2 Gold Cyanidation
Transcription
2 Gold Cyanidation
Universidade de São Paulo, Escola Politécnica, Dept Engenharia de Minas PMI 5003 Studying Gold Ores: Mineralogy, Cyanidation, Toxicity and Environmental Issues Gold Process Mineralogy Dr. Arthur Pinto Chaves (Universidade de São Paulo, Dept Engenharia de Minas) Dr. Marcello Veiga (University of Britsh Columbia, Dept Mining Engineering, Canada) Common Gold Minerals Gold Electrum Cuproauride Porpezite Rhodite Iridic gold Au (Au,Ag) (Au,Cu) (Au,Pd) (Au,Rh) (Au,Ir) Calaverite Krennerite Montbrayite Petzite (antamokite) AuTe 2 (Au,Ag)Te 2 (Au,Sb)2Te 3 Ag3 AuTe 2 Uytenbogaardtite Ag3AuS2 Aurostibite AuSb2 Fischesserite Ag3AuSe2 Common Gold Minerals Physical Properties of Gold Property % Au SG Mohs Hardness Native Gold Electrum >75 45-75 16-19.3 13-16 2.5-3 2-2.5 Platinum gold Bismuthian gold Gold amalgam Maldonite Auricupride Palladium Curoauride (Au,Pt) (Au,Bi) Au 2 Hg 3 (?) Au 2 Bi AuCu3 (Cu,Pd)3 Au 2 Muthmannite Sylvanite Kostovite Nagyagite (Ag,Au)Te (Au,Ag)Te 4 AuCuTe 4 Pb 5 Au(Te,Sb)4 S5-8 Physical Properties of Gold Tellurides Mineral %Au SG Hardness Calaverite 39.2-42.8 9.2 2.5-3 Krennerite 30.7-43.9 8.6 2.5 Sylvanite 24.2-29.9 8.2 1.5-2 Montbroyite 2.5 38.6-44.3 9.9 Petzite 19-25.2 9.1 2.5 Hessite 4.7 8.4 2.5-3 1 Physical Properties of Gold Minerals Au% SG Mohs Hardness Nagyagite 7.4-10.2 4.5 1.5 Kostovite 25.2 Mineral 2-2.5 Aurostibnite 43.5-50.9 9.9 3 Maldonite 64.5-65.1 15.5 1.5-2 Gold Mineral Associations and Size • Gold occurs in several forms – Free gold is liberated – Attached to gangue along grain boundaries or completely occluded within a particle grain – Finely disseminated within a mineral structure. GOLD GANGUE HENLEY, K.J,(1975). Gold-ore mineralogy and its relation to metallurgical treatment. Minerals Sci. Engng, vol.7, n. 4, p. 289-312 Gold in the Electron Microscope History of Gold Ore Processing • 1700 to early 1900’s – Mostly alluvial gold – Gold pans, sluice boxes and mercury amalgamation • Late 1800’s to mid 1900’s – – – – Cyanidation Invented Depletion of alluvial gold Increase in hardrock gold mining Processing evolved towards cyanidation, although mercury still used in some large scale operations • 1970’s to present Image of back-scattered electrons Process Design for Large Scale Gold Mines • Process designs are based on ore specific mineralogy • Processes are kept as simple as possible with minimum number of stages • Usually coarse gold is removed first from the leaching circuit • Cyanidation is usually applied for gold particles finer than 0.15 mm (100 mesh) – – – – – Development of heap cyanidation New technologies for refractory gold ores Mercury use in large scale mines almost completely disappears Centrifugal gravity concentrators developed Escalation of ASM in developing countries Typical Terminology for Gold Ores • Alluvial (usually free naturally gold) sands and gravels, rivers, beaches usually gold particles are liberated • Free milling surface and underground hard rock minesEgold associated with silicates • Refractory not amenable to conventional cyanidation usually associated with sulfides 2 Gold Ore Processing Practices (Alluvial) • USUALLY gold is liberated in alluvial ore, but sometimes it is not Gold Ore Processing Practices (Alluvial) Scrubbing • Sometimes gold is aggregated with clayEscrubbing is needed • In Coluvial and Eluvial ores, gold IS PARTIALLY liberated and this is the reason why the Au recovery is low, as many miners do not grind the ore before concentration Gravity and/or Flotation Concentration Free gold Gold Ore Processing Practices (Alluvial) Brazil, 1993 (BBC Documentary) Dredging alluvial gold in the Amazon Gold Ore Processing Practices (free milling ores) Comminution Cyanide Leach Comminution Gravity and/or Flotation Concentration Gold Comminution Gravity Sep Free gold Flotation Oxidation Cyanide Leach Free gold Cyanide Leach Gold Concentration of alluvial gold by flotation. Photo H. Wotruba Gold Ore Processing Practices (refractory) Brazil, 2006 Mining coluvial gold ore in the Amazon Typical Terminology for Gold Ores • Attached (occluded) gold – sulfides – Silicates • Invisible gold • Au grains sizes range from: – very coarse >1 mm – coarse >0.15 mm – fine <0.074 mm – to very fine <0.010 mm 25 µm Reflected light in optical microscope Fine gold in pyrite grain Gold 3 Free Gold Particle Gold Associated with sulfides • Gold rarely forms solid solution with sulfides but it is possible • Gold can be occluded in sulfides in grains <0.02 µm • Invisible Au can be sub microscopic gold or gold in the sulfide lattice • Invisible Au is preferentially concentrated in arsenopyrite which is apparently related to crystal chemistry • When an ore has fine and coarse grained arsenopyrite, Au concentrates in finer grained 25 µm Gold Associated with sulfides Reflected light in optical microscope Gold Associated with sulfides Polished-thin Section, reflected light, optical microscope Ga Chalcopyrite CuFeS2 Au Si Gold with Galena and Silicates Gold is usually difficult to polish (lots of scratches) Reflected light Very often in the optical microscope, chalcopyrite looks like gold, but gold is much brighter HENLEY, K.J,(1975). Gold-ore mineralogy and its relation to metallurgical treatment. Minerals Sci. Engng, vol.7, n. 4, p. 289-312 Gold Associated with sulfides Gold Associated with Sulfides To differentiate Au from Chalcopyrite Reflected Light Reflected Light gold gold chalcopyrite gold sulfides (chalcopyrite and pyrite) become oxidized in the optical microscope when the specimen is attacked by diluted HNO3 (10%) for one day 4 Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores • • • increasing liberation. Grain size distribution of a “garimpo” tailing before grinding. 2 Au 1.5 (g/t) 1 0.5 Grain size analyses conc. Fire Assay It is noticeable that the Artisanal Miners could not recover the fine gold (they used sluice boxes) and the unliberated gold in the coarse fractions. # # # 10 0# 15 0# 20 0# 27 0# 40 0# -4 00 # 65 25 Au 20 15 distr.10 (%) 5 0 65 # 10 0# 15 0# 20 0# 27 0# 40 0# -4 00 # tail. Mesh Gold grades in screened fractions - 20 min. - 30 min. Batch Flotation 28 20 Grinding (various time) - no grinding - 5 min. - 10 min. 28 # grinding time 20 # Composite Sample # 0 # The average gold grade of this tailing from Crixás, Brazil is around 0.7 to 1 g/tonne. Gold liberation was studied as follows:: 3 2.5 48 # Increasing grinding time Example 35 # • Studying Liberation by Flotation or Gravity Concentration 48 Studying Liberation by Flotation or Gravity Concentration 35 Studying Gold Liberation It is difficult to establish gold liberation as this is usually a trace element in most ores, hardly visible in microscope. Liberation of gold can be obtained by indirect methods, such as heavy liquid separation, gravity concentration, flotation, etc.. One technique (very common) to establish the gold liberation is grinding in different times followed by concentration Mesh Gold distribution in screened fractions Studying Liberation by Flotation or Gravity Concentration Studying Liberation by Flotation or Gravity Concentration Concentration of the different ground sub-samples indicates that the liberation must be around 10 minutes of grinding. Taking this information to the grain size distribution graphic, we can obtain the liberation size of the gold particles. % Mass Passing 100 100 90 %Gold recovery 80 by concentration 70 80 grinding time 60 40 1 min 5 min 10 min 20 20 min D80 for 10 min of grinding (probable gold liberation) 0 16 60 20 28 35 48 65 100 150 200 270 400 -400 Tyler Mesh 50 0 5 10 20 30 Grinding time (min.) 5 Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores • • • Very often the concept of gold liberation is usually replaced by accessibility of gold to reagents such as mercury, cyanide, etc. In other words: submit the sample (or concentrates) to cyanidation and amalgamation. The grain size distribution must be knownE.or make cyanidiation or amalgamation of the sized fractions Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores • • • Au exposed but not liberated Quartz particle Hg Activation Improves Amalgamation Hg Activation Improves Amalgamation • Usually Hg becomes “oxidized” (dirty) when it is old • The efficiency of amalgamation is low (usually 70%)EHg doesn’t grab Aut • Hg forms droplets and loses coalescence • Lots of Hg is lost to amalgamation tailings (usually have 60-300 ppm Hg) For amalgamation a gold particle must be at least >90% liberated Amalgamation is difficult for -200 mesh fractions unless the mercury is activated For cyanidation gold does not need to be liberated; it can be exposed • • • • • • Boil water (Indonesia) Detergent (Brazil, Zimbabwe, Tanzania) Lime juice (Laos) Dilluted nitric acid (Peru) Brown