Cultural policy in Nigeria - unesdoc
Transcription
Cultural policy in Nigeria - unesdoc
Cultural policy m Nigeria T. A. Fasuyi Unesco Paris 1973 Studies and documents on cultural policies In this series Cultural policy: a preliminary study Cultural policy in the United States by Charles C. Mark Cultural rights as human rights Cultural policy in Japan by Nobuya Shikaumi Some aspects of French cultural policy by the Studies and Research Department of the French Ministry of Culture Cultural policy in Tunisia by Rafik Said Cultural policy in Great Britain by Michael Green and Michael Wilding, in consultation with Richard Hoggart Cultural policy in the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics by A. A. Zvorykin with the assistance of N. I. Golubtsova and E. I. Rabinovitch Cultural policy in Czechoslovakia by Miroslav Marek, Milan. Hromadka and Josef Chroust Cultural policy in Italy A survey prepared under the auspices of the Italian National Commission for Unesco Cultural policy in Yugoslavia by Stevan Majstorovic Cultural policy in Bulgaria by Kostadine Popov Some aspects of cultural policies in India by Kapila Malik Vatsyayan Cultural policy in Cuba by Lisandro Otero with the assistance of Francisco Martinez Hinojosa Cultural policy in Egypt by Magdi Wahba Cultural policy in Finland A study prepared under the auspices of the Finnish National Commission for Unesco Cultural policy in Ceylon by H. H. Bandar a Cultural policy in Nigeria by T. A. Fasuyi The serial numbering of titles in this series, the presentation of which has been modified, was discontinued with the volume Cultural policy in Italy 00&.004. 1 FAS Published by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation Place de Fontenoy, 75700 Paris Printed by Presses Universitaires de France, Vendome ISBN 92-3-101029-8 LC No. 72-95232 © Unesco 1973 Printed in France Preface The purpose of this series is to show how cultural policies are planned and implemented in various Member States. As cultures differ, so does the approach to them; it is for each Member State to determine its cultural policy and methods according to its own conception of culture, its socio-economic system, political ideology and technical development. However, the methods of cultural policy (like those of general development policy) have certain common problems; these are largely institutional, administrative and financial in nature, and the need has increasingly been stressed for exchanging experiences and information about them. This series, each issue of which follows as far as possible a similar pattern so as to make comparison easier, is mainly concerned with these technical aspects of cultural policy. In general, the studies deal with the principles and methods of cultural policy, the evaluation of cultural needs, administrative structures and management, planning and financing, the organization of resources, legislation, budgeting, public and private institutions, cultural content in education, cultural autonomy and decentralization, the training of personnel, institutional infrastructures for meeting specific cultural needs, the safeguarding of the cultural heritage, institutions for the dissemination of the arts, international cultural co-operation and other related subjects. The studies, which cover countries belonging to differing social and economic systems, geographical areas and levels of development, present therefore a wide variety of approaches and methods in cultural policy. Taken as a whole, they can provide guidelines to countries which have yet to establish cultural policies, while all countries, especially those seeking new formulations of such policies, can profit by the experience (already gained. This study was prepared for Unesco by T. A. Fasuyi, Head of the Art Section, Federal Ministry of Education, Lagos, Nigeria. The opinions expressed are the author's and do not necessarily reflect the views of Unesco. Contents 9 Introduction 11 Before the colonial conquest 17 Traditional organization of culture 20 Nigerian culture under colonial rule 26 Current administration and financing of culture 37 Art agencies and cultural organizations 42 The transmission of culture 61 The future Introduction Nigeria had acquired great reputation in the world of art long before she attained her present political and economic position in the world of nations. Nigeria is singularly distinguished in Africa, south of the Sahara, for her rich and vast cultural manifestations, a heritage of the past and a pride of the present generation. Her antiquities, especially the masterpieces from the ancient cultures of Ife, Benin and Nok, contributed more than any other factor towards her reputation. Such masterpieces, exhibited in leading museums and galleries all over the world, have become part of the sum total of the cultural heritage of mankind. Ideally, the cultural policy of a country should reflect the established traditions and culture of the people. European countries with longestablished traditions and continuous administrative structures, extending over centuries, find it easy to formulate or discuss their cultural policy. But African countries, having undergone diiferent and drastic political and administrative change within the last century, cannot formulate their policy without looking into their glorious past. It is therefore necessary in this study to look back into history, not to relay mere historical facts, but in order to portray the cultural situation in Nigeria, past and present, in its true historical and traditional context. Nigerian cultural policy reflects three political phases: (a) the precolonial period during which tribal kingdoms or empires existed and under which the ancient art of Nigeria flourished; (b) the period between 1900 and 1960 when Nigeria was under British rule and influence; (c) the current phase: present administrative machinery for art and culture, and an evaluation of cultural needs and development within the context of a cultural policy. In the pre-colonial period, cultural policies were determined and administered by the traditional rulers or heads of the different cultures that existed within the boundaries of what is now known as Nigeria. During the Introduction colonial period, a cultural policy was imported and operated for Nigeria by the colonial administrators. The cultural policy of Nigeria during the past ten years of her independence could be attributed to the political leaders who emerged after the departure of the British administrators. 10 Before the colonial conquest Long before the advent of the white man to the western coast of Africa, there had existed many ancient kingdoms and empires founded and administered exclusively by Africans. But the origins and development of the kingdoms are obscure as there were no written records. However there exist fairly reliable legends in oral tradition describing their origins; and some of the facts contained in the legends are being confirmed by recent archaeological and historical findings. Most notable among the kingdoms that flourished in areas now covered by Nigeria include the Yoruba kingdom, the Benin empire in the south; the Bornu empire and the Hausa States in the north. Recent archaeological findings have also confirmed the existence of an early culture around Nok,1 a village near the centre of the present Nigeria. Kingdoms in the south Ife is regarded as the cradle of the two major kingdoms that flourished in the southern parts of Nigeria, west of the Niger. The origin of Ife itself is obscure; but the most acceptable legend has it that Oduduwa, the founder of Ife, came from the north-eastern part of Africa,2 stopping in one or two places before finally settling down at Ife with his people. His seven sons later became the founders and rulers of the seven crown divisions of what later became the Yoruba land. Ife has since remained the ancestral home of the Yorubas; and the Oni of Ife, the traditional ruler of Ife, is always regarded as the spiritual head of the Yorubas. 1. 'The Nok Culture', West African Review, 156. 2. Rev. S. Johnson, The History of the Yorubas, London, Routledge, 1921. 11 Before the colonial conquest OYO KINGDOM The most powerful kingdom to emerge from Yoruba land was Oyo, founded by Oranmiyan, son of Oduduwa, who became the first Alafin of Oyo. As a result of its power and influence, Oyo later became the administrative and political centre of the old Oyo kingdom which flourished until the early nineteenth century. Historically notable among the early Alafins were Shango, who was later deified as 'god of thunder'; Ajiboyede, who regained old Oyo from the Nupes and captured their king, and during whose reign there was peace in Oyo; and Abiodun, who was the last Alafin to reign before the collapse of the kingdom. At the height of its glory, the Oyo kingdom cut across the present boundaries of Nupe to the north, Dahomey and Togo, to the west, extending eastwards to the River Niger.1 The supreme head of the kingdom was the Alafin of Oyo who was regarded by his subjects as second only to the gods. The kingdom was divided into a number of provinces headed by Oba or viceroys who owed allegiance to and depended on the Alafin for external protection. The internal administration and organization of each sectional or provincial unit rested with the Oba, who in turn established a council of chiefs for the over-all control of his area. Members of the council usually included heads of various cult societies, outstanding warriors, religious and political leaders. The council of chiefs was responsible, after due ritual consultations, for the election of the Oba from the ruling house. Once elected and crowned the Oba assumed the spiritual and political power of his domain. The excesses of any Oba could however be checked by the chiefs in council. For example, in Oyo itself, the Oyomesi (Local Council of Chiefs), constituted a check on the Alafin as all important policies were usually discussed and approved by them before they could be effected. It was by this highly organized system of administration that Oyo, the largest kingdom of the Guinea Coast,2 was administered. The system did not however eradicate internal rifts and dissensions among the smaller provincial units whose rulers wanted to be independent. Encouraged by external European influences and aid from the south, and by the powerful Fulani invasion from the north, some of the rulers started to agitate against the Alafin. One after the other, each Oba declared himself independent, and the kingdom gradually collapsed. The collapse of Oyo was followed by smouldering hostilities among the newly independent towns and villages, and this led to intensive inter-tribal wars. The Fulanis, taking advantage of the situation, invaded the kingdom and captured a number of towns, including Oyo itself in 1837. The Dahomeans launched 1. R. Akpofure and M. Crowder, Nigeria, London, Faber, 1966. 2. J. D. Fage, Introduction to the History of West Africa, Cambridge University Press, 1962. 12 Before the colonial conquest an attack from the south; but their invasions were <juickly halted by British intervention. It was this timely intervention that gave the British the opportunity to establish their influence over the Yorubas. BENIN KINGDOM Another important ancient kingdom in the south was centred in Benin, and its influence and power covered the remaining areas of southern Nigeria outside the Yoruba kingdom: those extending from the west of the River Niger to Dahomey. Its coastal area was named the 'Bight of Benin' by early European explorers, foremost among whom were the Portuguese. There were regular contacts between the Benin and Yoruba kingdoms. They had common borders, and both regarded Ife as their spiritual home. In fact it was from Ife that Oranrniyan, founder of the present dynasty of Benin, came at the request of the Benin elders. He did not, however, stay long; but his son, Eweka, later became the first Oba of Benin. After him, came a line of over thirty Obas, prominent among whom were Oguoba, who built the great city wall and introduced brasswork, and Ewuare, a famous warrior who introduced ivory- and wood-carving, and during whose reign the kingdom was greatly expanded. At the zenith of its power, the Benin kingdom was highly organized under the Oba, who was both the political and spiritual head of his people. The Oba was regarded as divine, but he shared his political power with the seven Uzama chiefs who were next in rank to him. Other important chiefs were the Eghavbo, the feudal and war lords and the chiefs of the royal household. There were also three aristocratic societies who performed some ceremonial duties in the Oba's palace. To maintain order and good government in the kingdom, the Oba maintained a large army. The Portuguese were the first Europeans to visit Benin and to trade with them. After the Portuguese, other European traders came; and during the period of the slave trade, Benin became a very famous centre. The king- dom later disintegrated as a result of tribal wars. British rule was established in Benin in 1897 after the ill-fated mission of Consul Phillips and the conse(juent punitive expedition. Because of its power and size, the Benin kingdom enjoyed a prosperous economy that was based on agriculture and industry. Its stability and prosperity gave the citizens ample time to practise their arts and crafts, survivals of which are now regarded as masterpieces all over the world. Benin and Oyo were similar not only in their highly organized adminis- tration, their cultural and artistic maturity, but also in their indigenous growth, without Islamic or European contacts. 13 Before the colonial conquest Kingdoms in the north NOK CULTURE This stone-age culture is believed to have flourished between 500 B.C. and A.D. 200 about the centre of the present Northern Nigeria. The first evidence of the culture was the finding, in 1936, of a terracotta in Nok, a village in the Bauchi Plateau. Further archaeological relics were discovered in 1944 in another village called Jemaa;1 and similarities in the works led to the assumption that the culture might have existed along the areas now covered by Katsina Ala, stretching north-westwards to Kagara. Detailed studies of the Nok terracotta revealed that the people were agriculturists and probably kept cattle. The ornaments on it also suggested that they were fond of ornaments and body decorations. They seemed to have practised some iron smelting (as indicated by their tin and quartz beads, found in some tin mines). Considering their similarities, it is also believed that Nok art may have influenced early Yoruba art.2 THE H A U S A STATES Daura was the spiritual home of the early Hausa States, founded between A.D. 1000 and 1200.3 Other States, including Zamfawa, Kebbi, Nupe, Gwari and Yauri, later came under Hausa influence. Because of their geographical and trading positions, Kano and Katsina developed regular trading contacts with the kingdoms of Bornu in the north and Mali on the western coast. To help in the administration and organization of the States, the ruler of each State appointed a number of district heads. The district heads in turn appointed village leaders through whom taxes were collected from farmers and cattle dealers for the central authority. During the fifteenth century there reigned a powerful queen in Zaria called Amina who conquered some of the older Hausa States in addition to Nupe and Kororofa. She later directed the building of the great defence walls to protect her cities; some of the walls still survive. Zaria later became a slave trading centre while Kano developed her leather industries and agriculture. Each of the States rose to power and prominence from time to time until Bornu became their overlord. 1. 'Mining for History', Nigeria (Lagos), 71. 2. 'The Nok Culture', op. cit. 3. C. R. Niven, A Short History of Nigeria, London, Longmans, 1955. 