1. Dr. Farizah Muhd Hairi
Transcription
1. Dr. Farizah Muhd Hairi
Symposium: Symposium: Enhancing quality of life of the Enhancing quality of life of the elderly elderly Problems, Policies and Program to Improve Quality of Life of the Improve Quality of Life of the Warga Emas in Malaysia Associate Professor Dr Farizah Associate Professor Dr Farizah Mohd Hairi University of Malaya farizah@ummc edu my farizah@ummc.edu.my Outline • I. Challenges • II. Policies • III. Programs *Also would like to acknowledge that some slides are shared by Dr Mohmad Bin Salleh, Senior Principal Assistant Director, Sector of Elderly Health, Division of Family Health Development Division of Family Health Development, Ministry of Health, Malaysia. Challenges – warga emas Challenges – Challenges • Demographic changes • Health challenges among warga emas • Implications Social Economic Health 3 Demography Number Number of Elderly in the World of Elderly in the World and % in Developing Countries Year Population 60 yr old and above (million) % in developing countries 2000 614 62 2025 1,200 72 2050 2,000 80 Source: United Nations, 2001 Rate of general population growth Rate of general population growth ~ 50 % 50 % BUT growth rate for the elderly ~75 % Countries with 10 million population or almost (in the year 2002) with the highest number of elderly 2002 2025 Italy 24.5% Japan 35.1% Japan 24.3% Italy 34.0% Germany 24.0% Germany 33.2% Greece 23.9% Greece 31.6% Belgium 22.3% Spain 31.4% Spain 22.1% Belgium 31.2% Portugal 21 1% 21.1% United Kingdom 29 4% 29.4% United Kingdom 20.8& Netherlands 29.4% Ukraine 20.7% % France 28.7% % France 20.5% Canada 27.9% Source: United Nations,, 2001 Penduduk Warga Emas (60 (60+ tahun tahun) di Malaysia, 1947 tahun)) di Malaysia, 1947 tahun ) di Malaysia, 1947‐ 1947‐2050 22 20 20 17 18 Percentage (%) P 16 “Negara tua” (aged nation) apabila w. emas > 60 = 15% jumlah penduduk 16 15 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 1947 1957 1970 1980 Total population (60+) 1991 2000 2010 Male (60+) 2020 2030 2035 2040 2050 Female (60+) Sources: 1. Department of Statistics,2006 & 2011 2. United Nations, 2010 World Population Prospects: The 2010 Revision. Retrieved from web Population Division, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, http://esa.un.org/unpp/ Number and Percentage of Number and Percentage of Warga Warga Emas by States, 2010 10.7 320.0 280.0 240 0 240.0 7.9 9.0 8.4 7.6 9.4 12.0 10.1 N % 10.0 8.6 8.1 7.7 6.6 200.0 6.3 7.7 80 8.0 5.8 5.0 160.0 6.0 120.0 4.0 80.0 40.0 2.0 252.7 167.0 123.9 67.1 85.1 114.2 140.8 252.9 24.4 326.3 71.0 200.0 141.9 0.0 3.5 118.7 0.0 State High percentage of older persons 60+ / rapidly ageing states Percentt 60+ (%) Numberr 60+ ('000) MALAYSIA, 2010 [60+; N = 2067.0, % = 7.7] Speed of Population Ageing (Doubling of 65+ Population from 7% to 14%) Developed Countries 115 France (1865 - 1980) 85 Sweden (1890 - 1975) 73 Australia (1938 - 2011) 69 United States (1944 - 2013) 53 Hungary (1941 - 1994) 45 United Kingdom (1930 - 1975) Japan (1970 - 1996) 26 Developing Countries 33 Azerbaijian (2004 - 2037) 26 China (2000 - 2026) Source: Kinsella and He, 2009; and U.S. Census Bureau, International Data Base, accessed on October 20, 2010. Sri Lanka (2002 - 2026) 24 Malaysia (2020 - 2043) 23 Thailand (2002 - 2024) 22 Columbia (2017 - 2036) 19 Singapore (2000 - 2019) 19 South Korea (2000 - 2018) 18 Population p Pyramids y Slide : Prof. Gary Andrews Aust. …….factors contribute to increase ratio of warga increase ratio of warga emas …… ‐ increase life expectancy ‐ decrease birth rate ‐ decrease death rate ‐ migration ‐ internall ‐ external Life Expectancy At Birth, Malaysia, 1957 ‐‐ 2012 Life Expectancy At Birth, Malaysia, 1957 Age Years Male Female 1957 55.8 58.2 1985 67.0 72.5 1990 69.0 74.0 199 1997 69 69.5 74.4 44 2000 70.2 75.0 2003 71.0 75.5 2006 71.8 76.3 2007 71.7 76.4 2011 72.2 76.8 2013 * 72.6 77.2 Source: Health Facts 