sugar (Ecuador) Molasse, guava leaves, lime juice, bicarbonate (Colombia, Antioquia) • Urine (Chile) • Electrolytic formation of Na- or K-amalgam (Colombia, Nariños) Activating Hg before amalgamation (increase coalescence = reduces Hg flouring = less Hg loss with tailing) + wire Battery 12 V - It forms sodiumamalgam which is more consistent than pure Hg Graphite rod Mercury Water with 10% of salt NaCl or KCl Brazil, 2006 Zimbabwe, 2006 6 Brown Sugar in the Amalgamation Barrel Amalgamation Barrel Ecuador, 2004 It is not know the role of brown sugar in improving amalgamtion. This is widely used in Ecuador and some parys of Colombia • • • • Indonesia, 2006 Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores A Simple Methodology: screened fractions are submitted to heavy liquid separation. The floats are assayed for gold. The sinks are submitted to amalgamation. The mineral residue is submitted to cyanidation. This will determine the gold portion accessible to mercury (almost free gold) and accessible to cyanide (not quite free). The final residue, after cyanidation is analyzed by fire assay, in which all ore is melted. This determines the portion of mineral-locked gold (not amalgamated or leached). ATTENTION: • • This is just a lab test This must not be used in an actual processing plant Hg-contaminated tailings must not be leached with cyanide since this forms Hg-cyanide which is very bioavailable • Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores Gold Ore (8g/tonne Au) Results: 35, 48, 65, 100, 150, 200, 270 mesh Screening light fractions Heavy Liquid Separation heavy fractions amalgams Amalgamation (60% solids; Hg:solids = 1:20) residue Cyanidation (*) (*) (10g/L NaCN, NaCN, pH=10, 40%sol, 24 h) All fractions finer than 48 mesh had similar Au recovery (~60%) in heavy liquid. Amalgamation showed that particles coarser than 48 mesh did not show enough exposure to be amalgamated. • Crushing ((-28#) solutions Chemical Analysis Nitric Acid Hg--Dissolution Hg gold Chemical Analysis gold residue Fire Assay Fraction (Tyler mesh) -28 +35 -35 +48 -48 +65 -65 +100 -100 +150 -150 +200 -200 +270 • (*) gold Just the -48 mesh fractions were leached by cyanide. High concentration of CN was used to avoid CN consumpion control • Gold in Heavy Products (%) 32 68 57 55 62 60 n.a. Amalgamated Gold (%) 4 1 21 48 67 87 n.a CN Leached Gold (%) n.a n.a n.a 88.0 93.2 95.0 99.0 We should expect to extract up to 60% of the gold from this ore ground -65 mesh and subjected to gravity separation. Cyanidation of -200 mesh recovers almost all gold. 7 Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores Example: Gold liberation of an ore from Texada Island, BC, Canada As the ore had more than 30% of heavy minerals (pyrite, bornite, iron oxides) (sg>2.89) and high gold grade (7.3 g/t), the heavy liquid separation was not used, just amalgamation followed by cyanidation and fire-assay (fusion) of final residues. It is possible to notice the gold liberation increasing with particle size decreasing. Representative sample Store in bags Fusion 75 - Cyanidation 50 - +100# - 6 Mesh (3.4 mm) sub-samples sub-sample - 0 (polished thin sections) Crushing DAu (%) 100 25 Optical and electron microscopy Chips of sample selected Amalgamation -200+400# -400# -100+200# Grinding - 28 M (0.6 mm) Screening fractions Heavy Liquid Separation heavies Liberation of Sulfides (Microscopy) Chemical Analysis Gravity Sep. tailing Flotation conc. Cyanidation residue Diagnosis Leaching Amalgamation residues Overall Gold recovered by: Cyanidation Fusion: Cyanidation: Amalgamation: 11.4 % 64.0 % 24.6 % residues Fire Assay Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores Clifton et al. (1969) calculated the size of sample required to contain 20 particles of gold (spheres) as a function of gold particles and grade, assuming that Au particles are uniform and randomly distributed. Size of Gold Particle (mm) The mass of sample to be used is a function of the gold particle shape, size and distribution. = splitting = optional Studying of Liberation of Gold Ores • Grinding with different times kg of sample required 4 ppm Au 1 ppm Au 2.0 400 1000 1.0 50 200 30 0.5 8 0.25 1 4 0.125 0.1 0.5 0.062 0.02 0.05 0.031 0.002 0.006 0.015 0.0002 0.002 0.008 0.00002 0.0001 • According to Clifton et al. (1969) a precision of ± 50% is achieved at 95% certainty when a sample for analysis contains a minimum of 20 gold particles • Usually 100 kg of a representative sample crushed below 1/4" (6.35 mm) is a good starting material. • If gold particles are not larger than 0.25 mm (no nuggets), material can be stored in 1 kg bags after crushed below 6 Mesh (3.4 mm). • When there is indication of presence of >1mm nuggets the entire process becomes complex as we cannot work with small samples. • When the amount of sulfides in the ore is low (<2%) it is convenient to concentrate the screened fractions in heavy liquids before the microscopy (Gaudin Method) History of Gold Cyanidation Date Name Discovery 6th Century Jabir Hayyan Discovered aqua regia & that it dissolved gold 6HCl + 2HNO3 + 2Au → 2AuCl3 + 2NO + 4H2O 1704 Gold Cyanidation Discovered Prussian Blue (Fe4[Fe(CN)6]3) by accidentally combining dried blood with potash (K2CO3) and treating with iron vitriol (FeSO4) 1774 C.W. Schule Discovered chlorine & that it dissolved gold 1852 K.F. Plattner Applied chlorination to gold recovery 2Au + 3Cl2 → 2AuCl3 Early 1700s P.J. Discovered potassium ferrocyanide Macquer (K4[Fe(CN)6]) by combining Prussian Blue with Alkali (KOH) 1782 C.W. Schule Discovered Blue Acid by heating Prussian Blue with Dilute Sulphuric Acid 8 Date Name 1811 J.L. GayLussac 1834 Potassium cyanide produced by fusing potassium ferro cyanide with potash K4[Fe(CN)6] + K2CO3 → 6KCN + FeCO3 1. Oxygen Theory, L. Elsner (1846) 2. Hydrogen Theory, L. Janin (1888) 1840 Elkington Patented process using KCN to prepare electrolyte for electroplating Au and Ag 1846 L. Elsner Recognized importance of oxygen to dissolution of Au with cyanide 4Au + 8KCN + O2 + 2H2O → 4KAu(CN)2 + 4KOH 1887 Cyanidation Process (theories) Discovery Determined Blue Acid was HCN J.S. MacArthur, R.W. Forrest, W. Forrest 4Au + 8NaCN + O2 + 2H2O → 4NaAu(CN)2 + 4NaOH 2Au + 4NaCN + 2H2O → 2NaAu(CN)2 + 2NaOH + H2 3. Hydrogen Peroxide Theory, G. Bodlander (1896) 2Au + 4NaCN + O2 + 2H2O → 2NaAu(CN)2 + 2NaOH + H2O2 H2O2 + 2Au + 4NaCN → 2NaAu(CN)2 + 2NaOH 4Au + 8NaCN + O2 + 2H2O → 4NaAu(CN)2 4NaOH Patented process for dissolution of Au from ore using weak cyanide solution and to precipitate Au with zinc shavings. Process was considered a significant improvement over amalgamation and chlorination. Cyanidation Process (theories) 4. Cyanogen Formation, S.B. Christy (1896) O2 + 4NaCN + 2H2O → 2(CN)2 + 4NaOH 5. Corrosion Theory, B. Boonstra (1943) O2 + 2H2O + 2e → H2O2 + 2OHAu → Au+ + e Au+ + CN- → AuCN AuCN + CN- → Au(CN)2 Au + O2 + 2CN- + 2H2O + e- →Au(CN)2- + 2OH- + H2O2 Factors Affecting Cyanidation • Hedley and Tabachnick (1968) listed the main factors affecting cyanidation: dissolved oxygen pH stability of cyanide solutions cyanide concentration gold particle size and shape accessibility of cyanide to gold (exposure) silver content (silver dissolves slower than gold) temperature presence of minerals consuming oxygen presence of cyanicides Hedley, N. and Tabachnick, H., 1968. Chemistry of Cyanidation. Mineral Dressing Notes, n. 23. American Cyanamid Co. Veiga, M.M. and Klein, B. (2005). Cyanide in Mining. Edumine.com. Cyanide Stability pH of Gold Cyanidation bitter almond smell Au Dissolution Rate CN- + H2O = HCN + OHNaOH Ca(OH)2 10.5 pH Au cyanidation is more efficient at pH=10.5 Ca(OH)2 precipitates on gold surface inhibiting the cyanide attackE.avoid high pHs 9 Oxygen in Cyanidation Cyanidation Process Mechanisms – Oxygen adsorption into solution – Transport of dissolved O2 and CN- to S/L interface – Adsorption of O2 and CN- onto gold surface – Electrochemical reaction – Desorption of soluble Au-CN complexes (e.g. Au(CN)2-) and other reaction products from solid surface – Transport of soluble products into solution Normal Cyanidation • In normal conditions of cyanidation, the minimum NaCN concentration to extract gold is 75 mg/L. • The level of dissolved oxygen controls the kinetics of gold cyanidation • The concentration of cyanide does not usually determine the rate of the gold cyanidation reaction • The level of dissolved oxygen required for the cyanidation process depends on the cyanidation reactions and cyanide consumption by other substances (cyanicides). • The concentration of dissolved oxygen also depends on: - pressure (altitude) - temperature - agitation - ionic strength of the solution Silver Slows Down Cyanidation • 4 Au + 8 NaCN + O2 + 2 H2O = 4 Na[Au(CN)2] + 4 NaOH • Gold