care international in rwanda

CARE INTERNATIONAL IN RWANDA
COMMUNITY ASSISTED ACCESS TO SUSTAINABLE ENERGY PROJECT
(CASE)
INTERIM NARRATIVE REPORT/ANNUAL 2008
Kigali, January 2009
ANNEX VI
INTERIM NARRATIVE REPORT
• This report must be completed and signed by the Contact person
• The information provided below must correspond to the financial information that appears in the
financial report.
• Please complete the report using a typewriter or computer
• Please expand the paragraphs as necessary.
• Please refer to the Special Conditions of your grant contract and send one copy of the report to
each address mentioned
• The Contracting Authority will reject any incomplete or badly completed reports.
• The answer to all questions must cover the reporting period as specified in point 1.6
1. Description
1.1. CARE Österreich, Association for Development Cooperation and Humanitarian Aid
1.2. Name and title of the Contact person: Kathrin Pauschenwein, Program Officer Africa
1.3. Name of partners in the Action: ADENYA, CITT/KIST
1.4. Title of the Action: Community-assisted Access to Sustainable Energy in Rwanda (CASE –
Rwanda)
1.5. Contract number: 9 ACP RPR 49 2
1.6. Start date and end date of the reporting period: January 1st –December 31th 2008
1.7. Target country(ies) or region(s): Rwanda, Southern Province, in the Districts of Nyamagabe,
Nyaruguru, Huye and Gisagara.
1.8. Final beneficiaries &/or target groups1 (if different) (including numbers of women and men):
Target groups:
24,000 vulnerable households (120,000 individuals) Most of these households (HHs)
are headed by widows, orphans and people living with HIV/AIDS.
100 charcoal producers from the southern province.
500 Village Savings and Loan Groups (VSLGs); each VSLG has an average of 15
members
300 Orphans and Vulnerable Children and Youths (OVCY) .
1
2008
“Target groups” are the groups/entities who will be directly positively affected by the project at the Project
Purpose level, and “final beneficiaries” are those who will benefit from the project in the long term at the
level of the society or sector at large.
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
2
Final beneficiaries:
The total population of the four districts: about 1.2 million people.
1.9. Country (ies) in which the activities take place (if different from 1.7): N/A
General
Currently, over 96% of Rwandans depend on wood for domestic energy because alternative sources of
energy are unreliable and unaffordable for the majority of Rwandans, leading to extensive
deforestation. This 3 year (2008-2010) Project has been designed to address the issues of availability,
access to, and production of reliable and affordable energy sources. Specifically, it will contribute to
the reduction of the gap between biomass energy supply and demand for 24,000 poor rural and periurban households in Southern Rwanda by 50% by the year 2010. The project activities support the
national strategies aiming at saving more biomass, producing more biomass, and substituting more
alternative energy sources for the biomass. The major project activities are related to trainings (in
improved stove making, in energy saving cooking techniques, in improved carbonization techniques,
in income-generating activities management & marketing), community mobilization and behavior
change communication for the use of biomass saving techniques and environment protection. In
implementing the project activities, CARE Rwanda works in close partnership with two local
institutions that have expertise in innovative/alternative energy technologies, CITT-KIST (Centre for
Innovation and Technology Transfer of Kigali Institute of Science and Technology) and ADENYA
(Association for the Development of NYABIMATA).
2. Assessment of implementation of Action activities
2.1. Activities and Results
Project activities started with a short delay of 4 months due to staff recruitment process that took
longerthan planned. The main reason was the difficulty that the Country Office faced to find a
suitable candidate for the Project Management Position. The position had to be advertised twice and
this took almost 3 months.
Also partnership building took more time than planned, the CO had to start MoU (Memorandum of
Understanding) negotiation with project partners, make project presentation to partners as most of
their senior staff had changed between the period of the project elaboration and the implementation.
The CO also looked for other potential partners for co-operation.
The project has started with the recruitment of key staff, the project Manager and the Training
Coordinator. The Training Coordinator started working on March 1st and, the Project Manager has
been hired to start on 14th April 2008. Two Field officers for the Project have been also recruited and
started working at the end of June 2008. Each one is in charge of implementing Project activities in
two Districts. After recruitment, orientation sessions have been organised for the new staff, mainly
focusing on understanding of the CASE Project, European Commission and CARE’s regulations and
procedures.
The project Manager and the Training Coordinator are based in Nyamagabe District, Southern
Province, where Care Rwanda has already a Sub-office; working place (rooms) has been given to the
team to host the staff and the project equipment.
The period May-December 2008 has been a crucial time for CASE Project. The start-up activities
have been carried out in these months. In the beginning of May, the project team has made a project
equipment and material need assessment. Based on the findings, procurement plans have been
prepared and implemented over the rest period of the year. The purchase process took more time than
planned as CARE had difficulties in following the rules of origin and nationality applicable for EDF
funds. In the need of complying with the EC procurement guidelines, project staff consulted time to
time EC technical staff in Kigali for technical help. Consultations made have been fruitful; process to
2008
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
3
be followed in purchasing main items such as vehicle and motorbikes has been made clear. Now, the
procurement team at CARE Kigali revised the work done before and is improving it.( E.g. elaboration
of a detailed and more clear tender dossier for the above items). In the meantime the project could
borrow some of the urgently needed items from other CARE projects, such as motorbikes and vehicle.
Nevertheless it complicated the implementation of the project activities.
Introduction of CASE Project
To ensure good start of the Project activities, the preparation of Project introduction & its real
introduction to local authorities, partners and the targeted community members have been done. The
project team has met all the 4 District Mayors and environment partners in order to introduce the
project and ask for their support and collaboration during the implementation. All 4 district authorities
were very enthusiastic about the project, as it responds to needs in terms of domestic energy,
environment protection and economic development for women and youth, and is in line of their
district development plans. They provided letter of support to facilitate the baseline study in selected
sectors and cells in April and May 2008.
The Project team held a number of meetings with the Ministry of Infrastructure (MININFRA), to
introduce the project to them, request for collaboration and identify area of potential collaboration as
CARE and the Ministry are both funded for improved stoves projects by the EC. It was noticed that
CASE project is in line with district plans and in the coming Biomass Energy Strategy, co-funded by
the Government of Rwanda and EC. Care Rwanda has been invited to come on board and share from
time to time its experience during the strategy development process.
Care Rwanda might have conducted the project environmental impact assessment. After submission
of the project document to REMA (Rwanda Environment Management Authority) for analysis, the
institution gave to Care an exemption to conduct such assessment. It considers the project not having
irreversible negative impact on the environment and in its response was highlighted that an
environmental impact assessment is not required.
In order to build on a participatory system and thus increase community awareness and ownership, the
project team presented the project to communities, along with the baseline study, which was
conducted in May 2008. The project has been also presented to potential beneficiaries during sessions
on the setting of the beneficiary selection criteria. Representatives from all the target groups attended
these sessions.
Preparation and building of partnership
CARE held meetings with ADENYA and CITT/KIST, aimed at preparing the project start up
activities and defining partnership and funds management principles. The Project has made positive
progress in the partnership building with Partners. Discussion meetings have been organised and
attended by the Project team with senior staff of ADENYA and CITT/KIST. Drafted MOUs have
been deeply discussed and finalised. Each partner has been helped by the project team to develop its
detailed action plan based on its roles and responsibilities in the implementation of CASE Project
activities. ADENYA has signed the MOU with CARE RWANDA and has already recruited 2 staff to
coordinate the field activities. This took place in August 2008.
During our meetings with CITT/KIST, it was highlighted that the institution was facing a number of
challenges related to management, internal governance and leadership. Even though the new
leadership of the centre has shown good collaborative willingness, too much turnover among senior
staff was still observed. The Rector and the vice-Rectors of KIST had been changed and the new
appointed ones had to be well briefed on the Project. Given this challenge, CARE has made contacts
with other organizations (Public & private) with relevant experience and expertise in areas planned to
be initially covered by CITT/KIST and explore the possibility for subcontracting some activities that
would be implemented by CITT/KIST. CARE has met IRST (Institute of scientific and Technological
Research) a government institute based in Huye; ISAE (Institut des Sciences Agronomiques et
2008
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
4
d’Elevage du Rwanda) a government institute that provides education on agricultural, livestock
sciences and that made research on economic use of firewood. For private organisations, CARE has
met a local cooperative called “KORA” that makes and sells improved stoves in the Project area and
met also a local Consultant called Sabin who also time to time contracts with government in providing
stoves to communities; today he is doing consultancy works for the FAO Program related to
reforestation support and economic use of wood.
