magazine - Animation World Network
Transcription
magazine - Animation World Network
May 1996 MAGAZINE Vol. 1, No. 2 Women in Animation WATCH OUT!! ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE Volume 1, No. 2 – May 1996 Editor’s Notebook by Harvey Deneroff 3 by Aleksandra Korejwo 4 Women in Animation and Bill Everson ANIMATION WORLD NETWORK 6525 Sunset Blvd., Garden Suite 10 Hollywood, CA 90028 Phone : 213.468.2554 Fax : 213.464.5914 Email : info@awn.com My Small Animation World Polish animator Aleksandra Korejwo muses about life, animation, music, Disney and her salt of many colors. Jim & Stephanie Graziano: An Interview by Harvey Deneroff 8 Jim and Stephanie Graziano have been behind some of the most successful TV shows around. Now DreamWorks has got them. Harvey Deneroff reports. Out of the Animation Ghetto: Clare Kitson and Her Muffia 11 by Jill McGreal Over the last few years, Channel 4 has helped put a new face on British animation. Jill McGreal reports how women will lead the broadcaster into series television using the irreverent talents of Candy Guard and Sarah Ann Kennedy. Rose Bond: An Animator's Profile ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE editor@awn.com PUBLISHER Ron Diamond, President Dan Sarto, Chief Operating Officer EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Harvey Deneroff ASSOCIATE EDITOR/PUBLICITY Frankie Kowalski CONTRIBUTORS : Giannalberto Bendazzi Christian Clark Harvey Deneroff Marcin Gizycki Wendy Jackson Aleksandra Korejwo Frankie Kowalski Neil McKee William Mortiz Linda Simensky Rita Street Le WEBMASTER Guillaume Calop DESIGN/LAYOUT : Guillaume Calop IMP Graphic e-mail : imp_ecmp@club-internet.fr ADVERTISING SALES North America : Wendy Jackson Europe : Vincent Ferri Asia : Bruce Teitelbaum by Rita Street 14 Independent animator Rose Bond is known for her use of mythology to explore the problems affecting humanity today. Rita Street explores her philosophy, methodology and her new foray into computer-assisted animation. Splendid Artists: Central And East-European Women Animators 17 Meena and Sara: Two Characters in Search of a Brighter Future for Women by Neill McKee and Christian Clark 20 by Marcin Gizycki Communist propaganda about the role of women in and out of animation in the USSR, Poland and Czechoslovakia did not always coincide with reality. Marcin Gizycki explains why and tells what has happened since then. The United Nations is using animation as a means of social change in Asia and Africa. Neill McKee and Christian Clark report from the field. Women In Animation: Changing the World: Person by Person, Cel by Cel by Rita Street 23 The founder of Women in Animation reveals her personal odyssey in founding the organization. Women in the Animation Industry —Some Thoughts 27 by Linda Simensky The Cartoon Network's Linda Simensky offers some personal observations on the ways women make it in today's animation industry. Mary Ellen Bute: Seeing Sound by William Moritz 29 Bill Moritz chronicles the work of pioneer experimental animator Mary Ellen Bute, whose films gained an unexpected acceptance by both Hollywood and the public. Claire Parker, An Appreciation by Giannalberto Bendazzi 33 Alexandre Alexeïeff usually gets the most of the credit for the pinscreen animation he did with his wife, Claire Parker. Giannalberto Bendazzi, a friend of both, examines her role in their collaboration. Film Reviews: James And The Giant Peach All Dogs Go To Heaven 2 Festival Review: Cartoons on the Bay Desert Island Series... Women always have plenty to pack!! by Wendy Jackson by Frankie Kowalski 35 38 by Giannalberto Bendazzi [English]40 [Italiano]42 43 compiled by Frankie Kowalski Our intrepid Desert Island maven queries some women in animation about their top 10 picks for an island getaway. News Preview of Coming Attractions Cover: Pond Life, the Series 2 45 46 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE Women in Animation s several articles in this issue point out, women have often played a key role in animation. Unfortunately, within the animation industry itself, there remains a dearth of directors and others in key creative positions. While this is starting to change, their participation pales in comparison to the dominant role they play among independent animators, whose films often constitutes half the offerings at major international animation festivals. This is where women have also come into their own have been in the executive ranks, both here and abroad. Thus, this issue is devoted largely to women in animation, it is not surprising that we offer a selection of pieces by and about independent animators Thus, Poland's Aleksandra Korejwo, in her first attempt at writing an article in English, provides us with a startling autobiographical essay, rich with poetry and imagery, that attempts to explain the sources of her inspiration. Rita Street explores the evocative films of Rose Bond, while William Moritz profiles the popular, but now largely forgotten pioneer experimental filmmaker, Mary Ellen Bute, and Giannalberto Bendazzi provides an appreciation of Claire Parker, whose role in animation history has often been subsumed to her husband. As Linda Simensky points out in her article, "Women in the Animation Industry-Some Thoughts," the way women get to the executive suite in today's animation industry often differs markedly from the way men get there. This is clearly illustrated by my interview with Jim and Stephanie Graziano, who both came to be major players in television animation by distinctly different routes. Jill McGreal in her piece, "Out of the Animation Ghetto," reports on how women, in both the executive and creative side of the business, are transforming animation at Britain's innovative Channel 4. Marcin Gizycki, A May 1996 meanwhile, explores the past and present roles women have and are playing in Russia, Poland and the former Czechoslovakia in his piece, "Splendid Artists." One of the more exciting and useful organizations around these days is Women in Animation. Rita Street, its founder and leader, provides a brief memoir on what led to its founding and explains its activities and aims. The way women have been portrayed in animation has often been a subject of concern in recent years, but that is certainly not a problem with regards to UNICEF's Meena and Sara projects, which are being used to fight destructive stereotypes seen in third world countries. Neill McKee and Christian Clark, who are both active in these projects, report on them in "Meena and Sara: Two Characters in Search of a The way women have been portrayed in animation has often been a subject of concern in recent years. Brighter Future for Women." Our focus on women in this issue appropriately concludes with the second of Frankie Kowalski's "Desert Island Series." New to this issue is our first set of film reviews of James and the Giant Peach and All Dogs Go To Heaven 2, by Wendy Jackson and Frankie Kowalski, as well as our first festival coverage from Giannalberto Bendazzi, who reports on Cartoons on the Bay, in Amalfi, Italy. Bill Everson always like to say that my interest in film and animation stems from being an industry brat, my father having I 3 worked at Fleischer and Famous Studios during the 1930s and 1940s. He was also a film buff, who had the pleasant habit of renting old silent films to show to family and friends on Friday nights. Although he died just before I turned 6, my older brother and I both maintained a strong interest in film; thus, at age 12, he took me to a series of films at New York's Museum of Modern Art, where I imbibed such classics as Intolerance, All Quiet on the Western Front and Rashomon. However, it wasn't until I happened on the Theodore Huff Memorial Film Society, run by William K. Everson, who died on April 14, that my passion for films and film going really started to take focus. The Society, which in the 1950s held its screenings in somewhat seedy meeting halls that also hosted such events as reunions of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade. More importantly, it provided a place for film buffs and scholars to meet, discuss and argue film. In those days before Cinema Studies became a respectable academic discipline, the Huff Society was key to the education of many a budding cinéaste, myself included. I need not go into a litany of Bill's accomplishments or activities, which including being a tenured professor of cinema studies at New York University, despite being a high school dropout. Though animation was not his prime focus, he was not averse to showing Chuck Jones or Friz Freleng cartoons before they became fashionable. I recall the time he was on an American Film Institute committee evaluating my proposal to do an oral history interview with animation pioneer J.R. Bray; to his (and my) surprise, he was the only one who knew who Bray was, and essentially shamed the others into approving my grant. For that and all the other kindnesses he showed me and others, I will always be grateful. Harvey Deneroff Editor-in-Chief Animation World Magazine ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 My Small Animation World by Aleksandra Korejwo Aleksandra Korejwo at her animation stand. “I only hope that we never lose sight of one thing—that it was all started by a mouse.” —Walt Disney or me, it all started with salt. Everybody knows salt. It is a common material. But for me, it is more than just salt. In this material, I discovered my new way for Art, my new way for animation. There were many years F of research and hard work. People often ask me, “How can you do such difficult animation so fast? It is impossible.” But I have been working for this moment all my life. Before my great meeting with animation, I studied painting. I learned to play the violin and I wrote poetry. My first thought was to create unity between painting, music and poetry. I could see that it was possible in animation art film. It was a great event in my life. But it was not enough just to know about it, I wanted to do it. I have been developing my own technique for many years. The most important thing was finding the method of coloring salt. I found it. It is a complicated process, but the effect on film is great. The next task was finding special tools for my unique material. It happened suddenly when I visited the zoo. The Swan by Aleksandra Korejwo 4 I don’t like looking at animals behind bars, but I know that some animals need man’s protection. It was spring and the bird’s feathers were dropping down onto the grass. They were long, strong feathers. I picked up a few and said, “Thanks” to the condors. After that, I formed the feathers in many ways and I have chosen the best ones, which I use to this day. Sometimes, the direction of your search can lead you to a surprise! The Movement, The Color, The Form My search for unity between painting, music and poetry began during my studies at the Academy of Fine Arts, where I did a lot of short musical compositions “without music.” My belief was that the music could exist only in the viewer’s imagination. Instead of from the sound, the music appeared in the movement, the color, the form! People said: “It is really colored music for our eyes.” At that time, I studied the works of John Cage. I prepared special scores for film, but I didn’t note musical notes. I noted form, color...they were my notes. I was groping in the musical world, but I knew intuitively that it was a good way. One day, something new happened. I was showing my film to a group of friends, but they had decided to give me a little surprise. When my film started, they switched on some music (it was some old Greek music I had never heard before). They wanted to see what the effect ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE would be with my film. It was just a joke pairing this casual music with my silent film. My friends (and I) were so surprised when we could see that the synchronization was absolutely perfect! My silent film became a “sound” film; a great event from the history of cinematography was being repeated in my own life. From that moment, I began The Travels of AKO my new adventures with the greatest classical music composers. I started creating films with music. I “noted notes” and translated them into frames. My new scores were different than before. In my silent films, I created only one musical line, for movement. Now I had two lines: music and movement. The most important thing, was finding the relationship between the two. My belief was that the music could exist only in the viewer’s imagination. Sometimes there was absolute synchronization, but sometimes I needed a counterpoint for a film idea. I was learning to understand the composers’ ideas and share my ideas with them. I tried to be very humble and to, very subtly, rediscover the composers’ personalities. May 1996 My parallel life motif which I was pursuing at this time, was to create films for children. Colored Changing Pictures When I was a child, as my family tells me, I used to watch Disney films and I would paint something like storyboards. My Mother laughs: “You used to sit on the floor and draw some rectangular frames with colored changing pictures inside.” At that time, my Grandpa sent me a lot of coloring books with Disney characters. I loved Disney’s “soft animation.” When I think about Walt Disney, I know that he felt movement. His characters really lived in his imagination. I believe the most important thing in animation is to feel movement. Therefore, before I start with a film, I always work around the film. I paint a lot, I make drawings to find the best movement for each element. I like to study movement in nature. I prepare my special scores for films, of course. I change my psyche and my mind for new movement in a new film. I work with my camera “face to face,” it is very important to have movement in mind. Before I started with my first children’s film, The Travel of AKO, I had thought about making a series for children. Disney was my inspiration, and I wanted to make films just like he did. The Travels of AKO is about three friends. The first looks like a yellow circle and is a very happy, optimistic “person”; the second, which is a blue triangle, is an enthusiastic, reserved, cold person; and the last is a very active and sometimes nervous person with a pink, square form. They appear and disappear, transforming into other 5 forms—good play for children. Fairyland in Salt Kids often visit me in my studio when I do my animation. They love to play with me and create forms from fairyland in salt. When I was making my next film for children about seven little colored ducks (from Julian Tuwim’s poem, “Hard Calculation”), I studied ducks walking in the country. My idea was to transmit from the screen to the child a visual knowledge of color theory, the process of additive and subtractive mixing of colors, through a good, humorous story. The most important thing in animation is to feel movement. I was pleased when the organizers of the International Animation Festival in Annecy, France, invited my film to the event. Later, I came back to making films for music, especially classical music. In 1989, I made The Weaver to the music of Stanislaw Moniuszko, for which I received the Award for Animation from the Association of Polish Filmmakers. After that, I made The Swan to the music of Camille Saint-Saëns. The idea for this film was born in Annecy, during the Festival, where I sketched swans gesturing near the lake. As I walked along the canals in this pretty Eine Kleine Nachtmusic —Romanze Andante ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE town, I was fascinated by the pure white, majestic birds. In my film, I wanted to achieve absolute perfect synchronization between music and painting. My film would also synchronize the ballet of a swan and a young girl. I had to be a choreographer as well. Many ballerinas say The Swan is the most difficult composition for ballet. For this film, I received two awards: The Special Prize for Perfect Transposition of Music Into Pictures given by the Jury of the Festival of Films for Children and Young People in Poznan, Poland (1992) and Grand Prix for the Best Animation Film (Under 10 minutes) given by the International Jury of the Festival of Animation Films in Shanghai (1992). At the Shanghai festival, I met many people from around the world, and many famous animation personalities. At that time I became an ASIFA member. My next projects were the films, Ave Maria to music by Schubert and Eine Kleine Nachtmusik— Romanze Andante to music by Mozart. I had to draw very fast because the horses wanted to eat my drawings. Eine Kleine Nachtmusik was a film about the sometimes sorrowful life of Mozart. After the filming, I too, experienced sorrow, when it was discovered that all of the film had been overexposed due to a problem in the camera. I had to start all over again, but it was not the same film. In my technique, I animate directly under the camera; I destroy the first picture to create May 1996 the second. When I finish, all that remains is the dirty salt on the floor. The life of the material exists only in movement, and only for a few minutes, but I hope it remains forever in the imagination of the audience. My next film was Exultate Jubilate Alleluja (Hallelujah), also to the music of Mozart, followed by On the Beautiful Blue Danube to the music of Strauss. For this film the On the Beautiful Blue Danube organizers of the International Animation Film Festivals in Canada, Portugal and France invited my film to their festivities. Hollywood, The Soul Of Film After my film was shown in Annecy (France) a man came up to me and said; “Congratulations”—It was Ron Diamond from Acme Filmworks in Hollywood. We began talking, I didn’t listen to anything else during that evening ... Hollywood always makes me think of the soul of film—and Walt Disney, of course. I was excited about the possibility of working in Hollywood, but I didn’t believe it could really happen until Ron called me. Now, I know that he is a brilliant manager and producer. He found me work that was very well suited to my personality. I 6 would make four films for the Austin Lyric Opera in Texas. There were four 30 second commercials to Opera music: La