docCase 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247
download 
Report Transcription
Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247
Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 1 of 39 This list was compiled from data provided by the California Secretary of State’s Office and contains donations to major “Yes on Proposition 8” groups that derive from corporate bank accounts. This list does not include CEO’s or senior executives of organizations that may have contributed, but did not do so from an identifiable corporate account. Due to some complexities in how the donations were tracked, there may be more companies that are not on the list. Also, the amounts should be considered approximate. NAME OF CONTRIBUTOR CITY STATE AMOUNT 100 W FOOTHILL BLVD., LLC TUSTIN CA $100.00 2205 FIFTH, LLC LAS VEGAS NV $1,000.00 ABOVE THE GATE DENTISTRY, JEFFREY L. DAVIDSON, DDS., INC. DIAMOND SPRINGS CA $5,000.00 ACCORD DESIGN GROUP, INC SANTA MARIA CA $100.00 ACCURA BULLETS, LLC NAMPA ID $1,000.00 ACE MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, INC. ST. GEORGE UT $10,000.00 ADAMO CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT CO. LAKESIDE CA $35,250.00 ADMIRALTY DIESEL SERVICES, INC. HERCULES CA $3,000.00 ADVANCED PROPERTIES, INC. FOLSOM CA $500.00 ADVANTAGE PHYSICAL THERAPY & REHAB., INC. COTO DE CAZA CA $1,000.00 ADVENTURE ENTERPRISES LLC HEMET CA $500.00 ALADDIN SUPPLY CO. CATHEDRAL CTY CA $750.00 ALL SEASONS HAY CO. CHERRY VALLEY CA $500.00 ALOSTA ANIMAL HOSPITAL, INC. GLENDORA CA $1,000.00 ALPHA SERVICES GROUP CARLSBAD CA $300.00 ALTA HOME CARE INC. RIVERSIDE CA $2,500.00 AMADA HOME CARE, INC. COSTA MESA CA $200.00 AMAYA CONSTRUCTION, INC. TEMECULA CA $1,000.00 AMERICAN MONEY GROUP INC COVINA CA $500.00 ANDERSEN NUT CO. NEWMAN CA $1,500.00 ANDERSON DESIGN ASSOCIATES ANAHEIM CA $1,000.00 APPLE GILROY, INC. SAN JOSE CA $100.00 APS ENVIRONMENTAL, INC. NORTH HIGHLANDS CA $1,000.00 ARMOUR PROPERTIES CV, LLC NEWPORT BEACH CA $75,000.00 ATHLETES BY DESIGN, INC. NEWPORT BEACH CA $100.00 ATLANTIC AIR TOOL CO., INC. TAFT TN $100.00 AZEVEDO DAIRY, INC. PATTERSON CA $100.00 B & G DELIVERY SYSTEMS, INC. SACRAMENTO CA $100.00 B. THOMAS WHEELER, DDS INC. HESPERIA CA $2,000.00 BARSTOW TRUCK PARTS & EQUIPMENT COMPANY, INC. BARSTOW CA $2,500.00 BAY CITIES PRODUCE CO., INC. SAN LEANDRO CA $1,500.00 BE READY, INC. OCEANSIDE CA $1,000.00 BELL & ASSOCIATES, INCORPORATED LAGUNA BEACH CA $6,000.00 BENCHMARK SERVICES, INC. CYPRESS CA $1,000.00 BERGESON & ASSOCIATES, INC. BLUE JAY CA $1,000.00 BILL NELSON MEDIA GROUP BAKERSFIELD CA $100.00 BLAINE LARSEN FARMS, INC. HAMER ID $5,000.00 BLUE RIVER ADVISORS, INC. IRVINE CA $3,000.00 BOONE TRUCKING, INC. ONTARIO CA $250.00 Exhibit 4 Page 98 Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document VACAVILLE 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 2 of 39$1,000.00 CA BRUCE BOSLER, DDS. INC. BULLS EYE PEST CONTROL INC. MURRIETA CA $500.00 C & K BILLS ENTERPRISES INC. ROCKLIN CA $100.00 CAL FRUIT INTERNATIONAL, INC. YUBA CITY CA $31,500.00 CARL TRUBSCHENCK DDS, INC. CITRUS HEIGHTS CA $1,000.00 CATHAY CIRCUITS, INC. MONTEREY CA $5,000.00 CHAD CHURCH, DDS, INC. ROCKLIN CA $2,500.00 CHILDERS INSURANCEAGENCY, INC. EUREKA CA $1,000.00 CHIPPONERI ELECTRIC, INC. HILMAR CA $100.00 CLASSIC FLOOR CARE, INC. GLENDORA CA $250.00 CLEARWORD COMMUNICATIONS GROUP, INC. BRISTOW VA $4,302.00 COLONIAL MEDICAL GROUP, INC BAKERSFIELD CA $500.00 CONTAINER SUPPLY CO., INC. GARDEN GROVE CA $278,070.00 COOL SPRING ELECTRIC COOLER CO. SAN MARCOS CA $100.00 COOLEY FAMILY INVESTMENT LLC HIGLEY AZ $10,000.00 CORE FRAMING, INC. FOLSOM CA $500.00 CRITICAL SOLUTINOS, INC. WALNUT CREEK CA $1,000.00 CS CONCRETE SOLUTIONS, INC. MISSION VIEJO CA $10,000.00 CTP CONSTRUCTION CO., INC. ANAHEIM CA $2,500.00 CULBERTSON INSURANCE SERVICES, INC. ANAHEIM CA $2,500.00 D & M MOTORS, INC. PALO ALTO CA $100.00 D.L. HEATON, LLC HONOKAA HI $200.00 D.P. DEVELOPMENT CO., INC. LANCASTER CA $120.00 DALTON CAPITAL, INC. YORBA LINDA CA $5,000.00 DANIEL PROPERTIES, LLC ELK GROVE CA $1,000.00 DARREN SHAFFER-FARRIER, INC. ESCONDIDO CA $1,000.00 DAVE BANG ASSOCIATES INC TUSTIN CA $3,500.00 DAVID A. WARNER D.D.S., INC. WHITTIER CA $1,000.00 DAVID R. RUSSELL, D.D.S. INC. LAKESIDE CA $500.00 DCIPHER GROUP, LLC LAS VEGAS NV $2,000.00 DEAN K STEWARD, D.D.S. INC. LA HABRA CA $1,500.00 DEAN K. STEWART, DDS INC. LA HABRA CA $1,500.00 DEMAND SIDE ENVIRONMENTAL, LLC HAYWARD CA $2,450.00 DIABLO INVESTMENT CO. DANVILLE CA $1,000.00 DIAMOND BOUTIQUE LLC DEL MAR CA $250.00 DIANE ALLPHIN SPRINGFIELD MI $2,500.00 DIRECT RECOVERY ASSOCIATES, INC. WESTLAKE VILLAGE CA $250.00 DIVISION ST HOLDINGS LLC STEVENSON RANCH CA $250.00 DIX MACHINE SHOP, INC. VISALIA CA $1,000.00 DJM, INC. EL CAJON CA $100.00 DON MCBRIDE CO. BREA CA $1,000.00 DOOLAN CREATIVE GROUP WESTLAKE VILLAGE CA $500.00 DOUGLAS YOUNBERG INVESTMENTS INC. WASHINGTON UT $5,000.00 DSS ENTERTAINMENT, LLC MURRIETA CA $100.00 DUANE L. CHAPMAN CONSTRUCTION CO. SAN CLEMENTE CA $120.00 E. G. GRAPHICS, INC. ANTELOPE CA $1,000.00 E.T.S. & ASSOCIATES, INC. GILROY CA $5,000.00 EAGLE SYSTEMS INTERNATIONAL, INC. HAYWARD CA $2,450.00 EAGLES QUALITY CONSTRUCTION, INC. SONORA CA $250.00 EDGEWORTH & ASSOCIATES APPLE VALLEY CA $1,000.00 EDWARD D. HOKE COMPANY, INC. FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA $4,000.00 ELK 5 ENTERPRISES, INC. MURRIETA CA $1,000.00 ENERGY EFFICIENCY MGMT LLC DRAPER UT $2,450.00 Exhibit 4 Page 99 Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document NEWCASTLE 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 3 of 39$5,000.00 CA ENG. MECH. CONTRACTOR, INC. ENGINEER MECHANICAL CONTRACTOR, INC. SACRAMENTO CA $5,000.00 EQUITY GROUP MANAGEMENT RENO NV $1,000.00 EXALEN CONSULTING, LLC CARLSBAD CA $200.00 EYE-TO-EYE COMMUNICATIONS, INC. SAN DIEGO CA $100.00 FACILITATION ENTERPRISES, LLC ELVERTA CA $400.00 FARGUSON INVESTMENTS, LLC LA JOLLA CA $10,000.00 FARRIS ENTERPRISES, INC. NORCO CA $3,000.00 FIELDSTEAD AND CO. IRVINE CA $1,195,000.00 FINYL VINYL INC. HUNTINGTON BEACH CA $1,000.00 FIRST GLOBAL MARKETING, LLC PROVO UT $10,000.00 FLORES COMMUNICATIONS, INC. BURBANK CA $200.00 FORWARD REAL ESTATE GROUP, INC. BAKERSFIELD CA $200.00 FOX TRAILER SALES, INC. SACRAMENTO CA $250.00 FUNDET FOUNDATION, INC. DRAPER UT $9,950.00 GARI SOMMER WALLCOVERING ELK GROVE CA $3,000.00 GARVIN AND ASSOCIATES INC FOUNTAIN VALLEY CA $2,000.00 GARY H. PULSIPHER, DDS, INC. SAN DIEGO CA $1,000.00 GATES CONSTRUCTION, INC. IRVINE CA $100.00 GREGG A. TOOLSON DDS, MS, INC. ENCINITAS CA $2,500.00 GRIFFITHS & ASSOCIATES VISTA CA $250.00 GUY R. NASH, DDS INC. TEMECULA CA $300.00 GUY R. NASH, DDS, INC. TEMECULA CA $300.00 HALVERSON & CO., INC. ENCINITAS CA $1,000.00 HALVERSON & COMPANY, INC. CPA’S ENCINTAS CA $1,200.00 HANDS ON BILLING, LLC HUNTINGTON BEACH CA $10,000.00 HARBER COMPANIES, INC. SAN BERNARDINO CA $1,000.00 HARMONY CIRCLE LLC ANAHEIM CA $5,000.00 HARTFORD HOLDINGS, LLC PROVO UT $300,000.00 HEATHCOTE & ASSOCIATES THOUSAND OAKS CA $250.00 HEATHCOTE PROPERTIES, INC. NORTH TUSTIN CA $1,000.00 HILTON AND ASSOCIATES HONOLULU HI $100.00 HUESSER NEWEIGHT LLC CONCORD CA $1,000.00 ION SATELLITE INC. MISSION VIEJO CA $1,500.00 IZOR AND ASSOCIATES, INC. ESCONDIDO CA $150.00 J&L CONSULTING, INC. YORBA LINDA CA $9,500.00 JACKSON BUILDING GROUP SACRAMENTO CA $150.00 JAMES H. AVERY CO. SAN LUIS OBISPO CA $1,000.00 JAMES OLSON INSURANCE AGENCY, INC. HOLLYWOOD CA $1,000.00 JC-EVANS, INC. GOLD RIVER CA $1,000.00 JEFFREY D. POTTER, DDS INC. YORBA LINDA CA $2,500.00 JERNER CONSTRUCTION, INC. TURLOCK CA $1,000.00 JEROME B. CRIPPEN & ASSOCIATES MARYSVILLE CA $200.00 JK MANAGEMENT, INC. LAS VEGAS NV $2,000.00 JOHN C. PLATTS, D.D.S., INC. HEMET CA $1,000.00 JOHN CHANDLER, ALLSTATE INS. CO. GOLD RIVER CA $6,000.00 JOHN K GUNDERSON D.D.S., INC. TEMECULA CA $500.00 JOHN MANRY AND ASSOCIATES INC LANCASTER CA $1,000.00 JOHN MEADOWS INC. SIMI VALLEY CA $1,000.00 JOUNEY CREATIONS LLC LOS ANGELES CA $1,000.00 JUMPSTART ENTERPRISES LLC BREA CA $1,000.00 KALANI CONSTRUCTION INC. KAUAI HI $1,000.00 KAZUO ENTERPRISES, INC. CYPRESS CA $5,000.00 Exhibit 4 Page 100 Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document AVILA 247-2 Page 4 of 39$100.00 BEACHFiled 08/25/11 CA KEN WARD & ASSOCIATES KENNETH RICKS & ASSOCIATES BAKERSFIELD CA $500.00 KEVIN D. CHALK DMD, INC. VISTA CA $100.00 KEVIN NEUBERT & ASSOCIATES INC. LAKE ARROWHEAD CA $1,000.00 KINGMEN, INC. CARMEL CA $200.00 KJELSTROM & ASSOCIATES, INC. GLENDORA CA $1,099.00 KRISHAN WORKINGER CPA’S INC. LAKE FOREST CA $500.00 KYLE & KYLE RANCHES, INC. LANCASTER CA $300.00 LAKESIDE STORAGE, LLC PROVO UT $1,000.00 LANG CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC. WESTLAKE VILLAGE CA $1,000.00 LANG ROOFING CO., INC. BELL GARDENS CA $10,000.00 LARGE FORMAT COMPUTING, INC. SAN FRANCISCO CA $1,500.00 LARRY H. GASSIN & ASSOCIATES TUSTIN CA $100.00 LARRY JOHNSON CONSTRUCTION, INC. UPLAND CA $2,500.00 LEADING EDGE DUPLICATION, INC. MOORPARK CA $1,700.00 LEONCE M. ARCENEAUX, D.D.S., INC. HEMET CA $1,000.00 LEPISCOPO & MORROW, LLP SAN DIEGO CA $300.00 LILCO INC. ORANGE CA $5,000.00 LILCO, INC. ORANGE CA $5,000.00 LOS JARDINES, LLC YORBA LINDA CA $9,500.00 LUBRICANT, INC. ALBURQUERQUE NM $5,000.00 M & D DEVELOPMENT, LLC CORONA CA $7,000.00 M. T. WALKER CO. STANTON CA $1,000.00 M.K.P. CONSTRUCTION, INC. UPLAND CA $5,200.00 M.T. WALKER CO. STANTON CA $100.00 MAGNON ENGINEERING, INC. RANCHO CUCAMONGA CA $2,000.00 MANCHESTER FINANCIAL GROUP SAN DIEGO CA $125,000.00 MARINA LANDSCAPE, INC. ANAHEIM CA $15,000.00 MARK WARD GOINGS, INC. RCHO STA MARG CA $250.00 MARLER DENTAL GROUP ESCONDIDO CA $2,000.00 MASSEY ADVANTAGE, INC. FAIR OAKS CA $1,000.00 MCKENNA BOILER WORKS, INC. LOS ANGELES CA $1,000.00 MEDEX PRACTICE SOLUTIONS, INC. OAKDALE CA $500.00 MEDICAL TRANSCRIPTION & ASSOCIATES REDONDO BEACH CA $100.00 MELLENNIA SOLUTIONS GROUP, INC. OCEANSIDE CA $500.00 MERU CONSTRUCTION, INC. NEWBURY