Daniel B. Oerther Environmental Research Center
Transcription
Daniel B. Oerther Environmental Research Center
Daniel B. Oerther Environmental Research Center Daniel.Oerther@mst.edu 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Sustainable development Biofuels Obesity epidemic Population and density Membrane (bio)reactors Sustainable Development • 2 billion people living on $2/day need basic needs to be met – Maslow’s hierarchy of needs (air, water, food, shelter) • Technology ideas: – Indoor cook stove, play pump, climate change resistant crops, ISSB Biofuels • Food plus energy from crops = use more water and generate more polluted runoff • Treatment of disperse, nutrient rich, waste streams how to recycle nutrients (esp phosphorus) http://www.ecofriend.org/images/ebio_4773.jpg Obesity Epidemic • 1 in 3 adults (and children) are obese • Costs $5,000/person/yr • Attributed to poor diet and lack of exercise • May also be due to ‘obesogens’ http://www.getamericafit.org/images/american-obesity-trends.gif Population and Density • 50% of humanity lives in cities (80% of USA) • Opportunities to reduce impacts through scale • Danger of sprawl creating worse impacts – Urban planning lies between architectural engineering and civil engineering Membrane (bio)reactors • Fabrication (functionality) • Applications (water, water, everywhere…) • Anti fouling US Army Engineer School Directorate of Environmental Integration Our mission: We are Army’s Proponent for operational environmental issues. Bob Danner Director Contingency operating bases produce all waste streams common to any small municipality but with no pre-existing infrastructure. Environmental and Sustainability Solid Waste Per soldier waste generation: in a 2003 study 15.8 #/day and in a 2006 study 18.2 #/day This shows a 15% increase in all studied waste streams over a 3 year period between studies. In March of 2010 long term use of Open Air Burn Pits was halted by the Under Secretary of Defense. Unfortunately while the intent of this policy change is laudable, we currently don’t have the means to provide Innovative Landfill designs, Waste to Energy Systems, and Water reuse technologies to the operational army. More research and development needed to bring technologically superior but operationally simple systems into the Army to solve these issues. Deployable Wastewater Treatment systems Soldiers produced about 2 pounds per day of sewage sludge Human waste must be treated to avoid disease causing conditions in the environment. Systems must be deployable, expandable and easy to operate/maintain. Our concerns: 1. We need a more responsive process to get innovative technologies into the operational Army. 2. We need to integrate sustainable systems of systems into the operational Army Culture. 3. We need to practice better waste management techniques to reduce, reuse, and recycle wastes to reduce the need for technical treatment options. Department of Engineering Management and Systems Engineering, S&T Contact: Suzanna Long, longsuz@mst.edu 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Sustainability as a Sociotechnical System Civil Infrastructure Systems Sustainability and the Smart Grid Alternative Energy Sources Sustainability and Change Resistance Sustainability as a Sociotechnical System Component • What is Sustainability? No good definition exists! • Must consider the human elements as well as the technical • What quantitative and qualitative metrics are most useful in determining sustainability? • EMSE Faculty: Long, Grasman Civil Infrastructure Systems • Cradle to grave logistics systems • Capacity modeling • Energy reduction • Supply/demand as part of the supply chain • EMSE Faculty: Long, Grasman, Cudney, Corns, Gosavi, Guardiola Sustainability and the Smart Grid • The future smart grid will encompass all of the following features: – Flexibility – fulfilling customer’s needs while responding to changes and challenges ahead; – Accessibility – granting connection access to all network users, particularly for renewable power sources and high efficiency local generation; – Reliability – assuring and improving security and quality of supply; – Economy – providing the best value through innovation, energy efficient management, competition, and regulation. • EMSE Faculty: Long, Corns, Grasman Alternative Energy Sources • Supply chain logistics • Energy performance and life cycle