The image quality of the Southern African Large Telescope (SALT)

The image quality of the Southern African Large Telescope (SALT)

!
!"#$%&' )*+&,
!"#$%&'(#$)*'+%,-$./$,"#$0.*,"#12$3/1%4'2$5'1(#$!#+#64.7#$8035!9$
!
"#$$#%&!'(!)*"+,+%&-.#/!'01!23#45'33.4%-16/!7-18!9#0+,##/!9$-:.!;(!91%.0+<:/!=+&,!2(!9++3&4/!
7-:1#,!9+3&##/!=#,-8!"(!9$1,>#/!"#?14!2(!@(9-:>0.A#/!B&10!;&#$0.8#/!20$1,!;&$1831#,8#/!=(!
;&$183+C&.$!;0.D.,8./!718#!2(!;$#-8.#/!E3.?.,!F(!;$#<G+$4#/!H.+GG$.A!B(!'?#,8#/!@13.8&!H#II#$#/!
J#8!@#8&1D+3+#/!F#0:+0D!@.,4$1:>8#/!20.K.1!L,1#M.?#/!2,3&+,A!N(!L+.80#%#/!O1001.!B(!L++$38#/!
@.$D#,!=(!L$1.0#/!P1:+0#!E(!7+#$1,%#/!=+,#3&#,!7+?.#/!Q$.4!F#$#,%#/!"+-%0#8!F.3:#0G.#/!9$.,,#,!
F.A.$#/!=#D.8!)*;+,,+$#/!;&#$0!2(!4-!B0.8818#/!7#<$.,:.!O(!N#D8.AG/!',:#$,1!N+D.$+5
;+0D.,.$+#/!;$#1%!E#88#/!=+&#,,!;(!E:&+03M#/!N#D+3&+0+!E.G#>+#/!E#,418#!E1A.,%+#/!F#$31,!E3100#/!
):>.$3!=(!E3$A4+D#/!2$>#41-8M!E<#3%/!=+&#,,!Q(!"-!R+13&/!B.3$1!S#18#,.,#/!F#$3A,!O.0086/!@#,,#&!
O+$3.$8#/I!!
#
E+-3&!2G$1:#,!283$+,+D1:#0!)68.$?#3+$A/!B)!9+K!T/!)68.$?#3+$A!UTVW/!;#C.!R+<,/!E+-3&!2G$1:#/!
6
XL!283$+,+D1:#0!R.:&,+0+%A!;.,3$./!R&.!N+A#0!)68.$?#3+$A!'41,6-$%&/!90#:>G+$4!@100/!
'41,6-$%&!'@T!V@=/!X,13.4!L1,%4+D/!
:
".C3(!+G!B&A81:8/!X,1?.$813A!+G!F1:&1%#,/!YWZ!;&-$:&!E3$..3/!2,,!2$6+$/!F1:&1%#,!Y[\ZT/!XE2/!
4
F:"+,#04!)68.$?#3+$A/!X,1?.$813A!+G!R.K#8!#3!2-831,/!N7F!9-1041,%/!2-831,/!R]!U[U\^/!XE2/!
.
".C3!+G!B&A81:8!#,4!283$+,+DA/!X,1?.$813A!+G!P+$3&!;#$+01,#/!;&#C.0!@100/!P;!^UWTT/!XE2/!
G
".C3!+G!283$+,+DA!#,4!283$+C&A81:8/!B.,,8A0?#,1#!E3#3.!X,1?.$813A/!W^W!"#?.A!7#6+$#3+$A/!
X,1?.$813A!B#$>/!B2!\_[Z^/!XE2/!
%
'-$+C.#,!E+-3&.$,!)68.$?#3+$A/!L#$05E:&<#$M8:&1045E3$#88.!^/!H#$:&1,%/!"5[WUY[/!H.$D#,A/!
&
E-,EC#:./!B)!9+K!V\[V/!F#31.0#,4!U_Z^/!E+-3&!2G$1:#/!
I
;.,3$.!G+$!283$+C&A81:8/!X,1?.$813A!+G!;.,3$#0!7#,:#8&1$./!B$.83+,/!BN\!^@'/!X,13.4!L1,%4+D(!
3:0!;3<!$
;+,83$-:31+,!+G!3&.!E+-3&.$,!2G$1:#,!7#$%.!R.0.8:+C.!`E27Ra!<#8!0#$%.0A!:+DC0.3.4!6A!3&.!.,4!+G!^ZZW!#,4!81,:.!3&.,!
13! &#8! 6..,! 1,!1,3.,81?.! :+DD1881+,1,%(! R&18! &#8! ,+<! #0D+83! 6..,! :+DC0.3.4! .K:.C3! G+$! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.*8! 1D#%.! b-#013A!
<&1:&!8&+<8!+C31:#0!#6.$$#31+,8/!:&1.G0A!#!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!#:$+88!3&.!G+:#0!C0#,./!#0+,%!<13&!#831%D#318D!#,4!+3&.$!0.88!
81%,1G1:#,3!#6.$$#31+,8(!R&18!C#C.$!4.8:$16.8!3&.!+C31:#0!8A83.D8!.,%1,..$1,%!1,?.831%#31+,!3&#3!&#8!6..,!:+,4-:3.4!81,:.!
.#$0A! ^ZZ_! 3+! 41#%,+8.! 3&.! C$+60.D(! 2! $1%+$+-8! #CC$+#:&! &#8! 6..,! G+00+<.4! <&1:&! &#8! .,3#10.4! 6$.#>1,%! 4+<,! 3&.!
8A83.D!1,3+!3&.!D#I+$!8-658A83.D8!#,4!8-6I.:31,%!3&.D!3+!3.831,%!+,!#,!1,41?14-#0!6#818(!E1%,1G1:#,3!C$+%$.88!&#8!6..,!
#:&1.?.4!<13&!D#,A!:+DC+,.,38!+G!3&.!+C31:#0!8A83.D!8&+<,!3+!6.!+C.$#31,%!:+$$.:30A(!R&.!G#-03!&#8!6..,!18+0#3.4!3+!#!
D#I+$!+C31:#0!8-658A83.D(!O.!C$.8.,3!3&.!$.8-038!+63#1,.4!8+!G#$/!#,4!418:-88!<&#3!$.D#1,8!3+!6.!4+,.(!
=#->.1?6@! E+-3&.$,! 2G$1:#,! 7#$%.! R.0.8:+C./! E27R/! 1D#%.! b-#013A/! 8C&.$1:#0! #6.$$#31+,! :+$$.:3+$/! E2;/! +C31:#0!
#6.$$#31+,8/!#831%D#318D/!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!
!
AB! CD!;EFG<!CED$
R&.! E+-3&.$,! 2G$1:#,! 7#$%.! R.0.8:+C.! `E27Ra! `&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#a! 18! #! \Z5D! :0#88! 3.0.8:+C.! <13&! #! G1K.45#0313-4.!
4.81%,! 81D10#$! 3+! 3&#3! +G! 3&.! @+66A5'6.$0A! R.0.8:+C.! `@'Ra! #3! F:"+,#04! )68.$?#3+$A! 1,! O.83! R.K#8(! ;+,83$-:3.4!
4-$1,%! 3&.! C.$1+4! ^ZZZ5^ZZW/! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.! #,4! 138! 1,83$-D.,3#31+,! &#?.! 6..,! <.00! 4+:-D.,3.4\5T! 1,! 3&18! :+,G.$.,:.!
8.$1.8!#,4!.08.<&.$.(!`F#,A!#44131+,#0!C#C.$8!G+:-81,%!+,!8C.:1G1:!8-658A83.D8!#$.!#08+!#?#10#60.!#,4!.#810A!G+-,4!-81,%!
#,! 2"E! 8.#$:&! +,! eE27Rf! +$! eE+-3&.$,! 2G$1:#,! 7#$%.! R.0.8:+C.ga(! "-$1,%! ^ZZW/! 3&.! G1$83! 8:1.,:.! +68.$?#31+,8! <.$.!
:+,4-:3.4\Z! #,4! 81,:.! 3&.,! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.! &#8! 6..,! C#$31#00A! 1,! 8:1.,:.! +C.$#31+,8! #,4! C#$31#00A! 1,! :+DD1881+,1,%(! R&.!
0.,%3&A!:+DD1881+,1,%!&#8!#$18.,!4-.!3+!3<+!D#I+$!G#:3+$8c!`1a!3&$+-%&C-3!1,.GG1:1.,:A!1,!3&.!<+$>&+$8.!G1$83!%.,.$#31+,!
h,83$-D.,3/!3&.!N+6.$3!E3+61.!EC.:3$+%$#C&!`NEEa/!#!0+<5D.41-D!$.8+0-31+,!XSd+C31:#0!8C.:3$+%$#C&!`C$.?1+-80A!>,+<,!!
-'#*".&' /+%$.*0 *"' 1&.2*"$.*0 3&.2"4045$&6 $" 3&0&6.4+&6 *"' !"6%,78&"%*%$4"9 &'$%&' :; <0$ -%*'=<%%&'57$9
>$&%,$.2 ?&8@&9 ),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH9 EFGHGI9 JKFFHL M FKEE=EHNOPFHPQGH M '4$R GFAGGGEPGKAEHHHSG
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=G
!
R
'I
a
!
!
Q1%(!\(!9#81:!0#A+-3!+G!E27R(!R&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!:+DC$18.8!T\!&.K#%+,#0!8.%D.,38/!\!D!1,!81M.(!R&.!C$1D#$A!18!8-CC+$3.4!
+,!#!83..0!3$-88!D+-,3.4!1,!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!83$-:3-$.!<&1:&!18!31CC.4!+?.$!#3!#,!#,%0.!+G!VU+!3+!3&.!?.$31:#0(!23!3&.!3+C!+G!
3&.!3.0.8:+C.!18!#!eR$#:>.$g!<&+8.!D+?.D.,3!:#C#61013A!.,#60.8!:.0.831#0!3#$%.38!3+!6.!G+00+<.4!G+$!#3!0.#83!\!&$/!#,4!-C!
3+!V!&$!#3!3&.!D+83!8+-3&.$0A!4.:01,#31+,8(!
!
Segmented
primary
mirror
!
Q1%(!^(!)C31:#0!0#A+-3!+G!E27R(!23!$1%&3!18!8&+<,!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!#,4!3+C!.,4!+C31:8!#,4!1,83$-D.,38!<&1:&!#$.!D+-,3.4!
+,!3&.!R$#:>.$!`8..!Q1%(!\a(!23!0.G3!18!#!0#$%.$!8:#0.!?1.<!+G!3&.!3+C!.,4!+C31:8!#,4!1,83$-D.,38!8&+<1,%c!3&.!Y5D1$$+$!
8C&.$1:#0!#6.$$#31+,!:+$$.:3+$!`E2;ai!3&.!E#031:#D!#:b-18131+,!:#D.$#!#,4!81DC0.!8:1.,:.!1D#%.$!G.4!6A!#!G+04!D1$$+$i!
3&.! j83$#1%&353&$+-%&f! G+:-8! G..41,%! 3&.! 8013! C0#,.! +G! 3&.! N+6.$3! E3+61.! EC.:3$+%$#C&! `NEEa(! h,! 6+3&! C#$38! +G! 3&.!
41#%$#D/!8+D.!+,5#K18!$#A8!#$.!3$#:.4!3&$+-%&!3&.!8A83.D!G+$!3&.!C-$C+8.8!+G!100-83$#31+,(!
!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=K
!
i/ '4'kc
!
Q1%(!V(!B&A81:#0!0#A+-3!+G!3&.!E27R!3+C!.,4(!L.A!8-65#88.D601.8!#$.!.KC01:130A!0#6.0.4(!E..!3.K3!G+$!4.8:$1C31+,(!
!
#8! 3&.! B$1D.! Q+:-8! hD#%1,%! EC.:3$+%$#C&! `BQhEaai! #,4! `11a! C$+60.D8! <13&! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.g8! 1D#%.! b-#013A(! R&18! C#C.$!
4.8:$16.8!3&.!,#3-$.!+G!3&.!1D#%.!b-#013A!C$+60.D8/!$.C+$38!#,!.K3.,81?.!1,?.831%#31+,!1,3+!3&.!:#-8.8/!8&+<8!3&.!C$+%$.88!
3+! 4#3./! #,4! 418:-88.8! <&#3! $.D#1,8! 3+! 6.! 4+,.(! 2! ?.$A! 4.3#10.4! #::+-,3! +G! .?.$A! 83.C! +G! 3&.! 1,?.831%#31+,! #CC.#$8! #3!
&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad(!
!
HB! !IJ$FJ0CKD$EL$035!$
HBA! !"#$:'6%4$035!$<.24#7,$
R&.!6#81:!:+,:.C3!+G!E27R\/!.88.,31#00A!14.,31:#0!3+!3&#3!+G!3&.!@+66A5'6.$0A!R.0.8:+C./!18!8&+<,!1,!Q1%(!\c!#!8C&.$1:#0!
C$1D#$A! D1$$+$/! :+DC$181,%! T\! &.K#%+,#0! 8C&.$1:#0! 8.%D.,38/! 18! 8-CC+$3.4! 6A! #! 83..0! 3$-88! D+-,3.4! 1,! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.!
83$-:3-$.(!R&.!3.0.8:+C.!83$-:3-$.!18!#60.!3+!$+3#3.!3&$+-%&!V_Z+!1,!#M1D-3&/!6-3!3&.!#0313-4.!+G!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!18!G1K.4!#3!VU+!
G$+D!3&.!M.,13&(!hG!E27R!<.$.!-,#60.!3+!3$#:>/!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!<+-04!3&.$.G+$.!+,0A!6.!#60.!3+!#::.88!:.0.831#0!3#$%.38!<&.,!
3&.1$! M.,13&! 4183#,:.! <#8! .K#:30A! VU+(! h,4..4/! 4-$1,%! +68.$?#31+,/! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.! 83$-:3-$.! #,4! C$1D#$A! D1$$+$! #$.!
83#31+,#$A(! @+<.?.$/! #3! 3&.! 3+C! .,4! +G! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C./! 1,:+DC0.3.0A! 8&+<,! #8! eR$#:>.$! 2,4! B#A0+#4g! 1,! Q1%(! \/! 18! #!
