Pickleman`s marketed as franchise opportunity
Transcription
Pickleman`s marketed as franchise opportunity
Volume 15 Issue 14 February 7, 2009 Pickleman’s marketed as franchise opportunity Sandwich maker Brandon Sterr, right, shares a laugh with Nikki Stritzel, the owner's wife, and their daughter, Audrey, during Pickleman's lunch rush. 5 13 18 Candidate Orientation Council candidates learn ins and outs of city government MU's Budget Nixon's higher education funding plan attracts Republican ire Addy Award Winners Woodruff Sweitzer takes home gold (Story begins on Page 7) Ad strategies scrutinized during downturn By Jacob Barker All Super Bowl party guests in Columbia got a taste of Les Bourgeois Vineyards whether they bought a bottle or not. The Rocheport winemaker aired the first television commercial of its new ad campaign during the big game, kicking off an expanded marketing budget geared toward grabbing market share during the economic downturn. “For 2009, it’s all about touching new people and letting them know about what we’ve got to offer, right here in their backyard,” Les Bourgeois Marketing Director Rachel Mills said. “There’s no better way to reach out than the Super Bowl.” The commercial showed workers making wine and patrons drinking wine at the Blufftop Bistro. It displayed the slogan, “Stay warm this winter with Les Bourgeois.” Although national advertisements for America’s biggest TV event of the year still carried multi-million-dollar price tags, overall advertising expenditures nationally have declined for the first time in years as consumers and businesses alike tighten their wallets. The declines, however, are not across the board. Television and Internet advertising expenditures continue to increase even as placement prices have dropped, but newspapers and radio are taking a hit at the national level. In Columbia, media outlets are working more closely with businesses to craft marketing agreements, and businesses are seeing ad dollars stretch further than usual. (continued on Page 22) PRST STD U.S. Postage SPECIAL SECTION Permit #353 Columbia, MO Marketing & Promotions PAID See Page 22 1 $ 50 photo by jennifer kettler www.columbiabusinesstimes.com 2 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com 14 26 34 People You Should Know: Chris Stevens Meet BCNB's relationship banking guru, an art and music aficionado Promotional Products Local companies feed customer fondness for free stuff Video Gaming The number of women playing video games is increasing Accountable MARKeting.............................. 23 Ace Pumps................................................... 21 Arysta Life Science.................................. 19,21 Axiom...................................................... 21,22 BCNB................................................... 4,14,21 Bleu Restaurant and Wine Bar................ 19,21 Bradley Marketing................................... 20,21 Callaway Bank................................................ 4 Central Trust & Investment Company............ 4 Cherry Street Artisan.................................... 19 Columbia Daily Tribune................. 10,11,14,25 Commerce Bank............................................. 4 Country Club of Missouri............................. 10 D&H Drugstore............................................. 21 Dave Griggs Flooring America..................... 17 Diamond Pet Foods..................................... 19 Enginet Technologies................................... 16 First National Bank....................................... 16 Glen Martin................................................... 21 House of Brokers Realty.............................. 16 KMIZ............................................................. 22 KT Diamond Jewelers.................................. 21 Landmark Hospital...................................... 5,6 Learfield Communications........................... 21 Les Bourgeois........................................... 1,22 MBS Textbook Exchange............................. 10 Mid America Harley Davidson...................... 21 Missouri Contemporary Ballet Company..... 21 Nanoparticle Biochemistry Inc..................... 16 OnMedia.................................................. 19,21 Pickleman's........................................... 1,7,8,9 Plaza Dental................................................. 21 Pure Marketing & Media................ 20,21,22,23 R.Anthony Development.............................. 16 Research Center for Human-Animal Interaction.................................................... 16 Sass and Fras............................................... 17 Shelter Insurance......................................... 26 Socket............................................................ 4 Southside Pizza............................................ 20 Sub Shop........................................................ 9 The Bank of Missouri...................................... 4 Thumper Entertainment................................ 21 Tint by Toalson............................................. 23 True Media Services..................................... 22 VANGEL........................................................ 23 Visionworks Marketing & Communications................................ 21,27,32 White Dog Promotions............................ 26,27 Williams-Keepers LLC.................................... 4 Woodruff Sweitzer......................... 18,20,21,22 Word Marketing......................................... 4,21 Alley A Realty............................................... 13 Atterberry Auction & Realty.......................... 34 Boone County National Bank....................... 36 Boys & Girls Club......................................... 12 Business Conference & Showcase................ 7 CenturyTel.................................................... 32 City of Columbia Parks & Recreation........... 31 City of Columbia Rolloff & Commercial Waste Services........................ 34 City of Columbia Water & Light.................... 23 Columbia Turf................................................. 5 Commerce Bank........................................... 25 Corporate Identi-T's..................................... 15 Delta Systems.............................................. 12 First National Bank......................................... 2 Hawthorn Bank............................................... 3 Instant Imprints............................................... 8 KFRU Morning Meeting................................ 30 McAdams' LTD............................................. 24 Midwest CompuTech................................... 28 Moresource.................................................. 33 Paul Land—Plaza Real Estate Commercial Division..................................... 31 Personalized Computers................................ 9 Pro Fitness................................................... 17 Recycled Office Solutions.............................. 8 Room 38 Restaurant & Lounge.................... 29 Shelter Bank................................................. 16 Shelter Insurance—Mike Messer & Mike Hatchett............................................... 21 Shelter Office Plaza........................................ 4 Socket Internet............................................... 6 Stephens College—Performing Arts ........... 26 Tiger Hotel—Events & Catering.................... 22 Towner Communication Systems................. 22 Visionworks.................................................. 20 Waddell & Reed............................................ 27 Williams Keepers—Raymond James........... 17 Willie Smith's Magic Services...................... 31 editor@ businesstimescompany. com Columbia’s business leaders also heard an optimistic economic message last week from Scott Colbert, the director of fixed income with Commerce Bank in Saint Louis. Colbert, who has investment responsibilities for more than $7 billion in fixed income assets and is highly regarded in the financial community, said predicting the future of the national economy is guesswork. But his best guesses are that the stock market has hit bottom and the economy will rebound in July. During a similar presentation one year ago, Colbert said the country was entering a recession. He acknowledged this year that, “we didn’t predict it would be this bad.” Then he cautioned, “The gloom and doomers have been right more than the optimists.” And he added that there is a slight chance that the country would enter a mild depression. (He put the chance at 20 percent). Colbert said he doesn’t recommend “jumping in (the stock market) with both feet,” but told audience members that he believes there are stocks worth investing in. His tips are to invest in municipal and corporate bonds and listed a few stocks he likes, including General Electric, Hewlett Packard and Visa. But on a cautionary note, here’s what happened to the stocks he picked last year: Cisco fell from close to $25 a share to about $15.60 currently. Sallie Mae fell from $20 to $11.25, Microsoft dropped from $29 to about $18 and GE plummeted from $35 to $11.50. (573) 499-1830 | (573) 499-1831 fax editor@businesstimescompany.com Chris Harrison | General Manager | Ext.1010 David Reed | Group Editor | Ext.1013 Cody Moore | Graphic Designer Alisha Moreland | Graphic Designer Betsy Bell | Creative Marketing Director Jennifer Kettler | Photo Editor | 573-529-1789 Cindy Sheridan | Operations Manager Becky Beul | Marketing Representative Claire McNett | Marketing Representative Joe Schmitter | Marketing Representative Writers in this issue: Jacob Barker, Heath Hooper, Christen Jackson, Jordan Milne, Mary Paulsell, Jason Rosenbaum, Sean Spence, Columnists in this issue: Al Germond, Mike Martin, Lili Vianello, Larry Schuster, Tom Schauwecker The Columbia Business Times is published every other Saturday by The Business Times Co. 2001 Corporate Place, Suite 100, Columbia, Mo 65202. (573) 499-1830. Copyright The Business Times Co., 2008. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use of any editorial or graphic content without the express written permission of the publisher is prohibited. Third-class postage paid at Columbia, Mo. The annual subscription rate is $39.95 for 26 issues. OUR MISSION STATEMENT: The Columbia Business Times strives to be Columbia’s leading source for timely and comprehensive news coverage of the local business community. This publication is dedicated to being the most relevant and useful vehicle for the exchange of information and ideas among Columbia’s business professionals. February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com David Reed At the beginning of every month, Barbara Bremer from the city Finance Department sends us an e-mail that lists all of the new business licenses issued during the previous month. The list for January was 19 pages long and includes 38 general businesses in the city (see Page 33). Careful readers will recognize that as an unusually large number. We usually place a brief story about a new business above the list of newly licensed businesses, but this one was so long it took up the whole page. There are a few new bars and restaurants that have opened in Columbia, along with a dance studio, a beauty salon, two used car dealerships, a bank branch, a scooter showroom, a shoe store, a tax preparation service and two dozen more. Then there’s a multitude of home-based businesses and contractors from outside the city. Aren’t we in a recession? Aren’t people supposed to be putting their dreams on hold until we know when the economy will rebound? Doug Stritzel, the owner of Pickleman’s restaurants in Columbia, is also counting on the entrepreneurial spirit to kick in this year. As Sean Spence reported in the story that begins on Page 7, Stritzel hopes to open two or three Pickleman’s franchises in Missouri’s biggest cities by the end of 2009. “This next year and a half should be a great time for franchising businesses to really take off simply because you have a lot of mid-level and senior-level executive that are going to get laid off,” he said. 3 editor's welcome 4 people on the move February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Ferrugia Ropp Williams Stevens Hoecker Mavel Johnson Upendrani Hirings Socket, a telephone and Internet service provider, has hired two employees at its corporate headquarters in Columbia. Alan Flandreau is Socket’s newest outside engineer, and Tiana Stratman is a marketing representative. Flandreau’s primary duties include installing and testing equipment at customer sites as well as troubleshooting phone, data and equipment issues. Originally from St. Louis, Flandreau graduated from the University of Missouri-St. Louis with a bachelor’s degree in business administration. Stratman’s duties include planning and executing events, managing Socket’s non-profit partnership program and coordinating advertising throughout Missouri. Born and raised in Rolla, she graduated from the University of Missouri-Columbia in 2007 with a bachelor’s degree in journalism. Commerce Bank, Central Missouri Region, has hired Gianina Beusan as a retail banking officer and branch manager for the company’s Business Loop Banking Center. She is responsible for business development and customer service related to the branch’s banking and lending services for consumers and small businesses. Beusan has more than 10 years of banking experience and has a bachelor’s of science degree in business administration. Jamie Ferrugia has joined The Callaway Bank as a senior vice president and wealth management officer. He will work closely with the trust officer to manage the investments of trust customers while also being available to manage individuals’ asset portfolios. Following graduation from Fulton High School, Ferrugia earned his undergraduate degree from the University of Alabama. Prior to joining the bank, he worked previously at Waddell & Reed, Merrill Lynch, Ferrell Companies, W.P. Carey & Company, E.F. Hutton and Morgan Stanley. The Bank of Missouri has hired Mary Ropp as banking relationship manager. In her position, she will be responsible for enhancing relationships with current clients and building relationships with new clients. Prior to moving to Columbia, Ropp was a banker with JPMorgan Chase in Michigan. Central Trust & Investment Company hired Mark T. Williams as senior portfolio manager in the Columbia market. With more than 20 years in the financial services industry, Williams Mountjoy will work with individual and business clients to create customized portfolios. Prior to his appointment with Central Trust & Investment Company, Williams worked as a financial adviser for Piper Jaffray/UBS Wealth Management US. He was also a security analyst, portfolio manager and director of research at Invista Capital Management. Williams holds a master’s degree in business administration, a law degree from Drake University and a bachelor’s of science degree from State University of New York. Promotions Boone County National Bank has promoted Chris Stevens to director of sales, relationship banking. Stevens has been with BCNB for 10 years and has progressed from assistant director of educational finance to vice-president relationship manager to his new position. Stevens graduated from the University of Missouri with bachelor’s degrees in communications and art history. Boone County National Bank appointed Michelle Mountjoy as consumer banking manager at the Smiley Lane Bank. Mountjoy, who has five years of financial service experience, oversees the staff of the bank and works with consumers and local businesses to meet all their financial needs. She previously worked at UMB Bank, where she was a vice president, and at Word Marketing, where she was vice president of business development. She graduated from the University of Missouri with a bachelor’s degree in marketing. Williams-Keepers LLC announced that 13 of the firm’s associates earned promotions effective Jan. 1. Amanda Gaither was promoted from senior II to supervisor, Julie Majors was promoted from senior II to supervisor, Kelly Schwartze, CPA, was promoted from senior II to supervisor, Nathan Alexander was promoted from staff II to senior I, Rhonda Bowne, CPA was promoted from staff II to senior I and Suzanne Fuller was promoted from staff II to senior I. Bridget Geisendorfer was promoted from staff II to senior I, Heather Holtschneider was promoted from staff II to senior I, Sarah Hooper, CPA, was promoted from staff II to senior I, Brad Langan was promoted from staff I to staff II, Jessica Lehmen, CPA was promoted from staff I to staff II, Nick Mestres was promoted from staff I to staff II and Megan Toalson, CPA, was promoted from staff I to staff II. (continued on Page 