Newsletter - Port Authority Police Benevolent Association Inc
Transcription
Newsletter - Port Authority Police Benevolent Association Inc
Page 1 PAPBA Report port Port Authority Police Benevolent Association, Inc. 2010 PAPBA COP OF THE YEAR Vol. VII No. 1 February 2011 hicle’s locked doors but eventually persuaded the female to unlock the doors herself. Rail opened the door and the woman lunged at him with a knife and retreated back into the vehicle. It was then that Rail realized the blood on the woman’s neck was from self-inflicted knife wounds. Rail was shocked to see the woman’s four-month-old son on the seat behind her. After a tense standoff, Rail was successful in disarming the On Thursday, February 4, 2010, Port Authority Police Officer Thomas woman and taking her into custody. As Rail entered the veRail was on routine patrol in the vicinity of the George Washington hicle, he noticed a single-burner, gas camping stove, with a Bridge in Fort Lee, NJ. At approximately 4:15 p.m., Rail was dislit flame on the front seat. The lit stove crepatched to investigate a reported motor vehicle acThomas Rail ated a lethal environment within the sealed cident on the entrance road to Palisades Interstate vehicle, requiring Rail to act with extreme Parkway. Once on scene, Rail observed a 2000 Audi A4 exhibited caution in order to extract the baby safely that appeared to have veered off the roadway into extreme from the vehicle. Rail then coordinated one of the many large boulders lining the roadway. The boulders courage while emergency medical response for the woman and the child. create a confronting safety barrier It became apparent that the woman tried to for vehicles an armed intentionally drive the vehicle off the roadtraveling the way to send the vehicle into the Hudson Rivindividual, road, which er below, meaning almost certain death for and a situation her and her son. When that attempt failed, is high above the Hudson she lit the stove to ensure the death of her that required River. As Rail son and then proceed to attempt suicide by all his skills as slitting her throat. approached the vehicle, a police Officer Police Officer Thomas Rail exhibited extreme which was courage while confronting an armed individin a precarious position, he ual and a situation that required all his skills as a police ofnoticed a female in the rear ficer. His quick thinking and swift actions resulted in averting seat with what appeared to a murder/suicide while placing himself in grave danger. The be blood on her neck. Rail Port Authority PBA is honored to award Police Officer Thomas attempted to open the veRail the 2010 PAPBA Cop of the Year Award. report PAPBA Page 2 PAPBA Report An Official Publication of The Port Authority Police Benevolent Association, Inc. ExEcutIVE OFFIcE: 611 Palisade Avenue Englewood Cliffs, NJ 07632 Ph: 201.871.2100 Ph: 212.947.3754 Fx: 201.871.2343 E-Mail: info@papba.org Web site: www.papba.org PrEsIdENt PAUL NUNzIATO FIrst VIcE PrEsIdENt Robert Morris sEcONd VIcE PrEsIdENt Mike DeFilippis trEasurEr RJ White rEcOrdINg sEcrEtary Steve Ekizian FINaNcIal sEcrEtary Frank Conti sErgEaNt-at-arms Phil Erickson ExEcutIVE sEcrEtary Brian Bull BOard OF trustEEs Chairman Bob Egbert Chris Carini Cesar Morales Joe Arias Gus Mokanos NEWSLETTER DESIGN/PRODUCTION: Marci Rosenblum RWD Group (845) 364-0222 A Message From President PAUL NUNZIATO First, I want to congratulate Police Officer Thomas Rail (GWB) for being selected as the 2010 Cop of the Year. I also congratulate all the 2010 Cop of the Month recipients for their outstanding police work. The professionalism shown by these members and the extraordinary level of their work shows the Port Authority Police Department in a positive light to the public and other police agencies. Since I became President of the PBA, I have sought to highlight these individual acts of bravery and extraordinary conduct by our members in order to better promote our job. Police officers, firefighters, and teachers have come under attack by politicians who want to blame the excesses of government on public servants. In this down economy, no one wants to pay extra taxes or tolls. With no one else to blame, we are a good target for the political propaganda that union workers with pensions and benefits are the cause of all the problems. No one complains about the multi-million dollar annual bonuses paid to the bankers, CEOs, and mortgage brokers that derailed our economy, but everyone thinks that our pensions and benefits are too rich. In this political environment, there has never been a more important time to promote the outstanding job that our Department does day in and day out. We keep the citizens of the metropolitan area safe from crime and other security threats and still keep the region’s airports, bridges, tunnels, and transportation facilities operating efficiently. In this time of diminishing public budgets, we must promote the professionalism of our Department and our membership. I can’t state enough that our membership needs to be proactive and do our job diligently on a daily basis or we risk the job not being around tomorrow. The best way to protect your job is to get out and be the police! To that end, we have created a new award to recognize the Command that has been the most active, where our membership is doing its job, day in and day out. I am happy to announce that our first Command of the Year Award goes to the The Port Authority PBA joined nearly 70 public employee unions that gathered in Albany on February 1 as part of the New York State Public Employee Conference’s Legislative Gathering. This annual event is a chance for the municipal labor organization to present its unified legislative agenda to New York’s lawmakers and let them know that despite the state’s fiscal woes, the budget cannot be balanced on the backs of public employees. Shortly after the gathering, Governor Andrew Cuomo presented his proposed $132.9 billion budget for the state’s fiscal year beginning April 1, plugging a $10 billion gap without raising taxes, but warned that as many as 9,800 state workers could be laid off if public employee unions do not give up wage and benefit increases. He also called for cuts in funding for state operations, Medicaid and education. The proposed cuts brought sharp rebukes from unions who are being asked to shoulder a lot of the pain. Under his plan, state operations would see a reduction of $1.4 billion, which includes expected wage and benefit cuts of unionized workers. The Governor’s proposals immediately drew ire from unions. “We are all willing to do our part, but this budget proposal does not spread out the pain,” said PAPBA President Paul Nunziato. He added that the PAPBA will be meeting with other big police unions from around the City and State on an ongoing basis to try and stay in front of the challenging issues ahead. “This is definitely going to be a rough year. The State’s problems are bad, and the City’s aren’t any better. We’re taking hits on all fronts and the more we can band together with other police unions, the better off we will be in the long run,” he said. report PAPBA Lincoln Tunnel. The 75 members assigned there compiled 726 arrests and a staggering 17,086 summonses, all while keeping the Tunnel traffic flowing and serving motorists with a courteous and professional attitude. Congratulations to all the members of the Lincoln Tunnel Command! Our members are out on the front lines every day while the Agency we work for takes us for granted. PA civilians who do not understand or appreciate what we do put us in harm’s way by not providing us with proper equipment or manpower. This not only jeopardizes us, but also the people we are sworn to protect. Budget crunchers on Park Avenue are just looking at numbers and don’t have any concept of policing. The police professionals who do understand the consequences of cutting these budgets have no real voice in setting their budgets. This has to stop. The PBA is working to eliminate added levels of bureaucracy for our safety as well as the people we protect every day. I think the Executive Director, Deputy Executive Director, and incoming Chairman of the Board of Commissioners are realizing the need to cut the layers of bureaucracy out of the Public Safety Department. The PBA is working to accomplish this inside the Agency as well as with the Governor’s offices in both states and numerous politicians from New York and New Jersey on both sides of the aisle. While the PBA fights these bureaucratic battles, we need to reconnect with the public (as do police everywhere) so they remember what a difficult and dangerous job we perform on their behalf, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. The public needs to be reminded why we are entitled to the pensions and benefits that we earn. A routine day in our profession is the worst day of a citizen’s life: they or someone they love was hurt, killed or the victim of a crime. We, as law enforcement officers, have to respond to these tragedies and protect people from events that other people run from. The public honored police after September 11, 2001. They said that no one would ever forget and they thanked us for our service. Well, less than 10 short years later, they have forgotten and it is our job to start reminding them. We need to do our jobs in a professional and visible manner to help everyone remember why their children want to grow up to be police officers. WE ARE THE GOOD GUYS! From left: Chairman, Board of Trustees Bobby Egbert, Treasurer RJ White, Assemblyman Peter Abbate, President Paul Nunziato and 1st Vice President Bobby Morris at the New York State Public Employee Conference Legislative Gathering on February 1, 2011 in Albany. Page 3 PAPBA Report dElEgatEs George Washington Bridge Brian Ahern Matt McKeon holland Tunnel Manuel Cuprill Giovanni Perrotta Kennedy airport Michael Balestracci Peter Candela Robert Paulsen Jordan Esposito Thomas Koster LaGuardia airport Anthony Baicich Dominic Palumbo John Garrone Marciano Shay Lincoln Tunnel Anthony Giardullo Paul Pimenta newark airport Lou Defelice Patrick Nascak Chris Demetriades Andrew Kurpat Brian O’Connell Port authority Bus Terminal Robert zafonte Marcus Ciserano PAPBA Report is produced by the Port Authority Police Benevolent Association. Entire contents copyrighted. FIRST report PAPBA Page 4 dElEgatEs Port authority Trans-hudson Jerry Colligan Jim Higgins Christopher McNerney Michael Mollahan Port newark George Brown Howard Latimer Special Operations Division Raymond Butler Brett Porigow William Riiska Vinny zappulla Staten island Bridges Jerome Crimi Alexander Hamaty World Trade Center Angel Serrano Peter Sippel VP Bobby Morris There has been a lot going on so far this year, although we are only just beginning February. I would like to start off with a few recent positive notes. On January 2, 2011, President Obama signed into law the James Zadroga 9/11 Health and Compensation Act of 2010, also called the “Zadroga Act.” This new law provides health care and medical monitoring for those exposed to toxins released by the attack on the World Trade Center towers and reopens the Federal Victim Compensation Fund (VCF) to provide economic relief to those harmed by the attacks. You may be eligible for additional compensation for your injuries, wage losses and medical care from the Zadroga Bill benefits. If