ABN AMRO Annual Report 2014
Transcription
ABN AMRO Annual Report 2014
9 10 Our profile 12 Strategic priorities 17 Strategic governance 22 Risk & Capital Report Key trends Business Report In a challenging economic and regulatory environment, our strategy should address the opportunities and threats presented by our environment. This report highlights selected trends, our profile, strategic priorities and our achievements so far. Strategic Report report Introduction strategic Governance Report Annual Financial Statements Other ABN AMRO Group Annual Report 2014 10 Strategic Report Key trends key trends This selection of trends could affect ABN AMRO’s strategy, execution and business model going forward. Macroeconomic trends On a broader level, we will continue to monitor After having contracted for the previous two years, gross the following risks (in random order): domestic product (GDP) in the eurozone inched up in ÅÅ re-ignition of the euro crisis; 2014. Unlike in 2012 and 2013, growth of the Dutch ÅÅ risk of deflation in the eurozone; economy kept pace with the eurozone, growing slightly ÅÅ interest rate increases in the US; in 2014. Private consumption and investment in the ÅÅ hard landing of China’s economy; Netherlands picked up. The export sector was once ÅÅ contagion effects from geopolitical developments again the pacesetter, having benefitted from an upturn in global trade. The prospects for the Dutch economy in 2015 look around Europe, Asia, the Middle East and Russia; ÅÅ potential effects of the ECB’s Quantitative Easing (QE). positive. The United States is expected to remain on its Regulatory and supervisory trends steady growth path, and emerging economies and the Under the Single Supervisory Mechanism (SSM) eurozone could benefit from this. Lower energy prices and implemented in November 2014, prudential supervision a depreciated euro are expected to help the Netherlands over the largest banks established in EU member achieve higher growth in all market sectors in 2015 than in states has been transferred to the ECB. The ECB is 2014, as the domestic drags on the economy (housing expected to dominate the regulatory agenda and to market, government cutbacks and pension problems) focus on topics besides capital, liquidity and risk exposure have clearly weakened. amounts. Supervision is moving from principles-based to rules-based standards and is expected to be much more ABN AMRO is particularly sensitive to the state of the data driven. Dutch economy, an open and mature market well positioned for recovery, though with limited upside in The complexity and number of regulations is expected to GDP growth. This underlines the strategic importance further increase. The evolving regulatory and supervisory of maintaining our strong capital and liquidity position, landscape in the European Union (EU) is challenging for while selectively growing the business outside of banks and there are concerns that this may lead to an the Netherlands. uneven playing field with banks in other regions, such as the US and Asia. ABN AMRO strongly focuses on timely implementation of and compliance with new rules and regulations in a cost-effective manner. 11 Social trends Clients increasingly prefer to use digital solutions and The financial crisis damaged trust in the financial sector. demand a multi-channel approach. Technological As a result of this and other factors, society expects developments in areas such as mobile banking, social greater transparency in pricing, less complex products and media, data analytics (‘big data’) and cloud computing better value. Clients are increasingly seeking products and create opportunities for banks to respond to changing services that fit their unique situation and expect a wider client behaviour and needs. range of digital solutions and direct channels. There is also socially responsible solutions. to the business model of established banks. Leveraging on new technologies, non-traditional banking players could Social networks and cooperative platforms, combined cause disruptions within short time spans. Technology with a desire to be less reliant on banks, support the firms, which are not subject to the same regulatory existence of collaborative finance platforms such as controls imposed on banks, have already entered parts crowdfunding, peer-to-peer lending, social savings and of the banking value chain. In the Dutch mortgage and social lending. created increased competition. Rapid technological advances in social media, mobile banking, data analytics and cloud computing are helping In a world that is becoming ever more technologically banks to better serve clients by using personal data to connected, the increasing risk of cybercrime is driving the perform individual profiling. As boundaries of privacy and need for advanced security and detection measures. data protection are being explored, banks need to be Business Report savings markets, these non-traditional players have Strategic Report a growing demand for more environmentally friendly and The accelerating pace of innovation could pose challenges Introduction Technological trends diligent in protecting clients’ privacy and be sensitive to the evolving public concern and attitude towards sharing technology in order to grasp opportunities to better serve of personal data. clients, create more value and respond to challenges posed by non-traditional banking players. Risk & Capital Report ABN AMRO has decided to increase its investments in Governance