83$-:3-$.!<&1:&!18!:#C#60.!+G!D+?1,%!4-$1,%!+68.$?#31+,8!<13&!$.8C.:3!3+!3&.!#K18!+G!8ADD.3$A!+G!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!1,!
81K! 4.%$..8! +G! G$..4+Dc! K5A! 4.:.,3$./! 31C/! 3103/! C183+,! #,4! $+3#31+,(! R&18! 83$-:3-$./! :#00.4! 3&.! eR$#:>.$g/! .,#60.8! 3&.!
3.0.8:+C.! 3+! G+00+<! :.0.831#0! 3#$%.38! +?.$! #! M.,13&! 4183#,:.! $#,%.! G$+D! V\+! 3+! YV+/! G..41,%! 83#$01%&3! 3+! 3&.! 1,83$-D.,3!
C#A0+#4(!R&18!$#,%.!+G!M.,13&!4183#,:.!:+$$.8C+,48!3+!#!3$#:>!31D.!+G!#3!0.#83!\!&$/!#,4!-C!3+!V!&$!#3!3&.!D+83!8+-3&.$0A!
4.:01,#31+,8(!R&.!8#D.!%.+D.3$1:#0!:+,83$#1,38/!#0+,%!<13&!3&.!5V\+!0#313-4.!+G!E27R/!$.8-038!1,!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!6.1,%!#60.!
3+!#::.88!3#$%.38!<13&!4.:01,#31+,8!+,0A!1,!3&.!$#,%.!k\Z+!3+!5U^+(!
HBH! !"#$035!$E7,%4'+$F#6%(2$
28!D.,31+,.4!#0$.#4A/!4-$1,%!+68.$?#31+,!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!18!83#31+,#$A!#,4!3&.!R$#:>.$!G+00+<8!:.0.831#0!3#$%.38!+?.$!
3&.!8C&.$1:#0!G+:#0!8-$G#:.!+G!3&.!3.0.8:+C.(!R&18!3.:&,1b-.!$.b-1$.8!#!8C&.$1:#0!C$1D#$A!<&1:&!1,!3-$,!4$1?.8!3&.!+C31:#0!
4.81%,!+G!E27RY(!2!Y5D1$$+$!8C&.$1:#0!#6.$$#31+,!:+$$.:3+$^!`E2;a!:+$$.:38!3&.!&-%.!8C&.$1:#0!#6.$$#31+,!#$181,%!G$+D!#,!!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=I
!
!#+#64.7#$/.4*6$
!.7$+#/,$
5.>#1$1%(",$
M'(2%/%#?$,.7$+#/,$
M'(2%/%#?$+.>#1$1%(",$
NOBP$
!
NOBQ$
!
NOBH$
!
OBO$
!
OBH$
!
OBQ$
!
OBP$
!
Q1%(!Y(!E-651D#%.8!+G!#!j3&$+-%&5G+:-8f!8.b-.,:.!100-83$#31,%!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3(!E..!3.K3!G+$!D+$.!.KC0#,#31+,(!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=S
!
Gd\(Y!8C&.$1:#0!D1$$+$/!\\!D!1,!41#D.3.$(!R&.!G+-$!D1$$+$8/!$#,%1,%!1,!41#D.3.$!G$+D!\ZZ!DD!3+!_ZZ!DD/!#$.!#00!#8C&.$1:!
<13&!3&$..!6.1,%!:+,1:!#8C&.$.8/!#,4!3&.!G+-$3&/!FV/!6.1,%!#!%.,.$#0!#8C&.$.!<13&!\(W!DD!+G!#8C&.$1:!4.C#$3-$.(!Q1%(!^!
8&+<8!3&.!E2;!0#A+-3/!<13&!0#6.01,%!+G!3&.!E2;!D1$$+$8!F^5W/!#,4!8:1.,:.!1,83$-D.,38!NEE!#,4!E#031:#DT/\\(!
HBR! 035!$!.7$J2?$5'-.*,$
h,!+$4.$!3+!#CC$.:1#3.!G-00A!3&.!1D#%.!b-#013A!1,?.831%#31+,!$.C+$3.4!1,!3&18!C#C.$/!13!18!,.:.88#$A!3+!>,+<!3&.!4.3#108!+G!3&.!
3+C!.,4!+G!3&.!3.0.8:+C.(!R&.8.!#$.!8&+<,!1,!3&.!C&+3+%$#C&!1,!Q1%(!V(!!
28! D.,31+,.4! 1,! E.:31+,! ^(\/! 3&.! R$#:>.$! G+00+<8! :.0.831#0! 3#$%.38! -81,%! D+31+,8! 1,! _! 4.%$..8! +G! G$..4+Dc! 3&.! K!
3$#,80#31+,!18!#:&1.?.4!6A!3&.!.,31$.!R$#:>.$!e6$14%.g!D+?1,%!+?.$!3&.!3+C!.,4!+G!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!83$-:3-$.i!3&.!A!D+31+,!18!
#:&1.?.4!6A!3&.!eA5:#$$1#%.g!D+?1,%!-C!#,4!4+<,!3&.!R$#:>.$!6$14%.i!31C/!3103!#,4!C183+,!#$.!#:&1.?.4!6A!D+-,31,%!3&.!
C#A0+#4!+,!_!&.K#C+4!0.%8!<&+8.!0.,%3&8!:#,!6.!:+,3$+00.4i!$+3#31+,!+G!3&.!1,83$-D.,3!C#:>#%.!18!#:&1.?.4!-81,%!3&.!$&+!
83#%.!`0#6.0.4!1,!Q1%(!Va(!
R&.! E2;! 18! D+-,3.4! #3! 3&.! 6+33+D! +G! #! 83$-:3-$.! D#4.! -C! +G! :#$6+,! G16.$! C#,.08! :#00.4! 3&.! P+,5N+3#31,%! E3$-:3-$./!
0#6.0.4!PNE!1,!Q1%(!V(!R&.!PNE!18!#33#:&.4!#3!V!C+1,38!3+!#!$1,%!#3!3&.!3+C!+G!3&.!&.K#C+4!0.%8(!28!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!D+-,3!18!
.88.,31#00A!+G!3&.!#035#M!>1,4/!G1.04!$+3#31+,!4-$1,%!.KC+8-$.!18!$.b-1$.4/!8+!3&.!$&+!83#%.!C$+?14.8!3&18!G#:1013A!G+$!NEE!
D+-,3.4!#3!3&.!3+C/!#8!<.00!#8!3&.!:+,3.,38!+G!3&.!8+5:#00.4!N+3#31,%!E3$-:3-$.!`NEa(!R&.!NE!18!#08+!D#4.!-C!+G!:#$6+,!
G16.$!C#,.08!#,4!&#,%8!4+<,!G$+D!3&.!$&+!83#%.!1,814.!3&.!PNE(!h3!18!0#6.0.4!NE!1,!Q1%(!V!#,4!:#,!6.!%01DC8.4!3&$+-%&!#,!
+C.,!&#3:&!4++$!1,!3&.!PNE(!E#031:#D!18!0+:#3.4!1,!3&.!NE(!
!
RB! !IJ$CM3KJ$SG35C!T$U;E:5JM$
RBA! 0-&7,.&6$./$,"#$71.V+#&@$/.4*6$(1'?%#2,W$'6,%(&',%6&$'2?$X'1%'V%+%,-$
Q1%(! Y! 8&+<8! 8+D.! +G! 3&.! 8ADC3+D8! +G! 3&.! 1D#%.! b-#013A! C$+60.D(! '#:&! $+<! +G! 1D#%.8! 1,! Q1%(! Y! :+$$.8C+,48! 3+! #!
41GG.$.,3!$.0#31?.!G+:-8!C+8131+,!#8!1,41:#3.4!#3!3&.!0.G3(!R&.!0.G3D+83!:+0-D,!1,!Q1%(!Y!8&+<8!3&.!-CC.$!0.G3!b-#$3.$!+G!#!
E#031:#D! 1D#%.! `+G! #,! #$613$#$A! C+1,31,%! +G! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.a(!R&.! :+0-D,! 1DD.41#3.0A! 3+! 138! $1%&3! 8&+<8! 3&.! 0+<.$! $1%&3!
b-#$3.$! +G! 3&.! 8#D.! 1D#%.(! R&.! $1%&3D+83! 3<+! :+0-D,8! 8&+<! 8-651D#%.8! +G! 3&.! 0.G3D+83! 3<+! :+0-D,8! #3! 0#$%.$!
D#%,1G1:#31+,(!
R&.!8.b-.,:.!+G!j3&$+-%&5G+:-8f!1D#%.8!8&+<8!#!41GG.$.,31#0!G+:-8!#:$+88!3&.!G1.04c!1,!3&.!3+C!$+<!6+3&!-CC.$!0.G3!#,4!
0+<.$! $1%&3! #$.! +-3! +G! G+:-8/! <13&! 3&.! 0#33.$! D+$.! +-35+G5G+:-8! 3&#,! 3&.! G+$D.$(! 28! 3&.! $.0#31?.! G+:-8! 6.:+D.8! D+$.!
C+8131?./!3&.!-CC.$!0.G3!:+D.8!3+!G+:-8!G1$83/!6.:+D1,%!+C31D#0!#3!#!$.0#31?.!G+:-8!C+8131+,!+G!#6+-3!5Z(^(!23!3&18!C+8131+,/!
&+<.?.$/!3&.!0+<.$!$1%&3!&#8!83100!,+3!:+D.!3+!6.83!G+:-8(!R&.!0+<.$!$1%&3!18!+C31D#0!#3!#!$.0#31?.!G+:-8!+G!#6+-3!kZ(^/!#3!
<&1:&!C+1,3!3&.!G+:-8!+G!3&.!-CC.$!0.G3!&#8!C#88.4!+C31D#0!#,4!18!<+$8.,1,%(!23!#!$.0#31?.!G+:-8!C+8131+,!+G!kZ(_/!6+3&!
-CC.$!0.G3!#,4!0+<.$!$1%&3!#$.!+-3!+G!G+:-8/!6-3!3&18!31D.!<13&!3&.!-CC.$!0.G3!D+$.!+-35+G5G+:-8!3&#,!3&.!0+<.$!$1%&3(!R&.!
#6+?.!6.&#?1+-$!:#,!D+83!.#810A!6.!-,4.$83++4!#8!#!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!+?.$!3&.!G1.04(!R&.!D#%,13-4.!+G!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!18!
D+83! .#810A! .KC$.88.4! #8! 3&.! 3103! +G! 3&.! NEE! .,3$#,:.! 8013! C0#,.! `Q1%(! ^a! $.b-1$.4! 3+! 6$1,%! #00! C+1,3! 8+-$:.! 1D#%.8! 1,3+!
81D-03#,.+-8!6.83!G+:-8(!R&18!3103!<#8!G+-,4!3+!6.!#6+-3!^(W+(!
h,! #44131+,! 3+! #! G+:-8! %$#41.,3/! 3&.$.! 18! #08+! #831%D#318D(! 2! :#$.G-0! 1,8C.:31+,! +G! 3&.! D#%,1G1.4! 1D#%.8! 1,! 3&.! 8.:+,4!
:+0-D,!G$+D!3&.!$1%&3!1,!Q1%(!Y!`G$+D!3&.!-CC.$!0.G3!:+$,.$!+G!3&.!+$1%1,#0!1D#%.a!8&+<8!3&#3!+,!3&.!D+$.!,.%#31?.!814.!+G!
6.83! G+:-8! 3&.! 83.00#$! 1D#%.8! #$.! .0+,%#3.4! 0+<.$! 0.G3! 3+! -CC.$! $1%&3/! #,4! +,! 3&.! D+$.! C+8131?.! 814.! 3&.! 1D#%.8! #$.!
.0+,%#3.4!-CC.$!0.G3!3+!0+<.$!$1%&3(!E-:&!6.&#?1+-$!18!3AC1:#0!+G!#831%D#318D(!2831%D#31:!.0+,%#31+,!+G!83.00#$!1D#%.8!18!#!
?.$A!:+DD+,!C$+C.$3A!+G!E27Rg8!1D#%.8(!
h,!#44131+,!3+!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!#,4!#831%D#318D/!3&.!1D#%.!b-#013A!&#8!#08+!6..,!G+-,4!3+!6.!?#$1#60.c!R&.!81M.!+G!3&.!G+:-8!
%$#41.,3!?#$1.8/!#,4!3&.!#831%D#31:!.0+,%#31+,!+G!C+1,3!8+-$:.!1D#%.8!#08+!?#$1.8(!R&.!?#$1#31+,!+G!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!18!
#6+-3!Z(W+!#6+-3!3&.!D.#,!+G!^(W+i!3&.$.!18!#08+!#!?#$1#31+,!+G!3&.!C+8131+,!#,%0.!+G!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!+G!#6+-3!YW+(!
)3&.$! .K#DC0.8! +G! 3&.! :+DC0.K13A! +G! 3&.! C$+60.D/! 1,:0-41,%! 1D#%.8! +G! 3&.! %0+6-0#$! :0-83.$! YU! R-:/! :#,! 6.! G+-,4! #3c!
&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad1D#%.5b-#013A5C$+60.D54.8:$1C31+,d!
#,4!
&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad.KC0+$1,%53&.5G+:-8541D.,81+,5?#$1#61013Ad!
#,4!
&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad+4450++>1,%583#$8d!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=T
!
!
Q1%(!W(!E27R!k!8:1.,:.!1,83$-D.,3!1D#%.8(!),!3&.!0.G3!18!3&.!E#031:#D!1D#%./!+,!3&.!$1%&3!18!3&.!NEE!1D#%.!+G!3&.!8#D.!G1.04/!
+63#1,.4!eb-#81581D-03#,.+-80Ag!`8..!3.K3!G+$!4.G1,131+,!+G!3&18!3.$Da(!
!
QB! LC;0!$0!JU0$CD$FC3KDE0C0$
P+!+,58>A!1D#%.!+G!3&.!G-00![5#$:D1,!8:1.,:.!G1.04!+G!?1.<!&#4!6..,!+63#1,.4!#,4!,+!8A83.D50.?.0!3.831,%!+G!3&.!+C31:#0!
