Michigan Golf 2009 - Golf Association of Michigan
Transcription
Michigan Golf 2009 - Golf Association of Michigan
$2.95 NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2009 WWW.GAM.ORG The Big Picture: Michigan Golf 2009 the good, the bad, and the ugly Plus: Understanding the Handicap Committee The Buick Open’s Lasting Legacy Tournament Highlights 00_COVER_FINAL_Garland.indd 1 10/27/09 1:41:20 PM Golfers at over 175 golf clubs and courses have helped Rally spread awareness about breast cancer in Michigan. have you? Alpena Golf Course Ann Arbor Country Club Ann Arbor Golf & Outing Club Bay Harbor Golf Club Beacon Hill Golf Club Bear Lake County Highlands Golf Course Bloomfield Hills Country Club Blossom Trails Golf Club Blythefield Country Club Boulder Lakes Golf Club Boyne Mountain Resort Briar Hill Golf Course Brookside Golf Course Brookwood Golf Course Burning Tree Golf & Country Club Canadian Lakes Country Club Candlestone Inn Cascade Golf Course Centennial Country Club Champion Hill Golf Club Charlevoix Golf & Country Club Chestnut Hills Golf Course Clor’s Outposts Copper Ridge Golf Club Country Club of Detroit Crestview Golf Course Crown Golf Course Crystal Downs Country Club Dearborn Country Club Deer Run Golf Club Detroit Golf Club Drummond Island Golf Club Eagle Crest Golf Course Eastern Hills Golf Club Elk Rapids Golf Club Elmbrook Golf Course Emerald Vale Golf Club Fairview Hills Golf Course Farmington Hills Golf Club Faulkwood Shores Golf Course Fenton Farms Golf Club Fox Run Country Club Franklin Hills Country Club Garland Golf Resort Gaylord Country Club Golden Sands Golf Course Goodrich Country Club Gowanie Golf Club Grayling Country Club Great Oaks Country Club Green Briar Golf Course Green Oaks Golf Course Green Valley Golf Club Greenbush Golf Course Hankerd Hills Golf Course Hartland Glen Golf Course Hiawatha Sportsman’s Club Hidden Valley Golf Club Highland Hills Golf Club Highland Hills Golf Course Hillsdale Golf & Country Club Hilltop Golf Course Hudson Mills Metropark Huntersridge Golf Course Huron Breeze Golf Club Huron Shores Golf Club Huron Valley Women’s Golf Club Indian Lake Golf & Country Club Indianwood Golf & Country Club Iron River Country Club L’Anse Golf Club Lake Forest Golf Club Lakelands Golf & Country Club Lakeview Hills Country Club Lakewood Shores Resort Lincoln Golf Course Lochmoor Country Club Lost lake Woods Club Manistee National Golf & Resort Maple Grove Golf Course Maple Hill Golf Club Maple Ridge Golf Club Maples of Novi Country Club Marquette Golf & Country Club Marysville Golf Course Marywood Golf Club Meadowbrook Country Club Midland Country Club Missaukee Golf Course Morrison Lake Country Club Mulberry Fore Golf Course Munoscong Golf Club Mystic Creek Golf Club New Hawthorne Valley Golf Course Newberry Country Club Northport Point Golf Club Northville Hills Golf Club Oak Lane Golf Course Oak Pointe Country Club Oak Ridge Golf Club Oakhurst Golf & Country Club Oakland Hills Country Club Oakland University Golf & Learning Center Old Channel Trail Golf Course Orchard Lake Country Club Overbrook Golf Course Paint Creek Country Club Pebblewood Country Club Pictured Rocks Golf & Country Club Pine View Golf Club Pine View Highlands Golf Course Plum Hollow Country Club Pointe Aux Barques Golf Course Pontiac Municipal Golf Course Port Huron Golf Club Preserve Golf Club Quincy Golf Course Railside Golf Club Rammler Golf Club Ravines Golf Club Red Fox Run Golf Club Reddeman Farms Golf Course River’s Edge Golf Course Rustic Glen Golf Club Saginaw Country Club Sand Wedge Golf Course Sault St. Marie Country Club Scenic Golf & Country Club Shanty Creek Golf Course Shenandoah Country Club Silver Lake Country Club Somerset Golf Club Southgate Municipal Golf Course Spring Lake Country Club Spring Meadows Country Club Springport Hills Golf Course States Golf Course StoneWater Country Club Stoney Links Sugar Springs Country Club Sugarloaf Golf Course Tanglewood Golf Club The Dream The Fortress The Heathers Club The Highlands Golf Club The Leelanau Club at Bahles Farms The Lynx of Allegan The Prairies The Quest at Houghton Lake The Wyndgate Golf & Country Club Thunder Bay Golf Resort Tomac Woods Golf Course Travis Pointe Country Club Twin Lakes Golf & Swim Club Ubly Heights Golf Course Vassar Golf & Country Club Verona Hills Golf Club Village Green Golf Club Walloon Lake Country Club Warwick Hills Golf & Country Club Water’s Edge Country Club Wawonowin Country Club White Lake Oaks Golf Course White Pine National Golf Club Willow Springs Golf & Country Club Wolf Creek Golf Club Ye Nyne Olde Holles Golf Club host a rally For thE CUrE® golF EVENt aND JoIN othErs IN yoUr statE Who haVE MaDE a CoMMItMENt to thE FIght agaINst BrEast CaNCEr. For more information or to secure your date call 1.800.327.6811 or email info@rallyforthecure.com. Rally for the Cure ® and the Running Ribbon are registered trademarks of Susan G. Komen for the Cure ® . vol. 11 no. four Special Report michigan golf 2009: the good, the bad, and the ugly 13 the big picture Contents Private clubs struggle to retain members, resorts fight for a share of tourism dollars, and rumors (mostly false) fly about bankruptcies and closings. So was all gloom and doom in Michigan? It depends on where you look and whom you talk to. Michigan Links provides a special regional roundup to find out how a cross-section of golf facilities are working to weather the economic storm. 14 weather and the economy’s one-two punch hit up north The Michigan economy is leading clubs such as Thunder Bay Resort (above) to rely on non-golf revenue. Meanwhile, Garland Resort (on the cover) has new ownership. 15 “pure michigan” is a ray of Departments 17 necessity drives invention Features 9 Season Highlights The GAM adds Forecaddie GAM/Detroit News Hole-in-One Contest participants donate more net events for “the rest of us,” plus $4,000 to Folds of Honor Foundation, all the 2009 GAM season champions and you need to know about the Handicap Players of the Year. Committee, new “Exclusive Tee Times” 24 Buick Open’s Lasting Legacy benefit gives GAM members access to For more than 50 years, the Buick Open private clubs, easy online renewal for was a PGA Tour mainstay. Here are 2010, and more. eight great moments and personalities. 7 Tee Party GAM Member Relations Day at Western G&CC. 3 sunshine in metropolitan detroit 18 half empty ... and half full in west michigan 20 new approaches to survival in michigan’s midsection 22 weather takes edge off upper peninsula’s growing reputation above photo courtesy of thunder bay resort. bottom photo courtesy of gowanie golf club. Gowanie Golf Club’s “Stag Day, 1949.” The club celebrates its 100th anniversary next year. 26 Rules & Etiquette What do you do when a cart path interferes with your stance, swing, or lie? The “immovable obstruction” rule has the answers. 28 Links to the Past Gowanie Golf Club celebrates its 100th anniversary next year. The Mount Clemens-area “hidden jewel” was originally known as Riverview GC, and its rich history includes being one of the GAM’s original 14 member clubs. On the Cover: Garland Resort’s Monarch course Photo by Joann Dost 01_TOC.indd 1 10/27/09 1:46:44 PM official publication of the golf association of michigan Golf Association of Michigan 24116 Research Drive | Farmington Hills, MI 48335 Phone: 248-478-9242 Fax: 248-478-5536 | www.gam.org editor & publisher Tonia J. Branch Officers president William F. Wright vice president J. Lee Juett vice president Rondal Gaines vice president John Schulte treasurer Lloyd A. Schwartz secretary Richard Topp assistant secretary James R. Kohl General Counsel Harrison C. Stackpole, Ogne, Alberts & Stuart, P.C. Presidents Emeritus Dr. Walter Albers Fritz Balmer Donald J. Barrett Paul F. Beaupre Thomas W. Chisholm Victor S. Cuiss David C. Devendorf Jere B. Gillette Neil J. MacPhee Robert L. McMasters Thomas M. Murphy Jeanne Myers John F. O’Donovan Dr. Richard A. Papp William A. Prew David F. Rentschler Lewis A. Rockwell John D. Standish James H. Stevens Wallace G. Wheeler Staff executive director David Graham assistant executive director Tonia Branch manager of member services & communications michiganlinks@gam.org associate publisher Edward J. Peabody epeabody@hour-media.com managing editor Steve Wilke swilke@hour-media.com art director Jennifer Arnone Susan Smiley jarnone@hour-media.com handicap & membership associate account manager Molly Smith Mary-Jo Green msmith@hour-media.com director of course rating & member services copy editor Anne Berry Daugherty Doug Hendershot production director Trudie Cloyd director of finance Jan Qualtiere senior production artist Eric Weir event coordinator/ executive assistant production artist Rosie Rockov senior director of rules & competitions Robert Gorczyca senior advertising designer John Tenney Ken Hartmann advertising designer assistant director of rules & competitions — rules Megan DeKok Jeanne Myers assistant director of rules & competitions — juniors Chris Mills web consultant Smith Patterson contributing writers Jack Berry, Ron Gaines, David Graham, Dennis Grall, Greg Johnson, Vartan Kupelian, Tom Lang, Jeanne Myers, Norm Sinclair contributing artists Joann Dost, Carrie Hall, Jose Juarez, Kyle Raetz, Dave Richards, Dave Troppens address editorial comments to tonia branch — golf association of michigan Board of Governors Gary H. Adelman John W. Allen Barry J. Andrews Christopher Angott John T. Barbour David Baughman Thomas Bollinger Steve Braun Inez Bridges Robert Buckley Danielle Buth David G. Cameron James Champion Pat DeMaire Frederic Devendorf Charles H. Edwards James Evanoff A.J. Galsterer Jr. Bill Hartwig Thomas J. Hicks Doug Hinton James F. Judge Cathy Kalahar Mick Kildea James A. Koepke Roger Kuhl Pam Kurtz Linda T. Lester Mark McAlpine Brian E. Mills Terry Moore Timothy Moore Jean Murray Robert Nowikowski Cynthia Pinkard David Price John Rowlands James E. Russell Donald R. Schepers Harrison Stackpole John B. Tomey Stephen Varga Marvin N. Weinstein Sara Wold Betty Woods Michigan Links is the official publication of the Golf Association of Michigan, a not-for-profit organization serving all golfers in Michigan. The text, opinions, and views expressed within this publication do not necessarily reflect the opinions or the official policies of the Golf Association of Michigan, editor and publisher. No part of this magazine is intended as an endorsement of any equipment, publication, videotape, Web site, golf course, or other entity. No part of this magazine may be reproduced for any reason without prior written approval from the GAM. The Association does not sell, rent, or otherwise release its mailing list of GAM Individual and Club Members. We welcome all editorial submissions but assume no responsibility for the loss or damage of any unsolicited material. They will not be returned unless accompanied by a self-addressed, stamped envelope. 24116 Research Drive Farmington Hills, MI 48335 Phone: 248-478-9242 Fax: 248-478-5536 for advertising, please call Jason Hosko jhosko@hour-media.com Phone: 248-691-1800, ext. 126 ad coordinator Sheryl Vallus svallus@hour-media.com 248-691-1800, ext. 128 hour media, l.l.c. ceo Stefan Wanczyk president John Balardo Michigan Links ISSN 1531-1732 (U.S.P.S. No. 018-935) is published four times annually (March/April, May/June, July/August and November/December) by the Golf Association of Michigan. Periodical postage paid at Farmington Hills, MI 48331 and additional mailing offices. Single copies are available through the GAM for $2.95. Postmaster: Send address changes to: Michigan Links, 24116 Research Drive, Farmington Hills, MI 48335, 248-478-9242. All GAM members should receive Michigan Links. Copyright © 2009, Golf Association of Michigan. Products and services mentioned in this publication may be trademarks of their respective companies. 