LIO and the TCMU Userspace Passthrough: The Best of Both Worlds

LIO and the TCMU Userspace
Passthrough:
The Best of Both Worlds
Andy Grover <agrover@redhat.com>
@iamagrover
March 11, 2015
1
LIO AND TCMU
What is LIO?
Multi-protocol in-kernel SCSI target
2
LIO AND TCMU
Multi-protocol in-kernel SCSI target
Unlike other targets like IET, tgt, and SCST,
LIO is entirely kernel code.
3
LIO AND TCMU
targetcli
rtslib
Configuration
User
Kernel
Fabrics
/sys/kernel/config/target
iscsi
tcm_fc
block
LIO core
file
pscsi
iSCSI commands
4
Backstores
LIO AND TCMU
/dev/vg0/vol0
disk.img
/dev/sdc
Why add userspace command handling?
●
Enable wider variety of backstores without
kernel code
●
●
●
●
5
Clustered network storage filesystems like
Ceph, GlusterFS, & other things that have
shared libraries available
File formats beyond .img, such as qcow2 &
vmdk for more interesting features &
compatibility
SCSI devices beyond mass storage
Enable experimentation just like FUSE did for
filesystems
LIO AND TCMU
Userspace handling challenges: perf
6
●
I/O latency
●
I/O throughput
●
Parallelism within a dev (OoO cmd completion)
●
Parallelism across devs, we're good.
LIO AND TCMU
Userspace handling challenges: usability
7
●
Configuration as simple as existing backstores
●
Userspace daemon failure
●
Userspace daemon activation/restart
●
Balance ultimate flexibility with common use
●
Avoid “multiple personalities”
●
Reasonable resource usage
LIO AND TCMU
SCSI Command processing
cmd handling daemon
targetcli
rtslib
Configuration
uio0
uio1
User
Kernel
Fabrics
/sys/kernel/config/target
iscsi
tcm_fc
tcm-user
block
LIO core
file
pscsi
iSCSI commands
8
Backstores
LIO AND TCMU
!!
W
W
E
E
NN
/dev/vg0/vol0
disk.img
/dev/sdc
User/Kernel Communication
Shared Memory Region Layout
cmd handling daemon
(not to scale)
Mailbox
Mailbox
cmdr_off
cmdr_size
cmd_head
●
●
dev
add/remove
(netlink)
●
read (wait for cmd)
write (cmds done)
mmap (get SMR)
●
read to get
configuration
cmd_tail
Command
CommandRing
Ring
cmd_entry
opcode
/sys/class/uio/uio0
uio0
...
/dev/uio0
iovec[]
Data
DataArea
Area
...
in/out data
tcm-user
from LIO core
9
LIO AND TCMU
tcm-user merged in 3.18
●
●
●
10
Initial patch as simple as possible
Performance tuning not done, BUT an interface
flexible enough to not block likely perf
optimization strategies
Acceptance enabled phase 2: userspace
usability pieces
LIO AND TCMU
Performance Opportunities for Later
●
Larger vmalloc()ed shared mem region
●
-> Demand-allocate pages to avoid bloat
●
●
Complete commands out of order
●
●
●
11
Must handle data area fragmentation
Fabrics copy into already-mapped pages
●
●
Block size == PAGE_SIZE preferred
Just moves the cache misses?
Fabrics don't have per-lun device queues
anyway. Just IB reimplemented poorly?
Userspace busywait on ring cmd_head
LIO AND TCMU
Our user-kernel API ended up flexible,
but fraught with danger!
●
Ring operations easy to mess up
●
Make every handler write daemon boilerplate?
●
And support Netlink?
●
And maybe D-Bus???
12
LIO AND TCMU
tcmu-runner: A standard handler daemon
●
Handle the messy ring bits
●
Expose a C plugin API
●
●
Implement library routines for common handler
code, e.g. mandatory SCSI commands
Permissively licensed: Apache 2.0
●
●
13
Doubles as sample code for do-it-yourself-ers
Needed a prototype daemon in any case
LIO AND TCMU
tape
targetcli
rtslib
vmdk
mmc
smc
tcmu-runner
Configuration
uio0
glfs
!!
