Lower Merion School District Enrollment Study
Transcription
Lower Merion School District Enrollment Study
Lower Merion School District Enrollment Study Lower Merion School District Enrollment Study Prepared By The Montgomery County Planning Commission April 27, 2015 Board of School Directors Dr. Robin Vann Lynch - President Dr. Melissa Gilbert - Vice President Laurie Actman Diane DiBonaventuro Ben Driscoll Dr. Marissa Golden Dr. Maureen O'Leary Virginia Pollard Subha Robinson Acting Superintendent Dr. Wagner Marseille, Ed.D. Table of Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Summary of Key Findings .............................................................................................................................. 3 School District Characteristics Population ........................................................................................................................................................ 5 Birth Patterns .................................................................................................................................................. 7 School District Enrollment........................................................................................................................... 9 Alternative School Enrollment ..................................................................................................................11 Housing Activity Impacts of Housing on Enrollment ...........................................................................................................15 Housing Units Built ......................................................................................................................................17 Housing Units Proposed.............................................................................................................................19 Housing Sales ................................................................................................................................................21 District Enrollment Projections Cohort Progression Model ........................................................................................................................25 Projected Enrollment Summaries .............................................................................................................29 Indicators of Projection Change ...............................................................................................................33 School Profiles .............................................................................................................................................................37 Appendix ............................................................................................................................................................................ 50 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Introduction School districts can only plan for their future if they have some idea of what that future will entail. The number of students that will need to be served by district facilities is the key variable that must be understood in order to make prudent decisions. This report gives an overview of the population and housing characteristics within the Lower Merion School District (LMSD) in order to establish the conditions that have formed the most recent enrollment trends. Future enrollments will depend largely upon the following factors: Recent and future births Housing activity Moves in and out of the school district Private, charter, home, and cyber school change The study employs the use of a cohort progression model to account for the above factors and form projections for each grade level over the next ten years. The progression model tracks changes in grade sizes as they progress each year into the following grade. Over time, the averages of those progression rates are applied to future grade sizes. The additional data and analysis in this report help not only explain what has happened in the past but also how it will affect the future. These important data points should be reviewed every year to determine if unanticipated activity is occurring and how that might influence the projections and actual enrollments down the line. Three years ago, the district hired another consultant, DeJong-Healy, who also used a cohort progression model to project enrollments. Those projections for the overall district have turned out to be fairly accurate after three years. The DeJong numbers for individual buildings were less accurate, especially pertaining to some of the elementary schools. This report is intended to improve upon the remaining projection years from the previous study by incorporating the most recent data and also utilizing detailed geographic information kept on record by the county. More specific and accurate projections for individual buildings and attendance boundaries are expected. 1 ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 1: District School Locations and Elementary School Boundary Areas n n Belmont Hills ES Welsh Valley MS nn n Gladwyne ES n Cynwyd ES Cynwyd MS Penn Valley ES n n Harriton HS Merion ES n Lower Merion HS Belmont Hills Cynwyd Gladwyne Merion Penn Valley n Penn Wynne ES ´ Penn Wynne 2 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Summary of Key Findings The Lower Merion School District is in the midst of a major growth spurt that has increased enrollment by more than one thousand students over the last five years. This report is intended to identify the most likely causes for this recent growth and then assess those causes to best determine how enrollment will be influenced over the next ten years. Enrollment growth stems first from the overall quality, reputation, and appeal of the Lower Merion School District. This is an underlying driver of all factors contributing towards growth, but there are at least three specific factors that have driven the district’s recent growth: Students in Lower Merion and Narberth have been enrolling in private schools at an exceedingly lower rate compared to public school. Whereas about 38% of school-age children were in private school a decade ago, only about 32% attend private school today. This could be a swing of as many as 600-700 students going to public school that would not have ten years ago. Multifamily homes, mostly rental apartments, are providing a greater number of public school children than before. The rate has almost doubled over the last eight years. The report implements these findings into three projection scenarios based on recent trends and a variety of adjustments stemming from observable changes in demographic and enrollment patterns. The scenarios result in a high, medium, and low projection, but all three options indicate considerable growth on top of what has already happened in the district. A near term reversal of recent growth is virtually impossible since new students from the last few years are now in the system, especially in the younger grade levels, and most will remain in the system through their educational life. The forces that brought them into the district may still be at work bringing more students as well. However, the projected growth will not affect all school levels and buildings the same. The most likely projection scenario, referenced as Option 2– Medium, implements the progression model and adjusts it with increases for additional students brought on by new multifamily construction and more students coming out of existing multifamily developments. The following results are from Option 2: Overall district enrollment will increase by 1,248 students over the next ten years, with growth at its strongest during the first five of those years. Enrollment peaks eight years out in 2022, followed by slight declines. The elementary school level, which has grown the most in recent years, will increase for another year or two before starting to come back down. Enrollment should actually be lower than the current total at the end of the ten year study period. Home sales have increased and a greater rate of public school students are coming out of these homes that have sold compared to those that have left the district. These three factors have measurably increased enrollments in the LMSD and this growth will continue since these additional students are now in the system progressing through higher grade levels. Additional growth pressure may come from over 2,000 units of new multifamily housing proposed in the district. Many of these units are not necessarily suited for families with young children, but the large number promises some impact. Also, existing 3 average almost 100 additional students per year for the next five years before starting to decline again over the second five year period. A total of 304 students will be added after ten years. multifamily units will continue to draw even more public school children as they offer the lowest barrier to families that want to send their children to a high quality district. The middle school level will start to pick up some of the elementary school growth as students cycle through and enrollment will The high schools have been less subject to growth swings over the last ten years, but that will change. Increases in high school enrollment will rise throughout the next decade with peak gains scheduled six to eight years out. The total for the high schools will top 3,500 by 2024, an increase of 1,000 students. These are substantial growth figures, especially for the middle and high school levels. They are supported by real data trends that are already occurring within Lower Merion. This report highlights those trends and provides the district with the expectations and understanding needed to plan ahead. Additionally, the appeal of the district to outsiders should remain at a high level. Many people are embracing a more urban lifestyle, especially the younger generation of millennials. Lower Merion and Narberth provide walkability, proximity to employment, public transportation, and one of the shortest commutes into downtown Philadelphia. They also still maintain many suburban conveniences and advantages, including a high quality public education. Note: All projection numbers have been rounded for the sake of simplicity in this report. The original precise numbers are kept intact within the models to maintain integrity, so the addition of rounded numbers in a given table may not exactly equal the sum as shown. However, any sum total should be School District Characteristics Part LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT School District Characteristics Population Birth Patterns School District Enrollment Alternative School Enrollment Population The general population within the Lower Merion School District, which comprises Lower Merion Township and Narberth Borough, declined by 1.4% from 2000 to 2010. This reversed a similarly sized gain from the previous decade. Lower Merion and Narberth are considered built-out mature suburbs, so population changes since 1970 have generally gone down due to changes in household compositions with some redevelopment compensating for those losses. with the recent spate in apartment proposals that may add as many as 2,000 more living units to the district. However, it is important to recognize that population totals do not necessarily reflect changes in the numbers of school-age children or public school enrollment figures. While the overall population may grow within the district, other factors such as shifts in age cohorts, migration of young families, and school attendance choice within that population can have more pronounced effects on the numbers of public school children in the future. Regional projections are calling for the population to slightly increase again through 2020. Population estimates from the U.S. Census Bureau confirm that growth through 2013 has occurred close to the forecasted rate. The general trend for the immediate future is continued modest growth based on a steady changeover of some sites with denser housing development. The rate of increase should hasten FIGURE 2: Population of Lower Merion School District, 1980-2020 64,500 64,000 63,500 63,000 62,500 62,000 61,500 61,000 1980 19 90 2000 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, except 2020 Projections (DVRPC and MCPC) 5 2010 2020 (projected) ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 3: Population Totals, 1990-2020 1990 1980‐1990 1980‐1990 Change Percent Total Lower Merion SD Montgomery County 2000 62,281 678,111 ‐1,844 34,740 ‐2.9% 5.4% Total 2010 1990‐2000 1990‐2000 Change Percent 62,973 748,987 692 70,876 1.1% 10.5% Total 2020 (Forecasted) 2000‐2010 2000‐2010 Change Percent 62,107 799,874 ‐866 50,887 ‐1.4% 6.8% Total 62,905 823,564 2010‐2020 2010‐2020 Change Percent 798 23,690 1.3% 3.0% Source: U.S. Census Bureau, except 2020 Forecasts (DVRPC and MCPC) Age Cohorts and School Age Children Age data from the last three decennial censuses reveal patterns in how the demographics of the Lower Merion School District have changed. The cohort that best represents school age children is the 5-17 year old group. This cohort increased dramatically during the 1990s but then remained fairly steady from 2000 to 2010 with only a slight decrease. These figures include all children, not just public school students. The younger cohort, 0-4 year olds (pre-school age), also remained at a similar level in 2010 compared to 2000. This snapshot would not suggest major shifts in enrollment if no other factors were involved, but we know that is not the case based on the actual enrollment levels throughout the decade. The remaining cohorts show that the population aged 45-54 years old represents a “bubble” where there are disproportionately more people in this age range. This age group along with the 55-64 year old group roughly account for the baby boomers and the cause for why places like the Lower Merion School District and Montgomery County are said to be home to an aging population. These people may still have FIGURE 4: Age Cohorts, Lower Merion School District, 1990-2010 Age Cohort 1990 1980‐1990 Total Change 2000 1990‐2000 Total Change 2010 2000‐2010 Total Change 0‐4 3,496 893 3,207 ‐289 3,251 44 5‐17 18‐24 8,871 6,385 ‐2,543 ‐1,480 10,737 5,491 1,866 ‐894 10,709 5,933 ‐28 442 25‐34 7,448 ‐678 6,639 ‐809 5,360 ‐1,279 35‐44 9.892 2,351 8,599 ‐1,293 7,448 ‐1,151 45‐54 7,834 453 10,028 2,194 9,195 ‐833 55‐64 6,546 ‐1,356 6,692 146 8,899 2,207 65‐74 6,189 ‐355 5,282 ‐907 5,391 109 75 and over 5,620 849 6,298 678 5.921 ‐377 children in their households or have seen them move out in recent years. The effect is that there may be fewer children per