14 Before the colonial conquest K I N G D O M OF B O R N U The Kingdom of Bornu was the first part of northern Nigeria to emerge clearly into history at about A.D. 750.1 It was well placed geographically for development, being a convenient settlement area for early peoples coming from the east through Egypt. A forerunner kingdom of Zaghawa was believed to have existed near the present Western Sudan; it collapsed, breaking up into several kingdoms. One of the kingdoms, located around Karen basin, now partly corresponds to the present Bornu Province in Nigeria. The extended kingdom later became powerful enough to exact tribute from Kano and other Hausa States. The kingdom was centrally ruled by the Mai through his appointed provincial governors. PtTLANI E M P I R E The Fulanis, whose origin is historically uncertain, were ardent Moslems who had settled peacefully in many Hausa States. They intermarried with local people and gained positions of influence as a result of their great understanding of the Koran. Their unmixed loyalty and devotion to the cause of Islam caused concern among the Hausa kings against whom they preached; the kings were accused of tolerating pagans in their domains, contrary to the teaching of Islam. A local disturbance in Gobi, one of the strongest Hausa States, gave the Fulanis under Usman Dan Fodio the opportunity of launching the Jihad—the holy war against the infidels. With their well-organized and united army, devoted to the ideals of Islam, they attacked the uncoordinated Hausa States, which crumpled one after the other. By 1830 the Fulanis had conquered all modern Northern Nigeria excepting Bornu, which strongly resisted them. The Jihad later spread southwards to Illorin where the ancient Yoruba town was captured. The Fulani empire, too large to be ruled centrally, was divided into two big provinces with headquarters in Sokoto and G-wandu. Sokoto was however the imperial capital with the She as the spiritual and temporal ruler. The indirect system of administration inherited from the Hausa States was continued with necessary modifications. The Jihad not only established Islam firmly in all the empire, but brought political and economic stability. Other settlements Outside the kingdoms and empires that were centrally organized and ruled by historically known Obas and Emirs, there were other settlements and tribal groups in northern and southern Nigeria. The tribal groups include 1. Akpofure and Crowder, op. cit. 15 Before the colonial conquest Igala, Idoma, Junkum and Tiv in the north, and the Ibo, Ibibio and Ijaw in the south. Within the tribal settings there were organized towns and villages in which the elders directed the administration of social and cultural programmes. Some big towns had traditional rulers, similar to those in Yoruba and the Hausa States. Early European explorers, traders and missionaries have recorded their meetings with such traditional rulers, especially those along the Bight of Biafra. Old Calabar, Brass, Opobo, Bonny and Okrika were some of the notable and highly developed towns. During the efforts of the British Government to stop the slave trade and extend British rule, treaties had to be signed with traditional rulers. Some of the northern groups were not concjuered during the war of Jihad and, until British rule was established, remained independent kingdoms. 16 Traditional organization of culture Art and cultural activities were closely interwoven with, the social life of the kingdoms under the traditional rulers, who were not only political heads but also the spiritual leaders of their people. In the States and locally, councils or meetings of elders advised the traditional heads in planning the cultural programmes. The main administration of cultural programmes came under each traditional head, who in turn delegated his powers to his chiefs. The local chiefs would then assign different aspects to people according to their ability and talents. Under this division of labour, the different members of the society contributed their quota towards the success of the programme. The carvers made masks; the costume-designers made dresses; the musicians and the dancers created dances with the relevant drum beats and music. The priests performed rituals according to the direction of the gods while the farmers and palm-wine tappers were responsible for providing food and drinks. This traditional administration of cultural activities was to some extent a social obligation system in which everybody was willing to contribute his (juota for the success of the agreed socio-cultural programme. It encouraged active and willing participation by the people in cultural programmes. Talents used for the benefit of the society were appreciated. It was, in short, a system that was very suitable for the needs and condition of the time. Role of artists In many of the cultural settings that existed in Nigeria, the arts contributed in no small way to most of the social activities, and enhanced them spiritually and aesthetically. In such societies where art and cultural activities were closely interwoven with social life the importance and status of artists were unique. As all social activities usually centred around the traditional head of the 17 Traditional organization of culture society, his house, Ms dress, his dances and so on were designed by artists who were in a position to know what was aesthetically and spiritually suitable. The traditional head in turn bestowed such important duties. As a result, the artists were highly respected in the community and their contributions were highly valued and appreciated. It was the artists who dictated the cultural pace of the society; and it was they who directed the social taste. In the absence of machines or other technological devices, most articles were designed and produced by artists and craftsmen. Many people were skilled in one or more crafts, but the works of the competent and talented were always in great demand. This gave the artist or craftsman a measure of control in the economic life of the society. Recompense The chief artist was usually left to organize the actual and physical production of art works for cultural programmes, either in his compound or at an allocated area within the community. He was empowered to scout for the talented and experienced artists and assign duties to them. He gave duties to each type of artist (carver, musician, drummer and so on), according to his ability and experience. As they were all working for the same purpose, there was co-operation and understanding among the different artists in planning and carrying out the cultural or religious programmes of their society. Artists undertook their different assignments usually without pay; but they received the personal gratitude of the Oba and the society's praise in general. It was also usual for artists to receive free cash crops, cattle and clothing to cover their needs while thus serving the society. When some financial compensation was involved, the traditional head met their demands; but the artists valued the social honour and praise more than any financial compensation. After the completion of a programme, they returned to their main occupation until they were commissioned again. Financial subsidies or material assistance were therefore given only while the artists were contributing to a cultural programme. Training As there was no formal education in Nigeria before the European missionaries came, artists (sculptors, musicians, poets, dancers) were trained under an apprenticeship system. Each of the arts was usually practised as a family trade and the techniques and secrets were handed over from the elders to their children. For example, a child born to a wood-carver would start as early as six years of age to practise his father's craft. He first learned the different types of the woods, then the tools and techniques used by his father in carving. By the time he was 16 or so, he had acquired 18 Traditional organization of culture enough skill and confidence to produce good work on his own. In addition to being taught how to carve, he was also introduced to the social and religious uses of different types of carvings. Freely was he given his training; and freely was he expected to train others for the family trade circle to grow. Although the works of the family guild were done collectively, yet there was room for individual and original innovations. Individual talents were recognized and admired; and new inventions or innovations by any member were adopted by the entire guild. As members of a family, they shared the joys of their achievement, or reverses when they occurred. Every family guild of musicians, drummers or singers trained their young to accpiire and retain the family tradition with minimal external diffusion. This apprenticeship and family system of training gave the child enough early confidence to learn with ease, and left him in harmony with his family or village background. It enabled the child to develop according to his ability, without any serious emotional tension. It developed in different Nigerian cultural settings, and achieved the main purpose of modern art education which, in Herbert Read's definition, is 'to foster the growth of what is individual in each human being, at the same time harmonizing the individuality thus educated with the organic unity of the social group to which the individual belongs'.1 1. Herbert Read, Education through Art, London, 1958. 19 Nigerian culture under colonial rule When the slave trade was brought to a halt, the European colonizers met in Paris and agreed to partition Africa among themselves. By the end of the nineteenth century, every square foot of the western coast of Africa had been allocated to the different colonial powers. The old kingdoms and empires having been arbitrarily shared, each European country established its authority over its conquered or allocated areas. The areas in Nigeria, comprising the major parts of the Fulani empire in the north, the Yoruba and Benin kingdoms and the Ibo, Calabar and Ibibio tribes were allocated to Britain. Constitutional developments In 1900 the administration of all the areas allocated to Britain was formally taken over by the British Government after the Royal Niger Company's Charter had been revoked. In 1906 the colony and protectorate of Lagos became part of Southern Nigeria and a protectorate was established over the northern provinces. On 1 January 1914, the two protectorates were merged, with Lagos, into the colony and protectorate of Nigeria. A legislative council was established to advise the governor for Lagos and the southern provinces, but the administration of the northern provinces remained the sole responsibility of the governor. In 1946, a new constitution was introduced, establishing a central legis- lative council to administer the whole country. Regional houses of assembly were also established to act as advisory bodies to the central legislature on regional matters. Further revisions of the constitution were carried out in 1951 and 1954, to give the regions autonomy and greatly increased powers. Lagos was declared a federal territory and separated from the western region. After further constitutional talks, regional self-government was given to the eastern and western regions in 1957; and to the northern region in 1959. The country became independent on 1 October 1960. 20 Nigerian culture under colonial rule Effects of colonization on traditional culture With, the collapse of the former empires and the spread of British rule the authority and influence of the traditional rulers was undermined. They were obliged to swear allegiance to the Crown of England and to sign treaties of loyalty and obedience. In most of the big towns, the cultural activities formerly encouraged by the traditional rulers were greatly curtailed, if not suspended. In the smaller towns and villages, however, where the people still had a measure of control over their own affairs, the people continued to carry on their traditional cultural pursuits. The traditional status and important social functions of the artists were greatly reduced, with the consequent adverse effects on the quality and quantity of artistic expression. The early missionaries came to introduce a new religion; all the former religious rites and manifestations (including the dance and music) were banned, and the new converts were encouraged to dispose of any art works which had been used in religious rites. The West European educational system was introduced, replacing the informal traditional system; it was geared to the needs of the colonial administration. This objective was stated in a 1921 speech by the first Governor of Nigeria: 'The chief function of Government Primary and Secondary Schools ... is to train the more promising boys from the village schools as teachers for those schools, as clerks for the local native courts, and as interpreters. . . .n Formal education was started in towns and big villages by the missionaries. In order to pass the prescribed examinations set and marked in England, the students had to learn things which had little bearing on their own way of life, e.g. the geography and the political, social and economic history of Britain and the British Empire. Foreign literature was studied. English became the official language, in which all transactions were effected. Indigenous languages were neglected; oral traditional poetry gave way to Shakespeare and English literature. Those who managed to study abroad frequently came back alienated from their own society. European dances were introduced to replace the traditional dances. Western music was introduced, through gramophone records, to accompany the new dance forms, as were films, photography and other graphic arts. All these new cultural forms, which were in most cases strange and exciting, developed at the expense of traditional art and culture; a new sense and set of values began to emerge. It was difficult for Nigerians to sense the possible dangers of this development, but a few expatriates did. Commenting 1. Otinfci Nduka, Western Education and the Nigerian Cultural Background, Nigeria, 1965. 21 Nigerian culture under colonial rule on the situation in 1938, E. H. Duckworth, editor of the governmentowned Nigeria magazine, maeazine, wrote: . . . Many of the old crafts, especially those of wood-carving and brass casting, are in very great danger of dying out owing to lack of support. In the past, many of the chiefs and other important men employed carvers to construct beautiful stools, carved doors, panels and posts. Benin City became world-famous as a result of the high standard of workmanship in metal casting and engraving attained by her craftsmen in years past. Now, as we travel about the country, we see carved doors and posts rotting and neglected; and on the other hand, churches with cheap imported hymn boards and brass-eagle reading desks, also Native Administration Council Halls, as at Ibadan and llesha, completely devoid of everything African. At Benin City we might at least expect to see carving or brass work incorporated in the Court House, Post Office, Police Station and other public buildings, but our search will be in vain; even the new Middle School is equally barren. The skilled brass workers of Benin have received so little encouragement during the past few years that most of them have abandoned the craft and taken to other work. Two years ago it was impossible to get any of suitable quality. Let us now cross the Niger and visit Awka. Surely here they will have employed local carvers to decorate the doors of some of the public buildings, but we are again disappointed, and only find doors of dull Public Works Department type. Our search for African art work in modern buildings will indeed be a difficult one unless we are told where to go. . . . The art of the people of Nigeria is something they may well be proud of. It can be easily adapted to modern conditions and is one of the contributions they can make to civilisation and something that brings honour and respect to the African race. Yet many of our men, African and European, in high positions are completely unmindful of this fact. Commenting on the unsuitability of European dress for a tropical climate, he continued: We suggest that more use should be made of African hand-made cloth and African dress designs. This hand-made cloth is a little more expensive than machine-made cloth, but it will last for years, and by purchasing such material encouragement is given to one of our important village industries. In our study of import and export statistics we are liable to forget