you would like more detailed information about this new law, please contact the Union office. Another change that took effect at the beginning of this year deals with health insurance for young adults. Beginning January 1, 2011, Federal Health Care Legislation requires essential health benefit extensions for your adult children up until age 26 regardless of their financial dependency, residency or employment/school status. Unless you have been living under a rock, you have read or heard on numerous occasions from the media and politicians alike that public sector employees and their benefits and pensions are the cause of New York’s fiscal problems. In New York, government pension contributions have risen sharply. The media and politicians scare the public into believing the system will soon go bankrupt unless we trim benefits. The truth is, New York’s pension system is solvent and fully funded. While it’s true that contributions have risen, it is because for years, City and State governments relied on high-performing pension funds to pay for their share of contributions. In fact, in 2000, New York’s share dropped to zero. Municipalities did not have to contribute for years, yet public employees in contributory plans continued to pay into the system. The collapse of Wall Street led to the reduction in those investment returns, thus forcing higher City and State government funding. This is not the fault of public employees, yet the media likes to blame it on someone and we’re the target. As the saying goes, if it’s in print, it must be the truth. Quite honestly, it’s in print so often that if I didn’t know any better, I might believe it, too. New York State legislators are also trying to refocus the public’s attention off their ineptitude and on to something else. With the 2010 elections changing the face of politics in New York, we now have a Republican majority in the Senate, a Democratic minority and a newly formed Independent Democratic Caucus with four Senators. Let’s see what gets accomplished now versus what we’ve watched in the last two years with the Senate fiasco over which party was the controlling party. I wish I had the space here to speak about New Jersey and the union bashing taking place on that side of the river. But, I guess I’ll save that for my next column. Simply put: we have our work cut out for us. It seems that the common and popular stance will be to bash unionized workers. With 10 percent unemployment and a desperate workforce that has seen reduced wages and benefits, one would think that public anger would be directed at those who caused this mess to begin with. Wall Street executives are enjoying millions in bonuses, while New Yorkers are being asked to direct their anger at the “greedy” cops and firemen. Public employees have become a convenient scapegoat for those who would rather distract from the fact that corporations are enjoying record profits while not creating any new jobs. There is a blatant need to educate the public. The PAPBA is doing our part in that area and has joined together with other police and fire unions in an education program that you will hear more about in the coming months. As a union member, you will have to, as sad as this sounds, defend yourselves to family, friends, and strangers if you haven’t already. Speak out about the job we do, the hours we keep, the situations we encounter, and explain that we do our jobs to protect others and are entitled to fair compensation. Congratulations to our Top Cops; they truly deserve the accolades and are an example of what we do and how hard we work. Do your job and in unity we will get through this tough time. Second VP Mike DeFilippis I would like to start by wishing everyone a happy and healthy New Year. During the past year, numerous New Jersey Police Departments faced serious financial problems and hundreds of Police Officers were laid off. Being the New Jersey State PBA Delegate, I attend both the State and Bergen County conference meetings. Many New Jersey Departments are gearing up for even more layoffs in 2011. The murder rate, along with violent crimes, has increased in several major New Jersey cities in which the Port Authority has facilities. Every day our Officers have to deal with the possibility of terrorist attacks and now increased gang violence due to municipalities downsizing their Police Departments. Let’s see what steps Police Headquarters has implemented: Discontinue heavy weapons training because it costs too much. You now have more than 125 Officers who can no longer carry these weapons. Excellent decision with European terrorist intelligence warning of a Mumbai style terrorist attack, and gang violence being on the rise. The Port Authority should step up to the plate and assist municipalities by increasing our patrols and covering all posts. On the other hand, the Port Authority had no problem paying for a Weehawken Police Officer on Lincoln Tunnel property backing up a Port Authority construction crew. A grievance was filed that is still pending. In fact, we had several problems with other Police Departments on our property providing construction protection at the George Washington Bridge, Newark/Teterboro Airports and Port Elizabeth. Due to the paperwork supplied by the Delegates, all were resolved and the Departments were removed. Any time you observe another Department in our jurisdiction, doing our job, call the Tour Commander to the scene. Also, notify your delegate. Protect our jobs! Take a good look at the World Trade Center security issue. This is our house — 37 of our Officers died in our house. Many Officers were injured, became ill and had to retire. Several have recently passed away. The men and women of the Port Authority Police answered the call on September 11, 2011. Many lives were saved due to their heroic efforts. Our Officers worked 12 hour tours, had their RDOs and vacations cancelled for a long period of time and never complained. Other Departments were treated to 9-11 vacations and concerts while we remained on 12-hour tours. How quick the Port Authority forgets when giving away our house. Commisioner Ray Kelly wants to send 600 NYPD officers to our house. People are being murdered in the Bronx and Brooklyn but he has no problem sending Police Officers from these crime-ridden precincts to our house. This is pure politics. Commissioner Kelly is appeasing his rich friends on Wall Street, while poor people are being gunned down. Keep your 600 Police Officers where they belong. It’s time for the civilian leadership at Park Avenue, along with the uniform leadership at Police Headquarters, to step up to the plate on the World Trade Center security issue. I know a place where Commissioner Kelly can put his 600 Police Officers. BEND OVER RAY! On a brighter note, several of my New Year’s resolutions have already come true. Bye-bye Chief Pumpkinhead Whittaker and Sidney Fields. Let’s not forget retired Inspector Preston Fucci. I hope you all had the opportunity to see Preston’s video on our contract discipline. All the veterans know what a class act Preston was. For you younger Officers who didn’t know Preston, picture this: Whittaker and Fucci on the game show Jeopardy. Whittaker wins -500 to -450. Preston, keep up the good work with your national Right to Work Committee. Your next video should be on a topic that you have firsthand knowledge of: alcohol in law enforcement. I would like to welcome Deputy Superintendent Jerry Speziale to the job. Jerry put the Passaic County Sheriff’s Department on the map. We all hope he can do the same for this job. Remember it’s the professional Police Officers at the Port Authority who make this job work. We must go out every day and protect our jobs. Be safe and back each other. report PAPBA Page 5 attorney John McAusland General Counsel disciplinary representation Brian Bull PBA Representative certified Public accountants McEnerney, Brady & Co. (973) 535-2880 New york chaplain Rev. Joseph D’Angelo (516) 223-9101 New Jersey chaplain Father David Baratelli (908) 232-1162 Police stress counselor Peter J. Killeen aFFIlIatIONs: New York State Association of PBAs, Inc. National Association of Police Organizations, Inc. New Jersey State Policemen’s Benevolent Association, Inc. New York State Public Employee Conference, Inc. Police Conference of New York, Inc. Treasurer RJ White report PAPBA InAdequATe STAFFIng A PRoBlem Page 6 ImPoRTAnT PHone numBeRS Pa Employee Benefits (212) 435-2870 Ny state Police & Fire retirement (866) 805-0990 (518) 474-7736 deferred compensation (800) 422-8463 PaPBa Office (201) 871-2100 (212) 947-3754 Labor unions are organizations that represent people at work. The philosophy of a union, that a group is more powerful than any individual, has not changed throughout time. By joining together with other workers, there is a better chance of having a voice and influence at the workplace. them a voice in the workplace. Unions also kept management from taking advantage of employees. Unions play a pivotal role both in securing legislated labor protections and rights such as safety and health, overtime, and family medical leave, and enforcing these rights on the job. Since union workers are more informed, they are more likely to understand their employment protections as well as social insurance programs like Workers’ Compensation. The beginning of the American Labor Movement started with the Industrial Revolution. Textile mills were the first factories built in the United States. These factories sprung up all over and a demand for workers increased. They hired large amounts of young women and children who were expected to do the same work as men for less wages. Many Americans take their job benefits for granted, forgetting the struggles our ancestors underwent for their security and happiness. As per the United States Constitution, every American is entitled to the right of “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness”. If the workers were controlled and overpowered by their employers, you can rest assured that they would never enjoy the aforementioned constitutional rights. During this period, the United States had the highest job-related-to-fatality rate of any other industrialized nation in the world. Eighty hour or more work weeks were the norm and wages were extremely low. Men and women earned 20to 40-percent less than the minimum deemed necessary for a decent life. The number was even worse for children. The American Labor Movement of the 19th Century developed as a result of city-wide organization that unhappy workers were establishing. These men and women were determined to receive the rights and privileges they deserved as citizens of a free country. No longer would they put up with being treated like slaves and work under unbearable conditions. Workers realized the importance of economic and legal protection against the powerful employers who took advantage of them. The Labor Movement had an extremely violent and ugly side, complete with strikes, riots, and loss of life. The country would not have survived if the people had not compromised and shared the wealth. It was hard fought, but over time unions were successful in obtaining better pay and working conditions for workers. Unions protected the rights of workers and gave Today unions have become the scapegoat for politicians explaining the reasons for the current fiscal