2014, MOH, June 2014 Population aging • Population aging was first observed in developed countries, but more recently this phenomenon has extensively occurred in developing countries. countries • In Malaysia, mortality rates among the elderly group are on the In Malaysia, mortality rates among the elderly group are on the decrease, which means there will be more elderly group in the coming decades. Health Challenges Among Warga Emas B By 2020 By 2020; 2020 • it is projected that three‐quarters of all deaths p j ee qua e s o a dea s in developing countries could be ageing‐related, • the largest share of these deaths will be th l t h f th d th ill b caused by non‐communicable diseases, such as di diseases of the cardiovascular system, cancers f th di l t and diabetes, • the number of people affected by senile dementia in Africa, Asia and Latin America may , y exceed 55 million ‐ Active Ageing: A Policy Framework Active Ageing: A Policy Framework (WHO/NMH/NPH/02.8) ….. Malaysia……. •Study by MOH (1995), among rural elderly:‐ ‐ 77.1% elderly able to move independently. ‐ 1.3% bedridden. ‐ 16.5% considered themselves as in “good” 16 5% id d th l i “ d” health condition (Urban ‐ 6% ‐ study by ISIS & LPPKN, 1991). ‐ 69.7% considered themselves as in “fair” health condition (Urban ‐ 65% ‐ study by ISIS & LPPKN, 1991). (Urban ‐ 29% “poor” health – study by ISIS & LPPKN, 1991). ….. Malaysia……. Malaysia •The study also showed:‐ ‐ 81.4% suffered from at least from one chronic medical illness. ‐ 12.7% had 3 or more chronic diseases. •The commonest medical illness:‐ Th t di l ill ‐ joint paint ‐ eyesight problem i ht bl ‐ hearing problem ‐ hypertension hypertension ‐ heart diseases ‐ diabetes diabetes 50.1% 40% 21% 26% 16.3% 11 6% 11.6% ….. Malaysia……. • Study by ISIS & LPPKN (1991), among urban elderly:‐ • The commonest medical illness:‐ The commonest medical illness: ‐ weakness in arms and legs poor vision ‐p ‐ respiratory problem ‐ urinary tract ‐ heart problem ‐ digestive tract ‐ back bone back bone ‐ others 35.8% 19.3% 13.8% 11.9% 11.0% 5.5% 1 8% 1.8% 0.9% 1st Five Morbidities Among Malaysian Five Morbidities Among Malaysian Warga Warga Emas (Return BPKK) 30 20 Hipertension p Diabetes Joint Problem Heart Problem Repiratory Problem Eye 15 10 2013 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 0 2005 5 2004 Percentag ge 25 Year Morbidities Morbidities Among Malaysian Warga Morbidities Among Malaysian Among Malaysian Warga Emas (NHMS III) (NHMS III) Prevalence (%) 95% CI Lower Upper Hypertension 73.7 72.3 75.1 Hypercholesterolemia 37.9 36.3 39.5 Diabetes Mellitus 23 6 23.6 22 3 22.3 24 8 24.8 Asthma Adult 6.2 5.5 6.9 Physical Disability 2.4 2.0 2.9 - Underweight 11.0 10.1 12.0 - Normal 48.4 46.9 49.9 - Overweight 29 8 29.8 28 4 28.4 31 2 31.2 - Obese 10.8 9.9 11.7 Nutritional Status - BMI Prevalence of chronic diseases among warga Prevalence Prevalence of chronic diseases among of chronic diseases among warga warga emas in Malaysia emas in Malaysia • Increasing in life expectancy and number of elderly result in increased cases of chronic diseases. • The most common prevalence of chronic diseases among elderly in Malaysia were Malaysia were • • • • • cardiovascular diseases (21.1%), neoplasms (16.8%), urinary diseases (13 9%) urinary diseases (13.9%), respiratory diseases (7.7%) and metabolic diseases (7.1). Implications/issues due to population ageing • Social Implication ‐ dependency ratio/aged dependency ‐ labour source ‐ availability of care givers ‐ feminization ageing ‐ g g lebih ramai warga g emas wanita yyang hidup g p bersendirian (kerana jangka hayat mereka lebih panjang daripada lelaki). ‐ living arrangements living arrangements – penyediaan tempat kediaman yang sesuai yang sesuai untuk warga emas bersesuaian dengan kebolehan fizikal serta mental mereka. ‐ public facilities – public facilities kemudahan awam sesuai dengan warga emas seperti tempat rekreasi/riadah, pengangkutan