16) photos by jennifer kettler Candidates for upcoming City Council races got their first taste of the time commitment they will face if elected. The trio showed up last Saturday morning for what City Manager Bill Watkins said should be a two-hour orientation on the city’s functions and responsibilities. It took longer, of course. Allan Sharrock and Jason Thornhill, who are vying for the Second Ward seat that is being vacated by 18-year incumbent Chris Janku, and Rod Robison, who is challenging three-year incumbent Barbara Hoppe for the Sixth Ward seat, listened to presentations by department directors on their functions and activities. The city staff also briefed the candidates on important issues the council will most likely deal with this year. The election will be held April 7. Orientation lasted three hours, and candidates were offered the opportunity to ask questions. They mostly took notes so they could later revisit what they couldn’t absorb during the barrage of information. The staff provided PowerPoint slides and a casual setting while cracking the occasional joke and making lighthearted quips about how the city operates and who on staff they would really need to listen to. “Nobody’s afraid of Bill [Watkins], but everybody’s afraid of Carol,” City Counselor Fred Boeckmann told the candidates, referring jokingly to Carol Rhodes, who works in the city manager’s office. “If she tells you to do something, you better do it.” Watkins contributed occasionally during the presentations. For instance, Watkins informed the candidates that the Water and Light and Public Works departments could possibly lose up to 25 percent of their staffs, many in supervisory positions, to retirement soon. According to Watkins and Interim Police Chief Tom Dresner, department transparency and accountability are also ongoing concerns among citizens. And of course, the economic downturn will make a new council member’s first experience with the budget process a challenge. “Next year, the budget is going to look like holy heck,” Watkins said, reflecting the anticipated sharp reductions in sales tax revenue. The three candidates have indicated their desire to focus on economic development and job creation, reflecting the perception among many in the business community that Columbia is sometimes unaccommodating to business interests. v Announcing Mid-Missouri’s two largest grounds maintenance companies, Missouri Mowing, LLC and Columbia Turf, LLC are joining forces to better serve you! THE NEW COMPANY WILL DO BUSINESS AS COLUMBIA TURF, LLC WITH THREE DIVISIONS: Columbia Turf Grounds Maintenance Columbia Landscape Design/Build Columbia Turf Snow removal Allan Sharrock is running for the Second Ward council seat. A business community litmus test The CBT asked the three newly filed candidates for City Council how they would have voted on three development projects important to business interests in Columbia. Second Ward Rep. Chris Janku, who is not seeking re-election, voted in favor of each of the proposals outlined below, and Sixth Ward Rep. Barbara Hoppe voted against each of them. Although the City Council eventually approved the Crosscreek Center development plan last August, it was initially voted down because of opposition from nearby neighborhood associations. In March, the City Council voted 4-3 to deny a request by Stadium 63 Properties to include a car dealership in the 74-acre development at Stadium Boulevard and U.S. 63, prompting a mediation process among the developer and neighborhood associations. In May 2008, City Council voted 5-2 to rezone land at Old 63 and Alfred Street from residential to office to allow Landmark Hospital to build an acute care center there. Nearby residents voiced concern that the hospital would diminish the historic character of their neighborhood and that the owner, who also owns parcels surrounding the hospital site, would seek to have those zoned for commercial use in the future. The extension of Maguire Boulevard, a road running parallel with Lemone Industrial Boulevard, was another issue that barely won council approval. The 4-3 vote in June to extend Maguire to the future Stadium Boulevard extension was designed to alleviate traffic conges(continued on Page 6) &DOOXVRUYLVLWRXUZHEVLWHWRÀQGRXWKRZZH FDQSURYLGHDXQLTXHJURXQGVPDQDJHPHQW SODQGHVLJQHGVSHFLÀFDOO\IRU\RX February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com By Jacob Barker 5 Council candidates get crash course in city business 6 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Rod Robison is challenging Sixth Ward incumbent Barbara Hoppe. Jason Thornhill is a candidate for the Second Ward city council seat. Community litmus test ... continued from Page 5 tion in Concorde Office and Industrial Plaza, located on the east side of U.S. 63. Opponents were concerned about the cost of the project and construction runoff damaging the streams in southeast Columbia. Second Ward candidate Allan Sharrock said he would have voted yes on the Crosscreek plan in March. Sharrock added that he would have liked to see the plan gain approval sooner. He also said he would have supported the Landmark Hospital rezoning but refused to comment on the Maguire Boulevard extension because he was not familiar with the public sentiment on both sides of the issue. Sharrock said if elected he will focus on job creation, particularly efforts to attract corporations offering high-paying jobs, which would in turn help reduce crime. He added that Columbia needs to recognize that it is competing with other municipalities offering more attractive business incentives. “Those who snooze, lose,” he said. Sharrock’s opponent for the Second Ward seat, Justin Thornhill, said he would have voted against the initial Crosscreek plan, citing the public disapproval of the project. But he said that he would have voted for both the Landmark rezoning and the Maguire Boulevard extension. Like Sharrock, Thornhill is a strong proponent of job growth and economic development. Specifically, Thornhill said he would focus on fostering collaboration between the Chamber of Commerce, REDI and other business organizations. Rod Robison, who is challenging Barbara Hoppe for her Sixth Ward seat, said he supported the Crosscreek development from the beginning. He said nearby residents need to understand that “you’re going to get commercial development” on the intersection of a U.S. highway and major roadway. Robison also said he would have voted yes for Landmark rezoning and the Maguire extension, citing the “dangerous” conditions created by the traffic congestion in the industrial park. v 7 business profile | pickleman's By Sean Spence Doug Stritzel and his wife, Nikki, at the Pickleman's downtown location. Consider the facts: Two sandwich shops—Quiznos and W.G. Grinders—closed recently downtown. Two others are among the nation’s most successful franchises, Subway and Jimmy John’s. We’re in the midst of a national recession. And still, Doug Stritzel, who opened his second Pickleman’s on Broadway less than a year ago, isn’t just thinking about how to survive. He believes his restaurant is America’s next great franchise opportunity. Stritzel created the concept for the restaurant from scratch, relying on four years as the second in command to Jimmy John’s founder and CEO Jimmy John Liautaud and another four years as operating partner of a Wendy’s franchise. “One of the biggest advantages I have is that I’ve been on both sides of the business as both a franchisor and a franchisee,” Stritzel said. “I know what it takes to make this business work.” Stritzel opened the first Pickleman’s in southeastern Columbia on Old 63 in 2005 and the second restaurant is approaching its one-year anniversary. He has 50 to 55 employees, depending on the season, including three who have been with him since the beginning and intend to make Pickleman’s a career. Stritzel hopes to open two or three Pickleman’s franchises in Missouri’s biggest cities by the end of 2009. “This next year and a half should be a great time for franchising businesses to really take off simply because you have a lot of mid-level and senior-level executives that are going to get laid off,” he said. “These are the kind of people that might have a quarter million or more available, have the skills and are looking for something to do. (continued on Page 8) February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Pickleman’s marketed as franchise opportunity 8 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Just because your business is small, doesn’t mean your desk has to be. W hether it’s buying a new desk or expanding workstations, Recycled Office Solutions makes purchasing office furniture affordable. ROS sells previously owned, name brand office furniture such as Steelcase, Haworth and Kimball. Providing personal service, the knowledgeable sales staff will find you the pieces you need and deliver them to you quickly. Visit the showroom just east on I-70, exit 133, call 573-449-3876, or visit ROSFurniture.com Solving Your Office Furniture Needs business profile | pickleman's Pickleman's owner Doug Stritzel shows a trainee how to put the pizza toppings on properly. Business Profile—Pickleman's ... continued from Page 7 He says he’s “pretty confident” a franchise will open up in six to nine months in Springfield, and “we have a couple of parties interested in doing some franchising in St. Louis; then perhaps there will be somebody in Kansas City.” Stritzel said that the biggest obstacle is getting someone to invest in building his or her own resKieren Drapeau works the cashier during Pickleman's lunch rush at their downtown location. taurant. The cost of opening a Pickleman’s franchise will be between $200,000 and $250,000. “For some people that’s a big, big deal,” he said. “In the restaurant franchising business, that’s less than a Jimmy John’s, less than a Quiznos and far less than a lot of other franchise companies. I think it’s a pretty good bargain.” Lincoln or Omaha, Nebraska, where they want to do the whole city, it’s a great deal for them.” Alan Skouby, who teaches at the University of Missouri’s Trulaske College of Business, said that the real benefits of franchising come when a critical mass of restaurants is reached, and that it will take a while for Pickleman’s to reach that point. “I’m not sure what the number is when critical mass is reached, but it is probably more than 10,” Skouby said. “At that point, it will be easier to get financing, name recognition will be a bigger factor, and they’ll be able to take greater advantage of cooperative advertising and buying power.” John Dupuy, former owner of Columbia’s Ninth Street Deli and now an investor in two Quiznos locations, thinks that Pickleman’s could go national. “It's possible,” he said. “They certainly started the stores in a way that is reproducible. The restaurant trade is a tough one, but he certainly has a shot.” A bit of a sandwich aficionado, Dupuy is a fan of Pickleman’s. “I rotate between Pickleman’s, Quiznos and Sub Shop, depending on mood,” Dupuy said, offering his off-the-cuff review. “Pickleman’s is lighter and fresher tasting. Subshop is more meaty. Quiznos does the beef sandwiches best.” Stritzel knows there are no guarantees that his franchise dreams will be realized. “But in my opinion, success is a lock as long as you follow the process,” he said. “You’ve got to roll your sleeves up and make it work.” Pickleman's 1106 E Broadway | Columbia, Mo. | 573-875-2400 2513 Old 63 S | Columbia, Mo. | 573-886-2300 www.picklemans.com Not All Computers Are Created Equal. ...nor are the companies who service them. At Personalized Computers our client base is comprised of professionals from almost every field, including health care, engineering, government, retail, professional services, restaurants, school districts and insurance. We provide full-service computer support to clients who are just starting out, all the way up to clients with hundreds of computers in a multi-server environment. We also provide project support and consulting for the largest companies in the region. Our experience allows us to add value to any size network, including yours. Call today to schedule an appointment. 30% off in-house service and repair FREE SECURITY EVALUATION on-site networking limited to the first 5 respondents 1st hour free/value $125 new customers only 207 East Broadway 877.817.2597 • 573-817-2597 www.personalized-computers.com *limited availability and restrictions apply February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Pickleman’s has advantages over comparable franchises such as Subway, Jimmy John’s and Quiznos, he said, including the quality of the food and marketing materials. “We spent the last six months really working on the infrastructure, making sure the franchisee will have the marketing materials they need to look professional in whatever environment in which they choose to open,” Stritzel said. “My food pictures are real food. It’s not a doctored up thing,” he said. “When you see the picture, that’s really what the food looks like contrary to what you see with a lot of companies with big marketing budgets.” Stritzel also touted a variety of business practices that customers won’t see but that can make a big difference for owners. For example, as franchisees join the Pickleman’s organization, Stritzel said he will do something almost unheard of in restaurant franchising. Because of bulk buying, chain stores typically get large rebates from their vendors, ranging from thousands to millions of dollars in a single year for larger chains. Stritzel said that, unlike other franchisors, he will share those rebates with his franchisees. Stritzel also said that he’s committed to straight talk with potential franchisors about where Pickleman’s might be viable. “Pickleman’s will do well in any larger market or any college town, and I’m not opposed to doing that now,” he said. “What I am opposed to is a single operator who wants to open somewhere like Boise, Idaho, in the middle of nowhere, because it would be too costly to give them support, and they would be starting with not a lot of name brand recognition.” “If there’s someone that’s interested in doing a three- to five-store deal in Austin, Texas, or 9 business profile | pickleman's 10 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com voices From the Roundtable Power Brokers should engage in constructive, not destructive, activity Al Germond Al Germond is the host of the “Columbia Business Times Sunday Morning Roundtable” every Sunday at 8:15 a.m. on kfru. He can be reached at algermond@gmail.com. County View One of the most intriguing mysteries within any community is figuring out who has the clout to get things done. Every community has a small contingent of Power Brokers, private citizens who have the ability to get things done because of one or more factors—their possessions, positions, experience in the community and just plain raw gravitas. They operate best out of the limelight such as inside a private country club at a meeting that excludes the media. That happened to be the setting for a recent luncheon arranged and hosted by Bob Pugh, CEO of MBS Textbook Exchange and a former mayor who would be on everyone’s list of Columbia Power Brokers. The gathering of former mayors and city managers at Country Club of Missouri, an annual tradition it turns out, was a private party that violated not a single rule or regulation. The luncheon, nonetheless, piques the community's curiosity about what transpired between a group of Power Brokers. The gathering took on the perception of a covert operation when information surfaced that the guest list included two public officials—the sitting mayor and city manager—and a speaker advocating an amendment to the city charter, along with the publisher of the Columbia Daily Tribune, and excluded other representatives of the Fourth Estate. The details emerged because the bandwidth of communications has expanded dizzyingly into the Internet blogosphere, a daily stream of commentary and criticism that has increased exponentially. The conversations are healthy, if not a little discomforting, and at times exaggerated. They reflect a genuine concern about a community poised to graduate from a small to a mediumsized city of a hundred grand in population when the next federal census is taken 15 months from now. Pugh’s luncheon addressed the topic of amending the city charter to allow City Council members to be paid for their services. The subtext is that business community leaders want the City Council to have more members who are pro-business and fewer who are perceived to be anti-development. Mike Martin, on his Columbia Heartbeat blog, revealed details of the private conversations. Power Brokers in attendance