eni af Gujarai {GDG). rfivilegec' cr rrhenrjse srcrectec by iaei. Vi€ws cf
cprnrcns cresented in this ertail arc ihose ci tre aulhor and dc nol nec€ssaiiiy represeri ihose af ine .cincany. The infcrn"raticn j€ sciely irtended icr tle ,ndrr;cua:
rnessaae or an't Bart of ii. li you tave r€ceived lhrs errari in error. pl€ase nDtrf/ the s€rc€r imrnediately Dy return eora:l anC d€lete
cctnaany accepls nc iiabiirty fcr airy camage railsed by an!, virus transmrlled by inis email.
:t frorn
ycu. ccn:puief The
This message contains confidential information and is intended only for the indivldual
named. ff you are not the named addressee you should not disseminate, distribute or copy
thls e-maiI. PLease notify the sender immediately by e-mail if you have received this email by mistake and deLete this e-nail from your system. E-mail transmission cannot be
guaranteed to be secure or error-free as information could be i.ntercepted, corrupted,
Iost, destroyed, arrive late or incomplete, o.r contai.n viruses. The sender therefore does
not accept liability
for any error or omissions in the contents of this rnessage, which
arise as a result of e-maif transmission.
m/s
,
Save Environment : Gare for next Generation
Environment public hearing of
Kejriwal integrated textile park, palsana, dist. surat, Gujarat
page 01/04
Date 29 110 12015
FOR MOSTURGENT ATTN
VERSION 02
From:
Pravinbhai P. Sheth, A-8, KalindiAppartment, Chikuwadi,Ankleshwar-393001. Gujarat.
Senior citizen : Technocrat & environmentalist
cell no. :09377958840.
contact mail id - oefastservice2@gmail.com
to, member secretary, GPCB, Gandhinagar,
cc Dist. Magistrate & chair person,
environment public hearing, Dist. Surat.
regional officer,Surat'
secreta
Gujarat
ms-qocb@qu
Gujarat
Gujarat
collector-sur@q
ia
rat.qov. i n
u ia
rat.gov.in
qbcbrosrt@vahoo.in
Sub: environment public hearing of m/s , Kejriwal integrated textile park, vill,
kareli,
plot 341+, Palsana, dist. Surat, Gujarat, on 30 Oitober ,|S
fife no. EIA-I0-2014'2151'E, ToR dt 29.05.2015, ToR issued by secretary€LEAC-kcm
Project activity- S (f) ?, 7(c), 7(h), study area 10 km radius,
period,l March- 31 May ( year not cleared on page 5l!!! Bui presuming
as 201f )
Respected Hardik shah saheb,
we refer to the 'public- notice', inviting a written response from publicr
we have reviewed
draft REIA report, and without any biis approach & with all
due respect to froponent &
consultant, we fonvard herewith our response vERSloN 02 probably,
it;;t add some
,
value to improve draft REIA report further for a better presentation
at SLEAG.
It is summarized under section A,B,C,D, as under,
Section R Appreciations
Sr
no.
01
The propo""O
y:11:y,::::l?i:"-
02
03
Y$99Pssljlnd
Thi= CE
ividual ETp.
Gravity fin"
member units.
Section
B
EI4
to sma' scate
leyite enrrepreneurs, facititate scientific
prov ide other infrastructu
re fac itities.
-
Queries extracted from draft RE|A
Draft REIA Report reviewed by Pravinbhai sheth,
Ankleshwar.ceil 0g377g5gg4o
dist. surat,
textile
What will be payback period of proiect capital cost of Rs.12l -28
Ot-a";
you will ensure that you will not pollute very nearest canal
Water body , which is iust 0.16 km from project site,
02-'Why the direction of canal not mentioned?, pl. provide the
level direction of proiect site?
