MRS Submissions (Volume 1 of 6) - Part A

Transcription

April 2016
Metropolitan Region
Scheme Amendment
1210/41
Rationalisation of Stirling
Highway Reservation
Submissions 1 – 100
Volume 1 of 6
City of Fremantle, City of Nedlands,
Town of Claremont, Town of Cottesloe,
Town of Mosman Park and the Shire of
Peppermint Grove
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Amendment 1210/41
Rationalisation of Stirling Highway Reservation
Submissions 1 - 100
Volume 1 of 6
City of Fremantle, City of Nedlands,
Town of Claremont, Town of Cottesloe,
Town of Mosman Park and the
Shire of Peppermint Grove
April 2016
Disclaimer
This document has been published by the Western Australian Planning Commission.
Any representation, statement, opinion or advice expressed or implied in this
publication is made in good faith and on the basis that the government, its employees
and agents are not liable for any damage or loss whatsoever which may occur as a
result of action taken or not taken, as the case may be, in respect of any
representation, statement, opinion or advice referred to herein. Professional advice
should be obtained before applying the information contained in this document to
particular circumstances.
© State of Western Australia
Internet: www.wa.gov.au
Published by the
Western Australian Planning Commission,
140 William Street,
Perth WA 6000
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
MRS Amendment 1210/41 - Submissions 1 – 100 Volume 1 of 6
File 809-2-1-91 Pt 2
Published April 2016
Internet:
Email:
Phone:
Fax:
National
Infoline:
www.planning.wa.gov.au
corporate@planning.wa.gov.au
(08) 655 19000
(08) 655 19001
Relay Service: 13 36 77
1800 626 477
This document is available in alternative
formats on application to Communications Services.
Introduction to Metropolitan Region Scheme major amendments
The Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC) is responsible for keeping the
Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) under review and initiating changes where they are
seen as necessary.
The MRS sets out the broad pattern of land use for the whole Perth metropolitan region. The
MRS is constantly under review to best reflect regional planning and development needs.
A proposal to change land use reservations and zones in the MRS is regulated by the
Planning and Development Act 2005. That legislation provides for public submissions to be
made on proposed amendments.
For a substantial amendment, often referred to as a major amendment (made under section
41 of the Act), the WAPC considers all the submissions lodged, and publishes its
recommendations in a report on submissions. This report is presented to the Minister for
Planning and to the Governor for approval. Both Houses of Parliament must then scrutinise
the amendment before it can take legal effect.
In the process of making a substantial amendment to the MRS, information is published as a
public record under the following titles:
Amendment report
This document is available from the start of the public advertising period of the proposed
amendment. It sets out the purpose and scope of the proposal, explains why the
amendment is considered necessary, and informs people how they can comment through
the submission process.
Environmental review report
The Environmental Protection Authority must consider the environmental impact of an
amendment to the MRS before it can be advertised. Should it require formal assessment, an
environmental review is undertaken and made available for information and comment at the
same time as the amendment report.
Report on submissions
The planning rationale, determination of submissions and the recommendations of the
WAPC for final approval of the amendment, with or without modification, is documented in
this report.
Submissions
This document contains a reproduction of all written submissions received by the WAPC on
the proposed amendment.
Transcript of hearings
A person who has made a written submission may also choose to appear before a hearings
committee to express their views. The hearings proceedings are recorded and transcribed,
and the transcripts of all hearings are reproduced in this volume.
Alphabetical Listing of Submissions
MRS Amendment 1210/41
Submission
Number
48
137
308
309
128
189
447
446
398
120
355
337
44
138
587
184
365
145
433
175
30
132
468
119
440
441
17
228
419
211
385
32
124
47
576
75
63
62
165
13
282
Submitter Name
Abzalov, Aygul
Albrecht, Marina
Aldrovandi, Jill
Aldrovandi, Riccardo
Allan, Ken & Dot
Allan, Sarah
Allerding and Associates (act on behalf of landowners Harman Nominees
Pty Ltd)
Allerding and Associates (act on behalf of landowners Two Twenty
Investments Pty Ltd & Dion Nominees Pty Ltd)
Anglican Church, Diocese of Perth
Annear O.A.M., Anne
Armstrong, Patrick H
Art Deco Society of WA (Vyonne Geneve)
Artelaris, Spiro & Penelope
Artelaris, Steve (Steve Artelaris Architects)
Ashford, Max
Asphar, Florence E
Asphar, Ian
Auer, John
Australian Urban Design Research Centre
Auto Management Pty Ltd
Backhouse, Lisa M
Bagshaw, Anthony & Ann
Bailey, Carolyn
Bailey, Mark
Balfe, Michael
Banfield, Tim & Gemma
Barker, David
Barron, Steve
Barrymore, Geoffrey
Bartel, Matt
Basson, E J & R M
Beamish, Marjorie (Flamenco Holdings Pty Ltd)
Bellson Pty Ltd ATF Brady Property Trust
Bennett, Pamela
Bennett, Pia
Bennett, Samuel
Bentley, Marjorie R
Berden, Matthew
Bishop, Luke
Blackburne Property Group (on behalf of The Owners of St Quentins
Apartments)
Blackwell & Associates Pty Ltd (Tony Blackwell)
470
416
459
294
114
361
92
190
520
50
195
202
384
68
109
484
59
399
323
201
327
31
270
322
580
329
91
378
219
430
49
390
163
452
45
522
262
429
523
12
153
155
453
574
110
310
223
77
180
103
203
Blackwell, Emmet
Blackwood, Beth (on hehalf of the Presbyterians Ladies' College)
Blair, Alison
Blanchard, Serverine (Co-Manager of Allegro Pizza)
Blight, Nicole
Blumann, Siobhan
Boehm, Peggy R
Bogue, Kevin & Marion
Bond, I L
Bowra & O'Dea - Funeral Directors
Boyd, A G
Boyd, L
Boyland, Father Peter (Parish Priest, Anglican Parish of Christ Church
Claremont)
Boyle, Peter & Celia
Boyle, Rafeena
Brake, Anne
Bremner, Mark
Brescacin, Danny (on behalf of his parents)
Brooker, Jacinta
Brooks, Y
Brown, Carolyn
Brown, Russell & Sally (Belregis Pty Ltd)
Brown, Sherri
Bruns, Maurits
Burns, William
Burrows, Amanda
Butcher, Luke
Butler, David & White, Justine
Calcutt, Julie
Cant, Ryan
Cardno (WA) Pty Ltd (on behalf of BP Australia Ltd)
Carles MLA, Adele (Member of Fremantle)
Carr, Emma
Carter, Jacqui
Carton, Romilly
Caslleden Family
Catelli, Anna & Maria
Challen, Michael B
Charlecraft, Henry
Charlesworth, Kate
Chartres, Margot (owner Violet Pilot)
Cheffers, Freya (owner Violet Pilot)
Cheffins, Jane & Pete
Cheffins, Peter
Cheung, Carol
Christy, Julie-Anne
Churack, Danielle
Churley, Julie
Clancy, Robyn L
Claremont Baptist Church (Ian Simms)
Claremont, Town of
95 Clark, Donald (on behalf of the Landowners of Seaview Lane Strata Lot
52/100 Stirling Hwy, North Fremantle)
579 Clune, Anna
212 Cmielewski, Cecelia
581 Cock, Daniel
369 Connor, Tony
100 Cook, Bruce
568 Cooper, Katey
284 Cooper, S P & G R
273 Cotton, Sandra J
577 Courtney, Liam
341 Cowell, Wendy
89 Craig, Daniel
391 Cranfield, Richard L J
332 Cromag Pty Ltd
498 Cropley, Cecily
491 Cropley, Peter
386 Croudace, Michael
387 Croudace, Susan
487 Crugnale, Gianpaolo (Gage Roads Construction)
415 Cullity, Dr Marguerite
93 Cunningham, Lesley
111 Cunningham, Tom & Bryant, Peri
115 Currie, Rachel
121 Curtis, Jackie
280 Dagg, Alan & Jennifer
72 D'Angelo, Marissa
388 D'arcy, John L
346 Date, Russel
141 Davidson, David K
232 Davidson, Ron & Dianne
6 Davies, Denise
3 Davies, Xian-Li
253 Davis, Christopher
382 Davis, Dr Neville J
252 Davis, Mary
373 Daw, Ian T
396 Daw, Trevor A (Chairman of the Forrest Grove Villas Body Corporate on
behalf of the Forrest Villa owners)
420 Day, Brenna
485 Day, Robert
191 D'Cress, Brian G
288 de Caux, Christian
104 Dean, Allan & William
28 Deejay Nominees Pty Ltd (Durack & Zilko Lawyers on behalf of)
272 Deighan, Dorothy H
566 Demissie, Bayoush
331 Department of Transport, Main Roads WA & Public Transport Authority
286 Desforges, Jonah & Danielle
519 D'Esterre Family
81 Dobra, Wendy & Max
277 Dodd, Marilyn
423 Donovan, Kim S & Payne, Carl D (Twine Court Pty Ltd)
55
237
254
313
139
394
358
436
502
255
267
23
474
207
351
178
583
210
431
181
596
489
243
4
135
136
345
404
87
257
438
244
98
19
8
84
307
242
336
25
595
269
206
584
401
353
479
35
226
570
214
506
Douglass, Tony (on behalf of Empire City Superannuation Fund)
Drayton, Roslyn
Dreyfus, Michele
D'Souza, Father James (Parish Priest Cottesloe/Mosman Park)
Dutry, Danicia
Dwyer, Bryan & Nyree
Eastwood, David
Eidsvold. Jaimie
Eldon, Lisa
Eldred, Sara
Elsey, Richard
Elton, Sophie
Evans, Glenn
Farnsworth, Kate
Faye, Bridget
Fearis, Neil
Ferguson-Thomas, Susan
Ferrari, Robert
Ferrell, Margaret
Ferrell, Walter J
Findlater, Kate & Brendon
Finn, Kirsty
Fiocco, Suzanne & John
Fire & Emergency Services Authority of WA
Flack, Ian
Flack, Jacqueline
Fleming, Hamish
Fletcher, Paul F
Flynn, Amber
Forarty, Cain
Ford, Patrick
Forma, Ann
Forrest, David & Nedela, Janis
Freind Investments Pty Ltd (Clayton Friend, Director on behalf of)
Fremantle Ports
Fremantle, City of
Galan-Dwyer, Bianca
Gamblin, Paul
Gardiner, Leigh
Gare, Robert C & Kathleen L
Gay, Marlene M
Gerard McCann Architect (on behalf of the owners Lot 51 Stirling Hwy,
North Fremantle)
Gilchrist, Sylvia
Glass, Stuart
Glassby, Cathie
Glegg, Trevor
Godden, Alison & Andrew
Godlonton, Heath Sanderson & Sasha
Goodlich, Mary-Ann
Goodridge, Phillipa
Goodwin, Clare
Grant, Barbara
505
260
261
558
559
389
427
445
458
82
67
43
409
76
9
362
54
408
134
186
162
172
371
71
333
412
301
421
381
350
147
340
483
572
74
511
503
57
276
357
10
321
379
196
197
342
225
20
64
Grant, Randall
Green, David
Green, Janet
Green, Russell
Green, Shirley
Greenway, Claire
Greg Rowe and Associates (act on behalf of owners Ortona P/L & Don
Russell Holdings)
Greg Rowe and Associates (act on behalf of owners Yat-Wing Liu &
Precious Holdings Pty Ltd)
Griffin, Scot & Clare
Groves, Norman John
Hall, John D & Penuel K
Hall, Lorraine & Geoff
Hamersley, Vicki & Simon (property held in the name of LF Rural Nominees
Pty Ltd)
Hammond, L
Hams, Simon D D
Harper-Meredith, Karri
Harriott, John F
Harris, Daphne
Harvey, Clare
Hasluck, Sally A
Hatton, Damien
Hawkes, E
Hay, Cameron
Hayes, Bruce
Heagney, Karen
Health, Department of
Heard, Kent
Herbert, Serina
Hewitt, Maxwell E (on behalf of the North Fremantle Community
Association)
Hill, Richard & Schell, Fleur
Hills, Lisa J
Hills, Neville F
History Council of Western Australia (Dr Lise Summers, president)
Hopkins, Alexandra
Hopkins, Philip & Mary
Hos, Joanna
Hoskings, Janet
Hotchkin Hanly Lawyers (on behalf of Euro Form Constructions Pty Ltd)
House, Kate
Howe, Jim
Howe, Peter M
Howieson, Jill
Hume, B
Hunter, J M
Hunter, W
Hutchison, June
Hyndman, Trish
Imani, Dr Pedram
Independent Cinemas Pty Ltd
11
113
1
463
131
377
39
241
300
235
231
424
289
383
518
216
338
170
393
352
108
168
274
204
205
125
209
158
221
493
591
339
588
169
348
349
293
188
33
215
375
14
466
271
83
46
496
38
599
586
578
302
Indigenous Affairs, Department of
Ioppolo, Gary
Ioppolo, James
Jackson, Andrew (on behalf of all owners of Greenough Home Units)
Jeffree, Marjorie G V
Jelovsek, Francesco
Jeta Pty Ltd
Johnson, Jill
Johnson, Josephine
Johnstone, Graeme
Johnstone, Klara
Jones, Alex
Jones, Bryn
Jones, Peter F
Jordan, Ray
Joyce, Fletcher J
Kaesehagen, David
Kain, Anthony
Keely, Dr Nicholas
Keen, Michelle
Kelly, Simon
Kennedy, Dorothy
Kenny, Judith
Kent, Jack
Kent, Louis
Kidd, Paul
King, Natasha
Kleinig, Richard
Knutson, Barry
Kohan, Kimberley
Kotsoglo, Imogen
Kowald, Brian
Kruit, Michael
La Fontaine, Monique
Lane, Glendon
Lane, Jennifer
Lane, Richard
Langmead, Rex A (representing Langmead Investments P/L in trust for the
Langmead Familty Trust)
Leach, Jeffery & Helen
Leah, Ann
Leahy-Kane, Jane
Lee, Shirley C L
Leighton, Chris
Leondro Mika
Leslie, Benjamin & Oliver, Nicole
Lim, Tanya Fong
Line, Wendy
Ling, Kendrick
Litis, Desi
Llewellin, Michael
Loe, Louise
Lopresti, Frank (on behalf of the owners of 176 Stirling Hwy, Nedlands)
482
27
562
126
367
557
60
258
85
291
504
151
112
299
359
356
585
217
573
246
142
65
171
368
130
249
179
592
571
575
594
473
461
230
229
354
56
501
517
192
563
316
315
24
140
450
360
53
303
41
500
70
Lorenz, Anita
Lund, Wayne
Lushey, Robert A
Lyndon, Angie
Lyons, Christopher
Lyons, Emma
MacDougall, Sonya Lee
MacGill, Gerard (on behalf of the North Fremantle Community Association)
MacGowan, John & Charmaine
MacKay, Sharon
MacKie, Maggie
MacLeay, Shayne
MacLeay, Travis
MacNeill, Ron
Maher, Ingrid
Mair Property Securities Ltd (on behalf of all the owners of 525 Stirling Hwy,
Cottesloe)
Malacari, Luke S
Maley, Kirsten
Maloney, Bruce
Mannolini, Amanda; Gerrish, Laurence & Connolly, Anne-Maire
Mansell, Vanya
Martinick, Dirk
Martino, Bianca
Marwick, Susan
May, Sarah
McCormick, Jonathon R
McGechie, David & Ada
McGowan, Claire
McGown, Michael (on behalf of Kirsten Maley)
McKean, Andrew
McKenzie, Ian
McNab, Sandy C
Meehan, Pamela
Mellor, Edward
Mellor, Thomas
Meredith, David
Merks, Kristy
Metcalfe, Chris
Mian, C
Mignot, Belinda A
Miller, Todd
Milliner, Andrew
Milliner, Jessica
Mines and Petroleum, Department of
Monk, Anthony & Shirley
Monro, Caroline
Monro, Victoria
Morgan, Sue
Moriarty, Bruce
Morris, Dr Christina (Appollonia Nominees, Cottesloe Dental)
Morton, Keith
Mosman Park, Town of
582
457
600
476
495
413
494
101
372
486
26
292
29
183
123
462
347
182
434
222
567
437
52
298
236
99
516
314
187
256
296
418
213
512
513
90
34
561
560
467
263
233
428
320
319
278
247
295
564
480
266
364
156
Moulden, Deanne
Muir, Gregory
Mullen, Kate
Mulvena-Trinder, Brendan
Murray, David
Murray, John (Creation Landscape Supplies)
Murray, Lisa
Mussared, Helen A
Musto, Ken & Lyn
Nairn, Pam
Nardone, Rocco A (for Conpec Pty Ltd)
National Trust of Australia (WA)
Naughton, Paul
Nedlands Electors Association (Inc)
Nedlands, City of
Neil, Anne & Tepper, Steve
Newson, Alan & Barlow, Johanna
Nguyen, Thai Duy
Niblett, Dylan
Nichol, Colin
Nicholls, Scott
Nicholson, Charlie
Nikakhtar, Loghman
Nikolich, Amanda & Goran
Nixon, Bruce & Handcock, Karen
Nomet Pty Ltd
Nottage, J
O'Connor, David
O'Dea, John
Officer, Meg
O'Keefe, Joe
O'Loughlin, Edmond (on behalf of Geraldine O'Loughlin)
Orchard, Stuart
O'Reilly, Alexandra
Oria, Conrad
Orly, Tammy
Ou, Zhiliang
Owenell, Ben
Owenell, John
Owners of Brookwood, 396 Stirling Hwy (Andrew Bremner)
Owners of Terrara (Strata Plan 1275)
Palmer, Narayani
Palmer, Richard D
Paparone, Jack
Paparone, Romaine
Parmentier, Brice
Paterniti, Robert & Sue
Paterson, Alistair
Paterson, Eleanor
Paterson, Jennifer A
Paton, Mary-Anne
Pattison, Cate & Giles
Paulik-White, Dr Georgie
335
265
88
149
425
66
218
118
51
220
410
200
597
185
465
403
426
227
166
287
590
208
328
312
251
106
78
161
159
370
451
569
167
144
297
18
37
477
58
598
593
129
157
454
443
407
193
411
435
133
514
5
238
Pauling, Glenn
Paxton, James F
Pearce, Cameron
Pedro, Zamia
Peppermint Grove, Shire of
Petrides, Peter
Phillips, Dodie
Phillips, Jenny
Philpott, Martin & Mary
Pickles, Carol
Pieniazek, Jan & Cecilia
Pinkster, Lauren
Pinto, E
Pisano, Ngarie & Giglieto
Pittaway, Janine & Brown, Stewart
Planning Solutions (on behalf of Amana Living)
Poland, Greg
Pollard, Helena
Porter, Clare
Pratt, Brian & Gillian
Prindiville, T
Pritchard, Georgina
Ptolomey, Brendon (AAPI Certified Practising Valuer)
Pyvis, Sally
Quayle, Monica
Rae-Frae, Ama
Ramdas Tampi & Pamela Hendry
Ramsay, Rob
Randall, Brooke
Rattigan, Annabel
Rattigan, Graeme
Redgrave, Sian
Reed, Sandra
Rees, John (Mosman Park Veterinary Hospital)
Reeve, Thomas & Valerie
Reid, Sarah M
Remmerswaal, N
Revell, Kerry
Richardson, Gavin
Ridley, Ben & Dietrich, Jessica
Ridley, Cate
Rigg, Jeremy
Riley, Jim
Rippingale, Kelly
Rivalland, Virginia & Daniel
Roberts, Giles
Roberts, Lynn
Roberts, Peter; Strauss, Caroline; Wood, Anne & Lankester, Keith
Roberts, Tom
Robinson, John
Rogers, Joanna
Rogers, John
Rogers, Steve
515
127
173
160
400
326
565
79
510
40
488
432
290
380
22
275
490
259
250
281
344
343
448
21
107
234
69
414
442
248
116
366
509
80
481
279
224
97
330
456
499
469
15
283
285
240
334
94
102
154
521
148
174
Rogers, Steve
Rosenstein, Jennifer
Runco, Mario & Mary
Russell, Glenn
Ryan, Gary
Sambrailo, Christian
Savill, Julie
Savoy Management Pty Ltd
Scott, Elizabeth
Seng, James Cheah Kit (Duomark on behalf of the owners)
Shaw, Jeni
Shepherd, Melissa
Shepherd, Pip
Showell, John A
Simpson, John & Marie-Louise
Skipworth, Ric & Tish
Sluga, Lena
Smith, Deonne
Smith, Keith & Elizabeth
Smith, Roland
Smith, Sophie
Smith, Stewart
Socha, Pauline M
South West Aboriginal Land & Sea Council (SWALSC)
Spencer, David
Stansfield, Judith
State Heritage Office
Staude, Anita
Steffen, Thomas & Franscesca
Stirling, Kim
Stokes, Amy
Stone, Noel T
Stoner, B
Subiaco, City of
Sullivan, Andrew
Sullivan, Jane
Suttar, Craig
Swan River People Native Title Holders
Sweetman, Lorraine
Swift, Omega
Swiney, Tracey
Tambasco, Serena
Tan, John Tiang Tong
Tapp, Aimee
Taylor, Annie
Thayne, Nell
The Fremantle Society
The Landowners of Stirling Heights - SP5036
The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth
Thomas, Jacinta (Manager Violet Pilot)
Thompson, M O
Thompson, Stephen
Thorpe, John
122 Thorpe, Susan
444 TPG (on behalf of Rhys Edwards, owner Nedlands Post Office)
397 TPG (on behalf of the landowners Amhurst Enterprises Pty Ltd and John
Fountain as trusteee for the John Fountain Family Trust)
439 TPG (on behalf of the owners CITI Fiedlity Nominee Co Pty Ltd)
497 Tregonning, Anne
492 Trishs' Place (Antiques)
245 Truscott, Kate
449 Tucak, Layla
478 Tucak, Michael
146 Tulloch, Alastair (Councillor)
376 Turner, Stacey
96 University of Western Australia (Professor Paul Johnson)
471 Unknown
524 Unknown
525 Unknown
526 Unknown
527 Unknown
528 Unknown
529 Unknown
530 Unknown
531 Unknown
532 Unknown
533 Unknown
534 Unknown
535 Unknown
536 Unknown
537 Unknown
538 Unknown
539 Unknown
540 Unknown
541 Unknown
542 Unknown
543 Unknown
544 Unknown
545 Unknown
546 Unknown
547 Unknown
548 Unknown
549 Unknown
550 Unknown
551 Unknown
552 Unknown
553 Unknown
554 Unknown
555 Unknown
556 Unknown
601 Unknown
602 Unknown
61 Vasudavan, Dr Sivabalan (Sole Director of Lola Management Pty Ltd)
16 Victoria Creek Pty Ltd
198 Vidulich, K M
199 Vidulich, M
86
152
164
507
472
239
143
317
318
402
422
306
2
363
177
264
460
455
105
176
268
508
374
417
589
395
325
475
73
117
150
464
405
305
304
36
311
392
406
42
7
194
324
Late
Submissions
623
612
620
622
608
626
Vigano, Anthony J
Vujic, Tara
Vujic, Tijana
Wall, Jon
Wallbridge, Philip
Walsh, Aiden
Walsh, Brett
Walsh, Jane
Walsh, John
Walter, Peta (on behalf of the North Fremantle Community Association)
Walton, Haylee
Warrall, Ian
Water (Swan Avon Region), Department of
Water Corporation
Watson, Nevin J
Weber, David
West, Carly
West, Michael
Wheeldon, Chris
Whelans WA Pty Ltd (on behalf of owners Gull Properties)
Whelans WA Pty Ltd (on behalf of owners WA Flour Mills Pty Ltd)
White, Rolf
Whitley, John
Wickenden, Kyele J
Wilkinson, Kate
Williams, Simon & Jill
Willis, Jane
Willson, Hayley E
Wilson, Kerri
Wilson, Stacey
Wilson, Tracey
Woods, Trent
Woollett, Sara
Worrall, Charlotte
Worrall, Karen
Yau, Bonnie
Yeaton, Jeff
Yeo, Veronica J
Yu, Lawrence
Yuen, Julie (for Weng Hoong Nominees Pty Ltd)
YWB Pty Ltd
Zevis, M A & A C
Zuvela, Peter
Name
Adams, Pete
Bekkevold, Sacha
Bell, James
Berrovic, L
Caddy, Stephen M
Cottesloe, Town of
627
606
624
625
621
610
614
613
611
609
607
618
604
615
628
603
605
616
617
619
Crandell, J D
Evans, George M
Evans, Susan
Gow, Peter
Graeme Robertson Group
Hood, Libby
Lane, Gary
MacRae, Jenna
Merride, Christopher
Nolan, Clint
O'Driscoll, Nanette
Owenell, Helen; Willing, Suzanne & Bennett, Christine (Busatti)
Page, Jane & Gilmore, Mike, Jane, Tom & Elea
Rowe, Jacqui
Shell Company of Australia, The
Silove, Dr Kym
State Development, Department of
Unknown
Unknown
Wright, Timothy (Wrightfeldhusen Architects)
Submissions
Submiss osii 1 * I
From: James.Ioppolo@l-3com.com [mailto:James.Ioppolo@l-3com.com]
Sent: Wednesday, 21 March 2012 1:28 P
To: StirlingHighway
Subject: Metropolitan Region Scheme Major Amendment 1210/41 - Rationalisation of Stirling Highway
Reservation
Hi Stirling Highway Planners,
I support the rationalisation in Amendment 1210/41.1 think it s wonderful that the Department of
Planning has published lon term plans for the im rovement of this important link. I have observed with
interest, the upgrading of Great Eastern Highway between Koorong Road and Tonkin Highway, and
recognise the importance of good planning across Perth.
With respect to Stirling Highway, I live in Maylands, work in Fremantle, and don't want to see the
Department pandering to the needs of minority groups.
I would like to provide formal support of the amendment. Is it necessary to provide a handwritten
submission, or do emails of support suffice ?
Cheers,
James loppolo, PhD
Senior Analyst / Software Engineer
L-3 Nautronix
108 Marine Terrace, Fremantle, WA 6160, Australia
T +61 (0) 8 9431 0022, F +61 (0) 8 9430 5901
E iames.ioPDolo@L-3com.com
www.L-3Com.com/nautroni
Submission 2
weste
Australian
Planning
Commission
Our Ref: 809-2-1-91 Ft 2 (RLS/0248)
Enquiries: Mr John O Hurley (6551 9187)
Government of Western Australia
Department of Water
1 o
Watfer
I : . \ (;
SpAa-Z-
Swan-Avon Region
Regional Manager
Department of Water
11 mar ?fjp
Returned referral
Swan-Avon Region
Assessed-
7 Ellam Street
VICTORIA PARK WA 6100
No comments
:: ? -f°)
MJ i&S IS1S
CANNED; Y M
Signed.
Dear Sir/Madam
DEPARTMRC Or f!..ANNINGi
(' R - &uk>Q )i'c!
Metropolitan Re ion Scheme Proposed Amendment 1210/41
Rationalisation of Stirling H ghway Reservation
2 7 MAR 201?
: Z
ls/o
s;!
1
jflLt
The Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC) has recently initiated the above
amendment to the Metropolitan Region Scheme and is seeking public comment.
The amendment proposes an overall reduction of the existing Stirling Highway 'Primary Regional
Roads' reservation to limit the reservation to land which realistically may be needed for future
road works. The proposed road reservation includes adequate space for future improvements to
better cater for pedestrians, cyclists and public transport as well as address traffic congestion
and improve road safety, as detailed in the enclosed amendment report.
The purpose of the amendment is to rationalise the existing Stirling Highway reservation and
ensure sufficient land is protected for long term regional and local traffic needs. Presently, the
reservation is too wide in some locations, whilst not wide enough in others. Modifying the existing
reservation will assist budget and priority setting for future highway improvements.
Notices will be published in the Government Gazette, The West Australian, The Sunday Times
and relevant local newspapers. The amending plans and other documents will be on display at
various locations in the metropolitan area. Documents can also be accessed on the PlanningWA
website www.planning.wa.gov.au. The various ways to access more information about this
amendment are summarised on the separate page titled: Howto access further information on Stirling
Highway MRS amendment 1210/41.
Your agency is invited to comment on the amendment. Please use the submission form that is
printed in the back of the amendment report, so that we can match your comments to the
appropriate planning issue.
If making a submission, please use headings or numbers to separate issues or matters for