cyanidation employs diluted sodium or potassium cyanide solutions containing 100 to 1000 mg/L. • In average 100 tonnes of NaCN are needed to extract 1 tonne of gold • Most plants operate at between pH 9.5 and 11.5. • Cyanide consumption usually is between 0.05 and 5 kg NaCN/tonne of oreE.for cyanidation of concentrates, the cyanide consumption can be higher (>5 kg/t) Some Minerals Consume Cyanide • • • Some of the cations that form stable complexes with cyanide, and in the process consume cyanide, are: Cu+, Cu2+, Fe2+, Fe3+, Mn2+, Ni2+, Zn2+. One way to eliminate the cyanide consumption problem is to remove cyanicide, e.g. pyrrhotite, by magnetic separation or flotation (assuming it does not contain a significant amount of associated gold) prior to cyanidation. Other methods include adding lead nitrate, or oxidation of the sulfides by pre-aeration, oxygen or peroxide. Effect of Lead Nitrate • • • • Lead nitrate reduces cyanide consumption and speed up the gold leaching reaction Pb forms insoluble PbS removing passivation ions (S2+) from gold surface Local galvanic cells between is also formed on gold surface In a cyanide solution, lead nitrate, lead sulfide and lead sulphite react with gold to form AuPb2, AuPb3 and metallic lead, which clearly accelerate the gold dissolution Deschenes et al (2000/ Minerals Engineering v.13, n.12, p.1263-1279. 10 Effect of Lead Nitrate Some Minerals Consume Cyanide Au Extraction (%) 50 g/t Pb(NO3)2 No Pb(NO3)2 Time (h) Ore: 4.2 g/t Au, 0.9 g/t Ag, 3.1 pyrrhotite, 0.4% pyrite, Conditions: 0.38 g/L NaCN, pH 10 Deschenes et al (2000/ Minerals Engineering v.13, n.12, p.1263-1279. Some Minerals Consume Cyanide Some Minerals Consume Cyanide Pyrrhotites range from Fe5S6 to Fe16S17 Some Minerals Consume Cyanide Some Minerals Consume Cyanide • • When high concentrations of cyanideconsuming minerals (in particular Cu minerals) exist in a ore, cyanidation may become uneconomical as this results in poor gold recovery and high operating costs The ammonia-cyanide leaching system is an alternative approach. It is proposed that the ammonia stabilizes a copper(II)-ammoniacyanide complex such as Cu(NH3)4(CN)2 that is responsible for gold dissolution 11 Preg-Robbing Ore Preg-Robbing Ore • • • • Gold in solution can also be adsorbed by some mineralogical components of the ore. These are known as 'preg-robbing' substances. The most common preg-robbing substances are carbonaceous materials which are organic substances with high surface area. Not all carbonaceous material is activated • • • One way to eliminate this effect, in milder cases, is addition of diesel or kerosene to the leach to deactivate the carbonaceous matter, This has to be done with caution otherwise the posterior carbon-in-pulp (CIP) process (adsorption of gold on activated charcoal) could be adversely affected. The addition of kerosene can effectively passivate the carbonaceous material by coating it. This process is suitable for ore with less than 1% carbonaceous material. Preg-Robbing Ore • • • • Preg-Robbing Ore In other circumstances, the organic matter must be eliminated prior to cyanidation by flotation or by oxidization / burning Most common procedure to overcome this effect is the CIL (carbon-in-leach) process. AC is introduced into the leaching process and soluble gold is immediately adsorbed by the charcoal. The process takes advantage of the fact that the adsorption kinetics of gold on charcoal is faster than it is on the preg-robbing mineralogical species Recovering Gold from Cyanide Solutions • Gold can be recovered from CN solution by 3 methods: Activated Charcoal (AC) Adsorption Zinc precipitation (Merrill-Crowe • Adsorption with Activated Charcoal (AC) Carbon-in-Pulp (CIP) Carbon-in-Leach (CIL) Carbon-in-Columns (CIC) Recovering Gold with Activated Charcoal Ore or Conc. Ore or Conc. Ore or Conc. Cyanidation Cyanidation with AC Cyanidation pulp CIP AC Separation S/L AC Elution Au rich solution solution Elution solution Resin Adsorption • The first two are the most popular methods Source: Marsden, J.O, House I. 2006. The chemistry of gold extraction. 2nd ed. Littleton, CO: SME – Society for Mining, Metallurgy and Exploration. 651p Columns with AC Au rich solution AC Electrolysis Electrolysis Elution Gold Gold Electrolysis Au rich solution Gold AC = activated chacoal 12 Recovering Gold with Activated Charcoal • Activated Charcoal (AC) Properties: - Adsorptive Capacity (porous) - Adsorption Rate - Mechanical Strength and Wear Resistance - Reactivation Characteristics - Coarse Grain Size • Most AC are manufactured from coconut shell • Other materials can also be used anthracite, peat, etc. Recovering Gold with Activated Charcoal Recovering Gold with Activated Charcoal • The CIP method (Carbon-in-Pulp ) makes use of the physical affinity that activated charcoal (AC) has for gold (it can attract 7% of its weight in gold), which it readily attracts to its surface in cyanide solution. • Usually the industry does not load the AC with more than 8000 g Au/t charcoal = 0.8% • The following figure shows that less gold stays in solution when the max load is 5000 ppm • Adsorption rate on AC is rapid initially as Au adsorbs to most accessible sites but then decreases as rate controlled by diffusion along pores. Recovering the AC • As the particles of AC are coarser than the ground ore, the AC is screened after the cyanidation • The fine material is sent to cyanide destruction • Some fine AC particles (with Au) can be lost if the charcoal does not have good physical properties Ecuador, 2009 Source: Marsden, J.O, House I. 2006. The chemistry of gold extraction. 2nd ed. Littleton, CO: SME – Society for Mining, Metallurgy and Exploration. 651p Elution of Activated Charcoal • After loading the AC, gold must be extracted (eluted) from the charcoal surface • Elution procedures are very variable. Just a high pH solution can strip Au from the AC, but this takes time. • Usually companies use a cyanide solution 1-2 g/L and 10 g/L of NaOH and temperature 90-100 oC and up to 72 hours to strip >97% gold from AC • Elution is not done everyday. Wait for the charcoal to be loaded (5000 – 8000 gAu/t AC) Elution of Activated Charcoal • Solvents such as ethanol (10 to 20% vol) can speed up the process to be completed in 8 hours • The elution solution, now with 1000 to 3000 mg Au/L (ppm) is submitted to electrolysis • Some people use Zn to precipitate Au from the elution solution • Excess zinc is dissolved with acid, and gold is melted 13 Elution - Stripping of Au from AC Recovering Gold with Activated Charcoal • Figure: the elution solution (7 m3) is heated in a diesel oil burning column and pumped through two columns filled with the loaded activated charcoal • Stainless steel columns work in series to the electrolysis cell and then to a large holding tank, insulated with Styrofoam in a wooden box which in turn feeds the heating vessel. Recovering Gold with Activated Charcoal • After elution, the AC must be treated with nitric or hydrochloric acid to remove contaminants. • Usually the charcoal is treated after 10 to 12 times of use • After acid treatment, the AC is heat to 500 °C. • Impurities are removed as gases or remain as a tar-like residue. • Then the charcoal is exposed to an oxidizing atmosphere of steam containing CO2 and O2 at 700 – 1000 °C. This burns off the tar-like residue, develops internal pore structure, and the carbon atoms at the edges of crystallites become 'active sites' due to unsaturated valencies. Typical Carbon-in-Pulp Process Flowsheet Ore or Conc. Re-cycle to Process Comminution Cyanide Leach pulp CIP Recovering Gold with Zinc 4Au + 8CN- + O2 + 2H2O = 4Au(CN)2- + 4OH2Au(CN)2- + Zn = Zn(CN)42- + 2Au (Merrill-Crowe process) • Pulp is filtered and the clarified solution is then passed through a vacuum de-aeration tower where oxygen is removed from the solution. • Zinc powder is added to the solution with a dry chemical feeder. The reaction of the special fine powder zinc with the solution is almost instantaneous. Precipitated gold is recovered by filtering. Cyanide Destruction solution AC Tailings Pond Elution Electrolysis Gold • The Merrill-Crowe process is usually preferred over the charcoal process when the pregnant solution is high in Ag, or other metals like Hg, as these metals very quickly plug the pores of the charcoal Elution columns in Portovelo, Ecuador solution In the case of leaching concentrates, comminution is not always needed Merrill-Crowe Process (Factors Affecting Zinc Precipitation) • Suspended solids - interfere with the process possibly by coating the Zn particles and contaminate the final concentrate. Therefore, leach slurries are filtered to remove solids prior to Zn precipitation. • Dissolved Oxygen - oxygen reduction competes with