awam, keselematan jalanraya, t d lif tandas, lif, susur t tangan ( (ramps) dan ) d sebagainya. b i • Economic implication • Health implication Beban Penduduk Kumpulan Umur Bekerja (I5 ‐‐ 64 Tahun) Menanggung Seorang Warga Emas (I5 Tahun 2004 = 11 pekerja* Source: Statistical Department, Malaysia Dependency Ratio 100 Youth Dependence Ratio (0-14) 90 Old Age Dependency Ratio (65+) T o t a l D e p e n d e n c y R a t io 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 1970* 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 Year 2020 2030 2040 2050 There is a decrease in the youth dependency ratio, but an increase in , old age dependency ratio. The falling birth rate results in a lowering total dependency ratio, but as population ageing continues, the overall ratio rises again. Policies • Malaysia’s Vision 2020 • Health Vision • Goals of health care system • National N ti l Policy P li for f Older Old Persons, P 1995 (rev ( 2010) • National Health Policy for Older Persons, 2008 27 MALAYSIA’S VISION 2020 By The Year 2020, Malaysia Is To Be A United Nation With A Confident Malaysia Society: a ays a Soc e y • Infused By Strong Moral & Ethical Values • Living In Society That Is Democratic, Liberal, Tolerant & Caring • Economically Just & Equitable, Progressive & Prosperous Economically Just & Equitable Progressive & Prosperous • In Full Possession Of An Economy That Is Competitive, Dynamic, Robust And Resilient b d l HEALTH VISION Malaysia is to be a nation of healthy individuals, families and communities Characteristics of future healthcare system •Equitable •Affordable •Efficient •Technologically appropriate •Environmentally y adaptable p •Consumer friendly Emphasis of future healthcare system •Quality •Innovation Innovation •Health promotion •Respect for human dignity •Promotion of individual responsibility •Promotion of community participation GOALS GOALS OF HEALTH CARE SYSTEM OF HEALTH CARE SYSTEM • Wellness Focus (tumpuan kepada kesejahteraan) • Person Focus (tumpuan kepada individu) Person Focus (tumpuan kepada individu) • Informed Person (individu berpengetahuan) • Self Help (kendiri) • Care Provided At Home Or Close To Home • Seamless, Continuous Care • Services Tailored To Individual Or Group Need Services Tailored To Individual Or Group Need • Effective, Efficient And Affordable Services GOVERNMENT’S RESPONSE • Establishment of National Policy for Older Persons (1995, revised 2010) and Action Plan of National Policy for Older Persons (1999, revised 2010) – A unified, holistic, inter-sectoral national policy. – Formation of National Advisory and Consultative Council for the Older Persons with the Department of Social Welfare as the national secretariat. • • • National Plan of Action for Health Care of Older Persons (1997) - MOH. N i National lT Technical h i lC Committee i ffor Health of the Older Persons (1998) - MOH. National Health Policy for Older Persons (2008) - MOH. National Policy for Older Persons National Policy for Older Persons is a government commitment to create a society of senior citizens who are i t f i iti h independent, contented and possess a high sense of self‐worth and dignity, by g g y y optimizing their potential through healthy, positive, active and productive ageing to improve their well being along ageing to improve their well‐being along with national development. Improvement in Improvement Improvement in National Policy for Older in National Policy for Older National Policy for Older Persons Giving priority for preparation during old age; Giving priority on strengthening relationship among the older persons as well as inter‐ generation; and Improve mechanism of implementation and I h i f i l t ti d monitoring by formation of committee at the national, state at district level. ti l t t t di t i t l l Majlis Penasihat dan Perundingan Warga Emas Negara PELAKSANAAN DASA AR Jawatankuasa Teknikal g Emas Negara g Dasar Warga