have denied allegations that they plotted to rid the council of “activist” members such as Karl Skala, who represents the Third Ward. Unrelated to Pugh's gathering, though coincidentally circulated, was a quartet of letters between Skala and Chamber of Commerce Chairman Larry Moore, who asked Skala to withdraw from the Chamber's Governmental Affairs Committee. If there ever was a time someone should have slept on a letter before putting it in the mail, this would have been it. Moore wrote that he received numerous complaints that Skala’s participation on the committee was disruptive—basically because he talked too much. Skala refused to withdraw or become a listener only, with no voting or speaking privileges. The complaints should have been resolved internally thus avoiding an ugly trail of communications that likely alienated Skala—and perhaps colleagues on the council—from the business community. The most embarrassing point was when Skala quoted to Moore the Chamber’s description of the role of the Government Affairs Committee: “to develop cooperative relationships with organizations and to establish and nurture positive relationships with local, state and national elected officials.” Skala troubles the Power Brokers because he is "progressive" in a still undefined sense, perhaps a trifle odd, occasionally obstreperous and only rarely the patsy to their aims. Basking in retirement, he has the luxury of time to devote as many hours as he pleases to looking out for the interests of his ward as well as the city at large. Maybe some of us in the business community don't care for the policies or ideas of a particular elected official, but that hardly justifies engaging in destructive activity. Business folk can get elected if they and their supporters stop stewing about the other side and focus on making themselves more attractive—thus electable—to the constituents of a given ward or district. They also can get things done through open communications rather than behind closed doors at a country club. The facts pertaining to property tax valuations in Boone County Mushrooms are kept in the dark, covered with manure and one hopes they grow. This article will cast light on the laws governing property taxation in Missouri and shed the manure spread by the ill-informed with hope that knowledge grows. Real property tax classifications and effective tax rates Tom Schauwecker Tom Schauwecker has been the Boone County assessor for 20 years. His e-mail address is TSchauwecker@ boonecountymo.org There are three sub-classifications of real property defined in Missouri law: agricultural, residential and commercial. The effective tax rate for agricultural property is about 0.70 percent, residential is nearly 1.2 percent, commercial is approximately 2.2 percent. Agricultural property valued at $100,000 would incur an annual tax liability of $700. Residential property with a market value of $100,000 is liable for $1,200 each year. Commercial real estate having a market value of $100,000 would result in a tax bill of $2,200. Missouri voters gave the General Assembly a blank check in August of 1982. A constitutional amendment overwhelmingly approved by Missourians resulted in three dramatically different tax bills for properties with identical valuations. *Agricultural land is an exception to the fair market value basis of valuation and taxation. Agricultural land valuation is based upon a “use value” established by the University of Property Tax Classification Missouri College of Agriculture and approved by the Missouri General Assembly. The State Tax Commission of Missouri publishes and defines eight soil grades, which range in “use value” from $30 per acre to $985 per acre. Property taxes average from $2 to $5 per acre for agricultural land in Boone County. Few, if any, states enjoy a lower rate of taxation on agricultural land than Missouri. Agricultural land and “billionaire tax breaks” There is a 133-acre vacant tract of land located on the southeast corner of Nifong Boulevard and Sinclair Road near Mill Creek Elementary School. The City of Columbia by ordinance zoned this property as A-1 Agricultural upon annexation. A portion of this tract lies within the 50-year flood plain.The property tax classification is agricultural. The “use value” based upon soil, subject to periodic flooding, slope and cover is $300 per acre. A review of case law indicates that the current classification and valuation are appropriate. Land in transition and “developers not paying fair share” Missouri statutory and case law bestow favorable property tax status on all vacant land. Missouri law was amended in 1994 and states that filing of subdivision plat shall not affect Market Value Tax Effective Tax Rate Agricultural 100,000* $700 0.70% Residential 100,000 $1,200 1.20% Commercial 100,000 $2,200 2.20% the tax classification or increase the appraised value. All contiguous lots and lands for which a plat has been filed shall be combined and valued as a single parcel if no improvements have been made to such lots or lands. There is a time value to money. A dollar today is worth more than a dollar received a year or two from now. There is an ample supply of vacant commercial and industrial land in our local market. State law requires the assessor to consider current supply, demand and the absorption period of vacant tracts with unknown potential in the valuation process. Recent deeds in lieu of foreclosure indicate the speculative bubble for vacant land in Boone County may have burst. Regional Economic Development Inc. has identified the No. 1 “shovel ready” site as the vacant 103 acres located on the northeast corner of Providence Road and Southampton Drive near Rock Bridge High School. The City of Columbia by ordinance has zoned this parcel as O-1 Office. The infrastructure is super adequate. Sewer, gas, electric, water and streets are in place and complete. This parcel was subject to appeal at the Missouri State Tax Commission. The property tax classification of agricultural was deemed to be appropriate. The valuation was reduced from $10,000 to $8,500 per acre in a ruling by the State Tax Commission of Missouri. This decision was rendered shortly after the voters of Columbia approved the lease/purchase of Stephens Lake for $61,242 per acre. The tax commission decision set a precedent for the valuation and classification of commercially zoned tracts of land with unknown potential. (continued on Page 12) Citizen Journalist Troubles in The Village Mike Martin Columbia resident and science journalist Mike Martin earned a master’s degree in business administration from the University of Washington, with a concentration in entrepreneurship and innovation. He can be reached at Mike. martin@weeklyscientist. com About a year ago, at a meeting of the North Central Columbia Neighborhood Association, I challenged association President Linda Rootes’ support for a “troubled youth shelter” planned across from Hickman High School. Ardently advocating a so-called “overlay ordinance” that would mandate neighborhood design standards and ban so-called “undesirable” activities—including halfway houses— Rootes nonetheless supported the shelter. A member of the neighborhood association since 2002, I agreed with neighbors who opposed the proposed six-plex as a striking deviation from nearby single-family homes. And with drug dealers and the now infamous “crime house” at 802 Wilkes operating with impunity nearby, it was a questionable environment for troubled kids. But Rootes refused dissent and shut down the discussion. I walked out of the meeting and have only returned a handful of times at the urging of friends. It’s become too painful to watch—a personality-based leadership crisis that could harm one of Columbia’s great neighborhoods. In the Beginning Soap Box The story of this association starts with a scrappy group of neighbors who, 15 or so years ago, decided to fight back. Reeling for decades from failed segregation and the poverty it caused, North Central Columbia—now known as The Village—fought crime, decay, slumlords, and City Hall apathy with little organization and even less political clout. Enter sometime mayoral candidate John Clark, a bear of a man whose often overbearing style was exactly what the troubles ordered. The duo of Clark and his equally outspoken partner Mrs. Rootes, in a word, worked. Armed with a law degree and a mind for the kind of minutiae that ties unthinking bureaucracies in Gordian knots, Clark countered the siege. With Rootes and a newly constituted neighborhood association, he raised money, published a newsletter, fired off letters to errant landlords, butted heads with code violators, shined the Neighborhood Watch light on drug dealers and rode City Hall until it got tired of having the neighborhood association on its back. In many ways, John Clark and Linda Rootes wrote the book on organizing substantive, effective neighborhood associations. But their efforts have become a mixed success story of late, largely because they catalyzed so much progress that the neighborhood outgrew their leadership. In conflict with Rootes, Clark stepped down and hasn’t attended a meeting in more than a year. President for the past two years, Rootes has brought imperiousness to the job at precisely the time when debate, coalition building and new ideas are in critical demand. Troubling Trio Under Rootes’ leadership, the neighborhood and its association have suffered a trio of stunning defeats. Just last month, after going through tens of thousands of dollars in donations and tax credits, the association, in partnership with Central Missouri Community Action, lost the historic Heibel March Drugstore, a 10-year renovation project returned in worse repair to its original owner, City Hall. At a weekly meeting of renovation coordinators that included Rootes and retired Stephens College drama professor Peter Byger, “tempers ran high as committee members spent much of the session sniping at each other,” the Columbia Daily Tribune reported in 2007. “‘You’ve been antagonistic to everything I’ve put on the table,’ Byger told Rootes, his voice rising.” Acknowledging “dysfunction,” Rootes told the Tribune, “We have a lot of organizational issues. Nobody knows who’s in charge here.” The Shoe Factor Deciding they no longer wanted to worry about who was in charge, half the north central neighborhood—the business half—angrily seceded, forming the Shoe Factory District in October. After donating money to North Central Columbia Neighborhood Association for the overlay’s preparation, neighborhood booster Tom Atkins later condemned his firm’s surprise appearance on that list of forbidden enterprises. Atkins said he felt betrayed. Ironically, it wouldn’t matter. At last month’s neighborhood association meeting came the third shocker: The overlay ordinance—another 10-year project—appears all but kaput. To neighborhood association board member Amir Ziv, the overlay’s sudden death signaled a time to get back to basics like crime and slumlords. “We have someone killed in Douglass Park, we have gunshots fired off on Fairview Street in the afternoon, and we don't have time to talk about any of this,” Ziv e-mailed association members after the meeting. “I am not interested in using our less than two hours each month for venting,” Rootes responded. (continued on Page 12) Gov. Nixon: only the gullible will buy your budget Larry Schuster Larry Schuster is a former city councilman and political observer. Gov. Jay Nixon: call me crazy, cynical or cantankerous, but please, do not try to dupe me with a smug sound byte proposing to protect the University of Missouri from budget cuts if the curators agree to freeze tuition rates. My goodness fella, do you really think that we taxpayers are that gullible? The reality is that the state has a revenue shortfall, and the latest projection is close to $300 million. You know it. Even the most disinterested is well aware. No institution as large as the University of Missouri should even remotely entertain the notion they can strike a deal to avoid sharing the burden of current fiscal constraints. Government activities from top to bottom in all areas should be scrutinized and not only during this budget cycle. In all honesty, we should be preparing for round two next year. Do we really believe that as a state we can borrow ourselves out of the current calamity or fund ongoing programs with resources that allow only one dip at the well? Missourians, as you have noted, are a proud, independent and pugnacious lot. We did not earn the moniker “The Show Me State” by accident. Some folks may lament the good-’nuff attitude of many Missourians, but in so doing they ignore the root of this attitude. We understand a few of life’s immutable facts. There is never enough money for all of our benevolent notions. Life throws a mean curve ball, and Old Man Murphy is alive and well. In the midst of this, it is therefore either deplorable to propose “favoritism” with parts of state government over others or a bald-faced lie to suggest that cutting a new Ellis Fischel Cancer Center, the MU Agro Forestry Center in New Franklin or the MU Extension program is not a cut to the higher education budget. Birthing new programs at this time is most certainly irresponsible or, at a minimum, ill advised in the face of the decisions necessary at this time. The same is true regarding the expansion of programs that encourage citizens to rely on the government rather than their own ingenuity, hard work and general good sense. I do not want any funds cut from the university. However, it is just not practical to start or expand programs. Should I not expect fundamental honesty from those entrusted with the sacred duties of public office as so sworn in the oath of those offices? We are adults. Do not patronize, politicize or play one-upmanship with the future of our great state. Look at the state budget honestly and assess the money truly available for use in the next budget. Ask each of us to share the burden. Do not saddle us with the grim inevitability of future program cuts that grow from hopeful notions that money will materialize to sustain programs started with single-source funds. Divvy up the funds among the various agencies of government to the best of your ability devoid of political ambition, rhetoric and rancor. Stand above the fray. Allow those in charge of roads, health care, education, law enforcement, etc. to determine the best manner in which to serve Missourians. Do not give raises to your policy team and then claim you lead by example by reducing that budget because you have fewer people. Do both; employ fewer advisors at the same rate of pay as their predecessors. This is integrity. Meddling at the program level earned the legislature the last couple of years a black eye. We Missourians expect leadership. Do not hand us more of the same tied with a different color bow. If the federal government is going to try to “borrow” us back to a sound economy, use those funds for capital projects. Dollars spent in the construction industry bolster activity throughout the economy and instill confidence in the future. Lead with the certainty that sound, fundamental, middle-class values bear as much fruit as brighter tomorrows. Do not mortgage the future, polarize the electorate or neglect the call of forthright governance. 