Molybdenum - an extraordinary metal in high demand

®
I MO A
INTERNATIONAL MOLYBDENUM ASSOCIATION
Molybdenum - an extraordinary metal in high demand
By Hans Imgrund and Nicole Kinsman, International Molybdenum Association
Ferromolybdenum (left); Roasting molybdenite concentrate (right). Courtesy of Molymet, Chile
A reprint from the September 2007 issue of Stainless Steel World
International Molybdenum Association
Rue Père Eudore Devroye 245, 1150 Brussels, Belgium
Tel: +32 2 770 8878 · Fax: +32 2 770 8898
e-mail: info@imoa.info · www.imoa.info
Molybdenum - an extraordi
The US Air Force Memorial in Arlington, Virginia,
USA, was designed by James Ingo Freed. It features three curved spires of welded, 19mm-thick,
type 316 stainless steel plate up to 82 metres in
height. Photo: Patrick McCafferty.
20
S T A I N L E S S
S T E E L
W O R L D
J U L Y / A U G U S T
2 0 0 7
www.stainless-steel-world.net
imoa
29-08-2007
15:24
Pagina 21
inary metal in high demand
The recent nickel shortage has attracted a lot of attention. What is less known is that molybdenum too is in ever greater demand, with tightening supplies and soaring prices. A world-wide
boom in infrastructure projects, especially those which have critical applications, has fuelled
demand for this versatile metal. Stainless Steel World asked Nicole Kinsman and Hans Imgrund of
the International Molybdenum Association to explain the background and indicate what the future
may hold. Their findings suggest that supplies will remain tight in the short term, but that the
long-term supply prospects are looking good.
By Hans Imgrund and Nicole Kinsman, International Molybdenum Association
Introductory
In the last four years demand for
molybdenum soared by 35 per cent.
This surge comes mainly from a
strong world-wide push to invest in
industrial infrastructure: from a factory building boom in China to a
rush to develop oilfields, many projects rely on the help of materials
containing molybdenum.
All this activity has trickled down to
Molybdenum facts
• About 25 per cent of all molybdenum produced is used to make
moly-grade stainless steel.
• About 50 per cent is used for other iron-based metals, such as construction steel, tool and high-speed
steel and cast iron.
• Molybdenum as an alloying element in steel is almost always used
in combination with other elements
such as chromium, nickel, vanadium, tungsten or niobium.
• Steel mills add molybdenum either
as molybdenum oxide or ferromolybdenum.
• The remaining 25 per cent is purified and used as moly metal, as an
alloying element in nickel and other
super alloys, as catalysts, lubricants, flame retardants, corrosion
inhibitors and pigments.
• Super alloy producers use moly
metal pellets as a high-purity alloying addition.
www.stainless-steel-world.net
an increase in demand for the metal
and the transformation of a market
that had been stagnant for nearly 20
years. Molybdenum has diverse appeal: it is used in pipelines, to improve strength to transport oil and
gas under high pressure; in processing vessels in the chemical industry,
to withstand corrosion in an array
of solutions; and even in sculptures,
such as the US Air Force Memorial,
which is located just across the river
from Washington, DC, to keep their
finish shiny for a long time.
The global interest in going “green”
has also had an impact: as more
companies reduce plant waste by recycling their waste streams within
factory walls, moly-grade stainless
steels handle the higher corrosiveness that comes with higher concentration of aggressive substances.
Compounds of the element that allows steels to resist high tempera-
tures and stainless steels to resist corrosive environments can also work
as an effective lubricant, as a catalyst
for the production of oil products or
as a pigment to make orange paint.
How molybdenum metal is
used
The most important properties of
pure molybdenum metal and molybdenum alloys are their high melting
point (in the order of 2600°C), high
temperature resistance, high wear resistance and good corrosion resistance. These products are often used
in applications that require high
strength at high temperature, while
their coefficient of expansion and
thermal conductivity also make
them valuable to the electronics industry. Products made of molybdenum metal and molybdenum base
alloys include metal powder, wire,
sheet, bar and specialised powders.