2 117 West Third St., Royal Oak, MI 48067 Phone: 248-691-1800 Fax: 248-691-4531 MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 02_GAM_Board_Masthead copy.indd 1 10/27/09 1:48:30 PM photographs by carrie hall. Forecaddie At this year’s GAM/Detroit News Hole-in-One Contest, participants were given the option to donate $10 for an extra two shots. The event raised $4,000 for the Folds of Honor Foundation. Major Ed Pulido (above right), a retired U.S. Army veteran who lost a leg during duty in Iraq, was on hand to explain the foundation’s goal to provide scholarships to spouses and children of military service members disabled or killed in service. Since 2007, the foundation has raised more than $3 million and provided nearly 600 scholarships. news & notes | events | gam benefits teeing it up for patriot First Tee Helping golf Youth day Perfect weather — and a good cause — drew a healthy crowd of hole-in-one hopefuls to Whispering Willows GC. 03_Forecaddie_intro_.indd 1 10/27/09 1:50:09 PM Forecaddie news | handicap Handicap Committee Have you ever heard the phrase, “Golf is a game of honor?” Not just hollow words to most of us. We’re expected to call penalties on ourselves and question others. We have no problem asking a fellow competitor to recount his strokes, or keeping an eye on a member of our group as he takes a drop from a water hazard. We “protect the field” by monitoring the actions of others, and at the end of the round place an attesting signature on a scorecard. We seem to have no problem applying “peer review” to a tournament or two-dollar Nassau, but when it comes to handicapping, it’s a different story. The code of honesty and integrity that levels the playing field seems to fall apart. The game’s code of honor means that even a hint of dishonesty or cheating can’t be accepted. But we seem to have trouble asking whether a round was posted for handicap purposes or if Equitable Stroke Control was applied properly. Like the Rules of Golf, such serious infractions can’t be ignored. If so, the sense of honor as it applies to handicapping is challenged. Protecting the Game’s Integrity Why the breakdown in “peer review,” and what can a Handicap Committee do about it? The Handicap Committee is one of the most important committees at a golf club, ensuring fair play. But making sure the system works correctly doesn’t start with the committee; it starts with each member and peer review. In most cases, that’s where the breakdown occurs. If you look at the results of your tournaments and constantly see the same names, it’s time to act. Every member needs to feel he has a chance to win as he steps to the first tee, but for some, the need to win supersedes the need for integrity. That’s why it’s important to develop a strong Handicap Committee, with the support of each member. The authority of your club to issue and update USGA Handicap Indexes rests with them. 4 Think of a Handicap Index as a letter of introduction presented by a stranger you meet at the first tee. The club they belong to vouches for the accuracy of the index. If that player were to play an event at your club with a Handicap Index that didn’t actually match his playing ability, it would reflect negatively on his home club. It’s up to the Handicap Committee — and each member — to protect the club’s integrity. The Committee’s ‘Power’ Once the Handicap Committee has been formed and problems identified, it’s important for the Board and other committees to let the Handicap Committee function independently. The question then becomes: What circumstances should result in an adjustment to a player’s Handicap Index? There are two committees at your club that have the power to adjust a player’s handicap. The first is an adjustment made by a Tournament Committee. This is an adjustment made only to a player’s Course Handicap for a temporary period of time, and is the only adjustment that a tournament committee can make. The second type of adjustment is to a player’s Handicap Index. This adjustment is the most severe, and can only be made by the player’s Handicap Committee. Adjusting an Index The USGA Handicap Manual is pretty definite in this area. Remember, no one is entitled to a Handicap Index, so there are six circumstances in Section 8-4c when a committee must make adjustments to an index. Most would consider the first three of these benign: (i) a player improves faster that the system can react, (ii) a temporary disability, or (iii) if numerous away scores are posted, which changes an index. The next two are more strongly worded: (iv) failure to post scores, and (v) player manipulation of rounds. The provisions under (iv) allow the committee to post the score or a penalty score for an individual who fails to post or otherwise does not observe the spirit of the Handicap System. Under the provisions found in (v) the committee must adjust or withdraw the Handicap Index of a player for (a) posting erroneous scores, (b) stopping play to avoid posting, (c) playing more that one ball to avoid posting, (d) not adjusting hole scores under Section 4, (e) deliberately reporting more or fewer strokes than actually scored, or (f) deliberately taking extra strokes to inflate a score. The most serious violation is found in (vi), and it encourages a Handicap Committee to withdraw the index of a player who continues to post scores that are unacceptable for handicap purposes. Before making any adjustments, the committee needs to gather all information, including statements of other players. Just as in our legal system, each golfer is considered innocent until proven otherwise, so the committee must give the player the opportunity to present evidence either in person or in writing before an adjustment is made under Section 8-4b. Handled properly, the committee gives the club the ability to attest to the validity of each member’s index, and is the reason each club needs a strong and vigilant committee to safeguard golf’s code of honor. photograph courtesy of istock. by ron gaines, gam handicap chair MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 04_Forecaddie.indd 1 10/27/09 1:51:21 PM news | milestones Forecaddie It’s Easy to Renew! sign up online for your 2010 gam membership common misconceptions Two of the most common misconceptions a committee must deal with are: photographs courtesy of istock. 1. A score doesn’t have to be posted if it is just a casual round. 2. A score doesn’t have to be posted if it wasn’t played on your home course. Both are incorrect assumptions. A Handicap Index reflects a player’s potential ability. The only valid reflection of a player’s potential ability comes from posting all scores. The second misconception — that a player can have an index based just on home course scores — goes to the core of the regulations under which Handicap Indexes are computed. Section 1-1 in the manual states in part “that each player will try to make the best score at every hole in every round, regardless of where the round is played, and that the player will post every acceptable round for peer review. The player and the player’s Handicap Committee have a joint responsibility for adhering to these premises.” If your home club uses an index computed from just home or tournament scores it’s not following the spirit or guidelines of the USGA Handicap System. In most cases, clubs that use this method do so because they either do not have a Handicap Committee or the committee is so weak that it becomes a method of last resort. GAM members from public clubs and former private club members wishing to maintain their Handicap Index can sign up now for a 2010 GAM Gold Card membership. Current GAM members can renew their existing membership by clicking on “Member Login,” found at www. gam.org. Also starting Dec. 1, 2009: GAM members leaving their private club can transfer their membership — including their scoring record — by logging into “Member Login” and selecting the “transfer” button. In addition to posting your scores and maintaining your official GAM/ USGA Handicap Index, your 2010 GAM Gold Card membership entitles you to numerous Swing & Save discounts (there were some 215 offers for 2009), a one-year subscription to Golf Digest, the opportunity to play in GAM tournaments, plus a chance to play in GAM Golf Days and book “Exclusive Tee Times” online at www.gam.org at select private, resort, and public clubs, and much, much more. The GAM’s online score-posting system features a handicap “trend index” that updates as you post scores, in addition to an official Handicap Index which updates on scheduled revision dates. To renew your GAM Gold Card membership, visit www.gam.org. new exclusive tee times benefit gets early thumbs-up Numerous GAM members took a “test drive” when the GAM launched its newest member benefit in September: the ability to book tee times online. Select private clubs set aside blocks of tee times exclusively for GAM members. The GAM plans to expand the program to public courses and resorts next season. Early results were very positive. Members were able to visit the GAM Web site to see a listing of tee times set aside exclusively for them at select private clubs. The entire process is easy: just log in, go to “tee times” on the toolbar, find a tee time that fits into your schedule, book it, and pay for it — all in one convenient step. The price includes golf, cart, and driving range (if available). This new program is a great opportunity for GAM members to play different courses and experience the benefits of private club membership. Visit www.gam.org during the “off-season” for more information about the expansion of this program. But please, do not call the clubs directly. If you have any questions about this new program, call the GAM membership department at (248) 478-9242, ext. 19. NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2009 04_Forecaddie.indd 2 5 10/27/09 1:52:18 PM more opportunities, more participants by david graham Wabeek CC was an ‘Exclusive Tee Time’ particpant. We are all too aware of the economic challenges virtually everyone has faced this past year in Michigan. Unless you are in the foreclosure business or the moving business, you have felt the pinch. Despite these challenges, the GAM had a reasonably strong 2009. Our membership actually increased over 2008 … not a lot, but an increase is still meaningful. We also saw an increase in tournament participation, with more than 3,000 competitors entering GAM events in 2009. Part of the increase was due to adding two new events to our schedule — Boy’s Stroke Play and Men’s Senior Match Play. Again, the increase was not huge, and average participation per event was flat year-over-year, but it’s still progress. We also increased opportunities for members to play more great golf for less. There were 215 Swing & Save offers, where members could show their GAM Gold Card and receive special offers. We also increased opportunities for members to play great courses through “GAM Golf Days” and a pilot program introdced this fall, “Exclusive Tee Times.” In its second year, GAM Golf Days 6 have proven to be a smashing success. We increased the number of days to 15 this year, from nine in 2008, and we had more than 1,100 participants — double the participants in the first year. In September, we launched a pilot project that is an extension of GAM Golf Days. Six private GAM member clubs permitted GAM members to purchase tee times at their facilities through our Web site, www.gam.org. While the day didn’t include a chance to participate in a competition, as in the GAM Golf Day, you and your golf buddies could sign up for tee times at great facilities, including Grosse Ile G&CC, The Wyndgate, Davison CC, Boulder Lakes GC, Western G&CC, and Wabeek CC. We will review the results of this pilot to determine if we should continue the program for 2010, possibly on an even larger scale. At the GAM, we remain committed to providing ways for our members to play more golf at more Michigan facilities than ever before. Thank you for your support. Let’s hope for a short winter and a warm spring! David Graham is executive director of the GAM. Osprey Group Provides More Scholarships GAM corporate sponsor Osprey Recreational Properties is in the process of awarding several more $2,000 scholarships to GAM junior golfers. Osprey began awarding the scholarships in 2006. Four junior golfers receive these renewable scholarships. WGA Names Kaczkowski President/CEO The Western Golf Association has named John Kaczkowski to be its next president and CEO. He succeeds Don Johnson, who held the post for the past 21 years. Kaczkowski joined the WGA in 1998 and became its tournament director in 2000. He will head management of both the WGA and the Evans Scholars Foundation for caddies. Michigan Courses Get Noticed Golf Digest named Ann Arbor’s Leslie Park Golf Course as the state’s “best municipal” course for 2009. It earned a 4.5-star rating. Meanwhile, Forest Dunes Golf Club, the 7,141-yard Tom Weiskopf design in Roscommon, was selected as the best public course in America in a national vote by readers of Golf World magazine. Think Spring! West Michigan Golf Show For more than 20 years, West Michigan has started the golf season off with the West Michigan Golf Show. Top equipment dealers, courses, and resorts from around the country, and more — all make their way to Grand Rapids. DeVos Place will once again host the event, scheduled for Feb. 12-14, 2010. Don’t forget, GAM members can receive a discount to the show. Go to www.gam.org for details. photograph courtesy of wabeek country club. Forecaddie news | milestones Good Golf Despite Tough Times milestones MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 04_Forecaddie.indd 3 10/27/09 1:53:01 PM Forecaddie photographs by carrie hall. news | milestones Forecaddie gam member relations day The 2009 GAM Member Relations Day — held on Sept. 11 at Western Golf & County Club in Redford — was a big success, raising $14,240, which was split between the Michigan Turgrass Foundation and The Evans Scholars Foundation. After a fun team-oriented day of golf at the Donald Ross-designed course — including entry into hole-in-one contests — participants bid on specially donated auction items, including rounds of golf at premium sites. The evening included dinner, the silent auction, and a raffle. Bob Buckley, Dave Baughman, and Ron Gaines Ken Juroff, Frank Guerro, Adrian Lyman, and Frank Jacoboni Francine Pegues, Pat Shelton, and Cynthia Pinkard Bidding on silent auction items don’t let varicose veins ruin your game. Wear shorts again. Have your legs treated in under an hour using the latest technology with no downtime, no scarring, and NO STRIPPING. BeFoRe BeFoRe aFteR You may have a medical condition covered by insurance known as Venous Insufficiency if you experience any of these leg symptoms: • Pain/Aching/Throbbing of Legs • Heaviness or leg fatigue • Swelling of feet/ankles • Restless legs • Night cramps • Itchy veins • Varicose veins • Non-healing ulcers JeffreY H. mIller, mD /PSUIXFTUFSO)JHIXBZt4PVUImFME tXXXKSEFUSPJUDPN 0901-018 Golf Magazine Ad For Detroit.indd 1 04_Forecaddie.indd 4 3/19/09 2:15:09 PM BoaRd CeRtiFied iNteRveNtioNal RadiologiSt BoARd ceRTIfIed PHLeBoLogIST 46325 W. 12 Mile Road aFteR NeW TreATmeNT advanced vein therapies is the only provider of veinwave™ in the state of Michigan, a new safe and effective treatment of rosacea and facial veins. 