C.$G+$D#,:.! +G! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.! &#4! 6..,! :#$$1.4! +-3! -,310! 3&.! 0#83! &#0G! +G! ^ZZW(! B$1+$! 3+! 3&#3! 31D./! C$.01D1,#$A! +,5#K18!
1D#%1,%! &#4! 8&+<,! $.#8+,#60.! 1D#%.! b-#013A/! 8+! 13! <#8! #! 8-$C$18.! <&.,! G-005G1.04! 1D#%1,%! +63#1,.4! 1,! ^ZZW! 2-%-83!
1DD.41#3.0A! 8&+<.4! #! G+:-8! %$#41.,3! +?.$! 3&.! G1.04! #8! <.00! #8! +3&.$! %.+D.3$1:#0! #6.$$#31+,8(! R&.8.! C$+60.D8! <.$.!
1,131#00A!1,3.$C$.3.4!#8!D.:&#,1:#0!D18#01%,D.,38!+G!3&.!G+:#0!C0#,.!#,4!3<+!3.0.8:+C.!+C31:#0!$.5#01%,D.,38!<.$.!:#$$1.4!
+-3!1,!^ZZW!E.C!#,4!):3/!6-3!<13&+-3!#,A!1DC$+?.D.,3!3+!3&.!C$+60.D(!2!G-0058:#0.!1,?.831%#31+,!<#8!0#-,:&.4!#3!3&.!
83#$3!+G!^ZZ_(!R$#:>1,%!4+<,!3&.!:#-8.!+G!3&.!C$+60.D!#,4!G1K1,%!13!&#8!6..,!E27Rg8!3+C!C$1+$13A!.?.$!81,:.(!!
QBA! !"#$%22.4#24#$./$,"#$%26,1*&#2,6$
Q+$! 3&.! G1$83! A.#$! +G! 3&.! 1,?.831%#31+,/! 3&.! +,0A! :#C#61013A! G+$! 1D#%1,%! #3! 3&.! 418C+8#0! +G! E27R! <.$.! 3&.! 3<+! 8:1.,:.!
1,83$-D.,38! NEE! #,4! E#031:#DT/\\! `3&.! 0#33.$! 4+-601,%! #8! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.g8! G1.04! #:b-18131+,! :#D.$#a(! E#031:#D! &#8! $.5
1D#%1,%! 0.,8.8\\! #,4! NEE! &#8! #! j83$#1%&3! 3&$+-%&f! 1D#%1,%! D+4.! -81,%! #! :0#881:! $.G$#:31?.! :+001D#3+$! #,4! :#D.$#(!
203&+-%&!3&.!1D#%.!b-#013A!+G!6+3&!1,83$-D.,38!<#8!3.83.4!+GG!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!C$1+$!3+!1,83#00#31+,/!3&.1$!#44131+,#0!0.,8.8!
D1%&3! 0.#4! 3+! 3&.! 8-8C1:1+,! 3&#3! E27Rg8! 1D#%.! b-#013A! `hla! C$+60.D8! #$18.! G$+D! 3&.D(! R&18/! &+<.?.$/! <#8! b-1:>0A!
C$+?.,!,+3!3+!6.!3&.!:#8.!6.:#-8.c!
!
h3!18!C+88160.!3+!+63#1,!eb-#81581D-03#,.+-8g!1D#%.8!<13&!6+3&!1,83$-D.,38!6A!G01CC1,%!1,!#,4!+-3!3&.!G+04!D1$$+$!!
8&+<,! 1,! Q1%(! ^! <&1:&! G..48! 01%&3! 3+! E#031:#D(! O&.,! 8-:&! 1D#%.8! <.$.! +63#1,.4/! 3&.!same! #6.$$#31+,8! <.$.!
G+-,4!1,!1D#%.8!G$+D!6+3&!1,83$-D.,38/!C$+?1,%!3&#3!,.13&.$!:+-04!1,41?14-#00A!6.!$.8C+,8160.(!2!8D#00!8.:31+,!
+G!#,!#$613$#$A!83#$!G1.04!18!8&+<,!1,!3&.!.K#DC0.!1D#%.8!G$+D!E#031:#D!`0.G3a!#,4!NEE!`$1%&3a!1,!Q1%(!W(!P+3.!3&.!
4+-601,%!+G!#00!83#$!1D#%.8!`3&.!#CC#$.,30A!81,%0.!1D#%.8!&#?.!8#3-$#3.4!0++>-C!3#60.8!8+!3&.1$!4+-601,%!18!,+3!
#CC#$.,3a(!"+-60.4!83#$!1D#%.8!&#?.!:+DD+,0A!6..,!8..,!<13&!E27R/!.8C.:1#00A!+,!+,.!:+$,.$!+G!3&.!8:1.,:.!
G1.04!+G!?1.<(!
!
9+3&!1,83$-D.,38!$+3#3.!<13&!3&.!$&+!83#%.(!R&.!#6.$$#31+,8!#$.!G1.04!4.C.,4.,3/!8+!$+3#31+,!+G!3&.!$&+!83#%.!:#,!
4.D+,83$#3.!<&.3&.$!+$!,+3!3&.!+$1%1,!+G!3&.!#6.$$#31+,8!18!1,!+C31:8!<&1:&!$+3#3.(!hD#%.8!+63#1,.4!#3!41GG.$.,3!
?#0-.8!+G!$&+!8&+<.4!3&.!#6.$$#31+,8!83#A1,%!G1K.4!e+,!8>Ag!#,4!$+3#31,%!+?.$!3&.!4.3.:3+$8!+G!6+3&!1,83$-D.,38(!
R&18!3&.$.G+$.!#08+!C$+?.4!3&#3!3&.!#6.$$#31+,8!#$18.!1,!,+,5$+3#31,%!+C31:8(!
Q-$3&.$!.K#DC0.8!#,4!418:-881+,!+G!3&18!3+C1:!:#,!6.!G+-,4!#3!&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$AdG1$835
D10.83+,.53&.51,,+:.,:.5+G53&.51,83$-D.,38d!
Q$+D!Q1%(!^/!13!18!.?14.,3!3&#3!3&18!0.#?.8!+,0A!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!#,4!E2;!#8!C+3.,31#0!:#-8.8!+G!3&.!hl!C$+60.D8(!
!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=N
!
Alignment
tower
!
Q1%(! _(! E27R! C$1D#$A! D1$$+$! #01%,D.,3! 8:&.D#31:(! 23! 3&.! $1%&3! 18! #! 3&-D6,#10! 8>.3:&! +G! 3&.! E27R! 6-1041,%! #,4! 4+D.!
:+,3#1,1,%!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$/!#8!<.00!#8!3&.!;.,3.$5+G5;-$?#3-$.!201%,D.,3!EA83.D!`;;2Ea!3+<.$(!O13&1,!3&.!;;2E!
3+<.$! 18! #! :0#881:#0! E&#:>5@#$3D#,,! :#D.$#! <&1:&! 100-D1,#3.8! 3&.! 8C&.$1:#0! C$1D#$A! G$+D! #! C+1,3! 8+-$:.! `C1,&+0.a!
0+:#3.4!#3!138!:.,3$.!+G!:-$?#3-$.(!R&.!+C31:#0!0#A+-3!18!8&+<,!1,!3&.!:#$3++,8!#3!3&.!0.G3c!3&.!01%&3!C$+:..48!3&$+-%&!#!
6.#D8C0133.$! 3+! 3&.! C$1D#$A/! #,4! $.3-$,8! ?1#! 3&.! 8#D.! C#3&! 3+! 3&.! -8-#0! :+001D#3+$! 0.,8! #,4! 0.,80.3! #$$#A(! 2! eC.$G.:3g!
$.G.$.,:.!D1$$+$!1,!3&.!+3&.$!#$D!+G!3&.!1,83$-D.,3!`3+C!0.G3a!C$+?14.8!#!$.G.$.,:.!#%#1,83!<&1:&!3&.!C$1D#$A!18!#01%,.4(!
!
YB! <EMU;JIJD0CZJ$!J0!CDK$EL$!IJ$U;CM3;T$MC;;E;$
R&.!1D#%.!b-#013A!?#$1#61013A/!#,4!3&.!4+-601,%!+G!3&.!1D#%.8!.?14.,3!1,!Q1%(!W/!C+1,3!83$+,%0A!3+!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!#8!
3&.! :#-8.! +G! 3&.! hl! C$+60.D8(! R&18! 18! 6.:#-8./! 6.1,%! #! 8.%D.,3.4! 8C&.$1:#0! D1$$+$/! 13! 18! #01%,.4! `4#10Aa! 1,! 3<+! &#0?.8!
-81,%! #! :0#881:#0! E&#:>5@#$3D#,,! :#D.$#! 0+:#3.4! #3! 3&.! :.,3$.! +G! :-$?#3-$.! +G! 3&.! D1$$+$! 1,! 3&.! 8+5:#00.4! ;.,3.$5+G5
;-$?#3-$.!201%,D.,3!EA83.D!`;;2Ea!3+<.$!#0+,%814.!3&.!E27R!6-1041,%/!#3!#!4183#,:.!+G!^_\_W!DD!G$+D!3&.!?.$3.K!+G!
3&.! C$1D#$Ag8! :.,3$#0! 8.%D.,3! `8..! Q1%(! _a(! R&.! hl! ?#$1#61013A! :+-04! 3&-8! #$18.! ,#3-$#00A! G$+D! 3&.! C$1D#$A! #8! 13! 18!
e$.:+,83$-:3.4g!4#10A(!h,!#44131+,/!3&.!E&#:>5@#$3D#,,!1,83$-D.,3!18!,+3!#60.!3+!e8..g!3&.!<&+0.!C$1D#$A!81D-03#,.+-80A!
4-.!3+!?1%,.331,%!6A!3&.!R$#:>.$(!R&.!C$1D#$A!18!3&.$.G+$.!#01%,.4!1,!3<+!&#0?.8c!6A!D+?1,%!3&.!R$#:>.$!3+!3&.!.K3$.D.8!
+G!138!K!3$#?.0/!3&.!E&#:>5@#$3D#,,!:#D.$#!:#,!8..!.#:&!814.!-,?1%,.33.4(!R&.!:.,3$#0!8.%D.,3!18!-8.4!#8!3&.!$.G.$.,:.!3+!
<&1:&! .#:&! 814.! 18! #01%,.4/! #,4! 18! 3&-8! 3&.! 01,>! 6.3<..,! 3&.! 3<+! &#0?.8! +G! 3&.! D1$$+$(! R&18! D+4-8! +C.$#,41/! 1G! ,+3!
<+$>1,%!:+$$.:30A!G+$!8+D.!$.#8+,/!<+-04!,#3-$#00A!%1?.!$18.!3+!4+-601,%!+G!83#$!1D#%.8(!`2:3-#00A!#!:0+8.$!1,8C.:31+,!+G!
3&.!4+-60.4!1D#%.8!8&+<8!3&#3!3&.A!#$.!,+3!eG-00Ag!4+-60.4!<13&!no!01%&3!1,!6.3<..,!3&.!3<+!:+DC+,.,38i!3&.$.!18!8+D.!
01%&3!6$14%1,%!3&.!:+DC+,.,38!6-3!#3!#!8-$G#:.!6$1%&3,.88!8.?.$#0!31D.8!0+<.$!3&#,!1,!.13&.$!:+DC+,.,3a(!
2! :+DC$.&.,81?.! 1,?.831%#31+,! +G! 3&.! C.$G+$D#,:.! +G! 3&.! C$1D#$A! D1$$+$! <#8! 6.%-,(! h,! +$4.$! 3+! #CC$.:1#3.! G-00A! 3&.!
?#$1+-8!#8C.:38!+G!3&.!1,b-1$A/!#!01330.!D+$.!4.3#10!#6+-3!3&.!#01%,D.,3!+G!3&.!C$1D#$A!18!<#$$#,3.4(!R&.!;;2E!3+<.$!18!
0+:#3.4! #3! #M1D-3&! _Z+! 3+! <&1:&! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.! 83$-:3-$.! 18! $+3#3.4! <&.,.?.$! #01%,D.,3! +G! 3&.! C$1D#$A! 18! $.b-1$.4(! R&.!
R$#:>.$!18!D+?.4!3+!+,.!.K3$.D.!+G!138!K!$#,%./!#,4!3&.!E&#:>5@#$3D#,,!1,83$-D.,3!18!3&.,!-8.4!3+!#01%,!3&.!G-00A!?18160.!
&#0G!+G!3&.!D1$$+$/!#G3.$!<&1:&!3&.!+3&.$!&#0G!18!#01%,.4!<13&!3&.!R$#:>.$!#3!3&.!+3&.$!.,4!+G!138!K!$#,%.(!R&.!3.0.8:+C.!18!
3&.,! #?#10#60.! G+$! $.8-D1,%! +,58>A! +68.$?#31+,8(! 203&+-%&! #,! .4%.! 8.,8+$! 8A83.D! 3+! D#1,3#1,! C$1D#$A! #01%,D.,3! <#8!
C0#,,.4!G+$!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!ab initio/!#!G-00A!+C.$#31+,#0!8A83.D!&#8!A.3!3+!6.!:+DD1881+,.4!8+!3&#3!4-$1,%!3&.!.,31$.!hl!
1,?.831%#31+,!$.C+$3.4!&.$./!,+!C$1D#$A!#01%,D.,3!D#1,3.,#,:.!8A83.D!<#8!#?#10#60.(!
YBA! !#6,%2($,"#$71%&'1-$&%11.1$'6$,"#$4'*6#$./$,"#$?.*V+%2($./$6,'1$%&'(#6$
R&.!D+83!+6?1+-8!<#A!G+$!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!3+!:#-8.!3&.!4+-601,%!+G!83#$!1D#%.8!<+-04!1,?+0?.!3&.!1,:+$$.:3!#01%,D.,3!
+G!.#:&!814.!+G!3&.!D1$$+$(!2!81DC0.!.DC1$1:#0!3.83!<#8!4.?18.4!3+!:&.:>!<&.3&.$!+$!,+3!3&18!<#8!+::-$$1,%c!+,.!814.!+G!
3&.!C$1D#$A!<#8!,+3!#01%,.4!#,4!1,83.#4!81DC0A!j3&$+<,!#<#Af!6A!31031,%!138!8.%D.,38!#!0+,%!<#A!G$+D!3&.!#01%,.4/!+3&.$!