Table 2.3,
how the color reported as 'not detectable'
a-- ls it just bY a 'vision method
b--
ORwhich instrumentwas
use@
Sec 2.9,
we appreciate gravity pipe line will be installed for the member
units,
whaf will be the highest and lowest slop level ( MsL) of member
Table 2-5 GW,
a--Why only l8 parameters monitoredn
b-how,ma
p1-. p64[ AS FlG.2.3
Table 2.3, water balance diagram'
What is the reason for 80 kld loss on recycled treated wate
Fig 3.1, wind rose diagram
15, so total hr should be
pl'
check at your end'
hrs,
one hr less, i.e. should be 22O7
b-what was to!4|-se!l hrs?
Table 34 AAQ,
pl'
a-- are there no industry, in study aiea, using COAL as a fuel'
confirm
b--why 'GO' not monitored, as it is also a part of AA
faUle 3-12, noise quality parameters
noi=" teveinOf ueesuneD at high noise area like
and
"--rrfry
nftTSntnty line, as applicable, pl' measure the same
incorporate the same in final report and confirm'
q.: you have closeO at Zg hrs on 31 May
b-.-exceptprojectsite,noise|eve|measuredon|yata||4residentia|
site' in
sites, why noise ievel NOT MEASURED at other industry
area-
studY
from
c--pl. pr6vide list of major industries with their direction
site, in studY area.
69,70,71,
71to74
d of each data / table'
Pl. proviCelhe same..
t sec'3'7'5 )
01--What was the source of all these data
personally and who
o2--OR who FAE has carried out this study
period'
what
villaoer/s Dresence and during
Sec 3,8,
book
whai was the yEAR of census & dist. statistical hand
Sec 4.5,
memberchip and how
Which TSDF site You are referring to obtain
far it will be from
DraftRE|AReportreviewedbyPravinbhaisheth,Ank|eshwar.ce||09377958840
m/s
Save Environment : Care for next Generation
ntegrated textile park, palsana, dist. surat, Gujarat
,
17
93
18
96-97
19
108
Section C
Pase 03/04
Sec.5.6.
hazardous waste -construction phase
You mentioned all such waste will be stored properly, BUT where it
will be disposed off ?
Green belt,
Total green belt area: 15857.58 m2 .i.e works out to be hardly 13.4%
on the basis of total plot area as 21248'1.88 m2 ( 52.50 acres, as per
page 16).
01--what green belt % norrns you have considered while designing
green belt area?
02--you propose to plant in all 1500 trees in two years span, but as
per set norns , the tree density is 1000 trees per
acreage of total land area, ( unless you have some different
norms) so, in consideration with total land as 52.50 acres, you
are supposed to plant total 52500 trees, so, it will be short by
51,000 trees, pl. confirm whether this norm is equally applicable
to your project also, lF lT lS SO,
d---sor how you will make up to plant balance trees in 2
years of span.
b-perhaps, your water balance diagram MAy CHANGE,
then how you will make up additional water for green
belt?
c---have you surveyed any land out side to plant trees?
d--if so. How you will mange to provide water for that?
03--you propose to use, in all, B0 kld cETp treated water to cover
up 15857.58 mr green belt area, it works out to be f lits /m2,
a-'pl. provide permitted norms of treated waterfor usage for
green belt.
b--in case, if treated water does not comply set norms, then
what wilr be your pran to obtain dairy water requirement.
c--what will you do for rejected treated water.
O4--what will be the suryival rate of trees proposed to be planted?
O9--what will be the APTI values of trees to be otanrert?
a--Why FAE at n
".
b-OR was not available
during base tine studied
c-lf so, who has carried out such Ae studies. ftrloO,
General queries
Why details of, in which ap
analysis like GWSW, AtR, NOISE, SOIL , as applicable,
Were carried out, pl. provide details like,
a- name of lab. with contact details,
b--how far it is from project site?
provide copy of status of it's VALID approval as like MoEF,
"'-p!r
NABL, with valid copy of scope of analysis
d--Pl. confirm whether, referred approvediab. has facirity to
analyse pm 2.5.
f--why name of approved lab. was not disctosed at the end of
each table of all analytical result of base line studies
have
for rain water harvesting?
s_ample
Draft REIA Report reviewed by Pravinbhai Sheth, Ankleshwar.ce[
0937795gg40
m/s
,
Keiriwal integrated textile park, palsSna, dist. surat, G
page 04/04
Section D suggestions to be implemented if found
viable
acceptable and economica
Gomment
lift the society weaker class persons of project
affected area, like senior citizens, widows, rejected female from society,
dumb & deaf, blind, orphans, hlndicapped one etc.
environment public hearings, who has
@this
extended valuable in puts , when you commission the project, to witness
vour success.