The results from these visits made, have shown that each of the above organisations concentrates its
efforts on one type of stove (rural or urban). No knowledge developed on other existing types. This
was a serious limitation that can not allow the Project beneficiaries to get a chance of choosing
efficient and affordable stove that they like. The conclusion at Country Office was that the
CITT/KIST which can work on different models interred into partnership with CARE as planned. The
MOU with CITT/KIST has been signed in the beginning of September. CITT/KIST has been asked to
take on board, especially during training sessions and based on the stove to be made and required
skilled personal resources from the above institutions. There are no specific contracts signed between
CARE and any of the other organisations/companies above. However, all of them have been requested
to be member of the Project steering committees in order to allow the project to continue benefiting
from their experiences.
Set up of project committees: Steering committees and Management committees
Members of the above committees at both levels (District & National) have been identified and
contacted. The terms of references for each committee have been written. Members have been
meeting as planned.
Preparation and conduction of baseline study:
Terms of references for baseline study consultant have been designed and produced. A consultancy
firm (local private company) named International Business Centre “IBC” has been recruited,
following EC and Care procedures. The baseline tools have been drafted and finalized in
collaboration with the hired company, the project team and other CARE relevant staff (M&E
professionals, economic security progamme team members, project teams based in the Southern
Province). Apart a questionnaire developed a number of improved stoves photos had been collected
and shown to interviewees in order to know the existing types within the targeted community. The
baseline to ascertain the current situation of energy supply and demand in the target area has been
conducted by the company. In total 813 interviews have been carried out to collect information.
78.72% of them are female and 21.27% are male. Among female, 41.8% are heading households.
The baseline findings have been presented during a stakeholders’ workshop organised by the project.
The Baseline survey has shown that local authorities have motivated and supported households to
plant more trees and to use improved stoves as a solution to the deforestation and to the increasing
demand of firewood. However more efforts have to be done because the use of exclusively improved
stove in the household is at 48.2% and only 58% of households have planted at least one tree around
the house during last year and a lot of hectares have to be reforested. Those efforts should be oriented
in the promotion and dissemination of improved stoves as well as in trainings in making and repairing
improved stoves with emphasis on follow-up strategies for a sustainable use.
There is a great need of tree plantation not only around the house but also on mountains/hills
deforested, especially those with slope above 40%. The increment of firewood demand for cooking
appears as a major environmental and economic issue not only in the surveyed districts but also in the
whole country at the micro and macro levels. The use of traditional three stone stoves and traditional
charcoal production techniques contribute significantly to increase of quantity of firewood for
cooking and producing charcoal. Charcoal production sector was found disorganized and has to be
structured and empowered. In additional the exposure of women and their children while cooking is
one of causes of respiratory and eye diseases.
2008
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
5
In the stove selection workshop selected participants including Andreas Zahner, the Program and
Policy Advisor Poverty & Environment from Care Austria (who was visiting Care Rwanda) also
worked on the indicators based on the results of the baseline. The baseline study and the updated log
frame including revised indicators have been finalized. As a reminder, during the baseline survey, data
collectors and project staff introduced the project to the involved VSLGs members.
These are photos taken during the baseline survey. In some areas, they use traditional and improved
stoves at the same time; damaged stoves are neither repaired nor replaced. A number of households
are still using traditional stoves (3 stones) which need too much fire woods.
In some areas, they use traditional and improved stoves at the same time; damaged stoves are neither
repaired nor replaced. A number of households are still using traditional stoves (3 stones) which need
too much fire woods. In some of the visited houses fixed stoves have been found, local associations in
the target area have shown the types of improved stoves produced and sold in the peri-urban and
urban areas. The followings are produced and sold by a local cooperative called Kora, located in Huye
District.
These types had been brought to the selection
workshop that put together improved stoves
from research institutions. CARE, partners,
lines ministries, representatives from the
targeted
District
authorities,
potential
beneficiaries and other stakeholders have
selected 4 types of improved stoves that are
being promoted by the CASE Project. This
selection workshop took place on the 5th
August 2008 during which four types of
stoves have shown high efficiency comparing
with other types present in the Country. They
have been recommended by participants for
being promoted by CASE Project.
The following four types have shown high efficiency comparing with other types present in the
Country. They have been recommended by participants for being promoted by CASE Project.
1. METAL-CLAY STOVE
2008
2. ROKET STOVE (clay)
3. SAW DUST
METAL STOVE
4. IMPROVED STOVE
DARFOUR
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
6
Activities related to Expected Result #1: 16,000 rural HHs and 8,000 peri-urban HHs use
improved stoves and save at least one ton of biomass per household per annum.
Training preparation: Formulate selection criteria for beneficiaries VSLGs, OVCYs and HHs
The project staff has drafted criteria for the selection of beneficiaries. Later, citeria have been
discussed and finalised with Local authorities, POWER (Promotion Opportunities for Women
Empowerment in Rwanda – another project implemented by CARE) Project field staff and Partner
Organisations staff before being finalised. As a reminder, the intended 500 VSLGs targeted by CASE
Project have been selected among the VSLGs established and working with POWER project in the
targeted Districts. POWER project is promoting loan and saving models among the VSLGs. POWER
field based staff played a great role in helping CASE staff to identify and select suitable VSLGs for
CASE activities. The cooperation between the two Projects is much related to the day to day exchange
of information on the targeted groups, exchange on the staff project plans to harmonise the field visits
and avoid a mess that two different interventions can create to the same target groups. Project staff
work closely with other CARE staff already present in the field in order to build Project interventions
based on the experiences that their have of the location.
Before starting trainings, meetings with representatives of trainees together with local authorities and
partners have been organised for selecting sectors and sites that have to host the first trainings. The
criteria used for selecting sectors were related to the intensity of the environmental degradation and
low coverage of improved stove use. A total of 6 sectors by working District have been selected,
which make a total of 24 sectors in the four Districts. For trainings sites, the same exercise has been
conducted, criteria were related to the availability of row materials, the distance from the location of
trainees and availability of basic infrastructure that can accommodate training activities, especially
regarding the possibility of material storage.
Training sessions on improved stoves making.
After the stove and beneficiaries selection, trainings for trainers on improved stoves have been started.
The strategies and methodology for the training sessions were as follows:
a) 2008 Beneficiaries: The training sessions were carried out in three sectors of each district for
all four districts; VUP (Vision Umurenge Program) inclusive. The total number of
beneficiaries is 446 out of 400 scheduled for this year coming to a percentage of 112%
achievement; these were all be trained in both of two types of cooking stoves: square mud
(Darfour type) and rocket stoves
b) Trainings took place from November 17th to December 24th, 2008.
c) Training teams: KIST/CITT availed 4 training teams, each team led by an Engineer supported
by 2 technicians of whom one technician must come from the district. The technicians helped in
the 1st week and then replaced by local technicians.
d) Training sessions: A total of 16 training sessions have been conducted. Each training session
was composed of 24 to 30 trainees and was facilitated by 1 Engineer and 2 technicians. The
theoretical part has been done in a group and they altogether have developed the first prototype.
This was followed by breaking the group into 2 small groups of 12 -15 people each; each group
guided by a technician developed 2 stoves. The total number of stoves produced by each group
is 5(of square mud) per training session and 5 and up for rocket stove.
e) ) Training materials. Some of the materials used in the construction of these cooking stoves
were sourced locally. These include: Clay, Sawdust, Anthill soil, Banana leaves, Soil blocks,
Burnt bricks, Sand…
Other materials such as molds, training kits, etc… were brought from KIST. The timetable followed
for each session:
2008
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
7
DAY 1
9am-3pm:
Theoretical
Training of
the group
using a
manual on
both types
of stoves
DAY 2
8:30 am-12:00pm:
Building the square mud
stove by the trainers
while the trainees look on
(with local bricks/ adobe)
1:00am-3:30pm:
Building the square mud
stove by the trainees
under supervision from
the trainers (with local
bricks/adobe)
DAY 3
8:30am-12:00pm:
Building the square mud
stove (with local
bricks/adobe) by the
trainees with minimal or
no supervision from the
trainers
1:00am-3:30pm:
Questions and answers
session, reflection on
lessons learnt, comments
and recommendations.