household as these people age, but that effect will also be countered by seniors moving to other types of housing or downsizing, providing opportunities for younger families to move in. The remaining ages in between the previously mentioned cohorts, the 25-44 year old population, declined by large numbers in 2010. These people are the most likely to have babies and their decline heralds a period of lower birth activity, which can ultimately result in fewer students enrolling for kindergarten six years later. This shifting of age cohorts over time is usually a good place to start when considering why enrollments cycle up and down, but they are only one part of the picture when it comes to explaining and predicting what will happen with school enrollment in the Lower Merion School District. Source: U.S. Census Bureau 6 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT School District Characteristics Population Birth Patterns School District Enrollment Alternative School Enrollment Birth Patterns The number of births in an area is an important component to projecting future enrollment in a school district. While some families will migrate over time, births provide a beginning indicator of the potential size of future kindergarten classes. This relationship will be detailed in the cohort progression model (p. 25-28), but it is important to note that existing birth data influences what will happen with entering students over the first five years of the projection period. Also note that annual birth totals are aligned to match the school calendar year (September—August) in order to make the most accurate correlations to future kindergarten classes. The trend for live births since 1998 in the Lower Merion School District is a general decrease over time. Looking at four-year increments, the average number of births has gone from 631 in 1998-2001 to 547 from 2010-2013. Births have dropped in the 2011 and 2012 school years, but they are expected to have gone back up in 2013 based on an estimate using partial year data available. This general decline over the last decade or more is not just relative to the LMSD. Countywide, birth totals have also fallen since 2008. Has the downturn in the economy starting with the Great Recession in 2008 driven this decline in births? Logically, it would make sense for some to defer or delay decisions to have children based on economic uncertainty in one’s life. Some studies have looked at national population bases, both the United States and globally, and determined that overall fertility rates do decline with downturns in the economy. However, in the Lower Merion School District, the rate of decline since the recession has not been any faster than the years preceeding it. The countywide FIGURE 5: Number of Live Births in Lower Merion School District by School Calendar Year (Sept.-Aug.) 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 * Births during the 2014 months in the 2013-2014 school year were estimated due to state data being unreleased at the time of this report. Source: Pennsylvania Department of Health 7 ENROLLMENT STUDY pattern, and that of many other districts, appears more closely aligned to the timing of the recession. The economy can have an impact as it influences factors such as housing construction and sales activity, but it alone should not be considered the cause for declines in births in the LMSD. Therefore, future improvements in the economy may not have a strong effect on driving births upward again. Attempting to pinpoint the causes of change in birth totals over time is difficult, but another clue comes from looking at the population of child-bearing age women. According to the Pennsylvania Department of Health, birth activity in Montgomery County is at its highest when potential mothers are between the FIGURE 6: Number of Live Births in LMSD by School Calendar Year (Sept.-Aug.) School Year 2000‐01 2001‐02 2002‐03 2003‐04 2004‐05 ages of 25-34. The population of women in that age group from the LMSD dropped from 3,400 in 2000 to 2,804 in 2010, a loss of over 17%. Figure 7 identifies age cohorts for females of child-bearing age. Interestingly, all other cohorts for females of child-bearing age also decreased across the decade. These demographics do not give cause to suggest that the 25-34 year old female cohort will increase by 2020. However, the countywide forecasts adopted by DVRPC show that this age group is ascending in number and will continue to do so through at least 2025. New apartment construction and an increase in housing sales activity could still bring about more younger women of child bearing age into the LMSD and thus increase the chances for greater annual births, but severe changes are not anticipated. FIGURE 7: Females of Child-Bearing Age in LMSD, 2000 and 2010 LMSD 621 660 588 568 582 2005‐06 604 2006‐07 566 2007‐08 573 2008‐09 560 2009‐10 543 2010‐11 569 2011‐12 536 2012‐13 2013‐14* 526 555 Birth Rates Birth rates are a different statistic than live births. An increase or decrease in actual births could be explained by concurrent growth or decline in the population base, but birth rates average out the number of live births per 1,000 persons in an area. The statistics in Figure 9 confirm that the trend of lower birth activity is not solely caused by an overall reduction in population. FIGURE 8: Birth Rates (Births Per 1,000 Population) in LMSD by Calendar Year (Jan.-Dec.) Calendar Year 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 LMSD 9.8 8.9 9.3 9.5 9.2 Montgomery County 12.7 12.3 12.1 12.3 11.9 Age Cohort 2000 Females 2010 Females 2008 9.4 12.1 Age 15 ‐ 19 Age 20 ‐ 24 Age 25 ‐ 29 Age 30 ‐ 34 Age 35 ‐ 39 Age 40 ‐ 44 2009 8.8 11.7 2010 9.1 11.4 2011 9.3 11.2 2012 2013 8.6 8.4 11.0 10.7 2,711 2,660 1,589 1,811 2,199 2,480 2,683 2,283 1,391 1,413 1,824 2,168 Sources: Pennsylvania Department of Health, U.S. Census Bureau Source: U.S. Census Bureau * Births during the 2014 months in the 2013-2014 school year were estimated due to state data being unreleased at the time of this report. Source: Pennsylvania Department of Health (modified by MCPC from detailed address review of files) 8 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT School District Characteristics Population Birth Patterns School District Enrollment Alternative School Enrollment School District Enrollment Over the last six years, district enrollment has grown by 18%, adding 1,241 students and reaching more than 8,000 total students. Looking further back, the district has been adding students on a fairly regular basis since 1989, when enrollment was only around 5,200 students. The recent growth has been somewhat unexpected in its rate of increase given the lack of an appreciable population or housing construction gain. Looking at the school level distributions in Figures 9 and 10, growth is observable at each of the three levels in the district, but it is most pronounced within the K-5 or elementary level. This study is intended to answer the question of how much growth will continue within the district, but it is clear that enrollment should continue to grow in the immediate future. The swelling early grade levels today will advance through the system and replace likely smaller class sizes that came before them. FIGURE 9: School District Enrollment by Grade Divisions, 2005-2014 9,000 8,000 7,000 6,000 K‐5 5,000 4,000 6‐8 3,000 9‐12 2,000 Total K‐ 12 1,000 0 2005‐ 2006‐ 2007‐ 2008‐ 2009‐ 2010‐ 2011‐ 2012‐ 2013‐ 2014‐ 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 Source: Lower Merion School District (enrollment as of the 10th day of each school year) 9 ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 10: District Enrollment by Division, 2005-2014 Year Total Number Change Percent Change K‐12 from Previous Year from Previous Year 2005‐06 6,899 140 2.1% 2006‐07 6,945 46 0.7% 2007‐08 6,920 ‐25 ‐0.4% 2008‐09 6,812 ‐108 ‐1.6% 2009‐10 6,952 140 2.1% Grade K‐5 2,774 2,863 2,943 2,961 3,039 Grade 6‐8 1,657 1,610 1,586 1,583 1,614 Grade 9‐12 2,468 2,472 2,391 2,268 2,299 2010‐11 7,142 190 2.7% 3,140 1,660 2,342 2011‐12 7,360 218 3.1% 3,286 1,728 2,346 2012‐13 7,682 322 4.4% 3,399 1,808 2,475 2013‐14 7,859 177 2.3% 2014‐15 8,053 194 2.5% 3,508 3,659 1,866 1,874 2,485 2,520 Source: Lower Merion School District (enrollment as of the 10th day of each school year) FIGURE 11: District Enrollment by Grade, 2005-2014 Year 2005‐06 2006‐07 2007‐08 2008‐09 2009‐10 K 317 366 353 352 391 1 470 480 522 494 518 2 522 485 504 536 521 3 467 549 509 517 551 4 484 484 552 505 533 5 514 499 503 557 525 6 490 533 514 499 562 7 570 501 560 523 514 8 597 576 512 561 538 9 587 613 568 515 602 10 637 583 608 560 528 11 642 624 594 601 563 12 602 652 621 592 606 2010‐11 411 528 539 544 571 547 549 584 527 584 620 547 591 2011‐12 413 585 556 564 568 600 564 564 600 573 589 635 549 2012‐13 438 602 614 572 580 593 630 593 585 656 579 601 639 2013‐14 2014‐15 449 454 630 621 616 658 640 660 585 660 588 606 603 610 662 604 601 660 614 642 677 610 587 671 607 597 Source: Lower Merion School District (enrollment as of the 10th day of each school year) 10 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT School District Characteristics Population Birth Patterns School District Enrollment Alternative School Enrollment Alternative School Enrollment Potential alternative schooling choices include private schools, charter/cyber schools, and homeschooling. Enrollment in these schools are enumerated from several data sources and do not always have a consistent historical record. Further confusing matters is that charter and most cyber schools are also considered public schools. Private Schools While public school enrollment has been increasing over the last six years, the opposite appears to have occurred with private school enrollment for residents in Lower Merion and Narberth. National and district data sources both show a considerable decline for private school enrollment in recent years. The U.S. Census Bureau and its American Community Survey (ACS) provides data on public versus private school enrollment, which is probably the most straightforward assessment of trends. However, these figures are still estimates with a margin of error and they rely upon the accuracy of individuals filling out questionnaires. Figure 12 shows the available data that can be compared from the Census and ACS. The Census Bureau indicates that private school enrollment has gone from 38.7% of school-age children in 2000 to only 32.6% from 2011-2013. Such a decrease is a swing of approximately 700 FIGURE 12: Private School Enrollment According to U.S. Census Bureau Year 2000 2013* Private School Percent in Private Students School 4,174 38.7% 3,470 32.6% The Lower Merion School District also keeps data on residents that attend private school through its monitoring of district bus records which include public and private school students. However, the data is incomplete as it only recognizes students who FIGURE 13: Private School Enrollment According to LMSD Bus Records School Year 2006‐2007 Private School Students 3,296 2007‐2008 3,328 2008‐2009 3,240 2009‐2010 3,078 2010‐2011 2,914 2011‐2012 2,854 2012‐2013 2,758 2013‐2014 2,674 2014‐2015 2,719 Note: Data only recognizes private school students that opt for LMSD bus transportation. Source: Lower Merion School District Bus Records Dataset Census 2000, ACS, 3 Year Es mates, 2011‐2013 * 3 Year Estimates from the ACS are an average of 3 years worth of sampling data 11 students that could be in public school as opposed to private. However, we must also acknowledge that these Census figures are subject to a margin of error and the level of accuracy diminishes with shorter time frames and smaller geographies. ENROLLMENT STUDY are using the district’s public buses. The bus data in Figure 13 goes back to the 2006-07 school year and supports a general decrease in private school students. This data shows a gradual pattern of decline, but the numbers appear to drop by a similar margin assuming that non-district transported students fell at a similar rate. The level of change in private school students compared to the gains in public school enrollment reveals a shift that has contributed to growth in the district. However, this shift does not appear to be based on existing private school students enrolling in public school due to the economy. The district’s data on incoming student transfers shows that the number of new public students in grades 2-12 coming from local private schools has gone down each of the last four years. Homeschooling The last alternative, which is not considered public schooling, is homeschooling where the parent is responsible for educating the child. District records show that there were 43 students being homeschooled within the LMSD during the 20132014 school year. This number has been relatively stable over the last four years, but averaged in the 30s during the middle of the 2000-2010 decade. The number of homeschooled students in Montgomery County has been relatively stable over this time period. While these levels should be monitored, the relatively low numbers still have a minimal impact on the overall enrollment in the district. The more likely situation is that families moving into the district with children just starting school or not yet there are moving with the intention of enrolling in public school over private at a greater ratio than in the past. While there is no specific data to verify this notion, it seems the most reasonable explanation for the increase in the ratio of public school students to private school students within Lower Merion and Narberth. Charter / Cyber Schools Charter schools are still considered public in that they usually have free tuition and are funded with public dollars. However, they are independently operated and students are not considered in the district enrollment figure. According to the Lower Merion School District, there were 32 students living in the district in 2014-15 that enrolled in charter schools. Most of these were actually cyber charter schools, which are a form of home-based virtual charter schools. These types of schools are relatively new options in the area, first appearing less than ten years ago. The district’s records show that there has been an average of 28 charter school students per year since 2005. 