PARK CA $2,000.00 MILES CHEMICAL COMPANY, INC. ARIETA CA $5,000.00 MILES CHEMICAL COMPANY, INC. ARLETA CA $2,500.00 MJD PARTNERS, INC. ESCONDIDO CA $500.00 MORIARITY AND ASSOCIATES WOODLAND HILLS CA $225.00 NELSON DENTAL GROUP FULLERTON CA $500.00 ORTON’S EQUIPMENT COMPANY, INC. STRATFORD CA $100.00 OSTERBAUER COMPRESSOR SERVICE, INC. LOS ANGELES CA $1,000.00 P M TRUCK REPAIR, INC. W. SACRAMENTO CA $1,000.00 P.J. CARROLL COMPANY, INC. YORBA LINDA CA $2,000.00 PACIFIC RETAIL RESOURCES, INC. PLACENTIA CA $1,000.00 PACO PLASTICS & ENGINEERING, INC. SANTA FE SPRINGS CA $1,200.00 PAPER BOYS, INC. BREA CA $1,000.00 PAT BOONE FOUNDATION, INC. LOS ANGELES CA $300.00 PATRELL ENGINEERING GROUP, INC. GLENDORA CA $1,000.00 PATRICK SANDHILL LLC LAS VEGAS NV $3,000.00 PAUL B HANSEN, DDSINC. MERCED CA $1,000.00 PAUL B. HANSEN, DDS INC. MERCED CA $1,000.00 Exhibit 4 Page 101 Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document ROSEVILLE 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 5 of 39$1,000.00 CA PENNEY & ASSOCIATES PETRICH FINANCIAL SERVICES INC. SANGER CA $1,000.00 PHILLIPPI ENGINEERING, INC. VACAVILLE CA $2,500.00 PHYSICAL THERAPY ASSOCIATES RED BLUFF CA $200.00 PINNACLE CONSULTING LLC ORANGEVALE CA $1,000.00 PLATINUM ROOFING, INC. SAN JOSE CA $250.00 POLY SALES INC. FLAGSTAFF AZ $1,000.00 PREHM & ASSOCIATES SACRAMENTO CA $300.00 PRICE FUNERAL CHAPEL, INC. CITRUS HEIGHTS CA $1,000.00 PRISM ENGINEERING GROUP, LLC FRESNO CA $500.00 PROSOL, INC. RIVERSIDE CA $9,900.00 PROVOST REAL ESTATE LLC SAUGUS CA $250.00 R. BROOKE LANDSCAPING, INC. ANTIOCH CA $9,500.00 R.P. WESTBROOK ENTERPRISES, INC. HACIENDA HEIGHTS CA $100.00 RACHEL THURSTON PHOTOGRAPHY, INC. SANDY UT $100.00 RANCHO DEL RIO ENTERPRISES LLC RANCHO SANTA FE CA $300.00 REBEL INDUSTRIES, INC. UPLAND CA $3,750.00 REDLANDS GLENNMARK LLC SKYFOREST CA $200.00 REDOX CHEMICALS, LLC BURLEY ID $250.00 REYBRO, INC. VISTA CA $10,000.00 RICARDO RANGEL ANDASSOCIATES SOUTH GATE CA $100.00 RJ SALES CO. CORONA CA $100.00 RLG ENTERPRISES, INC. HUNTINGTON BEACH CA $5,000.00 ROAD WORKS, INC. POMONA CA $5,000.00 ROBERTS RETIREMENT GROUP INC JACKSON CA $1,000.00 ROCKY MOUNTAIN DISTRIBUTORS LLC CORONA CA $2,000.00 ROCKY MOUNTAIN SUPPLY, INC. IDAHO FALLS ID $1,000.00 RODDEL MARKETING GROUP, INC. TUSTIN CA $250.00 ROY E. WHITEHEAD, INC. RIVERSIDE CA $5,000.00 ROYAL SUMMIT, INC. OAKDALE CA $2,500.00 RUTHERFORD PRODUCTION COMPANY, INC. SANTA MONICA CA $20,000.00 RYAN, SAUNDERS & CO. FRESNO CA $1,000.00 SAN MIGUEL FARMS, INC. NIPOMO CA $2,500.00 SAN YSIDRO FARMS, INC. NIPOMO CA $5,000.00 SAN YSIDRO LAND CO. LLC NIPOMO CA $1,000.00 SANTA FE NURSERY, INC. NIPOMO CA $1,000.00 SANTIAGO ROOFING, INC. ANAHEIM CA $200.00 SCOTT D. GRAY, D.D.S. INC. HEMET CA $500.00 SCOTT L. HENRIKSEN, D.D.S., INC. VISALIA CA $2,000.00 SCS CONTRACTING, INC. SAN JUAN CAPISTRANO CA $190.00 SEAVIEW NURSERY, INC. CAMARILLO CA $2,500.00 SHERMAN ANDERSON DESIGN ASSOCIATES, INC. ANAHEIM CA $1,000.00 SHERWOOD CAPITAL, INC. AGOURA HILLS CA $20,000.00 SIGNATURE PAVING, INC. TEMECULA CA $1,000.00 SKYLINE ENERGY SAVERS, INC. EL DORADO HILLS CA $1,000.00 SMITH DENTAL, INC. SACRAMENTO CA $1,000.00 SPERRY CONSTRUCTION & ELECTRIC, INC. EL CAJON CA $1,000.00 SRS INSURANCE SERVICES, INC. SANTA ANA CA $25,000.00 STAMPEDERS LLC. LA VERNE CA $150.00 STEPHEN C. KIMBALL, INC. MISSION VIEJO CA $5,000.00 STEVEN M. ROWAN D.M.D. INC. MERCED CA $1,000.00 STILES CUSTOM METAL, INC. CERES CA $3,000.00 STRONGTOWER FINANCIAL, INC. FRESNO CA $5,000.00 Exhibit 4 Page 102 Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document MONARCH 247-2 BEACH Filed 08/25/11 Page 6 of 39$200.00 CA SUBURBAN DEVELOPMENT CO. SUBWAY-MERCED MALL, M PAGE ENTER., INC. FRESNO CA $2,500.00 SUMMIT MUSIC, INC. VALENCIA CA $1,000.00 SUNSTONE PARTNERS, LLC CAMARILLO CA $25,000.00 SURGICAL EYE CARE CENTER, INC. CARLSBAD CA $2,000.00 SWEETWATER POOLS, INC. WEST COVINA CA $1,000.00 SYAR INDUSTRIES, INC. NAPA CA $1,000.00 SYNERGY ENTERPRISES, INC. HAYWARD CA $2,450.00 SYNERGY ENTREPRENEURS LLC DRAPER UT $2,550.00 T.B. PENICK & SONS, INC. SAN DIEGO CA $40,000.00 T.E. NEESBY, INC. FRESNO CA $500.00 TCA PARTNERS, LLP FRESNO CA $1,000.00 T-CRAFT, INC. EL NIDO CA $100.00 TELASTRA, INC. PALOS VERDES ESTATES CA $198.00 TELECOM NETWORK SOLUTIONS, INC. YUCAIPA CA $300.00 TERRY M. DAVIS, DDS INC. SN BERNRDNO CA $500.00 THE FOURELS INVESTMENT CO. ORANGE CA $15,000.00 THE HAUS GROUP FOLSOM CA $1,000.00 THE INFINITY GROUP ROSAMOND CA $250.00 THE KENDALL COMPLIANCE GROUP INC HEMET CA $100.00 THE PARADISE GROUP LAS VEGAS NV $250.00 THE SCOTT GROUP TEMECULA CA $200.00 THE VINEYARD GROUP MESA AZ $100,000.00 THE VINEYARD GROUP QUEEN CREEK AZ $25,000.00 THE VINEYARD GROUP, LLC MESA AZ $35,000.00 THE X-FACTOR SYSTEMS LLC HENDERSON NV $5,000.00 THERON L. VINES, JR., D.D.S., INC. REDLANDS CA $2,000.00 THOMAS N. LUDLOW DDS, INC. FOLSOM CA $2,500.00 TITEL ENTERPRISES, INC. BELLFLOWER CA $100.00 TOOLSON CONSTRUCTION CO., INC. ENCINITAS CA $1,000.00 TRAINING LEADERS OF AMERICA, LLC CHINO HILLS CA $100.00 TRANSNORTAD, INC. GENERAL ACCOUNT VISTA CA $6,000.00 TRICKS’ GYMNASTICS, INC. GRANITE BAY CA $5,000.00 TULARE COUNTY INVESTMENTS LLC CAMARILLO CA $5,000.00 TULARE COUNTY INVESTMENTS, LLC CAMARILLO CA $20,000.00 U.S. AIR FILTRATION INC. MURRIETA CA $2,500.00 U.S. TELEPHONE RENTALS, INC. LAS VEGAS NV $1,000.00 U-RENT, INC. CAMARILLO CA $5,200.00 USA PRESORT, INC. STOCKTON CA $1,000.00 VACATION POOLS ANDSPAS INC. HESPERIA CA $500.00 VALLEY PACIFIC PETROLEUM SERVICES, INC. STOCKTON CA $745.00 VIC FOSTER & ASSOCIATES MURRIETA CA $250.00 VISIONARY ELECTRONICS, INC. SAN FRANCISCO CA $99.00 WEBB AUTOMOTIVE GROUP, INC. FARMINGTON NM $9,950.00 WELLCARE, INC. LAGUNA HILLS CA $3,000.00 WESTERN WATER FEATURES, INC. EL DORADO HILLS CA $5,000.00 WESTON & TUTTLE, LLP CAMERON PARK CA $2,000.00 WILCOX APPRAISAL & ASSOCIATES, INC. WINTON CA $1,000.00 WILDE INVESTMENTS SC, LLC SAN CARLOS CA $50,000.00 WILKINSON ELECTRIC, INC. ST. GEORGE UT $10,000.00 WISER WATER, LLC POWAY CA $1,000.00 WITTWER MANAGEMENT, LLC ST. GEORGE UT $10,000.00 Z MANAGEMENT, LLC FOLSOM CA $500.00 Exhibit 4 Page 103 Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 7 of 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Exhibit 4-22 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Exhibit to Pls.’ M emo in Supp. of M ot. for Summ. J. Exhibit 4 Page 104 The Bay Area Reporter Online | Prop 8 fight gets ugly on both sides Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Follow The Bay Area Reporter Filed 08/25/11 Page 8 of 39 Issue: Vol. 41 / No. 24 / 16 June 2011 About News Latest Blogs Opinion Arts Columns Search Classifieds Supervisor Scott Wiener quietly named acting mayor in Mayor Lee’s absence - Jun 19, 2011 Prop 8 fight gets ugly on both sides Published 10/16/2008 by Seth Hemmelgarn Proposition 8, which would ban same-sex marriage in California, has generated incidents on both sides in recent days, with the Yes on 8 side reporting a supporter was attacked, and those opposed to the measure report yard signs being burned or stolen. Print this Page Send to a Friend Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on MySpace! A D V E R T NEWS I S M E N T The ProtectMarriage campaign reported Monday that a Prop 8 supporter was attacked Sunday, October 12 by an apparent opponent of the measure. According to an e-mail from Chip White, press secretary for Yes on 8, Jose Nunez, 37, was waiting to distribute yard signs to other supporters of the measure after church at Modesto's St. Stanislaus Parish Sunday. White's e-mail, which was sent out on Monday, said that someone grabbed about 75 signs and yelled at Nunez, "What do you have against gays?" Nunez replied that he had nothing against gays, according to the e-mail, and was then attacked. In an e-mail to the Bay Area Reporter , Sergeant Brian Findlen, a Modesto police spokesman, wrote that the suspect apparently took the signs and was followed by Nunez. When Nunez caught up with the suspect, the suspect allegedly punched Nunez once. According to White, Nunez - his eye dripping with blood - walked into a building on church grounds where a fellow parishioner called 911. The church's pastor did not respond to a request for comment. White's e-mail said Nunez "suffered a bloody eye, serious wounds to his face, and a scratch to his knee." Findlen said that Nunez suffered a laceration near his eye that required medical treatment, and was transported by ambulance to a local hospital. He said he couldn't confirm the other injuries. Findlen said Nunez was assaulted at about 11:15 a.m. The case has been assigned to a detective. "We have investigative leads ... and hope to identify the suspect in this case," Findlen wrote. According to White, Nunez, a native of Mexico, became an American citizen two months ago and has three children, ages 9, 5, and 3. "It's outrageous that the No campaign calls themselves the voice of tolerance and moderation and wants people to feel bad for supporting Prop 8," White said in the e-mail. "There was nothing tolerant or moderate about beating up Jose." White did not provide a phone number for Nunez by press time. The No on 8 campaign sent out an e-mail Monday calling for a peaceful campaign. Asked about the incident in a conference call with reporters Tuesday, Patrick Guerriero, No on 8's campaign director, said, "Our campaign and its values are all about respect for every single citizen." In Larchmont, a suburb of Sacramento, sheriff's deputies were called to a home Saturday after it was reported that a Exhibit 4 Page 105 http://www.ebar.com/news/article.php?sec=news&article=3403[6/20/2011 5:30:56 PM] The Bay Area Reporter Online | Prop 8 fight gets ugly on both sides Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 9 of 39 neighborhood teenager burned No on 8 yard signs. The teenager was taken into custody for a 72-hour psychological evaluation. While the youth was in custody, a third sign was stolen from the same home. Paul Curtis and Ray Allen, a couple who own a home in the neighborhood, said neighbors have been divided over Prop 8. Their own No on 8 sign has not been damaged. Dan Aiello contributed to this report. Recommend Sign Up to see what your friends recommend. Add a comment... Comment using... Facebook social plugin Copyright © 2011, Bay Area Reporter, a division of Benro Enterprises, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Home | News | Open Forum | Columns | Arts & Entertainment | Arts Columns | Classifieds | Obituaries | Archives | About the BAR | Advertising Exhibit 4 Page 106 http://www.ebar.com/news/article.php?sec=news&article=3403[6/20/2011 5:30:56 PM] Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 10 of 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Exhibit 4-23 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Exhibit to Pls.’ M emo in Supp. of M ot. for Summ. J. Exhibit 4 Page 107 Attack outside of Catholic church part of 'wave of intimidation,' says Yes on 8 :: Catholic News Agency (CNA) Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 11 of 39 June 2011 16:33 GMT-05:00 Custom search News Resources Tools Columns Search Documents Mobile version | Español | Português | AUDIO | VIDEO | Advertise with us | Donations | About us ACI Group Headlines | Vatican | Americas | Asia - Pacific | US | Europe | Middle East - Africa | Most Read | Most Commented | Archive Home » News » US Latest news: Attack outside of Catholic church part of 'wave of intimidation,' says Yes on 8 8 Comments ADVERTISING Place your ad here 03:07 pm | Researcher: Google queries on Catholic topics show major drop 02:01 pm | Nearly 20,000 priests expected to attend World Youth Day 12:45 pm | Father Corapi’s Bombshell 05:55 pm | Bishops' committee okays early introduction of some new Mass responses Sacramento, Calif., Oct 15, 2008 / 08:17 pm (CNA).- This past Sunday, a parishioner at St. Stanislaus Catholic Church in Modesto, California was attacked while helping promote Proposition 8, which will define marriage as only between a man and a woman in California. According to promoters of the initiative, the assault is part of a “wave of violence” throughout the state. Jose Nunez, 37, was waiting outside of St. Stanislaus for Mass to finish so he could distribute yard signs to Prop. 8 supporters when he was approached by an opponent of the initiative. The unidentified man grabbed about 75 of the “Vote Yes on 8” signs and ran. Nunez then spotted the man trying to throw the signs over a wall and approached him. 01:15 pm | Florida woman reflects on letters received from Mother Teresa More... Related news : Bishop of Fresno removes priest who opposes Prop. 8 Yes on 8 supporters holding yard signs in front of St. Stanislaus Related articles: Marriage in the Catechism of the Catholic Church Why do so few Catholic OB/GYN's promote NFP? Conn. bishops call for constitutional convention to reverse same-sex marriage decision California restores ‘bride’ and ‘groom’ to marriage licenses Major Welsh adoption agency to cut Catholic ties due to new same-sex adoption rules More... Get CNA News on your email: The Meaning of Catholic marriage Your E-mail: Catholic Marriage and annulments When he got nearer, the man shouted, "What do you have against gays!" to which Nunez replied that he had nothing against gays. When Nunez attempted to take the stolen signs from the assailant, the man punched him. The blow sent Nunez to the hospital, where he received 16 stitches for the wound below his left eye. “Yes on 8” press secretary Chip White told CNA that the irony of the whole episode is that, the opponents of Prop. 8 “are the ones who are claiming to be tolerant and open-minded.” "It's outrageous that the ‘No’ campaign calls themselves the voice of tolerance and moderation and wants people to feel bad for supporting Prop. 8. There was nothing tolerant or moderate about beating up Jose," said White. "Clearly the man who attacked Jose is intolerant of those who support traditional marriage," he added. Subscribe HTML Unsubscribe Text only Headlines Send Resources First Reading: Gen 12:1-9 Psalm: Ps 33:12-13,18-20,22 Gospel: Mt 7:1-5 Saint of the Day St. Alban Homily of the day Following the altercation between Nunez and the anti-Proposition 8 assailant, the “No on Prop. 8” campaign director Patrick Guerrier released a statement Mt 7:1-5 Exhibit 4 Page 108 http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/attack_outside_of_catholic_church_part_of_wave_of_intimidation_says_yes_on_8/[6/20/2011 5:33:58 PM] Attack outside of Catholic church part of 'wave of intimidation,' says Yes on 8 :: Catholic News Agency (CNA) condemning theCase violent 2:09-cv-00058-MCE attack and saying that such actions not be tolerated -DAD“should Document 247-2 in any campaign." Filed 08/25/11 Page 12 of 39 In an interesting twist, Jose Nunez is originally from Mexico but just became a U.S. citizen two months ago. He will be voting for the first time in November. Nunez is also active in his parish as the Grand Knight of the St. Stanislaus Council Knights of Columbus, an organization that has contributed more than $1 million to the campaign for Prop. 8. The attack has not lessened Nunez´s support for Proposition 8. "The other side wants to intimidate us, but we can't stop standing up for traditional marriage,” he said. “I may be bloody and bruised, but I'm not giving up. Protecting traditional marriage is just too important for our kids," added Nunez, who is the father of three children, ages 9, 5, and 3. According to Chip White, Californians from around the state have reported being harassed by people who are against Prop. 8. Among the incidents he related were: verbal harassment of Prop.8 supporters on the freeway, including obscene gestures; the theft of yard signs; and a woman in Riverside, California who had her garage sprayed with graffiti. White characterized the incidents as “a whole wave of intimidation and violence up and down the state.” 8 Comments Thanks for your comments. The number of messages that can be online is limited. Length should not exceed 1500 characters. CNA reserves the right to edit messages for content and tone. Comments and opinions expressed by users do not necessarily reflect the opinions or beliefs of CNA. CNA will not publish comments with abusive language, insults or links to other pages Like Add New Comment Optional: Login below. Image Post as … Showing 8 comments Sort by Newest first Newest first Subscribe by email Subscribe by RSS aaa 4 months ago Memorial Day Prayers On Memorial Day I must pray to the souls of those who gave their lives, those who gave up all their tomorrows so that I can have mine, and ask their forgiveness. They died for Mom, Pop, apple pie, justice, honesty, morality, liberty and the flag. They died for my freedom. Now our society presents, same sex marriage, injustice, legislative liars, moral decay, politically incorrect speech not allowed, illegal immigration, and flag burning. I must pray to their souls and ask forgiveness, for, I let it happen. Like Reply Exhibit 4 Page 109 http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/attack_outside_of_catholic_church_part_of_wave_of_intimidation_says_yes_on_8/[6/20/2011 5:33:58 PM] Attack outside of Catholic church part of 'wave of intimidation,' says Yes on 8 :: Catholic News Agency (CNA) Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 13 of 39 Joe 4 months ago I hope some eyewitness is able to identify the assailant; that's totally reprehensible behavior. However, characterizing opponents of Prop 8 based on this one unidentified attacker would be as wrong-headed as characterizing Prop 8 supporters based on Fred Phelps and the Westboro Baptist Church, or on people who have beaten or killed others for being gay. You wouldn't want that, would you? Like Reply MW Patterson 4 months ago Thank you for posting and for the ministry of your website. I very much want our nation and world to honor marriage as God intended - between one man and one woman - as a life long bond before Him. Let's be praying Christians - Protestant, Roman Catholic, And Orthodox - For we are all sinners in need of His saving grace, love and direction in these times. Like Reply Brian 4 months ago Possibly there is a mistaken notion that same-sex unions are part and parcel of basic human rights, a natural follow-through of earlier causes. Please consider that, Mrs. O'Riordan. Feel free to correct the people who hold that notion, but please don't demonize the people. Like Reply lds 4 months ago I don't understand why they respond with attacks when we're doing our part peacefully. Our yard sign was vandalized the same day we put it up and I don't get how they want us to respect their "rights" when they don't respect ours. Yes on 8! Like Reply Denise 4 months ago Wow - the ones who demand tolerance can't treat others the way they want to be treated. What a surprise. Extremists - whether left or right leaning - are always the problem, and ironically the most intolerant. Like Reply NGJ 4 months ago God bless you mightily, Jose Nunez! When you turned the other cheek you were as Christ-like as one can be. Thank you for your courage, perseverance and righteous stand for Prop. 8. We support you in prayer. Godspeed in your mission! Like Reply Mrs. Rene O'Riordan 4 months ago Exhibit 4 Page 110 http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/attack_outside_of_catholic_church_part_of_wave_of_intimidation_says_yes_on_8/[6/20/2011 5:33:58 PM] Attack outside of Catholic church part of 'wave of intimidation,' says Yes on 8 :: Catholic News Agency (CNA) Correct me if I'm wrong but never in the known history of mankind have homosexuals lobbied for marriage! This new development is surely saying something about our times Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Like Filed 08/25/11 Page 14 