248.344.9110 Suite 335 Novi www.AVtherapies.com West of Novi Road near i-96 NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2009 7 10/27/09 1:53:37 PM T H E O N LY C OUN T RY C LU B ON SKIS! B E S T T E R R A I N P A R K I N T H E M I D W E S T • 31 R UN S /5 L I F T S • 3 R E S TAU R A N T S C R O S S C OUN T RY S K I I NG • S NO W S H O E I NG • H E AT E D O U T D O O R P O O L S AUNA • E X E R C I S E F AC I L I T I E S The Otsego Ski Club is the perfect destination for families looking to create memories that will last a lifetime. We offer the best terrain park in the Midwest, a safe, family friendly rd d environment, no lift lines, as well as expert ski & snowboard instruction. There is something for everyone from thee youngest ones learning to ski all the way to the most seasoned skiers/boarders looking for some of the best groomed and challenging terrain in Michigan. Our commitment to providing our members with the best skiing/snowboarding experience will create a one of a kind experience for your family and friends. T E S T D R I V E M E M B E R S H I P S A VA I L A B L E ! Become a part of one of the best kept secrets in northern Michigan! For additional information, please contact our Director of Member Services, Liesel McNeil at 800.752.5510 ext. 327 or lmcneil@otsegoclub.com. 696 M32 East • Gaylord • otsegoclub.com We Are Michigan Golf. Britney Hamilton took the Michigan Women’s Amateur crown in dramatic fashion. Tom Werkmeister bested the field to win his first Michigan Amateur title. Veterans, Rookies, Playoffs, and More Cap GAM Championship Season photographs courtesy of jose juarez, dave troppens, and the famly of christine meier. From the early May qualifiers for the Michigan Amateur to October’s finale at the GAM Tournament of Club Champions, the GAM continued to administer some of the best-run amateur tournaments in the country. The 2009 season was filled with action-packed moments, including victories by veterans and rookies — plus a few tense playoffs. At the 98th Michigan Amateur at Spring Meadows CC, Tom Werkmeister — who lost in last year’s semifinal match — was on a mission. The 41-year-old from Kentwood got his season off to a good start, winning his second Horton Smith Invitational title (he won in 2005) at Detroit Golf Club in May. At the Michigan Amater, he bested a host of college-aged competitors — including Battle Creek native and U-M golfer Matt Thompson 3 and 2 in the title match. “Greg Davies was my inspiration,” Werkmeister said. “He won the tournament when he was 38 and that made me think that maybe I can win at 41.” Meanwhile, Britney Hamilton capped a come-from-behind run to sink a 19-foot putt on the 18th hole to win the 93rd Michigan Women’s Amateur at Great Oaks CC. “This is the first championship I’ve won since high school, and my first match play championship ever,” said the Western Michigan University golfer after her backand-forth final match against MSU golfer and Mount Pleasant native Natalie Brehm. It was a satisfying, if less dramatic, victory for Chris Mory (Haslett) at the 88th GAM Christine Meier Championship at Travis Pointe CC. A birdie on the 17th hole put him four strokes ahead of his closest competitor on the final day. Mory, a sophomore on the MSU golf team, shot 69s in the first two rounds. On the junior front, it was a 2-for-1 for Devon Compton of Rochester. She took top stroke play and match play spots at the 31st Michigan Girls Junior Amateur. Petoskey’s Joey Garber split the take at the Michigan Junior State Amateur, winning the stroke play portion of the event, defending his title from last year. Jordan Fletcher prevailed in match play. At the Tournament of Club Champions, Stacy Slobodnik-Stoll (Haslett) took the women’s honors, while Greg Reynolds (Flint) won the men’s event in a playoff. The longest playoff of the championship season came during the 18th GAM Women’s Championship at Battle Creek CC. Christine Meier (Rochester Hills) won in dramatic fashion, sinking her putt on the fourth playoff hole to defeat Darby Peters (Lake Orion). It was a “deja-vu” moment: The high school rivals met in a four-hole playoff in a tournament last year. Meier won that battle, as well. Meier capped the year by taking top individual honors and leading Rochester High to an MHSAA Division 1 championship. See page 10 for a complete list of GAM Championship winners. For more season highlights and results, go to www.gam.org. NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2009 9_GAM Highlights.indd 1 9 10/27/09 1:54:35 PM 2009 GAM Championship Results Tournament/Sponsor Champion(s) 38th Fuller Cup Matches Oakland Hills CC (North Course) GAM Team 1st GAM Senior Match Play Port Huron GC (Presented by: Buick Open) Bill Zylstra 11th GAM Women’s Mid-Am Western G&CC (Presented by: Nationwide Insurance) Stacy Slobodnik-Stoll Each year the GAM tallies up its Honor Roll for amateur golfers. The top point-getters are crowned Player of the Year (POY). For 2009, there are some new — and a lot of familiar — faces. 98th Michigan Amateur Tom Werkmeister Spring Meadows CC (Presented by: Osprey Recreational) 8th Michigan Women’s Senior Am Barb Schmid Hawk Hollow GC (Presented by: Hometown Newspapers) 31st Michigan Girls Junior State Amateur CC of Jackson (Presented by: Osprey Recreational) Devon Compton (Stroke Play) Devon Compton (Match Play) 93rd Michigan Women’s Amateur Great Oaks CC (Presented by: Buick Open) Britney Hamilton 31st Michigan Junior State Amateur Pine Lake CC Joey Garber (Stroke Play) Jordan Fletcher (Match Play) (Presented by: Osprey Recreational) 7th GAM Junior Two-Person Team Atlas Valley CC (Presented by: Osprey Recreational) Brooke Adamczak/Heather Marks (Girls) Wesley Gates/Trevor Grigg (Boys) Kaitlyn Brasher/Alex Hemmila (Mixed) Women’s Atlas Trophy Matches Lyon Oaks GC Public Team 88th GAM Championship Travis Pointe CC (Presented by: Nationwide Insurance) Chris Mory 18th GAM Women’s Championship Battle Creek CC (Presented by: Nationwide Insurance) Christine Meier 3rd GAM Senior Four-Ball Oakhurst G&CC (Presented by: Sullivan Golf & Travel) Bill Zylstra/John Jakubiak (Seniors) John Czarnik/John O’Donovan (Super Seniors) 1st GAM Boys’ Stroke Play Lakelands G&CC (Presented by: Osprey Recreational) Francesco Ruffino 13th GAM Women’s Senior Little Traverse Bay GC (Presented by: Pepsi) Joan Garety 27th GAM Mid-Amateur Tom Werkmeister Boyne Highlands Resort (Presented by: Lesson on Golf) (Presented by: Michigan Golf Live) Al Petrulis/Sal Petrulis (Men) Debra Horning/Sonia Pysh-Denison (Women) Molly Gibson/Wayne Kennedy (Mixed) 8th Michigan Net Amateur Oak Pointe CC (Presented by: Pepsi) Mike Kidder (Overall & Men) Keith McKenzie (Senior Men) Janelle Marshall (Women) Liz Houston (Senior Women) 23rd GAM Senior Championship Blythefield CC (Presented by: Robert W. Baird) Tom Stauffer Men’s Atlas Trophy Matches Meadowbrook CC Private Team GAM Tournament of Club Champions Oakland University (Sharf & Katke Courses) Greg Reynolds (Men) Stacy Slobodnik-Stoll (Women) 19th GAM Net Team Edgewood CC 9_GAM Highlights.indd 2 players of the year Junior Boy’s: Petoskey’s Joey Garber wins his second straight POY. He made the quarterfinals at the Michigan Amateur, plus racked up points at the U.S. Junior Amateur, Michigan Junior Amateur, and the AJGA. Junior Girl’s: Devon Compton of Rochester pulled off a 2-for-1 at the Michigan Girls Junior Amateur, taking both the top stroke play spot and finishing as the match play champion. Men’s: Tom Werkmeister of Kentwood nabbed his first POY, winning the Michigan Amateur and the GAM Mid-Am, as well as the Michigan Medal Play, and a Top 10 spot at the Michigan Open. Women’s: High school senior Christine Meier of Rochester took the POY title with strong play — including a victory at the GAM Women’s Championship and the semifinals at the Michigan Women’s Amateur. Senior Men’s: Bill Zylstra took his fourth straight POY title, winning the GAM Senior Match Play Senior Division, plus playing well in GAM and other Michigan and USGA championships. Senior Women’s: Joan Garety of Ada took her third straight senior POY title by winning the GAM Women’s Senior Championship, plus strong showings at a number of GAM- and USGA-run events, including the U.S. Women’s Senior Amateur sectional. 10/27/09 1:55:03 PM Significant results of state players at other 2009 championships: Scott Hebert, the professional at Grand Traverse Resort and Spa, won his fourth consecutive Michigan PGA Championship, setting a competitive course record of 64 at Eagle Eye. Hebert also played in the PGA Championship and Buick Open, and went 5-0-0 to help the U.S. team to victory at the 24th PGA Cup in Scotland. We’re Listening gam adds more championships, more ‘net’ events photo courtesy of blythefield country club. Based on member feedback, the GAM added several events this past year — for the young, the young at heart, and for the “rest of us” who may never come close to playing scratch golf. The 1st GAM Boys’ Stroke Play Championship, won by Francesco Ruffino, gave the 14-and-under set a 36-hole tournament experience. The 1st GAM Senior Match Play offered 18 holes of stroke play, followed by three days of match play. Senior Men’s Player of the Year Bill Zylstra took the top spot. An expanded series of “GAM Golf Days” continued the GAM’s push to add more “net” opportunities — the fastest-growing segment of GAM-run events and tournaments. For only $55 — less than a normal guest fee — GAM members were able to play at more than 15 of Michigan’s finest private clubs and resorts. Many of the 18-hole stroke-play events with a full GAM/USGA Handicap Index sold out quickly. The cost included a cart, range balls, and prizes for gross and net winners. Visit www.gam.org for details on next year’s “GAM Golf Days” and join the fun! Additional “net” events dot the GAM schedule, from the Net Amateur (won this year by Mike Kidder) and Net Team (won by siblings Al and Sal Petrulis) to the GAM Father & Son and Parent & Child championships. There are also gross and net winners at the GAM’s Senior Women’s Am and Women’s Mid-Am championships. To find a GAM event that fits your game — and your schedule — be sure to visit www.gam.org and join in the fun! 2009 gam tournaments by the numbers 20 GAM Championships 12 USGA Qualifiers 3,465 Players ages 6 to 89. 85 Golf courses played. Brendan Gielow of Muskegon helped the U.S. Walker Cup team to victory over the Great Britain & Ireland team. The Wake Forest golfer won his final singles match at Merion in Ardmore, Pa. He also won the Porter Cup at Niagara Falls CC in dramatic fashion, chipping in from just off the green on the third playoff hole, as well as top-10 finishes at the Jones Cup Invitational, The Northeast Amateur, and the Sunnehanna Amateur. Allison Fouch, former MSU golfer and currently on the LPGA Tour, won the Michigan Women’s Open, held in August at Crystal Mountain. She edged current Spartan, Laura Kueny, by one stroke. Ryan Brehm, the former MSU All-American from Mount Pleasant, won the 2009 Michigan Open at Orchard Lake Country Club in June. Russ Cunningham won the 2009 West Michigan Amateur at Candlestone Resort, edging fourtime champion Tom Werkmeister. Randy Lewis made it to the round of 16 during the U.S. MidAmateur Championship at South Carolina’s Kiawah Island Club. Greg Reynolds made it to the quarterfinals of the U.S. Senior Amateur at Beverly CC in Chicago. NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2009 9_GAM Highlights.indd 3 news | milestones Forecaddie other michigan notables Blythefield CC was one of the popular “GAM Golf Days” sites. 