the value of our internal trade, especially from the point of view of the health and happiness of our people. Some of our village industries give employment in the aggregate to a vast number of people. It is estimated that at least 60,000 people are engaged in the mat-making industry alone. We cannot lightly neglect the fostering and development of our home industries. Our weavers, dyers and carvers especially need our patronage if they are to survive the impact of shoddy machine-made_goods. Some people say, why not start machine-run factories in Nigeria? We doubt if such factories would bring happiness; on the other hand, we are certain that by giving more attention to our village crafts and to practical forms of education, and also to the education of our girls, we could transform our villages into places of health, centres alive with little 22 Nigerian culture under colonial rule home industries carried on by educated people not ashamed to work with their hands and prepared at times to engage in work for the community.... These were the words of an. expatriate observer; and they constituted a factual and objective review of the cultural situation in the country. His ideas were re-echoed and confirmed in another article written in the same magazine by K. C. Murray, who wrote as follows: African art, however, is now in. a transitional stage, and it is yet uncertain whether it will gradually disappear or whether it will be able to assimilate ideas from Europe and still keep its character. Under modern conditions it cannot stand still, but if it is to develop and survive as art and keep its valuable qualities, it must be firmly based on the traditional work. The younger generation who have been to school axe unfortunately mostly ignorant... of their local traditions and history, and fail to appreciate ... African art. The old religious carvings are gone or are disappearing. . . . No study is being made of Nigerian music, and it is neglected in schools. In craft work, improvements in technique are taken up by newcomers so that the traditional craftsmen, who are not being helped, are likely to die out gradually along with their inherited knowledge of materials and design. Europeans, many of whom have a great respect for African art, could help to make circumstances favourable for its survival but, officially, practically nothing has been done to foster and encourage its survival. On the very rare occasions that buildings have been decorated with African work it has been due to individual initiative and not to official policy. European action and admiration, however, cannot save African art; its existence finally depends on the respect, admiration and support of Africans themselves. Cultural landmarks during the period The colonial era did see some development or improvement in artistic or cultural matters; there were some developments which could be regarded as cultural landmarks of the era. They included: (a) the establishment of Nigeria magazine; (b) the establishment of museums of antiquities; (c) the creation of the post of the Federal Art Adviser; (d) the creation of departments of art. Some of these developments have been taken over and continued by the independent Nigerian Government. Their subsequent history is discussed in later chapters, but their beginnings can be briefly mentioned here. NIGERIA MAGAZINE Nigeria magazine was first published in 1923 as Nigerian Teacher, a government publication on educational and cultural matters. The title was changed in 1927 to Nigeria and later developed into the federal government cultural information journal. 23 Nigerian culture under colonial rule It has regularly carried features and articles since on cultural activities from all parts of the country. It started^its literary supplement about four years ago. The literary supplement carries literary and scholarly articles and research works of Nigerian scholars prominent in art and culture. Photographs of dances and other performances are regularly featured. Notable among its past editors are E. H. Duckworth and Michael Crowder, both of whom used the magazine to publicize and promote Nigerian art and culture. MUSEUMS After the punitive expedition to Benin in 1897, many of the captured bronzes were sold as scrap metal. It was really owing to the initiative of the Germans, who preserved the majority of the works in their museums, that Benin became famous. In 1911, a German professor came to Nigeria and brought to light the treasures of Ife; some of the best works are now in Frankfurt Museum.1 Some British administrators realized that the disappearance of such works would be a great loss to both the British and Nigerian peoples. They therefore campaigned for the creation of local museums where remaining specimens could be preserved and displayed. Outstanding among the advocates of this policy were S. Milburn and E. H. Ducfcworth (both former editors of Nigeria magazine). They used the magazine not only to popularize other aspects of Nigerian art and culture, but also to appeal to the government to build museums to keep the best of the Nigerian art works. E. H. Duckworth in an editorial in the paper in 1937 wrote about Nigerian art and culture as follows: Our African contributors by researching into and describing the antiquities, the craft work, the customs of the country, can help to create in the mass of the people an appreciation of Nigerian art and culture. The museums of Europe and America contain great and valuable collections of Nigerian craft work. Some of these art treasures were sold by the original owners to foreigners for a mere pittance. . . . Help to build up an appreciation of the old things; do not be afraid of them. Respect the past, record its history, treasure its signposts, help to build museums in Nigeria. The day may come when people will voyage from all parts of the world to see the museums and exhibition rooms of Lagos, Abeokuta, Ife and Benin City. The Jos Museum was the first to be built in Nigeria and was opened to the public in 1952. It housed the Department of Antiquities until 1963 when it was shifted to the Nigerian National Museum, Lagos. 1. K. C. Murray, 'Museums', Nigeria (Lagos), 14, 1938. 24 Nigerian culture under colonial rule FEDERAL ART ADVISER Another landmark was the creation in 1947 of the post of the Art Supervisor. A Nigerian artist, Ben Enwonwu, who had taught art in a government college and been formally trained in a London art school, was appointed to the post. His duties included the promotion of Nigerian art, locally and abroad, through exhibitions and lectures. In 1955 the post was redesignated as Federal Art Adviser. In 1957 he was transferred to the Ministry of Education and his duties widened to include the inspection and teaching of art in schools. He was also expected to advise the government on matters of cultural importance. He felt himself hindered by being under civil-service control; the usual long procedure of getting financial or formal support for his ideas was frustrating. He continued, however, to work as a professional artist and held several exhibitions in Nigeria and abroad. Among his many outstanding sculptures is the statue of the Queen of England made to commemorate Nigeria's independence and now set up in front of the Nigerian Parliament in Lagos. D E P A R T M E N T S OF ART The establishment of a Department of Fine Art as part of the Nigerian College of Art, Science and Technology is worth mentioning under the heading of art-education development of the colonial period. The department started in 1953 with a handful of European lecturers and some interested Nigerian students at the Ibadan branch of the college. It was later transferred to the Zaria branch where the Art Department expanded to enable it to introduce a four-year diploma course. Graduates since 1959 have been taking up teaching jobs in schools and colleges. Some have gone into advertising, publishing and television. Unfortunately, the training provided under the European lecturers was based mainly on European art standards and values. Before the establishment of the college in Zaria, some sandwich art courses had been started at the Yaba Technical Institute, founded in 1948. Art classes introduced there in 1952 were designed to provide in-service training for graphic artists in the different government departments. Both departments of art are further discussed below. 25 Current administration and financing of culture Under the Nigerian Constitution, each of the states has considerable powers regarding its own cultural policy and administration. Each can initiate cultural programmes; build and maintain cultural centres; and decide what type of cultural education it believes best for its citizens. While the states are thus autonomous in their cultural pursuits, the federal government initiates national programmes to promote national cultural unity. International cultural exchanges and programmes are the exclusive domain of the federal government. Federal administration and financing There is no separate Ministry of Culture, Nigeria in this differing from many European and African countries whose art and cultural programmes are planned and implemented by a single ministry. Cultural policy is therefore not embodied in a single document. Every ministry formulates its own policies and federal art and cultural responsibilities are shared among different ministries as follows: Federal Ministry of Information: (a) cultural promotion; (b) international cultural exchanges; (c) cultural information and publications; (d) mass media. Federal Ministry of Education: (a) art and cultural education; (b) art exhibitions and artists' societies; (c) museums and monuments; (d) Unescosponsored cultural activities. Federal Ministry of External Affairs: (a) international cultural exchanges (see Federal Ministry of Information above); (b) industrial and cultural exhibitions. Federal Ministry of Trade and Industry: (a) international trade fair and cultural display; (b) promotion of art and crafts industries. 26 Current administration and financing of culture F E D E R A L M I N I S T R Y OF I N F O R M A T I O N Cultural promotion The Cultural Division of the ministry plans and handles major government cultural programmes (e.g. the annual independence celebration, local and international festivals of the arts, international cultural exchanges) and maintains an exhibition centre for art exhibitions of local and foreign artists. Until 1968 the division was headed by the editor of Nigeria magazine, assisted by a few officials. In that year the new post of Federal Cultural Adviser was created to give professional guidance. The former Federal Art Adviser, a renowned and experienced Nigerian artist, was appointed into the post. As the division does not have snineient professionally trained staff, it often sets up ad hoc committees or calls on the Nigerian Arts Council to help. International cultural exchanges Various cultural agreements with other nations are prepared by the ministry after due consultation in ad hoc meetings (usually with the ministries of external affairs, education, trade and industries). Cultural information and publications The Information Division regularly publishes books, pamphlets, journals and documentation on government activities, programmes and policies (e.g. information and photographs of official, social and cultural events, articles on Nigeria's participation in international festivals, pamphlets entitled Our Cultural Heritage, Nigerian Music, Nigerian Drama). The photographic section of the division arranges regular film and photo exhibitions on important events; its film unit has produced some documentary and feature films. The administrative head of the Information Division is a civil servant, but his staff are professionally trained for their different jobs. Moss media The major government mass media (broadcasting, television, film, photography, libraries, press) come under the direction or supervision of the ministry, the services being allocated either to departments of the ministry or to autonomous bodies, established and financed by the government through the ministry (broadcasting and television come under the Nigerian Broadcasting Corporation, library services under the Nigerian Library Board, government publications under the Nigerian Press Corporation, while the Department of Film and Photography is part of the Information Division of the ministry). The financial and administrative structures are as follows. 27 Current administration and financing of culture Nigerian Broadcasting Corporation (NBC). The NEC was set up by an Act of Parliament in 1956 as a corporate body to succeed the old Nigerian Broadcasting Service (which, was a department of the Federal Ministry of Information) and 'to reflect the wealth of culture in the country; and to promote the unity of the federation'. The corporation is headed by a director-general. It has four directors, one of whom is in charge of the television services. Transmission was at first centralized in Lagos and picked up by the other stations. Later, the system was decentralized to give each of the former three regions an opportunity of listening to local programmes, often given in the local languages. The corporation now maintains a network of stations through which it transmits its programmes to all the states in the federation. State broadcasting houses have powers to originate and relay their own cultural programmes; these may also be incorporated in the national programmes. State and provincial broadcasting reflect local cultures and carry the services of the NBC to Nigerians in the villages and hamlets. NBC-TV operates on channel 10 in Lagos and covers the parts of Western State which are near Lagos. There is an estimated 35,000 sets in the Lagos area and 50,000 in the whole country. At an average of seven viewers per set, some 250,000 watch NBC-TV programmes within a fortymile radius from Lagos. One of the aims of the television service is to promote awareness of the Nigerian cultural heritage. National Library Board. The ministry is responsible for national library services through its National Library Board, whose members include educationists, eminent citizens and government officials. A director is responsible for the general administrative and professional aspects. The board co-ordinates the work of the regional and other institutional libraries. Film censorship. New films coming to Nigeria are first viewed to decide their suitability for adults or children by the Film Censorship Board, set up by the ministry. Its members include representatives of the Ministry of Education, the police and the Social Welfare Department. The board can take disciplinary action against any cinema house contravening its orders. Nigerian National Board. The federal board for newspapers and other publications has a chairman who is responsible to the Commissioner or Minister of Information. The board works in co-operation with the Information Division of the federal Ministry of Information to publicize government activities and to relay information to the public. 28 Current administration and financing of culture F E D E R A L M I N I S T R Y OF E D U C A T I O N The section of the ministry which deals with the art and cultural programmes is headed by the Federal Art Adviser. Art and cultural education The ministry plays a leading role in the promotion of art and cultural subjects in schools and colleges. It helps the states in reviewing the syllabus and in planning the curriculum; and if the state so requests, in inspecting the state's art schools. It circulates visual aids, including Unesco art slides, to schools and colleges. The head of the Art Section also serves on examination panels, so ensuring a certain standardization in the art examinations. Art scholarships. The government awards only a few scholarships annually to art students, as the main priority for awards goes to science and technical subjects. This trend in most developing countries is justified only by the dire need for more technical personnel for economic development; it must be realized, however, that art and cultural education is likewise needed to give the necessary spiritual and aesthetic overtones to scientific and technical education. The attitude of the government in regard to the training of teachers is more positive. In 1968 it started a 'crash programme for the training of teachers'. Scholarships are awarded on a quota basis: 60 per cent for science, 30 per cent for liberal arts, 10 per cent for cultural and creative subjects. Over one hundred art, music and drama students had been awarded 'crash scholarships' during the past two years. Once they have completed their courses, the number of specialist art teachers available to schools and colleges will be greatly increased. Schools exhibition. The ministry organizes an All-Nigeria Schools Art Exhibition and Competition: 1. To promote cultural contact and understanding among children in all the states of the federation, with a view to developing a common national artistic heritage. 