landscape - Irish Landscape Institute
Transcription
landscape - Irish Landscape Institute
LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D N u a c h t l i t i r O i f i g i ú i l I n s t i t i ú i d A i litirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 W h a t i s a p a r k ? • Re-opening of Eyre Sq • Father Collins Park • Martha Swarthz interview LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D The Irish Landscape Institute is kindly supported by: Gold Sponsor Silver Sponsor Bronze Sponsor LANDSCAPE I LANDSCAPE Ireland is the official journal of the Irish Landscape Institute. The Irish Landscape Institute is the representative body for Landscape professionals in Ireland. The Irish Landscape Institute is affiliated to the European Foundation for Landscape Architecture (EFLA). Editorial: Irish Landscape Institute 8 Merrion Square Dublin 2 E L A N D C O N T E N T S 04 News & Events S P E C I A L F E A T U R E S P 09 Eyre Sq Re-newed P 14 Martha Schwarthz Ph + 353 1 6627409 Email infoili@eircom.net visit R P 16 Father Collins Park www.irishlandscapeinstitute.com R E G U L A R S Editorial Committee: Deirdre Black Mark Boyle Daibhí Mac Domhnaill P 19 Project Profile All rights reserved. The views expressed in this publication are not necessarily those of the Irish Landscape Institute or the editorial committee P 22 Practice Profile; Stephen Diamond & Associates Cover Photo: Eyre Sq Galway, April 2006 by kind permission of Mitchell & Associates P 21 On Location; Sitio Burle Marx P 08 An t-Eagarthóir P 23 Weblinks P 23-24 Classifieds The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 03 News & events LANDSCAPE I R E L A N L andscape D Architec ts a nonymous? by Mark Boyle The Building Control Bill 2005 aims to regulate use of the title ‘architect’ by setting up a register of architects administered by the RIAI. The reason for this is to protect consumers from unqualified individuals posing as architects. The Bill went before the Dáil in December 2005 and is currently in the second stage, prior to referral to select committee. The concern for landscape architects is that the wording of the Bill was such that it would preclude landscape architects from using their established professional title as it stated that: Launch of New Landscape Journal Spring 2006 sees the publication of the first issue of JoLA (Journal of Landscape Architecture); a new peer reviewed journal which is being published by the European Council of Landscape Architecture Schools (ECLAS). The journal is to be published twice annually. The aim of JoLA is to provide a platform for and to stimulate scholarly debate in Landscape Architecture. Typically issues will consist of research papers, critiques of projects and visual essays, along with book reviews, academic notes and editorial. See: www.info-jola.de “Any person who… practises or carries on business under any name, style or title containing the word “architect”, unless he or she is registered under this Part… shall be guilty of an offence”. The ILI learnt of the Bill in April 2006 and have been working to ensure that the Bill is amended to allow landscape architects to continue to use their title. An ILI committee was set up to address the issue, consisting of Kieran O’Neill, Deirdre Black, Tony Williams, John Ward and Mark Boyle. After writing to Mr. Dick Roche, Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government and lobbying several politicians requesting that the Bill be changed and that the ILI be consulted in this change, the ILI has just been informed by the Department of the Environment that the Bill will be amended in the coming weeks. The Department of the Environment and the RIAI have also assured the Irish Landscape Institute that it was never the intention to exclude landscape architects. This has led to a great deal of discussion within the ILI about the possibility of legal protection for the title ‘Landscape Architect’ and this possibility is being carefully examined at present. Look up ‘Landscape Architect’ in the Golden Pages and you will see all manner of contractors and garden centres listed. Is this acceptable? If you have an opinion on this matter, please email; mark.boyle@murray-associates.com or write to the ILI at 8 Merrion Square, Dublin 2. 04 The Parks Professionals Network The Parks Professionals Network (PPN) is an informal group of local authority professional staff working in Parks Departments around Ireland. The network has been set up with the aim of sharing information and addressing issues of common interest among the members of the network under the umbrella of the ILI. It also aims to advance the continuing professional development of parks staff in local authorities. The PPN has organised several successful workshops and meetings with an emphasis on policy and professional development eg. Special Needs Accessibility; Planning; Parks & Open Space Management and looks forward to organising a joint seminar/ workshop with the ILI in the near future. Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 LANDSCAPE I For New National Planning Strategy? E L A N D The Life and Death of News & events Call R Jane Jacobs Henk Van Der Kemp and Minister Dick Roche, pictured at the IPI Planning Awards during November 2005 - photo by Anew Mc Knight President of the Irish Planning Institute, Henk Van der Kemp has called for the preparation of a new national planning strategy to replace the National Spatial Strategy 2002-2020. Speaking at the annual IPI conference in Sligo, Mr Van der Kemp suggested that if current trends in population and economic growth are sustained, the population of the island could in the future reach the pre-famine population of 8 million. Van der Kemp criticised The National Spatial Strategy (NSS) as being incoherent and spreading development too widely with too many designated “gateways” and “hubs” and that the NSS was based on population projections which are now being exceeded. Mr. Van der Kemp criticised the incongruence of the NSS as adopted and the Governments plans for decentralisation of government departments to 53 locations in 25 counties as announced in 2003, many of the locations being in small market towns, without high capacity public transport links or complimentary educational and commercial services. Van der Kemp argued that the projected population expansion, associated developments and the prospect of an additional 1.5 million cars on our roads; requires more radical planning solutions to deliver sustainable settlements that support efficient public transport, services and quality of life. Speaking at the same conference, Minister for the Environment Heritage and Local Government Dick Roche; responded to Henk Van der Kemps call for a drafting of a new National Plan as “premature”, as the 20 year NSS strategy was sufficiently robust to cope with population growth. April saw the passing of Jane Jacobs; influential writer and urban theorist. Ms. Jacobs died of natural causes, on Tuesday April 25th at the age of 89. Jacobs was best known as the author of The Life and Death of Great American Cities (1961), a book long established as core reading on University courses the world over. Born on May 4thy 1916, Jacobs never acquired formal training in Architecture or Planning yet with The Life and Death of American Cities, Jacobs attacked the principles of modernist planning and city design prevalent at the time. Jacobs espoused a humanist or traditional vision of the city, where neighbourhoods contain a mix of uses