Pengerusi: Y.B. Menteri Urus setia: Jabatan Kebajikan Masyarakat Pengerusi: Ketua Setiausaha Urus setia: Bahagian Dasar, KPWKM 7 JAWATANKUASA KECIL 1 Jawatankuasa 1. J t k K il kesihatan Kecil k ih t 2. Jawatankuasa Kecil Sosial dan Rekreasi 3. Jawatankuasa Kecil Pendidikan d Kerohanian dan K h i 4. Jawatankuasa Kecil Perumahan dan Persekitaran 5. Jawatankuasa Kecil Ekonomi 6 Jawatankuasa 6. J t k K il Pekerjaan Kecil P k j 7. Jawatankuasa Kecil Penyelidikan dan Pembangunan NEGERI Majlis Tindakan Negeri Majlis Tindakan Daerah/ Pihak Berkuasa Tempatan Jawatankuasa Pembangunan Warga Emas Negeri Jawatankuasa Pembangunan Warga Emas Daerah/ Pihak Berkuasa Tempatan Pengerusi: Timbalan SUK Urus setia: JKM Negeri Pengerusi: Ketua Penolong Pegawai Daerah Urus setia: PKMD 10 National Health Policy for the Older Person (2008) To ensure healthy, active and productive ageing by productive ageing by empowering the older persons, family and community with knowledge, skills, an enabling environment; and the provision of optimal health care services at all levels and by all sectors. sectors. The Rationale of the Policy • Seven rationales; • Among it: Are not always accorded appropriate attention or treatment A t l d d i t tt ti t t t because their ailments are considered to be the result of age itself. Financially disadvantaged compared to when they were employed. Principles For Service Provision (stated in the Policy) • Six principles; Six principles; • Among it: Recognising the Distinctive Needs of Older Person ‐ Health services should provide older person with choices. This should include choice between types of service methods and quality of service delivery as between types of service, methods and quality of service delivery as well as the provision of services Promoting Healthy Ageing ‐ All services for older person should optimize their opportunities for healthy ageing through the life course perspective on ageing and the encouragement of planning for a healthy old age. a healthy old age. Providing Continuity of Care ‐ Older persons who are ill or who have a disability require continuity of care. Their access to support services and the standard of care available to them should be maintained Goal • to achieve optimal health through to achieve optimal health through integrated and comprehensive health and health related services. Objectives • Four objectives outlined; • Among it: To improve the health status of older persons. To provide age friendly, affordable, equitable, accessible, cultural acceptable, gender sensitive, accessible, cultural acceptable, gender sensitive, seamless health care services in a holistic manner at all levels. Strategies: 1. Development of a continuum of health care services 2. Interagency / intersectoral collaboration Interagency / intersectoral collaboration 3. Research and development 4. Human resource planning and development 5. Health promotion 6. Legislation 7 Information system 7. I f i Plan of Action Primary Care Secondary and Tertiary Care y y Health education and p promotion R & D Inter Inter‐sectoral sectoral collaboration collaboration Legislative Programs • Services • Issues / Constraints I /C t i t what works and what doesn’t? 42 Ministry Of Health http://www2.moh.gov.my/images/gallery/carta_org/carta_besar_bm‐100713.png Public Health Devision Public Health Devision at Federal Level 45 The Services The Services Services Three main services: • medical ( hospital ) • health ( health clinic ) • ‘institution’ institution Health Care Services for Warga for Warga Emas Pilot project: Health Care Services for Warga Pilot project: Health Care Services for Warga Emas • year 1996 1996 • 4 health clinics: 4 health clinics: ‐ H.C. Kuala Kedah (Kota Setar) ‐ H.C. Parit Baru (Sabak Bernam) ‐ H.C. Sungai Mati (Muar) ‐ H.C. Karak (Bentong) • 1 hospital – Hospital Seremban …. medical …. medical and health services …. medical medical and health services….. and