The price for molybdenum has spiked recently but was at low levels for much of the last 25 years.
(Source: Metals Week)
S T A I N L E S S
S T E E L
W O R L D
S E P T E M B E R
2 0 0 7
21
MATERIAL S
Materials
Materials
Examples of the metal’s uses include parts of industrial furnaces,
support wire for tungsten filaments
in light bulbs, glass melting equipment, electronic equipment, and
metal and plastic forming equipment. One example of a metalforming product is a piercing plug.
It is made of TZM (a molybdenum
alloy, dispersion-strengthened with
titanium carbide and zirconium oxide) and used for the production of
stainless steel tubing. Such piercing
plugs are made of TZM because
they must have high strength and
high wear resistance at the high
rolling temperature of stainless steel
(see photo.)
Making a better stainless
steel
Molybdenum is added to stainless
steels to increase corrosion resistance. About 10 per cent of stainless
steel production contains molybdenum, of which the content averages
about 2 per cent. Traditionally the
most important moly-grade stainless
steel is the austenitic type 316 (18%
Cr, 10% Ni and 2 or 2.5% Mo),
which represents about 7 per cent of
global stainless steel production. In
recent years moly-grade ferritics
have grown fast. These include
types 444 (18% Cr, 2% Mo), 436
(18% Cr, 1.25% Mo) and 434 (17%
Cr and 1% Mo). The combined tonnage of moly-grade ferritics has
jumped from 47,000 metric tons in
2002 to 366,000 tons in 2005, according to the International
Stainless Steel Forum. Their percentage of total stainless production has
grown from 0.3 per cent to 1.7 per
cent in just three years. Duplex
stainless steels have also been growing strongly to an estimated
200,000 metric tons in 2006.
TZM piercing plug for the production (rolling) of
stainless steel tubes (courtesy of Plansee).
www.stainless-steel-world.net
This sculpture right next to the ocean shows corrosion staining on type 304 stainless steel due to
incorrect grade selection in a demanding environment.
Industrial sectors
The most important uses of molygrade stainless steel are industrial.
The chemical and petrochemical, oil
and gas, paper, power, water, food
and pharmaceutical industries use
processing equipment made of molygrade austenitic and duplex stainless
steels.
Moly-grade stainless steel is also used
in architectural applications. The correct selection of stainless steel in
these applications is essential to avoid
unpleasant surprises, for instance
where a moly-free grade was used
next to the ocean (see photo).
Because the stainless steel selected
here is not corrosion-resistant enough
for this difficult environment, this
sculpture has to be cleaned from superficial corrosion staining every year.
The US Air Force Memorial, using a
moly-grade type 316 stainless steel
S T A I N L E S S
S T E E L
(which contains 2 per cent molybdenum) will most likely not have this
problem (see photo).
Making a stronger alloy steel
Molybdenum enhances hardenability, strength and toughness, and elevates the temperature resistance of
constructional steels. It is often used
in combination with chromium
and/or nickel and other alloying elements, with the molybdenum content typically ranging from 0.2 to
1.2 per cent. Moly-grade steel categories include heat-treatable engineering steels, case-hardened steels,
high-temperature steels, oil country
tubular goods and HSLA (High
Strength, Low Alloy) steels. These
grades are used in all kinds of engineered products for automotive,
shipbuilding, aircraft and aerospace
industries; drilling, mining and pro-
W O R L D
S E P T E M B E R
2 0 0 7
23
Materials
These mill cutters are made of high-speed steel with 5 per cent Mo (courtesy of Boehler Edelstahl).
cessing industries; and energy generation industries. Products include
vessels, tanks and heat exchangers,
gears and shafts, piping and many
more.
Making a longer-lasting tool
steel
Molybdenum contributes to secondary hardening (in combination with
vanadium) in tool steels. It also separates the pearlite and bainite reactions, and therefore allows step
quenching. Products made of tool
steels include hand tools, knives
and saws, forging dies, pressure casting moulds and molding plates. The
typical molybdenum content in tool
steels is around 0.8 per cent.