and activities, old buildings are recycled and public transport is championed over the private motor car. The principles under-pinning Jacobs’ thesis on the city; of pedestrian permeability, density, diversity and the famous phrase of “eyes on the street”, have formed the cornerstone of contemporary urban design theory. In The Economy of Cities (1969) Jacobs argues that in certain situations, city development preceded agriculture. In the Wealth of Nations (1984) Jacobs argues that the financial health of a nation depended on productive cities. Jacobs began her career working as a freelance journalist in Scranton, Pennsylvania. In 1952 she moved to Architecture Forum magazine where she later became editor. In late 1968 Jacobs moved with her family to Canada, later becoming a Canadian citizen. Jacobs’ remained active throughout her life as an urban theorist and community activist, touring at the age of 88 to promote her book Dark Age Ahead (2004). The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 05 News & events LANDSCAPE I R E L A N S ustaining D Interest: achieving s u s ta i n a b i l i t y t hrough landscape ar c h i t e c t u r e Barry Lupton & Mark Boyle review the recent ILI Conference “Sustainability is increasing in relevance and urgency,” said Trevor Sargent TD, opening the biennial Irish Landscape Institute conference. The conference was entitled Sustaining Interest: Achieving sustainability through landscape architecture – a direct reference to the waning interest in the over-used, underinformative term ‘sustainability’. We’ve heard it all before, and yet, as professionals, we must continue to be environmentally responsible in our schemes. But is sustainable design inherently dull? That’s one stereotype that the speakers put to rest in a remarkable day at the Brooklodge Hotel. Setting the tone for the thought provoking day was Lars Gemzøe, Architect with Gehl Architects in Copenhagen and senior lecturer at the Royal Danish Academy of Fine Arts, with his talk entitled People and Public Spaces. Utilising a variety of often-humorous slides, Lars illustrated how societal change, and particularly mass communications and the rise of sedentary lifestyles, have altered use patterns in public space. “Public space was historically used out of necessity. When a family of eight share a two-room home, there is no option but to be outside. Now we live in lower density environments and are becoming increasingly more isolated. There is a growing need for more informal contact and we can address this by creating spaces focused on human needs” said Lars. Lars’ work with Jan Gehl aims to analyse how people actually use space to create an awareness of the value of well-designed public spaces for a high quality of life. Throwing a spotlight on the diverse interpretations and definitions of sustainability and offering the attendees a number of specific environmental remediation solutions was Maria Helena Farrall, of the School of Science and Technology at the Xochimilco Ecological Park, by kind permission Grupo de Diseno Urbano 06 Universidade Nova de Lisboa. Extolling the virtues of wildlife over-bridges, culverts and viaducts, Maria cautioned that remediation interventions would only succeed where they are continually monitored, evaluated and maintained. While Maria provided many specific examples of remediation techniques, Ann Buttimer, Emeritus Professor of Geography at UCD, drew back and presented a macro view of development, exploring the broader factors of scale, socio-political and functional contexts in respect to transforming use and interpretations of landscape. With the morning session and a fantastic dinner under their belts (many thanks to An Bord Bia for providing sponsorship) the delegates returned to their seats to be inspired by Davie Philip and Bruce Darrell, both active members in the The Village, Cloughjordan sustainable village initiative. Outlining the background to the project Davie said, “The world is changing; in the near future we will have to continue to develop but with less and less. At Cloughjordon we are creating a cooperative, self sufficient community that will evolve from the bottom up.” The plans for the 67-acre development in North Tipperary include, 132 households, community allotments and an extensive area for woodland. Design and planning is undertaken in consultation with all members and is guided by permaculture principles. “Cloughjordan will explore the reintegrating of human habitation and food production. While it will certainly be productive it will also be a place where people want to stay rather than feeling that they need to go to somewhere nice for their holidays” commented an enthused Bruce. “To whom does Water Belong?” said Gerhard Hauber introducing his talk entitled Waterscapes – Creative and Sustainable use of Water in Public Space. Principal Landscape Architect with Atelier Chapultepec Park, by kind permission Grupo de Diseno Urbano Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 LANDSCAPE I Dreiseitl, one of Europe’s most innovative landscape architecture offices, Gerhard has worked on a range of waterscapes aimed at maximising the opportunities presented by water, particularly management of stormwater and site water. ”Of all the water that falls on our cities only 20% ever recharges our aquifers. Finite, indispensable and under threat, water, not oil, is our most valuable resource” said Gerhard. In addition to opening the audiences’ eyes to the benefits of exploiting storm water, Gerhard also illustrated how adopting a multidisciplinary design approach can produce truly successful sustainable results and stunning public spaces. Atelier Dreiseitl’s public space projects include Potsdamer Platz, Berlin; City Hall, Chicago; and Zurich Zoo. Continuing Gerhard’s aqueous flow and holistic approach was Mario Schjetnan, founder partner of Grupo de Diseno Urbano (GDU) in Mexico City, with his talk entitled Parks as Expressions of Contemporary Urbanism. Using a number of his practice’s projects from Mexico City and California, Mario demonstrated how the environment, history, culture, economics, art and modern concepts of living can be interwoven to produce layered, sustainable habitats, which respond and evolve to enhance increasingly complex urban lives. GDU’s projects are – like the projects of the late Luis Barragán – a stunning synthesis of Mexico’s rich cultural heritage and modern landscape architecture. Some of the projects presented on the day were Xochimilco Ecological Park, Technoparque Azcapotzalco and Chapultepec Park – all in Mexico City. Chapultepec Park is a 19th Century park in the centre of Mexico City (which gets 17million visitors per year!) and is being reinvigorated by GDU’s creative interventions. R E L A N D “It makes good economic sense to make good environmental choices”. Further Reading: Lars Gemzøe www.gehlarchitects.dk; Books: Life Between Buildings (by Jan Gehl); Public Spaces Public Life (with Jan Gehl); New City Spaces (with Jan Gehl) Ann Buttimer Book: Sustainable Landscapes and Lifeways: Scale and Appropriateness The Village www.thevillage.ie; www.cultivate.ie Atelier Dreiseitl www.dreiseitl.com; Book: New Waterscapes: Planning, Building and Designing with Water Mario Schjetnan www.gdu.com.mx; Book: Ten Landscapes: Mario Schjetnan by James Grayson Trulove. Drawing the day to a close and capturing its central message in a few short words was Declan O’Leary, Vice President of the ILI: Wildlife over bridge, by kind permission Maria Helena