DAY 4
8:30am-12pm:
Building the rocket
stove by the trainers
while the trainees
look on
1:00am-3;30pm:
Building the rocket
stove by the trainees
under supervision
from the trainers
DAY 5
8:30am-10:30pm:
Building the rocket
stoves by the
trainees with
minimal or no
supervision from
the trainers.
10:30am11:30am:
Questions and
answer session,
reflection on
lessons learnt,
comments and
recommendations
12:00am-3:30pm:
Building a model
square mud stove
(with burnt bricks
with 3 cooking
places)
The project trainees making Darfour stove (Photo 1) and rocket stove (Photo 2), finalised rocket
stoves (Photo 3)
SECTOR
RUSENGE
NYARUGURU
RUSENGE
KIBEHO
RUHERU
KIBUMBWE
NYAMAGABE
KIBUMBWE
GASAKA
TARE
MARABA
HUYE
MARABA
MUKURA
MUKURA
GISHUBI
GISAGARA
GISHUBI
MUGOMBWA
MUGOMBWA
2008
Trainees
SITE
DISTRICT
GROU
P
People have been trained as follows:
1
2
3
4
1
2
3
4
1
RASANIRO
2
3
4
1
2
3
4
MARABA
RASANIRO
KIBEHO
RUHERU
KIBUMBWE
KIBUMBWE
GASAKA
GASARENDA
MARABA
MUKURA
MUKURA
GISHUBI
GISHUBI
MUGOMBWA
MUGOMBWA
F
M
PERIOD (NOV 10TH-DEC 24TH 2008)
W1
T
10-14/11
22
22
25
22
20
23
27
21
21
8
8
1
12
12
7
2
14
9
30
30
26
34
32
30
29
35
30
27
14
12
17
24
16
17
3
6
8
13
6
4
3
30
20
20
30
30
20
20
W2
17-21/11
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
W3
W4
24-28/11
19-24/12
/31
8
Community mobilisation and sensitisation on the use of improved stoves and environment
protection
Training sessions have been organised in order to raise awareness among the targeted communities on
the use of improved stoves. Specialist from the government institutions, Key ministries have been
invited to make presentations on the existing policies, strategies and laws regarding biomass Energy,
environment protection etc… Local leaders and the other participants have got information that
opened their mind towards friendshipness with environmental resources.
The Government representative (photo 1) and CASE staff (photo 2) facilitating awareness meetings
for CASE project beneficiaries and their representatives in Nyaruguru District.
Activities related to Expected Result # 2: 100 charcoal producers save 50% of wood by using
improved carbonization techniques.
The project staff have drafted criteria for the selection of beneficiaries. In the same way as this was
done for selecting improved stoves beneficiaries, the project staff discussed criteria with Local
authorities, POWER Project field staff and Partner Organisations staff and have been finalised. In
collaboration with ADENYA, the local Organisation that is responsible for trainings in improved
carbonisation techniques, the Project team has made contact with specialised institutions and
experienced charcoal makers in the Country that could bid for providing trainings. Institutions like
ISAE (Institut des Sciences Agronomiques et d’Elevages) and some private individuals have shown
interest in providing such trainings. On the 4th December 2008, carbonisation techniques selection
workshop has been organised at national level. Participants from scientific institutions, lines
ministries, representatives from the Districts offices, partners and project beneficiaries attended the
workshop. 4 carbonisation techniques have been chosen by participants for being promoted by the
Project as efficient and appropriate techniques. The techniques chosen are:
“ Meule Casamancaise”
“ Meule traditionnelle amelioree”
“Meule rectangulaire sur flanc de coton »
« Meule rectangulaire sur terrace »
A draw of Meule Casamancaise
2008
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
9
Meule rectangulaire sur terrasse
Meule traditionnelles
Meule rectangulaire sur flanc de coton
In year 2008 the project team put emphasize on the activities related to improved stove making and
using. This was an entry point for other activities. Activities relating to ER2 (100 charcoal producers
ave 50% of wood by using improved carbonization techniques) delayed a bit. This is due to the fact
that at field level, the carbonization activity was not supported by local authorities and in some areas
it was not accepted at all. This situation was not in line with existing policies and laws regarding
carbonization. So it was necessary to sensitize local leaders on these policies first by using
representatives from key Ministries and high government institutions such as Rwandan Environment
Authority. After the sessions organization of charcoalers for training have started. The trainings will
be started early 2009.
Activities related to ER3 (6,000 vulnerable women and 300 OVCY make and sell improved stoves,
thus raising their income by at least 40%) have not yet started. These activities are the consequences
of the activities related to ER1 and ER2. IGA activities could only start after trainings on improved
stoves and carbonization techniques have been implemented. The IGA to be developed are related to
the improved stoves making and carbonization techniques. Now after the trainings on improved stoves
making, beneficiaries have started to elaborate IGA to be supported by CASE project. This is an
activity to be expanded in 2009. The activity has to involve OVC, this particular group had to be
identified and selected as no CARE project in the zone works with them. We worked together with
other stakeholders to identify OVC. This activity has been completed and we are in a process of
preparing the OVC for IGA projects.
Meetings and workshops:
Apart from the implementation of Project planned activities, the Project team have organised
important meetings and workshops. The details are in the following table:
2008
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
10
July 08
05/08/08
0615/08/09
22/0819/09/08
2328/10/08
04/12/08
16/12/08
Oct-Dec
08
23/12/20
08
1
2
3
4
6
7
8
9
2008
5
Date/
period
No
Project Management
meeting
Study tours by trained
beneficiaries and local
authorities
Training on improved stove
making and use
Meetings to introduce project
to communities, define and
validate criteria for project
beneficiaries selection
Meetings to select trainees
on improved stoves
Trainings on government
environment protection and
biomass Energy policies
and related laws
Workshop to select
carbonization techniques to
be promoted by the Project
Workshop to select stove
types to be disseminated in
the project targeted area
Project introduction
Topic
Type of participants
/31
Representatives from ADENYA(Legal representative on top)
Representatives from CITT-KIST(CITT Director on top)
Representatives from CARE( Country Director on top)
Beneficiaries
Local authorities at sector level
1 local Radio journalist
Trainees selected from Saving groups
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
Eastern part
of the
Country
8Sectors(2
training sites
per District)
ADENYA
Office
Community and saving groups representatives, authorities from
the lowest government institutions (Cell & Sector).
- Charcoal burners
- Districts authorities in charge of environment and
infrastructure
- Beneficiaries representatives
National level
Representatives of project beneficiaries from 4 Districts
Districts authorities in charge of environment protection
Representatives of line Ministries
- Research institutions (3 of them)
24 Sectors of
4 Districts
4 Districts
Districts authorities: Mayors, Vice-Mayors, Executive
secretaries, Directors of infrastructure
National level
Representatives of project beneficiaries from 4 Districts
Districts authorities in charge of environment protection
Representatives of line Ministries
Research institutions (3 of them)
24 Sectors of Authorities at sector levels and representatives of beneficiaries
the 4
(2 representatives from each saving group) and agronomists
Districts
All 4 Districts
Location
1
38
2
28
14
38
87
81
13
F
3
7
58
8
19
75
96
56
18
M
16
Participants
by sex
8
440
36
33
113
183
137
31
19
Total
partici
pants
11
2.2. Please list all contracts (works, supplies, services) above 5000€ awarded for the
implementation of the action during the reporting period, giving for each contract the
amount, the award procedure followed and the name of the contractor
Contract
Amount
Procedure followed Company/Institution
Name
of
Contractor
the
Consultant
€15,403
agreement for
the
CASE
Project baseline
study
Bidding process
International
Munyehirwe Anicet
Business
Center
(IBC) P.O.Box 3223
Kigali, tel (250)
08610448
Supply of 200 €28,000
training kits
Bidding process
BELL Company
2008
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
…………
/31
12
2008
2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
CASE Project action plan 2009
11
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
This plan will cover the financial period between the interim report and the next report.