of 39 Reply ADVERTISING CNA does not necessarily endorse these advertisers. Please proceed with discretion. If you feel that a website announced has inappropriate or offensive content, please send it by e-mail to catholicna@catholicna.com Resources: Columns: News: Documents: Tools: ACI Group: Abortion A Life Worth Living Headlines Pope Benedict XVI Catholic Podcast ACI Prensa Advent Bishops' Corner Vatican Pope John Paul II RSS Feeds ACI Digital Apologetics Book Reviews Americas Pope Paul VI CNA TV Catholic News Agency Benedict XVI Both Oars In Asia - Pacific Pope John XXIII CNA Audio Directorio Católico Bible Catholic & Single US Pope Pius XII Enciclopedia Católica Cardinals Catholic Men Europe Pope Pius XI Móvil Católico Catechism Guest Columnist Middle East - Africa Pope Pius X Solteros del Ave María Church Fathers Most Read Pope Leo XIII Life & Family Harvesting the Fruit of Vatican II Most Commented Vatican II Liturgical Calendar In Good Company Archive Liturgy Indispensable Economics Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith Mary Led Into the Truth Politics Movie Reviews Pontifical Council for the Family Prayers Preparing the way for the Roman Missal – 3rd Edition United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) With Good Reason Cardinal James Francis Stafford Sacraments Sacred Arts Saints Virtue Archbishop Charles J. Chaput Bishop Samuel J. Aquila Copyright © CNA All rights reserved Email us at: news@catholicna.com Search www.catholicnewsagency.com web Exhibit 4 Page 111 http://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/attack_outside_of_catholic_church_part_of_wave_of_intimidation_says_yes_on_8/[6/20/2011 5:33:58 PM] Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 15 of 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Exhibit 4-24 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Exhibit to Pls.’ M emo in Supp. of M ot. for Summ. J. Exhibit 4 Page 112 Protect Marriage - Yes on 8 » News Not receiving ProtectMarriage.com emails? Sign Up! Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 16 of 39 California Voices for Prop. 8 News PROP. 8 SUPPORTER VIOLENTLY ATTACKED FOR DISTRIBUTING LAWN SIGNS October 13, 2008 Contact: Chip White/Sonja Eddings Brown, 916-215-4392 "We are at one of those moments. This is THE major change point of the last few decades..." MODESTO-October 13—In a violent display of intolerance, an opponent of Proposition 8 attacked and seriously injured a man who was volunteering on Sunday for the initiative to define marriage as between and a man and a woman. Prop. 8 supporter, Jose Nunez, 37, was brutally assaulted while waiting to distribute yard signs to other supporters of the initiative after church services at the St. Stanislaus Parish in Modesto. 109,065 The assailant grabbed about 75 signs and yelled at Nunez accusingly, “What do you have against gays!” Although Nunez replied that he had nothing against gays, he was attacked anyway. The assailant punched Nunez in the left eye and ran off with the signs. Nunez, his eye dripping with blood, walked into a building on church grounds where a fellow parishoner called 911. Police and paramedics responded to the scene. Nunez, who suffered a bloody eye, serious wounds to his face, and a scratch to his knee, was rushed by ambulance to a local hospital where he received 16 stitches under his eye. According to the Yes on 8 campaign, the attack shows that their opponents are not as tolerant and open-minded as they would like voters to believe. “It’s outrageous that the No campaign calls themselves the voice of tolerance and moderation and wants people to feel bad for supporting Prop. 8. There was nothing tolerant or moderate about beating up Jose,” said ProtectMarriage.com—Yes on 8 press secretary Chip White. “Clearly the man who attacked Jose is intolerant of those who support traditional marriage,” White added. Ironically, Nunez, a native of Mexico, became an American citizen two months ago and plans to vote for the first time in November. Nunez, who is recovering and in good spirits, said the attack only strengthens his resolve to help ensure that Prop. 8 passes. “The other side wants to intimidate us, but we can’t stop standing up for traditional marriage. I may be bloody and bruised, but I’m not giving up. Protecting traditional marriage is just too important for our kids,” said Nunez, the father of three children, ages 9, 5, and 3. “I don’t want my kids taught in public school that same sex-marriage is the same as traditional marriage,” Nunez added. Nunez has been forced to take time off work to recover. It was not immediately clear how much Nunez will suffer in medical expenses and lost wages. Anyone who is interested in contributing funds toward Nunez’s medical expenses or lost wages may contact the campaign at info@protectmarriage.com. The campaign asks those who have been attacked, threatened, or had yard signs stolen to file a police report and to email the campaign. ### Media contacts: Northern & Central California (Sacramento Press Office): Chip White, 916-215-4392 Los Angeles & Southern California: Sonja Eddings Brown, 818-993-4508 http://www.protectmarriage.com/article/prop-8-supporter-violently-attacked-for-distributing-lawn-signs[6/20/2011 5:36:14 PM] Exhibit 4 Page 113 Protect Marriage - Yes on 8 » News Protect Marriage, 915 L Street, # C-259, Sacramento, CA 95814 Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Back to News Home Prop. 8 About Us Blog Why Marriage Matters Take Action Contact Us Filed 08/25/11 Page 17 of 39 Donate Now © 2008 - 2010 ProtectMarriage.com. All Rights Reserved. ProtectMarriage.com is a project of California Renewal (I.D. #1302592) | Privacy Policy Exhibit 4 Page 114 http://www.protectmarriage.com/article/prop-8-supporter-violently-attacked-for-distributing-lawn-signs[6/20/2011 5:36:14 PM] Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 18 of 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Exhibit 4-25 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Exhibit to Pls.’ M emo in Supp. of M ot. for Summ. J. Exhibit 4 Page 115 Prop 8 supporter attacked while distributing signs | NBC Los Angeles Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 19 of 39 TIPS | LOGIN | REGISTER NEWS LOCAL ENTERTAINMENT POLITICS SPORTS THE SCENE HEALTH TECH ON AIR WEIRD TRAFFIC WEATHER BLOGS» WEATHER PROP ZERO PRESS HERE HOME > NEWS > POLITICS OFFERS 74° 77 | 61 Search U.S. & WORLD TOP STORIES Prop 8 supporter attacked while distributing signs TODAY MOST WATCHED MOST EMAILED By David Markland | Thursday, Jan 7, 2010 | Updated 3:21 PM PDT View Comments (0) | Leave A Comment | Email | Print 0 Recommend Send advertisement Stow's Doctors Upgrade Condition Ryan Dunn Legally Drunk at Time of Crash Cuban Comments Give Hope to "Save Dodgers" Gay marriage debate becomes violent A Modesto man was attacked while passing out Yes On Prop 8 signs last Sunday. Jose Nunez, 37, who became a U.S. citizen two months ago, was outside St. Stanislaus Catholic Church when an unidentified man grab about 75 of the signs and ran. Nunez took chase, and when he caught up the man punched him the face. Proposition 8 supporters, who are fighting to overturn gay marriage in California by changing language in the state Constitution, describe this incident as part of “a wave of intimidation and violence up and down the state.” Celebrity Weight Watchers: Heidi Montag FOLLOW NBCLOSANGELES The Bay Area Reporter, a gay community targeted news source, says the Prop 8 debate has become “ugly on both sides”: Exhibit 4 Page 116 http://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/politics/Prop_8_supporter_attacked_while_distributing_signs_LA.html[6/22/2011 6:09:34 PM] Prop 8 supporter attacked while distributing signs | NBC Los Angeles According to Chip White, Californians Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 20 of 39 In Fair Oaks, a suburb of Sacramento, sheriff’s deputies were called to a home Saturday after it was reported that a neighborhood teenager burned No on 8 yard signs. The teenager was taken into custody for a 72-hour psychological evaluation. While the youth was in custody, a third sign was stolen from the same home. 0 Posted Friday, Jul 17, 2009 - 4:26 AM PDT from around the state have reported being harassed by people who are against Prop. 8. Among the incidents he related were: verbal harassment of Prop.8 supporters on the freeway, including obscene gestures; the theft of yard signs; and a woman in Riverside, California who had her garage sprayed with graffiti. [Catholic News Agency] Recommend Send FURIOUS INTRIGUED This story makes me feel: SAD THRILLED HAPPY BORED Leave Comments Add a comment... Comment using... Facebook social plugin MORE NEWS MORE POLITICS LOCAL PROP-ZERO AS-SEEN-ON LOCAL LOCAL AS-SEEN-ON US-WORLD PROP-ZERO MOVIES Businesses Preparing for So-Called "Carmageddon" Lawmakers Go Home Chicago Storms Delay Flights at LAX Students Surprised By Navy Captain's Rap Song Controller Halts Lawmaker Pay Report: Obama Plans Quicker Afghan Pullout More News MORE MULTIMEDIA How Vulgar Is That TShirt in the Window? Stop Paying Brown and Chiang Too More Politics Owen Wilson & Eddie Izzard Get Their Engines Running In 'Cars 2' More Multimedia Exhibit 4 Page 117 http://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/politics/Prop_8_supporter_attacked_while_distributing_signs_LA.html[6/22/2011 6:09:34 PM] Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 21 of 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Exhibit 4-26 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Exhibit to Pls.’ M emo in Supp. of M ot. for Summ. J. Exhibit 4 Page 118 Inbox Influence | Influence Explorer Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 22 of 39 SEARCH enter a politician, company or individual donor SHARE Your new favorite email tool since the spam filter. How To Install Inbox Influence is an add-on Everyday our email inboxes are filled with urgent messages from co- for your browser that adds workers, dinner reminders from family, as well as news alerts, listserv functionality to Gmail. messages and even political advocacy communications. Browser extensions are Inbox Influence is a new tool from the Sunlight Foundation that allows you to see the political contributions of the people and organizations that are mentioned in emails you receive. This easy-to-use tool can be used for researching influence background on corporate correspondence, adding context to newspaper headlines or discovering who is behind political fundraising solicitations. Inbox Influence provides details on any entity in the body of the email, plus information on both the sender of the email and the company from available for Firefox and Chrome. Other browsers, including Internet Explorer 9 and Safari, can use Inbox Influence through the bookmarklet, but support in these browsers has not been extensively tested at this time. which it was sent. With it, you can even see how your friends and family have given to political campaigns. Perhaps Uncle Joe has more mainstream views after all? Inbox Influence is the latest addition to Sunlight’s collection of web tools that use publicly available data to help Americans explore the connection between money and politics: Checking Influence—a web tool that analyzes your online bank or credit card statement to reveal how your everyday spending wields political influence. Poligraft—a bookmarklet that connects the dots between money and politics in Congress for any online An Inbox Influence button news article, blog post or press release. will appear in the upper Influence Explorer—a searchable library of federal and state influence data including political contributions, when you next load Gmail. lobbying records, earmark requests, government contracts and more. right corner of the window An Inbox Influence button will appear in the upper right corner of the window when you next load Gmail. Exhibit 4 Page 119 https://inbox.influenceexplorer.com/[6/22/2011 2:08:55 PM] Inbox Influence | Influence Explorer Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 23 of 39 To activate, click on the bookmark while on your Gmail page. PRIVACY In order to attach political influence information to your emails, Inbox Influence sends the text of the email and the sender information to our servers. This information is used only to process the request and is not stored in any way. All connections to Inbox Influence are made using industry-standard SSL--the same encryption technology that Gmail itself uses. Inbox Influence can be easily toggled on and off using the button in the upper right corner of the Gmail page. No information is transmitted when Inbox Influence is disabled. To activate, click on the favorite while on your Gmail ABOUT THE DATA page. Inbox Influence uses data from other Sunlight sites, including Influence Explorer, Transparency Data and Party Time. The Influence Explorer about page has links to detailed methodology pages describing the sources of data, how totals are computed and various caveats. Inbox Influence will sometimes make mistakes when matching email text to politician and organization names. For example, 'Gap', 'Caterpillar' and 'Oracle' are all both company names and common nouns. Similarly, politician names will sometimes erroneously match names of ordinary people. There are probably hundreds of Jerry Browns in the US, only three of whom are politicians. For both companies and individuals, Inbox Influence will highlight the name if it thinks there could be a match. Variations in formatting and punctuation may also cause names to be missed. Inbox Influence is solely a product of the Sunlight Foundation. Google did not participate in its creation. Google has provided some funding support to Sunlight, primarily for its Apps for America contests and its TransparencyCamps. ABOUT CONTACT Founded in 2006, the Sunlight Foundation is a non-partisan non-profit that uses cutting-edge technology and ideas to make government transparent and accountable. Visit SunlightFoundation.com to learn more. Exhibit 4 Page 120 https://inbox.influenceexplorer.com/[6/22/2011 2:08:55 PM] Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 24 of 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Exhibit 4-27 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Exhibit to Pls.’ M emo in Supp. of M ot. for Summ. J. Exhibit 4 Page 121 Leatherby's Family Creamery - Sacramento Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 25 of 39 sign in with facebook Health & Medical Restaurants Beauty Home & Garden All Categories Advertise With Us find Sacramento, CA > Desserts > Ice Cream Parlors > Leatherby's Family Creamery join near Ads by Google Leatherby's Family Creamery 46 Reviews 916-920-8382 2333 Arden Way # A Sacramento, CA 95825 leatherbys.net Add Photo Edit Business Claim Business About Leatherby's Family Creamery Categories: Desserts, Ice Cream Parlors, Get Map & Directions Not sure yet? Consider these two similar businesses Cold Stone Creamery Vic's Ice Cream Inc 4 Reviews 3199 Riverside Blvd Sacramento, CA 5 Reviews Or, see more choices in Sacramento: Reviews Insider Pages Reviews for Leatherby's Family Creamery Have experience with this business? Write a Review. Your chocolate in my peanut butter heath s. | follow us Sacramento, CA Classic Magnum Ice Cream Thick Belgian Chocolate Shell over Silky Vanilla Bean Ice Cream. Yum! www.magnumicecream.com 1028 Florin Rd Sacramento, CA sign in Insider | Rank: 28,641 peanut butter and chocolate ice cream with chuinkcs ofr peanut globs and chocolate hmmm yum I m going to go right now January 24, 2011 Report Abuse Was this review helpful to you? Not Family Friendly, Dirty, Poorly Managed Rachel H. In the past we have loved Leatherby's icecream and have frequented it even though it is dingy and run down inside -- but we are fed up with the poor service. We tried to use our groupon at Leatherby's and we wanted to sit and eat one sundae with our daughter and then get 2 to take home for our kids who were asleep in the car and my spouse who was waiting with them because we do not live near the store. They would not allow this because the coupon said dine-in. So we were dining in and they wouldn't let us take anything to go. I would have tipped on the full amount. Then I offered to get the sundaes and then put them in containers myself to go and still they would not allow it. I am not happy and will never go to Leatherby's again. It is supposed to be a family friendly establishment and the management bullied us and embarrassed us and made us feel like they did not want our business. When we called to complain later they were like "oh Come in now and we will honor your request," but we were already on our way home and had wasted our time and dignity on them. The manager just wanted to be a bully and to be rude. I will never recommend Leatherby's or visit them ever again. Plus their restaurant is FILTHY inside and I would not want to Exhibit 4 Page 122 http://www.insiderpages.com/b/3711178877/leatherbys-family-creamery-sacramento[6/22/2011 2:03:40 PM] Leatherby's Family Creamery - Sacramento ever dine-in there ever. Had I seen those words dine in on the groupon print I would not have CaseHuge 2:09-cv-00058-MCE purchased the groupon. disappointment, lame place-DAD and I will Document not be using my247-2 groupon afterall, nor will I give my business to Leatherby's again - so sad. They should take family out of their name altogether... Filed 08/25/11 Page 26 of 39 January 11, 2011 Report Abuse Was this review helpful to you? Unacceptable Jon A. I ordered two crab sandwich with fries for both, upon ordering i ask that my fries be fresh. (As the last time i dined there they arrived at my table cold as the ice cream) My dinner arrives & sure enough the french fries are cold & old, I immediatly tell my waiter that this is not as i had ordered, Sorry he tells me as he takes my plate with sandwich away. Five mins later he returns with hot fries ok great except that now these fries are very undercooked, like raw oily potatoes. Ok no fries tonight, but even had they been good i would'nt have been able to eat them. Why you ask? No f'n ketchup. No joke! My waiter tells me sorry we are out. Five minuts later he brings me two empty bottles turns them upside down standing on there lids & says there ya go. I then tell him (Because he asks how is everything?) that my fries are undercooked he agree's and say's that he is sorry. My ice cream sundae was well... ok. Ice cream was kinda bland & the construction of the sundae was very sloppy with way to much pinapple sauce all over it. I was on a date, so ya it was quite lame going through this. $ 40.00 plus tip later was a total waste of money as far as i'm concerned & i would not recomend. I told the cashier as i was leaving that i thought being out of ketchup was unacceptable. She told me O, then looked away. Nice Place. Overpriced as well. August 19, 2007 Report Abuse Was this review helpful to you? Dieters Beware: Y ou Won't Be able to Resist Hong N. | Insider | Rank: 22,099 The desserts at this place are absolutely sinful, but it is worth it. The ice cream is made relatively fresh and the hot fudge is so yummy. Leatherby's also has your basic burger and sandwich meals, but people often go there for their gigantic ice creams, which fill you up as if they were a meal in themselves. The prices are pretty steep for dessert though. A average sundae will cost you about 7 or 8 bucks. I also love the fact that they are open so late during the weekends! PROS: Magnificant Ice Cream Sundaies, Great Service CONS: Pricey Ice Cream December 25, 2005 Report Abuse Was this review helpful to you? Leatherbys Maya S. | Insider Expert | Rank: 12,899 Leatherbys Family Creamery is my other favorite