&#0G(!O&.,!3&18!<#8!4+,.!13!<#8!#!:+,814.$#60.!8-$C$18./!3&.$.G+$./!3+!G1,4!3&#3!4+-601,%!+G!83#$!1D#%.8!C.$8183.4/!4.8C13.!
3&.! -8.! +G! +,0A! +,.! 814.! +G! 3&.! C$1D#$A(! h3! #08+! D#4.! ,+! 41GG.$.,:.! <&1:&! 814.! +G! 3&.! C$1D#$A! <#8! 6.1,%! -8.4(! F+$.!
1,G+$D#31+,! +,! 3&.8.! 3.838! :#,! 6.! G+-,4! #3c! &33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad3.831,%53&.5C$1D#$A5
D1$$+$51d!!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=E
!
YBH! !#6,%2($,"#$'44*1'4-$./$'+%(2&#2,$./$,"#$71%&'1-$&%11.1$
2,#0A818! <#8! :#$$1.4! +-3! +G! 3&.! C.$G+$D#,:.! +G! 3&.! E&#:>5@#$3D#,,! #01%,D.,3! 1,83$-D.,3! 1,! 3&.! ;;2E! 3+<.$(! F+$.!
8C.:1G1:#00A/!3&.!$.814-#08!<.$.!#,#0AM.4!6.3<..,!3&.!8C+38!G+$D.4!6A!3&.!$.3-$,!+GG!3&.!C$1D#$A!#,4!3&.!8C+38!G+$D.4!6A!
3&.!$.3-$,!+GG!3&.!1,83$-D.,3g8!$.G.$.,:.!D1$$+$!`Q1%(!_a(!R&.8.!$.814-#08!<.$.!3&.,!1,8.$3.4!1,3+!#!m.D#K!D+4.0!+G!3&.!
3.0.8:+C.! 1,:+$C+$#31,%! #! 8.%D.,3.4! $.C$.8.,3#31+,! +G! 3&.! C$1D#$A(! F-031C0.! 8.C#$#3.! 8.38! +G! $.814-#08! G$+D! $.#0!
#01%,D.,3! C$+:.4-$.8! <.$.! -8.4(! R&.! +-3:+D.! <#8! 3&#3! .?.,! 3&.! <+$83! :#8.8! +G! #01%,D.,3! <.$.! G+-,4! 3+! %1?.! 1D#%.!
b-#013A! G#$! 6.33.$! 3&#,! 3&#3! +68.$?.4! <13&! E27R/! #,4! 3&.$.! <#8! ,+! .?14.,:.! G+$! 4+-601,%(! h,4..4/! #03&+-%&! 3&.! G-00!
C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!18!,+3!?18160.!3+!3&.!E&#:>5@#$3D#,,!:#D.$#!#3!#,A!+,.!31D./!#!8-683#,31#0!C#$3!+G!3&.!?1%,.33.4!&#0G!18!
?18160./!#,4!,+!8A83.D#31:!41GG.$.,:.8!6.3<..,!3&.8.!8.%D.,38!#,4!3&.!G-00A!?18160.!&#0G!<.$.!G+-,4(!F+$.!4.3#108!:#,!6.!
G+-,4!#3c!&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad3.831,%53&.5C$1D#$A5D1$$+$511d!
YBR! C2X#6,%(',%2($,"#$'V#11',%.26$./$,"#$71%&'1-$&%11.1$
m.D#K!81D-0#31+,8!<.$.!:#$$1.4!+-3!1,!<&1:&!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$/!$.C$.8.,3.4!#8!#!D+,+013&1:/!C.$G.:30A!#01%,.4!+C31:#0!
.0.D.,3/!&#4!G1$83!+$4.$!:+D#!#,4d+$!#831%D#318D!1DC+8.4!+,!138!G1%-$.!`#88-D.4!3+!#$18.!G$+D!8+D.!-,8C.:1G1.4!:#-8.a(!
R&.!1DC#:3!+G!3&18!.$$+$!1,!3&.!C$1D#$A!G1%-$.!+,!+,58>A!C.$G+$D#,:.!<#8!:#0:-0#3.4!#,4!G+-,4!`-,8-$C$181,%0A!#8!3&.!
C$1D#$A!18!#3!3&.!.,3$#,:.!C-C10a!3+!6.!-,1G+$D!+?.$!3&.!8:1.,:.!G1.04!+G!?1.<(!R&18!:+,G01:38!<13&!3&.!8ADC3+D8!+G!3&.!hl!
C$+60.D!4.8:$16.4!1,!E.:31+,!V!1,!<&1:&!?#$1#31+,8!+?.$!3&.!G1.04!`1,!6+3&!G+:-8!#,4!#831%D#318Da!<.$.!$.C+$3.4!#8!3&.!
D+83! C$+D1,.,3! 8ADC3+D8(! F+$.! 4.3#108! :#,! 6.! G+-,4! #3c! &33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad3.831,%5
3&.5C$1D#$A5D1$$+$5111d!
YBQ! [5#(N*7\$,#6,%2($./$,"#$71%&'1-$&%11.1$
2!C+3.,31#0!<.#>,.88!+G!3&.!3.831,%!+G!3&.!#01%,D.,3!+G!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!#8!#,!1,41:#3+$!+G!138!:+$$.:3!<+$>1,%!1,!+,58>A!
+68.$?#31+,8!18!3&#3!#G3.$!#01%,D.,3/!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!83$-:3-$.!&#8!3+!6.! D+?.4!3+!8+D.!+3&.$!#M1D-3&!3+!#::.88!:.0.831#0!
3#$%.38(!R&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!18!8-CC+$3.4!+,!#!83..0!3$-88!<&1:&!1,!3-$,!18!#33#:&.4!3+!3&.!6#8.!<.4%.!+G!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!1,!#!
8.D15>1,.D#31:!D+-,3(!R&.!6#8.!<.4%.!138.0G!&#8!G+-$!0.%8!<&1:&!#$.!8.3!4+<,!+,!#,!-03$#5G0#3!:+,:$.3.!C1.$(!O&#3!<+-04!
3&.!:+,8.b-.,:.8!6.!1G!3&.!:+,:$.3.!C1.$!<.$.!,+3!G0#3!.,+-%&n!R&.!:+,:$.3.!C1.$!18!8-CC+8.4!3+!6.!G0#3!3+!#!C.#>53+5?#00.A!
?#$1#31+,!+G!,+!D+$.!3&#,!\!DD(!h,!+$4.$!3+!1,?.831%#3.!3&.!C+88161013A!+G!1,8-GG1:1.,3!G0#3,.88!+G!3&.!C1.$/!8C#:.$8!+G!Z(_!
#,4!\(^!DD!<.$.!C0#:.4!-,4.$!.#:&!+G!3&.!G+-$!0.%8!+G!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!1,!3-$,(!R&18!C$+:.4-$.!<#8!G1$83!:#$$1.4!+-3!<13&!3&.!
3.0.8:+C.!C+1,31,%!#3!3&.!;;2E!3+<.$!`#M1D-3&!_Z+a/!8+!3&#3!3&.!E&#:>5@#$3D#,,!#01%,D.,3!1,83$-D.,3!:+-04!6.!-8.4!3+!
D.#8-$.!3&.!1DC#:3!+G!3&.!0.%5-C!8C#:.$8!+,!3&.!#01%,D.,3!+G!3&.!D1$$+$!8.%D.,38(!),:.!#%#1,/!.?.,!1,!3&.!:#8.!+G!3&.!
0#$%.83!1DC#:3!`1,?+0?1,%!#!\(^!DD!8C#:.$!-,4.$!0.%!^a/!3&.!D18#01%,D.,3!+G!3&.!C$1D#$A!<#8!G+-,4!3+!6.!1,8-GG1:1.,3!3+!
4.%$#4.! 1D#%.! b-#013A! 3+! 3&#3! +68.$?.4! <13&! E27R(! F+$.! 4.3#108! +G! 3&.8.! 3.838! :#,! 6.! G+-,4! #3c!
&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad3.831,%53&.5C$1D#$A5D1$$+$51?d(!Q-$3&.$!3.831,%!+G!3&.!8#D.!>1,4!<#8!
#08+! :+,4-:3.4! +,58>A/! <&1:&! &#4! 3&.! #4?#,3#%.! 3&#3! #,A! C#$3! +G! 3&.! :+,:$.3.! C1.$! `#3! #,A! #M1D-3&a! :+-04! 6.! 3.83.4(!
2%#1,/!3&.8.!3.838!#$+-8.4!,+!:+,:.$,8!3&#3!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!<#8!-,4-0A!8.,8131?.!3+!C1.$!&.1%&3!?#$1#31+,8!+G!-C!3+!\!DD(!
YBY! E2N6]-$,#6,%2($%2$,"#$'+%(2&#2,$7.6%,%.2$
h,! G-$3&.$! C-$8-13! +G! 3&.! C+88161013A! +G! hl! 4.%$#4#31+,! 3&$+-%&! D18#01%,D.,3! +G! 3&.! C$1D#$A! D1$$+$! 4-.! 3+! D+?1,%! 3&.!
3.0.8:+C.!83$-:3-$./!+,58>A!+68.$?#31+,8!<&10.!C+1,31,%!#3!3&.!;;2E!3+<.$!<.$.!:+,4-:3.4(!R&#3!3&18!18!C+88160.!#3!#00!18!
4-.!3+!3&.!G#:3!3&#3!3&.!;;2E!3+<.$!18!80.,4.$/!#,4!C$+?14.4!3&.!+68.$?#31+,8!#$.!+G!3#$%.38!,.#$!3&.!:.,3$.!+G!3&.!R$#:>.$!
$#,%./!3&.!4+D.!+,!3&.!3+<.$!<100!G#00!1,!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!:.,3$#0!+68:-$#31+,(!N.C.#3.4!83#:>1,%!#,4!+,58>A!+68.$?1,%!<.$.!
:+,4-:3.4! <13&+-3! #,A! D+?.D.,3! +G! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.! 83$-:3-$.(! ),:.! #%#1,/! C++$! 1D#%.8! <.$.! 8..,! 4.8C13.! 3&.! E&#:>5
@#$3D#,,! 1,83$-D.,3! $.C+$31,%! 3&#3! 3&.! C$1D#$A! D1$$+$! <#8! #01%,.4! <.00! <13&1,! 138! 8C.:1G1:#31+,! +G! #,! NFE! 8.%D.,3!
31Cd3103! .$$+$! +G! ,+! D+$.! 3&#,! Z(ZU! #$:8.:(! 2! G-00! $.C+$3! +,! 3&.8.! 3.838! 18! #?#10#60.! #3c! &33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#035
1D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad3.831,%53&.5C$1D#$A5D1$$+$5?5+,58>A54#3#5#35::#8d(!
YBP! !#6,%2($,"#$0"'4]NI'1,&'22$%26,1*&#2,$1#/#1#24#$&%11.1$
R&.! C$1D#$A! D1$$+$! &#8! C#88.4! #00! +G! 3&.! 3.838! 4.8:$16.4! #6+?.! <13&+-3! $#181,%! #,A! 8-8C1:1+,8! #6+-3! 138! :+$$.:3!
G-,:31+,1,%(! R&.! +,58>A! 3.83! 18! C#$31:-0#$0A! C.$8-#81?.! 1,! D#>1,%! 3&.! :#8.! 3&#3! 3&.! C$1D#$A! 18! ,+3! $.8C+,8160.! G+$! 3&.!
E27R!hl!C$+60.D8(!@+<.?.$/!3&18!18!+,0A!3$-.!1G!3&.!E&#:>5@#$3D#,,!:#D.$#!1,!3&.!;;2E!3+<.$!18!<+$>1,%!:+$$.:30A(!
h,!C#$31:-0#$/!3&.!$.G.$.,:.!D1$$+$!`8..!Q1%(!_a!D-83!6.!1,!%++4!G1%-$.!+3&.$<18.!#,A!G1%-$.!.$$+$!<100!3&.,!6.!1DC+8.4!+,!
3&.!E27R!C$1D#$A(!h,!+$4.$!3+!3.83!<&.3&.$!+$!,+3!3&.$.!D#A!6.!C$+60.D8!<13&!3&.!$.G.$.,:.!D1$$+$/!#!8D#00!3.83!D1$$+$!
<#8!1,8.$3.4!1,3+!3&.!#$D!+G!3&.!1,83$-D.,3!8.,41,%!01%&3!3+!3&.!E27R!C$1D#$A!`#3!3&.!C+8131+,!+G!3&.!0#6.0!j^_!D.3.$!3+!
C$1D#$A!D1$$+$f!1,!Q1%(!_a(!h,83.#4!+G!3&.!01%&3!3$#?.01,%!^_!D!3+!3&.!E27R!C$1D#$A/!13!+,0A!3$#?.0.4!^ZZ!DD!3+!3&.!3.83!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=H
!
D1$$+$!8+!3&#3!3&.!1,83$-D.,3!<#8!3&.,!D.#8-$1,%!<#?.G$+,3!.$$+$!6.3<..,!3&.!3.83!D1$$+$!#,4!3&.!$.G.$.,:.!D1$$+$(!R&.!
$.8-03!+G!3&18!3.83!8&+<.4!3&#3!3&.!<#?.G$+,3!.$$+$!6.3<..,!3&.!3<+!+C31:8!&#4!#,!NFE!31Cd3103!.$$+$!+G!,+!D+$.!3&#,!Z(Z\!
#$:8.:!`<&.,!8:#0.4!-C!3+!#!31Cd3103!.$$+$!+G!3&.!E27R!8.%D.,38a(!R&.!8C.:1G1:#31+,!G+$!3&.!C$1D#$A!#01%,D.,3!18!#,!NFE!
31Cd3103!.$$+$!+G!,+!D+$.!3&#,!Z(ZU!#$:8.:(!E+!3&18!$.8-03!C$+?.8!3&#3!3&.!$.G.$.,:.!D1$$+$!18!1,4..4!1,!%++4!+C31:#0!G1%-$.!