Preparation of demonstration in the usage
and maintenance of improved stoves for
the 15,000 HHs
Refreshing training for the initial 500
members of VSLGs
Train the 15,000 HHs in energy-saving
cooking techniques
Production of basic improved stoves by
the trained HHs
Preparation of refreshing training for
improved stoves makers
Training of the 15,000 HHs in improved
stoves making
Production of improved stoves by the
trained ToT
Preparation of the production of improved
stoves by the trained ToT
ToT for the 600 members of VSLGs in
improved stoves making and 100 OVCYs
/31
Activities related to Expected Result #1: 16,000 rural HHs and 8,000 peri-urban HHs use
improved stoves and save at least one ton of biomass per household per annum.
Preparation of ToT: Select 15,000 HHs
and 600 members of VSLGs
Results& Activities
2.3. Please provide an updated action plan 2
12
CARE, CITTKIST,ADENYA
CARE, CITTKIST
CARE, CITTKIST
CITT KIST
ADENYA
CARE, CITTKIST
CARE, CITTKIST
CARE, CITTKIST, ADENYA
CARE, CITTKIST
CARE, ADENYA
Implementing
body
13
2008
CARE, ADENYA
Implementing
body
CARE, CITTKIST
CARE, ADENYA
Facilitate the establishment of 8 charcoal
storage facilities.
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
CARE
CARE
CARE
CARE, ADENYA
Follow-up on the activities of the 100
charcoal producers.
Activities related to Expected Result #3: 6,000 vulnerable women and 300 OVCY make and
sell improved stoves, thus raising their income by at least 40%.
Preparation of marketing and
management training material
Training of the 800 women members of
the VSLG, 100 charcoal producers and
200 OVCY in income generating activities
management and marketing
Facilitation of linkages between improved
stoves makers and charcoal producers
with micro financing institutions
CARE, ADENYA
CARE, ADENYA
Production of improved charcoal
Activities related to Expected Result # 2: 100 charcoal producers save 50% of wood by
using improved carbonization techniques.
Train the 100 charcoal producers in
improved charcoal carbonization
CARE, CITTKIST
CARE, CITTKIST, ADENYA
12
Conduct demonstration in usage and
maintenance of improved stoves for the
15,000 HHs.
On-going supervision, coaching and
refresher training courses
11
CARE, ADENYA
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Community mobilization/Awareness
raising campaign
Conduct demonstration in the usage and
maintenance of improved stoves for the
15,000 HHs
Conduct environmental education
sessions in the 4 districts
Results& Activities
14
2008
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
Project Monitoring/ Learning/ Document & Dissemination activities
Monitoring meetings (management and
steering committees)
Internal reporting
Donor reporting (preparation and
submission)
Bi-annual/ Annual Stakeholders
Monitoring & Evaluation & Learning
Preparation of the mid-term evaluation:
Development of ToR and recruitment of
consultant
Implementation of the mid-term evaluation
Build organizational capacity of 500
VSLGs
Results& Activities
11
12
CARE
CITT-KIST
ADENYA
Consultant
CARE
CARE
CARE
CARE
CARE
Implementing
body
CARE, ADENYA
15
3. Partners and other Co-operation
3.1. How do you assess the relationship between the formal partners of this Action (i.e. those
partners which have signed a partnership statement)? Please specify for each partner
organisation
The relationship between partners ADENYA and CITT/KIST is so far good. ADENYA has recruited
two field staff who are implementing Project activities in the field. The management leadership of the
organisation continues to show greater interest for implementing the Project activities. Senior staff of
the organisation have shown commitment and availability in fulfilling their roles and responsibilities.
The organisation has made their reports as required in the MOU.
CITT/KIST new leadership have improved work relationship with other organisation involved in the
Project. They attend meetings, give feedbacks when required, share information etc… However, the
instability observed at the high management of the institution has affected work speed in
implementing agreed plan. The new senior staff need time to understand the signed MOU and the
Project in general. This delayed sometimes implementation as they had to approve most of the
required means of implantation (plans and money). The project registered delays in paying for food
and transportation for trainees in the field. As a solution, CARE Staff and CITT staff agreed to let in
future, CARE pay allowances for trainees instead of transferring such money to CITT-KIST. A part
that CITT-KIST has implemented their plans as required and respected as much as possible the MOU
signed with CARE.
3.2. How would you assess the relationship between your organisation and State authorities in the
Action countries? How has this relationship affected the Action?
The relationship between Care Rwanda and State authorities is generally healthy; this explains the
interest and involvement of MININFRA (Ministry of infrastructure), which selected CARE as a part
of monitoring committee members in charge of developing Biomass Energy Strategy. Ministry staff
have helped the Project by making field visits to the Project and made presentations on the
government policies and laws related to Biomass Energy. The project staff have been inviting line
ministries in all workshops organised and all invited sent representatives. This relationship already
developed needs to be strengthened, to ensure full participation and buy-in of relevant local
authorities, for ownership and sustainability purposes. At local level, CARE is member of the Joint
Action Forums in the target Districts. These forums put together local government and all
development actors within the District. CARE has used this channel also to strengthen relationship
with local authorities and they are very supportive of CARE intervention.
3.3. Where applicable, describe your relationship with any other organisations involved in
implementing the Action:
•
•
•
Associate(s) (if any) N/A
Sub-contractor(s) (if any)
Final Beneficiaries and Target groups
Most of final beneficiaries and target groups have already benefited from other services provided by
previous CARE projects in the southern province; they are familiar with CARE interventions so it is
strength for the success of project activities. A high % of the Project target people have been met and
good relationship has been developed. They are committed and respond to invitations given by Project
staff.
Other third parties involved. N/A
3.4. Where applicable, outline any links you have developed with other actions
FAO in Rwanda has developed a similar project that will be implemented in the Eastern part
of the Country and CARE is in touch with this organisation. Consultations between each other
about progress and lessons learnt are ongoing. Harmonisation in terms of improved stoves to
2008
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
16
be promoted has been wished by the FAO so that the organisation has been invited in the
stove and carbonisation techniques selection workshop.
3.5. If your organisation has received previous EC grants in view of strengthening the same target
group, in how far has this Action been able to build upon/complement the previous one(s)?
(List all previous relevant EC grants).
4. Visibility
How is the visibility of the EU contribution being ensured in the Action?
The European Commission may wish to publicise the results of Actions. Do you have any
objection to this report being published on EuropeAid Co-operation Office website? If so,
please state your objections here.
The project team has developed an action plan based on the Communication and Visibility
Manual for EU External Actions as required by the EC. When the project was being introduced,
participants were informed about the donors (EC, ADA & CARE) of the Project. Trainings sites
are always marked with a banner containing key messages related to sensitisation and logos of the
donors. The produced documents have been marked with logos e.g. baseline report. Key assets
such as Project office and, computers have been marked with EC, ADA and CARE logos.
Announcements in local news paper have been done with appropriate visibility elements.
Conclusion
Even though the project implementation begun with a delay of 4 months, most of key activities have
been achieved or started. CASE Project is now well settled in the target communities, get support
from beneficiaries, government authorities and other stakeholders. Project partners are familiarised
with their role and responsibilities, they implement correctly their plans versus MOUs signed with
CARE Rwanda, except some minor challenges that need to be addressed, e.g. administration
procedures are different and specific for each of the partner and this need a harmonisation.