health services….. services….. a) Medical ( hospital ) a). i. Acute medical cares ii. Long term care iii. Discharge plan iv. Psychogeriatric care v. Physiotherapy vi. Occupational therapy vii. Clinical pharmacy viii. Counselling ix. Medico social / welfare …. medical and health services….. b). Health services (at health clinics):‐ i. Health education and promotion. ii. Screening and assessment ‐ memory status, ADL, IADL, fall, incontinence, etc. iii. Medical examination, counseling, treatment and referral. iv. Home visits and home nursing. v. Rehabilitation. h bl vi. Recreation, social and welfare. …. medical and health services….. b). health services (at health clinics.):‐ i. Health education and p promotion. …. activities at health clinics …… ii. Health screening and assessment. …. activities at health clinics …… ii. …. health screening and assessment…… ….. …. activities at health clinics …… iii. Medical examination, treatment and counseling. …. activities at health clinics …… iii. …medical examination, , treatment and counseling ….. Counseling by trained g y Ahli Panel Penasihat for their colleague. …. activities at health clinics …… iv. Home visiting and home nursing. …. activities at health clinics …… v. Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. …. activities at health clinics …… v. ….physiotherapy and occupational therapy ….. …. activities at health clinics …… vi. Social, recreation and welfare. …. medical and health services….. c). Institutional Services i. Long‐term residential care ii ii. Respite care Respite care iii. Day care • Currently, the Social Welfare Department, Non‐ Government Organisations and private nursing homes are providing institutional services. Services for elderly Services for elderly emphasize on community participation. h i i i i i ‘‘provide’ physical, mental, social and spiritual well‐ id ’ h i l t l i l d i it l ll being. caring concept. involvement of NGOs, private sectors and involvement of NGOs private sectors and communities – indicate the success of the programs. effort to make hospitals and health clinics elderly‐ friendly. Achievements - Hospital that provide the services (9) - Geriatricians (10 MOH – 7 univ. – 6 private) - Psychogeriatricians y g ((8 MOH – 3 univ.)) - No. of health clinics provide the services • ~ 300 health personals (AMO and nurses) undergone post‐basic training in “Gerontology Nursing” upgraded to “Advance upgraded to Advance Diploma in Gerontology Diploma in Gerontology Nursing” • > 27k health personals had been trained in “Healthcare for the Elderly” (in‐service training) • ~ 23k carers had been trained Trained Overseas Trained Overseas • 4 Medical Gerontologists (doctor with master in gerontology) gerontology). • 4 did attachment in Australia – Community Geriatric • 5 attended Short Course in Gerontology (in Singapore) 5 attended Short Course in Gerontology (in Singapore) organised by International Institute on Ageing, United Nation, Malta and NGO in S’pore. • 1 attended Short Course in Gerontology in Malta. • 2 did attachment in Hong Kong in community paticipation (elderly care) (elderly care). • 2 did attachment in Japan (JICA Program ). 2 Dr 2 PPP 2 Nurses 2 OTs 2 PTs did attachment in • 2 Dr, 2 PPP, 2 Nurses, 2 OTs, 2 PTs did attachment in Australia. • 1 nurses did study visit to England. Health education materials 1. Proses Penuaan. Phamplet 2. Panduan Pemakanan Untuk Warga Tua. Phamplet 3. Panduan Kearah Penjagaan Kesihatan Mulut Warga Tua. Phamplet 4. Apakah Masalah Pergigian Yang Dihadapi Oleh Warga Tua? Phamplet 5 5. Penjagaan Dentur Phamplet 6. Pemeriksaan Kesihatan Untuk Warga Tua. Phamplet 7. Osteoporosis (Kerapuhan Tulang). Phamplet 8. Insomnia (Kesukaran Tidur). Phamplet ……bahan …… bahan‐‐bahan pendidikan kesihatan…. kesihatan…. 