consideration and, where relevant, include specific property addresses or locations.
Written submissions addressed to he Western Aust alian Planning Commission must be
eceived no late than Friday 27 July 2012 to be conside ed.
Postal address: Locked Bag 2506 Perth WA Street address:140 William Street Perth WA 6000
Tel: (08) 655 19000 Fax: (08) 655 19001 TTY: 655 19007 Infoline: 1800 626 477
\MM±U corporate@planninq.wa.qov.au www. lanninq.wa.qov.au
ABN 35 482 341 493
If you would like more information about this amendment, please contact Mr John O Hurley,
Project Officer at the Department of Planning on 6551 9187.
Neil Thomson
Secretary
Western Australian Planning Commission
20 March 2012
Postal address: Locked Bag 2506 Perth WA Street address: 140 William Street Perth WA 6000
corporate@plannind'.wa.'qo\/.au vww.planninq.wa.qov.au
ABN 35 482 341 493
DEPARTiW
Planning and Development Act 2005
Section 41 Amendment (Substantial)
J\NNlMG
Form 41
? 3 MAR 2012.
Submission
1 41Q-2
i
I
Wletropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1210/41
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 3
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name ...Xffi fiJ.r.Li...QDlJ. J-fLLLL.
j (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)
Address .
: .tb.... ..l/ . Postcode (S&.lJ......
Contact phone number /.
Email address XlQ. .!(: iL t yi il.L V
Tips for completing a submission:
o Use headings or numbers to separate different topics and issues
o Include property addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
° Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
t . .31. J.h. .p P d. Qpk. l:0.qfP.Qucd sQa..../.Pdp..
.i&. QPd .. kmid.. AA. Ir. .p.T?peMu.
qd/sivo... ihiS.. ..L/p. t. M
m....(jys/y)..i06ASd).(Pi..iPldMydded, .C0q?.l(d P.. Qip ,
lP....P( cq!q..Q ... pioidQ(...
cA... mood..... G.CCu ... ..CApJrP. tip.... IMiKlyMj.
... SB. SSM... .&. .lAt). oLS I/P..... Spi ed... .GuJ.... (L/C.
. fitSkP. .cmd./.Q. c.. BpSt claM.. cr\EMa.... .mtQ.
Ljl ... U dciGuAftiikSSk ..BsBttlfxuJ:.. JPPqp
PM. ...Of.... C(MPp.MMCPQ.(Xp..)
turn over to complete you submission
Hearing of submissions
Anyone who has made a written sub ission on the amendment may personally present the basis of their
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compulsory. Your
written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment
whether you nominate to speak at the hearings or not.
Further information on submissions and hearings is included in Appendix E of the amendment report.
Please choose one of the following:
N No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
Q Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)
I will be represented by:
E Myself - My telephone number (business hours):
or
A spokesperson
Name of spokesperson:
Contact telephone number (business hours):
Postal address:
I would prefer my hearing to be conducted in:
EH Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation)
OR
H Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
permitted to attend)
You should be aware that:
° The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC ma ;
subject to applications for access under the act.
0 In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties.
© All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment. The
WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissions and tabled in Parliament.
To be signed by person(s) makin the submission
Signature
.
c Y c tY
.. vc
Date ...
>3/ -
Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertise closing date, being close of
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will NOT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://www.planning.wa.gov.au
Section 41 Amendmen (Substantial)
Form 41
Submission
Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1210/41
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submi sion 4
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
it
Name
Address ..
j/.Q
.
r
(PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)
~ &.
.
.. S. .7
. Postcode ... ¦> /.'r?.
O act phone number ?. address
° Include property addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
Submission
turn over to complete your submission
Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment may personally present the basis of their
M- Wo, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
O Yes,
wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)
I will be re resented by:
Myself - My telephone number (business hours):
o
A spokesperson
Postal address:
Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation)
OR
Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
o The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be
o In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
° All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
To he11 si ned by person(s) makin the submission
Signature
Date
2.} :/}/ .?..
Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of
busine s Spm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will NOT be considered.
f
o rLo
-6'2-
VVestern
Australian
Planning
Commission
Our Ref: 809-2-1-91 Ft 2 (RLS/0248)
Chief Executive Officer
Fire & Emergency Services Authority of WA
?
IN TRIM
-J
r nfradL /?<£>
GPO Box P1174
PERTH WA 6844
Dear Sir/Madam
Metropolitan Region Scheme Proposed Amendment 1210/41
The Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC) has recently initiated the above
amendment to the Metropolitan Region Scheme and is seeking public comment.
The amendment proposes an overall reduction of the existing Stirling Highway 'Primary Regional
Roads' reservation to limit the reservation to land which realistically may be needed for future
road works. The proposed road reservation includes adequate space for future improvements to
better cater for pedestrians, cyclists and public transport as well as address traffic congestion
and improve road safety, as detailed in the enclosed amendment report.
ensure sufficient land is protected for long term regional and local traffic needs. Presently, the
reservation is too wide in some locations, whilst not wide enough in others. Modifying the existing
reservation will assist budget and priority setting for future highway improvements.
Notices will be published in the Government Gazette, The West Australian, The Sunday Times
and relevant local newspapers. The amending plans and other documents will be on display at
various locations in the metropolitan area. Documents can also be accessed on the PlanningWA
website www.planning.wa.gov.au. The various ways to access more information about this
amendment are summarised on the separate page titled: How to access further information on Stirling
Hig way MRS amendment 1210/41.
Your agency is invited to comment on the amendment. Please use the submission form that is
printed in the back of the amendment report, so that we can match your comments to the
appropriate planning issue.
Written submissions addressed to the Western Australian Planning Commission must be
received no later than Friday 27 July 2012 to be considered.
Postal address: Locked Bag 2506 Perth WA Street address: 140 William Street Perth WA 6000
Tel: (08) 655 19000 Fax: (08) 655 19001 T Y: 6.55 19007 Infoline: 1800 626 477
corporate@planninq.wa.qov.au www.planninq.wa.qov.au
ABN 35 482 341 493
PARl'jVii Ni Dr F'LAMNiNG
Form 41
-1 APR 21) r/
Subm ssioin
/letropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 121 /41
ationalisation of S irling Highwa Reservation
OFFICE USE ONLY
To:
Secretary
..
.
,,,
Submission §
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
L..„
J
Name
Address A
Contact phone number. .G.fyj. ?. Email address .QGr :. J. lAF,
u
Tips for com leting a submission:
Use headings or numbers to separate different topics and issues
Include property addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
¦To -the- SHAG-this plan-is just-athi red-line
They say what are you worried about this will take 10- 20 years id it ever happens '
Exactl the.problem ; 15,000 pro erties made effectivel unsaleable and unable to be
improved or modified on the basis of a plan that may never happen; certainly is it
unlikely any govern men t as $' 1000,000,-GOO' dollars to' recompense owners andto do the
.structural,
works
here is ho' buy back'; just a promise of a one sided ' egotiation; ' ith the government
¦holding all the.cards. .An .with.the go ernment has ah dy.significantl negatively.
manipulated property values by this very announcement, with the uncertainty and the
forward deterioration of the marked area
" "
To the residents of Claremont Cottesloe Fremantle and Mosman Park it s a black cloud
hanging ove a major part of the economic social i frastuctuf e of their sub'urb'ds
Please choose one of t e following:
Wo, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)
or
H A spokesperson
Postal address:
I woul prefer my hearing to be conducted in:
OR
EH Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
To the SHAC this line
They say what are you wonied about this will take 10- 20 years id it ever happens
subjeciiinia]6plii34t!MhSifdJiit
m'gcfe fo. eH/VAPC may be
>iJfefe 8%sd?:f.a Plan that may never l aPPen; certainly is it
unlikely anv government has $ 1000,000,000 dollars to recompense owners and to do the
° In the course pf.the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
sub rn i ssiof or e YuSsfance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties.
® All heaTjijg tg fftPbul ib Jrp QliifMdnTilse trfiascriptsidfcdlItlt aitiia paioVigthith lEtt/Yi Sh Shhlnissions, are
tabled g(flg[li gptg(a(igM! i.sMftla hWl?d dVdft«h@B.ltlltlae S®aach,oR ip[fieeit pmegstBCfcbj nendment. The
forward deterioration of the marked area
To be signed by person(s) making the submission
To the residents of Claremont Cottesloe Fremantle and Mosman Park it s a black cloud
hanging over a ajor part of the economic social infrastucture of theii subuibds
Signature
Date
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website-http://www.planning.wa.gov.au
A highly significant number of small business operate from the highway strip,
particularly in Mosman Park
The worst outcome is what they promise; not a buy back and immediate action, but
decades of inaction and declining property values with no positive outcome to the
community or property owners
For what ??
No more lanes
A wider median strip
Another cycleway not utilising the railway reserve
A bus lane for virtually non existant bus service along the highway
The Govememnt is hiding the true effect by refusing to release photo overlays of the
affected areas ; these must be made immediately available to the propery owners and the
public in general /
John Rogers ,
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING
"I DEC 2012
Form 41
Submission
FILE <vL S I o C? (?
Rationalisation of Sti ling Highway Reservation
OFFICE USE ONLY
SUBMISSION NU BER
To: Secretary
5
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name John Rogers
Address !.!
?.!.!. ostcode . .<5.
Contact phone number...Q rh)• Email address
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes' box is tic ed. This is not compulsory. Your
No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
I will be epresented by:
Myself - My telephone number (business hours): ... .' l! ..!..(.'.<D,.3.1-E
o
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
I would prefer my hea ing to be conducted in:
OR
• The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be
° In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
o All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
To be signed by person(s) m kin
Signature
he submission
Date
Note: Form 41 MUST be received close of business (5pm) on 8 December 2012.
i DEPARTWid' ; OF PL NN'NG
2 APR
Form 41
Su mission
FILE
OFFICE USE ONLY
E
ll
To: Secretary
ubmissio
6
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
m
Name
lDC
v
. r:!>. r?. r... ? lT>y.
.
U
r: .(
(PLEASE
r
P
a. .t. QS T ,TD
PRINT
st
l
~
smsBO Rav)& 14 (a'Z- Z
CLEARLY)
Address ..9/?? .. . fl 'E
Postcode b.QO. a(
Contact phone number
Email address ..Q.tSC-cl
.
.Q., r
].
(
'
' 1
71,. or completing a submission:
o Use headings or numbers to se arate different topics and issues
® Include roperty addresses and s ecific location descri tions where relevant
. ° Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
. . .TE..TIA«T..:Thi.e.. ec O.PQit:rr;/\i
.. \ Q/ArA P. Pose.S. . O.. .Gh i G L . GT S
sthG. .fe.Fh GRAf.. gl. .fRoAiDS'... ea R g r Ri f o;a. ; hG
£...pRD.PG.FT.Y.... ..E .SrVrY...fta&Ge . . s RPoRT
£..PRG.P SF.tRT. .. StiR .FCa..H &RlRA.Y..a'.Y
R-LRE G .. ERY..b FDG ./GX1...TIGIE..RRC.RUo.fR...AF
: he e. .tee> \to..- ?e.. 0...c e?\c l. Refvso
. AGOE3 . GRAC .. .G
FTTVE . .G.eS.eR'V!. ATI, 0. W. '.TVfGT
. t LU..tG 0. t.... G\!.BF.. T... 3ex>. o.F...EGQuiRG O,
H
/
OR
1 will be rep esented by:
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
1 would prefer my hearing to be conducted in:
OR
e In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of r
To be si ned by person(s) making the submission
JO r ...wcYT.
T n.f
Signature
Date
I2-
Section 41 Amendment (Substan ial) department f planning
Form 41
3 APR 2012
Su mission
/t i j p. h ?
Metropolitan Region Scheme mendment 1210/44P
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
S bmissio 7
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
B
Name
2
.7.
(PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) FT tcT t' '
Address . 7. At. . .C. vftf&ffP.hA.1 ... .,?.)7
"g? '
T. T3?P.>G<T. l 7- Postcode pt
Contact phone number .3.67.6. Zf. A Email address .l. . . k .66
Cf (j
T/ s for completing a submission:
0 Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
. (I.) (6. .frf bfry. u..
~?.. 73*- h
p tt
. C.e3. t-3 3.... (. r: #.VP.... G- : ?. .f. (663.6. . Ar. 77 >A y f.
i ) T .. . .r?y. <y...
kNrNrVV. -sA dc
wy dr.... 6p... 7.13j. .. .fopp yy3
. Cp ).... 7~ .. .4 . rt i .. /3?6y:yfr 3rf t
n
aV t?. . r7?7i .6k>... . f.v . 7 . .6333. T. NTr. T7<-Er < > 4 . / (j ..
33.y.(3.f/.V:....?.(Y. 3./(/ /.yt.
°
?7
sr /y /(f.i(~r3
777 3....773. r /9. Z ....33.3.... J .J/....*3;. /.x3y. r:.y.3r. .3.36.3y
..33:.33.3 .6.3.3.3..?..3r...3.33.. 3 .3{ 3.3/
3. y3 r33y.3? 7.
3773 ....733..737.6.... 3733/3_ .(73.7.c 33.P .3:. ?3 <? 3
7737. f.3.33.. /73 Az 77.7y:3 *
m
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
e In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
Signature
Western
Australian
iCBPAHTMLC Of PLANNIN
Planning,
Commission
¦ 3 APR M
Property Ref: 212B, Claremont
WAPC Ref: 809-2-1-91 Pt 2 (RLS/0173)
j
I «- :
YWB Pty Ltd
C/- Davenport Real Estate
FILE
- -
,ci2 I
BY;
9/8 Booth Place
7'
BALCATTA WA 6021
9
Dear Sir/Madam
M4R m |l
BY;
Re Property: Lot 3 (No. 3) Stirling Hwy. Claremont
Re Property: Lot 4 (No. 208) Stirlin Hwv, Claremont
This letter is to notify you, as owner of the above property, of a proposed amendment to the
Metropolitan Region Scheme ( RS).
The Western Australian Planning Commission invites you to make a written submission on
MRS Amendment 1210/41 Rationalisation of Stirling Highway reservation to be received no
later than 27 July 2012 to ensure your views are taken into consideration.
The amendment proposes an overall reduction of the existing Stirling Highway 'Primary
Regional Roads' reservation to limit the reservation to land which realistically may be
needed for future road works. The proposed road reservation includes adequate space for
future improvements to better cater for pedestrians, cyclists and public transport as well as
address traffic congestion and improve road safety.
ensure sufficient land is protected for long term regional and local traffic needs. Presently,
the reservation is too wide in some locations, whilst not wide enough in others. Modifying the
existing reservation will assist budget and priority setting for future highway improvements.
North of Jarrad Street, Cottesloe, many properties are presently affected by the existing 80
metre wide 'Primary Regional Roads' reserve, placed in 1963 and larger than necessary.
The amendment proposes to r duce the regional reservation over the above property.
A sketch plan showing the existing reservation boundary (green) and the proposed reduced
reservation boundary (red) is attached for your consideration.
The enclosed Amendment Report includes specific details and reasons for the amendment,
as well as information on the Metropolitan Region Scheme and amendments.
The amendment only proposes changes for land in close proximity to Stirling Highway
(generally less than 40 metres) between Hampden Road/Broadway, Nedlands and Queen
Victoria Street, North Fremantle (see Figure 1 in the attached Amendment Report).
wa.gov.au
corporate@plannin .wa. ov.au www.planning.wa.gov.au
ABN 35 82 341 493
There are various ways to access more information about this amendment. These are
summarised on the following page titled: How to access further information on Stirling
Highway MRS ame dment 1210/41.
Your opinion and views on the amendment are very important however may only be taken
into account if written or typed with the writer's details included.
A submission form (Form 41) is included in the Amendment Report. Further copies of the
form may be photocopied, downloaded from the PlanningWA website
(www.planning.wa.gov.au) and from relevant local government offices.
Written submissions add essed to the Western Australian Planning Commission must
be received no later than Frida 27 July 2012 to be considered.
For further enquiries, please call the Stirling Highway Information Ses ice on 65S1 9543
and leave a detailed voice message with your name, phone number and exact property
address for a return phone call by a project officer.
If the above property and/or ownership details are incorrect please contact the Region
Schemes Officer on telephone 6551 9427.
Yours sincerley
Neil Thomson
Secretary
20 March 2012
corporate@plannina.wa.aov.au www.plannina.wa.aov.au
ABN 35 482 341 493
Proposed Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) Amendment
Reduction in land required
for road purposes
No.208 (Lot 3) & (Lot 4)
Stirling Highway, Claremont
Proposed area required 289 m2
subject to survey
Extract of proposed changes: plan number 1.7146 ( 212-b )
GOVERNMENT OF
WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Existing reserve boundary
Western
Australian
Planning
Commission
c!are212.dgn
16 Aug 2011
Produced by Mapping & GeoSpalial Dala Branch, Department ol Planning, Perth WA
On behalf of the V/estem Australian Planning Commission.
Base information su plied by Western Australia Land Infor ation Authority LI 430-2009-4
Proposed reserve boundary
Scale 1:600
0
X
GDA
12
Property boundary
Proposed area required
metres
Note: All dimensions are in metres.
Submis io S
REMANTLE
Health &
Safety
Ref: PDE.172
Environment
Quality
IS014001
ISO 9001
AS 4801
OKI'S
3 April 2012
DEPARTMEIT OF PLANNING
The Secretary
APR 2012
Locked Bag 2506
FILE
PERTH WA 6001
o2
Dear Sir,
METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME AMENDMENT 1210/41 -
RATIONALISATION OF STIRLING HIGHWAY RESERVATION
I write to you regarding Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1210/41 for the
rationalisation of the Stirling Highway reservation.
Fremantle Ports interest is in the southe end of the Stirling Highway Access
Corridor which connects with the strategic road freight routes servicing the Fremantle
Inner Harbour, namely Port Beach Road, Tydeman Road, Curtin Avenue and Stirling
Highway.
Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1210/41 does not consider the potential for
extension of Curtin Avenue via a new traffic bridge over the passenger railway line to
join Stirling Highway near Queen Victoria Street. The only reference to the proposed
extension of Curtin Avenue is a note on a drawing that in the future it will be subject
to separate consultation by the Department of Transport.
The planning of the Stirling Highway corridor needs to be considered in the context of
the strategic planning for this wider regional road network and should integrate with
transport planning for strategic road freight routes in this area. Consideration should
also be given to relevant land use planning proposals in the area such as the recently
finalised MRS Amendment for the Beehive Montessori School site in Mosman Park.
Fremantle Pen's: 1 Cliff Street, Fremantle, Western Australia 6160 - Postal Address: PO Box 95 Fremantle WA 6959
Telephone: +61 8 9430 3555 • Facsimile: +61 8 9336 1391 ® Email: mail@fremantlepoi1s.com.au 0 Web: www.fremantleports.com.au
ABN 78187 229 472
Ref: PDE.172
We strongly urge the WAPC to progress the planning for Stirling Highway and Curtin
Avenue in a co-ordinated and timely manner, to provide certainty and clarity for
landowners and stakeholders in the North Fremantle Area potentially impacted by
either or both proposals.
I can be contacted on 9430 3390 should you have any queries or require further
information.
Yours sincerely
Dean Davidson
Planning Manager
;. |T i '|f PI ANHlN'
Section 41 Amen ment (Substantial)
Form 41
i . 4 APR
0 \
Submission
[Vletropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1210/411
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
SMbmis ibiD i
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
P-
Name
..
S.
_
j
.1.4,
(PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) ['Ol 2A\£9 \*
Address
C
..
5P..
....
Postcode
.
j.
.
tact phone number Email address ( j •.
'
e Use headings or numbers to separate different topics and issues
® Attach additional numbered ages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
. fe /.. . .
.cC
.
. r... .Cf...
;C.. , C .
r g o Pc\( _ _ _ i s
ca
... .CCr..
fe ir y 9
. .. .0C 3.u.e; _
iA AQ d rx Sdr
.
.. .CC.A....
. .C r>B-r-.
J l.I...
xof
. ;
CYX / C. . .Crr. rfr rA . .( CQpA rj
. J A ir'dro r<A - aC?. AcC. .. C .. :jjrr .p/TQ
. EC
Q
>fe AC:
i.
iP... .DcfOr* -.... A C
cr?r pFo< ...
A.cC.A
turn over to complete your sub ission
A»
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
0 The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be
® All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
Signature
Date
I IJEPAl ITM! /\ (- DI ,, „ .
j ' •¦d/'./i li G,
Form 41
I 1 0 APR ?[i 12 1
[file 6LL&loiliQ
Sub nissioni
-2- 1 r
OFFICE USE ONLY
Submission 10
To: Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
:/
Name
' (PLEiA!
(PL ASE PRINT CLEARLY)
r
Address .l/./v.Y.
/A
T. ..-r.AlPi / . ......Ar... Postcode
Email address . Al i
® Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
.(... httilAh..... hf.&fu&lrC. l/S/A!A ATZATf.Afft....- /®/71/7
f tt&A.F.e.R.C-. >ZA/7..\TA.AA
K s. l./Pil.T.l.anl.... .< £. tfbyf> /? ;. Ih/P//::///. /;~-P.. . /A/ /X
l t: .8£ .(AiAf.. /ife . ufe r.... .i cA. £« r yife..
n.
o t... .m/w... . .
./frrA ... ftMA.m./ /..
fi./j/M .A. Faj. mc£.... ./ferurn/A. C.&.o. rfeA..... life:::... .71. /.. P..
.17/. A..... CrO,/Ul. &CZ7.. Q/AsM.feAAK.
Pc.... Kyc fKrtc-...M.Q!?r.t.....lry. tr vfe/cc. i f A.7....pAvAfe.
P . (1 miSt. MmAtiAnsT.
M!li/.A/i..../rhrp ....' wtA....fe«7f>. lf]j7h... fe...fMX:,....
O&t Ava.A.. ..1&M0C,.. Mfc/.M. A. . AA/tfe/Zp/fe/)..
... S.ftp.k L/> /L C.... A O.A/7i.6r7? 7A1. . *7/o... /Jfe/.A.ltI7./:\.. './.Uflfi/.A....
OR
C Myself - My telephone number (business hours):
or
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
0
OR
® In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
e All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
Box 761, Dunsborough
Western Australia 6281
Ph: (08)97552630
Fax: (08)97552631