Farrall Potsdamer Platz, by kind permission Atelier Dreiseitl The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 07 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D An t-Eagarthóir What is a Park? What does does it matter? March saw the staging of a thoroughly invigorating and inspirational ILI biennial conference. The presentations on the day – though widely varied – were remarkably synchronous in their central message that sustainable development is an opportunity for landscape architects. The stereotype of an ecological park as a creative void, a dull, naturalistic place was blown out of the water. Public spaces, parks, plazas, business parks and housing areas were all presented as works of art which integrate sustainable principles, not simply as swamps with ‘KEEP OUT’ signs. Several months ago the esteemed Editorial Committee on postulating captivating and topical themes for future publications agreed that the Spring 2006 edition would take the title; New Irish Parks. Ever eager to receive contributions from members we issued a call for articles under this heading. Reactions were surprising, disapproving of the theme and notion. A colleague responded, “we don’t design new parks”, and another “we don’t design parks”. The editorial committee reconvened, gallons of midnight oil later we considered a title changed to; New Public Spaces, then we made an executive decision, hence the title: “What is a Park?” The Oxford dictionary defines a park as: “a large public garden in a town for recreation, a large enclosed piece of ground attached to a country house usually with woodland and pasture and/or a large area of kept land in its natural state for recreational use”. The Irish for park: párc, also describes an enclosed field used for the grazing of animals. All of the above meanings would suggest a park as a territory, defined and enclosable. However it is not uncommon in foreign jurisdictions for the term park to be attributed to open space areas void of enclosure devices (railings, fences). The above linguistic definitions also suggests that creativity and art have little or no role in park-making Is Galway’s Eyre Square a park, or is it a plaza? Is it a plaza, is it a park? A park-plaza, a plaza park? A plark? A parkza? It is green and hard, soft and paved, with trees and boasts a children’s playground and pretty planting beds. It is definitely for recreation but is not railed or enclosed. Is it a demi-park, semipark, parkette or parkesque plaza? And anyway what does is matter? Tired of Etymological bickering, the editorial committee have proposed a new word to quell the fiery debacle; PARF (Publicly Accessible Recreational Facility), admittedly a bit audibly flat rolling off the tongue, but distinctly more accurate and a catch 08 all for the grande mellée of squares, parks, plazas, greens. A new word that surfs over the waves of linguistic ambiguity and poor definition. So, dear reader we hope you enjoy the delights of the PARFs all around you and those featured in this issue. Landmark projects such as G a l w a y ’s E y r e S q u a r e , F r. Collins Park and the Royal Canal Linear Park; demonstrate a revived application of artistry to the built environment in Ireland. ILI KEY DATES Irish Landscape Institute AGM 6.30pm, 20th June 2006 at the RIAI, 8 Merrion Sq., D2 Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 LANDSCAPE I E y r e S q u a r e R E L A N D R e - n e w e d existing trees proposed trees modular paving grey granite paving flags PC concrete flags shrub planting hedge planting Plan for the refurbishment Eyre Sq (planning Stages) by kind permission Mitchell & Associates By Daibhí Mac Domhnaill Finally, after many long years of difficulty and controversy the new Eyre Square was opened on Thursday April 13th, to the great excitement and relief of the people of Galway. The ambitious Eyre Square project has been an endurance test for designers Mitchell and Associates, a project that has been through oral hearings, protests, local politics and construction delays. The re-opening of Eyre Square completes a pedestrianised zone which now runs from Galway’s Train Station to the banks of the Corrib River along the historic east-west spine of the mediaeval city. Eyre Square originated from a mediaeval common, the Irish for Eyre Sq is; An Faiche Mór (the big green/fare ground). The space is reputed too have been used for jousting tournaments and markets. Archaeological excavations undertaken during construction uncovered the remains of an eighteenth century market building (in addition to 20 skeletons). The square was officially presented to the city in 1710 by Mayor Edward Eyre, from whom it took its name. Originally the square was enclosed with timber railings. These were later replaced in the 1890’s with iron railings, when the square was regraded and rows of trees were planted, some of which survive in the new scheme. Of note is that this has not been the first occasion an esteemed landscape architectural practice has prepared a scheme for the square. During the early 1960’s a design by Jim Fehilly FILI was implemented. The scheme was based on an orthoginal modernist plan and incorporated a plaza area to the top of the square overlaid with a grid of Norway Maple trees. The iron railings were at this time removed to the churchyard of St. Nicholas’ Cathedral where they still stand today. In 1965, the square was officially renamed “Kennedy Memorial Park” in honour of US President John F. Kennedy, who visited here shortly before his assassination in 1963. The involvement of Mitchell and Associates in the project began in 1997, when a feasibility study was undertaken on the upgrading of the urban spaces in the City Centre. early phases of which included the Spanish Parade and Shop St. The proposals for Eyre Square were first presented in January 1999. The preferred scheme was one of many options prepared by Mitchell & Associates; and perhaps the most understated. Earlier options included a formal/symmetrical arrangement of terraces and a cascading canal. The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 09 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D general dissatisfaction with the tone and image of the proposed make-over. Many opponents latched onto the sound-bite of the proposed plaza element being a concept alien to Galway and its heritage. At one stage the Galway Environmental Alliance enlisted the services of Chelsea Garden Winner Mary Reynolds to design an alternative scheme. Despite misgivings by some local groups; the City Council persisted with the preferred scheme and commissioned an Environmental Impact Assessment. An Bord Pleanala later held an oral hearing during September 2002 and upheld the proposals with some conditions; such as the retention of 21 additional trees and the incorporation of a children’s play area. Aerial view of Eyre Sq, prior to refurbishment The primary thrust of the chosen scheme celebrates and accentuates the linkage of the bus and rail station with Shop St/William St, in a gracious arced path that segments the space between hard plaza and lawn terracing. A colleague recently asked “Is the New Eyre Square very different from the old”, I responded, “No, just better”. The designers clearly recognised the cultural and local value of Eyre Square as a green space, where for generations Galwegians have loitered and gathered during clement weather. On warm summer afternoons the lawn areas would fill with circles of friends. The Mitchell scheme has not