`+$! 3&.! &1%&0A! -,01>.0A! C+88161013A! 3&#3! 3&.A! 6+3&! &#?.! 3&.! 8#D.! 8-$G#:.! G1%-$.! .$$+$a(! F+$.! 4.3#108! :#,! 6.! G+-,4! #3c!
&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad::#853.831,%53&.5::#851,83$-D.,35$.G.$.,:.5D1$$+$d(!
YB^! 0UCLLT@$,"#$4.24+*6%X#$'+%V%$/.1$,"#$71%&'1-$
203&+-%&!#!?.$A!#::-$#3.!1,83$-D.,3/!3&.!E&#:>5@#$3D#,,!#01%,D.,3!:#D.$#!418:-88.4!#6+?.!4+.8!,+3!%1?.!#,!1,3-131?.!
G..0!G+$!3&.!:+$$.:3!+C.$#31+,!+G!3&.!C$1D#$A(!E+!#!81DC0.!C1,&+0.d:#D.$#!:+D61,#31+,/!:#00.4!EBhQQJ/!<#8!1,83#00.4!#3!
3&.!:.,3$.!+G!:-$?#3-$.!+G!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$(!hD#%.8!+G!3&.!C1,&+0.!<.$.!G+$D.4!6A!3&.!C$1D#$A!+,!3&.!:#D.$#(!RAC1:#0!
EBhQQJ!1D#%.8!<.$.!$+-,4/!,+3!4+-60.4!#,4!&#4!#!QO@F!+G!#6+-3!Z(Y!#$:8.:(!R&18!18!<13&1,!138!8C.:1G1:#31+,!#,4!D-:&!
3++!8D#00!3+!6.!#!:+,3$16-3+$!3+!3&.!E27R!hl!C$+60.D(!EBhQQJ!18!#08+!?.$A!-8.G-0!G+$!#88.881,%!3&.!83#3.!+G!3&.!C$1D#$A!
D1$$+$!8.%D.,3!.,8.D60.!#8!3&.!C1,&+0.!1D#%.8!G$+D!1,41?14-#0!8.%D.,38!:#,!6.!8..,!8.C#$#3.0A!1G!.#:&!8.%D.,3!18!3103.4!
#! 01330.! #<#A! G$+D! 138! ,.1%&6+-$8(! S#$1#31+,8! 1,! $#41-8! +G! :-$?#3-$.! #,4! G1%-$.! G+$! .#:&! 8.%D.,3! :#,! 6.! D.#8-$.4! #,4!
D+,13+$.4/! #,4! <100! ,+! 4+-63! C$+?.! 3+! 6.! 1,?#0-#60.! #8! #! 41#%,+831:! 1,! $+-31,.! +C.$#31+,8(! 'K#DC0.! 1D#%.8! #,4! D+$.!
1,G+$D#31+,!+,!EBhQQJ!:#,!6.!G+-,4!#3c!&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad8C1GGAd(!
h,! 3&.! 01%&3! +G! 138! 8-::.88G-00A! C#881,%! #00! 3&.! #6+?.! 3.838/! 3&.$.! :#,! 6.! 01330.! 4+-63! 3&#3! 3&.! C$1D#$A! D1$$+$! 18! ,+3!
$.8C+,8160.!G+$!3&.!E27R!hl!C$+60.D8(!
!
PB! !IJ$LE<G0$K;3FCJD!@$<3G0J0W$0C_J$3DF$LC;0!$3!!JMU!$3!$3$LC`$
PBA! <'*6#6$./$,"#$/.4*6$(1'?%#2,$'2?$.,"#1$6-&7,.&6$
O13&!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!.01D1,#3.4!G$+D!:+,3.,31+,/!3&.!E2;!<#8!0++D1,%!0#$%.!#8!3&.!C$1D#$A!8-8C.:3!#8!3&.!:#-8.!+G!
3&.! E27R! hl! C$+60.D8(! @+<.?.$/! :+-04! 3&.$.! 6.! +3&.$! :#-8.8n! 9.G+$.! C$+:..41,%/! 13! 18! -8.G-0! 3+! $.?1.<! #00! C+88160.!
:#-8.8!+G!3&.!?#$1+-8!8ADC3+D8!+G!3&.!hl!C$+60.D!+3&.$!3&#,!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$(!
R#60.!\(!EADC3+D8!#,4!C+88160.!:#-8.8!+G!3&.!E27R!hl!C$+60.D(!!
!
L.4*6$(1'?%#2,$ 36,%(&',%6&$ CS$X'1%'V%+%,-$
P+!
P+!
n!
03<$MH$,%7a,%+,a?#4#2,1#$
P+!
P+!
n!
03<$MH$4.&'$
P+!
J.8!
n!
03<$MH$'6,%(&',%6&$
P+!
J.8!
n!
03<$MR$,%7a,%+,a?#4#2,1#$
P+!
P+!
n!
03<$MR$4.&'$
P+!
J.8!
n!
03<$MR$'6,%(&',%6&$
J.8!
J.8!
n!
03<$MQaMY$,%7a,%+,a?#4#2,1#$
J.8!
J.8!
n!
03<$MQaMY$4.&'$
P+!
J.8!
n!
03<$MQaMY$'6,%(&',%6&$
J.8!
P+!
n!
L.4'+$7+'2#$,%7a,%+,$
!
R#60.!\!%1?.8!8-:&!#!$.?1.<(!R&.!D#I+$!hl!C$+60.D!8ADC3+D8!#$.!0183.4!#3!3&.!3+C!+G!3&.!:+0-D,8!#,4!3&.!0.G3D+83!:.008!
1,!.#:&!$+<!8&+<!C+88160.!:#-8.8!#$181,%!G$+D!D18#01%,D.,3!+$!3&.!D#I+$!G1$83!+$4.$!#6.$$#31+,8!:+D#!#,4!#831%D#318D(!
O&.3&.$!+$!,+3!#!:#-8.!18!:#C#60.!+G!%1?1,%!$18.!3+!3&.!8ADC3+D!18!8&+<,!#8!A.8!+$!,+!1,!3&.!3#60./!#,4!<#8!.?#0-#3.4!
-81,%! #! m.D#K! D+4.0! +G! 3&.!3.0.8:+C./! 1DC+81,%!+,! 3&.! ?#$1+-8!+C31:#0!.0.D.,38! 3&.! 1,41:#3.4! D18#01%,D.,3! +$! G1%-$.!
.$$+$!`:+D#!+$!#831%D#318Da(!R&.!,.3!$.8-03!+G!3&.!D+4.01,%!8&+<.4!3&#3!+G!3&.!G+-$!E2;!D1$$+$8/!+,0A!D18#01%,D.,3!+$!
:+D#!1,!FY!+$!FW!`8..!Q1%(!\!G+$!3&.!0#6.01,%!8:&.D.a!#$.!:#C#60.!+G!%.,.$#31,%!#!G+:-8!%$#41.,3(!E-:&!.$$+$8!$.b-1$.!#!
:+DC.,8#31+,!G+$!3&.!?.$A!0#$%.!:+D#!%.,.$#3.4/!6-3!3&18!18!.#810A!4+,.!6A!31Cd31031,%!3&.!<&+0.!E2;(!2!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!
:#,!#08+!6.!%.,.$#3.4!6A!#!G+:#0!C0#,.!31Cd3103!`#8!18!1,3-131?.0A!+6?1+-8a(!
2831%D#318D!1,!83#$!1D#%.8!1,!3&.!G+:#0!C0#,.!:#,!6.!%.,.$#3.4!6A!D18#01%,D.,3!+$!#831%D#318D!1,!3&.!G1%-$.!+G!D1$$+$8!
FV/! FY! +$! FW/! 6-3! ,+3! 6A! G+:#0! C0#,.! 31Cd3103(! R&.! +,0A! $+<8! +G! 3&.! 3#60.! 3&#3! &#?.! A.8! 1,! 6+3&! 3&.! 8.:+,4! #,4! 3&1$4!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=U
!
:+0-D,8! &#?.! D18#01%,D.,3! +$! :+D#! 1,! 3&.! G1%-$.! +G! FY! +$! FW(! P+,.! +G! 3&.! C+88160.! :#-8.8! ,#3-$#00A! %1?.! $18.! 3+!
?#$1#61013A!1,!hl(!
PBH! !"#$6%b#$./$,"#$/.4*6$(1'?%#2,$
F.#8-$.D.,38!+G!3&.!81M.!#,4!+$1.,3#31+,!+G!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!<.$.!D#4.!6A!+63#1,1,%!8.b-.,:.8!+G!1D#%.8!#3!41GG.$.,3!
G+:-8! C+8131+,8/! 4.3.$D1,1,%! G+$! .#:&! 83#$! 1D#%.! 3&.! 6.83! G+:-8! 8.331,%/! :+,?.$31,%! 3&#3! 3+! 3&.! #CC$+C$1#3.! 6#:>! G+:#0!
4183#,:./! #,4! G1331,%! #! C0#,.! 3+! 3&.! $.8-031,%! #$$#A! +G! 6#:>! G+:#0! 4183#,:.8! #8! #! G-,:31+,! +G! C+8131+,! 1,! 3&.! G+:#0! C0#,.(!
E#DC0.!$.8-038!#$.!8&+<,!1,!R#60.!^(!
R#60.!^!E1M.!#,4!+$1.,3#31+,!+G!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3(!
F',#$
D.$./$6,'16$ L.4*6$(1'?%#2,$8?#(9$ U.6%,%.2$'2(+#$8?#(9$
YY!
^(V!o!Z(\!
5_\!o!V!
HOO^$0#7$c$
^T!
^([!o!Z(V!
5WT!o!_!
HOO^$0#7$c$
U\!
^(T!o!Z(\!
5YW!o!^!
HOO^$0#7$A^$
WU!
^(_!o!Z(^!
5[Y!o!Y!
HOO^$0#7$A^$
WY!
^(W!o!Z(\!
5WV!o!V!
HOO^$0#7$A^$
!
R&.!$.8-038!8&+<!81%,1G1:#,3!?#$1#61013A!1,!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!G$+D!^(V+!-C!3+!^(T+!<13&!#!$+-%&0A!YW+!?#$1#31+,!1,!C+8131+,!
#,%0.!<&.$.!5TZ+!:+$$.8C+,48!3+!#01%,D.,3!<13&!3&.!R$#:>.$!A!41$.:31+,!`<&1:&!18!#08+!#01%,.4!<13&!%$#?13Aa(!
R&.!D#%,13-4.!+G!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!18/!#8!,+3.4!#0$.#4A/!?.$A!0#$%.c!3&.!?#0-.8!1,!R#60.!^!1,41:#3.!#!D.#,!%$#41.,3!+G!
#6+-3!^(_+!1,!3&.!4.3.:3+$!+?.$!3&.!\ZU!DD!8:1.,:.!G1.04!+G!?1.<(!R&18!:+$$.8C+,48!3+!#!?#$1#31+,!+G!6#:>!G+:#0!4183#,:.!+G!
Y(T!DD!+?.$!3&.!G1.04!+G!?1.<(!h,3.$C$.31,%!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!#8!#!D18#01%,D.,3!+G!FW/!G+$!.K#DC0./!$.b-1$.8!#!4.:.,3$.!
+G!Z(W!DD!+$!#!31Cd3103!+G!Z(\+!1,!FW!3+!%.,.$#3.!#!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!+G!^(_+(!E1D10#$0A!0#$%.!?#0-.8!#$.!$.b-1$.4!1G!FY!18!3&.!
:#-8.!+G!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3(!R&.8.!?#0-.8!.K:..4!,+$D#0!+C31:#0!3+0.$#,:.8!6A!,.#$0A!#,!+$4.$!+G!D#%,13-4.p!
PBR! L%16,$',,#&7,$',$'$/%d$
28!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!18!3&.!D+83!8.$1+-8!8+-$:.!+G!4.%$#4#31+,!+G!1D#%.!b-#013A!+?.$!3&.!G1.04/!#!C+88160.!83$#3.%A!G+$!#3!
0.#83!#D.01+$#31,%!3&.!C$+60.D!18!3+!$.D+?.!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!<13&!#!81DC0.!D.:&#,1:#0!3103!+G!3&.!1,83$-D.,38(!R&18!<#8!
D+83!.#810A!4+,.!6A!31031,%!3&.!N+3#31,%!E3$-:3-$.!`NEc!8..!Q1%(!Va!6A!^(_+!`R#60.!^a(!),:.!3&18!<#8!:#$$1.4!+-3/!&+<.?.$/!
#03&+-%&!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!<#8!.01D1,#3.4/!3&.!$.8-031,%!+,58>A!1D#%.!b-#013A!<#8!<+$8.!3&#,!6.G+$.!3&.!3103(!R&.!$.#8+,!
G+$!3&18!18!,+3!-,4.$83++4(!
!
^B! LC;0!$U;E:J0$EL$!IJ$0UIJ;C<35$3:J;;3!CED$<E;;J<!E;$803<9$
^BA! U1.X%2($,"',$,"#$03<$%6$1#67.26%V+#$
R&.! .01D1,#31+,! +G! 3&.! C$1D#$A! D1$$+$! #8! 3&.! :#-8.! +G! 3&.! C$+60.D! 0.#?.8! 3&.! E2;/! 3&.! 0#83! +C31:#0! 8-658A83.D! 3+! 6.!
1,4.C.,4.,30A! 3.83.4/! #8! 3&.! +,0A! $.D#1,1,%! C+88161013A(! O13&! #! :#D.$#! :+?.$1,%! 3&.! 8:1.,:.! G1.04! +G! ?1.<! #3! 3&.! NEE!
.,3$#,:.!8013!C+8131+,!`8..!Q1%(!^a/!#,4!<13&!EBhQQJ!C$+?141,%!#!81DC0./!b-1:>!#,4!1,3-131?.!%#-%.!+G!3&.!C.$G+$D#,:.!+G!
3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$/!#!81DC0.!3.83!<+-04!C$+?.!6.A+,4!#00!4+-63!3&#3!3&.!E2;!18!$.8C+,8160.!G+$!3&.!E27R!hl!C$+60.D8(!
R&.!:#D.$#!$.b-1$.4!<#8!#88.D60.4!-81,%!#,!2C+%..!+GG53&.58&.0G!XTZZZF!C.031.$5:++0.4!:#D.$#!<13&!#!YZT_!K!YZT_!K!