Traviata, Tannhäuser and Lucia di Lammermoor. I had to chose 30 seconds from each of these operas for the films. Many ideas appeared in my mind. I think, I chose the best parts for my technique. Now, when I think about my good fortune in meeting Diamond, I am reminded of my aunt who inspired me to create the film On the Beautiful Blue Danube. She was interested in my films. When I visited her, she would pour coffee for me in a very pretty cup with a beautiful, delicate design on it and we would talk about my films. She became very ill and on the last night before her death, she gave me that pretty cup for memory. That cup became a film star. I often think about the parallels between my life and my films. Perhaps, one day I will make a live-action film about these parallels. Synchronizing With My Life Every film has a different story and synchronizes with my own life. My most recent film project (a three-part collection from the Bizet opera Carmen: Carmen Suite, Carmen-Habanera and Carmen Torero) was born in a little town in Spain called Huesca. The International Film Festival there had invited me and my film. I could feel the warm Spanish sunlight on my face and also in my heart. I saw fiestas which took place in the moonlight. In the morning, I observed the sun above the brown-red Spanish land. Of course, before I started making ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE the films, I studied the Spanish flamenco dance. Also, before I started on the first Carmen film, I lived on a ranch. Everyday, I made lots of drawings among the horses. My lovely horses used to come to me and look at my drawings or paintings as if they were mirrors. It was very funny for me and I think for them also. I had to draw very fast because the horses (especially one of them) wanted to eat my drawings. My professor from the Academy of Fine Arts used to say, “Keep your sketchbook in your pocket always.” I try to make sketches every place I go. It is my principle. I keep my flipbook in my pocket. I am very happy that I can participate in animation festivals, that I can travel to other countries. There are many places for interesting, sometimes surprising meetings with wonderful, sensitive people who are making art films more and more beautiful. There is one heart of animation art shared by all film directors, animators, cameramen, good producers and enthusiastic people who love animation film. Each animation festival impresses my mind and heart with a deep sign. I try to note these impressions with drawings and write them down. When the last Annecy festival ended, I wrote a short impression: “The day after the end of the Annecy Festival: I am sitting on a bench at the side of a lake. Only the swans are unchanged. The surroundings get altered, decorations change, the water in the canals has fallen low. People are walking faster. Trucks, cruising the park, make noise. Even pigeons May 1996 are more uneasy and are looking inquiringly. “Only the swans are swimming quietly certain of their presence. My heart is full of conversations and animated forms. I am breathing the presence of people I saw (maybe it was too short to understand, too short to remember). Yet I can still observe the animation of life. The animated film is going on. “The swan as question marks, maybe it is enough to sail along the route of God?” The Ocean of Life This story is only a little drop in the ocean of life. My life and work really makes me think of the ocean. Maybe every film is just like one wave? Always the same rhythm, but a different story, a different, unusual sound and form. When I was teaching students at the Academy of Fine Arts they asked me, “You very often make films around ballet, dance, opera; what is the most interesting area for you?” My answer is, “Every moment is unusual for me. How amazing is movement in nature. I observe it often and I find ideas of the harmony in it. There is an incredible dialogue between creating shapes, sounds and movements. “It is a great play of many instruments, of many feelings. The fantastic combination is joyful and sorrowful, dramatic and humorous—the true poetry of life. I feel like I am just one element from that composition, from that landscape. My body speaks the same language, which is sometimes called dance, ballet or pantomime.” And all the time, I am looking for the point of meeting between poetry, movement, music and painting. I see that point not only in music films, not only in ballet or other dance, not only in opera. I see that point everyday in my life. When I walk across the meadow, when I look at the ocean, and at the noisy intersection. I think the most important thing is to be able to observe movement in its variety and still learn by looking at the world through artists’ and children’s eyes. Alexsandra Korewjo is a filmmaker based in Poznan, Poland. Carmen Habanera 7 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Jim & Stephanie Graziano: An Interview by Harvey Deneroff ast November, Jeffrey Katzen- Spielberg was known for his berg asked Jim and Stephanie hands on involvement in these Graziano to head up produc- shows, which is likely to continue tion for Dreamin the new venture. (In Works’ new televiaddition, former Disney sion animation diviTelevision Animation sion. While the offer President Gary Krisel has was not surprising, been brought in to given the Graziano’s oversee the whole track record, what operation.) was surprising is Stephanie Graziano how readily they explained that, We had accepted. After all, three previous offers to their company, buy the studio, but Graz Entertainnone of them made ment, noted for any sense. DreamWorks such hit shows as was the first case where X-Men and The Tick, we were offered things Stephanie Graziano that we were lacking as was one of the © Graz Entertainment hottest studios in a small studio. town. There was also the fact DreamWorks Television Ani- that it was a startup, mation is the newest and so far which is always exciting, least clearly defined of Dream- and that we could work Works SKG, Hollywood’s newest together. That was really a super studio. The division’s man- big part of it.” date extends beyond only televiDespite being one of sion to also include direct-to-video Hollywood’s most sucproductions and interactive ani- cessful animation couples, mation. The operation itself falls Jim and Stephanie under the aegis of Steven Spiel- Graziano have not been able to work together as much as they would like. In fact, We actually have different Jim had just returned to Graz after mind sets, but they end up a three year stint at Universal Carcomplementing each other. toon Studios when DreamWorks came along. Their longest stint berg, whose previous TV efforts in together was not at Graz, but at collaboration with Warner Bros. Marvel Productions, where they (Tiny Toon Adventures, Animaniacs, met (in 1984) and married (in Pinky and the Brain, etc.) helped rev- 1988)—he was Senior Vice Presiolutionize broadcast animation. dent of Production and she L 8 worked under him as a producer. Why Would We Even Want to Do It “People often ask us,” Stephanie says, “about how we work together, or why we would even want to do it. But we really are at our best working together. We actually have different mind sets, but they end up complementing each other.” She explains that, “I come from the creative side, while Jim comes more from the technical end. So, in trying to find solutions to problems, we realize that not every person is the same. Some artists are better dealt with in a creative fashion, while others are better dealt with in a technical fashion. What we try to do is weigh these situations and decipher which direction would be more appropriate.” This difference also translates into Jim Graziano different strengths vis-à-vis their roles atGraz. “When we started Graz,” Stephanie notes, “we opened it with three work for hire series. I did all of the administrative work and Jim actually ran the studio. At that point, because it was really a function of his getting the production going, it was perfect. After the first six months, when he went to Universal and I ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 X-Men, Red Dawn episode © Saban Entertainment took over the studio, the timing couldn’t have been more perfect. The company had reached a point where it needed to start going after other properties and production deals. And that isn’t what he does. Jim really does more of the day-to-day management and talent recruiting, while I’m better at making acquisitions and trying to build relationships with distributors and creators.” From Different Directions Both Jim and Stephanie were to get “a real job.” As his father was a film editor with his own company, he “knew how to pop track and do a lot of other things. So, I got a job at Warner Bros. as an apprentice editor,” eventually becoming “a full fledged editor.” After he worked with Friz Freleng putting together such compilation films as Daffy Duck’s Fantastic Island, he was hired in 1984 as studio production manager at Marvel Productions, where he stayed until 1991, eventually becoming Senior Vice President of Production. Despite being one of Hollywood’s most successful animation couples, Jim and Stephanie Graziano have not been able to work together as much as they would like. born and raised in the Los Angeles area, but they came into animation and animation management from different directions. For his part, Jim had bummed around a few years after graduating from the University of Idaho in 1975, where he had gone on a football scholarship (playing tight end) and majored in Physical Education. In 1978, he finally decided Those were Marvel’s “big years,” Jim recalls, “when they did The Transformers, Muppet Babies and My Little Pony.” On the other hand, Stephanie’s entry into animation was (for a woman) more conventional. In 1972, right after high school, she got a job as an inker at HannaBarbera. She earned an A.A. degree in Advertising from Los 9 Angeles Valley College, and went on to UCLA to study Fine Arts, all while continuing to work in animation. She recalls that, “I was at a point in the business where it was thriving. I was freelancing for two or three places, while working during the day at Hanna-Barbera. It became such a lucrative situation that I thought, ‘Well, I can always go back to school!’” She left college and decided to “pursue various avenues and tried to become more versatile.” She became an ink and paint supervisor at Ruby-Spears, while, on her own, learned all she could about camera and editing. At this time, American studios were beginning to send ink and paint to Asia in an effort to cut costs. She “did not really want the work to go over there, but I knew that it was going to happen and wanted to know exactly what they were capable of.” Thus, she “volunteered three or four times to go overseas to set up shows for them.” Stephanie became studio manager for Tom Carter, before going to Marvel in 1984 as a production manager. Two years later, she got her first producing assignment (The Humanoids), and then started working in development with Margaret Loesch. The Land Before Time 2 © MCA/Universal Home Video ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE The Tick © Sunbow Entertainment When Loesch left to start the Fox Children’s Network, Stephanie went along as Director of Animation Programming and Production. When Jim started Graz in 1992, she stayed on at Fox, but helped him out with administrative tasks in her spare time. After Jim went to Universal, Stephanie stepped in to run Graz full-time. Expanding the Studio At Universal, Jim oversaw production on such shows as Beethoven, Shelly Duvall’s Bedtime Stories and Earthworm Jim, along with three made-for-video sequels to The Land Before Time. Meanwhile, Graz, under Stephanie’s direction, expanded from a studio for hire to the point where it had an ownership interest in half of its projects, as well as expanded into such areas as home videos (Cathy), video games (Shadoan) and TV commercials. May 1996 By last year, Graz had reached their long term goal of having an ownership interest in half their productions (with the other half being done on a for hire basis). Stephanie states that, “I didn’t really see it getting too much bigger, or it probably wouldn’t have been as enjoyable in the same way. I really anticipated it’s future being more of a maintenance base than a growth base.” At the same time, the animation market was also changing, as the industry was becoming increasingly dominated by the major studios. As a result, Stephanie says, “it will be interesting to see how small, independent studios who want to retain ownership survive in a market, where the big guys want to own everything. It was something that I really couldn’t analyze at Graz, but it was something interesting to consider.” Jim concurs, feeling that while Graz would have been able to maintain its work flow and perhaps “grown a bit,” but wonders what would have happened, with “all the big guns really gearing up.” For the Grazianos, their new position means stepping up from modest budgets set by clients, to dictating their own budgets and schedules. However, they plan to continue the same creator friendly approach that had contributed so much to Graz’ success. In this, the Grazianos are part of a new generation of studio managers who have transformed the creative environment. As such, they have helped television animation, especially, turn away from the factory approach initially heralded by 10 the likes of Hanna-Barbera in the early days of Saturday morning animation. At Graz, there was a conscious effort to cast each artist for each show, while encouraging interaction between the crew in order to promote greater creativity. Stephanie notes that their new studio will be planned with “production units that will be defined by, in almost all cases, individual offices on the exterior. In almost all cases, individual offices, with a living room setting in the center. That will act as a meeting place, a communications center, with screening capabilities, that will encourage people to interact together and be part of a team.” (It’s interesting to note, in this regard, as Jim points out that, “there are no titles within any division of DreamWorks.”) It will be interesting to see how small, independent studios survive in a market where the big guys want to own everything. Given the fact that no shows have yet been given the green light at DreamWorks Television Animation, it is too early to tell how the new operation will fare. But given its all-star management line up—including Jim and Stephanie —it is an operation which in many ways seems to have everything going for it. Harvey Deneroff, in addition to his duties as Editor of Animation World Magazine, edits and publishes The Animation Report, an industry newsletter, which has taken over operation of the annual Ojai Animation Conference. ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Out of the Animation Ghetto: Clare Kitson and Her Muffia by Jill McGreal nimation moves around the globe finding the right conditions of production and digging in for the duration. At various times, and for various reasons, the best work has to come out of America, Canada, Eastern Europe...wherever the climate permitted. Sometime in the eighties it landed in Britain, where animators began to produce increasingly confident work resulting in the recent run of international prizes. At the recent Pre-Selection Committee for the Zagreb World Festival of Animated Film, now thankfully back on form after a rocky war-torn patch, there were 450 entries to the competition section, of which 133 were from Britain—by far the largest number for any one country. The standard of this work was high and the range of subject matter, techniques and individual styles stretched across the board. There were robust showings of experimental, political, personal and narrative work commissioned or produced by a host of national and local funding bodies. It’s an interesting time for any filmmaker to be at work in the UK. In the past decade and a half, along with other Western democracies, we have, according to the pundits, entered a new post-modern era. In Britain, this era was ushered in by Thatcherism in 1979, where the population is still held in the moral grip of its rightwing politics of conviction— A despite the succession of scandals, resignations, sackings, by-election losses and a distinct change in the political atmosphere. But not all of the social change of the last decade has been for the worse. The trickle down effect of the 1974 Sexual Discrimination Act began to speed up as the eighties-style ideologies promoted individualism wherever it came from—postfeminism arrived as Dolly Pond part of the post-modfrom Pond Life ern package. Deregulation of the public service sector—a Thatcherite imperative and definitive of the pattern of social change in the UK over the past decade—started in a small way when Channel 4 began transmitting on November 2, 1982; it was a daring move, which increased the number of television channels available in the UK from three to four! Animation for Adults The channel’s mandate to deliver innovative work to specialized audiences was interpreted generously and, as part of a wider scheduling experiment, animation for adults was given its own commissioning department. It’s impossible not to link this development with the growth of animation in 11 the UK; indeed, Channel 4’s role in the benign circle of funding and stimulation of talent has been recognized at all levels. Narrative is no longer the province of male filmmakers—if it ever was. Channel 4’s Commissioning Editor for Animation, Clare Kitson, continues to commission difficult but award-winning work, much of which has been directed by women. For reasons adequately covered elsewhere, and especially in Jayne Pilling’s introduction to her book, Women and Animation (BFI, 1992), animation has always been able to accommodate women. So, the present animation boom in the UK, taking place in a late 20th century climate which is generally more supportive of women, has sustained many female directors. Over the last few years, women have worked in every genre: personal—Karen Watson’s Daddy’s Little