radically altered or re-orientated the function of the space, but rather built on its historical value and success. The new scheme actually has 20% more green space than the previous incarnation and includes 120 new trees. The plaza area at the top of the square is more flexible and usable; as a result of the removal of a dense grid of Norway maples and the repositioning of the ‘corten sails’ sculpture to the edge. The refurbishment of Eyre Square has also dovetailed with a larger traffic management strategy for the city centre. Car parking was removed from the edges of the square and the west side is now closed off to traffic, connecting the green space of the square seamlessly with the pedestrianised Shop St. However greater difficulties loomed ahead. The tender for the construction of the project was awarded to Samuel Kingston Constuction Ltd. Works commenced on site in February 2004. Initial progress on the construction of the project was slow. Works on the site were limited to weekdays, a pattern that provoked the ire of city businesses and residents; in addition the project was setback by employer/employee disputes. In April of that year the 30 workers on site downed tools, demanding improved pay and conditions. The lowest point was reached when at dawn on Monday June 27th 2005, Samuel Kingston Construction Ltd, quit the site, leaving the works unfinished. This matter is currently still the subject of proceedings between Kingston and the City Council. The project attracted negative publicity in the local media. An editorial in the Galway Advertiser, described the idle construction site as “Fallujah Square” and suggested that Eyre Sq would become a byword for “inefficiency and incompetence”. Children’s play area, photo by D Mac Domhnaill The design process for the scheme involved extensive public consultation and was the subject of an accessibility audit to ensure universal and disabled access. The City Council’s proposal for the square was resisted initially by some local traders and the Galway Environmental Alliance. The Galway Environmental Alliance were concerned about the removal of trees as part of the redevelopment and expressing 10 Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D A task force was appointed by the Council to oversee the completion of the project and subsequently SIAC Construction were appointed to complete the works. SIAC have won great esteem in the city for the manner in which they proceeded to complete the refurbishment and delivered the square within the revised programme and budget. Local fast food outlet Supermacs even hung a banner outside their Eyre Sq restaurant, thanking SIAC for a job well done. The overall budget for the square was €9.6 million, the construction budget accounted for €6.3 million, of which approximately 25% was spent on sub surface infrastructure, such as relaying a foul sewer for the Mutton Island Wastewater Treatment Plant. Ed Frampton of landscape architects Mitchell and Associates describes the project as “ a statement of the civic ambition of Galway as a city and the premier space of the west coast”. “The project stimulated controversy, but this is not untypical of major urban space projects, where it is difficult to please all affected”. The arced path leading to the train station, photo by D Mac Domhnaill The initial impact of the reopened Eyre Square, has been exceptionally positive. The children’s play area has proven hugely popular, and a welcome innovation in such a high profile city space. The one major criticism would be the modest scale of the play area which will inevitably be saturated with children during the busy weeks of July and August. There is no doubting the ambition and courage of Galway City Council, in investing so much in the public realm of the city. Over the course of time, the city and its residents will continue to benefit from these investments as the city consolidates its image as a cultural destination and a place to serendipitously saunter. One hopes that other local authorities are motivated and not discouraged to emulate and compete with the civic ambitions of Galway. Sitting wall at edge of lawn terrace, by kind permission of Mitchell & Associates The plaza at the top of the square, by kind permission of Mitchell & Associates The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 11 LANDSCAPE I R E L A M e e t N D M a r t h a Grand Canal Square in Dublin is the latest part of the world to undergo the Martha Schwartz treatment. A landscape architect and artist, Schwartz is a lead player in the global theatre of modern city building. Her approach is determined by a belief that landscape design solutions can be raised to the level of fine art, and she describes her creations as “site-specific installation”. As the principal of Martha Schwartz Inc. with offices in Massachusetts and London, a Professor in the Harvard Graduate School of Design, and the recipient of more design awards than is polite to mention, she has the kind of international career enjoyed by only the starriest of starchitects. When I met her recently in Belfast, where she was about to give a lecture on the design of the public realm from an artistic standpoint, she was feeling decidedly edgy; “From the art point of view, I think I would be seen as a tangential kind of something. I actually like edge conditions better than being at the centre of anything. It’s a very interesting place to be”. While those located closer to the cores of the worlds of landscape architecture and art may question her “smudging” of the lines between the two disciplines, she seems to enjoy the creative collisions that result; “I really think we are enjoying some kind of strange Renaissance, and I think that the world of design and the world of art have crashed together.” S c h w a r t h z B y D e i r d r e Schwartz can be seen as a direct descendant of the Land Artists of the 1960s and 70s, American artists such as Robert Smithson, Nancy Holt, Alan Sonfist and James Turrell. These sculptors worked on monumental scales using the landscape itself as material – constructing works of art in wild or degraded landscapes as a creative reaction against the commercial gallery system. Schwartz, however, sees her work as being made of the stuff cities are made of - “I would say that my work is Land Art, except it is Land Art brought into the city, where instead of bulldozing rocks and earth we are trying to manipulate the stuff that we produce in the city, man made stuff, our manufactured environments.” While the original Land Artists relied on wealthy patrons and private foundations to fund their work, Schwartz plays an active part in the practical processes of city development, land reclamation and master planning. Artists may take inspiration from a place, or may create a piece of public art in a particular place, but Schwartz actually gets to create place, within developments as diverse as Japanese apartment blocks, Atlanta shopping centres, a New York plaza and Dublin’s own Grand Canal Square. How does one get to a stage where the landscape becomes one’s easel? “You have to be really clever about how you get sites to make your site-specific art. One way is you Grand Canal Square, montage of proposals, by kind permission of Martha Schwarthz Inc. 12 B l a c k Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 LANDSCAPE I make maquettes and you put them in a gallery until bigger and bigger opportunities come by, except that is horribly slow, and is very unsatisfying if you don’t want to