11 10/27/09 1:55:21 PM foundation formed to support junior golf Potential golf stars of tomorrow will be on hand next July when Egypt Valley Country Club hosts the 2010 U.S. Junior Amateur. But the Grand Rapids-area club’s members are hoping the event spurs an even greater impact on the future of local junior golf. They’ve formed the Western Michigan Junior Golf Foundation, a 501(c)(3) organization, to help defray the expense of hosting the USGA event — and to lay the groundwork to support more local junior golf programs (see sidebar). “Junior golf is a special passion of mine, and I’d like to see more opportunities for kids,” says John O’Donovan, the former GAM president and longtime Egypt Valley member who is general chairman for the 2010 U.S. Junior Amateur. “Right now, excellent junior tournament players have all sorts of venues. But there are not a lot of opportunities for beginning and less skilled players. Locally, The Mines and Grand Rapids Golf Club have junior programs with over 150 participants. Even though at $80-$100 (five-week program) it’s a great value, a lot of kids can’t afford the cost.” The foundation hopes to help open such programs up to more junior golfers. But first, there’s that big event to host next July 19-24. And with the Buick Open leaving the state, it will be the only “major” tournament held in Michigan next year. Tomorrow’s PGA Stars The U.S. Junior Amateur features the very best under-18 male golfers in the world (in 1999, the championship attracted a record 4,508 entries). Only Tiger Woods (naturally) has won the event more than once. Only five players have reached the finals twice. Woods remains the youngest champion (he was15 years, six months, and 28 days old when he won in 1991). He also holds titles to the most championships won, most consecutive championships, and most times in the finals (1991, 1992, and 1993). Woods hasn’t been the event’s only future star. Jack Nicklaus qualified five times. Other participants who eventually made the PGA Tour include Johnny Miller, Gary Koch, Andy North, David Duval, Curtis Strange, Trevor Immelman, Hunter Mahan, Aaron Baddeley, and Ryan Moore. 12 A Worthy Venue The 2010 U.S. Junior Amateur will be contested on the inward nines of Egypt Valley’s Ridge and Valley courses, both designed by Arthur Hills and opened in 1990. The club has hosted many USGA qualifiers and GAM championships, and a Champions Tour event was played here from 1994-2004. The juniors will play the course at 7,206 yards (slightly less than the longest Junior Amateur held in Shoal Creek, Ala., in 2008), but Egypt Valley will more than live up to the challenge. “All the USGA has requested of us is that we grow the rough from the customary 2 inches to 3½, and the green speed will be about 11 — we’re normally at around 9½,” says O’Donovan. “Plus, the players will get their fill of uphill and downhill lies.” The U.S. Junior’s Michigan Roots “The U.S. Junior Amateur has some roots here in Michigan,” says O’Donovan. In 1948, the USGA’s inaugural U.S. Junior Amateur was held at the University of Michigan Golf Course and drew 495 entries. Dean Lind defeated future U.S. Open Champion Ken Venturi in the final. Michigan hosted the U.S. Junior Amateur two other times: in 1962 at Lochmoor Club in Grosse Pointe Woods, and in 1980 at Pine Lake Country Club in Orchard Lake. Michigan has hosted 29 previous USGA championships, from U.S. Amateurs at the Country Club of Detroit (notably, Arnold Palmer’s win in 1954) to U.S. Opens at Oakland Hills. The 2008 U.S. Women’s Mid Am was held at Barton Hills CC in Ann Arbor. The U.S. Senior Amateur is slated for 2012 at Indianwood G&CC’s Old Course. For more information about the 2010 U.S. Junior Amateur, go to www.usga.org. support the u.s. junior am Hosting a national championship is prestigious, but it comes with a cost. The USGA considers it “noncommercial” — the host can’t charge admission or even charge for parking. It’s up to Egypt Valley to provide transportation to and from the hotels, plus food for players and caddies. “When we signed on to do this five years ago,” says John O’Donovan, “none of us expected the Michigan economy to be as bad as it is.” The club is seeking ways to keep costs down. “We don’t plan to emulate Trump National and hold lavish parties,” adds O’Donovan. (Trump National GC hosted the 2009 U.S. Junior Amateur. Reportedly, Donald Trump himself wrote a check to put on the event.) All told, it will still cost about $200,000 to host the event. Egypt Valley members donated services to form the Western Michigan Junior Golf Foundation. The 501 (c)(3) organization is seeking corporate and individual patrons to make tax-deductible donations to help pay for the Junior Amateur. Contributors will be listed on a board at the scoreboard and in the program. After the event, the foundation will continue to support local junior programs. Egypt Valley formed 16 committees to make sure the event is a success, says O’Donovan. “There is a group working to bring an LPGA event to the Grand Rapids area. If we do this well, that will go a long way to show that the area is capable of hosting other events, too.” The Western Michigan Junior Golf Foundation plans to establish a Web site. If you are interested in making a donation or volunteering, contact John O’Donovan at modono9950@ aol.com, or call Jennifer Warner at Egypt Valley CC: (616) 676-2626, or e-mail Jennifer@egyptvalley.com. Forecaddie Forecaddie news | milestones Egypt Valley CC Set to Host 2010 U.S. Junior Amateur MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 9_GAM Highlights.indd 4 10/27/09 1:55:50 PM Feature the big picture The Big Picture: Michigan Golf 2009 the good, the bad, and the ugly photograph courtesy of treetops resort. Nearly half of Treetops Resorts’ online bookings came from out of state. Golf has suffered along with the rest of the Michigan economy. As the 2009 season progressed, private clubs struggled to retain members, resorts fought for a share of tourism dollars, rumors (mostly false) flew about pending bankruptcies and closings, and there were tales of near-empty parking lots and dwindling tee sheets. So was all gloom and doom in Michigan? Depends on where you look. And whom you talk to (understandably, some locations declined to discuss any negative news). “From my board members, I’m hearing the industry overall is flat, but optimistic,” says Kate Moore, executive director of the Michigan Golf Course Owners Association. “Everyone is working harder and smarter for the same dollar. No one is jumping for joy, but most are holding their own. “People realize they have to approach the business differently,” Moore says. Many operations adjusted to the down economy by developing out-of-the-box plans. Says Crystal Mountain’s Director of Golf Brad Dean: “We used different media, offered different packages … we changed the way we thought. You can’t just do ‘same old, same old’ or you’re not going to do well.” Michigan’s not alone in this. According to a recent article in Golf Business magazine, some 15 percent of private golf clubs have been reporting serious financial challenges, and more than 50 percent admit to trying some form of discounting. Mike Bylen, managing partner at Pine Trace, Shepherd’s Hollow, and Cherry Creek golf clubs, sees a silver lining in the state’s economic malaise. “I’ve learned some valuable lessons because of the situation we find ourselves in,” he says. “I think I have become a better businessman out of necessity.” On the following pages, Michigan Links provides a regional roundup to find out how a cross-section of golf facilities in Michigan are weathering the economic storm. NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2009 16_Feature2indd.indd 1 13 10/27/09 1:59:21 PM Feature the up north report Weather and the Economy Pack a One-Two Punch by jack berry Bargain Hunters and Late Bookers Operators throughout the north found golfers always looking for deals, wanting to negotiate a better price. “Whether it was a twosome or a group of 24, they wanted Traverse City G&CC to negotiate,” explains Darin Philport, the general manager at Dunmaglas GC. “It’s an unfortunate process our industry is going through.” weather was a factor. Radio and TV weather forecasts would Some courses cut prices to boost traffic. Crystal Lake GC talk of rain and people would stay away. Even so, he says, “We in Beulah packed them in with “dollar days” on Monday and didn’t have many total washout days.” Thursday, charging a dollar per hole. Carts How about good news? were $4 for nine holes; $7 for 18. “Everything is green. It’s like June,” says It’s so important to Another common comment regarded DeAgostino of the late-season conditions. late booking. Instead of booking a week or Also on the “glass-is-half-full” side, there re-image the state, month ahead, people would wait until a weren’t any high-humidity, 90-plus-degree, putting out images of scorching days. Cool days and rain resulted day or two before calling for reservations or tee times, which made it difficult to all that we have — the in so much grass at some courses, one golfer decide on staffing levels. who had difficulty whacking his ball out of water, the towns, the the rough asked the staff if they were preWeather Woes courses, the beauty ...” paring for a PGA tournament. “They said Want more woe? Try the weather. they’d had to cut staff and weren’t mowing — Boyne USA’s Stephen Kircher “It snowed last November 19 and the rough as much,” he reports. never melted until April,” says Steve Hammon of Traverse City “We put our maintenance staff on 36-hour weeks, down G&CC and president of the Michigan Golf Course Superintenfrom 40 hours in 2008 — and before that, we’d do overtime,” dents Association. “We opened nine holes on April 10, but still Treetops’ McKinley says. “But all our courses were in great had snow on nine holes.” condition. And we used to have three manager meetings dur“The weather’s been awful,” Matthias agrees. “Rain, rain, ing the summer, but instead of meetings, we went out and rain in July and August, and cold.” pulled weeds.” “The average July temperature was 66,” adds Bob Koutnik of An early September break helped. “Finally, we’ve had 14 Fox Run CC in Grayling. “Last year it was the economy and gas- straight days of perfect sunshine and good bookings,” says oline prices. This year it’s been the weather and the economy.” Boyne USA’s head man, Stephen Kircher. “And we’ve had an Then there was Boyne Country, where it rained eight straight inordinate amount of out-of-state business, more than we’ve Saturdays. ever seen — and that’s thanks to the Pure Michigan campaign.” J. Michael DeAgostino of Grand Traverse Resort says: “Our general manager is a 30-year veteran of the industry and he says The Pure Michigan Factor he’s never seen anything like this.” Praise for Michigan’s media campaign was unanimous. “It’s so Like everyone in the north, Treetops’ McKinley says the important to re-image the state, putting out images of all that 14 photo courtesy of traverse city g&cc. It wasn’t the best of times for Northern Michigan golf this season, but it wasn’t the worst. High Pointe GC near Traverse City didn’t even open. Garland Resort was sold. One thing that wasn’t a concern was high gasoline prices — a huge damper during 2008. But the sluggish Michigan economy and Mother Nature dealt a double-edged blow. “The only thing keeping the doors open are our elk rides with dinner, wine tastings, and bus tours from outside Michigan,” says Jack Matthias of Thunder Bay Resort near Lake Huron. Adds Kevin McKinley of Treetops Resort: “We’re definitely down a little from last year (but) not as bad as we thought it would be.” MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 16_Feature2indd.indd 2 10/27/09 1:59:39 PM Value Packages and Guarded Optimism A spike in out-of-state travelers, coupled with a necessity-induced shift in the mindset of many courses’ marketing and operating strategies, is giving rise to optimism. “We changed the way we do things,” Treetops’ McKinley explains. “People who booked an unlimited golf package could play as much as they wanted — we didn’t have a replay fee if they wanted to play 36 holes. “We also donated $10 per person per night to a charity of their choosing in their home town. We sold 275 of those packages and feel we had a very good response.” Additions such as an alpine slide and water park “added another dimension to what we offer,” says Crystal Mountain Resort & Spa’s Director of Golf, Brad Dean. “We did a lot of different things. We put together family fun packages and had golf packages that included a lesson, which kept our teachers busy and brought in new customers.” Watching costs helped, too. “We made adjustments in staff every day, and made ‘out-of-play’ areas on the courses into ‘wilding’ areas,” Dean says. “We weathered the summer very well as a total resort. Was it our best? No. But we did OK.” At Shanty Creek Resort, meanwhile, rounds were actually up this year, thanks to packages offering unlimited golf. Adding to the increased rounds: “We also offer a ‘kids stay and eat free’ — and on the Summit and Schuss courses, youth 17 