Report Annual Financial Statements Other ABN AMRO Group Annual Report 2014 12 Strategic Report Our profile our profile This section presents an overview of who we are, our values and the business principles which will guide us in achieving our mission and vision. We serve retail, private and corporate banking clients based on our in-depth financial expertise and extensive knowledge of numerous industry sectors. Description of ABN AMRO ABN AMRO is a full-service bank with a primary focus on knowledge of numerous industry sectors, we serve retail, the Netherlands and selective operations internationally, private and corporate banking clients and offer in-depth employing 22,215 full-time staff. Based on our extensive financial expertise. Operating income by type of income (in %) 4 Operating income by geography (in %) 7 Operating income by business segment (in %) 1 12 21 35 2014 EUR 8,055m 2014 EUR 8,055m 49 2014 EUR 8,055m 75 81 15 Net interest income Net fee and commission income Other operating income Retail Banking Private Banking Corporate Banking Group Functions The Netherlands Rest of Europe Rest of the world With a long-standing history in banking and roots that private and corporate banking. Our client base is stable and go back for centuries, ABN AMRO emerged from the generates recurring and resilient operating income, of which financial crisis as a leading Dutch bank. Our business over 95% consists of interest, fee and commission income. profile and international footprint have changed while our historic roots remain. Today, we have a high degree ABN AMRO targets a moderate risk profile, which is of focus, operating domestically and in selected reflected in, among other things, three key elements: international markets under several strong brand names. (i) a clean balance sheet, (ii) a clear risk governance structure and strong risk culture, and (iii) a solid capital Our deep focus on the Netherlands is complemented by and liquidity position. This is maintained and strengthened international operations where we have specific expertise by strict risk appetite targets, a controlled and focused and hold leading market positions in selected activities. growth strategy for selected international activities, and In the Netherlands, we are a leading player in retail, disciplined capital allocation. 13 collectively have over twenty years of experience in the ABN AMRO is organised into three business segments - Group across business segments or support functions or Retail Banking, Private Banking and Corporate Banking both. Their excellent track records are reflected in their - which are supported by Group Functions. Group leading the complex integration of ABN AMRO Bank and Functions includes the support and control functions: FBN on time and within budget while structurally reducing TOPS (Technology, Operations & Property Services), our cost base. Despite the complex integration process Finance including ALM/Treasury, RM&S (Risk and the challenging economic environment at the time, Management & Strategy), PR&I (People, Regulations ABN AMRO has delivered resilient operating income and & Identity), Group Audit, and Corporate Office. created a solid capital and liquidity position with the support of its professional and highly engaged workforce. Retail Banking Private Banking Corporate Banking Group Functions Leading position in TOPS (Technology, Operations the Netherlands; ranked the Netherlands & Property Services) 5,000,000 clients 3rd in France, Germany 70,000 commercial Finance including 300,000 businesses with up and in the eurozone; and international clients ALM/Treasury to EUR 1 million turnover with a solid position in with annual turnover RM&S (Risk Management 300 Retail branches, which selected countries in Asia exceeding EUR 1 million & Strategy) includes Advice & Service and the Middle East across 15 defined sectors PR&I (People, Regulations Centres, 24/7 internet and 100,000 clients Operates in selective & Identity) mobile banking centres EUR 191 billion Assets under markets based on three Group Audit Management (AuM) specialities: Clearing, Corporate Office Present in 10 countries with Energy, Commodities more than 50 branches & Transportation, and Governance Report Market leader in position in the Netherlands Risk & Capital Report Solid and recognised market Business Report ABN AMRO Strategic Report Description of our business activities Introduction The Managing Board and senior managing directors asset-based financing Serving Dutch clients internationally through local Dutch Desks and partner banks management teams – covering daily banking services, Retail Banking, Private Banking and Corporate Banking mortgages and wealth & advisory services – align work closely together to ensure that clients are served by products across the organisation and pursue synergies. the appropriate business segment and to enable efficient use of resources. Feeder channels arrange for the transfer Corporate Banking and Retail Banking have a process in of clients to the appropriate segment. place to transfer business clients, always in close dialogue Annual Financial Statements Cooperation among business segments with these clients. Retail Banking provides a feeder channel of business clients to Corporate Banking based deliver a seamless offering across all wealth categories in on annual turnover criteria and receives business clients the Netherlands through institutionalised upstreaming and who are better served by the retail