ice cream parlor. I go here for there great sundaes and banana splits. I love their chocolate fudge topping. It is just to die for. Try Valeries Black and White. It has marshmallows, whipped cream, chocolate fudge, nuts and a cherry all on top of chocolate and vanilla ice cream. November 19, 2005 Report Abuse Was this review helpful to you? Exhibit 4 Page 123 http://www.insiderpages.com/b/3711178877/leatherbys-family-creamery-sacramento[6/22/2011 2:03:40 PM] Leatherby's Family Creamery - Sacramento Leatherbys Elijah K. | Case -DAD Document 247-2 Insider 2:09-cv-00058-MCE Expert | Rank: 10,533 Filed 08/25/11 Page 27 of 39 I heard so much about Leatherbys from so many people in this area but I didn't think it was as great as people said it was. Maybe the hype ruined it for me. It was good ice cream don't get me wrong but not anything I would go out of my way for. The whip cream was gross though. But the employees were super nice and they really kept that old time home style old fashioned feeling. That is cool. The atmosphere makes you want to eat ice cream. They also have other old fashioned ice cream shop foods there such as burders and fries. it's all decent. Again the ice cream is good but not out of this world. November 05, 2005 Report Abuse Was this review helpful to you? The best ice cream around! Stephanie T. | Insider Expert | Rank: 8,449 Leatherbys has the best ice cream and toppings anywhere in the area. The portions are HUGE and the prices are very reasonable for the portion size. The food is average but the ice cream is fantastic! November 03, 2005 Report Abuse Was this review helpful to you? Great place for the whole family Sarah K. | Insider Expert | Rank: 5,001 Leatherby's is great for birthdays, dates, family outings, and just having a bite to eat. They have great food, but it's ALL about the ice cream. And TONS of it. And the super friendly service. PROS: Great people and serivce and GREAT ice cream CONS: Gets a little crowded at "peak" hours. September 02, 2005 Report Abuse Was this review helpful to you? Latest reviews from Citysearch. September 10, 2010 I will be visiting by canative at Citysearch I grew up coming to Leatherby's as a child. I left for the military 15 years ago... Recently married with a baby girl I will be bringing my family to your establishment when I come home in 2 weeks! Thank you for your values! February 24, 2010 Worth the trip by Legionnaire at Citysearch When I was a kid my family and I would stop for sundaes every time we were in the fremont area. The caramel sundae with cookies and cream ice was my treat baby... After they closed down at the fremont hub I thought they were gone forever. I decided to look up my old friends and found them in sac only an hour from where I'm at today. It seems the ice cream shop is under some controversial discrimination. Well I'm proud to see that they stand up for what they believe in and for what is right. By standing against the abomination that is known as gay marriage. What is this world coming to? I for one will be making the trip very soon to be reunited with my caramel sundae and will be happy to enjoy it in the presence of moral people. Thank You Leatherby's!! Pros: Best Caramel Sundae Ever Cons: I live in Patterson November 29, 2009 see you on wendsday Exhibit 4 Page 124 http://www.insiderpages.com/b/3711178877/leatherbys-family-creamery-sacramento[6/22/2011 2:03:40 PM] Leatherby's Family Creamery - Sacramento by Gary Whitlock at Citysearch Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE Document It was a hundred and fifty degrees, all i could think about -DAD was. the bananna split. my247-2 sergeant Filed threw a right angle flash light and screamed for me to pay attention, dreaming about that ice cream again private montoya said. best ice cream ever great atmosphere, i was thousands of miles away fropm home and all i wanted was some comfort food wendsday i get it, back in cali. spc. whitlock over and out 08/25/11 Page 28 of 39 Pros: The best ice cream ever Cons: Liberals November 18, 2009 Ice Cream Lover by 2tab2 at Citysearch Love the caramel sundae! Pros: caramel March 18, 2009 My kids political statement by pshepp at Citysearch So my kids (9, 11 and 13) decided after eating at Leatherby's their whole lives, that they did not want to patronize a company who did not believe in equal rights for everyone. They decided that the ice cream was yummy, but they don't want our dollars going towards removing rights from people in our community. I have to say I am very proud of them!!! Pros: Example: best croissants in town Cons: What are the drawbacks? November 19, 2008 Great Ice Cream, Great Service, Great Family Values by bunchabarries at Citysearch Wow.. great Ice Cream, Great Pies, Great Family Values. This creamery gets 100% support for standing up for FAMILIES.. look at the reviews it isn't the people with the family values who show the bitterness, it is those that have no family to value.... Pros: all around great family dining, easy access to parking, November 19, 2008 Great icecream!!! by Dbot at Citysearch Last night was the first time we visited Leatherby's, after we heard that they were boycoted for donating money to support the marriage between a man and a woman. We had the best service and icecream. We brought another family along and encouraged all our friends to suport this restaurant for standing for the truth and what is right. Should we boycot the Public Schools and Teacher's Association for donating money for no on 8??? That is not right or fair, so if you are reading this , do Support Leatherby's!!!! Will go back!!!! November 14, 2008 Excellent Ice Cream! by barrett5 at Citysearch Leatherby's ice cream is excellent! When our FAMILY indulges in treats, it's at Leatherby's FAMILY Creamery! The ice cream servings are ridiculously large--the prefect size to share with your sweetheart/child(ren). Love the caramel topping with toasted almond ice cream in particular. The prices are right, too! Leatherby's FAMILY Creamery has been a huge supporter in the community for decades. They're a family concern with good, old fashioned FAMILY values. There simply aren't enough solid FAMILY businesses like Leatherby's FAMILY Creamery anymore. Anyone who speaks against Leatherby's FAMILY Creamery and accuses them of "hate" because they support a cause, simply does not know anything about the business or the FAMILY. The same people would be singing their praises if Leatherby's FAMILY Creamery decided their way on a given issue. Consider the source and the anger behind their detractors, then DECIDE FOR YOURSELF about their ice cream. I believe you'll like it, too! As for me and my house, we will continue to support Leatherby's FAMILY Creamery! :o) Leatherby's FAMILY Creamery - A loyal FAMILY friend in the community! Pros: HUGE servings of tasty freshly made ice cream; the whole ice cream menu is delicious! Cons: Some tables can feel small; ask for a booth if they're available November 14, 2008 A great family tradition by Wendylady73 at Citysearch My husband and I really enjoyed our experience at Leatherby's! The service was great and the atmosphere was wonderful. It is a very family friendly place. We had dinner and sundae's. Dinner Exhibit 4 Page 125 http://www.insiderpages.com/b/3711178877/leatherbys-family-creamery-sacramento[6/22/2011 2:03:40 PM] Leatherby's Family Creamery - Sacramento was very good, my Husband loved his burger. And the sundae's!!! Whoooo they are BIG!!! Be Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE Document Filed prepared for alot of delicious ice cream!! I have to say that-DAD I was very HAPPY to see247-2 that the store is doing very well, in spite of the bitter and angry people who are harrasing this traditional family resturant. Leave the politics at home and go there to enjoy some good food and friendly service. 08/25/11 Page 29 of 39 Pros: great ice cream Cons: none November 14, 2008 Poor Service by aolbites at Citysearch The Leatherby family supports discrimination and are bigots. I will never visit any of their stores again. And I would suggest those thinking about it to look to another dessert store such as Rick's Dessert Diner downtown or Gunthers. Cons: Bigots, Discriminate November 13, 2008 We support you! by Pilchers at Citysearch I have not been to Leatherby's since I was a boy living in the Bay Area. However, because of the backlash that your organizaiton is receiving because you excersized your civil right to donate to a cause that you believed in, my family of 9 children and I will now be dining with you on a regular basis. We want you to know that we refuse to be intimidated by those who would limit the very rights of those they accuse of attemting to limit their rights! Way too much hypocrisy! We will see you soon, I hope your food is good. November 13, 2008 I'd rather eat dirt...... by rights at Citysearch Other than the fact that the Arden way store smells of dirty towels and just being plain dirty, I will not do business with people that say one thing and do the complete opposite. In your interview with the Sacramento Bee, you, Dave Leatherby said, "Let's move on. I always told my children that once a rule was made, you have to abide by it. I think it should be the same in this circumstance. Well, apparently, you DO NOT PRACTICE what you preach. Apparently, you forgot about the court ruling back in June. They said that marriage between two people with the same gender was legal. So, by supporting Prop. 8, I am assuming that you are telling people that it's "OK" for you to go against the law, but, for the opponents of Prop. 8, it's not okay to go against you and all the other supporters of Prop. 8. I too am a Catholic, but I tell you what, I would rather have people of the same gender marry, than worry about what the priests are doing in the rectory or in the confessional. Hey, but it was "OK" for the bishops and the