Tube Dilution Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing: Efficacy of a Microtechnique Applicable to Diagnostic

Tube Dilution Antimicrobial
Susceptibility Testing:
Efficacy of a Microtechnique
Applicable to Diagnostic
Laboratories
Lawrence A. Chitwood
Appl. Microbiol. 1969, 17(5):707.
These include:
CONTENT ALERTS
Receive: RSS Feeds, eTOCs, free email
alerts (when new articles cite this article),
more»
Information about commercial reprint orders: http://journals.asm.org/site/misc/reprints.xhtml
To subscribe to to another ASM Journal go to: http://journals.asm.org/site/subscriptions/
Downloaded from http://aem.asm.org/ on October 21, 2014 by guest
Updated information and services can be
found at:
http://aem.asm.org/content/17/5/707
MICROBIOLOGY, May 1969, p. 707-709
Copyright @ 1969 American Society for Microbiology
APPLI
Vol. 17, No. 5
Printed in U.S.A.
Tube Dilution Antimicrobial Susceptibility Testing:
Efficacy of a Microtechnique Applicable
to Diagnostic Laboratories
LAWRENCE A. CHITWOOD
Department of Pediatrics, Children's Memorial Hospital, University of Oklahoma Medical Center, Oklahoma City,
Oklahoma 73104
A microtechnique for determining antibiotic susceptibilities by the serial dilution
method was evaluated in a clinical diagnostic microbiology laboratory. As compared with the standard tube method, an agreement of 94% was achieved for determining minimal inhibitory concentration with i one tube dilution as the criterion
of comparison. The experience with this system suggests that it could easily be incorporated into diagnostic laboratories as a routine procedure.
weighed on an analytical balance, diluted in glassdistilled water to a concentration of 1,000 Ag/mlI
sterile filtered, and stored as 1 ml of frozen stock.
Macromehd. For each antibiotic examined, 0.2 ml
Of 1,000 pg/ml was added to 1.6 ml of Brain Heart
Infusion broth (BHI), and nine serial twofold dilutions were made in 0.9 ml of broth. Subsequently,
0.1 ml of a 0I dilution of an 18-hr broth culture of
the organism was added to each tube. One tube without antibiotic served as the organism control. After
18 hr of aerobic incubation at 37 C, tubes were examined for evidence of turbidity or sediment. The
tube exhibiting no visible growth and containing the
least amount of antibiotic was considered the minimal
inhibitory concentration (MIC).
Micromethod. Disposable transparent V plates,
(Cooke Engineering Co. or Linbro Chemical Co.),
containing 96 cups arranged in 8 rows of 12 cups,
were sterilized by being rinsed in ethyl alcohol,
drained in an inverted position overnight, and placed
under a germicidal ultraviolet source for 1 hr. Working solutions of antibiotics were prepared weekly
by diluting the frozen stock to 200 pug per ml of
BHI. Each week a disposable plate containing 12
different antibiotics was prepared. Each cup, in a
vertical row of 12 cups, was filled with a different
antibiotic and stored at 4 C. At the end of a week,
the working stock standards were discarded and
fresh solutions were prepared. For the microtitration
procedure, 0.025 ml of BHI was added to each well
with a calibrated pipette dropper. A heat-sterilized,
0.025-mil multi-microdilutor was utilized for diluting
12 antibiotics simultaneously (Fig. 1), by placing
MATERIALS AND METHODS
the microdiluter in the plate containing the working
Stock standards of antibiotics generously provided stock of antibiotics and transferring to the first row
by pharmaceutical companies, including cephalothin, of the titration plate, mixing, and transferring to
ampicillin, colistin, neomycin, tetracycline, kanamycin, subsequent rows until the titration was complete.
polymyxin B, streptomycin, chloramphenicol, gent- The complete twofold serial titration of 8 dilutions
amicin, cephaloridine, linocomycin, erythromycin, of 12 different antibiotics usually took less than
penicillin G, carbenicillin, and cloxacillin, were 1 min. An inoculum of 0.025 ml of an 18-hr BHI
707
In recent years, the increasing availability and
types of antimicrobial agents have added appreciably to the problems confronting the diagnostic
laboratory. In many clinical situations, the tube
dilution method of determining antimicrobial
susceptibilities is generally recognized as providing more accurate and useful information as c6mpared with results obtained by the disc method.