T!q!C1K.0!;;"(!R&.!C&A81:#0!81M.!+G!3&18!;;"!18!VU!K!VU!DD/!+$!W\!DD!#:$+88!3&.!41#%+,#0(!R&18!4.3.:3+$!<#8!D+-,3.4!
+,!3&.!K5A!3#60.!C$.?1+-80A!-8.4!1,!3&.!S.$1G1:#31+,!h,83$-D.,3!`Sha!:+,G1%-$#31+,!+G!E#031:#D\\(!R&.!K5A!3#60.!&#8!V!K!V!
418:$.3.!C+8131+,8/!#,4!#0+,%!<13&!3&.!0#$%.!81M.!+G!3&.!;;"/!3&.!:+D61,#31+,!:+?.$.4!3&.!\Z[!DD!41#D.3.$!8:1.,:.!G1.04!
+G!?1.<!+G!E27R(!R&.!C$+:.4-$.!-8.4!<#8!81DC0.c!`1a!#01%,!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$i!`11a!+63#1,!EBhQQJ!1D#%.8!8&+<1,%!3&#3!
3&.!C$1D#$A!18!1,!%++4!G1%-$.i!`111a!+63#1,!+,58>A!1D#%.8!<13&!3&.!2C+%..!1,!T!C+8131+,8!+G!3&.!NEE!8013!C0#,.i!`1?a!$.3-$,!
3+!3&.!;;2E!3+<.$!#,4!-8.!EBhQQJ!3+!8&+<!3&#3!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$!18!83100!1,!%++4!G1%-$.(!
R&.!#6+?.!C$+:.4-$.!<#8!.K.:-3.4!1,!^ZZU!2-%dE.C/!?.$1G1.4!3&.!%++4!+C31:#0!83#3.!+G!3&.!C$1D#$A!6.G+$.!#,4!#G3.$!+,5
8>A!1D#%1,%!<&1:&!$.?.#0.4!3&.!-8-#0!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!#,4!+3&.$!#6.$$#31+,8( At last the SAC was proven to be the culprit.!
'K#DC0.!1D#%.8!#,4!D+$.!1,G+$D#31+,!:#,!6.!G+-,4!#3c!&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$AdC$++G53&#35
3&.58#:5185$.8C+,8160.d(
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=GF
!
Outer skin
removed
Full SAC
M4 I M5
sub-structure
:W4p
M5 radial
support
detail
!
Q1%(!U(!E2;!9$.#>4+<,(!23!0.G3!18!8&+<,!3&.!G-00!E2;!<&1:&!18!#33#:&.4!3+!3&.!PNE!6A!3&.!1,3.$G#:.!$1,%!`8..!#08+!Q1%(!Va(!
O13&!3&.!+-3.$!8>1,!$.D+?.4/!FV!#,4!F^!#$.!$.?.#0.4!<13&!3&.!FY5FW!8-6583$-:3-$.!+,!3+C!+G!F^!#,4!8&+<,!#0+,.!#3!
3+C!$1%&3(!23!6+33+D!$1%&3!18!3&.!4.3#10!+G!3&.!FW!$#41#0!8-CC+$3c!#!3#,%.,3!#$D!18!#33#:&.4!#3!+,.!.,4!3+!3&.!-CC.$!8-65
83$-:3-$./!#,4!#3!3&.!+3&.$!.,4!3+!#,!1,?#$!6-33+,!6+,4.4!3+!3&.!.4%.!+G!3&.!%0#88(!EC&.$1:#0!6.#$1,%8!#$.!#3!.13&.$!.,4!+G!
3&.!3#,%.,3!#$D(!R&.!6.#$1,%!#33#:&.4!3+!3&.!1,?#$!6-33+,!8138!+,!#,!#K1#0!8-CC+$3!6+03!#,:&+$.4!+,!3&.!:#,310.?.$(!
^BH! 0#4.2?$',,#&7,$',$'$/%d@$6"%&&%2($MY$
O13&1,! #! G.<! D+,3&8! +G! 3&.! 6.%1,,1,%! +G! 3&.! 1,?.831%#31+,/! 13! <#8! $.#01M.4! 3&#3! +G! 3&.! G+-$! E2;! D1$$+$8/! +,0A!
D18#01%,D.,3!+G!FY!#,4d+$!FW!<#8!:#C#60.!+G!%.,.$#31,%!#!G+:-8!%$#41.,3(!R&.!:+DC$.&.,81?.!8-$?.A!<&+8.!$.8-038!#$.!
0183.4!1,!R#60.!\!#44.4!3+!3&.!0183!#!:+D#53AC.!8-$G#:.!4183+$31+,!+G!FY!+$!FW/!+$!31Cd3103!+G!3&.!G+:#0!C0#,.(!E.:31+,!_(V!
8&+<.4!3&#3!3&18!<#8!,+3!#!?1#60.!G1K(!E+!<13&!3&.!:+,G14.,:.!3&#3!3&.!E2;!<#8!#3!G#-03/!#,4!81DC0A!#8!#!C$++G5+G5:+,:.C3/!
13!<#8!4.:14.4!3+!3103!FW!1,!#!$.?.$8160.!D#,,.$!3+!8..!1G!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!:+-04!6.!.01D1,#3.4!#,4!3&.!+3&.$!hl!C$+60.D!
8ADC3+D8!#D.01+$#3.4(!R&18!<#8!.K.:-3.4!6A!1,8.$31,%!#!8&1D!+G!3&1:>,.88!Z(_W!DD!`pa!-,4.$,.#3&!3&.!8C&.$1:#0!6.#$1,%!
+,!3&.!.,4!+G!+,.!+G!3&.!3#,%.,3!#$D8!8-CC+$31,%!FW!r!8..!Q1%(!U!#,4!138!:#C31+,!G+$!100-83$#31+,!#,4!.KC0#,#31+,!+G!3&.!
FW! $#41#0! 8-CC+$3! 8:&.D.! `#8! <.00! #8! #! 6$.#>4+<,! +G! 3&.! E2;! +C3+D.:&#,1:#0! 8A83.Da(! R&18! 414! 1,4..4! $.D+?.! 3&.!
G+:-8!%$#41.,3!#,4!8-65#$:8.:+,4!83#$!1D#%.8!<.$.!C$+4-:.4!#00!+?.$!3&.!G1.04(!9-3!3&.!%#1,!<#8!8&+$3501?.4!#,4!<13&1,!#!
G.<!4#A8/!3&.!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!#,4!+3&.$!#6.$$#31+,8!<.$.!6#:>(!R&.!?#$1#61013A!&#4!4.G.#3.4!3&.!#33.DC3!#3!#!8ADC3+D#31:!
G1K!#,4!#!4..C.$!1,?.831%#31+,!+G!3&.!E2;!<#8!:0.#$0A!$.b-1$.4(!'K#DC0.!1D#%.8!#,4!D+$.!1,G+$D#31+,!:#,!6.!G+-,4!#3c!!
&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad8&1DD1,%5DWd(!
!
eB! !IJ$MQNMY$f3ZJL;ED!$!J0!$
h,!+$4.$!3+!6$.#>!4+<,!3&.!E2;!1,3+!138!8-6:+DC+,.,38/!#,!+C31:#0!3.83!+G!FY5FW!<#8!4.?18.4(!2!C+1,3!8+-$:.!C0#:.4!1,!
3&.!C.$G+$#31+,!1,!FW!:#,!6.!1D#%.4!6A!3&.!FY5FW!C#1$!C.$G.:30A!831%D#31:#00A!#3!3&.!0+:#31+,!1,41:#3.4!1,!Q1%(![c!3&.!
$#A8!3$#:.4!1,!Q1%(![!G$+D!3&.!C1,&+0./!$.G0.:3.4!+GG!FY!3+!FW!#,4!3&.,:.!3+!3&.!G+:-8/!8&+<!3&.!+C31:#0!0#A+-3(!23!3&.!
1D#%.!+G!3&.!C1,&+0./!.13&.$!81DC0.!#$$#A!4.3.:3+$8!<.$.!C0#:.4!`3+!G+$D! 41$.:3!1D#%.8! +G!3&.!C1,&+0.a/!+$!#!@#$3D#,,!
<#?.G$+,35D.#8-$1,%! :#D.$#! `&33Ccdd<<<(+>+3.:&(:+Da! 3+! D.#8-$.! 3&.! <#?.G$+,3! #88+:1#3.4! <13&! 3&.! 1D#%.! +G! 3&.!
C1,&+0.(!R+!C0#:.!3&.!C1,&+0.!$+-%&0A/!13!<#8!D+-,3.4!1,!#!C.$8C.K!3-6.!<&1:&!<#8!1,8.$3.4!3&$+-%&!3&.!C.$G+$#31+,!1,!
FV/!<13&!+,.!.,4!0+:#3.4!1,!3&.!C.$G+$#31+,!1,!F^/!#,4!3&.!+3&.$!.,4!8.:-$.4!#3!3&.!C.$G+$#31+,!1,!FV(!!
R&.!.K#:3!C0#:.D.,3!+G!3&.!C1,&+0.!<#8!:+,3$+00.4!6A!#,!K5A5M!#$$#A!+G!Bh!01,.#$!83#%.8!<13&!WZ!,D!$.8+0-31+,!#,4!^W!DD!
83$+>.(!R+!4.3.$D1,.!<&.$.!3&.!C1,&+0.!8&+-04!6.!C0#:.4/!3<+!0#8.$8!#,4!3&.!8+5:#00.4!eE2;!$.G.$.,:.!D1$$+$g!`E2;NFa!
<.$.!-8.4(!Q1$83/!#!4+<,<#$458&1,1,%!0#8.$!G$+D!3&.!;;2E!3+<.$!<#8!8.3!-C!3+!$.3-$,!1,!#-3+:+001D#31+,!G$+D!3&.!:.,3$.!
+G!3&.!:.,3$#0!8.%D.,3!+G!3&.!C$1D#$A!D1$$+$(!O13&!3&.!4+<,<#$4!0#8.$!8.3!-C!1,!3&18!<#A/!#,!-C<#$4!0#8.$!G$+D!3&.!.4%.!
+G!3&.!C$1D#$A/!$.G0.:31,%!-C<#$48!3+!3&.!;;2E!3+<.$!+GG!#!C$18D! D+-,3.4!#6+?.!3&.!C$1D#$Ag8!:.,3$#0!8.%D.,3/!<#8!
#4I-83.4!3+!6.!:+001,.#$!<13&!3&.!4+<,<#$4!0#8.$(!R&.!R$#:>.$!#,4!3&.!E2;NF!<.$.!3&.,!1,3$+4-:.4(!R&.!E2;NF!18!#!
WZ!DD!41#D.3.$!G0#3!<&1:&!:#,!6.!6+03.4!3+!#,!1,3.$G#:.!+,!3&.!$.#$!+G!FY!C$+?14.4!6A!3&.!E2;!8-CC01.$(!2!0#8.$!8&1,1,%!
G$+D!3&.!;;2E!3+<.$!+,!3+!3&.!E2;NF/!1DC#:31,%!+,!138!:.,3$.!`#8!1,41:#3.4!6A!#!8:+$.4!:$+88!1,!3&.!+C31:#0!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=GG
!
Image of Pinhole
25-micron pinhole
as point source
Downward
Pinhole
mounting
tube
shining
laser
MS
'I,
I
SAC reference
Upward
shining
laser
mirror
M2
M3
!
Q1%(![(!FY5FW!<#?.G$+,3!3.83(!2!^W5D1:$+,!C1,&+0.!D+-,3.4!#3!3&.!.,4!+G!#!C.$8C.K!3-6.!18!1D#%.4!6A!FY!#,4!FW(!R&.!
C1,&+0.!18!C+8131+,.4!-81,%!:+001,.#$!4+<,<#$4!#,4!-C<#$4!8&1,1,%!0#8.$8!`4#8&.4!01,.8a!#,4!3&.!E2;!$.G.$.,:.!D1$$+$(!
!
Best
Nominal 1514 - MS system
Best
MS tilted by 0.1 deg
LBEEE1HHHHH
-1.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
Pinhole V Position
3.0
4.0
5.0
0.0
7.0
0.0
Pinhole X Position
!
Q1%(! T(! FY5FW! <#?.G$+,3! 3.83! $.8-038(! R&.! 3+C! $+<! 8&+<8! 3&.! 1D#%.8! +G! 3&.! C1,&+0.! .KC.:3.4! G+$! 3&.! ,+D1,#0! 8A83.D! G+$!
41GG.$.,3! C1,&+0.! A! C+8131+,8! `#8! 1,41:#3.4! -,4.$! 3&.! 0#6.0! eB1,&+0.! J! B+8131+,ga(! R&.! 8.:+,4! $+<! 8&+<8! 3&.! 1D#%.8!
.KC.:3.4!1G!FW!18!3103.4!6A!Z(\!4.%(!R&.!3&1$4!#,4!G+-$3&!$+<8!8&+<!3&.!$.#0!1D#%.8!+63#1,.4!G+$!K!#,4!A!C1,&+0.!8:#,8(!!
!
8-$G#:.! +G! 3&.! D1$$+$a! #,4! $.3-$,1,%! 1,! #-3+:+001D#31+,/! 4.G1,.8! 3&.! +C31:#0! #K18! +G! 3&.! E2;(! R&.! R$#:>.$! <#8! 3&-8!
#4I-83.4!1,!4.:.,3$.!#,4!31Cd3103!8+!3&#3!3&.!4+<,<#$4!0#8.$!$.3-$,.4!1,!#-3+:+001D#31+,!G$+D!3&.!:.,3$.!+G!3&.!E2;NF(!
Q1,#00A/!3&.!C1,&+0.!<#8!:.,3$.4!+,!3&.!-C<#$458&1,1,%!0#8.$(!
R&.!4.%$..8!+G!G$..4+D!+G!3&.!8A83.D!#$.!01D13.4c!3&.!+,0A!418:$.31+,!#3!3&.!+C.$#3+$g8!418C+8#0!18!3&.!KdA!C+8131+,1,%!+G!
3&.!C1,&+0.(!),:.!C0#:.4/!3&.!:#D.$#!`41$.:3!+$!<#?.G$+,3a!&#8!3+!G+00+<!3&.!1D#%.!+G!3&.!C1,&+0.!`3&.!FY5FW!C#1$!:#,!