Au reductions, therefore, dissolved oxygen reduces precipitation kinetics. De-aeration is required to lower dissolved oxygen levels to <0.5 - 1.0 mg/l prior to precipitation. • pH - the process is not very sensitive over pH range of 9 to 12. Above and below this range, precipitation decreases 14 Merrill-Crowe Process (Factors Affecting Zinc Precipitation) Typical Merrill-Crowe Process Flowsheet Ore or Conc. • Cyanide concentration - minimum concentration required otherwise rate of precipitation is reduced (Typically > 0.05 - 0.20 g/L) solution • Temperature - precipitation kinetics are accelerated at elevated temperatures • Gold concentration - precipitation rate increases with Au grade of solution • Zinc concentration - at high Zn concentrations, the dissolution rate of Zn can be slow. Also, high Zn concentrations can lead to formation of insoluble Znhydroxide which passivates Zn surface. Zn added at 5 to 30 times the stoichiometric Au requirement. Re-cycle to Process Comminution Cyanide Leach pulp pulp S/L Separation Settling Tank pulp solution solution pulp Precipitation w/ Zn Cyanide Destruction Leach with Acid Tailings Pond pulp Precipitate w/Al Gold In the case of leaching concentrates, comminution is not always needed Zinc Electrowinning • Instead of Zn precipitation, electrolysis can be used to treat high-grade gold solutions (carbon eluates) to produce loaded cathodes or cathode cell sludges Main Cyanidation Practices • Agitated Tanks – CIP (Carbon-in-Pulp) – CIL (Carbon-in-Leach) Au(CN)2- + e- → Au + 2CN• Advantages (over Zn precipitation) • Static leaching No chemicals or metals introduced in process More selective for Au and Ag over Cu – Vat leaching with Carbon-in-Column or Zinc ppt – Heap leaching with Carbon-in-Column or Zinc ppt • Intensive cyanidation (for concentrates) • Higher purity product • Disadvantages Low single pass efficiency per unit cell requiring recirculation of solution to achieve acceptable extraction – Gekko – Acacia – Mill-leaching (cyanidation in a small ball-mill) It needs high Au concentration in solution Cyanidation in Agitated Tanks in Small-scale • Cyanidation is being used in 160 tanks in Zaruma-Portovelo region • Tanks range from 10 to 20 m³ processing from 4 to 20 tonnes/day • Some plants use either MerrillCrowe or CIP (Carbon-in-Pulp) techniques Cyanidation in Agitated Tanks in Small-scale • CIP: 3 tanks = 9 hours, 100 tonnes/d, 2 g Au/t • 0.7 g NaCN/L, consumption = 2.5 kg NaCN/t of ore Ecuador, 2009 Ecuador, 2009 15 Cyanidation in Agitated Tanks in Small-scale • Merrill-Crowe process in Ecuador • The concrete tanks are loaded with 3,600-4,500 kg of sluice (“canalone”) concentrate and filled with about 11 m3 of cyanide solution that ranges from 2 to 4 g NaCN/L. • After 12 hours, agitation is stopped to allow the pulp to settle. The semi-clarified solution flows by gravity to a holding tank and then through 4 clusters of 4 PVC columns containing a total of 11 kg of zinc shavings. • Gold precipitation is not efficient as it is not conducted in vacuum. • Miners do not leach Zn with acid to obtain gold, they simply evaporate the zinc (bad practice!!!) Cyanidation in Agitated Tanks in Small-scale • Merrill-Crowe process in Ecuador Ecuador, 2007 Cyanidation in Vats Cyanidation in Agitated Tanks in Small-scale • Merrill-Crowe process in Ecuador • Vat leaching: cyanide solution slowly percolates through ore in a static tank. • Ore can be coarser than in agitation leaching, with sizes of <1 cm. • Ore is not agitated and coarse material must have good permeability. • Very fine grain sizes of <1 mm may tend to block the free circulation of the leaching agent. • The leaching period is 2 to 4 days and gold recovery is approximately 70 to 80%. Ecuador, 2007 Cyanidation in Vats • Some artisanal miners leach for 30 days Vat-leaching in the Tapajós Region, Amazon, Brazil Tailing pond (baixao) Vat-leaching tank Pool with CN solution Artisanal Gold Miners in Zimbabwe using Amalgamation Tailings to fill the cyanidation vat Tanks with activated charcoal Pool with pregnant solution 96 16 Heap Leaching Cyanidation in Heaps • Heap Leaching: the cheapest but slowest technique of gold cyanidation • It is a process usually applied to low-grade gold ore. • The ore is piled to a given height on an inclined impermeable surface, a so-called leach pad. • A sprinkler system provides a continuous spray of alkaline cyanide solution that percolates through the ore, dissolving the gold. • The gold-bearing or pregnant solution is collected and pumped to a gold recovery plant. http://www.sulliden.com/projects/shahuindo-gold-project.aspx Cyanidation in Heaps • The amount of material contained in a heap can reach 400 million tonnes (Yanacocha). Leaching time ranges from several weeks to a few months. Gold recovery rarely exceeds 70% Cyanidation in Heaps • Yanacocha Mine, the 4th gold producer in the world. • Location: Cajamarca, Peru, 4700 m above sea level • Started in 1993. In 2005, produced: 3.3 Moz gold • Ore Production: 544,000 tonnes/d @ 0.9 g Au/t • Rock is crushing and agglomerated with cement before going to the heap. Au recovery = 74% • Waste:Ore Ratio ~0.40 • Solution: 0.1 g/L NaCN, pH 10.5, 10 L/h/m2, NaCN consumption 0.06 kg/t ore Installing the plastic pads http://www.mining-technology.com/projects/minera/ Yanacocha Mine, Peru http://www.mining-technology.com/projects/minera/minera2.html • Au is adsorbed on activated charcoal, and then eluted solution is precipitated with zinc or submitted to electrolysis http://www.geomineinfo.com/Complimentary%20Downloads/Yanacocha.pdf Intensive Cyanidation • • • • Many mining companies do not concentrate gold before leaching it with cyanide The whole ore cyanidation is a common practice usually when gold is very fine, hard to liberate but the rock is prorous to allow penetartion of cyanide solution The operating cost of whole ore leachingis higher than cyanidation of concetrates also called intensive cyanidation The cost of destroying cyanide is high when the whole ore is leached Intensive Cyanidation • • • • • • Coarse gold takes a long time to be dissolved in normal cyanidation solutions. In normal conditions of cyanidation the solubility rate of pure metallic gold is 3.25 mg/cm2/hour. Pure silver dissolution rate is 1.54 mg/cm2/hour. The more silver, the slower is the dissolution of the Au-Ag alloy Then a pure gold grain of 44 µm (400 mesh) would take about 13 hours to dissolve. A 150 micron (100 mesh) diameter pure gold particle would need almost 44 hours to dissolve. Hedley, N. and Tabachnick, H., 1968. Chemistry of Cyanidation. Mineral Dressing Notes, n. 23. American Cyanamid Co. 17 Intensive Cyanidation • • • • • In the past many companies used gravity concentration followed by amalgamation of the gold in the concentrate. Amalgamation was used to remove the “coarse” (100 µm) gold The tailings from amalgamation was leached with cyanide. Problem: this forms mercury cyanide which is very toxic and also consumes cyanide. Most organized mining companies no longer use amalgamationEartisanal miners use 1000 tonnes Hg/annum Intensive Cyanidation • To leach coarse gold a strong oxidant is needed. • The concentration of the oxidizing agent is more important than a high cyanide concentration. • High concentration of cyanide is used because, in an oxidant environment, cyanide will be oxidized as well, forming cyanate (CNO-). Intensive Cyanidation • • • • If the ore has coarse gold (>100 µm), companies use gravity concentration and/or flotation. They concentrate gold until >3000 g Au/tonne and melt it with borax. Problem: gold can be in the slag and this must be leached with cyanide or all middling products in the gravity sep. must be recyled Recently, mining companies are concentrating gold (gravity or flotation) followed by leaching the concentrate: Intensive Cyanidation Intensive Cyanidation • Intensive cyanidation of gravity and flotation systems have been used by GEKKO and Acacia Systems • The GEKKO process is a thin film in a drum • 5 to 20 g/L of NaCN is used • Use of catalysts Leachwell® or LeachAid® or hydrogen peroxide (up to 0.5 g/L) is common • Temperature can also increase cyanidation rate Intensive Cyanidation Intensive Cyanidation • Acacia System CS 250: 375 kg conc./cycle Acacia System: • Knelson Centrifuge provide concentrates for the reactor • Pre-washing of the gold concentrate to remove ultra-fine solids (slimes) • NaOH, NaCN and LeachAid® • Agitation for 16 hours with warm CN solution • Decanting and wash the solids with water • Electrowinning • Tailings sent to the normal cyanidation circuit http://www.knelsongravitysolutions.com/page361.htm http://www.knelsongravitysolutions.com/page361.htm 18 Intensive Cyanidation Intensive Cyanidation • A good methodology to