11 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com voices 12 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Voices—Schauwecker ... continued from Page 10 Voices—Martin ... continued from Page 11 Subsidized housing and “the $700 duplex” Obama Time? “The methodology set forth in Maryville Properties v. Nelson, as modified by the Western District Court of Appeals, is the correct methodology to determine market value of subsidized properties.” Boone County negotiated a settlement that is 10 percent higher than valuation prescribed by case law. The developer is a Boone County resident. The State Tax Commission of Missouri and “school funding deficits” The Missouri State Tax Commission is charged with the responsibility of monitoring the assessment accuracy in each of the 114 counties and the city of St. Louis. A biennial Assessment Ratio Study is used to accomplish this oversight function in Missouri. Residential, commercial and agricultural properties are subject to review. The tax commission has certified to the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education for 20 consecutive years that Boone County valuations are accurate as prescribed by law. Local school districts receive about 80 cents or 80 percent of every property tax dollar we pay. The assessed valuation of Boone County was $650 million in 1989. Last year the total assessed valuation of Boone County was $2.2 billion. Need I say more? Reassessment 2009 and “Homeowners spoil for fight over taxes” Market is down. Assessments stay up. These headlines were printed above the fold on the Metro page of the St. Louis Post Dispatch on Jan. 25, 2009. Not a day goes by that I am not asked when I’m “going to lower taxes.” Missouri assessors will make difficult decisions this year in the midst of a turbulent real estate market. The Missouri General Assembly amended a 10 percent usury limit during the late 1970s. Mortgage rates exceeded this threshold and Missouri markets were frozen, nothing sold. We survived 16.25 percent interest rates on one-year adjustable rate mortgages in 1982. Federal income tax reform dramatically altered the demand for multi-family housing in 1987. No one has experience with current market conditions. We are carefully analyzing sales in the fourth quarter of 2008 and the first quarter of 2009 before we decide what changes are appropriate this year. Tax Increment Financing and “blight” A local government may declare an area “blighted” and freeze property taxes paid by developers at predevelopment levels. Any new or “incremental” property tax revenue from improvements is diverted to help pay off bonds issued at the start of the project. Half of new sales, utility and earnings taxes generated by the project may also be used to pay off infrastructure. TIFs expire after 23 years. The Columbia City Council passed a resolution authorizing the use of this “economic development tool” in the Central Business District. The Cordish Co. developed the Power and Light District in Kansas City, Mo., utilizing a TIF in 2008. Cordish is contesting the property taxes for its entertainment district. Last year the Jackson County assessor’s office placed a value of $61 million on the Power and Light buildings. Cordish filed a lawsuit Dec. 31, 2008, claiming its property was worth only $12 million, not $61 million. Kansas City taxpayers will make up the difference if revenues fall short of debt service requirements. How does Columbia avoid this risk? “Tax collectors and the prostitutes” Some perceptions never change. In ancient times a tax collector was aligned with the enemy or occupying force. Tax collectors cheated people of their money. Prostitutes and tax collectors were considered public sinners. You can view my “sins” on the Parcel Information Viewer found on the assessor’s home page located at www.showmeboone.com . The North Central Columbia Neighborhood Association should take a page from Barack Obama’s book: It’s time for change. In the president’s case, change apparently means returning to basics by rebuilding roads, bridges and schools. In North Central’s case, change should mean persistent letters that got a one-time neighborhood repository of spent condoms, burned drug spoons and empty whiskey bottles fenced, posted and cleaned. It should mean fundraising drives, membership outreach and helping low-income neighbors get rid of household hazards. Today, change at the North Central association should mean working with the new Shoe Factory association and other central city groups such as the First Ward Ambassadors and Ridgeway neighborhood to address crises like the spike in violence at Douglass Park. As the best-located neighborhood in the city but working with what association member Sid Sullivan insightfully termed “a housing stock mostly in the code enforcement stage rather than the urban renewal stage,” North Central faces unique challenges. A neighborhood association should be an instrument of “organic” urban renewal, fighting blight and crime from within, but also supporting the arts; encouraging forward-thinking entrepreneurs like the Atkins family, John Ott, Brian Pape and Mark Timberlake; and communicating with the larger public through newsletters and the giant Village neighborhood online listserv. It’s time for North Central to start saying, “Yes, We Can” again. If America can do it, so can one great Columbia neighborhood. By Jason Rosenbaum Gov. Jay Nixon’s proposals for funding higher education, which will now be considered by the House Budget Committee, elicited enthusiasm from the local legislative delegation but some skepticism from Republicans who control the General Assembly. Before introducing his budget at the end of January, Nixon traveled around the state, including to the Reynolds Alumni Center at the University of Missouri, to tout a plan that would make no cuts in state funding for the colleges and universities in exchange for a tuition freeze. "The leaders of Missouri's four-year public institutions have spent the past few weeks carefully reviewing the budget and planning for our future," Nixon said on Jan. 21. "We know that a highly trained work force is vital if we're going to turn this economy around." With state revenues down because of the recession, the University of Missouri has planned for deep cuts in funding for the budget that starts July 1. Shortly before Nixon’s visit, Forsee complied with a state government directive by asking department heads to prepare scenarios for funding cuts ranging from 15 to 25 percent. Nixon’s proposal was enthusiastically endorsed by UM System President Gary Forsee, who attended the news conference. Also present were three members of the Columbia delegation: state Sen. Kurt Schaefer, R-Columbia; state Rep. Chris Kelly, D-Columbia; and state Rep. Mary Still, D-Columbia. "For the university's part, we commit to being great stewards of the state's resources," Forsee said. "We want to be sure that we'll be able to heighten the accountability that should be [in line with the economic times]." Nixon used a great deal of his State of the State address to delineate the expansion or creation of several higher education programs. For instance, Nixon is calling for a boost to the state's A+ Program, which allows high school students who tutor and earn a certain grade point average at eligible schools to go to a vocational or junior college tuition-free. Nixon wants to provide a chance for students in the program to go to a four-year college or university for free as well. "It builds upon our current A+ Schools Program, which allows students at eligible high schools to get their two-year degrees at community colleges tuition-free," Nixon said in his address. "The Missouri Promise allows those students who take advantage of A+ scholarships to continue at a Missouri public college or university and complete their four-year degree debt free." Nixon also brought back a revamped version of the "Preparing to Care" initiative. The measure, which would cost roughly $40 million, is aimed at creating space at colleges and universities to train health care professionals. This year, the plan has been re-branded as the "Caring for Missourians" plan. "Right now, we have far too many jobs in health care that we can't fill right here in Missouri because we can't find people with the right skills," Nixon said. "We need nurses, pharmacy workers and rural health care workers. Filling those positions is critical to both our economy and our health care system." Democrats generally were enthused with Nixon's proposals. Kelly, for instance, let out an excited yelp when Nixon announced he was reintroducing the Preparing for Missourians initiative. Although Rep. Stephen Webber, D-Columbia, said a funding freeze was "not ideal," he added it was the best option for the current budget situation. Kelly said he was especially pleased with Nixon's relationship with Forsee. After Nixon's speech, Forsee released a long statement praising the governor for a "clear commitment to investing in public higher education, and his belief that education is vital to advancing Missouri's economy, creating jobs and preparing students for a globally competitive workplace." "I'm incredibly encouraged," Kelly said. "It's interesting to see what a difference it makes when you have a governor who graduated from [MU]." Some Republicans were receptive to some of Nixon's proposals. Schaefer said he would support getting funds for the Caring for Missourians Program. He also said there were a lot of members of the General Assembly who would want to see the tuition plan implemented. Senate Appropriations Chairman Gary Nodler, R-Joplin, also found something to like in the tuitionfreeze proposal. "I'm not guaranteeing that we can and will do it," he said. "But yes, I think it's possible. And yes, I think it's a good idea." But some Republicans were less positive about Nixon's agenda and approach. For instance, members of House Republican leadership—including House Speaker Ron Richard, R-Joplin, and House Higher Education Committee Chairman Gayle Kingery, R-Poplar Bluff—said they were not happy that Nixon didn't consult with them before announcing his tuition freeze. And some Senate Republicans said they were concerned about how Nixon was predicating nearly $800 million within his budget with funds from a pending federal stimulus package. (continued on Page 16) /,9(:25.,1&2/80%,$02 5(6,'(17,$/ $OOH\$/X[XU\$SDUWPHQW &200(5&,$/5(7$,/ (%URDGZD\VTIW SHUVTIW &200(5 &,$/2)),&( (%URDGZD\6WH URRPRIILFHVTIW SHUPRQWK (%URDGZD\VTIW SHUPRQWKPRQWKOHDVH %5%$+DUGZRRG)ORRUV :DVKHU'U\HU 6WDLQOHVV6WHHO$SSOLDQFHVLQFO 'LVKZDVKHU&XVWRP&ORVHWV &DOODKDQ*DOORZD\ SHUVTIW -RKQ2WW MRKQRWW#FROXPELDPRFRP 13 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Nixon’s college funding plan gets mixed reviews 14 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com people you should know Chris Stevens Director of Sales for Relationship Banking Boone County National Bank AGE: 41 JOB DESCRIPTION: I lead the sales and development efforts of our Relationship Banking Department. Relationship banking is designed to provide a high level of customer service to our valued clients. Relationship banking houses some of our most seasoned and knowledgeable customer service representatives, each one having an area of expertise. YEARS LIVED IN COLUMBIA: 24 ORIGINAL HOMETOWN: Hammond, Louisiana EDUCATION: Bachelor of Science in Speech Communication and Art History COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT: Right now I am president of the University Club, president of the Arts and Science Alumni Organization, on the board of Mizzou Alumni Association and have recently become involved with the Farmer’s Market Pavilion Project. I recently finished a 10-year stint on the Cultural Affairs Commission. I have been fortunate to get involved with many things that I am passionate about. PROFESSIONAL BACKGROUND: After working eight years in the media business with the Columbia Daily Tribune and KBXR radio, I moved to Boone County National Bank’s student loan department. After three years working with colleges all across the state, I moved to the Relationship Banking department and have been here for almost eight years. My emphasis is acting as a “private banker” with a concentration on faculty, staff and administrators at the University of Missouri. A COLUMBIA BUSINESSPERSON I ADMIRE AND WHY: I realize that this technically doesn’t answer your question. However, after 24 years in Columbia, there are many people that have shaped my career, influenced me or I just look up to for their passion for Columbia. Here is the short list: Dan Scotten, Marie Hunter, Bo Fraser, John Ott, Fred Parry, John Bailey, Chris Marks, Connie Martin, Arnie Fagan, Richard King and Jerry Dethrow. I also have to put in a plug for my wife, Jennifer Perlow. I am proud of what she and a few others are doing to further the arts in Columbia. WHY I’M PASSIONATE ABOUT MY JOB: As cliché as this may sound, I enjoy helping people attain their dreams. Whether it’s a new house or car, sending a child to college, remodeling a kitchen or just setting up a savings plan, I have truly enjoyed being there to help. I try to never say no. If anything, I try my best to offer alternative solutions to whatever the situation may be. IF I WEREN’T DOING THIS FOR A LIVING, I WOULD BE…either running a resort hotel in a tropical location or acting as a scout for a major record label. BIGGEST CAREER OBSTACLE I’VE OVERCOME AND HOW: Realizing I am a banker. This was not in my career plan in college. In fact, I had to take my mom to my office and show her the name plate on my desk before she would believe that I actually worked at a bank. A FAVORITE RECENT PROJECT: I am looking forward to the Farmer’s Market Pavilion Project. I love our farmer’s market. I have visited farmer’s markets all over the country. Although ours may not be as large as some, it still has one of the most diverse product offerings I have seen. Having a permanent, covered facility will only make it better for all of Columbia. WHAT PEOPLE SHOULD KNOW ABOUT THIS PROFESSION: Bankers are not as boring as everyone may think. The old days of a stodgy banker are over. Even the look of banks will continue to evolve into a more retail-oriented, customer-friendly atmosphere. Competition for banking has grown tremendously, not just with more banks, but with many non-banking institutions offering banking products like home loans and CDs. Traditional banks have had to reinvent themselves to become more customer-friendly. WHAT I DO FOR FUN: I am kind of a music fanatic. I spend a lot of time reading blogs and magazines trying to find the greatest new music. It’s amazing what is out there that you have never heard of. I wish they made a bigger iPod to hold all of my findings. Suggested reading: “1,000 Recordings to Hear Before You Die” by Tom Moon. FAMILY: My wife, Jennifer, two children, Clayton 13 and Charlotte 7, a cat and a dog. FAVORITE PLACE IN COLUMBIA: I know this will sound like a blatant plug, but my favorite place is PS: Gallery. I often make my wife put me on the schedule to work Sundays. I put on some great tunes and walk around the gallery making up stories about my favorite paintings, or I try to come up with a song to fit each piece. ACCOMPLISHMENT I’M MOST PROUD OF: I am very proud of the gallery. When we opened, we wanted to be more than just the gallery. We wanted to be an interactive part of the community. I am proud of the artists we have shown and the respect we have given to them and their work. I have also been pleased to be able to use the gallery for special showings and fundraisers. From the CARE Gallery, Thompson Center for Autism, Hickman High School Honors Class and many more, we have been able to utilize the gallery to show the work of those less fortunate and raise awareness for their causes. Of course the trick is, in order to keep the doors open, we need to sell the work of the artists we represent. MOST PEOPLE DON’T KNOW THAT I: have toured just about every Civil War battlefield in the country. As a child, we didn’t go to Disney World or the beach. We toured Bull Run, Gettysburg, Manassas and many others. I hated it as a kid but now have a much greater appreciation for this time of American history. v photo by jennifer kettler By Christen Jackson If Congress passes President Barack Obama’s stimulus package, the Missouri Department of Transportation could receive an infusion of one-time cash that would enable the department to immediately undertake projects across the state. MoDOT has already selected 34 projects that could be awarded within 180 days of passage of the federal stimulus legislation. The projects, which would total approximately $510 million, would create 14,000 jobs and would have an estimated $2.4 billion impact on Missouri’s economy, according to MoDOT. Boone County is on the list of communities to benefit. MoDOT would like to build a railroad bridge over U.S. 63, north of Route B, in Columbia. The total cost of the project would be approximately $9 million. "We stand ready to quickly deliver 34 transportation improvements that would mean jobs, increased safety and a better quality of life for Missourians," said Pete Rahn, director of the Missouri Department of Transportation. "These are much-needed projects that will benefit Missouri citizens." Mitch Skove of Columbia’s Planning and Development Department said the department was contacted around Jan. 20 about possible federal stimulus money that could fund road improvements around Columbia. Two projects were added as proposed amendments to the Columbia Area Transportation Study Organization’s Transportation Improvement Plan at the request of MoDOT. CATSO's technical committee approved the amendments and recommended their approval by the coordinating committee, which will meet Feb. 26. One of the projects would be resurfacing 19 miles of Route Z from State Route 124 to I-70 for an estimated cost of $1.045 million. The other road improvement project added to the list would resurface the 4.8-mile stretch of I-70 Drive Southeast from U.S. 63 to the Route Z interchange for around $264,000. In addition, three amendments were