Annex N - Land Use and Tenure Baseline Report
Transcription
Annex N - Land Use and Tenure Baseline Report
October 2015 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT Annex N - Land Use and Tenure Baseline Report REPORT Submitted to: Teck Coal Limited Suite 1000, 205 - 9th Avenue SE Calgary, AB T2G 0R3Teck Report Number: 1213490003/R31 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Executive Summary Teck Coal Limited is proposing an extension to the existing Elkview Operations in the East Kootenay Region of southeastern British Columbia (Figure N-1). The extension of Elkview Operations is referred to as the Baldy Ridge Extension Project and includes the extension of existing mining areas, waste rock spoils, and storage facilities for tailings and coarse coal refuse. The Baldy Ridge Extension Project will also require the development of new waste rock spoils, the relocation of existing infrastructure, and development of water quality treatment facilities based on the Elk Valley Water Quality Plan recommendations. The estimated total area of disturbance is approximately 2,665 ha of which 763 ha are outside of the current C-2 permit boundary and 1,901 ha are within the current C-2 permit boundary. The main area of Elkview Operations is bounded by the Elk River to the west, Erickson and Harmer creeks to the east, and Michel Creek to the south. Highway #3 (Crowsnest Highway) follows Michel Creek along the western and southern sides of Elkview Operations. The primary land use activities occurring within the area are: coal mining, recreation, tourism and forestry. The Elkview Operations property is located on 25,500 ha of privately owned land (fee simple) in the front ranges of the Rocky Mountains, adjacent to the community of Sparwood, British Columbia. The Baldy Ridge Extension Project is subject to review under the British Columbia Environmental Assessment Act, as outlined in the Baldy Ridge Extension Project Application Information Requirements (BC EAO 2015). This baseline report forms Annex N of the Environmental Assessment Certificate Application being prepared to meet the requirements of the British Columbia Environmental Assessment Act. This baseline study for the Baldy Ridge Extension Project describes tenures and current land and resource use activities occurring in the area potentially affected by the Project and in the surrounding region. The local study area for land use and tenure is consistent with the terrestrial local study area and follows rivers, watersheds and topographic features, where appropriate. The regional study area also includes the British Columbia communities of Sparwood, Elkford and Fernie, as well as the unincorporated settlements (e.g., Hosmer) and rural areas surrounding these communities. Although Crowsnest Pass is not included within the terrestrial regional study area boundary, its residents visit the Elk Valley for recreational and hunting purposes so this area has been included in the regional study area too. Secondary research included a review of existing land ownership and tenure information, local, regional and provincial land use plans, agricultural lands, recreation and tourism, access management, mining, forestry, gas activities, wildlife harvesting and management information. Primary information was collected through mapping sessions with user group representatives held in Sparwood and Crowsnest Pass in 2013 to determine focal areas in the regional study area and local study area respectively, for hunting, fishing, and motorized and nonmotorized recreation and tourism. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 i 5600000 YUK O N TE RRI TO RY Invermere 660000 710000 NO RT HW ES T TE RRI TO RI ES ! BRI TI SH CO L UM BI A ³ Longview R RIV E EL K CANADA ! 5600000 610000 ALB ERTA Project Location Fording River Operations R FO W HI T E RIV E R 5550000 IVE Greenhills Operations GR R 5550000 DIN U N IT E D S TATE S O F A ME R I C A Elkford ! IE LUS S 43 R Line Creek Operations BULL RIVE R E R RIV V U Ä Ã 22 Ä Ã _ ^ Elkview Operations ! A LB E R TA Ä Ã 3 Coleman ! Blairmore OLDMAN RESERVOIR ! ! Hosmer O KO TE ! VE Cranbrook RI ! Y NA Coal Mountain Operations Fernie Ä Ã ! Elko 610000 ! _ ^ CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY PROJECT LOCATION CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY 660000 710000 25 BRITISH COLUMBIA - ALBERTA BORDER FIRST NATIONS RESERVE PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA PROJECT WATERBODY Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE COAL MINING OPERATION WATERCOURSE REFERENCE ! 3 Wardner ! LEGEND Pincher Creek ! Beaver Mines R I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\SharedFigures\B-Shared-001-GIS-GeneralProjectLocation.mxd 5500000 95A Sparwood 5500000 B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A TITLE 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT GENERAL LOCATION OF THE PROPOSED PROJECT PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW MH 12-1349-0013 07 Oct. 2013 DR 05 Aug. 2014 LE 31 Aug. 2015 MH 31 Aug. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N-1 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT The key results from the land use and tenure baseline assessment are as follows: The Baldy Ridge Extension Project is located on fee simple land owned by Teck Coal Limited and most of the Baldy Ridge Extension Project footprint overlaps with the District of Sparwood. The land is zoned Extraction Industrial, which provides for mineral extraction and processing of extracted minerals. The remainder of the Baldy Ridge Extension Project footprint and surrounding areas overlaps with the Regional District of East Kootenay and is zoned as Rural Resource under the Elk Valley Zoning Bylaw No. 829. The Baldy Ridge Extension Project footprint is situated on private lands that are not subject to provincial land use plans. Crown land nearest to the Baldy Ridge Extension Project is situated within the Coal Enhanced Resource Development Zone of the Kootenay-Boundary Land Resource Management Plan Implementation Strategy, which states that there is an assurance of long-term security of access and tenures to this land for coal mining exploration and development purposes. There are a number of provincial parks in the region but none overlaps with the Baldy Ridge Extension Project footprint. Livestock and forage production characterizes agriculture in the Elk Valley and in 2011, an estimated 73% of the Agricultural Land Reserve designated land in the Elk Valley was used for natural pasture/rangeland or was forested. Agricultural Land Reserve land is concentrated along Highway #43 between Sparwood and Elkford. Two range tenures exist to the west and to the east of the Baldy Ridge Extension Project. Elkview Operations is surrounded by a No Unauthorized Entry Area implemented by Teck Coal Limited to maintain public and worker safety at and near the existing operation. Permission is needed to enter this No Unauthorized Entry Area and access is controlled by Elkview Operations. Signs are posted at potential entry points to the No Unauthorized Entry Area, and changes or updates to the No Unauthorized Entry Area are advertised regularly in local papers and in the annual BC Hunting and Trapping Regulations Synopsis. Coal licences held by NWP Coal Canada Ltd. (subsidiary of Jameson Resources Ltd.) are located directly to the east of Elkview Operations. Coal licences held by CanAus Coal Limited (subsidiary of CoalMont Pty Ltd.) on Crown land are located to the southeast on the other side of Highway #3. The federal government owned Dominion Coal Block 73 is located approximately 6.5 km south of the Baldy Ridge Extension Project. For all of Teck Coal Limited’s mining operations, environmental considerations are based on the premise that mining is a temporary use of the land and that all disturbed lands will be reclaimed to be fully productive post-closure landscapes. Elkview Operations strives to reclaim surface disturbances in a timely manner and to re-establish a sustainable, diverse, functional landscape that is greater than or equal to the capability/productivity that existed prior to mining (Teck 2014a). As part of Teck’s broader commitment to sustainability, in October 2013 Teck Coal Limited announced the purchase of three blocks of land from Tembec Industries Inc. in British Columbia, totaling approximately 7,150 ha. The intended use of this land is for the protection of key wildlife and fish habitat in the Elk River Valley and Flathead River Valley. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 iii BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Surrounding Elkview Operations is Managed Forest 471. Under an agreement with Teck Coal Limited, Canfor Corporation has the exclusive right (in perpetuity) to harvest, sell, process or dispose of all timber on Managed Forest 471 land. Land within the boundaries of Managed Forest 471 is owned by Teck Coal Limited including the lands around Elkview Operations. Canfor Corporation’s rights are subject to Teck Coal Limited’s dominant user rights to explore for minerals, to conduct mining and drilling operations and to use or remove minor amounts of certain areas from Managed Forest 471 land. Managed Forest 482 is located to the north and south of Elk VO. Tembec completed the sales of a total of 49,000 ha of land from Managed Forest 27 to Jemi Fibre Corporation in 2014. These lands now comprise Managed Forest 482. Managed Forest 27 currently consists of approximately 850 ha located near St. Mary’s Lake, Morrissey, and between Sparwood and Fernie. A petroleum title belonging to Apache Canada Ltd. covers the southern end of Elkview Operations (referred to as the Mist Mountain project). There has been no recent development by Apache on its Mist Mountain project, and it is not anticipated that development will occur in the near future. Apache acquired its rights when this company purchased British Petroleum’s Canadian assets in 2010. Elkview Operations footprint overlaps with portions of the following Registered Trapline areas, TR0423T021, TR0423T023, and TR0423T022. There was no registered activity on trapline TR0423T022 and TR0423T021 between 2008 and 2012, while TR0423T023 recorded five beaver, one coyote and three marten in 2010. Prior to 2010, 2002 was the last year of reported activity for TR0423T023. Although TR0423T021 reported consistent trapping activity prior to 2008, there has been no recorded activity for TR0423T022 since 1986. Gravel roads along Grave and Harmer Creeks are located on private lands owned by Teck Coal Limited and provide access to areas north of Elkview Operations. There is no public road access into the Erickson Valley from either Harmer Creek or from the southern end of Elkview Operations. To the east, the Alexander Creek Access Management Area is a high use area for all-terrain vehicle riding and snowmobiling in the Elk Valley. Riders from Alberta access the area using Deadman’s Pass, North Fork Pass and Racehorse Pass. Trails in the Alexander Creek Access Management Area connect with Grave Creek in the north. Tourism in the Elk Valley peaks during the winter season, with its secondary peak occurring in summer. The area attracts a substantial number of weekend visitors and the demand for seasonal residences in the Elk Valley is primarily driven by Alberta residents. Fernie Alpine Resort is 5 km from downtown Fernie and is the centrepiece for winter recreation and tourism in the local area. Mountain biking, hunting and angling along the Elk River and Michel Creek are important draws in the summer and fall months. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 iv BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Study Limitations Golder Associates Ltd. (Golder) has prepared this document in a manner consistent with that level of care and skill ordinarily exercised by members of the engineering and science professions currently practicing under similar conditions in the jurisdiction in which the services are provided, subject to the time limits and physical constraints applicable to this document. No warranty, express or implied, is made. This document, including all text, data, tables, plans, figures, drawings, and other documents contained herein, has been prepared by Golder for the sole use of Teck Coal Limited (Teck) [Elkview Operations] and regulatory agencies, in decision-making regarding Teck’s operations. It represents Golder’s professional judgment based on the knowledge and information available at the time of completion, and is not applicable to any other project or site location. Golder is not responsible for any unauthorized use or modification of this document. Other parties may not rely on this document without the written permission of Golder. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 v BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Table of Contents N1.0 OVERVIEW....................................................................................................................................................................... 1 N1.1 Overview.............................................................................................................................................................. 1 N1.2 Purpose ............................................................................................................................................................... 3 N1.3 Scope .................................................................................................................................................................. 3 N2.0 STUDY AREA ................................................................................................................................................................... 4 N2.1 Regional Study Area ............................................................................................................................................ 4 N2.2 Local Study Area ................................................................................................................................................. 4 N3.0 METHODS ........................................................................................................................................................................ 7 N3.1 Review of Existing Information ............................................................................................................................ 7 N3.2 User Group Mapping Sessions ............................................................................................................................ 7 N3.3 Data Analysis and Reporting ............................................................................................................................... 8 N4.0 RESULTS ......................................................................................................................................................................... 9 N4.1 Land Use Plans and Designations ....................................................................................................................... 9 N4.1.1 Regional Study Area ...................................................................................................................................... 9 N4.1.2 Local Study Area .......................................................................................................................................... 15 N4.2 Land Uses, Tenures and Focal Areas ............................................................................................................... 18 N4.2.1 Access ......................................................................................................................................................... 18 N4.2.2 Parks and Protected Areas .......................................................................................................................... 20 N4.2.3 Agriculture .................................................................................................................................................... 22 N4.2.4 Coal and Mineral Exploration and Mining..................................................................................................... 23 N4.2.5 Forestry ........................................................................................................................................................ 29 N4.2.6 Oil and Gas Development ............................................................................................................................ 35 N4.2.7 Non-Timber Forest Products ........................................................................................................................ 38 N4.2.8 Wildlife and Fish Harvesting ......................................................................................................................... 39 N4.2.9 Outdoor Recreation and Tourism ................................................................................................................. 49 October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 vi BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N5.0 SUMMARY ..................................................................................................................................................................... 56 N6.0 CLOSURE ...................................................................................................................................................................... 58 N7.0 REFERENCES ............................................................................................................................................................... 59 N7.1 Acts and Regulations ......................................................................................................................................... 68 N8.0 GLOSSARY .................................................................................................................................................................... 69 TABLES Table N3.2-1 User Group Mapping Session Participants Held December 11 and 12, 2013 ............................................... 8 Table N4.2-1 Provincial Park Visitors ................................................................................................................................ 22 Table N4.2-2 Teck Mines in the Regional Study Area ....................................................................................................... 24 Table N4.2-3 Summary of Areas Disturbed and Reclaimed Before December 31, 2013 .................................................. 26 Table N4.2-4 Forestry Requirements on Crown and Private Land in British Columbia ..................................................... 29 FIGURES Figure N-1 General Location of the Proposed Project ..................................................................................................... ii Figure N1.1-1 Project Footprint and Existing Elkview Operations ........................................................................................ 2 Figure N2.1-1 Land Use and Tenure Regional Study Area and Communities ..................................................................... 5 Figure N2.2-1 Land Use and Tenure Local Study Area ........................................................................................................ 6 Figure N4.1-1 Southern Rocky Mountain Management Plan ............................................................................................. 11 Figure N4.1-2 Kootenay-Boundary Land Use Plan ............................................................................................................ 12 Figure N4.1-3 Agricultural Land Reserve Areas ................................................................................................................. 14 Figure N4.1-4 Old Growth Management Areas in the Local Study Area ............................................................................ 16 Figure N4.1-5 Land Use Zoning in the Local Study Area ................................................................................................... 17 Figure N4.2-1 No Unauthorized Entry Area ........................................................................................................................ 19 Figure N4.2-2 Parks and Protected Areas in the Regional Study Area .............................................................................. 21 Figure N4.2-3 Land Ownership, Mineral Claims and Coal Tenures in the Local Study Area.............................................. 25 Figure N4.2-4 Crown Forest Land Base in the Regional Study Area ................................................................................. 30 Figure N4.2-5 Crown Forest Land Base in the Local Study Area ....................................................................................... 33 Figure N4.2-6 Canfor Harvests in the Local Study Area ..................................................................................................... 34 Figure N4.2-7 Gas Wells in the Regional Study Area ......................................................................................................... 36 Figure N4.2-8 Gas Wells in the Local Study Area .............................................................................................................. 37 Figure N4.2-9 Guide Tenures and Limited Entry Hunting in the Regional Study Area ....................................................... 41 Figure N4.2-10 Trapline Tenures in the Regional Study Area .............................................................................................. 45 October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 vii BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Figure N4.2-11 Hunting in the Local Study Area .................................................................................................................. 47 Figure N4.2-12 Trapline Tenures in the Local Study Area.................................................................................................... 48 Figure N4.2-13 Recreation Trails and Sites in the Regional Study Area .............................................................................. 50 Figure N4.2-14 Recreation Trails and Sites in the Local Study Area .................................................................................... 51 APPENDICES APPENDIX N.I User Group Mapping Session Seasonal Calendars APPENDIX N.II Hunting and Trapping Seasons for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 APPENDIX N.III Hunting Data for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 APPENDIX N.IV Trapping Activity for Local Study Area October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 viii BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS Acronym/Abbreviation Definition AAC annual allowable cut ALR Agricultural Land Reserve Altitude Altitude Resources Inc. ATV all-terrain vehicle BC British Columbia BC EAO British Columbia Environmental Assessment Office BCEAA British Columbia Environmental Assessment Act BCWF British Columbia Wildlife Federation BSE bovine spongiform encephalopathy Canfor Canfor Corporation CMO Coal Mountain Operations COI communities of interest e.g. for example EA environmental assessment EAC Environmental Assessment Certificate EKB East Kootenay Basin Elan Elan Coal Ltd. ERDZ Enhanced Resource Development Zone EVO Elkview Operations FLNRO Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations FRO Fording River Operations GHO Greenhills Operations Golder Golder Associates Ltd. GPS global positioning system i.e. that is ILMB Integrated Land Management Bureau KBLUP Kootenay-Boundary Land Use Plan LCO Line Creek Operations LSA local study area October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 ix BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Acronym/Abbreviation Definition MOE Ministry of Environment OGMA Old Growth Management Area pers. comm. personal communication PMFLC Private Managed Forest Land Council RDEK Regional District of East Kootenay RMI Resort Municipality Initiative RSA regional study area SRMAC Southern Rocky Mountain Advisory Committee SRMMP Southern Rocky Mountain Management Plan Teck Teck Coal Limited Tembec Tembec Industries Inc. the Project the Baldy Ridge Extension Project THLB Timber Harvest Land Base TSA timber supply area WMU wildlife management unit UNITS OF MEASURE Unit Definition % Percent ha hectare km Kilometre km2 square kilometre m3 cubic metre masl metres above sea level Mmtcc million metric tonnes October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 x BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N1.0 OVERVIEW N1.1 Overview Teck Coal Limited (Teck) is proposing an extension of its Elkview Operations (EVO), as part of its plans to maintain continued operations at EVO as identified in the 2014 Life of Mine Plan (Teck 2014b). The proposed extension is referred to as the Baldy Ridge Extension Project (the Project). The Project is situated in southeastern British Columbia (BC) in the District of Sparwood (Figure N1.1-1). The main area of EVO is bounded by the Elk River to the west, Erickson and Harmer Creeks to the east, and Michel Creek to the south. Highway #3 follows Michel Creek along the western and southern sides of EVO. The Project footprint includes the following: Extension of existing mining areas: Baldy Ridge (BR3, BR4, BR6 and BR7); Adit Ridge (AR1); and Natal Ridge (NP2). Extension and re-design of existing ex-pit waste rock spoils in Dry Creek and Erickson Valley. Development of a new ex-pit waste rock spoil near Adit Ridge and in-pit waste rock spoils. Extension of existing storage facilities for tailings and coarse coal refuse. Re-location of existing infrastructure to accommodate the proposed Project: re-location of the existing administration and maintenance complex located on Baldy Ridge; and re-location of the existing raw coal conveyor and utilities corridor that runs through the tunnel in Baldy Ridge. Development of water quality treatment facilities. The estimated total area of disturbance is approximately 2,665 ha of which 763 ha are outside of the current C-2 permit boundary and 1,901 ha are within the current C-2 permit boundary (Figure N1.1-1). The Project footprint ranges in elevation between 1,185 and 2,180 metres above sea level (masl). The Project will include continued operations of the existing EVO plant site and infrastructure. Mining is scheduled to start in 2017 with the BR6 pit, subject to regulatory approvals. Mining activities would then continue until the planned end of the Project in 2047. The Project is subject to review under the British Columbia Environmental Assessment Act (BCEAA), as outlined in the Project Application Information Requirements (BC EAO 2015). This baseline report forms Annex N of the Environmental Assessment Certificate (EAC) Application being prepared to meet the requirements of the BCEAA. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 1 655000 660000 HA X K S EE AW MI LL C K EXA CR EE CR ST A L WE M I LE RE ER RM SI EK HOLLOW CREEK ND ON CR K TH A FE L C UM Y CREE LIND SA Dry Creek Spoil K CR EE K C OSS A R IN BR4 EE K West Fork Tailings Facility Adit South Spoil ES Lagoon D W TO OT I CR e Ridg Lagoon C AR1 y Bald BR7 e EEK GOD DA R D CR g Rid E it Ad BR6 LK R I V E R 43 EEK Coarse Coal Refuse K M IN GS C RE EK V U R MC 5515000 5515000 WH ING C R E IT E EV EE O DR YC R EE K EK CR E ER FE L NNE ³ T FO RE U T K E RE C Proposed Maintenance Complex 3 & K CREE Ä Ã C R E EK ES HA N EEK R TH C RA NP2 CR H G ATE H C IG A MI L L CR E EXISTING CONVEYANCE ROUTE EXISTING DIVERSION CHANNEL NEW CONVEYANCE ROUTE PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE NOTE R O BERT TAILINGS FACILITY WATERBODY * Active water treatment facility will have an approximate footprint of 23,500 m² within the conceptual location. REFERENCE Populated places obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 C REEK E EK P IT C R CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY CONCEPTUAL CLEAN WATER DIVERSION CONCEPTUAL INTAKE PIPE 655000 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT FOOTPRINT BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT FOOTPRINT OUTSIDE THE CURRENT C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY CONCEPTUAL INTAKE CONCEPTUAL LOCATION FOR ACTIVE WATER TREATMENT FACILITY* ELKVIEW OPERATIONS CURRENT C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY PERMITTED COARSE COAL REFUSE PILE TH 3 & CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY PROPOSED FACILITY S OU ! KS O N EK RE ER R IV LEGEND E R IC ER EK LK E I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\SharedFigures\B-Shared-002-ProjectFootprint-ExistingEVO.mxd SO U T EK K K EE E CR EE CR E 5510000 BO DIE L HE e i dg lR IC ta Na M GAT 3 Erickson Spoil NC R Q C ED U ! 5510000 Sparwood BR3 K IE R IC LT A Q UA K R Proposed Administrative Complex E 3 & 660000 2 0 SCALE 1:70,000 PROJECT TITLE 2 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT PROJECT FOOTPRINT AND EXISTING ELKVIEW OPERATIONS PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW MH 12-1349-0013 07 Oct. 2013 SS 17 Sep. 2015 LE 31 Aug. 2015 MH 31 Aug. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N1.1-1 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT This baseline integrates information collected during secondary and primary data gathering activities, and presents the current understanding of land use and tenure activities in the region and Project-affected area. This report is organized as follows: Section N2 describes the study areas; Section N3 presents the methods used for the baseline study; Section N4 presents the results of the baseline study; Section N5 provides a summary of key baseline results; Section N7 presents references cited in this report; and Section N8 provides a glossary of terms used in this report. N1.2 Purpose The purpose of the land use and tenure baseline report is to describe existing land-based activities and tenures within the vicinity of the Project. This information will be used to: identify potential effects of Project construction and operations on land use activities and tenures; determine suitable mitigation and benefit measures; identify residual effects after mitigation; and evaluate the significance of residual effects once mitigation has been taken into account. The assessment of potential effects is presented in Sections B3.1 and B4.2 of the EAC Application prepared for the Project. N1.3 Scope The land use and tenure baseline presented in this report addresses the current land use activities and trends at the regional and local level. The scope for the land use and tenure baseline report included a review of historical information and the analysis of data collected during field surveys and desktop study. Traditional land use baseline information for specific First Nations (Ktunaxa Nation) is presented in the Ktunaxa Nation interests section of the EAC Application (Section C). October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 3 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N2.0 STUDY AREA N2.1 Regional Study Area The regional study area (RSA) for the land use and tenure discipline incorporates the regional terrestrial study area as set out in the valued components (VCs) document (Teck 2015a) plus the incorporated municipality of Crowsnest Pass, and as such reflects the area of potential regional effects of the Project. The RSA includes the BC communities of Sparwood, Elkford, and Fernie as well as the unincorporated settlements (e.g., Hosmer) and rural areas surrounding these communities. The community of Crowsnest Pass in Alberta has also been included in the RSA because its residents heavily use the Elk Valley for recreational and hunting purposes (Figure N2.1-1). These four study area communities are home to approximately 70% of EVO employees and it is anticipated that they will be the home communities for a similar percentage of the Project’s workforce. These workers, their families and other members of these communities may be affected through the Project’s potential effects on local outdoor recreation and public access. N2.2 Local Study Area The land use and tenure LSA corresponds with the terrestrial LSA plus the District of Sparwood, which was included because of its proximity to the Project (Figure N2.2-1). The LSA, which covers 23,660 ha, is defined to capture direct and small-scale indirect effects to the terrestrial environment resulting from the Project (e.g., human and terrestrial wildlife health, wildlife and wildlife habitat, fish and fish habitat, water quality and aquatic health, and noise, air and visual) as these effects have the potential to result in subsequent effects on land use and tenure. The northern edge of the LSA is bounded by Grave Creek, while the western edge is bounded by the Elk River and the western edge of the District of Sparwood municipal boundary. The southern and eastern boundaries of the LSA are defined by topographic ridges. Located next to the BC-Alberta border, the LSA includes part of Highway #3 and the existing Elk Valley Operations footprint. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 4 660000 710000 ! ! ³ Longview Invermere 5600000 5600000 610000 R RIV E EL K Fording River Operations IVE 5550000 GR Greenhills Operations DIN 5550000 R FO W HI T E RIV E R R B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A A LB E R TA Elkford ! IE LUS S R BULL RIVE R E R RIV V U 43 Line Creek Operations Ä Ã 22 Ä Ã ! 95A _Elkview ^ Operations Ä Ã 5500000 3 Municipality of Crowsnest Pass Hosmer IC TE RI VE Fernie ! Blairmore C REE Coal Mountain Operations Ä Ã LAKE KOOCANUSA ! _ ^ CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY PROJECT LOCATION CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE REFERENCE ! Elko 610000 ! Pincher Creek ! Beaver Mines 3 Wardner ! LEGEND OLDMAN RESERVOIR K R I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-002-GIS-RSA.mxd Y NA Cranbrook L HE O KO ! ! Coleman M ! ! 5500000 Sparwood 660000 710000 25 BRITISH COLUMBIA - ALBERTA BORDER SCALE COAL MINING OPERATION FIRST NATIONS RESERVE MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY PROJECT PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA REGIONAL STUDY AREA STUDY AREA COMMUNITY WATERBODY Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 TITLE 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT LAND USE AND TENURE REGIONAL STUDY AREA AND COMMUNITIES PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 20 Oct. 2015 SDL 20 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N2.1-1 0 660000 GR E AV CR 670000 EE K ³ M E C RE EK ME R EK YC RE EK CREE K CRE CUMMINGS IL HAR 5520000 DALZ ELL CREE K SI X 5520000 650000 DR V U EV O 43 B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A Sparwood HE L CR Ä Ã EE K ER ICKS ON K EE CR FIR RO BE RT CR EE K CREE K LLADNAR CREEK 5510000 ALEXA NDER CREE K IC 3 M 5510000 ! M CC O L CR EE Crowsnest 5500000 5500000 K Hazell RI VE R ! A LB E R TA EL K I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-001-GIS-LSA.mxd O ! 650000 LEGEND ! CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA - ALBERTA BORDER 660000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY LOCAL STUDY AREA PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA REFERENCE Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE 1:140,000 PROJECT WATERBODY DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 670000 4 TITLE 4 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT LAND USE AND TENURE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 21 Oct. 2015 SDL 21 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N2.2-1 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N3.0 METHODS N3.1 Review of Existing Information Secondary research completed for the baseline report includes a review of land ownership and tenure information and of local, regional and provincial land use plans. Tenure information was collected from DataBC and the Integrated Land and Resource Registry. Local, regional and provincial land use designations and plans were reviewed, as was information on the Agricultural Land Reserve (ALC 2002). Additional information about mining, forestry and gas activities was provided by Tembec Industries Inc. (Tembec), Canfor Corporation (Canfor) and Teck. Information on parks and protected areas and their use came from BC Parks online publications, while tourism and outdoor recreational use information was collected from tourism, recreational club and service provider reports and websites. Wildlife and fish harvesting data were provided by the BC Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations (FLNRO). N3.2 User Group Mapping Sessions Primary research was conducted via mapping sessions with user group representatives. These were held in Sparwood and Crowsnest Pass on December 11 and 12, 2013 respectively. Local user groups were invited to each send one or two representatives to one of the sessions. At the beginning of the group mapping session, Teck gave a presentation about the Project and informed the attendees about upcoming public consultation activities. Each attendee was given the opportunity to ask questions about the Project and questions and responses were noted and shared with Teck’s consultation team. After the presentation, representatives were asked to complete a seasonal calendar of group activities and were interviewed individually about the history and activities of their respective clubs or organizations. During user group mapping sessions, short individual interviews were conducted to collect information on the organization’s history, membership and activities. The groups invited to attend are shown in Table N3.2-1. A total of 13 groups were represented at the meetings. Mapping sessions were also held with representatives of motorized recreation groups to obtain information for Teck’s Line Creek Operations Phase II and Swift Projects. During this session, a representative of the Elkford all-terrain vehicle (ATV) Club and Elkford Snowmobile Association provided Golder Associates Ltd. with digital maps of motorized recreation trails and cabin locations in the Elk Valley. During the sessions in 2013, it was confirmed that these digital maps are still current. Mapping information collected in support of the Swift and Line Creek Operations Phase II projects has also been used where appropriate. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 7 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Table N3.2-1 User Group Mapping Session Participants Held December 11 and 12, 2013 Representative Invited Representative Attended Elk Valley Mountaineers Group Elkford ATV Club Crowsnest Pass Quad Squad Crow Snow Riders Fernie Rod and Gun Club Sparwood Fish and Wildlife Association Elkford Rod and Gun Club Hillcrest Fish and Game Association Sheep Mountain Outfitters Elk River Guiding Company Freestone Fly Angler Conservation Officer Service (BC Ministry of Environment) Fernie Search and Rescue Fernie Trails Alliance - Fernie Snowmobile Association - Fernie Nordic Society - Fernie Trails & Ski Touring Club - Elk Valley ATV - Elkford Snowmobile Association - Elkford Recreation Development - Bohomelec Stables - United Riders of Crowsnest - East Kootenay Wildlife Association - Corbin Country Club - Kootenay Fly Shop & Guiding Company - Elk River Alliance - Mountain High Adventures - Fernie Fly Fishing - Fernie Wilderness Adventures - Dave Brown Outfitters - Big Horn Guide Outfitters - Inn on the Border - Elkford Search and Rescue - Note: = yes; - = no. N3.3 Data Analysis and Reporting Data collected through a review of publicly available information, group sessions and individual interviews were summarized and sorted by land use and tenure categories for presentation in this report. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 8 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.0 RESULTS N4.1 Land Use Plans and Designations This section describes existing local, regional and provincial land use management plans, zoning and land use designations near the Project, including: East Kootenay Land Use Plan; Southern Rocky Mountain Management Plan (SRMMP); Agricultural Land Reserve (ALR); Old Growth Management Areas (OGMA); and Municipal and Regional Zoning. The Project is located on fee simple land owned by Teck and most of the Project footprint (with the exception of the very eastern portion of the Project) and the LSA are situated within the municipal boundaries of Sparwood (Figure N4.1-5), which has zoned the area as Extraction Industrial. The Extraction Industrial zone provides for mineral extraction and processing of extracted minerals. Specific allowed uses include mineral extraction, processing of minerals extracted, railway lines and utilities lines required for the processing or extraction, waste rock spoils and accessory buildings (District of Sparwood 2014b). The remainder of the Project footprint and LSA overlaps with the RDEK and is zoned as Rural Resource under the Regional District of East Kootenay Elk Valley Zoning Bylaw No. 829 (RDEK 2014b). The Rural Resource designation allows agricultural, rural residential and rural resource land uses for parcel sizes of 8 ha and larger. The Rural Resource designation recognizes the use of this land for public utility use, resource extraction, green space and outdoor recreation. Land within the Project footprint and currently outside of the District of Sparwood’s boundary will be transferred from RDEK jurisdiction into Sparwood’s municipal boundary for inclusion in the Elk Valley Tax Sharing Agreement under the Municipalities Enabling and Validating Act (2001). The transfer would likely occur if ministerial approval of the Project were granted (District of Sparwood 2009, pers. comm.). N4.1.1 Regional Study Area N4.1.1.1 Provincial Land Use Plans In 1991, the BC Government directed that a strategic Kootenay-Boundary Land Use Plan (KBLUP) be prepared to identify a comprehensive and integrated vision for regional land and resource use. The East Kootenay Land Use Plan was completed in 1995 and the KBLUP Implementation Strategy was adopted in 1997 (Government of British Columbia 1995; FLNRO n.d.a). The Kootenay-Boundary Higher Level Plan order was approved in 2001, which established new resource management zones and objectives (FLNRO n.d.a; Kootenai Tribe of Idaho and Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks 2004). The Kootenay-Boundary Higher Level Plan order was revised in 2002 (FLNRO n.d.a). October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 9 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT The 2003 Southern Rocky Mountain Management Plan (SRMMP), which covers the Flathead, Wigwam, the east side of the Bull River drainage, and the west side of the Elk River drainage (Figure N4.1-1), further refined and clarified the KBLUP Implementation Strategy and implemented the Kootenay-Boundary Higher Level Plan order (Kootenai Tribe of Idaho and Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks 2004; FLNRO 2002). All federal lands, private lands and provincial parks are excluded from the SRMMP (FLNRO 2002). The plan balances economic, social and environmental values for the long-term health of the economy, communities and ecosystems (Kootenai Tribe of Idaho and Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks 2004). The Southern Rocky Mountain Advisory Committee (SRMAC) was established to advise the BC Government on SRMMP monitoring, implementation, and effectiveness, and to recommend changes in plan direction and content (FLNRO 2002). Specific duties of the committee include participating in plan support and monitoring, providing advice and recommendations, and reviewing proposals, developments and maps. The committee has not recently been active (FLNRO 2014a pers. comm.). Under the East Kootenay Land Use Plan, land within the RSA overlaps with the following designations (Figure N4.1-2). Integrated Resource Management Zone – The primary objective in the Integrated Resource Management Zone designation is to balance environmental, economic and social benefits of the resources within the zone. Land in this designation supplies extensive opportunities for most land use activities (Kootenay Inter-Agency Management Committee 1997). Special Resource Management Zones - Areas with high concentrations of regionally significant and sensitive resource value (e.g., critical fish and wildlife habitat), ecosystems that are underrepresented in the region’s protected area systems, important viewscapes, sensitive recreations areas and cultural heritage features (Kootenay Inter-Agency Management Committee 1997). Enhanced Resource Development Zone (ERDZ) - Lands designated as ERDZ indicate the suitability or potential of the land for relatively intensive resource development activities, aimed primarily at regional economic development and community and workforce stability (Kootenay Inter-Agency Management Committee 1997). Coal Enhanced Resource Development Zone – A Coal ERDZ encompasses areas of known coal reserves, existing coal mining facilities and infrastructure and areas for potential expansion. The Coal ERDZ designation signifies an assurance of long-term security of access and tenures to this land for coal mining exploration and development purposes (Kootenay Inter-Agency Management Committee 1997). October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 10 660000 710000 ! ³ 5600000 ! Longview Invermere 5600000 610000 R RIV E EL K B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A Fording River Operations R FO W HI T E RIV E R DIN Greenhills Operations 5550000 IVE R 5550000 GR Elkford ! IE LUS S 43 Sparwood Ä Ã 95A ! 22 Operations Ä Ã Coleman 5500000 3 Hosmer H IC L C E TE Y NA ! RI VE Cranbrook ! ! Municipality of Crowsnest Pass Fernie ! Blairmore RE E K Coal Mountain Operations ! R Ä Ã LAKE KOOCANUSA ! Elko 610000 ! _ ^ CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY PROJECT LOCATION CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER COAL MINING OPERATION REFERENCE Pincher Creek Beaver ! Mines 3 Wardner ! LEGEND OLDMAN RESERVOIR M ! O KO I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-019-GIS_RockyMtnMangPlan.mxd A LB E R TA _Elkview ^ 5500000 BULL RIVE R R V U Ä Ã E R RIV Line Creek Operations 660000 710000 25 LOCAL STUDY AREA SCALE MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA REGIONAL STUDY AREA PROJECT RESOURCE EVALUATION AREA SOUTHERN ROCKY MOUNTAIN MANAGEMENT PLAN AREA STUDY AREA COMMUNITY WATERBODY Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. Resource Evaluation Area and Southern Rocky Mountain Management Plan Area obtained from the LRDW. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 TITLE 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT SOUTHERN ROCKY MOUNTAIN MANAGEMENT PLAN PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 23 Oct. 2015 SDL 23 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.1-1 0 660000 710000 ³ ! Longview 5600000 ! Invermere 5600000 610000 R RIV E EL K Fording River Operations R A LB E R TA Elkford ! IE LUS S 43 ! 22 _Elkview ^ Operations Ä Ã Ä Ã 5500000 3 Hosmer IC TE Y NA RI ! L HE O KO VE Blairmore C R EEK Coal Mountain Operations Fernie KOOTENAY-BOUNDARY LAND USE PLAN (1997) Beaver ! Pincher Creek Mines COAL ENHANCED RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT ZONE Ä Ã 3 Wardner ! OLDMAN RESERVOIR ! R Cranbrook ! Municipality of Crowsnest Pass M ! Coleman 5500000 BULL RIVE R R V U Ä Ã E R RIV Line Creek Operations Sparwood ! 5550000 IVE B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A 95A I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-018-GIS_KootenayLandUsePlan.mxd GR Greenhills Operations DIN 5550000 R FO W HI T E RIV E R ENHANCED RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT ZONE INTEGRATED RESOURCE MANAGEMENT ZONE LAKE KOOCANUSA SPECIAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT ZONE ! PRIVATE LAND Elko 610000 LEGEND ! _ ^ CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY PROJECT LOCATION CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER REFERENCE 660000 COAL MINING OPERATION PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA PROJECT REGIONAL STUDY AREA STUDY AREA COMMUNITY WATERBODY Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. Kootenay land use areas obtained from the LRDW. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE LOCAL STUDY AREA MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY 710000 25 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT TITLE KOOTENAY-BOUNDARY LAND USE PLAN PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.1-2 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.1.1.2 Agricultural Land Reserve The Agricultural Land Commission (ALC) administers the Agricultural Land Reserve (ALR). Land designated as situated within ALR boundaries can be used only for certain agriculture related purposes. The objectives of the ALR include preserving agricultural land, and encouraging and enabling farm businesses throughout BC (ALC 2010). Within the RSA, the ALR areas are located between Sparwood and Elkford along Highway #43 and between Sparwood and Fernie along Highway #3 (Figure N4.1-3). The total ALR area in the RDEK is 264,379 ha, of which 13,177 ha overlaps with the RSA. Further information on agriculture activity in the RSA is provided in Section N4.2.3.1. N4.1.1.3 Old Growth Management Areas In 1999, a biodiversity planning initiative focused on the establishment of legal old growth management areas (OGMA) was launched by the BC Government. The Kootenay-Boundary Higher Level Plan Order provides legal direction for identifying old and mature seral forests. The order provides targets for retention of seral types by landscape units and biogeoclimatic subzones and variants and defines what ages or other attributes constitute mature and old seral types. Direction is provided on recruitment of old growth where subject areas are in deficit of retention requirements. In 2006, the Integrated Land Management Bureau (ILMB) decided not to legalize spatial OGMAs in the Southern Interior Region as existing legal objectives were deemed adequate (ILMB 2007). Therefore, OGMAs in this area are referred to as non-legal OGMAs. OGMAs and old growth areas within the RSA are further described in the ecosystem assessment (Section B2.3.1) of the EAC Application. N4.1.1.4 Municipal and Regional Zoning Municipal and regional zoning and subdivision bylaws regulate the allowable uses, such as industrial, commercial and residential, on private property within a designated area and can specify other elements of land use, such as the size of buildings and lots. The four incorporated RSA communities (i.e., Sparwood, Elkford, Fernie and Crowsnest Pass) control land use zoning on private land within their boundaries, as does the RDEK for the unincorporated areas of the RSA. Coal mines, coal processing works or coal related infrastructure that are located in the RSA are subject to the Elk Valley Property Tax Sharing Agreement, which allocates revenues collected from property taxes levied on the industrial coal mining properties in the Elk Valley between Sparwood, Elkford, Fernie and the RDEK (Electoral Area A). 1 Under the agreement, if coal mining or processing properties are identified outside existing municipal boundaries, then a municipality can apply for a boundary expansion to facilitate property taxation of these properties. 1 Crowsnest Pass is not part of the Elk Valley Property Tax Sharing Agreement. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 13 660000 710000 ³ ! Longview 5600000 ! Invermere 5600000 610000 R RIV E EL K Fording River Operations IVE 5550000 GR Greenhills Operations DIN R 5550000 R FO W HI T E RIV E R B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A A LB E R TA Elkford ! IE LUS S Line Creek Operations V U Ä Ã R BULL RIVE R E R RIV 43 22 Ä Ã 95A ! _Elkview ^ Operations Ä Ã 5500000 Hosmer IC TE Y NA RI ! VE CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY PROJECT LOCATION CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY AGRICULTURAL LAND RESERVE AREA BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER REFERENCE OLDMAN RESERVOIR RE E K Fernie Pincher Creek ! Beaver ! Mines Ä Ã LEGEND WATERCOURSE C Coal Mountain Operations ! Elko 610000 PRIMARY HIGHWAY Blairmore R LAKE KOOCANUSA _ ^ ! 