investigate intensive cyanidation of gravity concentrates can be: • Concentrate is ground with different times and leached with cyanide (5 to 20 g/L) for 1 to 12 hours, 40% solids and pH 10.5 to 11 and presence of H2O2 (0.3 g/L = 100mL of 3% v.v. H2O2 solution in 1 L of water) • It is always useful to do CIL – Carbon-in-Leach process to avoid any preg-robbing effect Veiga,M.M.; Nunes,D.; Klein,B.; Shandro,J.A.; Velasquez,P.C.; Sousa,R.N. (2009). Replacing Mercury Use in Artisanal Gold Mining: Preliminary Tests of Mill-Leaching. J. Cleaner Production, v.17, p.1373–1381 Small-scale Intensive Cyanidation implemented in Tapajós, Brazil +2mm Screen 2 mm Hammer mill Gold ore (Mill-leaching) • The ore is not primarily finely ground (this can be conducted in a hammer-mill) • Gold concentration in centrifuge or in sluice boxes or jig or flotation • Unliberated gold is also concentrated = pre-concentration • Concentrate is taken to a small batch ball-mill with cyanide and a capsule of activated charcoal • Leached for 8 hours with 10-20 g/L NaCN and 0.3 g/L H2O2, pH 10.5. • Remove the capsule of activated charcoal • Elution • Electrolysis or precipitation with zinc and leaching with acid A Simple Intensive Cyanidation System Icon centrifuge: 2 tonnes/h of ore -2mm Icon centrifuge tailing Icon centrifuge tailing flotation co nc . conc. . nc co Intensive Cyanidation activated charcoal elution final tailing electrolisis meting gold Icon® (Falcon) centrifuge A Simple Intensive Cyanidation System Re-grinding the centrifuge concentrates Source: Falcon website, 2009 Capacity: 2t/h Pulp: 30% solids Cycle: 15 to 30 minutes Bowl: 1kg concent. (dry) Day: 40 to 80kg conc Au recovery: 50 to 65% Capsule of activated charcoal in the ball mill Sousa,R.N.; Veiga,M.M.; Klein,B.; Telmer,K.; Gunson,A.J.; Bernaudat,L. (2010). Strategies for Reducing the Environmental Impact of Reprocessing Mercury-contaminated Tailings in the Artisanal and Small-scale Gold Mining Sector: Insights from Tapajos River Basin, Brazil. In press by Journal of Cleaner Production. 19 Centrifuge concentrate [CN] 20 g/L, 0.3 g/L H2O2 grinding Intensive Cyanidation in Ball Mill • This is an easy procedure • Replace the use of Hg in these small ball-mills • Capsule of activated charcoal can be added together with rods or ballsEbut this depends on the resistance of the capsule • If necessary grind first, remove rods and add the AC capsule later Same but no grinding Conventional cyanidation Head sample, [CN] 1g/L, pH 10-11, no grinding Ecuador, 2009 Sousa,R.N.; Veiga,M.M.; Klein,B.; Telmer,K.; Gunson,A.J.; Bernaudat,L. (2010). Strategies for Reducing the Environmental Impact of Reprocessing Mercury-contaminated Tailings in the Artisanal and Small-scale Gold Mining Sector: Insights from Tapajos River Basin, Brazil. In press by Journal of Cleaner Production. Intensive Cyanidation Tests in Ecuador • Concentrate from sluice boxes (17,3 g Au/t) was split in 3 subsamples: – Amalgamation (160 kg) – Conventional cyanidation in tank (695 kg) – Intensive cyanidation in ball mill (80kg) Result of Amalgamation • Manual amalgamation • 8 hours in a batea with mercury and brown sugar • Gold recovery from the gravity concentrate after amalgamation was: 26% Ecuador, 2007 Ecuador, 2007 Result of Conventional Cyanidation Result of Intensive Cyanidation in Ball Mill • In agitated tank • pH = 11 • Gold recovery from the gravity concentrate after 31 horas was: 94% • NaCN consumption was 4.5 kg/t of concentrate • Gold recovery after 8 hours of millleaching the concentrate was: 95% • Cyanide consumption was 0.95 kg/t of concentrate Ecuador, 2007 20 Results of Elution of Activated Charcoal Intensive Cyanidation (conclusion) • For environmental and economic reasons, intensive cyanidation of gravity and flotation concentrates must be the future of gold mining industry. • • • • NaCN = 2g/L, NaOH = 10 g/L Alcohol = 20% Temperature: 90 °C, 8 h 97% of gold removed from the activated charcoal • Gold precipitated with small amount of zinc • Zinc leached with HNO3 • Zinc can also be precipitated with aluminum (cementation) • Coarse gold particles (up to 1 mm) can be leached in intensive cyanidation circuitsEthe use of catalysts (oxidants) is fundamental. • This reduces liability and operating costs • Capital costs is not much higher but depends on flotation and gravity concentration circuits Ecuador, 2007 Diagnosis Leaching • This is a procedure to assess why the gold is not being extracted by classical cyanidation (low CN concentration and no peroxide) Tests to Check Accessibility of Cyanide to Gold Particles • First of all, the sample must be ground below 0.1 mm, homogenized and 30g obtained to make a fire assay • Fire assay is a procedure to melt (~1200 oC) the whole material with borax, lead oxide and a source of carbon (e.g. flour). The carbon reduces the PbO and the lead carries the precious metals to the bottom of the crucible. • The lead button is placed into a cupel, which is a small dish made from fishbone ash, and placed into a furnace. Lead volatilizes and soaks into the cupel, leaving a small "bead" of precious metals. • The bead is leached with aqua regia and analyzed by atomic absorption spectrometry Diagnosis Leaching Diagnosis Leaching • Another subsample of the ground material (200 g) is leached with cyanide 1 g/L (467 mL) for 24-48 hours (rolling bottles or agitated beaker) using 30% of solids, pH 10.5, ambient temperature. During the test, check free cyanide consumption (titration with AgNO3) and eventually add more cyanide if needed. • %Au extracted = mg gold in solution (volume was 467mL) • Some people keep the rolling bottles for 72 h, but this depends on how much coarse gold has the material. You can pan a bit of the material to check the presence of coarse (>0,1mm) gold mg of gold in sample (weight was 200g) • If total gold was not extractedEuse the filtration residue (now it its dried). • Regrind it, weigh it and leach it again with cyanideEin most cases this solve the problemEbut the question is how fine you must grind the material (ore or concentrate)? • It is not suggested to grind too fine since this is a very expensive operation in a real plant • Filter the solution and send it to be analyzed by atomic absorption. Wash, dry and keep the residue. • Grind below 200 mesh (0.074mm) and use same leaching with CN conditions as above • With the result from the atomic absorption you can check if the total gold was dissolved in cyanide • Filter and send solution to atomic absorption. Wash, dry and keep the residue. 21 Diagnosis Leaching Diagnosis Leaching • If the total gold was not extract yet, gold can be occluded in the sulfide minerals. Weigh the dry residue. • Leach the residue with cyanide using similar conditions as above. Filter and keep residue. Fe3+ • Oxidize sulfides using 2M HCl and 100 g/L as FeCl3, at boiling temp. for 6 to 24 h, L:S=2:1. Use an agitated beaker. • Send solution to atomic absorption • If the total gold was not extracted yet and the sample has organic matter (dark color), use the filtration residue from the previous leaching step • Filter the sample, wash it and keep solution (measure the volume). If you notice in the wet solids some sulfides, add on the wet sample nitric acid 1:1 (HNO3 55%: distilled water) L:S=10:1 (approximately) • Check if gold is adsorbed on organic matter. Extract gold using 40% v/v acetonitrile in distilled water, 10 g/L sodium cyanide, and 2 g/L NaOH, 16 hours, L:S = 5:1Efilter, wash and analyze solution. Dry residue. • Filter it, wash it well (measure the volume of solution). All acid solutions must be analyzed as acid + oxidizing agent can dissolve some gold (some authors found gold in solution) • If total gold was not extracted yetEuse filtration residue. Probably the acetonitrile was not enough to extract all organic matter • Dry and weigh residue Diagnosis Leaching • An ultimate test is to burn carbonaceous material off in a furnace at 700 °C for 6 hours and repeat cyanidation. This can also roast any residual sulfide • Leach silicates with HF and filter. L:S=10:1 • Residual gold: leach the residue with aqua regia: 3 HCl + 1 HNO3. L:S=10:1 Environmental Management of Cyanide • Analyze solutionEnow the total gold was definitely extracted. Based on the weight of each leaching step calculate the % gold extracted in each step. • The sequence of leaching can have more steps depending on the mineralogical phases to be investigated Adapted from Lorenzen, L. (1995). Minerals Engineering, v. 8, n. 3, p. 247-256 Use of Cyanide Use of Cyanide • About 1.4 million tonnes of hydrogen cyanide (HCN) are produced annually worldwide. • Cyanide price is around US$ 1.1 and 1.3 per kilogram but now increased to near US$ 3/kg Gold Mining 13% Used in production of Organic Chemicals 