Mob: 0427471 066
Submission 11
ENQUIRIES : Melissa Davis - Ph 9235 8000
OUR REF: 12/0289
YOUR REF: 809-2-1-91 Pt2 (6551 9187)
Mr Neil Thomson
Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
PERTH WA 6000
Attention: Mr John O Hurley
Dear Mr Parker
METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME PROPOSED A END ENT 1210/41
RATIONALISATION OF STIRLING HIGHWAY RESERVATIO
Thank you for your letter dated 20 March 2012 seeking our comment on the proposed
rationalisation of Stirling Highway Reservation, We understand the rationalisation is seeking
to overall reduce the reservation to land which realistically may be needed for future road
works. The proposed road reservation will include adequate space for future improvements
to better cater for pedestrians, cyclists, public transport, traffic congestion and improve road
safety,
I have reviewed the information you provided and advise, based on that information, there
are two Aboriginal heritage places currently mapped on our Aboriginal Heritage Information
System (AHIS) that fall within the proposed amendment area boundary. These include DIA
3336 (Victoria Street Station) and DIA 21253 (Mosman Park).
Please find below a link to our Due Diligence Guidelines for assistance that help in
identifying the risk that proposed activities may have on adversely impacting Aboriginal
heritage alues.
http://www.dia.wa.qov.au/Documents/HeritageCulture/Heritage%20management/AHA Due
Diligence Guidelines.pdf
Whilst rezoning and changes to boundary alignments are not included in the Guidelines,
future activities that may be a result of the adjustment are.
If you have any further queries regarding this matter please do not hesitate to contact Senior
Heritage Officer Melissa Davis on 9235 8000.
- Hbhristine Lewis
Manager, Heritage South
10 April 20)2
1st Floor, 197 St Georges Terrace, Perth, Western Australia 6000
PO Box 7770, Cloisters Square, Pei th, Western Australia 6850
telephone (08) 9235 8000 Facsimile (08) 9235 8088
wvvw.dia.wa.gov.au
a.gov.au
Section 41 mendment (Substantial)
Form 41
Submission
iVIetropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1210/41
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 12
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
o Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
tu n over to complete yo r submission
0
OR
or
C A spokesperson
Postal
address:
I would p efe my hearing to be conducted in:
C Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation)
OR
E Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
a The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions ade to the WAPC maybe
o in the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
Signature
Date
{d£X(e('
Note: Submissions MUST be recei ed by the advertised closing date, being close of
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions ill OT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - ttp://www.planning.wa.go .au
'ARTWit NT f PIAMM!
2 0 APR W
Form 41
Submission
Metropolitan Region Scheme Amend ent 1210/41
FILE
Rationalisation of Stirling Highway Reser ation
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 13
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
.
...
.¦
i.
.
.
2
,
Address ...'P/r..Gy$ p.
Postcode
I n
.fi I)
Contact phone number Q'. r& .3 )31). Email address ....p.Q- r.k Y ,.g;
Trps for completing a submission:
o Include property addresses and s ecific location descriptions where relevant
o Attach additional numbered ages if you require more space to complete your sub ission
Submission
ST QUENTINS APARTMENTS - STRATA PLAN 52198 - LOT 200
As Strata Manager for St Quentins Apart ents, Lot 200, we have received a copy of your letter
of the 20th March outlining the MRS Rationalisation of Stirling Highway.
The MRS amendment 1210/41 Rationalisation of Stirling Highway Reservation has been
reviewed by the Council of Owners of St Quentins Apartments. The following issues have been
identified to reject the proposed increase in reservation area.:
1. The increased reservation boundary (red) would require St Quentins Apartments to be
demolished;
2. The St Quentins building was only recently built and met all local planning authority
requirements, including density and appearance; and
3. The concept of establishing an extra lane on Stirling Rd will not alleviate traffic
congestion on Stirling Hwy.
The Strata Company, through the Council of Owners, agrees with the proposal to increase the
flow of traffic along Stirling Hwy but contests the proposal to increase the reservation
boundary (red) along Stirling Road.
Should you have any queries, or wish to discuss this matter, please do not hesitate to contact me.
- <ro»/rj .fi/
Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment may personally p esent the basis of their
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the belo 'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compulsory. Your
written submission ill be considered in deter ining the recommendation for the p opose amen ment
Further information on submissions and hearings is inclu ed in Appendix E of the amendment report.
Pleas© choose one of the following:
Mo, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
Yes, I ish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)
C Myself- My telephone number (business hours):
or
C A spokesperson
Na e of spokesperson:
Postal
address:
I would p efer my hearing to be conducte in:
CD Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation)
OR
CD Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
o The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC ma be
o All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcri ts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and published as publ c records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment. T e
WAPC reco mendations are similarly published in a report on submissions and tabled in Parlia ent.
Note: Sub issions MUST e received b the ad ertised closing date, being close of
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will. NOT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning. a.gov.au; Website - http://www.planning. a.gov.au
BLACKBURNE
PROPERTY GROUP
19th April 2012
department of planning
Mr N Thomson
Secretary
Weste Australian Planning Commission
Locked Bag 2506
2 0 APR 2012
L
PERTH WA 6000
Dear Mr Neil Thomson,
ST QUENTINS APARTMENTS - STRATA PLAN 52198 - LOT 200
As Strata Manager for St Quentins Apartments, Lot 200, we have received a copy of your letter
of the 20tl1 March outlining the MRS Rationalisation of Stirling Highway.
reviewed by the Council of Owners of St Quentins Apartments. Issues have been identified to
reject the proposed increase in reservation area as presented in the attached submission.
The Strata Company, through the Council of Owners, agrees with the proposal to increase the
flow of traffic along Stirling Hwy but contests the proposal to increase the reservation
boundary (red) along Sti ling Road.
Should you have any queries, or wish to discuss this matter, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Se ior Strata Manager
For and On Behalf of the Owners of St Quentins Apartments
Tel: 08 9429 5731
Fax: 08 9729 5766
Email: paul.webb@bIackbume.com.au
1050 Hay Street, West Perth, Western Australia 6005 I PO Box 422, West Perth, Western Australia 6872
T +61 8 9429 5777 I F +61 8 9429 5766 I E general@blackburne.com.au I W www.blackburne.com.au
Blackburne Property Group Pty Ltd as trustee for Blackburne Property Group Unit Trust I ABN 75 741 338 514
Member of the Real Estate Institute of Western Australia I Licensee: Blackburne Property Group Pty Ltd
iDEPARTiviDA Or LANNING
! 2 o APR 2012
Form 41
Submission
FILE
OFFICE USE ONLY
il
Sufomlssio 14
To: Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
P
;
,
I
Name.
Postcode
Address . Ml ...it . J.?... Zllfrk WA.. HI.Bl.WM.,.
( tact phone number
Email address .
gKirl KoLluiU j ¦ &Ma
s Use headings or numbers to separate different topics and issues
e Include property addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
;
U
J k\
R1.
.
....
PKLf ivl Id htm
Op
fettLTi
.1
k OF
lLfvi ArM. ... A.M f.
in k iM in ...
turn o er to complete your submission
Please choose one of the foliowing:
m
Mo, do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
o The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may
Section 41 Amendmen (Substantial)
z 0 Al R 2012
Form 41
Submission
OFFICE USE ONLY
Submissio IS
To: Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
i
.
T?.*?
.
/
-
_
_i
.A/.
Address
...
//.
,.7rl..
Postcode
Email address ..
ga.
o Include ro erty addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
Submission
frf
Hea ing of submissions
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compulsory. Your
Further nformation on submissions and hearings is included in Appendix E of the amendment report.
Mo, I do not wi h to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
LJ Myself - My telephone number (business hours):
or
C A spokesperson
Name
of
spokesperson:
Postal address:
! I P blic (members from the general public may attend your presentation)
OR
I I Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
® The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be
Signature
Date...A. /:T
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will OT be considered.
SUBMISSION
Name: John Tiang Tong Tan
Address: 1/128 Forrest St (also known as 444 Stirling Hwy)
Peppermint Grove WA 6011
Contact phone: 93856708
Email: DiaDen88888@vahoo.com
SUBMISSION:
A) Great dama e to utility and alue of roperty. Street arkin con estion.
I do not support the proposed rationalization because it will render my double garage
unusable. Besides my property, there are six other adjoining villas, each with a
double garage, that will be similarly affected, making a total of 14 parking spaces that
will be lost.
There is no other space on the strata property that can replace these 14 spaces.
Owners will be forced to park on Forrest St or some other street, leading to greater
congestion on these streets.
There will be great damage to the value of these properties, far beyond the value of
the land resumed. Each villa will be changed from having "double-garage" parking to
street parking.
My estimate is that the value of each property will be diminished b at least a third if
the proposal is adopted, compared to if it is not.
B1 Other expenses will also rise.
Living expenses will also rise. For example, the cost of car insurance will rise as a
result of the cars being street parked instead of garaged.
Cl Less safety for residents, many of whom are seniors.
I am a senior, being over 60 years of age. Many other residents in the other six
affected villas appear more senior than me. Requiring residents to park in Forrest St,
which is quite dimly-lit, will result in less safety, especially at night.
D1 Considerable inconvenience.
There will be considerable everyday inconvenience. For example, residents
returning with groceries or other goods will have to carry them for up to 50 metres
between the street parking and the front door.
Currently, arbage bins are taken out through the rear. This will not be possible if the
rationalization scheme is implemented. They will have to be taken out through the
living room and the front door.
The strata development I am in was conceived with the idea that each villa would
have free access to the rear, which is why there is only a narrow walkway at their
front. It would be very difficult to move large goods, like white goods or furniture,
through the pathway at the front.
1
E) Inconsistent practices in the past
I am informed that the state government authority has had a road reserve of greater
than 30 metres since 1963. Yet, the strata property development I now live in was
approved and built in 1974. The Shire of Peppermint Grove informs me that at that
time, the plans would probably have been referred to the state authority and
approved by them, although they can find no record of this.
May I submit that I, as a property owner, should not be so severely punished as
would happen under the proposed scheme gi en that the 1974 plans were approved
by competent authorities.
Ft Resume the entire property if severely affected
May I also submit that for properties that are severely affected, such as mine would
be, the state consider resuming the entire property so I can buy somewhere else.
2
Form 41
Submission•'
*
Metro olitan Region Scheme Amendment 210/41
Rationalisat on of Stirling Highway Reservation
OFFICE use ONLY
Submissio 16
To: Secretary
Western Austral an Planning Commiss on
Locked Bag 2506
Perlh WA 6001
Name.
. \l\CA _L\ A .. .,..
tPLEAS&PRINTCLe RL j) V ' "
Address
..
¥}.ir.... .(a! t
.. Postco e
Email address..
Tips for completing a submission;
* Use headings or numbers to se arate different topics and issues
» Include pro erty ad resses and specific location descriptions where relevant
o Attach additional number d pages it you require more s ace to cornpieia your submission
Submission
reviewed by m self and the following issues have been identifie to reject the proposed increase
in reservation area.:
1, The increase reservation boundary (red) ould require St Quentins Apartments to be
demolishe ;
2. The St Quentins building as only recently built and met all local planning authority
requirements, including densify and appearance; a d
O Tk concept of establishing an ext a lane o Stirling d ill not alleviate traffic
congestion on Stirling H .
I, .i7.r'!! ?.. a rei wit the proposal to increase the flo of traffic along
Stirling H y but contests the proposal to increase the reservation boundary (red) along
Stirling Road.
Hear ng of subm ssions
Anyone who has ma e a written submission on the amendment may personally present the basis of t eir
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes'box is ticked. This is not compulsory. Your
written submission will be considered in determining the recommen ation for the proposed amendme t
Further information on sub ssions and hearings is included in Appendix E of the a endment report,
m
Mo, I do not wish to spea at the hearings. (P lease go to the bottom of the for and sign)
OR
D Yes, I wish to speak at t e hearings. (Please complete the following details)
I will be represe ted by:
Myself- My telephone number (business hours):
or
C A spokesperson
Name of spo esperson:
Postal address:
S would prefer my hearing to be conducted in:
[ Public ( e bers from the general public ay attend your presentation)
OR
Pri ate (onl t e people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
The WAPC Is subject to the F eedom of Informat on Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC a be
su ject to applications for access under the act.
o In the cours of the WAPC assessing submissions, or a ing its report on these submissions, copies of your
sub ission or the substance of that submission, ay be disclosed to third parties.
tabled in Parliament and publishe as public records should the Governor approve the propose amendment. The
WAPC recommendations are similarl ublished in a report on submissions and tabled in Parliament
To be signedby personfs) making the subm ssion
0
Signature
..
.
Zo'
Date
Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertise closing ate,.being close of
business (Spjti) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will NOT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone-(08) 6551 SOD; Fax-(OS) 6551 9001; Email - (nrs@plannlng.v/a,gov.au; Wsbsite- tlpVAwM.planning.wa.gov.au
Section 41 Amendment (Subs antial)
Form 41
Submission
ationalisation of Stirling Highw y Reservation
OFFICE USe ONLY
To: Secretary
Submissio 17
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
/t (- A
Name..
Address
;
Postcode
Email ad ress...:..'.
o Use headings or numbers to separat different topics and Issues
° include pro erty addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
« Attac additional numbered ages if you r quire mo e space to complete your submission
Submission
The MRS amen ment 1210/41 Rationalisation of Stirling Highway Reservation has been
reviewed by myself and the follo ing issues have been identified to reject the proposed increase
i reservation area.:
1. The increased reservation boundaiy (red) would require St Quentins Apartments to be
demolishe ;
3. The concept of establishing an ext a lane on Stirling R ill not alleviate traffic
congestion on Stirling H y. I,
I, ;
agree with t e proposal to increase the flow of traffic along
Stirling H y but contests the proposal to increase the reservation boundaiy (red) along
Stirling Road.
Hear ng of submissions
An one who as made a written submission o the amen ment may personally present the basis of their
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compuleoiry. Your
written sub ission will be consi ered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment
hether you nominate to spea at the earings or not.
Further information on submissions an hearings is inclu ed in Appendix E of the endment report.
Please choose on© of the following:
m
Mo, I do not wis to speak at t e hearings. (P tease go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
Q Yes, I wish to spea at the hearings. (Please complete the following etails)
S will be represente by:
Myseif ~ My telephone num ber (busi ness hours):
or
iZ] A spokesperson
Postal
address:
Public (me be s from the general public may atten yo r presentation)
OR
I I Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
permitte to attend)
You sho ld be aware that:
» The WAPC Is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be
o !n the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
o All hearings are recorded and transcribe . The transcripts of all hearings, along ith all written submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the propose amen ment. The
WAPC recom en ations are similarly ublished in a report on sub issions and tabled In Parliament
To be si ned bv aersonfs) making the submission
Signature
/-
Date
/v/
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will NOT be consi ered.
Contacts: Telephone-(08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6561 9001; Ema l-mra@planntng.wa,gov.Bu; Website-Mip:/AwAv.plann!ng.wa.gov,au
2_no f\
Form 41
2 APR 2012
Submission
Metropolitan Region Scheme Am ndment 1210/
j FILE P S i 0*
Rationalisation of Stirli g Highway Reservation
OFFICE USE ONLY
Submissito 18
To: Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
p
Name
..#
7 (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)
Address ... .< l ..
#...
j
.
r.c. .. Postcode .. .< .0/./
Contact phone number Email address .. .Q/fi }
Submission
/ .Zfe
/<?r rJ/ A/T u yp
csv!?..
tf/Ct.... /
..m
&T
....
•: j j.irtt.... T rf.t. s .p&o./?.QS>fi/v.... is .rr rt ... /«. w.
J/PC. cL. <2.Rq a/.Q. . .rf/V.....-£f.....WA
/Tim /.h
§>
HtH.....
.y:.
Sj/.e . ?..
Pi £&££.. EfeoM Pi . .../V.. ~....PZ.Hi....
/ c...
.m?/./iHHP.
5/ <5 //..... .
'3. .P.... .o/
.....
* JZ Oo.. Mp/c. .. (J.a/vr...... Hi.... HSpem. S/9.H.
/£>.....&.O.... £(-/££>.£>...
'(
urn over to complete your submission
M©, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
1 will be represented by:
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
I would p efer my hea ing to be conducted in:
OR
° The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be
9 In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
® All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with ail written submissions, are
To be si ned b person(s) making the submission
Signature .. 4.: .
Date .T??Q
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will OT be conside ed.
EJ No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
1 will be represented by:
or
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
1 would prefe m hearing to be conducted in:
E Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation)
OR
° The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of/nfo/ /r?af/o/?Acf /992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may b
To e sipjned by personfs) makiinei the submission
Signature
Date
E? D&( <~f£-ry
./
)..P.6...
> 7 < or7~ss
Note: Submissions IVIUST be received b the advertised closing date, eing close of
business (Spm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will OT be consi e e .
1 I APR 2012
FILE ili lazfyf
Form 41
Submission
Rationalisation of Stirling Hig way Rese vation
OFFICE use ONLY
Submission 19
To: Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth W 6001
cnfZ-£ r <- - £( 1 1? i/' W' Ts 7 L
Name
0
Address .. ! ... f. . . Postcode ..
x a i_
o S
06
'£)t5 ¦>
c
Email address . ... J: r. 7/....
Tips for complet ng a submission:
• se headings or numbers to e arat different topics and Issues
a Includ property address s and s ecific location descriptions where relevant
» Attach additional numbered pages if you require mo space to complete your submission
Sub ission
reviewed by myself and the follo ing issues have been i entified to reject the proposed increas
in reservation area,:
1. The increased reservation boundai (red) would require St Quentins A artments to be
demolished;
2. T e St Quentins building was only recently built and et all local planning authorit
requirements, including density and appearanc ; and
3. The concept of establishing an extra lane on Stirling Rd ill not alleviate traffic
congestion on Stirling H y.
I, .'rr.' . .! ... f. f .' V/! P agree with the proposal to increase the flow of traffic along
Stirling H y but contest the proposal to increase the reservation boundaiy (red) along
Stirling Road.
L
s
01
Anyone who has made a written submission on the amen ment may personally present the basis of their
submission to a sub-committe of the WAPC if the below Yes box is ticke . This is not compulsory. Your
written submission will e consi ered in determining the recom endation for the roposed amendment
whether you nominate to spea at the hearings or not.
Furt er information on submissions an hearings is included in Appen ix E of the amendment report.
Mo, I do not wish to spea at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
O Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)
O M self - My telephone number ( usiness hours):
or
C A spokesperson
Name of spokesperson
Postal a dress:
Public (me bers fro the general publ c may attend your presentation)
OR
C Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
permitte to attend)
You should be aware t at:
o The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions ade to the WAPC ay be
subject to applications for access nder the act.
e In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or aking its report on these submissions, copies of your
sub ission or the substance of that sub ission, may be disclosed to third parties.
» All hearings are recorded and transcribe . The transcripts of all earings, along wit all written submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the propose a endment. T e
WAPC recommendations are similarly publis ed in a report on sub issions and tabled In Parliament
To be signed by persortfsl makin the submission
Signature f.... P.i . Jf. S! :?.B..
(
c
VT
f-J
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 20'12. Late submissions will NOT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@ptannlng. a.gov.au; Website-http://www.plannlng.W3.gov.au
Western
Australian
\m£ Planning
w Commission
Enquiries: Mr John O'Hurley (6551 9187)
Properly Ref: 169E; CLAREMONT