and under play for no charge with an adult,” A Ray of Sunshine Pure Michigan Campaign Takes Edge Off Stagnant Economy Pure Michigan ads were seen in Chicago — and beyond. Pure Michigan isn’t just for television and radio anymore. It’s a giant billboard in New York’s Times Square. It’s the Internet social networks of Facebook and Twitter, YouTube and Blogger, and Flickr. The campaign welcomes a non-Michigan audience to our unique two-peninsula state, with more than 800 public courses designed by today’s foremost wizards of the soil. Michigan is bursting out across America with the smooth voice of native son Tim Allen, narrating the wonders of our state with pictures that draw outsiders in. Ad agency McCann Worldwide developed the program, which Forbes. com listed as one of the 10 best tourism campaigns ever (think “I ‘heart’ NY” or “Virginia is for Lovers”). “We did ‘Great Lakes State’ for 10 years and it never caught on,” says George Zimmermann, a native Texan who is vice president of Travel Michigan, an arm of the Michigan Economic Development Corp. Does Pure Michigan work? “Anecdotally, we hear it all the time. But we hired Longwood International, which does research on advertising campaigns, the last five years,” says Zimmermann. “We’ve found that for every dollar spent on advertising, out-of-state visitors return $40 to Michigan businesses, and $2.86 of that goes, in tax, to the state treasury. “This is the first year that we’ve gone national,” Zimmermann adds. “All of the media and editorial have been positive. The private sector is near unanimous in support and wants it to continue. We received 6,000 petition signatures and 1,000 letters of approval from convention and visitors’ bureaus around the state (to present to the governor and Legislature).” (Editor’s Note: The Legislature approved $30 million to advertise Michigan in 2009, a significant boost. At press time, the 2010 funding for the Pure Michigan campaign had not been determined as negotiations continued on the state budget shortfall.) Zimmermann says it is important to keep the campaign going — a feeling shared by course owners across the state. Thunder Bay’s Jack Matthias says: “The campaign has been wonderful. Things would’ve been worse if it hadn’t been done, and as for the return on the investment, the Mafia would kill for that kind of return.” “The bottom line is there is no question that Michigan is a national quality product and not every state is,” Zimmermann says. “Sometimes things are taken for granted — the (usually) nice weather, the long summer daytime hours, the golf courses, the water. People who live in hot places with no water — Atlanta, Dallas, Tulsa, Oklahoma City, Omaha, St. Louis — should come here.” Zimmermann knows of which he speaks. As a youngster in Dallas, he caddied in 100-degree heat. Back then, he couldn’t go to www.michigan.org and link onto Pure Michigan. —Jack Berry NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2009 16_Feature2indd.indd 3 photo courtesy of travel michigan. we have — the water, the towns, the courses, the beauty — instead of, ‘Oh Michigan! Detroit, decay, crime,’ ” says Kircher. Adds Dunmaglas’ Philport: “We’ve had a lot of people from other states — Missouri, Georgia, Texas. We had numerous groups from California fly in on a six-day vacation ... and there’s so much else to do in this area (Charlevoix, Petoskey, Harbor Springs).” “Nearly half of our online tee time bookings came from out of state,” adds Treetops’ McKinley. “We were one of the sites shown in the (Pure Michigan) TV spots and we got a lot of comments: ‘Know what? I think I saw this on TV.’ ” 15 10/27/09 2:00:02 PM Feature the up north report Garland Lodge Thanks To you, we’re advancing The game. — Garland’s Barry Owens says Brian Kautz, director of golf. However, the boost from those types of rounds didn’t add revenue (which was slightly down). Kautz credits the ownership (the resort was purchased by Trinidad Resort & Club, LLC in 2006) with “doing everything that the property required. It was getting very dated and tired, and they’ve gone to great lengths to rejuvenate it.” Topping the list was a $10 million renovation of its hotel and conference center. Garland, long popular for a half-century, got new ownership on Aug. 1. Ron Otto, whose father started Garland, retired after expanding the resort and bringing in the biggest logs this side of the Rockies for the lodge. Says Barry Owens, who has been retained as president of the newly christened Garland Lodge and Resort: “The new owners are committed to growing the property, giving it a whole face-lift from rooms in the lodge to the patio, to repaving areas. And all the bunkers will be improved. Incredible things are going on.” The new owners — New Frontiers Capital, LLC — are certainly bullish on Michigan. They’re planning to not only reinvest in all four courses, they’ve also retained course architect Michael Benkusky to develop a fifth championship golf course. Jack Berry is a frequent contributor to Michigan Links, and a member of the Michigan Golf Hall of Fame. 16 photograph courtesy of garland lodge and resort. The golf association of michigan is pleased to recognize the support of our 2009 corporate sponsors. in addition to providing special benefits to gam members, these partners, through their financial investment, help insure that amateur golf in michigan continues to grow and prosper. we urge our members to recognize and patronize these companies to help express our thanks for their ongoing interest and support. The new owners are committed to growing the property, giving it a whole face-lift from rooms in the lodge to the patio, to repaving areas. And all the bunkers will be improved.” MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 16_Feature2indd.indd 4 10/27/09 2:01:26 PM Feature metro detroit report Necessity Drives Invention by norm sinclair Through most of 2009, golf course operators were desperately praying for a miracle to save them from record cool temperatures, constant rainfall, and Michigan’s moribund economy. Then Mother Nature teed up dry, summer-like weather in late August and September. The stretch provided such a tonic that some operators predicted this year’s bottom line could actually surpass last year’s. Ironically, while the cool and wet days chased players away, the damp conditions provided unexpected help in money saved on irrigation and turf management. “From a standpoint of the expense side and cost of maintaining golf courses, we had a very favorable year,” says Jim Dewling, president of Total Golf, an organization with 12 clubs in metro Detroit, Lansing, Grand Rapids, and Mount Pleasant under its umbrella. photograph courtesy of cherry creek golf club. Cherry Creek GC A Change in (Business) Plans The tepid economy forced most clubs to adjust their business plans, resorting to discounts, special days, and creative membership drives to attract players and members. Danny Wilkie, director of golf at Heather Hills GC north of Romeo, says a coupon program offering $100 green fees with carts for foursomes and $20 with cart for seniors has been very helpful. “It’s a drive to get to our golf course, but overall it’s been pretty good,” he says. “We (had) a lot of group outings and end-of-the-year outings on the books.” Lindsay Mason III, director of golf at New Rogell GC in Detroit, says special discounts on the 1914 Donald Ross design paid off. “Play is up about 15 percent,” he says. “We believe in giving back to the community. We give early bird specials, discount golf on the weekends, as well as quite a bit of discount during the week. Monday and Tuesday, for instance, discount golf with a cart is $20. On Friday, the 18-hole special — based on two people with cart — is $15.” Increasing course “traffic” is the key. “What you’re looking to do is make up for price, hopefully, with volume, and recover the lower prices with your hot dogs, pro shop, and range sales,” Dewling says. At Dewling’s flagship Mystic Creek GC in Milford, Monday, once reserved for outings, is now called “Mystic Monday.” “We offer a $21 rate for golf and cart, where the normal fee would have been in the $40 range,” Dewling says. “We basically doubled the gross on Monday. We turned a $21 player into a $30 player, before they are done with their grill and concessions and range balls. We may have taken a little abuse on the golf course but, at the same time, I think it is one way to combat the economic times.” Avoiding ‘Giveaways’ While he accepts discounts as a way of life these days, Mike Bylen, managing partner at Pine Trace, Shepherd’s Hollow, and Cherry Creek golf clubs, stays clear of “giveaways.” “There is a difference between what some people consider discounting and market rate,” he says. “What I’m averse to is giving away two-for-ones, and the like. I would rather adjust my rate to where everyone is in the marketplace.” Bylen says that despite revenue shortfalls, his courses are performing well, thanks to cost-cutting and — thanks to the cool weather — savings reaped from reduced maintenance expenses. “We’ve taken very systematic costcutting measures,” he says. “A lot of it is in staffing levels, especially at the management level. We still write a schedule for a week in advance, but we are reviewing it every day to see what the tee sheet looks like and we are calling people on or off.” Private Bargains Private clubs around the area have, likewise, adopted discounts to attract new members. Some, like TPC of Michigan in Dearborn and Oak Pointe CC in Brighton, offered incentive membership drive programs. “It was a limited program for a select number of people that gave them access on very restricted days and times,” says NOVEMBER /| DECEMBER DECEMBER 2009 2008 16_Feature2indd.indd 5 19 17 10/27/09 2:01:42 PM metro detroit TPC General Manager Lee Woodruff. “We did it that way so we could protect the integrity of the full members.” The newcomers were restricted to Tuesday and Wednesday, and after 2 p.m. on Thursday through Sunday. Members got first pick of the tee times. Newcomers’ guest fees were higher than the full membership paid, and they had to pay cash or with credit cards at each visit and did not get lockers, club storage, or other privileges of full membership (such as reciprocity at other TPC courses). While Woodruff declined to reveal how many players took advantage of the program, he says it filled gaps in their slowest times, while building a pool of prospects for next year’s full membership drives. Jon Cheshire, general manager at Oak Pointe, says the club managed to keep stable their membership of 850 families — including 600 golfing families. The club offered a discount in initiation from $6,000 to $3,500, while keeping monthly dues intact. They also mailed two $25 certificates for food and beverage to each member in the spring and fall, to encourage club use. “We created a member referral program this year that not only rewards the member doing the referral but rewards the new member, as well,” he says. “Referral members get $100 off their dues each month for one year, and the new member also gets the same discount.” Cheshire says the club is experiencing an increase in rounds played by members, plus Oak Pointe’s ClubCorp ownership insulates members from not having to pay assessments or food or beverage minimums. And their membership is honored at 200 clubs around the country. Leagues and Seniors Carry the Day While many clubs say corporate golf outings had almost disappeared and other outings were also faltering, league play and weekday play by seniors were the bright spots. “The league numbers held up pretty well,” Total Golf’s Dewling says. “I think it’s a case where household budgets allow for nine holes a week in a league, where some of the open golf might be curtailed a little bit.” Seniors have become the mainstays of weekday business. Senior golfers responded to special discounts and special day fees. At the family-run Hunter’s Ridge GC in Howell, Joe and Janet Miesle decided early in the year to keep their usually lower spring rate on all summer. Seniors age 50 and over could play this Jerry Matthews/ Paul Albanese design with a cart Monday through Friday for $20. The weekday rate was $25 with a cart; on weekend afternoons, foursomes played for $30. “We realize times are tough for everyone,” says Janet. “Hopefully, we can make it up with more rounds.” Norm Sinclair is a former Detroit News writer and award-winning investigative reporter who also likes writing about golf. 18 Half Empty … and Half Full by greg johnson Blythefield CC’s Patti Butcher isn’t the type to brag that she saw this coming … but she saw it coming. The general manager/golf professional/instructor put a new business model in place more than two years ago at the private club in Belmont on Grand Rapids’ north side. “The industry has changed and the golfers have changed in terms of what they want from a golf experience,” she said earlier this year at the West Michigan Golf Show. “And obviously, the