12 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT 13 Housing Activity Part LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Housing Activity Impacts of Housing on Enrollment Impacts of Housing on Enrollment School Age Children by Housing Type Housing Units Built Housing Units Proposed Housing Sales The average number of school age children in a residential unit depends on the type of residential unit. MCPC reviews the latest census data and compares it to county property records as part of its report titled, “Characteristics of the Population in New and Existing Housing Units.” The latest report, based on the 2010 Census, contains the average number of school age children in single family detached, attached (townhomes and twins), and multifamily (apartments or multiple units in a structure) housing types. The data is also analyzed in terms of new and existing units. The results of the study (Figure 14) show that a newly constructed single family detached home is over 15 times more likely to contain a school age child than multifamily units. The difference is less stark when considering all existing units, but there are clearly more children found in detached units than in multifamily units, with single family attached units falling in between the other two. The methodology for the report was replicated to just focus on data within the Lower Merion School District. While there were not enough new units to develop representative figures, existing units were comparable to the county regarding their disparity between housing types. Multifamily and attached units in the LMSD had fewer children per unit than the county, but detached homes had a higher rate of children per unit. These factors can be used to make estimates on the impact of different housing types in terms of school age children, but it should be noted that the study only considers census blocks of housing that are homogenous. Additional information was collected for multifamily housing since it is a concern with current projects being proposed in the district. Multifamily Housing Analysis The district’s student records from 2006-07, 2010-11, and 2014-15 were compared to the addresses of all multifamily developments with 20 or more units in Lower Merion and Narberth. The results shown in Figure 15 indicate that the number of public school children coming from multifamily developments has been increasing. There were 0.08 public school FIGURE 14: Average Number of School Aged Children by Housing Unit Type Montgomery County Single Family Detached Single Family A ached Mul family School Age Children per Household in Exis ng Units 0.55 0.41 0.18 School Age Children per Household in New Units 0.93 0.21 0.06 Single Family Detached Single Family A ached Mul family School Age Children per Household in Exis ng Units 0.64 0.31 0.06 School Age Children per Household in New Units NA NA NA Lower Merion School District Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission 15 ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 15: Actual LMSD Data for All Existing Multifamily Developments with 20 Units or More Year 2006‐07 2010‐11 2014‐15 LMSD 242 296 432 Units 5,385 5,514 5,514 Student / Unit 0.04 0.05 0.08 Note: Only includes public students and ratio is based on units, not households. FIGURE 16: Percentage of Children in LMSD Area Households Related to Geographic Mobility Persons Age 1‐4 Persons Age 5‐17 Persons Age 25‐34 Percent Percent of Percent Total Persons Number of Total Number Total Number of Total Persons in households that have moved within the last year 8,135 425 5.2% 922 11.3% 1,759 21.6% Persons in households that have remained in the same house 53,537 2,120 4.0% 9,999 18.7% 3,720 6.9% Source: American Community Survey, 2009-2013 Estimates students per existing multifamily unit in the 2014-15 school year. This is still a fairly low rate, and new units typically have fewer school-age children then existing units. This data also shows that multifamily rental units have a higher rate of public school students (0.12/ unit) than owner-occupied units (0.04/unit). However, many of the children coming out of existing rental units are from older developments that may be more affordable to families seeking an opportunity to enter the LMSD. More expensive luxury apartment rentals like many being proposed may not provide as many public school students. See the Appendix for a full listing of the properties studied in this analysis and their student/unit rates. Migration of Households The connection between new housing units and new population is fairly clear, although it also depends on the type of units. The impact of household movement in and out of existing housing units is a less certain connection, but it is still incorporated into the cohort progression model. It would be useful to look at sales data of homes and come to an understanding of what might happen with school age children when sales activity increases for one reason or another. The American Community Survey offers data on geographic mobility of households and the age composition of those households. Figure 16 shows a breakdown of households that have remained within the same house as the year prior and households that have moved within the last year. This latter group would constitute the characteristics of people who are purchasing homes or moving into rental units. The results show that the percentage of school age children is higher in homes that are occupied by the same household as the year before. This would seem to indicate that new households will contain fewer school age children than homes that have not been sold or rented to a new household. However, what this data does not show is who has been replaced by the new household. If those new households that do have children are taking the place of a household without children, such as an empty nester or nonfamily household, then the new sale or rental can still drive enrollment higher. FIGURE 17: Impact of Housing Units Sold on Enrollment Year of Housing Units Sold Number of Units Sold Another analysis using county housing sales data and district enrollment records was conducted to identify public school students that lived in homes prior to being sold and students that lived in a home after it was sold. The results in Figure 17, show that the net gain in public students resulting from sales in a specific year has doubled from 2009 to 2013. This suggests that recent sales in the LMSD are adding new students into the district at a greater rate than sales from five years ago. This does not address rental units, but an increase in sales would likely add more students than would otherwise be expected. Owner / Renter Occupied Housing in the LMSD is predominately owner occupied—75 percent of all occupied units. This is slightly higher than the rate of home ownership in the county as a whole. Overall, the rental market has been stronger in recent years after the recession and decline of the housing market since 2008. Almost all of the current multifamily proposals in the LMSD are designated to become rental units. Data from the 2010 Census (Figure 18) suggests that children under the age of 18 are more likely to be found in owner occupied housing than they are in renter occupied housing. 2009 658 2013 976 Incoming Students at Address of Units Sold 165 303 FIGURE 18: Presence of Children Within LMSD Outgoing Students at Address of Units Sold 125 222 Net Change in Students from Sales Ac vity + 40 + 81 Owner Occupied Housing Renter Occupied Housing Source: LMSD Records, MCPC Median Price Sales Reports Percent of Housing with Children Under 18 35% 20% Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2010 Census 16 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Housing Activity Housing Units Built Impacts of Housing on Enrollment Residential construction activity in Montgomery County hit historic lows following the recession and housing market bubble burst in 2008. Development in the LMSD hit its lowest point in 2010 and 2011, but Lower Merion and Narberth are different from many municipalities due to their older suburban character with an increasing presence of more urban types of development. Most of the land is considered built out, so new development usually occurs on sites with demolitions or other infill sites that may not have been fully developed. Changes in the zoning codes can also spur new development such as recent rezoning activity around City Avenue in Bala Cynwyd. Housing Units Built Housing Units Proposed Housing Sales Development since 2000 has generally consisted of less than 50 units per year except for when a larger multifamily development gets built, such as the Corinthian Condominiums. The types of units being built vary from year to year, but all three are fairly represented. There has been an upswing in attached homes in 2012 and 2013. This is expected to continue for the time being as some property owners have assembled groups of smaller lots, often with older detached units located on them, and proceeded to propose or build more units in order to increase the value of their property. Figure 19 shows the last ten years of actual residential construction in the district. Future development is not considered to change drastically with regards to single family detached and attached units. However, there has been an immense level of interest in higher density multifamily construction. Over 2,000 units are currently being proposed that could see construction within the next 5-6 years. This construction will need to be considered as an influence on enrollment growth that is outside of the recent construction trends accounted for in the projection models. The map in Figure 20 on the following page shows the most recent developments in the LMSD, recognizing all units built from 2009 through 2013. FIGURE 19: Housing Units Built in the LMSD by Housing Type, 2004-2013 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Multifamily Single Family Attached Single Family Detached 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission 17 ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 20: Housing Units Built in the LMSD, 2009-2013 n n Belmont Hills ES Welsh Valley MS nn n Gladwyne ES n Cynwyd ES Cynwyd MS Penn Valley ES n n Harriton HS Merion ES n Lower Merion HS n Legend BELMONT HILLS CYNWYD GLADWYNE MERION PENN VALLEY PENN WYNNE Penn Wynne ES Type of Housing Unit Built Multifamily Units Single Family Attached Units Single Family Detached Units ´ 18 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Housing Activity Impacts of Housing on Enrollment Housing Units Built Housing Units Proposed Housing Sales Housing Units Proposed Lower Merion is currently looking at a remarkable number of proposed multifamily apartment buildings. The housing market has started to improve, but it is the rental market in the Philadelphia region that is currently booming. Recent zoning changes have also encouraged high density residential uses along the existing Bala Cynwyd office corridor and the Schuylkill riverfront. Some of these projects have been on the table for many years and are only now close to coming to fruition. The chart in Figure 21 shows the volume of units proposed each year over the last decade. Proposals are only counted once, but plans will often go through multiple submissions and variations as the process takes place. Not all of those units will be built, but a high percentage of them now have a strong chance of being constructed. The map in Figure 22 shows the location and number of units for the developments that are most likely to be built in the next one to six years. Each project has been estimated in terms of its most realistic timeline and the number of public school children they are likely to house. The number of additional public school students expected to come from these proposals has also been estimated based upon the county and local student/unit factors, including the existing multifamily development inventory located in the appendix. Approximately 108 new students are expected if all these units get built. See Figure 35 on page 34 for the detailed estimates and timelines for each proposal. Due to a lack in multifamily construction over the last five years, a housing adjustment is recommended for the projections in Part Three. This potential construction will not affect all individual schools equally. Almost half of the new students will fall within the Cynwyd Elementary School boundary, and about a third will come into the Penn Valley Elementary School boundary. Gladwyne and Merion boundaries will receive no impact. The middle schools and high schools will be pretty evenly disbursed in terms of potential new students from these developments, although a few more will come into the Bala Cynwyd Middle School and Lower Merion High School side. FIGURE 21: Housing Units Proposed in the LMSD, 2004-2013 800 700 600 500 Multifamily 400 Single Family Attached 300 Single Family Detached 200 100 0 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission 19 ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 22: Proposed Housing Developments Expected to be Constructed 601 & 615 Righters Ferry 237 Units 600 Righters Ferry 593 Units 131-151 Rock Hill Rd 332 Units n n 150 Monument Rd 207 Units Belmont Hills ES 335 Righters Ferry 210 Units Welsh Valley MS nn n Gladwyne ES Cynwyd ES Cynwyd MS n Penn Valley ES n n Harriton HS Merion ES n 331 Penn Rd 250 Units Lower Merion HS 112 Sibley 46 Units Palmer Seminary 130 Units 24 Cricket Ave 110 Units 11-15 E. Athens Ave. 25 Units Legend BELMONT HILLS CYNWYD GLADWYNE MERION PENN VALLEY PENN WYNNE n Penn Wynne ES ´ 20 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Housing Activity Housing Sales Impacts of Housing on Enrollment Market-rate housing sales activity in the LMSD has followed a pattern similar to countywide sales activity. The number of units sold peaked at very high levels in the early to mid 2000s before the housing boom crashed and the economy entered a recession. Sales levels continually declined to historically low levels through 2011. During this collapse, home values flattened out and often depreciated as financial markets tightened up for potential buyers. Housing Units Built Housing Units Proposed Housing Sales in that time. At the county and local levels, these figures still pale in comparison to earlier in the last decade, but it is unlikely that the market returns to those markers in the foreseeable future. The impact of an increase in sales in the LMSD is that it can spur migration activity in an area that features a majority of its housing stock as owneroccupied housing. It was demonstrated on pages 1516 that home sales in recent years have brought more public school children with them. Continual increases in sales over the near future could continue this “churning” of households and sustain more growth for the district. The last two years have shown the beginnings of a recovery in the county with the number of home sales rising 31% from 2011 to 2013. That recovery has been even stronger