6.!3&+-%&3!+G!#8!#!81DC0.!0.,8!1D#%1,%!3&.!C1,&+0.a(!hG!3&.!C1,&+0.!18!:+$$.:30A!C0#:.4/!#,4!3&.!8-$G#:.8!+G!FY!#,4!FW!#$.!
,+D1,#0/!#,4!FY!#,4!FW!#$.!C.$G.:30A!#01%,.4/!#!41GG$#:31+,501D13.4!1D#%.!+G!3&.!C1,&+0.!8&+-04!6.!$.#01M.4(!
eBA! L%16,$1#6*+,6$/1.&$,"#$MQNMY$>'X#/1.2,$,#6,@$&%6'+%(2&#2,$./$,"#$&%11.16$
Q1$83!$.8-038!G$+D!3&.!3.83!-8.4!41$.:3!1D#%.8!+G!3&.!C1,&+0.(!O&#3!<+-04!6.!.KC.:3.4n!R&.!#,8<.$!3+!3&18!b-.831+,/!#0+,%!
<13&!3&.!$.8-038!#:3-#00A!+63#1,.4/!#$.!8&+<,!1,!Q1%(!T(!h,!3&.!3+C!3<+!$+<8!3&.!6+K.8!8&+<!m.D#K!81D-0#31+,8!+G!3&.!
.KC.:3.4!1D#%.8!+G!3&.!C1,&+0.!G+$!?#$1+-8!C1,&+0.!C+8131+,8!1,!3&.!A!41$.:31+,(!(!R&.!3+C!$+<!8&+<8!3&.!,+D1,#0!8A83.D!
`6+3&!FY!#,4!FW!<13&!C.$G.:3!G1%-$.8!#,4!C.$G.:30A!#01%,.4a(!R&.!6.83!1D#%.!`0#6.0.4!e9.83ga!+::-$8!<&.,!3&.!C1,&+0.!J!
C+8131+,!18!Z(Z!DD!`1(.(!+,!#K18a(!R&18!1D#%.!18!41GG$#:31+,!01D13.4(!h,!:+,3$#83/!1G!FW!<.$.!3103.4!6A!Z(\+!`#!4.:.,3$.!+G!Z(W!
DD! &#8! 3&.! 8#D.! .GG.:3a/! 3&.! 6.83! 1D#%.! +::-$8! <&.,! 3&.! C1,&+0.! 18! D+?.4! +GG! #K18! 6A! #6+-3! _! DD(! R&18! 1D#%.! 18!
81%,1G1:#,30A!#831%D#31:(!R&.!3&1$4!#,4!G+-$3&!$+<8!8&+<!3&.!+68.$?.4!1D#%.8!G$+D!K!#,4!A!C1,&+0.!8:#,8(!h3!18!b-13.!:0.#$!
3&#3!3&.!6.83!1D#%.8!1,!3&.8.!$+<8!:+$$.8C+,4!3+!3&.!D18#01%,.4!FW!:#8./!#,4!,+3!3&.!,+D1,#0!8A83.D(!!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=GK
!
M5 w.r.t. M4 radial gauges
Top: 1 o'clock Centre: 5 o'clock Bottom: 9 o'clock
0.070
0.050
I
0.030
nflnflnA nfl nfl nfl
nn
MW45%.JJ
fJ'uu.4
.,-,flnflr,rflr,Cr,r1r,r
0.010
.0.0101
v%,____
V V VV V V VU V V VU
\,IV VV
21:00
21:15
21:30
21:20
21:40
21:50
22:00
Time
MS w.r.t. M4 radial gauges
Top: 1 o'clock Centre: 5 o'clock Bottom: 9 o'clock
0.050
0.070
0.550
— 0.050
0.040
0.030
0.020
0.0 10
0.000
22:00
22:10
22:20
22:30
22:40
22:50
23:00
23:10
23:20
23:30
22:40
Time
23:50
00:00
!
Q1%(!\Z(!"1#0!%#-%.!D+,13+$1,%!+?.$!#!V!&$!1,3.$?#0!+G!3&.!D+?.D.,3!+G!FW!<13&!$.8C.:3!3+!FY(!E..!3.K3!G+$!4.3#108(!
;+-04!3&.!C0#:.D.,3!+G!3&.!C1,&+0./!+,!<&1:&!3&.!$.8-03!8&+<,!1,!Q1%(!T!$.838/!6.!-,:.$3#1,!6A!8.?.$#0!DDn!R&.!#,8<.$!18!
,+c!<#?.G$+,3!D.#8-$.D.,38!+G!3&.!C1,&+0.!1D#%.!8&+<.4!81%,1G1:#,3!#831%D#318D!`m.$,1>.!mWs\(^W!<#?.8a/!:+,G1$D1,%!
3&#3!3&.!FY5FW!C#1$!#$.!#831%D#31:/!#,4!:+,8183.,3!<13&!$.0#31?.!D18#01%,D.,3!+G!#6+-3!Z(\+!31Cd3103!+$!Z(W!DD!1,!4.:.,3$.(!
R&.!3.83!8.3-C!8&+<,!1,!Q1%(![!<#8!G+-,4!3+!6.!8-GG1:1.,30A!83#60.!3&#3!<#?.G$+,3!D.#8-$.D.,38!:+-04!6.!D#4.!.?.,!#G3.$!
.K.$:181,%!#00!3&.!#:3-#3+$8!+G!3&.!3.0.8:+C.c!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!83$-:3-$.!<#8!3&-8!$+3#3.4!6A!\[Z+!#,4!3&.!R$#:>.$!D+?.4!1,!#00!
_!#K.8/!<13&!<#?.G$+,3!D.#8-$.D.,38!6.1,%!D#4.!#G3.$!.#:&!1,41?14-#0!D+?.D.,3(!h3!<#8!G+-,4!3&#3/!<13&!3&.!.K:.C31+,!
+G!D+?.D.,3!+G!3&.!$&+!83#%.!`8..!Q1%(!V!#,4!8.:31+,!^(Va/!,+,.!+G!3&.8.!D+?.D.,38!&#4!#,A!.GG.:3!+,!3&.!1D#%.8(!F+$.!
1,G+$D#31+,!18!#?#10#60.!#3c!&33Ccdd<<<(8#03(#:(M#d1bd3&.58#0351D#%.5b-#013A583+$Ad3&.5DY5DW5<#?.G$+,353.8351d(!!
eBH! 0"%&&%2($MY$'('%2$
h,!+$4.$!3+!8..!1G!41GG$#:31+,501D13.4!C.$G+$D#,:.!G+$!FY5FW!:+-04!6.!$.83+$.4/!8&1DD1,%!FW!<#8!$.C.#3.4(!R&.!8&1D!
3&1:>,.88! #,4! +$1.,3#31+,! <.$.! :#0:-0#3.4! <&1:&! <+-04! $.D+?.! 3&.! #831%D#318D! G$+D! 3&.! C#1$(! R&18! 3-$,.4! +-3! 3+! 6.!
.K#:30A!3&.!8#D.!#8!$.b-1$.4!3+!$.D+?.!3&.!+,58>A!G+:-8!%$#41.,3!`8..!E.:31+,!U(^a(!XC+,!$.51,8.$31+,!+G!3&.!8#D.!8&1D/!
13!<#8!G+-,4!3&#3!3&.!6.83!1D#%.!$.b-1$.4!3&.!C1,&+0.!3+!6.!D+?.4!3+<#$48!3&.!,+D1,#0!C+8131+,!`8..!Q1%(!Ta/!#,4!3&#3!
41GG$#:31+,501D13.4!1D#%1,%!<#8!1,4..4!#:&1.?.4(!B$1+$!3+!8&1DD1,%/!3&.!6.83!`#831%D#31:a!<#?.G$+,3!<#8!G+-,4!3+!&#?.!
NFE!+G!Z(V_!<#?.8/!C.#>53+5?#00.A!+G!^(U!<#?.8i!#G3.$!8&1DD1,%!3&.!:+$$.8C+,41,%!,-D6.$8!<.$.!Z(\^!#,4!\(Z!<#?.8(!
@+<.?.$/! +,:.! #%#1,/! 3&18! 8-::.88! <#8! 8&+$3501?.4(! O13&1,! #! D+,3&! 3&.! D1$$+$! C#1$! <#8! G+-,4! 3+! G+$D! 1D#%.8! +G! 3&.!
C1,&+0.!<&1:&!<.$.!,+!0+,%.$!41GG$#:31+,!01D13.4!#,4!mW!&#4!1,:$.#8.4!3+!Z(_!<#?.8/!#6+-3!&#0G!3&#3!8..,!6.G+$.(!
eBR! F%'+$('*(#$&.2%,.1%2($./$&.X#&#2,6$./$MQ$'2?$MY$'2?$,"#%1$6*77.1,6$
h3! <#8! :0.#$! 6A! 3&18! 31D.! 3&#3! 8-683#,31#0/! $#C14! ?#$1#61013A! 1,! 3&.! +C31:#0! 8A83.D! <#8! +::-$$1,%(! h,! +$4.$! 3+! 418:+?.$!
.K#:30A!<&#3!<#8!:#-81,%!3&18/!#!8A83.D!+G!41#0!%#-%.8!<#8!1,83#00.4!1,!3&.!FY5FW!+C3+D.:&#,1:#0!8A83.D(!Q+$!,#D1,%!
C-$C+8.8/! 3&.! 3&$..! 8-CC+$3! C+1,38! +G! FY! #,4! FW! <.$.! $.G.$$.4! 3+! #8! j\! +g:0+:>f/! jW! +g:0+:>f! #,4! jT! +g:0+:>f!
#CC$+C$1#3.!3+!3&.1$!#CC.#$#,:.!<&.,!?1.<.4!G$+D!3&.!;;2E!3+<.$!`_!+g:0+:>!18!3&.!0+:#0!%$#?13A!?.:3+$!C$+I.:31+,a(!
R&$..!41#0!%#-%.8!<.$.!#,:&+$.4!+,!3&.!3&$..!:#,310.?.$!8-CC+$38!+G!FW!`8..!Q1%(!Ua!<13&!3&.1$!C$+6.8!3+-:&1,%!3&.!.4%.!
+G!FW!`3&.8.!3&$..!<100!6.!:#00.4!%$+-C!2a(!h,!#44131+,/!G1K3-$1,%!<#8!1,83#00.4!+,!3&.!6#:>!+G!FY!<13&!C1.:.8!4.8:.,41,%!
3+! FW! +,! <&1:&! <.$.! #,:&+$.4! 3&$..! G-$3&.$! %#-%.8! `%$+-C! 9a/! %1?1,%! D.#8-$.8! +G! 3&.! $#41#0! D+?.D.,3! +G! FW! <13&!
$.8C.:3! 3+! FY(! Q1,#00A/! 3&$..! G-$3&.$! 41#0! %#-%.8! `%$+-C! ;a! %#?.! 3&.! $.0#31?.! D+?.D.,3! +G! FY! <13&! $.8C.:3! 3+! 3&.!
:#,310.?.$8(!R&.!%#-%.8!C$+?14.4!41%13#0!$.#4+-3!.?.$A!G.<!8.:+,48!#,4!<.$.!#00+<.4!3+!$-,!G+$!#6+-3!W!4#A8(!P+3&1,%!
<#8!D+?.4!+3&.$!3&#,!8C+$#41:!$+3#31+,8!+G!3&.!$&+!83#%.!.?.$A!G.<!&$(!R&.$D#00A/!3&.!3.0.8:+C.!:&#D6.$!<#8!D#,#%.4!
#8! ,+$D#0c! #1$! :+,4131+,1,%! 1,! 3&.! 4#A! 3+! >..C! 3&.! 3.DC.$#3-$.! :0+8.! 3+! 3&.! 3<101%&3! +C.,1,%! 3.DC.$#3-$./! <13&! 3&.!
3.0.8:+C.!G+00+<1,%!#D61.,3!4-$1,%!3&.!,1%&3(!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=GI
!
R&.!3+C!C#,.0!+G!Q1%(!\Z!8&+<8!3&.!.GG.:3!+G!$&+!$+3#31+,8!+,!3&.!3&$..!%$+-C!9!41#0!%#-%.8!`D.#8-$1,%!FW!<13&!$.8C.:3!3+!
FYa(!B.$1+41:!81%,#08!`Q1%(!\Zc!3+Ca!<.$.!G+-,4/!#$181,%!G$+D!$&+!83#%.!$+3#31+,(!R<+!C-08.8!1,!Q1%(!\Z!:+$$.8C+,4!3+!+,.!
:A:0.!+G!3&.!$&+!83#%.!G$+D!Z+!3+!\ZZ+/!3+!5\ZZ+/!#,4!6#:>!3+!Z+(!2!G-$3&.$!$.D#$>#60.!G.#3-$.!18!3&#3!3&.!%#-%.!#3!W!+g:0+:>!
`:.,3$#0!4#8&.4!01,.a!4+.8!,+3!#CC.#$!3+!C#$31:1C#3.!1,!3&.!D+31+,!8&+<,!6A!3&.!+3&.$!3<+!%#-%.8!`-CC.$!#,4!0+<.$!8+014!
01,.8a(! R&.! 0+<.$! C#,.0! +G! Q1%(! \Z! 8&+<8! <&#3! &#CC.,8! +?.$! #! 0+,%.$! C.$1+4! +G! 31D.! #,4! <13&! 3.DC.$#3-$.! ?#$1#31+,!
1,4-:.4!6A!:+,3$+001,%!3&.!#1$!:+,4131+,1,%(!2%#1,/!3&.!W!+g:0+:>!%#-%.!4+.8!,+3!C#$31:1C#3.!1,!3&.!D+31+,!8&+<,!6A!3&.!
+3&.$! 3<+! 4-$1,%! 3&.! $&+! $+3#31+,8/! 6-3! 13! 4+.8! 8&+<! 8-44.,! I-DC8! `I-83! 6.G+$.! ^VcZZa/! #CC#$.,30A! 4-.! 3+! 3&.! $&+!
D+?.D.,3(! R&.8.! .GG.:38! $#18.! 8.$1+-8! :+,:.$,8! #6+-3! 3&.! +C3+D.:&#,1:#0! 1,3.%$13A! #,4! 83#61013A! +G! 3&.! 8A83.D(! h,!