Name of the contact person for the Action: Kathrin Pauschenwein
Report written by Prudence Ndolimana, CASE Project Manager, CARE Rwanda
Signature: ………………………………………
Location: CARE Österreich and CARE Rwanda
Date report due: 31.3.2009
Date report sent: 31.3.2009
2008
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
17
APPENDICES
Appendix 1
TRAINING TOOL KIT ARTICLES
ITEM S
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
2008
Trowels
Hoes
Jerrycans
Spades
Machetes
A meter/tape measure
Plumb line
T-Square
Nylon string
Stickle
Sheetings
Basins (plastic)
Hammers
Chisel
Spirit level
Moulds ( see sample)
QUANTITY
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
18
Appendix 2
LIST OF PARTICIPANTS IN TRAININGS
Venue: Nyakibungo……/Sector…Gishubi………District: Gisagara
s/n
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Names
Nsengimana theogene
Mushimiyimana donatha
Nsengiyumva felicien
Bamurange pelagie
Mukamurenzi fatuma
Uyisenga damien
Yabaragiye christine
Bukuru didas
Nyiramuruta agnes
Mazina francois
Aburorabo vedaste
Bugenimana genevieve
Habineza augustin
Mukantagara jacqueline
Rwambibi jonas
Mujawamariya serafine
Miburo beatrice
Munyentwari felicien
Havugiyaremye xavier
Nyirabukeye pelagie
Nikuze Beatrice
Mukansenga donatille
Urayeneza josephine
Mukaruranwa jeanette
Mukamusoni jacqueline
Ndayisaba jean damacene
Mushimiyimana josephine
Habumugisha aloyis
Nyiraneza ansille
Musabande francois
VSLG name
AJPG
Twitezimbere
Twizimbere
Twizimbere
Twisungane
Twisungane
Abishyizehamwe
Intumwa
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Intumwa
Imanzi
Imanzi
Twisungane B
Twisungane B
Inkingiyamajyambere
Inkingiyamajyambere
Twitezimbere B
Abahuzamugambi
Dushyigikirane
Imboni
Imboni
Bategarugoribari
Abahuzamugambi
AJPG
Bategarugoribari
Twisungane A
Twisungane A
Dushyigikirane
Cell
Nyabitare
nyakibungo
Nyakibungo
Nyakibungo
nyakibungo
nyakibungo
Nyabitare
Nyakibungo
Nyabitare
Nyabitare
Nyabitare
Nyakibungo
Nyakibungo
Nyakibungo
Nyabitare
Nyabitare
Nyabitare
Nyabitare
Nyakibungo
Nyabitare
Nyakibungo
Nyabitare
Nyabitare
Nyabitare
Nyabitare
Nyabitare
Nyabitare
Nyakibungo
Nyakibungo
Nyakibungo
Venue: Gabiro……/Sector…Gishubi………District: Gisagara
s/n
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
2008
Names
Nanwahafi augustin
Mwungantare donate
Twagirimana varantin
Twagirayezu alphonse
Uwitije claudine
Mukazayire genevieve
Bampire verediana
VSLG name
Abajyambere
Igisubizo
Abishyizehamwe
Igisubizo
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Twisungane
Cell
Gabiro
Gabiro
Gabiro
Gabiro
Gabiro
Gabiro
Gabiro
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
19
s/n
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Names
Sabayagirwa marie
Nyirandorimana domitira
Nyirantaganira liberathe
Mukangarambe Odette
Karwera jamviere
Nyiramana alphonsine
Hitimana faustin
Niringiyimana anastase
Nyirabizimana agnes
Nyirarukundo pasicasie
Mukansabimana volonique
Nyiranziyimana vestine
Simbananiye aloyis
Hagenimana olivier
Nzamwitakuze solange
Niyoyita
Ntegamaherezo claudine
Uwambaye drocelle
Mukeshimana liberahta
Uwiringiyimana epiphanie
Nzamunganyande
Nyiraharyarimana cecile
Ndindiyimana etienne
VSLG name
Tuzamurane
Tuzamurane
Jyambere
Abajyambere
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Ubudahemuka
Twisungane
Turwanekubuzima
Twitezimbere
Ubudahemuka
Twisungane
Twitezimbere
Abisunganye
Duterimbere
Duterimbere
Dukomezumujishi
Abisunganye
Turwanekubuzima
Twizamure
Twizamure
Dukomezumujishi
Jyambere
Venue: Mugombwa Parish…/Sector…Mugombwa
s/n
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
2008
Names
Mukangamije M.claire
Niyonambaza genevieve
Kabanda JMV
Niyonizeye appolinarie
Nyirambonabucya
Uwambajimana providance
Nyirabizimana mediatrice
Niyonizeye liberata
Uwizeyimana jacqueline
Ndagijimana francois
Barihenda emanuel
Barakagwira
Nyiraneza elizabeth
Uwitonze beatrice
Sanyu epaphrodite
Nzasabimfura evaliste
Mukamwiza clautilde
Niyitegeka francine
Nyiraneza gloriose
Mukeshimana victoria
Cell
Gabiro
Gabiro
Gabiro
Gabiro
Gabiro
Gabiro
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
Nyeranzi
District: Gisagara
VSLG name
Tuzamuringo
Tuzamuringo
Tuzamurane C
Tuzamurane C
Duterimbere
Duterimbere
Tuzamurane D
Tuzamurane D
Terimberemugore
Terimberemugore
Duteimbere C
Duteimbere C
Dufatanye
Dufatanye
Abahizi B
Abahizi B
Intiganda
Intiganda
Abisunzimana
Abisunzimana
Cell
Kibu
Kibu
Kibu
Kibu
Kibu
Kibu
Kibu
Kibu
Kibu
Kibu
Kibayi
Kibayi
Kibayi
Kibayi
Kibayi
Kibayi
Mugombwa
Mugombwa
Mugombwa
Mugombwa
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
20
Venue: Mugombwa Parish…/Sector…Mugombwa
s/n
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
Names
VSLG name
Cell
Ntakirutimana emanuel
mukasarambuye christine
nyiraminani victoire
musabyemariya donatira
uwizeyimana sophie
itangishaka marie.gorette
mukansanga christin e
muhayemariya justine
mukantwari marie louise
mukamageza bernadette
nikuze julienne
uwanyirigira tarisira
bankundiye beatrice
uwitonze josephine
hajyarimana emil
niyonsaba consolee
mujawamariya therese
uwimana consolee
uwineza jacqueline
uwimana alexandre
Inyjyamumuigmbi
Indashyikirwa
Tuzamurane A
Tuzamurane A
Abisunganye A
Abajyanama
Dushyirehamwe
Dushyirehamwe
Abunzubumwe
Abunzubumwe
Abatigayubuke
Abahizi A
Abajyanama
Injyamugambi
Abahizi A
Twitekubuzima
Twitekubuzima
Abatigayubuke
Indashyikirwa
Abisunganye A
mukomacara
mugombwa
Mukomacara
mukomacara
kibayi
mugombwa
mugombwa
mugombwa
mugombwa
mugombwa
mogombwa
kibayi
mugombwa
mukomacara
kibayi
mugombwa
mugombwa
mogombwa
mogombwa
kibayi
Venue: KIBUMBWE………/Sector: KIBUMBWE
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
2008
District: Gisagara
Names
Mukahirwa Josine
Mvuyekure Dismon
Mbanda Juvenal
Mukangarambe Alphonsine
Nyiramajangwe Edureda
Mutamuriza Fortuné
Mbabariye Vicent
Mukarugwiro Anatalie
Ukwitegetse Vestine
Musabyimana Rosa
Dusabimana Francois
Uwimana dathive
Hakizimana Efron
Rusizana Aphrodis
Habimfura Innocent
Mukamana Francine
M.rukundo
Nyirahatangimana
Mukamurenzi Phoib
Dusabimana Béata
Mutuyimana Drocelle
Harelimana Xavier
Uwingabire Godance
Mukartamu Violette
District: NYAMAGABE
Sex
F
M
M
F
F
F
M
F
F
F
M
F
M
M
M
F
F
F
F
F
F
M
F
F
VSLG name
Twongerumusaruro
Umutinyawo
Komayaga
Abakoranamurava
Abatanyuranya
Abatanyuranya
Abahujinama
Twongerumusaruro
Twisungane turwanya SIDA
Twisungane turwanya SIDA
Rubyiruko Twitezimbere
Turwanya SIDA
Umutinyawo
Imboni
Komayaga