Molybdenum contributes to secondary hardening and is an important
constituent of the primary M6C carbide, which makes high-speed steels
more wear-resistant. Principal uses
are for cutting tools and saws for
steel, cast and non-ferrous materials,
twist drills, milling cutters (see photo) and pushing tools. The average
molybdenum content in high-speed
steels is around 5 per cent.
www.stainless-steel-world.net
Molybdenum mining
The main regions of molybdenum
mining include South America,
North America and China. These regions accounted for 93 per cent of
global production in 2006, which
was estimated to be 422 million
pounds (192,000 metric tons).
Roughly 60 per cent of molybdenum is produced as a by-product of
another mining operation, most
commonly copper production. The
ore from copper mines which also
produce molybdenum usually contains between 0.5 and 1.5 per cent
copper (5 to 15 kg per metric ton of
ore) and between 0.01 and 0.05 per
cent molybdenum (0.1 to 0.5 kg/t).
Major operations mine more than
50 million tons of ore per year, producing over 200,000 tons of copper
and between 5,000 and 15,000 tons
of moly. For every kilo of copper,
between 20 and 40 grams of moly is
extracted.
For these producers, it is a relatively
inexpensive step to extract molybdenum from the ore that is already
ground up to take out copper. The
revenues from molybdenum are
S T A I N L E S S
S T E E L
usually less than 10 per cent of total sales. Therefore, the molybdenum output does not necessarily
follow the demand for molybdenum but the demand for copper.
The moly output automatically increases when the mine increases its
copper production and it falls when
the mine decreases its copper production because demand for copper
falls.
Mining for moly only (primary production) is much more expensive. A
primary mine in the West, with an
annual production capacity in the
order of 10,000 tons of molybdenum (22 million lbs), takes an investment of several hundred million US dollars to open. Of the 40
per cent molybdenum from primary mines, 25 per cent is produced in China and the CIS and 15
per cent in the West.
Ore grades in primary mines contain between 0.12 and 0.20 per cent
moly. Thus, the production of
10,000 tons of Mo requires mining
and milling in excess of 5 million
tons of ore per year. The cost of this
has to be borne by the revenue
W O R L D
S E P T E M B E R
2 0 0 7
25
imoa
29-08-2007
15:24
Pagina 26
Materials
from molybdenum alone. Therefore
the production of primary molybdenum is significantly more costly
than the production of by-product
molybdenum. The primary mines
are swing producers, i.e. they increase their production when the
market has higher demand for
molybdenum and decrease their
production when the demand is
down.
The changing structure of
the industry
The balance of molybdenum mining has shifted over the years from
mainly primary production to
mainly by-product production. As
copper companies have increased
and optimized the recovery of
molybdenum, the amount of byproduct molybdenum produced has
increased significantly in the last 15
years. During that same time, production in China and the availability of Chinese molybdenum for export to the rest of the world have
also increased.
Because of these structural changes,
the primary mines in North
America that have traditionally produced the bulk of molybdenum
have decreased their production
and have become swing producers:
these mines are only able to increase their production, or come
back on-stream, when the market
demand requires their more costly
molybdenum. The by-product
mines, on the contrary, produce
their lower-cost molybdenum along
with copper to fill the demand for
copper and do not adjust much to
the market conditions for molybdenum.
Market conditions became difficult
in 2001 and 2002, when the molybdenum price dropped even further
after being already low for most of
the previous 20 years. The production of the primary mines in North
America was reduced to less than 45
million pounds per year, or less
than 15 per cent of global production. With this low production level, the swing producers, the primary
North American mines, were no
longer able to adjust their production sufficiently to absorb changes,
particularly strong increases in demand.
26
S T A I N L E S S
S T E E L
W O R L D
Production of Western primary mines has decreased when prices and demand were low for
several years. Production from these mines was only about 40 million lb in 2001 and 2002.
(Source: IMOA, Metals Week).
Global molybdenum demand has increased strongly in the last four years after being stagnant for
several years. (Source: IMOA, Metals Week).