in Lower Merion and Narberth with the number of sales growing by 35% FIGURE 23: Total Housing Units Sold in the LMSD, 2004-2013 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 2004 2005 2006 2007 Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission 21 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 24: Existing Housing Units Sold in the LMSD, 2009-2013 n n Belmont Hills ES Welsh Valley MS nn n Gladwyne ES n Cynwyd ES Cynwyd MS Penn Valley ES n n Harriton HS Merion ES n Lower Merion HS n Legend BELMONT HILLS CYNWYD GLADWYNE MERION PENN VALLEY PENN WYNNE Penn Wynne ES Type of Housing Unit Sold Multifamily Units Single Family Attached Units Single Family Detached Units ´ 22 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT 23 District Enrollment Projections Part LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT District Enrollment Projections Cohort Progression Model Projected Enrollment Summaries Indicators of Projection Change Cohort Progression Model The method used in this study to calculate projections for each grade level is known as the Cohort Progression Model, which is also referred to as Cohort Survival in some applications. This is a fairly common approach and one used by the state and other districts in formulating projections. However, it should always be used with caution and presented in context with the other variables offered in this report. In some districts there will be cause for adjustments to the model based on changing factors in population growth or migration. The nature of the model allows it to integrate trend activity across a number of variables. Birth rates have the most obvious impacts in the model, but the changes that take place account for trends in population migration, housing construction, sales, and alternative schooling choices, such as private, charter, or homeschooling opportunities. The model is fairly straightforward in its method. It tracks each class in a given year and measures the change in that class from one year to the next. Then it applies an average of changes over a specified time period to determine the percentage of a given grade likely to “progress” to the next grade in future years. A six year average was used for the Lower Merion School District, since it would account for enrollment patterns from the 2009 through 2014 school years. Figure 25 displays all of the progression rates for each grade transition from the last nine school years. The most recent six year average is calculated to arrive at a basic trend that will be applied for each projected year. Any progression rate that is greater than 1.0 indicates that a class increased in size from one year to the next as it also moved up a grade level. Progression rates that are lower than 1.0 indicate that a class decreased in size. For example, the eighth grade class of the 2012 school year increased in size when it entered the ninth grade in 2013 at a rate of 1.05. Using actual enrollment figures, the class went from 585 to 614 students during that period. The 25 following year in 2014, it entered the tenth grade and this time it decreased at a rate of 0.993, losing four students by the enrollment figures. Progression rates between the numbered grades in the LMSD are high compared to most districts. The average for every grade level above kindergarten is above 1.0. Often, districts with a strong reputation for performance will add students at many of the early grade levels, but it may become less guaranteed as students advance. By high school, many districts see progressions below 1.0 due to dropouts and a lower likelihood of older students transitioning into a new district at this stage of school. The six-year average progression rates for the LMSD generally do decrease through the range of grades as they get higher until the ninth grade. The rate for incoming high school freshmen classes jumps higher than any rate since the first grade. This appears to have started around the 2009 school year which was also about the time that the two high schools underwent significant renovations and expansions. However, some more historic progression rates from the previous decade also show big jumps at the ninth grade level. The magnitude of the progression rates account for the trends outlined in this study that are driving up enrollments—public school preference, multifamily student ratios, increased home sales, and the essential attractiveness of the district to families from outside the district. These rates almost make growth inevitable, even if births or age cohort demographics might imply otherwise. Birth-to-Kindergarten Ratio The projection of future enrollments in the model requires that we apply the trends in progression rates to future classes as they go from one grade to the next. However, the kindergarten class for each year does not have an enrollment figure for its prior year since those children would be in preschool or home care outside of the district system. Therefore, we must use live birth data to identify ratios of births to ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 25: Grade Progression Rates Over the Last Nine Years School Year K‐1 1‐2 2‐3 3‐4 4‐5 5‐6 6‐7 7‐8 8‐9 9‐10 2006‐07 Birth‐K* 0.589 1.514 1.032 1.052 1.036 1.031 1.037 1.022 1.011 1.027 0.993 10‐11 0.980 11‐12 1.016 2007‐08 0.535 1.426 1.050 1.049 1.005 1.039 1.030 1.051 1.022 0.986 0.992 1.019 0.995 2008‐09 0.599 1.399 1.027 1.026 0.992 1.009 0.992 1.018 1.002 1.006 0.986 0.988 0.997 2009‐10 0.687 1.472 1.055 1.028 1.031 1.040 1.009 1.030 1.029 1.073 1.025 1.005 1.008 2010‐11 0.704 1.350 1.041 1.044 1.036 1.026 1.046 1.039 1.025 1.086 1.030 1.036 1.050 2011‐12 0.684 1.423 1.053 1.046 1.044 1.051 1.031 1.027 1.027 1.087 1.009 1.024 1.004 2012‐13 0.768 1.458 1.050 1.029 1.028 1.044 1.050 1.051 1.037 1.093 1.010 1.020 1.006 2013‐14 0.778 1.438 1.023 1.042 1.023 1.014 1.017 1.051 1.013 1.050 1.032 1.014 1.010 2014‐15 0.808 1.383 1.044 1.071 1.031 1.036 1.037 1.002 0.997 1.068 0.993 0.991 1.017 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 0.738 1.421 1.044 1.044 1.032 1.035 1.032 1.033 1.022 1.076 1.017 1.015 1.016 * The birth-to-kindergarten ratio uses birth data six years prior to the indicated school year, thus drawing the relationship between children born and the year they would actually enter kindergarten. FIGURE 26: Grade Progression Rates with Historical Comparison School Year 7 Year Average 1994 –2000 Birth‐K* K‐1 1‐2 2‐3 3‐4 4‐5 5‐6 6‐7 7‐8 8‐9 9‐10 0.432 1.762 1.007 1.015 1.014 1.015 0.993 1.022 1.008 1.027 1.008 1.014 1.013 2002‐03 0.492 1.601 1.016 1.037 1.024 1.035 1.022 1.042 1.037 1.080 1.010 1.012 1.017 2006‐07 6‐Yr Avg. 2009 ‐2014 0.589 1.514 1.032 1.052 1.036 1.031 1.037 1.022 1.011 1.027 0.993 0.980 1.016 0.741 1.421 1.044 1.044 1.032 1.035 1.032 1.033 1.022 1.076 1.017 1.015 1.016 kindergarten. The birth data comes from a given past year and is then applied to the kindergarten class that would follow six years later in order to capture the same children at each end of the ratio. For instance, a birth-to-kindergarten ratio for the 2014-15 school year uses birth data from 2008-09 as the numerator and divides it by the kindergarten enrollment in 2014 to form the rate (0.808) shown in Figure 25. The ratios of births to kindergarten are much lower than the yearly grade progression rates. Some will go straight into a private school, and others may move away before entry into kindergarten. The averaging out of the ratios gives us the best approximation of the net result of all birth and migration activity in the district, but clearly there is room for error in any singular instance. One beneficial aspect of a birth-to-kindergarten ratio is that it allows the model to integrate real data into the first five years of the projection period. In other words, projections of kindergarten classes for the first five years, through the 2019 school year, can account for real changes in birth patterns that have 10‐11 11‐12 occurred from 2009 to 2013. The downside is that an estimated birth figure must be used for any projection beyond the 2019 school year. Projection Periods Due to the distinction between using real birth data and the need to estimate beyond five years, enrollment projections are divided into two periods. The primary period covers the first five school years from 2015 to 2019, and the secondary period covers the next five school years from 2020 to 2024. There is a higher degree of accuracy expected during the 26 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT primary period than in the secondary period. Recent trends are more likely to continue in the short term before outside factors can influence a change in patterns, but the use of the birth data also gives a more dependable start to projecting the size of kindergarten classes in the future. Estimated Births The projection of kindergarten classes after 2019 requires the use of estimated birth figures for the next five years. A simple approach to estimate these births is to use an average of the most recent birth figures and extend it through the end of the projection period. housing construction. The Multifamily Students Adjustment assumes that more students will be moving into existing multifamily properties, thus raising the current 0.08 students/unit ratio to 0.1 students/unit by the end of the projection period resulting in a gain of 120 additional students over the next ten years. Housing and Multifamily Students Adjustments are included with no further adjustments. Estimated births for the next five years are based on an average of the last three years (539 births). Private school attendance will remain at its current historically low percent. Details of the three options are as follows: OPTION 1—High Projection OPTION 3—Low Projection Housing and Multifamily Students Adjustments are included. Housing and Multifamily Students Adjustments are included. Increase in Housing Sales Activity - An adjustment that provides for 93 additional students over ten years to reflect an increase in housing sales to 1,100 units per year by 2017. Increase in Estimated Births - The future births estimated for the next five years that will impact entering classes between 2020 and 2024. has been increased to progressively reach 600 births, cycling back to birth rates in line with ten years ago. Private school attendance will remain at its current historically low percent. Private school attendance will begin to cycle back to a higher percentage than the present, thus reducing the number of students enrolled in public school. The mechanism used to account for this change is substituting a 9-year average of progression rates instead of a 6-year average. Three additional years of older rates brings the rates down to a level closer to the period when a higher percentage of school-age children were going to public school. See Figure 30 for rates. Estimated births for the next five years are based on an average of the last three years (539 births). Projected Enrollments Figures 27, 28, and 29 offer three variations of grade by grade projections over the next ten years. They have been designated as High, Medium, and Low, simply by the level of growth that they support. Each option differs by the assumptions that are made along with designated adjustments to each model. All three options include the same housing adjustment and increase in multifamily students adjustment. The Housing Adjustment incorporates the 108 additional students over time expected from likely multifamily OPTION 2—Medium Projection FIGURE 27: Projected Enrollments, OPTION 1—High Projection Births 6 School Year Years Ago* K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 TOTAL 2015‐16 543 404 647 650 688 683 685 627 632 619 712 654 621 683 8,303 2016‐17 569 426 576 677 681 713 709 709 650 648 668 726 666 633 8,480 2017‐18 536 406 608 606 712 708 743 737 737 669 702 684 742 682 8,736 2018‐19 526 403 578 639 636 739 736 770 765 757 724 718 699 758 8,923 2019‐20 555 427 570 605 669 659 767 762 798 784 816 738 731 712 9,037 2020‐21 564 436 602 596 633 692 684 793 789 817 844 832 751 744 9,212 2021‐22 573 444 613 630 623 654 717 706 820 807 879 860 846 764 9,365 2022‐23 582 453 625 641 658 644 678 741 731 839 869 895 874 861 9,509 2023‐24 591 461 636 653 670 680 668 701 767 748 903 884 910 889 9,570 2024‐25 600 469 647 665 682 693 705 690 725 784 805 919 899 926 9,609 * The birth figure for each row does not pertain to births during that year, but rather the births that occurred six years prior to the projected year. 27 ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 28: Projected Enrollments, OPTION 2—Medium Projection Births 6 School Year Years Ago* K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 2015‐16 543 404 646 650 688 682 684 626 632 618 711 654 620 683 8298 2016‐17 569 425 575 676 680 712 708 708 649 647 667 725 665 632 8468 2017‐18 536 405 606 604 710 706 741 735 736 667 700 682 740 680 8713 2018‐19 526 401 575 637 634 736 734 768 763 755 721 715 696 756 8891 2019‐20 555 424 566 602 665 656 764 758 795 781 813 735 728 709 8994 2020‐21 539 413 598 592 629 688 679 789 785 813 840 828 747 740 9141 TOTAL 2021‐22 539 414 582 625 618 650 712 702 815 802 875 855 841 759 9251 2022‐23 539 415 583 608 652 639 673 735 725 834 863 890 869 855 9341 2023‐24 539 416 584 609 635 674 661 694 760 742 897 878 904 883 9338 2024‐25 539 417 585 610 636 656 698 683 718 777 798 912 892 919 9301 FIGURE 29: Projected Enrollments, OPTION 3—Low Projection Births 6 School Year Years Ago* K 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 TOTAL 2015‐16 543 373 650 648 688 678 682 624 631 616 696 648 616 680 8,231 2016‐17 569 393 535 679 678 707 701 703 646 644 650 703 656 625 8,320 2017‐18 536 375 565 561 712 699 734 725 730 662 682 660 714 667 8,486 2018‐19 526 371 536 592 589 734 725 757 752 747 700 691 669 725 8,589 2019‐20 555 393 528 560 618 605 759 746 783 767 787 707 699 678 8,631 2020‐21 539 383 558 551 584 635 626 781 771 798 808 795 714 708 8,712 2021‐22 539 384 543 581 575 600 656 643 806 786 841 815 802 723 8,756 2022‐23 539 385 544 566 607 590 620 674 665 822 828 848 823 812 8,783 2023‐24 2024‐25 539 539 386 387 545 546 567 568 590 591 622 606 609 643 637 627 697 658 677 710 865 713 835 873 856 843 833 867 8,721 8,631 * The birth figure for each row does not pertain to births during that year, but rather the births that occurred six years prior to the projected year. The average birth-to-kindergarten ratio is then applied to get the projected kindergarten class. FIGURE 30: 9-Year Average Progression Rates Used for OPTION 3—Low Projection School Year 9‐Yr Avg. 2006 ‐2014 Birth‐K 0.685 K‐1 1‐2 2‐3 3‐4 4‐5 5‐6 6‐7 7‐8 8‐9 9‐10 1.429 1.042 1.043 