service proposition. downstreaming of clients to the right segment. Product ABN AMRO Group Annual Report 2014 Other Retail Banking and Private Banking cooperate closely to 14 Strategic Report Our profile Private Banking and Corporate Banking cooperate mainly SWOT by means of referrals. Corporate Banking introduces The following SWOT summary provides a brief overview eligible business owners, shareholders and executives of ABN AMRO’s capabilities and the environment in which to Private Banking. Conversely, Private Banking refers it operates. business owners and executives to Corporate Banking for their business needs. This cooperative environment allows for leveraging of technology and client and product solutions. Strengths Weaknesses Leading player in the Dutch market as a full-service bank Large exposure to and dependence on the Dutch economy with strong core and local brands Growth opportunities in the Dutch home market limited Low complexity, client-driven business model that by current leading position generates resilient operating income Solid but complex IT landscape following the integration Strong positions in selected international activities of ABN AMRO Bank and FBN Experienced senior management with a proven track Suboptimal scale of businesses in a few countries record in executing the integration of ABN AMRO Bank and FBN, supported by a professional and highly engaged workforce Diversified mix of activities combined with a solid liquidity position, well-capitalised and strong balance sheet contributing to a moderate risk profile Opportunities Threats Dutch economy well-positioned to benefit from continued Potential macroeconomic and geopolitical headwind momentum in the recovery in the global economy and effects on the Netherlands and the eurozone the eurozone Mature market combined with ageing population New technological developments can be leveraged resulting in relatively limited GDP growth upside to respond to changing client behaviour and needs Regulatory pressure, complexity and volume of regulation Increasing client desire to be environmentally and New entrants in (parts of) the banking value chain socially responsible provides opportunities for new with potentially disruptive effects from the accelerating product development pace of (technological) innovation Lowered barriers to enter other EU markets as a result Increased competition from incumbents and of the European Banking Union non-traditional players, especially in the mortgage and savings markets 15 Introduction Stakeholder management ABN AMRO strives to put clients’ interests first and to create long-term, sustainable value for all of our stakeholders, including clients, investors/shareholders, employees, the environment and society at large. We take the interests of these stakeholders seriously and believe it is our responsibility to manage the impact of our activities. Strategic Report In doing so, we focus on systematically balancing the bank’s interests with those of our stakeholders. Our efforts are discussed in the Strategic priorities section of this Strategic Report. Business Report Clients Environment Investors/ Shareholders Risk & Capital Report Society ABN AMRO Employees Governance Report Regularly engaging in a dialogue helps us to identify important areas for our stakeholders. We apply the materiality principle when discussing sustainability topics. This means that we focus on the issues that are most important to our key stakeholders and to our business, where we are actually in a position to influence the outcomes. Annual Financial Statements Other ABN AMRO Group Annual Report 2014 16 Strategic Report Our profile Our core values, mission, vision and business principles Our core values are embedded in the company culture and reflect our identity. We want to be trusted by our stakeholders and be professional in everything we do, and we have the ambition to continuously improve. Trusted Professional Ambitious At ABN AMRO we believe trust is all At ABN AMRO we understand At ABN AMRO we are always about establishing and maintaining banking. As true professionals, stretching ourselves and striving lasting relationships. We take the time we have a thorough grasp of the to achieve more for our clients. to get to know our clients by listening banking industry and the discipline We always strive to improve to their specific needs and aspirations. to achieve results. ourselves. Our goal is to find the products and We genuinely believe in our profession and We make it our business to know what services that are right for our clients. take responsibility by saying ‘no’ if saying is going on in the market and to respond When we make a promise, we always live ‘yes’ would not do right by our clients. proactively, and we do everything possible up to it; when we communicate with our to understand what clients really need clients, we are always straightforward We create solutions that are simple, and never have hidden agendas. understandable and workable, and we and to design innovative solutions. strive to improve ourselves every day by Our optimism about the future drives Our commitment to responsible banking working together and learning from one our ambition to offer our clients more. means we carefully weigh risks and returns another – and from our clients. At ABN AMRO, we are not afraid to so that our clients know their money is in venture outside our comfort zone to put good hands at all times. our ambition to work for our clients. Our mission