Molybdenum mine production in China has dropped in 2005 as mines were closed due to safety
concerns (Source: IMOA)
S E P T E M B E R
2 0 0 7
www.stainless-steel-world.net
imoa
29-08-2007
15:24
Pagina 28
Materials
Company
Mine
Location
Type
Estimated annual
capacity
(million lb Mo)
Status
Montana/
Gruppo Mexico
Butte
USA
Cu by-product
8
Reopened 2004
Quadra Mining Ltd.
Robinson
USA
Cu by-product
1
Started 2006
Taseko Mines
Gibraltar
Canada
Cu by-product
1
Reopened 2005
Collahausi
Chile
Cu by-product
7
Started 2005
-
Chile
Cu by-product
1
Started 2005
Ashdown
USA
Primary
0.5
Started 2006
Nortoba - Tyson
Canada
Primary
1
Started 2006
Anglo American/
Falconbridge
Amerigo (Minera
Valle Central)
Golden Phoenix
Minerals
Roxmark Mines
Table 1: Mloybdenum mines recently started or reopened (source: Adams Metals)
Molybdenum demand has
increased significantly
As indicated already, the uses for
molybdenum-containing products
are mostly industrial and include energy generation, oil and gas, chemical processing, transportation, mining, mechanical engineering, building and construction and fabrication.
[Demand for molybdenum]
Many of these sectors have seen an
up cycle in investment in the last
few years. High oil prices have boosted exploration and brought new production facilities online. The new
fields often are more difficult to
reach and more difficult to tap.
Higher temperatures, pressures and
concentrations result in a need for
better (often molybdenum-alloyed)
materials. Five to ten years ago, for
example, refineries did not need to
use much stainless steel in their processing. Today, the raw oil to be
processed is becoming increasingly
aggressive, so stainless steel equipment is becoming more common.
The general trend in the chemical
and petrochemical industries of increasing process temperatures and
pressures to increase plant efficiency
also favours the use of moly-grade
materials. Similarly, environmentally friendly processing, where effluents are recycled in the plant instead of being released to the environment, increases the need for
moly-containing materials that can
withstand the higher concentrations of aggressive compounds.
Finally, the rapid expansion of the
Chinese economy, creating a need
for more industrial processing
plants and for investment in new
infrastructure, has multiplied the
use of moly-grade materials in that
part of the world in just a few years.
Therefore, molybdenum demand
had a compounded annual growth
rate of 8 per cent between 2002 and
2006. Such market conditions have
not been seen for decades. In fact,
between 1990 and 2006 the growth
rate was only 3.3 per cent per year.
To express this in weight: in the 12
years between 1990 and 2002 the
demand for molybdenum increased
by 58 million pounds. In the last
four years, between 2002 and 2006,
the demand increased by 112 mil-
Company
Mine
Location
Type
Planned annual
capacity
(million lb Mo)
Status
Probable
start-up
Freeport / PD
Cerro Verde
Peru
Cu by-product
8
Commissioning
Q2 2007
Roca Mines
Max Moly
Canada
Primary
5
Under Construction
Q3 2007
Alumbrera
Bajo de la
Alumbrera
Argentina
Cu by-product
5
Under Construction
Q4 2007
BHP
Pinto Valley
USA
Cu by-product
3
Under Construction
Q4 2007
Mercator
Mineral Park
USA
Cu by-product
10
Under Construction
Q2 2008
Adanac
Ruby Creek
Canada
Primary
10
Feasability complete;
contracting
Q2 2009
Moly Mines
Ltd.