WAPC Ref: 809-2-1-91 Pt 2 (RLS/0248)
,
l
"
ik
.M.k , fiW
to
Freind Investments Pty Ltd
PO Box 716
4
)A
l2 '
CLAREMONT WA 6910
Dear Sir/Madam
Re Property: Lot 53 ( Unit 202 / 40) St Quentin Av, Claremont
Metropolitan Region Sc eme Proposed Amendment 1210/41
Rationalisation of Stirling Hi hway Reservation
Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS).
The amendment proposes to increase the regional reservation over the above
property.
A sketch plan showing the existing reservation boundary (green) and the proposed
increased reservation boundary (red) is attached for your consideration.
(generally less than 40 metres) between Ham den Road/Broadway, Nedlands and Queen
Postal address: Locked Bag 2506 Perth WA Street address: 140 William Street Per h WA 6000
v/a.gov.au
corporate@plannin .wa.gov.au wwnv.planning.wa.gov.au
ABN 35 482 341 493
2 ' APR 2012
Form 41
Submission
filg
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submissio 20
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
f
/
} (PLEASE PRIN GLEARLY)
Address .. S.
c .H J O.. . A\l
Postcode <5..C?.\..Q.
< 2. cxt e yno v
Contact phone number Email address
¦SDc eT
T/ s for completing a submission:
Lo d • Li v/
o L/se headings or numbers to se arate different topics and issues
« Include property addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
Submission
l?.
g£r£...
:M.e.
.
A7,
id..... .. (.../.&( ijc'/ idi . iod. Q.. .&??..
i
/m
i....
- A MMerfd
(j)... ffli ffe/.. Mk . .. Mdk.
..
dA
...
./j
.
r
..
i...
.. .m... sAd/M dc/...
dr?yd
dkd.,..
..id..iteft?*?...ZTf.trl.AS ?..$£.;
& . .. d/ A. ... . dfj/Ad.f.. A / A
sd-¦ diiZ iv)--- jt/i..ifdd y.. Ay/.tf
,
/ fj..
...
..u/fl/i.d&u . ..ii?.. AM.......Ad .r.
e.i/?/£... ' Af if // ////a 7
d...A7.L.£i/t. .a.:p.7 id hA. dJu /ij. •
Uf
/p/?.
Anyone who has made a written sub ission on the amendment may personally present the basis of their
OR
or
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
Signature
.-./.
.
Date
( / (9
Note: Submissions
lissic
MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of
Our Ref: FTA2162
South West Aboriginal
Land & Sea Council
24 April 2012
Mr Neil Thomson
Acting Secretary
; M iNC
? 7 APR
Locked Bag 2506
PERTH WA 6000
FILL
lsI o 2
Dear Neil
METROPOLITAN REGION SCHE E PROPOSED AMENDME T - 1210/41
The South West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council (SWALSC) is the registered native
title representative body for the claimants the Whadjuk People (WAD242/2011).
The SWALSC on behalf of its clients will table this matter at the next Working Party
Meeting (WPM) on 23 and 24 May 2012 and obtain their instructions and submission.
Subject to their instructions, the SWALSC reserves the right under the Aboriginal
Heritage Act 1972 (WA) and MOD with the WAPC to request Aboriginal Heritage
„ survey work.
The SWALSC will be in a position to advise shortly after the WPM.
If you wish to discuss this matter further, please contact me.
Yours sincerely,
Carolyn Fennelle
Legal Officer
South West Aboriginal Land & Sea Council
Telephone: 9358 7400 • 1800 617 617 • Facsimilie: 9358 7499
1490 Albany Highway, Cannington • PO Box 585 Cannington, WA 6987
w vw.noongar.org.au
ICN 3832
ABN 42 485 265 673
Addition to
Submission 21
Your Ref: 809-2-912-5 Pt2
Our Ref: DOC2012/06023; FTA2162
South West Aboriginal
Land & Sea Council
13 July 2012
Mr Neil Thomson
Acting Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
PERTH WA 6000
Dear Neil
METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME PROPOSED AMENDMENT 1210/41
title representative body for the claimants the Whadjuk People (W D242/2011).
The SWA SC on behalf of our clients were to table this matter at a recent Working
Party Meeting (WPM) ut due to a death in the community the WPM was cancelled.
Subject to the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) (AHA) and the MOU the SWALSC
has with the WAPC we reserve the right to request Aboriginal Heritage survey work
and/or monitors as requested for any clearance work.
Yours sincerel .
Carolyn Fennelle
Legal Officer
South West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council
Telephone: 9358 7400 • 1800 617 617 » Facsimilie: 9358 7499
1490 Albany Hig way, Canninglon • PO Box 585 Cannington, WA 6987
',w v, noorig3r.org.au
ICN3832
ABN 2 85 265 673
ddition to
Submissio 21
Your Ref: 809-2-1-91 Ft 2 (RLS/0275)
Our Ref: FTA2162: DOC2012/08039
South West Abori ginal
Land & Sea Council
7 September 2012
Mr Neil Thomson
Acting Secretary
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNI G
Locked Bag 2506
1 0 SEP 2012
PERTH WA 6000
Dear Neil
FILE L
METROPOLITAN REGION SCHE E PROPOSED A ENDMENT 1210/41
RATIONALISATION OF STIRLING HIGHWAY RESERVATION major amendment
title representative body for the Whadjuk People (WAD242/2011).
On behalf of its clients, SWALSC tabled this matter at the Working Party Meeting
(WPM) held on 22 and 23 August 2012 and obtained their instructions and submission.
We understand that the purpose of the Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment
(MRS) 1210/41 is to rationalise the Primary Regional Roads reservation in the MRS
which presently exists over Stirling Highway, as shown on Figure 1 of the Amendment
Report.
Subject to the Aboriginal Heritage Act 1972 (WA) (AHA) and the MOU the SWALSC
has with the WAPC, we are instructed by our clients to request that monitors are
present for commencement of works.
Where the proximity of the realignment is to a registered site the necessity for s 18
clearances may be required.
Yours sincerely,
Carolyn Fennelle
Legal Officer
South West Aboriginal Land & Sea Council
Telephone: 9358 7400 • 1800 617 617 • Facsimilie: 9358 7499
1490 Albany Highway, Cannington • PO Box 585 Cannington, WA 6987
www.noongar.org.au
ICN 3832
ABN 42 485 265 673
0 2 ft'iAY 2012
Form 41
tc 02L1S
Submission
Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendmen 1210/41
Rationalisation of Stirling Highway Rese vation
OFFICE USE ONLY
8°°= -
To: Secretary
'=3
Submission 22
Locked Bag 2506
Perth 6001
Sf*r*** *«
Address
...
...
Postcode
j 1
....7
. f.. 1*.... (.It.®. Q.. Email address .7 T
Tips Tor completing a submission:
o Use headings or numbers to se arate ifferent topics and issues
° Include property addresses and specific location descriptions where rel vant
° Attach additional numbered ages if you require more space to compl te your submis ion
Submission
/)(faf<k
a.
/
s* hot
reviewed by myself and the following issues have been identified to reject the proposed increase
1. The increased reservation boundaty (red) would require St Quentins Apartments to be
de olished;
2. The St Quentins building was only recently built and et all local planning authority
congestion on Stirlin Hwy.
Anyone who as made a written submission on the amendment may personall present the basis of their
submission to a sub-committee ofthe WAPC if the below 'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compulsory. Your
written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amen ment
whet er you nominate to speak at the hearings or not.
Further information on submissions and hearings is included in A pendix E ofthe amendment report.
Wo, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (P lease go to the botto m of the form and sign)
OR
Y©s, 1 wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)
or
CD A spokesperson
Postal
address:
Public (me bers from the general publ ic may attend your resentation)
OR
ermitted to attend)
s All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approv the proposed amendment. The
To be si ned by person(s) aking the submission
I, C/Mrjrctf
Sign
t
r
Date
Contacls: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Email - mrs@planning.wa.gov.au,' ebsite - htlp://www.planning. a. ov.au
DCPARTMENT OF PLANNING
o 2 JUL 2012
cnf ilLSIa h!?
Form 41
Submission
Addition to
To: Secretary
Western A stralian Planning Commission
Submission 22
Locked Bag 2506
Perth A 6001
Address .3.
Postcode ...fe.Q.l.Q,
Contact phone number 3.iLri. Entail address jiCCl. . r.LL(?.)r.CLtt
• Use h adings or numbers to separat different topics and Issu s
¦ Include property addresses and s ecific location descriptions wh re r levant
• Attac additional numbered pages if you r quir more pa to complete your submi sion
Submission
reviewed by m self and the follo in issues have been identified to rejec the roposed increase
2.
demolished;
The St Quentins building as only recently built and met all local planning authorit
requirements, including density and a pearance; and
3.
The concept of establishing an extra lane on Stirling
will not alleviate traffic
congestion on Stirling Hw .
? S\Vvu9 ev\
,
.LL .S :gree witH the proposal to increase the flo of traffic along
Stirling H y but contests the propos l to increase the reservation boundary (red) along
Stirling Road.
Hr
i_
r
Hu ;
Oujr\&r cs\ ?rQ|R/rh uHr % Si; U ut 401
40 (SI - (Suauim fWo u j2
Ct O vio rt
W A OOlD
Section 41 Amendment (Substantia!)
Form 41
G 3 MAY 2012
Su mission
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 23
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name .... ,
I
? H '
E V0,
trLtMot rKIIM I ULtAKLY)
Address .
J .. i>. .. H. .... (v£ P.Pr' 1. /YTl£.postcode 3
Contact phone number. , ft
Email address ..
® Use headings or nu bers to separate different topics and issues
* Include property addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
Submission ° Attach add'tional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
j
f).li
p.C.....G)
.
>.
... O. ... :
I..
?. ;X
....
t\
.
t
.
.C.
0 No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
• All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
Signature
To The Western Australian Planning Commission.
MRS Amendment 1210/ l.
Property Ref: 491E FREMANTLE
WAPC REF: 809-2-1-91 PT 2 (RLS/0248)
Re Property 261a Queen Victoria Street, North Fremantle., 6159
AN APPEAL AGAINST THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT.
My husband and I own a property at 261A Queen Victoria Street comprising of a
small town house and a Commercial Kitchen both of which are rented out. The
value of these will be drastically reduced by the proposals currently under
review. In fact to all intents and purposes they will be rendered worthless.
The reason is a very simple one, parking.
When the various properties on the 261A block were built a condition of the
planning permission was that they would have their own parking. This was an
essential requirement because there is no on street parking available adjoining
the block. The only street in which parking is allowed (Jackson Street) is
inadequate even for current requirements and is full at all times.
The current proposal ignores the council's own ruling by completely removing
the very parking on which they sensibly insisted in the first place. No one would
ever buy or rent a house where there was zero parking and so the buildings
would very likely become derelict.
We would therfore be forced to pursue the council for the entire March 2012
value of our property plus appreciation. As no doubt would everybody else
affected.
On a separate issue the proposal also actually takes a chunk out of our Kitchen
Building which would almost certainly mean the whole thing would have to be
demolished anyway.
Beyond the very practical financial threat we are now under, there is the equally
distressing social and cultural one. North Fremantle has long been blighted by
being cut off by major roads but it has recently begun to really get back on it's
feet. Queen Victoria Street is it s heart and we now have thriving shops, pubs and
cafes for the first time in decades. We feel this proposal could very well wipe out
completely all that has been achieved. Demolishing at least one business and
ruining others.
Heritage buildings and walls would also have to be demolished. This would be a
crime as so much of Perth and Fremantle s history and culture has already been
lost. Our own property is bounded on one side by a heritage listed wall,
protected under council guidelines which would have to be destroyed.
PTO.
1
And for what? The traffic is not heavy on Queen Victoria Street we drive it every
day and are never held up by buses. The extra bus lane suggested is entirely
unnecessary.
With respect this is a ridiculous idea to which we as residents object in the
strongest possible terms and which we will vigorously resist.
In the mean time we are cursed with the phenomenon of planning blight' in as
much as nobody can sell their property while the procedure progresses. This is
not only ruinous to some residents who depend on their properties for their
Superannuation but puts an immediate brake on all that has been happening to
make North Fremantle an attractive town once more.
Queen Victoria Street and Jackson Street are not the Stirling Highway. Whatever
may be the merits of speeding traffic on the main arteries servicing Perth (and
they are questionable) they should not be allowed to threaten our thriving local
community. We appeal to the W.A.P.C to cancel it s proposals immediately and
remove this distressing threat which has darkened the lives of all those affected.
Yours sincerely
Sophie Elton.
2
Submission 24
Government of Western Australia
Department of Wlines and Petroleum
Your ref: 809-2-1-91 Pt 2 (RLS/0248)
Our ref: A1763/200801
Enquiries: Colin Strickland - Ph 08 9222 3139
Email: colin.strickland@dmp.wa.gov.au
Mr Neil Thompson
Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
PERTH WA 6000
Dear Mr Thompson
METROPOLITAN REGIO SCHEME PROPOSED E D E T 1210/41
R TION LISATION OF STIRLING HIGHW Y RESERVATION
Thank you for your letter dated 20 March 2012 inviting comment on the above
MRS amendment.
The Geological Survey of Western Australia has assessed this proposal, on
behalf of the Department of Mines and Petroleum with respect to access to
mineral and petroleum resources, geothermal energy and basic raw materials
and has no comment to make in this regard.
Yours sincerely
Rick Rogerson
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
GEOLOGICAL SURVEY OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
May 2012
003560.colin.Strickland.docx - Perth
Release Classification: - For Public Release
Mineral House 100 Plain Street East Perth Western Australia 6004
Telephone +61 8 9222 3333 Facsimile +61 8 9222 3862
www.dmp.wa.gov.au
www.wa.gov.au
ABN 69 410 335 356
Form 41
Submission
OFFICE USE ONLY
~
To:
Secretary
™
'
1
„
Western Australian Planning Commission StUiEMIfllSSIOli l 25
Locked Bag 2506
Perth
Name
WA
...
6001
.
.BfAT...Qtkk..
Address .r /p/. .... . L//C /XSA/A.S. ....tfiAMAA. TAt- Postcode (?.ISA\.
Email address . i..A. . . aJ.W . C A
« Use headings or nu bers to se arate different topics and issues
o Include property addresses and specific location descri tions where relevant
® Attach additional numbered pages if you require more s ace to complete your submission
Submission
&£> T tf £<( ... /-AAATS.... .(a). .. (z .
M 4WWGS.
A AfjAA
Pa
...£&v.T
o
<3MPjt£7T~
W/v E&i A - Cbf f
W/ j
i.
.
.
if7
it
t
//
OR
[ Myself- My telephone number (business hours):
or
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
I would prefe my hearing to be conducted in:
OR
a In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
Signature
Date ... .3.0.. A/3/0...
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email - mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://www.planning.wa.gov.au
1. PROPERTY
261A Queen Victoria St North Fremantle being Lot 100 comprising Strata
Lots 1,2,3,4,5,6 and Common Property Lots 7,8,9 on Strata Plan 9334.
Affected directly by increase in land required by MRS for road purposes are
Strata Lots 1, CP lot 7 and parking for Strata Lots 1.2.3.4.
2. BACKGROUND
Land was purchased from C of E in 1976 including church (built 1895) and
church hall (built 1905) for purpose of converting buildings to residences
with additional development of four residential townhouses (built 1979)
Granny flat (built 1990) was added to our church house and a commercial
catering kitchen (built 2001) was added to Strata Lot 1.
Increase in constructed plot ratio to .64 equivalent to R code density R60 (up
from gazetted R25) was granted by Fremantle City Council as reward for
preserving heritage building
This would conform to MRS stated aim of density increase adjacent to
highway.
The intention of development was to provide family and extensions with
financial security. All work was designed and hands-on-built by Bob Gare
as architect with family help.
Over time, four generations of Gare family were accommodated together with
family industry of artist studio and exhibitions, architects office, music band
management and practice, Catering Kitchen and weddings for family and
friends.
3. OBJECTIONS
The proposal as shown on attached drawing 1 virtually demolishes our
daughter s catering kitchen SL1 and removes all on site parking,
(required by local authority) thus severely affecting viability and value of
those units. The parking situation is further exacerbated by the fact that
most houses in Jackson St have only street parking.
Adjacent Lot 1, 261 to 267 Queen Victoria St comprising five connected
heritage listed double storey shops would have to be demolished by the
proposal. See attached drawing 2.
Both properties front Queen Victoria St (not Stirling Highway) so the
proposal is a very considerable affront to the integrity and gateway to the old
town of North Fremantle. The town has in the last few years been
rejuvenated after being depressed for years by Stirling Highway to Stirling
Bridge cutting off the large part of its residential population. It would be a
shame if any of this recent enlivenment were to be eroded in any way. It
should also be noted that the bus lane would remove the stairs serving
church access since 1895 and Jackson St. turning circle would demolish a
section of convict built and original church limestone walls.
4. SUGGESTIONS
At City of Fremantle Library, public information display, we gathered from
John O'Hurley of WAPC that the offending impositions on our and
neighbour s property were due to a proposed short bus lane up to the
Jackson St traffic light/cross walk in Queen Victoria St and a cul-d-sac
turning circle associated with the closure of the Jackson St connection to
Queen Victoria St/Stirling Hwy.
Because of its effect on the heritage shops Lot 1 and our Lot 100 , local
indigenous bush frontage and the fact that a bus stop is provided close by in
Queen Victoria St, it seems this short bus lane, here, could be deleted.
Jackson St, down to its closure from Jewell Pde ser es only four properties,
so the requirement of a full cul.de.sac turning circle seems to be an over kill'
Given that rubbish collection by truck could be jointly arranged at the Jewell
Pde Tee Junction. Smaller vehicles could be provided with a hammer head
solution at the dead end even using the town house crossover as many do
now.
5. PERSONAL
My wife and I are now self funded retirees in our 70's without
Superannuation and with rents from SL2 & 4 being insufficient to sustain us
in our old age, so it is our intention to sell these units, now, to make good.
Unfortunately (and this must apply to others in the same situation), with the
MRS proposal over our heads, the prospect of a satisfactory sale is severely
diminished.
SUBMISSION 25
TABLED AT the HEARINGS 29/10/13
JEWELL PDE
-l
>
03
I-
m
o
>
i
JACKSON ST
m
x
m
Sx
X 03
OS
.
CO
XO
OZ
M
W cn
ORIGINAL
CHURCH HALL
L. STOE
2 SUPPER ROOM
3 EXTERNAL TOILETS
4 PUBLIC & D NCEFLOOR
REDEVELOPMENT
CHURCH
5 VESTRY
SANCTURY
7 CHIOR
8 N VE
9 ENTRY LOBBY
1 CHURCH HALL HOUSE
2 CHURCH HOUSE
3 TOWNHOUSE
4 CATERING KITCHEN
ST
MARYS REDEVELOPED
2S1a QU EN VIC ORIA ST NORTH FREMANTLE
gCflON 6-6
JEVfll FOE EVATION
LEVEL 1 P AN
MJjQliSS
1 KlICfet/llVING
2 VERA W-I _ _
3 CT'rD DRi G 9 H fWGESCPS
EXTERNAL S R C 10 fWIVE'BLEH
5 OSmRKJMGBCiRS
6 I/S IWKIIG 2 C RS
11 KLIVERI58,DE F H12 SMJf UFT IGBBi
BCDaROOM
14 REFRIDGERATION MOOS
15 DIN ENQGQJRE
1 'mAifi
2 BS HSHR imrWC 5 KITCHEN 12 BATH SHR Ri C 19 BUILT-IN FRIG
3 BEDROOM 6 B JHSfllDRi WI 13 FTOOtA TERRADE 20£W \\C CHANGERM
7 VERANONH 14 VBWDAH 21 COOKING WISH UP
8 CTYD DOTING AREA 15-S ORE GCN DOTING 22 B LCONY
9 G RDEN 16 GRANNY R J CT YD Z3 LOOK CUT
10 ONE C R B1 K 17 TWO CAR BARK
IH 5 FGZANNE 5DR03M L
6 MEZZANINE SHR WC 9 STAIR VOID
7 VOID
Section 41 Amen ment (Substantial)
For 41
Submissio
Rationalisation of Stirling Highw y Reservation
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 26
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
(PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) V.
/
Address 2- . 1.i.cY...£.e.. >DALH....E«\..ft*TLecT«?fp0StC0de.,.&,l.5 .
Contact phone number .0 j.
.. B. . i,
L T. Email address
® Use headings or numbers to se arate different topics and issues
® Include property addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
• Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
.S .tr....fs: 7 - .c 4.(5 <. P
.j.. v!.1 O. ;L 55c X .fc...
O
i will be represente by:
o
A spokesperson
Name of spokesperson:../? ' .A. .Cf .. . ,C>! . . /Y. A' .A ?. XXX. Yr..
Contact telephone number (business hours):.Q.Lf. 1.S. Aj iA{.. .. J. fA
Postal address: . .Yr!.Y. ?.£?: ?.AK.©i... AV?.f.LC.Q.(Y.9. f.A
I would refer my hea ing to be conducte in:
O
To be s ned by person(s) making the submission
Signature ...
..
). Date A.ifl.
....Xrt ?..I
Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing ate, being close of
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://www.planning. a.gov.au
CONPECPTYLTD
26 TWEEDDALE RO,
APPLECROSS W.A.A 6153
Ist OF MAY 2012
TO: NEIL THOMSON
SECRETARY-WAPC
LOCKED BAG 2506,
PERTH W.A.
i
0 4 MAY 2012
[FiiF
Dear Sir,
RE: OBIECTION TO PROPOSED WIDENING AND TRUNCATION OF 2.5 & 8
METRES OF PROPERTY LOCATED AT 187 STIRLING HWY. NEDLANDS W.A.
Thank you for your letter dated the 20th of March 2012,
We The Owners Rocco A. & Maria Nardone (for Conpec P/L], would like to
request a mutually agreed site visit for discussion to be made in relation to the
proposed WAPC 2.5metre widening and 8 metre truncation to the above
mentioned property.
Please note there is a two storey building at this site with two tenancies, the top
floor is occupied by Mobile Connections which has direct access from the rear of
the car park.
The ground floor is occupied by a health beauty clinic (Skyn) which has direct
access from the front corner (were the proposed 8 meter truncation is to be
done). This firm employs approx. 6 employees and operates 6 days a week, with
a high volume of clients getting access from the only access point at the front.
The objection we present is on the ground of duty of care to disabled people
access and the safety hazard associated with the proposed works to disabled
people were access to the premises, including disabled car bays, is only available
from the front access way (Facing Stirling Hwy).
On these grounds I would like to ask you to organize a site visit by one of your
authorized representative with my self Rocco A. Nardone.
Could you please inform the undersigned of a date and time to meet, should you
have any further queries, please feel free to call Rocco Nardone, on 0418 917
678.
Please note I will not be available for an on site visit any time between the 25th of
July to the 30th of August 2012.
Kind Regards,
H /h.
Rocco A. Nardone
(Owner/Director]
for road purposes
No. 187 (Lot 76) Stirling Highway, Nedlands
subject to survey
Extract of proposed changes: plan number 1.7145 ( 84-b )
A.
GOVERMMEMT OF
