INTRODUCTION - Cisco Contracts for Public Sector
Transcription
INTRODUCTION - Cisco Contracts for Public Sector
White Paper INTRODUCTION Are Inflexible Contracts Locking you into Outdated Technologies? In today’s public sector world, the procurement of cutting edge IT can be much more difficult than it needs to be. Technology is changing fast and even outpacing the time allowed for procurement. The result? Obsolete contracts locking you into outdated technologies and with them, a host of lost opportunities for you, your team and those you serve. This is especially true with cloud computing. As emerging technologies, the cloud and related cloud services were often dismissed, or their wide ranging impacts not anticipated in the procurement process. So too were their benefits; from the security advantages of off-site storage and reduced maintenance costs, to the bottom line impacts of increased efficiency and added resilience. Today, unfortunately, your public sector organization may not be able to enjoy the benefits of cloud computing because you are hindered by inflexible contracts. As a result you might be spending time and money developing supplemental Requests for Proposals (RFPs) or Requests for Information (RFIs), or even re-issuing or withdrawing RFPs. Or perhaps you are interested in adding new innovations as your project is being built but contract limitations are preventing it. For public sector this inflexibility can result in project delays, cost impacts and the perception of inefficiency by team members and citizens. Are you Searching for Strategies that Increase Contract Flexibility? The rapidly changing face of technology can make your procurement efforts more difficult. So it is necessary to develop strategies that will make your contracts more adaptive to future innovations. Through this White Paper, public sector CIOs and procurement officers can gain a better understanding of how to develop strategies for flexible RFPs for Cloud Services. This paper discusses: How public sector should define cloud How the cloud may impact you and your public sector organization Characteristics of and working models for cloud computing in the public sector © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 1 of 18 Examples of successfully implemented public sector cloud strategies Steps you can take to increase and maximize the flexibility of your cloud contracts to ensure continued access to innovative cloud technologies Terms and conditions for cloud contracts that work to your advantage. WELCOME TO THE CLOUD How Should Public Sector Define Cloud? As with many technologies, a firm definition for cloud can be elusive, especially when the technology itself is an evolving one. Many accept the definition devised by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) in 2011. It concludes that “cloud computing is a model for enabling ubiquitous, convenient ondemand network access to a shared pool of configurable computing resources (e.g., networks, servers, storage, applications and services) that can be rapidly provisioned and released with minimal management effort or service provider interaction.” The NIST also defines five “essential characteristics” of the cloud. These are ondemand self-service, broad network access, resource pooling, rapid elasticity and measured service. However, a broader, more adaptable definition of cloud computing is needed for the public sector. The definition of cloud for public sector should also include “Anything as a Service” (XaaS) offerings. XaaS is experiencing tremendous growth and spanning key services such as Voice as a Service (VaaS), Collaboration as a Service (CaaS), Managed Security as a Service (MSaaS), Disaster Recovery as a Service (DRaaS) and more. In general, XaaS computing services allow the customer simple, recurring usage-based pricing. It is based on a flexible consumption model where the service provider offers and operates the services and charges for each, based on consumption. This can include services for collaboration, video conferencing and voice. At the end of the day, broadening the definition of cloud to include XaaS will ensure public sector organizations continue to benefit from innovative technologies as they emerge. How Cloud Impacts You Cloud computing marks a major shift in how technology will impact your organization. By changing the very foundation of information/ services delivery, use and storage the cloud is impacting almost every aspect of how we work. For public sector, this has had obvious and measurable benefits, including: Increased agility Faster development times for projects Improved scalability – both up and down Easier and more efficient deployment Operating expenses vs. capital expenditure © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 2 of 18 Is the Cloud Secure? Data breaches have become all too common today. As organizations move to the cloud, security is a major concern. What many organizations do not realize is that data security is just as vulnerable, or more, in their own data center as it is in the public cloud. To protect sensitive data and customers, organizations must be diligent in ensuring onpremise and off-premise technology solutions are fully protected. So when choosing a cloud platform, public sector organizations need to consider security as a critical component. To ensure the maximum security of your cloud, it should include the use of certified architecture which is validated and tested. In addition, your cloud architecture should be built with network features that allow appropriate critical data from the network to be used for advanced threat analytics. If possible, it should also allow a Security Operations team to have full visibility of and data on real-time network