9. Arthritis (Sakit Sendi). Phamplet 10. Keusiaan dan Kasih Sayang Phamplet 11. Menyesuaikan Diri Anda Di Usia Tua Phamplet 12 Senaman 12. S K Kearah h Warga W Tua Cergas. C Phamplet h l 13. Panduan Pemakanan Warga Tua Di Institusi. Booklet 14. Panduan Untuk Penjaga Warga Tua Manual 15. Senaman Warga Tua CD & Tape 16. Teknik Mengangkat dan Mengalih Warga Emas CD & Buku, booklet ……bahan …… bahan‐‐bahan pendidikan kesihatan…. kesihatan…. 17. Osteoarthritis Lutut. Phamplet 18. Jatuh. Phamplet p 19. Senaman Aerobik Warga Emas. Phamplet 20 Warga 20. W E Emas d Senaman. dan S Ph Phamplet l t 21. Penuaan Sihat Phamplet. 22. Dementia Phamplet MyHealth @ http://www.myhealth.gov.my Bahagian Pembangunan Kesihatan Keluarga http://fh.moh.gov.my The Elderly The Elderly …. in in the Health Clinic Guideline to Guideline to Implement p Healthcare Service for the Elderly Guideline to Implement Implement Healthcare Service for the Elderly • S.O.P • Activities • Elderly friendly facilities • Targets/indicators • Committees Issues / Constraints (what works and what doesn’t?) ‐ manpower, manpower, manpower ‐ (money) ??? ( ) ‐ lack of interagency collaboration: lack of interagency collaboration: e.g. multiple agencies do training KKM – carers JKM volunteers JKM – other NGOs – carers ‐ Stigma for the older person: • are not always accorded appropriate attention or treatment because their ailments are considered to be the result of age itself. ‐ Older persons often described in terms of: cost factors, • cost factors, • burden of the future • dependent individuals, d d t i di id l • lacking social autonomy, neglected, and a burden to the producing world. ‐ One coordinator for research in elderly heath issues O di t f h i ld l h th i ‐ Issue on old folk home which have nursing g activities Currently two acts C tl t t ‐ Laws to protect elderly (Child Law) p y( ) ‐ Power of Attorney, elderly abuse issues, work di i i ti /di i i ti discrimination/discrimination at work place, t k l driving, etc. Global Commitment Global Commitment • Vienna International POA on Ageing 1982 g g • Health of Elderly Report 1989 • Brasilia Declaration on Ageing and Health 1996 Brasilia Declaration on Ageing and Health 1996 • Madrid International POA on Ageing 2002 • Active Ageing – A ti A i A P li F A Policy Framework 2002 k 2002 • Beijing Declaration • Asia Pacific International POA on Ageing • ……………… Note: POA = Plan of Action Having said so …….. g * * * * * • Healthy Ageing / Successful Ageing / * Active Ageing * • Ageing Process and Process Of * * * Ageing • Add Years to Life and Add Life to Years International Day of Older Persons International Day of Older Persons • 1st October 1991 • 2015: Theme 2015 Th Sustainability and Age Inclusiveness in the Urban Environment 82 WOMAN When she is 18 ‐ She is a football, 22 men going after her. , g g When she is 28 ‐ She is a hockey ball, 8 men going after her. When she is 38 ‐ She is a golf ball, 1 man hitting on her. When she is 48 ‐ >She is a pingpong ball, 2 men pushing to each other. At the age of 60? MAN At 20 ‐ A man is like a coconut, so much to offer, so little to give. At 30 ‐ He is like a durian, dangerous but delicious. At 30 He is like a durian dangerous but delicious At 40 ‐ He is like a watermelon, big, round and juicy. At 50 ‐ He is like a mandarin orange, the season comes once in a year. At 60 ‐ He is just like a raisin, dried out, wrinkles and cheap. At 60 ‐ He is just like a raisin dried out wrinkles and cheap S h t So what would you like to be? ld lik t b ? Ageing is a privilege and a societal achievement. It is also a challenge, which will impact on all aspects of 21st century society. It is a challenge that cannot be addressed by the public or private sectors in isolation: it addressed by the public or private sectors in isolation: it requires joint approaches and strategies. Take Take Home Message Home Message • If you want to go fast, If you want to go fast, go alone. • If you want to go far, If you want to go far, go together. If you want to go far, go together. 85 f i h@ farizah@ummc.edu.my d 86