is: Our business principles translate our core values, mission ÅÅ to be successful through the success of our clients; and vision into our day-to-day actions. ÅÅ to strongly commit ourselves to and be positively recognised for our position on sustainability and transparency; ÅÅ to be an organisation that has the best talent and where people grow both professionally and personally. Our vision is to be a professional, full-service bank with a leadership role in the Dutch market. Internationally, we aim to be a capability-led bank in selected businesses and geographies. Our ambition is to be a top class employer. I aim to provide my clients with the best solutions I build relationships through collaboration I take responsibility I am a passionate professional I only take risks I understand I am committed to sustainable business practices 17 priorities Business Report Enhance client centricity Risk & Capital Report Improve profitability strategic Pursue selective international growth Invest in our future Targets 2017 Results 2014 Return on equity 9% - 12% 10.9% Cost/income ratio 56% - 60% 60% CET1 ratio (fully-loaded) 11.5% - 12.5% 14.1% Other Strategic targets Annual Financial Statements Strongly commit to a moderate risk profile Governance Report priorities Strategic Report Our strategy is based on five priorities with targets set for 2017. The following section briefly describes each of the strategic priorities, including an overview of our achievements in 2014. Introduction strategic ABN AMRO Group Annual Report 2014 18 Strategic Report Strategic priorities Five strategic priorities Enhance client centricity Quality and relevance of advice Using technology to better serve our clients Continue Customer Excellence Invest in our future Re-engineer IT landscape & optimising processes Positively recognised on sustainability and transparency Recognised as top class employer Strongly commit to a moderate risk profile Optimise balance sheet Further diversification Good capital and liquidity position Pursue selective international growth Capability-led Fitting moderate risk profile Fitting efficiency focus Improve profitability Improve top-line revenues Continuous focus on costs Manage on the basis of risk-adjusted return Enhance client centricity We have introduced environmental, social and governance ABN AMRO aims to stand out from other banks based (ESG) criteria in our investment processes, developed on the quality and relevance of our advice and services. a sustainability indicator to help private banking clients We intend to further distinguish ourselves by enhancing make informed investment decisions and launched socially our need-based client segmentation and providing responsible products. solutions that suit our clients’ unique situations. We continued to raise financial awareness through In response to changing client needs in the Netherlands, our Carefree Living (Zorgeloos Wonen) programme, we have implemented changes in our retail branch opening by reaching out to an additional 25,000 clients facing hours across the country, introducing evening and weekend potential arrears in 2014. hours. We have also extended our webcam advisory services to offer our clients greater flexibility and A strategic review was conducted for Capital Markets convenience. The digital Retail Banking platform is also Solutions, resulting in the winding down of our Equity used for the Private Banking website and app design in the derivatives activities and a shift within Sales & Trading from Netherlands. Outside the Netherlands, we are developing a product-oriented focus to a more client-oriented focus. an ambitious digital offering consisting of a blend of omni-channel services combined with personal interaction. 19 the 15 sectors, benefiting from the pooling of knowledge ABN AMRO aspires to achieve a positively recognised and specialised services. position on sustainability and transparency. Introduction Banking to ensure that each client is assigned to one of Positively recognised position on sustainability and transparency We enhanced our sector-based approach in Corporate Our sustainability strategy supports this commitment and is based on four aspirations: Excellence (CE). Combining customer focus with ÅÅ We pursue sustainable business operations; operational excellence, this was applied across products ÅÅ We put our clients’ interests centre stage and build and businesses in several countries. sustainable relationships; ÅÅ We use our financial expertise for the benefit of society; We continuously take bank-wide initiatives to put our ÅÅ We finance and invest for clients in a sustainable manner. clients’ interests centre stage in everything we do. In the An inspired and engaged workforce is vital to the success centricity rose from 52% to 53%, while client satisfaction of our strategy. To this end, we promote sustainability remained stable compared with 2013, with 50% of clients internally and encourage our staff to get involved. rating our services favourably at scores of 8 and above. Our efforts are clearly paying off: the score for sustainability Our ambition is to build on our client-centric approach in the Employee Engagement Survey for 2014 rose to and make our clients promoters by giving them the best 61% from 45% in 2013. experience. In line with our ambition, we intend to implement the Net Promoter Score (NPS) methodology In 2014, we translated our sustainability aspirations into in most of our business segments in 2015. specific