22
23
i@Gujarat.betibachao&kanyake|waniabhiyan''the
24
unique awareness piogramme of Guiarat Govt, for sustaining female child.
DI
tirnlrar free construction. as applicable.
Iworkers , stake holders'
for their valuable
opinion
their
to
seek
in a CSR committee / activities
25
26
iflputs.
, = =,medlcal
., , reatment
, , ,:;::_-:;:::::
ror emProyee
pl. provide, under a humanity ground, a full
provide full
and
disease,
diagnosed for TB, and /or for any other infectious
+-aa*nanr *a fhair claeo familv members who are residinq with him.
Pt. set up a female grievance resolving cell' as appllcaDle' lr ye
27
28
^-lahlialrad
pl. enlist some external EHS expert for a regular vlslts to your lranet utrrt
at par for
future, and a|so for your estab|ished uniUs, so you can remain
29
lELtQt
rala*arl
iccrrae
Pl. declare this
decided.
30
report
unit as a gutkha / cigarette , tobacco FKEE z\rNE
rr v
to imProve draft REIA
.
is' all proponent
related major
EHS
all
par
with
at
should set up environmentally sustainable unit,
our positive in
presenting
in
where
some
issues oR pl. draw our aftn. if we are wrong
puts.
our vision
Pl. do contact us for any further technical inputs, since
by a good quality
We welcome all industries in Gujarat, being supported
EIA report
thanks,
t
frr..t.r'r*Lrl q".,l4--f
( pravinbhai P sheth
'
)
benior citizen, technocrat & environmentalist
nt"
- f"ltioal-detox-surat30t015'
version 02'
pl.excuse,tot"nVtyp"-typesetting/spelling/vocabularymistakesifany'
plant more trees - save environment - care for next generation
wEALLNEEDAHELP|NGHAND-LETUSPRoTEGTTHEENV|RoNMENT
Sauno saath
- sauno vikas
Ankleshwar'cell 09377958840
Draft REIA Report reviewed by Pravinbhai sheth,
KEJRT\MAL
Integrated Textile Park Pvt. Ltd.
Annexure D1
Date:30.10.2015
To,
Shri Jitendrakumar Patel
Ankleshwar,
Gujarat
Subject: Public Hearing of Kejriwal Integrated Textile park pvt. Ltd.
Dear Sir,
In regard to the above subject, please find herewith the point wise reply:
1.
2'
3.
The depth to water level is ranging about 2.60 to 3.10 m below ground level,.
There will be provision of emergency storage tanks by the member units to store the
effluent in case of any unprecedented circumstances in CETP operation. 24 hour
storage capacity will be provided.
The mitigation measures to be adopted while working close to the noise generating
equipments are as follows:
r Noise producing equipment should be placed at distance from each other to
reduce the cumulative noise level.
o Rotation of workers shall be done based on their exposure to noise level
during the working hours as per the Factory Act, td+g and amendments
thereof.
Entry to the working area wherein the noise generating sources are located
' should
be permitted with ppE,s like ear muff, eir plugs
Regular
test of workers should be done and the medical repofts
' of same audiometric
should be maintained.
DisplaV should be made clearly indicating noise prone area along with dB level
' All
equipment in the plant would be designed/operated to have a totat noise
'
level not exceeding 85 to 90 dB (A) as pei the requirement of OSHA
(Occupational Safety and Health Administration) standard and the
'
Environment (protection) Rules.
Develop proper awareness among workers by regular training session.
Hope the above reply is in line with your requirement.
Thanking You
Yours Sincerely
Authorized Signature
For Kejriwal fntegrate{^T-extile park pvt. Ltd.