WESTERN AUSTRALIA
i
3 Western
i Australian
JL4 Planning
Proposed reser e boundary
1 Commission
ned8 .dgn
09 Aug 2011
Produced by Mapping & GeoSpatial Data Branch, Department of Planning. Penh WA
On behalf of the Weste AustraJian Planning Commission.
Base infor ation supplied by Weste AustraJian Land Information Authority LI 430-2009-4
Property boundary
Scale 1:400
0
8
metres
Western
Australian
Planning
Commission
Mr John O Hurley (6551 9187)
Enquiries:
Property Ref: 84B, Nedlands
809-2-1-91 Pt 2 (RLS/0173)
WAPC Ref:
Conpec Pty Ltd
26 Tweeddale Rd
APPLECROSS WA 6153
Dear Sir/Madam
Re Property: Lot 76 (Mo. 187) Stirling Hwy, Nedlands
metre wide 'Primary Regional Roads' reserve, placed in 1963 and larger than necessary.
The amendment propos s to educe the regional res rvation over the above property.
corporate@plannin .wa.gov.au www.planning.wa.gov.au
ABN 35 482 341 493
This system has been optimised for IE browsers version 5.0 and above
© 2004 Copyright RP Data Ltd, PSMA Australia Ltd, Local, State, Commonwealth Govt. All rights reser ed. No
reproduction, distribution, or transmission of the copyrighted materials at this site is permitted. The information
provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
il hursday, September 9ih 2004
2/187 STIRLING HWY, EDLANDS, 6009
UBD Wo PER17, E16 Map Wo:
Photo Date: September, 2001
Transfer
o: Issue: 0306
LA: 56F IMED NDS
Zoning VGO Map:
rea: 125 M (DOLA Approx)
Sale 0 18/11/98
Multi-Sale: No
Vol/Fol: 2149/238
Certificate of Title 2149/238
Owner Code
Land U e: MISCELL EOUS
Prop Class:
Prop Use:
RPD: jLOT 2 S035363
Owner: CONPEC PTY LTD
+2/187 STIRLING HWY
EDLANDS
WA 6009
Phono
Print
Map Record
Previous Next
Find fi Browse;
This system has been optimised for IE browsers version 5.0 and abo e
© 2004 Copyright RP Data Ltd, Local, State, Commonwealth Govt. All rights reser ed. No reproduction,
distribution, or transmission of the copyrighted materials at this site is permitted. The information provided is
deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
\ I
fr
AtX
'.-t- i':'
•-_ >-• ¦_
H
.M
I • , U / i
16 OcroB -20)3
OCGUpj £> By
SKy
HYDRAULIC NOTES:
SLSffi1?!! 0 SAT'SF'' RELEVANT STANDARDS AND
MATERIALS ARE TO 0E APPROVE3D FOR USE WITH N
AUSTRALIA.
EXACT LOCATION OF SERVICES CONNECTIONS TO BE COS BY
ShOPFITTER AND CONTRACTOR
rS 10''10( 7HE PLANS HWE been TAKE FROM
AVAIL BLE RECORDS. CONTRACTOR TO VERIFY EXACT
OCATION ND DEPTH OF SERVICES ON SITE.
ENSURE TH T FA S IN FLOOR SUIT NE AMD/OR EXISTING
H.OOR ASTES
HOT ATER LOCATION TBA BY CONTRACTOR. HOT WATER
SUPPLY REQUIRED
o
o2
- ¦ Ki
_¦ WHT H £ 3 / F(XJD lEJiVIGr 9
w«U'a)auuii cr
==ssasa=as»,
<iWflvb( rE3in!mn3W.MK5iivy:wHfwiw . w/w.
o-Awiwiusio. ajiB'aB 1
~g ?AtmucimAi
I PORT
T;
nt jm w;»iaenrr
wnj.i>iyc«.>v»iOT*TM3.«w»»MMfa>uma
;ww.i
imcMWlKAUlWWMl
oeM
FINIS ES, USHTINQAK'D ECUlPMENT
VM Hir/cor.xnai i w.hi io w w .- , ALLPURNITURE,
ORDERS ARE TO DEPLACED V.TTHIN SEVEN DAYS OF
CON CT FINALISATION ITHTTt CLIENT, TO ENSURE
STOCK IS AVAIAOLG. PLE SE NOTE THAT SOf E STOCK
oe sbalbervceb
I BpiS M\Y H VE CGLIVE Y LEAD TCvES |M EXCESS 0F8
V -KS, CONTR CTO TO ENSURE LEAD TIM S /JJGN WITH
TNE PROJEC SCHEDLIE, AND TO NOTIFY D CCR
COhaULT WTWirHNTHE SE EN CAY ORDERI G PERIOD I twJionrn '
OF ANY DISCREPENCIGO. CONTRACTOR TO PROVIDE
E IDENCE OF CRD ISTO DECOR CONSULT NT ALSO
WHIN THE SEVEN DAYTIVEFR VE,
SKYN
187 STIRLING HVVY
NEDLANDS WA 6009
fon CATHERINE LEE
HYDRAULIC LAYOUT
TJB.IIJIWUC III,
tywwiw icfiiini
5703 To/osffloia
KC Isp- T neg!A3
ortehapdinacomsu
ru-
r-':A
•' v! „o L; - f
_ 2l< \
_1
_.
F.-Tiil 'i1:
' |r ! i'
iliiil T
iTiii.nn .
[ re
vJtJrT i
REAR elevation
L \ AaVW v
e> i'L
„
0
.£n
t»
f t -
ELEVATfcN FROM STIRLING HIGHWAY
ty i|\MrA)-rfey
fJO-r - o SCjALi?
-/
,4
; •{
»i
/
vi
"H
I
SUBMISSION 26
TABLED AT THE HEARINGS 16/10/13
r CITY OF NEDLANDS j
' I DEVELOPMENT APPLICATION DATEDj
¦ APPROVED
I coo
o
a .
SUBJECT TO THE ENDORSEMENTS HEREON AND ,
COMPLIANCE WITH. THE CONDITION'S OF APPROVAL ]
TO COMMENCE DE ELOPMENT.
f?
S FILE REF:
45-70
\ '
OFPSgt'-I WK Itallrluy l-a
-
. i/ i
o\
-
y£s>'
DATE APPRO ED:...,.
ai3iS WiS_AI®l30t!W=-D3ESHJ9TNSTSBJ E A- BUILDING .LICENSE
_ . i£fC-
jo.ll
•-cyy g7
\
Jx5
S W»>kx'|-2lo>iaL& \ ®
i-tL ioo
w
- |t '
i
.6 ouNt> Floor. '
2 65 5/M.'
4-
GFL 8-00
FFL 1T20
: ' 1 T
' .|
\L
\
.d\
-?¦
'Z
2
A pV°v l\in acc Bte cs with the
\\
Local ®ov!arnnwv liscellaneous
;Provi iaa§)\Ao 60.QWs page
Fbrra part oQftj?f.l'd 2?icence No.
W
-
¦
ulldlng Services
' OF NEDLANDS
-
¦¦"f
ll ® |o-lo • .
5
k_;4
\
. Lj/iclL
A0
1
\
'd
45-7 0
.6?
iL troSJffVi. '-
\Q
'
tC/vfi C oS ol d_r
>!,
SSCB
L.G-F T-U-S. -' ST
\o
SITE /tPL AN -200
LOT I
]g7 STiRl_iM<
NttiLAA/ PS '
H y
)Lj Ds /
/
.-tPARTM OF PLANNING
0 4 may 2012
Fotm 41
Submission
OFFICE US€ ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 27
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Nam©
(P EASE PRINT Cl EARLY)
Address
postcode
Email a dress C-©•
s Use headings or numb rs to s parate different topics en Issues
n Includ p operty addres es a d specific location descriptions wh re relevant
° Attach additional numbered pages if you r qui e more spac to complete your su mission
Submission
reviewed by myself and the follo in issues have been identifie to reject the proposed increase
1. The increased reservation boundary (red) ould require St Quentins Apartments to be
demolishe ;
requirements, inclu ing density and appearance; and
I, agree with th proposal to increase the flow of traffic along
Stirlin Hwy but contests the proposal to increase the reserv tion boundar (red) along
Stirling Road.
Hearing) ©f submissions
Anyone who has made a written submission o the amendment may personall present the basis of their
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes' box is ticked. This is not com ulsor . Your
ritten submission will be considered in determining ihs recommendation for the proposed amendment
hether you nominate to spea at the hearings or not.
Furt er information on submissions and hearings is included in Ap endix E of t e amendment report,
B Mo, I do not wis to speak at t e hea ings. (Please go to the bottom of the form an sign)
OR
n Y@©, 1 wish to speak at t e hearings. (Please complete the following details)
I will ba represented by:
Myself - M telephone num her (busi ness hours):
OF
A spokesperson
Name of spokes erson:
Co tact telephone number (business hours):
Postal address:
0 would refer my hearing to be conducted im
Public (members from the general pu lic may attend our presentation)
OR
•
Private (only the people nominated by you or the earings committee will be
o The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPG ma be
subject to applications for access under the act
a In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
su mission or the substance of that sub ission, may be disclosed to thir parties.
» All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
tabled in Parliament an publishe as public records should the Governor a pro e the proposed a endment. he
WAPC recommen ations are similarl published in a re ort on submissions an ta led In Parliament
Mote: Sub issions MUST b@ received by the advertised closing date, being clos© of
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will MOT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone-(08) 6551 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Email - mr8@plann!ng.v/a.go ,au; Website-http:/Awuw. lanntng.wa.gov.a»
Form 41 fj 7 iv iAY 20 i2
Submissiora
! FILE
OFFICE USE ONLY
t
To: Secretary
. „
Submission 28
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
a
Name
? /;7
Address .../.l!
. .
.. k .
.
Postcode .677 /.P.
Contact phone number.76.•?.8f . ?. 6 r?.$?. Email address . '. LCi
° Use headings or numbers to separate different topics and issues
<5 Include property addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
0 Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to co plete your submission
Submission
I t
Sk
;
i
itl /i'
c11
er/
Jy / OCw/ /i/
V$ / uf s iC - 'C yyl Xi . X U
W -vCr . Ck:v. I '.2-/-fal. ??. .
/Aff.L. Yr?. Ak 7/2.7 . A!/
/ p_,C -f /r o a
/ Oi.cY C/i'
.t : ? . 3..
1 \JrC-
v/ Yk n. <>/ !ZOb> 7
7 / ,. /£/a/
bi i AA Yr~t- /%i . / v
2./X-L v A. fvtr1 tHta fu/. Y/YY //k y> Y\ ~
-2 fj YYa. /Y.. 7.T YffSc/ . P V r. /. .k. /Y . .<? 0 ./Y bx. AS/Y.Y. ..
/ r' rff lT Y Y> -~>rcYr<J i Y C •
2 • z 7Yz YYcJ< /' AY Y><Ya Yy n YrfrY/ /YYtc /d c./ cYj > ti/ / ct-efk/Yt_ Y c '-y
t Cvpfyjj-'/Yy AY. Si/Yd -/ j;// S
Mtf .. Cfyrypf 7 cA/
fYi- 2jY> ftI
2 .? Y / 5V
*
YL i- cw/ C-tZ /Y tYCf Zi Y tc***, & kL J
/ yff /vw-fy C ci/ Yk Y -YA y- /k-t. J hi
/r
/r Y
-ri /ir 1/-'Cc \ Tij- f yjp A/Yj/oY Yv t - c i r t
Yf .
-/ 7 7
jr1)
>
c 2AIJi' / k'/r
(i f c / 66
y.)
c?/ r A
. 6-' •
y -bj-' AYx-yfn y
> 7
i ry YY - i r 1 Y YY
'-/7 YYA /i.-q
//
2
Yvxx j xYo xfi Y-+:
L J_
p l/[YY
jr dY (
2i/Yxlv f /-£x j /Ylj-
x.j /C
tCc-'/i?
l f; Z* *
yf ri0
'- ffrY /-j/fY O
Yb c~f( c/ 2l S/ Yus - YxYYa fj ffj. yay/' S YY rrfY. CvY kYo S/Yx //(As- YAxl
p r~ ) j=L///A /YY C/rChr j t
J> A *1 ( ) /Ov-topciJ '/ At ? <
turn over to complete your sub ission ,/ Zo U
2-- ~ /)(L ,'/
Ccl-A . x-A y ,-rv ,, /,Z AY (f - c
fufx- rt- A-Ac y YZ/ A i+- /
7 2 fs /Y
yAr-
Y yg AYj cA C'/cAl oA Y
O -iCd }' ) Lcf /* ~r v y ej e oex/f V/XX
* , . / /,,// r ic~r>. 4 v-, .f r* VO $ YA * /j /c2 Oo / \ llri, f-s L Cy///
f <?Cl£S-) A
Yf-AY ALAr t-r r{ reju/l i- if o.n 7 yOcckiY i» -% at (*. >» } YiYt. XLr»
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
Signature<
Date ..
Note: Submissions iVIUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of
Durack & Zilko
Lawyers
ABN 25 398 552 926
In association with
Cullen Babington Hughes
Lawyers
3 May 2012
Le el 3
95 Stirling Highway
NEDLANDS WA 6009
The Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
PERTH WA 6001
Postal Address:
P O Box 935
NEDLANDS WA 6909
Tel 61 8 9389 3928
Fax 61 8 9389 1511
Email
mpapa@cbhlegal.com.au
Our ref: JWD:mp:mis deejay/SQ
Your ref: 809-2-191 Pt 2 (RLS/0248)
Dear Sir/Madam
MRS Proposed Amendment 1201/41 (Ratification of Stirling Highway Reservation)
We act for Deejay Nominees Pty Ltd.
In respect of the above we enclose our client s Form 41 Submission on proposals to reserve an
area along Stirling Road, Claremont affecting Lot 200.
Yours faithfully
Durack & Zilko
Li
! i1 .
0 7 MAY 2012
Section 41 Amen ment (Su stantial)
!a
FILE
Form 41
Subm ssion
IMetiropDlitan Region Scheme mendment 1210/41
OFFICE use ONLY
Submission 29
To: Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth A 6001
kj.i
A
ress
:
Pcy.
5 YC
Contact phone num ber
A.A
c . .. Postcode fo. .Q.S
. . .1
Email address.
Q77fr. -.YrS>. .<
T/ps for complet ng a submission;
o Use headings or numbers to eparate different topics and issues
° Includ property addr sses and specific location descriptions whe e relevant
Attach additional numb r ages if you req ire more spac to complete your submission
Submission
reviewed by myself and the follo ing issues have been identifi d to reject the proposed increase
demolished;
2. The St Quentins building as only recently built and et all local planning authorit
3. The concept of est biishing n extra lane on Stirling d will not alleviate traffic
I, .V/ A. . . . rA.YAA) l.Yagree with the proposal to increase the flow of traffic along
Stirlin H y but contest the propos l to increase the reservation boundar (red) along
Stirling Road.
. .Y
. .Yr
Hear ng of ubmissions
An one who has made a ritten submission on the amendment may personall present t e basis of their
submission o a sub-commi tee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compulsory. Your
written sub ission ill be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment
hether you nominate to speak at the hearings or not.
Further information on submissions and hearings is inclu e in Appendix E of the a endment report
d Mo. I do not wish to spea at the hearings. (P lease go to the bottom of th form and sig )
OR
O Yes, I ish to spea at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)
i will be represented by:
or
E]
spokesperson
Contact telephone number (bus ness hours):
Postal address:
CJ Public (members from the general publ c may attend our resentation)
OR
Cl] Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearin s committee will be
The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Aot 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC a be
o In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or aking its report on these submissions, copies of your
su mission or the substance of that submission, may be disclosed to third parties.
® ll hearings are recor ed and transcribed. The t anscripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
table in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor a prove the proposed am ndment. The
WAPC recommen atio s are similarly published in a report on sub issions an tabled In Parliament.
To be signed bv personfsl makin the sub Sgsion
/ - I J
Signature
.. , ~
.V. .
//
Y. .*;
Date
30 -
- \
Mote: Submissions MUST be received y the advertised clos ng date, being close of
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will MOT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone-(08) 6t>51 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@plannlng. a.gov.au; Website - httpVAvww.plannlng.wa.gov.au
' 'A! t i »Vi 1 ¦'
1 0 MAY 2012
Form 41
FiLE iL joZ
Submission
Rationalisation of Stirling Highway eservation
OFFICE US6 ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 30
Loc ed Bag 2506
Perth 6001
Name
.
(PLEASE
Address dl/$/.
P
INT
?....d/ . ... .
CLEARLY)
.f. Postco e
Contact phone number .0.¥rP . Email address
o Use headings or nu bers to se arate different topics and Issues
a Inclu roperty addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
° Attach additional numbered pages if you req ir more space to complete your s bmission
Sub ission
The MRS amendment 1210/ 1 Rationalisation of Stirling Highway Reservation has been
reviewed by m self and the follo ing issues have been identifie to reject the proposed increase
demolished;
re uirements, including density and appearance; and
3. The concept of establishing an e tra lane on Stirling Rd will not alleviate traffic
I, agree with the propos l to increase the flow of traffic along
Stirling Hwy but contests the proposal to increase the reservation boundar (red) along
Stirling Road.
Hear ng of submissions
Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment ma personall present the basis of their
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if t e belo 'Yes' box is ticke . This is not compulsory. Your
written submission ill be considered in deter ining he recommendation for the roposed amendment
whether you nomi ate to speak at the hearings or not.
Further information on sub issions and hearings is included in Ap endix E of the a en ment report.
Cf Mo,
do not wish to speak at the hearings. (P tease go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
Yes, I w s to s eak at the hearings. (Please complete t e following details)
Myself- My telephone number (business hours):
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
Public (me bers from the general publ c may attend your presentation)
OR
'
o In the course of the APC assessing submissions, or aking its report on these submissions, copies of your
su mission or the substance of that sub ission, may be disclosed to third parties.
0 ll hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
table in Parliament and published as pu lic records should t e Governor appro e the propose a endment. The
WAPC recommendations are similarly publis ed in a report on submissions an ta led in Parliament
To be signed by personfs) mak n the submission
Signature
Note: Submissions MUST be received y the advertised closing date, being close of
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions ill NOT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone-(08)6351 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@plannIng. a.go .au; ebsite- ttpV/www.planning.wa.go .au
Form 41 i ¦ MA i
¦
Submission FllE
iVIetropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1210/41
OFFICE USE ONLY
F
To: Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth
Sylb issiom 31
WA
Name
.
6001
,
Ae&
Address
Contact phone number... Email address YfY/ Y ./.Yd .Yd .Y
Submission
/dy dL&
J
- ro
turn over to complete your submissio
OR
i will be represented by:
or
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
H Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
® The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC maybe
e All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
Note: Submissions MUST be received by the ad ertised closing date, being close of
Belregis Pty Ltd
20 Clayton Street
East Fremantle WA 6158
11 May 2012
The Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Dear Secretary,
This letter is written to express our strongest possible objection to
the Proposed Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) Amendment
which will severely affect our property at 2/136 Stirling Highway,
North F emantle.
When this scheme is eventually enacted, it will necessitate the
demolition of our building.
This proposal will now hang ominously over any prospect we may
have of keeping our existing tenant, attracting a new tenant or
selling the property.
Our original intention in buying the property in 1987, that of using
the rental proceeds to fund our retirement has now been thrown
into disarray as has the long term strategy of holding the property
indefinitely.
This location is one of the few opportunities to hold an office
warehouse in a Highway position between Perth and Fremantle
which is precisely the reason for our original purchase.
This advantage is now in danger of being denied us.
Our long term tenant of more than 20 years must now ponder the
future prospects of his business as he is near retirement age. The
tenant s only real option will be to move the business to alternative
premises in order to sell out, sacrificing the prime Highway position
which has always been the main consideration in locating here.
We believe that this Amendment will effectively destroy any real
value which our property may have in the future, leaving only one
potential purchaser - The Government of Western Australia, who
may or may not show any interest in purchasing the property in our
lifetimes.
This leaves our future in a rather precarious position to say the
least!
While we fully understand the need for future traffic planning, we
are not of the opinion that the entry of McCabe Street onto Stirling
Highway warrants the amount of injurious affection which will be
visited upon us if this proposal is enacted and once again register
our firm objection to the proposal.
Yours faithfully,
Russell Brown
Director
Sally Louise Brown
Director
Increase in lan required
for road purposes
No. 136 (Lot 100) Stirling Highway, North Fremantle
subject to survey
McCabe street
Extract of proposed changes: plan number 1.7150 (448-e )
GOVERNMENT OF
WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Western
Australian
Planning
Commission
Frem448.dgn
00 Sep 2011
Produced by Map ing & GeoSpalial Data Branch, Department ol Planning, Perth WA
On behalf of the este Austral an Planning Commission.
Base information supplied by Weste Australian Land Information Authority LI 430-2009-4
Scale 1:400
0
8
Propert boundary
metres
Additio t©
Submission 3\
Belregis Pty Ltd
20 Clayton Street
0 1 JUN mi
30 May 2012
K- iSj O-Z f
The Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Dear Secretary,
Enclosed please find a copy of an additional objection to the
proposed Scheme Amendment 1 1/41.
IQ O
You will note that there is a glaring anomaly in the Amendment
Report and Fremantle Council fact Sheet regarding payment for
land being reserved.
I am objecting to the premise stated in the FCC document stating
that land indicated for widening is to be ceded free of cost to the
Crown .
Please advise whether this is the case or if compensation will be
paid in the event of the land being acquired.
Yours faithfully,
Russell Brown
Director
20 Clayton Street
30 May 2012
The Chief Executive Officer
City of Fremantle
PO Box 807
Fremantle WA 6959
Dear Chief Executive Officer,
Re: Public Submission Form,
Planning Scheme Amendment No. 12
Ref: 218/016 - Sharn Meekel
Subsequent to my original submission to Council regarding the
proposed road widening at McCabe Street and Stirling Flighway
and the reservation of a large part of our building, I am submitting
this extra objection to the plan on the following grounds.
1. The fact sheet supplied regarding modifications to the
Scheme Amendment is totally at odds with the information
contained in Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment
1210/41 in regard to compensation to be paid to landholders
whose property is required for road purposes.
You will notice that I have highlighted sections of the
document where it states land indicated for widening is to be
ceded free of cost to the Crown
Also enclose are two a photocopied pages from the WAPC
document outlining procedure for compulsory acquisition and
compensation.
2. Please explain in detail how you and WAPC expect to treat
landowners in this Scheme when the scheme is implemented
in regards to fair and reasonable payment for land and
existing buildings.
3. Is this inconsistency in the documents an accident or
oversight or is it a government conspiracy to acquire land
free of cost.
4. In the event of the property being confiscated by
Government agencies, are you prepared to defend these
actions in the High Court? WE ARE!!
We await your prompt reply.
Yours faithfully,
Russell Brown
Director
Belregis Pty Ltd
cc.
The Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
SVSodifications to proposed Scheme Amendment Wo, 12 to the City's
Local Planning Scheme No. 4
On the 16 of April 2012, the City received correspondence from the Minister for Planning
advising that Scheme amendment No. 12 (the rezoning of the Matilda Bay Brewery area
from Industrial to Development Zone), as adopted by Council on the 26 May 2010, will not
be approved until such time as the amendment can be modified. The Minister goes onto
direct the Council to modify the scheme amendment and advertise the scheme amendment
with the modifications. The first part of the amendment (Part i, the rezoning of the site) is
the same as the originally proposed amendment. The modifications to the amendment are
in Part ii and include modifying the existing provisions in Schedule 11 for DA 18 of the Local
planning Scheme No. 4 s text, to include:
• provisions that require the ceding and leveling of land in the proposed road widening
area on Stirling Highway and McCabe Street as a condition of any future
development approval; and
o the requirement for an internal link road through the area connecting McCabe Street
to Coventry Parade/McCabe Place as part of any structure plan for the area.
BACKGROUND TO SCHEME AMENDMENT O. 12
On 30 October 2009 the Western Australian Planning Commission s (WAPC) Metropolitan
Region Scheme (MRS) Amendment 1168/57 Matilda Bay Brewery Precinct was gazetted.
This amendment rezoned the Matilda Bay Brewery site No's 130 (Lot 220), 136 (Lot 100) and
138 (Lot 8) Stirling Highway, North Fremantle, from the Industrial' zone to the 'Urban' zone
under the provisions of the MRS. The City of Fremantle's Local Planning Scheme No. 4 was
not concurrently rezoned with this amendment therefore making it inconsistent with the
MRS.
The purpose of Scheme amendment No. 12 was to render LPS4 consistent with the MRS.