focus areas by implementing performance metrics Business Report annual client satisfaction survey, the score for client Strategic Report Throughout the year, we continued to focus on Customer and targets to support our sustainability strategy in in an increasingly concrete and transparent manner. For example, we started developing the Sustainability Risk Management policy for investments, with a focus The TOPS 2020 programme was launched in 2013 and To further broaden the scope to include all of our aims to upgrade and simplify our IT landscape based on investments, we aim to set a threshold for investments three aspirations: easiest to do business with, creating in line with the principles of the UN Global Compact. on environmental, social and governance (ESG) criteria. value through innovation and providing best-in-class productivity. We believe that value creation and sustainability go hand in hand, and we support entrepreneurs that share our In 2014, we finalised the blueprint for the new IT vision. For example, our Social Impact Fund, which invests landscape, which will be delivered in stages until 2020. in social enterprises, was positively received. ABN AMRO This will simplify our IT landscape, increase our agility and Informal Investor Services brings together Private Banking reduce our cost base. clients and SMEs. Private Banking clients invest in these the new agreement, IBM intends to, among other things, In recent years, we have been focusing increasingly on tax implement and manage an on-premise cloud environment matters, which is supported by the materiality analysis we for ABN AMRO. The dedicated on-premise cloud will help performed in 2014. The prime issue here is whether or not us to improve our standard of service, achieve greater internationally operating businesses pay their fair share of operational efficiencies and provide innovative products tax. To address this issue, we have increased transparency to our clients. by publishing our tax principles on our website and Annual Financial Statements social enterprises and often offer advice as well. We extended our partnership with IBM in 2014. Under Governance Report Re-engineering the IT landscape and optimising processes Risk & Capital Report Invest in our future practice. This will enable us to report on our progress providing country-by-country reporting on various income items. More information can be found in the Annual environment in 2015. We also expect to implement a new Financial Statements section in this report. security concept designed to protect our employees’ and clients’ digital information. More details are provided in our Sustainability Report 2014. ABN AMRO Group Annual Report 2014 Other We expect to migrate the first applications to this cloud 20 Strategic Report Strategic priorities Top Class Employer Strongly commit to a moderate risk profile Making a difference to our customers now and in the ABN AMRO is committed to maintaining a moderate risk future requires a talented, committed workforce more profile, which is reflected in, among other things, three than ever. Our Top Class Employer strategy aims to inspire key elements: (i) a clean balance sheet, (ii) a clear risk employees to develop continuously and to make their governance structure and strong risk culture, and (iii) a own, unique contribution to the bank’s sustainable growth. solid capital and liquidity position. Internationally, we focus Employees who take ownership of these goals are our on capabilities and geographies where we have a proven most valuable asset. They are at the heart of our ability to track record and a right to win. build long-lasting relationships with our clients. We have drawn up a roadmap with three aims: We are pleased that our prudent risk management ÅÅ Defining our meaningful corporate identity; approach resulted in our comfortably passing the ECB’s ÅÅ Developing a culture of excellence; comprehensive assessment, which consisted of the Asset ÅÅ Creating the best place to work. Quality Review and a stress test. This was carried out in preparation of the ECB taking over the supervisory role Managers at every level of the company play a pivotal role from DNB in November 2014. in motivating employees to realise ABN AMRO’s goals based on our corporate identity. They are the catalysts for We continued to optimise the sector-based risk approach change. Our leadership programmes help managers throughout the Risk Management organisation based on execute the strategy and develop an inspiring leadership improved risk knowledge and awareness. This has helped style. ABN AMRO introduced the Leadership Qualities to us to better monitor and manage portfolio intake and clarify what is expected of our managers. sector concentrations. This approach, together with the recovery of the Dutch economy, resulted in a decrease of But simply possessing talent is not enough: it is every loan impairments, primarily in our mortgage and business employee’s responsibility to use their talent. Equally, it is banking within Commercial Clients. the bank’s responsibility to support every employee’s professional development. We intend to introduce the Bank-wide operational risk awareness was strengthened Talent Identification Tool in 2015, a method to facilitate through rigorous training and e-learning programmes. open dialogue between managers and staff. This resulted from implementation of the Advanced Measurement Approach (AMA) for calculating operational To ensure that employees