costing • Market-based technology innovation • Lessons learned from nonrenewable consumption patterns • EMSE Faculty: Grasman, Corns, Long Problem of Change Resistance • Humans Fear Change because of: – Loss of control – Loss of power – Loss the familiar • Many technology-focused projects fail because change environment is not properly managed! • EMSE Faculty: Long U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Brenda Groskinsky Science Policy Advisor and Office of Research & Development Science Liaison for Region 7 901 N. 5th St. Kansas City, KS 66101 (913) 551-7188 groskinsky.brenda@epa.gov U.S. EPA Office of Research & Development Research Program Realigned w/ EPA Administrator’s Priorities •* Air/Climate Energy * Sustainable Communities * Safer Products for a Sustainable World •* Safe and Sustainable Water Resources * Human Health Risk Assessment * Homeland Security Research Examples of U.S. EPA Region 7 Challenges and Opportunities U.S. EPA Region 7 Overview •Workable water quality solutions to deal w/ hypoxia and other surface water quality issues • Sustainable practices for agriculture • Biofuels and Biogas • Economically feasible technology and built environment solutions for improved energy efficiency • Small Community Environmental and Human Health Issues • Emergency Response • Lead Remediation Joel G. Burken Environmental Research Center Burken@mst.edu 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Sustainable development Environmental impacts of Δ infrastructure Integrated environmental infrastructure Energy of environmental processes Implementation and change impacts Sustainable development • 2 billion people living on $2/day need basic needs to be met – Maslow’s hierarchy of needs (air, water, food, shelter) • As these (and billions to come) strive to advance the development will impact the earth (fact) and the direct impact to human health will be substantial… but should be minimized. • Engineering & Science and Education for maximizing social benefit and minimizing impact Big Δ infrastructure = New Environmental Issues • • • • • • • Process contaminants Fugitive contaminants Water Footprint Carbon Footprint Nitrogen Footprint ??? Nano-contaminants Nuclear, rare earths http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ ToxicPhlebotinum Integrated environmental infrastructure • LCA on social design and natural treatment • Design systems with the treatment integrated in the infrastructure • Green buildings = healthy and efficient Environment’s energy • Cognizant energy efficiency and minimization in environmental systems • Life Cycle Energy in design of env. infrastructure • Generation of energy in some environmental systems Implementation and change impacts • Change is going to be more at personal decision levels. • Citizen engineers and scientists • Smart societal choices will always beat smart engineering choices to fix later… Collaborative Interests Joe Engeln Assistant Director for Science and Technology Missouri’s Energy Future • Assessing new energy sources • Assessing environmental risks and benefits • Energy conservation • Carbon capture and sequestration Missouri’s Lead Legacy • • • • • Water pollution challenges Assessment techniques Impact assessment Remediation State and Federal Partners Emerging Contaminants • • • • Hormone disrupters or enhancers Nano-scale technologies Assessing risks and impacts Outside current regulatory authority Environmental Techniques • • • • Innovative remediation techniques Vapor intrusion Long Term Stewardship Sampling, analysis, impact studies Community Assistance • Engineering studies for small communities • Fast assessments – risk-based approach Joon-Ho Choi Architectural Engineering Program choij@mst.edu 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Lesson from Campus Buildings Passive (Design) System Geothermal Energy Systems Integration Ecological Footprint Campus Building as a Research Tool • • • • • • • Building sizes System types Orientations Building materials Utility bill records Sub-meters Which one is the best or worst? Passive Design Strategies Daylighting Shading Night ventilation Solar heating Natural conditioning Solar heating Natural conditioning Geothermal Energy MO • MO: suitable for Geothermal Heat Pumps. • 40% to 70% less energy than conventional systems http://geotherma.blogspot.com/2008/08/geothermal-energy-companies-including.html Campus