(,,.,
Office :7004, World
office
world Trade
Trade centfi'Rifig Road, SURAT - 395 002. Phone : (o) 4flt3it07 Fax : +91-261-2919212
E'mail : textilepark@keiriwal.net.in URL: http://rwvw.kejriwaltextilepark.com CIN : UlTl2OGJ2mgpTCOSOsgg
N,KEf RTwAL
Nr/
Integrated rextite Park Pvt. Ltd.
Annexure D2
Date:30.10.2015
To,
Shri Krishnakant
Paryavaran Suraksha Samiti/ NAPM
Subject: Urgent Clarification regarding documents to be allowed as proof of accreditation for
Environmental Public Hearing (EPH) of M/s Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park and M/s Shanti Integrated
Textile Park Pvt. Ltd. to be held on 30-10-2015 in Surat district, Gujarat.
Dear Sir,
In regard to the above subject, we will like to submit our reply that as per EIA notification 2006 and
amendment thereof, preparation of EIA report is to be done by NABET approved consultant.
The lists of consultants approved by NABET are uploaded online on QCI website every month. We shall
like to bring to your notice that M/s Detox Corporation Private Limited is approved consultant and the
name of organization is noted at Sr. no. 31 of List of Accredited Consultant Organization uploaded on
QCI website (http://nabet.qci.ors.in/environment/pop.asp?file=documents/AnnexureT.pdf)
on
date
08.10.2015.
Hence this is a valid EIA report submitted by NABET accredited consultant. Hope the above is in line with
your requirement.
Thanking You
Yours Sincerely
For Kejriwal Integrated Textile park pvt. Ltd.
a
r\\t
-/
ffi
Office :7@4, World Trade Gentrc, Ring Road, SURAT - 3gS 0@.
fhone : (O) 4gO03O7 Fax : +91-261-2919212
E-mail : textilepark@kejriwal.net.in URL :
CIN : Ul 71 2OGJ2mOPTCGt:fSSil
I
I
Annexure D3
Date:30.10.2015
To,
Shri Jayesh Patel
Secretary,
Khedut Samaj,
Gujarat.
Subject: Clarification regarding documents
Public Hearing (EPH)
to be allowed
as proof of accreditation
for Environmental
of M/s Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park and M/s Shanti Integrated Textile Park Pvt.
Ltd. to be held on 30-10-2015 in Surat district, Gujarat.
Dear Sir,
In regard to the above subject, we will like to submit our reply that as per EIA notification 2006 and
amendment thereof, preparation of EIA report is to be done by NABET approved consultant.
The lists of consultants approved by NABET are uploaded online on QCI website every month. We shall
like to bring to your notice that M/s Detox Corporation Private Limited is approved consultant and the
name of organization is noted at Sr. no. 3L of List of Accredited Consultant Organization uploaded on
QCI website (http://nabet.qci.org.inlenvironment/pop.asp?file=documents/AnnexureT.pdf)
on
date
08.10.2015.
Hence this is a valid EIA report submitted by NABET accredited consultant. Hope the above is in line with
your requirement.
Thanking You
Yours Sincerely
For Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park Pvt, Ltd.
Office :70M, World Trade Centre, Ring Road, SURAT - 395 002. . Phone : (O) a0G307 Fax : +91-261-2919212
E-mail : textilepark@kejrlwal.net.in URL: hftp://wrvw.kejriwaltextilepark.com CIN : Ul712OGJ2(X)BPTCOS3SS3
I
I
j
{sNP/KEJRTWAL
rextite
Nr/
Integrated
Park Prrt. Ltd.
Annexure D4
Date: 30.10.2015
To,
Shri Pravin Sheth
Senior Citizen, Technocrat & Environmentalist
Ankleshwar,
Gujarat.
Subject: Response to EPH of M/s Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park Pvt. Ltd., Kareli , Palsana, Dist: Surat,
Gujarat on 3Oth October 2015 at 11 hours.
Dear Sir,
In regard to the above subject, please find herewith our point wise response
1.
The lists of consultants approved by NABET are uploaded online on QCI website every month.