1.025 1.032 1.028 1.032 1.018 1.053 1.008 10‐11 1.009 11‐12 1.011 28 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT District Enrollment Projections Projected Enrollment Summaries Cohort Progression Model The summarized enrollment projections for the district and at each school level are presented on the following pages. The three options are based on differing adjustments and assumptions reviewed in the previous section. However, the variation in birth estimates will make no difference at the middle school and high school levels since children born over the next five years will not be old enough to influence those projections within the ten year timeframe. Projected Enrollment Summaries Indicators of Projection Change The general trend for the district under all scenarios is that enrollment will continue to grow most rapidly over the next five to six years. Beyond that, the medium and low options show growth winding down and enrollment going back down the last couple of years. Figures 32, 33, and 34 isolate the projections according to the grade levels of buildings in the district. Changes have also been evaluated over the five-year intervals of the primary and secondary periods. Some of the levels will experience very different trends from one five-year period to the next. Option 2, the medium projection, is recommended as the most realistic or likely result at this time. It adjusts for the two factors that are believed to be likely regardless of other trends—new housing construction and more students filling existing rental apartments. Other factors are left to recent trends under Option 2. FIGURE 31: Total District Enrollment Projections Year 29 Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change 2014‐15 (Current) 8,053 8,053 8,053 2015‐16 8,303 250 8,298 245 8,231 178 2016‐17 8,480 177 8,468 170 8,320 89 2017‐18 8,736 256 8,713 245 8,486 166 2018‐19 8,923 187 8,891 178 8,589 103 2019‐20 9,037 114 8,994 103 8,631 42 2020‐21 9,212 175 9,141 147 8,712 81 2021‐22 9,365 153 9,251 110 8,756 44 2022‐23 9,509 144 9,341 90 8,783 27 2023‐24 9,570 61 9,338 ‐3 8,721 ‐62 2024‐25 9,609 39 9,301 ‐37 8,631 ‐90 Total Change 2014‐2024 1,556 1,248 578 ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 32: Grades K-5 Elementary School Enrollment Projections Year Op on 3—Low Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change 2014‐15 (Current) 3,659 3,659 3,659 2015‐16 3,756 97 3,754 95 3,719 60 2016‐17 3,781 25 3,775 21 3,692 ‐27 2017‐18 3,783 2 3,772 ‐3 3,646 ‐46 2018‐19 3,732 ‐51 3,717 ‐55 3,547 ‐99 2019‐20 3,696 ‐36 3,677 ‐40 3,463 ‐84 37 18 ‐196 2020‐21 3,642 ‐54 3,600 ‐77 3,337 ‐126 2021‐22 3,682 40 3,602 2 3,339 2 2022‐23 3,699 17 3,571 ‐31 3,311 ‐28 2023‐24 3,768 69 3,580 9 3,320 9 2024‐25 3,860 92 3,602 22 3,340 20 5 Yr. Change from 2019‐20 to 2024‐25 164 ‐75 ‐123 10 Yr. Change Since 2014‐15 201 5 Yr. Change from 2014‐15 to 2019‐20 Elementary Schools The elementary school level has been the fastest growing section in the last five years, increasing by 519 students or over 16% during that time. The increases were not driven by any increase in birth activity, but rather the ratio of students entering the district in kindergarten or first grade did rise during that time. As discussed, more preschool children going into public school instead of private along with new students from existing multifamily homes and more home sales helped to drive that ratio up. ‐57 ‐319 least another year, but it will then come down again. The long term projections show an overall decrease after ten years under the medium and low options. The projected declines come after some of the large gains in recent grade classes move through the system and enter middle school while smaller classes replace them. The high enrollment projection assumes that birth activity goes up and this will start to bring growth back to the smallest grades during the secondary period after 2020. Each of the projection options suggest that growth will continue at the elementary school level for at 30 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT FIGURE 33: Grades 6-8 Middle School Enrollment Projections Op on 1—High Year Total Annual Students Change Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change 2014‐15 (Current) 1,874 1,874 1,874 2015‐16 1,877 3 1,876 2 1,871 ‐3 2016‐17 2,006 129 2,004 128 1,993 122 2017‐18 2,143 137 2,138 134 2,117 124 2018‐19 2,293 150 2,285 147 2,256 139 2019‐20 2,344 51 2,334 49 2,297 41 470 460 423 2020‐21 2,398 54 2,386 52 2,351 54 2021‐22 2,334 ‐64 2,319 ‐67 2,236 ‐115 2022‐23 2,311 ‐23 2,294 ‐25 2,161 ‐75 2023‐24 2,215 ‐96 2,196 ‐98 2,011 ‐150 2024‐25 2,199 ‐16 2,178 ‐18 1,995 ‐16 5 Yr. Change from 2019‐20 to 2024‐25 ‐145 ‐156 ‐302 10 Yr. Change Since 2014‐15 325 5 Yr. Change from 2014‐15 to 2019‐20 Middle Schools The middle school level has also grown over the last five years, adding 217 students or 13% in that time, but not quite as much as the elementary schools. These grade levels are poised for even higher growth over the next 3-4 years as the larger elementary classes move into middle school. However, this growth is not expected to continue much beyond the primary period. All three projection scenarios are consistent with the notion that these grade levels will decline starting with the 2021 school year. Adjustments to the estimates of future births will not affect enrollment at the Middle School since those children will not have reached the sixth grade prior to 2025. 31 304 121 ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 34: Grades 9-12 High School Enrollment Projections Op on 1—High Year Op on 3—Low Op on 2—Medium Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Change Students 2014‐15 (Current) 2,520 2,520 2,520 2015‐16 2,670 150 2,668 148 2,640 120 2016‐17 2,693 23 2,689 21 2,634 ‐6 2017‐18 2,810 117 2,803 114 2,723 89 2018‐19 2,898 88 2,888 85 2,786 63 2019‐20 2,997 99 2,984 96 2,871 85 477 464 351 2020‐21 3,171 174 3,155 171 3,025 154 2021‐22 3,349 178 3,330 175 3,182 157 2022‐23 3,499 150 3,477 147 3,311 129 2023‐24 3,587 88 3,562 85 3,390 79 2024‐25 3,550 ‐37 3,521 ‐41 3,296 ‐94 5 Yr. Change from 2019‐20 to 2024‐25 553 537 425 10 Yr. Change Since 2014‐15 1,030 5 Yr. Change from 2014‐15 to 2019‐20 1,001 High Schools Enrollment at the high school level has also grown over the last five years, but at a much slower rate than in the elementary and middle school levels. Only 178 students were added in that time frame, which was a gain of under 8%. Going back further shows that the high school level was actually declining for the five years prior. Over the course of the decade, the net change was only a gain of 52 students. This will not be the case going forward. All three options show a period of major growth in the years ahead driven by increased class sizes already in the public school system. Adjustments made for housing construction, more multifamily home students, and potential increases in sales will also boost growth. Even the low option, which is based on an 776 increase in more students going to private school, shows substantial growth since there are already students in the system driving the increases. 32 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT District Enrollment Projections Cohort Progression Model Projected Enrollment Summaries Indicators of Projection Change Indicators of Projection Change No further adjustments to the projections on the preceding pages are necessary at this time. The background data and analysis throughout this report forms a basis and understanding of how the numbers should be interpreted. However, markets and trends can always change in unexpected manners. This section provides a further understanding of the assumptions inherent with the progression model and potential warning signs that would prompt a future reconsideration of the projected enrollment figures. Any district should continually monitor the data in this report to keep apprised of how trends are developing. A district as actively growing as the LMSD should also plan on formal studies of enrollment projections at least every three to four years. Housing Construction All three projection options in this study incorporate the same adjustment for new multifamily unit construction that is expected over the next six years. The adjustments were not altered for each option because they represent our best understanding of currently proposed projects and there is no cause to alter them unless the prospects of a proposal change in the future. Of course, all proposals are subject to sudden changes in outlook due to the marketplace, local government concerns, financial issues, or other reasons. Figure 35 provides the data that was used to make the housing adjustments in the cohort progression models. The factor used to determine the number of public school students for most of the projects was 0.04 students per unit. This factor was based on analysis of countywide figures for new multifamily construction, which includes all school-age children both public and private, and actual data for existing multifamily developments within the LMSD. Two of the projects were calculated with a larger factor of 0.12 based on their character and similar developments within the LMSD. These factors are 33 estimates intended to reflect the overall impact from the developments. One project may ultimately result in more or less students, but the total for all developments are expected to average out in the end. Of course, if a project falls through or follows a different timeline, those students attributed to that project would not make an impact as scheduled. The number of students added as an adjustment are maintained throughout the ten year study period once they enter the system, but they are added outside of the progression rates so as not to compound the influence of new construction. Birth Patterns Birth numbers are directly integrated into the cohort progression model and the number of births can significantly affect future projections, but any changes today will not be felt for at least six years in terms of the projections. The high projection model, Option 1, uses higher birth estimates than the medium and low models. Annual birth data should be tracked to anticipate if one option may become more likely during the secondary period. Live birth data is available from the Pennsylvania Department of Health, but the numbers should be correlated to the school year rather than the calendar year. Alternative School Enrollment Private school choice has been demonstrated to have a significant impact on recent growth in the public schools. The high and medium projection models assume that the lower rate of private school attendance is a reality that will continue into the foreseeable future. The trend in more public students stems from more people moving into the district for its public school system as opposed to people moving back and forth between public and private school for economic or other reasons once they are already here. However, the low projection model does show what could happen if the trend is short-lived and students return to private school in greater numbers. The American Community Survey provides delayed data on private schools averaged out over multiple years, ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 35: Factors Used for Housing Adjustment Model Calculations Project 131‐151 Rock Hill Road ES School Area Belmont Hills 600 Righters Ferry Cynwyd 335 Righters Ferry Cynwyd 150 Monument Road Cynwyd 601 & 615 Righters Ferry Cynwyd School Age Years Added to Pub‐ Children in lic School across Total Units Public School Grades 7 2017‐18 6 2018‐19 332 6 2016‐17 12 2017‐18 593 6 2018‐19 4 2017‐18 4 2018‐19 210 4 2018‐19 2019‐20 4 207 5 2019‐20 5 2020‐21 237 15 2017‐18 15 2018‐19 250 331 Penn Road* Penn Valley 112 Sibley Penn Valley 46 2 2016‐17 11‐15 E. Athens Avenue* Penn Valley 25 Palmer Seminary Penn Wynne 130 3 3 3 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 24 Cricket Avenue Penn Wynne 110 4 2017‐18 based on housing sales reaching 1,100 units per year by 2017. The recommendation of this study is that sales are more likely to remain stable at or slightly above 1,000 units, in which case an adjustment is not needed. The Planning Commission publishes annual sales totals for each municipality in its “Median Prices for Housing” report released in May. Multifamily Student Ratio Another adjustment made to all three projection models was to acknowledge a continuing increase in the number of public school students coming out of existing multifamily developments, especially apartment rentals. While the ratios of students per unit are not large, they are increasing. The adjustment considers an increase of 0.08 to 0.1 in the number of students per unit. This number can be monitored each year by comparing student address records to the addresses of multifamily developments as listed in the Multifamily Inventory found in the appendix of this study. The adjustment recognizes an additional 120 students from this trend, but if the ratio proves to go higher an additional adjustment would be needed. * These projects were calculated with a factor of 0.12 students per unit. All other projects were calculated with a factor of 0.04 students per unit. so the district’s record of private school students using district buses is going to provide more immediate information on any change in enrollment trends. Charter school and homeschooling impacts are much less substantial compared to private school, but these counts should also be monitored in case there are any unsuspected trends that would affect public school choices. Housing Sales Activity The number of market-rate housing sales transactions in the LMSD has increased over the last two years and brought more gains in public school students as a result. Regionally, the housing market overall is improving, but still going through fits and starts. If sales do increase further in the district, more “churning” of households is expected with net gains in public school students. The high projection model accommodates the growth of 93 additional students 34 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT 35 School Profiles Part LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT School Profiles Introduction Belmont Hills Elementary School Cynwyd Elementary School Gladwyne Elementary School Merion Elementary School Penn Valley Elementary School Penn Wynne Elementary School Bala Cynwyd Middle School Welsh Valley Middle School Harriton High School Lower Merion High School 37 Introduction Application of the Cohort Progression Model to individual school buildings is usually problematic and not recommended. There are concerns