build maquettes all your life. Another way is to get direct commissions from cities. What I chose to do is to call myself a landscape architect because people are not really threatened by that, whereas artists are by their very nature subversive.” The pace of modern society deems that place is more often than not created all at once, rather than emerging slowly over time, time that allows for the gradual adaptation of the landscape to its required function. Historically, tumultuous or all at once placemaking has been at the behest of single minded monarchs and dictators or followed the devastation of war. Now, landscape architects work alongside a wide range of professions in the modern frenzy to create and re-create urban places. In the face of many and often conflicting public, political and financial requirements - as the song goes - there can be a load of compromisin’ on the road to our horizon. Schwartz, however, is known for sticking to her guns, and for defending her designs in the face of the harshest of critics and bureaucratic wranglings. She is clear in her personal design approach; “The intent is to exercise one’s vision, one’s will, one’s sensibility and to make something that somehow is whole.” While asserting her right to artistic expression in the public realm, Schwartz is critical of the skewed imbalance between the design professions that resulted from some of the ideals of R E L A N D early modernism. “We are just getting to push past this kind of Bauhausian notion that the architect is the master artist, thank God this seems to be coming to an end. Architecture is like any other profession today in that there is so much information that nobody can cover it all. Certainly, in the modernist tradition the landscape played, I wouldn’t say an insignificant role, but certainly a passive role in the whole story. The landscape supported the “architecture as sculpture”, and was a passive kind of female thing against the active male. The only story or relationship the landscape had was that of portraying nature against the machine - the machine in the garden paradigm.” Such an attitude that sees the designed landscape as merely providing a natural foil to the buildings, limits the potential for creative expression within landscape design; “If you only read the designed landscape as a passive re-creation of a natural landscape - as a designer, if you have an artistic agenda or an ego, how far can you go with that?” Suspicious of relying on languages of landscape design that are outmoded, Schwartz believes in the predictive nature of art and the role it can play in the development of quality public spaces; “Our job as artists is to talk about the time we’re in and to invent the future - to invent what’s coming. Landscape design cannot just be rooted in the past, it has to draw through osmosis what a place is about, and then express this in a way that is almost a new language for that place. In order to cut a creative path you have to create the future. “ O ur job as artists is to talk about the time we’re in a n d to invent the future - to invent what’s coming ... “ Grand Canal Square, montage of proposals, by kind permission of Martha Schwarthz Inc. The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 13 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D Artists are feared and loathed because people don’t want change to happen, people are by nature fearful of change, well, most people, thank God not everyone.” A Dubliner fearful of change would be a very fearful Dubliner indeed these days, so it makes sense that Schwartz has been commissioned to design a new open space here at a time when then the city is busy inventing its future. Her proposals for Grand Canal Square are a dramatic and dynamic interplay with the jagged geometry of the Daniel Libeskind designed Theatre building. It is envisaged that work on the Square will begin this year and construction will roll out in phases in line with the completion of the surrounding buildings. The last phase will coincide with the delivery of the Theatre in 2008. She praises the Dublin Dockland Development Authority for being “an incredible client, someone who wanted something special and then made it happen. Without the client you don’t have anything. Working in the public realm you’re working with public money, the client has to be brave enough to do something special and have the emotional constitution to be able to take the heat if people don’t like it, take the risk, you don’t get those kind of clients very often.” Landmark projects and others such as Galway’s Eyre Square, Fr. Collins Park and the Royal Canal Linear Park in Spencer Dock; demonstrate a revived application of artistry to the built environment in Ireland. The hope is that such totem projects will raise public expectations of open space and landscape design in general. We are now seeing well designed parks, streets and open spaces, for what they really are – integral elements of the quality of life in any city, town or village - not optional extras, discarded if budgets dictate. Our recent penchant for large scale suburban building has denied whole swathes of the population of the civic benefits that urban artistry can bring. Quality open space requires a critical local mass of users that suburban and spread out building can never provide. As Schwartz remarks, if we are not designing places for people who exactly are we designing for? Schwartz demonstrated her approach to designing landscapes that function in the context of “how people actually live”, in recent proposals for East Darling Harbour, Sydney. Schwartz’s office came second an the international design competition, but nonetheless, the process allowed her to explore the opportunities for developing public space that functions in accordance with modern “genres de vie”. “We had worked very closely with Exchange Square, Manchester The square in Manchester was constructed after the site was destroyed by the IRA bombing of 1996. The sloping site is navigated by means of a series of large ramps, with informal seating opportunities. A stream formerly flowed though the site and is recalled in the water feature which runs the length of the square. Photo by Shauna Gillies-Smith and Alan Ward, by kind permission of Martha Swarthz Inc. 14 Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D Jacob Javits Plaza, New York Jacob Javits Plaza in New York was partly designed to enliven views from the high buildings surrounding the space, the pattern makes reference to the formal parterres of classic French gardens. The swirling benches covering the entire plaza allow for the users to sit wherever the sunny spot may be over the course of the day. Schwartz used the design language of Olmstead’s Central Park in a new context – the standard park benches are painted lime green, the “keep off the grass” mini-railing encloses grass mounds which produce cooling mist in hot New York summers. Photo Alan Ward, by kind permission of Martha Swarthz Inc. Arups, the engineers, to come up with a system whereby we would be able to create a collage of different environments. We were going to create a big beach, we were going to plant big trees in the rocks and then recycle all the grey water from the development portion of the project and use that to grow the trees, because without the trees as canopy, people can’t use the beach. It was a conflation of best ecological practice but also an environment that people can use. We had the trees all wired up so that people could