the presentation
Transcription
the presentation
Five Things We’ve Learned about Growing Print Audiences Tom Ratkovich, Managing Partner Thursday, April 30, 15 About Me… Thursday, April 30, 15 About Me… • I’m a data geek Thursday, April 30, 15 About Me… • I’m a data geek • Managing Partner, LEAP Media Solutions Thursday, April 30, 15 About Me… • I’m a data geek • Managing Partner, LEAP Media Solutions • Founder/CEO, ASTECH InterMedia Thursday, April 30, 15 About Me… • I’m a data geek • Managing Partner, LEAP Media Solutions • Founder/CEO, ASTECH InterMedia • Co-owner, Aurora (CO) Media Group Thursday, April 30, 15 About Me… • I’m a data geek • Managing Partner, LEAP Media Solutions • Founder/CEO, ASTECH InterMedia • Co-owner, Aurora (CO) Media Group • I am not a print apologist… Thursday, April 30, 15 About Me… • I’m a data geek • Managing Partner, LEAP Media Solutions • Founder/CEO, ASTECH InterMedia • Co-owner, Aurora (CO) Media Group • I am not a print apologist… • I’m a Platform Agnostic Thursday, April 30, 15 About Me… • I’m a data geek • Managing Partner, LEAP Media Solutions • Founder/CEO, ASTECH InterMedia • Co-owner, Aurora (CO) Media Group • I am not a print apologist… • I’m a Platform Agnostic • And because it’s always nice to associate a name with a face… Thursday, April 30, 15 About Me… • I’m a data geek • Managing Partner, LEAP Media Solutions • Founder/CEO, ASTECH InterMedia • Co-owner, Aurora (CO) Media Group • I am not a print apologist… • I’m a Platform Agnostic • And because it’s always nice to associate a name with a face… TOM Thursday, April 30, 15 Print Audiences are Immensely Valuable See http://leapmediasolutions.com/news/dont-fold-tooearly-on-print/ Thursday, April 30, 15 Print Audiences are Immensely Valuable 1. Print audiences are critical sources of data and revenue – data that can enable relevance… and revenue that can fund other strategic initiatives. See http://leapmediasolutions.com/news/dont-fold-tooearly-on-print/ Thursday, April 30, 15 Print Audiences are Immensely Valuable 1. Print audiences are critical sources of data and revenue – data that can enable relevance… and revenue that can fund other strategic initiatives. 2. Print audiences are a source of customers for other offline and online products. See http://leapmediasolutions.com/news/dont-fold-tooearly-on-print/ Thursday, April 30, 15 Print Audiences are Immensely Valuable 1. Print audiences are critical sources of data and revenue – data that can enable relevance… and revenue that can fund other strategic initiatives. 2. Print audiences are a source of customers for other offline and online products. 3. The ability to offer advertising solutions that can be integrated and optimized across multiple online and offline channels offers a compelling proposition to advertisers vis-àvis single channel providers. See http://leapmediasolutions.com/news/dont-fold-tooearly-on-print/ Thursday, April 30, 15 Print Audiences are Immensely Valuable 1. Print audiences are critical sources of data and revenue – data that can enable relevance… and revenue that can fund other strategic initiatives. 2. Print audiences are a source of customers for other offline and online products. 3. The ability to offer advertising solutions that can be integrated and optimized across multiple online and offline channels offers a compelling proposition to advertisers vis-àvis single channel providers. 4. Print advertising works. See http://leapmediasolutions.com/news/dont-fold-tooearly-on-print/ Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #1: Thursday, April 30, 15 You CAN Grow Print Audience Lesson #1: You CAN Grow Print Audience About the LEAP Coalition Benchmarks Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #1: You CAN Grow Print Audience About the LEAP Coalition Benchmarks • 40 companies with audience universes of 5,000 to 100,000 Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #1: You CAN Grow Print Audience About the LEAP Coalition Benchmarks • 40 companies with audience universes of 5,000 to 100,000 • Coalition Objective: Share costs & best practices in customer intelligence and marketing automation to drive audience growth, engagement and monetization across all platforms Thursday, April 30, 15 What the Numbers Say… • Key metric #1: The number of starts that last at least ONE YEAR – Comparison based on starts generated in the 12 months prior to datadriven marketing automation vs. 12 months subsequent to implementation Source Direct Mail Email Telemarketing Voluntary ALL STARTS Thursday, April 30, 15 One Year Pre One Year Post What the Numbers Say… • Key metric #1: The number of starts that last at least ONE YEAR – Comparison based on starts generated in the 12 months prior to datadriven marketing automation vs. 12 months subsequent to implementation Source One Year Pre Direct Mail 34.4 Email 44.4 Telemarketing 16.1 Voluntary 