regarding the reduction in size of the student pool being measured, but the main problem is a lack of birth data below the municipal level. This problem was overcome in the LMSD with acquisition of birth data down to the census block group level. This allowed for a good determination of births within each elementary school boundary going back to 2003. Much of the county data used in the housing activity analyses is spatially recorded using GIS, so that it may also be broken down at the school boundary level. Adjustments included in the districtwide models have been distributed across the individual school levels and grades based on the actual data related to each area. It is fortunate to be able to develop models at the building level, but confidence in the results at the districtwide level should be higher than individual building results. Therefore, these building projections were adjusted by a single factor each year to conform to the overall district totals in the models from Part 3. The adjustments needed were minimal, changing the final totals by only a few students from what their unadjusted model would have indicated. Elementary school projections have been limited to five years due to the uncertainty with future births and the smaller student pool, although assessments of how the model would play out to ten years are included in the narrative. Middle school and high school projections are detailed out to ten years since they are drawing from a previous grade that can be more strongly estimated as opposed to birth rates six years earlier. Building projections under the Option 3 Low Model were made using modified 6 year average progression rates rather than the 9 year average used at the district level due to a lack of some data at the individual building level beyond 6 years. The modified rates reflected the overall difference between the 6 and 9 year averages seen at the district level. ENROLLMENT STUDY FIGURE 36: Summary of Projected Enrollments Under Option 2 for Elementary Schools Year Belmont Hills ES Cynwyd ES Gladwyne ES Merion ES Penn Valley ES Penn Wynne ES 2014‐15 (Actual) 468 543 738 568 660 682 2015‐16 472 542 735 600 700 704 2016‐17 474 550 740 605 694 713 2017‐18 487 543 714 602 706 720 2018‐19 485 529 715 599 685 704 2019‐20 475 526 722 603 651 700 7 ‐17 ‐16 35 ‐9 18 Total Change 2014‐2019 FIGURE 37: Summary of Projected Enrollments Under Option 2 for Middle Schools Year Bala Cynwyd MS FIGURE 38: Summary of Projected Enrollments Under Option 2 for High Schools Welsh Valley MS Year Harriton HS Lower Merion HS 2014‐15 (Actual) 901 973 2014‐15 (Actual) 1,170 1,350 2015‐16 884 992 2015‐16 1,223 1,445 2016‐17 916 1,087 2016‐17 1,239 1,450 2017‐18 996 1,141 2017‐18 1,309 1,494 2018‐19 1,082 1,204 2018‐19 1,368 1,520 2019‐20 1,108 1,226 2019‐20 1,439 1,545 2020‐21 1,149 1,237 2020‐21 1,529 1,627 2021‐22 1,101 1,218 2021‐22 1,596 1,734 2022‐23 1,103 1,191 2022‐23 1,675 1,802 2023‐24 1,042 1,155 2023‐24 1,670 1,892 2024‐25 1,044 1,134 2024‐25 1,667 1,854 143 161 497 504 Total Change 2014‐ Total Change 2014‐ 38 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Belmont Hills Elementary School births that occurred in 2010-11will provide additional students beginning in 2016-17, but the departure of the large 2014-15 fourth grade class in 2016-17 will balance out many of those additions. Growth in the Belmont Hills area has been moderate, gaining 26 students since 2009. The medium projection indicates that no major shifts are expected in the next five years. Approximately 13 new students will be added from the 131-151 Rock Hill Road project in a few years (at all grade levels, including middle and high school). The bump in Major enrollment changes are not expected for this area over the next ten years. This area will continue to experience low levels of new construction outside of the Rock Hill Road project. If that project is successful, more FIGURE 42: Number of Live Births in Belmont Hills ES FIGURE 39: Belmont Hills Elementary School Enrollment by Grade, 2009-2014 Year multifamily unis could come into the Rock Hill Road corridor in the future. K 1 2 3 4 5 Total Change 2009‐10 63 72 74 78 77 78 442 0 2003‐04 78 2010‐11 61 82 76 81 78 83 461 19 2004‐05 70 2011‐12 40 89 85 79 78 80 451 ‐10 * 2012 and 2013 school year births are estimates based on a 3 year average and adjusted to match county totals. 2005‐06 67 Source: MCPC and PA Dept. of Health 2012‐13 52 64 87 83 79 87 452 1 2006‐07 66 2013‐14 63 81 74 92 79 80 469 17 2007‐08 71 2014‐15 54 89 82 71 94 78 468 ‐1 School Year Births 2008‐09 83 Source: Lower Merion School District 2009‐10 64 FIGURE 40: Grade Progression Rates for Belmont Hills ES 2010‐11 91 2011‐12 58 2012‐13* 2013‐14* 68 72 School Year 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 Birth‐K 0.767 K‐1 1‐2 1.462 2‐3 1.042 1.019 3‐4 0.987 4‐5 1.043 FIGURE 41: Belmont Hills ES Enrollment Projections Year FIGURE 43: Housing Activity in Belmont Hills ES Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Year New Units Exis ng Built Units Sold % of Total Housing Units 2014‐15 (Current) 468 468 468 2009 1 90 2.4% 2015‐16 473 5 472 4 468 0 2016‐17 475 2 474 2 462 ‐6 2010 2011 2 5 107 102 2.8% 2.7% 2017‐18 489 14 487 13 470 8 2012 2 132 3.4% 2018‐19 488 ‐1 485 ‐2 462 ‐8 2013 3 139 3.6% 2019‐20 478 ‐10 475 ‐10 446 ‐16 Total 13 570 14.9% 10 7 ‐22 Total Change 2014‐2019 39 Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission ENROLLMENT STUDY Cynwyd Elementary School This projected decline is in spite of the amount of new multifamily units expected in the next five years. Over 1,200 new units are possible under four proposed developments, but these projects are midrise luxury apartments located along the waterfront and near City Avenue. They will not have strong family appeal, but the model adjusts for 54 potential students (at all grade levels, including middle and high school) through 2020. Cynwyd Elementary School has had a couple growth spurts in 2010-11 and 2014-15 resulting in a net gain of 64 students since 2009. However, enrollment is expected to decline in the next five years. Birth activity is down from ten years ago, which will bring smaller kindergarten and first grade classes than what the area has seen in recent years. FIGURE 47: Number of Live Births in Cynwyd ES FIGURE 44: Cynwyd Elementary School Enrollment by Grade, 2009-2014 Year The long term projection out to ten years suggests that enrollment will stay down closer to 500 students unless birth activity increases. K 1 2 3 4 5 Total Change 2009‐10 55 80 78 89 94 83 479 7 2003‐04 2010‐11 57 82 83 84 98 98 502 23 2004‐05 88 2011‐12 70 86 90 84 86 96 512 10 2005‐06 116 2012‐13 66 98 86 93 85 88 516 4 2006‐07 87 2013‐14 56 92 96 85 93 86 508 ‐8 2007‐08 85 2014‐15 71 86 102 104 85 95 543 35 School Year Births 100 2008‐09 82 Source: Lower Merion School District 2009‐10 72 FIGURE 45: Grade Progression Rates for Cynwyd ES 2010‐11 83 2011‐12 84 2012‐13* 2013‐14* 77 81 School Year 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 Birth‐K 0.681 K‐1 1‐2 1.464 2‐3 1.044 1.038 3‐4 1.034 4‐5 1.009 FIGURE 46: Cynwyd ES Enrollment Projections Year * 2012 and 2013 school year births are estimates based on a 3 year average and adjusted to match county totals. Source: MCPC and PA Dept. of Health FIGURE 48: Housing Activity in Cynwyd ES Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Year New Units Exis ng Built Units Sold % of Total Housing Units 2014‐15 (Current) 543 543 543 2009 9 77 2.5% 2015‐16 542 ‐1 542 ‐1 537 ‐6 2016‐17 551 9 550 8 539 2 2010 2011 0 2 77 99 2.5% 3.2% 2017‐18 545 ‐6 543 ‐7 526 ‐13 2012 2 113 3.6% 2018‐19 531 ‐14 529 ‐14 506 ‐20 2013 1 152 4.9% 2019‐20 529 ‐2 526 ‐3 497 ‐9 Total 14 518 16.6% Total Change 2014‐2019 ‐14 ‐17 ‐46 Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission 40 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Gladwyne Elementary School The Gladwyne Elementary School has grown at a fairly drastic rate since 2009, gaining 179 students in that time. The progression rates are very high for each grade level over the last six years indicating more students migrating into the school beyond kindergarten and first grade. Home sales have gone up considerably and this area has had more construction of single-family detached and attached units than other areas, which also can bring new students. The shift in fewer students going to private school could be having a bigger effect in this area as well. observation of current class sizes. The 3rd-5th grades are very high while the younger grades are lower in comparison. As the older classes proceed to middle school, they will be replaced by smaller classes bringing enrollment back down. All of the projection models call for an immediate end to this growth. Support for this is found in the lower birth rates the last few years and an The long term projections under Option 2 indicate that enrollment should stay down below 700 students through 2024. FIGURE 52: Number of Live Births in Gladwyne ES FIGURE 49: Gladwyne Elementary School Enrollment by Grade, 2009-2014 Year K 1 2 3 4 5 Total Change 2009‐10 80 95 89 107 83 105 559 23 2003‐04 2010‐11 86 109 105 97 109 94 600 41 2004‐05 99 2011‐12 90 107 119 107 101 109 633 33 2005‐06 116 2012‐13 66 131 120 129 120 109 675 42 2006‐07 123 2013‐14 71 110 132 128 140 120 701 26 2007‐08 90 2014‐15 90 103 112 145 137 151 738 37 School Year Births 118 2008‐09 112 Source: Lower Merion School District 2009‐10 104 FIGURE 50: Grade Progression Rates for Gladwyne ES 2010‐11 110 2011‐12 92 2012‐13* 2013‐14* 98 103 School Year 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 Birth‐K 0.742 K‐1 1‐2 1.437 2‐3 1.081 1.071 3‐4 1.067 4‐5 1.052 FIGURE 51: Gladwyne ES Enrollment Projections Year * 2012 and 2013 school year births are estimates based on a 3 year average and adjusted to match county totals. Source: MCPC and PA Dept. of Health FIGURE 53: Housing Activity in Gladwyne ES Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Year New Units Exis ng Built Units Sold % of Total Housing Units 2014‐15 (Current) 738 738 738 2009 17 150 2.2% 2015‐16 736 ‐2 735 ‐3 729 ‐9 2016‐17 741 5 740 5 724 ‐5 2010 2011 19 19 196 182 2.9% 2.7% 2017‐18 715 ‐26 714 ‐26 690 ‐34 2012 35 241 3.6% 2018‐19 717 2 715 1 682 ‐8 2013 25 259 3.8% 2019‐20 725 8 722 7 680 ‐2 Total 115 1028 15.3% Total Change 2014‐2019 ‐13 ‐16 ‐58 41 Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission ENROLLMENT STUDY Merion Elementary School Birth activity has been fairly consistent since 2005 and this area has seen lower sales activity than some other school areas. Very little home construction is occurring and no major proposals are being considered. These trends all support the stability of enrollment at Merion shown in the medium projection. Over the long term, enrollment should hover just under 600 students under Option 2. The Merion Elementary School has grown by 78 students since 2009 with some inconsistent jumps in enrollment. The projections show that the school is in for another substantial increase in 2015-16, but will remain stable following next year. The growth in 2015 is coming from the departure of an undersized 5th grade class in 2014-15. FIGURE 57: Number of Live Births in Merion ES FIGURE 54: Merion Elementary School Enrollment by Grade, 2009-2014 Year K 1 2 3 4 5 Total Change 2009‐10 53 86 87 94 88 82 490 14 2003‐04 91 2010‐11 68 69 88 90 90 90 495 5 2004‐05 117 2011‐12 68 97 75 95 95 100 530 35 * 2012 and 2013 school year births are estimates based on a 3 year average and adjusted to match county totals. 2005‐06 102 Source: MCPC and PA Dept. of Health 2012‐13 82 97 107 81 89 93 549 19 2006‐07 101 2013‐14 73 100 102 105 80 89 549 0 2007‐08 106 2014‐15 75 94 103 114 102 80 568 19 School Year Births 2008‐09 97 Source: Lower Merion School District 2009‐10 100 FIGURE 55: Grade Progression Rates for Merion ES 2010‐11 100 2011‐12 103 2012‐13* 2013‐14* 97 102 School Year 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 Birth‐K 0.684 K‐1 1‐2 1.409 2‐3 1.055 1.056 3‐4 0.991 4‐5 1.027 FIGURE 56: Merion ES Enrollment Projections Year FIGURE 58: Housing Activity in Merion ES Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Year New Units Exis ng Built Units Sold % of Total Housing Units 2014‐15 (Current) 568 568 568 2009 2 89 2.7% 2015‐16 600 32 600 32 594 26 2016‐17 606 6 605 5 592 ‐2 2010 2011 0 1 76 89 2.3% 2.7% 2017‐18 603 ‐3 602 ‐3 581 ‐11 2012 1 94 2.9% 2018‐19 601 ‐2 599 ‐3 571 ‐10 2013 0 96 2.9% 2019‐20 606 5 603 4 567 ‐4 Total 4 444 13.5% 38 35 ‐1 Total Change 2014‐2019 Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission 42 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Penn Valley Elementary School expected to slow down growth and the departure of the currently large class sizes will ultimately bring enrollment back to under the current total by 2019 according to the Option 2 projection. Penn Valley Elementary School has grown each year since 2009, adding 149 students in that time. The area had a surge in birth activity from 2004-2007 which has fueled growth over the last five years. The school also has relatively high progression rates for its birth-kindergarten and kindergarten-1st grade transitions. A gradual lowering of birth activity is This area does have a few multifamily projects being proposed and they are viewed as having a bit more of an effect on school-age children than some of the other developments studied. The projects are Home sales have not risen as dramatically as in other areas and remain a relatively low percentage of total housing units. The long term projection for Option 2 holds enrollment within the 650-670 range through 2024. FIGURE 62: Number of Live Births in Penn Valley ES FIGURE 59: Penn Valley Elementary School Enrollment by Grade, 2009-2014 Year expected to bring about 35 students into the Penn Valley area by 2018. K 1 2 3 4 5 Total Change 2009‐10 63 96 89 84 95 84 511 41 2003‐04 76 2010‐11 68 89 97 93 89 88 524 13 2004‐05 94 2011‐12 69 104 94 108 109 100 584 60 * 2012 and 2013 school year births are estimates based on a 3 year average and adjusted to match county totals. 