85% Other 2% • According to the ICMI – International Cyanide Management Institute, 1.4 million of HCN is produced annually in the the world. This is equivalent to 2.5 million tonnes of NaCN. • About 13% is used in the gold mining industry. • This is equivalent to 325,000 tonnes/a of NaCN. Used for NaCN production • ICMI (2010). International Cyanide Management Institute. http://www.cyanidecode.org/cyanide_use.php 22 Gold Uses Gold Uses Source: Elma van der Lingen (2005). Gold’s Other Uses, The LBMA Precious Metals Conference 2005, Johannesburg, p.75-80 Source: Elma van der Lingen (2005). Gold’s Other Uses, The LBMA Precious Metals Conference 2005, Johannesburg, p.75-80 Gold Consumption Gold Mine Production 2009 (tonnes) 1. China (314) 2. Australia (227) 3. United States (216) 4. South Africa (205) 5. Russia (205) 6. Peru (180) 7. Canada (95) 8. Ghana (90.2) 9. Indonesia (90) 10. Uzbekistan (80) Total: 2572 tonnes • The total gold produced in the world: 161,000 tonnes; enough to fill 2 Olympic swimming pools • India is the largest gold consumer. In 2008 consumed 660.2 tonnes Au • In 2008 China consumed 395.6 tonnes of gold Photo: http://goldprice.org/buyinggold/uploaded_images/indian-gold-742896.jpg Others (854) Source: Goldsheet. http://www.goldsheetlinks.com/production.htm Use of Cyanide • Cyanidation employs diluted sodium or potassium cyanide solutions containing 50 to 500 mg/L (free cyanide is typically 50 to 100 mg/L). • Cyanide consumption is typically 300 to 2000 g NaCN per tonne of ore. • In average 100 tonnes NaCN is used to produce 1 tonne of gold. • Cyanide concentration in effluents (Canadian gold industry) range from 0.3 to 30 mg/L (ppm). • Cyanide is also used as a depressant to separate multiple sulfide ores by flotation (e.g.: depress chalcopyrite to float galena). Concentration of total cyanide in flotation effluents is <0.03 mg/L (ppm). Cyanide Toxicity Species Rainbow trout Yellow perch Snail Temperature (°C) 6 10 12 18 15 21 20 96-h LC50 (mg/L) 0.028 0.057 0.042 0.068 0.090 0.102 0.432 Higher temperature, lower toxicity 23 Cyanide Toxicity • Adverse effects on fish swimming and reproduction usually occur between 0.005 and 0.007 mg of free cyanide/L. • Free cyanide concentrations between 0.05 and 0.2 mg/L are fatal to the more-sensitive species Cyanide Toxicity • Public perception is that cyanide is very dangerous... chemical warfare judicial executions mass suicides the Tylenol affair • A large majority of the public believes that cyanide is more dangerous than mercury...however cyanide is not persistent in the environment and Hg is. • Problems: spills misuse of cyanide by Artisanal Gold Miners Cyanide Toxicity Cyanide Toxicity • Jim Jones was the founder and leader of the Peoples Temple, in Jonestown, Guyana • On November 18, 1978, 909 Temple members, including 276 children, drunk cyanide with Cool Aid Source: Infoczarina, 2008 http://www.chicagostagereview.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/jonestown1.jpg Cyanide Spills Cyanide Spills • Baia Mare, Romania, mine re-opened in 1999. • 1000 tonnes of fish killed • Intense rain in Jan 2000 = overflow • CN in the Danudbe m3 • 100,000 of tailings with cyanide released to the river • 50 to 100 tonnes of cyanide released • Public reaction was horrible 24 Cyanide Spills • 1995 – Omai Mine in the Esequibo region in Guyana • 4 millions m3 of cyanide contaminated tailings entered the Essequibo River • Until now the use of cyanide in mining is not allowed in Guyana • The use of Hg has increased Rudimentary Cyanidation Plant made by Artisanal Miners in Zimbabwe Amalgamation tailings (full of Hg) are submitted to cyanidation http://www.ec.gc.ca/inre-nwri/default.asp?lang=En&n=0CD66675-1&offset=14&toc=show Rudimentary Cyanidation Plant made by Artisanal Miners in Zimbabwe Misuse of Cyanide • Increasing the use of Hg-amalgamation followed by cyanidation in Artisanal Mining. • Cyanidation of Hg-rich tailings forms Hg(CN)42which is a very stable and persistent compound. This can be transformed into highly toxic compounds, e.g. Methylmercurycyanide ...at least they know that cyanide is dangerous!!! Artisanal Gold Miners (Sulawesi, Indonesia) Artisanal Gold Miners (Sulawesi, Indonesia) Rudimentary tailing pond; often CN-rich tailings reach the streams Recovering loaded charcoal (retained in a screen) Only CN destruction method = NATURAL = sun light False perception that this destroys all cyanide complexes 25 Cyanide Toxicity • Free cyanide criteria currently proposed for the protection of natural resources: Free cyanide (CN- or HCN) criteria for the protection of aquatic life of natural resources: <0.005 mg/L (Canadian Water Quality Guidelines, 2001). for human protection: • drinking water in USA and Canada: MAC = 0.2 mg/L • in drinking water in Sweden: 0.05 mg/L • WHO Drinking water quality guideline: 0.07 mg/L (12 µg/kg body weight) • <50mg/kg in diet • <5mg/m³ in air Cyanide Toxicity (humans) Cyanide Toxicity • The cyanide toxicity depends on the cyanide species. The predominance of free cyanide (CN- and HCN) depends on the pH • In solutions with pH above 10, free cyanide is as CN- and not as HCN gas • The gold cyanidation is usually conducted at pH 10.5 to 11 Cyanide Toxicity (humans) • In solution, 3 to 5 mg of cyanide/kg body weight is lethal • Cyanide is readily absorbed through inhalation, ingestion or skin contact. If a mine uses a CN solution of 300 mg/L • In respiratory exposure to hydrocyanic acid (HCN gas), death occurs at 0.1 to 0.3 g/m³ A 100-kg person should drink 1.5 L to die • Cyanide is a potent asphyxiant. It induces tissue anoxia through inactivation of cytochrome oxidase due to the reaction of CN- and Fe3+. • Oxygen cannot be utilized and death results from the depression of the central nervous system. You need to drink a lot of Cyanide solution to die Cyanide Toxicity (humans) • Some plants such as sorghum, cassava, bamboo and lima beans can contain over 2,000 mg/kg total cyanide. At this level, ingestion of 170 g of the plant can be lethal to a 80 kg-human being. Fishing with Cyanide It’s forbidden to fish with cyanide and explosives • Congenital hypothyroidism (cretinism) is present in 15% of newborns in certain areas of Zaire where cassava is a staple food. This incidence is approximately 500 times that observed in industrial countries. Ecuador, 2006 26 Cyanide Toxicity (humans) • Cyanide is detoxified by an enzyme called rhodanase forming thiocyanate CNS • The major route of cyanide elimination from the body is via urinary excretion of thiocyanate (CNS). • The toxicity of thiocyanate is significantly less than that of cyanide, but chronically elevated levels of thiocyanate in blood can inhibit the uptake of iodine by the thyroid gland, thereby reducing the formation of thyroxine. Cyanide Toxicity (humans) Organs affected by Chronic intoxication with cyanide (oral exposure): • Central nervous system: neuropathies and amblyopia (partial or complete loss of vision in one eye caused by conditions that affect the normal development of vision) • Thyroid: increase thyroid weights and depress thyroid function • Reproduction and Development: congenital hypothyroidism was reported in human newborns Cyanide Toxicity (humans) Cyanide does not accumulate in the blood and tissues following oral exposure to inorganic cyanide and no cumulative effect on the organism during repeated exposure has been demonstrated. There is a cumulative effect of exposure to thiocyanate resulting in thyroid toxicity, including goitre and cretinism. Cyanide Toxicity (humans) Organs affected by Chronic intoxication with cyanide (inhalation): • Central nervous system: vertigo, equilibrium disturbances, nystagmus, nervousness, headache, weakness, loss of appetite, changes in smell and taste • Cardiovascular and/or respiratory system: breathing difficulties • Gastrointestinal tract: nausea, and gastritis • Thyroid: Enlarged thyroids • Reproduction and Development: risk of giving birth to low body weight infants and of perinatal death. • Kidneys Cyanide Toxicity (hypothyroidism) • The main purpose of thyroid hormone is to "run the body's metabolism”. It takes iodine, found in many foods, and convert it into thyroid hormones. • Hypothyroidism results in inflammation of the thyroid gland and reduction of hormone production. Cyanide Toxicity (congenital hypothyroidism) Cretinism: • Poor length growth Adult stature without treatment ranges from 1 to 1.6 m • Neurological impairment • Thickened skin goitre Sources: http://www.endocrineweb.com/thyfunction.html http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goitre thyroid gland normally weighs <30g • Enlarged tongue • Protruding abdomen Sources: • http://www.gidabilimi.com/images/kretenizm1.png • Wikipedia 27 Important Toxicological