Piece of Dresden China (1988) and her new film Sweet Heart (1995) address the issues of childhood sexual abuse and anorexia from an autobiographical point of view; lyrical—Susan Young’s Carnival (1985), Karen Kelly’s Egoli (1989) and Stressed (1994); documentary—Marjut Rimminen’s Some Protection (1987), the Leeds Animation Workshop’s Through the Glass Ceiling (1995) both to do with the treatment of women, in prison in Rimminen’s film and at work in the Leeds film; ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE experimental—as in Vera Neuebauer’s The World of Children (1984) or her Lady of the Lake (1995); abstract—Erica Russell’s Feet of Song (1989) and Triangle (1995); narrative without dialogue—Joan Ashworth’s The Web, Alison Snowden’s Second Class Mail (1984); narrative with dialogue—Sarah Ann Kennedy’s Nights (1992) or any of Candy Guard’s many short films. Kitson’s Muffia Narrative is no longer the province of male filmmakers—if it ever was. Certainly, when Kitson’s budget was increased in 1994 and she modified her policies to include series work, she felt that only Sarah Ann Kennedy and Candy Guard were able to write dialogue and structure narrative sufficiently well to move forward in this direction. As a result of this bold move, Kitson has been accused, unfairly, of running a ‘Muffia’; but, in fact, her decision to move into series production, a program space previously occupied exclusively by producers of children’s programming, has once again extended the boundaries of animation. May 1996 that Kitson’s irritation is only halfconcealed when she notes that the BBC has now also started commissioning adult animation series. Pond Life Kitson’s real move forward is into mainstream comedy and out of the animation ghetto. She has been so successful that she will now have to watch her back for product-hungry comedy commissioning editors straying onto her patch. Neither Crapston Villas nor Candy Guard’s Pond Life are Grand Prix winners at traditional animation festivals like Annecy or Zagreb—the source of many awards, honors and prizes for Channel 4. But both Kennedy and Guard have expressed a desire to move into live action. Animation is perhaps, for both, a route Animation is perhaps, for both, a route through the glass ceiling. In gratitude Crapston Villas, Kennedy’s model animation series about the flat-dwelling inhabitants of a run down Victorian house in a seedy London street, won Best New Program in the 1996 Broadcast Awards (Broadcast is a major British trade magazine), and for the first time, animation went up against live action and won—a major coup for Kitson and Channel 4. It’s unsurprising, therefore, through the glass ceiling. Candy Guard has been working on Pond Life since 1992, when the pilot, I Want a Boyfriend ... Or Do I?, was co-commissioned by S4C and Channel 4. The 13 x 11 minute series premieres on Channel 4 later this year. Kitson put the Pond Life concept into research before giving the series the green light. “When results of the research came back,” Kitson said, sounding surprised, “the male 12 participants had identified Pond Life as to do with ‘women issues,’ whereas I believe that the issues that Candy addresses are universal.” Kitson was being disingenuous. The issues—career, driving test, clothes, friends, rock music, holidays—are universal, but the tale on them is assuredly not— women may go awkward, silent and tongue-tied the minute they think a bloke fancies them (see I Want A Boyfriend ... Or Do I?), but men get loud, show off and clown about in front of the girl they fancy ... (Or do they?). Not that Guard thinks of herself as a feminist. “It’s not a word that I use about myself. I’m much more likely to describe myself as a socialist,” is her initial response to my question; but knowing that I will ask her if she is a feminist, Guard has consulted her boyfriend on the matter, who clearly thinks she is one—“Because I get cross about things,” she says. “I get especially cross about women’s role in the film industry, both as actresses and creators. Taking sex Pond Life scenes, for instance, in which male directors forever have women bouncing up and down on top of the male actors, presumably so that you see their tits better. Even in Toy Story, which I really enjoyed, I felt the filmmakers could have tried harder. Why did all the toys have to be male?” Guard respects Kitson’s judgment although she doesn’t necessarily always agree with it. In fact, when her friend and col- ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE Crapston Villas The dialogue sparkles with smut and filth—so it’s more British. league, Sarah Ann Kennedy, was commissioned to make Crapston Villa before Pond Life got to go ahead, Guard confesses to being dismayed. Crapston Villas offers a different kind of humor than Pond Life. It’s more lavatorial—the dialogue sparkles with smut and filth—so it’s more British and perhaps, for that reason, easier to commission. A More Daring Kind of Comedy Guard likens her work to American series like Roseanne, Friends, and Ellen. And it’s true that Pond Life, which centers on the angst-ridden life of Dolly Pond, explores issues in a more personal way than Crapston Villas, where the humor is spread across a broader social canvas. And, as is well known, the British can poke May 1996 fun at the idiosyncrasies of their class system, but they get coy about showing their emotions. In this sense Pond Life takes a step forward into a more daring, international kind of comedy. What Pond Life and Crapston Villas share is attitude to women’s issues in which female desire is OK and political correctness is a thing of the past. Crapston, in particular, revels in the shagging culture of the nineties. Take, for instance, this slice of dialogue from Episode 3. Marge, the late thirty-something mum, who lives at the top of Crapston Villas with her delinquent, glue-sniffing children and senile old mum, is having a telephone conversation with her black female friend, Denise. They are both smoking and drinking: Denise: “What you need is a good shag” (laughter). Marge: “Yeah, I quite fancy a handyman (gales of laughter). I’ve got a few odd jobs that need doing (shrieks of laughter). I don’t care what he looks like as long as he can screw a few things in for me (more Shrieks). I’ll advertise for an odd job man preferably with a large tool” (more shrieks). Denise: “Or what about, ‘caffolders wanted, quick erection only, site in desperate need of attention,’” (collapse into hysterical laughter). Scaffolders wanted, quick erection only, site in desperate need of attention. Pond Life takes a different route into equally taboo subjects as Dolly Pond pours out her neuroses to anyone who will listen. But neither series is afraid of representing women. The moral high 13 ground, once occupied by firstgeneration feminists, in which all representation was offensive, has given way to feistier generation of women who have more selfesteem and are, therefore, less fearful of their self-image, and less moralistic and judgmental in their attitudes to their own sex. Guard certainly doesn’t think of herself as a feminist filmmaker, at least not consciously. On the other hand, it wouldn’t have been possible for her to write Pond Life for a central male character. “So, in fairness, you can’t really blame men for writing scripts with strong male leads,” she remarks confidently. She wonders, though, whether Pond Life would have been made if the Commissioning Editor at Channel 4 had been a man...a question which thankfully, we are not able to answer. Crapston Villas Jill McGreal is an animation producer at Code Name: The Animation Agency, in Hampshire, England. ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Rose Bond: An Animator's Profile by Rita Street Director and Animator, Rose Bond ’ve always drawn horses,” says the reserved yet captivating Rose Bond, an award-winning animator from Portland, Oregon. “Teachers picked out my horse drawings to hold up. In kindergarten, at a back-to-school night, all my horse drawings were up on one board—which I thought was a little unfair to the other children.” But no matter how embarrassed she might have been for being singled out, Bond remembers with fondness the affect it had on her mother. When she walked in the room and saw Rose’s drawings, Bond’s mother sighed and said, “Oh, those horses!” Mrs. Bond’s reaction is one that has been shared by many when first introduced to her daughter’s animated shorts. Bond’s horses have a mythical I presence, as if they reside at once between two planes—the Bond’s horses have a mythical presence, as if they reside at once between two planes ... reality we know and the reality of Faerie. Bond’s major films are based on the myths and legends of pre-Christian Ireland, a time when the world of Faerie and the powers of witchcraft were considered a part of every day life. Says Bond of her stories, “The pre-Christian Irish had a very non-Western pantheon of gods. They believed you could be walking past a hillside and if it happened to be the hundredth day past a certain stage of the 14 moon, for instance, you could slip into another dimension. For them there was little difference between gods and mortals.” Bond also emphasizes a strong connection for the early Irish between humans and nature, a connection that allows for shape shifting and metamorphosis, a process that Bond has always been drawn to animate. But Bond’s films are about more than just beautiful horses changing into other animal forms. They address universal topics affecting humanity today through legends of the past. Bond’s oeuvre questions the importance of a dominate system of power. Should men rule over women? Should women rule over men? Is there another middle-ground or middle-way? The Light of Inspiration In her epic trilogy of three Irish legends, Cerridwen’s Gift, Deirdre’s Choice © Paint-on-Film Animation by Rose Bond, 1995 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE (1987), Mallacht Macha (or Macha’s Curse, 1990) and Deirdre’s Choice (1995), heroines struggle with a world that is shape shifting itself, moving from a matriarchal to patriarchal base. The white witch Cerridwen, whose daughter is pure and bright, attempts to bestow the light of inspiration upon her troubled and disagreeable son. Her potion boils in a cauldron for one year, but just as it is ready, it bubbles over and splatters the lips of her servant boy. Enraged, thinking that the boy has spoiled the potion, Cerridwen begins a marvelous chase after the frightened servant, in which both change shapes between animals of land, sea and sky. The boy makes the unwitting mistake of shifting into the form of a small seed which Cerridwen, in the shape of a hen, promptly eats. The seed grows in her belly until she bears a child that has the glow of inspiration on his brow. When the child grows to manhood and becomes known as May 1996 the womb is Druidpredicted to be trouble for the King. To show his might over even the Fates, the King decrees that when the girl grows up he will take her for his own. But, when Deirdre comes of age, she falls in love and escapes with her lover on a long pilgrimage through 35mm Film frames from Mallacht Macha (Macha’s Curse) distant lands. They © Paint-on-Film Animation by Rose Bond, 1990 are finally discovprophet he remembers Cerrid- ered by the King who has the wen, the mother of knowledge lad slain. Deirdre becomes the who delivered upon him the King’s woman, but to show her light of the world. power over even his authority, In Macha’s Curse, the goddess she takes her own life. appears in the form of a gray mare and discovers a handsome Something Magical, man living alone in her woods. Something Eternal She takes on human form and Each film depicts a struggle weds the man, but bids him for the right to “be,” for the right never say anything of it to other to live freely, for the ultimate mortals. At a festival, the man power that is in every woman, boasts that his wife can run and every man, to stand on faster than all the horses of the equal ground and declare, “In King. Insulted, the King arrests me is something magical, somethe man and sends his men to thing eternal.” Bond declared find the offensive woman, the just such a right in her own life goddess Macha, who is now by steadfastly allowing herself pregnant by her man. The King the privilege to grow as an artist. demands that the woman, even In college she had struggled in her burdened condition, run with art. Her creative passions against his horses. Macha does ran deep, but she found no so and wins the race but curses mentor to guide her through the the men of the village for nine reality of becoming a profesgenerations with the weakness sional so she set her art aside. of a mother in labor. It is their “I was very disenchanted just due for choosing a “king’s with college. I had no role modmight over a mother’s right.” els. It seemed that the only way And in the most recent short, to succeed as an artist was to be Deirdre’s Choice, a girl child still in an academic. I simply didn’t 15 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE understand how a career in art worked. It wasn’t until my late twenties when I took an animation night course at NorthWest Film Center that discovered where drawing could go.” Even though she was working a full-time job as an educational administrator, she began to work at night on her animated films. Finally the urge to fill in her own gaps of knowledge as a filmmaker led her to follow her heart and return to school. She took a leave without pay and attended the School of the Art Institute of Chicago to complete her MFA. As she says, “my art was calling.” At Art School she finished Macha and created a film installation called The Peep Show at the Name Gallery. Says Bond, The Peep Show was a take off on the porno booth where you step in a small dark room, put in your quarter and see a show. In a three minute cycle, she animates from A New View of a Women’s Body— presenting a revolutionary view on the female sexual arousal with the cycled engorgement of an intricate maze of tissues and capillaries; an interior felt but never seen. A Very Avant-Garde Approach After graduation, Bond returned to her work with the May 1996 Portland Public Schools, but added the role of animation instructor at Northwest Film Center to her list of professional duties. Today, Bond takes a very avant-garde approach to her classwork, teaching students the basics of squash and stretch, but asking them to apply this knowledge to non-traditional forms of animation. Bond, a “direct” animator, encourages experimentation in all forms, including work with computers. The Peep Show was a take off on the porno booth where you step in a small dark room, put in your quarter and see a show. master. To ink, I use a mixture of pens and watercolors. There’s a type of German pen I like as well and then I use on alcohol base dye for my warm palette.” But, Bond is now interested in trying her painterly animation process on the computer. She is dabbling with Fractal Design’s Painter software, which allows for the look and feel of a real painter’s toolset within the digital format. In a sense the computer seems to fit with the new era of work Bond hopes to move in to. “No more trilogies,” she says. “I’m at a period of my life where I’m reconsidering where I’m going with my personal work. My inclination is to go back away from story. Not exactly pure visual poetry, but something more “Stone Man” Rock Art Animation experimental, something that from Sacred Encounters installation © Rose Bond, 1995 leaves an impression.” And knowing Bond, that Says Bond, “I create my ani- impression is sure to be “lasting.” mation in flipbooks, then ink each page directly onto clear film leader. After I ink the whole film, and I usually have very little cutting, I end up with a big roll of about 400 feet with frame lines marked on it. Then I color Rita Street, the founder of Women in Animation and former editor and it. I never project that, I just take publisher of Animation Magazine, it straight to the lab which prints each frame two to three times is now a freelance writer based in Los Angeles. [Bond animates at 12 frames per second] and that becomes the 16 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Splendid Artists: Central And East-European Women Animators by Marcin Gizycki n the realm of communist regimes, theory and practice belonged to two different worlds: that of propaganda and that of harsh reality. The first pretended to be the universe of utopia, good will and justice. The second did not masquerade as anything but a patriarchal bureaucratic machine. It was Lenin who stated after the success of the Revolution that, “In the land of the Soviets, every housewife must be able to rule the state.” And it was also Lenin who announced that film was, “the most important of the arts.” According to the logic of this rhetoric, Soviet cinema was supposed to be an oasis for women filmmakers in the male dominated ocean of the world’s film industry. Actually, the beginnings were quite promising. Although women did not play the most prominent roles in the policy making bodies, they were particularly visible in all kinds of artistic activities blossoming in the years after the Revolution. Women painters, like Natalia Goncharova, Olga Rozanova, Lyubov Popova and Varvara Stepanova were I There was no other country where women artists achieved so much in such a short time. Snezny Muz, Petra Fundova (1986) among the leaders of the avantgarde. Poet Marina Tsvetaeva enjoyed a popularity equaled only by Mayakovsky’s. Women filmmakers, Esfir Shub, Lili Brik and Olga Preobrazhenskaya, although working in the shadow of Eisenstein, Pudovkin, Dovzhenko or Vertov, contributed significantly to the Soviet cinema of the 1920s. Too Good to Last Even if men still prevailed in these domains, one can not deny that there was no other country where women artists achieved so much in such a short time. This was too good to last and soon many women shared the fate of the majority of the avant-garde community. There was no longer a place for progressive ideals. Those who did not conform to the requirements of Socialist Real- 17 ism emigrated or spent the rest of their lives in oblivion. Many