economy has changed.” Blythefield CC, like all private clubs, has battled through membership issues — as in not enough members. Butcher reports progress has been made, however, and she credits a better understanding of what members want from the country club experience. “We’ve aimed at families, tried to make things more fun, and we’ve been open to suggestions,” she says. Watermark CC Rumors … and Refinancing Golf across West Michigan was varied in terms of success. Holland Country Club disappeared — sold for housing development. Grand Island Golf Ranch, once a busy 27-hole public course, is fenced off and surrounded by weeds. It was sold for development, like three other area public courses in recent years. Rumors ran rampant regarding private clubs. Doors were supposed to be closing at several places, but most clubs have managed to work out financial agreements with banks, called on members for more funds, or simply reorganized. Egypt Valley CC’s Fred Cahall, the president, says the club recently signed an agreement with its bank to fend off financial troubles, and new plans are being implemented. “We are designing a business model that takes advantage of what we have to offer,” Cahall says. “No other club in this area has what we have — two great golf courses. We are going to compete in price and services in a way that allows us to attract more members.” photograph courtesy of watermark cc. Feature MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 16_Feature2indd.indd 6 10/27/09 2:02:11 PM Feature Golfers have changed in terms of what they want from a golf experience. And obviously, the economy has changed.” — Blythefield CC’s Patti Butcher west michigan CC), and is making good on promised major construction and improvements. The private golf/public restaurant model is being put in place there, too. The Watermark group also made a successful offer to do the same at Sunnybrook CC in the Jenison/Hudsonville area. Says Steve Plakmayer of the Watermark group: “Instead of having to pay more in membership dues to subsidize the members-only food and beverage operation, the members actually photograph courtesy of candlestone resort. Candlestone Resort Proactive Expansion Thousand Oaks GC started this year (its 10th year in business) by adding a $5.5 million, 13,000-square-foot clubhouse expansion, to turn the high-end public venue into what its management calls a “hybrid” golf facility of the future. “We are doing both, being the same great public golf facility and a private club with banquet facilities for weddings, meetings, gatherings,” says Gary Smithson, the director of golf. Public play, which has drawn as many as 24,000 rounds in previous years, continues, and 90 members have been added in the last two years. The goal is to secure 250 to 300 members, who enjoy some separate facilities. The newly expanded restaurant and bar remain open to the public. “We are being proactive in this,” Smithson says. “Our owners think this is what golf has to become in the future.” New owners at Candlestone Resort in Belding, home of the West Michigan Amateur, have made good on $1 million in improvements since purchasing the course last year. Steve Leach of Rockford, one of the three new owners, is excited about what the resort can become. “We want to be something different for a lot of different types of golfers with different amounts of money.” Blurring the Public/Private Border Watermark CC in Cascade offers private golf, swimming, and health club options, while also having a public, high-profile restaurant. The Watermark ownership group purchased Crystal Springs CC from a bank last year (and renamed it StoneWater receive a discount off their food and beverage purchases.” The Highlands, a once-private Donald Ross design on the west side of Grand Rapids, went semiprivate two years ago, and reports it is doing well with a mix of public and private play. Meanwhile, Railside CC in nearby Byron Center was all set to go semiprivate as well. But member Jim Engen stepped up and purchased the club to keep it private. He also plans to improve the club’s facilities and lower fees to attract new members. Location, Location Reports have been fairly positive in much of the southwest. Diamond Springs, priced right from the beginning, remains popular. Hawkshead, The Ravines, and others continue to draw golfers, too. Chicagoans who summer in Michigan still consider the rates on this side of the lake preferable to those they find closer to home. The strictly public golf facilities in West Michigan are surviving, but clearly not thriving. Outings numbers are taking hits. Walk-up golf has been fairly steady, although coupons, discounts and specials at several places might be the reason. “It’s a challenge,” says Terry Sack, general manager at Grand Valley State’s The Meadows. “I can’t speak for everybody else, but we’re doing our best to offer what we’ve always offered — and more — at a fair price. I wouldn’t say we’re thriving, and I wouldn’t say we’re just surviving. We’re somewhere in between — hoping the economy and jobs get better.” Greg Johnson covers golf for the Grand Rapids Press. NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2009 16_Feature2indd.indd 7 19 10/27/09 2:02:25 PM Feature mid-michigan report Eagle Eye/Hawk Hollow Survival Means Taking New Approaches by tom lang Mixed Bag for Privates Many private clubs struggle in a bad economy because they have fewer members to support any debt they are carrying. Walnut Hills CC was purchased by a private group. Potential changes include enhancing the pool and adding recreation and dining amenities, plus expansion or new construction for a spa and fitness area. On the other side of the coin, Ann Arbor’s Barton Hills CC was approached by enough prospective members that they hired a part-time new membership coordinator. “People aren’t traveling as much as they used to, so they are focusing back toward a club situation, as opposed to the big trips or a second house up north,” says General Manager Corey Gerhart. 20 Despite maintaining 20,000 rounds of golf each year, Barton Hills still has economic factors to deal with. “We felt the effects of the economy, mostly in the dining part of our business,” just like the general restaurant business is experiencing slowdowns, too, Gerhart adds. Nearby, at Washtenaw CC — one of Michigan’s oldest facilities, dating back to 1899 — it’s a different story. There was talk of Washtenaw Community College acquiring the club, but that fell through. At press time, there were reports that nearby Polo Fields G&CC may buy the club. Riverside CC in Battle Creek took an interesting approach to solving a cash-flow problem — and increased their pool of potential new members at the same time. Instead of having to levy an assessment, the club began a “Pay photograph courtesy of hawk hollow. The state of the golf economy across Michigan’s midsection seems to be a matter of perspective. Partially isolated from the devastating woes of the automobile industry, mid-Michigan — especially near Lansing and Ann Arbor, with their major educational institutions — doesn’t appear to be suffering as bad of an economic blow. Its unemployment rate is 2 percentage points better than statewide numbers. Some golf courses from Ann Arbor to Battle Creek and north to Mount Pleasant are doing surprisingly well — but again, it depends on one’s perspective. Others feel it’s a struggle in historical comparison to the “grand old days” of a decade earlier. MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 16_Feature2indd.indd 8 10/27/09 2:03:33 PM Feature mid-michigan report Bucking the Trend Not everyone is scaling back or seeing reduced traffic. In the Jackson area, Calderone Farms is building a new clubhouse. At Arbor Hills GC, rounds are growing since the private club became public in 2007. The first year, Arbor Hills recorded about 10,000 rounds, and some 20,000 this year. “There was pent-up demand to play a course that had been private for 90 years,” says Cutting Costs … and Prices General Manger Bob Tillard. “We kept up that demand by keeping Further north in Mount Pleasant, courses like The PohlCat up the quality and condition of the course.” experienced a tougher year than hoped. The Eagle Eye and Hawk Hollow complex in Bath is meeting Manager Neil Patera says rounds were down, but net income expectations, staying “economically balanced” in part by booking remained flat, in part due to watching pennies on “day-to-day almost 300 weddings each year. But what surprised General Manexpenses” to cut costs on utilities like phones, going to lowager Alex Coss was that the highest growing revenue percentage energy light bulbs, and cutting back on air conditioner use. came from the mini-putting course, Little Hawk. “You’d be surprised how much it adds up.” “There are more non-golfers that play the Little Hawk course He adds: “Our focus is the customer’s perceived value. In than there are golfers,” Coss says. “On a Friday and Saturday times like this you don’t want to night, it’s wall-to-wall people.” slack on service or quality. The key In the Battle Creek area, the August is to not have knee-jerk reactions.” opening of Firekeepers Casino The Emerald in St. Johns raised sparked interest. One course that rack rates in ’09 by 8 percent (that’s expects to benefit from the relationstill $3 less than its 2000 rate). Web ship is The Medalist, a facility that site and e-mail club discounts were has already done well. a big hit. Overall rounds were up “We set a record last year for most 10 percent. Season passes were up revenue ever,” says Manager Lowell 25 percent, as General Manager Jay Weaver. “We’re up 3 percent over Eccleton dropped costs for golfers last year. In a flat economy, that’s who lived 25 miles or more from pretty good.” the course. Weaver gives full credit to the Barton Hills CC Eccleton is concerned that if golf 2004 ownership change to Osprey decisions all boil down to price, Recreational Properties, which everyone will suffer. “You’d be built a new banquet facility for the People aren’t traveling amazed how many calls we answer 12-year-old property. as much as they used to, (25-50) per day fielding price checks,” “You still have to be creative in this he says. “They don’t care about the environment; you can’t stick with the so they are focusing back amenities or the quality of the course, status quo,” Weaver adds. “We expect toward a club situation ...” to see another increase in rounds simply they just want the price. That hurts golf — Barton Hills CC’s Corey Gerhart overall, as quality will soon follow and because of Firekeepers Casino.” diminish.” College Fields in Okemos set out to Michigan’s Newest Course? cut 20 percent from its labor budget. Director of Operations Perhaps the area’s best feel-good golf story is taking place on a Carey Mitchelson says they were able to trim 23 percent, and small parcel of land not far from Eagle Eye. that a cooler summer also helped. Courses statewide needed Retired civil engineer John Kazenko, age 80, and his son, Doug, less irrigation and less fertilizer — and battled few heat stress have been hand-carving and nurturing their acreage into a golf issues. course for the past 15 years. After building highways for MDOT, “We have zero overtime, which is almost impossible,” “I just needed something to do to keep busy,” Kazenko says. Mitchelson says. “The cart staff used to be on in the mornKirkside GC will open the front nine next spring; 18 holes ing and stay until closing. Now they come in the afternoon to would have been ready if not for an irrigation problem detected handle leagues, and stay until evening. Everyone pitches in to a few years ago that required re-digging 500 sprinkler heads. do work they might not otherwise.” Graham Cooke, a Canadian architect and an MSU golfer 40 years College Fields’ rounds were up about 15 percent from ’08, ago, designed the course. due to an increase in college students playing and overall faster play. Mitchelson cleared out some tight landing areas so golfers Tom Lang is a freelance writer who covers golf for the Detroit Free Press, could play faster and fit in more rounds. Lansing State Journal, and other publications. Forecaddie photograph courtesy of barton hills cc. it Forward” program. According to Golf Professional Paul Hawkins, members who paid their yearly dues ahead of time could invite two people to become “trial” members for 2009. “This allowed us to showcase our facility to all these new people,” Hawkins says. “The jury is still out, but I believe we’re going to retain a larger percentage of them than what we estimated.” NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2009 16_Feature2indd.indd 9 21 10/27/09 2:03:50 PM Feature upper peninsula report Weather Takes Edge Off Growing Reputation by dennis grall While unemployment rates rose slightly in Michigan during the summer, the rate actually fell 0.7 percent in the Upper Peninsula, to 12.3 percent, as seasonal workers returned to their jobs. But