Rubyiruko Twitezimbere
Turwanya SIDA
Inyange
Abahujinama
Twizerane
Imbereheza
Imbereheza
Abakoranamurava
Ubumwenubwiyunge
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
Cell
Gakanka
Gakanka
Gakanka
Kibibi
Gakanka
Gakanka
Bwenda
Gakanka
Bwenda
Bwenda
Nyakiza
Gakanka
Gakanka
Gakanka
Gakanka
Nyakiza
Kibibi
Bwenda
Kibibi
Kibibi
Kibibi
Kibibi
Kibibi
Bwenda
/31
21
Nr
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
Names
Mukamuyango Emerthe
Sinumvayabo Elias
Bampire Concessa
Muhutu Damien
Kabagwira Nerena
Nsengumukiza Callixte
Ayirwanda Donat
Nyirabagabe Crisensiya
Sex
F
M
F
M
F
M
M
F
VSLG name
Inyange
Imboni
Twizerane
Ubumwenubwiyunge
Twisungane
Dufatanye
Dufatanye
Twisungane
Cell
Kibibi
Gakanka
Kibibi
Kanyenge
Kibibi
Kibibi
Kibibi
Kibibi
Venue: TARE ……………/Sector: TARE ……………..District: NYAMAGABE
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
2008
Names
Nkundimana Noel
Habimana Vicent
Nkundiye Félicien
Mukakabera Fais
Uwibambe Antoinette
Nyirantezibyimana Germaine
Twagirumukiza Baptiste
Bazigaga Espérance
Nyirantwari Mary
Mukamana Florence
Mukabutera Gaudiose
Yankurije Odette
Mbarubukeye Vincent
Munyampirwa Sylvestre
Musabyimana Sylvestre
Gakunde Alphonse
Ntamuhanga Justin
Mugemangango Celestin
Mukarurangwa M
Muunyandera Evariste
Uwizeyimana Virginie
Mukankusi Evarista
Mukeshimana Thérèse
Uzakunda Boniface
Mukankaka Rosa
Nyiransengimana cecile
Munganyika Bernadette
Uwimana Sandrine
Mukankindo Velene
Mukeshimana Josephine
uwimpuhwe Florentine
Muhirwa Francois
Kamizima Florida
Mugiraneza
Nyiramajangwe
Sex
M
M
M
F
F
F
M
F
F
F
F
F
M
M
M
M
M
M
F
M
F
F
F
M
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
M
F
M
F
VSLG
Urugero
Tuzamurane
Tuganimana
Tuganimana
Abashizubwoba
Abashizubwoba
Tuganeyesu
Urugero
Twitezimbere Bategarugori
Dukundabana
Dukundabana
Twitezimberebategarugori
Dufatanye I
Terimberemutegarugori
Sindagiramusaza
Twitezimbere
Abishyizehamwe
Twitezimbere
Abakarana
Tuganeyesu
Sindagiramusaza
Abunzubumwe
Abadacogora
Dufatanye II
Dufatanye II
Tuzamurane
Terimberemutegarugori
Urugero
Abadacogora
Abunzubumwe
Urugero
Abakorerabushake
Twisungane
Twisungane
Dufatanye
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
Cell
Gasarenda
Kaganza
Nyamigina
Nyamigina
Gasarenda
Gasarenda
Buhoro
Gatovu
Kaganza
Buhoro
Buhoro
kaganza
Nkumbure
Nkumbure
Gatovu
Gatovu
Gatovu
Gatovu
Bushakekavu
Buhoro
Gatovu
Nyamigina
Nyamigina
Nkumbure
Nkumbure
Kaganza
Nkumbure
Gasarenda
Nyamigina
Nyamigina
Gasarenda
Nkumbure
Nkumbure
Nkumbure
Nkumbure
/31
22
Venue: Rango A……………/Sector: Mukura……………..District: Huye
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
Names
Dusabe jeanne d'Arc
Uwizeyimana Laurencie
Nyirarindwi Annonciate
Mukasisi Thacienne
Nyiraminani Josepha
Uwamariya Perpetue
Uwimana Thérèse
Mujawamariya Venancie
Mukankusi Anastasie
Mukandekezi Marie
Niyoyirera Francine
Nsabimana jean damascène
Nyiramana Megitride
Mukantabama Alvera
Kanamugire Vicent
Habimana Innocent
Mukantwari Césarie
Muhongayire Clarisse
Munganyinka Grace
Nyiraminani Appolinarie
Nyandwi jean Bosco
Iryamukuru Jean De Dieu
Sex
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
M
F
F
M
M
F
F
F
M
M
M
VSLG
Indashyikirwa
Indashyikirwa
Twikure mu bwigunge
Kwisungana
Abuzuzanya
Abuzuzanya
Twitezimbere
Duterimbere
Twikure mu bwigunge
Twizigamire
Abishyizehamwe
Twizigamire
Abishyizehamwe
Duterimbere
Duterimbere
Twitezimbere
Twitezimbere
Duterane inkunga
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Local Technician
Local Technician
Cell
Buvumu
Buvumu
Buvumu
Bukomeye
Buvumu
Buvumu
Buvumu
Buvumu
Buvumu
Buvumu
Buvumu
Buvumu
Bukomeye
Bukomeye
Bukomeye
Bukomeye
Bukomeye
Bukomeye
Bukomeye
Bukomeye
Rukira
Shyembe
Venue: RANGO A ………/Sector: MUKURA………District: HUYE
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
2008
Names
Sex
VSLG
Cell
Havugarurema Idris
Sekugabanya J.claude
Minani Pierre Celestin
Musabhyemariya Chantal
Mukakalisa Marie Goretti
Mukakamonyo Hassira
Kandamura Athanasie
Mukakabera Seraphine
Mukagasana Marie Goretti
Nzabandora Swaibu
Mukashyaka Francoisse
Nizeyemariya Speciose
Bishyika Joel
Habanabashaka J.Damacsene
Ruremesha JMV
Twagirayezu J.Damacsene
Mukankusi Theresie
Mukagakwaya Esperance
Mukantwari Fracoise
Nyirababyeyi Marie Goretti
M
M
M
F
F
F
F
F
F
M
F
F
M
M
M
M
F
F
F
F
Abizeranye
Dutreaninkunga
Inkeragutabara
Abajyamugambi A
Twisungane
Abizeranye
Twisungane
Twisungane
Urumuli
Abajyamugambi A
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Urumuli
Abifatanyije
Twitezimbere
Tujijuke
Abifatanyije
Tujijuke
Tuzamurane
Twitezimbere
Bukomeye
Bukomeye
Bukomeye
Bukomeye
Rango A
Bukomeye
Rango A
Bukomeye
Icyeru
Bukomeye
Rango A
Rango A
Icyeru
Buvumu
Icyeru
Buvumu
Buvumu
Buvumu
Buvumu
Icyeru
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
23
Venue: Kibumbwe1 /
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Sector: Kibumbwe
District Nyamagabe
Names
SEX
VSLG
Cell
Habimana Emmanuel
Mukankiko Alphonsine
Mukansonera Daphrose
Bizimana FranÇois
Mukamabano Beatrice
Mukantwari Venantie
Dusabimana Beazilisse
Hakizimana Jean Baptiste
Mukaneza Gemime
Nyiransabimana Rosine
Mukabahizi Olive
Umazekabiri Thacienne
Karangwa Felicien
Musabyimana Jeannette
Muhayimpundu Janviere
Mukantaganda Euphrasie
Mukandekezi Adera
Nyiransengimana Berancille
Nyiravuguziga
Hakizimana Jeannette
Mukanyemera Jeannette
Mukashengero Christine
Nyiratabaruka Catherine
Mukashema Marie Louise
Uhawenimana Modeste
Mujawayezu Beatrice
Nyirabaganwa Agnes
Murekatete Caritas
Karanganwa Felicien
Mukankusi Agnes
M
F
F
M
F
F
F
M
F
M
F
F
M
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
M
F
F
F
M
F
Twisungane
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Abahuzamugambi
Duterimbere
Abakundamahoro
Abatanyuranya
Tuzamurane
Fatingamba
Fatingamba
Abatanyuranya
Abadatehuka
Abunzubumwe
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Abakundamahoro
Ubumwe
Tuzamurane
Zigama
Twisungane
Duterimbere
Zigama
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Abadatezuka
Amahoro
Amahoro
Ubumwe mubyiyungo
Zigama
Umubitsikibibi
Nyakiza
Nyakiza
Kibibi
Kibibi
Nyakiza
Nyakiza
Bwenda
Nyakiza
Bwenda
Bwenda
Bwenda
Gakanka
Gakanka
Nyakiza
Kibibi
Nyakiza
Gakanka
Nyakiza
Nyakiza
Nyakiza
Nyakiza
Nyakiza
Bwenda
Bwenda
Gakanka
Kibibi
Kibibi
Gakanka
Nyakiza
Nyakiza
Venue: NGIRYI…………/Sector:GASAKA……………District: NYAMAGABE
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
2008
Names
Mukamurangwa Marthe
Wibabara Alphonsine
Mukankubana Edisa