2005‐06 97 Source: MCPC and PA Dept. of Health 2012‐13 85 107 108 89 111 114 614 30 2006‐07 101 2013‐14 91 125 97 113 95 115 636 22 2007‐08 106 2014‐15 63 133 131 112 125 96 660 24 School Year Births 2008‐09 80 Source: Lower Merion School District 2009‐10 97 FIGURE 60: Grade Progression Rates for Penn Valley ES 2010‐11 73 2011‐12 95 2012‐13* 2013‐14* 84 89 School Year 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 Birth‐K 0.792 K‐1 1‐2 1.509 2‐3 1.020 1.059 3‐4 1.081 4‐5 1.049 FIGURE 61: Penn Valley ES Enrollment Projections Year FIGURE 63: Housing Activity in Penn Valley ES Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Year New Units Exis ng Built Units Sold % of Total Housing Units 2014‐15 (Current) 660 660 660 2009 12 115 2.3% 2015‐16 700 40 700 40 693 33 2016‐17 695 ‐5 694 ‐6 679 ‐14 2010 2011 9 3 120 121 2.4% 2.4% 2017‐18 708 13 706 12 683 4 2012 4 130 2.6% 2018‐19 688 ‐20 685 ‐21 655 ‐28 2013 1 167 3.3% 2019‐20 654 ‐34 651 ‐34 612 ‐43 Total 29 653 13.0% ‐6 ‐9 ‐48 Total Change 2014‐2019 43 Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission ENROLLMENT STUDY Penn Wynne Elementary School recent years. Its other progression ratios are not as high as some other areas though. This could be due to more families coming into the area with children at a younger age than kindergarten or having children after moving. Housing sales are very strong in Penn Wynne with the highest percentage of housing units selling. The Penn Wynne Elementary School has experienced rapid growth just within the last couple of years, gaining 124 students since 2010. Birth activity affecting the recent classes has not declined in Penn Wynne like it has in some areas and it should remain consistent. Penn Wynne does have the highest birthkindergarten ratio with larger kindergarten classes in FIGURE 67: Number of Live Births in Penn Wynne ES FIGURE 64: Penn Wynne Elementary School Enrollment by Grade, 2009-2014 Year K 1 2009‐10 77 89 2010‐11 71 2011‐12 2 The current growth should slow down and begin to reverse somewhat with overall enrollment only going up 18 by 2019-20, although it peaks at 720 in 201718 under Option 2. In the long term, enrollment is expected to stabilize under 700 students through 2024. 3 4 5 Total Change 104 99 96 93 558 ‐7 2003‐04 105 97 90 99 107 94 558 0 2004‐05 114 76 102 93 91 99 115 576 18 * 2012 and 2013 school year births are estimates based on a 3 year average and adjusted to match county totals. 2005‐06 106 Source: MCPC and PA Dept. of Health 2012‐13 87 105 106 97 96 102 593 17 2006‐07 88 2013‐14 95 122 115 117 98 98 645 52 2007‐08 115 2014‐15 101 116 128 114 117 106 682 37 School Year Births 2008‐09 106 Source: Lower Merion School District 2009‐10 106 FIGURE 65: Grade Progression Rates for Penn Wynne ES 2010‐11 112 2011‐12 104 2012‐13* 2013‐14* 102 108 School Year 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 Birth‐K 0.807 K‐1 1‐2 1.317 2‐3 1.032 1.014 3‐4 1.021 4‐5 1.035 FIGURE 66: Penn Wynne ES Enrollment Projections Year FIGURE 68: Housing Activity in Penn Wynne ES Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Year New Units Exis ng Built Units Sold % of Total Housing Units 2014‐15 (Current) 682 682 682 2009 0 137 3.4% 2015‐16 705 23 704 22 697 15 2016‐17 714 9 713 9 697 0 2010 2011 0 0 133 134 3.3% 3.3% 2017‐18 722 8 720 7 696 ‐1 2012 1 154 3.8% 2018‐19 706 ‐16 704 ‐16 671 ‐25 2013 13 163 4.1% 2019‐20 704 ‐2 700 ‐4 659 ‐12 Total 14 721 17.9% 22 18 ‐23 Total Change 2014‐2019 Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission 44 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Bala Cynwyd Middle School still add more students each year from new students coming into the district. The Bala Cynwyd Middle School had been growing each year up until 2014, with a total of 86 students added since 2009 gaining 124 students since 2010. The major factor influencing middle school growth is the prior year’s 5th grade class coming out of the elementary schools in BCMS’s area. The progression rates show that all middle school grades Enrollment will dip down next year based on the departure of an above average sized 8th grade class. However, more growth will follow over the next five years as the recent increases at the elementary schools, especially Penn Wynne ES, move into middle school grades. Option 2 shows a gain of over FIGURE 69: Bala Cynwyd MS Enrollment by Grade, 2009-2014 Year 6 7 8 2009‐10 283 265 267 815 16 2010‐11 268 295 268 831 16 2011‐12 284 274 307 865 34 2012‐13 318 292 283 893 28 2013‐14 290 332 300 922 29 2014‐15 280 299 322 901 ‐21 Source: Lower Merion School District FIGURE 70: Grade Progression Rates for Bala Cynwyd MS 5‐6 6‐7 7‐8 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 1.025 1.035 1.022 FIGURE 71: Housing Activity in Bala Cynwyd MS Year % of Total New Units Exis ng Housing Built Units Sold Units 2009 2010 11 0 303 286 2.9% 2.7% 2011 3 322 3.1% 2012 4 361 3.5% 2013 13 411 3.9% Total 31 1,683 16.1% Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission 45 FIGURE 72: Bala Cynwyd MS Enrollment Projections Total Change School Year 200 students by 2019. Enrollment will decline during the second half of the decade but all three options still show an increase. Note that under either option, growth will not be avoided in the next six years due to public school increases that have already occurred. Year Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change 2014‐15 (Current) 901 901 901 2015‐16 885 ‐16 884 ‐17 882 ‐19 2016‐17 918 33 916 32 911 29 2017‐18 999 81 996 80 987 76 2018‐19 1,085 86 1,082 86 1,068 81 2019‐20 1,113 28 1,108 26 1,090 22 2020‐21 1,156 43 1,149 41 1,132 42 2021‐22 1,108 ‐48 1,101 ‐48 1,063 ‐69 2022‐23 1,112 4 1,103 2 1,041 ‐22 2023‐24 1,051 ‐61 1,042 ‐61 954 ‐87 2024‐25 1,054 3 1,044 2 956 2 153 143 55 Total Change 2014‐2024 Welsh Valley Middle School school grades still add more students each year from new students coming into the district. The Welsh Valley Middle School has grown each year since 2009, with a total of 174 students added in that time. The major factor influencing middle school growth is the prior year’s 5th grade class coming out of the elementary schools in WVMS’s area. The progression rates show that all middle Enrollment will continue to grow over the next five years as the recent increases at the elementary schools move into middle school grades. Option 2 shows a gain of over 250 students by 2019. Enrollment will decline during the second half of the decade but all three options still show an increase. FIGURE 73: Welsh Valley MS Enrollment by Grade, 2009-2014 Year 6 7 8 2009‐10 279 249 271 799 15 2010‐11 281 289 259 829 30 2011‐12 280 290 293 863 34 2012‐13 312 301 302 915 52 2013‐14 313 330 301 944 29 2014‐15 330 305 338 973 29 Source: Lower Merion School District FIGURE 74: Grade Progression Rates for Welsh Valley MS 5‐6 6‐7 7‐8 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 1.039 1.033 1.022 FIGURE 75: Housing Activity in Welsh Valley MS Year FIGURE 76: Welsh Valley MS Enrollment Projections Total Change School Year % of Total New Units Exis ng Housing Built Units Sold Units 2009 30 355 2.3% 2010 2011 30 27 423 405 2.7% 2.6% 2012 41 503 3.2% 2013 29 565 3.6% Total 157 2,251 14.4% Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission Note that under either option, growth will not be avoided in the next six years due to public school increases that have already occurred. Year Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change 2014‐15 (Current) 973 973 973 2015‐16 993 20 992 19 989 16 2016‐17 1,089 96 1,087 95 1,081 92 2017‐18 1,144 55 1,141 54 1,130 49 2018‐19 1,208 64 1,204 63 1,188 58 2019‐20 1,231 23 1,226 22 1,206 18 2020‐21 1,243 12 1,237 11 1,218 12 2021‐22 1,225 ‐18 1,218 ‐19 1,173 ‐45 2022‐23 1,199 ‐26 1,191 ‐27 1,120 ‐53 2023‐24 1,164 ‐35 1,155 ‐36 1,057 ‐63 2024‐25 1,145 ‐19 1,134 ‐21 1,039 18 172 161 66 Total Change 2014‐2024 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Harriton High School districts will see their high school grades start to decline, but the LMSD continues to bring in new students at this level for a net gain. The Harriton High School grew rapidly for four years from 2009 to 2012 and then remained steady. The major factor influencing high school growth is the prior year’s 8th grade class coming out of the Welsh Valley MS area. The progression rates show that all high school grades still add more students each year from new students coming into the district. Many Enrollment will grow at a high rate over the next eight years as a result of the growth that has already occurred at smaller grade levels. Student choice zones and the International Baccalaureate program have been accounted for in these projections. FIGURE 80: Harriton HS Enrollment Projections FIGURE 77: Harriton HS Enrollment by Grade, 2009-2014 Year 9 10 11 12 Total Change 2009‐10 292 200 199 205 896 98 2010‐11 277 307 214 213 1,011 115 2011‐12 280 283 312 211 1,086 75 2012‐13 299 282 296 311 1,188 102 2013‐14 294 308 289 294 1,185 ‐2 2014‐15 295 283 300 292 1,170 ‐15 Source: Lower Merion School District FIGURE 78: Grade Progression Rates for Harriton HS School Year 8‐9 9‐10 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 1.025 1.018 10‐11 1.026 FIGURE 79: Housing Activity in Harriton HS Year % of Total New Units Exis ng Housing Built Units Sold Units 2009 30 355 2.3% 2010 2011 30 27 423 405 2.7% 2.6% 2012 41 503 3.2% 2013 29 565 3.6% Total 157 2,251 14.4% Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission 47 11‐12 1.011 Year Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change 2014‐15 (Current) 1,170 1,170 1,170 2015‐16 1,224 54 1,223 53 1,211 41 2016‐17 1,241 17 1,239 16 1,214 3 2017‐18 1,313 72 1,309 70 1,271 57 2018‐19 1,373 60 1,368 59 1,319 48 2019‐20 1,445 72 1,439 71 1,383 64 2020‐21 1,536 91 1,529 90 1,464 81 2021‐22 1,604 68 1,596 67 1,523 59 2022‐23 1,685 81 1,675 79 1,594 71 2023‐24 1,682 ‐3 1,670 ‐5 1,589 ‐5 2024‐25 1,680 ‐2 1,667 ‐3 1,558 ‐31 510 497 388 Total Change 2014‐2024 A Note About Choice Zones: The LMSD offers 8th grade students from Welsh Valley MS living within a specified boundary surrounding Lower Merion High School the opportunity to attend Lower Merion HS instead of Harriton. The progression rates used for Harriton HS account for this effect. The rate observed for the grade 8-9 transition (1.025) would be considerably higher if not for some Welsh Valley students choosing to attend Lower Merion HS. The choice zone was expanded in 2014, so an adjustment was made to the projections under the assumption that 40% of the students in the expanded choice zone would choose to attend Lower Merion High School. Lower Merion High School students coming into the district. Many districts will see their high school grades start to decline, but the LMSD continues to bring in new students at this level for a net gain. The Lower Merion High School was declining going back as far as the 2006-07 school year, but started to increase beginning in 2012. The major factor influencing high school growth is the prior year’s 8th grade class coming out of the Bala Cynwyd MS area. The progression rates show that all high school grades still add more students each year from new Enrollment at Lower Merion HS will grow at a high rate over the next nine years as a result of the growth that has already occurred at smaller grade levels. Student choice zones and the International FIGURE 81: Lower Merion HS Enrollment by Grade, 2009-2014 Year 9 10 11 12 310 328 364 401 1,403 ‐67 2010‐11 307 313 333 378 1,331 ‐72 2011‐12 293 306 323 338 1,260 ‐71 2012‐13 357 297 305 328 1,287 27 2013‐14 320 369 298 313 1,300 13 2014‐15 347 327 371 305 1,350 50 Source: Lower Merion School District FIGURE 82: Grade Progression Rates for Lower Merion HS 8‐9 9‐10 6‐Yr Avg. 2009‐2014 1.128 1.016 10‐11 1.008 FIGURE 83: Housing Activity in Lower Merion HS Year % of Total New Units Exis ng Housing Built Units Sold Units 2009 11 303 2.9% 2010 2011 0 3 286 322 2.7% 3.1% 2012 4 361 3.5% 2013 13 411 3.9% Total 31 1,683 16.1% Source: Montgomery County Planning Commission FIGURE 84: Lower Merion HS Enrollment Projections Total Change 2009‐10 School Year Baccalaureate program have been accounted for in these projections. 11‐12 1.021 Year Op on 1—High Op on 2—Medium Op on 3—Low Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change Total Annual Students Change 2014‐15 (Current) 1,350 1,350 1,350 2015‐16 1,446 96 1,445 95 1,430 80 2016‐17 1,452 6 1,450 5 1,421 ‐9 2017‐18 1,497 45 1,494 44 1,452 31 2018‐19 1,525 28 1,520 26 1,467 15 2019‐20 1,552 27 1,545 25 1,489 22 2020‐21 1,636 84 1,627 82 1,561 72 2021‐22 1,745 109 1,734 107 1,659 98 2022‐23 1,814 69 1,802 68 1,718 59 2023‐24 1,905 91 1,892 90 1,801 83 2024‐25 1,869 ‐36 1,854 ‐38 1,738 ‐63 519 504 388 Total Change 2014‐2024 A Note About Choice Zones: The LMSD offers 8th grade students from Welsh Valley MS living within a specified boundary surrounding Lower Merion High School the opportunity to attend Lower Merion HS instead of Harriton. The progression rates used for Lower Merion HS account for this effect. The rate observed for the grade 8-9 transition (1.128) would be considerably lower if not for some Welsh Valley students choosing to attend Lower Merion HS The choice zone was expanded in 2014, so an adjustment was made to the projections under the assumption that 40% of the students in the expanded choice zone would choose to attend Lower Merion High School. 