Catholic church itself to just sweep the pedophile priests under the rug. What did the church do about all that? They just moved those priests to another diocese. The Catholic church is just as hypocritical in their doctrine as you are in your so-called religious beliefs. Try living by your advice to your children, you and all the other proponents of Prop. 8 should have "moved on" when the court ruling came down. I hope that one day, you will be put in the same position that you have put the GLBT community in. When that happens, we will all tell you supporters to "Let's move on". It is just so endearing that you are raising 10 more people just like you. God save us all. You seem to be the type that would have kept women from voting, made sure that blacks sat in the rear of the bus and made sure that there would never be inter-racial marriages. Let me reiterate what I said before, you should have "MOVED ON". Pros: NONE Cons: Smelly, sticky tables and extremely slow service when you were finally seated. November 13, 2008 Surprised by LT9999 at Citysearch It's a no-brainer that I will never take my family to Leatherby's again (it's not like they're the only ice cream parlor in town, anyway) after I read about their contribution to Prop 8 on the Bee's web site. I then looked on Leatherby's web site and saw a Utah address. That explains a lot. So this company can and its owners can spend their money to support reprehensible issues if they choose to...I just won't be giving them any more of mine to use for it. November 12, 2008 Used to be a customer by Nnyan at Citysearch Long time customer and supporter but I can no longer be a patron of any company that supports taking away rights of any group. These Pro 8 arguments are the same exact ones we heard back in the days when blacks were not allowed to marry whites in this country. Do you own research, they were "protecting the instituion of marriage" also. What a crock. All of my family and friends have stopped going to Leatherby's so I can avoid Leatherby's Exhibit 4 Page 126 http://www.insiderpages.com/b/3711178877/leatherbys-family-creamery-sacramento[6/22/2011 2:03:40 PM] Leatherby's Family Creamery - Sacramento "confusion". So you participate in the annual gay pride event? Next you'll be telling us you have Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 friends that are minorities. Filed 08/25/11 Page 30 of 39 November 12, 2008 Leatherby's supports hate! by Bettybeeee at Citysearch 20,000 donates to Yes on 8??????? Are you kidding me???? WOW, what a bunch of bigots! I'll take my $$$$$ elsewhere. November 12, 2008 No $$ for Hate by sactoroy at Citysearch I too will vote with my wallet and not patronize a business that supports discrimination. Equality for all! November 12, 2008 Keep your progressive dollars away from here by stefinsac at Citysearch Though I used to frequent this establishment with my family, I will no longer do so. I am sick to learn that my patronage $$ were used to fund the repeal of GLBT's civil rights in California. I'd rather give my $$ to Gunther's or even Baskin Robbins to avoid this place from now on. Vote with your dollar. Cons: anti-gay establishment November 11, 2008 BOYCOTT LEATHERBYS by afterbirthist at Citysearch Alan Leatherby, General Manager of Leatherby's, made a personal donation of $10,000 to ProtectMarriage (dot) com in support of the hateful and discriminatory Proposition 8. If you are a supporter or member of the LGBT community, or civil rights in general, please boycott this establishment. There isn't a sundae in the world creamy and delicious enough to reverse the damage this family business has sponsored. July 17, 2008 Don't waste your time or money unless quantity is more important than quality I ordered two scoops of two different flavors, butter pecan & some type of chocolate. The butter pecan tasted stale. The chocolate flavor had little shivers of ice throughout and tasted stale. Anyone who really appreciates quality ice cream knows that these are signs of improperly stored and/or old ice cream. The portions may be large, but it's like have a large cowpie instead of a small one. It's still a cowpie. I can't believe someone would have the audacity to compare this cheap quality ice cream to Cold Stone. Cons: Stale taste, ice shivers throughout ice cream March 21, 2008 Don't waste your time or money by helenmckinley at Citysearch I haven't been to Leatherby's in a long long time....and now I remember why. We went last night. The restaurant was dirty...may have been all the french fries on the floor..... The service was good. We ordered a hamburger and a reuben. The $7.25 hamburger was fair if you're into frozen patties and not much else. The french fries were fried way to long. The reuben was awful. I think that a reuben is supposed to have sauerkraut, swiss cheese and corned beef, on grilled rye. The sandwich we received did have sauerkraut and grilled rye....that's about all. There was no discernable cheese and one thin Buddig type slice of corned beef. When the waiter came around we asked about it. He did go and bring a little more...very very disappointing. We ordered a black and tan sundae to take home. It might have been that. Couldn't tell for sure what it was. Packed in a styrofoam cup. I guess we should have eaten it there...but then there's those french fries on the floor to look at....Don't waste your time. We won't be back. Pros: the waiter brought water as we sat down Cons: food and cleanliness of store was AWFUL July 01, 2007 Best Banana Split by missamyq at Citysearch Its SO hard to not come here when its just a few blocks away from here. Its been a childhood favorite and...to adult I still come here and order from them. They hire the best people to work their that make you feel comfortable and make you feel at ease. Their burgers and fries are tasty and http://www.insiderpages.com/b/3711178877/leatherbys-family-creamery-sacramento[6/22/2011 2:03:40 PM] Exhibit 4 Page 127 Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 31 of 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Exhibit 4-28 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Exhibit to Pls.’ M emo in Supp. of M ot. for Summ. J. Exhibit 4 Page 128 Don'tBuyFromBigots.com 1 of 1 http://www.dontbuyfrombigots.com/album1_001.htm Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Home View the List Call to Action Faq's Volunteer Filed 08/25/11 Page 32 of 39 Contact On Election Day November 4, 2008, the most highly contested ballot measure in California was Proposition 8. Entitled “Eliminates the Right of Same-Sex Couples to Marry”, the purpose of Proposition 8 was to amend the state constitution to remove the constitutional right of gays and lesbians to marry. Proponents of Prop 8 waged a successful campaign to strip lesbian and gay citizens of their civil rights aided in large part to the nearly $40 million they raised. Many of these donations came from businesses throughout California and across the country. These businesses have the right to support whatever ballot measures they want, but fair-minded citizens of all sexual orientations also have the right to take their money elsewhere and not patronize businesses that support bigotry. This site is not a witch-hunt but is a tool intended to help people make informed decisions when they shop for products and services. This site hopes to overcome some of the limitations of existing Prop 8 donor databases on the web and in time hopes to become a useful repository of all companies in the U.S. with anti-gay policies. Using publicly available information from the California Secretary of State’s website, DontBuyFromBigots.com strives to be the most comprehensive business-specific listing of donors to Prop 8. This site is a work in progress created and maintained in the spare time of one person, so forgive the spartan appearance. Contact me if you want to help improve the website. Site designed by Lion Boddy Designs Copyright © All rights reserved. Exhibit 4 Page 129 7/16/2011 2:14 PM Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 33 of 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Exhibit 4-29 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Exhibit to Pls.’ M emo in Supp. of M ot. for Summ. J. Exhibit 4 Page 130 Five held on suspicion of stealing "Yes" on Prop. 8 signs | signs, macdonald, five - News - The Orange County Register Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 REAL ESTATE JOBS CARS DEALS CLASSIFIEDS PLACE AN AD SIGN-IN/SIGN-UP NEWS SPORTS BUSINESS SUBSCRIBE E-REGISTER CUSTOMER SERVICE TODAY'S PAPER SURF REPORT/CAMS | 63.0°F in Santa Ana | LIVE TRAFFIC NEWS HOME Filed 08/25/11 Page 34 of 39 ENTERTAINMENT LIFE TRAVEL OPINION Blogs | California | City-by-City News | Columns | Crime and Courts | Data Central | Education | Immigration | Military | Nation | Obituaries Text: | OC Watchdog | Photos | Politics and Government | Science | Technology | Videos | World Published: Oct. 21, 2008 3:00 a.m. Five held on suspicion of stealing "Yes" on Prop. 8 signs Story Highlights Suspects tell police they were angry after attending a rally at a Fullerton bar. By BARBARA GIASONE The Orange County Register Next Article » Tweet Recommend 3 Share ARTICLE FULLERTON - Five people were arrested early today on suspicion of participating in a sign-stealing spree the suspects said originated in a downtown bar, Sgt. Mike MacDonald said. A police officer patrolling the area near Chapman and Pomona avenues at 1:30 a.m. saw a passenger jump from a car and place a campaign sign on the corner. When the officer approached the driver, she noticed three "No on Prop 8" signs in the vehicle. She also located 10 torn-up "Yes on 8" signs on the front floorboard with three McCain-Palin signs. ADVERTISEMENT The Vintage Steakhouse 50% off! $30 for $60 Certificate at The Vintage Steakhouse! Like ADVERTISEMENT The "Yes on 8" signs were allegedly stolen and the "No on Prop 8" signs were not, police said. When questioned, the suspects said they had just come from a "No on 8" rally at a downtown business and were angry, MacDonald said. Based on their statements, all five were arrested on suspicion of possession of stolen property. Taken to city jail were Jonathan Barrett, 19, of Fullerton; Jennifer Berry, 23, Covina; Emanuel Muro, 23, Artesia; Daniel Palacios, 23, Lakewood; and Eric Gutierrez, 23, Fullerton. More from Fullerton 13 O.C. high schools named to Newsweek’s top 500 Police: Craigslist posting led to maid’s rape Recalls: Target, Macy's, Big Lots, Marshalls, T.J. Maxx COMMENTS | PRINT | EMAIL | MacDonald said all five admitted taking the signs. SHARE VIDEOS Latest More from Fullerton » Reader Comments Comments are encouraged, but you must follow our User Agreement. 