crisis. All of a sudden, our salaries are too high, medical benefits are too costly, work rules are counter productive, and they want to remove our guaranteed pensions. A naive public is blindly agreeing with them. I guess mismanagement of funds at the federal, state, and local government levels has nothing to do with anything. How about corruption and corporate greed? No that’s not it; it’s the fault of the poor working men and women who get up every morning to go to work to pay their ever increasing bills and put food on the table. There are forces out there working 24 hours a day, 7 days a week to whittle away at hard-won benefits and turn the clock back on the Labor Movement. People must be educated to the fact that all Americans are entitled to a fair and honest wage, affordable healthcare coverage, a safe work environment and protection from employer greed. The current trend of the rich get richer and the working men get shafted must be halted. The Bureau of Labor Statistics report PAPBA Page 7 reports that Unions lost 612,000 members in 2010, dropping the unionized share of the work force to 11.9% from 12.3% in 2009. That follows a loss of 771,000 workers in 2008, continuing a steady decline from the 1950s when more than a third of workers belonged to unions. Union membership in the private sector fell from 7.2% to 6.9%, a low point not seen since the infancy of the labor movement in the 1930s. Unions have had a substantial impact on unionized and non-unionized workers. Many laws that benefit working people, union or not, would have never been passed without heavy union support. OSHA, minimum wage, and the 40-hour work week are some examples. Unions reduce wage inequality because they raise wages more for low and middle wage workers than for higher wage workers. Unions have set norms and established work practices that have become more generalized throughout the economy, thereby improving pay and working conditions for the entire workforce. Also, many fringe benefits such as pensions and healthcare were first provided in the union sector and later spilled over to non union workers. Also, the union grievance procedures have been mimicked in many non-union workplaces to provide due process in the workplace. Unions must once again take a stand and defend themselves against the attack. The public must be re-educated as to the benefits and history of unions and the politicians must be exposed for who they really are. Union members must get more involved and familiar with the issues at hand. It is essential for union survival to have the full support and participation of its members. Remember, an honest man deserves an honest wage. EZ PASS Update As many of you are aware, the Port Authority Board of Commissioners voted to eliminate the EZ Pass program for non-represented personnel and retirees. Non-represented personnel were permitted to continue to use their Port Authority EZ Pass accounts for commuting until such time as the Port Authority relocates back to the World Trade Center. Effective January 1, 2011, Port Authority EZ Pass transponders for retirees, including police retirees, were terminated. The PBA has filed two grievances: one on behalf of active members objecting to the Port Authority’s unilateral termination of this contractual benefit and a second on behalf of retirees receiving this benefit. We continue to monitor and review this situation and will keep the membership up to date on developments. The 20Th annual awards luncheon of The federal law enforcemenT foundaTion was held november 12, 2010 at the waldorf astoria in new York city. event speakers were major General danny rothschild reT idf, 35th commandant General John f. amos, usmc. ray Kelly, roger alies ceo fox news, area leaders of the fBi, marshalls, dea, ice, dhs, u.s. secret service, nYfd, nYPd, PaPd and us Postal inspectors. attending from the Port authority were michael fedorko, robert sbarra, anthony whitaker and George albin, as well as assorted inspectors and captains and many PaPBa members. anthony Bergamo, federal law enforcement Foundation Chairman is on the left, and PO Anthony Alfieri is on the right. IndemnIFIcATIon: A SHoRT guIde report PAPBA Page 8 John McAusland General Counsel You took the test. You passed the background check and you were hired. You completed the rigorous training to be a Police Officer. You completed your first patrol, made your first arrest and (hopefully) many more. You are a seasoned Police Officer. Now, out of the blue, someone has served you with a civil summons and complaint or the law department is demanding that you speak with them concerning a lawsuit. You have now passed your final hurdle: you are a defendant in a civil lawsuit! congratulations and welcome to the club! while your career choice has many positive aspects, one of its most frustrating features is that you are a target for unscrupulous attorneys and their clients just for doing your job. The unfortunate fact is that too many PBa members will be sued at some point in their careers by people who have been properly arrested or summonsed. That is the bad news. Now, the good news: you have protection. under the memorandum of agreement, the Port authority must provide you with a legal defense and must pay on your behalf any damages assessed against you for actions that you take in the normal course of your duties as a Police Officer. The legal term for this protection is indemnification. You may find out about a legal claim against you in a variety of ways. You may be personally served with the summons and complaint. You may find out because another Police Officer is named in the lawsuit and that Officer may be served. Finally, you may find out because the Port Authority Law Department seeks to speak to you about the claim. Regardless of how you find out, you should take two steps immediately to protect yourself. first, try to get a copy of the summons and complaint so that you can see what claim is being made against you. second, apply immediately for indemnification. Forms to seek indemnification should be available at each command from the Police desk. Being a defendant in a civil lawsuit is certainly never fun, but it does not need to be the end of the world or your Port authority career. if you follow these simple steps, you will maximize your protection from civil damages: 1. 1. Apply for Indemnification. As soon as you become aware that you are a defendant in a law suit, apply for indemnification immediately. Even if you have not been served or have not yet seen a copy of the lawsuit against you, seek indemnification as soon as possible. 2. contact the PBa. if you are concerned about the allegations of the suit and you want to discuss your conduct or another officer’s conduct in the incident, the best person to communicate with is me. i am an attorney, so our conversation will be privileged from disclosure and i will be able to give you some insight as to the merit of the claims against you. if a claim is made for punitive damages against you, it is very important that you speak with me because the Port authority will not indemnify you against a punitive damage claim. we will need to evaluate the merits of the punitive damage claim to ensure that you are properly represented as to that claim. 3. obtain documentation. from the time you become aware of a claim, go to your records and get every document that you can find about the incident. Your memo book, handwritten memos, arrest reports and other similar documents will help refresh your recollection concerning the incident and will be helpful in your defense. 4. Remember Rule 3. Until you receive written confirmation that you are indemnified, do not speak with the Port authority law department or any person claiming to represent the Port Authority. We have clarified with the Port authority that attorneys for the Port authority should not be communicating with you until a decision is reached on indemnification, but, on occasion, contacts are still made directly to defendant Police Officers. If contact is made directly to you, contact the PBa immediately! 5. Cooperate. Once you are indemnified, cooperate fully with the Port Authority’s defense team. It is your responsibility as an employee of the Port authority to assist in defending claims against you. more importantly, it is in your interest that these claims are dismissed. The best way to assure dismissal is to make sure that the Port Authority’s attorney (who is now your attorney as well) fully understands all of the facts surrounding the incident. To be personally served, you must be handed the summons and complaint by an individual. It is not acceptable for the desk officer to receive it on your behalf or for it to be mailed to your home, neither of those methods constitute proper service on you. If you have not been personally served, be sure to inform the attorney for the Port Authority of that fact. The PBA congratulates all Police Officers on their award s and is honored to call them PBA members. report PAPBA Page 9 The Port authority PBa recognized 21 Port Authority police officers as May 2010 AnthonyAlfieri—PATH ‘Cops of the Month’ during BobbyCitko—JFK VictorTalamini—PATH 2010. Each Officer was June2010 LennyAverhoff—LT presented a ‘cop of the July2010 BrianCassidy—LT August2010 JohnBerardi—PATH PatrickCarrol—PATH Month’ certificate along with a gift of appreciation from the Port authority PBa. it is from these 21 Police Officers that the PBA recognizes one Officer to September2010 PhilErickson,DannyRodriguez, KevinHart&TomRail—GWB October2010 RudyFernandez—SIB November2010 ShaunKehoe—BT DanGalvin—BT JohnBasile—BT December2010 RobertWallace—PATH represent the PBa as its 2010 cop of the Year. The accounts of the January through April recipients appeared in the PBA’s previous newsletter. PAPBA coP oF THe monTH May 2010-December 2010 coP oF THe monTH 2010 report PAPBA PAPBA Page 10 May 2010 Po BoBBy cITko JFK May 2010 Po VIcToR TAlAmInI PATH May 2010 Po AnTHony AlFIeRI PATH MAY 2010 The Board of Trustees is proud to announce the selection of three Police Officers involved in two separate incidents as the PBa may 2010 cops of the month On Saturday, May 15, 2010, at approximately 0100 hours, Itwaru Deo, Jr., was operating a 2005 Volkswagen Passat with two passengers on North Service Road in John F. Kennedy International Airport at a high rate of speed. Deo, it was later learned, was intoxicated with a .132 blood alcohol level. While traveling south on North Service Road, Deo struck a vehicle that was stopped at a red light at the intersection of North Service Road and an entrance ramp to the northbound Van Wyck Expressway. After striking the vehicle, Deo’s vehicle veered left into a tree on the opposite side of the road, striking the tree with such force. Deo’s vehicle was propelled back to the road and flipped over. Both passengers in Deo’s vehicle were killed instantly and Deo fled the scene on foot. Police Officer Bobby citko, JFK Command, arrived on the scene to assist with the carnage. Learning the driver had fled, Citko was able to get a description and immediately began a canvass of the area. A short time later, PO Citko came upon an individual matching the description. He conducted a field interview of the person who stated he had just been carjacked. PO Citko took the individual into custody and returned to the scene. While at