3 Wardner ! ! L HE O KO Cranbrook ! ! Municipality of Crowsnest Pass M ! I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-012-GIS_AgricultureLRA.mxd Coleman 3 5500000 Sparwood 660000 710000 25 COAL MINING OPERATION SCALE FIRST NATIONS RESERVE LOCAL STUDY AREA MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY PROJECT PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA RANGE TENURE REGIONAL STUDY AREA STUDY AREA COMMUNITY WATERBODY Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. Regional District data obtained from ICIS. Agricultural Data obtained from the LRDW. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT TITLE AGRICULTURAL LAND RESERVE AREAS PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.1-3 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.1.2 Local Study Area N4.1.2.1 Provincial Land Use Plans The Project footprint is situated on private lands that are not subject to provincial land use plans. Crown land within the LSA is designated as Coal ERDZ, which provides for industrial uses that are consistent with Teck’s operations. N4.1.2.2 Agricultural Land Commission There are 1,124 ha of ALR designated lands overlapping the western side of the LSA between Sparwood and Elkford (Figure N4.1-3). No ALR lands overlap with the Project footprint. Further information on agriculture activity in the LSA is provided in Section N4.2.3.2. N4.1.2.3 Old Growth Management Areas No legal OGMAs are located within the LSA and Project footprint (Figure N4.1-4). However, non-legal OGMAS, as described in Section M4.1.1.3, are present in the LSA. N4.1.2.4 Municipal and Regional Zoning Most of the Project footprint overlaps with the District of Sparwood (Figure N4.1-5). The District of Sparwood has zoned land within the Project footprint “M-3 Extraction Industrial,” which is to provide for mineral extraction and processing of extracted minerals (District of Sparwood 2014b). Specific allowed uses include mineral extraction, processing of extracted minerals, railway lines and utilities lines required for processing or extraction, waste spoils and accessory buildings. Within the LSA along Highway #3 east of the G North Road, zoning designations include A-1 (Agricultural Land), C-2 (Highway Commercial), M-1 (Light Industrial), and M-2 (Heavy Industrial). West of G North Road, zoning includes different residential, commercial, agricultural and industrial designations. The remainder of the Project footprint and the rest of the LSA overlaps with the RDEK and is zoned Rural Resource under the RDEK Elk Valley Zoning Bylaw No. 829 (Figure N4.1-5). The Rural Resource designation allows agricultural, rural residential and rural resource land uses for parcel sizes of 8 ha and larger. The Rural Resource designation recognizes the use of this land for public utility use, resource extraction, green space and outdoor recreation. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 15 660000 GR E AV CR 670000 EE K ³ M E C RE EK ME R K EE DR Y CR EK CREE K CRE CUMMINGS IL HAR 5520000 DALZ ELL CREE K SI X 5520000 650000 V U EV O 43 B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A Sparwood Ä Ã IC HE 3 L CR EE K ER ICKS ON K EE CR FIR RT BE RO M CC O O L CR EE ! Crowsnest 5500000 5500000 K Hazell RI VE R ! A LB E R TA EL K I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-022-GIS-LSAOldGrowth.mxd CR EE K CREE K LLADNAR CREEK 5510000 ALEXA NDER CREE K M 5510000 ! 650000 LEGEND ! CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER 660000 LOCAL STUDY AREA OLD GROWTH MANAGEMENT AREA - NON LEGAL PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY REFERENCE Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE 1:140,000 PROJECT WATERBODY DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 670000 4 TITLE 4 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT OLD GROWTH MANAGEMENT AREAS IN THE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW SR SS MH SDL 12-1349-0013 25 Aug. 2014 24 Oct. 2015 06 Oct. 2015 24 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.1-4 0 660000 GR E AV CR 670000 EE K ³ M E C RE EK ME R K EE DR Y CR EK CREE K CRE CUMMINGS IL HAR 5520000 DALZ ELL CREE K SI X 5520000 650000 V U EV O 43 B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A Sparwood HE L CR Ä Ã EE K ER ICKS ON K EE CR FIR RT BE RO M CC O O L CR EE ! Crowsnest Hazell RI VE R ! 5500000 5500000 K A LB E R TA EL K I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-015-GIS_LandUseZoning.mxd CR EE K CREE K LLADNAR CREEK 5510000 ALEXA NDER CREE K IC 3 M 5510000 ! LEGEND ! CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY 650000 CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER DISTRICT OF SPARWOOD DISTRICT BOUNDARY 660000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 REFERENCE PROJECT REGIONAL DISTRICT OF EAST KOOTENAY RURAL RESOURCE ZONE WATERBODY Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. Bylaw Zoning data obtained from the Regional District of East Kootenay. Municipal District data obtained from ICIS. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE 1:140,000 LOCAL STUDY AREA PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA 670000 4 TITLE 4 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT LAND USE ZONING IN THE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.1-5 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.2 Land Uses, Tenures and Focal Areas This section describes the following land uses, tenures and focal areas in the RSA and LSA: access; parks and protected areas; agriculture; coal and mineral exploration and mining; forestry; natural gas (coal bed methane) development; non-timber forest products; wildlife and fish harvesting; and outdoor recreation and tourism. N4.2.1 Access N4.2.1.1 Regional Study Area Access to and within the RSA is primarily via Highway #3 through Fernie from the west and Crowsnest Pass from the east (Figure N2.1-1). A Canadian Pacific rail line runs north-south through the centre of the RSA as well as east-west from Sparwood to Crowsnest Past. Many motorized and non-motorized trails provide access to recreation areas (Section N4.2.9.1.1). The Elk Valley Regional Airport is located near Highway #43 on Lower Elk Valley Road between Sparwood and Elkford. The airport is not a commercial facility and is used by small private planes, corporate aircraft, medevac flights and the Forest Service (in the summer months) (RDEK 2008). N4.2.1.2 Local Study Area Access to EVO’s main gate is by way of Highway #3 (Crowsnest Pass Highway) and then north on Michel Creek Road. Access to the northern end of the LSA is possible from Highway #43 through the Grave Prairie Access Management Area using gravel roads. Access to the north can also be obtained by traveling along the eastern side of the LSA through the Alexander Creek Access Management Area from Highway #3. Canfor has an access arrangement with Teck that allows Canfor to use roads, bridges, and transportation facilities on Managed Forest 471 or providing access to Managed Forest 471 (Teck 2015c, pers. comm.). A Teck managed “No Unauthorized Entry Area” overlaps EVO. The No Unauthorized Entry Areas were implemented by Teck to maintain public and worker safety near the existing operations or exploration, and permission from Teck is needed to enter a No Unauthorized Entry Area (Figure N4.2-1). Signs are posted at potential entry points and along the No Unauthorized Entry Area. Permission is needed to enter the mine site and the No Unauthorized Entry Area and access is controlled by EVO. The location of the No Unauthorized Entry Area is published regularly in local papers and in the annual BC Hunting and Trapping Regulations Synopsis. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 18 660000 GR E AV CR 670000 EE K ³ X M E CR EE K ME R EK CREEK CRE CUMMINGS IL HAR 5520000 DALZELL CREE K SI 5520000 650000 V U 43 EV O Y DR CR K EE BR IT IS H C OL UM BI A Ä Ã 3 ERICKSON CREE K LLADNAR CREEK 5510000 ! ALEXANDER CREEK 5510000 Sparwood M H IC EE K CR RT FIR CR BE RO K EE EE K CR CC O L O CR Crowsnest 5500000 5500000 K EE Hazell RI VE R ! K ALB ER TA EL I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-020-GIS_NoUnauthorizedEntry.mxd EL M ! 650000 LEGEND ! CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 REFERENCE 660000 670000 4 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY LOCAL STUDY AREA MUNICIPAL NO SHOOTING SCALE 1:140,000 PROJECT NO UNAUTHORIZED ENTRY AREA PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA SPARWOOD RIDGE RESTRICTED AREA WATERBODY Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 4 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT TITLE NO UNAUTHORIZED ENTRY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.2-1 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT In addition, a “Sparwood Ridge Restricted Area”, located south of EVO, has been implemented by Teck to prevent public access to the area because of ongoing safety hazards associated with previous underground mine workings (Figure N4.2-1). A “municipal no shooting area” also surrounds the community of Sparwood, restricting the use of firearms. N4.2.2 Parks and Protected Areas N4.2.2.1 Regional Study Area Parks and protected areas within and near the RSA are shown in Figure N4.2-2. Small portions of BC’s Height of the Rockies Provincial Park overlap the northern boundary of the RSA. The Height of the Rockies Provincial Park is part of a protected area network lying north and south along the Continental Divide and has internationally significant biodiversity values and sustains habitat for a wide array of animals including grizzly bears and mountain goats. The park is closed to logging, mining and other resource uses, but (existing) grazing, guide outfitting and trapping activities are permitted. Height of the Rockies Park is a non-mechanized park where motorized and mechanized recreational access is prohibited (i.e., floatplanes, helicopters, snowmobiles, ATVs and mountain bikes) (BC Parks 2014a). At the north end of the RSA, Elk Lakes Provincial Park is an easily accessible wilderness park characterized by sub-alpine landscapes, remnant glaciers, rugged peaks and lakes. The park offers hiking, canoeing, climbing, fishing, horseback riding and hunting. Winter use of the park for ski touring and snowshoeing is limited due to unploughed roads, but it is possible to reach the park from Alberta by way of the Peter Lougheed Park ski trails. Snowmobile use in the Cadorna Valley of Elk Lakes Parks is limited to the seismic road and the regular winter route to Abruzzi Lake. Snowmobile use is not permitted in any other areas of the park (BC Parks 2014b). The following smaller BC provincial parks are found within the RSA. Crowsnest Provincial Park is located west of the BC – Alberta provincial boundary north of Highway #3. This park provides a stopping place with views of the Erickson and Loop ridges of the Rockies (BC Parks 2013a). Mount Fernie Provincial Park is located immediately southwest of Fernie and is close to amenities such as skiing, golfing, restaurants and art galleries that surround the City of Fernie (BC Parks 2013b). Elk Valley Provincial Park, 18 km northeast of Fernie, is a picnic area near Highway #3 with access to the Elk River’s riparian habitat (BC Parks 2013c). BC Parks provides annual statistics on visitor and camping attendance at Elk Lakes Provincial Park and Mount Fernie Provincial Park (Table N4.2-1). Swings in park attendance between years can be attributed in some instances to differences in data collection methods, but changes are also a result of other factors such as weather conditions. Between 2009/2010 and 2012/2013, the total number of visitors increased for both parks; 7,000 for Elk Lakes Provincial Park in 2012/2013, while Mount Fernie Provincial Park had over 30,000 visitors in the same year. Close to 40% of all visitors in Elk Lakes Provincial Park and Mount Fernie Provincial Park were campers. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 20 660000 Peter Lougheed Provincial Park 710000 High River ! Don Getty Wildland Provincial Park ALDERIDGE CREEK RECREATIONAL SITE RIV ER 5600000 A LB E R TA R RIV E Elkford LUS S IE Line Creek Operations BULL RIVE R Bob Creek Wildland Provincial Park NORTH FORK PASS Black Creek Heritage Rangeland V U 43 Ä Ã Top of the World Provincial Park Mt. Livingstone Natural Area Beehive Natural Area G R DIN ! Don Getty Wildland Provincial Park R FO BOIVIN CREEK RECREATIONAL SITE Chain Lakes Provincial Park Plateau Mountain Ecological Reserve Fording River Operations R RIV E EL K 5550000 FORDING PASS Greenhills Operations B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A 22 2 Don Getty Wildland Provincial Park Height of the Rockies Provincial Park ER Ä Ã 5600000 40 WEARY CREEK RECREATIONAL SITE Whiteswan Lake Provincial Park ! Ä Ã Elk Lakes Provincial Park W HI T E R IV ³ Longview Elbow-Sheep Wildland Provincial Park 5550000 CR OS 610000 Ä Ã S RIV E R 22 _Elkview ^ Ä Ã Ä Ã 5500000 Elk Valley Provincial Park 3 VE R ! LEGEND CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY PROJECT LOCATION RECREATIONAL SITE CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY GREAT DIVIDE TRAIL PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE REFERENCE C R EEK Coal Mountain Operations Pincher Creek Beaver ! Mines Mount Fernie Provincial Park Beauvais Lake Provincial Park ! 610000 _ ^ Ä Ã RI ! L HE Y NA Wardner ! IC TE Cranbrook ! Oldman Dam Provincial Recreation Area Blairmore ! M O KO 3 Fernie Coleman ! Municipality of Crowsnest Pass Hosmer ! I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-009-GIS_Parks.mxd Crowsnest Provincial Park Operations 5500000 ! Elko 660000 FIRST NATIONS RESERVE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA REGIONAL STUDY AREA STUDY AREA COMMUNITY WATERBODY Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE COAL MINING OPERATION TITLE 6 710000 25 BRITISH COLUMBIA - ALBERTA BORDER ! Ä Ã Sparwood 95A 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT PARKS AND PROTECTED AREAS IN THE REGIONAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.2-2 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Table N4.2-1 Park Provincial Park Visitors Day Use Visitors per Year Camping Visitors per Year 09/10 10/11 11/12 12/13 09/10 Elk Lakes Provincial Park 1,197 1,582 1,910 4,552 662 Mount Fernie Provincial Park - 5,418 14,840 19,128 - Total Visitors per Year 10/11 11/12 12/13 09/10 10/11 11/12 12/13 995 1,049 2,627 1,859 2,577 2,959 7,179 11,962 11,987 12,240 - 17,380 26,827 31,368 Source: BC Parks 2011, 2012, 2013d. Note: Some numbers are rounded for presentation purposes. Therefore, it may appear that the totals do not equal the sum of the individual values. - = Data not included due to methods change. In addition to provincial parks, the RDEK’s Elk Valley Regional Park is located between Elkford and Sparwood. This park is for day-use only, and camping is not permitted. Amenities include picnic areas, barbeque pits, baseball diamonds, and horseshoe and bocce ball pits. Elk Valley Regional Park covers approximately 25 ha and can accommodate approximately 200 people (RDEK 2014). N4.2.2.2 Local Study Area No provincial parks or protected areas are located in the LSA (Figure N4.2-2). Municipal parks are located within the District of Sparwood boundaries. N4.2.3 Agriculture N4.2.3.1 Regional Study Area The BC Ministry of Agriculture estimated that 9% of the ALR land in the Elk Valley was actively farmed in 2011, while 73% was natural pasture/rangeland or forested land. In 2011, there were 23 privately owned farm areas greater than 32 ha in the Elk Valley, with a combined potential agricultural area of 2,373 ha. Eight of these farm areas (569 ha) were owned by wildlife conservation groups (BC Ministry of Agriculture 2011). Livestock and forage production characterizes agriculture in the RDEK and Elk Valley. In 2011, approximately 99% of all cultivated land in the Elk Valley was dedicated to forage production and pasture. There were 572 head of beef cattle and 130 horses in the Elk Valley in 2011. The beef herd size is limited in the Elk Valley due to constrained local forage production capabilities; typically, winter feed cannot be supplied on farm to support large herds. Most local beef cattle are shipped to Alberta for finishing and processing (BC Ministry of Agriculture 2011). Gross farm-receipts in the RDEK rose by 46% since 1986 to a high of $15,570,846 in 2006, but dropped to $14,504,239 in 2011. The number of farms in the RDEK increased by 2% from 1986 through 2011 and the distribution of farm sizes remained constant, with: 15% of the farms under 4 ha; 36% between 4 and 52 ha; 24% between 52 and 161 ha; and 25% greater than 161 ha (BC Ministry of Agriculture 2011). October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 22 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT The number of RDEK cattle ranching operations declined by approximately 50% between 2001 and 2011. This decrease was due to three factors: the effect of the 2003 Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE) crisis on cattle prices; changes to the red meat inspection system; and economic instability in the beef cattle industry (VAST Resource Solutions Inc. 2013). Many East Kootenay farms and ranches are struggling financially and are relying on off-farm income to sustain their operations (VAST Resource Solutions Inc. 2013). Impediments to the agricultural industry in the RDEK include a short growing season, lack of water for irrigation, poor soils, long distance to major markets and suppliers, small local permanent population, and wage competition from the mining sector (RDEK 2012). Other challenges include elk, deer and predator damage to crops and livestock and demand for recreational and second homes raising the value of rural land (BC Ministry of Agriculture 2011). N4.2.3.2 Local Study Area Agricultural activity is limited within the LSA. The LSA overlaps 1,124 ha of ALR concentrated near Highway #43. A range tenure overlaps the eastern edge of the LSA by 646 ha, while another is located directly to the west of the LSA (Figure N4.1-3). N4.2.4 Coal and Mineral Exploration and Mining N4.2.4.1 Regional Study Area Coal mining and processing in the Elk Valley has been the primary economic driver for several generations of residents. As far back as the late 1880s, coal mines were operating in and near the Elk Valley, from the headwaters of the Fording River in the north to the Flathead River drainage in the south (Allen 2000). A description of coal’s current economic and social importance to the Elk Valley can be found in Section B5.1 of the EAC Application. N4.2.4.1.1 Teck’s Coal Activities Teck’s coal mining and processing operations in the Elk Valley directly employ almost 4,000 workers who reside in Sparwood, Crowsnest Pass, Elkford, Fernie as well as in other communities such as Cranbrook, Lethbridge and Calgary (Teck 2014c, pers. comm.; c, pers. comm.). In 2013, Teck’s Elk Valley mining operations produced approximately 70% of Canada’s total annual coal exports (BC MEM 2014). An overview of Teck’s Elk Valley operations is provided in Table N4.2-2. Teck’s coal mining operations in the Elk Valley include (Figure N4.2-3): Coal Mountain Operations (CMO): 30 km southeast of Sparwood (Teck 2014c); EVO: 3 km east of Sparwood (Teck 2014d); Line Creek Operations (LCO): 25 km north of Sparwood (Teck 2014e); Greenhills Operations (GHO): 8 km northeast of Elkford (Teck 2014f); and Fording River Operations (FRO): 29 km northeast of Elkford (Teck 2014g). Teck employs a number of people at a corporate office and shared services group located in Sparwood. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 23 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Table N4.2-2 Teck Mines in the Regional Study Area Operation Coal Mountain Operations Elkview Operations Line Creek Operations Greenhills Operations Fording River Operations Sparwood Office Area [ha] Production (Mine and Preparation Plant) 3,000 The current annual production capacities of the mine and preparation plant are, respectively, approximately 2.7 and 3.5 million metric tonnes of clean coal (Mmtcc). 27,100 The current annual production capacities of the mine and preparation plant (on a 100% basis) are approximately 6.5 and 6.8 million tonnes of clean coal, respectively. 8,200 The current annual production capacities of the mine and preparation plant are approximately 3.5 and 3.5 million tonnes of clean coal, respectively. 11,800 Coal mined at Greenhills is used to produce steel. The current annual production capacities of the mine and preparation plant (on a 100% basis) are 5.2 and 5.2 million tonnes of clean coal, respectively. 23,000 The mine produces steelmaking coal. The current annual production capacities of the mine and preparation plant are approximately 9.0 and 9.5 million tonnes of clean coal, respectively. n/a n/a Does not include proposed extensions to CMO, EVO and FRO. ha = hectares; n/a = not applicable; % = percent; Mmtcc = million metric tonnes of clean coal. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 3 29 19 14 70 n/a Source: Teck 2014,c,d,e,f,g,h, Teck 2014c, pers. comm.; c, pers. comm. (a) Reserve Life (a) [years] 24 Number of Employees as of December 2013 Employees’ Communities of Residence 321 Sparwood - 26.5%; Crowsnest Pass - 34.0%; Elkford - 2.8%; Fernie - 16.8%; and Other - 19.9%. 1,078 Sparwood - 24.2% Crowsnest Pass - 18.5%; Elkford - 3.1%; Fernie - 21.8%; and Other - 32.5%. 504 Sparwood - 22.0%; Crowsnest Pass - 15.3%; Elkford - 7.5%; Fernie - 24.8%; and Other - 30.4%. 600 Sparwood - 23.3%; Crowsnest Pass - 6.5%; Elkford - 30.3%; Fernie - 14.5%; and Other - 25.3%. 1,196 Sparwood - 12.8%; Crowsnest Pass - 4.9%; Elkford - 39.4%; Fernie - 8.9%; and Other - 34.0%. 143 Sparwood – 32.2%; Crowsnest Pass – 10.5%; Elkford - 9.1%; Fernie – 42.7%; and Other – 5.6%. 650000 660000 670000 327810 ³ 327811 1025617 G 1024276 EK 573413 538381 573412 625543 418150 418152 M IL 418153 CR EE CRE E ME R X RE HAR SI K 418430 418151 C R EE K CREEK EK CUMMINGS 5520000 C VE RA 5520000 DALZELL CREE K BR IT IS H C OL UM BI A 327719 625523 V U D RY 43 EV O 503936 418154 ALEXANDER CREEK M 5510000 ! H IC EL CR Ä Ã 3 K EE ERICKSON LLADNAR CREEK 5510000 Sparwood ALB ER TA K EE M CC O 418203 L O CR 1023062 5500000 K EE 513344 1023064 ! VE R Crowsnest K RI 418314 1029979 EL I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-004-GIS-Tenures.mxd 1023066 418319 5500000 CR FIR RO BE RT CR EE K CREE K 418313 ! Hosmer LEGEND ! CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER COAL LEASES AND LICENCES 327799 1025533 327800 327798 327801 650000 660000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY LOCAL STUDY AREA PRIVATE OWNERSHIP PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA WATERBODY MINERAL CLAIM TENURE Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. MF27 boundary data obtained from Tembec Inc. Ownership dataset put together by Golder in consultation with Teck Coal Limited. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 418315 670000 0 SCALE 1:175,000 PROJECT ! 418316 5 DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 COAL LICENCE APPLICATION REFERENCE 1024365 Hazell 5 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT TITLE LAND OWNERSHIP, MINERAL CLAIMS AND COAL TENURES IN THE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.2-3 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT In addition to its ongoing Elk Valley operations, Teck has proposed mine extensions and developments in the region: The Swift Project is an extension of current operations at FRO, and is estimated to provide an aggregate total of approximately 170 million metric tonnes of clean coal for the next 25 years. The Environmental Assessment Certificate Application for the Swift Project was submitted in January 2015. The Castle Mountain project is also an extension of FRO in the Kilmarnock Creek watershed, and is currently scheduled for development in 2025. The Baldy Ridge Extension (BRE Project) is an extension of EVO in the Bodie, Goddard and Dry Creek watersheds, with planned extraction of 130 Mmtcc. Teck anticipates submission of an Environmental Assessment Certificate Application in 2015. Cougar Pit Extension is a proposed extension of GHO in the Swift Creek watershed. N4.2.4.1.2 Teck Land Reclamation Environmental considerations at Teck’s mine operations are based on the premise that mining is a temporary use of the land and that all mine land will be reclaimed to be fully productive post-closure landscapes. Teck conducts annual reclamation research at its five Elk Valley operations to develop new reclamation techniques and monitor success of previous reclamation efforts (Teck 2014h). Elkview Operations strives to reclaim surface disturbances in a timely manner and to re-establish a sustainable, diverse, and functional landscape that, on a property average basis, is greater than or equal to the capability/productivity which existed before mining. The projected five year reclamation plan will concentrate on completing reclamation activities in the Harmer West and East areas, South Pit, Lagoon D and coarse coal refuse pile. Planned activities include ungulate fencing for seedling protection, re-contouring, site preparation, aerial seeding and fertilizing, and tree and shrub planting. The Invasive Plant Management Program is expected to continue in the lower Elk and Michel valleys and at priority areas identified during the 2013 program and subsequent surveys (Teck 2014a). An overview of areas disturbed and reclaimed by Teck in the Elk Valley is provided in Table N4.2-3. Table N4.2-3 Summary of Areas Disturbed and Reclaimed Before December 31, 2013 Mining Operation Area Disturbed Area Re-contoured and Re-sloped Area Seeded/Planted Area Fertilized Area (a) Revegetated Land Use Objective Coal Mountain Operations 1,033 48 254 181 224 Wildlife Habitat Elkview Operations 4,129 977 2,077 1,744 1,788 Wildlife Habitat Line Creek Operations 2,388 461 1,004 356 784 Wildlife Habitat Greenhills Operations 2,673 177 788 602 602 Fording River Operations 4,778 844 1,296 0 1,106 15,000 2,507 5,419 2,884 4,504 Elk Valley Total Forestry & Wildlife Habitat - Source: Teck 2014a,c,d,e,f,g. (a) (b) Totals are cumulative even though some areas may be treated more than once. Numbers were automatically generated from Geographic Information Systems datasets. Ongoing field surveys and data quality assurance/quality control continue to reconcile this information, which may result in slight variations between years. For an area to be recorded as “re-vegetated” it must have supported vegetation that will lead to the designated land use objective for at least one year. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 26 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.2.4.1.3 Teck Community and Land Stewardship In October 2013, as part of its commitment to biodiversity, Teck announced the purchase of three blocks of land from Tembec in BC, totaling approximately 7,150 ha. The intended use of these lands is the protection of key wildlife and fish habitat in the Elk Valley and Flathead River Valley. Teck will be working with communities of interest in the near future to determine potential management and stewardship approaches for the land (Teck 2013). Two blocks are located within or overlap the RSA and include: Alexander Creek: Approximately 10 km east of Sparwood, along the BC - Alberta border (3,098 ha; within the RSA); and Grave Prairie: Approximately 7.5 km northeast of Sparwood (3,059 ha; within the RSA). Teck is building relationships with regulators, First Nations, community leaders, and the public through partnerships, including the Elk Valley Bighorn Sheep Committee, the Regional Fish & Fish Habitat Committee and the Elk Valley Integrated Resource Task Force, to improve opportunities for consultation and collaboration on land and resource use management (Teck 2014h). In 2009, the inter-departmental Dust Management Task Force was formed to provide clearer direction and communication with a goal of minimizing fugitive dust emissions at EVO. Similar to other Teck operations, EVO relies on environmental awareness and good communication among all personnel to report dusting concerns so steps can be implemented quickly to prevent significant dusting events (Teck 2014a). N4.2.4.1.4 Other Mining Activities In addition to Teck operations, there are a number of coal exploration or development projects underway within the RSA. In 2013, Crowsnest Pass Coal Mining Ltd. carried out geological modelling, resource and pre-feasibility work at its Coal Creek property, south of Teck’s proposed Coal Mountain Phase 2 Project. Coal seams at Coal Creek are on the western limb of the Hosmer Ridge syncline in the Crowsnest Coalfield. Environmental baseline studies, including a water quality survey, are ongoing (BC MEM 2014). Centermount Coal’s proposed Bingay Creek coal project, located to the west of FRO, entered the environmental assessment process in 2012. It was anticipated that the mine would start production of clean coal in 2016 at one million tonnes and two million tonnes every year thereafter but in 2013 the Board of Directors of Centermount Coal Ltd. announced a suspension of the exploration and development program as the demand for steelmaking coal had fallen with the slippage in global iron ore production. The board decided that raising the major investment funds to complete a final economic feasibility study should await a market recovery in the prices for steel-making coal (Bingay Coal n.d.). In Alberta, two new coal mine projects in the Crowsnest Pass are in early exploration phases. Riversdale Resources has obtained a lease from Devon Energy, for an area northwest of Grassy Mountain (MacFarlane 2013). The company estimates potential production of at least two million tonnes per year, along with 100 new jobs and 700 spin-off jobs (Municipality of Crowsnest Pass 2013, pers. comm.). Altitude Resources Inc. (Altitude) has signed an exploration and option agreement with Elan Coal Ltd. (Elan), a privately owned Canadian coal exploration and development company. The agreement gives Altitude the option to acquire up to a 51% interest in Elan’s 22,000 ha of coal leases near Crowsnest Pass, as well as the right to conduct exploration activities on the leases (Stephenson 2013). Elan’s leases are adjacent to the Riversdale Resources property (Municipality of Crowsnest Pass 2013, pers. comm.). October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 27 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Mineral claims also exist across the RSA, including phosphate, lime, and stone. To the west of the LSA are several mineral claims held by High Brix Manufacturing Inc., Graymont Ltd., Fertoz Ltd. and Mr. Norman Lloyd Tribe. Fertoz Ltd. has three separate project footprints associated with its mineral claims (Barnes Lake, Marten and Crows Nest) referred to as the ‘Fernie Group’, which together cover 4,466 ha (Fertoz Ltd n.d.a, n.d.b). To the north of the LSA, Summit Natural Rock Inc. and American Manganese Inc. also have claims. American Manganese Inc. staked two claim blocks totaling 1,581 ha in 2014, historically known as “Line Creek/Mount Lyne” and “Fording River” (American Manganese Inc. 2014). N4.2.4.2 Local Study Area The Project footprint is located on fee simple land owned by Teck. Development of the Project will result in an estimated footprint area of approximately 2,665 ha. The total proposed disturbance area outside the existing C-2 permit boundary is approximately 898 ha. In addition to Teck’s activity, there is one coal licence and a further two coal licence applications held by CanAus Coal Ltd. (subsidiary of CoalMont Pty Ltd.) overlapping with the southeast corner of the LSA for the Michel Creek Hard Coking Coal Project. The Michel Creek Hard Coking Coal Project is located south of Highway #3 and east of Corbin Road (Figure N4.2-3). Recent exploration activity will contribute to a Preliminary Economic Assessment expected in 2014 to be followed by environmental baseline studies. The proponent is in the process of preparing a pre-feasibility study for this project. The total project footprint covers 6,144 ha (CoalMont Pty Ltd., 2015). Overlapping the northeast edge of the LSA is a coal licence application held by NWP Coal Canada Ltd. (subsidiary of Jameson Resources Ltd.) in support of the Crown Mountain Project. The Crown Mountain Project is located in the Elk Valley approximately 8 km northeast of EVO. A Preliminary Economic Assessment has confirmed potential robust economics for a low cost steelmaking coal mining operation (Jameson n.d.). Data required to initiate an environmental assessment process is being collected (Jameson 2014). In addition, one of American Manganese Inc.’s mineral claims overlaps the northern end while two claims held by Fertoz Ltd. associated with the Crows Nest and Marten projects overlap the southern end of the LSA. Site works on the Marten Project started in October 2014, and Fertoz Ltd. has approval for the collection of up to 10,000 tonnes bulk sample (Fertoz Ltd. n.d.a). The Dominion Coal Blocks are known to contain reserves of steelmaking coal (Standing Senate Committee on Energy, the Environment and Natural Resources, the Environment and Natural Resource Evidence 2013). The Dominion Coal Blocks comprise two parcels of Government of Canada fee simple owned land known as Parcel 73 (overlapping the LSA) and Parcel 82 (outside the LSA). Parcel 73 covers an area of approximately 2,000 ha and is located approximately 6.5 km south of the Project. These lands (and the sub-surface rights to the coal resources) were originally acquired by the Government of Canada in 1905 in exchange for a subsidy used for the construction of the Crowsnest Pass railway line linking BC and Alberta (Government of Canada 2014). The Government of Canada acquired these lands and the coal sub-surface rights under the terms of the Crow’s Nest Pass Agreement. The Dominion Coal Blocks have not been utilized for coal mining and processing purposes, mainly due to restrictions placed on the sale of coal from these lands under the Crow’s Nest Pass Agreement, which was assented to in 1897 (Standing Senate Committee on Energy, the Environment and Natural Resources, the Environment and Natural Resource Evidence 2013). In 2009, the federal government announced a Corporate Asset Management Review to examine opportunities for transferring assets to the October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 28 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT private sector, including the Dominion Coal Blocks, with the objective of stimulating additional economic activity (Standing Senate Committee on Energy, the Environment and Natural Resources, the Environment and Natural Resource Evidence 2013). The federal government brought forth a bill (C-4) to implement certain provisions of the March 2013 federal government budget, including provisions to facilitate the sale of the Dominion Coal Blocks. This legislation was given royal assent in 2013 and eliminates the liabilities for the Government of Canada under the Crow’s Nest Pass Agreement that have been the primary block to the development of these lands for coal mining purposes. The 2013 Economic Action Plan of the federal government noted that the government is continuing its preparations for the divestitures of the Dominion Coal Blocks, and that a sale will be conducted in a manner that maximizes benefits for taxpayers and in consultation with appropriate key stakeholders, including First Nations (Government of Canada 2014). The federal government, however, has committed to not sell the area of Parcel 82 that overlaps with the Flathead River Watershed. N4.2.5 Forestry N4.2.5.1 Regional Study Area Forestry in the RSA takes place on Crown land, on private managed forest land and on private agricultural lands (e.g., ranches). The BC FLNRO is the main agency responsible for protecting the public’s interest and providing leadership in the protection, management and use of BC’s forest and rangelands. High-level regulatory requirements for forestry on Crown land are compared to forestry on private managed forest land in Table N4.2-4. Table N4.2-4 Forestry Requirements on Crown and Private Land in British Columbia Forestry on Crown Land Forestry on Private Managed Forest Land Required to submit a forest management plan for approval by government. Not required to submit a plan for approval by government. Forest management plans must be consistent with objectives set by government. Must file a commitment to use the property for production and harvesting of timber and associated forest management activities. Forest management includes comprehensive array of timber and non-timber objectives and practices requirements. Protection limited to four key public values. Government issues permits for harvesting and road construction. Standard of practice for harvesting and road construction and maintenance similar to Crown land forestry. Sustainable harvest levels established by the Ministry of Forests Chief Forester. Land owner not constrained on level of harvest. Source: PMFLC 2007. The RSA overlaps with the Cranbrook timber supply area (TSA) which is administrative unit of Crown land managed for timber production amongst other objectives. The Cranbrook TSA has an annual allowable cut (AAC) of 904,000 m3. The area of operable forest on BC Crown land (i.e., Timber Harvest Land Base or THLB) in the RSA is 25,497 ha or 6.9% of the RSA. The area of Non-Timber Harvest Land Base (i.e., productive but inoperable forest) is 62,986 ha or 17.0% of the RSA. Taken together, these areas represent the total Crown Forest Land Base (88,483 ha or 23.9% of the RSA) (Figure N4.2-4). Within the Cranbrook TSA, Canfor purchased Tembec’s Crown rights to Forest Licence A19040, which provides an AAC of 477,652 m3 (FLNRO 2014b). Under A19040, harvesting has occurred to the east of the LSA in the Alexander Creek area. Also to the east, NWP Coal Canada Ltd. has received approval to harvest timber from its tenure area. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 29 660000 710000 ³ ! Longview 5600000 ! Invermere 5600000 610000 R RIV E EL K Fording River Operations W HI T E RIV E R A LB E R TA Elkford ! IE LUS S V U 43 Ä Ã 95A ! 22 _Elkview ^ Operations Ä Ã 5500000 Hosmer IC TE Y NA RI ! VE Fernie ! PROJECT LOCATION CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY RE E K ! PRIVATE OWNERSHIP WATERCOURSE STUDY AREA COMMUNITY COAL MINING OPERATION DOMINION COAL BLOCK REGIONAL STUDY AREA WATERBODY CROWN FOREST LAND BASE NON-HARVEST LAND BASE TIMBER HARVEST LAND BASE Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. Crown Forest Land Base data obtained from Tembec Inc. Ownership dataset put together by Golder in consultation with Teck Coal Limited. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 710000 25 MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY PRIMARY HIGHWAY BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER Pincher Creek Beaver ! Mines 660000 LOCAL STUDY AREA PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA SECONDARY HIGHWAY OLDMAN RESERVOIR Elko 610000 CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY REFERENCE C Coal Mountain Operations Ä Ã _ ^ Blairmore R LAKE KOOCANUSA ! ! 3 Wardner ! LEGEND L HE O KO Cranbrook ! Municipality of Crowsnest Pass M ! I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-013-GIS_ForestryRSA.mxd Coleman 3 5500000 R BULL RIVE R E R RIV Line Creek Operations Sparwood ! 5550000 B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A Ä Ã 5550000 Greenhills Operations 0 SCALE PROJECT TITLE 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT CROWN FOREST LAND BASE IN THE REGIONAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 06 Oct. 2015 SDL 06 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.2-4 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Canfor Corporation (Canfor) is the main forestry company operating in the Elk Valley. Canfor sources timber in the Elk Valley area from Crown lands via a Cranbrook TSA forest licence from Tembec’s Managed Forest 27 via a private forest land agreement with Tembec, and from Teck’s Managed Forest 471 2. In 2012, Canfor purchased the Elko sawmill (approximately 30 km south of Fernie) and Canal Flats sawmill (approximately 80 km north of Cranbrook) and certain timber harvesting rights to approximately 1.1 m3 of combined Crown, private land and contract AAC from Tembec (Tembec Inc. 2012). Canfor purchased the timber rights on Tembec owned private managed forest lands for a 10-year term, although Tembec retains the surface rights on these lands. Managed Forest 471 comprises most of the freehold surface tenure that Teck holds in the Elk Valley. There are two different agreements between Teck and Canfor for Managed Forest 471 lands: A Harvesting Rights Agreement gives Canfor the exclusive right to harvest, remove, sell, process or dispose of all timber including silviculture practices. Teck became the successor in title to Shell and Canfor has purchased timber rights from Tembec, which acquired Crestbrook Forest Industries Ltd. in 1999. Canfor’s rights are subject to Teck’s dominant user rights to explore for minerals and conduct mining and drilling operations, and to use or remove certain lands from Managed Forest 471 for mining-related purposes (Shell Canada Limited and Crestbrook Forest Industries Ltd. 1983). Under a Private Forest Lands Agreement, Teck is owner of the surface and timber rights, with Canfor granted rights to timber (Teck 2015c, pers. comm.). Tembec sold approximately 49,000 ha of lands covered by Managed Forest 27 to Jemi Fibre Corp in 2014. These lands now make up Managed Forest 482, which overlap parts of the RSA, and represent approximately 6.2 million m3 of mature timber. Jemi Fibre Corp has announced plans to cut between 300,000 to 400,000 m3 of timber per year for the next five to 10 years before reverting to a sustainable cut of 125,000 cubic metres per year following that period (The Free Press 2015). Managed Forest 27 now has approximately 850 ha of lands located near Sparwood, Fernie, St. Mary’s Lake, and Morrissey (Tembec Inc. 2015). The Ktunaxa Nation Community Forest covers approximately 20,000 ha over two parcels (Parcels 73 and 82) of Government of Canada owned land in the East Kootenay collectively known as the Dominion Coal Blocks (Ktunaxa Nation 2013). The Ktunaxa Nation has operated a community forest since 2004 under a pilot project agreement with the Government of BC. In 2009 the Ktunaxa Nation signed a 25-year community forest agreement with the Province, which features annual harvesting rights for 5,790 m3 of timber on the Dominion Coal Blocks (BC Ministry of Forests and Range 2009). This community forest arrangement falls under a memorandum of understanding between the Ktunaxa Nation, Government of Canada and Government of BC (Standing Senate Committee on Energy, the Environment and Natural Resources, the Environment and Natural Resource Evidence 2013). 2 Managed Forest’ is a property tax classification, which includes certain forestry practice obligations that a landowner must comply to maintain the Managed Forest designation. Teck owns the land within the boundaries of Managed Forest 471 and therefore is responsible for payment of property taxes on the lands within Managed Forest 471 and for managing compliance on Managed Forest 471 lands with Managed Forest obligations. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 31 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.2.5.2 Local Study Area The majority of the LSA is privately owned (94%) and covered by managed forests, including 13,151 ha of Managed Forest 471 and 1,089 ha of Managed Forest 482 and Managed Forest 27. The Project is surrounded by Managed Forest 471, while Managed Forest 482 is located in the northern and southern ends of the LSA and Managed Forest 27 is located near Sparwood. Under an agreement with Teck, Canfor has the exclusive right (in perpetuity) to harvest, sell, process, or dispose of all timber on Managed Forest 471 land. Teck owns the land within the boundaries of Managed Forest 471. Canfor’s rights are subject to Teck’s dominant user rights to explore for minerals, to conduct mining and drilling operations, and to use or remove minor amounts of certain areas from Managed Forest 471 land. Under the Harvesting Rights Agreement, Teck is obligated to compensate Canfor for costs incurred by Canfor from Teck’s exploration, mining, drilling and other related activities. Canfor reimburses Teck for all property taxes on Managed Forest 471 land. Teck must maintain the status of Managed Forest 471 as Managed Forest Land. There is no operable forest on Crown land (i.e., Timber Harvesting Land Base) in the LSA. The area of nonharvest land base (i.e., productive but inoperable forest) on Crown land in the LSA is 39 ha (Figure N4.2-5). There are 321 ha of available, permitted and proposed Canfor harvest areas in the LSA (Figure N4.2-6). Canfor has the exclusive right to harvest, sell, process, or dispose of all timber under the Managed Forest 27 Harvesting Rights Agreement (Shell Canada Limited and Crestbrook Forest Industries Ltd. 1983). Canfor’s rights are subject to Teck dominant user rights to explore for minerals, conduct mining and drilling operations, and to use or remove certain lands from Managed Forest 471 lands. Timber harvesting occurs in the Ktunaxa Nation Community Forest on Parcel 73 of the Dominion Coal Blocks which overlaps the southern edge of the LSA. The Ktunaxa Nation Community Forest is managed by Ktunaxa Nation-owned Nupqu Development Corporation (Nupqu). As of 2010, Nupqu had revenues of over $4 million per annum and 60 employees (70% are Ktunaxa Nation members) during the peak of its operating season (Section C of the EAC Application). October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 32 660000 GR E AV CR 670000 EE K ³ M E C RE EK ME R K EE DR Y CR EK CREE K CRE CUMMINGS IL HAR 5520000 DALZ ELL CREE K SI X 5520000 650000 V U EV O 43 B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A Sparwood Ä Ã IC HE 3 L CR EE K ER ICKS ON K EE CR FIR M CC O O L CR EE ! Crowsnest 5500000 5500000 K Hazell RI VE R ! A LB E R TA EL K I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-003-GIS-Forestry.mxd RO BE RT CR EE K CREE K LLADNAR CREEK 5510000 ALEXA NDER CREE K M 5510000 ! LEGEND ! 650000 660000 CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY LOCAL STUDY AREA PRIMARY HIGHWAY PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 PRIVATE OWNERSHIP WATERBODY TIMBER HARVEST LAND BASE ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY REFERENCE Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. Crown Forest Land Base data obtained from Tembec Inc. Ownership dataset put together by Golder in consultation with Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE 1:140,000 PROJECT CROWN FOREST LAND BASE NON-HARVEST LAND BASE 670000 4 TITLE 4 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT CROWN FOREST LAND BASE IN THE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.2-5 0 660000 GR E AV CR 670000 EE K ³ M E C RE EK ME R K EE DR Y CR EK CREE K CRE CUMMINGS IL HAR 5520000 DALZ ELL CREE K SI X 5520000 650000 V U EV O 43 B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A ALEXA NDER CREE K IC HE Ä Ã 3 L CR EE K ER ICKS ON EE FIR CR EE K CR RT BE RO M CC O O L CR EE 5500000 5500000 K ! Crowsnest RI VE R Hazell LEGEND ! CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY 650000 CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY LOCAL STUDY AREA REFERENCE ! A LB E R TA EL K I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-016-GIS_CanforHarvestLSA.mxd K CREE K LLADNAR CREEK 5510000 ! M 5510000 Sparwood 660000 MANAGED FOREST 471 BOUNDARY (HARVEST RIGHTS AGREEMENT) MANAGED FOREST 471 BOUNDARY (PRIVATE LANDS AGREEMENT) MANAGED FOREST 482 BOUNDARY PRIVATE OWNERSHIP WATERBODY AVAILABLE BLOCK HARVESTED BLOCK PERMITTED BLOCK PROPOSED BLOCK Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. Forestry data obtained from Tembec Inc. Ownership dataset put together by Golder in consultation with Teck Coal Limited All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE 1:140,000 PROJECT PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA HARVEST AREA BOUNDARIES 670000 4 TITLE 4 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT CANFOR HARVESTS IN THE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.2-6 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.2.6 Oil and Gas Development N4.2.6.1 Regional Study Area The RSA overlaps with the East Kootenay Basin (EKB), which extends from approximately 60 km north-northwest of Elkford to nearly 35 km south of Fernie and encompasses the community of Sparwood. The EKB is bounded to the east by the BC - Alberta border and its western boundary follows the west edge of the Elk Valley’s western edge. In 2011, BC Oil and Gas Commission estimated that 15% of coal bed methane (a type of natural gas) in BC is located within the EKB (BC Oil and Gas Commission 2011). Petroleum and Natural Gas tenure rights, issued by the Ministry of Energy and Mine’s Titles Division, cover 29,354 ha of the RSA and are centred around EVO and FRO. However, no active wells are located within the RSA (Figure N4.2-7). N4.2.6.2 Local Study Area There are no oil and gas wells overlapping EVO or the Project footprint, but four non-active gas well sites are located south of EVO within the LSA (Figure N4.2-8). A petroleum title belonging to Apache Canada Ltd. (Apache) lies within the LSA and covers the southern end of EVO and parts of the Project footprint. The original lease expired in 2010 but Apache has maintained the lease through a special extension. Apache acquired this lease upon purchasing British Petroleum’s Canadian assets in 2010. The petroleum project is called the Mist Mountain Project. Apache has not undertaken development activities recently on the Mist Mountain Project and development is not anticipated in the near future. Teck and Apache have the Elk Valley Petroleum and Natural Gas Appraisal and Development Agreement in place. Under the terms of this agreement, Teck and Apache have annual Joint Development Committee meetings to determine best land use and resource extraction practices (BP Canada Energy Company and Elk Valley Coal Partnership 2006a,b). October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 35 660000 710000 ! ³ ! Longview Invermere 5600000 5600000 610000 EL K RIVE R Fording River Operations IV E 5550000 GR R 5550000 DIN Greenhills Operations R FO WHI T E RIVE R BR IT IS H C OL UM BI A Elkford ! LUS S BUL L RIVER 43 Sparwood Ä Ã 95A Ä Ã IV ER V U 22 Elkview Operations ! Ä Ã Coleman 5500000 3 ! ! Blairmore OLDMAN RESERVOIR IC EN M OT HE L R AY IV E Fernie R ! Cranbrook ! Municipality of Crowsnest Pass Hosmer KO CANCELLED ! CASED RE E Coal Mountain Operations ! WELL LOCATION ABANDONED C K Pincher Creek ! Beaver ! Mines Ä Ã I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-021-GIS_RSAWells.mxd ALB ER TA _ ^ 5500000 IE R R Line Creek Operations 3 Wardner COMPLETED GAS TESTING SUSPENDED WELL AUTHORIZATION GRANTED LEGEND ! _ ^ ! Elko 610000 CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY PROJECT LOCATION CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER LAKE KOOCANUSA 660000 FIRST NATIONS RESERVE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA WATERBODY COAL MINING OPERATION REFERENCE PROJECT REGIONAL STUDY AREA STUDY AREA COMMUNITY Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. Wells obtained from the BC Oil & Gas Commission and are for representation purposes only. The Oil & Gas Commission assumes neither responsibility for inconsistencies or inaccuracies in the data nor liability for any damages of any type arising from errors or omissions. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY PETROLEUM ACTIVE TITLE 710000 25 TITLE 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT GAS WELLS IN THE REGIONAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.2-7 0 660000 GR E AV CR 670000 EE K ³ X M E CR EE K ME R EE K DR Y CR EK CREEK CRE CUMMINGS IL HAR 5520000 DALZELL CREE K SI 5520000 650000 V U EV O 43 BR IT IS H C OL UM BI A ALEXANDER CREEK H IC EL CR Ä Ã 3 K EE ERICKSON RO FIR M CC WELL LOCATION O CR K EE L O ABANDONED CR K R VE RI 5500000 CASED K PETROLEUM ACTIVE TITLE EL ! NO UNAUTHORIZED ENTRY AREA ALB ER TA SPARWOOD RIDGE RESTRICTED AREA ! 