events. Example: Cloud Impacts in the Real World As one of the top 20 wired cities in America, the city of Charlotte, North Carolina is a good example of how the cloud can impact the public sector. Like most large cities, Charlotte must operate and maintain multiple contact centers, including a 3-1-1 center, transportation and road conditions hotline, crime reporting service, and a utility bill payment center – staffed by over 200 agents. Combined, they receive over 140,000 calls a month. By 2011 the voice system for the contract centers was nearing the end of its life. The city was then selected to host the 2012 Democratic National Convention, an event the current system could not handle. Charlotte had only 18 months to prepare for 50,000 delegates, press and visitors (in addition to their rapidly growing existing call volume). After researching their options, they decided to implement a new system based on the cloud. The city decided to use a hosted voice and contact center solution based in the cloud instead of an on-premises system for several key reasons. Hosting and maintaining their own contact center platform would require hiring and providing ongoing training for multiple people with different skill sets. This would be expensive and take time that they did not have. However, using a cloud provider gave them immediate access to trained professionals with the knowledge and experience they needed to meet their needs on time and within their budget. After asking industry analysts for their recommendations, the city of Charlotte decided they should get their cloud services from a certified cloud provider. The city already had a trusted relationship with one - NWN. Their certification required NWN to undergo a rigorous testing process, including third-party audit of its cloud services. Certification is just one way in which you can ensure you receive the best service, security and 24-hour customer support for your cloud solution. As a result, today the city of Charlotte’s contact center platform includes multiple elements in different locations, all working smoothly together: 200 contact center agents connected to a hosted service in NWN’s data center A contact center platform integrated with applications that are hosted both on-premises and in public © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 3 of 18 clouds, including call accounting software and call recording and screen capture software Approximately 100 other city employees receiving voice services through NWN’s NCloud Hosted Collaboration service Plans to connect other personnel to the hosted cloud solution as existing Centrex service contracts expire A completely integrated experience for people who call the contact centers Software recordings of every call, including agent’s typed entries, which can be used for training and complaint resolution. The Intercloud: A “Cloud of Clouds” Empowering Full Interoperability A prime consideration for public sector is the real need for full interoperability. Too often, cloud computing strategies are developed which gloss over or ignore the full impacts of this critical issue. When developing an approach, your organization should fully explore options that address interoperability. A solution that does so is the Intercloud, an approach created by Cisco. The Intercloud is Cisco’s “cloud of clouds” that includes its own data centers and those of its partners. It is built on secure certified architectures validated by Cisco. By connecting clouds you can gain greater flexibility in workload portability plus the ability to handle any workload on any hypervisor – while working with any public or private cloud. As part of a city-wide solution, this can empower you to manage LED street lighting and other power consumption plus enable safety and security solutions, Wi-Fi anywhere at any time and even real-time parking and traffic analysis. © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 4 of 18 Example: Enabling Interoperability in the Real World Connecting clouds is providing public sector organizations the opportunity to significantly increase collaboration. It is letting cities like Charlotte now experience full interoperability in a way that lets their IT staff focus on core activities instead of redundant maintenance tasks. By using an open and integrated cloud solution, Charlotte can now easily interact with other vendor systems hosted at any location. By procuring cloud services from a certified cloud provider, the city increases its options and enjoys a vast selection of features to choose from. This empowers the city with constantly updated servers hosting the latest features, improved workload portability and full interoperability. Plus, by running their connected clouds on certified architectures, the city of Charlotte benefits from a secure and reliable solution. Charlotte’s cloud solution is also continuing to lower costs long after the convention, with the city currently experiencing savings of over $100,000 a year. Their cloud also lends itself naturally to video collaboration which saves the city significant money that was once spent on travel to meetings and training sessions. Thanks to the innovations inherent in using a cloud of clouds approach, the city of Charlotte can now focus on delivering better services to their citizens instead of being providers of telecommunications services. Due to this success, the city has now decided to transition other systems to the solution. As old service and maintenance contracts expire, the ability of their cloud solution and certified cloud provider to easily expand will enable Charlotte to replace outdated technologies with innovative ones; improving services and lowering costs even more. Developing your Cloud Contract