2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled Michael Van Valkenburgh

Transcription

2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
Michael Van Valkenburgh Associates
DRAFT
Trails Bring water to the site Active and passive rec. Picnic Nature Beautification Launching ground for kayaks Accessibility Lighting on pedestrian bridge is lacking Restrooms Place for a snack Year‐round water fountains Rock feature or Andy Goldsworthy type wall Dog park or dog beach like Prospect Park Bird Watching Higher topography‐ hills(ish) like Prospect Park for riding horses or mountain bikes or trail runs Bike access point at S.Boston‐ please keep Water play area Wildlife not displaced No bars along Crow Creek Trail Cincinnati between 31st and Crow Creek  most concerned traffic through rest area Duck pond! Young and old venues Pool center and swimming pool Access by Crow Creek to Peoria (pedestrian traffic) Parking‐ Traffic (safety issue) No trail on north side of the creek/public access from south impacting the north side Crime issues? Curfews? Don’t want walking trails No walking trail on or near Crow Creek +1 More walkways over Riverside Drive 24th and Riverside  Access  No sidewalk on east of river (safety issue) Bike trail connecting to Brookside Area Do want walking trail along Crow Creek +1 Replicate Blair House‐ make functional for meetings, restaurant, toilets (very easy to replicate) Close off the bridge at 33‐Cincinnati‐ dead end like it used to be! Reed/Phase 2; house backs to development: what is at that transition at property line? (currently fence with Sundance) Close Crow Creek bridge over Cincinnati Keep “dog park” on south edge of Blair Natural History park at Brookside Classes in the park‐ yoga, rock wall Paddle boats Restaurant on boat Community gardens 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Where would parking be? No large walls People love Woodward Park‐ did a good job of preserving the surrounding neighborhoods Look into streets around‐ is this permit only? No commercial on Blair Lawn. Push toward Crow Creek Upkeep on picnic tables and eateries is difficult‐ no grills, picnic tables Nature park Small scale concerts on west side Pedestrian bridge is iconic Water in the river Historic raft river race (bring back for an inaugural party) + rubber duck race Move or beautify the industrial area on the west side 24 hr security monitoring of the park‐ currently there is a flasher Don’t close 31st st. especially at Riverside Drive‐ someone else says this might actually be okay Maze (fun for kids and adults) Tree area (floods a lot) would be a good walking area Keep wide open space open Don’t want people looking over fence, but would like to see the nature Bring the daffodils back Place space front and center at flat part Commercial space at Crow Creek site Flowers, pond, stream Low key, not noisy Lighting can be a concern No access from Boston Place and Boston Avenue‐ pedestrian or vehicular‐ maybe permit only parking within neighborhoods Views from house‐ don’t want property value to go down Many people like the natural landscapes Want a range of types Conservative area‐ no carnival like atmosphere Maintain woods Natural setting Tea garden Careful balance between natural and built Maintain lawn Game fields Picnics Community building at back of Blair site Commercial activity in Crow Creek site 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Wide open space Temporary food stands Restrooms! Safety‐concerned about crime Who picks up trash Tie back side of apts. (boy scout property) to site Separate areas for adults and children Dog park No quick stop food stores Focus on the area for education about natural landscape, forest, wildlife Utilize Blair mansion as education center‐ do not move structure, it is historic and part of historic Riverside addition of Maple Ridge (This neighborhood is on the National Registry of Historic Neighborhoods and the Blairs are part of our neighborhood for several decades as our neighbors) No widening of Riverside Drive (except at Bridge) No restrooms on this side Don’t touch Riverside Drive‐ but this will only cause traffic issues on Cincinnati‐ we will fight that Overpasses not underpasses More trees More color Bird sanctuary More creative playgrounds Kayaking below the dam West side‐ decrease visibility of refinery Keeping some areas wild; mulch and trees sponge for water A designated parking area Manage unavoidable increase in traffic No access from neighborhoods Parking solutions Access points Blair House is iconic vision in Tulsa, sad to see city lose it. Do not move it. Blair mansion is one of the structures visitors remember about Tulsa. Do not move it‐ it is a landmark and gateway to downtown Tulsa and our historic neighborhoods along the east bank. No quick stop snack centers or bathrooms Save the forest on the Blair property Community gardens/rose garden/arboretum Food trucks Markets Do not make Boston Place access to park Pedestrian access only on Boston Ave. Large pond‐ water feature on side Privacy Street performers Reduce traffic at 31st and Riverside 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Existing site of Blair property is one of Tulsa’s most beautiful and remembered landmarks. Negotiate new deal with current owner not to move the house. Does not make sense financially. Encourage current owner to build new home‐ a model of Blair mansion at another location Love the natural forest and green space‐ great for air quality and mitigating pollution from the refineries‐ healthy for Tulsa to have green space! Community gardens and education center for sustainability No lake on tract “paddle boats” Need through access from parking to Blair Replace bridge over Riverside with wide walkways (very dangerous) Need pedestrian access over Riverside Remove tight turn on pedestrian ramp Do not remove Blair Mansion‐ beautiful, historic home that is a gateway to Downtown Tulsa. Use Blair home as nature center Do not remove native forest or trees on Blair property. Use forest for educational purposes on wetlands and wildlife. Velodrome‐cycling Use the site as an opportunity to educate the city about our natural surroundings‐ ecology. Make an educational connection with the Oklahoma aquarium Firework viewing in July‐ improve/provide place for this yearly gathering Provide a place for farmers market stands Provide a home for our Children’s Museum in need of a home Community gardens/arboretum/natural plants and trees of Oklahoma plaques Boardwalks and towers for bird watching What kind of commercial development? Adult‐oriented or kid but please nothing that will attract vandalism after hours, teen‐hangouts (Jenks now has a teen curfew, please avoid this) Good to have a place to eat No walking trails on north side of Crow Creek‐ want neighborhood to remain quiet Would like to see a walk connecting Peoria and the river along Crow Creek Walking trial for Park to Peoria Sufficient parking More, safer roadway crossings Interaction with wildlife Connect to Brookside Children’s museum and enchanted forest a la Winterthur (Wilmington, DE) Please remove the apartments Contemporary sculpture garden Children’s play Parking Connections over Riverside Not too much retail Low impact Range of activities Lots of ‘green’ 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Additional crossings to connect site Safety Beer garden would be great Blair house should be kept Stables and horse riding Keep the trees Children’s museum Petting zoo Other restaurant options besides hamburger joint View from trail‐ what will be? Wooded feel Kid friendly Apartments gone Grass and a park Connection to Brookside trail Want house to stay‐ use for weddings/keep structure for a meeting place Will you have parking? What about changing roads? Convert house into Civil War Museum‐ It’s a replica of Jefferson Davis’ house, cherry wood and paneling all the same. Honor the buffalo soldiers and battles fought in OK Don’t want front yard destroyed Varied experiences like Dallas Arboretum Olmstead’s Design on Central Park as design aesthetic Rental space for formal events‐weddings Equestrian uses Amazing trails Keep the Blair House‐ Dallas Estate near Arboretum‐ event center for Tulsa Concerned about traffic and parking in neighborhood north of property (3‐4 blocks) Always looking for big open space for sports, playing field, doesn’t need lots of equipment. Ultimate Frisbee players‐ very appealing Home backs up to pedestrian park. Want to know if it will back up to 31st Think the pedestrian is terrific‐ simple, easy to be attracted to them and pick a favorite helps simplify the issue Don’t want to be looked at sunset and have bar to block the view Want the river to stay more natural, river parks can stay on the west side‐ not a fan of the trails Returned to what it looked like 200 years ago Million dollar bronze sculpture Where will parking in the park be? Will there be access from neighborhood Nature trail‐ wooded incline to Blair House. Tons of serenity on trail, bird life. Don’t engulf the trail Are going to be archways from one side to the other? Need to have water in the river! What about crime in the park. Escape route into neighborhood. Please don’t move Riverside Drive east 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Big trees are needed‐ the more the better. For shade and bird photography areas Rock formations‐ active playground‐scapes Restaurants in current apartment area Kayak/paddler on east side for families Burying Riverside‐landscape Extending river edge‐ creating more land, more trail Noise pollution, 31st and Boston Place, privacy concerns No vehicular traffic to Maple Ridge Velodrome, night riding Skate park for kids Open lawn on Blair is an asset. Leave it. Great for pickup games like ultimate Frisbee. Tulsa Ultimate federation. Beer Garden. Munich has playground. Great family spot More artwork. Things people can interact with and have photo ops. Take landscape over Riverside Drive Dog park on Riverside of road. Rather than have co‐mingling, create a special place for dogs to go Put barrier between parking and houses. HGTV do a “design the block” here. Gets people to care about houses look and how the neighborhood looks Not lots of places to get a good view, what Tulsa needs is somewhere to toss back and enjoy the view. Commercial shops at Crow Creek end Blair property should be preserved Pedestrian bridge property but up to fence Preserve marshland and privacy. Let the north quadrant be natural Love bike trails. Driving Range, nice net system for small space Midland valley dropped down to grade level so you can see the trees Geologist‐ Crow Creek going into River‐ great educational opportunity to teach students water quality etc. Parking, sidewalks 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Mr. Chavez residing at 3225 S. Detroit is opposed to walking trails on west side of creek. Elizabeth, concerned about why she received a personal invitation. Believed she would be told her property was being taken. Understanding, that is not going to happen, she is opposed to an amusement park but supports walking trails. She would also like to be protected from people parking in her yard. Neighbor supports a connection/pathway from Brookside to Crow Creek and would like to see retail/food similar to that currently on Brookside. Believes that Mr. Kaiser owns the Boy Scout office near Peoria and that would provide a link through the neighborhood. Neighbor supports more walking trails. It’s so exciting! Happy to see the apartments go. Several (five) neighbors believe there should be additional pedestrian bridges. One neighbor would like to see the existing bridge be kept intact. Interested in the safety aspect of them. Concerned about people darting across Riverside. More parking! Existing area gets a lot of use and this will provide enhancement and more areas to use. “Great!” Keep existing trails. Southside of the Blair property near woods is very marshy, wet, almost a quagmire after rain. Would like to see this resolved so as to better access woods. Looking forward to finally getting to use this property freely. One neighborhood asked whether a dog park or dog area had been considered. 3100 block of Cincinnati at Crow Creek should not be a through street, not a public street all the time. Winterthur in Wilmington, DE is a park that one neighbor suggested as a model for the new space. Continued but CONTROLLED access at East 30th Street, near corner of 29th and Boston. All nearby neighbors agree that they support project but feel this is an area of concern. M.A. Doran. MVVA “seems to be a great feel – good fit.” “Gave every indication that they will hear our concerns.” How do you control vagrant population? How do you keep the homeless from living there? Will there be curfews? The neighbors need protection. In one of the photos at the landscape station, a neighbor really liked the native grasses and wildflowers. He said currently at River Parks, the authority just seems to mow the grass and cut back the trees. This neighbor would like to see a more native natural look. Will there be a bandstand? “If it is two blocks from my home I will not be able to sleep on a Saturday night. “ One neighbor does not like the shake and burger shack picture or the seating in that picture. She would like to be more of a nature park that focuses on walking trails and landscape. “No retail!” This was echoed by another neighbor. “No concessions.” 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Several neighbors have major concerns about the traffic flow on Cincinnati with a major public place in the area. Could it be blocked at Riverside Drive? “Please add more parking!” Boston is already busy thoroughfare. Major concern when there is events at park about what will happen on this street. “Boston cannot be a thru street once the park is built.” Will this interrupt /diminish the Fourth of July celebration? Neighbor would consider that a negative. Is there anything that can be done to protect bikers that are trying to get to the trails from Lewis and Peoria? Traffic is very scary for those folks. At the current time, it is very hard and dangerous to turn onto Riverside Drive from the arterial streets. Something must be done to ease that since there will be added congestion with the park. “I am excited about it! I don’t care what it looks like!” Boston Place must be changed to a dead end. One neighbor would like to see a “really swell” restaurant. “ Something more high end.” Will there be an endowment to maintain and keep the park clean? Do not want it to become a dump. Is there a way to connect Boulder Park to this site? One neighbor likes the shake and burger shack photo and loves the seating and lighting idea. Affordable housing for displaced residents Please no amusement park like atmosphere! Park for walking, riding, picnicking and a place for weddings! Leave as natural as possible while promoting involvement through parks, jogging paths, etc. No architect is capable of improving the Blair Estate‐ Leave it alone!!! Outdoor classes would be fun‐ Tai Chi for example A concrete skate park which could bring people from other cities for events/contests while building revenue for local businesses I’d love to see you look at the other large cities doing the same thing, specifically Chicago. We need to demolish the floating amphitheatre across the river and build a beautiful modern amphitheater that people actually want to go to. When there weren’t acts performing it would still be a beautiful sculptural piece, instead of an eyesore. A stand alone bldg for kids to do art/science projects. i.e. Wave Hill Park in the Bronx, NY area Purchase and preserve the Blair mansion‐ a historic site for all Tulsans. Use the mansion for a nature center or office space for sustainable Tulsa and other environmental projects. Preserve the forest on the Blair land‐ use it for educational purposes‐trees, wildlife, flowers. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Areas open to the air but sheltered from sun and rain are crucial in Oklahoma! Dog park somewhere! Use native plants! No retail, please. Ziplines and intricate tree houses sound AWESOME Make sure it’s not merely a repeat of Woodward Park/Lineas garden “Teaching Gardens”= DEFINITELY No retail Protect natural ecosystem and wildlife Greenspace Permaculture area‐sustainable community edible gardens (see growparadise.com for ideas) Provide retail rental space for a restaurant or two to lease. Like Blue Rose. Open area seating/restaurants and bars/surrounding I’m not sure “boundless” is very achievable in that space in such a central area when there are other urgent uses. HOT AIR BALLOONS Rock climbing? Affordable house for the apartment dwellers Tulsa has no “lookout” feature. This would be a great place for one. An iconic feature as in Chicago’s Millennium Park I love those white string lights in the photo :) Utilize and adapt the existing pedestrian bridge that crosses Riverside Mixed use structures, with mixed income housing Love all the ideas given at the introduction. GREAT PROJECT! Sustainability features Open space for field sports other than soccer‐ ultimate Frisbee, rugby, lacrosse Velodrome Themed gardens (ex. English or Asian, mazes) Coffee shops, bistro Along riverside‐attractive walk to create sound barrier and safety Dog Park Kayak rental Enlarge pedestrian bridge access, enlarge multiple lanes or decks Fishing places off the bridge Walkway at Crow Creek‐paddle boats‐if you could bring water in‐could connect with museum Family gathering‐not too commercial Contemporary sculpture Native plants and trees 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Lots of water features‐gondolas‐waterfront @Crow Creek Parking‐one stop to get to both Brookside as well as to the proposed site STUB/cul‐de‐sac the 31st St. Bridge over the Riverside to access River Parks A few large scale architectural elements‐but elegantly built Current parking “lot” at 31st St. turned into water feature to connect both Blair and the apt. complex sites Teenagers shouldn’t be pushed to west side, let them hang out and feel welcome A Rustic Restaurant and Bar! For the love of Tulsa, please don’t give us a stagnant body of water. Go by Gilcrease and see how well that worked for them. If you haven’t been to the Dallas Arboretum, you need to go, it is the perfect mix of nature and family fun. Give us something that is truly beautiful. I am a photographer and in need of somewhere worthy to photograph. Good luck! Would rather the river stay natural looking, not have an overly landscaped, manufactured look. Good luck and thank you! I would like to see an interactive landscape. Rock slides and natural pools from Crow Creek, a cleaner, fuller river that would incorporate paddle boats, canoes, kayaks, fishing. I would like a spot for temporary street art. A place for small musical shows and seating. Leave Blair field as is Maybe boat tours on river: offers revenue, job opportunities and a good way to spend a few hours Please do not move the Blair House‐ buy it from Bufford. It is a visual treasure as well as the open space and natural forest No commercial development north of 31st! These changes sound great! More walking and nature trails with beautiful gardens Secluded bike and walking trails Coffee shop, sidewalk café, bakery (all locally owned) A well placed bistro to have a romantic evening Lots of flowers and color. Bring all the variety nature has to offer to Tulsa Small pub with Riverside seating Child play areas with NEW creative activities and games Spot for outdoor yoga, taichi Swinging rings and muscle challenges A second river park disc. Golf course Community open space for field sports! Blend urban and rural features Currently the Blair House makes the site feel strongly connected to the history of Tulsa. How will you preserve that feeling? Moving Riverside through the Blair property so that it runs along the east side of the current parking lot and between the RR, Borm and 31st St. Then make the Blair property east of riverside all natural by enhancing and expanding the current stand of trees. This would also create more green space between riverside Dr. and the River Slides 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