Scheme amendment No. 12 proposed rezoning land in the Matilda Bay Brewery area (No.
130 (Lot 5, 12, 218, 219, 220, 221, 314 & 253), No. 136 (Lot 100) and No. 138 (Lot 8) Stirling
Highway and No. 2-4 (Lot 9, 10 & 11) McCabe Street, North Fremantle) from 'Industrial' to
'Development Zone' (Development Area 18).
MODIFICATIONS TO SCHEME AMENDMENT NO. 12
As per the Ministers direction the City of Fremantle proposes modifying the Scheme
Amendment No. 12, as follows:
i) Amending the Scheme map in accordance with the Scheme Amendment map
(below) for No. 130 (Lot 5, 12, 218, 219, 220, 221, 314 & 253), No. 136 (Lot 100)
and No. 138 (Lot 8) Stirling Highway and No. 2-4 (Lot 9,10 & 11) McCabe Street,
North Fremantle, from a zoning of Industrial to Development zone and to include
the properties within Development Area 18 - McCabe-Coventry Street, North
Fremantle.
ii) Modify the existing provisions in Schedule 11 for DA 18 with the following
(modifications shown in italics):
DA 18
McCabe - Coventry
Street, North
Fremantle
130-138 Stirling
Highway and 2-4
1. Structure plan is to be adopted to guide subdivision,
land use and development prior to approval of
development applications.
2. Investigation of potential site contamination to the
satisfaction of the DEC.
McCabe Street,
North Fremantle
3. No development shall be ermitted within the pro osed
road wid ning on Stirling Highw y and McCabe Street
as indicated in the proposed metropolitan Scheme
Amendment 1210/41 or as in a fin lized MRS
amendment nd the land indicated for widening is to be
ceded free of cost to the Crown and to be level with the
existing verge as a condition of d velopment approval.
4. Any structure plan for the land is to include an internal
link road connecting McCabe Street to Coventry
Parade/McCabe Place.
5. Development applications received prior to adoption of
a structure plan, shall be assessed via Mixed Use
provisions of the Scheme. Applications for any form of
residential development and subdivision should be
deferred until the structure plan is adopted in order
that servicing, open space provision, environmental
remediation and other issues are resolved.
The Minister has advised Council that:
(a) The above modifications have been requested bec use land required for future road
widening of Stirling Highway is expected to be ceded free of cost to the Crown and
Main Roads Western Australia and the Western Australian Planning Commission
have identified a requirement for an internal road connecting McCabe Street to
Coventry P rade/McCabe Place in association with widening of Stirling Highway nd
im rovements to the intersection with McCabe Street; and
(b) The amendment is required to be re-advertised as these modifications are considered
to be significant.
The Minister has directed Council to advertise the modifications to Scheme Amendment No.
12 for a period of 28 days in accordance with the provisions of regulation 20(1) of the Town
Planning Regulations 1967. Following advertising Council is required to consider any
submissions received and to make a recommendation in respect of each submission and
forward the submissions and recommendations to the Commission.
MAKING A SUBMISSION
Accordingly, Scheme Amendment No. 12 has been placed on advertising for more than 28
days from Tuesday the 24 April 2012 to 25 May 2012. All comments on the amendment are
welcome. Submissions may be made in writing, before the close of business on the 25 May
2012, and addressed as follows:
Planning Services, City of Fremantle
PO Box 807,
FREMANTLE, WA 6959
or e-mail to: planning@fremantle.wa.gov.au
fax to: 9432 9842
Your Property and the Metropol tan Region Scheme
Landowners rights to compensation in relation to reserved land
If land is reserved in the Metropolitan
Region Scheme
Land which is affected by a reservation in the
Metropolitan Region Scheme (MRS) will
ultimately be acquired by the government, but
generally can remain in private ownership until
it is actually needed for the public purpose.
There are several options available to the
owners of reserved land:
Am I entitled to compensation?
If your land is reserved in the MRS, you may be
able to make a claim for compensation for
injurious affection if:
n you are the owner of the property when it is
first reserved in the MRS and you wish to
sell the property on the open market at a
reduced price;
or
a Retain ownership and continue with the
quiet enjoyment of the property until it is
needed for the public purpose. You may
complete any development or subdivision of
the property that was approved prior to the
reservation coming into effect.
D Sell the property on the open market to
another person(s). The Western Australian
Planning Commission (WAPC) recognises
that due to the reservation this may be
difficult and, subject to acquisition priorities
and the availability of funds, would be willing
to consider the purchase of a reserved
property if an owner is unable to achieve a
private sale on the open market.
0 the WAPC has either refused a
development application over the property
or has approved a development application
over the property subject to conditions that
are unacceptable to the applicant.
How do I claim compensation?
1 If you have chosen to sell the property on
the open market at a reduced price, complete a
notice of intention to sell form which is
available from the Department of Planning. The
.department will establish the extent of the
reservation and forward the notice to the Board
of Valuers.
a Offer the property for sale to the WAPC.
Subject to acquisition priorities and the
availability of funds, the WAPC would be
willing to consider the early acquisition of a
reserved property. In such cases the
property is purchased at the current market
value had the property not been affected by
the reservation, with the value being
determined by independent valuations of the
property.
n Make a claim for compensation for injurious
affection following the WAPC s refusal of a
development application or approval of a
development application subject to
conditions that are unacceptable. In such
cases the WAPC may elect to purchase the
property instead of paying compensation
with the purchase price being determined in
the same way as a negotiated purchase.
The Board of Valuers will determine the sworn
unaffected and affected values of the property.
You may wish to meet with the board to raise
any matters you believe are relevant to the
value of the property.
Following the determination by the board:
n You will be notified of the unaffected value
of the property.
D You pay a valuation fee to the WAPC, after
which you will be notified of the affected
value of the property - this will represent the
minimum sale price.
a You then arrange the sale of the property
(either privately or through an agent). Note
the sale price must not be less than the
affected value determined by the board.
H When the property is sold, you may make a
claim for compensation for injurious
affection for the difference between the sale
price and the unaffected value as
determined by the board.
a If the property does not sell within one year
of the board s valuation, you may ask the
board for a revaluation of the property. The
sale process is then repeated.
n Once compensation has been paid, a
caveat will be lodged on the certificate of
title to identify that compensation has been
paid. Please note that compensation is only
payable once.
Alternatively, you may ask the WAPC to
purchase the property, as you have been
unable to sell the property privately.
2 If the WAPC has refused your development
application or approved it subject to
unacce table conditions and the property is
reserved in the MRS, you may make a claim for
compensation for injurious affection within six
months of the WAPC s decision on the
application.
In such a case the WAPC will either pay
compensation or may elect to purchase the
property in lieu of paying compensation.
If the WAPC elects to purchase the property,
valuations are obtained for the market value of
the property as at the date of the election to
purchase had the property not been reserved
in the MRS. Please note that the date of
valuation is fixed at the date of election to
purchase.
What is compulsory acquisition?
A situation may arise where a property is
needed as a priority for a public purpose and
the owner is unwilling to sell the property to the
WAPC.
In such a case, the property may be
compulsorily acquired (or resumed) for that
public purpose.
Where a property has been resumed by the
WAPC, you have the right to make a claim for
compensation in respect of the land resumed.
The WAPC will have the resumed land valued
and following the checking of the compensation
claim will make you an offer of compensation
for the resumed land.
Should you have any queries concerning
the matters raised in this brochure, please
do not hesitate to contact the Department of
Planning, WAPC Property Management
Services.
Increase in land required
for road purposes
No. 136 (Lot 100) Stirling Highway, North Fremantle
subject to survey
McCabe street
Extract of proposed changes: plan number 1.7150 (448-e )
GOVERNMENT OF
WESTER AUSTRALIA
Western
Australian
Planning
Commission
Frem4 8.dgn
09 Sep 2011
Produced by Mapping & GeoSpatial Data Branch, Department ol Planning, Perth V/A
On behall of the Weste Australian Planning Com ission.
Base Information suppSed by V/estem Australian Land Information Authorit LI 430-2009-4
Scale 1:400
0
8
Property boundary
Proposed area require
metres
Form 41
Submission
FlLF
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 32
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
i
£SQRlE.B>£ftr <sH...F.AAOief'J&Q.
(?
.1
i; L-
.*
Address ...P:.0.:.. .P. r.. . XTP.tS'£-.
>.L-.<«<S .¦
. .Gf 'S.Q.O. b
Postcode
Email address
® Use headings or numbers to separate different topics and issues
o Include pro erty addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
o Attach additional numbered pages if you require more s ace to complete your submission
Submission
CU..
....(.
£f
...
. Cv. .
...
.
jL? ..
a,
.jp
x
X.
Q&. c . .
•d. ..
.
.
...
.
.
<5
3o.
-s f . Jd--)...
-
.c:
.
L;
l '.. .rs ).. .
-tsdv Tt. .Qy cd-rTr -A'.. Jdp .
... .Lr. . X .. . A-A X. .. fcX}.. .J L;-.
.
iY
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
0 The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC maybe
In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
Signature ...
Date
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http:// ww.planning.wa.go .au
•]
AY 2012
(ll S>jOol
Form 41
Submission
Wletropolitan Region Scheme Amen ment 1210/41
OFFlCEUSc ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 33
Lock d Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
.
Name..
.
li...
(PLEASE PRI XCI.EARIV) t h /
k±(o
Address
Contact phone number A ri. '. Email address
o Use h adings or numbers to s parat different topics and Issues
o Includ property addresses and specific location de criptions where relevant
« Attac additional nu bered pages if you require more s ace to complete your su ission
Submission
i reservation area.:
1. Th increased reservation boundary (red) ould require St Quentins Apartments to be
demolished;
2. The St Quentins building as only recently built and et all local planning authority
requirements, including density and appearanc ; and
3. The concept of est biishing an extra lane on Stirling Rd ill not alleviate traffic
.
agree with the proposal to increase the flow of traffic along
Stirlin H y but contests the proposal to increase the reservation boundat (red) along
Stirling Road.
J
Hearing ©f submissions
sub ission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes' box is ticked. This is not eompulsosy. Your
ritten submission will be considered in determining the recom endation for the proposed amendment
Further information on submissions and hearings is included in Appendix E of the a en ment report.
S3
/
Mo, I do not wish to speak at t e hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
M self- My telephone number (business hours):
or
CD A spokesperson
Postal
address:
8 would prefer my earing to be conducted in:
Public (members from the general pubiic may attend your presentation)
OR
ID] Private (only t e people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
permitte to attend)
• The W PC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC ay be
a In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or a ing its report on these submissions, copies of your
e ll hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all earings, along with all written sub issions, are
table in Parliament and publishe as public records should the Governor appro e t e proposed a endment. The
WAPC recommen ations are similarly ublished in a report on sub issions and tabled in Parliament
To be signed by personfs) mak ng the submission
Coniacts: Telephone-(08)6351 900; Fax-(08)6S51 9001; Email-mrs@plannlng.wa.gov.au; Website-htipi/Avww.planning.wa.gov.au
k
/
¦
iv
j
)
r /
j
f
r
a£
z>
7
<
.
'
w
\)
S
3 - _Jf
/
i
>
lp?l2
pj
S'S
• • -yj t/
fJz
r
>
r£
~t
cf
o -
n -*~ i
nry
H
•
¦ •
¦ -
7j
r J
cl)
¦•
:
p
33'
'(j " "
-
'4'' ¦
" y" ";" '
; - p''
y''
.j
/-
"
"
r5'
'4. ' 4 i»'
r 'P ¦
" ' 755 2
;>oA -
'' ~2h j<tp-7>
d' 2 3-' ¦'37')' o s " "
J
/
'
J" '
" 7i 34/'
sp 4 7
.
'-? '''
LJ|- 'V ''' pp 'i >
'
"74
'
o '1
-*v-l ?
i'-'I'-l'S''
0 ' 54
. o
i "
¦>•s- d yg ""•"47/?'JS3' u4''" 7Vl '
Qp'
•••4 4 4 '
|']'
''''
7''' ''' 343
¦]' v
*'
W'' '-Jiv ' "
7"'3 ppd"7;""
-1;" "74'' ' ' 4 s'7b''
pp.'' " JTptj 'pj" ".cp " "
r-y " " /Gi('i~
op " AA / »
445 /
5
' 556'y''' rp X
¦>'5''"rp"k
'3i-: 0)' ?S y)''
f,/ • ¦
0,
i
7 - pp
' 'V ')"P"
?£ :v
i p S''' >J
7 '' ' ' "3
-y cy.
j
wyp)
J
"
V)Cf
Up'' ¦' ' /1-6 ''''
"4
¦ ¦ cy_ ""
' ¦/' ¦
'' '
{23 '
A bp><P'•/'77 " " /''''pjUi Q
7 7 ¦ "cy_.'' - yv J ''p? "-pp ?'tf '
4 5"'cA'' " f 2r p ' ''
7
4-w
''
y • i
t / .y¦ ¦ • l rp\ ' ¦ j "¦ ¦ ¦
GojAd i "
¦ ¦ 4 jij
r,):]
'SJ x;>
3
' ¦
3
J7
u pjf
¦ C
J
-
4
44 • ¦
y fe7 r p y "3 ViJLj/"''
"S
/
4'
3
•
r
f Ad/
" 544-' "S5VI
.aV 4'A i)'' "'
c yuafyir'" y '"
5 '
' ' 0''' o oo)'" y "
uojssjiuqns
uoissiuiqns jnoA a)aidiuoo 0} ooeds ojolu ambej noA ; ssfied pejsqwnu /euo/j/ppe i/oe« »
juBAa/aj ajaqM suo/iduosap uoqeooi o oads pue sassajppe adojd apn/oui °
sanssi ue soldo} fuajafflp ajejedas o; sjaquinu jo sdui eaq asp
luo/ssiu qns e Buifaidi oo o; sd}±
sssjppe BLU3 '' 'Q p' y J ' f pP
©uoqd ejuoo
'cA-jfW p' S> "57y.77
apoojsod
ssajppv
G
( iavanoiNiadasvaid)
••SgV -su.BN
'T3
1-009 VM WS
9052 Beg ps ooi
UOlSSjlUUJOO BUjUUBId UB!|BJ)SnV UJ9)S9/\A
t?£ uoissjiuqns
/tiB)9Joas :oj_
AHNO 3Sn 30ldd0
uoqe Jassij Abm Bih Bumj s jo uoqBsneuoqBy
1>W0I<ZI- luaiupueiuv atua og uojBay UB;!|odo4jauy
uojssjiuqns
).t7 LUJOJ
(iBjjUBisqns) jueiupueui uopoag
710Z
/! . I
3002 PV }uaaido|a aa pue BmuuBi
q/ wo, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
C Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation)
OR
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.go .au; Website - http:// ww.planning.wa.gov.au
1 8 MAY 2012
Form 41
Submission
file/2/ LS[
OFFICE USE ONLY
L
To: Secretary
.
j
Submission 35
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
¦
.
.
/
7ts\
Address
Contact phone number..
Postcode
$...4:$%...
...A
1
Email address .
• Use headings or numbers to separate different topics and issues
Submission
x TX... YX.../XX.
.rife... f/eof$ rc> _ -fh/ yA h ..
..2;a/w.C/pLt.. kfc... .. f
.Sf-fffi?.7.27./yc*/ oa/
....... .'7.. .> 7.. 9kkPkyktkk... kr tynkk/.. J/y.
kk.cjfyfY... .7/ 7.... 2 7 77x77. Z.k
?/E. k ??.
kk /?/ZK y . .yZ.
FA...C7T..k yv&t......7xtfX>. Ay .ZS.y: .
x. . ... . k
h Z L... :C£atL
M? g&ry... .
£.... . x .. . ... . zfek?.. 9 r.
r... fz ... .CLosg C... cq .4z7.qy..
fkP. Ifilfi. r.... .fy.trk/.. MM.
.. ...iMu.LP...kUi....k!?M>. .k!@ ...7f. .7..Lw&xs:../.p...V. y..
M h. ..I ... . .... Pr Pci/Ak'p). . y...
tk?/L..
Hy.... 77.... kMQt.M.&y r... UM/MyA
yt .... kyp& . M....7Z/fM....(W? ?.IZMl. .4M.Zii?. Z}i.0yTS-
lot.. . ZtlZ . Z)... IniuZ k
.. U .Mt.t luZyt...
v
o"
N©, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
0 The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be
To be signed by erson(s) making the submission
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://w w.planning.wa.go .au
DEP RTMENT OF PLANNING
! 8 MAY 2012
Section 41 Amendment (Subs antial)
Form 41
FILE S O
Submission
k
Metropolitan Region Scheme mendment 1210/41
OFFICE USE ONLY
Submission 36
To: Secretary
Western Australian Planning Com ission
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
f ./.
.8a. .
.(. 5
Address
Yhs.i. .(fs .
Contact phone number.. A' Y Yj....'?.
Postcode
Email address
o Include roperty addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
° Attach additional numbered ages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
ab,j.r. C-r t .T
.V-jc
o Sr!.tc(.r.{f
/ J r.C'/r /b
'
k
,G0. ..... flOrf
D.. I v/. £..U..T7i. Gi r.Ttr&.Cx .'A. A . . lliT Sftr .G. t ..Xm.... rAf cX..
,
-
m»fo
.
.
L
/
/
s~
.
v
/
,
.XtJJ. s!n. .. .r tfc.f?-. Y./.-e. .<r.i.Y.CfnJ?.s X. f ,..).
/1
/:.Y: vi.. Y.GG. . PGY
.CmJ. ..
vl/
A& ..
f
f
¦ ¦
~
J
s
C?. 1
rXA 2.tCr..... f:\.G
Lc\r\
c
-
J
.
\:{. v
. .Qf fc. k\J.
-i
hA As-c/. . 2
K\ .
- . .. ..../. sl XYi
OJ.IfLV.'y klbvj... fi .... A-bkf.r. .w .c.i. j;
./v,(d.1 .v.Q
,
!.± ... /XQtXCf.x. J.... X Xl A
rfrci.. . . v -:1 cl... GW-UwAY
X
4 Xhi f .. (fs. / A A
Tr ci v£.f.
e:
r-<
.,,
, :\JL.uc„..<a
r!T.c:y.L.i. e-TT.'.YXs
FtT 4T....S
;v/7A
hA«\ Q_
-y
f ne_
Ac .r.
• V A:/
..' .k
.O.
. ./.. -.cv.r.
. . fe.... r
XY.Q,.cY v42
A
.GSG x: .XX - Xamtk . Y.. YY S: /.'Ga..
n
rji .Q b.Cibir. . Sr '.L.
.c uw il
/
Lf p a.
3 . ..jT
(. TS. taS.
i. c..r..v/ .Le..)...X .Vxi..nj c X ¦ ¦ • ¦ l£ Gi/.Q f .6 Rt ... <A/rcV-(A
k OxQvd ( . iL.irv ¦ ¦ ¦ .TrtGvj . c. .
a ..X.. :ki... .ta. r. .0
YX 1- XA-uK}
i vo . .>.... xf\ >... .C.vhsj. e sd:
... . /Y.
..
.1 C/£ c . v. a.H:Yfc /-«?-r-V>r'! ,- n JhS(.J.\.t.W.-S... .'02.... xfW )ir-£.£.... Y Y Si. ... bL .loj 'd
. D.VA
Y.... .T0..... .CV
v . j?.X .M . TL...vt ... c| r\
ii p tur over
to complete
you submission
__
.
, J__.
m
f X t\ Gs LLn
v)F
e
Av\.M
j
l I jj L0 S a| rvtL i c.aJ I O.
CLj
v-J ivQ. C'-O.
lT 6v1 v
. -( r~L
\
y eeb
Uc/W
b
_
Q;
¦
cA t
t
P
o
H jS
;F:( o - ce kVj~ vJ crP P'.i <4o lo \ '- A Y i-KMo) ' c- r V\Yt! - -(v:w 4
'-f (A - -fo I /d
T .C
i lov
r
c
-e fe Tc O n -
OR
Q Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)
or
A spokesperson
Postal
address:
OR
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http:// ww.planning.wa.gov.au
% 1 MMAY
2012 tm
2l
Form 41
|oat£ Jc
Su mission
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Sy mi sfe 37
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
i=
Name
t
/ (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY) \
...
-f-"
/ l-. J). . ?.3>. fir?... Postcode .. .(&. o. .<7.
Contact phone number#.
. .. Email m ess
j , 3 F /,*/.} n j/ :p f i/
o L/se headings or numbers to separate different top fapd ssup / fijf 0
/
d
® Include property addresses and specific location descriptions/ymere ei vant
• Attach additional numbered pages if you require more s ace to complete your submission
Submission
e
..7jL.A.
C
l'M&fsdj/F
a
....
. .. Aw a. 3e.S... AAr... A&ajpL. .
... / ?. .j
...
..
... tA, .. A&jAu . C7$.
A.
..
3:
..
A/kx.
.... CL&Jp.. . / - ¦ 0d fa$2'\ >. Am&A... ... Axs&dlT&Mt&KJt.
. -rr cY .
T rcr
.4 v.. .yp/ fri ..
f Ahr .A.... C. .c3.
£\f£....#r/A. lAfi....(
.
fi
... ..
..
co
/..
w .. rT.TTf
...»f
n % .t F?r,: C..A&.4~£A?br<o. AA
.F....A/sj&t
rf
...3s:..Ap...
Aa. . .,.. .Ash uA. a
. .-vAs.. ..Or F&Akt.cA.. . ../a fM . .
...
.&rui
...
.a£
.S.
.
?)
.
Aa »..... ?.&9./e.te&. jltt FZ A h JaAS
o_ -nt/
7Z$cX . . N A . A f
. .... tA . .. . i Mz ... sAouk.. i/t '&<ox ... &Ak A)...
. .&Zo ... AA>.... s/ u,.A. ...A?.m dArx>, Z/!?
. .d yxcL ..... cA r .... 3£? ?.\k -. x -r ... .Ck.7iAA.4A? t.FkAs r
ihs 1&A
s- .
.. &Fd ... .(<2)...k<r4$Ac... ./u feA .. . cgA-f. ... -.-A....
.. ho... . P.Ad.hk -... ./W.
>.. .id&st?/... '?$?.
3€L , turn OVer i complete your ubmission
ck/\jk
yi S a
<fi L r3 <-
OR
ED Myself - My telephone number (business hours):
or
C A spokesperson
Postal address:
Eli Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation)
OR
)
E Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearin s committee will be
o The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC maybe
g In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
Signature
.
- 1..... J.f
y}
Date
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://www.planning.wa.gov.au
11 2012
#0272 P.001 /002
I NG
22:59 +6136460 195
+61864604195
*
l 1 HO'I 2012 I
Form 41
SuEomission
FiL
ir
Metropolitan Region Scheme Amen ment 1210/411
OFFICE USE ONLY
SUBMISSI N UMBER
To: Secretary
Weste Australian Planning Commission
38
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name Kendrick Ling
* ........ . (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)
Address
fs e. c
Si ...wi'f,<3i 0d,
Em il address . r'_c
0.
H
Anyone who as ade a written submission on he amen ment may personall present t e basis of their
submission to a sub-committe of the WAPC if the below'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compulsory. Your
wheth r you nominate to speak at the hearings or not.
Furt er information on submissions and hearings is included in Appendix E of the amendment report.
/ Please choose one of the following;
SfsNo, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to t e bottom of the form and sign)
OR
Q Yes, 1 wish to speak at the hearings. (Please co plete the following details)
d Myself - My telephone number (business hours):
o
A spokesperson
Name of spokesperson: ¦
Contact telephone number (business hours) ...:
Po
t
l
address:
I would p efe imy hearing to be conducte .fn;
D Public (members from the gen ral public may atten your presentation)
OR
CZ! Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings co mittee will be
I&NG
17/11 2012 22:59 +61864604195
#0272 P.002 /002
+61864604195
You should be aware that
® The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions ma e to the WAPC may be
subject to ap lications for access under the act.
o In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these ubmissions, copies of your
submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclo ed to third parties,
® All hearings ar recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and published as public recor s should the Gove or approve the proposed amendment. The
WAPC recommendations are similarly publishe in a report on submissions and tabled in Parliament.
Contacts: Telephone-(08) 6551 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@ lanning.wa.gov.au; Website - http;//ww .planning.wa.gov.au
<l
Submissio 38
Original Message
From: Kendrick Ling [mailto:kendrickling@gmail.com]
Sent: Friday, 4 May 2012 3:25 PM
To: StirlingHighway
Subject: Submission
Hi,
As a recent ex and future resident of Nedlands I agree with the Stirling
Highway amendments. We need to make provision for buses, pedestrians and
bicycles
Regards,
Kendrick Ling
35 Blackford St
Mt Hawthorn
locutusSgraduate.uwa.edu.au
Form 41
Su mission
OFFICE USE ONLY
»
To: Secretary Western Australian Planning Commission
Locked Bag 2506
1
~
-- a
Submission 39
Perth WA 6001
j
Name
JETA
PTYLTD
Address c/: Paxton Hoad West, PO Bgx 700, Claremont, WA Postcode 6910
Contact phone number ....+61 438 867 624 Email address j.eta@iinet.net.au
o Include property addresses and specific location descri tions where relevant
Submission
1. lam Julian Louis Slier, a director and shareholder of Jeta Pty Ltd (" Jeta").