are given the opportunity to risk exposure for internal purposes. The application for continuously improve their expertise and skills in a culture AMA status will be submitted to the regulators in 2015. of excellence, we now offer talent development programmes to staff bank-wide rather than exclusively In late 2014, we formally applied to use the Internal Model to a small group. Approach (IMA) for market risk in the trading book. While regulatory approval is pending, the approach is being A new collective labour agreement was concluded with applied for internal risk management purposes and for the trade unions to give employees the autonomy to economic capital computations. personalise their working conditions, allowing them to create their best place to work. We review our risk appetite annually and continue to focus on actively managing it based on capital, liquidity and We have evaluated our Top Class Employer strategy and interest rate risks. We increasingly manage our bank are proud to report that we have improved on key metrics. based on risk-adjusted return on risk-adjusted capital Employee engagement scores rose further to 76% in (RARORAC) to ensure that our capital is employed in 2014. In terms of gender diversity, we increased the the most efficient way. percentage of women in senior and upper middlemanagement positions. Our efforts are reflected in the With the fourth profitable year in a row, we further annual Dutch Intermediair Image Survey, as our position improved our capital buffer. ABN AMRO had a fully loaded as a Top Class Employer in the Netherlands further CET1 ratio of 14.1% at year-end 2014, which is above our improved in 2014. target range of 11.5-12.5%. 21 Improve profitability ABN AMRO intends to grow in businesses where we The underlying cost/income ratio improved by four have a strong and proven track record (capability-led percentage points, from 64% in 2013 to 60% in 2014, growth) and that fit into our moderate risk profile. We which is at the upper end of the targeted range of 56-60% intend to build upon the ABN AMRO brand awareness and we set for 2017. This result was achieved thanks mainly to aim to match our local assets and liabilities over time. our re-pricing efforts, leading to margin improvements on Introduction Pursue selective international growth products across most segments. Growth of net interest income more than offset the modest cost increase, banking activities of Credit Suisse into Bethmann Bank, leading to the improvement in the cost/income ratio. our private bank in Germany. Bethmann Bank is now the third largest private bank in Germany. We also entered into Underlying ROE improved from 5.5% in 2013 to 10.9% a strategic global agreement with IndusInd Bank Limited, in 2014, which is within the 9-12% target range for 2017. a new generation Indian bank, to support our Asian private The full-year underlying net profit doubled to banking business. EUR 1,551 million, on the back of higher net interest Strategic Report In 2014, we completed the integration of the private income and lower loan impairments. The decrease in the level of loan impairments is the result of the initial online savings platform. recovery of the Dutch economy. In addition, we further strengthened our credit management, increased the level Clearing established a local clearing unit in Brazil to of early warning monitoring and improved our conduct clearing activities for existing clients and understanding of sector-specific risk by conducting expanded further in the US by servicing existing and extensive research and tightening credit requirements for acquiring new clients. new clients. These initiatives, together with the recovery ECT Clients further expanded in the US and Asia. improvement of net profit and ROE. We set up new Leasing branches in the United Kingdom and Germany, employing local staff with a track record in these markets. Risk & Capital Report of the Dutch economy, largely contributed to the Business Report In Austria, we introduced MoneYou, our retail banking Governance Report Annual Financial Statements Other ABN AMRO Group Annual Report 2014 22 Strategic Report Strategic governance strategic governance Below is an overview of the steps we take to assess, review and monitor the execution of our strategy. We review the long-term strategy annually in the Yearly Strategy Review (YSR) to assess its validity and relevance. External Internal The Managing Board bases its discussions on external developments (macroeconomic trends, competitive analysis and country landscape) and internal developments. During the yearly review, the most notable developments are discussed in terms of their impact on the long-term strategy and whether corrective actions are required. In the 2014 Yearly Strategic Review, the Managing Board Quarterly Execution Monitoring Fact base concluded that the bank’s long-term strategy is still substantially in line with external and internal developments. Monitoring The Managing Board monitors execution of the long-term strategy throughout the year by means of Quarterly Execution Monitoring (QEM). The QEM process consists Yearly Strategic Review of three building blocks: ÅÅ high-level monitoring of selected initiatives; ÅÅ performance reviews; ÅÅ in-depth dialogue sessions. Assessment The results of both the YSR and QEM are discussed and reviewed by the Supervisory Board as part of the corporate governance process. The Employee Council also receives updates on these results. Dialogue