We shall like to bring to your notice that M/s Detox Corporation Private Limited is approved
consultant and the name of organization is noted at Sr. no. 31 of List of Accredited Consultant
Organization
uploaded
on
QCI
(http://nabet.qci.ors.in/environment/poo.asp?file=documents/AnnexureT.pdf)
website
on
date
08.10.2015.
Organization
uploaded
on
qcl
(http://nabet.qci.ors.in/environment/pop.asp?file=documents/AnnexureT.odf)
website
on
date
08.10.201s.
3.
As per the TOR and the requirement of EIA based on the pollutant load due to project, FAE to
be involved in preparation of EIA report
4.
The same shall be updated in final EIA Report.
Organization
uploaded
on
QCI
(http://nabet.qci.ore.inlenVironment/pop.asp?file=documents/AnnexureT.pdfl
website
on
date
08.10.2015.
Office 7004, World Trade Centre, Rlng Road, SURAT - 395 002. Phone : (O) afl8307 Fax : +91-261-2919212
=
E-mail : textilepark@kejriwal.net.in URL: http:/ftvnrw.kejriwaltextilepark.com CIN : Ul7120GJ2(Xt8PTCoS3ttSg
I
I
RTWAL
{ssP/KEf
Nr/
lntegrated rextite Park Pvt. Ltd.
We have applied in October 2Ot4 for approval of TOR and as there is no emission from the
proposed project, monitoring for baseline study was initiated for basic parameters like PM10,
PM2.5, Sox, NOx
6.
(a)
Detox Corporation Pvt. Ltd.
l"Floor K G Chambers.
Udhna Darwaja,
Ring Road,
Surat - 395002
Phone No. : 0261- 6551058
(b) Approx. 21 km
(c) Certificate of NABI/MOEF is attached herewith as Annexure 1.
Hope the above is in line with your requirement.
Thanking you,
Yours Sincerely
Authorized Signature,
Kejriwal lntegrated Textile Park Private Limited
ffi
Office =7@4, World Trade Centre, Ring Road, SURAT - 395 002. Phone : (O) {908307 Fax : +91-261-2313212
E-mall : textilepark@kelriwal.net.in URL: http://rvrvw.kejrlwaltextilepark.com CIN : Ul7120GJ2@8PTC053583
l
N,KEJRTwAL
Nr/
Integrated rextite park pvt. Ltd.
Annexure D5
Date:30.10.2015
To,
Shri Mahesh Pandya
Paryavaran Paryavaran Mitra
Ahmedabad
Subiect: Environment Public Hearing of M/s Kejriwal Integrated Textile park pvt. Ltd. at Village: Kareli,
Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat to be scheduled on 30th Octobe r 2OlS.
Ref: pM/M p/2637/ 2075 dated 26. 10. 2015
Dear Sir,
With reference to above referred letter, please find herewith the point wise reply
1'
Previous land use of the proposed project was for agricutture purpose.
NA has been done for
industrial purpose. NA copy has been attached in Draft EIA report as a
annexure 2, page no A-1g
2'
This is private land and proposed tand is acquired under rules
and regulation of registrar of land.
No government land has been acquired for the project.
3.
Application along with form
4.
NOC application
5'
Major pollutant parameters are
l
and pFR was apptied on 9th octob er,2oL4
willbe made after public hearing.
TSS
and oil & Grease from the industries of similar nature.
considering the worst case scenario we have design the prant
6'
There
will
be
total 2000 employment due to proposed project. standard water requirement
is 45
liter per person per day against which we have provided 45 riter per person
per day
7.
we
have applied in october 2ot4 lor approval of ToR
and as there is no emission from the
proposed proiect, monitoring for baseline study
was initiated for basic parameters like pMlO
PM2.5, Sox, NOx
Base line monitoring had been conducted
from
15th January, 2015
to
15th
April, 2015. Exact date as
given below
(xfice :70(A, World rrade Gentre, Ring Road,
suRAT - 395 oo2. phone : (o) a06307 Fax : +91-261-2 g1g212
E-mall : textilepark@keirlwal.net.in unl : nttpynrrvuy.replrrartextiteparr.co#
oN : ul712ocJ2oogprcosgssif
I
,SNP/KErRlwAL
Nr/
Integrated rextite Park Pvt. Ltd.