Mukabaziga Agnès
Mukantwari Veneranda
Yankurije Annonciate
Muhawenimana Caritas
Niyirera immaculée
Dushimimana Julienne
Mukabatesi Francine
Nyirampirwa Mediatrice
Mukakarera Catherine
Umutesi Jeanne
Itangishaka immaculée
SEX
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
VSLG
Duteraninkunga
Duteraninkunga
Abajyamugambi
Abakoreramuco
Abajyamugambi
Abunzubumwe
Kundumurimo
Kundumurimo
Abisunganye
Kundumurimo
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Abisunganye
Abatigandakumurimo
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
Cell
Nyabivumu
Nyabivumu
Nyabivumu
Nyabivumu
Nyamugari
Remera
Remera
Remera
Remera
Remera
Kibanda
Kibanda
Kigeme
Nyabivumu
/31
24
Nr
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
Names
Mushimiyimana Claudette
Nyirambeba Hadidja
Dusenge Esther
Kasine Marie
Murekatete Anne Marie
Nikuze Philomène
Mukankindo Josephine
Mubarejo Priscille
Mukantwari Grace
Mukandoli Judith
Mukagasana Faith
Nyiramisago liberée
Senkware Emmanuel
Uwiringiye Fidèle
Kangabe Agnes
Venue: Rasaniro Part I /
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
2008
SEX
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
M
M
F
VSLG
Duterimbere
Jyambere
Duterimbere
Dufatanye
Dukundumurimo
Duhuzumugambi
Duhuzumugambi
Duhuzumugambi
Abunzubumwe
Abakoreramuco
Abisunganye
Abatigandakumurimo
Duterimbere
Abisunganye
Abisunganye
Sector: Rusenge
Cell
Nyamugari
Ngiryi
Ngiryi
Nyamugari
Remera
Remera
Remera
Remera
Remera
Nyabivumu
Kigeme
Nyabivumu
Ngiryi
Remera
Remera
District Nyaruguru
Names
Sex
VSLG
Cell
Mukabayiza Donata
Mukabanza Bernadetta
Mukaliberté M. Josée
Musabyemaliya Césarie
Mukagasana Venancie
Mukarutanga Odette
mukabonera Alvera
Nzirabatinyi Alphonse
Uwantege Angelique
Ngendambakenga Anastase
Mukamurama Berthe
Mukamana Dorothéa
Mukanyarwaya Annonciata
Mukaseli Donatille
Habyarumuremyi Athanase
Mukarugwiza Eugenie
Habimana Evariste
Bakayiranga Marie Renné
Mukagasana Therèse
Nyiramana Pélagie
Nyirahabimana valerie
Bizimana Narcisse
Nteziryayo Martin
Mukarurangwa Marguerite
Mukarunyange Clinia
Mukamutali Christina
Mukarusheme Stephanie
Murebwayire Gerturde
Iyamuremye Silas
Musana Innocent
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
M
F
M
F
F
F
F
M
F
M
F
F
F
F
M
M
F
F
F
F
F
M
M
Abisunganye
Abizerana
Abizerana
Tuzamurane
Tuzamurane
Abihanganye
Abisunganye
Abisunganye
Abajyamigambi
Abajyamigambi
Tuzamurane
Abihanganye
Abisunganye
Abadatabana
Twisungane
Twisungane
Abishyizehamwe
Abishyizehamwe
Abadatatirana
Abadatatirana
Abadatatirana
Dukundane
Abasenga
Abasenga
Dukundane
Abaharanira amahoro
Dufatanye B
Dufatanye B
tech
Abishyizehamwe
Raranzige
Gikunzi
Gikunzi
Maliba
Maliba
Raranzige
Bunge
Bunge
Cyuma
Cyuma
Rusenge
Raranzige
Raranzige
Maliba
Maliba
Maliba
Maliba
Maliba
Maliba
Maliba
Maliba
Raranzige
Raranzige
Raranzige
Raranzige
Rusenge
Maliba
Maliba
Kibayi
Raranzige
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
25
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Venue: Rasaniro Part II
/Sector: Rusenge
Names
Mukamana Béathe
Mukabeza Laurence
Nikuze Leophrosie
Mukamana Caritas
Nyirishema Laurent
Nyirazigama Liberree
Nshuitininka Francine
Mukakabare Bersile
Mukashema Veredienne
Kabugondo Emerithe
Karemera Venuste
Uwimana Theodette
Uwamurera Dorcelle
Mukabayire Placidie
Nyiramuhakwa Immacule
Minani Theogene
Habyarimana Damien
Mukagabiro Melanie
Mukasamali Feromine
Nyirahabimana Alphonsine
Rumanzi Jean Bosco
Kanzayire Tharcille
Mukamunana Euphenie
Kwizera Francine
Mukwangwije Vestine
Mukandanga Marie
Mugabekazi Claudine
Mukangenzi Beathe
Munyurangabo Alphonse
Nyaminani Ignace
Sex
F
F
F
F
M
F
M
F
F
F
M
F
F
F
F
M
M
F
F
F
M
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
M
M
Venue: Kibeho /
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
2008
Names
Mukarubuga Chantal
Mukantabana Rose
Mukamusoni Peragie
Nzeyimana Slyvestre
Ntihabose Genevieve
Mukarubayiza Consesa
Mukarubayiza Speciose
Mukankusi Catherine
Mukabatsinda Cecile
Uwizeyemariya Judithe
Duhozumwari Ansile
Mukagasana Françine
Mukarurangwa Eugenie
Kankindi Claudine
Nyiranani Beathe
Nyirahabimana Vestine
VSLG
Abizeranye
Abizeranye
Abaharanirakurera
Turwubake
Dufatanye
Dufatanye Kawa
Dufatanye Kawa
Dufatanye
Dufatanye
Urukundo
Abaharanira kurera
Abadacogora
Tuzamurane rubyiruko
Abahuzamugambi
Abahuzamugambi
Tuzamurane rubyiruko
Dufatanye
Abadacogora
Abahujemahoro
Girimpuhwe
Hinga worore
Abazirabute
Abazirabute
Turwubake
Abadatatirana
Abahujemahoro
Hinga worore
Urukundo
Abadatatirana
Twizamure
Sector: Kibeho
SEX
F
F
F
M
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
District Nyaruguru
VSLG
Rugoli
Rugoli
Abisunganye
Abahuzamugambi
Abahuzamugambi
Twisungane
Twisungane
Abisunganye
Abisunganye
Twisungane-Bana
Twisungane-Bana
Abatanyuranya
Abatanyuranya
Twitezimbere
Twitezimbere
Duterimbere
Cell
Gikunzi
Gikunzi
Bunge
Mariba
Cyuna
Cyuna
Cyuna
Cyuna
Cyuna
Cyuna
Bunge
Mariba
Raranzige
Gikunzi
Gikunzi
Raranzige
Cyuna
Mariba
Mariba
Mariba
Mariba
Cyuna
Bunge
Bunge
Mariba
Mariba
Cyuna
Cyuna
Mariba
Mariba
District Nyaruguru
Cell
Kibeho
Kibeho
Kibeho
Kibeho
Kibeho
Kibeho
Kibeho
Nyange
Nyange
Nyange
Nyange
Nyange
Nyange
Nyange
Nyange
Gakoma
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
26
Nr
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
Names
Mukamunana Feromine
Mukamana Dorcelle
Nyirmana Josephine
Mukamuzima Praceda
Ayinkamiye Françoise
Nyiramanwa Ferecite
Nyirantwari Donatille
Mukantabana Estelle
Mukarunyange Venasie
Nitonteze Beatrice
Venue: Ruheru/
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
2008
Names
Ruzigamanzi Vincent
Kabaganwa Esperance
Kubwimana Consilide
Niyonsaba Vestine
Rurangwa Jeremie
Kandenzi Bonifilde
Nyiraminani Console
Mukamwambutsa Francine
Habineza Elie
Musabyimana Eugenie
Sebaganwa Athanase
Mukarwego Josephine
Niyirora Annonciata
Nyirabenda Chantal
Itangishaka Julienne
Nyiraminani Estelle
Murerershejimana Vestine
Niyoyiremera Mediatrice
Ukubereyimfura Collette
Mundanikure Domitille
Mukarubibi Josephine
Nikuze Selaphine
Hitimana Martin
Habyarimana Enias
Nibarere Vestine
Nkundimana Alfred
Ntabareshya Jmv
Niyomukiza M. Rose
Nsanganiye Emmanuel
Kubwimana Florence
Rwasangabo Slyidie
Iyaremye Jean Damascene
Nsabimana Jmv
Ruhangintwari Nahason
SEX
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
VSLG
Duterimbere
Duteraninkunga
Duteraninkunga
Abadahinyuka
Twitezimbere
Twitezimbere
Abisunganye
Abisunganye
Abisunganye
Abadahinyuka
Sector:Ruheru.