Ground as Power Plant Ball State University, IN • Saving $2 million a year in operating costs and replacing four aging coal-fired boilers. • 50% reduction in carbon footprint. • Heating and cooling 45 buildings cross 660 acre campus. Systems Integration Health • Systems integration to create win-win solutions Wellbeing Productivity Systems Integration Energy Resources Economy Environment – Increase quality of life within and outside buildings – Reduce resource requirements – Secure US competitiveness Ecological footprint • We need 5.3 planets to support us. • Campus footprint is much larger than a community. • Foot, trash, transportation, service items, electronic waste, etc. • Where to start for Green Campus? Traffic Management Systems Missouri University of Science & Technology Environmental Summit December 15, 2010 Luis Lopez Republic ITS, a Siemens Company LLopez@RepublicITS.com © Siemens 2010. All rights reserved. Overview •Motor Vehicles are the largest source of urban air pollution •Vehicles generate 3 billion pounds of air pollutants yearly •Inefficient traffic signals account for significant portion •Vehicle stops and acceleration •28% of U.S. GHG emissions •2.9 billions gallons of fuel © Siemens 2010. All rights reserved. Industry sector, Mobility division, US, Traffic Solutions Current State of Signalized Intersections •300,000 Traffic Signals in the U.S. •5 to 10 percent cause delays due to improper timing •Funding timing improvement projects •35-40% of Traffic Signals are still incandescent © Siemens 2010. All rights reserved. Industry sector, Mobility division, US, Traffic Solutions Research Topics •Consistent Preventative Maintenance •Real-Time Traffic Management Systems •Advanced Transportation Controllers •Bluetooth, GPS, Dedicated Short Range Communications, Ethernet •Energy Efficient (LED’s … © Siemens 2010. All rights reserved. Industry sector, Mobility division, US, Traffic Solutions Early Promising Results •Fulton County, Georgia – Adaptive Systems •Harris County, Texas – Bluetooth Technology •San Jose, California – Ethernet Access Devices •DeKalb, Georgia – Formalized Traffic Signal Preventative Maintenance Program •Plano, Texas – Preventative Maintenance •City of Alpharetta, Georgia – Traffic Signal Retiming •Nashville, Tennessee – Updated Signal Timing Plans © Siemens 2010. All rights reserved. Industry sector, Mobility division, US, Traffic Solutions Materials Related Environmental Research Topics Prof. Matt O’Keefe Department of Materials Science and Engineering And Graduate Center for Materials Research Hex Cr Replacements Prof. Bill Fahrenholtz, Prof. Matt O’Keefe Strategic Environmental Research and Development Agency - SONs every November pH and the presence of CrCC influence re-precipitation of Pr-species which provide corrosion protection Phosphate Glasses Prof. Dick Brow, Prof. Del Day Specialty optics, biomaterials and waste remediation are important applications for phosphate glasses Missouri S&T Approach Use Information About the Molecular-Level Structures of Glasses to Design New, Technologically Useful Compositions Recycling of Electronic Wastes Assistant Professor Lifeng Zhang Importance: Objectives: - Need for recycling due to its big amount; - Control the toxic emission during - New potential energy source by the pyrolysis; conversion of waste plastics into fuel; - Conversion of waste plastics - Economic motivation for recycling since (polymers) into oil; containing precious metals; - Recovery of precious metals. - Environmental issues to control the toxic Current NSF Support (2009-2012): components during recycling. Lifeng Zhang (zhanglife@mst.edu) CBET-0853458: Green Thermal Degradation of Used Printed Wiring 2.0x10 HBr Experiment Condition: Boards Heating rate: 20 C/min CaCO3 is Flow rate: 50ml/min Hold time: 120min 1.5x10 very efficient Gas type: Synthetic Air No chemical to control the Na2CO3 1.0x10 emission of NaOH toxic gases, NaHCO3 Professors currently involved: such as HBr. 5.0x10 CaCO -10 o Intensity [A] -10 -10 -11 3 0.0 0 25 50 75 100 125 150 175 200 Time [min] Prof. Lifeng Zhang (Materials) Two Ph.D. students (Materials) Prof. Thomas Schuman (Chemistry) Prof. Glenn Morrison (Civil) Prof. Joel Burken (Civil) Recycling and Recovery of High Value Wastes Assistant Professor Lifeng Zhang Importance: Current Supports: - Shortage of raw material resources; Lifeng Zhang (zhanglife@mst.edu) - Environmental