Sr. no
Date AQ 1
L
2/3l207s
Date AQ 2
Date AQ4
Date AQ 3
4/3/zOLs
4/3/2Or5
213/2OLs
2
s/3/2OLs
7/3/21ts
713l20Ls
3
sl3/zors
1.u31zOLs
4
1-2/3l2O7s
1613/2O7s
74/3/2OLs
7u312ots
t4/3l2O7s
s/3/207s
s/3/20Ls
L2/3/2OLs
18/312O7s
t8/3/z1ts
1.6/31207s
6
ts/3/20Ls
2U3/20rs
7
22/312O7s
2s/3/zOLs
22/3120Ls
8
2e/3/21ts
9
2613/z}rs
tl4/zOLs
2u3/zOLs
2s/3/20Ls
29/3/z0ts
4/4/2OLs
414/207s
10
5/4/z}ts
11
9/412OLs
7/4/207s
ttl4/2o1-s
rsl4/207s
t9/4/2OLs
5
L2
7314/2O7s
13
L7/4/20Ls
t9/3/z}rs
26/3/201s
Ll4/20t5
s/4l2Ot5
7/4/21ts
77/4/2OLs
e/4l2oLs
73/4/zOLs
t7l4/2OL5
22/4/207s
tsl4/zots
'J.4
2214/2O7s
24/412075
1.9/4/20Ls
24/4l2o7s
15
27/4/2OLs
27/4/20Ls
30/4lzots
s/4lzlLs
9/sl2Ot5
3014/20Ls
L7
18
19
2s/4120ts
27/4/20ts
3/s/20Ls
7/s/2OLs
71./s/207s
s/4/20rs
e/s/207s
7/slz}ts
L3/51207s
L7/51207s
20
ts/sl20ts
13/sl207s
76/sl2OLs
76/sl2OLs
2t
20ls/2o1s
24/sl2O7s
t9/sl2o7s
L9/s/20ts
22/sl207s
26/sl2cts
2slsl20Ls
Lslsl20t5
20/sl2ots
16
22
23
27/s/2}ts
24
30lsl2O7s
22/s/207s
26/sl20ts
2s/sl207s
2s/412OLs
2714/2O7s
3/sl2OLs
24/sl20Ls
27lsl20ts
30/sl2O7s
Ground Water oualitv monitorine locations
Sr. No.
Ground water location
location (Borewell)
GW1
GW2
GW3
Project Site
L
2
3
Date
s/s/207s
s/s/20Ls
s/s/207s
Kareli
Dastan
Surface Water qualitv monitoring locations
Sr. No.
7
Surface water location
sw1
[ocation
Date
Project Site
s/s/2o7s
(Canal)
t-
Offfce : 7(X[, World Trade Centre, Ring Road, SURAT - 395 002. Phone : (O)
a0ffi307 Fax : +91-261-2 g1g212
E-mail: textilepark@keiriwal.net.in URL: http:/^vww.kejriwaltexfibparr.com
ctN : u17120GJ2008pTc0535g3
o
KETRTWAL
Soil Qualitv monitorine locations
SoilQuality location
Sr. No.
9.
Location
Date
sls/207s
s/s/20Ls
L
sQ1
Project Site
2
SQZ
Kareli
Due to compression of file size & resolution of image,
"5" is read
as
'6". We shall submit the high
resolution file in final EIA report.
10.
Due to compression of file size & resolution of image,
"5" is read as 'G". We shall submit the high
resolution file in final EIA report.
11.
33% greenbelt is applicable for industry where high fugitive emissions occurs. From our proposed
project there is no fugitive/ process emission. Hence not applicable.
12,
Septic tank and soak pit shall be constructed for disposal of domestic waste water. Girbage
shall
be disposed appropriately.