perished during the witch hunts of the late 1930s and early 1940s. Vera Ermolaeva’s story epitomizes the destiny of thousands of people, men and women, who suffered and died only because they happened to live in the wrong place at the wrong time. An abstract painter, a splendid illustrator and a stage designer, she was also one of the closest allies of Kazimir Malevich in Vitebsk and Petrograd. In 1934, she was arrested and deported because her brother had been involved in “suspect” political circles many years before. A progressive illness, which led to the amputation of her legs, did not persuade the authorities to release her from exile in Siberia, where she eventually died in ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 1938. festivals. in the deeper memory of foreign At the time when this extraorAs to my native country, it is specialists on the subject. A situdinary woman was suffering worth mentioning that a woman ation that can be blamed, at least unspeakably in forced isolation, actually inaugurated experimen- in part, on the male-oriented prosome of her former mates from tal filmmaking in Poland. Fran- motional policies of Film Polski, the defunct avant-garde were ciszka Themerson, together with the state run film agency. And producing countless pictures and her husband Stefan, made seven there were always women posters attributing new roles to short films between 1930 and behind men, writing scripts for men and women in socialist soci- 1945. Among them she co-direct- their husband-directors, helping ety. The representations of the ed The Eye and the Ear, one of the them as art directors, and worknew Soviet woman were mainly most interesting abstract films ing as an army of anonymous confined to one area: agriculture. ever done. (It was actually made aides. A woman on a tractor, with a sick- in England at the end of World The fact is, though, that there le, resting after is no woman mowing, always director in smiling and Poland who happy. Women has gained did not disappear as much entirely from the recognition public life during as the leadthe Stalinist years. ing male aniOne can recall mators: LeniVera Muchina, ca, Kijowicz, Little Giraffe by Teresa Badzian, Poland Szczechura Katharina by Katarzyna Latallo, Poland one of the most prolific producers of idealized por- War II, for the Film Unit of the Pol- or Giersz. Now, the situation is trayals of Soviet people. It was ish Government in exile). even worse, for with the collapse she who sculpted the statue of of the communist regime state the “Worker and Collective Farm Addressing funding for film production has Girl,” which became the trade- Women’s Issues dropped radically. The newly mark of Soviet cinema. But in real It would be unfair to say that born capitalism is not ready yet life gender equality in the film women did not have any chance to support cultural institutions industry no longer existed, not as animators/directors in com- and it is quite possible that it will only under Stalin, but also in the munist Poland. The list of those never do so. As a result, the years to come. Unfortunately, this who made significant films starts auteur form of animation is in is particularly evident in the field with Halina Bielinska (the co- jeopardy. Not a great prospect for of animation. author of an excellent and inno- animators of either gender. The None of the women anima- vative Change of Guard in 1958) outlook for other former comtors in the Soviet Union achieved and ends at Ewa Bibanska, munist countries looks very much the international recognition whose Incomplete Portrait (1982) the same. enjoyed by some outstanding, is one of a very few films that The Czech Republic seems to although not numerous, female directly addresses women’s issues. be doing the best. Among the feature film directors, like Larisa In between, to mention only group of animators who still manShepitko or Kira Muratova. It was some of the most important age to pursue their own ideas are only in recent times that animat- names, are Katarzyna Latallo, an impressive number of women. ed films made by women in Rus- Zofia Oldak, Zofia Oraczewska, In a catalogue of an exhibition of sia (for example Tatyana Alina Maliszewska, Alina Skiba, Czechoslovak animators which Jitkovskaya and Natalia Orlova) and Joanna Zamojdo. None of took place in Prague in 1988, 31 started to appear regularly at film them has imprinted her presence out of 76 active animators listed 18 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE were women. Many of them started their careers in the 1980s, including Lucie Dvorakova, Petra Fundova, Michaela Pavlatova, Milada Sukdolakova, Eva Sykorova, Zuzana Vorlickova, Sarlota Zahradkova and Sarka Zikova. One has to remember, though, that women’s animation has a strong tradition in the Czech and Slovak republics. One of the founders of animated film there after WWII was Hermina Tyrlova, a splendid puppeteer whose international fame would have been much greater, if she did not devote herself entirely to children’s films. May 1996 Soviet Bloc countries, feminist oriented critics in the West are inevitably surprised that so many women directors there do not want to be called feminists, even if they address women’s issues. I might suggest a possible answer to this phenomenon. Sixty odd years of communist propaganda in the Soviet Union (44 in the satellite countries) has led to a certain distrust in words, especially those associated with ideologically charged social the- There is no woman director in Poland who has gained as much recognition as the leading male animators. Expressing Their Attitudes The common attitude in the West that there are no important female directors in Central and Eastern Europe diminishes the role of those splendid artists who, despite obstacles, have made their way into the industry. What is absent, though, is the sort of distinct, personal, almost confessional current within women’s animation, as represented in the U.S. by Susan Pitt, Kathy Rose, Caroline Leaf or Emily Hubley. The reason might be cultural: discussing problems of ones body and soul in public in Slavic countries can embarrassing. Instead, artists prefer to look for ways of expressing their attitudes by more universal metaphors. Finally, when dealing with women’s cinema in the former The Etude From An Album by Michaela Pavlatova ories. Listening to the postulates of the Polish Women’s League, the only legal women’s rights organization under communism, one could get the impression that it did not differ much from the agenda of feminist movements in the West. Representatives of the League were regularly sent to international conferences, where they spoke about the equality of men and 19 women in the socialist world. Their words were not meant to represent reality, but to substitute for it. And they did. The regime was not afraid of big words and it knew how to manipulate them. Borrowing terminology from post-modern discourse, one would say that what the communist regimes did not suffer from was a lack of “grand narrations.” In fact, there were too many of them. At least for intellectuals who subconsciously developed an immune system to fight their omnipotent presence. In the post-modern world of postcommunist societies, the feminist vocabulary sounds to some ears like one of these already known narrations. Do not be bewildered, therefore, when a Russian, or Polish, or Hungarian filmmaker tells you: “I am not a feminist, but ...” They are not lesser artists just because they say this. Sfinga, Lucie Dvorakova (1989) Marcin Gizycki is a Polish art historian, art critic and former Editor-InChief for Animafilm magazine. He has taught at Rhode Island School of Design since 1988. ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Meena and Sara: Two Characters in Search of a Brighter Future for Women by Neill McKee and Christian Clark n Eastern and Southern Africa a young girl figure is about to be born who has the potential to become as well known as Nelson Mandela. Her name is Sara and she was conceived in ten countries. Sara is a cartoon character. She is the product of 20 months of research and development work involving over 150 writers, artists, and researchers from Eritrea and Ethiopia in the Original artwork of North, to the UNICEF’s new Cape of Good character, Sara. in the © UNICEF Hope South. Sara, her friends and family, and the characters and happenings in her community are also the result of discussions with over 5000 people in villages and slums throughout this vast region. It is their insights and reflection which have shaped the adventures of Sara, an adolescent girl between 13 and 15 years of age. Sara has a similar beginning to Meena, a younger girl cartoon character from South Asia. Both projects have been launched by the United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund (UNICEF) with financial contributions from the Government of Norway and I UNICEF committees in United States, Europe and Japan. Meena has been a joint project of UNICEF and Hanna-Barbera Cartoons. Sara is still looking for a corporate partner. UNICEF recognizes the power mass media can have in providing a catalyst for social change. Meena and Sara are examples of an “entereducation” strategy, which seeks to harness the drawing power of popular entertainment to convey educational messages. These initiatives illustrate how creative and exciting stories can be used to promote social issues in an appealing and provocative way. Meena is quickly becoming a household name and a popular film star in South Asia. In December 1995, she was identified by Newsweek magazine as “one of the actors to emerge on the world’s stage in 1996.” Role Models Both Meena and Sara are uplifting role models for girls. They are empowered girl figures who are able to act, to ask questions and seek solutions to the problems which face them and their friends and family. And their problems are many. In South Asia and Africa, there are many customs and traditions which affect the development of female Children. In India, a million fetuses are detected and aborted each year simply because they are female. In both regions there is much more value and attention given to the boy from in the first hour of life and this continues 20 through childhood. The drawing power of popular entertainment can convey educational messages. From a young age the girl must serve male family members, care for younger children, fetch water and firewood, wash the clothes and cook. Her life becomes a “nightmare that never ends.” The girl is often seen as someone who is “just passing through” the household. She will get married and move out whereas it is believed that the boy will support his parents in their old age. As the girl grows, the disparities in treatment and status are compounded. Death rates are higher Meena and her friend Mithu © UNICEF among female children. When sickness strikes, male children will be ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 taken to hospital can be used to sooner, while girls “strike a common have to wait to chord” across a the very last diverse region. moment, which is Common charsometimes too acters, backlate. grounds and stoIn many counries can be found tries, fewer girls Sara and her pet monkey Zingo, shown in a victim situation requiring assistance and protection. which belong to © UNICEF everybody’s enter school and more girls are “pushed out” at an multiple partner relationships all neighborhood. early age. This disadvantage in edu- have contributed to the rapid In creating the series, research cational opportunities also robs the spread of HIV/AIDS. The adolescent revealed the need to remain withgirl of her chance to be a child as girl is two to seven times more like- in the realm of realism in order to school is one of the only places ly to be HIV positive than the ado- maintain a credible message source. where she can socialize and play lescent boy. Therefore, Meena’s parrot, Mithu, with other children and learn essenonly ever repeats what he has Striking a Common Chord tial life skills such as communication, heard and Sara’s pet monkey, This is a negative and depress- Zingo, does not talk. She only mimnegotiation, problem solving and ing picture. While it is possible to ics and gestures in sympathy with conflict resolution. Another aspect is the socializa- present the female child as a victim Sara’s emotions. Both animals are tion process of the young girl in the requiring assistance and protection, extensions of the girls’ egos. They home, school and wider commu- it is more important to recognize can do things which the Meena nity. She acquires a sense of inferi- her potential as a leading agent in and Sara would like to do but ority, resulting in a negative self-con- promoting development. In both which would be disrespectful, for cept. It is reinforced by the way girls the Meena and Sara Communica- a girl to do in Asian or African sociand women are defined in text- tion initiatives, UNICEF decided to ety. Therefore, cultural sensitivity is books and various media. The over- create a role model and set of com- maintained. By steering this fine line all result is a limited perception of mon stories which would provide between reality and fantasy, these her own capabilities and possibili- motivation for a way towards stories remain both relevant and acceptable solutions. ties. exciting to the target audiences. But how can cartoons address They are their stories. What the In many parts of Africa the problem of teenage motherhood is such deep-rooted problems? In research revealed is that the target endemic. Girls are often not yet viewing live action films, people in audiences don’t have a vocabulary ready for motherhood, physically multi-ethnic environments respond for ‘cartoon’ versus “live action.” The or psychologically, and are thrown to cultural and social cues such as Meena and Sara films are viewed out of the educational system. Their dress, facial features, language and as stories on their situations and situation becomes even more wor- accents, housing and vegetation lives, as opposed to the live action rying in the context of the AIDS pan- which may alienate and distract fantasies churned out by Hollydemic, which is hitting both regions them. They may be fascinated by wood or BollyWood. While it is possible to present the female child as a victim, it is more important to recognize her potential as a leading agent in promoting development. harder than any other area of the world. In Eastern and Southern Africa, rape, adolescent pregnancies, female genital mutilation, forced marriage, polygamy and what they see but may miss the main message or conclude that the situations posed are “someone else’s problem.” However, with proper formative research, animated film 21 The Flagship Medium Also, animated film can portray difficult social issues and values in sensitive, non-threatening ways, without losing message impact. The stories and messages provide a “hook” into the culture without alienating or threatening cultural integrity. In addition, animated films can be dubbed and produced in ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE A storyboard session for the UNICEF South African Initiative. © UNICEF many languages at little cost, making them useful across a large population base. In both Meena and Sara initiatives, the animated film is the “flagship” medium through which a set of characters and core set of stories “come to life,” capturing the attention and imagination of audiences and providing a creative focus, However, multi-media dissemination is essential to reach target audiences who often do not have access to television, video or film. A Meena radio series has been broadcast in Asia through the BBC Bangla service and the BBC Africa Service will broadcast a five language Sara series beginning in June 1996. In addition, comic books, story books, audio cassettes, posters, users’ and facilitators’ guides are either available or in planning. However, films and videos have further reach than is often assumed. India has had satellite television with community viewing stations since the 1970s. There are also growing informal channels of video distribution — associations, religious groups and commercial outlets, for example. Videos are shown in public places such as restaurants and bars and “video theaters” are quickly growing in small communities. in some countries there are mobile film or video units owned by private firms or government. Also in the plans for both Meena and Sara is the merchandising of products. In Bangladesh Meena tex- May 1996 tiles, ceramics, dolls, writing products and greeting cards are already being pilot marketed and educational games are planned. Such products have the potential to extend the reach of Sara and Meena images and messages. They also may have a role in fund raising, thereby sustaining the projects, for it is recognized that changing the societal position and view of female children is a long-term endeavor. bulk of the animation to date. South Asian artists and researchers have increased their skills through their involvement. Ram Mohan and the others of the South Asian team - Mira Aghi, the chief researcher in New Delhi; Rachel Carnegie, Meena’s main creative force and former coordinator; Nuzhat Shahzadi, researcher and trainer-disseminator based in Bangladesh - have all contributed to the training of African artists, writers and researchers in the Sara project. And such capacity building remains a major goal of both projects. The Meena and Sara initiatives are two visible bright stars in the African and South Asian girls’ otherwise troubled night sky. They demonstrate how animated film can become a force for social transformation. A First Step Broadcast or video viewing is important in developing awareness and knowledge as a first step to behavioral change information is provided and awareness enhanced. We can also motivate people through entertaining Program formats. However, in the Meena and Sara episodes, an attempt has been made to address all behavioral change factors. The episodes are informative and motivational, through entertaining stories which are based on careful research into traditional and modern values. But they also address the life skills and enabling environment factors which are so often A depiction of the South African picturesque landscape omitted change behavior © UNICEF or bring in children. Finally, both initiatives have Neil McKee is the Senior Program involved a great deal of capacity Communication Officer for UNICEF’s building. The design of the Meena character, character models, back- Eastern and Southern Africa Regional grounds, storyboards and post pro- Office based in Nairobi, Kenya. He is the author of Social Mobilization duction has all been undertaken in and Social Marketing in Developing South Asia under the supervision of Communities. Ram Mohan of Light Box Moving Pictures, Bombay. Light Box has also produced some of the episodes Christian Clark, former Informafrom start to finish-h although tion Officer in UNICEF Somalia, is Hanna Barbera Manila-based stunow the Meena Project Coordinator dio, Fil Cartoons has produced the for UNICEF in Katmandu, Nepal. 