Approach Cloud Procurement: Best Practices Your cloud solution will connect with the world, so it needs to integrate and interact smoothly across a wide range of network components, applications and services that make up today’s public sector organizations. Plus, you will need the freedom to incorporate any future innovations. That’s why successful cloud strategies must be committed to an open, interoperable and standards-based approach. A critical part of achieving this is using Open Standards. This enables a true partner ecosystem made up of secure and interoperable cloud providers. By procuring services based on Open Standards, your organization can simplify provisioning and extend your IT resources and applications. Specifying open solutions where possible will help make sure your cloud strategy works smoothly for years to come. Include a Master Contract It is important that your cloud contract be well developed and flexible. It should provide you with the freedom to explore innovations as they develop. A master contract can help ensure this capability. A master contract contains mandatory base terms that are flexible enough to be applied to the end user requirement and offering. This can reduce unforeseen risks and result in significant benefits later. Using a master contract will make sure your © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 5 of 18 organization only selects cloud providers that meet its main requirements. Yet it will allow terms to adjust to the offering and end user agency as needed, to cover future innovation in cloud. To provide your organization the greatest flexibility, consider creating a master contract with terms requiring: Certified Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) architecture Portability and preservation (data and virtual machines) Workload portability (to and from service provider clouds for physical and virtual workloads) Cloud provider interoperability Any-to-any hypervisor Highly secure, scalable connectivity (to extend private cloud to service provider clouds) Single Point of Management and Control (for physical / virtual workloads across public / private clouds) Choice of cloud providers Secure Layer 2 network extension (from private data centers to provider cloud) A secure tunnel to connect all of the cloud virtual machines Monitoring and reporting of statistics of virtual machines in the cloud Collection of secure overlay related statistics Once the general terms are developed in the master contract, additional terms applicable to the specific cloud offering (IaaS, SaaS, XaaS), along with the technical and security requirements applicable to the end user requirements, will be put into the Request for Quote (RFQ) and Scope of Work (SOW) with the applicable contract terms. This model of a master contract with RFQ/SOW for custom terms allows for a flexible, scalable and customizable approach to developing an optimal contract for cloud services in general. By including these terms in the contract, your organization can minimize risk and vendor lock-in. Include Flexible Terms for Cloud Services An advantage can also be gained by including a flexible term approach to the different types of cloud services required by the end user agency. This term approach should extend to the type of data to be stored off-site. This can be done by having any service contract include applicable technical terms associated with the cloud offering and the data stored off-site. The terms should be developed by the end user agency. This will allow your organization to modify terms, per the service, while still providing the ability to acquire future cloud offerings that may need new, unknown terms. A cloud strategy should also address moving workloads efficiently from IT environments to the public cloud, and back again. Workload migration will have the greatest moment-by-moment impact on your cloud’s efficiency. So your solution will require an ability to support multiple hypervisors, infrastructure management platforms and cloud providers effectively. And as cloud evolves, natural connections to multiple clouds and cloud service providers will develop. Your strategy should be prepared for this evolution and able to maintain its performance level. Keep your Cloud Model Open to Innovation A cloud solution should also leave open the option of multiple approaches. This gives you the greatest freedom of choice and flexibility as your cloud solution evolves. For example, in addition to the five essential characteristics listed earlier, the NIST has defined two elements that make up the typical cloud model. They are: Traditional Cloud Service Models © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 6 of 18 Deployment Models However, the NIST definition of Traditional Cloud Service Models does not consider evolving technologies. This will eventually limit choice and flexibility. So an additional element should be added to the two: Emerging Cloud Services, specifically Anything as a Service (XaaS). Traditional Cloud Service Models Software as a Service (SaaS) - Allows you to use applications made available from the provider and running on a cloud infrastructure. SaaS provides easy access via various client devices through a thin client interface such as a web browser (e.g., web-based email). The consumer does not manage or control the underlying cloud infrastructure including network, servers, operating systems, storage or even individual application capabilities (with the possible exception of limited user-specific application configuration settings). Platform as a Service (PaaS) – Lets you deploy consumer-created or acquired applications onto the cloud infrastructure using programming languages and tools supported by the provider. This capability does not necessarily preclude the use of compatible programming languages, libraries, services and tools from other sources including third-party components. The consumer does not manage or control the underlying cloud infrastructure including network, servers, operating systems or storage, but has control over the deployed applications and possibly application hosting environment configurations. Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) - Allows provision processing, storage, networks and other fundamental computing resources where the consumer is able to deploy and run arbitrary software (including operating systems and applications). The consumer does not manage or control the underlying cloud infrastructure, but has control over operating systems; storage, deployed applications and possibly limited control of select networking components (e.g., host firewalls). Emerging Cloud Anything as a Service (XaaS) - Computing services that are delivered to the customer using a recurring, usagebased pricing model. Often termed utility pricing. It is a type of Flexible Consumption Model where the service provider owns and manages the assets, provides and operates services, and charges based on consumption. This can include services for collaboration, video conferencing and voice. Deployment Models The NIST suggest four deployment models for Cloud Computing: Private, Public, Community and Hybrid. However, the cloud is already evolving and so it should also include Managed Clouds. Private cloud - The cloud infrastructure is provisioned for exclusive use by a single organization comprising multiple consumers (e.g., business units). It may be owned, managed, and operated by the organization, a third party or some combination of them. And it may exist on or off premises. © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 7 of 18 Public cloud - The cloud infrastructure is provisioned for open use by the general public. It may be owned, managed, and operated by a business, academic, government organization or some combination of them. It exists on the premises of the cloud provider. Community cloud - The cloud infrastructure is provisioned for exclusive use by a specific community of consumers from organizations that have shared concerns (e.g., mission, security requirements, policy, and compliance considerations). It may be owned, managed, and operated by one or more of the organizations in the community, a third party, or some combination of them, and it may exist on or off premises. Hybrid cloud - The cloud infrastructure is a composition of two or more distinct cloud infrastructures (private, community or public) that remain unique entities but are bound together by standardized or proprietary technology that enables data and application portability (e.g., cloud bursting for load balancing between clouds). Managed Cloud – The cloud infrastructure is managed by a cloud provider. The provider’s engineers manage the customers’ computing, storage, networks and operating systems. They also manage the complex tools and application stacks that run on top of that infrastructure. Managed cloud allows each customer to choose which IT functions it wishes to manage in-house, while leaving all the rest to its service provider. Consider the Value of Cloud Brokers Managing your cloud solution can be time-consuming and costly. Keeping them collectively maintained and operational requires tremendous skill and resources. This is made more difficult in the public sector by increasingly restrictive IT budgets that are unable to keep up with the demands of acquiring new technologies. However, by utilizing the cloud of clouds approach and a cloud service provider your organization can overcome these barriers and enjoy a cloud solution that is secure, scalable, high performance and interoperable. It also enables your IT team to retain control of IT service delivery and management, if desired. This empowers your IT team to become the cloud service broker for its customers without surrendering control to a third-party cloud provider. © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 8 of 18 Figure 1. NIST Typical Role of Cloud Broker A certified cloud broker can help you set baseline requirements and can ensure that the cloud provider selected can meet your needs before you commit. This saves you time and frustration. In addition, using a certified cloud broker mitigates shadow computing that is so common today and can reduce risk associated with services that have not been inspected yet for compliance. Figure 1 above illustrates the typical role of a cloud broker model in the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Cloud Reference Architecture. Becoming the cloud broker removes a lot of the stress inherent in the service delivery process, especially when working with multiple cloud service providers. But most importantly, becoming the cloud broker makes your daily life a lot easier by reducing or removing the complexity of managing your cloud solution. THE CLOUD AND PUBLIC SECTOR What Does Public Sector Need from Cloud? In general, your public sector team should seek to fulfill three core needs as it develops its cloud services strategy: Virtual computing – Your cloud solution will need to be scalable, able to access virtualized computer processors, provide memory resources and instances, include local area network (LAN) and VM management plus other resource provisioning. Your virtual computing provider should have built-in flexibility regarding on-the-fly © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 9 of 18 capacity changes, hosting options and data centers. They should also allow you administrative control and an extensive, yet solid, network. Virtual storage – Your