W
W
NNEE
User
uio1
Kernel
Fabrics
/sys/kernel/config/target
iscsi
tcm_fc
tcm-user
block
LIO core
file
pscsi
iSCSI commands
14
Backstores
LIO AND TCMU
/dev/vg0/vol0
disk.img
/dev/sdc
Handlers Need Config Info
●
●
●
●
All configuration should still be through
standard LIO mechanisms (i.e. targetcli)
User backstore create includes a URL-like
“configstring” that gives handler and per-device
handler-specific stuf
This is published in uio sysfs, and netlink
add_device message
Also has info to allow going from uio dev back
to matching LIO backstore
●
15
Handler needs attribs, block size, etc.
LIO AND TCMU
Config tools need Info on Handlers Too!
●
●
●
●
●
16
Users should call “backstores/foo create x y z”
not “backstores/user <configstring>”
targetcli needs param and help strings for xyz
Verify backstore params are correct before
creating the device
Must be loosely coupled – no hard dependencies
on targetcli or tcmu-handler
Solution: D-Bus!
LIO AND TCMU
!!
W
W
E
E
NN
DBus
targetcli
rtslib
tape
vmdk
mmc
smc
glfs
tcmu-runner
Configuration
uio0
User
uio1
Kernel
Fabrics
/sys/kernel/config/target
iscsi
tcm_fc
tcm-user
block
LIO core
file
pscsi
iSCSI commands
17
Backstores
LIO AND TCMU
/dev/vg0/vol0
disk.img
/dev/sdc
The QEMU Question
●
QEMU has great support for many image
formats and other backstores
●
Can we reuse or integrate somehow?
●
How?
●
●
●
18
Build qemu handler code separately and
integrate as a tcmu-runner handler?
Extend qemu to implement TCMU directly, and
possibly also enable it to configure LIO exports?
Deferred for now
LIO AND TCMU
Getting Involved
●
Give feedback!
●
●
●
●
19
agrover@redhat.com, target-devel@vger.kernel.org
Check out tcmu-runner:
https://github.com/agrover/tcmu-runner and its included
sample handlers.
●
Use github PRs and issue tracking.
●
Much help needed, esp. QEMU hackers!
Start doing some TCMU performance benchmarking
Start thinking of interesting device types, userspace
libraries to use, or weird things to do with a SCSI
command sandbox
LIO AND TCMU
Thanks!
Questions?
20
LIO AND TCMU
lsmcli (libstoragemgmt)
targetcli
Remote
Local
targetd
rtslib
liblvm
tcmu-runner
User
Kernel
/sys/kernel/config/target
Fabrics
iscsi
tcm_fc
tcm-user
block
LIO core
file
pscsi
ISCSI commands
21
LIO AND TCMU
!!
W
W
NNEE
/dev/vg0/vol0
disk.img
/dev/sdc
User/Kernel Communication
Shared Memory Region Layout
(not to scale)
tcmu-runner
Mailbox
Mailbox
cmdr_off
cmdr_size
cmd_head
●
●
●
read (wait for cmd)
write (cmds done)
mmap (get SMR)
●
read to get
configuration
cmd_tail
Command
CommandRing
Ring
cmd_entry
opcode
/sys/class/uio/uio0
uio0
...
/dev/uio0
iovec[]
Data
DataArea
Area
...
in/out data
tcm-user
from LIO core
22
LIO AND TCMU
SCSI
A set of standards for physically connecting and
transferring data between computers and
peripheral devices*
* http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCSI
23
LIO AND TCMU
SCSI target
Initiator sends commands,
Target handles them
24
LIO AND TCMU
Multi-protocol SCSI target
SCSI commands & data can be sent over many
types of physical links and protocols. e.g:
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
25
SCSI Parallel Interface (original)
iSCSI (over TCP/IP)
SAS (over SATA cables)
Fibre Channel (over FCP)
FCoE (over Ethernet)
SRP (over Infiniband)
SBP-2 (over Firewire)
LIO AND TCMU
tgtadm
Configuration
libglfs
tgtd
!!
W
W
NNEE
librbd
User
iSCSI commands
from initiator
Backed by local files
or block devices
disk.img
26
LIO AND TCMU
Kernel
/dev/vg0/vol0
gg
n
i
n
i !
m
m
o
CCo oooonn!
SS
others
qcow2 vmdk
librbd
libglfs
vdi
rbd*
glfs*
qemu-lio-tcmu
tcmu-runner
User
Kernel
/sys/kernel/config/target
Fabrics
iscsi
tcm_fc
tcm-user
block
LIO core
file
pscsi
ISCSI commands
27
LIO AND TCMU
/dev/vg0/vol0
disk.img
/dev/sdc