What to do when duties have been imposed? How to Avoid Circumvention and

What to do when duties
have been imposed?
How to Avoid
Circumvention and
Fraud to Customs Origin
Before the Delegation of the Ministry of Industry
and Trade of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam
24 June 2014
www.mcguirewoods.com
Meet McGuireWoods: Our speakers today
Yves Melin
ymelin@mcguirewoods.com
+32 2 629 42 26
Rue des Colonies 56 b.3
1000 Brussels
2 | McGuireWoods
Yongqing Bao
ybao@mcguirewoods.com
+32 2 629 42 24
www.mcguirewoods.com
Overview
• Why do circumvention and customs fraud matter to Vietnamese
Industries?
• What is circumvention?
• Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework
• Customs fraud and circumvention in the EU Common Customs
Code
• What should you do?
3 | McGuireWoods
Why do circumvention and customs fraud
matter to Vietnamese Industries?
• Application of anti-circumvention rules by the European Commission
under the TDI framework
– Investigation of nine months
– Customs registration of imports and possible retroactive imposition of
anti-dumping/anti-subsidy duties
– Extension of residual highest duty initially applied to other countries
– Disturbance of export to the EU onwards
• Application of rules of origin by OLAF and EU customs authorities
– Investigation of customs fraud
– Retroactive collection of customs duties due on imports in the past three
years + interests of the duties unpaid
– Likely fines on top of the duties
– Possible criminal prosecution in certain Member States
• Conclusion: Enormous legal and commercial exposure
4 | McGuireWoods
What is circumvention?
• Duties (including anti-dumping/anti-subsidy duties) are calculated
and imposed on certain product from certain origin (country).
• Two key elements:
– Does it fall within the product scope subject to duty ? – Classification
– Does it originate in the country/region/exporter subject to duty? – Rules
of origin
• Ways of duty evasion/circumvention
– Modifying the product to make it fall out of the scope subject to duty
– Change the product origin by:
• Consignment via third countries – Paperwork only (including Certificate of
Origin or Preferential origin), e.g. Chinese product transhipped via Vietnam
• Import via the supplier benefiting the lowest duty level
• Processing in a third country – Assembly / screw-driving operation in Vietnam
– Where to draw the line?
5 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (1)
• Legislative history
– First introduction into the EU anti-dumping legal framework in 1984
(Article 13(10) of Regulation 2176/84, replaced by Regulation 2423/88))
– Found to be GATT incompatible in 1988 by GATT panel
– No consensus on the rules in Uruguay Round – No regulation of
circumvention in WTO ADA
– Statement in the final Act of Uruguay Round negotiation to refer to
further discussion under the framework of Committee on Anti-dumping
Practices
– Interpreted by the EU (and the US) as allowing WTO members to deal
with the problem unilaterally, pending the multilateral solution
– Currently applicable legal framework – Article 13 of AD Regulation
1225/2009 and Article 23 of AS Regulation 597/2009
6 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (2)
• Conditions for applying anti-circumvention measures – Article 13.1
of the AD Regulation (Article 23.3 of the AS Regulation)
– Change in the trade pattern between Vietnam and the EU or between
individual companies in Vietnam and the EU
– Practice, process or work without sufficient due cause or economic
justification other than the imposition of the duty
– Evidence of injury or that the remedial effects of the duty are being
undermined in terms of the prices and/or quantities of the like product
– Evidence of dumping in relation to the normal values previously
established for the like product
7 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (3)
• Practice, process or work:
– Slight modification of the product concerned to make it fall out of the
scope subject to the duty, provided that the modification does not alter
its essential characteristics
– Consignment of the product subject to duty via Vietnam
– Reorganisation of patterns and channels of sales in Vietnam in order to
eventually have their products exported to the EU through producers
benefiting from a lower duty level
– Assembly operation in the EU or Vietnam
8 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (4)
• Definition of assembly under anti-circumvention rules – Article 13.2
of the AD Regulation
– Timing of the start/substantial increase of the operation
– Numerical threshold:
• Not less than 60% of value of the parts imported from the country subject to
duty
• Less than 25% of added value to the parts
– Undermines remedial effect of the duty and evidence of dumping
9 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (5)
• Anti-circumvention investigation procedure
– Initiation ex officio or at the request of Member State or interested party
(complainant)
– Immediate customs registration of import since initiation
– Investigation and decision making process are similar to normal TDI
investigations
– Investigation lasts for nine months
– Outcome of investigation: change of product scope / extension of duty
to Vietnam / termination
– Possible application for exemption from registration or extension of duty