cloud solution will also need comprehensive, scalable and secure storage for your missioncritical applications. This should include the ability to scale storage service on an as-needed basis. It should have ondemand, fast, and reliable block storage. Your virtual storage provider should provide easy and automatic provisioning and management from a web-based portal as well. Virtual networking – Your cloud solution must be based on proven technologies and product lines, featuring OpenStack capabilities. It needs to provide your team the ability to create and manage private networks, support of advanced network service and provision load-balancing. Your team’s cloud services strategy should also focus on solutions that have these five basic personality traits: interoperability, easy workload migration, secure data, scalability and that are diverse enough to enable cloud brokering if needed. Types of Cloud Services Needed by Public Sector For your convenience, a list of primary cloud services often used by public sector is provided below. As mentioned earlier, you should also consider two additional services when developing your cloud strategy: Anything as a Service (XaaS) and Cloud Brokering. XaaS and Cloud Brokering are often overlooked or under anticipated. However, they offer public sector the greatest long-term opportunity. The primary cloud services highly valued by public sector consist of two categories: Cloud services and Managed Services. They include: Cloud Services: Collaboration Cloud Services Unified Communications as a Service (based on hosted collaboration services (HCS)) Contact Center as a Service (based on HCS) Video and TelePresence as a Service WebEx Infrastructure Cloud Services Managed Services: Infrastructure as a Service Software as a Service Desktop as a Service Disaster Recovery as a Service. Managed Services for Collaboration Managed Business Communications Services Managed Unified Contact Center Services Managed Business Video Services © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 10 of 18 Managed Services for Connectivity Managed Business Communications Services Managed Internet Protocol Trunking Services Managed Metro Ethernet Services Managed Multiprotocol Label Switching (MPLS) and Virtual Private Network (VPN) Services Managed Wi-Fi Data Services over Satellite Managed Load Balancing Managed Services for Data Center Managed Application Performance Management Services Managed Security Managed Firewall Services Managed Intrusion Prevention and Detection Services Managed Secure MPLS Services Advanced Threat Analytics. The Need for a Certified Cloud Service Provider and Solution Unfortunately, not all cloud providers and managed services are the same. There can be tremendous variations from one company to another. To make the best decision for your team, the provider you select should meet these three key benchmarks: Use of third-party audits to guarantee enterprise-class performance Use only validated architectures and open standards Meet strict industry requirements for hardware, software and processes (including SSAE 16, ISO 27001, ITIL). This can be done by selecting a provider that is certified. Certified cloud service providers are more than cloud providers: at Cisco they’re rigorously tested and certified, their capabilities are audited continuously and their scalability independently validated. This lets your organization directly benefit from integrated end-to-end security, validated architectures and high-level service-level agreements (SLAs) featuring 24-hour support, year round. Certified cloud solutions are also important. They are unique in that they are architected with no single point of failure. This enables a stringent SLA plus superior performance and reliability. Certified cloud platforms are also designed so that every layer of the stack can handle high availability from the network through compute all the way down to storage. At Cisco this includes the unified computing system (UCS) solution which can be upgraded without service interruption and that features flexible virtualized hardware and redundancy. This allows certified cloud partners to provide and maintain high level SLA’s and performance while reducing your total cost of ownership. © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 11 of 18 List of Cloud Service Providers for the Public Sector For your convenience, a list of public sector cloud providers that meet these three key benchmarks is provided below. If you have any questions about how to select the best provider for your organization, please reach out to us at cloudcontractquestions@external.cisco.com and we will be glad to answer them for you. Company Contact Information and Services Provided CDW jack Nichols Phone: 202.494.0029 Email: jack.nichols@cdw.com HCS, Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS), Hosted Collaboration Solution for Contact Center (HCS for CC), Unified Thread (UTM), Unified Contact Center, Business Communication, Application Performance Management (APM) Di Data NTT America Scott Cruikshank Phone: 919.791.1058 Email: scott.cruikshank@dimensiondata.com Cloud and Managed Services Melanie Sunahara Phone: 312.953.3473 Email: melanie.sunahara@dimensiondata.com Tony Connor Phone: 703.773.6331 Email: t.connor@eh.ntta.com Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS) NWN Corp. Chris Ludwig Phone: 919.653.4409 Email: cludwig@nwnit.com Hosted Collaboration Solution (HCS), Cloud Services Peak 10 QUEST Reggie Harris Phone: 513.645.2912 Email: reggie.harris@peak10.com Adam Burke Phone: 916.609.8049 Email: adam_burke@questsys.com Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS) Sentinel Rachel Jenkins Phone: 630.769.4347 Email: rjenkins@sentinel.com Data Center