1. Keep it civil and stay on topic. 2. No profanity, vulgarity, racial slurs or personal attacks. 3. People who harass others or joke about tragedies will be blocked. Buena Park soldier Christopher Fishbeck laid to rest Play Man eats ice cream sundae in 24 seconds Could more cuts be on the way for Costa Mesa? Play Play » MORE All videos | Your Videos | » Submit a video Exhibit 4 Page 131 http://www.ocregister.com/news/signs-124083-macdonald-five.html[6/21/2011 9:33:42 AM] Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 35 of 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Exhibit 4-30 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Exhibit to Pls.’ M emo in Supp. of M ot. for Summ. J. Exhibit 4 Page 132 Sheriff: Prop. 8 Signs Being Stolen, Burned - Sacramento News Story - KCRA Sacramento Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Home Weather Local News As Seen On KCRA CrimeTracker Morning News Quake Reports Slideshows National News Sports Entertainment u local Traffic Politics Community Money Health Food and Recipes Irresistible KQCA My58 Get Headlines Sent To Your Email Or Phone Enter Email Filed 08/25/11 Page 36 of 39 Site Search Web Local Businesses Hot Topics: Miss USA | Fitz Workouts A-Z: Uphill Training | Summer Fun As Seen On KCRA Homepage > SACRAMENTO NEWS Sheriff: Prop. 8 Signs Being Stolen, Burned Both Sides Of Gay-Marriage Initiative See Signs Destroyed Email Like KCRA on Facebook Sign Up 27K Create an account or log in to see what your friends are recommending. Print Recommend 'Judgment Day' Two Days Away 249 people recommend this. POSTED: 9:31 pm PDT October 19, 2008 UPDATED: 12:08 am PDT October 20, 2008 SACRAMENTO, Calif. -- As the days leading up to Election Day dwindle down, signs on both sides of the gay-marriage initiative are being stolen, and in some cases even burned, sheriff's officials said. Hector Lluen said that a "Yes" on Prop. 8 sign nailed to the front of his Fair Oaks home door was stolen in the middle of the night. "My family and I strongly believe that their acts are cowardly," Lluen said. "It is not going to intimidate my family. We will continue to put up 'yes' on Prop. 8 signs." Some supporters of the vote "No" on Prop. 8 campaign said those stealing signs are just hurting their own cause. Summer Advertise With Us Deal Center A-List "If someone is doing it on our side it needs to stop, and if someone is doing it on their side that needs to stop as well," said David Cano, who supports the "No" on Prop. 8 campaign. Related POLITICAL SIGNS Green Pages Automotive Cash For Appliances Technology Family Dating Sacramento Jobs Real Estate House and Home Education Travel Grow Your Business Coupons SureWest Yellow Pages Some voters who have had their signs stolen said it feels like getting mugged. "I feel disenfranchised," said Linda Subramanian, who had her political sign stolen. "That was my sign. That was my political expression." In Midtown, voters are coming together to urge those breaking the law to have a better approach. "You got to vote, that's where you make your opinion count," said voter Megan Evans. Most Read Most Watched Most Commented Rising Heat Sends Children To Hospital Panhandling Scam Stretches Across Central California Expensive Lemons: Used Car Prices To Rise 2-Alarm Fire Guts Sacramento Building Related Story: » More Most Popular October 19, 2008: Survey: Race For Prop. 8 'Essentially Tied' Copyright 2008 by KCRA.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. Recommend Video: Political Sign Vandalism Rising, Sheriff Says Sign Up to see what your friends recommend. Gear Stolen During Fire Call Police Respond To McDonald's Shooting Afghan Farmers Need Opium Crops Police: Baby Scammers Hit Around The Valley » More Most Popular » More Most Popular Pictures In The News America's 20 Dirtiest Cities FDA Unveils Graphic Exhibit 4 Page 133 http://www.kcra.com/news/17758850/detail.html[6/21/2011 9:38:54 AM] 10 Cities With The Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Filed 08/25/11 Page 37 of 39 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Exhibit 4-31 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Exhibit to Pls.’ M emo in Supp. of M ot. for Summ. J. Exhibit 4 Page 134 Sacto 9-1-1: Arrests made in Roseville after Yes on Proposition 8 signs found in car Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 Sign In Join Reader Services Filed 08/25/11 Page 38 of 39 Subscribe to The Bee TODAY Site Feedback Stay Connected Sacto 9-1-1 News Business Capitol & California Our Region Sports Local Medical Boomers Obituaries Environment Living Here Data Center Entertainment Investigations 65° F Weather | Traffic Opinion Nation/World Cars Topics Wednesday, March 2, 2011 Jobs Homes Classifieds Blogs/Columnists Find n Save ROSEVILLE TOYOTA Web search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH Subscribe to this blog's feed Most Wanted | Crimemapper | Arrest Logs | Crime databases | Crime News | Ask Sacto 9-1-1 October 28, 2008 Arrests made in Roseville after Yes on Proposition 8 signs found in car From David Richie: Roseville police arrested a man and two women early today who were reportedly stealing "Yes on Proposition 8" signs from residents' yards. Officers recovered 53 signs from the suspects' vehicle - all in support of Proposition 8, said Dee Dee Gunther, police department spokeswoman. The arrests occurred about 12:32 a.m. after a resident in the 200 block of Sierra Boulevard spotted someone taking a sign out of a neighbor's yard. A few minutes later an officer spotted a green sedan, matching the description of the suspect vehicle in the 700 block of Shasta Street. All four doors and the trunk were open and the officer watched as two people walked to the car and placed something in the trunk. The car then drove away but was stopped by police. Police arrested Brian Joseph Greene (left photo), 18 of Roseville, Kacey Elizabeth Flieder (right photo), 18, of Sacramento and a 17-year-old girl from Roseville. The 18-year-olds were booked on suspicion of possession of stolen property, conspiracy, petty theft and contributing to the delinquency of a minor. The 17-year-old was cited and released to her parents. CONTACT US Send feedback on Sacto 9-1-1 to Assistant Metro Editor Anthony Sorci at asorci@sacbee.com Subscribe to Breaking News Alerts AREA'S MOST WANTED See photos and descriptions of the most wanted suspects from local, state and federal law enforcement Karen England, a local coordinator for the Yes on 8 campaign said theft and vandalism of Proposition 8 signs has become a continuing problem. In some cases, signs have been stolen multiple times. Proposition 8 backers along Misty Creek Drive, off Foothills Boulevard, have started bringing their signs in at night ARREST LOGS El Dorado Exhibit 4 Page 135 http://blogs.sacbee.com/crime/archives/2008/10/post-13.html[6/21/2011 9:42:26 AM] Sacto 9-1-1: Arrests made in Roseville after Yes on Proposition 8 signs found in car but recently they also have experienced spray paint vandalism as well as sign theft. Case 2:09-cv-00058-MCE -DAD Document 247-2 PlacervillePage 39 of 39 Filed 08/25/11 South Lake Tahoe "This has been happening all over Roseville," England said, noting that she has filed two police reports related to theft of signs from her yard. Her organization recently posted a $1,000 reward for information leading the arrest of sign thieves and vandals, England said. Categories: Arrests Tags: Campaign signs Posted by Anthony Sorci 11:01 AM | 0 Comments | Like Sort newest first Sortbyby newest first Citrus Heights Elk Grove Folsom Galt Isleton Rancho Cordova Sacramento Yolo Davis Woodland West Sacramento M Subscribe by email S RSS Real-time updating is enabled. (Pause) Add New Comment Auburn Colfax Lincoln Loomis Rocklin Roseville Sacramento Share Showing 0 comments Placer Login Arrest reports provided by LocalCrimeNews.com TAG CLOUD Please wait… Arrest Arrests Arson Assault Bank robbery Body found Burglary Court sentencing Crime Alert Drugs Fire blog comments powered by DISQUS Homicide Missing person Robbery Sexual assault Shooting Shots fired Stabbing Traffic accident traffic fatalities FOLLOW US | Get more from sacbee.com SACTO 9-1-1 Q&A Q: Is Mitchell Patterson from Lincoln Calif still in prison for killing his Daughter on I-80 back in 1993. A: Mitchell Patterson remains in state prison, almost two decades after he killed his daughter by pulling her in front of a big-rig truck. Patterson, now 54, grabbed his 10-year-old daughter, Andreana, and threw her in front of a truck on Interstate 80 near Truckee in March 1993. During the trial in Nevada County, jurors heard that Patterson wanted to kill himself and take his daughter with him. They also heard that Patterson -- a smallbusiness owner who once headed the Lincoln chapter of Ross Perot's United We Stand organization -- had a history of being abusive to his wives. Patterson is at the California Men's Colony in San Luis Obispo. Exhibit 4 Page 136 http://blogs.sacbee.com/crime/archives/2008/10/post-13.html[6/21/2011 9:42:26 AM]