34.8 ALL STARTS 27.0 Thursday, April 30, 15 One Year Post What the Numbers Say… • Key metric #1: The number of starts that last at least ONE YEAR – Comparison based on starts generated in the 12 months prior to datadriven marketing automation vs. 12 months subsequent to implementation Source One Year Pre One Year Post Direct Mail 34.4 67.0 Email 44.4 72.6 Telemarketing 16.1 39.2 Voluntary 34.8 56.5 ALL STARTS 27.0 45.0 Thursday, April 30, 15 What the Numbers Say… • Key metric #2: The arithmetic differential between new starts and permanent stops YOY Newspaper Company A Company B Company C Company D Thursday, April 30, 15 YOY Starts YOY Stops Net +/- What the Numbers Say… • Key metric #2: The arithmetic differential between new starts and permanent stops YOY Newspaper Company A Company B Company C Company D Thursday, April 30, 15 YOY Starts -1,427 YOY Stops -13,119 Net +/+11,692 What the Numbers Say… • Key metric #2: The arithmetic differential between new starts and permanent stops YOY Newspaper YOY Starts YOY Stops Net +/- Company A -1,427 -13,119 +11,692 Company B +307 -1,331 +1,638 Company C +928 -275 +1,203 Company D +372 -204 +576 Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #2: Thursday, April 30, 15 Not All Customers are Equal Lesson #2: Not All Customers are Equal Low!------------------------------------Ability to Retain---------------------------------"High 275 21 250 14 225 200 1 7 2 15 10 175 3 49 125 28 -10 15 40 65 23 5 46 90 20 55 38 51 58 33 60 59 47 66 31 61 57 41 40 24 50 29 30 140 56 52 50 54 64 48 16 35 63 22 25 44 0 53 65 -25 Low!--------------------------------------------Ability to Attract-------------------------------------------"High Thursday, April 30, 15 18 19 42 36 75 45 115 34 25 32 12 8 37 100 27 43 6 39 13 4 26 11 150 9 17 165 190 Strategy may be varied based on attributes Low!------------------------------------Ability to Retain---------------------------------"High 275 21 250 Hard to Acquire, Good Retention 14 225 200 1 7 2 15 10 175 9 3 49 -10 15 40 Hard to Acquire, 55 38 Poor 51 58 60 33 Retention 59 47 66 31 65 125 23 5 90 20 61 32 57 41 24 63 42 36 50 52 50 54 22 115 34 75 45 48 16 35 40 25 27 43 18 12 8 37 100 46 13 4 26 6 39 28 17 11 150 Easy to Acquire, Good Retention 64 19 29 30 140 56 165 Easy to Acquire, Poor Retention 25 44 0 53 65 -25 Low!--------------------------------------------Ability to Attract-------------------------------------------"High Thursday, April 30, 15 190 Strategy may be varied based on attributes Low!------------------------------------Ability to Retain---------------------------------"High 275 21 250 Hard to Acquire, Good Retention 14 225 200 1 7 2 15 10 175 9 3 49 -10 15 40 Hard to Acquire, 55 38 Poor 51 58 60 33 Retention 59 47 66 31 53 65 65 125 23 5 90 20 61 32 57 41 24 44 63 42 36 50 52 50 54 22 Move marketing $ elsewhere, or micro-target based on desirable characteristics. 115 34 75 45 48 16 35 40 25 27 43 18 12 8 37 100 46 13 4 26 6 39 28 17 11 150 Easy to Acquire, Good Retention 64 19 29 30 140 56 165 Easy to Acquire, Poor Retention 25 0 -25 Low!--------------------------------------------Ability to Attract-------------------------------------------"High Thursday, April 30, 15 190 Strategy may be varied based on attributes Low!------------------------------------Ability to Retain---------------------------------"High 275 21 250 Hard to Acquire, Good Discounting or pricing with Retention migration to full price. 14 225 200 1 2 Worth spending more to acquire. 40 59 47 66 31 53 65 65 125 23 5 20 61 57 41 24 44 63 42 36 50 52 50 54 22 Move marketing $ elsewhere, or micro-target based on desirable characteristics. 115 34 75 45 48 16 35 40 25 32 18 12 8 37 90 27 43 13 4 26 3 100 46 17 6 39 28 Hard to Acquire, 55 38 Poor 51 58 60 33 Retention 10 11 150 49 15 15 175 9 -10 7 Easy to Acquire, Good Retention 64 19 29 30 140 56 165 Easy to Acquire, Poor Retention 25 0 -25 Low!--------------------------------------------Ability to Attract-------------------------------------------"High Thursday, April 30, 15 190 Strategy may be varied based on attributes Low!------------------------------------Ability to Retain---------------------------------"High 275 21 250 Hard to Acquire, Good Discounting or pricing with Retention migration to full price. 14 225 200 1 2 Worth spending more to acquire. 40 59 47 66 31 53 65 65 125 23 5 20 61 57 41 24 44 63 42 36 50 52 50 54 22 Move marketing $ elsewhere, or micro-target based on desirable characteristics. 115 34 75 45 48 16 35 40 25 32 25 0 18 12 8 37 90 27 43 13 4 26 3 100 46 17 6 39 28 Hard to Acquire, 55 38 Poor 51 58 60 33 Retention 10 11 150 49 15 15 175 9 -10 7 Easy to Acquire, Good Retention 64 19 29 30 140 56 165 Easy to Acquire, Poor Retention Early, consistent engagement and reinforcement of value. EZ Pay focus. -25 Low!