Interconnect, Unified Contact Center, Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS), Application Performance Management (APM) Sungard Monica Seemiller Phone: 412.370.2093 Email: monica.seemiller@sungardas.com Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS), DR aaS Windstream Hosted Solutions Jaclyn Mispagel Phone: 501.748.7085 Email: jaclyn.mispagel@windstream.com Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS), Cloud Services Virtustream Duane Flowers Phone: 240.252.1018 © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Email: duane.flowers@virtustream.com Page 12 of 18 WRITING YOUR CONTRACT SCOPE Two Steps to Increased Flexibility Making sure your contract gives you the most flexibility can prove beneficial to your organization in the long term. There are two techniques that will allow you to enjoy this flexibility and future cloud innovation. These are: Writing requests for solutions or architectures that meet a specific business need, instead of products Requesting suppliers submit specifications for all elements needed to meet the business need. Public sector organizations should also solicit feedback through a Request for Information (RFI) or draft request for proposal (RFP) then adjust accordingly before release of the final RFP. If possible, you should also restrict cloud procurement to OEM based cloud environments to ensure secure, scalable, flexible and interoperable cloud infrastructures that have the full support and breadth of leading technology suppliers. Example: Requests for Solutions - Instead of Products The cloud can encompass every type of technology your organization uses on a day-to-day basis (such as monitors, servers, routers, cables, etc.) but by requesting the supplier provide a workable solution that fits your end goal, instead of just products, you give them more flexibility. This can mean added savings, better performance and expanded opportunities for innovation. Your requests for solutions, instead of products, should be short and concise. Clearly state the type of service and end with a specific goal or set of goals: Video or web-conferencing solutions to provide distance learning Unified communications to reduce telephone line costs and leverage the data network infrastructure Data center consolidation and virtualization solutions to reduce data center space, power and cooling requirements and increase business agility Interoperable communications solutions that enable public safety employees to talk directly using any type of radio or phone and to increase situational awareness by sharing video, building floor plans, etc. Mobility solutions that enable eligibility-determination for workers, inspectors, home-health nurses and other field personnel to retrieve and input case information from the field, lowering travel time and costs Video-based arraignment solutions to avoid the time, costs, and public safety risks of transporting prisoners to the courtroom Video interpretation solutions to avoid skyrocketing costs and judicial delays while overburdened contract interpreters travel between courtrooms. Example: Requests for Specifications - to Meet the Need Once you have established a need and end-goals via the requests for solutions, you can gain greater contract flexibility by adding requests for specifications. These should ask the supplier to provide all available information on any elements they feel necessary to fulfill their cloud solution. This may include the following, depending on your project scope: Content security Servers and storage area networking SaaS, IaaS, XaaS, etc. Unified computing © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 13 of 18 Application switching Virtual desktop Maintenance services, installation and configuration services, professional services and training Physical security Logical security Smart hands/remote hands support Colocation space Power and cooling requirements Data security and management Specific computing requirements by year (processing, RAM, network) Backup and recovery requirements Facility access requirements APIs Help desk and technical support Self-service portal Monitoring and reporting. Additional Strategies for Contract Flexibility By adding flexibility to your contracts, you can increase opportunities to take advantage of innovations in cloud technology as they become available. Additional strategies that can maximize this flexibility further include adding language that: Allows manufacturers to provide all products and services in their price book that meet RFP scope Stipulates that solutions interoperate with existing equipment and other IP standards–based solutions Includes any new IT products, services or solutions that are within the RFP scope - but not stipulated in the contract – thus giving contracting officers the chance to add them, at their discretion Allows vendors to include third-party products or services as part of their overall solution, avoiding multiple contracts for a single business solution Provides anticipatory provisions allowing manufacturers to request the addition of new technologies to their awarded contract offerings, whether developed in-house or obtained via product or company acquisitions Makes statewide contracts from the RFP available to all governmental entities within each state, subject to applicable laws, including but not limited to state offices, agencies, departments, boards, bureaus, commissioners, institutions, colleges and universities (FYI – be sure to open statewide contracts to other state authorities, local governments, municipalities, cities, townships, counties, K-12 school districts and political subdivisions as well). © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 14 of 18 TERMS AND CONDITIONS You can also