added to CATSO’s transit section that would improve bus service in Columbia. If the stimulus money funds the projects, 20 new bus shelters will be built and rundown bus-stop benches will be replaced for an estimated $151,050. The transit system would also receive $15,600 to fund data collection and analysis on the system’s use and service. MoDOT said that given addition funds beyond ‘We stand ready to quickly deliver 34 transportation improvements that would mean jobs, increased safety and a better quality of life for Missourians’ —Pete Rahn $510 million, significant portions of four additional highway projects totaling roughly $290 million could be underway in 2009. Rahn said federal funding for infrastructure projects would have a ripple effect. It could create jobs for road builders and designers, demand for related supplies and services, as well as further economic development around the improvements. "The job creation will go beyond just those building the projects," Rahn said. "Suppliers, retailer, restaurants, hotels and other businesses will benefit." In addition, MoDOT would be prepared to undertake $137 million of work on Interstates 70, 44, 55, 35 and 29. Approximately $60 million would go toward fixing the states lettered routes in rural Missouri. The rest would be used on a variety of transportation projects across the state. According to MoDOT, 17 of the proposed projects are already part of the state’s five-year construction program but would be sped up, some by up to four years. Projects would then be added to the statewide construction program to replace those that were accelerated. The other 17 are new projects that have been identified as regional priorities and on which environmental work and preliminary design are already under way. Ongoing Problem Adequate funding for the transportation department has been a long-time problem. Transportation professionals, lawmakers and MoDOT all say that the federal stimulus package would be a huge boost for Missouri’s transportation system, but it is one-time only funding. In 2008, the Missouri Transportation Alliance was formed in order to look for long-range answers to transportation funding problems. The non-partisan group is made up of representatives from the business community, business and labor organizations, and local leaders. On its Web site (missouritransportation.org) the group says it is "working collaboratively with Missouri citizens, public officials, local leaders, and transportation advocates, will focus on assessing regional needs and priorities to create a statewide vision that will meet the needs of the citizens of Missouri for the next decade." (continued on Page 17) 15 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Local projects targeted for federal stimulus funding 16 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Legislature—MU Funding ... continued from Page 13 "It was a good speech for people who are bad at math," said Senate Majority Leader Kevin Engler, R-Farmington. “If you don't listen to the details, it's really good. But when you start listening to the details and you look at the budget, it balances only if there's $800 million coming from the federal government." Nodler said he was concerned about paying for programs needing funding each year, such as the A+ Program or an eligibility expansion in the state's Medicaid program, with stimulus money. "You don't want (the federal stimulus plan) to be like a shot of heroin that causes a dependency and causes withdrawal," Nodler said. Additionally, the Caring for Missourians plan faces steep opposition from powerful lawmakers. Last year, the previous iteration of the plan was taken out of Gov. Matt Blunt's budget. Nodler, then-House Speaker Rod Jetton, R-Marble Hill, and House Budget Chairman Allen Icet, R-Wildwood, opposed the measure. Icet expressed doubt last week that the plan would find favor in an even tougher budgetary climate. "I think it's fair to say that any new decision item—unless we can find a program that could pay for (it)—I think for the most part is dead on arrival," Icet said. "It's just not fiscally prudent to do something like that." v POTM ... continued from Page 4 Achievements Three Columbia-area businesses—Enginet Technologies Inc., operated by Allen Mavel, Nanoparticle Biochem Inc., directed by Rebecca Johnson and the Research Center for Human-Animal Interaction, operated by Anandhi Upendrani—were among 20 outstanding small businesses in Missouri honored by members of the General Assembly Jan. 28 at a business showcase in Jefferson City. The event, sponsored by the Missouri Small Business & Technology Development Centers and the Missouri Procurement Technical Assistance Centers, highlighted the achievements of some of the two programs’ top-performing clients. Enginet Technologies focuses on the development of software used for the efficient creation and placement of assessment questionnaires and surveys for a variety of uses. Nanoparticle Biochem conducts research and development on an array of products that encompass nanoparticle-based agents for biocompatible, antimicrobial and diagnostic and therapeutic medicine applications. The Research Center for Human-Animal Interaction studies the mutual benefits of human/animal bond relationships. Matthew Ravosa, University of Missouri professor and director of graduate studies in pathology and anatomical sciences, was recently elected as a fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, the world’s largest general scientific society. Ravosa will be recognized as a fellow Feb. 14 during the AAAS annual meeting in Chicago. He was one of 15 individuals nationwide appointed to the organization’s section on anthropology. Partnerships The R. Anthony sales team recently joined forces with House of Brokers Realty. In her new role, Christi Wolverton will serve as a real estate agent for House of Brokers while Rob Wolverton will continue to focus on development and other properties. The Wolvertons developed neighborhoods such as Bellwood, Madison Park, Auburn Hills and The Cascades. Retirements B.W. “Perk” Hoecker retired from First National Bank and its holding company, The Landrum Company, on Jan. 30. Hoecker joined First National Bank in October 1998 as Executive Vice President and head of retail banking. He then led the consumer loans division of the bank until 2004, when he took over the company’s real estate acquisition and development function full time. Hoecker started his banking career in 1972 in St. Louis as a commercial mortgage banker and held various lending and management jobs for Mercantile Bank, which is now US Bank. In 1985, he returned to Columbia as the regional president of what is now Bank of America. Hoecker retired from Bank of America in June 1996. v Chaired by Bill McKenna, former chairman of the Missouri Highways and Transportation Commission and former president pro tem of the Missouri Senate, the group recently completed a series of educational meetings around the state and has plans for other meetings in the coming months. Dave Griggs, of Dave Griggs Flooring America in Columbia, and Bob Robuck, of Central Bank in Jefferson City are serving as district chairs for Central Missouri on MoTA’s Statewide Stakeholders Central Committee. McKenna has said that MoTA will work to secure extensive public input from citizens across Missouri regarding current and future concerns and challenges for Missouri's transportation system. That input will provide the basis for MoTA to develop and recommend a long-term comprehensive transportation vision. At a news conference Feb. 4, Rahn outlined the ongoing challenges faced by MoDOT due to declining transportation revenues as people drive less and make fewer vehicle purchases. While the proposed stimulus package would allow the department to fund some projects it would have had to wait on otherwise, it does not address the “slide in transportation funding the state is facing.” The good news is Missouri’s roads have improved over the last five years. The approval of Amendment 3 in 2004 by Missouri voters redirected highway user funds to MoDOT, which allowed the department to finance more infrastructure maintenance such as smoothing roads, installing larger signs and painting wider stripes. That brought the percentage of roads deemed to be in “good condition” up from 44 percent in 2003 to 83 percent today, Rahn said. The bad news is Amendment 3 funding ends in 2009, and McKenna said that “will significantly reduce the amount of funding available for maintenance and repair of our current system and leave virtually no new money for Missouri’s transportation needs beyond our current system." v PRO Fitness 1 $ Single memberships start at just over $1 a day MENTION THIS AD FOR A FREE WEEK PA S S * *SOME RESTRICTIONS MAY APPLY Baby product business wins innovation award Local micro-business Sass and Fras was given an honorable mention in the “most innovative” category by StartupNation, an entrepreneur community and resource center, in its Home-based 100 contest. StartupNation recognizes the most innovative, successful and creative home-based businesses in its yearly contest. Sass and Fras, owned and operated by Jennifer Albin, offers the “baby bloak,” a mix between a coat and a blanket that is car seat safe. Rather than put a bulky coat between the baby and the car seat, the bloak goes over the baby and the car seat straps. It resembles a cloak; it has a hood and no arm-holes and keeps the baby warm and comfortable. Albin developed the patent-pending concept herself and sells the bloaks through her Web site, thebabybloak.com. v Dear Business Associate You’ll say “WOW!” when you see our state-of-the-art fitness facility. Just minutes from your home or office, we’ve got the tools you need for the results you want. Convenience • Work out day or night • Close to your home or office • Save more—ask about corporate discounts • Freeze your membership – if you don’t use it, put it on hold The best way to see how you can benefit from a health club membership is to come in and try PRO Fitness for a free week—with full club privileges 573.446.4FIT(4348) WWW.PROFITNESSCOLUMBIA.COM LOCATED BETWEEN BASS PRO & HILTON GARDEN 17 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Legislature—Transportation ... continued from Page 15 ADDY Awards 2008 The Mid-Missouri Advertising Fe The winners earned a chance to Federation. The mid-Missouri group of networking and advocacy for creators, bu Arysta LifeScience-Midas Campaign Gold ADDY Award and Best of Show ADDY Woodruff Sweitzer Category: Mixed Multiple Media, national consumer Contributors: Justin White, associate creative director; Greg Beers, copywriter; Jeff Lowe, group director; Lori Kruger, account manager; Steve Sweitzer, creative director; Jori Rose, production manager; Chris Canipe, production artist; Michael Head, production artist; Gaige Iaron, production artist Judges comments: “Great consistent design and strong compelling benefit.” ederation presented the local Addy Awards on Feb. 6 at Cherry Street Artisan. o compete in regional and national competition presented by the American Advertising advertising professionals was started in 1994 to create an opportunity for education, uyers and sellers of advertising, design, public relations, printing and media. :34 PM 12 2 f1 4o Cherry Street Artisan Gold ADDY Award and Best of Television OnMedia Category: Television, local TV Contributors: Jay Pelzer, commercial producer Judges comments: “Great footage.” “Excellent music-visual editing.” True/False Film Festival Campaign Judges’ Certificate of Merit Boxcar Films Category: Advertising for the Arts & Sciences, Arts TV Spot and Arts Campaign Contributors: Nathan Truesdell, director, cinematographer and editor; David Wilson, producer; Brock Williams, executive producer Bleu Restaurant and Wine Bar Gold ADDY Award and Best of Web Pure Marketing & Media Category: Interactive Media, Web Site, Consumer Flash Contributors: Zach Fisher, lead Web design; David Anderson, art direction Judges comments: “Well Done – Organized & Imagery.” “Site gives good indication of brand.” (continued on Page 20) 20 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Diamond Packaging Gold Addy Award and Best of Print Woodruff Sweitzer Category: Sales Promotion, Packaging Campaign Advertiser: Diamond Pet Foods for Del’s Feed & Farm Contributors: Justin White, associate creative director; Gaige Larson, production artist; Steve Sweitzer, creative director; Brenna Naufel, account executive, Ken Jacobsen, illustrator; Jori Rose, production manager; Scott Kington, account supervisor Judges comments: “Great appeal to dog owners.” “Excellent use of color, from logo throughout.” “Consistent look from bag to bag while giving them a subtle change for the consumer.” True/False Film Festival Program Gold ADDY Award and Judge’s Choice Category: Advertising for the Arts & Sciences; Arts Brochure Contributors: Chris Canipe, graphics coordinator; Mary Nguyen, graphic designer; Gaige Larson, graphic designer; David Wilson & Paul Sturtz, co-directors Southside “Pizza Investigator” Gold ADDY Award and Best of Radio Bradley Marketing Category: Radio, local radio campaign Contributors: Tom Bradley, writer/producer Beetle Invasion Learfield Communications Advertiser: Department of Entomology, Purdue University Category: Radio, Local Radio A World Without Corn Learfield Communications Advertiser: Iowa Corn Growers Association Category: Radio, National Radio Campaign Rain “Numbers Pure Marketing & Media Advertiser: Missouri Rain Category: Local Television Contributors: Eric Mousel, motion graphics animator; David Anderson, art direction; Kim Sherman, art direction. Tiger Checking Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Boone County National Bank Category: Local Television Contributors: Justin White, assoc. creative director; Mark Swanson, assoc. creative director; Steve Sweitzer, creative director; Pam Ogles, account manager; Nicole Thieret, account coordinator; Jori Rose, production manager Plaza Dental-Cheese OnMedia Advertiser: Plaza Dental Category: Local Television Contributors: Michelle Cropp, director of sales; Jay Pelzer, commercial producer Rebus Axiom-An Identity Company Advertiser: Downtown Optimist Tree Lot Category: Local Television Contributors: Paula Elias, creative; Ken Leija, creative; Max Wheeler, after effects Columbia Youth Community Coalition OnMedia Advertiser: Columbia Youth Community Coalition Category: Local Television Campaign Contributors: Becky Markt, director of Youth Communtiy Coalition; Jay Pelzer, commercial producer Thumper Festival Poster Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Thumper Entertainment Category: Advertising for the Arts & Sciences Contributors: Steve Sweitzer, creative director; Brian McGeorge, senior art director; Jori Rose, production manager; David Spear, illustration Big 12 Sportsmanship PSA Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Big 12 Conference Category: Public Service, Television Contributors: Justin White, associate creative director; Greg Beers, copywriter; Steve Sweitzer, creative director; Lori Kruger, account manager; Scott Kington, account supervisor Glen Martin Logo Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Glen Martin Category: Elements of Advertising, Logo Contributors: Brian McGeorge, senior graphic designer; Steve Sweitzer, creative director; Cynthia Kotovsky, account executive Silver ADDY Award winners Glen Martin Brochure Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Glen Martin Category: Collateral Material, Brochure Basketball Media Guide Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: University of MissouriAthletics Category: Collateral MaterialBrochure Ace Pumps Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Ace Pumps Category: Consumer/Trade Campaign flushafterflush.com Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Arysta LifeScience Category: Interactive MediaConsumer Web Site KT Diamond Jewelers Web Site Visionworks Marketing & Communications Advertiser: KT Diamond Jewelers Category: Interactive MediaConsumer Web Site Mid America Harley “One Minute Life Stories” Bradley Marketing Advertiser: Mid-America Harley Davidson Category: Local Radio Campaign “Unrealistic Expectations-Baby Talk” Learfield Communications Advertiser: Children’s Trust Fund of Missouri Category: National Radio Carolina Chocolate Drops Poster Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Thumper Entertainment Category: Arts-Poster D & H Drugstore “Psychic Pharmacists” Pure Marketing & Media Advertiser: D & H Drugstore Category: Local Television Dancing with the Stars Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Missouri Contemporary Ballet Company Category: Advertising for Arts & Sciences-Poster You Get Us Word Marketing Advertiser: Capitol Chrysler Category: Local Television Campaign No Worries TV Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Western Financial Group Category: National TV, Consumer Services Bleu Restaurant and Wine Bar Pure Marketing & Media Advertiser: Bleu Restaurant and Wine Bar Category: Mixed Media, Local Consumer Arysta PrePare Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Arysta LifeScience Category: Advertising for Arts & Sciences Christmas Cookies Learfield Communications Advertiser: Iowa Kidsnet Category: Public Service-Radio D & H Drugstore, Diabetes PSA Pure Marketing & Media Advertiser: D & H Drugstore Category: Public Service, Television Sugar Invite Sugar, A Woodruff Sweitzer Company Category: Industry Self Promotion Pure Marketing & Media Pure Marketing & Media Category: Industry Self Promotion Platte County Logo Woodruff Sweitzer Advertiser: Platte County Economic Development Council Category: Elements of Advertising-Logo Cinematography Project Advertiser: Pure Marketing & Media Category: Elements of Advertising-Cinematography 21 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Gold ADDY Award winners Marketing Market ... continued from Page 1 Some businesses, such as Les Bourgeois, are increasing budgets to steal market share while others are focusing their strategy and maintaining a consistent presence. Although local businesses vary in their marketing responses to the downturn, marketing and advertising agencies have noticed one constant: Clients are scrutinizing their ad budgets to make sure they’re using dollars effectively. “When things were more footloose, marketing got sloppy,” Paula Elias, president of Axiom, said. “The economy should serve as a warning sign, but it shouldn’t dictate everything we do. It should make us stronger, smarter marketers.” Clients are being more thoughtful about their advertising strategies, Elias said, and this often results in a shift from mass media to more targeted advertising. “People are not focusing as much on the radio, TV and print spending of yesteryear,” she said. “They’re spending the same amount. It’s just shifting.” According to TNS Media Intelligence, a company that measures U.S. ad spending, advertising dollars declined by 1.7 percent in the first three quarters of 2008 compared with the same nine months of 2007. Print and radio are the mediums that dragged that number down, with newspapers declining by 10 percent and radio by almost 9 percent, while TV and the Internet posted modest increases. London-based ZenithOptimedia, a company that tracks global advertising expenditures, projects total U.S. advertising dollars to drop by 6.2 percent in 2009, by far the largest globally. Although the company also sees modest increases in TV spending and healthy in- Projected percentage of advertising spending, by medium Source: ZenithOptimedia 22 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com SPECIAL SECTION | marketing & promotion 2008 2009 creases in online spending, it projects large declines in print and radio advertising. A buyer’s market “There is no doubt that contracting advertising budgets are indicative of the slowing economy, and advertisers are looking for media outlets to work harder for a smaller percentage of the buy,” said Jack Miller, owner and president of True Media Services. “This coupled with the trend of marketing dollars migrating from traditional media to Internet, cable and 2010 2011 more demographically targeted media is making it a challenge for mass media.” As a result, media outlets have become “more aggressive in their pricing strategies,” according to Terry Woodruff, president of Woodruff Sweitzer. “It is definitely a buyer’s market,” KMIZ Sales Director Mark Hotchkiss said. “Rates are certainly more affordable than last year with all of the political activity driving things.” Although the Columbia market has not been nearly as affected as the national market, many busi- Source: ZenithOptimedia Projected North American advertising expenditures, in millions 2008 2009 nesses and media companies have noticed a slight decline in advertising prices as well as more flexibility demonstrated by media outlet sales representatives. And every business has at least paused to make sure its marketing budget is being used effectively, advertising executives said. They emphasize that there is no universal strategy — each business has its own response to the new eco- Jack Miller nomic conditions. “Now is a hell of a time to pick up market share,” Brent Beshore, owner and CEO of Pure Marketing and Media, said. One of his company’s clients is Les Bourgeois, which has increased its advertising budget, focusing on TV ads and online media. According to Les Terry Woodruff Bourgeois’ marketing director, Pure Marketing is also producing a cinematic profile for the company to be used for its Web site, on-site promotions and new media pushes. Pure Marketing itself has benefited from the downturn; revenue over the last three months has increased 40 percent, Mike Vangel Beshore said. Clients have been attracted by its expertise in new media such as social networking and video branding, he said. And the business, which had only two employees at the beginning of 2008, has hired 10 more over the course of the year. Now the company has around 30 clients, Beshore said. But like any advertiser, he said all his clients are different in their approach to marketing, with some increasing advertising in certain mediums and decreasing in others. Most advertising firms have noticed little change in their clients’ marketing budgets. It’s just not a good idea to reduce your presence 2010 2011 in the marketplace, they noted. Businesses are loathe to reduce their advertising budgets at any time, and many advertisers say a more effective message is needed in a recession because potential customers are more careful about the purchases they make. “Even in this tough economic environment, successful business people are doing what they always do but perhaps Paula Elias with a little more focus,” Mike Vangel, president of VANGEL, said. “They are taking a hard look at what they’ve done in the past to make sure it’s still working. Every recession, and I’ve seen a couple now, good businesspeople have the discipline to maintain their marketing focus.” Carl Toalson, of Tint Brent Beshore By Toalson, is one of the business owners who has tried to focus his spending rather than reduce it. Even though his window-tinting business has been affected by Columbia’s decline in new home construction, Toalson said he’s kept his ad dollars in television. “I learned a long time ago you want to stay conLili Vianello stant,” he said. “We try to budget the same amount every month.” Guerilla marketing But it’s also the little things business owners do that can make a difference. Toalson’s advertising consultant, Accountable MARKeting owner Mark Dahl, is a big proponent of free, innovative marketing. “Sometimes it’s as simple as putting business cards on complementary businesses’ counters,” Dahl said. In fact, that’s usually the first thing Dahl suggests to his clients. (continued on Page 25) 23 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com SPECIAL SECTION | marketing & promotion Source: TNS Media Intelligence U.S. ad spending, % change in Q-1/Q-3 of 2008 compared with same period in 2007 Marketing Market ... continued from Page 23 Toalson keeps up a rapport with managers of furniture stores around town and leaves a supply of business cards in their stores. Someone who buys a new piece of furniture might also want to have his or her house’s windows tinted to keep the new furniture from fading, Dahl said. “It’s not something we could rely on 100 percent, but it’s gotten us jobs we wouldn’t have gotten in the past,” Toalson said. And why not, he said, it’s free. Dahl said though the results aren’t quick and obvious from these so-called guerilla-marketing tactics, it’s a time investment that could yield results well into the future. Once the economy settles down, he said, customers need to have your business in mind when they do make their purchase. Maintaining a presence on traditional media is no longer enough, he said. “The truth is, mass media is not what it was 15, 20 years ago,” Dahl said. Terry Woodruff at Woodruff Sweitzer has seen his larger, national clients take this advice much more quickly than smaller companies. Interactive advertis- ing is the most attractive marketing to consumers right now, he said. He has noticed that his clients haven’t had their normal advertising budget increase this year, but there is still an ongoing shift to new media. “Most of our customers’ advertising has been shifting from traditional media with print probably taking the biggest hit,” he said. Buchroeder’s Jewelers is buying very little print advertising in newspapers these days but is improving its Web site and shifting more of its advertising budget to new media, President Mills Menser said. The company’s bread and butter is engagement rings, and that generation is very active online, he added. But Brian Steffens, executive director of the National Newspaper Association and associate professor at the MU School of Journalism, said that though larger newspaper chains and metros are hurting right now, there will always be a need for papers to advertise goods and services that everyone needs. Newspapers have 200 years of experience, he said, and the judge is still out on the Internet’s effectiveness in growing business and driving shoppers to physical stores. “I feel that lots of stuff that goes to the Internet is going there because it’s sexy,” he said. “They’re just going because everyone is.” In small markets, often the only truly local news outlet is the community paper, he said. And here in Columbia, people love their news. “There is a media appetite here,” Steffens said. “There was an uproar when they mentioned cutting back the Missourian even though it’s a second paper and much smaller than the Tribune.” Vicki Russell, associate publisher of the Columbia Daily Tribune, said that while certain advertising sectors have softened, the newspaper has not adjusted (continued on Page 27) 25 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com SPECIAL SECTION | marketing & promotion 26 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com SPECIAL SECTION | marketing & promotion Promotional products feed customer fondness for ‘free stuff’ By Jordan Milne Shelter Insurance agent Nancy Allison wants to become a household name in Columbia, with a little help from Kammie Teter at White Dog Promotions. To promote Allison and the company’s life insurance policy for children, Teter designed a refrigerator magnet that can be used as a photo frame and has a pop-out growth chart. “The more you can put your name in front of people, the better,” Allison, who’s been a Shelter agent for 35 years, said. “My goal is to be on every refrigerator in Columbia.” Teter has provided a slew of other promotional projects for Allison, including pens, pull-apart key chains, golfing divot tools, insurance card holders, business card magnets, embroidered baby bibs and beverage insulators that are better known as koozie cups. “People love giveaways and free stuff,” Allison said. “And in the insurance business, my clients don’t walk away with a big screen TV. All we have is a promise that we’ll be there when something bad happens.” The largest single display of promotional products in town can be perused at the annual Columbia Chamber of Commerce Business Conference & Showcase, which is being held March 17 at the Holiday Inn Select Executive Center. Allison’s products will be there, as will giveaways from Grossmann Promotional Products, which is owned by Larry Grossmann. Although the most popular giveaways are pens, sticky notes and business card magnets, Teter said the promotional product business “is so much more than pens and mugs. It’s really anything you want to advertise your business. Promotional products are an excellent way to reach people, whether they come into the store or it’s through direct mail. With radio and TV you pay for a mass distribution, and that works better for some businesses than others.” Grossmann said that stainless steel and aluminum drink wear are on the rise since the BPA in plastics has been cited as a carcinogenic. He will be at the Business Conference and Showcase giving away biodegradable insulated mugs. “Recently I’ve seen a real increase in the amount of eco-friendly products available and I’m trying to educate my clients,” said Teter. “Bamboo clothing is big, as well as shirts made with recycled water bottles and items made with recycled tires.” Both Teter and Grossmann also said solarpowered items have become very popular, and Teter said last year’s big item was a calculator that runs on liquids poured into a reservoir. Kammie Teter of White Dog Promotions named her business after her dog Doc. Marketing Market ... continued from Page 25 rates downward. The MU hiring freeze and slow business growth have had an impact on job-opening classifieds, and retail store closures such as Circuit City’s have also been noticeable, Russell said. But the newspaper is preparing to launch a new online product that will have a strong free advertising component for every business in Boone County, Russell said. “When times get tough, you have to look for ways to help local business,” she said. White Dog Promotions products. “The price of traditional media has continued to increase, while the price of promotional products has decreased,” Grossmann said. “There are surveys out there that prove you can create a brand, put it on a promotional product and have better response.” Grossmann started the promotional product company in the mid-1980s and, after a hiatus, brought it back again in 2007, the year he sold the ADD Sheet, a company he founded in 1971. The store in the Forum Shopping Center has a 15,000-square-foot showroom, one of the largest in the region, according to Grossmann. “As promotional product counselors our job has changed in that today we find a solution that is at the right place at the right time,” Grossmann said. “There are many more products these days to be more specific in the solution. If we’re looking for a solution that’s (a promotional product placed) on the desk top, we have thousands of items; if it’s a solution in the home, we have tens of thousands of items; for the cell phone, we have hundreds of items.” Teter started White Dog Promotions (www. whitedogpromos.com) in 2005 and has been working out of her home. But she said that her basement “is overflowing,” so she intends to open a showroom on March 2 at 4603 John Garry Dr., across from Rock Bridge High School. v A healthy mix of media Even Woodruff, whose company often stresses the advantages of online marketing, said mass media advertising should rebound as the economy corrects. But he said that clients who have shifted more of their budgets to the Internet and see results could keep their dollars there. “Traditional media is still needed to launch new products and services,” Woodruff said. “You still need to reach the masses.” Vangel also said that good advertising will always rely on a healthy mix of media. “I don’t see any radical shifts coming,” he said. “Are people using the Web more? Yes. But is there a Holy Grail of advertising? I don’t think so.” Savvy companies are always tweaking their message and placement to find what works, Vangel said, economic downturn or not. Lili Vianello, president of Visionworks Marketing & Communications, said the main advice she’s giving clients right now is “don’t get caught up in the hype,” but don’t be reckless either. “Keep your head and manage expectations — double digit increases are a few years off,” she said. “It’s fine to think twice about not making an expenditure, but don’t be ruled by fear.” v 27 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com SPECIAL SECTION | marketing & promotion 28 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com SPECIAL SECTION | marketing & promotion Companies can survive, even thrive, during a recession By Mary Paulsell Recently, I heard two series of local radio ads that I found refreshing. One is for a siding company and another for an HVAC firm. They send a similar message: “We’re trying to keep our business going until things get better. Call us now for special deals and even better customer service. We want to keep our guys working.” It’s unfortunate that the economy has required these firms and others to develop such direct messages, but I personally like that directness. These companies are making no secret of the fact that times are tough right now, particularly for folks in their business, but they are intent on