issues; 1) NSF: CBET-0853458: Green Thermal - Energy saving (Recycling only use 5% Degradation of Used Printed Wiring of energy of the primary production). Boards (2009-2012) Recycling and Recovery of: 2) DOE: DE-EE0000575: Development of - Solar cell silicon; Solar Grade Silicon (SOG-SI) Feedstock - Electronic wastes; by Recycling SOG-SI Wastes (2009- Aluminum scrap and dross; 2010) - Waste heats from molten slag; - More 10% scrap wastes Solar cell Silicon 40-50% slurry wastes 10% scrap wastes High temperature electromagnetic purification unit for the recovery of metal scraps at MSE: Primary Pb Production Doe Run to pay millions in fines; Operations at Herculaneum smelter to stop in 2013 Doe Run's new technology could end need for lead smelter THE FLUBOR® PROCESS - Engitec A new Hydrometallurgical-Electrochemical Approach to the Lead Minerals Cost Effective Low Environment Impact The “Environmental Revolution” is a “Social Revolution” 1. Advancements in Human Interface We need to “Discover” and “Re-Discover” 2. Innovation Based on Natural Systems 3 Words: Measure, Measure, Measure… Solar Flux… We GET 100-650 W/m2 We NEED: 0.5 W/m2 3. Analysis by Holistic Integrated Common Units 3 More Words: Transparency, Feedback, Improvement! STATE PROBLEM Metrics Are Not An End, But A Vehicle… FORMULATE HYPOTHESIS DESIGN EXPERIMENT MAKE OBSERVATIONS INTERPRET DATA DRAW CONCLUSIONS HYPOTHESIS ACCEPTED Metrics Inform Policy-Making… Policies Inform Implementation… Implementation is Measured… HYPOTHESIS REJECTED PEER REVIEW 4. Actions Built on the Scientific Method - Benjamin Franklin - Albert Einstein 2 WATER 3 ATMOSPHERE 4 MATERIALS 5 ENERGY 6 FOOD 7 SHELTER 8 TRANSPORT 9 COMMUNITY 10 CULTURE 11 HEALTH 12 EDUCATION 13 GOVERNANCE 14 COMMERCE 15 VALUE Capital Budget + Operating Budget = Capitoperational Budget - Life Cycle Costing Owner Alliancing Contracts Engineer ECOSTRUCTURE Lawyer “The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results” 1 FiT = Fully Integrated ThInkIng Creating “New” and “Strange” Partnerships PM Anthro - biolo - gitect Engi - psycho - linguist Socio - physi - conomist 5. Implementation of Integrated Methodologies Eric Farrow Environmental Engineering Undergraduate efarrow24@gmail.com 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Sustainable (re)development Energy with morals Solid waste management Sustainable agriculture Obesity epidemic Sustainable (re)development • Cities crumbling from the inside out – 450,000 brownfields in the U.S. (EPA) – Over 4,300 acres vacant in St. Louis (stlouis.missouri.org) • Research: How do we reuse existing structures? http://goo.gl/t0mP7 Energy with Morals “Using energy without abusing the planet” http://goo.gl/VyBpj http://goo.gl/Avkkj http://goo.gl/je1HM http://goo.gl/kyAd4 • "[T]he time has come to aggressively accelerate [the transition from fossil fuels.]” – Bill Mckibben • “The direction we are headed is sobering” – Eric Farrow • Research: (all of the above) engineering Solid Waste Management • Fact: There will be waste http://goo.gl/QZYld http://goo.gl/SL8wf – Average American generates 1600lbs/yr • Goal: Zero waste – 2020, San Francisco http://goo.gl/susuF http://goo.gl/8y4gC • Research: Economics and LCA’s. Sustainable food & agriculture • 1.9B lbs pesticides applied per year (USDA) • Animals intake 70% antibiotics used (UCS) • Research: http://goo.gl/6m5c4 http://goo.gl/LoML – True costs of cheap food (i.e. LCA); – Environmental impacts (i.e. nutrient loadings) Obesity on the rise http://goo.gl/viSlE http://goo.gl/IS59L http://goo.gl/RnRVE http://goo.gl/4zzUn • Ingredients and recipes, not factories and conveyors • Farms not factories • Research: How do we get “good food to good people”? FLW’s Five Environmental Research Opportunities 15 December 2010 Ms. Emily S. Brown Chief, Environmental Branch 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Lead Migration Integrated Composting Sediment Control Low Impact Development LEED Implementation We are the Army’s Home FLW’s Five Environmental Opportunities Lead Migration • Lead from live firing activities exists on active Ranges • Develop methods to prevent migration of lead from active firing Ranges for Ozark soils Source: The Guidon FLW’s Five Environmental Opportunities Integrated Composting • Four types of organic wastes; four management methods – treated wastewater sludge – food service waste – yard waste – bio-remediated