the scene, the now suspect stated to Citko that he was driving the vehicle. Citko placed him under arrest. After the initial investigation was completed, Deo was charged with two counts of Vehicular Manslaughter, two counts of Aggravated Vehicular Homicide, Reckless Endangerment 1st, Operating a Motor Vehicle under the Influence of Alcohol and Reckless Driving. On Sunday morning, May 9, 2010, Police Officers Anthony Alfieri and Victor Talamini, PATH command, were in the vicinity of the PATH Station at 14th Street and Sixth Avenue in Manhattan when they were flagged down by a man who reported a robbery-in-progress in a nearby plaza restaurant. The man informed Alfieri and Talamini that the suspect was armed with a handgun. Both Police Officers responded to the location, Alberto’s Pizza, on Sixth Avenue and gained access to the establishment after observing two employees cowering in fear behind the counter. After entry, Alfieri and Talamini were alerted to a third person by the employees who yelled, “That’s the guy.” The Officers ordered the suspect to show his hands and get down on the floor. The suspect ignored the Officers’ commands and, after a tense standoff, shouted, “Fuck you mother fuckers...I’ll kill you”, as he reached under his jacket as if to retrieve a weapon. Police Officer Talamini was able to grab the suspect’s arm as both Officers wrestled the suspect to the ground. After subduing and handcuffing the suspect, Talamini recovered a silver pistol from the suspect’s jacket. An investigation revealed the suspect menaced the employees with the gun after the owner approached the suspect regarding a theft that just occurred in the restaurant. The pistol, unknown to the Officers at the time, was an imitation. The suspect was subsequently charged with Attempted Robbery 2nd, Burglary 2nd, Criminal Use of a Firearm 2nd and Resisting Arrest. coP oF THe monTH 2010 PAPBA JUNE 2010 report PAPBA JUNE 2010 Page 11 A Sunday morning in spring can be a quiet time for police on patrol. Not the case on Sunday, June 13, 2010, when at about 0745 hours, Police Officer lenny averhoff of the Lincoln Tunnel Command heard a loud crash with the Po sound of braking glass. With that sound came motorists who began pointlenny AVeRHoFF ing PO Averhoff to the Mercedes-Benz dealership on West 40th Street. Upon arrival at the dealership, Averhoff observed an abandoned, four-door, gray LT Chevrolet facing eastbound on the westbound street with its engine running and driver’s side door open. PO Averhoff also noticed that one of the large, dealership showroom windows was shattered. Averhoff, who had informed his Command of the situation, was alone on the scene when a female ran toward him from llth Avenue. At the same time, a male walked toward Averhoff from within the showroom. The female, who had the same last name as the man, informed Averhoff that the man was the driver of the vehicle, was driving erratically and was high on drugs. Averhoff, still alone, approached the man and ordered him out of the building. The man continued walking toward Averhoff, but now in a threatening manner, and shouted, “Allah is God, no one can stop me”. The man continued to ignore Averhoff’s orders. Averhoff requested immediate assistance as the man became combative toward Averhoff. Once backup arrived, Averhoff and another Officer, after a violent struggle with the man, were able to take the man into custody. The back-up Officer, as a result of being assaulted by the man, suffered injuries requiring hospitalization. The following day, PO Averhoff followed up with the dealership manager who was able to provide a video of the incident. The video showed the man attempting to enter the premise through locked entrances and then intentionally driving his vehicle into the showroom window to gain access. PO Averhoff’s actions the day of the incident along with his diligent follow up that resulted in further charges, are a credit to both him and this Department. The Port Authority Police Benevolent Association is proud to name Police Officer Lenny Averhoff its June 2010 Cop of the Month. JULY 2010 Po BRIAn cASSIdy LT JULY 2010 On July 15, 2010, at approximately 1805 hours, Police Officer Brian Cassidy was on duty at the Lincoln Tunnel monitoring the evening’s rush hour traffic. The Officer observed a vehicle, occupied by a male and female, with a outdated state inspection sticker. Cassidy performed a motor vehicle stop during which the female operator of the vehicle was unable to produce a driver’s license, vehicle registration or insurance card. PO Cassidy later determined the vehicle operator had a suspended license. PO Cassidy’s attention was also on the male passenger who at first provided Cassidy with false identification. After being questioned a second time about his identity, the man gave Cassidy what turned out to be his true identity. While conducting his investigation, Cassidy detected what he believed to be the odor of fresh marijuana coming from the vehicle. After receiving permission to search the vehicle, PO Cassidy recovered a large amount of marijuana under the driver’s seat and from under a rear passenger seat. Further investigation revealed the marijuana was placed in both locations by the male passenger without the driver’s knowledge. The driver was issued numerous summonses for the motor vehicle violations. PO Cassidy’s investigation also revealed the male had 12 outstanding warrants. It was determined the suspect was wanted by Union City Police as a result of a racing accident two weeks prior. In that incident, which the suspect fled, three people were left injured. One of those was a 15-year-old female passenger in the suspect’s vehicle who suffered head trauma and the loss of a finger. PO Cassidy’s keen observation, professional skills, and tenacity resulted in an important arrest along with the closing of numerous outstanding warrants. His actions are a wonderful example of the good police work conducted each day by members of this Department. The Port Authority Police Benevolent Association is proud to name Police Officer Brian Cassidy the July 2010 Cop of the Month. coP oF THe monTH 2010 report PAPBA PAPBA Page 12 August 2010 Po JoHn BeRARdI PATH AUgUsT 2010 On the evening of August 25, 2010, Police Officers John Berardi and Patrick carroll of the PATH Police Command were on patrol inside Newark Penn Station when they observed an individual jump over a turnstile without paying the fare. The suspect entered a train car where he was apprehended by Berardi and Carroll and removed from the train. Once off the train, the Officers began asking questions regarding the suspect’s identification. The suspect gave conflicting information, such as stating he was 17 years old but supplying a birth date that would make him 18 years old. He was later proved to be 22 years of age. August 2010 Po PATRIck cARRol PATH While continuing their investigation, the suspect was instructed to put the duffel bag he was carrying on the ground. The suspect refused to comply, shoved PO Carroll, and began to run. Both Officers pursued the suspect and continually ordered the suspect to stop. The suspect ran onto the eastbound Track 1 platform and tossed the duffel bag onto the track. Berardi and Carroll continued their pursuit of the suspect who was now attempting to kick through a set of locked, double doors at the end of the platform. PO Carroll was able to grab a hold of the suspect, who violently resisted Carroll’s attempt to control him by assaulting PO Carroll. The suspect continued his attack on Carroll and Berardi as they struggled to physically restrain the suspect. Eventually the suspect was handcuffed and Carroll and Berardi continued their investigation. The suspect denied the duffel bag he threw to the tracks was his and indicated he stole it from a passenger on the train. PO Carroll retrieved the bag from the tracks from which the Officers recovered a handgun, 24 bags of marijuana, 10 bags of cocaine and three vials of cocaine. As a result of being assaulted by the suspect, PO Carroll sustained lacerations on both hands and an injured right knee. The Officers’ keen observation and tenacious pursuit of a felon resulted in removing a handgun, along with a quantity of narcotics, from the streets of Newark while subjecting the Officers to extreme danger. The Port Authority PBA is proud to honor Police Officers John Berardi and Patrick Carroll as the August 2010 Cops of the Month. How to Nominate a PO for Cop of the Month To nominate someone for a future Cop of the Month award, please submit their name(s), command and recount of the incident you are nominating them for. All submissions should be sent to the PAPBA office, or given to your Command Delegate. Those selected as Cops of the Months should show that they went above and beyond the call of duty as a Port Authority Police Officer. coP oF THe monTH 2010 PAPBA report PAPBA Page 13 september 2010 Po PHIl eRIckSon gWB september 2010 Po THomAS RAIl gWB sEPTEMBER 2010 On Wednesday, September 8, 2010, at approximately 1930 hours, Police Officer Kevin Hart, George Washington Bridge Police Command, received a radio call of a possible suicidal person on the westbound lower level of the bridge. PO Hart responded, along with Police Officer Thomas Rail, to the location and observed a male who had made his way over the bridge’s side railing and climbed down the support structure below the lower level catwalk. The Officers were able to make contact with the person, who later was determined to be an emotionally disturbed. While engaging him in conversation, the Officers were successful in persuading the man to climb back up the support structure to the lower level. It was then that the Officers, at great risk to their own safety, were able to rescue the man by pulling him to safety high above the Hudson River. Later in the month, on September 22, Police Officer Phil Erikson, while on patrol at approximately 1310 hours, responded to a report of a man attempting to possibly jump off the George Washington Bridge in the vicinity of the New Jersey towers at the south walkway. Upon arrival, PO Erikson observed Police Officer Daniel Rodriguez talking to the man, who had climbed over the railing and was poised to jump. After distracting the man, both Officers were able to get hold on the man, barging him back over the railing and rescuing him from almost certain death. Both these incidents show the dedication and undeniable courage of Port Authority Police Officers in saving lives. The unselfish actions of these brave Police Officers led the Port Authority Police Benevolent Association to name them the PBA’s September 2010 Cops of the Month. september 2010 Po keVIn HART gWB september 2010 Po dAnny RodRIguez gWB coP oF THe monTH 2010 report PAPBA Page 14 October 2010 Po Rudy FeRnAndez sIB PBA President Paul Nunziato and Police Officer Rudy Fernandez, Staten Island Bridges Command, who was the October 2010 PAPBA Cop of the Month. OCTOBER 2010 The PBA is proud to announce the selection of Police Officer Rudy fernandez of the Staten Island Bridges Command as the October 2010 “Cop of the Month”. In the early morning hours on October 10, 2010, Police Officer Rudy Fernandez finished a midnight tour and was heading home on the Outerbridge Crossing. He came across a motor vehicle accident in which a vehicle, with heavy front end damage, was blocking