Sex
F
F
F
F
M
F
F
F
M
F
M
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
M
M
F
M
M
F
M
F
M
M
M
M
VSLG
Intumwa B
Dufataneurunana
Duhugurane
Abadatebana
Umurava
Duhugurane
Umurava
Tuzamurane A
Jyamberemubyeyi
Jyamberemubyeyi
Tuzamurane B
Dufataneurunana
Abizewe
Abizewe
Intumwa
Tuzamurane A
Twitezimbere
Dufatanirizehamwe
Urwunge
Urwunge
Jijukamubyeyi
Jijukamubyeyi
Twitezimbere
Abatangampundu
Abatangampundu
Dufatanirizehamwe
Abahuje
Abahuje
Tuzamurane
Abahuje
Intore
Ingabo
Ingabo
Umurava
Cell
Gakoma
Gakoma
Gakoma
Mbasa
Mbasa
Mbasa
Mpanda
Mpanda
Kibeho
Mbasa
District Nyaruguru
Cell
Gitita
Remera
Kabere
Gitita
Uwumusebeya
Kabere
Uwumusebeya
Uwumusebeya
Ruyenzi
Ruyenzi
Remera
Remera
Kabere
Kabere
Gitita
Uwumusebeya
Ruyenzi
Gitita
Kabere
Kabere
Uwumusebeya
Uwumusebeya
Ruyenzi
Ruyenzi
Ruyenzi
Gitita
Gitita
Gitita
Remera
Gitita
Kabere
Kabere
Kabere
Awumusebeya
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
27
Venue: Shanga……………./Sector: Maraba…..District: Huye
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Names
Uwimana Marie Grace
Uwimbabazi Francoise
Sebuteto Claudette
Niyonsaba Geraldine
Mukabutera Godelive
Nyamuganza Emmanuel
Twagirayezu Pierre
Celestin
Sibomana Aciel
Hagenimana Xavier
Rukundo Gerald
Uwamariya Thérèse
Musengeneza Bernadette
Ahishakiye Esprance
Musabyemariya olive
Nyirakanani Clementine
Mushimiyimana Odette
Mukangenzi
Thaciacienne
Muhundwangeyo
Francoise
Niyongira Gemime
Nyirandashyikirwa
Béathe
Mukamudenge Donatille
Iryamungu Jean de Dieu
Rurangwa Venuste
Mundanikure Pelagie
Nsengimana Innocent
Nibarere Valerie
Nyirakamana Marie
Jeanne
Musafiri JMV
Nabagize Solange
Mukamirambi M Rose
Sex
F
F
F
F
F
M
M
VSLG
Dufatanye A
Dufatnye A
Jyambere Mutegarugori
Tuzamurane Duterimbere
Abadasigana 3
Abatiheba
Abajyamugambi
Cell
Shyembe
Shyembe
Kanyinya
Kanyinya
Shanga
Kanyinya
Shyembe
M
M
M
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
Tujyinama
Abahuzamugambi
Tujyimbere
Twitezimbere B
Jyambere Mutegarugori
Tuzamurane
Twisungane
Tujyinama
Abadacogora
Twitezimbere B
Shanga
Buremera
Shyembe
Shyembe
Kanyinya
Kanyinya
Shanga
Shanga
Buremera
Shyembe
F
Abuzuzanya
Shanga
F
F
Dutizanyintege
Abishyizehamwe
Shyembe
Shyembe
F
M
M
F
M
F
F
Dutizanyintege
Twitezimbere
Abuzuzanya
Abajyamugambi
Twisungane
Abatiheba
Abadasigana
Shyembe
Shyembe
Shanga
Shyembe
Shanga
Kanyinya
Shanga
M
F
F
Abadacogora
Tujyimbere
Ingobokababyeyi
Buremera
Shyembe
Kabuye
Venue: Kabuye……………./Sector: Maraba…..District: Huye
Nr
1
2
3
4
5
6
2008
Names
Nyiramanywa Yozepha
Nyiramukunzi Jacqueline
Ndiringiye Xavier
Nyiraneza Bernadette
Bahutiraho Vicent
Mukarugwiza Virginie
Sex
F
F
M
F
M
F
VSLG
Abadasigana
Abadasigana
Intabangira
Dukomere ku mwuga
Twizamure
Twizamure
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
Cell
Buremera
Buremera
Kabuye
Buremera
Buremera
Buremera
/31
28
Nr
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
2008
Names
Habiyambere Pascal
Mukamusoni Bellancille
Nyiramana Laurence
Mukamana berthilde
Uwimana Vestine
Uwizeyimana Frida
Mukamuhire Clothilde
Mukashyaka Felicité
Uwizeyimana Verediana
Mukantwali Immaculée
Yabaragiye Venerande
Mukeshimana Dative
Mupfasoni Edisa
Mukabaziga Céraphine
Mukarushema Agnes
Nyiraminani Séraphine
Mukarutesi Bonifrida
Mukantagara Léonie
Mukamukire M.Claire
Mutamuliza Francine
Musabyimana Miliam
Mukakalisa Venancie
Nyirabuhoro Josephine
Mukamana Anastasie
Sex
M
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
F
VSLG
Twisungane
Twisungane
Abaticumugambi
Abaticumugambi
Abakundamwuga
Abakorerahamwe
Abakorerahamwe
Umurava
Abakundumwuga
Duteraninkunga
Duteraninkunga
Duhuzimbaraga
Duteraninkunga
Duteraninkunga
Tuzamirane
Tuzamurane
Duhuzimbaraga
Abahujumugambi
Abahujumugambi
Umurava
Dukomere kumwuga
Imbaraga B
Imbaraga B
Intabangira
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
Cell
Kanyinya
Kanyinya
Buremera
Buremera
Buremera
Buremera
Buremera
Gasumba
Buremera
Buremera
Buremera
Kabuye
Kabuye
Kabuye
Gasumba
Buremera
Kabuye
Buremera
Buremera
Gasumba
Buremera
Buremera
Buremera
Kabuye
/31
29
Appendix 3: Other pictures
OTHER PICTURES DURING TRAININGS
Theoretical lessons were given classrooms
Practices: Women in clay mixing
Mud stove construction with burnt bricks Demonstration: building of a rocket stove
Complete mud stove
at the end of training
2008
Exchange of ideas and social refreshing
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
30
2008
CITT/KIST
ADENYA
CARE
Organisation
Engineer Trainer for Huye District
Tito Rugamba
CARE, CASE Project, CARE
/31
Engineer Trainer for Nyaruguru District
Engineer Training Coordinator
J Nepomscene Mutsinzi
Didier Nkubito
Director of CITT/KIST
Etienne Ntagwirumugara
Engineer Trainer for Gisagara District
ADENYA Coordinator
Gabriel Nkurikiyimana
Cesar Niyonzima
Field Officer Huye-Gisagara Districts
Georges Ruberabahizi
Engineer Trainer for Nyamagabe District
Field Officer Nyaruguru-Nyamagabe Districts
Oswald
Guillaumme Sebahutu
Field Officer Huye- Gisagara Districts
Anita Niyongira
Training Professional
Augustin Niyonsaba
Field Officer Nyaruguru-Nyamagabe Districts
Project Manager
Prudence Ndolimana
Wellars Bayingana
Position
Names
(+ 250) 750249108
(+ 250) 750216457
(+ 250) 788460649
(+ 250) 788461194
(+ 250) 788689868
(+ 250) 788353874
(+ 250) 788564089
(+ 250) 788540399
(+ 250) 783249999
(+ 250) 783009953
(+250) 788646668
(+250) 788865624
(+250) 788592524
Telephone
Appendix 4: CARE & Partners’ staff involved in the Field activities of the Project
mutsinzi@yahoo.com
entagwir@yahoo.fr
adenya2000@yahoo.fr
rugeoges@yahoo.fr
Anitan.rw@co.care.org
wellarsb.rw@co.care.org
augustinn.rw@co.care.org
prudencen.rw@co.care.org.
E-mail
31