C#$31:-0#$/!$.G.$$1,%!6#:>!3+!Q1%(!V/!#,4!$.:#001,%!3&#3!3&.!E2;!18!6+03.4!3+!3&.!6+33+D!+G!3&.!PNE!3&$+-%&!138!1,3.$G#:.!
$1,%!`8..!Q1%8(!V!#,4!Ua/!3&.!+,0A!<#A!3&#3!$&+!$+3#31+,8!:#,!#GG.:3!FY!#,4!FW!18!G+$!83$.88.8!3+!6.!3$#,8D133.4!4+<,!3&.!
814.8!+G!3&.!PNE!G$+D!3&.!$&+!83#%./!3&$+-%&!3&.!1,3.$G#:.!#,4!1,3+!3&.!-CC.$!E2;!8-6583$-:3-$.!#,4!D1$$+$!8-CC+$38(!
5.200
20
15
0.100
0.000
0.00
1.00
1.60
2.00
2.50
3.00
400
3.60
4.00
5.60
6.00
!
lime (daysi
Q1%(!\\(!F+,13+$1,%!+G!FW!#,4!FY!6A!T!41#0!%#-%.8!+?.$!#!W!4#A!1,3.$?#0!#8!4.8:$16.4!1,!E.:31+,![(V(!
F+,13+$1,%! +G! 3&.! >1,4! 8&+<,! 1,! Q1%(! \Z! <#8! :+,4-:3.4! G+$! G1?.! 4#A8(! R&.! G-00! $.8-038! #$.! C0+33.4! 1,! Q1%(! \\(! N&+!
$+3#31+,8! <.$.! .K.:-3.4! 4-$1,%! +::#81+,#0! ?18138! 3+! 3&.! 3.0.8:+C.! 6A! +,.! +G! -8! 4-$1,%! 3&18! 31D./! #,4! #$.! +6?1+-8! #8!
e8C1>.8g!1,!3&.!C0+3(!R&.!3+C!:-$?.!18!3&.!+-3C-3!G$+D!#,!-,:#016$#3.4!3&.$D+:+-C0.!1,!3&.!C#A0+#4!,.K3!3+!3&.!E2;(!)?.$!
3&.!W!4#A8!3&.!3.DC.$#3-$.!4.:01,.4!6A!#6+-3!\Z!4.%!;!`#8!1,41:#3.4!6A!3&.!$+-%&!8:#0.!#3!$1%&3a(!R&.!%#-%.8!G$+D!.#:&!+G!
3&.! %$+-C8! 4.G1,.4! #6+?.! #$.! 1,41:#3.4! 6A! 3&.! 0#6.0! :0+8.83! 3+! 3&.! :+$$.8C+,41,%! :-$?.(! R&.! D+83! +6?1+-8! $.8-03! 18! #!
:+$$.0#31+,!6.3<..,!3.DC.$#3-$.!#,4!3&.!D+?.D.,38!+G!3&.!%#-%.8!1,!%$+-C8!2!#,4!9(!h,!3&.8.!8#D.!3<+!%$+-C8/!3&.!W!
+g:0+:>!%#-%.8!`01%&3.$!8&#4.4!8+014!01,.a!8&+<!3&.!8#D.!#,+D#0+-8!6.&#?1+-$!,+3.4!C$.?1+-80A(!R&.$.!#$.!41GG.$.,31#0!
<#,4.$1,%8!+G!:+,814.$#60.!81M.!`-C!3+!WZ!D1:$+,8a!6.3<..,!3&.!%#-%.8!+G!#!%1?.,!%$+-C(!!
0220
Bolts re-tightened
01
0.170
00
c5
0.125
T___
1iT
rt
Al
0.075
E
B
0.025
C=
Al
+9i
Cl
______________
0
Al
05
00
Cl
-0.025
Al
1
-0.075
—11:
AS
Al
01
0
0
05
05
Bolts slackened
-0.125
0.40
0.40
0.00
0.00
0.60
Time (days)
0.60
0.70
!
Q1%(!\^(!F+,13+$1,%!+G!FW!#,4!FY!6A!T!41#0!%#-%.8!4-$1,%!80#:>.,1,%!+G!D+83!+G!3&.!E2;5PNE!D+-,31,%!6+038(!E..!3.K3(!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=GS
!
23!3&.!.,4!+G!3&.!D+,13+$1,%!C.$1+4!8&+<,!1,!Q1%(!\\/!#,!.KC.$1D.,3!3+!4.583$.88!3&.!E2;5PNE!1,3.$G#:.!`8..!Q1%(!Va!<#8!
:+,4-:3.4(!R&18!1,3.$G#:.!18!C++$0A!4.81%,.4c!3&.!E2;!1,3.$G#:.!$1,%!18!83..0(!R&.!$1,%!3+!<&1:&!13!6+038!+,!3&.!PNE!814.!18!
D#4.!+G!#0-D1,1-D/!<&1:&!1,!3-$,!18!6+,4.4!1,3+!3&.!:#$6+,!G16$.!+G!3&.!PNE(!R&.8.!#$.!#00!D#3.$1#08!<13&!8-683#,31#00A!
41GG.$.,3!;R'8!#,4!3&.$D#0!83$.88.8!#$.!1,.?13#60.(!^\!6+038!8.:-$.!3&.!E2;!3+!3&.!PNE!#,4!1,!3&.!.KC.$1D.,3/!#00!6-3!_!
<.$.!80#:>.,.4(!R&.!_!31%&3!6+038!<.$.!0+:#3.4!1,!V!%$+-C8!+G!^/!8C#:.4!#C#$3!6A!\^Z+(!R&.!6.&#?1+-$!+G!3&.!41#0!%#-%.8!
4-$1,%!3&18!C$+:.4-$.!18!C0+33.4!1,!Q1%(!\^(!hDD.41#3.0A!.?14.,3!#$.!?.$A!$#C14!I-DC8!1,!3&.!%#-%.8!#8!8++,!#8!3&.!6+038!
<.$.! 80#:>.,.4! <13&! #! 0#$%.! 1,:$.#8.! 1,! 8C$.#4(! Q-$3&.$D+$./! 8+D.! %#-%.8! `2\/! 9\/! 2T/! 9Ta! 414! ,+3! $.3-$,! 3+! 3&.1$!
83#$31,%!?#0-.8!#3!3&.!.,4!<&.,!3&.!6+038!<.$.!$.531%&3.,.4(!R&.8.!8ADC3+D8!1,41:#3.!#!3&.$D#00A!83$.88.4!1,3.$G#:.(!
!
cB! 0GMM3;T$3DF$<ED<5G0CED0$
E27R! 18! :+,3.,41,%! <13&! 8.$1+-8! hl! C$+60.D8/! :&1.G0A! #! G+:-8! %$#41.,3! #8! <.00! #8! #831%D#318D! #,4! +3&.$! #6.$$#31+,8(!
F#I+$! C$+%$.88! 1,! 3&.! 41#%,+818! &#8! 6..,! D#4.(! O.! &#?.! 8+! G#$! C$+?.,! 3&#3! ,.13&.$! 3&.! 1,83$-D.,38! ,+$! 3&.! C$1D#$A!
D1$$+$!#$.!$.8C+,8160.(!),!3&.!+3&.$!&#,4/!3&.!8C&.$1:#0!#6.$$#31+,!:+$$.:3+$!18!$.8C+,8160.(!2!0#$%.!$#41#0!D18#01%,D.,3!
+G!E2;!D1$$+$8!FY!#,4d+$!FW!`Z(\+!1,!31Cd3103!+$!Z(W!DD!1,!4.:.,3$.a!18!$.b-1$.4(!E-683#,31#0!?#$1#61013A!1,!hl!&#8!#08+!
6..,! G+-,4/! #!8D#00! C#$3! +G!<&1:&! #$18.8! G$+D! D.:&#,1:#0! 83$.88.8! G$+D! 3&.! PNE! 6.1,%! 3$#,8D133.4! 3&$+-%&! 3&.! E2;5
PNE!1,3.$G#:./!#,4!3&.!D+$.!81%,1G1:#,3!:+DC+,.,3!G$+D!3&.$D#00A51,4-:.4!83$.88.8!1,!3&.!1,3.$G#:.(!R&.!G-,4#D.,3#0!
:#-8.!18!3&.!-8.!+G!3&.$D#00A!1,:+DC#3160.!D#3.$1#08!1,!3&.!E2;!D+-,31,%!1,3.$G#:.(!2!4.81%,!G+$!#!$.C0#:.D.,3!1,3.$G#:./!
-81,%!#!>1,.D#31:!D+-,3!+$!G0.K-$.8/!&#8!#0$.#4A!6.%-,/!#,4!8&+-04!6.!1,83#00.4!1,!3&.!0#83!b-#$3.$!+G!^ZZ[(!h3!18!01>.0A!
3&#3! $.5#01%,D.,3! +G! 3&.! +C31:8! <100! 6.! ,..4.4! #3! 3&#3! 83#%.(! ".G1,1,%! &+<! 3+! 4+! 3&18! .GG1:1.,30A! 18! 3&.! ,.K3! D#I+$!
:&#00.,%.(!!
;JLJ;JD<J0$
t\u
t^u
tVu
tYu
tWu
t_u
tUu
t[u
tTu
t\Zu
t\\u
E3+61./!N(/!F.1$1,%/!=(!#,4!9-:>0.A/!"(2(@(/!j".81%,!+G!3&.!E+-3&.$,!2G$1:#,!7#$%.!R.0.8:+C.!`E27Raf/!B$+:(!EBh'!
QOOR/!VWW5V_^!`^ZZZa!
)g"+,+%&-./!"(/!j;+$$.:31+,!+G!8C&.$1:#0!#6.$$#31+,!1,!3&.!E+-3&.$,!2G$1:#,!7#$%.!R.0.8:+C.!`E27Raf/!B$+:(!EBh'!
QOOR/!V_V5VU^!`^ZZZa!
F.1$1,%/!=(H(/!9-:>0.A/!"(2(@(/!7+D6.$%/!F(!#,4!E3+61./!N(/!jE+-3&.$,!2G$1:#,!7#$%.!R.0.8:+C.!`E27Ra!C$+I.:3/!
C$+%$.88!#,4!83#3-8!#G3.$!^!A.#$8f/!B$+:(!EBh'!QeR^/!\\5^W!`^ZZVa!
E<#3/!2(/!)g"+,+%&-./!"(/!E<1.%.$8/!=(/!P.0/!7(!#,4!9-:>0.A/!"(2(@(/!jR&.!+C31:#0!4.81%,!+G!3&.!E+-3&.$,!2G$1:#,!
7#$%.!R.0.8:+C.f/!B$+:(!EBh'!QeR^/!W_Y5WUW!`^ZZVa!
F.1$1,%/!=(H(!#,4!9-:>0.A/!"(2(@(/!jE+-3&.$,!2G$1:#,!7#$%.!R.0.8:+C.!`E27Ra!C$+I.:3/!C$+%$.88!#,4!83#3-8!#G3.$!Y!
A.#$8f/!B$+:(!EBh'!YQec/!!WT^5_Z^!`^ZZYa!
9-:>0.A/! "(2(@(/! @.#$,8&#</! =(9(/! P+$481.:>/! L(@(! #,4! )g"+,+%&-./! "(/! jE:1.,:.! 4$1?.$8! #,4! G1$83! %.,.$#31+,!
1,83$-D.,3#31+,!G+$!3&.!E+-3&.$,!2G$1:#,!7#$%.!R.0.8:+C.!`E27Raf/!B$+:(!EBh'!QeRQ/!^_Y5^UW!`^ZZVa!
9-:>0.A/! "(2(@(/! ;+33$.00/! B(7(/! P+$481.:>/! L(@(! #,4! )g"+,+%&-./! "(/! jR&.! G1$835%.,.$#31+,! 1,83$-D.,38! G+$! 3&.!
E+-3&.$,!2G$1:#,!7#$%.!R.0.8:+C.!`E27Raf/!B$+:!EBh'!YQcH/!!_Z5UY!`^ZZYa!
9-:>0.A/! "(2(@(/! E<#$3/! H(B(! #,4! F.1$1,%/! =(H(/! j;+DC0.31+,! #,4! :+DD1881+,1,%! +G! 3&.! E+-3&.$,! 2G$1:#,! 7#$%.!
R.0.8:+C.f/!B$+:(!EBh'!PHP^/!W_Y5WUW!`^ZZVa!
9-:>0.A/!"(2(@(/!9-$%./!'(9(/!;+33$.00/!B(7(/!P+$481.:>/!L(@(/!)g"+,+%&-./!"(!#,4!O1001#D8/!R(9(!jE3#3-8!+G!3&.!
E+-3&.$,!2G$1:#,!7#$%.!R.0.8:+C.!`E27Ra!G1$835%.,.$#31+,!1,83$-D.,38f/!B$+:(!EBh'!PHPc/!_^_TZ2!`^ZZ_a!
)g"+,+%&-./!"(!.3!#0(/!jQ1$83!8:1.,:.!<13&!3&.!E+-3&.$,!2G$1:#,!7#$%.!R.0.8:+C.c!C..$1,%!#3!3&.!#::$.31,%!C+0#$!:#C8!
+G!3&.!.:01C81,%!C+0#$!E"EE!=Z\WWYV(YZkZZ^[ZU(^f/!F+,(!P+3(!N(!#83$(!E+:/!R^H/!\W\5\_^!`^ZZ_a!
)g"+,+%&-./!"(/! '(! 9#-.$D.183.$/! '(/! ;#$3.$/! "(9(/! '?#,8/! H(B(/!L++$38/!O(B(/!)g;+,,+$/! =(/! )8D#,/! Q(/!?#,! 4.$!
F.$<./! E(! #,4! 91%.0+</! 9(;(! jE27Rh;2Fc! 2! vZ(WF! 2:b-18131+,! ;#D.$#c! '?.$A! 91%! R.0.8:+C.! E&+-04! @#?.!
),.f/!B$+:(!EBh'!QeQA/!Y_W5YU_!`^ZZVa!
),4.A 4B C)!< D40A EFGH EFGHGI=GT