A Dog Park Bike Trail Trail/Water Feature to Brookside Night light/21st bridge Keep Blair property as natural as possible. Maybe add more landscaping to add cover for the wildlife that is on this site. There is a family of foxes, rabbits and owls. Limit commercial development to the Crow Creek apartment site Mixed elements‐ possibly raise the land, Central Park feel, Bird feeders for bird watching The Blair House is one of Tulsa’s most beautiful properties along Riverside. Buy the Blair House from current owner and he can build new model on another site Save the forest! Bird watching opportunities along the river. Least tern population is present along the sand banks of the Arkansas River. http://www.tulsaaudubon.org/leastterns.htm Lots of parking…well‐hidden parking (underground?) Include a sculpture garden! (kinetic and interactive)‐ Ned Kahn “Wind leaves” Look at NYC’s central park  boulders make hills and ups and downs Connect to the river‐ make it easy Like Central Park, lots of different activities  a little central park w/ baseball diamonds, ice skating etc. Ziplines Holland Park in London‐Japanese Zen Garden‐like! Bicycle transit hub! Farmers’ Market Is there any intention to transfer ownership of properties from Buff to the city? Who’s going to pay for lights and security? Utilize temporary, pop‐up strategies during the design process to help clarify how the public wants to use the space Bury Riverside Drive along the front of the park to truly connect the river to the space Make an innovative playscape that is not equipment‐based. Look at natural and adventure playgrounds Consider the entire park as “playable” space Make sure to consider all the climates that Tulsa experiences (hot summers, flooding, winds, ice etc.) We don’t want a hot summer to turn a pond into mosquito nests Skate Park‐ State of the art!!! Nature trails Climbing wall (look at Chandler Park around 51st) 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Small amusement park Dog park Climbing wall! Tulsa offers many running race events (5ks, half/full marathons etc). Currently Veterans Park is used for the finish line. It would be cool to have a “natural” race finish corridor w/ some grassy stadium type seating to receive finishers Bury riversidecut and coverpull Riverside east – fill up to level of Railway bern to make a continuous landscape. Solve drainage and ventilation with a good engineer. OPEN SPACE! A citizen suggested having a 300 foot observation tower with a revolving restaurant and 360 panoramic view. Something like that in Chicago or what is being built at the Dallas Fairgrounds. This will not require additional parking and would also be a good event center for weddings. Could this be an eventual site for the Farmer’s Market that is now on Cherry Street? Boats please. A citizen is concerned about respecting wildlife and nature and wants the park to restore some of the natural ecology that Blair property owners destroyed for their horse habitats. A citizen suggests changing the way 31st enters Riverside so that the green space would connect to the river. Please no parking up next to Riverside. The river is known as a braided prairie river. Enhance what it is, do no try to change it. Kayaking and paddle boats would be harmful to the bird ecology. Please try to connect it all. New QT space is great but the parking is not adequate. “DO NOT WIDEN RIVERSIDE!” Citizen does not think this should be any type of sports complex, very limited if at all. Please emphasize the natural surroundings. Biking and walking trails need to be separate. Too dangerous now. Could there be kayak rental on the west bank? Rework the coffer dam to accommodate? Please keep the Blair house. From Janet Allen: We have an opportunity here. All of us. When you see the Eiffel Tower your think PARIS. Golden Gate Bridge: SAN FRANCISCO. Gateway Arch: ST LOUIS. Whatever you are going to think up: TULSA. My words for you are: be audacious, think big. Whatever you can come up with, we as a community can handle. Go for it! 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Citizens would like to see a dog park. Please do not have surface parking. Underground would be great. Please do not think so Tulsa and small, thing big and progressive. Yes to a bistro! Yes to playground equipment. Can we move the Farmer’s Market there? Yes to onsite equipment rental? Soccer, kites, kayaks, paddle boats Place parking out of view of Riverside Dr. +1 I wish you would keep the big, white house and stable intact. It’s one of the things that makes Tulsa special! Leave grassy expanse and the woods too! Trail transition correctly identified as dangerous‐please widen! At PlaniTulsa, I suggested that this should be one of a series of library/park/famers’ market/community garden/along a lite rail system throughout Tulsa, which includes a bicycle/walking path. It should go all over the city, to the airport, Broken Arrow and down the river. If a walker/bicyclist gets tired, they could just hop on the (free?) lite rail system (a la Miami, FL). A different farmer’s market could be held on alternate days Elevate or bury the road (Riverside Drive). Or put out over river!? When I was younger, my mom helped to stop Riverside Drive from becoming a highway! We need wildlife to return to the area Some structure with seating/restaurant out of weather in Blair House location. The embankment may separate the spaces but it also adds interest and could be an asset Preserve open, flat field space on Blair Mansion Property for low impact field sports. No trees, trails, benches, etc. Maintain walking/biking access to space from neighborhood. Don’t make neighbors get in a car to enjoy the park/space I think it’d be great to have horse‐drawn carriages down the river and through the property, maybe rent horses a la central park? Parking garages Children’s museum and playground Farmer’s market and cafes Fix the way Riverside chokes up and goes under in the bridge. Moe it east, straighten it and create more space between river and the road. I am a daily commuter on R.S. Drive and can’t wait to see the finished project! Parking‐ but please no parking lots. That’s a challenge! Ziplines Turkey Mountain to site at bout $50 each 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Place median in Riverside Drive‐ separating north/southbound traffic (mother votes for this!) Relieve congestion at pedestrian bridge for runners and bicyclists The Blair property is beautiful and impressive. Don’t break it up with a lot of “stuff”! Do not force uses to park in the neighborhood! Maintain or even improve the privacy of the neighbors whose property abuts the Blair property The Blair MUST REMAIN. It’s perfect for a “gathering place.” People need a structure‐ a place to visit etc. Create rock gardens w/ falls‐running water, flowers, long growing plants Keep the Blair home‐ use for special events. An outdoor band stand Dog park Please not too groomed‐ no azaleas and creeping myrtles Adequate parking where apartments are now Great trails, trees, keep a lot open too If Blair mansion must go, build a replica for weddings, private events, no retail! Bring river into park with retaining pond/canals Wakeboard cable park Artificial surf wave PERMEABLE PAVERS SUSTAINABILITY IS THE KEY! RAINWATER HARVESTING! Terrace some entrances for picnic style areas for when water is low It would be nice to keep the berm to isolate the parking from the Park Try to keep as much natural landscape as possible  TREES Create a GREAT sense of arrival Multi‐laned bride that keeps the existing viewing bridge intact Have an ejecting peninsula for viewing w/ Gazebo or such style environment A much more upbeat style park v. the ordinary Tulsa Park (concrete and Bermuda grass lawns) would be nice A turn around point for cyclists/walkers/runners from N/S Tulsa Half/Half parking on either side of Riverside to avoid car wrecks from fast traffic and narrow bridge overpass Limit restaurant additions to 1‐3 small kiosk/buy and run style I hope your bubble diagram under LA goals is not the placing you are currently looking at  not cohesive  also disturbs much of the current land assets Give Tulsa back its ecosystem services‐ water quality, aesthetic value, food production The Blair Mansion should remain‐ as a “Crown Jewel” of what emerges Interpretive Center‐ The Southern influences on Tulsa’s early development and culture! It is a unique example of confederate ties and culture‐ excellent example of southern, French coastal home World class whitewater park Artistic statuary No golf course Plenty of shade, water features and wildflowers and fun things for children/adults to do 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Oklahoma historical statuary w/ educational vignettes to explain Outdoor space for movies, plays etc in the park Picnic areas Sun and shade Bird sanctuary Pond Solar lighting Rental space for urban gardening Butterfly garden Dead end 31st street 9‐18 hole disc golf course Water misters near gathering places Park shouldn’t be too busy Morton arboretum has a children’s garden for educational an recreational uses. Small scale for this site (in Chicago) Tents, cabanas, shade and trees Preserve riparian zone‐ this is a huge prairie river‐ let the river BE river, not a pool Old fashioned covered dance floor (gazebo) with ability to have open air or closed during the cold weather Riverside Dr. is a natural barrier and also a traffic feeder, can you make it look/work like a park road? Fully link both sides at Riverside together and down the slope good BUT insure to keep flood control at max or better capacity. Make the connection natural. Multigenerational and handicapped accessible Unify the site is important Re‐routing riverside drive to allow land access to water More trees! Amphitheater Landscaping should be planned with an eye towards neighborhood privacy and security! This isn’t listed as one of your “goals.” Why? Refurbish Zink lake fountain‐ it was very nice when the water was flowing A statue that is large and unique to Tulsa Rowing friendly river‐reliable water level World class whitewater venue Trees, flowers and grass 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
300 ft. tall observation tower‐360 degree panoramic view of Tulsa with 2 floors at top‐bottom of which would be conference or weddings, etc. to rent out, top would be public viewing‐ “Kaiser Vision Tower” In front of Blair Mansion  put Riverside Dr. in a tunnel so park reaches right down to the riverbank Ditto the tower unique views of all of Tulsa front that point of view! One of a kind Tulsa Merry go Round  Tulsa/Oklahoma figures: buffalo, armadillos, etc. and native American designs and figures A putting green (1‐9, 1‐18) or putt‐putt area Remote parking with shuttle A disc golf course in the naturally wooded area of the Blair property. An 18‐hole course could fit within this area. Ditto to tunnel Butterfly garden Support completion of Tulsa wave whitewater park Keep it natural/shady Boundless‐ big trees, de‐emphasize vehicular culture “Bring” river into park‐ retaining pond/canal Trail for the blind/Braille system Pond with sailboats (for kids) Large fountain A place to stroll Café Wake board cable park Artificial surfing wave Sufficient parking City transportation connections to other neighborhoods (mono rail) Organic fertility mgmt (no chemicals) Community garden Runners/walker trail Public art Drinking fountain Dog Park Plenty of seating Crow Creek to Brookside Retain existing (native) wildlife Pump track, bike skills park‐ has small footprint See Zink Park‐ Rockscaping, “Turkey Mt. in town” wild and safe and beautiful Nature screen for riverside (shrubs, noise barrier) Shade and benches in the shade Community garden where people can tend their own plots of garden Children’s museum (low admission) Median in Riverside Contemporary public art 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Rower friendly development (boathouse, higher water level) Native plants Carousel Zipline from Turkey Mtn. to Blair Land bridge connecting Blair Property to river Rowing Club needs water and long course! Kayak center is in OKC on a fake concrete river. We need to encourage kayaking here. Bicycle velodrome = get the kids off the street Like Millennium Park in Chicago An off‐leash dog park (1‐2 acres) similar to existing parks on Charles Page and Hunter Park  Ditto! Coordinate and enhance Zink Dam improvements being planned Don’t take away the green expanse for parking! Connect to Brookside‐ by way of Crow Creek Provide Northbound traffic east of existing underpass (below pedestrian bridge) Save the lowlands hardwood forest! Re‐establish native wildlife: Birds, mammals etc. Water taxis! Use the lake for viewing and connect‐acres Consider vehicular generated air pollution Walk‐through aviary Boating, canoeing, Kayaking, swimming Retail and food Connect to Brookside Connect to Brookside w/ a canal both east/west Design like Stanley Park in Vancouver , Canada (beautiful flower beds, trails, restaurants) Unique play areas‐zipline, ropes course etc., bike rentals Waterpark for kids like the one in Brooklyn Bridge Park Modern sculpture garden (miniature Storm King) Fountains/waterfall Land Bridge over Riverside drive connecting park to river Nice restrooms that are hands free Hand gel dispensers throughout park Smoking area that is designated 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Splash pad/ice skating rink Small amusement park for kids like the one in Bartlesville Skateboarding park More trees More places to sit Amphitheater—great place for live music Keep it natural. Planned “activities” are not needed so close to the neighborhood Rowing friendly river—reliable water level. World class Whitewater park A movie projection screen installed so that old movies could be shown, and a summer movie film series held in the park. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
What do you like about the current site? This site is habitat for both water and land birds. A pair of Belted Kingfishers appear to be nesting somewhere around light pole 133, Riverwalk East. I have noticed nesting pairs over the years along the river from 21st to 42nd. This whole area is crucial for both Oklahoma resident birds as well as for migrants. Any reconstruction of habitat should be discussed with the Oklahoma Ornithological Society. Great green space close to the river, which is the city’s crown jewel still somewhat undiscovered by many. That it is left in a natural state with native plants and grasses. This is great for local wildlife, including migrating birds in spring and fall and local birds year round. It provides food, shelter, and places for rearing young. Its natural beauty, location, and historical significance. I like the visual spaciousness of the large lawn in front of the white house and the fact that the trail area is the home to many species of birds. I like that the trail connects the downtown area with the river area. I like the PSO sign across the river and the bridge across the river. I most value and enjoy the WOODs running south of the Blair House, and I use several times a week the Midland Valley Trail just east of the Blair House. Therefore I'm very concerned that the GatheringPlace development leave the WOODS undisturbed and do as little damage as possible to the woods on either side of the Midland Valley Trail. Both are priceless and unusually fine natural amenities for an urban area and should be protected. As for the large, flat and open area along Riverside Drive, I think it's ideal for recontouring into a casual recreational area consisting of grasses, shrubs, trees and walking paths. Such development could include a Japanese tea garden and a wildflower "meadow" that would attract butterflies and songbirds. I hope something like this can become a reality, rather than the flat and uninteresting "lawn" that merely invites Canada geese to congregate, and a monoculture of grass and pesticides to rid the lawn of weeds. Joseph Copenhaver T.D.S.A. member (507)…I would like to say that it’s really good to see something come of the property at 31 riverside. Would love to see disc golf course there… The possibilities of development. When I first starting coming to Tulsa in the early 1970's, I was extremely impressed by the beautiful, gigantic, stately front yard and house (Blair estate) which I felt to some degree....was the essence of Tulsa, Oklahoma. That setting could/should be a postcard for Tulsa. It really made a profound statement regarding Tulsa and its' beauty. Please, please, please leave the front yard and house as is......leave the elegance of simplicity as is. Hopefully the house could be turned into some type of museum or art gallery or a location for the Historical Society, etc. As you know it has many acres behind it which could be some type of a "natural park" setting.....kind of like Woodward park.......but please leave the front yard as is. As to the "apartments on Crow Creek" property, I have no strong opinion....but would hope it could have as much greenery as possible. Thanks for considering these comments/ideas. Proximity to downtown and Brookside. It would be great to see all of our districts and popular areas linked by more than run down, residential or unattractive corridors. It's perfect, don't touch it! I have been running on the Midland Trail for 30 years and always thought the Blair property was beautiful. I have always felt so lucky to have what I call the "back trail" to run on and walk the dogs. I have seen owls, foxes, raccoons, etc., on an given day. I would only hope that nothing is proposed that would cut down trees or destroy 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