soil • Impacts landuse, inefficient, costly, lost potential for nutrient synergy • Develop integrated and comprehensive approach FLW’s Five Environmental Opportunities Sediment Control • Highly erodible soils – Intensive, costly maintenance during construction and post construction – impacts water quality • Develop non-toxic, sediment stabilizer for construction site sediment runoff control which also enhances post construction Erosion control and re-vegetation FLW’s Five Environmental Opportunities Low Impact Development • Integrating LID is challenging due to high clay content of Ozark soils and large temperature fluctuations • Identify or develop technologies suitable for Ozark for clay soils and weather (permeable pavements, bio-retention etc.) Source: Environmental Protection Agency FLW’s Five Environmental Opportunities LEED Implementation • LEED Silver is the minimum standard for Army construction • Identify the most effective means to achieve Silver, Gold, and Platinum LEED Energy and Atmosphere credits for the Ozarks Source: General Services Administration Geological Sciences and Engineering Environmental Research “5 Big Ideas” Environmental Summit Dec 15, 2010 Geological Sciences and Engineering Earth Energy Environment The following five slides are not an exhaustive list of GSE environmental work…clean water, hazardous waste cleanup, others are not included… CO2 Sequestration Rock Characterization Caprock Integrity, Modeling Feasibility Wronk… Bai DunnNorman Eckert Nygaard Dept of Energy Hydraulic Fracturing Essential for Shale Gas Development Water use for fracturing fluids? Is fracturing safe? Fracture modeling… Global Climate Change Dr. Franca Oboh-Ikuenobe is conducting research in global climate Australia and Egypt for the change ultimate goal of understanding global climate change from the geological record Dr. Franca Natural Hazards Assessment, Mitigation • The narrow fringe comprising 17 percent of the contiguous U.S. land area is home to more than half of the nation's population. • Between the years 1980 and 2003, population in coastal counties increased by 33 million people, or 28%. • In 2003, 23 of the 25 most densely populated counties were in coastal areas. Earthquake/hurricane risks on infrastructure: Pipelines, power/data transmission, above and under ground fuel tanks, transportation infrastructure • By 2008, over half of the American population lives within 50 miles of the coast Space Resources Sustainability requires: – reduce usage rate, and – increase source volume – draw raw material needs from entire Solar System Reduce environmental effects of Human Civilization – increasing population – increasing expectations Research: – space-based solar power – space manufacturing Research: – ET ore formation mechanisms – adapt mining and processing to ET environments Planetary Security Research: – preventive mining Leslie Gertsch, Space Resources Laboratory, Rock Mechanics and Explosives Research Center Missouri University of Science and Technology Environmental Summit Paragon Business Solutions, Inc. • Management Consulting firm specializing in assisting clients with implementing environmental management systems (EMS) and for assisting Department of Defense clients with using their EMS to reach the DoD sustainability goals. Executive Orders 13514 and 13423 Performance Area E.O. 13514 E.O. 13423 Greenhouse Gas Inventory & Reduction X Energy Efficiency/Renewable Energy X X Water Resource Efficiency X X Pollution Prevention/Waste Reduction X X Sustainable Communities X Sustainable Building/Construction X X Sustainable Acquisition X X Electronics Stewardship X X Environmental Management X X Sustainability Goals • • • • • Reduce the use of fossil fuel – Reduce energy intensity – 18.3% of energy consumed by facilities is produced or procured from renewable sources by 2020 – Use of petroleum products by vehicle fleets Water – Reduce potable, industrial and irrigation water consumption. – Development maintains pre-development hydrology. Reduce GHG Emissions Solid waste minimized and optimally managed – Diversion – Landfill gas reclaimed Sustainable Practices – Procurement – LEED Buildings Department of Biological Sciences Robert S. Aronstam aronstam@mst.edu 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Loss of Biodiversity C, N, P, H2O management Quality of Life Nanomaterial toxicity Synthetic Biology Management