--------------------------------------------Ability to Attract-------------------------------------------"High Thursday, April 30, 15 190 Strategy may be varied based on attributes Low!------------------------------------Ability to Retain---------------------------------"High 275 21 250 Hard to Acquire, Good Discounting or pricing with Retention migration to full price. 14 225 200 1 2 Worth spending more to acquire. 40 59 47 66 31 53 65 65 3 125 23 5 90 20 61 32 57 41 24 44 63 42 36 50 52 50 54 22 Move marketing $ elsewhere, or micro-target based on desirable characteristics. 115 34 75 45 48 16 35 40 25 27 43 12 8 37 100 46 4 26 6 39 28 Hard to Acquire, 55 38 Poor 51 58 60 33 Retention 10 11 150 49 15 15 175 9 -10 7 25 0 64 Easy to Acquire, Good Retention Incremental 17 penetration may13be costly. May be somewhat price 18 inelastic. 19 29 30 140 56 165 Easy to Acquire, Poor Retention Early, consistent engagement and reinforcement of value. EZ Pay focus. -25 Low!--------------------------------------------Ability to Attract-------------------------------------------"High Thursday, April 30, 15 190 Find the Sweet Spot Low!------------------------------------Ability to Retain---------------------------------"High 275 21 250 Hard to Acquire, Good Discounting or pricing with Retention migration to full price. 14 225 200 1 2 Worth spending more to acquire. 40 59 47 66 31 53 65 65 3 125 23 5 90 20 61 32 57 41 24 44 63 42 36 50 52 50 54 22 Move marketing $ elsewhere, or micro-target based on desirable characteristics. 115 34 75 45 48 16 35 40 25 27 43 12 8 37 100 46 4 26 6 39 28 Hard to Acquire, 55 38 Poor 51 58 60 33 Retention 10 11 150 49 15 15 175 9 -10 7 25 0 64 Easy to Acquire, Good Retention Incremental 17 penetration may13be costly. May be somewhat price 18 inelastic. 19 29 30 140 56 165 Easy to Acquire, Poor Retention Early, consistent engagement and reinforcement of value. EZ Pay focus. -25 Low!--------------------------------------------Ability to Attract-------------------------------------------"High Thursday, April 30, 15 190 Lesson #3: Thursday, April 30, 15 How is More Important than How Much Lesson #3: • How is More Important than How Much The Circulator’s Predicament – Responsible for “the number” – Limited access to meaningful data and analytics – Without knowing how to spend money, success is dependent on how much budget Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #3: How is More Important than How Much • The Circulator’s Predicament • Intelligent Marketing changes the paradigm – Responsible for “the number” – Limited access to meaningful data and analytics – Without knowing how to spend money, success is dependent on how much budget – How becomes more important than how much – Analytics optimizes investments by informing the structure of campaign activities Objective – acquisition, retention, engagement, value enhancement Channel – email, direct mail, telemarketing Target – defined by transactions, demographics, contact history, channel preference, etc. Offer – print, digital, price, term, etc. Creative execution – copy, graphics, script Thursday, April 30, 15 Data-Driven Marketing Executions Customer insights drive communication strategy • • • • offer messaging creative channel Thursday, April 30, 15 Data-Driven Marketing Executions Customer insights drive communication strategy • • • • offer messaging creative channel Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #4: Thursday, April 30, 15 Think CLM– Not Retention Lesson #4: • Think CLM– Not Retention What is Customer Lifecycle Management? – Data-driven, technology-enabled process – Designed to optimize customer value of a customer relationship – not just the tenure – Typically comprises a curriculum of timely, relevant communications – Communications intended to provoke a specific response such as a purchase, renewal, EZ pay migration, survey response or engagement with content Thursday, April 30, 15 Multichannel CLM Curriculum Thursday, April 30, 15 End-to-End Marketing Automation Acquisition – Targeted prospecting to high-value, high-propensity consumers – Reacquisition to former subscribers, weighted based on recency – Multi-channel, integrated campaign management & execution (DM, TM and Email) – Web-based response fulfillment Customer Lifecycle Management – – – – Channel-integrated renewal and retention marketing Cross selling / upselling for print and digital activation Promote brand loyalty through early engagement Drives retention and customer profitability Engagement and Monetization – Promote engagement with content and social sharing – Build awareness and adoption of all products – Generate new revenue through sponsorships and advertising Thursday, April 30, 15 End-to-End Marketing Automation Acquisition – Targeted prospecting to high-value, high-propensity consumers – Reacquisition to former subscribers, weighted based on recency – Multi-channel, integrated campaign management & execution (DM, TM and Email) – Web-based response fulfillment Customer Lifecycle Management – – – – Channel-integrated renewal and retention marketing Cross selling / upselling for print and digital activation Promote brand loyalty through early engagement Drives retention and customer profitability Engagement and Monetization – Promote engagement with content and social sharing – Build awareness and adoption of all products – Generate new revenue through sponsorships and advertising Thursday, April 30, 15 End-to-End Marketing Automation Acquisition – Targeted prospecting to high-value, high-propensity consumers – Reacquisition to former subscribers, weighted based on recency – Multi-channel, integrated campaign management & execution (DM, TM and Email) – Web-based response fulfillment Customer Lifecycle Management – – – – Channel-integrated renewal and retention marketing Cross selling / upselling for print and digital activation Promote brand loyalty through early engagement Drives retention and customer profitability Engagement and Monetization – – – – Promote engagement with content and social sharing Generate customer data Build awareness and adoption of all products Generate new revenue through sponsorships and advertising Thursday, April 30, 15 Digital Content Automation Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #5: Thursday, April 30, 15 The Requirements for Growth Lesson #5: • The Requirements for Growth Set the expectation – Remove the term “Managed Decline” from your vocabulary Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #5: The Requirements for Growth • Set the expectation • Take the long view – Remove the term “Managed Decline” from your vocabulary – Focus on strategic audience growth and customer value Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #5: The Requirements for Growth • Set the expectation • Take the long view • Think “investment” rather than “expense” – Remove the term “Managed Decline” from your vocabulary – Focus on strategic audience growth and customer value – Technology Thursday, April 30, 15 The Role of Technology Thursday, April 30, 15 The Role of Technology • Optimization • Personalization • Integration • Automation Thursday, April 30, 15 CUSTOMER INTELLIGENCE PLATFORM Data Integration Marketing Analytics Campaign Management Multichannel Executions Reporting Address Demogra phics Thursday, April 30, 15 Subscribe rs Dispositi ons User Newslette Registrati rs on Deals Contests Loyalty Merchant s Lesson #5: Thursday, April 30, 15 The Requirements for Growth Lesson #5: The Requirements for Growth • Set the expectation • Take the long view • Think “investment” rather than “expense” – Remove the term “Managed Decline” from your vocabulary – Focus on strategic audience growth and customer value – Technology – Data Thursday, April 30, 15 Third Party Demographic/Lifestyle Data • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Name/address/phone Age/gender/ethnicity Marital status Occupation/education Hispanic language preference Number of children/ages Political party Homeownership/home value/type/age Length of residence Vehicle interest/car buyer/number Channel preference Online purchaser Direct mail purchaser Military veteran Thursday, April 30, 15 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Dog/cat owner Culture/arts/collectibles Fashion Camping/fishing/hunting/shooting Gardening Gourmet cooking/food Travel – foreign/domestic Home video games/computers Bicycling/boating/golf/tennis/skiing Home furnishing/decorating Home improvement Fitness/running Casino gambling Sweepstakes/contests Wines Lesson #5: Thursday, April 30, 15 The Requirements for Growth Lesson #5: • The Requirements for Growth Set the expectation – Remove the term “Managed Decline” from your vocabulary Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #5: The Requirements for Growth • Set the expectation • Take the long view – Remove the term “Managed Decline” from your vocabulary – Focus on strategic audience growth and customer value Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #5: The Requirements for Growth • Set the expectation • Take the long view • Think “investment” rather than “expense” – Remove the term “Managed Decline” from your vocabulary – Focus on strategic audience growth and customer value – – – – Technology Data Expertise Executions Thursday, April 30, 15 Lesson #5: The Requirements for Growth • Set the expectation • Take the long view • Think “investment” rather than “expense” – Remove the term “Managed Decline” from your vocabulary – Focus on strategic audience growth and customer value – – – – • Technology Data Expertise Executions Follow through Thursday, April 30, 15 Case studies are available at: tom.ratkovich@leapmediasolutions.com http://www.slideshare.net/astechtr/case-studies-in-datadriven-marketing-automation Thursday, April 30, 15 Thursday, April 30, 15