However, from a practical point of view, cost,
time, and personnel factors frequently require
that the tube dilution method be used only with
isolates from the problem patient.
A number of papers (1, 4, 9) have appeared
which question disc antibiotic susceptibility testing procedures. Discrepancies frequently arise
when one compares the results obtained with the
disc and tube dilution methods.
These studies were undertaken to evaluate the
feasibility of an in vitro susceptibility testing
technique in a clinical laboratory which is reproducible, accurate, and reliable, but lacks the
disadvantages of being time-consumingexpensive,
and tedious.
For this purpose, the Microtiter (Cooke
Engineering Co.) system, as used routinely in
many serological laboratories (10), was investigated as a possibility to resolve the inherent
difficulties in the standard accepted method.
Downloaded from http://aem.asm.org/ on October 21, 2014 by guest
Received for publication 7 March 1969
708
APPL. MICROBIOL.
CHITWOOD
broth culture diluted 10 was added to each cup.
After inoculation, the plate was covered with transparent sealing tape, a small pin-hole was made at
the center of each cup, and the plate was incubated
at 37 C for 18 hr. The end point of the titration was
determined by examining the plate, with transmitted
light against a dark background, for growth in the
first cup (50 jg/ml) and each succeeding cup (Fig. 2).
TABLE 1. Comparative evaluation of antibiotic
susceptibility testing with standard
macromethod-and micromethod
RESULTS
No.
agreeing ±examined
one tube
dilution/no.
1
2
3
55/71 (78%)
90/113 (89%)
168/179 (94%)
compared, a correlation of 78 % was
achieved initially (series 1). However, after technical familiarization with the technique was
established (series 2), a correlation of 89% was
noted. Subsequently, after the technique was
firmly established (5 months), a correlation of
94% was achieved between the two methods.
were
DISCUSSION
Variabilities (4, 7, 9, 11) encountered in antibiotic disc susceptibility testing have been attributed to diffusibility of the antibiotics, size and
distribution of the inoculum, moisture content of
the agar, type of medium used, interpretation of
narrow zones, failure to set the disc properly, and
other variables. The multidisc technique, two
discs, or the use of a single high- or low-concentration disc are additional variations of the technique which tend to cause confusion in the interpretation of results from a clinical laboratory.
The serial tube method of susceptibility testing
is considered the common method of reference,
but the tedious nature of the macromethod has
prevented universal usage on routine isolates.
FIG. 1. Simultaneous dilution of 12 antibiotics with
The obvious advantage of determining discrete
multi-microdilutor.
end point susceptibilities which can be correlated
with therapeutic levels obtainable in the patient is
that the physician is afforded a more sophisticated
~ lo'A
0i;
i_
_s;SlingtR:
approach in the management of bacterial infec-o
tions. Although this approach is generally recognized as ideal, tube dilution susceptibility testing usually is relegated to the research oriented
laboratory. An initial modification of the macrotechnique utilizing spot depression plates (3) was
reported from this laboratory in 1965. Although
the spot plate compared favorably with the tube
technique, the time required and the glassware
used remained significant problems to be resolved. Subsequently, commercially available
microtitration equipment and disposable plates
became available and provided an alternate
FIG. 2. Completed antimicrobial susceptibility methodology which could overcome inherent
titration of an organism against 12 antibiotics. Row H problems in manual pipetting procedures.
These data and other reports (8; L. A. Chitwod,
contains 50 ,gg of antibiotic per ml, row G contains 25
S. Med. J. 60: 1358; J. D. MacLowry and H. H.
,ug of antibiotic per ml, etc.