22 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Women In Animation: Changing the World: Person by Person, Cel by Cel by Rita Street Rita Street, founder of Women in Animation Marshall Armistead Photography s my friend, veteran animator/producer Sue Kroyer says, “I’m not much of a joiner.” Like Sue, I’ve never been overly fond of organizations which seems rather odd since I founded an International organization three years ago. I’ve also never been overly fond of the socalled Woman’s Movement, which makes my position all the more contradictory since the organization I founded focuses on women’s issues within the industry of animation. Let me explain. To me organizations were only entities to pay dues to and receive newsletters or magazines from. My ideas concerning feminism were even more obtuse. While I was growing up, my mother was busy working a fulltime job and driving three hours A every other night to the nearest university in order to get her master’s degree. My father and his cronies were my life and an overwhelming influence. When Dad said, even jokingly, that the Women’s Movement was great for men, “let the women do all the work,” I agreed. Those silly, silly women, wasn’t housework more appropriate? I grew up thinking like a man, or at least like the old boys club my father belonged to, believing I had the right to do whatever I pleased, whenever I pleased and more power to me. Like a pet that grows up isolated from its own kind, I never realized the term “women” would eventually mean “me.” In the work place, I realized that no matter how smart, how efficient, how dynamic I was, it still took some extra genitals to land a really good salary or job that could provide me with even a modicum of self-respect. To get ahead, I couldn’t act like a man as I once thought I could; I had to think like a woman and work like a woman. Like my mother, I had to drive forever and work myself to death to create even a glimmer of hope for a career. Destroying oneself—paying dues beyond the price of imagination—I found was and is the only acceptable way for a woman to succeed in the workplace. 23 Like a pet that grows up isolated from its own kind, I never realized the term "women" would eventually mean “me.” When I finally landed a job that I really liked, with a boss who respected my abilities (as editor and eventually publisher of Animation Magazine for Terry Thoren), I realized that I still had to kill myself in order to gain respect from the animation community at large. During my three year stint with AniMag, I began to hear other women’s stories, stories of discrimination that were far worse than my own. As I delved into the history of animation I found an industry that typically placed women in low paying, unsatisfying positions that kept their artistic talents bottled up. Female animators were cursed with a very real glass ceiling and female executives, although they had made it up the ladder (mainly due to the fact that there actually are some wonderful men in this area of entertainment with extraordinary foresight), they still had to work harder and longer than most of their male counterparts. On The Brink of Disaster At the same time that I began to understand the basic condi- ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 fax to 40 women and asked them to meet at my house. About 20 women attended, representing all areas of the animation Sari Gennis, Lily Tomlin and John Kricfalusi at a WIA panel on Images of Women in Animation. industry—Sue Kroyer, Lily tion of many women in the pened to be working in. Names industry, I realized that animation of prominent men came to mind, Tomlin (voice over), Libby Simon (producer), Linda Miller (animaitself seemed to be on the brink of to sit on this panel. disaster. At the magazine, I was These men would, of course, tor) Donna Ravitz and Ruth Clamuniquely positioned to see the come up with many great ideas; pett (animation art), Jan Nagel overwhelming amount of activity but after the panel ended and and Jessie Ungerleider (publiciin the industry in 1993. New the audience and press went ty), Maureen Furniss (animation companies were sprouting up all home, would they actually take historian and publisher of Animaover the globe in every genre of action? I doubted that they tion Journal), Becky Bristow (Dean, animation. Animation seemed to would have either the time or the California Institute of the Arts). We be moving in a million different inclination. The only people I sat on my floor, ate cookies and directions at once. knew who would actually “act” discussed whether or not we As a person pondering, I can’t on an “idea”—something not should found the organization take the drain of energy it takes to charted, mapped, graphed, sto- now known as WIA. Of course, go in so many different directions ryboarded, approved, budgeted, the answer to that question was all at once, so how could an sanctified or licensed—were my an overwhelming yes. We also firmly declared that industry? Could animation hold women friends. And thus the up to such a wave of activity next thought, forming what I had this would not be an organizawithout losing valuable momen- never thought to form before— tion driven by feminist blindness. tum? Would such an upswing an organization dedicated to the To help break the glass ceiling in cause an equally dynamic down- needs of women called Women animation for female artists, we swing as it had in the past? I In Animation. Perhaps by work- would embrace the opposite sex decided that this was indeed a ing together, women could make and prove that together we danger. If the animation industry a difference for themselves, for could rise above issues of gender, race and handicaps. We would had no backbone, no spine if you men and for animation. also be an organization dedicatwill to support it, how could it ed to solidifying the world of continue to move forward? Perhaps by working animation. We would study the The idea came to me to hold together, women could past and promote the future. We an industry-wide panel discussion make a difference for would, as Terry Thoren is so fond regarding the future of animathemselves, for men and for animation. of saying, make the world a safer tion. Animation Magazine would place for cartoons! invite industry heads from all over Over the months that folthe world to begin a dialogue lowed, a Steering Committee was about bringing the industry A Safer Place established to guide the organitogether, to support one another for Cartoons no matter what style they hapIn November of 1993, I sent a zation as it moved through the 24 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE difficult path of establishing its non-profit status. Antran Manoogian, president of ASIFAHollywood was approached and together he and his board voted to make WIA a special project of their chapter. That meant that we could receive tax deductible donations before receiving our own non-profit status. It also meant that we had a bank account. (I would like to add here that WIA will always be indebted to ASIFA-Hollywood for all their efforts to help it grow. They continue to support us in every move we make.) A simple mission statement was written defining our goals and a first general meeting was planned. Karen Schmidt (who is now Director of Recruiting and Training for Warner Bros. Feature May 1996 Tools of the Toons Since that time, we have grown enormously. Our general meetings are held four times a year and sponsored by Warner Bros. Feature Animation. (Thanks to both Karen Schmidt and Senior Vice President of Operations, Michael Laney for their support.) These panel discussions have covered diverse topics such as development, computer animation, licensing, production management, writing for animation and the image of the female character in cartoons. We have also expanded to include many different committees that service the needs of the membership and the needs of the industry. The Program Committee, in addition to organizing general meetings here in Los years of animation at each of our general meetings and to begin an oral history program that would preserve the lives and times of these extraordinary individuals. Under Simon’s guidance and because of her hard work, 20 women have now been interviewed on tape and/or on video. These interviews (which continue in both Los Angeles and New York) have been transcribed and will soon be available to researchers through the University of California, Los Angeles Library. The Communications Committee publishes a quarterly newsletter recording the activities of members and the organization as a whole. The Youth & Education Committee, headed by Film Roman’s Phyllis Craig, helps young people make the jump from student to professional a reality by placing them in intern programs at several independent and major studios. The Independent Film Selection Committee is dedicated to providing a forum for the work of independent animaRita Street (2nd from left), CalArts instructor Maureen Selwood, Faith Hubley and Calico's Jan Nagel (on far right) at press preview hosted by WIA and KCET for the Animated Women TV series, along with two KCET representatives. tors and the Public Services Committee is Animation, and who was then at Angeles, has developed a series working to make a difference the Disney) arranged a large screen- of workshops open to the public world over through the art of aniing room for our meeting. Over called the “Tools of the Toons” mation. one hundred women showed up series. The first workshop ran last WIA currently boasts one at Disney Feature Animation for fall and focused on the art of chapter. Founded by the Cartoon our first gathering which con- pitching story ideas. Network’s Director of Programsisted of screenings of new work On the suggestion of Sue ming, Linda Simensky, WIA-NY is by women. We actually had to Kroyer and Libby Simon, a His- extremely active. In the next few turn some women and men torical Committee was organized months, when the non-profit staaway at the door. to honor women from the early tus is received for WIA Interna25 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE tional, Los Angeles will form its own chapter. Other chapters based in major cities around the world will soon follow. No Longer Iffy I have learned a great deal since I started the organization three years ago. I am no longer “iffy” about organizations; I love them. At least... this one. All the women who I have had the opportunity to meet and work with have caused the organization (and myself) to blossom. It has become a thrill of mine to sneak around the outskirts of a crowd bubbling over with enthusiasm during the “networking” portion of a general meeting and hear just how well the organization is working for people. Men and women are open and friendly and thrilled to be finding out what is going on with friends at other companies around town. Members discuss problems and offer insights. There’s even some storytelling from the good ol’ days. It seems that barriers are broken between people the moment they walk in the door. All ages attend. I’ve seen 10 year-olds and 80 year-olds sitting May 1996 in the same row. And all ages learn, think, remember, hope and go home with the urge to create—whether it be a piece of tangible art or something as ephemeral as their own spiritual lives, everyone leaves inspired to do what they have not yet attempted. And that’s what make’s a truly great organization, I’ve found. The people who are a part of it and the dreams that they find they can fulfill. I attribute this attitude of excitement to the many women on both coasts who make up the current Steering Committees and our Advisory Board. They are all women of power, foresight and honor. With individuals like this around me, I find it impossible to believe that I ever scoffed at the importance of women’s rights and women’s issues. Here’s to organizations, women and men, and the future of animation. May all support organizations like this one help it grow into the next century and beyond. And here’s to not being afraid of “joining”—sometimes it’s just a part of a little thing called “growing.” For information about Women In Animation, send email to rpstreet@aol.com or wanki@ aol.com, or write to P.O. Box 17706, Encino, CA 91416, or call (818) 7599596. Painting by Mary Blair, for Disney's Alice in Wonderland, which was displayed at a Name That Toon gallery fundraiser for WIA. © The Walt Disney Company Rita Street, the founder of Women in Animation and former editor and publisher of Animation Magazine, is now a freelance writer based in Los Angeles. REGISTER with Animation World Network TODAY and • Receive our bi-weekly animation News Flash via email • Get announcements of Animation World Network developments • Be a part of the global community of AWN. Interact with animation professionals, scholars and fans all over the world Get all this and more FREE, when you register now! 26 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Women in the Animation Industry—Some Thoughts by Linda Simensky Linda Simensky, The Cartoon Network’s Director of Programming n the animation industry, a professional association called Women In Animation formed in 1993. Men in the business joked, “Where’s the Men In Animation group?,” to which the women replied, “That’s what we call ‘The Animation Industry.’” Actually, there are a lot of women in animation, and their number has been rising. I don’t know that there are statistics that are readily available, but since this is an opinion piece, my opinion is that there are more women than ever working in animation. What is unusual and noteworthy, though, is that there is not an even breakdown of tasks between men and women. This is obvious to the naked eye of anyone visiting an animation studio or network animation department. Just as an entomologist can view the breakdown of gender roles in an ant colony, we can analyze the animation industry the same way. The following are some thoughts—not on the analysis itself—but on why we can analyze the industry that way. First, imagine you were attending a large party for members of I It is also important to look at the motivations of people entering animation. The artisans of the industry (more men than women) tend to enter by first studying animation in school and then simply getting jobs in their chosen field. Some women have taken that path as well, such as director Becky Bristow, currently head of the California Institute of the Arts Character Animation program, and Nancy Beiman, a supervising animator at Disney. But many women, more often than not, tend to “end up” in the industry by one of three different paths, all not all of which involve animation or even an initial interest in the field. The “different path” theory includes the following typical job motivations. Some women are driven by an interest in children’s television, of which animation comprises a large bulk. These people could just as easily end up in Different Paths First, there is the history of the publishing or teaching, where industry. While there have always many began their careers. Geralbeen women in the animation, his- dine Laybourne, formerly president torically the more important jobs of Nickelodeon/Nick at Nite, and have gone to men. This is as much now President of Disney/ABC a function of the eras involved and Cable Networks, initially pursued a career in eduof the history of cation and the business. Just as an entomologist can entered the When you consider that the view the breakdown of gender media industry entire anima- roles in an ant colony, we can with an active tion industry analyze the animation industry interest in chilthe same way. dren’s television. has been Others simaround for less ply aspire to than a century, and that for years women were work in the entertainment industry, systematically relegated to such and have career paths that take “lesser” jobs such as ink and paint, them through the animation women have actually done fairly industry as well as through livewell even getting into any posi- action television and film productions in the industry over the last tion.There are also other career paths that can lead to animation, 20 years. the animation industry. After a round of toasts to, say, Bob Clampett or Shamus Culhane, everyone went off to the lavatories at the same time. The line into the women’s room would be comprised of a large number of network executives, studio management types ranging from producers to production assistants, color and background designers, and perhaps an occasional director. The line into the men’s room would include studio owners, business types, directors, artists, show creators, designers, and a significant number of other animation artists. While this is more of an observation, it has already been established that men and women gravitate to different parts of the industry. There are a couple of theories that are often discussed to support this. 27 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE including the CD-ROM or CGI industries, as well as graphic design and illustration. Oddly enough several translators of Japanese language materials have gone on to careers as animation producers. There are also those who aspire to work in animation but cannot animate. I offer myself as an example of this. People