weather conditions made a big impact in 2009 — bigger, perhaps, than the wretched economy. Despite that doublewhammy, golfers still flocked to the northwoods. “Most people that come here come for the quality of the golf course,” says Joe Rizzo, first-year pro at Iron Mountain’s TimberStone Golf Course. “This is a unique experience they can’t get anywhere else.” photograph courtesy of timberstone golf course. Packages Sweeten the Deal TimberStone, a two-time recipient of the prestigious five-star ranking from Golf Digest magazine, banded together with two other nationally ranked courses, Sweetgrass Golf Club in Harris and Greywalls Golf Course in Marquette, to create a package deal timed nicely for the economic crunch. Billboards publicizing the package were placed along major highways in Wisconsin and Michigan. The “Pure Michigan” campaign has also attracted out-of-state visitors. “The three-course package has been great for us, it really did get us through what could have been a very difficult time,” says Rizzo. “The package deal has helped,” agrees Marc Gilmore, golf professional at Greywalls. “Local stay-and-plays have helped, and we have been in some pretty dynamic publications (including appearing on the cover of Golfweek). That helped traffic.” TimberStone GC the weather we’ve had,” says Rob Lussenhup, golf professional at Wild Bluff. Dave Douglas, director of golf at Sweetgrass, agrees. “We rarely had days in the 70s through mid-July,” he says. “Every month, play increased. We didn’t know what to expect. It is still a feeling-out period,” he says of the relatively new course. Greywalls felt the pinch, too. Gilmore indicated play was reduced 20-25 percent because of the weather, but income still exceeded the budget by 22-23 percent. “A really good year (weather-wise) would have been unbelievable,” he says. Growing Reputation, Lower Prices Rizzo says the U.P. courses are frequently The word is out. The U.P. Living on Tourism compared with high-profile tracks in Wisconsin (Whistling Straits, The Bog, Despite the Upper Peninsula’s relative is not as far away as The Bull) and lower Michigan. golfers still shook off their people think. There is a remoteness, “Even compared to those places, we are financial concerns to help fill tee sheets. pot of gold at the end of a much lower rate and, we feel, a greater Tourists from Kentucky and Texas value. I think the word is out, the U.P. is recorded aces at Sweetgrass. An eightthe rainbow.” not as far away as people think. There is a member group from Alaska visited Grey— TimberStone’s Joe Rizzo pot of gold at the end of the rainbow.” walls this year. Solid reputations of area courses, includ Wild Bluff draws golf and gaming ing the Golf Digest 4.5-star Wild Bluff Golf Course and Casino in groups from the Detroit area, Mount Pleasant, Saginaw/Bay Brimley, George Young Resort near Iron River, and Lac Vieux City, and Sudbury, Ont. “People are still traveling,” says LussenDesert Resort Casino in Watersmeet, helped weather the economhup. “We’ve been packed. We do a thousand rounds just out of ic storm. Sudbury.” None of the major courses made cutbacks on maintenance or Lussenhup is looking forward to next year. “I have entire weekhelp. “We have to make sure we maintain the same level,” says Rizends that are already sold out,” he says. “If the economy is off, zo. “We try to maintain expenses but also maintain our reputation.” people are still going to travel; they just might not travel to faraway destinations. They’ll take their RV, drive four to five hours, A Stormy Start and play golf and do some gaming.” Weather definitely hurt early in the season. “I would assume the Dennis Grall is the sports editor of the Escanaba Daily Press. economy impacts [golf], but it is hard to tell this summer with 22 MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 16_Feature2indd.indd 10 10/27/09 2:04:14 PM Read. Advertise. Subscribe. Support your hometown newspaper. Birmingham Eccentric Canton Observer Farmington Observer Garden City Observer Livonia Observer Milford Times Northville Record Novi News Plymouth Observer Redford Observer South Lyon Herald South Oakland Eccentric Royal Oak, Clawson, Berkley, Huntington Woods, Southfield, and Pleasant Ridge Westland Observer Local provider of advertising, features, news, and sports. RETAIL ADVERTISING Observer & Eccentric (734) 582-8363 Hometown (248) 437-2011 CLASSIFIED ADS: 1-800-579-7355 HOME DELIVERY/CUSTOMER SERVICE 1-866-887-2737 Feature the buick open Big Finish Billy Casper (right) nabs a Buick in 1958. buick open leaves a lasting legacy by vartan kupelian For more than a half-century, the Buick Open was a mainstay on the PGA Tour calendar. The tournament’s creators and organizers were ahead of the game. Buick became golf’s first corporate sponsor in 1958, and the wisdom of that action has been confirmed time and again. At one point or another, pretty much every auto manufacturer on the globe became involved with golf sponsorship. The Buick Open has departed the PGA Tour schedule, but it won’t soon be forgotten — not in these parts, and not across the country. At its peak, Buick was the title sponsor of four PGA Tour stops, and the presenting sponsor of a fifth in one season. The Buick Open had become an important piece of the fabric that made Michigan one of golf ’s great destinations for both professional and recreational golf. In addition to providing outstanding tournaments and renowned champions, the Buick Open raised more than $11 million for local charities since 1982. Here is a look at the Buick Open’s “Great Eight” at Warwick Hills Golf and Country Club — memories and the personalities that made it a truly special sporting event in Michigan history. Casper as its first titleholder. Casper is one of golf’s greatest ever. He’s a major champion — the U.S. Open in 1959 and 1966, and the Masters in 1970 — and won a combined 60 events on the PGA Tour (51) and the Champions Tour between 1956 and 1989. The 1958 Buick Open was the fourth victory in Casper’s career. The purse of $52,000 was the largest ever on the PGA Tour. Casper’s share was $9,000. Casper won by one stroke over a young lad named Arnold Palmer. Already, the Buick Open had established itself as the home of champions. Billy the Kid (1958) Without a beginning, there can be no end. The Buick Open started in 1958 at Warwick Hills. What elevates any competition is the caliber of its champions, and the Buick Open hit the jackpot with Billy Champagne Tony (1964-1965) Tony Lema’s golf talents were surpassed only by his charm, quick wit, and smile. When he won a tournament, Lema served Champagne to the press. Lema won back-to-back Buick Opens in 24 1964 and 1965. The second victory made him the first two-time champion at Warwick Hills. The Oakland, Calif., native was a rising star when he and his wife were killed in 1966 when their chartered twin-engine aircraft ran out of fuel and crashed on the seventh hole of a golf course in Lansing, Ill. The Playoff (1981) How about a four-man playoff for an exciting finish? That’s what the Buick Open provided in 1981. Hale Irwin was the man to catch after an opening 65 — a Buick Open first-round record at that time. But Peter Jacobsen, Gil Morgan, and Bobby Clampett closed the gap over the next two rounds and finally caught Irwin, all shooting 11-under-par 277 through 72 holes. A playoff birdie by Irwin at the 17th gave him the victory — and here’s an MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 24_buickopen.indd 1 10/27/09 2:05:09 PM round by the eventual winner of a tournament. He also set the Buick Open record of 195 for 54 holes. By now, the first-prize money had soared to $108,000 — a major chunk of the Wake Forest star’s $1.4 million career total. Ben Crenshaw was a fan favorite in 1986. interesting historical tidbit: During that playoff the 17th hole began what would become a lengthy tradition as one of the PGA Tour’s most raucous spots. Irwin’s birdie was greeted with a thunderous reception, and the decibel levels continued to grow in coming years. Gentle Ben’s Magic Putter (1986) If you’re counting popular victories, few surpass what Ben Crenshaw achieved at the 1986 Buick Open. He’d always been a fan favorite and arrived on tour heralded as the next great golfer, the next Jack Nicklaus. Crenshaw had a magical putting stroke — still does — and his pleasant demeanor earned him the nickname “Gentle Ben.” In 1986, the purse reached the $500,000 mark for the first time. Crenshaw’s share was $90,000 for holding off J.C. Snead and Doug Tewell by 1 shot with four rounds in the 60s. Robert Who? (1987) A little-known professional from Austin, Texas, turned PGA Tour scoring records upside-down at the 1987 Buick Open. Robert Wrenn put together four recordsetting rounds. His 26-under, 262 total came within 1 stroke of tying Ben Hogan and 1960 Buick Open winner Mike Souchak for the lowest four-round score in history. Wrenn’s 63 was the lowest second Boom Boom (1994) The tournament featured two watershed moments: Fred Couples’ victory and the return to competition by Paul Azinger, who was stricken by cancer less than a year before, soon after winning the PGA Championship at Toledo’s Inverness Club. Couples himself was returning to the PGA Tour after being sidelined with a back injury. Rain forced cancellation of Thursday’s opening round, so Couples, bad back and all, faced a 36-hole Sunday. He shot 65-68 for a 270 total and 2-stroke victory over Corey Pavin. In both Sunday rounds, Couples made eagle 3 at the 13th hole. In all, he made eagle at the 13th three times in four rounds. Tiger Woods won three Buick Opens. The Tiger Era (1997-2006) The Tiger Woods era began in 1997 (his first full season on tour) and included his appearance at the Buick Open a few months after his historic victory at The Masters. Woods tied for eighth behind winner Vijay Singh at Warwick Hills. Woods played in the Buick Open nine times, winning titles in 2002, 2006, and in the finale in 2009. The 2006 victory Champagne Tony Lema captured back-to-back Buick Opens. was the 50th in his career and was celebrated by Buick, whose officials presented Woods with a cake in addition to the trophy and a check for $864,000. In six appearances beginning in 2002, Woods won the Buick Open three times, tied for second twice, and tied for third once. Only once did he fail to finish in the top 10 — he tied for 11th in 2000. Kenny Perry’s Comeback (2001) This Buick Open represented the rebirth of a career. Kenny Perry, winless in six years since the 1995 Bob Hope Chrysler Classic, broke through with his fourth career victory. He outdueled Chris DiMarco and Jim Furyk, a perennial contender at Warwick Hills, down the stretch to win by 2 strokes. Perry shot 66-64-64-69—263. Perry used the victory as a springboard to a great second career. He went from a journeyman to a star. He added another Buick Open crown in 2008, and he was a leader of the United States’ winning Ryder Cup effort in his native Kentucky two months after winning the Buick Open. The other highlight of 2001 was Billy Mayfair’s PGA Tour record-setting performance in the final round. Mayfair had a back-nine 27 — that’s 9-under — for a closing 61. Vartan Kupelian is a former sports columnist for The Detroit News. NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2009 24_buickopen.indd 2 25 10/27/09 2:05:26 PM know the game Getting Off the Cart Path Rules for Taking Relief by jeanne myers The first step in taking relief is to determine what club the player would have used for the next shot if the cart path hadn’t been there. Assuming it is a short shot, the player will probably use some sort of wedge. Taking the wedge in hand, the player should take a stance off the path (taking complete relief) assuming an address position and place a tee in the ground where the clubface hits the ground. That is “a point of relief.” In other words, if the ball lay there, there would have been no interference with either the lie, the stance or the swing. The player will probably have to do this on the other side of the path, as well. The tee closest to the ball, which should still be lying on the path, is the “nearest point of relief.” The player now gets to drop the ball within one club-length of the “nearest point of relief.” This club-length may be measured with any club in his bag. Many golfers erroneously believe that because a ball may lie toward the right side of a path, the relief will be on the right side. This is incorrect. Many factors come into play here. For example, the result of the procedure above will result in an entirely different “nearest point” for a left-handed golfer. The curvature of the path and the width of the path also make it necessary to go through the above procedure. A word of caution here — the ball should always be left where it lies until the area into which it has to be dropped 26 Find the nearest point of relief that does not interfere with your stance or area of your intended swing (point B for right-handed golfers; point