both New Jersey bound lanes. Fernandez secured his personal vehicle and responded to the accident to render assistance when he was informed by a witness that the operator of the disabled vehicle was currently at the bridge’s superstructure and preparing to jump from the bridge. Fernandez responded to the superstructure and observed an individual who climbed over the bridge railing and was holding on with a meager grasp. Fernandez, who had his portable radio with him, began to coordinate responding PAPD patrol and ESU units along with units from the Perth Amboy Police Department. At the same time, Fernandez was able to start a conversation with the individual, a United States Marine Corp and Iraqi War veteran who was experiencing difficulties as a result of his war service, along with family problems. In addition to all Fernandez was dealing with, he was also able to arrange for family members of the individual to respond to the scene in case their assistance would be helpful. At one point, the individual wanted to speak with his wife. Knowing the individual had an adversarial relationship with her, Fernandez told the individual he would not bring his wife to the scene unless he came over the railing to the roadway. Just as it seemed the individual would comply, he suddenly became agitated when he noticed increased police presence and climbed down to a substructure walkway. This prompted PAPD ESU personnel, with the assistance of Fernandez, to quickly attempt what became a successful rescue. PO Fernandez, using his training, experience and professionalism, was able to bring a dangerous situation to a successful conclusion and save the life of a distraught individual. The PBA congratulates Police Officer Rudy Fernandez on his selection of the October 2010 “Cop of the Month”. November 2010 Po SHAun keHoe BT PAPBA NOvEMBER 2010 The Port Authority PBA Cops of the Month for November 2010 are Po shaun Kehoe, Po dan Galvin and Po John Basile of the Port Authority Bus Terminal Police Command, for their actions on November 12, 2010. At approximately 1107 hours on that day, PO John Basile observed a vehicle commit a motor vehicle violation in the vicinity of Eighth Avenue and 41st Street. Basile directed the operator of the motor vehicle to move the vehicle to the street side and then stop. The motor vehicle operator briefly complied with the order then chose to flee in the vehicle westbound on 41st Street. Basile, along with POs Kehoe and Galvin, pursued the vehicle as it headed toward Ninth Avenue. Before reaching Ninth Avenue, the operator turned left into the New Taxi Roadway where he was stopped by the metal pillars, which prohibit vehicular traffic from 42nd Street. As the three Police Officers entered the New Taxi Roadway, the suspect placed the vehicle in reverse and accelerated to a high rate of speed toward the Police Officers, striking Police Officer Galvin and injuring him. After injuring PO Galvin, the suspect once again, and still in the vehicle, fled on 41st Street. coP oF THe monTH 2010 PAPBA report PAPBA Page 15 November 2010 Po dAn gAlVIn BT POs Kehoe and Basile were again able to stop the vehicle and contain the suspect’s actions from causing additional harm to members of the public. After violently struggling with the Officers, they were able to arrest the individual. It was at that point the Police Officers realized the suspect had a juvenile in the vehicle who was later released to a legal guardian. Further investigation revealed the suspect had a suspended driver’s license in both New York and New Jersey. The Port Authority PBA is proud to honor PO John Basile, PO Dan Galvin and PO Shaun Kehoe as November 2010 Cops of the Month for their efforts to protect the public with total disregard for their own safety. November 2010 Po JoHn BASIle BT DECEMBER 2010 In sports it’s the guy who puts the points on the board who gets the recognition. The same can be said for Police Officer Robert Wallace of the PATH Police Command, who in December, put some pretty impressive numbers up. Among PO Wallace’s activity for the month, four arrests stand out as examples of Wallace’s diligence in performing his duty. Starting on December 2, while PO Wallace was on patrol in Journal Square, Jersey City, he came upon an individual who did not have a legitimate reason to be in a transportation facility. After the individual refused numerous lawful orders to leave the facility, Wallace detained the individual for a routine warrant check. It was revealed the individual had three active warrants; two from the City of Newark and one out of Ewing Township. December 2010 Po RoBeRT WAllAce PATH A few days later on December 5, Wallace stopped a suspect for Theft of Service in Newark Penn Station. After the suspect was arrested, PO Wallace recovered an amount of alleged cocaine from the suspect. PO Wallace was not done with Penn Station when, on December 17, he arrested another suspect for Theft of Service. This time a warrant check turned up an outstanding warrant out of Newark for Bail Jumping. In addition, during a search of the suspect after arrest, Wallace recovered an illegal knife adding the charge of Possession of a Weapon for Unlawful Purposes to the other charges of Theft of Service and Bail Jumping. On December 20, while on patrol, Wallace recognized an individual wanted for a robbery that occurred in the 23rd Street PATH Station the day before. Wallace was able to detain the suspect and have him positively identified in a line-up. The suspect was subsequently charged with Robbery in the First Degree, Assault in the Second Degree and Criminal Possession of a Weapon in the Fourth Degree. As a result of Police Officer Robert Wallace’s outstanding police work and devotion to duty, the Port Authority PBA is proud and honored to recognize him as the December 2010 PBA Cop of the Month. report PAPBA COMMAND REPORTs Page 16 Lincoln Tunnel Command CALENDAR Feb. 24, 2011 General Membership Meeting The Assembly 5:00 p.m. March 24, 2011 General Membership Meeting The Assembly 5:00 p.m. Delegate POs Anthony Giardullo & Paul Pimenta The Lincoln Tunnel Command would like to wish everyone a Happy, Healthy and Safe New Year. We would also like to take this time to thank the PBA for recognizing the Lincoln Tunnel as the Command of the Year. We want to extend a hearty thank you to the Police Officers at the Lincoln Tunnel for their continued dedication to duty that enabled us to achieve this honor. We have a lot of hardworking men and women at the Tunnel and it is great to be recognized for our efforts. We also send out a thank you to Captain Hardy for encouraging the men and women of this Command to go out and do their jobs to the best of their ability. We would like to congratulate PO Cangiarella and his wife and PO Harrington and her husband on the new additions to their families. Also congratulations to PO Zerega and PO Panos on their respective marriages this year. We would also like to send get well wishes and a speedy recovery to all who are out sick or injured. And lastly, a warm welcome to recent transfers to the Lincoln Tunnel, PO Ford and PO Vega. As everyone knows, this was a difficult year for our Command with the loss of PO David Tellado. We would like to thank everyone who went above and beyond to help us through those terrible days, including but not limited to the PBA, Pipes and Drums Honor Guard, Pete Killeen, and all those who assisted in any way. It really meant a lot to the entire Command and to Dave’s family. Please keep Dave’s family in your prayers. sOD COMMAND Delegate POs Brett Porigow, Ray Butler & William Riiska Since our last update, SOD has welcomed back PO Weinberg (K9) and PO Franco (CVI) from injury-related absences. We welcomed some new SOD babies in the past few months: PO Sal Lobrutto (K9) had twins, Giovanni Anthony and Giulianna Elena; PO Kreush (K9) had a baby boy, Jackson Matthew; PO Deprisco (K9) had a baby girl, Angelina Rose; PO Evan Weinberg (K9) had a baby boy, Steven Ian; and PO Cascante (CVI) had a baby boy, Marco Antonio. PO Zappulla get well soon! The rumors are not true, the job is NOT teaching the dogs to drive the patrol cars in an effort to eliminate the Police Officers assigned to the K9 Unit…not yet, anyway. The bosses found out the dogs were too young…and apparently are unionized as well! Who knew? report PAPBA WTC COMMAND Page 17 Delegate PO Angel Serrano Our main objective at the precious World Trade Center site has been to maintain it safely and securely while construction of the remaining towers are built. Therefore, there isn’t much activity due to grounded sectors and various fix patrol posts. Last year I explained how the World Trade Center is one of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey’s most unique commands and how we are currently building six new sky scrapers along with a state-of-the-art transportation hub, and a memorial site. Today I’m expressing to you the difference a year makes! Recently, The Daily News reported that Port Authority Police Officers working at the World Trade Center site will run security at the PATH hub and take part in police operations at the office Towers under terms of a controversial memorandum of understanding reached in 2008 in which the NYPD was given overwhelming control of the 16-acre site. We all hope that we remain here at the World Trade Center no matter who joins us on site! The World Trade Center symbolizes the Port Authority and our Police Department and will forever be our most unique Command. In other news at the World Trade Center, many Officers feel morale is at an alltime low. Morale has become an issue some say due to loads of estrogen, while others say it’s due to diminished testosterone! Most feel it’s a sense of entitlement among many and a lack of maturity among others. Either way you look at this situation, we all need to stop blaming each other and do something for one another! Enough with the _ _ _ s. Just stating the facts! Congrats to Officers Perez, Holder, Harris and Cumminings on their new baby additions to their respected families. God bless them all. Best regards to our former Inspector Sue Durett and Capt. McCalluy. A toast to your retirements! Congrats to Tony “Rib Tips” Brooks on more than 25 years of service! Too late for early retirement, huh? Warm wishes go out to Paul Rodriguez and his family, as he is never to return. We wish you all the best! Class #106 looking forward to another beer garden reunion! Another Officer “JJ” John Johnson or “MM” when he is out with his cohorts has also been told he is never to return due to his “ carrot finger”. Best wishes to you and your family as well. Frank Annunziata, good luck on your return to “JFK”. Let’s stay in touch and catch up sometimes! To Sgt. “Downtown” Brown: wishing you a speedy recovery. Ummm, too late for that, right? Our time keeper Pilar, thank you again for all your hard word and dedication! You’re simply the best. Happy birthday Lt. Gloria Frank. Thank you for all you do. Looking forward to the new 8. Finally, bosses in the words of Rodney King “can’t we all just get along”? sIB Command Delegate PO Al Hamaty report PAPBA Page 18 2010 RETIREEs the following are PaPBa members in good standing who retired since may 2010. PO t. Vitulano HQ may 30, 2010 PO s. Jablow JFK July 10, 2010 det. sgt. J. leather cIB July 10, 2010 PO J. Verdi HQ July 10, 2010 lt. s. chin