48 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT 49 Appendix Part LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Appendix.1 Multifamily Inventory All multifamily developments with 20+ units and the number of enrolled LMSD students in 2006, 2010, and 2014. Name Oak Hill/Tower at Oak Hill Green Hill 191 Condominium Wynnewood Park Apartments Thomas Wynne Apartments Sutton Terrace Brynwood Apartments Corinthian Fairmont Twelve Nineteen Condominium Suburban Court Apartments Wynnewood House Whitehall Apartments Oakwynne House Apartments Wynnewood Plaza Condominium Latch's Lane Condominiums Conwyn Arms Montgomery Court Trianon Apartments Tedwyn Apartments Benson House 429 Apartments The Mermont Wyndon Apartments Montgomery Plaza 101 Apartments Mayflower Square Saint George's Apartments Narberth Hall Apartments Hampshires at Haverford Condos Llanfair House Apartments Mermont Plaza Grays Lane House The Greenhouse Dunfern Apartments Thornbrook Manor Apartments Merion Court Apartments Hunter House Bryn Mawr Gables One Montgomery Avenue Lakeside Apartments 51 Unit Type Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Street Address 1637 Oakwood Drive 1001 City Avenue 191 Presidential Blvd 150 E Wynnewood Rd 200 N Wynnewood Ave 50 Belmont Ave 250 E Wynnewood Rd 190 Presidential Blvd 41 Conshohocken State Rd 1219 W Wynnewood Rd 113 Cricket Ave 300 E Lancaster Ave 410 Lancaster Ave 1209 W Wynnewood Rd 346 E Lancaster Ave 40 Old Lancaster Rd 830 W Montgomery Ave 214 Price Ave 20 Conshohocken State Rd 840 W Montgomery Ave 930 W Montgomery Ave 429 W Montgomery Ave 906 W Montgomery Ave 625 E Lancaster Ave 120 E Montgomery Ave 101 Mill Creek Rd 922 W Montgomery Ave 119 Mill Creek Rd 300 N Essex Ave 104 Woodside Rd 17 Llanfair Rd 901 Montgomery Ave 100 Grays Lane & Montgomery Avenue 19 Rock Hill Rd 10 Montgomery Ave 819 W Montgomery Ave 118 Montgomery Ave 449 W Montgomery Ave 806 W Montgomery Ave 1 Montgomery Ave 170 Lakeside Rd Date Units Built 753 1969 543 1960 228 1963 224 1945 215 1950 172 1974 150 1950 108 2006 100 1976 96 1976 95 1926 88 1956 88 1926 84 1961 83 1945 81 1948 80 1954 73 1940 73 1976 72 1959 67 1977 66 1940 66 1940 65 1948 64 1964 62 1963 62 1952 60 1930 60 1929 59 1939 58 1966 55 52 1975 50 1976 50 1924 50 1939 49 1954 49 1967 48 1930 46 1964 45 1975 Students/ unit 0.05 0.04 0.04 0.13 0.17 0.00 0.21 0.03 0.00 0.02 0.05 0.03 0.02 0.06 0.06 0.09 0.15 0.25 0.04 0.00 0.00 0.05 0.00 0.18 0.13 0.18 0.00 0.08 0.12 0.00 0.05 0.13 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.00 0.35 0.00 0.00 0.20 0.40 2014-15 Student Count 41 24 9 30 37 0 32 3 0 2 5 3 2 5 5 7 12 18 3 0 0 3 0 12 8 11 0 5 7 0 3 7 1 1 1 0 17 0 0 9 18 2010-11 Student Count 21 13 3 44 17 0 29 6 0 2 0 3 1 1 3 6 11 13 0 0 0 8 0 5 4 8 0 1 3 1 1 3 0 1 2 0 9 3 0 10 7 2006-07 Student Count 19 9 3 30 12 2 24 1 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 5 8 10 0 0 0 9 0 3 10 7 0 3 1 0 0 3 0 0 1 0 9 1 0 5 7 ENROLLMENT STUDY Name Argyle Court Apartments Churchill Court Cynwyd Court Edgehill Court Apartments 101 Cheswold Lane Condominiums Pennmount Apartments Wynmont Merion Manor Yorklynne Manor Hardie Apartments Summit Court Apartments Pennswood Condos Waterford Condos Haverford Apartments Cricket Club Bryn Mawr Court 37 East Montgomery Condominiums (NONE) Bernola Apartments Narberth Station Apartments Sevilla Court Beechwood Apartments Breton Hall Apartments Haverford Gables Apartments Essex Manor Apartments Cambridge Square Unit Type Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Street Address 126 Argyle Rd 237 W Montgomery Ave 42 Conshohocken State Rd 25 Old Lancaster Rd 101 Cheswold Ln 34 W Montgomery Ave 1334 Montgomery Ave 212 Idris Dr 415 City Ave 1 Oakland Ter 101 Summit Ln 601 W Montgomery Ave 383 Lakeside Rd 411 Lancaster Ave 103 W Montgomery Ave 805 W Montgomery Ave 37 E Montgomery Ave 859 Old Lancaster Rd 87 Rittenhouse Pl 280 Haverford Ave 32 Conshohocken State Rd 509 Conway Ave 117 N Essex Ave 312 W Montgomery Ave 205 N Essex Ave 120 Sibley Ave Date Units Built 44 1920 42 1920 38 1948 37 1960 33 1982 32 1965 32 1960 31 1925 31 1926 28 1925 28 1952 27 1960 27 1989 26 1920 25 1972 25 1922 24 1965 24 1960 24 1900 24 1929 24 1940 24 1956 24 1961 23 1920 23 1962 21 2007 Coach House Essex House Ardglen Apartments Llanberris Apartments La Chanterelle Llanalew Condos Mansard House Llanfair Court Apartments Merioneth Apartments Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Condo Multifamily Rental Multifamily Rental 1011 W Mongtomery Ave and 100-108 N. 226 Essex Ave 18 W Montgomery Ave 101 Conshohocken State Rd 414 Old Lancaster Rd 100 Llanalew Rd 264 W Montgomery Ave 200 E Montgomery Ave 20 W Montgomery Ave 21 21 21 21 20 20 20 20 20 1957 1973 1962 1950 1982 1977 1972 1960 1962 2014-15 Student Count 2010-11 Student Count 2006-07 Student Count Students/ unit 0.05 0.00 0.13 0.11 0.03 0.28 0.03 0.00 0.16 0.04 0.36 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.04 0.00 0.08 0.17 0.00 0.08 0.29 0.00 0.00 0.13 0.00 0.05 2 0 5 4 1 9 1 0 5 1 10 0 0 0 1 0 2 4 0 2 7 0 0 3 0 1 2 0 0 2 0 2 2 0 7 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 6 6 1 0 3 0 0 0 1 1 3 2 4 2 0 3 1 5 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 3 5 0 1 1 0 0 0.05 0.00 0.00 0.76 0.05 0.05 0.00 0.30 0.40 1 0 0 16 1 1 0 6 8 0 0 0 8 0 0 0 8 2 1 0 0 8 0 2 0 11 1 52 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT Appendix.2 Individual Building Projection Datasheets A. BELMONT HILLS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 53 BIRTHS 64 91 58 68 72 BELMONT HILLS ES OPTION 1 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 49 79 93 84 70 70 72 82 95 83 46 103 75 84 94 54 67 107 77 84 57 78 69 109 76 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 473 98 475 73 489 87 488 98 87 478 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 BIRTHS 64 91 58 68 72 BELMONT HILLS ES OPTION 2 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 49 79 93 84 70 70 72 82 94 82 45 102 75 84 94 54 66 107 77 83 57 77 69 109 76 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 472 98 474 73 487 86 485 98 87 475 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 BIRTHS 64 91 58 68 72 BELMONT HILLS ES OPTION 3 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 45 79 92 84 70 65 67 82 94 82 42 95 70 84 93 50 62 99 72 83 53 72 64 101 70 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 468 98 462 72 470 86 462 97 86 446 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 ENROLLMENT STUDY B. CYNWYD ELEMENTARY SCHOOL YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 BIRTHS 72 83 84 77 81 CYNWYD ES OPTION 1 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 49 104 90 106 108 57 72 109 94 110 59 85 77 114 98 56 87 89 81 119 60 81 91 93 84 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 542 86 551 109 545 112 531 100 121 529 BIRTHS 72 83 84 77 81 CYNWYD ES OPTION 2 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 49 104 90 106 107 57 72 109 93 110 59 84 76 114 98 55 86 89 80 118 59 80 91 93 83 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 542 86 550 109 543 112 529 99 120 526 CYNWYD ES OPTION 3 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 45 104 89 106 107 53 67 109 93 109 55 79 71 114 97 52 81 83 75 118 55 75 84 86 77 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 537 85 539 108 526 111 506 98 119 497 BIRTHS 72 83 84 77 81 54 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT C. GLADWYNE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 55 BIRTHS 104 110 92 98 103 GLADWYNE ES OPTION 1 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 77 129 111 120 155 82 111 139 119 128 69 117 119 149 127 73 98 126 128 159 77 105 106 135 136 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 736 144 741 162 715 134 717 133 167 725 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 BIRTHS 104 110 92 98 103 GLADWYNE ES OPTION 2 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 77 129 111 120 154 82 110 139 119 128 68 117 119 149 127 73 98 126 127 158 77 104 105 135 135 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 472 144 474 162 487 134 485 133 166 475 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 BIRTHS 104 110 92 98 103 GLADWYNE ES OPTION 3 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 71 130 111 120 75 103 140 119 63 109 111 149 67 91 117 118 71 97 98 125 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 729 143 724 161 690 133 682 131 165 680 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 4 153 127 125 158 125 ENROLLMENT STUDY D. MERION ELEMENTARY SCHOOL YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 BIRTHS 100 100 103 97 102 KDG 69 69 71 68 71 MERION ES OPTION 1 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 1 2 3 106 99 109 97 112 105 97 102 118 100 102 108 95 106 108 4 113 108 104 117 107 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 600 105 606 116 603 111 601 107 120 606 BIRTHS 100 100 103 97 102 MERION ES OPTION 2 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 69 106 99 109 69 96 111 105 71 97 102 118 67 100 102 107 71 94 105 107 4 113 108 104 116 106 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 600 105 605 116 602 111 599 107 119 603 MERION ES OPTION 3 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 63 106 99 109 64 90 112 104 66 90 94 118 62 93 95 100 66 88 98 100 4 112 107 103 116 98 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 594 105 592 115 581 110 571 105 119 567 BIRTHS 100 100 103 97 102 56 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT E. PENN VALLEY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 57 BIRTHS 97 73 95 84 89 PENN VALLEY ES OPTION 1 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 77 95 136 139 121 59 116 98 144 150 78 89 120 105 157 71 117 92 128 114 75 104 119 98 138 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 700 131 695 128 708 159 688 165 119 654 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 BIRTHS 97 73 95 84 89 PENN VALLEY ES OPTION 2 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 77 95 136 139 121 59 116 97 144 150 77 89 120 104 157 70 117 92 128 114 74 104 119 97 138 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 700 131 694 127 706 159 685 165 119 651 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 BIRTHS 97 73 95 84 89 PENN VALLEY ES OPTION 3 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 71 96 136 139 121 54 108 98 144 149 72 83 111 105 155 65 109 86 119 113 69 97 111 90 127 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 693 131 679 126 683 157 655 163 118 612 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 ENROLLMENT STUDY F. PENN WYNNE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 BIRTHS 106 112 104 102 108 PENN WYNNE ES OPTION 1 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 85 133 120 130 116 91 113 137 121 132 85 120 117 139 124 83 111 123 118 142 88 109 115 125 120 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 705 121 714 120 722 137 706 128 147 704 BIRTHS 106 112 104 102 108 PENN WYNNE ES OPTION 2 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 85 133 120 130 116 90 112 137 121 132 85 119 116 139 124 83 111 123 118 142 88 109 114 124 120 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 704 121 713 120 720 137 704 128 146 700 PENN WYNNE ES OPTION 3 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT KDG 1 2 3 4 79 134 119 129 115 84 105 137 121 131 78 111 108 140 123 77 103 114 109 141 81 101 106 115 110 5 TOTAL STUDENTS 697 121 697 119 696 136 671 126 145 659 BIRTHS 106 112 104 102 108 58 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT G. BALA CYNWYD MIDDLE SCHOOL 59 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 BALA CYNWYD MS OPTION 1 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 5TH GRADE 6 7 8 TOTAL STUDENTS 885 312 288 290 306 918 345 320 300 298 999 360 356 334 309 1,085 335 371 371 343 1,113 387 345 386 381 1,156 319 399 360 397 1,108 338 327 413 368 1,112 334 348 340 424 1,051 318 343 361 348 336 328 356 370 1,054 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 BALA CYNWYD MS OPTION 2 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 5TH GRADE 6 7 8 TOTAL STUDENTS 884 311 288 290 306 916 345 320 299 297 996 359 356 333 308 1,082 334 370 369 342 1,108 385 344 385 379 1,149 317 397 358 395 1,101 336 325 411 366 1,103 331 345 337 421 1,042 315 340 358 344 332 324 353 367 1,044 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 BALA CYNWYD MS OPTION 3 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 5TH GRADE 6 7 8 TOTAL STUDENTS 882 311 287 290 305 911 342 318 298 296 987 356 351 331 305 1,068 330 365 364 338 1,090 383 338 379 373 1,132 291 393 351 388 1,063 309 298 406 358 1,041 305 317 309 415 954 290 312 328 315 306 297 323 335 956 ENROLLMENT STUDY H. WELSH VALLEY MIDDLE SCHOOL YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 WELSH VALLEY MS OPTION 1 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 5TH GRADE 6 7 8 TOTAL STUDENTS 993 373 339 342 312 1,089 363 389 350 350 1,144 380 380 404 360 1,208 397 397 395 415 1,231 373 414 412 405 1,243 367 390 430 423 1,225 374 382 403 440 1,199 342 390 396 414 1,164 347 356 403 405 366 362 369 414 1,145 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 WELSH VALLEY MS OPTION 2 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 5TH GRADE 6 7 8 TOTAL STUDENTS 992 373 338 341 312 1,087 362 388 350 349 1,141 379 379 403 360 1,204 396 396 394 414 1,226 372 412 410 403 1,237 365 388 428 421 1,218 371 379 401 437 1,191 339 387 393 411 1,155 344 353 400 402 363 358 366 411 1,134 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 WELSH VALLEY MS OPTION 3 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 5TH GRADE 6 7 8 TOTAL STUDENTS 989 372 337 341 311 1,081 359 386 348 348 1,130 375 374 400 357 1,188 391 391 388 410 1,206 369 406 404 396 1,218 336 384 420 414 1,173 342 348 397 429 1,120 312 355 360 405 1,057 316 323 367 367 334 329 335 375 1,039 60 LOWER MERION SCHOOL DISTRICT I. HARRITON HIGH SCHOOL 61 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 HARRITON HS OPTION 1 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 12 TOTAL STUDENTS 8TH GRADE 9 10 11 304 1,224 312 327 301 291 1,241 295 350 301 334 310 1,313 360 340 310 347 316 1,373 415 349 350 321 353 1,445 405 402 357 360 326 1,536 423 393 410 368 365 1,604 440 410 401 422 372 1,685 414 427 418 412 428 1,682 405 399 435 430 418 414 391 407 447 1,680 436 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 HARRITON HS OPTION 2 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 8TH GRADE 9 10 11 12 TOTAL STUDENTS 1,223 312 327 301 291 304 1,239 349 301 334 309 295 1,309 360 339 309 346 315 1,368 414 348 348 320 352 1,439 403 401 355 359 324 1,529 421 391 409 366 363 1,596 437 407 398 420 370 1,675 411 424 416 409 426 1,670 402 397 432 427 414 411 387 404 444 1,667 432 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 HARRITON HS OPTION 3 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 8TH GRADE 9 10 11 12 TOTAL STUDENTS 1,211 311 321 298 289 303 1,214 348 293 324 305 292 1,271 357 330 298 334 309 1,319 410 338 336 307 338 1,383 396 388 342 343 309 1,464 414 376 392 350 346 1,523 429 392 380 400 352 1,594 405 406 396 388 403 1,589 367 383 411 404 391 375 345 387 419 1,558 407 ENROLLMENT STUDY J. LOWER MERION HIGH SCHOOL YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 LOWER MERION HS OPTION 1 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 12 TOTAL STUDENTS 8TH GRADE 9 10 11 379 1,446 306 384 353 330 1,452 338 298 366 391 357 1,497 309 359 374 396 367 1,525 343 373 367 379 406 1,552 381 413 380 371 389 1,636 397 453 420 384 379 1,745 368 471 459 423 391 1,814 424 440 478 464 432 1,905 348 503 446 482 473 370 416 511 450 1,869 492 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 LOWER MERION HS OPTION 2 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 12 TOTAL STUDENTS 8TH GRADE 9 10 11 1,445 306 383 353 330 379 1,450 297 366 390 357 338 1,494 308 358 374 396 366 1,520 342 371 365 378 405 1,545 379 410 378 369 387 1,627 395 451 417 382 377 1,734 366 468 457 420 389 1,802 421 437 476 461 429 1,892 344 499 443 479 470 367 412 506 447 1,854 489 YEAR 2015‐16 2016‐17 2017‐18 2018‐19 2019‐20 2020‐21 2021‐22 2022‐23 2023‐24 2024‐25 LOWER MERION HS OPTION 3 PROJECTED ENROLLMENT 12 TOTAL STUDENTS 8TH GRADE 9 10 11 1,430 305 375 350 328 377 1,421 296 357 378 351 334 1,452 305 350 362 381 359 1,467 338 360 354 364 389 1,489 373 398 364 356 371 1,561 388 433 401 365 362 1,659 358 450 436 402 371 1,718 415 419 454 437 408 1,801 315 481 422 454 444 335 369 484 422 1,738 461 62