help yourself by helping the cloud supplier. Your contract should take into account their needs as well. It may sound counter-productive but it does work. By looking at things from their point-of-view, you can gain an advantage by giving them the “opportunity” to offer you better pricing. For example, in most cases any non-standard terms or conditions will increase the manufacturer’s costs. This would naturally reduce any savings he could pass on to you. To help them help you, consider specifying the following terms and conditions in your cloud contract: OEM as Prime/Contractor Holder with Resellers as Subcontractors - Allow manufacturers to use certified resellers as fulfillment agents and cloud (managed) service providers. This benefits public sector customers by providing a local source of support and expertise. It also supports state interests in encouraging local hiring and other economic development activity. Limitation of Liability - Avoid contracts requiring unlimited liability. In addition, cloud services providers are reluctant to agree to any liability for indirect, special, consequential, exemplary, punitive or special damages or loss of profits. Capital Lease Financing - To avoid the need for up-front capital outlay, public sector contracts should allow for manufacturers to offer capital financing arrangements under their awarded contracts. This can help mitigate any upfront non-recurring charges for private cloud implementations, if applicable. Payment Terms - The standard commercial payment term is net 30 days. Since many OEMs use resellers under their prime contracts as subcontractors, any payment term that exceeds 30 days will impose a financial hardship on these resellers, many of whom are small or medium-sized businesses. Since many of the cloud services offerings are like subscription-based services, payment in advance, for example, for a 1-year managed services contract term is reasonable. In addition, such payment structure also minimizes any nonappropriation issues that some customers may have for such procurements. Service Level Agreements (SLAs) – From a practical perspective, instead of negotiating and incorporating SLAs at the master/prime contract level, allow the individual authorized buyers to negotiate the SLAs with the OEM and/or its authorized partners/cloud managed services providers on a case-by-case basis at the transactional level. Cloud services offerings can vary greatly depending on the type of cloud services procured and equally important, based on the scope of the customer’s business needs and technical requirements. Therefore, it would be challenging to have a “one size fits all” set of SLAs pre-negotiated in the master/prime contract. Additionally, SLAs are more appropriate as part of the Statement of Work that the OEM and/or its authorized cloud managed services provider will need to execute with the buying entity. Manufacturer certified and supported – To help ensure security and interoperability as well as for increased performance, include OEM certifications such as Cisco-powered certified architecture, Cisco Managed Serviced Provider (CMSP), certified cloud solutions and Intercloud Fabric Authorized Technology Partner. Cloud Interoperability – To help mitigate vendor lock-in and provide architecture flexibility and increased security and performance, add a requirement for cloud interoperability. This includes the ability to move virtual machines (VM’s) between other Cisco Intercloud partners with a single point of management and control for physical and virtual workloads across public and private clouds. This requirement also requires that the connectivity between the private and service provider clouds is highly secure and scalable, providing a secure © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 15 of 18 Layer 2 network extension from the private Data Center to the provider cloud. All with the ability to utilize any to any hypervisor in your multi-cloud environment that you just enabled. Annual Third-Party Audit of Data Center – It is best practice to require an annual Statement on Standards for Attestation Engagements (SSAE) No. 16 report from the contracting services provider. SSAE 16 is the replacement of SAS 70. The SSAE 16 is a standard in the reporting and controls of a services provider to an auditor. User organizations (customers) receive valuable information regarding the service organization’s controls and the effectiveness of those controls. Support – OEM certified architectures generally provide additional support vs. white-label offerings. By identifying an OEM certified architecture, such as those identified from Cisco, customers will receive benefits such as 24X7 manufacturer technical support services as well. Security Controls & Requirements - Similar to the SLAs above, instead of negotiating and incorporating security controls, standards and requirements at the master/prime contract level allow the individual authorized buyers to negotiate those requirements and terms with the OEM and/or its authorized partners/cloud managed services providers on a case-by-case basis at the transactional level. Cloud services offerings can vary greatly depending on the type of cloud services procured and not all cloud services would require or necessitate certain security controls (such as FEDRAMP or FISMA). Each End User Agency shall set the appropriate security control set based on the data classification level of the associated End User data. Standard Software License - To offer non-standard software license terms, OEMs would need to incur the costs to set up separate internal systems, tools, and resources. Consequential, Incidental, Indirect, Special or Punitive Exclusion - It is standard in the IT industry to exclude