2. To enable children to see how their counterparts in other states solve their aesthetic problems—their methods and techniques, their materials and improvisation. 3. To give art teachers the opportunity of seeing the standard of works in other schools so as to improve and guide the teaching of art in schools. The state ministries of education help in the collection and selection of works. The original scheme was started to coincide with the tenth anni- versary of Nigeria's independence. After its opening show in Lagos the 29 Current administration and financing of culture exhibition, is sent round the state capitals. Prizes in the form of art materials are awarded to students for outstanding works. International children's art exhibitions. The ministry arranges Nigerian participation in international exhibitions of children's art; it keeps a library from which selections are made and forwarded. During the past few years Nigerian children have been consistently winning major prizes in these exhibitions: in 1970 alone, seventeen prizes were won at international art exhibitions in Venezuela, Tanzania, Japan and India. This of course is a source of pride and encouragement to both the officials and the schools. Artists' societies Matters concerning art and artists' organizations are also dealt with by the ministry. Some of the organizations apply either for government recognition or for subvention, or both. Some have been recognized and given subventions. The Society for Art and Humanities (whose main objective was the collection of art works for the proposed Museum of Modern Art) received over £30,000 in subventions in four years from the ministry. The International Institute of African Languages and Culture also receives an annual subvention of £500. Other societies that have been recognized or aided include the Society of Nigerian Artists, the Society for Education through Art, the Nigerian Museum Society and the Society of Art Teachers. National museums Government grants to the national museums are channelled through the Ministry of Education, which is also responsible for their administration. The Federal Commissioner or Minister of Education is responsible for the appointment of members to the National Antiquities Commission, which is composed of distinguished men of culture and notable scholars in the arts and humanities. The commission is responsible for the establishment and maintenance of museums and for the discovery, preserving and study of traditional art and culture; it also has power to schedule monuments and antiquities, and to control archaeological excavations and the export of antiquities. The Director of Antiquities is professionally and administratively responsible for museums all over the country; he has the assistance of a deputy director and the curators of the different museums. Other officers concentrate on archaeological, iconographical and architectural research. Government expenditure on the Department of Antiquities over the past ten years has been as follows: 1960/61, £47,190; 1961/62, £54,240; 1962/63, £98,790; 1963/64, £87,100; 1964/65, £87,500; 1965/66, £83,870; 1966/67, £91,340; 1967/68, £92,650; 1968/69, £81,250; 1969/70, £79,610. 30 Current administration and financing of culture Unesco-sponsored cultural activities The Art Section of the ministry works with the National Commission for Unesco in planning and organizing Nigeria's participation in Unesco cultural and sponsored special programmes, e.g. the recent Education Year celebrations, in which the Art Section, in collaboration with state ministries of education, mounted art exhibitions and put on cultural displays. The section coEects materials for publication and promotes the circulation of Unesco papers, journals, visual aids and so on. FEDERAL M I N I S T R Y OF E X T E R N A L AFFAIRS This ministry has a Department of Information which also covers cultural matters, including publicity and information through embassies abroad. Information officers attached to the embassies perform, the duties usually covered by cultural attache's. The ministry receives an allocation for cultural and industrial exhibitions, and participates in the drafting and implementing of cultural agreements. The ministry determines Nigeria's foreign cultural policy; after the necessary political consideration, it makes recommendations regarding the countries with which Nigeria should be culturally associated. F E D E R A L M I N I S T R Y OF TRADE AND I N D U S T R Y This ministry's connexion with cultural affairs is through the promotion of indigenous art and craft industries. In co-operation with the state ministries of trade, it encourages the production of local materials and arts and crafts, and subsidizes and encourages corporative societies. Products are regularly collected and exhibited in local and international trade fairs. Occasionally, other cultural displays are arranged as part of such trade fairs. The ministry initiates the programmes; the expenditure is borne by the Federal Ministry of Information. FEDERAL GOVERNMENT EXPENDITURE ON ART AND CULTURE It is very difficult to know how much exactly the federal government spends annually on art and culture. As already indicated, four ministries are involved, and even within them, more than one division may be dealing with cultural matters (cf. the account of the Ministry of Information above). The figures given in Tables 1 and 2 below are derived from the annual estimates and do not necessarily mean the actual amounts spent. In fact, the government invariably spent more on art and culture than the sums given in the annual estimates. This is because certain programmes were 31 H^ H o\ o o O o O (M o I O O 1 1C O &* C^ O o O O O «5 o c£ 0^ o ift Ift o" O M <M (M I—( o S3 o o^ 5" [— J CO o o O o Current administration and financing of culture \o o\ O O O T-T O t s m ift Ift O O (M i—4 1— 1 Cft o o CO o o (M loo 1 in> o <N M O CO s O (M o O O T-H VO ^* o ^ Ift O r-H (M cq o i£ o in Ot o" in_ i-t in 2 in 0} <X) w qj .S 'g O ^ I p *J § p -3 C3 ^ t-*" . O t-T 1-1 O (M in CO O (N ^ o co" O (M O O O O U^ O O o \O* (M O C<I IQ O VO (M CS1 o o o 0" (M O •** O O O O I i-i O Lft O (NO I Ift | CO i—1 (M (M VO I I I i*-l tC^ O O O N „ | •<# O ift CO (N CN! t- O tft r-J^ ift <N ~ '1 ri ^ i § "i *g | O O r—i in* O O O i—1 O CO^ Ift O 0 o^ 1—1 ® bq S co - ^ O ^ H 32 OH PH ^3 -3 g o ^ g p i ^ ^ co K » r-i 111 IPs iJlJJII * g O O 1 iiii iijii i «_||g.e "I" 0 SO O vO Ift O O O (M ift Ift •^f Ift o o o o CO* o vo g W -^ C$ CO^ o o o CO c^ I—I CO I—1 Ift o \o a 1 CO Ift t^" 1—1 t- «• I-l VO to" Ift 1—1 Ift 1ft ^" O £1< •* £ s ci CO i-H I o" OS rH tft r—I r-l r—I Ift (M OS s- d 1 ni H aw 0 <5 p § d & s faD r£ fQ 13 M f=i r-i TABLE CO O ft o .s, \o I 1—1 1 i-rt 4-> 9 S s £ •g O rON" rH ON ^O co" o\ rH CO c--" s s »3~ ON rH rH «. in~ *o 10 O vO OS rH S ON <ro" ^o OO I-H o oT t> <rq <rq OO 1C O r-T CO OO OO OO => O C o o m t0 OO Co* ic i/5 t oo OOO o o o O co1 1C rH t-H O (M O O O O O 1C o CO O O 1C rH O 0 O^ o" o o" o ^ o rH in O rH O rH oC OOO \O 0 O t-^ O^ ^? CO o O O c4" in" ON o o rH O T? OOO rH rH T? o o Current administration and financing of culture ic in *o <M O o O O O^ i-H^ O^ ^f OOO r-T lJO T-T OO O "^ r> CO f. N ^^ cq \Q rH £"•" rH CO U3 rH CO «• 1^1 i-H rH rH «« o 1C C* (M* l/T rH t- 0 0 rH i-H co^ (M t- 0 O o^ a 3 ^§ s i ? £ S o 'B « -g S a c3 m 1 l^l o » _g e3 o H Uil o" O CO O -<}i <rq o o c-f in rH O O O eo o o rj|^ O^ "^ rH O O O CO O O rH O •S uf OOO O OOO I-H IO_ OOO oT e<j r*l IC^ ^< w in §a S <! M o ills I1! oj 0 OOO 1C O O 1C O ^3* C^ Wi p. O IO c 7\ a r-H CO 8 « OOO OO ~ CO C^ z* OO OS OO m u «» o ^5 o o 0 10 o o in o O in o c^ me <) C\ co cq CO CO o o CO o m ui e-q t-T GSj^N 1C 00 ON LO ^ I •1 0 ji^||| s ^ -§ >s ^3\ lUH ! illll ijljjl 'o a o o O 10 i—j^ <N t>" CO o o rH CO o\ in *>_ cq CO o" o o cT \o ON i—I <N rH rH ON rH rH B 1 S3 o 1 CD rH H M H 33 Current administration and financing of culture arranged after the estimates had been prepared and the money had to be found for them. This happened in 1970/71 for example. By the end of 1970, three months before the end of the financial year, the government had spent about £100,000 on different cultural programmes including (a) £30,000 for a Nigerian group sent to Expo '70 in Japan, (b) £30,000 for the 1970 AllNigeria Festival of Art, (c) £10,000 for participation in a trade fair in Dahomey, (d) £16,000 on cultural exchangeprogramm.es. Thus, money is provided for approved cultural programmes from time to time, regardless of what the estimate foresees. The states ADMINISTRATIVE MACHINERY After the amalgamation of the Northern and Southern territories in 1914, Nigeria was ruled centrally by a colonial federal government in Lagos, through a number of provincial administrative centres. Following a constitutional review, Nigeria was divided in 1952 into three regions. Lagos, the federal capital, remained a separate territory administered by the federal government through the local council. Each regional government was autonomous and had powers on many constitutional matters, including education and culture. Art and cultural matters were dealt with in the regions under different ministries: Eastern Region, Internal Affairs; Western Region, Home Affairs; Northern Region, Local Government and Tourism. The Western Region was later subdivided, so increasing the number of regions to four. The Ministry of Community Development was made responsible for the festival in the mid-West. In 1967, the country was redivided into twelve state units (including the State of Lagos), which became responsible for local cultural matters. Like the federal government itself, they have no written cultural policy and do not concentrate cultural matters under one ministry. Provincial and local councils have a major role in planning and executing local cultural programmes, most of which they also finance. The state governments' cultural duties cover: cultural promotion and festivals of the arts; art and cultural education; cultural and community centres; museums and libraries; mass media and cultural information; State expenditure on culture. State festival of the arts Each provincial authority is requested to organize local festivals and select the best group to participate in the state festival, usually held in the state capital. The provincial authorities are responsible for the practical and financial administration of the local festivals and for arranging participation in the state festivals. 34 Current administration and financing of culture Art and cultural education (primary and secondary schools) Regardless of political or administrative changes, formal art education Las always come under the federal and state ministries of education. As already mentioned, education is a domain in the Constitution in which both the federal and state governments have powers in regard to policy, planning and administration. Primary and secondary schools and colleges are states' matters (although the federal government maintains some inter-state secondary schools, known as the Federal Government Colleges). The states' ministries are now responsible for the policy-making, administration and inspection of their individual systems of education. Some state ministries establish local school boards who share powers with them; others control education centrally. Some states' ministries have art departments for the planning and inspection of cultural subjects; some also have local inspectors, attached to the different local councils through whom the state inspectors work. Although art, music and drama are listed in the state educational planning, many primary and secondary schools do not teach them, mainly for lack of teachers and materials. During the last decade, however, the situation improved as more trained teachers became available. Some states appoint specialists in cultural subjects to tour their schools, giving demonstrations and organizing exhibitions with a view to improving standards. Some also include the arts in their adult education schemes; Lagos State, for example, runs a school of art and crafts as one of the centres for its adult education evening classes. Many states give scholarships annually for the training of teachers, including those specialists in art and cultural subjects. Museums and cultural centres One or two states give subventions for the upkeep and maintenance of museums. However, most museums, even if located in states, are maintained by the federal government. There are also very few state cultural centres, although some local councils maintain community and youth centres. It has always been difficult to indicate separately the amount spent in such cases on specifically cultural activities. Library services Each state is now responsible for its library services. The former regions established separate library boards through which library services are extended to all parts of the regions. Local and district councils maintain local libraries. Foreign embassies have regularly donated books. Other notable donors are the British Council and the United States Library Services. 35 Current administration and financing of culture Moss The former regional governments had separate broadcasting and television services, with local cultural programmes (in various Nigerian languages) which might also be relayed nationally. Again it is difficult to know exactly how much each station spends on cultural programmes. With the creation of the twelve states, it may be necessary to review the status and operations of the regional services. State expenditure on culture The state governments annually give subsidies to each provincial or local council to finance local activities and programmes, including culture and festivals. It is difficult to separate out the amounts spent on purely cultural programmes. Regional government subventions for art festivals since independence are as shown in Table 3. TABLE 3 Region North West Mid-West East Regional government subventions for art festivals 1960/61-1967/68 (in pounds) 1960/61 1961/62 _ 250 — 200 _ 250 — 200 1962/63 1963/64 1964/65 1965/66 1966/67 1967/68 5,000 250 — 700 5,000 250 — 500 5,000 250 — 300 5,000 250 250 300 5,000 250 250 300 5,000 230 250 300 These subventions are small as compared with expenditure and subventions for other programmes. But they grossly under-indicate the amounts spent on art and culture. They do not include, for example, the cost of transporting, feeding and housing some 300 or more participants at a typical festival, or government subventions for art workshops and industries. None the less, one must agree that expenditure on culture is exceedingly small, as compared with that on economic and political matters. However, subventions have been increasing gradually since independence and with more political stability it is expected that state governments will substantially increase their subventions and grants for cultural programmes. 