2. I am duly autho ised to make this submission.
3. Jeta is the owner of a unit located on the ground floor of the development located at Lot 70 Stirling
Highway, Claremont.
4. I received a booklet entitled "Rationalisation of Stirling Highway Reservation" containing a plan described
as "Extract of Proposed Changes: Plan Number 1.7147 (243-b). The plan is entitled "Reduction in land
required for road purposes No. 392 (Lot 70) Sti ling Highway, Claremont Proposed area required 159 m2
subject to survey".
5. The proposed "rationalisation" will adically affect the amenity of the unit which we own. It is located on
the ground floor of the development and the garden and lawn in front of it abuts the Stirling Highway.
6. If the proposed change (and presumably the resumption of part of the land) occurs as depicted on the plan,
the amenity and market value of our unit will suffer significantly.
7. Currently the complex and the unit are protected from the Stirling Highway by a istance of several metres
occupied by a magnificent old tree and hedges, which not only provide privacy and shelter from traffic
noise, but also shade.
8. The proposed changes will ean that our unit will effectively be on the edge of Stirling Highway without
any protection because the tree, hedges and also the lawn on which they are located, will have to be
destroyed.
9. Disturbingly, the proposed chances will seriously affect the value of the property. Currently, its seclusion
from the highway makes it a desirable ground floor unit. The removal of the seclusion and the expansion of
the highway will make the property less desirable and affect not only the capital v lue of the property but
also the rental values.
Please choose one of the foliowing:
M©, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
I will be ep esented by:
o
A spokesperson
Name of spokesperson: ..JLSher
Postal address: 26 Melrose Crespeiit,, Menora,.WA 6050
I would prefe my hea ing to be conducted in:
0
OR
kI\
To e signed by person(s) ma ing the submission
<?
Signature fA..\.. Y.y..
Date
Y
J/ /
'2-
Note: S bmissions MUST be recei e y the adve tised closing date, being close of
bijsijriess (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late sub issions will OT e consi ere .
From: Kym Peters [mailto:Kym.Peters@hfw.com]
Sen Wednesday, 23 May 2012 12:35 PM
To: mrs
Cc: corporate
Su ject: WAPC Ref: 809-2-1-91 Pt 2 (RLS/0173) - Form 41 Submission [HFWPER-HFWPER.FID601]
Attention: Mr John O'Hurley
By email and post
Dear MrO'Flurley
On behalf of Mr Julian Sher, please find attached Form 41 Submission in relation to the property
located at Lot 70 (No. 392) Stirling Highway, Claremont.
Kind regards
Kym Peters
on behalf of Julian Sher
Jeta Pty Ltd
Direct: +61 (0)8 9422 4701
Julian.Sher(5)hfw.com
HOLMAN FENWICK WILLAN
Level 13
140 St Georges Terrace
Perth 6000
T: + 61 (8) 9422 4700
F: + 61 (8) 9422 4777
hfw.com
holman fenwick willan
hf
A list of partners' names is available at this address. The firm is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors
Regulation Authority
This e-mail (including all attachments) is intended for the named addressee. It is confidential and may be
privileged
If you have received it in error, please contact us immediately and then delete it. You should not disclose its
contents to any other person
This message has been scat ed for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl
'.iUMEN i OF PLANNING
Sectio 41 Amendment (Substantial)
3 1 MAY 2012
Form 41
Submission
FILE
Metro olitan Region Scheme Amendment 1210/41
Rationalisation of Stirling Highwa Reservation
OFFICE USE ONLY
Submission 4©
To: Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name James CHEAH Kit Seng
Address
Unit 23/ 20 Royal street, East Perth, WA Postcode
Contact phone number.. .°.41.28.28.7®1 Email address . tche=h@.du.on1a,k:co.m:a.u.
Submission
Property: 301 Stirling Highway, Cnr. Leura Avenue
The property abo e already has restricted and limited vehicular access connecting t e Leura A enue vehicle parking
with the lower level Stirling Highway vehicle parking. The proposed scheme aithough less than the original reservation,
will remove this vehicular access way completely, effectively shutting of e icular access to the car bays on the property.
Regular and new business clientele will be confused and frustrate by the limited exits an entry oints from the property
and will not ha e the ability to migrate within the site if the top or lower le els are fully occupied.
Tenants both current and future will penalize the property through the rental likely to be paid and the property will
suffer from value destruction well above the fair compensation for land that may occur due to this reservation.
As a real life example, on the 16th of September 2011 negotiations began on securing a national retailer for the whole
of t e premise for $310/sqm nett + VO + 3% annual increases with the tenant paying relocation cost and refurbishment
cost with a 3 month rent free period. This represented a 24% increase from the current rental in one of the worst retail
trading environments in 20 years. Negotiations were being finalize in March-April 2012 when the pro osed amendments
were received, the Offers were quickly withdrawn an fell apart once the disclosure was made about the proposed
reser e.
The owners DO NOT support the proposed amendments and DO NOT belie e the current roposal re resents a
sustainable sol tion to the traffic management along Stirling Highway.
turn over to co plete ou submission
submission to a sub-committee ofthe WAPC if the below'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compulsory. Your
Further information on submissions and hearings is included in Appendix E ofthe amendment report.
OR
041 2828 761
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
X
OR
The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be
0 All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor appro e the proposed amendment. The
Note: Submission MUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of
business (5pm on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will NOT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http:// ww.planning.wa.gov.au
toDU OMAR K
PRACTICAL • F NCTIONAL • EFFICIENT
ACN 1 15 093 297 ¦ ABN 47 1 15 0 3 297
www.duomark.com.nu
Unit 23/20 Royal Street • East Perth 6004 ¦ Western Australia ¦ t (+ 1 8) 9421 1241 ¦ f (+61 8) 9421 1241
y
Metropolitan Regional
Scheme(MRS) Amendment 1210/41
4 October 2013
301 Stirling Highway
Portion DRG No. 1.7227
James Cheah
Tabledat hehearings4/10/13 Submis ion 40
Portion DRG No. 1.7227
301 Stirlng Highway
Impact on Property
Impact on Property
Reduction in number of bays
Decrease access to tenancy by clients
Decrease in parking amenity
Disruption in the current flow of car parking
Deterioration of businesses due to drop in traffic
Questions?
3 0 MAY 2012
Form 41
I
Submission
Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendme t 1210/41
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 41
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
G=
Name 5 .:. ... o ..:./AppD.ll.B .ia.. e S ( it<£ )ot 06 b\)
Address ...4:3: ... Sl l
.OCj..330 .
. . /
. Postcode .... (oD.U
Contact phone number 4Qp. . IL TT '.l'.F Email address . t. .I.OAr.OlTr '. .l ..CCii .trAi L dO 1 ttll,.
.
COl
t
*
CU
Submission
0 ...fVgpevt j.Lot.3.Q...(3.Q.-.433)..333.3 ...ttvotj..p.e .p : y i/4..,Cjt vt .
\n.. .5 000... ( . tam . .( d. /.
.uo ud
me t ..of:.. .o ,r.. . rof tvj... poa . .c pWed
C)... c . . .at.. j- t. . fro t.. of.o
..pYDpailA
* a... .o cf....her...e
....
ed..."to..Li a...tdc/ease ..of...th ....miofiaJ.
. .. .as.. ;teus.. (M sa.. .i/M.oad.. btona.. itoa.. rue .O tiun
u...!,... . u vioii . M . .stops.. .to et . o . mui d. .to).. .access.
ba.tte
c)
4?. . A ioxtopt.. o.aa X h.e.,e.i. cMcx.. ccess
;
.*... .Oix ,. ri tai.. pr dhte...., h ... ba .. to.. > !L. .oxea.. .suo.ll. .. in.41
aAd....Kft5...bL.LW.. ... /A5..stX....s.tA.cis....i1ia...eaL.t ...l.c |fof>,'s ¦
Wed.... h&M \lt... .iKi.oreas.iWo.. iAr,.. m.&uf.'/atM... mum.
(i:i,yt.i.slj... .affect... cue.... hm UXM
turn over to complete you submission
G 9o, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
or
ED A spokesperson
Name
of
spokesperson:
Postal address:
lD Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation)
OR
LJ Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
® The WAPC s subjecllothe Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be
q In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
Date .... e?/74.
Note: Submissions IVIUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.go .au; Website - http://www.planning.wa.go .au
El cottesloedental
cottesloedental. com. au
t (08)93841644 f (08)9384 1617
DEPAR'l ivtlS'-H OF i LAI'rtide
0 MAY 2012
With Compliments
478 Stirling Hwy, Cottesloe WA 6011 | PO Box 222, Cottesloe WA 6911
e admin@cottesloedental.com.au Cottesloe Dental ABN 43 191 080 168
Form 41
Submission
OFFICE USE ONLY
ti-
To: Secretary
Submession 42
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
„
-
LI l \ £_.
.
-
] U t vT .(t, r O r{q lV) i FI £_6LS P • L.
'f
? , (HL Abc PKINI CLfcAKLY) [J ( )
Address ....5. P VHl'.P. ....fe
0
C.;...AlC\n .. Postcode'
.9. .9r...
Contact phone number..QA... t. . . fc h... Email address .t .UL.-.'O. . ;..(. ./iLhL'
Submission
Rz. joe. - Hi ¦ L-c?
. (£) ).
\ rr e. t.?? f v. . ?. .L
I i u .c
\ .c ) > .01 ....
> ...,
to. .Rb S.... .0. r>. f
(?)! \ e k
) !.
f-r... fy
LO. .LOL..
.v. f
r \ \ ci \ sO C
XOv;::;:,
r A
vA
.!-
L.i. ....
\ c
.... ,p y/;Ho uO.
if)....fT V
?
vs r c tcvC
:.
.; ....\\.
....
. . (A Le
iLi.Le/C ... .rrr... .VoViO.LP -........ .C &c lG?
.f
.
''
-0 f. . ffl). ..to.?
.©
X)\. L..
cj
.XI YY...S?.Q.MYf.i.A. 7.4.
. .
X
4
c
..
torrr... .f?..... L P
a
b.
;pLi e...
....
.. .... .O
. |
ycnO/
k
... .t'l .VO
.l
. .3}Y 7.
fe g ..... ' s ?.
¦ • ¦
K '
f.. . . r
&
ro- 'pe r lpA:' • •
turn over to complete your submission . r •. c
41 toiSs .v : fbbk
O
.
'V3 f lA& fe fc
written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amen ment
¥
OR
o
1 ill be re resented by:
I I Myself - y telephone number (business hours):
or
C A spokesperson
Postal address:
! would refe my hea ing to be conducted in:
H Public (members from the general public may attend your presentation)
OR
o All hearin s are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of ail hearings, along with all ritten submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment. I he
WAPC recommendations are si ilarly published in a report on submissions and tabled in Parliament.
Signature
/
oiz
Note: Submissions MUST be received y the advertised closing date, being close of
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will NO l be consi ered.
for roa purposes
No.280 (Lot 1) Stirling Highway, Claremont
subject to survey
Extract of proposed changes: plan number 1.7146 (190-b )
1
Western
a. Australian
Planning
Propose reserve boundary
Scale 1:600
Commission
0
12
Propert boundar
c!ar«lS0.o'sn
31 ug 2011
Frorfu cd b/ Mnppinj & GooSpa'.ia! Data Brarch, Dfpaitn'.enl ol Planrlnj, Perth V/A
On behatt of tha V.'tstsm Aostf atan Flarn rg Corrn sjlon. fin A
Bass b'on -tico supcliid by Western Austut sn Land tn ormstio Air oirt LI 30-2032 4 .
Proposed area require
//A
metres
Western
. . Australian
\vA Planning
Commission
Enquiries: Mr John O'Hurley (6551 9187)
Property Ref: 190B, Claremont
WAPC Ref: 809-2-1-91 Pt 2 (RLS/0173)
Weng Hoong Nominees Ply Ltd
C/O Ron Farris Real Estate
PO Box 112
SOUTH PERTH WA 6151
Dear Sir/Madam
Re Property: Lo 1 (No. 28Q) Stirling Hwy, Claremont
Rationalisa ion of Sti ling Highway Reservation
later than 27 Jul 2012 to ensure your views are taken into consideration.
Regional Roads reservation to limit the reservation to land which realistically may be
the reservation is too wide in some locations, whilst not wide enough in others. odifying the
metre wide Primary Regional Roads' reserve, placed in 1963 and larger than necessary.
The amendment proposes to reduce the regional ese vation ove the above p operty.
The enclosed Amendment Report includes specific details and reasons for the a endment,
corporate@planning.wa.gov.au vv w.planning.wa.gov.au
ABM 35 482 341 493
DEPAffi MFNT OF PLANNING
0 1 JUN 2012
Form 41
FILE Q 2,
Submission
[ etropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1210/41
OFFICE USE ONLY
t
Submission 43
To: Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
p
i
Na e 4/•d aj-v A O4/
/ (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)
Address .. (. 7/.S ..
T.. A A. ,
Postcode . TfP.Q. ?.
Contact phone number. A..T.T. ...S .Tl7.
Email address
T/ps for completing a submission:
® Use headings or numbers to se arate different topics and issues
® Include property addresses and specific location descri tions where relevant
Submission
E No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
I will be represente by:
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
Note: Submissions MUST be received by the idvertised closing date, being close of
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late -submissions will NOT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - ttp://www.planning.wa.gov.au
Q 1 JUN 2012
Section 41 mendment (Subs antial)
FILE
Form 41
Submission)
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submissio 44
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name... .Pl.9>.Q.... ....?.£.h\ . .9 £
Address- . &.I ).' /Is)...
J /ifel ostcode ..fe.O..1.lO.
Contact phone number .(£>.&).Email address .p<?j
>
es
oj. c-. ;_
v
vs
° Include roperty addresses and specific locat on descriptions where relevant
° Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to com lete your submission
Sub ission
reviewed by myself and the following issues h ve been identified to reject the proposed increase
demolished;
2. The St Quentins building was only recently built and met ll local planning authority
requirements, ncluding density and appearance; and
, T.X
agre with the proposal to increas the flo of traffic along
Snrling Hwy but contests the propos l to increase the reservation boundary (red) along
Stirling Road.
0
Anyone who has made a written submission on the amendment may personall present the basis of their
written submission will be co sidered in determining the recommendation for the proposed amendment
whether you nominate to s eak at the hearings or not.
Further information on submissions and hearings is included in Appendix E of the a endment report.
Ef
IM©, I do not wish to spea at the hearings. (P lease go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
I will be represente by:
or
C A spokesperson
Postal
address:
! would prefer my hearing to be conduc ed in:
CD Public.(members from the general publ c may attend your presentation)
OR
C Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings c ommittee will be
° In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or ma ing its report on these submissions, copies of your
ta led in Parliament and pu lished as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment. The
WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissions and table in Parliament.
Signature
Date ...•?.:.D1.
Note: Submissions MUST be received by the advertised closing ate, being close of
Contacts: Telephone-(08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http:/Avww.planning.wa.gov,au
thewest
@ ®Uf (EUfstaustraliiiu
Thursday, March 15, 2012
PERTH'S RAPID GROWTH
Public transport
the key: Michael
Daniel ercer
Former WA governor and cele¬
brated engineer Ken Michael has
spoken of the need for Perth to
have more public transport.
He says the city cannot rely on
building more roads to underpin
its development.
Dr Michael, who gave the key¬
note speech at the annual C.Y.
O Connor lecture last night, also
called on authorities to draw up
longer-term plans for the State
amid concerns current t meframes were too short.
Less than a year since stepping
down as WA’s representative of
the Queen, Dr Michael said State
governments of all persuasions
had done a pretty good job of
managing development.
But citing the trailblazing
work of famed engineer C. Y.
O Connor in the late 1800s and of
Gordon Stephenson in designing
Perth’s roads in the 1950s, Dr Mi¬
chael said authorities should
never lose sight of the big picture.
He pointed to Perth’s transport
network to highlight the claim,
saying policymakers would need
to plan for more public options if
the rapidly growing city was to
remain sustainable.
And he singled out light rail as
a means of public transport that
could be an important part of the
solution.
Ideas man: Former governor Ken Michael. Picture: ichael Wilson
I’m very supportive of it in
providing connections between
key centres, Dr Michael said.
The fundamental nature of
our society is that we have to
move goods and people around
the place in the best possible way.
“Public transport provides an
absolute key to the effectiveness
of this continuing.
You can’t, and I would agree
with this, continue to have more
and more and wider roads.
“We are fairly well dominated
justify e panding the North-
by the car and I don’t think that is
bridge tunnel.
going to change dramatically.
“But, if there are services
available that encourage people
not to use their cars - with better
facilities, with better accessibili¬
ty, with comfortable public trans¬
port then I think we would do
very well.
The comments are likely to
carry wei ht with the Barnett
Government after Transport
Minister Troy Buswell referred
to Dr Michael’s “sage advice to
0 1 JUN 201
Section 41 Ame dment (Substantia!)
Form 41
Submission
Rationalisation of Stirling Highwa Reservation
OFFICE USE ONLY
Submission 45
To: Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
p
-
ii
Name . . .o Al LCyY fxftj O.lJ .
Address . . a j. A) A IX f -\
IT) H. AA3 .W £). Postcode ... 'SA!?. .
Contact phone number .AAAt ). . A/.S3>. ) Email address AtATA).'.ll.Vj. SAC :A. .r\lA A-.('J?-s] ,
Co TT .
Submission
. AA 3 ! .U f?X.[ (At
. -
..
. .'A.'A) .t: . i-r.QA'.
SAJ.AAQA
\i.Q
. 'yAAAp.AA a a t ... - r. 0 k . v. vQ/ i o r. .Q-.0 aAAAA. x. .¦.. AAcAA
QtQKaQ ... .A'A Q/k AXX (AAj 3.A.. .. SAQt l.. J.A . A... .3.A A- -O.AxAXVl A. i-JT. .Al ,.
.
•
¦
.?.
...r?.:
.1.
.U-STA... ,q3 . .do.AAQ.. ... . AQAA.V-.O.. .0 A-..C A;o:vv
T)
OX... TjA s S. .'Vi k ( \ D tbCA... .A T.Abkf!.. .x.. .Aft:Cb... . !(A)/A.A. A>bj •. lb... ib . LT. !XA>r .
A.V C .. FSr ..Tlt l .. .Ox.oJX- . .bu ..AA/ bXA... fAfbX).. .fe ..b '.AX b ..A £. . .ThUi. .Tc.
(.YWN<
.
f
o
... .. .fev
. .L .
fi QbQ.. ..
. v. .. .Q« .. .tH
\..
S .9K? .. SiqX. . * . . .H.A .VbfX) ,
p.o \ .. 3 \ oXA?.. AXBP.AAVr . -
3o ' .QrA.SXT ;?t .... X?A qsawQ. . &>. ... .S Q XO.. Asaa>. ... bbv.QTb.. .. 3 x? ( XV\ . XX..
.b)
<51..
.fe.
..
.Sft
. .. .QaA(XyX:a . c .. . oaX Aoc . bcTL O.. lb.. !yA2-k>l .
.Cj
LL-
.. AsTQibt .
•
.
1/ ,. Xo. iVAbA j.
A . A A r . A' TXb.A).. . .AaAA. . X.. bbX/XA. . .6. .XHb. .XX/AC.'bbb.. .. lb.. .'TiAXtAb.. .(bXx ¦ ¦ aX&A.'AA. .
.. .Al .. .'ty.O.'.VA.O.' b
.O.Vb. fAX- At.
IbP.v.A. X VfX. jbVVA.. VXat.j. . .?XvAaX. . iAt'XA A . . 7.V3. .XayXX. . . x r.. ..
. AbAb.A)... .bx .. xtO. c.c .Q . . ...
XbXXX.. .X .L
¦.
bjH.v.TbA)
Xx.vAT. .
turn over to co plete your sub ission
Ab>
0 No, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
I would refer my hearing to be conducted in:
OR
To be signed by person(s)
SignatuVe
Date .
Note: Submissions IViUST be recei ed by the advertised closing d te, being close of
Romilly Carton
Personal Assistant to GM
Telfer Gold Mine
NEWCREST
MINI G LIMITED
Telfer Gold Mine. Telfer WA 6762, PO Box 6380. East Perth 6892. Australia
TellerT 61 8 9158 6372 Perth T 61 8 9270 7070 F 61 8 9158 6380
M +61 (0) 448 389 536 E romilly.carton newcrest.com.au
W www.newcrest.com.au
0 JUN 2012
Section 41 Amendment (Substantia!)
Form 41
FILE
Submission
OFFICE USE ONLY
- • ' • -
•
|i
To: Secretary
Western Australian Planning Commission Submission 4S
Locked Bag 2506
Perth
WA
6001
,
„
Name . ....Tft .A
Address
....
I..
..
.$
.
".
Contact phone number..
$r
.°.....
Postcode
Email address
.
.
¦
.'y
T; s for completing a submission:
Submission
X *
tirM
O.fe... .$7 .O....?
¦ ¦ .hos/&. ..0.
s S
rf.
!
.«
..
.. I. /. ..
X.
s
...
.
?
t..
r.Of&r
p.c?s
V-
.
..
.
...
...
fTS;
I j.. . -.e-..
...
;|®
...
(.1
t #. . :f.« & i.ck&ss.... ...
1
...
.
p
i
.m
.
A
c.
. f-AAA ....
?(
. ...
.c
.$.
©
. fl.<f ...a
s&
....
k®.
g...fX';.
'fM
..
.
r
.
.s.&
. th&'. ...
hj....
......
i.4.
....
>
.
'6
.Cfe ....k ?Z(e. ,...... ncta,
efi
.
.
X ... v.X»...w1.pj ®c rt rb-€r-.....
.....XbcL
.
t
». r.
X*-..
.h
si.
"
.
c&Ls.srfc,
<*.<5..C..
fa...
....
..
£
....
?
turn over to co lete your submission
..,
.
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compuisory. Your
OR
I will he represented by:
o
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
ll 6 JUN 2012
Section) 41 Amendment (Substantial)
Form 41
Su missions
Rationalisation of Stirling High ay Reservation
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 47
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
Address .A..(.Wf5?.
©t.' f.'/A.'TA.sy. .J.
Postcode
.
.y.AI.
Contact phone number....% ?. .I Email a dress
o Use headings or numbers to separate different to ics and issues
° Includ property addresses and specific location descriptions wher rel vant
o Attach additional numbered pages if you requir more space to complete your submission
Sub ission
reviewed by myself and the following issues have been identifi d to reject the proposed increas
in rese vation area.:
demolished;
2. The St Quentins building was only recently built and met all local planning authorit
requirements, including density and a pearance: and
.. W rirUT . 'rT.-. i agree with the proposal to increase the flow of traffic along
Stirling H y but contests the proposal to increase the reservation boundary (red) along
Stirling Road.
o
Y-o*-
ko-i
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes box is icked. This is not compulsory. Your
written submission will be considered in determining the recommendation for t e proposed amendment
Further informa ion on submissions an hearings is included in Appendix E of the amendment report.
OR
O Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings, (Please complete the following details)
Cl] Wlyself- My telephone number (business hours):
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
Public (members from the general publ ic may attend your presentation)
OR
Private (onl the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
° In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of our
submission or the substance of that submission, may e disclosed to third parties.
° All hearings are recor ed and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and pu lished as public records should the Governor appro e the proposed amendment. T e
To be signed by personfsl makin the submission
Signature
Date
Mote: Submissions MUST be received b the advertised closing date, being close of
business (5p ) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will NOT e considered.
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fa - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://www.plannjng.wa.go .au
2 7 JUl, 2012
Form 41
£ILE .,. I
Submission
OFFICE USE ONLY
ddition to
To: Secretary
Sufomissoo
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
!?>
Name ...
7
(
I (PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY)
(pjz=.
Address ..l?.>.NYLL.E.TfA : Postcode
... o
,-A
.
Contact phone numberDr .kV.C.<? .. ...TAk.>.T..' . Email address