the natural beauty. I am thankful to GKF for all of the wonderful things they have done to enhance the trail on Riverside and on the West Bank. Beautiful views. Well connected to River Parks. Access to the low water dam. Access to the bike path (abandoned RR tracks). Access to the pedestrian bridge & west side of the Arkansas River. Large enough to host very large functions or several smaller functions at the same time. There three sites may function as a single site or separately. The locater dam is actually very beautiful, but the property is far to small to be truly appreciated by the citizens. This park will allow the citizens to see the dam and interact with the area surrounding the dam. This will have an enormous impact on the citizens appreciation of the river and the amenities the City has already constructed. Nothing could promote further development of the river as an amenity for Tulsa, Sand Springs, Jenks, and Bixby more than this project (Owasso will appreciate the economic impact of strengthening the metro area). Will breath new life into the development (or redevelopment) of Crow Creek. Will connect the river to Brookside to the river. With the addition strategically located public parking structures, this park could spur a new round of commercial development in Brookside (an area that is far from meeting its potential). Crow creek may be redeveloped with a focus on commercial instead of residential (or even better high density mixed use development). Will bring about a (much needed) public debate about the development (redevelopment) of the residential area adjacent to Riverside Drive to increase the density so that more people may enjoy the river as a life shaping amenity to Tulsa. I want to see nothing done to this site, there will be many, many of residences of the Sundance and Legacy apartments that will be displaced. BAD IDEA!!! The Blair Property green is a unique and beautiful asset. I am familiar with concepts that preserve most of the green and develop at the edges of it. I think this is the right idea. Its size and expanse. It is remarkable to have such a large green space in the heart of a city. I also like the potential to easily connect to the neighborhoods and Midland Valley trail to the east, and the River to the west (and from the river trails south to Broken Arrow and north to Skiatook). Great. This area should be utilized for something besides parking lot. The parking lot off of 31st is a buffer for the traffic noise from Riverside drive, as is the Blair property. I like the open greenspace in front of the Mansion, but I think it would be nicer to plant some trees on it. That would become a prime picnic area. I like the Blair mansion. I like seeing this Tulsa Landmark while driving down Riverside. What a gift from the Kaiser Family Foundation to the city, considering the insulting defeat of the Kaiser‐supported bond issue of a few years ago, principally by unprogressive, myopic county voters, not city residents. Any development in this area will be welcomed and enjoyed by thousands of appreciative residents and visitors far into the future. Kudos to the Kaiser family for your continued selfless generosity and vision for all Oklahomans. Pedestrian connections to river, neighborhoods and Brookside. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
I love the grove of trees on the Southeast side of the Blair property. The "old growth" look of it should be preserved and enhanced. Close by to our home a lot of land available biking trails and walking area already separated great views The wide open space, the house on the property and the horses. When I lived in Brooklyn, I loved the horseback riding ability. I would love to see those horses and stables stay and perhaps make some trail riding area in there. It is a gathering place for the Tulsa community. The most active and diverse of all of the places in town. The vast open space in front of the Blair property is a treasure. I'm very excited about the prospects for development, but I hope a significant portion of the open space can be preserved. Jogging/biking trail along the river including Midland trail into the neighborhood. Love the wide open field in front of the Blair Mansion That my apartment is on it Everything!!! This is great for Tulsa!!! Go Mr. Kaiser!!! I appreciate what you (George Kaiser) are doing for Tulsa I own the apartment property at 21st and Riverside, across the street from the Blue Rose Restaurant. I am working on a new project for this property that will fit right in with your project. Feel free to contact me if you are interested. (Greyfoxprop@gmail.com) A mail piece by the GKF Foundation about the neighborhood meeting… It is green. I would like to see rock climbing structure like the one on the University of Washington in Seattle. It would really compliment the outdoor sports for the area, plus it would be really fun. Check it out! I like it. I'll like it more once more possible develop art is created I am most interested in learning how this proposed project will effect the Legacy Apartments. I have an elderly Mother who lives there, on a very low and fixed income. Re‐locating her to an affordable location creates a serious hardship. Please Advise. Doesn’t seem like there would be enough parking, unless most is underground (which would be great). The closeness to the river and River Parks system. River Parks trails are really nice. Lots of mature trees! The improved bike trails. Natural beauty of the river. I have always loved this spot since I was a teen in the 60's. Of course it was very romantic with the white house set back with such large grounds. I like that it is close to downtown and the bike trail as well. That is my neighborhood. It would be nice to keep the natural feel with all the large trees etc. I enjoy the bike trail and the river for the nature. I like the fact that we have wild life along the river and native plants etc. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Close to downtown with wide‐open and forested portions bordering riverparks. Crow Creek is another asset needing improvement and protection. Large area of natural environment with random seating; some separate playground areas and open areas for sport; nature sculptures along the river Location, location, location. I always thought the Blair Mansion was going to be the Cherokee Yaght Club with slips so folks could sail right up to the clubhouse for lunch, dinner and then get back on the water. Do Tulsans know the Mansion is a replica of Monticello? Green Space Great green space close to the river, which is the city’s crown jewel still somewhat undiscovered by many. What do you not like about the current site? I like the current site fine Barrier of Riverside Drive and safety of pedestrians needing to cross to access the trails and the river itself. The corner of 31st and Riverside is a bottleneck of vehicles turning onto Riverside Drive and vehicles turning 31st Street, plus vehicles turning into and out of the entrance to the parking lot for the pedestrian bridge. block traffic from both directions on 31st at the intersection. It is unsafe and impedes the flow of traffic. It's fine as is. Don't change it. The abuse to the area from dog owners. The entire area is covered with dog feces, and urine is on every public light pole, bench and sculpture. I don't think the dog owners know that the animals are simply marking territory. There is no need for a dog to have to urinate 15 times on a one mile walk. The dog owners need some training about animal behavior prior to buying, (in my opinion), a worthless animal that is going to destroy public property. Do not like the current Barrier of Riverside Drive and safety of pedestrians needing to cross to access the trails and the river itself. The possibility that it is going to be "improved". Aren't there enough other "gathering places" nearby that this area can be left as is? I love the current site, except for the devastating news that the Blair Mansion itself will be removed. I was dumbfounded to learn that; it destroys one of the main reasons why Tulsans feel so attached to the property. Is there not any way the seller could be persuaded to reconsider? It's like removing a mini "Tara!" :) I live just behind the current parking lot (2940 South Boston Place) and I do not like the parking lot and the type of activity that it attracts. I do not like the fact that there is not a public restroom available. I do not like that the trail is elevated and looks down into the neighborhood houses and that it is only one lane wide which forces walkers/runners and bikers to share the same lane I have some fear that park development so close to the Riverwalk recreational areas and future shops will invade the present peace and natural beauty of the woods and the Midland Valley Trail. I think it's essential to protect the peace and quiet that can be found in those areas now. I don't want to see the current pedestrian bridge area developed any more than it already is. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Barrier of Riverside Drive and safety of pedestrians needing to cross to access the trails and the river itself. That it does not extend further South. It would be nice to connect the growth that is planned for this area to the park at 41st and Riverside and then to the 71st St. bridge. That the beautiful replica of Jefferson Davis' Beauvoir House is hidden at the back of the property. It should be moved more into the forefront of the property. There is nothing no to like about the Blair property. The apartments have been there so long, I cannot even imagine the land there without them! That might be a good spot for a children's park with water features. Convenient and safe pedestrian/bike access to all points of interest ( crossing Riverside Drive, crossing 31st Street) currently this is dangerous. Cars and pedestrians must be separated (it would be even better if pedestrians and bicycles also had some separation). PARKING, PARKING, PARKING! Currently and for the near future, cars are the primary mode of transportation in Tulsa. Strategically located public parking structures are essential to immediate success of this exciting project. Bus, trolley, walking and bicycles will make great gains in popularity and we begin to actually plan convenient and safe ways to use alternative transportation. But we can't expect that tis will change overnight. The more opportunities we create for people to choose to live their life without depending on a car the more people will see this as a real possibility for them. This park may be a big boost to many recognizing other modes of transportation. Till then, CHOICE, is critical. Failure to provide parking, to force the public to use alternative forms of transportation will only cause a negative backlash and drive people away. I live at Legacy apartments and was shocked to see on news that I will have to move. Will displace 600 plus individuals from their homes. The configuration of Riverside Drive. The bend and dip at the old trestle is a bit of a wild ride. I wouldn't be opposed to a realignment of the street and some redesign for traffic calming. A little torn here. I recognize the importance of Riverside Dr as a north‐south parkway for automobiles, but I also worry about the traffic speed in this area. Its isolation. There is a lot of potential to improve access, but today it is an island. The high speed traffic on Riverside Dr. and 31st St., and barriers between the property and the neighborhoods surrounding it, make it difficult to reach. We live about a block from the site, but walk a half mile or more to reach it. More direct pedestrian/bike access from the neighborhoods would be great. Very close to homes. I do not like the apartments. I don't like the apartments that are there. I don't like the apartments at 31st and Riverside. I don't like the old run down parking area at 31st and Riverside. I don't like the difficult accessibility from the parking area to the Blair mansion grounds, the Midland Valley Trail or the main Riverside Trail. The location to the hub of the downtown development, which is critical to the vitality of the city as a whole. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
The apartments. If nothing comes of this except for the demolition of those two complexes, then most of us in the neighborhood would consider the project a success... The opening photo is offensive. Could you be any more blatant in showing your agenda? This might "appeal" to mind numb, PC indoctrinated 'hipster' kids, but those with a brain that are over 18 years old actually vote as well as provide the tax base from which "public works" proffer forth. Shoving race mixing in their/our faces is certainly counterproductive to support of stated goals. Obviously Riverside has to be dealt with in a way that contributes to an effective and timely commute, but also allows safe access from Blair to and from the tails and river. A pricey challenge to take it (Riverside) underground, but how else? We also need to accommodate 21st century mass‐trans options which could include electric rail coming across a double‐decked pedestrian bridge or a terminal on the west bank allowing pedestrian access across the same or improved bridge. traffic flow is accident prone near the 31st street bridge under the walkway ‐ very dangerous there is hardly ever any water in the river No food areas available not very kid friendly ‐ no activities currently concern about parking ‐ area at 41st street development already maxed out on many nice days The apartments. They are not only unsightly but they attract some rough folks to the neighborhood. I'm located directly in between both properties being discussed here. Also, you'd have to make sure there was ample room for parking otherwise our charming, kid‐friendly, quaint little side street (Boston Court) will become cluttered with visitors to the park and traffic. Crossing Riverside to get to the trail system. I live in the neighborhood. Riverside Drive noise is not as bad as the constant noise from the PSO plant across the river. Small and inadequate restrooms and drinking fountain on the west side of Riverside at 31st St I understand that this project will supposedly be a positive thing for River parks but in doing so I will be losing my home. I live in the Sundance apartments. It is close to my job and I feel safe there. These are the two main reasons I moved there. Now I will be forced to move. I do not feel this is fair. It is wrong. I do not appreciate this upcoming project. I do not support this planned construction and I absolutely do not support all parties involved. Any respect I had for the GKFF has been thrown out the window. I am a resident of the Sundance Apartments on 31st and Riverside and I love Riverside and the parks and trails.... it is pleasant and convenient for me to exercise or take my dog for walks. Is it really necessary to have more park and less residents? If I have to move across town to another complex I would not frequent River parks as often if at all. There are several other nice park areas in the vicinity to picnic or lounge around at in addition to what is already available at River Parks so why create more. Also Sundance are some of the nicest apartments I looked at when I moved to Tulsa (other than the outrageous priced ones). This place is ideal in location, its small, well kept, and I know the staff and they know me and my neighbors. I would be very saddened if if it was torn down to make "a gathering place for Tulsa". That I have neighbors I would like historical garden that reflects the prairie and natural plants that have been replaced by stuff that just grows fast. Check out Stone Mountain in ATl area. They have a cool garden walk that explains the native plants and 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
preserves the history of the area. IT would be really cool to include native corn that may not even be grown in the area. The two apartment complexes. Place One apartments are old and run down. Crow Creek is under‐utilized. The places where the bike trail has not been updated are very hard on cyclists with regard to having to deal with the pedestrian traffic. Crossing Riverside to get to the trail system. Sometimes the mosquitoes can be a big problem with the swamp like area just below the walking path that is the old railroad. I don’t like the congestion at the 31st st. bridge. Vegetation along the river is too thick in some parts; tasteful (no junky) structures for refreshment. I worry about parking It is a wide open lawn with no definition and no activity. While additional park space will be a plus, what Tulsa truly needs is more urban green spaces. Not just wide expanses that are lightly active in the day and dead at sundown, but defined park spaces that provide an urban amenity with "eyes on the park" 24‐7 if possible. Access from the neighborhoods is not pedestrian and biker friendly What would you like to see at the new site? exactly what is there now, nothing more, nothing less.