650000 CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PIPELINE PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT FOOTPRINT BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT FOOTPRINT OUTSIDE THE CURRENT C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY REFERENCE Hazell ! MUNICIPAL NO SHOOTING LEGEND Crowsnest 5500000 CANCELLED EE I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-017-GIS_LSAWells.mxd BE RT CR EE K CREE K LLADNAR CREEK 5510000 ! M 5510000 Sparwood 660000 BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY LOCAL STUDY AREA PERMITTED COARSE COAL REFUSE PILE TAILINGS FACILITY PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA WATERBODY Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. Wells obtained from the BC Oil & Gas Commission and are for representation purposes only. The Oil & Gas Commission assumes neither responsibility for inconsistencies or inaccuracies in the data nor liability for any damages of any type arising from errors or omissions. Pipelines obtained from IHS Energy Inc. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 670000 4 0 SCALE 1:140,000 PROJECT TITLE 4 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT GAS WELLS IN THE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW SR 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 06 Oct. 2015 SDL 06 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.2-8 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.2.7 Non-Timber Forest Products Non-timber forest products (NTFPs) 3 include wild edibles, floral greenery, medicinals and nutraceuticals, landscaping and restoration products, crafts and art, miscellaneous products, and forest-based cultural tourism or ecotourism. NTFPs are harvested for traditional, recreational, and commercial purposes. While recreational harvesting of NTFPs is relatively steady on an annual basis, commercial harvesting levels vary in response to weather and timber harvesting that affect growing conditions for NTFPs, the market price for NTFPs, and general economic conditions (NTFP Harvesting Representative 2015, pers. comm.). Traditional (cultural) and commercial harvesting of NTFPs by the Ktunaxa Nation is considered in Section C. N4.2.7.1 Regional Study Area Key NTFP species in the Elk Valley include huckleberries and morel mushrooms (Mitchell, Sinclair, Brigham, Cocksedge, & Hobby 2010; NTFP Harvesting Representative 2015, pers. comm.; BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). The Elk Valley has been anecdotally identified as a prime area for harvesting huckleberries in the East Kootenay, but the most productive contemporary huckleberry sites have generally been logged and broadcast burnt because huckleberry bushes re-establish faster than other bushes (Hobby and Keefer 2010; NTFP Harvesting Representative 2015, pers. comm.). Huckleberry harvesting in the Elk Valley generally starts the third week of July and ends by October, as some harvesters prefer to wait until after first frost to harvest huckleberries (BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). Due to ease of accessibility, the most popular huckleberry sites in the RSA are located near communities and main roads, including sites near Hosmer, Ridgemont, Corbin town site, Fernie, and Morrissey. South of the LSA, old burn and recent logging sites around the headwaters of Wheeler, Marten, and Coal Creeks, located adjacent to 4x4 accessible roads, have also been identified as popular huckleberry harvesting locations, though they are not as heavily used as more accessible sites. The area around Wheeler, Marten, and Coal Creeks was particularly productive in 2014, but due to dry conditions the harvest in 2015 in these areas was low (BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). Other identified huckleberry harvesting sites include Fir Roberts Road, Alexander Creek, Corbin Creek, Fernie Alpine Resort, Lizard Creek near Fernie, west of Morrissey, and the Flathead Valley (NTFP Harvesting Representative 2015, pers. comm.; BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). In the Elk Valley, almost all huckleberry harvesters are recreationists (NTFP Harvesting Representative 2015, pers. comm.; BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). In 2005 and 2006, a survey of some recreational huckleberry harvesters in the Kootenay region reported an average harvest of 11.34 kg of huckleberries per person per year, with an average of 8 days of harvesting per season (Hobby and Keefer 2010). By comparison, commercial harvesters reported harvesting between 9 kg and 544 kg per year, and harvesting between 10 and 40 days annually. The overall range of net income from commercially harvested huckleberries in the Kootenay region is estimated to average $1,000 in a low production year and $2,000 in a high production year (Hobby and Keefer 2010). 3 Sometimes referred to as wildcrafters. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 38 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Harvesting of morels and other mushrooms in the Elk Valley generally begins in September and continues into October, with harvesting occurring after rainfalls (BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). Morels are known for fruiting following major wildfire events, but otherwise their location is difficult to predict (Keefer et al. 2010; NTFP Harvesting Representative 2015, pers. comm.; BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). Morel mushrooms are typically harvested recreationally on an incidental basis in conjunction with other activities such as hunting, fishing, or ATVing, while commercial harvesters focus on areas that have experienced wildfires (CBC News 2015; NTFP Harvesting Representative 2015, pers. comm.; BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). As a result, recreationists undertake most morel harvesting in the Elk Valley (Keefer et al. 2010; BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). In 2005 and 2006, a survey reported the average daily earnings for commercial harvesters in the East Kootenay region as $91.30, with the majority of commercial harvesters earning less than 10% of their total annual income from harvesting morels (Keefer et al. 2010). Other NTFP species harvested in the Elk Valley include Saskatoon berries, grouse berries, bilberries, elderberries, choke cherries, lomatium root, king bolete mushrooms, porcini mushrooms, hedgehog mushrooms, chanterelles mushrooms, and shaggy mane mushrooms (Hobby and Keefer 2010; NTFP Harvesting Representative 2015, pers. comm.; BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). Saskatoon berry harvesting sites were identified along the bottom of the Elk Valley and near the communities of Sparwood and Fernie. King bolete mushrooms are reported to occur more often in areas with cattle, while shaggy mane mushrooms are reportedly more common around logging roads (BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). These species are harvested on a recreational basis in the Elk Valley as they do not occur in large quantities and are not in commercial demand. Commercial harvesting of native plant seeds occurs in the Elk Valley in response to demand from Teck in support of mine reclamation (NTFP Harvesting Representative 2015, pers. comm.). N4.2.7.2 Local Study Area Huckleberry harvesting was not identified near EVO because the area is generally too dry and cold for growth of huckleberry bushes, but huckleberries are harvested on naturally re-vegetated slopes around Sparwood and between Sparwood and Hosmer to the east of Highway #3 (NTFP Harvesting Representative 2015, pers. comm.; BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). Harvesting of saskatoon berries was also identified as occurring around Sparwood (BC MOE 2015, pers. comm.). Morel mushroom harvesting was not identified near EVO, but as previously cited the presence of morels is tied to wildfire events and predicting their location is difficult. N4.2.8 Wildlife and Fish Harvesting Wildlife and fish harvesting occurs throughout the RSA and is done by local residents who hunt and fish for sport and food, as well as trappers who hunt furbearing animals for commercial purposes. Hunting and fishing guides operate in the RSA. Traditional hunting and fishing by First Nations also occurs in the RSA for food, social and cultural purposes. Information on traditional land and resource use can be found in Section C of the EAC Application. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 39 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT For the purposes of administering the BC Wildlife Act (1996; amended in 2004) and BC hunting regulations, the province is divided into wildlife management units (WMU). The RSA is located within Resource Management Region 4 (Kootenay Region) and largely overlaps WMU 4-23. For BC residents, a BC Resident Hunter Number Card is required to purchase hunting and species licences. In addition to the hunting licences, species licences are required for most large mammals. Hunters may apply for a licence to hunt in special limited entry hunt areas, which are allocated by lottery (Figure N4.2-9). The limited entry management tool is used to achieve wildlife management objectives without resorting to measures such as shortening seasons or completely closing areas. Five authorizations were issued for the 2014 spring grizzly bear hunt in WMU 4-23 (FLNRO n.d.[b]). In BC, non-resident hunters must be accompanied by either a licenced guide or a resident holding a Permit to Accompany. The hunting season for deer occurs primarily between September and November, while the elk season is concentrated in September and October. Regular hunting for moose occurs in the latter half of October. Black bear hunting season is open in the fall (between September and November) and again in the spring (between April and June). Information on hunting season by species for WMU 4-23 is provided in Appendix N.II. In Region 4, daily catch quotas apply to trout, char, burbot, crayfish, kokanee and whitefish. All fishing is closed for northern pike, bass, walleye, white sturgeon and yellow perch. No fishing is allowed in any stream in Region 4 from April 1 to June 14. Trout/char catch and release occurs between June 15 and October 31 within the Elk River, from the Line Creek Bridge to the Canadian Pacific rail bridge at Sparwood and from the Highway #3 bridge at Hosmer to the northern Highway #3 bridge at Fernie (BC MOE 2013). One-day, eight-day and annual angling licences are available to residents and non-residents of BC, although non-residents must pay more for their licence. In addition to the basic angling licence, a Classified Waters Licence is required before fishing on streams designated as such. Many East Kootenay rivers and their tributaries are classified waters, including the Elk River and its tributaries (FLNRO n.d.[d]). Classified waters in BC are specially designated trout streams, and the designation is intended to maintain their fishing opportunities, which contribute significantly to the province's reputation as a world class fishing destination. A Classified Waters Licence allows BC residents to fish on any classified water during the licensing year (from April 1 to March 31). For Non-Residents, the Classified Waters Licence is sold on a per diem basis and is date- and water-specific. Although anglers may purchase as many Classified Waters Licences as they wish, each licence may not exceed eight consecutive days (FLNRO n.d.[c]). In 2015, it was announced that Michel Creek would be established as its own classified water, while simultaneously removing it from the larger Elk River Classified Water designation. As part of this change, a new booking system was also announced for non-resident anglers along Michel Creek, which has seen non-resident, non-guided angler use exceed targets, resulting in overcrowding and pressure on fish populations. Under the new system, a set amount of non-resident, non-guided angler days will be made available through the existing online angling licensing system. Selections will be made on a first-come, first-serve system, ensuring all non-resident anglers have an equal opportunity. Once these days are sold, non-resident anglers will have to book through a licenced angling guide to fish on Michel Creek (FLNRO 2015a). October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 40 660000 710000 ³ 5600000 ! Longview Invermere R RIV E EL K IVE R B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A A LB E R TA Elkford ! IE LUS S 43 Ä Ã 95A 22 Elkview _Operations ^ Sparwood Fish & Wildlife Association Gun Range ! Ä Ã 5500000 3 L C E TE Y NA ! RI VE Fernie R Ä Ã I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-007-GIS-RSAHunting.mxd Hosmer H IC O KO Cranbrook ! Municipality of Crowsnest Pass 3 Wardner ! Blairmore OLDMAN RESERVOIR ! M ! Coleman 5500000 BULL RIVE R R V U Ä Ã E R RIV Line Creek Operations Sparwood ! 5550000 GR 5550000 Fording River Operations DIN Greenhills Operations R FO W HI T E RIV E R ! 5600000 610000 RE E Coal Mountain Operations K Pincher ! Creek Beaver Mines ! Fernie Rod & Gun Club Range LIMITED ENTRY HUNTING ZONE ELK GOAT LAKE KOOCANUSA LEGEND ! _ ^ GRIZZLY ! 610000 CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY PROJECT LOCATION CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER COAL MINING OPERATION 660000 GUIDE TENURE AREA PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA PROJECT REGIONAL STUDY AREA STUDY AREA COMMUNITY WATERBODY Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. Limited entry hunting zone & guide outfitter areas obtained from the LRDW. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE LOCAL STUDY AREA MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY 710000 25 FIRST NATIONS RESERVE EXISTING NO SHOOTING / NO UNAUTHORIZED ENTRY REFERENCE MOOSE Elko 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT TITLE GUIDE TENURES AND LIMITED ENTRY HUNTING IN THE REGIONAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. FIGURE N4.2-9 0 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT In BC, approximately 3,500 trappers actively harvest 17 furbearing animal species, following standards, legislation and regulations developed by the Ministry of Environment. An estimated half of the province’s trappers are Aboriginal persons. In general, trapping seasons have been developed by considering a variety of criteria including pelt condition, relative vulnerability of age and sex classes to harvesting, abundance and capture technology. The registered trapline system is the primary system for setting harvest guidelines and managing furbearing animals. Harvest levels are guided by species management strategies, with furbearers divided into the following three classes. Class 1 Species – can be managed on individual traplines. This class includes the beaver, fox, marten, mink, muskrat, racoon, skunk, squirrel and weasel. Class 2 Species – move between and among traplines and thus are not manageable on individual traplines. Harvests will be regulated regionally, in consultation with local trappers. This class includes the lynx, bobcat, wolverine, fisher and otter. Class 3 Species – also move between and among traplines, but generally are not vulnerable to over-trapping. This class includes the wolf and coyote. Trappers will be encouraged to trap these species especially in areas of chronic animal damage control problems. Trappers must register trapline cabins that are on Crown land. The trapping season starts in the fall, in October and November. Trapping for bobcat, fox, lynx, marten, mink, weasel, skunk and wolverine ends in January or February, while trapping for beaver, black bear, coyote, muskrat, racoon, otter, squirrel and wolf ends in the spring between March and May. Trapping season information by species for WMU 4-23 is provided in Appendix N.II. N4.2.8.1 Regional Study Area Hunting is carried out in forested areas throughout the RSA (Figure N4.2-9). Within WMU 4-23, an annual average of 1,059 hunters targeted elk between 2002 and 2012. 4 This was followed by white tailed deer (693 hunters per year), mule deer (630 hunters per year) and moose (173 hunters per year). Hunting activity grew between 2002 and 2012 in WMU 4-23, with the total number of hunters increasing by over 1,000 across all species (54% increase) and the number of hunting days increasing by close to 16,000 (61% increase). The total number of kills declined by close to 500 animals over the same period, but most of this was driven by declines in Spruce Grouse and Blue Grosbeak. While 2012 saw the highest number of hunters and hunter days at close to 4,000 and 41,500, respectively, the number of kills peaked in 2010 at approximately 2,000 animals. Between 2002 and 2012, there was a significant increase in the number of moose hunters (over 800% increase) and moose kills (close to 190% increase). Over the same period, the number of moose kills per hunter day and per hunter declined. In 2002, the average moose hunter hunted for 3.8 days and harvested 0.5 moose on average and in 2012 there was an average of 10.41 days and 0.16 kills per hunter (FLNRO 2013, pers. comm.). Hunting data are presented in Appendix N.III. 4 Hunters targeting more than one species will be double-counted, i.e. a hunter targeting three different species will be counted as three hunters. Therefore this is an overestimation of the number of hunters active within WMU 4-23. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 42 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT The Elk River is popular for fishing for cutthroat trout, whitefish and bull trout. Fly fishers access the river by using a boat or “walk and wade” into the river. Based on a 2002 survey, it was estimated that there were 2,500 angling days on the Elk River by residents (FLNRO 2014c, pers. comm.). Outside of the LSA, Summit Lake (to the east) was identified as a popular fishing location. To the north of the LSA, Grave Lake is the only large, accessible lake in the Elk Valley where a variety of lake-orientated recreational opportunities are possible (RDEK 2014). Crown lands in the RSA within BC are blanketed by trapline tenures (Figure N4.2-10). As part of its Community Investment funds, Teck provided approximately $23,000 in support of local hunting and fishing clubs based in the RSA in 2013. The following hunting and fishing clubs and organizations are active in the RSA. East Kootenay Wildlife Association: The East Kootenay Wildlife Association is a regional body of the BC Wildlife Federation (BCWF), a province-wide voluntary federation of conservation organizations having hunters, anglers and recreational shooters as members (BCWF 2010). The East Kootenay Wildlife Association represents about 1,900 members across six clubs in Canal Flats, Sparwood, Elkford, Fernie, Golden and Invermere. The East Kootenay Wildlife Association hosts events to promote outdoor activities and education (e.g., hunter safety courses) and support wildlife conservation through fundraising and volunteerism. Fernie Rod and Gun Club: The Fernie Rod and Gun Club, formed in 1899, is the oldest hunting, fishing and archery club in BC and has approximately 300 members. Membership has doubled in recent years, which is attributed to the club’s engagement with the community and with youth. Members often volunteer to conduct wildlife conservation work. Membership fees go to the BCWF, range costs (i.e., leasing land from Tembec and insurance), events and equipment. The Fernie Rod and Gun Club has an archery range and provides guns and youth bows for weekly youth shoots. Hunter members focus on large game (e.g., deer, elk, moose, bear, sheep and goats) primarily for food, with some trophy hunting. Those who fish in the Elk Valley, do so for cutthroat and rainbow trout in the Elk River. Sparwood Fish and Wildlife Association: The Sparwood Fish and Wildlife Association’s membership includes approximately 150 family and individual members. Facilities operated by the Sparwood Fish and Wildlife Association include a campsite at Grave Lake on Teck owned land. Membership fees cover the use of the group’s rifle range, membership in BCWF, insurance and lease fees paid to Teck. Hunters focus on large game, with elk and deer the most commonly hunted animals. Members hunt for moose, mountain goat, bighorn sheep and black bear. A few members hunt cougar on occasion. Most members are hunting for food but there is some trophy hunting. Anglers fish for whitefish and cutthroat, rainbow, and bull trout in the Elk Valley’s rivers and streams. The membership is represented by more hunters than anglers (although many hunters also fish), and the club is working to encourage younger hunters and anglers to join. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 43 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Elkford Rod and Gun Club: The Elkford Rod and Gun Club’s membership is about 240 families and individuals and has been increasing every year for over a decade. Similar to the other groups, club fees cover membership in BCWF and insurance. The club is engaged in wildlife conservation work including annual wildlife counts (e.g., identifying elk wintering areas) and clearing dead fall to encourage grass growth. Elk and mule deer are the species most commonly hunted by members. A limited number of members (i.e., approximately 15%) hunt for bighorn sheep and mountain goat. Grouse hunting occurs, but usually in conjunction with large game hunting. Hunting and wildlife management is emphasized more than fishing, but those who hunt fish on occasion. Hillcrest Fish and Game Protective Association: Hillcrest Fish and Game Protective Association, which is affiliated with the Alberta Fish and Game Association, was started in 1925. The mandate of the association is to promote responsible use of fish, wildlife and habitat. Membership stands at between 160 and 200 members. Hillcrest Fish and Game Protective Association engages in river clean-up activities, but these activities are limited to Alberta. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 44 660000 710000 ! ³ ! Longview Invermere 5600000 5600000 610000 EL K RIVE R Fording River Operations R FO WHI T E RIVE R DIN R BR IT IS H C OL UM BI A Elkford ! LUS S BUL L RIVER 43 Sparwood Ä Ã IV ER V U 22 ALB ER TA _ ^ Elkview Operations ! Ä Ã Ä Ã Coleman 5500000 3 ! Hosmer Blairmore OLDMAN RESERVOIR IC OT HE L C EN RE E K R AY IV Coal Mountain Operations Fernie ! ! M KO ER Cranbrook ! ! Municipality of Crowsnest Pass 5500000 IE R R Line Creek Operations 95A Pincher Creek Beaver ! Mines Ä Ã I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-011-GIS_RSATraplines.mxd 5550000 IV E 5550000 GR Greenhills Operations ! 3 Wardner ! LAKE KOOCANUSA ! Elko 610000 LEGEND ! _ ^ CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY PROJECT LOCATION CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY 660000 FIRST NATIONS RESERVE MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY PRIMARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE STUDY AREA COMMUNITY SECONDARY HIGHWAY REGIONAL STUDY AREA BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER TRAPLINE TENURE REFERENCE WATERBODY Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. Trapping area data obtained from the LRDW. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA COAL MINING OPERATION 710000 25 PROJECT TITLE 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT TRAPLINE TENURES IN THE REGIONAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. 0 FIGURE N4.2-10 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.2.8.2 Local Study Area Hunting for large game occurs in the LSA, primarily for black bear, elk, deer and moose. Hunting areas identified include Harmer Creek (northeast of EVO), to the west of the Elk River, and south of Highway #3. The LSA is easily accessible through a combination of trails and forestry roads. Teck allows public access to its private property for hunting and fishing outside of the No Unauthorized Entry Area. Based on interviews for preparation of this baseline, hunting appears to be particularly concentrated to the north of the Project footprint, with an estimated 1,200 and 2,300 hunting days (or approximately 80% of the total hunting within the LSA). Hunting areas corresponding to the seasonal calendars prepared in the mapping sessions are shown in Figure N4.2-11. Within the LSA, fishing activities were identified as occurring along the Elk River and Michel Creek. North of Sparwood, it was estimated that between 15 and 20 fishers use the Elk River daily during summer and early fall. Michel Creek, located to the southeast of the Project footprint, is popular for angling along its length with a high level of general public and guided use. No other angling locations were identified in the LSA. Sheep Mountain Outfitters, which has been operating in the Elk Valley for approximately 30 years, has a guiding tenure that overlaps a small portion of the LSAs southwestern corner (565 ha), but is located on the other side of Highway #3 from EVO (Figure N4.2-11). The total size of the tenure is 62,942 ha. Ten trapline tenures overlap the LSA (Figure N4.2-12): TR0423T004 (176.7 ha); TR0423T005 (727.7 ha); TR0423T006 (6.9 ha); TR0423T007 (1,177.7 ha); TR0423T008 (7.8 ha); TR0423T009 (106.1 ha); TR0423T010 (117.4 ha); TR0423T021 (4,540.6 ha); TR0423T022 (1,467.7 ha); and TR0423T023 (15,331.0 ha). October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 46 660000 GR DALZELL CREE K CR EE K ³ Grave Prairie AMA SI A X M E CR EE K ME R EK CREEK CRE CUMMINGS IL HAR 5520000 E AV 670000 5520000 650000 V U 43 B EV O Y DR CR K EE Alexander Creek AMA BR IT IS H C OL UM BI A Sparwood EL 3 CR ERICKSON CR FIR RO M CC O L O CR ! Crowsnest TENURE # 400402 ELK GOAT ! CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY 650000 MUNICIPAL NO SHOOTING NO UNAUTHORIZED ENTRY AREA CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE SPARWOOD RIDGE RESTRICTED AREA ACCESS MANAGEMENT AREA (AMA) UNGULATE WINTER RANGE - LEGAL BOUNDARY BRITISH COLUMBIA - ALBERTA BORDER DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY REFERENCE WATERBODY A-C GROUP INTERVIEW HUNTING AREA Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. Access Management Areas obtained from the BC Ministry of Environment. ATV trail data obtained from the Elkford ATV Club. LEH Zones and Ungulate winter range obtained from the LRDW. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 670000 4 LOCAL STUDY AREA TRAIL / ACCESS ROAD ! 660000 GUIDE TENURE AREA NON-MOTORIZED TRAIL Hazell ALB ER TA Corbin Creek AMA GRIZZLY AND MOOSE LEGEND 5500000 K LIMITED ENTRY HUNTING ZONE EL 5500000 RI VE R K EE I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-005-GIS-LSAHunting.mxd BE RT EE K CR EE K CREE K LLADNAR CREEK K EE C 5510000 Ä Ã H IC TENURE # 400806 ALEXANDER CREEK M 5510000 ! 0 SCALE 1:140,000 PROJECT 4 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT TITLE HUNTING IN THE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. 0 FIGURE N4.2-11 660000 GR CR EE K ³ DALZELL CREE K TR0423T010 5520000 E AV 670000 TR0423T022 SI X M E CR TR0423T021 EE K HAR CUMMINGS IL 5520000 650000 ME R 43 EV O Y DR CR K EE TR0423T006 EK V U CRE CREEK TR0423T009 BR IT IS H C OL UM BI A TR0423T007 TR0423T023 5510000 ! M 5510000 Sparwood Ä Ã H IC EL 3 CR K EE AN DE RC RE EK CREE K LLADNAR CREEK ERICKSON K EE CR FIR BE RO M CC O O TR0423T005 L CR 5500000 5500000 K EE ! Crowsnest RI VE R TR0423T004 K 650000 LEGEND ! LOCAL STUDY AREA PRIMARY HIGHWAY NO UNAUTHORIZED ENTRY AREA CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY REFERENCE ! 660000 CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER Hazell ALB ER TA EL I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-014-GIS_LSATraplines.mxd RT CR EE K AL EX TR0423T008 PROJECT PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA SPARWOOD RIDGE RESTRICTED AREA WATERBODY Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. Trapline Tenures obtained from LRDW. Access Management Areas obtained from the BC Ministry of Environment. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE 1:140,000 MUNICIPAL NO SHOOTING TRAPLINE TENURE 670000 4 TITLE 4 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT TRAPLINE TENURES IN THE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 06 Oct. 2015 SDL 06 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. 0 FIGURE N4.2-12 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT In the LSA, the most active trapline was TR0423T008 with over 100 animals harvested between 2008 and 2012, the majority of which were marten. The TR0423T009 trapline reported 74 harvested animals between 2008 and 2010, distributed between marten, squirrel and weasel. The TR0423T004 trapline reported 62 animals, primarily focussing on marten between 2008 and 2012, while the TR0423T010 trapline reported 40 marten over the same time period. Sporadic activity was recorded on the TR0423T005 and TR0423T006 traplines. Further trapping activity information by species for the LSA is provided in Appendix N.IV. Three registered traplines in the LSA, TR0423T021, TR0423T022, and TR0423T023, overlap EVO on Teck private property. The TR0423T021 trapline reported consistent trapping activity before 2008, but no harvesting between 2008 and 2012. The TR0423T022 trapline has no recorded harvesting activity since 1986 (FLNRO 2014d, pers. comm.). The TR0423T021 and TR0423T022 traplines are amalgamated and controlled by the same trapper, and Teck has one trapping licence with the trapline holder for each of TR0423T021 and TR0423T022 traplines that permit use of Teck’s privately owned lands. The trapping licence applicable for TR0423T021 was originally signed in 2011 and is currently renewed annually, but Teck may terminate this licence at any time upon giving 60 days’ notice (Agreement between Teck and holder of TR0423T021 2011). Targeted species include wolves, coyotes, lynx, bobcats, marten, and occasionally beaver. Trapping locations vary between years, but consistent trapping was identified along Harmer Creek, Grave Creek, and the upper reaches of Grave Creek. Both access roads following Harmer Creek are used to access trapping areas. Grave Lake may be used for trapping wolves or beaver, but typically is not heavily used for trapping due to the amount of recreational activity that occurs near the lake. Although part of EVO’s No Unauthorized Entry Area is included in the trapping licence for the TR0423T021 trapline, this was not identified as an area of use. Trapping in the TR0423T021 and TR0423T022 traplines typically begins in mid-December and ends around April, with the summer months spent building sets and trails. Trapping activity occurs each weekend between January and March, but the level of use is expected to increase once the trapline holder retires (TR0423T021 2015, pers. comm.). The TR0423T023 trapline recorded a harvest of five beaver, one coyote, and three marten pelts in 2010. Before 2010, 2002 was the last year with reported harvesting activity by the TR0423T023 trapline (FLNRO 2014d, pers. comm.). Teck has no trapping licence with the holder of the TR0423T023 trapline allowing use of its lands. N4.2.9 Outdoor Recreation and Tourism There are numerous outdoor recreational opportunities available in the Elk Valley, including downhill and cross-country skiing, ATV and snowmobile riding, mountain biking, camping, and hiking. In addition to considerable front country opportunities, such as formal trails and parks located within and directly adjacent to local communities, backcountry opportunities accessed via informal trails and forestry roads are dispersed throughout the RSA. Outdoor recreation is highly valued by local residents, and it is considered an important lifestyle attraction of the Elk Valley. Tourism in the Elk Valley is similarly focused on outdoor recreational activities. Recreation access trails and sites in the RSA and LSA are shown in Figure N4.2-13 and Figure N4.2-14, respectively. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 49 660000 710000 ! ³ ! Longview ! F = ! = ! = ! F È ! !! = Weary Creek Recreation Site ! A LB E R TA Aldridge Creek Recreation Site ! Upper Elk Valley Fording River C AMA F ! ! 9 ! ! ! = 9 ! Upper Elk Valley Fording River B AMA ! = Upper Elk Valley Fording River A AMA ! = ! ! F ! = ! = L ! ! = È ! ! = ! F ! L 5600000 5600000 610000 ! ! = A ! ! R RIV E EL K GR ! ! i ! ! © IVE ! . ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Crown Ridge ! ! ! L ! !! = . Racehorse Pass ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! L ! ! ! = = ! ! Alexander Creek AMA ! !! = ! ! Deadman's Pass ! ! ! ! Ä Ã ! !! ! L ! ! ! ! ! ©! " = ! ! ! PROJECT LOCATION L ! ! ! ! CABIN CAMPING CROSS-COUNTRY SKIING OLDMAN DOWNHILLRESERVOIR SKIING EQUESTRIAN FISHING GUN RANGE ! 5 . ! i ! © ! TRAIL / ACCESS ROAD LOCAL STUDY AREA SECONDARY HIGHWAY PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA FIRST NATIONS RESERVE NON-MOTORIZED PICNIC AREA SNOWMOBILE STAGING AREA ELKFORD ROD & GUN CLUB PRIMARY HIGHWAY MUNICIPAL BOUNDARY REGIONAL STUDY AREA STUDY AREA COMMUNITY WATERBODY Provincial boundaries, Communities and Hydrography obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Provincial Parks/Protected Areas, Railroad and First Nations data obtained from GeoGratis. ATV Trails obtained from Elkford ATV Club. Other data obtained from Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 SCALE PROJECT TITLE Pincher ! Creek 710000 25 BRITISH COLUMBIA ALBERTA BORDER NON-MOTORIZED TRAIL REFERENCE ATV 660000 ACCESS MANAGEMENT AREA (AMA) COAL MINING OPERATION RECREATIONAL TRAIL TRAPPER'S CABIN F HIKING ! Beaver ! Mines A LOOKOUT ! East Flathead AMA Wigwam Flats AMA CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY WATERCOURSE ! ! Elko Gargantuan Caves ! ! ! K ! _ ^ . ! Upper Flathead AMA 610000 CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY . ! Barnes Lake AMA 3 LAKE KOOCANUSA ! RE E ! I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-008-GIS-RSARecreation.mxd R * ! C ! VE ! Fernie Wardner ! LEGEND L ! Ä Ã RI Pickering Hills AMA L ! Y NA Fernie Alpine Resort ! HE IC TE Cranbrook Power Plant AMA M O KO ! © " . !! A ! ! Municipality of Crowsnest Pass ! Blairmore ! ! L = ! 9 ! ( * ! È ! l ! " © = Hosmer 3 ! ! ! Corbin Creek AMA ! . ! Coleman Ä Ã 5500000 ! 22 BIGHORN OUTFITTERS RECREATION SITE ! _ ^ ( Sparwood CABIN ! ! Sparwood Fish & Wildlife Association Lease 43 ! V U 5500000 ! ! ! = l ! i ! !! BULL RIVE R ! !! ! R !! F L Grave Prairie AMA North Fork 9 ! i ! Ä Ã A ! ! E R RIV È ! Springs ! Weigert Creek AMA ( 95A R ! = ! 5 ! North Galbraith AMA Chauncey ! i Todhunter A ! AMA !Elkford *! ! F (! = ! = Sulpher ! Boivin Creek Recreation Site IE LUS S Premier Ridge AMA Wapiti Alpine Ski Area ! B R IT IS H C O LU M B I A 5550000 Koko Claims DIN 5550000 W H I T E RIV E R R FO Mutton Creek AMA 25 KILOMETRES 1:750,000 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT RECREATION TRAILS AND SITES IN THE REGIONAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. 0 FIGURE N4.2-13 660000 Sparwood Fish & Wildlife EK RE Association Lease AVE C i ! DALZELL CREE K Grave Prairie AMA L ! = ! SI X M . ! Crown Ridge E CR EE K ME R 43 O EV D RY C R Racehorse Pass EE L ! = V U K EK CREEK CRE CUMMINGS IL Alexander Creek AMA ! M H IC EL Ä Ã 3 CR K EE ERICKSON L ! CABIN ( CROSS-COUNTRY SKIING " © GUN RANGE L ! NON-MOTORIZED . ! SNOWMOBILE i ! STAGING AREA K EE CR Corbin Creek AMA ! Crowsnest Hazell ! VE RI K ALB ER TA EL LEGEND ! Crowsnest Provincial Park 5500000 = ! = ! R ATV = L ! " © FIR RT RO BE RECREATION SITE 5500000 I:\CLIENTS\TECK_COAL\12-1349-0013\Mapping\MXD\LandResourceUse\B-LRUT-006-GIS-LSARecreation.mxd CR EE K CREE K LLADNAR CREEK Deadman's Pass ALEXANDER CREEK Sparwood 5510000 ( 5510000 ³ HAR 5520000 BR IT IS H C OL UM BI A GR 5520000 650000 650000 CITY / TOWN / COMMUNITY NON-MOTORIZED TRAIL TRAIL / ACCESS ROAD CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAY PRIMARY HIGHWAY SECONDARY HIGHWAY WATERCOURSE ACCESS MANAGEMENT AREA (AMA) BRITISH COLUMBIA - ALBERTA BORDER DOMINION COAL BLOCK PARCEL 73 REFERENCE 660000 4 ELKVIEW OPERATIONS C-2 PERMIT BOUNDARY SCALE 1:140,000 LOCAL STUDY AREA NO UNAUTHORIZED ENTRY AREA PROJECT MUNICIPAL NO SHOOTING PROVINCIAL PARK / PROTECTED AREA SPARWOOD RIDGE RESTRICTED AREA WATERBODY Populated places and provincial boundary obtained from The Atlas of Canada, Natural Resources Canada. Roads obtained from Geobase. Parks/Protected Areas obtained from GeoGratis. Alberta hydrography obtained from NTDB. ATV trail data obtained from the Elkford ATV Club. Access Management Areas obtained from the BC Ministry of Environment. All other data provided by Teck Coal Limited. DATUM: NAD 83 PROJECTION: UTM ZONE 11 0 TITLE 4 KILOMETRES ELKVIEW OPERATIONS BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION PROJECT RECREATION TRAILS AND SITES IN THE LOCAL STUDY AREA PROJECT DESIGN GIS CHECK REVIEW BB 12-1349-0013 19 Jul. 2013 SS 24 Oct. 2015 SDL 24 Oct. 2015 MH 06 Oct. 2015 FILE No. SCALE AS SHOWN REV. 0 FIGURE N4.2-14 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.2.9.1 Regional Study Area N4.2.9.1.1 Outdoor Recreation Recreational sites in the RSA are shown in Figure N4.2-13. All communities in the RSA have local recreational trails for use by hikers, bikers, horseback riders, snowshoers and cross-country skiers. Elkford has 40 km of marked interpretive hiking and biking trails, including Josephine Falls, Lily Lake Trail, Lost Lake Trail, and Boivin Creek Peace Trail (United Riders of Crowsnest 2013). Around Fernie, popular local hikes include Mount Fernie, Fairy Creek/Mount Proctor, Mount Hosmer, Castle Mountain, Mountain Lakes Trail, the Lizard Range/Cedar Valley, and the Three Sisters Trail (BC Forest Service n.d., City of Fernie n.d.). Crowsnest Pass has approximately 360 km of hiking and equestrian trail, as well as 30 km of mountain bicycling specific trail (IMBA Canada Trail Solutions 2012). See Section N4.2.9.2.1.1 for information on trails in Sparwood. Other trails in the RSA include: Coal Discovery Trail, which runs between Fernie, Hosmer and Sparwood. In 2014, responsibility for the Coal Discovery Trail was transferred from the RDEK to the District of Sparwood and Fernie Trails Alliance. The majority of the trail through Hosmer follows a BC Hydro owned parcel and right of way with the small sections entering private land. These sections of the trail may need to be relocated or agreements formed with individual land holders. The exact location of the trail is unconfirmed as global positioning system (GPS) mapping of the trail has not been completed (District of Sparwood 2014a). The Great Divide Trail, which runs along the BC-Alberta border, starting from the Canada-US border in the south and ending at Kakwa Provincial Park, north of Jasper National Park. Despite spanning over 1,000 km, the trail is not officially recognized, although efforts are being made to make the trail official (Calgary Herald 2014). The Great Divide Trail uses existing ATV trails in the RSA, including Deadman’s Pass trail (Trails.com n.d.). During the winter, the Elkford Nordic Ski Club grooms about 10 km of trails for cross-country skiing at Boivin Creek Ski Recreation Area, which has two trail shelters. The Fernie Nordic Society sets and maintains tracks for classic and groomed trails at the Fernie Golf and Country Club, as well as on the City of Fernie’s trail system. The Fernie Nordic Society also maintains the Elk Valley Nordic Centre, located near the Mount Fernie Provincial Park. Fernie Alpine Resort and Island Lake Lodge maintain trails in areas approximately 5 km from Fernie. The Crowsnest Pass Cross Country Ski Association promotes cross-country skiing at the Allison-Chinook cross-country ski area, located on the east side of Tecumseh Mountain in Alberta. The largest ski hill in the RSA is Fernie Alpine Resort, located 5 km from the centre of Fernie. This ski hill offers 142 named runs, 5 alpine bowls and glade skiing. In addition to Fernie Alpine Resort, Elkford and Crowsnest Pass have smaller ski hills that primarily serve their local communities. Wapiti Ski Hill is located on the west side of Elkford and offers seven ski runs that include beginner and expert options. The hill is operated by the volunteer Wapiti Ski Club (District of Elkford n.d.). The Pass Powderkeg Ski Resort is owned and operated by the Municipality of Crowsnest Pass (Crowsnest Pass Powderkeg 2014). October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 52 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Motorized recreation (i.e., ATV and snowmobile) is also popular in the RSA. ATV and snowmobile activities occur on designated trails, as well as along forestry, access roads, and rights-of-way (Figure N4.2-13). Due to the increasing popularity of motorized recreation, access management areas (AMAs) have been developed to restrict the use of motorized vehicles in specific areas for the purpose of wildlife management, including limiting hunting or fishing. There are nine AMAs in the RSA including Corbin Creek AMA, Barnes Lake AMA, Alexander Creek AMA, Grave Prairie AMA, Weigert Creek AMA, Chaucey Todhunter AMA, Upper Elk Valley – Fording River A AMA, Upper Elk Valley – Fording River B AMA, and Upper Elk Valley – Fording River C AMA (Figure N4.2-13). East of the LSA, the Alexander Creek Access Management Area is a high use area for ATV riding and snowmobiling in the RSA and attracts ATV riders from Alberta who access the area using Deadman’s Pass, North Fork Pass and Racehorse Pass. A snowmobile cabin is located in the northern end of the Alexander Creek Access Management Area. Trails in the Alexander Creek Access Management Area connect with Grave Creek in the north. Intersecting the northwestern portion of the LSA, Grave Prairie AMA is considered to be the busiest AMA in the Elk Valley with open roads used by recreation groups year round (BC Conservation Officer Service 2014a). Intersecting the southeastern portion of the LSA, Corbin Creek AMA is a popular location for anglers to camp because access to Michel Creek. Anticipated logging activity in the Corbin Creek AMA is expected to reduce activity levels (BC Conservation Officer Service 2014b). Active ATV and snowmobile clubs within the RSA include: Elk Valley Mountaineers: A snowmobile club based in Sparwood with approximately 30 members (BC Snowmobile Federation n.d.). Elkford ATV Club: The Elkford ATV Club has 384 members: 82 are in Elkford, 80 are in Sparwood, 50 are in Fernie, 102 are in Cranbrook and others are based in Vancouver, Kamloops and Alberta. Two-thirds of the membership work four-days-on and four-days-off shifts at the local mines and, consequently, trail use is distributed throughout the week with higher activity levels on the weekends. Elkford Snowmobile Association: All 50 members of the Elkford Snowmobile Association are based in Elkford. While snowmobiling is popular in the area, ATV riding appears to be more appealing to families, so the Elkford ATV Club is seeing a membership transition from snowmobiling to ATV riding because of more usable months and better trail options. Crowsnest Pass Quad Squad: The Crowsnest Pass Quad Squad has existed for approximately 15 years and has a current membership of 300 to 325 (corporate members are counted as two and family members as three). The organization is mandated to maintain and keep backcountry areas open to public access and engages in trail maintenance in Alberta. Crow Snow Riders Snowmobile Association: The Crow Snow Riders Snowmobile Association, started in 1991, promotes responsible snowmobiling. Current membership is around 160 and the association has two cabins and a building for housing its groomer in Alberta. Most of the association’s activities as a group are within Alberta, including conservation, wildlife counts, clean-ups and trail maintenance. From its Community Investment funds, Teck provided approximately $59,000 in support of local trails and outdoor clubs (i.e., ATV, snowmobile or cross-country skiing) in the RSA in 2013. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 53 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.2.9.1.2 Tourism The Elk Valley is located within the Kootenay Rockies region, which covers 58,000 km2 of southeastern BC. Visitors to the Kootenay Rockies region are primarily drawn by outdoor recreational activities and experiencing scenery and nature, including sightseeing, wildlife viewing and visiting parks (Tourism BC 2012). In 2010, the Kootenay Rockies region received 1.6 million overnight person-visits and generated $522 million in related spending. Over half of overnight visitation and spending in the Kootenay Rockies region came from Alberta tourists. Domestic overnight travellers accounted for 82% of visitation and 78% of related spending, while international travellers accounted for 18% and 22%, respectively (Destination BC 2013). Tourism in the Elk Valley is primarily centred in Fernie, which is part of the provincial Resort Municipality Initiative (RMI). The RMI is a provincial program that provides development, business promotion and financing tools to enhance the resort sector in BC (City of Fernie 2013). The RMI funds for 2014 will be used toward projects including the development of recreational trails, cultural and heritage tourism, the Fernie Nordic Centre (i.e., cross-country skiing centre), a museum and information centre, signage and a winter shuttle service (Obre 2014). In 2011, Fernie had over 11,000 visitors to its Visitor and Business Information Centre (City of Fernie 2012). Due to the Elk Valley’s proximity to the BC – Alberta provincial boundary, Alberta residents frequently travel to the Elk Valley for weekend trips and comprise the primary demand for seasonal residential properties in the area. Tourism in Fernie is primarily focused on downhill skiing, with its peak season occurring between December and April (Tourism Fernie 2013, pers. comm.). Fernie Alpine Resort is known internationally as an excellent skiing experience and is consistently highly ranked among the top ski destinations in North America and internationally (Vaugeois et al. 2013; Fernie Alpine Resort n.d.). In addition to downhill skiing, this resort offers cross-country ski and snowshoeing guided tours. Also to the west of Fernie, Island Lake Lodge offers cat skiing, cross-country skiing and snowshoeing opportunities on 7,000 acres of privately owned terrain. Cat skiing opportunities are available through Fernie Wilderness Adventures to the southeast of Fernie. Guided snowmobiling tours are offered on the Island Lake Lodge property and along the backcountry trails around Fernie. Guided ice fishing is available in the winter (Island Lake Lodge n.d.). A concerted effort has been made by various parties in the Fernie tourism sector to grow the summer tourism industry, which is the secondary tourism season in the Elk Valley. The summer tourism peak occurs between July and August and is mainly centered on fishing, mountain biking, hiking, wildlife viewing, canoeing, rafting and waterskiing (Vaugeois et al. 2013). Visitation associated with mountain biking and dry fly fishing is growing in Fernie (Vaugeois et al. 2013; Tourism Fernie 2013, pers. comm.). From June through September, Fernie holds numerous mountain biking events. Fernie Alpine Resort offers cross-country, downhill, single track and dual slalom trails with and without chairlift access. Guided mountain biking is available in the Fernie area. Tourism Fernie wants to construct a facility and trail system that meets the criteria of Cross Country Canada by 2015, which would allow for the hosting of regional and provincial level mountain bike races (City of Fernie 2012; Tourism Fernie 2015a,b). Guided hiking services are provided by Fernie Alpine Resort, Island Lake Lodge and other operators (Tourism Fernie 2015c), and there are other opportunities for self-directed hikes around local communities and throughout the Elk Valley, as outlined in Section N4.2.9.1.1. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 54 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Two commercial recreational tenures along the Elk River between Fernie and Sparwood are held by Mountain High Adventure (tenure #4404208) and Canyon Raft Company (tenure #4404196). Both operators are based in Fernie and provide rafting tours along the Elk and Bull rivers. Fishing guides operate throughout the RSA (and LSA), with the Elk River being a prime fly-fishing location. Non-residents of BC can obtain angling licences and are not required to use a guide. For non-residents without the services of a guide, the province targets 3,540 angler days per year on the Elk River, but in 2012/13 the number of days (based on licence sales) was 5,720. The angler day quota for guided fishing on the Elk River is 2,950 days, which is currently divided between approximately seventeen different guides. Guiding companies with a quota of over 100 days on the Elk River include the Elk River Guiding Company, Dave Brown Outfitters, Fernie Wilderness Adventures, Kootenay Fly Shop and Guiding Company, Freestone Fly Angler, St. Mary Angler Fly Fishing, Fly Fish the Elk, and Crowsnest Angler Fly Shop (FLNRO 2010, 2015b, pers. comm.). Many fishing guides in the RSA visit Michel Creek, Fording River, Flathead River and Wigwam River, and offer their services further afield on the Bull River, Columbia River, Kootenay River and Saint Mary River, as well as rivers in Alberta (Dave Brown Outfitters 2014; Elk River Guiding Company n.d.; Freestone Fly Angler 2010; Kootenay Fly Shop 2008). The Ktunaxa Nation has also expressed interest in participating in the guiding economy in the Elk Valley, including sports fishing based tourism and guide outfitting. In Cranbrook, outside of the RSA, the Ktunaxa Nation operates the St. Eugene Mission Resort, which is the 10th largest private sector revenue generator in the RDEK at $13.6 million per year, and has 250 employees, of whom 25% are First Nations members (Section C of the EAC Application). Both Sparwood and Elkford are interested in generating more tourism in their communities. Elkford has branded itself as “Wild at Heart” to attract outdoor recreation-oriented visitors (District of Elkford 2009). Further information on Sparwood’s tourism industry and attractions is provided in Section N4.2.9.2.1.2. N4.2.9.2 N4.2.9.2.1.1 Local Study Area Outdoor Recreation Gravel roads along Grave and Harmer Creeks used by recreationists are located on private land owned by Teck and provide access to the northern end of the LSA (Figure N4.2-14). There is no public road access into the Erickson Valley from either Harmer Creek or from the southern end of EVO. A staging area for ATVing and snowmobiling just south of Grave Lake (north of the LSA) was identified by users. There is a campsite on Teck private land at the south west corner of Grave Lake. The campsite is leased to the Sparwood Fish and Wildlife Association, which manages the area. The campsite has a boat launch, picnic area and outhouses. There are 24 cabin lots situated on the lake’s west side. The cabin owners lease their property from Teck. Other recreational opportunities in the LSA are centred around Sparwood. This community has 14 trails, including the two hour alpine trail Matevic Draw, as well as Elk River Trail, Mountain Shadows Trail, Ponderosa Trail, View Trail, Deer Run Trail, Sparwood Ridge Trail, Cypress Park Loop, Pine Forest Trail and Michael Trail (Cameron 2011, District of Sparwood 2014c, The Free Press 2014). In addition, the Sparwood Sunset Ridge Cross Country Ski Society maintains 10 km of groomed trails and a day lodge to the west of Highway #43 (Cameron 2011). A 9-hole golf course is also located within the District of Sparwood, on the eastern side of Highway #3. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 55 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N4.2.9.2.1.2 Tourism Sparwood, the closest community to the Project, offers visitor attractions and amenities. Visitor accommodation in Sparwood includes the Causeway Bay Hotel, Vessel Motel, local bed and breakfasts, and Mountain Shadows Campground (District of Sparwood 2014c, e). Key tourism attractions include the 1974 Terex Titan, formerly the largest truck in the world, located adjacent to the visitor centre (District of Sparwood 2014f). The community of Sparwood actively celebrates its mining history with interpretive signage and historical markers, community events, and self-guided walking tours. The Sparwood Chamber of Commerce also conducts interpretive coal mine tours in the months of July and August on Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays (District of Sparwood 2014g). Whiskey Jack Resort completed its first phase of development in Sparwood, and includes the development of an 18-hole golf course and a maximum of 900 equivalent mixed use residential units (Sparwood Chamber of Commerce 2013, pers. comm.; BC Ministry of Small Business, Technology and Economic Development 2013). Other potential tourism opportunities in Sparwood include the development of commercial outdoor recreation businesses such as fish guiding, guided rafting, hunting, and tourism related accommodation, beverage, and entertainment businesses (District of Sparwood 2014h). Sheep Mountain Outfitters holds a guiding tenure overlapping the southwestern corner of the LSA (Figure N4.2-11). A Guiding Territory Certificate provides exclusive control over guiding privileges within a guiding territory. Guided fishing also occurs on the Elk River and Michel Creek within the LSA by multiple operators who have specific angling day allocations for this system (see Section N4.2.9.1.2 for information about angling guides and activity levels). N5.0 SUMMARY The land use and tenure baseline study describes land use designations, tenures, and activities that are located or occur in the Elk Valley area and regionally. The RSA includes the communities of Sparwood, Elkford, Fernie, Crowsnest Pass and unincorporated settlements (e.g., Hosmer) and rural areas surrounding these communities. The Project footprint is situated on Teck owned private lands, the majority of which lies within the boundaries of the District of Sparwood. The Project lands in the District of Sparwood have been zoned as Extraction Industrial by the municipal council, which allows for coal mining and processing. Crown land within the LSA footprint is designated as Coal Enhanced Resource Development Zone, which provides for industrial uses that are consistent with Teck’s operations. The coal mining and processing industry in the Elk Valley has been its primary economic driver since the first coal mine was established at Fernie in 1897. Teck’s coal mining and processing operations in the Elk Valley directly employ approximately 4,000 workers who reside in Sparwood, Crowsnest Pass, Elkford, and Fernie as well as in other communities outside the RSA. In addition to Teck operations, there are other coal exploration or development projects underway within the LSA. One coal licence and two coal licence applications held by CanAus Coal Ltd. overlap with the southeast corner of the LSA and one coal licence application held by NWP Coal Canada Ltd. overlaps with the northeast edge of the LSA. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 56 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Forestry in the RSA takes place within 88,483 ha of total Crown Forest Land Base, on private managed forest land and on private agricultural lands (e.g., ranches). Private managed forest lands within the LSA include Managed Forest 471 and a small portion of Managed Forests 482 and 27 (approximately 3,000 ha). Petroleum and Natural Gas tenure rights cover 29,354 ha of the RSA and are centred around EVO and Fording River Operations. Forestry and natural gas interests, held by Canfor and Apache respectively, directly overlap with EVO and the Project footprint. Teck currently has agreements in place with both Canfor and Apache regarding the use of the land. There are many provincial and regional parks and protected areas located within the RSA, however, no parks or protected areas are located in the LSA. Outdoor recreation is highly valued by local residents and is considered an important lifestyle attraction of the Elk Valley. Numerous outdoor recreational opportunities are available in the LSA, including downhill and cross-country skiing, ATV and snowmobile riding, mountain biking, camping, hiking, fishing, and hunting. These activities take advantage of considerable front country opportunities including formal trails, ski resorts and parks located within and near local communities, as well as backcountry opportunities accessed by informal trails and forestry roads throughout the RSA. Motorized ATVing and snowmobiling activities were identified as popular recreational uses with a number of related clubs located locally and regionally. No Unauthorized Entry Areas were implemented by Teck to maintain public and worker safety near the existing operations or exploration and permission is needed to enter a No Unauthorized Entry Area. Wildlife and fish harvesting occurs throughout the RSA and BC Government registered angler guides attract an international clientele to fish along the Elk River and Michel Creek. Three trapline tenures overlap with EVO; the nearest guide outfitting tenure is located on the other side of Highway #3 from EVO. Popular hunting areas include Harmer Creek northeast of EVO, to the west of the Elk River, and south of Highway #3. These areas are largely accessible by ATV, although access limitations apply in specific areas of the Access Management Area’s developed to restrict the use of motorized vehicles for the purpose of limiting hunting or fishing for wildlife management. In addition to guided hunting and fishing in the RSA and LSA, the community of Sparwood offers other visitor attractions and amenities. Key tourism attractions include the 1974 Terex Titan, at one point the largest truck in the world, located adjacent to the visitor centre. Sparwood actively celebrates its mining history with interpretive signage and historical markers, community events, interpretive coal mine tours and self-guided walking tours. In addition, the ongoing expansion of Whiskey Jack Resort at Sparwood will include the development of an 18-hole golf course and mixed use residential units. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 57 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N6.0 CLOSURE We trust the above meets your present requirements. If you have any questions or require additional details, please contact the undersigned. GOLDER ASSOCIATES LTD. ORIGINAL SIGNED ORIGINAL SIGNED Derek De Biasio, BA, MA, CMC Senior socio-economist Roxanne Scott, M.P.A., M.Ed. Associate, Socio-economic Specialist Golder, Golder Associates and the GA globe design are trademarks of Golder Associates Corporation. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 58 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N7.0 REFERENCES Agreement between Teck and holder of TR0423T021. 2011. Trapping Permit. Document on File at Golder Associated Ltd. ALC (Agricultural Land Commission). 2002. How the ALR was Established. Available at: http://www.alc.gov.bc.ca/alc/content.page?id=DD252CEFA3464882B8BB425CE2572232. Accessed: February 2015. ALC. 2010. Main Page. Available at: http://www.alc.gov.bc.ca/. Accessed: March 2010. Allen, J.H. 2000. A Perspective on People, Coal and Fish in the Southern Rocky Mountains. Prepared for Fording Coal Ltd., Luscare Ltd. Line Creek Mine, Elkview Coal Corporation. Pisces Environmental Consulting Services Ltd. Red Deer, AB. American Manganese Inc. 2014. American Manganese Inc. Acquires Phosphate Claims in Elk Valley, Southeastern BC. Available at: http://www.americanmanganeseinc.com/american-manganese-incacquires-phosphate-claims-in-elk-valley-southeastern-bc/. Accessed: December 2014. BC Conservation Officer Service. 2014a. Access Management Compliance and Enforcement Program (AMCEP) May/June Report Crowsnest Provincial Park. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/kootenay/eco/reports/Access%20Guardian%20Report%20for%20September %202014.pdf. Accessed: January 2015. BC Conservation Officer Service. 2014b. Access Management Compliance and Enforcement Program (AMCEP) May/June Report Crowsnest Provincial Park. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/kootenay/eco/reports/Access%20Guardian%20Report%20for%20July%20201 4.pdf. Accessed: January 2015. BC EAO. 2015. Elkview Operations Baldy Ridge Extension Project Application Information Requirements. As Approved by the British Columbia Environmental Assessment Office in September 2015. BC Forest Service. n.d. Three Sisters Trail. Available at: http://www.for.gov.bc.ca/drm/!bak/Recreation/RecreationTrails/FernieFlathead/ThreeSisters.pdf. Accessed: December 2014. BC MEM (British Columbia Ministry of Energy and Mines). 2014. British Columbia Coal Industry Overview 2013. Available at: http://www.empr.gov.bc.ca/Mining/Geoscience/PublicationsCatalogue/InformationCirculars/Documents/I C2014-5.pdf. Accessed: February 2014. BC Ministry of Agriculture. 2011. Land Use Inventory Report Elk Valley East Kootenay. Available at: http://www.al.gov.bc.ca/resmgmt/sf/gis/lui_reports/RDEK2011_ElkLUIReport.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. BC Ministry of Forests and Range. 2009. Long-Term Community Forest Support Ktunaxa Success. Available at: http://www2.news.gov.bc.ca/news_releases_2009-2013/2009FOR0081-000654.htm. Accessed: September 2014. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 59 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT BC Ministry of Small Business, Technology and Economic Development. 2013. BC Major Projects Inventory September 2013. Available at: http://www.jtst.gov.bc.ca/ministry/major_projects_inventory/pdfs/September_2013_MPI.pdf. Accessed: January 2014. BC MOE (British Columbia Ministry of Environment). 2013. Freshwater Fishing Regulations Synopsis Region 4 – Kootenay. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/fw/fish/regulations/docs/1315/fishing_synopsis_201315_region4.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. BC MOE. 2014a. Hunting Regulations Synopsis Region 4 – Kootenay. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/fw/wildlife/hunting/regulations/1416/docs/region_4.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. BC MOE. 2014b. Trapping Regulations. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/fw/wildlife/hunting/regulations/1416/docs/Trapping_Regulations.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. BC MOE. 2015. Telephone interview. Personal Communication with Sarah Rutherford, Golder Associates Ltd. on July 23, 2015. BC Oil and Gas Commission. 2011. State of the Play: East https://www.bcogc.ca/node/6007/download. Accessed: May 2014. Kootenay Basin. BC Parks. 2011. BC Parks: 2010/2011Statistics Report. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/bcparks/research/statistic_report/statistic_report_2011.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. BC Parks. 2012. BC Parks: 2011/2012 Statistics Report. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/bcparks/research/statistic_report/statistic_report_2012.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. BC Parks. 2013a. Crowsnest Provincial Park. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/bcparks/explore/parkpgs/crowsnest/. Accessed: February 2014. BC Parks. 2013b. Mount Fernie Provincial Park. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/bcparks/explore/parkpgs/mt_fernie/. Accessed: February 2014. BC Parks. 2013c. Elk Valley Provincial Park. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/bcparks/explore/parkpgs/elk_valley/. Accessed: February 2014. BC Parks. 2013d. 2012/2013 Statistics Report. BC Parks. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/bcparks/research/statistic_report/statistic_report_2013.pdf. Accessed May 2014. BC Parks. 2014a. Height of the Rockies Provincial Park. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/bcparks/explore/parkpgs/height/. Accessed February 2014. BC Parks. 2014b. Elk Lakes Provincial Park. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/bcparks/explore/parkpgs/elk_lk/. Accessed February 2014. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 60 Available at: BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT BC Snowmobile Federation. n.d. Elk Valley Mountaineers. Available at: http://bcsf.org/operator/elk-valleymountaineers. Accessed January 2015. BCWF (BC Wildlife Federation). 2010. BC Wildlife Federation Main Page. Available at: http://www.bcwf.bc.ca/. Accessed: March 2012. Bingay Coal. n.d. Bingay Coal Suspended. Posted April 09. Available at: http://bingaycoal.com/bingay-coalsuspended/. Accessed: February 2014. BP Canada Energy Company and Elk Valley Coal Partnership 2006a. Elk Valley PNG Appraisal and Development Agreement. Document on file at Golder Associates Ltd. BP Canada Energy Company and Elk Valley Coal Partnership 2006b. Conveyance and Option Agreement. Document on file at Golder Associates Ltd. Calgary Herald. 2014. Official status sought for 1,200-km Great Divide hiking trail, March 24, 2014. Available at: http://www.calgaryherald.com/travel/Official+status+sought+Great+Divide+hiking+trail/9656525/story.ht ml. Accessed: May 2014. Cameron, D. 2011. Sparwood invites you. Available at: http://kootenaybiz.com/sparwood/article/sparwood_invites_you. Accessed: December 2014. CBC News. 2015. Morel mushrooms draw foragers to secret spots in Rocky Mountains. Available at: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/edmonton/morel-mushrooms-draw-foragers-to-secret-spots-in-rockymountains-1.3097159. Accessed July 2015. City of Fernie. n.d. Fernie Recreational Trails. Available at: http://trailsbc.ca/sites/default/files/docs/pdf/tct/City%20of%20Fernie%20Trail%20Map.pdf. December 2014. Accessed City of Fernie. 2012. 2012-2016 Resort Development Strategy, Fernie and Area Resort Municipality Initiative. Available at: http://www.fernie.ca/assets/News/Docs/201216%20Resort%20Development%20Strategy_final_Council%20Review.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. City of Fernie. 2013. Resort Development Strategy. Available at: http://www.fernie.ca/EN/main/city/documentspublications/resort-development-strategy.html. Accessed: May 2014. CoalMont Pty Ltd. 2015. Michel Creek Coking Coal Project, Available at http://www.coalmont.com.au/michel_creek. Accessed: March 2015. Crowsnest Pass Powderkeg. 2014. Crowsnest Pass Powderkeg. Available at: http://www.passpowderkeg.com/mountain. Accessed: May 2014. Dave Brown Outfitters. 2014. Dave Brown Outfitters. Available at: http://elkriverflyfishingguides.com/other-rivers/. Accessed: May 2014. Destination BC. 2013. Regional Tourism Profile Kootenay Rockies. http://www.destinationbc.ca/getattachment/Research/Research-by-Region/KootenayRockies/RegionalProfiles_Kootenay-Rockies.pdf.aspx. Accessed: December 2014. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 61 Available at: BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT District of Elkford. n.d. Wapiti Ski Hill. Available at: http://www.elkford.ca/wapiti_ski_hill. Accessed: May 2014. District of Elkford. 2009. District of Elkford Official Community Plan and Climate Change Adaptation Strategy Background Report. Available at: http://www.elkford.ca/include/get.php?nodeid=78. Accessed: May 2014. District of Sparwood. 2009. Personal communication with Cal McDougal (Teck) and Barb Nunes (District of Sparwood June 4, 2009. District of Sparwood. 2014a. District of Sparwood Regular Meeting of Council, January 20, 2014. Available at: https://sparwood.civicweb.net/Documents/DocumentDisplay.aspx?Id=40325. Accessed: August 2014. District of Sparwood. 2014b. District of Sparwood Unofficial Office Consolidation Zoning Bylaw No. 264, August 25, 2014. Available at: https://sparwood.civicweb.net/Documents/DocumentList.aspx?ID=564. Accessed: August 2014. District of Sparwood. 2014c. Trail System. Available at: http://www.sparwood.ca/residents/recreation/trailsystem. Accessed: December 2014. District of Sparwood. 2014d. Mountain Shadows Campground. Available at: http://www.sparwood.ca/visitors/accommodation/campground. Accessed: December 2014. District of Sparwood. 2014e. Hotels & Motels. Available at: http://www.sparwood.ca/visitors/accommodation/hotels-motels. Accessed: December 2014. District of Sparwood. 2014f. The Truck. Available at: http://www.sparwood.ca/visitors/terex-titan. Accessed: December 2014. District of Sparwood. 2014g. Mine Tours. Available at: http://www.sparwood.ca/visitors/activities/mine-tours. Accessed: December 2014. District of Sparwood. 2014h. Draft Sparwood Official Community Plan. Available at: http://ocp.sparwood.ca/wpcontent/uploads/2014/03/Sparwood_OCP_Draft2.pdf. Accessed: December 2014. Elk River Guiding Company. n.d. Elk River Guiding Company. Available at: http://elkriver.ca/waters. Accessed: May 2014. Fernie Alpine Resort. n.d. Award and Accolades. Available at: http://www.skifernie.com/news-and-info/aboutus/awards.aspx. Accessed: May 2014. FLNRO (British Columbia Ministry of Forest, Lands and Natural Resource Operations). 2002a. KootenayBoundary Regional Land Use Plan. Available at: http://ilmbwww.gov.bc.ca/content/plans/2010/03/02/kootenay-boundary-regional-land-use-plan. Accessed: May 2014. Fertoz Ltd. n.d.(a). Marten British Columbia. Available at: http://www.fertoz.com/marten.html. Accessed January 2015. Fertoz Ltd. n.d.(b). Canadian Projects. Available at: http://www.fertoz.com/canadian-projects.html. Accessed January 2015. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 62 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT FLNRO (British Columbia Ministry of Forest, Lands and Natural Resource Operations). 2002. SRMMP (Southern Rocky Mountain Management Plan). Available at: http://www.for.gov.bc.ca/tasb/slrp/pdf/srmp/SRMMP_plan2.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. FLNRO. 2010. Classified Waters – Angler Days – Region 4. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/pasb/applications/docs/classifiedwaters_anglerdays_reg4.pdf. Accessed: January 2015. FLNRO. 2013. Big Game Harvest Information. Email correspondence from P. Stent (FLNRO) to S. Rutherford (Golder Associates Ltd.). Email on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. FLNRO. 2014a. Telephone interview. Personal Communication with Sarah Rutherford, Golder Associates Ltd. on May 2, 2014. FLNRO. 2014b. Cranbrook TSA AAC, Apportionment and Commitments. Available at: https://www.for.gov.bc.ca/ftp/hth/external/!publish/web/timber-tenures/apportionment-fy-2014/APTR011Cranbrook.PDF. Accessed: May 2014. FLNRO. 2014c. Angler Days. Email correspondence from J. Burrows (FLNRO) to S. Rutherford (Golder Associates Ltd.). Email on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. FLNRO. 2014d. Trapper Harvest. Email correspondence from P. Stent (FLNRO) to S. Rutherford (Golder Associates Ltd.). Email on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. FLNRO. 2015a. Kootenay angling plan secures quality fishing for all. http://www2.news.gov.bc.ca/news_releases_2013-2017/2015FLNR0268-001443.htm. September 2015. Available at: Accessed: FLNRO. 2015b. Guide Rod Days. Email correspondence from J. Burrows (FLNRO) to S. Rutherford (Golder Associates Ltd.). Email on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. FLNRO. n.d.(a). Kootenay-Boundary Higher Level Plan Order. Available at: http://archive.ilmb.gov.bc.ca/slrp/lrmp/cranbrook/kootenay/pdf/KBHLPOrder0925.pdf. 2014. Accessed: May FLNRO. n.d.(b). Limited Entry Hunting. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/fw/wildlife/hunting/resident/docs/2014springgrizzly_skeenasheep.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. FLNRO. n.d. (c). Angling Licences and Fees. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/fw/fish/licences/#ClassifiedWaters. Accessed: May 2014. FLNRO. n.d.(d). Seven New Classified Waters in Kootenay Region. Available at: http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/fw/fish/licences/docs/vendor_guidelines_kootenay_cw.pdf. 2014. Freestone Fly Angler. 2010. Freestone Fly Angler. Available at: http://www.freestoneflyangler.com/rivers/southwest-alberta/. Accessed: May 2014. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 63 Accessed: May BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Government of British Columbia. 1995. The East Kootenay Land-Use Plan (EKLUP). Available at: www.for.gov.bc.ca/tasb/slrp/pdf/LRMP/east_kootenay_plan.pdf. Accessed: May.2014. Government of Canada. 2014. Budget 2014. Available at: http://www.budget.gc.ca/2014/docs/plan/pdf/budget2014-eng.pdf. Accessed: September 2014.Heaven's Gate. n.d. Heaven's Gate. Available at: http://www.heavensgatefernie.ca/gondola/. Accessed: September 2014. Hobby, T. and M. Keefer. 2010. A black huckleberry case study in the Kootenay region of British Columbia. Available at: http://jem.forrex.org/index.php/jem/article/view/66/24. Accessed June 2015. ILMB (Integrated Land Management Bureau). 2007. Boundary Timber Supply Area and Tree Farm Licence 8 Old Growth Management Areas Report. Prepared by: Frank Wilmer RPF, Strategic Planning Forester, Client Services Division, Integrated Land Management Bureau, Ministry of Agriculture and Lands. Victoria, BC. 36 pp. IMBA Canada Trail Solutions. 2012. Crowsnest Pass Mountain Bicycling Trail Masterplan. Available at: http://www.uroc.ca/files/Masterplan_FINAL_v4-3.pdf. Accessed: December 2014. Island Lake Lodge. n.d. Fun Things to Do in Fernie. Available at: http://islandlakecatskiing.com/summer/summer-directions/summer-activities/. Accessed August 2014. Jameson Resources Limited. 2014. Positive Property-Wide Coal Quality Crown Mountain Coking Coal Project. Available at: http://www.jamesonresources.com.au/index.php/investor-centre/asx-announcements. Accessed: May 2014. Jameson Resources Limited. n.d. Overview. Available at: http://www.jamesonresources.com.au/index.php/projects/crown-mountain/overview. 2014. Accessed: May Keefer Ecological Services Ltd. 2011. Quantifying the effects of silvicultural techniques, wildfire and forest stand attributes on black huckleberry abundance and productivity. Available at: https://www.for.gov.bc.ca/hfd/library/fia/html/FIA2011MR018.htm. Accessed June 2015. Keefer, M., R. Winder and T. Hobby. 2010. Commercial development of non-timber forest resources: A case study. Available at: http://jem.forrex.org/index.php/jem/article/view/54/23. Accessed June 2015. Kootenai Tribe of Idaho and Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks. 2004. Kootenai River Sub basin Inventory. Available at: http://www.nwcouncil.org/media/20821/Kootenai_Inventory.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. Kootenay Fly Shop. 2008. Kootenay Fly Shop. Available at: http://www.kootenayflyshop.com/the-waters/rivers. Accessed: May 2014. Kootenay Inter-Agency Management Committee. 1997. Kootenay-Boundary Land Use Plan Implementation Strategy. Integrated Land Management Bureau. June 1997. Victoria, BC. Available at: http://www.for.gov.bc.ca/tasb/slrp/pdf/LRMP/Kootenay%20Boundary%20Land%20Use%20Plan%20Impl ementation%20Strategy.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 64 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Ktunaxa Nation. 2013. Ktunaxa Nation Community Forest Management Plan. Available http://www.thektuq.com/2012-07-13-CommunityForest.html. Accessed: September 2014. at: MacFarlane, J. 2013. Riversdale proceeding with mining project. Crowsnest Voice, Wednesday, October 16, 2013. Available at: http://www.crowsnestvoice.com/2013/10/riversdale-proceeding-with-mining.html. Accessed: February 2014. Mitchell, D., Sinclair, T., Brigham, T., Cocksedge, W., & Hobby, T. (2010). Policy Gaps and Invisible Elbows: NTFPs in British Columbia. Available at: https://books.google.ca/books?id=VoSxZYW1E8IC&pg=PA113&source=gbs_toc_r&cad=3#v=onepage& q&f=false. Accessed: August 2015. Municipality of Crowsnest Pass. 2013. Focus Group Meeting with Council and Administration. Personal Communication with Derek De Biasio and Sarah Rutherford, Golder Associates Ltd. on December 12, 2013.NTFP Harvesting Representative. 2015. Telephone interview. Personal Communication with Sarah Rutherford, Golder Associates Ltd. on June 10, 2015. Obre, N. 2014. A Financial Boost for Fernie's Tourism. Available at: http://issuu.com/blackpress/docs/i2014012310001759/19. Accessed: May 2014. PMFLC (Private Managed Forest Land Council). 2007. Private Managed Forest Land. Presentation to Union of BC Municipalities. September 27, 2007. RDEK (Regional District of East Kootenay). 2008. Airport. On file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. RDEK. 2012. Regional District of East Kootenay Regional Profile. Issue No. 7. Regional District of East Kootenay, Cranbrook, BC. Available at: ftp://ftp.rdek.bc.ca/pdf/Issue7Draftv2_Nov12.pdf. Accessed: February 2014. RDEK. 2014a. Draft Elk Valley Community Plan. Report on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. RDEK. 2014b. Elk Valley Zoning Bylaw No. 829, 1990. Available at: http://www.rdek.bc.ca/bylaws/ocp_zoning_landuse/zoningbylaws/elkvalleyzoning/. Accessed: May 2014. Shell Canada Limited and Crestbrook Forest Industries Ltd. 1983. Shell/CFI Taxation Tree Farm 27 Harvesting Rights Agreement Highlights. Agreement dated May 18, 1983. 42 pp. Sparwood Chamber of Commerce. 2013. Key Informant Meeting. Personal Communication with Amanda King and Sarah Rutherford, Golder Associates Ltd. on November 14, 2013. Standing Senate Committee on Energy, the Environment and Natural Resources. 2013. Standing Senate Committee on Energy, the Environment and Natural Resources, the Environment and Natural Resource Evidence. Available at: http://www.parl.gc.ca/content/sen/committee/412/ENEV/51045-E.HTM. Accessed: September 2014. Stephenson, A. 2013. Second company sets its sights on Crowsnest Pass Coal. Calgary Herald, August 12, 2013. Available at: http://www.calgaryherald.com/business/Second+company+sets+sights+Crowsnest+Pass+coal/8780202 /story.html. Accessed: February 2014. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 65 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Teck. 2013. Teck Acquires East Kootenay Lands. Available at: http://www.google.ca/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&frm=1&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CCgQFjAA&url=http %3A%2F%2Fteck.com%2Fdocument%2FDocumentViewer.aspx%3Fportal%3Dtc%26path%3D_ces_po rtal_meta%2Fdownloads%2FMedia%2F2013%2F13-31TR.pdf&ei=1zlhU_qcPMSuyASE34KIDg&usg=AFQjCNEwaZJU1KT7MNL5ShmWIwr_nbETw&bvm=bv.65636070,d.aWw. Accessed: May 2014. Teck. 2014a. Elkview Operations Annual Reclamation Report for 2013. Report on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. Teck. 2014b. Teck Coal Ltd. 2014 Life of Mine Plan Elkview Operations. July 1, 2014. Teck. 2014c. Coal Mountain. Available at: http://www.teck.com/Generic.aspx?PAGE=Teck+Site%2fDiversified+Mining+Pages%2fCoal+Pages%2f Coal+Mountain&portalName=tc. Accessed: May 2014. Teck. 2014d. Elkview. Available at: http://www.teck.com/Generic.aspx?PAGE=Teck+Site%2fDiversified+Mining+Pages%2fCoal+Pages%2f Elkview&portalName=tc. Accessed: May 2014. Teck. 2014e. Line Creek. Available at: http://www.teck.com/Generic.aspx?PAGE=Teck+Site%2fDiversified+Mining+Pages%2fCoal+Pages%2f Line+Creek&portalName=tc. Accessed: May 2014. Teck. 2014f. Greenhills. Available at: http://www.teck.com/Generic.aspx?PAGE=Teck+Site%2fDiversified+Mining+Pages%2fCoal+Pages%2f Greenhills&portalName=tc. Accessed: May 2014. Teck. 2014g. Fording River. Available at: http://www.teck.com/Generic.aspx?PAGE=Teck+Site%2fDiversified+Mining+Pages%2fCoal+Pages%2f Fording+River&portalName=tc. Accessed: May 2014. Teck. 2014j. Coal Mountain Phase 2 Project Description. Submitted to: British Columbia Environmental Assessment Office, August, 2014. Teck. 2014k. Fording River Operations Annual Reclamation Report for 2013. Report on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. Teck. 2014l. Coal Mountain Operations Annual Reclamation Report for 2013. Report on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. Teck. 2014m. Line Creek Operations Annual Reclamation Report for 2013. Report on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. Teck. 2014n. Greenhills Operations Annual Reclamation Report for 2013. Report on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. Teck. 2014c. Staff/hourly stats all sites. Email correspondence from S. Strom (Teck Coal Limited) to D. DeBiasio (Golder Associates Ltd.). Email on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 66 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Teck. 2014d. Sparwood Office Employee Data Request. Email correspondence from C. Hoogeveen (Teck Coal Limited) to S. Rutherford (Golder Associates Ltd.). Email on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. Teck. 2015a. Elkview Operations Baldy Ridge Extension Project Valued Components for Environmental Assessment. As approved by the British Columbia Environmental Assessment Office in September 2015. Teck. 2015b. Elkview Operations Baldy Ridge Extension Project Valued Components for Environmental Assessment. As approved by the British Columbia Environmental Assessment Office in September 2015. Teck. 2015c. Personal communication with Murray Chitwood (Teck) and Sarah Rutherford (Golder Associates Ltd.) January 27, 2015. Email on file at Golder Associates Ltd., Vancouver, BC. Tembec Inc. 2012. Tembec announces closing of the sale of its British Columbia wood products assets. Available at: http://tembec.com/en/Media/Press-Releases/tembec-announces-closing-sale-its-britishcolumbia-wood-products-assets?section=media. Accessed: March 2014. The Free Press. 2014. Sparwood to form trail naming committee. Available at: http://www.thefreepress.ca/news/252659901.html. Accessed: December 2014. The Free Press. 2015. Concerns over Jemi Fibre Corp. logging. Available at: http://www.thefreepress.ca/news/296736131.html. Accessed: March 2015. Tourism BC. 2012. 2012 In-Market Research Report Kootenay Rockies. Available http://www.destinationbc.ca/getattachment/Research/Research-by-Region/Kootenay-Rockies/InMarket_Regional_Report_KR_2012.pdf.aspx. Accessed December 2014. at: Tourism Fernie. 2013. Key Informant Meeting. Personal Communication with Sarah Rutherford, Golder Associates Ltd. on November 13, 2013. Tourism Fernie. 2015a. Mountain Biking. Available at: http://tourismfernie.com/activities/mountain-biking. Accessed March 2015. Tourism Fernie. 2015b. Fernie Bike Park - Lift Access. Available at: http://tourismfernie.com/activities/mountainbiking/fernie-bike-park. Accessed March 2015. Tourism Fernie. 2015c. Guided Hiking. Available at: http://tourismfernie.com/activities/guided-hiking. Accessed March 2015. Trails.com. n.d. Great Divide Trail: Coleman to Alexander Creek Campground. http://www.trails.com/tcatalog_trail.aspx?trailid=XRM016-007. Accessed: May 2014. Available at: TR0423T021. 2015, pers. comm. Personal communication with Sarah Rutherford (Golder Associates Ltd.) and holder of TR0423T021. June 23, 2015. United Riders of Crowsnest. 2013. Mountain Biking - Trails. Available at: http://www.uroc.ca/trails.php. Accessed: December 2014. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 67 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT VAST Resource Solutions Inc. 2013. RDEK Agricultural Plan Background Report. Available at: ftp://ftp.rdek.bc.ca/pdf/agplan/rdek%20ag%20plan_background%20report%20final.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. Vaugeois, Maher, Heeney, Rowsell, Bence, and McCartney, 2013. BC Resort Community Labour Market Strategic Analysis Final Report. Available at: https://www.go2hr.ca/sites/default/files/legacy/reports/go2BC-Resort-Community-Labour-Market-Strategic-Analysis.pdf. Accessed: May 2014. N7.1 Acts and Regulations Note: S.B.C. = Statute of British Columbia; S.C. = Statute of Canada; R.S.C. = Revised Statute of Canada. British Columbia Environmental Assessment Act. S.B.C. 2002. c.43. Available at: http://www.bclaws.ca. Municipalities Enabling and Validating Act (No. 3). S.B.C. 2001, c. 44. Available at: http://www.bclaws.ca. Private Managed Forest Land Act. S.B.C. 2003. c.80. Available at: http://www.bclaws.ca. Species at Risk Act S.C. 2002 c. 29. Available at: http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/S-15.3/ Wildfire Act. S.B.C. 2004. c.31. Available at: http://www.bclaws.ca. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 68 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT N8.0 GLOSSARY Alluvial Soil or earth material which has been deposited by running water, as in a riverbed, floodplain, or delta. Baseline A surveyed or predicted condition that serves as a reference point to which later surveys are coordinated or correlated. Biodiversity Biodiversity is the variety of life included at the genetic, individual organism, species, population, community, ecosystem and landscape levels of organization and all the ecological and biological processes through which they are connected. Biogeoclimatic Zone A geographic area having similar patterns of energy flow, vegetation and soils as a result of a broadly homogenous macroclimate. Coal Coal is a naturally occurring combustible rock containing 70% by volume carbonaceous material including moisture. Coal Bed Methane A type of natural gas. Continental Divide A drainage divide on a continent (especially North America) such that the drainage basin on one side of the divide feeds into one ocean and the basin on the other site either feeds into a different ocean, or else is not connected to the open sea. Crown Forest Licence A licence or land area where a licence is available to cut timber on Crown land. Crown Land All provincial and federal government lands. Provincial parks and public land are examples of provincial Crown land. Drainage Basin A region of land that eventually contributes water to a river or lake. Ecosystem An integrated and stable association of living and non-living resources functioning within a defined physical location. A community of organisms and its environment functioning as an ecological unit. For the purposes of assessment, the ecosystem must be defined according to a particular unit and scale. Environmental Assessment A review of the effects that a proposed development will have on the local and regional environment. Fee Simple Land A land estate in which the owner is entitled to the entire property with unconditional power of disposition except as limited by the original grant or contained in any other grant or disposition from the Crown. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 69 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT First Nation A term that came into common usage in the 1970s to replace the word Indian, which some people found offensive. Although the term First Nation is widely used, no legal definition of it exists. The term has generally come to refer to Aboriginal groups that have status under the Indian Act. Some Aboriginal groups have also adopted the term First Nation to replace the word band in the name of their community. Footprint The proposed development area that directly affects the soil and vegetation components of the landscape. Footprint The proposed development area that directly affects the soil and vegetation components of the landscape. Furbearers Mammals that have traditionally been trapped or hunted for their fur. Global Positioning System A system of satellites, computers and receivers that is able to determine the latitude and longitude of a receiver on Earth by calculating the time difference for signals from different satellites to reach the receiver. Habitat The area or environment where an organism or ecological community normally lives or occurs. Land Tenure The right to exclusively occupy and use a specified area of land. Tenure may be limited to certain resources such as timber but not to all resources in a given area. Tenure may be held by individuals, communities, government, or corporations. Landscape A heterogeneous land area with interacting ecosystems that are repeated in similar form throughout. From a wildlife perspective, a landscape is an area of land containing a mosaic of habitat patches within which a particular “focal” or “target” habitat patch is embedded. Landscape unit Spatially identified areas of land and/or water used for long-term planning of resource management activities Local Study Area Defines the spatial extent directly or indirectly affected by the Project. Managed Forest Privately-owned forest land property for which an acceptable forest management commitment has been made that is approved and complies with the Private Managed Forest Land Act (2003). Mitigation Implementation of practices including design, construction, scheduling, restorative efforts, to control, reduce or eliminate a potential adverse effect of an activity or Project. Mitigation may address ecological, economic, or social effects. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 70 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Old Growth Forest An ecosystem distinguished by old trees and related structural attributes. Old growth encompasses the later stages of stand development that typically differ from earlier stages in a variety of characteristics which may include tree size, accumulations of large dead woody material, number of canopy layers, species, composition and ecosystem function. Old growth forests are those forested areas where the annual growth equals annual losses, or where the mean annual increment of timber volume equals zero. They can be defined as those stands that are self-regenerating (i.e., having a specific structure that is maintained). Periglacial A periglacial lake is one formed where the natural drainage of the topography is obstructed by an ice sheet, ice cap or glacier. Permafrost Permanently frozen ground (subsoil). Permafrost areas are divided into more northern areas in which permafrost is continuous, and those more southern areas in which patches of permafrost alternate with unfrozen ground. Productive Forest Forest land that is capable of producing a merchantable stand within a reasonable length of time. Regional Study Area Defines the spatial extent related to the cumulative effects resulting from the Project and other regional developments. Residual Effects Effects that remain after mitigation has been applied. Riparian Terrain, vegetation or a position next to or associated with a stream, floodplain or standing waterbody. Seral Type Related to a community or stage of development found in ecological succession of an ecosystem advancing towards its climax community. Silviculture The science and practice of controlling the establishment, composition and growth of the vegetation in forest stands. It includes the control or production of stand structures such as snags and down logs, in addition to live vegetation. Viewscapes A range of sight that provides an aesthetically pleasing view. Waterbody A general term that refers to rivers, streams, and lakes. Watershed The entire surface drainage area that contributes water to a lake or river. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 71 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT Wildlife October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 Under the Species at Risk Act, wildlife is defined as a species, subspecies, variety or geographically or genetically distinct population of animal, plant or other organism, other than a bacterium or virus that is wild by nature and is native to Canada or has extended its range into Canada without human intervention and has been present in Canada for at least 50 years. 72 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT APPENDIX N.I User Group Mapping Session Seasonal Calendars October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 APPENDIX N.I User Group Mapping Session Seasonal Calendars Table N.I-1 Elkford ATV Activity Area ATV all areas Location Notes Estimated Number of Days per Month Group Members Engage in Activity January February March April - - - - Existing Trails May June July August September October daily usage by members November December - - - = no response provided; ATV = all-terrain vehicle. Table N.I-2 Hillcrest Fish and Game Association Location Notes Estimated Number of Days per Month Group Members Engage in Activity Activity Area Fishing - Elk River Fishing - Summit Lake - - - - 20 20 20 20 - - - - Fishing - Michel Creek - - - - 10 10 10 10 - - - - January February March April May June July August September October - - - - - 15 15 15 - - November December - - - = no response provided. Table N.I-3 Activity Area BC Ministry of Environment Location Notes Estimated Number of Days per Month Group Members Engage in Activity January February A Hunting B C cougar 100 to 200 days March April May June August September October November December - - black bears 200 to 300 hunter days - - 1,000 to 2,000 days for elk, white tailed deer, mule deer and moose - - black bears 50 hunter days - - 400 to 500 days for elk, white tailed deer, mule deer and moose - - black bears 50 hunter days - - 300 to 400 days for elk, white tailed deer, mule deer and moose - = no response provided. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 July N.I-1 APPENDIX N.I User Group Mapping Session Seasonal Calendars Table N.I-4 Activity Area Elk River Guiding Company Location notes not much angling in area A, but prime spawning habitat and juvenile development for fish on Harmer Creek Estimated Number of Days per Month Group Members Engage in Activity January February March April May June July August September October November December - - - - - - - - - - - - Angling A Angling B - - - - - 15 to 20 per day Along Elk River and Line Creek - - Angling C - - - - - To Sparwood - - Note: No response was provided by the following groups: Freestone Fly Angler, Sparwood Fish and Wildlife, Elk Valley Mountaineers and Fernie Search and Rescue. - = no response provided. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 N.I-2 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT APPENDIX N.II Hunting and Trapping Seasons for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 APPENDIX N.II Hunting and Trapping Seasons for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 Table N.II-1 Hunting Seasons in Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 Species Mule deer White-tailed deer Class September 10 to November 10 1 bucks September 1 to September 9 (a) (bow only season and youth only season) 1 September 10 to November 30 1 bucks September 1 to September 9 (a) (bow only season and youth season) 1 antlerless October 10 to October 31 2 November 1 to November 30 (youth only season) 2 December 1 to December 20 (bow only season) 2 6-point bulls September 10 to October 20 1 bulls September 1 to September 9 (bow only season) 1 (f) spike bulls antlerless (f) Moose spike-fork bulls Bighorn mountain sheep full curl bighorn rams Black bear Bag Limit 4 point bucks either sex Elk Season Dates not applicable Wolf September 10 to September 19 September 1 to September 9 (bow only season) 1 (b) 1 October 15 to October 31 1 September 1 to October 14 (bow only season) 1 September 10 to October 25 1 September 10 to November 30 2 April 1 to June 30 2 September 1 to September 9 (bow only season) 2 August 1 to August 31 (private land only, with permission) 2 September 10 to March 31 2 April 1 to June 15 2 Coyote September 10 to March 31 no bag limit Wolverine November 1 to January 31 1 Lynx November 15 to December 31 Cougar September 10 to January 31 not applicable (c) 1 1 Bobcat November 15 to February 15 Snowshoe hare August 1 to April 30 Racoon September 10 to March 31 no bag limit Columbian ground squirrel No Closed Season (private land only, with permission) no bag limit Skunk August 1 to April 30 no bag limit Grouse: blue, ruffed and spruce September 1 to November 30 Raven not applicable Ptarmigan Pheasant Turkey Mourning doves October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 No Closed Season September 10 to November 30 cocks bearded October 15 - November 30 April 15 to May 15 1 10 (daily) 5 (15 possession limit) 5 10 (30 possession limit) 3 (daily) 1 (d) September 1 to September 30 (bow only season) 1 any turkey October 1 to October 15 1 not applicable September 1 to September 30 N.II-1 (d) 5 (15 possession limit) APPENDIX N.II Hunting and Trapping Seasons for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 Table N.II-1 Hunting Seasons in Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 (continued) Species Class Season Dates Bag Limit 10 (30 possession limit) Coots, common snipe 8 (e) (24 possession limit) Ducks Geese: snow, ross’s and whitefronted not applicable September 10 to December 23 5 (15 possession limit) 10 (30 possession limit) Geese: Canada and cackling Source: MOE 2014a. (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) Restricted to hunters under the age of 18. Restricted to hunters under the age of 18 and those 65 years of age or older. The cougar season closes 72 hours after the regional manager has published that the total number of female cougars killed in WMUs 4-1 to 404, 4-21 to 4-26, 4-34 to 4-37 and 4-40 has reached 20. The aggregate bag limit for turkey is 2, only one may be taken in the spring and one in the fall. Restricted daily bag limits of 4 pintails, 4 canvasbacks, 2 goldeneye and 2 harlequins. Restricted to only portions of 4-23 only. Table N.II-2 Trapping Seasons for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 Species Beaver Season October 15 to April 30 Black bear October 1 to May 31 Bobcat November 15 to February 15 Coyote October 15 to March 31 Fox October 15 to February 28 Lynx November 15 to February 15 Marten November 1 to February 15 Mink November 1 to February 15 Muskrat October 15 to April 30 Racoon October 1 to March 31 River otter October 15 to April 30 Skunk October 15 to February 28 Squirrel November 1 to March 15 Weasel November 1 to February 15 Wolverine November 1 to January 31 Wolf October 15 to March 31 Source: BC MOE 2014b. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 N.II-2 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT APPENDIX N.III Hunting Data for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 APPENDIX N.III Hunting Data for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 Table N.III-1 Hunting Data for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 Measurement hunters hunter days Elk Moose kills 2009 2010 2011 2012 1,090 1,180 1,163 1,191 1,236 Average per Year 1,059 8,822 7,109 5,202 8,549 9,260 9,109 12,011 12,486 12,417 13,615 12,802 11,138 95 209 171 174 155 247 251 186 249 203 9.54 10.78 10.02 11.02 10.58 10.68 11.43 10.36 1.05 kills per hunter 0.02 0.12 0.26 0.19 0.23 0.20 0.19 0.14 0.21 0.22 0.16 0.20 hunters 34 46 60 66 58 72 142 395 317 223 316 173 hunter days 129 196 296 291 285 278 1,324 3,105 2,785 3,026 3,289 1,500 kills 18 35 32 39 39 53 77 81 38 48 52 51 days per hunter 3.79 4.26 4.93 4.41 4.91 3.86 9.32 7.86 8.79 13.57 10.41 0.87 kills per hunter 0.53 0.76 0.53 0.59 0.67 0.74 0.54 0.21 0.12 0.22 0.16 0.03 kills 579 500 388 564 587 624 737 523 826 745 857 693 6,395 4,964 3,812 5,457 6,388 6,623 8,147 6,592 10,745 7,691 10,950 7,776 167 147 108 222 183 164 266 159 256 237 314 222 days per hunter 11.04 9.93 9.82 9.68 10.88 10.61 11.05 12.60 13.01 10.32 12.78 1.12 kills per hunter 0.29 0.29 0.28 0.39 0.31 0.26 0.36 0.30 0.31 0.32 0.37 0.03 kills 576 421 343 533 590 542 717 597 618 672 693 630 5,965 4,239 3,210 5,640 5,406 5,408 7,375 6,521 6,999 6,946 7,446 6,516 55 87 65 99 113 82 107 36 104 61 34 84 days per hunter 10.36 10.07 9.36 10.58 9.16 9.98 10.29 10.92 11.33 10.34 10.74 1.03 kills per hunter 0.10 0.21 0.19 0.19 0.19 0.15 0.15 0.06 0.17 0.09 0.05 0.01 hunters 83 76 24 80 62 98 79 68 119 119 101 91 hunter days 527 436 149 403 343 480 661 450 641 511 610 521 kills 21 24 2 20 19 32 24 12 45 40 18 26 days per hunter 6.35 5.74 6.21 5.04 5.53 4.90 8.37 6.62 5.39 4.29 6.04 0.57 kills per hunter 0.25 0.32 0.08 0.25 0.31 0.33 0.30 0.18 0.38 0.34 0.18 0.03 hunters 102 92 58 125 113 112 154 169 150 168 131 137 1,035 882 730 1,278 1,269 1,225 1,843 1,832 1,350 1,856 1,757 1,506 kills 6 3 9 15 15 6 8 2 6 12 16 10 days per hunter 10.15 9.59 12.59 10.22 11.23 10.94 11.97 10.84 9.00 11.05 13.41 1.10 kills per hunter 0.06 0.03 0.16 0.12 0.13 0.05 0.05 0.01 0.04 0.07 0.12 0.01 70 77 78 92 110 64 82 140 91 126 128 106 1,532 1,040 1,170 727 1,111 539 1,593 1,497 1,565 962 1,971 1,371 hunter days kills days per hunter kills per hunter hunters hunter days Grizzly bear 2008 909 10.18 hunters Black bear 2007 859 196 hunter days Wolf 2006 896 9.59 hunters Sheep 2005 511 97 hunter days Goat 2004 741 10.81 hunters Mule deer 2003 816 days per hunter hunter days White tailed deer 2002 kills - 6 - 8 8 9 - - - - 13 4 21.89 13.51 15.00 7.90 10.10 8.42 19.43 10.69 17.20 7.63 15.40 1.30 0.00 - 0.08 - 0.09 0.07 0.14 - - - - 0.10 124 129 64 147 135 130 142 216 169 179 139 157 1,064 1,112 685 1,512 1,431 1,549 1,188 2,316 2,291 2,019 2,134 1,730 35 19 7 12 18 10 12 22 9 6 14 16 days per hunter 8.58 8.62 10.70 10.29 10.60 11.92 8.37 10.72 13.56 11.28 15.35 1.10 kills per hunter 0.28 0.15 0.11 0.08 0.13 0.08 0.08 0.10 0.05 0.03 0.10 0.01 hunters 6 3 12 1 5 5 11 16 13 4 7 8 hunter days 86 39 228 25 93 117 257 297 221 40 126 153 kills 2 - 7 1 3 2 9 7 8 2 2 4 days per hunter 14.33 13.00 19.00 25.00 18.60 23.40 23.36 18.56 17.00 10.00 18.00 1.84 kills per hunter 0.33 - 0.58 1.00 0.60 0.40 0.82 0.44 0.62 0.50 0.29 0.05 October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 N.III-1 APPENDIX N.III Hunting Data for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 Table N.III-1 Hunting Data for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 (continued) Measurement hunters hunter days Ruffed grouse kills 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Average per Year 54 62 145 76 52 93 193 135 157 113 - - - - - - - - - - - - 497 398 70 147 445 336 238 124 785 417 340 380 - - - - - - - - - - - - 7.10 4.47 1.30 2.37 3.07 4.42 4.58 1.33 4.07 3.09 2.17 0.34 77 89 69 47 120 75 73 94 165 125 105 104 - - - - - - - - - - - - 555 420 186 93 447 272 258 152 427 345 222 338 days per hunter - - - - - - - - - - - - kills per hunter 7.21 4.72 2.70 1.98 3.73 3.63 3.53 1.62 2.59 2.76 2.11 0.33 21 21 46 31 94 38 42 63 91 52 78 58 - - - - - - - - - - - - 400 150 100 39 59 94 52 - 121 115 65 120 kills hunters hunter days Cougar 2004 89 kills per hunter hunters Blue grosbeak 2003 70 days per hunter hunter days Spruce grouse 2002 kills days per hunter - - - - - - - - - - - - kills per hunter 19.05 7.14 2.17 1.26 0.63 2.47 1.24 - 1.33 2.21 0.83 0.21 hunters 17 20 12 23 27 10 25 34 19 31 33 25 hunter days 182 420 212 493 392 112 415 397 214 546 334 372 kills 3 - 2 10 7 2 5 8 3 - 15 6 days per hunter 10.71 21.00 17.67 21.43 14.52 11.20 16.60 11.68 11.26 17.61 10.12 1.48 kills per hunter 0.18 - 0.17 0.43 0.26 0.20 0.20 0.24 0.16 - 0.45 0.02 Source: FLNRO 2013 pers. comm. - = Data not available. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 N.III-2 BALDY RIDGE EXTENSION - LAND USE AND TENURE BASELINE REPORT APPENDIX N.IV Trapping Activity for Local Study Area October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 APPENDIX N.IV Trapping Activity for Local Study Area Table N.IV-1 TR0423T023 TR0423T021 TR0423T022 TR0423T005 TR0423T004 TR0423T006 Trapping Activity for Wildlife Management Unit 4-23 TR0423T008 2006 2007 2008 2009 Total beaver - - - - - - 0 - - - - - - 0 lynx - - - - - - 0 wolf - - - - - - 0 coyote 7 6 10 3 - - 26 lynx 1 - - 1 - - 2 marten 1 1 4 2 - - 8 squirrel - - - - - - 0 wolf - 1 - - - - 1 - - - - - - - 0 1 - - - - - 1 lynx 1 - 1 - - - 2 marten 6 - 6 - - - 12 1 - - - - - 1 beaver - 19 3 10 - 7 39 lynx - 1 1 - - - 2 marten 5 2 19 2 14 15 57 weasel 1 - 11 4 1 2 19 coyote - 1 4 - - - 5 marten 6 - - - - - 6 beaver - 8 - - - - 8 coyote - 1 - - - - 1 lynx - - 2 1 - 1 4 beaver TR0423T010 2005 coyote wolverine TR0423T009 2004 - - - 1 - 1 2 11 - 4 1 - - 16 marten 2 - 3 8 8 5 26 squirrel 3 - 20 2 8 15 48 weasel 1 - - - 8 8 17 lynx - - 1 1 - - 2 muskrat - - - - - 1 1 marten 3 3 4 5 7 8 30 bobcat - - - - 1 - 1 lynx - - - - 1 - 1 50 43 93 41 48 63 338 Total Source: FLNRO 2014d pers. comm. - = Data not included. October 2015 Report No. 1213490003/R31 N.IV-1 Golder Associates Ltd. 102, 2535 - 3rd Avenue S.E. Calgary, Alberta, T2A 7W5 Canada T: +1 (403) 299 5600