36 Art agencies and cultural organizations Ait agencies and cultural organizations have contributed in very great measure to the general cultural awareness and development in Nigeria. They provide the living forces behind all cultural activities and compensated somewhat for the seeming official indifference. They can be broadly divided into three groups: agencies for the promotion of the arts; societies of professional artists; institutional or tribal cultural groups (which are found all over the country). Arts agencies Arts agencies or organizations spring up from time to time on the initiative of people who, though not necessarily artists, are interested in the arts. They include Nigerians and non-Nigerians in different walks of life. Members usually pay a subscription. If influential enough, or carrying out activities considered important by the government, they may get official recognition or a subvention, e.g. the Society for Arts and Humanities and the Nigerian Arts Council. S O C I E T Y F O R ARTS A N D H U M A N I T I E S This society was founded in 1963 by a group of Nigerians and expatriates collaborating in general cultural programmes in Lagos. Its main objective is to establish a museum of modern art. A foreign foundation indicated its readiness to help with grants to build the museum, but the civil war intervened. Meantime, the Federal Ministry of Education gives the society an annual subvention to finance the collection of art works. N I G E R I A N ARTS C O U N C I L The council was founded in 1959 on the eve of independence by the then Minister of Information and Social Services and some Nigerians and 37 Art agencies and cultural organizations Nigerian Arts Council Advises the Federal Government on cultural matters; plans and organizes national and international cultural programmes; promotes art. and culture; secures aids for cultural programmes Members Federal government officials, state government representatives, state art council representatives, university representatives and co-opted artists Executive Council Plans and executes all cultural programmes Members Elected officials, government officials IT Art and Gallery •Committee Plans and organizes art activities, museums, galleries and art societies Members Selected professional artist-painters, sculptors, designers and arcliitects T Music Committee Plans and organizes all musical activities Members Selected professional artistes, musicians, musicologists, directors Festival Committee Dance ami Drama Research Committee Plans and organizes all Plans and organizes all festival activities Members Government representatives, state representatives, university representatives, council officials, other co-opted members drama activities Research and studies in culture, art education, films, slides, reproductions Members University representatives, art educationists, -writers, Members Selected professional artistes/playwrights, poets, authors, actors, other co-opted members General Purpose Committee Takes urgent decisions for the council; Council Gallery Curator supervises the secretariat and gallery Five council members resident in. Lagos Secretariat Organizing Secretary Other secretariat staff Organization chart of the Nigerian Arts Council. 38 iilm producers, other co-opted members Art agencies and cultural organizations expatriates as a private organization to promote the advancement of arts in Nigeria. The objectives were set out as follows (see also the organ- ization chart opposite): The council shall work towards the promotion, revival development and encouragement of literary, visual and performing arts of Nigeria by: (a) assisting and encouraging deserving Nigerian artists and craftsmen; (b) initiating and participating in the revival, organization and conduct of cultural festivals, exhibitions, concerts and displays; (c) promoting and publicizing Nigerian arts in and outside Nigeria; (d) advising in the acquisition and preservation of art and cultural monuments; (e) fostering appreciation and pride in local tradition and culture by encouraging the compilation of publications on local history and monuments, the giving of lectures on local history and by education in the value of their artistic heritage; (f) encouraging the performance and exhibition of the forms of nonNigerian cultural activities in Nigeria with a view to the development of indigenous arts by the impact of international culture. The council quickly received government and public recognition, an annual subvention of £5,000 being approved by Parliament in 1961. It was the first cultural organization in Nigeria to receive government financial and moral support. It soon co-opted distinguished artists and men of culture. In connexion with the independence celebrations in i960, the council mounted an exhibition of ancient and contemporary Nigerian art works and organized some cultural dances and manifestations. In 1961 its Lagos branch established the gallery LABAC for the exhibition and sale of Nigerian art and crafts products. The council gradually became the main agent for government cultural activities. It was reconstituted in 1964 so as to include representatives of all the regional governments. In co-operation with the Federal Ministry of Information, it organized Nigerian participation in the 1965 British Commonwealth Festival of Art and the first Negro Festival of Art in Dakar; it was also responsible for arranging participation in other international events, including the 1968 Olympic Games. In 1968, the council was reorganized and its constitution reviewed to reflect new political changes and cultural development. Membership was enlarged to accommodate representatives of the newly created twelve states of the federation; in addition, all federal government officials concerned with art and cultural duties were co-opted. The council also has representatives from all five universities. The Executive Committee of the council is made up of elected officers as follows: president; three vice-presidents; secretary; treasurer; financial secretary; publicity secretary; four co-opted members. The Executive Committee meets once or twice a year to consider.-the reports and recommendations of the different committees which are also elected annually. . •• 39 Art agencies and cultural organizations Permanent committees deal with the following matters: art and art galleries; dance and drama; music; festivals; research. The five or six members of each committee meet from time to time to discuss matters concerning their assigned duties and make recommendations. The council maintains a secretariat and a gallery, both located in the same premises in Lagos. Its permanent officials include two organizing secretaries and a gallery curator. The day-to-day running of the council is left to the Honorary Secretary, who is helped by a General Purposes Committee. Among its other functions, the council organizes the annual national festival. The new constitution of the council provides for the creation of state art councils, i.e. each state has a branch of the Nigerian Arts Council which is responsible for local cultural activities and their co-ordination. The Nigerian Cultural Society was founded in Kaduna in the old Northern Region for the same purposes as the Nigerian Arts Council (which was originally active mainly in the south). It was recognized and financed by the then regional government, to plan and implement cultural programmes. It had a secretariat in Kaduna, and was responsible for the annual art festival. Members included professional artists, government officials and statesmen. It was also affected by the division of the region in 1968 into six new states. It operated under the Interim. Joint Common Service of the new states, and got money from the states to organize a festival in 1963. The festival was elaborately planned and other states were invited. After consultations, the society agreed to merge with the Nigerian Arts Council, which took over its responsibilities. Its president became first vice-president of the council. Artists' societies Painters, musicians, writers and other artists group together to meet, plan activities and try to find solutions to their common problems. Some of their activities may get government subventions. Notable examples are the Society of Nigerian Artists, the Union of Nigerian Musicians, the Musical Cultural Society, the Mbari Club. The Society of Nigerian Artists is requested each year to organize art exhibitions as part of the independence celebration. The Mbari Club was very active during the early 1960s when it organized many cultural activities in the then regional capitals. Cultural groups Cultural organizations exist in most towns and villages to promote their own ethnic or tribal culture and traditions. Members subscribe for regular activities, some of which commemorate events of local historical or cultural 40 Typical Nigerian traditional cultural centre in Northern Nigeria. Typical Nigerian traditional cultural centre in Southern Nigeria. Typical Northern Nigeria architecture. Two Nigerian artists painting a mural commissioned by a commercial firm in Lagos, Nigeria. Potters in Abuja at work. Typical Northern Nigeria traditional music makers. A Nigerian musician teaching his son the secret of his profession. A traditional ruler at the Ojofa cultural festival surrounded by his Odis chiefs. Photos: Federal Ministry of Information, Nigeria. Art agencies and cultural organizations significance. In cities and towns, people from clans or villages come together as cultural groups to continue the traditions from which they are otherwise cut off in their new place of residence; sometimes the purpose is to raise funds for educational and social development in their home villages. Similar to the tribal groups are societies grounded in a common religious or educational institution. They too organize regular art and cultural programmes for members, and invite the public. 41 The transmission of culture Cultural centres Cultural centres can be either specially designed, permanent structures, or existing buildings adapted or adopted for cultural purposes. In the pre- colonial era, special cultural centres were few, for the single reason that most of the traditional activities and performances did not need them, taking place mainly in the open air at appropriate places in towns and villages. Rites for ancestral worship, for the celebration of the new yam, the marriage ceremony, and initiation into cults, took place in towns, or sometimes in the bush. Some traditional performances like the Northern durbars could be performed only in the open. The few cultural structures that existed were mostly religious: shrines (e.g. Ibo Mbari shrines) and the Moslem moscjues. When new art forms were introduced and assimilated, it became necessary to provide more formally organized premises. These are of four main kinds: (a) cultural centres staffed and equipped by the public authorities; (b) public buildings, available part-time (e.g. town halls, community centres, schools); (c) centres specially provided by art and artists' organizations; (d) centres provided by foreign embassies, mainly for international cultural exchanges. MUSEUMS1 Notable among the centres provided by the public authorities are the six museums, in different parts of the country, which mainly display Nigerian antiquities. Jos Museum. Jos displays the Nofc terracottas, Ife and Benin bronzes, wood-carvings and other sculpture from different parts of the country, 1. Written in consultation with Efcpo Eyo, Director of Museums. 42 The transmission of culture unique Abuja pottery and books written by Northern scholars. Other items on display include masks, stone and iron implements of prehistoric communities. Traditional craftsmanship is being revived as part of the museum's activities. There are two Buji blacksmiths, a woman potter from the Jawara village, an Igala wood-carver and a brass-smith—all working with traditional equipment in the museum grounds. A zoo was started in the museum grounds in 1955. The animals include various types of monkeys and a 250-year-old tortoise. Ife Museum. Opened in November 1954, the museum has on display the world-famous Ife bronze heads which have been acclaimed by experts as among the finest bronze casts in the world. There are also terracotta heads, Ife stone sculpture, finds excavated by the Department of Antiquities. Benin Museum. Opened in 1960, this museum contains some of the earliest and finest Benin bronzes, some of which were dug up accidentally in constructing the modern city of Benin. Benin has produced some of the finest bronze heads and statues ever made, and they are the most widely known of all Nigerian arts in the outside world. Apart from the bronzes, there are also on display carvings and brasswork, commemorating Obas and princesses and the history of the Edo people. Nigerian National Museum. This, the principal museum in Nigeria, was opened to the public in 1957. It is situated near King George V Memorial Park, in Lagos. The museum has three main galleries. The first contains ethnographic objects, some of which are exceedingly rare specimens: wood-carvings which include ancestor figures from Oron (regarded as the oldest wood-carvings in Africa) and Yoruba carvings—divination bowls and boards, figures representing dead twins, gelede masks, carved door panels and tools; water spirit masks from Ibo and Ibibio areas; carved heads covered with skin, made more impressive by the curling horns, beads and feathers fixed on to them (a unique art form not produced anywhere else in West Africa); calabashes, and pottery. The second, smaller, gallery on the ground floor contains the largest terracotta Nok head, from one of the specialized cultures that flourished in Nigeria some 2,000 years ago; terracottas from Ife; some of the famous Ife bronze heads; a very fine one-metre-high Ogboni bronze figure; iron lamps from Yoruba land; brass bowls from Bida; and archaeological stone tools (scrapers, razors, grinding stones, axes and other implements of daily use). In the courtyard, stone age slabs reveal how stone figures were produced* The third gallery, the Benin gallery on the first floor, contains some world-famous works: bronze plaques from the walls of the Oba's palace depicting events and life in the court of Benin, a unique queen-mother's bronze head, beautiful bronze leopards, ancestral heads representing 43 The transmission of culture previous Obas, carved tusks and other ivory-carvings. A considerable number of these objects were recovered from Europe where they had been taken after the British expedition to Benin in 1897. The objects are aesthetically arranged in such a way as to provide a cross-section of the Nigerian community and its individual traditions. Other museums. There are small museums at Oron, Esie, Kano and Owo, and at Mbari houses at Ibadan, Benin and Oshogbo. All museums are open, to the public daily from dawn to dusk. Nigerian museums and monuments enhance the world's knowledge of the people who have inhabited Africa; they are helping to open the door to man's past and to increase the world's respect for the African people. MONUMENTS1 The scheduled monuments of Nigeria include sites of prehistoric rock paintings, ancient city walls, traditional buildings of architectural interest, tombs of historic Nigerians, monoliths, carved stone figures and talking drums. These are protected by law under the Antiquities Act of 1963. In some cases, the monuments are in towns, e.g. the old Iga Idunganran in Lagos which is of both architectural and historic interest. In many cases the tourist may have to travel out of town to view them. The following are some of the outstanding monuments. Rock paintings: Birnin Kudu and Geji. These rock paintings, in Kano and Bauchi provinces respectively, are the most important so far found in Nigeria. The Birnin Kudu cattle paintings and symbolic drawings have affinities with some of the Sahara paintings. Both are accessible by motor road. Gobirau minaret: Katsina. This is a fifty-foot tower built of mud and palm timber. It is the remains of the mosque constructed in Habe times, before the holy wars of Sheikh Usman Dan Fodio. Parts of the tower are thought to be 250 years old. Carved monoliths: Ikom. The most accessible of these monoliths are in a grove by the roadside near Maghabe on the Enugu-Ogoja-Gboko road. There are many circles with stone-carvings representing human beings; some show affinities with wood-carvings of the Oran clan. The carvings are sacred, and an annual festival is held here at the end of the dry season. 1. Adapted from Paul Coremans, 'Preservation of the Cultural Heritage in Tropical Africa', Museum (Paris, Unesco), Vol. XVIII, No. 3, 1965. 