by genuine Vietnamese producer (Article 13.4 of the AD Regulation and
Articles 23.5 and 23.6 of the AS Regulation)
• Affiliation to the producers already subject to duty (e.g. Chinese invested) is
relevant but not decisive
10 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (6)
• Anti-circumvention cases per year
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
• Total 49 cases since 1995
11 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (7)
• Anti-circumvention cases per original country subject to duty
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Belarus
12 | McGuireWoods
Brazil
China
India
Japan
Russia
Singapore
Taiwan
Ukraine
USA
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (8)
• Anti-circumvention cases per type of circumvention practice
1
8
5
1
Slightly modified
Wrong declaration of product
65
Assembly operation in the EU
Export through lowest duty company
Consignment through third country
13 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (9)
• Anti-circumvention cases per third country of consignment
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
14 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (10)
• Anti-circumvention cases per products
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Ring binder mechanism – 4 times
Tube or pipe fittings of iron or steel – 4 times
Open mesh fabrics of glass fibres – 4 times
Steel ropes and cables – 3 times
Bicycles – 3 times
Magnetic disks – Twice
Molybdenum wires – Twice
Zinc oxides – Twice
Coumarin – Twice
Gas-fuelled, non-refillable pocket flint lighters – Twice
PET film – Twice
Silicon - Twice
15 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (11)
• Outcome of anti-circumvention investigations
Extension of duty or modifying
product scope
Termination of investigation
without measure
16 | McGuireWoods
Anti-circumvention under the EU TDI framework (12)
• Anti-circumvention cases against Vietnam
– Zinc oxides from China, consigned from Vietnam (2002)
– Ring binder mechanisms from China, consigned from Vietnam (2003)
– Integrated electronic compact fluorescent lamps (CFL-i) from China,
consigned from Vietnam (2004)
– Gas-fuelled, non-fillable pocket flint lighters from China, consigned from
Vietnam (2012)
17 | McGuireWoods
Customs fraud and circumvention in the EU
Common Customs Code (1)
• What is the imported product ? – Product classification
• What is the origin of product ? – Economic nationality of product
• Definition of origin ? – Article 23 and 24 of CCC
– Wholly obtained or produced in one country – Article 23
– Production involving more than one country – Article 24
• Where the product undergoes the last, substantial, economically justified
processing or working in an undertaking equipped for that purpose and
resulting in the manufacture of a new product or representing an important
stage of manufacture
• List rules published on the Commission’s website – Non-binding nature
– Change of tariff heading
– 45% added value
– Specific manufacturing stage
18 | McGuireWoods
Customs fraud and circumvention in the EU
Common Customs Code (2)
• Non-preferential origin and Preferential origin (e.g. GSP)
– Non-preferential origin determines whether anti-dumping/antisubsidy duties are applicable
– Preferential origin decides whether preferential duty level is
applicable
– Attention: a product can aquire preferential origin (e.g., GSP), but
not acquire non-preferential origin  the anti-dumping/anti-subsidy
duties will apply
• Customs fraud and circumvention behaviors
– Deliberate wrong classification of products
– Erroneous declaration of origin (non-preferential and/or preferential)
– Undervaluation of imported products
19 | McGuireWoods
Customs fraud and circumvention in the EU
Common Customs Code (3)
• Live examples of enforcement by OLAF and Member States
customs authorities
– Colour TV of false origin declaration (2001) – duty recovery of 18 million
EUR
– Chinese bicycles declared as Philippines origin (2003) – duty recovery
of 1.5 million EUR + criminal prosecution
– CFL-i lamp transhipped or assembled in third countries (2004) – 13
non-EU countries involved – duty recovery of 30 million EUR + criminal
prosecution
– Ring binder mechanism consigned from three non-EU countries (2004)
– duty recovery of 6 million EUR + criminal prosecution
– Fake Certificate of Origin over Chinese made textiles imported from
Bangladesh (2005) – involving hundreds of importers spread in almost
every Member State across the EU – duty recovery of around 30 million
EUR + criminal prosecution
– Hand pallet trucks imported from Thailand (2008) – duty recovery of
20 | McGuireWoods
more than 20 million EUR + criminal prosecution
What should you do?
• A priori – monitoring and alert system
– When issuing Certificate of origin / Certificate of preferential origin
– Regularly checking trade statistics concerning products that are
subject to TDI measures
• A posteriori – cooperate in anti-circumvention investigations
– Encourage genuine Vietnamese producers to request exemption
during and after the investigation
– Customs cooperation
21 | McGuireWoods
Questions or Comments?
Yves Melin
ymelin@mcguirewoods.com
+32 2 629 42 26
Rue des Colonies 56 b.3
1000 Brussels
22 | McGuireWoods
Yongqing Bao
ybao@mcguirewoods.com
+32 2 629 42 24
www.mcguirewoods.com