actually work with their computers and send their work to a station on the beach to print the work out. You could actually work on the beach, what people today might want to do. We’re figuring out how people want to use space today, not how they used to use space. These are really interesting social, environmental, spatial kind of ideas.” Unsurprisingly, Schwartz has some issues about the direction her country is heading; “Right now the US is in a real retrograde movement - post 9/11, things have really gone downhill for the States in many ways. We’re busy making up a myth of the past and we’ve lost a sense of the future, I think that we are fearful of the future. There are wonderful things about the States, but we’ve been resting on our laurels in a major way. If you take a look at architecture, what major architecture has been coming out of the States? Not architects, there are great architects coming out of the States, but where have they been given their chance, where has the culture actually supported them – Frank Gehry, hello? He never would have had a chance in the United States. At the moment, we are working a lot in the UK, where there has been a great push from the top to improve the public realm. The public spaces in cities, the spaces between the buildings, are really the things that characterize what the city is all about. People have choice in where they might live, and they want a quality of life. All of a sudden the regulatory agencies are reviewing and scrutinizing the design quality of public spaces. Design is on the table”. Although we may both have been somewhat biased, I put it to Schwartz if she agreed with the assertation that landscape architecture will prove to be the most consequential art of our time. It was no great surprise that she agreed - “the design of the landscape, of our environment, is the most important design issue on the agenda for the 21st century. I really think that with the landscape, being that it’s man-made, a construct, a figment of our imaginations - anything goes”. Further Reading: The Vanguard Landscapes and Gardens of Martha Schwartz edited by Tim Richardson, Thames & Hudson (see LANDSCAPE IRELAND, Summer 2005, for review) The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 15 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D F a t h e r C o l l i n s By Deirdre Black P a r k In December 2003, the entries for the competition to design Fr. Collins Park in Donaghmede were displayed in the Civic Offices. The winners, Abelleyro and Romeo Architects from Buenos Aires in Argentina have since formed a partnership with Magahy and Company (forming a new company AR.ARQ.IRELAND) in order to deliver the proposals first presented in 2003. ILI practice member, Cunnane Strattan Reynolds have also been involved in the delivery of the project, which is currently on display in the foyer of Dublin City Council as part of the Part VIII planning approval process. Unfortunately the ILI magazine budget wouldn’t stretch to cover flights to Buenos Aires, so I put some questions about the development of the project to architect Phillip Crowe of the Irish side of the partnership, Magahy and Company; Since you began working on the project, what practicalities were encountered in terms of site constraints/budget/ facility provisions and how were these issues dealt with in the revised proposals? Taking the competition winning scheme through to planning has involved considerable design development due to cost issues and clarification of the brief. The main physical constraints on the site are from the existing underground services along the west side which requires a wayleave, and the existing woodland to the west which is to be preserved. There is also an existing water treatment plant to the northwest and the Trinity Sports Centre in the southern sector of the park, both of which have to be retained. How did the partnership process operate considering the geographical distance between practices? Roles are very clearly defined and technology has made this type of arrangement much easier – use of a shared internet remote storage service, email and skype VOIP. Strategically timed visits from the Argentinean architects were very useful in pushing forward design development. Father Collins Park, park masterplan by kind permission of Magahy and Co. 16 What do you see as the main features of the design? The park will be dominated by the central axis features of the lake, promenade, wind turbines, water features and viewing mound. The perimeter planting encloses the large open space of the park with circulation and recreational facilities distributed around the central axis. Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D What is your approach to the edges of the site, and how it interfaces with the surrounding urban landscape? The concept of the park is to create a place apart from the surrounding urban streetscape. To this end the perimeter planting is very dense and visual permeability is not a priority. The boundary fence is a relatively low and simple post and beam steel fence that will mark the perimeter without creating a visual and physical barrier. The main point of interaction with the urban landscape occurs on the ‘main street’ which bisects the park. This street has very wide pavements to allow activities and events to take place and create the sense of a public space rather than a road. At this point the perimeter planting is broken to allow a view up the length of the park to the water feature and viewing mound. What skills in particular do you feel architects bring to the design of external space? I don’t think it is possible to answer this question in such general terms. In this instance the architects have succeeded in accommodating a complex brief within one very simple and elegant design move – the promenade on a central lake. View of model focussed on wind turbines by kind permission of Magahy and Co. Have you developed a palette of materials for the park yet, and what has informed these choices? The most prominent hard landscaping material will be insitu concrete. This is a very versatile, hardwearing and cost effective material. The surface of the promenade will be ground and polished to reveal the aggregate. Seating will generally be concrete detailed with timber and sheltering elements will be constructed from steel. How have issues of sustainability been addressed? The drainage system for the park is designed to avoid reliance on external sources for water and to avoid loading onto the local drainage system. Wetlands and a continuous cycle of water movement will ensure rainwater is used within the park and cleaned, to ensure the lake is clean and kept replenished at a constant level. The electrical energy needs of the park will be met by the 5no. wind turbines located along the promenade. The loading will include water features, lighting and electric maintenance vehicles. View of model showing central promenade and lake by kind permission of Magahy and Co. The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 17 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D Do you see Fr. Collins Park acting as a “totem project”, raising the standard and expectation of open spaces in Ireland, and if so, what are the precedents being set with this project? The design team is concentrating on providing a park that gives identity and appropriate recreational provision for the new and existing urban communities of the North Fringe area. The park will be quite different to anything of a similar scale in Ireland and will hopefully provide a precedent for similar developments throughout the island. Montage of recreation and play areas by kind permission of Magahy and Co. What is the programme for delivery from now on? Dublin City Council hopes to be on site in early 2007. Montage of promenade with seating by kind permission of Magahy and Co. Montage of wind turbines and wetlands by kind permission of Magahy and Co. 18 Amphitheatre and stage by kind permission of Magahy and Co. Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D Project Profile Grand Canal Square The Square, at 10,000 sq m, will be one of the largest paved public spaces in the city. The space will be framed by a new theatre, 5-star hotel, and shops, restaurants and cafes at ground level. The €8 million scheme replaces a smaller paved space and is built over an underground car park at the centre of the Grand Canal Dock development area. The design features a composition of a red “carpet” extending from the theatre into and over the dock crossed by a lush green “carpet” of paving with lawns and vegetation. The red carpet will be made of bright red resin-glass paving covered with red glowing angled light sticks. The green carpet of polygon-shaped planters will provide incidental seating while the planters will contain marsh vegetation to soften the space and act as a reminder of the historic wetland nature of the site. At night-time, coloured lighting designed by Schwartz, in collaboration with Edinburgh based Spiers and Major Associates, will illuminate the square and add to the theatrical experience of the space. The Docklands Authority is currently investigating, with the designers, ways to make this lighting interactive. For more on the existing developments in the Dublin Docklands area visit the website of the Dublin Docklands Development Authority; www.ddda.ie Grand Canal Square, plan drawing by kind permission of Martha Schwarthz Inc. The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 19 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D Recommended Reading By Mar Boyle The past 6 months or so has seen a deluge of quality landscape architecture publications hit the shelves. The following is a selection of the most For sheer indulgence, the following are lavishly illustrated publications that no self-respecting practitioner should be without. These are primarily survey type books. The most self-important of these is Fieldwork: Contemporary European Landscape Architecture (Ed. Landscape Architecture Europe; Birkhauser, Germany). It is part-funded by the Landscape Architecture Europe Foundation and contains a selection of 42 projects from around Europe (including Fr. Collins Park – see p16). The book is prefaced with 6 essays by eminent practitioners and academics. Other survey titles are In Gardens (Udo Weilacher; Birkhauser, Germany), European Landscape Architecture (Ed. P. Zöch, G. Loschwitz; Edition Topos, Germany), Contemporary Public Space: Un-Volumetric Architecture (Eds. A. Aymonino & V.P. Mosco; Skira Editore, Italy). Don’t let the title of the first of these put you off. This is a first-rate collection of more than 30 new public spaces, many from Eastern Europe and not published elsewhere. Topos’ selection of 50 contemporary projects is also captivating, if too brief at times. The Italian book is inspirational in that it doesn’t necessarily concern itself with built work, and liberally dips into the related arts of land art, architecture and civil engineering. Several thematic volumes have also come from the Birkhauser stables: Lighting the Landscape by Roger Narboni and New Waterscapes, edited by Atelier Dreiseitl (Gerhard Hauber of AD was one of the speakers at the recent ILI conference, see p.6) are the pick of the crop for the sheer breadth and depth of their reach. The Cultured Landscape (Eds. Sheila Harvey and the late Ken Fieldhouse; Spon Press, London) is a collection of essays on the aims, values and purposes of landscape architecture. Contributors include Martha Schwartz, Alan Tate and Catherine Ward Thompson. Less a visual feast and a little drier than the others, this is, however, a worthwhile and rewarding read. Penelope Hill’s Contemporary History of Garden Design (Birkhauser, again) is also a fascinating read, overlapping late 20th- and early 21st century private and public small-scale design from around the world. Readers should also keep a lookout for books on landscape practices which seem to be increasing in frequency too. Gustafson-Porter, Martha Schwartz, Ken Smith, Michael Van Valkenburgh and Peter Walker are among those contemporary practices featured by various publishers in recent times. Purchase High Quality Print versions of LANDSCAPE IRELAND Spring 2006 and back issues available Fill out the order form below and return with euro cheque made payable to; Irish Landscape Institute. Irish Landscape Institute, 8 Merrion Sq, Dublin 8 Name: Prices; €10 1 issue (includes postage and packaging) €18 2 issue (includes p+p) €25 3 issue (includes p+p) 4+ issues for €8 each (includes p+p) Adress: Email: Spring 2006 (no. of copies) Winter 2005 Summer 2005 Total Payment 20 € Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D On Location Sitio Burle Marx Rio Brasil Text and photos by Daibhí Mac Domhnaill A recent trip to Brasil provided an opportunity to explore in-situ the works of Roberto Burle Marx; great icon of the Modernist and Post Modernist periods of Landscape Architiecture. Burle Marx projects are not difficult to find as I soon discovered on arrival in Rio de Janeiro, where one can walk across the city from one project to another. The highpoint of this pligrimage was a visit to his estate; Sitio Burle Marx, in Guaritiba on the outskirts of RIO. The Sitio was donated by Marx to the State Government in 1985. The estate is approximately 100 acres large, with a plant collection of some 3,500 species, accumulated by Marx over 40 plus years. Water feature fronting the terrace of the Villa Visitng Sitio Burle Marx is a window onto the multiplicitious influences and motivations that inspired and drove his works over seven decades. The paraphernalia of his personnal life; an eclectic mix of pre-columban artefacts, Brazilian folk art, an international collection of modern glassware, religious/spiritual icons and antique furniture are testament to a person intensely curious, passionate and surpisingly nostalgic. The Marx villa also contains many examples of his own hand painted tableclothes and bed linen, the motifs and patterns of which resonate with his landscape compositions, in particular later projects, such as the Copacabana promenade. These hand-crafted works demonstrate the painterly approach to composition and the making of form and pattern, which is the signature of his landscape work and his legacy generations of landscape professionals. Water feature and canopy associated with outdoor dining area Agave garden Admisison is by appoinment only; Sitio Burle Marx, Estrada da barra de Guaratiba, 2019 Guaratiba, Rio de Janeiro, Ph (55-21) 2410 1412 Further Reading Burle Marx The Lyrical landscapes, by Marta Iris Montero, an insightful and beautifllu illustrated book, with excellent location maps and keyed plans of schemes. View of Burle Marx’s landscape architecture studio The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 21 LANDSCAPE I R E L A N D Practice Profile STEPHEN DIAMOND & ASSOCIATES Having graduated from the undergraduate degree and post graduate diploma in