44 The transmission of culture Makama's House: Kano. This is one of the oldest remaining houses in Kano. It has been declared a monument and converted into a museum for antiquities and the arts and crafts of the Hausa and Fulani of the Kano area. Slit Drums: Ikot Ekpene. These drums are carved from hard wood and are about nine feet long and three feet in diameter. These Ikuruk drums are treasured possessions of many villages in the Oron, Afaha and Otoro clan areas of Uyo Province. Jebba and Tada bronzes. These are nine extraordinary bronze figures associated with Tsede, founder of the Nupe Kingdom in the fifteenth century. Six are the largest cast bronzes in Africa. They show affinities with early Ife and Benin works. Apart from their aesthetic appeal, each has a history. The monuments are useful for educational purposes and also interest tourists. Their presence is adequately sign-posted at convenient places on the road leading to them. The Department of Antiquities is responsible for protecting monuments and keeping them in good condition. PUBLIC HALLS A N D C O M M U N I T Y C E N T R E S In most towns and big villages there are public halls and community centres suitable for day-to-day local cultural activities. They are built and maintained by the local authority. Some are designed to accommodate modern theatre, musical performances, dances, lectures, exhibitions and perhaps film shows. The staff are usually not artists, but look after bookings and arrangements. They vary in design and capacity, from the city hall with room for a thousand to the local community centre holding less than a hundred. Organizations are allowed to bring in their own equipment for performances. A hiring fee may or may not be charged. Theatre or auditorium. Schools and colleges may have suitable halls designed and equipped to accommodate performances. However, they are not usually available for outside use except perhaps during school holidays. Cinemas. In addition to normal film shows, cinemas may at times be available for other shows and for music and drama rehearsals. Clubs. A few organizations use rented houses or premises which they staif and equip themselves as cultural centres, mainly for members, e.g. the Mbari houses established in different parts of the country in the early 1960s, which accommodate drama, music and dance performances, art exhibitions, seminars and lectures. The public is usually admitted on payment of an entry charge. The Mbari houses also publish journals and periodicals which 45 The transmission of culture may be offered for public sale. The Nigerian Arts Council has always had a centre (at secretariat headquarters) for cultural activities, including art exhibitions, lectures and seminars. E M B A S S Y CULTURAL CENTRES Some foreign embassies run centres as a means of promoting international contacts and understanding, and regularly arrange art exhibitions, film shows, concerts and plays. They sponsor exhibitions by local artists and bring works of foreign artists for show in Nigeria. Activities in the centres are usually filmed by the embassies and the films are sent to the home countries, and occasionally shown in Nigeria. The United States Information Service, the British Council and the German Cultural Institute all have centres both in Lagos and in the former regional capitals. Many new Western cultural forms and values have been assimilated, but lack structural facilities; in particular, there is a great need for more cultural centres. A few organizations are doing their best, but the scale of faculties needed for national and international cultural festivals is definitely beyond the reach of private organizations; only the government or the really big commercial firms could cope. The positive step taken by the federal government in allocating £500,000 for the building of a national theatre in its four-year development programme is very encouraging. The money will probably be used to build a theatre in Lagos capable of accommodating the different festivals. It is hoped that each state government will build theatres in its capital and other cities. Meanwhile, existing halls should be equipped to accommodate film shows, lectures, seminars and so on. There is no reason why the states should not have their own museums and museum services, collecting and displaying local objects of artistic and historical significance. This would increase the tourist attraction and allow more people to experience art. As part of the museum, states could collect and snow contemporary art and crafts. However, it is important to avoid state rivalries. Each could have its own museum, but works of art discovered or produced locally should also be exhibited in other states and at the national museums. As facilities for the training of museum personnel are inadequate, a centrally organized training service would provide a good solution. The proposed extension of the National Museum, in Lagos should be done qiiickly, and local facilities should be provided to allow Nigeria to display the richness of its artistic heritage to the world. Galleries for contemporary works are also needed—the existing galleries are usually over-booked; and a national museum of modern art should be established for the permanent display of outstanding contemporary works. 46 The transmission of culture Mass media Radio and television. Radio and television have played very significant roles in spreading art and culture and fostering contacts and awareness of music and the arts. Television seems to have produced the more effective and lasting impact, mainly because of its visual quality (particularly important, obviously, in e.g. dances and acrobatic displays). Radio broadcasting is mainly limited to music and drama. Some 3.5 million radios have an estimated audience of 20-25 million listeners. Radio covers all parts of the country, and hence has a wider audience than television. Regular features and talks, by professional artists, scholars and specialists, have helped to promote a better understanding and appreciation of the arts. Editors also interview artists. School units produce and relay educational and cultural programmes to schools and colleges, in co-operation with the ministries of education, and usually during school hours. Specialists in art, music and drama are commissioned to prepare lessons suitable for the different categories of students. Programmes and visual aids are circulated in advance so that students can follow the lessons or talks intelligently. Other school programmes include live art, music, and drama broadcasts, model-making for teenagers and arts and crafts demonstrations. Visual arts. Television interviews with local and foreign artists, often in connexion with exhibitions, are a regular feature. Most Nigerian artists are formally trained in local and foreign universities and use media that are new to the Nigerian public. During such programmes, artists can explain their materials, methods and techniques and their approach to creative work, while the general public has a chance to hear at first hand what the contemporary artist has to say. Nigerian television, which is mainly black-and-white, has been fairly effective in bringing the modern arts nearer to the people, thereby increasing the hearing given to artists and making publicity for them (it is not uncommon for artists to get a new commission after an appearance on television). Exhibitions of foreign works allow the public to compare local and foreign talent, show local artists how their colleagues abroad solve similar problems and are also very helpful to art teachers and students. Music. Music programmes are similarly educationally beneficial to the public, local musicians and musicologists, music students and teachers. Drama. Drama programmes are very popular with viewers. They vary in types and in manner of production. Some traditional plays are often performed by amateur actors in Nigerian languages; other plays are performed by professional actors in English. Some of the plays comment on or reflect local social, religious or political events. 47 The transmission of culture Dance. Traditional dances from different parts of the country make exciting television and show not only the diversity but also the complexity of the traditional dance systems. Apart from weekly programmes, foreign films and occasional documentaries, the big cultural occasions and festivals are transmitted live. Cinema. The film industry is comparatively new but the Federal Film Unit has produced some good documentary films and features. These however are rarely shown in the commercial cinemas, which prefer to show foreign films. No film of real cultural significance has so far been produced. As stated above, a federal Films Censorship Board screens films before they are shown to the public. Cinemas in many towns and villages attract teenage and older spectators, most of whom have no other way of spending their evenings. The films are mostly foreign, from America, India and Britain. Foreign films display the subtleties of foreign cultures, but unfortunately also their violent aspects. Their effects on society are not always healthy. There is now a growing tendency for people to stay at home and watch television rather than go to the cinema. Libraries. The role of the library in promoting cultural diffusion is steadily increasing as more and more libraries are opened in towns and villages. Unfortunately, most of their books (like films in the cinemas) are foreign, written and published abroad. While there are few Nigerian authors (and fewer still on cultural subjects), some of the novels and literature by Nigerian writers succeed in reflecting Nigerian life and culture. The National Library and some of the bigger libraries periodically organize programmes with films and slides. A few libraries also adorn their premises with Nigerian paintings and sculpture. Newspaper critics. There are very few trained art critics in Nigeria, but articles on art or artists nevertheless appear in the different newspapers. Whatever their limitations, they play a useful role in publicizing artists, art exhibitions and other programmes. They report talks or lectures given by art scholars and sometimes publish pictures of works of art and various cultural activities. Festivals of the arts The origin of these festivals dates back to 1938 when Nigeria participated in the British Empire Exhibition at Glasgow and art and crafts from Nigeria were exhibited along with the works of artists of other countries. Nigeria's participation was not very successful. After the exhibition a group of expatriate officials was invited to organize local festivals in preparation for 48 The transmission of culture such international exhibitions. The government later provided some subventions. However, these festivals differed greatly from the traditional local festivals held in towns and villages today. Festival administration first came under the Public Relations Office in Lagos; it was later transferred to the Ministry of Natural Resources and Social Welfare and finally to the Federal Ministry of Information. For many years, the festivals were centrally organized from Lagos, but artists all over the country participated. The main events were traditional and modern drama, instrumental and choral music, traditional folk-lore, dances, poetry writing and reading, and art and crafts. There were junior competitions for schools and senior competitions open to all professional artists. Following the creation of the regions and later, of the states, changes were made in the festival organization and administration. Each local council is now responsible for the selection of groups and troupes to participate in the provincial or state festival. From the state festival the best troupes are selected to participate in the National Festival of the Arts. The practical and financial organization is undertaken, first by the local councils and later, by the states' arts councils. In the past ad hoc committees organized the National Festival, but this is now done by the Nigerian Arts Council under the auspices of the Federal Ministry of Information. The federal government bears the main cost (a grant of over £30,000 was made to the council to organize the 1970 festival). The council intends to hold the National Festival successively in the different state capitals, to encourage the spread of culture and promote national unity. Firms and private organizations made contributions towards the costs of the 1970 National Festival. Selected items from the National Festival may also represent Nigeria in international or other festivals—which, in recent years, have included the Commonwealth Festival of Arts, the World Festival of Negro Arts, the All-African Cultural Festival sponsored by the Organization of African Unity, Expo '67 in Canada, and Expo '70 in Japan. -Premises are a major difficulty. There is at present not a single theatre in Nigeria that could cope with the National Festival. Those at present available are inadequate. Nigeria urgently needs a proper national theatre. As indicated above, the government's four-year development programme includes provision to spend some £500,000 on one. Finance is another problem. The expenditure on lodging, hotels and transport is so heavy that it can only be met by the government. Unless it and the states contribute, it may be difficult to organize future festivals (especially in the states). The competitive nature of the festivals poses another problem. What should be judged in the traditional dances of a state or ethnic group and who is qualified to make the judgement? And does the judgement presuppose that some cultures are better than others? 49 The transmission of culture There is also potentially a shortage of personnel capable of handling the actual physical organization. When the National Festival moves to some of the newly created states it may be difficult to get enough hands to cope. In Lagos there is a concentration of art experts, many of whom work in different federal ministries and organizations. A possible solution would be to give enough funds to the Nigerian Arts Council to enable it to employ more permanent staff" who could be posted temporarily to cover the festivals. Art education and personnel training FORMAL T E A C H I N G The introduction of formal teaching in cultural subjects in Nigerian schools was a fairly late development. The first Nigerian to train as an artist was the late Chief Aina Onabolu, who studied art in London and Paris before returning in 1923 to teach art in schools in Lagos. He also continued to paint—mainly portraits of eminent citizens and administrators. Chief Onabolu was credited with having convinced the government to invite expatriate teachers to come to teach art.1 The first to accept the invitation was K. C. Murray, an Englishman, who arrived in Nigeria in 1927 and formally introduced the teaching of art at government colleges in Lagos and Umuahia. However, there was still no government policy regarding the teaching of art or other cultural subjects. The teachers were left to teach in any way they liked and with any material they chose. Most of the European teachers used imported materials with which they were familiar and exhibited the results from time to time for the inspectors who went round occasionally to give them encouragement. But their efforts did not induce the inspectors to press for more attention to creative subjects; these continued to be rated low and taught least in the schools and colleges. Today the situation is not much better. None of the cultural and creative subjects are compulsory in primary and secondary schools in Nigeria. Even at the teacher-training colleges, art and music are either optional or not available. As a result, over 80 per cent of primary-school teachers have not had any formal art training. Getting materials creates further problems. It is only in schools where there are trained or interested teachers and sufficient funds from the head of the school to buy materials that the subjects are taught. Such schools constitute a very low percentage of the primary schools. The position is better in the secondary schools, where art and cultural subjects have gradually been taking their rightful place in the curriculum. 1. Nigeria Magazine (Lagos), 79. 