sIB July 13, 2010 PO a. mccrystal HQ July 24, 2010 PO l. Forte JFK July 30, 2010 Insp. s. durett Wtc sept. 16, 2010 PO N. Kester HQ sept. 26, 2010 PO a. schafer HQ Oct. 22, 2010 I will have to at some point begin to consider retirement from a job I have aspired to do since childhood. I want to take this opportunity to speak to my brothers and sisters in blue about us. We were 40 Bridgemen in June of 1928, the first of The Port Authority Police Department when the Outerbridge Crossing and Goethals Bridge opened in that same month and year. We worked for the first agency in the U.S., created under a provision in the Constitution of the United States, through an agreement between the states of New York and New Jersey. The agency was named The Port of New York Authority, which was created to bring separation from political pressures and corruption and would work in the best interest of the public. We, The Port Authority Policen protect and serve that public in many different ways, at many different Commands today, unlike any other Police Departments, at our Tunnels, Bridges, Airports, Trains, Bus Terminals, Marine TermInals, World Trade Centers and our SOD who provide a more specialized degree of protection to the public. What an impressive group of men and women, who work and did work for The Port Authority Police Department. These are individuals who know they can make a difference in public service. We are assigned to a Command, but we are members of one Police Department and a Union that represents us. Follow the direction of your PBA Executive Board Members, some of which I’ve had the pleasure of working with and your leadership in that Union is an equally impressive group who will continue to guide all of us through these troubled times. Remember, stay safe. EsU COMMAND ESU Delegates ESU would like to wish a warm welcome back to POs Vaivao, McKenna, O’Dea, Whitman, Ross and whoever else we may have missed…nice job guys! A get well soon to POs Taianni, May, Vecchia, Egan and of course, Sinopidis! George, Aflac called and said they can no longer insure you…please call them back when you choose a less risky line of work, like digging in a coal mine! Our sincere condolences to P0 Morelli on the passing of his mother late last year…but also congratulations on his new baby girl! What can we say brother…circle of life. Also a belated congratulations to P0 Costello on the new addition to his family…great luck and health! Truck #5 would like to thank whoever is responsible for sending the Medium Duty over as an early Xmas gift…they’d like to thank you 12 on one in front of 4 Vestry Street, you name the date and time. Chip Michaels, congrats and good luck…to both of you :) Congratulations to newlywed Joe Windisch…even great runs have to come to an end sometimes pal :( Finally, we’d be remiss to fail to acknowledge the many fine and distinguished Chiefs and Inspectors on their recent retirements, but to the men in ESU, there is truly one standout who cannot go unrecognized, our beloved Captain Kevin Feeley. Sir, we can only hope that should you choose a new line of work after the Port Authority, that that employer will show you the same care and concern you’ve shown us during your tenure with SOD. You were a real gem! P.S. — OT tip for 2011…if the current fiscal situation fails to improve, try “accidentally” breaking the toe of the guy next to you…worked for us! Sorry Mark. JFK COMMAND By POs Michael Balestracci, Jordan Esposito, Thomas Koster, Robert Paulson & Peter Candela report PAPBA The state of the JFK Command is dismal at best. The plan put forth by headquarters, and implemented by the JFK Command staff, to curtail police services has been an overwhelming success. Simply put, the services the public expects from its police are not provided by the Port Authority Police Department at JFK Airport. Page 19 2010 RETIREEs For example, The JFK AirTrain still remains an unpoliced railroad. The original patrol plan for the AirTrain called for 20 Port Authority Police Officers spread over each day’s three tours. No one can deny the success of the AirTrain. Thousands of people use the system each day but, none of these people can rely on the PAPD for safe transit because we are nonexistent on the trains, platforms and stations. Now, to give Headquarters some credit, let’s be honest, if a person becomes the victim of a crime but there is no police officer to report it to, did a crime actually occur? And, if a crime is actually reported, through no fault of Headquarters or the JFK Command staff, how does it somehow become a Non-Criminal Incident Report? the following are PaPBa members in good standing who retired since may 2010. Speaking of NCIRs, one thing we can all be proud of is the JFK Command’s lead position regarding the number of Lost Property Reports. Because of the outstanding Command leadership of staying on top of this problem and identifying its underlying root cause, it is now understood that only the world’s most forgetful people use JFK Airport. This social phenomenon, which has always baffled scientists, now has sociologists excited about finally figuring out this tragic social behavior. There is talk of a Group Citation honoring the members of the JFK Command for their hard work in this breakthrough accomplishment. Insp. l. Fields lga dec. 16, 2010 Another amazing leap forward, pioneered by the JFK Command staff, which is being watched closely by police commanders worldwide, is the use of cell phones for dispatching Police Officers. The implementation of this technology in police communications could lead to finally abandoning those bulky, expensive, magic speaking boxes, known in the business as “Portable Radios”, and the elimination of that annoying problem of wondering whether those portable radios will actually work. The brain trust behind this plan will, undoubtedly, be enshrined in the annals of law enforcement on a level equal with Sir Robert Peele. Finally, in an a to lessen the work load of each Police Officer at JFK, the Command staff has been successful in getting other law enforcement agencies to agree to pick up where we fail ajob at the AirTrain/Jamaica Station. Also, the robbery, larceny, hustler problem at the Howard Beach Station appears under control with the exceptional work of the New York City Police Department Transit Bureau. Then, there is the invitation to the Taxi and Limousine Commission to address JFK’s illegal taxi activity. And, of course, where would we be without the Command staff recommendation to the TSA that the TSA should open their own investigations on Port Authority Police Officers who do not subject themselves to the superior authority of TSA screening personnel? Now, that’s backing your cops! So, there you have it. The plan to continue to demoralize and marginalize the JFK cops is well underway and appears to be on the road to success. Coupled with the Department’s demeaning and divisive promotion policy, those in charge, whoever they may be, must be thrilled by how dysfunctional and inconsequential they have made the PAPD. Have a great New Year. cpt. W. mccauley Wtc Nov. 30. 2010 asst. chief c. torres HQ dec. 21, 2010 capt. r. losak PN dec. 24, 2010 dep. chief a. Whitaker HQ dec. 25, 2010 capt. F. desio HQ-QWm dec. 30, 2010 asst. chief g. albin HQ dec. 31, 2010 capt. d. Burns Ht dec. 31, 2010 PO a. Welch HQ dec. 31, 2010 gWB COMMAND Delegate PO Matt McKeon & Brian Ahern report PAPBA Page 20 IN MEMORIAM Our condolences to the family of: PO D. Tellado LT Oct. 24, 2010 Happy new year from the George Washington Bridge. First off a few birth announcements: Congratulations to PO Mary Jarvis, and PO Christian Orscher on the births of their children. We wish you the very best. A big welcome home to Chris Arroyo. Thanks for all you do for us and your country. A good-bye to Scott Benoit, enjoy it brother. Next a big welcome to Lt. Chip Michaels to the midnight tour. You are a breath of fresh air from all the complaining we have had to deal with from a certain boss. To all those out sick or IOD — get well and return soon. We would like to wish Inspector White a farewell. We hope you land somewhere with less headaches and more morale. A big thanks to all of our officers for trying to do more work with less resources. Your work is greatly appreciated. Budget cuts to the F.J.C. security guards make a heavy load even heavier; keep up the great work. Please have a safe and happy new year and remember to back each other up out there. MARINE TERMINAL COMMAND Marine Terminal Delegates Here at the Marine Terminals things have changed for the worse. Our Command was enlarged by picking up a whole new GAOE, which is Port Jersey and Port of Bayonne. Port Jersey encompasses Global Marine terminal BMW and Weeks Marine. Port of Bayonne encompasses Cruise ship line Royal Caribbean, Marine Drydock and many other small businesses and warehouses. Both Terminals encompass many city and state roadways. Like most things in the PAPD, your Command increases in size and your manpower decreases. Before taking over the PJMT and Bayonne Terminal, we turned out four sector cars down here at the NJMT command. Since taking over PJMT, we now turn out three sectors at NJMT. We do turn out two sectors for Port of Bayonne and Port Jersey Terminals. So you can see, they stole one sector from down here at NJMT to have two sectors up in PJMT. Figure it out. When the Marine terminal was much less productive, it turned out three sectors. Now the second largest shipping Port in America is Port Authority and we still turn out only three sectors. Our vehicles are a sight for sore eyes other than the three SUVs we have. We would be better off on two-wheel segways to get around. Our newly transferred Police Officers are still in a trailer in the garage with no bathroom accommodations (more than two years). These Officers weren’t just assigned here out of the Academy. The PAPD knew they were transferring Officers here. These are not rookies, but veteran officers. In closing, all is not bad. We go to work and most of the time we go home in the same safe condition. Thank God. Also we have four newborn additions to our family. PO Gant, a girl; PO Brown, a boy; PO Keown, a boy; and PO Arroyo, a boy. From our Command to every Command, happy New Year. Be safe and back each other up. A special hello to Gus Danese. Stay strong POs Brown and Latimer. PATH COMMAND Delegate PO Jim Higgins Greetings from PATH. Congratulations and good luck to Gus Kapsis and Billy Doyle on their recent retirements; we wish you guys the best. Congratulations to all of those at PATH command who had recent additions to their families. Congratulations and good job to the guys for being honored Cops of the Month this past year: POs P. Carroll, J. Berardi, V. Talamini, A. Alfieri, and B. Wallace. Welcome aboard PO Sorace and PO Dillardo to the PATH Command. Congratulations to all of those who passed the Sergeant’s exam. Congratulations and good luck to Lt. Kelley Hennessy and Chief Walcott on their recent promotions. BUs TERMINAL COMMAND Delegate POs Marcus Ciserano & Robert Zafonte Happy New Year fellow members! The Bus Terminal would like to applaud PO Plunkett who has safely returned home from fighting overseas for our Country. We cannot thank you enough for your bravery and dedication. We would also like to acknowledge the following members who have received the PAPBA’s “Top Cop of the Month” awards — POs Kemble, Reilly, Galvin, Kehoe and Basile. Thank you for making the BT proud. As we begin 2011, there is no question that the future of our job is about to be challenged. State politicians continue to propose more cuts and continue to come after labor unions. Our pensions, salaries and benefits are all under attack! Last year Camden, Newark and Atlantic City all experienced police layoffs. Is New York next? In the last three years, we have watched the bean counters do their best to dismantle our Department. Our motorcycle unit has been disbanded, aviation unit’s helicopter has been sold, and our patrol boats are left idle at our airports. The idea to do more with less has become the Port Authority’s motto, leaving facilities like the Bus Terminal more vulnerable to a terrorist attack. Where is the pride? Sometimes many of us find it hard to remember why we joined this Department. We have a promotion system that is corrupt to the core and has become nothing more than a water cooler joke. Supervisors have been guided foolishly to keep police activity down in order for them to continue earning record breaking salaries. They have become blinded by the Port’s “BS” to do more with less and keep the cops’ salaries inline, even if it means selling out the integrity of this Department and compromising public safety. So, what do we do? Stick together! Become more involved with your Union and do your job! I have noticed in the last few years that people are forgetting what it is to be in a union. I see cops more worried about being in good graces with Supervisors. Some have lost their way and have become more concerned with chasing the “carrot” then sticking together. Wake up and support your union! Let’s work together, protect our job security, and ensure that we make the Port Authority Police the world’s best police job. It’s time we become proud again. report PAPBA Page 21 HOLLAND TUNNEL COMMAND Holland Tunnel Delegates report PAPBA Page 22 The Holland Tunnel Command is one of the smallest commands in size but not in activity. We have 57 Police Officers assigned to the facility, over half of which have less than three years on the job. We normally produce activity that ranges within the top three commands in regard to summonses issued. Also, we usually produce anywhere between 300-500 arrests per year, which is a lot considering the small number of Police Officers assigned to the Command. In regard to arrests, we would like to acknowledge P0 Fernando Garcia with getting ANOTHER gun collar that involved two active “Bloods” members, as well as POs Sepelya and Narvaez for seizing more than four pounds of marijuana while conducting a routine car stop. Congratulations to PO O’Neill on the birth of his daughter, and condolences to PO Konopada and PO Hassel who experienced deaths in the family. We welcome back Officers Cuprill, Perrotta and Matias from IOD, and wish Officers Dunphy, Cardoza and Berraud a speedy recovery from their injuries. Congratulations to all the Police Officers who passed the recent Sergeant’s exam, especially PO Fernando Garcia who scored a perfect 100. Remember, strength in numbers! Support your PBA, support your delegates, and stay safe out there. LgACOMMAND Delegate PO Marciano Shay 2010 was an eventful year for all of us. We said farewell to Commanding Officer Inspector Larry Fields, Staff Lieutenant Emilio Sepluveda and Sgt. Thomas Hoey who between them had more than 100 years of Port Authority experience (you can add another 30 plus years if you include Inspector Fields’ alter egos “Sid” and “Viscious”). The three of them never hesitated to tell you “how the job used to be” or the “back when I was a cop” story. Each of them brought something to the Police Command that can never be replaced. Whether it was mountainous piles of paper on “Sepi’s” desk or Sgt. Hoey racking up thousands of hours on working overtime at EVERY Command and saying, “Hey, I’m only working so other Sergeants don’t get forced”, yeah that was believable. Each of them are missed and we wish them a happy retirement. We also had the pleasure of moving into a $40 million plus police building nicknamed the “Inspector Honig Memorial Building” by Police Superintendent Fedorko (because Honig spent about three years helping the architect “design” the building but never actually had the pleasure of sitting in the new Commanding Officer’s office, with custom leather chair, cherry wood desk, large windows overlooking the new LaGuardia tower and the runways due to his transfer. The Command boasts four large cells in the arrest room, state-of-the-art cameras, conditioning room, 10 bays for emergency vehicles, and numerous other amenities. We can only hope 2011 treats us just as well. FROM JFK COMMAND CHECK YOUR sTATUs report PAPBA Page 23 How many times have you said, “OK, I will facebook you tonight to see what’s going on.” When did the word “Facebook” become a verb It seems like overnight! Two years ago, many people hadn’t even heard of the Facebook Social Networking site ... and now everyone and their grandmother seems to be on it. Yes, it is fun to catch up with old friends, old flames and distant cousins ... but what impact does this have on our jobs as Police Officers? The message here is “BE CAREFUL WHAT YOU POST ON YOUR STATUS.” Why? Because what you post on there or on any social networking site is not only a representation of your own personal name but as a representation of the entire Port Authority Police Department. This will affect the company you work for and the fellow Officers who depend on you. You may feel a FALSE sense of anonymity while venting your frustrations with your job or employer, but I assure you that your colleagues and supervisors are watching ... and reading. A good rule of thumb is: If you wouldn’t say it at roll call or to someone’s face, then don’t post it on Facebook. Also, keep in mind that when something is posted, texted, e-mailed, tweeted or blogged anywhere on the world wide web or to a friend, it could be quoted, indexed and virally spread without your permission because it is posted on a public forum. So, if you want to vent your feelings over the misgivings of supervisors, fellow officers or even the public, please choose your forum cautiously. The best way would be in person, to a friend or over coffee. Protect yourself and protect our jobs. There are social networking laws and employee policies that are being penned all over the country, especially in major corporations. We all must remember that there could be ramifications for posting ill-willed comments on such public forums as Facebook. The law holds that disciplinary actions can be taken by an employer if an employee uses a public domain to destroy the employer’s business or cause disharmonious working between colleagues and employers. The bottom line is, if you post something that could damage the “good will” of the company you work for, you can be in a lot of trouble, both civil and legal. If you have kids or have read the newspapers lately, you know that Facebook is a playground for the most unlikely bullies, as well. Unfortunately, adults are not immune to cowardly bullies. Some victims have even committed suicide over irresponsible postings by others on Facebook. The issue is THAT serious and, in this case, words CAN hurt someone. So, be careful what you post about people, as well. And, of course, be careful what you post about your personal life. Many supervisors, employers and even college recruiters now check the social networking sites as part of their routine interviewing process for potential candidates. This could indeed affect your future in regards to promotions, future employment or even your acceptance into higher education institutions. BE SMART. Remember that what you post on social networking sites not only reflects on you but on your fellow Officers and the Port Authority Police Department. Do not undermine the company you work for or belittle your fellow Officers with flippant and negative comments about the serious job we do every day. Many of us take our job extremely seriously and are proud of what we do. We are in contact with thousands of members of the traveling public each day and we work hard to maintain a level of professionalism that is necessary for us to command respect and cooperation from that public. To be cut off at the knees by a casual, yet vile “status” posted by a Police Officer venting about a stressful day at work is not only irresponsible, but it could be criminal. If you have something to say, say it directly to the person or vent your feelings directly to a trusted friend or PBA delegate. Don’t post it on a public domain for everyone and their grandmother to see. When it comes to social networking, think like the Police Officer you are and should be. One that is responsible, respectful and proud of the job you have sworn to do. “BE CAREFUL WHAT YOU POST ON YOUR STATUS.” Why? Because what you post on there or on any social networking site is not only a representation of your own personal name but as a representation of the entire Port Authority Police Department. PATH WINs THIRD TITLE report PAPBA Page 24 SlIdIng PAST neWARk 4-3 in seventh TouRnAmenT FlIeS HIgH FoR 9 yeARS Staten Island, NY: Once again in early September we gathered to remember the great loss to our Department from the September 11 attacks. Before we start the tournament, we pause in a 37 seconds moment of silence and the playing of our National Anthem. We stand almost 200 strong, year after year to show our respect and to bond in our national past time. It was nice for a change not have to worry about the weather. It seems almost every year I am following the path of a hurricane or tropical storm, but as fate would have it, we had a beautiful day for softball. So the teams came piling in with pretty much the same complaints as always. Who picked out these colors for the T shirts? I didn’t know they still made puke green. Matt McKeon saying “Great job with the scheduling, why don’t you just give us the best two teams to play every year?”Angel Serrano telling me “I don’t have a very good team this year,” and five guys on his team are waiting for the next MLB draft! And of course “The umpires are blind”, “The bathrooms are dirty”, “Can’t you get me comp time” and the universal call to excellence “You suck”. With all that said, I love this game! The timing of this tournament is always played within a week of September 11 because dates are important and we all experience a time of anguish in this period. I believe this tournament helps us get through this time while also showing a commitment to our lost heroes. It also establishes a tradition amongst us, and it’s a tradition that defines the heart and soul of a group or a nation. Speaking of timing, our tournament was also in the midst of the Mosque/Cultural Center controversy. Therefore, we simply stated our case on the back of our T-shirts “Move the Mosque, it’s just not right”. So in our great country, we will continue this discussion on the pros and the cons of building this Mosque, but I can only say,” I don’t hate, I’m just not ready yet” So the tournament went on, and here we are, swinging bats, throwing balls and eating dogs (frankfurters, not to alarm PETA people), the PBA set up shop and Vinny Zapulla was strong arming people to buy PBA stuff, he was