landscape architecture at Manchester Metropolitan University, Stephen returned to Ireland in 1994 to work at Belfast City Council for a period of two years while studying towards full membership of the Landscape Institute. Completion of the Part IV examinations in 1996 signalled a need for change in direction and a preference to work in private practice. Acceptance of a job offer with CSR brought Stephen to Dublin where he remained for four years until the formation of Stephen Diamond Associates (SDA) in July 2000. SDA was established as a design orientated practice committed to the development of site generated proposals to promote interaction with and connection to the landscape. Particular attention is given to site analysis and the development of strong conceptual design to be carried through to a built form. UCD Industrial Centre, by kind permission of Stephen Diamond & Associates The practice ethos is to engage in a progressive approach, pursue the use of appropriate modern materials and innovative uses for conventional materials. To deliver highly considered spaces that subtly impose a new function and aesthetic. Bold and informed solutions, distilled to minimal composition, emerge from the land with an atmosphere of permanence and solidity. river Shannon excavated water course island of retained alder floodplain reclaimed land existing road The practice works in a studio environment and currently employs three full time landscape architects. A number of projects have recently started construction on site. These include a new public square along Simmonscourt Road, designed to connect The Anglesea and Simmonscourt sites of the RDS; Carrick on Shannon Town Park; The AIB Bankcentre in Ballsbridge; Dun Laoghaire Institute of Art Design & Technology and Phase 2 of The UCC West Campus Masterplan. Construction is nearing completion on a project to connect Belfield House with The UIC/Engineering buildings at UCD. Further projects at UCD include Roebuck Hall Residence and the first phase of a 6.5km ‘Boundary Woodland Track’. Carrick on Shannon Town Park, by kind permission of Stephen Diamond & Associates Looking to the future SDA strive toward the continuing development of an innovative and unique approach to landscape architecture and providing motivation, professional growth and personal development for staff. Aras na Laoi Masterplan UCC by kind permission of Stephen Diamond & Associates 22 Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006 LANDSCAPE Weblinks Cabe Space, Manifesto for Better Public Spaces: Log on to www.itsyourspace.org.co.uk to review and possibly sign up to the Manifesto for Better Public Space Cabe Space is part of the Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment (CABE) set up in May 2003; which is funded by the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (UK). CABE champions excellence in the design and management of urban and green spaces. Galway N6 R E L A N D Landscape Architect MOVING WEST? Are you a Landscape Architect looking to Move West?… Move On?… Move Up? Keville & O’Sullivan Associates, a multi-disciplinary environmental consultancy based in Galway City, is seeking to recruit a Senior Landscape Architect to head-up a new landscape architecture division. The new division will combine the skills and knowledge of our existing staff, with the professional experience and expertise of landscape architects to bring the traditional services offered by the profession to a new level. The successful candidate will join and lead a team of environmental scientists, ecologists, graduate landscape architects and AutoCAD technicians to develop a unique suite of services. Applicants for the position should have at least three years post-graduate professional experience in the field. The successful candidate will have significant business development and project management responsibilities and must demonstrate they have the ability, experience, ambition and drive to take on such a role. An attractive salary and benefits package will be offered to the appropriate applicant. Prospective candidates should e-mail brian@kosconsulting.com with details of their educational background and professional experience. All enquiries and e-mails received regarding the available position will be considered in the strictest confidence. Keville & O’Sullivan Associates Ltd. Unit 24, Galway Technology Centre Mervue Business Park, Galway T:091 704856 F:091 704876 www.kosconsulting.com s The Official Journal of the Irish Landscape Institute, Spring 2006 23 CLASSIFIEDS I LANDSCAPE R E L A N D LAND PLANNING & DESIGN I CLASSIFIEDS OPPORTUNITIES IN IRELAND NATIONWIDE CUNNANE STRATTON REYNOLDS Go Play Ltd. is a specialist company focused on children’s play. We are market leaders in the field of playground equipment. We supply unique and interesting high quality public playgrounds and activity toys for children. Playground Designer – GALWAY BASED Due to continued growth and expansion, a new opportunity exists within our company; we are now seeking to hire a playground designer as part of our design team in our GALWAY office. As part of the Go Play team, responsibilities will include the following: - Liase with customers and the sales team in relation to customer requirements - Choose and locate equipment within the playground design - Choose surface types and designs - Complete quotations within budget and within required timeframe - Develop relevant software and specify requirements - Support on-site queries - Assist with the development of relevant related marketing material - Improve the design process Requirements: - Experienced use of AutoCAD 2d and 3d, Imaging Software. - Background in landscape architecture advantageous - Knowledge of 3d Studio Max an advantage - Strong academic background in design - Must be child centric Please apply by sending your CV to Anna Gallagher at the following address Senior Landscape Architect -Dublin Project Landscape Architects -Cork and Galway Graduate Landscape Architects -Cork and Galway Student Internship Posts -Dublin, Cork and Galway Cunnane Stratton Reynolds is a national multidisciplinary practice of Landscape Architects, Urban Designers and Town Planners with offices in Ireland in Dublin, Cork and Galway. Recent growth has created opportunities for enthusiastic professionals at a range of levels in our Dublin and Cork offices as well as a unique opportunity to be part of our new and developing Galway office. Cunnane Stratton Reynolds offer a pleasant and supportive working environment and a competitive salary, training and career opportunities. The practice is involved in a broad range of challenging landscape, planning and urban design projects. For an informal discussion please contact: Declan O’leary at our Dublin office, Jim Kelly at our Cork office, Keith Mitchell at our Galway office; To apply please submit your CV and A3 examples of your work, if appropriate, by post or e-mail without delay to the Dublin office indicating which office(s) you are interested in. . Dublin: 3 Molesworth Place, Dublin 2 Email: info@csrlandplan.ie Tel: 01-6610419 Cork: Copley Hall, Cotters Street, Cork Email: corkinfo@csrlandplan.ie Tel: 021-4969224 Galway: No 13, Galway Technology Park Parkmore, Galway Email:kmitchell@csrlandplan.ie Tel: 087-9068673 www.csrlandplan.ie goplayltdhr@gmail.com Ph: 087-811 0566 Advertise in LANDSCAPE Ireland: products, jobs, classifieds etc. c on t a c t ; ilieditor@mail.co m 24 Iris oifigiúil Institiúid Ailitirí Tírdhreacha na hÉireann, Earrach 2006