13' Due to lack of employment in the any area, skill up gradation
opportunities are negligibte.
to the local workers to upgrade their skills
and thereby gain sustainable employment. To continuously upgrade the skill of workers,
constant up gradation of skill set is required. Company proposed to set up one training
center as
pre employment job training and safety training. The training facility shall
be helpful in
Proposed Textile Park would provide opportunities
implementing and upgrading such skills.
For contributing our part in Prime Ministe/s Swachh Bharat Abhiyan,
company is committed to
construct toilet blocks in nearby rural area. Needy families will be served on priority
basis.
In the initial two years, company shatl develop greenbelt within the premises.
In the later phase
the green belt development will be carried out in the surrounding barren land
and both side of
approach roads. Textile Park will provide Assistance to Panchayat for development
of village,
Temple, Approach Road to village Etc
14. csR Activity will be as below, and its budget will be g laces annually
Proposed Textile Park would provide opportunities to the local
workers to upgrade their skills
and thereby gain sustainable employment. To continuously upgrade
the skill of workers,
constant up gradation of skill set is required, Company proposed to
set up one training center as
I
Office z 7004, World Trade Gentre, Ring Road, suRAT - 3q-s 0021 phpne
: (o) a{x}tilO7 Far : +91-261-2 g1g2r2
E-mail : textilepark@kejriwal.net.in URL : http:/lunvuy.kelriwattrexil6park.com
ctN : Ul 71 2ocJ2oosprcosgssg
o
KEJRTWAL
pre employment job training and safety training. The training facility shall be helpful in
implementing and upgrading such skills.
For contributing our part in Prime Minister's Swachh Bharat Abhiyan, company is committed to
construct toilet blocks in nearby rural area. Needy families will be served on priority basis.
ln the initial two years, company shall develop greenbelt within the premises. In the later phase
the green belt development will be carried out in the surrounding barren land and both side of
approach roads.
Textile Park will provide Assistance to panchayat for development of village, temple, approach
road to village, etc.
15. Total estimated employment generation will be 2000 in proposed project. Company is committed
to give priority to local public. Out of total employment generation, approx 600 will be skilled and
1400
will be unskilled.
We hope the above reply is in line with your requirement
Thanking You,
Yours Sincerely
For Kejriwal Integrated Textile park private Limited
/?
L\'/
,/
office :7(Jf'i,., world Trade centre, Rlng Road, SURAT - 395 002. phone : (o) a6g0307 Fax : +91-261-2g1g212
E-mail : textllepark@kelrlwal.net.in URL : http:/ftvrvrv.kefrlwaltextilepark.com CIN : UlZl2OGJ2(xt8pTCOSgSgg
I
KEf RT\^/AL
lntegrated Textile Park Pvt. Ltd.
Annexure
DG
of M/s Kejriwal Integrated Textile Park Pvt. Ltd on 3oth October 2015 at
11
Date:30.10.2015
To,
Shri Pravin Sheth
Senior Citizen, Technocrat & Environmentalist
Ankleshwar,
Gujarat.
Subject: Response
to
EPH
hours.
Dear Sir,
In regard to the above subject, please find herewith our point wise response
Point no. 1 to 3 are suggestion/ appreciation for project
The pay back period of project capital cost will be approx. 6 years.
01.
We have designed the complete close system for treatment of water and waste water.
CETP
is the integral part of the operation of water jet looms. Beside this CETP will be develop in
different modules. So that at the time, portion of CETP will always in operation.
We made a sufficient provision of for storage of generated wastewater. These are the precaution
taken to ensure we shall maintain always zero liquid discharge state.
02-Direction of the canal is in West direction.
O3-Slope level direction is slope of site in
two part,
N-W Corners
South Side
6.
Color had been measured by UV-VIS Spectrophotometer 117 instrument and results are reported.
7.
We shall decide the plinth level to maintain the slope for gravity collection network. All units'
plinth level will be same. COP 2 lowest where ETP location
8.
a. We have considered only major parameters.
b
There are total 43 parameters in different category according to lS 10500.
