Bering Straits Native Corporation ANCSA Region
Transcription
Bering Straits Native Corporation ANCSA Region
Bering Straits Native Corporation ANCSA Region Map prepared by the ANCSA Regional Association [http://ancsaregional.com] Report by: Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine. Cold Climate Housing Research Center. Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment Table of Contents Bering Straits Native Corporation Dashboard .............................................................................................................................................................. II Bering Straits Native Corporation Summary ........................................................................................................................................................... III-XI Community....................................................................................................................................................................................................... III Overcrowding................................................................................................................................................................................................... III Energy .............................................................................................................................................................................................................. IV Affordability ..................................................................................................................................................................................................... IX Community, Regional, and Statewide Housing Characteristics ....................................................................................................................... XI How to Interpret the Profile: Data Sources, Definitions & Clarifications................................................................................................................ A-H Bering Straits Native Corporation Profile .................................................................................................................................................................. 1-4 Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment I Bering Straits Native Corporation Dashboard1 Population: The Alaska Department of Labor and Workforce Development's current (2012) population estimate for the Bering Straits Native Corporation ANCSA region is 9,869, an increase of 7% from 2000. Housing Units: There are currently 3,975 housing units in the Bering Straits Native Corporation ANCSA region. Of these, 2,756 are occupied, 241 vacant units are for sale or rent, and the remaining 978 are seasonal or otherwise vacant units (Profile Figure R6). Energy: The average home in the Bering Straits Native Corporation ANCSA region is 1,136 square feet and uses 195,000 BTUs of energy per square foot annually. This is 42% more than the statewide average of 137,000 BTUs per square foot per year. Energy Costs: Using AKWarm estimates, average annual energy cost for homes in the Bering Straits Native Corporation ANCSA region is $7,900, which is approximately 2.8 times more than the cost in Anchorage, and 3.7 times more than the national average (Profile Figure R13). Energy Programs: Approximately 10% of the occupied housing units in the Bering Straits Native Corporation ANCSA region have completed either the Home Energy Rebate or Weatherization programs, or have received BEES certification since 2008, compared to 21% statewide (Profile Figure R12). Housing Quality: Within current housing stock, newer homes have better energy performance. On average, homes built before 1940 are currently rated at 1-star compared to a current average rating of 3-star-plus for homes built after 2000. Air-tightness: Within current housing stock, newer homes are tighter. On average, homes built in the last decade exceed the 2012 BEES standard of 4 air-changes per hour at 50 pascals (ACH50). In contrast, homes built before 1940 are 6.2 times leakier than those built since 2000 (Profile Figure R7). Ventilation: An estimated 887 occupied housing units (or 32%) in the Bering Straits Native Corporation ANCSA region are relatively air-tight and lack a continuous ventilation system. These houses are at higher risk of moisture and indoor air quality-related issues (Profile Figures R9-R10). Overcrowding: Twenty two percent of occupied units are estimated to be either overcrowded (11%) or severely overcrowded (11%). This is roughly 7 times the national average, and makes the Bering Straits Native Corporation region the third most overcrowded ANCSA region in the state. Affordability: According to American Community Survey (ACS) data, approximately 24% of households in the Bering Straits Native Corporation region spend 30% or more of total income on reported housing costs, including rent, water and sewer utilities, and energy costs. Using AKWarm estimates, the average annual energy costs constitute 15% of census median area income for occupied housing. 