Remove the entrance and vehicle access from 31st Street, remove the parking lot on the south side of the pedestrian bridge and place a new parking lot on the Blair property on the north side of the running path that leads to the pedestrian bridge. There should be a turn lane from Riverside drive into the new parking lot, north of the pedestrian bridge. There could be a left turn lane from Riverside into the new lot also. There should be no left turn onto riverside from this parking lot. The parking lot south of the bridge should be removed and the area landscaped. A biking and running path should connect 31st to the pedestrian bridge and path, replacing the present drive. I think a tower that people could climb and see the surrounding area would be an iconic element to the park. A example would be the Bok tower gardens in Lake Wales, FL. I think one done in a beautiful Art Deco floral design would become a landmark for all of Oklahoma. Also a flame or light on top would add interest at night time. Please see attached picture of BOK tower in Florida. Or go to their website http://boktowergardens.org/ A climbing park...like Marymoor Park in Seattle, which has free standing climbing feature(s). The main climbing areas around Tulsa are at Chandler Park or some secret spots known within the climbing community. That's unfortunate because climbing is a great sport and would be very appealing to a diverse segment of Tulsa...families, teens and adults. The added benefit to a climbing feature is that climbing, as a recreational activity, is still new in Oklahoma. The park proposal has an opportunity to be a "one of kind" climbing experience which can only be duplicated in urban areas like Portland, Seattle or Austin. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
An interactive fountain like the Uncle Wilbur fountain in downtown Colorado Springs. Below is some information about their fountain, but we have so many incredible local artists it would be wonderful to have one of them design a fountain unique to Tulsa. Wilbur Fountain was created in 2001. This is what the official Uncle Wilbur Fountain website says: " ... [a] delightful sculpture [with] 52 vertical pop jets, over 200 unpredictable streams of water, dozens of colorful fiber‐optic lights, danceable scores, and a water‐themed riddle that, when the fountain is on, is accessible only to those willing to "take the plunge" and venture beneath the waterfall cascading from Wilber's sky‐blue dome." SO MUCH FUN! I have photographs of the fountain if you would like to see them. Water in the River, all the time. Starting with just south of the 96th street bridge there should be water in the river throughout all of Tulsa. My job is to recruit people to Tulsa and every sinlge person I tour through our great city comments about how odd it is to not have a RIVER in our RIVER. More "free" bike rentals, like the Saint Francis Tulsa Townies. I don't have any specific wishes for this site, other than for it to truly be a destination for Tulsa and an attractive place for those visiting and considering moving here. My job is to recruit people to Tulsa and I feel like the tour of Tulsa and they "vibe" they get from it either wins it or kills it for us. While I will happily say that Tulsa has had a palpable increase in energy in the past few years, we're still light years away from where we could be. Concessions, outdoor dining, plenty of green space for frisbee/kites, splash pads, small concert area, dog park, playground equipment (tree fort style), restrooms, under or overpass to RiverParks at several locations, trails for walking/jogging, water fountains, trees, trees. Tivoli Gardens, as in Denmark (http://www.tivoli.dk/composite‐3351.htm), which I have never seen but have about, often. The wooded area could be a strolling place, with lots of lights in the trees for the evening, sculptures, picnic areas, etc during the day. An amusement park, restaurants, and indoor stage (there is already an outdoor venue, across the River). "Stay off the lawn" signs... I think the Blair area should be preserved as much as possible as far as trees and grassland. Maybe a picnic area there with tables would be nice. No playground equipment or parking lots. Maybe we could save that one little spot and keep it more attractive to those without children. So no swings, soccer, etc. A secure, family friendly destination. This should become the primary location for short duration public events (Water sports, German Fest, (May Fest?), farmers markets). We have enough parks, use the money to improve existing parks. public art,,, hands on type...we and other artists did some work for the City of Chattanooga and would love to see this type of art located here at this site...sounds like a grand idea... Something unique and interesting...like a white water rafting park. Any chance we could bury Riverside? I'd like to see strong pedestrian and transit connections to downtown and Brookside. Improved pedestrian, stroller, wheelchair, and bicycle access, all around, and safe and attractive connections ('gateways') to the neighborhoods to the north and east. Wide sidewalks on 31st St. would be great. An easy 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Walkable connection to Brookside would also be nice. The whole site should be 'sutured' to everything around it. Imaginative play areas would be preferable to prescriptive play areas. In other words, inherently interesting landscapes, structures, and objects would be preferable to 'designated play equipment' (standard bars, swings, slides, etc.). Give kids interesting landscapes, but leave the contours of play to childrens' imaginations. Small‐scale, local commercial ventures would be great, to provide amenities and to generate sufficient revenue to maintain the parks in perpetuity. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR WHAT YOU ARE DOING FOR THE COMMUNITY!!! New way for Midland Valley Trail to connect with this area. I use it often and the way it's connected to the parking lot lacks a lot. It's very rough and the parking lot is isolated, my group never parks there for safety reasons. Needs a water fountain and maybe a restroom. I love the landscaping of the River Parks area and I think this area should keep with the same theme. Play ground maybe, but splash pad attracts way too many people and gets congested. If it gets congested, the trail affect is lost. Just park area, nothing commercial. I would like to see a swimming pool, some splash pads, a fountain feature, a zip line, a rock climbing wall, a rappelling wall, and a skate park included. I would like to see interactive water features suitable for young children and their families similar to what is in place at 41st and Riverside. I would like plenty of shaded seating for adults surrounding the water features play area. I would like a top notch play ground with swings, climbing walls, bridges etc nearby. I would like a trail system to safely and easily get from one end of the proposed area to the other. I would like the Blair mansion to remain and perhaps be rented out for weddings, banquets etc. I would like the Blair mansion to have lavishly landscaped gardens with water features and stone walking paths. Some thoughts on the gathering place: I love music so my first thought is a venue for indoor/outdoor music. When I take my 3 year old granddaughter to some of the parks around town, I notice that there aren't either enough of the toddler size toys/equipment or they aren't entertaining enough to keep their attention. I also note that a lot of teenagers hang out on the toys, not allowing smaller children to play on them so maybe "big kid" outdoor equipment for them! Surprise me with the inclusion of Native American statues and memorabilia. Hopefully, Gilcrease will become involved in displaying some of its treasures central to our native heritage. A cop checking for green cards… It would be nice if the peace and serenity of "the grove" (of old growth trees) could be maintained. It would be nice if it was developed with a water feature (stream) running trough it (the grove) out into the larger open area on the lawn where the water could be part of a wading pool/splash pad area. Make "the grove" a quiet place posted with signs that require any speaking be a soft conversational level with no yelling, shouting, music, etc. In "the grove" ideally the only sounds would be the sound of a stream and birds singing. The grove would also have open meditation spaces within it where people could whenever they wish engage in meditation, yoga, tai chi (sp), etc. and maybe some larger areas where classes could be held for free. The lawn would have elements and spaces which contributed to and supported activities cultivating physical and mental well‐being, cultural awareness, community building (critically needed in this time of runaway incivility, intolerance, apathy, obesity, etc.). The lawn would have a suitable stage for performances by everyone from the symphony to high school jazz bands, from poetry readings to chautauquas, from bluegrass duos to gospel choirs. An endowed fund could be established with which to underwrite regular performances of all of the above. Also somewhere on the grounds would be a tasteful "points of interest" display/grand kiosk speaking to the other points of interest in the greater Tulsa metro area (JHF Reconciliation Plaza, Gilcrease, Philbrook, Sherwin Miller, Route 66, Blue Dome district...). Summing up, this is a 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
wonderful once in a lifetime opportunity to create "TULSA'S FRONT YARD." Let's give thought to doing so in a way that calls upon the things from our past when communities interacted, homogenized, came to know, support and engage each other in truly meaningful ways (a spirit of "we're all in this together, so lets not just get along, but grow closer"), but also with a nod toward creating opportunities for enhancing physical and mental well‐being. Horseback riding. A doggy beach (again, this is an idea from Prospect Park). More diverse terrain. Add some hills. I think a large portion of the big lawn should remain as is for concerts or classic movies or opera in the park. Petting zoo. I think that the existing home should stay and be a site for hosting family friendly educational events, light healthy concessions, rest‐areas etc, calendar of events etc. You are also more than welcome to buy all the homes on Boston Court and have that be your path connecting the two...mine being one of them. ;‐) Perhaps where the apartments are could be an upscale river‐walk...or crow‐creek walk...as it were...and have lowkey nice restaurants with patios, not cheese‐ball sports bars. In fact I'd say NO bars. Keep it clean. Keep it family friendly. A Children's Museum and/or Discovery Center! lighting, landscaping, water features, stone work, gardens, and open space. Snowcone stand on weekends during June‐Sept. More benches Bike rental spot Chess tables Refreshment stand on weekends during summer (reasonably priced hot dogs, nachos, soda Stage with bands playing music on weekends during summer In the newly purchased acres (only) along Riverside, split to a split‐level bridge going North and South to allow pedestrians a safe place to cross Riverside (walking East and West) and yet keep the traffic flowing North and South along Riverside. (either pedestrians walk on the top level and traffic would be underneath, or vice‐versa.) Include a stacked vertical parking garage at that same area because parking is always a problem in Brookside. Have an outdoor amphitheater like the one at the Jenks Riverwalk. Include a backdrop of a white cinder block wall to use as an outdoor movie screen, to view outdoor movies. Include areas to sit on concrete graduated steps, and on a lawn. Have a swimming pool. In the Winter, cover it up and turn it into an ice skating rink for the holidays. Have covered picnic tables and bicycle rental and a splash pad for the little children. I am so grateful for your deep generosity to the city and all you have done to make Tulsa a wonderful place to live. My suggestion would be to put a pedestrian tunnel under riverside so people can get across the street safely. I also think that some "lunch type/food truck" facilities would be wonderful. Would like to see Crow creek used as an pedestrian access to river parks. Also expanding a trail all the way to the Brookside area. A large 'landbridge' tying the new area to the river. Would need to have Riverside drive go under bridge in this area. This could be in the middle of the park where current midland trail goes over riverside. Also have two pedestrian walkways go under Riverside drive at both ends. Could use existing crow creek to go under Riverside at the south end. It would be nice to have a sidewalk on the East side of Riverside Drive between 21st and 26th Pl(or new Gathering Place). Currently neighborhood has no access to safe crossing over Riverside Drive. I am a high school math and pre‐engineering teacher. I am having my students dream about what this space could look like for a class project/test. I will be mailing their proposals to you unless there is a more efficient way to communicate their ideas to you. Any acknowledgement from you of their ideas would be very powerful in their lives. Thanks so much! Xan Black ‐ Mingo Valley Christian School 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Suggestions on a gentle relocation program for the hundreds of people who will be looking for a new home when you tear down Sundance and Legacy Apartments. My townhouse surrounded by a park. Can you do that? It would make me very happy… My name is Vaun Poffenbarger, I recently heard there was possibility for a disc golf course on the Blair mansion property and just wanted to chime in with my two sense in saying I thought it was a great idea. I’ve never seen as many people start to get up and off the couch and actually get a little exercise as I have with disc golf recently. Not only does it make the city look good and help local businesses to thrive from after disc golf hunger, but it looks a lot better than anything else I could think to put there. Thank you for your consideration, Vaun Poffenbarger. Disc golf course Greetings, I would love to see a disc golf course winding through the woods of the prpety….or anywhere on the property for that matter. Disc golf is a great blend of exercise, fun and recreation for all ages. Thank you for your time. Jeremy Geiger. I think there should be a new disc golf on the Blair property. I am seeing more and more families on the disc golf courses… A new disc golf course would be really cool Hello, I am an avid Tulsa parks support and love the community of riverparks. I think another disc golf course could be useful to bring people into our area and get more familiar with the flora/fauna of green county. Something scenic, kind of like woodward park. The current course is just too hazardous for hitting cars/pedestrians and even children who play at the playground. Thanks for reading! Free disc golf course! Greetings: Would love to see a disc golf course put in at the mansion! Mike Connors Disc golf course!!!!!!!! I work a shop at riverside park during the summer and I see hundreds of people a day at the park just for disc golf. Also in the past 4 years I’ve seen the numbers of golfers grow drastically. Just an idea if you want a gathering place for Tulsa  Greetings—I wanted to take a quick moment to say how pleased I am to see Tulsa’s continued progress in developing community resources to provide a better place to raise a family. I wanted to lend my support for developing a disc golf course for this area. The popularity of disc golf at its current Riverside location is a simple example of the benefit an additional course would be to Tulsa. The local avid and recreational disc golf community have a distinct advantage for maintaining and promoting new and existing courses in Green Country. I currently teach Business Management classes at Oklahoma State University‐Tulsa, including Sports Management. We use disc golf as an example in this course about non‐traditional sports and how they can provide tangible economic and social impact on community. Thank you for the opportunity to let my voice be heard. Please let me know if I can further explain my support for including a disc golf course in this project. Jeffrey B. Paul, Ph.D. I think it would be a great place for a disc golf course. I live in the Claremore area. We come to Tulsa often ad a Disc Golf Course would be a great idea for this location. A disc golf course would be a great investment for the Blair Mansion Property! Thank you. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