wearing a long trench coat and talking out the side of his mouth, he scared a couple of kid spectators, and attracted a few New Jersey housewives, but no arrests were made at the end of the day. The day went on with few problems and many laughs; we were like a bunch of kids at the playground. What is it about this game that takes hardened guys and gals of the street and turns them into children again? I do not know but its fun to play and just as much fun to watch. In the next section, the results of each team after three games, the top eight teams with the best record and lowest runs against and highest runs scored, advanced to the elimination rounds. report PAPBA PO Lou DeFelice Page 16 TEAM WON LOST RuNS AgAiNST RuNS ScOREd Path A 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 3 7 7 10 11 14 26 21 27 20 30 35 41 42 45 28 38 43 44 22 31 31 46 26 16 42 17 19 39 21 31 24 28 23 14 28 18 16 WTC LGA LT A NIA A SIB NIA D GWB Path C DET HT A Path B JFK NIA E NIA B LT B PN BT NIA C Elimination Round-Quarter Finals Path A defeats GWB — 6-5 WTC defeats NIA D — 11-10 SIB defeats LGA — 10-8 NIA A defeats LTA — 15-8 Elimination Round-Semi Finals Path A defeats SIB — 8-4 NIA A defeats WTC — 12-1 CHAMPIONSHIP GAME — PATH A defeats NIA A 4-3 The championship game went seven innings, as NIA A was leading going into the bottom of the seventh, but Path A got a huge clutch hit, and won the game. This is Path’s third championship trophy since the inception of this tournament; the Holland Tunnel is the only other team to accomplish this. Thank you to all 19 teams that participated this year, it was an incredible turnout! Thank you to Superintendent Michael Fedorko for attending the tournament and supporting the troops. Thank you to our PBA, SBA, DEA and LBA for the financial and moral support. Thank you to Lisa Kurdyla and Jeff Freifeld for the excellent photography. The proceeds from this tournament partially went to the family of deceased brother Officer Dave Tellado of the Lincoln Tunnel. The remainder of the proceeds will be used to enhance the development of a new website www. 37heroes.org, which is in progress and will provide future information about the tournament, tournament-scheduling, directions to the field, a PayPal section to accept donations from outside sources, and updates on the use of any funds received. This also includes costs to register with the IRS as a section 503c not for profit corporation. Finally yet importantly, since we are nearing the 10th year since that terrible September morning, I thought it would be special if we invited a team from Shanksville Pa. (UA Flight 93), a team from the Pentagon, a team from NYPD and a team from NYFD. Jerome Crimi will be assisting me on making these contacts. If anyone would like to give me any input on this upcoming tournament, please email me at louied1@juno.com or you can look me up on PA Outlook. report PAPBA Page 26 POLICE OFFICER DAN sTEFFENs RAN ACROss THE UsA LAsT sUMMER So, what did you do on your summer vacation? Dan was a member of a 9/11, first-responder, fundraising effort called the “Tour of Duty Run”. This 4,600 mile, 31-day run that traveled through 20 states would be quite a journey for anyone, but for Dan it was actually the culmination of a journey that began almost nine years earlier. Dan’s journey goes back to September 11, 2001, when he was working for Bear Stearns, the investment banking giant. At the same time Dan was a soldier in the New York Army National Guard. He earned a commission as a Second Lieutenant after completing the U.S. Army’s Reserve Officer Training Corp program at Loyola University in Maryland in 1997. On that day, Dan had to change from his business suit to his Army uniform as a result of the attack on America. Dan left his office and, because there was no public transportation, walked to the Armory on 68th Street and Park Avenue and began a mobilization that would see him and his unit deployed to the World Trade Center to assist with the rescue and recovery efforts. While at the World Trade Center, Dan saw firsthand the death and destruction caused by America’s enemies. And, like many New Yorkers, Dan lost some friends that day. After his mobilization, Dan returned to Bear Stearns to continue his investment banking career but, he was left with the feeling he needed to do more for others and for himself. His brother Pat, a New York City Police Officer and currently a Lieutenant in the 75th Precinct, served as an influence on Dan’s thoughts of considering public service. Because of his brother and, along with his military experience, the thought of becoming a Police Officer was not all that foreign to him. In 2002, Dan took the Port Authority Police Department entrance examination. He was not notified to begin processing for the PAPD until 2008, but, the time in between was anything but uneventful. ABOUT OUR MEMBERs report PAPBA Dan’s banking career was progressing well and included a promotion to vice president but, another military mobilization loomed ahead for him. This time Dan, now a U.S. Army Captain, was going to war. He received orders for a deployment to Iraq with the famed “Harlem Hellfighters,” a legendary United States Army unit. Page 27 Dan’s deployment began on December 7, 2003, Pearl Harbor Day, a day that shares a unique, historical importance with September 11, 2001. He returned from the war in February 2005 and after his long deployment, once again returned to Bear Stearns and his banking career. Three years after fighting a war, Dan received an appointment to the Port Authority Police Academy. Many things changed in the five years since he took the test and now had a major decision to make. Dan decided to become a Police Officer. Of that decision, Dan said, “God was looking out for me the day I decided because the day after I left Bear, its stock tumbled dramatically. Over the weekend Bear ceased to exist and that Monday, St. Patrick’s Day, was my first day in the Police Academy”. Dan graduated from the Police Academy and was assigned to the JFK Police Command before being transferred to the PABT Police Command. Eventually Dan transferred to the World Trade Center Police Command, where he is a member today. It is as if Dan was destined to be assigned to the WTC Command. “I feel very fortunate to be a Port Authority Policeman,” he said recently while speaking about the Tour of Duty Run. He went on to say, “I feel an additional sense of duty to make sure those 37 PAPD officers who died that day are properly remembered.” Dan became aware of the run from a high school friend with whom he coached rugby. His friend’s father and two brothers were members of the New York City Fire Department. The idea of taking on such a challenge appealed to Dan. And Brett Porigow with Nero September 10, 2010 South Queens Boys and Girls Club Photographer: Kara Eusebio so, on August 12, 2010, at 0846 hours, the Tour of Duty Run stepped off at the Santa Monica Pier in Los Angeles starting the 4,600 mile odyssey, which can be called the ‘Beginning to the End of Dan’s Amazing Journey’. The Tour of Duty Run was organized by the Australian Fire Brigade that has performed long, fundraising events in the past. The run was also representative of the long history of the United States and Australia coming to the aid of each other. To honor that cherished alliance, the Run was completed by both Americans and Australians. Thirty-two runners insured that there was a runner on the road every hour of every day for 31 days. In a letter Dan wrote to explain the Tour of Duty Run he stated, “Each dawn of the Run will be dedicated to the individuals whose lives were tragically taken in their tour of duty. We run to remember their honor and sacrifice, respect their courage and appreciate their commitment to service and devotion to duty”. Well said Dan and, well done! CHANGE OF ADDRESS? Call the Union to update your records 201-871-2100 PAPBA Report port First Class Prsrt Mail US Postage PAID Albany, NY Permit #370 Port Authority Police Benevolent Association, Inc. 611 Palisade Avenue Englewood Cliffs, NJ 07632 THe neW clASS WAR Same As The old clASS WAR There is a class war brewing between the haves and the havenots. according to a recent column in the new York Times, the “haves” are public-sector employees who enjoy “cadillac pensions” and the “have-nots” are those in the private sector who don’t. In recent months, right-wing think tanks and elected officials have been beating the drum that the decent wages and benefits that public employees enjoy are the cause of our economic woes. News sources frequently cite accounts of those scamming the system by earning two pensions or skirting overtime rules. The perception is that most public employees retire with $100,000 pensions, when the truth is the average pension is $33,000. With a 10-percent unemployment rate and a desperate workforce who have seen dwindling wages and benefits, one would think that public anger would be directed at those that caused this mess to begin with. But, in an expert sleight of hand, Wall Street executives are enjoying millions in bonuses, while we are being asked to direct our anger at the “greedy” sanitation workers and cops. Public employees have become a convenient scapegoat to those who would rather distract from the fact that corporations are enjoying record profits yet are not creating any new jobs. Attacks on labor are nothing new, however: with anxiety about the recession, it is easier than ever to direct anger against those who have struggled to maintain some semblance of middle-class life—all at the “taxpayer’s expense.” Americans are suffering “pension envy.” This is not to dismiss the challenges that states face as they struggle to meet financial obligations in light of stark budget shortfalls. In New York, government pension contributions have sharply risen, and alarmists warn the system will soon go bankrupt unless we trim benefits. The truth is, of course, New York’s pension system is solvent and fully funded. While it’s true that contributions have risen, it is because, for years, city and state governments relied on high-performing pension funds to pay for their share of contributions. In fact, in 2000, New York’s share dropped to zero. Public employees, however, continued to pay into the system. The greed which led to the collapse of Wall Street also led to the diminution of those investment returns, thus forcing higher government funding. This is not the fault of public employees. The reality is, good pensions and retirement security are good for the economy. The vast majority of public-sector retirees remain in New York. They pay taxes, buy products and support local businesses. Ultimately, however, this is not about pensions, it is about a concerted effort to pit working families against one another. After all, when corporations are wringing as much productivity as possible from their workforce while slashing pay and benefits, public-sector workers with decent wages and retirement security are a glaring example of what is possible when workers organize. There is indeed a war going on, but the real war is against the middle class. Rather than envying public-sector benefits, we should be demanding the same for the entire workforce. By Sen. Diane Savino (Democraic Senator representing parts of Brooklyn and Staten Island. Chair of the Senate Civil Service Committee)