1 Figures referenced in the Dashboard are located in the ANCSA Region profile. Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment II Bering Straits Native Corporation Summary Community The Bering Straits ANCSA region is located on the western coast of Alaska, bordered by the NANA region on the north, and the Calista region in the south. Average home sizes in the region range from 593 square feet in Stebbins to 1,302 square feet in Nome. Overcrowding The Bering Straits ANCSA region is the third most overcrowded area in the state with 22% of occupied housing units with more than one person per room (Figure R-I). Approximately Figure R-I: Percent of Overcrowded Housing in Bering 6% of the housing in the region is vacant and available for sale or rent. Straits and Neighboring ANCSA Regions Gambell has the lowest percentage 100% of available housing, with no housing 90% units available for sale or rent, and 80% Wales has the highest percentage at 12%. Overcrowding in the region 70% varies by community. Nome has the 60% lowest percentage of overcrowded 50% households (8%) and Savoonga has 40% the highest percentage of households with more than one person per room 30% (61%). 20% 10% 0% Bering Straits Not overcrowded Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens NANA Overcrowded 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment Calista Severely overcrowded III Figure R-II: Average Annual Home Energy Costs vs Energy Consumption 270 $11,500 Annual Energy Costs ($) Regional average energy costs are the third most costly ANCSA region in the state, despite the relatively small regional average home size of 1,136 square feet. Figure R-II shows that annual energy costs vary by community3, from a low of $3,994 in Stebbins to a high of $8,457 in Nome. Nome also has an average annual energy use that is approximately double that of Stebbins, due at least partially to an average home size that is more than twice that found in Stebbins. $10,500 $9,500 $8,500 $7,901 220 $8,457 182 178 $7,500 170 $6,500 $5,500 $3,994 $4,500 $3,500 $2,500 70 BSNC 2 3 120 89 Nome Annual Energy Use (MMBTU / Year) Energy2 Stebbins Regional data appearing in this section is based on communities with sufficient levels of ACS data, meaning not all communities were included in the analysis. Only communities with sufficient data for reporting are included in Figure R-II. Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment IV Figure R-III: Average ECI vs. Average EUI 195 $9.00 $8.82 5 175 $8.28 $8.00 $7.16 180 160 150 $7.00 140 $6.00 120 $5.00 100 $4.00 80 $3.00 60 $2.00 40 $1.00 One contributing factor to the high average ECI is the high average home $0.00 heating index of 10.6 BTUs/ft2/HDD, BSNC which is the second highest in the state. Again, there is some variation at the community level, from a low of 7.6 in Nome to a high of 9.4 in Stebbins 4 200 20 EUI (thousands of Btus / square foot / year) $10.00 ECI ($ / square foot / year) The BSNC region has the highest energy use per square foot4 of any of the ANCSA regions using an estimated 195 kBTUs/ft2/yr. The BSNC region also has the second highest energy cost per square foot5 of the ANCSA regions at $8.82/ft2, nearly 9 times the national average. The energy use and cost per square foot for communities in the BSNC region are shown in Figure R-III. Among communities with sufficient AKWarm data for reporting, Nome has both the lowest EUI and ECI in the region at 150 kBTU/ft2 and $7.16/ft2 respectively. Stebbins has both the highest EUI and ECI at 175 kBTU/ft2 and $8.28/ft2respectively. 0 Nome Stebbins Energy use per square foot is also known as Energy Use Intensity, or EUI and is given in kBTUs per square foot, per year. Energy cost per square foot is also known as the Energy Cost Index, or ECI and is given in dollars per square foot, per year. Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment V Understanding the variations between communities participating Figure R-IV: Percent of Occupied Housing Completing in energy efficiency programs is an Energy Program essential to targeting work and 100% resource allocation in the region. Figure R-IV shows the region’s 90% participation in the three AHFC 80% energy programs. Approximately 10% of housing units in the Bering 70% Straits region have participated in 60% the Weatherization or Home Energy Rebate program, or have received 50% BEES certification since 2008. The 40% Bering Straits region has the second lowest participation of all the 30% regions with approximately 6% of 20% housing units in the region completing the Home Energy 10% Rebate or Weatherization programs, with an additional 3% certified to 0% meet BEES. Participation varies BSNC Nome Savoonga Stebbins widely by community, from an % BEES % HERP estimated zero housing units in % Weatherization (post-2008) % No programs completed Gambell participating to a high of 86% of housing units in Stebbins completing one of the programs. The highest participation in the BEES program occurred in Savoonga where 8% of homes have been certified to meet BEES. Regionally, only 1% of housing units have participated in the Home Energy Rebate Program. The Weatherization program has varying levels of participation by community, from an estimated 0% participation in Savoonga to a high of 86% in Stebbins completing a weatherization retrofit. Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment VI The majority of housing units in the Bering Straits region use fuel oil for space heating (Figure R-V). This is especially the case in Nome, the region’s largest community, where 95% of space heating needs are met with fuel oil. In other communities in the region wood fuel is used more to supplement fuel oil as evidenced by a 23% usage of wood fuel for space heating region-wide. The lack of wood heat in Nome is likely caused by limited availability of wood in the community. Other communities have trees available to use for space heating needs. Figure R-V: Percent Space Heating Energy Used by Fuel Type in Bering Straits 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% Electric 50% Wood 40% Fuel Oil 30% Nat Gas 20% 10% 0% Bering Straits Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment Nome VII An estimated 18% of homes in the region have a continuous mechanical ventilation or heat recovery ventilation system, which is just slightly lower than the percentage in Nome (19%), the region's largest community. Figure R-VI shows both the regional ventilation characteristics and those of Nome. The Bering Straits region has the second lowest percentage of homes that are relatively air-tight but lack continuous mechanical ventilation. This suggests there are fewer homes at risk of moisture and indoor air quality-related issues, but likely comes at a high energy penalty since the Bering Straits region has, on average, the second leakiest homes in the state. Figure R-VI: Ventilation Types by Census Area 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Bering Straits % Heat Recovery Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens Nome % Continuous 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment % Non-Continuous VIII Affordability Approximately 24% of households in the Bering Straits Native Corporation region are considered cost-burdened, spending 30% or more of total household income on housing costs.6 This is similar to the affordability found in the neighboring ANCSA regions of NANA and Calista (Figure RVI), which have an estimated 24% and 19% of cost-burdened housing units, respectively. Affordability varies by community in the region, ranging from a low of 8% of cost-burdened housing in Unalakleet to a high of 46% in Brevig Mission. The percent of costburdened households in the six most populous communities range from a low of 8% in Unalakleet to a high of 44% in Savoonga. Figure R-VI: Percent Cost-Burdened Housing in Bering Straits and Neighboring ANCSA Regions 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Bering Straits NANA % with costs <20% % with costs 20.0 -24.9% % with costs 30.0 - 34.9% % with costs 35% or more Calista % with costs 25.0 - 29.9% 6 CCHRC’s analysis of ACS energy costs indicate that there are systematic underestimations for rural Alaska, which suggests that ACS-based cost burdened housing estimates are low. See Appendix A, "Analysis of American Community Survey Energy Cost Estimates" for more details. Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment IX Figure R-VIII shows the median household incomes for the region and the six most populous communities along with housing and energy costs.6 The lowest median household income in the region is $23,929 in Koyuk, and the highest median income is $69,522, found in Nome. Considering only the six most populous communities, median household incomes range between $26,000 in Gambell and $69,522 in Nome. Figure R-VIII: Annual ACS Median Income and Housing Costs vs. AKWarm Energy Costs by Community $120,000 $100,000 ACS Median Income ACS Annual Housing Costs AkWarm Annual Energy Costs $80,000 $60,000 $40,000 $20,000 $0 Bering Straits Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens Nome Unalakleet Gambell Savoonga Shishmaref Stebbins 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment X Community, Regional, and Statewide Housing Characteristics This ANCSA region summary