C is not the nearest point of relief because the distance A-C is greater than A-B. The nearest point of relief for a left-handed golfer is point D). Drop your ball within one clublength of point B, no nearer to the hole (the yellow shaded area). If you don’t like where you are going to have to drop, you have the option of playing the ball where it came to rest (point A). is determined. The player may discover that the area where he is going to have to drop the ball is knee-high rough, and he would have been better off playing it from the cart path. He is entitled to lift The first step in taking relief is to determine what club the player would have used for the next shot if the cart path hadn’t been there.” the ball to take relief, but if he doesn’t take relief, he is not entitled to lift the ball. He will receive a one-stroke penalty (for lifting his ball in play) if he wishes to replace the ball on the path and play from there. There is one other thing to keep in mind. There are situations where a player might be unable to determine the nearest point of relief. For instance, the nearest point may be within the trunk of a tree. In this case, you can “estimate” the nearest point of relief, then drop the ball within one clublength from that estimated point, not nearer the hole. Fortunately, once you have learned to do this correctly, you have also learned the proper procedure for taking relief from ground under repair, casual water, and other abnormal ground conditions. It is all the exact same procedure. Jeanne Myers is the GAM’s assistant director of Rules and Competitions. If your club is interested in hosting a fun and informative rules seminar, please call the GAM office at (248) 478-9242, ext 14. illustration by kyle raetz. Rules & Etiquette One commonly misunderstood or misinterpreted procedure happens because of artificially surfaced cart paths. When a player’s ball in play lies on a cart path, or when the player has to stand on the path, or the path is going to interfere with his swing, the player is entitled to relief without penalty under Rule 24-2 (immovable obstruction). MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 26_Rules.indd 1 10/27/09 2:06:09 PM PUTT LIKE THE PROS Practice at home on your own putting green... Call now for fall or spring installation specials. Reach Fellow GAM Members with Your Advertising Message in Michigan Links SERVING MICHIGAN GOLFERS FOR 90 YEARS 2009 WWW.GAM.ORG $2.95 JULY/AUGUST Plus: The GAM’s 90-Year Milestone • Michigan Links is the official publication of the Golf Association of Michigan • Mailed to the most affluent and avid golfers in Michigan Unspoiled A Good Walk GREAT MICHIGAN COURS ES TO LEAVE THE CART BEHIND Don’t miss your chance to advertise in the March/April 2010 Issue To advertise, please contact your account executive at 248.691.1800 ext. 104 STATEMENT OF OWNERSHIP, MANAGEMENT AND CIRCULATION (Required by 39 USC 3685) Title of Publication: Michigan Links. Publication No. 018-935. Filing Date: 9/24/09 Frequency of Issue: Quarterly. Number of Issues Published Annually: Four. Annual Subscription Price: Not available for subscription. Complete Mailing Address of Known Office of Publication: Golf Association of Michigan, 24116 Research Drive, Farmington Hills, MI 48335. Contact Person: Tonia Branch. Telephone: (248) 478-9242. Complete Mailing Address of the Headquarters of the General Business Offices of the Publisher: Golf Association of Michigan, 24116 Research Drive, Farmington Hills, MI 48335. Full Names and Complete Mailing Addresses of the Publisher, Editor and Managing Editor: (Publisher) Tonia Branch, Golf Association of Michigan, 24116 Research Drive, Farmington Hills, MI 48335. (Editor)Tonia Branch, Golf Association of Michigan, 24116 Research Drive, Farmington Hills, MI 48335. (Managing Editor) Steven Wilke, Hour Custom Publishing, 117 W. Third St., Royal Oak, MI 48067. Owner: Golf Association of Michigan, 24116 Research Drive, Farmington Hills, MI 48335. Known Bondholders, Mortgagees, and Other Security Holders Owning or Holding 1 Percent or More of Total Amount of Bonds, Mortgages, or Other Securities: None. Tax Status: The purpose, function, and nonprofit status of this organization and the exempt status for federal income tax purposes has not changed during the preceding 12 months. EXTENT AND NATURE OF CIRCULATION Publication Title: Michigan Links. Issue Date for Circulation Data Below: July/August 2009. (Average Number of Copies of Each Issue During Preceding 12 Months listed first, followed by Actual Number of Copies of Single Issue Published Nearest to Filing Date.) Total Number of Copies: 42,194 and 40,667. Mailed Outside-County Paid Subscriptions Stated on PS Form 3541 (Paid Circulation): 39,503 and 39,169. Mailed In-County Paid Subscriptions Stated on PS Form 3541: 0 and 0. Paid Distribution Outside the Mails Including Sales Through Dealers and Carriers, Street Vendors, Counter Sales and Other Paid Distribution Outside USPS: 490 and 475. Paid Distribution by Other Classes of Mail Through the USPS (e.g. First-Class Mail): 0 and 0. Total Paid Distribution: 39,993 and 39,644. Free or Nominal Rate Outside-County Copies Included on PS Form 3541: 0 and 0. Free or Nominal Rate In-County Copies Included on PS Form 3541: 0 and 0. Free or Nominal Rate Copies Mailed at Other Classes Through the USPS (e.g. First-Class Mail): 0 and 0. Free or Nominal Rate Distribution Outside the Mail (Carriers or Other Means): 1,235 and 210. Total Free or Nominal Rate Distribution: 1,235 and 210. Total Distribution: 41,228 and 39,854. Copies not Distributed: 966 and 813. Total: 42,194 and 40,667. Percent Paid: 97.0% and 99.5%. I certify that the statements made by me are correct and complete: (signed) Tonia Branch. 27_ML1109.indd 1 MICHIGAN 21500 24 Mile Road, Macomb, MI 48042 Phone: 586-421-1769 ATTENTION GAM MEMBERS: sign up today for E LINKS get this biweekly e-newsletter about what’s new in michigan golf stay connected with your gam member benefits it’s easy to sign up 1. Gotowww.gam.org 2. Clickon“memberlogin” 3. Provideane-mailaddressonyourmemberprofile 4. Besuretosetyoure-mailpreferencestoallowe-mailsfrom info@michiganlinksmagazine.com 5. LookforMichiganELinksinyourinboxeveryotherTuesday 10/27/09 2:07:43 PM gowanie golf club Links to the Past ‘Lost’ Club A July/August 2009 Michigan Links story celebrating the GAM’s 90th anniversary listed 14 original clubs, but we knew the fate of only 13. George Mayernik, a member of the “lost” club, led us to the answer: “Riverview” became Gowanie Golf Club, which celebrates its 100th anniversary next year. Here’s their story: In 1910, Thomas Shoemaker built a nine-hole course called Riverview Golf Club on land he had tilled for 35 years near the Clinton River in Mount Clemens. Perhaps he was tired of farming. Or maybe he hoped to cash in on the town’s “Bath City” fame, when its mineral waters attracted enough visitors to spur a host of elegant hotels. The name “Riverview” faded into obscurity after Shoemaker leased the land to club members around 1920. A Scotsman named Dave Millar became the golf professional. Millar — credited with designing Kalamazoo’s highly regarded Milham Park course — expanded the club to 18 holes in 1922. He dubbed it “Gowanie” (GOW-nee): roughly translated to “dell of the daisies.” Ross Axford, who owned a company that built many golf courses for architect Robert Trent Jones, purchased Gowanie in 1939. Axford died in 1972, and for years the club was a member-run nonprofit, leased from his widow. Financial troubles mounted in the early 2000s. In 2001, Kathy and Wayne Babbish — club members since 1991 — brought it out of bankruptcy. “We couldn’t imagine it being turned into condos,” says Kathy. “We decided to jump in and keep her going!” 28 Gowanie through the decades: (above left) “Stag Day” 1949; (top) The 1968 Yearbook; (above) “Scenes On Gowanie Golf Course” is taken from a July 1928 Nellis News article called “Pageant of Progress.” The going wasn’t easy. A mere 90 members remained after the bankruptcy dust settled — up considerably today with the addition of younger, intermediate, and social members (but like most private clubs, they could use more). Another setback occurred in 2007 when fire gutted the old clubhouse. It was rebuilt in 2008. Gowanie remains a hidden jewel — tucked away on nearly 100 acres off of I-94. The home course for Grosse Pointe South and Regina high schools, it also boasts a strong junior program. While it’s relatively short (6,398 yards), Gowanie’s fast and true greens and narrow fairways are a test. The club has hosted U.S. Open qualifiers and numerous GAM qualifiers; very few contestants break par. Gowanie prides itself on being strictly a golf club — no pool, no tennis. “It’s a friendly community of people who get the heart of this truly special place,” says Kathy. There are longstanding members (some since the 1950s), as well as staff. Paul Prigel, the golf professional, and his brother Mark, the locker room manager, grew up at Gowanie. Their parents worked here; a third generation (Paul’s son) works in the pro shop. Adding to the idea that people don’t want to leave Gowanie: There’s a rumored ghost named “Rosemary” — perhaps a former “schoolmarm” who lived in a house that served as Gowanie’s first clubhouse. “We blame her when we can’t find things,” Kathy says. — Steve Wilke photographs courtesy gowanie golf club. news clipping courtesy macomb county. Found MICHIGAN LINKS | WWW.GAM.ORG 28_Links Past.indd 1 10/27/09 2:07:06 PM Save Save up to $500 ** aa year insurance. year on on your car insurance. Golf could receive receive special specialrates rateson onauto auto GolfAssociation Associationof ofMichigan Michigan members members could insurance that has has helped helpedmany manyof ofits itscustomers customers insurancefrom fromNationwide® Nationwide®,, aa company company that save saveup upto to$500* $500*aayear yearon on their their auto auto policies. policies. We Wecan canalso alsooffer: offer: • One home, boat, boat,RV, RV,motorcycle motorcycleand andmore! more! • OneStop StopConvenience–insurance Convenience–insurance for for your your car, car, home, • Outstanding phone. • OutstandingService–in Service–inperson, person, online online and and by by phone. customerswho whofiled filedaaclaim claimwould would • Superior Nationwide customers • SuperiorSatisfaction–9 Satisfaction–9out outof of10** 10** Nationwide recommend recommendNationwide Nationwideto totheir theirfamily family and and friends. friends. Ask Ask us us for for a quote! Nationwide NationwideInsurance® Insurance® Toll TollFree: Free:1-866-556-SAVE 1-866-556-SAVE (7283) Be Besure sureto tomention mention you’re you’re a member! Teaming Teamingup upwith with Nationwide® Nationwide® *Average annual savings based ononNationwide 2007. *Average annual savings based Nationwidepolicyholder policyholderdata datagathered gatherednationally nationally through July 2007. **Based onon a survey conducted nationally **Based a survey conducted nationallyon onNationwide Nationwidecustomers customerswho whofiled filed aa claim claim in 2007. Nationwide is an Equal Housing Opportunity Nationwide is an Equal Housing OpportunityInsurer. Insurer. Products underwritten byby Nationwide Nationwide Lloyds Lloydsand andNationwide NationwideProperty Property&&Casualty CasualtyCompanies Companies TX). Home Office: Columbus, Products underwritten NationwideMutual MutualInsurance InsuranceCompany Companyand andAffiliated Affiliated Companies. Companies. Nationwide (in(in TX). Home Office: Columbus, OHOH 43215. Subject toto underwriting availableto toall allpersons personsininall allstates. states.Nationwide, Nationwide,the the Nationwide framemark, and Your Side, 43215. Subject underwritingguidelines, guidelines,review, review,and andapproval. approval. Products Products and and discounts discounts not available Nationwide framemark, and OnOn Your Side, areare federally registered service marks ofofNationwide Mutual Insurance InsuranceCompany. Company.All Allrights rightsreserved. reserved. federally registered service marks NationwideMutual MutualInsurance InsuranceCompany. Company. © © 2009 2009 Nationwide Mutual 888 W. Big Beaver Suite 115 Troy, MI. 48084 (248) 362-3888 www.Prlanta.com U.S. Pat. No. 7,007,507 Since 1971, Prlanta has been known for their exclusive selection of fine and custom jewelry at wholesale prices. Accompanied by a team of skilled designers, proficient goldsmiths, and meticulous stone setters who work diligently with you to make all of your jewelry dreams a reality. U.S. Pat. No. 7,007,507 • © • All rights reserved • PA N D OR A - J E WE L R Y . C OM U.S. Pat. No. 7,007,507 • © • All rights reserved • PANDORA- JEW ELRY.COM U.S. Pat. No. 7,007,507 • © • All rights reserved • P A N DO R A- J E W E L R Y . CO M FOR ELEGANCE & SOPHISTICATION, CHOOSE THE JEWELER’S JEWELER. Hours Mon, Tues, Wed & Fri 10-6 Thursday 10-7 Saturday 10-5 888 W. Big Beaver Road Suite 115 Troy, Michigan 48084 (248) 362-3888 www.Prlanta.com