of C, N, P, water • C from atmosphere or pipes to photosynthesis or storage – Biofuels, C sequestration • N and P not going downstream – Dead zones, ag losses • Water from floods to aquifers – Water wars Loss of Biodiversity Causes: • Habitat destruction • Invasive species • Climate change Consequences • Ecosystem services • Economic impact • Loss of bioactive substances Quality of Life (QOL) and sustainability explicit goal • environment • physical and mental health • education • recreation and leisure time • social belonging Nanomaterial toxicity • 2015: $1 trillion • Occupational exposure • End user toxicity – Inhalational – Dermal – Intestinal Synthetic Biology • iGEM team • Application of engineering concepts to biological problems • Cellular (genetic) engineering – Sensors – Fuels – Remediation Kevin S. Griesemer, PE, LEED AP, CPMP g&w engineering corporation KGriesemer@GandWEngineering.com www.gandwengineering.com We specialize in energy related and functional building systems, providing consulting services and solutions for new and existing facilities. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. LEED & Sustainability Energy Audits Commissioning Retro-Commissioning Energy & Resource Conservation LEED & Sustainability • • • • • • • LEED 2009 (v3) Sustainable Sites (26) Water Efficiency (10) Energy and Atmosphere (35) Materials and Resources (14) Indoor Environmental Quality (15) Innovation in Design (6) Regional Priority (4) – Certified 40–49 points – Silver 50–59 points – Gold 60–79 points – Platinum 80 points and above • • Alternative Energy Highly Efficient HVAC & Lighting Systems Energy audits What are the Types of Commercial Energy Audits? – Preliminary Energy Use Analysis – ASHRAE Level 1 – Walk Through Analysis – ASHRAE Level 2 – Energy Survey and Analysis – ASHRAE Level 3 – Detailed Analysis of Capital Intensive Modifications Commissioning Commissioning is a systematic, forensic approach to quality assurance. The building commissioning process provides documented confirmation that building systems function according to criteria set forth in the project documents to satisfy the owner’s operational needs. Retro-commissioning Existing Building Commissioning is a systematic process for investigating, analyzing, and optimizing the performance of building systems through the identification and implementation of low/no cost and capital intensive Facility Improvement Measures and ensuring their continued performance over time. Energy & resource conservation • Key is Awareness and Education – Green building associations - About 601,000 results – Energy conservation associations About 10,700,000 results USGBC, Green Globes, Energy Star, etc. • ASHRAE 90.1 Energy Standard for Buildings Except Low-Rise Residential Buildings • ASHREA 189.1 Standard for the Design of High-Performance Green Buildings (30% greater than 90.1) • Keep the implementation of practical, functional applications in harmony with rational educated decisions regarding conservation of resources. LED Lighting Application Mariesa L. Crow Energy Research & Development Center crow@mst.edu 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Microgrids/Renewable energy/SmartGrid Carbon Sequestration Synthetic Fuels/Biomass to Fuel Plug-in Vehicles Energy Storage SmartGrid Carbon Capture and Sequestration • Reduce the buildup of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere • Worldwide CO2 emissions from human activity have increased to annual emissions of more than 33 billion tons today Synthetic Fuels Would allow America to reduce foreign oil imports by tapping its own domestic energy resources to produce fuel for transportation and national defense Synthetic fuels are produced from coal, natural gas or biomass and provide a clear, clean liquid for use primarily as diesel or jet fuel Plug-in Vehicles Stochastic Resources and Loads Transportation is almost completely powered by oil - 60% of which comes from foreign sources. Adoption of plug-in hybrids will transfer the majority of our miles driven to electricity. Renewable Resources Exhaustible Resources Mobility/Energy Demands If all vehicles were plug-in hybrids we would cut our oil needs by 55%, nearly enough to eliminate foreign sources altogether. PHEVs Power Generation Storage & Distribution Energy Storage Suzan D. Gonder, CHMM Managing Principal Environmental Works, Inc. suzan@environmentalworks.com