surviving it through a blend of optimism, determination and very hard work. And they are reflecting one of the tried-and-true strategies for marketing during a recession: Keep talking, and when things improve, you’ll still be standing while your competitors may have thrown in the towel. I was fascinated by a list I found the other day of the companies that had actually started or thrived during past recessionary periods. The leaders of these firms saw a market opportunity and capitalized on it — good advice for prospective and existing business owners regardless of the economy’s health. In 1957, during the Eisenhower recession, Hyatt Corporation launched its first hotel at the Los Angeles International Airport while Burger King, a fledgling start-up at the time, introduced its signature Whopper. Another success story from that same year was the opening of the first International House of Pancakes. In 1958, Jim Henson started creating his Muppet characters and launched an entertainment empire. In 1959, Pronto Markets, a series of convenience stores, first opened. Now the company is known as Trader Joe’s. LexisNexis started as a government contractor during the 1973 oil crisis. Seven years later, a little-known I was fascinated by a list I found the other day of the companies that had actually started or thrived during past recessionary periods. The leaders of these firms saw a market opportunity and capitalized on it. station called Cable Network News launched during the 1980 downturn, followed one year later by MTV, which added a new brand of entertainment for young people. Although it was launched in early 2001, Wikipedia really took off following the attacks of Sept. 11, possibly as a result of us cocooning more around our computers. And Hewlett-Packard Development Company was born from a $538 investment in a garage in Palo Alto at the end of the Great Depression. The lesson here is that survival — even prosperity and growth — is possible. One component of that survival may very well be a more sophisticated marketing approach. What can you do to turn tough times into times of opportunity? Research. This is the time when you need more information — not less — about how your customers are responding to the recessionary times. What are they buying? What is the new price point? Are they negotiating more? Customers are more likely to go with tried-and-true products at times like these than they are to try new items or services. The comfort of the familiar. In uncertain times, we want to be in familiar places with familiar people doing familiar things. So market what you can to enhance the comforts of home and family. Hold the line. When your competitors are cutting back, you need to maintain your strategy. You can gain more market share without increasing your marketing investment above what you had budgeted originally. We want the assurance of known brands and vendors, and because we’re spending more time watching television, you can likely count on more of us seeing your promotion. Try to maintain the frequency of your advertising, but reduce the length of spots from 30 seconds to 15 if you must. Substitute radio for television. Augment with direct-mail marketing that makes a greater impact. (continued on Page 30) Customer Service » Lili Vianello 10 money-saving (and inexpensive) tips for a better booth experience How to build a better exhibition booth It’s here — that time of year when business- ers. Once you establish why you are exhibiting, es gather their crews, pack up everything they it will be easier to identify key messages and acown and head down to some cavernous hall to tivities for your booth. Your booth should have an appealing envisell their wares to thronging crowds of targeted ronment. Keep it simple and clean. Don’t bring shoppers. Expo season is officially upon us. It’s not uncommon for companies to pay for in everything from your office or showroom just a booth, throw together banners and brochures, to fill your booth or try to show every product you carry. The goal grab the nearest inis to have it warm tern to stick in the and inviting, not booth and hope for One key to long-term success cluttered. the best. But, there Who you are, is a better way. To from trade shows that is often what you stand for get maximum return and how you appear on your investment, overlooked is prompt follow-up. to do business is vivspend a little time Showcase exhibitors often miss idly on display in planning. First, ask yourself: important leads because they have your booth. Within seconds of seeing Why are you exhibitno lead development strategy. your booth, visitors ing? The reasons vary will begin to see in from show to show your exhibit a story and from company to company. Is your goal to generate leads or make about your corporate culture, personality and sales? Perhaps you hope to establish credibility capabilities. Within minutes, your company’s or increase awareness of your company, product image will be evaluated and mentally compared or service. You may be introducing a new prod- against other displays and competitors both uct or service, recruiting staff or merely working on and off the showroom floor. The environto reinforce relationships with existing custom(continued on Page 32) 1 # 2 # 3 # Do not scrimp on graphics. Use professionally designed signage and promotional pieces. Cutting costs in this area can actually cost you money. Put your best salespeople in your booth. It is a waste of money to do otherwise. If you do not have branded shirts, have your employees dress similarly — in black shirts and khaki pants, for example. This way they will look like a team without the extra expense of a uniform. 4 # 5 # Don’t pay extra money for gimmicky themes. Keep your booth’s theme simple. Remember, it’s a reflection of you and your business. Everything looks better with light. You do not need large, powerful overhead lights. Smaller spotlights can show off specific items of importance. Light also gives your booth a warm, welcoming feeling that invites people in. Additional lighting can increase awareness of your exhibit by 30–50 percent. www.exhibitoronline.com 29 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com SPECIAL SECTION | marketing & promotion 30 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com SPECIAL SECTION Focus ... continued from Page 28 Value and reliability. With less money to spend, customers are looking for the best value, even if it includes fewer bells and whistles. Push multipurpose products. Stress reliability, durability, safety and consistently high performance. Image and brand. Although the temptation may be to drop to lower-priced lines, avoid it. You want to maintain your brand and your image of supplying high-quality goods and services. You’ll want to retain that position when things improve. Promotions. Of course, we’re all looking for the best deal, but that doesn’t necessarily mean you should lower prices. Instead, offer temporary and special promotions, offer more quantity discounts, and extend credit to some of your best customers. Face time. Now is the time to spend more time with your customers. Assure them that you will survive these challenging times, that you will not sacrifice quality and that you will not cut corners. Emphasize to your customers that their loyalty to you is not misplaced. Measure it. Ensure that you have some system for tracking the effectiveness of your marketing efforts. Your tactics must be measurable. If they are not, revisit your marketing strategy. Deepen the relationship. It’s probably more practical in a downturn to enhance your relationship with existing customers than it is to find new customers. Because they know you, they will turn to you for information, service and the best products. They are less likely to gamble on a source with which they are unfamiliar. So cater to them. Market to them. Ask them what they need and want. Think ahead. Even when things are going well, think of what you could cut if you had to. Then do it. You may decide to print materials in-house rather than outsource it. Reduce your travel budget by holding virtual meetings. Establish clear goals. The good news is that once you have followed all of these guidelines, you will have a more efficient and effective marketing operation. Good times or bad, you will have built a system that serves you and your customers well. v Vanguard Jazz Orchestra performing at Mo Theatre Bob Brookmeyer The multi-tiered centerpiece of the “We Always Swing” Jazz Series, an event supported by the National Endowment for the Arts, takes place in Columbia on Feb. 17-18. The 16-piece Vanguard Jazz Orchestra from New York City will perform on Feb. 18 at the Missouri Theatre Center for the Arts. The performance by one of the nation’s most highly regarded big bands incorporates a world premiere commission conducted by Bob Brookmeyer. Brookmeyer and Dan Morgenstern, who have both received the Jazz Masters title from the NEA, will participate in a pair of public forums on Feb. 17 in MU’s Whitmore Recital Hall. Columbia’s Jazz Series (www.wealwaysswing.org) is now in its 14th year and is one of only 12 recipients in the country to receive a NEA Jazz Masters Live matching grant. v Deeds of Trust more than $250,000 $2,900,000,000* YRC INC JPMORGAN CHASE BANK LT 4 CONCORDE EAST PLAT 1 *National Refinancing $3,200,000 G2 ENTERPRISES LLC FIRST NATIONAL BANK & TRUST CO LT 110 CROSSCREEK CENTER PLAT 1 $2,500,000 1031 EXCHANGOR INC PROVIDENCE BANK LT 1 PT FF ANDERSON’S ADD $1,758,000 WARNKEN PROPERTIES VI LLC CENTRAL TRUST BANK THE STR 18-48-12 //SW $575,000 ELM BUILDING PARTNERSHIP LLP HAWTHORN BANK LT 35 PT COLUMBIA $417,000 ABRAMOVITZ-ELWING TRUST BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK STR 2-47-12 /NE SUR BK/PG: 954/386 FF PT TR B/ TR $417,000 KUHNS, CRAIG A& JULIE K MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATION SYSTEMS INC LT 32 THORNBROOK PLAT NO 1 $417,000 FORREST, BRIAN K & MELANIE D STIFEL BANK & TRUST LT 227 THORNBROOK PLAT NO 7 $415,150 FLEMING, MATTHEW & PAULA FIRST NATIONAL BANK & TRUST CO LT 63 THORNBROOK PLAT NO 3 $415,000 GARMAN, DAVID W & CAROL J MID AMERICA MORTGAGE SERVICES INC STR 32-49-13 /NE/NW $415,000 SCOTT, LOUIS D & VICKY MID AMERICA MORTGAGE SERVICES INC STR 31-48-11 /W/NE SUR BK/PG: 1772/628 AC 10.000 $410,000 FOOTE, BRYAN BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK LT 213 THORNBROOK PLAT NO 7 $390,000 POTTER, JOHN S & CHERYL L CENTRAL BANK OF LAKE OZARKS LT 26 BROOKFIELD ESTATES PLAT 3 $385,650 POPE, LARRY & KRISTA FIRST NATIONAL BANK & TRUST CO LT 468 THORNBROOK PLAT NO 13 $383,000 COOK FAMILY TRUST BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK STR 30-48-11 /NE SUR BK/PG: 1561/27 AC 12.090 $381,000 PERKEY, RODNEY & CHRISTINA BANK OF MISSOURI THE STR 19-48-11 /SW $380,000 BRASELTON, FREDRICK D & DIANE M BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK STR 6-47-13 /N SUR BK/PG: 1118/856 FF TRACT 24D $376,000 MOLLER, CHAD T & SHERRY L FIRST NATIONAL BANK & TRUST CO LT 15 STRATFORD CHASE $371,000 THAKKAR, ANUP & NEELA PREMIER BANK LT 452 THORNBROOK PLAT NO 13 STR 20-51-13 /W/SW SUR BK/PG: 3142/88 AC 29.880 $288,000 RAETZ, JEFFREY W & JUDY R BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK LT 168 HERITAGE ESTATES PLAT NO 1 $362,500 HASSEMER, MARK & ELAINE MID AMERICA MORTGAGE SERVICES INC LT 102 HINKSON RIDGE PLAT 1 $285,400 LAZINGER, MAXWELL LAZINGER CARPE DIEM TRUST THE BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK LT 211 SPRING CREEK PLAT 2 $360,000 TANZEY, S STEVEN & LAURA A FIRST NATIONAL BANK & TRUST CO LT 135 HERITAGE ESTATES PLAT NO 1 $285,000 JOHNSON, LENWORTH N & PATRICIA J BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK LT 1064 HIGHLANDS PLAT 10A $330,000 WASHER, GLENN A & KAREN E MISSOURI CREDIT UNION LT 306 THORNBROOK PLAT NO 9 $285,000 ISENHART, RONALD G JR & SHERYL D FIRST FINANCIAL CREDIT UNION LT 3 BLACKBERRY BEND SUB PLAT 1 $325,600 FULLER, MELINDA A & CHRISTOPHER BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK LT 220 SPRING CREEK PLAT 2 $281,000 BRODERSEN, MATTHEW & KARLA MISSOURI CREDIT UNION STR 24-49-14 /SE $314,400 REED, CHRISTOPHER S & JENNIFER D CALLAWAY BANK THE STR 27-49-14 /SW SUR BK/PG: 903/320 AC 10.02 $312,000 KIRBY, JOHN S & ELIZABETH J BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK LT 1443 HIGHLANDS PLAT 14-A $312,000 KIRBY, ELIZABETH J BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK LT 1443 HIGHLANDS PLAT 14-A $311,500 OVERTON, KEITH & JENNIFER BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK STR 29-49-14 /NW/SW $311,000 JENNE, MATTHEW D & MELINDA J U S BANK LT 16 WOODRAIL SUB PLAT 8 $308,100 MAGSAMEN, RONALD J FIRST NATIONAL BANK & TRUST CO LT 56 BEDFORD WALK PLAT 8 $304,950 MILYO, JEFFREY D & LYNN K FIRST NATIONAL BANK & TRUST CO LT 33 THORNBROOK PLAT NO 1 $304,500 COEN, WILLIAM & JOETTA FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF AUDRAIN COUNTY LT 202 BLUFF CREEK ESTATES PLAT 2-A $300,000 HAKE, MATTHEW THOMAS & KAY ELCAN BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK LT 1422 HIGHLANDS PLAT 14-B THE $300,000 GENTRY, ERIC G BANK OF MISSOURI THE LT 146 HERITAGE ESTATES PLAT NO 1 $300,000 STRIEGEL, RUTH A BANK OF MISSOURI THE LT 146 HERITAGE ESTATES PLAT NO 1 $290,000 TIMBROOK, DANIEL A & ASLISHA M F & M BANK & TRUST CO $277,100 DUNCAN, DRUE W & ELIZABETH S METLIFE BANK LT 134 SPRING CREEK PLAT 1 $276,000 BECKER, MARY C & MARY R FIRST NATIONAL BANK & TRUST CO STR 13-47-13 /NW SUR BK/PG: 1527/545 AC 3.500 $272,000 WARD, GARY & SANDRA HAWTHORN BANK LT 32 BLUEGRASS SOUTH ESTATES $271,000 SINGLETON, EDWARD & LORA NELSON FIRST NATIONAL BANK & TRUST CO LT 247 THORNBROOK PLAT NO 7 $270,000 BALL, KRISTOFER & KARRI U S BANK LT 105 CASCADES PLAT 1 THE $269,050 KESPOHL, CHRISTOPHER L & JESSICA M JEFFERSON BANK OF MISSOURI LT 107 WEST LAWN SUBDIVISION PLAT 2 $259,182 MCKENZIE, RYAN N & AMY N PRIMARY RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INC LT 229 WESTCLIFF PLAT 2 $256,000 VROOMAN, ANDREW C & GERRI L AMTRUST BANK LT 102 CASCADES PLAT 1 THE $253,900 NEIL, JULIE A & TRAVIS K FIRST NATIONAL BANK & TRUST CO LT 68 LONGVIEW SUB PLAT 1 $251,275 LINDELL, EVERETT & EVELYN MORTGAGE ELECTRONIC REGISTRATION SYSTEMS INC LT 100 LAKE WOODRAIL SUB PLAT 8 $250,000 BONDERER, AUGUST B & MELISSA K BOONE COUNTY NATIONAL BANK STR 30-46-12 /E/NW 31 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com PUBLIC RECORD 32 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com SPECIAL SECTION | marketing & promotion Vianello ... continued from Page 29 ment you create should reinforce what you want attendees to walk away knowing about your company and their experience with you. Everything in the booth should be a reflection of the image you have built for your business, including the personnel who staff it. According to The Center for Exhibit Industry Research, 80 percent of what visitors remember most about their visit to a trade show booth is their interaction with the exhibit staff. This is why it is essential to provide comprehensive training for your exhibit team before the show. Tell your booth personnel why this particular show was chosen and its role in the firm’s marketing strategy. Other things to share: • The specific selling goals for the show • Why they were selected to make this a successful show • The kinds of people likely to arrive, and the names of specific target prospects • Features and benefits of products on display — especially the solutions those products have provided to current customers • How to answer the most common questions • Knowledge about competitors — particularly those at the show One key to long-term success from trade shows that is often overlooked is prompt followup. Showcase exhibitors often miss important leads because they have no lead development strategy. According to CEIR, as many as 80 per- cent of trade show leads never receive any form of follow-up at all. So create a plan for following up on leads before attending the show. Discuss with your team the qualifications of ideal prospects. Your staff should be able to easily identify qualified leads and differentiate them from those on which they should not spend a lot of time. Designate exactly who will follow up on leads and how it will be done. Write and prepare all follow-up letters and information packets ahead of time so they can be sent as soon as you return to the office. Plan to pick up the phone, mail letters or information or set an appointment within a few days of the event. Given the cost of entry fees, the cost of developing a great exhibit and the manpower expense to run it, immediate lead follow-up is just good business sense. After the show, assess how well you attained each of your pre-show goals. Make decisions for future show participation. Will you exhibit again? Was your booth in a good location? What changes in strategy are indicated? Keep a file of your observations and decisions. It will help you as you decide which shows are worthy of a return visit and what exhibit tactics are worth trying again. v Lili Vianello is President of Visionworks Marketing & Communications, a Columbia-based full-service advertising, marketing and public relations firm. Contributions to this article were made by Visionworks staff members. Visit them online at www.visionworks.com. 6 # Use fabric to create your environment. Wrap lightweight structures with material, drape tables and pedestals and/or use fabric for a backdrop. This is an inexpensive way to add color and texture to your booth. 