I, along with several others in our disc golf community, think that this section of land would be an excellent area for a new disc golf course. Disc golf courses are relatively cheap to install (around $750 a hole for quality materials), is low impact, wouldn't block off the property from other uses, and is one of the most popular sports in Tulsa (we have ten 18‐hole courses in the Tulsa area, many of them tournament quality, plus many more 9‐hole courses). New courses have recently gone up in Broken Arrow (Neinhuis park) and at NSU‐BA, a testament to how quickly the sport is growing and a quality course can even help draw people from out of town to come and play both casually and in tournaments (we run about 15 local tournaments of note each year, many bringing people in from outside Tulsa). Disc golf popular among all ages and we see everyone aged from eight to seventy‐eight on the course regularly. Our local Tulsa Disc Sports Association would be happy to help in assisting with this new course as well. I hope you'll seriously consider using part of the land to contribute to a new disc golf course on such beautiful land. It's an excellent game with no downside, little cost to put in the course and draw to all people. Please feel free to contact me if you need to speak with someone from the TDSA concerning this possibility further. +16 Seriously, is nature not sacred at all anymore to anyone? Just because someone has a lot of money to throw around, why destroy the beauty of this little peace of nature. This area has been a joy forever just as is to so many. Areas like this are becoming fewer and fewer because of man's selfish, self‐serving wasteful destruction. Some of us actually enjoy just getting outdoors and walking and enjoying the peace and tranquility this area offers on its own. It is also one of the few areas birders can visit to see once in a lifetime the most beautiful songbirds, warblers and vireos, some on the endangered list for the very reason that habitat and important migratory routes are being destroyed‐ habitat loss. Please this is just such a place that is so important, so very important to maintain and not destroy. When you destroy nature, you're destroying life. But for nature and all that it offers, many folks would have nothing left to enjoy. Please, please, please ‐ if there are hands and money so itchy for ideas to take hold of, why not replenish this area with more nature‐ make it a more beautiful trail with more trees, butterfly gardens, bird bath fountains, little ponds and waterfalls.. Don't destroy the area just to make a place for another silly, boring concrete human establishment or manmade structure to dwell in. Haven't we seen enough of that already? When is enough enough? It is beyond my comprehension why people do not take advantage of nature and all it has to offer. Pay attention! Go for a walk. As Arme Frank wrote, "Think,!! all the beauty stilll around you and be happy!" It's healthier for the mind, body and soul ‐‐ certainly more than anything man can build. It will be pitifully sad and tragic in more ways than one if this sweet, natural environment is destroyed and replaced with some god awful boring manmade whatever. Haven't we destroyed enough natural habitat? For God's sake, why do we need more "gathering places" for humans? Aren't there enough places in Tulsa to satisfy our needs for food, coffee, drink, etc? Do we need to destroy more natural wonders which provide "food for the soul" and shelter for endangered bird species? And, finally, if you hadn't noticed, take a look at the path itself ‐‐ it already provides a "gathering place " for thousands of Tulsans yearly as they walk, bicycle, run, hike an even bird watch together. What's next for the George Kaiser Foundation ‐ raze Woodward Park to the ground? A broad promenade along the river where people can walk and get down to the river level, but also with on or two overlook areas which extend out a small ways into the water. Fountains along the promenade where children can play in the water on hot Oklahoma summer days. I have attached a few pictures of a fountain at Sea World in Orlando. LED or fiber optic lights imbedded into the sidewalks which can be seen at dusk & night. They could be abstract patterns or form moving images which magically appear giving a feeling of wonder to kids and adults alike. I also have attached photos of sidewalks like this at Epcot in Orlando. First, I think it should be a "destination" project. In other words, a place where folks can visit, learn, contemplate, rest, read, experience beauty, have fun and feel like they are no longer in the city. Similar to Central Park in NY. There should be lots of lighting, recycle/trash receptacles, walking paths, benches, tall trees (oaks, maples, pecan) and floral features (redbuds, crepe myrtles, roses, butterfly bushes, etc), (educational boards that "teach" about animals, plants, the environment, recycling, history, etc), bird and animal habitats, beautiful sculptures, plants to 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
attract birds, butterflies and other animals. There should be some wrought iron guardrails/fencing where you want folks to "view" but not trample through and destroy. Consider a focal point in the middle of the open space, like a very large waler feature to tie in with the Arkansas River or, interactive pirate ship or even bigger. Disney World has built the Swiss Family Robinson/Robinson Caruso Tree House in three or four of its theme parks. It is a huge draw for families and IS enduring in its popularity. The view of the river would be great as you climb to the top of the structure. It would be indestructible as it is made of concrete to look like a tree,(I large branches and places to sit and enjoy the view. A large public water feature with fountain, would also be great. Parking should be separate from the park, designed so folks walk or ride their bikes. No cars should be allowed in this space. It should also be a gun free/smoke‐free space. What about a beautiful gazebo for outdoor entertaining? Folks could bring folding chairs or blankets to hear music or speakers. Use the existing southern‐style home for public restrooms, drink and snack sales (or vending machines), rental space for weddings or receptions (charge a fee), and/or a meeting space. The front porch could be used for public entertainment, concerts, speakers, "Chautauqua" actors, etc. It would need great acoustics, electric outlets and lighting. Also, let the public get financially linked, by allowing contributions, both large and small. Donor's names on bricks or small plaques in the park, would create a broad feeling of "ownership" in the project. At least two pedestrian/bicycle bridges, built from the park across Riverside drive toward the river, would be necessary to keep folks from "crossing" Riverside drive and getting injured. –Carol Klenda Please keep the site as natural as possible – and park‐like, not commercial. Playground, climbing rocks/wall, water features, small scale restaurant/coffee shop would be great but no retail or amusement park rides (!). Linsk to and extension of River Parks Trail critical. Thanks for the opportunity to comment. Here's a thought on the Blair Mansion grounds ‐‐‐ not related to my work at all ‐‐‐ a personal opinion as a lifelong Tulsan: would hate to see the mansion moved away from the law . Couldn't it be repurposed on the site? I've seen a plan that shows Riverside going up behind the mansion along the old rail trail for a block or a few. I don't have a problem with that, but I think it would be mistake to remove the mansion ‐‐‐ if I understand correctly about the plan. That mansion makes the lawn more than a field and it would make it more than just a spectacularly average park because it's almost a natural piece of the setting that says Tulsa. Without it you'll create an awesome park that could be found in Any City, USA ‐‐ any city that's fortunate enough to have the genorosity of Mr. Kaiser and company. Just an opinion from someone who's not footing the bill. So, take it for what it's worth . I'd also like to see Crow Creek take on a look like the canal in Georgetown for the little stretch that would be in the park. Thank you for even asking and thank you for looking after our home town. My biggest hope would be that the refineries are reconstructed by the Port of Catoosa and that Disney build "Disney Pixa’s Route 66 America" on part of the 800 acre old Sunoco site. I'd like to see an NFL stadium with the Oklahoma Mustangs (old Jacksonville Jaguars). I agree education and early child care are vital, but I also see how a massive, flashy, development can jump start a community by building excitement like the Thunder has done for OKC. I don't even care about the NFL, but some of our other more basic goals could be accomplished jf more creative, funseeking younger people were here. A large state‐of‐the‐art.miniature golf course unlike any other in the world. It could feature miniature replicas of Tulsa's most famous landmarks with elaborate landscaping features (various elevations, water falls and creeks, lots of beautiful trees, etc.). If it would be "Walt Disney quality" th is would be something light years ahead of Gilligan's Island at 61st Street and Highway 169 as well as a national and international destination and major family‐oriented tourism draw. Thanks for your consideration! People enjoying the outside and the river. To attract people something to draw interest may be considered, something that expresses the uniqueness of Tulsa and the Arkansas River. Build it and they will come. We are all dreamers. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
In the neighborhood meeting on Feb. 29, Jeff Stava said that there could be a bike shop, running store, canoe shop and a market that would sell milk, bread and things that people might want in the park. A small market would be fine, but a 24 hour Quikmart would not be something we want or need in our neighborhood. Mr. Stava also made the comment that many of the homes in the area of the new park, do not face Riverside Drive, implying what we cannot see should not concern us. My back yard backs up to the parking area at 30th and Riverside, my house may not face the river, but when we sit in our yard we can see the cyclist and runners, that is why we purchased our home. The bikes and walkers were using the trails long before the improvements (not that we won't appreciate them), but we would not be happy with the backs of buildings or high concrete walls blocking our view. Plenty of trash cans so we can keep it clean AND recycling areas Lots of crepe myrtles. The ones added as part of River Parks remodeling look great and they do well here in Tulsa How about an additional way to get OVER Riverside Drive. Right now there is only one. With the extension of space on the east side, people will need a safe way to get over the trails. How about permanent “vendor booths” where local artists can set up like once a month or local growers can sell locally grown fruits and vegetables like a farmers market. I know there are a couple in town, but this would open them up to a wider audience making us a more sustainable city. Plenty of water fountains. The new ones in River Parks are great because you can also water your pets there too! Connect the old Boy Scout site on Peoria to this new space. As frequent user of river trail, have long had thoughts on public gathering space at River Parks. Not seeing time/place of public input meetings. I'm a poll worker so can't get to Tues meet, but will try to attend Wed. Several Wifi hotspots Separate bike and pedestrian lanes everywhere. More water in the river. More open, grassy spaces so people can lounge. Maybe a place for concerts. Why am I going to go there? I have no doubt that you will receive a long list of suggestions of what people will want to do at the park. and I do not have any particular wishes. I already enjoy the improved biking and jogging opportunities at the River Park which I access either by biking or running from my home in the Yorktown neighborhood. Like everyone else, I'll hang out at a park if others are hanging out at a park. One critical question will be. what can the park provide. which is not already offered by a different park. Perhaps closer to where Tulsans already live. If I lived close to LaFortune Park, am I going to want to come over to this park? I currently do live much closer to Woodward Park. which I can easily walk to. with its beautiful trees. other plantings and the WPA Rose Garden. Why am I going to want to go further to this other park? One strong draw will be that people from around Tulsa already enjoy coming over to the River Park. so the way the Gathering Place relates to River Park will be important. Fortunately. the Midland Valley Trail already crosses from the Gathering Place to the River Park. It is by the river. but the Gathering Space does not offer any special views of downtown. and the southern part of the park can only offer a view of the power plant across the river. There is also very little for the park to connect to on the west side of the river, although one could hope that some residents on the west side might decide to walk, bike or jog across the Midland Valley Bridge. How can this benefit the future development of the city? 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
The Gathering Place, along with other public improvements, can encourage locals to remain and new arrivals to stay. The working name for the project suggests one of the potential goals that the GKFF envisions which is for the people of Tulsa to actually see each other in some location. There is little in Tulsa that holds Tulsa together as a city. While the GKFF helps to move community projects forward, there is remarkably little that Tulsans themselves seem willing to undertake together. Viewing each other as "taxpayers" is hardly a strong basis for undertaking civic projects collectively and a shared sense of fate. Gathering in shopping centers does not encourage Tulsans to feel any particular connection to each other. The developments occurring downtown are important, because it can begin to give a focus to the city's energies. The Gathering Place can add to this other development by encouraging Tulsans to come to this larger gathering point which the Brady District. Downtown and the new baseball stadium are all helping. Tulsans need to develop a sense of some shared destiny, which will help encourage other civic projects. This park can help. but it needs to feel connected to the daily life of the city. Who is going to go there and when? The park needs to attract different users throughout the day and throughout the week. What will attract young mothers with children and retired people during the day? What will draw the workers in the early morning or evening? What will pull in families on the weekend? How am I going to get there? With its almost nonexistent public transportation system, Tulsans are only going to reach River Park and the new Gathering Space by driving, biking or walking . Because of Tulsa's extremely low population density and limited bike trails, most will have to drive whether they want to or not. The strong success of the River Park, thanks to the GKFF supported improvements, shows that Tulsans like to exercise in a beautiful and safe setting. Getting Tulsans to exercise is another important step to improving the overall city. Improving walking and biking access to the new Gathering Space can help guarantee its success and also help to minimize additional car traffic. There is relatively little that the current project can do to address these broader problems for the city, but making sure the park is well connected to the immediate surrounding community will be key. Limit parking, encourage day round usage from the local community, and do as much as possible, with the city, to improve walking and biking access. Fortunately, those who access the River Park from the north or the south by bike or on foot will easily reach the park. Connection to the surrounding community: Currently, River Park and the proposed GKFF Gathering Place are largely cut off from the Brookside and Maple Ridge neighborhoods by Riverside Drive. Those who wish to reach the River Park only have protected crossings at the stoplights at 18th‐Denver‐Riverside (the safety of which the city should work to improve), the Mid land Valley Bridge near 31st, 31st‐Riverside and 41st Riverside. I am sure people manage to run across the four lanes of traffic and the traffic is not always heavy, but it does create a barrier. Imagine a mother with a couple children living on E 35th Street ‐ she will need to drive to safely reach the park. She lives yards from the park, but with no access. Even though the 31st‐Riverside intersection offers a safe crossing, one first has to go down 31st St. with its narrow sidewalk, often with heavy traffic. There are many ways to analyze the movement of people around this part of the city, so I mention the above just as a preface for the following point: try to make the new GKFF sponsored park open up to those living immediately around the park and use the new park as a way to improve access to the River Park. S. Cincinnati Ave. will play an important part in this as it is the only connection between Maple Ridge and Brookside that pedestrians and cyclists can use without going out to 31st or Peoria, which are unpleasant because of the narrow sidewalks and extremely heavy traffic. This especially true on Peoria. Those living south of E34th between Riverside Dr. and Peoria are currently cut off from the new park development without a significant detour. A similar barrier exists between the proposed park and a good part of the Maple Ridge neighborhood, which will only have access from E25th via the Midland Valley Trail and a narrow, poorly marked, public access trough E 30th. The success of the park will be defined by how frequently it is used. Frequent usage also makes people feel safe and helps the public patrol itself against potential troublemakers, who may engage in nothing more than vandalism, but this still bears a cost. The better the new park is integrated and open to those living in the immediate neighborhood, the more frequently they will use it In this way, improving the usage and sense of security along the Midland Valley Trail can also be important to the Gathering Place's success. One potential development proposal: From the 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
reporting in the Tulsa World and the Urban Tulsa, the removal of the apartment complexes south of 31st sounds like a done deal. The overall goal is to improve the park space along the river, which is a good goal, and the current apartments appear to be underused and in poor condition. However, by removing the apartments, we are lowering the amount of housing in the center of the city and in a highly desirable location, if access to the park and shopping along Peoria (Brookside) is improved. Might it be worth to consider using part of the land for some new housing development with a medium or high density. A Children’s Museum and/or discovery center! Lighting, landscaping, water features, stone work, gardens and open space In the newly purchased acres (only) along Riverside, split to a split level bridge going Noth and South to allow pedestrians a safe place to cross Riverside and yet keep the traffic flowing North and South along Riverside. (either pedestrians walk on the top level and traffic would be underneath, or vice‐versa.) Include a stacked vertical parking garage .at that same area because parking is always a problem in Brookside. It would be nice to have a sidewalk on the East side of Riverside Drive between 21st and 26th Pl (or a new Gathering Place). Currently neighborhood has no access to safe crossing over Riverside Drive. Lawn left largely intact. Open air concert/theatre venue? http://www.takepart.com/article/20 1 2/02/21/its‐not ‐fairytale‐seattle‐ b u i I d‐nations‐first ‐food‐forest Plenty of Parking I would like to see better parking at 31st street. Pedestrian/bike bridge connecting River Parks to new site over Riverside Dr. Space for outdoor café/concessions. Preservation of open spaces for all manner of field sports and activities A library branch with a great view of the water. The building should have lots of river facing window space similar to Lafortune library's view of the pond and fountain. Additionally it should have good child facilities like Hardesty. A coffee shop inside like Hardesty used to have would be very nice. Tulsa county has the greatest library system of any city I've lived in. This proposed park just wouldn't be complete without a world class library branch to compliment Tulsa's others. Having a library at this location will be a natural extension of the rest of the facilities where visitors can flow in and out as they enjoy the rest of the park facilities. I've seen great parks (and Tulsa has some) and I've seen great libraries, but rarely do you see both complimenting each other. Hello. I am a native Tulsan of 38 years. I have long thought that what we need here is something really ‐ nice, to put it quite simply. Something, if not world‐class, then at least very noteworthy in this country. Something that people would associate with Tulsa, that could be featured prominently on post cards and shiny brochures about the city. Think about it. What do we have here that is truly unique and a "sight to behold?" Not much. The "Golden Driller" is ugly. Unique, but ugly. ~RU's praying hands or its spaceship structure? Not hardly. We don't need any more banks, restaurants, or shopping centers. One thing I thought of was a fountain. Not just an ordinary one, but a really nice one. It could be the centerpiece for the space. I'm not sure about the architectural style, whether more modern (but not wild and futuristic looking) or more traditional, but, please, no more bronze. I think we need something more lively and inviting for the space. A harmonious integration of the natural landscape with new development that is thoughtfully designed and created using natural, native materials as much as possible. And of course, a children's museum! :) What a great 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