50 The transmission of culture Art teachers are graduating every year, with a corresponding increase in the number of secondary schools that can offer art teaching. The subject's popularity has been greatly enhanced by the success of students in local art examinations and international exhibitions. Music has also been formally introduced into many schools, especially those directly administered by the federal or state ministries of education. But as compared with other countries, the position still needs to be improved. A former Chief Art Examiner, R. Carline, said in a recent survey of art education in Nigeria: It is perhaps relevant to observe that in Great Britain, with a population comparable to that of Nigeria, it would be hard to find any school that does not include art in its curriculum. Even so, the schools are under constant pressure to give the subject yet more attention. Meanwhile, the number of candidates in art at Ordinary Level in Great Britain must be nearly one hundred times as great as in Nigeria. Comparison with countries in an equivalent stage of development may be relevant. In Uganda, for example, 80 per cent of its fifty-two schools listed for School Certificate enter candidates in art, and the number (1,300) far exceeds that of Nigeria, although Uganda's population is so infinitely smaller. The same is true, but to a slightly lesser extent, in the other East African countries (Kenya, Tanzania, Zambia). Mauritius enters as many candidates in art as Nigeria, and Malaysia enters thirty times as many. In both these two countries, nearly all the secondary schools—those which teach up to the School Certificate level—include the teaching of art.1 As far as art training in higher education institutions is concerned, covering visual arts, music, drama, architecture, etc., the different courses given by the principal universities and colleges are as follows. Ahmadu Bella University, Zaria. This was the first university to start a four-year diploma and graduate course in art. Specializations include painting, sculpture, design, textiles, ceramics, with subsidiary courses in printing, photography, history of art. Following a recent reorganization, the university now runs the following courses, differing in duration, entry qualifications and academic level: B.A. (Art) (three years). Entry qualification: General Certificate of Education, Advanced level (GCE 'A' level) in art and one other subject. M.A./Ph.D. Two- or three-year M.A. or Ph.D. courses in fine art are open to B.A. graduates in art. Diploma course (four years). Entry qualification: GCE Ordinary level, or the Nigerian Grade Two Teacher Certificate. Proficiency course (one year). A specialization course for practising and professional artists. Art teachers' course. A post-graduate one-year course run jointly by the faculties of education and of fine art provides opportunities for artists 1. R. Carline, Art Education Survey, Lagos, 1967. 51 The transmission of culture wishing to teach, enables them to learn the principles, materials and methods of art teaching. As far as architecture is concerned, a four-year B.A. (Arch.) course is open to students who hold the GCE 'A' level in relevant subjects. Subsequent professional examinations are arranged by the Nigerian Institute of Architecture in co-operation with the university. University of Nsukka. This university also offers a B.A. (Art) course. Specializations include painting, sculpture and design, with archaeology, printing, photography and journalism as subsidiary subjects. There is also a three-year diploma (non-graduate) course for vocational teachers. The university's Showande College of Music offers a four-year B.A. course and a three-year diploma course in music. University of Ife. A newly created Art Department under the Faculty of Education offers a three-year B.Ed. (Art) course, primarily intended to train art teachers and educationists; students attend education courses and obtain teaching practice. The Music Department of the university is still part of the Institute of African Studies. Students can take music as a supplementary subject for their degrees. Talented students from other departments have also attended practical courses with very good results. Yaba College of Technology. A two-year programme for personnel needed in government departments, commercial firms and the private sector offers courses in general art, printing, commercial design, sculpture, pottery and fashion design. A four-year Higher Diploma course, expected to start soon, will give more advanced training. The college also runs part-time evening courses. Training of art teachers. Apart from university courses, courses at some six advanced teacher-training colleges include art as a subject for the Nigerian Certificate of Education. University of Ibadan. The School of Drama runs a course in drama and allied subjects. The school has a travelling theatre which brings plays to all parts of the country. In addition to the Schools of Arts already mentioned, all the universities have institutes of African studies where courses are available in African literature, languages, anthropology, archaeology, African history and sociology. 52 The transmission of culture INFORMAL TRAINING Not all practising artists and craftsmen in Nigeria have received formal training or would even want to. The academic and financial demands are too heavy for some, and these mostly learn through an apprenticeship system. During the early part of his training, the apprentice is maintained by his master for whom he does all sorts of odd jobs. After some time (depending on his ability), the apprentice may be able, at a modest price, to sell some of what he produces. When he has gained skill enough he sets up on his own and apprentices come to him in turn for training. The system may be less strict but it has produced many outstanding craftsmen. The duration of training depends on the type of craft. Carving, weaving, casting and ironwork take about three years; calabash decoration, tying and dyeing, and embroidery, take about two. Other new crafts in which Nigerians train informally include printing, photography and sign-writing. Co-operative craft industries. Informal apprenticeship training and the ministries of trade and industry encourage craftsmen to come together and set up a co-operative crafts workshop. These get government subventions and many local industries have prospered in consequence in towns and villages where suitable local materials are available. The workshops are not directly controlled by the ministry, which does however arrange for displays and publicity, especially at national and international trade fairs. Some examples of local crafts industries: carving (Benin); pottery (Ado-Ekiti); weaving (Iseyin and Okenne); calabash workshop (Oyo); leather (Kano and Kaduna); weaving (Akwete); dyeing (Ilorin and Abeokuta); pottery (Abujah); ceramics (Ikorodu). Other workshops. Besides the regular co-operative industries, periodic art workshops are organized by art societies for the people who could not study at established institutions. The Mbari Club ran a series of art, drama and music workshops before the civil war. Participants included illiterate freelance artists, and schoolteachers wanting to learn new art techniques. Courses included painting in different media, wood printing, etching and traditional terracotta. The Ori-Olokun Art Centre of the University of Ife now runs similar courses, and products from it are regularly exhibited in Ibadan and Lagos. Arts and crafts trade centres. Post-primary trade centres have recently been established in some Northern states. Subjects at the centres include painting and decoration and traditional crafts (leather, weaving, pottery, calabash decoration). The main course lasts for about three years, after which the students go out to establish or work in industries where their skills are needed. The training is organized under specialist and trained instructors; unlike the co-operative workshops, the trade centres admit students between the ages of 12 and 18 years only. There is a federal government trade centre in Lagos; the training provided is more technical than creative, and concludes with examinations. 53 The transmission, of culture PROBLEMS OF ART EDUCATION Primary and secondary. The major problems are the lack of qualified teachers, of art rooms and art materials, and of visual aids and textbooks. The first problem is gradually being solved by the number of art teachers graduating yearly from institutions of higher learning and by the concerted government efforts to train more teachers under a crash programme. Unfortunately, such teachers tend to work only in the secondary schools, where they have enhanced status; the problem of the primary schools remains. Only a very few teacher-training colleges have made an effort to include art in the curriculum. Serving teachers in primary schools have no opportunity of learning the subjects, as no in-service training in art is available, and this will continue unless drastic government measures are taken to improve it. The state ministries of education could run part-time evening courses in art and crafts for such teachers, or refresher courses during the holidays. They could also make art and music compulsory in the teachertraining colleges. Most headmasters or school authorities still regard art and music as 'luxury' subjects for which no funds can be provided to purchase materials and equipment. Few schools have art rooms, space having been allocated long before art and music were included in the curricula. With no rooms or materials, the art teacher finds it extremely difficult to work. Even when funds are available, the materials may not be, as they are mostly imported. Examinations demand the use of more imported than local materials—out of the six sections of the School Certificate Art examination, only one (crafts) can be done with local materials. A government embargo on the import of certain materials also adversely affected teaching in textile print- ing and embroidery. Very few books on art, visual aids or reproduction are available; slides are fewer still. In view of the present financial situation in the schools, only ministries and school authorities can provide the funds for such aids and provide regular refresher courses for both primary and secondary teachers. Most of the latter have to work in isolation in towns and villages, usually several miles apart, with none of the regular contacts or exchanges that refresher courses could provide. Universities. Although the educational system was inherited from the United Kingdom, there are no independent art schools. Art departments are part of the universities and are controlled by them. Many educational administrators have very little understanding of the arts and little time for cultural subjects; they may superficially agree that these subjects should 54 The transmission of culture be encouraged along with the others, but in practice find it difficult to equate them to other disciplines. Opinions vary. Some doubt whether art can be academically equated with science and other subjects—if so, must not art students present the same entry academic qualifications, irrespective of their talents in the arts? But then, should students who only have their outstanding ability in the arts be excluded from the university? What roles are art graduates expected to play in society? Should they be treated as people with special talents, or as other graduates in administrative or executive appointments? Will art graduates be capable of holding administrative or other responsible posts if their training is artistic only? Content. The question of content raises other problems for art education planners. In view of Nigeria's reputation in the arts, it is often held that art education should be unequivocally based on traditional forms. Others feel it should develop along the same lines as in other countries. And some favour a compromise between the two. If a compromise is the solution, what are to be the proportions of foreign and traditional art? Again, what jobs are graduate artists likely to find? At present, over 90 per cent are engaged in teaching. They have few openings in the civil service, industry or commerce. As still more art teachers are needed in schools, it has been suggested that the art course shoiild include courses in education. This may be one of the reasons for the University of Ife B.Ed, course in art and for the introduction of education as a subsidiary subject for art students in Ahmadu Bello (Zaria) and Nsukka. On the other hand, the time taken by education may adversely affect the art course and distract the art student. At present, the only feasible solution is to train on the assumption of a future teaching career. Perhaps growth in industry and advertising will provide a better market for free-lance artists, and justify a change of direction in art courses. Finances. Apart from materials, equipment may also be essential, i.e. lighting and costumes for a play or concert. College authorities are usually slow to appreciate the need to spend so much money on art departments for results which are not tangibly or economically evident, and the resulting scarcity or lack of funds means hardship for both art students and teachers. Departments have to cancel or postpone studies, teach without essential visual aids (e.g. reproductions, slides), and without suitable references or textbooks. Staffing. From the time the first art department was set up in Nigeria, expatriates dominated the staffing, as few Nigerians were qualified, and they introduced the systems and kind of education with which they were familiar. The results have been ably desciibed by Demas Nwoko, a lecturer 55 The transmission of culture in drama in one of the Nigerian universities, in a paper read at an African symposium: Many of our students are now employed in radio and television, and many more are teaching in grammar schools, but I regret to say that it seems we have not made African artists out of them. As I said earlier, by the very system we use, which is an amalgamation of the European and American university systems, added to the situation where available teaching materials were almost entirely on Western theatre forms, they stepped out of our school as if they had trained in any drama school in London. There is very little one can do to change the orientation of the school since our university is international in character and our staff from all over. This also reflects the situation in other art subjects and steps must be taken to improve it. One way would be to recruit more qualified and experienced Nigerians into the departments teaching art and cultural subjects, people who know and feel Nigerian cultural values and can gradually help them to permeate our cultural education; this would transform the present system and enable it really to reflect the traditions and aspirations of the people. TRAINING OF P E R S O N N E L There are few directors of theatres, curators of museums and galleries, and other such administrators, for the simple reason that Nigeria has few such institutions. Those which do exist have staff who are trained locally and send a small number abroad for more advanced training. Museum personnel. In addition to departmental and overseas training, an international bilingual centre in Jos, run with Unesco aid and experts, provides training for museum technicians from Nigeria and other tropical countries. The principal and the instructors are bilingual. Courses last about nine months. Entry qualification is the GCE '0' level. Practical training includes conservation techniques, display design, moulding of replicas, production of audio-visual aids. Museum education services. The Department of Antiquities in Lagos has started a schools and colleges programme. Experts have been invited from abroad to run short courses and seminars for officials and schoolteachers. Regular workshops are helping to revive traditional arts and crafts, and popularize them in schools. Television staff training. NBC-TV, the Nigerian Broadcasting Corporation, has a staff training school and also arranges for advanced training and attachments overseas. Local authority training. Western State and a few others run in-service training courses for local government officials, including those in charge of community centres and local libraries. The training seldom covers arts administration, but certainly enhances ability and confidence. 