consequential, incidental, indirect, special or punitive damages in a contract. The potential risk exposure could exceed the contract value and even insurance coverage limits. Liquidated Damages - Standard terms in the IT industry do not encompass liquidated damages, which are not contemplated under the standard-terms-and-discount structure. Rights and Remedies of State for Default - It is standard for global OEMs to provide customers with remedies for default. However, it is unreasonable to ask OEMs to assume additional liability on “any loss or damage” incurred by a customer because such damage is equivalent to consequential, incidental, indirect or special damage. General Indemnity - The scope of the indemnity should be reasonably limited to the OEM’s and/or its authorized partners’ products and services supplied under the prime contracts. The extent of the indemnification obligations should be apportioned relative to fault. Patent, Copyright and Trade Secret Indemnity - It is common for technology vendors to require certain exceptions or exclusions to their IP indemnification obligations. For example, an OEM would not be responsible for indemnifying if its product was modified by a third party or by the OEM itself, or in accordance with the buyer’s specifications or instructions. Because OEMs face damages that could exceed the contract value, it is reasonable for OEMs to require limitations of liability with respect to the scope of its IP defense and indemnification obligations. Equally important, OEMs, as the IP owners of their product offerings, should be © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 16 of 18 able to control the defense of any indemnity claim, including settlement negotiations. Rights in Work Product(s) - Such rights generally are only appropriate if the customer is hiring an IT vendor or OEM to create, develop, and/or build hardware and/or software that is new, original or unique. Although OEMs and/or its authorized partners may provide some customization to product offerings based on the buyer’s technical requirements, such customization is typically limited in nature and does not justify providing buyer with rights into the developed work products. Right to Copy or Modify - Granting customers the right to copy or modify under an Indefinite Delivery, Indefinite Quantity (IDIQ) contract undermines the technology company’s intellectual property rights and control of its assets. The exception is a formal licensing arrangement that includes royalties or licensing fees. Stop Work Order - These provisions result in significant revenue recognition issues under accounting rules for publicly traded corporations. Confidentiality Provisions - Technology companies understand the importance of keeping their customer’s information confidential and often agree to reasonable confidentiality provisions. Technology vendors expect that the confidentiality provisions are reciprocal given that they are routinely asked to share proprietary information regarding their product and services offerings in response to RFPs, RFQs and other project proposals. Contract Term - The supplier community supports the existing practice of most customers in issuing multiyear, prime contracts or IDIQs with automatic 1 or 2 year renewals or simple extensions. Given the time and resources that both the customer and awarded vendor invest to operationalize new agreements, it is mutually beneficial for all parties involved to have a reasonable multi-year contract term. Early Termination for Convenience Charges – Unlike typical purchases for IT products and services, cloud managed service providers must make some capital investments with each customer engagement. If a customer terminates a cloud managed services agreement for convenience before the end of a contract term, the customer should pay reasonable early termination fees so that the provider can be compensated for any initial set-up costs. SUMMARY Providing your team and the citizens they serve with the latest innovative technologies can be frustrating and expensive. However, your organization can overcome these and other barriers to innovation by developing a strategy that provides a flexible approach to your cloud contracts by: Utilizing cloud procurement best practices Using a master contract Developing a strategic approach to the scope of the contract Including specific strategic language Providing focused terms and conditions. By maximizing your future options you can deliver increased efficiency, reduced costs and improved services for your public sector organization. © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. Page 17 of 18 FOR MORE INFORMATION To learn more about maximizing the benefits of cloud contracts, how to select a cloud services provider or for answers to your cloud questions, please email us at cloudcontractquestions@external.cisco.com. To learn more about the cloud in the public sector and how to work efficiently with equipment manufacturers, contact your Cisco account manager or visit: http://www.cisco.com/web/solutions/trends/cisco-powered/index.html. To learn more about how to select the right cloud service provider for your organization, check out: http://blogs.cisco.com/datacenter/finding-the-perfect-cloud-service-provider-with-cisco/. To read up on how cloud is changing the roles of IT leaders like you, visit: http://unleashingit.com/docs/P14/CIS14050%20Cloud%20Executive%20Perspective%20vDigital.pdf?utm_source=Cisco &utm_medium=Web&utm_content=Cloud%20Exec%20Perspective%20PDF&utm_campaign=CP. Printed in USA © 2015 Cisco and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. This document is Cisco Public. For more information on the creation of this document, call 919.392.4834 / 3.25.15 Page 18 of 18