° Use headings or numbers to separate differ nt topics and issues
o Include property addresses and specific locatio descriptions where relevant
Submission
.
.-rrr7.
E
CK'X
ca yrv_
...
.'
.
v
t
r
m
_
_
....
<~C,\
_Vr)
'.Ch1. .'
m.
,
.7
.
.
.-
r
.
5
cX
. . ?. <Ti ErSrt .... .'r rWrtd bC, v.Y>. . d.'TF..
¦ .(. fL,v.JT. f . .'TrA . cT t.
C
'
VTrr).Et
-
; .
FL
S-N E TL&
.
r Yi-VrY
7f?.... Ai rtxy.'O L
: p .L VT?...
iTT T
t'. xe. oa ky ... tEx
C if
.
. TL
ffr.
fT S
1?rh5 rr ~ i 1
•/Vn O
-
r5
O L
Tr.... fA f?.Y.~ fr Y_ i.t rr,
rr -. .ipk . ,oy
.. .VrF G... .7.. ftiT...
• • • .Aj-A • • .' TiOrY-.Yrr .T . fVP.
....
G .'-. . Y'T?r'F:
¦ •l7'»... * >. .£
ik.
.Yi . >:v.(.:
>.... thf/
7 .. . . . k sd Kr»r
... AxC- Y Y (Vrfe
ft . srYT.Y ,....(?. ,<Xy
Yi£>.7? 1
. i&Shi&teG.
y 0
.
_. ' _ _ .Liii.Y.LrYTr1.
.Vt F/.'YFC.IYy . .. ? .. XTrt
Al Ax w A.. ...:- . c -; xT
. . .C iYr
i-
C J. .v?.V. y.V.£y1L1 ' rf r... ..rrA Prfrf c
X-. . .Y iL. .Vy.VPrY.YX .VS-
... .CSA
, & &!&
G*-<?
:
F... .OCV.T
, X>. .XV,>>A FrP.>/ tr r
A; *... X -r.7.7.. ~
-
r ..
Pr..
i
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compulsor . Youi
Further information on submissions and hearings is inclu ed in Appendix E of the amendment report.
OR
D Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)
o
A spokesperson
Postal
address:.
.
.
i would p efer my hearing to be conducted in:
Public (members from the general public may attend your resentation)
OR
Private (onl the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may be
q In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
tabled in Parliament and published as public records should the Governor approve the proposed a endment. The
To be si ned y person(s) makin the submission
Signature
Date
Note: Submissions MUST e eceived by the advertised closing date, being close of
business (Semi on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will NOT be cons dered.
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; ebsite -hl!p:/Avww.plannin .wa.go .au
0 7 JUN 2012
Form 41
FILE
Submission
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 48
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
j
Name.. n j U
.MteuO.V
pto mp S/i o F5p Sf -r '
Addres
,
Postcode..
.
.'I
Submission
Q
.(
A r. k
ho
\ ).... r. . . Q \c\\.Q' i.... /frr.
... g.l \
bY
r.
lkv.-Y.
.
.
c
3 j i ... tpofc Yi.. .P YYYY. ;... . >4PYr3 . . ...Ci.iJ.
yrv r U if\G\ eKpi'
P0..
,(y pr
P
. ...
r
p.
i .Ip...
philrrtT
i. . .... . .-e.C . .
I
p. :. id
,... . 1 P.d
... PY.F .i.... .... h.\.k d P.C....
d.
P<p up + 1 fY. ... .Qd YY. (;.|2.iTT prYY .tpj.
V ( .i/vt. P. p. D.YT
... .dD.
. xp. i
spupVi. j \0 [a eg b.v . y. ...x fe r.....
x
>
. 1 2 t .... .cl(
pi.A x .cv.Mr.... £?.{
>\ W-0 .....PXA Pa.x:....X .\ X.7..Pr....!P b.I .frX-TX!.
0 YV p >\ \ p j rA, .Vk .0. .... j/YrM .\.. .1 .L . O'.CY
X...b .kX
dbYP A.l .d b.
bo.c .d (rb.p .w. .y-fX....,€x.,p.x\x>.Y.i.o.xr...P .... .xf e ...vp.l..bvbfBb c ¦
p p pp p X k o. p. yj. ...lb .LPp px r . .P i .LA0 Ipp.il A.. .P d.bi
P0 Iv pv f&\\ V. Vl.vnM....C \.Q\ \Gj....few .wv.p. .....Qb.fe.. p.r..Wwi.b.1 c: A
C.Q .b: b.
.?. b.... .ixt. D b.\Tc x\ .wJ. ..Ap.l x ,\b.. ..p/&pw.vC:tpC.4. ...x..
(2pv 1 -A Wvp _ _. .ULSP M... .pW.' ...rfevlb.... . Pi-.W .C. . j Sb.:. !.fed4. b:.. P .bg
ofe ecifpxtp.P \ b. :hxAb...P AAPPP.AT.. fV.P.M...ip. Pbr.P X..dieb.
do C W vxieu
wy t t ' ¦ > P Pi p P i dpx xI £- bNx bT 'l IPp,
L-
, LP
o tu n ove
to complete your submission
afpo+d pa-i
(T V,-. cT ft V p U
XiCS
> Pb i q Cxp
sr
Y iA X«-e i+ f' p
e lopx c!'
m
OR
I will be ep esented by:
EJ Myself - My telephone number (business hours):
o
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
I would p efe my h aring to be conducted in:
OR
0 All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
To be si ned by,person(s) making the submission
Signature
jt _y.
Date .
Note: Subrfiissions MUST be recei ed by the advertised closing date, being close of
business (Spm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will NOT be considered.
Contacts: Telep one - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://www.planning.wa.go .au
C 3438
32 J
CURT
DEPARTMENT OF PLA NI G
0 7 JUN 2012
For 41
Submission
FILE 1 Z
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Su miss omi 49
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
o i\ lo
.
y\
<
u->
\ \ feip ij AS
Address ... . iO...
,/\
pr'nt clearly) r o
ck .'Al . | . r! ... .S'?r'r. V ,
'"
Postcode .. . PA.fr.
Email address - CC'
Submission
fete?.
m
S o, I do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
° The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC maybe
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://v/ww.planning.wa.gov.au
Shaping the F ture
Our Ref: P99038-001
Contact: Ashwin Subramaniam
6 June 2012
Cardno (WA) Pty Ltd
ABN 77 009119 000
Secretary
Locked Bag 2506
PERTH, WA, 6001
Dear Sir/Madam
11 Harvest Terrace
West Perth WA 6005
PO Box 447
West Perth WA 6872
Australia
Phone +61 8 9273 3888
Fax +61 8 9486 8664
Email wa@cardno.com
www.cardno.com
SUBMISSION - METROPOLITAN REGIO SCHE E A ENDMENT 1210/41 RATIONALISATION OF STIRLING HIGHWAY RESERVATION
In response to the formal advertising of Amendment No. 1210/41 to the Metropolitan
Region Scheme (MRS), the following submission is lodged by Cardno (WA) on behalf
of our client, BP Australia Limited ( BP ), who operate the BP Service Station on Lot 1
(No. 553) Stirling Highway, Cottesloe (herein referred to as 'the subject site ).
It is understood that Amendment 1210/41 will facilitate the rationalisation of the existing
Stirling Highway Road reservation over the subject site. The existing reservation under
the MRS currently extends over the whole of the subject site. The reduced road
reservation will result in a residual land area of 537m2, with the remainder of the site
(207m2) being subject to the Regional Road reservation. The residual land will be zoned
'Urban under the MRS as part of this amendment, and most likely rezoned to 'Town
Centre under the City of Cottesloe Town Planning Scheme No. 2, in accordance with
the adjacent landholdings.
Although the proposed amendment is resulting in a reduction in the current reservation
over the subject site, it will still have detrimental impacts on it’s existing operations. The
proposed reservation extends over the existing forecourt area of the site and as such is
affecting the most critical component of the service station. The disturbance to the
forecourt area will render the whole site useless for a service station.
The proposed road reservation will also diminish the value of the site as it will affect its
potential use as a future Town Centre’ site, which would be consistent with all adjoining
land uses.
If the proposed road reservation is approved over the subject site BP will claim
compensation in accordance with the Planning and Development Act 2005 on the basis
that the rationalisation will still result in the site being unable to be operated as a service
station or developed as a town centre development.
Australia • Belgium • Canada • Ecuador • Germany • Indonesia • Italy • Kenya •
New Zealand • Papua New Guinea • Peru • Tanzania • Unite Arab Emirates •
United Kingdom • United States ¦ Operations in 85 countries
Quality
ISO 9001
# SMGt GAL
2
Thank you for your attention to this matter. If you have any queries or require additional information, please
do not hesitate to contact me at your convenience on 9273 3888.
Yours faithfully
Ashwin Subramaniam
Town Planner
for Cardno
cc: Loreley De Los Santos - BP Australia Pty Ltd
www.cardno.com
2 0 JUN 2012
Form 41
Submission
file
i?
Rationalisation of Stirling Highway Reserva ion
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Western Australian Planning Commission Submissio
Locked Bag 2506
Perth
Name
WA
3c>.W.4A..rf..<?.
6001
.O. .A
.
5(0)
i
i
r.. . O.
Address ...S..
J.T/&
6. J .k . . ( O.I. 7.
Contact phone number.
Postcode
Email address JO /fS<:.*£
o./J.
.c&ty/.au
Submission
/ &dSG:..
,s.u£./ ?/ss
turn over to compl te our submissio
y .,
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below'Yes' box is ticked. This is not compulsory. Your
OR
1 will be re resented by:
or
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
EE Private (only the people nominated by you or the hearings committee will be
o The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may
SUBMISSION
METROPOLITAN REGION SCHEME PROPOSED AMENDMENT 1210/41
1) Bowra and O Dea Funeral Directors have had a presence at 571 Stirling Highway
Cottesloe, at the intersection of Jarrad Street over the last 8 decades and are part of the
local fabric, offering a valuable service to the community.
2) The current proposal for the rationalisation of the Stirling Highway Reservation proposed
in Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1210/41 affects those premises to such a
profound extent that Bowra and O Dea will not be able to operate its business from the
land remaining after the taking of the reservation.
3) Several issues may conspire in the permanent loss of this long standing branch of Bowra
and O Dea. These issues are:
a) Funeral Parlours are contemplated under a Town Centre zoning in the local town
planning scheme, but are an A-A use under the scheme, permitted at Council
discretion. Therefore, no guarantee exists that a similar use will be approved by
Council on another similarly zoned site in the locality.
b) It has been the experience of Bowra and O’Dea that funeral parlours are often a
misunderstood land use and that an approval for this use, or for the establishment of a
new facility, can be hampered by emotive opinion within certain factions of the
community. Therefore, factional pressure can prejudice a discretionary decision,
potentially removing the potential to re-establish the business on an alternate site.
c) Given the tightly held nature of property in the Cottesole commercial and retail
precinct, the possibility of Bowra and O’Dea identifying another suitably zoned site
with Stirling Highway frontage offering appropriate access and egress characteristics
is remote.
d) We believe that this is an unacceptable outcome at several levels. Firstly, the local
community may permanently lose an important service. Secondly, this set of
circumstances specifically disadvantages Bowra and O’Dea compared with other
more generic land users. Thirdly, Bowra and O’Dea will suffer a potentially
irreplaceable loss to its business enterprise, the cost of which would be considerable.
Page 1 of 2
4) With regard to the highway rationalisation scheme at a global level, we do not believe
that it adequately addresses the following critical issues:
a) Relief of existing congestion surrounding private schools in Claremont affecting both
westbound and eastbound traffic during peak times.
b) The ability of Stirling Highway to grow into the future as a regional road link catering
for increased population densities along its length.
c) The ability of Stirling Highway to support additional modes of transport such as light
rail to supplement existing forms including road, cycle and heavy rail.
5) Existing planning policies have a medium term view (Directions 2031). Planning experts
such as Richard Weller suggest that a longer term view is needed for planning and the
provision of infrastructure, possibly to century s end, in order to adequately cater for the
needs of our cities on a global level. Shorter term views are likely to accede to local or
political interests, resulting in policies that may preclude the implementation of
meaningful initiatives which in many cases will be unpopular but necessary. If the
existing highway reserve is rationalised for the piecemeal construction of bus passing
lanes, cycle lanes and turning lanes; then that is likely to be the extent of future
infrastructure possible within that reserve. The existing reserve (circa 1963) is extensive
but seems to more adequately provide for the goal of providing a meaningful long term
transport solution for what is an important regional road link. Any decision to expand the
reserve after the proposed rationalisation will come with a far greater cost, both socially
and financially. It is our opinion that the current proposal for rationalisation of the
Stirling Highway reserve is ill-conceived, bordering on irresponsible; and is not
consistent with the longer term interests and needs of our community.
Bowra & O’Dea - Funeral Directors
department of planning
j 9 JUN 2012
Form 41
file uzlosM
Su mission
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Western Australian Planning Commission v
Locked Bag 2506
Perth
Name
.
..
WA
I I il;) 11H ll 11& T ii (()) If il S3,
6001
¦
.
.
j
(plqC
Address ... . ... .. .... IX
Contact phone number .A
Postcode f. .... /
Email address ,.. . Q YS . I- C/ . . r..
o Use headings or numbers to s parat different topics and issues
o Includ property addresses and specific location descriptions vriiere relevant
° Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submis ion
Submission
demolished;
2. The St Quentins building was only recently built and et all local planning authority
congestion on Stirli:
ivy.
agree with the proposal to increase the flow of traffic along
proposal to increase the reservation boundary (red) along
Stirling Road.
eari g of su missions
submission to a sub-committee of the WAPC if the below 'Yes' box is tic ed. This is notcompulsoiry. Your
written submission will e considered in etermining the recommendation for the proposed amendment
Further information on sub issions and hearings is included in Appendix E of the amendment report.
W
No, I o not wish to spea at the hearings. (P lease go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
Y©s, I wis to speak at the hearings. (P lease complete the follo ing details)
I il! be represented by:
Myself - y telephone number (business hours):
or
E A spokesperson
Postal
ad
ress:
II woul prefe m hearing to e conducted in:
E Public (me bers from the general pubi ic may attend your presentation)
OR
° T e WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC ay be
° In the course of the WAPC assessing sub issions, or ma ing its report on these submissions, copies of your
submission or the su stance of that sub ission, may be disclosed to third parties.
° All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all earings, along with all ritten submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and publishe as public records should the Governor approve the proposed amendment. The
WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on submissions and table in Parliament.
Mote: Submissions MUST be recei e b the advertise closing date, being close of
business (5pm) on 27 JULY 2012. Late submiss ons will NOT be considered.
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http:/Avww.planning.wa.gov,au
JJUN-E012 19:40 From:
To:S5519001
ddd
Pa se:1 2
DEPAHTMENT 'r PLANNING
iecfion 41 Amendmen (Su stantial)
1 JUN 2012
Form 41
Submission
FILE
l
Rationalis tion of Stirling Highway Reservation
OFFICE USE ONLY
To: Secretary
Submission 12
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
(PLEASE PRINT CLEAR Y) A
Address .. J."7.-£ o n IT. Postco e .£ Q.i.0
ontact phone
umber ..O. L .Email address fif.lklj4o
<2u' ( l C-&9V3
o Use headings o numbers to separate different topics and issues
a Include property addr sses and pecific location de cri tions where relevant
o Atta h additional numbere pag s if you require more space to complete your submission
Submis ion
.
...
/7
Sat:
.
¦ .fiA . ¦ q p'0)f\VoJ v. .t
Xq. p.Xl
...
. <xts.A.. i
. i
¦ ¦ ¦• .
. .Wfi
L
clft
.. Ou .. . X
J..be. -i yr..
-
c, ¦ • .
A.. - .. . b... A : ..
l
TC W.i r
.. -7
.
.
. A a ,S|
.
.
io a
CjmAnJ
s+.\n L.'
H..iA.
c a.. .
La . .
O-'fi---ktAJS-i £-S4.& &....QW&sf
.w
>
Mo pf'k .
turn ver to complete your submission
I
fidjh
.
H«-A - -I5e. Ca,uu0
S\,<kQ
....
'. .. .s
.. ..
7. , (d b i
. . l ..£•¦• - C .l vo ic- ¦ ¦ ¦ fXo.. .OIaA ts • ¦ S.
.
vsX
pAv t...Isxus s....Du...Qoo,
¦ ¦ ¦ ai?.. .'.Vq.... .- y erJt..Mkjl .
o. .... Cor
-
,
. Oy OA . £rfx6> 1 r t s.... rfe.. . r
. .w cV... A k .Tt ....
A- ¦ t¦ • • •
I
S7 M7 ,-t
.iro...,. o vac .r kiL,....
.
|.
-.,
10-JUN-2012 19: 0 From:
To:65519001
Page: 2
Anyone ho has made a written submission on the amendment may personally present the basis of their
written submission will be considere in determining the recommen ation for the proposed amendment
Further information on submissions and hearings is included in Appendix E of the amend ent report.
Mo, I do not wish to speak at t e hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
1 will be re resented by:
Myself - My telephone numbe (business hours):
or
A spokesperson
Name of spokesperson;
Contact telephon number (business hours):
Postal address:
8 would prefer my hearing to b© con ucted in:
Public ( embers from the gen ral public may attend your presentation)
OR
permitte to attend)
The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions mad to the WAPC ma be
<5 In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on th se submissions, copies of your
submission or the substance of that submission, may be disclose to third parties.
o All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of ll hearings, along with all written submissions, are
tabled in Parliament and pu lished as public records should the Governor approve the proposed a en ment. The
WAPC recommendations are similarly published in a report on su mission® and tabled in Parliament.
Motet Submissio s MUST be received by the advertise closing date, bein close ©IF
business (5pm),on 27 JULY 2012. Late submissions will NOT be considered.
Contacts: ielephone - (03) 6551 900; Fax-(08) 6551 9001; Cmail-mrs@plannirig.wa.gov.au; Website - http://wvmplanning.vva.gov,au
14 JUKI 2012
Form 41
Submission
FILE M- LS 1(9.2./,|<P
OFFICE USE ONLY
To:
Secretary
a
»
-
Western Australian Planning Commission SlIDITIISSIOII §<3
Locked Bag 2506
Perth
WA
Name
6001
(zft.
I
|
..
Address
. .C&.fi.&.P. .
Postcode C\
.f. .
Contact phone number....7.'s$.3. .& Email address .( )0.rfff .
» cosn
0 Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
/}
Eif
No, l do not wish to speak at the hearings. (Please go to the bottom of the form and sign)
OR
or
A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
To be si ned by person(s) makin the submission
Signature .
.?.
Date
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://www.pianning.wa.gov.au
REDUCTION IN LA D REQUIRED FOR ROAD PURPOSES
18 MDERUP CLOSE, CLAREMO T
PROPOSED RE REQUIRED 4 SQU RE MET ES
SUBMISSIO
1 I agree that the proposed changes to Stirling Highway are necessary in order to
address traffic congestion through Claremont and to make it safer for cyclists
and pedestrians.
2 ffect on My Prope ty
a The proposed .4 metre reduction on the southern boundary will bring the
boundary wall 15 cms from my parapet garage wall. This will mean the
loss of mature trees and a footpath and I will not be able to gain access
behind the garage.
b The proposed .2 metre reduction on the northern boundary will bring the
boundary wall 35 cms from the roof eave.
3 Future Sale of the P operty
Will I be gi en any guarantee by the Government that my property will be
purchased by them if it fails to sell within a reasonable period of time? I would
prefer to sell now, rather than wait for all this to happen and to have to endure
the disruption of having a large limestone wall moved nearer to my house.
1 8 JUN 2012
Form 41
Su m ssion
FILE
ationalisation of Stirling Highway Reservation
OFFICE USE ONLY
To:
Secretary
„
.
Western Australian Planning Commission SypmBSsto 5
Locked Bag 2506
Perth
[\jarne
WA
Chfi-fL-f
6001
I
|
( C?'7
Address , , ... frr
; .. .-f.r....
I . .4 .
Postcode
Contact phone number 9 . 9.9 7. Email address
Submission
r .
? £r
.JL
Juid
Af
'j
r o
>
turn over to compl te your submission
earing of submissions
a"
OR
or
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
S would prefer my hearing to be conducted in:
OR
® The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC may b .
Note: Submissions R/IUST be received by the advertised closing date, being close of
Contacts: Telephone - (08) 6551 900; Fax - (08) 6551 9001; Email-mrs@planning.wa.gov.au; Website - http://www.planning.wa.go .au
DEPARTMF P NNiN'Gj
l
Form 41
0 6 JUL 2012
Submission
file t-S /O Z. -%
Addition to
To: Secretary
Submission 54
Locked Bag 2506
Perth WA 6001
Name
i
c? M '
V. o < i
Address
Postcode
Contact phone number 7777.77.7 Email address ....• 77.
Include property addresses and specific location descriptions where relevant
• Attach additional numbered pages if you require more space to complete your submission
Submission
/2c.
r |
/ll
i L lin & / .j-1 g Cj f
M
ut ro s .
f'
.
O
OR
O Yes, I wish to speak at the hearings. (Please complete the following details)
or
E A spokesperson
Postal address:
OR
• The WAPC is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 1992 and as such, submissions made to the WAPC maybe
• In the course of the WAPC assessing submissions, or making its report on these submissions, copies of your
• All hearings are recorded and transcribed. The transcripts of all hearings, along with all written submissions, are
Re Lot 1, 111 StirlingHighwayNediands
I support the reduction of the road reserve, and the smaller the better.
As views against any resumption of property 1 provide the following:
At this point in the highway the median strip is up to 5rn wide, and suggest
consideration given to using this as effectively as possible.
Any extra width required should be provided from properties on both sides of the
highway to minimise disraption.
Commonsense needs to be applied to the width of any footpath on the north side of
the highway. It may not be able to be straight or of consistent width.
Now this proposal has been aired, there is general conce that property so affected
will even now, decrease in value. What is your comment?
The possible plan for a bus lane to turn left ( north) into Dalkeith road, as matters
stand, is drawing a long bow , because buses heading from Fremantle go straight
along the highway, and buses going along Dalkeith road continue in that direction. So
is ther©ny need for such a lane?
if a left turn lane is really required, it could commence at Baird Av., leaving plenty of
room for more than one bus, considering that at the moment none turn left at Dalkeith
road, (see above).
Right and left turns from the highway are always a problem. There should only be
designated points for these to occur. Suggest Vincent St. for a right tu .
I hope this has given you some ideas to minimise your resumption costs and still
achieve what you want.
One final question. 1 am sure you have thought this through, as any public servant
would. If there is a resumption of common property on a strata plan and payment is
subsequently made, to whom is payment made to on the statement/cheque?
If it is to the strata company, according to the relevant act, the strata company camiot
pay the individual owners. It remains in a fund. Once money is contributed to a strata
company fund, it cannot be returned to owners.
1 look for ard to your reply on this.

MRS Submissions (Volume 1 of 6) - Part A

Transcription

Similar documents

BGTV Earth Week Gallery Flyer

Submissions on the - Have Your Say

Submission Themes: Knit Picks is looking for

discoveryAUG15

PDF call - ESEC/FSE 2015

Tree

witnesseth - City of Naples

Competition Overview - Canada`s Next Top Ad Exec

are factory farms hog-tying people`s

Particles on the Wall