taking this path, which ultimately leads them to animation, often take the same paths noted above, but direct themselves toward animation and are not as interested in the other areas. We need to understand why girls lose interest in watching cartoons. What’s So Funny About Cheese? Whether or not there is a historical precedent for women in the animation industry, there theoretically are no reasons for women not to be in it now. Perhaps the question to ask is, “Why aren’t women as interested in animation as men are?” Maureen Furniss explored this in her article, “What’s So Funny About Cheese? And Other Dilemmas: The Nickelodeon Television Network and Its (Female) Animation Producers,” which can be found in the Spring 1994 issue of Animation Journal. She took a look at the animated shows on Nickelodeon, particularly Doug and The Ren & Stimpy Show, which were created and developed by men, and how the shows’ staffs dealt with Nickelodeon’s management, which was primarily women. Furniss discussed the difference in men and women’s taste in what was funny, and how that shaped the animation they were doing. The article also chronicles the problems and arguments women encountered when opposing humor they saw as gross, inap- May 1996 propriate or obscure. I think, though, to understand this difference in taste, we need to understand why girls lose their interest in watching cartoons; this seems to occur when many reach their early teens, as they become more interested in their personal lives, in music and films, as well as showing that they are “older.” It’s a time when cartoons are associated with their younger selves. I think girls are also driven away by their difference in taste, which involves less interest in watching slapstick, violence and the maleoriented topics of most animated fare. There is a slightly old and out of date theory that girls will watch shows about boys, but boys will not watch shows where the main characters are girls. I disagree, as it seems clear that everyone will watch a clever, well-made show. Nevertheless, this theory, along with the feeling that girls no longer watch cartoons after a certain age, and the need to sell toys, has led to many of the animated programs being made specifically for boys. And then the lack of interest in cartoons by women ultimately led to the lack of women in the industry. Many women who want to enter the animation industry tend either to avoid the more violent sorts of programs, or are in network management where they attempt to mollify the shows. Many, particularly those who wish to create shows, have directed themselves more toward preschool programming or more traditional Disney or Disney-influenced animation. More Room For Self Expression Another aspect of this is that women pursuing careers in the field seem more interested than men in animation as an art form. Thus, it is not surprising that the area of independent filmmaking 28 seems to have more women than men; after all, it is an area of animation which has more room for self-expression and no real traditional hierarchy in which to fit. It seems that as animation becomes more and more popular, a larger number of potential workers and executives will migrate to animation from other fields. This leaves us pondering how the animation industry will change in the future, particularly with regard to women in the industry. Will more women enter the industry, and will they shift over to the more maledominated jobs? Will the financial success of animated films and television shows cause more workers to shift from live action to animation? Will more men supplant women in key positions in children’s television, at the networks and at animation studios, as in the past? Many women tend to “end up” in the industry by different paths, not all of which involve animation. It seems clear that as more programs are made that girls like as well as boys, such as The Simpsons, Doug and Rugrats, there will be more girls who will consider animation as a viable career option. However, if the industry continues to concentrate on animation that will sell toys to boys, the attraction may be less. In the meantime, here is what I would like to see: Female show creators, more female directors, and a funny cartoon with a female lead character. After that, everything would be different. Linda Simensky is Cartoon Network’s Director of Programming. ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Mary Ellen Bute: Seeing Sound by William Moritz Mary Ellen Bute The Museum of Modern Art/Film Stills Archive s with many pioneer animators, Mary Ellen Bute is hardly known today, primarily because her films are not easily available in good prints. This was not always true. During a 25-year period, from 1934 until about 1959, the 11 abstract films she made played in regular movie theaters around the country, usually as the short with a first-run prestige feature, such as Mary of Scotland, The Barretts of Wimpole Street, or Hans Christian Andersen—which means that millions saw her work, many more than most other experimental animators. The diminutive Mary Ellen grew up in Texas, and retained a soft southern accent and genteel demeanor throughout her life. She studied painting in Texas and Philadelphia, but felt frustrated by the inability to wield light in a flowing time- A continuum. She studied stage lighting at Yale in an attempt to gain the technical expertise to create a “color organ” which would allow her to paint with living light—and also haunted the studios of electronic genius Leo Theremin and Thomas Wilfred whose Clavilux instrument projected sensuous streams of soft swirling colors. She was drawn into filmmaking by a collaboration with the musician Joseph Schillinger, who had developed an elaborate theory about musical structure, which reduced all music to a series of mathematical formulae. Schillinger wanted to make a film to prove that his synchronization system worked in illustrating music with visual images, and Mary Ellen undertook the project of animating the visuals. The film was never completed, and a still published with an article by Schillinger in the magazine Experimental Cinema No. 5 (1934) makes it clear why: the intricate image, reminiscent of Kandinsky’s complex paintings, would have taken a single animator years to 29 redraw thousands of times. Mary Ellen continued to use the Schillinger system in her subsequent films, often to their detriment, for Schillinger’s insistence on the mathematics of musical quantities fails to deal with musical qualities, much as John Whitney’s later Digital Harmony theories. Many pieces of music may share exactly the same mathematics quantities, but the qualities that make one of them a memorable classic and another rather ordinary or forgettable involves other nonmathematical factors, such as orchestral tone color, nuance of mood and interpretation. In Mary Ellen’s weakest works, like the 1951 Color Rhapsodie, she is betrayed precisely by this problem, using gaudily-colored, percussive images of fireworks explosions during a soft, sensuous passage—perfectly timed Polka Graph (1952) Mary Ellen Bute Courtesy of William Moritz ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE mathematically, but unsuited to mood and tone color. Egg Beaters, Bracelets and Sparklers Mary Ellen made her own first film, Rhythm in Light, together with Melville Webber, who had collaborated with James Watson on two classic liveaction experimental films, The Fall of the House of Usher (1928) and Lot in Sodom (1933). Webber contributed his experience on those films with making models of paper and cardboard and filming them through such things as mirrors and a cutglass ashtray to get multiple parallel reflections of the shape. The cameraman, Ted Nemeth, who worked commercially on advertising and documentary films, would soon marry Mary Ellen, and worked on all her subsequent films. Rhythm in Light, with black-andwhite images tightly synchronized to “Anitra’s Dance” from Grieg’s music for Peer Gynt, uses not only Webber’s models, but also cellophane, ping-pong balls, egg beaters, bracelets and sparklers to create abstract light forms and shadows. Many of these images are “out of focus” or filmed reflected on a wall for soft nuance and distortion that conceals the origin of the abstract apparition. Mary Ellen made two more similar black-and-white films, Synchromy No. 2 (1936) and Parabola (1938), which also are not exactly animation, nor completely abstract in the sense of Oskar Fischinger’s films. Syn- May 1996 effects created with conventional stage lighting, such as imploding or exploding circles made by rising in or out a spotlight. For the 1940 Spook Sport, Mary Ellen hired Norman McLaren (living in New York before he went to Canada) to draw directly on film strips the “characters” of ghosts, bats, etc., to synchronize with Saint-Saëns’ Danse Macabre. Mary Ellen kept McLaren’s painted originals, and reused some of the images in later films, including Tarantella (1941), Color Rhapsodie (1951) and Polka Graph (1952), where they seem less at home stylistically than in their original conColor Rhapsody (1951) Mary Ellen Bute Courtesy of William Moritz text. Tarantella seems Mary Ellen’s dle slow section provides a satbest film. Using an eccentric isfying closure. In 1931, Universal had run modern composition by Edwin one of Oskar Fischinger’s Stud- Gershefski, Mary Ellen herself ies as a novelty item in their animated most of the imagery, newsreel. Mary Ellen had seen using jagged lines to choreoit, and proposed to Universal graph dissonant scales. Even that they use one of her films the sensuous McLaren interlude in a similar fashion. Since they is not totally out of character. could use only two or three Another of her finest films, Pasminutes, Mary Ellen made a torale (1953), reverts to the techspecial piece, Dada, which Uni- nique of the early black-andwhite films, creating continuous versal distributed in 1936. flows of colored light, swirling in various directions to mime Working in Color Beginning with the 1939 the multiple voices of J.S.Bach’s Escape, Mary Ellen began to work in color, and used more The diminutive Mary Ellen conventional animation for the grew up in Texas, and main themes in the music, but retained a soft southern still combining it with “special accent and genteel effect” backgrounds—somedemeanr throughtout her times swirling liquids, clouds or life. fireworks, other times light chromy No. 2, synchronized to the “Evening Star” aria from Wagner’s Tannhäuser, uses a statue of Venus to represent the star. The effect of constant flowing forms, however, is quite striking, especially in Parabola, which is a bit long at nine minutes, and could well drop the jazzy finale since the lovely mid- 30 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 tube for her films seems somewhat simpler or weaker than the forms McLaren and Hirsh use in their films. But she makes up for the “slinky” look of her main figures by imaginative backgrounds and animation supplements. In the 1954 Abstronic, Mary Ellen uses her own paintings, with a kind of surrealist depth perspective, zooming in and out in rhythmic pulsations synched with the beat of “hoe down” music. In the exciting Spook Sport (1940) Mary Ellen Bute Contrasts Courtesy of William Moritz Mood (1956, incorporating animation from a 1947 film Mood Lyric), she created her Combining most complex collage of aniScience and Art In 1954, Mary Ellen began mation and special effects, using oscilloscope patterns to including a striking sequence of lights refracting create the main “figures” in her colored films. In her publicity, which is through glass bricks in oozing often repeated, she claimed to soft grid patterns. Mary Ellen made two more be the first person to combine “science and art” in this way, commercial shorts, a 1958 Imagand she sold her last two films ination number for the Steve Abstronic (1954) and Mood Con- Allen television show, and a trasts (1956) on their novelty. 1959 commercial for RCA, New Actually, Norman McLaren used Sensations in Sound, both of oscilloscope patterns in 1950 to which are clever, sharply edited generate abstract images for his collages of effects from her preAround is Around, which was vious films. In 1956 she made screened at the Festival of a live-action short The Boy Who Britain in 1951—and described Saw Through and spent the next in technical detail in American decade working on a live-action Cinematographer. Hy Hirsh also feature based on James Joyce’s used oscilloscope imagery in his Finnegan’s Wake. In the 1970s, 1951 Divertissement Rococo in his feminists “rediscovered” Mary 1953 Eneri and Come Closer. The Ellen as a pioneer woman filmsort of shapes that Mary Ellen maker, but by that time many captured from the cathode ray of her abstract films were no Sheep May Safely Graze. The music’s conductor/arranger, Leopold Stokowski, appears at the end superimposed over the abstract images—reminiscent of Fantasia! 31 longer available in good prints, and the original nitrates were dispersed to archives in Wisconsin, Connecticut and New York. She was still, however, celebrated justly for a major achievement in making her films and distributing them herself, against all odds, successfully. Mary Ellen is also quite important as a formative influence on Norman McLaren. The kind of titles Mary Ellen used to preface her films, explaining them to an average audience as a new kind of art linking sight and sound prefigure McLaren’s similar audience— friendly prefaces to his National Film Board experiments. Mary Ellen also proudly announced that she had used combs and collanders and whatever else to make the imagery in her films, encouraging a delight in simplicity and novelty of experimentation. Surely this left its mark on McLaren, too. Mary Ellen Bute Abstract Filmography Synchronization (1934) Collaboration with Joseph Schillinger and Lewis Jacobs [paper or cel animation; lost? incomplete?] Rhythm in Light (1935, b&w, 5 min.) In collaboration with Melville Webber. Music: “Anitra’s Dance” from Grieg’s music for Peer Gynt. Moving models with lighting: “cellophane & ping- ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 rors & lighting. [cel animation] Spook Sport (1940, color, 8 min.) Music: Danse macabre by Saint-Saëns. Cel animation plus McLaren’s drawn-onfilm effects. Abstronic (1954) Mary Ellen Bute The Museum of Modern Art/Film Stills Archive pong balls,” sparklers, egg beaters, bracelets & barber poles, and some drawn animation. Synchromy No. 2 (1936, b&w, 5 min.) Music: “Evening Star” from Wagner’s Tannhäuser, sung by Reinald Werrenrath. Light reflections from cut glass, collander, etc. “Gothic arches, a flowering rod, and stairs recognizable.” Dada (1936) 3-minute short for Universal Newsreel. Parabola (1938, b&w, 9 min.) Music: Création du monde by Darius Milhaud. Based on a sculpture by Rutherford Boyd. Small models and bent rods on a turntable. Escape (1939, color, 5 min.) Music: Toccata in D Minor by J.S. Bach. Comb, cut celluloid, mir- Tarantella (1941, color, 5 min.) Music by Edwin Gerschefski. Drawn animation and cut-outs with light effects, McLaren. Color Rhapsodie (1951, color, 6 min.) Music: Hungarian Rhapsody No. 2 by Liszt. “Paint on glass, fireworks,” animation, fireworks and clouds optically colored. Polka Graph (1952, color, 5 min.) Music: “Polka” from The Age of Gold by Shostakovich. Cel animation over graph pattern, using Schillinger system. cutouts and cellophane layered. Pastorale (1953, color, 8 min.) Music: Sheep May Safely Graze by J.S. Bach. “Kaleidoscope of ever-changing shapes, colors, forms, vapors, illuminations and mobile perspectives.” Abstronic (1954, color, 7 min.) Music: “Hoe Down” from Billy the Kid by Aaron Copeland and 32 “Ranch House Party” by Don Gillis. Oscilloscope patterns over drawn backgrounds. Mood Contrasts (1956, color, 7 min.) Music: “Hymn to the Sun” from The Golden Cockerel and “Dance of the Tumblers” from The Snow Maiden by Rimsky-Korsakov. Oscilloscope over backgrounds, including colored liquids, clouds, and grids of colored light shot through glass bricks or cut-glass plate. Imagination (1958, color, 3 min.) Collage of effects from earlier films. [Abstract bit for Steve Allen] RCA: New Sensations in Sound (1959, color, 3 min) Commercial. Collage of effects from previous films. William Mortiz teaches Animation History at Cal Arts, and has widely published articles on Animators. He has also made dozens of films, and received an American Film Institute Grant to complete a half-hour animation film All My Lost Lovers. ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Claire Parker, An Appreciation by Giannalberto Bendazzi lexandre (“Alosha”) Alexeïeff and Claire Parker (A Night on Bald Mountain [1933], The Nose [1963], Pictures at an Exhibition [1972], etc.), loved to introduce themselves as “the artist and the animator,” i.e., he was the one who created the images and she choreographed them. I knew them both for the last 11 years of their life together; and although I became very close friends, I still feel it is almost impossible to know which of them did what. Their working relationship was very much like their personal relationship: happy, loving, creative and, above all else, inextricably linked. I witnessed Alosha (a nickname based on his family name, not his first name) proposing certain movements to Claire, which she faithfully executed; and I saw her discussing (and, on that occasion, rejecting) the development of a scene he had conceived. A 90 years ago, on August 31, and died in Paris on October 3, 1981. Her family was rich, prominent and cultivated, and did not discriminate against her because she was a woman. Claire had the freedom to travel anywhere, read The Nose (1963) by Alexandre Alexeïeff and Claire Parker Courtesy of Cecile Starr what she wanted and associate with who she liked. (As a Discreet Yes, Shy No In fact, she always main- teenager, her father decided tained that, “Between us, he’s to introduce her to the perils the genius.” I know that she of whiskey and got drunk.) In did not say this out of either her twenties, like many other love or because she was shy. American artists, writers and Although she loved Alosha intellectuals of her generation, very much, she was also very she left for Paris. In Paris, she had the urge frank; and she certainly wasn’t shy. (Discreet, yes; shy, no.) to create, but didn’t know But Alosha’s genius could not exactly what to do. Her curhave been expressed without rent beau , a Mexican lawyer Claire. For it was she who also living in Paris, gave her allowed his creativity to flour- some books illustrated by a ish. Initially, in a very practical Monsieur Alexeïeff. She was way with money, and later giv- immediately struck by these ing him energy, confidence illustrations and promptly wrote to the publisher asking and inspiration. Claire Parker was born in to meet the artist, so she could Boston, Massachusetts, nearly study with him. “I figured I 33 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE would meet an old, dignified man with a white beard,” Claire recalled with a giggle, “but [instead] I saw this tall, brown, handsome, aristocratic 30 year old guy. Our first lesson ended on the banks of the Seine, hand in hand; and there was never a second one.” Gravures Animées Claire was wealthy, while Alosha, a Russian émigré, was not; so, she decided to invest May 1996 registered under her name, and that the film, like all the later ones, was signed by both. Claire always maintained that the films she was most responsible for were the advertising shorts they made between 1935 and 1940 using various techniques, but not the pinscreen She directed these films, while Alosha created the images and their collaborator Etienne Raik animated them. (It is less clear what Although she loved Alosha very much, she was also very frank; and she certainly wasn’t shy. the contribution of Alexandra de Grinevsky, Alexeïeff’s former wife and the fourth member of the production team, actually was.) Many of these films still exist and what is most striking about them is the way they express the joys of color; this may seem strange from a pair of filmmakers who preferred to work in black and white. Alosha didn’t like color in films, although he pioneered it in the engravings he did for boThe Nose (1963) oks. He said by Alexandre Alexeïeff and Claire Parker Courtesy of Cecile Starr he found it her money into the building of the pinscreen he conceived for creating gravures animées (animated engravings), and into the first film made with it: A Night on Bald Mountain, based on Mussorgsky’s tone poem. It should be noted that the patent for the pinscreen was 34 too decorative and it was Claire who best exploited the language of chromatism. Claire, who spoke perfect French (though with an American accent), mastered Russian well enough to read Dostoevski aloud for the delight of her husband when he was sick. She knew the Russian classics almost by heart. Thus, it is not surprising that she was able to relate so closely to Alosha so closely when making films such films as The Nose (from Gogol), Paintings at an Exhibition and Three Themes (both from Mussorgsky). Claire Parker was a cultivated, intelligent and scholarly; but she was always, incredibly, charmingly sensitive and even candid. When I asked her to name her favorite films of all time, she immediately said, “The ones with Tom Mix and his beautiful white horse!” Giannalberto Bendazzi is a Milan-based film historian and critic whose own history of animation, Cartoons: One Hundred Years of Cinema Animation, was published in the US by Indiana University Press and in the UK by John Libbey. His other books on animation include Topoline e poi (1978), Due voite l’oceana (1983) and Il movimento creato (1993, with Guido Michelone). ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Peaches N’ Dreams: Henry Selick’s James And The Giant Peach by Wendy Jackson “It was a tiny seed of an idea. I walked around it, looked at it, and sniffed it for a long time.” —Roald Dahl efore being adapted to the screen, Roald Dahl’s children’s book, James and the Giant Peach captured the imagination of several generations of readers since it was first published in 1961. James is the story of an orphaned boy and his dream of going to New York City, “the place where dreams come true,” his parents told him, before they were eaten by a wild rhinoceros. With the help of some magic crocodile tongues, the lonely little boy’s dream turns into a fantastic adventure when he crawls inside a giant peach inhabited by a family of anthropomorphised insects. Obviously, this is not your typical Hollywood story, even for an animated film. Dahl’s writing is, by its nature, essentially macabre and outrageous—which is also what makes it so delicious; in this, it is much like the early (pre-Nightmare Before B Christmas) films of director Henry Selick, who has now brought Dahl’s film to the screen. Roald Dahl turned down several movie offers for the book over the years, because he felt that it would be nearly impossible to translate the story into film. But when the late author’s widow, Felicity, was approached by Selick, she was so impressed with his accomplishments in animation that she offered him the opportunity to adapt the story for the screen. Director Henry Selick and the Giant Peach. © Walt Disney Pictures 35 It lacks the saccharin sweetness and gushy romantic subplots one comes to expect in Disney films. From his training at CalArts and beginnings at Disney, to his years producing award-winning commercials and MTV station ID’s, Selick has developed an unparalleled imaginative style, making him one of the most innovative directors working in the animation industry today. As a fan of both artists’ work, I was pleased with Selick’s adaptation, which lacks the saccharin sweetness, unrealistic smarminess or gushy romantic subplots one comes to expect (and dread) in Disney films. Karey Kirkpatrick, who co-authored the screenplay, noted that, “One of the big challenges in writing the script was to stay true to the book while giving it the stronger emotional drive that it needed to work as a film.” There are, of course, the usual moral fibers woven into the story, mostly in the heartwarming but unnecessary musical score; but even the songs are tastefully and appropri- ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE ately incorporated into the overall plot. The team that brought Dahl’s story to life on the screen have produced a virtually seamless blend of stop-motion animation, computer-generated imagery (CGI) and live-action. Selick put together quite a crew, including several talented artists from the Nightmare Before Christmas production team, such as Animation Supervisor Paul Berry, as well as contributors with experience in other areas, such as Visual Effects Supervisor Nancy St. John(Babe). Peach’s visual sophistication and level of technical finesse far surpasses that of Nightmare, proof that Selick has molded a production company that has finally found its voice. In developing the film’s striking visual style, Selick turned to illustrator Lane Smith, creator of such acclaimed children’s books as Math Curse, The True Story of the Three Little Pigs, and the wonderfully wacky The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales. Selick, who had long wanted to work with Smith, describes his style as “glowing James and the spider. © Walt Disney Pictures May 1996 paintings that are just wonderful the animated world. We wanted and filled with lots of mystery and the live-action world to be much style. His work looks like a cousin more monochromatic and the aniof my own, only a little sweeter.” mated sequences to be rich in satSmith, a long-time fan of Dahl’s urated color and much more writing, recalls that, “Contractual- expansive in feel.” Jessup did a ly, I was only supposed to do 20 notable job of marrying the two inspirational paintings and worlds by adding a sense of the designs, but I ended up doing 50. surreal to the live-action using It was also supposed to be just a forced-perspective sets, and a 6-month job, but I stayed on for a sense of the hyperreal to the anicouple of years just because it was mated sequences through the use really fun.” Smith’s first experience of computer-generated effects. working on a big screen film “We made a decision early on,” seems to have been a positive one Selick recalls, “that we would start for him, as he is finally consider- our film in a very stylized and ing developing The Stinky Cheese Man as an animated film. The inspirational paintings Smith created for the film have been published in a Disney “storybook version” of the book, and it’s worthwhile buying it just to see The shark attack scene in James and The Giant Peach Smith’s fantastic artistry. Dahl’s © Walt Disney Pictures family was so pleased with Smith’s inspirational artwork that muted live-action world that they commissioned a set of illus- would look almost like a stage play trations for a new edition of the or an opera set. That way, when original novel, wholly different we entered the world of animathan those used for the film. tion, it would be more magical. Lately, there has been a grow- By saving animation for when ing trend of feature films combin- James enters the peach, it adds to ing animation and live-action. The the strength of the fantasy.” challenge they all face is how to One of the film’s most impresbring about a unity of design. sive scenes is when James faces Harley Jessup, Peach’s production his ultimate fear—a terrifically terdesigner, notes that, “A big issue in rifying and huge rhinoceros— terms of production design was emerging from the clouds towards how to blend and relate the live- him. In the book, the rhinoceros action beginning and end with situation is inherently nonsensical 36 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE to begin with, and the seriousness with which they represented it in the film embraced its delightful ridiculousness. This scene was actually produced in a relatively old-fashioned manner, with an underwater puppet, cloud tanks and cel animated lightning effects. The shark scene, however, seems rather gratuitous. What happened to the school of real sharks described in the book? Although technically impressive, the gigantic computer-generated mechanical monster (i.e., shark) seems to be more of a drastically out of place World War II metaphor than an integral part of the story. It is a pretty long scene, and after awhile I found myself seeing the shark as a visual metaphor for the overbearing technology which is replacing traditional, organic techniques of animation. Peaches N’ Dreams On the other hand, the sequence following the scene where James is tucked into a web bed by Miss Spider after a rowdy round of peach-eating and singing is something else. You know what they say about how eating before bed affects your dreams? Well, don’t blink, because what follows should make all animation fans start eating peaches at bedtime. The dream sequence is a daringly experimental 30 second mini-masterpiece that employs two-dimensional cutout anima- May 1996 tion, much in the manner of Selick’s Slow Bob In The Lower Dimensions (1990) done for MTV. Another instance of Selick’s unique visual style is reserved for the die-hard credit-watchers. At film will be yet another marriage of live-action, stop-motion and CGI. Production on Toots will start next summer, and in the interim, Twitching Image animators are The delightful insects in James and The Giant Peach © Walt Disney Pictures credit’s end, there’s a brief but clever sequence in the style of his freakish MTV Top of the Hour spots. It features “Spike the Aunts,” an 18th century-style mechanical toy which plays revenge on James’ wicked aunts. A thoroughly delightful sequence, obviously created just for the fun of it, but representative of the charm and brio that characterizes the whole film. What’s next for Selick and his team of talents? As part of a threepicture deal with Miramax, Selick’s San Francisco based production company, Twitching Image will create a movie version of another unusual children’s book, Toots and the Upside-Down House by Carol Hughes. In development now, the 37 being provided with finishing funds to complete a handful of animated shorts. Finally, a studio that realizes the value of fostering the talent and imagination of its’ individual contributors. Henry Selick understands this concept well; after all, his own creative inspirations are rooted in the films he produced independently. Wendy Jackson is a Sales Representative for Animation World Network. Previously employed as General Manager of the International Animated Film Society’s Los Angeles chapter (ASIFA-Hollywood), she coordinated events such as the 1995 Annie Awards and the 1996 Animation Opportunities Expo. ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 All Dogs Go To Heaven 2 by Frankie Kowalski nlike most sequels, All Dogs Go to Heaven 2 , directed by Paul Sabella and Larry Lerker, is clearly better than the 1989 Don Bluth original. This tale of how Charlie Barkin (voiced by Charlie Sheen) gets to go back to earth to retrieve Gabriel’s horn, has considerably more substance, is certainly more comprehensible and the art direction of Deane Taylor really captures the essence of San Francisco. Yet, despite its virtues, it suffers from a problem endemic to many studios trying to cope with a worldwide shortage of animation artists while working with small budgets and having big “Disney dreams.” All Dogs Go to Heaven 2 begins with our scoundrel Charlie totally bored with heaven’s nothingness and yearning for earthly adventure. Fallen Angel Carface (Ernest Borgnine) steals Gabriel’s Horn (without it the gates of heaven can’t open) and becomes a sidekick to Satan’s helper, Red-a cat (George Hearn). So Charlie and Itchy (Dom DeLuise) go back to earth to rescue the horn as well U as befriending an 8-year old runaway boy, David (Adam Wylie). Charlie is also charmed by a sassy Irish setter Sasha La Fleur (Sheena Easton) who follows along as if she were his Many studios are trying to cope with a worldwide shortage of animation artists while working with small budgets and having big “Disney Dreams”. alter-ego. Charlie rediscovers, through this mischance adventure, his compassionate soul and in the end he prevails over evil. Writer-producers Mark Young and Kelly Ward should be commended for giving the story considerably more validity the second time around for the original characters Charlie Barkin, Itchy, Carface and Annabelle (Bebe Neuwirth). The film’s songs by Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil revealed more about the characters as well. My favorite song was “Count Me Out” performed by saavy Sasha (Sheena Easton), as she Andy sings in the streets of San Francisco with his new pals, Charlie B a r k i n , I t c h y, a n d S a s h a i n A l l D o g s G o T o H e a v e n 2 . © MGM/UA 38 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE makes her entrance in a canine dive. The original film seemed to have suffered both from Bluth’s inability to tell a story and a rampant perfectionism that often ends up making his films more confusing than not. For instance, if you sawAll Dogs Go To Heaven, I think you have a good idea of what I’m talking about. Scenes seemed to have been added and/or taken out without any explanation. For example, the girl wins lots of money gambling with Charlie and Itchy and buys all new sets of clothes; then, in the very next scene she still has her rags on... I just don’t get it??? All Dogs Go To Heaven 2 does display inconsistencies of a different sort. This time, as a result of what sometimes occurs when dealing with multiple studios around the world. At least that’s the only way I can explain why characters went from opaque to transparent and back again within the scene; or why the colors would be bright and vivid in one shot, only to become overcast in the next! I’m sorry to say that I walked out of the theater almost thinking I needed new glasses—and I am already very nearsighted. I guess the only saving grace during this task was that they used my favorite color purple throughout the movie. Perhaps a good part of the problem stems from the fact that their main studio, Screen Animation Ireland (Don Bluth’s May 1996 old studio in Dublin), went out of business and could not finish the film. As a result, MGM had to do much more subcontracting than anticipated. The worse part was that this happened towards the end of production, when about 90% of the film had already been animated. Trying to finish a film under these circumstances, given the tight labor market and the worldwide boom in animation, was probably something of a nightmare. It is for these reasons, among others, that the Hollywood majors have invested so heavily in building their own inhouse studios, where they can control every aspect of the production process—despite the extra costs involved. MGM, which started its modest animation division only a few years, is still recovering from its receivership by Credit Lyonnais. Despite all of its dilemmas, it’s nice that MGM Animation has entered the feature film emporium and won’t be discouraged from further attempts at theatrical films. Your Ad Could Be Here! For rate cards and additional information about various opportunities for exposure at Animation World Network, contact our Los Angeles office at 213.468.2554 or e-mail any of our sales representatives: North America: Wendy Jackson wendyj@awn.com Europe: Vincent Ferri vincent@awn.com Frankie Kowalski is Associate Editor of Animation World Magazine and is a regular contributor to ASIFAHollywood’s newsletter The Inbetweener. 