Major parameters were selected for analysi
otfice i7w4, world Trade centre, Ring Road, SURAT - 395 002. Phone : (o) 4003307 Fax : +g1-261-2g1g212
E-mall : textilepark@keiriwal.net.in URL : http:/^vrvw.kejriwaltextilepark.com CtN : Ul7t2oGJ2OO8PTCOS3SS3
l
N
KETRTWAL
9.
lt is not a loss, 80
10.
a.
Start hour is 00:00 AM on
b.
Total calm hour is approx 32 hrs.
KLD
11. a-- List of industries
water it will be utilized in gardening purpose.
l't
is given in
March ,2OL5 and Stop hour is 23:00 PM on 31* May, 2015.
the answer of point 11-C
b. There is no process emission from the proposed project. Thus only basic
NOx, PM10, PM2.5) has been selected for baseline monitoring.
MQ
parameters (Sox,
12. We have considered your suggestion and same shall be incorporated in Final EIA report
b--We have considered your suggestion and same shall be incorporated in Final EIA report
c--List of major industries are as below
1. KejriwalGeotech Pvt. ttd. (Within the plant premises)
2. Tulsi Paper Mill Pvt. ttd. (North West direction)
13. We shall incorporate the same in final EIA report
14. Primary data has been collected by FAE
15. The year ofcensus is 2011
15.
SEPPL (Saurastra Enviro Proiects Pvt. Ltd.)
at Kutch. lt is 500 km away from the project site
17. lt will be generated in minor quantity; it will be stored properly and reused within plant premises.
18. The green belt data is as below
O1--This is a no emission industry. Hence the guideline is not applicable
02---Question is not appropriate.
a
to c --Question is not appropriate.
03 (a to c) 5 liters/m2 norms will be followed for usage of treated waste water in green belt
04-- The same shall be calculated after tree plantation
otfice :7004, world Trade centre, Ring Road, SURAT - 395 002. Phone : (o) aflF307 Fax +g1-261-2g1g212
=
E-mail : textilepark@keiriwal.net.in URL: http://wrvw.kejriwaltextilepark.com CIN : Ul7t20GJ20OgpTCOOg5g3
o
KEf RTWAL
05--Kindly clarify APTI
19. (a to c) Geology study was not conducted for proposed project
impacted due to the proposed proiect
20.
(a) M/s Detox Corporation Pvt
[td.
as
the said attributed will not be
Lab
3rd Floor, K. G. Chambers, Udhna Darwaja, Ring Road
Surat - 395002, Gujarat, lndia
b--lt is approx
rtO kms away.
c-- The same is submitted with your previous reply
d--
Yes.
e--- lt will be mentioned in Final EIA report.
21. Yes, we proposed to construct ground water recharge percolation wells. Location in the layout is
shown in page no A-7.
,6,.
ffi
Office :7004, World Trade Centre, Ring Road, SURAT - 395 002. Phone : (O) aOffiO0Z Fax : +91-261-2g1g212
E-mail : textilepark@keiriwal.net.in URL: http:/Aruvrv.kejriwaltextilepark.com CIN : UlTl2OGJ2OO8PTCOS3S&|
r
t
G@AnAT SrATE pErRot8
{
EWEI.IP AllO RryD HP foR I4oDMc^TIoI
oFTARARI CPS MD CoMr&TIor|oF
crRpoRArDN ADDmoilAr wElrs ro TARARJR eps Dl
8rofiCB{N2
Anacsm & Ccrfficab ol Kadnt Enyimnmontd CottsulUtb lnm
KADA{ EHvtRonr'tElTA
ConsurAilrrl Juryzols
QCI
/ ,tABfr
233

ffi urat - 395 003. RF - Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Transcription

Similar documents

Geotechnical Engineering-2016 Dr. C H Solanki

Saturday, June 26, 2016 Zorinsky Lake Picnic Pavillion

application form - Angkasa Aviation Academy

Caring, Handling and Empowering PWDs by Dr. Josephine

Roger that!

CHICAGOLAND AUDIBEL HEARING AID CENTER ONLINE OFFERS

Horrockses

July - CaptionCall

Rayola Dougher - The Coal Institute