only includes the highlights of housing characteristics at the ANCSA regional level. A detailed data profile with charts and tables for this region follows. The 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment provides a significant amount of data and analysis at statewide, ANCSA region, census area, and community levels. This assessment provides a statewide analysis of housing characteristics, how they compare to national numbers, and the estimated housing needs. Within the 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment, written summaries are available for each individual ANCSA region and census area, and data profiles are available for each community and census area characterizing the housing stock from the perspective of community, overcrowding, energy and affordability. These different tiers of information and analysis allow researchers, housing authorities, policymakers and others to generate answers to specific questions. For a detailed discussion of estimating housing need and comparison of methods to previous Housing Assessments, see Appendix B, "Statewide Need Assessment” of the 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment. Bering Straits Native Corporation Wiltse, N., D. Madden, B. Valentine, V. Stevens 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment XI ACS ARIS CEN MIX How To Interpret the Profile 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment A ACS ARIS ARIS How To Interpret the Profile CEN 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment B How To Interpret the Profile 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment C How To Interpret the Profile 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment D How To Interpret the Profile 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment E How To Interpret the Profile 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment F How To Interpret the Profile 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment G How To Interpret the Profile 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment H ANCSA Region Profile for: Bering Straits Native Corporation Climate Zone (Heating Degree Day Range) Zone 8 (12,600 - 16,800 HDD) COMMUNITY - Bering Straits Native Corporation Constructed Units Figure R1: Existing Housing by Decade Built 1,200 1,000 800 600 400 200 0 1,013 1,073 CEN 10,000 9,492 9,500 751 9,196 9,000 387 265 8,288 8,500 217 196 8,000 73 7,500 Pre- 1940s 1940s 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s Existing housing units by decade built Figure R3: Trends in Housing Unit Size 1990s 3,000 1,200 2,500 1,000 2,000 1,500 1,000 500 1970s Houses Lacking Complete Plumbing or Kitchen Facilities Lack complete plumbing Lack complete kitchen Anchorage municipality 1980s Households Number Percent 565 21% 482 18% Estimated Total Annual Community Space Heating Fuel Use Fuel Oil 2,218,556 (gallons) Natural Gas (ccf) Electricity 1,216,663 (kWh) Wood 4,798 (cords) Propane (gallons) Coal (tons) Bering Straits Native Corp 1990s Figure R4: Housing Completing an AHFC Energy Program after 2007 ARIS 400 200 0 Pre1940s BEES Certified Avg Annual Energy Cost with PCE Avg Annual Energy Cost without PCE Housing Need Indicators Overcrowded Housing cost burdened 1 Star Homes 2010 600 National 2000s 2000 800 Bering Straits Native Corporation 1990 2000- 2011 MIX # housing units Square footage Figure R2: Population ACS 1940s 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s Existing housing by decade built Rebate & Wx Completions $7,901 $9,149 Number % Occupied Housing of units 616 22% 572 21% 686 25% 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment Rated but Unmodified 1990s 20002011 Untouched housing Weatherization Retrofits (funding increased 2008) Date Range Units 2008-2011 165 2003-2007 85 1990-2002 535 Housing Stock Estimates All Housing All Occupied Housing All Vacant housing Vacant Housing for Sale or Rent Number of Units 3,975 2,756 1,219 241 1 of 4 OVERCROWDING & VENTILATION - Bering Straits Native Corporation Figure R5: Overcrowded Units Figure R6: Housing Occupancy ACS Overcrowded: 308 Other Vacant: 695 Vacant, recreational: 284 Severely overcrowded: 308 MIX Renteroccupied: 1,297 Vacant, for rent: 211 Occupied, Not overcrowded: 2,140 Figure R7: Average Air-Tightness of Current Homes by Decade Built 15.0 10.0 5.0 0.0 Pre1940s 1940s 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s 1990s 20002004 Pre1940s 2005 or later 1950s % Heat Recovery ARIS ARIS 700 1950s Bering Straits Native Corp 1990s 20002004 2005 or later % Non-Continuous ARIS ARIS Insufficient Data 500 400 300 1960s 1970s 1980s 1990s Existing housing by decade built % Low Risk 1980s # Units at High Risk 100 1940s 1970s Figure R10: Quantity of Housing Stock at High Risk of Moisture and Air Quality Problems 200 Pre1940s 1960s % Continuous 600 Insufficient Data 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 1940s Existing housing by decade built Existing housing by decade built Air-tightness (ACH50) 2012 BEES Requirement Figure R9: Percent of Housing Stock at High Risk of Moisture and Air Quality Problems ARIS 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Note: Higher numbers indicate leakier homes 20.0 Figure R8: Existing Ventilation Type by Decade Built ARIS Insufficient Data ACH @ 50 pascals 25.0 Owneroccupied: 1,459 Vacant, for sale: 30 % High Risk 20002004 2005 or later 0 Pre1940s 1940s 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s 1990s Existing housing by decade built 20002011 2 of 4 OVERALL Pre- 1940 1940- 49 1950- 59 1960- 69 1970- 79 1980- 89 1990- 99 2000- 2004 2005 or later EUI (kBTUs / SF / YR) 350 # of AkWarm Records 351 27 15 5 44 77 61 51 57 15 Figure R11: Current Average Energy Use Intensity and Average Square Footage by Decade Built 1,800 1,600 1,400 1,200 1,000 800 600 400 200 0 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Pre1940s 1940s EUI 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s 1990s Avg. EUI (kBTUS /SF) 195 302 225 132 243 228 133 163 100 170 Avg. ECI $8.82 $13.37 $10.89 $6.49 $13.15 $9.41 $6.38 $6.24 $4.95 $4.70 Avg. Home Heating Index 10.6 18.0 12.1 6.9 13.0 13.0 6.5 8.9 3.9 10.2 Figure R12: Percent of Total Residential Space Heating Energy by Fuel Type ARIS ARIS Wood 23% Square Footage Current Residential Units by Year Built ENERGY - Bering Straits Native Corporation Current Bering Straits Native Corporation Housing Energy Characteristics By Decade Built Avg Annual Energy / End Use (million Btus) Avg Energy Avg. Annual Avg. Annual Avg Energy Rating Avg Sq. Rating Energy Cost (with Energy Use Points Feet Space Heating DHW Appliances Stars PCE) (million BTUs) 58.3 $7,901 182 130 24 26 2-star 1,136 32.1 $11,792 259 215 1-star 1,006 22 23 43.6 $8,533 182 133 1-star plus 849 23 25 60.9 NR 200 151 22 27 2-star plus 1,523 32.9 $6,725 133 100 1-star 715 12 21 54.3 $7,112 171 127 2-star 897 19 25 69.9 $8,000 168 114 3-star 1,284 31 24 65.0 $7,165 180 128 2-star plus 1,237 21 25 86.2 $7,129 144 74 4-star plus 1,435 41 29 64.5 $11,723 449 330 56 62 2-star plus 2,325 Electricity 1% Fuel Oil 76% 20002011 Existing housing by decade built Square Footage Current Bering Straits Native Corporation Housing Envelope Characteristics By Decade Built Current Residential Units by Year Built OVERALL Pre- 1940 1940- 49 1950- 59 1960- 69 1970- 79 1980- 89 1990- 99 2000- 2004 2005 or later # of AkWarm Records 351 27 15 5 44 77 61 51 57 15 BEES 2009 - Climate Zone 8 BEES 2012 - Climate Zone 8 Bering Straits Native Corp Above Grade Wall Below Grade Wall Above Grade Floor R R R ACH 50 Ceiling R 10.2 19.7 14.4 NR 12.2 10.7 7.5 8.4 3.4 2.2 16 9 10 NR 9 16 28 35 38 42 14 7 14 NR 12 14 18 19 23 6 7 NR NR NR NR NR NR NR NR NR 7.0 4.0 38 48 30 30 15 15 On Grade Floor R Below Grade Floor R Door U Garage Door U Window U 20 14 23 NR 12 17 30 34 37 37 3 NR NR NR NR NR NR NR NR NR 3 NR NR NR NR NR NR NR NR NR 0.51 0.49 0.60 NR 0.72 0.55 0.39 0.55 0.25 0.34 0.51 0.49 0.60 NR 0.72 0.55 0.39 0.55 0.25 0.34 0.61 0.62 0.68 NR 0.81 0.66 0.51 0.54 0.36 0.69 38 38 15 15 15 15 0.22 0.22 0.22 0.22 0.22 0.22 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment 3 of 4 AFFORDABILITY - Bering Straits Native Corporation Figure R13: Average Annual Home Energy Cost and Use $8,000 MIX 300 $7,901 258 250 Energy Costs ($) $7,000 182 $6,000 200 $5,000 150 $4,000 $2,786 $3,000 91 $2,129 $2,000 100 50 $1,000 $- Energy Concumption (Millions of BTUs) $9,000 Housing Information All-occupied Owner-occupied Renter-occupied Avg Household Size (# of people) 3.3 3.7 2.9 0 Bering Straits Native Corporation Anchorage municipality Median value of owner-occupied house with mortgage $171,800 Median value of owner-occupied house without a mortgage $93,700 National Median Household Income Housing Units Annual Household Income $ 52,435 All-occupied $ 50,244 Renter-occupied $ 58,274 Owner-occupied $ 91,855 w/ mortgage $ 41,780 w/o mortgage Median Housing Costs Monthly All-occupied $ 855 Gross rent $ 1,003 Owner-occupied $ 736 Housing units w/ mortgage $ 1,281 Housing units w/out a mortgage $ 472 Avg % of Median Income Spent on Energy Annual 10,260 12,036 8,832 15,372 5,664 15.1% Figure R15: Number of Cost-Burdened Housing Units ACS Figure R14: Affordability - Housing Costs as a Percent of Income $ $ $ $ $ ACS 700 100% 600 80% 60% 40% % with costs <20% 500 % with costs 20.0 -24.9% 400 % with costs 25.0 - 29.9% 300 % with costs 30.0 - 34.9% 20% % with costs 35% or more 0% Overall With Mortgage Bering Straits Native Corp W/o Mortgage Rental # with costs 30.0 - 34.9% # with costs 35% or more 200 100 0 Overall With Mortgage W/o Mortgage 2014 Alaska Housing Assessment Rental 4 of 4