Facts • The greatest source of cyanide exposure to humans and some animals is cyanogenic food plants and forage crops, not mining operations. • Free cyanide is the primary toxic agent • Cyanides are not mutagenic or carcinogenic. • There is no indication that cyanide is biomagnified in food web. • Cyanide has low persistence in the environment • In general, the toxicity of free cyanide is reduced when a complex is formed. Free Cyanide • Determined by tritation with AgNO3 • Silver will complex with free CN and excess of Ag+ is detected by p-dimethylaminobenzalrhodanine or by potassium iodide (KI) whihc are indicators • AgNO3 + 2NaCN = NaAg(CN)2 + NaNO3 • Color will change from yellow to blue (dimetyl) or a white bluish color in the case of KI • Free cyanide is determined based on the volume of silver nitrate used in the titration • Total CN is determined by another method... distillation Fate of Free Cyanide • Free cyanide seldom remains biologically available in soils and sediments because it is either complexed by trace metals, metabolized by various microorganisms, or lost through volatilization. • Under aerobic conditions, cyanide salts in the soil are microbiologically degraded to nitrites or form complexes with metals. Types of Cyanide 1. Free cyanide (HCN/CN-) and simple cyanide salts (NaCN, KCN) which dissolve in water to form free cyanide. Free cyanide is the active form to leach gold 2. Weak and moderately strong cyanide complexes such as cyanides of Zn(CN)42-, Cd(CN)3-, Cd(CN)42-, Cu(CN)2-, Cu(CN)32-, Ni(CN)42-, Ag(CN)2- These cyanides are known as Weak Acid Dissociable Cyanides (WAD) as they can be decomposed in weak acid (pH 3 to 6). 3. Strongly bound cyanide complexes such as Co(CN)64-, Au(CN)2-, Fe(CN)64-. These are stable under ambient conditions of pH and temperature Complexes with Heavy Metal • In the leaching of gold, many other metals can be dissolved in cyanide forming complexes. • Example of minerals soluble in cyanide: – – – – – – – – – Pyrrhotite - FeS Argentite - AgS Malachite - CuCO3.Cu(OH)2 Chalcocite - Cu2S Bornite - Cu5FeS4 Orpigment - As2S3 Galena - PbS, partially soluble Sphalerite - ZnS, partially soluble Pyrite - FeS2, sparingly soluble Main Cyanide Reactions Hydrolysis Oxidation of HCN/CN- CN- + H2O = HCN + OH2HCN + O2 = 2HCNO 2CN- + O2 + catalyst = 2CNO- Hydrolysis of CNO HCNO + H2O = NH3 + CO2 Hydrolysis/saponification of HCN + 2H2O = NH4COOH or HCN + 2H2O = NH3 + HCOOH HCN Aerobic biodegradation 2HCN + O2 + enzyme = 2HCNO S 2x − + CN- = S 2x −−1 + CNS - • Under anaerobic conditions, cyanides denitrify to gaseous nitrogen compounds and enter the atmosphere. Thiocyanate formation • All cyanide complexes are subjected to (biotic and abiotic) oxidation. Metal-cyanide complexation Zn2+ + 4CN- = Zn (CN ) 24 − Anaerobic biodegradation CN- + H2S = HCNS + H+ HCN + HS- = HCNS + H+ Cyanide compound dissociation S 2 O 32 − + CN- = SO 32 − + CNSNaCN = Na+ + CN- 28 Cyanide Treatment Processes Cyanide Cycle • Natural Degradation (Lagooning) NH3 + CO2 HCN/CNcyanidation tank • Oxidation Processes evaporation and decomposition – Alkaline Chlorination spill tailing pond River NH3 + HCO3or tailing with cyanide HCN/CN- Fe(CN)63Fe(CN)64- NO3- – Electrochemical Processes – Ozonation – Hydrogen Peroxide CO32- – INCO’s SO2/Air Process CH4 + CO2 • Precipitation (Cuprous Process) Natural Degradation Cyanide Treatment Processes (cont.) • Conversion to Less Toxic Forms • Biological Treatment • Cyanide Recovery Processes • It is the oldest treatment method used by Canadian gold mines to remove cyanide from effluents. • Volatilization is the main mechanism. The most important variables are: – Acidification/Volatilization/Reneutralization AVR – – pH temperature – Ion Exchange – – UV light aeration – Activated Charcoal • Other variables: – Electrolytic Processes – – – Natural Degradation • The equilibrium between free cyanide species (CNand HCN) is pH dependent: HCN = H+ + CNDissociation constant + − [ H ].[ CN ] = 4 .93 x10 −10 [ HCN ] • Molecular HCN has high vapor pressure and therefore can readily be volatilized to the atmosphere. At pH 7, 99.5% of free cyanide exists as molecular HCN. Kd = (CN-/HCN) • Free cyanide is rare in mining tailings because of the high reactivity of the CN- molecule with metal ions. biodegradation precipitation conversion to thiocyanate Stability of Cyanide Complexes Cyanide Complex Co(CN) 4− 6 Dissociation Constant 10-50 Fe(CN ) 4− 6 10-47 Hg( CN ) 2− 4 10-39 Au( CN ) −2 10-37 Cr ( CN ) 3− 6 10-33 Cu( CN ) 24 − 10-30.7 Ni( CN ) 2− 4 10-30 Cu( CN ) 23 − 10-29.2 Cr ( CN ) 4− 6 10-21 Zn( CN ) 2− 4 10-21 Ag( CN ) −2 10-20.4 Cd ( CN ) 2− 4 10-19 29 Natural Degradation • 3− 4− Ferrocyanides ( Fe( CN ) 6 ) and Ferricyanides ( Fe (CN ) 6 ) are very stable compounds. They can form complexes with trace metals. Most complexes are insoluble, e.g.: SnFe (CN ) 6 = tin(IV) ferrocyanide Cyanide Guidelines (Canadian Legislation) Water Use Strong-acid dissociable cyanide plus thiocyanate µg/L (as CN) Strong-acid dissociable cyanide µg/L (as CN) Weak-acid dissociable cyanide µg/L (as CN) Raw Drinking Water (maximum) 200 µg/L Not applicable Not applicable Fe 4 [ Fe( CN ) 6 ]3 = ferric ferrocyanide Co 3[ Fe( CN ) 6 ]2 = cobalt ferricyanide Sn 3 [Fe(CN ) 6 ]2 = tin(II) ferricyanide • Major environmental concern: ferrocyanides and ferricyanides (usually in the sediments) can form free cyanide by influence of ultraviolet light This reaction can take hundreds of years Freshwater Aquatic Life (30-day average) Not applicable None proposed < or = 5 µg/L Freshwater Aquatic Life (maximum) Not applicable None proposed 10 µg/L Marine and Estuarine Aquatic Life (maximum at any time) Not applicable None proposed 1µg/L British Columbia Approved Water Quality Guidelines (Criteria) 1998 Edition Cyanide Guidelines • The Canadian MMER (Metal Mining Effluent Regulation, 2002): maximum level of total cyanide to be released in a mining effluent is 1.0 mg/L (ppm) as a monthly average concentration, 1.5 mg/L in a composite sample and 2 mg/L in a grab sample. • In Yukon Territory, the discharge limits are 0.5 mg/L of total cyanide and 0.2 mg/L of WAD (weakly acid dissociable) • The World Bank guidelines (1995) for discharge into the environment are: – Free Cyanide: 0.1 mg/L – Weak Acid Dissociable: 0.5 mg/L – Total Cyanide: 1.0 mg/L. – In no case should the concentration in the receiving water outside of a designated mixing zone exceed 0.022 mg/L. Natural Degradation • Natural degradation is: suitable for removal of “free cyanide”, removes partially Zn and Cd cyanide complexes and thiocyanate (CNS) does not remove Cu and Ni complexes and Iron-cyanides. • Natural degradation is more effective when barren solutions (“barren bleed ponds”) are stored separately from solid tailings in shallow ponds. Natural Degradation • Before the mid 1970s, natural degradation was the only treatment method used by the Canadian mining industry • Photodegradation is affected by turbidity, color and depth, intensity and wavelength of light, angle of light incidence and cloud cover. • Degradation: free cyanide in the concentration range of 0.1 to 0.5 mg/L is volatilized at a rate of 0.021 mg CN/ft2.hr in still waters. • Rates in agitated water are up to 3 times as great. • A temperature increase of 10°C causes the free cyanide removal rate to increase by more than 40% Oxidation by Chlorine • Alkaline chlorination is the oxidation of cyanide in an alkaline solution by chlorine or hypochorite. • The complete oxidation of cyanide proceeds in two stages at different pH’s: • In the first stage, cyanide is transformed to cyanate (CNO) (which is considered approximately onethousandth as toxic as hydrogen cyanide). The oxidation of cyanide is represented by the equations: Any pH: High pH: CN- + Cl2 = CNCl + Cl- CNCl + 2OH- = CNO- + Cl- + H2O With hypochlorite: CN- + OCl- = CNO- + Cl- 30 Oxidation by Chlorine Oxidation by Chlorine • Advantages of the process: Easy to operate Reactions reasonably rapid Free and WAD cyanides as well as thiocyanates are destroyed Chlorine or hypochlorite readily available in several forms Capital outlay relatively low • The second stage consists of cyanate being converted to bicarbonate and nitrogen: 2CNO- + 3Cl2 + 4H2O = (NH4)2CO3 + 3Cl2 + CO32(NH4)2CO3 + 3Cl2 + 6OH- + CO32- = 2HCO3- + N2 + 6Cl- + 6H2O Oxidation by Chlorine • Disadvantages: High operating cost (reagents are costly) Requires pH control to prevent cyanogen chloride which is highly toxic Ferro and Ferricyanides are not destroyed High content of chloride and chlorine in effluents Some chlorination products (e.g. Nahypochlorite, chloro-lime, etc.) are degradable: storage problems in remote regions. Electrochemical Processes Electroreduction: Complex metal cyanide ions reduce at the