Spinfex Ridge
Australia
Cu by-product
20
Completing
feasability
Q3 2009
Grupo Mexico
Canenea
Mexico
Cu by-product
10
Completing
feasability
Q3 2009
Freeport / PD
Climax
USA
Primary
20 to 30
Restarted conditionally approved
2010
Idaho General
Mount Hope
USA
Primary
30
Completing
feasability
2011
Thompson Cree
Davison
Canada
Primary
8
Starting feasability
study
2012
Table 2. Likely molybdenum mine projects (source: Adams Metals)
28
S T A I N L E S S
S T E E L
W O R L D
S E P T E M B E R
2 0 0 7
www.stainless-steel-world.net
Materials
CIS & Mongolia 8%
South America 16%
China 43%
North America 33%
Global molybdenum reserves total 19 million tons and are mainly situated in China and North
America (source: US Geological Survey 2006).
lion pounds, from 310 million
pounds to 422 million pounds. This
is over 35 per cent of the total demand in 2002 and 2.5 times as
much as the primary mine production in the same year. This situation
has created a major strain on the
supply of molybdenum.
Conference), the Western roasters
were running at a capacity utilization
rate of 77 per cent in 2003, which
moved up to 94 per cent in 2004 and
reached 100 per cent in 2005.
This combination of circumstances
led to the current - and unexpected
- tight supply of molybdenum.
Molybdenum supply
High demand leads to mine
and roasting expansions
Mining operations take many years
to develop and start. Feasibility
studies, environmental impact studies, negotiation with local residents
and financing are just part of the
process needed to start a new mine
or restart a mothballed one. Because
of this, metal production cannot be
quickly increased when demand increases sharply.
Of course, there is some flexibility
to increase production in existing
mines, but that flexibility is limited
to a few percentage points. The
sharp rise in demand after 2002
overwhelmed the swing producers,
who had seen their business shrinking continuously during the five
preceding years. At the same time,
molybdenum production in China
was not able to compensate for this
limitation. Its production actually
decreased in 2005, mainly because
the Chinese government had to
close some mines due to safety concerns.
The problem was further compounded by limited roasting capacities.
Roasting is a necessary step to refine
molybdenum. According to estimates by Climax Molybdenum (presented at the 2005 Ryan’s Notes
www.stainless-steel-world.net
The tight supply situation and the
continued high prices of molybdenum over the last four years have
prompted many mining companies
to develop new molybdenum min-
ing and roasting facilities. Projects
have become possible that would
not have been profitable at the low
molybdenum prices previously seen.
New operations that opened in the
Americas since 2003 have added an
estimated annual capacity of almost
20 million pounds. Production in
China also increased by some 20
million pounds in 2006.
Additionally, many new projects are
under consideration and in various
planning and construction stages. A
shortlist can be found in table 2,
provided by Terry Adams of Adams
Metals Ltd. The lead times for some
of these projects are very long.
According to Mr Adams there are
around 500 other molybdenum
projects in discussion with varying
probabilities of completion.
Roasting capacity should also be
growing soon as capacities in the
Western world are projected to increase from today’s 340 million
pounds to 410 million pounds by
2010.
For the long term, known reserves
for molybdenum amount to 19 million metric tons, according to the
US Geological Survey of 2006. This
would be sufficient for 100 years at
present demand levels, providing us
with a corrosion-free future for
many years to come.
About the authors
Dr. Hans Imgrund
works as a part-time
consultant to IMOA.
A German national,
he studied
metallurgy at the
Clausthal Bergakademie and the
Technical University in Berlin. He
started his career in the moly
business in 1973 as a development
engineer of Climax Molybdenum
Company.
He worked as Vice President Sales
and Marketing for Climax and for
Cyprus Mines Corporation from 1981
until his retirement from Climax in
2003.
He was actively involved in the
foundation of IMOA and has served
on IMOA’s Executive Committee since
its inception in 1989.
S T A I N L E S S
S T E E L
Dr. Nicole Kinsman
is the Technical
Director of the
International
Molybdenum
Association (IMOA).
A Swiss citizen, she studied
mechanical engineering and
metallurgy at the Swiss Federal
Institute of Technology in Zurich (ETH)
and business administration at
Carnegie Mellon University in
Pittsburgh, USA. In 1995 she started
her career as a market development
manager at TMR in Pittsburgh, a
consulting company focusing on
technical consulting in stainless steel.
Since 2002 she is Technical Director
of IMOA, in charge of the market
development programme of the
association.
W O R L D
S E P T E M B E R
2 0 0 7
31