56 The transmission of culture Citizenship and leadership training. The federal government has sponsored courses in different parts of the country to train people capable of taking leading roles in local social, sporting and cultural activities. More formal and specifically designed training will be necessary for staff of the proposed national theatre, the Museum of Modern Art and other developments likely to take place within the next few years. INTENSIFIED CULTURAL AWARENESS Cultural education has a very vital role to play in bridging the gaps between the illiterate majority and the educated minority. It transmits and perpetuates in addition to serving as an instrument of unity, development and change. Formally or informally, a good system of cultural education should reach everyone, irrespective of age, sex, religion, ethnic origin or language; through it, the culture of a people can be effectively transmitted; with its help, the spiritual challenges posed by the modern world can be confidently faced. The Nigerian educational system must give more attention to cultural subjects—this will definitely promote inter-tribal understanding and national unity. Cultural education can be made more effective by more youth exchanges, through festivals, exhibitions and literary and cultural seminars. These in turn suppose having cultural and sports centres throughout the country, and the formation of art clubs and cultural societies. Prizes and study grants should be awarded to those having outstanding artistic or creative abilities. Papers for children should help to counteract the perhaps excessive influence of foreign newspapers and magazines and enough publications on Nigerian art, music, folk-lore and traditional poetry should be made available to occupy a gieat portion of their reading time. Efforts should also be made to introduce the major Nigerian languages into the school curricula, which in turn should give greater weight to things, envisaging comparative local studies to eradicate prejudice and promote cultural harmony. It is when cultural education has inculcated the idea of national unity that a national policy becomes really practicable; cultural education is a potential instrument of peace that has never been adequately used and, at this present time of national reconstruction and reconciliation, it should not be neglected. It should be used to reduce antagonisms between tribal, religious, social and political groups, to promote the inter-tribal understanding that can lead to active cultural co-operation in a new awareness of a common cultural heritage. Art patronage and the artist's problems As a result of the new patronage and new social functions of the arts, certain traditional forms of aid have largely disappeared. New forms of financial 57 The transmission of culture aid and other encouragement are being given by those who are now in a position to patronize the arts: public authorities, firms, foundations and local art organizations. Government aid. Government grants are limited, and usually come as subventions for the making or purchases of specially needed works. Thus, the federal government has commissioned certain items to commemorate historical occasions in Nigeria or for presentation to other countries or world organizations in similar circumstances (e.g. at the time of Independence, the bronze statue of the Queen of England which now stands in front of the Parliament). Regional and state governments have also commissioned statues and paintings to mark special occasions or to honour heroes or statesmen. The Federal Ministry of Education makes an annual subvention for the collection of art works for the proposed Museum of Modern Art (a total of over £30,000 during the past six years). This has allowed the purchase of over a hundred items from leading Nigerian artists. The Federal Ministry of Information also subsidizes the purchase of art works for embassies abroad, or government offices and public buildings in Lagos. Government honours for artists. Artists have not been left out in honour awards. The late Chief Aina Onabolu, who could be regarded the father of Nigerian modern art, was also the first artist to receive a national honour, the colonial government awarding him the Order of the British Empire. Two other artists (one a musician) received the Member of the British Empire order before British honours were renounced shortly after independence. A Nigerian architect and a woman potter were later awarded the Order of the Niger. The Federal Cultural Adviser has received an honorary doctor of letters degree from a Nigerian university. These awards carry no financial benefits, but are valued and appreciated by artists so rewarded and encourage others who can likewise aspire to them. Firms. Commercial firms, including banks and hotels, have constituted the main patrons, commissioning or purchasing murals, paintings and sculpture to decorate offices and residences. Almost all the big hotels and banks possess murals or art works by Nigerian artists and many free-lance artists depend on their patronage. A few firms give annual prizes or scholarships to art and architecture students in Nigerian universities. Art associations. The Nigerian Arts Council makes annual cash awards for different competitive events in the National Festival. The Society of Nigerian Artists awards cash prizes to outstanding art students in schools and colleges. Some private patrons (mostly European collectors) pro- vide financial or other help for artists, but it is difficult to say how much. 58 Tlie transmission of culture The artist's problems. The artist has problems in relation both to his art and to society. Nigeria has two main categories of artists: traditional and 'modern'. The traditional artists are mainly illiterate. They lack formal education but have inherited a family tradition. Found mostly in towns and villages, the most successful among them live in the cities. They simply continue traditional techniques and have very few problems. After an apprenticeship, they settle down to reproduce in quantity what they have learnt to make and sell easily to tourists and foreign collectors. The others, formally trained locally or abroad, assimilate foreign techniques and attitudes. Some settle down to permanent jobs, mainly in teaching. Modem in outlook, their art is understood and appreciated only by foreigners and some more sophisticated Nigerians. Very often neither their own families nor the public understand. Their work, similar to what is produced in Europe (or produced in Nigeria by Europeans), does not find a ready market. Tourists and foreign collectors are seldom interested in a kind of art they can easily collect anywhere in Europe or America. In their efforts to find a market, some of the artists fall back on copying traditional forms, or working local materials with western techniques. Unfortunately, many lack conviction in using their newly acquired techniques and remain undecided about their proper line of development. Some have withdrawn altogether, and packed away their easels and chisels. This problem is not confined to the visual artists: musicians and playwrights are equally affected. The academic artist can hardly survive on a free-lance basis because the demand for his works is so limited. There are few openings for him in the civil service or in commercial firms. Some are therefore forced to take up teaching jobs in small towns and villages, doing their art work only in their spare time. For lack of facilities, publicity and patronage, such artists are usually less favoured than their counterparts in the cities. Even in some big towns the acquiring of art materials can present difficulties. But in the small towns and villages, the artist receives little or no public attention, as the press is mainly concerned with the cities. His work is rarely seen on television. Anything he sells, he has to sell cheap. The local people will have little appreciation of 'modern' or academic works. He therefore can only hope for the occasional visits of foreign collectors. Even in his school, the village artist is usually isolated. The school head and other teachers attach less importance to his subject and anything he may produce. He is misunderstood, especially if he puts himself forward as an artist; and this hostile environment can hardly be called encouraging. Writers have a special problem—that of language. English has become the official language and the accepted language in which to communicate ideas. But Nigeria has over ten languages and some 200 dialects. To the playwright or poet, this language problem raises obstacles of communication. In any local language his writing may fail to attract the attention of 59 The transmission of culture foreign publishers, for whom a first condition is a language they can understand, and for which type-faces are available. The writer therefore has either to write in English or take a chance on finding a local publisher. As local publishing, and hence, locally published books tend to be more expensive, the local reader tends to prefer cheaper foreign books. When the writer uses English, he is naturally handicapped by having to translate local concepts and ideas into a foreign idiom. But if he does get published, he will also be widely publicized and reviewed by local critics, and may quickly go on to national fame. Outstanding writers in local languages will thus be less known than mediocre writers who use the English language, because circulation is usually limited to the areas in which the language used is understood. Musicians face a similar kind of problem. Their academic training is based on foreign instruments, and few will have explored the possibility of local instruments which, in any case, are not suited for use in compositions intended, more often than not, for a foreign audience. Nigerian musicians who have achieved international fame are little known or appreciated at home where, again, their admirers are limited to trained connoisseurs. These are problems facing artists and writers in Nigeria. Some can be solved only by the artists themselves, others through a new kind of cultural education that will link artists better with their environment and traditions. 60 The future Nigeria has had no specific written government cultural policy since it attained independence. The colonial government did not bother to formulate a policy. Towards the end of the colonial period, Nigerian politicians who were in control of the administrative and financial machinery concentrated all their efforts and attention on political and economic programmes. This is understandable in a newly independent country still struggling against the strains of poverty and underdevelopment. Indifference was also caused by the erroneous belief that, culture being interwoven with Nigerian social life, it needed no special development measures. However, with more political and economic stability, the government and people are increasingly aware that culture is the essence of civilization and the federal and state governments are getting more and more involved not only in promotion but also in cultural education and in preserving the national heritage. The federal government inherited and continued the colonial administration policy on antiquities. Annual subventions are made to museums all over the country, and arrangements to develop them and to build a national theatre are well in hand. There have been growing demands by artists, writers, educationists and men of culture in different walks of life for a government policy on culture, and the creation of a unified ministry or department of culture as opposed to the present system of leaving cultural matters to a series of different ministries. Officials dealing with art and culture have also been trying to co-ordinate their efforts and have unanimously recommended the creation of a federal government cultural council as a prelude to the creation of a department of culture. Six senior officials in different ministries could provide the nucleus of such a department: (a) the Federal Cultural Adviser in the Ministry of Information; (b) the Federal Art Adviser in the Ministry of Education; (c) the Director of Museums (Ministry of Education); (d) the Controller of 61 The future Archives (Ministry of Education); (e) the Head of the Cultural Division, Ministry of External Affairs; (f) the officer in charge of trade affairs in the Ministry of Trade and Industry. They could be brought together under the Federal Cultural Adviser and, with some administrative assistance, could form a Ministry of Culture. Cultural education, promotion and preservation could then be directed centrally and organized more effectively. After due consultations the officials could formulate a cultural policy for submission to the government. In formulating a national cultural policy, however, the complex geographical, social and cultural patterns of the country must be taken into consideration. A national policy should avoid the over-centralization of programmes. The present constitutional position in regard to culture is satisfactory. The state governments and the local authorities should be consulted, to ensure that the federal cultural policy adopted makes sense also to people in towns and villages and is not made only for a privileged and already cultured elite in the cities. It must respect cherished customs and traditions, and aim at enhancing life for everyone, irrespective of their sex, age, or religion. Admitting this need for participation, there is at the same time a great need for a central policy-making and co-ordinating body. It could help to forge a common national identity and cultural image; promote inter-State cultural co-operation and understanding; plan national festivals and other programmes that enhance national cultural awareness; and arrange Nigerian participation in international festivals and other cultural activities. Many people believe that the present Nigerian Arts Council should be reconstituted and given the same terms of reference in regard to cultural matters as the Nigerian Sports Council has in sport, i.e. that of a subsidized and semi-autonomous agency acting for the government but with a minimum of State interference. The council is at present greatly handicapped by the smalbiess of its subvention, the delay in actually getting it and a lack of recognized authority. The federal government is expected to take a definite step towards defining both a national and an international cultural policy. Cultural plans should be integrated with political and economic programmes in the fouryear development programmes. This would, inter alia, avoid the confusion that often arises at the time of international festivals. The above are some of the proposals that are in the air. The government has taken no decision on them yet. However, commissioners and governors have publicly stressed the need for a ministry of culture or similarly national body. The present mood of national reconstruction and reconciliation offers a good opportunity for government-concerted cultural development. In a multi-tribal society such as exists in Nigeria, cultural programmes could be very effective in bringing about mutual understanding and national unity, as cultural programmes and exchanges do foster a better understanding and 62 The future appreciation of other people's way of life. The more people know of one another, the less grounds do they have for irrational suspicions. A country is not judged by its political and economic development alone—its arts, literature, and music also count. Nigeria has rich cultural potentialities which, if developed and properly organized, should enhance her role in Africa. Countries relatively less favoured have been concerned for their arts, and earned world-wide attention. The performances of Nigeria in international festivals still leaves a lot to be desired; and improvement implies better organization. Only through a coherent government policy can Nigeria's cultural potentialities be fully developed. 63 S.$2;60p(stg.);8F is taxes, if applicable IN 92-3-101029-8