K''w'''0~ts "S^w.If
Downloaded from http://aem.asm.org/ on October 21, 2014 by guest
Isolates of various gram-negative rods, including Pseudomonas, Salmonella, Shigella, Klebsiella,
Enterobacter, and Escherichia, gram-positive
organisms such as coagulase-negative and
coagulase-positive Staphylococcus, and other
rapidly growing organisms were examined against
a variety of antibiotics. As noted in Table 1, if
one accepts -+ one tube dilution as the criterion
for comparison between methods, an excellent
correlation was achieved. When the methods
Series
VOL. 17, 1969
ANTIMICROBIAL SUSCEPTIBILITY TESTING
micotechnique (6).
Occasionally, spurious results do occur which
have been attributed invariably to a mixed culture
for the inoculum; however, by maintaining a log
of tube dilution susceptibilities by organism, such
errors are detected easily.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The author acknowledges the fine technical assistance provided by Vi Patnode during these studies.
LITERATURE CITED
1. Bauer, A. W., C. E. Roberts, and W. M. Kirby. 1960. Single
disc versus multiple disc and plate dilution techniques for
antibiotic sensitivity testing. Antibiot. Ann.-1959, p.
574-580.
2. Bauer, A. W., M. M. Kirby, J. C. Sherris, and M. Turck.
1966. Antibiotic susceptibility testing by a standardized
single disc method. Amer. J. Clin. Pathol. 45:493-496.
3. Beargie, R. A., E. C. Bracken, and H. D. Riley, Jr. 1965.
Micromethod (spot-plate) determination of in vitro antibiotic susceptibility. Appl. Microbiol. 13:279-280.
4. Branch, A., D. H. Starkey, and E. E. Power. 1959. The international situation with regard to the use of discs for antibiotic sensitivity tests. Antibiot. Ann.-1958, p. 833-835.
5. Branch, A., D. H. Starkey, and E. E. Power. 1965. Significance of the occurrence of nonreacting discs in antibioticsensitivity tests. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother.-1964,
p. 395-399.
6. Goss, W. A., and E. B. Cimijotti. 1968. Evaluation of an
automatic diluting device for microbiological applications.
Appl. Microbiol. 16:1414-1416.
7. Greenberg, L., K. M. Fitzpatrick, and A. Branch. 1957. The
status of antibiotic disc in Canada. Can. Med. Ass. J.
76:194-198.
8. Harwick, H. J., P. Weiss, and R. F. Fekety. 1968. Application of microtitration techniques to bacteriostatic and
bactericidal antibiotic susceptibility testing. J. Lab. Clin.
Med. 72:511-516.
9. Petersdorf, R. G., and J. C. Sherris. 1965. Methods and
significance of in vitro testing of bacterial sensitivity to
drugs. Amer. J. Med. 39:766-779.
10. Sever, J. L. 1962. Application of a micro technique to viral
and serological investigations. J. Immunol. 88:320-329.
11. Truant, J. P., J. E. Bolin, and J. Mullins. 1965. Evaluation of
susceptibility testing procedures w.t"th single and multiple
antibiotic discs. Antimicrob. Agents Cherother.-1964,
p. 384-394.
Downloaded from http://aem.asm.org/ on October 21, 2014 by guest
Larsh, Intersci. Conf. Antimicrob. Agents
Chemother., 8th, 1968, New York) suggest that
an excellent correlation exists between the microand macrotechniques and that the microtechnique
can be incorporated into a routine diagnostic
laboratory.
Tke most time-consuming procedure of the
technique is the addition of the diluent to each
cup. However, with the use of an automatic
dispensing instrument (Cooke Engineering Co.),
automation of the technique becomes a possibility.
Decreased activity of antibiotics, usually by
two tubes, was noted when the 10-3 dilution of
the test organism was inadvertantly allowed to
remain at room temperature for several hours before being added to the antibiotics. Obviously,
the size of the inoculum requires standardization.
Although a 103 dilution was empirically established for most rapidly growing organisms, a 1O-2
dilution was used for more fastidious organisms
such as beta-and alpha-hemolytic streptococci and
pneumonococci. In addition, with these and similar organisms, it was found advantageous to add
5 % fresh sheep blood as an indicator of growth.
Triphenyl tetrazolium chloride in the media has
been used as a visible indicator of growth in the
709