space to show children and families the possibilities of honoring an eco‐system while enhancing its place in the community. A way to shield for Travis Park residents from park traffic and parking Public transit stop (hopefully light rail) Trail leading to Brookside shops I would hate to see some commercial development with shopping and restaurants. I would like to see nature emphasized and have some kind of education about the importance of a balance in nature. It would be great if the trees and plans used in the area could be trees with food for aniamsl and people. I am interested in Permaculture. The idea is that land tends to try to go back to a forest which is why one has to do so much yard work. If you plant a forest in an educated way, you do less work and receive food etc. How about a non‐profit group to run a demonstration facility that could educate about the type of plants and trees that can be used to prepare us to live more sustainably even in the urban center. Also, a spot for intimate local musical or small theater performance and lectures would be good too. Creating a facility that could grow and change as the needs of the citizens changed, a facility run by its citizens through non‐profit organizations and volunteer efforts that was responsive in an organic way to the concerns and interests of those taking advantage of the opportunities at the ground level. A large plaza with a fountain as the focal point much like you would find in Europe. A planetarium and a waterpark for families. A wide variety of features appealing to a diverse populous while preserving and enhancing the park’s natural beauty. Features will include rigorous physical activity opportunities. I see the site highlighting low‐maintenance and drought tolerant Oklahoma Native plantings that attract butterflies and other wildlife for the public's enjoyment and education, The site should protect the water quality of Crow Creek and partner with the Corp of Engineers and City of Tulsa with the planned aquiline restoration project. All of these efforts can benefit from a partnership with many local experts via non profits, governmental agencies, and civic groups. A structure/kiosk with story of early history of city’s settlement The potential of this project is tremendously exciting for our city. If we want‐it to be a true gathering place for Tulsans we should look at what has been successful in other cities. The premier example is Millennium Park in Chicago, which has it all‐‐first‐class art and architecture, a great pavilion for events, and beautiful gardens. Also notable is the relatively new City Garden in St. Louis, a blend of lush landscaping and fabulous sculpture. The sculpture garden in Minneapolis, adjacent to the Walker Arts Museum, with Claes Oldenburg's "Spoon bridge and Cherry" sculpture also comes to mind. And then there are gathering spots such as the Tuilieries and Luxembourg Gardens in Paris, where water ponds are such a magnet. If you look at these examples and more, you find that fabulous art, interactive water features and wonderful landscape are key to attracting people. Those are the ingredients that I hope will shape this project. Tulsa turned down a Claes Oldenburg sculpture, the "Cowboy Hat," which would have been a huge asset to our city's art. I hope that with his wonderful project on the river, we will think big and make it a place that not only becomes a favorite spot for Tulsa families but also distinguishes our city for its arts, its beauty, and its quality of life. Activate the park and its edges. Don’t just focus on the park’s interior amenities, but also finely tune and define the park’s edges with multiple uses. Please do not provide a big green gathering space which is alive during events and dead most other times. Tulsa needs more mixed use urban spaces with strong urban edges, whether it be via urban streets, boulevards, neighborhoods or parks. Move Riverside underground for a mile 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Preserve the open feeling. Preserve the woods and make them accessible. Create areas for unstructured play. Stuff like this: http ://publicworkshop.us/blog/20 11/06/20/berlin‐researching‐temporary‐land‐use‐policy‐playgroundsl or http: //citymuseum.org/ is amazing to me. Perhaps something on that scale would not work in this location, but those ideas of a place where people can create and lean and make mistakes is really appealing to me. Also, the parking lot at 31st and Riverside is really hard to get in and out of…Fixing that would be great. Another thing I would like to see is intentional integration into public transportation. As Tulsa works to increase the city wide use of the bus system, biking, walking, rail, etc. This could be a great destination that could serve as a catalyst for connecting disconnected parts of the city. Making planning for and making it intentional would be really good, its not just an after thought to stick a bus top sign on the edge of the park and call it good. (how about dedicated bus route that connects the aquarium, this park, the zoo, and the air and space museum to some other key part of town (downtown, east, west, north, south)? I would like to see a geology and petroleum exhibition, some of it outside, that celebrates Tulsa’s past as the “Oil Capital of the World.” And Tulsa’s present position as a petroleum center. Community gathering space, retail and restaurant space, and maybe condos. An outdoor amphitheater, an outdoor fountain/splash area, concessions, anything the increases access and safety for bikers, walkers, joggers, etc. increased parking areas and improved street crossings at 31st. Maybe the city would consider making 31st dead end into Riverside ... this would alleviate some traffic confusion, increase parking, and make it easier to cross at Riverside Both wooded and paved bike/walking trails, playgrounds, pond, picnic area, Bronzes, sculptures within the landscaped areas, flowers. Large open spaces for outdoor concerts, picnics and athletics, renewable energy features, sculpture, water features, a maze, bicycle storage, tennis courts, a public pool and clubhouse of some kind. In addition, perhaps an elevated bridge or underground tunnel solution, or something like building up the road and creating mini‐bridges for automobile traffic to address the parking issue. A water park for older and younger kids Disc golf course Plan for bike lanes and bike parking, sidewalks and public transportation to connect the park with downtown and the Brookside area. ADA compliance. I would also like to see English gardens with lots of walking trails and landscaping, and a playground with an Alice in Wonderland theme. Public artwork and an outdoor sculpture area. A high point with steps all around where people can view the park and the people and activities within it. I would love for Tulsa to have a spot with some of the essence of say the "Spanish Steps" in Rome. the steps on the hillside of the Sacre‐Coeur in Paris. the grand steps leading down to the pond in NYC's central park. the steps in front of the Central Library in NYC. People like to sit on steps and have a view, not just a view of scenery. but also of people. Often in classical parks there is a high point that contains a "folly". think the Castle in NYC's Central Park or it may have a gazebo, a monument or sculpture. When your sitting on steps leading up to something like that where there is a great view, even when there are lots of people around, it can somehow have a romantic, intimate feel to it. These spots also act as easily identifiable gathering and meeting places "everyone meet at the ......Imagine, just for an example for I am not concerned with the particulars, more the general concept and feel", a high point with steps on all four sides, on top of the high point a sculpture, structure or viewing platform of some sort. Whatever side you wish to sit on offers different viewing possibilities. Perhaps to one side there is a playground with children playing, on another side you can see the river. on another people walking through garden 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
trails amongst the trees, on another possibly a water feature. And, often these new parks with their patterns of curving trails, gardens, etc. look quite nice from a birds eye view. Why not let some of that be seen? Again. a high point with steps all around where people can view the park, other people and activities. Acts as an easily identifiable meeting point adds another "interesting thing to see and do" in the park, adds to the parks variations of height and depth. But, don't mistake what I am trying to get across as the usual. "steps leading down to the river" thing . That is indeed nice mind you, but it's not the same. Steps like I have described have the wonderful ability to somehow be a romantic place in which you can BOTH. Step away from it all. yet still be in the middle of it all. Thank you for the opportunity to share my idea Use of recycled materials, permeable surfaces, rain barrels. Also, an amphitheater and a parking garage to reduce the amount of impermeable surface at the site. A stone labyrinth and an old‐fashioned gazebo with a wooden dance floor! After commenting earlier I thought of a much better precedent for unlocking the potential of this site. Earlier I had mentioned a Chicago example, but a much better example for upgrading this kind of site is the Old Fourth Ward Park that just opened next to the Belt line Trail on the East Side of Atlanta. A lot can be learned from this precedent. In a way the two bike trails connecting your Tulsa site are similar to the 6elt line. Also the scale of the new Fourth Ward Park is instructive. Rather than creating a large mono land use called “park” it would be much better to graft a smaller urban park with multiple uses along its edges onto this site… Via the bike trails, Tulsa’s urban fabric could be extended from downtown. A large section of this site used to be garden apartments. While they were of a suburban template and prone to flooding, they were at least added to density to River Park’s edges. If you wipe away that density and lining with out replacing it you will actually decrease the urban quality of the location. The berm leading from the Midland Trail to the Pedestrian Bridge should be widened into a green plaza sloping from the current parking lot and from the Blair Mansion property and extending across Riverside Drive. If possible it should be expanded all the way to 31st St. creating a tunnel for Riverside Drive. The new property should have feel of incorporating the nearby neighborhood. I would also like to see a meadow like the one in Central Park, where people can sunbathe, play Frisbee/soccer, read. Etc. That should not be in the swampy part of the Blair Mansion property. What would you like to see at the new site? Another pedestrian access point could be created at Crow Creek under Riverside Drive minimizing the pedestrian traffic that would need to cross at 31st Street impacting traffic flow on Riverside Drive. ‐I support taking the underground parking off any project design layout. Underground parking does not provide good access from vehicles to the park activities and is, therefore, not user‐friendly. As you stated, underground parking creates an image that is in contrast with those of a park‐like setting. ‐I recommend a single‐lane access roadway design for the Blair property with two‐way traffic cross connections with parking. A single lane will reduce the visual impact of the roadway on the park setting. ‐I would prefer not to see a traffic light on Riverside Drive west of the Blair property for several reasons. An additional light on Riverside Drive delays the commuter traffic flow and increases the traffic noise due to stop and go traffic acceleration. The street lights and poles impact the potential pristine vistas from both the elevated berms along Riverside and the Blair property as well as from Riverside Drive and the existing river park trails. Naturally, this is a big and important decision that has to take into account all potential site improvements. ‐Several tunnel design options could be considered. There is the option of one tunnel approximately 500 feet in length or a design of two shorter 250 feet tunnels located where there is the greatest functional and aesthetic impact. Naturally both tunnel options would provide crossing areas for pedestrians and help blend one open space to another. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Keep it as natural as possible. this is a fantastic area in the middle of the city. It is heavily used now by folks who like nature as nature. It is a destination spot for birders from all over the state during spring migration. Sometimes there are almost "wall to wall" birds there. exactly what is there now, nothing more, nothing less. A few benches is all it needs. A sign that says "No Dogs or Cats Allowed", would be even better. I am so excited about this new space, its going to be awesome. It will be the perfect way to continue & ramp up what the river park is already bringing to the area. It will be hard to ignore the beauty & class that we have in Tulsa once this is complete. I can't think of a single thing I am opposed to, the whole idea is perfect from top to bottom. I would like to see pedestrians & bikers be able to fluidly move from the east to west side of river side drive with ease & safety. I would like to see the new area & the current area (west side of riverside drive) meshed into one to where park goers can go from one side of the RSDrive with ease. I would like people to be able to move over RSdrive with so much ease that they hardly even notice it. I would like to see a distinct entrance to the park @ E 33rd Pl & Cincinnnati to the park with an archway marked with the Kaiser name. I would also like to see a pedestrian & bike access to the west side of RSdrive @ E 34 th st with a bridge or a tunnel under the street. I DO NOT like what I am hearing about plans to have a New York company to "design a people place" on what is already a natural, beautiful place for people to come who actually appreciate it. I do not want groups of people jostling among each other on a "green" that is artificially contrived when we have already a beautiful natural greensward there ‐ and the loss to major groups of migratory birds at all seasons is absolutely devastation – we already have native plant species that should be appreciated and do not need more "horticultural plants" that do not serve natural plants and animals for food and shelter ‐‐ and the beauty of our native wildflowers on the west bank has already been devastated by city mowing crews. Tulsa's natural beauty should be preserved and not destroyed for the money‐making schemes of people who just want another place to browse shop and sip drinks and cover the area with exhaust fumes. Masses of people and shops also attract all kinds of human predators, and the increased need of police patrols. Take an example of what is already happening downstream at the Jenks river development. Why do we NEVER Learn. It should be left alone. WE have enough of these grandiose schemes planned for downtown Tulsa. Please leave the River Parks land alone. NO MORE DEVELOPMENT. I would like to see a farmers' market be a part of the new site. A farmers' market is a great family friendly place for people to come together. I would like to see an emphasis on connecting pedestrians on the east side of Riverside Drive to the River Parks trail system. This would enable people to access the site without the road being a significant barrier. One way to do this would be to depress Riverside Drive for the portion along the Blair Property. Then create a wide bridge at current grade level so that pedestrians can easily get from the new park to the river. This would also serve to mitigate the noise from vehicles on Riverside Drive and have little to no impact on traffic flow on the roadway. The road could return to grade level at 31st Street to allow for turns onto and from 31st Street. Priority signal timing should be considered for pedestrians needing to cross 31st Street from north to south. Another pedestrian access point could be created at Crow Creek under Riverside Drive minimizing the pedestrian traffic that would need to cross at 31st Street impacting traffic flow on Riverside Drive. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Little or no change. Many people already use and enjoy the area as it is. This includes birders, runners, and others walking to enjoy nature. If a change must be made, add signs at the parking lot to provide information about what birds, local and migratory, may be seen and where to look for them. Please don't destroy this important bird area! I agree, there are many pieces at 31st and Riverside that could come together. I'm a runner, so I like the bathrooms and the available water. My father who is 89 years old, will stop at this park location to sit in the shade (behind the bathrooms overlooking the pedestrian bridge) to have coffee and watch the fishermen on the pedestrian bridge. Because I often park at the few handicap parking spaces right off of Riverside at that bathroom, I would like to see these spaces preserved. Parking across the street is available, but not very "senior friendly" as my Dad would say. Anything built across the street in the proposed large grassy area would need pedestrian access to the trails across the street. The traffic right there is significant. I like the idea of building the area up so that you could sit and view the river from the East side of the street I'm confident that the architects and planners will create those elements that make parks natural and beautiful. In addition to that, however, I would like to see an area developed that's specifically designed for reflection, meditation, etc., protected from noise pollution and evocative of the spiritual. I'd also like to see an icononic piece of public art. We are so excited about this project and are so deeply grateful to the George Kaiser Family Foundation for making this possible. I think it would be interesting to have a bandstand type structure in the land area where the Blair house is now, something of the same architectural era, that would be reminiscent of a town square where bands could perform and other special events could take place as well as be visually appealing much as the Blair house is now. I would like to see the Midland Railroad trail dropped down below where it is currently located and have vegetation planted on that berm so that the neighborhood would have a sense of privacy from the park as there is nothing to be gained for the park to look down onto the neighborhood and the neighborhood would benefit from the privacy. The area needs to have public restrooms, but I would like to see "pod" stand alone restrooms much like what is used in Germany utilized instead of the traditional style restroom that breeds unsavory behaviors. I would like to see the utility lines and poles buried in the area of the Midland Valley trail buried. Question ‐ I have noticed that a fence has been constructed in the parking lot area behind our house which has closed that part of the trail to the public. Can you tell me what you plan to use that area of the public lot for, and for how long? would be interested to volunteer if you decide to form a neighborhood committee. I think a small fruit and nut tree orchard would be great. I think this would be a great way to get fresh fruit to people who wouldn't typically get any. I don't think rotting fruit would be a problem either as people would come and pick the fruit. It could maybe even include a community garden area. 1. Blair property – Country Estate style complex with the following features, tree lined access roadway on north side (buffering abutting properties screened by plantings), existing turf areas maintained for large event overflow parking, existing residence purchased or rebuild for meeting/conference use with small offices government functions or income producing options, northeast area developed as repurposed country estate accessory buildings (sheds, carriage house, greenhouse, etc.) for office and/or gathering use, southeast area anchored by a sizeable gambrel, barn structure housing RiverParks Maintenance on the ground floor and administrative functions on the second floor, accessory buildings and working areas bordered by the untouched urban forest area, areas of natural vegetation abutting the midland trail preserved with the exception of a private gated trail for RiverParks maintenance crews, additional trail access at the northeast complex, right of way dedications required at Riverside Drive, Solar and Wind power generation where feasible. (white exterior and suitable agricultural roofing materials) (gathering uses community gardening, arts, festival , school, etc.) 2. City/County parcel‐ Roadway and Intersection improvements as considered in the Riverside Parkway Study 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
1993?, widened roadway and trail use with trail and landscaping buffering existing residences, railway bridge rebuild in similar style of as used at I‐44 (whitewashed or natural concrete surfaces preferred) 3. Apartments‐ Entertainment and Retail purposes with master planned single family residences (historical estate replicas) abutting residential areas, refrain from” pie in the sky” urban ecosystem or connector plans with the Brookside Commercial District, rebuild existing creek bank areas with concrete art deco retaining walls and sandstone materials repurposed from the WPA project, slightly increase floodway capacity and add secondary floodplain overflow south of the Cincinnati bridge, include a public accounting of expenditures and status of the 2001 3rd penny sales tax and GO Bond items for Crow Creek , support the restoration and improvement of existing crow creek watershed floodway system. 4. RiverParks‐ Use capable with Parcel 3 , roadway, intersection, bridge, trail and dam reconstruction/improvements, cylindrical blade wind power generation Trees, birds, river, untouched. DO NOT DEVELOP IT ANY MORE. Bark Park‐park for people and their dogs A lot of parking, but more accessible for people on foot, dogs on leash, etc., cycles Parking be invisible from Riverside Preserve Trees Van Valkenburgh development on West side‐ better than Branson Landing Not too much lighting on east side (eg. Trash to energy plant) Education opportunities for children Use local contractors for bidding and construction. Keep Tulsa dollars in Tulsa 31st is a bike route‐ very dangerous, must make it safer Icon architecture Improve access to park from the east‐ sidewalk on 31st and Cincinnati Carousel‐ all weather, all seasons Consider relocating fireworks on 4th of July‐ better vantage point Clean up debris on the river When will apartments be vacant, torn down? Erosion in Crow Creek‐ Any plans to help that? Outdoor dining opportunities Preserve wildlife in the area‐birds, foxes Equestrian amenities at site 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Work w/ Brookside‐trail that is walkable. Fix it together‐36th St. Build Museum‐ like Field Museum (Chicago). Collection of animals‐ Sam Daniel III Loss access from Hazel No parking on Cincinnati Children’s Museum‐ affordable opportunities Widen Riverside‐ put a median in. More public transportation to mitigate traffic. Disc Golf Foundation‐ wooded area is ideal for 18 hole course. Can be in multiuse areas with enough planning South Boston Place‐ purchase 28 homes ($100 k each) to unify the sites Linking everything together‐ Woodward, Zink, Rose Garden. Trails. Multilevel parking in place where apartments are w/ bathrooms Keep all the urban wilderness‐ kids love the groves River can be dangerous‐ lots of wildlife on river bank. Steep banks are there for a reason. Water isn’t clean, isn’t safe. Sink holes, ledges etc. Teresa Burkett Keep it natural. Lots of trees and shade. Not commercial. Longevity, should be around for 100 years. Thanks for doing this. Would love for Blair house to stay. Icon of neighborhood. Not economic to move the house. Tulsa needs historic preservation. Better than plan it Tulsa. If tenant wants to move it, then do it. Swing dancers would want some indoor/outdoor wood floors. Gazebo style. Could be used for tai chi, weddings, etc…Vintage swing movement. Mixture of old and new, Tulsa style. Rinked in play area for small children, can’t run out. Nature activities built into park. Water earth, parks that have gates. No place that is purpose for skyline of Tulsa. Build out, like Blue Rose. Make sure skyline isn’t ruined as a view. Velodrome‐ style of HS track, gets kids out of the streets. Multiple uses Kaiser vision Tower= Vision for Tulsa Would like to see 300 ft. obs. Tower similar to Seattle space needle or John Hancock Center. 360 degree views, Gorgeous views from up there. Two floors, big conference room and venue. Only money making aspect of the park. For poor kids who’ve never been more than 5 ft off the ground it would be an educational tool. Midland Valley Trail is hot spot for Warbler birds. Must retain the habitat. No golf course. No dog park. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Navigate Crow Creek. Make walkable. Could import sand. Keep as much open lawn as possible. Put retail at East end of property Offer guided tours of storm drainage system Open Crow Creek to pedestrian access Make an open gazebo for dancing and other events Keep Blair Mansion as it is. I grew up in Maple Ridge. Houses like this are what make Tulsa special. It should be library or museum. Blair has to stay. It qualifies for historic register status. Grant Hall Attract people; what is the public transit plan? Limit parking lots Get people active, non‐traditional park Horse trails  Wild West Ice Hockey Why can’t we keep the Blair Mansion? It’s an icon. Make room for the wildlife (foxes, etc.) quantify the landscape and wildlife Use the non‐glare lights; minimize light pollution Westside  Please = need views of something better AGatheringPlaceforTulsa.com Please focus on Children’s Museum‐ Marvin Shirley Wifi in the park. Iphone App  health/community programs Rowing/White water Tie in to Crow Creek channel and Brookside. Transport down channel from shops to trails Riverside Drive itself  Median? South of 1‐44 = different road Trails bottleneck @ pedestrian bridge. Widen and fix dip. Encourage city involvement. Bigger Programming than “grow veggies”. Educate on polluting land and water Tulsa History Inference. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
World Class White Water Park in River. Big wave feature = key. “Tulsa Wave” west side of rive by dam, 2005 destroyed by flood. Foster Kayak culture. International contest destination again. Cone, raft, kayak. Tulsawhitewaterpark.com Landscape midland valley trail Designated smoking Keep Blair House. History‐ save, save, save. Architect. Tear down Monticello b/c he had salves. Don’t think Buford’s will follow thru with taking house. Geese, fox, wildlife. GBK = patron saint of Tulsa Woodward Park = disaster remodel Leave house b/c its historic preservation 22nd and Peoria house torn down. Huge Shabat koy House outcry. Mid‐century modern. Move trees, move greenery. Natural, variation (hills) No Concrete Parking lots! Parking solution‐ “Tulsans love to drive.” Instantaneous, accessible. Pedestrian bridge needs higher capacity, capability Iconic feature or statue Keep away from trendy stuff. No fixed retail. NATURAL Parking: None now‐ where to commuters go? Single level parking = wasted space Use public transit; like OKC 50 cent Bricktown Trolley. Baby bus with bike trailer on trails. Area is overloaded already. Riverside = substandard for this purpose. Uses GKFF $$ to push alternative transportation. Step in b/c city wanted it. +5 Focused lighting‐ non like on trail now = too bright Privacy along trail Paris and Berlin have floating swimming pools. Kiosks with grand snacks on barge. +2 “Park for whole city” +2 Channels Link w/ Crow Creek water activities Land Bridges Dog park = too much land to kill lawn and not have kid accessible. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Sustainability! Solar lights, recycling, community buildings and gardens, nature, nature, nature, native materials and plants = low maintenance, programs to educate public about initiatives OSU landscape architecture classes here tonight for extra credit Local labor= employ out of work landscape contractors Panoramic Tower‐ center Blair Children’s Playground w/ Merry go round w/ Tulsa “Rides” +2 Make Riverside tunnel under park People in park – lots of cars and commuters Access thru Riverside w/ adequate parking Park Board‐ trails and sidewalks connecting hoods Open space = asset: kite flying Warf? Marina? How do we access water for recreation?? Boardwalks in water? Integrated Natural as possible. Keep trees! Need place for solitude White water rapids‐ previous study shows the river in this area is very suitable. Could have Olympic level course. Like to see Riverside re‐routed add land out into river and have terraced levels Promenade level where people gather Splash Pad Concerns: Shouldn’t move Blair Mansion. It’s historic. Don’t eliminate affordable housing. Would love to see a dog park Need maintenance endowment Need sidewalk on 31st st. Make wide bridge over Riverside for pedestrians. Get rid of amphitheater and build one like Chicago Farmer’s market, 7 days/wk Greg Bledsoe‐ concerned about elimination‐no further gentrification of affordable housing since WWII. Sidewalk on 31st from at least Peoria 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Dog Park Crow Creek‐ neighbors have problem, how about you connect and make compatible Peoria and pedestrian Don’t move Blair Mansion, Tulsa History Road over Riverside. All pedestrian, green space, have green spaces connected Need more green, move/hide the street When will apartments be removed and vacated? Partner with centennial gardens; native plants and trees Sculpture garden Site Potential Urban (favorite picture) 100 picnic tables; huge court with dominos Benches  Aging population need places to sit Other demographic needs to 3 generations gathering spot Landscape goals‐ bring decks/docks so people can get close to the water Rivers must be close Raised sidewalks Educate people about natural world Was there a maze back in the 70’s? Is it still there? Behind/next to the wooded area? Do not disturb the wooded area Less development; more green space Make Crow Creek more accessible 6 hole mini golf Swimming – regular pool Sculptor  Ned Kahn‐ kinetic, interactive. Milwaukee art museum “Wind Leaves” amazing multisensory experience in a sculpture Millennium Park Chicago’s BP Pedestrian Bridge by Frank Gehry Grandparent accessible parks Concerns: easy to dispose of pet waste. Safety, lighting, park lighting. Patrol, monitoring, private property Bike Transit hub, kayaking, Farmer’s market 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
Keep restaurants local Milwaukee and Chicago Growing power. Urban gardening, team gardening, Global Garden Algonquin Provincial Park. Arts center and gallery with activities each day Public transportation to park Blair Lawn remain open. No soccer fields, not designated. Alternative fields‐ cricket, Frisbee No concrete‐ limited parking lots Green, natural Recycling Environmentally friendly Small, local, quaint No large and intrusive Trucks and carts Visiting and fairs, markets Austin’s Riverfront Parks = great example Off‐leash Water dog park Steps into water from park Accessible bike trails  keep usability same Emphasis on cycling and pedestrian Activities  draw people TULSA niche; get Tulsa active Different than Central Park. People live in NY around central park Elevate land to SEE river or more water and ponds Rocks and natural materials Raised lawn amphitheater Parking underground? DRAFT
DRAFT
Make DESTINATION. Lake and paddling, bout house entry, ice skating Grand kids of able ages  lots of activities Flowing curves, not square concrete Elevated areas, amphitheaters, tree houses Georgia tech‐ land bridge =  tunnel =  Pedestrian Planning Put water in river year round Native tall grasses Create some destination opportunities, native plant botanical garden uses, Separate vehicular and pedestrian areas. Maintain and encourage large pedestrian only zones. Consider putting pedestrian plazas above streets or even better streets under the park. Encourage enhancement of the great focal point with the big white house. Provide smaller spaces for neighborly interaction, possibly along Crow Creek and train trail area northeast of pedestrian bridge. Create some destination opportunities, native plant botanical garden uses, encourage select venders reflecting local food, art, music. kite flying etc ..... . Respect the adjacent neighborhood but integrate new activities, possibly some commercial, mixed use living spaces, museum outreach. Make it feel like it has always been there and it needs to be an essential element of the overall river park system. Cool zones for the hottest part of the summer Shade Water Seating Encourage air movement in summer. This park is very close to: (Encourage connection opportunities) Philbrook Art Museum Brookside Theater (Houston at Riverside) Zink Park Single family residential and multi family neighborhoods Don't ignore the refinery's, concrete plant, across the river. Why aren't they a more integral part of the park system. Why have they ignored their potential contribution to the park system. Are they focal points or just the opposite of focal points. Collect and recycle storm water, use river water for irrigation. Get the large fountain going or make it better and get it going. Public transportation instead of parking Vote‐ money to be spent on it‐ what can we do to help people who do not live close: public comments/destination for Tulsa 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Elevated highway to 51st. Price? Plot bond package Widen road? Sundance? What will happen‐ letter sent to residents sounds like that. Will price be increased? Would help relocate? Apartments don’t fit in Keep most open space‐ for Tulsa Ultimate Federation Other affordable housing in area Landscape on other side of river? Whitewater rafting Wave Hill in the Bronx, by Riverdale to study nominal fee to get in Pedestrian advisory comm.: bike parking? Bike station w/ showers and lockers Connections to neighborhoods/downtown; transit System to downtown. Farmer’s market; integrated into downtown; low maintenance for city. Potential for funds Land purchase south of Crow Creek apartments – 51st – plans for that land Must have a vision‐pull in other areas. Connect downtown to river to other areas Bring water from river into neighborhoods. Doesn’t have to stay in banks Move road away from the river Keep the plan realistic‐ appeal to Tulsans Worried about not getting enough notice for move Worried about not getting enough notice for move Upsetting coverage‐ glossing over people losing their homes Blair woods in SE preserved‐ good wildlife area Keep Crow Creek corridor as natural as possible‐ preserve wildlife Need to be amenities for older and younger children Pedestrian bridges‐ restaurant with old railway cars Cyclist on RP= lay seeds to develop west side. Pedestrian bridge. More seamless between both sides (E+W). Reach out and lay groundwork for future development Skate park‐ adolescent boys and hard age group to hit. Doesn’t have to look like a skate park 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Chemicals killing trees, herbs tree keep in wetlands What is the commercial development? Worried about traffic Beautiful property National treasure Don’t destroy the house YMCA Sun Valley best example ever seen Native plants, xeriscape Ray Hunt‐wants to volunteer rayfromok@gmail.com Herb Gottfried‐ Cornell Landscape Architect Prof. retired. hwgz@cornell.edu Preserve the fountain that exists in river already. Modified not removed Open to moving Riverside. Depress or cover it Parking: River west festival park and have water taxis to get across I would like to see an emphasis on connecting pedestrians on the east side of Riverside Drive to the River Parks trail system. This would enable people to access the site without the road being a significant barrier. One way to do this would be to depress Riverside Drive for the portion along the Blair Property. Then create a wide bridge at current grade level so that pedestrians can easily get from the new park to the river. This would also serve to mitigate the noise from vehicles on Riverside Drive and have little to no impact on traffic flow on the roadway. The road could return to grade level at 31st Street to allow for turns onto and from 31st Street. Priority signal timing should be considered for pedestrians needing to cross 31st Street from north to south. (James Miller, DRAFT
transportation planner for INCOG) DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