Remediation Trends 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Traditional soil remediation Traditional groundwater remediation Current Considerations In situ vs. ex situ Sustainable but cost-effective remedial alternatives Soil Remediation •Dig and haul is still widely used •Fast, low tech •Easy to demonstrate compliance (sampling) •Immediate removal of source ►►may help groundwater contamination •Accepted by state and public •The down side to dig and haul: •Process can leave a big carbon footprint •Generates waste, creates potential future cleanup •Diesel powered equipment •May disrupt site operations •Not precise Groundwater Remediation •Pump and Treat: •Fairly simple process •Contaminant is being removed from environment •Maintain hydraulic control •Still readily accepted by regulators/public •Downside: •Costly O&M: utility costs plus labor •Must deal with water management •Reach a point where its no longer effective •Long term process: volume you pump out compared to the amount of contaminant removed may be small •Rebound is an issue if system is off Current Considerations •Risk Based Corrective Action •Huge change in how sites are cleaned up •How clean is clean? •Maximum extent practicable •Future land use •Institutional controls to prevent exposure •Air Issues •Vapor Intrusion into buildings = consequence of leaving residual contamination behind •Hot issue with regulators – significance may be overrated •How do you evaluate and mitigate this hazard? Current Considerations •In situ vs. ex situ •Ex situ •In Situ •Current technologies •Biotreament, Chemical treatment •Thermal •Soil stabilization •Downside •Difficult to control outcome •Limited by media type •Difficult to evaluate success •Can be expensive •Regulators/public may not readily accept the method •May require permitting •May disrupt site operations Current Considerations Key to future remediation success = Sustainable but cost effective methods •Many are able to develop great ideas but must be cost effective •Move towards more “green” technologies •Better use of resources •Reuse/reduce/recycle •Buy in from regulators and the public Any Questions? Suzan D. Gonder, CHMM Managing Principal Environmental Works, Inc. suzan@environmentalworks.com Environmental Opportunities in Materials Manufacturing Kent Peaslee – MSE Department kpeaslee@mst.edu 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Unconventional CO2 Sequestration Revolutionize Manufacturing Lean, Mean and Green Steel Renewable Carbon for Manufacturing Design based Life Cycle Assessment Unconventional CO2 Sequestration – Works for any emission of carbon dioxide – Simpler than end of pipe capture of CO2 – May be most economic and non-intrusive approach to CO2 sequestration – Use unconventional sequestration agents • Manufacturing slag and residues • Cement kiln dust System for carbon capture from air. http://www.nextenergynews.com/news1/next-energy-news3.31c.html Revolutionize Manufacturing • Fully continuous and automated operation – Zero waste • All co-products 1610 conventional batch operation 2990 Energy Savings: - less time and less heating in EAF - no tapping into colder ladle - no transport - no holding 1630 steel temperature (ºC) • Many industries • need improvement proposed continuous steelmaking EAF 2960 2930 2900 1590 tap & transport 1570 2870 LMF refining 2840 EAF 1550 transport & sitting on turret 3-step refining 1530 tundish mold 1510 0 2810 tundish 2780 mold 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 200 time (minutes) 2750 steel temperature (ºF) – Reduced water use – Reduce air emissions – Capture energy Lean, Mean and Green Steel (light-weight, high-strength and green steel development) • Lower density steels • Higher strength steels • Recycled content increasing • Combination of lower density & higher strength = lighter weight parts with improved performance – Better gas mileage & safety Renewable Carbon for Manufacturing • Manufacturing uses coal/oil – No good source of C in renewable sources – What if we developed renewable coke? Design Based Life Cycle Assessment • Complex design must include LCA – – – – – 1022 Steel Rolled Bumper Replacement using LCA Bumper has mechanical function - rescaled to design strength = volume & mass change = change in energy in materials, manufacturing & use Graph constructed using Granta CES Software Materials Manufacturing Transportation Use Disposal