7 # Partner with another business to provide the elements you need for your booth. Use their furniture, carpet, plants or a flat-screen TV, and offer them signage in your booth in return. 8 # Don’t fill your booth with papers that are just going to get tossed out later. Limit literature and giveaways to potential customers that are sincerely interested in your business. Give potential customers a place to sign up for more information, then follow up and/or send something to them at a later date. 9 # Use recycled materials. Update your past displays by adding on to them, covering them with a different material or using them differently. Also look into recycled carpet, paneling and other materials to create a one-of-a-kind look. Make use of existing marketing materials such as television or radio spots. Play them in the background for interest and reinforcement of your product/service. Look for a used trade show display instead of buying new. A good place to start is www.findstuff.com. 10 # Think ahead when ordering display items for your booth. Will you be able to use them later in your office or showroom? Licenses issued in January, includes ownership changes A Better Insurance Agency Jeffrey S. O’Rourke 573-289-7840 111 E. Broadway, Ste. 221 Insurance sales Bach-Yager Funeral Chapel John W. Bach, III 573-441-2932 1610 N. Garth Ave. Funeral home Ballroom Academy of Columbia Amanda Jean Buchanan 3910 Peachtree Dr. Ballroom dancing Bu Ting Xi Kung Fu Academy Gregory N. Butler 573-489-9150 315 N. Eighth St. Martial arts instruction Carlito’s Cabo Sara Y. Hvaco 573-443-6370 12 E. Business Loop 70 Restaurant Cash N-A Flash Leigh Borage 573-449-2400 1408 I-70 Drive Southwest, Ste. 106 Cash advances and income tax preparation Cherry Street Artisan/Parkade Laurie E. McAllister 573-817-3274 601 Business Loop 70W Coffee kiosk Columbia Condo Management, LLC Sarah Jo Melchert 573-446-6825 1412 I-70 Drive Southwest, Ste. 4 Condo management Direct Freight/Trucker Search Jonathan Paul Gabrielson 573-442-6114 409 Building 4, Vandiver Dr., Ste. 204 Freight load matching and trucker resumes Dunn Bros Coffee Andrew Brian Vercelli 573-446-4122 1412 Forum Blvd., Ste. 135 Coffee shop EZ Loan Services Joseph L. Rotunda 512-314-3465 212 E. Business Loop 70 Payday and consumer loans Gumball Galleria, Inc. Richard N. Savaiano 785-836-3346 2300 Bernadette Dr. Candy vending Hudson Hair Studio Trisa Lynn Hudson 573-443-0158 3711 Santiago Dr. Beauty salon Tiger Zou, LLC Paul E. Stephenson 573-268-6423 3200 Penn Terrace, Ste. 121 Pub and grill JJ’s Cafe, LLC James E. Clayborn 573-682-0657 600 Business Loop 70W Restaurant Triple Loop Housewares, LLC Holly E. Smith-Berry 573-442-2742 2201 Chapel Plaza Ct., Ste. 104 Sales, marketing and logistics Kobe Japanese Steak House Simon & JJE Corp. 573-441-2341 2531 Broadway Bluffs Dr. Restaurant and bar Verlin Uptergrove Agency Verlin Uptergrove 573-445-4680 2000 Forum Blvd., Ste. 2 Insurance agency Mexico Finns & Feathers, LLC Theresa Ridgway 3302 Broadway Business Park Ct., Ste. H Pet store Walk-In Tubs of Mid-Missouri Joshua M. Hill 573-234-2005 1603 Chapel Hill Rd., Ste. 103 Medical equipment Paysmart, LLC Walter Capell 573-445-5535 3400 Buttonwood Dr., Ste. B Payroll company Webgate, LLC Jakub Sarnecki 573-819-0707 3315 Berrywood Dr., Ste. 103 Website design Providence Bank Providence Bank 573-442-6023 8 N. Fifth St. Bank Wild Bird Center Bruce R. Bynam 573-449-8777 2300 Bernadette Dr. Retail backyard birding store Rick’s Taxi Rickey Carl Lacy 1120 Wilkes Blvd. Taxi service Women’s Shoe Outlet Andrea C. Evans 573-777-6999 601 Business Loop 70W Retail Shoes Schrader Automotive James M. Schrader 573-449-6680 1000 Big Bear Blvd., Ste. B Auto repair Shelter Enterprises, LLC Shelter Insurance Companies 573-214-4735 1817 W. Broadway Real estate management Spirit of Missouri Elite Tricia Scholes 573-442-8677 3906 Peachtree Dr., Ste. A Cheer and gymnastic instruction Studio 209 Cheryl L. Freeman 601 Business Loop 70W, Ste. 209 Beauty salon The Flying Cow Construction Co. Michael J. Keevins 573-489-0185 903 University Ave. General contractor The State Group Industrial The State Group Industrial 573-814-0882 6700 Stephens Station Rd., Ste. 107 Electrical construction supervision NEW BUSINESS page sponsored by: 1 Affordable Insurance Agency Dan Burks 573-449-1995 1106 I-70 Drive Southwest Insurance agency 63 Auto Sales Moez B. Aschi 573-449-5544 922 Business Loop 70E Used auto sales Ingredient Columbia, LLC Kent A. Coxe 573-442-1502 304 S. Ninth St., Ste. 101 Restaurant and bar Mustard Seed Fair Trade, Inc. Jessica Ann Linneman 573-449-6166 25 S. Ninth St. Handcrafted items Tin Can Tavern & Grille Tin Can Columbia, LLC 220 S. Eighth St. Restaurant and bar Vespa of Columbia Steven J. Tuchschmidt 573-424-9482 823 E. Broadway Retail scooter shop 33 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com NEW BUSINESS LICENSES 34 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com Video gaming fascination, from female perspective By Heath Hooper 2IIHUHG$W$XFWLRQ &RPPHUFLDO3URSHUW\=RQHG& LOCATION � LOCATION � LOCATION SATURDAY • 2/28/09 • 10 AM 7HUPV2I 3XUFKDVH3ULFH 'RZQ'D\2I $XFWLRQ%DODQFH 'XH:LWKLQ'D\V%X\HUV )HH$SSOLHG7R)LQDO%LG %XVLQHVV/RRS:HVW³&ROXPELD 6T)W/RW 'DLO\7UDIÀF&RXQW3HU&HQVXV &ORVH3UR[LPLW\7R,:LWK(DV\$FFHVV *UHDW/RFDWLRQ:LWK(QGOHVVSRVVLELOLWLHV 3RWHQWLDO)RU0XOWL%XVLQHVVHV &ORVH7R3DUNDGH3OD]D5XVN5HKDELOLWDWLRQ %DQNV)RRG0RUH $WWHUEHUU\$XFWLRQ5HDOW\&R//& 2U9LVLWZZZDWWHUEHUU\DXFWLRQFRP The “boys only” atmosphere of video game culture is quickly vanishing. Although men still tend to be regarded as the biggest demographic for gamers, the pastime has been opened up to everyone by new devices and modes of play. And though recent developments have brought new women into the fold, many say there’s always been room for both genders. Nearly 40 percent of video game players are female, and they’re spending an average of 7.4 hours a week playing, according to the Entertainment Software Association. Jessica Donahoe, 24, an assistant manager at a local game store, has been a gamer for years. “I got a Super Nintendo for my 10th birthday, and Super Mario was a fantastic game,” she said. “It was something that I was good at, that was entertaining and that gave me something to talk about with other kids my age.” Donahoe says she’s not a stereotypical female gamer. “I have systems other than the Wii and the DS, which I think is what most people think of when they hear that someone is female and a gamer,” she said, referring to the Nintendo console and handheld systems. While she is a fan of the DS, her favorite system is Microsoft’s Xbox 360. “It seems to have the most games and the greatest variety of games,” she said. “More of the Triple-A titles come out exclusive to 360. The online service is second to none.” A system like the Wii tends to appeal to a more casual player with more games consisting of a series of mini-games that can be played in short bursts. “There’s nothing wrong with that,” Donahoe said. “It’s just not where my tastes run.” Donahoe said the gaming experience tends to split more along experience lines than gender. “I think that new gamers tend to be the ones that Nintendo is going for and what they’re making products to appeal to, and that once people have been involved with video games for a little while they start to seek out a richer experience, something more equivalent to watching a movie or reading a book,” she said. Donahoe prefers role-playing games, action titles and first-person shooters like “Call of Duty 4,” where players take on the role of modernday soldiers. For casual experiences, she prefers puzzle games like “Luxor,” “Bejeweled” and “Puzzle Quest,” which combine both role playing and puzzle elements. Massively multiplayer online role-playing games, which Donahoe said have very broad appeal, have been a major factor in getting more women into gaming. Of the 300 pre-orders at her store for the latest installment of the “World of Warcraft” franchise, a fantasy online role-playing game with millions of devoted players, almost half were from female players. “The only customers that I know that are maniacs about the game (are) all female, hundred percent,” she said. Video games go mainstream An annual survey by the video game industry’s trade industry released in July found that women age 18 or older represent a significantly greater portion of the game-playing population (33 percent) than boys age 17 or younger (18 percent) Other major findings: 65 percent of American households play computer and video games; 38 percent of American homes have a video game console; the average game player is 35 years old; one out of four gamers are over age 50; 41 percent of Americans expect to purchase one or more games this year.The new research also shows how involved parents are in the way their children buy, rent and play games: 94 percent of parents are present when games are purchased or rented; 88 percent of parents report always or sometimes monitoring the games their children play; and 63 percent of parents believe games are a positive part of their children’s lives. Source: Entertainment Software Association, The 2008 Essential Facts About the Computer and Video Game Industry A Whole New World Emily Holt, 29, was one of those customers. She and her husband, Jerry, joined hundreds of fans lined up at midnight on a chilly November night to be among the first to purchase the third expansion of the game, in which players create fantasy characters to do battle with other human and computer characters. Holt, a stay-at-home mom, has been playing the game since 2005. “For me it was either join my husband or hate the game and hate him playing it,” she said. “And I loved it. As soon as I started playing I was like, ‘Why have I not been playing this the whole time?’” It’s not an unusual starting point for women gamers, Donahoe said: women getting into gaming because their partners play, Donahoe said. Donahoe herself got into the first-person shooter “Call of Duty 4,” where players take on the role of a modern-day soldier, by watching her boyfriend. By the time she started playing multiplayer on her own, she knew all of the game’s maps and strategies. Her frustration with her husband for ignoring her soon became frustration with him for taking up all the household computer time. Buying a second computer solved that problem. “I dumped $1,600 to stop the marital feud,” Jerry said. “And it’s been bliss ever since,” Emily replied. Photo by Jennifer Kettler On the DS, Sharp is a fan of role-playing and life-simulation games such as “Harvest Moon” and “Animal Crossing” along with old favorites like “Tetris.” But it’s the system’s more user-friendly titles like “brain-training” and puzzle games, which are drawing in the new players, which Sharp said is a positive development. But social acceptability brings its own issues, she said. Sharp said she disliked game companies’ use of body-image hang-ups, for instance, to promote exercise titles. “I find that a little insulting,” Sharp said. “I think it’s pretty unfortunate.” More than just a game. Donahoe said she is looking forward to the increased abilities of systems, such as the Xbox 360’s partnership with Netflix, which will allow people with both Xbox Live and Netflix to download movies to their systems. It’s partly the social aspects that are drawing more people to the gaming world, at least in terms of the changes Donahoe has seen over the past 14 years. “More people are involved,” she said. There’s no longer as much of a stigma attached to being a gamer. Older generations are more willing to give games a fair hearing. Sharp advised those curious about video games to just to get out there and play. “Don’t be afraid to play kid games; don’t be afraid to explore different things you think might be silly,” Sharp said. For new players shy about picking up a controller for fear of not excelling, Donahoe suggested starting out with something non-competitive such as the quirky hit “Katamari Damacy” or a game that can be played cooperatively. “Learn as much as you can before you try something, and have a good footing on which to start,” she said. Ask questions, either from a gamer in their lives or from video game store employees, and embrace not knowing. As Sharp puts it: “It’s all about trying it out, seeing what you’re good at, seeing what you like.” v 35 February 7, 2009 Columbia Business Times | ColumbiaBusinessTimes.com The Wii has been successful in bringing new gamHolt came to gaming relatively late in life, starting after she graduated from high school. “I think my ers into the fold, Winter said. “My mom is even playing,” she said. “My grandma boyfriend at the time was playing Everquest,” another online role-playing game, she said. “It looked fun, and bought one to do exercise. We have family get-togethers, and they’re bowling on Wii.” I made a character, and I just got into it.” The ease of accessibility and play has made it an “World of Warcraft’s” social aspect pulls her in, she said, and she feels obligated to play when other mem- easy point of entry, Winter said. Michelle Sharp, 24, said she doesn’t necessarily debers of her online team are playing. Holt, who plays when her 1- and 3-year-old chil- fine herself as a gamer. But the University of Missouri dren are snoozing, said the game is a soothing ending student, who also works at a game store, said the term now certainly applies across genders. to pressure-filled days. “It’s more socially acceptable for women to be gam“I put my kids to bed, and it’s my time,” she said. “It’s an excellent escape from a day of diapers and ers,” Sharp said. Sharp said she used to watch her step-siblings play screaming.” Stephanie Winter, 19, and Cristina Johnson, 20, when she was little but didn’t game much between both students at the University of Missouri, were her days playing Mario on her Super Nintendo and also at the November release. Both have been playing her current Nintendo DS and 360. She started slowly getting back into gaming, games since they were children: Winter started out on the Sega Genesis while Johnson played both Nintendo playing fighting games with her boyfriend. It was and computer games. Winter and Johnson agreed the gender gap had been largely bridged in gaming. Growing up, the pair said games were largely something boys played. “But I played with the boys, so it didn’t matter,” Winter said. “I think the boys like to think that it’s still the boys club.” Both play all female characters in “World of Warcraft.” “I tried one (male character),” Johnson said, but she didn’t like the way the character shaped up. Getting hit on by other female characters was also awkward, she added. Roughly a third Caitlin Whiting’s WOW chararacter, “Red Light,” visits the “Valley of Wisdom” in the city of “Orgrimmar.” of their guild, or online team, is female, and the women tend to play more a far cry from her high school gaming experiences, than the men, they said. Johnson said she appreciated where her then-boyfriend ignored Sharp while playthe fact she could play a female warrior without deal- ing Playstation 2. “He wasn’t very nice anyway,” she said. ing with bias. Getting beyond her high school experiences, Sharp picked up an Xbox 360 after discovering her love of Family-Friendly Gaming has become much more mainstream these music games like “Guitar Hero” and “Rock Band.” “I like games that I can play with other people,” she days, Holt said, which she attributes both to MMORPGs said of her preferences. and a generation that grew up with games. Sharp also had a Wii but got rid of it. “Most of the The new generation of hardware has also had an games that were on it, I just wasn’t interested in,” she impact, she said. In addition to their computers, Holt said the family said. But that’s not true of Nintendo’s other system, the also owns a Wii. “I play Wii Fit,” Holt said. “Not so much for the game aspect but for the exercise aspect.” take-along DS. “I could play it for hours, but I’m trying to do my homework,” she says of the handheld system.