39 Asia: Bruce Teitelbaum bruce@awn.com ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Cartoons On The Bay by Giannalberto Bendazzi artoons on the Bay—The International Festival of Animation: Films, TV Series and Fairy Tales is the English name of an Italian international festival held April 15-18 in Amalfi, Italy. The city itself is a tiny, beautiful and colorful town on the Mediterranean coast 60 km south of Naples. It was the festival’s first edition and it’s artistic director, Alfio Bastiancich ( a young veteran of animation festivals and animation scholarship), has pointed out the novelty of its focus. “There is no other festival like this,” he told The Hollywood Reporter, “since the other festivals, like Annecy, Ottawa and Hiroshima, focus their attention on auteur films, and not so much on individual TV production.” Which actually is the point, since high quality animated entertainment for television is the great novelty of today’s global market, as opposed to the situation of just 5-6 years ago, when basically only two forms of animation existed (besides commercials): auteur films and TV series. Giampaolo Sodano, SACIS’ Chairman, added: “With animation occupying 20% of the audiovisual market and becoming a growing trend, as of yet there had never been a festival that analyzed and rewarded the very best in TV cartoons.” Sodano was the big muscle behind the festival; his company is the distribution branch of the government-owned Italian C broadcaster RAI, and his decision in favor of animation shows a strong determination to get involved with it—finally, after 30 years of absentmindedness. Pulcinella, Pulcinella ... There were 56 films in competition representing 14 countries; 52 more were screened in the out of competition Showcase section. The Golden Pulcinella for Best Character was awarded to Italy’s Franceso Tullio Altan for Pimpa (a naive red spotted dog, created 20 years ago for a comic strip aimed at children; the 1995 pilot for a TV series is directed by Enzo D’Alò). The other Golden Pulcinella went to France’s Fantôme Animation (Renato and Georges Lacroix) for their 1995 series Insektors, as Best Programme All Round. It is a 26 x 13’ series using 3-D computer animation, that was honored “for its technical innovation in computer graphics, for the beauty of its images, for its rhythm and editing, for its sense of humor, for the quality of its soundtrack and for the originality of the characters.” High quality animated entertainment for television is the great novelty of today’s global market. The Silver Pulcinella for the Best Programme for Infants went to France Animation (Jean-Luc Morel, Daniel Orgeval) for The Babalous, 40 a 65 x 5’ Franco-Canadian series. The Silver Pulcinella for the Best Children’s Programme (6-12 Years) went to Ralph Hibbert Entertainment (Graham Ralph, James Stevenson) for The Forgotten Toys. This was a 25 minute British TV special that was, to this writer’s taste, actually the best film of the festival, masterfully crafted, tender, sensitive, very well written and very well designed. The Silver Pulcinella for the Best Programme for Adolescents went to France Animation (Pascal Morelli) for Nighthood, a 26 x 26’ series starring the classic feuilleton character Arsène Lupin. The Silver Pulcinella for the best program for adults went to Klasky Csupo (Eva Almos) for Duckman, the 13 x 24’ American series. The Silver Pulcinella for Best Family Programme went to Bruno Bozzetto Productions (Bruno Bozzetto) for the Spaghetti Family pilot, a humorous description of everyday life in a typical Italian family of today. ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE Special awards were given for graphics, to Japan’s Four Seasons of Pepperon (a TV special produced by NHK Educational corporation and directed by Mitsumosa Anno); for animation to the UK’s The Tale of the Flopsy Bunnies and Mrs. Tittle Mouse (a special produced by TV Cartoons Ltd. and directed by Dave Unwin from a tale by Beatrix Potter); for background scenery to Belarus’ Home Sweet Home (a pilot produced by Validia and directed by Vitaly Bakunovic and Susan Sivachov). The Fairy Tales section showed previews of the forthcoming Disney extravaganza, The Hunchback of Notre Dame (exciting, as usual), an upcoming Italian feature,The Blue Arrow, directed by Enzo D’Alò and designed by Palolo Cardoni (a very promising film for children, with nice drawings and a very good music score by Paolo Conte), and a cinematic version of Prokofieff’s Peter and the Wolf, directed and produced by George Daugherty, with characters designed and created by Chuck Jones (a little disappointing). Children and Violence During the festival, a UNESCO sponsored conference about children and violence was held. At the end, some guidelines were issued, aimed not at limiting creativity, but “to be a challenge to find new ways of telling stories, catch adventures and portray a May 1996 character.” Among these guidelines: plot conflicts should find a positive solution in each episode of a series; conflicts and violence should be expressed in a hum- orous and playful way; animated cartoons for small children should avoid, as much as possible, any violence—physical or psychological, explicit or implicit; violence, if present, should be justified by the plot; violence shouldn’t be presented as a viable solution for a problem. It is true that virtually each and every educator in Europe is currently complaining about violence on television, and that it is going to be rejected in almost all children’s programs. This could be a problem in global markets, as there are actual differences among audiences. Stanford Blum, President and CEO of the US-based Imagination Factory, explains that, “In Europe, they don’t want violence. In Japan, it’s key. You either have to do one type of show or the other.” 41 Last but not least, Amalfi brought out some good news about Italian animation. As I noted above, SACIS and RAI are getting more and more involved with animation production and distribution. Giuseppe Laganà is already at work on a series based upon the popular Italian comic book star, Lupo Alberto (Albert the Wolf); pilots have been commissioned from Laganà Insektors (Arturo and © Fantome Malik), Bruno Bozetto (The Spaghetti Family), Maurizio Forestieri (The House of Decius), Enzo D’Alò and Paolo Zaniboni (Steam Rail), Pier Luigi De Mas (Goose Pimples), Guido Manuli (Gno Gno and Go Duck); Manuli is also working on a project for a comedy-horror feature film. It is a great start for a broadcaster that had scorned Italian animation for 30 years—and for an industry that has suffered for too long from a lack of a home market. ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Cartoons On The Bay per Giannalberto Bendazzi artoons on the Bay è il titolo inglese di un festival italianissimo, ma tutto orientato a un grande mercato planetario: quello del disegno animato televisivo di qualità, novità strutturale destinata a scrivere (come del resto già sta facendo) un capitolo totalmente nuovo della storia del cinema d’animazione. Al festival diretto da Alfio Bastiancich, che si è svolto nell’ammirevole cornice della baia di Amalfi e che era alla sua prima edizione, partecipavano 56 opere in concorso, selezionate tra fiabe, special ed episodi di serie, in rappresentanza di 14 nazioni. Vincitori con il Pulcinella d’oro sono risultata l’italiano Francesco Tullio Altan per il miglior personaggio (Nuove aventure della Pimpa, 1995, serie diretta da Enzo D’Alò) e i francesi Renato e Georges Lacroix per la serie in computer animation Insektors (1995). Fra i diversi Pulcinella d’argento spiccano il nostro Bruno Bozetto con il “pilota” della serie La famiglia Spaghetti (una saga ironicorealistica sulle disavventure quotidiane di una famiglia media italiana), il britannico Graham Ralph con il sottile e delicato special The Forgotten Toys (un orsac-chiotto C e una bambola gettati via cercano una nuova vita e nuovi padroncini), l’americana Eva Almos con la serie Duckman, di grande inventiva sia nelle immagini sia nei testi, destinata eminentemente agli adulti. La sezione “fiabe” ha offerto l’anticipazione del nuovo musical della Disney, Il gobbo di Notre Dame e il non meno promettente assaggio del lungometraggio italiano La freccia azzurra, tratto da un racconto di Gianni Rodari e diretto da Enzo D’Alò su disegni (ottimi) di Paolo Cardoni e musiche di Paolo Conte (produzione Laterna Magica di Torino). Si diceva della novità rappresentata dal disegno animato televisivo di qualità. La globalizzazione dei mercati ha fatto si che negli ultimi quattro-cinque anni il prodotto cinetelevisivo sia stato realizzato non più per un pubblico limitato, “nazionale”, ma piuttosto pensando a spettatori statunitensi, europei, asiatici, latinoamericani contemporaneamente. A sorpresa, questo allargarsi dell’audience non ha portato a un abbassamento del denominatore comune qualitativo, ma esattamente al contrario: a una riqualificazione continua del lavoro, tanto da creare una sempre più dirompente “terza via” fra l’animazione d’autore e quella commerciale. L’esempio più significativo ne è probabilmente il progetto “What a Cartoon” della Hanna-Barbera, che ha portato alla realizzazione di brevi opere uniche degne dei grandi classici americani dei Tex Avery, Chuck Jones, Friz Fre42 leng. Cartoons on the Bay ha capito il fenomeno ed è stato la prima manifestazione al mondo a testimoniarlo. L’altra grande notizia proveniente da Amalfi riguarda il nostro Paese. Dopo decenni di trascuratezza, la RAI e la Sacis si stanno oggi impegnando massicciamente e direttamente nella produzione di film d’animazione italiani (di fatto, questo è stato un festival “della” Sacis e del suo presidente Giampaolo Sodano, ed è valso come testimonianza di una scelta di campo). Sono già completati o sono in corso di realizzazione porgetti di Bozzetto, Manuli, Laganà, De Mas; molti altri sono in fase di elaborazione, con un occhio di riguardo per gli autori-prouttori giovani. Per il momento i dirigenti di viale Mazzini parlano esclusivamente di opere per ragazzi, e battono anzi molto su questo tasto (sul quale la conorrenza Finivest è piuttosto sguarnita). A precisa domanda, hanno manifestato l’intenzionne di indirizzarsi in un secondo tempo volontà, e zittendo il pessimismo della ragione, questo potrebbe essere l’inizio di una nuova era per la storia della nostra produzione. ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Women always have plenty to pack!! compiled by Frankie Kowalski Cecile Starr's top 9 picks if stranded on a desert island... "I've been lucky enough to know all the mentioned animators in person except one (Morse), and to count one of them (Parker) among my close friends. Their films reflect a wide range of subjects and techniques—from abstract to sexual, from hand drawn to electronic. By and large each is one-of-a-kind, and each one sparkles even after many screenings. Some of the films reflect the femaleness of their creators, and some reflect the creativeness of females. I would be proud to have made any one of them." 1. Galatea (1935) silhouette cut-out animation by Lotte Reiniger 2. Night On Bald Mountain (1933) Alexander Alexeieff and Claire Parker 3. Dwightiana (1959) stop-motion with baubles and doodads, Aleksandra Korejwo's top 10 picks by Marie Menke 4. Abstronic (1952) by Mary Ellen Bute 5. The Owl Who Married The Goose (1974) sand animation by Caroline Leaf 6. Improvization (1977) video animation of dance Kei Takei, by Doris Chase 7. Tub Film (1972) minimual line drawing by Mary Beams 8. Charleston Home Movie (1980) rotoscoping with feeling, by Deanne Morse 9. Permanent Wave (1969) optical printing with passion, by Anita Thacher 43 "I think salt corresponds with sand from the desert as well." 1. Alice in Wonderland by Walt Disney 2. One film from the Nick Park collection—Just for laughing 3. One film from Faith Hubley collection--It is the colored music for my eyes 4. The Subject of the Picture by George Schwitzgebel—To remember good painting 5. In the Time of Angels by David Anderson—For my romantic soul 6. Adagio Cantabilo by Tomaso Albinioni 7. Diver timento KV13 Presto by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart 8. The Flight of the Bumble Bee by Nikolai RimskiKorsakov 9. The Swan —For contemplation 10. Hallelujah—For joy ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Artwork by Joanna Priestley Linda Simensky's 10 picks "If I were packing films for a desert island, I'd probably have to figure out a way to sneak an extra 50 films to the island. I'd also want a healthy dose of the work of independent women filmmakers, including Sally Cruikshank, Joanna Priestley, Michaela Pavlatova, Jane Aaron and Allison Snowden." 1. The Cat Came Back by Cordell Barker 2. Screwy Truant by Tex Avery 3. Broken Down Film by Osamu Tezuka 4. The Tender Tale of Cinderella Penguin by Janet Perlman 5. Duck Amuck by Chuck Jones 6. Hair-Raising Hare by Chuck Jones (or any other of about 25 Bugs Bunny cartoons) 7. Drawn From Memory by Paul Fierlinger 8. Lava Lava by Federico Vitali 9. Day-O by Susan Brand 10.Pictures from Memory by Nedjeljko Dragic Nicole Salomon's 10 top picks 1. Damon the Mower by George Dunning 2. Windy Day by Faith and John Hubley 3. Une Bombe par Harard by Jean-François Laguionie 4. Tableaux d'une Exposition by Claire Parker and Alexandre Alexeieff 5. The Big Snit by Richard Condic 6. Pulcinella by Emanuelle Luzzati & Giulio Gianini 7. To Shoot without Shooting by Kihachiro Kawamoto 8. Kama Sutra Rides Again by Bob Godfrey (when cheering up is necessary) 9. Three Monks by Ada 10. The Lion and the Song by Bretislav Pojar And finally, my top 10 picks if stranded on a desert island--including plenty of sunscreen and (Snapple) mango iced tea... 1. Fantasia by Walt Disney 2. Pink Floyd The Wall by Roger Waters, Gerald Scarfe and Alan Parker 3. The Lady and the Tramp by Walt Disney 4. The entire works of Aardman Animations 5. Anything Max & Dave Fleischer ever made,especially the bouncing ball Sing-A-Longs with Ethel Merman 6. Girls Night Out by Joanna Quinn 7. Chitty Chitty Bang Bang by Ken Hughes (United Artists) 8. The Beany and Cecil Show animated series by Bob Clampett 9. Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer by Rankin-Bass Studios 10.How the Grinch Stole Christmas by Chuck Jones Frankie Kowalski is Associate Editor of Animation World Magazine and is a regular contributor to ASIFAHollywood’s newsletter The Inbetweener. 44 ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE Saul Bass, Animator, Graphic Designer and Filmmaker, Dies. Bass, who revolutionized the design and production of feature film credits with his innovative design and animation concepts died April 25, in Los Angeles, at the age of 75. His early work on such Otto Preminger films as Carmen Jones andThe Man With the Golden Arm caused a sensation in their day and opened the market for production of extended animated title sequences in theatrical films. In 1961, he married Elaine Bakatura, who became his collaborator on a number of projects, including several awardwinning shorts. Colossal Gives Up on Commercials, Refocuses Efforts on "Content." After 20 years as a full-service commercial house, Colossal Pictures announced that it "focus to content development for television, feature films and new media--as well as context and identity design for TV, interactive navigators, web sites and location-based entertainment." Concurrently, Gary Gutierrez, a cofounder with Drew Takahashi of Colossal, announced his departure from the company. The announcement was the latest in a number of changes from the San Franciscobased studio, ranging from development deals with companies May 1996 like Walt Disney Television Animation to a major investment in Colossal by software publisher Quark; Gutierrez’ departure is also the most dramatic of recent staff changes reflecting the turmoil the company has been going through in recent months. The announcement that it was getting out of the commercial business was startling, to say the least, as it ranked as one of the top five commercial houses in the United States, and will lead to substantial layoffs from one of the Bay Area’s largest studios. Universal Family Entertainment and Universal Cartoon Studios have been folded into MCA Television Entertainment (MTE). In a move to streamline and consolidate its television operations, Bar-bara Fisher, President of MTE, will now add oversight of all family entertainment activities to her current responsibilities. As part of the reorganization, current UFE President Jeff Segal has entered into a production deal with the MCA Television Group and will continue to develop and projects for the company. Cambridge Animation Systems Debuts Animo V2 and Announces Software’s Availability on Windows NT. The latest upgrade to one of the leading digital ink-and-paint software systems was recently announced. The new version is said to include a new architecture 45 for greater production speed and flexibility, a new user interface, a computerized version of the “Xsheet,” an open system architecture that allows users to integrate a wide range of software into the production environment, and a new interactive PencilTester module. In addition, Cambridge announced that it will be shipping a Windows NT version of its Animo software later this year. DreamWorks Feature Animation at work on El Dorado. Dylan Kohler, co-head of DreamWorks' technology department states that they hope to start principal production on El Dorado by the middle of next year. The company is already in production on its first animated feature, The Prince of Egypt, and is involved with an as yet untitled feature being done by Pacific Data Images, which DreamWorks recently bought a 40% stake in. It is also in development on a fourth feature, which has yet to get the green light. 7th Level Teams Up With Disney and Morgan Creek for New Games. This summer, 7th Level will be coming out with new CD-ROM games this summer in collaboration with Disney Interactive and Morgan Creek Interactive. The former involves a new gamepack featuring characters from Disney's upcoming feature, The Hunchback of Notre Dame, while the latter is an interactive version of Ace Ventura, Pet Detective. ANIMATION WORLD MAGAZINE May 1996 Animation World Magazine 1996–97 Calendar Coming in June The Independent Spirit The June issue will focus on the role independent animators play in the animation industry, especially in feature films. Watch for articles on the surreal Brothers Quay, the marvelously wacky Bill Plympton, as well as a look back on the career of Germany’s legendary Lotte Reiniger. Also, director John Dilworth takes a look at the newest in anime, Ghost in the Shell. The Spirit of the Olympics (July) Anime, Anime, Anime—A Worldwide Phenomenon International Television (August) (September) Politics & Propaganda (October) Theme Park Animation (November) Interactive Animation (December) Animation Festivals (January ‘97) International Animation Industry (February '97) Children & Animation (March '97) 46