Arkansas River Natural History Education Center Although many are unaware of it or enjoy it without thinking of it in these terms, the Arkansas River currently forms a wildlife corridor through the center of Tulsa. Much of the pleasure Tulsans derive from the river comes from its scenic wild and green beauty. In developing the river we should seek to retain this; if people want to shop they can already go to Utica Square. But to watch a bald eagle fish, a fox cub play with a wayward Kleenex, turtles of all sizes sunning themselves, stately white pelicans and all kinds of waterfowl in migration, Tulsans from all walks of life flock to the river. Having this amazing green corridor in the downtown and midtown of a city Tulsa's size is unusual if not unique. Any plan to develop the river should preserve the river bed and riparian habitats that sustain it. The George Kaiser Family Foundation's purchase creates potential to not only encourage preservation of the river bank, but to utilize it for educational purposes in a way that can benefit all of Tulsa. A Natural History Education Center located on the banks of the Arkansas would be accessible to school groups, families and individuals, and could have exhibits, trails, and interactive programs. One model of how this can be done is Albuquerque's Rio Grande Nature Center (http://rgnc.org!index.htm), although it is both larger and less easily accessed than an educational center sited in the area of 31't st. in Tulsa could be. Tulsa needs a Natural History Education Center. The Sam Noble Oklahoma Museum of Natural History in Norman is a long way for school trips to go, and economically disadvantaged families are not likely to travel that far for educational purposes. The wildlife center at the Tulsa Zoo is limited by topic; the Tulsa Geoscience Center is open only for tours. A center offering the geological and geomorphological history of the Arkansas River plus an exposition of prairie river ecosystems and the wildlife of Tulsa – visible through the front door ‐‐ would open an educational gateway into the history of the settlement of Tulsey Town itself, and the natural resources that fuelled its growth. The corner of Riverside and 31't, where the Sundance apartments currently stand, would be ideal for this purpose: easy to access from either street, and just across the street and trail from the wide and wild river bank created by Crow Creek's sediment output and the curve of the Arkansas' main channel at that point. As has been done in Albuquerque, a short trail with interpretive signage along the river bank would be an attraction in itself, as well as further illustration of habitats and concepts presented in the Education Center. Crow Creek, which is home to a surprising variety of wildlife from beavers to turtles, could stand to have its banks rehabilitated from its current concrete‐lined state between the two apartment complexes, and the head of such a trail could start on the creek bank, passing over or under Riverside Drive and the trail to the river bank. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
DRAFT
Proposals for the Blair Property Reading the paper, I saw that GKFF was planning to develop the Blair Property on Riverside (between 26th and 29th) and that they were looking for input from the community, which is so exciting. A park created by the people for the people is a very appropriate idea. This park presents Tulsa with an opportunity to create something truly unique that can serve as a model to other cities across the nation. Through some preliminary site analysis, I have outlined some points that I think are relevant to the project. I do believe that by including the visions and voices of ordinary citizens, and factoring in the natural community into the design, this park will be one of the most successful and valued gathering spaces in the Tulsa. First, the property is right on the Arkansas River. Chemical fertilizer and pesticide use would be incredibly irresponsible for this site. Do we really want to picnic with our families while fifty feet away biocides are being sprayed anyway? If any fertilizers are to be used they should be 100% organic. However, organic fertilizers still have nitrogen and phosphorus components and these can still contribute to the devastation of our waterways. Ponds and Bio‐Filtration channels can both absorb and filtrate this runoff. If small ponds were implemented over 15% of the landscape, rainfall and irrigation runoff could instead be channeled into these ponds using swales. In this way water can be slowed down reducing erosion along the river and having more time to filtrate through attractive reeds, sedges and other aquatic plants that remove nitrogen and phosphorous by using them as fertilizer. These ponds could also serve as a storage reserve for irrigation water in dry spells. And of course the ponds and waterways could offer habitat to native amphibians and other aquatic fauna. Keyline Design as outlined by A. Yeomans explains how to effectively place ponds and channels on a landscape. The plant selection in the park should be diverse. This will offer more habitat to more species and help to maintain a balanced ecosystem. Native grasses and shrubs require little water, fertilizer and maintenance as well as keep weeds down. Fruit bearing shrubs and trees (cherries, apples, pears, nuts, grapes, huckleberries, currants, goose berries) not only offer habitat and forage for wildlife but a tasty snack for park visitors and a step towards local food security. A variety of flowers that bloom at different times of the year can offer forage to butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds year round. Vines can with edible fruits and flowers (hardy kiwi, grapes, passion flower) can wind there way around trellises and arbors creating edible aromatic shade. Perennials should be used over annuals to minimize maintenance and to increase success. The Midland Valley Trail is one of the longest wildlife corridors in midtown and it lets off right at the proposed site for the park. This is such a valuable element that must be utilized and maintained. Habitat and forage for birds, squirrels, and pollinating insects should be promoted in the park's design, so that we may enhance this corridor and secure species diversity in our city. Chemicals used in conventional landscape maintenance diminish the populations of urban wildlife. Winds prevail from the south in the warmer months on the site and a strategic network of windbreaks (trees and shrubs) could reduce pollen, pollution and heavy winds for the park's visitors, especially considering the bareness of this field. At the same time aromatic plants such as herbs and flowers could be planted at the southern end of the park to create an aromatic wave that could permeate throughout the park in spring and summer. Some enclosure areas should be offered perhaps by bamboo groves to offer an environment away from heavy traffic on riverside and industrial views from the west side of the river as well as hot afternoon sun. Community gardens are places of gathering. Most folks do not go to the park to meet up with other parties. They go by themselves or with a few others. Community gardens are something that other cities across the nation are using to produce local healthy food, bring people in the community together, and provide education. It would also serve as an incentive to keep chemical usage to a minimum. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
To develop the park to the point where there is no room to make adjustments in the future might prove unwise. If this is a gathering place for Tulsans, creative space should be left for the co‐evolvement between the park, the park visitor's and the natural community. Recycling should be available. Other ideas; fire pit for the winter, amphitheatre for outdoor movies and productions, a central gathering place (circular with lots of seating), dog park, boulders (for climbing like at Turkey Mountain). My name is James Spicer and I work with Green Country Permaculture LLC. Our company offers design plans and consulting for landscapes and agricultural systems. We are currently involved with Langston University and Tulsa Public Schools and Chandler Park doing educational outreach for people interested in sustainable living skills and design for small scale production systems. I have included my card. George Krasier Foundation representative TV,TV,TV Quik Trip Group, ditto Consider Adequate access from the east No new traffic lights on Riverside Protection from the wind Lots of Trees for shade and beauty Adequate access to toilets Tunnel or bridge to the water Plenty of bench seating Lots of tables Water pool and fountains Keep Zink lake full of water No demonstrations allowed Disneyland clean Vendor carts and stalls Borrow concepts from the great plazas and piazzas of Europe; open ness, space, free movement Plaza de Popolo, St. Peters' Square, Piazza Navarone Tivoli Gardens Trafalgar Square Spanish Steps Belgium's Markt Bruge Use volunteers to cut cost, solicit help to clean and cut and rake, friends of the park, high school students looking for community credit. We love our jewel in the crown of Tulsa Parks and want to support it. Recommendations Re: Blair Site Open lawn and performance space No commercial businesses No noise pollution Keep the Blair Mansion where it is Water Quality Institute Concrete area that could be used for skate hockey and flooded in winter for ice skating. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
Article in March AARP (!!!) about playgrounds for older adults which bring generations together. Example is Midway Safe Harbor Center playground east of Orlando, FL. It is called a multi‐generational playground. My cousin has such a soft spot for wounded veterans and people with disabilities that she sent this to me to forward to you. Know that you are working on the riverside project and thought it might be something of interest to look into. With so many vet returning home it would be nice to have a place that EVERYONE could have some fun. By this time, I am certain that a number of Tulsa Audubon Society members and other nature enthusiasts have provided thoughts about the proposed development along Riverside Drive that could potentially impact the Midland Valley Trail. During the spring and fall migrations, this area (the Midland Valley Trail) is an important resting stop for migratory songbirds. The presence of the birds, in turn, is a special treat for those of us who love birds and enjoy watching and identifying them. While others like myself can travel to find other spots that afford good birding during migration, I fear what happens if the birds return to find that this important resting and feeding spot has been transformed into some gigantic amusement park with hoardes of noisy people who do not appreciate birds and the importance of conservation. Where would these tiny creatures, most of whom are already declining in numbers annually, find to rest before they complete their trips to their breeding grounds? I am writing to add my voice to those who may already have spoken up on behalf of the birds who consistently use this area in their migration paths. I am hopeful that any development that might occur will keep in mind the importance of this small area (between 21st Street and the pedestrian bridge parking lot) where the birds congregate to rest and replenish their energy stores before continuing their migration. Please allow this small area to remain as pristine and untouched as possible for our feathered friends. Dear Idea Gatherers, My name is Kim Doner, and I am a Tulsa artist/illustrator/wildlife rehabilitator. My husband, Dennis England, has spent the last several years recreating our backyard into a wildlife habitat for me to release songbirds there from my aviary. We were recently hosts to the Audubon Wildlife Habitat tour held annually in Tulsa; my studio has also been on the Oklahoma Visual Artist's Coalition tour in the past year. Of course, our wishes for converting the Riverside acreage reflect our passions and pursuits. But our passions and pursuits have developed from doing homework to become part of the solution, starting (literally) in our own backyard. Our thoughts on the Gathering Place: 1. Have the most public traffic and any buildings located close to Riverside Drive, with a bridge over the street for safety in crossing. Parking lots, accessibility, and higher maintenance for security and events should be there. Secure such development from the nature park to maintain peace for the animals who (with luck) will live there. 2. Landscape with ONLY native plants and trees to reflect our state, as well as model the beauty that can be achieved with such plantings as opposed to imported items. Refer to Doug Tallamy's wonderful book, Bringing Nature Home. It's environmentally brilliant, and could start a new culture in Tulsa to follow his lead. Just knowing that a Bradford Pear tree supports four kinds of life, whereas an oak supports over a thousand ‐ well, that's all we need to hear. 3. Set aside an area for songbird release and bird watching. This would be created with few paths through it, back near the bicycle trail, and have plenty of native berry‐bearing bushes plus wildflowers, seeded grasses, and nut trees. The area would NOT be sprayed and WOULD be minimally maintained as opposed to mowed, weeded, clipped, cleared, poisoned, and controlled. It would be like having a Discovery Channel area for bird viewing, and would offer a haven for small wild mammals, too, sort of an "Oxley South" or a tiny Tulsa version of the Tallgrass Prairie. It's pretty phenomenal to see what Oklahoma looks like when left to its natural state. 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
4. Have some sort of building available for educational purposes, not rock concerts or restaurants. Offer art classes, nature walks, literary signings, etc. but ensure it would be used in a way that the surrounding neighborhoods would not be disturbed. 5. Integrate a few covered viewing and/or art decks among the trees in the nature area, so plein air people could paint there or birders could stay out of the rain. We have not been in town to attend any of the recent meetings, but hope to do so for a few of the upcoming times. When is the next one? And thanks for considering these ideas. I appreciate the fact that Tulsa wants to keep up with other cities in regards to recreation, but we need to also preserve nature. Please consider working with nature/environmental staff to ensure a place for the wildlife to have as well. To Whom It May Concern: It is my understanding that the George Kaiser Family Foundation owns the B.B. Blair Mansion (located at 2800 S. Boston Avenue) and surrounding land, and is soliciting recommendations on how to best use the land to benefit Tulsa citizens. The following is my submission. The land along Riverside Drive, and the white home that sits so grandly upon it, are beautiful focal points of Riverside drive. Being positioned along the road as it is, many people are able to enjoy the view of the house and its park‐like lawn. And now for the first time, potentially enjoy the opportunity to walk the grounds and through the historic rooms as well. Although from Tulsa, I now live in Southern California and have traveled a great deal. I love Tulsa as though it were a member of my family and feel very passionate about the City's development. From New York to New Orleans, Rome to San Fransisco, the great cities of the world have left an impression on me that I never forget. What I love about places like New York City, is the blending of old and new in a way that is respectful of history and encouraging of progress. The Boat House in Central Park reminds me of the B.B. Blair Mansion and grounds. I believe a concept similar to the Boat House could work very well at the B.B. Blair property: + Turn the Mansion into a restaurant ‐ open up the mansion to private investors with a history of running a successful, moderately high‐end restaurant ‐ benefit is that this will generate revenue to help keep up the property ‐ creates jobs ‐ opportunity to generate further revenue by allowing the venue to be rented (similar to Philbrook, etc) + Build a water feature in front of the mansion with sturdy iron benches ‐ perhaps have remote control sail boats or some other Boat House‐like pond feature ‐ even if a person cannot afford to eat in the restaurant, they can still enjoy the water and the park ‐ just like the ponds outside the Boat House in Central Park ‐ install some plantings to give people shade ‐ requires maintenance which will again, create jobs + Allow picnics ‐ again allows people of all demographics to enjoy the expansive lawn 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
+ Install heavy duty and appealing trash receptacles + Do not take out all of the forest ‐ people like to explore ‐ instills a sense of wonder and appreciate for one of Tulsa's crowning glories, our trees Thank you to the GKFF for their commitment to Tulsa. If you have any questions, I can be reached via email or the number below. Sincerely, Lane 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
3.07 Neighborhood Meeting Sketch 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
Ideas from Mingo Valley Christian School Swings Laser Tag A giant zipline over restaurants and cafes. A Rainforest Café! Dog park Big picnic grounds First Aid Day Care for kids Duck pond Disney themed park Soccer and football fields Water park and skate park Skywalk over the park and Arkansas River Massive slide Haunted House Park campouts Hammocks A “Kid’s Castle” for kids to play on Family area with sand volleyball pits, picnic tables and jungle gyms Mini golf Splash pad with colored water and lazy river Different colored lights Shelter in case of tornado Gazebo Riverfront terrace Bush maze as an “eccentric and rich architectural element” Tree houses Interconnected geodesic domes‐ each dome with a different activity (trampoline, carousel, laser tag, bowling, paintball) Museum with interactive exhibits Concession stands (Josh’s Sno Shack and Pizza) Pavilions Themed botanical gardens‐ Each of the six will be themed using the continents, excluding Antarctica. “Around the World Garden Series” Farmer’s market Basketball and tennis courts Outdoor movie theater Small amusement park for little kids Paddleboats and fishing Shuffleboard and horseshoe toss Ferris wheel Carousel Indoor soccer field complex 2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT

2012.05.01 – Public Comments Compiled Michael Van Valkenburgh

Transcription

Similar documents

march - Cobblestone Apartments

Mad Scientists On Wheels

April 2014 - Riverside College

October Newsletter - Cleveland Metropolitan School District

Attached File

"What You Must Know if Disaster Strikes" Brochure

Early Childhood Inte..

Schottenstein Center

Parking Lot Striping - Parking Control Unit