cathode to deposit or precipitate the metal, regenerating free cyanide: Me( CN ) 2n − n + 2 e − = n CN − + Me° ↓ ( Me = divalent metal) Electrochlorination : Anode reaction: Cl − = Cl° + e − 2Cl° = Cl 2 (g) Cathode reaction: H 2 O + e − = H° + OH − 2 H ° = H 2 (g ) ↑ • Introducing NaCl into the solution, chlorine is produced by electrolysis. Hypochlorite and chlorate can also be formed. Free cyanide, WAD cyanides and thiocyanates are destroyed. Ironcyanides are not destroyed • Cyanide can be regenerated Oxidation with Hydrogen Peroxide Oxidation with Hydrogen Peroxide • Cyanide oxidation with H2O2 is a fast, one-step reaction, forming non-toxic intermediates. • Cu and Ni cyanides are partially destroyed and Iron-cyanides are partially precipitated. • H2O2 oxidizes free and Zn & Cd cyanides to cyanate which is further hydrolyzed yielding biodegradable ammonia and carbonate. • Since copper and other metal ions are already in many mining effluents, additional metallic catalyst may not be required to enhance the reaction rate. CN- + H2O2 = CNO- + H2O (Cu2+ is a catalyst) CNO- + 2H2O = NH4+ + CO32- • Degussa process uses borate compounds as catalysts resulting in a substantial saving of hydrogen peroxide consumption (up to 60%). (pH just < 7) 31 Oxidation with Hydrogen Peroxide Oxidation with Hydrogen Peroxide (Example) • There are a variety of processes combining hydrogen peroxide with other compounds, such as glycolonitrile (Kastone process), H2SO4 (Caro’s acid), SO2, etc. Species • Formation of thiocyanate by H2O2 is slow (in contrast to chlorination). As Cu total CN Fe Se Ag Zn • H2O2 consumption is estimated to be around 3 kg/kg CN-. Theoretical dosage: 1.5 kg H2O2/kg CN• The process is not very suitable for slurries. • High operating cost. • First used at Ok Tedi in 1984 and in Canada at Teck Corona in 1985. Many plants in Canada use peroxide. Invented by INCO in 1984 as a result of a research to destroy cyanide used to depress pyrrhotite during flotation of pentandite (NiFe9S8) and Chalcopyrite (CuFeS2). • A mixture of sulphur dioxide and air rapidly oxidizes free cyanide and WAD metal cyanide complexes in the presence of Cu2+ as catalyst. - INCO SO2/Air Process • Copper should be present in minimum concentration of 50 mg/L and can be added as copper sulphate. Cu2+ additions depend on the iron content of the effluent and are in the range 0 to 0.5 g/g total CN. • Free cyanide, Zn, Cd, Cu, Ni cyanides are destroyed. Iron-cyanides are partially precipitated. Thiocyanide is partially (10 to 20%) destroyed. • The process is usually performed in one or two stages, bubbling SO2-air or adding sodium metabisulphite. Air flowrate is around 1 L/min per liter of solution. In practice 3-4 kg SO2 (or 5-8 kg of sodium metabisulphite) is required per kg of cyanide. Stoichiometrically the reactions require 2.46 kg SO2 per kg of WAD cyanides. • Retention time ranges from 20 min to 2 hours. - CN + SO2 + O2 + H2O = CNO + H2SO4 (Cu2+ is a catalyst) Me(CN) 24− + 4 SO 2 + 2 O 2 + 4H 2 O = 4 CNO − + 4 H 2SO 4 + Me 2+ Me2+ = Zn2+, Cu2+, Ni2+, Cd2+, etc. (neutralization): H2SO4 + Ca(OH)2 = CaSO4.2H2O ↓ (pH>8) (precipitation): Me2+ + Ca(OH)2 = Me(OH)2 ↓ + Ca2+ 2 Me 2 + + Fe(CN ) 64− = Me 2 Fe(CN ) 6 ↓ INCO SO2/Air Process • The process has been licensed at over 100 project sites worldwide. • The process has been used to treat effluents containing > 200 mg/L total cyanide and routinely reduces this to <1 mg/L • Capital cost for an installation to destroy 3,000 tonnes of slurry/d is Cn$ 1.2 million (installed) • Typical operating cost to treat tailings from a plant using CIP is Cn$0.8/tonne • Patent expired in 2004 EPA dws (mg/L) 0.05 9.0 0.05 0.3 0.01 0.05 5 Note: H2O2 dosage = 2.5 mL/L dws = drinking water standard INCO SO2/Air Process • Effluent (mg/L) Before After 0.2 <0.05 4.5 <1 280 3 16 <0.015 5 4 3.2 1 157 <1 INCO SO2/Air Process Species Total cyanide WAD cyanides Cyanate Thiocyanate Cu Fe Ni Liquid Effluent (mg/L) Before After 365.8 0.69 225 0.15 44.6 100.7 35.45 45.82 4.13 324.2 82.5 1.21 0.26 0.25 Final Tailing (mg/L) 29.4 12.2 52.9 18.9 7.7 5.35 0.51 32 Combinox Process • Developed in Germany by CyPlus, this is a variation of the INCO Process, when the patent expired (May 2008) • This process is a combination of SO2/Air and Peroxide (Degussa Process) • Thiocyanate (CNS) is destroyed • It destroys free and Zn, Ag, Cd, Cu, Ni cyanides • Fe cyanides are precipitated in presence of copper: Fe(CN)64- + 2Cu2+ → Cu2Fe(CN)6 (solid) • Final product: CO2 + NH4+ • It is considered one of the most effective cyanide destruction processes Combinox Process • • • • Applied in Las Crucitas Project, in Costa Rica 7500 tonnes/day of saprolite In the future 5000 tonnes/d hard rock (1.5-2 g/t) All material is leached with 150-200 mg/L CN: CIP Compound (mg/L) • First applied in 1984 at Homestake Lead Mine, South Dakota to treat 800 t/h of mixed mine water and tailings. • Sensitive to temperature (optimum: 30 °C, pH 7 – 8.5). • Process requires gradual acclimatization of mutant strains of bacteria (Pseudomonas) to the high concentration of cyanides and thiocyanate. • Oxidation rate of cyanide to cyanate is increased by the bacteria. 0.58 0.03 Free CN <2 <0.02 0.31 <0.01 WAD CN (moderately complexed) Cyanide Recovery • Acidification - Volatilization - Reneutralization – AVR Processes was used successfully at Flin Flon (Canada) from 1930 to 1975 and in several other commercial operations. • The process consists of acidification of the alkaline cyanide leach solution producing hydrogen cyanide (HCN) which is removed by volatilization in a stream of air to be reabsorbed into an alkaline solution. • The Cyanisorb is an AVR process that uses high efficiency packed towers, low pressures and moderate pH levels. It recovers about 90% of the cyanide from tailings: Gold mine in Waihi (New Zealand), AngloGold in Argentina, DeLamar (U.S.), Marlin Mine (Guatemala) are using Cyanisorb method CN- + H+ = HCN Acidification: Absorption: 2HCN + NaOH = NaCN + 2H2O Cyanide Recovery • Golconda (Australia) has reduced the total cyanide concentration in effluents from >200 mg/L to < 5 mg/L. Reagent consumption is 0.6 kg H2SO4/t solution and 0.45 kg NaOH/t. Cyanide recovery 50 to 85%. Solution after 10 days Total CN Biological Treatment • Cyanide is degraded by aerobic and anaerobic microbes Solution after Combinox Cyanisorb Process Barren solution 300 ppm HCN HCN ladden air H2SO4 bleed air 10% air pH 5 - 7.5 Ca(OH)2 • AVR technology has been developed to allow treatment of slurry streams directly without the need for solid-liquid separation. stripped slurry NaCN (recovered) solution Pulp to tailing pond Metals precipitation 33 Cyanide Recovery: Ion Exchange • Developed in the mid-1950s for the recovery of cyanide from electroplating solutions. • Resin impregnated with copper (to tie up all free cyanide as complex) precipitates cuprous cyanide in the resin matrix. • Strong-base anion exchange resins remove cyanide complexes of iron, zinc, copper, nickel, cobalt, gold and silver can be removed effectively followed by elution of the resin. • Practical problems: Efficient elution of all species that load onto the resin is hard to achieve Resin must be regenerated or new resin must be used to maintain process efficiency High costs involved You and me, we used to mine together Cyanide together, always I really felt, a bitter almond smell When the pH fell, and I ran You don’t know, where the pH goes 10.5 is good to leach the gold Don't leach if you don’t have control pH cannot be low Be careful ‘cause it hurts Don't leach if you forgot the lime the smell can be sublime, but Be careful ‘cause it hurts Cyanide Recovery: Activated Charcoal • Activated Charcoal has been used for recovery of metals from cyanide solutions. • Activated charcoal is capable of adsorbing up to 5 mg CN-/g from aerated alkaline cyanide solutions. This can reach 25 mg CN/g in the presence of a catalyst such as copper. • Cyanide can be recovered (elution) from the AC into low ionic strength solution at elevated temperature. In long term, the cyanide effect, A lump in your neck, you will cry Thyroidism, this can appear And them it will be to late you’re gonna die Don't leach gold or even silver, Dumping cyanide in rivers Be careful ‘cause it hurts Don't leach if you think the fish won’t feel Cyanide in their gills, Be careful ‘cause it hurts You don’t agree, but with 5 ppb, fish can die You told me, you’ve never had destroyed The cyanide you have employed, you fool You’ve just trust, what the sun can do You’ve just left the tailings in a pool Don't leach what you’re doing is quite insane Cyanide still remains Be careful ‘cause it hurts Don't leach I don’t need your reasons Telling this is sunny season Be careful ‘cause it hurts THE END 34